City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Mar 12, 2024 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY COUNCIL Tuesday, March 12, 2024 | 7:00 PM
Council Chamber- City Hall
900 Church Street
Lynchburg, VA 24504
AGENDA
I. Invocation Councilmember Wilder
II. Recognitions
III. Consent Agenda
III.1. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-014 amending the FY 2024
City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $189,985 from the Virginia
Department of Forestry for tree maintenance and planting.
IV. Public Hearing
IV.2. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-___ amending the Future Land Use
Map (FLUM) from Resource Conservation to Community Commercial and
adopting Ordinance #O-24-___ changing a certain area located at 6201 Fort
Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-3, Community Business District.
V. Public Comment
V.3. Hear from a citizen regarding, "Public comment policy." (Jo Meadows)
V.4. Hear from a citizen regarding, "Mismanaged transparency, Citizens that come
forward with complaints, and the lack of affirmative action." (Margaret Johnson)
V.5. Hear from a citizen regarding, "Lynchburg taxpayers’ money (& where it goes)"
(Keely Meadows).
V.6. Hear from a citizen regarding, "City Councilʼs School Board appointments"
(Penny Page).
VI. General Business
VI.7. FY 2025 Budget Presentation
VI.8. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-___ approving the newly amended
“Guidelines for Implementation of the Public-Private Transportation Act of 1995
and Public-Private Education Facilities & Infrastructure Act of 2002” for the City
of Lynchburg.
VII. Closed Session
Page 1 of 138
RESOLUTION: #R-24-014
BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2024 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget is amended and $189,985 is
appropriated with resources from the Virginia Department of Forestry, Urban and Community
Forestry, Non-Matching Grants Program, for tree maintenance and planting.
Introduced: February 27, 2024 Adopted: March 12, 2024
Certified:
Clerk of Council
Page 2 of 138
City Council
Agenda Item IV.2.
Action
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY
March 12, 2024 Rachel Frischeisen, City Planner
AGENDA ITEM # IV.2
Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-016 amending the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) from
Resource Conservation to Community Commercial and adopting Ordinance #O-24-017 changing a
certain area located at 6201 Fort Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-3, Community
Business District.
RECOMMENDATION
Approval of the petition to amend the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) from Resource Conservation to
Community Commercial.and to rezone 6201 Fort Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-3,
Community Business District.
SUMMARY
Watan Holdings, LLC is petitioning to amend the Future Land Use Map from Resource
Conservation to Community Commercial and to rezone approximately eight hundred ninety-two
thousandths (0.892) of an acre located at 6201 Fort Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-3,
Community Business District to allow the use of an existing structure as a restaurant.
This property has been used commercially since at least 1978 and has previously been used as a
restaurant several times. Those restaurants were considered "legally nonconforming" as restaurants
are not permitted in the I-2, Light Industrial District. Since more than two (2) years have passed
since the most recent use as a restaurant, the nonconforming status has lapsed and rezoning would
be required to use this property as a restaurant.
PRIOR ACTION(S)
February 27, 2024: City Council Business Item Briefing.
February 14, 2024: The Planning Commission recommended approval (4-0, with 3 absent; Johnson,
Perault, Rogers) of the rezoning petition.
February 14, 2024: The Planning Division recommended approval of the petition.
FISCAL IMPACT
N/A
CONTACT(S)
Page 3 of 138
Rachel Frischeisen, City Planner
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. R-24-016
2. O-24-017
3. Resolution
4. Ordinance
5. Planning Commission Minutes, Report, and Attachments
REVIEWED BY
Date: March 04, 2024
William Martin, Community Development Director
Date: March 04, 2024
Kent White, Assistant City Manager
Date: March 06, 2024
Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council
Page 4 of 138
RESOLUTION: #R-24-016
A RESOLUTION AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP (FLUM) OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 2013-
2030 FOR A CERTAIN AREA LOCATED AT 6201 FORT AVENUE FROM RESOURCE CONSERVATION TO
COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG that the petition of Watan Holdings, LLC
to amend the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 from Resource Conservation
to Community Commercial at a certain area located at 6201 Fort Avenue is hereby approved.
Adopted: March 12, 2024
Certified: _______________________
Clerk of Council
Page 5 of 138
UNCODIFIED ORDINANCE: #O-24-017
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING A CERTAIN AREA LOCATED AT 6201 FORT AVENUE FROM I-2, LIGHT
INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT TO B-3, COMMUNITY BUSINESS DISTRICT.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG that in order to promote the public
necessity, convenience, welfare and good zoning practice that Chapter 35.2 of the Code of the City of Lynchburg,
1981, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended by adding thereto Section 35.2- 54.__ which
shall read as follows:
Section 35.2-54.__. Change of a certain area located at 6201 Fort Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District to
B-3, Community Business District.
The area embraced within the following boundaries:
“COMMENCING AT THE POINT OF BEGINNING (STATION 1) AN IRON REBAR FOUND ON THE
WESTERN RIGHT OF WAY LINE OF FORT AVENUE; THENCE WITH SAID RIGHT OF WAY SOUTH
52°40'33" WEST, A DISTANCE OF 317.08 FEET (L1) TO AN IRON REBAR FOUND (STATION 2); THENCE
LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY NORTH 49°21'00" WEST, A DISTANCE OF 185.51 FEET (L2) TO AN IRON
REBAR FOUND (STATION 3); THENCE NORTH 43°15'37" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 85.59 FEET (L3) TO AN
IRON REBAR FOUND (STATION 4); THENCE NORTH 88°26'44" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 217.34 FEET (L8)
TO AN IRON REBAR FOUND (STATION 5); THENCE NORTH 88°26'44" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 117.02
FEET (L7) TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING, CONTAINING 0.892 ACRES, MORE OR LESS.”
…is hereby changed from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-3, Community Business District.
And the City Planner shall forthwith cause the “Official Zoning Map of Lynchburg, Virginia,” referred to in Section
35.2-30 of this chapter to be amended in accordance therewith.
Adopted: March 12, 2024
Certified: _______________________
Clerk of Council
Page 6 of 138
RESOLUTION:
A RESOLUTION AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP (FLUM) OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 2013-
2030 FOR A CERTAIN AREA LOCATED AT 6201 FORT AVENUE FROM RESOURCE CONSERVATION TO
COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG that the petition of Watan Holdings, LLC
to amend the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 from Resource Conservation
to Community Commercial at a certain area located at 6201 Fort Avenue is hereby approved.
Adopted:
Certified: _______________________
Clerk of Council
Page 7 of 138
UNCODIFIED ORDINANCE
AN ORDINANCE CHANGING A CERTAIN AREA LOCATED AT 6201 FORT AVENUE FROM I-2, LIGHT
INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT TO B-3, COMMUNITY BUSINESS DISTRICT.
BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG that in order to promote the public
necessity, convenience, welfare and good zoning practice that Chapter 35.2 of the Code of the City of Lynchburg,
1981, as amended, be and the same is hereby further amended by adding thereto Section 35.2- 54.__ which
shall read as follows:
Section 35.2-54.__. Change of a certain area located at 6201 Fort Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District to
B-3, Community Business District.
The area embraced within the following boundaries:
“COMMENCING AT THE POINT OF BEGINNING (STATION 1) AN IRON REBAR FOUND ON THE
WESTERN RIGHT OF WAY LINE OF FORT AVENUE; THENCE WITH SAID RIGHT OF WAY SOUTH
52°40'33" WEST, A DISTANCE OF 317.08 FEET (L1) TO AN IRON REBAR FOUND (STATION 2); THENCE
LEAVING SAID RIGHT OF WAY NORTH 49°21'00" WEST, A DISTANCE OF 185.51 FEET (L2) TO AN IRON
REBAR FOUND (STATION 3); THENCE NORTH 43°15'37" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 85.59 FEET (L3) TO AN
IRON REBAR FOUND (STATION 4); THENCE NORTH 88°26'44" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 217.34 FEET (L8)
TO AN IRON REBAR FOUND (STATION 5); THENCE NORTH 88°26'44" EAST, A DISTANCE OF 117.02
FEET (L7) TO THE POINT OF BEGINNING, CONTAINING 0.892 ACRES, MORE OR LESS.”
…is hereby changed from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-3, Community Business District.
And the City Planner shall forthwith cause the “Official Zoning Map of Lynchburg, Virginia,” referred to in Section
35.2-30 of this chapter to be amended in accordance therewith.
Adopted:
Certified: _______________________
Clerk of Council
Page 8 of 138
RESOLUTION:
A RESOLUTION AMENDING THE FUTURE LAND USE MAP (FLUM) OF THE COMPREHENSIVE PLAN 2013-
2030 FOR A CERTAIN AREA LOCATED AT 6201 FORT AVENUE FROM RESOURCE CONSERVATION TO
COMMUNITY COMMERCIAL.
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG that the petition of Watan Holdings, LLC
to amend the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) of the Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 from Resource Conservation
to Community Commercial at a certain area located at 6201 Fort Avenue is hereby approved.
Adopted:
Certified: _______________________
Clerk of Council
Page 9 of 138
MINUTES OF THE FEBRUARY 14, 2024 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING (MINUTES HAVE
NOT BEEN APPROVED):
Petition of Watan Holdings, LLC to rezone approximately eight hundred ninety -two
thousandths (0.892) of an acre located at 6201 Fort Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District
to B-3, Community Business District and to amend the Future Land Use Map from Resource
Conservation to Community Commercial to allow the use of an existing structure as a
restaurant.
Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, City Planner, provided the following summary to the Commission. The
purpose of the petition is to allow the use of the existing structure at 6201 Fort Avenue as a restaurant.
The Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends a Resource Conservation use for the subject property.
These areas are planned to remain an open and vegetative state with limited development; however, this
property has been used commercially since at least 1978. The petition proposes amending the Future
Land Use Map from Resource Conservation to Community Commercial. These areas allow for retail,
personal service, and restaurants that draw people from several neighborhoods, the city, and the region.
Community Commercial often contains clusters of businesses located at intersections. The existing I -2,
Light Industrial District zoning was established in 1978 and this property has been occupied by
nonconforming restaurants in the past . The existing building appears to have been built as a restaurant
and is believed to have originally been used as a Golden Corral. The building permit for this property was
issued in September of 1978 while the zoning became effective in December of the s ame year. Since
more than two (2) years have passed since the most recent use as a restaurant, the nonconforming status
has lapsed and rezoning would be required to use this property as a restaurant. The proposal should have
limited impact on the area. No exterior changes are proposed at this time and approval of the rezoning
would allow it to return to restaurant and retail type uses. The Technical Review Committee (TRC)
reviewed this petition on December 19, 2023 and the comments were minor in nature. The Planning
Division recommends approval of the rezoning and Future Land Use Map amendment.
Commissioner Bowden asked if anyone was present to speak on behalf of the petition.
Dr. Thomas Brooks , Sr. of Acres of Virginia was present to represent the applica tion. When the
property was originally surveyed a portion of the building was found to be on the railroad’s property. The
building was first occupied by Golden Corral. The purpose of the rezoning from I-2 to B-3 is to allow it to
return to business use and specifically be used as a restaurant. The property currently sits directly across
from the former Crown Sterling restaurant. The current owner wishes to update the property and bring it
back to business use instead of letting it sit unused.
Commissioner Bowden asked if there was anyone present to speak in favor or opposition of this
petition. With there being none, Commissioner Bowden closed the public hearing.
Commissioner Gammon asked about the railroad’s ownership of part of the property.
Dr. Brooks advised the owner was looking to purchase the portion currently owned by the railroad
and added that railroads are very difficult to work with. They are in the process of negotiating a purchase
price. The railroads are known for drawing out these negotiations and sometimes choosing to not sell.
Ms. Frischeisen advised that the portion owned by the railroad was excluded from the rezoning
request, as they would need the owner’s permission to rezone.
Commissioner Gammon asked if there was a legal encroachment document.
Dr. Brooks stated he was not aware of such a document.
Commissioner Gammon agreed that railroads were difficult to deal with and asked if there were any
Page 10 of 138
expectations of objections from the railroad.
Dr. Brooks replied he does not believe that there will be any objections.
Commissioner Gammon asked for more details regarding the use of the property.
Mr. Faiz Malik , one of the owners of the property, advised it would be used for an international
restaurant with a grocery store.
Commissioner Gammon asked what portion was expected to be larger.
Mr. Malik responded that the restaurant would be the larger use.
Dr. Brooks and Mr. Malik clarified that it will be a restaurant and the grocery store is just an idea of
something he may add.
Commissioner Henderson asked if it would be a full-service dine-in restaurant.
Mr. Malik replied that it would be.
Commissioner Bowden asked if the grocery store would be tied into the theme of the restaurant.
Mr. Malik replied it would not.
Commissioner Marion stated that th e rezoning seems to be a necessity to be able to return this
property to use.
Mr. Malik agreed.
Dr. Brooks stated that the rezoning is needed to be able to use the property. The restaurant would
make a great asset to the ar ea and there are plans to renovate the property. They have also agreed to
remove an entrance to make it safer for traffic. The only entrance will be at the traffic light.
Commissioner Henderson asked about the occupancy of the restaurant.
Mr. Malik advised it was approximately one hundred fifty (150) people.
Commissioner Marion made the following motion, seconded by Commissioner Gammon, and
approved by the following vote:
“Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City
Council approval of the request of Watan Holdings, LLC to amend the Future Land Use
Map from Resource Conservation to Community Commercial, and to rezone
approximately eight hundred ninety-two thousandths (0.892) acres at 6201 Fort Avenue
from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-3, Community Business District.”
AYES: Bowden, Gammon, Henderson, Marion 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Johnson, Perault, Rogers 3
Page 11 of 138
The Department of Community Development
City Hall, Lynchburg, VA 24504 434-455-3900
To: Planning Commission
From: Planning Division
Date: February 14, 2024
Re: REZONING: I-2, Light Industrial District to B-3, Community Business District
FLUM Amendment: Resource Conservation to Community Commercial
6201 Fort Avenue
I. PETITIONER
Watan Holdings, LLC, 7104 Suncrest Drive, Lynchburg, VA 24502
Representative: Dr. Thomas C. Brooks, Sr., LS, Acres of Virginia, Inc., 404 Clay Street,
Lynchburg, VA 24504
Property Owner: Same as petitioner
II. LOCATION
The subject property contains approximately eight hundred ninety-two thousandths (0.892) of
an acre located at 6201 Fort Avenue.
III. PURPOSE
The purpose of the petition is to allow the use of the existing building as a restaurant.
IV. SUMMARY
• The Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends a Resource Conservation use for the
property. The areas are planned to remain in vegetated open space with limited
development; however, the property has been used commercially since at least 1978.
• This building has been occupied by nonconforming restaurant uses in the past. Since more
than two (2) years have elapsed since the most recent restaurant use, its nonconforming
status has lapsed and a rezoning is required to re-establish the use.
• Rezoning the property to B-3, Community Business District, as proposed would allow the
building to be used for its original purpose.
The Planning Division recommends approval of the rezoning and FLUM amendment
petitions.
V. FINDINGS OF FACT
1. Comprehensive Plan. The FLUM of the Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 recommends a
Resource Conservation use for the property.
Resource Conservation Areas encompass lands with special natural characteristics that limit
land uses and development to protect the City’s environmental health. The mapped
Resource Conservation Areas include the steep slopes of Candlers Mountain as well as the
City’s stream valleys. The stream valleys, as defined in this Comprehensive Plan, include
streams and rivers, their 100-year floodplains, connected wetlands and adjacent steep slopes.
Steep slopes are defined as slopes of 25% or greater. The actual boundaries of the Resource
Conservation Area should be determined on a site-by-site basis using the best available
environmental data.
Page 12 of 138
Planning Commission: CUP – 6201 Fort Avenue – February 13, 3024 2
Resource Conservation Areas are planned to remain in vegetated open space with
development limited to: 1) trails and other passive recreational facilities that involve minimal
removal of vegetation, and 2) public facilities that must be located in stream valleys. These
include sewer mains, wastewater treatment plants, water intakes and outfalls, road crossings,
and public boat ramps. The goal is to keep Resource Conservation Areas as natural as
possible to stabilize slopes, prevent soil erosion, provide natural absorption areas for urban
runoff, moderate climate, and provide wooded areas for wildlife and for the respite of City
dwellers. Many of the stream valley Resource Conservation Areas are recommended to
become greenways in the Parks and Recreation element, and thus may have public access
trails. Other Resource Conservation Areas, not designated as greenways on the Parks &
Recreation Map, are to remain in natural vegetation for purely environmental protection
reasons.
The petition proposes to amend the FLUM to Community Commercial.
Community Commercial areas contain retail, personal service, entertainment, and restaurant
uses that draw customers from at least several neighborhoods, the entire City or the region.
Community Commercial areas contain clusters of businesses, often at major intersections,
and shopping centers. Most community shopping centers range from 100,000 to 200,000
square feet and serve 40,000 to 70,000 people. Regional shopping centers would be at least
as large as Community Commercial ones, 100,000 to 200,000 square feet, possibly larger, if
parcels of sufficient size can be found or assembled. They are intended to serve 70,000 to
100,000 people. Office, research and development, and technology development uses may
be permitted in Community Commercial areas as long as traffic and other impacts to the
community are mitigated. In particular, conversion of existing vacant retail space to these
uses may be appropriate in areas where there is sufficient retail to serve the community and
space for employment uses is needed. Residential uses may be established on the upper
floors of commercial structures or as transitional structures between residential and
commercial buildings. (p. 75-76)
2. Zoning. The subject property was annexed into the City in 1958. The existing I-2, Light
Industrial District zoning was established in 1978.
3. Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA). The Zoning Official has determined that no variances
would be needed for the development of the property as proposed.
4. Surrounding Area. There have been several items requiring City Council approval in the
immediate area:
On February 13, 1979, Council approved the request of W. Logan Rowse to rezone property
located behind 6006 Fort Avenue from R-2, Single-Family Residence, to B-1, Limited
Business District to allow for a two (2) story addition to a furniture store.
On September 12, 1982, Council approved the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) petition of
Spanky’s Fun Time Pizza for a restaurant and game room located at 1200 Fenwick Drive.
On February 14, 1984, Council approved the request of Reams and Company, Inc. to rezone
property located behind 6006 Fort Avenue from B-1, Limited Business District to B-3,
Community Business District to allow for the expansion of a furniture store.
On August 9, 1988, Council approved the CUP petition of Fort Avenue Church of Christ to
allow a child care center at 1132 Sandusky Drive.
Page 13 of 138
Planning Commission: CUP – 6201 Fort Avenue – February 13, 3024 3
On March 13, 2001, Council approved the CUP petition of Quaker Memorial Presbyterian
Church to allow a columbarium at 5810 Fort Avenue.
On May 13, 2008, Council approved the CUP petition of Quaker Memorial Presbyterian
Church to allow the expansion of an existing parking facility at 5810 Fort Avenue.
5. Site Description. The property consists of approximately eight hundred ninety-two
thousandths (0.892) of an acre at 6201 Fort Avenue.
The property contains a one (1) story “fire resistant” structure constructed in 1978. The
structure is approximately five thousand, three hundred (5,300) square feet in size, and has
been used as a restaurant in the past.
The property is bound by railroad property and commercial uses to the north, to the east by
commercial uses (across Fort Avenue), by commercial uses and vacant land to the south, and
by industrial uses and vacant land to the west.
6. Proposed Use of Property. If the petition is approved, the existing building would be used
as a restaurant.
7. Traffic, Parking and Public Transit. The petitioner was not required to conduct a traffic
analysis as part of the petition.
The submitted concept plan shows sixty (60) parking spaces.
The property is served by Greater Lynchburg Transit Company (GLTC) Routes 6/7X, 10,
and 11, with a bus stop located adjacent to the property.
8. Stormwater Management. An erosion & sediment control / stormwater management
plan will not be required since no external improvements or modifications are proposed at
this time.
9. Emergency Services. The City Fire Marshal’s Office and Police Department had no
comments of concern.
10. Impact. The proposed use of the property should have limited impact on the area. The
property has been developed and used commercially since at least 1978. Several restaurants
have been located in the building previously.
11. Technical Review Committee. The Technical Review Committee (TRC) reviewed the
concept plan on December 19, 2023. Comments were minor in nature.
VI. PLANNING DIVISION RECOMMENDATION
Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to
City Council approval of the request of Watan Holdings, LLC to amend the Future
Land Use Map from Resource Conservation to Community Commercial, and to
rezone approximately eight hundred ninety-two thousandths (0.892) acres at 6201
Fort Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-3, Community Business District.
This matter is respectfully offered for your consideration.
