City Council Meeting — Minutes
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Jan 24, 2023 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
January 24, 2023
1
// A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 24th day of January 2023, at
4:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie Reed, President, presiding. The following
Members of the Council were present:
Present: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, Jeff Helgeson, MaryJane Dolan, Marty Misjuns, Sterling
Wilder, Larry Taylor 7
Absent: 0
// In the matter of Public Works, Agenda Item #1, Deputy Director of Public Works Mr. Clay Simmons
provided a presentation for informational purposes regarding pavement management using the pavement
condition index data. Each year, the City dedicates about $2,500,000 to dedicated Highway Maintenance
Funds toward Street Overlay (paving) in the Capital Improvement Program. Public Works uses a data-
driven approach to determine which streets are eligible for re-paving. Data is collected on all 800 lane
miles of our primary, secondary and residential streets approximately every five years using a specialized
vehicle called an automatic road analyzer (ARAN). Streets are rated on a scale of 1-100 with 100 being in
excellent condition. Streets that are rated below 60 are considered fair to the poor and are eligible to be
considered for the spring and fall paving list.
Councilmember Helgeson asked whether new paving techniques and technologies had been
used to patch potholes. Mr. Simmons responded that cold-patching was typically used in the winter when
asphalt production was not open. He said that cold-patching did not withstand high-traffic roadways, and
the potholes would reopen.
// In the matter of Schools, Agenda Item #2, Council was briefed on the appropriation of fund balance
from FY 2022 unexpended schools operating fund. Mayor Reed stated that the item would appear before
Council for action on February 14, 2023. Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt provided the staff report.
This action is requested in accordance with an agreement, dated December 14, 1993, signed by the
Lynchburg City Council and the Lynchburg City School Board. This agreement provides for the creation
and maintenance of a Schools Operating Fund fund balance for “the purpose of underwriting any
occasional shortfalls from the various budgetary categories of direct state funding support as well as other
applications, all based upon the required expenditure approval of the School Board.” A request was
submitted by letter to the City Manager on December 9, 2022, for use of the FY 2022 Schools Fund
January 24, 2023
2
Balance. The Lynchburg City School Board approved the attached submittal at the December 6, 2022,
School Board meeting.
Vice Mayor Faraldi requested information regarding the R.S. Pane building envelope repair.
Deputy Superintendent Dr. Reid A. Wodicka stated that the CIP development was focused on ensuring
the buildings were safe and stable. He said that R.S. Pane had a significant amount of water infiltration
into the structures, and Lynchburg City Schools (LCS) had begun replacing roofs throughout the division.
He explained that the building had an exterior masonry envelope around the building, and it was
deteriorating. He said that there were other masonry issues at R.S. Pane. He stated that the water
infiltration issues were not related to water issues over the winter. He noted there were water-related
issues in the gymnasium and auditorium.
Vice Mayor Faraldi requested a further breakdown regarding what the funds would be used for
and what improvements would be made. He clarified that the issues were unrelated to the water issues
over winter break. Dr. Wodicka stated that over winter break, the power went out and waterlines in the
HVAC system broke and caused some flooding among other damage. He said that the damage had since
been repaired.
Vice Mayor Faraldi requested more information regarding security projects and the structural
analysis and repair of the schools. Dr. Wodicka stated that they would ensure the structural cracks found
during the facilities assessment were addressed before they became worse.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked whether Council could specifically allocate the funds for security
purposes to the School Board. Ms. Witt responded that the Council had $1.2M in a contingency reserve
that could be considered for such uses. She stated that the Council could return a specific portion of the
funds to the School Board.
Councilmember Taylor noted that the damage had occurred for a while and asked why it had not
yet been addressed. Dr. Wodicka responded that there had been a tremendous amount of deferred
maintenance. Councilmember Taylor noted that there was mold in the pictures.
Councilmember Misjuns requested to know how long maintenance had been deferred and when
the problems had been identified.
January 24, 2023
3
// In the matter of Schools, Agenda Item #3, Council was briefed on the 1993 Letter of Agreement
Between Lynchburg City Council and Lynchburg City Schools. Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt
provided the staff report. Council requested this item be included on the agenda for discussion on
whether the 1993 agreement should continue as written.
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that the agreement should be terminated. He said that he would
appreciate input from the School Board.
Councilmember Helgeson stated that he would support a discontinuation option. He noted that
enrollment had decreased, but they had the same number of buildings and operating costs had
increased.
Councilmember Misjuns stated that he believed the agreement should be repealed.
Councilmember Wilder stated that he supported maintaining the agreement as it was. He said
that the school buildings were City property, and they should trust the School Board to appropriately
utilize the one-time funds.
Councilmember Dolan said that the School Board and school system should not be penalized for
being frugal with their money. There were many buildings in need of repair, but that was because there
was a lack of resources made available to them, and this would put a further wrench in their ability to do
things. She said that the School Board had the best knowledge of the maintenance of the buildings and
the best use of these funds.
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that the School Board had received tens of millions of dollars from
ARPA funding that could have been used for infrastructure projects to accommodate for some of these
things, but other things were chosen over this one specifically.
Councilmember Helgeson asked if there would be documentation provided to the Council this
evening or at the next meeting, or if direction from Council was sought from the staff at this time. Mr.
Freedman answered that he did not think there was a majority in one direction or the other. He suggested
that this matter be discussed with the School Board at a later date as a starting point for finding a majority
in a particular direction. Councilmember Helgeson asked if a motion to find that consensus would be
beneficial at this time. Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that it was not in the procedural nature of work sessions
to make a motion for a matter such as this, so he suggested those who had not expressed insight to offer
January 24, 2023
4
it so that a direction would be received from the majority. Mr. Freedman said that he was perhaps
misunderstanding; he had not seen a majority in favor to terminate the agreement. Councilmember
Helgeson said that he heard from two people who wanted to keep it as it stood currently. Mr. Freedman
said that he had also heard mentioned one modification and two terminations. Vice Mayor Faraldi said
that he was open to modification so that it was not required, or termination if it was the best direction. Mr.
Benda said that by way of procedure, it would be positioned for a vote at the next scheduled meeting,
which was February 14, 2023. He said that if the 1993 amendment were appealed, it would have a
procedural impact because those resources would go to an unassigned fund balance, which would result
in a number that would allow them to have subsequent conversations about how those monies were
spent.
Councilmember Misjuns asked if the current agreement would only require one vote to
appropriate the monies requested or if two votes were required. Mr. Benda answered that it still required
two votes. Councilmember Misjuns asked if the agreement were appealed, it would take two agreements
to appropriate those monies if they requested them from the unassigned general fund balance. Mr. Benda
said yes. Councilmember Misjuns asked if there was any procedural change and whether or not the
agreement was repealed. Mr. Benda said that was one means, but the history included a concern in the
early 1990s that the schools were spending down what they had quickly, so he did not know what it would
mean for them financially, and right now they had something that was a gauge to revisit annually.
