City Council Work Session — Agenda Packet
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Jan 10, 2023 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY COUNCIL
Tuesday, January 10, 2023 | 4:00 PM
Council Chamber- City Hall
900 Church Street
Lynchburg, VA 24504
Our Mission: To elevate the quality of life through excellent city services.
WORK SESSION AGENDA
I. Welcome Stephanie Reed, Mayor
II. Work Session Agenda Overview Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
III. Work Session Agenda Items Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
III.1. HOME Investment Partnership American Rescue Plan to Reduce Homelessness
and Increase Housing Stability
III.2. Considerations for Establishing a School Funding Formula
IV. Business Item Briefing(s)
IV.3. FY 2023 General Obligation Public Improvement Bond Issue
IV.4. Additional City Street Mileage for Virginia Department of Transportation Highway
Maintenance Payments
IV.5. (TENTATIVE) Discuss a resolution expressing the City of Lynchburg’s intent to
stand as a Sanctuary City for Second Amendment rights.
V. Roll Call
VI. Closed Session
VI.6. Consideration of a closed meeting to discuss the acquisition of real property for
public safety purposes where discussion in an open meeting would adversely
affect the bargaining position or negotiating strategy of the public body pursuant
to Section 2.2-3711(A)(3) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended.
VI.7. Consideration of a closed meeting to discuss the potential resolution of a
pending City law-enforcement lawsuit pursuant to Section(s) 2.2-3711(A)(7) -
(A)(8) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended.
Page 1 of 100
City Council
Agenda Item III.1.
Information Only
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY
January 10, 2023 Melva Walker, Grants Manager
AGENDA ITEM # III.1
HOME Investment Partnership American Rescue Plan to Reduce Homelessness and Increase
Housing Stability
RECOMMENDATION
This item will appear for City Council vote on the Janaury 24, 2023 Public Hearing agenda. Approval
of the Allocation Plan for the HOME-American Rescue Plan Program (HOME-ARP) funds from the
U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD).
SUMMARY
The City has been allocated $1,498,471 in HOME Investment Partnership American Rescue Plan
(HOME-ARP) funds to assist individuals or households who are homeless, at risk of homelessness
and other vulnerable populations (“Qualifying Populations”). The purpose of the HOME-ARP funds
is to reduce homelessness and increase housing stability. The funds may be purposed for housing
development, tenant based rental assistance (TBRA), supportive services, and non-congregate
shelters. To receive the HOME-ARP allocation, the City must develop and submit a HOME-ARP
Allocation Plan to HUD.
The City procured the consulting services from the firm of Mullin and Lonergan (M&L) Associates,
who has conducted extensive analysis of community needs and existing resources. The firm
consulted with partners from across the City to inform priority needs and opportunities for the
HOME-ARP funds to have the greatest possible impact.
Ms. Marjorie Willow, Principal of M&L will provide an overview and requirements for the submittal of
the proposed Allocation Plan.
PRIOR ACTION(S)
None
FISCAL IMPACT
To be determined through the development of a project and/or projects for the eligible uses of the
funds.
CONTACT(S)
Melva Walker, Grants Manager
Tom Martin, City Planner
Page 2 of 100
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. HOME-ARP Allocation Plan Presentation
2. Lynchburg HOME-ARP Allocation Plan
REVIEWED BY
Date: January 03, 2023
Kent White, Director of Community Development
Date: January 03, 2023
Mercedes Braun, Executive Assistant to the City Manager
Date: January 05, 2023
Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
Date: January 05, 2023
Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council
Page 3 of 100
HOME -ARP ALLOCATION PLAN
FOR CITY OF LYNCHBURG
Page 4 of 100
THE HOME -
AMERICAN
RESCUE PLAN
(ARP) )
Provides $5 billion of supplemental
HOME funds:
▪ To assist individuals or households
who are homeless, at risk of
homelessness and other vulnerable
populations
▪ By providing housing, rental
assistance, supportive services
and/or non-congregate shelter
Lynchburg is receiving $1,498,471
Page 5 of 100
NEEDS IDENTIFIED BY STAKEHOLDERS
More affordable and accessible rental housing for lower-income households
Need three- and four-bedroom rental units for families but individual adults
have difficulty finding studios and one-bedroom units
Need rental assistance to make housing affordable for households at 0-30%
More supportive services are needed to get people housed and to maintain
stability (case management, employment training, financial counseling,
childcare, etc.)
At-risk of homelessness: households without subsidies, barely making ends meet
on low-wage jobs
Page 6 of 100
NEEDS IDENTIFIED THROUGH DATA ANALYSIS
84 Number of persons experiencing homelessness during 2022 PIT Count
673 Number of persons served in the homeless system
239 Persons experiencing homelessness for the first time
157 Persons fleeing domestic violence, etc.
2,442 Households received emergency rental assistance (2020-2022)
74% ERAP payments made to 0-30% AMI households with $3,737 average
amount paid per household
3,174 Persons with disabilities living below 150% of poverty ($25,860 in 2020)
Page 7 of 100
PRIORITY NEEDS IDENTIFIED
Development of affordable and accessible rental housing
Permanent Supportive Housing rental units for homeless persons
Page 8 of 100
PROPOSED BUDGET
Eligible Activities Funding Amount Proposed
Supportive Service ---
Acquisition/Development of Non-Congregate Shelter ---
Tenant-Based Rental Assistance ---
Development of Affordable Rental Housing $ 1,348,624
Non-Profit Operating ---
Non-Profit Capacity Building ---
Planning & Administration $ 149,847
Total $ 1,498,471
The city plans to partner with a local nonprofit organization or housing provider to develop
affordable rental units. Old Forest Village and the new Florida Terrace would be models for
this new project.
Page 9 of 100
NEXT STEPS
JANUARY 10-24
Required 15-day public comment period
Draft plan has been posted online for public review
Written comments should be sent to haley.campbell@lynchburgva.gov
JANUARY 24
Public hearing before City Council at 7:30 pm
Oral and written comments will be included in the final plan
JANUARY 31
City anticipates submitting plan to HUD
Page 10 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
1
CITY OF LYNCHBURG, VA
HOME-ARP Allocation Plan
Submitted to the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development
(HUD) as a Substantial Amendment to the
Approved Program Year 2021 (Fiscal Year 2022) Community Development
Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program Annual Action Plan
Acronyms Used
The following acronyms are used throughout this document and are listed below in the order they appear:
ACS: American Community Survey
AMI: area median income
CE: Coordinated Entry system of a CoC
CH: chronic homeless
CHAS: Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy
CHIA: Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access
CVCoC: Central Virginia Continuum of Care
DHCD: (Virginia) Department of Housing & Community Development
DV: domestic violence
ERAP: Emergency Rental Assistance Program
ESG: Emergency Solutions Grant
ESG-CV: Emergency Solutions Grant – Coronavirus program
FMR: fair market rent
HCV: Housing Choice Voucher Program
HIC: Housing Inventory Chart
HMIS: Homeless Management & Information System
HOME: HOME Investment Partnerships Grant program
HOME-ARP: HOME American Rescue Plan Act
HUD: US Dept. of Housing & Urban Development
IRS: Internal Revenue Service
LIHTC: Low-Income Housing Tax Credit program
LMI: low- and moderate-income
LRHA: Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority
Lyn-CAG: Lynchburg Community Action Group
NCS: non-congregate shelter
PIT: Point in Time count
QP: Qualifying Populations of the HOME-ARP program
PJ: Participating Jurisdiction in the HOME Program (i.e., a recipient of HOME funds)
PSH: permanent supportive housing
RFP: Request for Proposals
RRH: rapid re-housing
TBRA: tenant-based rental assistance
TH: transitional housing
Page 11 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
2
Consultation
Section 1: Describe the consultation process including methods used and dates of consultation
See Appendix A for all Stakeholder Consultation materials. Stakeholder comments received throughout
the various sessions are referenced throughout the Needs Assessment & Gaps Analysis.
The City of Lynchburg (“Lynchburg”) conducted a series of stakeholder listening sessions in July 2022.
The purpose of these listening sessions was to identify the unmet housing and supportive service needs of
the Qualifying Populations. The sessions were held remotely via GoToMeeting. For all stakeholder
sessions, a PowerPoint presentation on the HOME-ARP program was presented followed by a series of
questions meant to engage participants. Details of Round 1 are included in the chart below.
Date Method Participant
Stakeholders
Agency/Organization Type
(required stakeholders in italics)
Central VA Continuum
of Care (CVCoC) Board
Meeting
July 6, 2022
11:00 am – 1:00 pm
Zoom virtual
session
7+ Continuum of Care, Public housing authority,
Homeless service providers, Private organizations
serving the needs of the QPs, Public agency serving
the needs of the QPs
July 26, 2022
10:00-11:30 am
GoToMeeting
virtual session
18 Homeless service providers, Organizations that
address civil rights, Continuum of Care, Private
organizations that address the needs of the QPs,
Public housing authority, Domestic violence service
provider
July 28, 2022
10:00-11:30 am
GoToMeeting
virtual session
12 Continuum of Care, Homeless service providers,
Organization that address civil rights, Public housing
authority
Interviews were also conducted with additional stakeholders (via Teams or telephone) whose input was
required for this planning process. Details of these interviews are included in the chart below.
Date Method Participant
Stakeholders
Agency/Organization Type
(required stakeholders in italics)
VA Legal Aid Society
September 26, 2022
11:00 am
Telephone 1 Organization that addresses civil rights, fair housing
Lynchburg Area
Veterans Council
September 26, 2022
11:00 am-12:00 pm
Telephone 1 Veterans services
The second round of stakeholder meetings was held in October 2022. The purpose of this round was to
present summaries of the needs identified by stakeholders and the unmet needs identified through data
analysis. The sessions were held remotely via GoToMeeting. Each session began with a PowerPoint
presentation summarizing key findings from the stakeholder consultations and the data analysis. Details
of Round 2 are included in the chart below.
Page 12 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
3
Date Method Participants
Stakeholders
Agency/Organization Type
(required stakeholders in italics)
October 11, 2022
9:30-11:00 am
GoToMeeting
virtual session
6 Continuum of Care, Private organization that
address the needs of the QPs, Homeless service
providers
October 13, 2022
1:00-2:30 pm
GoToMeeting
virtual session
3 Homeless service provider, Organization that serves
the needs of persons with disabilities
Section 2: List the organizations consulted and summarize feedback received and results of upfront
consultation with these entities. Required stakeholders are italicized.
A list of all invited stakeholders is included in Appendix A. Also included in Appendix A are summaries
of the comments received during each stakeholder consultation session. All required stakeholder
categories were engaged either through group stakeholder sessions, regular organization meetings,
individual interviews, or via e-mail to obtain data.
