RecordWell Data

City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Sep 12, 2023 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY COUNCIL Tuesday, September 12, 2023 | 7:30 PM Council Chamber- City Hall 900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 CITY COUNCIL AGENDA I. Invocation Councilmember Helgeson II. Recognitions II.1. Virginia Committee of Employer Support of Guard & Reserve Award - Lynchburg Fire Department III. Consent Agenda III.2. Consideration of approving the minutes from 2022 City Council Meetings. III.3. Consideration of approving the minutes from 2023 City Council Meetings. III.4. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-23-069 amending Lynchburg City Schools Major Classification Funding for FY 2024. IV. Public Hearing IV.5. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-23-___ granting a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to allow the construction of a 150 foot telecommunications tower to be located at 119 Leroy Bowen Drive. V. Public Comment V.6. Hear from a citizen "concerning the closure of Dearington Elementary School". (Consuela Mosley) V.7. Hear from a citizen regarding the "LCS Facilities Master Plan". (Kimberly Dyke- Harsley) V.8. Hear from a citizen regarding "[September 12, 2023 Roll Call items.]" (Gail Goldsmith) V.9. Hear from a citizen regarding "Lynchburg Poice Department Staffing." (Martin Misjuns) V.10. Hear from a group representative regarding the "Lynchburg Regional Business Alliance." (Scott Kowalski)(Lynchburg Regional Business Alliance) V.11. Hear from a citizen regarding the "Merit Resolution." (Peter Cefaratti) V.12. Hear from a citizen regarding "the proposed closure of TC Miller Elementary." (Mark Furlow) V.13. Hear from a citizen regarding "Merit, Excellence, and Opportunity (MEO) Resolution." (John Vassar) VI. General Business VI.14. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-23-___ approving the execution of a negotiated Comprehensive Agreement between the Lynchburg City School Page 1 of 564 Our Mission: To elevate the quality of life through excellent city services. Board/Lynchburg City Schools and Southern Air, Inc. for the design and construction of heating system upgrades at Dunbar Middle School. VI.15. Consideration of introducing Resolution #R-23-___ amending the FY 2024 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $57,200 for the purchase of one (1) Lifepak 15 monitor/defibrillator and one (1) Lucas 2 chest compression system. VI.16. Second Reading: Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-23-070 amending the FY 2024 General Fund budget and appropriating up to $100,000 and transferring a full-time vacant benefited employment position from a City department to the Office of the General Registrar for the purpose of helping the General Registrar with staffing issues. VII. Closed Session Page 2 of 564 City Council Agenda Item III.2. Consent Agenda AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY September 12, 2023 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council AGENDA ITEM # III.2 Consideration of approving the minutes from 2022 City Council Meetings. RECOMMENDATION Approve the outstanding minutes from the 2022 City Council meetings. SUMMARY April 26, 2022 City Council Meeting Minutes May 10, 2022 City Council Meeting Minutes May 24, 2022 City Council Meeting Minutes June 7, 2022 Special Called Meeting Minutes June 28, 2022 City Council Meeting Minutes July 26, 2022 Special Called Meeting Minutes August 23, 2022 Special Called Meeting Minutes September 13, 2022 Joint Work Session LCS/City Council Meeting Minutes and City Council Meeting September 27, 2022 City Council Meeting Minutes PRIOR ACTION(S) N/A FISCAL IMPACT N/A CONTACT(S) Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council ATTACHMENT(S) 1. 2022 Meeting.Minute List REVIEWED BY Date: September 07, 2023 Page 3 of 564 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 4 of 564 Meeting Approved April 26, 2022 May 10, 2022 May 16, 2022 May 20, 2022 May 24, 2022 June 7, 2022 June 28, 2022 July 26, 2022 August 23, 2022 September 13, 2022 September 27, 2022 October 4, 2022 October 11, 2022 October 25, 2022 November 1, 2022 November 14, 2022 December 13, 2022 2022 City Council Meeting Minutes Page 5 of 564 April 26, 2022 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 26th day of April 2022, at 4:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Agenda Item #1, Council continued a discussion on redistricting. Mr. Kent White, Director of Community Development, gave a brief overview of the item to the Council. The Council was previously briefed on this matter on April 12, 2022. This was the fifth work session for redistricting, which was required based on the results of the 2020 Census. Staff requested direction from Council on selecting a scenario for adoption, with the intent of advertising the public hearing and bringing the item back on May 24, 2022 to discuss precinct boundary changes in that day’s work session, and finalizing in June to allow adequate time for notice prior to the November election. He said that the survey for public input has been reopened but no responses had been received as of yet. Vice Mayor Wright clarified that at the previous Council meeting, he had mentioned that he wished to provide another redistricting map to consider, but after discussion with staff, he decided that it was best to not submit the new map. Councilmember Faraldi made a motion to adopt the Resolution in conjunction with Option D, seconded by Councilmember Nelson. Councilmember Faraldi said that Option D met many of the requirements of the state while also addressing the growth in the majority of the City. He said that further, the corresponding data from staff indicates that this option is best supported by the public who was surveyed, and that this option was closest to the standard deviation. Councilmember Nelson said that the standard deviation for this item was the best that they had, and as such was most likely to survive without any modifications when the next Census was taken in 2030, which translated to not disrupting more citizens after the next Census. Councilmember Helgeson said that ward-specific issues have historically been addressed by the public officials who represented that ward and that representative was given deference when dealing with Page 6 of 564 April 26, 2022 2 specific issues. He said that he could support Option D, but his stated preference was a scenario that presented minimal impact to citizens, and Option D had noticeable impact on the ward he represents. Vice Mayor Wright said that he was in greatest support of Scenario B, because it had a relatively low impact on citizens and would limit confusion among the public, and thus lessening the work the Registrar’s Office would be performing related to the redistricting process. Councilmember Wilder said that finding the least disruptive option was his primary focus, and while he understood the drive to keep the neighborhood structures contained, citizens would certainly be confused by this change, so he was more in support of Scenarios A and B. Councilmember Tweedy said that she supported a scenario that had the least impact on their residents. Mayor Dolan said that she supported a scenario with the least impact, and ultimately preferred Scenario B. Councilmember Faraldi asked how many total people would be affected by a change in polling precinct rather than in representation of their ward. Mr. White responded that for Scenario D, 9,777 people would change from one ward to another. Ward I would gain population from Ward IV and would also gain from Ward II. Councilmember Faraldi asked how many voters were in the precinct for 101, which currently under Scenario D would be split in half down Lakeside Drive. General Registrar Ms. Christine Gibbons answered that from the November 3, 2020 election, there were 4,789 registered voters and a total turnout for the election of 3,222, and Ward IV had 5,148 registered voters in 2020 with a turnout of 3,746. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the changes only affected the residents between those two precincts. Ms. Gibbons answered that she would not know that information until she physically changed the precinct streets. Councilmember Faraldi reiterated that he was supportive of Scenario D because it did not split neighborhoods in the way that Scenarios A and B did. Councilmember Helgeson asked if there were any other changes that could be made to compromise and allow for precincts to stay the same while allowing for changes in representation of the Wards. Mr. White answered that it varied. Mayor Dolan asked if this would be more advantageous to Councilmember Helgeson. Councilmember Helgeson replied that it was not more advantageous, but that amendments could be made to these scenarios. Mayor Dolan said that she was viewing the numbers of Page 7 of 564 April 26, 2022 3 people impacted, and Scenario A moved a small number in Councilmember Helgeson’s ward. Councilmember Helgeson said that it moved 1,050 people, and asked Mr. White if that number was equal to those affected in Scenario D. Mr. White responded that it was about the same between the two scenarios for those affected in Councilmember Helgeson’s ward. Mayor Dolan asked what the long-term effect was of Scenario D. Councilmember Helgeson said that the long-term effects were that over the next 10 years, changes would be made, and those changes must distribute growth more equally around the City so redistricting would not need to happen again. Councilmember Faraldi said that in 10 years, Scenarios A and B would require significant adjustments because the growth in the south end of town was projected to continue, and Scenario D allowed them to make that adjustment now to avoid impacting the future, larger population. Vice Mayor Wright said that while there was general consensus about where the future growth was projected to occur, they could not predict it, and regardless of where the growth was, there would be boundary modifications required to accommodate any change. Councilmember Faraldi said that he did not disagree with Vice Mayor Wright, but by making the adjustment now, it would give minimal impacts in the future because they were acknowledging the growth areas that exist currently. Councilmember Helgeson said that the future growth would have to occur in areas other than the southern end of the City based on how developed it currently is in that area. Councilmember Nelson said that he agreed with Councilmembers Faraldi and Wright that things would certainly change over 10 years, but Scenario D was closest to the standard deviation and could absorb any large population growth better than A or B, therefore impacting the least amount of citizens over time by limiting future changes. He added that Scenario B did not follow contiguity or compactness as well as Scenario C or Scenario D, and in order to be true to the philosophies of the movement against gerrymandering, Scenario D was the best choice to make. With no further discussion, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Nelson, Helgeson, Dolan, Faraldi 4 Noes: Tweedy, Wright, Wilder 3 // In the matter of Economic Development, Agenda Item #2, Council received a presentation from Ms. Marjette Upshur, Director of the Office of Economic Development and Tourism, on the 2022 special events for spring and summer. All sectors in the City have seen a growth in special events for this fiscal Page 8 of 564 April 26, 2022 4 year, with 11 races, 3 food and beverage events, and 20 community engagement events, and the Office of Economic Development and Tourism was on track to permit more than 42 special events this year with a total economic impact of over $2 million. Special events, whether offered by the City of Lynchburg, businesses or nonprofit partners, contribute to community pride, quality of place and help to enhance Lynchburg as a great place to live, work, and play. The Office of Economic Development and Tourism will distribute a roundup of events planned throughout the City through summer 2022. The summer events flyer was attached in the Council materials and was available at www.lynchburgvirginia.org/events. // In the matter of Agenda Item #3, “Housing Toolkit,” Council reviewed proposed changes to City Code to address neighborhood blight abatement strategies. Mr. Kent White, Director of Community Development, gave a brief overview of the item to the Council. On March 8, 2022, staff presented a strategy to use the targeted sale of tax delinquent properties, additional demolition resources, and City Code changes to help address the impacts of derelict housing and clutter. One recurring theme during the recent Strong Neighborhood Alliance’s listening sessions in Diamond Hill is the impact of derelict housing and blight on the neighborhood as a whole. This feedback is consistent with concerns expressed in other neighborhood planning efforts and complaints that City Council and staff receive. The proposed derelict building ordinance would require owners to submit a plan to repair or remove the structure. The code is structured to incentivize owners to correct the issue or transfer ownership to someone who would correct it, and after a grace period, residential structures without a plan of action could be fined $500 per month up to the cost of demolition. There is no proposal for additional staffing, so the process would be measured with a focus on condemned buildings, with the penalty payments supporting demolition funding. There is a current inconsistency of demolition requirements of a private owner removing the structure versus the City; the proposed amendments for the demolition code would codify the demolition requirements to require private owners and contractors to match City standards. Amendments to the City’s nuisance ordinance would add items including mechanical equipment, household furniture, and containers that can be seen from a public street, and would include materials that were not intended for use within 30 days, or if there was no active building permit. There would be an outreach campaign performed before citing anyone, with a 30-day reminder letter sent prior to any violation notice, and if the issue still remained, the timing and billing of the removal would be communicated. Page 9 of 564 April 26, 2022 5 Councilmember Helgeson said that the goal for this program is to help renovate these vacant or derelict buildings, and the examples given were illustrative in how drastically it could improve the property and the surrounding neighborhood. He asked what incentives there were for promoting this behavior of homeowners. Mr. White said that staff previously presented five overall strategies, one being to discuss what incentives existed and what priorities should be made for these individual properties. Councilmember Helgeson said that being able to adequately provide incentives to developers and homeowners was integral to solving the issue. Councilmember Wilder said that there were many older homes in Ward II, with a variety of homeowner issues, so he was glad to see this as another option in their housing toolkit to address blight and clutter in their community. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the changes to the demolition ordinance were counterintuitive, because it took away the preferential treatment of a private owner to remove derelict buildings by giving the responsibility to the City. Mr. White said that many of these derelict houses are located in the most densely populated areas of the City, and a focus was minimizing the impact to the neighbors by giving them appreciating values. One important incentive was that the demolition permit costs were waived. Councilmember Helgeson asked how much a permit for demolition cost. Mr. White answered that the amount varied based on the size of the structure, but was a few hundred dollars. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the City had ever resisted demolishing derelict houses. Mr. White replied that his position from Community Development was never that demolition is bad, but the goa l is to have demolition with something to follow, and multiple tools and pathways for owners are a part of that. Councilmember Helgeson said that if there is a way to incentivize individuals to do so, it would be beneficial. Mr. White said that they would take lead from Council, as it is a separate ordinance, but it is true that there would be potential for costs and they should make sure they were not further negatively impacting those living next to these structures. Councilmember Helgeson asked if Mr. White could address the issue of clutter. Mr. White said that there was a state code change in 2021 that addressed specific items and gave an expansion of power on that item. Councilmember Faraldi asked if there was an appeals process in the proposal. Mr. White said that there was both an administrative appeals process Page 10 of 564 April 26, 2022 6 for nuisance and clutter, and an administrative and Council-appointed appeals body for building code issues. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the owner had the ability to combat the administrative ruling in court. Mr. White said yes. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the notification would be communicated only by physical mail or if electronic means of communication could be used. Mr. White said that the requirement is that they post the property as well as take the time to mail it to the mailing address on file. // In the matter of the Airport, Agenda Item #4, Council opened the bidding process for the Freedom Aviation Franchise Bid Opening and Acceptance. As a result of legal notice that was published in the News & Advance on March 24, 2022, and again on April 1, 2022 one bid was received on April 6, 2022 from Freedom Aviation. Mayor Dolan addressed the audience and asked if there were any additional bids offered; there were none and Mayor Dolan declared the bidding closed. Councilmember Helgeson said that Freedom Aviation had relation to Liberty University, and he must disclose that he is an adjunct professor at Liberty University, however he could participate in this discussion objectively and openly to cast a vote for or against this regarding this franchise. Councilmember Faraldi made a motion to accept the bid. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, and the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Dolan, Wright, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 Mayor Dolan announced that there would be a public hearing at the April 26, 2022, at 7:30 p.m. in Council Chamber to hear from members of the public regarding the adoption of an ordinance granting the franchise to the successful bidder. // In the matter of Animal Control, Agenda Item #5A, the Council was briefed on the Extreme Weather/Dogs in Cars Ordinance by Mr. Ryan Ball, Chief Animal Warden. The item will appear before City Council for action on May 10, 2022. On March 26, 2019 City Council approved §7-43, and subsequent amendments were requested to be made to the City ordinance due to 2020 Virginia legislation changes to the definition of “adequate shelter,” which added language requiring a windbreak at the entrance to a dog house in cold weather and properly shaded shelter in hot weather. The proposed ordinance also creates specific language that properly addresses the problem of animals left in vehicles during the summer heat, so that if it was 75ºF or greater outside, it would be classified as a Class 4 Page 11 of 564 April 26, 2022 7 misdemeanor, and a repeat offense would be classified as a Class 2 misdemeanor. The current terminology and classifications were inadequate to describe animals left in cars, so the ordinance provides animal control officers and police officers the ability to navigate the situation with discretion and communicate to the public that dogs should only be in the car when necessary and never should be left in cars. This ordinance did not affect transporting dogs in the bed of pickup trucks, but if that situation became unsafe, the charge of animal cruelty would apply. Councilmember Faraldi asked about §3, which dealt with animals in cars. He asked if a cat would qualify in these scenarios for the intent of the ordinance and if it met the definition in actuality. Mr. Ball said that specifically included were dogs, but they could certainly change the language to encompass domesticated animals or pets. Councilmember Faraldi said that there was no exemption as he read the ordinance that allowed for a situation such as if the car was running or had “significant airflow” such as windows or sunroof being opened. Mr. Ball said that he would be amenable to including that information. Councilmember Faraldi said that he would specifically look for that when approving it in the future. He asked what the fines associated with Class 2 and Class 4 misdemeanors. Mr. Ball replied that Class 2 offered a $1000 fine and jailtime, and Class 4 was up to a $250 fine. Councilmember Faraldi asked if temperatures above 95ºF were included in the ordinance under the information for doghouses in §C. Mr. Ball replied that for temperatures above 95ºF, the dog was supposed to be brought indoors. Councilmember Faraldi asked if that information was contained in the associated materials. Mr. Ball said yes, it was contained under §B-2. Councilmember Faraldi said that the only item he would like to see would be an addition that gives exemption for airflow. Mayor Dolan said that many people left their dog in the car with the air conditioning on, so language to acknowledge that would be helpful. Councilmember Nelson asked what a windbreak for a doghouse was. Mr. Ball said that a windbreak was a plastic flap that covered the entrance. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #5b, Council was briefed on the Cornerstone Condominiums, 1240 Greenview Drive. The item will appear before City Council for action on May 10, 2022. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, summarized to Council that Cornerstone Professional Offices, LLC is petitioning for a CUP at 1213 Greenview Drive to allow three additional condominium units in the Cornerstone TND. Page 12 of 564 April 26, 2022 8 The property is zoned R-1 Residential, and the future land use map of the comprehensive plan recommends it be a mixed-use area. The additional units would exceed the 600 multi-family units approved for the Cornerstone TND. The proposed buildings would contain commercial office space facing Greenview Drive, consisting of approximately 4,200 square feet, and a total of three residential units would be constructed on the upper levels of the building. The units were not expected to have an overall detrimental impact on the area, which is near a signalized intersection at Greenview Drive and Lighthouse Drive, and no additional curb cuts would be made onto Greenview Drive as a result of this development. The Technical Review Committee reviewed the petition on March 22, 2022 with no major comments of concern, and the Planning Commission recommended approval (5-1) with one vacancy of the CUP petition, and they recommended approval of the rezoning petition on April 13, 2022. Councilmember Helgeson said that he was not in favor of the petition as presented, because it was missing the intent and codified requirements of the TND, which set the maximum limit of 600 condominiums. He mentioned that a recent proposal requesting the same type of exception for a different property was denied by the Council. He asked if the property could be removed from the Cornerstone TND. Ms. Frischeisen replied that from Council’s perspective, that would be held as a public hearing, and from the TND perspective, it was unclear what it would mean to remove this block from Cornerstone. Councilmember Helgeson said that he did not wish to allow an excess of the maximum allowable units in the Cornerstone TND, so another solution would have to be presented before the item returned on May 10, 2022. Councilmember Wilder asked if the Planning Commission expressed any concerns. Ms. Frischeisen said that one member dissented over the matter for the same reason that Councilmember Helgeson stated, which was that it was reaching above the maximum allowable units. There was discussion of what the allocation was of all the units and if there was flexibility of the unit ranges, but overall, there was not concern over adding the three units. Staff continued to view objectively from the perspective of it the matter negatively impacted the area, which it should not, however, if Council wishe s to adhere to the maximum allowed amount of 1,000, that is within its right. Councilmember Wilder asked how many units were proposed in the petition recently denied by Council, mentioned by Councilmember Helgeson. Ms. Frischeisen said that it was 12 units. Page 13 of 564 April 26, 2022 9 Councilmember Helgeson asked if the current petition was equivalent or greater than 12 units. Ms. Frischeisen stated that there were three units, and the bottom floor was a commercial unit. Councilmember Faraldi said that he agreed with Councilmember Helgeson that if it was across the street and clearly away from the TND, removing the block from the TND would be appropriate. He asked if there would be a legal implication if they approved amending the TND while having recently denied a similar project. Mr. Freedman replied that he would have to look into the matter with Community Development staff. Ms. Frischeisen said that the property had been described as a townhouse with commercial on the bottom, but from a zoning perspective, that would be viewed more as multi-family. Councilmember Helgeson said that another solution could be sought rather than exceeding the regulations of the TND. Ms. Frischeisen said that they would discuss options with Mr. Freedman’s office. // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item #6, Councilmember Tweedy said that she had received complaints about the business that sat across from E.C. Glass and the Plaza, and she would provide more information later. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda asked if it was the Dollar General. Councilmember Tweedy said yes. Councilmember Faraldi said that last night, he attended the first community conversations with City schools at Sandusky Elementary regarding the facilities study, and the next one was the upcoming Monday at Linkhorne Elementary. He noted that the Lieutenant Governor was in Lynchburg on Friday, joining LU Serve, an event with Liberty students who cleaned up and tended to things around Lynchburg, to do some gardening work at the Boys and Girls Club. He said that Lynchburg firefighters are currently fundraising and have devoted an immeasurable amount of time to acquiring funds for the fire department. Councilmember Wilder said that this past Saturday, Liberty University had over 1,200 students from the community representing various nonprofits and agencies that provided services to the community. He said that the City also has a group called the Strong Neighborhoods Alliance that was working in the community with an event called “Clean Your Block Party,” which is a much appreciated effort that helped to make the entire community better. He said that he also attended a very informative session along with the Lieutenant Governor and Senator Kaine at the Lynchburg Water Resources Treatment Plant. He congratulated the University of Lynchburg for a program called “Lynchburg Tomorrow,” a free leadership workshop offered to 10th-12th graders on May 4th. Page 14 of 564 April 26, 2022 10 Vice Mayor Wright said that he offered his thanks to the City team that made the state of the City possible last week, the community members and Councilmembers who were able to attend last week , and to those who received the Mayor’s Award for Excellence. Mayor Dolan recognized the Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office for their recent support for the citizens of Ukraine. The Sheriff’s Office not only responded to a call to action to donate expired body armor to the Lift Up Ukraine Organization, but went beyond the line of duty to partner with Lift Up Ukraine to organize donation of the body armor for over 50 law enforcement agencies throughout the state. This protective gear has been now equipped in Ukraine as they protected their country. The Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office not only demonstrates their desire to keep the citizens of Lynchburg safe on a daily basis, but answered the call to help and protect citizens around the world. She said that May 1st–7th was National Travel and Tourism Week, a time when travel and tourism professionals across the country united to celebrate the value that travel holds for their economy, businesses, and personal wellbeing. In 2020, the City of Lynchburg tourism jobs comprised 3,245 of their local employment, and the tourism industry drove $18.9M in state and local revenues. During National Travel and Tourism Week, the Office of Economic Development and Tourism encouraged citizens to celebrate and thank restaurants, retail, attractions, and lodging partners that made an impact on their workforce, economy, and community. She noted that the Mayor’s Youth Council is very busy this year working on a project, with the culmination being a mural painted across from the skate park, to be completed on Saturday. She thanke d the Public Works Department for the help in orchestrating the project. // The meeting was recessed at 5:31 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan proclaimed May 1, 2022 – May 7, 2022 as Drinking Water Week. Director of Water Resources Mr. Tim Mitchell was in attendance to accept. Page 15 of 564 April 26, 2022 11 Mayor Dolan also proclaimed April 26, 2022 as Gary Christie Day in honor of the retirement of Mr. Gary Christie, Executive Director of Central Virginia Planning District Commission. Mr. Christie and wife Fran Christie were in attendance to accept. Mayor Dolan presented Rev. Dr. Carl B. Hutcherson, Jr. with a Key to the City, recognizing his service to the City of Lynchburg. She also recognized his recent retirement as senior pastor of First Baptist Church of South Lynchburg and proclaimed April 26, 2022 as Rev. Dr. Carl B. Hutcherson, Jr. Day. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda Item A, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Ordinance #O-22-024 releasing surplus funds received by the City from the delinquent tax sa le of 1119 Wise Street to Robert L. Crews, Sr., the prior sole owner of that property. On motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda Item B, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Resolution #R-22-029 appropriating $50,000 of the FY 2023 Reserve for Contingencies for use by the City Manager. On motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda Item C, copies of the minutes of the February 4, 2022 meeting have been previously furnished to Council. Councilmember Faraldi stated he would be abstaining from the vote due to his absence from this meeting. On motion of Vice Mayor Wright, seconded b y Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 6 Noes: 0 Abstain: Faraldi 1 Page 16 of 564 April 26, 2022 12 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda Item D, copies of the minutes of the February 8, 2022 meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Agenda Item #7, a public hearing was held and Council received citizen input regarding appointments to vacancies that will exist June 30, 2022, in School Board Districts I, II, and III. Mayor Dolan read the names of the citizens who had volunteered to serve on the School Board and the School Districts in which they lived: School District 1 had Mr. James Porter, Mr. Clifton Reed, Ms. Ashley Reich, Ms. Brandy Gibbs, Mr. Anthony Andrews, Ms. Mary Wieberg, Dr. Justin Hensley, Mr. Elliot Clifton, and Ms. Marianne Criswell. School District 2 had Dr. Veronica McCue, Ms. Letitia Lowery, Dr. Martin Day, Ms. Erin Cruz, and Ms. Charleta Mason. School District 3 had Dr. Jason Fleshman, Mr. John Miska, Mr. Gary Woodson, and Mr. Steven Smith. Mayor Dolan opened the floor to any candidates who would like to speak at tonight’s public hearing. Dr. Martin Day, nominee for School District 2, spoke before the Council. Ms. Letitia Lowery, nominee for School District 2, spoke before the Council. Mr. James Porter, nominee for School District 1, spoke before the Council. Dr. Veronica McCue, nominee for School District 2, spoke before the Council. Ms. Brandy Gibbs, nominee for School District 1, spoke before the Council. Ms. Erin Cruz, nominee for School District 2, spoke before the Council. Dr. Jason Fleshman, nominee for School District 3, spoke before the Council. Dr. Justin Hensley, nominee for School District 1, spoke before the Council. Mr. Clifton Reed, nominee for School District 1, spoke before the Council. Mr. Steven Smith, nominee for School District 3, spoke before the Council. Ms. Charleta Mason, nominee for School District 2, spoke before the Council. Mayor Dolan opened the floor to any citizens present who would like to comment upon any name that had been submitted, or offer additional names for consideration. Page 17 of 564 April 26, 2022 13 Ms. Susan D. Morrison, School Board Member, spoke in favor of Anthony Andrews for School District 1. Mr. Andrew Glover spoke about the need to appoint members who will listen to parents. Clerk of Council Ms. Alicia L. Finney read Mr. Anthony Andrews’ emailed statement into the record which spoke to his qualifications to perform as a School Board member. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to keep the public hearing open until May 10, 2022, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, and with no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 Mayor Dolan stated that the public hearing would remain open until May 10, 2022. // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #8, a public hearing was held and Council considered a Resolution #R-22-032 amending the FY2022 Operating and Capital Budgets and appropriating or rescinding funds to reflect the FY2022 Third Quarter Detail by Fund. The Council was previously briefed on this matter at the April 12, 2022 work session Business Item briefing. Ms. Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, gave an overview to Council. The third quarter adjustments were needed prior to the end of the fiscal year and represented multiple funds, and since that presentation, three chang es had been made to Attachment A regarding the General Fund, with two items being removed in regard to the Registrar’s Office because they were no longer needed and one $7,000 item added to the Attorney General’s Office for temporary staff. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Vice Mayor Wright made a motion to adopt the Resolution, seconded by Councilmember Wilder. Vice Mayor Wright stated that line item information for the budget could be accessed on the City Council webpage. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 Page 18 of 564 April 26, 2022 14 // In the matter of the Airport, Agenda Item #9, a public hearing was held and Council considered approving an Ordinance #O-22-033 granting a franchise to Freedom Aviation, Inc., to construct, manage, and operate a new aircraft maintenance/storage hangar and office facility. The Council was previously briefed on this matter at the March 22, 2022 City Council work session Business Item briefing, and the Lynchburg Regional Airport Commission formally recommended adoption on April 18, 2022. Councilmember Helgeson said that while he was unsure of the relationship between Freedom Aviation and Liberty University, he would disclose his status as an adjunct professor of finance at Liberty University, but believed that he could participate in this matter fairly, objecti vely, and in the public interest. Mr. Andrew La Gala, Airport Director, stated that Freedom Aviation has been operating as a fixed base operator (FBO) and tenant at Lynchburg Regional Airport (LYH) since acquiring Falwell Aviation in 2011. In 2014, Freedom Aviation purchased the airport’s other FBO, Virginia Aviation, and was subsequently awarded a separate lease by City Council effective October 1, 2015. Since that time, Freedom Aviation has operated under two separate agreements: the original 20 -year, six-month Falwell Aviation franchise agreement with an expiration of December 2027 and a revised Virginia Aviation lease set to expire in June 2023. Consequently, in order to consolidate its operations and to accommodate growing demand for its aviation services, Freedom Aviation desires to expand its aeronautical facilities through the construction of a new 19,600 square-foot aircraft hangar at LYH, while combining its current facilities contained in its two existing agreements under one franchise ordinance. This franchise consists of two terms; Term One is 20-year, six months for certain facilities (shown in the presentation) and Term Two is for five years with a five-year option for the remaining facilities. Based on the terms proposed under the franchise, Virginia law requires advertising for bids and a public hearing before voting on whether to adopt the franchise and grant proposed. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Faraldi made a motion to adopt the Ordinance, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson. Councilmember Nelson said that extensive discussions and analysis of the facilities and operations at the airport had been going on for the past six years, with the result of a lease and franchise Page 19 of 564 April 26, 2022 15 that was now expiring, and the lessons of what could be done with the airport were reflected in the expiring lease and franchise and injected into the new arrangement. He said that he was pleased to support this. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Public Comment, the Council heard from a group representative, Dr. John Vassar, Jr. of the Oasis Special Needs Parents Support Group, addressed the City Council. It came to the attention of the group that the upcoming Lynchburg City budget had a reduction of 25% of funding for special needs education in relation to the proposed funding level for other students. They noted that special education, in addition to being a federal mandate, was meant to execute programs that allowed students to become productive, taxpaying citizens. His wife is a corporate CEO who served in the education market space, and recently toured their local special education facilities. She was quite disappointed at the appa rent lack of resources and dismal atmosphere despite the heroic efforts of the staff and faculty. There was a significant budget surplus that could easily cover the shortfall with minimal reduction to the surplus. He noted that they were on the verge of an unavoidable economic downturn, and if they remembered the collapse of City tax revenue during 1930-1933, the budget surplus should be used to finance the City during the next recession. // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #10, the Council considered adopting an Ordinance #O-22-034 approving the comprehensive agreement for the design and construction of a new police headquarters and to approve the acquisition of property. The Council was previously briefed on this matter at the March 8, 2022 City Council public hearing on the PPEA proposals received for the project. Mr. Ryan Zuidema, Chief of Police, gave a brief overview to staff. After thorough negotiation, the form of the final negotiated comprehensive agreement was posted to the City’s website for public inspection and review on April 19, 2022. The comprehensive agreement is ready for review and approval by the City Council, but will not be signed until the associated posting requirement is satisfied. Vice Mayor Wright said that the contract contained a contingency amount of $1.75M, and anything remaining from that contingency would be split on a 70/30 basis with English retaining. He asked Page 20 of 564 April 26, 2022 16 if that was customary in agreements such as this for a contingency amount to not come back to th e sponsoring entity but to be split in such a manner. Mr. Zuidema said that he would defer to Mr. Freedman or Mr. Benda for that information, but there were negotiations contained within the documents that led to that agreement. Mr. Benda said that usually, the agreement was a 50/50 split, but in these negotiations, the projected costs associated had increased, so for English that split allowed for them to continue. Vice Mayor Wright asked if any of the money was expected to remain at the end of the process . Mr. Benda answered no. Councilmember Faraldi made a motion to adopt the Ordinance #O-22-034, seconded by Councilmember Wilder. City Attorney Mr. Matthew C. Freedman clarified that the motion was the adoption of the Ordinance before the City Council, titled “An uncodified ordinance to approve a comprehensive agreement for the design and construction of a new police headquarters building, authorize the acquisition of related real property, and authorize other actions related to such comprehensive agreement.” Councilmember Helgeson said that it was also approving approximately $47M in funding, which he was glad to support to build this much-needed facility. He asked what the construction timeline was expected to be. Chief Zuidema answered that the most recent schedule provided by English Construction Company estimated their date to occupy the building was September 2024. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the FY 2023 Budget, Agenda Item #11A, the Council considered adoption of an Ordinance #O-22-035a approving a method for returning surplus real estate tax revenues to taxpayers during the 2023 fiscal year. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the language of the ordinance separated the 2-cent tax rebate as one vote; City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda stated that was correct. Councilmember Faraldi asked City Attorney Mr. Matthew C. Freedman how necessary was the language for Item 1 that referenced a specific dollar amount of $2.6. Mr. Freedman answered that the Page 21 of 564 April 26, 2022 17 statute required the establishment that a surplus existed in the appropriate fiscal year that it was issued, so it was be necessary to state the actual surplus amount when doing the return of a portion of the surplus revenues at issue. Councilmember Faraldi said he was attempting to understand if $2.6M was the surplus, but $4.8M was the overall increase, where that fell. Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt answered that they were in the same years, and the $2.6M was the additional amount budgeted for uncollectable real estate tax that must be attached to real estate tax as a surplus. They did not count on that additional uncollectable being available to the budget, so it could therefore be considered a surplus. The $4.8M was in FY2022 and was to equalize the tax rate. Councilmember Faraldi made a motion to approve the Ordinance #O-22-025a, seconded by Councilmember Wilder. Councilmember Helgeson said that he was glad to see this item come forward and stated his support. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the FY 2023 Budget, Agenda Item #11B, the Council conducted a second reading and adopted Resolution #R-22-025 appropriating the FY2023 General Fund Operating Budget (excluding Discretionary External Service Providers). Councilmember Tweedy made a motion to approve the Resolution #R-22-025, seconded by Councilmember Wilder. Councilmember Faraldi said that there were multiple items he supported in the general fund, including increases in firefighter and EMS pay to $40,000, and he would have liked to see the cost -of- living adjustment be targeted more towards those frontline workers. He reiterated that funds were not being properly allocated within the school system, which was an issue that rested with the School Board and had been difficult to manage. He voiced his support of the general fund budget because of the many positive things it would accomplish, noting that the budget as a whole failed to address the $4.8M increase from the previous year, an issue that could be addressed with the federal funds available through the CIP. Page 22 of 564 April 26, 2022 18 Councilmember Helgeson said that he could not support this item due to the many opportunities presented to create a balanced budget for the taxpayers and the needs of the City, which were not included in this proposed budget. Mayor Dolan said that the budget allowed them to do what was needed to advance their first responders, employees, citizens, and infrastructure. They needed to continue to invest in the City if they wanted it to be relevant and grow, which was why she would support this budget. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: Helgeson 1 // In the matter of the FY 2023 Budget, Agenda Item #11C, the Council conducted a second reading and adopted a Resolution #R-22-026 appropriating the FY2023 Discretionary External Service Providers Budget. Vice Mayor Wright made a motion to adopt the Resolution #R-22-026, seconded by Councilmember Nelson. Vice Mayor Wright stated that his support of the Virginia Legal Aid Society and the critical role the organization had in the legal system of the City was one of the reasons he was especially supportive of this Resolution. Councilmember Nelson stated that he supported the lawyers who donated their time to legally represent citizens in order to help them navigate what could be a difficult legal system, especially to those who were unfamiliar with it. Councilmember Helgeson said that Legal Aid assisted a citizen in suing the City’s police officers for discrimination and violation of constitutional rights relating to assisting in the repossession of the citizen’s vehicle, and he did not agree with funding an organization that would sue the taxpayers or the police department. Councilmember Nelson said that while he was precluded from commenting on information he received in a closed session, the characterization of a high-profile case was not factually accurate. He explained that some of the oversights and omissions in that high-profile case were subsequently Page 23 of 564 April 26, 2022 19 discussed, and communication procedures and policies were changed with Legal Aid so that it would not happen again. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 // In the matter of the FY 2023 Budget, Agenda Item #11D, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Resolution #R-22-027 approving FY2023 Operating Fund Budgets for all other funds and appropriating the sums of each fund. Vice Mayor Wright made a motion to adopt the Resolution #R-22-027, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and with no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 // In the matter of the FY 2023 Budget, Agenda Item #11E, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Resolution #R-22-028 approving the FY2023 - FY2027 Capital Improvement Program. Councilmember Wilder made a motion to adopt the Resolution #R-22-028, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright. Councilmember. Wilder said that he supported this because of the several sessions held discussing the long-term strategy to ensure citizens had infrastructure and facilities that were needed, which had been stated to be hundreds of millions of dollars in repairs and renovations. The strategic funding to support their capital needs and ensure their City maintained a good bond rating and their citizens maintained a good quality of life. Councilmember Helgeson said that it would have been more beneficial to take ARPA funds to apply it to the police headquarters project because it would lower the debt service to be paid, and would be one project paid for rather than the numerous projects included in the capital improvement plan that had not been discussed previously as funded projects, yet were now included as yearly funded projects. He reiterated his desire for fiscal restraint and utilization of budgetary priorities. Mayor Dolan asked Councilmember Helgeson to speak in less generalities about the projects and to be more specific in his comments, as each item in the CIP had been previously discussed. Councilmember Helgeson mentioned Page 24 of 564 April 26, 2022 20 one in particular was the $4M put towards the park in the floodplain, which was mentioned in the 2040 plan, but now was moved into the top projects included. He would rather debate and prioritize the items not at the expense of the money that could be used towards the police headquarters, so debt would not need to be financed in the following years. Mayor Dolan replied that many of these items were included so that all of the neighborhoods were being invested in by the City. Councilmember Faraldi said that City Council would be failing to reconcile an unnecessary $4.8M tax increase from last year. A 2-cent property tax credit was being applied in part to correct this, after much conversation and debate. Councilmember Helgeson asked City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda if the fuel reserve amount was at zero. Mr. Benda said no; it was $300,000 to begin with, and the increase would have been $200,000 more. Councilmember Helgeson said that that reserve was eliminated to be spent, as well as multiple other reserves to be spent on this budget, which he did not find fiscally prudent when it could have been given back to the taxpayers rather than spent. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 // The meeting adjourned at 9:25 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 25 of 564 May 10, 2022 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 10th day of May, 2022, at 4:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Public Works, Agenda Item #1, Council received an update on the Shentel Glo Fiber Installation. Ms. Gaynelle Hart, Director of Public Works, provided Council with an overview of the item. This was a successful partnership between the City, Shentel, and Hurt & Proffitt to bring fiber to thousands of homes in Lynchburg and providing citizens another option to have high-speed internet and TV-streaming services brought to their home. The process began in 2019 when City Council approved the franchise agreement for Shentel to operate a cable TV company within the C ity limits. Then Shentel stated their plans to design and construct a fiber network for approximately 20,000 homes in Lynchburg in a two-year timeframe, estimating that they would be submitting about 230 projects over the two years, and four to six permits per week for review by City staff. This was in addition to the normal developmental reviews they would have to do, and they quickly realized they did not have staff to process these plans and applications in a timely manner. If Shentel followed the normal City process, they would have submitted plans to the Technical Review Committee, received comments, and rev ised the plans. Once the plan was approved, they needed to apply for permits, such as excavation permits for digging in City streets, maintenance of traffic permits for lane closures. The entire process of approval of a plan to permitting could take five to eight weeks depending on number of revisions. To solve that dilemma, City staff engaged with Hurt & Proffitt to supplement their staff and to expedite review and approval. Hurt & Proffitt initially embedded an engineer into the Engineering Division to streamline the process along with Shentel. Shentel continued to reimburse the City for any additional expenses, such as the cost of Hurt & Proffitt or any additional expenses incurred due to the expedited process. They were able to reduce the review time from five to eight weeks to one to two weeks, which allowed Shentel to construct up to 12 projects at any one time in the City. The partnership had been a great success, and the understanding was that there were cities considering replicating this process so that they were able to build out their Page 26 of 564 May 10, 2022 2 network quickly and offer services to citizens. Ms. Hart introduced Mr. Matthew Estep, Vice President for Engineering and Construction with Shentel, who would give an update on their construction process. Mr. Estep thanked the City Council for the partnership Shentel and the City had developed over the past few years and for the staff who assisting greatly with the permitting process. The latest update on the project was that they were about 75% complete with the initial plan, with 10% remaining in the construction and permitting phase, and 15% that would require additional agreements. The key players from a franchising standpoint were Assistant City Manager Mr. John H. Hughes, IV and Deputy City Manager Dr. Reid A. Wodicka, who presented this information to Council, as well as Ms. Kate Berger, Ms. Gaynelle Hart, and Mr. Lee Newland who assisted in the permitting and construction process. This process was planned to replicated in the company’s future ventures because they understood that the localities had fixed resources, and the flexibility and partnership had been key in success. He said that they measured themselves on a damaging complaint basis, and Lynchburg perhaps four times better than most of their markets, which he contributed to the press releases, communications, and the permitting processes of the City. He introduced Mr. Don Gibson. Mr. Gibson stated that after moving through the build phase, the next step was deploying the product and selling it to citizens. The citizens of the City now had a choice for broadband, with speeds that were better than offered before and competitively priced. Recently introduced was a 100Mbps plan for $30, and with the Affordable Connectivity Program (ACP) , this was a free internet service. Recently an agreement was signed with Stewart Langley to perform over 900 multiple dwelling unit upgrades, the process for which was beginning over the next few weeks. Additionally, a small business offering was tailoring product to suit individual businesses’ needs. They continued to expand into other cities in Virginia, but Lynchburg was a great city to work with and be located in. Councilmember Wilder said that it was important for citizens to have options. He asked what areas of the city Shentel was currently providing service in. Mr. Gibson answered that they were throughout the City in different places, but building continued. Mr. Estep said that mapping and updates would be provided for the service boundaries, including completed and in-progress projects, but he did not currently have street data available. Page 27 of 564 May 10, 2022 3 // In the matter of Public Works, Agenda Item #2, Council received an update on the Appalachian Power Distribution & Transmission Project Update. Director of Public Works Ms. Gaynelle Hart introduced Mr. Larry Jackson, the external affairs director for Appalachian Power. Mr. Jackson said that present with him was Mr. Tom Woodford, an account manager who had dealt most with the many projects in the City. He said that expectations had changed over the past couple of decades about what customers expected of their power company; not only do they prefer and demand more reliable service, they demand it to be from cleaner sources. AP intended to be carbon-neutral by 2050, although they had been a coal-fired company in the past. Customers also wanted information on what caused power outages when they occurred. He explained that most outages occurred due to old infrastructure failing, trees falling, or severe weather events. The partnership between the City and Appalachian Power was essential to being able to clean up after such issues. While weather events and trees falling could not be controlled, aging infrastructure could be addressed, and that was currently being worked on extensively in this area. Many projects were underway in the City, and there were many more to come. Recently completed was the downtown project and the Water Resources dual projects, and nearly finished was the Dearington/Reusens transmission line rebuild. The transmission work was finished, and multiple transmission line rebuilds were all going to Reusens station, which at one point was the substation for the entire area, and why most of these major lines go into that one point. It was difficult to rebuild many of these lines because it was difficult to put an outage on that station without creating an outage for most of the City, so it must be taken piece by piece. The last two major transmission lines were rebuilding lines from the 1930s and 1940s, the Reusens/Roanoke transmission line and the Reusens/New London transmission line. The latter transmission line would have an impact because it went through the City, and it would be in the late 2020s when everything would be completed. There was another projec t in Nelson, Amherst, and Albemarle Counties that would bring in reinforcement from Dominion in Charlottesville. Once transmission work was completed, distribution would follow. An area in the City that was challenged during severe weather events was around Virginia Baptist Hospital, so one of the first distribution automation systems they would install would be feeding into that area of the City, where electronic reclosures would sense an outage, disconnect the part of the circuit that had the problem, and reconnect from another source. At that point, new sources would be coming in from the Reusens station, so Virginia Page 28 of 564 May 10, 2022 4 Baptist Hospital would have better service than in the past. In regard to reliability in streetlighting, the next major change would be to get the 10,000 streetlights that Lynchburg currently has to be replaced with LED lighting. The challenge around streetlights currently was that there was no way to monitor them other than by eyesight, and they did not have the existing technology that would allow them to monitor them remotely. Issues could be reported online at www.appalachianpower.com or by phone at 1-800-956-4237. Councilmember Tweedy asked if the streetlight poles would be as massive on Hollins Mill Road. Mr. Jackson said yes, as it was the new federal standard for transmission lines to keep them high and away from the trees. Councilmember Nelson asked Mr. Jackson if the Reusens station was the first source of electrical power in the area. Mr. Jackson answered that the Reusens Dam was installed in 1850, energized in the 1890s, and was the first source of electricity for the City, followed by the Blackwater coal-fired plants, which were what fueled the trolley lines, and ultimately led to Appalachian Power coming to Lynchburg in about 1925. Councilmember Nelson asked if the electrification of the Reusens power station coincided with the Rivermont Electric Attraction Company, the streetcar line. Mr. Jackson stated that those four or five attraction companies combined into Lynchburg Attraction & Light, which was what Appalachian Power purchased in 1924 and 1925. They were then able to move out to the University of Lynchburg area and Rivermont, leading to further growth of the City. Councilmember Helgeson asked for clarification that the LED lights did not require a different pole, but did require a different bulb. Mr. Jackson said that the existing high-pressure selenium lights had to be out farther over the road than the LED lights, so the arms of the streetlights would be shorter, and the LED lights were brighter and cleaner lights that provided better visual aid on the street. Councilmember Helgeson asked how long it would take to install the 10,000 streetlights. Mr. Jackson replied that it would depend on the supply chain deficiencies. Councilmember Helgeson asked if there was any estimated timeline. Mr. Jackson said that he could not make a commitment , but whenever an existing streetlight failed, they would replace the entire head with the new technology. Councilmember Helgeson asked what the procedure was when power outages were experienced in the parts of the City that would not have updates made to their power grids. Mr. Jackson said that the meters that indicated Page 29 of 564 May 10, 2022 5 outages were not always accurate, so it was encouraged for people to call or report it online. Th e AP website provided updated outage information that was accessible to the public. Mayor Dolan asked if AEP had a system to allow people to be notified when the power was out; Mr. Jackson replied yes. Mr. Jackson said that the average customer in Virginia in 2010 used less than 1300kWh per month, at 10.3 cents per hour. In 2020, the average customer in Virginia used 200kWh less per month at a 0.5 cent increase. Energy efficiency was important, so they were trying to make a more robust program to allow more people to become more energy efficient. // In the matter of Schools, Agenda Item #3, Council continued the Lynchburg City Schools Facility Study Part II: Demographic Analysis. Superintendent Dr. Crystal Edwards provided Council with an update on the Lynchburg City Schools Facility Study concerning the demographic analysis and introduced Mr. Blair Smith with Dominion 7. Mr. Smith stated that this item was a follow up to the March 22, 2022 work session and had been presented to the School Board. The first task was demographics, which included information on the City population and school enrollment. The City population between 2020 and 2025 was expected to increase by 1,360 people to 80,340 or by 1.7%, and from 2025 to 2030 the City population was expected to increase by 1,000 people to 81,430 or by 1.2%. Significant numbers of the 18-24-year-old population is leaving the City for college or employment. The median age was expected to increase from 31.0 in 2020 to 33.0 in 2030. Most non-college in-migration to Lynchburg occurs in the 0 to 9 and 25 to 44-year-old age groups. The schools of the City that would be seeing the largest increases in population were the Dearington area, with 11.5% increase, and Heritage with 10.8% increase. The schools of the City with expected decreasing populations were William M. Bass with 12.8% decline, Linkhorne with 0.2% decline, T.C. Miller with 0.7% decline, and Perrymont with 0.2% decline. Fertility rates in the country had been declining since 1948, and Lynchburg resident fertility rates reflected this and overall were 10% below replacement level, which was a primary reason for the decline in enrollment rates. A challenge faced by the City was that there was not much availability for new subdivisions, meaning that for a family to move into Lynchburg, another family must move out in order for that home to be made available. There were currently between 500 and 550 students in the City who were being homeschooled, which was about 50 to 75 students more than before the Covid-19 pandemic. Private Page 30 of 564 May 10, 2022 6 schools not only drew from the City but the surrounding areas as well, so it was difficult to compare it in any form. The enrollment of the schools based in relation to the population of the City was in a decline beginning in 2010. There were four attendance zones inside the City that were expected to grow by about 10%, and two attendance zones were expected to experience flat growth. There was a historic trend that the decline rate was flattening, which was expected to continue in the future. From 2021- 2022 to 2026- 2027, the total enrollment decrease would be 383 students or 4.9% across the division, and from 2026- 2027 to 2031-2032, total enrollment decrease would be 189 students or 2.5% across the division. The projection was for the elementary school enrollment to increase after the 2023- 2024 year to 7.8% or 290 students by 2031-2032. The increase should not be perceived as a long-term trend, as the long-term trend was for it to continue to decline. The projections over the next 10 years did not take into account any change in the Pre-K enrollment, which was currently at 268 children, along with a waiting list. Elementary school enrollment projections were provided for each ward’s schools, using 19 years of data from the Virginia Department of Education. All elementary schools were expected to see an increase in enrollment in the future. Middle school enrollment will decline by 5.1% or 87 students by 2031- 2032, and high school enrollment will decline by 14.5% or 352 students by 2031-2032. However, due to the projected increase in elementary school enrollment, there would be a later increase at the middle and high school levels due to matriculation. The report was prepared by Cropper GIS, who utilized a demographics expert named McKibben. The methodology of Cropper GIS included that historical enrollment did not affect the enrollment forecast, which is a significant difference between that analysis and Weldon Cooper’s. Another component of the Cropper GIS methodology is that existing housing sales are a key component. The Weldon Cooper methodology relied on birth to kindergarten ratios and historical enrollment, as well as relying not on existing home sales but new home construction as a key component. Comparison of reports were provided for elementary, middle, and high school demographics projections. Based on information provided by the City and from best practices, there would be a lower teacher ratio in kindergarten versus a 5 th grade classroom, but not considered was that the City schools received funding for limiting class sizes. Provided was a chart that indicated the maximum class size with projected funding, in which there were inefficiencies. A question that remained for consideration was if it was more efficient to condense the classes or if it was better to receive that funding for limiting the class Page 31 of 564 May 10, 2022 7 sizes. Capacity and utilization rates indicated that as time went on, there was chance of overcrowding at the elementary schools and underutilization at the middle and high school levels, which was a situation typical for all divisions with declining enrollments. Urban divisions have neighborhood schools, which made school closures a challenge, and rural divisions have schools spread over a larger area, which made consolidation a challenge. A task not within their scope was that they were encouraging the School Board to seek out a national educational planner to provide a national perspective on the trends and solutions of similar school divisions to facilitate a locally-developed vision for the City. In addition, it was recommended that a new vision for the Lynchburg City Schools be developed in order to determine the future of Pre-K education, evaluate the Schools for Innovation, and to develop a marketing campaign to promote Lynchburg City Schools. In doing so, this would help identify what the needs for the facilities would be and allow for improvement through renovation and new construction. Energy efficiency was a priority for school buildings, and collaboration and technology spaces were part of future learning. The demographic trends likely could not be slowed in the future, but things such as marketing what was offered could improve that situation. Recommendations to consider included relocation of programs that were currently leasing space, repurposing of elementary schools versus closing the school and leaving it empty, determining the future home for the alternative programs and LAUREL, if the school administration should be relocated to an existing school, and to work to find ways of keeping or attracting young families. The potential options were to focus on operational efficiency, a middle ground option, and to focus on existing facilities. Additional recommendations included update of the demographic report after the 2020 census is complete and regular budgeting every 10 years of funds for demographic study with the population changes. Assuming that the enrollment at the middle and high schools will continue t o decline, those schools will soon be too large for the number of students, so the future of those buildings should be considered. A challenge to be continually addressed was the evaluation and balance of the needs of the division versus the needs of individual schools and neighborhoods. The School Board will inform and seek guidance from the community and school faculty and staff, and will develop three elementary school options for the future of the Lynchburg City Schools for the public’s review and discussion. The Dominion Seven Architects’ role will be to provide technical assistance, development of proposed physical changes to schools and attendance zones, short-term maintenance projects, Page 32 of 564 May 10, 2022 8 estimated costs, schedules, and phasing of construction projects, energy savings options, and to document the recommendations in the final report. Councilmember Faraldi asked if clarification could be provided on the statement that the past was not relevant for the future enrollment in the schools. Mr. Smith answered that it specifically meant that if the enrollment had declined by 5% over the last 10 years, it should not be assumed that it would continue to decline by 5% in the next 10 years. Councilmember Faraldi said that it had not gone up in the past five, 10, or 20 years, so it was difficult to understand the correlation between the decline and the expected increase in elementary school enrollment. Mr. Smith said that per the calculations used to find these projections, the increase in the elementary school level was not expected to continue over time, but was an anomaly that would ultimately result in an overall decrease. Councilmember Faraldi said that he had difficulty understanding it without knowing the exact processes of the calculations mentioned. Mr. Smith said that specifics could be provided by the members who performed the calculations. Councilmember Faraldi said that he would welcome that, because this was a difficult process to undertake and that information was vital to him, especially with the past 20 years of decline in enrollment with relation to the investment strategy of the City. Councilmember Faraldi asked for clarification about the main reason there was no increase in overall enrollment being due to fertility rates. Mr. Smith replied that fertility rates were down. Councilmember Faraldi asked what the fertility rates for Lynchburg were specifically. Mr. Smith answered that he did not currently have that report but could say that it was 10% below the median to replace the death rate. Councilmember Faraldi asked if it was known how many school-aged children there were in the City. Mr. Smith said yes, that number was included in the demographics report. Councilmember Faraldi asked if it was known how many of those students were enrolled at LCS. Mr. Smith said that it was certain that that information was known. Councilmember Faraldi said that he was told during the budget process by their City Manager that that information could not be found. Mr. Smith said that there was not current information; information from the 2010 census was available, but the 2020 census would not provide that information until the end of the year. Councilmember Faraldi said that information was helpful. Given the challenges seen in education and the reasons why people were leaving, he did not understand how fertility rates were why enrollment was decreasing, so he was curious to see how the calculation put that forward. Page 33 of 564 May 10, 2022 9 Councilmember Helgeson said that there were many schools located near each other in the City, and if they were looking at updated data, the decline in enrollment would result in the attendance zones to be redrawn, especially if they were also closing schools. Mr. Smith said that if schools were closed, attendance zones should be reconfigured. Councilmember Helgeson said that how they were drawn now was likely not the best way to be configured. Mr. Smith said that they were what was currently had. If they kept all the schools, they had to check and make sure they complied with the 1971 court order, which had not been done, so it was unclear if the attendance zones could be changed due to that. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the Heritage High School functional capacity was 1,460. Mr. Smith said that Heritage High School was built for 1,200 students based on the criteria they were working under, and that number may include the governor’s school. Councilmember Helgeson said that based on projections, the high school was given additional functional capacity, but they were now at 900 and were expecting that to be about 63% utilization moving forward. Mr. Smith said yes. Councilmember Helgeson said that there were recent analyses that indicated growth, which was why Heritage was given that additional capacity. Mr. Smith said that he could not comment as he was not involved in those conversations. Councilmember Helgeson asked if any internal factors had been analyzed. Mr. Smith said no, because that was not part of their charge. Councilmember Helgeson said that internal factors should be analyzed in order to better understand the demographics and the current attendance zones. Mr. Smith said that the school populations and City populations could be recreated in particular areas when redesigning the attendance zones. Councilmember Helgeson said that a recommendation that he did not agree with was that there was a loss of enrollment that necessitated demolishing an old school and building a new one. Mr. Smith replied that a challenge was meeting the requirements of the 1971 court order when shutting down schools and moving students to another school. Another issue was that construction and renovation was necessary to make consolidation of other schools available while closing another school. Councilmember Helgeson asked what the premise of the 1971 court order was. Mr. Smith said that he was unsure of the specifics, but the schools’ attorney was researching related information. Mr. Freedman said that he was unfamiliar with the court order, and he was not the primary attorney who worked with the schools so he could not provide anything further. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the court order was in reference to busing for integration of schools. Mr. Smith said that part of the issue was that some of the schools Page 34 of 564 May 10, 2022 10 mentioned no longer functioned as the same type of school, which was why he could not analyze the matter further. Councilmember Tweedy said that even with declining enrollments, there still remained 7,000 children in the City who needed education. She said that she agreed with Councilmember Helgeson that the 1971 court order played a large role in this issue, and along with the schoolyear being based on the Farmer’s Almanac, these ideas had not been revisited since the initial development of the public school system. She asked if information could be provided as to why families chose education outside of the school system and if there was anything that could be done to influence those choices. It was crucial for the national educational planner to assist in approaching this process. For future development of the schools, they must consider how to create schools differently in terms of programming and draw more students, as well as reflecting the business needs and growth. Vice Mayor Wright asked if it was known what the percentage of children within the City were enrolled in the school system. Mr. Smith said that he did not know. Vice Mayor Wright asked if other localities reported that information. Mr. Smith said that he was unsure if other counties did those types of comparisons, but he would seek more information to provide to Council. Vice Mayor Wright asked if projections would be updated once 2020 data was received. Mr. Smith said that it was recommended that they do so. Vice Mayor Wright asked if they should be updated for 2030 or within the next year. Mr. Smith said that whenever the data was published, the numbers should be updated. Vice Mayor Wright said that it was mentioned that enrollments had declined since 1948, but the curve seemed to be flattening. Mr. Smith answered that birth rates had been in decline since 1948. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the decline in enrollment had been occurring since first recorded. Mr. Smith said that it began declining in the mid- 1960s. Vice Mayor Wright said that there appeared to be a spike in the graphs in enrollment around 2009 and 2010, and he was curious if it was due to the economic crisis. Mr. Smith said that that was limited to the Bedford Hills area, which he was unsure of the source of. Vice Mayor Wright asked if other wards had similar increases. Mr. Smith said that there were variations between the zones, but he could not explain why. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the schools must have a certain elasticity to account for spikes in enrollment. Mr. Smith said absolutely. Vice Mayor Wright asked what the right amount of capacity was in that instance. Mr. Smith said that planning for 80%-94% capacity was optimal, and 100% capacity would Page 35 of 564 May 10, 2022 11 mean adding trailers. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the funding chart included funding from the state. Mr. Smith said that he did not know the source of the funding. Dr. Edwards stated that they received funding for class size reductions, based on a three-year average of the free and reduced lunch poverty rate for individual schools, and that class size must be maintained to receive funding in grades K -3. Vice Mayor Wright asked if that funding went to those specific schools assuming those class sizes were maintained. Dr. Edwards replied yes. Vice Mayor Wright asked what determined the maximum class size number for this funding. Dr. Edwards said that the class sizes were based on the three-year average poverty rate of that school and were administered by the state upon receipt of the application for funding. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the numbers were based on what the facility could accommodate. Dr. Edwards said no, the numbers were guidance to receive funding, but were not based on the actual building the classes were located in. Mr. Smith said that capacity differed when using the ratios provided by localities versus state and federal data, so it was difficult to plan for. Vice Mayor Wright asked what metric was used for the capacity and utilization score card provided. Mr. Smith said that he used the reduced maximum class size in the funding chart. Vice Mayor Wright asked if that was not based on the physical capacity of the school. Mr. Smith said that he would personally use the standards of the Virginia Department of Education to design an elementary school and kindergarten class size. Vice Mayor Wright said that when discussing the optimal class size, he struggled to understand what parameters should be used. Mr. Smith said that an educational planner would be able to determine how to design the schools for future use. Councilmember Wilder said that the Council must decide through policy how to invest in the City to create infrastructure to attract young families. Lynchburg was different from other cities because of the amount of private schools and Christian schools, and he would like to know how those numbers compared to other cities. He asked if this study addressed whether empty classrooms were able to be utilized for different instruction or were truly empty and unused. Mr. Smith said that the understanding of an empty classroom was a classroom being unused when it was not regularly used for classes. At the time of their visit, they found three elementary school classrooms that were unused, at Heritage, Linkhorne, and Perrymont, and empty classrooms currently existed at the middle and high school levels as well. Councilmember Wilder asked if they were not being used for anything at all. Mr. Smith said that they were not being used on a regular basis, so they were considered empty. Councilmember Wilder said Page 36 of 564 May 10, 2022 12 that something mentioned in the presentation was a marketing campaign for Lynchburg City Schools, which was something he found crucial to maintaining the school system. Councilmember Tweedy said that the funding for the limited class size was due to the poverty rate, and the poverty rate should be addressed as a City-wide issue because it was not limited to schools. She asked if they had ever determined if there would be new metric standards for neighborhoods and calculate it for the school system they were building. Mr. Benda answered that he was unsure if they had done enough in considering how to attract different areas of the City to different parts because they had not attempted to approach these issues in different ways from the past. They would have to approach variables together to make an impact on some of the numbers presented. He stated his willingness to do things differently, because this process required it. Councilmember Tweedy said that there was a charge to the City Council to determine what the philosophical approach was to investment and planning of the community. She stated that achieving this was possible if they intentionally planned. Councilmember Helgeson said that the Weldon Cooper study showed how many school-aged children there were in the City, which was about 12,500 school-aged children, and about 7,000 were enrolled in the school system, meaning that about 60% of the school-aged children were using the public school system. The birth rates in Lynchburg were increasing according to the Virginia Department of Health and should not be blamed along with empty nest homes for the declining enrollments. Mr. Smith answered that those numbers came from the demographer, Cropper GIS. Councilmember Helgeson said that if it were not related to live births, empty nests, or lack of housing, the decline was an enigma related to programming. If 40% of the community did not want to be included in the school system, it should be considered and researched in order to understand the demographics and growth rates of the schools, as well as the needs of the community. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he had toured four or five elementary schools, and many of these buildings had historic aspects that should be considered and protected as they were repurposed for the future. He noted that from the highest view of the school system, there were very low graduation rates and declining enrollment rates. There was room for improvement, but when doing things differently in creating specialized schools, there should be consideration of charter schools or lab schools. Page 37 of 564 May 10, 2022 13 Councilmember Tweedy said that there was a generational difference in students and their ability to learn, and entire schools had been created to avoid certain students, mandates, and requirements imposed upon them. The national education planner would allow for better understanding of the problems and differences in learning environments that children currently needed. All of the neighborhoods and areas of the community were planned, and intentional planning was necessary to create the Lynchburg envisioned for 2030. // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item #4, Councilmember Wilder thanked the City staff who attended the Fairview Community Center to discuss plans for the development in the Tyreanna and Pleasants Valley area. There were extreme opinions and an interesting dialogue. He commended staff for the International Festival held this past weekend, which helped make their community richly diverse and attractive as an event venue. He congratulated the firefighters of Lynchburg for raising over $21,000 in the Fill the Boot Campaign. Vice Mayor Wright stated that he also attended Fairview Heights last evening, and was grateful to the staff for taking the time to present and listen to the neighbors’ comments. He thanked the constituents of Pleasants Valley and Tyreanna for sharing their thoughts. He congratulated the Old City Cemetery for their annual rose sale and new marker for Carl Cato, a rosarian at the cemetery. Councilmember Tweedy thanked everyone who planned the International Festival, which was a great event with many people in attendance. Mayor Dolan announced that the Office of Economic Development and Tourism celebrates Economic Development Week May 9-13. Economic Development Week was created by the International Economic Development Council to increase awareness of local programs that cr eated jobs, supported business investment, and improve the quality of life in communities everywhere. Please visit www.opportunitylynchburg.com to learn more about the City’s economic profile and how businesses were making a difference in their community. Mayor Dolan announced that Virginia Amateur Sports was seeking volunteers for the upcoming Commonwealth Games, July 22-24, at Liberty University. Each years, thousands of athletes and their families visited Lynchburg to compete in the Commonwealth Games with sporting events ranging from pickleball to ultimate frisbee to basketball and much more. Please help make an impact and a successful Page 38 of 564 May 10, 2022 14 event this year by volunteering to make a difference in the lives of thousands of athletes and their families who will be competing this year in the City of Lynchburg. More information about the Virginia Commonwealth Games and the volunteer form can be found at ww.commonwealthgames.org. Councilmember Wilder commended the Commonwealth Games at Liberty. He stated that Virginia Amateur Sports was doing free physical exams this Saturday at Jubilee for middle school and high school students. // The meeting was recessed at 6:04 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan gave a Proclamation recognizing Drug Court Month. Ms. Taylor Jones accepted the Proclamation. Mayor Dolan gave a Proclamation recognizing Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Week. Fire Chief Greg Wormser accepted the Proclamation. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda Item A, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Resolution #R-22-032 amending the FY 2022 Operating and Capital Budgets and appropriating or rescinding funds to reflect the FY 2022 Third Quarter Detail by Fund. On motion of Councilmember Tweedy, seconded by Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of School Board Appointments, Agenda Item #5, a public hearing was held and Council received citizen input regarding appointments to vacancies that will exist June 30, 2022, in School Board Districts I, II, and III. Council conducted its first public hearing on the matter on April 26, 2022, and chose to continue the hearing until its May 10, 2022 meeting. The School District 1 appointments were Mr. James Porter, Mr. Clifton Reed, Ms. Ashley Reich, Ms. Brandy Gibbs, Mr. Anthony Andrews, Ms. Mary Wieberg, Dr. Justin Hensley, Mr. Elliott Clifton, Ms. Marianne Criswell, Dr. Kathie Carwile, Dr. Andrea Yesalis, Dr. Kevin Struble, Mr. Jerry Gibson. The School District 2 appointments were Dr. Veronica Page 39 of 564 May 10, 2022 15 McCue, Ms. Letitia Lowery, Dr. Martin Day, Ms. Erin Cruz, Ms. Charleta Mason, Ms. Rosamond Phillips. The School District 3 appointments were Dr. Jason Fleshman, Mr. John Miska, Mr. Gary Woodson, Mr. Steven Smith, Ms. Gloria Preston. Mayor Dolan opened the floor to candidates who wished to speak on their qualifications. Mr. Gary Woodson, nominee for School District 3, spoke before Council. Mayor Dolan opened the floor to any citizens who wished to comment upon any name that has been submitted, or offer additional names for consideration; there were none. Councilmember Wilder made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to close the public hearing. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded : Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 Mayor Dolan announced that City Council would be convening in a closed session at the close of the current meeting to review candidates’ applications and decide on an interview schedule. // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #6, Council considered adopting an Ordinance #O-22-035 approved the proposed amendment to the City Code regarding dogs left outside during extreme weather conditions. The Council was previously briefed on this matter at the April 12, 2022 work session Business Item briefing. Mr. Ryan Ball gave an overview of the item to Council. Recommendations from Council were made with specific regard to dogs being left in cars, so two changes were implemented. Instead of only mentioning dogs, it now stated “dog or other companion animal,” and where the language in §C stated that “no persons shall be charged with a violation of the subsection if the motor vehicle’s engine and air conditioning were operating and in effect when such dog or other companion animal is inside such motor vehicle.” In regards to open windows, when referencing national veterinary groups, studies indicated that open windows had no effect on lessening the temperature inside of the vehicle, so was unable to be included as effective language. Mayor Dolan said that the amendment did not ban the owners to secure their dogs to the bed of a truck. She asked if this was allowed if the temperatures were very high. Mr. Ball stated that that part of the amendment was in reference to hunting dogs that would likely only momentarily be in the City, but any dogs were supposed to be inside when temperatures were above 95ºF. City Attorney Mr. Matthew C. Page 40 of 564 May 10, 2022 16 Freedman stated that these particular amendments were adopted pursuant to the power of adopting ordinances for animal cruelty, so these were lesser offenses than animal cruelty. Hypothetically, if an animal control officer or police officer was to find a dog tied in the back of a pickup truck that was suffering in some way, they would still have recourse to act. This amendment was a different means to pursue a lesser offense than charging someone with a Class 1 misdemeanor of animal cruelty. Councilmember Faraldi said his requests in regard to the air conditioning exception to this amendment were satisfied. Vice Mayor Wright made a motion to adopt the Ordinance #O-22-035, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Agenda Item #7, the Council considered a closed meeting to consider appointments to the Lynchburg City School Board and to determine a time in which to conduct the School Board candidate interviews pursuant to §2.2-3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia. Councilmember Wilder made the motion, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy, to enter into a closed session. Councilmember Faraldi stated that this appointment process for the school system should be done transparently and open to the public. There were 24 candidates for three open positions, and parents had the complete right to govern the education of their child, so it would be most proper to allow them to see who Council decided to appoint. The votes did not exist to conduct this process transparently and would ultimately be conducted in closed session. He stated that he would vote against this process to be held in closed session at this meeting. The following names were candidates that he would consider: Mr. James Porter, Clifton Reed, Ms. Ashley Reich, Brandy Gibbs, Anthony Andrews, Justin Hensley, Kathy Carwile, Kevin Struble, Veronica McCue, Martin Day, Erin Cruz, Jason Fleshman, and Gary Woodson. Councilmember Helgeson said that the process issue of deciding a schedule to interview candidates was not a closed session issue. Clerk of Council Ms. Alicia L. Finney stated that additional Page 41 of 564 May 10, 2022 17 meetings must be set to hold the interviews. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the meetings must be set in an open session. Ms. Finney said that the motion after the closed session would be to add those additional meetings for the interviews. Councilmember Helgeson asked what necessitated a closed session for this item. City Attorney Mr. Matthew C. Freedman answered that the closed session was meant to be a time for discussion of candidates and which should be appointed to the School Board. Councilmember Helgeson stated that the language written included determination of a time in which to conduct interviews. Mr. Freedman answered that yes, specific candidates would be discussed and they could discuss when an additional interview would be held. After closed session, they would set an additional meeting, and on that date, the normal meeting would be held and then they would go back into closed session to conduct the interview. Councilmember Helgeson said that the process would be discussed in an open session. Mr. Freedman said that was correct. Councilmember Helgeson asked if it was an exception to discuss the process within the closed session. Mr. Freedman said no, they would be unable to discuss the process, but what would be discussed included specific candidates and specific dates for those specific candidates. Councilmember Helgeson said that they would be unable to know who to interview and to schedule it unless it was discussed in an open session. Mr. Freedman said the motion could be amended to only include consideration of appointments and for scheduling to be held in open session. Councilmember Helgeson asked if that was the usual process. Councilmember Tweedy answered that the normal process was discussion of candidates who were to receive an interview, followed by discussion of the dates, times, and opportunities for Council to convene for those interviews of the persons discussed. With no further discussion, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Dolan, Wright, Wilder 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and Page 42 of 564 May 10, 2022 18 WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // Councilmember Helgeson made the motion to hold two special called meetings on May 16, 2022, and May 20, 2022, both beginning at 1:00 p.m. in Council Chamber for the purposes of conducting School Board Candidate Interviews. Vice Mayor Wright seconded the motion. Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting adjourned at 8:28 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 43 of 564 May 24, 2022 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 24th day of May, 2022, at 4:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, Maryjane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Maryjane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Parks and Recreation, Agenda Item #1, Ms. Maggie Mace, Recreation Services Manager, provided Council with an update on upcoming summer events. Ms. Mays stated that with the support of City Council, other City departments, and other organizations throughout the City, they had been resilient and able to meet their goals in meeting pre-Covid-19 numbers. This includes the performance goal of reaching or surpassing an 80% implementation rating on all programs, and they offered 289 programs from January to April of this year at 85%. Participation and revenues are significantly higher this year in 2022 from 2021 when comparing the two, due to places like the Jackson Heights Arts Studio, which has a 100% implementation rate, and all classes offered there are full, and due to classes and programs that naturalists offer, which are seeing increases again in requested programs from schools. Through new virtual programs, special events, outdoor recreation, and facility improvements, they utilized strategic partnerships to impact their community. This Friday, there would be a celebration at the Miller Center for the older members of the Lynchburg community for Older Americans Month. Returning this summer would be the award-winning Hill City Hoops program, which will be happening every Friday night at Miller Park in the month of July, where teams will participate in the weekly league, then at the end of the season, they will get to participate in a tournament hosted by the Lynchburg Area Youth Sports Initiative. The Lynchburg Fire Department had partnered with them to help with this program. The partner organizations for the sports programming allowed them to serve the youth in the community and to help them grow through athletics. With the Council’s support, they were able to extend the summer season at Miller Park Pool and will be open through Labor Day weekend, they had been able to offer competitive salaries to their first responders, which helped improve staff retention, helped with recruiting new staff, in over to overcome the national lifeguard shortage. Also continuing is the partnership with Lynchburg City Schools to offer the free lunch program at Miller Park Pool for youth Page 44 of 564 May 24, 2022 2 in the community. There were lots of volunteer opportunities through the Department of Parks and Recreation, and so far, they have had 1,200 people volunteer with them to complete projects such as invasive plant removal, beautification projects, and others. Many volunteers came from other community organizations and became City employees, and these people helped make Lynchburg a great place to live, work, and play. Councilmember Nelson asked if the kayaks and canoes at Ivy Creek Park should be reserved in advance, or if they were first-come, first-serve. Ms. Mays said that it was first-come, first-serve and reservations were not necessary. Vice Mayor Wright asked if kayaking and canoeing was offered at Hollins Mill in addition to Ivy Creek. Ms. Mays said that they had tried out Hollins Mill last year, but this year were back at Ivy Creek. There would be special days at Hollins Mill, so there was still the opportunity to do that. Councilmember Wilder said that this was an example of all of the great things that happened in the community that benefited everyone’s quality of life. The extended pool hours were appreciated, Hill City Hoops was a great Friday night event for the youth to attend, and the Friday programs at Miller Park allowed for a central location for children to enjoy themselves during the summer. Councilmember Tweedy said that the collective programming the Parks and Recreation offered to all age groups was encouraging and she appreciated it, because it made Lynchburg a place people enjoyed coming to and living in. Mayor Dolan said that it looked like a fun and robust program. // In the matter of the Downtown Lynchburg Association (DLA), Agenda Item #2, Ms. Ashley Kershner, Executive Director of DLA, provided Council with the organizations 2021 Annual Report. The Downtown Lynchburg Association is a 501(c)3 organization, and the 17-member Board guides the work of the organization and the overall strategy. Three strategic priorities set last year in the strategic plan are to foster a thriving and diverse storefront economy, cultivate a lively and engaging downtown atmosphere, and create a truly welcoming environment. Support for businesses included communications about funding opportunities, surveying and shifting programs in response, marketing consultations , Small Business Saturdays, and the Downtown Gift Card Program. Leveraging the power of local volunteers, companies, and City government officials, they raised $60,000 to create the Art Alley, transforming a Page 45 of 564 May 24, 2022 3 public space into a colorful and attractive environment, and 1,300 people walked the Bluff Walk the night of the Art Alley opening, and the month after the Art Alley opening saw a 119% increase in foot traffic compared to the month before the opening. The community had requested fireworks in Riv erfront Park to return for a long time, and with the help of the City and major sponsors, they were able to bring the event back with great success. More information would be brought back to Council related to a business improvement district, because new structures would be needed to be able to serve the needs of a growing downtown. The tax data related to downtown activity is an easily measurable way to gauge the success and current state of downtown, which showed that the economy was down in 2020 but had begun to resurge in 2021. The entire annual report had been provided to the Council, including some events such as movies in the park, fireworks on July 1, and Get Downtown on October 1. Additional placemaking projects include the midtown parking deck mural to raise the awareness of public parking options downtown and a mural in collaboration with Blackwater Branding with a location yet to be determined. A new project being developed by the Downtown Lynchburg Association was the Downtown Lynchburg Cookbook, which would feature 40 restaurants downtown and on Rivermont Avenue and exemplify how great the food in Lynchburg is. Councilmember Faraldi said that he would like to see four or five more organizations similar to DLA that focused on other areas of the City. He said he looked forward to the return of the Get Downtown Event. He commended Ms. Kershner for the organization’s work and for sharing metrics that measured success. Councilmember Wilder said that the investment in the downtown area was paying off for the entirety of the City, because everyone could come there and enjoy it. The highlight and mark of a City was the main street, and he thanked Ms. Kershner for protecting it and keeping it vibrant and ali ve. Councilmember Nelson said that it had been refreshing to see how Ms. Kershner and her staff captured opportunities with creativity and initiative, drawing resources they had downtown into improving its situation. It was most impressive that during Covid-19, when there were challenges that no one had anticipated, the Downtown Lynchburg Association was able to find new ways to make things not only better but great. He expressed his enjoyment for being able to work on the mural on the downtown parking deck. He asked if the gift cards for downtown were currently sold at one location or if they would Page 46 of 564 May 24, 2022 4 expand that. Ms. Kershner answered that they could always be bought through their website, but there was also a plan to expand the locations where they were sold. Vice Mayor Wright said that it was deeply impressive that DLA worked by punching above its weight, which is apparent by the awards they have won, the projects they undertake, and the sense of community they help foster. He thanked Ms. Kershner for the meaningful and impactful work DLA did in Lynchburg. He asked where Downtown Lynchburg Association mugs could be bought. Ms. Kershner said that all merchandise was sold online, and they could be picked up locally at Ayven Avenue, a boutique on 5 th Street or mailed directly to customers. Vice Mayor Wright asked if Ms. Kershner could share the movie line-up for the summer. Ms. Kershner answered that the season would open with In the Heights, then The Incredibles, Spiderman: No Way Home, Tangled, and another movie she could not recall. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the list was accessible on their website. Ms. Kershner said yes, it was available on Facebook, Instagram, or their website. She noted that the final movie she had forgotten was Back to the Future. Councilmember Tweedy thanked Ms. Kershner for her work and expressed her enjoyment of the Art Alley murals. She said she had recently referred some prospective business owners to the Downtown Lynchburg Association to discuss ideas they had for the future. Ms. Kershner said that they had specific welcome packages for new businesses and wanted to make sure they had those conversations. Councilmember Wilder said that the marketing support was very key so that small businesses could still access marketing and other resources. He asked if the flag shop at the end of Main Street was also included in the downtown stores. Ms. Kershner said yes. Mayor Dolan said that Ms. Kershner had done an extraordinary job and they appreciated everything she had done to make their City great. // In the matter of Redistricting, Agenda Item #3, City Planner Mr. Tom Martin provided Council with a review of the different scenarios for adjusting precinct boundaries. This was the monthly work session for redistricting, which was required to do based on the results of the 2020 Census. Staff would present Scenario D for the City Ward Boundaries in a public hearing, address absentee ballots and zip codes, review requirements for precincts, the requirements for polling places, review precinct boundary scenarios, and discuss next steps. Scenario D was selected by Council to go to public hearing. Ward 2 Page 47 of 564 May 24, 2022 5 needed to gain populations, Ward 3 and 4 needed to lose, and Ward 1 was within the range, but the chosen scenario added some population. Ward 1 gained population north of Lakeside Drive, Ward 2 gained population from Ward 4 east of Old Forest Road, and also from Ward 3 east of Oakley Avenue. Ward 4 shifted population to Ward 1 while Ward 1 shifted population south of Lakeside Drive into Ward 4. All were within the ranges required. There were two bills that went forward, converged, and §24.2- 667.1 was amended, signed by the Governor, and became effective July 1, 2022. The law required the Registrars report to the Department of Elections absentee ballots to the precincts. He asked if this answered Councilmember Faraldi’s question; Councilmember Faraldi replied yes. Mr. Martin said that the requirements for precincts were that they had to have clearly defined, observable boundaries, the maximum registered number of voters was 5,000, and the minimum number of registered voters in the City was 500. The precinct scenarios were based upon voting age population, because they did not have geographic data on registered voters. The premise was that the precinct scenario would fall within that voting age and did not go over it, they would be okay. Councilmember Helgeson said that the registered voters were the 5,000. He did not want to get down a path of moving people based on an assumption that was not factual. There were a lot of people of voting age who were not registered voters, and some rules may need to be cleaned up before they began splitting precincts. Mr. Martin said that he believed it was an acceptable practice to use the voting age population, but he would ask the City Attorney to confirm that. Mr. Freedman said that there had been an issue with how to locate particular data for the time of the adoption of new precincts, in that they had been unable to determine the registered voters and did not know how many voters woul d be chosen for the precinct at the time it was adopted by Council. He understood that localities had been going by the voting age for purposes of determining that and then determining how many registered voters were in the particular precinct. He was unsure if Christine had reached out to the Department of Elections on that question, but they did want to try to confirm that with them that that would be an acceptable practice. Councilmember Helgeson said that he understood the dilemma, but they had the data of who was registered and was not, and that data could be used rather than an assumption. Mr. Martin said that they did not have access to that data, and he did not know if the Registrar had it readily available for them to use, so they proceeded based on voting age populations. There was the potential that if Council would Page 48 of 564 May 24, 2022 6 like to ask the Registrar for more information. Councilmember Helgeson asked if they would be working with the Registrar. Mr. Martin said that they had been involved. Ms. Christine Gibbons, Director of Elections and General Registrar, stated that the requirements for County and City precincts in §24.2- 307, at the time any precinct was established, it shall have no more than 5,000 registered voters. The General Registrar shall notify the governing body whenever the number of voters who voted in a precinct in an election of the President of the United States exceeds 4,000. Within six months of receiving the notice, the governing body shall proceed to revise the precinct boundaries and any newly established or redrawn precincts shall have no more than 5,000 registered voters. She stated that she had spoken to the Registrar in Bedford County, who used voting age population, whereas the Registrar in Montgomery County used registered voters. Registrar voter counts by locality were available and had been shared with the redistricting committee, which stated how many voters were currently registered in all of those precincts. Also shared was the voter turnout by precinct for the November 3, 2020 election, including the total turnout and how many registered voters they had at that time. Councilmember Helgeson asked if they would need to notify if there were over 4,000 in a precinct. Ms. Gibbons said that was for those who had voted. Councilmember Helgeson asked if they were now discussing boundaries that did not have more than 5,000 actual registered voters. Ms. Gibbons said yes. She stated that the only way to really look at that was at the Registrar counts by locality, and they could not look at the numbers of the registered voters of the scenarios given, and the changes would need to be made first in order to know how many would be in the precincts. Councilmember Helgeson asked if they were first looking at an assumption and then would get the real number from working with Mr. Martin to get the actual count. Ms. Gibbons said yes, but she could not do so until Council made their determination as to what each of the precincts would be in the form of an ordinance. Councilmember Helgeson asked if they could not have approximations. Ms. Gibbons said no, the only way she could make changes was using the report of current registered voters in the current precincts. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the report came from the Registrar. Ms. Gibbons said yes, she could run the report at any time, which included information on active and inactive voters, and how many there were in all. The total number had to be used, because even inactive voters were registered. Councilmember Helgeson said that he did not want the 5,000- person limit to be based on presumptions and then people were moved to different pr ecincts when they Page 49 of 564 May 24, 2022 7 actually did not have to. Ms. Gibbons said that she could offer the current report and the report of the 2020 election turnout. Councilmember Helgeson said that Montgomery County did it differently. Ms. Gibbons said they looked at registered voters, looking at the report she currently had. Mr. Martin emphasized that they could not use those numbers because they were not tied to a geographic area, and those precincts were changing based on the proposed ward boundaries, and the only information they had to go off of was voting age population. Councilmember Helgeson said that Scenario A had had limited changes, and could have been done quickly, which may have been good to know. Councilmember Tweedy said that she knew they had a lot to do, but the analyzation had her worried about manipulation of numbers, so she would like to walk through this as slowly as possible. She stated that the verbiage was confusing, and she would like to have another work session on how they manipulated and changed over the boundaries, who would be affected, and why they would be affected. There was a lot of language about the streams, rivers, and railroad tracks that had been used as boundaries, and other reasons as to why things were being moved around, and why precincts should be even. She said that she was leery about that, and if anyone had questions, they could email or call her to ask why. She stated that she understood the information was presented to the Council as requested, but the general public should know that they were moving potential precincts, moving boundaries, and she had concern about the verbiage and rationale for why they were doing it. Mr. Martin said that he was unsure how to respond. Ms. Tweedy said that it was rhetorical. Mr. Martin clarified that they were required to have the plus- or minus-5% in the ward boundaries, and they presented Council with five options, and mentioned that there were infinite ways in which it could be done. Scenario A was the most minimal change that could have occurred, because it increased the population of Ward 2 while decreasing 3 and 4, and the area towards Odd Fellows Road and Oakley Avenue would be the only area changed. He hoped that staff had presented the information in a way that did not lead the Board in any certain direction on this. Staff must stress the timing of this to ensure that everything was in place for the November election, and staff was presenting options based on data. Councilmember Tweedy replied that she felt confident in that staff was responding to questions posed to them, and she wanted the public to know the depth and breadth of the questions received based on the information and questioning being sent to staff. Page 50 of 564 May 24, 2022 8 Mr. Martin said that polling place requirements were one polling place for each precinct, it had to be located within the precinct or within one mile of the precinct boundary, had to be accessible, and had to be located in a public building whenever practical. During analysis, staff attempted to keep the current polling places as they were, but that was not to say that some might change. Ward 1’s precinct 1 would be Linkhorne Middle School, Precinct 2 would be Bedford Hills, Precinct 3 would be First Presbyterian Church, Precinct 4 would be Rivermont Presbyterian, and Precinct 5 would be First Christian Church. All of those fall within the 5,000 range, and were shown in the chart on the slide. He said that the scenario that staff did not recommend would require the removal of a polling place, and after talking with the City Attorney, they felt that this could potentially disenfranchise voters. Councilmember Helgeson asked why this scenario would require the removal of a polling place in Ward 2. Mr. Martin said that it was below the 5,000, so breaking them out separately would keep them above the 500, or they could combine them and be below the 5,000. He said that it was a bad scenario which was not recommended, but was a possibility. Councilmember Helgeson said that he did not understand how that could be a scenario. He asked if none of them were below five hundred, which would require the precinct to be removed bec ause it was so small. Mr. Martin said that this scenario combined the Jubilee and R. S. Payne polling places, giving them a precinct with roughly 3,000 people. R. S. Payne would have 3,368, and Jubilee would only have 1,400 to 1,600 people. Councilmember Helgeson asked if this did not require removal of a polling place. Mr. Martin said no. He said that it was shown to be a bad alternative which they were asked to move away from. He said that this one, which was called the second ward alternative, precinct 1 would be St. Paul’s Episcopal, with 3,712 voting age, the Lynchburg Public Library would have 4,134, Robert S. Payne would have 3,368, Fairview Christian would have 2,472, and Jubilee would have 1,416. Councilmember Helgeson asked which public library Mr. Martin was referring to. Mr. Martin said he was referring to the Memorial Avenue Public Library. Councilmember Helgeson said that it was actually in Ward 3, precinct 1. Mr. Martin said that it was not in Ward 3 anymore. Councilmember Helgeson said that it was in the mile boundary. Mr. Martin said that if they moved the ward boundary, it was in Ward 2. He said that all of the precincts were within ward boundaries. Councilmember Helgeson said that they were now exacerbating all the people who lived in Ward 3, precinct 1, and there now would be people voting Page 51 of 564 May 24, 2022 9 there at precinct 301 and 202. Mr. Martin said no, they would be moved under Scenario D, which Council directed them to advertise. Mayor Dolan asked if they were looking at Scenario A or B, would either of those scenarios would require a new polling place or elimination of the polling places. Mr. Martin said that he believed that for both of those, they would have to do something with Liberty University, but they would have to go back and look at those numbers. Councilmember Helgeson said that two precincts could be done for Liberty University at one spot, but the difference would be with some of the other ones. Mr. Martin said yes. He said that it was fine if Council did not want Scenario D anymore, but it was on their public hearing tonight. Councilmember Helgeson asked why they were moving the precincts. He asked where precinct 202 currently was; Councilmember Tweedy answered that it was at R. S. Payne. Ms. Allison Johnson, GIS Manager, indicated the boundary with the new ward scenario, which indicated there must be a new precinct for Ward 2 precinct 2. Mr. Martin said that under Scenario D, the Lynchburg Public Library was moved out of Ward 3 and into Ward 2. Councilmember Helgeson said that all the people in Ward 2 would now be voting at the library, and precinct 202 would now be voting at the libr ary. Mr. Martin said that the question was where those people in the newly drawn Ward 2 had voted before. Ms. Gibbons answered that they were in Ward 3 and voted at the public library, so those people voted at the same precinct, but were in a different ward. Councilmember Helgeson said that before, they were Ward 2. Ms. Gibbons said that in the scenario, the precinct had changed on the map, so Ward 2 precinct 2 in the scenario map was no longer R. S. Payne, but they were now using the public library. Mr. Martin clarified that the precinct names changed. Councilmember Helgeson said that nobody in precinct 301 was voting at the library, and now Ward 2 was voting at the library. Mr. Martin said that was correct. He said that the question was where the rest of the people who were originally in Ward 2 that was in the proposed Lynchburg Public Library precinct voted before. Ms. Gibbons said that they added another precinct in Ward 1, another precinct in Ward 2, and another precinct in Ward 3, so none were being taken away in each of the presented scenarios. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the presentation could be finished before discussion began again. Mayor Dolan said yes. Page 52 of 564 May 24, 2022 10 Mr. Martin said that for Ward 3, precinct 1 would have to be a new precinct, which they had talked about in reference to the Liberty precinct, in which there were about 7,000 people. He said that they asked them for their student numbers by building, so under this scenario, there would be a new precinct 1, essentially east of 460 to Odd Fellows Road, and that would have 2,764 people in it. Precinct 2 would be the Vine Center, with 4,309 voting age population in it. The voter registration staff had expressed amenability to adding a precinct, and they would like to look at the possibility of moving both to the LU Conference Center, which was not Circuit City. He said that precinct 3 would be Sheffield Elementary School with 3,616, precinct 4 would be First Church of the Nazarene, 2,208, and precinct 5, Heritage United Methodist would have 4,849. The current Liberty precinct could not be kept due to the number of voters. Ward 4 precinct 1 was St. Thomas Moore Catholic Church, with 4,601, precinct 2 was Sandusky Middle School with 4,984, Perrymont Fellowship, 4,821, and precinct 4 would be Heritage Baptist Church with 1,939. An alternate sent by Councilmember Faraldi was that Wards 1 and 3 are the same, precinct 2 would still be Sandusky Middle School, but that area north of Tomahawk and Blackwater Creek would be combined with Precinct 4. Councilmember Faraldi said that there was a concern about traffic patterns near Heritage Baptist, and he thought it would be worth considering. The whole idea was to keep the bulk of those folks who had voted at that location there. Councilmember Helgeson asked for a review of Ward 3. He said that Ward 3 had five precincts, and a new one had to be added because of Liberty, so there were now six. Mr. Martin said that there were four precincts, and precinct 1 was Sheffield. Councilmember Helgeson asked if people who voted at the library voted at Sheffield. Mr. Martin said that precinct 1 would be the new precinct, which would be the Liberty campus, southeast of 460, towards Odd Fellows Road. It was southeast of the railroad that bordered the campus, east of the unnamed tributary of Rock Castle Creek, and west of Candlers Mountain Road. Ms. Gibbons said that she thought the original agreement were that students were only to vote at the campus, so she was unsure if those people should vote off-campus. Mr. Martin said that he was unsure if it was a legal requirement, but the new proposed precinct was that area of the Liberty campus. The main campus, which would be precinct 2, the Vine Center, was east of the railroad, basically going up to a tributary that went underneath the Vine Center. Precinct 3 would vote at Sheffield, and was northwest of 460, east of Fort Avenue, west of Odd Fellows, Mayflower Drive, and Martin Street. Page 53 of 564 May 24, 2022 11 It also included a new area of Fort Avenue, south of Sussex and Richmond and east of Oak Ridge Boulevard and Oakley Avenue. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the people moving from 301 to 303 was done as assessment. Mr. Martin said that the boundaries were drawn based on the block populations. They did not calculate the existing precinct and how many they had now, and how many they would gain or lose. Councilmember Helgeson said that Scenario D caused additional disruptions to voters. Mr. Martin said that it was a change, and the precincts would obviously change based upon that. If the Council would like staff to go back and do this on another scenario, they would, but all they had to present was based upon Scenario D. Councilmember Tweedy requested this information for Scenarios A and B. Mayor Dolan said that she would also like to see that information. Councilmember Faraldi asked if that required overriding staff direction to bring this item to a public hearing. Mr. Freedman suggested to Council that they could hold the public hearing, adjourn it or close it, and then continue the matter to be voted upon in some fashion, delaying the resolution. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the resolution changed based on the drawing of the map, that they would have to have another public hearing by law. Mr. Freedman said yes, another public hearing would be required. If there was a majority of City Council tonight that did not want to proceed with Scenario D, it must be resolved if definitive. He said that time was of the essence to get the wards precincts straight. If Council knew they did not want to proceed, they need only vote to cancel the public hearing a nd resolution, or if they wanted to put it to a vote to be heard, hold the public hearing, close the public hearing, and put it to a vote. Councilmember Faraldi asked how many members had chosen Scenario D in the survey. Mayor Dolan said that there could also be a motion to move to accept Scenario A or Scenario B by someone who had voted for Scenario D. Councilmember Tweedy asked if the public hearing could be held and a vote could be taken for Scenario D. Mr. Freedman said that was right, and staff could ask for guidance on the next scenario to be considered. Councilmember Faraldi said that another public hearing would need to be held. Mr. Freedman said that was correct, and they would also have to redraft the boundaries for presentation to City Council. Councilmember Tweedy asked what the timeline was for staff. Mr. Freedman said that Page 54 of 564 May 24, 2022 12 everything had to be done 60 days before the November election. Councilmember Faral di asked if it would also have to be 60 days before early voting started, so 85 days would be when the y had to adopt it. Mr. Martin said that approximately 41% of 156 people selected Scenario D as their preferred choice. Councilmember Faraldi said that members of the public who were polled voted for Scenarios A and B as their least preferred options. He cautioned against moving back to considering a completely different map from what was adopted, and contrary to the poll that was put forward to the general public and associated with the deadlines. The change and disruption were based off of what ward someone was in, but if they went with A and B and kept the precincts the same, 401 would be shifted, and there were too many voters, so there were other precincts that would have to be shifted in addition to Liberty’s precinct . Then the people left out of Liberty’s precinct would need a new precinct, and Ward 2 would have to lose a precinct if it did not gain the population. Vice Mayor Wright asked how many people responded to the survey. Mr. Martin answered that it was 156 respondents. Vice Mayor Wright asked how that survey was given to the community. Mr. Martin said that it was put online, and hard copies were put in City Hall and in the public library. Vice Mayor Wright asked if there was anything preventing people from submitting it multiple times. Mr. Martin said that he did not believe so. Vice Mayor Wright said that 156 constituted a very small percentage of the community, so it was not a relevant sample size, but the comments were good and worth considering. He clarified that they had not adopted the boundaries for Scenario D but said that they wanted to move forward with exploring it and coming back for the public hearing. Mr. Martin confirmed that Council asked staff to advertise it for public hearing. If Council decided as a majority that they did not want to adopt Scenario D, they would start the process of creating scenarios for the boundaries , but there was work that remained to be done. Vice Mayor Wright said that the statute referenced 60 days, but 85 days was what they were working with. Mr. Freedman said that Council could call special meetings if they had to do so. Mr. Martin asked if 85 days was in August. Mr. Freedman said that there would probably be action in August. Mayor Dolan said that it was important that they not set this up so that future wards became noncompetitive and so that they did not disenfranchise voters in certain wards, which required looking at the distribution very carefully. Mr. Martin said that if the majority of Council said that they wanted to look at Page 55 of 564 May 24, 2022 13 Scenarios A and B, staff could do polling scenarios for A and B. Mayor Dolan said that it seemed that they needed some sort of consensus. Mr. Martin asked if it was possible to have a work session on June 28. City Manager Wynter C. Benda answered yes. Councilmember Helgeson said that the library could have stayed in Ward 2 because it was technically within one mile. Mr. Martin said that was technically correct. Councilmember Tweedy asked if a vote to direct staff to investigate Scenarios A and B was necessary. Mr. Martin said that consensus and adequate direction had been received from Council. Councilmember Faraldi suggested that a formalized vote would be best for the public record. Mr. Benda asked if the public hearing could serve as the vote for the matter so as not to call th e question too early. Mr. Freedman said that the public hearing would serve well as the environment to cast a vote on Scenario D, and a motion to approve or to deny the resolution could be made at that time, as well as pursuing a different scenario. Councilmember Faraldi said that public hearings should not be futile, and if there were enough votes for the public hearing to be canceled, people should be given the notice. Dr. Tweedy said that she would accept the input from the public hearing and survey but did not want to disenfranchise voters by being shifted into other precincts, so asking staff to return with information on Scenarios A and B allowed them to do the greatest level of research to stop related issues. Councilmember Nelson said that he did not see changing the place where one cast their ballot as disenfranchising the voter, but were simply voting somewhere else than where they had a practice of voting in the past. Citizens could comprehend the information distributed through departments and media as to where voters in certain locations should vote in upcoming elections. There would be drastic changes in the wards and precincts based on the Censuses of 2020 and 2030, and rather than kicking the can down the road, the need to get gerrymandering out of the City and establish wards that were compact and contiguous, which was what Scenario D did, was something they must tackle right now and not do it in a dramatic way in the future. The City must be able to adapt to the patterns of where citizens live d and should vote, and there was nothing wrong with being versatile in dealing with the realities of the City, and not pretend that the status quo should be kept. Councilmember Wilder said the public hearing should be held so that it was already taken care of when information was received about Scenarios A and B. Page 56 of 564 May 24, 2022 14 Councilmember Tweedy said that the time should be put in to make the process less disruptive, then the next ten years could be about educating voters about making all the changes. Councilmember Helgeson said that the public hearing was about the advertised boundaries, so the public hearing could be kept open for other scenarios and they could amend the boundaries. Mr. Freedman said that the state code required the specific boundaries and the map to be advertised. Councilmember Helgeson asked if it was a two-week advertisement. Mr. Freedman said yes. Councilmember Helgeson said that they could keep open the public hearing on Scenario D tonight and advertise another on Scenario A and keep both open. Mr. Freedman said that they could draft another ordinance based on what Council directed them to do and based on that scenario, and advertise it for consideration for adoption. The public hearing would open, continue to another date certain, then a new ordinance would be drafted and advertised the same as Scenario D. Councilmember Helgeson asked what the difference was between Scenario A and Scenario B. Ms. X indicated the different maps on the slide. Councilmember Tweedy said that the timing of this must allow for education of voters. Councilmember Wilder asked if the library moved in Scenario B. Ms. X said that the polling place of the library would still be in Ward 2. The people moved out of Ward 2 would vote at R. S. Payne. Vice Mayor Wright asked if there were any procedural issues if the public hearing went as scheduled and Council discussed the issue after. Mr. Freedman said that under the scenario, they would open the public hearing, proceed in the normal course of business, close the public hearing , and move to defer consideration of that ordinance on the agenda this evening to the next meeting date. Vice Mayor Wright said that they could also have a motion now to defer the public hearing and direct staff on another scenario. Mr. Freedman said that they would need to hold the public hearing, then leave it open to be considered at the next meeting. Vice Mayor Wright asked if there was consensus to discuss the issue after the public hearing. Councilmember Faraldi asked if they would not need to reconsider redirecting the public hearing and the ordinance, because the motion was to accommodate that, and to change the directive of Council should include the new map situation. Mr. Freedman said yes. Vice Mayor Faraldi said that Council would first consider, then change it. Mr. Freedman said that in keeping the public hearing open, Council could Page 57 of 564 May 24, 2022 15 defer consideration of the ordinance until whatever date certain, and also making a motion for staff to proceed with an additional option for consideration, and they would advertise for another public hearing with another ordinance. Councilmember Faraldi said that it would be clearer for Council to direct staff to initiate a public hearing process on another option instead of wrapping it in with Scenario D. Councilmember Helgeson asked if that could be done tonight after the public hearing. Councilmember Faraldi said yes. Vice Mayor Wright said that the public hearing had to be specific to what was advertised. Councilmember Faraldi said yes, and if they continued the public hearing and then asked to bring in a new proposal, the only way they could do that was if they reconsidered the initial vote. Vice Mayor Wright said that was right. Mayor Dolan asked Mr. Freedman if that was right. Mr. Freedman said that only Scenario D could be considered in the public hearing, they had the options to adopt, defer, or deny the ordinance, and could certainly direct staff by motion or direction to bring back another option to advertise a public hearing. Due to time constraints of the evening, Mr. Benda stated that Agenda Item #4 would be pulled from the agenda and brought back on June 28, 2022, but the business item briefings should be discussed. Mayor Dolan asked if those business item briefings could be conducted at the June 7 meeting. Mr. Benda said that would work. Vice Mayor Wright asked if these items could be completed in ten minutes. Councilmember Helgeson said that they should wait to get the full briefing. Mayor Dolan said that it appeared that was the direction they would like to take. Mr. Benda said that he was amenable to that. He clarified that they would do business item briefings only, and not also the review of requirements for residential uses and commercial zoning districts. Mayor Dolan said that was correct. Mr. Benda asked what time the June 7 meeting would be held at. Mayor Dolan said that the advertised time was 5:00 p.m. Councilmember Nelson said that they would not know what the 2030 Census would show them as to how the wards and precincts would be, and the education at that point would still have to be done within a few months of time. If changes were made now, a new Census in 2030 would not drastically or materially change the wards, and not change any of the precincts because they had already adapted to that likelihood by doing it in the way they were now. Mayor Dolan asked Mr. Benda about Item #5e. Mr. Benda said that the item required two votes, one of which was going to be held today after the briefing, and one which would be at the meeting on Page 58 of 564 May 24, 2022 16 June 28. He asked if the Council was able to vote on said item on June 7. Mr. Fr eedman said that if it was not in the call of the special meeting and not to be considered there, then no, unless there was a way to advertise it for the special meeting. Mayor Dolan said that the special meeting had not been advertised yet. Mr. Freedman said that if there was enough time to do the advertisement, they would add those items at the special meeting. Mr. Benda said that he was concerned that there were some funds that looked like it would fall to fund balance if not used in some said way, and th ere was a proposal about how to use it, which was to increase compensation for living wages for full-time and then part-time employees. If there were resources left from that $600,000, he wanted to deploy those to impact compression. He had concern that if the June 7 meeting did not afford them the ability to have the vote, there must be two opportunities to vote. Mayor Dolan asked if they could vote on this this evening if Council felt they had enough information after the presentation. Mr. Benda said that was correct. // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item #6, Councilmember Helgeson said that the Finance Committee met this morning, when they discussed revenues and the current $6.1M over budget, projected towards the end of the year to be around $8M in increase in revenue over the budget. Expenditures were below the budget, possibly a year-end savings of $15M. He said that this money could be utilized to give back to the citizens. Vice Mayor Wright congratulated the E.C. Glass women’s lacrosse team, who clinched the Seminole District Title. He said that most of them had seen the news out of Texas this afternoon, and he would be thinking about them this evening. Mayor Dolan said that as part of the Mayor’s Youth Council You Matter Campaign, the Council completed their cornerstone project with a mural on the 700 block of Jefferson Street, across from the skatepark and at the entrance of the trail. There was a colorful message to the st udents and citizens that no matter what problems they are facing, they matter. She asked people to take a moment to admire the impressive project. She thanked the Mayor’s Youth Council for that. // The meeting was adjourned at 6:07 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Page 59 of 564 May 24, 2022 17 Absent: 0 Councilmember Wilder gave the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan congratulated the members of the 2022 Citizens Academy on their successful completion of the program. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda Item A, copies of the minutes of the February 22, 2022 meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Vice Mayor Wright, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Redistricting, Agenda Item #7, a public hearing was held and Council received citizen input regarding the consideration of approving an ordinance adopting the City’s Ward boundaries. Mr. Kent White, Community Development Director, provided a summary of the item. Redistricting is the process of redrawing the boundaries of districts that elect representatives who serve specific geographic areas. Redistricting occurs every 10 years following the United States decennial census and is the responsibility of state and local governments. City Council’s ongoing discussions of redistricting had allowed transparency in the process. All scenarios had been posted online, and hardcopy maps were in City Hall and the library, along with an online survey done with the help of Community and Public Engagement. Five scenarios had been considered to achieve the correct population numbers. Scenario A moved the fewest between wards and mainly affected voters in Oakley Avenue, Allegheny, St. Augustine, Monticello, and Hood Street areas, meaning that those citizens would change from one ward to another. Scenario B would change the voter wards from the areas north of Ivy Creek, and Oakley Avenue, St. Augustine, Allegheny, along with Wythe, Rye, and Stadium Road areas. Scenario C was more of a dramatic shift, changing the wards into more of a quadrant scenario, so voters would shift north of Lakeside from Oakley to Rockridge, along Edley Place, Cornerstone, and Windsor Hills. Council ultimately directed staff to advertise Scenario D, a similar quadrant scenario, which came up during their discussions when another Scenario D was discarded in an early work session. This new Scenario D would shift voter wards north and south of Lakeside Drive, east of Old Forest Road, east of Oakley Avenue and Wythe Road, and west of James Street. Precinct and polling places would change, so it was Page 60 of 564 May 24, 2022 18 a matter of the scenario, and the guidance that staff was looking for through the City Council process was what the alignment of the boundaries were, which allowed them to focus through those precincts and polling places. The public hearing tonight was on Scenario D, and following that public comment, they could vote to adopt, defer, or deny that scenario. On June 28, they would continue the conversation on ward boundaries or additional discussion of the precinct and polling places. Mayor Dolan asked if there was anyone who would like to speak in favor. Mr. Andrew Glover commented in favor of Scenario D, which represented the City well and created a geographical sense of how the City was oriented. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Tweedy made the motion to defer the vote on the adoption of the ordinance until the June 28, 2022 meeting so staff can provide more information on Scenario’s A and B for Ward boundaries. Councilmember Wilder seconded the motion, stating this would allow time to review additional information and make an adequate decision. Councilmember Faraldi made a substitute motion to approve the ordinance as it stands, adopting Scenario D. There was no second and the motion died. Councilmember Faraldi said that speaking to the motion on the floor, said that by delaying more time, they were now in a position that if they did not get this done by the end of July, they would not have affairs in order to make the changes needed. The concern was that they only met once in July, so they would have to call one, two, or three special meetings in July to work through the proposals, work through the precincts, and have an associated public comment period to adopt another proposal. It was also a valid concern to not want to shake up where people were voting, but by simply moving the precinct location, they were not robbing any person of the right to cast a ballot. The standard deviation for Scenario D was less than 350, meaning it was very accurate to the rest of the districts, and Scenario A was closer to 850, meaning they were not close from a population standpoint. Scenario A was a clear gerrymander. By delaying this, not only were they cramping down the deadline because they were concerned about the changes this might ensue, they may then have a process they were rushing to get done, with public comment and multiple meetings required to get it in order. These districts were compact Page 61 of 564 May 24, 2022 19 and contiguous, while the others were not. He stated that he would not support a district that was anything less than that. It was not forthright to delay the public process and to ignore the survey results that indicated majority favor of Scenario D and least favor for Scenarios A and B. Councilmember Nelson said that the foundation of the motion before the Council was that it was disruptive to the citizens’ past practices that they wanted to keep the voters voting in the precincts where they had been used to voting for a long time, and to change some of those precincts would be confusing, and potentially disenfranchised voters. He did not dispute that this changed the status quo, however, that was and has been the fundamental premise and principle advocating against gerrymandered districts. There was a consensus that it was wrong when those who were elected picked their own voters by crafting the districts and wards by excluding voters who would not support them. The solution Scenario D was almost the perfect example of compactness and contiguous districts, and the four wards were geometric shapes that were almost identical and did not guide into each other. He trusted the voters to learn the new locations for where they would cast their vote, and that people would be able to access the sites. He said that they would not know what the Census 2030 results would be, and the education would still have to be undertaken within a few months. They should undertake this task now, and City staff had come up with an option that was viable, compliable with rules opposing gerrymandering, and between now and Election Day, their citizens and communications efforts were more than adequate to educate citizens as to where they would go to cast their vote, with no more undue difficulty than if they had not changed things. He stated he was in favor of Scenario D, and he would support Councilmember Faraldi’s motion. There was no issue with delaying it until June 28, and it may be that they needed more information from the City and entertain another option, but they were not accomplishing anything by going to Scenarios A or B as they did not change any of the offensive circumstances that gerrymandering had created for the City at the present time. Councilmember Tweedy said that she agreed that change would happen, but full transparency required reviewing all the information from all scenarios. On June 28, they would review all scenarios that would change precincts. Scenario D was disruptive, so they should review Scenarios A and B. There was enough time that staff could review this information, and they would not delay the electoral process. Page 62 of 564 May 24, 2022 20 Councilmember Helgeson said that voters must be moved between precincts because some populations had changed. Taking time to ensure they were not disenfranchising anyone would not be a problem, and when staff returned with the information and advertised Scenario A for public hearing, they would have weighed both options equally. He asked if a separate motion was necessary for Scenario A. Mr. Freedman said that for Scenario D, the public hearing had been closed. If the motion passed, there would be a public hearing for A and B. Councilmember Faraldi asked when they would expect to consider the public hearings for Scenarios A and B. City Attorney Mr. Matthew C. Freedman said that June 28, 2022, was the date they would aim for the public hearings for A, B, or deferral of the consideration of Scenario D. Councilmember Faraldi asked if they knew when they had to get everything to Richmond. Mr. Freedman said that once everything was adopted and finished, he hoped they could have that turned around in a week. Councilmember Faraldi said that the latest would be August 5. Mr. Freedman said that that was his hope for what he and City staff could aim for. Councilmember Faraldi said that it was a tight deadline, and with another public hearing to be held, they must adopt additional meetings into the schedule. Vice Mayor Wright said that there was time to do this judiciously and thoughtfully. People had preference for Option D, but they should take their time to do their due diligence. Councilmember Nelson reiterated that no elected official could listen to their constituents too often, and for that reason, it was prudent to delay until June 28, but he remained in favor of Scenario D for the options stated. Mayor Dolan called for the vote, and the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Helgeson asked if June 28 would include the public hearing and work session on this item. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda said that was correct. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the item could be voted on that evening. Mr. Benda said whatever the will of the Council was. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #8, the Council considered adopting Resolution #R-22-036 accepting the Tyreanna and Pleasant Valley Neighborhood Plan as part of the City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave an overview of the Item to the Council. Page 63 of 564 May 24, 2022 21 Following the March 8, 2022 public hearing, City Council directed staff to hold an additional neighborhood outreach meeting. That meeting was held on May 9, 2022 at Fairview Neighborhood Center. A number of the residents who attended asked questions, offered comments and volunteered to be part of ongoing conversations on issues such as safety, transportation, sewer, maintenance and the future of City-owned property. The plan serves as a starting point for these discussions and, once adopted, provides the potential to leverage resources towards the neighborhood’s collective goals. Councilmember Wilder commended the residents of Tyreanna and Pleasant Valley for coming out to the Fairview Heights Community Center for voicing their wide variety of opinions on the matter and providing great discussion. City staff and Virginia Department of Transportation officials were there to listen to concerns from the residents of that particular area. Councilmember Tweedy said that it was mentioned at the meeting was that residents would have an opportunity to be involved. Ms. Frischeisen said that they had found at the public meeting that people were interested in the details, which they did not always have until closer to design and implementation, so right now they had an email list of people who were interested in staying involved in the process, and she would encourage anyone who wanted to be involved to call the City’s main line and ask for this plan with Community Development. She said that the next time they asked for community input it would be with more specific questions so that these things could be implemented. Councilmember Helgeson said that the more that they could clarify that this was a high- level plan, and the only way that specific things were carried out were if Council voted to fund those specific things, and Council voted on specifically changing zoning and changing or giving a conditional use permit. They should ensure that the plan was productive for everyone involved, and they should listen to everyone. Vice Mayor Wright made a motion to adopt the Resolution, seconded by Councilmember Nelson. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #9, Council considered several ordinances approving City Code amendments for derelict buildings, demolition, and clutter. Mr. Kent White, Community Development Director, gave a brief summary of the toolkit ordinances to Council. On March 8, Page 64 of 564 May 24, 2022 22 2022, Deputy City Manager Dr. Reid A. Wodicka presented some of the findings from the Diamond Hill south walkthroughs, which brought to light that derelict buildings and blight negatively impacted neighborhoods. Following discussions with multiple stakeholders, staff presented a safe housing and blight abatement “toolkit” earlier this year – a combination of strategies including tax delinquent property sales, increased demolition funding and code amendments. On April 26th , staff reviewed the specifics of those proposed code changes with Council. The appeals process for public nuisances was added to the derelict structure ordinance draft as a result of that discussion. Over the last month, s taff has continued outreach through media outlets, neighborhood discussions and conversations with real estate professionals and housing developers. The feedback staff received as a result of the outreach has been supportive of the code amendments. Councilmember Wilder said that Amherst County was adopting a similar ordinance. He stated that people should not be in a situation where they were forced to sell because they could not afford to renovate their houses. Mr. White said that the ordinance specifically required 90 days to submit a plan for the property owner. About 300 of the buildings were condemned, no one was living in them, but they were blighted property. The additional tools give staff the pretense to have this conversation, which had been difficult because so many owners lived out of state, out of neighborhood, and outside of the City. Options included rehabilitation, selling, or donation to a housing organization. As for the neighbors adjacent to those properties, there was nothing the City did, and the outreach process started here and continued all the way through so that they could make sure the options were clear. Councilmember Faraldi asked if there was any parity to other localities in saying the appeals process was left to the City or County Manager. Mr. White said that the appeals section was replicated in other ordinances. City Attorney Mr. Matthew C. Freedman said that while this did not provide for the City Manager designee, it does somewhat reflect what was under the nuisance ordinance as far as an appeals process. Providing an administrative means of appeal gave the due process if someone wanted to challenge the protocol of the issue. Councilmember Faraldi asked if a court proceeding could still follow if they really wanted to. Mr. Freedman said that they could, but there would likely be adequate grounds on the City’s behalf to defend it, otherwise they would not have standing or a proper avenue to seek that. To have an administrative process of appeal versus having a court process of appeal was the alternat ive. Page 65 of 564 May 24, 2022 23 Councilmember Faraldi asked if there was any similar parity across the Commonwealth where a Board had appointed a commission or the legislative body itself was the final say on it, because otherwise it would be tied to one person. Mr. White said that he was unaware of other localities using that sort of appeals process. There was a Board of Building Code Appeals that looked at some issues, but most of those processes went through a state board, and a lot of deference came back to that individual appeal s process. Defining derelict housing was the definition of a standard in the ordinance, with specific notes of findings of facts. Councilmember Faraldi asked what the punishment was related to the nuisance ordinance. Mr. White answered that the City was allowed through the nuisance standard to remove the violation and charging the owner, which was consistent with how they handled other public nuisances. Councilmember Nelson said that he had concern with the area of the ordinance that said that said the City Manager’s decision would be final and not subject to appeal. He asked if this ordinance meant that even if the locality had abused its discretion and not afforded due process that there was a bar to the property owner who may suffer loss of property rights was forfeited by virtue of the City’s actions. Mr. Freedman said that they would not be able to proceed pursuant to this statute on a general appeal, but if more than two were considered, it would not be an issue to make an appeal as far as another boar d or court proceeding. These were presented as part of a toolkit, but if Council wanted to just adopt the other two, they could look at it again. Councilmember Nelson said that abusive discretion was the very foundation which justified an appeal to a judicial body from an administrative hearing or decision, and this ordinance made no consideration for possible abusive discretion. There should certainly be some sort of intermediary body who would review what the City Manager and staff did so as to ensure that due process was protected for and by everyone in the City. He proposed that it be worked on and brought back to them with that note. Councilmember Helgeson said that the City Manager worked for City Council, and if there was some egregious thing that the Council found, the Manager would correct their ways or leave the position. There were already standards for the properties in the ordinance that Mr. White had mentioned. He asked if there was any problem with repealing it once enacted. Mr. White said no. Councilmember Wilder motioned, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy, to adopt all three ordinances. Page 66 of 564 May 24, 2022 24 Councilmember Wilder said that if there were concerns, they could make adjustments if need be in the future. Councilmember Tweedy said that citizens were concerned that this the topic should be revisited in terms of a report on what had been done so far or example scenarios. Councilmember Nelson said that he appreciated the motivation and justification for an ordinance like this, but he had concern about the procedural protections and due process. They should get it right the first time and not wait to see who would be unduly burdened by it, putting on that individual property owner the cost to undertake and initiate the efforts to protect the property because the City did not care what happened to them if the City Manager or the designee had made a decision. It should be built into the process an orderly and logical means by which an aggrieved citizen who felt things did not go well for them to be heard by an institution and authority of this City without bothering them about it, because if it was meritorious, it would be dealt with by the administrative appellate body or by a court. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the last section could be amended to add the decision of the City Manager could be appealed by City Council. Councilmember Nelson said that he would like for the City Administration to state what they would like to have included in the document that would be a reasonable, responsible, and practical solution. Councilmember Helgeson said that rather than having a body to oversee the appeals, the easiest thing would be to say the decision could be appealed to City Council. Councilmember Nelson said that it may be a reasonable solution, but he did not l ike a political majority. Mr. Freedman said that something like this with an appeals process should have more robust wording, so staff could look at it and provide something for further process beyond the City Manager and bring it back to the Council. Councilmember Faraldi said that they as a government should not set out a policy that did not allow for appeal. He said that he supported the last two ordinances but could not support all three without more crafting on that matter. Vice Mayor Wright said that he was sympathetic to fleshing out the appeals process more. He asked if there were other land use questions that could be appealed directly to City Council for decisions. Mr. White said that he could not think of anything other than the standard zoning process when Council Page 67 of 564 May 24, 2022 25 was making the decision. Vice Mayor Wright said that he would be happy to vote on the other two ordinances, but preferred to hold until the other language was identified. Councilmember Wilder made the motion to approve Ordinance #O-22-037 which addresses clutter and Ordinance #O-22-038 which addresses demolition and to table the ordinance addressing derelict properties. Councilmember Tweedy seconded the motion. Councilmember Nelson asked for the code section that they were voting to approve. Mr. Freedman said that the second ordinance was identified as an Ordinance to Amend and Re- Enact the Code of the City of Lynchburg 1981 by Amending §11-123 of Chapter 11, the amended section related to demolition permits, and the third ordinance was an Ordinance to Amend and Re- Enact the Code of the City of Lynchburg 1981 by amending §26-2 of Chapter 26, the amended section related to enumeration of public nuisances. Councilmember Nelson asked which ordinance was not being voted on. Mr. Freedman said that the ordinance not being voted on was titled an Ordinance to Amend and Re- Enact the Code of the City of Lynchburg 1981 by adding thereto a new §11-61 of a new Article 2A of Chapter 11, a new article on the section related to derelict buildings. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Engineering, Agenda Item #10, Council considered adopting a resolution supporting the inclusion of two SMART SCALE project applications to VDOT for funding. Mr. Lee Newland, City Engineer, gave a brief overview to Council. Council reviewed these projects as a Business Item Briefing on February 22, 2022 and recommended the projects be included in the pre-application process. The application process is required to be submitted by August 2, 2022 and a resolution of support from the governing body of the entity making application is required. The suggested projects are: 1. A Candlers Mountain Road Study from University Blvd to Sunnymeade Road in Campbell County identified the offset intersection of Liberty Mountain Drive as a concern that needed to be addressed. If this application is successful, funds will be provided to reconfigure the intersection; final configuration will be determined after additional engineering analysis. Page 68 of 564 May 24, 2022 26 2. A Potential Safety Improvement (PSI) Study identified the intersection of Langhorne Road, Rivermont Terrace, and Vassar Street as an opportunity for safety improvements. A concept plan is underway, to include public outreach, to determine what is the best solution for this intersection. If this application is successful, funds will be provided to implement the final plan. Vice Mayor Wright motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to adopt the Resolution #R -22- 039. Councilmember Helgeson asked what the price was for the second project. Mr. Newland said that the application had not been finalized and was due in August. He said that a consultant was currently working on the project, and a public meeting was held at the public library three weeks ago, where the majority of people were in favor of a roundabout because that area was one of the highest crash areas in the City. Councilmember Helgeson asked what the cost was of the project. Mr. Newland said that it was about $8M before, and they were trying to reduce the size of the roundabout so that they did not have to take as much property and so that it would be a less expensive project. Councilmember Helgeson said that he could support the first option but not the second one, because residents did not think it was an appropriate use of funds to construct the roundabout in the middle of their neighbo rhood. The funds could be moved to another project where work was more desperately needed. Vice Mayor Wright made the motion to adopt Resolution #R-22-039a which supports the SMART SCALE project that addresses the intersection of Liberty Mountain Drive. Councilmember Faraldi seconded the motion. Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 Vice Mayor Wright made the motion to adopt Resolution #R-22-039b which supports the SMART SCALE project that addresses the intersection of Langhorne Road, Rivermont Terrace, and Vassar Street. Councilmember Faraldi seconded the motion. Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: Helgeson 1 // In the matter of the Budget, Agenda Item #11, Council considered adopting Resolution #R -22-040 amending the FY 2023 General Fund budget and appropriating funds for the purpose of extending the Page 69 of 564 May 24, 2022 27 living wage increase for all part-time and hourly employees and to enhance funds available to impact compression. Ms. Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, gave a brief overview of the item. The FY 2022 Adopted Budget appropriated funds to implement a 5% general wage increase for City employees. This amount was an estimate, based on personnel data at the time the budget was adopted. Following the implementation of the 5% general wage increase, funds of approximately $620,492 are remaining due primarily to vacancies. The Adopted FY 2023 Budget appropriates funds to provide a living wage for all full-time employees. In addition, funds are earmarked in the FY 2023 Adopted Budget to address compression. With the funds remaining from the 5% general wage increase implemented in FY 2022, all part-time and hourly employees will also be included in the living wage. Use of these remaining funds beyond those necessary for the living wage will be added to the compression funds to provide additional impact. Vice Mayor Wright clarified that these were recurring funds, so the money was expected annually, and the recommendation was to make this more of an ongoing commitment. Ms. Witt said that was correct, because it was provided for the 5% increase, which was an ongoing cost. Vice Mayor Wright asked how much was broken down in wage increases addressing compression. Ms. Witt said that only $30,000 would bring the rest of the temps and hourly workers up to the $14.03. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the $590,000 was for compression. Ms. Witt said yes. Vice Mayor Wright asked if that was encompassing all departments. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda said that two years through 30 years were included. Vice Mayor Wright asked if they were identifying which departments had the most need or if it would be pro-rata. Mr. Benda said that there were 15 other departments that this would apply to. Vice Mayor Wright said that he favored this but would like to know ultimately once they decided where this was going to go what departments were affected and how. Vice Mayor Wright made the motion, seconded by Councilmember Nelson. Councilmember Helgeson said that the revenue could go back to the tax payers. He said that he would not support the measure. He said that they needed to provide relief to the citizens. He said that they could reduce the tax rate by $0.01 ongoing. Page 70 of 564 May 24, 2022 28 Councilmember Nelson said that the lower end of the salary range deserved the salary increases. He said that part-time and hourly employees were at the lower end of the salary range. He said that he would support the measure to take steps to provide a living wage. Councilmember Wilder stated that he would support the motion. He said they needed to take action to address compression and appropriately compensate employees. Vice Mayor Wright said that excellent services were delivered through a high-quality workforce, which was difficult to attract and retain if they were not compensated correctly. He asked what type of positions were affected by the $30K increase. Ms. Witt responded that there were part-time positions in Parks and Recreation, life guards, and temporary summer positions. Councilmember Faraldi asked how much was in the previous budget for the recurring positions throughout the City. He clarified that they were using recurring vacancies to fund the proposal. Ms. Witt said that they were not. She said that for the 5% across-the-board increase in 2022, they set aside a projected amount of the cost for all employees. She said that because there continued to be so many vacancies in 2022, the funding for the present measure was the leftover from the 5% increase. Councilmember Helgeson noted that the budget increased spending on personnel by $13M. He said that he was not supportive of the measure. Councilmember Tweedy stated she supported the citizens, the work of the finance department, and the City administration. Councilmember Faraldi asked if they could receive a copy of the report of where the funds would go for compression prior to the deadline for spending the funds. Mr. Benda said that the report could be provided. He said that the report could be provided on the 28. He said that approval would take two votes—one now, and one on the 28. Ms. Witt said that they could provide the information. She clarified that the cost was about $200K for the living wage increase for part-time and hourly employees. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he needed more information to support the measure. Councilmember Wilder stated that he supported the decisions by staff. He said that the City Administrator was addressing compression issues as directed by the Council. Page 71 of 564 May 24, 2022 29 Councilmember Nelson said that he would support the measure. Councilmember Helgeson stated that they did not want to cause wage inflation by paying employees above a market rate wage. He asked why the item was not included in the budget process. Mr. Benda said that the budget was level funded, and departments were able to submit enhanced funding requests. He said that when they discussed a living wage, they knew that there were 96 people who fell into the category, and of fulltime employees, there were 13. He said that it was difficult for the City to recruit lifeguards because they were at the low end of wages. He said that small seat compression across the board was an issue he was supposed to address ever since he started working for the City. Councilmember Helgeson clarified that the funding was from the present fiscal year, and it required two votes to be able to allocate it. Ms. Witt explained that the funding would be allocated to the compression funding appropriated for FY 23. Vice Mayor Wright moved the previous question. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Sterling Wilder, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy 5 Noes: Jeff Helgeson, Chris Faraldi 2 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to consider appointments to the Lynchburg City School Board pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1.) of the Code of Virginia. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and Page 72 of 564 May 24, 2022 30 WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting adjourned at 9:35 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 73 of 564 June 7, 2022 1 // A special meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 7th day of June, 2022, at 5:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of recognitions, Vice Mayor Wright presented the Patty Worsham Recognition Day Proclamation. Ms. Patty Worsham thanked Council, Mayor, Vice Mayor, and her friends and colleagues present this afternoon, and all the people she worked with and taught at E.C. Glass. She said that it had been a privilege and honor to teach generations of children, and being educated by one Councilmember’s father at Lynchburg College, she learned about the tradition of a community where people stayed together, and students came back and raised their families. // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #1a, Council received a briefing on the Fiscal Year (FY) 2023 Annual Action Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program Funds. Mayor Dolan stated that the item will appear for City Council vote on the June 28, 2022 Public Hearing agenda. Ms. Melva Walker, Grants Manager, gave a summary to staff. The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) requires local governments, which receive federal Community Planning and Development (CPD) formula block grant funds to prepare an Annual A ction Plan as a component of the approved 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan for the CDBG and HOME Program. This Plan has been prepared, with the required sections, and includes the CDBG and HOME projects that will be implemented during the program year to address the identified needs and objectives. The FY 2023 decrease in CDBG ($14,338) and increase in HOME Program ($7,178) funding based on final entitlement amounts from HUD. Ms. Walker stated that the recommended and approved project amounts had been adjusted as follows: Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan and Improvement Project in the CDBG Program decreased by $14,338, and the HOME Program, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority’s Home for Good Project, had been increased by $7,178, and the required 30-day public comment period for the plan began on May 21, 2022, and will conclude at the public hearing scheduled to be conducted by the City Council on June 28, 2022. Page 74 of 564 June 7, 2022 2 Councilmember Wilder asked how the decision to reduce the amount for the Diamond Hil l project was reached. Ms. Walker answered that it was the recommendation from CDAC. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #1b, Council received a briefing on the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) of the New Vistas School at 520 Eldon Street. Mayor Dolan stated that this item will appear for City Council vote on the June 28, 2022 Public Hearing agenda. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, stated that New Vistas School is petitioning for a CUP at 520 Eldon Street to allow the construction of a six thousand two hundred sixty-two (6,262) square foot building to be used as a gymnasium and classroom space in an R-3, Medium-Density Residential District. There is no proposed increase in student enrollment with this petition. On April 27, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (6-0), with 1 vacancy, of the CUP petition on, and the Planning Division recommended approval of the CUP petition. Councilmember Helgeson said that this would be a great improvement and addition to the school site. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #1c, Council received a briefing on a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for the Spring Hill Cemetery Association at 1550 James Street. Mayor Dolan stated that the item will appear for City Council vote on the June 28, 2022 Public Hearing agenda. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a summary of the item to Council. Spring Hill Cemetery Association has submitted a CUP petition proposing the expansion of the existing cemetery. The expansion would include enlargement of the existing columbarium, new columbarium walls, a cremation garden, new burial plots and a new vehicular egress to Stadium Road. The property is zoned R-3, Medium-Density Residential District which allows cemeteries upon approval of a CUP by City Council. On May 11, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (4-0), with 1 vacancy and 2 members absent, Bowden and Johnson, of the CUP petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the CUP petition. Councilmember Helgeson said that he regretted his past vote to close Rives Street, and if there was a way to rectify the closure of that public, he would like to identify and implement that procedure before this new CUP returned to the Board. He said that he would not be voting to any changes to the CUP while Rives Street remained closed. Councilmember Tweedy asked if the cemetery owned most of the property in the neighborhood. Ms. Frischeisen said yes, most of the undeveloped parcels that did not have a house on it were owned by Page 75 of 564 June 7, 2022 3 the cemetery. She said that she recalled that during her tenure on the Physical Development Committee, there was much discussion about the expansion, and the cemetery’s ownership of the surrounding parcels and the development and expansion of the cemetery was a factor in that decision-making then. She asked if more information regarding that could be provided. Ms. Frischeisen said that although it would not change the decision made at that time, there was a code change enacted after that in which right-of-ways proposed to be vacated that were currently in use by the public had to have signage posted prior to the public hearing. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #1d, Council received a briefing on a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) for the Liberty Christian Academy (LCA) at 1120 Hershey-Esbenshade Drive and 701 Mountain View Road. Mayor Dolan stated that this item will appear for City Council vote on the June 28, 2022 Public Hearing agenda. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a summary of the item to the Council. Liberty University, Inc. has submitted a CUP petition to allow the construction of a four thousand, one hundred twenty-one (4,121) lighted multi-sport athletic complex at 1120 Hershey-Esbenshade Drive. Ingress / Egress improvements to support the facility are proposed at 701 Mountain View Road. On March 14, 2017, Council approved a CUP petition to allow a larger, six thousand (6,000) seat facility; however, the CUP has since expired. On May 11, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (5-0), with 1 vacancy and 1 member absent, Johnson, of the CUP petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the CUP petition. Councilmember Helgeson asked for clarification for the purpose of the traffic study needed. Ms. Frischeisen said that the institutional use allowed many uses, and this was one of very few that required a CUP, which was valid for 36 months for institutional uses, and because that time had lapsed, it was procedural to bring this item back to Council. // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item #2, Council held a discussion regarding the July 2022 City Council Meeting Schedule. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda gave a brief overview to Council. A calendar was adopted annually by Council, and the redistricting conversation had taken them to June 28, 2022. He stated his intent to propose a work session around the A, B, and D, options, but the timing necessitated Council to decide if they wanted two meetings in July in order to meet the standards under code. Page 76 of 564 June 7, 2022 4 Councilmember Helgeson asked what the time constraint was for advertisement for June 28, 2022 or July 12, 2022 when the original motion was to have advertisements for scenarios A and B at that meeting. Community Development Director Mr. Kent White answered that they still did not have enough time to have things advertised on June 28, 2022, but the goal was to have all information related to precincts, boundaries, and polling places before the Board at that date, then advertise the preferred scenario. Mr. White said that staff’s suggestion was to have a called meeting on July 26, 2022 , giving Council the ability to have both meetings in July or cancel the July 12 meeting. Councilmember Helgeson suggested the fourth Tuesday in August as the next date. He asked if the July 12 meeting was unnecessary. Mayor Dolan said that was correct. Mayor Dolan asked what the consensus was for July 26, 2022 as a meeting date. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the meeting was currently scheduled or would be called as a special meeting on July 26. Mr. Benda said that it was not currently on the calendar, and the current date was held as July 12. He said that the July 12 meeting would be cancelled and a special meeting would be held on July 26. He said that Councilmember Helgeson had proposed they cancel August 9, 2022 and add a meeting on August 23, 2022; Councilmember Helgeson said that was correct. Mayor Dolan noted that there was consensus from the Council. // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, Council considered the to hold a closed meeting to consider appointments to the Lynchburg City School Board pursuant to Section 2.2- 3711(A)(1.) of the Code of Virginia. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he would be voting against the closed meeting because he would rather have this process be more transparent and open to the public. Councilmember Helgeson said that taxpayers, students, families, teachers, administration, and the School Board had been suffering in their school system. He said that many issues had not been addressed, and constituents had stressed how important it was for their elected officials to make education better in Lynchburg. He noted that bus drivers had recently been petitioning the School Board for collective bargaining within the City of Lynchburg because they had not been heard by their unions, administration, or the City government, but the issues of the school bus service had been going on for Page 77 of 564 June 7, 2022 5 years. He said that there must be dramatic changes, and there must be credible candidates to serve on the School Board. He motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to appoint Dr. Martin Day to School District 2. Councilmember Helgeson said that Dr. Day had answered the questions and was a good person who would bring wisdom, age, and intellect. He said that many current employees in the schools were not happy, so he hoped they could appoint Dr. Day to District 2. Councilmember Tweedy said that she would like to make a substitute motion to go into closed session. She stated that politics should not be encroaching on the education system. Councilmember Faraldi said that Dr. Day would be a fine addition to the School Board with his background in education at Virginia Tech and in Lynchburg. He said that it would be a disservice to put someone of lesser caliber to the position, so he looked forward to voting on the motion to support his appointment. Councilmember Nelson said that he agreed with the high qualifications of Dr. Day, but it was inappropriate to critique any or all of these portfolios in a public session where they wanted to hear candid remarks and observations. He stated that while he would vote against the motion, it did not mean he would not otherwise support Dr. Day, but he wished to have the flexibility to candidly discuss candidates and make sound decisions. Vice Mayor Wright said that he agreed that Dr. Day was a quality candidate but the inappropriateness of this motion led him to be unsupportive. Councilmember Wilder said that he appreciated the process that allowed them to discuss all of the candidates. He said that the City had reviewed all interviews of candidates and had sent comments regarding that. Councilmember Helgeson said that the vote for appointments would be public. He said that it was appropriate to have the justifications for the votes as well. Mayor Dolan stated that the conversation would not be as candid in open session as it would be in closed session, and she did not want the process hijacked. She said that it had no reflection on her opinion of Dr. Day, however she would be voting against the motion. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 Page 78 of 564 June 7, 2022 6 Noes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Councilmember Helgeson clarified that the votes would be in public after the closed session. Mayor Dolan said yes. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Nelson, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Helgeson motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to appoint Dr. Martin Day to the Lynchburg City School Board, School District 2, for a 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 Page 79 of 564 June 7, 2022 7 Councilmember Wilder motioned, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, to appoint Mr. Anthony Andrews to the Lynchburg City School Board, School District 1, for a 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025. Councilmember Faraldi said that he would not be supporting this appointment because he did not think Mr. Andrews adequately supported parents’ oversight and ability to make decisions in bringing up their children, and there was a stronger application for Dr. Struble in this process. Councilmember Helgeson said that he would be voting against Mr. Andrews’ appointment because there were many issues plaguing the school system that other candidates could address more adequately. Councilmember Wilder said that Mr. Andrews had worked in their community in elementary and pre-kindergarten education programs to ensure their children were educated properly, and his own children attended the Lynchburg City schools, so his voice was appreciated. Councilmember Tweedy stated that she would be voting in support of Mr. Andrew s due to his engagement in the school system and community through his work as a parent and as a firefighter. She stated that his qualifications, time spent in the community, and volunteer work gave him an understanding of the school system that they wanted to build for the current and future students. Councilmember Helgeson said that parents decided to take their children out of Lynchburg City schools because the schools required improvement. He said that there were facts as to how the schools were doing, and it was critical that they appointed leadership who would ask good questions and demand accountability. Councilmember Tweedy said that there were many reasons why people did not enroll their children in the public school system, but all were invited to participate. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Faraldi, Helgeson 2 Councilmember Helgeson motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to appoint Dr. Jason Fleshman to the Lynchburg City School Board, School District 3, for a 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025. He stated that Dr. Fleshman had noted the issue of high teacher turnover and the underlying issues, which was important in making Lynchburg schools better. Councilmember Faraldi said that Dr. Page 80 of 564 June 7, 2022 8 Fleshman would be a wonderful addition to the Lynchburg City School Board because he opposed collective bargaining and spoke creatively about how to bring in a competitive nature to the public school system by teaching vocational opportunities and was transparent and direct in his answers. Councilmember Wilder made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy, to appoint Ms. Gloria Preston to the Lynchburg City School Board, School District 3, for a 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025. Councilmember Wilder said that Ms. Preston had worked as an educator in Lynchburg City Schools and surrounding counties for more than 30 years, and he was a well-respected member of the community who had continued to strongly support public education through volunteerism. He said that she would be a great asset to the School Board due to her insight and relationships within the school system in order to make it better. Councilmember Tweedy said that Ms. Pr eston had a proven record of pulling children across the standardized testing line as a principal, served in rural county and city school systems, and served in positions that shouldered many large burdens throughout the years. She said that Ms. Preston’s knowledge was essential to addressing issues in the school system and Dr. Fleshman did not have commensurate experience. Vice Mayor Wright said that he would support the motion because he had great respect for Ms. Preston, her experience, and her integrity. He expressed his thanks to the candidates who submitted their names and participated in the process. Councilmember Nelson said that Dr. Jason Fleshman would be a great member of the School Board, with a variety of insights that could be brought, and not only had he been a teacher in their school system but could look at the school division from a state level. He said that however, he also shared the highest regards for Ms. Gloria Preston, and he would be supporting her nomination. Mayor Dolan said that Ms. Preston would be a strong School Board member due to her experience in the school system and community involvement, so she would be supporting her appointment. Councilmember Faraldi clarified that the vote was for the substitute motion, which was to appoint Ms. Preston to District 3; Mayor Dolan replied yes. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Page 81 of 564 June 7, 2022 9 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 Councilmember Faraldi said that he challenged the notion that by nominating the same type of person who had works within the institution, there would be some sort of product. He said that having less involvement in the school system did not bar other citizens from serving on the School Boar d in this capacity. Vice Mayor Wright said that he was not entirely clear on what Councilmember Faraldi’s comments referred to, because both nominees had served their entire careers in school systems of a public nature, and affiliation with Liberty did not preclude anyone from serving in Lynchburg boards and commissions. Councilmember Tweedy said that in her time served on the School Board, many members had been employed by Liberty University, and nor the City nor Council was against anyone working with Liberty. She said that there should not be divisive verbiage around these appointments and those who had previously served in the seats. Councilmember Faraldi said that Dr. Fleshman’s and Ms. Preston’s backgrounds were not being compared fairly when they each had adequate experience, and Dr. Fleshman’s interview gave clarity on his views of collective bargaining. Councilmember Helgeson said that Dr. Fleshman had the best chance of facing the challenges in the school system based on the questions answered in his interview, and he had brought up the issues of teacher turnover and alternative education. Mayor Dolan said that Ms. Preston was a very qualified person for this position. She said that both Dr. Fleshman and Ms. Preston were impressive candidates, and it was difficult for her to decide, but she would continue to support Ms. Preston because she was who the community needed for this position. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 // The meeting adjourned at 6:20 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 82 of 564 June 28, 2022 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 28th day of June, 2022, at 4:00 P.M. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 6 Absent: Beau Wright 1 // City Manager Wynter Benda announced that Assistant City Manager John Hughes had recently earned a Doctor of Philosophy, so his title would now reflect that association. He announced that Alec Brebner had been hired as Executive Director at Central Virginia Planning District Commission. // In the matter of Redistricting, Agenda Item #1, Council continued a discussion on redistricting. Mr. Tom Martin, City Planner, gave a brief overview of the item to the Council. This was the monthly work session for redistricting, which was required to be done by state and local governments based on the results of the 2020 Census. City Council would select Scenario A, B, or D forward and precinct boundaries for public hearing on July 26, 2022. At the May 24, 2022 Work Session, City Council directed staff to redraw precinct boundaries based upon the minimal impact necessary to voters for Scenarios A, B & D. Precinct boundaries have been redrawn for each scenario and meet the requirements of State Code for ward, precinct, and polling places. He stated that in Scenario A, there would be 788 voters with a change in polling place, in Scenario B, there would be 1,359 voters with a change in voting place, and in Scenario D, there would be 3,983 voters with a change in voting place. He said that also in Scenario D, there would be 5,986 voters who experienced a change in ward but not in polling place, for a total change affecting 9,969 voters. He stated that for Liberty University, there was a request to move the polling place from the Vines Center to the Montview Alumni Ballroom for Scenarios A, B, and D, which would affect 2,145 voters in Ward III, Precinct 2. He said that in Scenario A, the Change Area 1 was the area from Old Forest Road to Lakeside Drive, which would shift from Ward IV, Precinct 4, to Ward II, Precinct 1, and voters would begin voting at St. Paul’s Episcopal Church. Change Area 2 was currently in Ward IV, Precinct 3, and was proposed to go to Ward II, Precinct 2, which had a polling place of Robert S. Payne. Change Area 3, the Fort Avenue to Oakley Avenue area had the largest shift in voters over to Robert S. Pay ne. Change Area 4 had no population in the area but was suggested as a change because of mapping issues. He Page 83 of 564 June 28, 2022 2 said that under Scenario A, the people who would remain in Ward III, Precinct 1, could continue to vote at Lynchburg Public Library, or they could vote at a new polling place, West Lynchburg Baptist Church, or it could be combined at Sheffield. He indicated the resulting shifts in the wards resulting in these changes. He said that Scenario B also shifted population into Ward II and out of Wards III and IV. He said that in this scenario, Change Area 1 shifted from north of Ivy Creek, currently in Ward IV, Precinct 4, to Ward I, Precinct 5, and voters currently voting at Linkhorne Middle School would begin voting at First Christian Church. Change Area 2 had Ward III, Precinct 1, where voters currently voted at the library and would move to Robert S. Payne. He indicated the shifts in the ward boundaries resulting from the population changes. He said that Scenario D divided the City more into quadrants, meeting the populations for each wards, but with more change areas involved. Change Area 1 contained the area north of Ivy Creek that would begin voting at First Christian Church, changing from Ward IV to Ward 1. Change Area 2 was currently in Ward IV and would become part of Ward I, but polling places would not be changed. Change Area 3, north of Lakeside Drive, was part of Ward I, and would still be in Ward I but would have a change in polling place from Heritage Baptist Church to Linkhorne Middle School. Change Area 4 was the area south of Lakeside Drive, currently in Ward I and would change to Ward IV, with the polling place remaining at Heritage Baptist Church. Change Area 5 was in Ward IV and would go to Ward II, becoming part of a new precinct, Ward II, Precinct 5, along with Area 6 and 7, that would vote at the Lynchburg Public Library. Area 8 was a triangular piece, and in this scenario, Area 9 was the polling place for Ward III, Precinct 1 would have to go to Lynchburg Baptist Church or be combined with Sheffield. He indicated the changes in boundaries resulting from the ward shifts. He reiterated that staff requested decision for the scenario, the polling place for Ward III, Precinct 1, and consideration of the request for Liberty University to move the polling place for Ward III, Precinct 2. Councilmember Helgeson said that after discussing Scenario D, there was more disruption to voters than initially anticipated, and he preferred a scenario with less impact such as Scenario A, which only moved about 800 voters and allowed the polling place to remain at the library. Councilmember Nelson asked if affected voters and least changes for voters were somewhat synonymous with maintaining closer to the status quo. Mr. Martin said that he was unsure if it was the least change, but it was a change that citizens would be notified, whether it was a change of ward or Page 84 of 564 June 28, 2022 3 polling place. Councilmember Nelson asked if A and B had the least changes and D had greater changes. Mr. Martin said that from the numbers, yes. Councilmember Nelson said that three of the principles opposing gerrymandering were to ensure that districts were compact, cohesive, and contiguous. The three scenarios presented had the least compactness, contiguity, and cohesiveness in Scenarios A and B, but Scenario D complied with those standards in a strict way so that there was no gerrymandering. It would be beneficial to make a change in 2022 that was sustainable through 2040 than to make a massive change in 2031, and this would allow their citizens to adjust to what would become a much more established landscape that could persevere and be sustainable. He said that changing the status quo was not concerning if there was just reason to do so, and Scenario D gave them a concise, anti-gerrymandered approach. He stated that he approved for Ward III, Precinct 1 to move to West Lynchburg Baptist Church. Councilmember Faraldi asked if there was a definition as to what clearly defined and observable boundaries were. City Attorney Mr. Matthew Freedman said that it was statutorily defined in the State Code, and typically referred to boundaries in the real world such as roadways, bodies of water, and railroads, and was specifically contemplated in State Code §24.2. Councilmember Faraldi asked if defining a residential neighborhood between one of those roads counted, meaning any road dividing one set of houses from another. Mr. Feedman said that as long as the boundaries followed the road, it would be acceptable. Councilmember Faraldi asked for clarification that a townhome community could be divided in such a way. Mr. Feedman said that under the definition of observable boundary, yes, but depending on the motive behind the change, there may be other issues, such if there were other issues that created dilution of a minority group of voters or changed a majority/minority vote in a particular ward. He said that Council could consider keeping neighborhoods together and cohesive as described by Councilmember Nelson, but in discussion of clearly observable boundaries, the idea did not necessarily look at a neighborhood but at physical things to follow on a map. Councilmember Faraldi said that in his understanding of the materials, splitting a neighborhood would not be justified. He clarified that his question pertained to Scenarios A and B, which maintained a split of a townhome community currently divided by Wards IV and I, on Devonshire Road. He said that this split affected the ability for the neighborhood to be represented effectively. He stated that he agreed with Councilmember Nelson in that Page 85 of 564 June 28, 2022 4 Scenarios A and B maintained the status quo, which was not appropriate for this process, and the r ight thing to do was to follow Scenario D, bring together the neighborhoods, and use the boundaries in the proper way. He said that the goal was that for people who had a new precinct should be counted as an impact, change, or adjustment, but moving from one precinct or ward to another was not considered a change, because there was not a physical change but a change in district, and the state did not consider that a change in their creation of districting maps. He asked if the change in the Liberty Universi ty polling place was included in the numbers for impacts. Mr. Martin answered that no, they were not included in the previously listed numbers, because they came in very late and it was equal across all three scenarios. Councilmember Faraldi said that a change associated with a number should be considered with this definition change. Mr. Martin said that yes, and the number of voters affected had been shared with Council. Councilmember Tweedy said that Scenario D was disrupting, conflicting, and confusing. She said that she agreed with Councilmember Helgeson about selection of Scenario A, which was the least disruptive to voters. She motioned, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to approve Scenario A, allowing Liberty University to switch their polling places from the Vines Center to the Montview Ballroom, and keeping the library polling place for Ward III, Precinct 1. Councilmember Helgeson said that with the exponential growth in Lynchburg, it was the Council’s duty to decide how to fulfill the comprehens ive plan, and Scenario A would be the easiest option to achieve their goals. Councilmember Wilder asked if any additional comments had been received. Mr. Martin said that about 100 more comments had been received since April, and it was essentially the same information as had been stated before. Councilmember Wilder asked if Scenarios A and B were considered to be gerrymandered. Mr. Martin said that he would leave that to Council to decide. Councilmember Wilder said that he could approve of Scenario A. Councilmember Helgeson clarified that there was a scenario that added a precinct in Scenario D. Mr. Martin said that yes, Scenario D added a precinct. Councilmember Faraldi asked how or who was disenfranchised by Scenario D. Councilmember Tweedy said that there was potential of 9,000 voters who would be moved around the City and affected as Scenario D was implemented. Councilmember Faraldi said that if they were going to make a decision Page 86 of 564 June 28, 2022 5 about redistricting using a word such as impact, there was question about if there should be a definition as to what impact was. Councilmember Tweedy asked if it was legally required there be a definition of impact. Councilmember Faraldi said that there was not, but if they did not have a definition, they were making a decision on an idea that may include different understanding among the members of the Council and community, and potentially could lead to issues if they were not codified in what was understood to be the impact by an associated vote. Councilmember Tweedy asked Mr. Freedman if Scenarios A, B, and D kept the Council in legal compliance with the task of this decision. Mr. Freedman said yes, they stayed within the mathematical limits and preserved the minority/majority district of Ward II, which was of paramount importance, and as far as the precincts and polling places, they adhered to the standard requirements that should be considered in the redistricting process. Councilmember Faraldi asked staff if there was any guidance in the packet information for redistricting procedures as to whether or not impact was used as a justification for changing a district. Mr. Martin said that he was not aware, and the scenarios were based on numbers that the City Attorney had referenced. Councilmember Faraldi asked if Mr. Martin was not aware that there was any in there regarding that. Mr. Martin said no. Councilmember Faraldi said that if that could be provided, it would be helpful. Ms. Christine Gibbons answered that she did not know if there was a definition of impact, but what had been seen in her office and with the Redistricting Committee with Scenario A and B, with the voters being moved who used to vote at the public library being moved to R. S. Payne, and being moved to St. Paul’s, there would be additional people voting there, bringing up the total number of voters to over 4,500 for both of those, and they were both currently around 3,500. R. S. Payne was already impacted because there were many people who voted there in person, and it was a small area, and often the line was out of the door. Councilmember Faraldi said that there was no justification for impact making a decision on redistricting, but they could consider impact in their discussions. He said that impact should be defined if the City Council was to make a decision behind it and vote accordingly. He asked if Mr. Martin could share some of the recent information from the public survey. Mr. Martin answered that out of 251 responses, which still considered Scenario C, 43% preferred Scenario D. Councilmember Faraldi asked how many people listed Scenario D as their second choice. Mr. Martin answered that it was 29%. Councilmember Faraldi reiterated that about 70% of people selected Scenario D as their first or second choice. Mr. Martin said Page 87 of 564 June 28, 2022 6 yes. He said that the other question, which was if it was important that wards were compact, 165 out of 251, or 68% of people said yes, and if it was important for wards to keep neighborhoods together, 180 people or 81% said yes, if it was important for people to remain in the same ward they were in now, 29% said yes, 32% said no, and 39% were indifferent. He said that when asked to indicate what ward they were in, only 94 people responded out of 251. Councilmember Faraldi said that the survey indicated why Scenario D was the best option for the city. Councilmember Nelson said that Scenario D disenfranchised voters by moving them all over the City. He stated that disenfranchisement included barriers put up that hindered a person’s ability to reach the polls, confusing information that suggested wrong directions, voting days, or candidates, but simply having someone travel from a point to a new point was not disenfranchisement. He s tated that Scenario D promoted and enhanced the convenience of more voters to vote in their City than either A or B, with wards that were compact, cohesive, and contiguous, and as such, moved voters closer to the precincts in which they would cast their votes rather than distanced through a circuitous route in which a ward extended from Boonsboro to Maple Hill. Councilmember Helgeson said that they had already held the public hearing from Scenario D, and after this public hearing, they would decide and vote. He said that because both had been properly vetted and advertised with public hearings, they could discuss this on July 26, 2022 as to what option was best. Mr. Freedman said that they would have to have another public hearing in Scenario D in its entir ety, because when there were changes in precincts or polling places, it must be readvertised. Councilmember Faraldi made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, to hold a public hearing on July 26, 2022, for Scenarios A and D as currently presented, incorporating the Liberty University precinct. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the public hearing was necessary when Scenario D had already had its public hearing. Mr. Martin stated that only the ward boundaries were under consideration during that public hearing, and the new polling places and precincts required a new public hearing. Mr. Freedman clarified that the public hearing for both scenarios required the boundary changes and related ordinances to be drafted for each. Councilmember Helgeson asked if that information was prepared. Mr. Martin answered that the maps were prepared, but the ordinances were not, as it required a lot of staff Page 88 of 564 June 28, 2022 7 time to create the descriptions for the ward boundaries and precinct boundaries within the wards. Councilmember asked what the timeframe was to create this information. Mr. Martin said that it would take multiple days. Councilmember Helgeson said that he approved of having another public hearing, but not if it required staff work for an option that had no future or had already been fully addressed. Councilmember Tweedy asked if not everyone submitted their ward for the survey. Mr. Martin said that was correct. Councilmember Tweedy asked if that was not required on the survey. Mr. Martin said that it was a question on the survey but was not required. Councilmember Tweedy asked if the incomplete surveys were statistically sound based on the questions. Mr. Martin said that the survey gave Council a general idea of how 251 people thought, which was a very small percentage of 79,000 people. Councilmember Tweedy stated that roughly half of those people did not state what ward they lived in. Mr. Martin stated that statistically, he was unsure if they could use the results of the survey to support A, B, or D. Councilmember Helgeson asked how long it took to get the ballots when deciding between Scenarios A and D and if staff was preparing for either option. General Registrar Ms. Christine Gibbons stated that she would be participating in training through the state so that they could discuss the new changes in the law regarding that each precinct would have to have their own distinct ballot so that the results for early voting and voting by mail could be aggregated by the precinct. She stated that there would be continued training in July and August that would give more information as to what that looked like, but they did look at the numbers for past elections, which was broken down by precinct, and she usually brought those scenarios and estimates to the Council in August, because they had to have them ready by the beginning of September so that they could mail out over 2,000 ballots. Councilmember Helgeson asked if Ms. Gibbons would be preparing any differently, so having both options would not be negative. Ms. Gibbons said no. She stated that the Commissioner of Elections contacted the City, asking what the status was of the local redistricting. She stated that the state was paying for notices to be sent to all voters state-wide, given in the budget from the General Assembly, and the deadline for everything to be done was September 1. Mayor Dolan called the vote to consider the substitute motion. Ayes: Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Dolan, Faraldi 5 Page 89 of 564 June 28, 2022 8 Noes: Wilder 1 Absent: Wright 1 Mayor Dolan called the vote to approve the substitute motion. Ayes: Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Dolan, Faraldi 5 Noes: Wilder 1 Absent: Wright 1 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #2a, Council received a briefing on the rezoning of R-3, Medium Density Residential to R-4, High Density Residential at 2237 Rivermont Avenue. Mayor Dolan stated that this item will appear for City Council vote on the July 26, 2022 public hearing age nda. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave an overview of the item to Council. Brian Feedman, M.D. is petitioning to rezone 2237 Rivermont Avenue from R-3, Medium Density Residential District to R-4, High Density Residential District. The property is currently a nonconforming use with seven (7) apartments. On May 25, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended denial (5-0), with 1 member absent, Marion, and 1 vacancy, of the rezoning petition. The Planning Division recommended denial of the rezoning petiti on. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #2b, Council received a briefing on the Rezoning of B-1, Limited Business District to R-3, Medium Density Residential District; Future Land Use Map Amendment, Community Commercial to Medium Density Residential, at 620 Leesville Road. Mayor Dolan stated that this item will appear for City Council vote on the July 26, 2022 public hearing agenda. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, gave a brief overview of the item to Council. KAL Holdings is petitioning to amend the Future Land Use Map ( FLUM) from Community Commercial to Medium Density Residential and to rezone approximately one (1) acre from B-1, Limited Business District to R-3, Medium Density Residential District at 620 Leesville Road. If approved the property would be developed as four (4) duplexes. On June 8, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (5-0), with 1 member absent, Light, and 1 vacancy, of the FLUM Amendment and rezoning petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the FLUM Amendment and rezoning petition. // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item #6, Councilmember Helgeson stated that the June 22, 2022 TRC meeting included a piece of property in Cornerstone that Council had denied for apartments and had now been approved and recommended for a tiny hotel, with no comment from the Zoning Administrator. Page 90 of 564 June 28, 2022 9 He said that they denied the residential use because of the potential as a business, but typically hotels had 100 rooms. He said that he wanted to know why it had not come back t o Council who had just recently looked at that property and voted down, and why it came back through TRC without comments and as an anomaly as it was. He said that normally there were provisions, conditions, and other items related to retail developments. Councilmember Wilder stated that the Oak Tree Cemetery had a great event for Juneteenth, and he wanted to commend the staff for that. He stated that Parks and Recreation was also doing Hill City Hoops during the month of July so their children had activities during the summertime. He said that he also appreciated the extended hours at the pool and having events at the basketball arena. Councilmember Faraldi said that he recently met with the Wyndhurst HOA on Paulette Circle, who had a variety of concerns, one being that they wanted a no U-turn sign put in, and second that they had a tree keeper who was unable to tend to the trees, so the trees were overgrown. He said that they had hoped to have those two items addressed if possible. He requested that at the next scheduled meeting, City Council consider a vote on a resolution speaking to their joint support of the rights of all residents to safely protest, speak, and assemble, a document encouraging peaceful political and civic engagement for anyone seeking to participate, and finally that expresses their unified condemnation and total admonishment of the destructive actions, vandalism, intimidation, and potential violence perpetrated against the Blue Ridge Pregnancy Center on June 25, 2022. City Manager Benda said that there was opportunity for Council to continue their work session on redistricting for the remainder of the time allotted. He stated that there were closed session items on the formal docket for later, and there was time left to have City staff engage Council until 6 p.m. Mayor Dolan asked if one item could be addressed during closed session now and the other during the later closed session. City Manager Benda said that was acceptable. Mayor Dolan asked if there were any objections from Council and heard none. // On motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss the pending City’s Region 2000 Services Authority lawsuit and surrounding circumstances pursuant to §2.2-3711(7) and §2.2-3711(8) of the Code of Virginia, as amended. Page 91 of 564 June 28, 2022 10 With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Nelson, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: Absent: Wright 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certi fication resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Nelson, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Wright 1 // The meeting was recessed at 5:39 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Jeff S. Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 6 Absent: Beau Wright 1 Councilmember Faraldi gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. Page 92 of 564 June 28, 2022 11 // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #4, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting a Resolution #R-22-041 approving the FY 2023 Annual Action Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program. Ms. Melva Walker, Grants Manager, gave a summary of the item to Council. The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) requires local governments, which receive federal Community Planning and Development (CPD) formula block grant funds, to prepare an Annual Action Plan as a component of the approved 2020-2024 Five- Year Consolidated Plan. The Plan outlines the City’s needs, goals, and objectives for community development (both housing and non-housing areas). The Plan has been prepared and is comprised of the required components, including the CDBG and HOME projects that will be implemented during the program year to address the identified needs and objectives. On May 21, a public notice was published in The News and Advance stating that a draft of the proposed Program Year 2022 (FY 2023) Annual Action Plan was available for public review for a 30-day comment period and that City Council would be conducting a public hearing on June 28 to receive public comments regarding the Program Year 2022 (FY 2023) Annual Action Plan. The advertisement for the Annual Action Plan included the projects recommended by City Council at the March 22 meeting. Notably, the neighborhood projects approved for implementation included Jefferson Park improvements, Timber Ridge Hill Pedestrian improvements, housing rehabilitations within the Diamond Hill and Dearington neighborhoods, and the development of affordable rental and home-ownership housing units. City staff has not yet received any public comments regarding the draft Plan. City Council and citizen comments received at the public hearing regarding the contents of the Annual Action Plan will be incorporated into the final document and submitted to HUD for approval. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Wilder made a motion, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, to approve the Resolution #R-22-041 approving the FY 2023 Annual Action Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Page 93 of 564 June 28, 2022 12 Noes: 0 Absent: Wright 1 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #5, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting a Resolution #R-22-042 approving the CUP to allow the construction of a lighted sports complex at Liberty Christian Academy. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, provided a brief summary to Council. Liberty University, Inc. has submitted a CUP petition to allow the construction of a four thousand, one hundred twenty-one (4,121) lighted multi-sport athletic complex at 1120 Hershey-Esbenshade Drive in an IN-2, Institutional 2 District. Ingress / Egress improvements to support the facility are proposed at 701 Mountain View Road. On March 14, 2017, Council approved a CUP petition to allow a larger, six thousand (6,000) seat facility; however, the CUP has since expired. City Council previously was briefed on this item at the June 7, 2022 work session, and on May 11, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (5-0) with 1 vacancy and 1 member absent, Johnson, of the CUP petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the CUP petition. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to adopt the Resolution #R-22-042, approving the CUP to allow the construction of a lighted sports complex at Liberty Christian Academy, seconded by Councilmember Wilder. Councilmember Helgeson asked why this item was brought back before the Council. Ms. Frischeisen said that CUPs were valid in the case of an institution for 36 months, and this was to essentially renew that CUP. Councilmember Helgeson asked if a CUP was still required under the IN-2. Ms. Frischeisen said yes, an arena was one of the only uses that was not by-right in an institutional district. Councilmember Helgeson clarified that while he taught at Liberty University and was affiliated with a group, there was no conflict in his objectivity of interest in that this was a different institution. Ms. Frischeisen clarified that this was a project for LCA, a high school, but was on property belonging to Liberty University. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Page 94 of 564 June 28, 2022 13 Absent: Wright 1 // In the matter of planning, Agenda Item #6, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting a Resolution #R-22-043 approving the CUP to allow the expansion of Spring Hill Cemetery located at 1550 James Street. Ms. Frischeisen gave a brief summary of the item to Council. Spring Hill Cemetery Association has submitted a CUP petition proposing the expansion of the existing cemetery. The expansion would include enlargement of the existing columbarium, new columbarium walls, a cremation garden, new burial plots and a new vehicular egress to Stadium Road. The property is zoned R-3, Medium-Density Residential District which allows cemeteries upon approval of a CUP by City Council. On May 11, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (4-0), with 1 vacancy and 2 members absent, Bowden, Johnson, of the CUP petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the CUP petition. Mayor Dolan opened the floor to receive input from citizens. Mr. Eames Power, Secretary - Treasurer of the Spring Hill Cemetery Association said that he represented their nonprofit organization to request approval of the petition for the Conditional Use Permit for expansion of their burial space within the existing cemetery. He explained that the proposed work was in the southeastern portion of the existing cemetery and would include modeling and expansion of the existing columbarium, creation of a new columbarium with interment garden, and creation of additional grave space for traditional interments. There would be two new drives created, with one leading to Stadium Road and the other leading to James Street, and these two drives would be gates at the public street and were to be opened as exit drives at other funerals that occurred in this area of the cemetery. He said that the cemetery had continuously served the needs of the Lynchburg community since its first burial in 1855, and they currently had over 15,700 interments in the cemetery. He said that it was the Association’s intention to remain an active cemetery and continue their tradition and history of service to Lynchburg families into the next century, and the petition today was part of their plan to meet those needs. A letter addressed to City Council in support of the proposal and previously furnished to the Clerk of Council by the surrounding neighbors of the property was read into the record. A letter addressed to City Council in support of the proposal, previously furnished to the Clerk of Council by the surrounding neighbors of the property was read into the record. (Kathy Thompson, 1609 Page 95 of 564 June 28, 2022 14 Shaffer St.; Annette Burford, 1611 Shaffer St.; Latrinda Burford, 1611 Shaffer St.; Luther Richards, 1611 Shaffer St.; Amber Jennings, 1660 Callaham St.; James Stewart, 1540 Gordon St.; Ronnie Mayberry, 1604 Callaham St.; Wilbert Ward, 1802 Shaffer St.; Carolyn Williams, 1802 Shaffer St.; Mary Mayberry, 1604 Callaham St.; Alan Brooks, 1590 Blackburn St.; Kennth McCormick, 1500 Blackburn St.; Nancy McCormick, 1500 Blackburn St.) There was no one else to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt the Resolution #R-22-043 approving the CUP to allow the expansion of Spring Hill Cemetery located at 1550 James Street. Councilmember Wilder asked if it was a conflict of interest if he owned a plot in the cemetery. Mr. Freedman said that he believed he could so long as he announced that he was a member of the gr oup of owners of plots there and could participate impartially. Councilmember Helgeson said that he understood the necessity for the cemetery to expand physically to continue their work in the community. He stated that he still regretted his vote to close the public street in the cemetery, and although some community members approved of the closure, many citizens were surprised afterwards that their local road was closed to them with a fence and no explanation. He said that he would like to see a condition within the CUP that opened Rives Street to the public. He stated that he could not support the CUP without thinking of the citizens that he represented in that area and his responsibility for the closure of that street. Councilmember Nelson said that it was unfortunate that no members of Council were aware that there were notice issues that resulted in close neighbors being unaware that the public street would be closed until after the fact, and they then came to Council with valid points that Council could not control at that point because the street had already been vacated. He stated that it was improper for the City to impose an expectation of proffers being made by the applicant, because proffers and concessions had to be unilaterally initiated by the applicant and not based on coercion or pressure from the City to do something or refrain from doing something. He clarified that they could not even talk about it from a legal perspective. City Attorney Mr. Matthew Freedman said that was correct, and the conditions must be reasonably related to the use. He said that the City Manager and he could not find how they were related, Page 96 of 564 June 28, 2022 15 so unless the applicant was willing to voluntarily consent to do that, there would be no way to forcefully impose it on them to grant the permit. Councilmember Helgeson said that it was not a proffer, but a condition on the Conditional Use Permit. Councilmember Nelson said that he could understand that. He said that the City still should not be putting pressure on someone to do somethin g in exchange for approval from Council. He said that on its own merits, this was a viable Conditional Use Permit because it was internal to the existing property of the cemetery, and there would be additional access, which should minimize traffic congestion during events. Councilmember Tweedy stated that she supported the Resolution and appreciated their long- term plan and development. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 5 Noes: Helgeson 1 Absent: Wright 1 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #7, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting Resolution #R-22-044 approving the CUP to allow the construction of a gymnasium and classroom addition at New Vistas Schools located at 520 Eldon Street. Ms. Frischeisen gave a brief summary of the item to Council. New Vistas School is petitioning for a CUP at 520 Eldon Street to allow the construction of a six thousand two hundred sixty-two (6,262) square foot building to be used as a gymnasium and classroom space in an R-3, Medium-Density Residential District. There was no proposed increase in student enrollment. On April 27, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval of the CUP Petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the CUP Petition. Mayor Dolan opened the floor to receive citizen input. Ms. Laurie England, head of the New Vistas School, addressed the Council. She said that the school was a nonprofit that served over 600 children in the area who had attention and learning issues, and this new building would enhance their curriculum specifically with the addition of two new science labs, an art room, and the half -court gymnasium. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Page 97 of 564 June 28, 2022 16 Councilmember Helgeson motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to approve the Resolution #R-22-044 approving the CUP to allow the construction of a gymnasium and classroom addition at New Vistas School located at 520 Eldon Street. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Wright 1 // In the matter of Public Comment, Citizen Timothy Santiago addressed the Council to state that the matter he had wished to address to Council had been handled appropriately so he had no further remarks. // In the matter of City Code, Council considered adopting Ordinance #O-22-045 approving City Code amendments for derelict buildings. Council received a brief summary of the item from Community Development Director Mr. Kent White. At the May 24, 2022 City Council meeting, code changes were adopted to address demolition of buildings and clutter, and at the same meeting, Council requested staff bring back the proposed derelict building ordnance with updates to the appeal process. Ordinance A provides the owner of a derelict building with the option to appeal the decision of the City Manager to the circuit court. Ordinance B provides the owner of a derelict building with the option to appeal the decision of the City Manager to City Council. Councilmember Helgeson motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt Ordinance B. Councilmember Helgeson said that he approved of having the City Council be the body of appeal in order to remain apprised of all issues that were had with their own processes and received feedback as elected officials. Councilmember Wilder said that he appreciated having an ordinance to fine- tune the process. Councilmember Nelson asked City Attorney Mr. Matthew Freedman if the applicant disagreed with City Council under Ordinance B, the ordinance allowed an appeal to circuit court from the City Council’s decision. Mr. Freedman answered that it did not provide for it, but if someone were aggrieved and had a due process or takings argument, they would still have the right to go to court over it, irrespective of what appeal process there was in the City. He said that there were benefits of either ordinance, and the benefit of Ordinance B was that City Council was overseeing the administrative Page 98 of 564 June 28, 2022 17 decision made by the manager or staff. He said that the circuit court process outlined in Ordinance A could be done anyway if they had a claim. Councilmember Nelson said that he wanted to confirm that they could not cut off due process to the judiciary. He said that for that reason, he was not inclined to let this Council be an extra step in that process, because if the applicant was truly aggrieved, then the circuit court should be vested at that earlier stage in the process. Councilmember Tweedy said that she would be in support of going to the circuit court first but appreciated the toolkit for their residents who had invested in their property. She said that it would be more beneficial to have the process be done through the courts in order to be more impartial. Councilmember Faraldi said that he was more supportive of Ordinance A. At the local level, they should be mindful of the separation of powers, and he would rather dissociate the Council from deciding which property goes and which stayed. Councilmember Helgeson clarified that the matter could still go to circuit court. He said that their form of local government had a leader who was elected by Council, and if there was a problem with the staff process, the elected officials would hear about it at some point in the future and be able to take some form of action. Mayor Dolan said that she would support Ordinance A to have the matter heard first by the circuit court. Councilmember Faraldi made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, to consider Ordinance A. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 5 Noes: Helgeson 1 Absent: Wright 1 Mayor Dolan called the vote for the motion to approve Ordinance A. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 5 Noes: Helgeson 1 Absent: Wright 1 Page 99 of 564 June 28, 2022 18 // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item #9, Council had a discussion about amending the City Council’s Rules of Procedure to align Mayor and Vice Mayor elections with general elections. Councilmember Faraldi stated that under Section 4-1(B) of City Council’s Rules of Procedure and pursuant to Section 15.2-1400 of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, City Council should consider amending its Rules of Procedure to move its Mayor and Vice- Mayor elections from July to January. Should City Council wish to pursue this amendment, City staff will include it as an amendment when City Council’s Rules of Procedure are presented for re-adoption in July 2022. Councilmember Wilder said that it made sense to make such a change. Councilmember Faraldi asked when this would be considered. City Attorney Mr. Matthew Freedman answered that staff would prepare a resolution for July 26, 2022. He said that Council had also requested some other changes related to the Rules of Procedure, so that would be brought forward as well to Council. Councilmember Faraldi asked if there was an issue if the rules expired. Mr. Freedman said no, because Virginia recognized the holdover rule, which permitted the mayor to serve as long as necessary until the next mayor was appointed. Council reached a consensus and directed staff to bring this back for a vote at the July meeting. // In the matter of the Budget, Item #10, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-22-040 amending the FY 2023 General Fund budget and appropriating funds for the purpose of extending the living wage increase for all part-time and hourly employees and to enhance funds available to impac t compression. Councilmember Wilder motioned, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, to adopt Resolution #R - 22-040 amending the FY 2023 General Fund budget and appropriating funds for the purpose of extending the living wage increase for all part-time and hourly employees and to enhance funds available to impact compression. Councilmember Helgeson said that he would be voting against this motion because of the tax increases and budget surpluses that had been incurred, and this item for part -time and hourly employees should have been included. He said that this money should be returned to the taxpayers. Councilmember Tweedy said that she would be supporting this item in order to adequately address the equitable pay and compression issues that were occurring along with growth and Page 100 of 564 June 28, 2022 19 development in the City. She stated that it was important to provide wages that kept hourly and part -time staff in place and supported the needs of those citizens. Councilmember Faraldi asked if there could be information provided regarding the allocations for funding for each department. Ms. Donna Witt answered that it would be based on years of service for each staff member. Councilmember Faraldi asked if that was in every department. Ms. Witt stated that it would be in every department and based on staff. Councilmember Faraldi said that an individual had emailed him some information related to their experience with compression in their own City department job, which they had worked at for a substantial number of years, and the lack of traction for proposals to alleviate compression ultimately had led them to question their value as a City employee. He asked if full - time staff with significant service in every department would receive an increase in pay. City Manager Benda said that they would, and that information had been provided to Council. He said that the percentage in the budget had not been projected until the very end and was part of the 5% that went unspent last year, so the request was made in order to meet Council’s desire to ensure employees were adequately compensated. He said that the implementation of this raise included a 3% general wage increase, and depending on years of service, the compression component in the budget. Councilmember Faraldi said that there was a tax burden in the budget that he had advocated against, and he still recommended there be an offset to the tax raise from the last year. He said that the dollars from certain revenues that did not see a statistical adjustment or equalization, he wanted to ensure that people who had served the City for a long time were able to see the City as a place where they were invested in for the services they offered to the community. He stated that he would continue his support for this measure. Councilmember Helgeson said that there were spending proposals in the budget that made it more difficult for small businesses to stay afloat. He said that raising these wages to a living wage would force small businesses to compete with those wages. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 5 Noes: Helgeson 1 Absent: Wright 1 Page 101 of 564 June 28, 2022 20 // On motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder , Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting for to consider appointments to the following boards and commissions: Board of Zoning Appeals, Central Virginia Community College Board, City Employee Appeals Board, Economic Development Authority, Historic Preservation Commission, Martin Luther King, Jr./Lynchburg Community Council, Museum Advisory Board, Region 2000 Services Authority, Youth Services Citizens Board, Airport Commission, Planning Commission, Social Services Advisory Board, Transit Company Board of Directors, and Lynchburg Emergency Planning Committee pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1.) of the Code of Virginia. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Wright 1 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Page 102 of 564 June 28, 2022 21 Absent: Wright 1 // On motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Board of Zoning Appeals: City Council recommends the reappointments of William Flint, Dennis Melancon, and Donald Doebler for new 5-year terms ending June 30, 2027. Central Virginia Community College Board: Justin Hensley to a new 4-year term expiring June 30, 2026. City Employee Appeals Board: Deborah Power to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025; reappointment of Kraig Cole to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025; Economic Development Authority: Craig Pettitt to a new 4-year term expiring June 30, 2026; R. Sackett Wood to a new 4-year term expiring June 30, 2026. Historic Preservation Commission: Reappointment of Tracey Langseth to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025; reappointment of Shanda Horner to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025. Martin Luther King, Jr./Lynchburg Community Council: Dr. Owen Cardwell to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025; Dr. Brenda Farmer to an unexpired term ending June 30, 2024; Dale Reed to an unexpired term ending June 30, 2024. Museum Advisory Board: Mark Poole to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025; reappointment of Douglas Lee to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025; Joseph Scott to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025; Clifton Potter to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025; Marjorie Freeman to a new 3- year term expiring June 30, 2025; Cynthia Fein to a new 3-year term expiring June 30, 2025. Region 2000 Services Authority: Acting Deputy City Manager Kent White Youth Services Citizens Board: no appointments were made during this time. Lynchburg Regional Airport Commission: City Manager Wynter C. Benda for an indefinite term; Dan Deter for a new 3-year term expiring December 31, 2024. Planning Commission: no appointments were made at this time. Social Services Advisory Board: Katheryne Goodman to an unexpired term expiring September 30, 2025. Greater Lynchburg Transit Company Board of Directors: Acting Deputy City Manager Kent White Lynchburg Emergency Planning Committee: Councilmember Chris Faraldi for a new 6-year term ending June 28, 2028. Page 103 of 564 June 28, 2022 22 Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Wright 1 // The meeting adjourned at 9:03 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 104 of 564 July 26, 2022 // A special called meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 26th day of July, 2022, at 4:00 P.M. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: P resent: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item 1, Residential Uses in Commercial Districts, Acting Director of Community Development Mr. Tom Martin provided a summary presentation to the Council. The City has a limited amount of vacant land. With only ten and eight-tenths percent (10.8%) of the City’s land zoned for commercial purposes, Council has expressed concern with allowing residential uses in commercial districts. Councilmember Faraldi asked if there was a standard ratio or best practice for land zoned for commercial use. Mr. Martin said he would research the answer and follow up with the Council. Councilmember Faraldi asked what percentage of the 10% was currently occupied. Mr. Martin said he could follow up with the Council. Councilmember Faraldi asked how many residential developments had been denied in the B zoning districts in the past five years. Mr. Martin responded that he recalled only one or two. Councilmember Faraldi asked where those developments were located. Mr. Martin responded that they had been in the southwest portion of the City. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the conversion of commercial space to residential because long-term vacancy was a recurring problem. Mr. Martin said that it was a concern. Councilmember Faraldi asked how often it happened. Mr. Martin said he did not recall it happening. He said if it was a concern of the Council, then they could require the commercial use be constructed first. Councilmember Faraldi asked how often they enforced set back requirements. Mr. Martin responded that they were enforced all the time, primarily at the site plan review process and time of building permitting. Councilmember Nelson asked if there was a functional difference between the zoning classifications of urban residential and B-4. Mr. Martin said that the end goal was the same—to allow residential uses without allowing a wide set of commercial uses. He said the urban residential district would have similar parking and set back reductions for an urban site with limits on commercial uses. He Page 105 of 564 July 26, 2022 said if they only used a B-4 zoning, staff may recommend excluding non-residential uses in applications, but they could not dictate proffers. He said creating an urban residential district would simplify the process. Councilmember Nelson asked if staff saw a benefit to creating an urban residential district. Mr. Martin said that staff promoted mixed-use development and wanted to see greater flexibility in the spaces. Councilmember Helgeson asked for clarification about how to increase business uses. Mr. Martin responded that B-4 zoning had been useful for developers to renovate and redevelop large industrial buildings that had been vacant for years. He said that allowing residential uses in the other B zoning districts provided the Council the option to approve or deny the applications. He said that single-family developments were not happening as often due to land costs and availability. He said if they wanted to curb population growth, they should slow apartment growth. Councilmember Helgeson stated that he wanted to curb the apartment growth. Mr. Martin responded that they should not rezone properties for higher density residential uses and not approve CUPs to limit apartment growth. Councilmember Helgeson clarified that residential uses were only in the B-4 district. Mr. Martin said 50% mixed use was available in the B-3 and B-5 districts by-right, but the first floor had to be commercial uses. He said in the B-4 district, the uses could be any mix of commercial and residential. Councilmember Helgeson clarified that the B-4 was specifically for downtown. Mr. Martin responded that when they changed the zoning to urban commercial, the B-4 zoning was applied to other buildings that were close to downtown but not in downtown. Councilmember Helgeson requested information from 20 years ago about the City's position on commercial property and high-density residential compared to present policies. Mr. Martin responded that 20 years ago, developers were requesting to rezone from low-density residential to commercial because retail uses were booming. Councilmember Helgeson suggested a way to make it more cost effective to construct single-family homes. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda responded that there were ways the City could prepare and construct the infrastructure to incentivize single-family development. Mr. Martin responded that the Council had taken action to incentivize single-family development, which had worked. He said cluster developments were working along with continuing the cost sharing of curb, gutter, and sidewalk. Page 106 of 564 July 26, 2022 Councilmember Wilder asked what the timeframe was for the comprehensive plan. Mr. Martin said they were drafting the proposals to provide to consultants, and they hoped to start the process by the end of the year. Councilmember Wilder asked about the benefits of the comprehensive planning process. Mr. Martin responded that the comprehensive plan would set the vision for the City for the next 20 years. He said that they wanted to review the future land use map to make sure it aligned with the City's goals and objectives. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the comprehensive plan review would include a consideration of the City's future economic needs. Mr. Martin responded that it could, and they would be working closely with the Office of Economic Development. Vice Mayor Wright asked whether the construction of apartments was driving away commercial development and hurting the City economically. Mr. Martin stated that he had not heard developers complain about apartment construction. He said that in the land use map review, they would consider how much land to dedicate to each use. Mr. Benda said that interest rates were increasing, so advertising more units in the same space was a commercial incentive. Vice Mayor Wright stated that there was a cost to developing apartments. Mr. Martin said that they had to determine the cost to the City, and they would review those costs during the comprehensive plan review. Councilmember Tweedy asked where incentive funding was sourced. Mr. Martin responded that it came from multiple sources, such as department budgets or other funds. Councilmember Tweedy asked what the cost was for a single-family development of 10 homes. Mr. Martin said that there was a range, and he could provide more information in a follow-up. Councilmember Tweedy asked what the cost was to public services for adding developments. Mr. Martin said that they were considering reviewing residential developments and the impacts they generated since development, such as the number of service calls and traffic generated. Councilmember Tweedy requested a comprehensive review of land use and residential development impact. Mr. Martin said he could begin researching the information. // In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item 2, Lakeside Drive: Second Phase, Water Quality Manager Erin Hawkins provided a summary of the staff report. As the completion of Lakeside Drive bridge and roundabout nears, the City will soon begin the removal of College Lake Dam. This aspect of the project will both mitigate a potential hazard and provide additional opportunities to connect the University Page 107 of 564 July 26, 2022 of Lynchburg and Lynchburg’s greenway system. Staff will provide an overview of the progress to date, schedule, construction methodology and expected outcomes. Councilmember Faraldi asked how they would account for upstream sediment and development. Ms. Hawkins responded that the design had accommodated for the watershed. She said that they were in the early stages of developing a watershed monitoring program. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the sediment was toxic. Ms. Hawkins said the sediment was not harmful. She said that when they performed sediment sample tests, there were elevated levels of chromium which restricted it from residential use. She said that the sediment could be used in industrial uses. She said that a review of the flood plain would happen with the FEMA flood plain map update. Vice Mayor Wright asked when DEQ reviewed the application and project. Ms. Hawkins responded that a review was ongoing from DEQ and the Army Corps of Engineers. She explained the Corps was the primary permitting agency, and the DEQ permits would ride the Corps permits. She said they anticipated receiving permits from the Army Corps of Engineers and the Virginia Marine Resource Commission in mid-September. Councilmember Nelson asked clarifying questions about how the dam and drainage functioned. Ms. Hawkins explained how the drainage functioned and how the sediment would be impacted. Director of Water Resources Mr. Tim Mitchell explained that they had monitoring resources that notified their phones, and they had weekly dam inspections. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item 3a, Street Renaming Process: Lakeside Drive Bridget to Elliot Schewel, and Dunbar Drive to Principal C.W. Seay, Acting Director of Community Development Mr. Tom Martin provided a summary of the staff report. City Council members have requested information on the possibility of renaming Dunbar Drive as “Principal C.W. Seay Drive” and naming the Lakeside Drive Bridge for Elliot Schewel. City Code Section 35-109 through Section 35-114 provides for the naming or renaming of streets within the City. City Policy provides the process for naming City Owned Properties, Facilities and Structures. Vice Mayor Wright asked if renaming the private portion of Dunbar Drive would pose a difficulty to drivers. Mr. Martin responded that it would be easier because none of the properties on the street had a Dunbar address. Page 108 of 564 July 26, 2022 Councilmember Helgeson asked if there was anything on Dunbar Drive. Mr. Martin responded that it was behind a school property. Councilmember Helgeson said he was less inclined to support changing the name if people regularly used it. Mr. Martin responded that the school did not have a Dunbar address. Councilmember Wilder said he supported the name changes to honor the individuals and African- American history. Vice Mayor Wright clarified that part of the request to rename Dunbar Drive came from the Dunbar High School alumni community. Councilmember Tweedy asked if the private section was the only portion requested to be renamed. Mr. Martin responded that the request did not specify which portion. Councilmember Tweedy clarified that the private addresses on Dunbar Drive would have an address change; Mr. Martin replied yes. Councilmember Tweedy requested to hear from the applicant about their intents for renaming. Councilmember Helgeson said they should reach out to the impacted residents. Mr. Martin said that if the applicant were interested in renaming the whole street, they would reach out to the private owners. Councilmember Helgeson said he wanted to discuss renaming the bridge further. Councilmember Tweedy requested a list of the names of the other bridges in the City, and she requested a list of any recently changed street names. Councilmember Wilder said he wanted to proceed with the renaming of the Lakeside Drive Bridge and Dunbar Drive. Vice Mayor Wright stated he supported moving forward with the request. // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item 3b, Clayton Avenue Street Vacation, Planner I Ms. Eve Mergenthaler provided a summary of the staff report. Ed Willman of Accupoint Surveying & Design, LLC, on behalf of Kathryn M. and Christopher T. Zabriskie, is petitioning to vacate a portion of Clayton Avenue located between 4013 and 4101 Peakland Place. The right-of-way vacation is proposed to allow the residents to enclose their backyard and assume ownership of the existing paved driveway. The total area of the proposed vacation is approximately two hundred eighty-eight thousandths (0.288) of an acre. The area to be vacated contains a sidewalk and a paved driveway that serves the residences at 4013 and 4101 Peakland Place. The petitioner proposes to allow continued pedestrian access by establishing a five Page 109 of 564 July 26, 2022 (5) foot wide public pedestrian access easement that extends the length of the area to be vacated. With the access easement in place, the vacation would not impact vehicle or pedestrian access. // In the matter of the Airport, Agenda Item 3c, The Hertz Corporation Lease Agreement, Airport Director Mr. Andrew La Gala provided a summary of the staff report. In September 2020, The Hertz Corporation elected to discontinue operating from the Lynchburg Regional Airport and ceased all rental car transactions due to a bankruptcy filing. The Hertz Corporation previously conducted business at the Lynchburg Regional Airport since 2004. Earlier this year, The Hertz Corporation expressed a renewed interest in operating from the airport once again. Due to the current airline industry environment and rental car business trends, this agreement will be in effect with a month-to-month term. An addendum to the existing concession agreements with the airport’s other three rental car operators – Enterprise, Avis and Budget – will be executed concurrently in order to keep all terms and conditions consistent. // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item 3d, Organizational Meeting, Clerk of Council Ms. Alicia L. Finney provided a summary presentation to the Council. Section § 15.2-1416 of the Code of Virginia and Section § 2-6 of the City Council’s Rules of Procedure provide that each year the local governing body shall prescribe by resolution the schedule of meeting dates, times, and places for the upcoming year. City Council’s schedule of meetings and work sessions is set forth in its rules of procedure under Section § 2- 1. Meetings shall be held in the City Council Chamber, on the first floor in City Hall, as follows: Second and fourth Tuesday of the month, at 4:00 p.m. There will be no regular meeting on the fourth Tuesdays during the months of July, August, and December. As such, City Council’s Rules of Procedure should be readopted to confirm City Council’s schedule of regular meetings and work sessions for the upcoming year. Additionally, Councilmembers and City staff have identified necessary amendments to the r ules of procedure outlined below: Clerical Revisions • Grammatical and formatting changes • Uniform language changes • Modernization of terminology changes • Section 2-6, Subsection A, biennially to annually to align with State Code Section § 15.2- 1416 Page 110 of 564 July 26, 2022 • Previously agreed upon changes directed by Council (e.g. removal of “Deputy Clerk”; addition of Public Comment Agenda Delivery; and Mayor/Vice Mayor Elections being moved to January vs. July) Proposed Councilmember Amendments for Discussion • Councilmember Conduct – Mayor Dolan (Section § 3-4. Preservation of Order) • Prohibiting harassment toward Councilmembers, staff, and/or general public – Mayor Dolan (Section § 5-4. Prohibited Conduct) Councilmember Faraldi asked what constituted harassment. City Attorney Mr. Matthew Freedman responded that it would be the dictionary definition or common-sense definition of harassment. Councilmember Nelson said that a definition of harassment would have to include a consideration of the intent of the speaker to harass an individual. Councilmember Helgeson said that he agreed with Councilmember Nelson. He said that the harassment rule should be removed. Mayor Dolan said that she was fine removing the harassment section. Councilmember Tweedy asked when harassment would cross the line into criminal behavior. Mr. Freedman said that item 6, which limited interruptions to other speakers and behavior that disrupted the meeting, could include the conduct referenced by Councilmember Tweedy. He said that other rules limited rude or demeaning language. He said if speakers breached the rules, law enforcement could remove the speaker. Councilmember Tweedy asked what would happen if the harassment extended to social media. Mr. Freedman said that if the comments only insulted or demeaned the councilmembers on their political social media, then the comments could be removed. He said that the Council would not have control of the moderation of other forums. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the rules applied outside of the Council Chambers. Mr. Freedman stated that the rules were specific to the Council Chambers. He explained that the Council had a greater control over meeting proceedings to ensure they went uninterrupted. Councilmember Faraldi asked for an explanation of the grammatical change from "must" to "should" in §1-2b. Mr. Freedman stated that the rules were not mandatory. Councilmember Faraldi asked Page 111 of 564 July 26, 2022 who had discretion to determine when the rules applied. Mr. Freedman said that if the word were not changed to "should", the effect would be the same. He said that the rules of procedure were not intended to be entirely prescriptive. He said that the Council chose how to conduct its meetings, and it could take a vote to deviate from the rules of procedure. Councilmember Helgeson said that the word "must" should be used for the speaking section of the rules to protect the interests of the minority opinion. Councilmember Faraldi said the word should be "must" or "shall". Mr. Freedman said that he did not see an issue with leaving the word as "must". He said that the rules would not prevent a majority of the Council from deviating from the rules. City Manager Mr. Wynter Benda responded that the Council would take action on the rules of procedure and the 2023 calendar at the evening session. He said that changes had been proposed to the meeting dates because of the impacts of the census , and he provided an overview of the proposed changes to the calendar. // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item 4, Councilmember Tweedy requested a report from the Commonwealth Attorney's Office and the police department with information on the strategies for combating gun violence, how guns were getting onto the street, the number of unsolved murders, messaging around gun violence, resources to public safety, and the impacts on economic development. Councilmember Helgeson reported the Finance Committee met and discussed ways to all eviate tax burdens on Lynchburg residents. Councilmember Wilder announced that the Commonwealth Games were recently hosted in the City. Mayor Dolan announced that Co-Starters program had returned, and applications were open online. // On motion of Councilmember Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to review and/or evaluate the performance of the City’s Clerk of Council, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: Page 112 of 564 July 26, 2022 WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was recessed at 6:51 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff S. Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 Vice Mayor Wright gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan recognized Ms. Virginia Trost, E.C. Glass Salutatorian. Ms. Trost was in attendance to accept. // In the matter of Recognitions, Vice Mayor Wright recognized Dr. Reid A. Wodicka for his years of service to the City of Lynchburg. Dr. Wodicka was in attendance to accept. // In the matter of Consent Agenda Item A, copies of the March 8, 2022 City Council meeting minutes were previously furnished to the Council, and on motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Page 113 of 564 July 26, 2022 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #6, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting Ordinance #O-22-046, approving the rezoning petition of 2237 Rivermont Avenue from R-3, Medium Density Residential District to R-4, High-Density Residential District. Council was previously briefed on this item at the June 28, 2022 City Council meeting. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen gave a brief summary of the item to Council. Brian Freedman, M.D., of Freedman Family Enterprises, LLC, is petitioning to rezone 2237 Rivermont Avenue from R-3, Medium Density Residential District to R-4, High-Density Residential District. The property is currently a nonconforming use with seven (7) apartments. The rezoning would allow the expansion to ten (10) apartment units. On May 25, 2022, The Planning Commission recommended denial (5-0), with 1 member absent, Marion, and one vacancy, of the rezoning petition, citing concerns that it would set a precedent for similar nonconforming rezonings in the area. The Planning Division recommended denial of the rezoning petition. Mr. Brian Freedman stated that he was the petitioner of the request, and the purpose of the rezoning was to add a maximum of three additional units to the property by finishing the unfinished phase, using that space to recoup the substantial cost of renovating the building, as well as creating an off-street parking lot and three additional on-street parking spots for citizens to use in the immediate area. He said that the Council had heard the reasons for denial as well as the reasons for approval, notwithstanding the fact that the R-4 zoning was applicable in the City’s adopted Future Land Use Map as well as the City having three additional parking spaces on the street which were currently not present. He said that the decision tonight was to support a property in need of renovation and the creation of high- quality rental housing, as well as increased tax revenue and neighborhood infrastr ucture. He said that they had the choice to support decline and decay and poor-quality rental housing. He said that they had the choice to invest in someone who was a local citizen and worker who was investing in the local property. He said that the City had supported other initiatives in the area that led to the beautification of the area, as well as increased public use of the entire area as well, and he hoped they would do so again by voting for approval of this rezoning. Mayor Dolan asked if there were any speakers in person or by email. Page 114 of 564 July 26, 2022 Clerk of Council Ms. Alicia L. Finney stated that there was one email in support received from Brett Schiller at 2124 Rivermont Avenue, which she read into the record. Mayor Dolan closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson said that there were many benefits to allowing the rezoning, most importantly that it would assist in the greater improvement of the neighborhood. He motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to approve the rezoning of the property. Councilmember Wilder said that he grew up in the neighborhood that the building was located in, and had recently received a tour of the building, which was in need of substantial renovations. It was great that Mr. Freedman wanted to invest that money in the community in Ward 2, as well as maintaining the historic nature of the property. Councilmember Nelson stated that he agreed with Dr. Freedman’s initiative and would be supporting the rezoning. He said that in looking at the plans for the property, there was no question that the completion of the proposed project would enhance the value of all of the properties adjoining it in the neighborhood. Councilmember Tweedy said that seeing the buildings along this road becoming repurposed had been a great success. She said that the condition of the building was disappointing, and Dr. Freedman had assisted in helping the former residents find better housing stock. She stated that she would be supporting the rezoning for the project and looked forward to the opening of the apartments. Mayor Dolan said that she also visited the site with Dr. Freedman, and she thanked him for his initiative and vision to move forward with this project that was so important to the neighborhood. She stated that she would also be supporting this project. Vice Mayor Wright said that he would also be supporting the rezoning. He thanked Dr. Freedman for taking the time to work through the process and with members of City staff. He thanked the Planning Commission for their commitment and time in working on this case. Councilmember Faraldi said that he also met with Dr. Freedman for this project and looked forward to supporting the project. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Page 115 of 564 July 26, 2022 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #7, a public hearing was held and the Council considered adopting a Resolution #R-22-047 and Ordinance #O-22-048 amending the Future Land Use Map from Community Commercial to Medium Density Residential and to rezone approximately one (1) acre from B - 1, Limited Business District to R-3, Medium Density Residential District at 620 Leesville Road. The Council was previously briefed on this matter at the June 28, 2022 work session Business Item Briefing. Ms. Frischeisen provided a brief summary of the item to Council. KAL Holdings, LLC is petitioning to amend the Future Land Use Map (FLUM) from Community Commercial to Medium Density Residential and to rezone approximately one (1) acre from B-1, Limited Business District to R-3, Medium Density Residential District at 620 Leesville Road. If approved the property would be developed as four (4) duplexes. On June 8, 2022, the Planning Commission recommended approval (5-0), with one member absent, Light, and one vacancy, of the FLUM Amendment and rezoning petition. The Planning Division recommended approval of the FLUM Amendment and rezoning petition. Mr. Norm Walton of Perkins and Orrison, representing the petitioner, stated that this property had been undeveloped for a long time, so this was an opportunity to develop it to be in character with the other developments along Leesville Road. City staff worked with the petitioner to ensure the ingress and egress was considered, as there was an existing driveway adjacent to the store there that served several houses, and another entrance had been added so that there would be access to all the duplexes. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Vice Mayor Wright made a motion to adopt the Resolution #R-22-047 and Ordinance #O-22-048, seconded by Councilmember Nelson. Councilmember Faraldi said that he would be voting in opposition to this measure due to concerns raised by community members about this type of housing and the compactness of the proposal, which should be kept in mind as the area continued to develop out. Councilmember Wilder asked what the Planning Commission noted as reason for recommendation of approval. Ms. Frischeisen answered that the proposal fit within the neighborhood and the land had yet to be developed, so the Planning Commission felt it would be appropriate. Page 116 of 564 July 26, 2022 Councilmember Wilder asked if neighbors had discussed the proposal. Ms. Frischeisen said that neighbors had attended the public hearings, but she did not think anyone spoke. Councilmember Wilder asked for clarification that no one spoke in opposition at the public hearings; Ms. Frischeisen said no. Mayor Dolan asked if the neighborhood had duplexes in the near vicinity of the property. Ms. Frischeisen said yes, it was noted by a Planning Commissioner that there were duplexes in the area that looked nice, so they felt it was appropriate. Councilmember Helgeson asked if there had been any discussion about single-family houses being placed there rather than duplexes. Ms. Frischeisen said no, there had not been, and the petitioner’s request was not countered with such a proposal. Councilmember Helgeson asked how many duplex units there would be. Ms. Frischeisen said that there would be four duplexes for a total of eight units, and the property would be combined with another owned property that was already zoned R -3. Councilmember Helgeson asked how many duplexes could exist only on the 620 Leesville Road property by right. Ms. Frischeisen said that there could be no duplexes in the B-1 district. Councilmember Helgeson asked for clarification that there could be no duplexes put on this property by right. Ms. Frischeis en said that they could not do so by right. Councilmember Helgeson asked if this item could be denied as a rezoning and return for a Conditional Use Permit. He said that they must be cognizant of where high- density living was placed in areas of growth, because it could be impactful when cumulatively placing multiple units in a small area. He stated that a CUP would be more appropriate, and putting in eight units would be deleterious to the neighborhood. Councilmember Tweedy said that she had concern about the number of units proposed in an area that was developing so quickly, but also recognized how the development fit into the character of the development of the neighborhood and that the applicant was attempting to keep the same zoning between the two lots that they owned. She said that she would be open to learning more about the impacts and was not opposed to approving the rezoning. Councilmember Wilder stated that the City was growing, and they must have a deeper conversation about how they wanted their City to grow and if they must limit the development and growth. He said that many developers built apartments because of the higher profit margins compared to single- family houses, so if they wanted those developers to do so, they must incentivize that bui lding. He said Page 117 of 564 July 26, 2022 that they should not penalize the applicant, and if the property had been vacant, they must decide if the use was better than leaving the property vacant. He stated that he supported the rezoning. Councilmember Tweedy asked how many other apartment development projects were due to appear before Council this year. Mr. Tom Martin stated that with the projects currently being proposed or submitted, they could potentially be seeing upwards of 2,000 units coming online in the next year to two years. Councilmember Tweedy said that she would like to see that conversation come to the Council first before approving those developments through the Planning Commission and Council processes. She said that the Council should have all the information on how to incentivize developers to build single- family homes. She stated that she was not opposed to this project, but the vote should encompass their plan for the future development of the City. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 // In the matter of Redistricting, Agenda Item #8, a public hearing was held and Council considered approving an Ordinance #O-22-049 approving either Scenario A or Scenario D as the ward and precinct boundaries. The Council was previously briefed on this matter at the June 28, 2022 City Council work session on redistricting. Mr. Tom Martin gave a brief summary of the item to Council. Redistricting is the process of redrawing the boundaries of districts that elect representatives who serve specific geographic areas. Redistricting occurs every 10 years following the United States decennial census and is the responsibility of state and local governments. During the June 28, 2022 work session, City Council directed staff to advertise the ward & precinct boundaries for Scenario A and Scenario D for public hearing. Following the public hearing, City Council may adopt either Scenario A or Scenario D as the ward & precinct boundaries. A letter from a citizen Mr. Todd Cooper addressed to City Council in support of Scenario D was previously furnished to the Clerk of Council and was read into the record. A letter from a citizen Mr. Curt Diemer addressed to City Council in support of Scenario D was previously furnished to the Clerk of Council and was read into the record. Page 118 of 564 July 26, 2022 A form email in support of Scenario D was read into the record from the following citizens: Charles Faulconer, Steven Troxel, John Vassar, Marina Guenther, Ricky Templeton, George Harton, Ben Kahle, Susan Stowell, Sherry McCormick-Hawkins, Ted Weigand, Ronald Gillispie, Terry Adams, Charlie Judd, Janice Quattlebaum, Sandra Weigand, Chip Harvey, H. Cary III, Suzanne Chappell, Daniel Pence, Gary Garner, Glenda Frye, William Clough, and Timothy Echols. Mayor Dolan closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Faraldi made a motion to adopt Scenario D, seconded by Councilmember Nelson. Councilmember Nelson stated that he had been a part of the One Virginia 2021 initiative to end gerrymandering throughout the state, and the Virginia Constitution was successfully amended, although the outcome was challenging in implementing. He said that the principles of that initiative emphasized compactness and contiguity, so it would be hypocritical of him to promote those principles throughout the Commonwealth of Virginia but reject them when redistricting their own City. He said that many social and political evils had been justified and perpetuated on appeal to preserving the convenience of the status quo, and he categorically opposed doing so in this decision. He said that Scenario D aligned their City’s wards and precincts in a manner that induced Councilmembers to be more sensitive to a broader constituency rather than focusing on a singular partisan influence. He stated that he supported Scenario D for the integrity and long-term sustainability it would bring to the City’s elections and its citizens. Councilmember Wilder stated that he favored Scenario A. He asked if it was correct that both scenarios met the state requirements. Mr. Martin answered yes, they both met the requirements for wards and precincts. Councilmember Wilder said that he still felt favorable toward Scenario A. Councilmember Helgeson said that they could make a relatively small change of moving about 1,000 voters, which had been done previously after the 2010 census, and there likely would not be a large change in 2030. He said that he did not want to disrupt the lifelong voters who resided in their wards unless they absolutely had to. He stated that he was in favor of Scenario A due to its limited impact. Councilmember Tweedy stated that she was in support of Scenario A because of its lack of disruption to voters. She said that the disruption of 9,000 voters was concerning, so she would be choosing the scenario that did not do that. Page 119 of 564 July 26, 2022 Mayor Dolan said that Scenario D may look appealing due to the evenly shaped districts, but it did not exclude the possibility of it being partisan, and clearly moving residents into Ward I to Ward IV could have unexpected consequences of making Ward I noncompetitive in the future. She said that maintaining the status quo was not always a bad thing, especially if that if chosen by its very nature could have long-term effects on voting results. She stated that she supported Scenario A in order to achieve this and to give minimal changes to voters. Vice Mayor Wright stated that Scenario D did not solve the issue of gerrymandering because it had been created by and endorsed by politicians, and solving gerrymandering would require appointing a citizen board to draw the maps or to create the least distinct amount of change by approving Scenario A. He said that they would have to meet the changes that occurred by 2030 regardless of the mapping changes, and he did not understand the argument that these maps could create some sort of evil. He said that he did not agree that if people did not know how to vote they should not be trusted to do so, because their job as government was that people had as little barriers as possible to exercising their right to vote. He said that he opposed Scenario D and supported Scenario A because it was least disruptive and had confidence in its source. Councilmember Nelson stated that Scenario D did not create barriers to voting, and actually better located polling places to be accessible. He said that gerrymandering was not changing polling places or precincts but was drawing boundary lines of precincts in a way that took people out of one and into another so as to affect the outcome and voice of those speaking, to minimize the impact of a majority and give greater voice to a minority. He stated that Scenario D satisfied the eyeball test and was an un- gerrymandered configuration of the wards. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Nelson, Faraldi 2 Noes: Dolan, Wright, Tweedy, Helgeson, Wilder 5 Councilmember Helgeson motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to approve Scenario A. Councilmember Faraldi said that gerrymandering was the making a decision for a legislative district based off of the representation changing. He said that there were some changes where one Page 120 of 564 July 26, 2022 precinct went from one district to another, but that should not be counted into the total impact of voters. He said that districts needed to be compact and contiguous, and Scenario A was not equivalent in population the way that Scenario D was, and in fact split developments in half. He said that these maps were drawn this way because of the splits from approximately 12 years ago and upheld that way because of the way state legislature drew the maps. He said that he preferred the more even divisions regardless of the political implications, and Scenario D spoke effectively to this matter. Councilmember Helgeson said that his primary concern was minimizing impact to the voters, and he looked forward to the Council moving on to the next part of implementation of this process. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Nelson, Faraldi 2 // In the matter of Public Comment, Mr. Timothy Santiago previously signed up to speak to City Council but was not in attendance. // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item #9, the Council considered adoption of a Resolution #R-22- 050 approving City Council’s Rules of Procedure. The Council was last briefed on this item at the July 26, 2022 work session Business Item Briefing. Vice Mayor Wright asked if the language proposed to be removed from the Resolution had been updated. Clerk of Council Ms. Alicia L. Finney answered that the information in the Council packet would be updated to reflect those changes but had not yet occurred. Vice Mayor Wright asked if Ms. Finney could summarize the items. Ms. Finney answered that it was from §5.4(A)7 of the Prohibited Conduct, there would be removal of language that addresses “or harasses,” specifically, and revert the clerical revision in §1.2(B) of the Basic Principles of the Underlying Rules of Procedures that would say “the Council’s Rules of Procedures must be followed consistently.” Councilmember Helgeson asked if the changes regarding the calendar were included. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda answered that the July and August changes had been notified, and he proposed September 13 or 27, of which the 13 th seemed most amenable to Lynchburg City Schools as a joint meeting. He said that it would be held at 4:00 p.m. at the Lynchburg Regional Business Alliance, and a fall retreat was proposed for October 7. He said that in November, the second and fourth Tuesdays had Page 121 of 564 July 26, 2022 been changed to the first and third Tuesdays, the first being a voting meeting and the third being a legislative dinner. Ms. Finney stated that in the Rules of Procedure, it addressed the calendar for 2023, and the other dates would require the Council’s approval. Vice Mayor Wright motioned, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to approve the Rules of Procedures with the changes made. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item #10, Council considered adopting a resolution condemning violence perpetrated against Blue Ridge Pregnancy Center. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, to adopt the resolution. Councilmember Faraldi stated that this resolution gave Council the opportunity to fully condemn the actions against the individuals who vandalized the Blue Ridge Pregnancy Center, and also ensured that anyone had the right to protest peacefully in Lynchburg. Councilmember Helgeson said that he was glad to see that people were there to clean up the next day and was glad to support the Resolution. Councilmember Nelson said that the City of Lynchburg had laws that prohibited the behavior that was perpetrated against the property of the Blue Ridge Pregnancy Center. He said that condemnation of such crimes was one of the purposes inherently encompassed in their criminal laws, and if City Council were to pass resolutions condemning criminal behaviors whenever and wherever they occurred, they would be burdening staff and their time in an exercise that duplicated the role of law enforcement personnel and the judiciary. He stated that he would rather their taxpayer funds be directed to pursuits that fell within the legal authority and purpose of City Council. He said that while the damage to the Blue Ridge Pregnancy Center violated core American principles, the Resolution would set a bad precedence when criminal actions were being investigated and prosecuted by the City’s law enforcement personnel, and for those reasons he would not be supporting the Resolution. Page 122 of 564 July 26, 2022 Councilmember Helgeson said that he appreciated the City’s law enforcement and groups who peacefully protested in the City. He reiterated that he supported the resolution. Councilmember Tweedy said that she would not be supporting the resolution. She said that in talking to citizens about violence in Lynchburg and the ways to stop those violent acts in the community, it had been suggested that the City form a human rights commission to look into the issues of what the City condoned and did not condone, and what groups or issues deserved the City’s support. She said that this issue deserved the opportunity for citizens to come together and discuss the acts of violence and the solutions to them. She said that a larger approach to the topic was necessary to bring people together and view the issues of human rights in the City to ensure all organizations were respected and pr otected. Councilmember Wilder stated that there were many resolutions the City Council could make, including apologizing for past City Council resolutions that segregated public facilities in the City, or a Resolution to recognize the shootings of young people in the City. He said that vandalism occurred to many businesses and nonprofits, and such violence should be stood against completely through a group such the human rights commission suggested by Councilmember Tweedy. Mayor Dolan said that she condemned all types of violence but did not see it fit to create resolutions for every case that they saw. Councilmember Helgeson said that any of those other topics could be brought forward as resolutions to Council, but what was before Council through this procedure was the Resolution prepared to condemn the vandalism perpetrated against the Blue Ridge Pregnancy Center. Vice Mayor Wright said that he and his colleagues strongly condemned all acts of violence, which was proven through the enforcement of laws and funding of their police department to ensure that crimes were investigated and thoroughly prosecuted. He said that to pass this Resolution would condemn the vandalism against the Blue Ridge Pregnancy Center, but it also would be a comment to the public on t he general topic of abortion and how the City Council felt about abortion as an issue, which was why City Council had historically stayed away from making these types of resolutions related to very political issues. Page 123 of 564 July 26, 2022 Councilmember Tweedy said that if the Council was going to begin choosing sensitive topics such as this to bring recognition to, there must be an overarching group of citizens who stated the values of the City and the support of quality of life for the people of the City. Councilmember Faraldi said that this Resolution was the only form of acknowledgment from Councilmembers of the event that had transpired at the Blue Ridge Pregnancy Center. He said that resolutions acknowledging past actions or violence should be brought forward to the Council i n order to begin to come together on those issues. He said that the City Council represented Lynchburg, so it was important for them to vote in order to voice their opinion on this issue. Councilmember Nelson clarified that his vote against the Resolution would not condone the reprehensible damage, vandalism, and intimidation against the Blue Ridge Pregnancy Center. Councilmember Wilder said that there were platforms to speak on issues other than at the dais of City Council, and he did not judge Councilmembers for what they chose to do in supporting or not supporting organizations or individuals who experienced violence in the community. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Helgeson,

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.