City Attorney Mr. Freedman asked if he should send a letter on behalf of his office to the School
Board Chair and the Superintendent advising them of the date that the 1993 agreement would be
revisited for modification or cancellation. Councilmember Helgeson said that once they voted on it, they
could decide whether to send the letter, either doing so today or on February 14.
Councilmember Wilder requested data on what the fund balance had been used for in the past
few years, which would allow for a better understanding for Council and parents with children in the
school system.
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that he was comfortable with discussing termination at the February 14
meeting.
January 24, 2023
5
Mr. Freedman said that the idea was to give notice to the School Board, so while the Council was
within its rights to modify or repeal the agreement, he would ask if he should send a letter to them making
them aware so that they could come in to be heard. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked why notification would be
sent if an action had not yet been taken. Mr. Freedman replied that there was potential action to be
expected on February 14.
Mayor Reed asked what the procedure for putting the item on the agenda for the February 14
meeting would be. Mr. Freedman suggested that the item go on the agenda for a vote with a resolution,
but he would submit that due to it being an agreement, notice should be given to the other party to the
agreement so that they had an opportunity to respond in some way. Mayor Reed asked what steps were
needed to be taken at this point. Mr. Freedman said that if there was consensus for a letter coming from
his office to state that the matter was up for a vote, he would certainly do so.
// In the matter of Lynchburg Municipal Employees Federal Credit Union (LMEFCU), Agenda Item #4,
Council was briefed on an Extension of Agreement of Lease between the entity and the City. Mayor Reed
stated that this item would appear before Council for action on February 14, 2023. Ms. Gaynelle Hart,
Director of Public Works, gave a brief overview to Council. In October 1999, the City and LMEFCU
entered into an Agreement of Lease wherein the Credit Union leased the "Caretaker's House" at the City
Stadium for the purpose of operating the Credit Union for a term of five years. That lease agreement has
been extended for three-five-year terms with the most recent agreement ending on September 30, 2019.
Since that time, the October 25, 1999 Agreement of Lease has continued month-to-month without formal
renewal since September 30, 2019. The Credit Union now desires to formally extend the said Agreement
of Lease for an additional term of five years.
// In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Wilder thanked the Martin Luther King, Jr. Lynchburg
Community Council for the breakfast they held at The Virginian with one of the first African-Americans to
integrate E.C. Glass High School, who gave a very moving speech. He thanked the committee members
who participated at that event and stated the importance of Dr. King’s contributions and those that had
been made by everyone since his time. He said that by following principles of love and community
service, they would continue to positively impact their community.
January 24, 2023
6
Councilmember Helgeson said that last week, Liberty University began school again, which had
had a notable impact on the tourism industry. The school was experiencing a record number of students
enrolled this year, and it was good to see the students back.
Councilmember Misjuns brought forward an item for discussion. Lynchburg City Schools (LCS)
recently adopted a policy regarding the identification of sexually explicit instructional materials and the
responsibility for parental notification made in response to a change in Virginia law. He applauded the
policy but believed that it could further protect children’s education and innocence in schools and that it
was within the purview of the City Council when appropriate to make recommendations to the School
Board on issues related to the operation of public schools. He stated that he sought a majority consensus
from his colleagues to strengthen the new policy to ensure that parents’ rights were a top priority of the
School Board along with protecting the children. Opposition to this measure may include concerns over
book-banning or censorship, which was untrue, as he was not asking for any instructional materials to be
removed, but simply asking for the school system to request permission from parents rather than relying
on implied consent to share materials with minors that may contain “bestiality, lewd exhibitions of nudity,
sexual excitement or sexual conduct, sadomasochistic abuse, coprophilia, or urophilia,” as stated in the
policy. Some of these materials in their public schools contained the topic of sexual exploration and how
sex apps worked, which in paraphrase was that after uploading a picture and enabling location services,
the app put the user in touch with people nearby to chat or, because they were nearby, to meet them in
person. There was no excuse for this book to be in the hands of a minor without express parental
consent. In 2018, the National Institute of Health recognized that the use of smartphone dating apps has
significantly created an emerging risk factor for sexual abuse. It was common knowledge that sexual
predators used these applications to find and exploit minors, so he could not in good conscience have
this knowledge of pedophiles preying on the community’s children and not speak out on it when taxpayer-
funded material existed in their schools that would encourage minors how to use these apps that made
them vulnerable to exploitation. He indicated the letter that would endorse this action, which he requested
all Councilmembers to sign.
Mr. Taylor thanked the law enforcement community for the work done in the last weeks in
responding to several shootings in Lynchburg and apprehending the perpetrator.
January 24, 2023
7
Vice Mayor Faraldi expressed his regret in being unable to join his colleagues at the MLK, Jr.
event due to a previous work engagement. He said a citizen brought to his attention the intersection of
Jubal Street and Lakeside Drive, and the entrance issues, visibility, and lane painting. He asked if
information related to the crash data at that intersection could be made available. He had received
multiple requests of the Billings & Collections window being closed and he would like information about
what was needed to make that available. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda replied there was a staffing
issue and they hoped that within a short period that there would be a forward-facing person to staff that
window. Vice Mayor Faraldi asked if the information could be made available on how to do so. Mr. Benda
said yes. Vice Mayor Faraldi commended Councilmember Misjuns for his initiative, and he also would be
putting something in writing to the School Board about the same matter, requesting that the policy be
changed so that the burden was not on individual parents to go to the school to change their child’s
education.
Mayor Reed thanked Councilmember Misjuns for articulating his feelings on this issue. Many
emails had been received from parents who had these concerns, and all had been read, with differing
opinions. She talked to many parents over the summer who expressed concerns about their voices being
heard at the schools and about what their children were learning. When she was asked about this policy
last week, she wanted to ensure she understood it fully before answering any questions. She had
previously expressed her desire for the City to have good relationships with everyone they worked with,
so last week she met with the Superintendent, Chair, and Vice Chair of the School Board. She respected
the fact that the School Board was its own entity, just as the City Council was, and they could not order
them to do anything, but the Council did represent the citizens of Lynchburg, and those citizens had
expressed concerns. She said that the Chair and Vice Chair of the School Board, having also received
the correspondence from the Vice Mayor, understood those concerns and that the intent of changing the
policy was to be more proactive in giving parental control over sexual content for their students. She
received an email today from Dr. Coleman, the Chair of the School Board, which stated that they were,
“absolutely committed to working with each parent regarding concerns about their children,” and that the
School Board was happy to revisit this policy and wanted to hear from the parents. Avenues that existed
for parents to follow up with the School Board included the Superintendent’s Parent Advisory Council,
January 24, 2023
8
Equity Task Force, Health Advisory Board, and Special Education Advisory Committee, as well as
emailing or calling the School Board. It was the right thing to do as a parent to directly contact them,
which was stated in the Chair’s email. She reiterated that the Council had heard these concerns and the
School Board was ready to hear directly from the parents and to revisit the policy.
Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to appeal Mayor Reed’s point of order to allow
Councilmembers Helgeson and Dolan to speak under the Roll Call Rules of Procedure.
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Taylor, Misjuns 4
Noes: Wilder, Reed, Faraldi 3
Councilmember Dolan stated that she would not be signing Councilmember Misjuns’ letter
because “opting in” censors the learning opportunities for every student, whereas “opt-out” gave students
the opportunity to access the material. For “opt-in,” only children who received the form, brought it home
to their parents, had the parents read and sign the form, and returned it to the school would have the
opportunity to learn. The three steps assumed that children were able to follow this process, and this
limited all students in their ability to learn. The policy could be fine-tuned, but “opt-in” was an issue when
getting forms to and from the school. Her second issue was with Councilmember Misjuns’
characterization of her having the schools closed. She never had the authority to close the schools during
the pandemic, and never even suggested that.
Councilmember Helgeson said that Ms. Dolan’s reasoning that parents sometimes did not receive
the form was another reason why the forms to opt in were reasonable because if the forms were lost with
an opt-out, children would be receiving information the parents had no knowledge of. He said that he
appreciated the presentation by Councilmember Misjuns on the issue and the potential solutions, which
did not take away authority or limit materials or educational methods and was glad to support it.
Mr. Freedman said that unless there was official Council action, the letter would not be an action
on behalf of City Council, so certainly anyone who enjoined in that letter would be an individual joining
irrespective of the fact that the letterhead itself showed it was on behalf of City Council. Mayor Reed
asked Mr. Freedman if the letter would need to be signed by the Mayor before being sent out. Mr.
Freedman said that was correct; if there was official action, typically a letter on behalf of the City Council
would be signed by the City Council of Lynchburg, Virginia, by its Mayor. Mayor Reed asked if there was
January 24, 2023
9
an opportunity to modify the wording of the letter if it were written originally by the Mayor and signed
below. Mr. Freedman said that was true should the Council adopt it as a governing body.
Vice Mayor Faraldi said that he would reconsider and make a vote on a public stance of
Lynchburg City Council, but the verbiage and messaging associated with the officeholder who
communicated on behalf of the Council, which would be the Mayor.
// On motion of Councilmember Misjuns, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, by the following recorded
vote, elected to hold a closed meeting for the purpose of briefing by staff to Council on public safety and
vulnerability, pursuant to §2.2-3711(A)(19), of the Code of Virginia, 1950 as amended.
Councilmember Helgeson stated that he would be voting to go into the closed session but would
not be present to certify it.
Ayes: Wilder, Dolan, Helgeson, Reed, Faraldi, Taylor, Misjuns 7
Noes: 0
// The meeting was reopened to the public.
// Councilmember Wilder made the following motion:
WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date,
pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of
Information Act; and
WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that
such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to
the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open
meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification
resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening
the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council.
The motion was seconded by Councilmember Dolan, and Council, by the following recorded vote,
adopted the motion:
Ayes: Dolan, Wilder, Taylor 4
Noes: 0
January 24, 2023
10
Absent: Helgeson, Faraldi, Misjuns 3
// The meeting recessed at 6:04p.m.
// City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present:
Present: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, Jeff Helgeson, MaryJane Dolan, Marty Misjuns, Sterling
Wilder, Larry Taylor 7
Absent: 0
Councilmember Dolan gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance.
// A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 24th day of January 2023, at
7:30 P.M. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Stephanie T. Reed, President, presiding. The following
Members of the Council were present:
Present: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, Jeff Helgeson, MaryJane Dolan, Marty Misjuns, Sterling
Wilder, Larry Taylor 7
Absent: 0
Councilmember Dolan led the Council in the invocation and pledge of allegiance.
// In the matter of Recognitions, Agenda Item #1, Mayor Reed recognized Miss Sameria Lamberth,
Mayor's Youth Council, a senior at Heritage High School who was in attendance. Mayor Reed stated that
it was Miss Lamberth's second year on the Mayor's Youth Council and served as the President.
She also recognized Miss Caroline Corbett, Mayor’s Youth Council, a freshman at E.C. Glass
who was also in attendance. This was Miss Corbett’s first year on the Mayor’s Youth Council.
// Vice Mayor Faraldi made the motion to amend the agenda to include the discussion of one of the
proposed letters brought forth by Councilmember Misjuns related to the previous School Board issue as
the last item on the agenda; the motion was seconded by Councilmember Misjuns.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Stephanie Reed, Chris Faraldi, Larry Taylor, Jeff Helgeson, Marty Misjuns 5
Noes: MaryJane Dolan, Sterling Wilder 2
// In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #2, Council held a public hearing and
considered adopting Resolution #R-23-003 approving the HOME Investment Partnership American
Rescue Plan to Reduce Homelessness and Increase Housing Stability. Director of Community
January 24, 2023
11
Development Mr. Kent White stated that during the January 10th meeting, Ms. Marjorie Willow provided
an overview of available funding from the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) HOME-
ARP Program and a recommended action plan. Ms. Marjorie Willow, Principal of M&L, provided an
overview of the proposed Allocation Plan and next steps. The City has been allocated $1,498,471 in
HOME Investment Partnership American Rescue Plan (HOME-ARP) funds to assist individuals or
households who are homeless, at risk of homelessness, and other vulnerable populations (“Qualifying
Populations”). The purpose of the HOME-ARP funds is to reduce homelessness and increase housing
stability. The funds may be purposed for housing development, tenant-based rental assistance (TBRA),
supportive services, and non-congregate shelters. To receive the HOME-ARP allocation, the City must
develop and submit a HOME-ARP Allocation Plan to HUD. The City procured the consulting services from
the firm of Mullin and Lonergan (M&L) Associates, who has conducted extensive analysis of community
needs and existing resources. The firm consulted with partners from across the City to inform them about
priority needs and opportunities for the HOME-ARP funds to have the greatest possible impact.
Citizen Timothy Santiago, Lynchburg City, speaking in favor of the item, stated that he
volunteered with two homeless shelters in the community, and there was a need for housing and money
in the City. He requested that the plan be approved and that the Council be mindful of how money is
spent on the community.
Citizen Shawn Farmer, Executive Director of Interfaith Outreach Association, speaking in favor,
stated that she was speaking as a board member of the Central Virginia Continuum of Care. She said
that she supported the identified activity in the plan to create more housing for those experiencing
homelessness. She noted that Interfaith Outreach operated the City's homelessness prevention program.
She stated that affordable housing provided opportunities and stability.
Citizen Tab Robertson, President of the Central Virginia Continuum of Care, speaking in favor,
stated that she supported the identified primary activity in the proposed plan to develop housing for those
experiencing homelessness. She said that finding available housing for clients had been one of the most
difficult aspects of the continuum of care. Citizen Robertson said that in 2022, Horizon Behavioral Health
received funding for a permanent supportive housing program and a grant for the benefit of homeless
individuals. She said that each of the programs provided housing-related services and rental assistance
January 24, 2023
12
to individuals with mental illness to secure and maintain affordable housing. She said that they continued
to struggle to find available affordable housing.
