City Council Work Session and Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of May 10, 2022 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
May 10, 2022
WORK SESSION AGENDA
City Council Work Session – 4:00 p.m.
Council Chamber | City Hall, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, VA 24504
I. Welcome MaryJane Dolan, Mayor
II. Work Session Agenda Overview Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
III. Work Session Agenda Items Wynter C. Benda, City Manager
1) Shentel Glo Fiber Installation Update 4:05 p.m. – 4:20 p.m.
2) Appalachian Power Distribution & Transmission Project Update
4:20 p.m. – 4:35 p.m.
3) Lynchburg City Schools Facility Study Part II: Demographic Analysis
4:35 p.m. – 5:35 p.m.
4) Roll Call 5:35 p.m. – 5:45 p.m.
Lynchburg, VA
Project Update
Initial Plan
• 20,000 homes planned
• 300 miles of fiber
• Implementation of permitting &
construction process
• Initial conversations started 2Q 2019
• Construction started 1Q 2021
• ~75% construction complete
• ~10% in construction/permitting phases
• ~15% remaining will require additional
agreements
Municipal Leadership
• Franchising
• John Hughes
• Reid Wodicka
• Permitting & Construction Process
• Kate Berger
• Gaynelle Hart
• Lee Newland
Effective Collaboration
Lynchburg Citizen Impact
• Current offerings
• Triple-Play capable
• Data Tiers
• 300 Mbps: $65
• 1 Gig: $80
• 2 Gig: $100
• Committed to expanding to remainder of City (ex: Stewart Langley and
small businesses)
• Affordable Connectivity Program (ACP) Participant
• $30/month discount for qualifying customers
• Added $30, 100 Mbps plan – effectively a free plan for qualifying customers
• We have noticed a competitive response from Comcast
• Continue to look for retail presence to eventually be manned
Appalachian Power
Distribution & Transmission
Project Overview
City of Lynchburg
May 2022
Customer Expectations
Reliable Service
◦ Customers expect few outages – even
blinks
◦ Want quick restoration time when outages
do occur
Outages often related to
◦ Aging infrastructure
◦ Tree impacts
◦ Severe weather
Employees repair damage following
the 2018 Lynchburg tornado.
Distribution & Transmission Projects
Current Improvement Projects
◦ Reusens/Roanoke Transmission Line Rebuild
◦ Reusens/New London Transmission Line Rebuild
◦ Expressway/Perkins Park Tap Project
◦ Involves rebuilding approximately 0.6 miles of 69-kilovolt transmission line between the Expressway and
Perkins Park substations.
Recently Completed Projects
◦ Dearington/Reusens Transmission Line Rebuild
◦ Brush Tavern/South Lynchburg
◦ Downtown Lynchburg Underground Project
◦ Distribution automation schemes (self-healing circuits)
◦ Commerce Street Project
Lynchburg-Area Projects
Dearington-Reusens
Brush Tavern-South Lynchburg
Reusens-Roanoke
Downtown Lynchburg &
Commerce Street Project
Expressway-Perkins Park Tap Project
Reusens-New London
* Map intended to show the general vicinity of projects.
Transmission Improvements
Projects involve
◦ Clearing rights-of-way
◦ Installing taller poles with bigger
pole bases and stronger wire
◦ Work occurring in rural and
populated areas
Distribution Improvements
Projects involve
◦ Clearing rights-of-way
◦ Adding circuits
◦ Installing taller, stronger
poles and wire
◦ Replacing underground
equipment in downtown
Lynchburg
◦ Replacing street lighting
Reach us 24/7
◦ By phone at 1-800-956-4237
◦ On the web www.AppalachianPower.com
◦ New digital assistant, Aepril
◦ By mobile app
◦ Via Facebook and Twitter
Renewable energy
◦ Carbon neutral by 2050
Customer Expectations
Our digital assistant “Aepril” doesn’t require an app.
You can connect on any internet-enabled device.
