RecordWell Data

Housing Advisory Committee Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Housing Advisory Committee · meeting of May 21, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Attachment 1- April 16, 2025, Regular HAC Meeting Minutes 1 of 3 Housing Advisory Committee (HAC) Minutes Wednesday, April 16, 2025 City Space Conference Room 12pm - 2pm HAC Members Present: • Joy Johnson, Chair (JJ) • Sunshine Mathon, Vice Chair (SM) • Phil d'Oronzio (PdO) • Heather Griffith (HG) • Peppy Linden (PL) • Mike Parisi (MCP) • Dan Rosensweig (DR) • Nicole Scro (NS) HAC Members Absent: • Michael Payne (MP) • John Sales (JS) Staff Attendees: • Alexander Ikefuna (AI) • Madelyn Metzler (MM) • Alan Peura (AP) • Antoine Williams (AW) 1. Welcome JJ: Calls meeting to order at 12:10pm. 2. Introductions and Attendance 3. Staff Updates AW: Council agenda for April 21 i. Housing Program Manager provide copies of upcoming council items of interest a. 2025 Affordable Housing Report AW: This is the 4 year checkpoint of 2021’s 10 year plan. $100mil commitment over next ten years. $59mil spent so far, $48.1mil in direct investments. There are 1023 SAUs (Supported Affordable Units) at present. SM: SAU number includes future SAUs? AW: Accounts for money already committed by the City, but that money might not be received by orgs yet. Projected to hit $120mil spent on housing-related activities (includes admin cost, tax relief programs, etc.) Re: AMI (Area Median Income) levels goals, City is below goals for 30% AMI units to date, but that figure does not include 30% AMI units in the pipeline. Next steps: close out FY 2025, develop 2026 workplan, create beta for web dashboard for tracking housing investments. Dashboard is up now but data is not yet comprehensive. NS: How can we figure the average cost per affordable unit? AW: That data is not in an existing spreadsheet or database. We would need to assemble the data from disparate sources. MM: Can more easily calculate unit cost on a project-by-project basis. SM: There was a big change at the mid-point of last Trump admin re: funding, occurring again now. Historic projections may be hard to use going forward. NS: Could we use existing audits to help figure that out? Attachment 1- April 16, 2025, Regular HAC Meeting Minutes 2 of 3 SM: Audits occur at the state level with VH (Virginia Housing), it’s an onerous process. No audits at the City level. NS: Are the VH audits available to the City? AW: We have access to public Virginia Housing records. HG: What is Dogwood? AW: Portfolio acquisition by the City, ~74 properties. Originally owned and managed by Eugene Williams, then Woodard Properties. City investment kept units affordable, now managed by CRHA. b. Housing Ecosystems & Anti-Displacement Toolkit (HEAT) Policy Development Update: 1. Land Bank Authority of the City of Charlottesville (LBAC): Update and Next Steps PdO: This ordinance has significant changes to what HAC submitted. Policy changes beyond what a lawyer would do. Does not reflect HAC memo about establishing a parallel nonprofit and sunsetting LB (Land Bank) as an authority after initial trial period. SM: Reasoning behind changes from the city attorney would be useful. AW: HAC can submit questions to City; changes could have come from city council member, staff, legal, etc. This draft put together via templates from other Authorities and input from various voices. If policy change is identified, HAC can give feedback to city executive team. This draft is an update/work in progress, reflects a review to make sure there’s nothing counter to VA law. Once it becomes an action item it will look different. Re: timeline, it is feasible to have an active Land Bank by this time next year. SM: $500k set aside for LB is gone from FY 2026 budget; will need some preliminary capitalization from City. Money from City likely won’t come until FY 27 unless something opens up. Given funding climate overall, best to assume City money won’t be committed until then. AW: For reference, the timeline for the Chesapeake Land Bank from incorporation to being active was 6-8 months. JJ: Let’s set a subcommittee meeting to discuss this new draft and craft HAC’s feedback. HAC Subcommittee Meeting set for 4/30 1pm. 2. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program (CAHTAP): Development and Introduction AW: Staff looked at tax abatement programs in 16 cities. Here in Charlottesville, it could fit under CEDA, or be standalone. Staff is presenting prompts, potential directions. E.g., could be used to fund ADUs, affordability levels, project sizes. In Richmond, affordability Attachment 1- April 16, 2025, Regular HAC Meeting Minutes 3 of 3 duration tied to abatements is 15 years with potential renewal. Keep in mind the zoning ordinance might require a longer duration. PdO: HAC previously looked at the City’s tax credit program for rehabilitating homes and its adaptability to promoting affordability. Will send to staff. AW: RFP (Request for Proposals) is out now for Market Needs and Fiscal Gap Analysis. Open to recommendations for analysis scope. SM: With RFPs for the Comprehensive Plan, HAC played a role in helping draft that. Would be useful for us to see a draft of the RFP . Motion to express HAC’s support for continued exploration of CAHTAP concept and desire to partner in its development. PL: Second. Motion passes. 4. Agenda Items i. March 19, 2025 Regular HAC Meeting Minutes Minutes approved. ii. Elect HAC Officers Continuing motion from last meeting to renew JJ, SM, MP in their positions. Motion approved. AW: Will review bylaws at next meeting. Adding the option for the CRHA director to designate a representative to HAC will be presented to Council in May. iii. Discuss and approve the Risk Reduction Fund Survey (RRF) and next steps HG: Where will money for fund come from? SM: Set aside from City general fund. AW: No specific funding identified right now. Last recommended amount was $75,000. DR: Recommend allowing AW to move forward distributing survey, asking questions of stakeholders, survey doesn’t need to be perfect or occupy too much time. 5. Next Meeting: May 21, 2025 6. Public Comment No public comment. 7. Adjourn Meeting adjourned 1:26pm. Attachment 2- April 30, 2025, Special HAC Meeting Minutes 1 of 5 Housing Advisory Committee (HAC) Special Meeting Minutes Wednesday, April 30, 2025 City Space Conference Room 1pm - 3pm HAC Members Present: • Joy Johnson, Chair (JJ) • Sunshine Mathon, Vice Chair (SM) • Phil d'Oronzio (PdO) • Heather Griffith (HG) • Mike Parisi (MCP) • Michael Payne (MP) • Dan Rosensweig (DR) • Nicole Scro (NS) HAC Members Absent: • Peppy Linden (PL) • John Sales (JS) Staff Attendees: • Antoine Williams (AW) • Madelyn Metzler (MM) Other Attendees: • Kathleen Glenn-Matthews, Deputy Director CRHA (KGM) 8. Welcome DR: Calls meeting to order at 1:03pm. 9. Introductions and Attendance 10. Agenda Items iv. Land Bank Ordinance (LBO) Discussion DR: To summarize, LBO has been a years-long process. First put on the backburner by COVID, then the Zoning Ordinance revision. HAC drafted an LBO again in 2024, then the city’s acting attorney recently rewrote it with eye to keeping it in accord with existing law. AW: Attorney directed staff to look at the Chesapeake’s LBO and the state law re: Land Banks (LB). Staff then assembled this LBO draft with further input from City leadership. LB’s board structure and governance are the primary parts that have been carried over from HAC’s LBO draft. I can go section by section. Definitions AW: Flagged by staff and city’s attorney to add this section following examples from other localities and to address questions from attorney about items that weren’t defined. LB as Authority Formation and Purpose AW: Authority language is carbon copied from Virginia’s Land Bank Entities Act; Formation and Purpose was something that we also saw in the Chesapeake LBO. For context, the primary reason to switch to an Authority in this draft from HAC’s nonprofit recommendation was to have more oversight by City, especially because City staff Attachment 2- April 30, 2025, Special HAC Meeting Minutes 2 of 5 will be the first LB employees. We were also asked by executive leadership team about how LB would prioritize projects and AMI levels. Added language re: 31-50% AMI (Area Median Income) that is specifically reflecting what isn’t being addressed by actual projects, even though that range doesn’t exactly correspond to the AMI ranges in the Affordable Housing Plan (AHP). PdO: HAC proposed nonprofit, City preferred Authority due to tax revenue and other funding being used by LB. HAC agreed that if LB will be an Authority, 1) there needs to be a pilot program with a sunset provision, and 2) a parallel nonprofit with same board members be immediately established as a conduit for incoming funds from banks, tax write offs, etc. HG: Timing for sunset? PdO: Could say at any time within 3 years but point is to force an evaluation and decision point. AW: No comments about dual