RecordWell Data

City Council & School Board Joint Work Session — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Aug 8, 2023 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY of LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL and CITY SCHOOLS Special Called Joint Meeting August 8, 2023 | 4:00PM Lynchburg Regional Business Alliance 300 Lucado Pl, Lynchburg, VA 24504 AGENDA I. Welcome and Introductions Stephanie T. Reed, Mayor Dr. Atul Gupta, School Board Chair Wynter C. Benda, City Manager Dr. Crystal Edwards, Superintendent of Schools II. LCS Facilities Master Plan Dr. Lance Richards, Project Manager and Monica Farirai, Analyst, MGT Consulting III. Breakout Session a. Core Actions b. Four (4) Scenarios Dr. Crystal Edwards, Superintendent of Schools IV. Report Out Dr. Crystal Edwards, Superintendent of Schools V. Closing Remarks Stephanie T. Reed, Mayor Dr. Atul Gupta, School Board Chair Lynchburg City Schools August 2023 Page 2 of 37 2 Introductions Dr. Lance Richards Project Manager Education Solutions Group lrichards@mgtconsulting.com Monica Farirai Analyst Education Solutions Group mfarirai@mgtconsulting.com Page 3 of 37 3 • Meet with school community leadership • Examine Inventory, Facility Conditions, Capacity, and Utilization • Review School and Program Enrollment • Assess Changes • Determine Master Plan Drivers • Meet with Community Partners o 30+ groups and individuals • Community Meetings to gather community input o 3 school-based events • Community Surveys • Assess programmatic needs of the Division • Presentations of scenarios for community feedback • Open houses • Develop Recommendations Planning Process Page 4 of 37 4 • Provide equitable programmatic and support service opportunities to the highest degree possible • Connections to Families and Neighborhoods • Optimization of occupancy and staffing • Address schools with urgent needs based on educational suitability and physical condition data • Future Flexibility/Sustainability • Examine programmatic needs o Career & Technical Education (CTE) o Early Childhood Education o Alternative Education Framework o STEM/STEAM – Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts, and Math o Building level programs and initiatives • Maintain fiscal responsibility o Operations/Transportation • Hiring Challenges • Student Recruitment and Retention Master Plan Drivers Page 5 of 37 5 Map of Lynchburg Virginia City of Lynchburg Page 6 of 37 6 Population by Age: Lynchburg City 2011-2021 Page 7 of 37 7 Historical and Projected Enrollment by Grade Band 8,583 8,577 8,566 8,477 8,413 8,286 8,238 7,961 7,879 7,903 7,838 7,821 7,785 7,708 7,643 7,591 7,544 7,510 7,488 7,489 4,375 4,326 4,344 4,205 4,158 4,028 3,988 3,717 3,753 3,820 3,759 3,777 3,769 3,736 3,695 3,662 3,608 3,575 3,559 3,563 1,838 1,824 1,823 1,856 1,822 1,822 1,795 1,820 1,701 1,685 1,672 1,647 1,627 1,617 1,601 1,587 1,589 1,599 1,601 1,571 2,370 2,427 2,399 2,416 2,433 2,436 2,455 2,424 2,425 2,398 2,407 2,397 2,390 2,355 2,347 2,343 2,347 2,336 2,328 2,355 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000 2013/14 2014/15 2015/16 2016/17 2017/18 2018/19 2019/20 2020/21 2021/22 2022/23 2023/24 2024/25 2025/26 2026/27 2027/28 2028/29 2029/30 2030/31 2031/32 2032/33 Historical Enrollment Projected Enrollment Total K to 5 6 to 8 9 to 12 Page 8 of 37 8 Community Engagement Endorsements and Considerations Closer to Home / Neighborhood Schools ▪ Community meetings and interviews reflected broad support for Neighborhood/Close