Citizen Pat Young, Senior Director of Community Health Services at Sentra Health, speaking in
favor, stated that she was speaking as a board member of the Central Virginia Continuum of Care. She
noted that Sentra was the largest health system in the region, and they felt the impacts of homelessness
every day. She said that the emergency rooms were full of people with long-neglected medical issues or
people who had nowhere else to go during inclement weather. She said that the proposed program would
provide the funds and resources to increase access to safe and affordable housing.
Citizen Kristen Nolen, Director of Housing Services at Miriam's House, speaking in favor, said
that she strongly supported the draft plan recommendation to develop affordable and safe rental housing
for the homeless population. She noted that rent costs had increased, and the availability of habitable
units had decreased.
Citizen Sarah Quarantotto, Executive Director of Miriam's House, speaking in favor, stated that
she supported the proposed plan's identified priority to create more affordable housing for those
experiencing homelessness. She said that in 2022, Mariam's House served more homeless neighbors
than in previous years. She requested the Council to support the plan.
Citizen Bryon Meade, CFO of Roads to Recovery, speaking in favor, stated that he was speaking
as a board member of the Central Virginia Continuum of Care. He said that he supported the plan. He
noted that Roads to Recovery operated the City's only no-barrier homeless shelter. He said that housing
was the single largest barrier for homeless clients.
Citizen Todd Blake, Executive Director at Parkview Community Mission, speaking in support,
stated that in 2022, the Parkview Community Mission resource center addressed needs through 327
financial assistance form submissions, 9,746 calls, and countless direct interactions. He said that there
had been a 700% increase in assistance requests since 2019. He said that the needs in the City were
increasing.
Citizen Paul Robertson, Board Member of the Central Virginia Continuum of Care, speaking in
favor, stated that he supported the plan's identified priority activity. He said that the lack of affordable
housing had deep impacts. He said that an increase in affordable housing would allow homelessness
January 24, 2023
13
assistance programs to operate more effectively and efficiently. He said that a lack of housing affordability
decreased housing stability. He urged the Council to adopt the proposal.
Citizen Chelsea Tomlin, Secretary for the Board of the Central Virginia Continuum of Care and
Director of Operations for Johnson Health Center, speaking in favor, stated that the Johnson Health
Center was the area's federally-qualified health center. She said that last year, 73 patients self-identified
as homeless, and 50% of patients fell below the federal poverty level. She said that food, transportation,
and housing were the top life challenges identified by patients.
Citizen Sarah Fuentes, Homeless Systems Coordinator for Mariam's House, speaking in favor,
stated that Mariam's House led the coordination of all homeless services in the City and four surrounding
counties. She said that the community homeless hotline received dozens of calls daily from people
experiencing a housing crisis. She said that there was not enough affordable housing in the community.
She said that she was in full support of the HOME-ARP allocation plan, and she encouraged the Council
to approve the plan as written and to allocate all of the funds to the creation of affordable housing.
Citizen Tim Saunders, Board Member of the Central Virginia Continuum of Care, speaking in
favor, requested the Council approve the HOME-ARP plan. He said that businesses were struggling to
find workers. He said that job seekers wanted to work in the City, but some barriers prevented them from
living close to their jobs. He said that creating affordable housing would diversify the workforce. He
requested the Council support the plan as presented.
Citizen Michelle Baumann stated that she was a homeless outreach worker, and she encouraged
the Council to support the plan.
Citizen Jeremy White, Board Member of the Central Virginia Continuum of Care, speaking in
favor, said that people in the community experienced problems with safe and habitable housing. He said
that families needed housing stability to establish work, medical, and educational stability.
Citizen Jeff Smith, Executive Director of Rush Homes, speaking in favor, stated that Rush Homes
had developed 99 homes since 1996, and they were scheduled to construct 31 additional homes
scheduled to be leased by mid-summer. He noted that all the homes were accessible to people with
mobility impairments. He said that they would make eight more apartments available when Florida
January 24, 2023
14
Terrace came online via project-based vouchers. He said that he endorsed the plan on behalf of Rush
Homes. He said that more could be done with funding from outside sources.
There was no one to speak in opposition. Clerk of Council Ms. Alicia L. Finney reported that one
email was received from Ms. Evelyn Jordan, in support of the plan, and read it into the record.
Mayor Reed closed the public hearing and the matter rested with Council.
Vice Mayor Faraldi made the motion to approve the resolution, stating that government would
never solve the housing problem, but it did play an integral part in the solution. The motion was seconded
by Councilmember Wilder.
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that they needed more support organizations in the community. He
said that community members should look for ways to join organizations aiding in solving the housing
issues in the City.
Councilmember Wilder stated that there was a need for affordable housing in the City.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Wilder, Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of Parks and Recreation, Agenda Item #3, Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-23-
004 approving the Parks and Recreation Master Plan as part of the City of Lynchburg's Comprehensive
Plan 2013-2030, Planner Ms. Rachel Frischeisen provided the staff report. The purpose of the Lynchburg
Parks and Recreation Master Plan is to assess the City’s public parks and recreation system and define
how to best enhance these services throughout our community. The plan, developed by Lose Design with
significant input from the Lynchburg community, provides recommendations to help guide future
programs, parks, and recreational capital improvement projects over the next decade. The Master Plan is
designed to be a flexible working document that establishes an overall vision for the City's future parks
and recreation system. Once adopted, staff will explore opportunities and potential funding mechanisms,
as resources permit, to implement the recommendations. City Council conducted a public hearing on
January 10, 2023, and chose to continue it to the January 24, 2023 meeting. During the public hearing,
some concerns were raised by a citizen over the lack of a major park in Ward IV, maintenance of the
January 24, 2023
15
current Heritage Park, and whether new trails/greenways would be utilized enough to justify the cost.
Staff offers the following responses:
A) The Master Plan identifies two new neighborhood parks within Ward IV, as well as an
expansion of the existing Heritage Park. A new community park is also proposed nearby in the
Windsor Hills/Leesville Road area of Ward III, which would serve Ward IV residents.
B) Much of Heritage Park (including the fields and building) is currently maintained by Lynchburg
City Schools (LCS). The Parks and Recreation Department is working with LCS to transfer
stewardship of additional park land to the City to allow for more frequent maintenance and
development of new park amenities.
C) Lynchburg’s 40+ miles of trails see nearly 500,000 trail users per year, tracked by trail
counters at the four most popular trailheads. There are numerous grant sources available for
trail/greenway projects, which the City has successfully obtained in the past and will continue to
pursue.
Citizen Beth White, Fort Hill, speaking in favor, stated that she had concerns regarding the Fort
Avenue section of the plan. She noted that there were several traffic accidents on Fort Avenue, and traffic
had increased despite improvements. She said she approved the overall plan, but she had concerns
about reducing the number of lanes from four to two on Fort Avenue.
