RecordWell Data

City Council Meeting — Minutes

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Oct 24, 2023 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

October 24, 2023 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 24th day of October, 2023, at 4:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie Reed, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jeff Helgeson, Larry Taylor, MaryJane Dolan, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Agenda Work Session overview, City Manager Wynter C. Benda provided an overview of the agenda. // In the matter of Central Virginia Planning District Commission, Agenda Item #1, Council received a presentation from Alec Brebner, Executive Director of the Central Virginia Planning District Commission, on current CVPDC initiatives. Councilmember Helgeson noted that anything the CVPDC could do to secure federal and state grants for the region was very helpful. // In the matter of Public Works and Police Department, Agenda Item #2, Council received an update regarding the construction of the Police Department Headquarters. Clay Simmons, Deputy Director of Public Works, provided a summary of the item to Council. The City of Lynchburg Police Department project consists of land acquisition, design and construction of a modern, state of the art building to meet the current and future law enforcement needs for the City of Lynchburg. The main building is three stories tall and will be 93,991 square feet in area once completed. The scope of work includes the entire site development — stormwater, utility infrastructure, site grading, parking facilities (including a separate rolling asset building), site security, lighting, landscaping, and building construction — foundation and structure to the roof including all systems and finishes necessary to operate the building as a Police Department upon completion. The Notice To Proceed was issued on October 14, 2022 and provides 847 days for the completion of construction. This would place the construction completion on or about February 7, 2025. The project is currently well underway with site clearing/grading 95% complete, utilities (stormwater, water and sewer) run to the site, building foundation completed, structural slabs (all floors) 100% completed and steel erection 99% completed at this time. Framing and sheathing on the building exterior is underway as well as roof construction. Interior mechanical, electrical and plumbing systems are October 24, 2023 2 being installed at this time as well. Overall, the project is estimated to be approximately 29% complete at this time. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #3, Council received an overview of actions to address skilled gaming facilities, blight and safety concerns. Tom Martin, Acting Community Development Director, provided a summary of the item to Council. Staff has reviewed concerns about stand alone skilled gaming facilities and limited visibility into a number of businesses. The findings are that both are violations of C ity Code. He provided an update on steps being taken to address these concerns, as well as how the recent Virginia Supreme Court ruling affects skilled gaming throughout the Commonwealth. Councilmember Misjuns asked for clarification about what the blue and green dots on the provided heat map represented. Mr. Martin replied that they represented the vape shops and convenience stores. Councilmember Taylor asked if it was accurate that the shops were targeted in lower income neighborhoods. Mr. Martin said that it was true that a lot of these vacant commercial structures were located in lower income areas and were more difficult to lease. Councilmember Dolan asked if it was known whether the structures were locally owned. Mr. Martin answered that he was unsure about the standalone facilities, but the restaurants and convenience stores were all over. Councilmember Wilder asked what the difference was between gas stations versus those buildings. Mr. Martin said that both venues had the same type of machine in them, but this item was referring to the illegality of standalone facilities that provided only skill games, while permitted uses such as convenience stores or restaurants were allowed to have the machines in their businesses to make additional revenue. Councilmember Helgeson asked for clarification that these skill games were banned by the General Assembly. Mr. Martin confirmed that they were banned by the General Assembly because they were classified as illegal gambling. Councilmember Helgeson asked if due to the blight and safety concern, notices would be sent to those businesses to close down. Mr. Martin said that the businesses would be treated as any other zoning violation and would be given notices. He noted that these structures were also operating without certificates of occupancy and creating a lot of calls for service. October 24, 2023 3 Councilmember Helgeson asked if the difference between the standalone and the other machines was that the other machines would be located in a facility such as a gas station. Mr. Martin confirmed that was correct. Vice Mayor Faraldi noted that there had been past attempts to tax these games in order to pay for school construction. Councilmember Misjuns asked if there were measures that could be taken to prevent these skill games from being located near the high schools in the City. Mr. Martin said that staff could certainly research what could be done in terms of keeping certain uses at a specific distance from other uses. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #4, Council received an update on a proposal for nineteen (19) apartments at 3146 and 3150 Wards Ferry Road. Tom Martin, Acting Community Devel opment Director, provided a summary of the item to Council. At the October 10, 2023 meeting, City Council held a public hearing on a request for a conditional use permit to allow 19 apartments on the corner of Wards Ferry Road and Copley Place. The property included two (2) parcels; 3146 & 3150 Wards Ferry Road. The petitioner originally submitted plans in May to the City’s Technical Review Committee for 26 townhouses. During the review, staff noted the owner did not have sufficient land for the townhouses as required by zoning ordinance and the plan indicated relocation of the City’s stormwater facility. The developer then resubmitted the plan in July for 24 apartments. Both apartments and townhouse developments are permitted on the properties with approval of a conditional use permit by City Council. The City’s zoning ordinance requires a minimum of two (2) acres for a townhouse development. The two parcels consist of approximately one and six hundred twelve thousandths (1.612) acres. City Staff met with the developers and engineer on October 13, 2023. At the meeting several “paths” forward were identified to develop the property as townhouses. Each path involved differing levels of complexity and time. All included resubmitting the petition for review by the City of Lynchburg Planning Commission: 1. Obtain additional land area for the development — No movement of City Stormwater Pond. The developer owns an additional parcel of land located at 3142 Wards Ferry Road. This parcel consists of thirty-five hundredths (.35) acres and is zoned R-2, Low-Medium Density Residential. This property “could” be rezoned to B-1, Limited Business District and included in the conditional use permit petition. If this parcel was included, the total acreage in the petition would be one and nine hundred sixty -two (1.962) October 24, 2023 4 acres. This is thirty-eight thousandths (.038) acres less than the required two (2) acres for a townhome development. The additional property could be obtained through a right-of-way vacation request or from an adjacent landowner. The petitioner has not done an actual field survey of the property. This option would not require any modifications to existing City Stormwater facilities, yet would possibly result in fewer townhouse units due to parcel configuration. 2. Move yet separate City Stormwater Pond. This is similar to path number 1, yet moving the pond could allow the developer to obtain additional land from the City to build additional townhouse units. The public / private stormwater would be separate and maintained by each responsible party, i.e. City / Developer. Under either scenario, a right-of-way vacation may be necessary. Title research would need to be completed and the value of right-of-way would need to be determined. 3. Move and share the public stormwater pond — City Maintained. This technically can be done; however, appropriate rules, procedures, and associated City Code changes would need to be done. The State Code allows for a “pro-rata” program for shared stormwater facilities. The program would essentially be set up where the City would sell capacity for both water quantity controls and water quality controls in City-owned facilities with enough capacity to manage runoff from multiple sites. The costs for capital, ongoing maintenance, inspection, and future replacement costs would be divided on a pro- rata basis between participating property owners. This generally works best in a situation such as an industrial park where a regional stormwater facility could serve multiple parcels more efficiently and effectively than a number of individual facilities. The City would design and construct the facility in advance of any development, then sell capacity in the facility in-lieu of the individual parcels constructing, inspecting, and maintaining the individual facilities. It does not generally work well for small, individual developments. Implementing a pro-rata program would involve creating a program that is equitable and that could be replicated around the City. There would be a need for additional administrative staff to manage the program and additional maintenance staff needed to maintain larger facilities that serve both public and private lands. Water Resources has had similar requests for shared facilities in the past but has not pursued setting up a pro-rata program for stormwater management due to the administrative and maintenance burden. October 24, 2023 5 4. Shared Stormwater Facility — Developer Maintained. This may also be possible; however, additional research would need to be done. There would need to be discussions with the De partment of Environmental Quality about how this may impact the City’s permit. While the City of Lynchburg is responsible for ensuring the proper maintenance of private stormwater facilities, City-owned facilities require an additional level of maintenance and inspection which could complicate the situation. A maintenance agreement is required for all private stormwater facilities and since the developer is typically not the property owner or manager, after the development is complete, the maintenance agreement would need to be established with the property management entity or homeowner’s association. This agreement would be complicated by a shared facility. A shared facility would be costlier to maintain due to the additional size and it would also need to be maintained at a higher standard due to it receiving runoff from City facilities. This cost would be ultimately passed on to the property owners. There is also a question about liability and clean-up that would need to be resolved should a hazardous release, such as a fuel spill on a City roadway enter the facility. City staff discussed the options with the developer on Monday, October 16. The developer indicated that they would like to pursue an option for townhomes that did not include sharing of stormwater facilities. Councilmember Helgeson said that as the