Rachel Frischeisen
City Planner
Page 14 of 138
Planning Commission: CUP – 6201 Fort Avenue – February 13, 3024 4
pc: Wynter Benda, City Manager
Greg Patrick, Deputy City Manager
Kent White, Assistant City Manager
Tom Martin, Director of Community Development
Matthew Freedman, City Attorney
J. Lee Newland, City Engineer
Cynthia Kozerow, Lynchburg Police Department
Thomas Goode, Fire Marshal
Doug Saunders, Building Official
Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator
Dr. Thomas C. Brooks, Sr., LS, Representative
Watan Holdings, LLC, Petitioner & Property Owner
VII. ATTACHMENTS
1. Zoning Map with Adjoining Property Owners
2. Future Land Use Map
3. Watershed Map
4. Planimetric and Topographic Map
5. Concept Plan
6. Property Photograph
Page 15 of 138
ZoningZoning
TRCTRC
~154.39
95
~222.40
176.00
176.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
150.00
200.00
85.11
165.60
90.00
30.00
311.05
35.15
138.05
421.07
180.00
246.90
71.97
132.98
248.47
97.47
215.08
22.94
60.28
172.12
222.77
192.08
115.00
128.13
85.00
323.72
122.81
200.00
18.67
185.50
234.35
105.00
76.49
75.51
185.43
113.49
26.38 172.06
116.80
316.93
82.18
50
(2)
(3)
AEP TRANSMISSION LINE
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
I-2I-2
B-5B-5
B-1B-1
B-3B-3
R-2R-2
R-CR-C
R-CR-C
I-2I-2
R-CR-C
I-2I-2
B-3B-3
61156115
62006200
61206120
12001200
12071207
62016201
12151215
62106210
61216121
61196119
FENWICK DR
FORT AVE
MAP SCALE: DATE PRINTED: 12/5/2023
PROPERTY INFORMATIONPROPERTY INFORMATION LEGENDLEGEND
µµ
PARCEL ID ADDRESS
JOHN
LYNCH PL
OLDMILL RD
SHORT ST
GLASS
AVE
NELSONDR
COPLEY PL
WHITE
OAK DR
ALICE
ST
LINDSAY ST
LOG A N SLN
RICHLAND
DR
SANGLOEPL
FENWICK
DR
PAWNEE
DR
L IC H F O R D
L N
M ILLRID G E RD
MORTON
DR
LEROY
BOW
EN DR
AARON
PL
O
LD
M
ILL
RD
RICHLAND DR
H IG H LANDD R
N
ELSON
DR
PAWNEE DRPAWTUCKET DR
BERKSHIRE PL
HEATH
AVE
OLD
M
ILL RD
R IC H LA N D
D R
S U N C R E S T D R
MIDDLEBOROPL
P E A C H TREER D
NELSON
DR
F E N W IC K D R
ADAMS
DR
TAYLOR RD
GLENFIELD
DR
WARDS
FERRY RD
WARDS
FERRY RD
AUTUMNDRAUTUMNDR
IGLOE
DR
IGLOE
DR
LONGMEADOWS DRLONGMEADOWS DR
WARDS
FERRY RD
WARDS
FERRY RD
AUTUMN
DR
AUTUMN
DR
EDGEWOOD
AVE
EDGEWOOD
AVE
SHEFFIELD
DR
SHEFFIELD
DR
IG LO E DR
IG LO E DR
FENWICK
DR
FENWICK
DR
GRAVES
MILLRD
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
M
ILLRD
GRAVES
M
ILLRD
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
MILL RD
S H E F F IE L D D R
S H E F F IE L D D R
W A R D S
FER R Y R DW A R D S
FER R Y R D
FORT AVEFORT AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT AVEFORT AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
WARDSRD
WARDSRD
WARDS RDWARDS RD
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
WARDSRD
WARDSRD
TIMBERLAKE
RD
TIMBERLAKE
RD
WARDS RDWARDS RD
TIMBERLAKE RDTIMBERLAKE RD
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURGEXPYLYNCHBURGEXPY
LY N C H B U R G
E X P Y
LY N C H B U R G
E X P Y
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG EXPYLYNCHBURG EXPY
OVERVIEW MAPOVERVIEW MAP
Subject PropertySubject Property
B-1B-1
B-4B-4
B-5B-5
I-1I-1
I-2I-2
I-3I-3
R-1R-1
R-2R-2
R-3R-3
R-4R-4IN-1IN-1
IN-2IN-2
B-3B-3
R-CR-C
215 Foot Buffer215 Foot Buffer
WATAN HOLDINGS, LLC
15501006 6201 FORT AVE
Parcel ID Address
6201 FORT AVE
Address
1:1,555
Page 16 of 138
6201 Fort Avenue Adjoining Owners
Parcel ID Address Property Owners
15503001 6210 FORT AVE SMITH, CHRISTOPHER & LENAYA
11601004 6121 FORT AVE NORFOLK & SOUTHERN RAILWAY
11601002 1601 LIGGATES RD NORFOLK & SOUTHERN RAILWAY
15503002 6200 FORT AVE GLH PROPERTIES LLC
15502002 6120 FORT AVE CCE PROPERTIES LLC
15501002 6115 FORT AVE R & M TURNER ENTERPRISES LLC
15501006 6201 FORT AVE WATAN HOLDINGS LLC
24503003 98 LICHFORD LN VIRGINIA EAGLE PROPERTIES LLC
Page 17 of 138
FLUMFLUM
TRCTRC
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
61156115
62006200
61206120
12001200
12071207
62016201
12151215
62106210
61216121
61196119
FENWICK DR
FORT AVE
MAP SCALE: DATE PRINTED: 12/5/2023
PROPERTY INFORMATIONPROPERTY INFORMATION LEGENDLEGEND
µµ
PARCEL ID ADDRESS
JOHN
LYNCH PL
OLDMILL RD
SHORT ST
GLASS
AVE
MORRISLN
NELSONDR
COPLEY PL
LINDSAY ST
DOVER PL
LOG A N SLN
RICHLAND
DR
SANGLOEPL
FENWICK
DR
PAWNEE DR
L IC H F O R D
L N
M ILLRID G E RD
MORTON
DR
LEROY
BOW
EN DR
AARON
PL
NEWPORT DR
O
LD
M
ILL
RD
RICHLAND DR
N
ELSON
DR
PAW
NEE
DR
PAWTUCKET DR
BERKSHIRE PL
HEATH
AVE
OLD
M
ILL RD
R IC H LA N D
D R
S U N C R E S T D R
MIDDLEBOROPL
P E A C H TREER D
NELSON
DR
F E N W IC K D R
ADAMS
DR
TAYLOR RD
GLENFIELD
DR
WARDS
FERRY RD
WARDS
FERRY RD
AUTUMNDRAUTUMNDR
LONGMEADOWS DRLONGMEADOWS DR
WARDS
FERRY RD
WARDS
FERRY RD
AUTUMN
DR
AUTUMN
DR
EDGEWOOD
AVE
EDGEWOOD
AVE
SHEFFIELD
DR
SHEFFIELD
DR
IG LO E DR
IG LO E DR
FENWICK
DR
FENWICK
DR
SANDUSKY
DR
SANDUSKY
DR
GRAVES
MILLRD
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
M
ILLRD
GRAVES
M
ILLRD
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
MILL RD
S H E F F IE L D D R
S H E F F IE L D D R
W A R D S
FER R Y R DW A R D S
FE R R Y R D
FORTAVEFORTAVEFORTAVEFORTAVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT AVEFORT AVE
FORT AVEFORT AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
WARDSRD WARDSRD
WARDS RDWARDS RD
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
WARDSRD
WARDSRD
TIMBERLAKE
RD
TIMBERLAKE
RD
WARDS RDWARDS RD
TIMBERLAKE RDTIMBERLAKE RD
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURGEXPYLYNCHBURGEXPY
LY N C H B U R G
E X P Y
LY N C H B U R G
E X P Y
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG EXPYLYNCHBURG EXPY
OVERVIEW MAPOVERVIEW MAP
15501006 6201 FORT AVE
Parcel ID Address
6201 FORT AVE
Address
WATAN HOLDINGS, LLC
Local Historic DistrictLocal Historic District
Traditional ResidentialTraditional Residential
Low Density ResidentialLow Density Residential
Medium Density ResidentialMedium Density Residential
High Density ResidentialHigh Density Residential
Neighborhood CommercialNeighborhood Commercial
Community CommercialCommunity Commercial
Employment 2Employment 2
InstitutionInstitution
DowntownDowntown
Public UsePublic Use
Public ParksPublic Parks
Resource ConservationResource Conservation
Employment 1Employment 1
Mixed UseMixed Use
1:1,555
Page 18 of 138
WatershedWatershed
TRCTRC
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
BURTON
CREEK
BURTON
CREEK
BURTON
CREEK
B
U
RTO
N
CR
EEK
BURTON CREEK
BURTON CREEK
TRIBUTARY
BURTON
CREEK
717
709
721
725
738
61156115
62006200
61206120
12001200
12071207
62016201
12151215
62106210
61216121
61196119
FENWICK DR
FORT AVE
MAP SCALE: DATE PRINTED: 12/5/2023
PROPERTY INFORMATIONPROPERTY INFORMATION LEGENDLEGEND
µµ
PARCEL ID ADDRESS
Blackwater Creek
JOHN
LYNCH PL
OLDMILL RD
LOGANS LN
FORT AVE
SHORT ST
GLASS
AVE
NELSONDR
COPLEY PL
WHITE
OAK DR
ALICE ST
LINDSAY ST
LOGANS LN
RICHLAND
DR
SANGLOEPL
FENWICK
DR
PAWNEE
DR
MORTON
DR
LEROY
BOWEN DR
AARON PL
MILL
RIDGE RD
O
LD
M
ILL
RD
RICHLAND DR
N
ELSON
DR
PAWNEE DRPAWTUCKET DR
BERKSHIRE PL
HEATH
AVE
OLD
M
ILL RD
S U N C R E S T D R
R IC H LA N D
D R
MIDDLEBOROPL
P E A C H TREER D
NELSON
DR
F E N W IC K D R
ADAMS
DR
TAYLOR RD
GLENFIELD
DR
IGLOE
DR
IGLOE
DR
WARDS
FERRY RD
WARDS
FERRY RD
AUTUMNDRAUTUMNDR
IGLOE
DR
IGLOE
DR
LONGMEADOWS DRLONGMEADOWS DR
WARDS
FERRY RD
WARDS
FERRY RD
AUTUMN
DR
AUTUMN
DR
EDGEWOOD
AVE
EDGEWOOD
AVE
SHEFFIELD
DR
SHEFFIELD
DR
FENWICK
DR
FENWICK
DR
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
MILLRD
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
M
ILLRD
GRAVES
M
ILLRD
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
MILL RD
S H E F F IE L D D R
S H E F F IE L D D R
W A R D S
FER R Y R DW A R D S
FER R Y R D
FORTAVEFORTAVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVEFORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE FORT AVEFORT AVE
WARDS RDWARDS RD
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
WARDSRD
WARDSRD
TIMBERLAKE
RD
TIMBERLAKE
RD
WARDS RDWARDS RD
TIMBERLAKE RDTIMBERLAKE RD
LYNCHBURG EXPYLYNCHBURG EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURGEXPYLYNCHBURGEXPY
LY N C H B U R G
E X P Y
LY N C H B U R G
E X P Y
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG EXPYLYNCHBURG EXPY
OVERVIEW MAPOVERVIEW MAP
WATAN HOLDINGS, LLC
Base Flood ElevationBase Flood Elevation
FloodwayFloodway
FloodzoneFloodzone
River / Lake / StreamRiver / Lake / Stream
Subject PropertySubject Property15501006 6201 FORT AVE
Parcel ID Address
6201 FORT AVE
Address
1:1,555
Page 19 of 138
Planimetric and Topographic-TRCPlanimetric and Topographic-TRC
TRCTRC
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!! !!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
!!
* ")Ŧ
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
!
61156115
62006200
61206120
12001200
12071207
62016201
12151215
62106210
61216121
61196119
BURTON
CREEK
BURTON
CREEK
B URTON C R E E K
TRIB UTARY
B URTON C R E EK
TRIB UTARY
FENWICK DR
780
770
760
750
740
720
730
710
780
770
760
750
740
730
720
710
700
740
720
730
710
790
780
730
720
700
700750
780
730
FORT AVE
City of Lynchburg - GIS Office - 434.455.3961 - GIS@lynchburgva.gov
MAP SCALE: DATE PRINTED: 12/5/2023
PROPERTY INFORMATIONPROPERTY INFORMATION LEGENDLEGEND
µµ
PARCEL ID ADDRESS
JOHN
LYNCH PL
OLDMILL RD
SHORT ST
GLASS
AVE
NELSONDR
COPLEY PL
WHITE
OAK DR
ALICE
ST
LINDSAY ST
LOG A N SLN
RICHLAND
DR
SANGLOEPL
FENWICK
DR
PAWNEE
DR
L IC H F O R D
L N
MORTON
DR
LEROY
BOW
EN DR
MILL
RIDGE RD
AARON
PL
O
LD
M
ILL
RD
RICHLAND DR
H IG H LANDD R
N
ELSON
DR
PAWNEE DRPAWTUCKET DR
BERKSHIRE PL
HEATH
AVE
OLD
M
ILL RD
S U N C R E S T D R
R IC H LA N D
D R
MIDDLEBOROPL
P E A C H TREER D
NELSON
DR
F E N W IC K D R
ADAMS
DR
TAYLOR RD
GLENFIELD
DR
WARDS
FERRY RD
WARDS
FERRY RD
AUTUMNDRAUTUMNDR
IGLOE
DR
IGLOE
DR
LONGMEADOWS DRLONGMEADOWS DR
WARDS
FERRY RD
WARDS
FERRY RD
AUTUMN
DR
AUTUMN
DR
EDGEWOOD
AVE
EDGEWOOD
AVE
SHEFFIELD
DR
SHEFFIELD
DR
IG LO E DR
IG LO E DR
FENWICK
DR
FENWICK
DR
GRAVES
MILLRD
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
M
ILLRD
GRAVES
M
ILLRD
GRAVES
MILL RD
GRAVES
MILL RD
S H E F F IE L D D R
S H E F F IE L D D R
W A R D S
FER R Y R DW A R D S
FER R Y R D
FORT AVEFORT AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT AVEFORT AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
WARDSRD
WARDSRD
WARDS RDWARDS RD
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
FORT
AVE
WARDSRD
WARDSRD
TIMBERLAKE
RD
TIMBERLAKE
RD
WARDS RDWARDS RD
TIMBERLAKE RDTIMBERLAKE RD
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURGEXPYLYNCHBURGEXPY
LY N C H B U R G
E X P Y
LY N C H B U R G
E X P Y
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG
EXPY
LYNCHBURG EXPYLYNCHBURG EXPY
OVERVIEW MAPOVERVIEW MAP
UtilitiesUtilities
WaterWater
ActiveActive ProposedProposed AbandonedAbandoned
SanitarySanitary
StormStorm
Planimetrics Planimetrics
PavedPaved UnpavedUnpaved OtherOther
SidewalkSidewalk
RoadwayRoadway
ParkingParking
DrivewayDriveway - - - -
- - - -StructureStructure
- -
- -
- - - -
TopographyTopography ContourContour
20'20'
10'10'
100'100'
50'50'
5'5'
1'1'
WATAN HOLDINGS, LLC
6201 FORT AVE
Address
15501006 6201 FORT AVE
Parcel ID Address
1:1,555
Page 20 of 138
Page 21 of 138
Page 22 of 138
Watan Holdings, LLC./6201 Fort Ave Rezoning
February 14, 2024
PLEASE PRINT CLEARLY
NAME ADDRESS PHONE IN FAVOR
fk,'Z- MAL( fl- ;
"7
--; //owds ::£5.a-.,�/C
IN OPPOSmON NEUTRAL
Page 23 of 138
1
Holt, Loryn
From: Finney, Alicia
Sent: Monday, March 11, 2024 11:18 AM
To: J Meadows
Cc: Holt, Loryn
Subject: RE: Online Form Submittal: Public Comment
Hi Joseph – confirming receipt of your Public Comment request. You are on the agenda for our March 12th meeting
beginning at 7pm. Thank you!
From: J Meadows <jmeadowsskinsfan@gmail.com>
Sent: Monday, March 11, 2024 11:11 AM
To: Finney, Alicia <Alicia.Finney@lynchburgva.gov>
Subject: Fwd: Online Form Submittal: Public Comment
CAUTION: External Sender
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐ Forwarded message ‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
From: <noreply@civicplus.com>
Date: Thu, Feb 29, 2024, 10:50 AM
Subject: Online Form Submittal: Public Comment
To: <jmeadowsskinsfan@gmail.com>
Public Comment
Public Comment Sign-Up
Public Comment shall be for the purpose of allowing members of the public to
present any matter, which, in their opinion, deserves the attention of the Council.
They shall not serve as a forum for debate with the Council.
Remarks shall be addressed directly to the Council and not to City staff, the
audience, or the media.
Deadline for sign-up: The Friday preceding the Council meeting by noon.
Page 24 of 138
2
First Name Jo
Last Name Meadows
Name of group
represented, if applicable:
Field not completed.
Address 202 Cleveland Ave Apt 10
City Lynchburg
State Virginia
Zip Code 24503
Council Meeting March 12, 2024
Email jmeadowsskinsfan@gmail.com
Phone 4345092600
Topic of Discussion Public comment policy
Acknowledgement ‐ Three
Month Rule
I acknowledge that I have read the following statement: Once
the Council has heard a presentation from an individual or
organization on a particular subject, the individual or
organization may not make another presentation on the same
subject within three (3) months of the first presentation, except
b
y a majority vote of the Councilmembers present and voting.
Decorum & Prohibited Content
All persons appearing before the Council or in the Council Chamber while a
meeting of the Council is in session will not be allowed to: campaign for public
office; promote private business ventures; use profanity or vulgar language or
gestures; use language which insults or demeans any person or which, when
directed at a public official or employee, is not related to his or her official duties,
however, citizens have the right to comment on the performance, conduct, and
qualifications of public figures; make non-germane or frivolous statements; interrupt
other speakers or engage in behavior that disrupts the meeting, including but not
limited to, applause, cheers, jeers, etc.; engage in behavior that intimidates others;
or, address the Council on issues that do not concern the services, policies, or
affairs of the Council or the City.
Acknowledgement ‐
Decorum & Prohibited
Content
I acknowledge that I have read the Decorum and Prohibited
Content Statement
Page 25 of 138
Submitted On:
Mar 1, 2024, 08:24PM EST
Public Comment Sign-Up
City of Lynchburg
Full Name
First Name:
Margaret
Last Name:
Johnson
Name of group represented, if
applicable:
Locality of Residence
1505 Longview Dr. Apt#211 Lynchburg Va 24501
Council Meeting:
March 05, 2024 07:00 AM
Email
redwidow430@gmail.com
Phone Number
4345099677
Topic of Discussion
Mismanaged transparency, Citizens that come forward with
complaints, and the lack of affirmative action.
Acknowledgement - Three (3)
Month Rule
I acknowledge that I have read the following statement: Once the
Council has heard a presentation from an individual or organization
on a particular subject, the individual or organization may not make
another presentation on the same subject within three (3) months of
the first presentation, except by a majority vote of the
Councilmembers present and voting.
Acknowledgement - Decorum
and Prohibited Content
I acknowledge that I have read the following statement: All persons
appearing before the Council or in the Council Chamber while a
meeting of the Council is in session will not be allowed to: campaign
for public office; promote private business ventures; use profanity or
vulgar language or gestures; use language which insults or
demeans any person or which, when directed at a public official or
employee, is not related to his or her official duties, however,
citizens have the right to comment on the performance, conduct, and
qualifications of public figures; make non-germane or frivolous
statements; interrupt other speakers or engage in behavior that
disrupts the meeting, including but not limited to, applause, cheers,
jeers, etc.; engage in behavior that intimidates others; or, address
the Council on issues that do not concern the services, policies, or
affairs of the Council or the City.
Page 26 of 138
Submitted On:
Mar 4, 2024, 10:34AM EST
Public Comment Sign-Up
City of Lynchburg
Full Name
First Name:
Keely
Last Name:
Meadows
Name of group represented, if
applicable:
Locality of Residence
5327 Cooper Street, Hollins, VA, USA
Council Meeting:
March 12, 2024 07:00 AM
Email
keelymeadowsadvocate@gmail.com
Phone Number
5404670863
Topic of Discussion
Lynchburg taxpayers’ money (& where it goes)
Acknowledgement - Three (3)
Month Rule
I acknowledge that I have read the following statement: Once the
Council has heard a presentation from an individual or organization
on a particular subject, the individual or organization may not make
another presentation on the same subject within three (3) months of
the first presentation, except by a majority vote of the
Councilmembers present and voting.
Acknowledgement - Decorum
and Prohibited Content
I acknowledge that I have read the following statement: All persons
appearing before the Council or in the Council Chamber while a
meeting of the Council is in session will not be allowed to: campaign
for public office; promote private business ventures; use profanity or
vulgar language or gestures; use language which insults or
demeans any person or which, when directed at a public official or
employee, is not related to his or her official duties, however,
citizens have the right to comment on the performance, conduct, and
qualifications of public figures; make non-germane or frivolous
statements; interrupt other speakers or engage in behavior that
disrupts the meeting, including but not limited to, applause, cheers,
jeers, etc.; engage in behavior that intimidates others; or, address
the Council on issues that do not concern the services, policies, or
affairs of the Council or the City.
Page 27 of 138
Submitted On:
Mar 5, 2024, 04:34PM EST
Public Comment Sign-Up
City of Lynchburg
Full Name
First Name:
Penny
Last Name:
Page
Name of group represented, if
applicable:
Locality of Residence
3216 Azalea Place, Lynchburg, VA, USA
Council Meeting:
March 12, 2024 07:00 PM
Email
pennypage@pennypage.org
Phone Number
8043160100
Topic of Discussion
City Council's School Board appointments
Acknowledgement - Three (3)
Month Rule
I acknowledge that I have read the following statement: Once the
Council has heard a presentation from an individual or organization
on a particular subject, the individual or organization may not make
another presentation on the same subject within three (3) months of
the first presentation, except by a majority vote of the
Councilmembers present and voting.