structure. But that language should be in the Formation section if HAC wants to include it. SM: Staff perspective is property tax and general revenue necessitates more control and oversight by City. Tradeoff s would be CRA, private investments and donations, ability to morrow more easily, would disappear. AW: Those points were discussed, leadership comfort level is with Authority. We looked at Chesapeake’s ability to work with nonprofits and other partners. And with tax abatement and bonding decisions being informed by executive staff and Council, even more reason for Authority. PdO: If LB conveys $500,000 of property in one year that is only $2500 in property taxes to LB. If LB conveys $20mil of property, it is increasing the value of the property by definition and providing $1,000,000 in tax revenue to the City that it wouldn’t otherwise get. City couldn’t do better than that. SM: HAC discussed balance of tradeoff s extensively, fair for City to see it otherwise, is it possible to meet in the middle. AW: Does HAC want to acknowledge City’s stance but stick with nonprofit, or tweak Authority ordinance version? DR: Want to avoid past practice of HAC and staff competing proposals before Council. Possible to put forth staff proposal but with HAC alternatives noted? AW: Not staff driving proposal. City Manager Sam Sanders (SS) acknowledged that some, all, or none of the HAC’s LBO draft would be adopted. Board component was carried over. MP: In Council, SS, staff convos re: Authority, cost benefit analysis was Authority would be more likely to have bonding capability. Ex: easier to fund Carlton Mobile Home acquisition that way. Saw more flexibility with that source of funds than a nonprofit’s ability to collect funds via Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) investment from banks, donations, etc. DR: I’m stuck on the org chart. Who does HAC recommend to? City Manager? Council? Attachment 2- April 30, 2025, Special HAC Meeting Minutes 3 of 5 AW: My understanding is HAC’s recommendations funnel up through the Office of Community Solutions and the City Manager’s office to Council. SM: Staff, SS developed this LBO draft with substantial changes not made lightly. Not viable to return to HAC’s version. Can HAC identify concerns with changes in the hope of influencing a second draft by the City? MP: HAC recommendations in public and private meetings were presented and discussed fully by SS and Council. DR: Is HAC comfortable with noting recommendations and differences, not sticking with previous ordinance? PdO: Yes. Need to go line by line, note concerns and reasons behind those, not just say no to this ordinance. DR: Thoughts on including language re: parallel nonprofit in the ordinance? NS: I like it for transparency. Putting it in ordinance can highlight why it’s necessary, its purpose. AW: Is HAC’s concern about nonprofit language about tools for LB that wouldn’t otherwise exist, or as a means to keep City honest about purpose? NS: Strictly about receiving private donations, CRA money. That’s the only purpose. AW: CRHA can do that, as an Authority. DR: Does CRHA have a foundation? KGM: We are in the process of setting up a parallel nonprofit for CRHA. PdO: Setting up nonprofit on paper is very easy, useful, and is a guidepost on the way towards sunsetting from an Authority. Deputy City Manager James Freas (JF) said the intent was to LB as an authority as a pilot program (Authority). Parallel nonprofit and sunset language would confirm that. AW: Would be Council’s decision to do that. Won’t see “pilot” in the ordinance. PdO: If pilot and eventual; transitional period is not the intent, let’s be clear about that. NS: Not legally required to put nonprofit language into ordinance, but good discussion whether to include it in memo or ordinance. DR: Downside to putting nonprofit language into ordinance? NS: More prescriptive, would mean LB has to come to Council to alter that language. DR: Consensus on parallel nonprofit to enable fundraising? SM: Let’s focus on the tools that we want LB to have. If it turns out Authority can do those, that’s fine. PdO: Tools include donations that are tax write-off s, CRA money, independent borrowing from banks. SM: I.e., ability to go to a bank and get a 3% loan, as opposed to a 5% rate from issuing a bond. PdO: Also 3rd party partnerships. Forming an LLC or subsidiary. AW: All entities that are formed must come back to council by state law. DR: But can an authority participate in a joint venture? SM: Question is if a parallel nonprofit would need to come to council to do so? AW: By state law yes. Attachment 2- April 30, 2025, Special HAC Meeting Minutes 4 of 5 DR: Can an authority accept tax deductible donations? KGM: No. DR: Need to emphasize to Council that tax deductible donations and CRA credits are foundational abilities for LB. SM: If donations aren’t tax deductible, potential donations go down. KGM: Authority does have access to funds and rates that are particular to them. MP: Useful to list LB tools and whether each is available or not to an Authority. Vision, Mission, and Values PdO: Re: transparency and accountability, LB can’t be discussing details of property transactions in public, would lose leverage. KGM: CRHA goes into closed session to discuss land deals. DR: Recommend slight tweak to “decision making processes are open and accessible to the public” so LB isn’t hamstrung when dealing on the real estate market. From original LBO, re: prioritization of disposition of property, “board shall first prioritize affordable housing in accordance with AHP . If property entails other uses, LB shall document reasons and act by ⅔ vote.” NS: Why wasn’t original language included? AW: Not sure. DR: HAC was intentional and deliberate about this because of local context, LB will not be dealing in blighted properties like other land banks. Created specifically for affordable housing, but in some circumstances other uses may be appropriate. Chapter 2 Section 3B should be replaced by original text from the HAC LBO draft. JJ: Re income priorities, should include as a reminder to Council. SM: Missing from this and the AHP is that the highest priority 30% AMI and below is also the most expensive to build. Trade off is fewer units are being built because they are more costly to build. OK to be in here but recognize that it could produce fewer units than otherwise. DR: Can loosen “The Authority Shall…” language in each income bracket and include reference to Affordable Housing Plan. Re: Core Value of Equity and Inclusion, inclusion of certain specific words may be used to eliminate grants and programs with this type of language. Can flag for Council. Re: City Manager or designee on board, the language we talked about didn’t make it into HAC LBO draft or this one. AW: That language was in HAC’s memo, not LBO. DR: Can include a note to reiterate City Manager or “senior level staff” not just any employee. AW: Should use the term “appointee” not “designee” if the idea is City Manager cedes his seat to another person, versus only occasionally when he can’t make it. SM: In General Powers section 1E the language defining 0-60% AMI as moderate priority is not consistent with previous section. Attachment 2- April 30, 2025, Special HAC Meeting Minutes 5 of 5 PdO: Can restate “....affordable dwelling units in accordance with City Council’s endorsed priorities” or similar. Financial Operations and Oversight AW: This flowed from questions internally re: balancing being nimble vs. the rules an Authority is required to follow. DR: Do we need to include this much detail about how Authority can receive funds? NS: Could add “any other sources” to Section 1A.6. DR: In LBO draft, it reads “may receive funding according to provisions of VA code…” pointing to statute. PdO: Drop HAC draft language back into this section (A) PdO: In Section 1B “a dedicated fund” singular is too prescriptive, could be multiple funds. SM: Parallel nonprofit could control funds not in the City’s coffers. Might need a bank account separate from the city. DR: Carlton Mobile Park has its own banking account. This language is limiting. SM: Can’t fully anticipate where funds will have to sit. For donors to get write offs those funds will have to be in a non-City account. DR: Retain availability to segregate funds. SM: Replace “a dedicated fund” with “any”. AW: Might have to be in there. Not sure. SM: Then we’ll have to add additional language. Dissolution of Authority NS: Pros of including authority sunset language: reminds, memorializes for all parties about this founding discussion and intent. Cons: Adds a required action. SM: Has Council weighed in about HAC’s idea of LB authority pilot phase sunsetting into a nonprofit LB? MP: Council discussed whether it’s easier to start as an Authority versus a nonprofit. Conversation is ongoing. 11. Next Meeting: May 21, 2025 12. Public Comment No public comment. 13. Adjourn Meeting adjourned 2:57pm.

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.