Contact Information
Larry Jackson
Appalachian Power External Affairs
lejackson@aep.com
540-985-2690
Lynchburg City Council: Facilities Master Plan Update
May 10, 2022
Status Report
Dominion Seven Architects Tasks
• 1) Demographics - Complete
• 2) Facility Condition Assessment - Complete
• 3) Educational Programming - Complete
• 4) Future of Education – Not Part of Dominion Seven Architects Agreement
• 5) Recommendations – Pending
TASK #1 DEMOGRAPHICS
Demographics – City Population Projections
Executive Summary
• 2020 Census: Detailed information will not be available from the Census Bureau until the
end of 2022
• 2020 to 2025: City population expected to increase by 1,360 people to 80,340 or 1.7%
• 2025 to 2030: City population expected to increase by 1,000 people to 81,430 or 1.2%
Demographics – City Population Projections
Executive Summary
• Significant numbers of the 18 to 24 year-old population is leaving the City for college or
employment
• Median age will increase from 31.0 in 2020 to 33.0 in 2030
• Most non-college in-migration to Lynchburg occurs in the 0 to 9 and 25 to 44 year-old age
groups
Demographics – City Population Projections
Executive Summary
• Highest Percentage Growth for Age Ranges Lynchburg City 2020 to 2030:
➢ 35 to 39 – 131.44%
➢ 40 to 44 – 147.75%
➢ 45 to 49 – 120.87%
➢ 75 to 70 – 136.53%
➢ 80 to 84 – 141.51%
Demographics – City Population Projections
Attendance Zone Changes in Population
• City of Lynchburg Population - Increasing
➢ Dearington – 11.5% increase
➢ Heritage – 10.8% increase
• City of Lynchburg Population - Decreasing
➢ William M. Bass – 12.8% decline
➢ Linkhorne – 0.2% decline
➢ T. C. Miller – 0.7% decline
➢ Perrymont – 0.2% decline
Demographics – LCS Enrollment Projections
Executive Summary
• Lynchburg resident fertility rates are below replacement level
• Primary reason for the enrollment decline
➢ High empty nest households
➢ Low number of the elderly housing units turning over for younger families
➢ Flat in-migration rate of young families to the city
• The rate, magnitude, and price of existing home sales will become the increasingly
dominant factor affecting the amount of enrollment change.
Demographics – LCS Enrollment Projections
Executive Summary
• Between 500 and 550 students (City residents) are being home schooled
• Lynchburg City Schools Enrollment
➢ 2010 – 8,476 (11.20% of the City’s population)
➢ 2020 – 7,832 or a 7.5% decline from 2010 (9.905% of the City’s population)
➢ 2030 – 7,683 or a 1.9% decline from 2020 (9.435% of the City’s population)
Demographics – LCS Enrollment Projections
Attendance Zone Changes in Population
• Lynchburg City Schools Enrollment – Significant Growth
➢ Bedford Hills – 9.5% increase
➢ Dearington – 10.4% increase
➢ Heritage – 11.2% increase
➢ Sheffield – 10.2% increase
• Lynchburg City Schools Enrollment – Flat Growth
➢ William M. Bass – 1.1% increase
➢ Sandusky – 1.5% increase
Demographics – LCS Enrollment Projections
Division
• 2021-2022 to 2026-2027: Total enrollment decrease by 383 students (4.9%) across
the division
• 2026-2027 to 2031-2032: Total enrollment decrease by 189 students (2.5%) across
the division
• Note: The division enrollment decline appears to be flattening
Demographics – LCS Enrollment Projections
Elementary Schools
• The elementary school enrollment will slowly increase after the 2023-2024 to 7.8% or 290
students by 2031-2032
• The increase should not be perceived as a long-term trend unless the status quo changes
• The enrollment projections do not account for any expansion of Pre-K Education
• Note: There is a waiting list for Pre-K
Demographics – LCS Elementary School Projections
Ward 1
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Bedford Hills Elementary Paul Munro Elementary Sandusky Elementary
Demographics – LCS Elementary School Projections
Ward 2
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
William M. Bass Elementary Dearington Elementary For Innovation T.C. Miller Elementary For Innovat. Robert S. Payne Elementary
Demographics – LCS Elementary School Projections
Ward 3
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Heritage Elementary Sheffield Elementary
Demographics – LCS Elementary School Projections
Ward 4
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Linkhorne Elementary Perrymont Elementary
Demographics – LCS Enrollment Projections
Middle and High Schools
• Middle and High School enrollment will continue to decline
➢ Middle school enrollment will decline by 5.1% or 87 students by 2031-2032
➢ High school enrollment will decline by 14.5% or 352 students by 2031-2032
Demographics – LCS Enrollment Projections
Middle Schools
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
700
800
900
Paul L. Dunbar Mid. For Innov. Linkhorne Middle Sandusky Middle
Demographics – LCS Enrollment Projections
High Schools
0
200
400
600
800
1,000
1,200
1,400
1,600
1,800
E. C. Glass High Heritage High
Demographics – Comparison of Reports
Report Prepared by Cropper GIS with McKibben Demographics
• CROPPER GIS METHODOLOGY
➢ Age specific population forecast for each elementary school zone
➢ The City population forecast drives the enrollment forecast
➢ Historical enrollment does not affect the enrollment forecast
➢ Existing house sales is a key component
Demographics – Comparison of Reports
Report Prepared by Cropper GIS with McKibben Demographics
• WELDON COOPER METHODOLOGY
➢ Most recent report was prepared in 2020.