Acknowledgement - Decorum
and Prohibited Content
I acknowledge that I have read the following statement: All persons
appearing before the Council or in the Council Chamber while a
meeting of the Council is in session will not be allowed to: campaign
for public office; promote private business ventures; use profanity or
vulgar language or gestures; use language which insults or
demeans any person or which, when directed at a public official or
employee, is not related to his or her official duties, however,
citizens have the right to comment on the performance, conduct, and
qualifications of public figures; make non-germane or frivolous
statements; interrupt other speakers or engage in behavior that
disrupts the meeting, including but not limited to, applause, cheers,
jeers, etc.; engage in behavior that intimidates others; or, address
the Council on issues that do not concern the services, policies, or
affairs of the Council or the City.
Page 28 of 138
Page 29 of 138
•
•
•
•
Page 30 of 138
•
•
•
Page 31 of 138
•
•
•
•
Page 32 of 138
•
•
•
•
•
Page 33 of 138
•
•
•
•
•
Page 34 of 138
Page 35 of 138
Page 36 of 138
•
•
•
•
Page 37 of 138
•
•
Page 38 of 138
•
•
Page 39 of 138
•
•
•
•
•
•
Page 40 of 138
Page 41 of 138
Page 42 of 138
Page 43 of 138
City Council
Agenda Item VI.9.
Action
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY
March 12, 2024 Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer
AGENDA ITEM # VI.9
Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-___ approving the newly amended “Guidelines for
Implementation of the Public-Private Transportation Act of 1995 and Public-Private Education
Facilities & Infrastructure Act of 2002” for the City of Lynchburg.
RECOMMENDATION
Adopt a Resolution which approves newly amended “Guidelines for Implementation of the Public-
Private Transportation Act of 1995 and Public-Private Education Facilities & Infrastructure Act of
2002” for the City.
SUMMARY
City Council adopted guidelines for implementation of both the Public-Private Transportation Act
(PPTA) and Public-Private Education Facilities & Infrastructure Act (PPEA) in 2004 and then
amended both in 2006. Changes to the PPTA legislation over the years have resulted in procedural
differences from the PPEA. An update to the guidelines is needed.
PRIOR ACTION(S)
January 27, 2004 Adopted
January 10, 2006 Amended
February 27, 2024 Council Worksession - Business Item Briefing
FISCAL IMPACT
N/A
CONTACT(S)
Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer
Stephanie Suter
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Proposed Resolution - PPEA - PPTA Amended Guidelines (2024)
2. PPEA - PPTA Amended Guidelines (2024)
3. PPEA - PPTA Guidelines (2004 & 2006)
Page 44 of 138
REVIEWED BY
Date: February 29, 2024
Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer
Date: March 07, 2024
Matthew Freedman, City Attorney
Date: March 07, 2024
Gregory Patrick, Deputy City Manager
Date: March 07, 2024
Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council
Page 45 of 138
RESOLUTION: #R-24-____
BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG:
1. That the City of Lynchburg’s implementation procedures and guidelines for the Public-Private
Transportation Act of 1995 (PPTA), as amended, and the Public-Private Education Facilities and
Infrastructure Act of 2002 (PPEA), as amended, also known as the Lynchburg PPTA/PPEA
Procedures, are hereby amended, approved, and reenacted as provided in that certain document
entitled “City of Lynchburg, Virginia, Guidelines for Implementation of the Public-Private
Transportation Act of 1995 and Public-Private Education Facilities & Infrastructure Act of 2002”,
as of the date of March 12, 2024, which is expressly incorporated herein by reference.
2. That this Resolution shall be effective upon its adoption.
Adopted:
Certified: _____________________________
Clerk of Council
Page 46 of 138
Page 47 of 138
Page 48 of 138
Page 49 of 138
Page 50 of 138
Page 51 of 138
Page 52 of 138
Page 53 of 138
Page 54 of 138
Page 55 of 138
Page 56 of 138
Page 57 of 138
Page 58 of 138
Page 59 of 138
Page 60 of 138
Page 61 of 138
Page 62 of 138
Page 63 of 138
Page 64 of 138
Page 65 of 138
Page 66 of 138
Page 67 of 138
Page 68 of 138
Page 69 of 138
Page 70 of 138
Page 71 of 138
Page 72 of 138
Page 73 of 138
City of Lynchburg, Virginia
Implementation Procedures and Guidelines
for the
Public-Private Transportation Act of 1995
and the
Public-Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure
Act of 2002, as amended
Adopted January 27, 2004
Amended January 10, 2006
Page 74 of 138
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CITY OF LYNCHBURG PPTA/PPEA IMPLEMENTATION
PROCEDURES AND GUIDELINES
I. INTRODUC TION............................................................................................... 4
A. Scope and App licability................................................................................ 4
B. Point of Contact for PPTA/PPEA Information
and Submission of Proposals ...................................................................... 5
C. City Review Board ....................................................................................... 5
D. Reservation of Rights .................................................................................. 6
E. Timeline for Proposal Re view and Consideration ........................................ 7
II. GENERAL PROV ISIONS ................................................................................. 7
A. Proposal Subm ission ................................................................................... 7
B. General Administ rative Issues ..................................................................... 10
C. General Format for Submissi on of Conceptual Proposal............................. 10
D. General Format for Submissi on of Detailed Proposal.................................. 11
E. Proposal Revi ew Fee................................................................................... 12
F. Virginia Freedom of Information Act ............................................................ 13
G. Affected Local Juri sdiction Review .............................................................. 14
H. Applicability of Other Law ............................................................................ 14
I. Adoption of Certain Portions of the Virginia Public Procurement Act
and
Use of competitive Negotiation and Competitive Sealed Bidding
Procedures....................................................................................................15
III. PROPOSAL EVALUAT ION AND SELECTION................................................ 16
A. Decision to Accept an Unsolicited Proposal................................................. 16
B. Initial Review by the City.............................................................................. 16
C. Written Determination of Qualification.......................................................... 17
D. Conclusion of an Agre ement on the Protection of
Confidential Information............................................................................... 17
E. Publication for Co mpeting Proposals........................................................... 17
F. Receipt of Com peting Proposals ................................................................. 17
G. Determination and Agreement on Confidential Material
for Competing Proposals ............................................................................. 18
H. Selection for Submission of Detailed Proposals .......................................... 18
I. Receipt and Review of Detailed Proposals.................................................. 18
J. Selection of Proposal(s) for Negot iation of Comprehensive Agreement ...... 19
K. Negotiation and Approval of Comprehensive Agreement ............................ 19
IV. FORMAT FOR CONC EPTUAL PROPOSALS ................................................. 19
A. Descrip tion................................................................................................... 19
B. Tab 1: Qualificat ion and Experience ........................................................... 20
C. Tab 2: Project Characteristics..................................................................... 21
D. Tab 3: Proj ect Financing............................................................................. 22
E. Tab 4: Public Support, Proj ect Benefit and Compatibility............................ 22
Page 75 of 138
3
V. FORMAT FOR DETA ILED PROPOSALS........................................................ 23
A. Description and Re quired Information ......................................................... 23
VI. PROPOSAL EVALUATION.............................................................................. 24
A. Manner of Evaluat ion and Use of Outside Professionals............................. 24
B. Evaluation and Sele ction Criteria................................................................. 24
VII. COMPREHENSIVE AGREEMENTS AND INTERIM AGREEMENTS.............. 24
A. Descripti on and Terms................................................................................. 24
B. Interim Ag reements ...................................................................................... 27
VIII. DISPUTES, CLAIMS AND OT HER MATTERS ARISING UNDER OR
RELATING TO ANY COMPREHENSIVE AGREEMENT OR INTERIM
AGREEMENT ................................................................................................... 27
IX. PROTESTS OF PPTA/PPE A PROCUREMENTS ............................................ 29
X. PARTICIPATION OF SMALL AND MINORITY-OWNED BUSINESS.............. 30
XI. PROPOSERS' AGREEMENT TO TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS
POLICY............................................................................................................. 30
Appendix A: The Public-Private Transportation Act of 1995 ............................... 31
Appendix B: The Public-Privat e Education Facilities and
Infrastructure Act of 2002, as amended........................................... 44
Appendix C: Projected Procurement Timeline for PPTA/PPEA Procurement
Initiated By Unso licited Proposal..................................................... 57
Appendix D: Projected Procurement Timeline for PPTA/PPEA Procurement
Solicited By Request fo r Proposals (“RFP”) ................................... 58
Appendix E: Potential Proposal Eval uation and Selection Criteria..................... 59
Appendix F: Proposers' Certification .................................................................... 64
Page 76 of 138
4
CITY OF LYNCHBURG
PPTA / PPEA IMPLEMENTATION PROCEDURES AND GUIDELINES
I. INTRODUCTION.
A. Scope and Applicability.
This document presents the implementation procedures and guidelines (the
“procedures") developed by the City of Lynchburg ("the City") to guide the
selection of projects under the purview of the City as authorized by the Virginia
Public- Private Transportation Act of 1995 (the "PPTA") (Virginia Code §56-556
et seq.), and the Virginia Public-Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure
Act of 2002, as amended (the "PPEA") (Virginia Code §56-575.1 et seq.). The
PPTA and PPEA are collectively referred to herein as "the Acts". Copies of the
PPTA and PPEA are included as Appendices A and B, respectively, to these
procedures. The City is a political subdivision of the Commonwealth of Virginia
with the authority to acquire, design, construct, improve, renovate, expand,
equip, maintain, operate, implement and install a wide range of projects for public
use, and therefore is a "Responsible Public Entity" as that term is used in both
the PPTA and PPEA.
As discussed below, the PPTA authorizes public-private partnerships to develop
"qualifying transportation facilities," and the PPEA authorizes such partnerships
to develop "Qualifying Projects.” The term "qualifying transportation facility" is
defined in the PPTA as follows:
"Qualifying transportation facility" means one or more transportation
facilities acquired, constructed, improved, maintained and/or operated by
a private entity pursuant to this chapter.
The PPTA further defines a "transportation facility" as follows:
"Transportation facility" means any road, bridge, tunnel, overpass, ferry,
airport, mass transit facility, vehicle parking facility, port facility or similar
commercial facility used for the transportation of persons or goods,
together with any other property that is needed to operate the
transportation facility.
The term "Qualifying Project" under the PPEA is defined as follows:
"Qualifying project" means (i) any education facility, including, but not limited to a
school building, any functionally related and subordinate facility and land to a
school building (including any stadium or other facility primarily used for school
events), and any depreciable property provided for use in a school facility that is
operated as part of the public school system or as an institution of higher
education; (ii) any building or facility that meets a public purpose and is
developed or operated by or for any public entity; (iii) any improvements, together
with equipment, necessary to enhance public safety and security of buildings to
be principally used by a public entity; (iv) utility and telecommunications and
Page 77 of 138
5
other communications infrastructure; (v) a recreational facility; or (vi) technology
infrastructure, including, but not limited to, telecommunications, automated data
processing, word processing and management information systems, and related
information, equipment, goods and services.
The terms "Proposal," "Qualifying Project" or "Project" will be used herein to
apply to authorized projects under either the PPTA or PPEA, unless otherwise
stated.
These procedures apply to proposals submitted under the authority of either the
PPTA or PPEA, or both. The City reserves the right to consider a proposal under
either or both Acts. While the Acts are fundamentally similar, prospective
proposers are cautioned to review them closely as there are significant
differences between the PPEA and PPTA.
The Acts allow both solicited and unsolicited proposals. The major steps
involved in evaluating, selecting, and implementing the projects are similar for
both solicited and unsolicited proposals. It is anticipated that the private sector
will identify prospective projects, although the City may, from time to time, solicit
proposals generally or for specific projects. Private entities may also propose
innovative financing methods, including the imposition of user fees, lease
payments, or other service payments under the provisions of the Acts.
As explained more fully below, these procedures adopt a "two phase" proposal
process for both solicited and unsolicited proposals. The first phase involves the
submission of a "Conceptual Proposal" of limited scope, and the second phase
requires the submission of a "Detailed Proposal" by one or more proposers
selected by the City after review of the Conceptual Proposal.
B. Point of Contact for PPTA/PP EA Information and Submission of
Proposals.
The City Manager has designated the City Purchasing Agent to serve as the
point of contact for the implementation of these procedures, to receive proposals
submitted under the PPTA/PPEA and to respond to inquiries regarding the
PPTA/PPEA or these procedures.
C. City Review Board.
All proposals for a Qualifying Project will be reviewed and selections made by a
City Review Board (CRB), which shall consist of:
The City Manager
The Director of Financial Services
The City Attorney
The Purchasing Agent
Other members as the City Manager may determine
The CRB may also employ outside advis ors and consultants to assist in its
review of proposals.
Page 78 of 138
6
D. Reservation of Rights.
In connection with any proposal or Qualifying Project, the City shall have all
rights available to it by law in administering these procedures, including without
limitation, the right in its sole and unfettered discretion to:
1. Reject any or all proposal s at any time, for any reason,
solely within the discretion of the City. Proposers shall have
no recourse against the City for such rejection. Proposers
will be notified in writ ing of such rejection in accordance with
these procedures.
2. Terminate evaluation of any and all proposals at any time.
3. Suspend, discontinue and/ or terminate Comprehensive
Agreement negotiations.
4. Negotiate with a proposer without being bound by any
provision in its proposal.
5. Request or obtain additional information about any proposal.
6. Issue addenda to and/or cancel any request for proposals
("RFP") or invitation for bids ("IFB").
7. Revise, supplement or withdr aw all or any part of these
procedures at any time.
8. Modify any standard fee schedul e as stated herein for a
specific proposal or for all future proposals.
9. Decline to return any and all fees required to be paid by
proposers hereunder, except for initial fees paid by
proposers with an unsolicited conceptual proposal where the
City declines to accept the proposal for consideration.
10. Request revisions to Conceptual or Detailed Proposals.
11. Treat any proposal which may have certain characteristics in
common yet differ in meaningful ways from a previously
received proposal as either a competing proposal or a
noncompeting unsolicited proposal and proceed accordingly.
12. Submit a proposal for review by outside consultants or
advisors selected by the City without notice to the proposer.
Such consultants or advisors shall be advised of and
contractually required to agree to maintain the confidentiality
of information that has been designated as confidential
Page 79 of 138
7
pursuant to an agreement between the City and the
proposer, and to refer all requests for such information to the
City.
13. Modify the stated timeline fo r consideration, review or
negotiation of proposals when deemed necessary by the
City in its sole discretion. Written notice will be provided to
any affected proposers when such departures from a stated
timeline are deemed significant.
Under no circumstances shall the City be liable for, or reimburse, the costs
incurred by proposers, whether or not selected for negotiations, in developing
proposals or in negotiating agreements. Any and all information the City makes
available to proposers shall be as a convenience to the proposer and without
representation or warranty of any kind. Proposers may not rely upon any oral
responses to inquiries. If a proposer has a question regarding application of
these procedures, the proposer must submit the question in writing to the City
Purchasing Agent and the City will respond in writing as it determines
appropriate.
E. Timeline for Proposal Re view and Consideration.
For solicited proposals, the City will include an anticipated timeline for
submission and review of proposals. For unsolicited proposals, the City will
attempt to review proposals in a timely manner and will discuss with the proposer
an anticipated timeline for the full process should the City decide to proceed.
Every attempt will be made to move through the process as expeditiously as
possible.
Normal expected timelines for selectin g proposals and negotiating an interim
agreement or comprehensive agreement ar e set out at Appendices C and D
hereto. Appendix C sets out the norma l expected timeline for a procurement
initiated by an unsolicited proposal. Appendix D sets out the normal expected
timeline for a procurement solicited by the City.
For projects deemed a priority by the City , the portion of timelines related to
selection, review, and documentation may be accelerated.
The City should generally adhere to thes e timelines, but the City Manager may
deviate from them when it is in the City’s interests to do so.
II. GENERAL PROVISIONS
.
A. Proposal Submission.
1. Solicited Proposals
From time to time, the City may issue RFPs or IFBs inviting proposals from
private entities to acquire, design, construct, improve, renovate, expand, equip,
Page 80 of 138
8
maintain, operate, implement and/or install Qualifying Projects. The RFP or IFB
will outline minimum qualifications and project selection criteria, specify
information and documents which must accompany the proposals, the factors
which will be used in evaluating the proposals, and contain or incorporate by
reference other applicable terms and conditions, including any unique capabilities
or qualifications which will be required of private entities submitting proposals
("proposers"). Proposers are encouraged to be as innovative as possible in their
proposals.
Pre-proposal conferences may be held, as deemed appropriate, and notice of
such will be provided in the RFP or IFB. Proposers will be instructed as to the
format in which to submit proposals and what minimum information, materials,
and fees must be submitted in order for the proposal to be considered complete.
Public notice of the solicitation of proposals under the Acts will be posted at least
60 days prior to the date set for receipt of proposals by posting in a public area of
City Hall normally used for the posting of City public notices, by posting on the
Purchasing Division website, www.lynchburgva.gov/procurement, and other
electronic posting sites, and by publication in one or more newspapers or other
publications of general circulation within and/or outside the City of Lynchburg,
including the Virginia Business Opportunities publication, so as to provide
reasonable notice to the maximum number of proposers that can be reasonably
anticipated to submit proposals. In addition, proposals may be solicited directly
from potential proposers.
2. Unsolicited Proposals
The Acts permit responsible public entities to receive, evaluate and select for
negotiations unsolicited proposals from private entities to acquire, design,
construct, improve, renovate, expand, equip, maintain, operate, implement
and/or install Qualifying Projects. The City will receive such unsolicited
proposals at any time pursuant to these procedures. The City will evaluate
unsolicited proposals whenever received so long as the proposals meet the
requirements of the Acts and these procedures and are determined to be in the
City's best interest.
Once a proposal is received and deemed by the City to meet all legal and policy
requirements for initial review, as set out in relevant provisions of the Acts, and
the proposer and the City have reached an agreement on the protection of
confidential information as permitted under Virginia Code Section 2.2-3705.A.56,
the City will publish a notice accepting such proposal for initial review and inviting
other private entities to submit competing proposals, as follows:
i. Post a notice for 45 calendar days, or such additional time
as determined by the City, in a public area of City Hall
normally designated for such public notices.
ii. Publish the same notice in one or more newspapers or
periodicals of general circulation, including the Virginia
Business Opportunities publication, as appropriate to notify
Page 81 of 138
9
potential proposers that might be interested. The notice will
state that the City has received an unsolicited proposal
under the Acts, that it intends to evaluate the proposal, that it
may negotiate a Comprehensive Agreement with the
proposer based on the proposal, and that it will accept for
simultaneous consideration any competing and compliant
proposals the City receives in accordance with these
procedures within 45 calendar days, or more, of the initial
posting of the notice. The notice will summarize the
proposed Qualifying Project, including its location, and will
generally contain a deadline, not less than 45 calendar days
from posting of the notice, for receipt of competing
proposals.
iii. Post the notice on the City' s Purchasing Division website,
www.lynchburgva.gov/procurement.
The deadline for the City's receipt of any such competing proposals in writing will
generally be 3:00 p.m. local, on the designated day after the City's initial
publication of the notice unless otherwise stated by the City in the notice of
acceptance and invitation for competing proposals. Only those competing,
compliant proposals submitted and actually received in writing by the City at the
location specified in the invitation for competing proposals by such deadline will
be considered unless the City terminates consideration of, or negotiation on the
original unsolicited proposal.
The City may, in it sole discretion, ex tend the 45 day peri od, but otherwise will
not accept competing proposals receiv ed after the designated period. The City
recognizes that it may receive proposals, which have certain characteristics in
common yet differ in meaningful ways. In such cases, the City reserves the right,
in its sole discretion, to treat such a proposal or any portion of such proposal
received after the original proposal, as either a competi ng proposal or a non-
competing unsolicited proposal, and to proceed accordingly under these
procedures.
Because of the consequences to a proposer for failing to submit within the
designated period a proposal which the City could later deem a competing
proposal, prospective proposers are strongly urged to monitor the City notices of
proposals received, and to be prepared to submit within such designated period if
they perceive that a proposal they are considering or are preparing bears certain
similarities to, or has characteristics in common with, a proposal which is the
subject of a notice.
In the event a proposer is unsure whether its planned proposal will be sufficiently
similar to the proposal which was the subject of a notice to be deemed a
competing proposal, such proposer may submit to the City a written request for
a preliminary determination of whether its project would be deemed a competing
proposal in whole or in part. The City will endeavor, no later than fourteen days
thereafter, to respond to such request with a preliminary determination as to
whether or not the proposal would be a competing proposal or that it has
received insufficient information to make a determination. In the event the City
Page 82 of 138
10
elects to treat a proposal, or part of a proposal, received within the designated
period as a non-competing proposal, the City will follow the above notice
procedure to permit competing proposals to be submitted, including from the
proposer whose proposal triggered the original notice.
If state or federal funds ar e anticipated in any proposal , the City may also notify
the appropriate state or federal agencies.
B. General Administrative Issues.
Proposers shall deliver one (1) original, nine (9) copies, and one (1) electronic
copy of their Conceptual Proposal and, if requested, Detailed Proposal to the City
at the following address:
Purchasing Agent
City of Lynchburg Purchasing Division
Third Floor Hall
900 Church Street
Lynchburg, Va. 24504
Proposals are to be sealed in mailing envelopes or packages bearing the
proposer's name, address and the words "PPTA / PPEA Project Proposal" clearly
written on the outside.