The general themes and trends that emerged from the stakeholder sessions include the following:
• More affordable and accessible rental housing for lower-income households
• Without an adequate supply of affordable units, it can take 60+ days to place a homeless person
in housing
• Individuals/families with tenant-based rental assistance/Housing Choice Vouchers (HCVs) can’t
find units that are affordable
• There is a need for three- and four-bedroom rental units for families but individual adults have
difficulty finding studios and one-bedroom units
• There is a lot of housing development occurring but none of it is affordable; nearby communities
have lower-cost housing but units are substandard
• There is a need for tenant-based rental assistance and project-based rental assistance to make
affordable housing financially accessible to 0-30%
• More supportive services are needed to get people housed and to maintain stability—case
management, transportation, employment training, financial counseling, childcare, legal services,
substance abuse treatment, and more
• Transportation, childcare, and jobs are needed so families can work toward housing stability
• Many landlords refuse to accept Housing Choice Vouchers by setting their rents above the
threshold allowed by the rental subsidy program; many also refuse to rent to tenants with criminal
histories, evictions, poor credit (even with the ability to pay rent), and released offenders
• The level of HCVs is inadequate to serve families in need of subsidized rental housing
• Some individuals cannot be released from a local hospital for 30-40 days until housing is found
• There is a need for a low-barrier shelter to replace the one that closed last year; funding for
operations exist (Note: The Hand Up Lodge shelter closed in March 2022.)
• At-risk of homelessness: households without subsidies who are barely making ends meet on low-
wage jobs
• Released offenders have few if any affordable housing options
Page 13 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
4
Public Participation
[To be completed following the 15-day public comment period and public hearing.]
See Appendix B for evidence of Public Participation conducted for the plan.
Section 1: Describe the public participation process, including information about and the dates of
the public comment period and public hearing(s) held during the development of the plan.
• Date(s) of public notice: Click or tap to enter a date.
• Public comment period: start date – Click or tap to enter a date. end date - Click or tap to enter a
date.
• Date(s) of public hearing: Click or tap to enter a date.
Describe the public participation process:
Enter narrative response here.
Describe efforts to broaden public participation:
.
Summarize the comments and recommendations received through the public participation process
either in writing, or orally at a public hearing:
.
Summarize any comments or recommendations not accepted and state the reasons why:
Enter narrative response here.
Page 14 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
5
Needs Assessment & Gaps Analysis
This section presents the results of the homeless needs and gaps analysis, drawing on data from the
Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) Homeless Management and Information system (HMIS),
Point-In-Time (PIT) count, and several other sources that are identified. Where appropriate, this
information is contextualized with feedback from stakeholders consulted during the HOME-ARP
planning process. Where possible, data specific to the City of Lynchburg was used. Data obtained from
the CVCoC reflects the entire CoC’s full geographic area consisting of the city plus the surrounding
counties of Amherst, Appomattox, Bedford, and Campbell.
Section 1: Housing Inventory
Like many cities, Lynchburg has a shortage of affordable rental housing that impacts the ability of
homeless services providers to rapidly re-house or place homeless and at-risk homeless persons in stable
living situations within 30 days. Among stayers in Emergency Shelter facilities, the median stay was 79
days—nearly three months. In 2022, 42% remained between 30-180 days. Longer lengths of stay may
increase the need for beds, as there is less turnover for new clients to be able to use those resources. And,
with the end of the Emergency Rental Assistance Programs (ERAP), the 2,315 households that depended
on funding to cover rent/mortgage and utility arrears to carry them financially during under-employment
and unemployment resulting from the pandemic are at risk for utility shut-offs and eviction.
The CVCoC Housing Inventory Count (HIC) reported on the inventory and occupancy of Emergency
Shelter, Permanent Supportive Housing and Rapid Re-Housing beds and their utilization rates on the
night of the 2022 Point In Time (PIT) count. Of the 138 Emergency Shelter beds, 67 were occupied,
resulting in an overall utilization rate of 48.6%. The Salvation Army’s Emergency Lodge had a utilization
rate of 75%. The remaining non-domestic violence shelter, Hand Up Lodge, had 9 people during the PIT
count. In January 2022 when the PIT count was conducted, several factors resulting from the COVID-19
pandemic could have influenced lower utilization rates, including social distancing requirements that
remained in place, eviction moratoria that kept individuals and families in their housing when they could
not pay rent which prevented eviction, and some facilities not having full staffing capacity to open all
available beds.
The 2022 PIT count conducted in the summer revealed 25 homeless adults who were not sheltered. Other
homeless households included 11 families with at least one child, eight veterans, and 22 victims of
domestic violence—all of whom were sheltered. The current gap of 25 adult-only beds is based on the
PIT count and bed/unit availability on the same night of the PIT count.
Page 15 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
6
Table 1. Homeless Needs Inventory and Gap Analysis
Homeless
Lynchburg CVCoC
Current Inventory Homeless Population Gap Analysis
Family Adults Only Vets Family
HH (at
least 1
child)
Adult
HH
(w/o
child)
Vets Victims
of DV
Family Adults Only
Beds Units Beds Units Beds Beds Units Beds Units
Emergency
Shelter (Non-DV) 35 7 22 0 6 6 26 8
Emergency
Shelter (DV) 36 11 1 1 0 5 9 0
Transitional
Housing
Permanent
Supportive
Housing
3 1 38 37 4
Other Permanent
Housing (RRH) 52 17 32 28 12
Sheltered
Homeless 11 35 8 22
Unsheltered
Homeless 0 25 0 0
Current Gap 0 0 25 0
Data Sources: 1. Point in Time Count (PIT) July 21, 2022, 2.CV Continuum of Care Housing Inventory Count (HIC) 2022, 3. Virginia Sexual and Domestic Action
Alliance 2022, 4. CVCoC Collaborative Applicant
Lynchburg has a strong demand for affordable rental housing. This shortage of units for those at or below
30% area median income (AMI) increases housing insecurity and rent pressure on lower income
households.
Table 2. Housing Needs and Gap Analysis
Renter Households
Household Income
Total 0-30% AMI 31-50% AMI
Total Households 3,655 2,340 5,995
Affordable Housing Units 1,755 3,740 5,495
Units Occupied by Appropriate Income Tier1 650 760 1,410
Units Occupied by Other Income Households2 1,105 2,980 4,085
Housing Gap3 3,005 1,580 4,585
Data Source: 2014-2018 Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy
1 Number of housing units occupied by a household of the same income tier (i.e., a 0- 30% AMI household occupies
a unit that is affordable to a 0-30% AMI household)
2 Number of housing units occupied by a household that is not of the same income tier (i.e., a 0- 30% AMI unit is
occupied by a household above 30% AMI)
3 Total Number of Households minus Units Occupied by Appropriate Income Tier equals the number of units
needed to house the balance of the households within that income tier that are occupying units affordable to
households above their income tier (i.e., the housing gap).
Page 16 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
7
Within the rental housing inventory, there is a severe housing gap for households at 0-30% and 31-50%
AMI (see Table 2). Analyzing the household occupancy of rental units by income tier provides additional
information. According to CHAS data, there are 3,655 renter households in Lynchburg at 0-30% AMI.
However, there are only 1,755 rental units affordable to this group of households. Further exacerbating
the situation is that only 650 of these 1,755 affordable units are occupied by 0-30% AMI households. The
remaining 1,105 units are occupied by households with incomes above 30% AMI. This results in a
housing gap of 3,005 rental units affordable to 0-30% AMI renter households.
Moving up the income spectrum, there are 2,340 renter households at 31-50% AMI. For this income
group, there is an over-supply of 3,740 units affordable to them. However, only 760 of the 3,740 units are
occupied by 31-50% AMI households. The remaining supply of 2,980 units are occupied by households
of other income tiers, likely including some of the 0-30% AMI households who are living in units outside
of their income tier and that would cause them to be cost burdened. This results in a housing gap of
1,580 rental units affordable to 31-50% AMI renter households.
Section 2: Size and Demographic Composition of Qualifying Populations
To analyze the size and demographic composition of Qualifying Populations for HOME-ARP funding,
the CVCoC provided HMIS data for the 12-month period of July 2021-June 2022. This was
supplemented with data from the Virginia Sexual and Domestic Action Alliance for the 12-month period
of July-June 2022.
1. Homeless as defined in 24 CFR 91.5
The number of Lynchburg residents that meet the definition of homeless under 24 CFR 91.5 was derived
from the 2022 PIT winter count conducted by the CVCoC on January 26, 2022. A total of 84 persons
were homeless. Among these, 67 (79.8%) were sheltered and 17 (20.2%) were unsheltered. In terms of
racial and ethnic demographics, 45 (53.6%) were White, 35 (41.7%) were Black/African American, and
three (3.6%) were Hispanic/Latino. Across the CVCoC jurisdiction, Black/African Americans account for
only 16% of the total population but are more than twice as likely to be homeless than Whites.
According to HMIS data for the period of July 1, 2021 through June 30, 2022, 239 individuals
experienced homelessness for the first time in 2021, representing a 40.8% decrease over 2020. There were
301 persons served: 239 who were homeless for the first time and 62 who were returning. The median
length of stay among these individuals was 67 bed nights, a 130% increase over the 2020 median stay.
The lower number reflects fewer evictions, and more safety net programs due to COVID-19. The lower
rate of evictions decreased the rental vacancy rate, which meant fewer vacant units for the unhoused to
access housing.
HMIS data reported 130 persons were served by the CVCoC’s Street Outreach Program with 91% of
those engaged being adults and 72 being male. Four were veterans and 13 were chronically homeless.
Nine children ages 17 and younger were engaged but the majority (55%) of persons were between the
ages of 35-61. The majority of individuals were White (53.8%) but at 33.8%, Black/African Americans
were disproportionately represented among the street outreach engagements.
Page 17 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
8
2. At Risk of Homelessness as defined in 24 CFR 91.5
Table 2 reveals that there are only 1,755 rental units affordable to the 3,655 households with incomes at
0-30% AMI. Of these, only 650 units are occupied by households at 0-30% AMI. This means that the
remaining 3,005 households at 0-30% AMI are cost burdened since they are living in units that are
affordable to higher-income households (above 30% AMI) and are at risk of homelessness. A similar
trend is found among the 1,580 households at 31-50% AMI who are living in units that are affordable to
higher-income households (above 50% AMI).
Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy (CHAS) data was used to identify the degree of cost
burden among the lower-income Lynchburg renter households. As described in Table 3, there are 2,310
renter households at 0-30% AMI and 565 renter households at 31-50% AMI that are severely cost-
burdened and paying more than 50% of their monthly income on housing costs. These 2,875 households
comprise a Qualifying Population as other families requiring services or housing assistance to prevent
homelessness.
