RecordWell Data

City Council Retreat Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Oct 7, 2022 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Lynchburg City Council Retreat October 7, 2022 9:00AM – 4:00PM – Greater Lynchburg Transit Company 419 Bradley Drive, Lynchburg, VA 24501 Agenda I. Welcome, Arrival and Continental Breakfast 8:45-9am MaryJane Dolan, Mayor II. Agenda Overview 9-9:15am Wynter C. Benda, City Manager III. Chris Chmura Presentation 9:15-9:45am Dr. Chris Chmura, CEO, Chmura Economics & Analytics IV. Discussion 9:45-10:30am Group V. Break 10:30-10:45am VI. Chris DeLacy Presentation 10:45-11:15am Chris DeLacy, Partner, Holland & Knight VII. Discussion 11:15am-12:00pm Group VIII. Lunch 12:00-12:45pm IX. Housing Presentation 1-1:30pm Kent White, Director of Community Development X. Discussion 1:30-2pm Group XI. City Financials 2-2:30pm Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer XII. Discussion 2:30-3pm Group XIII. Closing Remarks 3-3:15pm MaryJane Dolan, Mayor XIV. Drive the Bus! 3:00-4:00pm Group 1© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics 2© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Economic Update and Overview: U.S. and City of Lynchburg October 6, 2022 3© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Overview  National Economy  Labor market is tight  Inflation is high and driving Fed behavior  Recession is likely  City of Lynchburg  Growing slower than the nation  Liberty University boosts growth  Tight labor market  Now more than ever, economic developers need to work with educators 4© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Two General Measures Show Inflation is Near a 40-Yr High: Personal Consumption Expenditure Price (PCE) Index and Consumer Price Index (CPI) Sources: BEA and BLS. Data through August 2022. -1.0 0.0 1.0 2.0 3.0 4.0 5.0 6.0 7.0 8.0 9.0 Aug-10 Aug-12 Aug-14 Aug-16 Aug-18 Aug-20 Aug-22 Percent Change, Year-Over-Year PCE CPI 5© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Lockdown Shifted Demand to Goods and Away From Services Source: BLS -6.0 -4.0 -2.0 0.0 2.0 4.0 6.0 8.0 10.0 12.0 14.0 16.0 Aug-10 Aug-12 Aug-14 Aug-16 Aug-18 Aug-20 Aug-22 Consumer Price Index Percent Change, Year-Over-Year Services Total Commodities 6© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Inflation Is Not Good For Long-Term Economic Growth  It is a regressive tax  It distorts decision making  Inventory accumulation  Can lead to deeper recessions  It can spiral upward with wages rising and inflation expectations ‘unanchored’  It can lead to recession if Fed continues to raise rates 7© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics -35.0 -25.0 -15.0 -5.0 5.0 15.0 25.0 35.0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Doesn’t Two Consecutive Declines in Real GDP Qualify As Recession? Source: BEA and Chmura Great Recession Quarterly Annualized 8© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics No, Not 2 Straight Declines in GDP NBER is the Arbiter of Recession in U.S. Sources: BLS, BEA, and Federal Reserve. 126,000 131,000 136,000 141,000 146,000 151,000 156,000 Aug-10 Aug-12 Aug-14 Aug-16 Aug-18 Aug-20 Aug-22 Nonfarm Employment, in Thousands -20.0 -15.0 -10.0 -5.0 0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0 30.0 Jul-10 Jul-13 Jul-16 Jul-19 Jul-22 Personal Income and Consumption Percent Change, Year-Over-Year Consumption Income -20 -16 -12 -8 -4 0 4 8 12 16 20 Jul-11 Jul-13 Jul-15 Jul-17 Jul-19 Jul-21 Industrial Production Percent Change, Year-Over-Year https://www.chmura.com/blog/five-horsemen-of-a-recession 9© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics The Economy is Slowing: Job Ads -6.5% Since June 27 10© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Job Ads for Staffing Firms -8.3% Since June 27 11© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Raising Federal Funds Rate Target Too Much Will Invert the Yield Curve Source: U.S. Treasury. 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 Treasury Curve, Interest Rates 3m 1yr 3yr 5yr 10yr 30yr Term 1-Year Ago Last Week of September 2021 12© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics An Inverted Yield Curve Typically Precedes a Recession (3-Month Bill vs. 10-Yr Note) Source: U.S. Treasury. 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5 3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 Treasury Curve, Interest Rates week ago 9/30/22 year ago 3m 1yr 3yr 5yr 10yr 30yr Term 13© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Latest Thoughts From Fed Officials Point to Further Increases in Federal Funds Rate Target  Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland President and CEO Loretta Mester, WSJ, September 10, 2022  “…elevated inflation was leading her to conclude the central bank would need to raise the central bank’s benchmark federal-funds rate to around 4% somewhat sooner than she had anticipated.”  Fed Governor Christopher Waller, WSJ, September 10, 2022  “…the Fed would need to lift the rate well above 4% if inflation accelerates in the coming months, and officials might be able to stop raising it shy of 4% if inflation suddenly decelerates, he said.”  Chair Jerome H. Powell, Jackson Hole, Wyoming  “We are moving our policy stance purposefully to a level that will be sufficiently restrictive to return inflation to 2 percent.”  “Our monetary policy deliberations and decisions build on what we have learned about inflation dynamics both from the high and volatile inflation of the 1970s and 1980s, and from the low and stable inflation of the past quarter-century.” 14© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Federal Reserve Chair Jerome Powell, August 19, 2022 (quote, emphasis mine)  Restoring price stability will take some time and requires using our tools forcefully to bring demand and supply into better balance. Reducing inflation is likely to require a sustained period of below- trend growth.  Moreover, there will very likely be some softening of labor market conditions.  While higher interest rates, slower growth, and softer labor market conditions will bring down inflation, they will also bring some pain to households and businesses.  These are the unfortunate costs of reducing inflation. But a failure to restore price stability would mean far greater pain  “To bring price increases down to 2%, we may need to tolerate unemployment of 6.5% for two years.” Jason Furman, WSJ, 9-8-22 15© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics © 2022 Chmura Economics and Analytics 16© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Real GDP Has Slowed—’Official’ Recession in Our Forecast -35.0 -25.0 -15.0 -5.0 5.0 15.0 25.0 35.0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Source: BEA and Chmura Quarterly Annualized Forecast 17© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Population in City Based on Census 18© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Lynchburg Labor Shed – 45 Minute Drive-Time Commute 19© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Lynchburg Employment is Fell 6,321 Jobs Since 2008Q4 Without Liberty University (w/o LU), 2022Q1 20© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Lynchburg City Employment (w/o LU) 21© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Strong Employment Growth with Liberty University Added Employment Recovered from Great Recession to Be Hit By Covid Lockdown 50,000 51,000 52,000 53,000 54,000 55,000 56,000 57,000 58,000 59,000 60,000 Employment Total Employment QCEW Total Employment with Liberty *Note: 2022 data represent an average of the first two quarters of the year for Liberty and the first quarter of the year for all other employment Source: Chmura's JobsEQ and Liberty University +1,014 59,368 +836 +54,444 58,077 22© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics 50,000 51,000 52,000 53,000 54,000 55,000 56,000 57,000 58,000 59,000 60,000 Employment Total Employment QCEW Total Employment with Liberty *Note: 2022 data represent an average of the first two quarters of the year for Liberty and the first quarter of the year for all other employment Source: Chmura's JobsEQ and Liberty University 1.2% annual average 0.5% annual average +1,014 59,368 +836 +54,444 58,077 Strong Employment Growth with Liberty University Added Employment Recovered from Great Recession to Be Hit By Covid Lockdown 23© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Covid Stimulus Funds Drove Spending and Supported Revenues Over Last 2 Years • Many communities are grappling with how to spend increased revenue • Investing in infrastructure enhances attractiveness of region for expansions • Expand air services • Inventory (land and buildings) for expanding firms • Workforce remains a top priority for firms • Work from home trend opportunity to attract more talent • Continue to invest and promote walkable communities • Support connectivity of K-12 to local firms, especially career technical education 24© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Employment Growing Slower Than National Average of 4.7% But “Tourism Experiences” Sectors Growing -0.6% 0.0% 1.1% 20.4% 4.4% 2.0% 4.0% 2.8% -7.6% 2.4% 3.2% 0.9% -3.7% 2.0% 26.9% -4.4% 4.4% 2.3% 27.5% 2.6% -10.0% -5.0% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% Health Care and Social Assistance Retail Trade Manufacturing Accommodation and Food Services Educational Services Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services Administrative and Support and Waste Management… Other Services (except Public Administration) Finance and Insurance Construction Transportation and Warehousing Wholesale Trade Public Administration Management of Companies and Enterprises Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation Real Estate and Rental and Leasing Information Utilities Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting Total - All Industries Ann % Change in Employment - Lynchburg 2021Q1-2022Q1 25© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics July 2022 Unemployment Rate Has Fallen to 3.8% Compared to 3.6% in the U.S. (Household Survey LU Employees) 26© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Lynchburg Employment Expected To Grow 1.6% Over Next Year Compared with 2.4% in U.S. Current, 2022Q1 (w/ LU) 2-Year History (w/ LU) 1-Year Forecast (w/o LU) Industry Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Empl. Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl. Growth Ann % Growth Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting 83 $16,101 0.11 17 12.00% 10 4 6 0 0.10% Utilities 106 $73,012 0.37 -4 -1.60% 8 3 7 -1 -1.20% Construction 1,761 $64,547 0.53 43 1.30% 191 54 116 20 1.10% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.3 -204 -1.70% 686 213 407 67 1.10% Wholesale Trade 1,375 $74,113 0.65 -115 -3.90% 170 51 96 24 1.70% Retail Trade 6,191 $30,166 1.06 -536 -4.10% 840 337 498 5 0.10% Transportation and Warehousing 1,447 $57,234 0.51 22 0.80% 201 63 100 38 2.70% Information 482 $48,997 0.42 -52 -5.00% 52 15 31 5 1.10% Finance and Insurance 2,006 $82,488 0.87 -103 -2.50% 170 62 118 -10 -0.50% Real Estate and Rental and Leasing 704 $42,918 0.71 -106 -6.80% 80 29 41 9 1.30% Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 3,122 $94,449 0.77 -21 -0.30% 329 95 180 53 1.70% Management of Companies and Enterprises 960 $75,218 1.14 31 1.70% 104 30 57 17 1.70% Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services 2,294 $32,153 0.63 -431 -8.20% 333 104 167 62 2.70% Educational Services 8,730 $39,536 1.96 -279 -2.00% 485 155 192 138 3.80% Health Care and Social Assistance 11,338 $60,194 1.39 -788 -3.30% 1,089 487 592 10 0.10% Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation 871 $17,185 0.86 85 5.30% 195 52 74 70 8.00% Accommodation and Food Services 5,345 $19,706 1.15 -382 -3.40% 1,206 394 536 277 5.20% Other Services (except Public Administration) 2,060 $30,156 0.85 -244 -5.40% 268 94 136 37 1.80% Public Administration 1,340 $53,911 0.51 -88 -3.10% 110 48 77 -15 -1.10% Unclassified 90 $40,167 1.25 -5 -2.50% 5 4 6 -4 -4.70% Total - All Industries 56,243 $50,439 1 -3,160 -2.76% 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.60% Source: Chmura’s JobsEQ. 27© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Some Industries Still Shy of Covid Peak Employment Industries Most Impacted by Covid: Unable to WFH or Social Distance Current, 2022Q1 (w/ LU) 2-Year History (w/ LU) 1-Year Forecast (w/o LU) Industry Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl Growth Ann % Growth Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting 83 $16,101 0.11 17 12.00% 10 4 6 0 0.10% Utilities 106 $73,012 0.37 -4 -1.60% 8 3 7 -1 -1.20% Construction 1,761 $64,547 0.53 43 1.30% 191 54 116 20 1.10% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.3 -204 -1.70% 686 213 407 67 1.10% Wholesale Trade 1,375 $74,113 0.65 -115 -3.90% 170 51 96 24 1.70% Retail Trade 6,191 $30,166 1.06 -536 -4.10% 840 337 498 5 0.10% Transportation and Warehousing 1,447 $57,234 0.51 22 0.80% 201 63 100 38 2.70% Information 482 $48,997 0.42 -52 -5.00% 52 15 31 5 1.10% Finance and Insurance 2,006 $82,488 0.87 -103 -2.50% 170 62 118 -10 -0.50% Real Estate and Rental and Leasing 704 $42,918 0.71 -106 -6.80% 80 29 41 9 1.30% Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 3,122 $94,449 0.77 -21 -0.30% 329 95 180 53 1.70% Management of Companies and Enterprises 960 $75,218 1.14 31 1.70% 104 30 57 17 1.70% Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services 2,294 $32,153 0.63 -431 -8.20% 333 104 167 62 2.70% Educational Services 8,730 $39,536 1.96 -279 -2.00% 485 155 192 138 3.80% Health Care and Social Assistance 11,338 $60,194 1.39 -788 -3.30% 1,089 487 592 10 0.10% Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation 871 $17,185 0.86 85 5.30% 195 52 74 70 8.00% Accommodation and Food Services 5,345 $19,706 1.15 -382 -3.40% 1,206 394 536 277 5.20% Other Services (except Public Administration) 2,060 $30,156 0.85 -244 -5.40% 268 94 136 37 1.80% Public Administration 1,340 $53,911 0.51 -88 -3.10% 110 48 77 -15 -1.10% Unclassified 90 $40,167 1.25 -5 -2.50% 5 4 6 -4 -4.70% Total - All Industries 56,243 $50,439 1 -3,160 -2.76% 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.60% Source: Chmura’s JobsEQ. 28© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Competitive Advantage in 5 Industries Points to Diversity Current, 2022Q1 (w/ LU) 2-Year History (w/ LU) 1-Year Forecast (w/o LU) Industry Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl Growth Ann % Growth Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting 83 $16,101 0.11 17 12.00% 10 4 6 0 0.10% Utilities 106 $73,012 0.37 -4 -1.60% 8 3 7 -1 -1.20% Construction 1,761 $64,547 0.53 43 1.30% 191 54 116 20 1.10% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.3 -204 -1.70% 686 213 407 67 1.10% Wholesale Trade 1,375 $74,113 0.65 -115 -3.90% 170 51 96 24 1.70% Retail Trade 6,191 $30,166 1.06 -536 -4.10% 840 337 498 5 0.10% Transportation and Warehousing 1,447 $57,234 0.51 22 0.80% 201 63 100 38 2.70% Information 482 $48,997 0.42 -52 -5.00% 52 15 31 5 1.10% Finance and Insurance 2,006 $82,488 0.87 -103 -2.50% 170 62 118 -10 -0.50% Real Estate and Rental and Leasing 704 $42,918 0.71 -106 -6.80% 80 29 41 9 1.30% Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 3,122 $94,449 0.77 -21 -0.30% 329 95 180 53 1.70% Management of Companies and Enterprises 960 $75,218 1.14 31 1.70% 104 30 57 17 1.70% Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services 2,294 $32,153 0.63 -431 -8.20% 333 104 167 62 2.70% Educational Services 8,730 $39,536 1.96 -279 -2.00% 485 155 192 138 3.80% Health Care and Social Assistance 11,338 $60,194 1.39 -788 -3.30% 1,089 487 592 10 0.10% Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation 871 $17,185 0.86 85 5.30% 195 52 74 70 8.00% Accommodation and Food Services 5,345 $19,706 1.15 -382 -3.40% 1,206 394 536 277 5.20% Other Services (except Public Administration) 2,060 $30,156 0.85 -244 -5.40% 268 94 136 37 1.80% Public Administration 1,340 $53,911 0.51 -88 -3.10% 110 48 77 -15 -1.10% Unclassified 90 $40,167 1.25 -5 -2.50% 5 4 6 -4 -4.70% Total - All Industries 56,243 $50,439 1 -3,160 -2.76% 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.60% Source: Chmura’s JobsEQ. 29© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Health Care Employs 22% of Workforce: Enjoys a High LQ and Competitive Advantage Current, 2022Q1 (w/ LU) 2-Year History (w/ LU) 1-Year Forecast (w/o LU) Industry Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl Growth Ann % Growth Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting 83 $16,101 0.11 17 12.00% 10 4 6 0 0.10% Utilities 106 $73,012 0.37 -4 -1.60% 8 3 7 -1 -1.20% Construction 1,761 $64,547 0.53 43 1.30% 191 54 116 20 1.10% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.3 -204 -1.70% 686 213 407 67 1.10% Wholesale Trade 1,375 $74,113 0.65 -115 -3.90% 170 51 96 24 1.70% Retail Trade 6,191 $30,166 1.06 -536 -4.10% 840 337 498 5 0.10% Transportation and Warehousing 1,447 $57,234 0.51 22 0.80% 201 63 100 38 2.70% Information 482 $48,997 0.42 -52 -5.00% 52 15 31 5 1.10% Finance and Insurance 2,006 $82,488 0.87 -103 -2.50% 170 62 118 -10 -0.50% Real Estate and Rental and Leasing 704 $42,918 0.71 -106 -6.80% 80 29 41 9 1.30% Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 3,122 $94,449 0.77 -21 -0.30% 329 95 180 53 1.70% Management of Companies and Enterprises 960 $75,218 1.14 31 1.70% 104 30 57 17 1.70% Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services 2,294 $32,153 0.63 -431 -8.20% 333 104 167 62 2.70% Educational Services 8,730 $39,536 1.96 -279 -2.00% 485 155 192 138 3.80% Health Care and Social Assistance 11,338 $60,194 1.39 -788 -3.30% 1,089 487 592 10 0.10% Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation 871 $17,185 0.86 85 5.30% 195 52 74 70 8.00% Accommodation and Food Services 5,345 $19,706 1.15 -382 -3.40% 1,206 394 536 277 5.20% Other Services (except Public Administration) 2,060 $30,156 0.85 -244 -5.40% 268 94 136 37 1.80% Public Administration 1,340 $53,911 0.51 -88 -3.10% 110 48 77 -15 -1.10% Unclassified 90 $40,167 1.25 -5 -2.50% 5 4 6 -4 -4.70% Total - All Industries 56,243 $50,439 1 -3,160 -2.76% 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.60% Source: Chmura’s JobsEQ. 30© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Employment in Most Industries is Expected to Grow Current, 2022Q1 (w/ LU) 2-Year History (w/ LU) 1-Year Forecast* (w/o LU) Industry Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl Growth Ann % Growth Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting 83 $16,101 0.11 17 12.00% 10 4 6 0 0.10% Utilities 106 $73,012 0.37 -4 -1.60% 8 3 7 -1 -1.20% Construction 1,761 $64,547 0.53 43 1.30% 191 54 116 20 1.10% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.3 -204 -1.70% 686 213 407 67 1.10% Wholesale Trade 1,375 $74,113 0.65 -115 -3.90% 170 51 96 24 1.70% Retail Trade 6,191 $30,166 1.06 -536 -4.10% 840 337 498 5 0.10% Transportation and Warehousing 1,447 $57,234 0.51 22 0.80% 201 63 100 38 2.70% Information 482 $48,997 0.42 -52 -5.00% 52 15 31 5 1.10% Finance and Insurance 2,006 $82,488 0.87 -103 -2.50% 170 62 118 -10 -0.50% Real Estate and Rental and Leasing 704 $42,918 0.71 -106 -6.80% 80 29 41 9 1.30% Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 3,122 $94,449 0.77 -21 -0.30% 329 95 180 53 1.70% Management of Companies and Enterprises 960 $75,218 1.14 31 1.70% 104 30 57 17 1.70% Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services 2,294 $32,153 0.63 -431 -8.20% 333 104 167 62 2.70% Educational Services 8,730 $39,536 1.96 -279 -2.00% 485 155 192 138 3.80% Health Care and Social Assistance 11,338 $60,194 1.39 -788 -3.30% 1,089 487 592 10 0.10% Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation 871 $17,185 0.86 85 5.30% 195 52 74 70 8.00% Accommodation and Food Services 5,345 $19,706 1.15 -382 -3.40% 1,206 394 536 277 5.20% Other Services (except Public Administration) 2,060 $30,156 0.85 -244 -5.40% 268 94 136 37 1.80% Public Administration 1,340 $53,911 0.51 -88 -3.10% 110 48 77 -15 -1.10% Unclassified 90 $40,167 1.25 -5 -2.50% 5 4 6 -4 -4.70% Total - All Industries 56,243 $50,439 1 -3,160 -2.76% 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.60% Source: Chmura’s JobsEQ. *Represents average annual growth over next ten years. 31© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Even the Manufacturing Sector is Expected to Add Jobs Current, 2022Q1 (w/ LU) 2-Year History (w/ LU) 1-Year Forecast (w/o LU) Industry Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl Growth Ann % Growth Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting 83 $16,101 0.11 17 12.00% 10 4 6 0 0.10% Utilities 106 $73,012 0.37 -4 -1.60% 8 3 7 -1 -1.20% Construction 1,761 $64,547 0.53 43 1.30% 191 54 116 20 1.10% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.3 -204 -1.70% 686 213 407 67 1.10% Wholesale Trade 1,375 $74,113 0.65 -115 -3.90% 170 51 96 24 1.70% Retail Trade 6,191 $30,166 1.06 -536 -4.10% 840 337 498 5 0.10% Transportation and Warehousing 1,447 $57,234 0.51 22 0.80% 201 63 100 38 2.70% Information 482 $48,997 0.42 -52 -5.00% 52 15 31 5 1.10% Finance and Insurance 2,006 $82,488 0.87 -103 -2.50% 170 62 118 -10 -0.50% Real Estate and Rental and Leasing 704 $42,918 0.71 -106 -6.80% 80 29 41 9 1.30% Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 3,122 $94,449 0.77 -21 -0.30% 329 95 180 53 1.70% Management of Companies and Enterprises 960 $75,218 1.14 31 1.70% 104 30 57 17 1.70% Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services 2,294 $32,153 0.63 -431 -8.20% 333 104 167 62 2.70% Educational Services 8,730 $39,536 1.96 -279 -2.00% 485 155 192 138 3.80% Health Care and Social Assistance 11,338 $60,194 1.39 -788 -3.30% 1,089 487 592 10 0.10% Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation 871 $17,185 0.86 85 5.30% 195 52 74 70 8.00% Accommodation and Food Services 5,345 $19,706 1.15 -382 -3.40% 1,206 394 536 277 5.20% Other Services (except Public Administration) 2,060 $30,156 0.85 -244 -5.40% 268 94 136 37 1.80% Public Administration 1,340 $53,911 0.51 -88 -3.10% 110 48 77 -15 -1.10% Unclassified 90 $40,167 1.25 -5 -2.50% 5 4 6 -4 -4.70% Total - All Industries 56,243 $50,439 1 -3,160 -2.76% 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.60% Source: Chmura’s JobsEQ. 32© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Most Manufacturing Industries in Lynchburg Expected to Grow Current, 2022Q1 1-Year Forecast Manufacturing Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl Growth Ann % Growth Apparel Manufacturing 2 $64,925 0.04 0 0 0 0 3.5% Beverage and Tobacco Product Manufacturing 17 $38,107 0.17 3 1 1 0 2.8% Food Manufacturing 730 $53,686 1.34 104 32 55 18 2.4% Wood Product Manufacturing 2 $122,539 0.01 0 0 0 0 2.3% Electrical Equipment, Appliance, and Component Manufacturing 353 $70,179 2.73 42 12 23 6 1.8% Primary Metal Manufacturing 258 $56,486 2.24 30 9 18 4 1.5% Miscellaneous Manufacturing 184 $56,396 0.85 22 7 12 2 1.3% Nonmetallic Mineral Product Manufacturing 101 $77,805 0.75 12 4 7 1 1.3% Fabricated Metal Product Manufacturing 670 $63,647 1.44 75 23 47 6 0.9% Plastics and Rubber Products Manufacturing 604 $52,407 2.54 69 22 42 5 0.9% Chemical Manufacturing 1,103 $47,875 3.82 117 33 74 9 0.8% Machinery Manufacturing 1,077 $76,627 3.07 116 35 72 9 0.8% Furniture and Related Product Manufacturing 290 $37,891 2.27 32 11 19 2 0.8% Paper Manufacturing 270 $63,380 2.35 31 10 19 2 0.8% Transportation Equipment Manufacturing 81 $74,252 0.15 9 3 5 1 0.8% Printing and Related Support Activities 50 $61,944 0.39 6 2 3 0 0.3% Computer and Electronic Product Manufacturing 143 $51,464 0.41 12 4 8 -1 -0.5% Textile Product Mills 2 $40,267 0.06 0 0 0 0 -1.8% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.43 686 213 407 67 1.1% Total - All Industries (w/o LU) 51,128 $50,439 1.00 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.6% 33© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Part of Manufacturing Growth Supported By DoD Spending Source: Department of Defense and Chmura’s FedSpendTOP $- $50.0 $100.0 $150.0 $200.0 $250.0 $300.0 $350.0 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 $237.3 $149.3 $117.8 $140.8 $198.4 $286.0 $331.9 $319.7 $271.4 $219.8 $206.5 $196.3 $150.5 $149.5 $148.5 Millions Fiscal Year 34© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Part of Manufacturing Growth Supported By DoD Spending Source: Department of Defense and Chmura’s FedSpendTOP Spending, FY 2022 Babcock Wilcox Company $116,432,233 Kmw Krauss-Maffei Wegmann $18,798,154 Harris Corp $8,302,284 Flowserve $3,387,635 Liberty University, Inc. $530,977 Wiley Wilson $277,893 Advanced Manufacturing Technology, Inc. $243,399 Flowers Foods $237,810 N C S $154,216 Lynchburg Sheltered Industries, Inc. $33,754 35© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics People Transferring Out of Industries Creates Many Job Openings Current, 2022Q1 (w/ LU) 2-Year History (w/ LU) 1-Year Forecast (w/o LU) Industry Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl Growth Ann % Growth Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting 83 $16,101 0.11 17 12.00% 10 4 6 0 0.10% Utilities 106 $73,012 0.37 -4 -1.60% 8 3 7 -1 -1.20% Construction 1,761 $64,547 0.53 43 1.30% 191 54 116 20 1.10% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.3 -204 -1.70% 686 213 407 67 1.10% Wholesale Trade 1,375 $74,113 0.65 -115 -3.90% 170 51 96 24 1.70% Retail Trade 6,191 $30,166 1.06 -536 -4.10% 840 337 498 5 0.10% Transportation and Warehousing 1,447 $57,234 0.51 22 0.80% 201 63 100 38 2.70% Information 482 $48,997 0.42 -52 -5.00% 52 15 31 5 1.10% Finance and Insurance 2,006 $82,488 0.87 -103 -2.50% 170 62 118 -10 -0.50% Real Estate and Rental and Leasing 704 $42,918 0.71 -106 -6.80% 80 29 41 9 1.30% Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 3,122 $94,449 0.77 -21 -0.30% 329 95 180 53 1.70% Management of Companies and Enterprises 960 $75,218 1.14 31 1.70% 104 30 57 17 1.70% Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services 2,294 $32,153 0.63 -431 -8.20% 333 104 167 62 2.70% Educational Services 8,730 $39,536 1.96 -279 -2.00% 485 155 192 138 3.80% Health Care and Social Assistance 11,338 $60,194 1.39 -788 -3.30% 1,089 487 592 10 0.10% Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation 871 $17,185 0.86 85 5.30% 195 52 74 70 8.00% Accommodation and Food Services 5,345 $19,706 1.15 -382 -3.40% 1,206 394 536 277 5.20% Other Services (except Public Administration) 2,060 $30,156 0.85 -244 -5.40% 268 94 136 37 1.80% Public Administration 1,340 $53,911 0.51 -88 -3.10% 110 48 77 -15 -1.10% Unclassified 90 $40,167 1.25 -5 -2.50% 5 4 6 -4 -4.70% Total - All Industries 56,243 $50,439 1 -3,160 -2.76% 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.60% Source: Chmura’s JobsEQ. 36© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics People Exiting the Industry (Mainly Retiring) Create Many Openings Each Year Current, 2022Q1 (w/ LU) 2-Year History (w/ LU) 1-Year Forecast (w/o LU) Industry Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl Growth Ann % Growth Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting 83 $16,101 0.11 17 12.00% 10 4 6 0 0.10% Utilities 106 $73,012 0.37 -4 -1.60% 8 3 7 -1 -1.20% Construction 1,761 $64,547 0.53 43 1.30% 191 54 116 20 1.10% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.3 -204 -1.70% 686 213 407 67 1.10% Wholesale Trade 1,375 $74,113 0.65 -115 -3.90% 170 51 96 24 1.70% Retail Trade 6,191 $30,166 1.06 -536 -4.10% 840 337 498 5 0.10% Transportation and Warehousing 1,447 $57,234 0.51 22 0.80% 201 63 100 38 2.70% Information 482 $48,997 0.42 -52 -5.00% 52 15 31 5 1.10% Finance and Insurance 2,006 $82,488 0.87 -103 -2.50% 170 62 118 -10 -0.50% Real Estate and Rental and Leasing 704 $42,918 0.71 -106 -6.80% 80 29 41 9 1.30% Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 3,122 $94,449 0.77 -21 -0.30% 329 95 180 53 1.70% Management of Companies and Enterprises 960 $75,218 1.14 31 1.70% 104 30 57 17 1.70% Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services 2,294 $32,153 0.63 -431 -8.20% 333 104 167 62 2.70% Educational Services 8,730 $39,536 1.96 -279 -2.00% 485 155 192 138 3.80% Health Care and Social Assistance 11,338 $60,194 1.39 -788 -3.30% 1,089 487 592 10 0.10% Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation 871 $17,185 0.86 85 5.30% 195 52 74 70 8.00% Accommodation and Food Services 5,345 $19,706 1.15 -382 -3.40% 1,206 394 536 277 5.20% Other Services (except Public Administration) 2,060 $30,156 0.85 -244 -5.40% 268 94 136 37 1.80% Public Administration 1,340 $53,911 0.51 -88 -3.10% 110 48 77 -15 -1.10% Unclassified 90 $40,167 1.25 -5 -2.50% 5 4 6 -4 -4.70% Total - All Industries 56,243 $50,439 1 -3,160 -2.76% 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.60% Source: Chmura’s JobsEQ. 37© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Lynchburg Expected to Need an Average 6,464 Workers over the Next Year Current, 2022Q1 (w/ LU) 2-Year History (w/ LU) 1-Year Forecast (w/o LU) Industry Empl Avg Ann Wages LQ Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Transfers Empl Growth Ann % Growth Agriculture, Forestry, Fishing and Hunting 83 $16,101 0.11 17 12.00% 10 4 6 0 0.10% Utilities 106 $73,012 0.37 -4 -1.60% 8 3 7 -1 -1.20% Construction 1,761 $64,547 0.53 43 1.30% 191 54 116 20 1.10% Manufacturing 5,938 $61,017 1.3 -204 -1.70% 686 213 407 67 1.10% Wholesale Trade 1,375 $74,113 0.65 -115 -3.90% 170 51 96 24 1.70% Retail Trade 6,191 $30,166 1.06 -536 -4.10% 840 337 498 5 0.10% Transportation and Warehousing 1,447 $57,234 0.51 22 0.80% 201 63 100 38 2.70% Information 482 $48,997 0.42 -52 -5.00% 52 15 31 5 1.10% Finance and Insurance 2,006 $82,488 0.87 -103 -2.50% 170 62 118 -10 -0.50% Real Estate and Rental and Leasing 704 $42,918 0.71 -106 -6.80% 80 29 41 9 1.30% Professional, Scientific, and Technical Services 3,122 $94,449 0.77 -21 -0.30% 329 95 180 53 1.70% Management of Companies and Enterprises 960 $75,218 1.14 31 1.70% 104 30 57 17 1.70% Administrative and Support and Waste Management and Remediation Services 2,294 $32,153 0.63 -431 -8.20% 333 104 167 62 2.70% Educational Services 8,730 $39,536 1.96 -279 -2.00% 485 155 192 138 3.80% Health Care and Social Assistance 11,338 $60,194 1.39 -788 -3.30% 1,089 487 592 10 0.10% Arts, Entertainment, and Recreation 871 $17,185 0.86 85 5.30% 195 52 74 70 8.00% Accommodation and Food Services 5,345 $19,706 1.15 -382 -3.40% 1,206 394 536 277 5.20% Other Services (except Public Administration) 2,060 $30,156 0.85 -244 -5.40% 268 94 136 37 1.80% Public Administration 1,340 $53,911 0.51 -88 -3.10% 110 48 77 -15 -1.10% Unclassified 90 $40,167 1.25 -5 -2.50% 5 4 6 -4 -4.70% Total - All Industries 56,243 $50,439 1 -3,160 -2.76% 6,464 2,223 3,424 817 1.60% Source: Chmura’s JobsEQ. 38© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics 4 of Top 20 Occupations Pay Better than Region Average (w/o LU) Current, 2022Q1 5-Year History 1-Year Forecast Occupation Empl Mean Ann Wages2 Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Trans- fers Empl Growth Ann % Growth 1 Registered Nurses 1,723 $71,200 96 1.1% 82 46 43 -7 -0.4% 2 Fast Food and Counter Workers 1,605 $22,700 -44 -0.5% 421 166 182 73 4.5% 3 Retail Salespersons 1,472 $29,400 -327 -3.9% 208 81 120 8 0.5% 4 Cashiers 1,125 $23,800 -124 -2.1% 203 92 104 7 0.6% 5 Customer Service Representatives 1,040 $32,500 68 1.4% 133 48 81 4 0.4% 6 General and Operations Managers 986 $102,700 88 1.9% 102 20 63 19 1.9% 7 Stockers and Order Fillers 886 $29,500 -64 -1.4% 150 50 87 13 1.4% 8 Office Clerks, General 874 $34,000 -139 -2.9% 103 47 51 5 0.5% 9 Waiters and Waitresses 789 $27,100 -197 -4.4% 195 61 100 34 4.3% 10 Janitors and Cleaners, Except Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners 769 $27,200 -57 -1.4% 118 49 55 15 2.0% 11 Nursing Assistants 767 $29,900 -155 -3.6% 85 49 44 -7 -0.9% 12 Personal Care Aides 741 $24,100 132 4.0% 111 58 51 2 0.3% 13 Laborers and Freight, Stock, and Material Movers, Hand 608 $32,400 -142 -4.1% 97 27 54 16 2.6% 14 Heavy and Tractor-Trailer Truck Drivers 598 $46,300 133 5.2% 80 25 41 14 2.3% 15 First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers 534 $54,400 -49 -1.7% 54 19 32 2 0.4% 16 First-Line Supervisors of Food Preparation and Serving Workers 510 $33,600 22 0.9% 105 25 56 24 4.7% 17 Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks 506 $40,000 -104 -3.7% 56 29 25 2 0.4% 18 Cooks, Restaurant 504 $26,100 -7 -0.3% 115 34 49 32 6.4% 19 Accountants and Auditors 498 $71,700 -37 -1.4% 49 14 30 5 1.1% 20 First-Line Supervisors of Retail Sales Workers 487 $45,800 -62 -2.4% 51 17 33 2 0.4% 39© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Office/HQ Presence Clear in Top 20 Occupations (w/o LU) Current, 2022Q1 5-Year History 1-Year Forecast Occupation Empl Mean Ann Wages2 Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Trans- fers Empl Growth Ann % Growth 1 Registered Nurses 1,723 $71,200 96 1.1% 82 46 43 -7 -0.4% 2 Fast Food and Counter Workers 1,605 $22,700 -44 -0.5% 421 166 182 73 4.5% 3 Retail Salespersons 1,472 $29,400 -327 -3.9% 208 81 120 8 0.5% 4 Cashiers 1,125 $23,800 -124 -2.1% 203 92 104 7 0.6% 5 Customer Service Representatives 1,040 $32,500 68 1.4% 133 48 81 4 0.4% 6 General and Operations Managers 986 $102,700 88 1.9% 102 20 63 19 1.9% 7 Stockers and Order Fillers 886 $29,500 -64 -1.4% 150 50 87 13 1.4% 8 Office Clerks, General 874 $34,000 -139 -2.9% 103 47 51 5 0.5% 9 Waiters and Waitresses 789 $27,100 -197 -4.4% 195 61 100 34 4.3% 10 Janitors and Cleaners, Except Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners 769 $27,200 -57 -1.4% 118 49 55 15 2.0% 11 Nursing Assistants 767 $29,900 -155 -3.6% 85 49 44 -7 -0.9% 12 Personal Care Aides 741 $24,100 132 4.0% 111 58 51 2 0.3% 13 Laborers and Freight, Stock, and Material Movers, Hand 608 $32,400 -142 -4.1% 97 27 54 16 2.6% 14 Heavy and Tractor-Trailer Truck Drivers 598 $46,300 133 5.2% 80 25 41 14 2.3% 15 First-Line Supervisors of Office and Administrative Support Workers 534 $54,400 -49 -1.7% 54 19 32 2 0.4% 16 First-Line Supervisors of Food Preparation and Serving Workers 510 $33,600 22 0.9% 105 25 56 24 4.7% 17 Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks 506 $40,000 -104 -3.7% 56 29 25 2 0.4% 18 Cooks, Restaurant 504 $26,100 -7 -0.3% 115 34 49 32 6.4% 19 Accountants and Auditors 498 $71,700 -37 -1.4% 49 14 30 5 1.1% 20 First-Line Supervisors of Retail Sales Workers 487 $45,800 -62 -2.4% 51 17 33 2 0.4% 40© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Office/HQ Presence for Top 20 Occupations – 45 Minute Drive Time Current, 2022Q1 5-Year History 1-Year Forecast Occupation Empl Mean Ann Wages2 Empl Change Ann % Total Demand Exits Trans- fers Empl Growth Ann % Growth 1 Fast Food and Counter Workers 3,339 $22,000 -164 -1.0% 867 346 378 144 4.3% 2 Retail Salespersons 3,189 $28,400 -201 -1.2% 454 175 260 19 0.6% 3 Cashiers 3,049 $22,900 -217 -1.4% 551 250 282 20 0.7% 4 Registered Nurses 2,333 $70,000 -29 -0.2% 116 63 58 -6 -0.2% 5 General and Operations Managers 2,317 $99,200 274 2.5% 238 47 147 44 1.9% 6 Personal Care Aides 2,194 $23,000 216 2.1% 344 174 153 17 0.8% 7 Office Clerks, General 2,155 $32,800 -156 -1.4% 253 116 125 12 0.5% 8 Stockers and Order Fillers 2,148 $28,400 76 0.7% 373 123 211 39 1.8% 9 Customer Service Representatives 1,904 $31,700 132 1.4% 243 88 147 8 0.4% 10 Heavy and Tractor-Trailer Truck Drivers 1,896 $44,600 107 1.2% 250 79 130 41 2.2% 11 Janitors and Cleaners, Except Maids and Housekeeping Cleaners 1,762 $26,200 -208 -2.2% 269 111 125 33 1.9% 12 Laborers and Freight, Stock, and Material Movers, Hand 1,545 $31,300 -115 -1.4% 248 70 137 41 2.7% 13 Waiters and Waitresses 1,475 $26,300 -223 -2.8% 366 115 187 64 4.3% 14 Farmers, Ranchers, and Other Agricultural Managers 1,457 $48,900 -340 -4.1% 147 89 50 7 0.5% 15 First-Line Supervisors of Retail Sales Workers 1,370 $43,700 -33 -0.5% 144 46 91 6 0.4% 16 Elementary School Teachers, Except Special Education 1,330 $50,700 -86 -1.2% 130 42 54 34 2.5% 17 Team Assemblers 1,289 $37,100 6 0.1% 146 51 94 2 0.2% 18 Nursing Assistants 1,270 $29,100 -278 -3.9% 143 81 72 -11 -0.9% 19 Bookkeeping, Accounting, and Auditing Clerks 1,217 $38,600 -179 -2.7% 136 70 61 5 0.4% 20 Construction Laborers 1,169 $31,800 99 1.8% 140 36 81 23 2.0% 41© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Job Posts in Lynchburg are Down 13% from Week of June 27 42© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Education Institutions Have the Greatest Demand for Workers 43© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics 4% of Ads Promote Remote Work in Lynchburg 44© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics How Will Lynchburg Fair During a Recession? -10% Peak to Trough 2008 Recession 45© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Manufacturing Fell 41% from Start of Recession to Trough Expected -250 mid-October MasterBrand Cabinet -670 additional jobs due to KDC/One closure in Dec. 2023 46© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Implications of Recession: Local Revenues Lag Economy by Year or Two • Housing is already slowing • Slower price appreciation impact revenues from assessments • Slower housing sales impact recordation taxes • Slower retail sales impact growth of local 1% • Layoffs increase need for social assistance 47© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Home Price Appreciation Has Begun to Slow $1.02 $1.03 $1.04 $1.05 $1.06 $1.07 $1.08 $1.09 $1.10 $1.11 $1.12 $20,000,000 $25,000,000 $30,000,000 $35,000,000 $40,000,000 $45,000,000 $50,000,000 $55,000,000 $60,000,000 $65,000,000 $70,000,000 Actual Real Property Tax Revenue Tax Rate per $100 Assessed Value Source: Lynchburg City Staff. 48© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Conclusions  National Economy is Slowing  Recession is highly likely  Unemployment rate will rise and ease tight labor market  Sub-par growth will last for more than one year  Lynchburg  Growing somewhat slower than the nation  Will also see slower growth due to recession  Working with educators is critical in this tight labor market 49© 2022 Chmura Economics & Analytics Copyright © 2020 Holland & Knight LLP. All Rights Reserved Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act Funding Opportunities for City of Lynchburg October 7, 2022 Chris DeLacy Christopher DeLacy is co-chair of the Political Law Group and a member of the Public Policy & Regulation team at Holland & Knight. For 20 years, he has been representing corporations, trade associations, local governments, coalitions and nonprofits before Congress and the executive branch. Mr. DeLacy has extensive experience with technology, infrastructure, agriculture and trade issues. He has helped to develop legislation and federal policies in these areas and has represented clients during related hearings. Mr. DeLacy advises clients on the Federal Election Campaign Act of 1971, the Lobbying Disclosure Act of 1995, Congressional gift and travel rules, the Ethics in Government Act of 1978, and related state and local laws. Mr. DeLacy has represented clients before the Federal Election Commission, the House and Senate Ethics Committees and Office of Congressional Ethics. He has also represented clients during inspector general and congressional investigations, and advised clients on federal conflict of interest, post-employment and financial disclosure issues. His political law clients include political action committees (PACs), corporations, trade associations, nonprofit organizations, ballot question committees and coalitions. He serves as general counsel to the Holland & Knight Committee for Effective Government PAC. Prior to entering private practice, Mr. DeLacy served as counsel to Sen. John Warner of Virginia. In that capacity, Mr. DeLacy served as the Senator's Rules Committee counsel during consideration of the Bipartisan Campaign Reform Act of 2002 (McCain-Feingold Act) and as his representative to the Senate Republican High Tech Task Force. Before working for Sen. Warner, Mr. DeLacy served as counsel on the Technology Subcommittee of the House Science Committee