representative of this area, he was disinclined to vote in favor of the apartments as presented tonight. He asked what types of business uses would be located here. Mr. Martin answered that it would be small offices and small restaurants that did not have drive- throughs, with less than 50,000 square feet. Councilmember Helgeson asked if those uses were allowed by right in the B-1 district. Mr. Martin replied yes. He noted that the traffic safety was raised as an issue by staff, and the developer subsequently provided trip generation data that indicated the proposed townhomes would generate less trips per day, which could equate to safer conditions at the intersection, as opposed to a restaurant use which would generate far more trips. Councilmember Helgeson said that peak traffic hours could influence the traffic safety. Mr. Martin said that was correct. He said that staff discussed with the petitioner about potentially doing more traffic analysis if they chose to go back and look at that. Councilmember Misjuns said that he also had concern regarding the traffic in the area and was not in favor of putting this level of residential density there. Mayor Reed asked if Councilmember Misjuns October 24, 2023 6 could address the general business item as well. Councilmember Misjuns stated that he was not in favor of the apartments, and he was unsure about whether townhomes were appropriate without receiving further information. He expressed his concern with the residential density in the area that would likely have similar peak hours to the nearby school. Mr. Martin said that if the applicant considered the townhomes again, they had been recommended by staff to submit more analyses regarding traffic safety. Councilmember Taylor said that he supported the item due to its generation of revenue for the City. Mayor Reed asked for clarification that Councilmember Taylor was supportive of allowing the townhomes and taking the apartments off of the general business. Councilmember Taylor replied yes. Councilmember Wilder asked if the application would return to the Planning Commission if it was changed to the townhomes again. Mr. Martin said yes, absolutely. Councilmember Wilder asked if the main concern of the Planning Commission the traffic. Mr. Martin said that the Commission’s concerns were regarding the traffic safety of the intersection and the Wards Ferry Road corridor study’s recommendation to refrain from increase in traffic count on that road. He said that the staff and Planning Commission were also aware of Council’s concern with the amount of apartments in this area. Councilmember Wilder said that his biggest concern was regarding the traffic as well. Councilmember Dolan said that she would not be supportive of the request f or apartments, but was also unsure of being able to support townhomes either. Mayor Reed said that she supported the applicant bringing forward a new proposal for townhomes if they wished to do so. She said that Council would defer to staff and the applicant on how to proceed. // In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #5, Council was briefed on the Blackwater CSO Tunnel US Pipe Agreements. This item will appear before Council for public hearing at a later date. Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources, provided a summary of the item to Council. The Blackwater CSO Tunnel Project (CSO 52) requires the City to acquire a portion of Tax Map Parcel 04513002, 16 7th Street, from Griffin Pipe Products Co LLC and obtain a temporary construction easement on the entire parcel for the duration of the project. This displaces approximately 100 parking spaces significantly impacting the operation of US Pipe. Over the last year staff has been in negotiation with US Pipe to develop solutions October 24, 2023 7 that will minimize the impact to their operations during and after construction is complete. These negotiations include: 1. Swap New Parcel "A" (subdivided from Tax Map Parcel 04513002) 0.311 acres, for City Owned Tax Map Parcel 04510002, 8 Adams Street, 0.540 acres. This would terminate their current lease of 8 Adams Street for which they are paying the City $600 per month. 2. The City will construct a 100 space parking area on Tax Map Parcel 04513005, 2 Adams Street, a parcel owned by Griffin Pipe Products Co LLC to accommodate the displaced parking. 3. Vacation of a portion of Adams Street that serves their operation. 4. The City will remove a construction debris pile on north side of 7th Street to provide US Pipe more usable area. 5. Convey an access easement across Tax Map Parcel 04513004, 4 Adams Street, a parcel owned by the City of Lynchburg, to access parking described in item no. 3. // In the matter of Parks and Recreation, Agenda Item #6, Council was briefed on the Jefferson Park and Tinbridge Hill Overlook Dedications/Restrictions of Conserved Open Space Land. Wy att Woody, Director of Parks and Recreation, provided a summary of the item to Council. City Council previously approved Community Development Block Grant funding for park projects in the Tinbridge Hill and Dearington Neighborhoods, respectively. In Tinbridge Hill, the project includes a trail connection and overlook structure at the end of Hollins Street. In Dearington, upgrades to Jefferson Park include a new basketball court with a community-chosen mural, stair improvements to the old amphitheater, a small loop trail in the park, a neighborhood “patio” with a pavilion on the former tennis court, and park lighting. These enhancements were identified as part of neighborhood plans based on input from the residents and ultimately adopted by Council. The improvements to both properties will generate surface water runoff (i.e. stormwater) that will need to be managed in accordance with City Code and state law. Conserved open space — the practice of setting aside land via