City Council Budget Work Session — Agenda Packet
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of May 2, 2023 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY COUNCIL
Tuesday, May 2, 2023 | 4:00 PM
2nd Floor Training Room - City Hall
900 Church Street
Lynchburg, VA 24504
BUDGET WORK SESSION AGENDA
I. Welcome Stephanie T. Reed, Mayor
II. Budget Work Session Agenda Overview Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
III. Budget Work Session Agenda Items Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
III.1. FY 2024 Proposed Budget Reconciliation
Page 1 of 30
BUDGET RECONCILIATION
Budget Work Session
May 2, 2023
Page 2 of 30
BASELINE ASSUMPTIONS FOR TODAY’S RECONCILIATION
▪ Local contribution to Lynchburg City Schools (LCS) set at FY 2023 Level
of $40.8M
▪ BPOL License requirements waived for all businesses with gross
receipts of $200K and less
▪ Reduces City revenue by $75K
▪ Previously assumed $650K in revenue reduction to exempt all gross receipts
under $150K from taxation
▪ $575K in budget savings used to offset department/service level cuts
2
Page 3 of 30
SERVICES PROPOSED FOR RESTORATION
▪ Close Templeton Senior Center
▪ Close Collections Teller Window permanently
▪ Reduce funding for demolition
▪ Reduce contracted services for right-of-way
mowing
▪ Reduce funding for on-site citywide training
▪ Reduce funding for occupational health
▪ Reduce staffing for youth and adult library
programming
▪ Reduce staffing and hours for Museums
3
▪ Eliminate hanging of banners/holiday decorations
▪ Eliminate contribution for Lynchburg Regional
Business Alliance (LRBA)
▪ Eliminate State of the City event
▪ Reduce funding and contracted services for Snow
Removal
▪ Reduce contracted services for tree cutting
▪ Reduce funding for event public relations and
contracted services for camera operators
▪ Reduce funding for Miller Park Pool – season
shortened by 10 days
▪ Miscellaneous reductions to operating line items
Restored Services Remaining Service Cuts
Page 4 of 30
WHAT’S IN AT $0.89
▪ Full public safety package as outlined in City Manager’s Proposed
Budget
▪ Public safety employees targeted pay progression/compression
▪ New LPD positions and operational support
▪ Other new public safety positions and operational support including cyber
security positions
▪ New Constitutional Officer positions and operational support
▪ New LPD take home car program
▪ Five percent general wage increase for non-sworn general employees
▪ Level funding of local contribution to LCS at $40.8M
4
Page 5 of 30
HOW WE GET THERE
▪Budget updates - $1,007,186
▪ Update Social Services Reimbursement Revenue - $600,000
▪ Update Blue Ridge Regional Jail Funding - $407,186
▪Reduced budget flexibility - $4,600,000
▪ Budget for vacant positions - $2,000,000
▪ Replace ongoing fleet replacement funds with one-time funds - $2,600,000
▪Budget cuts/service level reductions - $851,095
▪ Department budget/service level reductions - $743,036
▪ Eliminate City Council salaries - $77,508
▪ Eliminate funding to discretionary external service providers - $30,551
5
Page 6 of 30
BUDGET OPTIONS AT DIFFERENT TAX RATES
6
$0.89 $0.93 $0.99
+ Eliminate Budget Cuts
+ $2.1M Increase to LCS
Local Contribution
from FY 2023 level
+ Eliminate Budget Cuts
+ $2.1M Increase to LCS
Local Contribution
+ $4.6M Increase
Budget Flexibility
o Unprecedented