to Home Schools. ▪ There is particularly strong support for this approach with meeting and interview participants connected to the areas surrounding Bass and Payne Elementaries. ▪ Careful consideration will have to be given to adjusted attendance zone framework regarding diversity and programmatic equity. Transportation ▪ The current transportation framework will be unsustainable in the near future. ▪ There are currently 64 daily routes in LCS. ▪ There are currently 18 driver openings. ▪ Average age of bus drivers over 60 years. ▪ LCS runs approximately 1,000,000 miles a year. ▪ All in, it is roughly $5.00 per mile to run a bus. Page 9 of 37 9 • Community meetings and interviews reflected broad support for expansion of CTE in Lynchburg City Schools. • Rapid growth and expansion CTE on both campuses is necessary to meet current and future needs. • Lynchburg is in a unique position to meet the needs of these programs and students. Career & Technical Education (CTE) • Community meetings and interviews reflected broad support for Early Childhood Education with broad consensus around the benefits of Early Childhood Education. • There is a generous swath of private and faith-based preschools in Lynchburg. • There is a shortage of available/affordable/accessible preschools for some in the school community. • 184 applicants were turned away by LCS due to capacity issues. (2022-23) Early Childhood Education Page 10 of 37 10 • Community meetings and interviews reflected broad support in providing alternative educational opportunities for students that require those services. • There is increasing apprehension among educators, community members, and the public at large about how to address the more extreme behaviors of students, balanced with concern about sending disruptive and potentially dangerous students "out on the streets," without any support or remediation. • Discussions centered around space limitations, repurposing facilities, or additions to Ft. Hill. Alternative Education Framework Student Discipline • Classroom and Building Level Discipline o Discipline became a part of the equation as a result of these discussions. o There is a concern over student discipline across the Division. o Teachers, administrators, parents, community members, community leaders, and others expressed concern. Page 11 of 37 11 • LCS is currently leasing space. • There should be capacity in current LCS facilities to house these programs. • Direct cost savings to Division • Challenges that must be addressed to ensure effective learning outcomes. • There are direct benefits of a hybrid model that combines both virtual and in-person learning. • Through virtual and hybrid learning the Division must assure that students are maximizing their learning and are being set up for future success. Virtual Education Improvements STEM / STEAM – Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts, and Math • The benefits of STEM or STEAM are far reaching for students. • Students who participated in the project-based STEAM learning had a significantly higher level of STEAM interest and motivation. • STEAM education should: o Enable students to become analytical and critical thinkers. o Increase their science, mathematics, and technology literacy. o Foster the next generation of innovators and entrepreneurs. Page 12 of 37 12 • Concerns over hiring are far reaching. These are at all levels. It is a national challenge. o The bus driver shortage is critical. o The lack of qualified