RecordWell Data

City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · City Council · meeting of Jun 16, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City Council Meeting Agenda June 16, 2025 City Hall Council Chamber 605 E. Main St. Charlottesville, VA 22902 Juandiego R. Wade, Mayor Brian R. Pinkston, Vice Mayor Natalie Oschrin Michael K. Payne J. Lloyd Snook, III Kyna Thomas, Clerk 4:00 PM Opening Session I. Call to Order/Roll Call II. Agenda Approval III. Reports 1. Report: NDS Zoning Implementation Update and FY26 Workplan 5:30 PM Closed Meeting • By Motion: Consideration of appointment(s) to the Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority Board, Retirement Commission, and Charlottesville- Albemarle SPCA Board • Discussion: Consideration of the appointment, performance, and salary of a specific named appointee of the public body, specifically, to conduct the City Manager’s annual performance evaluation 6:30 PM Business Session IV. Moment of Silence V. Announcements VI. Recognitions/Proclamations VII. Community Matters Public comment for up to 16 speakers (limit 3 minutes per speaker). Preregistration available for first 8 spaces at https://www.charlottesville.gov/692/Request-to-Speak; speakers announced by Noon on meeting day (9:00 a.m. sign-up deadline). Additional public comment at end of meeting. Comments on Public Hearing items are heard during the public hearing only. VIII. Consent Agenda* The consent agenda consists of routine, non-controversial items whereby all items are passed with a single motion and vote. Individuals speaking during Community Matters may address items on the Consent Agenda. 2. Resolution: Resolution to Appropriate $266,387 in FY 24 Meadowcreek Golf Course Surplus Funds (2nd reading) 3. Ordinance: Ordinance to Amend and Reordain City Code Chapter 31 (Utilities) to Establish New Utility Rates and Service Fees for City Gas, Water, and Sanitary Sewer (2nd reading) 4. Resolution: Resolution to Allocate Housing Operations and Support ("HOPS") FY 26 Grant Funding for Affordable Housing and Homelessness Support Programs in the Amount of $460,574 5. Resolution: Resolution Authorizing Hospital to Home to Operate as a Non-Emergency Medical Transport Agency in Charlottesville IX. City Manager Report Page 1 of 289 • Report: City Manager Report a. Report: Human Rights Calendar Year 2024 Annual Report X. Action Items 6. Public Hearing/Res.: Public Hearing and Resolution to appropriate additional funds for the Virginia Department of Transportation ("VDOT") City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City") Project Portfolio ($23,317,263) (1 of 2 readings) 7. Public Hearing/Res.: Public Hearing and Resolution to approve a Lease Amendment for property located at 100 5th Street NE to the Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless 8. Public Hearing/Res.: Public Hearing and Resolution to amend the City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City"), CDBG and HOME Funding Awards for Program Year 2025-26, a Minor Amendment to the City's 1-Year Annual Action Plan, in the amounts of $6,835.00 (CDBG) and $2,859.47 (HOME) (1 of 2 readings) a. Resolution: Resolution appropriating Community Development Block Grant (“CDBG”) funds anticipated from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development for Program Year 2025-26, in the approximate amount $445,452, amended b. Resolution: Resolution approving HOME Investment Partnership Program activity with funds anticipated from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development for Program Year 2025-26, in the approximate amount of $85,876.13, Amended 9. Resolution: Resolution to allocate $8,690,000 of Capital Improvement Program (CIP) Contingency Funds (2nd reading) 10. Resolution: Resolution approving Albemarle Charlottesville Regional Jail ("ACRJ") Renovation Plan of Finance for the ACRJ Authority's Issuance of 2025 Bonds and the 2025 Grant Anticipation Note ("GAN") 11. Resolution: Resolution to Amend and Reallocate Tax and Rent Relief Budgets 12. Resolution: LLC/Entity Creation Authorization Resolutions: Westhaven Phase One and Sixth Street Phase Two Redevelopment Projects (1 of 2 Readings) a. Resolution: Resolution Authorizing Entity Formation for Sixth Street Redevelopment Phase Two b. Resolution: Resolution Authorizing Entity Formation for Westhaven Redevelopment Phase One XI. General Business 13. By Motion: Approval of an Employment Agreement appointing William David Milton as Charlottesville City Assessor 14. By Motion: Confidential Settlement Agreement XII. Community Matters (2) XIII. Adjournment Page 2 of 289 Page 3 of 289 MEETING GUIDELINES • This is an in-person meeting with an option for the public to participate electronically by registering in advance for the Zoom webinar at www.charlottesville.gov/zoom. The meeting may also be viewed on the City's streaming platforms and local government Channel 10. Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide 48 hours’ notice so that proper arrangements may be made. • The presiding officer shall ensure that individuals address their comments to City Council at appropriate times, in accordance with the meeting agenda and Council’s Rules of Procedure. • No person who is not a member of the city council shall orally address it until leave to do so has been granted by the city council or until invited to do so by the mayor. (City Code sec.2-71) • Remarks and actions that disrupt the progress of the Council meeting, and remarks from persons other than councilors, the City Manager, the City Attorney, or a presenter for an Agenda Item are not permitted. • The presiding officer shall call an individual to order, including a councilor, when that individual goes afoul of these rules. The following are examples of remarks and behavior that are not permitted: i. Interrupting a speaker who is addressing Council at the speaker's microphone, or interrupting a speaker who has otherwise been invited to address Council during Community Matters or a Public Hearing ii. Interrupting a councilor who is speaking iii. Shouting, and talking (either individually or in concert with others) in a manner that prevents a speaker or a Councilor from being heard or that otherwise hinders the progress of the meeting iv. Blocking paths for emergency exit from the meeting room; engaging in any conduct that prevents a member of the audience from seeing or hearing councilors during a meeting; standing on chairs or tables within the Council meeting room v. Threats or incitement of violence toward councilors, City staff or members of the public vi. Engaging in conduct that is a criminal offense under the City Code or the Virginia Code vii. Campaigning for elected office viii. Promotion of private business ventures ix. Using profanity or vulgarity x. Personal attacks against Councilors, City staff or members of the public xi. Behavior which tends to intimidate others • During a City Council meeting the presiding officer shall have control of the Council Chambers and the connecting halls and corridors within City Hall, and any other venue where a Council meeting is being held. In case of any conduct described above, the presiding officer may take measures deemed appropriate, including but not limited to suspending the meeting until order is restored, ordering areas to be cleared by the Sergeant at Arms, or requiring any individual to exit the meeting room and adjacent premises (connecting halls and corridors.) Page 4 of 289 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: NDS Zoning Implementation Update and FY26 Workplan Staff Contact(s): Kellie Brown, Director of NDS Presenter: Kellie Brown, Director of NDS Date of Proposed Action: June 16, 2025 Issue This is a presentation on the NDS FY26 Work Plan and Progress Report on the Implementation of the Development Code. Background / Rule Presentation on Neighborhood Development Services Work Plan and Development Code Implementation Analysis Staff has been asked to provide an update on the implementation of the Development Code since its adoption in 2024. This report identifies the department's priority items for achieving the goals of the Comprehensive Plan as regulated through the Development Code and other department responsibilities. Financial Impact Program activities align with the resources allocated in the City's budget. Recommendation This report is informational. No action is needed. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) n/a Attachments 1. NDS Workplan_FY26 Page 5 of 289 Neighborhood Development Services Department Development Code Implementation and FY26 Workplan June 2025 Page 6 of 289 Agenda 1. NDS Organization 2. Accomplishments 3. Key Workplan Considerations 4. Workplan Priorities 5. Development Code Amendments Vision: To be a place where everyone thrives. Page 7 of 289 NDS Organization – Dedicated to Creating a Sustainable and Vibrant Community Zoning: Ensures compliance with city zoning ordinances, manages zoning applications, and reviews land use proposals (3). Property Maintenance: Oversees the enforcement of property maintenance codes to ensure public health, safety, and aesthetic standards (3). Building Inspections: Manages permitting processes for construction projects, ensuring safety and code compliance in building development (5). Support Services: Provides administrative, technical, and customer service support for all divisions within NDS (2). Development Services: Provides oversight and support for land development; site planning, subdivision, and developer coordination (4). Transportation: Focuses on planning, design, and implementation of transportation projects to improve mobility and connectivity (4). Historic Preservation: Promotes preservation, interpretation of historic sites and structures and ensures that new buildings complement those resources (2). Long-Range Planning: Guides future growth through visionary, justice-centered planning initiatives that shape policy, land use, and urban design (2). Together, these divisions work to promote responsible development, foster community engagement, and work towards a community where Charlottesville’s residents thrive. Page 8 of 289 Strategic Outcome Areas 1. Climate Action 2. Economic Prosperity 3. Education 4. Housing 5. Organizational Excellence 6. Partnerships 7. Public Safety 8. Recreation, Arts, and Culture 9. Transportation 10.Commitment to JEDI Page 9 of 289 Strategic Outcome Areas 1. Climate Action 2. Economic Prosperity 3. Education 4. Housing 5. Organizational Excellence 6. Partnerships 7. Public Safety 8. Recreation, Arts, and Culture 9. Transportation 10.Commitment to JEDI NDS Page 10 of 289 Key Accomplishments Page 11 of 289 Notable Accomplishments Project Completion and Funding (FY25) • Regional Transit Authority (CARTA) • Move Safely Blue Ridge Adoption and Pilot • Pump Track Installation at McIntyre Park • ID'ed 60+ Urgent Transportation Improvements • Café Standards Updates • Court Square & Carver Inn Historical Markers • Development Review Improvements • Development Code Amendments (1st Batch) • NDS Webpage Refresh (e.g STR Guide) • Stabilizing Property Taskforce Staff Development (FY25) • Director • Development Review Planning Manager • Long Range Planning Manager • Long Range Senior Planner • Permit Technician • Student Housing Property Maintenance Inspector • Transit Planner • Property Maintenance & Housing Inspector Certification • Combination Building Inspector Certification Page 12 of 289 Building Inspections *- through April '25 Building Code Inspections (2024) 2023 2024 2025* Permits Issued 1643 1741 717 Permits Reviewed 873 977 395 Inspections 5909 6055 2196 Page 13 of 289 Key Workplan Considerations and Priorities Page 14 of 289 Key Workplan Considerations 1. Timely accomplish non-discretionary, core mission services (Building Code review and enforcement, Property Maintenance Code review and enforcement, Development plan review and approvals, Historic preservation, Zoning enforcement) 2. Prioritize efforts in support of health, safety, and implementation of new Development Code, before adding new initiatives 3. Consistently apply an equity lens to our work and the selection of it 4. Align workplan commitments with staff capacity, while growing capacity through professional development and training What do we do? Who benefits? Who is burdened ? Who is missing ? Who is left out? How do we know? Page 15 of 289 Workplan Priorities Organizational Excellence Status and Anticipated Completion Other Strategic Outcome Areas Regulatory Review, Permitting and Enforcement: Continue to manage the City’s review of all property development and property maintenance with applicable local and state regulatory compliance. Ongoing All Strategic Outcome Areas Electronic Plan Review System Improvements: Continue to make improvements to Cityworks and Onbase for plan intake and review Ongoing All Strategic Outcome Areas Recruitment:, Zoning Inspector, UVA Property Maintenance Inspector Completion by Fall 2025 All Strategic Outcome Areas Training and Professional Development: Complete Required certifications and professional development (i.e. AICP, VAZO, Building Code Certifications, NACTO, Manager Training) Ongoing All Strategic Outcome Areas Development Review Process Improvements : Implement 21-day review process for by-right development applications Implementation by Fall 2025 All Strategic Outcome Areas Page 16 of 289 Workplan Priorities Housing Status and Anticipated Completion Other Strategic Outcome Areas 10th and Page and Rose Hill Visioning Plans: This project, although previously identified as the 10th and Page Small Area Plan, is a priority of the 2025 Neighborhood Development Services workplan and City Manager’s office. Neighborhood Development Services is attempting to take on a different planning process, launching this summer, to better serve the needs of the 10th and Page and Rose Hill neighborhoods, by forecasting the next five years. Anticipated 1 year process JEDI Economic Prosperity Transportation Development Code Training and Education: Develop training webinars and graphics-based informational materials to illustrate development parameters commonly referenced in the development review process, with a focus on making the materials easy to understand and accessible. Creation of a Development Plan template that would standardize submissions for Zoning compliance. Ongoing/Spring 2026 Training and education materials initiated through webpage refresh in Spring 2025 JEDI Economic Prosperity Development Code Monitoring, Evaluation, and Amendments: Initiate annual program of proposing amendments for Council consideration and adoption: 1) technical corrections 2) clarifications to support the intent of regulations as adopted 3) policy-based amendments. First batch of proposed amendments Fall 2025 Additional amendments Summer 2026 Organizational Excellence Economic Prosperity Stabilizing Property Task Force: Convene task force to develop customized plans to address limited number of most neglected/deteriorating properties and return them to stabilized housing opportunities. Ongoing Initiated in spring 2025 Economic Prosperity Page 17 of 289 Other Priorities Status and Anticipated Completion Strategic Outcome Areas Short Term Rentals: improve enforcement by investing in software with CoR that enables better tracking of homestays and conducting zoning study to refine existing regulations to make enforcement easier Initiate in Spring 2025 and complete by Winter 2026 Economic Prosperity Housing Environmental Policy Review and Ordinance Revisions : Develop a new policy framework, implementation recommendations, and regulatory revisions to align the City’s regulations for natural resources with the Comprehensive Plan Complete scoping effort in Summer 2025; Anticipated 2 years Climate and Sustainability Housing Economic Prosperity Charlottesville Design Guideline Review : Develop scope of work to study local districts and Development Code requirements, identify key policy issues and recommendations, and amend design guidelines and the Development Code to balance Comp Plan goals for housing and historic resources Complete scoping in FY26 Historic Preservation Housing Economic Prosperity JEDI Opportunities for Historic and Cultural Resource Recognition: Document accomplishments, areas of additional need and opportunities, potential prioritization of future efforts and resource needs Complete review in FY26 Historic Preservation Housing Economic Prosperity JEDI 5-Year Comp Plan Review: Initiate review of Comp Plan required by 2026, along with discussion around indicators that can track the City’s success towards the objectives of the plan, as required Develop scope and complete by end 2026 All Strategic Outcome Areas Workplan Priorities Page 18 of 289 Workplan Priorities Transportation Status and Anticipated Completion Other Strategic Outcome Areas Comprehensive Transportation Plan: To update the policies and priorities in a consistent manner, across all of the modes, in a way that aligns with guidance from Council on the City’s transportation goals, staff will begin scoping a new comprehensive transportation plan. Initiate procurement of consultant support by Spring 2026 All Strategic Outcome Areas Safe Streets: Test strategies and demonstration project identified in the Move Safely Blue Ridge Safety Action Plan. Conduct testing of traffic calming devices on local, low -volume streets. Work with Traffic Engineering to assess effectiveness of temporary traffic calming measures. Develop a strategy for lower traffic speed limits throughout the City. Create a new non-motorized counter network to better understand the scale and locations of pedestrian and bicycle travel in the City. Ongoing Public safety Partnerships Organizational Excellence Economic Prosperity JEDI Pedestrian Facilities and Sidewalks: Create initial conceptual plans for all Tier 1 and Tier 2 sidewalks to develop updated cost estimates for FY2027 budgeting. Complete 3 permanent Safe Routes to School projects. Continue to identify potential quickbuild locations for Neighborhood Transportation Improvements and SRTS in collaboration with BPAC. Ongoing Public safety Partnerships Organizational Excellence JEDI Page 19 of 289 Workplan Priorities Transportation Status and Anticipated Completion Other Strategic Outcome Areas Regional Transit and CAT Planning: Work with the regional transit authority (CARTA) to identify regional priorities, opportunities for near -term investments, and potential funding structures, working with CARTA and state legislators to develop enabling legislation for a dedicated funding source for transit. Ongoing Partnerships Economic Prosperity JEDI Biking, Bikes, and Bike Facilities: Complete implementation plans for 5th St Road Diet and implement the demonstration project alternative with a protected bikeway. Add more than 200 new bike parking spots. Expand the school bike fleets and identify opportunities to increase their use through afterschool programs. Promote low-stress routes for bicycling and other biking information through the BikeCville website. Ongoing Public safety Partnerships Economic Prosperity JEDI Recreation, Arts, Culture Neighborhood Walking Tours: NDS staff will continue the monthly Neighborhood Walking Tour series in FY26. Started in January 2024, the Neighborhood Walks have drawn residents and students out on one Sunday a month, to see the City and learn more about the neighborhoods and people who make it a great place to live. Ongoing Organizational Excellence Partnerships JEDI Recreation, Arts, Culture Micro Mobility: Update and enforce regulations to make City -management of the permit less burdensome and encourage Veo’s investment in resources and staff that would further improve its performance. Continue the e-bike voucher pilot program and work with Office of Sustainability to develop a new pilot to provide e -bikes to residents working with Social Services and Human Services programs Ongoing Public safety Partnerships Organizational Excellence JEDI Page 20 of 289 Environmental Policy Review and Ordinance Revisions Page 21 of 289 • Focus on balancing Comp Plan goals for housing with community vision for healthy air, water, and ecosystems, as well as ample, high-quality, and accessible open space and natural areas, and a preserved and enhanced tree canopy. • Key emerging question: How to meet state stormwater management requirements and also allow additional housing units and lot coverage allowed by the Development Code? • Study work plans this summer will chart a path for evaluating: • Potential impacts and mitigation strategies from lowering the threshold of on-site stormwater management requirements • Opportunities for coordination with City stormwater utility planning • Other natural resources in need of additional study (i.e. trees, critical slopes, streams, green buildings, floodplains), and potential regulatory changes or City investment Environmental Policy and Regulatory Review Page 22 of 289 10th and Page and Rose Hill Visioning Processes Page 23 of 289 Timeline April 2025 – Stage 1: ORGANIZE • Prepare for visioning process • Develop engagement strategies & materials May–July 2025 – Stage 2: IDENTIFY • Identify issues & opportunities • Finalize engagement strategies July–Dec 2025 – Stage 3: STRATEGIZE • Finalize vision statement • Develop projects/programs Winter–Spring 2026 – Stage 4: FORMALIZE • Assemble, review, & finalize plan Stage 5: VISUALIZE • Begin plan implementation • Bi-annual review process 2026–2031 (Five Year) – Implementation Page 24 of 289 Engagement Process Phase 1: PREPARE (Organize & Build Trust) • Inform public of process shift • Partner with neighborhood associations • Develop website & plan public launch • Focus on trauma-informed, equity- centered relationship-building Phase 2: DISTRIBUTE (Inform, Involve) • Share draft materials for input • Host open houses & community meetings • Collaborate with stakeholders Phase 3: REVIEW (Inform, Consult)  Final edits made with feedback  30-day public review period Phase 4: DECISION-MAKING  Present plan to Planning Commission & City Council  Public hearings and transparent communication • Phase 5: FOLLOW-UP  Bi-annual updates  Continued engagement & plan transparency Page 25 of 289 Short Term Rental Study Page 26 of 289 Overview • Neighborhood Development Services (NDS) is leading the Short-Term Rentals (STR) ordinance update to: • Increase equity (address benefits, burdens, who has been missing/left out) and compliance • Ensure clear enforcement mechanisms • Streamline digital application/ recertification process • Conduct inclusive community engagement • Launch Request for Proposals (RFP) for Short-Term Rentals (STR) monitoring software and database Page 27 of 289 Timeline • March–April: Internal prep, draft workplan and engagement materials • April–June: STR recertification window opens (applications due June 15th); survey distributed • June–August: Internal drafting of ordinance and survey/data integration • September–October: Public engagement, focus groups, draft revision • November - December: Planning Commission and City Council Work Sessions and determination of next steps based on stakeholder feedback • January/February (tentative) : Planning Commission and City Council hearings • February/March 2026: Ordinance becomes effective Page 28 of 289 Accessing short-term Rentals Page 29 of 289 Restabilizing Property Team Page 30 of 289 There are properties with complex circumstances that require attention beyond standard enforcement. A list of consulting parties has been identified who may be appropriate to consult with to identify both the property and the human related circumstances and provide information on community resources. Groups to date include ANCHOR, Social Services, Human Services, Police, Fire, City Attorney, Region T en, NDS, City Manager The overall goal is to provide links to community resources while reaching compliance. Complex Properties Stabilized Properties Property Maintenance Zoning Building Inspections ANCHORHuman Services Social Services and Region 10 City Attorney Page 31 of 289 Architectural Design Guidelines Review Page 32 of 289 ADC ADC ADC ADC ADC ADC ADC ADC HC HC HC IPPs Board of Architectural Review (BAR) Design Review Purview per Chapter 34, Section 5.1.5. : Architectural Design Control (ADC) Districts, Individually Protected Properties (IPPs), and Historic Conservation (HC) Districts. ADC Districts. Ch. 34, Sec. 2.9.2. Approximately 1,100 properties and 368 acres. • Downtown • North Downtown • Ridge Street • West Main Street • Wertland Street • The Corner • Oakhurst-Gildersleeve District • Rugby Road - University Circle -Venable IPPs. Ch. 34, Sec. 2.9.3. 76 IPPs. Approximately 62 acres. HC Districts. Ch. 34, Sec. 2.9.4. Approximately 250 properties and 145 acres. • Martha Jefferson • Rugby Road • Woolen Mills Village Page 33 of 289 Entrance Corridor Review Board (ERB, City Planning Commission) Design Review Purview per Chapter 34, Section 5.1.3. : Entrance Corridors (EC). [Note: If overlap with an ADC District, HC District, or IPP, the BAR has purview.] ECs. Ch. 34, Sec. 2.9.5. Approximately 687 acres (exclude UVa). • 29 North • Hydraulic Road • Barracks Road • Ivy Road • Fontaine Avenue/Jefferson Park Avenue • Fifth Street, SW • Avon Street • Monticello Avenue/Route 20 • Long Street • East High Street/9th Street • Preston Avenue Page 34 of 289 The Design Guidelines ADC Districts and IPPs 133 pages Last comprehensive update: 2012 HC Districts 10 pages Last comprehensive update: 2017 Entrance Corridors 99 pages Last comprehensive update: 2011 Page 35 of 289 Updating the Design Guidelines 1. Required by City Code: The BAR and the ERB will develop design guidelines, which will become effective upon approval by City Council and thereafter will have the status of interpretive regulations. The BAR and the ERB must undertake a comprehensive review and update the design guidelines at least once every 5 years. 2. Assure alignment with the Comprehensive Plan (adopted 2021) and the subsequent updates to the Code of Development (adopted 2023). Page 36 of 289 Design Control Districts: By the numbers Purview Designation Acres % of City BAR ADC Districts (8) 367 10%IPPs 62 HC Districts (3) 145 ERB Entrance Corridors (12) (excl. UVa) 687 12% Total 1,261 22% Design Review: 2005 – 2024 CoA Requests Formal reviews Purview Approvals Denials BAR 1,261 63 ERB 80 0 Total 1,341 63 Page 37 of 289 Development Code Updates Page 38 of 289 Development Data Development Plan Applications (March '24 - May '25) Pre-Application Meetings 90 Applications Submitted 20 Applications Approved 3 Page 39 of 289 Snapshot of Developments Currently Under Review Project Location/Zoning Review History Development Issues or Next Steps PL-24-0042 Major Development Plan 9 Residential Units 1609 Gordon Avenue RX-5 Residential Mixed Use • Preliminary Approval January 30, 2025 • Submit a Final Site Plan PL-24-0048 Major Development Plan 3 Residential Units 1317 E. Market Street R-A Residential • Submitted May 24, 2024 • Denied with Comments July 30, 2024 • Subdividing the property before reengaging the Development process PL-24-0113 Major Development Plan 12 Residential Units 811, 815, & 819 Hillcrest Road • Submitted October 21, 2024 • Denied with Comments December 20, 2024 • Resubmitted March 21, 2025 • Denied with Comments May 5, 2025 • Street Closure • City owned land being used for private utility access PL-24-0088 Major Development Plan 24 Residential Units 2030 Barracks Road R-B Residential • Submitted August 19, 2024 • Denied with Comments October 18, 2024 • Resubmitted December 9, 2024 • Denied with Comments on April 10, 2025 • Entry feature requirements • Streetscape requirements • Critical slope disturbance • Subdivision • Adjacent to VDOT streetscape project PL-24-0143 Major Development Plan 6 Residential Units 1040 St. Clair Avenue R-A Residential • Submitted December 18, 2024 • Denied with Comments February 10, 2025 • Resubmitted May 12, 2025 • Utility service upgrades PL-24-0075 Major Development Plan 6 Residential Units 303 Alderman Road R-B Residential • Submitted August 4, 2025 • Denied with Comments September 13, 2024 • Resubmitted October 28, 2024 • Denied with Comments December 28, 2024 • Denied with Comments March 13, 2025 • Massing requirements • Streetscape requirements • Subdivision Page 40 of 289 Approved Additional (aka Accessory) Dwelling Unit Permits (as of May '25) Page 41 of 289 Development Review Process Updates Objective: • Update and amend the Development Review Procedures Manual and portions of the Development Code to better align with the City’s Comprehensive Plan to provide more dwelling units. Key Activities: • Meeting with CADRe on April 17, 2025, to present an overview of draft changes. Proposed Changes: • Shortening review times. • Simplifying Development Plans. • Clarifying expectations for both City Staff and the Development Community. Timeline: • Aim to have the updated review processes in place by this fall. Page 42 of 289 Development Code Amendments • The Current Development Code was Adopted on December 18, 2023 – Designed to facilitate a more form-based zoning ordinance, increasing density in alignment with the 2021 Comprehensive Plan. • Need for Amendments – Staff identified both minor and significant issues requiring revisions to better support City goals. • Three-Tier Approach: • Tier 1 – Minor grammatical corrections, small adjustments, and state requirements. • Tier 2 – Modifications addressing oversights and clarifications. • Tier 3 – Policy changes requiring in-depth analysis and community engagement. • Next Steps: • Tier 1 & 2 – Advancing to Public Hearing for adoption this fall. • Tier 3 – Considered in the broader FY26 NDS workplan and beyond. • Ongoing Process – Annual updates for Tier 1 & 2 to ensure adaptability, best practices, and sustainable growth. Page 43 of 289 Tier 1 Amendments • Purpose – Addresses copy editing issues, missing text, and small refinements to accurately reflect the intended intent of the Development Code. • Legislative Updates – Incorporates recent actions passed by the Virginia General Assembly to ensure compliance. • Scope – Primarily technical corrections and minor adjustments, ensuring clarity and consistency without altering policy direction. • Process – Proposed amendments will be included an upcoming Public Hearing for formal adoption. • Annual Initiative – Establishing regular updates to maintain accuracy and alignment with evolving legislative and regulatory standards. Page 44 of 289 Tier 1 Amendment Examples Page Section Existing Language or Issue Proposed Language 4-10 4.3.2.B.1.A “…Administrator may allow once side of a block…” “…Administrator may allow one side of a block…” 6-15 6.7 .3.B.1.a.iii “See 5.2.7 Major Historic Review and 5.2.7 Major Historic Review” “See 5.2.6 Minor Historic Review and 5.2.7 Major Historic Review.” 2-40 2.5.6.A.6 “Type X” “Type B, D” 3-32 3.4.4.A “In a RX-District, commercial uses must not exceed 25% of the floor area on a lot.” *This information is not readily visible and should be added to the RX-district pages in Division 2. 5-5 5.1.3.B.1 Missing Special Exception Permits “f. Special Exception Permits” Throughout the code RN-A is missing, Example: RN-A is not listed in the Screening Transition Matrix under 4.7 .1.B.1 on page 4-48 Page 45 of 289 Tier 1 Amendment Examples State Regulations Bill General Changes that need to be made HB2660 Review timelines have been reduced for Subdivisions, Site Plans, and Development Plans. Most of this information is in the City’s Development Review Procedures Manual and not subject to requiring a code amendment. Acceptance of applications has been shortened from 10 days to 5 days, and this will need to be amended in the Development Code. Page 5-12 (5.2.1.C.4.a) SB974 Removes Planning Commission as the approval authority for administrative review for Subdivisions, Site Plans, and Development Plans. Staff is in the process of identifying the required edits conform to the new regulation. Page 46 of 289 Tier 2 Amendments • Purpose – Addresses oversights and ambiguities in the Development Code to enhance clarity and functionality. • Fee Schedule – Minor Amendments to the Neighborhood Development Services Fee Schedule to reflect changes to the Development Review process. • Scope – Includes modifications, additions, and removals that improve interpretation and implementation of existing provisions. • Impact – Ensures regulations align more effectively with intended planning goals while maintaining consistency. • Process – Proposed amendments will be included an upcoming Public Hearing for formal adoption. • Continuous Refinement – Part of the ongoing commitment to keeping the Development Code responsive and well-structured. Page 47 of 289 Tier 2 Amendment Examples Page Section Existing Language or Issue Proposed Language or Recommendation 2-8, 2-10, 2- 12, & 2-14 2.2.2.A.4.F, 2.2.3.A.4.F, 2.2.4.A.4.G, 2.2.5.A.4.G “Side lot line (min) 4’” (R-A, RN-A, R-B, and R-C). This section is preventing single-family attached style housing on abutting Zoning lots. Utilize the Alternate Forms Section (2.8) to allow attached housing types on Zoning lots in the Residential Districts. 