RecordWell Data

City Council Budget Retreat — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · General · meeting of Feb 10, 2023 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY COUNCIL Friday, February 10, 2023 | 9:00 AM Lynchburg Department of Social Services 99 9th Street, 5th Floor Training Room #539 Lynchburg, VA 24504 WORK SESSION AGENDA I. Welcome Stephanie Reed, Mayor II. Retreat Agenda Overview Wynter C. Benda, City Manager III. Retreat Agenda Items Wynter C. Benda, City Manager III.1. An Overview of City Programs and Services III.2. Analysis of the FY 2022 Unassigned General Fund Balance III.3. A Comparison of the City of Lynchburg and Surrounding Counties III.4. Preliminary FY 2024 Real Estate Reassessment Results III.5. An Update from the City's Financial Advisor, Davenport & Company, LLC. III.6. Structuring Tax Relief: City Council's Tax Levers III.7. Building the FY 2024 Budget Page 1 of 99 AN OVERVIEW OF CITY PROGRAMS AND SERVICES City Council Retreat Friday, February 10, 2023 1 Page 2 of 99 PRESENTATION OVERVIEW § Review of City Council’s Programs and Services Pre-work § Analysis of Results § Takeaways 2 Page 3 of 99 REVIEW OF CITY COUNCIL’S PROGRAMS AND SERVICES PRE-WORK § City Council members received a set of 78 flashcards that each listed a separate City program or service. § Only programs supported by the City’s General Fund were included § The front of each card described basic attributes of the program or service § The back of each card asked City Council questions about each program: § Is that program a core service? § Should that program be considered for budget reductions if necessary or additional investment if available? § The programs and services are divided into six priority areas: § Public Safety, Lifelong Learning, Economic Development, Infrastructure, Quality of Life, and Support Services 3 Page 4 of 99 REVIEW OF CITY COUNCIL’S PROGRAMS AND SERVICES PRE-WORK PROGRAM CARD EXAMPLE 4 Front Back Page 5 of 99 PRIORITIES AND PROGRAMS 5 Priority Examples Public Safety Police, Fire, Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney Lifelong Learning Libraries, Local K-12 Education Funding, Law Library Economic Development Business Attraction, Retention, and Expansion; Destination Marketing Infrastructure Building Maintenance, Street Maintenance, Engineering Quality of Life Museums, Parks and Recreation, Planning Support Services Accounting, Risk Management, Human Resources Page 6 of 99 IS THIS PROGRAM A CORE SERVICE? 6 Economic Development 25.0% Quality of Life 16.7% Public Safety 69.6% Lifelong Learning 0.0% Infrastructure 37.5% Support Services 29.6% Page 7 of 99 IS THIS PROGRAM A CORE SERVICE? 7 Page 8 of 99 SHOULD THIS PROGRAM BE CONSIDERED FOR A FUNDING REDUCTION? 8 Economic Development 0.0% Quality of Life 33.3% Public Safety 13.0% Lifelong Learning 25.0% Infrastructure 62.5% Support Services 29.6% Page 9 of 99 SHOULD THIS PROGRAM BE CONSIDERED FOR ADDITIONAL INVESTMENT? 9 Economic Development 25.0% Quality of Life 8.3% Public Safety 43.5% Lifelong Learning 0.0% Infrastructure 25.0% Support Services 14.8% Page 10 of 99 TAKEAWAYS § There are no right or wrong answers § Residents and businesses experience the City through services § Context – The scope and breadth of City operations and City Council’s oversight responsibilities are vast § Understanding City Council’s service priorities helps the City Manager build the proposed budget 10 Page 11 of 99 ANAL YSIS OF THE FY 2022 UNASSIGNED GENERAL FUND BALANCE City Council Retreat February 10, 2023 Page 12 of 99 PRESENTATION OVERVIEW § Definitions – Unassigned Fund Balance vs. Surplus Funds § Budgeting and a Budgetary Surplus § City Council’s Financial Management Policies § Unassigned Fund Balance Uses § Rainy-Day Fund § Pay-as-you-go Capital  § Breaking down the $66.4 million § Takeaways Page 13 of 99 DEFINITIONS § Unassigned Fund Balance  § The balance of funds in the General Fund, as recorded on June 30th of each year, that have not been assigned to other funds and that have not been restricted, committed, or assigned to specific purposes within the general fund. § Budgetary Surplus § The balance created when a government's tax and fee revenue within a given fiscal year exceed its expenditures on goods, services or transfer payments. § Surplus Unassigned Fund Balance § Funds within the Unassigned General Fund Balance that exceed the combination of City Council’s reserve requirements and approved and planned uses. Page 14 of 99 BUDGETING AND A BUDGETARY SURPLUS § The City of Lynchburg does not budget to create a surplus. § All revenue is tied to services § Conservative budgeting typically leads to a budgetary surplus. § Allowance for uncollectable taxes / fees § Fully funded personnel budgets § The COVID pandemic led to large positive revenue variances and higher than usual vacancy levels. § A return to pre-pandemic norms is expected going forward. Page 15 of 99 BUDGETING AND A BUDGETARY SURPLUS PANDEMIC WREAKS HAVOC ON REVENUE PROJECTIONS Page 16 of 99 CITY COUNCIL’S FINANCIAL POLICIES UNASSIGNED FUND BALANCE § The City of Lynchburg’s Unassigned General Fund Balance will  be maintained at a level to provide the City with sufficient working  capital  and  a  comfortable  margin  of  safety  to   address  emergencies  and  unexpected  declines  in  revenue  without borrowing.  § The City shall not use the Unassigned General Fund Balance to finance recurring operating expenditures.   § The  City  will  maintain  an  Unassigned  General  Fund   Balance  (UGFB)  equal  to  a  minimum  of  10 percent   of  General  Fund (GF) revenues with a goal of 15 percent  as the City strives to grow incrementally each year subject to revenues available.  In the event the UGFB is  used to provide for temporary funding of unforeseen emergency needs, the City shall restore the Unassigned General Fund Balance to the previous level within three years.   § The  City  will  balance  moving  towards  the  15 percent   targeted  fund  balance  with  its  annual  “Pay-as-you- go”  capital improvement requirements.  § Provides for working capital and a rainy-day fund § Sets a minimum balance (Reserve) of 10 percent of GF Revenues with a goal of 15 percent  § Balances getting to 15 percent reserve goal with investing in Pay-as-you-go capital needs Policy Language Executive Summary Page 17 of 99 UNASSIGNED FUND BALANCE USES RAINY-DAY FUND § Reserves set aside for use during unexpected deficits § Loss of revenue § Large unplanned expenses § Natural or economic disasters / disruptions § Also known as "Budget Stabilization Funds" § Typically funded with annual budgetary surplus funds § Virginia established a Rainy-Day Fund in 1993; Secretary of Finance expects combined reserves to grow to more than $4.3 billion by FY 2024 § The City’s reserves are carefully monitored by rating agencies  Page 18 of 99 UNASSIGNED FUND BALANCE USES PAY-AS-YOU-GO CAPITAL PROJECTS § Typically funds capital maintenance projects that aren’t bond financed § Average of more than $6.4 million/year over last 10 years § Without pay-as-you-go investment, the equivalent of an additional 8 to 10 cents on the real estate tax rate would have been needed annually for capital maintenance  Page 19 of 99 CALCULATING THE SURPLUS UNASSIGNED FUND BALANCE Page 20 of 99 TAKEAWAYS § Unassigned Fund Balance currently exceeds City Council’s goal of 15  percent of GF Revenues by $1.9 million when adjusting for approved uses and projected future pay-go needs § Recommend not dropping below 15 percent reserve goal in front of uncertain economic future  § Reserve Funds are a key metric tracked by credit rating agencies § FY 2023 tracking towards a budgetary surplus, which will help with pay-go needs in FY 2025 and beyond § Surplus Unassigned Fund Balance amount of $1.9 million can be used for one-time expenses now or in the FY 2024 Budget Page 21 of 99 A COMPARISON OF THE CITY OF L YNCHBURG AND SURROUNDING COUNTIES City Council Retreat Friday, February 10, 2023 1 Page 22 of 99 PRESENTATION OVERVIEW  General Differences between cities and counties in Virginia  Comparison of select characteristics between Lynchburg and surrounding counties  Comparative Spending  Public Safety  Public Works  Health and Human Services  Parks and Culture  Total Per Capita Spending  Takeaways 2 Page 23 of 99 GENERAL DIFFERENCES BETWEEN CITIES AND COUNTIES IN VIRGINIA  Cities are the economic, arts, and culture hubs for their regions.  Cities provide a higher level of service to residents.  There are significant differences in how the state funds cities and counties.  Cities typically have more concentrated poverty, requiring a higher level of support for vulnerable residents.  City infrastructure is typically older and more expensive to maintain.  Cities are usually fully developed, which limits economic development opportunities due to land availability and site prep costs. 3 Page 24 of 99 COMPARISON OF SELECT CHARACTERISTICS L YNCHBURG VS APPOMATTOX, AMHERST, BEDFORD AND CAMPBELL COUNTIES 4 Description Size (sq mi) Density* Average SFH Price Median HH Income Poverty Rate Taxable AV Per Capita Lynchburg 51 1,564 $222,870 $49,201 21.8 percent $69,638 Counties (average) 536 80 $256,731 $58,070 12.1 percent $89,888 Difference (485) 1,484 ($33,861) ($8,869) 9.7 percent ($20,250) *population/square mile Page 25 of 99 COMPARISON OF SELECT CHARACTERISTICS (CONTINUED) L YNCHBURG VS APPOMATTOX, AMHERST, BEDFORD AND CAMPBELL COUNTIES  The Counties have, on average, 10.5 times more land than Lynchburg.  Lynchburg’s population density is 20 times greater than in the counties.  The average single-family home in Lynchburg is worth 15.2 percent less than in the counties.  The median household income in Lynchburg is 18 percent lower than in the counties.  The poverty rate in Lynchburg is 80 percent higher than in the counties.  The taxable assessed value per capita in Lynchburg is 29.1 percent less than in the counties. 5 Page 26 of 99 COMPARATIVE SPENDING L YNCHBURG VS APPOMATTOX, AMHERST, BEDFORD AND CAMPBELL COUNTIES 6 Source: Virginia Auditor of Public Accounts FY 2021 Amended Comparative Report of Local Government Page 27 of 99 7 PUBLIC SAFETY  In FY 2021, Lynchburg spent more than twice as much (107 percent more) per capita than the counties on Public Safety.  Counties do not have police departments and the Sheriff’s Department is primarily funded by the state.  Counties have limited paid fire department staff or are 100 percent volunteer.  If Lynchburg were to adjust its FY 2021 per capita spending to match the counties, it would result in a reduction of $31.3 million – from $60.5 million to $29.2 million. Counties: $364/PC LYH: $753/PC Page 28 of 99 8 PUBLIC WORKS  In FY 2021, Lynchburg spent nearly three times as much (185 percent more) per capita than the counties on Public Works.  Counties have no refuse collection so residents either must take waste to the landfill convenience center or pay for private service.  Counties do not offer bulk and brush collection or leaf collection.  VDOT is responsible for street and highway maintenance in counties.  If Lynchburg were to adjust its FY 2021 spending to match the counties, it would result in a reduction of $18.6 million – from $28.6 million to $10 million. Counties: $125/PC LYH: $356/PC Page 29 of 99 9 HEALTH AND HUMAN SERVICES Counties: $352/PC LYH: $694/PC  In FY 2021, Lynchburg spent nearly twice as much (97.2 percent more) per capita than the counties on Health and Human Services.  Lynchburg’s poverty rate is significantly higher than the counties, resulting in a higher need for service.  Most localities do not have a group home or a juvenile detention center – Lynchburg has both.  If Lynchburg were to adjust its FY 2021 spending to match the counties, it would result in a reduction of $27.5 million – from $55.8 million to $28.3 million. Page 30 of 99 10 PARKS AND CULTURE  In FY 2021, Lynchburg spent nearly 3.5 times as much (240.5 percent more) per capita than the counties on Parks and Culture.  The City has more than a dozen parks, while the counties average much less.  The City has a miles-long trail system, something not found in the counties.  The City offers an extensive array of recreation programming, which many county residents travel into the City to attend.  If Lynchburg were to adjust its spending to match the counties, it would result in a reduction of $7.1 million – from $10.1 million to $3 million. Counties: $37/PC LYH: $126/PC Page 31 of 99 OVERALL FY 2021 PER CAPITA SPENDING In FY 2021, Lynchburg spent 36.6 percent more per capita overall. If Lynchburg were to adjust its overall spending to match the counties, it would result in a reduction of $80 million – from $298.8 million to $218.8 million. 11 Page 32 of 99 TAKEAWAYS  Lynchburg offers its residents more services, amenities and programming than the surrounding counties.  