➢ Relies on birth to kindergarten ratios, and historical enrollment
➢ Flat migration rate of young families to the city
➢ New home construction is a key component
Demographics – Comparison of Reports
Elementary Schools
3100
3200
3300
3400
3500
3600
3700
3800
3900
4000
Weldon Cooper Cropper GIS
Demographics – Comparison of Reports
Middle Schools
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
1800
2000
Weldon Cooper Cropper GIS
Demographics – Comparison of Reports
High Schools
1800
1900
2000
2100
2200
2300
2400
2500
Weldon Cooper Cropper GIS
Demographics – Comparison of Reports
Total Enrollment
6600
6800
7000
7200
7400
7600
7800
8000
8200
8400
Weldon Cooper Cropper GIS
Demographics – Elementary Schools
Maximum Class Size
Demographics – Elementary Schools
Maximum Class Size
• The formulas are inherently inefficient when evaluated across the division versus individual schools.
➢ Dearington: Maximum class size is 19 for Kindergarten through 3rd Grade
❑ 1st Grade has 21 students in 2 classrooms or 10.5 students per classroom which is 44.7% lower than the
maximum class size.
➢ Heritage: Maximum class size is 21 for Kindergarten through 3rd Grade
❑ 3rd Grade has 66 students in 4 classrooms or 16.5 students per classroom which is 21.4% lower than the
maximum class size.
➢ Paul Munro: Maximum class size is 24 for Kindergarten through 3rd Grade
❑ 2nd Grade has 52 students in 3 classrooms or 17.3 students per classroom which is 27.7% lower than
the maximum class size.
Demographics – Capacity and Utilization Rates
Rating System
Demographics – Capacity and Utilization Rates
Elementary Schools
Demographics – Capacity and Utilization Rates
Middle Schools
Demographics – Capacity and Utilization Rates
High Schools
Demographics – Surplus Capacity
Is Lynchburg in a Unique Situation?
• No, this is typical for all Divisions who have declining enrollments.
• Urban Divisions have neighborhood schools, which compounds closing/consolidation.
Demographics – Surplus Capacity
Is Lynchburg in a Unique Situation?
• No, this is typical for all Divisions who have declining enrollments.
• Rural Divisions have schools spread over a larger area, which compounds closing/consolidation.
Demographics
How Do You Compare with Your Peers
• Charlottesville City: 2.8% Decrease
• Hampton City: 14.7% Decrease
• Hopewell City: 4.9% Increase
• Lynchburg City: 10.2% Decrease
• Newport News City: 18.9% Decrease
• Petersburg City: 22.2% Decrease
• Richmond City: 16.2% Decrease
• Williamsburg City/James City County: 26.3% Increase
• Roanoke City: 1.1% Increase
• Danville City: 22.3% Decrease
• Harrisonburg City: 65.2% Increase
• Lexington City: .85% Increase
• Martinsville City: 30.4% Decrease
• Norfolk City: 25.1% Decrease
• Portsmouth City: 18.3% Decrease
• Staunton City: 2.1% Increase
• Winchester City: 14.2% Increase
Demographics
Questions Received:
How many of those school divisions have built new schools with a larger enrollment?
• Since 2010-2011
➢ Harrisonburg: 916 student ES
➢ Lexington: 480 student ES
➢ Newport News: 918 student ES
➢ Norfolk: (6) ES with average of 758 students and (1) 1,151 student K-8
➢ Richmond: (4) ES with average of 808 students, (1) 280 student ELC, (2) MS
with average of 1,215 students, and (1) 1,574 student HS
➢ Roanoke: 930 student ES
TASK #2: FACILITY CONDITION
ASSESSMENT
TASK #3: EDUCATIONAL PROGRAMMING
TASK #4: FUTURE OF EDUCATION
Task #4: Future of Education
Lynchburg City Schools Plan for the Future
• Utilize the services of an Educational Planner
➢ Provide a national perspective on the trends and solutions of similar school divisions.
➢ Facilitate a locally-developed vision for the students, teachers and staff and the City at large.
➢ Review current pedagogy and make suggestions for the future.
Task #4: Future of Education
Lynchburg City Schools Plan for the Future
• Utilize the services of an Educational Planner
➢ Provide a national perspective on the trends and solutions of similar school divisions.
➢ Facilitate a locally-developed vision for the students, teachers and staff and the City at large.
➢ Review current pedagogy and make suggestions for the future.
• Developing a New Vision for the Lynchburg City Schools
➢ Determine the future of Pre-K Education.