5-64 & 65 7-12 5.3.3.C 7 .2 Due to the definition of Building and Structure this section is preventing accessory structures on nonconforming lots. Add “..Primary Building…” to many of these sections. “Building, primary. The Building(s) occupied or designated for the primary use.” 5-37 5.2.9 “Development Review applies to…New construction, Addition, Site Modification…” “Development Review consists of two separate approvals, Development Plan and Final Site Plan.” “5.2.9.A.4 The following project activities are exempt from Development Review. a. New Construction of up to two dwelling units on one Zoning Lot or Sublot. b. Additions to an existing dwelling unit that does not expand the total number of units above two units post construction. Page 48 of 289 Tier 3 Amendments • Purpose – To establish new policies for issues not adequately addressed during initial preparation of the new Development Code process. • Scope – Study of issues with a meaningful impact on the built environment, such as clarification of the appropriate building height and/or massing, allowable density, and allowable uses in different types of locations, in which multiple options should be evaluated and community input will be needed to inform decision making. • Community Input – Extensive outreach to gather feedback and ensure alignment with public priorities. • Process – Will be prioritized as zoning studies within the broader future NDS workplans, given the complexity and resources required. • Future Considerations – Helps shape long-term regulatory strategies to maintain an adaptable and effective Development Code. Page 49 of 289 Tier 3 Amendment Examples • Clarification of acceptable height and building length for townhouses and other infill housing types allowed in Residential districts, and relatedamendments to standards including definition of "Building", requirements for Height in feet and stories, bonus height for additional units, and build-to width • Clarification of goals for RN-A districts, including consideration of benefits and burdens of requirements for RN-A as distinct from other Residential Districts, and related amendments to address policy refinements • Additional study of issues and opportunities for allowing neighborhood service retail and services within residential areas and Zoning amendments, and related amendments to address new policies Page 50 of 289 Tier 3 Amendment Examples • Development of standards for athletic field lighting • Clarification of how buildings and structures and associated features should be oriented toward different types of streets, and related amendments • Clarification of criteria for requiring mid-block pedestrian paths, and related amendments • Clarification of criteria for requiring active depth to meet goals for pedestrian realm and on- site structured parking, and related amendments • Clarification of critical slope definitions and criteria for waivers (studied through Environmental Policy and Regulations Review along with tree planting and preservation standards) Page 51 of 289 May 27, 2025 Planning Commission Work Session Highlight • May 27, 2025: Work Session with Planning Commission • Reviewed the Amendment Tiers • Requested an additional Work Session • Future engagement with City Council • Feedback from the Development Community • June 16, 2025: Work Session with City Council • June through August: Drafting of materials by staff • August: Additional Work Session with Planning Commission • September 9, 2025: Initiation Amendments • October 14, 2025: Public Hearing at Planning Commission • November 17, 2025: Public Hearing at City Council • December 1, 2025: Adoption Page 52 of 289 Other Items Previously Identified • Starr Hill Plan Implementation o To be considered through evaluation of City -owned properties for future use and through prioritization of small area plannings needs following completion of 10th and Page and Rose Hill Visioning Plan • Downtown Mall Study o To be considered through prioritization of small area planning needs following completion of 10th and Page and Rose Hill Visioning Plan • Alley Study o Creation of a comprehensive inventory of existing alleys, including ownership, existing conditions, and parcel access and options for City interventions in alley maintenance (i.e. formalizing ownership agreements and maintenance responsibilities) to be conducted when there are additional staff resources in the City Attorney's office • Noise Ordinance Review and Update o Specific concerns to be evaluated and addressed through inter -departmental study These are items that have not been prioritized for FY26, given staff capacity and focus on other needs. Page 53 of 289 Thank You Page 54 of 289 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Consideration of the appointment, performance, and salary of a specific named appointee of the public body, specifically, to conduct the City Manager’s annual performance evaluation Staff Contact(s): Presenter: Date of Proposed Action: June 16, 2025 Issue Background / Rule Analysis Financial Impact Recommendation Recommended Motion (if Applicable) Attachments None Page 55 of 289 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Resolution to Appropriate $266,387 in FY 24 Meadowcreek Golf Course Surplus Funds (2nd reading) Staff Contact(s): William Bassett, Business and Golf Manager, Riaan Anthony, Director of Parks & Recreation Presenter: William Bassett, Business and Golf Manager Date of Proposed Action: June 16, 2025 Issue Resolution Adoption Background / Rule Meadowcreek Golf Course is requesting to appropriate and transfer surplus funds from FY 24 to the Working Capital Account, so that it can utilize funds to reinvest into course conditions, amenities, and public services. Analysis Meadowcreek Golf Course, which operates as an Enterprise Fund, has had several successful years recently with improved course conditions, new services, and amenities, which has made the course highly utilized by City residents, the surrounding counties, and visitors. In FY 24, Meadowcreek had 43,618 rounds of golf played and an unappropriated surplus of $266,387. It is requested that these surplus funds be appropriated to Meadowcreek's Working Capital Account, so that it can continue to reinvest and improve the course conditions, amenities, and public services. Golf courses require continuous re-investments in equipment, maintenance, and service enhancements to keep up with customer expectations. The appropriated funds will fully or partially fund critical items such as: • Cart Path Repairs; • Bunker/Sand Trap Design and Restoration; • Signage and ADA Compliance; • Creek and Culvert Repairs; and • Service and Amenity Enhancement. Moving forward, any Meadowcreek surpluses will be added to the City year-end appropriations. Financial Impact The appropriation of surplus funds to the Working Capital Account will allow Meadowcreek to utilize the funds for ongoing capital improvement projects, maintenance, and equipment replacement. Recommendation City Staff recommends City Council adopt the attached appropriation Resolution. Page 56 of 289 Recommended Motion (if Applicable) "I move adoption of the Resolution appropriating and transferring Meadowcreek's FY 24 surplus funds to its Working Capital Account, allowing said funds to be utilized to reinvest in Meadowcreek Golf Course's conditions, amenities, and public services." Attachments 1. RES_$266,387 Golf Surplus appropriaion Page 57 of 289 RESOLUTION #R-25-___ To appropriate $266,387 in FY24 Meadowcreek Golf Course Surplus Funds WHEREAS, the unappropriated surplus of $266,387 from Meadowcreek Golf Course be appropriated for reinvestment in capital projects and improvements through the Golf Working Capital account. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, that a total of $266,387 be appropriated in the following manner. Revenues – $266,387.00 $266,387.00 Fund: 609 Cost Center: 3801001000 G/L Account: 498011 Expenditures – $266,387.00 $266,387.00 Fund: 609 I/O: 2000177 G/L Account: 599999 Date Adopted: Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 58 of 289 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Ordinance to Amend and Reordain City Code Chapter 31 (Utilities) to Establish New Utility Rates and Service Fees for City Gas, Water, and Sanitary Sewer (2nd reading) Staff Contact(s): Chris Cullinan, Director of Finance, Lauren Hildebrand, Director of Utilities Presenter: Chris Cullinan, Director of Finance, Lauren Hildebrand, Director of Utilities Date of Proposed Action: June 16, 2025 Issue A Public Hearing is being held to establish the annual rates and service fees for City utility services (water, wastewater, natural gas, and stormwater). These rates would be effective as of July 1, 2025, if approved by City Council on June 16, 2025. Background / Rule The City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City"), owns and operates public utilities for water, wastewater, natural gas, and stormwater. Utility services are essential, on a daily basis, to both individuals and to the entire community. Thoughtful, deliberate planning, and sufficient financial resources ensure safe, efficient, and orderly maintenance and operation of these systems. The need for investment in City utility systems is not without cost, but the City's utility rates must also be balanced with the need for continued affordability for our customers. Each of the City’s utilities is accounted for separately as Enterprise Funds. Enterprise Funds are operated on a self-supporting basis, meaning that each utility is required to cover the full costs of providing its service. The City’s utilities are funded solely through their rates and related fees and charges and are not subsidized by general tax revenues. The utilities do not operate on a for-profit basis. As such, utility rates are calculated annually to bring each Enterprise Fund to a break-even point; however, variable factors such as weather, usage, and number of customers may result in an unexpected operating surplus or deficit during any given year. If so, the surpluses or deficits are accounted for and remain within their respective utility Enterprise Fund. Rivanna Water and Sewer Authority ("RWSA"), which provides the treatment services for the City, is one of the largest fixed-cost elements for the water and wastewater Budgets. For FY26, RWSA rates have increased, and they are incorporated in the City’s proposed utility rates. Analysis Proposed Utility Rates for FY’26 The Budgets for each of the utilities have been thoroughly examined for opportunities to minimize costs without sacrificing service. Based on the revenue requirements needed to operate and maintain each utility, and the above-recommendations, the City is proposing the following rates in the water, wastewater, and gas utilities: ▪ $86.99/1,000 cubic feet (cf) of water (average annual composite rate); ▪ $95.29/1,000 cf of wastewater; and, ▪ $94.72/8,000 cf of natural gas. Page 59 of 289 In addition, the proposed Monthly Services Charges for Water and Wastewater are as follows: Water Monthly Service Charge Meter Size Current Monthly Service Charge Proposed Monthly Service Charge $ Change ⅝" $7.50 $10.00 $2.50 1" $18.75 $25.00 $6.25 1 ½" $37.50 $50.00 $12.50 2" $60.00 $80.00 $20.00 3" $120.00 $160.00 $40.00 4" $187.50 $250.00 $62.50 6" $375.00 $500.00 $125.00 14" $2,456.25 $3,275.00 $818.75 Wastewater Monthly Service Charge Meter Size Current Monthly Service Charge Proposed Monthly Service Charge $ Change ⅝" $7.50 $7.50 $2.50 1" $18.75 $25.00 $6.25 1 ½" $37.50 $50.00 $12.50 2" $60.00 $80.00 $20.00 3" $120.00 $160.00 $40.00 4" $187.50 $250.00 $62.50 6" $375.00 $500.00 $125.00 14" $2,456.25 $3,275.00 $818.75 For the stormwater utility, there are minimal changes to the Budget, and stormwater fees are proposed to remain unchanged for the coming year at $1.20 per 500 square feet of impervious surface. Impact on Average Customer Utility customers continue to conserve water and natural gas, which is both good for the environment and for their utility bill. The average residential water customer is using 400 cubic feet (cf) per month. Similarly, the average residential gas customer is using 4,600 cf. Based on these usage figures and the proposed utility rates, the average residential customer is projected to spend the following per month: Service Current (based on rates adopted 7/1/24) Proposed (Effective 7/1/25) Change Percent Water¹ $38.25 $44.80 $6.55 17.12% Wastewater¹ $44.52 $48.12 $3.60 8.09% Natural Gas¹ $63.35 $66.04 $2.69 4.25% Stormwater² $5.86 $5.86 $0 0% TOTAL $151.98 $164.82 $12.84 8.45% 1. Rates include monthly service charge. Page 60 of 289 2. The Budget impact shown reflects a residential monthly average fee and provides consistency with other utilities. Stormwater fees are rounded to the next whole billing unit and are billed to property owners biannually. For City residential customers who receive water, wastewater, stormwater, and natural gas (81.4% of City residents), their total utility bill is projected to rise by $12.84 per month, or 8.45%. For residential customers who receive just water, wastewater, and stormwater service, their utility bill will increase by $10.15 per month, or 11.45%. The proposed rate report can be found at https://www.charlottesville.gov/602/Utility-Billing. Financial Impact The Utility Funds (water, wastewater, and natural gas) are self-sustaining Enterprise Funds that are supported by the revenues from customers’ usages. The stormwater fee is based on the impervious surface of the property. The approval of the utility rates has no impact on the General Fund. Recommendation City Staff recommends approval of the proposed rates and attached Ordinance. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) "I move approval of the herein-described proposed rates and the attached Ordinance." Attachments 1. FY2026 Utility Rate Ordinance 2. At a Glance FY2026 3. FY2026 Operations Overview Page 61 of 289 ORDINANCE #O-__-___ AN ORDINANCE AMENDING AND REORDAINING CHAPTER 31 (UTILITIES) OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRIGNIA, 1990, AS AMENDED, TO ESTABLISH NEW UTILITY RATES AND SERVICE FEES FOR CITY GAS, WATER, AND SANITARY SEWER ______________________________________________________________________________ BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, effective July 1, 2025, that: 1. Sections 31-56, 31-57, 31-60, 31-61, 31-62, 31-102, 31-106, 31-153, 31-156, and 31-158 of Chapter 31, of the Code of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, 1990, as amended, are hereby amended and reordained as follows: CHAPTER 31. U TILITIES ARTICLE II. GAS DIVISION 2. T YPES OF SERVICE; SERVICE CHARGES Sec. 31-56. Rates - Generally. The firm service gas rates based on monthly meter readings shall be as follows: Basic Monthly Service Charge $ 10.00 First 3,000 cubic feet, per 1,000 cubic feet $9.7813 $12.4070 Next 3,000 cubic feet, per 1,000 cubic feet $9.1798 $11.7596 Next 144,000 cubic feet, per 1,000 cubic feet $8.5784 $11.1121 All over 150,000 cubic feet, per 1,000 cubic feet $7.9769 $10.4647 Sec. 31-57. Air Conditioning. (a) G as service at the rate specified in this paragraph ("air conditioning rate") shall be available to customers who request such service in writing and who have installed and use air conditioning equipment operated by natural gas as the principal source of energy. The air conditioning rate will be $7.3471 $9.8398 per one thousand (1,000) cubic feet of gas used per month. Sec. 31-60. Interruptible Sales Service (IS). (c) Basic monthly service charge . The basic monthly charge per meter for interruptible sales service (“IS gas”) shall be sixty dollars ($60.00). Page 62 of 289 2 (d ) Rate. For all gas consumed by interruptible customers the rate shall be $7.3466 $9.6895 per one thousand (1,000) cubic feet for the first six hundred thousand (600,000) cubic feet, and $6.6850 $8.9886 per one thousand (1,000) cubic feet for all volumes over six hundred thousand (600,000) cubic feet. (e) A nnual Minimum Quantity . Interruptible rate customers shall be obligated to take or pay for a minimum quantity of one million two hundred thousand (1,200,000) cubic feet of gas annually. Each year, as of June 30, the D irector of Finance shall calculate the total consumption of each interruptible customer for the preceding twelve (12) monthly billing periods and shall bill any customer that has consumed less than the minimum quantity for the deficient amount at the rate of $7.3466 $9.6895 per one thousand (1,000) cubic feet. Any new customer shall be required to enter into a S ervice Agreement with the City prior to the start of service. If an interruptible customer terminates service, the annual minimum requirement shall be prorated on the basis of one hundred thousand (100,000) cubic feet per month for each month the customer has received service since the last June 30 adjustment. S ection 31-61. Interruptible Transportation Service (TS). (b) Rates. The rates for interruptible transportation service (“TS gas”) shall be as follows: (1 ) $3.2827 $3.4713 per dekatherm for a customer receiving only TS gas, and (2) $1.9696 $2.0828 per dekatherm, for c ustomers who transport 35,000 or more dekatherms per month (“large volume transportation customers”) , regardless of whether such large volum e transportation customer receives only TS gas, or also receives IS service. S ection 31-62. Purchased Gas Adjustment. In computing gas customer billings, the basic rate charges established under S ections 31-56, 31-57, 31-60, and 31-61 shall be adjusted to reflect increases and decreases in the cost of gas supplied to the City. Such increases or decreases shall be computed as follows: (1) For the purpose of computations herein, the costs and charges for determining the base unit costs of gas are: a. Pipeline tariffs. b. Contract quantities; and c. C osts of natural gas, in effect or proposed as of May 1, 2023 April 1, 2025. Page 63 of 289 3 (2) Such base unit costs are $3.7668 $5.9327 per one thousand (1,000) cubi c feet for firm gas service and $1.8332 $3.8488 per one thousand (1,000) cubic feet for interruptible gas service. ARTICLE IV. WATER AND SEWER SERVICE CHARGES Sec. 31-153. Water Rates Generally. (a) Water rates shall be as follows: (1) Monthly S ervice Charge: Water Meter Size (Inches) Fee 5/8 $7.50 $10.00 3/4 $7.50 $10.00 1 $18.75 $25.00 1 ½ $37.50 $50.00 2 $60.00 $80.00 3 $120.00 $160.00 4 $187.50 $250.00 6 $375.00 $500.00 14 $2,456.25 $3,275.00 (2) Metered Water Consumption, per 1,000 cu. ft.: May – September October – April $88.83 $100.52 $68.33 $77.33 Sec. 31-156. Sewer Service Charges Generally. (a) Any person having a connection directly or indirectly, to the C ity sewer system shall pay therefor a monthly charge as follows: (1) Monthly S ervice Charge: Water Meter Size (Inches) Fee 5/8 $7.50 $10.00 3/4 $7.50 $10.00 1 $18.75 $25.00 1 ½ $37.50 $50.00 Page 64 of 289 4 2 $60.00 $80.00 3 $120.00 $160.00 4 $187.50 $250.00 6 $375.00 $500.00 14 $2,456.25 $3,275.00 (2) An additional charge of ninety-two dollars and fifty -five cents ($92.55) ninety- five dollars and twenty -nine cents ($95.29) per one thousand (1,000) cubic feet of metered water consumption. Date Introduced: June 2, 2025 Date Adopted: June 16, 2025 Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 65 of 289 At A Glance City of Charlottesville Utility Rate Report FY2026 The following information provides a brief summary of the rate and fee recommendations for water, wastewater, stormwater and natural gas for FY2026, and new rates will go into effect July 1st, 2025. For a more thorough explanation and details of the recommendations, please refer to the FY2026 Utility Rate Report. The table below illustrates the monthly impact on an average City residential customer using 400 cubic feet (cf) of water and wastewater, owning a property with approximately 2,440 square feet of impervious surface, and using 4,600 cubic feet (cf) of gas. This information is based on utility rates and charges adopted July 1 st, 2024, and proposed rates and charges. Current Based on rates adopted 7/1/24 Proposed Effective 7/1/25 Change Percent Water1 $38.25 $44.80 $6.55 17.12% Wastewater1 $44.52 $48.12 $3.60 8.09% Gas1 $63.35 $66.04 $2.69 4.25% Stormwater2 $5.86 $5.86 $0 0% Total $151.98 $164.82 $12.84 8.45% (1) Rates include monthly service charges. (2) The budget impact shown reflects a residential monthly average fee and provides consistency with other utilities. Stormwater fees are rounded to the next whole billing unit and are billed to property owners biannually. Water Rates Where your Water Dollar goes ... $0.56 RWSA (PURCHASE OF DRINKING WATER) $0.26 CITY OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE $0.16 CITY DEBT SERVICE (INFRASTRUCTURE) $0.02 CUSTOMER SERVICE & BILLING FY’26 Budget $20,711,105 Usage Rate Water rates are proposed to increase by $10.12 per 1,000 cf based on the amount of water used (13.2% increase). Page 66 of 289 City of Charlottesville Utility Rate Report FY 2026 02 Impact on the Customer The impact on a customer’s bill will depend on how much water is consumed. The average single-family household uses 400 cf/month (2,992 gallons/month; approximately 100 gallons/day). To the extent an individual customer’s usage differs from the average will determine the impact of the proposed rate on their bill. The table below shows the monthly impact on water customers at different amounts of usage. Water Use (cf per month) Current Composite Water (per 1,000 cf) Current Water Usage (charge per month) Proposed Composite Water (per 1,000 cf) Proposed Water Usage (charge per month) $ Change % Change Minimal User (10th Percentile) 140 $76.87 $10.76 $86.99 $12.18 $1.42 13.17% Small User (25th Percentile) 250 $76.87 $19.22 $86.99 $21.75 $2.53 13.16% Median User (50th Percentile) 400 $76.87 $30.75 $86.99 $34.80 $4.05 13.17% Large User (75th Percentile) 610 $76.87 $46.89 $86.99 $53.06 $6.17 13.16% High Volume User (90 th Percentile) 880 $76.87 $67.65 $86.99 $76.55 $8.90 13.16% Wastewater Rates Where your Wastewater Dollar goes ... $0.60 RWSA (PURCHASE OF WASTEWATER TREATMENT) $0.24 CITY OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE $0.14 CITY DEBT SERVICE (INFRASTRUCTURE) $0.02 CUSTOMER SERVICE & BILLING FY’26 Budget $19,072,787 Usage Rate Wastewater usage rates are proposed to increase by $2.74 per 1,000 cf based on the amount of water used (3.0% increase). Impact on the Customer The impact on a customer’s bill will depend on how much water is consumed. The average single-family household uses 400 cf/month (2,992 gallons/month; approximately 100 gallons/day). To the extent an individual customer’s usage differs from the average will determine the impact of the proposed rate on their bill. The table below shows the monthly impact on wastewater customers at different amounts of usage. Water Use (cf per month) Current Wastewater ($ per 1,000 cf) Current Wastewater Usage (charge per month) Proposed Wastewater Rate ($ per 1,000 cf) Proposed Wastewater Usage $ Change % Change Minimal User (10th Percentile) 140 $92.55 $12.96 $95.29 $13.34 $0.38 2.96% Small User (25th Percentile) 250 $92.55 $23.14 $95.29 $23.82 $0.68 2.94% Median User (50th Percentile) 400 $92.55 $37.02 $95.29 $38.12 $1.10 2.97% Large User (75th Percentile) 610 $92.55 $56.46 $95.29 $58.13 $1.67 2.96% High Volume User (90 th Percentile) 880 $92.55 $81.44 $95.29 $83.86 $2.42 2.97% Page 67 of 289 The monthly service charges for water and wastewater are proposed to change. The monthly service charges will increase to $10.00 for water and $10.00 for wastewater for a 5/8” meter. Approximately 94% of customers have a 5/8” meter. The proposed combined monthly service charges for water and sewer are as follows: City of Charlottesville Utility Rate Report FY 2026 03 Water & Wastewater Monthly Service Charge Water Meter Size (in inches) Current Proposed $ Change 5/8 $ 15.00 $ 20.00 $5.00 1 $ 37.50 $ 50.00 $12.50 1 1/2 $ 75.00 $ 100.00 $25.00 2 $ 120.00 $ 160.00 $40.00 3 $ 240.00 $ 320.00 $80.00 4 $ 375.00 $ 500.00 $125.00 6 $ 750.00 $ 1,000.00 $250.00 14 $ 4,912.50 $ 6,550.00 $1,637.50 Stormwater Rates Where your Stormwater Dollar goes ... $0.44 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS PROJECTS $0.21 CITY OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE $0.31 SALARIES $0.04 DEBT SERVICE FY’26 Budget $3,444,572 Stormwater rates are proposed to remain constant for the coming year at $1.20 per 500 square feet of impervious surface (or part thereof) per month. Stormwater fees are billed concurrently with real estate tax assessments and are due in June and December. Modernize and maintain infrastructure integrity while pursuing environmental stewardship. The City has adopted a stormwater utility fee to provide a dedicated and stable source of funding for stormwater management activities. Funds received are used to help the City comply with federal and state stormwater regulations, rehabilitate the City’s aging stormwater infrastructure, address drainage and flooding problems, and pursue environmental stewardship. Impact on the Customer The stormwater utility fee is charged to property owners based on the amount of impervious area on their property (areas covered by hard surfaces, such as: buildings, concrete, gravel, etc.). An example fee calculation is provided below: Example Fee Calculation - Total impervious area (house and driveway): 2,100 SF - Divide by 500 square feet: 2,100 / 500 = 4.2 billing units - Round to the next whole number: 4.2 rounds to 5 billing units - Multiply the number of billing units by the rate ($1.20 per billing unit per month) to determine annual fee: 5 x $1.20 x 12 = $72 annual fee, billed $36 due in June and December Page 68 of 289 $- $10.00 $20.00 $30.00 $40.00 $50.00 $60.00 $70.00 J an-24 Feb-24 Mar-24 Apr-24 May-24 J un-24 J ul-24 Aug-24 Sep-24 Oct-24 Nov-24 Dec-24 J an-25 Feb-25 Mar-25 Apr-25 04 Gas Rates Where your Natural Gas Dollar goes ... $0.43 PURCHASE OF GAS (BP) $0.34 CITY OPERATIONS AND MAINTENANCE $0.15 PAYMENT IN LIEU OF TAXES (PILOT) $0.05 CUSTOMER SERVICE & BILLING $0.03 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PROJECTS FY’26 Budget $35,356,398 City of Charlottesville Utility Rate Report FY 2026 Usage Rate Gas rates are proposed to increase for all natural gas customers. For the average residential gas customer, gas rates are proposed to increase by 4.25%. Impact on the Customer The impact on a customer’s bill will depend on the volume of gas that the customer uses. The average single family household uses 4,600 cubic feet of natural gas per month. The table below shows the monthly impact on gas customers at different amounts of usage. The base rate is set on July 1 st each year. This base rate is calculated using the cost of gas at that time. Gas Used (cf per month) Current Monthly Gas Bill with Most Recent PGA Proposed Monthly Gas Bill with Most Recent PGA $ Change % Change Minimal User 4,000 $56.62 $58.98 2.36 4.16% Average User 4,600 $63.35 $66.04 2.69 4.25% Large User 20,000 $227.47 $238.07 10.60 4.66% High Volume User 60,000 $651.60 $682.55 30.96 4.75% However, gas is purchased throughout the year and the cost per cubic foot of natural gas varies by month due to various factors (weather, economics, etc.) which are hard to predict, as shown below for the past 18 months. The purchased gas adjustment (PGA) acts as a “true up” to account for the differences between the current market cost of gas and the gas cost used to calculate the base rate. This ensures that customers are not over or underpaying and that the City is not over or under collecting. Base Rate Positive PGANegative PGA $54.28 $53.93 $50.01 $50.45 $50.60 $50.76 Average Residential Customer Gas Bill with PGA $51.79 $52.33 $53.97 $54.21$51.85 $62.74 $63.08 $63.68 $64.70 $63.34 Page 69 of 289 Operations Overview Utilities FY2026 The Department of Utilities is committed to providing the Charlottesville community with safe, reliable, and sustainable utility services by dedicated and knowledgeable staff. Core Programs & Services Department-Wide • Utility Location Oversight Protecting infrastructure & critical facilities, including utility locating: 35,071 tickets in 2024. • 24/7/365 Utilities Call Center The Utilities Call Center handles approximately 25,000 calls per year. • Emergency Operations Emergency response to water and gas leaks as well as sewer backups. 1,010 leaks checked in 2024. • GIS Mapping and Maintenance 48,500 feet of utility lines entered and 1,420 CCTV videos cataloged last year.• Customer Service Last year, we processed 6,631 Move-ins and 6,371 Move-outs. • Meter Reading and Maintenance We perfomed 449,889 meter readings including 2,626 implausible meter readings and completed 640 ERT replacements in 2024. • Development Site Plan Review Our engineers reviewed and followed the implementation of 242 site plans and 285 building permits in 2024. • Online Bill Pay Services In October 2021, we launched a new bill pay portal.To date, 7,118 customers have registered for Autopay, and over 15,535 customers receive paperless billing. Customer Satisfaction Experience Interacting with Utilities Department Staff (% Satisfied)* Politeness & courteousness of staff 96% Satisfied & Neutral Overall responsiveness to your request, question or concern 94% Satisfied & Neutral How satisfied you are with the new Utility Billing Online Payment Portal? 98% Satisfied & Neutral *Depar tment of Utilities Customer Satisfaction Survey - SurveyMonkey – April, 2025 Page 70 of 289 Utilities City of Charlottesville 02 Water Distribution & Wastewater Collection Water & Wastewater by numbers 14,800 CUSTOMERS SERVED 4.5 million GALLONS OF WATER PROVIDED DAILY 7,726 WORK ORDERS COMPLETED 179 miles OF WATER MAINS 168 miles OF WASTEWATER MAINS Water Quality & Water Loss Prevention • The quality of our drinking water meets and exceeds all regulatory requirements and expectations for safety and reliability. A water quality report is prepared annually and is available online. • Cross-contamination: - The situation in which water flows in a direction that is opposite from the intended flow is called backflow and presents a serious hazard to our water supply. - The City’s Department of Utilities currently maintains inspection records for 1,100 backflow devices in an effort to protect and provide the highest quality water to the City residents. Granular Activated Carbon (GAC) treatment providing superior quality water to our community. • Annual system-wide leak detection survey: - In 2024, 6 leaks totalling 125,280 GPD were detected and repaired. Water & Wastewater Asset Management • Water main replacement program: - 6,416 linear feet in 2024 and 135,076 linear feet of water lines have been replaced since 2010 (14.3% of the entire water system). - Total construction cost: $33.1 million • Water service line replacement: - 3,935 linear feet in 2024 and 65,118 linear feet of water services have been replaced since 2010 (20.3% of the City-owned water services). • Wastewater main rehabilitation program: - 5,148 linear feet of wastewater lines were rehabilitated or replaced in 2024 and over 381,350 linear feet of main have been rehabilitated or replaced since the program’s inception (43.0% of the wastewater system). - Total construction cost: $41.7 million • Manhole rehabilitation or replacement: - 1,359 manholes have been rehabilitated or replaced since the program’s inception (22.9% of the City’s wastewater manholes). Fats, Oils, and Grease Program • The City of Charlottesville prohibits the discharge of fats, oils, and grease (FOG) down the drain into the City’s wastewater system. - The City of Charlottesville maintains an active FOG program that routinely inspects and advises best management practices to over 300 city food service establishments annually on how to properly dispose of FOG. • We provide FOG Kits to residents to help properly dispose fats, oils, and grease from cooking processes. Page 71 of 289 Utilities City of Charlottesville 03 Customer Satisfaction The vast majority of our customers rated the value of their water and sewer service as fair and above (good and excellent). In our recent Utilities Customer Satisfaction Survey, our customers show high levels of satisfaction with the reliability of our services. 99% Satisfied & Neutral Reliability of your water service 100% Satisfied & Neutral Reliability of your sanitary sewer service 96% Excellent / Good / Fair Rate the value that you pay for your water service 96% Excellent / Good / Fair Rate the value that you pay for your sewer service Stormwater Stormwater Asset Management • Utilities has had an active Stormwater Conveyance System Rehabilitation Program since 2010. • Stormwater rehabilitation program: - 82,093 linear feet rehabilitated or replaced (11.5% of the system since the program’s inception). - Total construction cost: $13.0 million • Structure rehabilitation or replacement: - 533 structures rehabilitated or replaced since the program’s inception (5.4% of the system‘s storm structures). Rate the value that you pay for your stormwater service 87% Excellent / Good / Fair 25% reported that they are not familiar with the utility’s services and unable to rate the value. Page 72 of 289 Utilities City of Charlottesville 04 Gas System Natural Gas by numbers 21,600 CUSTOMERS SERVED 340 miles GAS MAIN LINES 10,782 WORK ORDERS COMPLETED 305 miles GAS SERVICE LINES 36 REGULATOR STATIONS Energy-efficiency programs: The Department of Utilities is excited to launch three new incentives to help improve home energy efficiency. Utilities now offers six home envelope resources that complement each other to help community members improve the energy efficiency of their home, lower utility bills, and increase home comfort. • Attic Insulation Self-Assessment : - According to Energy Star®, 90% of U.S. homes are under-insulated. The Attic Insulation Self- Assessment was developed by Utilities’ staff and is a great resource to help customers better understand their attic’s insulation needs. The self-assessment is 100% free to use, and can be accessed via smartphone, tablet, or computer. • $500 Attic Insulation Rebate: - Maximize the most cost-effective way to improve your home’s energy efficiency with upgraded attic insulation. Gas customers can receive a $500 rebate towards upgrading their home’s attic insulation and take advantage of an available federal tax credit to claim 30% of the cost of the insulation with a maximum of $1,200 credited. Combining these incentives could significantly lower the cost of your insulation upgrade. • $150 Attic Air Sealing Rebate: - For a limited time, gas customers can receive a $150 rebate to cover the cost of measures that plug holes and seal cracks in their attic. This process improves home comfort, enhances air quality, and boosts energy efficiency by keeping conditioned air inside the house. • $125 Smart Thermostat Rebate: - Gas customers can now receive a $125 rebate towards a smart thermostat to enhance the energy efficiency of their home. Smart thermostats use Wi-Fi to allow you to control a home’s indoor air temperature remotely from a smartphone or tablet. Plus, Utilities still offers a $100 Programmable Thermostat Rebate for customers interested in that option. • Home Weatherization Program: - The Charlottesville Gas Energy Efficiency Program (CGEEP) is Utilities’ no-cost home weatherization program for qualified gas customers. Newly expanded income- qualification levels have broadened the reach of this program to even more members of the community, and increased outreach for CGEEP will roll out in the coming months. In our recent Utilities Customer Satisfaction Survey, our customers show high levels of satisfaction with access to gas service, and value of natural gas. How important is it to have gas available to your home? 92% Extremely/ Very/Somewhat Important 96% Excellent / Good / Fair Rate the value that you pay for your natural gas service Page 73 of 289 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Resolution to Allocate Housing Operations and Support ("HOPS") FY 26 Grant Funding for Affordable Housing and Homelessness Support Programs in the Amount of $460,574 Staff Contact(s): Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager, Alexander Ikefuna, Director, Office of Community Solutions Presenter: Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Date of Proposed Action: June 16, 2025 Issue The HOPS Fund provides critical financial support to organizations offering housing stability services, emergency shelter, case management, and homeownership support in the City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City"). City Council is asked to approve a Resolution authorizing the allocation of FY26 HOPS Funds from the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund ("CAHF"), totaling $460,574, to support nonprofit agencies providing housing stability and homelessness-related services. Background / Rule The HOPS Program was created to provide operational support to nonprofit partners addressing affordable housing, housing access, and homelessness prevention in the City. Beginning in FY24, HOPS became a separate funding stream from the Vibrant Community Fund, with awards recommended by the CAHF Committee and reviewed by the City Manager and Executive Team as part of the Annual Budget process. While the $1.5 million HOPS line item is reflected in the adopted FY26 Capital Improvement Plan ("CIP"), the individual agency allocations are not specified. Therefore, a certified Resolution is required to authorize the specific Grant awards formally. This is consistent with past practice and necessary for City Saff to proceed with executing Grant Agreements and distributing funds. Analysis The FY26 HOPS process was conducted through a formal Notice of Funding Availability issued on August 19, 2024, with applications due by October 18, 2024. The CAHF Committee reviewed 16 eligible applications, totaling $1.47 million in requests, and applied an objective scoring rubric that focused on need, service alignment, organizational capacity, and City housing priorities. Following Committee review and Executive Team consideration, a final slate of Grant awards totaling $460,574 is recommended for approval. Additionally, $41,500 in FY26 HOPS funding was previously allocated by the Council on April 21, 2025, via Resolution, to the Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless ("BRACH") for an emergency Supportive Housing Grant. That action reduced the balance available for standard FY26 HOPS Grants. Key funding figures: • Total FY26 HOPS line item (CAHF): $575,000 • Amount previously allocated (BRACH): $41,500 • Recommended allocations in current Resolution: $460,574 • Remaining discretionary balance: $72,926 Page 74 of 289 The allocations reflect a balance between CAHF Committee scoring and Executive Team recommendations, with priority given to Programs that have a direct impact on vulnerable populations (e.g., shelter access, case management, housing stability services). Approval of the attached Resolution is necessary to issue formal award letters and execute Grant Agreements by July 1, 2025. Financial Impact Funding for HOPS is allocated in the FY25/26 CIP Budget. Recommendation City Staff recommends City Council adopt the attached Resolution. This action authorizes the disbursement of $460,574 from the previously approved $1.5 million FY26 CAHF HOPS allocation (Fund 426, Project CP-084). No new appropriations are required. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) “I move to adopt the attached Resolution allocating $460,574 in FY26 HOPS funding from the CAHF to nonprofit partners as outlined in the Resolution, and further move that City Council adopt the Resolution upon first reading, as the allocations align with the programmatic intent and funding commitments previously presented during the FY26 Budget process.” Attachments 1. FinalDraft_Charlottesville HOPS Resolution FY26 2. FinalDraft_Charlottesville HOPS Report FY26 Page 75 of 289 RESOLUTION #R-25-___ Allocating Housing Operations and Support (HOPS) FY26 Grant Funding for Affordable Housing and Homeless Support Programs in the amount of $460,574 WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, having established the Housing Operations & Program Support (HOPS) program to provide financial support for community agency programs aiding in affordable housing and homelessness relief, hereby allocates $460,574 from the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (CAHF) under Fund 426 Project: CP-084, as per the Capital Improvement Program budget for FY2026. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council, having received and reviewed recommendations from the CAHF Committee on the expenditure of CAHF funds for the HOPS program, resolves to allocate the amount to the following HOPS applicants: Fund Project GL Account Applicant Program /Initiative Award 426 CP-084 530670 Albemarle Housing Improvement Program (AHIP) System of Care $22,500 426 CP-084 530670 Community Services Housing, Inc. (CSH) Housing Development Support $43,424 426 CP-084 530670 Georgia’s Friends Georgia’s Friends Recovery Residence & Support Programs for Women $10,000 426 CP-084 530670 Habitat for Humanity of Greater Charlottesville Homeownership Program $52,500 426 CP-084 530670 People and Congregations Engaged in Ministry (PACEM) Case Management Program $50,000 426 CP-084 530670 Piedmont Housing Alliance Charlottesville Affordable Housing Program $92,500 426 CP-084 530670 The Haven at First & Market Inc Day Shelter Program $80,825 426 CP-084 530670 The Haven at First & Market Inc Vital Housing Services Program $108,825 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that all funding awards within this resolution shall be provided as grants to the entities listed under the “Applicant” column above to be used solely for the purposes outlined in their respective grant applications and any subsequent grant agreement. The City Manager is authorized to negotiate and execute funding grant agreements with each recipient to ensure proper utilization of funds. Date Adopted: Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 76 of 289 Charlottesville FY 26 Housing Operations & Program Support ( HOPS) Report March 13, 2025 CAHF Committee Members: Phil d’Oronzio Richard Fravel Misty Graves Taylor Harvey -Ryan S. Lisa Herndon City Staff Liaison: Antoine Williams , Housing Program Manager Page 77 of 289 Contents A. INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................... 1 1. Background ................................................................................................................... 1 2. Operational Funding Review Process .......................................................................... 1 3. Ranking Distribution by Category: .................................................................................. 2 4. The grid below shows how the quality rankings aligned: ................................................. 2 5. City Manager & Executive Review in Budget Process ............................................... 3 B. SUMMARY OF APPLICATION OUTCOMES: Funding Level Recommendations .......... 3 1. Applications Not Recommended for FY26 HOPS Funding ......................................... 4 2. List of Organizations Not Recommended .................................................................... 4 3. List of Organizations Awards -Recommended to Cou ncil ........................................... 6 4. Remaining HOPS Balance for Discretionary Use ....................................................... 6 5. Final Considerations for City Council .......................................................................... 6 C. SUMMARY OF ALL APPLICATIONS ................................................................... 6 1. Albemarle Housing Improvement Program (AHIP) ..................................................... 7 2. Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (BRACH) .............................................. 7 3. Charlottesville Public Housing Association of Residents (PHAR) .............................. 8 4. Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority (CRHA) ................................. 8 5. Community Housing Partners (CHP) ........................................................................... 8 6. Community Services Housing (CSH) ........................................................................... 9 7. Georgia’s Friends ......................................................................................................... 9 8. Habitat for Humanity of Greater Charlottesville .......................................................... 9 9. International Rescue Committee (IRC) .......................................................................10 10. International Rescue Committee (IRC) ................................................................... 10 11. Legal Aid Justice Center (LAJC) .............................................................................11 12. PACEM .....................................................................................................................11 13. Piedmont Housing Alliance (PHA) ..........................................................................12 14. Region Ten Community Services Board (Region Ten) ..........................................12 15. The Haven at First & Market, Inc. (The Haven) .....................................................13 16. The Haven at First & Market, Inc. (The Haven) .....................................................13 Page 78 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report, March XX, 2025 page 1 A. INTRODUCTION 1. Background Starting in FY24, affordable housing -specific applications were removed from the Vibrant Community Fund process and reviewed in a separate process. This affordable -housing -specific application process is now called the Housing Operations & Program Support (HOPS) program. This funding supports the operational needs of non- profit organizations involved in affordable housing and homelessness prevention. The CAHF Committee is tasked with evaluating the applications received through the HOPS application cycle and recommending to the City Council suggested priorities for using CAHF funding. The Committee reviews applications and scores them based on their quality , the importance of the type of service being provided, and alignment with the City’s affordable housing goals . On August 19, 2024, a Notice of Funding Availability (NOFA) was issued, detailing the timeline and funding amount for the HOPS Grant program. The NOFA announced that $575,000 would be available for allocations and awards in FY26 , with the application period set from September 18, 2024, to October 18, 2024. By the submission deadline, staff received 16 applications for funding, totaling $1,472,348 in requests . 2. Operational Funding Review Process The Committee reviewed the applications for quality using an objective rubric that evaluated: • Program details and outcomes, • Understanding of participants, • Strategies used to meet those needs, • Use of best practices, • Evaluation plan and metrics used, • Demonstration of need for the program, • Organizational capacity • Alignment with City priorities, • Staff and Board composition, • Local collaborative efforts, • Engagement of high need and underserved populations, • Program participants' involvement in evaluation and governance, • Proposed outcome and outcomes achieved in the previous year, and • Fiscal stability . Page 79 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 2 Priority is given to programs th at provide essential services to vulnerable populations, including programs targeting individuals experiencing homelessness and programs that positively impact the state of homelessness in the City of Charlottesville. Committee members individually reviewed and rated the applications before coming together as a group. First, they ranked the applications based on how well they aligned with the City’s affordable housing goals, as well as the quality and completeness of ea ch application. These rankings were determined collectively and categorized as follows: Category Definition A Proposals in this category are highly aligned with the committee's funding priorities and are deemed to have significant impact and feasibility. B Proposals in this category have merit but may require additional scrutiny or clarification from applicants before full funding can be justified. C Proposals in this category are either unclear, provide limited benefit or alignment with City's goals, or have significant concerns that raise doubts about their viability. 3. Ranking Distribution by Category: • 7 applications ranked A • 5 applications ranked B • 1 application ranked C Committee members evaluated the applications individually, using a scoring framework and rubric i developed by the Committee to assess the quality of each applicant’s responses and their proposed projects. After discussing each application as a group, the Committee finalized their scores. They then tabulated these scores and addressed any significant discrepancies among the reviewers' evaluations. Ultimately, the Committee calculated an overall score based on the average of the individual scores, with a maximum possible score of 105. • The lowest score received was 78 • The highest score received was 101 4. The grid below shows how the quality rankings aligned: Over 95 points 90-95 points 85-90 points Below 85 points 3 applications 8 applications 4 applications 1 application Page 80 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 3 5. City Manager & Executive Review in Budget Process As part of the City’s broader budget planning process, the City Manager and Executive Team review the CAHF Committee’s funding recommendations in the context of the City’s budgetary frameworks, financial constraints, and strategic funding priorities. This executive -level review ensures that the proposed allocations align with the City’s overall financial strategy and long -term planning. The review process may result in adjustments or recommendations based on the following: • Availability of funds in the City's overall budget, • Intergovernmental agency funding policies, • Competing City priorities across departments, and • Alignment with broader City housing strategies and fiscal policies. This review does not reject the Committee’s evaluation but is a necessary step in balancing housing funding within the City’s overall financial obligations. A key example of this process was the March 13, 2025, Council Budget Work Session, during which the Executive Team provided recommendations to the Council regarding funding levels for HOPS and CAHF allocations. This included: • Excluding intergovernmental and fundamental organizations (e.g., CRHA, BRACH, and PHAR) from competitive HOPS funding eligibility based on financial policy considerations. • Ensuring that final funding recommendations fit within the City’s overall fiscal plan. As is consistent with the City’s funding review process, no funding recommendation is final until formally approved by the City Council. This process allows for additional transparency, oversight, and Council input before final allocations are determined. B. SUMMARY OF APPLICATION OUTCOMES : FUNDING LEVEL RECOMMENDATIONS FOR FY26 HOPS ALLOCATION The Housing Operations & Programs Support (HOPS) fund provides critical financial support to organizations offering housing stability services, emergency shelter, case management, and homeownership support in Charlottesville. For the FY26 funding cycle, the City received $1,472,348 in total funding requests but had $575,000 available for allocation. After thorough evaluation by the CAHF Committee and subsequent review by the City Manager and Executive Team, the City is recommen ding $452,574 in HOPS funding, leaving a remaining balance of $122,426 for discretionary housing initiatives. Page 81 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 4 This funding allocation reflects strategic prioritization of programs that provide direct and immediate benefits to vulnerable populations while also considering broader budget constraints and City policies regarding intergovernmental and fundamental organizations. 1. Applications Not Recommended for FY26 HOPS Funding Despite the high level of demonstrated need, $1,019,774 in requests could not be funded due to budget limitations, eligibility considerations, or prioritization of direct service programs. A. Key Reasons for Non- Funding Decisions 1. Budget Constraints: o The City had $575,000 in available funds, while total requests exceeded $1.47 million —more than double the available budget. o The high demand meant that some programs, even those with merit, could not be supported within the funding limits. 2. Policy Considerations & Eligibility Restrictions: o As part of the March 13, 2025, Executive Review, funding to intergovernmental and fundamental organizations (CRHA, PHAR, and BRACH) was deemed ineligible under competitive HOPS funding. o These agencies provide essential services but were recommended for alternative funding sources outside of the competitive process. 3. Funding Prioritization for Direct Housing & Shelter Services : o Programs that provide immediate housing stability, case management, and emergency shelter services were prioritized over those focusing on system coordination, advocacy, or long -term planning. 2. List of Organizations Not Recommended ($ 605,500 in requests in the table below ) Organization Program Amount Requested Eligibility and Status 1. Charlottesville Redevelopment & Housing Authority (CRHA) Resident Services $75,000 Intergovernmental agency – ineligible for competitive HOPS funding 2. Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (BRACH) System Coordination $27,500 Fundamental organization – ineligible for competitive HOPS funding Page 82 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 5 3. Public Housing Association of Residents (PHAR) Leadership & Civic Engagement $13,950 Fundamental organization – ineligible for competitive HOPS funding 4. Community Housing Partners (CHP) Housing Operations Support $101,500 Eligible for Competitive Grant as General Organization 5. International Rescue Committee (IRC) IRC Charlottesville Rental Assistance Program $35,000 Eligible for Competitive Grant as General Organization 6. International Rescue Committee (IRC) Rental Assistance & Housing Specialist $86,000 Eligible for Competitive Grant as General Organization 7. Legal Aid Justice Center (LAJC) Eviction Prevention Services $100,000 Eligible for Competitive Grant as General Organization 8. Region Ten Community Services Board Region Ten Homelessness Prevention $20,000 Fundamental organization – ineligible for competitive HOPS funding While these organizations are not receiving HOPS funding for FY26, the City recognizes their importance . A. Key Factors in Funding Decisions 1. Direct and Immediate Impact: • Priority was given to programs that provide immediate housing stability services, such as case management, shelter operations, and homeownership assistance. 2. Alignment with City Housing Priorities: • Funded programs align with the City’s Comprehensive Plan and Affordable Housing Strategy, ensuring that HOPS funds support the most impactful housing initiatives. 3. Organizational Capacity and Track Record: • Organizations that demonstrated strong program outcomes, financial sustainability, and ability to scale their services were prioritized for funding. Page 83 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 6 3. List of Organizations Recommended for FY26 HOPS Funding ($458,550) Organization Program Award-Recommended* 9. The Haven Day Shelter Program $80,825 10. The Haven Vital Housing Services $108,825 11. PACEM Case Management $50,000 12. Piedmont Housing Alliance Charlottesville Affordable Housing Program $92,500 13. Georgia’s Friends Georgia’s Friends Recovery Residence & Support Programs for Women $7,976 14. Habitat for Humanity Homeownership Program $52,500 15. Albemarle Housing Improvement Program (AHIP) System of Care $22,500 16. Community Services Housing, Inc. (CSH) Housing Development Support $43,424 Total $458,550 * Award-recommended amounts may be modified after the date of publication of this report. 4. Remaining HOPS Balance for Discretionary Use • After funding allocations, $122,426 remains available in HOPS for the City Manager’s discretionary use on emerging housing needs or emergency interventions. 5. Final Considerations for City Council • High Unmet Demand : 69% of total HOPS requests went unfunded, reflecting the urgent need for additional resources in housing support and homelessness prevention. • Funding Strategy for Future Cycles : The City may consider alternative funding streams or policy adjustments to support eviction prevention, system coordination, and legal aid services, which were not prioritized in this cycle. • Importance of Strategic Oversight : The March 13 Executive Review played a critical role in ensuring that funding allocations aligned with the City’s broader budget constraints, intergovernmental policies, and strategic housing priorities. Page 84 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 7 C. SUMMARY OF ALL APPLICATIONS The following section provides a summary of all operational funding applications submitted for FY26 HOPS consideration. Each summary includes the program name, amount requested, purpose of funding as described by the applicant, committee scoring, and fundin g level recommendations from both the CAHF Committee and the Executive Team. Applications are listed in alphabetical order by organization name . 1. Albemarle Housing Improvement Program (AHIP) Program Name : AHIP’s System of Care Requested Funding : $150,000 Purpose of Requested Funding : HOPS funding directly supports the costs of enrolling city residents into AHIP’s System of Care, which provides pre -construction services by AHIP staff. Funding will allow AHIP staff to assist clients in crisis by providing resources and recourse for critical housing repair. Committee Ranking/Scoring: 91 Funding Level Recommendation : • Executive Team Funding Level: $22,500 (15%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $22,500 (15%) • Difference: $0 2. Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (BRACH) Program Name : Homeless System of Care Coordination Requested Funding : $55,000 Purpose of Requested Funding: The requested funding will support BRACH in maintaining its staffing capacity to improve system coordination within the homelessness Continuum of Care and address emergent, critical needs for unsheltered people. The current staff includes one executive director and an administrative coordinator, who was hired in February 2024 with the support of the FY2024 -25 HOPS award. This additional capacity translates to long overdue support for the Executive Director as BRACH works to implement new and innovative partnerships for housing, long -term planning, much -needed outreach on the Downtown Mall and beyond, and collaborative program applications that address large -scale needs that will eventually poise BRACH to make homelessness rare, brief, and non -recurring in our community. Committee Ranking/Scoring: 94 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $0 (0%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $27,500 (50%) • Difference: -$27,500 • Note: Marked ineligible on March 13 as a fundamental organization. Page 85 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 8 3. Charlottesville Public Housing Association of Residents (PHAR) Program Name : Leadership Development and Civic Engagement Requested Funding : $93,000 Purpose of Requested Funding : The requested funding will support the continuation and expansion of the PHAR Internship Program by covering personnel costs, program materials and supplies, transportation, and the alumni program. This will enable PHAR to expand the internship program, launch the youth leadership program, and develop an internship alumni program. Committee Ranking/Scoring : 91 Funding Level Recommendation : • Executive Team Funding Level: $0 (0%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $13,950 (15%) • Difference: -$13,950 • Note: Marked ineligible on March 13 as a fundamental organization. 4. Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority (CRHA) Program Name : CRHA Resident Services Requested Funding : $150,000 Purpose of Requested Funding : CRHA is requesting funds to help support our Resident Services department. These funds will go toward supporting our Resident Service Coordinators (RSCs) , who provide on -site case management, connect residents to supportive services, work with Property Managers to divert evictions, and act as wraparound support as residents pursue personal and professional goals. Committee Ranking/Scoring : 95 Funding Level Recommendation : • Executive Team Funding Level: $0 (0%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $75,000 (50%) • Difference: -$75,000 • Note: Marked ineligible on March 13 as an intergovernmental organization. 5. Community Housing Partners (CHP) Program Name: CRHA Resident Services Requested Funding: $101,500 Purpose of Requested Funding : CHP is requesting funding for a one-year full- time Housing Stability Coordinator to assist affected residents who continue to struggle financially. This special project provides not only a dedicated staff person but also dollars to assist vulnerable residents in becoming lease compliant . Page 86 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 9 Committee Ranking/Scoring: 78 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $0 (0%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $0 (0%) • Difference: $0 6. Community Services Housing (CSH) Program Name: Community Services Housing Requested Funding: $86,848 Purpose of Requested Funding: The requested funding is to develop, own, and operate clean, safe, affordable housing for people with disabilities and extremely low incomes in Charlottesville. Committee Ranking/Scoring: 94 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $43,424 (50%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $43,424 (50%) • Difference: $0 7. Georgia’s Friends Program Name: Georgia’s Friends Recovery Residence & Support Programs for Women Requested Funding: $10,000 Purpose of Requested Funding: Georgia's Friends is seeking funds to sustain general operations that support residence life and programs at Georgia’s House, the sober -living home we operate at 405 Ridge Street in Charlottesville. Continued support will help underwrite annual costs , which are approximately $18,000 per resident per year. Funds would also be used to support our structured program that supports women in the early stages of recovery from substance use disorders. The funding will help underwrite a nnual costs, which are projected to be ~$360,000 in the City’s FY25. Committee Ranking/Scoring: 92 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $7,976 (80%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $7,976 (80%) • Difference: $0 8. Habitat for Humanity of Greater Charlottesville Program Name : Habitat for Humanity of Greater Charlottesville Homeownership Program Requested Funding : $75,000 Page 87 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 10 Purpose of Requested Funding : HOPS funds will be used to hire an additional financial empowerment coach who will work directly with these newly approved homebuyers in the Core (Non -Southwood) and Pathways programs. In addition, funds will support staff providing expanded pre -application financial coaching services for residents living in both the Carlton Mobile Home Park and the Southwood Mobile Home Park. These services include comprehensive financial assessments, loan pre -qualification, financial coaching , and application support (for a Habitat home or a home on the market). Committee Ranking/Scoring: 98 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $52,500 (70%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $52,500 (70%) • Difference: $0 9. International Rescue Committee (IRC) Program Name : IRC Charlottesville Rental Assistance Program Requested Funding : $35,000 Purpose of Requested Funding: The Charlottesville Rental Assistance Program, which this proposal is designed to fund, is structured so that clients will contribute income from employment and 70% of their TANF towards their rent, submitting payment directly to their landlord. IRC Charlo ttesville will contribute the balance for one month if funds are available. This process will be repeated for another month if necessary; however, it is with clear understanding that it is the family’s responsibility to undert ake full accountability as soon as possible. For those IRC clients who qualify for Intensive Case Management (ICM) or Supplemental Case Management (SCM) services, this program may support portions of their rent for an average of four months, depending on t he level of vulnerability and assessment guidelines. Committee Ranking/Scoring : 85 Funding Level Recommendation : • Executive Team Funding Level: $0 (0%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $0 (0%) • Difference: $0 10. International Rescue Committee (IRC) Program Name : IRC Housing Specialist and Financial Coach Position Requested Funding : $51,000 Purpose of Requested Funding: This funding would be used to fund a .5FTE staff position for a Housing Specialist and a .25FTE for a Financial Coach to serve clients the IRC is resettling in the Charlottesville community. These roles are key in performing multiple functions, including apartment search, landlord outreach, payment of client initial rent and security deposit, Page 88 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 11 furniture procurement, utilities set up, and client education on financial literacy. This all leads to the coordination and execution of moving clients to their first apartment. Over the past 26 years, there has always been a challenge in finding housing o pportunities for our clients who come with no U.S. rental history, employment history, and no credit. The Housing Specialist is continually working on building new landlord relationships and maintaining existing ones, who waive or minimize these normal req uirements. Over the past few years, the affordable housing market has become exponentially more challenging, making the roles of the Housing Specialist and Financial Coach that much more important. Committee Ranking/Scoring: 89 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $0 (0%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $0 (0%) • Difference: $0 11. Legal Aid Justice Center (LAJC) Program Name : Legal Services to Prevent Evictions and Ensure Housing Stability Requested Funding : $100,000 Purpose of Requested Funding: Legal Services to Prevent Evictions and Ensure Housing Stability will provide free legal services , including tenancy rights information, service navigation, legal advice, and legal representation to low -income , elderly, and disabled residents in the City of Charlottesville. The program will provide a full range of services to eligible clients to prevent unlawful evictions and preserve safe and affordable housing. The goal of this program is to prevent homelessn ess through legal representation. This program aligns with Charlottesville's Affordable Housing Plan to "Design, fund, and implement a legal services program for residents facing eviction." Committee Ranking/Scoring: 88 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $0 (0%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $0 (0%) • Difference: $0 12. PACEM Program Name: PACEM Case Management Requested Funding: $100,000 Purpose of Requested Funding: A cornerstone of our success is housing -focused case management, equipping guests with the knowledge and support necessary to transition from our shelter to permanent, stable housing. The core of our approach lies in our capacity to collaborate with both secular and nonsecular organizations, forging partnerships that provide critical support to those most in need. Committee Ranking/Scoring: 95 Page 89 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 12 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $50,000 (50%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $50,000 (50%) • Difference: $0 13. Piedmont Housing Alliance (PHA) Program Name : Charlottesville Affordable Housing Program Requested Funding : $185,000 Purpose of Requested Funding : Funding will support essential frontline staff who play a crucial role in directly engaging with and providing vital resources to Charlottesville’s most vulnerable and resilient low -income families. These efforts aim to stabilize household finances, impr ove overall quality of life, and strengthen the fabric of our community. We are deeply committed to approaching this work through a Justice, Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion (JEDI) lens, ensuring that equity and inclusivity are embedded in every aspect of our operations. Committee Ranking/Scoring: 95 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $92,500 (50%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $92,500 (50%) • Difference: $0 14. Region Ten Community Services Board (Region Ten) Program Name : Region Ten Homelessness Prevention Requested Funding : $20,000 Purpose of Requested Funding : The Region Ten Homelessness Prevention program would assist individuals with paying rent and/or utility arrear payments; damage mitigation, allowing for a second security deposit and damages that go beyond the scope of the typical security deposit funds; identification and DMV fees, which are often a barrier to applications; utility deposits; application fees for lease and other rental agreements; cleaning services; and cleaning supplies. Committee Ranking/Scoring : 87 Funding Level Recommendation : • Executive Team Funding Level: $0 (0%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $0 (0%) • Difference: $0 Page 90 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 13 15. The Haven at First & Market, Inc. (The Haven) Program Name : Day Shelter Program Requested Funding : $110,000 Purpose of Requested Funding : While our Rapid Re -Housing and Homeless Prevention programs are federally funded, The Haven’s Day Shelter relies on private funding. Funding ensures that every single human being who enters the Day Shelter has access to the basic care and respite service s to meet their daily human needs at no cost to themselves while also simply being able to exist in a safe, secure, climate -controlled, welcoming, and nonjudgmental space. As demand for The Haven’s Day Shelter services has incre ased, costs to provide those services have grown. We continue to experience near-record -high rates of inflation in a community with an already abnormally high cost of living; funding support will help ensure ongoing competitive compensation for the demands and performance expectations of the Day Shelter team, who engage every day and most closely with our community’s most vulnerable members. Committee Ranking/Scoring : 101 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $80,825 (73%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $80,825 (73%) • Difference: $0 16. The Haven at First & Market, Inc. (The Haven) Program Name : Vital Housing Services Requested Funding : $150,000 Purpose of Requested Funding : Funding from HOPS for The Haven’s Vital Housing Services will be used to support the salaries of Housing Team staff, who administer financial support (rental subsidies, first month’s rent, etc.) and provide housing navigation and stabilization services f or program beneficiaries with efficiency, compassion, and trauma -informed care. In order to operate our Vital Housing Services, The Haven also requests support for functions crucial to the operation of our Housing Services , such as: Coordinated Entry System operation and staff who ensure equitable access and enrollment into housing programs; Homeless Management Information System (HMIS) administration to ensure accurate data reporting; website administration to facilitate increas ed transparency regarding our Housing Department policies, procedures, and data; and/or IT support to address the hardware and software needs of our Housing Department, including telecommunications. Committee Ranking/Scoring : 101 Funding Level Recommendation: • Executive Team Funding Level: $108,825 (72.6%) • CAHF Committee Funding Level: $108,825 (72.6%) • Difference: $0 End of Report Page 91 of 289 FY26 HOPS Report page 14 The city remains committed to expanding housing stability efforts and will continue working with stakeholders to strengthen support systems for Charlottesville residents. • Point of Contact : Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager , Office of Community Solutions , williamsan@charlottesville.gov (434) 970 -3513 Page 92 of 289 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Resolution Authorizing Hospital to Home to Operate as a Non- Emergency Medical Transport Agency in Charlottesville Staff Contact(s): Michael Thomas, Fire Chief Presenter: Michael Thomas, Fire Chief Date of Proposed Action: June 16, 2025 Issue Resolution Authorizing Hospital to Home ("H2H") to Operate as a Non-Emergency Medical Transport Agency in Charlottesville Background / Rule Virginia Code § 32.1-111.14 authorizes a local governing body to grant permits to medical services agencies to operate within its jurisdiction. Analysis H2H is a private ambulance transport service providing a non-emergency patient transport service. H2H is not authorized to respond to calls for emergency 911 services from the general public within the City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City"), unless requested by an authorized official from the Charlottesville Fire Department or through a written agreement with the City. Financial Impact None. Recommendation City Staff recommends City Council adopt the attached Resolution. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) "I move to adopt the attached Resolution authorizing H2H to operate as a non-emergency medical transport agency in the City." Attachments 1. RES_Hospital2Home Page 93 of 289 RESOLUTION #R-25-___ GRANTING APPROVAL FOR HOSPITAL TO HOME, LLC, D/B/A H2H EMERGENCY SERVICES, A PRIVATE EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES AGENCY, TO PROVIDE CERTAIN MEDICAL TRANSPORT SERVICES WITHIN THE CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA. WHEREAS Hospital to Home, LLC, d/b/a H2H Emergency Services (hereinafter “H2H”) a Virginia limited liability company, is an Emergency Medical Services Agency licensed by the Virginia Department of Health to provide Ground Ambulance – ALS and Ground Ambulance – BLS services in the Commonwealth of Virginia; and WHEREAS Virginia Code § 32.1-111.14 authorizes a local governing body to grant permits to medical services agencies to operate within its jurisdiction; and WHEREAS H2H is requesting approval to establish and operate a non-emergency ambulance transport service in the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, in compliance with requirements by the Virginia Department of Health, Office of Emergency Medical Services (hereinafter “OEMS”) pursuant to Virginia Administrative Code regulation 12VACS5-31-420, which requires that any applicant for licensure by the OEMS submit with its application an ordinance or resolution confirming the approval of the governing body of each locality where the agency maintains an office or stations an EMS vehicle for response; and WHEREAS H2H has requested and the City of Charlottesville grants approval for a period of two years for H2H to operate from its location at 1 Morton Drive. Suite 506, Charlottesville, Virginia 22903; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville that: 1. H2H is hereby granted local approval to provide routine non-emergency transportation of hospital discharges, other stretcher-based non-emergency EMS transports and non-emergency inter- facility transportation. 2. H2H will obtain all necessary license approvals from the OEMS prior to providing any non- emergency transport services within the jurisdictional boundaries of the City of Charlottesville and will remain in compliance with all applicable operational and inspection requirements while proving such services. 3. H2H is not authorized to respond to calls for emergency 911 services from the general public within the City of Charlottesville unless requested by an authorized official from the Charlottesville Fire Department or through a written agreement with the City of Charlottesville. 4. H2H shall timely pay all federal, state and local taxes, shall obey all applicable federal, state and local laws and regulations, and shall keep its transport vehicles and medical equipment in a safe, neat, well-maintained and sanity condition. 