Lynchburg is smaller, denser and poorer, with more vulnerable residents and older infrastructure than the counties.  Cities and counties both have unique competitive advantages that attract residents.  A laser focus on leveraging our competitive advantages is key.  The right services for our residents at the right price. 12 Page 33 of 99 PRELIMINARY FY 2024 REAL ESTATE REASSESSMENT RESUL TS City Council Retreat Friday, February 10, 2023 1 Page 34 of 99 MISSION STATEMENT The Assessor’s Office values real estate every two years. The process is required by VA Code. §58.1-3200 Code of Virginia mandates the Real Estate Assessment process - Our goal is to abide by the Laws and Procedures prescribed and outlined below:  When we perform reassessments- biennially §58.1-3250  Who performs reassessment- Dept. of Real Estate §58.1-3274  Reassessment Valuation Procedures & Practice §58.1-3280  Real Estate at 100% of Fair Market Value* §58.1-3201  Reassessment Records/Land Book Documents §58.1-3300  Public Disclosure/Access to Reassessment Records §58.1-3330/3332  Rules for Administrative & Judicial Review § 58.1-3350  Requirements for Boards of Equalization §58.1-3370/3389  The Assessor’s Office is mandated to value Ad Valorem(according to value); which facilitates the distribution of the actual tax load that is determined via the tax rate set by City Council. 2 Page 35 of 99 *FAIR MARKET VALUE-DEFINED “…the most probable price expressed in terms of money that a property would bring if exposed for sale in the open market in an arm’s-length transaction between a willing seller and a willing buyer, both of whom are knowledgeable concerning all the uses to which it is adapted and for which it is capable of being used.” (Property Assessment Valuation, Chicago: International Association of Assessing Officers, 1977, pg. 21) 3 Page 36 of 99 KEY DATES February 27: Estimated 30,000 Notices of changes in assessment will be sent out to property owners. March 31: Administrative Review period deadline. June 30: Board of Equalization deadline. 4 Page 37 of 99 2023 REASSESSMENT SUMMARY OF CHANGES Taxable Real Estate values increased from $6.3 billion to $7.5 billion due to appreciation, growth, plats and rezoning. Reassessment changes resulted in approximately 20 percent increase in taxable values 5 Page 38 of 99 ALLOWABLE METHODS TO DETERMINE FAIR MARKET VALUE  Cost Approach  Value calculated cost to build an equivalent structure (replacement cost)  Considers the value of land, plus costs of construction, less depreciation  Especially useful when evaluating new construction or unique properties  Sales Comparison Approach  Value calculated by comparing subject property to similar properties that recently sold in the area  Standard method used by residential real estate appraisers  Commonly considers location, recently sold listings, features, age, condition, and size in determining value  Income Approach  Typically used for income producing properties (Commercial / Industrial)  Calculated by dividing net operating income (NOI) by the capitalization rate (expected return) 6 Page 39 of 99 2023 REASSESSMENT – PARCEL VALUES 7 Category Value Total Taxable Value of Non-Exempt City Parcels $7.55 billion (75 percent) Number of Taxable Non-Exempt City Parcels 31,299 Net Tax at Current Levy Rate ($1.11) $83,797,324 Total Value of Exempt City Parcels $2.5 billion (25 percent) Number of Exempt City Parcels 1,625 Total Real Estate Value $10.1 billion Page 40 of 99 2023 REASSESSMENT – COMMERCIAL AND INDUSTRIAL PROPERTIES  Commercial Values: Increased from $1.59 billion to $1.76 billion (10.5 percent).  Commercial Income and Expense Survey average return rate: 37percent  Industrial Values: Increased from $398.7 million to $483.2 million (23 percent).  Industrial Income and Expense Survey average return rate: 36 percent 8 Page 41 of 99 2023 REASSESSMENT – MULTI-FAMILY PROPERTIES  Multi-Family Values: Increased from $620.8 million to $761.2 million (23 percent).  Multi-Family Income and Expense Survey average return rate: 23 percent  There has been significant multi-family sales activity over the last two years.  The main drivers of value are historic increases in rents and a lack of affordable single-family product, which has driven multi-family vacancies below 5 percent. 9 Page 42 of 99 2023 REASSESSMENT – SINGLE-FAMILY PROPERTIES  Single-Family Values: Increased from $3.65 billion to $4.54 billion (24.5 percent).  Key factors driving single-family property prices:  The supply of new homes is less than demand in most parts of the City.  The pandemic created a supply chain bottleneck, causing a shortage of lumber/materials; additionally, there is a skilled labor shortage in the building trades.  We are running out of land for new development. 10 Page 43 of 99 11 Page 44 of 99 2023 MEDIAN RESIDENTIAL VALUE COMPARISON – MEDIAN SINGLE-FAMILY DETACHED 12 Year Value 2020 $130,600 2021 $142,600 2022 $143,700 2023 $182,300 Page 45 of 99 2023 MEDIAN RESIDENTIAL VALUE COMPARISON – TOWNHOME 13 Median Condo Value 2020 = $111,700 2021 = $128,000 2022 = $128,000 2023 = $156,100 Year Value 2020 $103,700 2021 $113,050 2022 $118,300 2023 $141,400 Page 46 of 99 2023 MEDIAN RESIDENTIAL VALUE COMPARISON – CONDO 14 Year Value 2020 $111,700 2021 $128,000 2022 $128,000 2023 $156,100 Page 47 of 99 15  05/10/2019: $223,000  03/11/2022: $291,000  Value Change: 30.49%  Annual Appreciation: 16.63% SALE-RESELL DATA: NEIGHBORHOOD (NBHD) 341- CEDAR RIDGE Page 48 of 99 16  05/31/2019: $355,400  12/15/2021: $505,000  Total Change: 24.69%  Annual Appreciation: 10.22% SALE-RESELL DATA: NBHD 515- BOXWOOD Page 49 of 99 17  12/13/2019: $473,500  05/31/2022: $810,000  Total Change: 71.07%  Annual Appreciation: 47.38% SALE-RESELL DATA: NBHD 517- IRVINGTON PARK Page 50 of 99 18  07/01/2021: $430,000  05/13/2022: $540,000  Total Value Change: 25.58%  Annual Appreciation: 27.91% SALE-RESELL DATA: NBHD 502- WILDWOOD Page 51 of 99 19  08/14/2020: $284,000  08/15/2022: $365,000  Total Change: 28.52%  Annual Appreciation: 14.26% SALE-RESELL DATA NBHD 305- CORNERSTONE Page 52 of 99 20  09/11/2019: $212,000  01/15/2021: $260,000  Total Change: 22.64%  Annual Appreciation: 17.02% SALE-RESELL DATA NBHD 612- NEW SANDUSKY Page 53 of 99 21  07/20/2020: $166,000  11/04/2022: $244,000  Total Change: 46.99%  Annual Change: 20.17% SALE-RESELL DATA NBHD 357- SOUTHLAND/VISTA