candidates for a broad swath of certified positions is well documented. o Teacher staffing perceptions and challenges to hiring and retaining. o COVID exacerbated hiring challenges, overall attrition rates, and led to an increase in retirements. o Competitive salaries and benefits o Workload and stress o Lack of perceived support and agency o Narrowing pipeline in teacher training and perspective applicants o Alternative routes to licensure being implemented. Hiring and Retention Challenges Page 13 of 37 13 • Stay true to what the Division does well. • Celebrate and share successes. Lean into your strengths. • SOL scores for the Division are strong when compared to benchmark districts. POSITIVE SCHOOL CLIMATE AND CULTURE • Maintain school facilities that are well maintained and welcoming. • Foster a safe, inclusive, and supportive school environment where all students feel valued, respected, and connected. FAMILY AND COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT • Establish strong partnerships with families creating a shared responsibility for student success. • Conduct regular communication. • Offer workshops, training sessions, and resources to support parents in their role as active participants in their child's ed ucation. EARLY INTERVENTION STRATEGIES • Identify and address academic and behavioral challenges as early as possible to prevent further disengagement and attrition. DAT A-INFORMED DECISION -MAKING • Utilize data analysis to identify trends, patterns, and potential areas for improvement in student outcomes. Student Recruitment and Retention Page 14 of 37 14 o Examine current structure of gifted program (GO) and the Schools of Innovation. o Consideration of expansion of GO programming into other Division schools could present an opportunity for expanded participation. o Many qualifying students do not consider participation due to transportation and distance. o Many of the innovations of the past that were incorporated into past programs have been expanded to other campuses. o Reframing the current list of offerings and restructuring the curriculum to refresh the coursework can lead to expanded STEAM offerings across the Division. o Examine Elementary, Middle, and High Program Alignment Building Level Programs and Initiatives Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) o PPPs in education across the U.S. are becoming increasingly common as schools seek to improve educational outcomes through collaboration with private organizations. o Conversations around Pre-K and CTE. o Can help with financial support and community engagement. o Seen as method for improving subject-specific outcomes for students, such as in the STEAM and CTE fields. o Opportunities can also be found in Fine Arts and other paths of interest. Page 15 of 37 15 Programmatic Alignment: K-12 o Elementary Schools o Reconnect schools with neighborhoods and families o Examine buildings: inventory, utilizations, future uses, costs associated with operation and upgrades. o Innovation School Network: connect the Schools For Innovation concepts to STEAM at MS and CTE in HS o Identify a focus for each school and focus an innovation program in every part of the Division. o SFIs , GO Center, Bass Extended Calendar - Define level of interest, program, and future outcomes. o Middle Schools o Potential for Sixth Grade Academies o Potential pathways for Innovation School Network and Strategic Partnerships o Dunbar – Communications, Humanities, and the Performing