The cover page must include the title of the proposal, the name and address of
the proposing entity, the person authorized to act on behalf of the proposer and
his or her telephone and facsimile numbers, and email address.
Also, pursuant to the Acts, copies of proposals must be provided directly to the
governing body of each local jurisdiction (city, county, town etc.), if any, affected
by a proposed project. A list of all local jurisdictions being provided a copy of the
proposal must accompany the Conceptual Proposal with name and address of
recipient and date delivered.
In addition, in the case where the project is a highway or a bridge, a copy of the
proposal should be delivered to the Commonwealth Transportation
Commissioner on the same day it delivers its proposal to the City. The
Commissioner will be asked to provide written comments to the City within 60
days of receipt of such proposal.
C. General Format for Submi ssion of Conceptual Proposal.
An authorized representative of the firm or consortium making the proposal must
sign the proposal. All information requested under Section IV, "FORMAT FOR
CONCEPTUAL PROPOSAL" should be submitted. Proposers failing to submit
all information requested for Conceptual or Detailed Proposals may be given an
opportunity to promptly submit missing information or may be given a lowered
evaluation of the proposal. Conceptual Proposals that lack key information
required may be rejected.
Proposals should be prepared simply and economically, providing a
straightforward, concise description of the proposer's capabilities to complete the
Page 83 of 138
11
proposed project. Emphasis should be placed on completeness and clarity of
content.
Proposals submitted for consideration should include a comprehensive scope of
work and provide enough information about the project to determine whether it
meets the criteria stated herein. In addition, the financial plan for the project
must contain enough detail so that an analysis will reveal whether the proposed
project financing is feasible.
Proposals should be organized in the order requested herein. All pages of the
proposal should be consecutively numbered. Evaluation of proposals will be
better facilitated if proposers will cross reference responses by citing the tab
number, and sub letter, and repeating the text of the requirement, not the text of
the proposal. If a response covers more than one page, the tab number and sub
letter should be repeated at the top of the next page. The proposal should
contain a table of contents, which cross references the requirements by category.
Information that the proposer desires to present that does not fall within any of
the requirements should be inserted at an appropriate place or be attached at the
end of the proposal and designated as additional material. Proposals that are
not organized in this manner risk elimination from consideration.
Each copy of the proposal should be bound or otherwise contained in a single
volume where practical. All documentation submitted with the proposal should
be contained in that single volume, except that information for which a claim of
confidentiality is made should be submitted in a separately bound document or
volume for convenience of review by the City. Any such volume containing
confidential information should be clearly marked on its cover as containing
confidential information to reduce the potential for inadvertent disclosure.
Proposers who submit a proposal may be required to give an oral presentation of
their proposal to the City. Such presentations will provide opportunities to
educate the City and/or clarify aspects of the proposed project.
D. General Format for Submi ssion of Detailed Proposal.
Once Conceptual Proposals have been reviewed, one or more such proposers
may be selected for submission of Detailed Proposals. The required contents of
a Detailed Proposal are as listed below in Section V, entitled "FORMAT FOR
DETAILED PROPOSAL," but may be modified for specific projects in the notice
of selection and request for Detailed Proposals.
As with Conceptual Proposals, one (1) original, nine (9) copies, and one (1)
electronic copy of each Detailed Proposal must be submitted and the required
review fee increment paid. Each copy should be bound in one or more volumes
with a detailed table of contents showing the location of the required information.
The required items should be provided in individually tabbed sections marked in
accordance with the contents listed herein. Pages should be numbered
consecutively. As with Conceptual Proposals, confidential information should be
segregated into a separate volume for ease of review and production in response
to potential requests under the Virginia Freedom of Information Act (FOIA). Any
such volume containing confidential information should be clearly marked on its
Page 84 of 138
12
cover as containing confidential information to reduce the potential for
inadvertent disclosure.
E. Proposal Review Fee
The PPEA permits the City to charge a reasonable fee for the review of all
proposals for Qualifying Projects, whether solicited or unsolicited. The PPTA,
however, only allows the City to charge a review fee for unsolicited proposals.
When applicable, the fee will be payable in two increments: the first increment
must accompany the submission of a Conceptual Proposal, and the second
increment must accompany a Detailed Proposal requested by the City. Any
proposal submitted without the required fee will be deemed noncompliant and will
be rejected.
1. Proposal Review Fee for Solicited Projects.
For solicited proposals, for qualifying projects as defined under the PPEA, the fee
schedule will be set forth in the RFP or IFB.
2. Proposal Review Fee for Unsolicited Projects.
The City has established a fee schedule for the review of unsolicited proposals
for Qualifying Projects under these procedures. This fee schedule is subject to
revision for specific projects, based on the complexity or details of the project,
and upon the actual cost to the City to review the proposal.
The fee schedule is based upon the estimated construction cost of the proposed
Qualifying Project. If the proposal also includes maintenance and operation
services to be provided by the private entity for a period longer than one year
following construction, the required fee shall be increased by 50% to cover
evaluation of the services components of the proposal. Proposals including only
services and no construction component shall include a fee commensurate with a
proposal with a construction cost under $20,000,000.
a. Projects with Estimat ed Construction Cost under
$20,000,000, and "services only" proposals.
A total fee of $20,000, payable in two increments: (1) $5,000 with the Conceptual
Proposal, and (2) $15,000 with the Detailed Proposal, if requested.
b. Projects with Estimat ed Construction Cost between
$20,000,000 and $50,000,000.
A total fee of $30,000, payable in two increments: (1) $7,500 with the Conceptual
Proposal, and (2) $22,500 with the Detailed Proposal, if requested.
c. Projects with Estimated Construction Cost over
$50,000,000.
A total fee of $50,000, payable in tw o increments: (1) $10,000 with the
Conceptual Proposal, and (2) $40,000 with the Detailed Proposal if requested.
Page 85 of 138
13
3. Refunds of Fees.
If an unsolicited Conceptual Proposal is determined upon initial review by the
City to be not proper for consideration or is otherwise rejected without conclusion
of an agreement on the protection of confidential information, the initial payment
of the fee will be refunded. If an unsolicited Detailed Proposal is rejected without
negotiations with the proposer, ninety per cent (90%) of the second incremental
payment will be refunded to the proposer.
F. Virginia Freedom of Information Act.
Generally, proposal document s submitted by private ent ities are subject to the
Virginia Freedom of Information Act ("VFOI A"). In accordance with § 2.2-3705 A
56 of VFOIA, such documents are releasabl e if requested, exc ept to the extent
that they relate to (a) c onfidential proprietary inform ation submitted to the City
under a promise of confident iality or (b) memoranda, wo rking papers or other
records related to proposals if making pub lic such records would adversely affect
the financial interest of the City or the pr ivate entity or the bargaining position of
either party. Once a comprehensive ag reement has been entered into and the
process of bargaining of all phases or aspects of the comprehensive agreement
is complete, the City shall make the procurement records available upon request,
in accordance with Virginia Code §§ 2.2-4342 and 56-575.16.5. However,
proprietary, commercial or financial in formation, balance sheets, financial
statements, or trade secrets provided by a privat e entity as evidence of its
qualifications and properly designated under this paragraph as "Confidential-Not
Releasable under VFOIA" are not considered procurement records.
If requesting that the City not disclose information, the proposer must (i) invoke
an exclusion when the data or materials ar e submitted to the City or before such
submission, (ii) identify the data and materials for which protection from
disclosure is sought, and (iii) state wh y the exclusion from disclosure is
necessary. In addition, the proposer must clearly mark each page of its proposal
that it contends not to be disclos eable under the VFOIA with the legend
"Confidential – Not Releasable under VFOIA." The City may only protect
confidential proprietary information and wi ll not protect any portion of a proposal
from disclosure if the ent ire proposal has been desig nated confidential by the
proposer without re asonably differentiating bet ween the proprietary and non-
proprietary information contained therein.
Except as reasonably necessary for the Cit y, staff, and consultants to review
proposals, the City promises to mainta in the confidentialit y of confidential
proprietary information that is provided to it by a private entity pursuant to a
proposal for a procurement under these procedures if the private entity follows all
the steps required by paragraph 4.4. of this policy to designate the information as
confidential proprietary information excluded from disclosure under VFOIA, and if
the information is, in fact, information t hat is properly exempt from release under
VFOIA. The City Manager shall take r easonable precautions to protect the
confidentiality of such information from any disclosure beyond whatever
disclosure is reasonably necessary for t he City Council, staff, and consultants
having a need to know the information to carry out the procurement. Despite the
Page 86 of 138
14
City’s sincere intent to honor this promis e of confidentiality, nothing contained
herein shall constitute a wa iver of sovereign immunity, a consent to suit, or a
contractual undertaking, and it is a condi tion of submitting proposals that no
cause of action, in contract or otherwise, shall arise against the City or its Mayor,
council members, City Manager, officers, employees, attorneys, or agents for any
failure to maintain confidentiality of information.
Any information in a proposal that becom es incorporated into a Comprehensive
Agreement or Interim Agreement with t he proposer submitting it, such as by
becoming an exhibit, shall become a public record releasable under VFOIA upon
execution of the agreement and its approval by the City.
G. Affected Local Jurisdiction Review
The Acts require that proposals be submitted to affected local jurisdictions for
review. This requirement applies to both Conceptual Proposals and Detailed
Proposals. While, normally, the City of Lynchburg will be the only affected
locality, the City will notif y and solicit comment from any locality thought to be
affected by a proposal and will respond to a request from any locality that feels it
is affected. Affected localities will be provided with copies of accepted
Conceptual and Detailed Prop osals and Confidentiality Agreements at the
appropriate time in the process and will be given 60 days from the receipt of such
documents to provide comment. Comment s received within the 60-day period
will be given consideration by the City and no negative infer ence will be drawn
from the absence of comment.
Each proposer will be permitted to review any comments from affected
jurisdictions applicable to its or other proposals, subject to limitations on the
sharing of confidential information under a Confidentiality Agreement.
H. Applicability of Other Law.
1. Use of Public Funds
Virginia constitutional and statutory requi rements as they apply to appropriation
and expenditure of public funds apply to any agreement entered into under the
PPTA or PPEA. Accordingly, the pr ocesses and procedur al requirements
associated with the expend iture or obligation of public funds should be
incorporated into planning for any PPTA or PPEA projec t, and any PPTA/PPEA
procurement should comply with City fiscal policies. Virginia constitutional and
statutory restrictions that apply to the City regarding expenditures of public funds
shall be deemed to be incorporated into any agreement into which the City enters
pursuant to the PPTA/PPEA and to condition the City's obligations thereunder.
Nothing in the Acts affects the duty of the City or any of its officers, employees or
agents to comply with all other applicable law not in conflict with the Acts, and
proposals for Qualifying Projects shall consider those requirements where
applicable. However, the applicability of the Virginia Public Procurement Act (the
VPPA) shall be as set forth in paragraph I of this policy.
Page 87 of 138
15
I. Adoption of Certain Portions of the Virginia Public Procurement Act
and Use of Competitive Negotiation and Competitive Sealed
Bidding Procedures.
The provisions of the Virg inia Public Procurement Ac t, Va. Code § 2.2-4300, et
seq., shall not apply to procurements by the City under the PPTA/PPEA except
as follows:
1. The definitions of "compet itive sealed bidding" and
"competitive negotiation" of othe r than professional services
in Va. Code § 2.2-4301 are hereby adopted.
2. The provisions of Va. C ode §2.2-4310 shall apply to all
PPTA/PPEA procurements.
3. The provisions from the Ethics in Public Contracting Act, Va.
Code § 2.2-4367 through 2.2-4377, shall apply to all
PPTA/PPEA procurements.
4. The provisions of Va . Code §2.2-4343 are adopted as
additional authority for parts of this policy.
5. The provisions of Virginia Code §2.2-4337 apply to bonds or
letters of credit for any com ponents of a qualifying project
involving construction.
6. Before accepting any unsolic ited proposal or before issuing
any solicitation for proposals, the City will determine whether
it will proceed to evaluate proposals using either:
a. "Competitive sealed bidding" , as defined in Va. Code
§ 2.2-4301; or
b. "Competitive negotiation" of other than professional
services as defined in Va. Code § 2.2-4301.
7. The City may proceed using competitive negotiation
procedures described in paragr aph 6.a. above only if the
City Council first makes a written determination pursuant to
Virginia Code § 56-575. 16.2 that doing so is likely to be
advantageous to the public based upon either (i) the
probable scope, complexity or priori ty of the project, or (ii)
the risk sharing, including gu aranteed cost or completion
guarantees, added value, or debt or equity investments
proposed, or (iii) the increase in funding, dedicated revenue
source or other economic benefit that would otherwise not
be available.
Page 88 of 138
16
III. PROPOSAL EVALUATION AND SELECTION.
A. Decision to Accept an Unsolicited Proposal.
The City must make several determinations in order to accept an unsolicited
proposal for a Qualifying Project. Proposers are required to address all of the
following criteria in their proposals to assist the City in making informed
determinations.
B. Initial Review by the City.
1. Determination if the proposal presents a "Qualifying Project"
under the PPTA or the PPEA.
The first determination that must be made by the City is whether the proposal
constitutes a "Qualifying Project" under the PPEA, or a "qualified transportation
facility" under the PPTA. The definitions of these terms are presented in the
introduction to these procedures.
2. Determination of whether t he proposed project meets the
public purposes of the Acts and the City.
The Acts require that the City determine if the proposed project serves the public
purpose as defined in the Acts by facilitating the timely acquisition, design,
construction, improvement, renovation, expansion, equipping, maintenance,
operation, implementation and/or installation of a Qualifying Project or facility.
Specifically, in determining whether a proposed project meets this "public
purpose" requirement, the City must determine if:
a. There is a public need fo r or benefit derived from the
Qualifying Project;
b. The estimated cost of the Qualifying Project is
reasonable in relation to similar facilities; and
c. The private entity's plans will result in the timely
acquisition, design, construction, improvement,
renovation, expansion, equipping, maintenance,
implementation, installation, and/or operation of the
Qualifying Project.
Each of these criteria should be addressed in the proposal.
In addition, the City will determine if the proposed project is desirable and
compatible with other City, regional or state plans. Proposers are cautioned that
a proposal may be rejected on this basis alone even if it is an otherwise
Qualifying Project under the Acts.
3. Determination to use "com petitive sealed bidding" or
"competitive negotiation" procedures.
The City will acquire a Qualifying Project through the use of "competitive sealed
bidding" procedures unless a determination is made, in writing, that proceeding
Page 89 of 138
17
through "competitive negotiation" procedures will be advantageous to the City
and the public based on the (a) the probable scope, complexity or urgency of the
project, or (b) risk sharing, added value, an increase in funding or economic
benefit from the project that would not otherwise be available. Proposers should
address these factors in their proposals.
C. Written determination of qualification.
The City will make a written determination that the above criteria are satisfied
prior to proceeding with further consideration of Conceptual Proposals.
D. Conclusion of an Agreement on the Protection of Confidential
Information.
Following a decision of the City to accept and consider a Conceptual Proposal,
the City and the proposer will review the provisions of paragraph II.F., above,
and, if necessary, execute a Confidentiality Agreement designating confidential
information within the proposal that will be excluded from public availability under
the Virginia FOIA.
E. Publication for Competing Proposals.
Following a decision by the City to accept a Conceptual Proposal and the
conclusion of a Confidentiality Agreement, the City will publish a notice of its
decision and an invitation for the submission of competing proposals ("the public
notice").
If the City has determined it will proceed under competitive sealed bidding
procedures, it will so state in the public notice, and advise that it will enter into
negotiations to execute a Comprehensive Agreement for a Qualifying Project
with the proposer presenting a Qualifying Project with the lowest evaluated cost
to the City.
If the City has determined it will proceed under competitive negotiation
procedures, it will so state in the public notice and advise of any special
evaluation criteria it will use in its evaluation in addition to those stated in these
procedures or it will identify the person from whom such information can be
obtained at the City. If the City uses these procedures, it is not required to select
the proposal with the lowest price offer, but may consider price as one factor in
evaluating the proposals received.
The public notice will state the date, time and location for receipt of competing
proposals in accordance with these Procedures.
F. Receipt of Competing Proposals.
After passage of the date for the receipt of competing proposals, the City will
review and make the initial determinations required above for all competing
proposals. The City may reject any or all proposals at any time.
Page 90 of 138
18
G. Determination and Agreement on Confidential Material for
Competing Proposals.
Agreement must be reached on all competing proposals regarding protection of
confidential information. Upon conclusion of Confidentiality Agreements, if any,
with private entities submitting accepted proposals, the City may begin its review.
H. Selection for Submission of Detailed Proposals.
If no competing proposals are submitted after publication of the public notice, or
only one Conceptual Proposal is received in response to an RFP or IFB, the City
may proceed immediately to request a Detailed Proposal from the sole proposer.
Otherwise, the City shall then evaluate all Conceptual Proposals according to the
evaluation factors, and select two or more proposers deemed to be fully qualified
and best suited for submission of Detailed Proposals, unless it makes a written
determination that the original proposer was the only fully qualified proposer or
was clearly more highly qualified than the others under consideration.
The CRB will perform its review of each Conceptual Proposal to determine
whether the proposer has, in the sole opinion of the CRB (i) submitted a
complete proposal; (ii) assembled a team which is qualified and capable of
completing the proposed facility; (iii) developed a conceptual plan which is
technically feasible; and (iv) provided a financial plan which will allow access to
the necessary capital to finance the facility. The CRB may consider the advice of
outside consultants and advisors, federal and state agencies with appropriate
technical expertise, and legal counsel in reaching its decision. The CRB may
request oral presentations and/or additional documentation in order to assess
project feasibility and proposer's qualifications. If any proposer makes an oral
presentation, each proposer will be given that same opportunity.
The City will request submission of Detailed Proposals in writing and state the
date by which such submissions shall be required. The request for Detailed
Proposals shall specify the deliverables that must be included in the Detailed
Proposal. The City may also request that a proposer address in detail certain
aspects of its proposal or respond to certain questions in its Detailed Proposal.
Those private entities submitting proposals not selected for Detailed Proposals
shall also be notified in writing.
I. Receipt and Review of Detailed Proposals.
Those Detailed proposals received in a timely manner and complying with the
requirements of these procedures and the City's request for Detailed Proposals
will be reviewed by the CRB. Before such review, however, the City will execute
a Confidentiality Agreement, if necessary, with each proposer as to the protection
of confidential information.
A Detailed Proposal should not depart significantly from the technical approach
or financing plan described in the Conceptual Proposal. If a proposer departs
significantly in either respect, the City may reject the Detailed Proposal as non-
Page 91 of 138
19
compliant. In particular, adoption of significant aspects or characteristics of a
competing Conceptual Proposal will normally result in disqualification and
rejection of a Detailed Proposal.
Proposers may be required to make an oral presentation to the CRB to explain
their proposals and respond to questions. The format of the presentation will
include a formal presentation by the proposer, followed by any questions the
CRB may have pertaining to the project proposal or the presentation. The CRB
may also ask the proposer to address concerns expressed through the public
comment process. These meetings will allow the City to seek clarification of
project elements and complete deliverable requirements, and provide proposers
with the opportunity to further explain their proposed projects. If there is an issue
to which the proposer is unable to respond during the formal presentation, the
City may, at its discretion, grant the proposer a reasonable period of time in
which to submit a written response.
The CRB may request clarifying or additional information from any proposer
regarding its Detailed Proposal.
J. Selection of Proposal(s) for Negotiation of Comprehensive
Agreement.
The CRB will consider comments from any affected local jurisdictions and any
oral presentations of the proposers, and select one or more proposals for
negotiations leading to the selection of one proposal for the negotiation of a
Comprehensive Agreement. The selection by the CRB will be presented to the
Lynchburg City Council for review and final approval.
K. Negotiation and Approval of Comprehensive Agreement.
Following approval of the selected proposal, the City and the private entity
proposer will enter into negotiations to conclude a Comprehensive Agreement. If
the City and the proposer cannot conclude a Comprehensive Agreement
acceptable to both parties within a reasonable time, the City may terminate
negotiations with the selected proposer and negotiate with another proposer, or it
may terminate all negotiations or consideration of the proposed project.
The Lynchburg City Council must approve the proposed Comprehensive
Agreement before its execution.
IV. FORMAT FOR CONCEPTUAL PROPOSALS.
A. Description
Proposals shall provide a straightforward, concise delineation of capabilities,
experience and approach. Elaborate brochures and/or excessive promotional
materials are not required or desirable. A Conceptual Proposal shall contain the
following information: (i) proposer’s qualifications and experience, (ii) project
characteristics, (iii) project financing and estimate of construction costs, (iv)
anticipated public support or opposition, or both, (v) project benefit and
Page 92 of 138
20
compatibility and (vi) any additional information as the City may reasonably
request to comply with the requirements of the Acts.
Information in Conceptual proposals should be organized into an Executive
Summary, Introduction, and individually tabbed sections in accordance with the
following format:
Executive Summary
A brief description of the project scope and characteristics, the general approach
to financing the proposed project and the benefits. The Executive Summary may
be used by the City in public notices and other short descriptions of the proposal.
Introduction
Among other information, the Introduction should address the criteria by which
the City must evaluate the proposed project to determine if it is a "Qualifying
Project" under the Acts, identify how the proposed project serves the public
purposes of the Acts, and whether or not the use of competitive negotiation as a
method of procurement can be authorized.