Table 3. Severely Cost-Burdened Renters at 0-50% AMI
Total Cost Burdened
Severely Cost
Burdened
# % # % # %
Total Renters 14,500 100.0% 6,605 45.6% 2,965 20.4%
Very Low-Income
Renters (0-50% AMI) 6,005 41.4% 4,825 33.3% 2,875 19.8%
30-50% AMI 2,540 17.5% 2,090 14.4% 565 3.9%
0-30% AMI 3,465 23.9% 2,735 18.7% 2,310 15.9%
Data Source: 2014-2018 Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy
Beginning in 2020, the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) distributed funds during the pandemic to assist
Americans facing deep rental debt, the fear of eviction and the loss of basic housing security. The
Emergency Rental Assistance Program (ERAP) made funding available to assist households that were
unable to pay rent or utilities. Through the Virginia Department of Housing & Community Development
(DHCD), state and local administering agencies provided payment assistance to landlords for renters who
could not afford to pay rent and utilities due to loss of or reduced employment. During the period from
July 2020 through June 2022, a total of 2,442 households in Lynchburg received ERAP funding. Of these,
1,806 households were at 0-30% AMI and represented 74% of all payments made. The average payment
was $3,737.09. Another 278 (11.4%) payments were made to households at 31-50% AMI with the
average payment being $3,349.81. Of the 2,442 ERAP recipient households, only 1,222 reported their
race and ethnicity. The majority were Black/African American (61.3%). There were 334 (27.6%) White
households and 69 (5.6%) households who identified as multiple races. There were 53 (4.3%) Hispanic
households. Of the 1,222 ERAP recipient households that reported the age of the head of household and
the number of individuals living at home, the average household size was 2.37 persons. There were 562
households with children ages 17 or under. There were 277 households with youths aged 18-24, 961
households with individuals between the ages of 25-64, and 44 households over the age of 65. There were
Page 18 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
9
649 households that reported gender, veteran status, and disabilities. Of these, 435 (67%) were female-
headed, 25 (3.9%) were veterans, and 68 (10.5%) had a household member with a disability.
Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) also administered an emergency rental assistance
program from July 1, 2020, through June 30, 2022, assisting 231 households comprised of 286 persons.
Black/African American households were disproportionally represented at 65% of households assisted.
Persons with disabilities accounted for 8.4% of households assisted. Employment status among
households varied from 32% who had been unemployed for longer than six months, 11% who had been
unemployed for less than six months, and 22% who worked at full-time jobs. Female-headed households
accounted for 36% and single-person households accounted for 55% of households receiving assistance.
Nearly 18% of households had incomes below 100% of the federal poverty level. Among those who
provided their tenure status, 62% were renters and 9% were homeowners.
Now that the ERAP assistance has ended, these 2,673 households assisted by DHCD and Lyn-CAG that
depended on funding to cover rent/mortgage and utility arrears to carry them financially during under-
employment and unemployment resulting from the pandemic are at risk for utility shut-offs and
eviction.
LRHA’s public housing waiting list includes 2,348 households as of July 26, 2022. At 1,576 households,
the majority (67%) are extremely low income at 0-30% AMI. The largest demographic group is
Black/African American households, which account for 1,308 (57.1%) of the total. White households
represented 31% of applicants (720 households) and Hispanic/Latinos accounted for 3% (70 households).
There were 133 elderly households and 472 households with individuals with a disability.
The Authority’s waiting list for its Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) program includes 1,315 households
as of July 26, 2022. At 958 households, the majority are extremely low income at 0-30% AMI. The
largest racial/ethnic group on the list is Black/African American households at 956 (74.92%) followed by
188 White households (14.73%) and 48 Hispanic/Latino households (3.7%). There were 67 elderly
households and 303 households with individuals with a disability. Black/African American households,
who account for 16% of the total population across the CVCoC jurisdiction, are disproportionately
represented among the public housing and HCV waiting list applicants.
According to 2021 HMIS data (July 1, 2021 through June 30, 2022), 19.4% of households who exited
Emergency Shelters moved to temporary destinations. Among the 222 adults who exited Emergency
Shelters, 58% had no income upon exiting. Among the 95 adults who exited Rapid Re-Housing Program
services, 30.5% had no income upon exiting. Exiting to a temporary destination and a lack of income are
factors that can increase the risk of returning to homelessness.
Based on 2021 HMIS data (July 1, 2021 through June 30, 2022), 21% exited from Emergency Shelters
to temporary housing situations. Exiting to a temporary destination may indicate a greater risk of
returning to the homeless system (see Table 4).
Page 19 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
10
Table 4. Persons Exiting from Emergency Shelter to Temporary Destinations
Destination Youth Vets Others Total
Emergency Shelter/hotel or motel with voucher 3 6 9
Transitional housing 1 1
Staying/living with a family member, temporary tenure 4 4
Staying or living with a friend, temporary tenure 2 1 23 26
Place not meant for human habitation 2 2 4
Hotel/motel without voucher 6 6
Host home 1 1
Total 2 6 43 51
Data Source: HMIS 2021 (July 1, 2021 through June 30, 2022)
3. Fleeing, or Attempting to Flee, Domestic Violence, Dating Violence, Sexual Assault, Stalking,
or Human Trafficking, as defined by HUD in the Notice
According to the Virginia Sexual and Domestic Violence Action Alliance report for the Lynchburg
CVCoC, there were 157 individuals served by the YWCA Domestic Violence Prevention Center in
Lynchburg. This included 94 adults and 63 children. Among these, 63 households were adults only and
31 households included adults with children. Females accounted for 90 of the 94 heads of household.
Children under the age of 18 numbered 63 (40% of the 157) and young adults ages 18-24 numbered 20
(12.7%). There were 74 White individuals (47%), 60 Black/African American individuals (38%) and
eight Hispanic/Latino individuals served (5%). Black/African American individuals disproportionately
seek domestic violence shelter as the true number impacted is not known as middle and higher-income
women experiencing domestic violence have resources outside of going to shelter.
According to HMIS data (July 1, 2021 through July 30, 2022), a total of 259 persons receiving services
through street outreach, emergency shelter, rapid-rehousing, permanent supportive housing and the
YWCA reported a history of domestic violence. Of these, 52% were currently fleeing domestic violence.
4. Other populations requiring services or housing assistance to prevent homelessness
and other populations at greatest risk of housing instability, as defined by HUD in the
Notice
Persons with Disabilities: LHRA reported 472 of the 2,348 applicant households on the public housing
waiting list included at least one member with a disability. A total of 303 applicant households waiting
for Housing Choice Vouchers reported at least one member with a disability. According to stakeholders
consulted, accessible housing is a continuing and critical need for persons with disabilities, ranging from
individuals in wheelchairs to medical beds and in-home healthcare services in order to maintain housing
stability. Overall, there is demand for permanent rental housing that can support and accommodate
persons with disabilities.
According to 2020 ACS data, there are 4,285 persons 18 and older with an independent living difficulty
disability in Lynchburg. Among all persons with disabilities age 16 and older, 2,950 had earned income.
Of these, 61.5% earned less than $25,000 in 2020. The rate of poverty is higher among persons with
Page 20 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
11
disabilities than persons without disabilities. In 2020, 34.5% of persons with disabilities lived below
150% of the poverty level compared to 25% of persons without disabilities. This was equivalent to 3,174
persons with disabilities who were living below 150% of the poverty level, equal to $25,860 for a
household of two in 2020. With this income, the household could pay no more than $647/month for gross
rent (rent plus utilities) without being cost-burdened.
Section 3: Current Resources Available to Assist Qualifying Populations
LRHA owns and manages 312 units of public housing. Among tenant households, the average annual
income is $10,574. The Authority also administers 768 Housing Choice Vouchers whose tenant
households have an average annual income of $10,808. These households pay no more than 30% of their
income on housing costs.
The 2022 PIT winter count identified 131 Emergency Shelter beds of which 67 were occupied resulting in
a utilization rate of 48.6%. The lowest rates were noted at Bedford Domestic Violence Services (36%),
Lynchburg Community Action Group (32%), YWCA’s Domestic Violence Prevention Center (15%), and
YWCA’s Frannie’s House for Domestic Violence. Coordinated Entry System data for January-June 2022
revealed census numbers of 96, 62, 73, 78, 69, and 68 residents, respectively, in Emergency Shelter for an
average monthly utilization rate of 75% for the six-month period.
The 2022 Housing Inventory Count (HIC) includes 68 Permanent Supportive Housing beds with a
utilization rate of 94% during the PIT count.
Section 4: Describe the Unmet Housing and Service Needs of Qualifying Populations
According to stakeholders, the greatest need is for affordable rental housing, which has been exacerbated
by increased competition. Subsidized rental units fill quickly because there is strong demand. According
to stakeholders, there are landlords who set rents above the payment standard (i.e., threshold) allowed
under rental subsidy programs rather than refuse rental vouchers. (Refusing to rent to a tenant with a
rental subsidy violates Virginia law.) Some landlords also have initiated tenant selection policies (i.e.,
three times monthly income to qualify for a unit, 10-year look-backs on criminal histories, etc.) that act as
barriers for many, including special needs populations.
1. Homeless as defined in 24 CFR 91.5
The CVCoC’s HMIS indicated 938 individuals were served by the homeless system during the 12-month
period from July 2021-June 2022. According to the 2022 HIC, there are 68 Permanent Supportive
Housing beds, of which 64 were occupied.
According to the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities,
the average wait time for Virginia households to
receive housing vouchers is 38 months during which time persons who are homeless must struggle to find
other living arrangements, regardless of the cost, housing condition, location and lack of safety.
According to stakeholders consulted, the following unmet housing and supportive service needs were
identified:
Page 21 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
12
• There is no low-barrier Emergency Shelter located within the CoC since Hand Up Lodge closed
in March 2022
• Jobs, transportation, and childcare
• Tenant education on eviction law to prevent them from leaving units too soon and becoming
homeless
• Legal services to prevent evictions when tenants appear in court
• TBRA and project-based rental assistance is needed to provide deep subsidy for rental housing
for households at 0-30% AMI
• Adequate level of supportive services for persons in Permanent Supportive Housing to keep them
housed
• Supportive services are available in the community but funding is needed to combine them with
affordable housing
2. At Risk of Homelessness as defined in 24 CFR 91.5
According to 2014-2018 CHAS data, there is a gap of 4,585 affordable rental units for households at 0-
50% AMI. As a result, these households reside in housing units that are costlier than what would be
affordable to them. This does not consider additional costs for necessities such as transportation,
childcare, and/or accessibility modifications for individuals with disabilities. Based on cost burden, the
2,765 rental households paying more than 50% of their income on housing costs are at risk of
homelessness.
LRHA owns and manages 312 units of public housing. As of July 26, 2022, there were 2,348 applicants
on the waiting list—more than seven times the number of units. The Authority also administers 768
Housing Choice Vouchers. There are 1,315 applicants on the waiting list—almost twice as many as
there are vouchers. Across the city, there are 4,825 renter households at 0-50% AMI paying more than
30% of their income on housing costs. Of these, 2,875 pay more than 50% of their income on housing.
None of these cost-burdened and severely cost-burdened households receive any subsidy.
Black/African Americans represented 42% of the total homeless count during the 2022 PIT winter count
but only 16% of the general population of the CVCoC jurisdiction. Furthermore, they represent more than
half of all applicants on the public housing authority waiting list and nearly three-quarters of applicants on
the Housing Choice Voucher waiting list. Among household recipients of ERAP funding during the
pandemic, they were the majority (61.3%) of funding recipients. This suggests that low-income, and
especially extremely low-income households and persons identifying as Black/African American, are the
most likely to have a disproportionate need for housing assistance due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
According
to stakeholders, one-bedroom rental units are in high demand. This was supported by LRHA.
