Minutes (December)
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Dec 18, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Historic Preservation Commission
Minutes of December 18, 2023
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Peter Alexander
Julie Arrington
Michael Erquiaga, Vice-Chair
Emmett Lifsey
Tracey Langseth
MEMBERS ABSENT:
Shanda Horner, Chair
Dr. Gerry Sherayko
OTHERS PRESENT:
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission; Mr. Andrew Jensen, Planning
Technician; and the public.
ROLL CALL:
After a quorum was established, Vice-Chair Erquiaga called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m.
1. CONSENT AGENDA:
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner
Arrington, and passed by a unanimous vote.
2. NEW BUSINESS
a) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Diamond Hill Baptist Church to install a fence at
805 15
th Street. (HPC2312-0003)
Mr. Harry Grant of Diamond Hill Baptist Church was present to represent the application. Aluminum fencing
was approved previously for a childcare center. The fencing around the pit, at the side and rear of the
building, will now be lattice. There is existing lattice on the side porch. The fencing will match that.
Commissioner Lifsey asked if the purpose of the lattice fence was to prevent children from falling in to the
ditch.
Mr. Grant replied yes.
Commissioner Lifsey expressed concerns with the strength of the lattice. A child running could potentially
run through the lattice.
Mr. Grant advised that the lattice would be reinforced with posts in concrete.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the application as submitted . The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey 5
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Horner, Sherayko 2
2
b) ACTION (Advocate -Alexander): Request of Borel Construction Co., Inc. to install a
driveway at 1101 Harrison Street. (HPC2312-004)
Mr. Mark Borel of Borel Construction Co., Inc. was present to represent the application. He would like to
install parking closer to the alley, than shown in the drawing, with a sidewalk and a staircase. This would
prevent water from running towards the house and would be easier to install due to grading issues.
Commissioner Lifsey and Arrington agreed that having the driveway closer to the alley would not be an
issue.
Mr. Borel added that the alley is city right of way that services about ten (10) houses. The driveway would
be made to be a twenty-four (24) to thirty (30) foot deep driveway that is two (2) cars wide. It would then
be connected to the house via sidewalk.
Commissioner Erquiaga asked what material the driveway would be.
Commissioner Lifsey added that concrete or pea gravel are preferred materials as opposed to asphalt.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve a concrete parking area against the alley,
approximately 24-30 feet deep, and wide enough for 2 cars ; with a concrete sidewalk from
the parking area to the house . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by
the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey 5
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Horner, Sherayko 2
Mr. Borel would also like to install a wrought iron rail on the second-floor porch; three (3) Colonial box light
fixtures at each door; and eight-foot-tall, wood grain, fiber classic smooth star doors with two (2) panels.
Commissioner Lifsey stated what was presented was appropriate. Clear glass is preferable to wavy glass
for the light fixtures.
Mr. Borel asked about approval for aluminum clad wood windows with no panes.
Commissioner Lifsey advised the windows had been approved in a prior submittal.
Mr. Borel continued that he plans to install a two (2) panel fiberglass door.
Commissioner Lifsey stated it is a modern take on a Colonial door and should be acceptable.
Mr. Borel asked if the second-floor door could be all glass.
Commissioner Lifsey stated he would recommend making it a two -panel door with glass in t he top panel
and a solid bottom panel for privacy reasons.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve a wrought iron rail on the second-floor porch;
three (3) colonial box light fixtures, with clear glass, at each door; an eight-foot-tall
fiberglass two (2) panel front door; and an eight-foot-tall fiberglass two (2) panel porch
door with a solid lower panel. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by
the following vote:
3
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey 5
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Horner, Sherayko 2
c) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Russ Lescau lt to replace window s, a porch
railing, and a porch door at 1500 Madison Street. (HPC2312-0005)
Mr. Russ Lescault was present to represent the application. As seen in a photo from 1942, there were
previously four (4) windows and a transom window on the left side of the house. Currently the transom is
blocked with wood and the four (4) windows have been replaced with three (3) windows. Some of these
are vinyl. He would like to replace the window s with Pella Lifestyle Series windows, which are wooden
aluminum clad windows, and go back to the original design. The windows need replacement because they
are currently leaking. He would also like to switch out the existing chain link rail for the side porch, which
did not exist when the house was built . The concrete porch was installed around 1950. The porch is not
historically accurate and the existing railing is an eyesore. The replacement rails would be made of iron .
The porch also has a steel-clad door with a plastic frame. The plastic frame is falling apart and the door is
not insulated well. The proposed replacement door is a Pella insulated fiberglass door.
Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey 5
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Horner, Sherayko 2
d) ACTION (Advocate-Lifsey): Request of Sara Lissa Paulson to add a railing to a front porch
and resurface a concrete walkway and stoop at 2705 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2312-0006)
Ms. Sarah Lissa Paulson was present to represent the application. She would like more privacy on the front
porch, which is a framed porch and is not historically accurate. The existing curtains are not a great solution.
She would like to add a permanent railing around the porch with two (2) by four (4) wood pieces painted
white. The current temporary rail system is equidistant. She would also like to resurface the front concrete
with a pattern with regular lines.
Commissioner Arrington stated she has not seen a privacy setup like the one proposed before.
Commissioner Lifsey agreed. It is a bit unusual but having a pattern of alternating smaller and larger boards
would help break it up. It currently almost looks solid. Otherwise, it would be appropriate.
Commissioner Langseth asked if the rails would be flush.
Ms. Paulson responded that they will all be flush. They are all three and a half (3.5) inches out.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that they should all be in the same plane. A pattern of alternating wide and
narrow would be fine to break up the big mass.
Ms. Paulson stated that the porch sections were not the same distance apart and asked if two (2) wide
rails and then three (3) narrow rails would be an acceptable pattern.
Commissioner Lifsey and Arrington noted that there should be some type of variation but the rails should
remain on the same plane.
4
Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the application for concre te resurfacing as
submitted and the front porch railing with the condition that the rails have an alternating
pattern but remain on the same plane . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and
passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey 5
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Horner, Sherayko 2
e) ACTION: (Advocate -Horner): Request of Jamerson -Lewis Construction to replace light
fixtures at 1312, 1316, and 1316 ½ Church Street. (HPC2311-0011)
Mr. William Cook of Jamerson -Lewis Construction was present to represent the application. The previous
approval for work to these structures did not include approval for light fixtures. They are proposing t he
Princeton 630 series flush for the ceilings, larger sconces for the side entrances, and overdoor sconces for
the rear decks . The existing fixtures a re not original. The three (3) buildings are in different states of
deterioration and the hope is that adding uniform light fixtures will help them look better.
Commissioner Arrington made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey 5
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Horner, Sherayko 2
f) ACTION (Advocate-Horner): Request of Joshua and Maria Rolf to construct a house at 416
Cabell Street. (HPC2312-0007)
Mr. Seth Good of Frank Good Builders was present to represent the application. The project includes
building a new house that is historically accurate but also affordable.
Commissioner Erquiaga noted that he has not seen a mix of brick and Hardie Plank like this on other homes
in the historic districts. He then asked to be educated on the historic aspects of this home design.
Mr. Good replied that it is a Tudor style home.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that it would be appropriate for the home to be all siding as opposed to brick
and siding. The mix of materials is seen more in new construction.
Mr. Good advised that the owners like the current design but if the mix of materials is an issue then his
personal preference would be to go with all brick.
Commissioner Arrington added that all brick is more in keeping with Tudor style houses in the area.
Mr. Good stated the brick and Hardie siding is a new spin on Tudor houses but there are older houses that
have it as well.
Commissioner Lifsey noted that a compromise could be the main two-story body of the house as brick and
the one-story wings as Hardie siding.
5
Commissioner Langseth shared agreement.
Mr. Good responded that the owners would most likely be okay with that suggestion.
Commissioner Lifsey asked about the metal over the front window if it would be prefinished.
Mr. Good advised it would be prefinished standing seam metal as the owners are on a budget.
Commissioner Lifsey asked if the roof would be a shingle roof.
Mr. Good replied that the roof would be architectural shingles.
Commissioner Lifsey advised that for new construction architectural shingles would be okay but the shingles
should be black to emulate slate.
Commissioner Erquiaga noted that other new construction proposed in Daniel’s Hill is likely to have asphalt
shingle roofs as well. These houses will be the entrance to the Historic District.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that this style may not exist in this neighborhood but it does exist elsewhere.
The style is more of a 1930-1950 style but could still be considered contributing in a historic district.
Commissioner Erquiaga replied that material choices contribute to the image of the construction.
Commissioner Lifsey agreed but noted that this style of house would typically have a slate or asphalt shingle
roof found in the 1950s but not metal. Slate would be ideal but would be too costly.
Commissioner Erquiaga noted that synthetic slate is available. He then asked about the windows.
Mr. Good advised that they are casement windows and would be opened with a crank.