B. TAB 1.
Qualification and Experience
a. Identify the legal struct ure of the firm or consortium of firms making the
proposal. Identify the organizational structure for the project, the
management approach and how each entity and major subcontractor in
the structure fits into the overall team.
b. Describe the experience of the firm or consortium of firms making the
proposal and the key principals involved in the proposed project including
the length of time in business, business experience, public sector
experience, other engagements of the firm or consortium of firms and
experience with projects of comparable size and complexity. Include the
identity of any firms that will provide performance guarantees and
warranties and a description of such guarantees and warranties.
c. Provide the names, addresses, em ail addresses, and telephone numbers
of persons within the firm or consortium of firms who may be contacted for
further information.
d. Provide the address, telephone nu mber, and the name of a specific
contact person for an entity, or entities, for which the firm or consortium of
firms, or primary members of the consortium, have completed a similar
project or projects. These references should include:
• Name and address of project owner/sponsor
• Name, telephone number, fax number, and email
address of the owner’s project manager
• A summary of the projec t including budget and final
cost
• Project schedule (proposed and actual)
Page 93 of 138
21
e. Provide the most recent audited fi nancial statement of the firm or firms,
and each partner with an equity interest of twenty percent or greater.
Such financial statements shall be for a period not more than one year
before the date of the proposal. Submit the most recent Securities and
Exchange Commission 10-K and 10-Q reports, if such reports have been
filed.
f. Identify any persons known to t he proposer who would be disqualified
from participation in any transaction arising from or in connection to the
project pursuant to The Virginia State and Local Government Conflict of
Interest Act (Virginia Code § 2.2-3100 et seq.).
g. Include any planned participation by small, women-owned, or minority-
owned businesses during project development and implementation.
C. TAB 2.
Project Characteristics
a. Provide a description of the proj ect, including the conceptual design.
Describe the proposed project in sufficient detail so that the type and
intent of the project, the location, and the communities that may be
affected are clearly identified. Include a description of any components,
planned initially or for the future, that are expected to generate revenue for
the project or the proposer.
b. Identify and fully describe any wo rk to be performed by the City.
c. Provide a statement setting out the plans for securing all necessary
property. The statement must include the names and addresses, if
known, of the current owners of the subject property as well as a list of
any property the proposer intends to request the City to condemn.
d. Include a list of all federal, stat e and local permits and approvals required
for the project and a schedule for obtaining such permits and approvals.
Identify which, if any, permits or approvals are to be obtained by the City.
e. Identify any anticipated adverse social, economic and environmental
impacts of the project. Specify the strategies or actions to mitigate known
impacts of the project.
f. Identify the project ed positive social, economic and environmental impacts
of the project.
g. Identify the proposed schedule for wo rk on the project, including the
estimated time for completion, and any extended or maintenance
warranties.
h. Propose allocation of risk and liability for work completed beyond the
agreement's completion date, and assurances for timely completion of the
project.
Page 94 of 138
22
i. State assumptions related to owner ship, legal liability, law enforcement
and operation of the project and the existence of any restrictions on the
City's or the public's use of the project.
j. Provide information relative to phas ed or partial openings of the proposed
project prior to completion of the entire work.
D. TAB 3.
Project Financing
a. Provide a preliminary estimate and estimating methodology of the cost of
the work by phase and/or segment (e.g. planning, design, construction).
b. Submit a plan for the developmen t, financing and operation of the project
showing the anticipated schedule on which funds will be required.
Describe the anticipated costs of and proposed sources and uses for such
funds.
c. Include a list and discussion of assump tions (user fees, tolls, usage rates)
underlying all major elements of the plan.
d. Identify the proposed risk factor s and methods for dealing with these
factors.
e. Identify any local, state or f ederal resources that the proposer
contemplates requesting for the project. Describe the total commitment
(financial, services, property, etc.), if any, expected from governmental
sources and the timing of any anticipated commitment.
f. Provide financial information whic h indicates the proposer’s financial
stability and ability to finance the project.
g. Include a description and analysis (c ost/benefit, tax, etc.) to demonstrate
the project’s financial feasibility.
E. TAB 4.
Public Support, Project Benefit and Compatibility
a. Identify who will benefit from the project, how they will benefit and how the
project will benefit the overall community, region, or state.
b. Identify any anticipated public sup port or opposition, as well as any
anticipated government support or opposition for the project.
c. Explain the strategy and plans to involve and inform the general public,
business community, and governmental agencies in areas affected by the
project.
d. Describe the anticipated significant benefits to the community, region or
state, including anticipated benefits to the economic condition of the City
and whether the project is critical to attracting or maintaining competitive
industries and businesses to the City or the surrounding region.
Page 95 of 138
23
e. Address project compatibility with the City's master plan, local
comprehensive plans, local infrastructure development plans, the capital
improvements plan or other government spending plan.
V. FORMAT FOR DETAILED PROPOSALS.
A. Description and Required Information
If the City decides to proceed to the detailed phase of review with one or more
proposals, it shall specify any particular deliverables it will require in the Detailed
Proposals. In addition, the following information should be provided by the
proposer unless waived by the City:
1. A topographical map (1:2,000 or other appropriate scale) depicting
the location of the proposed project;
2. A list of public or private utility facilities, if any, that will be crossed
by the Qualifying Project and a statement of the plans of the
proposer to accommodate such crossings;
3. A statement and strategy setti ng forth the plans for securing all
necessary property. The statement must include the names and
addresses, if known, of the current owners of the subject property
as well as a list of any property the proposer intends to request the
City to condemn;
4. A detailed listing of all firms that will provide specific design,
construction and completion guarantees and warranties, and a brief
description of such guarantees and warranties;
5. A total life-cycle cost specif ying methodology and assumptions of
the project or projects and the proposed project start date. Include
the anticipated commitment of all parties; equity, debt, and other
financing mechanisms; and a schedule of project revenues and
project costs. The life-cycle cost analysis should include, but not
be limited to, a detailed analysis of the projected return, rate of
return, or both, expected useful life of facility and estimated annual
operating expenses.
6. A detailed discussion of assumpti ons about user fees or rates, and
usage of the projects.
7. Identification of any known gov ernment support or opposition, or
general public support or opposition for the project. Government or
public support should be demonstrated through resolution of official
bodies, minutes of meetings, letters, or other official
communications.
Page 96 of 138
24
8. Demonstration of consistency with appropriate local comprehensive
or infrastructure development plans or indication of the steps
required for acceptance into such plans.
9. Identification of any known conflicts of interest or other disabilities
that may impact the City's consideration of the proposal, including
the identification of any persons known to the proposer who would
be disqualified from participation in any transaction arising from or
in connection to the project pursuant to The Virginia State and
Local Government Conflict of Interest Act (Code of Virginia § 2.2-
3100 et seq.).
10. Additional material and info rmation as the City may reasonably
request.
VI. PROPOSAL EVALUATION.
A. Manner of Evaluat ion and Use of Outside Professionals
Unless the City Council directs a differ ent manner of evaluat ion in writing,
evaluations of proposals shall be by such persons or group or committee of
persons as the City Manager may designate, subject to such review as the City
Council or City Manager may direct. Eval uations of proposals shall include,
without limitation, analysis of t he proposals’ specifics, advantages,
disadvantages, long-term costs, and shor t-term costs, using the evaluation
criteria specified for the procuremen t. The City Manager shall engage the
services of qualified professionals not em ployed by the City, which may include,
without limitation, an architect, profes sional engineer, or certified public
accountant, to provide an independent analys is as part of the evaluation.
Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, if the City Council determines that such
analysis of proposals will be performed by City staff, the City Manager need not
engage such an outside professional.
B. Evaluation and Se lection Criteria
The City will consider criteria it deems appropriate in the evaluation and selection
of proposals at all phases of its review. Such criteria may include some or all of
the criteria listed in Appendix E hereto but shall not be limited to those criteria
alone. The City may, in its sole discretion, select other evaluation criteria that it
deems appropriate to the specific project.
VII. COMPREHENSIVE AGREEMEN TS and INTERIM AGREEMENTS.
A. Description and Terms
Prior to acquiring, designing, constructing, improving, renovating, expanding,
equipping, operating, implementing and/or installing, a Qualifying Project the
proposer(s) selected must enter into a comprehensive agreement with the City.
Page 97 of 138
25
Each Comprehensive Agreement shall define the rights and obligations of the
City and the selected proposer with regard to the project. The terms of the
Comprehensive Agreement shall include but not be limited to:
1. The delivery of maintenance, performance and payment bonds or
letters of credit in connection with any acquisition, design,
construction, improvement, renovation, expansion, equipping,
maintenance, operation, implementation or installation of the
Qualifying Project, in the forms and amounts satisfactory to the
City;
2. The performance milestones that will be required of the proposer.
3. The design, construction, operation and main tenance standards
with which the proposer must comply.
4. The review and approval of plans and specifications for the
Qualifying Project by the City if the plans and specifications
conform to the City’s standard conditions;
5. The rights of the City to ins pect the Qualifying Project to ensure
compliance with the Comprehensive Agreement;
6. The maintenance of a policy or policies of liability insurance,
(copies of which shall be filed with the City accompanied by proofs
of insurance), or self-insurance, in form and amount satisfactory to
the City and reasonably sufficient to insure coverage of the project
and the tort liability to the public and employees and to enable the
continued operation of the Qualifying Project;
7. The right of the proposer to ac quire, design, construct, improve,
renovate, expand, equip, maintain, operate, implement and/or
install the facility, the duration of the operator’s rights to operate the
facility, and the conditions under which the facility will be dedicated
to the City.
8. The monitoring of the practices of the proposer and/or operator by
the City to ensure proper maintenance and provisions for the City to
take appropriate action to ensure the facility is properly maintained.
9. The procedures by and condit ions under which the City will
exercise its power of eminent domain.
10. The terms under which the propos er and/or operator will reimburse
the City for services provided;
11. The events that will constitu te default by the proposer, the
proposer’s rights to notice and cure and the remedies available to
the City.
Page 98 of 138
26
12. The events that will constitute defaul t by the City, the City’s rights to
notice and cure and the remedies available to the proposer.
13. The rights and remedies of any lender with respect to the
proposer’s defaults and the City’s remedies.
14. The policy and procedures that will govern the rights and
responsibilities of the City and the proposer and/or operator in the
event that the Comprehensive Agreement is terminated or there is
a material default by the proposer and/or operator including the
conditions governing assumption of the duties and responsibilities
of the proposer and/or operator by the City and the transfer or
purchase of property or other interests of the proposer and/or
operator to/by the City;
15. The events that will constitute force majeure and the remedies the
parties will have in the event of such occurrence.
16. The terms under which the pr oposer and/or operat or will file
appropriate financial statements on a periodic basis.
17 The mechanism by which user fees, lease payments, or service
payments, if any, may be established from time to time upon
agreement of the parties. Any payments or fees shall be set at a
level that are the same for persons using the facility under like
conditions and that will not materially discourage use of the
Qualifying Project;
a. A copy of any service contra ct shall be filed with the City.
b. The proposer and/or operator shall make a schedule of the
current user fees or lease payments available to any
member of the public upon request.
c. Classifications accordin g to reasonable categories for
assessment of user fees may be made.
18. The terms and conditions unde r which the City may contribute
financial, or other, resources, if any, for the Qualifying Project; and
19. The conditions under which th e proposer may assign its rights
under the Comprehensive Agreement.
20. The obligation of t he operator to maintain records, to allow
inspection and audit and to provide regular reports to the City.
21. Other requirem ents of the Acts
Any changes in the terms of the Comprehensive Agreement as may be agreed
upon by the parties from time to time shall be added to the Comprehensive
Agreement by written amendment.
Page 99 of 138
27
B. Interim Agreements
In exceptional circumstances, the City may enter into an “Interim Agreement”
within the meaning of the PPEA prior to or in connection with the negotiation of a
comprehensive agreement for a qualifying project when doi ng so clearly is in the
City’s best interests. As a matter of policy, the City does not favor entry into
“Interim Agreements” with proposers because this technique tends to reduce
competition and competitive negotiations. In particular, entry into an “Interim
Agreement” with a proposer without firs t reaching an agreement as to the
material terms of a comprehensive agr eement, particularly as to Guaranteed
Maximum Price, scope of work, and qualit y of work, generally would tend to
eliminate most of the Cit y’s ability to obtain the best value through competitive
negotiations with two or more proposers. Accordingly, use of “Interim
Agreements” is strongly disfavored by the City, and their use must be fully
justified. Further, as a condition for entry into any interim agreement, the City
must first obtain approval of such entry from the City Council.
VIII. DISPUTES, CLAIMS AND OT HER MATTERS ARISING UNDER OR
RELATING TO ANY COMPREHENSIVE AGREEMENT OR INTERIM
AGREEMENT
The following provisions apply to any disp utes, claims or other matters arising
under or relating to any comprehensive ag reement or interim agreement entered
into pursuant to the Acts by the City on the one hand ("Owner") , and any private
entity ("Contractor"), on the other hand. Disputes, claims and other matters in
question between the parties arising under or relating to any comprehensive
agreement or any interim agreement shall only be resolved as follows:
A. The Contractor shall give Owner written notice of any claim for any
additional compensation, damages, delay or other relief within ten (10)
days of the beginning of t he occurrence of the event leading to the claim
being made and shall submit the actual claim and any supporting data
within thirty (30) days after the occu rrence giving rise to the claim ends.
The written notice shall be a docum ent addressed to the Owner that
clearly states Contractor's intenti on to make a claim and the occurrence
involved and shall be transmitted in a manner to ensure prompt receipt by
Owner. The claim must be certifi ed under oath as true and correct by a
principal of Contractor. The "occurrence" means the condition
encountered in the field giving rise to the claim and not a later dispute
about payment for that condition. Claims of time impacts will be resolved
as they occur, and no claims of cumu lative impacts or deferral of claimed
time impacts will be allowed. Complete satisfaction of this subparagraph
12.1 is an absolute prerequisi te for Contractor to pursue a claim, dispute,
or other matter arising under or rela ting to the agreement. Failure by
Contractor to satisfy this paragraph VIII.A. shall constitute a waiver by
Contactor of the claim, dispute, or other matter for which such failure
occurs.
Page 100 of 138
28
B. The parties shall first endeavor to resolve any disputes, claims or other
matters in question between them through direct negotiations, and if such
direct negotiations fail, by non-binding mediati on conducted pursuant to
the Rules of the American Arbitration Association, with the site of the
mediation being Lynchburg, Vi rginia. Should the di spute, claim or other
matter in question remain unresolved for the shorter of (i) following
negotiation and mediation, or (ii) mo re than 90 days after mediation is
requested by a party, either party ma y proceed in accordance with 12.1.3
below. However, nothing in this paragraph VIII.B. excuses Contractor
from compliance with all the provisions of Section VIII.
C. If the procedures of paragraph VIII.B. have been followed, but, more than
90 days have passed since a party has invoked mediation, and the
dispute, claim or other matter in question remains unresolved, then either
party may institute a lawsuit or chanc ery action, as appropriate, in the
Lynchburg Circuit Court, Lynchburg, Virginia, or if the subject or amount in
controversy is within its jurisdiction, the Lynchburg General District Court,
Lynchburg, Virginia, and may thereafte r pursue all available appeals in
Virginia state courts, to the extent they have jurisdiction.
D. Nothing in paragraphs VIII.B. and VIII.C. shall prevent a party from
seeking temporary injunctive or other temporary equitable relief in the
Lynchburg Circuit Court if circumstances so warrant.
E. In the event of any di spute, claim, or other matter in question arising,
Contractor shall continue its performance diligently during its pendency as
if no dispute, claim or other matte r in question had arisen. During the
pendency of any claim, dispute or ot her matter in connection with the
payments of moneys, Contractor sha ll be entitled to receive payments for
non-disputed items, subject to any right of set-off by Owner.
F. These procedures and the provisio ns of the interim agreement or
comprehensive agreement, as applicable, supercede any right at common
law by Contractor for a claim of mate rial breach or for rescission of such
agreement.
G. These procedures shall be deem ed automatically incorporated by
reference into any agreement entered in to by the City pursuant to the
Acts.
H. For purposes of these procedur es, "Owner" means the City, and
"Contractor" means the private entity or entit ies entering into the
agreement with the Cit y, as well as Contractor's successors, assigns,
sureties or others claiming through Contractor.
I. The City Manager may further supplem ent Section VIII. of this policy with
the terms and conditions of any agreements.
Page 101 of 138
29
IX. PROTESTS OF PPTA/PPEA PROCUREMENTS
The following are the exclusive proc edures for contesting or challenging
(protesting) (a) the terms or conditions of any solicitation of proposals by the City
pursuant to the Acts, (b) nonselection of a proposal for further consideration, and
(c) the selection of any proposal for ent ry into a comprehensive agreement or
interim agreement or the entry into a comprehensive agreement or interim
agreement under the Acts:
A. Any protest to any term or conditi on of a solicitation or any term or
condition imposed by the City must be made in writing and delivered to the
City Manager so it is received by the City Manager bef ore proposals are
due. Otherwise, any such protest shall be deemed to be waived.
B. A protest of a City decision not to select a proposal for further
consideration may only be made by the entity w ho submitted the proposal
at issue. A protest of a City decision to select a proposal for entry into an
agreement or to enter into an agreement may only be made by an entity
who submitted a proposal for the procurement at is sue and who was
reasonably likely to have its proposal a ccepted but for the City's decision.
Protests shall only be gr anted if (1) the proteste r has complied fully with
this Section IX and there has been a viol ation of law, these guidelines, or
mandatory terms of the solic itation that clearly prej udiced the protestor in
a material way, or (2) a statute requires voiding of the decision.
C. Any entity desiring to protest a City decision not to select a proposal for
further consideration, to select a pr oposal for entry into an agreement, or
to enter into an agreement shall submit the protest in writing and deliver it
so that it is received by the Cit y Manager not later than 5 business days
after announcement of the decision. Oth erwise any such protest shall be
deemed to be waived.
D. The City Manager shall issue a wri tten decision on a protest within 10
days of its receipt by the City Manager.
E. If the protest is denied, the prot ester may only appeal the denial or
otherwise contest or chal lenge the procurement by then filing suit in the
Lynchburg Circuit Court, Lynchburg, Vi rginia, and serving the City with
such suit within 10 days of such denial. Otherwise, the protester's right to
appeal the denial or to ot herwise contest or cha llenge the procurement
shall be deemed to be waived.
F. The exclusive relief allowed if a prot est is granted is to void the decision
being protested. Under no circum stances will any monetary relief be
allowed.
G. Strictly following these procedures shall be a mandatory prerequisite for
any challenge of any nature to a decisi on by the City relating to terms and
conditions of a PPTA/PPEA solicitati on or terms and conditions imposed
by the City, nonselection of a proposal for further consideration, selection
of a proposal, or entry into an agreement. A failure to follow all these
Page 102 of 138
30
procedures strictly shall constitute a waiver of any right to challenge
judicially a City decision (a) as to terms or conditions in a PPTA/PPEA
solicitation or imposed by the City, (b) not to sele ct a proposal for further
consideration, (c) to select a proposal, or (d) to enter into an agreement.
X. PARTICIPATION OF SMALL AND MINORITY-OWNED BUSINESS
The City's policy is to facilitate partic ipation of small businesses and businesses
owned by women and minorit ies in its procurement transactions, including
procurement transactions under the Acts.
Persons making proposals to the City pursuant to the Acts should ensure that
reasonable efforts are made to facilitate participation of small businesses and
businesses owned by women and minorities as part of their proposals. Resort to
lists of such businesses available from the Virginia Department of Minority
Enterprise is encouraged.
XI. PROPOSERS' AGREEMENT TO TERMS AND CONDITIONS OF THIS
POLICY
The City Manager shall require as a c ondition of accepting any proposal for
consideration that its proposer agree to be bound by all the te rms and conditions
of this policy. Proposers shall submit with any proposal the certification that is
set out at Appendix F hereto.
Page 103 of 138
31
Appendix A
The Public-Private Transportation Act of 1995
Code of Virginia, 1950, As Amended
§ 56-556. Title.
This chapter may be cited as the "Public-Private Transportation Act of 1995."
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-557. Definitions.
As used in this chapter, unless the context requires a different meaning:
"Affected local jurisdiction" means any county, city or town in which all or a portion of a
qualifying transportation facility is located.
"Asset management" means a systematic process of operating and maintaining the state
system of highways by combining engineering practices and analyses with sound
business practices and economic theory to achieve cost-effective outcomes.
"Commission" means the State Corporation Commission.
"Comprehensive agreement" means the comprehensive agreement between the operator
and the responsible public entity required by § 56-566 of this chapter.
"Maintenance" means that term as defined in § 33.1-23.02.
"Material default" means any default by the operator in the performance of its duties
under subsection F of § 56-565 of this chapter that jeopardizes adequate service to the
public from a qualifying transportation facility and remains unremedied after the
responsible public entity has provided notice to the operator and a reasonable cure period
has elapsed.
"Operator" means the private entity that is responsible for the acquisition, construction,
improvement, maintenance and/or operation of a qualifying transportation facility.
"Private entity" means any natural person, corporation, limited liability company,
partnership, joint venture or other private business entity.
"Public entity" means the Commonwealth and any agency or authority thereof, any
county, city or town and any other political subdivision of any of the foregoing, but shall
not include any public service company.
"Qualifying transportation facility" means one or more transportation facilities acquired,
constructed, improved, maintained and/or operated by a private entity pursuant to this
chapter.
"Responsible public entity" means a public entity that has the power to acquire, construct,
improve, maintain and/or operate the applicable transportation facility.
