RecordWell Data

City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · City Council · meeting of Apr 21, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY COUNCIL AGENDA April 21, 2025 City Hall Council Chamber Juandiego R. Wade, Mayor Brian R. Pinkston, Vice Mayor Natalie Oschrin Michael K. Payne J. Lloyd Snook, III Kyna Thomas, Clerk 4:00 PM OPENING SESSION This is an in-person meeting with an option for the public to participate electronically by registering in advance for the Zoom webinar at www.charlottesville.gov/zoom. The meeting may also be viewed on the City's streaming platforms and local government Channel 10. Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide 48 hours’ notice so that proper arrangements may be made. Call to Order/Roll Call Agenda Approval Reports 1. Report: 2025 Affordable Housing Report 2. Report: Housing Ecosystem Anti-Displacement Toolkit (HEAT) Update: Expanding Affordable Options and Stability a. Report: Establishing the Land Bank Authority: Progress and Next Steps b. Report: Introducing the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program ("CAHTAP"): a new tax abatement strategy for housing affordability 5:30 PM CLOSED MEETING (if called) 6:30 PM BUSINESS SESSION Moment of Silence Announcements Recognitions/Proclamations • Proclamation: Dark Sky Week: April 21-28, 2025 Community Matters Public comment for up to 16 speakers (limit 3 minutes per speaker). Preregistration available for first 8 spaces at https://www.charlottesville.gov/692/Request-to-Speak; speakers announced by Noon on meeting day (9:00 a.m. sign-up deadline). Additional public comment at end of meeting. Comments on Public Hearing items are heard during the public hearing only. Consent Agenda* The consent agenda consists of routine, non-controversial items whereby all items are passed with a single motion and vote. Individuals speaking during Community Matters may address items on the Consent Agenda. 3. Minutes: April 7 regular meeting; April 14 special meeting 4. Resolution: Resolution to Appropriate $1,304,308 from the Virginia Department of Transportation ("VDOT") for the Monticello 2nd Project (2nd reading) City Manager Report • Report: City Manager Report a. Report: Presentation of Charlottesville Police Department Annual Report b. Report: Presentation of Charlottesville Fire Department Annual Report c. Report: City Manager's 3rd Quarter Work Plan Update Action Items Page 1 of 147 5. Public Hearing: Public hearing on the City of Charlottesville's Proposed Real Property Tax Rate 6. Ordinance: Ordinance Establishing the Annual Tax Levy for Tax Year 2025 (1 of 2 readings) 7. Resolution: Resolution Establishing 2025 Tax Year Personal Property Tax Relief Percentage (1 Reading) 8. Public Hearing: Public Hearing for the Program Year 2025-26 One (1) -Year Annual Action Plan ("AAP") for the City’s Community Development Block Grants ("CDBG") and HOME Investment Partnerships Programs, and corresponding funding recommendations (1 of 2 readings). a. Resolution: Resolution approving the City of Charlottesville Program Year 2025- 2026 One-year Annual Action Plan for the city’s CDBG and HOME programs b. Resolution: Resolution appropriating CDBG funds anticipated to be received from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development as outlined in the Program Year 2025-2026 One-year Annual Action Plan, in the approximate amount of $438,617 (1 of 2 readings) c. Resolution: Resolution awarding HOME Investment Partnership Program funds anticipated to be received from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development as outlined in the Program Year 2025-2026 One- year Annual Action Plan, in the approximate amount of $83,016 (1 of 2 readings) 9. Resolution: Resolution allocating $35,000 of FY25 Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund as an Emergency Grant to the Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless ("BRACH") for Supportive Housing Program 10. Resolution: Resolution of Intent to Participate in the Biophilic Cities Program General Business 11. Written Report: 2024 Integrated Pest Management Report 12. Written Report: Rivanna Authorities Quarterly Report Community Matters (2) Adjournment Page 2 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: None (Informational Only Presentation) Presenter: Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Staff Contacts: James Freas, Deputy City Manager Alexander Ikefuna, Director, Office of Community Solutions Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Madelyn Metzler, Housing Compliance Coordinator Title: 2025 Affordable Housing Report Background In 2021, the City of Charlottesville, Virginia (“City”), adopted its first-ever Affordable Housing Plan (“AHP”). This foundational document called for a bold, equity-centered approach to reversing decades of underinvestment, exclusionary land use policy, and housing insecurity. Central to the plan was a $100 million ten (10)-year (FY2022 - 2032) Funding Recommendation—endorsed by sitting City Council Members. The AHP's funding strategy aims to expand affordable housing, prevent displacement, and establish a transparent governance system for effective stewardship. The information in the 2025 Affordable Housing Report ("AHR") is informed by SAP, Resolutions, Ordinances, Agreements, and Publicly Recorded Funding commitments in the year those commitments/investments became a planned intention of the City Council. This 2025AHR reflects the City’s continued effort to track and communicate its progress. It provides a detailed review of investments, program outcomes, and system reforms implemented between FY2022 and FY2025, the first significant checkpoint since the AHP's adoption. Specifically, this report aims to: • Document how the City allocates affordable housing funds across various funding streams, including Direct Investments, Tax Relief Programs, and Administration. • Provide an update on the City’s established ten (10)-year vision for housing equity and affordability. The AHP called for the City to reverse decades of underinvestment and exclusion by dedicating $100 million in local funding over ten (10) years (FY2022 – FY2032). • Provide some high-level analysis of whether investments are consistent with the AHP’s income-level targeting recommendations (50% of funds for <30% AMI households). • Provide an update on the City’s ten (10)-year affordable housing production and preservation strategy, which includes producing 1,100 new supported affordable units, preserving 1,300 existing units, and stabilizing up to 2,200 households through tax relief, vouchers, rehab, and related supports. • Summarize emerging strategies (e.g., land bank, tax abatement) to sustain long-term affordability. The 2025 AHR is aligned with the structure of the Agenda Memo that was submitted alongside it, offering complementary information for the City Council’s policy deliberation and oversight. It also serves as an Page 3 of 147 accountability tool — a snapshot of where the City stands, where it is headed, and what will be required to meet both the letter and the spirit of the AHP. Discussion A. FY22-25 Funding Summary—Scale and Consistency: The City’s AHP recommends allocating its $100 million investment over ten (10) years across three (3) strategic categories: Direct Housing Investments, Tax Relief Programs, and Administrative Capacity. This structure is designed to ensure a balance of physical development, immediate financial relief, and the infrastructure needed to govern equitably and efficiently. 1. Administrative Costs—$1.27M: While the AHP calls for $1 million annually to support implementation and oversight, actual administrative expenditures have totaled $1.27 million over the first four (4) years, falling significantly short of the $4 million target at this phase of the AHP. Fiscal Year Total Admin Salaries* FY22 $159,216 FY23 $331,870 FY24 $364,255 FY25 $416,986 *Note: Figures reflect full-time and allocated partial salaries related to affordable housing administration. This investment supports: • Two (2) full-time housing staff. • Five (5) fractional positions contributing to grant administration, compliance, and program delivery. • Key functions include policy development, compliance monitoring, technical assistance, and capacity- building efforts through boards (e.g., Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (CAHF) Committee, Housing Advisory Committee (HAC), and Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Committee) and community partner support. As the housing pipeline expands and new responsibilities (e.g., Land Bank Authority, ADU Program, Tax Abatement) come online, the operational investment must scale accordingly — supporting service delivery, compliance, reporting, and oversight. 2. Tax Relief Programs—$9.58M: Between FY22 and FY25, the city committed approximately $9.58 million to property tax relief and rent relief programs. These efforts help stabilize residents—especially low-income seniors and individuals with disabilities—who are vulnerable to displacement, lack of housing choices or stability, and/or rising housing costs. Programs Include: • Housing Assistance Tax Grant • Rent Relief for the Elderly and Disabled (two (2) Programs of Service) • Tax Relief for Elderly and Disabled (two (2) Programs of Service) These investments, through these five (5) programs, complement physical housing production by supporting long- term affordability and advancing anti-displacement goals. Page 4 of 147 3. Direct Housing Investments—$47.92M: From FY22 to FY25, the city invested $47.92 million in direct housing initiatives through its Capital Improvement Program (“CIP”). This includes support for major redevelopment projects, nonprofit construction, acquisition of naturally occurring affordable housing (NOAH), and preservation efforts. Major initiatives that were funded during this period: • Friendship Court (Kindlewood) infrastructure and Phases 1–2 • CRHA Public Housing Redevelopment (multiple sites) • MACAA Senior Apartments (1025 Park Street) • Park Street Family Apartments (1200 Park Street) • Carlton Mobile Home Park Acquisition • South First Street Phase 2 and 6th Street Phase 1 • Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (“CAHF”) • Charlottesville Supplemental Rental Assistance Program (“CSRAP”) B. Pipeline and AMI Targeting—As outlined in the AHP, the City is committed to producing and preserving affordable housing units across specific income bands with a clear and balanced focus. Specifically, the AHP recommends constraints on funding as appropriate to target funding allocation specific to the Area Median Income (AMI) level served: • 50% of the allocations should support households earning ≤30% AMI. • 30% of the allocations should support households earning 60% AMI. • 20% of the allocations should support households earning 80% AMI. These investment ratios were designed to prioritize deeply affordable housing for residents most impacted by exclusionary policy, gentrification, and housing insecurity. 1. SAU Pipeline Baseline to Date: As FY2025 closes, the City’s working Supported Affordable Unit (“SAUs”) pipeline reflects 983 SAUs supported through City funds. Accordingly, these units are distributed by income level as follows: • ≤30% AMI: 348 units (35%) • 60% AMI: 427 units (43%) • 80% AMI: 208 units (21%) The previously major initiatives mentioned projects include CRHA redevelopment phases (e.g., South First Street Phase 2, 6th Street Phase 1), Friendship Court (Kindlewood) Phases 1-2, MACAA and PHA-led senior and rental housing projects, Habitat for Humanity homeownership sites, and strategic acquisitions (e.g., Dogwood Housing, Carlton Mobile Home Park). Page 5 of 147 2. Key Considerations: Distribution and Balancing Funding Commitments with Needs. While the City is making strong progress toward the AHP’s unit goals, the distribution of units by AMI reveals a continued gap at the deepest affordability level: • Units targeted to ≤30% AMI households remain below the 50% investment benchmark, currently at approximately 34% of pipeline production. The observed under-representation likely reflects misalignments or discrepancies between direct funding allocations and the priorities established by AHP or municipal housing policies. Additionally, community partners highlighted the complexities arising from actual costs and the structural barriers that impede progress and the delivery of SAUs that service this high-priority area of deeply affordable units. Some resulting complexities reported to staff during this period include but are not limited to: • Higher per-unit subsidies • Longer timelines for development and occupancy • More intensive support services • Greater dependence on layered financing (LIHTC, vouchers, federal) Many of the City’s deeply affordable units (e.g., those that service ≤30% of AMI households) are concentrated in CRHA-led redevelopments. While this is appropriate, it raises important equity considerations around geographic distribution and access to safe, stable housing opportunities across cost-burdened neighborhoods. Additionally, tools like CSRAP and HOPS-funded services offer deep affordability that is not always captured in unit production counts but remains an essential component of the City’s broader equity strategy. 3. Looking Ahead: FY26-30 CIP—With $12.7 million scheduled for allocation in FY26 and an additional anticipated request of approximately $40.2 million for FY27-30, the total proposed investment in affordable housing reaches $53 million. These projected allocations will initiate or extend significant housing efforts. • Increase production for ≤30% AMI households e.g., Westhaven Redevelopment, Friendship Court (Kindlewood) Phase 3. • Diversify development partners beyond public housing authorities. • Advance mixed-income and inclusionary zoning models that integrate deep affordability into broader housing delivery. Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan Page 6 of 147 • 2023 Strategic Framework: Supports equitable growth, partnerships, housing affordability, some climate actions, and sustainability—goals that a land bank can help achieve by re-purposing underutilized land for affordable housing. • Comprehensive Plan (2021): This plan focuses on inclusive neighborhoods and sustainable development. A land bank can facilitate affordable housing and neighborhood revitalization in alignment with goals. • Affordable Housing Plan (2021) • Climate Action Plan 2023-2027 (where or when applicable). • Consolidated Plan (where or when applicable). Community Engagement The success of the City’s AHP depends not just on funding but on inclusive partnerships and responsive governance. • Partner Collaboration: OCS works closely with nonprofit developers — to deliver projects ranging from public housing redevelopment to affordable homeownership. These collaborations extend beyond funding to include technical support and shared implementation. • Resident Voice: Residents help shape housing solutions. The Friendship Court (Kindlewood) and Carlton Mobile Home Park projects integrate resident input into planning and design. CRHA’s Resident Advisory Board continues to guide redevelopment efforts from within the community. • Transparent Processes: The City has improved the accessibility and fairness of its Grant Programs (CAHF and HOPS), using competitive funding cycles and HAC input to ensure accountability. • Institutional Support: University of Virginia faculty and students have supported the City’s housing work through research, pipeline analysis, and equity-focused data tools — expanding capacity and sharpening strategy. • Real-Time Tracking: A new Housing Investment Dashboard, developed internally and now in beta form, will allow for real-time monitoring of housing investments and outcomes — reinforcing transparency and responsiveness. • Ongoing Oversight: The City Manager’s Transparency Portal, and this annual AHP, provide regular public updates on spending, results, and challenges — helping to keep the AHP grounded in civic trust and shared responsibility. Budgetary Impact As of FY2025, the City has committed or allocated approximately: • $47.92 million in direct affordable housing investments (FY22 – FY25), including CAHF Grants, CSRAP, public housing redevelopment support, and other City-supported CIP housing projects. • $9.58 million in local Tax Relief Programs, supporting residents through the Charlottesville Housing Assistance Grant, Rent Relief for elderly and disabled households, and real estate tax relief. • $1.27 million in administrative costs, covering full-time and fractional staffing, technical support, and governance functions within the OCS. Together, these categories represent a total of approximately $58.77 million in City investment over the first four (4) years of AHP implementation. From FY26 to FY30, the total proposed investment in affordable housing, as part of the CIP, is $53 million, which includes approximately $12.7 million in FY26 and $40.2 million in subsequent years. Page 7 of 147 IMPORTANT CONSIDERATION: It is important to note that certain CRHA-related projects in the CIP are bond- funded, which introduces financing costs that are not reflected in the base investment totals. These costs, typically ranging from 3% to 4%, will be borne through the City’s standard debt service and could increase the City’s overall financial obligation associated with these investments. Recommendation This Presentation is for information and discussion only. However, based on current trends and funding trajectories, City Council may wish to consider the following areas for guidance to the City Manager and Staff: A. Support Targeting Goals for Deep Affordability 1. City Council may wish to affirm that future-year housing investments should prioritize households earning ≤30% AMI, consistent with the AHP’s equity framework. 2. City Staff can be directed to ensure that funding allocations (e.g., CAHF, CSRAP, land acquisition) are explicitly aligned with this targeting goal. B. Provide Direction on Sustaining Implementation Capacity Page 8 of 147 1. Given that administrative funding remains below plan benchmarks, City Council may consider signaling support for reaching the AHP’s $1M/year target. 2. This would enable the City Manager to build the staffing and technical infrastructure needed for oversight, compliance, and performance. C. Clarify Expectations for Executing FY26 – 30 CIP Commitments 1. With over $53M in proposed housing allocations in the FY26 – 30 CIP, City Council may request regular reporting on agreement status, timing, and any necessary re-allocations. 2. Direction may be needed to prioritize readiness and alignment with community needs and AHP goals. D. Reinforce Support for Policy Tools in Development 1. City Council may reaffirm its commitment to fully implementing key policy tools outlined in the AHP — including the Land Bank Authority and Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program. 2. City Staff can be directed to bring forward implementation timelines, governance structures, and funding implications to ensure these tools are aligned with the City’s affordability and equity goals. E. Maintain and Strengthen Transparency and Evaluation Practices 1. City Council may continue to support the use of public-facing dashboards and reporting mechanisms to track housing investments and outcomes. 2. Periodic updates on AMI targeting, unit performance, and geographic equity can help maintain accountability. Alternatives No Council action is required. This report is presented for information and discussion only. Attachments 1. Attachment A - Tables/Figures 1-3 2. Attachment B - Snapshot Community Indicators 3. Attachment C - PowerPoint Presentation 2025 Affordable Housing Report 4. Attachment D - Referenced Key Excerpts of 2021 Affordable Housing Plan Page 9 of 147 2025 Affordable Housing Report City of Charlottesville Attachment A 1. Administration Expenditures The City of Charlottesville has steadily expanded its internal affordable housing administration capacity since FY2022. While the Affordable Housing Plan (AHP) recommended an average of $1 million per year for administrative expenses, actual administrative salary costs to date remain below that target. These expenses support critical operational functions of the Office of Community Solutions (OCS), includin g program design, fund administration, compliance oversight, technical assistance to grantees, policy enforcement, and capacity-building activities. (Figure 1: A table detailing administrative expenditures, e.g., salaries—namely, of the city from FY22-FY25) Category FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25 Full-Time Staff Salaries - $117,866 $193,249 $222,107 Allocated Staff, Salaries (Partial) $159,216 $214,004 $171,006 $194,879 Total Salaries $159,216 $331,870 $364,255 $416,986 Note: Full-time staff includes 2 FTEs solely dedicated to the AHP . Partial allocations represent five staff members, with 20%–80% of their time dedicated to AHP implementation. Examples of activities covered by these costs include: • Program Administration: Running competitive citywide Notice of Funding Availability ( NOFA) cycles, managing Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund ( CAHF) and Housing Operations and Program Support ( HOPS) grant awards . • Compliance & Monitoring: Reporting, inspecting , and evaluating housing outcome s. • Policy Development: Development and i mplementation of strategies , programs , and services, e.g., Land Bank Authority and Tax Abatement Performance or recently adopted Affordable Dwelling Unit Program . • Technical Assistance: Studies and research, consultants, and s upporting capacity -limited community partners • Training & Capacity Building: Professional development and certifications, Supporting community -led boards and housing nonprofits . With the scale of the affordable housing pipeline and the complexity of projects in motion (zoning changes, land bank formation, ADU compliance, etc.), full realization of the $ 1 million per year administrative benchmark will be essential. Page 10 of 147 2. Tax Relief Programs The City’s Affordable Housing investments also include targeted tax relief programs that support low - income homeowners and renters. These programs reduce the risk of displacement, especially among elderly or disabled residents on fixed incomes. Between FY2 2 and FY25, the City allocated over $9.5 million in combined tax relief . (Figure 2: A table detailing allocation in various tax relief programs of the city from FY22-FY25) Program FY22 FY23 FY24 FY25 Charlottesville Homeowner Assistance Program $924,986 $1,333,149 $1,254,042 $1,315,000 Rent Relief – Disabled $162,529 $123,206 $99,680 $118,000 Rent Relief – Elderly $27,500 $34,102 $30,043 $38,000 Tax Relief – Disabled $221,626 $216,665 $217,650 $231,000 Tax Relief – Elderly $469,196 $716,341 $1,035,838 $1,016,000 Total $1,805,837 $2,423,463 $2,637,253 $2,718,000 These programs are designed and administered by the Commissioner of Revenue and are aligned with the AHP's goal of stabilizing long-time or vulnerable residents. 3. Direct Housing Investments The City’s Capital Improvement Program (CIP) remains the largest funding source for direct affordable housing production, preservation, and acquisition. Key investments since FY2022 include a total of just under $48 million: (Figure 3: A table detailing direct affordable housing investment allocations of the city from FY22-FY25) Direct Funded Item CIP Other CAHF $4,850,000 $0 CSRAP $3,600,000 $0 Friendship Court (PHA) $6,144,841 $0 VCF – Housing Line $0 $1,000,000 501 Cherry Ave (PHA) $3,150,000 $3,350,000 Dogwood Portfolio (CRHA) $0 $5,025,154 Carlton Mobile Home Park $0 $744,000 1025 Park St Apartments (PHA) $3,770,000 $0 1200 Park Street Apartments (PHA) $2,250,000 $0 Virginia Supportive Housing Vista 29 $0 $750,000 South First Street (CRHA) $6,000,000 $0 6th Street Phase 1 (CRHA) $6,000,000 $0 Salvation Army Center of Hope $0 $1,282,579 Total $35,764,841 $12,151,733 Page 11 of 147 2025 Affordable Housing Report City of Charlottesville Attachment B Community Indicators $124,200 Area Median Income Effective April 2024 (HUD) $495,000 Median Sales Price As of December 2024 (CAAR Home Sales Report) $2,100/month Median Rent As of March 2025 (Zillow Rent Index) American Community Survey 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 Households Spending Over 30% of Income on Housing Owner Rental Page 12 of 147 To be a place where everyone thrives. Presented: April 21, 2025, 4 PM City Council Opening Session By the City’s Office of Community Solutions Page 13 of 147 What Is this Affordable Housing Report (AHR)? • Third checkpoint since adoption of the 2021 Affordable Housing Plan (AHP) • Tracks progress from FY22 to FY25 across: • Direct Investments • Tax relief Programs Budgets • Administrative Expenditures and Capacity • Provides analysis, accountability, and forward-looking recommendations Note: The Council is not being asked to take action tonight. This presentation is intended to inform and guide continued alignment with the 10-year AHP strategy. 2 Page 14 of 147 AHP Milestone Update: Housing Staff Now Testing Housing Investment Tracking Dashboard (Beta)  Supports AHP Funding Recommendation Pillar Four (Page 12):  Scale – Cumulative Investments  Consistency – Multi-year flow tracking  Targeting – AMI and unit analysis  Transparency – Public-facing, policy- informing, and information sharing Testing May 1 – July 30th. Early access with QR Code is available 3 Page 15 of 147 10-Year Affordable Housing Plan (AHP) Framework Overview A. Three Core Funding Categories • $70M – Direct Housing Investments • $20M – Tax Relief & Stability Programs • $10M – Administrative Capacity and Expenditures =$100M over 10 Years B.10-Year Housing Targets • 1,100 new Supported Affordable Units (SAUs) • 1,300 existing SAUs preserved • Up to 2,200 households stabilized (e.g., tax relief, rehab, vouchers) C. Income Targeting Guidelines • 50% of funds for ≤30%AHP Income Targeting Framework (Page 13 of AHP AMI households • 30% of funds for 31–60% AMI households • 20% of funds for 61–80% AMI households So, what does that mean in practice? If we apply those AHP equity benchmarks to the 1,100 new SAUs target, we could target to achieve 550 units serving ≤30% AMI; 330 units for 31–60% AMI; and 220 units for 61–80% AMI The same conceptual distribution could apply to the preservation and stabilization goals — especially for funding decisions, voucher programs, and acquisition priorities. 4 Page 16 of 147 FY22-25 Total Investment Summary These figures reflect actuals and committed funding verified through the City’s internal accounting system (SAP). Direct Investments $12.15 Million* 21% Direct Investments(CIP) $35.77 Million 61% Tax Relief Programs $9.58 Million 16% Administrative Costs $1.27 Million 2% Direct Investments $12.15 Million* Direct Investments(CIP) $35.77 Million Tax Relief Programs $9.58 Million Administrative Costs $1.27 Million • After FY/or CIP or Budget Adoption; and • FY22, FY23 Vibrant Community Funds Housing Funding Line $58.77M 5 Page 17 of 147 Investment Category Total (FY22–FY25) % of $100M AHP Goal Direct Housing Investments $47.92 Million 46% Tax Relief Programs $9.58 Million 9.6% Administrative Costs $1.27 Million 1.2% Total (FY22– 25) $58.77 M 57% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% FY2025 AHP Funding Recommendation Allocated Observation: Charlottesville is making real progress, with nearly 60% of the $100M Affordable Housing Plan already invested by FY25. However, future-year spending must remain balanced to uphold transparency, implementation capacity, and the Plan’s commitment to deep affordability (≤30% AMI). FY22-25 Total Investment Summary 6 Page 18 of 147 Direct Investments Breakdown (FY22–FY25) Key Direct Investments CAHF CSRAP Kindlewood (PHA) VCF – Housing Line 501 Cherry Ave (PHA) Carlton Mobile Home Park Dogwood Portfolio (CRHA) 1025 Park St Apartments (PHA) 1200 Park Street Apartments (PHA) Virginia Supportive Housing Vista 29 South First Street Phase 2 (CRHA) 6th Street (CRHA) Salvation Army Center of Hope Total Total = $47,916,574 7 CIP Other $4,850,000 $0 $3,600,000 $0 $6,144,841 $0 $0 $1,000,000 $3,150,000 $3,350,000 $0 $744,000 $0 $5,025,154 $3,770,000 $0 $2,250,000 $0 $0 $750,000 $6,000,000 $0 $6,000,000 $0 $0 $1,282,579 $35,764,841 $12,151,733 Page 19 of 147 Supported Affordable Unit (SAU) Pipeline—FY22–25 Total Pipeline Units: 983 (as of FY25) • ≤30% AMI: 348 units (35%) – Suggested Target (50%) • 31–60% AMI: 427 units (43%) – Suggested Target (30%) • 61–80% AMI: 208 units (20%) – Suggested Target (21%) Observation: On target, +/- approx. 40 additional units pending from April 2025 CAHF approvals → Projected Total: ~1,023 by FY26 Point of Caution / Imbalance: While the City is making progress on affordable unit production, the share of units targeted to households earning ≤30% AMI remains below the 50% goal outlined in the Affordable Housing Plan. 8 Page 20 of 147 9 FY26–FY30 CIP Outlook + Budget Snapshot Future Investment Outlook & Budget Summary Projected CIP Allocations (FY26-FY30) • FY26 - $12,732,200 • FY27 - $13,727,900 • FY28 - $10,256,100 • FY29 - $8,211,800 • FY30 - $8,065,000 Budget Totals Category FY22–FY25 FY26-FY30 (Future Proposed) Direct Investments $47.92M ~$53M* Rounded from 52.9 Tax Relief Programs $9.58M ~$3.1M Administrative Costs $1.27M ~$5M* (Demand +Target Based) Total $58.77M ~$61.1M Observation : If all projections hold, the City’s total 10- year investment will reach ~$ 119.87 , exceeding the original $100M Affordable Housing Plan by approximately. $20 million —or by more (ranging + 3% —4%) depending on financing/bonding cost for specific CRHA redevelopment projects funded in CIP FY25 and FY26- 28, e.g., South First Street Phase 2, Sixth Street Phase 1, or Westhaven Redevelopment Project. • = $52.9 Million Page 21 of 147 Policy Observations & Strategic Alignment Consideration Key Observations: • Direct Investments are ahead of pace, projected to exceed their $70M goal by nearly 45% • Administrative capacity remains underfunded, with only 13% of AHP's admin target met to date • ≤30% AMI units account for just ~34% of the pipeline — well below the 50% equity target Strategic Tools Advancing the Plan: What Comes Next—FY25 Closeout & FY26 Strategic Alignment • Citywide Fiscal Coordination and Alignment - Coordinate with the Budget Office and Finance Committee to validate investment figures and present one final data update — with outcomes summarized in a forthcoming City Manager’s Report to ensure financial clarity and alignment. • Land Bank Authority – Preserving affordability through land banking mechanisms and programs • Tax Abatement Program – Supporting low-income homeowners • ADU Program & Manual – Implemented 2024; driving inclusionary production • Housing Investment Dashboard (Beta) – Supports transparency, tracking, and compliance 10 Page 22 of 147 OCS Recommendations & Questions for Council Recommendations: 1. Reinforce funding for ≤30% AMI production 2. Scale administrative support to match implementation needs 3. Align future CIP appropriations with Plan equity and category targets 4. Support full execution of Land Bank, Tax Abatement, and ADU Programmatic Updates and tools 5. Maintain and enhance transparency tools (e.g., Dashboard, Reporting) Questions for Council: • Does the Council support continued prioritization of deeply affordable housing? • How should future-year CIP items be assessed for alignment with the Affordable Housing Plan and council focus (a guide for what the 2026 Affordable Housing Report will focus on) • (Following the subsequent presentations) Does the Council affirm the City Manager’s direction to implement Land Bank and Tax Abatement initiatives? 