5. Nothing in this Resolution shall be deemed to recognize H2H as an integral or essential part of the official public safety program of the City of Charlottesville. Date Adopted: Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 94 of 289 City Manager’s Report City Departments 6-16-2025 Page 95 of 289 City Manager – Sam Sanders (he/him) • The City workforce is completing annual performance evaluations as we close out Fiscal Year 2025. It is imperative that all staff know where they stand with the City as employees whose efforts impact lives daily. All staff are expected to receive evaluations. • The City’s LEADTeam is working to prepare Work Plans for Fiscal Year 2026 that outline their planning efforts for the new fiscal year. This tool is one that helps to connect the work efforts of frontline staff to directors to executives to the City Council. By planning our work, we have the ability to shift to working our plans with the arrival of a new budget year. • June 5-6: o Met with finalists for the City’s critical role of Emergency Management Coordinator. Four well-qualified individuals were interviewed by me and two panels. A new team member will be announced by the end of the month. • June 6: o I interviewed with Dan Schutte at the CBS19 studio to talk about the return of fireworks to the City; This year fireworks from the top of Carter Mountain will return as C’ville Spectacular. This community event is made possible through sponsorships from the City, County, and university. It is a free event, so find your spot and tune in to CBS19 for live event audio. • June 10-15: o Attended the Congress for New Urbanism in Providence, Rhode Island. This annual convening is a great opportunity to learn from peers how they are addressing and overcoming issues to achieve the highest quality of life for all of their communities. A series of tours, roundtable discussions, and larger gatherings provided insights on creative peacemaking, community brand, planning & zoning opportunities, and public service innovations. Deputy City Manager for Social Equity – Ashley Reynolds Marshall (she/her) • Conference Attendance: I attended the first National Economic Mobility & Opportunity Conference hosted by the International City/County Management Association, the National League of Cities, and other philanthropic organizations. Mr. Keith Grooms from the Office of Economic Development also attended to represent the City of Charlottesville. • Speaking Engagement: In May 2025, I was invited by the Office of Economic Development to speak at the Central Virginia Small Business Development Center's Piedmont Accent event, which is a half-day business conference for small business owners and entrepreneurs at every stage. The session's other panelists were Chef Antwon Brinson and David Corbin. Page 96 of 289 Deputy City Manager for Operations – James Freas (he/him) • Attended the May 15 Regional Environmental Coordination Meeting alongside staff from the Office of Sustainability. • D eputy City Manager (DCM) Marshall, the Director of Parks & Recreation, and I met with a UVa representative to discuss how we can collaborate on plans for Riverview Park. • Participated in the May 21 quarterly meeting of the Fifeville Neighborhood Anti- Displacement Working Group. • Along with the City Manager, I enjoyed lunch with the Public Works team on May 22 at their department cookout. • Represented the City Manager’s Office at the Continuity of Operations Plan (COOP) Workshop on May 29, organized by the Office of Emergency Management. Representatives of departments throughout the City gathered to continue drafting department-level plans. Parks & Recreation – Director Riaan Anthony (he/him) • Registration for the 2025 City Amateur Championship on June 28-29 is open. Players can register online at: 2025 City Amateur Golf Championship (link). • Meadowcreek Golf Course is now a participant with the national organization Youth on Course which provides discounted rates to youth under 18 to play the golf course for just $5. More information about Youth on Course and how to join is located online at: Youth on Course | It's All About Access (link). • All outdoor pools and splash pads are open for the season! • The City Swordfish swim team is still open for registration (link). We had 170 participants registered at the end of May. Tryouts are still taking place, and there is enough space for about 15 more swimmers. • Summer Camp staff training week began June 9. Camp Week One begins June 16 and will run for six weeks (through July 25) at Summit and Johnson Elementary Schools. • June Special Events: o June 20 from 7:30 AM to 10:30 PM is Play All Day VA. Charlottesville Parks & Recreation will be hosting multiple free events all day long! • City Market: o The City Market partnered with Neighborhood Development Services (NDS) to promote Bike Month. On the last Saturday in May, riders of all ages met at the City Market to go on a group bike ride. o With all of the fresh fruits and veggies in season, be sure to pick up one of The City Market's cookbooks. Be inspired by delicious dishes shared by some very familiar faces! Copies of the City Market Cookbook can be Page 97 of 289 purchased at any recreation center location, at The City Market information table on Saturday, or by contacting Justin McKenzie at mckenziej@charlottesville.gov. Utilities – Director Lauren Hildebrand (she/her) • The Charlottesville Department of Utilities continues its ongoing replacement of outdated infrastructure throughout the City’s water distribution system with the Locust Avenue Water Line Replacement Project, scheduled to break ground this month. The water main along Locust Avenue was installed in the 1920s, and due to its age, has experienced a steady increase in breaks and leaks over the past decade. This replacement project will improve service by bringing the water system in the area up to current industry standards, significantly enhance system reliability, and reduce the risk of future service disruptions. • Utilities held an open house for the project on June 10, inviting the community to learn more about the project, understand what to expect during construction, and to ask questions. Attendees were able to speak with representatives from the Department of Utilities, the City’s Traffic Engineer, the engineering firm Whitman, Requardt & Associates, LLP, and the contracting company Southeast Connections, LLC. Utilities communicated the upcoming work and open house through several social media posts, via a news story on NBC29, and by sending over 400 letters to residents who may be directly impacted by the replacement. o The Department of Utilities is committed to providing first-rate utility services. The Locust Avenue Water Line Replacement Project will strengthen the long-term sustainability, resiliency, and efficiency of the water distribution system for all of Charlottesville and will help ensure the community continues to receive reliable, high-quality water. o Updates on the project’s progress, and other relevant information, will be available at www.charlottesville.gov/utilitiesCIP (link) . Neighborhood Development Services – Director Kellie Brown (she/her) • Short Term Rentals (STR): o STR outreach is underway, including a targeted engagement effort via postcards, City newsletters, and neighborhood associations. o Application deadline: June 1, 2025, with a $100 late fee applied after 14 days. o A public survey was launched to gather feedback on STR policies (95 responses have been received at this time).  Survey link: https://forms.office.com/g/xnGGyLE7Ui o STR Info page: https://charlottesville.gov/1894/Homestay-Short-Term- Rental-FAQ Page 98 of 289 • Procurement for the Granicus compliance software has been finalized. • Staff Update: o Victoria “Tori” Kanellopoulos was introduced as the City’s new Long- Range Planner. She joins from Albemarle County with significant experience in long-range and strategic planning, including work on the County's Comprehensive Plan. o A Planning Intern joined the team for the summer to support various initiatives, including development of neighborhood fact sheets and assisting with existing conditions analysis and engagement for the 10th & Page and Rose Hill Vision Plans. Human Services – Director Misty Graves (she/her) • In an effort to promote safety and connection for teens in Charlottesville, the Department of Human Services and Parks and Recreation hosted its first Teen Takeover event this summer on May 31. It included free skating with food trucks and entertainment at Carver Recreation Center. Over 25 youth participated, and partners supported the event to help ensure it was safe and successful. The next event will take place on Sunday, June 29 from 3 - 6 PM at Washington Park with field day games, arts and crafts, and more entertainment. For more information follow on Facebook at: Charlottesville Area Youth Opportunity Coordination. There will be more events for teens to come! • Our community-based Services launched a week-long training to onboard eight summer staff. These dedicated staff will work alongside youth enrolled in the Community Attention Youth Internship Program (CAYIP) and the Teens GIVE Service-Learning Program. This summer, we anticipate hosting 150 interns with CAYIP and 25 youth with Teens GIVE. We look forward to cultivating excitement and passion for working with youth! Charlottesville Fire Department – Chief Michael Thomas (he/him) • The Insurance Services Office (ISO) score has been reviewed and returned. Charlottesville will remain an ISO 1. This is a huge lift for Water, Charlottesville- UVa-Albemarle Emergency Communications Center (CUA ECC), and the Charlottesville Fire Department (CFD). • Captain Butler completed the Virginia Fire Marshal Basic Law Enforcement Academy (14 weeks of law enforcement training) • The new Bypass Fire Station – Station #1 – CFD is planning an open house. The date is still TBD. Page 99 of 289 Key Operations Metrics: • Comparing the first 11 months of FY25 to the same period in FY24, CFD incidents are up by 3% across all categories. • Fire incidents increased by 24%, EMS incidents decreased by 6%, and all other types of incidents increased by 22%. Cooking fires increased by 78% in the first 11 months of 2025 compared to 2024. • On average, CFD has run about 374 EMS incidents, 15 fire incidents, and 203 other types of incidents each month in the last year. Comparing those monthly averages to the year before, EMS incidents slightly decreased. Fire and all other incident types increased. Page 100 of 289 Opioid Overdoses: • Opioid overdoses in the City decreased in 2025. CFD and Charlottesville- Albemarle Rescue Squad (CARS) have run an average of about four overdoses monthly in 2025, a decrease from 2024’s average of six overdoses monthly. • Unhoused EMS Patients: o CFD and CARS added a new field to patient care reports to track emergency medical responses to unhoused patients in June 2024. Our records show that over the last year, CFD & CARS have responded to 38 unhoused patients monthly on average. o The top three findings of attendants in charge on these incidents were non-traumatic pain (18% of calls), alcohol abuse (13% of calls), and bodily injuries (12% of calls). • Inspections (Year to Date): o 530 inspections (275 different businesses) in total. o 63 permits have been issued. o 160 third-party inspections with the Inspection Reports Online (IROL) system. o Engineering and Planning Bureau – CFD has seen an increase in plans reviewed and inspections for new construction since increasing staffing to a full-time Battalion Chief in January 2025. o 61 site plans reviewed. o 19 sprinkler plans reviewed. o 8 fire alarm plans reviewed (new to CFD for 2025). o 51 inspections (construction sites, sprinkler systems, fire alarm systems). • Investigations/Fires: o Lithium battery fire at Locust Lane o Lithium battery fire at Maury Avenue • The Fire Marshal’s Office (FMO) is working with the Communications & Public Engagement Office to send out a safety message this week about lithium-ion battery safety. Page 101 of 289 Charlottesville Area Transit – Director Garland Williams (he/him) • On May 29, two Charlottesville Area Transit (CAT) employees, Evelyn Trice and Janice Woodson, received the Helen Poore Transit Professional Distinguished Service Award from the Virginia Transit Association (VTA). • The Transit Professional Distinguished Service Award is named after Helen Poore, an outstanding transit manager of Charlottesville Transit from 1973-2003. She achieved national recognition as the first female Transit Manager and was a founding member of the VTA. This award is presented annually to transit professionals who, over the course of their career, have made outstanding contributions to public transportation in their locality and in the Commonwealth of Virginia. • Mrs. Evelyn Trice - For over 34 years, “Miss Trice” has been a driving force behind public transportation in Charlottesville. Beginning her career as a School Bus Operator, she transitioned to Charlottesville Transit Service (CTS), presently known as Charlottesville Area Transit (CAT), where she worked her way up from Dispatcher to Safety, Security, and Training Coordinator. Evelyn has played a vital role in ensuring operator and passenger safety, implementing federal and state training programs, and mentoring the next generation of transit professionals. • Mrs. Janice Woodson - For 33 years, Janice Woodson has been an unsung hero working behind the scenes. Janice started as an Account Clerk and continued to advance into her current role as Senior Accountant, handling (operating and capital) budgets, compliance issues, and financial operations that keep CAT on track. She is the backbone of CAT’s daily operations, ensuring that maintenance, operations, and administration always have the supplies, purchase orders, and resources they need. Without her meticulous coordination, CAT’s ability to function would be severely hindered. • Evelyn and Janice were both hired by Helen Poore and are the first CAT employees to receive the VTA distinguished service award. Page 102 of 289 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: June 16, 2025 Action Required: The Human Rights Commission ("HRC") and Office of Human Rights ("OHR") will present a summary of the Calendar Year 2024 Annual Report. Presenter: Todd Niemeier, Director of Human Rights Staff Contacts: Todd Niemeier, Director of Human Rights Title: Human Rights Calendar Year 2024 Annual Report Background Per the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance ("Ordinance"), City Sec. 2-432.(i), HRC shall make quarterly reports to the City Council concerning HRC operations and the status of HRC's performance of the duties, responsibilities, and roles set forth within the Ordinance. One (1) of the required quarterly reports shall be an Annual Report. Per City Code Sec. 2-441, HRC shall make an annual comprehensive report to City Council that outlines its efforts during the preceding year in the areas of identifying and addressing systemic or institutional discrimination; processing individual complaints of unlawful discrimination; and facilitating a community dialogue regarding issues of human rights. Said Annual Report shall also outline the HRC's Work Plan for the ensuing year, which shall be subject to approval or modification by City Council. Discussion The Calendar Year 2024 HRC and OHR Annual Report presents a summary and analysis of the work completed by both bodies during Calendar Year 2024. The accompanying Presentation to City Council will include significant takeaways from the Annual Report, along with a summary of HRC's Work Plan for the March 2025 – February 2026 work period. Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan HRC and OHR 's work aligns with City Council's vision for Charlottesville to be a place where everyone thrives by supporting the City's commitment to implementing equitable practices and policies across all of its activities through enforcement of the Ordinance. Community Engagement An early version of the Annual Report presentation was delivered during HRC' s Annual Planning Meeting on March 22, 2025. The final written Annual Report will be shared with the HRC in the Agenda Packet for the Regular Meeting on May 15, 2025. The written Annual Report will also be posted on HRC's web page on the City website. Page 103 of 289 Budgetary Impact This is an Annual Report of past work, and includes no new proposed financial impacts for FY26. Recommendation The Human Rights Commission and Office of Human Rights recommend that City Council receive the report and consider the information presented when evaluating its requests from either body in the coming year. Alternatives No alternative recommendations are suggested. Attachments 1. CY2024 HRC and OHR Annual Report (PDF) 2. CY2024 Annual Report Presentation - Council (PDF) Page 104 of 289 2024 Annual Report Human Rights Commission & Office of Human Rights Page 105 of 289 Table of Contents Report Sections and Subsections Page 1. Introduction 1 1.1. Report Structure 2 1.2. HRC Overview 3 1.3. OHR Overview 5 2. Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (a) – Individual Assistance 7 2.1. Sec. 2-433. (a) HRC Actions 7 2.2. Sec. 2-433. (a) OHR Actions 7 2.2.1. Total Incoming Contacts 8 2.2.2. Total Inquiries and Complaints by Location 11 2.2.3. Total Inquiries and Complaints by Protected Activity 12 2.2.4. Total Combined Inquiries and Complaints by Protected Class 13 2.2.5. Total Complaints by Protected Activity and Protected Class 14 2.2.6. Services Provided Through Individual Contacts 15 2.2.7. Navigation & Advocacy 16 2.2.8. Referrals to Other Services 18 2.2.9. Status of Complaints During the Calendar Year 21 3. Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (b) – Awareness and Guidance 24 3.1. Sec. 2-433. (b) HRC Actions 24 3.2. Sec. 2-433. (b) OHR Actions 28 3.2.1. OHR Community Outreach Activities by Outreach Type 29 3.2.2. Collaborative Activities and Engaged Partner Agencies 31 4. Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (c) – City Policies 33 5. Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (d) – Federal Workshares 35 5.1. Sec. 2-433. (d) HRC Actions 35 5.2. Sec. 2-433. (d) OHR Actions 35 6. Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (e) – Legislative Program 39 7. Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (f) – Commission Policies 40 8. Observations and Opportunities 41 8.1. HRC Observations and Opportunities 41 8.2. OHR Observations and Opportunities 43 9. Attachments 49 9.1. OHR CY2024 Data Dictionary 49 9.2. OHR CY2024 Individual Service Data 56 9.3. OHR CY2024 Community Outreach Data 63 9.4. HRC Recommendations for Housing Policies 64 9.5. HRC Recommendations for Effective Right to Counsel 66 9.6. HRC Recommendations for City Council’s 2025 Legislative Agenda 68 Page 106 of 289 1 1. Introduction This report will present the goals and strategies identified by the Human Rights Commission and show how the actions taken by the Human Rights Commission and Office of Human Rights in calendar year 2024 (CY2024) align with the roles and responsibilities specified in the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance (Code of the City of Charlottesville Chapter 2, Article XV). The Charlottesville Human Rights Commission (HRC), in partnership with the Office of Human Rights (OHR), acts as a strong advocate for justice and equal opportunity by providing citywide leadership and guidance in the area of civil rights. The Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance (CHRO) outlines the roles, duties, and responsibilities of the HRC and the OHR. Per Sec. 2-433 of the CHRO, it is the role of the HRC and OHR to: a) Assist individuals who believe they are the victim of an act of unlawful discrimination within the jurisdiction of the City; b) Collaborate with the public and private sectors for the purpose of providing awareness, education, and guidance on methods to prevent and eliminate discrimination citywide; c) Identify and review policies and practices of the City of Charlottesville and its boards, commissions, and other public agencies within the City and advise those bodies on issues related to human rights; d) Seek a Fair Employment Practices Agency (FEPA) workshare agreement with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and a Fair Housing Assistance Program (FHAP) workshare agreement with the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to conduct investigations of employment and housing discrimination on their behalf and enter into such agreement(s) subject to approval of City Council upon a finding that the agreement(s) would be in the best interest of the City; e) Make recommendations regarding the City’s annual legislative program, with an emphasis on enabling legislation that may be needed to implement programs and policies that will address discrimination; and f) Prepare recommendations to City Council as to policies and procedures the Commission believes are necessary for the performance of the roles, duties and responsibilities assigned to the Commission within this article, and for modifications of operating procedures approved by City Council. As required by Sec. 2-441 of the CHRO, the following report provides details of the work of the HRC and OHR during CY2024. Page 107 of 289 2 1.1. Report Structure Report section 1. Introduction provides a summary of the duties of the HRC and OHR along with information about the organizational structure and strategies that provided a framework for the work carried out by each body during the year. Report sections 2. through 7. make up the main body of the report. These sections are organized to align with each role of the Human Rights Commission as listed in Sec. 2-433. (a-f) of the CHRO. Some sections of the report will feature work from both the HRC and OHR, while other sections will feature the work of only one body. The CHRO was amended on August 5, 2024. As part of the amendments, duties and responsibilities of the Commission that existed in other sections (previously Sec. 2-434. Duties and Responsibilities – Community Dialogue and Engagement and Sec. 2-435 Duties and Responsibilities – Systemic issues) were incorporated into Sec. 2-433 as subsections. This realignment of the CHRO is reflected in this report. Report section 8. Observations and Opportunities includes a review of any trends in the data and information presented in the main body of the report coupled with any key takeaways about organizational structure and function that may impact the work of the HRC and OHR going forward. Report section 9. Attachments contains documents referenced in the main body of the report, including 9.1. OHR CY2024 Data Dictionary, which defines many of the technical terms used when describing the work of the HRC and OHR. The HRC and OHR are committed to improving accessibility to information about their work. This report has been made accessible for people who are visually impaired, and it uses plain language as often as possible to ensure its contents are understandable. Alternative text is included for graphs, charts, and some tables that may not be accessible for those who are visually impaired. Upon request, the OHR can provide additional information or clarification for graphics that are found to not be optimally accessible. City Councilors and members of the public are encouraged to contact OHR staff with any questions about the contents of the report or for more information about the services provided by the HRC and OHR. Staff Contact: Todd Niemeier, Director, Human Rights Commission Phone: 434-970-3027 Email: niemeier@charlottesville.gov OHR Webpage: www.charlottesville.gov/665/Human-Rights HRC Webpage: www.charlottesville.gov/963/Human-Rights-Commission Page 108 of 289 3 1.2. HRC Overview The HRC is a nine-member, volunteer body appointed by City Council to advise Council on human and civil rights issues. It also serves as an administrative public hearing body for complaints of unlawful discrimination investigated by the OHR. Each January, the HRC holds officer elections. In January 2024, the HRC elected Ernest Chambers as Chair and Wolfgang Keppley as Vice Chair. Each year, outgoing Commissioners finish their terms at the end of February and new Commissioners start their terms in March, unless a new Commissioner is appointed to fulfill an unfinished term for someone who departed early. In March 2024, two new Commissioners joined the HRC, replacing two whose terms had ended. In September 2024, the HRC welcomed three new Commissioners, who replaced three who departed early. The HRC’s work year runs from March through February to align with the start of new Commissioners’ terms. Each March, the Commissioners attend a meeting to choose focus areas and plan their work for the next year. This year's annual planning meeting was held on March 9th. During the planning meeting, Commissioners identified the following focus areas: Primary Focus Area(s): 1. Housing a. Homelessness i. City policies 1. Shelter 2. Wraparound services ii. Expert panel and fact gathering to determine current trends b. Systemic Barriers i. Restrictive housing access policies based on criminal records ii. Excessive rental costs iii. Excessive application fees iv. Source of funds 1. Rents for market rate units above HUD voucher payment standards 2. Rental properties in states of disrepair that can’t pass HUD voucher inspections Secondary Focus Area(s): 1. Legislative recommendations a. Removing voter exclusion from state constitution b. Rental application fees c. Rental registry d. Proactive rental inspections e. Legal representation for people facing eviction f. Anything housing related the emerges from primary focus areas g. Amplifying local food justice initiatives 2. Ally/Safe Space training program development – to be considered in 2025 3. Reparations – to be revisited in December a. Public discussion to determine public interest and priorities of impacted communities Page 109 of 289 4 Based on the focus areas above, the HRC set the following goals for March 2024 – February 2025. These goals will be referenced in each section of the report that corresponds with their alignment to the Human Rights Ordinance. Goals Human Rights Ordinance Alignment 1. Adopt an amended draft of the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance for presentation to City Council by June 2024. • Sec. 2-433. (a) Individual Assistance • Sec. 2-433. (d) Federal Workshares • Sec. 2-433. (f) Commission Policies • Sec. 2-439.1. Enforcement Authority 2. Complete public hearing training following the adoption of the revised Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance. • Sec. 2-433. (a) Individual Assistance • Sec. 2-433. (d) Federal Workshares • Sec. 2-433. (f) Commission Policies • Sec. 2-439.1. Enforcement Authority 3. Plan and hold a public panel with experts in housing to focus on homelessness (shelter and wraparound services) and barriers to entering stable housing during the June 6, 2024 HRC Work Session. • Sec. 2-433. (b) Awareness and Guidance • Sec. 2-433. (d) Federal Workshares • Sec. 2-434. Community dialogue and engagement 4. Submit policy recommendations to City Council pertaining to housing issues by October. • Sec. 2-433. (c) City Policies • Sec. 2-435. Systemic Issues 5. Submit a letter with legislative recommendations focused on homelessness and systemic barriers to housing to City Council by August 20, 2024. • Sec. 2-433. (e) Legislative Program In short, the HRC achieved all the goals proposed above, except for Goal 2. Public hearing training became a lower priority when Commissioners voted not to hold a hearing for Case 2020- 2. While the HRC achieved most of its annual goals, it was not able to realize actions on all the proposed primary and secondary focus areas. More details on the HRC’s work pertaining to these goals will be presented throughout the report. Page 110 of 289 5 1.3. OHR Overview The OHR is a division of the City Manager’s Office which receives and attempts to resolve complaints of unlawful discrimination, conducts community outreach, and provides support to the HRC. CY2024 marked another year of growth and change for the OHR. Following the departure of Saad Khaleefa on June 14, 2024, the OHR began the hiring process for a new Human Rights Intake Specialist. In the interim, Lily Gates, Outreach & Administrative Specialist, and Chyelle Chatman, Investigator (In Training), collaborated with the Director to manage intake, with Lily assuming the bulk of this responsibility. In August 2024, long-time OHR Intern, Ginny Helmandollar, began graduate school and ended her role after three years of outstanding service. On September 16, 2024, Lauren Harris assumed the Intake Specialist role. On December 11, 2024, after completing the OHR Investigator Training Program, Chyelle Chatman was promoted to Investigator, marking a new stage in the evolution of the OHR. Saad’s time in the Intake Specialist role demonstrated the need for a front desk staff person dedicated to serving all three programs within the Office of Social Equity (OSE) space at 507 East Main Street. The OSE space is shared by three public-facing programs, all with the same shared point of entry. With no staff person specifically assigned to the front desk, the Human Rights Intake Specialist was asked to fulfill OHR intake responsibilities while also handling walk-in traffic for all programs. Because the amount of walk-in traffic was very high, it was difficult to work on OHR intake processes without interruption and this arrangement proved unsustainable. Additionally, the front desk’s location offered no privacy for the confidential phone calls and document preparation required for OHR intake work. When Saad needed to hold in-person intake meetings, the front desk was left unoccupied and walk-in visitors would sometimes become frustrated if no one was available to answer the door. Following Saad’s departure, a temporary position was created to support front desk reception, and in late July 2024 Bridget Churchman-Colvin assumed this role. Bridget works under the supervision of the Employment and Financial Opportunity Manager, Roy Fitch. She primarily serves the Home to Hope and Downtown Job Center programs, both of which receive substantially more walk-in traffic than the OHR. Bridget refers any OHR walk-ins or appointments to OHR staff or provides them with OHR contact information. Bridget’s work has had a very positive impact on customer service and the workflow of all staff working in the office. At the conclusion of 2024, OHR staff members included an Intake Specialist, Investigator, Community Outreach & Administrative Specialist, and Director. Ginny’s departure revealed how reliant the OHR and HRC had become on the Intern role. The workload in the OHR, which also includes providing substantial support to the HRC, is only barely manageable with four full-time staff and leaves no capacity for essential community engagement and systemic impact work mandated by the CHRO. Saad’s departure and the interim period during which OHR staff filled in the intake duties further demonstrated the impact to productivity and staff wellbeing that happens when any one of the full-time positions is vacant. Page 111 of 289 6 The two charts below show the evolution of the organizational structure of the OHR from the beginning of 2024 through the end of 2024. Page 112 of 289 7 2. Individual Assistance Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (a) Assist individuals who believe they are the victim of an act of unlawful discrimination within the jurisdiction of the City. 2.1. Sec. 2-433. (a) HRC Actions The HRC’s primary role in the individual complaint process is to hold public hearings, as explained in CHRO Sec. 2-439.1. Enforcement Authority – The Role of the Commission. Only one complaint has required the HRC to hold a public hearing since the HRC was created in 2013. In 2024, the HRC considered holding a public hearing on a reasonable cause finding of retaliation in Case 2020-2. This case was filed under an earlier version of the CHRO that required a very complex public hearing procedure. After careful review of the investigative report and supporting documentation, Commissioners decided that the CHRO and the complainant’s interests would be better served by not holding a public hearing. 2.2. Sec. 2-433. (a) OHR Actions Most activities involving individual assistance rest with the OHR under CHRO Sec. 2-437.1., 2- 437.2., and 2-437.3. Individual service provision is one of the primary functions of the OHR. The following data presents a summary of service provision in CY2024 as well as an overview of trends in service provision over time. Since 2018, the OHR has used a consistent data collection process and classification system with only minor adjustments. Any referenced data prior to 2018 has been reanalyzed and redistributed into current categories for ease of comparison. Attachment 9.2. OHR CY2023 Individual Service Data provides detailed individual service data by month. Page 113 of 289 8 2.2.1. Total Incoming Contacts During CY2024, the Office received an average of 8 incoming contacts per day and served a total of 288 unique individuals. The OHR received the following number of incoming contact types: Contact Type Total Number Complaint 13 Inquiry 194 Individual Follow-up 1,233 Third Party Incoming 401 Total Incoming Contacts 1,841 In CY2024, the OHR received nearly twice as many discrimination complaints as compared to CY2023. Having dedicated Intake and Investigation staff has increased the office’s capacity to handle complaints and minimized referrals to state and federal agencies. In CY2024, the OHR received 219 (11%) fewer total incoming contacts than the previous year. The office has gone through many changes since 2014, including fluctuations in staffing from one to four full-time staff, a 14-month closure from March 2020 – May 2021 due to the COVID pandemic, and a major shift from 2022 to 2023 away from navigation and advocacy services. It is therefore hard to approximate an “average” volume of intakes per year. With consistent staffing, and barring no major disruptions or changes in services, a more consistent average intake volume should emerge over the next two years. Year Total Incoming Contacts 2014 107 2015 752 2016 1,302 2017 1,316 2018 696 2019 1,849 2020 1,159 2021 1,962 2022 3,253 2023 2,060 2024 1,841 Page 114 of 289 9 The chart below shows total incoming contacts by type from CY2014 through CY2023: It is important to note the difference between a complaint and an inquiry. A complaint is an incoming contact in which an individual wishes to pursue action regarding an allegation of discrimination that falls within the jurisdiction of the OHR, as defined by the CHRO. An inquiry is an incoming contact involving services provided to an individual by the OHR and/or an individual allegation of discrimination that falls outside the jurisdiction of the OHR, as defined by the CHRO. The attachment 9.1. OHR CY2023 OHR Data Dictionary provides detailed definitions for all contact types. Prior to CY2023, inquiries that evolved into complaints were reclassified in OHR records as complaints. These contacts were therefore combined and only counted once as complaints. In CY2023, the OHR stopped reclassifying inquiries when a contact evolves into a complaint, so the initial contact remains counted as an inquiry, and a new, separate contact is logged as a complaint. The total count of inquiries will therefore be higher by a number equal to the total number of complaints received for the year. 0 200 400 600 800 1000 1200 1400 1600 1800 2000 CY2014 CY2015 CY2016 CY2017 CY2018 CY2019 CY2020 CY2021 CY2022 CY2023 CY2024 Total Incoming Contacts by Contact Type CY2014 through CY2024 Complaints Inquiries Individual Follow-ups Third-party Incoming Page 115 of 289 10 The chart below isolates the number of inquiries and complaints received over the past seven years, highlighting that the OHR receives far more inquiries than complaints. 