Of the 2,348 applicants waiting for public housing units, 48% need one-bedroom units (elderly 11%,
persons with disabilities 29%, families 60%). Among the 1,315 households on the Housing Choice
Voucher waiting list, the demand for one-bedroom units represented 48% of applicants (elderly 12%,
persons with disabilities 43%, families 46%). Rush Homes, a nonprofit affordable housing provider for
persons with disabilities and low incomes, reported that two-thirds of its waiting list is for one-bedroom
units.
Page 22 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
13
Stakeholders reported there is tight competition for Permanent Supportive Housing. The existing system
works well but remains occupied with very low turnover and a high demand for expansion.
3. Fleeing, or Attempting to Flee, Domestic Violence, Dating Violence, Sexual Assault,
Stalking, or Human Trafficking, as defined by HUD in the Notice
According to the VA Data report for 2021, 50% of persons who were fleeing domestic violence exited the
homeless system to temporary destinations. Affordable rental units with vouchers would provide
permanent housing options.
4. Other populations requiring services or housing assistance to prevent homelessness
and other populations at greatest risk of housing instability
as defined by HUD in the
Notice
According to 2021 HMIS data (July 1, 2021 through June 30, 2022), 661 households exited the homeless
system. Of these, 21.5% exited to temporary destinations. Households without permanent housing may
be more likely to experience returns to homelessness. According to the CVCoC’s By-Name List, between
January 1 and September 29, 2022, there have been 27 homeless veterans in the Lynchburg area with 15
of them moving into permanent housing. The remaining 12 individuals are at-risk of returning to
homelessness.
Section 5: Identify Gaps within the Shelter, Housing Inventory, and Service System
Based on the stakeholder consultations and data analysis, the following gaps were identified:
• There is a housing gap of 3,005 rental units affordable to 0-30% AMI renter households.
• There is a housing gap of 1,580 rental units affordable to 31-50% AMI renter households.
• There are 2,875 renter households at 0-50% AMI who are severely cost-burdened.
• There are 2,084 ERAP recipient households at 0-50% AMI that are at risk of homelessness if they
have not been able to return to employment to cover rent and utility costs.
• There are 1,576 households at 0-30% AMI on the waiting list for public housing.
• There are 958 households at 0-30% AMI on the waiting list for Housing Choice Vouchers.
• Based on 2021 HMIS data (July 1, 2021 through June 30, 2022), 89 individuals exited
homelessness to temporary housing situations.
• There are 472 applicant households on the public housing waiting list that include at least one
member with a disability.
• There are 303 applicant households waiting for Housing Choice Vouchers with at least one
member with a disability.
• There are 3,174 persons with disabilities who are living below 150% of the poverty level.
• One-bedroom affordable rental units are in high demand, although two- and three-bedroom units
are needed for families.
Section 6: Additional Characteristics Associated with Instability and Risk of Homelessness
No additional comments.
Page 23 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
14
Section 7: Identify Priority Needs for Qualifying Populations
Based on stakeholder consultations and data analysis, the priority needs among the Qualifying
Populations are affordable and supportive housing solutions. This includes the following:
● Development of affordable and accessible rental housing, including accessibility for persons with
disabilities
● Development of rental permanent supportive housing with a strong supportive service component
● Supportive services
Section 8: How the Level of Need and Gaps was Determined
In addition to feedback from stakeholder consultation sessions, the following sources were consulted to
determine the housing and service needs and gaps for HOME-ARP qualifying populations:
• American Community Survey (ACS), 2016-2020
• HUD Comprehensive Housing Affordability Strategy (CHAS), 2014-2018
• Central Virginia Continuum of Care 2022 Point-In-Time Count (winter)
• Central Virginia Continuum of Care 2022 Point-In-Time County (summer)
• Central Virginia Continuum of Care 2022 Housing Inventory Count (HIC)
• Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA)
• Central Virginia Continuum of Care Annual Performance Report (APR) for July-June 2022
• Virginia Sexual and Domestic Assault Action Alliance VA Data for July-June 2022 (APR)
• Central Virginia Continuum of Care 2021 System Performance Measures
• United Way of Virginia’s 2-1-1 Counts
• Emergency Rental Assistance Program data from Virginia Department of Housing & Community
Development
• Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority
• Lynchburg’s 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan for the Community Development Block Grant
(CDBG) and HOME Program
Page 24 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
15
HOME-ARP Activities
Section 1: Describe the method(s) that will be used for soliciting applications for funding and/or
selecting developers, service providers, subrecipients and/or contractors
The Lynchburg Department of Community Development, Grants Administration Office, will solicit
applications from developers, service providers, and/or subrecipient organizations to administer eligible
activities and/or develop shelter and housing. The Request for Proposals (RFP) will, at a minimum,
specify eligible applicants, eligible activities, minimum and maximum funding amounts, application
thresholds, and underwriting criteria, and will provide instructions on how to submit an application. In
addition to soliciting applications through a HOME-ARP RFP, the city may provide HOME-ARP funding
to applicants that have applied for Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) projects proposed in
locations where an unmet need for Qualifying Populations was identified through the needs assessment.
The RFP issued will be specific in describing the unmet needs identified through stakeholder
consultations and data analysis.
2. Describe whether the Participating Jurisdiction (PJ) will administer eligible activities directly:
City staff will not directly administer HOME-ARP activities beyond program administration and
planning.
3. If any portion of the PJ’s HOME-ARP administrative funds are provided to a subrecipient or
contractor prior to HUD’s acceptance of the HOME-ARP allocation plan because the subrecipient
or contractor is responsible for the administration of the PJ’s entire HOME-ARP grant, identify
the subrecipient or contractor and describe its role and responsibilities in administering all of the
PJ’s HOME-ARP program:
No HOME-ARP administrative funds have been provided to a subrecipient or contractor prior to HUD’s
acceptance of the HOME-ARP allocation plan.
Table 3. Use of HOME-ARP Funding
Funding Amount Percent of the
Grant
Statutory
Limit
Supportive Services
Acquisition and Development of Non-
Congregate Shelters
Tenant Based Rental Assistance (TBRA)
Development of Affordable Rental Housing $ 1,348,624
Non-Profit Operating 0% 5%
Non-Profit Capacity Building 0% 5%
Administration and Planning $ 149,847 10 % 15%
Total HOME ARP Allocation $ 1,498,471
Page 25 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
16
4. Describe how the PJ will distribute HOME-ARP funds in accordance with its priority needs
identified in its needs assessment and gap analysis:
The HOME-ARP budget was driven by the priority needs identified as a result of stakeholder consultation
and data analysis. This decision was based on the following priority needs:
● Development of affordable and accessible rental housing, including accessibility for persons with
disabilities
● Development of rental permanent supportive housing with a strong supportive service component
● Supportive services
The greatest need is for affordable rental housing, which has been exacerbated by increased competition
for units. Subsidized rental units fill quickly because there is strong demand. According to stakeholders,
there are lower numbers of rental units to voucher holders due to increased rent costs in addition to
landlords who have initiated tenant selection policies (i.e., three times monthly income to qualify for a
unit, 10-year look-backs on criminal histories, etc.) that act as barriers for many, including special needs
populations. In addition, although supportive services were also identified as a need for qualifying
populations, the CoC lead administrator clarified that supportive services funding is already being
received and is provided to the CVCoC from Virginia homeless funding programs and is sufficient at this
time.
5.Describe how the characteristics of the shelter and housing inventory, service delivery system,
and the needs identified in the gap analysis provided a rationale for the plan to fund eligible
activities:
The CVCoC’s Homeless Needs Inventory and Gap Analysis Table (see Table 1) revealed a gap of 25
shelter beds for homeless adults during the 2022 Point in Time summer count conducted this past July.
Lengthy waiting lists for Housing Choice Vouchers and public housing units speak to the high demand
for affordable rental housing. Privately owned units are no longer available for affordable housing in
many places as landlords have tenant selection policies that act as barriers for special needs populations.
Shelters lack bed capacity for those experiencing homelessness. Due to a lack of affordable rental
inventory, it is increasingly challenging to move individuals out of shelter into permanent housing.
Page 26 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
17
HOME-ARP Production Housing Goals
1.Estimate the number of affordable rental housing units for qualifying populations that the PJ will
produce or support with its HOME-ARP allocation:
Lynchburg estimates that it can support the development of 5-6 new rental housing units, depending on
the financing structure of the development. This goal was based on an estimated total development cost of
$200,000 to $225,000/unit. The city anticipates leveraging project-based rental assistance to provide a
deep subsidy to the project.
2.Describe the specific affordable rental housing production goal that the PJ hopes to achieve and
describe how the production goal will address the PJ’s priority needs:
The development of 5-6 new permanent affordable rental units will advance the CVCoC’s mission to end
homelessness by providing affordable housing for the Qualifying Populations. These units will provide
housing for the most vulnerable residents in community-based settings meant to stabilize their housing
situation and improve their quality of life.
Page 27 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
18
Preferences
Section 1: Identify whether the PJ intends to give preference to one or more qualifying populations
or a subpopulation within one or more qualifying populations for any eligible activity or project:
Lynchburg will provide access for all Qualifying Populations but will include a preference for homeless
individuals giving them priority for admission above all other Qualifying Populations. All other
Qualifying Populations will be served on a first-come, first-served basis (i.e., in chronological order).
Section 2:If a preference was identified, explain how the use of a preference or method of
prioritization will address the unmet need or gap in benefits and services received by individuals
and families in the qualifying population or subpopulation of qualifying population, consistent with
the PJ’s needs assessment and gap analysis:
The Homeless Needs Inventory and Gap Analysis Table (see Table 1) revealed a gap of 25 shelter beds
for homeless adults during the 2022 Point in Time summer count. As a result, affordable rental housing
was determined to be the greatest need among the Qualifying Populations. All Qualifying Populations
will be provided access to the HOME-ARP activity with literally homeless households given priority.
Page 28 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
19
Referral Methods
1.Identify the referral methods that the PJ intends to use for its HOME-ARP projects and
activities. PJ’s may use multiple referral methods in its HOME-ARP program. (Optional):
Lynchburg will use the CVCoC’s Coordinated Entry system as its referral source since all Qualifying
Populations are covered by the CoC.
2.If the PJ intends to use the coordinated entry (CE) process established by the CVCoC, describe
whether all qualifying populations eligible for a project or activity will be included in the CE
process, or the method by which all qualifying populations eligible for the project or activity will be
covered. (Optional):
The CVCoC’s Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) system will be used to admit applicants
directly to a HOME-ARP assisted project as it serves all Qualifying Populations. Miriam’s House, as the
Lead Agency for the Central Virginia Continuum of Care, oversees the Coordinated Entry System.
