Minutes (January)
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Jan 22, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Historic Preservation Commission
Minutes of January 22, 2024
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Peter Alexander
Julie Arrington
Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair
Shanda Horner, Chair
Emmett Lifsey
Dr. Gerry Sherayko
MEMBERS ABSENT:
Tracey Langseth
OTHERS PRESENT:
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission; Mr. Andrew Jensen, Planning
Technician; and the public.
ROLL CALL:
After a quorum was established, Chair Horner called the meeting to order at 4:01 p.m.
1. CONSENT AGENDA:
Commissioner Arrington made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by
Commissioner Sherayko, and passed by a unanimous vote.
2. NEW BUSINESS
a) ACTION: (Advocate-Erquiaga): Request of Whirlwind Johnson, LLC to replace a roof and
porch ceiling at 1422 Pierce Street. (HPC2401-0001)
Ms. Jolynn Smith, president of the Whirlwind Johnson Foundation, was present to represent the
application. She is seeking approval to use synthetic slate to replace the existing slate roof. The house
has been vacant for many years with very few renovations done to the home. Funding for the roof and
other repairs has come from the National Trust and donors. Synthetic slate is preferred due to the cost
difference between it and real slate. Other renovations will be done following the roof.
Ms. Alyssa Bausbacher, a representative of L .G. Flint, passed around a sample of the Davinci synthetic
slate that was proposed for use.
Chair Horner asked for more details about the front porch.
Ms. Smith and Ms. Bausbacher replied that pla ster was originally used on the porch ceiling but they are
requesting to replace it with exterior gypsum board, which offers easier maintenance and can be painted
to match the existing color.
Commissioner Erquiaga asked about the scope of this project.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler added that the applicant has received prior approval for extensive work prior to
this, both administratively and through the Commission. The request for this meeting only includes the
roof and the porch ceiling.
Ms. Smith advised that the national trust had approved the use of synthetic slate but understood she also
needed approval of the Historic Preservation Commission (HPC).
2
Commissioner Arrington asked if any of the slate was salvageable.
Ms. Smith advised it was an old house and she would feel more comfortable replacing the entire roof.
The contractors and others that had viewed the attic had added that the interior was still in surprisingly
great condition.
Commissioner Alexander stated he only saw a few pieces of slate missi ng when he viewed it and asked
why they wouldn’t repair those areas instead of replacing the entire roof.
Ms. Smith advised that the roof is currently made of Amherst slate , which is not something you can
purchase now so they would not be able to replace the roof with the same type of slate anyway.
Commissioner Alexander asked about using drywall for the porch ceiling instead of using a composite
material.
Commissioner Lifsey advised that it was an exterior material.
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Arrington.
Commissioner Erquiaga stated that it didn’t sound like th ere was a lot of interior damage and wanted
more clarity as to why they wanted to replace the roof at this time.
Ms. Smith replied that some of the slate ha s cracked and some ha s fallen off the roof . The cost of the
synthetic slate replacement was significantly less costly than the use of real slate.
Commissioner Erquiaga said from his experience repairing portions of a slate roof was much cheaper
than replacing an entire roof with synthetic slate.
Ms. Smith stated they cannot get the same slate to do the repairs.
Commissioner Erquiaga replied that he understands there is not a lot of that type of slate ou t there but
that they could most likely find some. He added that the Commission is there to encourage applicants to
repair or keep what is original.
Commissioner Arrington noted that there are other types of slate that could be used as well.
Ms. Smith replied that she had not been on the roof herself but was relying on the experts that had been
on the roof. They had recommended replacement
Ms. Bausbacher added that the roofers believed the damage was extensive enough that it was not viable
to repair or patch the roof. There were two separate roofers who came to the same conclusion.
The motion to approve passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
b) ACTION: (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Len Scoggins to do extensive work at 713
Pearl Street. (HPC2401-0002)
Mr. Len Scoggins was present to represent the application. He purchased the house in November 2023.