547 610 217 176 294 214 194 13 6 2 12 9 7 13 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 700 CY2018 CY2019 CY2020 CY2021 CY2022 CY2023 CY2024 Total Complaints & Inquiries CY2018 through CY2024 Complaints Inquiries Page 116 of 289 11 2.2.2. Total Inquiries and Complaints by Location Despite fluctuations in the volume of inquiries and complaints, most inquiries and complaints received by the OHR over the last eleven years involved a concern that occurred in Charlottesville. In CY2024, the OHR received 87 inquiries originating in Charlottesville (45% of 194 total inquiries) and 13 complaints. The CHRO only authorizes the HRC and OHR to process complaints of discrimination that originate in Charlottesville. The OHR continues to receive regular inquiries from Albemarle County and beyond, and this may demonstrate an unmet need for services outside of Charlottesville. Inquiries received from localities other than Charlottesville and Albemarle came from many different locations in Virginia including Caroline County, Carroll County, Danville, Fork Union, Fredericksburg, Gordonsville, Louisa, Lynchburg, Norfolk, Prince Edward County, Prince George County, and Strasburg. The OHR also received three inquiries originating in North Carolina, and one international inquiry from Germany. The OHR refers inquiries for services not covered by the CHRO to the appropriate service provider, when possible, and refers inquiries involving any non-jurisdictional allegations of unlawful discrimination to the appropriate municipal, state, or federal agency. The chart below shows the combined number of inquiries and complaints originating in Charlottesville, Albemarle County, or a different or unspecified locality since CY2014: 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 CY2014 CY2015 CY2016 CY2017 CY2018 CY2019 CY2020 CY2021 CY2022 CY2023 CY2024 Total Inquiries & Complaints by Location CY2014 through CY2024 City of Charlottesville Albemarle County Other/Not Specified Page 117 of 289 12 2.2.3. Total Inquiries and Complaints by Protected Activity In CY2024, the OHR received a total of 194 contacts classified as inquiries and 13 complaints. The table below shows the total number of inquiries and complaints by protected activity in CY2024: Protected Activity Total Inquiries Total Complaints Housing 53 5 Employment 52 5 Public Accommodation 16 3 Credit 0 0 Private Education 0 0 Other (Unprotected) 73 0 The chart below shows a summary of the protected activities identified in inquiries and complaints received by the OHR from CY2018 through CY2024. Most inquiries and complaints received by the OHR are related to Housing, followed by Employment and Public Accommodation: 247 1 Inquiry 67 202 404 1 Complaint 13 20 28 0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350 400 450 500 Other (Unprotected) Private Education Credit Public Accommodation Employment Housing Total Inquiries and Complaints by Protected Activity CY2018 through CY2024 Inquiries Complaints Page 118 of 289 13 2.2.4. Total Combined Inquiries and Complaints by Protected Class The table below shows the number of times a protected class was identified in an inquiry or complaint in CY2024. Protected Class Combined Inquiries and Complaints Disability 42 National Origin 17 Race 12 Color 7 Elderliness (Housing) 6 Sex 5 Age 5 Religion 4 Sexual Orientation 4 Source of Funds (Housing) 2 Gender Identity 2 Military Status 2 Familial Status (Housing) 1 Pregnancy 0 Childbirth or Related Medical Conditions 0 Other (Unprotected) 20 Not Specified 101 The chart below shows a summary of the protected classes identified in inquiries and complaints received by the OHR from CY2018 through CY2024. Over the past seven years, disability has been the most often identified protected class in inquiries and complaints received by the OHR, followed by race and color. 508 96 1 1 3 6 7 8 9 9 13 17 36 45 59 99 133 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 Not Specified Other (Unprotected) Childbirth or Related Medical Conditions Pregnancy Military Status Familial Status (Housing) Gender Identity Sexual Orientation Religion Source of Funds (Housing) Elderliness (Housing) Age Sex National Origin Color Race Disability Total Inquiries & Complaints by Protected Class CY2018 through CY2024 Page 119 of 289 14 2.2.5. Total Complaints by Protected Activity and Protected Class The following chart isolates total complaints received by the OHR over the last seven years, broken down by protected activity and protected class. Overall, race is the most often identified protected class in complaints, followed by disability. In employment discrimination complaints specifically, race is also the most often identified protected class. In housing complaints disability is most often identified, and in public accommodation complaints disability is most often identified. In CY2024, there were 5 cases of housing discrimination, 5 cases of employment discrimination, and 3 cases of public accommodation discrimination. For a summary of case statuses in CY2024, please refer to section 2.2.9. Status of Complaint Cases During the Calendar Year of this report. Note that an individual may identify multiple protected classes when filing a complaint, so the total number of identified protected classes is larger than the total number of complaints. 0 2 1 1 1 3 2 1 3 11 9 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 4 2 5 5 2 10 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 3 2 6 4 0 5 10 15 20 25 Childbirth or Related Medical Conditions Familial Status (housing only) Pregnancy Military Status Elderliness (housing only) Gender Identity Religion Sexual Orientation National Origin Source of Funds (housing only) Age (not in housing) Marital Status Sex Color Disability Race Total Complaints by Protected Activity and Protected Class CY2018 through CY2024 Housing Employment Public Accommodation Credit Private Education Page 120 of 289 15 2.2.6. Services Provided Through Individual Contacts In CY2024, the OHR provided services through 2,830 incoming and outgoing contacts. Contacts during CY2024 were classified by the primary services of Case Administration, Conciliation Activity, Informal Dialogue, Information, Intake Activity, Investigation Activity, Mediation Activity, and Navigation & Advocacy. Community outreach contacts are tracked in a separate system, and community outreach data for CY2024 is examined in Section 3.2. of this report. Definitions for each of the service provision categories can be found in the attachment 9.1. OHR CY2024 Data Dictionary. The chart below shows the total number of service contacts by type and percentage of total services provided in CY2024: 2.3% 2.5% 3.0% 14.4% 17.9% 22.3% 37.5% Services Provided Through Incoming & Outgoing Contacts in CY2024 Conciliation Activity (0 contacts) Mediation Activity (66 contacts) Informal Dialogue (70 contacts) Investigation Activity (85 contacts) Navigation & Advocacy (408 contacts) Information (507 contacts) Case Administration (632 contacts) Intake Activity (1,062 contacts) Page 121 of 289 16 2.2.7. Navigation & Advocacy First introduced in CY2022, navigation & advocacy is a service provision classification that refers to individual service provision which does not involve a jurisdictional complaint of discrimination but may include referrals to other service providers, assistance with accessing services, communicating with other agencies, or clerical support. In CY2023, the OHR classified 2,059 incoming and outgoing contacts as navigation & advocacy, amounting to 67% of the 3,081 incoming and outgoing contacts handled by the OHR that year. In CY2024, the OHR classified only 408 incoming and outgoing contacts as navigation & advocacy: just 14% of the 2,830 incoming and outgoing contacts for the year. This marks a significant and intentional shift away from this work, as the OHR has focused more on making the complaint resolution process more robust while also putting more energy into supporting the systemic impact work of the HRC. Staff further categorize navigation & advocacy contacts as seen below. Housing navigation was the most common type of navigation & advocacy service provided in CY2024, making up 140 (34%) of the 408 navigation & advocacy contacts. This support primarily included negotiating with property managers or owners, facilitating discussions with housing voucher administrators, and limited contact with service providers in the homelessness continuum of care. The chart below shows the total number of navigation & advocacy contacts received in CY2024, classified by type of service provided: 0 0 0 2 2 3 3 3 11 12 16 32 37 89 140 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 Application Assistance Clerical Support DPOR Liaison Crisis Response Safe Space EEOC Liaison Mental Health Navigation Translation Services Other Agency Liaison Legal Aid Liaison AG OCR Liaison Other City Agency Liaison CRHA Liaison Housing Navigation Total Navigation & Advocacy Contacts by Type in CY2024 Page 122 of 289 17 As noted above, the OHR processed 408 incoming and outgoing contacts classified as navigation & advocacy in CY2024. Since CY2023, the Office has also tracked the time spent by staff on navigation & advocacy contacts to gain a better sense of the extent to which these contacts pulled staff away from other duties. In CY2023, OHR staff logged 389.7 hours as navigation & advocacy contacts. This was 72% of the total 539.43 hours spent on all incoming and outgoing contacts in CY2023. In CY2024, OHR staff spent only 62.68 hours on navigation & advocacy or 18% of the total 358.08 hours spent on all incoming and outgoing contacts in CY2024, marking an 84% decrease in navigation & advocacy contacts over the previous year. While the OHR still receives contacts classified as navigation & advocacy, staff continue to intentionally redirect and refer individuals seeking assistance to better-suited service providers whenever possible. Navigation & advocacy contacts in CY2024 centered on a few specific housing-related concerns. In one situation, the OHR received multiple contacts from both directly affected individuals and third-party witnesses, including service providers and family members. OHR staff, in this case primarily the Director, engaged in dialogue with property management and owners to relay the concerns and discuss possible solutions. After several months of negotiation, the property owner and management company took significant action to correct some of the core issues presented. This conversation remains ongoing, as some issues are still being addressed. In the situation described above, the OHR chose to engage because the issues presented affected a significantly large population (approximately 90 individuals), all of whom were members of one or more protected classes. The harms identified by the individuals and third parties who contacted the OHR pointed to recurring problems with a root cause that could be directly addressed by the owners and property management company, thereby having a positive systemic impact on a sizeable group of people. This particular situation is shared as an example of the type of navigation & advocacy work that seems to align with the CHRO, specifically Sec. 2-433.(b), which mandates that the HRC and OHR work collaboratively with the private sector to prevent and eliminate discrimination. It is worth noting the connection between navigation & advocacy at the individual level and the same at the systemic level. In the example above, OHR action helped encourage change that affected multiple residents in an apartment complex. Several of the residents in this complex were people to whom the OHR had provided individual navigation & advocacy assistance in the past. This included one individual who lost housing after failing to correctly navigate a COVID- era, state-sponsored rental assistance program. In this case, OHR staff helped the individual move out of the housing after eviction, acquire emergency shelter, apply for housing, connect with Region Ten case management, and ultimately move into the apartment complex. In another case, OHR staff helped a Spanish-speaking family living in substandard housing connect with a provider that helped one family member acquire social security disability support for a chronic medical condition that was preventing them from being able to work. OHR staff then assisted the family with applying for and attaining housing in the above-mentioned apartment complex. Both families still reside in the apartment complex described above and were thus also impacted by the positive changes made by the owners and property management company. Page 123 of 289 18 2.2.8. Referrals to Other Services When individuals seek assistance from the OHR for services that the OHR cannot provide, staff attempt to connect the individuals to the most appropriate service provider. These attempted connections are classified as referrals. Listed below are the five primary service providers most closely related to the services provided by the OHR. Referrals from the OHR are to agencies other than the primary five service providers and are classified as “Other”: AGOCR (VA Attorney General’s Office of Civil Rights): Individuals are referred to the AGOCR for employment and public accommodations cases that originate in Virginia but are outside the jurisdiction of the Office of Human Rights, as defined by state and federal law and the CHRO. In some situations, the OHR will refer cases to the AGOCR when the individual seeks a resolution that requires civil action. This is because the AGOCR partners with the EEOC, which can issue a right to sue letter for civil action in federal court for employment discrimination cases. EEOC (Equal Employment Opportunity Commission): Individuals are referred to the EEOC for employment discrimination cases that are outside the jurisdiction of the Office of Human Rights, as defined by state and federal law and the CHRO. Because the AGOCR has a workshare agreement with the EEOC, the OHR refers employment cases originating in Virginia to the AGOCR so that the complainant can dual file at both the state and federal level. DPOR (Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation): This is a state government department that includes the Virginia Fair Housing Office. In previous years, individuals were referred to DPOR for fair housing discrimination complaints when the complainant expressly sought civil action against the respondent. It is important to note that with the passage of the amendments on November 21, 2022, the CHRO now includes language that states that, when a housing complaint receives a finding of reasonable cause, the City will file a civil action on behalf of the complainant. As OHR staff capacity increases to investigate and render findings in housing cases and potentially enters a Fair Housing Assistance Program (FHAP) workshare agreement with the federal government, referrals to DPOR are expected to discontinue for jurisdictional housing discrimination cases. CVLAS (Central Virginia Legal Aid Society): Individuals are referred to CVLAS for assistance with a variety of legal issues raised during intake, often pertaining to the protected activities identified in the CHRO. In some cases, individuals have simultaneous cases with CVLAS and the Office of Human Rights. LAJC (Legal Aid Justice Center): Individuals are referred to LAJC for assistance with a variety of legal issues raised during intake, often pertaining to the protected activities identified in the CHRO. In some cases, individuals have simultaneous cases with LAJC and the Office of Human Rights. Other: The OHR refers individuals to a wide variety of other agencies and offices depending on their specific concerns. Page 124 of 289 19 The chart below depicts total referrals over the past seven years, including totals for CY2024, to the five organizations that do work most closely related to the OHR: In CY2024, the OHR had 35 contacts result in referrals. Note that some referral contacts resulted in referrals to more than one agency or service provider; therefore, the total number of referral contacts is lower than the sum of referrals to the five primary agencies and “Other” agencies. The chart below shows agencies that received five or more referrals in CY2024. 80 68 33 36 4 5 5 3 19 0 0 20 40 60 80 100 LAJC (Total: 85) CVLAS (Total: 73) EEOC (Total: 36) AGOCR (Total: 55) DPOR (Total: 4) Total Referrals to Agencies Most Similar to the OHR CY2018 through CY2024 CY2018 - CY2023 CY2024 66% 17% 17% Agencies that Received Five or More Referrals in CY2024 AG OCR (66%) CVLAS (17%) LAJC (17%) Page 125 of 289 20 Below is a list of agencies that fall into the “Other” agencies referral category. These agencies received between one and three referrals during CY2024. Note that some individuals were referred to several of these organizations following a single contact with the OHR. Acronyms are included as they are referenced in the CY2023 Individual Service Data (Attachment 2): • Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority (CRHA) o Note: while referrals to CRHA were minimal, the OHR engaged in significant navigation & advocacy work with CRHA (see report section 2.2.7. Navigation & Advocacy). • City of Charlottesville Adult Protective Services (APS) • City of Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board (PCOB) • Community Resource Line (CRL) • DisAbility Law Center (DLC) • Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) o Note: while the EEOC is considered one the five primary referral agencies, because the OHR referred individuals to the EEOC fewer than five times in CY2024, it is included on this list. • Homeless Information Line (HIL) • Housing Opportunities Made Equal (HOME) • Piedmont Housing Alliance Financial Opportunity Center (PHA FOC) • Shelter for Help in Emergency (SHE) • U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) • Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (DBHDS) Page 126 of 289 21 2.2.9. Status of Complaints During the Calendar Year At the end of CY2024, the OHR had 12 open complaint cases and had resolved 7 cases that had either been opened that year or during a previous year. Adequate OHR staffing and access to professional mediation services have been essential for effective and efficient complaint resolution. In August 2022, City Council approved funding for hiring an Intake & Administrative Specialist and an Investigator. As noted in report section 1.3 OHR Overview, these roles were first filled during 2023. In 2024, the OHR began the year with a fully staffed team. Since 2021, the OHR has had an active contract with the third-party mediation firm Resolute Mediation and Arbitration, Inc. (RMA). OHR staff are currently training to become General District Court certified mediators and used the skills learned in this training to conduct three informal dialogues in CY2024. The table below shows the year-end status of complaint cases that were active during CY2024: Case # Protected Activity Protected Class(es) Year-end Status 2020-2 Housing Race Reasonable cause finding of retaliation. HRC voted not to hold a public hearing. Case closed. 2021-4 Employment Sex Settlement reached through mediation. 2021-5 Employment Sexual Orientation, Race Investigation in progress. 2022-6 Housing Color, Race Mediation reached impasse. No Complainant response to OHR offer of additional support. Case administratively closed. 2023-2 Employment Religion, National Origin Offer of alternative dispute resolution pending. Page 127 of 289 22 Case # Protected Activity Protected Class(es) Year-end Status 2023-7 Public Accommodations Sex Finding of no reasonable cause. Case dismissed. 2024-1 Housing Race Non-jurisdictional. Case dismissed. 2024-2 Housing Age, Disability Informal dialogue in progress. 2024-3 Public Accommodations National Origin, Sexual Orientation Informal dialogue in progress. 2024-3R Public Accommodations Retaliation Informal dialogue in progress. 2024-4 Housing Disability Informal dialogue in progress. 2024-5 Public Accommodations Disability, Gender Identity Mediation reached impasse. Complaint withdrawn. Case referred to AGOCR. 2024-6 Employment Color, Race, Religion, Sex Complainant engaged in threatening behavior toward OHR staff. Case administratively closed. Page 128 of 289 23 Case # Protected Activity Protected Class(es) Year-end Status 2024-7 Housing Race, Religion, National Origin Informal dialogue in progress. 2024-8 Employment Race, National Origin Investigation in progress. 2024-9 Employment Disability Pending agreement reached through informal dialogue. 2024-10 Employment Marital Status Awaiting Respondent reply to offer of alternative dispute resolution. 2024-11 Employment Sex, Marital Status Awaiting Respondent reply to offer of alternative dispute resolution. 2024-12 Housing Disability Awaiting Respondent reply to offer of alternative dispute resolution. Page 129 of 289 24 3. Awareness and Guidance Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (b) Collaborate with the public and private sectors for the purpose of providing awareness, education, and guidance on methods to prevent and eliminate discrimination citywide. (1) The Commission shall serve as a forum for the discussion of human rights issues and be responsible for conducting ongoing efforts to engage community members in an open, honest, and creative dialogue regarding issues of equity and opportunity, including but not limited to issues considered by the City’s Dialogue on Race initiative. (2) The Commission shall conduct or engage in educational and informational programs for the promotion of mutual understanding, reconciliation, and respect between all classes of individuals protected by this ordinance and the larger Charlottesville community. This role is shared between the HRC and the OHR. Prior to the passage of the amended CHRO on August 5, 2024, the specific duties and responsibilities of this role were further explained in Sec. 2-434. Duties and responsibilities – Community dialogue and engagement. With the passage of the amendments to the CRHO, the content of the former Sec. 2-434. was incorporated as sub- sections (1) and (2) of Sec. 2-433. (b), as noted above. 3.1. Sec. 2-433. (b) HRC Actions The table on the following page shows how the HRC’s actions in CY2024 align with the duties and responsibilities in Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) and (2) in the CHRO and with the focus areas and goals Commissioners identified during their annual meeting, as detailed in report section 1.2 HRC Overview. It is noteworthy that the HRC did not independently realize any actions that align with Sec. 2- 433. (b)(2). This work was exclusively undertaken by the OHR. Additionally, most of the HRC’s actions taken under this section did not generally align with the annual focus areas or goals. This is not an indication that the HRC’s actions had no value, as a wide variety of community outreach efforts are essential to engaging the public in the HRC’s work. The lack of alignment may simply point to a need to develop a planning process that includes space for community engagement actions that may emerge throughout the year. Page 130 of 289 25 Date Alignment Action Summary 1/18/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: No Direct Alignment Goal: No Direct Alignment Public Discussion The Commission partnered with the City ADA Coordinator and Precision Infrastructure Management for a public presentation about updates to the City's ADA Transition Plan. 2/29/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: No Direct Alignment Goal: No Direct Alignment Public Awareness The Chair promoted the public poll on NBC29 Community Conversations. The poll was created to gather public input on topics of community concern for the purpose of informing the Commission's development of focus areas during the annual planning meeting in March. 5/6/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: LGBTQIA+ Ally/Safe Space Training Goal: No Direct Alignment Community Partnership A Commissioner met with community partners and OHR staff to coordinate efforts to organize local LGBTQ+ Ally trainings. 5/10/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: No Direct Alignment Goal: No Direct Alignment Community Event A Commissioner conducted service provision outreach in conjunction with OHR staff. Page 131 of 289 26 Date Alignment Action Summary 6/29/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: No Direct Alignment Goal: No Direct Alignment Community Event The Chair and Vice Chair conducted service provision outreach and HRC recruitment at Healthy Streets Healthy People in conjunction with OHR staff. 7/11/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: Legislative recommendations Goal: No Direct Alignment Public Awareness The Chair promoted the legislative recommendation expert panel on NBC29 Community Conversations. 9/7/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: No Direct Alignment Goal: No Direct Alignment Community Event A Commissioner conducted service provision outreach in conjunction with OHR staff. 10/25/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: No Direct Alignment Goal: No Direct Alignment Community Event A Commissioner conducted service provision outreach in conjunction with OHR staff. Page 132 of 289 27 Date Alignment Action Summary 11/14/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: No Direct Alignment Goal: No Direct Alignment Community Event A Commissioner conducted service provision outreach in conjunction with OHR staff. 12/22/2024 Sec. 2-433. (b)(1) Community dialogue and engagement Focus Area: No Direct Alignment Goal: No Direct Alignment Community Event Four Commissioners attended a service provision outreach event in conjunction with OHR staff. Page 133 of 289 28 3.2. Sec. 2-433. (b) OHR Actions Community outreach is one of the primary tools used by the OHR to inform community members of their protected rights as well as their options for assistance when those rights are unlawfully violated. An additional goal of community outreach is to advance systemic change by encouraging shifts in societal norms. Awareness, education, and a willingness to make change at individual and community levels play an important role in initiating progress towards justice and equity. The OHR categorizes outreach in three ways: • Service Provision: spreading awareness about the services provided by the OHR and HRC. • Education & Awareness: focused on teaching the community about human rights and fostering understanding between members of protected classes and the broader Charlottesville community. • Collaboration & Leadership: work done in partnership with other agencies. During CY2024, staff expanded outreach activities and audiences across the majority of metrics. Below are some examples: • The audience reached through service provision outreach more than doubled from 390 individuals in CY2023 to 833 individuals in CY2024. • Staff revamped the monthly Human Rights Newsletter, which had 4,393 opens in CY2024. Each newsletter edition was a brief digest of the OHR and HRC’s work in the prior month as well as an overview of upcoming HRC meetings and events hosted by the OHR or community organizations. • In CY2023, previous Community Outreach & Administrative Specialist Victoria McCullough created a presentation that outlined the services provided by the OHR and HRC and presented it to 2 groups throughout the year. In CY2024, staff expanded upon Victoria’s work by adding additional slides and information to the presentation and presenting it to 10 groups of service providers, reaching an audience of 144 people. This has already proven to be an effective outreach strategy, as several of the service providers reached through the presentation have referred individuals they support to the OHR for services. In addition, this bolsters relationships between OHR staff and other organizations in the community, allowing us to collaborate more effectively and generate creative ways to better serve the community. • From January-June of CY2024, the OHR was fully staffed, allowing the Community Outreach & Administrative specialist to continue to grow the OHR’s Education & Awareness outreach. The OHR was therefore able to host new events in this category, including a Fair Housing Know Your Rights Training and a Disability Pride Month Trivia Night. Staff also collaborated with the County’s Office of Equity and Inclusion and other partners to host a Community Walk in honor of Martin Luther King Jr. Day; this event was a walking tour of central Charlottesville in which nearly 100 community members joined together to learn about, reflect on, and share personal experiences of Charlottesville’s racial history and its impacts on the present-day social landscape of the city. Across all Education & Awareness events in CY2024, there were 276 attendees (over 5 times the 53 attendees at these events in CY2023). Page 134 of 289 29 3.2.1. OHR Community Outreach Activities by Outreach Type In CY2024, the OHR engaged in 246 community outreach activities, which were classified as the following: Outreach Type Total Number of Activities Service Provision 50 Education & Awareness 8 Collaboration & Leadership 187 The attachment 9.3. OHR CY2024 Community Outreach Data provides detailed individual service data by month. The chart below shows a summary of outreach activities conducted by the OHR over the last six years: 172 43 100 86 145 187 22 1 9 8 17 8 7 73 33 50 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 CY2019 CY2020 CY2021 CY2022 CY2023 CY2024 Summary of Community Outreach by Outreach Type CY2019 through CY2024 Service Provision Education & Awareness Collaboration & Leadership Page 135 of 289 30 In the second half of the year, Education & Awareness events decreased as the Community Outreach and Administrative Specialist was required to take on additional responsibilities due to changes in staffing. Following Saad Khaleefa’s departure from the Intake Specialist role in June 2024, and prior to Lauren Harris’ hire in September 2024, the Community Outreach and Administrative Specialist assumed additional intake duties to support the continued function of the OHR. This involved handling approximately 93 individual service-related contacts from June-October, including new inquiries (24), follow-ups (63), and referrals and third-party contacts (6) as well as attending internally and externally organized case conferencing meetings. In the absence of an Intake Specialist, the Director was not only required to complete additional service provision responsibilities, but also conduct the recruitment, hiring, and training processes. Because of this additional demand for work that only the Director could hold, the Community Outreach & Administrative Specialist assumed further added duties to support the continued function of the HRC. These included completing the majority of tasks related to the creation and publication of HRC agendas, agenda packets, OHR staff reports, and public notice as well as maintaining HRC-related data and other administrative tasks. Additionally, in August 2024, the OHR’s long-term intern Ginny Helmandollar departed, and the Community Outreach and Administrative Specialist assumed the additional responsibilities of creating and publishing HRC meeting minutes. Page 136 of 289 31 3.2.2. Collaborative Activities and Engaged Partner Agencies As in previous years, Collaboration & Leadership comprised most of the OHR’s outreach in CY2024. Collaboration & Leadership involves engagement with a variety of community partners to organize outreach events, develop referral networks for individuals seeking services, and lead discussion in projects that serve people who engage in protected activities and/or are members of protected classes. Of the 246 outreach activities conducted by the OHR in CY2024, 187 were in collaboration with other community partners. This is an increase from the 145 Collaboration & Leadership outreach activities conducted in CY2023. In CY2024, the OHR worked with or attended meetings and events hosted by the 70 primary collaborators listed: Albemarle Charlottesville Regional Jail Authority Albemarle County Communications and Public Engagement, Albemarle County Office of Equity and Inclusion Albemarle County Parks and Recreation Bicycle and Pedestrian Advisory Committee Birth Sisters of Charlottesville Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless Can I Talk to You Cville Central Virginia Community Justice Central Virginia Legal Aid Society Central Virginia Violence Interrupters (formerly B.U.C.K. Squad) Charlottesville Area Justice Coalition Charlottesville Democratic Socialists of America Charlottesville National Organization for Women Chihamba of Dancescapes, Ltd. City of Charlottesville ADA Coordinator City of Charlottesville Communications City of Charlottesville Department of Human Services City of Charlottesville Department of Social Services City of Charlottesville Office for Sustainability City of Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board City of Charlottesville Risk Management Community Based Recovery Support Advisory Committee Cville Pride DEC-VA (formerly DEC-UVA) Downtown Job Center Equal Justice USA Firefly Restaurant and Game Room Gender Expansive Community Advisory Board Greater Charlottesville Trauma Informed Community Network Home to Hope Housing Opportunities Made Equal Page 137 of 289 32 Jefferson Madison Regional Library Legal Aid Justice Center Lighthouse Studio Mediation Center of Charlottesville NAACP NBC29 Neighborhood Development Services Office of Social Equity Partner for Mental Health People and Congregations Engaged in Ministry Piedmont Group Sierra Club Piedmont Housing Alliance Police Civilian Oversight Board Precision Infrastructure Management Presidential Precinct Public Housing Association of Residents Racial Equity Institute Ready Kids Region 10 Sentara Sexual Assault Resource Agency Sin Barreras Soul of Cville The Fountain Fund The Haven The Women's Initiative Thomas Jefferson Area Planning District Commission Tom Tom Festival Trust Labs (formerly The Dinner Party Labs) United Way of Greater Charlottesville UVA Health UVA Office for Sustainability UVA Office of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Vinegar Hill Magazine Virginia Beach Human Rights Commission Virginia Organizing Welcoming America Welcoming Greater Charlottesville Page 138 of 289 33 4. City Policies Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (c) Identify and review policies and practices of the City of Charlottesville and its boards, commissions, and other public agencies within the City and advise those bodies on issues related to human rights. (1) Such policies, practices, and systems may include those of an institutional nature that: (i) May be unlawful discriminatory practices; or (ii) May not constitute unlawful discriminatory practices but nevertheless produce disparities that adversely impact individuals in accordance with the protected classes identified within this ordinance. (2) Any review undertaken pursuant to this section may be initiated at the request of any other public or private entity, or by the Commission on its own initiative. (3) The Commission may conduct its own research and review of existing studies and literature, collaborate with other research organizations, organize public focus groups, and hold such hearings as may be necessary to identify policies, practices and systems as referenced above. For each such identified policy, practice or system, the goal of the Commission will be to formulate recommendations and to propose to City Council concrete, actionable reforms that will eliminate discriminatory practices or the adverse effects of lawful other practices. The Commission will report the status of its ongoing project(s) or review(s) to City Council within its quarterly and annual reports. This role is primarily held by the HRC, with the OHR providing administrative support. Prior the passage of the amended CHRO on August 5, 2024, the specific duties and responsibilities of this role were further explained in Sec. 2-435. Duties and responsibilities – Systemic issues. With the passage of the amendments to the CRHO, the content of the former Sec. 2-435. was incorporated into the sub-sections (1), (2), and (3) of Sec. 2-433. (c), as noted above. Page 139 of 289 34 The table below lists the HRC’s actions in CY2024 that aligned with the duties and responsibilities in Sec. 2-433. (c) and identifies any additional alignment with the focus areas and goals Commissioners identified during their annual meeting. Documents referenced in the action summaries are publicly posted on the “Human Rights Commission” subpage within the “Human Rights” webpage on the City website. Date Alignment Action Summary 11/07/2024 Focus Area: Housing Homelessness Goal: City Policy Recommendations Council Recommendation The HRC voted to adopt a letter to City Council recommending policies and practices related to equitable and low-barrier year- round shelter for people facing homelessness, effective right to counsel for tenants in eviction proceedings, and support for the City Manager's plan to address homelessness. The letter was submitted to City Council on January 3, 2025. (See attachment 9.4. HRC Recommendations for Housing Policies) 11/21/2024 Focus Area: Housing Systemic barriers Goal: City Policy Recommendations Council Recommendation The HRC voted to adopt a letter to City Council regarding advocacy for effective right to counsel for tenants facing eviction. The letter was submitted to City Council on January 3, 2025. (See attachment 9.5. HRC Recommendations for Effective Right to Counsel) Page 140 of 289 35 5. Federal Workshares Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (d) Seek a Fair Employment Practices Agency (FEPA) workshare agreement with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and a Fair Housing Assistance Program (FHAP) workshare agreement with the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) to conduct investigations of employment and housing discrimination on their behalf and enter into such agreement(s) subject to approval of City Council upon a finding that the agreement(s) would be in the best interest of the City. Most of the duties and responsibilities relating to the pursuit of a Fair Employment Practices Agency (FEPA) workshare with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) and a Fair Housing Assistance Program (FHAP) workshare with the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) fall to the OHR, with the HRC playing a supporting role. These workshare agreements are directly related to the enforcement processes detailed in Sec. 2-437.1. Investigation of individual employment discrimination complaints and issuance of findings, Sec. 2-437.2. Investigation of individual housing discrimination complaints and issuance of findings, and Sec. 2-439.1. Enforcement authority – The role of the Commission regarding individual complaints of discrimination. In CY2021, the HRC prioritized pursuit of the FHAP workshare over the FEPA because simultaneous pursuit of both workshares without additional staff support was not practical. Therefore, work on the FEPA workshare remained on hold for the entirety of CY2024. 