Commissioner Lifsey and Langseth shared agreement that casement windows are appropriate for this style.
Mr. Good stated that Anderson Windows sells a composite product called Fibrex. It is a step up above vinyl
windows and is more durable and less maintenance than aluminum clad. The windows come with a
simulated divided lite (SDL) option.
Commissioner Lifsey expressed concern about the design of the window s. Diamond pattern casements
would be more appropriate.
Commissioner Erquiaga stated that the muntins should be exterior.
Mr. Good said he would look into what is available.
Commissioner Lifsey stated he is okay with the material being used but would rather see the windows with
no muntins compared to what is currently being proposed.
Mr. Good replied that they are flexible and could do double hung windows with a bar in the middle instead
of casement windows.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that casement windows are more appropriate for this style of house.
6
Mr. Good advised that the owners had not selected any windows yet so he can take the suggestions of the
commission to the owners. Mr. Good asked if the windows would have to come before the commission for
approval.
Commissioner Langseth asked if the Commission was only considering the diamond design.
Commissioner Lifsey added that there are other options but historically the diamond design would be an
appropriate option.
Commissioner Erquiaga asked about ceiling height. The current proposal is nine (9) feet, which he believes
is currently standard.
Commissioner Lifsey advised eight (8) feet is common but nine (9) feet is much nicer.
Commissioner Erquiaga stated he has not seen many houses that have that height on the first floor.
Commissioner Lifsey responded that a historic house in this style is unlikely to have ten (10) foot ceilings.
Commissioner Langseth added that the new housing being built nearby would not have taller ceilings.
Commissioner Lifsey stated he was fine with the house only having nine (9) foot ceilings.
Commissioner Erquiaga stated there are no other houses that look similar in the neighborhood. While there
is a range of styles, all of the current houses appear to be over one hundred (100) years old. The houses
on this block have ten (10) to twelve (12) foot ceilings. New construction should be similar to existing
houses per the guidelines.
Commissioner Langseth responded that there is such a wide range of styles that this construction proposal
would not be seen as disruptive.
Commissioner Lifsey added that the question he asks himself , in regards to new construction , is if this
house could exist in this historic district prior to now. It is not as imposing, in terms of scale, in comparison
to other surrounding houses but it is historic in image and placement.
Commissioner Erquiaga responded that the swoop in the roof is what differentiates it.
Commissioner Langseth stated that if the design is envisioned with the change in materials and window
design that have been discussed, it will help to differentiate it further.
Mr. Good added that the slight swoop is what makes it a Tudor home. Beyond that, Tudor homes are
pretty basic. Stucco is also a siding material option that could be utilized.
Commissioner Arrington stated that a brick main body and stucco wings would blend even more. There are
homes with stucco on the street. There is not a lot of other opportunities for new construction in this area
but each application should be treated on a case by case basis.
Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the concept and style of the new construction
with a two -story brick main body ; one-story stucco wings; Anderson Fibrex casement
windows with a diamond pattern; and a black architectural shingle roof. Additional submittals
will be required for other materials and details as they are decided upon – to include but not
be limited to railings, doors, deck, and lighting. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington
and passed by the following vote:
7
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey 5
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Horner, Sherayko 2
g) ACTION (Advocate-Erquiaga): Request of Chris Carlson to replace front windows at
210/212 Harrison Street. (HPC2312-0008)
Mr. Adam White, the new owner, was present to represent the application. He would like to replace the
existing vinyl windows that did not receive approval with aluminum clad wood windows or wood windows.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that aluminum clad wood windows are commonly approved in historic districts.
Mr. White stated the windows would be white. There is money in escrow to help make this project happen.
Commissioner Lifsey asked for clarification as to which windows will be replaced.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler advised six (6) front windows are being replaced and pointed to them on the screen.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve six (6) front replacement windows as aluminum
clad wood windows or wood windows with a nine (9) over nine (9) configuration and exterior
muntins to match the existing adjacent windows.
Commissioner Arrington asked if the lower windows with a two (2) over (2) configuration were original or
if nine (9) over nine (9) would be more appropriate for those.
Commissioner Lifsey agreed that they most likely were not original.
Commissioner Alexander asked how many total windows are going to be replaced.
Mr. White advised that six (6) in total will be replaced.
The motion was seconded by Commissioner Arrington and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Arrington, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey 5
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Horner, Sherayko 2
4. NEXT MEETING DAY:
The next regular meeting is scheduled for January 22, 2024.
5. ADJOURNMENT:
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:32 p.m.
ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________
Secretary Chair
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.