Arts o Linkhorne – Healthcare and Environmental Sciences o Sandusky – Engineering, Computer Sciences o School-Specific Recommendations o High Schools o Investment in CTE, Strategic Partnerships o Further define and enhance Arts and Athletics o Pre-Kindergarten Program o Investment to meet current need and capacity issues. o Alternative Programming to support larger alignment in Division o Virtual Academy o Fort Hill Program o Restorative Centers o Adult Education Page 16 of 37 16 Facilities Overview Synopsis of school buildings as reported in Lynchburg City Schools Facility Master Plan 2022. Capacity and Utilization The functional capacity of a school is defined as the number of students a building can support based on the program of studies offered and educational standards. Educational Suitability This functionality assessment evaluates how well the facility supports the educational program that it houses. Each site receives one suitability score which applies to all the buildings at the facility. Building Condition The building condition score measures the amount of deferred maintenance in the school building’s major systems. The condition score of a facility is the average condition score of all the buildings at a site. Page 17 of 37 Lynchburg City Schools 17 Overview • The High School Efficiency Rate is 76%. Facility Assessment is 89. • The Middle School Efficiency Rate is 78%. Facility Assessment is 81. • The Elementary School Efficiency Rate is 80%. Facility Assessment is 70. • In allowing for programmatic necessities, the ideal utilization is +/- 85% • The aspirational score for Facility Assessment is above 80. • While the average for elementary schools is above 80% there are schools with relatively low utilization, small student population, limited capacity, or very low Facility Assessment Scores. o Under-utilized schools ▪ 2 schools < 70% utilized o School size ▪ 4 schools under 225 students o Suitability ▪ Suitability scores range of 66 to 95 o Facility Condition ▪ Condition scores range of 62 to 97 o Utilization ▪ Utilization scores range of 65 to 92 Page 18 of 37 18 ➢ The functional capacity of a school is defined as the number of students a building can support. ➢ This is based on the program of studies offered and educational standards. ➢ A utilization score for each school using the building capacity data and enrollment. ➢ 100% is NOT the goal. Capacity and Utilization Page 19 of 37 19 Page 20 of 37 20 Page 21 of 37 21 Division Averages Page 22 of 37 22 Overall Scores Page 23 of 37 23 LCS Map of Schools Page 24 of 37 24 Page 25 of 37 25 Page 26 of 37 26 Page 27 of 37 27 Page 28 of 37 28 Page 29 of 37 29 Page 30 of 37 30 Removal of portables improves utilization to 82%. Page 31 of 37 31 oUtilization +/-89% o70% Support o$1,000,000 operational savings by 2030 Page 32 of 37 32 oUtilization +/-84% o63% Support o$3,700,000 operational savings by 2030 Page 33 of 37 33 oUtilization +/-84% with Expansion oUtilization +/- 92% without Expansion o48% Support o$4,400,000 operational savings by 2030 Page 34 of 37 34 oUtilization +/-98% o33% Support o $5,000,000 operational savings by 2030 Page 35 of 37 Scenarios Support Utilization % Ops. Savings by 2030 Est. Total 10 year Capital Costs Scenario 1 71% 91% $1,000,000 $235,000,000 Scenario 2 64% 86% $3,700,000 $180,000,000 Scenario 3 48% 86% $4,400,000 $206,000,000 Scenario 4 34% 98% $5,000,000 $187,000,000 Full Renovations 35 Safety & Maintenance with Required Expansions* Scenarios Support Utilization % Ops. Savings by 2030 Est. Total 10 year Capital Costs Scenario 1 71% 91% $1,000,000 Scenario 2 64% 86% $3,700,000 Scenario 3 48% 86% $4,400,000 Scenario 4 34% 98% $5,000,000 $147,000,000 $93,000,000 $139,000,000* $135,000,000* Page 36 of 37 Next Steps Page 37 of 37 Full Renovations by Scenarios Public Survey Score FY 30 Ops. Savings 10 year Cap. Costs Scenario 1 6.97 1,006,618 234,829,917 Scenario 2 6.31 3,710,791 181,227,941 Scenario 3 4.75 4,467,911 206,484,537 Scenario 4 3.36 5,098,196 187,830,236 Safety & Maintenance Improvements Only Public Survey Score FY 30 Ops. Savings 10 year Cap. Costs Scenario 1 6.97 1,006,618 146,580,752 Scenario 2 6.31 3,589,126 92,978,776 Scenario 3 4.75 4,498,196 139,235,372 Scenario 4 3.36 5,098,196 135,111,758 Public Survey Scores - As of 8/1/23 with 1,372 responses Parents Community Mem. LCS Staff Scenario 1 7.15 6.77 6.56 Scenario 2 6.33 6.16 6.43 Scenario 3 4.73 4.58 4.86 Scenario 4 3.15 2.67 4.08 Assumptions Annual Cost and Savings Escalation 4% Interest Rate 6% Debt Service Payment Period (years) 20 Definitions: Term Definition 2022 Estimates Dominion 7 2022 Estimates Current Cost 2022 Estimates escalated by 5% Year Proposed year of implementation Cost at action Current cost escalated by 4% per year until action Annual $ - Action Debt payment/initial annual savings, as appropriate LCS Facilities Master Plan - Preliminary Financial Analysis Finance and Facilities Committee - 8/1/23 Finance and Facilities Committee - 8/1/23 LCS Facilities Master Plan - Preliminary Financial Analysis Scenario 1 Current Cost Yr Cost at Action Annual $ - Action Operational Savings Close to Home Zoning 2025 550,000 Close Fort Hill 2026 300,000 2022 Estimates Construction Costs 49,853,000 New Sandusky ES 52,345,650 2026 56,533,302 (4,928,831) 101,294,474 Full Renovations 106,359,198 119,642,447 26,414,224 Linkhorne 27,734,935 2030 34,391,320 (2,998,392) 16,774,750 Paul Munro 17,613,488 2028 20,431,646 (1,781,324) 16,289,000 Perrymont 17,103,450 2027 19,155,864 (1,670,096) 41,816,500 RS Payne 43,907,325 2025 45,663,618 (3,981,162) 72,500,066 Safety & Maintenance 76,125,069 95,524,370 2,202,200 Bass 2,312,310 2025 2,404,802 (209,662) 3,670,845 Bedford Hills 3,854,387 2025 4,008,563 (349,485) 4,133,851 Dearington 4,340,544 2027 4,861,409 (423,840) 3,182,020 Heritage ES 3,341,121 2027 3,742,056 (326,249) 2,090,800 Hutcherson 2,195,340 2027 2,458,781 (214,368) 3,142,600 TC Miller 3,299,730 2029 3,959,676 (345,223) - Sandusky ES - - - 2,719,050 Sheffield 2,855,003 2031 3,654,403 (318,608) 8,751,400 Dunbar 9,188,970 2028 10,659,205 (929,318) 6,636,000 Linkhorne MS 6,967,800 2033 9,476,208 (826,179) 5,822,800 Sandusky MS 6,113,940 2033 8,314,958 (724,936) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 1 10,000,620 2028 11,600,719 (1,011,404) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 2 10,000,620 2033 13,600,843 (1,185,783) 11,099,700 Heritage HS 11,654,685 2035 16,782,746 (1,463,196) 223,647,540 Subtotal Costs 234,829,917 271,700,119 Survey Scores Parents 7.15 Community Members 6.77 LCS Staff 6.56 Overall 6.97 Scenario 1 - Assuming Full Renovations Scenario 1 Current Cost Yr Cost at Action Annual $ - Action Operational Savings Close to Home Zoning 2025 550,000 Close Fort Hill 2026 300,000 2022 Estimates Construction Costs 49,853,000 New Sandusky Elementar 52,345,650 2026 56,533,302 (4,928,831) 17,247,650 Safety & Maintenance 18,110,033 20,408,375 4,241,900 Linkhorne 4,453,995 2030 5,522,954 (481,516) 2,936,000 Paul