Minutes (March)
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Mar 18, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Historic Preservation Commission
Minutes of March 18, 2024
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Peter Alexander
Julie Arrington
Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair
Shanda Horner, Chair
Tracey Langseth
Emmett Lifsey
Dr. Gerry Sherayko
MEMBERS ABSENT:
OTHERS PRESENT:
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission; and the public.
ROLL CALL:
After a quorum was established, Chair Horner called the meeting to order at 4:01 p.m.
1. CONSENT AGENDA:
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner
Langseth, and passed by a unanimous vote.
2. NEW BUSINESS
a) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Patrick Richitt to replace a fence at 700 Pearl
Street. (HPC2403-0003)
Mr. Patrick Richitt was present to represent the application. He removed ivy from a chain link fence at the
side of his home and the fence began to fall over. He would like to replace the chain link with a black
aluminum fence that matches the fence at the front.
Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Alexander 1
Mr. Richitt asked the Commission to consider an additional item: installing metal chimney caps. He plans
to install gas fireplace inserts and was advised by his contractor to repoint the chimneys and install chimney
caps. They will be simple metal caps and resemble other caps found in the neighborhood. They can also
be painted red but the top will not be visible from the street.
Chair Horner asked how many chimneys he has.
Mr. Richitt replied that he believes there are three (3) chimneys but one (1) might already be capped.
Commissioner Lifsey noted that the example caps provided are simpler that what has previously been
approved by the Commission in the neighborhood.
2
Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the installation of chimney caps as presented.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: 0
b) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Jamerson-Lewis Construction, Inc., on
behalf of AHC Investments, LLC, to replace a front porch roof at 1312 Church Street.
(HPC2403-0004)
Ms. Lauren Smyk, a project manager for Jamerson-Lewis Construction, Inc., was present to represent the
application. Over the winter, the front porch had a lot of water issues. The roofer determined that the
gutter and surrounding wood was rotted. In an attempt to replace the gutter, the terracotta shingles started
to fall, chip, and shatter. Replacing the terracotta in -kind would be too expensive , so she is proposing to
replace it with DaVinci synthetic slate in a “Sonora” color.
Commissioner Lifsey asked if this proposal is only for the front porch roof at 1312 Church Street.
Ms. Smyk replied that they only own three (3) of the five (5) rowhomes. The front porch roof at 1316
Church Street will likely need to be replaced soon and 1316 ½ Church Street has an asphalt shingle roof.
The roof was replaced before they owned the building.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that slate shingles are a big visual change from terracotta and would be out of
character for the Italianate style of the rowhomes. He recommended that she look into the use of synthetic
terracotta.
Ms. Smyk responded that she had looked into synthetic terracotta but it was more expensive than they
were hoping. They were not expecting to replace the roof.
Commissioner Lifsey reiterated that slate would be a drastic visual change and out of character.
Commissioner Arrington shared agreement and noted that the appearance would change even more if
other terracotta roofs in the row were also replaced with the slate.
Commissioner Sherayko stated that the rowhomes are a big part of the streetscape and should be preserved
with their original features.
Commissioner Erquiaga shared agreement with the sentiments of the other Commissioners. He noted that
the Commission is willing to work with the applicant but the proposed material should replicate the profile
of the existing tiles. Synthetic terracotta has been approved for use previously on Rivermont Avenue.
Commissioner Erquiaga made a motion to deny the application . The motion was seconded by
Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: 0
c) ACTION (Advocate-Langseth): Request of the City of Lynchburg to install lighting at
900 Court Street. (HPC2403-0006)
3
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler stated that the City is proposing to install new pole lighting and to replace mounted
lighting at the Circuit Court building. The mounted lighting will be an update to what exists. Six (6) new
black metal pole lights will be installed around the parking lot, which currently has no lighting.
Commissioner Sherayko noted that the existing lighting is no t particularly historic and that the parking lot
needs more lighting.
Commissioner Lifsey asked if there is historic lighting along the street.
A variety of lighting was displayed via Google Street View.
There was d iscussion amongst the Commission on height requirements and locations of the parking lot
pole lighting.
Commissioner Lifsey noted that if a streetscape plan were to be implemented in this area, a certain style
of lighting would be installed throughout. This application is isolated to the parking lot so he does not have
an issue with the style. These lights will not set the vocabulary of the lighting for the rest of the street.
Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the application as submitted . The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Sherayko.
Commissioner Erquiaga stated that the proposed lights look better than the standard street light but he
wants to be consistent when making decisions. To him, these lights look modern.
Commissioner Alexander shared agreement. T here should be more of an attempt to make the proposed
lights fit in to the historic district.
Discussion about the building mounted lights determined that those are being replaced in-kind.
