RecordWell Data

City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Jan 23, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION Tuesday, January 23, 2024 | 7:00 PM Council Chamber- City Hall 900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 AGENDA I. Invocation Councilmember Taylor II. Recognitions III. Consent Agenda III.1. Consideration of approving the minutes from the 2022 City Council meeting. III.2. Consideration of approving the minutes from the December 12, 2023 meeting. III.3. Consideration of approving the minute from the January 9, 2024 meeting. III.4. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-004 amending the FY 2024 Budget to reflect adjustments in the General ($1,000,000), Fleet Services ($2,400,000), and City Capital Projects ($4,900,000) Funds with resources of $8,300,000 from the Unassigned General Fund Balance. IV. Public Hearing IV.5. Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-24-008 amending City Code to provide surety requirements for the decommissioning of energy storage facilities. V. Public Comment V.6. Hear from a citizen regarding "the hate mail situation and what we can do about it." (Robert Flood) VI. General Business VI.7. Consideration of introducing Resolution #R-24-009 amending the FY 2024 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $225,692 for the 2023 US Department of Justice COPS Hiring Program Grant. VI.8. Consideration of introducing Resolution #R-24-010 amending the FY 2024 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $400,000 for the implementation of a mental health co-responder model. VI.9. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-011 to increase the City's lane mileage for VDOT Highway Maintenance Payments. VI.10. Consent Agenda Item #4 VI.11. Item Not on the Agenda - Consideration of introducing Resolution #R-24-012 amending the FY 2024 Adopted Schools Operating Budget and appropriating $15,000 from the City of Lynchburg's General Fund Reserve for Contingencies to Instruction with the FY 2024 Adopted Schools Operating Budget. VII. Closed Session Page 1 of 172 City Council Agenda Item III.1. Consent Agenda AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY January 23, 2024 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council AGENDA ITEM # III.1 Consideration of approving the minutes from the 2022 City Council meeting. RECOMMENDATION Approve the outstanding minutes from the 2022 City Council meetings. SUMMARY May 16, 2022, City Council School Board Interview Minutes May 20, 2022, City Council School Board Interview Minutes October 7, 2022 City Council Retreat Minutes October 11, 2022, City Council Meeting Minutes October 25, 2022, City Council Meeting Minutes November 1, 2022, City Council Meeting Minutes November 14, 2022, City Council Legislative Dinner December 13, 2022, City Council Meeting Minutes PRIOR ACTION(S) N/A FISCAL IMPACT N/A CONTACT(S) Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council ATTACHMENT(S) 1. 2022 Meeting.Minute List REVIEWED BY Date: January 18, 2024 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 2 of 172 Page 3 of 172 Meeting Approved April 26, 2022 X May 10, 2022 X May 16, 2022 May 20, 2022 May 24, 2022 X June 7, 2022 X June 28, 2022 X July 26, 2022 X August 23, 2022 X September 13, 2022 X September 27, 2022 X October 7, 2022 October 11, 2022 October 25, 2022 November 1, 2022 November 14, 2022 December 13, 2022 2022 City Council Meeting Minutes Page 4 of 172 May 16, 2022 1 // A special called meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg for the purpose of conducting interviews with candidates for the School Board was held on the 16th day of May, 2022, at 1:00 P.M. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting for the purpose of interviewing the following candidates for appointments to the Lynchburg School Board pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1.)of the Code of Virginia: James Porter, District 3; Erin “Rox” Cruz, District 2; Clifton “Dale” Reed, District 1; Martin Day, District 2, and; Kevin Struble, District 1. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open Page 5 of 172 May 16, 2022 2 meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Wilder 1 // The meeting adjourned at 5:43 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 6 of 172 May 20, 2022 1 // A special called meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg for the purpose of conducting interviews with candidates for the School Board was held on the 20th day of May, 2022, at 1:00 P.M. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder 6 Absent: Chris Faraldi 1 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting for the purpose of interviewing the following candidates for appointments to the Lynchburg School Board pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1.)of the Code of Virginia: Anthony Andrews, District 1; Gloria Preston, District 3; Jason Fleshman, District 3; Steven Smith, District 3, and; Justin Hensley, District 1. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Faraldi 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Vice Mayor Wright made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; Page 7 of 172 May 20, 2022 2 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 6 Noes: 0 Abstain: Faraldi 1 // Councilmember Faraldi, who joined the meeting during the closed session, stated that had he been present during the opening of the meeting, he would have voted against going into closed session citing his desire to be transparent in the process of school board appointments. // The meeting adjourned at 5:50 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 8 of 172 October 7, 2022 1 // A special called meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 7th day of October, 2022, at 9:00 A.M. at the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company, 419 Bradley Drive, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following members of City Council were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright Jeff Helgeson, J. Randolph Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, 7 Absent: 0 // Dr. Chris Chmura, CEO of Chmura Economics & Analytics, presented Council with an economic update and overview of both the U.S. and the City of Lynchburg. Councilmember Nelson asked if the housing values will go down or if they just won’t go up as much. Dr. Chmura replied that she wouldn’t be surprised to see them go down a little bit, but not as much as 2008/2009. Vice Mayor Wright asked if as you go into a recession, you could see a lag in other revenue sources; Dr. Chmura replied, yes. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the more you tax something, the less you see of it; Dr. Chmura replied that was correct. Councilmember Helgeson stated that if the tax rate were lowered, there would be a subsequent boom. Councilmember Nelson stated that he has always advocated for lowering the Meals Tax since more people would benefit. He asked Dr. Chmura if she would agree that lowering a Meals Tax is a more compassionate movement to take to benefit the population that are impacted by inflation. Dr. Chmura replied yes, but it wouldn’t directly benefit the poorest population because they often don’t have the luxury of dining out. // Chris DeLacy, Partner, Holland & Knight, presented Council with infrastructure investment and Jobs Act funding opportunities for the City of Lynchburg. // Kent White, Director of Community Development, and Sarah Quarantotto, Executive Director of Miriam’s House, provided Council with an overview of housing in the City of Lynchburg. Page 9 of 172 October 7, 2022 2 Councilmember Helgeson asked if with the density bonus, if the City is charging people more if they are all in one area. Mr. White replied that the bonus goes to the developer, so they would be allowed more density if they provide more affordable units within the are. Councilmember Wilder asked if the purpose of the density bonus was to have mixed income housing? Mr. White replied yes, you could have 20 but you can have 23 if you ensure three are afforable. Councilmember Dolan asked what kind of research have you had or seen about younger people not wanting to own? Mr. White replied that he has not seen this personally, but there are studies out there that do show that. Councilmember Helgeson stated that it’s best practice to have as many owner-occupied homes as possible and Council needs to put the brakes on putting more apartments and condos and transient housing. Councilmember Wilder asked if there are resources to give people if they want to renovate a house; Mr. White replied that currently the City does not, but there are some localities that do. Councilmember Wilder stated that he likes the idea of the housing trust fund and would like to see an investment in this area during the budget process. // Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, provided Council with an overview of the FY 2022 Analysis of Unassigned General Fund Balance and the Fiscal Year 2022 Adopted Budget to Estimated Actual. // The meeting adjourned at 3:00 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 10 of 172 October 11, 2022 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 11th day of October, 2022, at 4:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Chris Faraldi, Jeff Helgeson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder 6 Absent: J. Randy Nelson 1 // In the matter of Schools, Agenda Item #1, Dr. Crystal Edwards, Superintendent of Lynchburg City Schools, presented the Lynchburg City Schools Achievement Preview to Council. At the September 20, 2022 School Board work session, the Spring 2022 SOL Achievement results were shared, and all related information was available on the website. Ms. Amy Pugh, Deputy Superintendent, stated there were 8 schools in the Lynchburg City School system that were fully accredited and 8 that were accredited with conditions. For most cases at the elementary level, science had been of difficulty, so they were focusing on learning recovery and grade level standards, including more hands-on learning of science with help from a STEM specialist. One of the two high schools was fully accredited and the other was accredited with conditions due in part to the drop-out rate. This year, they were partnering with Virginia Careerworks and Human Kind, identifying students at both high schools and at high school alternative programs to assign career navigators to students who were at risk of not completing school on time to give more support. Mr. Sam Coleman, Chief Academic Officer, walked the Council through the 2021- and 2022-SOL comparisons by race and subgroup. Learning recovery was noted in all categories between years, so progress was continuing to be made towards learning achievement goals. Dr. Edwards walked Council through shared information about the comparison of Lynchburg City Schools and other Virginia cities with SOL achievements and other school quality profile program achievements. Mr. Coleman listed the current strategies for closing gaps and the key focus areas to increase achievement and growth results. Dr. Edwards said that as they examined the middle schools, they were researching how to expand gifted program opportunities through implementing a lab school model with community partners. Councilmember Faraldi asked why the only years of data were 2020, 2021 and 2022. Dr. Edwards said that longitudinal SOL data was available, but the concern raised when the scores were presented last year was what was going to be done to improve, so that was the baseline of looking at Page 11 of 172 October 11, 2022 2 student’s placement and their growth. Councilmember Faraldi asked how the historical data, which showed little to no growth, related to the information presented today. Ms. Pugh said that the focus was currently on the most recent years of learning recovery and growth assessment of students. Dr. Edwards said that she understood Councilmember Faraldi’s concern about the historical data, but she could only answer to the data that was collected under her tenure and the efforts undertaken to help children rebound from Covid-19. Councilmember Faraldi said that the historical data did not look good, and there were questions that must be asked as to what the School Division was doing to su pport the Superintendent in accomplishing the goals of the City for the School Division. Dr. Edwards said that last year, the division implemented the iExcel assessment program in order to track the achievement of children in the school system and compare them to themselves year over year rather than comparing to different classes of students. Councilmember Tweedy said that there were noteworthy increases in testing achievements for Black students and economically disadvantaged students that should be recognized. She said that she hoped the reduction of poverty in the City would have an effect on the school system and decrease the deficits in the school system. She said that expanding the model of the schools was exciting, and she wondered if these necessitated being labeled lab experiment schools in order to receive state or federal funding. She asked if there was a breakdown of the education and background information on teachers in the school system, and if there was knowledge of how that factored in when they were a very urban school division, and how that may affect the outcome of students’ testing scores. Mr. Coleman said that many teachers found that their prep programs did not prepare them for what they faced in classrooms today, so as a learning organization, they wanted to develop the skillset of teachers through instructional coaches and professional development. Councilmember Tweedy noted that there were Career Technical Education opportunities in the school system, and progress continued in aligning them more with economic development and business needs in the City. Councilmember Helgeson said that there was room to grow, and they must recognize that 50% pass rates were not good compared to the pre-pandemic 73% pass rates. He asked how they dropped so far so quickly. Dr. Edwards said that the drop-in accreditation was a state-wide phenomenon and had not been contained exclusively to Lynchburg, and could be viewed in state data. Councilmember Helgeson Page 12 of 172 October 11, 2022 3 noted that other local private schools had stayed open to offer education to students during the pandemic, and having choice and competition was important for parents to have. Dr. Edwards said that they must support the students who were succeeding in the schools as well as those who were n ot, and while acknowledging that a 50% pass rate was not a good rate, 73% was not an acceptable goal either, so they would continue to try new strategies and maintain forward progress with their children . Part of the school quality report included information regarding efforts to reduce chronic absenteeism and providing more mental health services for younger students. Councilmember Helgeson asked what was being done with regard to discipline in classrooms. Dr. Edwards said that the first line of action was to contact the child’s family to find what was the root cause of the behavior, then to provide family and administrative support. Recent behaviors exhibited by some children resulted in destructive episodes that went beyond the level that teachers’ training prepared them for, so additional support was needed. Councilmember Helgeson asked if problem children were removed from classrooms as soon as possible. Dr. Edwards said that yes, all best practices and strategies were implemented, and because absence fr om school was not proven to alleviate the issue, they tried to work with the supports of the child, including clinical, family, counseling, and school staff support. Many schools had calm-down rooms where children could safely be removed from situations in order to calm down. Councilmember Helgeson asked if transportation assisted in allowing children to attend schools for partial days. Dr. Edwards said that yes, although drivers were needed for transporting children to the schools of innovation. Councilmember Helgeson said that if the schools rezoned, the transportation would not require driving all around town. He asked if redistricting was being considered. Dr. Edwards said that they were currently performing a facilities study, and their educational consultant would work on student assignment to schools, which was part of the educational programming, as well as the zoning of the schools. Councilmember Helgeson asked if rezoning could be done at any time. Dr. Edwards said yes, but they were waiting for the completion of the facilities study before applying any approaches in order to sustain an efficient solution. Councilmember Wilder said that some children attended schools far away from their neighborhoods because specific schools offered specific programs that those children attended, so transportation was necessary to pick up children all throughout the community. He asked Dr. Coleman how they would be addressing and working with teachers who came from a predominantly white Page 13 of 172 October 11, 2022 4 background in order to prepare them for being in the predominantly African American, multicultural environment of Lynchburg City schools. Dr. Edwards said that the Office of Equity and Inclusion normally gave a family simulation presentation at the beginning of each school year, which gave teachers and administrators a glimpse into the life of what family life could be for some children that they may not have had experience with yet. It was also acknowledged that educators must sometimes change their key strategies in order to understand the children of different cultures. A large part of this research came from neighborhood relationship building, so that the places that students brought with them to school were understood when trying to find the best educational strategies for them. Dr. Coleman said that children of all identities had the right and the ability to learn, and he prioritized leveraging the professional learning community opportunities to apply culturally relevant teaching strategies to other strategies to support students in the classrooms. Dr. Wilder asked how communications with local universities explained that policies or teaching methods may need to be changed or reevaluated. Dr. Coleman said that they had not yet begun working with universities to define how they prepared their teachers, but to prepare their own teachers in the school system, they prioritized equity and cultural and racial identities as a lens through which they practiced. There were some things that could be done in partnerships to provide f eedback to universities, and there were more things they could do when developing their own teachers with development opportunities through that cultural lens on a weekly or monthly basis. Dr. Wilder said that it was a worthwhile conversation to have with higher-level institutions, especially those in the area. He said that it would be useful to know the race and subgroup makeup of the children attending private schools versus public schools in Lynchburg. It was important to highlight that LCS offered CTE p rograms that were not offered through private institutions, as well as work with the career navigators to give children opportunities and career paths to curb the drop-out rate. Vice Mayor Wright asked if Lynchburg had the highest cost per pupil in the area. Dr. Edwards said that she could return with information about the cost per pupil in the surrounding counties. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the per pupil spending for peer cities could also be provided. Dr. Edwards confirmed that she would provide the data to Council. Vice Mayor Wright asked what Dr. Edwards had in mind when she had requested the Council to join them in this effort. Dr. Edwards said that she was highly aware of the issues in the school system and in each individual school, but constantly d iscussing the Page 14 of 172 October 11, 2022 5 deficits reduced the significance of the growth and progress that was being made. All public departments wanted to attract top talent to their organizations, but no one would want to come to the city if the City Council did not promote the positive aspects of the city, and children would not have a positive experience in the schools if the community around them did not support the school they were in . Vice Mayor Wright asked if funding formulas would be discussed during this upcoming budget season or was something to be expected next year. Mr. Benda said that the answer came down to how quickly the two bodies could agree to a number, and different funding formulas and calculations could be used. He said that they were discussing the school funding formulas in preparation of the budget , and while he would like to see it in FY 24, he was hopeful it would be in FY 25. Councilmember Tweedy asked how the published data related of the city schools compared to data published about private schools. She said that this may indicate how students in all schools interacted with the economic development and career opportunities in Lynchburg. Mr. Benda said that he did not currently know, but could inquire about that information. Councilmember Wilder said that the problems faced by the schools were a community -wide problem, so they must all work together to solve those problems. Mayor Dolan asked if it would take multiple years to get back to the 73% rates from the current 50% rates. Dr. Edwards said that they would certainly try to reach it, and they would continue to work with students to reach 100% passing the SOLs. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #2, a report on Enterprise Drive had been pulled from the agenda. City Manager Wynter C. Benda stated there must be a study performed before moving forward with any projects solving the traffic speed issues, so the item would not be engaged at tonight’s meeting. // In the matter of Finance, Agenda Item #3, Council received a presentation about City Financials. Mr. Greg Patrick, Deputy City Manager, gave a summary of the economic update and overview for the U.S. and City of Lynchburg presented by Dr. Chmura that previous week at the Council’s retreat. The national economy was experiencing a tight labor market, with high inflation driving Fed behavior, and recession was likely. The City of Lynchburg is growing slower than the nation on average, and Liberty University boosted growth. Lynchburg is also currently experiencing the tight labor market and now more than ever, economic developers need to work with educators. Inflation is currently at a 40 -year high, and could lead Page 15 of 172 October 11, 2022 6 to recession if the Fed continues to raise rates. It was unclear if the economy currently was experiencing a recession based on the evaluation of the metrics used by the National Bureau of Economic Research, but the economy was slowing in terms of job ads since June 27, the federal treasury interest ra tes had resulted in an inverted yield curve for borrowing rates, and real GDP was slowing, which indicated an official recession. He walked Council through the projections for the city’s industry and employment growth for the next year. The implications of recession may not be seen at a local level immediately because the local revenues lagged the economy by a year or two, but a recession is highly likely, and sub-part growth will last for more than one year. Councilmember Wilder asked if the average salary for workers in Lynchburg, including Liberty University, was known. Mr. Patrick said that he was unsure if they had the information with and without Liberty, but the average wage for jobs in Lynchburg was approximately $50,400. Councilmember Wilder asked if more information could be provided. Mr. Patrick said yes. Councilmember Tweedy asked if there was information available related to the average pay of technical skills and customer service jobs at Liberty University. Mr. Benda said that that inform ation had recently become available, so that data could be provided. Councilmember Tweedy said that there were 6,000 jobs projected to be available in Lynchburg, so they must ensure that people had the training and opportunities to access and succeed in those jobs. Ms. Witt, Chief Financial Officer, stated that the year’s ending fund balance was estimated to be about $66M, or approximately $16M more than last year’s $49.8M. The revenues came in over budget by about $14.5M, and expenditures were below the budget by about $7.7M. The list provided to Council showed that all economically-related revenues came in much higher than projected because the FY 22 projections were made while the economy was closed due to conditions of the pandemic, and it was not until the last quarter of FY 21 that the economy began to open back up. The budget had already been adopted at that time, so the revenues were well above what was projected. She noted that the business license tax came in at $1.2M more than projected, which was based on gross sales for businesses in 2021, and the real personal property tax came in at $500,000 less than projected. In March, the Commissioner of Revenue recommended that they reduce the ratio for assessments, so the assessments Page 16 of 172 October 11, 2022 7 went up for the first time in history. The City Council had already made an adjustment for that property tax and was included in the documents. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the $2M was with the adjustment that Council made. Ms. Witt said yes. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the 25% ratio adjustment resulted in $2M more than what was expected. Ms. Witt said that a lot of that came in with the December 5, 2021 installment, but some growth was seen with the first installment on June 5 even though they reduced the assessment by 25% . Councilmember Faraldi said that if the revenues were still coming in above the projections, they must revisit the issue. Ms. Witt said that the ordinance was good for one tax year, so the Commissioner of Revenue made a commitment to present the information again in March for the next tax year. She noted that continued vacancies in staffing resulted in $4.2M less than what had been projected in terms of both salaries and benefits, which was $1.5M higher than the city’s historical maximum. Operational savin gs were $1.3M due to the Finance Committee not using the fund for contingencies and the Blue Ridge Regional Jail returning $1M for per diems. Councilmember Helgeson said that the city financial presentations along with the unassigned funds balance gave the impression that the City was in great shape with finances, but the economic forecast showed that the citizens were not due to inflation and the slowing economy. The local government could alleviate the pressure of inflation by giving excess real estate ta x revenues back to the citizens. The rates must be corrected fully in the last bill and in the bills going forward so that the City could budget and plan for it. Councilmember Tweedy asked if excess funding could be used towards workforce development initiatives in public safety departments as part of their investment in infrastructure. She asked if the one - time funds could be invested as incentive bonuses to fill necessary public safety positions. Mr. Benda answered yes. Councilmember Tweedy asked if current incentives offered could be increased. Mr. Benda answered yes. Councilmember Faraldi said that with the surplus $14M they could offer substantial tax relief to citizens while still investing in the City, and there were many options to do so. Mr. Freedman clarified that there was only one statute in state law that permits governing bodies able to return what was deemed surplus revenues to citizens by a method determined by the local governing body. Those revenues must Page 17 of 172 October 11, 2022 8 be specific to surpluses in personal property taxes and real estate taxes, which according to Ms. Witt existed in the approximate amount of $2.5M. Councilmember Wilder asked when the last time the real estate tax rate was changed. Ms. Witt said that it went to $1.05 and was increased back to $1.11 in 2013. Councilmember Wilder asked for clarification that the real estate tax had not changed but stayed the same. Ms. Witt said that was correct, it had not been changed in almost ten years. Councilmember Wilder asked if the fund surplu s issues should be addressed at this time or during the budget process. Ms. Witt said that she had just received some of their August data this week, and some of it was trending upward, but it should be noted that the projections were based on an open economy, so it was not anticipated that these types of revenues would be occurring in 2023. Councilmember Wilder asked if this information was normally addressed during the budget process. Ms. Witt said yes. The money that filled the fund balance would be looked at when budgeting for 2024, and typically any excess unassigned funds went towards capital one -time expenditures. Councilmember Wilder asked if that timeframe would be in March or April. Mr. Benda said that one-time funds could be used for initiatives that the City Council was interested in invested in, and it was understood that Councilmembers desired multiple options for decision-making, so staff would ensure options were provided. The formal budget process began with departments determining how to structurally balance FY 24 expenses and revenues, but there would be an aspect of the budget that would take into account the surplus the City had. Vice Mayor Wright said that based on the data the City provided, cutting the real estate property tax would benefit the wealthiest property owners in the city, because they would receive a disproportionate share of the rebate for their very valuable properties. It was of concern that there was suggestion to cut the taxes back without recognizing the various ways in which the City needs investment, such as the debt load, school facilities, the Housing Trust Fund, and difficult -to-fill public safety positions. The Council must look at all options available to them, including how they could mitigate the current and future challenges they knew the city was facing. Councilmember Faraldi said that he disagreed with Vice Mayor Wright’s characterization of his comments regarding lowering taxes, because he was simply requesting options for how to give some relief to citizens in some form. Page 18 of 172 October 11, 2022 9 Councilmember Tweedy said that she agreed that the wealthiest in the City would receive the highest rebates from cutting the real estate tax, and those with less means needed additional services because they did not have the options afforded to the wealthy. She said it was of concern that they still were debating whether or not to invest in their growing City, because more residents resulted in more demand for public services. The tax rate had been raised in the past to avert laying off City e mployees, so there was question as to whether future tax cuts would result in those staff reductions. Councilmember Helgeson said that the $5M tax increase last year was unnecessary, so even if they were benefitting those wealthiest property owners in the City, it should be acknowledged that they should give back the previous amount that they should not have taken. He agreed that this topic was related to the budget process and was discussed when they heard from citizens, but Council decided that the citizens did not matter. He said that after they gave back to the citizens who they had overtaxed, they should adjust the real estate tax rate or meals tax because it was not needed to be so high. Councilmember Tweedy said that a citizen had recently asked her if public speakers who had requested a tax reduction were developers or homeowners. Renters understood taxes and tax relief, and people were questioning if developers or landlords would be receiving a rebate and if that would be reflected in reducing charges to renters. They also were a city that operated with a large college student population, so the tax rates related to tourism should be evaluated. It should also be analyzed how college students affected the housing and real estate markets in the community, because they did not live in owner-occupied homes. Mr. Benda said that he had no data related to the pass -through of rebates to landlords and renters. Councilmember Tweedy asked if it could be assessed how those rebates were affecting those citizens versus developers in the City. Mr. Benda said yes , he could provide that information to Council. Mayor Dolan said that she felt this conversation would be most appropriate for the FY 24 budget process, because reopening the FY 23 budget would be greatly difficult. Councilmember Helgeson said that he had brought this issue up with the budgets of past fiscal years as well, because the taxes did not need to be raised due to the values of real estate increasing over the past decade. The Council should support the citizens who came to speak publicly to the Council about what would make Lynchburg better in terms of economic development. Page 19 of 172 October 11, 2022 10 Vice Mayor Wright said that the investment in the City’s downtown and neighborhoods had brought important development and growth to the economic development of the City, and that resulted in a higher quality of life for everyone. Councilmember Tweedy said that the City should be taking a deeper look into how their investments affected the housing market, and how they could balance the housing market to allow for more owner-occupied homes in the City. The economic investments of the City had shown to have profitable returns in creating an environment that attracted people and development to the city, furthering its growth and stability. Due to the high status of Lynchburg as a college town, people appreciated the investment. // In the matter of Business Item Briefings, Agenda Item #4, Council decided to move the following scheduled items to the October 25, 2022 meeting: - Bikes Unlimited Lease - Prohibiting the Feeding of Deer Ordinance - Support of Campbell County SMART SCALE Application - Business License Tax // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item 5, Councilmember Tweedy stated that she attended the Chauncey Spencer statue dedication at the Lynchburg Airport, which was a well-attended and great event with many organizations represented to discuss Mr. Spencer’s iconic role in aviation and his other ventures in life. Councilmember Helgeson said that he read in the paper that their previous Commonwealth Attorney had said that they had not had enough staff or resources to prosecute misdemeanors and that it was happening again. He said that the front page said that the Commonwealth Attorney did not have the resources, and that was something that must be expeditiously solved. When some of these misdemeanors went unpunished, crime in Lynchburg was soaring through the roof, so they needed to get a handle on this. Not prosecuting misdemeanors is not a good thing, and they needed to get on that. Mayor Dolan clarified that the police would continue to prosecute misdemeanors, so criminals would still be charged. Councilmember Helgeson said that they would be arrested, but prosecution was Page 20 of 172 October 11, 2022 11 through the court system. Councilmember Tweedy asked Chief Zuidema if longitudinal crime data could be presented in a report to Council at the next meeting. Councilmember Faraldi said that he had a phone call regarding development behind the Wendy’s in Timberlake, and while he could not recall the road name, he would like staff to get background on a petition for a rezoning or conditional use permit near the Kroger. It appeared to be a developm ent building off of a previous community, and he would email staff about the street. He said that if any information could be provided, it would be helpful. Councilmember Wilder said that the Pink football game for E.C. Glass had a dinner tomorrow and the game was on Friday. He said that E.C. Glass had done a great job supporting cancer awareness, and Ms. Kay Vaughn worked with the football team at E.C. Glass for the project. He thanked all the supporters of that project and who continued to support and care for that community. Mayor Dolan stated that this afternoon, the Fire Department held their annual memorial service to honor the lives lost in service to the City of Lynchburg. It was a moving and beautiful service at the backdrop of the Fireman’s Memorial Fountain in Miller Park. On the back of the program is the Fireman’s Prayer, and near the end of the prayer it reads, “I want to fill my calling and give the best in me to guard my every neighbor and protect his property.” These men we honor today gave their best. She asked that they pause for a moment to reflect and honor those people. // On motion of Vice Mayor Wright, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss an active law-enforcement lawsuit currently faced by the City, pursuant to §§ 2.2-3711(7) and 2.2-3711(8) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Nelson 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: Page 21 of 172 October 11, 2022 12 WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: Nelson 1 // The meeting was recessed at 6:52 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff S. Helgeson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 6 Absent: J. Randy Nelson 1 Vice Mayor Wright gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan proclaimed the month of October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month. Ms. Linda Ellis-Williams, Director of Victim Services, YWCA, was in attendance to accept the proclamation. Mayor Dolan also proclaimed the week of October 9 – 15, 2022, as Fire Prevention Week. Fire Chief Greg Wormser was in attendance to accept the proclamation. // In the matter of Agenda Item #7, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting a Resolution #R-22-061 approving the Dearington Neighborhood Plan as part of the Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030. City Council was previously briefed on this item at the August 23, 2022 City Council work Page 22 of 172 October 11, 2022 13 session. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Acting City Planner, gave a summary of th e item to Council. The Dearington Neighborhood Plan was developed by City staff and based on input received from the neighborhood at two public events, steering committee meetings, a neighborhood survey, and numerous conversations over the years. The plan effort was modified due to the COVID-19 pandemic and a concern over ensuring the meetings would be inclusive enough with varying comfort levels in gathering. The draft plan recommendations have a focus on City-owned property, programming, and right-of-way, mainly from a recreation and parks perspective with the aim of transforming previously neglected spaces into valuable neighborhood assets that help the Dearington Neighborhood reach its full potential. Robert Flood stated that he was speaking on behalf of the NAACP and as a concerned citizen. He said that he was a member of the committee Ms. Frischeisen served on, and it was a beautiful thing they were doing in Dearington that was past due, however, there was concern about the methane gas emitting from the ground. He said that people who lived in Dearington knew that entire area had been used as a dumpster in 1961, when the City took garbage and used it to fill in the swimming pool of the predominantly Black neighborhood, then built houses on top of it. The first survey studying the methane gas emissions was not done until 2014 under the previous City Manager, and many current residents did not know that they were living on a former landfill. He said that he supported the project, but requested that City Council wait to proceed with funding until another survey of the gas was completed and they had full knowledge of the situation. Kimberly Dyke-Harsley stated that she was a resident of the City of Lynchburg. She said that she was in favor of the Dearington Neighborhood Improvement Plan with conditions, which she said as a former resident of Dearington, and as the city liaison for the Environmental Justice Committee of Virginia Organizing. The methane gas issue had been known for a while, and she would like to see the results of the September 8 study. She said that the number one issue in Dearington was safety, due to speeding and not enough stop signs, and effective lighting was needed in the area. She requested that a safety plan be developed prior to this budget cycle so that it could be incorporated, and with those conditions she would support the project. Angela Payne-Cox said that she was a citizen of Lynchburg and was in favor of the transformation that would happen in Dearington. She said that she agreed with the previous speakers Page 23 of 172 October 11, 2022 14 about the issue of the gas. The September 8 study stated that as long as nothing was built on top and the gas was not in an enclosed area, the gas was not harmful, however she had lived in Dearington, and she was on the committee and was supportive of the improvements to the community. There had always been a negative connotation associated with Dearington and the apartments at Dearington, and she was unsure how aggressively input had been gathered from residents about what they wanted, but she would support those families. Dearington was established as a working-class community for people to live in and save resources to become homeowners, and improving the community would give those living in the apartments the incentive to become homeowners in the neighborhood. There was no one else to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in -person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Wilder asked if construction was planned on the portion of the site that had been used as a landfill. Ms. Frischeisen said that the only planned structure near the pool site was a potential walking trail, composed of either earth or permeable asphalt, but that would require due diligence before they pursued that to prevent future issues. Councilmember Wilder asked if there were any other projects where landfills had been used for other projects. Ms. Frischeisen said yes, there were examples of landfills being used for passive recreational purposes because building an enclosed structure was not usually possible without puncturing the landfill cover. Councilmember Wilder asked if the most recent study on the methane gas at Dearington was available to the public. Ms. Frischeisen said yes, it was currently on the website and she had highlights of the study available. At Dearington Playground, 186 readings found detectable levels of methane gas out of the 1,200 readings were taken, and the maximum concentration at Dearington Playground was 0.139%. At Jefferson Park, 1,800 readings were taken and 150 of those detected methane, and the maximum concentration was 0.0.5%. In the text, the consultant talked about these readings being well below the threshold of regulatory standards of VDEQ. Councilmember Wilder as ked if it was known what the residents of the area desired to have happen near the area of the landfill since it was known to be somewhat of an issue. Ms. Frischeisen said that what the conclusions and report say were basically what the plan had already included in its text, which was to limit excavation sin the area, not dig down into the area that contained the landfill, and there should be no enclosed structures on the landfill. Councilmember Wilder asked if efforts to reduce the methane gas emissions co uld be undertaken or if it Page 24 of 172 October 11, 2022 15 was best to leave it alone. Mr. Clay Simmons, Deputy Director of Public Works, stated that unless there was some change in the current levels being emitted, the recommendation would be to leave it as it currently is. He said that adding fill and cover was possible for areas that experienced settlement, and could be incorporated into any projects taking place in the area. As far as performing any significant remediation, there were not levels of emissions that warranted it at this time. Councilmember Wilder asked what was being done to address the traffic and lighting issues in the area. Ms. Frischeisen said that there were some traffic calming recommendations in the plan, and speed was definitely an issue that was raised by the neighborhood as something that needed improvement so that was addressed. Councilmember Wilder asked when the housing development project in the area would begin. Ms. Frischeisen said a study was currently being done through Virginia Housing that was analyzing how to achieve more infill housing in the Dearington neighborhood, where vacant lots existed for potential new homes. Mr. Flood requested Ms. Frischeisen provide information on the survey from the consultant. Ms. Frischeisen said that the survey was completed by a group called TRC, formerly Draper Aden, the firm previously used for gas monitoring events in the park. They compared the results to standard set by VDEQ, which were in the report as 1.5% methane by volume in enclosed structures, and the lower explosive level was 5%, which the recorded levels were well-below. Councilmember Tweedy asked Ms. Frischeisen what VDEQ stood for. Ms. Frischeisen said it was the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality. Councilmember Tweedy said that she was a member of the Housing Authority, and they had developed the plan for the new Dearington Hills, which would add more than 200 units of mixed housing types where the Dearington neighborhood is. She asked if Ms. Frischeisen could speak to the collaboration of the City, residents, and the Housing Authority in achieving a strategic plan overall for the neighborhood. Ms. Frischeisen stated that the last chapter of the Dearington Neighborhood Plan was future planning efforts, and even though LRHA was its own entity, it talked about the future reimagination of the Dearington apartments. It would definitely be a collaboration between the two bodies of the City government and LRHA. Councilmember Tweedy asked if all information would be shared between groups when it came time to redeveloping the area. Ms. Frischeisen said yes. Page 25 of 172 October 11, 2022 16 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, to approve the Resolution #R-22-061 approving the Dearington Neighborhood Plan as part of the Comprehensive Plan 2013 -2030. Councilmember Faraldi said that the residents who spoke publicly about their concerns in handling this delicate aspect of their community had his commitment to be mindful of how they developed that area before putting any resources towards it. Vice Mayor Wright said that this was an excellent plan developed by the community and City staff, and they now had to face the issue of funding it and monitoring the former landfill site to ensure it remained safe. Councilmember Wilder asked what the approximate dollar amount was for investment in the community. Ms. Frischeisen said that the information was contained in the implementation matrix in the back of the plan. Councilmember Wilder asked if the City was planning to invest millions of dollars into the community. Ms. Frischeisen said yes, and it would be through a combination of funding sources. The act of Council approving the plan allowed them to go out and seek grant funding for the project. Councilmember Wilder asked what the time period was for the plan. Ms. Frischeisen said that there were a number of short and long-term goals, and the plan detailed what would be completed in 5, 10, and 20 years. Councilmember Wilder said that the long-term plan allowed them to continue to evaluate the methane gas and measure the residents’ comfort level with continued community input. Councilmember Helgeson said that the measured methane levels were well below the thresholds published by the VDEQ. Ms. Frischeisen confirmed that the levels were far below the threshold. She said that further study was in the plan, and it was understood that if anything was near any site such as this, they needed to do more monitoring and studying. Councilmember Tweedy asked if there was an ongoing monitoring schedule or if it was just a plan that triggered the monitoring. Ms. Frischeisen said that it was asked of the consultant if they needed to implement a regular monitoring schedule, such as every two years, but the consultant did not feel that there was a need to do so because the concentrations were so low. Mayor Dolan asked if the answer was no. Ms. Frischeisen said there was not a set monitoring schedule at this time. Councilmember Wilder asked if additional studies could be requested going forward. Mr. Benda said that was correct. Councilmember Tweedy said that the community wanted to ensure the neighborhood would be safe Page 26 of 172 October 11, 2022 17 going forward, and with the context of how they arrived at this point, citizens wanted to see ongoing monitoring in some capacity to fully know and have a record that the records cont inued to be low. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Nelson 1 // In the matter of the Airport, Agenda Item #8, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting a Resolution #R-22-062 authorizing a Fuel Farm Lease Agreement between the City of Lynchburg and Freedom Aviation. Council was previously briefed on this item on September 27, 2022. Mr. Andrew La Gala, Airport Director, gave a summary of the item to Council. The City of Lynchburg owns three (3) aviation fuel storage tanks and related pumping equipment located in the fuel tank farm at Lynchburg Regional Airport. This agreement would be between the City of Lynchburg and Freedom Aviation for the lease and use of the airport’s fuel farm facility. Our current Freedom Aviation Fuel Farm Agreement is due to expire on June 30, 2023. Freedom Aviation has approached airport administration to renew this agreement in order to keep the dates closer to their Fixed Based Operator agreement that was approved by City Council earlier this year. The proposed agreement would be for five years with a five -year option to renew at the end of the initial term. The business terms of the agreement will remain as the previous agreement with some required Federal Aviation Administration standard language updates. There is a statutory requirement for a public hearing prior to leasing City property. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Vice Mayor Wright motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt Resolution #R -22- 062 authorizing a Fuel Farm Lease Agreement between the City of Lynchburg and Freedom Aviation. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Nelson 1 Page 27 of 172 October 11, 2022 18 // In the matter of the Airport, Agenda Item #9, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting a Resolution #R-22-063 authorizing a lease agreement between the City of Lynchburg and ARINC, Inc. Council was previously briefed on this item on September 27, 2022. Mr. La Gala, Air port Director, gave a summary of the item to Council. ARINC is requesting a lease agreement for their ACARS (Aircraft Communications Addressing and Reporting System) equipment. ACARS is a digital datalink system for transmission of short messages between aircraft and ground stations via airband radio or satellite. This request is for a 5-year lease with an option to renew for up to five (5) successive one (1) year terms. The rental rate shall automatically increase by two percent (2%) on the first day of ea ch anniversary of the rent commencement date. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, to adopt Resolution #R-22- 063 authorizing a lease agreement between the City of Lynchburg and ARINC, Inc.: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Nelson 1 // In the matter of Economic Development, Agenda Item #10, Council considered adopting an Ordinance #O-22-064 approving the proposed boundary adjustments to the James River Arts and Cultural District. Council was previously briefed on this item on September 27, 2022. City Manager Wynter C. Benda stated that it was recognized that by redrawing this district, there were some venues that would be paying into the newly drawn district rather than the general fund. Assistant Director of Economic Development, Ms. Anna Benston gave a summary of the item to Council. The Office of Economic Development & Tourism (OEDT) works to position arts and culture, and the organizations that serve our community, as a critical sector that contributes to the City’s economic health. To this end, the James River Arts & Cultural District was established in 2011. The program includes business incentives and an annual appropriation of amusement tax generated in the District granted by the Office of Economic Development & Tourism through an application process to support programs, events, and projects that drive traffic and spending Page 28 of 172 October 11, 2022 19 in the District. A consortium of arts and cultural organizations within the District has requested that City Council consider a boundary amendment to include the following changes: 1) the Central Business District extending up Fifth Street to Taylor Street to include the old City Cemetery and Legacy Museum, Madison House for the Arts, and up Rivermont Avenue to Bedford Avenue.; and 2) the Pierce Street Renaissance Historic District, including the properties adjacent to Pierce Street between Thirteenth Street and Fifteenth Street; and 3) the areas along Norwood Street, A Street, B Street, and Cabell Street encompass and include the Point of Honor. Additionally, staff has added language to the ordinance to limit future boundary adjustments to protect the integrity of the arts and cultural district. Councilmember Helgeson asked what the fiscal impact was of redrawing the boundaries to include more businesses to give taxes to the Arts and Cultural District. Ms. Benston said that according to the ordinance, the amusement tax generated in the district by organizations or events and activities happening in those locations were budgeted each year by Council to the fund that was then reinvested in the district. Mr. Benda said that between the three sites that were to be included, they did not have the numbers to articulate the fiscal impact of including those areas, so staff would have to return with that information for Council. He said that from a practical standpoint, adding these areas gave synergy that made good sense and had been discussed with stakeholders for a long time. Councilmember Helgeson said that he understood it would be a positive impact, but would like for it to be estimated in some way so that it could be anticipated for budgeting purposes. Mr. Benda said that the item could be addressed at the October 25, 2022 meeting so the fiscal impact would be known. Councilmember Helgeson said that he would be glad to vote for it at that time once those numbers were received. Councilmember Wilder asked if the organizations being added would be eligible for support services from the Arts and Cultural District; Ms. Benston replied yes. Councilmember Tweedy asked if the numbers to be provided were for informational purposes only. Mr. Benda said that at least one Councilmember was concerned about the detail and accuracy of the impact this action would have on the General Fund, and he did not have that information available Page 29 of 172 October 11, 2022 20 tonight, so the action would be continued to the October 25, 2022 meeting. Councilmember Helgeson said that there was a fiscal impact with no known numbers associated, so the impact should be reflective. Councilmember Tweedy asked what the fiscal impact had been previously. Ms. Benst on said that the amusement tax revenues, which were allocated by City Council, had grown steadily over the years, and in FY2020 it was $91,205 and dropped slightly in FY2021 to $81,079, and in FY2022, it was $11,338, and in FY23, the fund is $102,193. There were definitely larger organizations within the district that drive the majority of the amusement tax within the district, and the organizations proposed to be added did not charge admission for many events, so the incremental impact of the boundary adju stment would be minimal at this time. She said that she would be happy to provide numbers to Council when available. Councilmember Tweedy said that was appreciated. She stated that she was prepared to vote on the item because of the minimal impact of adding these new organizations to the district. Councilmember Helgeson said that he was not in favor of voting for this until the fiscal impact was known and enumerated on the documents provided to Council. Councilmember Wilder asked what information would be brought back on October 25, 202. Ms. Benston said that she would provide a potential fiscal impact depending on historical data of the organizations considered. Councilmember Wilder asked if this would impact the planning process. Ms. Benston said no. Councilmember Tweedy motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt Ordinance #O - 22-064 approving the proposed boundary adjustments to the James River Arts & Cultural District. Vice Mayor Wright noted that he had served as an unpaid volunteer on the Board for the Pierce Street Gateway project, but had no hand in this proposal and was unaware of the presentation coming forward until a few weeks ago. He said that because he served in his unpaid capacity, he could fairly and impartially vote on this proposal tonight. Councilmember Faraldi said that this project had his unfettered support, but it was of concern that Councilmembers wished to move forward without having full picture in relation to fiscal impact on taxes, regardless of the amount of impact, so he would be unable to support the motion. Councilmember Helgeson said that it would be more appropriate to vote on the matter when more information was received in two weeks at the next meeting, and to allow Councilmember Nelson to Page 30 of 172 October 11, 2022 21 participate in the discussion. Councilmember Helgeson made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to table the motion until the October 25, 2022 City Council meeting. Mayor Dolan said that she could support tabling the discussion for Councilmember Nelson to attend, but disagreed that more information was necessary about this economic investment. Councilmember Tweedy said that the Arts and Cultural District was an important investment that attracted more spending by visitors attending college events in the City. She asked what the historical investment in the district had been. Ms. Benston said that since 2012, the program had awarded grants totaling $491,809 to 177 projects or programs, which yielded an estimated economic impact of $22,329,660. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 Noes: Dolan, Wright, Tweedy, Wilder 4 Absent: Nelson 1 Mayor Dolan called the vote for the main motion, which was to adopt the Ordinance. With no further discussion, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Tweedy, Wilder 4 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 Absent: Nelson 1 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to further discuss the evaluations of the City Manager, the City Attorney, and the Clerk of Council pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) of Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Nelson 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: Page 31 of 172 October 11, 2022 22 WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Nelson 1 // The meeting adjourned at 9:17 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 32 of 172 October 25, 2022 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 25th day of October 2022, at 4:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, Beau Wright, Vice President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Beau Wright, Chris Faraldi, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder 6 Absent: MaryJane Dolan 1 // In the matter of Economic Development, Agenda Item #1a, City Council received a briefing on the Hill City Bikes, LLC d/b/a Bikes Unlimited request for a lease of City-owned property at 1100 Jefferson Street. This item will appear before City Council for action on October 25, 2022. Ms. Marjette Upshur, Director of the Office of Economic Development and Tourism, gave a summary of the item to Council. Hill City Bikes, LLC d/b/a Bikes Unlimited, located at 1312 Jefferson Street, has requested to lease a portion of the City Owned Property at 1100 Jefferson Street. They plan to expand their existing business to include a food and beverage component named “OH! 4” and to create a more engaging and safe space on the City Owned Property surrounding their property. They plan to invest $100,000 into building a family -friendly space and project $250,000 annually in net new revenue. A five-year lease with the opportunity to renew has been drafted by the City Attorney. Hill City Bikes, LLC agrees to pay $100 per month in rent. All maintenance shall be the responsibility of the lessor. Any work performed on the property must meet the City’s requirements and be permitted accordingly. There is a statutory requirement for a public hearing prior to leasing City property. Councilmember Nelson asked what improvements were contemplated for placement in the space as part of the lease. Ms. Upshur answered that it would probably be some fencing. Councilmember Nelson said that he knew there were restrictions of what could be put in the floodplain. Ms. Upshur said that Community Development and Water Resources staff had looked at exactly what could be installed in that area. Councilmember Nelson asked if whatever would be installed could be easily removed in the event of a flood; Ms. Upshur said yes. // In the matter of Engineering, Agenda Item #1b, City Council received a briefing on the support of Campbell County SMARTSCALE Application in Lynchburg. This item will appear before City Council for action on October 25, 2022. Ms. Gaynelle Hart, Director of Public Works, gave a summary of the item to Page 33 of 172 October 25, 2022 2 Council. VDOT has required and Campbell County have requested the City of Lynchburg to support their participation in a SMARTSCALE Application to construct improvements to Candlers Mountain Road from Campbell County into the City of Lynchburg. These improvements would add a right turn lane at Liberty View Lane. This would extend into the City along Candlers Mountain Road. The Campbell County Board of Supervisors approved their resolution in July. If the application is successful and the funding awarded, design would begin in August 2025. Councilmember Wilder asked if Campbell County’s submission of a SMARTSCALE project affected Lynchburg City’s requests for SMARTSCALE projects. Ms. Hart said that was correct, this should not affect anything related to Lynchburg’s SMARTSCALE projects. // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #1c, City Council received a briefing on the Prohibiting the Feeding of Deer Ordinance. This item will appear before City Council for action on November 1, 2022. Mr. Ryan Ball, Chief Animal Warden, gave a summary of the item to Council. Colleagues with the Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources (DWR) connected with City staff concerning the extensive number of calls received pertaining to intentional and uninte ntional feeding of white-tail deer in the City. Written warnings and citizen complaints have increased significantly for both local animal wardens and DWR officers. Residents are actively purchasing feed for deer, which is laid out for consumption and/or placed into feeding dispensers. The practice of feeding deer in residential neighborhoods has been shown to correlate with increased traffic accidents, property damage, and introduction of other animals, including bear, in search of food. Also, DWR advised that concentrating white-tail deer over an anthropomorphic centralized food source potentially will increase the transmission rate of zoonotic disease (e.g., alpha gal, Lyme disease, rocky mountain spotted fever, etc.) that often cause life altering long-term health issues. Through subsequent meetings and dialogue between DWR, the City Attorney, Chief Animal Warden, Public Works, Parks and Recreation, and City Management, the attached proposed ordinance was developed to address the noted concerns. Councilmember Faraldi asked if bow hunting was allowed in the City. Mr. Ball said that residents must abide by state laws and obtain a permit through the Lynchburg Police Department, and they tried to work with landowners of small parcels to get adjacent neighbor approval to hunt in the area. He noted that the main complaint about deer was that they damaged property. Councilmember Faraldi asked if Page 34 of 172 October 25, 2022 3 peer localities had a year-long ban or just during hunting season. Mr. Ball said that approximately 30 out of 300 had a year-round ban, and those were mainly smaller urban localities. Councilmember Faraldi asked what education had been done to notify the public that they should not be doing this. Mr. Ball said that they had done a few social media posts about feeding deer throughout the year, and Animal Control and DWR tried to educate with every in-person call. Councilmember Faraldi said that he was unsure of what his action on this item would be because the education of the public should be considered before implementing a fined punishment. Councilmember Tweedy asked how they proved people were feeding deer. Mr. Ball said that residents would often state it to the officers responding to calls. Some people had large bird feeders outside of their homes and would explain that they were for deer or other animals, and part of the code said that if someone were putting an abundance of food out and it was attracting deer to that location, after a warning they could be fined. Councilmember Tweedy asked if there was another way to lessen the deer population other than hunting them, such as feeding them. Mr. Ball said no, he had not seen any research related to methods other than culling and restricting feeding. Mr. Matthew Overstreet, Region II Wildlife Manager, Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources, stated that the answer to the question of feeding them as an alternative to reduce the population was no. He said that it unfortunately augmented the population and increased their number by providing an anthropogenic food source, concentrating the deer into a locality, increasing the potential for diseas e, and therefore creating negative consequences for human health and safety. Councilmember Tweedy said that her question was if there was a food source that would decrease the population of the deer. Mr. ?? said no. He said that there had been studies to see if contraceptives could be given to deer, but it had shown to be a failure, and the only proven mechanism for reduction or maintenance of population was through a hunting effort, with archery being most preferable in cities for safety reasons. Councilmember Tweedy asked if there was no poison to kill the deer. Mr. Overstreet said that the problem with poison was that there would be non-target species impacted. Councilmember Wilder said that it may be challenging to enforce this policy, and it may be more beneficial with an educational campaign to explain why people should not feed the deer. Mr. Ball said that the Department of Wildlife Resources did have a campaign that they could enhance and implement in Page 35 of 172 October 25, 2022 4 Lynchburg. The civil fines did not necessarily have to be implemented for every case so long as complaints did not continue. Education was of most importance, and this policy was meant to keep the City as safe as possible. Councilmember Wilder said that information could be included along with residents’ water bills so that they could be more educated about not feeding the deer. Mr. Ball said that he could work with City management to implement that. Councilmember Nelson asked how it was proven that the intent to attract deer was present rather than inadvertent feeding from compost piles or landscaping. Mr. Ball said that it depended on the situation and the abundance. When people were consistently feeding the deer, there were often multiple complaints lodged against them, and that was used when determining the intent of the case. City Attorney Matthew Freedman clarified that this policy was not restricting residential plantings that may be attractive to deer, but appeared that there would be some sort of intent to actually feed a deer in order for the ordinance to apply. He said that an example would be if someone discarded something in the compost, then law enforcement warned it was attracting deer but they continued to add