Munro 3,082,800 2028 3,576,048 (311,776) 3,728,650 Perrymont 3,915,083 2027 4,384,892 (382,295) 6,341,100 RS Payne 6,658,155 2025 6,924,481 (603,708) 72,500,066 Safety & Maintenance 76,125,069 95,524,370 2,202,200 Bass 2,312,310 2025 2,404,802 (209,662) 3,670,845 Bedford Hills 3,854,387 2025 4,008,563 (349,485) 4,133,851 Dearington 4,340,544 2027 4,861,409 (423,840) 3,182,020 Heritage ES 3,341,121 2027 3,742,056 (326,249) 2,090,800 Hutcherson 2,195,340 2027 2,458,781 (214,368) 3,142,600 TC Miller 3,299,730 2029 3,959,676 (345,223) Sandusky ES - - - 2,719,050 Sheffield 2,855,003 2031 3,654,403 (318,608) 8,751,400 Dunbar 9,188,970 2028 10,659,205 (929,318) 6,636,000 Linkhorne MS 6,967,800 2033 9,476,208 (826,179) 5,822,800 Sandusky MS 6,113,940 2033 8,314,958 (724,936) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 1 10,000,620 2028 11,600,719 (1,011,404) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 2 10,000,620 2033 13,600,843 (1,185,783) 11,099,700 Heritage HS 11,654,685 2035 16,782,746 (1,463,196) 139,600,716 Subtotal Costs 146,580,752 172,466,047 Survey Scores Parents 7.15 Community Members 6.77 LCS Staff 6.56 Overall 6.97 Scenario 1 - Assuming Safety and Maintenance Improvements Scenario 2 Current Cost Yr Cost at Action Annual $ - Action Operational Savings Close to Home Zoning 2025 550,000 Close Dearington 2025 2,500,000 2022 Estimate Construction Costs 101,294,474 Full Renovations 106,359,198 119,642,447 26,414,224 Linkhorne 27,734,935 2030 34,391,320 (2,998,392) 16,774,750 Paul Munro 17,613,488 2028 20,431,646 (1,781,324) 16,289,000 Perrymont 17,103,450 2027 19,155,864 (1,670,096) 41,816,500 RS Payne 43,907,325 2025 45,663,618 (3,981,162) 71,303,565 Safety & Maintenance 74,868,743 95,466,698 2,202,200 Bass 2,312,310 2025 2,404,802 (209,662) 3,670,845 Bedford Hills 3,854,387 2025 4,008,563 (349,485) - Dearington - - - 3,182,020 Heritage ES 3,341,121 2027 3,742,056 (326,249) 2,090,800 Hutcherson 2,195,340 2027 2,458,781 (214,368) 3,142,600 TC Miller 3,299,730 2029 3,959,676 (345,223) 2,937,350 Sandusky ES 3,084,218 2029 3,701,061 (322,675) 2,719,050 Sheffield 2,855,003 2031 3,654,403 (318,608) 8,751,400 Dunbar 9,188,970 2031 11,761,882 (1,025,454) 6,636,000 Linkhorne MS 6,967,800 2033 9,476,208 (826,179) 5,822,800 Sandusky MS 6,113,940 2033 8,314,958 (724,936) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 1 10,000,620 2028 11,600,719 (1,011,404) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 2 10,000,620 2033 13,600,843 (1,185,783) 11,099,700 Heritage HS 11,654,685 2035 16,782,746 (1,463,196) 172,598,039 Subtotal Costs 181,227,941 215,109,146 Survey Scores Parents 6.33 Community Members 6.16 LCS Staff 6.43 Overall 6.31 Scenario 2 - Assuming Full Renovations Scenario 2 Current Cost Yr Cost at Action Annual $ - Action Operational Savings Close to Home Zoning 2025 550,000 Close Dearington 2025 2,500,000 2022 Estimates Construction Costs 17,247,650 Safety & Maintenance 18,110,033 20,408,375 4,241,900 Linkhorne 4,453,995 2030 5,522,954 (481,516) 2,936,000 Paul Munro 3,082,800 2028 3,576,048 (311,776) 3,728,650 Perrymont 3,915,083 2027 4,384,892 (382,295) 6,341,100 RS Payne 6,658,155 2025 6,924,481 (603,708) 71,303,565 Safety & Maintenance 74,868,743 94,364,022 2,202,200 Bass 2,312,310 2025 2,404,802 (209,662) 3,670,845 Bedford Hills 3,854,387 2025 4,008,563 (349,485) - Dearington - - - 3,182,020 Heritage ES 3,341,121 2027 3,742,056 (326,249) 2,090,800 Hutcherson 2,195,340 2027 2,458,781 (214,368) 3,142,600 TC Miller 3,299,730 