5.1. Sec. 2-433. (d) HRC Actions In CY2024, the HRC reviewed two rounds of proposed amendments to the CHRO. All amendments were made at HUD’s recommendation to make the CHRO substantially equivalent to federal fair housing law, which is required for interim FHAP certification. The HRC voted to adopt the first round of amendments on June 27, 2024, and the second round on December 19, 2024. 5.2. Sec. 2-433. (d) OHR Actions OHR staff presented the first round of amendments to the CHRO to City Council on July 15, 2024. Council conducted a second reading and voted to adopt the amendments on August 5, 2024. The second round of amendments were initially scheduled for presentation to Council on January 6, 2025, but this was later moved to January 21, 2025, due to inclement weather. Page 141 of 289 36 Council voted to adopt the amendments in one reading on January 21, 2025. The table below summarizes the actions taken by the OHR since CY2021 to progress toward a FHAP workshare agreement: Step Summary of Actions OHR initiates contact with federal agency. (CY2021) The Director set up the above-mentioned question-and- answer session with the HRC and Erik Steinecker from the HUD Fair Housing Office. OHR drafts necessary documents for application. (CY2021) The Director drafted a revised version of the CHRO that included language necessary for substantial equivalence with federal fair housing law. OHR submits draft documents to federal agency for informal review. (CY2021) The Director worked with Erik Steinecker at the HUD Fair Housing Office throughout 2021 to edit the initial draft of the revised CHRO. OHR submits draft documents to City Attorney for review. (CY2021) The Director met with City Attorney’s Office staff for an initial review of the revised CHRO. Following this meeting, the Director contacted the Fairfax County Office of Human Rights to ask questions about the practical implications of some of the duties required by substantial equivalence to federal fair housing law. OHR revises draft documents based on federal agency and City Attorney feedback. (January – July 2022) The Director further revised the CHRO, incorporating feedback from the Director of the Fairfax County Human Rights Commission, HUD, and the City Attorney’s Office. OHR prepares draft documents for review by HRC. (August 2022) The Director met with City Attorney’s Office staff for a follow-up review of the CHRO and makes additional revisions. Page 142 of 289 37 Step Summary of Actions OHR presents draft documents for HRC and public review and feedback. (September 2022) The Director included the draft CHRO in the HRC regular meeting agenda packet for September 15, 2022. Commissioners were asked to provide feedback before October 3, 2022. Members of the public were invited to provide feedback to OHR staff or during public comment at HRC meetings. OHR prepares final draft documents for presentation to HRC for adoption. (September – October 2022) The Director met with City Attorney’s Office staff to review final edits to the CHRO before presentation to the HRC. HRC adopts final draft documents for recommendation to City Council. (October 2022) At the HRC regular meeting on October 20, 2022, Commissioners voted to adopt the amended CHRO for recommendation to City Council. HRC and OHR present final draft documents to City Council. (November 2022) The Director met with Councilors individually to review the changes to the CHRO before a first reading at the November 7, 2022, Council meeting and a second reading followed by a vote to approve on November 21, 2022. OHR presents the approved documents to HUD for follow-up review and next steps. (February 2023) The Director met with Erik Steinecker and Maria Moreno from the HUD Fair Housing Office to review the CHRO as adopted by Council on November 21, 2022. Erik and Maria recommended additional changes to the CHRO. OHR staff draft amendments to the CHRO based on feedback from HUD. (March – September 2023) The Director and OHR Intern Ginny Helmandollar drafted amendments to the CHRO that included the recommendations from HUD as well as refinements to other parts of the CHRO unrelated to substantial equivalence to federal fair housing law. OHR submits draft CHRO to City Attorney for review. (October 2023) The Director and OHR Intern (prior to her hire as Outreach & Administrative Specialist) Lily Gates met with Deputy City Attorneys to review the proposed amendments. The Deputy City Attorneys offered further feedback. Page 143 of 289 38 Step Summary of Actions OHR revises draft CHRO in preparation for a second review by the City Attorney and HUD. (October 2023-June 2024) The Director incorporated the feedback provided by the Deputy City Attorneys and prepared a draft amended CHRO for sharing with HUD. OHR presents changes to the CHRO to new FHAP Director during virtual meeting. (June 2024) The Director presented a summary of the changes to the CHRO recommended by the previous FHAP Director, Erik Steinecker, for an informal review prior to presentation to City Council. The new FHAP Director, Tiffany Johnson, recommended passage of the amendments and submission to HUD by August 2024. OHR prepares final draft documents and presents to the HRC for adoption. (June 2024) The Director prepared a final draft of the amended CHRO, incorporating recommendations from HUD, and presented the amended draft CHRO to the HRC during a public meeting on June 27, 2024. The HRC voted to adopt the amended CHRO for recommendation to City Council. OHR presents the amended draft CHRO to Council for review and adoption. (July-August 2024) The Director presented the amended draft CHRO for a first reading on July 15, 2024. Council conducted a second reading and voted to adopt the amendments on August 5, 2024. OHR submits the adopted CHRO to HUD for review. (August-October2024) The Director submitted CHRO, as adopted by Council on August 5, 2024, to HUD for review. The HUD FHAP Director followed up on October 31, 2024, to report that more amendments were required for substantial equivalence to federal fair housing law. OHR meets with HUD to discuss additional revisions to the CHRO. (November-December 2024) The Director, City Attorney, and Community Outreach & Administrative Specialist met with HUD FHAP staff to review recommended changes and subsequent draft amendments to the CHRO. After the final informal review, HUD affirmed substantial equivalence. OHR presents a final draft of the CHRO to the HRC for adoption by the HRC and City Council. (December 2024-January 2025) The Director presented the revised CHRO to the HRC on December 19, 2024. The HRC voted to adopt the amendments. Presentation to Council is scheduled for January 6, 2025, then moved to January 21, 2025. Council voted to adopt the proposed amendments and the updated CHRO was sent to HUD on January 23, 2025. Page 144 of 289 39 6. Legislative Program Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (e) Make recommendations regarding the City’s annual legislative program, with an emphasis on enabling legislation that may be needed to implement programs and policies that will address discrimination. This role rests primarily with the HRC with support from the OHR and is closely related to the roles under Sec. 2-433. (b) and (c). As noted above, at the HRC’s annual meeting on March 9, 2024, Commissioners identified housing, and specifically homelessness and systemic barriers to housing, as a primary focus for CY2024. From January through September, the HRC sought input from a variety of community organizations and individuals to better understand the landscape of state legislation and housing challenges in Charlottesville: • January 5, 2024: The HRC invited Delegate Callsen, City Councilor Snook, and the City Attorney to share updates regarding Council’s legislative priorities and the process for bill sponsorship for the recommendations presented by the HRC in CY2023. • June 6, 2024: The HRC invited representatives from the Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless, Charlottesville Democratic Socialists of America, Charlottesville NAACP, Downtown Job Center, Home to Hope, and Region 10 to speak regarding city policy and state legislative priorities impacting housing and wraparound services for the people they support. • July 18, 2024: The HRC hosted Sen. Creigh Deeds, Del. Katrina Callsen, Laura Dobbs (Director of Policy for Housing Opportunities Made Equal), Dr. Elizabeth “PJ” Palmer Johnson (Alexandria Human Rights Commission Vice Chair), Michael Simms (Fairfax Human Rights and Equity Programs Director), and Dr. Virginia Jenkot (Virginia Beach Human Rights Commission Chair) for a discussion about state legislative priorities impacting housing and wraparound services for the people they support. • July 23, 2024: The HRC Chair and Vice Chair worked with the Community Outreach & Administrative Specialist to develop a public poll to solicit feedback regarding priority legislative and City policy issues. The HRC used this feedback to inform their state legislative and City policy recommendations to Council. The public poll ran from 7/23/24 through 7/30/24 and received 48 responses. • September 6, 2024: The HRC submitted its recommendations for City Council’s 2025 Legislative Agenda. A copy of these recommendations is included as attachment 9.6. HRC Recommendations for City Council’s 2025 Legislative Agenda. Page 145 of 289 40 7. HRC Policies Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance Sec. 2-433. (f) Prepare recommendations to City Council as to policies and procedures the HRC believes are necessary for the performance of the roles, duties and responsibilities assigned to the HRC within this article, and for modifications of operating procedures approved by City Council. This role is shared by the HRC and OHR and relates to all other duties and responsibilities detailed in the CHRO. Activities associated with this section generally include any changes to the CHRO and/or HRC Rules & Procedures. The HRC Rules & Procedures is a guiding document equivalent to bylaws that the HRC uses to codify protocols such as officer elections, meeting planning, and voting. As part of the two rounds of revisions made to the CHRO, two significant changes were made that affect the HRC’s roles, duties, and responsibilities: • First, the HRC voted to amend the procedures for public administrative hearings, as detailed in Sec. 2-439.1. The amendments included a move away from holding hearings involving live arguments and cross-examination from both parties in the complaint. Both appeal hearings for findings of no reasonable cause and hearings for findings of reasonable cause are now primarily a review of the investigatory record and finding, with the HRC reserving the authority to uphold or overturn the finding made by the Director. • Second, the amendments also included a substantial increase in the subpoena powers of the HRC, mirroring the same authority granted the OHR for investigation of complaints in Secs. 2-437.1, 2-437.2, and 2-437.3 of the CHRO. This expanded authority allows the HRC and OHR to petition the court for subpoenas of both material evidence as well as witness testimony for the purpose of completing an investigation or when the HRC requires additional information as part of the public hearing process. On December 19, 2024, the HRC also made minor changes to language in the HRC Rules & Procedures to clarify the nature and purpose of its Annual Planning Meeting. Page 146 of 289 41 8. Observations and Opportunities This section includes a summary of key takeaways from CY2024 pertaining to the work of the HRC and OHR. Most observations include references to sections of the report where relevant supporting information can be found. The observations and opportunities presented in this section are intended to highlight points that merit additional consideration and include staff recommendations for potential future action. 8.1. HRC Observations and Opportunities 8.1.1. Observations: In CY2024, the HRC further refined the annual planning process by defining specific focus areas, setting goals, and creating a work plan to guide its actions throughout the year. Despite this planning, the HRC was not able to take action within all of the planned focus areas. Opportunities: When HRC actions do not directly align with a focus area or goal they may still be valuable. This may suggest the following opportunities: • Refine the annual planning process to include space for creative actions in response to emerging and unanticipated events. • Consider ways to merge the focus areas and goals so that the alignment is easier to visualize during the planning process. • Examine the actions taken that were outside the specified focus areas and goals to determine if there is an area that deserves more attention in future planning processes. • Review the focus areas that did not receive attention in CY2024 and evaluate if they should be revisited in CY2025. Report sections for reference: • HRC Overview • 3.1. Sec. 2-433. (b) HRC Actions • CHRO Sec. 2-433. (c) – City Policies 8.1.2. Observations: In CY2024, the HRC engaged in multiple actions that aligned with CHRO Sec. 2-433. (b)(1), but it was not able to take any actions that aligned with CHRO Sec. 2-433. (b)(2). CHRO Sec. 2-433. (b)(2) states that the HRC shall conduct or engage in educational and informational programs for the promotion of mutual understanding, reconciliation, and respect between all classes of individuals protected by the ordinance and the larger community. In the current political climate this work is critically Page 147 of 289 42 important, but the OHR has had limited capacity to fully develop programming in this area in the last few years. The previous Director, Charlene Green, put significant energy into this work through the Dialogue on Race and other educational and collaborative programs throughout the city. Her departure, the disruptions caused by the COVID pandemic, an increased focus on addressing individual complaints of discrimination, and efforts to build and stabilize staffing in the OHR resulted in a diminished focus on educational and informational programming. Opportunities: In CY2025, the OHR must reimagine its organizational structure and develop and staffing plan that can support the work envisioned by CHRO Sec. 2-433. (b)(2): • Restructuring will likely require reclassification and potential hiring of staff. Any proposed increases in staffing costs for the remainder of fiscal year 2025 (FY2025) can only be covered by repurposing funds from the FY2025 OHR operating budget, as there is no funding for changes in staffing. • As the budget process for FY2026 is nearly complete, changes to staffing in FY2026 will need to be discussed with City Management, Human Resources, and the Budget Office, and proposed increases would likely need to be covered by repurposing funds from the vacant Intern position. • FY2027 presents the first opportunity for proposing the creation of additional positions as part of the budget development process. Report sections for reference: • 3. CHRO Sec. 2-433. (b) – Awareness and Guidance • 3.1. Sec. 2-433. (b) HRC Actions • 3.2. Sec. 2-433. (b) OHR Actions • 3.2.1. OHR Community Outreach Activities by Outreach Type 8.1.3. Observations: The HRC took two actions under CHRO Sec. 2-433. (c) in CY2024. Much like CHRO Sec. 2-433. (b), the work envisioned by this section is community- focused and of a systemic nature. As noted above, this type of work merits more attention than it has received in the last few years. It requires a significant investment of time to do the research required to develop highly informed policy recommendations. This means the OHR will need to develop the staffing structure necessary to support the HRC in this work. Opportunities: As noted above, the OHR must develop a revised organizational structure and proposed staffing plan to be executed over the next two fiscal years to fully engage in the work envisioned by CHRO Sec. 2-433. (b). Page 148 of 289 43 It is worth noting that private-sector collaboration will be crucial for this work, but OHR staff will ultimately still be required to coordinate any collaborative efforts between the HRC, OHR, and community partners. Current staffing levels severely limit the feasibility of this work. Report sections for reference: • 3.2. Sec. 2-433. (b) OHR Actions • CHRO Sec. 2-433. (c) – City Policies 8.1.4. Observations: This observation is not based on data presented in this report but reflects the Director’s perspective over the past seven years of observing the HRC at work. The HRC is a diverse group of volunteers tasked with discussing and acting upon complex and sensitive social issues. Given FOIA requirements, Commissioners have very limited time and forums in which to get to know each other and learn to work with one another. Opportunities: The Commission has steadily improved its processes to strategically develop focus areas, goals, and an annual work plan. In CY2025, the HRC will welcome at least three new Commissioners. This may present an opportunity to engage in intentional work around group dynamics that could strengthen interpersonal understanding and amplify Commissioners’ ability to do difficult collaborative work. 8.2. OHR Observations and Opportunities 8.2.1. Observations: CY2024 was the first year that the OHR had employees in all key positions, but we also learned that there was very limited capacity to adapt when one or more positions are vacated. During the first half of the year, the OHR had four full-time employees and one part-time employee. During the second half of the year, the full-time Intake Specialist position had to be refilled, and the part-time Intern position was vacant for the last four months. This required remaining staff to hold additional responsibilities, which had a significant negative impact on workflow, productivity, and workplace morale. Opportunities: CY2025 presents an opportunity to reimagine the organizational structure of the OHR to ensure staff retention and wellbeing while creating space for new initiatives. The OHR could explore the following opportunities: • Review the OHR organizational structure against the work mandated by the CHRO, and evaluate which work was not fully realized due to insufficient staff capacity. Page 149 of 289 44 • Review the OHR organizational structure against the work mandated by the CHRO, and evaluate which duties are most vulnerable to a staff vacancy. • Using information gleaned from the analyses above, develop a proposed organizational structure that enables a more complete realization of the duties outlined in the CHRO, creates a reasonable workload for each position with space for new ideas, and ensures resilience when and if a position is vacated. Report sections for reference: • 1.3. OHR Overview • 3.2. Sec. 2-433. (b) OHR Actions 8.2.2. Observations: The OHR opened 13 complaints in CY2024, nearly doubling the number received in CY2023 and increasing the number of simultaneous investigations and cases in ongoing alternative dispute resolution. Opportunities: When evaluating the organizational structure of the OHR it may be important to consider the following questions: • At what point will the Investigator reach maximum capacity with open investigations, and what is the best strategy, both from a public service and financial standpoint, for addressing increased caseloads? • As the OHR sees an increase in the need for alternative dispute resolution services, what is the best strategy to meet the need? • Will moving more alternative dispute resolution in house create an excessive burden on staff that will limit their ability to fulfill other duties unless additional staff are hired? • What aspects of the intake process may need to be revised to efficiently process incoming inquiries, and how will complaints be processed when the Investigator has reached maximum capacity and alternative dispute resolution is not an option? Report sections for reference: • 2.2.1 Total Incoming Contacts • 2.2.9. Status of Complaints During the Calendar Year 8.2.3. Observations: The OHR handled 1,841 incoming contacts in CY2024, an average of 8 contacts per day, which included 13 complaints and 194 inquiries. The total number of incoming and outgoing contacts in CY2024 was 2,830, the majority of which were related to intake activity (1,062 contacts) and case administration (632 contacts). Opportunities: When evaluating the organizational structure of the OHR it may be important to consider the following questions: Page 150 of 289 45 • At what point will the Intake Specialist need assistance with managing incoming inquiries and processing complaints, what division of labor could be considered, and what is the best strategy to address any needs for additional staffing? • Will moving more alternative dispute resolution in house create an excessive burden on staff that will limit their ability to fulfill other duties unless additional staff are hired? Report sections for reference: • 2.2.1. Total Incoming Contacts • 2.2.6. Services Provided Through Individual Contacts 8.2.4. Observations: In CY2024, the OHR received 32 inquiries originating in Albemarle County. Opportunities: This may point to an opportunity for dialogue with Albemarle County about potential human and civil rights enforcement services. Report sections for reference: • 2.2.2. Total Inquiries and Complaints by Location • 9.2. OHR CY2024 Individual Service Data 8.2.5. Observations: Of the 194 inquiries received in CY2024, there were no inquiries received for the protected activities of private education or credit. Since CY2018, the OHR has received only one complaint of credit discrimination (which was later determined to be non-jurisdictional) and one inquiry pertaining to private education. Opportunities: It may be beneficial to research the following: • Are localities the only entities authorized under Virginia law to address complaints of discrimination in private education? • If other state or federal agencies exist that address private education discrimination, are there any statistics available as to the number of complaints received from different localities? • Similarly, are there any other entities authorized under Virginia law to address complaints of credit discrimination, and is there any data as to the number and origin of complaints received? It is important to note that the research considered above would require staff time and points to a need for added capacity to conduct such research. Additionally, if it was determined that there was an unmet need for services to populations affected by unlawful discrimination in these two protected activities, it may Page 151 of 289 46 require additional staff capacity to conduct outreach to these populations and to handle any resulting intake and investigation work that may result. Report sections for reference: • 2.2.3. Total Inquiries and Complaints by Protected Activity • 2.2.5. Total Complaints by Protected Activity and Protected Class 8.2.6. Observations: When reviewing the protected classes identified in inquiries and complaints received by the OHR from CY2018 through CY2024, it is notable that some protected classes are less frequently identified. Opportunities: It may be useful to devote additional staff time to analyzing the populations reached with current outreach strategies, identifying populations that may not be reached with current outreach strategies, and researching additional strategies for outreach that may reach previously unreached populations more successfully. For the OHR and HRC to remain supportive of all segments of the population, an amplification of outreach and creative community engagement may be necessary. Further, it may be imperative to put additional focus on populations more severely impacted by current federal policies. As noted above, any significant changes or increases in services provided to the community will require additional staff capacity. Report sections for reference: • 2.2.4. Total Combined Inquiries and Complaints by Protected Class • 2.2.5. Total Complaints by Protected Activity and Protected Class 8.2.7. Observations: Of the 408 incoming and outgoing contacts classified as navigation & advocacy, 140 of those contacts included some form of housing navigation service, and 89 included some manner of liaising with the Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority (CRHA). Opportunities: The OHR has made an intentional shift away from navigation & advocacy work, but there may be an unmet community demand for housing navigation services and a more specific demand for navigating interactions with CRHA. This data is likely also indicative of the larger systemic problems in housing, including insufficient emergency shelter and wraparound services for people facing homelessness, unchecked rising rental costs, and high eviction rates. Page 152 of 289 47 The HRC will have the opportunity to consider these and other issues during the CY2025 annual planning meeting in March. While the OHR cannot reengage in navigation & advocacy services in ways it has done in the past, there may be additional policy and impact work that can be undertaken by the HRC that might relate to the underlying issues. This may be the moment for the OHR and HRC to reimagine navigation & advocacy: moving it away from work that addresses disparate treatment of individuals to work that address the disparate impact on protected populations. This shift would align with Sec. 2-433(b), 2-433(c), and 2-433(e) of the CHRO. As noted above, any additional services, including administrative support of the HRC for policy and impact work, will require additional staffing. Report section for reference: • 2.2.7. Navigation & Advocacy 8.2.8. Observations: When key OHR staff positions were vacated in CY2024, remaining OHR staff took on additional work to cover the vacancies. This placed a significant strain on staff capacity, negatively impacted the OHR’s ability to advance new and ongoing initiatives, and caused a decline in staff morale. Because of her longer tenure and knowledge of OHR systems, Lily Gates, Community Outreach & Administrative Specialist, took on most of the duties left unattended by departed staff, which the Director was unable to assume during the hiring and training process. This included handling intake work that was formerly held by the Intake Specialist and HRC administrative work formerly held by the Intern and the Director. Staff vacancies in an office as small as the OHR can cause significant impacts to productivity, innovation, and staff morale. The second half of CY2024 was a painful reminder that the OHR is still in a growth phase and has not yet found the optimal staffing levels or organizational structure required to fulfill all the mandates presented in the CHRO. While the receipt and attempted resolution of individual complaints of unlawful discrimination is a major component of the OHR and HRC’s duties under the CHRO, sections 2-433(b) and 2-433(c) present a very broad mandate regarding community engagement, policy, and systemic impact work. Over the last few years, the OHR has emphasized building and strengthening the services provided to individuals. In doing so, it has not put less focus on community engagement and systemic impact work. CY2025 presents an opportunity for organizational re-structuring to better support this work. Opportunities: In the coming years, the OHR needs to evaluate the scope of work mandated by the CHRO and develop a staffing structure that allows the office to fulfill its essential duties without overburdening individual staff and creates space for the expansion of community engagement, policy, and systemic impact work. Page 153 of 289 48 Report sections for reference: • 1.3. OHR Overview • 3.2. Sec.2-433. (b) OHR Actions • 3.2.1. OHR Community Outreach Activities by Outreach Type 8.2.9. Observations: In CY2024, the HRC and OHR made significant strides toward entering a FHAP workshare, as contemplated by CHRO Sec. 2-433. (e). As of the writing of this report, the HUD FHAP Director has affirmed that the City will likely qualify for interim FHAP certification in the spring of CY2025. Opportunities: CY2025 marks the culmination of a four-year journey toward interim FHAP certification. It comes at a time when funding from the federal government is both in limited supply and may come with new requirements that could fundamentally conflict with the visions, values, and commitments of the City. Entering the FHAP interim certification should be carefully considered by City Council, City Management, and the City Attorney’s Office during the spring of CY2025 to assess whether such agreement would be in the best interest of the organization. Report section for reference: • Sec. 2-433. (d) OHR Actions 8.2.10. Observations: In CY2024, the HRC built upon its success in CY2023 by again developing a work plan to support the information-gathering required to write and submit timely legislative recommendations to City Council. It is important to note that most of the administrative support required to make this process happen has come from the Community Outreach & Administrative Specialist. Fortunately, much of that support took place prior to the departure of the Intake Specialist and Intern during the second half of the year. However, it is important to note that OHR staffing vacancies could have a major impact on the HRC’s ability to effectively fulfill its duties under CHRO Sec. 2-433. (e). Opportunities: As noted in previous comments above, the OHR must evaluate organizational structure and create a long-term staffing plan that makes it feasible to fulfill the duties presented by the CHRO. Report sections for reference: • 1.3. OHR Overview • 3.2.1. OHR Community Outreach Activities by Outreach Type • 6. CHRO Sec. 2-433. (e) – Legislative Program Page 154 of 289 49 9. Attachments 9.1. OHR CY2024 Data Dictionary Term Definition Administrative Closure The dismissal of a complaint due to a complainant’s non- response for over 30 days, unwillingness to work in good faith with the Office of Human Rights, or threats to the wellbeing of City employees. AG OCR Liaison Any activity related to assisting an individual with accessing services of the Virginia Attorney General’s Office of Civil Rights (AG OCR), such as providing support for the filing of a complaint through the AG OCR. Alternative Dispute Resolution An attempt to resolve a complaint through informal dialogue, mediation, or conciliation. Application Assistance Any activity related to assisting individuals with applications to outside services, including jobs or services from agencies. Case A jurisdictional complaint of unlawful discrimination that has been accepted for further action by the Office of Human Rights. Case Administration The provision of services related to open complaints, including scheduling meetings, sending case notification letters, and other complaint management not defined as Mediation Activity, Intake Activity, or Investigation Activity. Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance A part of the Code of the City of Charlottesville found in Chapter 2, Article XV, that explains the roles and responsibilities of the Human Rights Commission and Office of Human Rights and defines the protected activities, protected classes, and enforcement mechanisms authorized to address unlawful discrimination within the jurisdiction of the City of Charlottesville. City Agency Liaison Any activity related to assisting an individual with accessing services provided by another office or department in the city. Clerical Support Providing access to a phone, computer, fax machine, printer, or comparable resource to an individual. Closed Complaint A complaint that is no longer being addressed by the Office of Human Rights. Reasons a Complaint may close include Administrative Closure, Conciliation, Court Action, Informal Resolution, No Response, Non-jurisdictional, Private Counsel, Referral, Settlement, Withdrawal, or a finding of No Reasonable Cause. Page 155 of 289 50 Term Definition Closed Inquiry An inquiry that is no longer being addressed by the Office of Human Rights. Reasons an inquiry may close include Informal Resolution, Navigation Only, No Response, or Referral. Complainant An individual or group of individuals who have filed a complaint of unlawful discrimination with the Office of Human Rights. Complaint A timely filing of a jurisdictional allegation of unlawful discrimination, as defined by the Human Rights Ordinance. Conciliation A form of Alternative Dispute Resolution by which Fair Housing Complaints may be resolved through facilitated formal dialogue between a Conciliator, the Complainant, the Respondent, and/or legal representation appointed by either party. Conciliation must be attempted in the period following the filing of the complaint and concluded prior to either the issuance of a charge on behalf of the complainant or upon dismissal of the complaint. Successful conciliation results in a Conciliation Agreement between the Complainant, the Respondent, and the City. In this Agreement, the role of the City is to enforce compliance and bring forth a case in court if the terms of the Conciliation Agreement are breached. Conciliation Activity Activity involving the provision of services related to attempts to resolve a Fair Housing Complaint through a Conciliation process; may include scheduling or updates to the status of Conciliation or the Conciliation Agreement. Contact All walk-ins, appointments, interactions in the community, phone calls, phone messages, text messages, emails, and postal mail related to services provided to an individual. Court Action Used when an Inquiry or Complaint is closed due to the filing of a civil suit in a court of competent jurisdiction. CRHA Liaison Any activity related to assisting an individual with accessing services provided by CRHA, including communication on behalf of the individual. Crisis Response Any activity related to assisting a community member with a crisis, including de-escalation. Determination A decision made by the Director regarding whether there is reasonable cause to believe that a violation of the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance has occurred. This decision is based on the evidence presented in an investigative report regarding a complaint of unlawful discrimination. This term is used synonymously with “Finding.” Page 156 of 289 51 Term Definition Dismissed Complaint A complaint that has been closed by the Director due to the case being outside the jurisdiction of the Office of Human Rights or due to a finding of no reasonable cause. DPOR Liaison Any activity related to assisting an individual with accessing the services of the Virginia Fair Housing Office with the the Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation (DPOR), such as providing support for the filing of a complaint through DPOR. EEOC Liaison Any activity related to a Navigation & Advocacy contact that involves assisting an individual with accessing the services of the federal Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), such as providing support for the filing of a complaint through the EEOC. Finding A decision made by the Director regarding whether there is reasonable cause to believe that a violation of the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance has occurred. This decision is based on the evidence presented in an investigative report regarding a complaint of unlawful discrimination. This term is used synonymously with “Determination.” Further Action Steps taken to address a complaint of discrimination that may include informal dialogue, conciliation, mediation, and/or investigation. Housing Navigation Any activity related to a Navigation & Advocacy contact that involves assisting individuals experiencing difficulty with matters related to housing. This may include facilitating dialogue with landlords, reviewing leases or ledgers, assisting with housing-related paperwork, accessing emergency housing resources, and more. Incoming Contact Any walk-ins, appointments, interactions in the community, phone calls, phone messages, text messages, emails, and postal mail from an individual seeking assistance from the Office of Human Rights or from a third-party entity. Individual Follow-up An incoming contact from an individual who has an open inquiry or complaint. Informal Dialogue A form of Alternative Dispute Resolution in which staff facilitate a conversation between the disputing parties in a jurisdictional complaint of discrimination with the intent of finding a mutually agreeable solution. Informal Resolution A cause for the closure of a case indicating that an agreement has been reached through informal dialogue or other informal means. Information A contact in which staff answers questions of a general nature or provides information regarding services provided to individuals by the Office of Human Rights. Page 157 of 289 52 Term Definition Inquiry An incoming contact requesting services provided to an individual by the Office of Human Rights and/or an individual allegation of discrimination that falls outside the jurisdiction of the office, as defined by the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance. Intake Activity A contact related to the provision of service following a Complaint or Inquiry including acquiring information to determine the type of service to be provided, setting appointments, and other services related to new requests for service. Investigation The process of gathering factual evidence regarding a complaint of discrimination. Fact gathering can include interviewing the Complainant, Respondent, and Witnesses. It may also include gathering other evidence such as documents, audio recordings, video footage, or physical evidence. Investigation Activity Any activity associated with the investigation of a complaint. Jurisdiction The geographic and legal scope of enforcement authority as defined by the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance. Legal Aid Liaison Any activity related to a Navigation & Advocacy contact that involves assisting individuals with accessing legal aid service organizations, including communicating on behalf of individuals or facilitating appointment set-up. Mediation A form of Alternative Dispute Resolution in which a qualified mediator facilitates a formal dialogue and negotiation between the Complainant and Respondent in a jurisdictional complaint of discrimination. If mediation is successful, the resulting settlement agreement is a private, legally binding contract between the Complainant and Respondent that is enforceable through civil action in the appropriate court. Mediation Activity Any activity associated with the request for or coordination of mediation services in conjunction with a complaint. Mental Health Navigation Any activity related to a Navigation & Advocacy contact that involves assisting individuals with accessing mental health services, including facilitating appointments, communicating with mental health organizations on behalf of individuals, or attending therapy appointments. Navigation & Advocacy A contact in which staff facilitates an individual’s connection to external resources, assists with access to other agencies’ services, or provides additional support that does not directly pertain to the filing and investigation of a complaint with the Office of Human Rights. Page 158 of 289 53 Term Definition Non-jurisdictional Indicates that a Complaint or Inquiry does not fall within the geographic and legal scope of enforcement authority as defined by the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance. Can be used as a reason for case closure. Open Complaint A complaint that is still being addressed by the Office of Human Rights. Open Inquiry An inquiry that is still being addressed by the Office of Human Rights. Other Agency Liaison Any activity related to a Navigation & Advocacy contact that involves assisting individuals with accessing services provided by a community organization not specifically listed and not affiliated with the City of Charlottesville. Outgoing Contact All service-related contacts initiated by Office of Human Rights staff. Prima facie Used generally, set of elements used to assess whether evidence gathered in an investigation supports an allegation of discrimination: • Complainant was engaged in a protected activity. • Complainant either self-identifies or is perceived by Respondent to be a member of a protected class. • There is testimonial or documentary evidence of a practice or policy to exclude or otherwise adversely treat individuals in Complainant’s protected class. • There are specific harms identified by Complainant as a result of the alleged discrimination. Private Counsel Used as a reason for Case or Inquiry closure to indicate that an individual chose to seek private legal counsel rather than further pursue the Complaint process through the Office of Human Rights. Protected Activity An activity of daily life in which a person who identifies as a member of a protected class can participate without fear of discrimination. The Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance lists the following activities as protected: housing, employment, public accommodation, credit, and private education. Page 159 of 289 54 Term Definition Protected Class A grouping of people, as defined by state and federal law, of which an individual either self-identifies as a member or is perceived to be a member, that is protected from discrimination when an individual is participating in a protected activity. The Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance lists the following classes as protected: • Age/Elderliness • Childbirth or related medical conditions • Disability • Familial Status (in housing) • Gender Identity • Marital Status • Military Status • National Origin • Pregnancy • Race • Religion • Sex • Sexual Orientation • Color • Source of Funds (in housing) Public Accommodation A protected activity relating to the use of public space or other services generally assumed to be available to the public. For example, patronage of a business, use of a park, ability to receive a vaccination at a pharmacy, etc. Public Hearing A service provided by the Human Rights Commission and coordinated by the Office of Human Rights, as specified by the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance, involving the recommendation of remedies related to either a determination of reasonable cause after the investigation of a complaint or a review of a determination of no reasonable cause at the request of the complainant. Referral A recommendation made by OHR staff for an individual to contact another agency in order to address a concern raised during an individual contact with the Office of Human Rights. Respondent An individual, group of individuals, or agency that is named by the complainant in a complaint of unlawful discrimination as responsible for a discriminatory act against the complainant. Safe Space Any activity related to a Navigation & Advocacy contact that involves the provision of a safe and comfortable space to an individual experiencing a form of difficulty. Page 160 of 289 55 Term Definition Settlement Used as a reason for Case closure to indicate that a settlement was reached between the Complainant and Respondent meaning that further action by the Office of Human Rights Staff is not needed. Staff Follow-up An outgoing contact in which staff communicates with an individual who has previously contacted the Office. Third-Party Incoming Contact An incoming contact with a person other than the individual directly involved with an inquiry or complaint being discussed. Third-Party Outgoing Contact An outgoing contact with a person other than the individual directly involved with an inquiry or complaint being discussed. The person directly involved must give verbal or written consent for staff to initiate a third-party outgoing contact. Translation Services Any activity related to a Navigation & Advocacy contact that involves assisting individuals with language access, including translating documents or facilitating communication across a language barrier. Unlawful Discrimination The denial of a person’s opportunity to engage in a protected activity, on the basis of their membership or perceived membership in a protected class. Withdrawal A reason for complaint closure indicating that an individual has chosen to rescind their complaint and halt further action on behalf of Office of Human Rights Staff. Page 161 of 289 56 9.2. OHR CY2024 Individual Service Data Measures Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTALS Open office days in the month 22 20 20 22 22 19 22 22 20 23 18 20 250 Total Incoming & Outgoing Contacts 171 178 100 419 387 237 154 211 229 323 219 202 2830 Total Incoming Contacts 121 154 56 354 276 124 89 102 139 196 116 114 1841 Average Incoming & Outgoing Contacts/Day 8 9 5 19 18 12 7 10 11 14 12 10 11 Average Incoming Contacts/Day 6 8 3 16 13 7 4 5 7 9 6 6 7 Total Unique Individuals Served (rough count due to some anonymous contacts) 242 Contacts in Spanish 6 1 0 6 0 1 1 5 5 7 0 3 35 Total Staff Follow-ups (Outgoing) 37 16 28 54 72 60 35 40 48 68 49 65 572 Total Third-Party Contacts (Outgoing) 13 8 16 11 39 53 30 69 42 59 54 23 417 Total Individual Follow-ups (Incoming) 81 128 16 311 222 76 29 56 68 111 54 81 1233 Total Third-Party Contacts (Incoming) 18 10 23 31 35 35 34 34 53 66 48 14 401 Total Inquiries (Incoming) 20 15 17 11 16 13 24 12 17 19 13 17 194 Total Complaints (Incoming) 2 1 0 1 3 0 2 0 1 0 1 2 13 Total Duration of all Incoming and Outgoing Contacts 27.21 21.12 10.79 39.75 36.35 27.03 27.27 31.17 30.00 46.29 27.02 34.08 358.08 Total Duration of Conciliation Activity Contacts 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Total Duration of Informal Dialogue Contacts 0.00 0.00 1.38 0.00 0.00 0.33 0.75 0.16 1.41 0.25 2.00 3.35 9.63 Total Duration of Information Contacts 3.44 1.12 0.64 3.77 1.45 3.79 3.96 6.31 3.66 10.41 3.36 3.36 45.27 Total Duration of Intake Activity Contacts 16.85 12.83 3.92 30.20 13.36 5.99 11.69 4.83 5.73 17.86 8.31 19.39 150.96 Total Duration of Investigation Activity Contacts 0.33 0.40 0.08 0.00 0.16 2.55 5.23 0.48 1.97 2.64 0.81 1.47 16.12 Total Duration of Mediation Activity Contacts 0.08 0.00 1.45 0.48 0.96 2.09 0.40 0.08 0.00 0.00 0.08 0.00 5.62 Total Duration of Case Administration Contacts 0.40 1.22 1.46 3.58 19.51 8.56 0.56 9.29 6.99 8.14 5.41 2.68 67.80 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (All Staff) 6.11 5.55 1.86 1.72 0.91 3.72 4.68 10.02 10.24 6.99 7.05 3.83 62.68 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (TN) 4.22 1.07 0.56 1.48 0.50 3.39 3.87 9.86 9.92 6.34 5.39 2.18 48.78 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (CC) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (TN & CC) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (LG) 0.08 0.00 0.00 0.08 0.00 0.00 0.81 0.16 0.24 0.08 0.00 0.00 1.45 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (SK) 1.56 4.48 1.22 0.16 0.41 0.33 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 8.16 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (GH) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (TN & SK) 0.25 0.00 0.08 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.33 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (LH) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.08 0.57 0.66 1.65 2.96 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (TN & LH) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 0.00 1.00 Total Duration of Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (CC & LH) 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Duration N&A Contacts (All Staff) out of Duration of All Contacts (%) 22% 26% 17% 4% 3% 14% 17% 32% 34% 15% 26% 11% 18% Total Duration of N&A Application Assistance Contacts 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Total Duration of N&A AG OCR Liaison Contacts 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.08 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.08 Total Duration of N&A City Agency Liaison Contacts 2.49 0.33 0.00 0.25 0.00 0.75 0.57 0.08 0.00 0.73 0.64 0.16 6.00 Total Duration of N&A Clerical Support Contacts 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 Total Duration of N&A CRHA Liaison Contacts 0.48 0.08 0.24 0.00 0.00 0.32 0.99 4.67 2.98 1.66 0.24 0.08 11.74 Total Duration of N&A Crisis Response Contacts 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.33 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.33 Total Duration of N&A DPOR Liaison Contacts 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.50 0.50 Page 162 of 289 57 Measures Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTALS Total Duration of N&A EEOC Liaison Contacts 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.08 0.08 0.00 0.08 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.24 Total Duration of N&A Housing Navigation Contacts 0.33 0.16 0.24 0.89 0.66 1.25 1.71 4.12 3.84 1.84 2.04 2.18 19.26 Total Duration of N&A Legal Aid Liaison Contacts 0.00 0.75 0.65 0.00 0.25 0.00 0.08 0.00 0.00 0.08 0.00 0.25 2.06 Total Duration of N&A Mental Health Navigation Contacts 0.00 0.00 0.24 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.24 Total Duration of N&A Other Agency Liaison Contacts 0.41 0.16 0.16 0.41 0.00 1.16 1.57 1.89 3.09 3.61 2.46 1.12 16.04 Total Duration of N&A Other Contacts 2.07 0.57 0.33 0.33 0.00 0.16 0.16 0.83 0.50 0.24 1.25 0.41 6.85 Total Duration of N&A Translation Services Contacts 0.50 0.25 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.08 0.00 0.00 0.83 Total Duration of N&A Safe Space Contacts 0.75 0.25 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.00 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts 31 18 19 13 5 15 31 60 86 58 41 31 408 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (CC) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (TN) 19 6 7 10 2 13 23 58 82 52 37 22 331 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (LG) 1 0 0 1 0 0 8 2 3 1 0 0 16 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (GH) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (SK) 10 12 11 2 3 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 40 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (LH) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 5 3 9 18 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (TN & LH) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (CC & LH) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (TN & SK) 1 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 Total Incoming & Outgoing Navigation & Advocacy Contacts (TN & CC) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Percentage: Navigation & Advocacy out of Total Contacts 18% 10% 19% 3% 1% 6% 20% 28% 38% 18% 19% 15% 14% Total N&A Application Assistance Contacts 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total N&A AG OCR Liaison Contacts 2 4 2 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 3 2 16 Total N&A City Agency Liaison Contacts 10 2 0 1 0 1 5 1 0 7 8 2 37 Total N&A Clerical Support Contacts 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total N&A CRHA Liaison Contacts 6 1 3 0 0 4 4 31 32 4 3 1 89 Total N&A Crisis Response Contacts 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 2 Total N&A DPOR Liaison Contacts 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total N&A EEOC Liaison Contacts 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 3 Total N&A Housing Navigation Contacts 2 2 3 9 4 2 15 18 26 23 14 22 140 Total N&A Legal Aid Liaison Contacts 0 2 6 0 1 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 12 Total N&A Mental Health Navigation Contacts 0 0 3 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 Total N&A Other Agency Liaison Contacts 0 0 3 2 0 0 3 0 1 1 0 1 11 Total N&A Other Contacts 8 5 2 2 0 2 2 2 1 3 2 3 32 Total N&A Translation Services Contacts 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 3 Total N&A Safe Space Contacts 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 Total Inquiries: P.A. - Employment 4 4 4 1 4 4 10 1 5 2 5 8 52 Total Inquiries: P.A. - Housing 7 0 1 1 7 6 10 2 5 8 2 4 53 Total Inquiries: P.A. - Public Accommodation 5 1 3 0 2 0 1 1 0 2 1 0 16 Total Inquiries: P.A. - Credit 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Inquiries: P.A. - Private Education 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Inquiries: P.A. - Other (Unprotected) 4 10 9 9 3 3 3 8 7 7 5 5 73 Total Complaints: P.A. - Employment 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 0 1 0 1 1 5 Page 163 of 289 58 Measures Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTALS Total Complaints: P.A. - Housing 2 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 5 Total Complaints: P.A. - Public Accommodation 0 1 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 Total Complaints: P.A. - Credit 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Complaints: P.A. - Private Education 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Complaints: P.A. - Other (Unprotected) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Inquiries & Complaints 4 4 4 1 5 4 11 1 6 2 6 9 57 Employment inquiries & complaints in Charlottesville 2 1 2 1 2 2 4 0 6 2 2 6 30 Employment inquiries in Albemarle Co. 2 1 1 0 3 0 5 1 0 0 2 3 18 Employment inquiries in other and unspecified localities 0 2 1 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 2 0 9 Total Housing Inquiries & Complaints 9 0 1 2 7 6 11 2 5 8 2 5 58 Housing inquiries & complaints in Charlottesville 5 0 1 2 4 3 3 2 3 8 2 4 37 Housing inquiries in Albemarle Co. 4 0 0 0 1 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 9 Housing inquiries in other and unspecified localities 0 0 0 0 2 1 2 0 2 0 0 1 8 Total Public Accommodation Inquiries & Complaints 5 2 3 0 4 0 1 1 0 2 1 0 19 Public accommodation inquiries & complaints in Charlottesville 4 2 1 0 2 0 0 1 0 2 1 0 13 Public accommodation inquiries in Albemarle Co. 1 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 Public accommodation inquiries in other and unspecified localities 0 0 2 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 Total Credit Inquiries & Complaints 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Credit inquiries & complaints in Charlottesville 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Credit inquiries in Albemarle Co. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Credit inquiries in other and unspecified localities 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Private Education Inquiries & Complaints 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Private education inquiries & complaints in Charlottesville 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Private education inquiries in Albemarle Co. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Private education inquiries in other and unspecified localities 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Other (Unprotected) Inquiries & Complaints 4 10 9 9 3 3 3 8 7 7 5 5 73 Other (Unprotected) inquiries & complaints in Charlottesville 0 2 5 2 0 0 1 3 0 1 2 0 16 Other (Unprotected) inquiries in Albemarle Co. 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 0 1 0 3 Other (Unprotected) inquiries in other and unspecified localities 4 8 4 7 3 2 2 5 6 6 2 5 54 Total Complaints in Charlottesville 2 1 0 1 3 0 2 0 1 0 1 2 13 Total Inquiries in Charlottesville 9 4 9 4 5 5 10 6 8 13 6 8 87 Total Inquiries in Albemarle Co. 7 1 1 0 5 3 7 1 1 0 3 3 32 Total Inquiries in other and unspecified localities 4 10 7 7 5 5 7 5 8 6 4 6 74 Total I&C: P.C. - Age 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 1 0 0 4 Total I&C: P.C. - Elderliness (Housing) 2 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 2 0 1 7 Total I&C: P.C. - Disability 6 1 3 2 8 1 5 1 2 5 3 5 42 Total I&C: P.C. - National Origin 3 3 0 0 0 1 5 1 2 0 0 2 17 Total I&C: P.C. - Pregnancy 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total I&C: P.C. - Childbirth or Related Medical Conditions 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total I&C: P.C. - Familial Status (Housing) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 1 Total I&C: P.C. - Race 1 1 0 1 1 1 2 0 0 0 2 3 12 Total I&C: P.C. - Color 0 0 1 1 1 0 4 0 0 0 0 0 7 Page 164 of 289 59 Measures Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTALS Total I&C: P.C. - Religion 0 0 0 0 0 2 2 0 0 0 0 0 4 Total I&C: P.C. - Sex 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 0 1 1 5 Total I&C: P.C. - Gender Identity 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 2 Total I&C: P.C. - Sexual Orientation 0 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 4 Total I&C: P.C. - Source of Funds (Housing) 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 2 Total I&C: P.C. - Military Status 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 2 Total I&C: P.C. - Not specified 9 10 13 8 9 5 8 7 10 10 5 7 101 Total I&C: P.C. - Marital Status 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 Total I&C: P.C. - Retaliation 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 3 Total I&C: P.C. - Other (Unprotected) 2 1 0 0 0 2 4 3 3 1 3 1 20 Total Contacts resulting in Referrals 4 2 4 1 5 2 10 2 0 0 2 3 35 Referrals to AG OCR 3 1 4 0 4 1 4 0 0 0 2 0 19 Referrals to AIM 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to APS 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Referrals to CPD 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to CPS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to CRHA 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Referrals to CRL 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 2 Referrals to CVLAS 1 0 0 1 1 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 5 Referrals to DARS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to DBHDS 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Referrals to DHS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to DJC 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to DLC 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Referrals to DOJ 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Referrals to DPOR 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to EEOC 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 3 Referrals to EHC 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to FIC 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to H2H 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to HIL 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Referrals to HOME 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 1 2 Referrals to IP 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to LAJC 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 1 0 0 0 1 5 Referrals to N2Work 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to PCOB 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 Referrals to PHA 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to PHA FOC 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Referrals to PHA Mediation 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to PHP 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to PMH 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to R10 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Page 165 of 289 60 Measures Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTALS Referrals to Ready Kids 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to SARA 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to SB 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to SHE 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Referrals to Haven 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to UVA WC 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to VLRS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Referrals to Other 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Contacts related to Community/Systemic Issue 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Related to CRHA 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Related to PHA 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Related to The Haven 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Related to Salvation Army 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Related to VEC 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Related to ACOH 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Age 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Childbirth or R.M.C. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Color 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Disability 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Gender Identity 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Marital Status 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 2 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Military Status 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - National Origin 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Not specified 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Other (Unprotected) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Pregnancy 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Race 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Religion 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Sex 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1 Total Employment Complaints: P.C. - Sexual Orientation 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Elderliness (Housing) 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Childbirth or R.M.C. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Color 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Disability 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 3 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Familial Status (Housing) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Gender Identity 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Marital Status 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Military Status 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - National Origin 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Not specified 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Other (Unprotected) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Pregnancy 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Page 166 of 289 61 Measures Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTALS Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Race 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 2 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Religion 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Sex 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Sexual Orientation 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Housing Complaints: P.C. - Source of Funds (Housing) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 1 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Age 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Childbirth or R.M.C. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Color 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Disability 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Gender Identity 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Marital Status 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Military Status 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - National Origin 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Not specified 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Other (Unprotected) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Pregnancy 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Race 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Religion 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Sex 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Pub. Accom. Comp.: P.C. - Sexual Orientation 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Total Open Inquiries 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 4 3 10 18 Total Closed Inquiries 20 15 17 11 15 13 24 12 17 15 10 7 176 Total Open Complaints 1 1 0 1 1 0 2 0 1 0 1 2 10 Total Closed Complaints 1 0 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 Reason for Complaint Closure: Conciliation 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reason for Complaint Closure: Court Action 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reason for Complaint Closure: Informal Resolution 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reason for Complaint Closure: No Response 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Reason for Complaint Closure: Non-jurisdictional 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reason for Complaint Closure: Private Counsel 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reason for Complaint Closure: Referred Case 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Reason for Complaint Closure: Settlement 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reason for Complaint Closure: Withdrawal 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reason for Complaint Closure: Finding 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Reason for Complaint Closure: Administrative Closure 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 Reason for Inquiry Closure: Informal Resolution 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 0 0 0 0 0 3 Reason for Inquiry Closure: Navigation Only 15 8 12 3 9 10 17 6 13 14 10 7 124 Reason for Inquiry Closure: No Response 4 6 5 7 5 1 1 5 1 1 0 0 36 Reason for Inquiry Closure: Referral 0 0 0 0 0 1 2 1 0 0 0 0 4 Reason for Inquiry Closure: Complaint Filed 1 1 0 1 1 0 2 0 3 0 0 0 9 Primary Service: Case Administration 5 10 13 30 227 87 7 49 59 66 56 23 632 Primary Service: Conciliation Activity 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Page 167 of 289 62 Measures Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTALS Primary Service: Informal Dialogue 0 0 13 0 0 2 3 2 3 1 25 21 70 Primary Service: Information 43 14 8 45 16 39 38 61 31 128 42 42 507 Primary Service: Intake Activity 89 131 30 325 125 56 55 32 37 61 46 75 1062 Primary Service: Investigation Activity 2 5 1 0 2 14 15 6 13 9 8 10 85 Primary Service: Mediation Activity 1 0 16 6 12 24 5 1 0 0 1 0 66 Primary Service: Navigation & Advocacy 31 18 19 13 5 15 31 60 86 58 41 31 408 Page 168 of 289 63 9.3. OHR CY2024 Community Outreach Data Measures Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTALS Open office days in the month 22 20 20 22 22 19 22 22 20 23 18 20 250 Total service provision events 3 6 2 5 6 5 4 4 3 5 2 5 50 Total education & awareness events 2 1 0 4 0 0 1 0 1 0 0 0 9 Total collaboration & leadership events 12 12 16 22 19 14 17 19 11 12 14 19 187 Total outreach activities 17 19 18 31 25 19 22 23 15 17 16 24 246 Total unique primary collaborators (estimate) No monthly count only total count 76 Total collaborative activities 16 17 17 29 24 18 20 21 14 16 13 22 227 Total attendees at service provision events 79 146 5 48 77 142 53 87 95 36 9 54 831 Total attendees at education & awareness events 104 0 0 152 0 0 20 0 0 0 0 0 276 Total newsletter opens 357 380 369 335 346 342 349 373 343 431 391 377 4393 OHR-led education & awareness - employment 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - housing 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 OHR-led education & awareness - public accommodation 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 OHR-led education & awareness - credit 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - private education 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - multiple activities 0 0 0 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 3 OHR-led education & awareness - age/elderliness 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - childbirth or r.m.c. 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - color 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2 OHR-led education & awareness - disability 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 OHR-led education & awareness - familial status (housing) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - source of funds (housing) 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 OHR-led education & awareness - gender identity 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - marital status 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - national origin 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - pregnancy 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - race 1 0 0 2 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 OHR-led education & awareness - religion 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - sex 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 OHR-led education & awareness - sexual orientation 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - veteran status 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 OHR-led education & awareness - multiple classes 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 Page 169 of 289 64 9.4. HRC Recommendations for Housing Policies December 23, 2024 Dear Mayor Wade and City Councilors, Pursuant to Sec. 2-433.(c) of the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance, it is the role of the Human Rights Commission to “identify and review systemic issues, policies, and practices of the City of Charlottesville and advise its boards, commissions, and other public agencies within the City on issues related to human rights.” During our annual planning meeting on March 9, 2024, Commissioners identified housing as the primary focus of their work in 2024. Commissioners sought feedback from community members and subject matter experts regarding specific, city level priorities that may have both local and regional impacts on housing. The Commission is deeply grateful for the budget recommendations that City Manager Sanders has put forth with regards to housing and we strongly encourage City Council to support and pass a budget that includes all of the housing recommendations, which we elaborate on in the letter below. At its work session on November 7, 2024, the Commission unanimously voted to recommend and/or affirm the following housing-related City policy and practice priorities for your consideration as Council prepares its annual budget and priorities. 1. Equitable and Low-Barrier Year-Round Shelter We affirm City Council’s exploration of the establishment of a year-round shelter that is equitable and low-barrier, with a specific focus on addressing the needs of LGBTQ+ individuals and families, while upholding the protections provided in the City's Human Rights Ordinance. The need for additional shelter for the unhoused population is critical and ensuring that services are provided equitably is equally important. 