City Council Budget Work Session — Minutes
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Mar 21, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
March 21, 2023
1
// A special called meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 21st day of March
2023, at 4:00 p.m. in the Second Floor Training Room, City Hall, Stephanie Reed, President, presiding.
The following Members of the Council were present:
Present: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, MaryJane Dolan, Sterling Wilder, Jeff Helgeson, Marty
Misjuns, Larry Taylor 7
Absent: 0
// In the matter of Water Resources and the Lynchburg Regional Airport, Agenda Item 1, Enterprise
Funds Operating and Capital Budget Overview, Director of Water Resources Mr. Tim Mitchell provided a
summary of the proposed rate increases and the water and sewer CIP. City Council received a briefing
on the need to update the City's water, sewer, and stormwater rates. The primary drivers for the rate
increases include significant cost increases, especially in chemicals and power; increasing regulatory
requirements, the need to invest in our critical infrastructure, employee compensation. The most
significant increase is in the sewer rate as required for continuing compliance with the financial criteria of
the Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) Consent Order.
Vice Mayor Faraldi clarified that the rate increases were mandated, but the cost increases were
associated with staffing and ongoing costs for mandated requirements. He said that once the mandates
no longer applied, the costs would no longer exist. Mr. Mitchell responded that once they completed the
last project of the CSO program, they would have to prove that the infrastructure improvements worked
for a period of time and met the compliance goals of the long-term control plan. He said after they met
those requirements, they would no longer be mandated to meet the 1.25% of median household income.
He said the consent order stipulated that operating needs were to be covered by the 1.25% rate, and then
generated revenue would fund the CSO program. He said there would still be debt service associated
with the CSO program, but they would no longer be required to keep the rate at 1.25%. He said there
were several operational increases that needed to be funded, but those were addressed through the
mandated rate increase. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if there were ways to offset the cost without a
mandate. Mr. Mitchell stated that the mandate was from the state. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if the stated
mandated the additional staff. Mr. Mitchell responded no. He stated the state mandated the rate, and the
additional staff were due to operational needs. He said that even without the CSO, the City had significant
March 21, 2023
2
amounts of sewer infrastructure needs that they needed to address. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked why the
neighborhoods or districts did not fund their own sewer improvements. Mr. Mitchell responded that the
sewer rates had to be equal for all customers. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked what the expected total dollar
increase would be. Mr. Mitchell responded that the water and sewer fund revenues were generated from
more than the rates, and they had several revenue sources, such as county contract revenue. He said the
adopted budget for the storm water fund was about $3.8M, and the proposed revenues for 2024 were
about $4.2M. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked what would happen if they did not approve the mandate. Mr.
Mitchell responded that the City could potentially receive enforcement action and be subject to lawsuits
from environmental groups because they were in non-compliance with the consent order. Vice Mayor
Faraldi asked if the lawsuits would come from the state or environmental groups. Mr. Mitchel responded
that there could be private lawsuits for non-compliance, but the City could also receive additional
enforcement action from the state. He noted that the City did not have a deadline to finish its program.
Councilmember Misjuns asked what the tap fees were for water and sewer. Mr. Mitchell
responded that the tap fees, or connection fees, for sewer were $130 for the connection, and the
availability fee was $1,950. He noted the combined water connection fees were slightly less.
Councilmember Misjuns asked how many they received per year. Mr. Mitchell said they did not receive
many. Councilmember Misjuns asked what was possible to lower the connection fees. Mr. Mitchell
responded that they were currently considering different avenues and researching what legal
opportunities there were. He said that they wanted to increase the customer base to offset the cost.
Councilmember Misjuns asked what the water tap fees were. Mr. Mitchell responded it was $1,100 for the
connection fee, and it was less than county fees. He said that the additional revenue generated by the
increase in the sewer fund was $1.9M. He said the water fund increase was about $900K.
Councilmember Wilder asked if the need in Tyreeanna and Pleasant Valley was similar to the
need in Richland Hills. Mr. Mitchell responded that there was a similar need, and they had 19
neighborhoods throughout the City without sewer service. He said that sewer extensions were not cost
effective, where the average cost per household for a sewer extension was $70K to $80K. He explained
they intended to do Richland Hills in two phases.
March 21, 2023
3
Mayor Reed asked when the estimated start time would be. Mr. Mitchell responded that it was
being designed. He noted that the ARPA funding for the project had to be spent by December 2026, and
they had to have construction under contract by December 2024. He said they intended to begin
construction in one year in Richland Hills. He said they had to acquire 19 easements in the neighborhood,
but the pipe would be predominantly routed through the streets which did not require easements. Mayor
Reed asked what the average cost increase for materials was. Mr. Mitchell stated chemical cost
increases were the most significant, and some had increased by 110%. He said other materials had
supply chain issues. Mayor Reed clarified the new positions were to address the new workload in sewer.