3.If the PJ intends to use the CE process established by the CoC, describe the method of
prioritization to be used by the CE. (Optional):
The CVCoC will prioritize the literally homeless within the homeless preference.
4.If the PJ intends to use both a CE process established by the CoC and another referral method
for a project or activity, describe any method of prioritization between the two referral methods, if
any. (Optional):
Not applicable.
Page 29 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
20
Limitations in a HOME-ARP Rental Housing
1.Describe whether the PJ intends to limit eligibility for a HOME-ARP rental housing or NCS
project to a particular qualifying population or specific subpopulation of a qualifying population
identified in section IV.A of the Notice:
Lynchburg will not limit eligibility to any HOME-ARP qualifying population.
2.If a PJ intends to implement a limitation, explain why the use of a limitation is necessary to
address the unmet need or gap in benefits and services received by individuals and families in the
qualifying population or subpopulation of qualifying population, consistent with the PJ’s needs
assessment and gap analysis:
Not applicable.
3.If a limitation was identified, describe how the PJ will address the unmet needs or gaps in benefits
and services of the other qualifying populations that are not included in the limitation through the
use of HOME-ARP funds (i.e., through another of the PJ’s HOME-ARP projects or activities):
Not applicable.
Page 30 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
21
Appendix A: Stakeholder Consultation Materials
Page 31 of 100
City of Lynchburg
HOME-ARP Stakeholder Consultation
Stakeholders Invited to Participate
Organization Type of Agency /Organization
Bedford Domestic Violence Services DV service provider
Bedford Social Services public agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Centra Health private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Central Virginia Alliance for Community Living private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Central Virginia Community College public agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
City of Lynchburg public agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Community Access Network private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Embrace Healthy Solutions private agency that addresses needs of persons with disabilities
Fontaine Foundation private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Horizon Behavioral Health public organization that addresses needs of persons with disabilities
HumanKind private organization that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Interfaith Outreach Association at-risk of homelessness service provider
Johnson Health Center private agency that addresses the needs of qualifying populations
Lynchburg Area Center for Independent Living Persons with disabilities
Lynchburg Area Veteran Council veterans' group
Lynchburg City Schools public agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Lynchburg Community Action Group at-risk of homelessness service provider
Lynchburg Daily Bread private organization that addresses the needs of qualifying populations
Lynchburg Public Defender’s Office Organization that addresses civil rights
Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority public housing authority
Lynchburg Social Services organization that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Miriam’s House at-risk of homelessness service provider, homeless service provider
Old Dominion Job Corps Center private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Park View Community Mission private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations, at-risk of homelessness service provider
Patrick Henry private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Refuge of Hope, Inc. homeless service provider
Rush Homes Persons with disabilities
Salvation Army homeless service provider, at-risk of homelessness service provider
TAP into Hope Private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations/veterans, at-risk of homelessness service provider
The Brother Kolbe Project private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
The Haven private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
United Way private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
University of Lynchburg private agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Virginia Career Works public agency that addresses needs of qualifying populations
Virginia Legal Aid Society Organization that addresses fair housing/civil rights
YWCA of Central Virginia DV service provider
Page 32 of 100
HOME-ARP Stakeholder Discussions
Please join us to discuss the federal HOME-ARP funds received by Lynchburg, the
Qualifying Populations that may receive assistance, and eligibl
e uses of program
funding. Stakeholders will be asked how these funds may address community
housing needs and gaps in services related to this program.
For additional details about HOME-ARP, view this video.
Stakeholder Session #1
July 26
, 2022 | 10:00 - 11:30 AM
Meeting link: https://meet.goto.com/670112125
Join via phone: +1 (224) 501-3412
Access code: 670-112-125
Stakeholder Session #2
July 28, 2022 | 10:00 - 11:30 AM
Meeting link: https://meet.goto.com/709990493
Join via phone: +1 (872) 240-3212
Access code: 709-990-493
For additional information, please contact:
Melva Walker
Department of Community Development
melva.walker@lynchburgva.gov
Haley Campbell
Department of Development
haley.campbell@lynchburgva.gov
Download GoToMeeting app here : https://meet.goto.com/install
Page 33 of 100
HOME- ARP ALLOCATION PLAN:
STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATIONS
City of Lynchburg, VA
Page 34 of 100
THE HOME-
AMERICAN
RESCUE PLAN
(ARP) )
SEC. 3205. HOMELESSNESS
ASSISTANCE AND SUPPORTIVE
SERVICES PROGRAM.
Provides $5 billion of supplemental
HOME funds to assist individuals or
households who are homeless, at risk
of homelessness and other vulnerable
populations by providing housing,
rental assistance, supportive services,
and non-congregate shelter.
Lynchburg is receiving $1,498,471
Page 35 of 100
QUALIFYING POPULATIONS
Homeless, as defined in section 103(a)
of the McKinney-Vento Homeless
Assistance Act
At-risk of homelessness, as defined in
section 401(1) of the McKinney-Vento
Homeless Assistance Act
Fleeing, or attempting to flee, domestic
violence, dating violence, sexual
assault, stalking, or human trafficking,
as defined by the Secretary
Other populations who do not qualify
under any of the populations above
but meet one of the following criteria:
(a) Other families requiring services or
housing assistance to prevent
homelessness
(b) Those at greatest risk of housing
instability
Page 36 of 100
HUD HOME- ARP
DEFINITION
HOMELESS
an individual or family who lacks a fixed,
regular, and adequate nighttime residence
an individual or family with a primary nighttime
residence that is a public or private place not
meant for human habitation, including a car, park,
abandoned building, bus or train station, airport,
or camping ground
an individual or family living in shelter
designated to provide temporary living
arrangements
an individual who resided in a shelter or place
not meant for human habitation and who is
exiting an institution where he or she temporarily
resided
an individual or family who will imminently lose
their housing, including housing they own, rent, or
live in without paying rent, are sharing with
others, and rooms in hotels or motels
Page 37 of 100
HUD HOME- ARP
DEFINITION AT
RISK OF
HOMELESSNESS
Multiple Moves: Has moved because of
economic reasons two or more times during the
60 days immediately preceding the application
for assistance
Doubled Up: Is living in the home of another
because of economic hardship
Hotel/Motel: Lives in a hotel or motel and the
cost is not paid for by charitable organizations
or by federal, state, or local government
programs for low-income individuals
Overcrowded Housing: Lives in a single room
occupancy (SRO) or efficiency apartment unit
where two or more persons reside or where
there are more than one-and-a-half persons per
room
Exiting Institution: Is exiting a publicly funded
institution or system of care (e.g., jail, prison,
psychiatric hospital, etc.)
Income at or below 30% AMI,
Lacks sufficient resources to attain
housing stability AND:
1-person household: $16,600
4-person household: $27,750
Page 38 of 100
ELIGIBLE ACTIVITIES
PRODUCTION
OR
PRESERVATION
OF AFFORDABLE
HOUSING
TENANT-BASED
RENTAL
ASSISTANCE
(TBRA)
SUPPORTIVE
SERVICES,
HOMELESS
PREVENTION
SERVICES, AND
HOUSING
COUNSELING
PURCHASE AND
DEVELOPMENT
OF NON-
CONGREGATE
SHELTER
NONPROFIT
OPERATING
AND CAPACITY
BUILDING
Page 39 of 100
DISCUSSION
Page 40 of 100
NEXT STEPS
Stakeholder comments will be considered when drafting the HOME-ARP
Allocation Plan
Round 2 of stakeholder outreach is anticipated in early October
15-day public comment period and public hearing on Draft HOME-ARP
Allocation Plan planned for October / November
Submission of the HOME-ARP Allocation Plan anticipated in November /
December
Page 41 of 100
FOR MORE INFORMATION
View a 21-minute narrated video with additional program info at:
HOME-ARP Overview Video or https://vimeo.com/701705670/4b0f271d58
Contacts:
Melva Walker, Grants Coordinator
melva.walker@lynchburgva.gov
Haley Campbell
haley.Campbell@lynchburgva.gov
Sarah Quarantotto
sarah@miriamshouseprogram.org
Page 42 of 100
1
Lynchburg, VA HOME-ARP / Central VA CoC Board Meeting
07/06/22 11:00-1:00 pm
Organizations represented: Agency/Organization Type (required stakeholders in italics)
Lynchburg CoC Continuum of Care
Lynchburg Redevelopment & Housing Authority Public housing authority
Miriam’s House Homeless service provider
Centra Hospital Private organization serving the needs of the QPs
Interfaith Outreach Association Homeless service provider
Community Health Center Public agency serving the needs of the QPs
(plus other unidentified attendees)
1. What are the most critical gaps and needs in the local homeless and housing service
system?
• Our hospital is at a crisis level because we cannot safely discharge patients who have
nowhere to go. We keep them in the hospital for 30-40 days until space is found
somewhere. The majority of these patients are chronically homeless.
• Maintaining housing on low-wage jobs makes it very difficult to pay rent on time
every month. These households have no subsidy and are at risk for homelessness. It’s
expected that this situation will increase as the Covid safety nets disappear. Landlords
are choosing not to rent to tenants who couldn’t reliably pay rent during Covid.
• Housing development is occurring but nearly of it is single-family units at high sales
prices. Nearby communities have more affordable options but the units are typically
substandard.
• Lynchburg lost its low-barrier shelter last year. The Community Health Center can
provide primary mental and physical care but there aren’t units to release them to.
2. Barriers to obtaining housing and remaining stably housed
• Credit scores required by landlords are too high even if a tenant has money to pay
the rent
• “Source of income” is a protected class but landlords will deny tenants with vouchers
due to poor or no credit even though they could pay the rent
• We need to market to more landlords to increase the availability of those willing to
participate in the HCV program
Page 43 of 100
1
Lynchburg, VA HOME-ARP Stakeholder Consultation
07/26/22 10:00-11:30 am
Organizations represented: Agency/Organization Type (required stakeholders in italics)
Lynchburg CoC Continuum of Care
Johnson Health Center Private organization that addresses the needs of the QPs
University of Lynchburg Private organization that addresses the needs of the QPs
Old Dominion Jobs Corps Center Private organization that addresses the needs of the QPs
Rush Homes Homeless service provider
Lynchburg Public Defender’s Office Organization that addresses civil rights
Lynchburg Redevelopment & Housing Authority Public housing authority
Miriam’s House Homeless service provider
Interfaith Outreach Association Homeless service provider
YWCA of Central VA Domestic violence service provider
1. What are the most critical gaps and needs in the local homeless and housing service
system?
• Affordable units in good condition available to rent overall
• “We have ERAP and RRH funding available but no housing to give them” –
stakeholder
• “More units would shorten the period of living outside” – formerly homeless
individual
• A low-barrier congregate shelter is needed to replace the one that closed. There is
funding for shelter operations.