2. “Effective Right to Counsel” in Eviction Proceedings We recommend that City Council set funding for legal counsel for tenants facing evictions at a sufficient level to meet the needs of City residents facing evictions. Tenants with representation are far more likely to be able to raise legal defenses and remain housed. In 2021, our letter to City Counsel applauded the City’s initiative in providing tenants lawyers in eviction proceedings during ii the COVID-19 pandemic, but we recognize that providing counsel to tenants in eviction proceedings is important and necessary at all times. We will be following up with a letter that further underscores our support for providing universal counsel to tenants in eviction proceedings as well as regional examples where this has been done effectively. Page 170 of 289 65 3. Supports for Homelessness We affirm the City Manager’s recommendation to include in the budget a Homeless Services Coordinator and two Street Outreach positions. We furthermore affirm the policy recommendations discussed during the City Council Work Session on October 21st, including Pallet shelters, public bathrooms, continued annual funding for BRACH, and operational funding for a future low-barrier shelter. The Commission welcomes questions, feedback, and dialogue with City Council about these recommendations. Please do not hesitate to reach out to me or the Office of Human Rights should you have any questions prior to making your recommendations or if you wish to schedule a time to meet. Sincerely, Ernest S. Chambers Chair Human Rights Commission Page 171 of 289 66 9.5. HRC Recommendations for Effective Right to Counsel December 23, 2024 Dear Mayor Wade and City Councilors, In April and August 2021, we wrote to you in support of an effort to provide universal counsel to tenants in eviction proceedings. We were pleased that City Council recognized this was an important means of protecting tenants and allocated funds toward this effort. However, as we understand it, the funding allocated was temporary COVID funding and was never sufficient to provide coverage for all, or even most, tenants in eviction proceedings. Having a lawyer changes matters dramatically for tenants. Most landlords have lawyers, but the research also reflects that landlords do not need representation to prevail in court in eviction cases.1 But tenants absolutely do. Tenants are significantly — up to 19 times — more likely to avoid eviction if they have legal representation.2 Eviction has lasting economic consequences for families. An eviction makes it dramatically harder to find housing in the future. The children of families who face evictions are far more likely to be forced to live in substandard housing, which can imperil the health of children and other family members. Families with children are twice as likely to face eviction than families without children. Nationally, 90 percent of landlords are represented by legal counsel in evictions, but fewer than 10 percent of tenants have representation. Black women are 1.4 times more likely to be served an eviction notice across all renter groups. This issue disproportionately affects people of color, and thus, the Human Rights Commission considers this an urgent matter of racial justice that our City must confront. As of 2023, three states and 15 cities nationwide established right-to-counsel policies and programs. Two cost-benefit analyses in New York and Pennsylvania of right-to-counsel programs found that the programs saved localities money while preventing evictions and displacement of families. In September 2024, Richmond passed a resolution and a recent budget allocation of $500,000 to create a pilot program to serve an expected 450 tenants facing eviction. Preventing unnecessary evictions is good for tenants and good for our community. As one scholar stated: “a right to counsel in eviction proceedings means tenants, and society at large are more likely to avoid persistent homelessness, drains on material and emotional wellbeing, increased emergency room use, and increased risk of mental health hospitalization.” Eviction is a gender justice issue, a racial justice issue, an economic justice issue, a children’s rights issue, and a civil liberties issue. The research on right-to-counsel programs demonstrates that it prevents the serious harms of eviction, gives families a fighting chance to stay in their 1 Ericka Petersen, Building a House for Gideon: The Right to Counsel in Evictions, 16 Stan. J. C.R. & C.L. 63, 85 (2020). 2 Id. Page 172 of 289 67 homes and communities, and is a budgetary gain for localities. Ensuring a right to counsel for renters in eviction proceedings is vital to address systemic inequity and our nation’s inexcusable failure to invest in affordable housing. Thank you for your service to our community and for your attention to these issues. Please contact the Human Rights Commission if you have questions or would like to discuss this topic further. Sincerely, Ernest Chambers Chair Human Rights Commission Page 173 of 289 68 9.6. HRC Recommendations for City Council’s 2025 Legislative Agenda September 3, 2024 Dear Mayor Wade and City Councilors, Pursuant to Sec. 2-433.(e) of the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance, it is the role of the Human Rights Commission to “make recommendations regarding the City’s annual legislative programs and policies that will address discrimination.” During their annual planning meeting on March 9, 2024, Commissioners identified housing as the primary focus of their work in 2024. Commissioners sought feedback from community members and subject matter experts regarding specific, state-level legislation that may have both local and regional impacts on housing. At its regular meeting on August 15th, 2024, the Commission voted to recommend the following housing-related legislative priorities for your consideration as Council prepares its legislative recommendations for the Thomas Jefferson Area Planning District Commission for referral to the General Assembly. The Human Rights Commission recommends that Council support enabling legislation related to the following key areas: 1. Access to Housing: a. Limit application fees for rental applications and/or allow groups of tenants to submit a single application. b. Require more transparency during the tenant screening process. Require landlords to list minimum criteria before an application and provide reasons for a tenant’s application denial. Require any fee increases to coincide with the terms of a lease. c. Establish a state-sponsored voucher program to increase the accessibility of rental subsidies. d. Support voucher portability, permitting voucher holders to apply a voucher outside of where that voucher was administered. e. Increase state funding for rent relief programs. 2. Tenant Rights: a. Reinstate 14-day pay or quit notices. Tenants are currently given 5 days to pay, or an eviction proceeding can commence. This legislative recommendation would expand the time tenants are able to pay. b. Amend the Virginia Residential Landlord and Tenant Act to allow tenants to raise unsafe or unsanitary conditions as an affirmative defense to non-payment of rent. Page 174 of 289 69 c. Increase protections against landlord retaliation. Include harassment, non-lease renewal, etc., as forms of landlord retaliation. d. Require that critical lease information be made available in languages other than English. e. Create an option for rental payment plans. f. Allow indigent tenants to waive their appeal bond. This would grant indigent tenants the same rights that exist for indigent people in other types of civil cases. g. Prevent eviction or threats of eviction as being used as methods of coercion for rent payments. h. Include provisions in the VA Residential Landlord and Tenant Act and the Manufactured Home Lot Rental Act to prohibit mid-lease rent increases except in cases where the renter has agreed in writing that the proposed mid-lease rent increase is permissible. i. Take rent control out of the Dillon Rule process, making it more possible for localities to add rent stabilization to their local control. j. Improve manufactured homes (mobile homes) to give them the ability to buy their communities when an owner wants to sell. This would give tenants first right of refusal and keep a property as a mobile home park. 3. A Focus on Homelessness: a. Support comprehensive probation reform bill that would offer more support to those experiencing re-entry. b. Allocate Medicare and Medicaid funds for addressing homelessness and affordable housing. c. Recognize homelessness as a protected class in the Virginia Human Rights Act and Virginia Fair Housing Law to prohibit discrimination based upon an individual’s housing status. d. Require that each county and city in Virginia maintain a public shelter for individuals or fund a private equivalent. Page 175 of 289 70 4. Wrap-around Services: a. Support the development of increased services for those experiencing mental illness and substance abuse. b. Increase public mental health care funding. 5. Other: 6. Implement a progressive income tax and taxes for consumer services. The resultant increase in the tax base should produce a subsequent increase in funding available for affordable housing. The Commission welcomes questions, feedback, and dialogue with City Council about these recommendations. The Commission also requests that Council communicate regarding the recommendations included in its proposal to the Thomas Jefferson Area Planning District. Commissioners look forward to planning with Council in advance of submitting legislative recommendations next year. Please do not hesitate to reach out to me or the Office of Human Rights should you have any questions prior to making your recommendations or if you wish to schedule a time to meet. Sincerely, Ernest Chambers Chair Human Rights Commission Page 176 of 289 Annual Report Summary City of Charlottesville Human Rights Commission & Office of Human Rights Calendar Year 2024 Annual Report Summary Presented by Todd Niemeier, Director, Human Rights Commission Heather Roberson-Gaston, Chair, Human Rights Commission Page 177 of 289 Contents Contents 1. Commission and Office Overview 2. Calendar Year 2024 Highlights 3. Observations and Opportunities 4. Human Rights Commission Work Plan Page 178 of 289 Human Rights Division of the City Manager’s Office Human Rights Division of the City Manager’s Office Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance (CHRO) City code Chapter 2, Article XV Human Rights Commission (HRC) Office of Human Rights (OHR) • 9 volunteer members • Addresses systemic issues • Conducts community outreach • Advises City Council • 4 full-time staff • Addresses individual complaints • Conducts community outreach • Supports the HRC Page 179 of 289 Office of Human Organizational Structure Office of Human Rights Organizational Structure City Manager (Samuel Sanders Jr.) Deputy City Manager Social Equity (Ashley Reynolds-Marshall) Director Human Rights Commission (Todd Niemeier) Human Rights Investigator (Chyelle Chatman) Human Rights Intake Specialist (Lauren Harris) Community Outreach & Administrative Specialist (Lily Gates) Page 180 of 289 The Human Rights Ordinance The Human Rights Ordinance Under Section 2-433 of the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance, it is the role of the Human Rights Commission and Office of Human Rights to: • 2-433.(a): Assist individuals with complaints of discrimination. • 2-433.(b): Provide awareness, education, and guidance. • 2-433.(c): Review City policies. • 2-433.(d): Seek federal workshare agreements with the EEOC and HUD. • 2-433.(e): Make legislative recommendations to City Council. • 2-433.(f): Prepare recommendations for City Council related to the function of the Commission. Page 181 of 289 2-433.(a): Individual Assistance 2-433.(a): Individual Assistance Highlights • 288 unique individuals served • 13 complaints opened • 1,841 incoming contacts Observations • Complaints nearly doubled • Simultaneous investigations increased • Multiple cases in alternative dispute resolution Opportunities • Consider anticipated workloads and personnel requirements o Intake and alternative dispute resolution o Investigation o Outreach to populations not being reached Page 182 of 289 2-433.(b): Awareness and Guidance 2-433.(b): Awareness and Guidance Highlights • 833 people contacted through service provision outreach • 246 total community outreach activities • 276 attendees attended 8 education and awareness events Observations • HRC engaged in but did not plan for outreach • Community engagement leads to systemic impact • Significant inquiries originated in Albemarle County Opportunities • Refine HRC annual planning to include outreach • Restructure OHR staffing to expand engagement and impact work • Consider dialogue with County regarding human rights services Page 183 of 289 2-433.(c): City Policy Review 2-433.(c): City Policy Review Highlights • Submitted recommendations to Council for: oEquitable shelter and supports for the homeless oEffective right to counsel for tenants facing eviction Observations • Research and community partnerships improve the HRC’s work • Research and community partnerships rely on OHR staff • OHR staff capacity is stretched Opportunities • Restructure OHR staffing to adequately support this work • Seek partnerships for research Page 184 of 289 2-433.(d): Federal workshares 2-433.(d): Federal workshares Highlights • Human Rights Ordinance amended on 08/05/24 and 01/21/25 • Amended Ordinance submitted for federal fair housing workshare Observations • Human Rights Ordinance stronger and more comprehensive • Qualification for federal fair housing workshare likely Opportunities • Consider the best interests of the City and community Page 185 of 289 2-433.(e): Legislative Program 2-433.(e): Legislative Program Highlights • Hosted 2 public panels with state legislators • Released a poll to gather public feedback • Submitted recommendations to Council on 09/06/24 Observations • Legislative process continues to improve • Supporting this process requires significant staff time Opportunities • Restructure OHR staffing to adequately support this work Page 186 of 289 2-433.(f): Commission Policies 2-433.(f): Commission Policies Highlights • Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance amendments regarding public hearings • Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance amendments regarding subpoena power • Rules & Procedures change for annual meetings Observations • Regular review of the Ordinance and Rules & Procedures is valuable • Supporting this process requires significant staff time Opportunities • Plan for annual review • Restructure OHR staffing to adequately support this work Page 187 of 289 Human Rights Commission Work Plan Human Rights Commission Work Plan: March 2026- February 2027 Focus Areas (as of April 15, 2025) • Housing access and stability across protected classes and economic status • Support for vulnerable and marginalized communities during federal uncertainty Goals (as of April 15, 2025) • Hold a landlord training on the enforcement authority under the Human Rights Ordinance • Hold a roundtable with immigration community stakeholders to ensure fair access to services • Hold a join summit with UVA and Albemarle County regarding the focus areas • Explore feasibility of a joint City/County Human Rights Commission • Host a public expert panel on the focus areas to inform policy and legislative recommendations • Submit legislative recommendations to City Council related to the focus areas by September 2025 • Submit policy recommendations to City Council related to the focus areas by October 2025 Page 188 of 289 Questions? Staff Contact Todd Niemeier, Director, Human Rights Commission Phone: 434-970-3027 Email: niemeier@charlottesville.gov Human Rights Webpage: www.charlottesville.gov/665/Human-Rights Page 189 of 289 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Public Hearing and Resolution to appropriate additional funds for the Virginia Department of Transportation ("VDOT") City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City") Project Portfolio ($23,317,263) (1 of 2 readings) Staff Contact(s): Krisy Hammill, Director of Budget, Colin Porter, Capital Development Division Project Manager Presenter: Michael Goddard, Deputy Director Date of Proposed Action: June 16, 2025 Issue Background / Rule VDOT has secured additional funds for seven (7) projects: the Barracks Emmet Streetscape Project UPC 111796, Emmet Streetscape Project (UPC 109551), Dairy Road Bridge Replacement Project (UPC 118295), East High Streetscape Project (UPC 109480), Preston Harris Pedestrian Improvements (UPC 113918), 10th and Grady Bike/Pedestrian Improvements (UPC 113916), and Washington Park Bike/Pedestrian Improvements (UPC 113861); ("Projects"). These funds need to be appropriated as part of the Projecs' Budget. Analysis With the continued rise in construction costs, the City's VDOT representative sought and secured additional funds for the Proejcts. VDOT has approved the allocations of the additional VDOT funds on these Projects and has issued new Appendix "A's", which have been signed. The scope of the Barracks Emmet Streetscape Project was reduced to limit Right-of-Way ("ROW") impacts, which also reduced construction costs. The original scope was estimated to cost $17 million to construct. The reduced scope consists of shortening the Shared Use Path up Barracks Road from 10’ to 6’ which, allows construction to largely remain in the City’s ROW and eliminates retaining walls along the properties up Barracks Road. Even with the reduced scope, an additional $495,738 has been awarded by VDOT to complete this Project. The scopes of the Emmet Streetscape Project, Dairy Road Bridge Replacement Project, East High Streetscape Project, Preston Harris Project, and the 10th and Grady Project have not changed. The East High Street Project and the Washington Park Bike/Pedestrian Projects are the only Projects requiring additional local funds with this Resolution. All the other Projects included here are 100% funded using VDOT funds. The Emmet Streetscape Project will also require additional local funds, which will be transferred from a previously appropriated account. That item will be presented for City Council approval as a separate Resolution. The attached Funding Summary includes a funding reconciliation for each Project. This Agenda item aligns with City Council's strategic outcome areas of Organizational Excellence, Partnerships, and Transportation of the Strategic Plan. Financial Impact Page 190 of 289 A large portion of these Projects are funded by funds the City will receive from VDOT. The required local matches are being transferred from previously appropriated funds in a separate account for undergrounding utility work, which will now be combined into the appropriate VDOT accounts. Recommendation Following conducting the legally required Public Hearing, City Staff recommends adoption of the attached Resolution appropriating additional funds for the City's VDOT Projects. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) "I make a Motion adopting the attached Resolution appropriating additional funds for the City's VDOT Projects." Attachments 1. VDOT Resolution - June 16 2. VDOT Funding Summary - May 19 Agenda Item 3. Appendix A - Barracks and Emmett Intersection (UPC 111796) 4. Appendix A - Emmet St Corridor Streetscape (UPC 109551) 5. Appendix A - Dairy Rd (UPC 118295) 6. Appendix A - East High Street (UPC 109480) 7. Appendix A - Preston and Harris (UPC 113918) 8. Appendix A - 10th and Grady (UPC 113916) 9. Appendix A - Bike Ped- Washington Park (UPC 113861) Page 191 of 289 RESOLUTION #R-25-___ Appropriating $23,317,263 for the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) City of Charlottesville Project Portfolio WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville has been awarded state and federal funds through the VDOT to locally administer various state funded transportation projects; and WHEREAS the Council of the City of Charlottesville previously authorized the City Manager to revise and reallocate funding within the City’s VDOT portfolio; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, that the sum of $23,317,263 is hereby appropriated as follows: Project: Barracks Rd @ Emmet St Intersection UPC #: 111796 Revenues $495,738 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-00972 GL Code: 430120 (Smart Scale) Expenditure $495,738 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-00972 GL Code: 599999 Project: Emmet Street Corridor Streetscape & Intersections UPC #: 109551 Revenues $5,257,378 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-00932 GL Code: 430120 (Smart Scale) Expenditure $5,257,378 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-00932 GL Code: 599999 Project: Dairy Road Bridge UPC #: 118295 Revenues $5,409,161 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01068 GL Code: 430120 (Smart Scale) Expenditure $5,409,161 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01068 GL Code: 599999 Project: East High Street UPC #: 109480 Revenues $500,000 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-00931 GL Code: 430117 (Revenue Share) $7,806,836 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-00931 GL Code: 430120 (Smart Scale) Transfers from City Undergrounding Utility Project Account (for City Match) $3,090,985 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-00127 GL Code: 599999 Page 192 of 289 Expenditure $11,397,821 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-00931 GL Code: 599999 Project: Pedestrian Improvements at Preston Ave/Harris Street UPC #: 113918 Revenues $410,801 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01069 GL Code: 430120 (HSIP) Expenditure $410,801 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01069 GL Code: 599999 Project: 10th and Grady UPC #: 113916 Revenues $327,129 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01092 GL Code: 430120 (HSIP) Expenditure $327,129 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01092 GL Code: 599999 Project: Bike/Ped Washington Park UPC #: 113861 Revenues $13,274 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01052 GL Code: 430120 (HSIP) Transfers from Parks and Rec Trails Project Account (for City Match) $5,961 Fund: 426 WBS Element: PR-001 GL Code: 599999 Expenditure $19,235 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01052 GL Code: 599999 Date Adopted: Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 193 of 289 SAP Account: P-00972 UPC #: 111796 To Be Appropriated April 2, 2018 May 19, 2025 Total Federal $0.00 - State Revenue Share $0.00 - SmartScale $9,136,604.00 $8,640,866.00 $495,738.00 $9,136,604.00 City Revenue Share $0.00 - City Local Match $0.00 - - Total Project $9,136,604.00 $495,738.00 9,136,604.00 SAP Account: P-00932 UPC #: 109551 To Be Appropriated February 13, 2017 June 20, 2023 May 19, 2025 Total Federal $0.00 - State Revenue Share $0.00 - SmartScale $17,372,099.00 $12,114,721.00 $5,257,378.00 17,372,099.00 City Revenue Share $0.00 - City Local Match $5,620,105.00 $4,183,586.00 4,183,586.00 - Total Project $22,992,204.00 $5,257,378.00 21, 555,685.00 **$1,436,519 in additional funds will be requested as part of a separate resolution. SAP Account: P-01068 UPC #: 118295 To Be Appropriated August 25, 2021 May 19, 2025 Total Federal - - VDOT Project Funding Summary and Reconciliation May 19, 2025 Council Appropriation Revenue Sources Revenue Sources Project: VDOT - #HB2.FY17 EMMET STREET CORRIDOR STREETSCAPE & INTERSECTIONS VDOT Appendix A Project: VDOT - Dairy Road Bridge Project Appropriations VDOT Appendix A Project Appropriations VDOT Appendix A Revenue Sources Project: VDOT - #SMART18 - Barracks Rd @ Emmet St Intersection Project Appropriations Page 194 of 289 VDOT Project Funding Summary and Reconciliation May 19, 2025 Council Appropriation SGR 12,619,825.00 7,210,664.00 5,409,161.00 12,619,825.00 SmartScale - - City Revenue Share - - City Local Match - - - Total Project 12,619,825.00 5,409,161.00 12,619,825.00 SAP Account: P-00931 UPC #: 109480 To be Appropriated January 17, 2017 FY 22 CIP May 19, 2025 Total Federal - - State Revenue Share 1,000,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00 1,000,000.00 SmartScale 13,444,836.00 5,638,000.00 7,806,836.00 13,444,836.00 City Revenue Share 1, 000,000.00 500,000.00 500,000.00 1,000,000.00 City Local Match 2,590,985.00 2,590,985.00 2,590,985.00 - Total Project 18,035,821.00 11,397,821.00 18,035,821.00 Project: Pedestrian Improvements at Preston Ave/Harris St SAP Account: P-01069 UPC #: 113918 To Be Appropriated Dec 20,2021 May 19, 2025 Total Federal $0.00 - State Revenue Share $0.00 - HSIP $656,526.00 $245,725.00 $410,801.00 $656,526.00 City Revenue Share $0.00 - City Local Match $0.00 - - Total Project $656,526.00 $410,801.00 656,526.00 Project Appropriations VDOT Appendix A Revenue Sources Project: VDOT - East High Street Project Appropriations VDOT Appendix A Revenue Sources Page 195 of 289 VDOT Project Funding Summary and Reconciliation May 19, 2025 Council Appropriation Project: 10th and Grady SAP Account: P-01092 UPC #: 113916 To Be Appropriated February 6, 2023 May 19, 2025 Total Federal $0.00 - State Revenue Share $0.00 - HSIP $827,235.00 $500,106.00 $327,129.00 $827,235.00 City Revenue Share $0.00 - City Local Match $0.00 - - Total Project $827,235.00 $327,129.00 827,235.00 Project: VDOT - Bike/Ped Washington Park SAP Account: P-01052 UPC #: 113861 To Be Appropriated December 21, 2020 October 4,2021 August 7, 2023 May 19, 2025 Total Federal $0.00 - State Revenue Share $0.00 - HSIP $473,839.00 $100,000.00 $74,900.00 $285,665.00 $13,274.00 $473,839.00 City Revenue Share $0.00 - City Local Match $19,411.00 $13,450.00 $5,961.00 19,411.00 - Total Project $493, 250.00 $100,000.00 $88,350.00 $19,235.00 493,250.00 Appendix A Revenue Sources Appendix A Revenue Sources Project Appropriations Project Appropriations Page 196 of 289 Page 197 of 289 Page 198 of 289 (SFHPSZ#BOLT Page 199 of 289 Date: 3/20/2025 UPC: CFDA # 20.205 Locality: From: To: This attachment is certified and made an official attachment to this document by the parties to this agreement. Program and Project Specific Funding Requirements This is limited funds project. The locality shall be responsible for any additional funding in excess of $14,444,836 (if applicable) This Appendix A supersedes all previous versions signed by VDOT and the LOCALITY . DateAuthorized VDOT Official DateAuthorized Locality Official This Project shall be initiated and at least a portion of the Project's programmed funds expended within one year of the budgeted year of allocation or funding may be subject to reprogramming to other Projects selected through the prioritization process. In the event the Project is not advanced to the n ext phase of construction when requested by the CTB, the LOCALITY or Metropolitan Planning Organization may be required, pursuant to § 33.2-214 of the Code of Virginia, to reimburse the DEPARTMENT for all state and federal funds expended on the Project. This Project has been selected through the Smart Scale (HB2) application and selection process and will remain in the SYIP as a funding priority unless certain conditions set forth in the CTB Policy and Guidelines for Implementation of a Project Prioritization Process arise. Pursuant to the CTB Policy and Guidelines for Implementation of a Project Prioritization Process and the SMART SCALE Reevaluation Guide, this Project will be re-scored and/or the funding decision re-evaluated if any of the following conditions apply: a change in the scope, an estimate increase, or a reduction in the locally/regionally leveraged funds. Applications may not be submitted in a subsequent SMART SCALE prioritization cycle to account for a cost increase on a previously selected Project. Total PE Smart Scale (HB2) DGP $2,590,985 $11,374,523 Smart Scale (HB2) $2,000,000 Construction Local Funds Smart Scale (HB2)Right of Way & Utilities $580,930 $1,489,383 Appendix A Revision 2 Locality UEI #: C6VFXLAFKEY1 Gregg Allen 434-426-5575 Gregg.Allen@vdot.virginia.govDepartment Project Coordinator Contact Info: Intersection of east market street/7th street NE Project Location ZIP+4: 22902-5148 Najeeb Behhnam 434-459-9763 Work Description: 109480Project Number: U000-104-298 City of Charlottesville Locality Address (incl ZIP+4): 610 East Market Street Charlottesville, VA 22902-5304 #HB2.FY17 EAST HIGH STREETSCAPE IMPROVEMENTS - Project will add bike lanes, rebuild sidewalks, road diet portions of East High Street from Locust Avenue westwards to High Street and 9th Street from High Street to Market Street and then along Market Stree t to 8th St. Preliminary Engineering ConstructionRight of Way and Utilities Total Estimated Cost behhnamn@charlottesville.gov $179,250 Project Estimates $15,875,508 $17,856,571 Project Cost and Reimbursement Estimated VDOT Project Expenses $551,680 $29,250 $1,429,383 Project Narrative $0$1,489,383 Local Share AmountFunds type (Choose from drop down box) Estimated Total Project Costs Estimated Reimbursement to Locality (Max. Reimbursement - Est. VDOT Expenses) $90,000 Estimated Locality Project Expenses $15,965,508$580,930 $60,000 $1,489,383 $18,035,821 Locality Project Manager Contact info: East High Street/Locust Avenue Maximum Reimbursement (Estimated Cost - Local Share) 0% Preliminary Engineering Phase Estimated Project Costs 0% Local % Participation for Funds Type $580,930 Smart Scale (HB2) $1,489,383 $11,374,5230% $0 $0 $0 $1,489,383$0 $551,680$580,930$0 $1,000,000 Total RW $580,930 $1,000,000 100% $0 $1,000,00050% $2,590,985 Revenue Sharing This Project shall be administered in accordance with VDOT's Locally Administered Projects Manual, Urban manual and Urban Construction Initiative Program Guide Aggregate AllocationsRevenue Sharing Local Match Local Funds Estimated Total Reimbursement by VDOT to Locality (Less Local Share and VDOT Expenses) $12,374,523 $12,836,203 Revenue Sharing State Match Total Estimated Cost Total Maximum Reimbursement by VDOT to Locality (Less Local Share) $3,590,985 $3,590,985 Project Financing All local funds included on this appendix have been formally committed by the local government’s board or council resolution subject to appropriation. Project estimate, schedule, and commitment to funding are subject to the requirements established in the Commonwealth Transpor tation Board Policy and Guidles for implementation of a project prioritization process code of Virginia and VDOT's instructional and information memorandums. $14,444,836 $12,836,203 $12,284,523Total CN $15,965,508 $1,000,000$13,444,836 $18,035,821$2,590,985 $18,035,821 $14,444,836 Revised: February 1, 2019 Page 200 of 289 Page 201 of 289 Page 202 of 289 Date: 5/4/2023 UPC: CFDA # 20.205 Locality: From: To: ● This Project shall be administered in accordance with VDOT's Locally Administered Projects Manual ● This is a limited funds project. The LOCALITY shall be responsible for any additional funding in excess of $473,839 This attachment is certified and made an official attachment to this document by the parties to this agreement. Program and Project Specific Funding Requirements ● Reimbursement for eligible expenditures shall not exceed funds allocated each year by the Commonwealth Transportation Board in the Six Year Improvement Program. ● All local funds included on this appendix have been formally committed by the local government’s board or council resolution subject to appropriation. and Urban Manual. DateAuthorized VDOT Official DateAuthorized Locality Official ● This Project is funded with federal-aid Highway Safety Improvement Program (HSIP) funds. These funds must be obligated within 12 months of allocation and expended within 36 months of the obligation. ● This Appendix A supersedes all previous versions signed by VDOT and the LOCALITY . ● The LOCALITY will continue to operate and maintain the facility as constructed. Should the design features of the Project be altered by the LOCALITY subsequent to Project completion without approval of the DEPARTMENT, the LOCALITY inherently agrees, by execution of this agreement, to make restitution, either physically or monetarily, as required by the DEPARTMENT. Total PE HSIP $468,250 HSIPConstruction Right of Way & Utilities $0 $25,000 Appendix A - Revision 2 Locality UEI #: C6VFXLAFKEY1 Gregg Allen 434-426-5575 gregg.allen@vdot.virginia.govDepartment Project Coordinator Contact Info: Preston Ave Project Location ZIP+4: 22903-5249 Chris Gensic 434-970-3656 Work Description: 113861Project Number: U000-104-353 City of Charlottesville Locality Address (incl ZIP+4): 610 East Market Street Charlottesville, VA 22902-5304 Washington park/Madison Avenue Bicycle Connector Trail ConstructionRight of Way and Utilities Total Estimated Cost gensic@charlottesville.org $45,000 Project Estimates $443,250 $448,250 Project Cost and Reimbursement Estimated VDOT Project Expenses $0 $0 $5,000 Project Narrative $0$5,589 Local Share AmountFunds type (Choose from drop down box) Estimated Total Project Costs Estimated Reimbursement to Locality (Max. Reimbursement - Est. VDOT Expenses) $25,000 Estimated Locality Project Expenses $468,250$0 $20,000 $25,000 $493,250 Locality Project Manager Contact info: Rose Hill Drive Preliminary Engineering Maximum Reimbursement (Estimated Cost - Local Share) 0% $0 $0 Preliminary Engineering Phase Estimated Project Costs 0% Local % Participation for Funds Type $19,411 $19,411100% $0 $0 HSIP Local Funds $5,589 $468,2500% $0 -$14,411 $0 $0 $5,589$19,411 $0$0$0 $19,411 Total RW $0 Aggregate Allocations Estimated Total Reimbursement by VDOT to Locality (Less Local Share and VDOT Expenses) $0 $468,250 $428,839 Local Funds Total Estimated Cost Total Maximum Reimbursement by VDOT to Locality (Less Local Share) $0 $19,411 Project Financing $473,839 $428,839 $443,250 $0 Total CN $468,250 $473,839 $493,250 $493,250 $473,839 Revised: February 1, 2019 Page 203 of 289 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Public Hearing and Resolution to approve a Lease Amendment for property located at 100 5th Street NE to the Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless Staff Contact(s): Brenda Kelley, Redevelopment Manager, John Hunt, Deputy City Attorney Presenter: Brenda Kelley, Redevelopment Manager Date of Proposed Action: June 16, 2025 Issue The Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (“BRACH”) currently leases a portion of CitySpace from the City of Charlottesville, Virginia (“City”). Said Lease expires in August 2025. BRACH has requested that the Lease be renewed. Background / Rule City Council approved a Standard Form Lease Agreement for Commercial Space within a City-Owned Building or Structure (“Original Lease”) between the City and BRACH in August 2023, for approximately 366 square feet of space at a rent of $1.00 per year, within CitySpace, located at 100 5th Street NE, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902. Pursuant to Section 3 of the Original Lease, BRACH has the option to renew the Lease one (1) time, for one (1) year (“Renewal Term”). BRACH has requested to exercise a Renewal Term of the Original Lease. Analysis BRACH is the HUD-designated coordinator of the Continuum of Care for the Charlottesville community, which includes the City and the five (5) surrounding Counties. BRACH supports system improvement and collaboration to ensure a secure safety net for the homeless and very poor. The Service Provider Council, a Committee of BRACH’s Board of Directors, provides a forum in which providers share information and address concerns. BRACH currently has two (2) full-time Staff, with an additional open position. BRACH has been in existence since 1998 and its mission is to make homelessness rare, brief, and non-reoccurring. BRACH’s strategy is to collaborate with service providers to alleviate homelessness. Working with BRACH to assist with the administration of its services aligns with the City’s Strategic Initiatives of “Partnerships” and “Housing.” Upon receiving BRACH’s request for the Renewal Term to the Original Lease, City Staff considered the current and ongoing use of CitySpace. At this time, it is determined that renewing BRACH’s Original Lease for the Renewal Term in CitySpace will have no negative impacts on the use of this City-owned property. Financial Impact There is no anticipated financial impact. Recommendation Page 204 of 289 Following conducting the legally required Public Hearing, City Staff recommends that City Council adopt the attached Resolution approving the attached Lease Amendment. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) “I make a Motion to adopt the attached Resolution approving the attached Lease Amendment with BRACH.” Attachments 1. RESOLUTION BRACH lease renewal 2. BRACH lease renewal Aug2025 BRACHsigned Page 205 of 289 RESOLUTION #R-__-___ APPROVING A LEASE AMENDMENT FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 100 5TH STREET NE, TO THE BLUE RIDGE AREA COALITION FOR THE HOMELESS ______________________________________________________________________________ WHEREAS, a Standard Form Lease Agreement for Commercial Space Within a City- Owned Building or Structure (“Original Lease”) by and between the City of Charlottesville, Virginia (“City”) and the Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (“BRACH”), was entered into in August 2023; and WHEREAS, per Section 3 of the Original Lease, BRACH requested to renew the Lease term for a one (1)-time, one (1) year term; and WHEREAS, City Cou

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.