He was made aware of the work that was done without approval and is looking to bring his property into
3
compliance. He would also like to install fencing at the edge of a drop-off that appears to have been the
location of a previous garage.
Chair Horner recommended discussing the items one at a time.
Mr. Scoggins stated that t he windows were not replaced with an appropriate material or style. Th is
request is to replace the windows with wood -clad windows, with simulated divided lite (SDL), a two (2)
over two (2) pattern, and in the original size. The second floor has seventy -two (72) inch tall windows
and the first floor has seventy -six (76) inch tall windows. There are five (5) windows to replace on the
first floor and ten (10) windows to replace on the second floor.
Commissioner Sherayko shared excitement and stated that matching the original windows is what needs
to be done.
Commissioner Lifsey asked about the trim.
Mr. Scoggins advised that the second item on the list was to replace the window trim to match the
previous trim before the windows were replaced.
Commissioner Alexander stated he noticed three (3) different types of windows.
Mr. Scoggins replied that he would be making the windows uniform. The bay windows and two (2) rear
windows are original but the other windows were replaced with vinyl windows without approval.
Commissioner Lifsey agreed that these replacements would correct what had been done without
approval.
Commissioner Alexander asked if the rear staircase was compliant.
Commissioner Sherayko stated that the rear deck is on the list of items. It is visible from Grace Street.
Mr. Scoggins stated that the front porch spindles had been replaced with metal . He is requesting to
replace them with wood spindles. The rear deck has wood square spindles going down the stairs but
metal spindles at the landing. He is requesting to replace the metal with wood square spindles to match
the stairs.
Commissioner Arrington asked about the height of the railing.
Mr. Scoggins replied that he believes the railing is 32 inches tall but does not know for sure . He is also
looking to replace the front door that is out of compliance. He would like to replace it with a lited wood
door. The door would be the same size as the existing door. He provide d three (3) options with true
divided lites.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that the doors with the solid bottom panel look appropriate and asked if the
door will be painted.
Mr. Scoggins responded that painting was not part of th e scope at this time but he ultimate ly wants to
paint the house blue and the door red. He will apply for colors at a later date. The door still has its
original peaked trim. He would also like to install a three (3) foot black metal rail at the rear of the home
around a drop-off area.
Commissioner Alexander asked for clarification as to the location of the railing.
Mr. Scoggins replied that the rail would be installed above an existing retaining wall. There is very little
clearance off of the rear stairs and the rail would help with safety.
4
Commissioner Sherayko stated that the proposed corrective work looks like a great improvement but he
has some concerns about the proposed fence. It looks modern and is unsure if it fits into the historic
district. He understands it would be a safety feature.
Commissioner Alexander asked if the railing would resemble the submitted image.
Mr. Scoggins advised it would match the picture but there would be no gate. He added that he is open to
other styles.
Commissioner Alexander recommended something with spindles.
Commissioner Lifsey noted that the gui delines list a simple woven wire fence as an option. There may
also be some cast iron fences at an architectural salvage shop.
Commissioner Sherayko shared agreement that woven wire may be a good option . A structure with a
woven wire fence was discussed. He added that with all the work that is being done it would be a shame
to not have a fence that ties in to the aesthetics of the house.
Commissioner Lifsey asked about painting the porch and deck railings. The application could be approved
with the stipulation that they be painted white now and the applicant come back with a final color
scheme later on. It is important for the rear deck to be painted as it is in a Historic District.
Mr. Scoggins responded that he is willing to paint them white now and submit for other colors later. The
front porch spindles will be painted black. He then asked if the porch floor should also be painted.
Commissioner Lifsey replied that it should be painted and that paint will protect it better long-term.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table the fence and to approve the windows and trim,
the front porch and rear deck spindles, and the front door (option 2 or 3) as submitted w ith
the condition that wood porch elements be painted white until a permanent color scheme is
submitted for approval . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the
following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Horner, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
4. NEXT MEETING DAY:
The next regular meeting is scheduled for February 26, 2024.
5. ADJOURNMENT:
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 4:40 p.m.
ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________
Secretary Chair
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.