ACRES Page 54 of 99 22  12/20/2019: $205,000  04/19/2022: $282,500  Total Change: 37.80%  Annual Change: 16.23% SALE-RESELL DATA NBHD 616- FORT HILL- NORTH Page 55 of 99 23  05/29/2020: $173,500  12/17/2021: $215,000  Total Change: 23.92%  Annual Change: 15.94% SALE-RESELL DATA NBHD 616- FORT HILL- NORTH Page 56 of 99 24  07/30/2020: $169,900  03/25/2022: $204,000  Total Change: 20.07%  Annual Change: 12.04% SALE-RESELL DATA NBHD 609- WESTOVER Page 57 of 99 25  08/24/2020: $123,900  11/16/2022: $175,000  Total Change: 41.24%  Annual Change: 18.33% SALE-RESELL DATA NBHD 621- CHESTNUT HILL- WEST Page 58 of 99 2023 REASSESSMENT – ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW PROCESS  Administrative Reviews will occur from February 27- March 31  Administrative Review Forms can be filed electronically online  All residential property owners will receive a sales list for every residential notice mailed  Parcel Viewer is a great resource for additional sales data. Tips to look at when doing research:  Look up your property mailing address to confirm address is correct.  Look at the sketch and supporting info to confirm data is correct.  Check the advance search option to do detailed research.  How does your home value compare to the sale comparable? 26 Page 59 of 99 Member NYSE|FINRA|SIPC February 10, 2023 City of Lynchburg, Virginia Retreat Presentation Page 60 of 99  Davenport & Company LLC (“Davenport”) has served as Financial Advisor to the City of Lynchburg, Virginia (the “City”) for approximately 18 years dating back to 2005.  The Financial Advisory relationship with the City has been continuously managed by David P. Rose, Senior Vice President and Manager of Davenport’s overall Public Finance practice, and Courtney E. Rogers, Senior Vice President who have worked together for over 30 years.  Since serving as the City’s Financial Advisor, Davenport has had the privilege to serve the City in a variety of engagements and act as a resource to help the City maintain its very strong financial condition. February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 1 Davenport & Company LLC Introduction Page 61 of 99 Davenport role as Financial Advisor to the City has included: Assisting with the development of major capital funding strategies for both City Capital and School Capital Projects as well as the City’s Utility projects; Executing the City’s capital funding strategies by helping the City undertake debt financings when needed including issuances in the Public Market as well as Direct Bank Loans; Consulting as requested on budget development strategies with regards to the City’s cash flows; Playing a principal role in the development as well as ongoing monitoring, updating, and amending of the City’s Financial Management Policies; and Serving as a liaison between the City and the National Credit Rating Agencies (i.e. Moody’s, S&P, and Fitch) in connection with both formal rating reviews tied to new debt issuances as well as ongoing surveillances/updates. February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 2 Background / Davenport’s Role as Financial Advisor Page 62 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 3 2023 G.O. Bonds  The City is preparing to sell its 2023 G.O. Bonds (the “2023 Bonds”) in February.  The 2023 Bonds will provide funding for projects appropriated in previous years including: – The new Police Headquarters; – Other City, School and Fleet capital projects; – Water Fund capital projects; – Sewer Fund capital projects; – Stormwater Fund capital projects; and – Airport Fund capital projects.  The City, School, and Fleet Capital projects total $45.4M while the Enterprise projects total $25.9M. Page 63 of 99  The Enterprise Funds are expected to produce sufficient revenues to pay for the debt service on their portion of the 2023 Bonds.  For the City, Schools and Fleet projects the City is projected to need an additional $1.2 million of recurring revenues to cover increased debt service costs associated with the 2023 Bonds over the next few years. This figure was estimated using a very conservative interest rate. Assuming a good interest rate market this figure will be reduced.  This would increase the City’s debt service budget to approximately $18.9 million. February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 4 Estimated Cash Flow Impact - General Fund (1) Includes debt service payments from the FY 2023 Adopted Budget for the General Fund, Schools (exclusive of debt service charge), Fleet Services and the Detention Home Fund. Fiscal Year Existing Debt Service 2023 General Fund GO Bonds Projected Debt Service Total Estimated Debt Service FY 2023 Debt Service Budget (1) Additional Recurring Revenues Needed Resulting Revenues Additional Recurring Revenues Available for Debt Service 2024 $16,139,198 $2,775,068 $18,914,266 $17,717,707 $1,196,559 $18,914,266 $- 2025 15,492,743 3,404,950 18,897,693 17,717,707 18,914,266 16,573 2026 15,285,307 3,402,950 18,688,257 17,717,707 18,914,266 209,436 2027 13,995,216 3,407,200 17,402,416 17,717,707 18,914,266 1,285,840 2028 12,100,421 3,407,450 15,507,871 17,717,707 18,914,266 1,894,545 2029 11,811,294 3,408,575 15,219,869 17,717,707 18,914,266 288,003 2030 10,700,859 3,410,325 14,111,184 17,717,707 18,914,266 1,108,685 2031 9,895,735 3,407,575 13,303,310 17,717,707 18,914,266 807,874 2032 9,705,082 3,405,200 13,110,282 17,717,707 18,914,266 193,028 2033 9,321,326 3,407,825 12,729,151 17,717,707 18,914,266 381,131 Page 64 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 5 Estimated Cash Flow Impact - General Fund (cont.) Note: Projected FY 2024 Debt Service Requirement includes FY 2023 budgeted debt service payments for the General Fund, Schools (exclusive of debt service charge), Fleet Services and the Detention Home Fund plus projected FY 2024 payment on the tax- supported portion of the 2023 Bonds. $0 $2 $4 $6 $8 $10 $12 $14 $16 $18 $20 Millions Existing & Projected Tax-Supported Debt Service Existing Debt Service 2023 General Fund GO Bonds Projected Debt Service Projected FY 2024 Debt Service Requirement Page 65 of 99  If the City maintains its debt service budget at the projected requirement of $18.9 million for FY 2024, it could undertake approximately $77 million in debt over the next 10 years. – This assumes future borrowings are undertaken utilizing a level debt service structure at 5.00% over 20 years.  