• Trade school students have skills and jobs paying $18/hr, they want to remain in
Lynchburg but they can’t find affordable housing
• Youth ages 16-24 who are couch-surfers—they need housing and transportation to
jobs
• Education for tenants and landlords on the eviction process; many tenants vacate
their units after five days rather than remain for the full 45-day period they’re
entitled, seek assistance and try to avoid eviction
o Most tenants in eviction court have no legal representation
• Persons with disabilities who need housing with a strong supportive service level
• Rental assistance in the form of TBRA and PBRA
• Supportive services are need on housing projects where they weren’t included in the
initial operating budget; these tenants are struggling with the proper level of
supportive services
• PSH tenants can end up in jail without supportive services
• While there are supportive services available in our community, the level is
inadequate meaning households in need of services are at risk of housing instability
• Requests through homeless hotline for affordable housing cannot be met
• Poor credit can keep homeless persons from becoming housed
Page 44 of 100
2
• Units of all bedroom sizes needed—1-bedrooms for single adults, larger units for
families
• Survey of LRHA ROSS program participants in 2021 revealed 80% needed jobs, transit
and childcare; LHRA needs partners to provide these supportive services
• Significant population re-entering from prison with nowhere to go. These individuals
have high barriers to securing housing and high levels of need for supportive services.
2. Additional comments
• PSH units need a deep subsidy for 0-30% AMI tenants
Page 45 of 100
1
Lynchburg, VA HOME-ARP Stakeholder Consultation
07/28/22 10:00-11:30 am
Organizations represented: Agency/Organization Type (required stakeholders in italics)
Lynchburg CoC Continuum of Care
Rush Homes Homeless service provider
Lynchburg Redevelopment & Housing Authority Public housing authority
Miriam’s House Homeless service provider
Virginia Legal Aid Society Organization that addresses civil rights, fair housing
1. What are the most critical gaps and needs in the local homeless and housing service
system?
• Finding units to place clients who are high-barrier and non-competitive in the rental
market with non-homeless persons
• Without units available, it can take 60+ days to place homeless individuals and
families; 1-bedroom units are our greatest need
• One homeless youth client has a TBRA voucher but there are no 1-bedroom units
available and the payment standard for the voucher is too low to compete against the
higher market rents that landlords can get
• We have clients competing for the same PSH and RRH units
• Rush Homes market study for a 31-unit affordable housing development
demonstrated the high demand for rental units
• Resources available to fund supportive services have outpaced housing dollars
• Rush Homes: A lack of supportive service funding for affordable housing
developments forces them to forego units for persons with disabilities to qualify
competitively for LIHTC funding
Page 46 of 100
1
Lynchburg, VA HOME-ARP / Phone Interview: VA Legal Aid Society
09/26/22 11:00 am
Organizations represented: Agency/Organization Type (required stakeholders in italics)
VA Legal Aid Society Organization that addresses civil rights, fair housing
• VLAS provides eviction prevention, RRH program, housing navigators to assist
communities
• Need additional eviction prevention funding
• VA Eviction Reduction Program could assist; City of Lynchburg could apply for funding
Page 47 of 100
1
Lynchburg, VA HOME-ARP / Phone Interview: Lynchburg Area Veterans Council
10/06/22 11:00 am-12:00 pm
Organizations represented: Agency/Organization Type (required stakeholders in italics)
Lynchburg Area Veterans Council Veterans services
• Council is a 501(c)(3) that accepts only private donations, annual budget of about
$70,000
• Member of the Central VA CoC; represents several hundred veterans in the area
• Provide financial assistance for rent, utilities, moving, vehicles—basically filling the gaps
that state and federal resources can’t pay for; managed like transitional housing with
one-year leases allowed; then work with the CoC to find them more permanent living
arrangements
• Brings veterans to get assessed by CoC and houses them in motels until they can get
rental assistance; motel rooms take about $20,000/year of their budget at $85/night
• The Council maintains a three-bedroom house for veterans who pay rent
• The Hands Up lodge (congregate shelter) is now closed and there are veterans living on
the street
• Affordable housing is needed
Page 48 of 100
HOME-ARP Stakeholder Consultations Round 2
Join us for the final round of stakeholder consultations focusing on a review of
the key findings on the unmet housing and supportive service ne
eds of
Lynchburg's Qualifying Populations. Stakeholder comments will be included in
the Draft Allocation Plan anticipated to be released in November for a 15-day
public comment period. Both sessions will have the same format and agenda.
For additional details about HOME-ARP, view this video .
Stakeholder Session #1
Oct 11, 2022 | 9:30 AM - 11:00 AM
Meeting link: https://meet.goto.com/913692301
Join via phon
e: +1 (872) 240-3212
Access code:
913-692-301
Stakeholder Session #2
Oct 13, 2022 | 1:00 PM - 2:30 PM
Meeting link: https://meet.goto.com/707220429
Join via phone: +1 (224) 501-3412
Access code: 707-220-429
Download GoToMeeting app here: https://meet.goto.com/install
For additional information, please contact:
Melva Walker
Department of Community Development
melva.walker@lynchburgva.gov
Haley Campbell
Department of Community Development
haley.campbell@lynchburgva.gov
Page 49 of 100
HOME- ARP ALLOCATION PLAN:
STAKEHOLDER CONSULTATIONS
City of Lynchburg, VA
October 11th and 13th
Page 50 of 100
THE HOME-
AMERICAN
RESCUE PLAN
(ARP) )
SEC. 3205. HOMELESSNESS
ASSISTANCE AND SUPPORTIVE
SERVICES PROGRAM.
Provides $5 billion of supplemental
HOME funds to assist individuals or
households who are homeless, at risk
of homelessness and other vulnerable
populations by providing housing,
rental assistance, supportive services,
and non-congregate shelter.
Lynchburg is receiving $1,498,471
Page 51 of 100
QUALIFYING POPULATIONS
Homeless, as defined in section
103(a) of the McKinney-Vento
Homeless Assistance Act
At-risk of homelessness, as defined
in section 401(1) of the McKinney-
Vento Homeless Assistance Act
Fleeing, or attempting to flee,
domestic violence, dating violence,
sexual assault, stalking, or human
trafficking, as defined by the
Secretary
Other populations who do not qualify
under any of the populations above
but meet one of the following criteria:
(a) Other families requiring services
or housing assistance to prevent
homelessness
(b) Those at greatest risk of housing
instability
Page 52 of 100
STAKEHOLDER IDENTIFIED NEEDS / ISSUES
More affordable and accessible rental housing for lower-income households
▪Without adequate supply of affordable units, may take 60+ days to place someone
▪ Individuals/families with TBRA/Housing Choice Voucher can’t find units
Need three- and four-bedroom rental units for families but individual adults have difficulty
finding studios and one-bedroom units
Lots of housing development occurring but none is affordable; nearby communities have lower-
cost housing but units are substandard
Need TBRA and Project-based Rental Assistance to make affordable housing financially
accessible to 0-30%, in some cases
More supportive services are needed to get people housed and to maintain stability—case
management, transportation, employment training, financial counseling, childcare, legal
services, substance abuse treatment, and more
Page 53 of 100
STAKEHOLDER IDENTIFIED NEEDS / ISSUES
(CONTINUED)
Transportation, childcare and jobs needed to work toward housing stability
Many landlords refuse HCV for higher market rents, also refuse tenants with criminal histories,
evictions, poor credit (even with ability to pay rent), released offenders
Level of HCV is inadequate to serve families in need of subsidized rental housing
Some individuals cannot be released from local hospital for 30-40 days until housing is found
Need a low-barrier shelter to replace the one that closed last year; funding for operations
exist
At-risk of homelessness: households without subsidies, barely making ends meet on low-wage
jobs
Released offenders have few, if any, affordable housing options
Page 54 of 100
DATA ANALYSIS: LYNCHBURG
84 Number of persons experiencing homelessness during 2022 PIT Count
673 Number of persons served in the homeless system
239 Persons experiencing homelessness for the first time
157 Persons fleeing domestic violence, etc.
89 Persons exited the homeless system to temporary destinations
2,442 Households received VDHCD ERAP funding (2020-2022)
74% ERAP payments made to 0-30% Area Median Income households;
average amount paid was $3,737 per household
4,285 Persons with independent living difficulty disability
3,174 Persons with disabilities living below 150% of poverty ($25,860 in 2020)
Page 55 of 100
DATA ANALYSIS: LYNCHBURG HOUSING &
REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
1,315 Applicants on LRHA HCV waiting list; 73% are 0-30% AMI
75% Black/African American applicants on waiting list
72% Families with children
23% Families with members with disabilities
2,348 Applicants on LRHA public housing waiting list; 67% are 0-30% AMI
57% Black/African American applicants on waiting list
74% Families with children
20% Families with members with disabilities
Page 56 of 100
DATA ANALYSIS: LYNCHBURG HOUSING GAP
Renter Households 0-30% AMI 31-50% AMI Total
Total Households 3,655 2,340 5,995
Affordable Housing Units 1,755 3,740 5,495
Units Occupied by Appropriate
Income Tier
650 760 1,410
Units Occupied by Other Income
Households
1,105 2,980 4,085
Housing Gap 3,005 1,580 4,585
0-30% Area Median Income in Lynchburg
up to $16,600 for a 1-person household
up to $27,750 for a 4-person household
31-50% Area Median Income in Lynchburg
$16,601-$27,650 for a 1-person household
$27,751-$39,450 for a 4-person household
Source: HUD Section 8 Income Limits for Lynchburg, VA MSA, effective April 2022
Source: 2014-2018 HUD CHAS Dataset
Page 57 of 100
PRIORITY NEEDS
LYNCHBURG
Development of affordable and accessible rental housing
Permanent Supportive Housing rental units for homeless persons
Increased supportive services
Page 58 of 100
QUESTIONS?
Page 59 of 100
NEXT STEPS
Comments from these sessions will be considered when completing the Plan
November 27 - December 13: public comment period
December 13: public hearing at City Council meeting with Council expected
to take action on Plan
December 16: submission to HUD
Page 60 of 100
FOR MORE INFORMATION
View a 21-minute narrated video with additional program info at:
HOME-ARP Overview Video or https://vimeo.com/701705670/4b0f271d58
Contacts:
Melva Walker, Grants Manager
melva.walker@lynchburgva.gov
Haley Campbell, Grants Coordinator
haley.Campbell@lynchburgva.gov
Sarah Quarantotto, Executive Director, Miriam’s House, Central VA Continuum of Care
Lead Agency
sarah@miriamshouseprogram.org
Page 61 of 100
1
Lynchburg, VA HOME-ARP Stakeholder Consultation
10/11/22 9:30-11:00 am
Organizations represented: Agency/Organization Type (required stakeholders in italics)
Lynchburg CoC Continuum of Care
Johnson Health Center Private organization that addresses the needs of the QPs
Rush Homes Homeless service provider
Miriam’s House Homeless service provider
Interfaith Outreach Association Homeless service provider
• Presentation summarizing identified needs made
• Comments from stakeholders:
o Surprised that the waiting lists at LRHA are open
o Rush Homes: not seeing as many HCV holders among applicants for its housing and very
low turnover among current tenants
o This proves the need for affordable rental housing
o Clients have vouchers but no units are available and landlords are not renewing leases
for current voucher holders
o RRH funding is available but cannot be used for paying late fees on rent; seeing the same
tenants struggle who were struggling before to pay rent on time
Page 62 of 100
1
Lynchburg, VA HOME-ARP Stakeholder Consultation
10/13/22 1:00-2:30 pm
Organizations represented: Agency/Organization Type (required stakeholders in italics)
Rush Homes Homeless service provider
Lynchburg Area Center for Independent Living Organization serving needs of persons with disabilities
• Presentation summarizing identified needs made
• Comments from stakeholders:
o This information validates our experience
o Currently there are 600+ on Rush Homes’ waiting list
o The CIL receives requests for apartments that are affordable and accessible to persons
with disabilities
Many tenants—due to generational poverty and mobility disabilities—are
incapable of maintaining their home and would benefit from housekeeping
services to remain housed. Otherwise, this becomes a risk factor for eviction.