investment in Public
Safety
o Competitive wage
increase for City
employees
Page 7 of 30
Page 8 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget (Expenditures)
Agency Agency
Agency
lnc/(Dec)
Actual Amended Submitted Amended from FY 2024 Funding
FY 2022 FY 2023 FY 2024 Submitted Proposal
FACILITIES
Personnel Services $2,108 $17,500 $17,500 $0 $17,500
Employee Benefits 180 2,730 2,730 0 2,730
Capital Outlay 2,259 19,980 4,980 (15,000) 4,980
TOTAL FACILITIES $4,547 $40,210 $25,210 $(15,000) $25,210
OTHER NON-INSTRUCTIONAL OPERATIONS
Personnel Services $8,386 $14,185 $22,663 $8,478 $22,663
Employee Benefits 2,454 2,854 5,297 2,443 5,297
Purchased Services 0 9,463 7,715 -1748 7715
Internal Services 555 500 500 0 500
Other Charges 3,000 1,299 1,300 1 1,300
Materials and Supplies 5,116 6,664 4,670 (1,994) 4,670
TOTAL OTHER NON-INSTRUCTIONAL OPERATIONS $19,511 $34,965 $42,145 $7,180 $42,145
Page 9 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget (Expenditures)
Agency Agency
Agency
lnc/(Dec)
Actual Amended Submitted Amended from FY 2024 Funding
FY 2022 FY 2023 FY 2024 Submitted Proposal
PUPIL TRANSPORTATION
Personnel Services $3,077,975 $3,294,872 $3,626,786 $331,914 $3,626,786
Employee Benefits 1,069,104 1,243,315 1,338,948 95,633 1,338,948
Purchased Services 325,749 152,348 252,348 100000 252348
Internal Services 18 2,498 2,500 2 2,500
Other Charges 375,434 435,132 510,959 75,827 510,959
Materials and Supplies 810,761 1,006,301 865,301 141,000 865,301
Capital Outlay 672,459 0 2,500 2,500 2,500
TOTAL PUPIL TRANSPORTATION $6,331,500 $6,134,466 $6,599,342 $746,876 $6,599,342
Page 10 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget (Expenditures)
Agency Agency
Agency
lnc/(Dec)
Actual Amended Submitted Amended from FY 2024 Funding
FY 2022 FY 2023 FY 2024 Submitted Proposal
OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE
Personnel Services $4,149,590 $4,823,045 $5,282,196 $459,151 $5,064,197
Employee Benefits 1,642,653 2,004,928 2,137,222 132,294 2,049,018
Purchased Services 1,310,038 776,752 776,752 0 776,752
Other Charges 3,555,232 3,371,644 3,380,232 8,588 3,380,232
Materials and Supplies 881,531 558,563 511,908 (46,655) 511,908
Capital Outlay 930,385 828,060 630,000 (198,060) 630,000
TOTAL OPERATION AND MAINTENANCE $12,469,429 $12,362,992 $12,718,310 $355,318 $12,412,107
Page 11 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget (Expenditures)
Agency Agency
Agency
lnc/(Dec)
Actual Amended Submitted Amended from FY 2024 Funding
FY 2022 FY 2023 FY 2024 Submitted Proposal
TECHNOLOGY
Personnel Services $1,833,073 $2,035,753 $2,215,532 $179,779 $2,137,541
Employee Benefits 830,420 798,682 830,686 32,004 801,444
Purchased Services 1,304,423 1,140,637 1,215,148 74511 1,215,148
Internal Services 856 500 200 (300) 200
Other Charges 116,424 93,220 95,842 2,622 95,842
Materials and Supplies 1,855,684 1,165,472 1,250,000 84,528 1,250,000
Capital Outlay 74,525 128,871 0 (128,871) 0
TOTAL TECHNOLOGY $6,015,405 $5,363,135 $5,607,408 $244,273 $5,500,175
Page 12 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget (Expenditures)
Agency Agency
Agency
lnc/(Dec)
Actual Amended Submitted Amended from FY 2024 Funding
FY 2022 FY 2023 FY 2024 Submitted Proposal
INSTRUCTION
Personnel Services $44,398,702 $48,529,703 $55,649,525 $7,119,822 ?
Employee Benefits 17,394,137 20,252,318 23,038,111 2,785,793 ?