to the compost the same things the deer would eat. Councilmember Nelson said that there was no doubt that the nuisances created by the deer were huge, and he agreed with Councilmember Wilder that the public should be educated on some of the innocuous activities that had negative consequences. Councilmember Helgeson said that he did not think that this was ready to vote on for November 1. He understood the problems caused by the deer but this was not the solution because there would be much speculation about the intent, while hunting the deer was a much more direct and effective effort. Very few localities in Virginia imposed fines for this behavior, so it would likely be best to educate the public on the reasons why they should not feed the deer. He said he was not inclined to vote on the ordinance as presented. Mr. ?? said that the intent was focused on individuals putting out 50 -pound sacks of corn rather than a bird feeder or squirrel feeder. In the Code of Virginia, there was a current law in which someone could be fined for intentionally feeding animals that caused damage to neighbors’ property, and penalties could be given for that. Hunting on a property where the individual next door had a 50-pound sack of corn on the ground became a violation of state law because they were hunting over bait, so they were technically not allowed to hunt on these properties at this point in time. Th e intent of this code was to mitigate damages to other persons property, reduce human conflict, and reduce human Page 36 of 172 October 25, 2022 5 health and safety concerns caused by deer in addition to allowing people the opportunity to still hunt their properties in the City without risk of being ticketed for hunting over bait. Councilmember Faraldi said that if the intent were to stop the damage, the neighbor that was feeding the deer should be found liable for the damage the deer did to the neighbor’s property . Mr. Freedman said that as Mr. Overstreet had noted, there was an administrative code section that spoke to the unauthorized feeding of deer that applied during a specific time of the year, which was the hunting season of deer. He said that the code may be more palatable to City Council if they tried to mirror at least one component of it. He said that the administrative code made not of an upon-written notification by department personnel, no person shall continue to place or distribute any food, salt, mineral, or similar substances. The proposed ordinance was based on a model ordinance from the Department of Wildlife Resources, but they did not necessarily have to have it verbatim. He asked if it would be more palatable for the written warning to be given before someone was given a civil penalty before they violated the ordinance. Councilmember Tweedy asked if they had had teams of bow hunters in the City before, and if they could try to do that again. Mr. Ball said that yes, that City program was paused at the end of 2020 due to budgetary restrictions and Covid-19-related issues. The program had existed for 25 years but had not been in effect since then. Councilmember Tweedy asked if it was effective. Mr. Ball said that it was unclear. They would kill anywhere from 300 to 400 deer per year on a schedule of hunting 2 days per week, with 2 people in a vehicle. The liabilities to employ two part-time people could be large because of the use of high-powered rifles in neighborhoods, and the program could drain money from the Police Department’s budget quickly due to overtime hours. Councilmember Tweedy asked if 300 to 400 deer were culled each year under that plan. Mr. Ball said yes. Councilmember Tweedy asked if $50 was a steep enough fine. Mr. Freedman said that $50 was the limit that could be imposed. Councilmember Nelson said that Mr. Freedman’s suggestion was a good solution in that the receipt of a warning letter would be strong and compelling evidence to prove intent to violate the law, and he would like to proceed with that option. Vice Mayor Wright asked if Mr. Freedman could prepare that text for the next meeting ; Mr. Freedman said yes. Page 37 of 172 October 25, 2022 6 // In the matter of Business License Tax, Agenda Item #1d, City Council received a briefing on the elimination of business license tax for businesses with gross receipts of less than $50,000. This item will appear before City Council for action on December 13, 2022. Mr. Mitchell Nuckles, Commissioner of the Revenue, gave a summary of the item to Council. In response to a request made by Council Member Helgeson, the Commissioner of the Revenue and City Staff will provide information related to the elimination of Business License tax for businesses with gross receipts less than $50,000 for the preceding calendar year. Currently, any business or profession whose gross receipts, wholesale, purchases, or commission sales for the preceding calendar year are between $10,001 and $50,000 pay an annual license tax of $30. Any business or profession whose gross receipts, wholesale, purchases, or commission sales for the preceding calendar year are $10,000 or less is not subject to the business and professional licensing requirements. A total of 510 businesses reported gross r eceipts in the range of $10,001 - $50,000 for calendar year 2021, with gross receipts totaling $15,384,958. The 2022 Business License Tax due from these businesses totaled $15,417, and the Business Personal Property (BPP) totaled $19,833, for total revenues of $35,250 from this range. Revising the current ordinance to eliminate Business License Tax for this group would reduce revenues by approximately $35,250. Councilmember Helgeson said that he was prepared to vote on the item when it came before the Council. He motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to adopt Option C , setting the cap at $150,000 or less. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the City Manager could explain why the item was scheduled to come before Council for a vote on December 13, 2022. Mr. Benda replied that the Mayor wanted to be present for the contemplation of taxpayer resources and that date was the nearest available on the calendar. Councilmember Helgeson asked how many businesses were at the second level. Mr. Nuckles answered that there are 340. Councilmember Helgeson asked how many were at the last level. Mr. Nuckles answered that there are 183, with a total of 1,033. Councilmember Helgeson asked if those businesses would be eliminated from the business license tax requirement begi nning next year. Mr. Nuckles said yes. Mr. Freedman asked if there was a motion currently on the table to adopt Option C. Councilmember Helgeson said that yes, Option C was his motion. Page 38 of 172 October 25, 2022 7 Councilmember Wilder asked if the notices were sent in January. Mr. Nuckles said that the business personal property forms were mailed in the first week of January, and the business license application was mailed the first week in March. The business equipment was due back before February 15 because of the twice-per-year billing and bills had to go out in April. Councilmember Wilder asked how much processing time was needed to change the system. Mr. Nuckles said that the change required to eliminate the gross receipts tax up to those levels would be very minimal. Vice Mayor Wright asked if Council held for this vote to allow the Mayor to participate until December 13 would have an operational impact to make this effective if Council adopted it. Mr. Nuckles said that as it was currently written, it would not go into effect January of 2023 but in January of 2024 so that there were no impacts on the FY23 budget which had already been set. Councilmember Wilder asked if this would go into effect in 2024. Mr. Nuckles confirmed as it was written, it would go into effect in January of 2024. Mr. Benda said that he would propose that when they adopted an option that it be positioned for 2024 because the revenues were already assumed in the adopted FY23 budget. Mr. Nuckles said that if it were 2024, it would have no impact on January 1, 2023. Vice Mayor Wright said that he was supportive of providing tax relief, but opposed making a motion in order to give the opportunity for the Mayor to participate. He asked if Mr. Benda could explain what he would recommend in terms of the amount. Mr. Benda said that he had offered an incremental approach to include Option A in order to encompass what was necessary for small businesses and for administrative operations. Option B was another relief component that would be an opportunity for impact and relief to the Commissioner by way of percentage. He said that he would caution on choosing C before stepping into that further because the percentages went up more starkly than from $0 to $100,000. Councilmember Faraldi said that whether or not a Councilmember’s absence should be considered as reason to delay a vote had been opined at the previous meeting , and he hoped that the Vice Mayor would be fair in deciding to wait or not to wait when taking a vote. He said that he was prepared to move forward with this vote. Vice Mayor Wright said that he would not be supporting this particular motion due to the reason he stated earlier. The Rules of Procedure did not currently permit Councilmembers to participate electronically. Page 39 of 172 October 25, 2022 8 Councilmember Helgeson said that when previously discussing this item with the Finance Committee, it was not under the assumption that it would begin in 2024, but should begin January 1, 2023 so that the notices were not sent out. He asked if notices would continue to be sent throughout Mar ch of next year and the policy would not take effect until the following year. Mr. Nuckles said that that was the way he understood it. Councilmember Helgeson said that this should begin in 2023 because they now had the ability to enact something to provide relief to businesses. Mr. Benda said that it was correct that Councilmember Helgeson had proposed the ordinance to be current, but he had proposed that the options be considered for FY24, however the options could also be considered for 2023. Mr. Freedman asked if there was consensus from Council to change that original motion to clarify the ordinance to affect in January 2023. Vice Mayor Wright said that the Council indicated consensus that the change to the motion was acceptable. Councilmember Wilder asked if Option B was recommended by the City Manager. Mr. Benda said that he was paying attention to the resources they had and the expenses they had to perform the day-to-day functions. He said that what he supported was an incremental approach that would allow him to understand the impact and the requirements of the Commissioner of the Revenue Office to support those options. Options A and B were supported but Option C was cautioned against due to the larger increases. Councilmember Nelson asked if the $50,000 increments had relation to how the Commissioner would handle the work. He asked if a compromise such as $130,000 would create an issue by not being on a $50,000 margin. Mr. Nuckles said no, assuming it was kept at the current limit. Councilmember Nelson asked if it would not impose any clerical or calculating hardship to his Office to pick a point less than $150,000 but over $100,000. Mr. Nuckles said that was correct. Councilmember Helgeson said that this amount would be $0.03% of the $43M surplus. Councilmember Wilder made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy, to approve Option B for $100,000 in 2023. Councilmember Wilder said that the impact of this should be measured incrementally in order for better preparation. Page 40 of 172 October 25, 2022 9 Councilmember Tweedy said that she supported giving back to small businesses and agreed with the City Manager that they should assess this alongside the budget. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 3 Noes: Wright, Helgeson, Faraldi 3 Absent: Dolan 1 Vice Mayor Wright said that the substitute motion failed and the main motion was back on the floor. Councilmember Helgeson said that all businesses had been struggling, and they sh ould alleviate their burden as much as possible in monetary and administrative ways. Councilmember Tweedy asked if the electronic participation of the meetings could be discussed by Council at a future date. Mr. Freedman said that if the City Council wanted to look into electronic participation, there was authority that could allow for it under certain guidelines, and he would gladly review it, but texting Councilmembers from a different location would likely not be permissible because the Clerk had to take minutes of the discussion as it related to it, and it would have to be public in some way so the public could observe the conversation. Any type of electronic participation authorized would have to be visible and subject to be put into the minutes in some fashion. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded to approve Ordinance #O-23-065: Ayes: Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 5 Noes: Wright 1 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Airport, Agenda Item #1e, City Council received a briefing on the supplemental lease amendment no. 10 with the General Services Administration. This item will appear before City Council for action on November 1, 2022. Mr. Cedric Simon, Assistant Airport Director, gave a summary of the item to Council. The GSA has requested that Supplemental Lease Amendment No. 10 to the lease number GS-03B-03314 be added to (i) incorporate one (1) five (5) year, one (1) year firm, renewal option as well as an additional five (5) year renewal option, (ii) memorialize the paint and carpet refresh of the Page 41 of 172 October 25, 2022 10 premises, and (iii) incorporate FAR 52.204-25 (AUG2020). This lease amendment is for office space at the Lynchburg Regional Airport for Transportation Security (TSA) personnel assigned to the airport. This lease amendment with renewal option would be at an annual fixed commitment with an annualized 3% rate increase already built into the rent structure. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #1f, City Council received a briefing on the rezoning of R-1 Low Density Residential to R-4C High Density Residential at 102 Garden’s Way. This item will appear before City Council for action on November 1, 2022. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a summary of the item to Council. Candlewood, LLC is petitioning to rezone one and twenty-nine hundredths (1.29) acres located at 102 Gardens Way from R-1, Low Density Residential District to R-4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional). The rezoning would allow the construction of six (6) townhomes with associated access and utilities. On October 12, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended Approval (3 -1, with 2 members absent, Light and Bowden and 1 vacancy) of the rezoning petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the rezoning petition. Councilmember Faraldi said that as he understood, this was the only space left that served as green space for the neighborhood, and conservation was important to keep in mind when developing property. Councilmember Helgeson asked how many houses could be built on the 1.3 acres. Ms. Frischeisen said that R-1 allowed for 2.9 units per acre, so for 1.3 acres it would be about 3.74 units. Councilmember Helgeson asked how many apartments would be built under this rezoning. Ms. Frischeisen said that the petitioner proffered that the site would be built in substantial compliance with the comprehensive plan, with a maximum amount of 6 units. R-4 allowed up to 7 units per acre, but with the proffered density, six units divided by the 1.3 was about 6 units per acre. Councilmember Helgeson said that this would allow for double the units available by right, which set a precedent and affected the neighboring properties. Councilmember Wilder asked if the units were townhomes or apartments. Ms. Frischeisen said that there were six townhomes, but would have to clarify whether they were for sale or would be retaining ownership. Councilmember Wilder asked how many units could be built on the property by right. Ms. Frischeisen said that R-1 zoning allowed for 3.74 units by right, so rounding down it would be 3 units. Page 42 of 172 October 25, 2022 11 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #1g, City Council received a briefing on the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for Providence Church at 108 Melinda Drive. This item will appear before City Council for action on November 1, 2022. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a summary of the item to Council. Providence Church is petitioning for a CUP at 108 Melinda Drive to allow the construction of a new five (500) seat sanctuary in an R-4, High Density Residential District. The subject property is zoned B-3C, Community Business District (Conditional) near the corner of Melinda Drive and Wards Ferry Road, with the remainder zoned R-4, High Density Residential District. The proposed sanctuary would be located in the R-4, High Density Residential portion of the property. Churches and their associated uses are permitted in the R-4, High Density Residential District upon approval of a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) from City Council. On September 28, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended Approval (5 -0, with 1 member absent, Light and 1 vacancy) of the CUP Petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the CUP petition. Councilmember Helgeson said that he had attended the church and given them money but was not a member. Mr. Freedman said that if a rezoning or CUP were affecting a large group as a whole and he had no financial interest in the entity, he could participate. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #1h, City Council received a briefing on the 1114 Old Graves Mill Rezoning. This item will appear before City Council for action on November 1, 2022. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a summary of the item to Council. ZZ & ZZ, LLC is petitioning to rezone approximately eleven and ninety-three hundredths (11.93) acres located at 1114, 1126 & 1168 Old Graves Mill Road from R-2, Low-Medium Density Residential District to R-4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional). The rezoning would allow the construction of one hundred sixty-nine (169) apartments, twenty-nine (29) condominiums, office, club house, pool, and two hundred sixty -two (262) parking spaces. On October 12, 2022, The Planning Commission recommended Approval (3 -1, with 2 members absent, Light and Bowden and 1 vacancy) of the FLUM amendment and of the rezoning petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the petitions with the addition of proffers. Councilmember Faraldi said that he had worked with the developer on this proposal, and he acknowledged the need for affordable housing in Lynchburg. He said that he could not support this item because of the multiple other large development going into the area and the related concerns of the Page 43 of 172 October 25, 2022 12 residents. He reiterated that there still must be creation of affordable housing, but could not support this proposal. Councilmember Tweedy said that much of the development in this specific part of the City was due to universities’ fast growth. There should be discussion on how they restricted development in these neighborhoods to the type of owner-occupied dwellings they wanted to see and regulate the creation of apartments. Mr. Benda said that it was on the table for town and gown to talk to the different colleges and universities, including Liberty University. The regulation of land would be presented in terms of zoning overlays after staff analysis and compilation of data. The Council could decide on how to invest in incentives for affordable housing such as a Housing Trust Fund. Councilmember Helgeson said that the comprehensive plan indicated the future land use map’s designations. For people who wanted to change it, it was incumbent upon them to ask for the change and not incumbent upon the City to offer. There were benefits to colleges providing housing for students in regard to the property values of the neighborhoods. He said that he was not supportive of this proposal due to the fast-paced development of the area. Councilmember Wilder asked how many units could be built on the property by right. Ms. Frischeisen answered that under the current R-2 zoning, the property could have approximately 52 units. Councilmember Wilder asked if some were apartments and some were condominiums. Ms. Frischeisen said yes. Councilmember Faraldi said that if this proposal were located somewhere else, he would be more amenable to it, but there were things that made it difficult for this specific location. Vice Mayor Wright asked City Attorney Mr. Matthew Freedman to describe the considerations they were permitted to take into account per state code when evaluating zoning proposals. Mr. Freedman said that the state code provided general parameters for governing bodies to consider as it related to making zoning decisions, and could involve essentially the health, safety, and general welfare of the community. There was also a code section that enumerated factors that lead to that general idea, including environmental safety, traffic safety, and making available affordable housing in communities. // In the matter of Planning, Item #1i, City Council received a briefing on the 2025 Lakeside Drive Rezoning. This item will appear before City Council for action on November 1, 2022. Ms. Rachel Page 44 of 172 October 25, 2022 13 Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a summary of the item to Council. Joel Sutton, of Sutton Landscaping, is petitioning to rezone approximately four hundred seventy-seven thousandths (0.477) of an acre located at 2025 Lakeside Drive from B-1, Limited Business District to B-5C, General Business District (Conditional). The rezoning would allow the use of the existing building as a landscaping services office and on -site parking of commercial vehicles. On October 12, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended Approval (4-0), with 2 members absent, Light and Bowden and 1 vacancy) of the rezoning petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the rezoning petition. Councilmember Helgeson said that this was going to B-1 to B-5, so he assumed there were a lot of conditions to account for the dramatic change. Ms. Frischeisen said that the conditions submitted were that the outdoor storage would be limited to the parking of the commercial vehicles , and staff felt they had come to a good compromise between this parcel and the B-5 parcel next to it. Vice Mayor Wright asked if there were any concerns about the shared driveway from the occupants of the homes. Ms. Frischeisen said that it was her understanding that the representative of Accupoint had been in conversations with the next-door neighbors about the shared access, and no comments or questions had been received prior to or at the Planning Commission meeting. Councilmember Helgeson said that he would prefer there be an answer rather than a non -answer. City Manager Benda asked if it was amenable for Council to go through roll call and the closed session and position the CSO 52 Tunnel Project and the 2023 Legislative Agenda items for the beginning of the next meeting. Vice Mayor Wright said there was consensus from the Council to proceed in that order. // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item #4, Councilmember Helgeson said that he was able to tailgate at Liberty University on Saturday for the football game. He said that Dr. Falwell a long time ago talked about and prayed over the ground, saying he wanted this school that did not have a football team to be a world - class university for evangelical Christians like BYU is for Mormons and Notre Dame is for Roman Catholics. He said that to have them play at home with a record crowd, bringing lots of tourism taxes to the City, was fantastic. He said that the win was fantastic, and they tailgated even after the game. He said that the spirit on the mountain there was really exciting, because lots of the kids there now did no t know Page 45 of 172 October 25, 2022 14 anything about Dr. Falwell, but fortunately they brought old videos and seeing the change in growth was hard to fathom. He congratulated Liberty University. Councilmember Wilder said that the firefighters’ graduation, promotion, and retirement cere mony took place yesterday. He said that one of the deputy fire chiefs had moved from Harrisonburg to Lynchburg, and was an example of how increasing the salaries drew in new residents from outside the City. He said that he wanted to give thanks to all the non-profits in the community, including the YWCA celebrating 110 years in service. He said that these organizations were part of what made Lynchburg so great and special to live in because of their care of those less fortunate. He said that he was thankful for all the great partnerships they had in their community that continued to do great things. Vice Mayor Wright congratulated E.C. Glass High School on their game against Jefferson Forest. He said that as the News & Advance stated, it was a blowout at 55-6, and also happened to be the annual pink game that raised awareness for breast cancer and to support the awareness garden. He commended the organizers and the players. He announced that there had been a change to the legislative dinner, and he knew that the City Manager and City Clerk had been working through those changes. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda said that on Tuesday, November 15, the local delegation had something with the state Assembly, and due to conflict, the most amenable time would be M onday, November 14, at the same location of University of Lynchburg’s Drysdale Student Center. He thanked the Council for their flexibility so they would have everyone on the best day possible. // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss the settlement of a pending lawsuit against a City employee pursuant to §§ 2.2-3711(7) and 2.2-3711(8) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, and: to discuss the appointments to the following Boards and Commissions: Transit Company Board of Directors, Parking Authority, Historic Preservation Commission, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Page 46 of 172 October 25, 2022 15 Absent: Dolan 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg cer tifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // On motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Transit Company Board of Directors: Holly Trent for a new term expiring October 31, 2025; Ben Blanks for a new term expiring October 31, 2025; Charles Spence for a new term expiring October 31, 2025. Lynchburg Parking Authority: James Mundy for a new term expiring October 31, 2027; Thorne McCraw and Ivajoan “Tobi” Jaeger were asked to holdover their positions. Historic Preservation Commission: William Watson for an unexpired term ending June 30, 2023. Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority: Marc Schewel for an unexpired term ending September 30, 2024. Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Page 47 of 172 October 25, 2022 16 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // The meeting was recessed at 6:00 p.m. // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 25 th day of October, 2022, at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Beau Wright, Vice President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 6 Absent: MaryJane Dolan 1 // Councilmember Tweedy led the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // Vice Mayor Wright welcomed the Mayor’s Youth Council members pre sent at the meeting, Mary Place from New Covenant and Hannah Page from E. C. Glass. He stated that there was consideration of a closed session at the end of this meeting to discuss the investment of public funds by the City and EDA for a building in downtown Lynchburg. Mr. Benda said that the timeliness of the item had to do with the turnaround time for the issue. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item A, copies of the minutes of the March 29, 2022 Council meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, Council by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item B, copies of the minutes of the March 31, 2022 Council meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, Council by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Page 48 of 172 October 25, 2022 17 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item C, copies of the minutes of the April 5, 2022 Council meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, Council by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of Agenda Item #6, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting Resolution #R-22-066 authorizing a lease agreement with Hill City Bikes, LLC. d/b/a Bikes Unlimi ted. Ms. Marjette Upshur, Director of the Office of Economic Development and Tourism, gave a summary of the item to Council. Hill City Bikes, LLC d/b/a Bikes Unlimited, located at 1312 Jefferson Street, has requested to lease a portion of the City Owned Property at 1100 Jefferson Street. They plan to expand their existing business to include a food and beverage component named “OH! 4” and to create a more engaging and safe space on the City Owned Property surrounding their property. They plan to invest $100 ,000 into building a family-friendly space and project $250,000 annually in net new revenue. A five -year lease with the opportunity to renew has been drafted by the City Attorney. Hill City Bikes, LLC agrees to pay $100 per month in rent. All maintenance shall be the responsibility of the lessor. Any work performed on the property must meet the City’s requirements and be permitted accordingly. There is a statutory requirement for a public hearing prior to leasing City property. Timothy Santiago stated that he was a resident of Lynchburg, Virginia. He stated that he recognized what Bikes Unlimited had done to engage cyclists in their neighborhoods, and he had heard good things about their service to the community. He said that allowing the lease enabled more investment into the economy from the business, and he encouraged any Councilmembers to defer to the Councilmember whose ward the business resided in, who was Councilmember Wilder. Vice Mayor Wright closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Counc il. Councilmember Nelson asked what the estimated revenues to the City was as a result of the increased operations. Ms. Upshur answered that the estimated revenue to the City for $250,000 of Page 49 of 172 October 25, 2022 18 increase in food and beverage, it would be $16,000 on the meals tax and $2,500 on sales tax. Councilmember Nelson asked if that was per year. Ms. Upshur said yes. Councilmember Nelson made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to approve the Resolution #R-22-066. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of Agenda Item #7, the Council considered adopting a Resolution #R -22-067 approving the College Park Master Plan as part of the City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013 – 2030. Ms. Susannah Smith, Project Manager, gave a summary of the item to Council. The College Park Master Plan serves as a roadmap to connect people, water, and community in the College Park neighborhood. Working w ith the consultant firm Skeo Solutions, the plan uses a Walkable Watershed approach to craft recommendations for passive recreation, improved pedestrian connectivity to the neighborhood and integrated sustainable practices for handling water flow to reduce flooding and improve water quality. Recommendations also include the provision for learning opportunities that serve to enhance the ecology and natural beauty of the park. This plan is a product of input received from neighborhood residents, citizen membe rs, University of Lynchburg, and City of Lynchburg staff. A Public Open House was held at College Park in Fall 2021 and a survey questionnaire was distributed to the neighborhood by City staff and University of Lynchburg students. On October 12, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended adoption (4-0), with 2 members absent, Bowden and Light and 1 vacancy) of the College Park Master Plan. Ms. Beth White stated that she was a resident of Oak Ridge Boulevard, where she had lived for 28 years and had become very familiar with this particular area. She said that this was a needed improvement to the park, which had become an unkempt eyesore over the past two decades, and it would be nice to be able to return to a local neighborhood park. Mr. Timothy Santiago stated that he was a resident of Lynchburg, Virginia. He said that he agreed that the park was an eyesore, where there sometimes was three or four weeks of trash built up there. He noted that the park was in Councilmember Faraldi’s Ward and that City Council should vote along with Page 50 of 172 October 25, 2022 19 him because his constituents were the most affected. He said the inaction of the City was sign that they had forgotten about the park, but there was no reason for the City or its residents to suffer for it. Vice Mayor Wright closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded Councilmember Nelson, to approve the Resolution #R-22-067. With no further discussion, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of Engineering, Agenda Item #8, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-22-068 supporting Campbell County’s participation in a Smart Scale application to fund a project partially within the city on Candler’s Mountain Road right turn lane at Liberty View Lane. City Council was previously briefed on this item during the October 25, 2022 work session. VDOT has required and Campbell County has requested the City of Lynchburg to support their participation in a SMARTSCALE Application to construct improvements to Candler’s Mountain Road from Campbell County into the City of Lynchburg. These improvements would add a right turn lane at Liberty View Lane. This would extend into the City along Candler’s Mountain Road. The Campbell County Board of Supervisors approved their resolution in July. If the application is successful and the funding awarded, design would begin in August 2025. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to approve the Resolution #R-22-068. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #9, Council conducted its first reading of Resolution #R-22-069 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $42,448 to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department an d technology equipment for the Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. Chief Ryan Zuidema gave a summary of the item to Council. The Police Department applies annually for the Justice Assistance Grant through the Office of Justice Programs. For the 2022 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Page 51 of 172 October 25, 2022 20 Assistance Grant, the City was awarded $42,448. The Lynchburg Police Department will use this funding to purchase eight protective helmets ($5,354) for drone team members and 23 tactical headset s for crisis negotiators and drone team members ($25,010) to ensure safe and effective communication during critical incidents. The Lynchburg Police Department will also purchase a ballistic blanket ($2,559) with a blanket stand and carry bag ($977). The Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office will use funds to purchase an ID data card system ($4,235) to increase the security of employee identification. The Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney will use the funds to purchase two desktop computers and two double -sided printers ($4,313) for use by the newly hired investigator and body worn camera assistant. The total equipment cost of $42,448 is fully reimbursable by the grant. No local matching funds are required. At its October 25, 2022 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #10, Council conducted its first reading of Resolution #R-22-070 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $59,676 to purchase 69 replacement ballistic vests for law enforcement officers. Chief Ryan Zuidema gave a summary of the item to Council. The Police Department applies annually for the Bulletproof Vest Partnership through the Office of Justice Programs. For the 2022 Police Bulletproof Vest Partnership, the City was awarded funding that covers the cost of replacement ballistic vests for both the Lynchburg Police Department and the Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office. The vests provide protection to officers in the line of duty and the life of the vest is five years from the manufacturing date. The total replacement cost for 69 vests is $59,676. The grant requires a 50% local match; these funds are available in the FY 2023 General Fund Police ($26,863) and Sheriff’s Office ($2,975) operating budgets. At its October 25, 2022 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson brought the committee’s recommendation for approval Page 52 of 172 October 25, 2022 21 forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #11, Council conducted its first reading of Resolution #R-22-071 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $50,160 to facilitate selective enforcement activities, equipment, and training. Chief Ryan Zuidema gave a summary of the item to Council. The Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) Highway Safety Program has awarded the City $33,440 for selective DUI activities, alcohol testing equipment, and annual DMV grant - related training. The grant excludes reimbursement of Medicare and Social Security benefit costs associated with the allotted overtime; however, funding of $2,368 is available for transfer from the FY 2023 General Fund Police Department budget to cover this expense. The grant agreement includes an in-kind match of $14,352 in police equipment and services from the department’s fuel and vehicle maintenance services budget. At its October 25, 2022 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #12, Council conducted its first reading of Resolution #R-22-072 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $46,125 to facilitate speed enforcement activities. Chief Ryan Zuidema gave a brief summary of the item to Council. The Department of Motor Vehicles Highway Safety Program has awarded the City $30,750 for speed enforcement activities. The grant excludes reimbursement of Medicare and Social Security benefit costs associated with the allotted overtime; however, funding of $2,353 is available for transfer from the Page 53 of 172 October 25, 2022 22 FY 2023 Police Department General Fund budget to cover this expense. The grant agreement includes an in-kind match of $13,022 in police equipment and services from the department’s fuel and vehicle maintenance services budget. At its October 25, 2022 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, Council considered a closed session to discuss the investment of public funds by the City and the Economic Development Authority for a building in downtown Lynchburg, Virginia, where competition is involved and if made public at this time would adversely affect the bargaining position of either or both public bodies pursuant to Section 2.2-3.711(A)(6) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. With no further discussion, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Wilder made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification Page 54 of 172 October 25, 2022 23 resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Nelson, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // The meeting adjourned at 8:44 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 55 of 172 November 1, 2022 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 1st day of November 2022, at 4:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, Beau Wright, Vice President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Beau Wright, J. Randy Nelson, Jeff Helgeson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 6 Absent: MaryJane Dolan 1 // In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #1, Mr. Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources, presented to Council an overview of the Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) 52 Tunnel Project. The City of Lynchburg is under a 2015 State Water Control Board – Consent Special Order to implement a plan to control combined sewage overflow discharges into the James River and its tributaries. Since the beginning of the City’s CSO program in the 1980’s the City has eliminated 115 of 132 overflow points and reduced total overflow volume by 93%. To date, over $307 million have been spent on the program. CSO 52 is the mostly costly and complex remaining project of the CSO program. The fiscal impact is $70,000,000, including design and construction. The City has been awarded $50 million in ARPA funds to be utilized for the CSO program. Vice Mayor Wright asked if there were other CSO locations that needed to be closed. Mr. Mitchell clarified that the CSO 52 tunnel project would address most of the overflows that would occur at that point, but the overflow point would still remain in case of extreme weather events. Vice Mayor Wright asked if all CSO work was encompassed in the $86 million or if that was only funding for CSO 52. Mr. Mitchell stated that that was the amount they must do in order to be in compliance with their consent order, and once the CSO 52 and other three projects were completed, they would have to complete a monitoring period to prove they had done enough to end the program. Vice Mayor Wright asked if Mr. Mitchell could address development within the sewer shed. Mr. Mitchell said that there were overflow events along the sewer shed within as little as a six-month storm event, and there were specific orders from the Department of Environmental Quality to address that problem through the CSO program, but based on their analysis, they would still have a lot of overflows along the trail. He said that at any point in time, DEQ could come in and say that because they were overflowing manholes along the trail, they could allow no new connections to the sewer line until they had a plan to address that problem. There Page 56 of 172 November 1, 2022 2 was opportunity to do a project in conjunction with the CSO program to utilize received funding to address the development issues. Vice Mayor Wright asked if it should be taken into account with large developments. Mr. Mitchell said that it was not at this point, but could change if DEQ became involved in that aspect of their operations. Vice Mayor Wright asked if they had a history of doing that. Mr. Mitchell said that there had not been a lot of development moratoriums with DEQ as long as the localities were taking reasonable efforts to address the issues, but there could be fines and other penalties associated with it if they did not address it as well. Councilmember Nelson asked if it was likely that the standards and criteria of the EPA and DEQ would change. Mr. Mitchell said that based on his work with the DEQ, there may be additional controls at the other overflow points, but with the CSO 52 project, they would be doing better than the agreement in the consent order. If they did not do the project with the tunnel, it was likely that they did not have the capacity for future development. Councilmember Nelson asked if it was correct that in an illustration in the report there was a dam constructed at the lower end of the tunnel that inhibited free flow into the body of water except when there was a major flood. Mr. Mitchell said that was correct, and there were multiple types of overflow systems in the City that varied in their complexity. Councilmember Nelson asked for clarification that there were risers and overflow pipes rather than dams in the tunnel as marked in the illustration. Mr. Mitchell said that was correct. The tunnel would be 70 to 100 feet below the surface of the ground, and in order to get the water out of the tunnel, they would have to pump it back into the sewer system after a rain event to be sent back to the water treatment plant to be treated. Councilmember Nelson asked where the tunnel-boring machine would be left after the project was completed. Mr. Mitchell said that it would potentially be left in the ground at the CSO 52 overflow point, near Hollins Mill. Councilmember Nelson asked if the boring machine was necessary to construct the connection tunnel to the treatment plant, or if a large tunnel was not necessary to complete that flow of stormwater. Mr. Mitchell stated that the tunnel would end at US Pipe, and there would be a pump station constructed to pump the water back into the sewer system once the rainfall event had passed. Councilmember Tweedy asked if they had secured the $75M. Mr. Mitchell said that there was one other step in the process to secure that funding, but they did have $75M available. Councilmember Tweedy asked where the additional $11M would come from. Mr. Mitchell said that the bulk of the $75M Page 57 of 172 November 1, 2022 3 would go toward the tunnel project, and the other three projects were not on a specific timeline, so they would look at their capital projects submittal each year to see if they had enough capacity to borrow for that additional $11M. With the CSO consent order, they had certain financial criteria they had to meet, and there may be enough debt capacity to borrow the additional $11M. Mr. Benda stated that the timing of the state budget had been later than normal, and they had received $25M more from the state to help with this project, which must be accepted by February. There would be a provision to accept those resources from the state at one of the Council’s upcoming meetings. // In the matter of Economic Development, Agenda Item #2, Council heard from County staff regarding upcoming community events through the holiday season. Ms. Marjette Upshur, Director of the Office of Economic Development & Tourism, gave a brief summary to Council. Special events, whether offered by the City of Lynchburg, businesses, or nonprofit partners, contribute to community pride and quality of place, and help drive spending in our City. The Office of Economic Development & Tourism will distribute a roundup of events planned throughout the City through the end of 2022. Councilmember Wilder stated that he knew that many of Lynchburg’s holiday events drew attendees from all across the country. Councilmember Helgeson said that a discouraged business owner called him yesterday because economic development had not been focusing on job losses. He asked what was being done to attract companies and promote the economy. Councilmember Wilder stated that when a company recently left the community, the City Council received a report about what was being done to attract more companies, keep companies in Ly nchburg, as well as efforts in workforce development. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda stated that staff could bring forward more information regarding what was being done in terms of workforce and economic development. // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item #3, City Manager Wynter C. Benda briefed the City Council on the City of Lynchburg’s draft 2023 Legislative Agenda. Each year, the City Manager works with the City department heads, City appointees, Constitutional Officers and their staff and ot hers on what topics, focus areas and/or potential bills/resolutions are important to City of Lynchburg that will first be presented Page 58 of 172 November 1, 2022 4 to City Council and later adopted by them as the City’s “legislative package” so as to position it well for the impending Virginia General Assembly Session. The key principals are 911 Reclassification, Emergency Custody Orders (ECOs) and Temporary Detention Orders (TDOs), and Swatting. Lynchburg City Police Chief Ryan Zuidema stated that the goal of this legislation was to forc e the state to put some type of structure in place to allow someone other than a law enforcement officer to sit with that patient while under an ECO as well as sitting with that patient to transport them to other localities around the state for treatment. Councilmember Wilder asked if there had been any movement on the legislative items from last year. Chief Zuidema stated that Senator Newman had pushed several bills forward that increased funding to localities, but that funding had not been sufficient. He clarified that funding was less of an issue than the design of the system. Mr. Benda stated that the Senators had been very supportive, and to the degree that they could create something particular as a solution for Lynchburg, that helped Senator Newman in his efforts at the state level. Councilmember Faraldi stated that there needed to be a specific place for people experiencing mental health issues to go, and that was something being explored with some of the funds secured by Senator Newman. Councilmember Tweedy asked why the state was not able to be more responsive to this issue, and if it was a problem across the state with other officers in localities. Police Chief Ryan Zuidema stated that in his discussions with other police chiefs around the Commonwealth, they were seeing the same challenges they were in Lynchburg. He stated that it required a massive overhaul of the mental health system in which the state provided infrastructure and investment to get things done, and there had not been enough momentum behind it to fund that overhaul. Councilmember Helgeson stated that the security guards should be at the hospitals, such as transferring people to the jail authority. Chief Zuidema clarified that swatting was when someone communicated a false threat or false emergency. The goal of the swatting legislation was to solidify the law and give additional options, because in some cases the law had not kept up with the technology, and the issue could be a serious resource drain. Page 59 of 172 November 1, 2022 5 Councilmember Tweedy asked if Council could provide any resources to Chief Zuidema to address the recent uptick in gun crimes and robberies. Chief Zuidema stated that the biggest struggle faced by the police was getting cooperation from witnesses and victims, and he encouraged victims to report information anonymously so that the police can solve the crime without identifying the individual or forcing them to appear in court to testify. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he would be interested in adding some language within the top guiding principles to increase the funding from the state to the Commonwealth Attorney’s Office without the locality having to pitch in. He stated that with increased state funding for teachers without a local match should be considered as well. He stated that there was currently language in the guidelines for unfunded mandates, and he would be interested in including that in the top priorities. Vice Mayor Wright asked how Council feedback should be given to staff. Mr. Benda stated that on Monday, November 14, they were scheduled to meet with the local delegation, so that would be an appropriate time to respond, and December 13 was positioned as a potential date for a Council vo te. He stated that he was always open to feedback or input from the Board on the materials provided , and opportunity for public feedback on the legislative agenda would be made available on the Lynchburg City website. Councilmember Helgeson stated that focusing on a few priorities rather than a long list may serve the City better in achieving the legislative goals. Mr. Benda stated that the three key principles were meant to serve as a focus, and the Council was welcome to choose only a few guidelines as m ajor priorities if they identified them as such. // In the matter of Economic Development, Agenda Item #4a, Council received an update from staff on a proposed new ordinance to allow filming on public property. This Item will appear for the City Council vote on the December 13 General Business Agenda. Ms. Anna Bentson, Assistant Director of Economic Development, gave a brief summary to Council. The Office of Economic Development & Tourism (OEDT) encourages filming in the City of Lynchburg to drive economic development, tourism and publicity for the City. Staff works with those wishing to film on City property through an application process and coordinates and shares information with any impacted departments including Police, Risk Management, Fire, Parks & Recreation, Community Development and Public Works. A certificate of liability insurance, Page 60 of 172 November 1, 2022 6 listing the City as additional insured, is required for all wishing to film on public property. The City Attorney recommended that an ordinance be in place to outline the process. Councilmember Helgeson stated that he would rather see the Economic Development & Tourism Office focus on job creation rather than creation of Ordinances. He stated that people could already film, and this was creating a more bureaucratic process. Councilmember Faraldi asked what the origin of this item was. Ms. Bentson answered that they had a process in place for filming to make sure that people were using parks or sidewalks in accordance with other uses, and the City Attorney asked that this be memorialized as an ordinance to support that process. Mr. Freedman, City Attorney, stated that there had been an informal process in which Economic Development had issued permits and permissions to keep track of and ensure the safety of public property in the City. As a part of that process, insurance certificates were required, namely to ensure that if there was damage to property or injuries that the individuals responsible had insurance to cover the actions they were responsible for. He stated that a citizen brought forth the fact that there was not an objective way for the City to determine if someone wanted to film their family at a park, so under the City’s power to police its property and ensure the safety of the community, this was a resolution that he and other departments worked on to have an objective, outlines process to account for applicable ex ceptions while ensuring the safety of public property and encouraging filming. Councilmember Faraldi asked if he would be required to abide by this ordinance if he filmed a political advertisement in a public park and then shared the advertisement video on Facebook. He asked what the point of this ordinance was if there was no fee or mandate behind it, because there was no way to administratively enforce it. He stated that the language of the ordinance could be interpreted as being subjective and in conflict with other City actions. He stated that this was a good step in the right direction, but they may not be meeting the right intent of what they should do. Mr. Freedman stated that regarding the idea of filming being subject to a permit for an individual in the road who wanted to engage for non-commercial reasons, that was excluded from the definition of filming, which was shown in the ordinance. He stated that in his estimation, the idea was to ensure that individuals’ First Amendment rights would allow them to engage in personal activities that were not subject to the ordinance. He stated that regarding penalties, if they wanted to enforce this on someone, they could enforce the provision in the City Code that speaks specifically to when provisions Page 61 of 172 November 1, 2022 7 of penalties were not provided for in an ordinance, there was a specific ordinance that spoke to what penalty would be imposed. He stated that the goal of this ordinance was to solidify the current process and in no way was anyone to be punished in the City, but would allow citizens to understand what was expected and needed from them in terms of filming on the City’s property. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he broadly agreed, but the challenge was that if he filmed on public property and then turned that into some form of marketable, tangible product, there was a commercial aspect to it. He stated that it was listed that drones could not be used, and it was not clear if that only applied to drones on public space, and fireworks were also prohibited. He stated that he agreed with the sentiment but they should be intentional in the wording. Vice Mayor Wright stated that by being so prescriptive, it might raise challenges for people. He asked how the ordinance would be enforced and to what extent. Mr. Freedman stated that these were all current requirements the City required in order to film in the City, so they were not arbitrarily created. If this was something that City Council wished to pursue, there was a way to allow for discretion from the Economic Development Office, subject to the appeal of the City Manager. These were informal requirements from the Economic Development Office that were made enforceable by t he ordinance. Vice Mayor Wright stated that he agreed that discretion would be useful. Councilmember Helgeson stated that the ordinance seemed to seek out new problems, and he would prefer the encouragement of filming in the City without bureaucratic invo lvement. City Attorney Mr. Matthew Freedman stated that if this item came back before City Council, it was including the clause for allowing discretion for exceptions by the Director of Economic Development subject to the appeal of the City Manager. Vice Mayor Wright stated that his recommendation to counsel would be to take the feedback received this evening and bring it back to Council at a later date. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #4b, Council received a briefing on the petition to rezone 3300 Carroll Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-5, General Business District. This item will appear for City Council vote on the December 13, 2022 Public Hearing agenda. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a brief summary to Council. Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church is petitioning to rezone approximately ninety-seven hundredths (0.97) of an acre located at 3300 Carroll Avenue from I -2, Light Industrial District to B-5, General Business District. The rezoning would bring the existing church into Page 62 of 172 November 1, 2022 8 conformity with the zoning ordinance and allow expansion. The church has been in operation since at least 1955 and is currently considered a legal nonconforming use in the I-2, Light Industrial District. On October 26, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (6-0) (with 1 vacancy) of the rezoning petition, and the Planning Division recommended approval of the petition. Councilmember Helgeson asked if there were any unintended consequences that the church building may experience if they rezoned from I-2 to B-5. Ms. Frischeisen answered that rezoning was necessary to allow for the expansion on the property because it currently was a nonconforming use and could not be expanded otherwise. // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item #5, Councilmember Wilder congratulated the One Community One Voice and the Police CAT Team for staying out in the rain to pass out candy to children, and it was wonderful to see their community working together to better their community. He stated that the CAT Team has been very active with One Community One Voice, and the Police and Fire Departments ha ve been coming out monthly. He stated that they talked about the two shootings that occurred this week and how to work together to address the situations of violence and shootings. He stated that churches, synagogues, the faith community, parents, and witnesses all have to work together to solve the community-wide problem. He recommended becoming mentors to children in their community through Big Brothers, Jubilee, Boys & Girls Club, and other various places where people could give back. He announced that this Wednesday, at Starr Hill Brewery from 4 p.m. to 9 p.m. there will be the sign-up for the Mustaches for Kids event, which raises funds for children in the community. He stated that it would be great to have City staff participation in the event, which had over 100 men who grew mustaches in 30 days, and usually raised about $300,000 in that time. He said that it is a great show of how people cared for children in the City. He announced that Friday will be the Pancake Jamboree, which is held by another great organization, The Exchange Club, giving back to the community. Councilmember Helgeson stated that the news is heartbreaking in its coverage of crime and shootings in the area. He stated that looking at the coverage of Birchwood Apartments, they could see the little numbers, which probably meant 41 empty casings. He stated that looking at the James Crossing shooting, and Cabell Street last night, and then listening to the single woman interviewed on the news breaks his heart. He stated that she said that she did not want her kids going outside without an adult. He Page 63 of 172 November 1, 2022 9 said that there are some rotten things from the national malarkey that has happened, and it was coming here. He stated that it broke his heart, and he hoped that they would not force single women protecting their kids to pay the highest fee in the state for a concealed weapon permit to defend themselves a nd their family. He stated that he would like to see something done about the sidewalks to nowhere. He said that when a church has to divert $100,000 to build a sidewalk, he would rather have it go to the building. He stated that he understood the purpose of it, but was interested in discussing if there was an ability to figure out something different. Councilmember Tweedy asked if the City Attorney could give information related to personal conflict in lobbying for varying policies and regulations by Councilmembers. She said that she did not know what that may be, but if there was any type of regulation or legislation about that, she would like to see it. Councilmember Nelson stated that City Council has many responsibilities, but crafting the annual budget is arguably the most important of its duties. He stated that City Council traditionally started formulating its annual budget each February, when local elections were held in May and newly -elected Councilmembers took office in July, at a time when Council’s summer agenda was light and the budgeting process was many months away. He stated that because local elections are now held in November, newly-elected Councilmembers will resume their respective offices in January, thereby immediately placing weighty budgeting responsibilities on non-incumbent Councilmembers who may have little or no practical experience on City Council. He stated that that is one of the many reasons why he opposed the Virginia General Assembly’s ill-conceived mandate to move all local elections to coincide with the November General Election. He stated that because he did not seek reelection to City Council, next Tuesday’s election will determine the successor to his vacated seat on this dais. He said that he wants that successor, whoever it is, to be oriented and qualified as soon as possible to undertake the responsibilities of this office, and not delay that process until January 2023, which would be on the eve of City Council’s 2023 budgeting process. He stated that orientation to the duties of service on this Council is neither quick nor easy, and he believes that the orderly, non-contentious, courteous, and respectful transfer of political office from one elected officeholder to the next is essential to ensure the survival of the nation’s constitutional system of representative democracy. He stated that likewise, as an old coach, he Page 64 of 172 November 1, 2022 10 often uses sports analogies to illustrate a point. He stated that in that context, he views Lynchburg as his team and their team, and he views himself as a player on their City’s team. He stated that as a team player, he feels an obligation to whoever took his position on their team to be as well-prepared as possible to confront their team’s challenges before the tough competition of the 2023 budgeting sea son began in February, because their team’s success may depend on it. He stated that if his position on City Council is vacated next week, City Council could call a special meeting to expeditiously appoint one of the newly-elected, non-incumbent victors in that election to fill that vacancy, at a time after Lynchburg voters had made their choice, but well before the budgeting season begins next year. He said therefore, he announced his resignation from Lynchburg City Council to be effective at noon, Monday, November 7, 2022, and he urged City Council to thereafter hold a special meeting to appoint one of next Tuesday’s non-incumbent election victors to fill that vacancy, enjoy a smoother orientation, and gain a little more experience in this office before Council’s budgeting process begins. He stated that accordingly, tonight will be the last time that he will sit on the dais, and perhaps the last time he will be with any of them in these Council chambers. He said that he offers each of them his sincerest gratitude for the efforts and sacrifices, the time and talent, of all City employees and administrators had given to him and his citizens during his four terms in office on City Council. He stated that said that as he vacated his seat, he repeated the words he expressed in 2010, when he first announced his candidacy of election to occupy this seat. He said “I do not do this because it is easy, I do not do this because it is profitable, I do not do this because it is convenient. I do it because it is right and virtuous to put the needs and interests of all of the people of Lynchburg first.” He gave thanks to everyone and said that he had and will continue to cherish the privilege and honor to serve on this Council, and to have promoted the diverse interests of everyone in the City. He stated that in pursuit of inclusive ideas, outcomes, and representative democracy, he urged all of them and their successors to embrace the virtues of unbiased, courteous, a nd nonpartisan public service on this Council and throughout this community. He stated that he prayed that all City Council members, both present and future, will collaborate, cooperate, and be willing to accept compromise when crafting solutions to their City’s challenges. Vice Mayor Wright thanked Councilmember Nelson for over 12 years of principled, committed service to the community. He said that he hoped they would have the opportunity to thank Page 65 of 172 November 1, 2022 11 Councilmember Nelson wholesomely as a Council and community at a date not too distant in the future. He stated that it was telling of Councilmember Nelson’s service on this body that another former member, Councilmember Turner Perrow, had joined them this evening, and he thanked Mr. Perrow for being present as well. Councilmember Faraldi stated that his heart was full yet empty. He said that no words could adequately summarize the respect, appreciation, and gratitude that he and so many others had for Councilmember Nelson and the service he had offered the City of Lynchburg. He said that in ways, this moment was the culmination of a lifetime of service to the City and all that it stands for. He stated that there would be some who would praise Councilmember Nelson for leaving this dais, but he would not be one. He stated that the friendship and camaraderie they had fostered during the last 2.5 years had led him directly to realize the great loss that this government and the community would feel by his leaving Council. He said that on any issue, they may arrive at different conclusions, yet that never once had forced them from being neighbors, colleagues, and friends, nor would he ever expect it to. He said that this was what makes Councilmember Nelson a treasure to cherish. He said that while one may disagree with any of Councilmember Nelson’s stances, comments, or proposals, they find themselves walking together as fellow citizens. He said that it cannot be denied the example Councilmember Nelson had set forth to all of them, constantly being true to himself and the principles that guided him. He said that in the charged, modern-day political environment, they should all strive to be more like Councilmember Nelson. He said that his tender resolve, humble spirit, and gentlemanly zeal were attributed to what he only remotely wished to obtain or emulate. He said that Councilmember Nelson was the consummate gentleman, and he prayed to the Almighty that he may fracturally present himself in that manner. He said that he had often said to both him in private and to others publicly that Councilmember Nelson was a picture of what he strived daily to be as a Councilmember, albeit with a slightly different voting record. He said that though he may not realize it, he was his mentor, his confidant, and most importantly, a dear friend. He said that he knew he still planned on calling Councilmember Nelson for his wise counsel and attentive ear for those times when he might not know how to move forward or to take a step backward, because he knew that there was no more honorable or faithful representative to the people of Lynchburg. He said that out of his love for Lynchburg’s citizens, Councilmember Nelson’s prudent word will still Page 66 of 172 November 1, 2022 12 influence his own ear and the City for years to come. Councilmember Faraldi read from Philippians I. He said that in Christ, and in sincere gratitude, he thanked Councilmember Nelson. // The meeting was recessed at 5:40 p.m. // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 1 st day of November, 2022, at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Beau Wright, Vice President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 6 Absent: MaryJane Dolan 1 // Councilmember Wilder gave the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Vice Mayor Wright, joined by members of the American Red Cross, recognized city employee Ashton Allen for rendering lifesaving first aid at Miller Park pool. // In the matter of Recognitions, Vice Mayor Wright recognized the International Economic Development Council’s Gold Award. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item A, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Resolution #R-22-069 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $42,448 to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department and technology equipment for the Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. On motion of Councilmember Nelson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item B, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Resolution #R-22-070 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $59,676 to purchase 69 replacement ballistic vests for law enforcement officers. On motion of Councilmember Nelson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Page 67 of 172 November 1, 2022 13 Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item C, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Resolution #R-22-071 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $50,160 to facilitate selective enforcement activities, equipment, and training. On motion of Councilmember Nelson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item D, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Resolution #R-22-072 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $46,125 to facilitate speed enforcement activities. On motion of Councilmember Nelson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of the Airport, Agenda Item #6, a public hearing was held and Council considered a resolution [later adopted on December 13, 2022] to authorize a Supplemental Lease Agreement between the City of Lynchburg and General Services Administration (GSA/TSA) and authorize the City Manager to execute the same. Council was previously briefed on this item at the October 25, 2022 work session. Mr. Andrew La Gala, Airport Director, gave a brief summary of the item to Council. The GSA has requested that Supplemental Lease Amendment No. 10 to the lease number GS-03B-03314 be added to (i) incorporate one (1) five (5) year, one (1) year firm, renewal option as well as an additional five (5) year renewal option, (ii) memorialize the paint and carpet refresh of the premises, and (iii) incorporate FAR 52.204-25 (AUG2020). This lease amendment is for office space at the Lynchburg Regional Airport for Transportation Security (TSA) personnel assigned to the airport. This lease amendment with ren ewal Page 68 of 172 November 1, 2022 14 option would be at an annual fixed commitment with an annualized 3% rate increase already built into the rent structure. The first five (5) years of the extended lease would be at an annual lease rate of $79,960.62 and the renewal option would be at an annual lease rate of $92,696.28. This includes an annualized 3% rate increase over a period of the term of the lease agreement. Citizen Timothy Santiago spoke in opposition of the resolution, stating that the annualized 3% rate increase was not keeping up with inflation so that the City got what it deserved. Vice Mayor Wright closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt the Supplemental Lease Amendment No. 10 with General Services Administration (GSA). Councilmember Helgeson asked if Mr. LaGala could address the issue of inflation in regard to this agreement. Mr. LaGala stated that to remain consistent with all federal grant assurances and other agreements, they determined that 3% was the average of the Consumer Price Index over the past 15 years, and GSA was agreeable to it. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #7, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting an ordinance approving the petition of Candlewood, LLC to rezone 102 Gardens Way from R -1, Low Density Residential District to R-4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional). Council was previously briefed on this item at the October 25, 2022 work session. Ms. Ra chel Frischeisen, Planer II, gave a brief summary of the item to Council. Candlewood, LLC is petitioning to rezone one and twenty - nine hundredths (1.29) acres located at102 Gardens Way from R -1, Low Density Residential District to R- 4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional). The rezoning would allow the construction of six (6) townhomes with associated access and utilities. On October 12, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended Approval (3-1, with 2 members absent–Light and Bowden, and 1 vacancy) of the rezoning petition, and the Planning Division recommended approval of the rezoning petition. Page 69 of 172 November 1, 2022 15 Mr. Jamey White, of White Engineering and Design, stated he was representing the petitioner, and addressed the Council. He stated that this proposal was for an expansion of an existing patio home and for creation of six identical patio homes to what was already in the neighborhood, with access from Candlewood Court. He stated that there was available water and sewer access, and the units would be for-sale and part of the same Homeowners’ Association as the rest of the Candlewood Court development. Citizen Timothy Santiago spoke in opposition to the proposed rezoning due to traffic concerns from the crowded development, and asked the Council not to approve the proposal on the grounds that they needed to look at their infrastructure first before allowing more development. Mr. White stated that he appreciated the comment, and they all knew that some areas, especially in Timberlake Road area were busy. However, what was proposed was meeting the requirements or suggestions of the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) and would have less traffic impacts than an apartment complex. Vice Mayor Wright closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the road for access would be a privately maintained street. Mr. White answered that the new road coming in was private. He stated that the amount of development in the area could not support more, and for that reason he motioned, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to deny the petition. Councilmember Helgeson stated that a drastic change from R-1 to R-4 zoning would signal to other adjacent properties that rezoning to higher density was acceptable, which could degrade the area, and he would be voting against the petition. Councilmember Wilder asked how many townhomes could be built by right on the property. Ms. Frischeisen replied that townhomes were not allowed in the R-1 zoning district, but the property could have three single family homes by right. Councilmember Tweedy noted that City Council has the power to give direction as to what development should be in the area by amending the FLUM, by incentivizing certain development initiatives, and putting a moratorium on development. Mr. Benda stated that they had not yet talked to the colleges in depth, but as part of the comprehensive plan, housing was in the RFP and would be a part of Page 70 of 172 November 1, 2022 16 their future discussions. He said he could provide further information regarding the number of pending development projects. Mr. Freedman clarified that each zoning decision was independent of itself. Councilmember Nelson stated that the level of development was appealing, but in weighing the alternative considerations, he believed the issue of green space should not be ignored, and changing this zoning would eliminate the buffer between the commercial development on Timberlake and the residential. Councilmember Wilder asked if the Planning Commission had discussed the zoning moving from R-1 to R-4. Ms. Frischeisen said not specifically. Councilmember Nelson noted that two members of the Planning Commission were absent at the vote. Councilmember Wilder stated that the City Council had to give direction to guide the development, as well as discuss student housing with the colleges in the City. Vice Mayor Wright asked staff if anyone had interest in developing single family homes on this lot. City Planner Mr. Tom Martin replied no, not that he’s aware of. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the proffer that limited the development to six units would stay with the property. Ms. Frischeisen said that was correct, the proffers were part of the zoning permanently until someone else rezoned it to amend a proffer or go to a different zoning district. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the Planning Division had ascertained that traffic would not be of severe issue. Ms. Frischeisen said that was correct, the City Traffic Engineer did not require a traffic study for a development of this size. Vice Mayor Wright stated that he was supporti ve of the petition, but understood the concerns that members had. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Faraldi 4 Noes: Wright, Wilder 2 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #8, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting Resolution #R-22-073 approving the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to allow the construction of a new five hundred (500) seat sanctuary in an R-4, High Density Residential District. Council was previously briefed on this item at the October 25, 2022 work session. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a brief summary of the item to Council. Providence Church is petitioning for a CUP at 108 Melinda Drive to allow Page 71 of 172 November 1, 2022 17 the construction of a new five (500) seat sanctuary in an R-4, High Density Residential District. The subject property is zoned B-3C, Community Business District (Conditional) near the corner of Melinda Drive and Wards Ferry Road, with the remainder zoned R-4, High Density Residential District. The proposed sanctuary would be located in the R-4, High Density Residential portion of the property. Churches and their associated uses are permitted in the R-4, High Density Residential District upon approval of a CUP from City Council. On September 28, 2022, The Planning Commission recommended Approval (5-0, with 1 member absent, Light and 1 vacancy) of the CUP Petition, and the Planning Division recommended approval of the CUP petition. Ms. Amy Seipp, Partner at Accupoint Surveying & Design, stated she was representing the church, and presented to Council. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, to approve the Resolution #R-22-073. He stated that he hoped the church would not have to build the required sidewalk because it did not had connecting ends. Councilmember Faraldi asked why the sidewalk was required. Ms. Frischeisen stated that when the zoning ordinance was amended in 2016, they initially required sidewalks with all site plans, and in 2017, Council directed staff to proceed with amendments to the sidewalk ordinance in order to a llow flexibility with requiring sidewalks across street frontage for all new development and requiring sidewalks along primary and secondary frontages. When the redevelopment of an existing site reached a certain threshold of disturbance or improvements, they would have to put in a sidewalk. Councilmember Faraldi asked if stormwater drainage would be provided with the construction of the sidewalk. M. Frischeisen said no. Councilmember Faraldi said that he was inclined to not support the application due to t he unnecessary requirement of the sidewalk. Vice Mayor Wright asked if it was correct that the City ordinance required the development carry the sidewalk. Ms. Frischeisen said yes, in the code it was left up to the Zoning Administrator. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the Zoning Administrator determined that this application was not exempt from providing the sidewalk. Ms. Seipp stated that by formula, the property did not meet the threshold for exemption of providing the sidewalk. Page 72 of 172 November 1, 2022 18 Councilmember Helgeson asked if he could amend the motion to approve the petition without requiring the sidewalk ordinance. Mr. Freedman replied that because it was the determination of the Zoning Administrator, he would not be comfortable answering without speaking to the Zoning Administrator. Mr. Tom Martin, City Planner, stated that regardless of whether or not Council decided to adopt the CUP tonight, the petitioner was required to put the sidewalk in. If Council wanted to revisit sidewalk discussions, they would have to collectively as a body direct staff to advertise that for public hearings. Councilmember Helgeson said that he would approve of amending the zoning ordinance. Mr. Martin said that it was a matter of how they infilled the infrastructure across the City. Councilmember Nelson asked if the ordinance were modified in some way, was there a feature or fact about the subject property that they could find justifying some exemption for sidewalk installation in light of all the benefits that sidewalks brought to the community. Ms. Frischeisen said that such a change would likely have to be influenced by traffic count. Vice Mayor Wright called for the vote. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // Mr. Benda stated that the applicant of Agenda Item #9 was unable to attend tonight’s meeting due to illness and had asked for the item to be continued to a future meeting. Vice Mayor Wright asked the City Attorney if a vote from Council was needed to continue the item to a future meeting. Mr. Freedman stated that the Council’s vote would be whether to table the matter indefinitely at this point, and then Council could bring it up again later on. Councilmember Faraldi stated that residents were attending the meeting to address this matter, and there had been ample opportunity to hear from the developer and Community Development, so he would like this item to move forward accordingly. Councilmember Nelson stated that this was an issue that was someone debated and contentious, and for the petitioner not to have their spokesman present to respond to any criticisms or to provide insights was not the proper way to make decisions on their City’s business. He stated that he would be in Page 73 of 172 November 1, 2022 19 favor of passing it over until they had all the resources and voices in the room to address all the questions from Council. He motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to table the item. Councilmember Faraldi stated that it was unfortunate that the petitioner’s representative was ill, but they had ample opportunity to discuss the matter with the City staff and Planning Commission, and it was incumbent upon Council to prioritize the citizens who wished to speak to this matte r at tonight’s meeting. He proposed the public hearing be held tonight to hear from the public and kept open. He stated that he would be voting against the motion. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the developer was present for the meeting. Mr. Benda answered that the developer was present, but the representative in charge of the presentation was not. Councilmember Helgeson stated that he would be voting against the motion to table the item, because it was unfair to those neighbors who showed up to speak. Vice Mayor Wright asked the City Attorney if the item was tabled indefinitely that it would need to go through the process of a public hearing advertisement and hearing per state code. Mr. Freedman stated that was correct. Council could pose the question to Planning staff if it would be feasible to have all the advertisements and postings completed by December, they could table it to a date certain in December. Councilmember Nelson asked Mr. Freedman if they could bifurcate the public hearing and hear from those who had something to say tonight. Mr. Freedman stated that they could, but they would not close the public hearing, and would keep it open until the next meeting in December. Councilmember Nelson amended his motion, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to proceed with the public hearing and keep the public hearing open to the December 13, 2022 meeting. Councilmember Faraldi asked if it was a feasible option to hold the public hearing open until the date of December 13, 2022; Mr. Benda answered yes. Councilmember Nelson asked Mr. Freedman if further advertisement was necessary if the public hearing was continued; Mr. Freedman answered no. Vice Mayor Wright called the vote. The following vote was recorded: Ayes: Nelson, Tweedy, Wright, Wilder 4 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 Page 74 of 172 November 1, 2022 20 Absent: Dolan 1 In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #9, a public hearing was held and Council considered approval of a petition to amend the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) from Medium Density Residential to High Density Residential and to rezone 1114, 1126 & 1168 Old Graves Mill Road from R -2, Low-Medium Density Residential District to R-4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional). Council was previously briefed on this item at the October 25, 2022 work session. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a brief summary of the item to Council. ZZ & ZZ, LLC is petitioning to rezone approximately eleven and ninety-three hundredths (11.93) acres located at 1114, 1126 & 1168 Old Graves Mill Road from R -2, Low-Medium Density Residential District to R-4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional). The rezoning would allow the construction of one hundred sixty-nine (169) apartments, twenty-nine (29) condominiums, office, club house, pool, and two hundred sixty-two (262) parking spaces. On October 12, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended Approval (3-1, with 2 members absent, Light and Bowden and 1 vacancy) of the FLUM amendment and of the rezoning petition, and the Planning Division recommended approval of the petitions with the addition of proffers. Vice Mayor Wright opened the public hearing. Mr. Jason Brown stated that he was a Principal with ZZ & ZZ, LLC, and addressed Council. He noted that there were only so many spaces to provide the needed affordable housing in the City, and this proposal would provide homeownership options to renters. Citizen Letitia Lowery stated that she was a resident of Ward II, and that she was not for or against the development, but was concerned about how a large development such as the proposed would impact the schools, which could not infrastructurally support this unless they worked to build schools and developments together. Citizen Timothy Santiago addressed the Council and spoke in opposition of the project because of the traffic congestion issues that would be worsened, and it should be considered that no further development should take place until they confirmed the roads could handle the growth and subsequent traffic. Citizen Albert Billingsley stated that he represented the Windsor Hills Neighborhood Association, and spoke in opposition of the project due to the Association’s concerns with how many developers chose Page 75 of 172 November 1, 2022 21 to build apartments, the lack of single-level housing, and road congestion. He requested the Council give consideration to the neighborhood residents who had to deal with this every day. Citizen Chris Mitchell stated that she was a resident of Windsor Hills and spoke in opposition of the project due to the high number of apartments in the area and the traffic concerns on Old Grave Mills Road. She requested Council consider limiting the type of development as well as promoting availability of green space. Clerk of Council Ms. Alicia L. Finney read Charles Gammon’s email into the record in opposition of the petition. Ms. Finney read Michael Hall’s email into the record in opposition of the petition. Ms. Finney previously received a letter from Citizen Albert Billingsley to read into the record, however, since he was able to attend the meeting in person, she stated that she would not be reading his statement into the record. Ms. Finney read Jay Martin’s email into the record in support of the petition. Ms. Finney read a form email into the record in opposition of the petition, sent in by Cassandra Taylor, Brian Zubroski, Letitia Lowery, George Harton, Dennis Toothman, Loretta Doty, John Ritchey, Kathy Germeroth, Keith Ballengee, Angelia Colinger, and Lorraine. Vice Mayor Wright stated that the public hearing would be continued to the December 13, 2022 meeting of the Lynchburg City Council. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #10, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting Ordinance #O-22-074 approving the petition of Joel Sutton, Sutton Landscaping to rezone 2025 Lakeside Drive from B-1, Limited Business District to B-5C, General Business District (Conditional). Council was previously briefed on this item at the October 25, 2022 work session. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a brief summary of the item to Council. Joel Sutton, of Sutton Landscaping, is petitioning to rezone approximately four hundred seventy-seven thousandths (0.477) of an acre located at 2025 Lakeside Drive from B-1, Limited Business District to B-5C, General Business District (Conditional). The rezoning would allow the use of the existing building as a landscaping services office and on -site parking of commercial vehicles. On October 12, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended Approval (4 -0, with Page 76 of 172 November 1, 2022 22 2 members absent, Light and Bowden and 1 vacancy) of the rezoning petition, and the Planning Division recommended approval of the rezoning petition. Ms. Amy Seipp, Partner at Accupoint Surveying & Design, stated that she was representing the Mr. Sutton, and presented to Council. Citizen Timothy Santiago addressed the Council and spoke in favor of the petition because the renovation of the property would raise property values. Seeing no further speakers, Vice Mayor Wright closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the proffers limited the use of the B-5 zoning to only include allowance of parking pickup trucks and trailers, and the other B-1 uses would remain. Ms. Frischeisen said that was correct. Councilmember Nelson motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to approve the Ordinance #O-22-074. With no further discussion, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan 1 // In the matter of Public Comment, the Council heard from a Citizen Timothy Santiago, resident of Ward II, addressed the Council regarding the Rules of Procedure Rule 6.9a, the duty to vote. He stated that the only time a Councilmember should abstain from a vote is when there is a conflict of interest. //Councilmember Tweedy requested that City staff discuss the development in different areas of town and the pending development projects. Councilmember Nelson stated that it had been a pleasure working with everyone, with staff, and engaging with the citizens and all the businesses in the City. He said he would not trade his almost -13 years on Council for anything. // The meeting adjourned at 9:40 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 77 of 172 November 14, 2022 1 // A special called meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg and its local delegation was held on the 14th day of November, 2022, at 6:00 P.M. at the University of Lynchburg, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following members of City Council were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 5 Absent: Beau Wright 1 // The following local legislatures were present: Present: Steve Newman (Senate of Virginia, District 23), Mark Peake (Senator of Virginia, District 22), Wendell Walker (Virginia House of Delegates, District 23), Kathy Byron (Virginia House of Delegates, District 22) 4 Absent: 0 // The following Councilmembers-elect were present: Present: Stephanie Reed, Larry Taylor, Martin Misjuns 3 Absent: 0 // Councilmember Wilder gave the Invocation, followed by a dinner served in the Drysdale Student Center of the University of Lynchburg. // Michelle Gowdy, President of the Virginia Municipal League, a statewide, nonprofit, nonpartisan association of city, town and county governments which aims to improve and assist local governments through legislative advocacy, research, education and other services. Ms. Gowdy spoke to the dinner guests about the upcoming General Assembly. Mr. Jim Regimbal, Virginia First Cities Policy Director/Fiscal Analytics, LLC, provided dinner guests with an overview of the State’s budget and an economic outlook. Page 78 of 172 November 14, 2022 2 // Senators Newman and Peake and Delegates Walker and Byron were afforded the opportunity to give remarks regarding the upcoming General Assembly session. // The meeting adjourned at 7:30 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 79 of 172 December 13, 2022 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 13th day of December 2022, at 4:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 6 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Finance, Agenda Item 1, Council received a presentation of the Annual Comprehensive Financial Report from Mr. Chris Banta with Brown Edwards. The audit gave an unmodified opinion of the City’s financial statements, detected no material weaknesses or significant deficiencies, found one immaterial item in the compliance supplement, and found one immaterial item in the federal single audit portion. There were no significant matters in either the City or the Schools’ audit, and a copy of the management representation letter was provided in the materials. // In the matter of Parks and Recreation, Agenda Item 2, Council received a presentation of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. Ms. Jenny Jones gave a summary of the item to Council. Mr. Josh Gulick of Lose Design presented the findings and recommendations for the project. The recommendations included upgrades to individual parks, increased trail activity, developing a new indoor multipurpose facility, and expanding the Templeton Senior Center in order to provide recreation that can accommodate the residents of Lynchburg in ten years. Councilmember Faraldi asked if data could be provided about how many people polled did not have access to trails. Mr. Gulick stated that it could be provided but would be in rough figures. Councilmember Faraldi asked if IP addresses of the respondents were provided. Ms. Jones answered no. Councilmember Faraldi stated that there was a dire need for green space in the southern part of town, which must be considered in Council discussions about future development in the City. Mr. Gulick stated that the purpose of this plan for the parks was to be used in conjunction with zoning and land use in the future development of the City. Councilmember Wilder stated that he supported the use of connectivity in the plan, and the proposed investment in trails that would make the City more enticing for residents. Page 80 of 172 December 13, 2022 2 Councilmember Helgeson stated that the plan must be very targeted to most effectively use Capital Improvement Plan funds. // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item 3, Council received an overview of the City of Lynchburg’s 2023 Legislative Agenda from Mr. Wynter C. Benda, City Manager. Each year, the City Manager works with the City department heads, City appointees, Constitutional Officers and their staff and others on what topics, focus areas and/or potential bills/resolutions are important to the City of Lynchburg that will first be presented to City Council and later adopted by them as the City’s “legislative package” so as to position it well for the impending Virginia General Assembly Session. The items of particular import to the City of Lynchburg were noted to be the emergency custody orders and temporary custody orders for the police, appropriate funding for state offices, and swatting. Councilmember Helgeson stated that there must be additional action taken to reduce the amount of time police officers spent with individuals awaiting psychiatric care. Mayor Dolan stated that there was a task force that was addressing the issue at the state level. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he would like to see inclusion of language similar to Roanoke’s legislative portfolio regarding rollback of primary enforcement traffic offenses and presumption against bail. He noted that the document may benefit from being shortened. // In the matter of Lynchburg Redevelopment & Housing Authority, Agenda Item 4, Council was briefed on the authorization of the designation of the Dearington Hills Apartments as a revitalization area. This item will appear before City Council for action on December 13, 2022. Dr. John Hughes gave a summary of the item to Council. The Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) are working to submit a 2022 Tax Credit Application. Mary Mayrose, Executive Director of LRHA, has requested that City Council acknowledge by resolution that the area of Dearington Hills is a revitalization area as evidenced by the City's Comprehensive Plan. Councilmember Wilder asked how many units were currently on the property. Ms. Rose stated that on the entire property there were 100 units, the first phase would be 80, the second pha se would be an additional 100, and the third phase would finalize it at 242. Councilmember Wilder asked if all of the units would be apartments. Ms. Rose stated that there were different architectural styles proposed at this time, including rowhouses, townhouses, a senior property, and garden-style apartments. Page 81 of 172 December 13, 2022 3 // in the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item 5, Council received a briefing on the FY 2024 Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Annual Action Plan Goals. This item will appear before City Council for action on January 10, 2023. Ms. Melva Walker, Grants Manager, gave a summary of the item to Council. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item 6, Council received a briefing on the Eastwood Park Future Land Use Map Amendment and Rezoning. This item will appear before City Council for action on January 10, 2023. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner, gave a summary of the item to Council. The Planning Commission recommended denial of the application on November 9, 2022. Councilmember Faraldi asked what procedure the City had with these types of developments so far as rearranging the order of events to prevent unnecessary tree removal. Ms. Frischeisen stat ed that clearing and logging were not determined by the rezoning, so that activity was permitted regardless. Councilmember Faraldi asked if there was precedent of a locality requiring approval prior to tree clearing of a certain acreage. Ms. Frischeisen replied that the Department of Forestry oversees logging, so they would have to research that. Councilmember Wilder stated that it would be helpful to have a work session with the Planning Commission and developers in order to discuss the future development of the City. Mr. Benda stated that staff was currently gathering information from developers about the housing type and locations being developed in the City. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item 7, Council received a briefing on granting a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to TPB Enterprises, LLC to allow the construction of 306 apartments at 1001, 1009 Dillard Drive and 2009 Enterprise Drive. This item will appear before City Council for action on December 13, 2022. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner, gave a summary of the item to Council. TPB Enterprises is petitioning for a CUP at 1001, 1009 Dillard Drive & 2009 Enterprise Drive to allow the construction of three-hundred and six (306) apartments in a B-3C, Community Business District (Conditional). Apartments and their associated uses are permitted in this zoning district upon approval of a CUP from City Council. City Council previously approved the CUP petition of 434 Center, LLC (Gary Schmincke) for one hundred sixteen (116) apartment units and associated gymnasium / commercial space at this location on August 13, 2019, which has expired. CUPs are valid for twenty-four (24) months once issued. Page 82 of 172 December 13, 2022 4 A traffic analysis was conducted in 2019 as part of the original petition. This study indicated that based upon the proposed one hundred sixteen (116) apartments and associated gymnasium /commercial space there would be no “appreciable impacts caused by the construction of the multi-use development”. The only warranted improvements indicated were left and right turn lanes to the proposed entrance from Enterprise Drive. While not warranted by the traffic analysis, City staff worked with the petitioner to include widening and restriping Dillard Drive from Enterprise Drive to the development driveway. As part of the current request, new trip generations based upon the updated concept plan were prepared by Engineering & Planning Resources using the ITE Trip Generation Manual V11. The updated trip generation based upon an increase to three-hundred and six (306) residential units, with the proposed reduction in gymnasium / commercial space, results in a decrease in the total vehicle traffic, including the number of weekday trips, AM peak trips and PM peak trips. Vice Mayor Wright asked how the traffic impacts from J. Crew were addressed. Ms. Frischeisen stated that the J. Crew had a high number of seasonal employees, the memo indicated no additional improvements were needed beyond the original proffers, and the petitioner showed a right -in right-out turn on Enterprise Drive. Mayor Dolan stated that the 2019 traffic study did not extend to the area that included the J. Crew. Mr. Lee Newland, City Engineer, stated that the traffic study from 2019 was done by Hurt & Proffitt, and looked at the intersection of Dillard Drive and Enterprise Drive should have taken into account the traffic down Dillard Drive. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he would not be supporting the item because of the traffic congestion on Enterprise Drive. Councilmember Wilder asked if notices were sent to residents in the area to communicate that there would be a public hearing. Ms. Frischeisen stated that required notice included posted signs along the frontage, legal notice in the newspaper, and notification of property owners within 200 feet of the property, which must be posted 30 days before the public hearing of the Planning Commission. // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Faraldi thanked everyone who participated in Mustaches for Kids. He commended Heritage and E. C. Glass High Schools with the strides made in their football programs this year. He stated that it was a really good thing to see how Heritage in the second half of the game put up such a fight until the very end. He commended Coach Bradley and the rest of the coaching Page 83 of 172 December 13, 2022 5 staff and team for their zeal and making Lynchburg proud. He stated that the Christmas Parade seemed to go very well and was well-received by its attendees. He stated that he was looking forward to celebrating the Christmas holiday and rest of the holiday season with family, and hoped everyone else did as well. Councilmember Wilder stated that Mustaches for Kids raised $503,000 in 30 days, which was amazing for the children in the community. He commended all the City staff, Police Chief, Fire Chief, and others for participating in the project. // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss the resolution of an active lawsuit currently faced by the City pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(7) and 2.2-3711(8) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, and to discuss the appointments to the following boards and commissions: Lynchburg Regional Airport Commission, Planning Commission, Community Development Advisory Committee, Horizon Behavioral Health Board of Directors, Economic Development Authority, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority, Lynchburg Parking Authority, and Greater Lynchburg Transit Company Board of Directors, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711A(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open Page 84 of 172 December 13, 2022 6 meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder. Councilmember Faraldi stated for the record that he had recused himself of discussion of the active lawsuit that the City is currently facing. By the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 // On motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Lynchburg Regional Airport Commission: Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick for an indefinite term as the City Manager’s by proxy; Mark Elliott for a new term ending December 31, 2025; Janice Crawford for a new term ending December 31, 2025. Planning Commission: Dave Henderson for an unexpired term ending December 31, 2024. Community Development Advisory Committee: Dr. Brenda Farmer for a new term ending December 31, 2023; Sandra Mitchell for a new term ending December 31, 2023; Lana Musgrave for a new term e nding December 31, 2023; Kay Reid for a new term ending December 31, 2023; Sally Schneider for a new term ending December 31, 2023; Dr. Sterling Wilder for a new term ending December 31, 2023. Horizon Behavioral Health Board of Directors: Betty Brickhouse for a new term ending December 31, 2025. Economic Development Authority: Sean Huyett for an unexpired term ending June 30, 2026. Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority: no appointments were made at this time. Lynchburg Parking Authority Greater Lynchburg Transit Company Board of Directors: Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick for an unexpired term ending December 31, 2023. Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 // The meeting was recessed at 6:23 p.m. Page 85 of 172 December 13, 2022 7 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 13 th day of December, 2022, at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 6 Absent: 0 // Councilmember Faraldi led the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan recognized Jenna Ng of the Mayor’s Youth Council. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan recognized the CO.STARTERS Graduat es: Nicole Levasseur, Kathleen Davis, Tony Trupe, Trish Cerulli, Amy Robinson, Brittany Gallahan, Emily Johnson, Latia Hancock, Clover Charles, Leidra McQueen, Julie Palmer, Nikos Hawkins, Tara Johsnon-Smith. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan presented the keys of the City to the Honorable Councilmembers Beau Wright, Dr. Treney Tweedy, and Randy Nelson. Mayor Dolan noted that Mr. Nelson was not present to receive his recognition, so she would deliver it to him at a later date. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item 5, Council formally adopted Resolution #R -22-075 ratifying the GSA/TSA Lease Agreement. On motion of Vice Mayor Wright, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item 6, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting Ordinance #O-22-076 approving the rezoning of Grace Orthodox Church at 3300 Carroll Avenue. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a brief summary of the item to Council. Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church is petitioning to rezone approximately ninety-seven hundredths (0.97) of an acre located at 3300 Carroll Avenue from I-2, Light Industrial District to B-5, General Business District. The rezoning would bring the existing church into conformity with the zoning ordinance and allow expansion. The church has been in operation since at least 1955 and is currently considered a legal nonconforming use in the I -2, Light Industrial District. The Planning Commission recommended approval (6-0, and 1 vacancy) of the rezoning petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the petition. Page 86 of 172 December 13, 2022 8 Mr. Scott Shallenberger stated that he was a ruling elder and trustee of Grace Orthodox Presbyterian Church. He said the purpose of the zoning change request was not to change the use of the church, but to build a covered deck off of the back of their fellowship hall so mothers could watch their children on the playground that was to be built in the backyard. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Tweedy motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, to adopt the Ordinance #O - 22-076. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item 7, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting a resolution granting a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to TPB Enterprises, LLC to allow the construct ion of 306 apartments at 1001, 1009 Dillard Drive and 209 Enterprise Drive. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a brief summary of the item to Council. TPB Enterprises is petitioning for a CUP at 1001, 1009 Dillard Drive & 2009 Enterprise Drive to allow the construction of three-hundred and six (306) apartments in a B-3C, Community Business District (Conditional). Apartments and their associated uses are permitted in this zoning district upon approval of a CUP from City Council. City Council previously approved the CUP petition of 434 Center, LLC (Gary Schmincke) for one hundred sixteen (116) apartment units and associated gymnasium / commercial space at this location on August 13, 2019, which has expired. CUPs are valid for twenty-four (24) months once issued. A traffic analysis was conducted in 2019 as part of the original petition. This study indicated that based upon the proposed one hundred sixteen (116) apartments and associated gymnasium / commercial space there would be no “appreciable impacts caused by the construction of the multi-use development”. The only warranted improvements indicated were left and right turn lanes to the proposed entrance from Enterprise Drive. While not warranted by the traffic analysis, City staff worked with the petitioner to include widening and restriping Dillard Drive from Enterprise Drive to the development driveway. As part of the current request, new trip generations based upon the updated concept plan were prepared by Engineering & Planning Resources using the ITE Trip Generation Manual V11. The updated trip generation based upon an Page 87 of 172 December 13, 2022 9 increase to three-hundred and six (306) residential units, with the proposed reduction in gymnasium / commercial space, results in a decrease in the total vehicle traffic, including the number of weekday trips, AM peak trips and PM peak trips. On November 9, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (3-2, with 1 absent and 1 vacancy) of the CUP petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the petition. Mr. Daniel Cyrus stated that he was representing TPB Enterprises and was presenting to Council. He stated that the CUP was not associated with the B-3 commercial uses, which could be constructed by right, but was specific to the proposed 306 apartments, which would be four-story buildings with interior corridors and elevators. Mr. Norm Walton, with Perkins & Orrison, presented to Council the allowed uses of the property and the proposed proffers of the project. Mr. Bill Lynch, Traffic Engineer, presented to Council the traffic analysis of the proposed development. Mr. Scott Munker, Vice President of Supply Chain for J. Crew, addressed Council regarding the traffic congestion of Dillard Avenue. Mr. George Bondurant, representing Hanwha Azdel, Inc, stated that his address w as 90 Horseman Drive, Lynchburg, Virginia, 24502. He stated that he had not received notification of either this rezoning or the 2019 rezoning. He stated his opposition to the proposal due to traffic congestion in the area and the issues of development of residential uses in an industrial area. Mr. Colby York, Vice President of Thrive Logistics, stated that Thrive Logistics was located across the street from the proposed development. opposition of the project due to the issues of development of residential uses in an industrial area. Mayor Dolan asked if the applicant had a rebuttal. Mr. Cyrus stated that the housing proposed was meant to provide housing for employees for the many businesses in the area, and the property had already been rezoned to not serve as an industrial use. He stated that the project was meant to address the existing concerns by alleviating them. Mayor Dolan closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to deny the petition. Councilmember Faraldi asked how many apartments could be built on the property by right. Ms. Frischeisen answered that mixed use residential was allowed by right with a ratio of 1 to 1. It would Page 88 of 172 December 13, 2022 10 depend on how large the floor plan was in order to determine the amount of residential. Councilmember Faraldi requested the Council review by-right policies that allowed business zoned parcels to have residential uses. He expressed his concern about the lack of communication between the develop er and the surrounding businesses and about the traffic issues in the area. Councilmember Helgeson noted the original rezoning was approved because it had much fewer apartments, but the current proposal was wholly different and he could not support it. Vice Mayor Wright asked what the notification process was for adjoining properties. Ms. Frischeisen stated that the requirements per the City Code included signage posted at the frontage of the property, notification in the newspaper, and notifying adjoining property owners. She stated that Azdel was sent a letter and J. Crew was located too far away to receive a letter. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the study took into account what the forecasted use of the road is. Mr. Lynch answered that the study did not include the traffic in the future, only the existing traffic and the predicted traffic on the sites. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the City was planning to make improvements to the intersection of the roads other than with this petition. Mr. Benda answered no. Councilmember Helgeson clarified that it was proffered in the rezoning of the property that when the property was developed, the turn lanes were to be improved. Councilmember Wilder stated that he understood the traffic issues of the area and was supportive of Councilmember Faraldi’s motion. Councilmember Tweedy stated that the growth of the area was of concern. She asked why the number of units had tripled. Mr. Cyrus replied that the project only worked from a financial perspective if the density was at its current proposal. Mayor Dolan stated that she did not support the project because of the traffic concerns and the industrial uses of the area. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item 8, a public hearing was continued and Council considered adopting Resolution #R-22-077 and Ordinance #O-22-078 amending the Future Land Use Map and approving a rezoning at 1114, 1126, and 1168 Old Graves Mill Road. On November 1, 2022, City Council Page 89 of 172 December 13, 2022 11 conducted a public hearing and held it open for the December 13, 2022 City Council meeting. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a brief summary of the item to Council. ZZ & ZZ, LLC is petitioning to rezone approximately eleven and ninety-three hundredths (11.93) acres located at 1114, 1126 & 1168 Old Graves Mill Road from R-2, Low-Medium Density Residential District to R-4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional). The rezoning would allow the construction of one hundred sixty -nine (169) apartments, twenty-nine (29) condominiums, office, club house, pool, and two hundred sixty -two (262) parking spaces. On October 12, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (3-1, with 2 members absent, Light and Bowden, and 1 vacancy) of the FLUM amendment and of the rezoning petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the petitions with the addition of proffers. Ms. Amy Seipp of Accupoint Surveying & Design, representing the applicant, addressed Council. Mr. Jason Brown of ZZ & ZZ, LLC stated that the proposal allowed for home ownership pathways to residents. Mr. Carl Hultgren, Traffic Engineer with Gorove Slade, presented the traffic study for the project to Council. Ms. Katrina Fields stated she was a resident of Coffey Road in Lynchburg City, and stated she was speaking in support of the project due to its creation of affordable housing and homeownership opportunities. Mr. Ted Hein stated that he was a resident of Lynchburg City and on the Board of Directors of the Lynchburg Humane Society, which was located across the street from the proposed development. He stated his support of the project due to residents being of great help to the Humane Society. Mr. Tim Sylvester stated that he was a resident of Lynchburg and retired surgeon who had practiced in Lynchburg for almost 40 years. He stated his support of the project due to its creation of different housing types in the City. Mr. Caleb Hill stated that he was a resident of Lynchburg and current student at Central Virginia Community College. He stated his support of the project for its creation of affordable housing and homeownership opportunities. Ms. Debbie Sebring stated that she was a resident of Ward IV in Lynchburg. She stated her support of the project due to its creation of different housing types in the City. Page 90 of 172 December 13, 2022 12 Mr. Steve Clevenger stated that he was a resident of Lynchburg and minister at the Seven Hills Church of Christ at 810 Old Graves Mill Road. He stated his support of the project due to its creation of affordable housing and homeownership opportunities, beautification of the area, and revenue for the City. Ms. Lakeisha Anderson stated her support of the project due to its creation of affordable housing and homeownership opportunities in the City. Ms. Alicia L. Finney, Clerk of Council, read three email correspondences into the record in opposition of the petition from the following citizens: Brian Zubroski, Brian Summers, and Rachel Mullins. She read a form email previously sent in from the following citizens, in opposition of the petition: Dan Johnson, Glenda Frye, Jennifer Tanner, Kathy Germeroth, Lynn Wayne Seipp, Sona Seipp, Keith Ballengee, Melinda Tennis, Michelle and Tim Osborne, Ben Kahle, Ashley Jones, Claudia Starkovich, and Greg and Darlene Marsh. Ms. Finney read into the record a letter supporting the project signed by the following citizens: Katrina Fields, Mary Brown, Paul Brown, Edward Hunt, Timothy Sylvester, Michael Voth, David Abdshah, Thomas Greene, Cary Tromby, John Buckles, Daniel Rhodes, Steven Powell, Hugh Parnell, Matt Meyers, and Steve Clevenger. Mayor Dolan asked if the applicant had a rebuttal. Mr. Brown stated that the traffic st udy indicated the true minimal impact of the project on traffic, and the development would improve the road and make it safer. Ms. Seipp stated that buffers for the parcel would be addressed at the site planning stage, and the intent was to provide a bus stop when service allowed it in the future, as well as stormwater management that enhanced the environment and walking trails available to the public. Mayor Dolan closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to deny the petition. Councilmember Faraldi stated that Council must have a discussion about the lack of available housing in Lynchburg, and the placement of housing was key. He stated that he did not support the resolu tion because of the overdevelopment of the area. Councilmember Helgeson stated that he did not support the resolution because it was the wrong location for this type of development. Page 91 of 172 December 13, 2022 13 Vice Mayor Wright stated that he was supportive of the project, so he would be voting against the motion on the floor. He stated that his concerns about the project’s impact to the watershed and traffic had been allayed, and that the type and density of housing was appropriate for the area. Councilmember Tweedy stated that she would be opposing the motion. Councilmember Wilder stated that he would be opposing the motion and was supportive of the project because of its creation of affordable housing and the homeownership program. He stated that the traffic issues were addressed in the traffic study. Mayor Dolan stated that she would be opposing the motion and supported the project because it fit within the neighborhood and offered homeownership. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he would amend his motion to extend the public hearin g until January. Councilmember Tweedy stated that it was integral for the community to support a diversity of housing and to allow for larger density because of the growing City. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 Noes: Tweedy, Dolan, Wright, Wilder 4 Councilmember Tweedy motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, to approve the Resolution #R-22-077 and Ordinance #O-22-078. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Tweedy, Dolan, Wright, Wilder 4 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 // In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item 9, a public hearing was held and Council conducted its first reading of Resolution #R-22-079 amending the FY 2023 Sewer Capital Projects Fund budget and appropriating $25,000,000 American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Grant to reimburse costs associated with combined sewer overflow projects. Mr. Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources, gave a brief summary to Council. The City of Lynchburg has been awarded a grant totaling $25,000,000 by the Virginia General Assembly's appropriation of ARPA funding to DEQ for costs directly associated with CSO projects which Page 92 of 172 December 13, 2022 14 are mandated by the State Water Control Board Enforcement Action–Consent Special order issued July 31, 2015. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Vice Mayor Wright motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt the resolution. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item 10, Citizen Zandrea Herbert who previously signed up to speak was not in attendance at the meeting. // In the matter of Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority, Agenda Item 11, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-22-080 authorizing the designation of the Dearington Hills Apartments as a Revitalization Area. City Council was previously briefed on this item during the December 8, 2022 work session. The Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) are working to submit a 2022 Tax Credit Application. Mary Mayrose, Executive Director of LRHA, has requested that City Council acknowledge by resolution that the area of Dearington Hills is a Revitalization Area as evidenced by the City's Comprehensive Plan. Councilmember Tweedy motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, t o adopt the Resolution #R-22-080. Councilmember Tweedy stated she was glad to support the project and to have served on the Housing Authority Board to be a part of the development process. Councilmember Wilder stated that the project was approved after much community input and would address the need for income-based housing in the City. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Fire Department, Agenda Item 12, Council conducted its first reading of Resolution #R-22-081 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $76,000 from Page 93 of 172 December 13, 2022 15 the 2022 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant to fund equipment for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. Fire Chief Gregory Wormser gave a brief summary of the item to Council. The resolution is to amend the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $76,000 with resources of $76,000 from the 2022 SHSP from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund equipment for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. The funds will be used for the purchase of PPE (Personal Protective Equipment), USAR (Urban Search & Rescue) bags, water rescue equipment and specialized rescue equipment for heavy lifting, debris removal and large animal rescue. The majority of this equipment is replacing existing equipment that has exceeded its useful life, but there are a few items that are being added to enhance our rescue capabilities. This equipment can be used in a variety of ways, such as stabilization of a structure that is in danger of collapse, stabilizing a vehicle after a crash or clearing debris from a trench. This equipment is vital to the successful mitigation of a variety of incident types and ensures not only the prolonged safety of our citizens, but also the immediate safety of our responders. In addition, this grant request will also include training that will enhance the knowledge and skills of our Technical Rescue Team members when confronted with patients that are victims of a U SAR related incident. The grant is 100% reimbursable; no local match is required. At its December 13, 2022 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion, stating that the language was vague, but it allowed for the use of funds for this purpose. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item 13, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-22-082 approving the City of Lynchburg’s 2023 Legislative Agenda. Council was previously briefed on this item at the December 14, 2022 work session. Mr. Wynter C. Benda, City Manager, gave a brief summary of the item to Council. Each year, the City Manager works with the City department heads, City appointees, Constitutional Officers and their staff and others on what topics, focus areas and/or potential bills/resolutions are important to the City of Lynchburg that will first be presented to City Council and later Page 94 of 172 December 13, 2022 16 adopted by them as the City’s “legislative package” so as to position it well for the impending Virginia General Assembly Session. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the language regarding Roanoke’s legislative initiatives could be included in the legislative agenda. Mr. Benda stated that it was not currently included but could be added. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he was comfortable with that and would rather not vote on something without seeing it. Mr. Benda stated that he would like to have something to work with before the General Assembly session began on January 11, 2023. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Faraldi 1 // The meeting adjourned at 9:42 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 95 of 172 City Council Agenda Item III.2. Consent Agenda AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY January 23, 2024 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council AGENDA ITEM # III.2 Consideration of approving the minutes from the December 12, 2023 meeting. RECOMMENDATION Approve the minutes from the December 12, 2023 meeting. SUMMARY N/A PRIOR ACTION(S) N/A FISCAL IMPACT N/A CONTACT(S) Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council ATTACHMENT(S) 1. December 12, 2023 REVIEWED BY Date: January 18, 2024 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 96 of 172 December 12, 2023 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 12th day of December 2023, at 4:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie Reed, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jeff Helgeson, Jerry Taylor, MaryJane Dolan, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // City Manager Wynter Benda provided an overview of the work session agenda to City Council. He asked Assistant City Manager Mr. Kent White to provide clarification regarding the monitoring of methane gas in Jefferson Park. Mr. White explained that the issue arose from an awful time in the City’s history when the City closed Jefferson Park community pool and turned the park itself into a City dump. The methane gas is the result of the natural decomposition of the materials currently in Jefferson Park. The City has been monitoring this on and off for over a decade, and as recently as last year they consulted with a firm called TRC to continue that monitoring. The gas ranges were determined to be well within the state health and safety guidelines, so there was no threat to the public. TRC would monitor it again next year, and then in two-year increments moving forward. This was meant to assure the public and Council that the situation with the gas was not changing or transitioning. He said that the subject had been raised at Dearington neighborhood planning meetings and when discussing the improvements to Jefferson Park that had been approved by Council. The construction of that work was due to begin next year and would not impact the fill area and would not make the methane gas situation any worse. The contractors also will be well-briefed on the fact of that in advance. Councilmember Dolan asked if this situation was on a monitoring schedule and was being routinely monitored. Mr. White answered yes, they did it intensively while doing erosion control and stormwater repair work from 2014 through 2017, and then at the behest of Council, they began doing it again last year and would continue every two years moving forward. Page 97 of 172 December 12, 2023 2 // In the matter of Finance, Agenda Item #1, Council received a presentation of the FY 2023 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) and related reports. Chief Financial Officer Donna Witt provided a summary of the item to Council. Chris Banta, leader of the state and local government practice of the City’s external auditing firm, Brown Edwards, LLC, presented the results of the annual audit to City Council. The following reports are attached for reference: •FY 2023 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report •Audit Committee Letter (ACL) – Required Communication with those Charged with Governance - City of Lynchburg •Management Letter (ML) – City of Lynchburg •Audit Committee Letter (ACL) – Required Communication with those Charged with Governance – Lynchburg City Schools •Management Letter (ML) – Lynchburg City Schools •Independent Auditor’s Report on Applying Agreed–Upon Procedures – City of Lynchburg’s Sheriff’s Office •Independent Auditor’s Report on Census Data submitted to the Virginia Retirement System-City of Lynchburg // In the matter of Public Safety, Agenda Item #2, Council received information regarding a Public Safety Recruitment and Retention Plan. Diversity, Equity, & Inclusion Strategist Dr. Hollie Jennings provided a summary of the item to Council. Public safety continues to be a top priority for the City of Lynchburg and City Council. Nationally, police officer resignations and retirements have spiked over the past three years. The Police Executive Research Forum (PERF) reported that nationally there were 47% more sworn officer resignations in 2022 than in 2019. In Lynchburg, the number of resignations did not significantly increase between 2019 and 2023. However, the police department currently has 30 sworn officer vacancies. These vacancies are placing a significant strain on our police officers and police department. The Department of Page 98 of 172 December 12, 2023 3 Emergency Services has a similar strain on staffing, with 14 vacancies for public safety communications specialists. The national shortage of police officers will require the City of Lynchburg to implement a strategic and creative approach to attracting and retaining the best officers for our city. The comprehensive plan to recruit and retain highly qualified police officers has a four- pronged approach: increase employee satisfaction, implement procedural changes to hiring, expand recruitment outreach, and develop meaningful compensation strategies. This plan can be replicated in any of our public safety departments based on the number of vacancies the department is facing. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if six months was the proper time to gauge if someone would be staying, considering the fact that it may take a year for people to get into other agencies and organizations. Dr. Jennings replied that they chose six months because they wanted to know what the immediate outlook would be in regard to staffing. New officers were under contract for the training they went through, so they would likely stay at least three years. This initiative was targeted more toward those that had been here for a while, and they wanted to know how many people planned to stay or leave over the next six months. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked what discussions arose regarding procedures that limited the ability for police officers to serve. Dr. Jennings answered that there had been feedback from officers currently serving in Lynchburg regarding current policies, and that was part of what the committee would be providing feedback on. The procedural changes in this initiative focused on the hiring process, and the question she received during that discussion was about making sure they were not lowering standards or expectations, which was certainly not being done; it was more about how the required processes could be made easier for people to complete, especially if they were recruiting out of state. Vice Mayor Faraldi said that anything they could do to make the police officers’ jobs easier to do was beneficial and should be undertaken in order to achieve their goal of making Page 99 of 172 December 12, 2023 4 Lynchburg Police Department the number one choice for law enforcement professionals in Virginia. Councilmember Helgeson suggested utilizing the exit interviews of those individuals they were unable to retain in order to better comprehend why people choose to leave the department. Councilmember Misjuns asked if there was an option for someone upon retirement to continue paying into the group at a lesser rate than the commercial market. Dr. Jennings clarified that City employees, upon retirement, could keep their health insurance by paying their portion of the City portion, which would be much lower than the commercial rates. They continued to explore other options that may be able to be provided. Councilmember Misjuns asked if the cost was known. Dr. Jennings answered that it depended on whether it was an individual plan or if it was family insurance. She clarified that Ms. Witt had communicated that it was $8,000 per year. Councilmember Misjuns said that any options that made it easier for first responders to get health insurance without it becoming a burden to the taxpayers should be considered. He asked how accrued sick leave for employees was budgeted. Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt said that employees could accrue eight hours of sick leave per month and carry up to 968 hours, but employees were not paid for those upon their departure. Councilmember Misjuns asked how that was budgeted compared to annual leave. Ms. Witt said that it was based on accrual, so they looked at entries at the end of the year based on the value of it, and did not carry that cost because they did not pay it out when employees left. It also looked different when considering hybrid employees who may have short-term disability. Councilmember Misjuns asked if retention and new hiring bonuses were designed in a way so that it was a lump sum or if there was a way to separate it out. Dr. Jennings said that they would continue to explore options for retention bonuses, but it was known to be more attractive to give the bonus as a lump sum. Ms. Witt noted that there was about $3.5 million budgeted annually Page 100 of 172 December 12, 2023 5 for retirees, or those employees who had retired and were still receiving benefits because they were hired prior to June 30, 1996. Councilmember Wilder asked if staff’s analysis included studying other peer localities such as Roanoke or other urban areas. Dr. Jennings said those areas were looked at when analyzing bonuses, and currently their northern neighbors were offering a $20,000 bonus, the western neighbors increased theirs to $7,000 in 2021, southern neighbors offered $5,000, and east toward Richmond was a $10,000 recruitment bonus plus a longevity bonus. She said that she was unaware if any other areas had done a similar type of survey or marketing strategy in this area. She said that she also looked into how many localities were still offering health insurance upon retirement, and it was very few in the state that still did this, with the only one in their region being Salem. Councilmember Wilder asked what the main concerns were of those people leaving the force. Dr. Jennings said that the main concerns seen throughout the survey were the vacancies, workload, and number of hours that employees had to work. Councilmember Wilder asked if survey respondents felt that management supported them well. Dr. Jennings said that there were 296 comments in the survey, and one person could comment up to three different times throughout the survey. Less than 1% of those comments were any type of complaint around command staff or the Chief, so the majority of folks felt supported and wanted to stay with LPD. Councilmember Wilder asked if there was a cadet program for the City of Lynchburg to facilitate training prior to joining the police force. Dr. Jennings answered that there was a P&R team of police officers that handled recruitment-type initiatives, and they went to City schools, including the criminal justice program, to engage the youth of the City around what was happening at LPD and encourage joining the police force after graduation. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the $3.5M budgeted for retiree health insurance was used each year. Ms. Witt answered that the majority of it was used to cover claims, and any excess at the end of the year was written back. Page 101 of 172 December 12, 2023 6 // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #3, Council was briefed on the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program – Public Hearing and Adoption of a Resolution Regarding Housing and Non-Housing Goals for the Fiscal Year 2025 (Program Year 2024) Annual Action Plan. This item will appear for City Council vote on the January 9, 2024 Public Hearing agenda. Grants Manager Ms. Melva Walker provided a summary of the item to Council. The Consolidated Plan for the CDBG and HOME Program was approved in June 2020 and covers the period from July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2025. This plan outlines the City’s needs, goals, and objectives for community development (both housing and non-housing areas). HUD requires Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program entitlement communities to review the goals in the Plan on an annual basis. City Council will be seeking the input of citizens and other interested parties regarding the approved goals at the public hearing. A 15-day public comment period to receive citizen input regarding the goals will be initiated on December 22, 2023 through a legal notice published in The News and Advance. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #4, Council was briefed on the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for West Lynchburg Baptist Church Preschool at 3031 Memorial Avenue. This item will appear for City Council vote on the January 9, 2024 Public Hearing agenda. Senior Planner Rachel Frischeisen provided a summary of the item to Council. West Lynchburg Baptist Church is petitioning for a CUP at 3031 Memorial Avenue to allow the use of a portion of the existing church as a childcare facility/preschool in an R-3, Medium Density Residential District. These facilities are permitted in this zoning district upon approval of a CUP by City Council. The Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends an Institutional use for the subject property. The City’s institutions include the religious, educational, and other nonprofit entities in the City. The petitioner has indicated that the facility would be operated by the YMCA of Central Virginia. The impact of the facility within the existing church should be minimal. Staff recommended the approval of this item to the Planning Commission, Page 102 of 172 December 12, 2023 7 which would hold a public hearing on December 13, 2023 and make a recommendation, and City Council will hold a public hearing on January 9, 2024. // In the matter of the Registrar’s Office, Agenda Item #5, Council was briefed on the relocation of a polling place for the Second Ward, Fourth Precinct. This item will appear before City Council for action on January 9, 2024. Chair of the Electoral Board David Neumeyer and Registrar Dan Pense provided a summary of the item to Council. The Electoral Board for the City of Lynchburg, Virginia (Electoral Board) voted at its meeting on December 7, 2023, to transfer the Fairview Heights precinct 204 polling place to Bass Elementary School. The new polling place would be located outside the precinct, but within one mile of the precinct boundary as required by Section 24.2-310 of the Code of Virginia. The reason for the request is that the current polling place, Fairview Christian Church, has several access barriers for the disabled, including a flight of stairs from the most-used parking area on Leyburn Street to the polling place entrance, an off-street parking lot on Sackett Street that, for the handicapped, has a difficult slope, and an entryway threshold that is approximately 3" above the approaching sidewalk. The Electoral Board would like to make use of Bass Elementary School for the Fourth Precinct of the Second Ward starting with the expected March 2024 Republican Primary Election and continuing through all subsequent elections for the indefinite future. A public hearing concerning the proposed change will be held before the Lynchburg City Council on January 9, 2024. Councilmember Helgeson asked how far the polling precinct was located outside of the boundary district. Mr. Pense said that it was about 350 feet, and the polling precinct was required to be within one mile of the precinct boundary line. Vice Mayor Faraldi said that while there were no outstanding issues with this proposed change in polling precinct location, he would like to avoid having polling precincts located outside of the boundaries in the future. Page 103 of 172 December 12, 2023 8 Councilmember Dolan asked if they had considered any locations within the precinct. Mr. Neumeyer answered that they had reviewed other potential locations, but they were unable to secure them for Election Day. Councilmember Wilder asked what the time period was for notifying voters in the area of the precinct change. Mr. Pense replied that it somewhat depended on action of the Attorney General, who had to approve the decision of City Council. He said that they must promptly correspond with the Attorney General and notify the Council of that response in order for things to be ready for March. Mayor Reed said that she agreed that this was the best option available for the polling precinct, so she was in support of staff’s recommendation. // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Wilder said he would like to thank and commend all the men who grew mustaches for the month to support Mustaches 4 Kids, which raised over $570,000. He said that he appreciated everyone on the team who worked so hard for the children in the community, who showed the spirit of giving and how much better they were when they all worked together. He said that he wanted to express his appreciation of their work. Councilmember Helgeson said that regarding recreation and tourism and generating tax revenue, a couple of days ago, last Saturday afternoon, they had lots of activity in Lynchburg. The state football championships were at Liberty, Liberty also hosted a big meet for track, they had a basketball game that brought in Grand Canyon, who just beat the semi-finalist from last year, San Diego State, in the NCAA tournament. They had hundreds of Grand Canyon people, family, friends, alumni, and students, who all came into Lynchburg. There were lots of flights, which helped with per-flight tax. Looking at the hotels, rooms, meals, all the lines inside for the concessions were very long and were subject to meals tax. He talked to several people from Grand Canyon, which is Phoenix, and they came, and it was neat and refreshing. As that happened, he wondered how much people had to pay for that as a City taxpayer, and the answer was nothing. All they had to do was say thank you. All they had to do was allow Liberty, Page 104 of 172 December 12, 2023 9 like they did several years ago when they gave them their property rights back so they could build and expand. It is so nice to see that the generation of all these taxes, whether it be the airport, property, meals tax, cars, all the rental cars that were there, the hotels, all those things for a basketball game. There were 20 basketball games per year, so it was neat. He expressed his thanks for them and noted it was a barn-burner of a game. It was sold out at 2 p.m. and had a raucous crowd with great revenues, so it was fantastic for the City. Councilmember Misjuns said that he wanted to make sure they were stressing to City employees, which he thought they would discuss the next time the City Manager and he had a one-on-one, was their rights under whistleblower protection laws and making sure that it is clear to them that they had a right to come to elected officials with things to blow the whistle, so to speak. That was one of the things he wanted to bring up and discuss one-on-one. Over the weekend, there was a call for the execution of Councilmember Misjuns, Councilmember Helgeson, their Congressman, and several other folks aligned with them. They did not need to be doing that as a community. One thing that was also interesting to him was, as an elected official in Lynchburg, why were they not notified of that by their police department, because someone else called it in. He said that stuff needs to stop. It had gone a little bit too far, and death threats are just not okay. Vice Mayor Faraldi congratulated the Bulldogs, the Liberty Christian High School’s football team, for winning their first state championship. He thanked City staff for engaging with him. He said that there were a lot of things to focus on, and one of which was leaf collection and frustration around the scheduling. He thanked the staff for amending it to some degree in some of the problem areas that constituents had highlighted during the last week and a half. One item he wanted them to consider was what Senator Newman offered at their legislative dinner with the potential policy changes and items that may come down the pipe from Richmond. It might be worth doing something they have not done in the past, and if there are legislative matters that really could impact Lynchburg, whether it was per-pupil funding, Smart Scale applications, or the other things Senator Newman mentioned, to have those come to Council for taking an official stance Page 105 of 172 December 12, 2023 10 on so they could say that it would really affect Lynchburg in a positive or negative way and whether they supported or opposed it. He did not intend for City Council to get into state business, but for those major items that will dramatically impact how they do business, he believed it was something they should at least consider. If Council said no, they did not want to engage with that as it was Richmond’s final decision, he would take that loss, but he thought it was something they should consider for those major items that their delegation could use the extra backup on. He said that in closing, he would also agree that a lot of things had gone too far, to use Councilmember Misjuns’ term, and to the degree of going after someone’s work history on both sides of this topic, whether they used to work for the City and are now suing them, or if they used to work for the state and are now a realtor, or if their husband is a retired colonel from the air force and served this nation admirably, it was not appropriate in any of those topics for them to use that as political capital to go after each other. He said that he wanted to make that clear. Mayor Reed congratulated the Bulldogs on their game, which she attended and thought was amazing. It had been an impressive and really cool football season for their City, and she was super proud. Even for those who were not fans of Liberty or LCA, it was really great for their City to have those two victories, and she was very proud. They have to support great athleticism, so those who enjoyed football and athletics had gotten to see some good, hardworking players, along with great coaching. She said that tonight, they would be highlighting the division of Juvenile Services. The division of Juvenile Services is part of the Lynchburg Department of Human Services and is comprised of the Lynchburg Youth Group Home and the Lynchburg Regional Juvenile Detention Center. The group home provides crisis stabilization through its shelter care services, as well as a longer-term program for youth requiring more structure. This facility provides services to youth from the City of Lynchburg, the Counties of Amherst, Bedford, Campbell, and Nelson, as well as other social services agencies throughout the state. In addition to meeting the basic needs of each youth, residents also engage in educational, employment, therapeutic, community service, and daily and/or weekly Page 106 of 172 December 12, 2023 11 groups and activities in the community. The detention center provides supervision of up to 48 youth awaiting education or disposition for a delinquent offense, serving time ordered by the court, or youth participating in the post-disposition program. The facility ensures the basic needs of residents are met and provides educational, recreational, and health opportunities designed to promote positive change within each youth in the hopes that they are able to transition back into the community as a more productive member of society. From January to November of 2023, 215 residents were admitted to the group home and 245 to the detention center. The facilities worked closely together with a goal to actively avoid re-traumatization and address the individual needs of each resident, and promote positive change within each youth they encounter. She thanked all those who work and serve at the Juvenile Services centers. She said that the Central Virginia United Soccer Club (CVU) was pleased to sponsor the 2023 United We Give collaborative giveback community event on Saturday, December 16, 2023 at the Lynchburg City Stadium. CVU representatives will be collecting food, toys, coats, pajamas, and sporting equipment for delivery to various local charities. This event will be conducted between 10 a.m. and 4 p.m., during which there will be open soccer sessions, free food items, and free activities for local youth. Activities conclude with a 2 p.m. charity soccer match between CVU coaches and players. CVU will donate the proceeds raised for each goal scored to Miriam’s House. Sporting goods received will be given to Challenge Sports Exchange, food will go to LYH Food Not Bombs, coats and clothing to the Salvation Army of Lynchburg, toys to the Parkview Mission, and pajamas to the Bedtime Pajama Drive. As stated, Miriam’s House will receive the funds raised from the charity soccer match. Central Virginia United especially thanks the Lynchburg Parks and Recreation Department for assisting CVU in this public-private initiative to benefit their fellow citizens. // Council considered a closed session to discuss appointments for vacancies to the Community Development Advisory Committee and Horizon Behavioral Health Board of Directors, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. Page 107 of 172 December 12, 2023 12 Mayor Reed noted that the first closed session was struck from the agenda and would not be considered at this time. Councilmember Dolan made a motion to go into a closed meeting, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and with no further discussion, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wilder, Dolan, Helgeson, Reed, Faraldi, Taylor, Misjuns 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Misjuns made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Wilder, Dolan, Reed, Faraldi, Taylor, Misjuns 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Helgeson 1 Page 108 of 172 December 12, 2023 13 // On motion of Councilmember Misjuns, seconded by Vice Mayor Faraldi, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Community Development Advisory Committee: Councilmember Larry Taylor, as Chair, for a new 1-year term expiring December 31, 2024; Mayor Stephanie Reed, as Vice Chair, for a new 1-year term expiring December 31, 2024; Sandra Mitchell for a new 1-year term expiring December 31, 2024; Sally Schneider for a new 1-year term expiring December 31, 2024; Dr. Brenda Farmer for a new 1-year term expiring December 31, 2024; Kay Reid for a new 1-year term expiring December 31, 2024; and Lana Musgrave for a new 1-year term expiring December 31, 2024. Ayes: Wilder, Dolan, Reed, Faraldi, Taylor, Misjuns 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Helgeson 1 // On motion of Councilmember Misjuns, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Horizon Behavioral Health Board of Directors: Councilmember Chris Faraldi for a new 3-year term expiring December 31, 2026. Vice Mayor Faraldi stated he would abstain from the vote to avoid a conflict of interest by voting for himself. Ayes: Wilder, Dolan, Reed, Taylor, Misjuns 5 Noes: 0 Abstain: Faraldi 1 Absent: Helgeson 1 // The meeting recessed at 5:39 p.m. Page 109 of 172 December 12, 2023 14 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 12th day of December, 2023, at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jeff Helgeson, Larry Taylor, MaryJane Dolan, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // Councilmember Wilder led the invocation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Agenda Item #1, Mayor Reed recognized the 2023 Liberty University Undefeated Football Team and Coaches. She noted that the Liberty Flames were the first FBS team in Virginia to post a 12-0 season. She invited Liberty President Dr. Dondi Costin, Head Coach Jamey Chadwell, Assistant Athletic Director Brad Queen, and Director of Government and Community Relations Kenny Craig to the dais to be recognized. // In the matter of Recognitions, Agenda Item #2, Mayor Reed recognized Emily Asbury of the Mayor's Youth Council who was in attendance. // In the matter of the Agenda, Councilmember Taylor requested to amend the agenda to include Ed McCann, Kiwanis Club, under Public Comment. Mayor Reed noted that there was consensus from Council to amend the agenda. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Councilmember Dolan motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to approve the Consent Agenda. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Faraldi, Helgeson, Misjuns, Reed, Taylor, Wilder 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #9, Council held a public hearing in consideration of adopting Resolution #R-23-104 granting a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to allow the use of an existing structure at 805 15th Street as a childcare facility. Senior Planner Rachel Frischeisen provided Council with a summary of the request. Diamond Hill Baptist Church is petitioning for a Page 110 of 172 December 12, 2023 15 CUP at 805 15th Street to allow the use of an existing structure as a childcare center in an R-2, Low-Medium Density Residential District. Childcare facilities are permitted in this zoning district upon approval of a CUP by City Council. The Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends a Traditional Residential use for the subject property. Public and private institutional uses are appropriate in these areas when they are designed to blend into the existing urban fabric. The petition is supported by the Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan draft. During the neighborhood planning process, stakeholders and residents have expressed strong support for the expansion of early childhood care and education opportunities. With ample parking in the adjacent Diamond Hill Baptist Church parking area, the impact of the childcare center should be minimal. Owen Cardwell, pastor of Diamond Hill Baptist Church and representing the petitioner, provided a statement in support of the request. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to adopt the Resolution #R-23-104. Councilmember Dolan disclosed that she served on the board of LynCAG, however, she was able to act impartially on the motion as she did not benefit personally. Vice Mayor Faraldi disclosed that he served on the board of LynCAG via proxy, but he did not have a conflict of interest. Councilmember Misjuns said that the resolution would help address the need for childcare in the City. Councilmember Helgeson said that the proposal was a good use of property. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Faraldi, Helgeson, Misjuns, Reed, Taylor, Wilder 7 Noes: 0 Page 111 of 172 December 12, 2023 16 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #10, Council held a public hearing in consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-23-105 to change a certain area located at 602 Taylor Street & 1212 Park Avenue from B-4, Urban Commercial to B-5, General Business District. Senior Planner Rachel Frischeisen provided a summary of the request. Mr. Hunter Dawson is petitioning to rezone 602 Taylor Street and 1212 Park Avenue from B-4, Urban Commercial to B-5, General Business District to allow the use of the properties for used automobile sales. The properties are included in the area covered by the Fifth Street Corridor Master Plan adopted by City Council on May 23, 2006. The Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 FLUM recommends a Neighborhood Commercial land use for the properties fronting 5th Street & Park Avenue. These areas are intended to consist primarily of office, retail, personal service, and restaurant uses that are scaled and designed to be compatible with and serve their immediate neighborhood. Planning Commission recommended denial of the petition, citing concerns of setting precedence for auto- oriented uses which negatively impacted 5th Street and the adjoining neighborhoods in the past. The proposed rezoning does not align with the recommendations of the FLUM, Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030, and the 5th Street Corridor Master Plan. Amy Igarta-Seipp, Accupoint Surveying and Design, and Hunter Dawson, property owner, provided a presentation of the request for the petitioner. Ernesto Santos, speaking in favor, said he lived near the proposed development and was comfortable with the location. Wesley Woods, speaking in opposition, said that he owned several neighboring properties that he planned to redevelop. He said that he believed a used car lot was not appropriate for the neighborhood. There were no phone calls, voicemails, or emails, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Faraldi, to adopt the Ordinance #O-23-105. Page 112 of 172 December 12, 2023 17 Councilmember Helgeson said that the proposal would meet a need in the community and allow the petitioner to pursue the American Dream. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked why the Planning Commission recommended denial of the proposal. Ms. Frischeisen replied that the Commission felt the B5 zoning was not conducive to the redevelopment that the neighborhood wanted to see on 5th Street. She said that they felt the uses permitted in B5 were not appropriate for the area. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if a CUP would be appropriate to address concerns regarding future uses. Ms. Frischeisen replied that a CUP was not an option in a B4 district for auto sales. She stated the Commission recognized that rezoning the site would potentially set the stage for similar rezonings, which did not align with the vision for the 5th Street corridor. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked whether staff or other developers had expressed interest in developing the property. Vice Mayor Faraldi said that the Council should approve the resolution because it would provide business and revitalization opportunities for the corridor. Mayor Reed asked whether there had been conversations with community members and residents in the neighborhood regarding the project. Ms. Frischeisen replied that the community feedback was reviewed from the public outreach in the 2006 vision plan. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Faraldi, Helgeson, Misjuns, Reed, Taylor, Wilder 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #11, Citizen Cherie Kemper addressed Council regarding building a teen social lounge. She stated that teens needed places to go and hang out after school or on the weekends that were dedicated for teens. She said that when she graduated from EC Glass, there were more things for teenagers to do then there were now. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #12, Citizen Christopher White was not present. Page 113 of 172 December 12, 2023 18 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #13, Citizen Vicente Gonzalez, representing Latin American Community Center, addressed Council regarding the School Board. He said that opening the Council meeting with a prayer violated the Constitution and served no business purpose. He stated that regarding the rejection of a $10 thousand grant from the It Gets Better campaign, there was misinformation being spread by elected and appointed City officials. He explained that the It Gets Better campaign was a suicide prevention campaign. He explained that Councilmember Misjuns claimed the campaign promoted porn literacy and group masturbation, which was a lie, and students would not be required to watch videos to enter into the space. He noted the myriad concerns about accepting a grant from a suicide prevention organization, but there were no concerns about associating with Liberty University, which had been investigated by the US Department of Education for systemic cover-ups of rape and sexual assault. He said that the letter to the City Attorney from Councilmember Misjuns regarding sexually charged and adult themed performances mirrored language in anti-Drag performance legislation, and he questioned how terms such as "sexually charged", "adult themed", "vice", or "immorality" would be defined. He said that such restrictions were violations of Free Speech. He urged Council to reject such an ordinance. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #14, Citizen Kelsey Molseed addressed Council regarding the conduct of Councilmember Misjuns. She stated that Councilmember Misjuns replied to comments on his social media by using his family to hide and deflect from criticism. She said that members of the public would continue to demand Councilmember Misjuns' expulsion from Council so long as he continued to levy accusations against members of the public. She said community members had expressed fears over retaliation from Councilmember Misjuns, as he kept a list of names of people who complained against him. She requested Council to expel Councilmember Misjuns. Page 114 of 172 December 12, 2023 19 // // In the matter of Public Comment, Item Not on the Agenda, Citizen Ed McCann, representing the Centennial Committee of the Kiwanis Club of Lynchburg, spoke in support of fully funding the Riverfront Park Improvements project. // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #15, Council considered introducing Resolution #R-23- 106 amending the FY 2024–2028 Capital Improvement Program and the FY 2024 City Capital Projects Fund budget and appropriating $3,000,000 in funds from the FY 2024 General Fund Unassigned Fund Balance to be used for Riverfront Park Improvements (Amphitheater). The creation of Riverfront Park was one of the key components of the Downtown and Riverfront Master Plan 2000. In FY 2023, City Council approved funding to complete improvements to the park with the goals of: • Build a destination amphitheater capable of hosting national touring acts • Install a fence and gate system to designate event areas and allow passive use between events • Build permanent public restrooms. • Partner with the Kiwanis to build a new playground next to the splash pad • Include additional shade canopy and landscaping • Upgrade stormwater, sewer and rain garden capacity The project was put out for bid on May 19, 2023 with a bid opening on July 13, 2023. Although the last estimate of cost (July 2022) was approximately $4.6 million dollars (+/- 6% of budget), the low bid came in at $7,998,000 from Jamerson-Lewis, which is significantly over budget. The project timing has been impacted by this effort as well, the contractor indicated that the steel components for the amphitheater will take a much longer lead time than originally anticipated. The project construction time will extend from an estimated 420 calendar days to 630 calendar days for completion in July 2025. Project Impact Page 115 of 172 December 12, 2023 20 Riverfront Park will be better positioned to drive visitor traffic through large-scale special events, festivals, movies and performances. On average there are approximately 16 local events per year at Riverfront Park varying from small community engagement events to music and food festivals. In 2022, local events in Riverfront Park generated 16,960 visits. The attendance capacity of the venue is approximately 3,500, up to 5,000. We expect an additional 10-20 nationally programmed performances per year in the new amphitheater within the first three years of operation. Based on actual visits to nationally performing artist events in Riverfront Park in recent years, we estimate that 20 additional nights of programming would conservatively drive nearly 75,000 visitors per year, a 330% increase in utilization of the Park. More than 90% of the foot traffic to Riverfront Park is for one-time events, meaning visitors are already using the park as a destination. Driving more visitors to the destination, will increase direct spending in restaurants, retail, transportation, lodging, and more associated with event attendance, across the City. Councilmember Dolan motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt the Resolution #R-23-106. Councilmember Dolan said that the resolution served as an opportunity to continue investment in the City, support local businesses and residents, and increase tourism. Councilmember Wilder stated that the downtown area was vital for a healthy community, as it served as the center of activity. He said that economic development was important to the revitalization of the downtown. He said that he supported continued investment in the City. Councilmember Helgeson expressed concerns about the increased cost of the project, and he suggested that the funding could be used to reduce taxes for residents. He said that they should move forward with the park aspect of the project and re-distribute the funds for the amphitheater to lower the car tax. Page 116 of 172 December 12, 2023 21 Councilmember Helgeson made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, to deny the $8 million request, lower the car taxes by $0.15, and direct staff to find ways to lower the tax burden while funding the Kiwanis Park project. Councilmember Helgeson said that since the budget process was approaching, staff would have a chance to reconsider the funding and find a way to alleviate the car tax burden. Councilmember Misjuns said that he received 80 emails from citizens that he separated into folders, and some requested relief on the car tax bill. He said that he would support the construction of a park. He said that the proposal from Councilmember Helgeson would free up funding that could be used to pay down debt. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked for clarification as to whether they can do what Councilmember Helgeson proposed. Chief Financial Officer Donna Witt explained that there could not be a direct correlation between reducing the taxes based on reducing debt service. She explained that the debt service was based on bond offerings that had already been completed, so the debt schedule was already set. She said that there was no way to reduce debt service in the FY25 budget. She explained that the project was cash funded, so there was no debt service to reduce. She said that if the $8 million was allocated to a different project so that it would not use debt service, then it would reduce the debt service for that specific project, but it would not reduce the overall debt service because they would have to issue bonds for mandatory projects. She said that they could not reduce debt service because it was set at previous borrowings for FY24 and FY25. Vice Mayor Faraldi clarified that the debt service had already been issued. Ms. Witt said that was correct. Vice Mayor Faraldi clarified that if Council wanted to reduce the tax rate, it had to be addressed at the beginning of the fiscal year. Ms. Witt said that it would have to be addressed during the budget process, and Council would have to find a way to replace the recurring revenue from personal property taxes. Vice Mayor Faraldi said that he agreed with the desire to eliminate personal property taxes, but the substitute Page 117 of 172 December 12, 2023 22 motion would not achieve that goal. He said that Council should reject the substitute motion and address the matter of the Riverfront Parks Improvement project. Councilmember Dolan stated that there were 38 emails which had been solicited by certain councilmembers themselves. Councilmember Taylor said that residential developers in downtown needed places to entertain potential residents. He noted that the potential economic impact of the project should be compared to the impact of the John Paul Jones Arena in Charlottesville since it would serve as the preeminent venue in the City. Councilmember Helgeson said that the funds could be used to reduce the need to issue more debt and lower personal property taxes. Vice Mayor Faraldi stated he did not appreciate colleagues manipulating facts for political purposes when they were on record stating that the personal property tax should not be addressed for another five years. He said that the motion would not achieve the stated goals. Mayor Reed called for the vote on the substitute motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Helgeson, Misjuns 2 Noes: Dolan, Faraldi, Reed, Taylor, Wilder 5 Mayor Reed emphasized that the project funding could not be used to provide tax relief, and if the Council wanted to provide tax relief, it had to be done during the budget process. She noted the parallels between the City investing in the Riverfront Park Amphitheater project and that of Liberty University continued expansion and growth due to its investments of itself. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Dolan, Faraldi, Reed, Taylor, Wilder 5 Noes: Helgeson, Misjuns 2 Page 118 of 172 December 12, 2023 23 // Mayor Reed stated that after the meeting, the voting board would be decommissioned. She noted that the voting boards were built in-house by City staff around 1981, and had been used for an estimated 4,000 votes over the course of 42 years. She said that in January, Council would be using updated voting software that would improve the viewing experience and streamline the meetings. She stated that the voting boards would be memorialized and put on display at the Lynchburg Museum. // The meeting adjourned at 9:06 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 119 of 172 City Council Agenda Item III.3. Consent Agenda AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY January 23, 2024 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council AGENDA ITEM # III.3 Consideration of approving the minute from the January 9, 2024 meeting. RECOMMENDATION Approve the minutes from the January 9, 2024 Meeting. SUMMARY N/A PRIOR ACTION(S) N/A FISCAL IMPACT N/A CONTACT(S) Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council ATTACHMENT(S) 1. January 9, 2024 REVIEWED BY Date: January 18, 2024 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 120 of 172 January 9, 2024 1 // A work session of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 9th day of January, 2024, at 4:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Larry Taylor, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 5 Absent: MaryJane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson 2 // In the matter of Work Session Agenda Overview, Mercedes Braun, Assistant to the City Manager, provided a briefing to Council on updates regarding the upcoming General Assembly session. // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #1, Council received a presentation from Zoning Administrator Kevin Henry regarding the Property Toolkit Update. On June 28, 2022, City Council adopted the additional code requirements for derelict buildings. These requirements, along with additional resources, have allowed the City to pilot a more proactive approach to addressing condemned/blighted properties. Staff will provide an overview of these efforts to date, as well as additional strategies to improve neighborhood and housing opportunities. Councilmember Wilder asked whether funding for the housing trust fund had begun. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda replied that they discussed it the prior year in collaboration with different partners, and it had been proposed as an element for the City's Housing Toolkit. He said that there were ways to seed a trust fund and solicit private interest to increase it. He said that currently, there was no funding assigned to a housing trust fund program. Councilmember Wilder asked what types of funds were available for such a program. Mr. Benda replied that typically, the funds were associated with a housing authority. Councilmember Wilder asked how the information was advertised to community members. Mr. Henry replied that they were not explicitly advertising the toolkit. He said that affected properties were made aware of the situation, and the City informally discussed the City's plans with property owners and Page 121 of 172 January 9, 2024 2 developers. He noted that they were not actively advertising the toolkit. Councilmember Wilder asked if there were assistance programs to help homeowners with renovations or repairs. Mr. Henry said that there were a variety of options, including programs offered by the housing authority. He said that it depended on the circumstances of the housing project. Community Development Director Mr. Tom Martin said there were various programs which the City referred people to help them make repairs to properties. He said that the properties they were referring to in this presentation were vacant, derelict, or condemned. Mayor Reed asked whether the staffing needs for the department primarily were for inspectors. Mr. Martin said that the current request was for an additional building inspector because the department was seeing that the programs were generating new construction. Mayor Reed asked what the cost would be for the additional position. Mr. Martin said they proposed to take a part-time position and add a 0.25 FTE to it. He said that he did not currently have the exact cost, but he could provide it in a follow-up. Mayor Reed asked how many properties they anticipated scheduling for demolition per year. Mr. Martin said that in FY 23, Council increased the funding to $100 thousand. He said that demolition costs had increased, so with the current funding, they were able to achieve between three to four demolitions per year. He said one request for the fiscal year was to increase the funding. He said that the funding enabled the department to leverage the City funds to get private interests to complete the work. He noted that there were over 300 condemned properties in the City. // In the matter of Economic Development, Agenda Item #2, Council received a presentation from Director of Economic Development and Tourism Marjette Upshur regarding the Economic Development and Tourism Update. The City's economic development and tourism initiatives are aimed at promoting, attracting, retaining, growing, and supporting businesses in the City. Councilmember Misjuns said he wanted to ensure Ms. Upshur was aware that US Pipe had converted many full-time positions to part-time. Page 122 of 172 January 9, 2024 3 // In the matter of Economic Development, Agenda Item #3, Council received a presentation from Executive Director of the Downtown Lynchburg Association Ashley Kershner regarding the Downtown Lynchburg Association Report on New Businesses in 2023 and Bright Nights on the Bluffwalk. Ms. Kershner spoke about the dynamic growth of the Downtown Lynchburg storefront economy throughout 2023, and offered a comprehensive overview of recently opened businesses and those in progress. She also discussed the economic impact generated by the Bright Nights on the Bluffwalk installation, and spoke of its role in fostering a thriving local business landscape. Councilmember Wilder stated that events like the Bright Nights adds to the quality of life in a good way for the community. Mayor Reed stated that the City has realized its return on investment with the funding provided for the Bright Nights installation. // In the matter of Business, Agenda Item #4, Council was briefed and received a summary presentation on the Energy Storage Decommissioning Ordinance from Senior Planner Rachel Frischeisen. The purpose of this Zoning Ordinance amendment is to ensure that energy storage projects within the City have a signed agreement and surety in place to decommission all equipment, facilities, and/or devices of the energy storage facility or solar facility. The Ordinance would ensure the proper removal of equipment when operations at the facility cease. This amendment was initiated by staff as a result of siting agreement discussions related to a proposed energy storage facility within the City. The terms of these agreements would be determined on a project-by-project basis and approved by the City Attorney’s office prior to execution of the agreements. Councilmember Misjuns clarified that the ordinance would not apply to the project on Harbor Street that was previously approved by Council. Ms. Frischeisen said that it would apply, as the ordinance would be a condition of site plan approval, and the project had not yet been submitted for site plan. Page 123 of 172 January 9, 2024 4 // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Wilder announced that a Martin Luther King Jr. breakfast would be held on Monday to begin African-American History Month. He said that they would host a speaker from Lynchburg. Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that a while back, they made important changes to Enterprise Drive. He requested that the Council receive a report on how the changes had improved the traffic problems in the area. He said that he received a complaint from a resident who was having his home reassessed. He asked for more information about why the property was being reassessed. He said that over the holidays, flyers were distributed across the City containing hateful messages, and the City should work to do what it can to stop the flyers from being distributed. Mayor Reed acknowledged the work and contributions of the Lynchburg Public Libraries. She also recognized January 16th as Religious Freedom Day. She announced that on January 18, she would be hosting a human-trafficking summit at the Miller Center Auditorium at 6:30 p.m., and the event was open to the public. She said they would be hosting a representative from the Attorney General's Office, a spokesperson from Freedom 424, a representative from Internet Crimes Against Children, and a representative from the Virginia State Police. She said that the summit was intended to be educational and informative. // On the motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, Council elected to hold a closed meeting to review a new boards and commissions software program and process where Council appointees and their personal information will be disclosed in the course of training, pursuant to Section § 2.2-3711(A)(1) and Section § 2.2-3711(A)(4) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended; and to discuss appointments for vacancies to the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority Board of Directors, pursuant to Section 2.2- 3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. With no discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 5 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan, Helgeson 2 Page 124 of 172 January 9, 2024 5 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Wilder made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Taylor, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 5 Noes: 0 Absent: Dolan, Helgeson 2 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Lynchburg Redevelopment & Housing Authority: Laura Dupuy – new term ending September 30, 2024. Ayes: Reed, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 4 Noes: Misjuns 1 Absent: Dolan, Helgeson 2 Page 125 of 172 January 9, 2024 6 // The meeting recessed at 5:56 p.m. // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 9th day of January, 2024, at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, MaryJane Dolan, Martin Misjuns, Larry Taylor, Sterling A. Wilder 6 Absent: Jeff Helgeson 1 // Councilmember Misjuns led the invocation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Reed announced that the recognition of the 2023 Liberty Christian Academy Football Undefeated Season had been postponed to a later date due to inclement weather. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Reed recognized both of the officers in Council Chambers for National Law Enforcement Appreciation Day. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #1, the item was deferred until the next meeting due to the absence of Councilmember Helgeson; there was a consensus among Council. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #3, Council held a public hearing in consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-001 granting a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to West Lynchburg Baptist Church Preschool to allow the use of an existing structure at 3031 Memorial Avenue as a childcare facility. Senior Planner Rachel Frischeisen provided a summary of the request to Council. West Lynchburg Baptist Church is petitioning for a CUP at 3031 Memorial Avenue to allow the use of a portion of the existing church as a childcare facility/preschool in an R-3, Medium Density Residential District. These facilities are permitted in this zoning district upon approval of a CUP by City Council. The Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends an Institutional use for the subject property. The City’s institutions include the religious, educational, and other nonprofit entities in the City. The petitioner has indicated Page 126 of 172 January 9, 2024 7 that the facility would be operated by the YMCA of Central Virginia. The impact of the facility within the existing church should be minimal. Chris Jordan, Senior Pastor of West Lynchburg Baptist Church, speaking in favor of the item, said that their building could be used throughout the week to meet the needs in the community. He said that in their community, childcare and school-readiness was one of the top needs. He said that they were looking to partner with the YMCA to operate the program. There was no one to speak in opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt Resolution #R-24-001. Councilmember Misjuns expressed the need for more opportunities for childcare and school-readiness programs. Councilmember Wilder said that children required more assistance in early learning education. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Helgeson 1 // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #3, Council held a public hearing in consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-002 approving the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Programs for the Fiscal Year 2025 (Program Year 2024) Annual Action Plan. Grants Coordinator Gabrielle Bateman provided a summary of the request to Council. The U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) requires state and local governments, which receive federal community development funds, to prepare a Consolidated Plan. The Consolidated Plan for the CDBG and HOME Program was approved in June 2020 and covers the period from July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2025. This plan outlines the City’s needs, goals, and objectives for community development (both housing and non- housing areas). HUD requires CDBG and HOME Program entitlement communities to review Page 127 of 172 January 9, 2024 8 these goals on an annual basis. City Council is seeking the input of citizens and other interested parties regarding the approved goals. A 15-day public comment period to receive citizen input regarding these goals was initiated on December 22, 2023 through a legal notice published in The News and Advance. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Wilder motioned, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, to adopt Resolution #R-24-002. Councilmember Wilder noted the immense benefits of the CDBG program. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Helgeson 1 // In the matter of the Registrar’s Office, Agenda Item #4, Council held a public hearing in consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-24-003 amending Section 14-33 of Article III of Chapter 14 of the Lynchburg City Code and relocating the polling place of the Fourth Precinct of the Second Ward from Fairview Christian Church to William Marvin Bass Elementary School. Lynchburg General Registrar Dan Pense provided a summary of the request to Council. The Electoral Board for the City of Lynchburg, Virginia (Electoral Board) voted at its meeting on December 7, 2023, to transfer the Fairview Heights precinct 204 polling place to Bass Elementary School. The new polling place would be located outside the precinct, but within one mile of the precinct boundary as required by Section 24.2-310 of the Code of Virginia. The reason for the request is that the current polling place, Fairview Christian Church, has several access barriers for the disabled, including a flight of stairs from the most-used parking area on Leyburn Street to the polling place entrance, an off-street parking lot on Sackett Street that, for the handicapped, has a difficult slope, and an entryway threshold that is approximately 3" above Page 128 of 172 January 9, 2024 9 the approaching sidewalk. The Electoral Board would like to make use of Bass Elementary School for the Fourth Precinct of the Second Ward starting with the expected March 2024 Republican Primary Election and continuing through all subsequent elections for the indefinite future. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt Ordinance #O-24-003. Councilmember Misjuns said that the location change would provide better opportunities for access and meet the necessary accessibility needs. Councilmember Wilder noted that there were several requirements for polling places and commended staff for finding an appropriate location. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Helgeson 1 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #5, Council held a public hearing in consideration of adopting Resolution #R-24-004 amending the FY 2024 Budget as well as adopting Ordinances for public safety recruitment and retention bonuses (#O-24-005) and to waive specified FY 2025 fees (#O-24-006)(#O-24-007). Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt provided a summary of the request to Council. At the December 1, 2023 City Council Retreat the following items received majority support for the use of available one-time funds: Implement Public Safety Recruitment and Retention Strategy - $1,000,000 Comprehensive initiative across all public safety services to improve recruitment and retention efforts including areas of compensation, procedure, marketing and outreach, and job satisfaction. Ladder Truck for Fire Department - $2,400,000 Page 129 of 172 January 9, 2024 10 To prepare for the new Candlers Mountain Fire Station, ordering a ladder truck now addresses vehicle manufacturing challenges where delivery takes more than 36 months. Convert White Rock Elementary School - $3,500,000 The former White Rock Elementary School has recently been vacated by Lyn-CAG/Head Start. This funding begins renovation and transformation of the facility into a neighborhood center. Plan and Construct Heritage Park - $450,000 Heritage Park master planning as well as upgrades to existing facilities adjacent to Heritage High School are currently funded in the CIP - current project includes: basic property cleanup (removal of high chain link fences, landscape cleanup, repair of existing buildings, etc.); installation of asphalt walking loop; and basic renovation of sports field and small-scale park amenities. This additional funding would allow for lighting of the fields and additional amenities to expand the use and hours. Improve Parking at Awareness Garden - $250,000 The Awareness Garden Foundation (AGF) wishes to partner with the City to build a new parking lot at the Ed Page entrance of the Blackwater Creek Trail. Parking construction is expected to cost $375,000 with the City contributing $250,000. The AGF has pledged an additional $200,000 to expand the garden; the total investment planned for the Awareness Garden is $575,000. Replace City Stadium Artificial Turf - $700,000 Total replacement of the existing synthetic turf, which is approaching the end of its useful life and is showing signs of wear and tear. The City has an opportunity to complete this project prior to the spring sports season. The field is used by both high school football teams, E.C. Glass soccer and lacrosse teams, numerous athletic tournaments, and community youth sports. Waive $10/month Refuse Collection Fee (FY 2025) - $2,300,000 In the FY 2024 Budget, City Council waived the $10/month residential refuse collection fee for FY 2024. This action would continue the waiver for FY 2025. Page 130 of 172 January 9, 2024 11 Waive Vehicle License Fee (FY 2025) - $1,500,000 In the FY 2024 Budget, City Council waived the vehicle license fee for vehicles registered in the City for FY 2024. This fee is either $29.50 or $34.50 per year based on the gross weight of the vehicle. This action would continue the waiver for FY 2025. The City Council was then informed these items would be considered at the January 9, 2024 City Council Meeting. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Misjuns requested to divide the question. He called a point of order. Mr. Freedman explained that it would depend on whether a majority of Council would approve such a motion. He said that currently, one resolution containing all of the items with one appropriation was proposed. He said if Council desired, it could divide the question as it saw fit. Councilmember Misjuns motioned to divide the question. There was no second, so the motion failed. Councilmember Wilder motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Faraldi, to adopt Resolution #R-24-004, amending the FY 24 Budget to reflect adjustments in the General ($1,000,000), Fleet Services ($2,400,000), and City Capital Projects ($4,900,000) Funds with resources of $8,300,000 from the Unassigned General Fund Balance. Councilmember Wilder said that while he may not support all of the projects that City Council chose, the list covered a variety of issues in the City and was the product of a good negotiation between the group. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Helgeson 1 Vice Mayor Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt Ordinance #O-24-005, approving the public safety recruiting and retention strategy. Vice Mayor Faraldi Page 131 of 172 January 9, 2024 12 said that the ordinance was a continuation of making the City the #1 choice for law enforcement professionals in Virginia. Councilmember Wilder said he supported the ordinance because of the challenges faced in hiring officers. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Helgeson 1 Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, to adopt Ordinance #O-24-006, suspending trash collection fees in FY 25. Councilmember Misjuns said that the City should continue to return funds to tax payers. Councilmember Taylor said that unnecessary taxation was not good, and some people were unable to afford the costs. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder 5 Noes: Faraldi 1 Absent: Helgeson 1 Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, to adopt #O-24- 007, suspending Motor Vehicle License Fees in FY 25. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Taylor, Wilder 4 Noes: Dolan, Faraldi 2 Absent: Helgeson 1 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #7, Citizen John Salmon, on behalf of Unified Potential, spoke regarding a waiver of vehicle personal property taxes as they continued to serve the local community. He said that he required the personal property taxes to be waived in order to continue offering the micro-transit services which benefited the community. Page 132 of 172 January 9, 2024 13 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #7, Council held a second reading and considered adopting Resolution #R-23-106 amending the FY 2024 - 2028 Capital Improvement Program and the FY 2024 City Capital Projects Fund budget and appropriating $3,000,000 in funds from the FY 2024 General Fund Unassigned Fund Balance to be used for Riverfront Park Improvements (Amphitheater). Councilmember Wilder motioned, seconded by Councilmember Dolan, to adopt Resolution #R-23-106. Councilmember Wilder said that investments in the City had high returns and benefited residents. Councilmember Dolan said that the project was an opportunity for investment which would serve all citizens. Mayor Reed asked for clarification regarding issues with the flood plain. Deputy City Manager Mr. Greg Patrick stated that the design of the project accounted for anticipated issues in the flood plain and was designed to be compatible with the topography. Mayor Reed clarified that if the funds were not used on this project, they could not be returned to the taxpayer; instead, they would have to be used for another project. Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt replied that was correct, one-time funds could not be used to replace recurring revenues. Councilmember Misjuns stated that in 2022, there was an ordinance where staff determined the source of the surplus, and there was a $0.02 real estate tax rebate. He said that the funds could be returned to the tax payers if the source of the funds was determined. Ms. Witt replied that there was $700,000 identified as a surplus for real estate revenues which could be returned; however, it would cost more to credit tax payers than what the tax payers would receive. Councilmember Misjuns asked from where the other surplus funds were sourced. Ms. Witt said that the funds were from Sales Tax, Meals Tax, and Lodging Tax. She said that there were funds from Personal Property Taxes, but the Commissioner of Revenue recommended reducing the assessment for the upcoming year. She explained that because the payments covered a fiscal year, it was awkward to determine the surplus, so Council voted to reduce the assessments moving forward. She said that interest from investments was another source. Page 133 of 172 January 9, 2024 14 Mayor Reed clarified that the funds at hand were not part of the Real Estate revenues, and if they were not spent on this project, they would be returned to the unassigned fund balance. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder 5 Noes: Misjuns 1 Absent: Helgeson 1 // The meeting adjourned at 8:10 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 134 of 172 RESOLUTION: #R-24-004 BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2024 Adopted Budget is hereby amended and funds are appropriated to reflect adjustments in the General ($1,000,000), Fleet Services ($2,400,000), and City Capital Projects ($4,900,000) Funds with resources of $8,300,000 from the Unassigned General Fund Balance. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the said appropriated funds shall be used as follows: •General Fund oImplement Public Safety Recruitment and Retention Strategy - $1,000,000 •Fleet Services Fund oLadder Truck for Fire Department - $2,400,000 •City Capital Projects Fund oConvert White Rock Elementary School - $3,500,000 oPlan and Construct Heritage Park - $450,000 oImprove Parking at Awareness Garden - $250,000 oReplace City Stadium Artificial Turf - $700,000 Introduced: January 9, 2024 Adopted: January 23, 2024 Certified: _____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 135 of 172 City Council Agenda Item IV.5. Action AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY January 23, 2024 Rachel Frischeisen, City Planner AGENDA ITEM # IV.5 Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-24-008 amending City Code to provide surety requirements for the decommissioning of energy storage facilities. RECOMMENDATION Adoption of Section 35.2-74, Decommissioning surety for energy storage facilities SUMMARY The purpose of this Zoning Ordinance amendment is to ensure energy storage projects within the City have a signed agreement and surety in place to decommission all equipment, facilities, and/or devices of the energy storage facility or solar facility. The Ordinance would ensure the proper removal of equipment when operations at the facility cease. This amendment was initiated by staff as a result of siting agreement discussions related to a proposed energy storage facility within the City. The terms of these agreements would be determined on a project-by-project basis and approved by the City Attorney’s office prior to execution of the agreements. PRIOR ACTION(S) January 9, 2024: City Council Business Item Briefing. December 13, 2023: The Planning Commission recommended approval (7-0) of the Ordinance. December 13, 2023: The Planning Division recommended approval of the Ordinance. FISCAL IMPACT N/A CONTACT(S) Rachel Frischeisen, City Planner Matthew Freedman, City Attorney ATTACHMENT(S) 1. O-24-008 2. Planning Commission Minutes, Report, and Attachments Page 136 of 172 REVIEWED BY Date: January 16, 2024 William Martin, Community Development Director Date: January 18, 2024 Kent White, Assistant City Manager Date: January 18, 2024 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 137 of 172 1 ORDINANCE: #O-24-008 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT THE CODE OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, 1981, BY ADDING THERETO A NEW SECTION 35.2-74 OF ARTICLE VII OF CHAPTER 35.2; SUCH NEW SECTION PROVIDING FOR SURETY REQUIREMENTS SPECIFIC TO THE DECOMMISSIONING OF ENERGY STORAGE FACILITIES WHEREAS, the Lynchburg City Council held a public hearing to consider and address the proposed Zoning Ordinance amendments described herein and to receive public comment on January 23, 2024; and WHEREAS, the Lynchburg City Council finds that these proposed Zoning Ordinance amendments should be adopted in order to promote the public necessity, convenience, welfare, and good zoning practice. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: 1. That the Code of the City of Lynchburg, 1981, be amended and reenacted by adding thereto a new Section 35.2-74 of Article VII of Chapter 35.2 as follows: Sec. 35.2-74. Decommissioning surety for energy storage facilities. (a) Definitions. Decommission means the removal and proper disposal. Energy storage facility means the energy storage equipment and technology within an energy storage project that is capable of absorbing energy, storing such energy for a period of time, and redelivering such energy after it has been stored. Project means a solar facility or an energy storage facility of any kind, either or both. Solar facility means any personal property designed and used primarily for the purpose of collecting, generating, or transferring electric energy from sunlight. (b) Surety Requirements. As a condition of approval of a site plan for any project, the owner, lessee, or developer of the project, as determined by the City Planner, shall enter into a written agreement with the City to decommission all the equipment, facilities, and/or devices of the energy storage facility or solar facility upon the following terms and conditions: (i) if the owner, lessee, or developer defaults in its obligation to decommission a project in accordance with a written agreement provided by this section, the City may enter the real property without further consent and engage in the decommissioning at the sole cost of the owner, lessee, or developer; and (ii) the owner, lessee, or developer must provide financial assurance of such performance to the City in the form of certified funds, cash escrow, surety bond, letter of credit, or parent guaranty, based upon an estimate of a professional engineer licensed in the Commonwealth of Virginia, acceptable to the City, who is engaged by the applicant, Page 138 of 172 2 who has experience in preparing decommissioning estimates. The estimate shall not exceed the total of the projected costs of decommissioning, which may include the net salvage value of such equipment, facilities, and/or devices, plus a reasonable allowance for estimated administrative costs related to a default of the owner, lessee, or developer, and an annual inflation factor. The City Manager, or his/her designee, shall execute such written agreements on behalf of the City. (c) Approval as to Form. All written agreements entered into pursuant to this section shall contain provisions related to the form and quality of the surety or guaranty, and shall be in a form approved by the City Attorney. However, failure to adhere to this requirement shall in no way adversely affect or void such written agreement. 2. That this Ordinance shall be effective upon its adoption. Adopted: January 23, 2024 Certified: ______________________________ Clerk of Council Page 139 of 172 MINUTES OF THE DECEMBER 13, 2023 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING (MINUTES HAVE NOT BEEN APPROVED): Consideration of amending the Zoning Ordinance by adopting Section 35.2 -74, Decommissioning surety for energy storage facilities. The proposed ordinance would require a written agreement for the decommissioning of an energy storage or solar facility prior to site plan approval. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Interim City Planner, provided the following summary to the Commission. The purpose of the zoning ordinance amendment is to ensure that any energy storage project within the City has an agreement in place to decommission all the equipment, facilities, and/or devices of the energy storage facility or solar facility, so that they are removed and properly disposed of when operations of the facility cease. This Zoning Ordinance amendment would affect energy storage facilities, which are considered a “Major Public Utilities Service.” These uses are permitted by Conditional Use Permit (CUP) in all residential districts, all commercial districts, all institutional districts, and I -1, Restricted Industrial District. They are permitted by-right in the I-2, Light Industrial District, and I-3, Heavy Industrial District. An example of the type of project this ordinance would ap ply to is the battery energy storage facility, which stores power from the electrical grid at off-peak hours and resupplies that power back into the grid during peak hours when demand is high, which Planning Commission reviewed this past March. It would also apply to solar projects, which have not been done within the City yet. This amendment was initiated by staff. The draft ordinance, in addition to the agreement which would be approved by the City Attorney, also requires a surety, which ensures the owner, lessee, or developer has the financial means to carry out the decommissioning, if needed. The terms

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.