Citizen Katrina Marple, speaking in favor, stated that her family renovated houses and
warehouses in the downtown Lynchburg area. She encouraged the Council to vote in favor of the plan.
Citizen Sandra Bowen, Ward III, speaking in favor, stated that her family enjoyed the public parks
and trails. She asked whether there was funding for Creekside trail improvements in the plan. She said
that the dirt trails allowed people to enjoy the natural beauty. She requested that the dirt trails be
addressed to preserve the City's natural resources. She said changing Fort Avenue from four lanes to two
lanes needed to be reconsidered.
There was no one to speak in opposition.
Clerk of Council Ms. Alicia L. Finney reported that 26 emails had been previously submitted to
read into the record, all in support of the plan: LaDonna; Wally Blair, resident of New Hampshire Avenue;
Tim Miles resident of Link Road; Connie Edwards; Jeffrey Kornblum, M.D.; Laurel Foot, resident of
January 24, 2023
16
Lexington Drive; Travis McDonald, representative of Thomas Jefferson’s Poplar Forest; Nora Cox; Heidi
James, resident of V.E.S. Road; Gary Nero, resident of zip code 24503; Kevin Cope; Pamela Shirey,
resident of Elmwood Avenue; Bette Bibee, resident of Greenhill Lane; Davy Hazlegrove, representative of
Blackwater Bike Shop; Jenny Tugman, resident of Langhorne Road; Shannon Brennan; Curt Baker,
resident of Locksview Road; William Blackman, M.D.; Jason Kendall, representative of Greater Lynchburg
Off-Road Cyclists; Sarah English, resident of Beacon Hill Place; Lindsey Cline and Corey Shrader; Kaye
Moomaw; Jacquie Glanz; Amy Bonnette, representative of Camp Kum-Ba-Yah; Thomas Nygaard M.D.;
and one form letter signed by the following BG Hilltrippers hiking club: Paul Mudrick; Bernard Mundy;
Terry Adams; Richard Pumphrey; Gary Urquhart; John Welker; Joe Stinnett; Christopher King; Bill
Sanford; Billy Giles; Richard Milam; Paul Seufer; J.R. Pugh; and Thomas Nygaard.
Mayor Reed closed the public hearing and brought the matter back before the Council.
Councilmember Helgeson noted that the impact on the tax rate was about a $0.17 increase in the
real estate tax to implement the proposal. He said that Fort Avenue was a main arterial road. He
suggested focusing on maintaining the current trails. He suggested that the item be tabled.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked how many dollars would be allocated out of funds from the City if the
proposal were adopted. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda responded that it was currently $0. Vice
Mayor Faraldi clarified that there was no fiscal impact to approving the plan beyond the costs of the plan
which had already been allocated; Mr. Benda responded that was correct. Vice Mayor Faraldi clarified
that each item in the plan would be addressed individually and would have funding allocated separately.
Vice Mayor Faraldi made the motion to approve the resolution, #R-23-004. The motion was
seconded by Councilmember Dolan. Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that the plan should incorporate a sports
complex. He said that there was a market for some type of sports complex. He said that parks projects in
the Fourth and Third Ward should be expedited. He said that he did not support the proposal for Fort
Avenue. He said that the Templeton Center should be put in the Fort Hill area. He said that the plan
should not be tabled.
Councilmember Dolan said that the plan was important, but the Council was not deciding to fund
the plan. She noted that even if the plan were approved, parts may not be funded or implemented. She
said that the proposal was critical if the City was to remain relevant, and she supported the proposal.
January 24, 2023
17
Councilmember Wilder stated that he supported the plan.
Councilmember Taylor asked how long it would take to fund the plan. Mr. Benda said that it would
depend on the Council's priorities, and the CIP planned for 5 to 10 years out. He said that they would
discuss the CIP on the 14th and discuss the Council's priorities. Councilmember Taylor asked how much
the proposal would cost the taxpayers. Mr. Benda said that he could not quantify the whole proposal.
Councilmember Taylor said that he installed a park at White Rock Hill without taxpayer funding and noted
that there were ways to achieve the plan without raising taxes. Mr. Benda said that there was no intent to
raise the taxes.
Councilmember Helgeson made an amended motion to table the item for further discussion. The
motion was seconded by Councilmember Misjuns.
Councilmember Misjuns said that they should finalize the proposal before it was approved. He
said that they should look to generate revenue through recreational tourism.
Vice Mayor Faraldi suggested that the proposal be sent back to a committee assignment. He
noted that he considered the amended motion a friendly amendment.
Councilmember Dolan noted that there was citizen input on the plan, and staff had worked with
the Council and with citizens to draft the plan.
Councilmember Wilder noted that several roundtable discussions were held in regard to the
vision for the parks. He stated that the planning was a work in progress and would be funded as items
were brought back before the Council. He said that the process provided a roadmap for the plan.
Mayor Reed noted that the plan acted as a vision board for the City, and it could be modified as
projects and concerns were presented. She noted that $125K had been spent to hire consultants to
develop the plan, and the planning had occurred over two years. Director of Parks and Recreation Ms.
Jenny Jones noted that the plan had taken two years, cost $125K, and had over 4,000 participants. She
said that the plan was a guide, and there were over 100 recommendations in the plan. She said that only
the projects which Council approved would be implemented, and projects would be brought back before
Council one by one.
Councilmember Helgeson noted that projects should be screened. Ms. Jones responded that
there were several public meetings and that there had been opportunities for the public and City staff to
January 24, 2023
18
express concerns or suggestions. She said that it was not expected the taxpayers would be responsible
for the full price of the projects included in the master plan. She said that the master plan could be used
to leverage grant funding.
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that he was not opposed to tabling the item for further discussion.
Mr. Freedman clarified that the rules of procedure did not specifically contemplate friendly amendments,
but in the past, friendly amendments had been determined by a consensus of the Council that the motion
would change. He said that if there was a disagreement within the Council, then it should consider the
motion to amend prior to the previous motion.
Mr. Freedman clarified that the motion as stated would table the item indefinitely. He said that if
the Council wanted the item to return on a date certain, it must state the date in the motion. Vice Mayor
Faraldi recommended that the item be sent to the Physical Development Committee for review.
Councilmember Wilder said that the Parks and Recreation Department had provided the
resources to develop a plan, and the Council should not try to control all of the plans. He said that they
should empower the people they hired. He said that the parks should be supported because they were
utilized and enjoyed by many residents.
