Finance Committee Meeting - September 27, 2022 — Minutes
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · Finance Committee · meeting of Sep 27, 2022 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Page 1 of 3
FINANCE COMMITTEE NOTES -- FINAL
Tuesday, September 27, 2022
GENERAL BUSINESS
Meeting commenced at 11:30 a.m. in Council Chamber.
ATTENDEES
Committee Members: Council Member Jeff S. Helgeson, Chair; Council Member Randy Nelson;
Council Member Beau Wright; Mayor MaryJane Dolan, Ex-Officio.
Others: Wynter C. Benda, City Manager; John H. Hughes, IV, Assistant City Manager; Rhonda
Allbeck, Assistant Director of Financial Services; Starlette Early, Budget Analyst
1. Approval of the Draft Finance Committee Meeting Notes from July 26, 2022.
The Finance Committee Meeting Notes from July 26, 2022 were approved as submitted.
2. Report on the General Fund Reserve for Contingencies.
There were no new items to report, leaving a current balance of $1,200,000 including
$50,000 for the City Manager’s Discretionary Funding.
3. Approve the submittal of a grant application to the Virginia Office of Emergency Medical
Services Emergency Medical Services Grant Program through the Rescue Squad Assistance
Fund (RSAF) for $54,162 w ith resources of $27,081 from the RSAF grant and $27,081 from
the FY 2023 General Fund Fire Department budget to purchase one (1) Lifepak 15
monitor/defibrillator and one (1) Lucas 3 chest compression system for the Fire
Department.
Fire Chief Greg Wormser presented information about the grant, including the 50/50 local
match. The application was approved.
4. Elimination of Business License Tax for Businesses with Gross Receipts Less than $50,000.
Commissioner of the Revenue Mitch Nuckles presented this item, stating there are currently
510 businesses with gross receipts in the range of $10,001 - $50,000. There is no business
license requirement for businesses with gross receipts less than $10,000, and this code
would eliminate the business license requirement for these additional 510 businesses. He
reported the total gross receipts of these businesses in 2022 are $15,384,958, with 2022
Business License Tax totaling $15,417, and Business Personal Property (BPP) totaling
$19,833, for a total revenue of $35,250 due from these businesses. He confirmed
eliminating the Business License Tax for this group would result in reduced revenues of
approximately $35,250 annually.
There was discussion regarding historical changes to the business license that eliminated the
requirement of obtaining a business license for those business with gross receipts less than
Page 2 of 3
$10,000 (approximately 500 businesses) and the staff time related to administering business
licenses for businesses with gross receipts less than $50,000. Mr. Nuckles reported about 15
– 20% of the population moves each year, and this makes sending renewal notices and
communicating with business owners a challenging process. The application of the business
license is also the initial process that flags the creation of a business equipment account.
Council Member Helgeson indicated the revenue loss seemed nominal compared to the time
savings for the staff and the benefit to those business owners. Council Member Nelson asked
if this code change was recommended by the Commissioner, and Mr. Nuckles reported he
supported the change. There was discussion regarding voluntary compliance with the
Business License requirement, the registration requirement that is still applicable for short-
term rental operators, and the remittance of lodging tax associated with this short-term
registration through Community Development. Mr. Nuckles also indicated all businesses
must still receive approval through Community Development to operate a specific type of
business in a desired location.
Council Member Wright questioned whether the City would be able to reconcile the accuracy
of lodging tax remitted by a short-term rental without the Business License requirement.
Mr. Nuckles reported beginning October 1, Airbnb is scheduled to begin collecting and
remitting transient occupancy tax to the locality. Airbnb has notified their hosts to no longer
collect the lodging tax, as they would begin collecting and remitting on their behalf. The
legislation passed by the General Assembly requires the facilitator (Airbnb, VRBO, etc.) to
provide room sales information to the locality. Council Member Wright inquired about the
cost to increase the exemption up to $100,000 gross receipts, and Mr. Nuckles reported it
would be approximately $68,000, or 0.55% of the total revenue generated by this group.
Finance Committee members indicated they are open to further discussion in the work
session. Council Member Nelson indicated he would be in favor of at least the $50,000
exemption due to simply keeping up with inflation.
5. Review collections received from five of the City’s revenue sources.
Rhonda Allbeck reported revenues were trending up, as they have in the prior months.
6. Estimated FY 2022 Unassigned General Fund Balance.
Based on the estimated ending Fund Balance of approximately $43 million above the
adopted Fund Balance, Chairman Helgeson proposed to return $5 million in revenues the
City will receive due to Council voting to not equalize the real property tax rate during the
2022 budget deliberations. In response to Council Member Wright’s concerns regarding this
proposal, City Manager Benda made comments regarding possible impacts of taking this
action outside of the fiscal year budget process, the definition of surplus as defined in
relation to State Code authority for returning surplus revenues to citizens, information
forthcoming regarding property assessments from the City Assessor, and his overall level of
comfort to make decisions of this nature outside of the Fiscal Year 2024 budget. Council
Member Wright expressed his recommendation to take opportunity to think strategically
about how these funds might best work within the City’s financial plans and for Council to
Page 3 of 3
spend some time fact gathering before making any decisions that would have long-term
impacts. Council Member Nelson reflected on the past budget process and how the City
decided to provide a credit back to citizens for some of the additional revenues received
above those anticipated. He expressed concerns regarding the City’s loss in revenues as a
result of significant market fluctuations in property values during the 2005 – 2008
timeframe. He recalled by lowering real property tax rates in response to market conditions,
the City was not able to pay their employees to maintain essential service levels. He doesn’t
want to repeat this scenario and agreed with Council Member Wright he would like to
understand all the factors surrounding the market conditions, consider potential long-term
impacts, utilize expert opinions, and also consider how investment of these funds might save
additional money for citizens.
Chairman Helgeson responded that his proposal is only taking a portion of the $16 million
additional revenues and giving it back to where it came from by Council’s vote to raise taxes.
He expressed the citizens should take priority now and it should be an easy first step by
Council to give back the additional unnecessary $5 million in real property revenues. There
was additional conversation by Council Member Nelson regarding the possibility of
eliminating the Meals Tax to benefit those people who do not have kitchens, work several
jobs and do not have the choice to cook at home, and for other reasons they are forced to
eat out. He believes there is time to weigh in on all the issues and consider all the priorities.
City Manager Benda commented Meals Tax is a tax considered to be paid by many people
living outside of the City.
7. Roll Call.
Council Member Nelson reported there is foliage that needs to be cut back around the
bottom of the MLK sign located south on Fifth Street.
Meeting adjourned at 12:21 p.m.
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.