deed restriction to allow low volumes of runoff to disperse and infiltrate -- is a state-approved measure to mitigate stormwater impacts. The engineers for each project identified conserved open space as a good fit for the park improvements and incorporated the practices into the approved design plans. To dedicate the land for stormwater management purposes, October 24, 2023 8 City Council will need to approve resolutions to create the necessary deed restrictions. The resolutions will be scheduled for a public hearing at the November 28, 2023 meeting. // In the matter of Police Department, Council was briefed on the Flock Group, Inc. and City of Lynchburg License Agreement and Contract. Police Chief Ryan Zuidema and Shane MacGregor of Flock Safety Inc. provided a summary of the item to Council. The Lynchburg Police Department (LPD) started the implementation of a Real-Time Crime Center and plans to add Flock Safety services. Flock Safety offers compatibility with Virginia’s Criminal Justice Information Services (CJIS) to include Amber Alerts, Silver Alerts, Be-on-the-Look-Out (BOLO) advisories, and other items specifically related to vehicle information as a service. Flock Safety license plate reader (LPR) camera systems utilize proprietary software to determine a vehicle’s make, model, and color by capturing images of license plates. This software integrates with our current Axon Evidence system used for both body cameras and in- car cameras. Flock Safety will help address auto-theft and assist the LPD by using stationary cameras. It has already proven to be effective in other jurisdictions in locating vehicles and individuals involved in criminal activity, stolen vehicles, and stolen license plates. In these situations, Flock Safety provides an alert to authorized users of CJIS, in conjunction with the Virginia Criminal Information Network (VCIN) and the National Crime Information Center (NCIC). Flock Safety also provides a supplemental gunshot detection system, called Raven. Raven provides up to a one-mile radius gunshot detection capability per installed location. Raven will provide an alert to the LPD upon detecting a gunshot. This tool will assist with the timely investigation of shots fired incidents in our community. The Virginia State Police have provided $10,000 in funding to us through the Help Eliminate Auto Theft (HEAT) program for Flock Safety. Additional funding is included in the FY24 budget. To move forward with this program, the approval of a right-of-way license agreement is needed to install the cameras on City-owned property. The cameras will be installed on existing City- owned signs and poles in the right-of-way and on City property. The LPD worked with Flock Safety, the City Attorney, and City Traffic Engineering to develop the license agreement. There are 15 proposed camera locations. The LPD will install the cameras at main entry points into the City and other high- volume traffic locations using traffic counts provided by the Virginia Department of Transportation. Councilmember Helgeson said that he did not approve of the concept of big brother-type surveillance. October 24, 2023 9 Councilmember Wilder said that he was inclined to support the idea so the Police Department would have more tools to address issues such as gunshots in neighborhoods and ensure the community was staying safe. Councilmember Misjuns asked if there was a data sharing agreement involved between the City and Flock. Mr. MacGregor said that all of the data was held on an Amazon web government -grade server, and after 30 days it was automatically deleted. He explained that it was techni cally the Police Department’s data, but Flock managed it for them. Every search made by a police officer could be internally audited to see who made the search as well as when and where. Councilmember Misjuns asked if there was an ability for someone in Flock to keep the data for longer than 30 days. Mr. MacGregor said no, it was automatically deleted. Councilmember Misjuns asked what would cause that to change. Mr. MacGregor said that it should never change, unless the state of Virginia said that they needed to keep the data for longer than 30 days. Councilmember Misjuns asked if there was an ability for someone to manually search for a license plate to see the activity of a vehicle over the 30 days of stored data. Mr. MacGregor said that because the system was auditable, a case number or other investigative number should be provided, and no officer should be using the system just to check on vehicles unrelated to ongoing investigations. Councilmember Misjuns said that he shared the concerns of Councilmember Helgeson in that there were potential privacy issues that may arise from putting up cameras that had the ability to follow vehicles by license plates. Councilmember Dolan said that the proposal seemed to be a very efficient method to provide and enhance public safety and the data they put forth was impressive and would be well worth it. She noted that turnpikes and expressways with tolls had license plate readers used to bill customers, so the practice was already in place. She noted that the Raven system would be very beneficial to the Police Department in addressing the issue of gunshots being fired in the City. Councilmember Wilder asked Chief Zuidema what the main benefits of the program were for the Police Department. Chief Zuidema said that the biggest benefit was that the department was able to leverage technology in a way to reduce the need for human resources during investigations. He said that the reason they used 30 days of data was so that they could look at past data if pertinent information was October 24, 2023 10 brought forward at a later point during an investigation. Councilmember Wilder said that it was important for the City to take advantage of additional resources to address