Mayor Reed stated that the motion was to table the discussion. With no further discussion from
Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns 3
Noes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Wilder 4
Councilmember Wilder made the motion to adopt the resolution, #R-23-004, seconded by
Councilmember Dolan. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Wilder 4
Noes: Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns 3
// In the matter of Finance, Agenda Item #4, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting
Resolutions #R-23-005 and #R-23-006 authorizing the issuance of General Obligation Public
Improvement Bonds not to exceed $78,500,000 in principal, and amending the FY 2023 General, Water,
Sewer, and Stormwater Funds’ Operating Budgets to provide appropriations totaling $475,000 with
January 24, 2023
19
resources from the General Obligation Public Improvement Bonds, Series 2023 for costs associated with
the issuance of $78,500,000 General Obligation Public Improvement Bonds.
Ms. Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, stated that in accordance with Section 15.2-2606.A of the
Code of Virginia, 1950, to authorize the issuance of $78,500,000 General Obligation Public Improvement
Bond of the City, a public hearing is required. After the public hearing, in coordination with the City's
financial advisors, Davenport and Company, LLC, and the City's bond counsel, Hawkins, Delafield, &
Wood, a resolution will be presented to approve a general obligation public improvement bond issue to
permanently finance the current Bond Anticipation Note, finance a portion of the new Police
Headquarters, and finance current projects to allow them to continue until the next BAN is in place. The
resolution will include a "not to exceed" clause of $78,500,000 which includes the estimated underwriter's
discount, a contingency should the bonds sell at a discount, and issuance costs.
There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email or in person, so the
public hearing was closed.
Councilmember Wilder made the motion to approve the resolution, #R-23-0005 and #R-23-0006,
stating the City's strong bond rating provided for a lower interest rate. The motion was seconded by Mr.
Taylor.
Vice Mayor Faraldi asked whether a vote could be called if two members were out of the
chambers. Councilmember Helgeson and Councilmember Misjuns had left the Council Chambers. Mr.
Freedman responded that for voting purposes, the Council was able to vote because there was a quorum
on the dais. He said that the Mayor could call a brief recess until the council members returned. Vice
Mayor Faraldi suggested that the Council wait until calling the vote. Councilmember Helgeson returned.
Councilmember Helgeson noted that they were taking on debt service. Ms. Witt responded that
no new projects were included in the bond issuance. She explained that all the projects were either
appropriated in the 2023 Capital Improvement Program (CIP) or a prior CIP and currently moving forward
under contract. She said that projects were placed on a Bond Anticipation Note (BAN) so that funds were
not borrowed until they were needed, and the BAN closed at the end of June, so they needed to finance
the projects. She said that about $25M of the $42M had been utilized, and they needed to permanently
finance it. She said that $26M was associated with the police department to fully fund the contract that
January 24, 2023
20
was in place. She said that they were utilizing funds to continue projects so that they did not stop
progress until the next line of credit was in place. Councilmember Helgeson clarified that they were
moving from a BAN type of financing to a longer-term form of financing. Ms. Witt responded that a BAN
was a line of credit. She explained that Council had used the BAN strategy for more than a dozen years.
She said that the City did not want to borrow money before it was needed. Councilmember Helgeson
clarified that the proposed plan was a higher priority than the school's excess funding which was
discussed earlier. Ms. Witt explained that the projects in the proposal were brought before Council and
adopted during previous CIP processes. She noted that the school project may not have been eligible.
Councilmember Helgeson asked if discussions were continuing related to school redistricting and
consolidation. Ms. Witt noted that the discussions were continuing. She said that the projects in the
proposal before the Council were mostly approved in 2022 and 2021. She noted that roof-replacement
projects were typically performed over the summer, and they could be bond-funded if they did a complete
roof replacement. Councilmember Helgeson clarified that the contracts were approved and funded by
BANs. Ms. Witt explained that there were no new projects. She said that the drafting process for the new
CIP would begin on February 14.
Mayor Reed clarified that the present motion was to approve both resolutions before the Council.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Wilder, Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #5, Citizen John Salmon, speaking on behalf of Unified
Potential, stated that transportation was an important determiner for the social health of a community, but
the City lacked the resources to serve people who could not operate or own a personal vehicle. He said
that fixed route transportation in smaller cities and rural areas was not effective, and micro-transit was a
better solution to serve the population.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #6, Citizen Timothy Santiago stated that there was a
housing crisis in the City. He noted that the properties on the vacant property list provided about 1,500
individual housing opportunities. He suggested that the Council provide incentives to renovate and lease
vacant properties.
January 24, 2023
21
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #7, Citizen Jack Underwood spoke on the recent letter
to the School Board to require a parent to opt-in for sexually explicit material. He read a verse from the
Song of Solomon and noted the sexual nature of the material. He said that under the current draft opt-
in/opt-out letter, parents would be able to prevent teachers from reading the Bible to students. He said
that the Council was not qualified to make such decisions related to the schools, and the matter should be
left before the School Board. He noted that such a policy would impose a burden on teachers and
learning.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #8, Citizen Michael Bremer, Sherwood Place, stated that
it was not the purview of the Council to determine school policy or practice—the matter was before the
Superintendent and School Board. He said that Council should address matters such as expanding green
and blue spaces in the downtown area, attracting small businesses, encouraging the expansion of
entertainment venues, improving transportation systems, increasing development, and increasing the tax
base.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #9, Citizen Nicholas Sanders stated that she was
against the opt-in policy as proposed in the letter to the School Board by Councilmember Misjuns. She
said that the teachers should be trusted to show students appropriate material. She said that the Council
was overstepping its mandate by determining school policy. She said that she objected to items being
added to work sessions and the agenda at the last minute.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #10, Citizen Clay Williams stated spoke on the opt-
in/opt-out letter proposed to be submitted to the School Board. He noted that state law already
established an opt-out policy which became effective in January. He said that an opt-in policy would put a
burden on teachers, but teachers were professionals and the best resource for instructional decisions.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #11, Citizen Jen Staten requested that the Council not
support Councilmember Misjuns' request to send a letter requesting the School Board implement an opt-
in policy. She said that opt-in policies censored students and teachers. She said that the opt-in policy
would require teachers to obtain permission slips for all educational materials. She stated that efforts to
make educational materials less accessible disproportionately targeted books by and about people and
stories who had been underrepresented in young adult and children's literature. She said that the
January 24, 2023
22
proposed opt-in policy was rooted in racism, gender discrimination, and ableism, but there was no place
for such mindsets in the City government or schools.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #12, Citizen Erin Rupe stated that she was unable to
speak on the matter of Lynchburg becoming a 2nd Amendment sanctuary city because the matter was
decided during a work session. She said that she was against the opt-in policy proposed by Council, and
such a policy was a statement of mistrust in the educational materials and teachers.
// In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #13, Council conducted a first reading of
Resolution #R-23-007 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating
$85,000 for the purchase of a Drone Mobile Command Response Vehicle for the Lynchburg Police
Department, Deputy Chief of Police Mr. Ken Edwards provided the staff report. The Police Department
was awarded $85,000 through a competitive grant process from the Virginia Department of Emergency
Management, State Homeland Security Program to purchase a Drone Mobile Command Response
Vehicle. This vehicle will be outfitted with drone equipment to respond quickly to critical incidents
impacting public safety, allowing real-time intelligence to be relayed to a command post for operational
decision-making. The total cost is $85,000 which is fully reimbursable by the grant; no local matching
funds are required.