2029 3,959,676 (345,223) 2,937,350 Sandusky ES 3,084,218 2029 3,701,061 (322,675) 2,719,050 Sheffield 2,855,003 2031 3,654,403 (318,608) 8,751,400 Dunbar 9,188,970 2028 10,659,205 (929,318) 6,636,000 Linkhorne MS 6,967,800 2033 9,476,208 (826,179) 5,822,800 Sandusky MS 6,113,940 2033 8,314,958 (724,936) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 1 10,000,620 2028 11,600,719 (1,011,404) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 2 10,000,620 2033 13,600,843 (1,185,783) 11,099,700 Heritage HS 11,654,685 2035 16,782,746 (1,463,196) 88,551,215 Subtotal Costs 92,978,776 114,772,397 Survey Scores Parents 6.33 Community Members 6.16 LCS Staff 6.43 Overall 6.31 Scenario 2 - Assuming Safety and Maintenance Improvements Scenario 3 Current Cost Yr Cost at Action Annual $ - Action Operational Savings Close to Home Zoning 2025 500,000 Close Sandusky Elementary 2028 700,000 Close TC Miller 2025 2,500,000 2022 Estimates Construction Costs 119,294,474 Full Renovations 125,259,198 142,070,447 36,414,224 Linkhorne + Expansion 38,234,935 2030 47,411,320 (4,133,535) 16,774,750 Paul Munro 17,613,488 2028 20,431,646 (1,781,324) 24,289,000 Perrymont + Expansion 25,503,450 2027 28,563,864 (2,490,328) 41,816,500 RS Payne 43,907,325 2025 45,663,618 (3,981,162) 77,357,466 Safety & Maintenance 81,225,339 101,750,614 2,202,200 Bass 2,312,310 2025 2,404,802 (209,662) 11,670,845 Bedford Hills + Expansion 12,254,387 2025 12,744,563 (1,111,129) 4,133,851 Dearington 4,340,544 2029 5,208,652 (454,114) 3,182,020 Heritage ES 3,341,121 2027 3,742,056 (326,249) 2,090,800 Hutcherson 2,195,340 2027 2,458,781 (214,368) - TC Miller - - - - Sandusky ES - - - - Sheffield 2,855,003 2031 3,654,403 (318,608) 8,751,400 Dunbar 9,188,970 2031 11,761,882 (1,025,454) 6,636,000 Linkhorne MS 6,967,800 2033 9,476,208 (826,179) 5,822,800 Sandusky MS 6,113,940 2033 8,314,958 (724,936) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 1 10,000,620 2028 11,600,719 (1,011,404) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 2 10,000,620 2033 13,600,843 (1,185,783) 11,099,700 Heritage HS 11,654,685 2035 16,782,746 (1,463,196) 196,651,940 Subtotal Costs 206,484,537 243,821,061 Survey Scores Parents 4.73 Community Members 4.58 LCS Staff 4.86 Overall 4.75 Scenario 3 - Assuming Full Renovations Scenario 3 Current Cost Yr Cost at Action Annual $ - Action Operational Savings Close to Home Zoning 2025 550,000 Close Sandusky Elementary 2027 700,000 Close TC Miller 2025 2,500,000 2022 Estimates Construction Costs 55,247,650 Safety & Maintenance 58,010,033 68,876,375 34,241,900 Linkhorne + Expansion 35,953,995 2030 44,582,954 (3,886,945) 2,936,000 Paul Munro 3,082,800 2028 3,576,048 (311,776) 11,728,650 Perrymont + Expansion 12,315,083 2027 13,792,892 (1,202,527) 6,341,100 RS Payne 6,658,155 2025 6,924,481 (603,708) 77,357,466 Safety & Maintenance 81,225,339 100,647,937 2,202,200 Bass 2,312,310 2025 2,404,802 (209,662) 11,670,845 Bedford Hills + Expansion 12,254,387 2025 12,744,563 (1,111,129) 4,133,851 Dearington 4,340,544 2029 5,208,652 (454,114) 3,182,020 Heritage ES 3,341,121 2027 3,742,056 (326,249) 2,090,800 Hutcherson 2,195,340 2027 2,458,781 (214,368) - TC Miller - - - - Sandusky ES - - - 2,719,050 Sheffield 2,855,003 2031 3,654,403 (318,608) 8,751,400 Dunbar 9,188,970 2028 10,659,205 (929,318) 6,636,000 Linkhorne MS 6,967,800 2033 9,476,208 (826,179) 5,822,800 Sandusky MS 6,113,940 2033 8,314,958 (724,936) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 1 10,000,620 2028 