Page 63 of 100
DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW DRAFT FOR PUBLIC REVIEW
22
Appendix B: Public Participation Materials
[to be inserted upon completion of public comment period and public hearing]
Page 64 of 100
City Council
Agenda Item III.2.
Information Only
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY
January 10, 2023 Greg Patrick, Deputy City Manager
AGENDA ITEM # III.2
Considerations for Establishing a School Funding Formula
RECOMMENDATION
Informational Only - No City Council action is required at this time
SUMMARY
This presentation will provide City Council with an overview of K-12 funding in the Commonwealth
and the considerations around potentially implementing a School Funding Formula that would
provide an objective basis for determining the city’s local contribution to Lynchburg City
Schools. Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick will also share his experience negotiating and
implementing a school funding formula between the City of Norfolk and Norfolk Public Schools.
PRIOR ACTION(S)
The City Manager's FY 2023 Budget included a commitment to provide Council with a discussion of
a School Funding Formula as part of FY 2024 budget development. This presentation is a
fulfillment of that commitment.
FISCAL IMPACT
N/A
CONTACT(S)
Greg Patrick, Deputy City Manager
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Presentation
REVIEWED BY
Date: January 05, 2023
Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council
Page 65 of 100
ESTABLISHING A LOCAL REVENUE
ALLOCATION POLICY
City Council Work Session
January 10, 2023
Page 66 of 100
K-12 FUNDING IN THE COMMONWEAL TH
§ General Assembly’s constitutional responsibility – provide for a system of free and appropriate public
education
§ State utilizes complex Standards of Quality (SOQ) funding model to determine state and
minimum local funding for each division
§ Local governing body allocates resources, school board operates the school system
§ Local school divisions do not have taxing authority
§ All funds must be appropriated through the local governing body
§ State Sets a local funding floor – the Required Local Effort (RLE)
§ RLE calculated based on a localities Composite Index of Local Ability to Pay and Enrollment
2
Page 67 of 100
K-12 FUNDING IN THE COMMONWEAL TH (CONT.)
§ Code of Virginia allows local appropriation of funds for public education in two ways:
§ Lump Sum (most common)
§ By Categories
§ Categories are as follows:
§ 1. Instruction
§ 2. Administration, attendance, and health
§ 3. Pupil transportation
§ 4. Operation and maintenance
§ 5. School food services and other noninstructional operations
§ 6. Facilities
§ 7. Debt and fund transfers
§ 8. Technology
§ 9. Contingency reserves
3
Page 68 of 100
L YNCHBURG CITY SCHOOLS FUNDING
4
Local, ongoing
support:
$40.7
State, ongoing
support:
$63.5
Federal / Other:
$1.6
FY 2023 Operating Revenue
$105.8 million
Focus of Revenue
Sharing Model
Page 69 of 100
BENEFITS OF A LOCAL REVENUE
ALLOCATION POLICY
§ Provide a predictable and objective method to determine the city’s local
contribution to schools
§ Improve the ability of the city and schools’ staff to plan and budget
§ Link school funding to economic growth to recognize the importance of schools
to the city’s economic success
§ Transition Council / School Board conversations from funding to performance
5
Page 70 of 100
REVENUE SOURCES INCLUDED IN FORMULA
6
Page 71 of 100
FUNDING
FORMULA
MODELS
7
Constant Share
Split Growth
Modified Constant Share
Per Pupil
Page 72 of 100
CONSTANT SHARE MODEL
§ Schools receives a constant share of a specified “bucket” of local revenues
§ Easiest to understand – City and Schools budgets will increase or decrease at the
at the same rate
§ Does not factor in enrollment / ADM
§ Difficult to negotiate the sharing percentage
§ Important to include sources of local revenue that are tied to the city’s economic
performance
8
Page 73 of 100
SPLIT GROWTH MODEL
§ Schools receives a constant share of the growth of a specified “bucket” of local
revenues
§ Complicated – City and schools' budgets will increase at different rates
§ Does not factor in enrollment / ADM
§ Can negotiate sharing percentage of revenue growth
§ Important to include sources of local revenue that are tied to the city’s economic
performance
9
Page 74 of 100
MODIFIED CONSTANT SHARE MODEL
§ Schools receives a constant share of a specified “bucket” of local revenues after
adjusting for RLE
§ Complicated – requires a good understanding of Virginia K-12 funding policy to
understand calculation
§ Impacted but not driven by ADM
§ Difficult to negotiate the sharing percentage
§ Important to include sources of local revenue that are tied to the city’s economic
performance
10
Page 75 of 100
PER PUPIL MODEL
§ Schools receive funding based on a calculated per pupil amount multiplied by ADM
§ Per Pupil amount adjusted based on growth in a specified bucket of local revenues
§ Most complicated model
§ Funding can fluctuate significantly based on enrollment
§ True-up process (projected vs actual ADM) can also cause large fluctuations in funding
§ Enrollment is king which may incentivize sub-optimal practices
§ Difficult to negotiate the initial per pupil funding amount
§ Important to include sources of local revenue that are tied to the city’s economic
performance
11
Page 76 of 100
FY 2005 FY 2006 FY 2007 FY 2008 FY 2009 FY 2010 FY 2011 FY 2012 FY 2013 FY 2014 FY 2015 FY 2016 FY 2017 FY 2018
$1.8
$0.7
$5.0
$3.5 $3.4
($3.5)
$3.5
$0.0
$2.7
$4.7
$0.6
$0.0
$2.5
$3.0
$6.3
$7.1 $6.9
$1.3
$2.5
$0.5
($1.1)
$0.4
($0.4)
$1.7 $2.0 $1.7 $1.7
$4.1
Actual YoY Change Model YoY Change
High
growth
(amounts in millions)Moderate
growth
Low
growth
Moderate
growth
Average incremental change (actual): $2.0 million
Average incremental change (model): $2.5 million
Total additional local funding (model): $113.4 million (FY 2004 – FY 2018)
INCREMENTAL FUNDING
ACTUAL VS. CONSTANT SHARE MODEL
FY 2005 – FY 2018
12
Page 77 of 100
RESUL TS SINCE IMPLEMENTATION
13
$126.0 $121.0 $129.6
$140.3
FY 2020 FY 2021 FY 2022 FY 2023
$3.0 (5.0)
$8.6
$10.7
$17.3M
Page 78 of 100
A COMPREHENSIVE POLICY
§ Definitions
§ Revenue Sharing Formula Calculation
§ Calculation
§ Revenue Sources
§ True-up Provision
§ Reversion Funds
§ Process to Revise the Policy
§ Procedure for Schools to Request an Increase in the Local
Contribution
14
Page 79 of 100
HAS IT BEEN A SUCCESS?
§ Yes! – City and Schools would both agree
§ Has de-politicized the city’s funding of the schools operating budget
§ Budget planning is much more straight forward
§ Schools has not yet requested more operating funds than the formula provides
15
Page 80 of 100
LESSONS LEARNED / OTHER CONSIDERATIONS
§ Policy does not address debt service, capital maintenance, or school construction
§ Tax-rate changes have a direct impact on school funding
§ Adopting the Policy – Council adopted by resolution, Schools has never formally
recognized the policy
16
Page 81 of 100
DISCUSSION
17
Page 82 of 100
City Council
Agenda Item IV.3.
Business Item Briefings
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY
January 10, 2023 Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer
AGENDA ITEM # IV.3
FY 2023 General Obligation Public Improvement Bond Issue
RECOMMENDATION
This item will appear for City Council vote on the January 24, 2023 agenda as a Public Hearing.
SUMMARY
In coordination with the City's financial advisors, Davenport and Company, LLC, and the City's bond
counsel, Hawkins, Delafield, & Wood, a resolution will be presented to approve a general obligation
public improvement bond issue to permanently finance the current Bond Anticipation Note and fund
various capital projects including the Police Headquarters. The resolution will include a "not to
exceed" clause of $78,500,000 which includes all issuance costs and also an estimate should the
bonds sell at a discount.
PRIOR ACTION(S)
June 9, 2020 Establish Up to a $42,000,000 Line of Credit for Interim Capital Financing
FISCAL IMPACT
Cost of issuance and debt service for the new bond issue
CONTACT(S)
Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Power Point Presentation - BIBs - FY 2023 GO Bond Issue
REVIEWED BY
Date: December 27, 2022
Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer
Date: January 03, 2023
Mercedes Braun, Executive Assistant to the City Manager
Page 83 of 100
Date: January 05, 2023
Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
Date: January 05, 2023
Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council
Page 84 of 100
FY 2023 GENERAL OBLIGATION
PUBLIC IMPROVEMENT BOND
ISSUE
Tuesday, January 10, 2023
Page 85 of 100
PURPOSE AND ACTION
Purpose:
The current Bond Anticipation Note (BAN) comes due June 2023. This
issue will permanently finance the BAN and fund current projects. In a
separate action, the next BAN will be established.
Why:
The goal is to not pay debt service on funds till needed.
Page 86 of 100
PURPOSE AND ACTION
History:
A borrowing strategy was created about 10 years ago
Establish a BAN or line of credit and permanently finance it every 2-3
years
Only pay interest on the drawn funds and then pay principal when
permanently financed
Allows for delays in project start or for projects to start ahead of
schedule
Page 87 of 100
EXPECTED ACTION
Hold the required public hearing on January 24, 2023
Vote to approve the resolution to issue General Obligation Public
Improvement Bonds not to exceed $78,500,000
FYI
Credit Rating Agency visits will be February 1, 2023
Bond Sale last week of February
Closing the first week of March
Page 88 of 100
City Council
Agenda Item IV.4.
Business Item Briefings
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY
January 10, 2023 Lee Newland, City Engineer
AGENDA ITEM # IV.4
Additional City Street Mileage for Virginia Department of Transportation Highway Maintenance
Payments
RECOMMENDATION
This item will come before Council for action at its January 24, 2023 meeting. Approve the attached
resolution requesting the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) to increase the official City
street lane mileage for reimbursement of highway maintenance funds for FY 2024.