where he oversaw technical standards issues and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). Chris DeLacy Partner Washington, D.C. 202.457.7162 chris.delacy@hklaw.com 2 Holland & Knight – Public Policy & Regulation (PP&R) Our Washington-based Public Policy & Regulation Practice Group, the lobbying arm of the firm, began in 1982. It is one of the most experienced and well-respected government relations practices of any law firm in the U.S. Home to more than 75 individuals, the group includes four former members of Congress; former Clinton, Bush, and Obama White House and Administration officials; former senior congressional committee and legislative staff; and former local government officials. Honesty, competence, persuasive communication, and deep, longstanding ties on both sides of the aisle are the PP&R Group’s hallmark traits when dealing with Congress, the White House, and the myriad federal agencies spread across Washington. Our attorneys and professionals partner with our clients to keep their voice front and center of federal policymakers. Some of the hallmarks of the Holland & Knight team include: − Bipartisan − Team Based − Seamless Extension of Your Team − Creative Campaign-Style Advocacy − Active Bipartisan PAC − Coalition Management − Subject Matter Expertise 3 Our philosophy is to function as an extension of your team. We achieve this through a combination of policy depth and experience, political astuteness, media savvy and access to nationwide resources across a range of practices. Washington Outlook Political: Current status: Democratic control of the House (221-212-2) and Senate (50-50). Current midterm election outlook: Republican House majority and a closely-divided Senate. Economic: Inflation (CPI-U) – 8.3% (as of August) Federal funds rate increased from 0 to 3.25% (projected at 4.0 to 4.5% by YE) Outlook for federal spending: Total COVID spending to date: $4.63 trillion Build Back Better ($2.2 trillion) became the Inflation Reduction Act ($737 billion) Opportunities for new federal spending/programs over the next two years may diminish 4 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act 5 • On November 15, 2021, President Biden signed the bipartisan “Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act” into law to invest in the nation’s infrastructure, including funding for roads and bridges, rail, transit, airports, energy, sustainability, water, and broadband, among other priorities. • The legislation provides $1.2 trillion in total spending over 5 years, including $550 billion in new spending. • DOT, EPA, and other federal agencies continue to release funding applications and distribute billions of dollars for infrastructure, broadband, and coastal resilience. Significant programs such as MEGA, INFRA, and RAISE have already been awarded. Existing Transportation Formula Programs FHWA Released Apportionments to State DOTs on 12/15/21 6 Program Funding Level Surface Transportation Block Grant (STBG) Program • Existing formula program; funding through CVTPO • Funds Federal-aid highways, bridges, and transit capital projects. $72 billion over 5 years; 23.57% increase over current funding Transportation Alternatives Program (TAP) • Existing formula program; funding through CVTPO • Funds smaller-scale transportation projects such as pedestrian and bicycle projects, recreational trails and environmental mitigation $7.2 billion over 5 years; 330% increase over current funding Congestion Mitigation and Air Quality Improvement Program (CMAQ) • Existing formula program; funding through VDOT $13.2 billion over 5 years; 9.79% increase over current funding Highway Safety Improvement Program (HSIP) • Existing formula program; funding through VDOT $15.575 billion; 34.4% increase over current funding Closed Transportation Grant Programs 7 Program Funding Level Nationally Significant Freight and Highway Projects (INFRA) • Existing competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Funding for highway, rail, and port projects of regional and national significance • Timing: $1.55 billion NOFO out 3/21/22; Deadline was 5/23/22; Awards announced on 9/ 9/22. $8 billion; 77.78 % increase over current funding Local and Regional Project Assistance (RAISE Grants) • Existing competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Renamed program that has increased funding for RAISE (formerly known as BUILD and TIGER). • Planning and construction eligible. • Timing: $2.275 billion NOFO out; Deadline was 4/14/22; Awards announced on 8/11/22. $7.5 billion over 5 years; 70.45% increase over current funding Safe Streets and Roads for All Grant Program (“Vision Zero”) • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Competitive grant program to develop and implement comprehensive safety plans and projects. • Timing: $1 billion NOFO out 5/16/22; Deadline is 9/15/22. $5 billion over 5 years Closed Transportation Programs 8 Program Funding Level Bridge Grant Programs • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • At least 50% of funds over 5 years must be used for large projects (at least $100 million). • Grant amounts, in combination with other anticipated funds, should be of a size sufficient to enable the project to proceed through completion. • Timing: $2.36 billion NOFO out on 6/10/22; Deadline was 7/25/22. $16 billion over 5 years Open Transportation Grant Programs 9 Program Funding Level Reconnecting Communities • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Program to mitigate existing transportation facilities that create barriers to mobility, access, or economic development. • Timing: NOFO released on 6/30/2022; NOFO closes on 10/13/2022. $500 million over 5 years Railroad Crossing Elimination Competitive Grant Program • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Competitive grant program for the elimination of hazards at railway-highway crossings. • Timing: NOFO released on 6/30/2022; NOFO closes on 10/4/2022. $3 billion over 5 years Bridge Replacement, Rehabilitation, Preservation, Protection, and Construction • Modeled after existing FHWA bridge formula program; funding through VDOT • Federal share is 100%. • 75% distributed by number of bridges in poor condition. • 25% distributed by number of bridges in fair condition. • Funding was distributed to state DOTs on 1/14/22. $27.5 billion over 5 years Upcoming Transportation Grant Programs 10 Program Funding Level Stopping Threats on Pedestrians • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Competitive grant program for bollard installation projects to prevent pedestrian injuries and acts of terrorism in areas used by large numbers of pedestrians. $25 million over 5 years (subject to appropriations) Culvert Removal, Replacement and Restoration Program • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • To remove, replace, and restore culverts to address the flow of water through roads, bridges, railroad tracks, and trails. $1 billion over 5 years Active Transportation Infrastructure Investment Program • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • New competitive grant program for safe and connected active transportation projects that connect destinations within or between communities -- including schools, workplaces, residences, businesses, recreation areas, and other community areas – or to create active transportation spines connecting communities and metropolitan regions, or states. $1 billion over 5 years (subject to appropriations) Upcoming Transportation Programs 11 Program Funding Level Promoting Resilient Operations for Transformative, Efficient, and Cost-saving Transportation (PROTECT) Grant Program • New formula and competitive grant program; VDOT will allocate formula; local govts eligible for competitive grants • Funding for planning, resilience improvements, community resilience and evacuation routes, and at-risk coastal infrastructure. • Timing: Fall of 2022 $7.3 billion in formula funding $1.4 billion in competitive grants over 5 years Healthy Streets Program • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Grants to deploy cool pavements and porous pavements, and to expand tree cover. $500 million over 5 years (subject to appropriations) Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging and Refueling Infrastructure Program • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible for competitive grants • New grant program to deploy electric vehicle (EV) charging and hydrogen/propane/natural gas fueling infrastructure along designated alternative fuel corridors and in communities. • Eligible projects include: acquisition and installation of publicly accessible EV charging or alternative fueling; and operating assistance (for the first 5 years after installation; and acquisition and installation of traffic control devices. $2.5 billion over 5 years Environment and Resiliency Provisions 12 Program Funding Level EPA Competitive Brownfields Grants • Existing competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Grants and technical assistance to assess, safely clean up, and sustainably reuse contaminated properties. • Timing: NOFO opens on 9/12/22; NOFO Closes on 11/22/22 $1.2 billion over 5 years Grants to improve material recycling, recovery, management, and reduction $75 million over 5 years Weatherization Assistance Program (DOE) • Existing formula grant program through state • Reduces energy costs for low-income households by increasing the energy efficiency of their homes. • Timing: DOE has provided guidance for developing a Weatherization Assistance Program Grantee Plan to apply for fund. $3.5 billion available until expended Energy Efficiency and Conservation Block Grant (EECBG) • Existing program; local govts eligible; created in ARRA stimulus bill in 2009 • Provides grants to state and local governments for energy efficiency and conservation projects. • Timing: Allocations expected to be released by the end of the year. $550 million over 5 years Open Water Programs 13 EPA Funding Level Per- and Polyfluoroalkyl