At its January 24, 2023 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that
committee, Vice Mayor Faraldi brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a
motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Wilder, Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #14, Council conducted its first reading of
Resolution #R-23-008 amending the FY 2023 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating
$387,250 to purchase Law Enforcement Equipment & Technology for the Lynchburg Police Department,
Deputy Chief of Police Mr. Ken Edwards provided the staff report. The City of Lynchburg was awarded
$387,250 in Department of Criminal Justice Services, American Rescue Plan Act, Funding for Law
Enforcement Equipment & Technology. The Lynchburg Police Department will use the funding to procure
& purchase (no local matching funds are required):
January 24, 2023
23
A) Two (2) years of FUSUS (open and unified real-time intelligence) service ($250,000) - extracts
live video footage for use by public safety. Enabling businesses and citizens to partner with the
police department, this software will enhance emergency preparedness by allowing public safety
professionals to better assess and respond to emergencies and reduce violent criminal activity
throughout the city.
B) Laser Scanner Focus S70 Premium system ($65,500) - this device will be used in
investigations to capture an entire crime scene through an extensive laser scan combined with a
series of HD photos and will reduce the time required to process crime scenes, allowing forensic
detectives to re-create a virtual walkthrough of the scene & evidence as it was found prior to
collection.
C) Five (5) Ballistic Bunker Shields ($42,800) - will allow responding officers a wider range of
agility and maneuverability to access and address an active threat. This will reduce the time it
takes to approach life-threatening situations and minimize the potential for greater loss of life.
D) Three (3) Kinetic Breaching Tools ($28,950) - allow a single officer to breach doors without
explosive technology and may be used in tandem with the ballistic shields for increased officer
safety.
At its January 24, 2023 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As
Chair of that committee, Vice Mayor Faraldi brought the committee’s recommendation for approval
forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the
motion:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Wilder, Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Dolan 1
// In the matter of Engineering, Agenda Item #15, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-23-009
requesting the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) to increase the official City street lane
mileage for reimbursement of highway maintenance funds for FY 2024 by 5.23 lane miles, City Engineer
Mr. Lee Newland provided the staff report. When required, usually each year, the City submits a list of
new or improved streets to VDOT for acceptance into the street maintenance system for payments to the
January 24, 2023
24
City from the Commonwealth. For FY 2024, staff has identified 5.23 lane miles of street segments that
need to be added. These street segments are shown on the attached maps and VDOT U-1 Form. This
action is required by VDOT to add these segments for addition to the system.
Mayor Reed stated that the Council had been briefed on the item at the January 10 meeting.
Councilmember Wilder made the motion to approve the resolution #R-23-009, seconded by
Councilmember Dolan. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Wilder, Dolan, Taylor, Helgeson 6
Noes: 0
Absent: Misjuns 1
// In the matter of the Finance Committee, Agenda Item #16, Council reviewed and approved the City’s
Finance Committee Guidelines, Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt provided the staff report. The
Finance Committee Guidelines are reviewed by the Finance Committee for relevance bi-annually, in
conjunction with the appointment of the Finance Committee chair. Following review by the Finance
Committee, these guidelines require approval by the City Council.
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that the item appeared before the Finance Committee which
recommended unanimous approval of the new guidelines, and meetings would be held on the fourth
Tuesday of the month at 3:00 p.m., 2nd Floor Training Room, City Hall. Vice Mayor Faraldi made the
motion to approve the guidelines and meeting time; no second was required.
Councilmember Helgeson asked if the advertising guidelines had been met. Ms. Witt responded
that notice was announced that the first meeting would be held at 3:00 p.m. in the 2nd Floor Training
Room, and the intent was that at the meeting, the guidelines and schedule would be approved for
meetings moving forward. Councilmember Helgeson asked if there had been changes made to the
guidelines. Ms. Witt responded that there was one recommended change to move the structure and
timing of the proposed bond sales to appear first before the Council before the Finance Committee.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Wilder, Dolan, Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns 7
Noes: 0
January 24, 2023
25
// In the matter of the Finance Committee, Agenda Item #17, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-
23-010 amending and reaffirming City Council's Financial Management Policies, Chief Financial Officer
Ms. Donna Witt provided the staff report. City staff and the financial advisors periodically review the
Financial Management Policies. The City shall be in complete compliance with all applicable federal, state
and local laws, and other regulations and statutes governing the investment of public funds. The Financial
Management Policies of Fund Balance, Debt Management, and Budget have no proposed changes and
are recommended to be reaffirmed. The Investment policy has revisions based on compliance with the
Code of Virginia. The revisions are noted in the attached document.
At its January 24, 2023 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As
Chair of that committee, Vice Mayor Faraldi brought the committee’s recommendation for approval
forward as a motion. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the
motion:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Dolan, Wilder, Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns
6
Noes: 0
// In the matter of Finance, Agenda Item #18, Council considered adopting and ordinance changing the
rate for a concealed weapon permit. Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt provided the staff report. Vice
Mayor Faraldi requested information related to lowering the fee required to obtain a concealed weapon
permit in the City of Lynchburg to $15 per permit. Section K of § 18.2-308 of the Code of Virginia breaks
down the fees that are both allowed and required for a concealed handgun permit (see highlighted
section in code section below). The current fee structure breakout for the City of Lynchburg is shown
below:
Lynchburg Police Department (LPD) officers conducting background investigations do so on an overtime
basis and are compensated one hour per background investigation. The $35 fee currently charged to
January 24, 2023
26
citizens does not cover the expenses incurred for even our lowest-paid officer. If the fee is lowered to
$15, the funding for the LPD’s expenses related to background investigations will need to be absorbed
into the current Police Department Budget without offsetting revenues. The chart contains the numbers
related to background investigations for concealed handgun permits for the past five years:
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that the matter came before the Finance Committee, and adoption was
recommended by a 2-1 vote. He made the motion to approve ordinance, #O-23-001, to set the local rate
to $0. He stated that reducing the fee would reduce barriers to obtaining a concealed-carry permit and
increase firearms training. Councilmember Wilder clarified that the motion was to set the fee to $0. Vice
Mayor Faraldi responded that the local fee would be set to $0, but there would still be a $15 fee to obtain
the permit. Councilmember Wilder clarified that the current fee did not cover the cost of the service. He
clarified that the difference in cost did not come from the police budget.
Councilmember Misjuns stated that he would support the item.
City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda stated that outside of a fiscal budget adoption process that
comprehensively addressed revenues and expenditures, mid-year budget changes posed complications.