The City’s capacity increases as existing debt service payments decrease. February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 6 Future Debt Capacity Within Projected FY 2024 Requirement Fiscal Year Additional Recurring Revenues Available for Debt Service Remaining Available Capacity Per Period Cumulative Additional Capacity 2024 $0 $0 2025 16,573 205,000 2026 209,436 2,610,000 2027 1,285,840 16,025,000 2028 1,894,545 23,610,000 2029 288,003 3,590,000 2030 1,108,685 13,815,000 2031 807,874 10,065,000 2032 193,028 2,405,000 2033 381,131 4,750,000 10-Year Total $77,075,000 Projected Remaining Debt Capacity - 5.00% Future Interest Rate $42,450,000 $34,625,000 Page 66 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 7 Capital Improvement Program – General Fund Source: City of Lynchburg 2023 Adopted Budget. The future Bond issues are within City debt guidelines. However, depending upon the timing of the projects, additional revenues will be needed to cover future debt service over the 2024 budgeted debt service. 56% 12% 32% 5-Year Capital Improvement Plan Sources Bond Funding General Cash Fund Other Funding FY 2023 FY 2024 FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027 5-Year Totals City Capital Buildings $47,774,711 $7,875,980 $11,657,500 $16,165,000 $16,568,000 $100,041,191 Transportation 22,968,864 19,971,913 24,950,500 25,979,324 31,394,002 125,264,603 Public Transit 4,730,000 4,781,100 490,100 531,100 1,230,000 11,762,300 Economic Development 7,461,459 6,755,000 3,470,000 6,600,000 2,570,000 26,856,459 Parks and Recreation 5,243,000 1,663,000 6,948,000 5,255,000 3,505,000 22,614,000 Miscellaneous 12,785,208 1,830,000 200,000 200,000 200,000 15,215,208 Reserves 350,000 350,000 350,000 350,000 250,000 1,650,000 Total City Capital $101,313,242 $43,226,993 $48,066,100 $55,080,424 $55,717,002 $303,403,761 School Capital Schools $ - $2,501,000 $4,620,000 $4,595,000 $35,020,000 $46,736,000 Total School Capital $ - $2,501,000 $4,620,000 $4,595,000 $35,020,000 $46,736,000 Total Uses $101,313,242 $45,727,993 $52, 686,100 $59,675,424 $90,737,002 $350,139,761 Sources Bond Funding $29,733,140 $18,809,913 $41,549,750 $33,411,658 $73,068,001 $196,572,462 General Cash Fund 9,798,546 9,718,484 6,105,012 7,295,952 8,106,800 41,024,794 Other Funding 61,781,556 17,199,596 5,031,338 18,967,814 9,562,201 112,542,505 Total Sources $101,313,242 $45,727,993 $52, 686,100 $59,675,424 $90,737,002 $350,139,761 Summary of Appropriations (City Capital and Schools) - FY 2023 - FY 2027 Capital Improvement Program Page 67 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 8 Estimated Available Unassigned Fund Balance Beyond Council Financial Management Policy Source: City of Lynchburg ACFRs, and 2023 Adopted Budget. The City revised its fund balance policy on December 10, 2019 to maintain its minimum Unassigned General Fund Balance (UGFB) target at 10% of General Fund revenues while also establishing a goal of 15% as the City strives to grow it incrementally each year subject to revenues available. The City plans to balance moving towards the 15% targeted fund balance with its annual “Pay as you go” capital improvement requirements. *Note: 2023 Unassigned Fund Balance represents a preliminary estimate from City Staff. Fiscal Year General Fund Unassigned Fund Balance General Fund Revenue General Fund Unassigned Fund Balance as a % of GF Revenues City Policy Future Target (Approx. 5 Years) 2014 $33,878,501 $173,619,523 19.5% 10.0% 15.0% 2015 32,089,924 176,615,630 18.2% 10.0% 15.0% 2016 25,589,098 180,853,471 14.1% 10.0% 15.0% 2017 27,147,729 184,021,445 14.8% 10.0% 15.0% 2018 29,197,526 186,818,862 15.6% 10.0% 15.0% 2019 29,364,685 190,091,362 15.4% 10.0% 15.0% 2020 34,579,844 192,770,975 17.9% 10.0% 15.0% 2021 49,771,343 196,982,499 25.3% 10.0% 15.0% 2022 66,394,917 213,188,870 31.1% 10.0% 15.0% 2023* 50,498,359 224,877,781 22.5% 10.0% 15.0% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023* Unassigned General Fund Balance (As a % of Revenues) General Fund Unassigned Fund Balance as a % of GF Revenues City Policy Future Target (Approx. 5 Years) $0 $10 $20 $30 $40 $50 $60 $70 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023* Millions Unassigned General Fund Balance (In Dollars) Page 68 of 99  In order to maintain the City’s position of financial strength from a credit rating perspective, Davenport and City Staff recommend the following are taken into consideration during the development of the FY 2024 Budget: – The continued impact of inflation on the City’s operating expenditures and capital project costs; Inflation reached a 40-Year high of 9.1% during FY 2022, and remains above 7% today. – Additional pressure on the City’s operating expenditures from onboarding new employees and retaining existing staff – particularly police officers and other emergency personnel; – The potential impact of an economic downturn on the City’s operating revenues; and, – Increases in debt service related to the financing of future capital projects. February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 9 Challenges Over the Next Three to Five Years Page 69 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 10 Rating Agency Commentary – 2009 (Post Economic Downturn) Agency Year Excerpt Moody’s 2009 “Fiscal 2009, ended June 30, proved to be a challenging year for many issuers due to the economic recession. Management reports economically sensitive revenues, primarily sales, meals and personal property performed $2.75 million under budget.” Moody’s 2009 “Given this shortfall and the budgeted use of $16.2 million of reserves, which other favorable budgetary variances only partially replenished, General Fund balance is projected to decrease by approximately $11 million to $23.7 million...” Moody’s 2009 “Moving forward, Moody's believes that slowed revenue growth will likely impact the city's ability to fund pay-as-you-go capital projects at historically strong levels, but reserve levels will remain consistent with policy objectives given the city's conservative management practices.” Fitch 2009 “Hiring freezes, a two-and-a-half day furlough, and departmental reductions were implemented in fiscal 2009 in response to projected revenue declines, and the city anticipates a general fund balance reduction of $7.6 million, inclusive of $5.9 million of pay-as-you-go capital financing.” S&P 2009 “On the expenditure side, the city implemented a hiring