11 Page 23 of 147 Thank You Page 24 of 147 Executive Summary | Funding Recommendations HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville should make a strong and recurring financial commitment to address housing needs in Charlottesville. In particular, the City should implement the following recommended changes to its funding policies: Scale Dedicate $10M per year to fund affordable housing, to (1) increase the number of subsidized affordable homes by 1,100 homes (on top of an existing stock of 1,630 actively subsidized homes), (2) preserve 600 existing subsidized affordable homes, and (3) stabilize 1,800 to 2,200 owner and renter households facing housing instability. Consistency Make a commitment to sustain this level of funding for ten years, identifying sustainable and reliable source(s) of dedicated funding. Targeting Target funding towards extremely low-income households to ensure that public funding is targeted to incomes with the greatest need. Allocate 50% of funding to serve households with incomes up to 30% of Area Median Income (AMI), 30% of funding for households earning up to 60% AMI, and 20% of funding for households earning up to 80% AMI. Attach funding awards to community representation, duration of affordability, and leverage of non-public funds. Projects that receive public funding should be administered and governed by organizations that directly represent the beneficiaries of housing assistance. Funding awards should also incentivize permanent affordability of both renter- and owner-occupied housing. Finally, public dollars should incentivize maximum leverage of federal, state, and private funding. Transparency Clearly identify overall housing expenditures within the City’s budget, and publish metrics on program funding, capacity, and impacts to create accountability and measure progress towards housing goals. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 12 E.g., for a three-person household: 30% AMI: $25,350 60% AMI: $50,760 80% AMI: $67,600 The funding chapter provides additional detail on recommended policy changes, as well as the anticipated impacts of these changes. See Appendix for full table of Area Median Incomes and affordable rents in Charlottesville. Page 25 of 147 Funding | Scale and Consistency HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 49 RECOMMENDED CHANGES The City of Charlottesville should dedicate $10 million per year to invest in housing affordability over the next ten years. This proposed figure of $10M represents total—not additional—spending, and it represents local spending, not including additional funding provided through state or federal sources. As appropriate, direct subsidy should be centralized and allocated through the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund. $1M Admin $2M Tax Relief $7M Direct Subsidy The City has historically “spent” close to $2M per year on household tax relief, provided to low-income households through the Charlottesville Housing Affordability Program and to elderly and disabled households through the Real Estate Tax Relief program. This allocation, which supports housing stability for low-income homeowners, should be highlighted within the City’s housing budget. The majority of the $10M should be allocated to direct subsidy. These expenditures include both “capital” subsidies used to build and preserve affordable homes, such as financing for public housing redevelopment and single- family infill development, and “operating” subsidies provided on an ongoing basis, such as emergency rental assistance and property tax relief. This funding includes the City’s current commitments to affordable housing programs including CSRAP and planned new subsidized housing developments. As appropriate, the allocation of these funds should be made through the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (CAHF) with input from the CAHF committee. As part of its $10M annual commitment, the City should set aside $1M in funding each year for administrative costs and capacity building. This is a standard practice for housing departments, programs, and funds. These funds would pay for the personnel required for a variety of tasks: to run a competitive process to award funds; monitor and evaluate impact; enforce compliance; design and develop new housing policies; provide technical assistance for funding recipients to improve their expertise and effectiveness; and provide training for new board members of the HAC, especially those who are community representatives and might not work on housing professionally. Page 26 of 147 Funding | Scale and Consistency HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 50 CONTEXT The City has already recently made significant commitments for future spending on housing. These commitments effectively fulfill the recommended $10M commitment through 2025. $40M Capital Improvement Program funding commitment, 2020-2025 Some of these commitments have been detailed in the City’s Capital Improvement Program (CIP), which allocates about $40M between 2020 and 2025 towards a number of housing programs. $5.25M Rental vouchers through the Charlottesville Supplemental Rental Assistance Program (CSRAP) $15M Public housing redevelopment $17M Friendship Court project $3.125M Housing rehabilitation and residential energy conservation Other annual housing expenditures, average of historical and projected spending 2020-2025 In addition to these commitments made in the CIP, the City has historically supported other housing programs through tax relief and through other direct subsidies allocated through the City’s operating fund. $1.7M Average annual property tax relief for low-income, disabled, or veteran homeowners ~$500K Vibrant Communities Fund, competitively allocated to various housing nonprofits Page 27 of 147 Funding | Scale and Consistency HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 51 CONTEXT Charlottesville has committed a significant amount of funding for a city of its size. A commitment of $100M over ten years would put Charlottesville in the top tier of cities making strong and lasting commitments to affordable housing. For the sake of comparison, the table below focuses on only funding used for direct subsidy, excluding property tax relief and administrative costs. Therefore, Charlottesville’s commitment shows $70M, excluding an estimate of $10M for administrative costs and $20M for tax relief over ten years. Raleigh, NC Durham, NC Richmond, VA Washington, D.C. Charlottesville, VA Funding Commitment Size and Sources $80M bond $95M bond (in addition to $65M of existing expenditures, part of $160M housing plan) $80M from dedicating tax revenues from properties phasing out of partial tax exemption $100M+ through housing trust fund, from transfer taxes and general fund $70M in direct subsidy funding Time Period 5 years 5 years 10 years annual 10 years Population 470,000 275,000 230,000 685,000 50,000 $ Per Capita Per Year $34 $116 $35 $146+ $140 Page 28 of 147 Funding | Scale and Consistency HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 52 RECOMMENDED CHANGES Charlottesville needs to identify one or more dedicated funding sources to sustain its commitment to affordable housing beyond 2025. Increased spending on housing will require either reallocating funding from other programs within the existing budget, or creating new fees or taxes that expand revenue sources. If funds cannot be reallocated from other priorities to support ongoing housing programs, the City will need to more closely evaluate potential funding sources. This analysis will need to consider several key factors: Legality Is this form of tax or fee legal in Virginia? Revenue potential How much revenue is this tax or fee estimated to yield on an annual basis? Revenue stability Does the tax or fee provide a reliable and stable source of funding? Equity Does the fee’s impact on the tax base meet the City’s equity goals? Is the tax regressive? Examples of revenue sources used for housing trust funds elsewhere in Virginia include: Property tax increase Additional property tax dedicated to housing Example: Richmond, VA Meals tax Additional tax on restaurant food and beverage sales Example: Alexandria, VA Developer contributions Impact fee on new market- rate residential development Examples: Alexandria, VA; Fairfax, VA Charlottesville currently funds its housing programs through general fund and capital fund contributions. Charlottesville already uses these and other revenue sources to fund a variety of programs. To sustain a $10M annual commitment over time, the City will need to evaluate potential revenue sources as well as its other policy and funding priorities, such as schools and Main Street improvements, to balance available resources with the City’s goals. This evaluation of opportunity and need should consider the near-term fiscal impacts of COVID-19, which has impacted some City revenues and intensified funding needs across a spectrum of priorities. Page 29 of 147 Funding | Scale and Consistency HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 53 CONTEXT AND RECOMMENDED CHANGES Local funding commitments will be particularly important in the face of limited and declining federal and state support. Federal and state funding for housing has been limited, and while the City should continue to pursue and advocate for this funding, it is not likely to increase. Public spending on affordable housing has declined over several decades for political and structural reasons, and local jurisdictions cannot rely on an infusion of federal resources to address local housing issues. To the extent possible, it is also crucial that funding be secured consistently. Fiscal year 2021 represents an extreme example of this challenge, as the level of funding for housing was significantly reduced due to budget impacts from the COVID-19 pandemic. Even before this fiscal year, though, spending on housing programs varied significantly, driven by one-time funding for large capital projects. This inconsistency has presented multiple challenges to the efficacy of housing programs in the city. Program administrators are less able to plan for their own operating and capital expenditures, relying on limited philanthropic dollars to fill emergency needs, and the City has less ability to award funding efficiently through a competitive process when funding is responsive to developer requests. While the City Council cannot commit funds on behalf of a future City Council, Charlottesville must still make a policy commitment to affordable housing and develop a funding approach, such that community partners can plan around an approach that future City Councils will reliably adopt. All programs should continue to seek to leverage as much private financing and additional public funding as possible, relative to Charlottesville’s contributions. For example, for every dollar that the City invested into Low-Income Tax Credit developments in 2018 – 2019, an additional three to seven dollars of public or private financing was secured to amplify the impact of local dollars. The City should continue to leverage philanthropic dollars, below-market-rate private lending, federal subsidy, and regional sources of funding. Regional Funding for Housing The City and regional stakeholders should consider the potential for a regional affordable housing funding agreement to jointly provide funding from Charlottesville, Albemarle County, and potentially other jurisdictions to support affordable housing development and programming, particularly within the urban ring. A regional funding agreement would allow for greater efficiency in housing production, as it would facilitate the streamlining of programs that serve the region, create flexibility to pursue the most cost-effective projects within the region, and reduce administrative overhead. Given the shared authority and tax relationship between the City and County for the urban ring investments should be shared between the two. The County and City should establish an agreement about how to coordinate investments within the urban ring to have the greatest impacts. In Wake County, North Carolina, the City of Raleigh and the County have separate housing funds and they collaborate with each other to make coordinated investments in LIHTC projects and other affordable housing development to leverage each others funding. Albemarle County and the City of Charlottesville should consider establishing a similar partnership. Page 30 of 147 Funding | Scale and Consistency HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 54 POTENTIAL IMPACTS What could be achieved with $100M in investments over 10 years? With $10M in average annual spending over ten years, Charlottesville could grow its existing stock of subsidized homes by nearly 70 percent, preserve nearly 40 percent of existing subsidized housing at risk of becoming unaffordable or obsolete, and provide direct assistance annually to up to 2,000 households facing housing instability. The resulting level of production shown is only possible if funds are used efficiently and leverage private investment as well as state and federal resources—and, to this end, it will be essential to thoroughly underwrite all funding awards. Combining the subsidy tools represented here with land use reform and tenants’ rights tools will potentially decrease costs and expand program benefits, further increasing the impact of public dollars. Of the other tools, inclusionary zoning would directly contribute to the production of additional homes, which are not included in the estimate below. Estimated impact of $100M in spending over 10 years These impact figures assume the following costs: • For newly subsidized homes, between $35K to $50K per home for new construction, up to $50K for down payment assistance, and approximately $25K for owner-occupied repairs • For preserved homes, up to $20K through an acquisition fund, and between $45 to $50K per public housing home. • For stabilized households, annual costs of up to $1,500 for property tax relief, $5K for emergency relief, and $9K for vouchers These numbers represent one potential distribution of funding—the actual impact will depend on City Council’s final funding allocations, informed by recommendations by the CAHF Committee. Change in Subsidized Homes Through programs such as LIHTC gap financing, public housing redevelopment, single-family infill 1,630 1,000 600 1,100 Current With $100M Newly subsidized homes Preserved homes Existing homes Households Stabilized Annually Through programs such as property tax relief, emergency rental assistance 1,600 – 2,000 Households+ Page 31 of 147 Funding | Scale and Consistency HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 54 POTENTIAL IMPACTS What could be achieved with $100M in investments over 10 years? With $10M in average annual spending over ten years, Charlottesville could grow its existing stock of subsidized homes by nearly 70 percent, preserve nearly 40 percent of existing subsidized housing at risk of becoming unaffordable or obsolete, and provide direct assistance annually to up to 2,000 households facing housing instability. The resulting level of production shown is only possible if funds are used efficiently and leverage private investment as well as state and federal resources—and, to this end, it will be essential to thoroughly underwrite all funding awards. Combining the subsidy tools represented here with land use reform and tenants’ rights tools will potentially decrease costs and expand program benefits, further increasing the impact of public dollars. Of the other tools, inclusionary zoning would directly contribute to the production of additional homes, which are not included in the estimate below. Estimated impact of $100M in spending over 10 years These impact figures assume the following costs: • For newly subsidized homes, between $35K to $50K per home for new construction, up to $50K for down payment assistance, and approximately $25K for owner-occupied repairs • For preserved homes, up to $20K through an acquisition fund, and between $45 to $50K per public housing home. • For stabilized households, annual costs of up to $1,500 for property tax relief, $5K for emergency relief, and $9K for vouchers These numbers represent one potential distribution of funding—the actual impact will depend on City Council’s final funding allocations, informed by recommendations by the CAHF Committee. Change in Subsidized Homes Through programs such as LIHTC gap financing, public housing redevelopment, single-family infill 1,630 1,000 600 1,100 Current With $100M Newly subsidized homes Preserved homes Existing homes Households Stabilized Annually Through programs such as property tax relief, emergency rental assistance 1,600 – 2,000 Households+ Page 32 of 147 Funding | Targeting HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 55 RECOMMENDED CHANGES AND IMPACTS Place constraints on funding as appropriate to target funding towards uses that achieve public goals. Beyond the overall scale and level of funding, the City should also consider what constraints it will place on where its funding should go, as a way of balancing commitments to different issues and goals. Income Levels Set a goal of targeting 50% of funding to serve households with incomes up to 30% of AMI, 30% of funding for households earning up to 60% AMI, and 20% of funding for households earning up to 80% AMI. Out of an annual $10M budget with $1M reserved for administrative costs, this means that $4.5M will go to households earning up to around $22K, $2.7M will go to households earning up to around $45K, and $1.8M will go to households earning up to around $60K. These figures represent the income bands for two-person households; refer to the appendix for a full table of income bands by household size. Income Targeting Income level Served Income for Two- and Four-Person Household Target Allocation, Percentage Target Allocation, Over 10 Years Up to 80% AMI Two: $60,100 Four: $75,100 20% $18M Up to 60% AMI Two: $45,120 Four: $56,340 30% $27M Up to 30% AMI Two: $22,550 Four: $28,150 50% $45M Page 33 of 147 Funding | Targeting HR&A Advisors, Inc. Charlottesville Affordable Housing Plan | 56 RECOMMENDED CHANGES AND IMPACTS Beyond the overall scale and level of funding, the City should also consider what constraints it will place on where its funding should go, as a way of balancing commitments to different issues and goals. Community Representation Set a community representation standard for all organizations receiving funding: The leadership and board of organizations that receive City housing funding should be reflective of the communities they are serving and include residents who are participating in City-funded housing programs. Reflection of the community served and inclusion of those participating in the program are two separate but related expectations. Residents who participate or have participated in housing programs have insight into how to reform housing programs to increase their effectiveness and should be represented in the decision-making process. In most communities, those who benefit directly from affordable housing have been excluded from the decision-making process. A lack of representation can unintentionally reinforce existing economic inequities and power imbalances. Charlottesville should adapt existing precedents for community representation to fit its racial justice focus. There are a range of approaches to community representation: from setting minimum requirements as HUD does for Community Housing Development Organizations (CHDOs), to including community representation as a scoring criteria as are used for Nashville’s housing trust fund (the Barnes Fund). The CAHF Committee will be charged with setting these standards and adapting them over time as appropriate. Setting a community representation requirement is crucial to the guiding principle of racial equity, as it will push both the City and program administrators to be deliberate about overcoming historical patterns of underrepresentation of non-white populations within staffing and decision-making. Duration of Affordability All programs should seek the longest affordability term feasible. The City should seek 99-year affordability for rental developments receiving City assistance, such as direct project funding or funding for infrastructure improvements. Affordable homeownership ownership programs should seek to preserve affordability by encouraging homes to be sold to income-qualifying (<80% AMI) buyers. If homes are sold to households earning >80% AMI, public funding put into the property should be repaid to the City through the sale proceeds. This repayment requirement helps ensure that public funds are recycled to continually assist low- income homebuyers. For all programs, the Housing Trust Fund Advisory Committee should review the affordability duration criteria for each program and adjust as appropriate. Page 34 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: None (informational only Presentation). Presenter: Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Staff Contacts: Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Title: Housing Ecosystem Anti-Displacement Toolkit (HEAT) Update: Expanding Affordable Options and Stability Background This is a two (2) - part Presentation. Please see the following items: (1) Item "A:" Establishing the Land Bank Authority: Progress & Next Steps;" and (2) Item "B:" "Introducing CAHTAP: A New Tax Abatement Strategy for Housing Affordability." Discussion Please see Item "A:" "Establishing the Land Bank Authority: Progress & Next Steps; " and Item "B:" "Introducing CAHTAP: A New Tax Abatement Strategy for Housing Affordability." Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan Please see Item "A:" "Establishing the Land Bank Authority: Progress & Next Steps; " and Item "B:" "Introducing CAHTAP: A New Tax Abatement Strategy for Housing Affordability." Community Engagement Please see Item "A:" "Establishing the Land Bank Authority: Progress & Next Steps; " and Item "B:" "Introducing CAHTAP: A New Tax Abatement Strategy for Housing Affordability." Budgetary Impact Please see Item "A:" "Establishing the Land Bank Authority: Progress & Next Steps; " and Item "B:" "Introducing CAHTAP: A New Tax Abatement Strategy for Housing Affordability." Recommendation Not applicable. Informational Presentation only. Alternatives Page 35 of 147 Not applicable. Informational Presentation only. Attachments None Page 36 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: None (Informational only Presentation) Presenter: Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Staff Contacts: James Freas, Deputy City Manager Alexander Ikefuna, Director, Office of Community Solutions Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Title: Establishing the Land Bank Authority: Progress and Next Steps Background The City of Charlottesville, Virginia (“City”), is considering establishing the Charlottesville Land Bank Authority (“LBAC”) as a public body corporate under Virginia Code §§ 15.2-7500 et seq. to facilitate land acquisition, redevelopment, and long-term affordability preservation. The Ordinance to create the LBAC has been drafted and is currently under legal review, incorporating best practices from prior land bank models, such as the Chesapeake Land Bank Authority. Policy Milestones and Rationale for Creating LBAC: • (2018 – 2021) Affordable Housing Planning: The 2021 Affordable Housing Plan and Housing Equity & Anti-Displacement Strategy identified a Land Bank as a critical tool for advancing long-term affordability and stabilizing neighborhoods. • (2023) City Council and HAC Re-engagement: The Housing Advisory Committee (“HAC”) and City leadership revisited the concept to refine priorities and ensure alignment with community needs. • (2024) Market and Policy Shift: Rising land costs, speculative development, and displacement risks reinforced the urgency of a City-led land banking initiative. City Leadership and Stakeholder Engagement The City Manager’s Office, through Sam Sanders, Jr., City Manager, and James Freas, Deputy City Manager, has worked closely with HAC, City Staff, and the City Attorney’s Office to refine the approach to Land Banking. Discussions in HAC Meetings (October and November 2024) and internal City Staff deliberations have focused on: • Ensuring the LBAC is structured for financial sustainability and operational feasibility; • Determining the appropriate governance model, leading to the decision to form LBAC as a public authority rather than a nonprofit; and Page 37 of 147 • Aligning LBAC’s land acquisition strategy with affordable housing and anti-displacement goals, Discussion The establishment of the LBAC presents both strategic opportunities and important considerations for City Council. Below are the key areas of focus: A. Governance and Structure 1. LBAC will be established as a public body corporate under the Virginia Land Bank Entities Act (Virginia Code §§ 15.2-7500 et seq.). 2. The LBAC’s Board of Directors (“Board”) will be composed of seven (7) voting members: a. One (1) City Councilor b. One (1) Planning Commission Representative c. One (1) City Manager Appointee d. Four (4) At-Large Community Members (Two (2) must have lived experience related to affordable housing challenges.) 3. OCS Housing Staff will work closely with LBAC’s appointed Board to develop an operational framework, policies, and strategic direction. B. Fiscal and Funding Mechanisms 1. LBAC will be able to acquire, hold, and manage land tax-free and leverage up to fifty percent (50%) of future real estate tax revenue from redeveloped properties for reinvestment in affordable housing. 2. Potential funding sources include: a. City Budget allocations; b. Tax Abatement Revenues; c. State and Federal Housing Grants; and d. Philanthropic and Private Investments (pending confirmation of legal mechanisms for donation acceptance). 3. City Staff will conduct further analysis to determine the financial feasibility of these funding streams and their long-term sustainability. C. Strategic Priorities and Implementation 1. LBAC’s primary mission is to increase affordable housing opportunities, revitalize underutilized land or real property, and prevent displacement. 2. The LBAC will develop policies for property acquisition, disposition, and partnerships to ensure equitable redevelopment in alignment with the 2021 Affordable Housing Plan. 3. City Staff is preparing an operational Work Plan, which will guide LBAC’s first year and be subject to annual review and reporting to City Council. Page 38 of 147 4. Next Steps and Council Consideration To formally establish LBAC, the following steps must be completed: 1. City Attorney’s Office completes legal review of the draft Ordinance. 2. Public Hearing is scheduled and conducted (required under Virginia Code § 15.2-7502). 3. City Council votes on the Ordinance to establish the LBAC. 4. Board appointments are made, and the LBAC begins its initial operations. 5. The City Attorney’s Office completes state processes for the creation of the Land Bank Authority entity. Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan • 2023 Strategic Framework: Supports equitable growth, partnerships, housing affordability, some climate actions, and sustainability—goals that a land bank can help achieve by re-purposing underutilized land for affordable housing. • Comprehensive Plan (2021): This plan focuses on inclusive neighborhoods and sustainable development. A land bank can facilitate affordable housing and neighborhood revitalization in alignment with goals. • Affordable Housing Plan (2021) • Climate Action Plan 2023-2027 (where or when applicable). • Consolidated Plan (where or when applicable). Community Engagement Extensive discussions with City leadership, advisory bodies, and housing experts have been instrumental in shaping the LBAC's governance, funding, and operational priorities. Notably, the HAC has played a crucial role, emphasizing the LBAC's potential to drive affordability, revitalization, and prevent displacement. HAC feedback underscored the necessity for clear oversight, sustainable funding strategies, and a well-defined operational framework, while supporting an initial City- supported Pilot phase for strategic implementation before full independence. Simultaneously, the City Manager’s Office has focused on refining coordination and oversight, addressing staffing, tax abatement impacts, and revenue allocation, and advocating for a Pilot Program aligned with Virginia best practices. Furthermore, a formal Public Hearing, as mandated by Virginia Code § 15.2-7502, will be conducted before City Council adoption. Ongoing stakeholder outreach with housing advocates, developers, and neighborhood groups ensures that the LBAC's development remains responsive to local needs and priorities. Budgetary Impact N/A. Informational Presentation only, at this time. Recommendation This Presentation serves as a progress update on the establishment of the LBAC. Based on City Council’s feedback, the City Manager’s Office will refine next steps and guide City Staff accordingly. Page 39 of 147 Key Discussion Points for City Council Consideration • Are there any concerns or refinements City Council would like addressed before the Public Hearing? • What additional information is needed to support the Ordinance adoption process? • How can LBAC’s strategic priorities best align with City Council’s broader housing and economic goals? Potential Next Steps (Pending City Council Direction to City Manager) 1. Finalize legal review and Public Hearing Preparation – City Attorney’s Office ensures compliance with Virginia Code § 15.2-7500 et seq. 2. Refine Governance and Operational Framework – Clarify Board roles, tax abatement mechanisms, and initial funding strategies. 3. Advance Community Engagement – Continue stakeholder outreach, including HAC and housing partners, to align expectations. 4. City Council Follow-Up – City Staff will return with refined materials based on today’s discussion. Alternatives While no specific action is required at this time, City Council may consider the following broad alternatives as next steps based on their deliberation and feedback: 1. No Immediate Action: City Council may choose not to provide specific direction at this time and defer further exploration of land bank options. 2. Leverage Existing Resources: City Council could opt to continue using existing housing programs and partnerships to address housing challenges, without establishing a formal land bank entity. 3. Request Further Research: City Council may direct City Staff to gather additional information or explore other models and approaches to Land Banking before making a decision. 4. Prioritize Other Housing Strategies: City Council could decide to prioritize other housing strategies or tools currently available to address the City’s needs. Attachments 1. Attachment A - Land Bank Authority of the City of Charlottesville (LBAC) Draft Ordinance 2. Attachment B - PowerPoint Presentation Introduction LBAC Page 40 of 147 CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATIONARTICLE [xx]. LAND BANK AUTHORITY, CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA Sec. [xx] – Definitions . For this Ordinance, the following terms shall have the meanings assigned: 1. Affordable Housing – Housing units reserved for households earning 80% or below of the Area Median Income ( “AMI”) as defined by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”) and/or where it may also mean housing units reserved for households earning 60% or below the AMI for specific City of Charlottesville , Virginia (“City”), housing policies or programs of service. 2. Affordable Housing Beneficiaries – Individuals or households earning at or below 80% of the AMI as defined by HUD), who qualify for housing assistance programs, including but not limited to the Housing Choice Voucher Program, Low -Income Housing Tax Credit ( “LIHTC ”) housing, or other HUD -designated affordable housing initiatives. 3. Affordability Covenant – A deed restriction or legally enforceable agreement that ensures a property remains affordable for a specified period, consistent with the Authority’s housing priorities and affordability goals. 4. Authority – The Land Bank Authority of the City of Charlottesville , Virginia (“LBAC”), established pursuant to the Virginia Land Bank Entities Act , Virginia Code §§ 15.2- 7500 et seq. , as amended . 5. Blighted Property – Real property that, due to neglect, abandonment, disrepair, or code violations, has been declared blighted under applicable local or state law, making it eligible for remediation, rehabilitation, or acquisition by the Authority. 