Commissioner Sherayko noted that he enjoys the historic lighting along the Rivermont bridge. A streetscape
plan with appropriate lighting in this area would be desirable.
Commissioner Langseth stated that even if a streetscape plan were implemented, this lighting is internal
to the parking lot.
Chair Horner added that lighting for a parking lot may need to be a different style to adequately cover the
center of the lot. She also noted that there is a street between the parking lot and the adjacent house.
Commissioner Alexander stated that he would not want to approve a lighting proposal now if it will be
replaced in a future streetscape plan. It should all be installed at the same time to save money.
Ms. Mergenthaler clarified that there is no streetscape plan proposed for the area. The current application
is for parking lot lighting, not street lighting.
The motion to approve the application as submitted passed by the following vote:
AYES: Arrington, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 5
NOES: Alexander, Erquiaga 2
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: 0
3. OLD BUSINESS
a) ACTION (Advocate-Alexander): Request of James Jean Louis Jeune to do extensive
work at 1014 Jackson Street. (HPC2402-0006)
4
Mr. James Jean Louis Jeune was present to represent the application. The windows that he installed were
not the same windows that had been previously approved. To him, t he specifications and price of both
types of windows were similar. All of the windows that were install ed have since been removed and he
plans to order new windows and present those to the Commission. If possible, he would like the Commission
to consider approving the rectangular windows he ha d installed. Window openings wer e installed on the
left side and the rear of the house without approval. Those additional openings will be closed.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that the windows that were installed are completely different than the original
windows and have no relevance to the house. The subtle arch and trim have been removed and the historic
integrity of the house has been severely damaged. He asked if the original windows have been discarded.
Mr. Jeune responded that the house was previously in disrepair.
Commissioner Lifsey agreed and stated that the Commission loves to see rehabilitation but it must be done
appropriately. The house is located in the historic district and cannot be renovated with complet ely new
materials or disregard the Residential Design Review Guidelines.
Mr. Jeune noted that he has retained the top trim. He was going to reuse it with the windows he previously
received approval for.
Commissioner Lifsey noted that his understanding of the initial application was that the original window
openings (height, width, curved top) would remain and the replacement windows would fit those openings.
Since then, the original windows have been removed and the openings altered.
The Commission shared agreement.
Commissioner Langseth reiterated the requirements of being in a local historic district.
Mr. Jeune restated that he has removed all of the windows. He will get measurements from the arched
windows that were previously approved and have Lowes get measurements for the other windows and
then reorder replacements.
Commissioner Arrington asked if the original windows are available to measure. She is not sure what Lowes
will be measuring.
Mr. Jeune replied that they would measure the openings using the “True Lumber” windows because the
windows he had installed had completely different openings.
Chair Horner asked for clarification that the windows installed without approval have been removed and
that the applicant plans to install windows matching the original window sizing.
Mr. Jeune replied that was correct. He noted that he can send the window estimate to the Secretary before
he places the order.
Chair Horner asked if Mr. Jeune has any of the original windows.
Mr. Jeune responded that many of them were missing, broken, or rotted. They have been thrown away.
Commissioner Erquiaga s tated that th e replacement windows should have an exterior mu ntin like the
original windows rather than an interior muntin like the windows installed without approval.
Mr. Jeune replied that he understands and has noted this for the window order.
5
Commissioner Lifsey and Arrington shared agreement that they would like to see dimensions before making
an approval.
Mr. Jeune continued with the other items in the application. He received a quote from Perimeter Roofing
and Exteriors for replacement of the front porch and bump out metal roofs. The color would remain gray.
He is withdrawing the application for lighting. He has not picked out fixtures.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler asked what his intent for the front door is.
Mr. Jeune responded that he plans to rebuild it. He has the two doors but not the arched transom. He is
working with a contractor to rebuild it to match what previously existed.
Ms. Mergenthaler asked about the right-side windows. Some windows have been removed and the shapes
of others have been changed from arched windows to rectangular windows.
Commissioner Sherayko asked why some of the windows were previously only half windows.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that they should be restored to their full length.
Mr. Jeune replied that there is a closet and a kitchen on the interior. He asked if he needs to restore the
small rectangular window as well.
The Commission shared agreement that all of the side windows need to be restored as they were originally.
Commissioner Sherayko expanded to say that the removal of windows and the alteration of window shape
has changed the profile of the house in ways that are unacceptable. The Commission wants to support the
restoration of deteriorated houses but said restoration must follow the Guidelines.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the metal replacement roofs as submitted in the
color gray. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Erquiaga and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: 0
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table the windows. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: 0
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table the front door. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
Alexander and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: 0
4. NEXT MEETING DAY:
The next regular meeting is scheduled for April 15, 2024.
6
5. ADJOURNMENT:
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:04 p.m.
ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________
Secretary Chair
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.