freeze and reductions in departmental spending and projects a $1.9 million decrease from the amended budget.” Source: City of Lynchburg Rating Reports. Page 70 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 11 Rating Agency Commentary – Last Published Ratings Agency Date Excerpt Moody’s Dec. 2019 “Lynchburg has a history of maintaining healthy reserve levels because of long-term financial forecasting and adherence to prudent fiscal policies. Fiscal 2019 marked the city's third consecutive year of positive operations, which contributed to a year end general fund surplus of $4 million, despite allocating $6.8 million to the city and school capital project funds for one-time capital expenditures” Moody’s Dec. 2019 “Total fund balance equaled $68.4 million or an ample 35.9% of revenues, and available (unassigned, assigned, committed) general fund balance was $54.4 million, or 26.6% of general fund revenues over the past five years. The city's reserves, while stable, fall below the national Aa2 reserve median (total general fund balance of 44% of revenues).” S&P Dec. 2019 “Lynchburg's budgetary performance has been strong overall, in our view, benefitting from conservative budgeting practices and several formal fiscal policies. These practices have allowed for the generation of surpluses over the past three fiscal years, which have in turn, increased reserves; keeping them at very strong levels.” Fitch Dec. 2019 “Fitch expects that in the event of an actual revenue decline of this magnitude (moderate economic decline), the city would maintain reserves at or above its policy level (an unassigned general fund balance equal to no less than 10% of revenue) through active expenditure management.” Source: City of Lynchburg Rating Reports. Page 71 of 99 Virginia First Cities Comparison February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 12 Page 72 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 13 Population Source(s): MFRA and Locality Audits. Virginia First Cities Population Lynchburg 80,054 Median 47,217 Lexington 7,456 Martinsville 13,517 Williamsburg 15,034 Staunton 25,661 Winchester 27,912 Petersburg 33,429 Danville 42,215 Charlottesville 47,217 Harrisonburg 53,558 Portsmouth 94,961 Hampton 135,169 Newport News 179,582 Richmond 229,233 Norfolk 244,300 - 50 100 150 200 250 Norfolk Richmond Newport News Hampton Portsmouth Harrisonburg Charlottesville Danville Petersburg Winchester Staunton Williamsburg Martinsville Lexington Median Lynchburg Thousands Population Page 73 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 14 General Fund Revenues Source(s): MFRA and Locality Audits. Virginia First Cities General Fund Revenues Lynchburg $213,189,000 Median 132,281,000 Lexington 20,322,000 Martinsville 35,626,221 Williamsburg 40,723,000 Staunton 64,979,887 Petersburg 76,275,000 Danville 96,931,000 Winchester 99,387,000 Harrisonburg 132,281,000 Charlottesville 195,892,000 Portsmouth 252,075,000 Hampton 376,852,000 Newport News 538,152,000 Norfolk 701,607,000 Richmond 774,248,000 $0 $200 $400 $600 $800 Richmond Norfolk Newport News Hampton Portsmouth Charlottesville Harrisonburg Winchester Danville Petersburg Staunton Williamsburg Martinsville Lexington Median Lynchburg Millions General Fund Revenues Page 74 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 15 $0.0 $0.5 $1.0 $1.5 $2.0 $2.5 $3.0 $3.5 $4.0 $4.5 Charlottesville Winchester Richmond Newport News Norfolk Hampton Lexington Williamsburg Portsmouth Martinsville Staunton Harrisonburg Danville Petersburg Median Lynchburg Thousands General Fund Revenues per Capita General Fund Revenues Per Capita Source(s): MFRA and Locality Audits. Virginia First Cities General Fund Revenues per Capita Lynchburg $2,663 Median 2,709 Petersburg 2,282 Danville 2,296 Harrisonburg 2,470 Staunton 2,532 Martinsville 2,636 Portsmouth 2,655 Williamsburg 2,709 Lexington 2,726 Hampton 2,788 Norfolk 2,872 Newport News 2,997 Richmond 3,378 Winchester 3,561 Charlottesville 4,149 Page 75 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 16 Full Value (Real Property, Personal Property, and Machinery & Tools) Source(s): MFRA and Locality Audits. Virginia First Cities Full Value Lynchburg $7,503,768,786 Median 5,255,074,000 Lexington 619,321,000 Martinsville 792,510,000 Staunton 2,024,971,000 Williamsburg 2,272,142,000 Petersburg 2,274,552,000 Danville 3,024,543,000 Winchester 4,331,995,000 Harrisonburg 5,255,074,000 Portsmouth 7,924,166,000 Hampton 11,925,859,000 Charlottesville 12,130,799,000 Newport News 20,673,643,000 Norfolk 26,681,757,000 Richmond 34,840,857,000 $0 $5 $10 $15 $20 $25 $30 $35 Richmond Norfolk Newport News Charlottesville Hampton Portsmouth Harrisonburg Winchester Danville Petersburg Williamsburg Staunton Martinsville Lexington Median Lynchburg Billions Full Value Note: Moody’s calculates Full Value as the total value of all Real Property, Personal Property, and Machinery & Tools. This is also equal to the Total Taxable Assessed Value of the City. Page 76 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 17 Full Value per Capita Source(s): MFRA and Locality Audits. Note: X-Axis is truncated at $175,000. Virginia First Cities Full Value per Capita Lynchburg $93,734 Median 93,734 Martinsville 58,631 Petersburg 68,041 Danville 71,646 Staunton 78,912 Lexington 83,063 Portsmouth 83,447 Hampton 88,229 Harrisonburg 98,119 Norfolk 109,217 Newport News 115,121 Williamsburg 151,134 Richmond 151,989 Winchester 155,202 Charlottesville 256,916 $0 $20 $40 $60 $80 $100 $120 $140 $160 Charlottesville Winchester Richmond Williamsburg Newport News Norfolk Harrisonburg Hampton Portsmouth Lexington Staunton Danville Petersburg Martinsville Median Lynchburg Thousands Full Value per Capita Note: Moody’s calculates Full Value as the total value of all Real Property, Personal Property, and Machinery & Tools. This is also equal to the Total Taxable Assessed Value of the City. Page 77 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 18 Unassigned Fund Balance Note: Median calculation does not include Lynchburg FY2023 Projected. Source(s): MFRA and Locality Audits. Virginia First Cities Unassigned Fund Balance Lynchburg FY2022 $66,394,917 Projected FY2023 50,498,359 Median 34,237,458 Martinsville 6,286,060 Staunton 6,479,724 Lexington 12,738,990 Williamsburg 20,541,513 Charlottesville 23,337,260 Winchester 24,951,839 Petersburg 25,232,435 Danville 34,237,458 Harrisonburg 