Substances (PFAS) Contamination • Allocated through state • Timing: EPA issued guidance 3/29/22 $10 billion over 5 years Drinking Water State Revolving Loan Fund (SRF) • Allocated through state • States must allocate 49% of the funds to provide subsidy with 100% forgiveness of principal or grants (or any combination of these). • Timing: EPA issued guidance 3/29/22 $11.713 billion mandatory funding annually Clean Water SRF • Allocated through state • States must allocate 49% of the funds to provide subsidy with 100% forgiveness of principal or grants (or any combination of these). • Timing: EPA issued guidance 3/29/22 $14.65 billion authorized over 5 years (subject to appropriations) $11.713 billion mandatory funding over 5 years Upcoming Water Programs 14 Program Funding Level Sewer Overflow and Stormwater Reuse Municipal Grants • Existing competitive grant programs; local govts eligible • Funding can be used to plan, design, or construct publicly owned treatment works (POTWs) or other facilities thatreceive and treat combined wastewater streams, as well as infrastructure for stormwater management. Authorized $280 million annually over 5 years (subject to appropriations) Drinking Water Technical Assistance Funding and Emergency Grants • Funding to help mitigate drinking water threats to public health, including emergency situations resulting from a cybersecurity event or vulnerability. Authorized $35 million annually over 5 years (subject to appropriations) Lead Inventorying Utilization Grant Pilot Program • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Provides funding for lead reduction projects, such as by replacing aging service lines. Cybersecurity and Public Safety Programs 15 Cybersecurity Funding Level State and Local Cybersecurity Grant Program (DHS) • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Grants for state and local governments to address cybersecurity risks and threats. • Timing: NOFO Opened 9/16/22. NOFO Closed on 9/15/22 $1 billion authorized over 5 years (subject to appropriations) Cyber Response and Recovery Fund (DHS) • A fund for federal, state, and local entities, as well as private entities, to seek reimbursement and technical assistance following significant cyber incidents. $100 million authorized over 5 years (subject to appropriations) Building Resilient Infrastructure and Communities (BRIC) Program (FEMA) • Existing competitive grant program; local govts eligible • Supports pre-disaster and hazard mitigation activities undertaken by states and local communities. • Timing: NOFO Opened 8/12/22; NOFO Closes on 1/27/23 $1 billion mandatory funding over 5 years Broadband Programs 16 Program Funding Level Broadband, Equity, Access and Deployment Program • Formula based program to states to competitively award grants to qualifying infrastructure, mapping, and adoption projects. $42.5 billion Middle Mile Broadband Infrastructure • Competitive grants for construction, improvement, or acquisition of middle-mile infrastructure. $1 billion Program Funding Level Affordable Connectivity Program • Existing program formerly known as the Emergency Broadband Benefit Program • Makes program permanent; subsidy now $30/month. $14.2 billion Digital Equity Competitive Grant Program • New competitive grant program; local govts eligible $2.75 billion HK Federal Grants Newsletter 17 How to prepare for grant opportunities Identity potential grant opportunities Participate in grant webinars Meet with federal grant managers Identify sources for non-federal match (typically 80/20) Identify grant writers (internal/external) Build political support for grant application Participate in agency debriefs 18 Other funding opportunities to consider Non-IIJA grants (COPS, FIRE, DCIP , HUD, EDA) Earmarks – returned after 10 years in FY 2022, currently in-progress for FY 2023 19 Questions? 20 Thank You 21 HOUSING OVERVIEW Kent White Sarah Quarantotto Community Development Miriam’s House October 7, 2022 AGENDA Housing Snapshot  Inventory and Trends  Barriers/Opportunities for Single Family Builds  Maintaining Existing Housing Housing Affordability  Housing Collaborative History  Affordability Need  Housing Collaborative Priorities Discussion: Matching Housing Tools to Council’s Goals 2 HOUSING SNAPSHOT  Approximately 30,000 existing housing units in the City  18,000 are single household units; 30% are short/long-term rental  12,000 are multi-household units; 98% are short/long-term rental  Median Home Sale Price - $240,000 [source: Realtor.com]  Median Monthly Rent - $1,150 [source: Zillow.com] 3 ACROSS THE COMMONWEAL TH Locality Total Housing Units Owner-Occupied Renter-Occupied Virginia 3,652,329 67.6% 32.4% Alexandria 80,350 43.2% 56.8% Hampton 62,528 54.4% 45.6% Lynchburg 34,156 52.1% 47.9% Newport News 81,913 47.1% 52.9% Norfolk 102,423 46.0% 54.0% Portsmouth 43,306 56.1% 43.9% Richmond 112,806 45.0% 55.0% Roanoke 48,912 51.8% 41.2% Source: 2021 American Community Survey 1-Year Estimates 4 RESIDENTIAL USES 5 Zoning • Single Household • 56% • Multi-Household • 18% NEW HOUSING BY TYPE 2017 -2022  Single Family / Duplex = 649  Townhomes = 228  Apartments = 1,273 6 30% 11% 59% New Housing Built 2017 – 2022, By Type Single Family / Duplex Townhomes Apartments NEW HOUSING BY TYPE – IN REVIEW  Single Family / Duplex = 119  Townhomes = 160  Apartments = 1,867 7 6% 7% 87% New Housing in Review, By Type Single Family / Duplex Townhomes Apartments POTENTIAL BARRIERS - SINGLE HOUSEHOLD BUILDS Land Availability/Cost $33,832 per 15,000 sf lot with 100’ Road Frontage (land + infrastructure) Average Vacant Residential Land Sale of $23,980 per acre (Assessors Data, Average Vacant Residential Sales 2016-2019) 2019 Infrastructure Costs = $511.25/foot (Based on City’s Annual Contract) Water/Sewer Availability Topography/Drainage 8 ADDRESSING BARRIERS - SINGLE HOUSEHOLD BUILDS Infrastructure Incentives City funds 100% of cost of extending water and sewer to subdivision boundary based upon economic feasibility: City costs shares curb, gutter & sidewalk 50/50. Subdivision Revisions Lots existing as of July 11, 2011 may provide access on dedicated improved street extending a minimum of 25’ past driveway entrance. Allows reduction in setbacks and lot sizes to encourage infill development (Neighborhood Norms) 9 ADDRESSING BARRIERS - SINGLE HOUSEHOLD BUILDS Zoning Revision – Residential Cluster Subdivision Allows up to 50% reduction in required lot size and setbacks to create residential cluster using density of underlying zoning district; undeveloped land preserved. 10 R-1 Subdivision • 31 ac • 43 Lots R-1 Cluster Subdivision • 31 ac • 71 lots • 30% open space RENTAL INSPECTION PROGRAM  Approximately 3934 Properties  400-450 Inspections per Year  Focus is older housing units  1 Housing Inspector 11 VACANT / DERELICT PROGRAM  Vacant Units in Program – 445  Derelict – 308  17-Unit Pilot Program Using Existing Staff  Scheduled for demolition by City - 4  Demolition by owner – 3  Plans to rehabilitate or sell – 10 12 HOUSING COLLABORATIVE MEMBERS  Bill Berkley, Cardinal Civil Resources  Tracie Gallahan, First National Bank  Billy Hansen, Hansen Realty  Kevin Henry, City of Lynchburg  Mary Mayrose, Lynchburg Redevelopment & Housing Authority  Sarah Quarantotto, Miriam’s House  Jeff Smith, Rush Homes  Bob Shetlar, University of Lynchburg  Donna Vincent, Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity 13 FOCUS ON AFFORDABLE HOUSING  Council endorsed the formation of the Housing Collaborative in 2012  Comprised of nonprofit housing organizations, realtors, attorneys, employers who want to invest in workforce housing, charitable organizations, etc.  In 2019, the Collaborative presented their housing stability study to Council; City Staff subsequently presented recommendations to improve housing affordability in Lynchburg.  Following a work session with the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority, Council adopted a Housing Policy vision statement and charged the collaborative with implementing best practices and recommendations for housing affordability.  Vision Statement: The City of Lynchburg envisions a place where all residents have access to stable, decent, and affordable homes in vibrant and sustainable neighborhoods. The City recognizes that the diverse nature of our community requires that we address the specific needs found in our community. The City supports a variety of community programs that ensure long-term pathways to housing security for all. 14 AFFORDABILITY NEED Renter Households Household Income Total0-30% AMI 31-50% AMI Total Households 3,655 2,340 5,995 Affordable Housing Units 1,755 3,740 5,495 Units Occupied by Appropriate Income Tier 650 760 1,410 Units Occupied by Other Income Households 1,105 2,980 4,085 Housing Gap 3,005 1,580 4,585 15 NOT HAVING AFFORDABLE HOUSING MEANS … Financial stress typically equates to housing trade-offs Quality, security, livability at the sake of affordability Strain on local school system ensuring students don’t fall behind. Difficulty attracting industry through a stable workforce. 16 HOUSING COLLABORATIVE AFFORDABILITY PRIORITIES Preserving Existing Affordable Housing Plan for Areas with Missing Infrastructure Develop Housing Trust Fund Increasing Housing Opportunity 17 PRESERVING EXISTING AFFORDABLE HOUSING Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) 1,914 housing units, with 330 reserved specifically for elderly. Affordability period lasts 30 years, at which point the development can shift to market-rate. Units at risk in the next 10 years = 524 Grant administered by the Central Virginia Planning District Evaluate impact of expiring contracts for rental property under the Department of Housing and Urban Development’s Housing Choice Voucher Program for both multi-family and single unit rentals. Establish near and long-term affordable unit needs based on existing rental rates, market trends, and horizon rate of units moving off the affordable housing roll. 18 PLAN FOR AREAS WITH MISSING INFRASTRUCTURE - NEW HOUSING Sewer & Water access (mostly sewer) Especially important for the development of single-family housing Transportation infrastructure (roadways, sidewalks, and transit) Develop a plan to install these items over time Planning for this to occur during the Comprehensive Plan update, 2023 19 DEVELOP HOUSING TRUST FUND Creates separate funding source to construct housing outside of the City’s Community Development Block Grant and HOME funds Benefits: Flexibility in how the money is disbursed No geographic limitations on where the money can be spent (HOME money is limited to qualified census districts) Resourcing the fund can be accomplished in a variety of ways, including private, grant, local/state and additional federal funding Currently pursuing Housing Virginia grant to explore best practices and recommended structure for a Housing Trust. 