11,600,719 (1,011,404) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 2 10,000,620 2033 13,600,843 (1,185,783) 11,099,700 Heritage HS 11,654,685 2035 16,782,746 (1,463,196) 132,605,116 Subtotal Costs 139,235,372 169,524,313 Survey Scores Parents 4.73 Community Members 4.58 LCS Staff 4.86 Overall 4.75 Scenario 3 - Assuming Safety and Maintenance Improvements Scenario 4 Current Cost Yr Cost at Action Annual $ - Action Operational Savings Close to Home Zoning 2025 500,000 Close Sandusky Elementary 2029 600,000 Close Paul Munro 2027 700,000 Close Dearington 2025 2,500,000 2022 Estimates Construction Costs 102,519,724 Full Renovations 107,645,710 121,638,802 36,414,224 Linkhorne + Expansion 38,234,935 2030 47,411,320 (4,133,535) - Paul Munro - - - 24,289,000 Perrymont + Expansion 25,503,450 2027 28,563,864 (2,490,328) 41,816,500 RS Payne 43,907,325 2025 45,663,618 (3,981,162) 76,366,215 Safety & Maintenance 80,184,526 100,501,637 2,202,200 Bass 2,312,310 2025 2,404,802 (209,662) 11,670,845 Bedford Hills + Expansion 12,254,387 2025 12,744,563 (1,111,129) - Dearington - - - 3,182,020 Heritage ES 3,341,121 2027 3,742,056 (326,249) 2,090,800 Hutcherson 2,195,340 2027 2,458,781 (214,368) 3,142,600 TC Miller 3,299,730 2029 3,959,676 (345,223) - Sandusky ES - - - 2,719,050 Sheffield 2,855,003 2031 3,654,403 (318,608) 8,751,400 Dunbar 9,188,970 2031 11,761,882 (1,025,454) 6,636,000 Linkhorne MS 6,967,800 2033 9,476,208 (826,179) 5,822,800 Sandusky MS 6,113,940 2033 8,314,958 (724,936) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 1 10,000,620 2028 11,600,719 (1,011,404) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 2 10,000,620 2033 13,600,843 (1,185,783) 11,099,700 Heritage HS 11,654,685 2035 16,782,746 (1,463,196) 178,885,939 Subtotal Costs 187,830,236 222,140,439 Survey Scores Parents 3.15 Community Members 2.67 LCS Staff 4.08 Overall 3.36 Scenario 4 - Assuming Full Renovations Scenario 4 Current Cost Yr Cost at Action Annual $ - Action Operational Savings Close to Home Zoning 2025 550,000 Close Sandusky Elementary 2030 600,000 Close Paul Munro 2027 700,000 Close Dearington 2025 2,500,000 2022 Estimates Construction Costs 52,311,650 Safety & Maintenance 54,927,233 65,300,327 34,241,900 Linkhorne + Expansion 35,953,995 2030 44,582,954 (3,886,945) Paul Munro - - - 11,728,650 Perrymont + Expansion 12,315,083 2027 13,792,892 (1,202,527) 6,341,100 RS Payne 6,658,155 2025 6,924,481 (603,708) 76,366,215 Safety & Maintenance 80,184,526 99,398,961 2,202,200 Bass 2,312,310 2025 2,404,802 (209,662) 11,670,845 Bedford Hills + Expansion 12,254,387 2025 12,744,563 (1,111,129) - Dearington - - - 3,182,020 Heritage ES 3,341,121 2027 3,742,056 (326,249) 2,090,800 Hutcherson 2,195,340 2027 2,458,781 (214,368) 3,142,600 TC Miller 3,299,730 2029 3,959,676 (345,223) - Sandusky ES - - - 2,719,050 Sheffield 2,855,003 2031 3,654,403 (318,608) 8,751,400 Dunbar 9,188,970 2028 10,659,205 (929,318) 6,636,000 Linkhorne MS 6,967,800 2033 9,476,208 (826,179) 5,822,800 Sandusky MS 6,113,940 2033 8,314,958 (724,936) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 1 10,000,620 2028 11,600,719 (1,011,404) 9,524,400 EC Glass - Phase 2 10,000,620 2033 13,600,843 (1,185,783) 11,099,700 Heritage HS 11,654,685 2035 16,782,746 (1,463,196) 128,677,865 Subtotal Costs 135,111,758 164,699,288 Survey Scores Parents 3.15 Community Members 2.67 LCS Staff 4.08 Overall 3.36 Scenario 4 - Assuming Safety and Maintenance Improvements

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.