53,108,748 Newport News 77,812,968 Portsmouth 80,433,488 Hampton 91,650,181 Norfolk 92,920,042 Richmond 107,862,492 $0 $40 $80 $120 Richmond Norfolk Hampton Portsmouth Newport News Harrisonburg Danville Petersburg Winchester Charlottesville Williamsburg Lexington Staunton Martinsville Median Projected FY2023 Lynchburg FY2022 Millions Unassigned Fund Balance Page 78 of 99 February 10, 2023 Retreat Presentation 19 Unassigned Fund Balance to G.F. Revenues Source(s): MFRA and Locality Audits. Note: Median calculation does not include Lynchburg FY2023 Projected. Virginia First Cities Unassigned Fund Balance to G.F. Revenues Lynchburg FY2022 31.1% Projected FY 2023 22.5% Median 25.1% Staunton 10.0% Charlottesville 11.9% Norfolk 13.2% Richmond 13.9% Newport News 14.5% Martinsville 17.6% Hampton 24.3% Winchester 25.1% Portsmouth 31.9% Petersburg 33.1% Danville 35.3% Harrisonburg 40.1% Williamsburg 50.4% Lexington 62.7% 0.0% 10.0% 20.0% 30.0% 40.0% 50.0% 60.0% 70.0% Lexington Williamsburg Harrisonburg Danville Petersburg Portsmouth Winchester Hampton Martinsville Newport News Richmond Norfolk Charlottesville Staunton Median Projected FY 2023 Lynchburg FY2022 Unassigned Fund Balance to G.F. Revenues Page 79 of 99 Richmond — Headquarters One James Center 901 East Cary Street, Suite 1100, Richmond, Virginia 23219 Telephone: (804) 780-2000 Toll-Free: (800) 846-6666 E-Mail: info@investdavenport.com February 10, 2023 Courtney E. Rogers Senior Vice President (804) 697-2902 crogers@investdavenport.com David P. Rose Manager of Public Finance Senior Vice President (804) 697-2905 drose@investdavenport.com A.J. Allen Analyst (804) 780-2796 ajallen@investdavenport.com Retreat Presentation 20 Stephen G. Geisz Associate Vice President (804) 697-2986 sgeisz@investdavenport.com Page 80 of 99 The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) has clarified that a broker, dealer or municipal securities dealer engaging in municipal adv isory activities outside the scope of underwriting a particular issuance of municipal securities should be subj ect to municipal advisor registration. Davenport & Company LLC (“Davenpo rt”) has registered as a municipal advisor with the SEC. As a registered municipal advisor Davenport may provid e advice to a municipal entity or obligated person. An obligated person is an entity other than a municipal entity, such as a not for profit corporation, that has commenced an application or negotiation with an entity to issue municipal securities on its behalf and for which it will provide support. If and when an issuer engages Davenport to provide financial advisory or consul tant services with respect to the issu ance of municipal securities, Davenport is obligated to evidence such a financial advisory relationship with a written agreement. When acting as a registered municipal advisor Davenport is a fiduciary requ ired by federal law to act in the best interest of a municipal entity without regard to its own financial or other interests. Davenport is not a fiduciary when it acts as a registered investm ent advisor, when advising an obligated person, or when acting as an underw riter, though it is required to deal fairly with such persons, This material was prepared by public finance, or o ther non-research personnel of Davenport. This m aterial was not produced by a research analyst, alt hough it may refer to a Davenport research analyst or research report. Unless other wise indicated, these views (if any) are the auth or’s and may differ from those of the Davenport fixed income or research department or others in the firm. Davenport may perform or seek to perform financial advisory services for the issuers of the securities and instruments mentioned herein. This material has been prepared for information purposes only and is not a so licitation of any offer to buy or sell any security/instrument or to partic ipate in any trading strategy. Any such offer would be made only after a prospective partic ipant had completed its own independent investigation of the securities, instruments or transact ions and received all information it required to make its own investment decision, including, where applicable, a review of any offering circular or memorandum describing such security or instrument. That information would contain material information not contained herein and to which prospective participants are referred. This material is based on public information as of the specified date, and may be stale thereafter. We have no obligation to tell you when information herein m ay change. We make no representation o r warranty with respect to the compl eteness of this material. Davenport has no obligation to continue to publish information on the securi ties/instruments mentioned herein. Recipients are required to comply w ith any legal or contractual restrictions on their purchase, holding, sale, exercise of rights or performance of obligations under any securities/instruments transaction. The securities/instruments discussed in this material may not be suitable f or all investors or issuers. Recipients should seek independent financi al advice prior to making any investment decision based on this material. This material does not provide individual ly tailored investment advice or offer tax, regulatory, accounting or leg al advice. Prior to entering into any proposed transaction, recipients should determine, in consultation with their own investment, legal, tax, regulatory and accounting advisors, th e economic risks and merits, as well as the legal, tax, regulatory and accounting characteristics and consequences, of the transaction. You sh ould consider this material as only a single factor in making an investment decision. The value of and income from investments and the cost of borrowing may vary be cause of changes in interest rates, foreign exchange rates, default rates , prepayment rates, securities/instruments prices, market indexes, operational or financial conditions or companies or other factors. There may be time limitations o n the exercise of options or other rights in securities/instruments transactions. Past performance is not necessari ly a guide to future performance and estimates of future performance are ba sed on assumptions that may not be realized. Actual events may differ from those assume d and changes to any assumptions may have a material impact on any projections or estimates. Other events not