Page 104 of 138
32
"Revenues" means the user fees and/or service payments generated by a qualifying
transportation facility.
"Service contract" means a contract entered into between a public entity and the operator
pursuant to § 56-561 of this chapter.
"Service payments" means payments to the operator of a qualifying transportation facility
pursuant to a service contract.
"State" means the Commonwealth of Virginia.
"Transportation facility" means any road, bridge, tunnel, overpass, ferry, airport, mass
transit facility, vehicle parking facility, port facility or similar commercial facility used
for the transportation of persons or goods, together with any other property that is needed
to operate the transportation facility.
"User fees" mean the rates, fees or other charges imposed by the operator of a qualifying
transportation facility for use of all or a portion of such qualifying transportation facility
pursuant to the comprehensive agreement.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647; 2001, c. 286; 2002, cc. 570, 593.)
§ 56-558. Policy.
A. The General Assembly finds that:
1. There is a public need for timely acquisition or construction of and improvements to
transportation facilities within the Commonwealth that are compatible with state and
local transportation plans;
2. Such public need may not be wholly satisfied by existing ways in which transportation
facilities are acquired, constructed or improved; and
3. Authorizing private entities to acquire, construct, improve, maintain, and/or operate
one or more transportation facilities may result in the availability of such transportation
facilities to the public in a more timely or less costly fashion, thereby serving the public
safety and welfare.
B. An action, other than the approval of the responsible public entity under § 56-560 of
this chapter, shall serve the public purpose of this chapter if such action facilitates the
timely acquisition or construction of or improvement to a qualifying transportation
facility or the continued operation of a qualifying transportation facility.
C. It is the intent of this chapter, among other things, to facilitate to the greatest extent
possible, the pooling and funding mechanisms of the Intermodal Surface Transportation
Efficiency Act of 1991, and any successor legislation, to the end that transportation
financing be expanded and accelerated to improve and add to the convenience of the
public, and such that public and private entities may have the greatest possible flexibility
in contracting with each other for the provision of the public services which are the
subject of this chapter.
Page 105 of 138
33
D. This chapter shall be liberally construed in conformity with the purposes hereof.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-559. Prerequisite for operation.
Any private entity seeking authorization under this chapter to acquire, construct, improve,
maintain and/or operate a transportation facility shall first obtain approval of the
responsible public entity under § 56-560. Such private entity may initiate the approval
process by requesting approval pursuant to subsection A of § 56-560 or the responsible
public entity may request proposals pursuant to subsection B of § 56-560.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-560. Approval by the responsible public entity.
A. The private entity may request approval by the responsible public entity. Any such
request shall be accompanied by the following material and information unless waived by
the responsible public entity with respect to the transportation facility or facilities that the
private entity proposes to operate as a qualifying transportation facility:
1. A topographic map (1:2,000 or other appropriate scale) indicating the location of the
transportation facility or facilities;
2. A description of the transportation facility or facilities, including the conceptual design
of such facility or facilities and all proposed interconnections with other transportation
facilities;
3. The projected total life-cycle cost of the transportation facility or facilities and the
proposed date for acquisition of or the beginning of construction of, or improvements to
the transportation facility or facilities;
4. A statement setting forth the method by which the operator proposes to secure all
property interests required for the transportation facility or facilities. The statement shall
include: (i) the names and addresses, if known, of the current owners of the property
needed for the transportation facility or facilities, (ii) the nature of the property interests
to be acquired, and (iii) any property that the responsible public entity is expected to be
requested to condemn;
5. Information relating to the current transportation plans, if any, of each affected local
jurisdiction;
6. A list of all permits and approvals required for acquisition or construction of or
improvements to the transportation facility or facilities from local, state, or federal
agencies and a projected schedule for obtaining such permits and approvals;
7. A list of public utility facilities, if any, that will be crossed by the transportation
facility or facilities and a statement of the plans of the operator to accommodate such
crossings;
Page 106 of 138
34
8. A statement setting forth the operator's general plans for financing and operating the
transportation facility or facilities;
9. The names and addresses of the persons who may be contacted for further information
concerning the request; and
10. Such additional material and information as the responsible public entity may
reasonably request.
B. The responsible public entity may request proposals from private entities for the
acquisition, construction, improvement and/or operation of transportation facilities. The
responsible public entity shall not charge a fee to cover the costs of processing,
reviewing, and evaluating proposals received in response to such requests.
C. The responsible public entity may grant approval of the acquisition, construction,
improvement and/or operation of the transportation facility or facilities as a qualifying
transportation facility if the responsible public entity determines that it serves the public
purpose of this chapter. The responsible public entity may determine that the acquisition,
construction, improvement and/or operation of the transportation facility or facilities as a
qualifying transportation facility serves such public purpose if:
1. There is a public need for the transportation facility or facilities of the type the private
entity proposes to operate as a qualifying transportation facility;
2. The transportation facility or facilities and the proposed interconnections with existing
transportation facilities, and the operator's plans for operation of the qualifying
transportation facility or facilities, are reasonable and compatible with the state
transportation plan and with the local comprehensive plan or plans;
3. The estimated cost of the transportation facility or facilities is reasonable in relation to
similar facilities; and
4. The private entity's plans will result in the timely acquisition or construction of or
improvements to the transportation facility or facilities or their more efficient operation.
In evaluating any request, the responsible public entity may rely upon internal staff
reports prepared by personnel familiar with the operation of similar facilities or the
advice of outside advisors or consultants having relevant experience.
D. The responsible public entity may charge a reasonable fee to cover the costs of
processing, reviewing and evaluating the request submitted by a private entity pursuant to
subsection A, including without limitation, reasonable attorney's fees and fees for
financial and other necessary advisors or consultants.
E. The approval of the responsible public entity shall be subject to the private entity's
entering into a comprehensive agreement with the responsible public entity.
F. In connection with its approval of the operation of the transportation facility or
facilities as a qualifying transportation facility, the responsible public entity shall
establish a date for the acquisition of or the beginning of construction of or improvements
to the qualifying transportation facility. The responsible public entity may extend such
date from time to time.
Page 107 of 138
35
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647; 2003, c. 289.)
§ 56-561. Service contracts.
In addition to any authority otherwise conferred by law, any public entity may contract
with an operator for transportation services to be provided by a qualifying transportation
facility in exchange for such service payments and other consideration as such public
entity may deem appropriate.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-562. .
Repealed by Acts 1995, c. 647.
§ 56-563. Affected local jurisdictions.
A. Any private entity requesting approval from, or submitting a proposal to, a responsible
public entity under § 56-560 shall notify each affected local jurisdiction by furnishing a
copy of its request or proposal to each affected local jurisdiction.
B. Each affected local jurisdiction that is not a responsible public entity for the respective
qualifying transportation facility shall, within sixty days after receiving such notice,
submit any comments it may have in writing on the proposed qualifying transportation
facility to the responsible public entity and indicating whether the facility is compatible
with the local comprehensive plan.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-564. Dedication of public property.
Any public entity may dedicate any property interest that it has for public use as a
qualified transportation facility if it finds that so doing will serve the public purpose of
this chapter. In connection with such dedication, a public entity may convey any property
interest that it has, subject to the conditions imposed by general law, to the operator,
subject to the provisions of this chapter, for such consideration as such public entity may
determine. The aforementioned consideration may include, without limitation, the
agreement of the operator to operate the qualifying transportation facility.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-565. Powers and duties of the operator.
A. The operator shall have all power allowed by law generally to a private entity having
the same form of organization as the operator and shall have the power to acquire,
construct, improve or operate the qualifying transportation facility and impose user fees
and/or enter into service contracts in connection with the use thereof. No tolls or user fees
may be imposed by the operator on any free road, bridge, tunnel or overpass unless such
road, interstate highway, bridge, tunnel or overpass is reconstructed to provide for
increased capacity.
Page 108 of 138
36
B. The operator may own, lease or acquire any other right to use or operate the qualifying
transportation facility.
C. Any financing of the qualifying transportation facility may be in such amounts and
upon such terms and conditions as may be determined by the operator. Without limiting
the generality of the foregoing, the operator may issue debt, equity or other securities or
obligations, enter into sale and leaseback transactions and secure any financing with a
pledge of, security interest in, or lien on, any or all of its property, including all of its
property interests in the qualifying transportation facility.
D. Subject to applicable permit requirements, the operator shall have the authority to
cross any canal or navigable watercourse so long as the crossing does not unreasonably
interfere with then current navigation and use of the waterway.
E. In operating the qualifying transportation facility, the operator may:
1. Make classifications according to reasonable categories for assessment of user fees;
and
2. With the consent of the responsible public entity, make and enforce reasonable rules to
the same extent that the responsible public entity may make and enforce rules with
respect to a similar transportation facility.
F. The operator shall:
1. Acquire, construct, improve, maintain and/or operate the qualifying transportation
facility in a manner that meets the engineering standards of the responsible public entity
for transportation facilities operated and maintained by such responsible public entity, all
in accordance with the provisions of the comprehensive agreement;
2. Keep the qualifying transportation facility open for use by the members of the public at
all times after its initial opening upon payment of the applicable user fees, except when
exempted by § 33.1-252, and/or service payments; provided that the qualifying
transportation facility may be temporarily closed because of emergencies or, with the
consent of the responsible public entity, to protect the safety of the public or for
reasonable construction or maintenance procedures;
3. Maintain, or provide by contract for the maintenance of, the qualifying transportation
facility;
4. Cooperate with the responsible public entity in establishing any interconnection with
the qualifying transportation facility requested by the responsible public entity; and
5. Comply with the provisions of the comprehensive agreement and any service contract.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647; 2002, c. 593.)
§ 56-566. Comprehensive agreement.
Page 109 of 138
37
A. Prior to acquiring, constructing, improving, maintaining, and/or operating the
qualifying transportation facility, the operator shall enter into a comprehensive agreement
with the responsible public entity. The comprehensive agreement shall provide for:
1. Delivery of performance and payment bonds in connection with the construction of or
improvements to the qualifying transportation facility, in the forms and amounts
satisfactory to the responsible public entity;
2. Review of plans and specifications for the qualifying transportation facility by the
responsible public entity and approval by the responsible public entity if the plans and
specifications conform to standard conditions of the responsible public entity;
3. Inspection of construction of or improvements to the qualifying transportation facility
by the responsible public entity to ensure that they conform to the engineering standards
acceptable to the responsible public entity;
4. Maintenance of a policy or policies of public liability insurance (copies of which shall
be filed with the responsible public entity accompanied by proofs of coverage), self-
insurance, in form and amount satisfactory to the responsible public entity and reasonably
sufficient to insure coverage of tort liability to the public and employees and to enable the
continued operation of the qualifying transportation facility;
5. Monitoring of the maintenance practices of the operator by the responsible public
entity and the taking of such actions as the responsible public entity finds appropriate to
ensure that the qualifying transportation facility is properly maintained;
6. Reimbursement to be paid to the responsible public entity for services provided by the
responsible public entity;
7. Filing of appropriate financial statements on a periodic basis;
8. A reasonable maximum rate of return on investment for the operator; and
9. The date of termination of the operator's authority and duties under this chapter and
dedication to the appropriate public entity.
B. The comprehensive agreement shall provide for such user fees as may be established
from time to time by agreement of the parties. Any user fees shall be set at a level that,
taking into account any service payments, allows the operator the rate of return on
investment specified in the comprehensive agreement. A copy of any service contract
shall be filed with the responsible public entity. A schedule of the current user fees shall
be made available by the operator to any member of the public on request. In negotiating
user fees under this section, the parties shall establish fees that are the same for persons
using the facility under like conditions and that will not materially discourage use of the
qualifying transportation facility. The execution of the comprehensive agreement or any
amendment thereto shall constitute conclusive evidence that the user fees provided for
therein comply with this chapter. User fees established in the comprehensive agreement
as a source of revenues may be in addition to, or in lieu of, service payments.
Page 110 of 138
38
C. In the comprehensive agreement, the responsible public entity may agree to make
grants or loans to the operator from time to time from amounts received from the federal
government or any agency or instrumentality thereof.
D. The comprehensive agreement shall incorporate the duties of the operator under this
chapter and may contain such other terms and conditions that the responsible public
entity determines serve the public purpose of this chapter. Without limitation, the
comprehensive agreement may contain provisions under which the responsible public
entity agrees to provide notice of default and cure rights for the benefit of the operator
and the persons specified therein as providing financing for the qualifying transportation
facility. The comprehensive agreement may contain such other lawful terms and
conditions to which the operator and the responsible public entity mutually agree,
including, without limitation, provisions regarding unavoidable delays or provisions
providing for a loan of public funds to the operator to acquire, construct, improve,
maintain and/or operate one or more qualifying transportation facilities.
E. The comprehensive agreement shall provide for the distribution of any earnings in
excess of the maximum rate of return as negotiated in the comprehensive agreement.
Without limitation, excess earnings may be distributed to the Commonwealth's
transportation trust fund, to the responsible public entity, or to the operator for debt
reduction or they may be shared with affected local jurisdictions.
F. Any changes in the terms of the comprehensive agreement, as may be agreed upon by
the parties from time to time, shall be added to the comprehensive agreement by written
amendment.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-567. Federal, state and local assistance.
The responsible public entity may take any action to obtain federal, state or local
assistance for a qualifying transportation facility that serves the public purpose of this
chapter and may enter into any contracts required to receive such federal assistance. If the
responsible public entity is a state agency, any funds received from the state or federal
government or any agency or instrumentality thereof shall be subject to appropriation by
the General Assembly. The responsible public entity may determine that it serves the
public purpose of this chapter for all or any portion of the costs of a qualifying
transportation facility to be paid, directly or indirectly, from the proceeds of a grant or
loan made by the local, state or federal government or any agency or instrumentality
thereof.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-568. Material default; remedies.
A. Except upon agreement of the operator and any other parties identified in the
comprehensive agreement, no responsible public entity shall exercise any of the remedies
provided in this section or in subsection B or C of § 56-569 unless the Commission, after
notice to the operator and the secured parties (as may appear in the operator's records)
and an opportunity for hearing, shall first issue a declaratory judgment that a material
default, as defined in § 56-557, has occurred and is continuing.
Page 111 of 138
39
B. Upon entry by the Commission of a declaratory judgment order pursuant to subsection
A above, unless such order is stayed pending appeal to the Virginia Supreme Court, the
responsible public entity may exercise any or all of the following remedies:
1. The responsible public entity may elect to take over the transportation facility or
facilities and in such case it shall succeed to all of the right, title and interest in such
transportation facility or facilities, subject to any liens on revenues previously granted by
the operator to any person providing financing therefor and the provisions of subsection
C below.
2. Any responsible public entity having the power of condemnation under state law may
exercise such power of condemnation to acquire the qualifying transportation facility or
facilities. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to limit the exercise of the power of
condemnation by any responsible public entity against a qualifying transportation facility
after the entry by the Commission of a final declaratory judgment order pursuant to
subsection A above. Any person that has provided financing for the qualifying
transportation facility, and the operator, to the extent of its capital investment, may
participate in the condemnation proceedings with the standing of a property owner.
3. The responsible public entity may terminate the comprehensive agreement and
exercise any other rights and remedies which may be available to it at law or in equity.
4. The responsible public entity may make or cause to be made any appropriate claims
under the performance and/or payment bonds required by subsection A 1 of § 56-566.
C. In the event the responsible public entity elects to take over a qualifying transportation
facility pursuant to subsection B 1 of this section, the responsible public entity shall
acquire, construct, improve, operate and maintain the transportation facility, impose user
fees for the use thereof and comply with any service contracts as if it were the operator.
Any revenues that are subject to a lien shall be collected for the benefit of, and paid to,
secured parties, as their interests may appear, to the extent necessary to satisfy the
operator's obligations to secured parties, including the maintenance of reserves and such
liens shall be correspondingly reduced and, when paid off, released. Before any payments
to, or for the benefit of, secured parties, the responsible public entity may use revenues to
pay current operation and maintenance costs of the transportation facility or facilities,
including compensation to the responsible public entity for its services in operating and
maintaining the qualifying transportation facility. Remaining revenues, if any, after all
payments for operation and maintenance of the transportation facility or facilities, and to,
or for the benefit of, secured parties, have been made, shall be paid to the operator,
subject to the negotiated maximum rate of return. The right to receive such payment, if
any, shall be considered just compensation for the transportation facility or facilities. The
full faith and credit of the responsible public entity shall not be pledged to secure any
financing of the operator by the election to take over the qualifying transportation facility.
Assumption of operation of the qualifying transportation facility shall not obligate the
responsible public entity to pay any obligation of the operator from sources other than
revenues.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
Page 112 of 138
40
§ 56-569. Condemnation.
A. At the request of the operator, the responsible public entity may exercise any power of
condemnation that it has under law for the purpose of acquiring any lands or estates or
interests therein to the extent that the responsible public entity finds that such action
serves the public purpose of this chapter. Any amounts to be paid in any such
condemnation proceeding shall be paid by the operator.
B. Except as provided in subsection A of this section, until the Commission has entered a
final declaratory judgment order under subsection A of § 56-568, the power of
condemnation may not be exercised against a qualifying transportation facility.
C. After the entry of such final order by the Commission, any responsible public entity
having the power of condemnation under law may exercise such power of condemnation
as provided in subsection B 2 of § 56-568 in lieu of, or at any time after taking over the
transportation facility pursuant to subsection B 1 of § 56-568.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-570. Utility crossings.
The operator and each public service company, public utility, railroad, and cable
television provider, whose facilities are to be crossed or affected shall cooperate fully
with the other in planning and arranging the manner of the crossing or relocation of the
facilities. Any such entity possessing the power of condemnation is hereby expressly
granted such powers in connection with the moving or relocation of facilities to be
crossed by the qualifying transportation facility or that must be relocated to the extent
that such moving or relocation is made necessary or desirable by construction of or
improvements to the qualifying transportation facility, which shall be construed to
include construction of or improvements to temporary facilities for the purpose of
providing service during the period of construction or improvement. Any amount to be
paid for such crossing, construction, moving or relocating of facilities shall be paid for by
the operator. Should the operator and any such public service company, public utility,
railroad, and cable television provider not be able to agree upon a plan for the crossing or
relocation, the Commission may determine the manner in which the crossing or
relocation is to be accomplished and any damages due arising out of the crossing or
relocation. The Commission may employ expert engineers who shall examine the
location and plans for such crossing or relocation, hear any objections and consider
modifications, and make a recommendation to the Commission. In such a case, the cost
of the experts is to be borne by the operator.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-571. Police powers; violations of law.
A. All police officers of the Commonwealth and of each affected local jurisdiction, shall
have the same powers and jurisdiction within the limits of such qualifying transportation
facility as they have in their respective areas of jurisdiction and such police officers shall
have access to the qualifying transportation facility at any time for the purpose of
exercising such powers and jurisdiction. This authority does not extend to the private
Page 113 of 138
41
offices, buildings, garages and other improvements of the operator to any greater degree
than the police power extends to any other private buildings and improvements.
B. To the extent the transportation facility is a road, bridge, tunnel, overpass or similar
transportation facility for motor vehicles, the traffic and motor vehicle laws of the
Commonwealth or, if applicable, any local jurisdiction shall be the same as those
applying to conduct on similar transportation facilities in the Commonwealth or such
local jurisdiction. Punishment for offenses shall be as prescribed by law for conduct
occurring on similar transportation facilities in the Commonwealth or such local
jurisdiction.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-572. Dedication of assets.
The responsible public entity shall terminate the operator's authority and duties under this
chapter on the date set forth in the comprehensive agreement. Upon termination, the
authority and duties of the operator under this chapter shall cease, and the qualifying
transportation facility shall be dedicated to the responsible public entity or, if the
qualifying transportation facility was initially dedicated by an affected local jurisdiction,
to such affected local jurisdiction for public use.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-573. Sovereign immunity.
Nothing in this chapter shall be construed as or deemed a waiver of the sovereign
immunity of the Commonwealth, any responsible public entity or any affected local
jurisdiction or any officer or employee thereof with respect to the participation in, or
approval of all or any part of the qualifying transportation facility or its operation,
including but not limited to interconnection of the qualifying transportation facility with
any other transportation facility. Counties, cities and towns in which a qualifying
transportation facility is located shall possess sovereign immunity with respect to its
construction and operation.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-573.1. Procurement.
The Virginia Public Procurement Act (§ 2.2-4300 et seq.) shall not apply to this chapter;
however, a responsible public entity may enter into a comprehensive agreement only in
accordance with procedures adopted by it as follows:
1. A responsible public entity may enter into a comprehensive agreement in accordance
with procedures adopted by it that are consistent with procurement through "competitive
sealed bidding" as defined in § 2.2-4301 and subsection B of § 2.2-4310.
2. A responsible public entity may enter into a comprehensive agreement in accordance
with procedures adopted by it that are consistent with the procurement of "other than
professional services" through competitive negotiation as defined in § 2.2-4301 and
subsection B of § 2.2-4310. Such responsible public entity shall not be required to select
the proposal with the lowest price offer, but may consider price as one factor in
Page 114 of 138
42
evaluating the proposals received. A responsible public entity shall proceed in accordance
with the procedures adopted by it pursuant to subdivision 1 unless it determines that
proceeding in accordance with the procedures adopted by it pursuant to this subdivision
is likely to be advantageous to the responsible public entity and the public, based on (i)
the probable scope, complexity, or urgency of a project or (ii) risk sharing, added value,
an increase in funding, or economic benefit from the project that would not otherwise be
available. When the responsible public entity determines to proceed according to the
procedures adopted by it pursuant to this subdivision, it shall state the reasons for its
determination in writing. If a state agency is the responsible public entity, the approval of
the Secretary of Transportation shall be required before the comprehensive agreement is
signed.