Purchased Services 1,966,980 1,799,462 1,799,462 0 1,799,462
Internal Services 101,997 11,242 2,100 (9,142) 2,100
Other Charges 63,838 201,820 106,240 (95,580) 106,240
Materials and Supplies 3,167,454 1,107,539 1,082,524 (25,015) 1,082,524
Tuition Payments/Joint Operations 1,131,865 1,226,581 1,226,581 0 1,226,581
Capital Outlay 81,963 59,009 54,639 (4,370) 54,639
TOTAL INSTRUCTION $68,306,936 $73,187,674 $82,959,182 $9,771,508 > $73,187,674
Page 13 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget
Page 14 of 30
LCS Operating Budget: Instruction (Personnel Services)
( T + P + A ) + x = C
Solve for x.
Page 15 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget: Instruction (Personnel Services)
( T + P + A ) + x = C Solve for x.
T = Teacher Pay
P = Principal Pay
A = Assistant Principal Pay
C = Total Instruction Compensation
Page 16 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget: Instruction (Personnel Services)
( T + P + A ) + x = C
Solve for x.
T = Teacher Pay
P = Principal Pay
A = Assistant Principal Pay
C = Total Instruction Compensation
T = Teacher FTEs · VDOE Average Teacher Compensation for LCS
P = Principal FTEs · VDOE Average Principal Compensation for LCS
A = Asst. Principal FTEs · VDOE Average Asst. Principal Compensation for LCS
C = Fiscal Year Total (Instruction Category Personnel Services)
Page 17 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget ( T + P + A ) + x = C
Solve for x.
T = Teacher Pay
P = Principal Pay
A = Assistant Principal Pay
C = Total Instruction Compensation
* Three additional FTEs added based on “Student Need” identified in LCS Operating Budget Discussion
Document From Joint City Council / School Board Work Session
FY2022 FY2023 FY2024
Teacher FTEs 619.35 619.35 622.35*
Principal FTEs 19 19 19
Asst. Principal FTEs 17 17 17
FY2022 (Actual) FY2023 (Budgeted)
VDOE: LCS Teacher Average
Compensation $ 51,675 $ 47,315
VDOE: LCS Principal Average
Compensation
$ 88,052 $ 86,423
VDOE: LCS Asst. Principal Average
Compensation
$ 68,507 $ 75,342
FY2022 Actual Expenditure for Instruction:
Personnel Services
$ 44,398,702
FY2023 Budget Expenditure for Instruction:
Personnel Services
$ 48,529,703
T = Teacher FTEs · VDOE Average Teacher Compensation for LCS
P = Principal FTEs · VDOE Average Principal Compensation for LCS
A = Asst. Principal FTEs · VDOE Average Asst. Principal Compensation for LCS
C = Fiscal Year Total (Instruction Category Personnel Services)
Source - https://rga.lis.virginia.gov/Published/2023/RD73/PDF: “Department of Education staff prepared the report based on Annual
School Report (ASR) expenditure data submitted by each school division and regional program. Statewide and school division salary
averages were computed for fiscal years 2022 and 2023. The report shows salary information from fiscal years 2021, 2022, and 2023
for comparative purposes. Year-to-year percentage change in salary averages is shown for statewide and division data.”
Page 18 of 30
LCS Operating Budget: Instruction (Personnel Services)
What happened between
FY 2022 and FY 2023?
FY2022 (Actual) FY2023 (Budgeted) Increase/(Decrease)
VDOE: LCS Teacher Average
Compensation $ 51,675 $ 47,315 (8.44%)
VDOE: LCS Principal Average
Compensation
$ 88,052 $ 86,423 (1.85%)
VDOE: LCS Asst. Principal Average
Compensation
$ 68,507 $ 75,342 9.98%
Page 19 of 30
Page 20 of 30
Page 21 of 30
FY 2023 budget process
occurs in 3rd quarter
Page 22 of 30
School year ending in
Spring 2022
Page 23 of 30
LCS Operating Budget: Instruction (Personnel Services)
What we know:
There was a historic wave of certified staff resignations in the
2021-2022 School Year (FY 2022).