crime in the area so everyone felt safer. Councilmember Taylor asked how this technology would address gunshots in neighborhoods. Mr. MacGregor said that 9 out of 10 of the gunshots would be referred to local law enforcement, whereas typically over 60% of gunshots nationwide were never called in. He said that it was a 45- to 60-second notification time, which could allow for lifesaving instances. The listening device used software with machine learning that would allow it to become more accurate over time. Councilmember Misjuns said he was not necessarily in favor of the proposal. He a sked if the City could require that future upgrades or expansions in technology come back before the Council for approval. He expressed concerns about facial recognition technology being used. Mr. Freedman explained that with any type of contracted work, it would be going through the City Manager and would not necessarily come before the Council. He explained that the reason this item was before the Council was because Flock required permission to be able to operate within the right-of-way and attach their facilities to City property. He said that currently, the license provided Council the ability to give Flock notice of cancellation. Mr. MacGregor explained that Flock was focused on vehicles, and they did not offer facial recognition services. He said that the software did not allow them to search by human characteristics. He said that the company was not focused on people, so facial recognition was not on the roadmap. Councilmember Misjuns said he had concerns about the Constitutional impacts of the technology. He asked if they could impose a limitation that would require new features to be approved by the City. Mr. Freedman said that the Council could direct the City Attorney to modify the license to include restrictions on offering new features. He explained that the license component allowed the Council to terminate the agreement with notice. Councilmember Misjuns said he would support amending the license to require approval for additional features to be included in Flock's service. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked how agencies outside of the City could utilize the services and data. Mr. MacGregor stated that they had about 53,000 cameras installed across the country, and they allowed law enforcement agencies to share data with other agencies. He said that Bedford County had multiple cameras, and access could be shared with the City, and vice-versa. He said that their goal was to equip law enforcement agencies to work together to make communities safer. He said they had about 70 October 24, 2023 11 partners across the state. Vice Mayor Faraldi requested more information about the state-wide partners. He asked if Flock had provided a rebuttal to the ACLU memo from 2022. Mr. MacGregor said he would have to follow up to answer the question. Councilmember Misjuns asked if Flock had federal partners. Mr. MacGregor said he did not have specific details, but he would provide a follow up. Mayor Reed clarified that the system could only be queried for a license plate if the license plate was associated with a valid case number, and searches could be audited. Mr. Zuidema responded that for searching purposes, officers required unique log in credentials for the system, and they had policies stipulating when searches could be informed. He noted that when officers accessed the information, they were accessing state and federal information as well, which came with their own regulations. He said that there was an audit trail for each individual officer. Mayor Reed asked if the Raven system would be able to detect outdoor gunshots. Mr. Zuidema replied that if they implemented the system, it would generate a heatmap of where the gunshots were reported. Mayor Reed stated that she supported the proposal because it would help to solve crimes. She asked if there was feedback on the program from the state level. Mr. MacGregor said that he had met and presented to the Attorney General's Office, and they appeared to be supportive. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if the City would be the ones considered collecting the data stored by Flock, or if they would only be accessing the data through a third-party. Mr. Freedman said that the City would likely be considered to be subscribing to a third-party service which was collecting data through privately owned facilities. He said that the subscription would allow the City to access the data, and what was collected became part of a larger database. Mr. Zuidema said that they could provide furt her clarification on the legal impacts as a follow up. Councilmember Misjuns asked where the AWS servers were located. Mr. MacGregor said that the data was served from across the country. He said that there were multiple servers and databases. Councilmember Misjuns clarified that the data collection and privacy regulations would be tailored to the state and local laws for data collected in Lynchburg. He clarified that no matter where the data was held, it would be subject to state laws. Mr. MacGregor said that was correct. Councilmember Misjuns asked how compliance with the Virginia Data Collection Act would be achieved if someone wanted to request October 24, 2023 12 the information that had been collected about them. Mr. Freedman said that he would be able to look into the matter and follow up with answers to the other questions from Council members . // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda #8, the Council received a presentation on the Fusus Public Safety Platform by Chief of Police Mr. Ryan Zuidema. Fusus is an open and unified real -time intelligence service that serves as a platform for our Real-Time Crime Center to operate on. It allows us to collaborate with our community and other criminal justice agencies to