He noted that the Council was about to begin the FY 24 budget process, and he encouraged the Council
to contemplate the budget matters during the regular budget process.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns 5
Noes: Wilder, Dolan 2
// In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #19, Council had a discussion on reducing the Real Estate Tax
Rate; Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt provided the staff report. City Councilmembers requested a
discussion on reducing the real estate tax rate be added to an agenda. This request includes reducing the
rate from $1.11 per $100 of assessed value to $1.03 dated back to November 2021 or reducing the rate
January 24, 2023
27
to $0.99 as of a date Council chooses to apply prospectively. Staff will provide context to the real estate
tax rate and the legal provision for a change in rate. A retroactive reduction in rate which would result in a
refund would not be proper pursuant to the tenets of Section § 15.2-2511.1 of the Code of Virginia and
until a method has been first developed by ordinance to account for the distribution of a surplus. The
desired refund in the amount of $4.8M (the amount of Real Estate Taxes related to reducing the rate to
$1.03 effective November 2021) cannot be defined as a surplus as contemplated by Section § 15.2-
2511.1 of the Code of Virginia. The proposed ordinance attached may be considered by Council in
reducing the Real Estate Tax rate prospectively. Please note, any change in revenues that will cause a
greater than 1% change of the total expenditures in the current adopted budget will require notice, a
public hearing, and a budget amendment.
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that the item was discussed as presented to the Finance Committee,
and the committee recommended approval unanimously. Vice Mayor Faraldi made the motion to direct
City staff to provide creative, effective, and legal options for the associated real estate tax increase as
presented to Council. He requested that the City Attorney explain why the item was brought before the
Council.
City Attorney Mr. Matthew C. Freedman responded that council members requested the
proposals for reducing the real estate tax rate to either $0.99 or $01.03 applied retroactively to November
2021. He explained that the $0.99 option would not be practical according to City staff and the finance
team. He further explained that per the requirements of § 15.2-2511.1, there was not necessarily a
surplus that would meet the amounts to be refunded by a retroactive tax refund. He continued that if
Council did determine there was a surplus, § 15.2-2511.1 required a method ordinance to be established
to change the tax rate.
Mr. Freedman explained that if Council wanted to achieve an expedited process, it could lower
the tax rate prospectively. He explained that if the ordinance were to apply mid-fiscal year, the Council
would need to pass a budget amendment, and if the expenditures in the amendment were greater than
1% of the budget, there would need to be notice, a public hearing, and a budget amendment. He
continued that if the ordinance were to take effect the next fiscal year, then it could be contained within
the regular budget process.
January 24, 2023
28
Councilmember Helgeson made the motion to set the tax rate to $0.99 effective retroactively to
November 2022. Councilmember Misjuns seconded the motion.
Vice Mayor Faraldi stated that the right approach would be to address the item during the
upcoming budget process, and he did not support the present measure.
Mr. Freedman explained that a retroactive tax reduction would have to be established by
ordinance. He said that he did not want to open the City up for an audit if it did not appropriately follow
state code. He cautioned the Council against establishing an ordinance without a method in place.
Councilmember Wilder clarified that the tax rate had remained at $1.11 for several years and had
not increased, but property values had increased. He noted that the City population was growing, and
development throughout the City was increasing.
Councilmember Taylor asked the city manager, Mr. Wynter C. Benda if he could provide a
balanced budget with a tax decrease. Mr. Benda clarified that he would have to provide a balanced
budget under the state code.
Mayor Reed asked for clarification regarding the procedural roadblocks to amending the budget
in the middle of the fiscal year.
Mr. Freedman responded that if the tax rate were lowered to a certain degree, it would cause
forgone revenues that would exceed 1% of the total expenditures in the budget. He continued that such a
circumstance would require notice, a public hearing, and appropriation items. He said that the item could
be handled mid-year, or it could be addressed during the regular budget process.
Councilmember Misjuns asked what the anticipated assessment increase was. Mr. Benda
responded that it was 20%.
Vice Mayor Faraldi moved the pending question.
Mayor Reed stated that she did not support the retroactive portion of the proposal, but she did
support lowering taxes.
Councilmember Helgeson amended his motion to be effective January 24, 2023. Councilmember
Misjuns seconded the motion.
Councilmember Wilder asked what the budget impact would be and whether they still were
required to undergo the budget amendment process. Mr. Benda responded that the important aspect was
January 24, 2023
29
whether the budget impact was greater than 1% of the expenditures. He said that if it was greater than
1%, then a public hearing and ordinance would be required. Councilmember Wilder clarified that the
budget would have to be amended. Mr. Benda said that it would be up to Council how to rebalance the
budget and account for the tax reduction. Councilmember Wilder asked whether Mr. Benda had
experienced this situation in previous years. Mr. Benda said that he had not handled such a situation in
his career.
Councilmember Dolan stated that she needed to know what services would be cut to fund the
reduction. She stated that the matter should be addressed during the regular budget process.
Mr. Freedman clarified that there was a motion to amend the previous motion to adopt the
proposed ordinance, to be effective January 24, 2023, to reduce the tax rate to $0.99. He stated that the
motion before Council was whether to make the amendment. With no further discussion from Council, the
following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Taylor, Helgeson, Misjuns 3
Noes: Reed, Faraldi, Wilder, Dolan 4
Vice Mayor Faraldi moved the pending question on the initial motion, to direct City staff to provide
creative, effective, and legal options for the associated real estate tax increase as presented to Council.
Councilmember Helgeson asked what the specific direction to staff would be. Mr. Freedman
responded that he interpreted the motion to mean Council deferred to the City Manager to determine
creative, effective, and legal options for providing tax relief to Lynchburg residents in FY 2024.
Councilmember Helgeson asked how the motion would differ from the regular budget process. Mr. Benda
responded that they would undergo the regular budget process.
Vice Mayor Faraldi clarified that the motion was a unified direction from the Council to staff
regarding providing tax relief to residents.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Wilder, Dolan, Taylor 5
Noes: Helgeson, Misjuns 2
// In the matter of an Item Not on the Agenda, Agenda Item #20, Council discussed the Opt-In Policy
Letter to the School Board proposed by Councilmember Misjuns. Vice Mayor Faraldi made the motion to
January 24, 2023
30
authorize the Mayor to draft a letter to the School Board requesting it to revisit and reconsider the
sexually explicit materials policy or opt-in policy. Councilmember Misjuns seconded the motion.
Councilmember Wilder stated that Council should defer to the School Board to make curriculum
decisions.
Mayor Reed reported that School Board Chair Dr. Coleman had emailed her, stating that the
School Board, Superintendent, and administrative staff were committed to working with each parent
regarding their children enrolled in LCS. She continued that parents were able to engage through the
Superintendent's Parent Advisory Council, the Equity Taskforce, the Health Advisory Board, phone,
email, and other methods. She clarified that the letter did not direct or order the School Board to take
action because the Council did not have authority over the School Board.
With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded:
Ayes: Reed, Faraldi, Helgeson, Misjuns, Taylor 5
Noes: Wilder, Dolan 2
// The meeting adjourned at 11:19 p.m.
____________________________
Clerk of Council
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.