SUMMARY
When required, usually each year, the City submits a list of new or improved streets to VDOT for
acceptance into the street maintenance system for payments to the City from the
Commonwealth. For FY 2024, staff has identified 5.23 lane miles of street segments that need to
be added. These street segments are shown on the attached maps and VDOT U-1 Form.
This action is required by VDOT to add these segments for addition to the system.
PRIOR ACTION(S)
None
FISCAL IMPACT
5.23 additional lane miles will increase highway maintenance funds in the amount of $79,880
annually.
CONTACT(S)
Lee Newland, City Engineer
Gaynelle Hart, Director of Public Works
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. RESOLUTION
2. U-1 FORM FY2024
3. FY2024 Street Addition Map
REVIEWED BY
Page 89 of 100
Date: January 05, 2023
Gaynelle Hart, Director of Public Works
Date: January 05, 2023
Greg Patrick, Deputy City Manager
Date: January 05, 2023
Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council
Page 90 of 100
RESOLUTION:
WHEREAS, the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) requires action to increase the lane mileage for
street maintenance entitlement funds from the Commonwealth; and,
WHEREAS, 5.23 lane miles of local and arterial streets have been identified to be added to the system; and,
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED THAT: The Lynchburg City Council requests the Commonwealth
Transportation Board to approve the addition of lane mileage as enumerated on Form U-1.
Adopted:______________________
Certified:______________________
Clerk of Council
Page 91 of 100
1
Appendix B LOCAL ASSISTANCE DIVISION
VDOT
REQUEST FOR STREET ADDITION, DELETIONS AND CONVERSIONS FOR
STREET PAYMENTS SECTION 33.2-319
CODE OF VIRGINIA
Form U-1 (rev. 7-1-17)
MUNICIPALITY Lynchburg DISTRICT Lynchburg
ACTION REQUIRED
(SELECT BELOW)
STREET NAME ROUTE NUMBER FROM TERMINI TO R/W
(Width)
(FEET)
PAVEMENT
WIDTH
(FEET)
CENTER
LANE
(MILES)
NUMBER
OF
LANES
MOVING
LANE
MILES
Eligibility
Code
Reference
Link
FUNC. CLASS.
(TMPD USE
except for HR
and NOVA)
ADD (New Road) Elmwood Avenue Daura Road to Goodyear Drive 50 30 0.14 2 0.27 1
ADD (New Road) Runway Court Elmwood Avenue to End 50 24 0.07 2 0.15 2
ADD (New Road) Goodyear Drive Elmwood Avenue to Waughs Landing Drive 50 24 0.08 2 0.15 5
ADD (New Road) Waughs Landing Drive Elmwood Avenue to Goodyear Drive 50 24 0.17 2 0.34 5
ADD (New Road) Liberty Mountain Drive Candlers Mountain Road to South City Limits Varies 20-40 1.21 2 2.42 3
ADD (New Road) Mill Lane 0.6 Mi. North 501 to 1.24 Mi. North 501 Varies Varies 0.64 2 1.28 3
Lane Change Existing segment) Lakeside Drive 0.13 Mi. East Joel Street to Blue Ridge Street 80 34 -0.31 2 -0.63 1
Lane Change Existing segment) Lakeside Drive 0.13 Mi. East Joel Street to Blue Ridge Street Varies 48 0.31 4 1.25 1
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
SELECT ONE 0.00 Select one
* Council Resolution and Map Attached
SIGNED SIGNED
MUNICIPAL OFFICIAL DATE AUTHORIZED VDOT OFFICIAL DATE
Submit to: District Point of Contact in triplicate CLASSIFIED BY
T&MPD ENGINEER DATE
Page 92 of 100
Elmwood, Goodyear, Runway & Waughs Landing
µ
DISCLAIMER: THIS MAP IS NEITHER A LEGALLY RECORDED MAP NOR A SURVEY AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED AS
SUCH. THE INFORMATION DISPLAYED IS A COMPILATION OF RECORDS, INFORMATION, AND DATA OBTAINED FROM
VARIOUS SOURCES. THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ITS ACCURACY OR HOW CURRENT IT MAY BE.
0 300 600
ft
1 inch = 300 feet
PRINTED ON
December 29, 20221:3,600
Page 93 of 100
Liberty Mountain Drive
µ
DISCLAIMER: THIS MAP IS NEITHER A LEGALLY RECORDED MAP NOR A SURVEY AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED AS
SUCH. THE INFORMATION DISPLAYED IS A COMPILATION OF RECORDS, INFORMATION, AND DATA OBTAINED FROM
VARIOUS SOURCES. THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ITS ACCURACY OR HOW CURRENT IT MAY BE.
0 750 1,500
ft
1 inch = 750 feet
PRINTED ON
December 29, 20221:9,000
Page 94 of 100
Mill Lane
µ
DISCLAIMER: THIS MAP IS NEITHER A LEGALLY RECORDED MAP NOR A SURVEY AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED AS
SUCH. THE INFORMATION DISPLAYED IS A COMPILATION OF RECORDS, INFORMATION, AND DATA OBTAINED FROM
VARIOUS SOURCES. THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ITS ACCURACY OR HOW CURRENT IT MAY BE.
0 580 1,160
ft
1 inch = 583 feet
PRINTED ON
December 29, 20221:7,000
Page 95 of 100
Lakeside Drive
µ
DISCLAIMER: THIS MAP IS NEITHER A LEGALLY RECORDED MAP NOR A SURVEY AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED AS
SUCH. THE INFORMATION DISPLAYED IS A COMPILATION OF RECORDS, INFORMATION, AND DATA OBTAINED FROM
VARIOUS SOURCES. THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ITS ACCURACY OR HOW CURRENT IT MAY BE.
0 300 600
ft
1 inch = 300 feet
PRINTED ON
December 29, 20221:3,600
Page 96 of 100
City Council
Agenda Item IV.5.
Information Only
AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY
MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY
January 10, 2023 Matthew Freedman, City Attorney
AGENDA ITEM # IV.5
(TENTATIVE) Discuss a resolution expressing the City of Lynchburg’s intent to stand as a
Sanctuary City for Second Amendment rights.
RECOMMENDATION
To discuss the attached Resolution
SUMMARY
This matter appears before Council at the request of Mayor Stephanie Reed for discussion. Action
upon this Resolution is contemplated to be taken at a later date. The primary question for City
Council being whether the City of Lynchburg, Virginia should be declared a Second Amendment
Sanctuary.
PRIOR ACTION(S)
A Public Hearing on a similar Second Amendment Sanctuary Resolution was held on January 14,
2020. City Council did not declare the City of Lynchburg, Virginia a Second Amendment Sanctuary
on January 14, 2020.
FISCAL IMPACT
TBD
CONTACT(S)
Matthew Freedman, City Attorney
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. 2A Sancturary Resolution - Lynchburg - Draft Rev. 1-5-23 CA
REVIEWED BY
Date: January 09, 2023
Matthew Freedman, City Attorney
Page 97 of 100
Date: January 09, 2023
Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council
Page 98 of 100
1
A RESOLUTION TO DECLARE
THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, VIRGINIA
A SECOND AMENDMENT SANCTUARY
WHEREAS, the Second Amendment of the United States Constitution provides “[a] well regulated
Militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms,
shall not be infringed.”; and
WHEREAS, Article I, Section 13, of the Virginia Constitution provides “[t]hat a well regulated militia,
composed of the body of the people, trained to arms, is the proper, natural, and safe defense of a free
state, therefore, the right of the people to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed . . .”; and
WHEREAS, Article I, Section 1, of the Virginia Constitution provides “[t]hat all men are by nature equally
free and independent and have certain inherent rights, of which, when they enter into the state of
society, they cannot, by any compact, deprive or divest their posterity; namely, the enjoyment of life
and liberty, with the means of acquiring and possessing property, and pursuing and obtaining happiness
and safety.”; and
WHEREAS, Article I, Section 2 of the Virginia Constitution reads “[t]hat all power is vested in, and
consequently derived from, the people, that magistrates are their trustees and servants, and at all times
amenable to them.”; and
WHEREAS, the United States Supreme Court, in District of Columbia v. Heller, 554 U.S. 570 (2008),
guaranteed an individual’s right to possess firearms, unconnected with service in a militia, for
traditionally lawful purposes, including self-defense within the home, and the United States Supreme
Court, in McDonald v. Chicago, 561 U.S. 742 (2010), provided that an individual’s right to keep and
bear arms under the Second Amendment applies not just to the federal government but to the states
as well pursuant to the United States Constitution’s Fourteenth Amendment ‘due process clause’, and
the United States Supreme Court in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association, Inc. v Bruen, 597 U.S.
____ (2022),overturned the use of all “means-end” tests when interpreting a Second Amendment
challenge and provided that if a government wishes to restrict firearm ownership, then it must
“affirmatively prove that its firearms regulation is part of the historical tradition that delimits the outer
bounds of the right to keep and bear arms.”; and
WHEREAS, certain legislation that has or may be introduced in the Virginia General Assembly, and
certain legislation which has or may be introduced in the United States Congress could have the effect
of infringing upon the rights of law-abiding citizens to keep and bear arms, as guaranteed by the Second
Amendment to the United States Constitution and Article I, Section 13 of the Virginia Constitution; and
WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia is concerned about the passage of any bill
containing language which could be interpreted as infringing upon the rights of the law-abiding citizens
of Lynchburg, Virginia to keep and bear arms; and
WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia desires to express its deep commitment to
the rights of all law-abiding citizens of Lynchburg, Virginia to keep and bear arms; and
WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia wishes to express opposition to any bill or
law that would unconstitutionally restrict the rights of the law-abiding citizens of Lynchburg, Virginia to
keep and bear arms; and
WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia desires to express its intent to stand as a
Sanctuary City for Second Amendment rights and to oppose, within the limits of the Constitution of the
United States of America and the Constitution of the Commonwealth of Virginia, any efforts to
unconstitutionally restrict such rights, and to use such legal means at its disposal to protect the rights
of the law-abiding citizens of Lynchburg, Virginia to keep and bear arms, including through legal action,
the power to appropriate public funds, and the right to petition for redress of grievances.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia:
Page 99 of 100
2
1. That the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia hereby declares the City of Lynchburg, Virginia a "Second
Amendment Sanctuary”; and
2. That the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia hereby expresses its intent to uphold the Second
Amendment rights of the law-abiding citizens of Lynchburg, Virginia; and
3. That the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia hereby expresses its intent that public funds of the City
not be used to restrict the Second Amendment rights of the law-abiding citizens of Lynchburg, Virginia or to
aid federal or state agencies in the restriction of such rights; and
4. That the Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia hereby declares its intent to oppose any infringement on
the rights of law-abiding citizens to keep and bear arms using such legal means as may be expedient,
including, without limitation, court action; and
5. That this Resolution shall be effective upon its adoption.
Adopted:
Certified:_________________________
Clerk of Council
Page 100 of 100
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.