Mr. Mitchell explained most of the sewer lines in the City were off-road, and they were difficult to access
and maintained. He said they needed a dedicated crew to inspect the lines.
Assistant Airport Director Mr. Cedric Simon provided a presentation on the Airport CIP following
the discussion of the water and sewer CIP.
// In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item 2, Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-23-028
approving a change order to the Black Water Creek Bank Stabilization Phase II, Director of Water
Resources Mr. Tim Mitchell provided a presentation of the staff report. The Blackwater Creek Bank
Stabilization Phase II project is stabilizing approximately 165 linear feet of stream channel along the north
bank of Blackwater Creek near Point of Honor. The purpose of the project is to maintain the structural
integrity of existing adjacent infrastructure, including the James River Heritage Trail and the 60-inch
sanitary sewer interceptor, which are threatened by severe bank erosion. The project area is immediately
downstream of prior bank stabilization efforts and is being implemented due to the rapid failure of an
existing sheet pile wall. This activity will protect public infrastructure while improving the overall
downstream water quality by reducing the amount of sediment entering the waterway from the eroding
bank. The original contract amount is $386,725.60 and the amount of the change order is $124,214.45
making the new contract amount $510,940.05. The contractor, KBS Earthworks, Inc. is requesting the
additional amount primarily due to unforeseen subsurface conditions that resulted in additional work and
significantly more materials including stone, four-ton boulders, and offsite disposal cost increases. The
contractor currently has equipment mobilized for the project. Any delay in approving the change order
may result in additional remobilization costs if the contractor removed the equipment from the site. The
March 21, 2023
4
Virginia Public Procurement Act requires change orders over 25% of the contract or $50,000 whichever is
greater, requires the approval of the governing body. The duration of the project is short with completion
expected next month. Without approval or delayed approval of the change order, the contractor will likely
leave the project unfinished or have additional costs associated with time delays or remobilization.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked where the funds for the adjustment were sourced. Mr. Mitchell
responded that they would come from the sewer fund and the capital program.
Councilmember Misjuns made the motion, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to approve the
Resolution #R-23-028.
Councilmember Helgeson clarified that there were bids on the project; Mr. Mitchell responded
yes. He said they were installing based on the plans, but they required more material based on the
subsurface conditions. He explained they did not perform any geotechnical survey for the project to
determine the subsurface conditions because of the costs. Councilmember Helgeson asked how the bid
was awarded. Mr. Mitchell responded that it would have been an estimated quantity on the bid form.
Councilmember Taylor asked if the funding would complete the project; Mr. Mitchell responded
yes.
Councilmember Dolan asked if they reviewed the bidding history of contract bidders. Mr. Mitchell
explained that by law, they had to accept the lowest bidder. He said some projects would pre-qualify
contract bidders to ensure they would be able to complete the project.
With no further discussion from Council, the following voice vote was recorded:
Ayes: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, Sterling Wilder, MaryJane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, Marty
Misjuns, Larry Taylor 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item 3, FY 2024 Proposed Budget Reconciliation, Mayor Reed stated
they would hold a roundtable discussion to address questions from councilmembers, and Chief Financial
Officer Ms. Donna Witt would provide an explanation and clarification to Council regarding the previously
mentioned budget surplus.
Ms. Witt stated that at the end of FY 2022, the unassigned fund balance was $66.4M. She said
that about $25M of the unassigned fund balance was dedicated as an emergency fund. She explained
March 21, 2023
5
that in the FY 23 budget, Council allocated unassigned fund balance funds for Pay Go capital, a $0.02
real estate tax rebate, one-time operating expenses, and a correction for the water resources fund,
reducing the fund balance to about $23M. She explained that the FY 24 budget proposed an estimated
use of about $21M of the one-time funds. She said they tried to use the funds for one-time costs in the
operating fund. She said they did not account for funds which would be allocated to the unassigned fund
balance at the end of FY 23. She said that between $10M to $15M would likely fall to the unassigned fund
balance at the end of the fiscal year.
Mayor Reed asked for clarification of the difference between what the counties offered and what
the City offered. Deputy City Manager Mr. Greg Patrick responded that cities were economic, arts, and
culture hubs for the regions, and many of the reasons the surrounding counties flourished because they
were suburban communities to the City. He said the state funded cities and counties differently, and cities
saw significantly higher poverty which required greater support. He said there were significant economic
development differences, such as land availability. He said counties had, on average, 10.5 times more
land than the City. He said overall, they spent 30% more per capita on services in the City compared to
the counties. He said cities and counties had different competitive advantages, and they appealed to
different people.
Councilmember Helgeson stated that the proposed real estate tax rate had to change. He said
that they should look for ways to not raise the tax rate at all to reduce the burden on the residents in the
City.