6. Board of Directors – The Authority's governing body is responsible for oversight, policy implementation, and financial accountability. 7. Community -Serving Projects – Developments, initiatives, or uses of Land Bank Properties that provide tangible benefits to City residents, including , but not limited to , affordable housing, public green space, community facilities, and neighborhood stabilization efforts. 8. Disposition Agreement – A legally binding agreement that governs the transfer, sale, or lease of a Land Bank Property by the Authority, specifying conditions such as affordability requirements, use restrictions, and timelines for development. 9. Interlocal Agreement – An agreement between the Authority and one (1) or more jurisdictions, as authorized under the Virginia Land Bank Entities Act (Virginia Code § § 15.2- 7500 et seq. , as amended) , to collaborate on land banking initiatives, regional property acquisition, and affordable housing strategies. 10. Land Bank Properties – Real property acquired, held, managed, or disposed of by the Authority in furtherance of its mission. This includes, but is not limited to, tax -delinquent properties, vacant and underutilized land, and properties designated for redevelopment or preservation in alignment with affordable housing and community stabilization priorities. Page 41 of 147 CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE [XX]. LAND BANK AUTHORITY, CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA 11. Neighborhood Stabilization – The strategic intervention in areas experiencing disinvestment, blight, or high foreclosure rates with the goal of promoting affordable housing, economic development, and long- term community resilience. 12. Permanent Affordability – A housing strategy that ensures long- term or indefinite affordability of a property through mechanisms such as deed restrictions, ground leases, or partnerships with community land trusts. 13. Real Property – Lands, structures, and any and all easements and every estate and right therein, legal and equitable, including terms for years and liens by way of judgment, mortgage, or otherwise, and any and all fixtures and improvements located thereon. 14. Request for Proposals ( “RFP”) Process – The competitive process by which the Authority solicits, evaluates, and selects developers, non -profits, or other entities for the acquisition and redevelopment of Land Bank Properties, subject to affordability and land use requirements. 15. Tax-Delinquent Properties – Real property on which taxes have remained unpaid for a period prescribed by law, making it eligible for acquisition by the Authority , under applicable tax foreclosure or tax sale procedures. Sec. [xx] Authority . This Ordinance is enacted pursuant to the Virginia Land Bank Entities Act (Virginia Code §§ 15.2- 7500 et seq. , as amended ), which grants localities the authority to create a land bank entity as an authority. Additionally, an authority created pursuant to the Act shall be created as a public body corporate and as a political subdivision of the Commonwealth. Sec. [xx] Formation and Purpose . This Ordinance establishes the Authority as a political subdivision to facilitate the acquisition, management, and disposition of underutilized, tax- delinquent, and vacant properties, increase the supply of affordable housing, and promote equitable land use for affordable housing development or preservation. While this Authority is established to serve the City, it is expressly within the sole discretion of the Charlottesville City Council (“City Council”) to authorize regional collaboration in accordance with the Virginia Land Bank Entities Act ( Virginia Code § 15.2- 7501, as amended) . Such authorization shall require a majority vote in the affirmative to amend this Ordinance. No action, policy, or administrative determination shall restrict or preclude the Authority from seeking City Council approval to enter into interlocal agreements or cooperative land banking efforts. Any such agreement shall require an affirmative vote of City Council. Page 42 of 147 CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE [XX]. LAND BANK AUTHORITY, CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA Sec. [xx] Vision, Mission, and Values. 1. Vision: A Charlottesville where all residents have access to safe, stable, and affordable housing. 2. Mission: To strategically acquire, manage, and repurpose underutilized properties to support affordable housing, prevent displacement, and promote equitable community development. 3. Core Values: A. Transparency and Accountability – Ensuring decision- making processes are open and accessible to the public. B. Community -Centered Development – Prioritizing affordable housing and neighborhood revitalization. C. Equity and Inclusion – Addressing historical disparities and promoting fair access to housing opportunities. Sec. [xx] Affordable Housing Priority Tiers . The Authority shall take all necessary steps to prioritize acquiring and disposing of properties for affordable housing development according to the following income levels: 1. High Priority (30% and below AMI) : Households in this category are classified as Extremely Low-Income (ELI) in accordance with U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) guidelines. These households face the highest risk of housing instability, severe cost burdens, and homelessness. The Charlottesville City Council has endorsed allocating 50% of the City’s affordable housing investments to this category. The Authority shall actively seek long- term affordability mechanisms, including deep subsidies, permanent affordability covenants, and partnerships with supportive housing providers, to ensure sustainabl e housing opportunities for these households. 2. Moderate Priority (31 -50% AMI) : Households in this category are classified as Very Low - Income (VLI) in accordance with HUD guidelines. These households often struggle with excessive rental cost burdens and limited homeownership opportunities, making them particularly vulnerable to displacement. The Charlottesville City Council has endorsed allocating 30% of the City’s affordable housing investments to this category. The Authority shall first prioritize Low -Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) -supported developments that most service high priority , e.g., deeply affordable rental housing initiatives and targeted homeownership assistance for this population. 3. Standard Priority (51 -80% AMI) : Households in this income range can access affordable homeownership programs, rental assistance, and workforce housing options as outlined by HUD. The Authority will support efforts to stabilize housing, promote mixed- income development, and develop transi tional housing models. This will help moderate -income households find affordable options while keeping housing affordable and accessible in the long run. Specifically, for households earning 80% of the Area Median Income (AM I), they are classified as Low -Income (LI) under HUD guidelines. These households can take advantage of affordable homeownership programs, workforce housing initiatives, and rental assistance. They usually face a lower risk of losing their homes compared t o lower -income groups. The Authority will ensure that mixed- income strategies do not displace those in greater need and instead work to expand access to affordable housing while promoting inclusive and fair housing opportunities. Page 43 of 147 CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE [XX]. LAND BANK AUTHORITY, CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA Sec. [xx] Title and Administrative Details . 2. Name of the Authority: The entity shall be known as the Land Bank Authority of the City of Charlottesville , Virginia (“LBAC”). 3. Address of the Principal Office: A. Physical Address: 700 E. Jefferson Street, 2nd Floor, the Office of Community Solutions (OCS) , Housing Division, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 B. Mailing Address: P.O. Box 911, Charlottesville, V irginia 22902 The Authority's principal office shall be located at the Office of Community Solutions, or such other location as designated by the Authority’s Board of Directors. 4. Incorporating Locality: LBAC is created by the City, by the adoption of this Ordinance and shall be incorporated as a public body corporate in accordance with the Virginia Land Bank Entities Act ( Virginia Code §§ 15.2- 7500 et seq. , as amended ). Upon the effective date of this Ordinance, the City shall take all necessary steps to complete the Authority's incorporation process as required by law. Sec. [xx] Governance and Operations . 1. Initial Board of Directors: City Council shall determine the names, addresses, and terms of office for the initial M embers of the Authority’s Board of Directors , at the time of the Authority’s incorporation , and include them in the official record of this Ordinance after the Authority’s incorporation . A. The Board shall include : 1. One (1) City Councilor, appointed by City Council, for a term specified by City Council, but which shall not exceed such Councilor’s elected term of office. 2. One (1) M ember of the Charlottesville Planning Commission, appointed by the Planning Commission, for a term specified by the Planning Commission, but which shall not exceed such M ember’s term on the Planning Commission. 3. The Charlottesville City Manager, or an employee of the City designated by the City Manager to serve as his/her representative (“designee”). This Member’s term shall not exceed one’s term of employment of the City Manager and/or the designee . 4. Four (4) individuals appointed by City Council : a) Two (2) M embers who shall be qualified as affordable housing beneficiaries or individuals with lived experience related to the hardship of finding safe, quality, and affordable housing. Page 44 of 147 CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE [XX]. LAND BANK AUTHORITY, CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA b) Two (2) at -large Community Members with relevant expertise or knowledge of housing, real estate, finance, or community development. 5. Initial terms shall be staggered, with two (2) members serving two (2) years , and the remaining three (3) years. Thereafter, all M embers shall serve four (4)-year terms. A majority of currently appointed Board Members shall constitute a quorum, and the vote of a majority of such quorum shall be necessary for any action taken by the Authority. 6. A vacancy in the board's membership shall not prevent a duly constituted quorum from exercising the Authority's powers and duties . However, any vacancy shall be filled within ninety ( 90) days in accordance with the appointment procedures set forth in this Ordinance. If a vacancy cannot be filled within this timeframe due to the specific qualifications required for Board composition, the City Manager may appoint a Director - level Staff member as an I nterim Board M ember. 7. Such Interim appointments shall not exceed ninety ( 90) days unless City Council, by majority vote, extends them for an additional ninety ( 90) days. No individual may serve more than two (2) consecutive Interim terms. If a vacancy remains unfilled beyond the Interim period, the City Manager shall provide a written report to City Council detailing efforts made to fill the position and recommending further action. Sec. [xx] Property Acquisition and Disposition . The Authority shall have any and all powers enumerated under Virginia Code § 15.2- 7506, as amended, including , but not limited to : 1. General Powers: A. Acquiring, holding, and disposing of real property in Charlottesville Metropolitan Statistical Area ( “MSA”), including, but not limited to Albemarle County, Fluvanna County, Greene County, and Nelson County, provided that such localities have formally entered into agreements with the Authority in accordance with the Virginia Land Bank Entities Act ( Virginia Code § 15.2- 7500 et seq. , as amended) ), and upon an affirmative majority vote of City Council to authorize such expansion. B. Entering into contracts and agreements. C. Accepting grants, loans, and public/private funding. D. Providing financing options for affordable housing and redevelopment projects within the Charlottesville MSA. E. Prioritizing the acquisition and development of affordable dwelling units , particularly for Critical Need (0 - 30%) to Moderate Priority (0 - 60%) households earning AMI in accordance with City Council’s endorsed housing priorities. Page 45 of 147 CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE [XX]. LAND BANK AUTHORITY, CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA 2. Acquisition of Property: A. The Authority may acquire real property only within the City's jurisdiction in the normal course of business. Any acquisition, transaction, or land banking activity outside of the City's jurisdiction, including within the Charlottesville MSA, shall require an affirmative majority vote of the City Council in accordance with the provisions of this O rdinance and applicable state law. B. In regard to conflict interests or violations of governing regulation for quasi -public entities, the Authority may follow its own adopted and City Council -approved standard operating procedures to acquire real property only within the City's jurisdiction, unl ess otherwise authorized by an affirmative majority vote of the City Council, pursuant to the provisions of this ordinance . C. The Authority may acquire real property through purchase, donation, foreclosure, transfers from the City, or tax -delinquent property acquisition, subject to applicable laws and policies. D. The Authority shall not exercise eminent domain. E. All acquisitions shall align with the Authority’s mission to increase the supply of affordable housing and prevent displacement. 3. Disposition of Property: A. The Authority shall establish comprehensive policies and procedures governing the sale, lease, or transfer of Land Bank properties to ensure transparent, equitable, and strategic asset management. B. Property disposition shall prioritize: 1. Affordable housing development that aligns with local housing needs and affordability targets. 2. Community- serving projects that enhance neighborhood stability and economic revitalization. 3. Neighborhood stabilization initiatives to prevent blight and disinvestment. C. The Authority may require covenants, deed restrictions, or affordability agreements to ensure long- term housing affordability. D. Strategies for flexible land disposition will be formulated to support small -scale housing initiatives that align with the City’s zoning regulations, all while aiming to reduce administrative complexities. Page 46 of 147 CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE [XX]. LAND BANK AUTHORITY, CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA E. The Authority may approve direct transactions outside of the RFP process when a stakeholder or property owner approaches the Land Bank for assistance, provided that such decisions are documented transparently and require a two- thirds (2/3) majority vote of the Board. Sec. [xx] Financial Operations and Oversight . 1. Financing of Operations: A. The Authority may receive funding through 1. City appropriations designated for affordable housing. 2. State and federal grants supporting land banking and redevelopment efforts. 3. Philanthropic contributions and private investments to expand housing opportunities consistent with the mission and values of the Authority. 4. Revenues generated from property sales, leases, or other transactions. 5. A share (up to 50%) of real property tax revenues collected on properties conveyed by the Authority, commencing with the first taxable year following the date of conveyance and continuing for up to ten (10) years. B. The Authority shall maintain a dedicated fund for all revenues and expenditures, which shall be subject to annual audit and financial oversight. 2. Exemption from Taxes : A. The Authority shall be exempt from local and state taxes or assessments on properties it owns, as provided in Virginia Code § 15.2- 7510. 3. Annual Reporting and Oversight : A. The Authority shall submit an annual report to City Council, which shall include: 1. Financial statements detailing revenues, expenditures, and fund balances. 2. A comprehensive inventory of properties held, acquired, or disposed of within the Fiscal Year. 3. Analysis of disposition outcomes, including the number of affordable housing units created or preserved. 4. Community impact assessment evaluating the effectiveness of the Authority’s activities in addressing housing needs. Page 47 of 147 CODE OF ORDINANCES CHAPTER 2 – ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE [XX]. LAND BANK AUTHORITY, CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA B. The Board shall adopt internal financial controls, transparency measures, and compliance procedures to ensure fiscal responsibility and public accountability. Sec. [xx] Dissolution of the Authority . 1. A two-thirds (2/3) vote of the Board, subject to approval by City Council, may dissolve the Authority . 2. Upon dissolution, all remaining assets, properties, and obligations shall revert to the City . 3. Dissolution shall not occur unless all outstanding obligations, debts, and contractual commitments of the Authority have been lawfully satisfied or otherwise provided for through an approved Transition Plan. 4. Prior to dissolution, the Authority shall provide City Council with a final financial report and Disposition Plan. Sec. [xx] Miscellaneous Provisions. 1. Severability: If a Court of competent jurisdiction holds any section, subsection, or provision of this O rdinance invalid or unconstitutional , such decision shall not affect the validity of the remaining provisions, which shall continue in full force and effect. 2. Effective Date: This Ordinance shall take effect immediately upon passage by the City Council. 3. Compliance with State and Federal Laws: The Authority shall operate in compliance with all applicable federal, state, and local laws, including but not limited to the Virginia Land Bank Entities Act and HUD affordable housing regulations. 4. Amendments: City Council may amend this Ordinance at its discretion. The Authority shall be provided with notice of any proposed amendments and may offer recommendations, but City Council retains full authority to enact changes as necessary to align with state law, local housing policy, or evolving community needs. Page 48 of 147 Land Bank Authority of Charlottesville (LBAC) Page 49 of 147 Land Bank Authority of Charlottesville (LBAC) How We Got Here: Key Milestones and Rationale • (2018 – 2021) Policy Foundations: The 2021 Affordable Housing Plan identified a Land Bank as a critical tool for affordability and neighborhood stabilization. • (2023) City Council and HAC Re-engagement: Council and the Housing Advisory Committee (“HAC”) refined priorities to align with community needs. • (2024) Housing Equity & Anti-Displacement Strategy: Reaffirmed the Land Bank’s role in promoting housing security, and affordability. • Rationale A (Market and Policy Shifts): Rising land costs, speculative development, and displacement risks highlight the need for a City-led land banking approach. • Rationale B (Strategic and Fiscal Opportunity): The LBAC can hold land tax-free, reinvest 50% of future real estate tax revenue, and enable targeted affordability interventions. 2 Page 50 of 147 Current Status: Policy Development and Legal Review • Ordinance Drafting: The Land Bank Authority of Charlottesville (LBCA) Ordinance has been developed and is under legal review by the City Attorney’s Office. • Enabling Regulation: The Ordinance is structured to align with Virginia Code §§ 15.2- 7500 et seq. (Land Bank Entities Act), ensuring: • Proper governance and structure. • Required Public Hearing process. • Defined powers, acquisition strategy, and tax-exempt status. • Collaborates with the Office of Community Solutions to align with housing, affordability, and revitalization strategies. It is NOT a City Department but is aligned for operational and policy coordination. • Similar to Charlottesville Economic Development Authority in structure and function, and not a City Department, but is aligned for operational and policy coordination. 3 Land Bank Authority of Charlottesville (LBAC) Page 51 of 147 Land Bank Authority of Charlottesville (LBAC) Implementation & Required Actions: Key Next Steps per Virginia Code 1. Public Hearing and Ordinance Adoption • As required by Virginia § 15.2-7502, a Public Hearing must be held, with formal notice published at least twice before adoption. 2. Board of Directors Appointment and Incorporation • Per Virginia Code § 15.2-7503, City Council must appoint at least five (5) Board Members, including specific representatives (e.g., housing/community development experts). • Board must be named in the ordinance & registered in incorporation documents. 3. Finalizing Governance and Policies • Develop and adopt bylaws, acquisition/disposition policies, and financial guidelines. • Determine priority properties for acquisition. 4 Page 52 of 147 4. Funding and Operational Planning • Align LBAC operations with City Budgeting Cycles (FY 2027). • Explore state/federal grants and intergovernmental agreements for financial sustainability. 5. Tentative Workplan for LBAC FY26-27 5 Timeline Key Action Milestone Q1 (Jul - Sep 2025) Present draft Ordinance to City Council, initiate Public Hearing process, and engage stakeholders. Council review & public hearing scheduled. Q2 (Oct - Dec 2025) Finalize Ordinance, appoint Board members, and draft operational framework. LBAC formally established. Q3 (Jan - Mar 2026) Initiate property acquisition strategy. Identify funding sources. Establish governance procedures. Operational plan and funding secured. Q4 (July 2026) LBAC fully operational Land Bank Authority of Charlottesville (LBAC) Page 53 of 147 Questions and Comments: Key Discussion Points for Council • Are there any concerns or refinements City Council would like addressed before the Public Hearing? • What additional information is needed to support the Ordinance adoption process? • How can LBAC’s strategic priorities best align with City Council’s broader housing and economic goals? 6 Land Bank Authority of Charlottesville (LBAC) Page 54 of 147 7 Questions or Ideas? Page 55 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: None (Informational only Presentation). Presenter: Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager, Alan Peura Staff Contacts: James Freas, Deputy City Manager Alexander Ikefuna, Director, Office of Community Solutions Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Madelyn Metzler, Housing Compliance Coordinator Alan Peura Title: Introducing the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program ("CAHTAP"): a new tax abatement strategy for housing affordability Background Enabling legislation: Virginia Code § 15.2-4905; This Virginia Code Section outlines the powers of Industrial Development Authorities (e.g., Charlottesville Economic Development Authority (“CEDA”)), including the ability to provide performance grants or other financial assistance to incentivize affordable housing. The Charlottesville Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program (“CAHTAP”) is a draft policy tool under development by the Office of Community Solutions to promote housing affordability, as a follow-up to the City’s newly adopted 2023 Development Code. CAHTAP could help continue the City’s broader strategy to ensure that affordability, displacement prevention, and housing access are not just aspirational goals, but measurable outcomes embedded in local development practice. Other jurisdictions in Virginia have created similar affordable housing tax incentive programs, including the City of Richmond and Albemarle County. The County created the Affordable Rental Housing Incentive Program (“ARHIP”), which provides a fifteen percent (15%) tax abatement for up to thirty (30) years for both new construction and preservation projects that provide at least twenty percent (20%) Affordable Dwelling Units (ADUs) as part of the housing project. Since Virginia law does not allow local governments to directly abate real estate taxes owed for affordable housing, these programs create a tax abatement calculation at the front end of the program, with a performance grant distribution at the back end. In other words, the tax incentive is calculated through a real estate tax abatement on the new increment value of the new development, and the abated tax amount is then reimbursed after it has been paid through a performance grant process. CAHTAP reflects commitments made across several planning processes and community engagement efforts—and is part of a longer arc of public policy work (e.g., Affordable Housing Plan 2021) rooted in past local housing ecosystems and economic downturns and planning propelled Page 56 of 147 forward by present-day pressures. Specifically, CAHTAP responds to the structural and financial tension created by the City’s new ADU requirement, which mandates that ten percent (10%) of units in qualifying residential developments meet affordability standards. According to some claims and implications for particular sub-markets/areas of the City, this requirement is being deeply reviewed for any measurable financial constraints to developers, particularly in the rental market, where the gap between market rents and capped affordable rents impacts operational revenue and project feasibility. In this context, CAHTAP emerges as a de-risking mechanism—providing a pathway to reconcile public affordability goals with the economics of housing delivery. It does so using only new revenue from the incremental value of new development, revenue that would not exist but for the building of new housing. The base tax revenue is not touched, so this protects existing fiscal resources while aligning future revenues for investment into our affordability commitments. Discussion A. Overview:Tax abatement is being evaluated as a potential tool to reduce the cost burden associated with the City’s new ADU requirement. For rental housing developers in particular, the mandate to provide ten percent (10%) of units at reduced, income-qualified rents for 99-years results in a measurable loss in operating revenue over time. Without an offset mechanism, this requirement could reduce the internal rate of return on projects and act as a barrier to new housing production. CAHTAP is designed to address this financial constraint through a real estate tax abatement reimbursement model—offering a fiscal incentive on the future incremental value of newly developed affordable housing projects. Developers would: 1. Pay full real estate taxes on the post-development assessed value, and 2. Receive a reimbursement based upon a pre-calculated percentage of the taxes on the newly built incremental value—i.e., the increase in assessed value created by new construction or redevelopment. This model preserves the base tax revenue, which continues flowing to support core City functions, such as education, safety, and infrastructure. It also ensures that public funds are disbursed only after affordability commitments have been met and new ADUs are built, making it a performance- based, fiscally prudent tool. B. Legal Mechanism: Virginia localities are prohibited from directly abating taxes for private entities, except under specific exemptions and affordable housing is not one of those. However, local governments may issue performance-based grants to qualifying projects through one of the following pathways: 1. CEDA: Authorized under Virginia Code § 15.2-4905 (Industrial Development and Revenue Bond Act), CEDA can administer financial incentives—including grants tied to affordable Page 57 of 147 housing development—as done in similar programs (e.g., Richmond, Albemarle ARHIP). This would be the most expedient and legally tested model. 2. Land Bank Authority of Charlottesville (“LBAC”): Authorized under Virginia Code § 15.2- 7500 et seq., LBAC may also provide subsidies or financing to support affordable housing objectives. While not yet tested for performance-based grant models, LBAC aligns closely with equity goals and place-based affordability strategies. If CAHTAP were to be linked to land disposition or anti-displacement interventions, LBAC may serve as a longer-term or targeted administrator. C. Prospective Workplan Activities: (No Timelines Established at This Time) The successful development and launch of CAHTAP will require a phased, multi-track work plan involving: 1. Completion of Market Needs and Fiscal Gap Analysis: A comprehensive analysis is required to accurately quantify the financial impact of the ten percent (10%) ADU requirement and to establish the “cost of affordability” across a range of development scenarios and sub-markets. This activity is already anticipated and budgeted in alignment with the City’s Affordable Housing Plan. 2. Stakeholder Consultation: Robust engagement will be conducted with local and regional stakeholders, including developers, affordable housing advocates, lenders, equity-focused organizations, real estate professionals, and community partners. Their insight will help shape the program’s structure, ensure practical feasibility, and guide adoption strategies. 3. Program Design Framework: City Staff will develop a flexible, tiered reimbursement calculation model that accounts for key policy variables such as Area Median Income (“AMI”) served, percentage of ADUs provided, project location, and the depth and duration of affordability commitments. 4. Administrative Structure Development: To support consistent implementation and long-term program integrity, City Staff will develop internal administrative protocols, including eligibility criteria, application procedures, compliance monitoring, performance verification, reimbursement processing, and reporting requirements. 5. Legal Review and Ordinance Drafting: The CAO will be involved ensuring the Program's design aligns with state legal authority and local administrative constraints. Upon confirmation of the legal framework, draft Resolutions or Ordinances will be prepared and brought forward for City Council consideration. D. Key Policy Levers: The following policy levers represent the core design considerations currently under evaluation by City Staff. While these are not being presented for decision at this time, City Staff believe it is Page 58 of 147 important to share them early in the process to ensure transparency and invite any preliminary input. Upcoming market analysis, stakeholder engagement, and internal modeling will inform a final City Staff recommendation to City Council. Sharing this framework now allows City Council to anticipate the areas of policy discretion that will ultimately define the program. 1. Administrative Body -Should the program be housed within CEDA, the LBAC, or in a hybrid/shared model? 2. Program Intention: a. Should CAHTAP offset the cost of the ADU requirement? Or. b. Should CAHTAP provide broader incentives above the cost of the ADU requirement to stimulate additional affordable housing production? 3. Abatement Thresholds: a. What is the maximum percentage of new incremental tax revenue to reimburse (e.g., 15%, 50%, 75%, or 100%)? 4. Qualifying Criteria Enhancements (“Elegance Variables”): a. Require a higher percentage of ADUs than the minimum ten percent (10%) to be eligible? b. Require deeper affordability than the required sixty percent (60%) AMI (e.g., units at thirty (30%) – fifty (50%) AMI) to be eligible? c. Require a minimum project size (# of units built) to be eligible? d. Adjust abatement by project geographic location based on market pressures? e. How many years should the abatement take (e.g., fifteen (15) years, thirty (30) years, etc.)? 4. Abatement Bonus Options: Once the above eligibility criteria are set, should CAHTAP offer bonuses: a. Provide additional abatement for each additional ten percent (10%) ADUs? or b. Provide additional abatement for deeper affordability ADUs? Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan • 2023 Strategic Framework: Supports equitable growth, partnerships, housing affordability, some climate actions, and sustainability—goals that a land bank can help achieve by re-purposing underutilized land for affordable housing. • Comprehensive Plan (2021): This plan focuses on inclusive neighborhoods and sustainable development. A land bank can facilitate affordable housing and neighborhood revitalization in alignment with goals. • Affordable Housing Plan (2021) • Climate Action Plan 2023-2027 (where or when applicable). • Consolidated Plan (where or when applicable). Community Engagement Page 59 of 147 Community engagement is both a foundational and forward-facing component of CAHTAP’s development. The policy concept itself emerged in part through community feedback and dialogue during the zoning reform process, where the affordability requirements—and their potential consequences—were discussed publicly and critically. Tax abatement as a tool was raised during those deliberations as a possible solution to mitigate development costs and preserve affordable housing opportunities. Building on that initial community signal, City Staff will design a layered engagement strategy to inform the final structure of CAHTAP. This approach will prioritize inclusion, transparency, and technical input from stakeholders most directly affected by the Program’s goals and implementation. Engagement efforts will include: 1. Listening Sessions with community-based organizations and tenant advocates to ground the program in local housing needs and displacement realities. 2. Technical Workshops with developers, equity-focused housing practitioners, lenders, and real estate professionals to test feasibility, address financing mechanics, and refine eligibility thresholds. 3. Public Comment Opportunities aligned with the release of the Market Needs and Fiscal Gap Analysis, ensuring that community members have access to key findings and a voice in interpreting the data. 4. Alignment with Standing Committees or Advisory Groups, where applicable, to ensure continuity with prior housing plans and initiatives. This engagement process recognizes that, while the CAHTAP mechanism is technical in nature, its success relies on public trust, community relevance, and practical usability. Therefore, stakeholders will be invited to help shape not only the policy levers, but also the program's “user experience”— from eligibility to compliance and impact measurement. Budgetary Impact There is no budgetary impact currently. This Presentation is for informational purposes only, and no Program costs or financial commitments are being proposed. Future iterations of CAHTAP may require fiscal modeling and appropriation decisions, pending the results of the ongoing market analysis and policy framework guidance from City Council. City Staff will return later with estimates on potential revenue impacts and administrative costs, if and when program implementation is considered. As City Council considers the financial sustainability of the current affordable housing grant investments, which appropriates funds from existing base revenue, the CAHTAP abatement and post-completion reimbursement model that appropriates future, unrealized revenue that is only realized when the new development occurs, may be a critical opportunity to sustain this funding commitment into the future within the context of other City Budget needs and priorities. Recommendation While no formal action is currently requested, City Staff welcomes City Council’s feedback on the proposed CAHTAP model's concept, structure, and direction. The insights shared today—particularly in response to the policy framework and legal pathways outlined—will help inform future City Staff work and interdepartmental coordination. Page 60 of 147 Should City Council express interest in further development, City Staff stands ready to: • Finalize the market analysis currently underway—award notices sent to research firms. • Return with a refined program framework and fiscal model, and • Present legal and administrative recommendations for potential adoption in FY26. City Staff also notes that further exploration of the appropriate administrative body (CEDA vs. LBAC) and potential integration with existing affordability tools may benefit from City Council guidance as the conversation continues. Alternatives As an informational Presentation-only item, no alternatives are presented for City Council decision. However, a range of future options may be considered based on City Council discussion or direction, including: • Proceeding with detailed Program design and administrative structure development • Pausing work pending completion of the market and fiscal analysis • Pursuing parallel or complementary affordability incentives through other funding mechanisms • Further evaluating legal and structural fit between potential administrators (e.g., CEDA, LBAC) Attachments 1. Attachment A - PowerPoint Presentation Charlottesville Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program (CAHTAP) Page 61 of 147 Charlottesville Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program (CAHTAP) Presented: April 21, 2025, 4 PM City Council Opening Session By the City’s Office of Community Solutions Page 62 of 147 Charlottesville Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program (CAHTAP) A proposed financial tool to offset the developers’ cost of providing Affordable Dwelling Units (“ADU”) in compliance with the City’s 2023 Development Code. Core Components: • Mechanism: Performance-based reimbursement of a portion of real estate taxes on the incremental assessed value of qualifying projects • Purpose: Improve financial feasibility of ADU production while preserving base tax revenue • Trigger: 10% ADU requirement (e.g., the ADU Program of New Development Code) creates a revenue gap that may deter or delay rental housing production Legal Basis: Authorized under Virginia Code § 15.2-4905 (Industrial Development and Revenue Bond Act) Potential Administrators : CEDA (a similar model or use in practice facilitated through the Office of Economic Development) or LBAC (an aligned alternative, if adopted). 2 Page 63 of 147 Charlottesville Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program (CAHTAP) Why Now? • New Development Code = New Developer Burden • 10% ADU requirement creates a long-term revenue gap • Particularly acute for rental housing developers • Affordability Pressures Rising • Property values, construction costs, and interest rates continue to increase the cost of building housing • Without incentives, development could stall or shift to higher-end markets • Strategic Fit • CAHTAP supports long-term affordability goals • Aligns with the 2021 Affordable Housing Plan and 2023 Strategic Plan • Uses future revenues – not existing General Fund allocations • May be a more sustainable option than grant from current revenues to continue funding affordable housing • Spends City funds AFTER projects are built and delivered – at the END of the pipeline 3 Page 64 of 147 Charlottesville Affordable Housing Tax Abatement Program (CAHTAP) Program Development Policy Options • Should CAHTAP merely offset the ADU cost mandate or be more generous to jump-start projects? • What is the maximum percentage of new incremental tax revenue to reimburse via abatement? • Should the program be housed and managed by: • CEDD; or • LBAC • Should eligibility for the abatement start at: • Just meeting the 10% ADU requirement, or something more than that? (15% or 20%?) • Just meeting the 60% AMI requirement, or something deeper than that? (50% or 40%?) • How many years should the abatement last? (15 years or 30 years?) • Should abatements be granted anywhere or be targeted to the high market rate rent areas only? • Perhaps abatements are lower in high market rate rent areas where these rents may subsidize/offset the ADUs’ cost • Should the program provide abatement bonus opportunities?: • Provide additional abatement for each additional 10% ADUs • Provide additional abatement for deeper affordability ADUs 4 Page 65 of 147 5 Questions or Ideas? Page 66 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE Proclamation International Dark Sky Week in Charlottesville April 21-28, 2025 WHEREAS the aesthetic beauty and wonder of a natural night sky is a shared heritage of all humankind, and the experience of standing beneath a starry night sky inspires feelings of wonder and awe, and many people in Charlottesville live under a dome of light pollution— excessive artificial lighting at night that disrupts natural darkness—and may never experience the visual wonder or ecological and health benefits of living under a dark sky; and WHEREAS light pollution has scientifically-established economic and environmental consequences, which result in significant impacts to the ecology and human health of all communities; WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville is in close proximity to the Shenandoah National Park and is surrounded by rural Albemarle County and these natural landscapes are home to many species which rely on undisturbed night environments to hunt, mate, and thrive; and WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville is a neighbor to McCormick Observatory and Fan Mountain Observatory - both observatories operated by the Astronomy Department of the University of Virginia, and the observations and research carried out at these observatories is hampered by the effects of light pollution; and WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville is within a reasonable distance from the James River State Park which is one of four Virginia State Parks designated as an International Dark Sky Park by the International Dark Sky Association; and WHEREAS peak spring bird migration falls during Dark Sky Week and 80% of migrating birds fly at night and need starlight to navigate; NOW, THEREFORE, the Charlottesville City Council, proclaims the week of April 21-28, 2025, as Dark Sky Week in the city of Charlottesville, and we ask residents to observe and ponder upon this important week and to join in raising awareness and support for protecting our dark sky resources on this week and throughout the year. Signed and sealed this 21st day of April 2025. ___________________________ Juandiego Wade, Mayor Attest: ___________________________ Kyna Thomas, Clerk Page 67 of 147 City Council Meeting Minutes – April 7, 2025 CHARLOTTESVILLE CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES April 7, 2025 at 4:00 PM Council Chamber The Charlottesville City Council held a regular meeting on Monday, April 7, 2025. Mayor Juandiego Wade called the meeting to order, and Clerk of Council Kyna Thomas called the roll, noting the following councilors present: Mayor Juandiego Wade, Vice Mayor Brian Pinkston, and Councilors Natalie Oschrin and Lloyd Snook. Councilor Payne arrived at 4:03 p.m. during the Interim City Attorney’s statement. Pamela O’Berry, Interim City Attorney, made a statement regarding the republishing of the public notice for the Real Property Tax Rate. On motion by Pinkston, seconded by Payne, Council unanimously adopted the meeting agenda with amendments as recommended by the Acting City Attorney, removing items related to the tax rate or tax levies. REPORTS 1. PRESENTATION of Draft ADA Transition Plan Update City Manager Samuel Sanders, Jr., made a statement about the City’s approach to complying with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), and the continual nature of work in progress to improve accessibility throughout the city. Ashley Marshall, Deputy City Manager, introduced the city’s ADA Team, and provided a summary of the approach to developing the ADA Transition Plan. Paul Rudacille, ADA Coordinator, provided general information about the goals and benefits of Americans with Disabilities Act. Charles Siebold, Precision Infrastructure Management, presented the overall findings of the ADA Study for the City of Charlottesville, and made recommendations specifically in areas of: City rights-of-way, facilities, parks, digital, and programmatic access for specified departments. Councilors asked clarifying questions, Mr. Sanders stated his expectation of a work plan to be presented to City Council on an annual basis. CLOSED MEETING On motion by Pinkston, seconded by Snook, Council voted 5-0 (Ayes: Oschrin, Payne, Pinkston, Snook, Wade; Noes: none) to meet in closed session as authorized by Section 2.2-3712 of the Virginia Code, specifically Section 2.2-3711(A)(3) for discussion or consideration of the acquisition of real property for a public purpose where discussion in an open meeting would adversely affect the bargaining position or negotiating strategy of the public body. On motion by Pinkston, seconded by Snook, Council certified by a vote of 4-0 (Ayes: Oschrin, Pinkston, Snook, Wade; Noes: none; Absent: Payne), that to the best of each Council member’s knowledge only public business matters lawfully exempted from the open meeting requirements of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act and identified in the Motion convening the closed session were heard, discussed or considered in the closed session. Page 68 of 147 City Council Meeting Minutes – April 7, 2025 BUSINESS SESSION Pamela O’Berry, Interim City Attorney, made a statement regarding the republishing of the public notice for the Real Property Tax Rate. Councilor Payne re-joined the meeting. City Council began the business meeting by observing a moment of silence. ANNOUNCEMENTS Councilor Payne announced a Black History Pathway community celebration honoring Central Virginia area musicians on April 19 at Carver Recreation Center. Councilor Oschrin announced the April 13 monthly Bike-Pedestrian Committee walk at UVA Grounds and surrounding neighborhoods. COMMUNITY MATTERS Mayor Wade opened the floor for comments from the public. 1. Thomas Vandever, Chairperson of the Independence Resource Center, spoke about the need for accessibility improvements at the Dogwood Vietnam Memorial. 2. Jackie Temkin, city resident, expressed appreciation for the recent amendments to the Parks and Recreation Master Plan to bring more gender-equitable access to play services and partnerships. She spoke about obstacles that some groups face when trying to book and access City parks and recreation facilities. 3. Marnie Allen, city resident, read a letter on behalf of the board of Reclaimed Hope Initiative to request support for an upcoming grant application. 4. Mario, a public housing resident, spoke about a sensitive personal living situation. 5. Jim Moore, city resident, spoke about the real estate tax rate adoption process. He requested consistency in language between the legal notice and various forms of communication. 6. Richard Vaughter spoke about safety issues at Kindlewood apartments. CONSENT AGENDA Clerk Thomas read the following Consent Agenda items into the record, and on motion by Pinkston, seconded by Snook, Council unanimously adopted the Consent Agenda (Ayes: Oschrin, Payne, Pinkston, Snook, Wade; Noes: none). 2.MINUTES: March 13 budget work session; March 17 regular meeting; March 20 annual City budget public hearing; March 27 budget work session 3.RESOLUTION for allocation of $788,000 of FY25 Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund Grant funding (2nd reading) RESOLUTION ALLOCATION OF CHARLOTTESVILLE AFFORDABLE HOUSING FUND (CAHF) FY25 FOR AFFORDABLE HOUSING PROJECTS AND INITIATIVES IN THE AMOUNT OF $788,000 Page 69 of 147 City Council Meeting Minutes – April 7, 2025 WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, having established the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (CAHF) Grant Program to provide financial support for community agency programs aiding in affordable housing and homelessness relief, hereby allocates $788,000 from the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (CAHF) Grant Program under Fund 426 Project: CP-084, as per the Capital Improvement Program budget for FY2025. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED The City Council, having received and reviewed recommendations from the CAHF Committee on the expenditure of CAHF funds for the CAHF Grant Program, resolves to allocate the amount to the following CAHF applicants: Fund Project GL Account Applicant Funded Project/Initiative CAHF Award 426 CP-084 530670 Albemarle Housing Improvement Program Charlottesville Critical Rehabilitation Program $240,000 426 CP-084 530670 Community Services Housing, Inc. (CSH) Rehabilitation Repairs to Preserve CSH Properties $88,000 426 CP-084 530670 Habitat for Humanity of Greater Charlottesville Habitat Core 2025 $160,000 426 CP-084 530670 Piedmont Housing Alliance 905 Rives St. $200,000 426 CP-084 530670 Piedmont Housing Alliance 11th St. NW $100,000 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that all funding awards within this resolution shall be provided as grants to the entities listed under the “Applicant” column above to be used solely for the purposes outlined in their respective grant applications and any subsequent grant agreement. The City Manager is authorized to negotiate and execute funding grant agreements with each recipient to ensure proper utilization of funds. 4.RESOLUTION considering 1114 E High Street Special Exception Permit for Build-To Requirements RESOLUTION APPROVING A SPECIAL EXCEPTION PERMIT FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1114 E HIGH STREET WHEREAS, LUCKYBALL’S JUGGLER TRAINING CAMP LLC (“Landowner”) is the current owner of a lot identified on 2025 City Tax Map 28 as Parcel 112 (City Parcel Identification No. 540021000), having an area of approximately 0.43 acres (18731 square feet) ("Subject Property"); and WHEREAS, the landowner proposes to modify the Build-To requirements on the Subject Property to build a studio workshop space behind the existing structure on site ("Project"); and WHEREAS, the Project is described in more detail within the Applicant's application materials submitted in connection with Application PL-25-0038, as required by City Development Code Section 34-5.2.15.B.2 (collectively, the "Application Materials"); and WHEREAS, the Planning Commission (“PC”) made a recommendation of approval at their February 25, 2025, Public Meeting, per City Development Code Section 34-5.2.15.C.2; and WHEREAS, upon consideration of the PC's recommendation and the Staff Reports discussing this application, as well as the factors set forth within City Development Code Section 34-5.2.15.D, this Page 70 of 147 City Council Meeting Minutes – April 7, 2025 Council finds and determines that granting the proposed Special Exception Permit would serve the public necessity, convenience, general welfare or good zoning practice; now, therefore, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia that, pursuant to City Code Development Sections 34-2.4.4.B.5 and 34-5.2.15, a Special Exception Permit is hereby approved and granted to authorize the Project and require a new building to be built outside of the build-to zone required on the primary street lot line in the CX-5 zoning district. 5.RESOLUTION considering a Special Exception Permit request for 1418 Emmet Street RESOLUTION APPROVING A REQUEST FOR A SPECIAL EXCEPTION PERMIT (“SEP”) FOR PROPERTY LOCATED AT 1418 EMMET STREET N WHEREAS, Scott Smith (“Landowner”) is the current owner of a lot identified on 2025 City Tax Map 40 as Parcel 4D00 (City Parcel Identification No. 400004D00), having an area of approximately 1.00 acres (43,700 square feet); (“Subject Property”); and WHEREAS, the Landowner wishes to install an accessory shed on the Subject Property (“Project”); and WHEREAS, the Project is described in more detail within the Landowner’s application materials submitted in connection with Application PL-25-0004 (“Application”), as required by City Development Code § 34-5.2.15.B.2 (collectively, "Application Materials"); and WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville Planning Commission (“PC”) made a recommendation of approval at its March 11, 2025, Public Meeting, per City Development Code § 34-5.2.15.C.2. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED, by the City Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia (“City Council”), upon consideration of the PC's recommendation and the City Staff Report discussing the Application, as well as the factors set forth within City Development Code § 34-5.2.15.D, that it finds and determines that granting the proposed SEP would serve the public necessity, convenience, general welfare, or good zoning practice; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, by City Council, pursuant to City Development Code Section §§ 34-5.2.15, a SEP is hereby approved and granted to authorize the Project and permit installation of an accessory shed consistent with the Application Materials for the Subject Property. 6.RESOLUTION to Appropriate Funds from the Virginia Department of Transportation ("VDOT") for the Monticello 2nd Project - $1,304,308 (layover) CITY MANAGER REPORT Eden Ratliff, Deputy City Manager, provided an update on work done over the last two years by city staff regarding the City’s Strategic Plan, and work that continues to be done. He and City Manager Sanders mentioned holding a City Council retreat over the summer to develop a “bridge” plan for the next five years. Mr. Sanders invited the public to attend an Open House on Wednesday, April 9 at 5:30 p.m. in the Jackson Via Elementary School gymnasium to discuss ways to make 5th Street SW a safer corridor for all travel modes. He announced that the Charlottesville City Market kicked off its 52nd season on April 5th, and that residents with SNAP benefits should check in with the market management tent to use their Page 71 of 147 City Council Meeting Minutes – April 7, 2025 benefits to access services that are available to them. Mr. Sanders announced the recognition of National Crime Victims Rights Week from April 6-12. ACTION ITEMS 7. PUBLIC HEARING and ORDINANCE: FY2026 Budget Public Hearing #2; Ordinance, Annual Appropriation Krisy Hammill, Budget Director, introduced the item for its second public hearing. After Council asked clarifying questions, Mayor Wade opened the public hearing. •James Moore, city resident, spoke about the effective tax rate increase advertised, and the impact of increased property assessments. Mayor Wade closed the public hearing. a. Ordinance Adopting a Budget and Annual Appropriation of Funding for the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, for the Fiscal Year ending June 30, 2026 (layover) Following discussion, Council unanimously agreed to lay consideration of this ordinance over to the April 14 special meeting for a second reading and vote, with the understanding that the April 10 budget work session will inform the final ordinance. 8. RESOLUTION: City of Charlottesville Parks & Recreation Comprehensive Master Plan Adoption Resolution (2nd reading) Riaan Anthony, Director of Parks and Recreation, provided a summary of the development process for the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. He reviewed amendments to the Plan incorporating input from the March 17, 2025, City Council meeting. On motion by Pinkston, seconded by Payne, Council by a vote of 5-0 approved the following resolution (Ayes: Oschrin, Payne, Pinkston, Snook, Wade; Noes: none). RESOLUTION TO AMEND THE NOVEMBER 15, 2021, CITY COMPREHENSIVE PLAN, AS AMENDED, TO ADD THE PARKS AND RECREATION MASTER PLAN WHEREAS, on Tuesday, March 11, 2025, the City of Charlottesville Planning Commission (“PC”) held a Public Hearing on a proposed amendment of the Comprehensive Plan for the City of Charlottesville, dated November 15, 2021, as amended to date (“Comprehensive Plan”), after notice of intention to do so was published in accordance with the requirements of §15.2-2204(A), Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended; and WHEREAS, after the Public Hearing on March 11, 2025, the PC recommended approval of the proposed Comprehensive Plan Amendment and directed that said Comprehensive Plan be transmitted to the City Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia (“City Council”), for consideration (“Certified Plan”); and WHEREAS, on Tuesday, March 17, 2025, City Council held a Public Hearing on the proposed Certified Plan after notice of intention to do so was published in accordance with the requirements of §15.2-2204(A), Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended; and WHEREAS, as required by § 15.2-2225, Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, a link to the Certified Plan was posted on the City’s website, the place where such information is posted, and the Certified Page 72 of 147 City Council Meeting Minutes – April 7, 2025 Plan has been available to the public; and WHEREAS, City Council desires that the proposed Amendments be made to the Certified Plan, to- wit: the addition of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that City Council finds and determines that, with the amendments adding the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, desired by City Council as described above, the Certified Plan has been made with the purpose of guiding and accomplishing a coordinated, adjusted, and harmonious development of the territory within the City, which will, in accordance with present and future probable future needs and resources, best promote the health, safety, morals, order, convenience, prosperity, and general welfare of the City’s inhabitants; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, by City Council that the aforesaid Certified Plan is hereby adopted, re-enacted and re-ordained as the official City Comprehensive Plan pursuant to §15.2-2226, Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, and shall hereafter continue to be known and referred to as the City’s “Comprehensive Plan (2021).” 9. WRITTEN REPORT: FY26 Operations Plan for Charlottesville Albemarle Convention & Visitors Bureau City Council acknowledged receipt of the written report from the Charlottesville Albemarle Convention & Visitors Bureau. Councilor Payne highlighted city and county investments. COMMUNITY MATTERS (2) Mayor Wade opened the floor for comments from the public. No speakers came forward. ADJOURNMENT On motion by Snook, seconded by Oschrin, Council voted 5-0 to adjourn the meeting at 7:44 p.m. BY Order of City Council BY Kyna Thomas, Clerk of Council Page 73 of 147 City Council Meeting Minutes – April 14, 2025 CHARLOTTESVILLE CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES April 14, 2025 at 6:30 PM Council Chamber The Charlottesville City Council held a special meeting on Monday, April 14, 2025. Mayor Juandiego Wade called the meeting to order, and Clerk of Council Kyna Thomas called the roll, noting all councilors present: Mayor Juandiego Wade, Vice Mayor Brian Pinkston, and Councilors Natalie Oschrin, Michael Payne and Lloyd Snook. On motion by Pinkston, seconded by Payne, Council unanimously adopted the meeting agenda. ACTION ITEMS 1. Ordinance Adopting a Budget and Appropriating Funds for the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, for the Fiscal Year ending June 30, 2026 (Second Reading) City Manager Samuel Sanders, Jr., summarized the budget reconciliation process since the initial proposal presented on March 6, and he reiterated specific budget facts. Revenues and corresponding expenditures for the Fiscal Year 2026 (FY26) City Budget totaled $265,248,446, representing revenue growth of $13,299,816. Growth in the Budget showed a 5.28% increase over the prior year. Tax rates remained the same in FY26: •Lodging Tax Rate: 9.0% •Meals Tax Rate: 7.0% •Personal Property Tax Rate: $4.40/$100 •Real Estate Tax Rate: $0.98/$100 Major budget drivers were: 1) Charlottesville City Schools, 2) affordable housing, 3) transportation, and 4) the City of Charlottesville strategic priority area of Organizational Excellence. Councilors asked clarifying questions about intended uses and timing for the use of surplus funds, proper usage of surplus for one-time expenses, and transportation budgeting priorities. Mr. Sanders stated that he plans to bring a proposal regarding the use of surplus funds to City Council within the next couple of regular City Council meetings. He emphasized discussion points made by Vice Mayor Pinkston regarding transit as a city priority. Khristina Hammill, Director of Budget, reviewed a list of budget amendments that were finalized during the April 10, 2025, City Council budget work session. On motion by Pinkston, seconded by Oschrin, Council voted 5-0 to adopt the ORDINANCE APPROVING A BUDGET AND ANNUAL APPROPRIATION OF FUNDING FOR THE CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE FOR THE FISCAL YEAR ENDING JUNE 30, 2026 (Ayes: Oschrin, Payne, Pinkston, Snook, Wade; Noes: none). On motion by Snook, seconded by Pinkston, Council by unanimous consent adjourned the meeting at 6:55 p.m. BY Order of City Council BY Kyna Thomas, Clerk of Council Page 74 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: Approval of Resolution to Appropriate the Funds Presenter: Chris Colin Staff Contacts: Steven Hicks, Director of Public Works Krisy Hammill, Director of Budget Title: Resolution to Appropriate $1,304,308 from the Virginia Department of Transportation ("VDOT") for the Monticello 2nd Project (2nd reading) Background VDOT has secured additional funds for the Monticello 2nd Transportation Project, UPC: 113917. These funds need to be appropriated by City Council. Discussion With the continued rise in construction costs, the City's VDOT representative sought and secured additional funds for the Monticello 2nd Project ("Project"), UPC 113917. Appendix "A" Revision one (1) shows a Project Budget of $485,177 in 2020. With the additional VDOT funding , which has been approved and signed off on by VDOT, the allocation for the Monticello 2nd Project is now $1,304,308, shown on Appendix "A" Revision two (2). Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan This Agenda item aligns with City Council's Strategic Outcome areas of Partnerships and Organizational Excellence. Community Engagement N/A Budgetary Impact $485,177 was previously awarded and appropriated by the City for this Project. The Project Budget has been revised to $1,304,308. An increase of $819,131 will be received from VDOT to complete the Project. There is no local match requirement for this Project. Recommendation City Staff recommends City Council adopt the attached Resolution approving the appropriation. Alternatives Page 75 of 147 N/A Attachments 1. CharlottesvilleCity-UPC113917-AppA-Rev2 countersigned 2. VDOT - Monticello and @nd Page 76 of 147 Date:2/21/2025UPC: CFDA # 20.205 Locality: From: To: $1,304,308Program and Project Specific Funding RequirementsTotal PE$1,172,808$1,500$130,000 Appendix A Revision 2$53,500Project Estimates$1,130,808 $1,250,808Project Cost and Reimbursement$0$1,500$120,000Project Narrative$0$130,000(Choose from drop down box)to Locality $42,000$1,172,808$1,500$10,000$130,000 $1,304,3080%0%$1,500$130,000$1,172,8080% $0$120,000$0$130,000$0$0$1,500$0Total RW$1,500Aggregate AllocationsEstimated Total Reimbursement by VDOT to Locality (Less Local Share and VDOT Expenses)$1,172,808$1,250,808Total Estimated CostTotal Maximum Reimbursement by VDOT to Locality (Less Local Share)$0$0Project Financing$1,304,308 $1,250,808$1,130,808Total CN$1,172,808$1,304,308 $1,304,308$1,304,308$1,304,30803/04/2025 Page 77 of 147 RESOLUTION APPROPRIATING FUNDS Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) funds for Monticello 2nd Project WHEREAS, the Virginia Department of Transportation has awarded funds to the City of Charlottesville for the Monticello 2nd project (UPC # U000-104-343); NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia that a total of $1,304,308 be appropriated in the following manner: Revenues 1,304,308 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01122 G/L Account: 430120 Expenses $1,304,308 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01122 G/L Account: 599999 Page 78 of 147 City Manager’s Report City Departments 4-21-2025 Page 79 of 147 City Manager – Sam Sanders (he/him) • Recognition of Five Year Anniversaries o In the prior report, I acknowledged career employees who have spent 10- 40 years with the City of Charlottesville. It is amazing that people work in one place for that long. But public service has changed as has other fields of work and it is important to acknowledge those who reach the five-year milestone just the same. On April 9th, I recognized 52 employees who were congratulated on their 5 Year anniversary with the City. Please join me in congratulating them for their dedication to serve our community. ▪ Kurt Adcock ▪ Derek Duncan ▪ Kerri Musico ▪ Jazmine Curry ▪ Mario Moyer ▪ Kyle Ervin ▪ John Thompson ▪ Roxanne Jones ▪ Shadee Gilliam ▪ Ramanda Jackson ▪ Lauren Capasso ▪ Mark Cole ▪ Alana Fuller ▪ Matthew Hildebrand ▪ Ryan Kuhns ▪ Colton Mays ▪ Colton Duprey ▪ Mark Eppard ▪ Kristy Hoover ▪ James Harris ▪ William Eppard ▪ Deanna Guedj ▪ Brady Winter ▪ Kyna Thomas ▪ Maxicelia Robinson ▪ Patrick Cory ▪ Stacey Washington ▪ Grant Armstrong ▪ Leonard Grooms ▪ Russell Jones ▪ Tiffany Miller ▪ Jack Samar ▪ Jamell Houchens Page 80 of 147 ▪ Decon Turner ▪ Devin Miller ▪ Christopher Vlasis ▪ Leo Kudej ▪ Maria Stella ▪ Roger Shepherd ▪ Thomas Terry ▪ Erin Britt ▪ Zenovia Jackson ▪ Robert Roach ▪ Sharane Leabough ▪ April Wilson ▪ Baccho Umbertis ▪ Lori Lam ▪ Richard Hunt ▪ Bryan Frazier ▪ Benjamin Maneno ▪ Garland Williams ▪ John Scott • Signed the annual request for federal funding to continue the City's entitlements from HUD to fund Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME projects. Deputy City Manager for Social Equity – Ashley Reynolds Marshall (she/her) • On March 21, the Deputy City Manager (DCM) for Social Equity spoke on a panel at the Virginia Women's Municipal Leadership Institute's Reunion event, which focused on the topic of Human Resources. • As a follow-up to the DCM's presentation on the City's Opioid Abatement efforts earlier this year, I am proud to announce that the City of Charlottesville's applications for funding from the Virginia Opioid Abatement Authority to support work with the Albemarle-Charlottesville Regional Jail's efforts to pilot providing critical medications to justice-involved persons for opioid use disorder, the Charlottesville-UVA-Albemarle Emergency Communication Center to pilot the inclusion of a behavioral health specialist in the communications center dispatch, and the City's efforts to ensure that life-saving naloxone is available in its facilities and with its frontline team members were all approved. Applications for FY2026 funds have also been submitted and are awaiting OAA decisions. Deputy City Manager for Operations – James Freas (he/him) • On March 25, DCM Freas attended the Public Works / Utilities Snow Appreciation lunch to thank all the employees who assisted with the snow Page 81 of 147 clearing efforts this winter. Planning for next winter’s snow removal is already underway! The departments involved are collaborating to ensure that the procedures are as efficient as possible. Parks & Recreation – Director Riaan Anthony (he/him) • Master Plan o An adopted Master Plan is available online at: Charlottesville Parks and Recreation Master Plan | EngagePros. • Meadowcreek Golf Course o Interior renovations at the clubhouse are currently underway. They include new carpet, paint, light fixtures, bathrooms, and furniture. Project is expected to be complete by May. o Food and Beverage services are open to the public Thursday – Sunday: Meadowcreek Cafe online menu (link). o The new Cavalier Pass is now available. This is a monthly subscription pass that provides discounts for greens and cart fees. Learn more at: Meadowcreek Golf Course Cavalier Pass (link). • Summer Pool Passes are now on sale. More information can be found at: Outdoor Pool Passes | Charlottesville, VA (link). • Summer Registration opens on April 21, 10:00 am. Included in some of the offerings this year are seven weeks of art camp and one week of chess camp. Registration options can be found at: Registration / Policies | Charlottesville, VA (link). • Summer camp is quickly filling up! Adventure Camp Week One of Camp Shenandoah is already full! • Washington Park Ramp VODT grant project is under construction • Rugby Avenue VDOT grant project - under contract, work to start soon. Utilities – Director Lauren Hildebrand (she/her) • The Department of Utilities is excited to launch three new incentives to help improve home energy efficiency. Utilities now offers six home envelope resources that complement each other to help community members improve the energy efficiency of their home, lower utility bills, and increase home comfort. o Attic Insulation Self-Assessment ▪ According to Energy Star®, 90% of U.S. homes are under- insulated. The Attic Insulation Self-Assessment was developed by Utilities staff and is a great resource to help customers better understand their attic’s insulation needs. Each assessment includes a free, personalized evaluation for attic insulation that provides guidance to help maximize the attic’s energy efficiency potential. Page 82 of 147 The self-assessment is 100% free to use, and can be accessed via smartphone, tablet, or computer. o $500 Attic Insulation Rebate ▪ Maximize the most cost-effective way to improve your home’s energy efficiency with upgraded attic insulation. For a limited time, gas customers can receive a $500 rebate towards upgrading their home’s attic insulation and take advantage of an available federal tax credit to claim 30% of the cost of the insulation with a maximum of $1,200 credited. Combining these incentives could significantly lower the cost of your insulation upgrade. o $150 Attic Air Sealing Rebate ▪ For a limited time, gas customers can receive a $150 rebate to cover the cost of measures that plug holes and seal cracks in their attic. This process improves home comfort, enhances air quality, and boosts energy efficiency by keeping conditioned air inside the house. And if you’re installing upgraded attic insulation, attic air sealing should be done at the same time to maximize the effectiveness of both measures. o $125 Smart Thermostat Rebate ▪ Gas customers can now receive a $125 rebate towards a smart thermostat to enhance the energy efficiency of their home. Smart thermostats use Wi-Fi to allow you to control a home’s indoor temperature remotely from a smartphone or tablet. Providing convenience, control, and insight, a smart thermostat helps deliver optimal performance for an HVAC system. Plus, Utilities still offers a $100 Programmable Thermostat Rebate for customers interested in that option. o Home Weatherization Program ▪ The Charlottesville Gas Energy Efficiency Program (CGEEP) is Utilities’ no-cost home weatherization program for qualified gas customers. Newly expanded income qualification levels have broadened the reach of this program to even more members of the community, and increased outreach for CGEEP will roll out in the coming months. • More information on programs and incentives from Utilities can be found on the Utilities webpage (link). Transit – Director Garland Williams (he/him) • Jan Yousufi joined Transit (CAT) as a Buyer II on February 28, 2025. Jan has over 10 years of experience as a procurement and contract specialist. With her strong background in developing and maintaining project schedules, as well as Page 83 of 147 managing detailed procurement timelines for multiple projects, she will assist CAT in completing federally funded capital projects. • Jan has an associate degree in Financial Management, a Bachelor of Business Administration, and is a Certified Contracts Management Associate (CCMA). She started her onboarding with the City’s Office of Procurement and CAT on Monday, April 7, 2025. Public Works – Director Steven Hicks (he/him) • Public Works conducted an internal "ROADEO" contest in March where equipment operators showcased their skills against set courses and objectives across a variety of equipment exercises, including snowplows, claw trucks, and mini excavators. This internal contest informed the selection of operators who will get the opportunity to travel to the upcoming Mid-Atlantic American Public Works Association Championship in Ocean City, Maryland to compete against other operators from localities across Virginia, Maryland, and West Virginia on April 30. Six Charlottesville equipment operators were selected: Joshua Wyland, Jimmie Newman, Milton Morris, Bryan Frazier Sr., Bryan Frazier Jr., and James Frazier Jr. • The Virginia Department of Transportation is planning for the three projects – Fontaine Interchange, Fontaine Streetscape and Hydraulic & District Ave Roundabout on May 22 from 5:00 to 7:00 pm at the Virginia Department of Forestry building, with a backup date of Tuesday, May 27 (same time & place). The address is 900 Natural Resources Dr #800, Charlottesville, VA 22903. Neighborhood Development Services – Director Kellie Brown (she/her) • Neighborhood Development Services (NDS) staff attended a meeting of the Charlottesville Area Development Roundtable (CADRe – link) on April 17. Staff’s presentation provided an update on the NDS annual workplan, development review process refinements, an initial round of Development Code amendments to address challenges identified in the first year since the Development Code went into effect in February 2024, and initial findings from review of environmental policies and regulations that intersect with Development Code provisions for more housing. Page 84 of 147 Charlottesville Fire Department – Chief Michael Thomas (he/him) Key Operations Metrics Comparing the first three quarters of FY25 to the same period in FY24, CFD incidents are up by 7% across all categories. Fire incidents increased by 42%, EMS incidents decreased by 4%, and all other types of incidents increased by 23%. Cooking fires in particular increased by 84% in the first three quarters of 2025 compared to 2024. On average, CFD has run about 385 EMS incidents, 16 fire incidents, and 197 other type incidents each month in the last year. Comparing those monthly averages to the year before, EMS incidents are slightly decreasing, and fire and all other incident types are increasing. Page 85 of 147 Opioid Overdoses Opioid overdoses in the city have decreased in the last six months. CFD and CARS have run an average of about five overdoses monthly in 2025, a decrease from 2024’s average of six overdoses monthly. Unhoused EMS Patients CFD & CARS added a new field to patient care reports to track emergency medical responses to unhoused patients in June 2024. Our records show that over the last nine months, CFD & CARS have responded to 40 unhoused patients monthly on average. The top three findings of attendants in charge on these incidents were non-traumatic pain (17.8% of calls), alcohol abuse (14.1% of calls), and bodily injuries (11.0% of calls). EMS: Effective April 14th, we will begin transitioning to CFD-stocked and maintained drug boxes. Moving forward, CFD will be fully self-supported for all medical supplies. This milestone marks the culmination of two years of planning and implementation, which included: • Purchasing and installing three drug and supply vending machines with full activity tracking • Securing all necessary licensure and certifications from the Virginia Board of Pharmacy, Virginia Department of Health (VDH), and the Drug Enforcement Agency (DEA) • Hiring a dedicated EMS Medical Supply Technician • Enhancing security in EMS supply rooms with door alarms and surveillance cameras CRR: • The Charlottesville Fire Department has had 4 Structure fires in the last few weeks. The Fire Marshal’s Office has determined that the Melbourne fire was Page 86 of 147 accidental. The Melbourne fire had over $250,000 damages to the $400,000 structure. • The fire on McCormick Rd. was an accidental lab fire. • The house fire on Ridge St. was accidental and caused around $4,000 in damages. • The fire on 2nd St. SW is still under investigation. The damage from the 2nd St. fire was under $30,000, and the building was saved more than $800,000. The building was restored to service with a minor impact on the businesses in the building or adjacent areas. • The Fire Marshal is working with the Virginia Forensics Lab to determine the final cause and origin of the case. • We released our annual report on Friday, April 11th. Page 87 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: Conduct a Public Hearing Presenter: Krisy Hammill, Director of Budget Staff Contacts: Samuel Sanders, Jr., City Manager Krisy Hammill, Director of Budget Title: Public hearing on the City of Charlottesville's Proposed Real Property Tax Rate Background Even though no tax rate change is being requested, a Public Hearing is required so the community can have the opportunity to provide input on the tax rate proposed as part of the City's FY 2026 Budget. A Public Hearing Notice was published in The Daily Progress on April 12, 2025, to alert the public of the date, time, and location of the Public Hearing. Discussion The Real Estate Tax rate was published at $.98/$100 assessed value, and the City's FY 2026 Proposed Budget is balanced with the revenue that the rate would generate. This rate is the same as the current year's rate and no rate increase is being requested. Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan The Budget aligns with Council’s Strategic Plan and Outcome Areas, which are detailed in the Budget document. Community Engagement There have been multiple opportunities throughout the Budget development process for the community to provide input into the Budget. This Public Hearing provides an opportunity for input on the proposed tax rates. Budgetary Impact N/A Recommendation N/A Alternatives Page 88 of 147 N/A Attachments 1. NOTICE OF PROPOSED REAL PROPERTY TAX INCREASE 2025_April 21 (Post) Page 89 of 147 NOTICE OF PROPOSED REAL PROPERTY TAX INCREASE AND NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING The City of Charlottesville proposes to increase property tax levies. 1. Assessment Increase: Total assessed value of real property, excluding additional assessments due to new construction or improvements to property, exceeds last year’s total assessed value of real property by 7.36 percent. 2. Lowered Rate Necessary to Offset Increased Assessment: The tax rate which would levy the same amount of real estate tax as last year, when multiplied by the new total assessed value of real estate with the exclusions mentioned above, would be $0.9128 per $100 of assessed value. This rate will be known as the “lowered tax rate.” 3. Effective Rate Increase: The City of Charlottesville proposes to adopt a real estate tax rate of $0.98 per $100 of assessed value. The difference between the lowered tax rate and the proposed rate would be $0.0672 per $100 or 7.359 percent. This difference will be known as the “effective tax rate increase”. Individual property taxes may, however, increase at a percentage greater than or less than the above percentage. 4. Proposed Total Budget Increase: Based on the proposed real property tax rate and changes in other revenues, the total budget of the City of Charlottesville will exceed last year’s by 4.97 percent. A public hearing on the increase will be held on Monday, April 21, 2025, at 6:30 p.m. in City Council Chambers at City Hall, 605 East Main Street, Charlottesville, Virginia. Persons desiring to be heard may attend and share their views on the proposed real estate property tax levy increase, within such reasonable time limits as established by City Council. Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public hearing may call (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide 48 hours’ notice so that proper arrangements may be made. Kyna Thomas Chief of Staff /Clerk of Council Advertised in The Daily Progress 4-12-25 Physically posted in City Hall 4-14-25 Page 90 of 147 ORDINANCE To Establish the Annual Tax Levy for Tax Year 2025 BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville THAT in order to pay the general operating expenses of the City, including local support for the City’s schools; to provide funding for other public purposes; and to pay interest on and to provide funding for retirement of City debt, taxes are hereby levied at the rates set forth within this Ordinance, for the current Tax Year (beginning at midnight on January 1, 2025 and ending December 31, 2025), and for each succeeding Tax Year during which this Ordinance continues in effect: 1. Section 1—Real Property and Mobile Homes On real estate, including land and improvements thereon and mobile homes, the tax rate shall be $0.98 on every $100 of the assessed value thereof. 2. Section 2—Personal Property On all automobiles, trucks, motorcycles and other motor vehicles; boats and aircraft; and on all tangible personal property used or held in connection with a business, trade, occupation or profession (excluding furnishings, furniture and appliances in rental units of 30 days or longer) the tax rate shall be $4.40 on every $100 of the assessed value thereof. 3. Section 3—Public Service Corporation Property (a) On that portion of the real estate and tangible personal property of public service corporations which has been equalized as provided in Sec. 58.1-2604 of the Virginia Code, the tax rate shall be $0.98 on every $100 of the assessed value thereof determined by the Virginia State Corporation Commission or Virginia Department of Taxation (for railroads and interstate pipeline transmission companies), and (b) Notwithstanding the foregoing, on automobiles and trucks belonging to public service corporations, the tax rate shall be $4.40 on every $100 of the assessed value thereof. 4. Section 4—Machinery and Tools On machinery and tools used in a manufacturing or mining business (excluding intangible personal property), the tax rate shall be $4.40 on every $100 of the assessed value thereof. 5. Section 5—Energy Efficient Buildings On energy efficient buildings the tax rate shall be $0.49 on every $100 of the assessed value thereof, subject to the limitations set forth within Chapter 30, Article V, Division 4 of the Code of the City of Charlottesville (1990), as amended, and applies only to buildings and not to the land on which such buildings are located. BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED THAT the Ordinance adopted April 15, 2024 establishing local tax rates for the Tax Year beginning January 1, 2024 and ending on December 31, 2024 is hereby repealed, effective at midnight on January 1, 2025. Page 91 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: Adoption of the Resolution Establishing the Personal Property Tax Relief Percentage for Tax Year 2025 Presenter: Todd Divers, Commissioner of the Revenue Staff Contacts: Lisa Newman, Personal Property Supervisor Title: Resolution Establishing 2025 Tax Year Personal Property Tax Relief Percentage (1 Reading) Background The City of Charlottesville, Virginia (“City”), receives a fixed Annual Grant from the Commonwealth of Virginia (“Commonwealth”) to be used to apply Personal Property Tax Relief (“PPTR”). The PPTR Program is governed by the Code of Virginia (58.1 Chapter 35.1), and gives the locality a pool of funds, the proceeds of which must be used to provide relief to the owners of qualifying vehicles. The Commonwealth’s obligation is capped and made certain; localities distribute the relief amount as determined by Local Ordinance. Discussion The method for computing the PPTR percentage is to subtract the tax year’s total tax on eligible vehicles valued $1,500 or less (that receive 100% relief) from the total PPTR Grant amount ($3,498,256), and divide the result by the total tax on the rest of the eligible vehicles’ portion of value that is $20,000 or less. Based on 2025 Tax Year Early Book and projections for said Tax Year, COR Staff recommends setting the PPTR percentage of tax on up to $20,000 value for vehicles valued over $1,500, by using the formula specified below: 2025 Formula: 1. Tax Levy on all qualifying vehicles = $12,850,000 2. PPTR used on 100% relief vehicles (vehicles valued $1,500 and under) = $63,000 3. PPTR total ($3,498,256) minus line 2, leaves remaining = $3,435,256 4. Levy on up to $20,000 value (of qualifying vehicles valued over $1,500) = $11,050,000 5. Divide 3 by 4 = .3109 or 31% Page 92 of 147 Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan Establishing the PPTR, like establishing tax rates, is one of the functions of a well-managed local government, which would put this under the Strategic Outcome Area of Organizational Excellence. If the percentage is set too high, the City may not have the full revenue it would from the tax rate set by City Council. If the percentage is set too low, the owners of qualifying vehicles may overpay their share of the local tax burden. Therefore, the attached Resolution applies directly to City Council’s Organizational Mission of a being “a diverse and compassionate organization dedicated to providing excellence in public service for a resilient and sustainable community.” Community Engagement N/A Budgetary Impact None anticipated, based on forecast of vehicle levy and relief to be received from the Commonwealth. Recommendation Suggested Motion: “I move for the adoption of the attached Resolution establishing the Personal Property Tax Relief Percentage for Tax Year 2025.” Alternatives N/A Attachments 1. Resolution Establishing the Personal Property Tax Relief Percentage for Tax Year 2025 Page 93 of 147 RESOLUTION ESTABLISHING THE PERSONAL PROPERTY TAX RELIEF PERCENTAGE FOR TAX YEAR 2025 BE IT HEREBY RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia (“City Council”), that, pursuant to the requirements of Virginia Code § 58.1-3524, that personal property tax relief at the rate of thirty -one percent (31%) shall be applied to the first $20,000 of value of each qualifying vehicle having a value of more than $1,500; and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by City Council that personal property tax relief at the rate of one hundred percent (100%) shall be applied to each qualifying vehicle having a value of $1,500 or less. Page 94 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: Review and approval of three (3) related items: 1. The 1-Year Annual Action Plan for the City’s CDBG and HOME Programs for Program Year 2025-26 2. Funding awards for CDBG activities 3. Funding awards for HOME activities Presenter: Anthony Warn, Grants Analyst Staff Contacts: Anthony Warn, Grants Analyst Alexander Ikefuna, Director, Office of Community Solutions Title: Public Hearing for the Draft 1-Year Annual Action Plan for the City’s Community Development Block Grants (CDBG) and HOME Investment Partnerships Programs for Program Year 2025-26 and Associated Funding Recommendations (1 of 2 readings) Background The City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City"), is an Entitlement Community (“EC) as designated by the U.S. Department of Housing & Urban Development (“HUD”) and, as such, is the recipient of annual allocations of federal funds through the Community Development Block Grants (“CDBG”) and the HOME Investment Partnerships Programs. The City is required to submit for review to HUD a locally approved Annual Action Plan (“AAP”) outlining steps the City will take through the use of these funds to meet HUD's national objectives. As of April 17, 2025, the City had not yet received any indication from HUD regarding funds to be made available for the 2025-26 program year. Consequently, and in accordance with HUD guidance, the funding award recommendations presented here for consideration are based on funds previously allocated to the city by HUD for the 2024-25 program year (PY24), with final award amounts to be prorated upon receipt of notification from HUD of actual funding for 2025-26 CDBG and/or HOME activities. Discussion For program year 2025-26, the CDBG/HOME Taskforce reviewed a total of fourteen (14) applications in this funding round, eleven (11) requests for funding through the CDBG program (totaling $604,736) and three (3) requesting HOME funding (totaling $409,188). It should be noted here that the largest number of applications received for the CDBG Program fall Page 95 of 147 under what HUD classifies as "Public Services" Programs (requests totaling approximately $399,236). For some years now, HUD policy institutes what is known as a "spending cap" that limits localities from awarding more than fifteen percent (15%) of their annual CDBG allocation to these types of Programs. For the current Program Year 2024-25, that limit was $65,792.55. Based on the applications received to date, the Public Services category alone represents a shortfall in anticipated funding available of approximately $333,443.45. At this time, the City has not been made aware of any funding decisions by HUD for the 2025-26 Program Year. This poses a significant challenge for the work of the CDBG/HOME Taskforce. So as to be best positioned to act quickly if/when HUD announces PY25 funding allocations, the Taskforce decided to continue the practice adopted last year of establishing funding recommendations based on the allocations received from HUD for the 2024-25 Program Year. And, again, similarly to last year, the recommendations will be calculated to the most precise decimal value possible. This will be used to calculate final dollar values for the slate of funding recommendations when allocations are announced by HUD and the White House. In conclusion, while CDBG/HOME Taskforce members would have liked to have been in the position of being able to fund each applicant in full, the funding recommendations outlined in the proposed AAP represent the Taskforce’s best efforts to invest the limited funds available to them, to maximize the positive impacts for our community and those residents at the heart of this work. All public comments received during the Public Hearings and/or the Public Comment period ending May 15, 2025, will be incorporated into the AAP. Two (2) Public Hearings have been scheduled before City Council (one (1) on Monday, April 21, 2025, and one (1) on Monday, May 5, 2025), and one (1) Public Hearing before the Commissioners of the Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission (“TJPDC”) on Thursday, May 1, 2025, at TJPDC’s Water Street Center. Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan The proposed Action Plan was developed to closely align with and support the City Council’s vision of the City as a community in which everyone has the opportunity to thrive. Specifically, activities have been carefully selected to support progress in several areas highlighted in City Council’s Strategic Vision, including Climate Action, Economic Prosperity, Housing, Education & Partnerships. Community Engagement This proposal conforms with the City's Citizen Participation Plan and has been presented to the public through multiple Public Hearings, including Public Hearings before the City's Planning Commission ("PC"), City Council, and the Commissioners of the Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission ("TJPDC"). HUD regulations require that participants in HUD’s CDBG and HOME Programs develop and submit for review by HUD locally approved Annual Action Plans ("AAP") that outline activities to be supported by funds allocated by HUD to meet the goals established in a five (5)-Year Consolidated Plan. Such plans are required to be presented before the general public, with opportunities for public comment. A thirty (30)-day public comment period is currently underway through May 15, 2025 (learn more at https://tjpdc.org/public-comment-py-2025-annual-action-plan/). A Public Hearing was held Page 96 of 147 before the City’s PC on Tuesday, April 8, 2025, during which the PC provided valuable input and suggestions for technical assistance to potential applicants during the mandatory pre-application workshops. After the Public Hearing, the PC voted to forward the draft Action Plan and associated funding recommendations for consideration by City Council (all in favor; 1 abstention). Budgetary Impact As the funds proposed to be awarded are federal funds allocated to the City by HUD to support community-benefit activities, and, as such, do not draw from the City’s General Fund, no adverse impacts to the City’s Budget are anticipated. Rather, use of these funds as recommended here will instead serve to address an important and pressing community need(s), while at the same time supporting the City’s eligibility for allocations of entitlement funds in future years. On a related note, and as of the time of this Report, City Staff has not received from HUD guidance from HUD as to how the policies of the new Presidential Administration might affect the City, especially regarding possible financial implications. Recommendation Recommendation #1: Approval of the AAP: Based on the anticipated benefits of the current proposal to the City, specifically in that the activities presented herein directly address important needs within our community, City Staff recommends that City Council approve the Program Year 2025-26 AAP as presented herein, and authorize City and TJPDC Staff to transmit the locally approved plan to HUD for final review and approval, with the suggested motion: “I move that City Council approve the attached RESOLUTION approving the City's Program Year 2025-26 One (1)-Year AAP for the City’s CDBG & HOME Programs.” Recommendation #2: Approval of Funding Awards (CDBG): City Staff also recommends that City Council approve the funding recommendations of the CDBG/HOME Taskforce for the award of CDBG funds and appropriate associated funds within the City’s CDBG Fund with the suggested motion: “I move that City Council also approve the attached RESOLUTION appropriating CDBG Block Grant funds anticipated to be received from HUD as outlined in the Program Year 2025-26 One (1)-Year AAP, in the approximate amount of $438,617.” Recommendation #3: Approval of Funding Awards (HOME): Finally, City Staff also recommends that City Council approve the funding recommendations of the CDBG/HOME Taskforce for the award of anticipated HOME funds with the suggested motion: “Finally, I move that City Council approve the attached RESOLUTION approving the award of HOME Investment Partnership Program funds anticipated to be received from HUD as outlined in the Program Year 2025-26 One (1)- Year AAP, in the approximate amount of $83,016.” Page 97 of 147 Alternatives Given that these funds are provided by HUD to the City for the execution of meaningful community- benefit programs and, as such, are not drawn from the City’s General Fund, no alternative courses of action are considered. CIty Council, could, of course, decide not to provide approval for this proposal and could instead direct City Staff to explore other options for expending these funds consistent with HUD’s programmatic requirements. Attachments 1. City Council Priorities PY25 CDBG & HOME (#R-24-115), adopted Sept. 3, 2024 2. HUD Annual Action Plan PY25 Resolution to Approve 3. HUD Annual Action Plan PY25 Resolution to Approve Funding Awards CDBG 4. HUD Annual Action Plan PY25 Resolution to Approve Funding Awards HOME 5. HUD Annual Action Plan PY25 City Council Slide Deck* Page 98 of 147 Resolution to Establish Council Priorities for the Program Year 2025-2026 Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) & HOME Investment Partnerships (HOME) Programs WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville has been designated as an Entitlement Community by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) and as such is a recipient of federal funds through the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) & HOME Investment Partnerships (HOME) programs, and WHEREAS the City is a contributing member of the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium (TJHC) in partnership with the counties of Albemarle, Fluvanna, Greene, Louisa and Nelson, and through the Consortium shares in the benefits of participation in HUD’s HOME program, and WHEREAS in accordance with the City of Charlottesville’s HUD-approved Citizen Participation Plan, the city’s CDBG/HOME Task Force composed of residents and community representatives will be called on to review requests for funding of potential CDBG & HOME projects and to make recommendations for funding to Council in