3. Comprehensive agreements for maintenance or asset management services for a
transportation facility that is a highway, bridge, tunnel or overpass, and any amendment
or change order thereto that increases the highway lane-miles receiving services under
such an agreement shall be procured in accordance with procedures that are consistent
with procurement through "competitive sealed bidding" as defined in § 2.2-4301 and
subsection B of § 2.2-4310. Furthermore, such contracts shall be of a size and scope to
encourage maximum competition and participation by agency prequalified contractors
and otherwise qualified contractors.
4. The provisions of subdivision 3 shall not apply to maintenance or asset management
services agreed to as part of the initial provisions of any comprehensive agreement
entered into for the original construction, reconstruction, or improvement of any highway
pursuant to Chapter 22 (§ 56-556 et seq.) of Title 56.
5. Once a comprehensive agreement has been entered into, and the process of bargaining
of all phases or aspects of the comprehensive agreement is complete, a responsible public
entity shall make available, upon request, procurement records in accordance with § 2.2-
4342.
6. Nothing in this section shall require that professional services be procured by any
method other than competitive negotiation in accordance with the Virginia Public
Procurement Act (§ 2.2-4300 et seq.).
(1995, c. 647; 2002, cc. 570, 593; 2003, c. 968.)
§ 56-573.2. Jurisdiction.
The Commission shall have exclusive jurisdiction to adjudicate all matters specifically
committed to its jurisdiction by this chapter.
(1995, c. 647.)
§ 56-574. Preservation of the Virginia Highway Corporation Act of 1988.
Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to repeal or change in any manner the Virginia
Highway Corporation Act of 1988, as amended (§ 56-535 et seq.). Nothing in the
Page 115 of 138
43
Virginia Highway Corporation Act of 1988, as amended, shall apply to qualifying
transportation facilities undertaken pursuant to the authority of this chapter.
(1994, c. 855; 1995, c. 647.)
Page 116 of 138
44
Appendix B
The Public-Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure Act of 2002, as amended
Code of Virginia, 1950, As Amended
§ 56-575.1. Definitions.
As used in this chapter, unless the context requires a different meaning:
"Affected local jurisdiction" means any county, city or town in which all or a portion of a
qualifying project is located.
"Commission" means the State Corporation Commission.
"Comprehensive agreement" means the comprehensive agreement between the private
entity and the responsible public entity required by § 56-575.9.
"Develop" or "development" means to plan, design, develop, finance, lease, acquire,
install, construct, or expand.
"Interim agreement" means an agreement between a private entity and a responsible
public entity that provides for phasing of the development or operation, or both, of a
qualifying project. Such phases may include, but are not limited to, design, planning,
engineering, environmental analysis and mitigation, financial and revenue analysis, or
any other phase of the project that constitutes activity on any part of the qualifying
project.
"Lease payment" means any form of payment, including a land lease, by a public entity to
the private entity for the use of a qualifying project.
"Material default" means any default by the private entity in the performance of its duties
under subsection E of § 56-575.8 that jeopardizes adequate service to the public from a
qualifying project.
"Operate" means to finance, maintain, improve, equip, modify, repair, or operate.
"Private entity" means any natural person, corporation, general partnership, limited
liability company, limited partnership, joint venture, business trust, public benefit
corporation, non-profit entity, or other business entity.
"Public entity" means the Commonwealth and any agency or authority thereof, any
county, city or town and any other political subdivision of the Commonwealth, any
public body politic and corporate, or any regional entity that serves a public purpose.
"Qualifying project" means (i) any education facility, including, but not limited to a
school building, any functionally related and subordinate facility and land to a school
building (including any stadium or other facility primarily used for school events), and
any depreciable property provided for use in a school facility that is operated as part of
the public school system or as an institution of higher education; (ii) any building or
facility that meets a public purpose and is developed or operated by or for any public
entity; (iii) any improvements, together with equipment, necessary to enhance public
safety and security of buildings to be principally used by a public entity; (iv) utility and
telecommunications and other communications infrastructure; (v) a recreational facility;
(vi) technology infrastructure, including, but not limited to, telecommunications,
Page 117 of 138
45
automated data processing, word processing and management information systems, and
related information, equipment, goods and services; or (vii) any improvements necessary
or desirable to any unimproved locally- or state-owned real estate.
"Responsible public entity" means a public entity that has the power to develop or
operate the applicable qualifying project.
"Revenues" means all revenues, income, earnings, user fees, lease payments, or other
service payments arising out of or in connection with supporting the development or
operation of a qualifying project, including without limitation, money received as grants
or otherwise from the United States of America, from any public entity, or from any
agency or instrumentality of the foregoing in aid of such facility.
"Service contract" means a contract entered into between a public entity and the private
entity pursuant to § 56-575.5.
"Service payments" means payments to the private entity of a qualifying project pursuant
to a service contract.
"State" means the Commonwealth of Virginia.
"User fees" mean the rates, fees or other charges imposed by the private entity of a
qualifying project for use of all or a portion of such qualifying project pursuant to the
comprehensive agreement pursuant to § 56-575.9.
(2002, c. 571; 2003, c. 1034; 2005, cc. 618, 865.)
§ 56-575.2. Declaration of public purpose.
A. The General Assembly finds that:
1. There is a public need for timely acquisition, design, construction, improvement,
renovation, expansion, equipping, maintenance, operation, implementation, or installation
of education facilities, technology infrastructure and other public infrastructure and
government facilities within the Commonwealth that serve a public need and purpose;
2. Such public need may not be wholly satisfied by existing methods of procurement in
which qualifying projects are acquired, designed, constructed, improved, renovated,
expanded, equipped, maintained, operated, implemented, or installed;
3. There are inadequate resources to develop new education facilities, technology
infrastructure and other public infrastructure and government facilities for the benefit of
citizens of the Commonwealth, and there is demonstrated evidence that public-private
partnerships can meet these needs by improving the schedule for delivery, lowering the
cost, and providing other benefits to the public;
4. Financial incentives exist under state and federal tax provisions that promote public
entities to enter into partnerships with private entities to develop qualifying projects;
5. Authorizing private entities to develop or operate one or more qualifying projects may
result in the availability of such projects to the public in a more timely or less costly
fashion, thereby serving the public safety, benefit, and welfare.
B. An action under § 56-575.4 shall serve the public purpose of this chapter if such action
facilitates the timely development or operation of qualifying projects.
Page 118 of 138
46
C. It is the intent of this chapter, among other things, to encourage investment in the
Commonwealth by private entities and facilitate the bond financing provisions of the
Economic Growth and Tax Relief Reconciliation Act of 2001 or other similar financing
mechanisms, private capital and other funding sources that support the development or
operation of qualifying projects, to the end that financing for qualifying projects be
expanded and accelerated to improve and add to the convenience of the public, and such
that public and private entities may have the greatest possible flexibility in contracting
with each other for the provision of the public services that are the subject of this chapter.
D. This chapter shall be liberally construed in conformity with the purposes hereof.
(2002, c. 571; 2003, c. 1034; 2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.3. Prerequisite for operation of a qualifying project.
A. Any private entity seeking authorization under this chapter to develop or operate a
qualifying project shall first obtain approval of the responsible public entity under § 56-
575.4. Such private entity may initiate the approval process by requesting approval
pursuant to subsection A of § 56-575.4 or the responsible public entity may request
proposals or invite bids pursuant to subsection B of § 56-575.4.
B. Any facility, building, infrastructure or improvement included in a proposal as a part
of a qualifying project shall be identified specifically or conceptually.
C. Upon receipt by the responsible public entity of a proposal submitted by a private
entity initiating the approval process pursuant to subsection A of § 56-575.4, the
responsible public entity shall determine whether to accept such proposal for
consideration in accordance with § 56-575.16. If the responsible public entity determines
not to accept for consideration the proposal submitted by the private entity pursuant to
subsection A of § 56-575.4, it shall return the proposal, together with all fees and
accompanying documentation, to the private entity.
D. The responsible public entity may reject any proposal initiated by a private entity
pursuant to subsection A of § 56-575.4 at any time.
(2002, c. 571; 2003, cc. 292, 1034; 2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.3:1. Adoption of guidelines by responsible public entities.
A. Any responsible public entity requesting or considering a proposal for a qualifying
facility shall adopt and make publicly available guidelines that are sufficient to enable the
responsible public entity to comply with this chapter. Such guidelines shall guide the
selection of projects under the purview of the responsible public entity and include, but
not be limited to, reasonable criteria for choosing among competitive proposals and
timelines for selecting proposals and negotiating an interim or comprehensive agreement.
B. Such guidelines shall permit accelerated selection, review and documentation
timelines for proposals involving a qualifying facility that the responsible public entity
deems a priority.
(2005, c. 865.)
Page 119 of 138
47
§ 56-575.4. Approval of qualifying projects by the responsible public entity.
A. A private entity may request approval of a qualifying project by the responsible public
entity. Any such request shall be accompanied by the following material and information
unless waived by the responsible public entity:
1. A topographic map (1:2,000 or other appropriate scale) indicating the location of the
qualifying project;
2. A description of the qualifying project, including the conceptual design of such facility
or facilities or a conceptual plan for the provision of services or technology infrastructure,
and a schedule for the initiation of and completion of the qualifying project to include the
proposed major responsibilities and timeline for activities to be performed by both the
public and private entity;
3. A statement setting forth the method by which the private entity proposes to secure
necessary property interests required for the qualifying project;
4. Information relating to the current plans for development of facilities or technology
infrastructure to be used by a public entity that are similar to the qualifying project being
proposed by the private entity, if any, of each affected local jurisdiction;
5. A list of all permits and approvals required for the qualifying project from local, state,
or federal agencies and a projected schedule for obtaining such permits and approvals;
6. A list of public utility facilities, if any, that will be crossed by the qualifying project
and a statement of the plans of the private entity to accommodate such crossings;
7. A statement setting forth the private entity's general plans for financing the qualifying
project including the sources of the private entity's funds and identification of any
dedicated revenue source or proposed debt or equity investment on the behalf of the
private entity;
8. The names and addresses of the persons who may be contacted for further information
concerning the request;
9. User fees, lease payments, and other service payments over the term of the interim or
comprehensive agreement pursuant to § 56-575.9 or 56-575.9:1 and the methodology and
circumstances for changes to such user fees, lease payments, and other service payments
over time; and
10. Such additional material and information as the responsible public entity may
reasonably request.
B. The responsible public entity may request proposals or invite bids from private entities
for the development or operation of qualifying projects.
C. The responsible public entity may grant approval of the development or operation of
the education facility, technology infrastructure or other public infrastructure or
government facility needed by a public entity as a qualifying project, or the design or
equipping of a qualifying project so developed or operated, if the responsible public
entity determines that the project serves the public purpose of this chapter. The
responsible public entity may determine that the development or operation of the
qualifying project as a qualifying project serves such public purpose if:
Page 120 of 138
48
1. There is a public need for or benefit derived from the qualifying project of the type the
private entity proposes as a qualifying project;
2. The estimated cost of the qualifying project is reasonable in relation to similar
facilities; and
3. The private entity's plans will result in the timely development or operation of the
qualifying project.
In evaluating any request, the responsible public entity may rely upon internal staff
reports prepared by personnel familiar with the operation of similar facilities or the
advice of outside advisors or consultants having relevant experience.
D. The responsible public entity may charge a reasonable fee to cover the costs of
processing, reviewing and evaluating the request, including without limitation, reasonable
attorney's fees and fees for financial, technical, and other necessary advisors or
consultants.
E. The approval of the responsible public entity shall be subject to the private entity's
entering into an interim or comprehensive agreement pursuant to § 56-575.9 with the
responsible public entity.
F. In connection with its approval of the qualifying project, the responsible public entity
shall establish a date for the commencement of activities related to the qualifying project.
The responsible public entity may extend such date from time to time.
G. The responsible public entity shall take appropriate action to protect confidential and
proprietary information provided by the private entity pursuant to an agreement under
subdivision 11 of § 2.2-3705.6.
H. Nothing in this chapter or in an interim or comprehensive agreement entered into
pursuant to this chapter shall be deemed to enlarge, diminish or affect the authority, if
any, otherwise possessed by the responsible public entity to take action that would impact
the debt capacity of the Commonwealth.
(2002, c. 571; 2003, c. 1034; 2004, c. 690; 2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.5. Service contracts.
In addition to any authority otherwise conferred by law, any public entity may contract
with a private entity for the delivery of services to be provided as part of a qualifying
project in exchange for such service payments and other consideration as such public
entity may deem appropriate.
(2002, c. 571; 2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.6. Affected local jurisdictions.
A. Any private entity requesting approval from, or submitting a proposal to, a responsible
public entity under § 56-575.4 shall notify each affected local jurisdiction by furnishing a
copy of its request or proposal to each affected local jurisdiction.
B. Each affected local jurisdiction that is not a responsible public entity for the respective
qualifying project shall, within sixty days after receiving such notice, submit any
comments it may have in writing on the proposed qualifying project to the responsible
Page 121 of 138
49
public entity and indicate whether the facility is compatible with the local comprehensive
plan, local infrastructure development plans, the capital improvements budget, or other
government spending plan. Such comments shall be given consideration by the
responsible public entity prior to entering a comprehensive agreement pursuant to § 56-
575.9 with a private entity.
(2002, c. 571.)
§ 56-575.7. Dedication of public property.
Any public entity may dedicate any property interest, including land, improvements, and
tangible personal property, that it has for public use in a qualifying project if it finds that
so doing will serve the public purpose of this chapter by minimizing the cost of a
qualifying project to the public entity or reducing the delivery time of a qualifying
project. In connection with such dedication, a public entity may convey any property
interest that it has, subject to the conditions imposed by general law governing such
conveyances, to the private entity subject to the provisions of this chapter, for such
consideration as such public entity may determine. The aforementioned consideration
may include, without limitation, the agreement of the private entity to develop or operate
the qualifying project. The property interests that the public entity may convey to the
private entity in connection with a dedication under this section may include licenses,
franchises, easements, or any other right or interest the public entity deems appropriate.
(2002, c. 571; 2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.8. Powers and duties of the private entity.
A. The private entity shall have all power allowed by law generally to a private entity
having the same form of organization as the private entity and shall have the power to
develop or operate the qualifying project and collect lease payments, impose user fees or
enter into service contracts in connection with the use thereof.
B. The private entity may own, lease or acquire any other right to use or operate the
qualifying project.
C. Any financing of the qualifying project may be in such amounts and upon such terms
and conditions as may be determined by the private entity. Without limiting the
generality of the foregoing, the private entity may issue debt, equity or other securities or
obligations, enter into sale and leaseback transactions and secure any financing with a
pledge of, security interest in, or lien on, any or all of its property, including all of its
property interests in the qualifying project.
D. In operating the qualifying project, the private entity may:
1. Make classifications according to reasonable categories for assessment of user fees;
and
2. With the consent of the responsible public entity, make and enforce reasonable rules to
the same extent that the responsible public entity may make and enforce rules with
respect to similar facilities.
Page 122 of 138
50
E. The private entity shall:
1. Develop or operate the qualifying project in a manner that is acceptable to the
responsible public entity, all in accordance with the provisions of the interim or
comprehensive agreement pursuant to § 56-575.9 or 56-575.9:1;
2. Keep the qualifying project open for use by the members of the public at all times, or
as appropriate based upon the use of the facility, after its initial opening upon payment of
the applicable user fees, lease payments, or service payments; provided that the
qualifying project may be temporarily closed because of emergencies or, with the consent
of the responsible public entity, to protect the safety of the public or for reasonable
construction or maintenance activities. In the event that a qualifying project is technology
infrastructure, access may be limited as determined by the conditions of the interim or
comprehensive agreement;
3. Maintain, or provide by contract for the maintenance or upgrade of the qualifying
project, if required by the interim or comprehensive agreement;
4. Cooperate with the responsible public entity in making best efforts to establish any
interconnection with the qualifying project requested by the responsible public entity; and
5. Comply with the provisions of the interim or comprehensive agreement and any lease
or service contract.
F. Nothing shall prohibit an private entity of a qualifying project from providing
additional services for the qualifying project to public or private entities other than the
responsible public entity so long as the provision of additional service does not impair the
private entity's ability to meet its commitments to the responsible public entity pursuant
to the interim or comprehensive agreement as provided for in § 56-575.9 or 56-575.9:1.
(2002, c. 571; 2003, c. 1034; 2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.9. Comprehensive agreement.
A. Prior to developing or operating the qualifying project, the private entity shall enter
into a comprehensive agreement with the responsible public entity. The comprehensive
agreement shall provide for:
1. Delivery of maintenance, performance and payment bonds, letters of credit in
connection with the development or operation of the qualifying project, in the forms and
amounts satisfactory to the responsible public entity and in compliance with § 2.2-4337
for those components of the qualifying project that involve construction;
2. Review of plans and specifications for the qualifying project by the responsible public
entity and approval by the responsible public entity if the plans and specifications
conform to standards acceptable to the responsible public entity. This shall not be
construed as requiring the private entity to complete design of a qualifying project prior
to the execution of a comprehensive agreement;
3. Inspection of the qualifying project by the responsible public entity to ensure that the
private entity's activities are acceptable to the responsible public entity in accordance
with the provisions of the comprehensive agreement;
Page 123 of 138
51
4. Maintenance of a policy or policies of public liability insurance (copies of which shall
be filed with the responsible public entity accompanied by proofs of coverage) or self-
insurance, each in form and amount satisfactory to the responsible public entity and
reasonably sufficient to insure coverage of tort liability to the public and employees and
to enable the continued operation of the qualifying project;
5. Monitoring of the practices of the private entity by the responsible public entity to
ensure that the qualifying project is properly maintained;
6. Reimbursement to be paid to the responsible public entity for services provided by the
responsible public entity;
7. Filing of appropriate financial statements on a periodic basis; and
8. Policies and procedures governing the rights and responsibilities of the responsible
public entity and the private entity in the event the comprehensive agreement is
terminated or there is a material default by the private entity. Such policies and guidelines
shall include conditions governing assumption of the duties and responsibilities of the
private entity by the responsible public entity and the transfer or purchase of property or
other interests of the private entity by the responsible public entity.
B. The comprehensive agreement shall provide for such user fees, lease payments, or
service payments as may be established from time to time by agreement of the parties. A
copy of any service contract shall be filed with the responsible public entity. In
negotiating user fees under this section, the parties shall establish payments or fees that
are the same for persons using the facility under like conditions and that will not
materially discourage use of the qualifying project. The execution of the comprehensive
agreement or any amendment thereto shall constitute conclusive evidence that the user
fees, lease payments, or service payments provided for comply with this chapter. User
fees or lease payments established in the comprehensive agreement as a source of
revenues may be in addition to, or in lieu of, service payments.
C. In the comprehensive agreement, the responsible public entity may agree to make
grants or loans to the private entity from time to time from amounts received from the
federal, state, or local government or any agency or instrumentality thereof.
D. The comprehensive agreement shall incorporate the duties of the private entity under
this chapter and may contain such other terms and conditions that the responsible public
entity determines serve the public purpose of this chapter. Without limitation, the
comprehensive agreement may contain provisions under which the responsible public
entity agrees to provide notice of default and cure rights for the benefit of the private
entity and the persons specified therein as providing financing for the qualifying project.
The comprehensive agreement may contain such other lawful terms and conditions to
which the private entity and the responsible public entity mutually agree, including,
without limitation, provisions regarding unavoidable delays or provisions providing for a
loan of public funds to the private entity to develop or operate one or more qualifying
projects. The comprehensive agreement may also contain provisions where the authority
and duties of the private entity under this chapter shall cease, and the qualifying project is
dedicated to the responsible public entity or, if the qualifying project was initially
dedicated by an affected local jurisdiction, to such affected local jurisdiction for public
use.
Page 124 of 138
52
E. Any changes in the terms of the comprehensive agreement, as may be agreed upon by
the parties from time to time, shall be added to the comprehensive agreement by written
amendment.
F. When a responsible public entity that is not an agency or authority of the
Commonwealth enters into a comprehensive agreement pursuant to this chapter, it shall
within 30 days thereafter submit a copy of the comprehensive agreement to the Auditor
of Public Accounts.
G. The comprehensive agreement may provide for the development or operation of
phases or segments of the qualifying project.
(2002, c. 571; 2003, c. 1034; 2004, c. 986; 2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.9:1. Interim agreement.
Prior to or in connection with the negotiation of the comprehensive agreement, the
responsible public entity may enter into an interim agreement with the private entity
proposing the development or operation of the qualifying project. Such interim agreement
may (i) permit the private entity to commence activities for which it may be compensated
relating to the proposed qualifying project, including, but not limited to, project planning
and development, design and engineering, environmental analysis and mitigation, survey,
and ascertaining the availability of financing for the proposed facility or facilities; (ii)
establish the process and timing of the negotiation of the comprehensive agreement; and
(iii) contain any other provisions related to any aspect of the development or operation of
a qualifying project that the parties may deem appropriate.
(2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.10. Federal, state and local assistance.