20 INCREASING HOUSING OPPORTUNITY Increasing access to housing outside of lower income census tracts. Some communities have used inclusionary zoning to provide a percentage of affordable units as part of new multi-household developments. To be discussed during Comprehensive Planning process. 21 MATCHING HOUSING TOOLS WITH COUNCIL GOALS Affordability Gap Financing Inclusionary Zoning/Density Bonus Housing Condition Housing/Rental Inspection Real Estate Rehab/Demolition Housing Type Infrastructure Funding Zoning Districts/Future Land Use Homeownership City/Nonprofit-owned Property Down payment/Homebuyer Assistance 22 Lynchburg Housing Collaborative Background: Following a Lynchburg City Council meeting in June 2012, the Lynchburg Housing Collaborative (herein referred to as “the Collaborative”) was formed to address housing needs in the Lynchburg community. In 2016, the Collaborative developed a mission to, “work to set the stage, encourage and provide quality rental housing and homeownership opportunities for people with low incomes in Central Virginia. Our focus areas are: 1. Promoting the positive economic impacts of affordable housing in our region 2. Advocating for local and regional policies that forward affordable housing 3. Developing additional affordable housing that meets the inclusive needs of all people with low incomes and rehabilitate current affordable housing in need 4. Advancing community development opportunities via housing 5. Reducing barriers to housing for people of low income in need.” Following the development of this mission statement, the Collaborative decided to pursue an up-to-date housing study of the area to better understand the needs of the community, increase awareness of these needs, and establish strategies by which to address them. In 2017, the Collaborative applied for a Community Impact Grant through the Virginia Housing Development Association (currently known as Virginia Housing) to commission a study on affordable housing in Lynchburg. A grant for $20,000 was approved, and the Collaborative contracted with Enterprise Foundation to conduct the study in 2018. The Enterprise Foundation’s study, Housing Stability and The Impacts of Affordable Housing in Lynchburg, VA, was completed in fall 2018 and findings were presented to Lynchburg City Council on January 8, 2019. The full study can be found here and a summary of points follow: • Many low income households in Lynchburg faced extreme conditions of housing stability in 2016 including 4,497 spending 50% or more of their income on housing. • Affordable housing is in short supply. The initial draft indicated that there were are at least 578 fewer affordable housing units than needed for people with extremely low incomes. In January, 2019, Enterprise updated the data using specific HUD program information indicating that there are at least 2,340 fewer affordable housing units than needed. • Many Lynchburg families are hypermobile. Of 7900 households that changed residences in 2016, 5,530 were households with incomes lower $25,000 per year. The median income of those that moved was $12,728. • Affordable housing positively impacts household economic security, health (both physical and mental), employment opportunities, and child development/educational outcomes, at the same time saving money for our community. • Affordable housing boosts local economies without any negative effect on neighboring property values. During the January 2019 City Council meeting, it was decided by Council that City staff work with the Collaborative and bring back their findings to City Council on next steps. Following this meeting, the City of Lynchburg formed the Collaborative for a Livable Lynchburg comprised of City leadership to review the Enterprise Foundation report and research best practices in affordable housing from across the country. In June 2019 the Collaborative for a Livable Lynchburg presented their findings via a white paper, A Place to Live, A Place to Thrive: A Report on Housing Attainability and Affordability Leading Practices Recommendation for Lynchburg (found here). A summary of this report was presented to Lynchburg City Council on July 9, 2019. In summary, the Collaborative for a Livable Lynchburg presented the following policy recommendations: 1. Develop a well-articulated vision clarifying how housing is a holistic community issue that impacts, and is impacted by, income concerns, strengths of families, and sustainability of the community. It is also imperative that as a community we confront the fact that race is a significant factor in our housing affordability concerns. 2. Expand the City Council established housing collaborative to include representatives from lending institutions, private residential developers, and anchor institutions, similar to the one created in the Charlotte, NC area that led to the formation of the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Housing Partnership, Inc. Create a charter based on the vision adopted in recommendation 1. 3. Create a Housing Trust Fund to assist with the preservation and development of housing options in the community. Specific funding amounts and plans should be developed after strategies are formed. Identify national housing network partners to leverage expertise. 4. Identify and analyze existing affordable housing options and determine if they should be slated for preservation. If so, create a plan to preserve these sites and subsidize rehabilitation of existing units. 5. Identify areas with missing standard infrastructure (water, sewer, sidewalk, etc.) and develop a plan to install it over time. 6. Develop and implement precise evaluation tools to determine specific housing needs, particularly considering preventing and reducing poverty clusters. Identify national housing network partners to leverage expertise and develop a strategy to increase attainable housing in needed sectors. 7. Develop a communication plan for attainable housing to improve the use of our existing tools and incentives. 8. Enlist the help of developers, builders, and design professionals to remove barriers for attainable housing products that support homeownership. Some examples of evolving design strategies to reduce the gap between income and home price include small homes (reducing square footage), value housing (new housing brand segment with reduced option packages), missing middle (attached housing) and high-density detached housing (clustering). 9. Enhance existing wrap-around support programs, providing both financial and personal/life support to stem high eviction rates and assist potential homeowners. 10. Evaluate public employees housing options similar to those found in Newark, New Jersey and Chapel Hill, North Carolina, the incentive packages available in other cities to determine their feasibility for implementation in Lynchburg, and the implementation of inclusionary zoning principles. City Council decided (minutes here) to hold a joint meeting with the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority board to develop a housing vision statement for the City of Lynchburg. On November 12, 2019, Lynchburg City Council and the Board of Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority had a joint meeting to discuss and develop a housing vision statement for the City of Lynchburg (minutes here). On January 28, 2020, City Council approved City staff’s recommendations to approve a vision statement and expand the Housing Collaborative (minutes here). The following vision statement was approved: The City of Lynchburg envisions a place where all residents have access to stable, decent, and affordable homes in vibrant and sustainable neighborhoods. The City recognizes that the diverse nature of our community requires that we address the specific needs found in our community. The City supports a variety of community programs that ensure long-term pathways to housing security for all. In addition to approving the vision statement, City Council reviewed the guiding principles established by City staff to guide specific policy proposals: - Matters of housing affordability require a variety of programs that seek to increase employment and income, the availability of a variety of reasonably affordable housing options including in the rental and homeownership markets, wrap- around support for those who need it, and improvements to public facilities and infrastructure. - Partners are vital to the success of the City’s housing vision; the City needs partners in order to achieve success. - Existing available housing and non- housing programs, if effective, should be supported and coordinated. - Wrap-around services that help youth, adults, and families with various phases of housing and economic opportunity are vital to the long-term success of the housing journey. - Different populations in our community often have a variety of hurdles to housing security. As a result, programs and opportunities need to be tailored to community needs with a specific focus on mixed income and inclusive communities. City Council and the Housing Authority considered the organizations or professions that should be represented on the Housing Collaborative. They are as follows: - Private developer - Real estate attorney - Realtor - Bank/Lending institution - Employers who want to invest in workforce housing - Faith community - Charitable organizations Current Lynchburg Housing Collaborative Members (2020): • Denise Crews, Director of Housing Counseling & Community Development, Lynchburg Community Action Group • Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator, City of Lynchburg • Sarah Quarantotto, Executive Director, Miriam’s House • Jeff Smith, Executive Director, Rush Homes • Buck Sydnor, Interim Executive Director, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority • Donna Vincent, Executive Director, Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity • Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager, City of Lynchburg Next Steps: 1. Expand the Lynchburg Housing Collaborative to have increased representation from sectors identified by City Council and the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority board. 