improve situational awareness, more efficiently respond to criminal activity, and more effectively investigate and prosecute criminals. Fusus works with the LPD’s existing body camera and in-car camera technology allowing for enhanced operational and investigative capabilities. Additionally, Fusus allows for live video feeds to be sent to an emergency operations center or directly to officers in the field to enhance the safety of our officers. Hill City Connect is just one component of the Fusus ecosystem. It is a voluntary camera registration platform for residents and businesses who choose to partner with the LPD in an effort to proactively address criminal activity in our community. We are continuing to leverage technology as a means of making the most efficient use our investigative resources. Violent crime in Lynchburg has become increasingly more difficult to investigate, often as a result of uncooperative witnesses, and in some cases even uncooperative victims. The importance of video footage for criminal investigative purposes cannot be understated. Mr. Chris Taylor, Fusus, provided an informational presentation about the company and the technology used by the company. He explained that the system had device limitations for storage and a robust audit trail. He explained that the data was not subject to FOIA requests because it was owned by the businesses that agreed to provide the information. Councilmember Misjuns asked what limits were in place to prevent federal law enforcement and intelligence agencies from accessing the system without first obtaining a warrant. Mr. Taylor explained that the system did not stream the data to the servers from the private cameras. He stated that the data was stored locally at the businesses on the provided hardware, and when a user tried to access the camera, the feed was uploaded at that point. He noted that the devices only had enough storage for about five days' worth of footage, after which older footage would be overwritten. He said that video could be pulled from a large number of cameras, but there was an audit trail for each individual user, and all of the cameras were permission-based and read-only. Councilmember Misjuns asked for more information October 24, 2023 13 about the data retention policies. Mr. Taylor explained that to update the hardware storage capacity, it would require changing the device. Councilmember Misjuns asked if the AI software was able to identify people based on descriptions. Mr. Taylor said that they were able to look for certain identifiers through the AI software, such as vehicle make, model, or color, or for people with specific personal items, such as a backpack or wagon. He said that the AI was not capable of any more detailed identification, and they did not have the ability to make it better. He said that their goal was not to provide an AI service, but rather to unify police access to private resources and cameras. He noted that they did utilize AI tools, but they were not an AI company. He said that the camera data was not saved on servers, it was stored locally on the hardware devices at the private businesses. Councilmember Misjuns asked if they would be able to expand the AI functionality. Mr. Taylor said that they could expand, but they tried to tailor the AI tools to what would be helpful for law enforcement and investigations. Councilmember Mi sjuns requested that if the service were to expand AI capabilities, then the Council should have to grant prior approval. Mr. Benda clarified that they had spent about $250 thousand to contract with Fusus, and they had already secured business partners. He asked if the item would come back before Council under general business. Mr. Freedman stated that since the matter had gone through the Finance Committee and been approved by Council, the Council could have it come back before them through a motion to reconsider, however, it would not be appropriate to do so during the work session unless there was a 2/3 agreement to consider the motion. Councilmember Misjuns asked when it would be appropriate to consider a motion to reconsider. Mr. Freedman said that a motion to reconsider could be brought up at any point during the rules of procedure. He said that a motion to amend the agenda to include a motion to reconsider could be made, but under the Council's rules of procedure, such a motion could not be made during a work session without a 2/3 majority of Council. He noted that such matters were typically considered within the City Manager's duties. Councilmember Misjuns said he would like to see a way for the City to act as a check and balance on the improving technology. Vice Mayor Faraldi said that the motion could not be reconsidered since the motion was not made during the succeeding regular meeting. Mr. Freedman said that was correct, but if a majority of Council wanted to reconsider the matter, it could suspend the rules of procedure. October 24, 2023 14 Councilmember Helgeson suggested that they consider the motion to reconsider at the evening meeting or the next meeting. Councilmember Misjuns suggested holding a public hearing for the program to receive public impact. Mayor Reed asked if there was consensus to reconsider the motion. She noted there was not a majority consensus. // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Wilder announced that the Puzzled Car Truck and Bike show was held on Saturday at the Plaza, and he thanked the City staff and community for coordinating the event. Councilmember Helgeson announced that LCS enrollment had declined again, but Pre- K numbers had increased, and he said he was curious how it would impact the state aid received by the City. He s aid that he prepared a vision statement for the City to consider adopting. He said he hoped that the Council consider adopting it. Councilmember Misjuns said