the Spring of 2025; now THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Charlottesville, Virginia, that the Program Year 2025-2026 CDBG & HOME programs (PY25) shall prioritize to the degree possible: o A continued emphasis on expanding access to affordable housing opportunities, including but not limited to low-income housing redevelopment; workforce development, including but not limited to efforts to bolster Section 3 training opportunities other economic development activities; microenterprise assistance; access to quality childcare; homeowner rehabilitation and energy-efficiency upgrades; down payment assistance; and improvements to public infrastructure designed to eliminate or reduce barriers to access to public amenities for mobility-impaired residents o For program year 2025-2026, $89,896.51 of CDBG Entitlement funds shall be set aside to support Economic Development activities o For program year 2025-2026, $89,896.51of CDBG Entitlement funds shall be set aside to support Public Facilities and Improvement activities, with a special emphasis on activities that will eliminate or reduce barriers to access for mobility-impaired residents o The CDBG Admin and Planning budget shall be set at 20% of the City’s CDBG allocation o Any other guidelines or directions Council may wish to give in determining how CDBG and HOME funds should be spent 5-2-115 Page 99 of 147 RESOLUTION Resolution Approving the City of Charlottesville-Thomas Jefferson Area HOME Consortium One-Year Annual Action Plan for Program Year 2025-26 WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville is a designated Entitlement Community by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”), and as such is a recipient of federal funds through the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and Home Investment Partnerships (“HOME”) programs, and WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville is a contributing member of the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium (“TJHC”) in partnership with the counties of Albemarle, Fluvanna, Greene, Louisa and Nelson, and through the Consortium shares in the benefits of participation in HUD’s HOME program, NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, hereby approves the Charlottesville-Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium One- Year Annual Action Plan and its submittal to HUD for final review, as presented at a public hearing before the city’s Planning Commission (on 8 April 2025) and at two public hearings before City Council (on 21 April and 5 May 2025). Approved by Council May 5, 2025 _____________________________ Kyna Thomas, CMC Clerk of Council Page 100 of 147 APPROPRIATION Appropriation of Community Development Block Grant (“CDBG”) Funds Anticipated from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development for Program Year 2025-26, in the Approximate Amount $438,617 WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville has been advised by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”) is eligible to receive an anticipated Community Development Block Grant (“CDBG”) allocation for the 2025-26 program year, in the approximate amount of $438,617; and WHEREAS City Council has received recommendations for the expenditure of funds from the city’s CDBG/HOME Taskforce, as reviewed and approved by the City’s Planning Commission at a public hearing on April 8, 2025, as provided by law; BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Charlottesville, Virginia, that upon receipt of anticipated CDBG funding from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, said funds are hereby appropriated to the following individual expenditure accounts in the Community Development Block Grant Fund in accordance with the respective purposes set forth; provided, however, that the City Manager is hereby authorized to transfer funds between and among such individual accounts as circumstances may require, to the extent permitted by applicable federal grant regulations, as set forth below: Economic Development Activities Fund Account/Internal Order # Funding Recommendation Revised Award 218 1900593 CIC Entrepreneur Programs $25,000.00 218 1900594 LVCA Beginning Workforce Development $50,000.00 Subtotal, Economic Development: $75,000.00 Public Facilities & Infrastructure Enhancements Fund Account/Internal Order # Funding Recommendation Revised Award 218 1900595 Arc of the Piedmont Shower Replacement at Shamrock Group Home $20,500.00 Subtotal, Public Facilities & Infrastructure: $20,500.00 Affordable Housing Activities Fund Account/Internal Order # Funding Recommendation Revised Award 218 1900592 AHIP Charlottesville Critical Home Rehabs $140,000.00 Subtotal, Affordable Housing: $140,000.00 Public Services Activities Fund Account/Internal Order # Funding Recommendation Revised Award 218 1900596 PHA Financial Opportunity Center (FOC) Credit Club $21,342.00 218 1900597 PHAR Resident-Involved Redevelopment $22,618.55 Page 101 of 147 218 1900598 The Haven Coordination of Community Service Providers $21,832.00 Subtotal, Public Services: $65,792.55 Programmatic Funds Fund Account/Internal Order # Funding Recommendation Revised Award 218 3914001000 CDBG Planning & Admin $87,723.40 218 3914001000 Unallocated Reserve $49,601.05 Subtotal, Programmatic Funds: $137,324.45 Total PY25 Funding Recommendations: $438,617.00 In the event that funding received from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development differs from the amounts referenced above, all appropriated amounts may be administratively increased/reduced at the same prorated percentage of change to actual funding received. No subrecipient’s grant may be increased above their initial funding request without further consideration by Council. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this appropriation is conditioned upon the receipt of not less than $438,617 in CDBG funds from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development for program year 2025-26, and all subrecipient awards are also conditioned upon receipt of such funds. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that any unspent funds available after the approved activity is completed and closed out with HUD will hereby be returned to the unallocated lump sum account within Fund 218 to be reallocated to suitable new activities by Council at a later date. FINALLY, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the funding award appropriated within this resolution will be provided as a grant to a private non-profit, charitable organization (“subrecipient”) and shall be utilized by the subrecipient solely for the purpose(s) stated within their approved Scope of Work. The City Manager is hereby authorized to enter into a funding agreement with the subrecipient named herein as deemed advisable to ensure that all grant funds are expended for their intended purposes and in accordance with applicable federal and state laws and regulations. Approved by Council May 5, 2025 _____________________________ Kyna Thomas, CMC Clerk of Council Page 102 of 147 RESOLUTION Approval of HOME Investment Partnership Program Activity with Funds Anticipated from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development for Program Year 2025- 26, in the Approximate Amount of $83,016 WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville ("City”) has been advised by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (“HUD”) that the region served by the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium (“TJHC)” is eligible to receive a HOME Investment Partnerships program (“HOME”) allocation for the 2025-26 program year, in the approximate amount of $651,111, of which the City is eligible to receive approximately $83,016 to support local affordable housing (“AH”) initiatives; and WHEREAS City Council has received recommendations for the expenditure of the anticipated funds from the city’s CDBG/HOME Taskforce, as reviewed and approved by the City’s Planning Commission at a public hearing on May 8, 2025, as provided by law; and WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville had in prior years appropriated local funds from the CAHF to meet HUD’s 25% local match funds requirement on behalf of the members of the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium, the City will now certify with HUD certain CAHF- funded projects in the current program year to meet the local match funds requirement, as established through the 2025 Cooperation Agreement established between Charlottesville & Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission (“TJPDC”), thereby significantly reducing the administrate burden on staff from both parties; BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, that upon receipt of this anticipated HOME funding from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, that the following HOME-funded affordable housing activity is approved: PY Subrecipient Funded Activity Proposed Award PY25 Piedmont Housing Alliance 905 Rives St. Townhomes AH $83,016.66 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this appropriation of subrecipient award funds is conditioned upon the receipt by the City of not less than $83,016.66 in HOME funds as the city’s local share of HOME funds received by the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development for Program Year 2025-26. If funding received from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development for Program Year 2025-26 differs from the amounts referenced above, all appropriated amounts may be administratively increased/reduced at the same prorated percentage of change to actual funding received. No subrecipient’s funding award may be increased above their initial funding request without further consideration by Council. FINALLY, BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the funding award appropriated within this resolution will be provided as a grant to a private non-profit, charitable organization Page 103 of 147 (“subrecipient”) and shall be utilized by the subrecipient solely for the purpose(s) stated within their approved agreement, as approved by TJPDC staff in accordance with the 2024 Charlottesville/TJPDC Cooperation Agreement. The City Manager is hereby authorized to enter into a funding agreement with the subrecipient named herein as deemed advisable to ensure that all grant funds are expended for their intended purposes and in accordance with applicable federal and state laws and regulations. Approved by Council May 5, 2025 _____________________________ Kyna Thomas, CMC Clerk of Council Page 104 of 147 City of Charlottesville CDBG & HOME Programs Program Year 2025-2026 City Council Public Hearing Monday, April 21, 2025 Staff Contact: Anthony Warn, Grants Analyst Office of Community Solutions warna@charlottesville.gov Page 105 of 147 • HUD national objectives are guided by three primary principles: o Establish and maintain thriving living environments through activities designed to benefit families, individuals, and the greater Charlottesville community o Create economic opportunities through activities related to economic development, commercial revitalization, or job creation o Provide decent housing through activities focusing on housing programs where the purpose of the activity meets individual, family, or community needs HUD National Objectives The authorizing statute of the HUD-funded programs requires that each activity funded (except for program administration and planning activities) meet one of HUD’s three national objectives: • Benefit to low-and moderate-income (LMI) persons; • Aid in the prevention or elimination of slums or blight; and • Meet a need having a particular urgency (referred to as urgent need) Available online at www.hudexchange.info/ resource/2555/national-objective-code- descriptions/ Page 106 of 147 • For the upcoming program year 2024-25, City Council has established the following priorities in Resolution #R-23-121 • Council resolutions can be found in the city’s Laserfiche Archive online at: https://weblink.charlott esville.org/public/brow se.aspx?dbid=0 • Y ou can also email me for a copy City Council Priorities With the goal of fostering a high degree of responsiveness to local needs, City Council each year establishes a set of local priorities for the CDBG program Council priorities are discussed at open public meetings and published as a formal resolution each year Page 107 of 147 • Matrix codes for eligible activities under CDBG fall into specific categories • Charlottesville focuses it’s CDBG funds on four of these categories: o Economic Development o Public Facilities & Infrastructure o Public Services o Housing • HUD caps funding for Public Services activities at 15% of the total allocation for a given year CDBG Eligible Activities HUD’s authorizing statutes require that CDBG-funded activities meet the definition of specific eligible activities, each of which is referred to by a specific ‘matrix code’ Available online at www.hudexchange.info/resource/89/community- development-block-grant-program-cdbg-guide-to- national-objectives-and-eligible-activities-for- entitlement-communities/ Page 108 of 147 HOME has four main eligible activities: • Homeowner (owner-occupied) rehabilitation • Rental housing acquisition, new construction, or rehabilitation • Homebuyer housing acquisition, new construction, or rehabilitation, including direct assistance to eligible homebuyers to purchase the housing • Tenant-based rental assistance (rental subsidy) HOME Eligible Activities HUD’s authorizing statutes require that CDBG-funded activities meet the definition of specific eligible activities, each of which is referred to by a specific ‘matrix code’ Available online at https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-24/subtitle- A/part-92/subpart-E/subject-group- ECFRf448ea7bbdfb69a?toc=1 Page 109 of 147 Overview of Funding Request Received for PY25 Summary of PY25 applications received for program year 2025-26 Actual Page 110 of 147 Draft Funding Recommendations PY25 Draft funding recommendations from the CDBG/HOME Taskforce for program year 2025-26, based on the amounts allocated for program year 2024-25 Draft / Proposed Page 111 of 147 Draft Funding Recommendations Scenario PY25 Projected funding recommendations for program year 2025-26 based on actual funding allocations from HUD below that awarded in previous 2024-25 program year Financial Modelling Scenario #1: Proposed awards if HUD funding for PY25 CDBG activities reduced to $300,000 Page 112 of 147 Thank You for your interest in the City of Charlottesville’s CDBG & HOME programs! For more information, please visit the city’s CDBG & HOME webpage at https://www .charlottesville.gov/678/ CDBG-HOME-Programs Please also feel free to email Anthony at warna@ charlottesville.gov and Taylor at harveyryant@charlottesville.gov Page 113 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: Adopt Resolution Reallocating Funding Presenter: Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Staff Contacts: Alexander Ikefuna, Director, Office of Community Solutions Antoine Williams, Housing Program Manager Madelyn Metzler, Housing Compliance Coordinator Title: Resolution allocating $35,000 of FY25 Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund as an Emergency Grant to the Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless ("BRACH") for Supportive Housing Program Background The City of Charlottesville, Virginia's ("City"), Fiscal Year 2024 - 2025 (FY25) Budget included funding for the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund ("CAHF"). $823,000 in funding was made available for the CAHF Grant Program. The CAHF Committee made recommendations for allocation of $788,000, leaving a difference of $35,000 for allocation at City Council's discretion. Discussion Recognizing that funding needs do not always arise in alignment with Grant funding cycles, the City Manager presented to City Council eight (8) off-cycle requests as part of the City's FY2026 Budget process. One (1) request is from BRACH for funding to replace a lost Grant. This funding would ensure BRACH, the lead Continuum of Care agency for our region, can continue its operations uninterrupted. Due to the potential for interrupted service, this funding request is deemed an emergency. Given the emergency need, the remaining $35,000 allocated for CAHF Grants is recommended to be awarded to BRACH for a Supportive Housing Emergency Grant. Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan The funding recommendations align with the following: (1) Alignment with Affordable Housing and Comprehensive Plans: The funding recommendation has been endorsed by the City Council and aligns with the goals and priorities outlined in the City's Affordable Housing and Comprehensive Plans. The recommended funding supports initiatives addressing homelessness prevention and affordable housing development, key focus areas of the City's affordable housing plan. (2) City Council Strategic Plan Framework/Strategic Outcome Area ("SOA") Housing: Housing Choice and Mobility: The CAHF Program supports a variety of initiatives aimed at improving housing affordability and accessibility. The Program directly contributes to housing choice and mobility for all Page 114 of 147 residents, as outlined in the City's Affordable Housing Plan. (3) SOA Economic Prosperity: Driving Prosperity for All: Investing in affordable housing initiatives through the CAHF Program ensures that all residents have access to stable and affordable housing. Stable housing is foundational for pursuing economic opportunities, building wealth, and contributing to community prosperity. By fostering economic stability for residents, the Program drives economic prosperity for the entire community. (4) SOA Partnerships: Magnify Positive Community Outcomes through Capacity Support: The CAHF Program involves collaboration with various stakeholders, including nonprofit organizations, housing authorities, legal aid services, and community development organizations. These partnerships amplify the positive outcomes of affordable housing initiatives by leveraging resources, expertise, and community networks. By fostering meaningful collaborations, the Program enhances the effectiveness of initiatives addressing housing needs. (5) Commitment to Justice, Equity, Diversity, and Inclusion: The CAHF Program reflects the City's commitment to justice, equity, diversity, and inclusion by addressing housing needs across various demographic groups and socioeconomic backgrounds. By providing housing support to vulnerable populations and advancing social and economic justice, the Program contributes to creating a more inclusive and equitable community. In summary, the CAHF Grant Program aligns closely with the City's vision for creating an environment where everyone can thrive. Moving forward, continued investment in the CAHF Grant Program will be essential for advancing the City's goals for inclusive and equitable community development. Community Engagement This CAHF allocation is in keeping with the provisions in the City's Affordable Housing Plan and 2021 Comprehensive Plan that were recommended by the Planning Commission and approved by the City Council. Both documents went through an extensive public engagement process. Budgetary Impact This request does not encumber any additional funding from the City Budget. CAHF funding was allocated in the City's Capital Improvement Program ("CIP") FY24/25 Budget. This approval allocates this FY24/25 CIP funding. Recommendation City Staff recommends City Council adopt the attached Resolution allocating $35,000 in FY25 CAHF Grant funding as an Emergency Grant to BRACH for its Supportive Housing Program. Alternatives N/A Attachments 1. CAHFGrantAward-Resolution_Allocating $35000(FY25) - BRACH Page 115 of 147 RESOLUTION ALLOCATION OF CHARLOTTESVILLE AFFORDABLE HOUSING FUND (CAHF) FY25 AS EMERGENCY GRANT TO THE BLUE RIDGE AREA COALITION FOR THE HOMELESS (BRACH) FOR SUPPORTIVE HOUSING PROGRAM IN THE AMOUNT OF $35,000 WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, having established the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (CAHF) Grant Program to provide financial support for community agency programs aiding in affordable housing and homelessness relief, hereby allocates $35,000 from the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (CAHF) Grant Program under Fund 426 Project: CP-084, as per the Capital Improvement Program budget for FY2025; and NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED The City Council, having received and reviewed recommendations from the CAHF Committee on the expenditure of CAHF funds for the CAHF Grant Program, resolves to allocate the amount to the Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (BRACH) for Supportive Housing Program. Fund Project GL Account Applicant Funded Project/Initiative CAHF Award 426 CP-084 530670 Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (BRACH) Supportive Housing Emergency Grant $35,000 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that all funding awards within this resolution shall be provided as grants to the entity listed under the “Applicant” column above to be used solely for the purposes of the program listed in this resolution and any subsequent grant agreement. The City Manager is authorized to negotiate and execute funding grant agreements with each recipient to ensure proper utilization of funds. Approved by Council April 21, 2025 ______________________ Kyna Thomas, CMC Clerk of Council Page 116 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: Adopt Resolution Presenter: Kristel Riddervold, Director of the Office of Sustainability Staff Contacts: Steven Gaines, Urban Forester Dan Frisbee Title: Resolution of Intent to Participate in the Biophilic Cities Program Background The City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City"), has long-standing commitments to sustainability, environmental stewardship, and community health and wellness. The City has a rich and varied diversity of ecosystems that provide benefits to residents, workers, businesses, visitors, and the diverse species with whom we share our City and our region. The City's Comprehensive Plan includes the Priority Area “Keep Charlottesville green, make it greener, and protect the natural environment and the many benefits it provides.” The opening paragraph of the Chapter 7 (Environment, Climate, and Food Equity) Community Vision Statement is “Charlottesville will be an environmental leader, with healthy air, water, and ecosystems, as well as ample, high-quality, and accessible open space and natural areas, and a preserved and enhanced tree canopy. The Rivanna River and other waterbodies will be celebrated and protected, and environmentally-sound community access will be enhanced”. The City has been encouraged to apply to participate in the Biophilic Cities Program ("Program"), which was initiated at the University of Virginia in 2011. The Program is a global network ("Network") of cities, scholars, and advocates working to build an understanding of the value and contribution of nature in cities to the lives of urban residents. The Network places nature at the core of design and planning, and works to create opportunities to learn about and connect with nature. Cities that join the Network can work with other Biophilic cities across the globe, participate in Network events, contribute policies and plans to a resource library, and more. Currently, sixteen (16) U.S. cities are members, with four (4) from Virginia (Arlington, Norfolk, Richmond, and Reston). Discussion Biophilia, a term popularized by the renowned biologist E.O. Wilson, refers to the innate connection of humans to the natural world. Examples of biophilia include: • The sense of peace and well-being experienced when spending time in nature; • The attraction to natural landscapes, like forests and oceans; • The enjoyment of animals and plants; and Page 117 of 147 • The preference for natural materials and designs in architecture and interior design. A Biophilic City is one that contains abundant biodiversity and nature that works to conserve that nature, as well as creatively insert new forms of nature, and fosters connections to the natural world. It understands and celebrates that its role is to provide habitat for many different forms of life, and advocate for humane co-existence. There are many clear and tangible benefits that flow from fostering urban connections to nature. These benefits include economic growth, positive educational impacts, and healthier, happier, and more productive cities. Nature in the city, moreover, helps to make cities and urban neighborhoods more resilient and livable, and this nature provides extensive and economically valuable ecosystem services. The City has already incorporated Biophilic principles into a number of major policy documents and programs that embody the City’s related values and priorities, including the Comprehensive Plan, the Rivanna River Corridor Plan, the Climate Action Plan, the Development Code, the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, the Urban Forest Management Plan, and the Water Resources Protection Program. Through a number of existing efforts, the City is already a Biophilic City, with numerous ways in which residents and visitors can already interact with and benefit from nature across the City. • The City has a commitment to a healthy and robust urban forest as well as its network of water resources, an appreciation for native species and diversity, and an understanding of the role of nature in addressing and responding to the climate crisis. • Nature elements are found in 2,300 acres of parks, school grounds, natural areas, landscape beds, medians/rights of way, and urban plazas/streetscapes. • The City has been a TREE CITY USA since 2006, has an active Tree Commission, funds an active urban forestry program (tree planting, restoration, invasives management), and is working on a comprehensive update of its Urban Forest Management Plan. • The City has tackled a number of nature-based solutions including stream restoration projects, forested wetlands, rain gardens, other green stormwater infrastructure, and pollinator gardens with consideration for appropriate, native plants. • Biophilic design has been integrated into various public projects, including several LEED- certified facilities and public spaces. • The City’s Development Code includes requirements to protect and maintain environmental quality. • An extensive and growing bike/pedestrian trail network offers a variety of opportunities to travel through and experience the City’s urban and natural areas. • Community gardens and urban farms offer hands-on experiences that also address food access interests. • The community also benefits from numerous community-based organizations whose missions involve environmental conservation, restoration, education, engagement, stewardship, inspiration, sustainability, human and environmental well-being, and more. Additional and intriguing efforts to further Bophilic Cities objectives are being explored and access to the global Network will provide opportunities to discover strategies and solutions. Additionally, there Page 118 of 147 is strong community interest in ongoing regional approaches to this work, building on past collaborations and developing a regional Biophilic framework. To become a Partner City, cities must submit an official Resolution, narrative statement, and list of municipal indicators by which Biophilic qualities can be assessed and progress can be evaluated over time. Partner Cities designate a specific Staff person (proposed to be the Office of Sustainability Director) who will serve as the City’s Biophilic Cities Network Contact and Coordinator. Initial membership is for two (2) years; partner status is renewable for subsequent periods of two to five (2 - 5) years. Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan This action is in direct alignment with City Council’s Strategic Plan Framework’s outcome areas of Climate Action, Recreation, Arts, and Culture, and Partnerships, as well as the Comprehensive Plan. Community Engagement The Priority Area in the City's Comprehensive Plan is the outcome of intensive community engagement efforts. Similarly, the development of the Climate Action Plan and Parks and Recreation Master Plan were the result of extensive community engagement, supporting related principles. Both City Programs, and various community partners, have and will continue to offer ongoing engagement and volunteering opportunities related to connecting with and valuing nature in the City. Budgetary Impact There is no financial mpact on the City's General Fund. Recommendation City Staff recommends City Council adopt the attached Resolution of Intent to Participate in the Biophilic Cities Program. Alternatives Continue locally-driven and biophilia-inspired efforts, without connection to this global Network. Attachments 1. Biophilic Cities Resolution 2. Biophilic Cities 04212025 Page 119 of 147 RESOLUTION EXPRESSING INTENT FOR THE CITY OF CHARLOTTEVILLE TO PARTICIPATE IN THE BIOPHILIC CITIES NETWORK WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville has long-standing commitments to environmental sustainability and community health and wellness, and City Council’s Strategic Plan Vision is “To be a place where everyone thrives,” including Strategic Outcome Areas focused on Climate Action, Recreation, Arts, and Culture, and Partnerships; and WHEREAS, the City has already incorporated biophilic principles in a number of major policy documents and programs including the Comprehensive Plan, the Rivanna River Corridor Plan, the Climate Action Plan, the Development Code, the Parks and Recreation Master Plan, the Urban Forest Management Plan, and the Water Resources Protection Program; and WHEREAS, Charlottesville has a rich and varied diversity of ecosystems that provide benefits to residents, workers, businesses, visitors and the diverse species we share our city and our region with; and WHEREAS, evidence demonstrates that people are happiest, emotionally and physically healthiest, and most productive when working and living in close proximity to nature; and WHEREAS, research suggests that exposure to nature can reduce stress, aid recovery from illness, enhance cognitive skills, improve academic performance, and aid in combatting childhood and adult illnesses; and WHEREAS, in an increasingly urbanized world, it is incumbent upon cities to provide vital natural habitat to plant and animal species that may otherwise perish; and WHEREAS, the concept of “biophilia” refers to the innate connection of humans to the natural world, and therefore “biophilic cities” are those that purposefully design, build, and manage their communities with abundant nature ensuring its residents have opportunities for deep, meaningful connection and engagement with the natural world as part of their daily life; and WHEREAS, the Biophilic Cities Network is a community of biophilic cities from around the world whose leaders recognize the important connection between humans and the natural world and strive to place nature at the core of design and planning and work to create abundant opportunities to learn about and connect with nature; and WHEREAS, a commitment to becoming a Biophilic City will support Charlottesville’s environmental sustainability and community health and wellness goals; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia that we support the principles of the Biophilic Cities Network and commit to collaborating with other participating municipalities, institutions, and organizations to support urban biodiversity and create opportunities for all Charlottesville residents to connect with nature. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that City staff are hereby authorized to submit an application for Charlottesville to join the Biophilic Cities Network. Page 120 of 147 4/7/2025 1 Biophilic CitiesNature + Cities Together Biophilia: “ …the innately emotional affiliation of human beings to other living organisms. Innate means hereditary and hence part of human nature. ” –E.O. Wilson1 2 Page 121 of 147 4/7/2025 2 3 4 Page 122 of 147 4/7/2025 3 5 6 Page 123 of 147 4/7/2025 4 City Comprehensive Plan Priority Area“Keep Charlottesville green, make it greener, and protect the natural environment and the many benefits it provides. ” Chapter 7 (Environment, Climate, and Food Equity)Community Vision Statement“Charlottesville will be an environmental leader, with healthy air, water, and ecosystems, as well as ample, high-quality, and accessible open space and natural areas, and a preserved and enhanced tree canopy. The Rivanna River and other waterbodies will be celebrated and protected, and environmentally-sound community access will be enhanced” .Photo credit: Paul Josey 7 8 Page 124 of 147 4/7/2025 5 Charlottesville & BiophiliaCommitment to a healthy and robust urban forest as well as its network of water resourcesAppreciation for native species and diversityUnderstanding of the role of nature in addressing and responding to the climate crisisNature elements are found in 2,300 acres of parks, school grounds, natural areas, landscape beds, medians/rights of way and urban plazas/streetscapesIntegration of biophilic design in various public projectsBike/pedestrian trail network Community gardens and urban farmsNumerous community-based organizations involved in environmental conservation, restoration, education, engagement, stewardship, inspiration, sustainability, human and environmental well-being, and more. •Partners with a global network of cities, scholars, and advocates to build an understandingof thevalue and contribution of nature in cities to the lives of urban residents.•Facilitates this global network of partner cities working collectively to pursue the vision ofanatureful citywithin their unique and diverse environments and cultures.•Network partners are working in concert toconserve and celebrate nature in all its formsand the many important ways in which cities and theirinhabitants benefit from thebiodiversity and wild urban spacespresent in cities.•Acknowledges theimportance of daily contact with nature as an element of a meaningfulurban life, as well as theethical responsibilitythat cities have toconserve global natureas shared habitatfor non-human life and people. 9 10 Page 125 of 147 4/7/2025 6 •Biophilia Creates Deep & Powerful Connections•Biophilia Benefits Economic Growth•Biophilia Creates Healthier Cities•Biophilia Positively Impacts Education•Biophilic Cities are Happier & More Productive 11 12 Page 126 of 147 4/7/2025 7 Partner Cities (United States)Austin, TXArlington, VALos Angeles, CAKansas City, MSMilwaukee, WIMiami-Dade County, FLPhoenix, AZNorfolk, VAPortland, ORPittsburgh, PAReston, VARaleigh, NCSan Francisco, CARichmond, VAWashington, DCSt. Louis, MO 13 14 Page 127 of 147 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CITY COUNCIL AGENDA Agenda Date: April 21, 2025 Action Required: Informational purposes only. Presenter: Staff Contacts: Katie Lockhart, Deputy Director of Parks Riaan Anthony, Director of Parks & Recreation Robert Mathes, Management Specialist II Landscape Title: 2024 Integrated Pest Management Report Background This written report is a summary of the activities of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia's (City"), landscape Integrated Pest Management ("IPM") Program (adopted by City Council in 2015) performed in calendar year 2024, as well as goals for calendar year 2025. Discussion Alignment with City Council's Vision and Strategic Plan Recreation, Arts, Culture Community Engagement Budgetary Impact Recommendation Receive report as information. Alternatives Attachments 1. 2024 IPM report FINAL COPY 2v2 Page 128 of 147 Charlottesville Parks and Recreation Department Integrated Pest Management Report: 2024 IPM Committee Rob Mathes -- Landscape Manager (IPM Coordinator) Randy Dean – Parks & Rec. Maintenance Specialist III (IPM Program Manager) Riaan Anthony – Parks & Recreation Director Katie Lockhart -- Deputy Director of Parks Kristel Riddervold – Office of Sustainability Director MaKshya Tolbert --Tree Commission Mark Dennison -- Parks and Recreation Advisory Board Page 129 of 147 Introduction Integrated Pest Management (IPM) is a methodology that establishes an effective and environmentally sensitive response to pests (insects, weeds, diseases, other vertebrates) that damage trees, shrubs, and turfgrass. IPM establishes a sustainable approach to managing pests by combining biological, cultural, physical, and if necessary, chemical tools in a way that minimizes health and environmental risks. This report is a summary of the activities of the City of Charlottesville’s landscape Integrated Pest Management (IPM) program adopted by City Council in 2015. An IPM approach to landscape management involves many different methods to ensure the success of landscape plants, but they all begin with inspections and assessments. By monitoring plants over time, and noting any changes, our landscape professionals can make the correct diagnosis of the problem. Maintaining proper soil fertility, soil moisture (irrigation), mulching, mowing, monitoring, and choosing native vegetation are all strategies that help ensure plant health. These are the strategies that Charlottesville Parks & Recreation incorporates into the management of City landscapes, which include over 1,000 acres of grass, flower beds, urban woodlands, and street trees. An effective IPM program requires analysis, planning, and revision. Changes can be made depending on the weather, pest pressure, or other factors. The following summary of activities and initiatives from January – December 2024 will help highlight some of these strategies in detail. Summary of Initiatives in 2024 Staff Training and Continuing Education: Charlottesville Parks division is committed to ongoing training and education, and in 2024, 5 employees completed re- certification classes for their Registered Technician’s license, and 1 employee re-certified as a Commercial Applicator. We also had 2 employees attain their certification as a Registered Technician through the Virginia Department of Agriculture and Consumer Services (VDACS). This requires 20 hours of on-the-job training, as well as 20 hours of studying the Virginia Core Manual, “Applying Pesticides Correctly.” This training includes practical and legal requirements, as well as training on the theory and practice of Integrated Pest Management principles. Staff training and educational events also present important continuing education opportunities. In March, 6 staff members of the horticulture crew attended the Shenandoah Valley Plant Symposium, an all-day seminar geared towards educating landscape professionals. Staff attended lectures given by industry professionals on such topics as “The Big Picture: Regenerating Life, Landscapes, Climate and Living Soils,” and “Specialist Bees,” which focused on the important role of pollinators. Also, in February, the Landscape Manager attended the Piedmont Landscape Association annual seminar in Charlottesville. This was an opportunity to attend lectures and earn continuing education credits for the International Society of Arboriculture. Native Plant Installations It is well known that native plants are the best choice for installing in landscapes, and they provide many benefits to wildlife. Native plants support local ecosystems by providing wildlife food and shelter, conserving water through drought tolerance, preventing soil erosion with deep root systems, and attracting pollinators like bees and butterflies. “Integrated Pest Management (IPM) is a strategy used to manage pests in the landscape by using economically and environmentally sustainable practices … The goal of IPM is not necessarily to eradicate or eliminate pests, but to strengthen and stabilize the landscape so that conditions are favorable for plants but unfavorable for pests.” https://landscapeipm.tamu.edu/ (Texas A&M Extension) Page 130 of 147 By installing and promoting native trees and plants, we can encourage natural resistance and insect predation, thereby reducing the need to apply chemicals. In 2024, Parks & Recreation completed the following native plant installations: • As part of the Urban Forestry unit, 179 native trees (2” diameter) were planted from December 2023 – January 2024. There were also hundreds of native seedlings (small, bare root trees) planted as part of the invasive plant restoration (see Table 1 for details) • In May, the horticulture crew renovated an elevated garden bed located on the Downtown Mall, installing, and replacing dozens of plants with native alternatives^^. This installation was well received by the community, and we hope to add to this garden bed as the budget allows. The site, a raised bed known to have poor drainage, posed challenges, but staff incorporated plants that thrive in shady, wet sites. ^^Video of the project: https://www.instagram.com/cvilleparksandrec/reel/C6g51qbOOXL/ • In October, a new pollinator garden was installed across from the existing garden located at the Butterfly Greenway. The new garden doubled the total size of the pollinator garden and was re-seeded with native grasses, wildflowers, and forbs, which should reach maturity in 2-3 years. The existing garden was also renovated and re-seeded. Located on either side of the Butterfly Greenway trail, these gardens will serve as a host and feeding site for wildlife as well as an educational and demonstration areas for the public. Invasive Plant Control: Parks staff and contractors continued work on suppressing and controlling invasive plants, including many different vines, shrubs, and trees. Several different methods of pest control were utilized, including mechanical, cultural, and chemical. The initial areas of focus in 2023 were Washington Park, Forest Hills Park, Azalea Park, and City-owned land located west of Jordan Park, totally approximately 11 acres. In 2024, this work continued in other areas of the City (nearly 20 acres) and are listed in Table 1. These areas, once cleared of the invasive plants, are then re-planted with either native trees or grasses – sometimes both. Utilizing groundcover and grasses are an example of cultural control for pests, because the dense grass cover helps reduce competition from weeds and unwanted plants. Work sessions involving volunteer and student groups also involved hand cutting and removal of vines. Also, a new community-based invasive plant work group, Charlottesville Invasive Plant Partnership (CHIPP), launched in 2024. The City’s Urban Forester and the Office of Sustainability were involved in this partnership with area non-profits to help educate the public on invasive plants and provide resources to encourage them to remove invasive plants on private property. CHIPP’s aim is to seek partnerships with community organizations for the mobilization of community-driven efforts for the treatment of invasive vines, with the long-term goal to protect and improve tree canopy. Invasive Plant Projects 2024 Property/Park # Acres Treatment # Seedling/Saplings Projected for Planting Free Bridge 1.8 Forestry mulcher 210 native tree saplings Quarry Park – Rivanna Trail 1.7 Forestry mulcher 400 native tree saplings John Warner Parkway 2.5 Forestry mulcher Re-seeded with groundcover Oakwood Cemetery .75 Forestry Mulcher; Hand cutting Re-seeded with groundcover Agnese/Park Street 3.9 Hand cutting and herbicide Applications None (wooded area) Butterfly Greenway area 12 Forestry mulcher & hand cutting Tree saplings planned for 2025 Table 1. List of invasive plant control sites in 2024. Page 131 of 147 Invasive plant removal near Oakwood Cemetery. (May 2024) Education and work session with school group (February 2024) Downtown Mall Trees The trees on the downtown mall remain a key part of the landscape and character of the mall and the City. In January 2024, the oaks were pruned to remove dead, diseased, and/or broken branches, and 1 oak was removed. As part of the data gathering for a detailed tree management plan for the trees on the Downtown Mall, specialists from Wolf-Josey Landscape Architects and Pitchford Associates Arboriculture performed high level testing on the trees. They gathered samples to assess soil fertility, inspected each tree for health and safety issues, and performed a safety analysis on several trees. Their plan, finalized in November 2024 (“Charlottesville Downtown Mall Tree Management Plan” ^), offers detail into site conditions and species selection for the next generation of trees on the mall. One of their key recommendations is to increase the species diversity on the mall and moving away from the monoculture of willow oaks. By selecting the right tree for the right site, and properly assessing site conditions, we can help ensure that the trees planted there are successful and healthy. ^ Downtown Mall Tree Management Plan: https://www.charlottesville.gov/1864/Downtown-Mall-Tree-Management-Plan Emerald Ash Borer In 2021 and 2022, researchers from the USDA Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service released beneficial wasps at the Heyward Community Forest. These insects can parasitize the eggs of emerald ash borers, which is a well-known destructive pest to ash trees. In October of 2024, they returned to gather samples from trees to evaluate the efficacy, and we are still waiting for the results. The results from sampling done in 2023 were inconclusive, but we will continue to partner with organizations like the USDA to utilize City resources to help explore biological solutions for pests like the emerald ash borer. As the ash trees continue to die off, we should expect that the only ash trees to survive are those that continue to be treated against the insect. To help protect prominent City-owned trees, Parks oversaw the injection of 34 ash trees throughout the City to suppress the beetle larvae. Nutrient Management Plan Parks division received confirmation from the Virginia Department of Conservation and Recreation that the Nutrient Management Plan we had written in late fall 2023 was officially accepted on March 1, 2024 (it expires January 1, 2027.) A nutrient management plan, written by a certified nutrient planner, is required in Virginia for publicly owned land that Page 132 of 147 is part of a Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4). The plan involves extensive soil testing for the sites (athletic fields, school fields, parks) and it develops recommendations for precise nutrient applications. This help reduce over- application of nutrients which can have negative impacts on water quality, both locally and in other downstream waterways, including the Chesapeake Bay. Pesticide Application Records In accordance with State laws and the City’s IPM policy, pesticide records were kept for each application made by Parks staff. Pest Scouting, Monitoring, and Identification: Key components of IPM are the inspections of plant material and the proper identification of pests. By properly identifying the pest, landscape staff can take the appropriate actions. As an example, in the summer of 2024, Parks staff received a report of swarming wasps at a City elementary school. School staff were requesting that the wasps, which were hovering low to the ground near the playground, be treated with an insecticide. Upon close inspection, however, we determined that the insects were blue-winged wasps, which are a beneficial insect (they feed on Japanese beetle grubs), and not harmful to people. Staff informed the school of this, and no treatment action was made. This is just one example of a situation that happens throughout the growing season. Deer Management In 2017 Charlottesville City Council passed a resolution to implement a program to manage the deer population within the City of Charlottesville. City Council approved the program in response to complaints about hazardous driving conditions, health concerns stemming from Lyme disease, landscapes being impacted by an overabundant deer population, and the health of the local herd. Deer culling is performed by a contracted service, in cooperation with the contract administrator from Parks and Rec, Charlottesville Police Department, and the Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources. In 2024, a total of 57 deer were harvested and processed, which yielded 1,575 pounds of venison donated to a local food bank. Urban Forest Management Plan In late 2024, the City finalized a contract to have Eocene Environmental Group create a new urban forest management plan. This will be a comprehensive assessment of the urban forest and will survey the health of the forest through a canopy assessment as well as an on-the-ground data collection. This plan will document the condition and the quality of the urban forest and will be a useful tool in the future for making tree planting decisions, tree pruning and removal plans, and invasive plant removal planning. The work is getting underway in January of 2025, and is expected to be completed in the fall of 2026. Summary The Parks and Recreation Department strives to be proactive rather than reactive in the implementation of IPM methods. This report demonstrates that the City’s commitment to maintain healthy, attractive, and productive landscapes is done in an environmentally responsible manner. We look forward to improving our program each year through education, collaboration, and training. The City will continue to cooperate with other organizations in the area, such as Charlottesville Area Tree Stewards (C.A.T.S.), the Virginia Cooperative Extension, USDA, & Tree Commission and are open to further collaboration. Other objectives and plans for 2025 are listed in the section below. Page 133 of 147 Objectives and Plans for 2025 • Maintain a well-educated, trained, and informed staff (e.g. professional development, continuing education). Goal for 2025: have more staff members achieve “Commercial Pesticide Applicator” license. • Watering, mulching, and practicing “right plant, right place.” The best defense against pests is keeping our plants healthy. • Continue to utilize a variety of methods for invasive plant control (e.g., goats, community-based approach). • Converting more annual flower beds to perennial beds. This will help reduce the amount of watering needed and it also presents an opportunity to introduce more native plants. An important side benefit of this is that less hand watering also reduces the staff exposure in high automobile traffic areas. • Other insects or diseases to look out for: o Beech leaf disease: This is disease, found mostly in the northeast U.S, is a complex of a disease and nematode (microscopic worm) that begins by infecting beech leaves, which slowly progresses into leaf mortality. It is still not widely known what the potential effects of this disease are. o Boxwood: box tree moth, boxwood blight. 2024 Photo Gallery: Butterfly Greenway pollinator garden installation (October 2024) Page 134 of 147 Native plant installation downtown (May 2024) Soil sampling on the Downtown Mall Page 135 of 147 Specialized testing to assess tree health . Bagworms at Jenkins Park: removed by hand Spotted lanternfly nymph. Sent in by C.A.T.S. Applying mulch to help suppress weeds Page 136 of 147 Date (mm/dd/yy) Time (total staff hours) Applicator Name License # General Location Type Detailed Location (for"multiple locations," put details in notes) Product Trade Name Active Ingr edient Epa Reg. # Signal Word Product Type Application equipment Mix Rate Unit 1 per _____ Total amount of mix applied Unit 2 Total volume of concent rate applied Unit Area (sq ft.) treated # of plants treated Area (acres) treated Pests Treated Treatment Notes 03/12/24 3.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 250 Bypass Prodiamine 4L Prodiamine 53883-379 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 1.00 oz. gallon 80 gal. 80 oz. 80,000 1.837 Broadleaf weeds/grasses Long st. liriope medians, Linear beds 03/13/24 8.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 250 Bypass Prodiamine 4L Prodiamine 53883-379 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 1.00 oz. gallon 180 gal. 180 oz. 180,000 4.132 Broadleaf weeds/grasses Linear beds along 250, located west of the fire station 03/14/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW DT Mall Prodiamine 4L Prodiamine 53883-379 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 1.00 oz. gallon 62 gal. 62 oz. 60,000 1.377 Broadleaf weeds/grasses Omni Beds 03/18/24 8.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 250 Bypass Prodiamine 4L Prodiamine 53883-379 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 1.00 oz. gallon 150 gal. 150 oz. 150,000 3.444 Broadleaf weeds/grasses Park St. Ramps, 5th st. euonymus banks 03/19/24 8.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Prodiamine 4L Prodiamine 53883-379 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 1.00 oz. gallon 200 gal. 200 oz. 200,000 4.591 Broadleaf weeds/grasses Jefferson bank, Preston ave. shrub banks, Beck's hill island, Estes parking lot, greenway banks @rescue , McGuffey park banks 03/26/24 10.0 William Atwell 101629G Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 2.00 oz. gallon 39 gal. 78 oz. 3500 0.080 broadleaf weeds Meade Park, Rives Park, Quarry Park, Pen Park 04/09/24 6.0 William Atwell 101629G Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 4.00 oz. gallon 27 gal. 108 oz. 3000 0.069 broadleaf weeds Washington Park, Emmet Street, McIntire Park, John Warner Parkway, 250 Bypass Guardrail (skatepark) 04/10/24 1.5 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Azalea Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gal lon 1.5 gal. 3 oz. 1500 0.034 weeds All landscaped areas 04/11/24 2.5 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 5th Street Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2. 5g a l . 5 oz. 2500 0.057 weeds Landscpaped area at corner of 5th and Harris St 04/12/24 0.3 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2. 00 oz. gallon 0.25 gal. 0.5 oz. 250 0.006 weeds Landscapeed areas and sidewalk/curbs of Frye Springs raingarden on Old Lynchburg Road 04/15/24 0.3 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T ROW 5th Street Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. ga llon 0.25 gal. 0.5 oz. 250 0.006 Weeds 5th and Harris bed 04/16/24 6.0 William Atwell 101629G ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 4.00 oz. gallon 30 gal. 120 oz. 4000 0.092 broadleaf weeds 5th st., East Water st., 04/16/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T ROW 5th Street Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. ga llon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 Weeds 5th St Euonymus banks 04/17/24 0.5 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Buildlings Crow Recreation Center Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 0.5 gal. 1 oz. 500 0.011 Weeds Crow Pool parking, sidewalks, landscaping 04/18/24 13.0 William Atwell 101629G Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 4.00 oz. gallon 45 gal. 180 oz. 6000 0.138 broadleaf weeds McGuffey Park, Tonsler Park, Forest Hills Park, Azalea Park, Jenkins Park 04/18/24 1.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Tonsler Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. ga llon 1 gal. 2 oz. 500 0.011 Weeds All landscaped areas 04/19/24 3.0 Randy Dean 106161G Buildlings Smith Aquatic Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz . gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 Weeds Onesty pool landscaped areas 04/22/24 8.5 Randy Dean 106161G Park Washington Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 8.5 gal. 17 oz. 8500 0.195 Weeds All landscaped areas and steps 04/26/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Jenkins Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gal lon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 Weeds Sidewalks and all landscaped areas 04/26/24 1.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Belmont Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. ga llon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 Weeds All landscaped areas 04/29/24 3.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Rives Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 gal .6 oz. 3000 0.069 Weeds All landscaped areas 04/30/24 10.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T ROW Meadowcreek Parkwa y Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 14 gal. 28 oz. 14000 0.321 weeds, invasives roadside, beds in front of Rescue Squad, Schenks Greenway additional applicator: Randy Dean 05/20/24 6.0 Ben Schiner 168952T School CHS Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 18 gal. 36 oz. 18000 0.413 weeds Ball field fences 05/21/24 3.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park McGuffey Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. g allon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds All landscaped areas 05/21/24 3.0 Theo Teichman 168825 T ROW 250 Bypass Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gall on 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds All landscaped areas 05/21/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Forest H ills Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds All landscaped areas 05/21/24 1.5 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Tonsler Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. ga llon 1.5 gal. 3 oz. 1500 0.034 Weeds Sidewalks and all landscaped areas 05/22/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Court Square Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallo n 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds Sidewalks and all landscaped areas 05/22/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Market St. Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds Sidewalks and all landscaped areas 05/22/24 0.5 Randy Dean 106161G Park Starr H ill Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 0.5 gal. 0.5 oz. 250 0.006 weeds All landscaped areas 05/23/24 0.5 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Riverview Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 0.5 gal. 1 oz. 500 0.011 weeds playground 05/28/24 3.5 Randy Dean 106161G Park McIntire Park West Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz . gallon 7 gal. 14 oz. 7000 0.161 weeds parking lot cracks, sidewalks, and landscaped areas 05/28/24 1.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Washington Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1g a l .2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds parking lot cracks 05/29/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G Buildlings Jefferson Center Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2.5 gal. 5 oz. 2500 0.057 weeds bottom of back bank close to windows 05/29/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Buildlings Jefferson Center Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backp ack 2.00 oz. gallon 4.5 gal. 9 oz. 4500 0.103 weeds Sidewalks and all landscaped areas 05/30/24 1.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Buildlings City Hall Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds parking lot cracks, sidewalks and curbs 05/30/24 2.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Buildlings City Hall Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds All landscpaed areas 05/30/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G Buildlings City Hall Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2 gal. 1.8 gram 2000 0.046 yellow nutsedge All landscaped areas 06/03/24 8.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Greenleaf Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 6g a l . 1 2 oz. 6000 0.138 weeds All playgrounds- Greenleaf, Washington, Rives, Meade, Belmont 06/03/24 3.0 Theo Teichman 168825 T ROW Preston Ave Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 3.00 oz. gal lon 3 gal. 9 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds shrub banks, sidewalks 06/03/24 3.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Tonsler Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2.5 gal. 2.25 gram 2250 0.052 yellow nutsedge 06/03/24 3.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Greenleaf Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2.5 gal. 2.25 gram 2500 0.057 yellow nutsedge All playgrounds- Greenleaf, Washington, Rives, Meade, Belmont 06/04/24 6.0 Theo Teichman 168825 T ROW cintire Road/Ridge Str e Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 3.00 oz. gallon 6 gal. 18 oz. 6000 0.138 weeds All landscaped areas at Schenks greenway PESTICIDE RECORDS 2024 CHOOSE ONE Page 137 of 147 06/04/24 8.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz . gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds Tonsler, Azalea, Belmont 06/04/24 6.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Multiple locations Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2 gal. 1.8 gram 2000 0.046 yellow nutsedge Tonsler, Azalea, Belmont 06/04/24 6.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Multiple locations Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2 gal. 1.8 gram 2000 0.046 yellow nutsedge Tonsler, Azalea, Belmont 06/04/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Preston Ave Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 0.5 gal. 0.45 gram 500 0.011 yellow nutsedge schenks, McIntire/Preston, Park st. bumpouts 06/06/24 12.0 William Atwell 101629G Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 2.00 oz. gallon 56 gal. 168 oz. 7500 0.172 weeds , Tonsler, Forest Hills, Fifeville, , Jenkins, Washington, , Pen Park 06/06/24 1.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. ga llon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds CBDG landscaped areas 06/06/24 0.5 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T ROW Other (see notes) Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 0.5 gal. 0.45 gram 500 0.011 yellow nutsedge CBDG landscaped areas 06/10/24 1.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School Burnley -Moran Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 4000 0.092 weeds parking lot cracks 06/10/24 10.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School Burnley -Moran Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 3. 00 oz. gallon 11 gal. 33 oz. 11000 0.253 weeds walkways, sidewalks, tree rings, beds, additional applicators: Matt Williams, Theo Teichman 06/10/24 1.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 250 Bypass Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 1.5 gal. 1.35 gram 1500 0.034 yellow nutsedge Park St. ramps 06/11/24 8.0 Ronnie Duty 97506G School CHS Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 59 gal. 118 oz. 59000 1.354 weeds parking lot cracks, sidewalks, and landscaped areas 06/11/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 250 Bypass Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 g al. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds park st. ramps 06/11/24 1.0 Randy Dean 106161G Buildlings Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2. 00 oz. gallon 2.5 gal. 5 oz. 2500 0.057 weeds Parks office/lot 1300 Pen Park Rd. Charlottesville VA 22901 06/12/24 5.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 250 Bypass Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 7 g al. 14 oz. 7000 0.161 weeds park st. ramps 06/12/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Vietnam Memorial Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2 .00 oz. gallon 2.5 gal. 5 oz. 2500 0.057 weeds All landscaped areas 06/13/24 5.5 William Atwell 101629G ROW 250 Bypass Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 3.00 oz. gallon 23 gal. 69 oz. 4500 0.103 weeds 250 bypass guardrails 06/13/24 5.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School Walker Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gal lon 5.5 gal. 11 oz. 5500 0.126 weeds Sidewalks and all landscaped areas 06/14/24 10.0 William Atwell 101629G ROW 250 Bypass Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 3.00 oz. gallon 73 gal. 219 oz. 10000 0.230 weeds 250 bypass guardrails, cracks and curbs 06/14/24 3.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Park Jenkins Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gall on 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds all landscaped areas 06/14/24 1.