2. Review the policy recommendations developed by the Collaborative for a Livable Lynchburg and develop an action plan and goals by which to address the vision statement, guiding principles and policy priorities. Lynchburg Housing Collaborative Policy Recommendations 8/18/2022 1. Develop a well-articulated vision clarifying how housing is a holistic community issue that impacts, and is impacted by, income concerns, strengths of families, and sustainability of the community. It is also imperative that as a community we confront the fact that race is a significant factor in our housing affordability concerns. Done- vision statement below: The City of Lynchburg envisions a place where all residents have access to stable, decent, and affordable homes in vibrant and sustainable neighborhoods. The City recognizes that the diverse nature of our community requires that we address the specific needs found in our community. The City supports a variety of community programs that ensure long-term pathways to housing security for all. 3. Expand the City Council established housing collaborative to include representatives from lending institutions, private residential developers, and anchor institutions, similar to the one created in the Charlotte, NC area that led to the formation of the Charlotte-Mecklenburg Housing Partnership, Inc. Create a charter based on the vision adopted in recommendation. Done- new members added to represent a variety of backgrounds and a charter established. • Tracie Gallahan, First National Bank • Billy Hansen, Hansen Realty • Kevin Henry, City of Lynchburg • Mary Mayrose, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority • Sarah Quarantotto, Miriam’s House • Robert Sheltar, University of Lynchburg • Jeff Smith, Rush Homes • Donna Vincent, Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity 4. Create a Housing Trust Fund to assist with the preservation and development of housing options in the community. • Researched the 6 local housing trust funds in Virginia- all established and operated by the cities using a combination of taxes, developer payments and private contributions and used for a variety of purposes: developing affordable housing, first time homebuyer assistance, rental assistance, and preservation of affordable housing. City staff recommended using a portion of the meals tax to fund the Lynchburg Housing Trust Fund. 5. Identify and analyze existing affordable housing options and determine if they should be slated for preservation. If so, create a plan to preserve these sites and subsidize rehabilitation of existing units. • Additional city staff support needed to accomplish this priority. 6. Identify areas with missing standard infrastructure (water, sewer, sidewalk, etc.) and develop a plan to install it over time. • Additional city staff support needed to accomplish this priority. 7. Develop and implement precise evaluation tools to determine specific housing needs, particularly considering preventing and reducing poverty clusters. Identify national housing network partners to leverage expertise and develop a strategy to increase attainable housing in needed sectors. • The tool identified to prevent and reduce poverty clusters was to enact inclusionary zoning. There are various ways this can be done and the Collaborative decided a mandatory option would be best with the option to opt out and pay the Housing Trust Fund. 8. Develop a communication plan for attainable housing to improve the use of our existing tools and incentives. • The Collaborative decided there were various tools in Lynchburg not being fully communicated with the community and that better marketing could make these more accessible. 9. Enlist the help of developers, builders, and design professionals to remove barriers for attainable housing products that support homeownership. Some examples of evolving design strategies to reduce the gap between income and home price include small homes (reducing square footage), value housing (new housing brand segment with reduced option packages), missing middle (attached housing) and high-density detached housing (clustering). • It is suggested that a focus group of the above professionals be held to assess if barriers exist for them to build more attainable housing. 10. Enhance existing wrap-around support programs, providing both financial and personal/life support to stem high eviction rates and assist potential homeowners. 11. Evaluate public employees housing options similar to those found in Newark, New Jersey and Chapel Hill, North Carolina, the incentive packages available in other cities to determine their feasibility for implementation in Lynchburg, and the implementation of inclusionary zoning principles. • More data needed around this issue possibly regarding City staff housing or major employer housing. To: Jeff Helgeson, Randy Nelson, Vice Mayor Beau Wright CC: Mayor MaryJane Dolan, Chris Faraldi, Treney Tweedy, Sterling Wilder, Donna Witt, Carrie Dungan From: Wynter C. Benda, City Manager Date: September 22, 2022 About: Fiscal Year 2022 Adopted Budget to Estimated Actual Th is memorandum seeks to provide clarification on recent discussions related to Fiscal Year (FY) 2022 year- end numbers. Although discussions regarding a “surplus” have previously been tied to the Unassigned General Fund Balance (UGFB), the focus should be on expenditures and revenues compared to budget. General Fund Actual FY21 (A) Adopted FY22 (B) Estimated FY22 (C) Adopted FY23 (D) Revised Beginning FB FY23 (E) Beginning Unassigned Fund Balance $34,579,844 $30,197,436 $49,771,343 $40,955,797 $66,565,011 Revenues and Use of Fund Balance 210,084,561 196,949,073 215,332,240 206,525,769 206,525,769 Expenditures, Reserves, and Transfers 194,893,062 204,023,769 198,538,572 223,116,195 223,116,195 Ending Unassigned Fund Balance $49,771,343 $23,122,740 $66,565,011 $24,365,371 $49,974,585 As you can see in the chart above, the ending FY22 UGFB in Column C is estimated to be $66.6 million, compared to an adopted budget amount of $23.1 million in Column B. Once we plug in this estimated UGFB as the estimated FY23 beginning fund balance in Column E, the ending FY23 UGFB will be at least $50 million, compared to the adopted budget general fund financial summary of $24.4 million as shown in Column D. The UGFB will continue to fluctuate as revenues and expenditures vary from adopted to actual budget. This is why the conversation needs to focus on revenues and expenditures compared to budget instead of UGFB. Ac tual FY22 revenues are estimated to be $16.5 million more than the adopted budget, and expenditures are estimated to be about $6.4 million below the adopted budget. This results in $23 million of additional money in the general fund. These additional revenues are a result of conservative budgeting during the COVID-19 pandemic, a robust economy, and unprecedented inflation. Expenditures are lower than projected primarily because extensive vacancies throughout the organization result in about $4.2 million in personnel savings, which is higher than it has ever been. St aff will break these numbers down further in the coming weeks, but I wanted to provide preliminary information for these conversations. Agenda Item #: 6 FY 2022 Analysis of Unassigned General Fund Balance (UGFB) as of October 4, 2022 (not final audited numbers) FY 2022 Adopted Budget Ending Fund Balance $23,122,740 Estimated  based on FY 2020 Ending Unassigned Fund Balance FY 2022 Actual Ending Fund Balance (Estimated) 66,376,757 ($43,254,017) Variance Additional Beginning Fund Balance Above FY 2022 Adopted 19,573,9 07 Revenues Above Budget 14,520,462 Expenditures Below Budget (Savings) 7,707,842 ($1,451,806) Miscellaneous Revenues and Expenditures FY 2022 Adopted Budget Beginning Fund Balance $30,197,436 Revised  FY 2021 based on Audited Actual FY 2020 FY 2022 Actual Beginning Fund Balance 49,771,343 Audited Actual F Y 2021 $19,573,907 Variance Revenues Above Budget Sales and Use Tax $3,247,211 Meals Tax 3,306,859 Personal Property Tax 2,028,128 FY22 Adopted Personal Property –  Local portion less FY22 Actual  (reduced assessment 75% for 6/5/22 and 12/5/22) Business License Tax 1,207,730 Lodging Tax 496,832 Amusement Tax 336,599 Current Real Property Tax (469,184) FY22 Adopted Current Real Pro perty less FY22 Actual Delinquent Real Property Tax 411,823 Delinquent Personal Property Tax 444,921 Consumer Utility Tax ‐ Electric 192,155 Right of Way Fees 253,449 Communications Sales & Use Tax 569,362 Bank Stock Tax 205,810 Recordation Tax 508,791 Building Inspection Permit Fee 123,697 Ambulance Service Fees 533,122 Trash Bag Service Waste Zero 115,408 Refuse Disposal Fees 469,562 Miscellaneous 200,497 Federal and State 337,690 $14,520,462 Expenditures Below Budget (Savings) Personnel Services  $4,221,472 Non‐Department and Department Operating Savings 1,297,545 Reserve for Contingencies 1,150,000 Blue Ridge Jail Per Diem 1,038,825 $7,707,842

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.