Average teacher pay decreased 8.4%in FY2023 with an
approved 5% pay increase in the adopted budget.
Page 24 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget ( T + P + A ) + x = C
Solve for x.
T = Teacher Pay
P = Principal Pay
A = Assistant Principal Pay
C = Total Instruction Compensation
FY2022 FY2023 FY2024
Teacher FTEs 619.35 619.35 622.35*
Principal FTEs 19 19 19
Asst. Principal FTEs 17 17 17
FY2022 (Actual) FY2023 (Budgeted)
VDOE: LCS Teacher Average
Compensation $ 51,675 $ 47,315
VDOE: LCS Principal Average
Compensation
$ 88,052 $ 86,423
VDOE: LCS Asst. Principal Average
Compensation
$ 68,507 $ 75,342
FY2022 Actual Expenditure for Instruction:
Personnel Services
$ 44,398,702
FY2023 Budget Expenditure for Instruction:
Personnel Services
$ 48,529,703
T = Teacher FTEs · VDOE Average Teacher Compensation for LCS
P = Principal FTEs · VDOE Average Principal Compensation for LCS
A = Asst. Principal FTEs · VDOE Average Asst. Principal Compensation for LCS
C = Fiscal Year Total (Instruction Category Personnel Services)
FY2022 FY2023 FY2024
T $ 32,004,911 $ 29,304,545 $ 33,862,064
P $ 1,672,988 $ 1,642,037 $ 1,724,345
A $ 1,164,619 $ 1,280,814 $ 1,344,870
x $9,556,184 $ 16,302,307 $ 12,502,926
C $ 44,398,702 $ 48,529,703 $ 49,434,205
Page 25 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget ( T + P + A ) + x = C
Solve for x.
T = Teacher Pay
P = Principal Pay
A = Assistant Principal Pay
C = Total Instruction Compensation
FY2022 FY2023 FY2024
Teacher FTEs 619.35 619.35 622.35*
Principal FTEs 19 19 19
Asst. Principal FTEs 17 17 17
FY2022 (Actual) FY2024 (Budgeted)
VDOE: LCS Teacher Average
Compensation $ 51,675 $ 47,315
VDOE: LCS Principal Average
Compensation
$ 88,052 $ 86,423
VDOE: LCS Asst. Principal Average
Compensation
$ 68,507 $ 75,342
FY2022 Actual Expenditure for Instruction:
Personnel Services
$ 44,398,702
FY2023 Budget Expenditure for Instruction:
Personnel Services
$ 48,529,703
FY2024 Calculated
FTEs
FY2024 Calculated
Average Pay
FY2024 Calculated
Expenditure Notes
Teachers 622.35 $ 54,410 $ 33,862,064
15% Increase to average teacher pay.
Current SY 22-23 base is $ 43,470.
Principals 19 $ 90,755 $ 1,724,345
5% increase to current VDOE average
Principal Compensation for LCS.
Asst. Principals 17 $ 79,110 $ 1,344,870
5% increase to current VDOE average
Asst. Principal Compensation for LCS.
Additional
Instructional Staff $ 12,502,926
11.2% Increase to distributed contract
totals for remaining Instruction Staff.
Instruction:
Personnel Services $ 49,434,205
1.9% increase to unrealistic FY23
Expenditure, & 11.3% increase to FY22.