Councilmember Misjuns said that they could not discuss budget reconciliation until they decided
on a tax rate.
Councilmember Taylor stated that they needed to address poverty in the City, and reducing the
real estate tax rate would help.
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that the real estate rate should decrease, but they should also look to
reduce other rates, such as personal property taxes, trash collection rates, and meals taxes. He noted
that 52% of the City residents rented and may not see the savings from real estate property tax relief. He
said if they equalized the real estate property tax rate and performed a $0.50 personal property tax
reduction, it would total $5.3M. He asked if the City Manager's proposal would still be funded with his
March 21, 2023
6
suggested rates. Mr. Benda responded that the refuse waiver and motor vehicle waiver were based on
one-time funding. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked how they could use one-time funding to pay the fee, which
was an ongoing cost. Mr. Benda clarified that the relief was for a finite period of time. He said that
equalizing the rate at $0.92 meant that was the rate to provide the same services as the year before. He
said if they adopted a $0.92 rate, then none of the proposed additions to the budget, such as public safety
projects, would be funded—they were not being cut, but they would not happen. Vice Mayor Faraldi
suggested reducing the capital contribution to reduce the budget. He noted that it was one-time funding,
but the funds had been available for multiple years. Mr. Benda responded that it was according to the
financial policies of the Council. He explained that Pay Go projects were those that needed to happen, so
they would be done. He continued that as part of their fiscal policy, they allocated Pay Go funding to
decrease debt allocation in the CIP. Vice Mayor Faraldi said that they could not do projects instead of
finding other ways to fund them. Mr. Benda responded that was possible. He noted that the City had
aging infrastructure, and there were several needs for improvements. He said that the year-over-year cost
increase was about 5%.
Mayor Reed asked for information about the current restrictions for the elderly tax relief program.
She suggested expanding the program to provide relief to elderly individuals on a fixed income.
Councilmember Helgeson responded that the relief was for a small number of people and only
applied to people who were disabled or over 65. He noted there were income and net-worth
requirements.
Mayor Reed asked for information about the number of homeowners living in poverty. Mr. Patrick
stated that they could review the census data.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if residents who lived in HOAs received the trash fee reduction. Mr.
Benda responded that it was dependent on whether the private owner passed the savings on to the
tenants.
Councilmember Wilder stated that he supported the investments and the proposed reductions in
the City Manager's budget.
March 21, 2023
7
Councilmember Helgeson said that the Council should focus on essential services and consider
reducing funding for other items. He said that they should reduce the tax burden on residents. He said
that they should reconsider the funding for schools.
// The meeting was adjourned at 5:55 p.m.
// A special called meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 21st day of March
2023, at 6:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie Reed, President, presiding. The following
Members of the Council were present:
Present: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, Sterling Wilder, Jeff Helgeson, Marty Misjuns, Larry
Taylor, MaryJane Dolan 7
Absent: 0
// In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item 1, a public hearing was held and Council considered
the first reading of Resolution #R-23-029 amending the FY 2023 Sewer Capital Projects Fund budget and
appropriating $6,600,000 American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) Grant awarded by the Department of
Environmental Quality (DEQ) for the Richland Hills Sewer Project, Director of Water Resources Mr. Tim
Mitchell provided the staff report. In December 2022 the City submitted a grant application to the
Department of Environmental Quality requesting a total of $6,600,000 in grant funds for the Richland Hills
Sewer Extension Project. The Department of Water Resources was notified on March 6, 2023 that we
have been awarded $6,600,000 in ARPA funds through DEQ's Sewer Collection System Program for this
project. The DEQ based the awards on factors such as: project type, environmental impacts, fiscal stress,
readiness to proceed, among other criteria. In order to accept these funds, the City must notify DEQ in
writing including a project description, timeline, and budget by April 5, 2023. Failure to accept the funds
by this date will result in the forfeiture of the grant. The grant does not require a local match. These funds
will enable the project to be completed all at once instead of in phases and will save $6,600,000 in local
funding.
Citizen Jason Snyder, speaking in favor and as a board member of the Richland Hills
Neighborhood Association, stated the association supported the sewer project and funding to increase
sewer access. He stated that septic systems were aging and failing in their neighborhood, and residents
benefited from the lower costs of sewer access.
March 21, 2023
8
There was no one to speak in opposition, and there were no phone calls or emails. Mayor Reed
closed the public hearing and brought the matter before the Council.
Vice Mayor Faraldi made the motion, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to approve Resolution
#R-23-029. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, Jeff Helgeson, Larry Taylor, Marty Misjuns, MaryJane
Dolan, Sterling Wilder 7
Noes: 0
// The meeting adjourned at 6:12 p.m.
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.