taken into account may occur and may significantly affect the projections or estimates. Certain assumptions may have been made for modeling purposes or to simplify the p resentation and/or calculation of any projections or estimates, and Davenport does not represent that any such assumptions will reflect actual future events. Accordingly, there can b e no assurance that estimated returns or projections will be realized or that actual returns or performance results will not materially differ from those estimated herein. This material m ay not be sold or redistributed without the prior written consent of Davenport. Version 01/01/2023 AA/SG/CR/DR February 10, 2023 Disclaimer Retreat Presentation 21 Page 81 of 99 STRUCTURING TAX RELIEF:  CITY COUNCIL’S TAX LEVERS          City Council Retreat Friday, February 10, 2023 Page 82 of 99 PRESENTATION OVERVIEW § Who are our Taxpayers § Council Tax Levers and the Revenue Rules of Thumb § Comprehensive Look at Taxes, Rates, and Revenue § Discussion Questions 2 Page 83 of 99 WHO ARE OUR TAXPAYERS? § Citizens  § Businesses § Visitors § Real Property Owners 3 § Some taxpayers fall into more than one group  § Not all citizens or businesses own real property § Meals, Transient Occupancy, Amusement and Tobacco taxes are paid by buyers and held in trust and ultimately remitted by businesses  Page 84 of 99 COUNCIL TAX LEVERS – RULES OF THUMB 4 Page 85 of 99 REAL ESTATE TAX A TAX ON REAL PROPERTY THAT IS CALCULATED ACCORDING TO PROPERTY’S FAIR MARKET VALUE AND A TAX RATE SET BY CITY COUNCIL 5 Revenue $83,040,00 0 Increment $0.01 Per $100 of Assessed Value Tax Rate $1.11 Per $100 of Assessed Value Tax Accounts 30,463 Taxpayers Real Property Owners Increment Value $750,000 Page 86 of 99 PERSONAL PROPERTY TAX A TAX ON THE VALUE OF ANY VEHICLE NORMALLY GARAGED IN THE CITY AND ANY TANGIBLE BUSINESS PROPERTY THAT IS NOT REAL PROPERTY TO INCLUDE MACHINERY, EQUIPMENT, FURNITURE, FIXTURES, CERTAIN COMPUTER HARDWARE AND ANY OTHER TANGIBLE PROPERTY USED IN A BUSINESS UNLESS SPECIFICALLY EXEMPTED 6 Revenue $23,180,00 0 Increment $0.10 Per $100 of Assessed Value Tax Rate $3.80 (general) $3.00 (Machinery and Tools) Per $100 of Assessed Value Tax Accounts 39,444 Taxpayers Citizens & Businesses Increment Value $610,000 Page 87 of 99 MOTOR VEHICLE LICENSE FEE A FEE CHARGED TO REGISTER ANY MOTOR VEHICLE, MOTORCYCLE, TRAILER, OR SEMI-TRAILER IN THE CITY. 7 Revenue $1,550,000 Increment $5.00 Tax Rate $29.50/ $34.50 Depending on GVW Tax Accounts 57,514 Taxpayers Citizens & Businesses Increment Value $250,000 Page 88 of 99 MEALS TAX A TAX, IN ADDITION TO SALES AND USE TAX, CHARGED ON THE PURCHASE OF PREPARED FOOD. 8 Revenue $20,000,00 0 Increment 1% Tax Rate 6.5% Tax Accounts N/A Taxpayers Visitors, Citizens & Businesses Increment Value $3,060,000 Page 89 of 99 LODGING TAX A TAX ON THE RENTAL OF ROOMS THAT IS CALCULATED BASED ON THE PRICE OF THE ACCOMMODATION 9 Revenue $3,640,000 Increment 1% Tax Rate 6.5% Tax Accounts N/A Taxpayers Visitors Increment Value $560,000 Page 90 of 99 BED TAX A TAX ON THE RENTAL OF ROOMS THAT IS CALCULATED BASED ON A PER NIGHT AMOUNT 10 Revenue $350,000 Increment $1 Per Room Night Tax Rate $1 Per Room Night Tax Accounts N/A Taxpayers Visitors Increment Value $350,000 Page 91 of 99 AMUSEMENT TAX A TAX ON THE AMOUNT PAID FOR THE PRIVILEGE OF ADMISSION TO PLACES OF AMUSEMENT OR ATHLETIC EVENTS 11 Revenue $850,000 Increment 1% Tax Rate 7.0% Tax Accounts N/A Taxpayers Citizens & Visitors Increment Value $120,000 Page 92 of 99 TOBACCO TAX A TAX IMPOSED ON TOBACCO PRODUCTS 12 Revenue $800,000 Increment $0.05 Per Pack of 20 Cigarettes Tax Rate $0.35 Per Pack of 20 Cigarettes Tax Accounts N/A Taxpayers Citizens & Visitors Increment Value $110,000 Page 93 of 99 BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONAL AND OCCUPATIONAL LICENSE TAX (BPOL) A TAX ON THE GROSS RECEIPTS OF A BUSINESS 13 Revenue $10,500,00 0 Increment 10% Of Total Tax Tax Rate $0.20 – Retailer Merchant $0.16 – Contractors $0.36 – Business/Personal Svcs $0.58 – Professional Services Per $100 of Gross Receipts Tax Accounts 1,800 Taxpayers Businesses Increment Value $1,000,000 Page 94 of 99 CONSUMER UTILITY TAX - ELECTRICITY A TAX ON THE USE OF ELECTRICITY PER KILOWATT HOUR 14 Revenue $3,500,000 Increment Maintain or Eliminate Tax Tax Rate It’s Complicate d (See Footnote) Tax Accounts N/A Taxpayers Citizens and Businesses Increment Value $3,500,000 Residential Rate: The greater of: $0.0046 for the first 1,000 kwh (or a fraction thereof plus $0.0026 for each kwh over the first 1,000 kwh or 7% of the minimum monthly charge Commercial Rate: The greater of: $0.0048 for the first 1,000 kwh (or a fraction thereof plus $0.0092 for each kwh over the first 1,000 kwh or 7% of the minimum monthly charge Industrial Rate: The greater of: $0.00375 for the first 1,000 kwh (or a fraction thereof plus $0.0026 for each kwh over the first 1,000 kwh or 7% of the minimum monthly charge Page 95 of 99 CONSUMER UTILITY TAX - GAS A TAX ON THE USE OF NATURAL GAS PER CENTUM CUBIC FEET 15 Revenue $610,000 Increment Maintain or Eliminate Tax Tax Rate It’s Complicate d (See Footnote) Tax Accounts TBD Taxpayers Citizens and Businesses Increment Value $610,000 Residential Rate: $0.86 per month plus $0.05088 on each CCF or fraction thereof delivered monthly Commercial Rate: $1.63 per month plus $0.02689 on each CCF or fraction thereof delivered monthly Industrial Rate: $1.63 per month plus $0.00256 on each CCF or fraction thereof delivered monthly Page 96 of 99 REFUSE COLLECTION FEE A FLAT MONTHLY FEE CHARGED BY THE CITY FOR RESIDENTIAL REFUSE COLLECTION 16 Revenue $2,640,000 Increment Maintain or Eliminate Fee Tax Rate $10 Per Month Tax Accounts TBD Taxpayers Citizens Increment Value $2,640,000 Page 97 of 99 WHO ARE OUR TAXPAYERS? 17 Revenue Source Citizens Visitors Businesses Real Property Owners Real Estate Tax X Personal Property Tax X X Motor Vehicle Licenses X X Meals Tax  X X Lodging Tax  X Amusement Tax  X X Tobacco Tax X X Business License Tax (BPOL) X Consumer Utility - Electric X X Consumer Utility - Gas X X Refuse Collection Fee X Page 98 of 99 DISCUSSION QUESTIONS § Which classification of taxpayers need tax relief the most? § Which classification of taxpayers need tax relief the least? § Would you substitute a higher tax rate in one area for a lower tax rate in another? 18 Page 99 of 99

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.