Page 26 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget (Expenditures)
Agency Agency
Agency
lnc/(Dec)
Actual Amended Submitted Amended from FY 2024 Funding
FY 2022 FY 2023 FY 2024 Submitted Proposal
INSTRUCTION
Personnel Services $44,398,702 $48,529,703 $55,649,525 $7,119,822 $49,434,205
Employee Benefits 17,394,137 20,252,318 23,038,111 2,785,793 20,465,057
Purchased Services 1,966,980 1,799,462 1,799,462 0 1,799,462
Internal Services 101,997 11,242 2,100 (9,142) 2,100
Other Charges 63,838 201,820 106,240 (95,580) 106,240
Materials and Supplies 3,167,454 1,107,539 1,082,524 (25,015) 1,082,524
Tuition Payments/Joint Operations 1,131,865 1,226,581 1,226,581 0 1,226,581
Capital Outlay 81,963 59,009 54,639 (4,370) 54,639
TOTAL INSTRUCTION $68,306,936 $73,187,674 $82,959,182 $9,771,508 $74,170,808
Page 27 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget (Expenditures)
Agency Agency
Agency
lnc/(Dec)
Actual Amended Submitted Amended from FY 2024 Budget
FY 2022 FY 2023 FY 2024 Submitted Calculations
ADMINISTRATION
Personnel Services $4,514,158 $5,223,819 $6,005,075 $781,256 $4,739,866
Employee Benefits 1,944,805 2,575,838 2,800,939 225,101 2,210,809
Purchased Services 752,581 562,032 562,032 0 562,032
Internal Services 14,135 11,539 5,100 (6,439) 5,100
Other Charges 605,150 715,555 538,853 (176,702) 538,853
Daterials and Supplies 152,494 100,006 70,167 (29,839) 70,167
TOTAL ADMINISTRATION $7,983,323 $9,188,789 $9,982,166 $793,377 $8,126,827
Page 28 of 30
FY2024 LCS Operating Budget Categorical Funding
FY2024 LCS Categorical Funding History and FY 2024 Funding Proposal
Proposed
FY2022 Proposed FY2022 Actual FY2022 Actual (CAFR) FY2023 Amended FY24 LCS Proposed Slide Calculations FY2024 Funding
Instruction $ 69,147,581 $ 68,306,936 $ 68,296,053 $ 73,187,674 $ 82,959,182 $ 74,170,808 $ 74,541,662
Administration 8,042,042 7,983,323 7,983,324 9,188,789 9,982,166 8,126,827 8,167,461
Pupil Transportation 5,799,425 6,331,500 5,659,041 6,134,466 6,599,342 6,599,342 6,599,342
Operation and Maintenance 11,401,488 12,469,429 11,539,043 12,362,992 12,718,310 12,412,107 12,474,168
Facilities 2,390 4,547 4,547 40,210 25,210 25,210 25,210
Other Non-Instructional Operations 38,026 19,511 19,510 34,965 42,145 42,145 42,145
Technology 6,409,895 6,015,405 5,940,881 5,363,135 5,607,408 5,500,175 5,527,676
Contingency Reserves* - - - - - - 1,800,0001
Capital Outlay** 2,047,097 1,690,511
TOTALS $ 102,887,944 $ 101,130,651 $ 101,132,910 $ 106,312,231 $ 117,933,763 $ 106,876,614 $ 109,177,663
* Not used previously by LCS but allowed by Code of Virginia
** Included in CAFR only Difference From FY23 $ 564,383 $ 2,865,432
1 The lowest proposed state budget in Richmond includes only $2.5 million for additional state funding,
and this reserve would cover the gap if adopted.
Increased State Contribution $ 4,300,000 $ 4,300,000
Local Funding Change $ (3,735,617) $ (1,434,568)
Page 29 of 30
FY2024 LCS Categorical Funding Proposal Effect on Gap Reduction
Increase of $ 1,434,568 to the City of Lynchburg Operating Budget
Operating Budget Line Item Expenditure Status
Department Budget and Service Level Reductions - $ 743,036 RESTORED
Eliminate City Council Salaries - $ 77,508 RESTORED
Eliminate Funding to Discretionary External Service Providers - $ 30,551 RESTORED
Re-establish Department of Internal Audit for City of Lynchburg - $ 150,000 ADDED SERVICE
Remaining balance of $433,473 after services are restored and an
internal control measure is added to ensure government oversight.
Page 30 of 30
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.