that he wanted to consider options regarding zoning to prevent elective abortion clinics from being built in the City. He said that the unborn were the most vulnerable population in the City. He said that there were localities in the state that had implemented restrictions on elective abortion clinics. He said he wanted to consider zoning ordinance res trictions. Mayor Reed recognized the Department of Human Resources and the contributions it made to City government. // On the motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, Council elected by the following recorded vote to enter into a closed session to discuss probable litigation (and other means of enforcement) to enforce the ban against “skill games” pursuant to §§ 2.2-3711(A)(7) and 2.2-3711(A)(8) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Helgeson, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and October 24, 2023 15 WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was recessed at 6:39pm // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jeff Helgeson, Larry Taylor, MaryJane Dolan, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // Vice Mayor Faraldi led the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Reed gave a Proclamation recognizing The Military Order of the World Wars (MOWW) National Public Safety/Law & Order Awards. Mike Reeves and Peter Bryan presented awards to Police Chief Ryan Zuidema and Fire Chief Greg Wormser for exceptional duty performance in keeping with the highest traditions of public service. // In the matter of Taxicabs, Agenda Item #2, a public hearing was held and Council considered adoption of an Ordinance #O-23-089 repealing Taxicab Regulations, as provided in Article II of Chapter 37 and Article IV of Chapter 2 of the Lynchburg City Code. Assistant City Manager Kent White provided a summary of the item to Council. City ordinances related to taxicabs have been in effect since 1931 and Council has reviewed them on multiple occasions. Chapter 37, Article II of city code includes requirements, such as, (i) regulation of taxicab rates; (ii) criminal background checks for taxicab driver applicants; (iii) standards for the issuance of permits to operate a taxicab; (iv) a provision, where proper, October 24, 2023 16 to revoke permits to operate taxicabs; and (v) an appeal process in the event the revocation of a permit to operate a taxicab was not proper. During the September 26, 2023 work session, Council directed staff to prepare ordinances to repeal provisions of city code that establish rates for taxicabs, along with any unnecessary regulations. The City Attorney's office has drafted two ordinances for Counci l's consideration -- Option 1 that repeals the entirety of the ordinance, and Ordinance 2 that repeals section 5 related to assigned rates. Prior to September 26, City Council last reviewed these requirements and adjusted the rates on February 22, 2022. As part of that packet, the taxicab owners board provided a letter unanimously supporting the City regulating the rate, citing it as a mechanism for taxicabs to avoid price wars and provide a means of fixed-rate transportation that families can build into their budget. The Lynchburg Police Department also supported their continued involvement in the registration of taxicab operators and drivers, in addition to enforcement of the other safety provisions defined in the code. Mayor Reed asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in favor of the ordinance. Seeing none, she asked if there was anyone to speak in opposition. Kimberly Dyke-Harsley addressed the Council in opposition to the proposed ordinance. She stated that Virginia Code stated that the governing body of the City may, by ordinance, regulate the rate of charges to taxicabs and may prescribe such reasonable regulations, but she questioned the legal definition of “may” in this circumstance. She said that in the Lynchburg City Charter, in expressing the powers and duties of City Council, it was stated that they were charged with regulation of all transportation of all articles through the streets of the City. She requested Council to listen to stakeholders in order to make the best decision for the citizens. Mayor Reed asked if there were any other speakers in opposition. Seeing none, she asked if there were any voicemails from citizens. Clerk of Council Alicia L. Finney replied there were none. Mayor Reed closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson said that he supported Option 2 because it gave their police the ability to inspect that vehicles were safe, as well as allowing private businesses to set their rates. He motioned, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, to adopt Option 2 as presented. Councilmember Wilder said that he would not support the motion due to taxicab companies previously communicating a preference for the regulations as they currently stand. October 24, 2023 17 Councilmember Dolan stated that she was supportive of Option 2 for the reason of competing creatively, With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Reed, Misjuns 4 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi, Taylor 3 // In the matter of Public Comment, Item #3, Lisa Giri was not present to address Council. // In the matter of Public Comment, Item #4, Cherie Kemper addressed Council regarding housing. She said that for those in Lynchburg who could not utilize the Housing Authority, they had to turn to steeply - priced rental places that required tenants’ income to be three times the rent. This made it extremely difficult to find a home in Lynchburg when rent was over $800 per month. She requested that this income requirement be adjusted so that people could afford to stay housed, and that vacant homes in the City be renovated and rented to those in need. // In the matter of Public Comment, Item #5, Gary Taylor, representing Citizens for a Better Lynchburg, addressed Council regarding the role of media in politics. He said that it was unclear if an entire story got out through the media when a lot of misinformation was spread, so he would ask the media to do a better job of incorporating the entire story. He emphasized the importance of facts being available, as well as transparency and accuracy in reporting so citizens could fairly and objectively evaluate what they were being told. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #6, Citizen Kathleen Davis spoke regarding community concerns regarding Council behavior and what it was doing to tarnish the name of the City. She expressed concerns about the Council's ability to manage City business, and she requested that the Council consider ousting Councilmember Misjuns due to his prior actions. // In the matter of Public Safety, Agenda Item #7, Council considered introducing Resolution #R-23-090 amending the FY 2024 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $47,138 to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department and technology equipment for the Lynchburg Sheriff's Office and the Office of the Commonwealth's Attorney. October 24, 2023 18 At its October 24, 2023 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Vice Mayor Faraldi brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Helgeson, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Police Department, Agenda Item #8, Council considered introducing Resolution #R-23- 091 amending the FY 2024 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $25,800 to facilitate speed enforcement activities. At its October 24, 2023 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Vice Mayor Faraldi brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Helgeson, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Police Department, Agenda Item #9, Council considered introducing Resolution #R-23- 092 amending the FY 2024 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $26,400 to facilitate selective enforcement activities, equipment, and training. At its October 24, 2023 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Vice Mayor Faraldi brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Helgeson, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Police Department, Agenda Item #10, Council considered introducing Resolution #R- 23-093 amending the FY 2024 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriat ing $55,618 for the purchase of 56 replacement bulletproof vests for law enforcement officers. October 24, 2023 19 At its October 24, 2023 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Vice Mayor Faraldi brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Helgeson, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Zoning, Agenda Item #11, the item “Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-23-___ denying a Conditional Use Permit and Resolution #R-23-___ denying an amendment of the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) that would allow the construction of nineteen (19) apartments to be located at 3146 and 3150 Wards Ferry Road.”, was pulled by the petitioner. // In the matter of Legislative Agenda, Agenda Item #12, Council considered adopting Resolution #R -23- 094 approving the 2024 Legislative Agenda for the City of Lynchburg. Vice Mayor Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, to adopt the Resolution #R - 23-094. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to amend the legislative agenda, under education, to support legislation that would promote school choice for parents and children accomplished by allowing funding to follow the child to the public, private, or faith-based school of the parent's choice. Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that he would withdraw his motion so that the proffered amendment could be considered by the Council as a whole. Councilmember Helgeson said that school choice would benefit families and students. Councilmember Wilder said that he did not support the motion, and he did not support school choice. Councilmember Dolan said she believed the motion was another effort to dismantle the school system, and the City should not be promoting using tax-payer dollars for private or Christian schools. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Helgeson, Taylor, Faraldi 5 Noes: Wilder, Dolan 2 October 24, 2023 20 Vice Mayor Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Taylor, to adopt the Resolution #R- 23-094. Councilmember Helgeson said that he supported some measures while he did not support others, but his vote for approval was based on the total package. Councilmember Wilder said that he did not support the legislative agenda, because he did not support elected school boards, and he did not support school choice. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Helgeson, Taylor, Faraldi, Dolan 6 Noes: Wilder 1 // In the matter of Finance, Agenda Item #13, Council received a second reading and considered adopting Resolution #R-23-088 to amend the FY 2024 General Fund budget and appropriate up to $2,455,000 for 12th Street Stabilization. Councilmember Helgeson motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt Resolution #R-23-088. Councilmember Helgeson noted that 12th Street had been closed for months, so they needed to take action to stabilize the street. He noted that staff had considered several options to arrive at a reasonable solution. Councilmember Wilder said that the reason they had taxes was to support projects and maintenance such as this proposal. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Reed, Misjuns, Helgeson, Dolan, Taylor, Wilder 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // The meeting adjourned at 8:18 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.