A. Any financing of a qualifying facility may be in such amounts and upon such terms
and conditions as may be determined by the parties to the interim or comprehensive
agreement. Without limiting the generality of the terms and conditions of the financing,
the private entity and the responsible public entity may propose to utilize any and all
funding resources that may be available to them and may, to the fullest extent permitted
by applicable law, issue debt, equity, or other securities or obligations, enter into leases,
access any designated trust funds, borrow or accept grants from any state infrastructure
bank, and secure any financing with a pledge of, security interest in, or lien on, any or all
of its property, including all of its property interests in the qualifying facility.
B. The responsible public entity may take any action to obtain federal, state, or local
assistance for a qualifying project that serves the public purpose of this chapter and may
enter into any contracts required to receive such assistance. If the responsible public
entity is a state agency, any funds received from the state or federal government or any
agency or instrumentality thereof shall be subject to appropriation by the General
Assembly. The responsible public entity may determine that it serves the public purpose
of this chapter for all or any portion of the costs of a qualifying project to be paid,
directly or indirectly, from the proceeds of a grant or loan made by the local, state, or
federal government or any agency or instrumentality thereof.
(2002, c. 571; 2005, c. 865.)
Page 125 of 138
53
§ 56-575.11. Material default; remedies.
A. In the event of a material default by the private entity, the responsible public entity
may elect to assume the responsibilities and duties of the private entity of the qualifying
project, and in such case, it shall succeed to all of the right, title and interest in such
qualifying project, subject to any liens on revenues previously granted by the private
entity to any person providing financing thereof.
B. Any responsible public entity having the power of condemnation under state law may
exercise such power of condemnation to acquire the qualifying project in the event of a
material default by the private entity. Any person who has provided financing for the
qualifying project, and the private entity, to the extent of its capital investment, may
participate in the condemnation proceedings with the standing of a property owner.
C. The responsible public entity may terminate, with cause, the interim or comprehensive
agreement and exercise any other rights and remedies that may be available to it at law or
in equity.
D. The responsible public entity may make or cause to be made any appropriate claims
under the maintenance, performance, or payment bonds; or lines of credit required by
subsection A 1 of § 56-575.9.
E. In the event the responsible public entity elects to take over a qualifying project
pursuant to subsection A, the responsible public entity may develop or operate the
qualifying project, impose user fees, impose and collect lease payments for the use
thereof and comply with any service contracts as if it were the private entity. Any
revenues that are subject to a lien shall be collected for the benefit of and paid to secured
parties, as their interests may appear, to the extent necessary to satisfy the private entity's
obligations to secured parties, including the maintenance of reserves. Such liens shall be
correspondingly reduced and, when paid off, released. Before any payments to, or for the
benefit of, secured parties, the responsible public entity may use revenues to pay current
operation and maintenance costs of the qualifying project, including compensation to the
responsible public entity for its services in operating and maintaining the qualifying
project. The right to receive such payment, if any, shall be considered just compensation
for the qualifying project. The full faith and credit of the responsible public entity shall
not be pledged to secure any financing of the private entity by the election to take over
the qualifying project. Assumption of operation of the qualifying project shall not
obligate the responsible public entity to pay any obligation of the private entity from
sources other than revenues.
(2002, c. 571; 2003, c. 1034; 2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.12. Condemnation.
At the request of the private entity, the responsible public entity may exercise any power
of condemnation that it has under law for the purpose of acquiring any lands or estates or
interests therein to the extent that the responsible public entity finds that such action
serves the public purpose of this chapter. Any amounts to be paid in any such
condemnation proceeding shall be paid by the private entity.
(2002, c. 571; 2005, c. 865.)
Page 126 of 138
54
§ 56-575.13. Utility crossing.
The private entity and each public service company, public utility, railroad, and cable
television provider, whose facilities are to be crossed or affected shall cooperate fully
with the other entity in planning and arranging the manner of the crossing or relocation of
the facilities. Any such entity possessing the power of condemnation is hereby expressly
granted such powers in connection with the moving or relocation of facilities to be
crossed by the qualifying project or that must be relocated to the extent that such moving
or relocation is made necessary or desirable by construction of, renovation to, or
improvements to the qualifying project, which shall be construed to include construction
of, renovation to, or improvements to temporary facilities for the purpose of providing
service during the period of construction or improvement. Any amount to be paid for
such crossing, construction, moving or relocating of facilities shall be paid for by the
private entity. Should the private entity and any such public service company, public
utility, railroad, and cable television provider not be able to agree upon a plan for the
crossing or relocation, the Commission may determine the manner in which the crossing
or relocation is to be accomplished and any damages due arising out of the crossing or
relocation. The Commission may employ expert engineers who shall examine the
location and plans for such crossing or relocation, hear any objections and consider
modifications, and make a recommendation to the Commission. In such a case, the cost
of the experts is to be borne by the private entity. Such determination shall be made by
the Commission within ninety days of notification by the private entity that the qualifying
project will cross utilities subject to the Commission's jurisdiction.
(2002, c. 571; 2005, c. 865.)
§ 56-575.14. Police powers; violations of law.
All police officers of the Commonwealth and of each affected local jurisdiction shall
have the same powers and jurisdiction within the limits of such qualifying project as they
have in their respective areas of jurisdiction and such police officers shall have access to
the qualifying project at any time for the purpose of exercising such powers and
jurisdiction.
(2002, c. 571.)
§ 56-575.15. Sovereign immunity.
Nothing in this chapter shall be construed as or deemed a waiver of the sovereign
immunity of the Commonwealth, any responsible public entity or any affected local
jurisdiction or any officer or employee thereof with respect to the participation in, or
approval of all or any part of the qualifying project or its operation, including but not
limited to interconnection of the qualifying project with any other infrastructure or
project. Counties, cities and towns in which a qualifying project is located shall possess
sovereign immunity with respect to its design, construction, and operation.
(2002, c. 571.)
§ 56-575.16. Procurement.
The Virginia Public Procurement Act (§ 2.2-4300 et seq.) and any interpretations,
regulations, or guidelines of the Division of Engineering and Buildings of the Department
of General Services or the Virginia Information Technologies Agency, including the
Page 127 of 138
55
Capital Outlay Manual and those interpretations, regulations or guidelines developed
pursuant to §§ 2.2-1131, 2.2-1132, 2.2-1133, 2.2-1149, and 2.2-1502, except those
developed by the Division or the Virginia Information Technologies Agency in
accordance with this chapter when the Commonwealth is the responsible public entity,
shall not apply to this chapter. However, a responsible public entity may enter into a
comprehensive agreement only in accordance with guidelines adopted by it as follows:
1. A responsible public entity may enter into a comprehensive agreement in accordance
with guidelines adopted by it that are consistent with procurement through competitive
sealed bidding as defined in § 2.2-4301 and subsection B of § 2.2-4310.
2. A responsible public entity may enter into a comprehensive agreement in accordance
with guidelines adopted by it that are consistent with the procurement of "other than
professional services" through competitive negotiation as defined in § 2.2-4301 and
subsection B of § 2.2-4310. Such responsible public entity shall not be required to select
the proposal with the lowest price offer, but may consider price as one factor in
evaluating the proposals received. Other factors that may be considered include (i) the
proposed cost of the qualifying facility; (ii) the general reputation, industry experience,
and financial capacity of the private entity; (iii) the proposed design of the qualifying
project; (iv) the eligibility of the facility for accelerated selection, review, and
documentation timelines under the responsible public entity's guidelines; (v) local citizen
and government comments; (vi) benefits to the public; (vii) the private entity's
compliance with a minority business enterprise participation plan or good faith effort to
comply with the goals of such plan; (viii) the private entity's plans to employ local
contractors and residents; and (ix) other criteria that the responsible public entity deems
appropriate.
A responsible public entity shall proceed in accordance with the guidelines adopted by it
pursuant to subdivision 1 unless it determines that proceeding in accordance with the
guidelines adopted by it pursuant to this subdivision is likely to be advantageous to the
responsible public entity and the public, based on (i) the probable scope, complexity or
priority of the project; (ii) risk sharing including guaranteed cost or completion
guarantees, added value or debt or equity investments proposed by the private entity; or
(iii) an increase in funding, dedicated revenue source or other economic benefit that
would not otherwise be available. When the responsible public entity determines to
proceed according to the guidelines adopted by it pursuant to this subdivision, it shall
state the reasons for its determination in writing. If a state agency is the responsible
public entity, the approval of the responsible Governor's Secretary, or the Governor, shall
be required before the responsible public entity may enter into a comprehensive
agreement pursuant to this subdivision.
3. Nothing in this chapter shall authorize or require that a responsible public entity obtain
professional services through any process except in accordance with guidelines adopted
by it that are consistent with the procurement of "professional services" through
competitive negotiation as defined in § 2.2-4301 and subsection B of § 2.2-4310.
4. A responsible public entity shall not proceed to consider any request by a private entity
for approval of a qualifying project pursuant to subsection A of § 56-575.4 until the
responsible public entity has adopted and made publicly available guidelines that are
sufficient to enable the responsible public entity to comply with this chapter. Such
guidelines shall:
Page 128 of 138
56
a. If the responsible public entity is not an agency or authority of the Commonwealth,
require the responsible public entity to engage the services of qualified professionals,
which may include an architect, professional engineer or certified public accountant, not
employed by the responsible public entity to provide to the responsible public entity
independent analysis regarding the specifics, advantages, disadvantages, and the long-
and short-term costs of any request by a private entity for approval of a qualifying
project, unless the governing body of the responsible public entity determines that such
analysis of a request by a private entity for approval of a qualifying project shall be
performed by employees of the responsible public entity.
b. Provide for the posting and publishing of public notice of a private entity's request for
approval of a qualifying project pursuant to subsection A of § 56-575.4 and a reasonable
time period, determined by the responsible public entity to be appropriate to encourage
competition and public-private partnerships pursuant to the goals of this chapter, such
reasonable period not to be less than 45 days, during which the responsible public entity
will receive competing proposals pursuant to that subsection.
Such guidelines shall also require advertising the public notice in the Virginia Business
Opportunities publication and posting a notice on the Commonwealth's electronic
procurement website.
5. Once a comprehensive agreement has been entered into, and the process of bargaining
of all phases or aspects of the comprehensive agreement is complete, a responsible public
entity shall make available, upon request, procurement records in accordance with § 2.2-
4342.
6. A responsible public entity that is a school board or a county, city or town may enter
into an interim or comprehensive agreement under this chapter only with the approval of
the local governing body.
(2002, c. 571; 2003, cc. 292, 968, 1034; 2004, c. 986; 2005, c. 865.)
Page 129 of 138
57
APPENDIX C
Projected Procurement Timeline for PPTA/PPEA
Procurement Initiated By Unsolicited Proposal
Activity
Number
Date Activity
1 D Receipt of
Unsolicited
Proposal
2 D+45 Decide whether to
accept Unsolicited
Proposal, whether
to use competitive
negotiation, and
what conditions to
impose
3 D+75 Prepare Notice of
Unsolicited
Proposal, Receipt
of Unsolicited
Proposal, and
Post and Publish
4. D+135 Receive
Competing
Conceptual-Phase
Proposals
5 D+195 Evaluate
Conceptual-Phase
Proposals, decide
whether to
proceed. If
proceeding, select
proposers to invite
to submit, and
invite submission
of Detailed-Phase
Proposals
6 D+225 Receive Detailed-
Phase Proposals
7.6. D+270 Evaluate Detailed-
Phase Proposals,
conduct
interviews, and
select proposers
for negotiation of
Agreement
8.7 D+315 Negotiate Interim
Agreement or
Comprehensive
Agreement
9 D+350 Obtain Approval
by City Council
Page 130 of 138
APPENDIX D
Projected Procurement Timeline for PPTA/PPEA Procurement
Solicited By Request for Proposals (“RFP”)
Activity
Number
Date Activity
1 D Initiate
procurement.
Decide whether to
use competitive
negotiation and
issue RFP.
2 D+45 Receive
Conceptual-Phase
Proposals
3 D+105 Evaluate
Conceptual-Phase
Proposals and
decide whether to
proceed. Select
proposers to invite
to submit, and
invite submission
of Detailed-Phase
Proposals
4. D+135 Receive Detailed-
Phase Proposals
5 D+180 Evaluate Detailed-
Phase Proposals,
conduct
interviews, and
select proposers
for negotiation of
Agreement
6 D+225 Negotiate Interim
Agreement or
Comprehensive
Agreement
7 D+270 Obtain Approval
by City Council
Note: Considerable planning befor e Step 1 is required to determine the City's needs for
a project and to state them in an RFP.
Page 131 of 138
59
Appendix E
Potential Proposal Evaluation and Selection Criteria
A. Qualifications and Experience
Does the proposer propose a team which is qualified, led, and structured in a
manner which will clearly enable the team to complete the proposed project?
1. Experience with Similar Projects
Have members of this team previously worked together in successfully
constructing, improving or managing similar projects? Has the lead firm
managed, or any of the member firms worked on, a similar privatization project?
2. Demonstration of Ability to Perform Work
What commitments has the team made to carry out the project? Does the team
possess the necessary financial, staffing, equipment, and technical resources to
successfully complete the project? Does the team and/or member firms have
competing financial or workforce commitments that may inhibit success and
follow-through on this project?
3. Leadership Structure
Is one firm designated as lead on the project? Does the organization of the team
indicate a well thought out approach to managing the project? Is there an
agreement/document in place between members?
4. Project Manager's Experience
Is a Project Manager identified, and does this person work for the principal firm?
If not, is there a clear definition of the role and responsibility of the Project
Manager relative to the member firms? Does the Project Manager have
experience leading this type and magnitude of project?
5. Management Approach
Have the primary functions and responsibilities of the management team been
identified? Have the members of the team developed an approach to facilitate
communication among the project participants? Has the firm adequately
described its approach to communicating with and meeting the expectations of
the City?
6. Financial Condition
Is the financial information submitted on the firms sufficient to determine the
firms' capability to fulfill their obligations described in the project proposal?
7. Project Ownership
Does the proposal identify the proposed ownership arrangements for each phase
of the project and indicate assumptions on legal liabilities and responsibilities
during each phase of the project?
Page 132 of 138
60
8. Participation of Small Busi nesses and Businesses Owned by Women
and Minorities
What is the level of commitment by the proposers to use small, minority-, and
women-owned business enterprises in developing and implementing the project?
9. Competitive Bidding
To what extent have adequate and transparent procurement policies been
adopted by the proposer to maximize competitive bidding opportunities for
potential subcontractors and suppliers?
B. Project Characteristics
Does the proposed project serve a public purpose as required by the Acts? Is
the project technically feasible?
1. Project Definition
Is the project described in sufficient detail to determine the type and size of the
project and its location?
2. Proposed Project Schedule
Is the time frame for project completion clearly outlined? Is the proposed
schedule reasonable given the scope and complexity of the project? Does the
proposal contain adequate assurances that the project will be completed and will
be completed on time?
3. Operation
Does the proposer present a reasonable statement setting forth plans for
operation of the facility?
4. Technology
Is the proposal based on proven technology? What is the degree of technical
innovation associated with the proposal? Will the knowledge or technology
gained from the project benefit other areas of the state or nation, as well as the
City? Does the technology proposed maximize interoperability with relevant local
and statewide technology? Can the proposed project upgrade relevant local
technology?
5. Conforms to Laws, Regulations, and Standards
Is the proposed project consistent with applicable state and federal statutes and
regulations, or reasonably anticipated modifications of state or federal statutes,
regulations or standards? Does the proposed design meet appropriate state and
federal standards?
6. Federal Permits
Is the project outside the purview of federal oversight, or will it require some level
of federal involvement or permitting?
Page 133 of 138
61
7. Meets/Exceeds Environmental Standards
Is the proposed project consistent with applicable state and federal
environmental statutes and regulations? Does the proposed design meet
applicable state environmental standards? Does the proposal adequately
address or improve air quality conformity?
8. State and Local Permits
Does the proposal list the required permits and a schedule to obtain them? Are
there negative impacts known for the project? If so, is there a mitigation plan
identified? Are alternatives to standards or regulations needed to avoid those
impacts that cannot be mitigated?
9. Property Acquisition
Does the proposal set forth the method by which the private operator proposes to
secure all property interests required for the facility? Does the statement include:
the names and addresses, if known, of the current owners of the property needed
for the facility, the nature of the property to be acquired, and a listing of any
property that the City is expected to be requested to condemn?
10. Maintenance
Does the proposer have a plan to maintain the facility in conformance with City
standards? Does the proposal clearly define assumptions or responsibilities
during the operational phase?
C. Project Financing
Has the proposer provided a financial plan and financial guarantees which will
allow for access to the necessary capital to finance the facility?
1. Financing
Did the proposer demonstrate evidence of its ability and commitment to provide
sufficient equity in the project as well as the ability to obtain the other necessary
financing?
2. Financial Plan
Does the financial plan demonstrate a reasonable basis for funding project
development and operations? Are the assumptions on which the plan is based
well defined and reasonable in nature? Are the plan's risk factors identified and
dealt with sufficiently? Are the planned sources of funding and financing
realistic? Does the proposer make a financial contribution to the project?
3. Estimated Cost
Is the estimated cost of the facility reasonable in relation to the cost of similar
projects? The final determination will depend, to a large extent, on a cost/benefit
analysis.
Page 134 of 138
62
4. Life Cycle Cost Analysis
Does the proposal include an appropriately conducted analysis of projected rate
of return and life-cycle cost estimate of the proposed project and/or facility?
5. Business Objective
Does the proposer clearly outline its reason for pursuing this project? Do the
proposer’s assumptions appear reasonable?
D. Public Support
Has the proposer garnered sufficient public support for the proposed project?
1. Community Benefits
Will this project bring a significant benefit to the City, the region, and/or the state?
Are there ancillary benefits to the City because of the project?
2. Community Support
What is the extent of support or opposition for the project? Does the project
proposal demonstrate an understanding of City and regional issues and needs,
as well as the impacts the project may have on those needs? Is there a
demonstrated ability to work with the City? Have all affected local jurisdictions
provided a clear written statement of the extent of their support for the project?
3. Public Involvement Strategy
What strategies are proposed to involve local and state elected officials in
developing the project? What level of community involvement has been
identified for the project? Is there a clear strategy for informing, educating and
obtaining community input through the development and life of the project?
E. Project Compatibility
Is the proposed project compatible with the City's master plan, local
comprehensive plans, local infrastructure development plans, the capital
improvements budget or other government spending plans?
1. Compatibility with the Ex isting Transportation System
Does the project propose improvements that are compatible with the present and
planned transportation system? Does the project provide continuity with existing
and planned state and local facilities?
2. Fulfills Po licies and Goals
Does the proposed project help achieve performance, safety, mobility or
transportation demand management goals? Does the project improve
connections among the transportation modes?
3. Enhance Community-Wide Transportation System
Are there identified project benefits to the affected community transportation
system? Does this project enhance adjacent transportation facilities?
Page 135 of 138
63
4. Consistency with Local, Regi onal and State Transportation Plans
Is the project consistent with the City’s comprehensive plan and regional and
state transportation plans? If not, are steps proposed that will achieve
consistency with such plans?
5. Economic Development
Will the proposed project enhance the City’s, the region’s and the state's
economic development efforts? Is the project critical to attracting or maintaining
competitive industries and businesses to the City or region, consistent with stated
objectives?
6. Impacts on Other Facilities
Have crossings or other impacts on facilit ies of public service companies, public
or private utilities, railroads and cable television prov iders, that may be affected
by the project, been addressed? If a tran sportation project, are all proposed
interconnections with other transportation fa cilities, the communities that may be
affected, and alternatives (e.g. alig nments) that may need to be evaluated
identified?
Page 136 of 138
64
Appendix F
Proposer’s Certification
Proposer’s Name: _______________________
_______________________
Proposer’s Address Proposer’s:
______________________________ Telephone No.: ________________
______________________________ Facsimile No.: ________________
______________________________ E-mail Addr ess: ________________
Proposer’s or Proposer’s Contractor’s Virginia Class A General Contractor’s
License Number ____________________________
Proposer’s or Proposer’s Architects and Engineers Virginia Registration
Numbers: _________________________________
After first being placed under oath, I hereby certify that I have authority to submit
this proposal on behalf of the proposer whose name appears above, that I am a
principal of the proposer, that the proposer hereby agrees to all of the terms and
conditions in The City of Lynchburg, Virginia, Implementation Procedures and
Guidelines for the Public-Private Transportation Act of 1995 and the
Public-Private Education Facilities and Infrastructure Act of 2002, as amended,
that neither the proposer nor any member of its team or their principals is
currently suspended or debarred from public contracting by any federal, state or
local government entity, that I have taken reasonable steps to ascertain the
accuracy of all the information contained in this proposal and this certification,
and that the information in this proposal and certification is accurate to the best of
my knowledge or information and belief.
______ _____________________
Signature
______ ______________________
P r i n t e d / T y p e d N a m e
______ ______________________
Title (Principal of Proposer)
Page 137 of 138
65
Commonwealth of Virginia :
: T o w i t
County/City of __________ :
On ______________, 200_, ________________, (same name as above)
appeared before me, and after satisfying me of his/her identity and after being
placed under oath, swore to the truthfulness of the above statement.
______ _____________________
N o t a r y P u b l i c
My commission expires: _______________________
(If applicable) the proposer acknowledges receipt of the following agenda:
Addendum No.: ______ Dated: ____________
Addendum No.: ______ Dated: ____________
Addendum No.: ______ Dated: ____________
Addendum No.: ______ Dated: ____________
Page 138 of 138
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.