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T School Lugo-McGinnis Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.0 0 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds parking lot, fenced areas, all landcaped area 06/14/24 1.0 Ronnie Duty 97506G School Clark Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal .2 oz. 1000 0.023 Poison Ivy chain link fence along east side of playground 06/14/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Jenkins Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2.5 gal. 2.25 gram 2250 0.052 yellow nutsedge all landscaped areas 06/20/24 6.0 William Atwell 101629G ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 3.00 oz. gallon 30 gal. 90 oz. 5000 0.115 weeds 250 bypass, John Warner guardrails,Ridge st. medians,Emmet st. guardrails (also used banish #10088-118-68562 at 3 oz. per gallon. 30 gallons 06/20/24 8.0 Randy Dean 106161G School Venable Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 5. 5g a l .1 1 oz. 5500 0.126 weeds all landscaped areas 06/20/24 2.0 William Atwell 101629G Park Pen Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 3.00 oz. gallon 5 gal. 15 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds Pen Park (also used Banish #10088-118-68562 @ 3 oz. per gallon. 5 gallons) 06/20/24 2.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School Venable Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gal lon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds beds, playground 06/20/24 1.0 Randy Dean 106161G School Venable Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 0.5 gal. 0.45 gram 500 0.011 yellow nutsedge all landscaped areas 06/21/24 1.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School Walker Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1.5 gal. 3 oz. 1500 0.034 weeds parkinglot and curbs only 06/21/24 1.5 Steve Gaines 163426T Cemetery Oakwood Glyphosate 5.4 Glyphosate 53.8% 81927-8 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.60 oz. gallon 7 gal. 18.7 oz. 21000 0.482 weeds Vacant Lot - at NW corner of Oakwood Cemetery 06/21/24 1.5 Steve Gaines 163426T ROW Other (see notes) Glyphosate 5.4 Glyphosate 53.8% 81927-8 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.60 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2.6 oz. 21000 0.482 weeds Northbound lane of Park St. near Melbourne Rd. 06/21/24 1.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School CHS Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 0.5 gal. 0.45 gram 100 0.002 nutsedge Sedgehamer: beds, curbs 06/21/24 1.5 Steve Gaines 163426T Cemetery Oakwood Triclopyr 4 Ester Triclopyr 61.6% 10404-119 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.60 oz. gallon 7 gal. 18.7 oz. 21000 0.482 weeds Vacant Lot - at northwest corner of Oakwood Cemetery 06/21/24 1.5 Steve Gaines 163426T ROW Other (see notes) Triclopyr 4 Ester Triclopyr 61.6% 10404-119 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.60 oz. gall on 1 gal. 2.6 oz. 21000 0.482 weeds Northbound lane of Park St. near Melbourne Rd. 06/25/24 3.5 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School Clark Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallo n 7 gal. 14 oz. 14000 0.321 weeds in landscape Locations: Clark Elementary, additional applicators: Matt Williams 06/25/24 3.0 Theo Teichman 168825 T School Johnson Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gal lon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds all landscaped areas 06/26/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T School Johnson Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds All hardscaping (sidewalks, curbs) 06/26/24 8.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T School Johnson Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. g allon 6 gal. 12 oz. 6000 0.138 weeds all landscaped areas 06/27/24 4.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T School Buford Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 4 gal. 8 oz. 4000 0.092 weeds all hardscaping (sidewalks, curbs) 06/27/24 3.0 Theo Teichman 168825 T School Greenbrier Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds All hardscaping 06/27/24 4.0 Theo Teichman 168825 T School Greenbrier Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 3.00 oz. g allon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds All landscpaed areas 06/28/24 6.0 Randy Dean 106161G School Greenbrier Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 8g a l . 1 6 oz. 8000 0.184 weeds All landscaped areas and track 07/02/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T ROW 250 Bypass Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds All hardscaping 07/08/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Multiple locations Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds Forest hills Azalea, Tonsler, Rives, * Frye Springs rain garden 07/08/24 8.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz . gallon 7.5 gal. 15 oz. 7500 0.172 weeds Forest hills, Azalea, Tonsler, Rives, Frye springs raingarden 07/08/24 1.0 Ronnie Duty 97506G Park McGuffey Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds Sidewalks and all landscaped areas 07/08/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Multiple locations Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0 .90 gra m gallon 1.75 gal. 1.9 gram 1750 0.040 yellow nutsedge Forest hills, Azalea, Tonsler, Rives, Frye springs raingarden 07/10/24 1.0 Ben Schiner 168952T Park Multiple locations Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1.5 gal. 3 oz. 1500 0.034 weeds Hardscapes Jenkins, Quarry, Jordan, Belmont Page 138 of 147 07/10/24 24.0 Ben Schiner 168952T Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 8 gal. 16 oz. 8000 0.184 weeds Jenkins, Quarry, Jordan, Belmont 07/10/24 3.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Multiple locations Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 3 gal. 2.7 gram 3000 0.069 Yellow Nutsedge Jenkins, Quarry, Jordan, Belmont 07/11/24 1.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Greenleaf Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal. 1 oz. 500 0.011 weeds sprayed all hardscaping 07/11/24 4.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Greenleaf Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 4.5 gal. 5 oz. 4000 0.092 weeds Sprayed all landscaped areas, trail 07/16/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T School CHS Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds sprayed all hardscaping 07/16/24 4.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School CHS Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 3.00 oz. gallon 25 gal. 75 oz. 25000 0.574 weeds curbs, parking lots additional applicator: Matt Williams 07/16/24 6.0 Randy Dean 106161G School CHS Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds sprayed all landscaped areas 07/17/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds Schenks greenway, Park st. Bumpouts, 5th/Bailey 07/17/24 16.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. g allon 7.5 gal. 15 oz. 7500 0.172 weeds Park st bumpouts, Schenks greenway, 5th st/Bailey 07/17/24 4.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T ROW cintire Road/Ridge Str e Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 5 gal. 10 oz. 5000 0.115 weeds in landscape rescue squad beds and parking lot, roadside. 07/17/24 1.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Park Forest H ills Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2 gal. 1.8 gram 2000 0.046 nutsedge Sedgehammer: beds and curbs Additional Applicator: Ben Schiner 07/17/24 4.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T ROW Other (see notes) Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 1.5 gal. 1.35 gram 1500 0.034 Yellow Nutsedge Schenks greenway, Park st. Bumpouts, 5th/Bailey 07/18/24 6.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2. 00 oz. gallon 7 gal. 14 oz. 7000 0.161 weeds Schenks greenway, Park st. Bumpouts, 5th/Bailey 07/23/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Fusilade II Fluazifop-P-butyl 100-1084 Danger herbicide Backpack 0.60 oz. gallon 2.5 g al. 1.5 oz. 2500 0.057 bermuda grass/unwanted park st bumpouts 07/23/24 0.5 Matt Williams 104699T ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds CBDG 07/23/24 1.5 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. ga llon 2.5 gal. 5 oz. 2500 0.057 weeds park st bumpouts 07/23/24 1.0 Matt Williams 104699T ROW Other (see notes) Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2 gal. 1.8 gram 2000 0.046 Yellow Nutsedge OAKHURST 07/23/24 0.5 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 0.25 gal. 0.225 gram 250 0.006 Yellow Nutsedge park st bumpouts 07/29/24 1.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T School CHS Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1g a l .2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds All landscaped areas 07/30/24 0.3 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School Johnson Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 0.5 gal. 0.45 gram 500 0.011 nutsedge landscape beds 08/05/24 4.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School Jackson-Via Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 4000 0.092 weeds hardscapes, Jackson Via and Jefferson 08/05/24 4.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T School Jackson-Via Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz . gallon 5.5 gal. 11 oz. 5500 0.126 weeds beds, Jackson Via, Jefferson. other applicators: Randy Dean, Ronnie Duty 08/11/24 8.0 Matt Williams 104699T Park Forest H ills Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 4 gal. 8 oz. 4000 0.092 weeds Forest hills park landscape beds and Pen Park tennis courts 08/13/24 12.0 Ronnie Duty 97506G Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 2.00 oz. gallon 35 gal. 70 oz. 35000 0.803 WEEDS washington park, forrest hills park, Preston ave/shrub banks / Matt, Ronnie 08/13/24 0.5 Ben Schiner 168952T Buildlings Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2 .00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 WEEDS GREENHOUSE LOT at 1300 Pen Park Rd. Charlottesv ille VA 08/14/24 12.0 Matt Williams 104699T Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 45 gal. 90 oz. 45000 1.033 weeds Azaleea, McIntire, Tonsler, Pen park…Ronnie/Matt 08/14/24 10.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 5 gal. 10 oz. 5000 0.115 weeds Mguffey Park, McIntire Park / Kathleen, Ben Keith 08/14/24 5.0 Ben Schiner 168952T Park Multiple locations Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2.5 gal. 2.7 gram 2500 0.057 Yellow Nutsedge Mguffey Park, McIntire Park / Kathleen, Ben Keith 08/15/24 2.0 Matt Williams 104699T Buildlings Multiple Locations Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1.5 gal. 3 oz. 1500 0.034 weeds all hardscape area 08/15/24 7.0 Matt Williams 104699T Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 5 gal. 10 oz. 5000 0.115 weeds Smith Pool, Star hill- all landscaped areas / Keith, Kathleen, Ben, Matt 08/15/24 3.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Buildlings Multiple Locations Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backp ack 0.90 gra m gallon 1 gal. 0.9 gram 1000 0.023 Yellow Nutsedge Smith Pool, Star hill- all landscaped areas / Keith, Kathleen, Ben, Matt 08/21/24 6.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Buildlings Multiple Locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Back pack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds City Hall, Annex, Transit, McGuffey arr center 08/21/24 8.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Buildlings Multiple Locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Back pack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds areas treated City Hall, Anex, Transit, McGuffy Art Center additional applicators Ben Schiner, Keith, Carolyn 08/26/24 0.3 Matt Williams 104699T Buildlings Smith Aquatic Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds ac unit 08/26/24 6.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 5th Street Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 4 g al. 8 oz. 4000 0.092 weeds 5th/Harris, 5th/Bailey, 5th/Ridge, Euonymus banks, 5th sign bed- Keith, Randy, Matt 08/26/24 0.5 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 5th Street Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 0.5 gal. 0.45 gram 500 0.011 Yellow Nutsedge 5th/Harris, 5th/Bailey, 5th/Ridge, Euonymus banks, 5th sign bed- Keith, Randy, Matt 08/27/24 1.0 Ronnie Duty 97506G Park Multiple locations Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1.5 gal. 3 oz. 1500 0.034 weeds Hardscaping at Belmont park and Spring/Cherry 08/27/24 6.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 7 gal. 14 oz. 7000 0.161 weeds Court Sq, Jenkins, Belmont 08/27/24 1.5 Randy Dean 106161G Park Multiple locations Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 1.5 gal. 1.35 gram 1500 0.034 Yellow Nutsedge Court Sq, Jenkins, Belmont 08/28/24 2.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Multiple locations Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds Hardscapes at Rives, Meade and Venable school 08/28/24 2.0 Matt Williams 104699T School Venable Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 0.5 gal. 0.45 gram 500 0.011 Yellow Nutsedge Venable and Rives, Meade Park 08/29/24 1.0 Matt Williams 104699T Park Fifev ille Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 0.5 gal. 1 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds 09/04/24 1.0 Ronnie Duty 97506G ROW Other (see notes) Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds in curbs Park Street Ramps-Curbs only 09/04/24 1.0 Ronnie Duty 97506G ROW Other (see notes) Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds in curbs Park Street Ramps-Curbs only 09/04/24 24.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. g allon 12.5 gal. 25 oz. 12500 0.287 weeds areas treated Vietnam memorial, park st ramps other applicators Matt, Ben, Kathleen, Keith, Ronnie 09/04/24 2.5 Kathleen Guevara 163519T ROW Other (see notes) Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2.5 gal. 2.25 gram 2500 0.057 weeds areas treated Vietnam memorial, park st ramps other applicators Matt, Ben, Randy,Keith, Ronnie 09/05/24 2.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. ga llon 1.5 gal. 3 oz. 1500 0.034 weeds Estes St., Parking lot other applicators: Ben, Matt Page 139 of 147 09/06/24 13.0 William Atwell 101629G ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 4.00 oz. gallon 52 gal. 208 oz. 5000 0.115 weeds 5th st guardrails, 250 bypass guardrails 09/10/24 1.5 Matt Williams 104699T ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2 gal. 4 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds Craw Memorial Gardens, ///Keith, Matt 09/11/24 6.0 Ronnie Duty 97506G Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz . gallon 2 gal. 8 oz. 2000 0.046 weeds , Rives Park, McGuffey park, McIntire Park: Ronnie, Randy, Kathleen, Keith, Matt 09/11/24 1.0 Matt Williams 104699T Park Multiple locations Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 9.00 gra m gallon 1 gal. 0.9 gram 1000 0.023 weeds Rives Park, McGuffy Park additional applicators Kathleen 09/12/24 1.0 Matt Williams 104699T Park Azalea Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 1 gal. 0.9 gram 1000 0.023 yellow nutsedge 09/13/24 4.0 Keith Cecchinelli 167723T Park Meade Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gall on 5 gal. 10 oz. 5000 0.115 weeds Azalea park, Meade Park: Matt Williams, Keith Cecchinelli, Kathleen Guevara, Randy Dean 09/16/24 1.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW Other (see notes) Fusilade II Fluazifop-P-butyl 100-1084 Danger herbicide Backpack 0.50 oz. gallon 1.25 gal. 0.625 oz. 1250 0.029 unwanted grasses cbdg, Alderman Rd. islands 09/16/24 2.5 Ben Schiner 168952T Multiple Locations Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 2.5 gal. 5 oz. 2500 0.057 weeds Alderman Islands, cbdg, Greenleaf park, 09/16/24 1.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Park Greenleaf Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 2 gal. 1.8 gram 2000 0.046 yellow nutsedge Greenleaf Park, 09/19/24 2.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Park Market St. Eco-mazapyr 2 SL Isopropylamine salt of Imazapyr 27.8% 81927-22 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds in sidewalks market Street, 09/20/24 1.0 Ben Schiner 168952T Park Tonsler Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1 gal. 2 oz. 1000 0.023 weeds Tennis courts and fencing....Ben and Matt 09/20/24 0.5 Ronnie Duty 97506G Park Azalea Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 1 gal. 0.9 gram 1000 0.023 Yellow nutsedge 09/23/24 1.0 Randy Dean 106161G ROW 250 Bypass Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 1. 5g a l . 3 oz. 1500 0.034 weeds Linear banks and locust Ave. 10/07/24 6.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Row Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.0 0 oz. gallon 7.5 gal. 15 oz. 150000 3.444 Weeds Schenks Greenway and park street ramps, additional applicators Ben and Randy 10/07/24 6.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T ROW Other (see notes) Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 1 gal. 0.9 gram 1000 0.023 nutsedge Schenks Greenway and park street ramps. additional applicators Ben and Randy. 10/08/24 3.0 Matt Williams 104699T Row Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 5 gal. 10 oz. 5000 0.115 weeds Mcintire Front Bed, Schenks rescue additional applicators Kathleen, Ben, Randy and Keith 10/10/24 3.0 Ben Schiner 168952T Park Forest H ills Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 3 gal. 6 oz. 3000 0.069 weeds Ben, Randy, Kathleen.... Forest hills park beds 10/10/24 0.5 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Park Forest H ills Sedgehammer Halosulfuron-methyl 81880-1-10163 Caution herbicide Backpack 0.90 gra m gallon 0.3 gal. 0.27 gram 200 0.005 yellow nutsedge Kathleen and Ben... Forest hills park 10/11/24 2.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.0 0 oz. gallon 6.5 gal. 13 oz. 6500 0.149 weeds Kathleen and Randy...butterfly garden @ Melbourne/JWP 10/18/24 7.0 William Atwell 101629G ROW Other (see notes) Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Hydraulic sprayer 4.00 oz. gallon 33 gal. 132 oz. 4500 0.103 weeds East water St. walk 10/30/24 5.0 Matt Williams 104699T ROW 5th Street Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 6 gal. 12 oz. 12000 0.275 weeds Randy, Keith, Kathleen, Ben, Matt...Cro w, 5th/Bailey, 5th/Harris, 5th/Ridge, 5th Entry 11/18/24 3.0 Kathleen Guevara 163519T Park Greenleaf Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. g allon 4 gal. 8 oz. 4000 0.092 weeds Kathleen, Randy, Matt...Greenleaf Park, McIntire Sign bed, Jenkins Park 11/19/24 8.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Multiple locations Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz . gallon 11.5 gal. 23 oz. 11500 0.264 weeds Randy, Keith, Kathleen, Matt....Market St. park, Tonsler park, Washington Park, Star hill park...Estes st parking lot/bed, Garret st beds 11/26/24 3.0 Randy Dean 106161G Park Azalea Prosecutor Pro Glyphosate-N 41.0% 524-536-10404 Caution herbicide Backpack 2.00 oz. gallon 5 ga l. 10 oz. 5000 0.115 weeds Randy and Keith....Azalea park, Washington park Page 140 of 147 Place Name Nickname Street Address City State Zip Azalea Park 304 Old Lynchburg Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Market Street Park 101 E Market Street Charlottesville VA 22902 Bailey Park 990 Hillcrest Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Belmont Par k 725 Stonehenge Avenue Charlottesville VA 22902 Fifeville Park 1200 King Street Charlottesville VA 22903 Forest Hills Park 1022 Forest Hills Avenue Charlottesville VA 22903 Greenbrier Park 1933 Greenbrier Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Greenleaf Par k 1598 Rose Hill Drive Charlottesville VA 22903 Hartmans Mill 2100 Avon Court (behind Edgecomb A Charlottesville VA 22902 Heyward Community Forest 1760 Reservoir Road Charlottesville VA 22902 Jordan Park 1607 6th Street SE Charlottesville VA 22902 Court Square Park 405 E High Street Charlottesville VA 22902 McGuffey Park 321 2nd Street NW Charlottesville VA 22902 McIntire Park East 345 250 Bypass Charlottesville VA 22902 McIntire Park West 151 McIntire Park Drive Charlottesville VA 22902 Meade Park 300 Meade Avenue Charlottesville VA 22902 Meadow Creek East 1031 Holmes Avenu e Charlottesville VA 22901 Meadow Creek Park 2030 Morton Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Michie Drive 2100 Michie Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Northeast Park 1001 Sheridan Avenu e Charlottesville VA 22901 Pen Park 1300 Pen Park Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Quarry Park 420 Quarry Road Charlottesville VA 22902 Ragged Mountain Natural Area 1730 Reservoir Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Riverview Par k 284 Riverside Avenue Charlottesville VA 22902 Rives Park 926 Rives Stree t Charlottesville VA 22902 Schenks Greenway 711 McIntire Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Starr Hill Par k 7th Street NW & Elsom Street Charlottesville VA 22903 Tonsler Park 500 Cherry Avenue Charlottesville VA 22903 Washington Park 1001 Preston Avenue Charlottesville VA 22902 Burnley-Moran Elementary School 1300 Long Street Charlottesville VA 22901 Clark Elementary School 1000 Belmont Avenu e Charlottesville VA 22902 Greenbrier Elementary School 2228 Greenbrier Drive Charlottesville VA 22901 Jackson-Via Elementary School 508 Harris Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Johnson Elementary School 1645 Cherry Avenue Charlottesville VA 22903 Venable Elementary School 406 14th Street NW Charlottesville VA 22903 Buford Middle School 617 9th Street SW Charlottesville VA 22903 Walker Upper Elementary School 1564 Dairy Road Charlottesville VA 22903 Lugo-McGinnis Academ y 341 11th St. NW Charlottesville VA 22903 Charlottesville High School 1400 Melbourne Road Charlottesville VA 22901 Carver Rec Cente r 233 4th St. NW Charlottesville VA 22902 Oakwood Cemetery 721 1st St. S Charlottesville VA 22902 area located across from 402 Monticello Rd. CDBG 407 Monticello Rd. Charlottesville VA 22902 Charlottesville City Hall 605 E. Main St Charlottesville VA 22902 Charlottesville City Hall Anne x Annex 120 7th St. NE Charlottesville VA 22902 Charlottesville Downtown Transit Center Transit 120 7th St. NE Charlottesville VA 22902 "Alderman Islands" 400 Alderman Rd. Charlottesville VA 22901 Parks and School Addresses Page 141 of 147 RIVANNA SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY RIVANNA WATER & SEWER AUTHORITY RIVANNA SOLID WASTE AUTHORITY RIVANNA WATER & SEWER AUTHORITY 434.977.2970 434.293.8858 www.rivanna.org 695 Moores Creek Lane Charlottesville, Virginia 22902-9016 April 1, 2025 The Honorable Charlottesville City Council P.O. Box 911 Charlottesville, VA 22902 Re: Quarterly Update – April Councilors: This quarterly update is to provide general information on the drinking water supply and treatment, wastewater collection and treatment, and refuse disposal and recycling programs managed by the Rivanna Authorities for the benefit of the Charlottesville/Albemarle community, as follows: 1. Drinking Water Supply: a. Our Urban reservoirs (Sugar Hollow, South Rivanna, Ragged Mountain) are 95% full. The water level in Sugar Hollow Reservoir was lowered five feet to support work being completed on the pneumatic piping which pressurizes the inflatable rubber bladder that sits on top of the concrete dam. The inflatable bladder controls the level of the upper five feet of water in the reservoir. When the work on the piping has been completed, the normal reservoir water level will be restored. b. Beaver Creek Reservoir (Crozet) is 100% full with about 500 million gallons of water available for use. Water demand in the Crozet area averaged 0. 55 million gallons per day in February. c. Totier Creek Reservoir (Scottsville) is 100% full with about 155 million gallons of water available for use. Water demand in the Scottsville area averaged 42,000 gallons per day in February. 2. The production of drinking water for the Urban area averaged 8.85 million gallons per day (MGD) in February 2025 (FY 2025), which is slightly more than the five-year average for December (8.73 MGD) as shown by the following graph: Page 142 of 147 2 3. Urban wastewater flow for February 2025 (12.22 MGD), including flows from Crozet but not from Scottsville, was above the five-year average for February (10.84 MGD), as shown by the graph below: 4. A general overview of significant current and future drinking water, wastewater and solid waste Capital Improvement Projects is provided below. Cost allocations between the Charlottesville Department of Utilities (Utility funds) and the Albemarle County Service Authority (ACSA), are identified for each project. Several of these projects are part of the community’s Water Supply Plan established in 2012 to increase the capacity of our drinking water reservoirs and infrastructure, as shown by the map below. Page 143 of 147 3 a. South Rivanna River Crossing a. Scope: Provide a second pipe (24” diameter; 2900 feet long) to convey treated drinking water under the river using trenchless technology. The second pipe will provide a redundant water supply and increase capacity to serve the northern area of the Urban Water System. b. Completion: January 2025 – January 2027 c. Cost: $6.2 million: 100% ACSA b. Water Pipe and Pump Stations Replacement, Ragged Mountain Reservoir to Observatory Water Treatment Plant a. Scope: Replace four miles of 36” ductile iron water pipe and two pumping stations which convey untreated water from the Ragged Mtn Reservoir to the Observatory WTP. These facilities have reached the end of their service lives and require replacement to reliably provide untreated water to the upgraded Observatory WTP. A project information meeting was held in January 2025 with neighbors bordering the work and others from the community. b. Completion: February 2025 – June 2029 c. Cost: $62 million: 52% ACSA / 48% City Utilities c. Urban Area “Central Water Pipe” a. Scope: Provide large diameter p iping (24” and 36” ductile iron) to strengthen and more efficiently distribute drinking water for the benefit of City and County residents and businesses. This five-mile-long piping project with two railroad crossings will extend from the Stadium Road area to the Long Street bridge near Pantops . The eastern end of the route was recently revised due to underground conflicts in E. High Street. Information m eetings will be scheduled with neighborhoods before construction begins . The route includes Stadium Road , Piedmont Avenue, Price Avenue, Lewis Street, Jefferson Park Avenue, Cleveland Avenue, Cherry Avenue, Elliott Avenue, 6th Street SE, South Street, Avon Street, 10th Street, Little High Street, Meade Avenue, Fairway Avenue, and property near the river to the Long Street bridge. b. Completion: July 2025 – July 2029 c. Cost: $79 million: 52% ACSA / 48% City Utilities d. Red Hill Water Treatment Plant Upgrade a. Scope: Provide additional building space to house additional water treatment equipment including a granular activated carbon filter. b. Completion: January 2025 – June 2026 c. Cost: $2 million: 100% ACSA, with partial grant from County e. Baling Facility, Ivy Solid Waste and Recycling Center a. Scope: Replace the existing recycling materials baling facility which is located on leased property and has exceeded its service life. The new facility will include equipment to compress cardboard, mixed paper, and plastic products into separate bales before shipment to a receiving vendor. Page 144 of 147 4 b. Completion: May 2025 – December 2026 c. Cost: $6 million: 70% Albemarle County / 30% City f. Moores Creek Structural and Concrete Rehabilitation a. Scope: Repair of concrete basins and wastewater treatment facilities constructed in the late 1970’s. b. Completion: May 2025 – May 2027 c. Cost: $15.5 million: 52% ACSA / 48% City Utilities g. Moores Creek Upfits and Gravity Thickener Improvements a. Scope: Renovate the Maintenance and Operations buildings along with repair of the sludge gravity thickener system and secondary clarifier influent valves. b. Completion: May 2025 – May 2027 c. Cost: $11.8 million: 52% ACSA / 48% City Utilities h. Crozet Wastewater Pump Stations Rehabilitation a. Scope: Replace pumps, valves, and electrical gear in four pump stations constructed in the 1980’s which convey wastewater from Crozet to the Moores Creek Treatment Plant. b. Completion: July 2025 – September 2027 c. Cost: $12.3 million: 100% ACSA i. Moores Creek Administration Building Renovation and Addition a. Scope: Renovate the existing administration building constructed in the 1980’s, including improvements to the Laboratory and Information Technology spaces. The project will also include a building addition to provide space s for a community education area, staff currently housed in temporary trailers, as well as future staffing. b. Completion: June 2025 – December 2027 c. Cost: $27.6 million: 52% ACSA / 48% City Utilities j. Crozet Water Treatment Plant GAC Expansion a. Scope: Provide a dditional building space and equipment to i ncrease the water treatment capacity of the granular activated carbon filter system from 1 to 2 million gallons per day. b. Completion: August 2025 – March 2027 c. Budget: $10 million: 100% ACSA with VDH grant k. Ragged Mtn Reservoir Water Level Increase a. Scope: Clearing of vegetation around the reservoir and minor modifications to the intake tower as necessary to increase the normal pool elevation 12 feet and provide 700 million gallons of additional water storage capacity in the reservoir. b. Completion: September 2025 - September 2026 c. Cost: $6 million: 80% ACSA / 20% City Utilities Page 145 of 147 5 l. South Rivanna Reservoir to Ragged Mountain Reservoir Pipe and Pump Station a. Scope: Construct a 6.5 mile long, large diameter pipe (36”) and pump station to transfer untreated water between the South Rivanna and Ragged Mtn Reservoirs, as required by the community’s drinking water supply plan. Complete a new raw water intake structure and pump station at the South Rivanna Reservoir . This infrastructure will increase the water storage capacity of the Ragged Mtn Reservoir from 1.4 to 2.1 billion gallons. b. Completion: February 2026 – December 2030 c. Cost: $117 million: 80% ACSA / 20% City Utilities m. Beaver Creek Dam, Pump Station and Piping Improvements a. Scope: Replace the spillway, which protects the reservoir dam, along with the water pump station and piping which convey untreated water to the Crozet Water Treatment Plant. b. Completion: May 2026 – January 2030 c. Cost: $62 million: 100% ACSA with partial federal NRCS grant n. Upper Schenks Branch Wastewater Piping Replacement, Phase II a. Scope: Replace sewer piping installed in the mid 1950’s , in conjunction with the City’s sewer upgrade program , to increase system capacity. The new piping will be located along McIntire Road between the McIntire Recycling Center and Preston Avenue. b. Completion: TBD c. Cost: $10 - 15 million: 100% City Utilities 5. Average daily refuse volume at the Ivy Transfer Station has increased from 146 tons per day in 2021 to 208 tons per day in 2024, as shown below. Our contract hauler is driving about 15 trailer loads of refuse to Henrico County for disposal each day, Monday – Friday. Page 146 of 147 6 6. Household Hazardous Waste and Special Collection Days The Ivy Solid Waste and Recycling Center located at 4576 Dick Woods Road will be the site for our Spring 2025 Household Hazardous Waste and Special Collection Days. These events provide free disposal of select items for residents of Albemarle County, the City of Charlottesville, and the Town of Scottsville . Registration is not necessary. Additional information is available at: www.rivanna.org/hhw Please let me know if you have any questions. Sincerely, William I. Mawyer, Jr., P.E. Executive Director cc: RSWA Board of Directors RWSA Board of Directors www.rivanna.org/hhw Page 147 of 147

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 10, 2026.