➢ Evaluate the Schools for Innovation.
❑ Is the current curriculum applicable for tomorrow?
❑ Should there be additional Schools of Innovation?
➢ Develop a marketing campaign to promote LCS.
Task #4: Future of Education
Lynchburg City Schools Plan for the Future
• Improving Facilities through Renovation and New Construction
➢ Building design to compliment 22nd Century teaching and learning strategies.
➢ Seek energy efficiency.
➢ Collaboration and technology rich maker spaces are the future. Children learn by doing and sharing.
Task #4: Future of Education
Lynchburg City Schools Plan for the Future
• Improving Facilities through Renovation and New Construction
➢ Building design to compliment 22nd Century teaching and learning strategies.
➢ Seek energy efficiency.
➢ Collaboration and technology rich maker spaces are the future. Children learn by doing and sharing.
• Slow the Demographic Trends
➢ Providing educational opportunities that are not found at private and home schools in order to keep a
larger percentage of the City of Lynchburg students.
TASK #5: RECOMMENDATIONS
Task #5: Recommendations
Suggestions to Consider
• Relocate programs that are currently leasing space.
• Consider repurposing some elementary schools versus closing a school(s).
➢ Empty buildings are not good for neighborhoods.
➢ If a school is closed, work with the City to find an acceptable use for the building.
• Determine the future home for the alternative programs and LAUREL.
• Should the school administration be relocated to an existing school?
• Work with the City to find ways of keeping or attracting young families.
Task #5: Recommendations – Elementary Schools
Potential Option #1: Focus on Operational Efficiency
• Larger and Newer Elementary Schools
➢ Short-Term Solutions
❑ School Closing and Consolidation
❑ Eliminate Leases
❑ Miscellaneous Renovations
❑ Attendance Zone Changes
➢ Construction of New Schools
➢ Renovation/Addition at Some Schools
❑ Fine Arts, Gymnasium, Classrooms (to eliminate modulars)
➢ Possible Repurposing of Some Schools
➢ Continued Maintenance Work at the Remaining Schools
Task #5: Recommendations – Elementary Schools
Potential Option #2: Middle Ground
• Mix Larger and Smaller Elementary Schools
➢ Short-Term Solutions
❑ School Closing and Consolidation
❑ Eliminate Leases
❑ Miscellaneous Renovations
❑ Attendance Zone Changes
➢ Construction of a New School
➢ Renovation/Addition at Several Schools
❑ Fine Arts, Gymnasium, Classrooms (to eliminate modulars)
➢ Possible Repurposing of Some Schools
➢ Continued Maintenance Work at the Remaining Schools
Task #5: Recommendations – Elementary Schools
Potential Option #3: Focus on Existing Facilities
• Less Elementary Schools, but Smaller Schools
➢ Short-Term Solutions
❑ School Closing and Consolidation
❑ Eliminate Leases
❑ Miscellaneous Renovations
❑ Attendance Zone Changes
➢ Construction of New Schools - none
➢ Renovation/Addition at Multiple Schools
❑ Fine Arts, Gymnasium, Classrooms (to eliminate modulars)
➢ Possible Repurposing of Some Schools
➢ Continued Maintenance Work at the Remaining Schools
Task #5: Recommendations
Additional Thoughts
• Update the demographic report after the 2020 census is complete.
• Regularly (every 10 years) budget funds for a demographic study to remain current with the population changes.
• Assuming the enrollment at the middle and high schools will continue to decline; those schools will soon be too
large for the number of students:
➢ What will be the future of those buildings?
Task #5: Recommendations
School Board’s Role
• Inform and seek guidance from the community and school faculty and staff.
➢ LCS is currently having “Community Conversations” at the elementary schools each Monday through May 23.
• Evaluate and balance the needs of the Division versus the needs of individual schools and neighborhoods.
• Develop 3 elementary school options for the future of the Lynchburg City Schools for the public’s review and
discussion.
• Make the final decision.
Task #5: Recommendations
Dominion Seven Architects Role
• Provide technical assistance.
• Development of proposed physical changes to the schools and attendance zones based on the options that you
develop.
• Development of short-term maintenance projects.
• Development of estimated costs, schedules and phasing of construction projects.
• Development of energy savings options.
• Document the recommendations in the final report
Task #5: Recommendations
Making These Types of Decisions is Hard
• This is a watershed moment for the City and LCS. Embrace the challenge.
• Remember that children are the most adaptable to change.
• Make a good decision and not a rushed decision. Be patient.
• We believe that there is a solution that can meet the needs of most people.
Lynchburg City Council: Facilities Master Plan Update
Questions?
May 10, 2022
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.