City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · City Council · meeting of Nov 16, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
City Council Meeting Agenda
November 16, 2026
City Hall Council Chamber
605 E. Main St.
Charlottesville, VA 22902
Juandiego R. Wade, Mayor
Natalie Oschrin, Vice Mayor
Jen Fleisher
Michael K. Payne
J. Lloyd Snook, III
Kyna Thomas, Clerk
4:00 PM Opening Session
I. Call to Order/Roll Call
II. Agenda Approval
III. Reports
1. Presentation: Draft Climate Adaptation and Resilience Plan
2. Presentation: Draft Urban Forest Management Plan
5:30 PM Closed Meeting (Boards & Commissions)
6:30 PM Business Session
IV. Moment of Silence
V. Announcements
VI. Recognitions/Proclamations
• Proclamation: Restorative Justice Week
VII. Community Matters Public comment for up to 16 speakers (limit 3 minutes per speaker). Preregistration
available for first 8 spaces at https://www.charlottesville.gov/692/Request-to-Speak;
speakers announced by Noon on meeting day (9:00 a.m. sign-up deadline).
Additional public comment at end of meeting. Comments on Public Hearing items
are heard during the public hearing only.
VIII. Consent Agenda* The consent agenda consists of routine, non-controversial items whereby all items
are passed with a single motion and vote. Individuals speaking during Community
Matters may address items on the Consent Agenda.
3. Minutes: August 3, 2026 regular meeting
4. Resolution: Resolution to Appropriate funds from the Sentara Foundation to the Department
of Human Services for the Westhaven CARES Center - $7,000 (2nd reading)
5. Ordinance: Consideration of Amendments to the Code of the City of Charlottesville, Chapter
19 - Personnel (1 of 2 readings)
IX. City Manager Report
• Report: City Manager Report
a. Report: Quarterly Financial Report
b. Report: Budget Brief #1
X. Action Items
Page 1 of 143
6. Public
Hearing/Ord.:
Public Hearing and Ordinance regarding Petition to Vacate a Portion of the Swift
Lane Right-of-Way adjacent to 1210 Smith Street (Tax Map and Parcel
490139100)
7. Ordinance: Ordinance Amending and Re-Ordaining Chapter 14 (Licenses), Section 14-24
(Tax Incentives for Technology Businesses) to Extend Eligibility Period for Five
(5) Years to December 31, 2031 (2nd reading)
8. Resolution: Resolution to Appropriate $67,667 from the City's low-barrier shelter operations
fund to SupportWorks Housing for Vista 29 (2nd reading)
9. Ordinance: Ordinance Amending City Code Sections 2-8, 2-37 AND 2-455 Concerning
Board and Commission Membership
XI. General Business
10. Presentation: Vinegar Hill Group Presentation
XII. Community Matters (2)
XIII. Adjournment
Page 2 of 143
MEETING GUIDELINES
• This is an in-person meeting with an option for the public to participate electronically by
registering in advance for the Zoom webinar at www.charlottesville.gov/zoom. The meeting may
also be viewed on the City's streaming platforms and local government Channel 10. Individuals
with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public
meeting may call (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The
City of Charlottesville requests that you provide 48 hours’ notice so that proper arrangements
may be made.
• The presiding officer shall ensure that individuals address their comments to City Council at
appropriate times, in accordance with the meeting agenda and Council’s Rules of Procedure.
• No person who is not a member of the city council shall orally address it until leave to do so
has been granted by the city council or until invited to do so by the mayor. (City Code sec.2-71)
• Remarks and actions that disrupt the progress of the Council meeting, and remarks from
persons other than councilors, the City Manager, the City Attorney, or a presenter for an Agenda
Item are not permitted.
• The presiding officer shall call an individual to order, including a councilor, when that individual
goes afoul of these rules. The following are examples of remarks and behavior that are not
permitted:
i. Interrupting a speaker who is addressing Council at the speaker's microphone, or
interrupting a speaker who has otherwise been invited to address Council during
Community Matters or a Public Hearing
ii. Interrupting a councilor who is speaking
iii. Shouting, and talking (either individually or in concert with others) in a manner that
prevents a speaker or a Councilor from being heard or that otherwise hinders the
progress of the meeting
iv. Blocking paths for emergency exit from the meeting room; engaging in any conduct that
prevents a member of the audience from seeing or hearing councilors during a meeting;
standing on chairs or tables within the Council meeting room
v. Threats or incitement of violence toward councilors, City staff or members of the public
vi. Engaging in conduct that is a criminal offense under the City Code or the Virginia Code
vii. Campaigning for elected office
viii. Promotion of private business ventures
ix. Using profanity or vulgarity
x. Personal attacks against Councilors, City staff or members of the public
xi. Behavior which tends to intimidate others
• During a City Council meeting the presiding officer shall have control of the Council Chambers
and the connecting halls and corridors within City Hall, and any other venue where a Council
meeting is being held. In case of any conduct described above, the presiding officer may take
measures deemed appropriate, including but not limited to suspending the meeting until order
is restored, ordering areas to be cleared by the Sergeant at Arms, or requiring any individual to
exit the meeting room and adjacent premises (connecting halls and corridors.)
Page 3 of 143
Policy Briefing Summary
City Council
Regarding: Draft Climate Adaptation and Resilience Plan
Staff Contact(s): Kristel Riddervold, Director of the Office of Sustainability, Emily Irvine,
Climate Program Manager
Presenter: Emily Irvine, Climate Program Manager
Date of Proposed
Action:
November 16, 2026
Issue
Through the Resilient Together project, staff have been working to develop a Climate Adaptation and
Resilience Plan for Charlottesville. The draft plan has been completed and shared with the community
for public comment. This presentation will provide Council with a briefing on the draft Plan and allow
Council to ask questions and provide feedback.
Background / Rule
In 2017, the City of Charlottesville formally joined the Global Covenant of Mayors for Climate and
Energy, which committed the City to plan for both the causes and effects of climate change. The
Climate Action Plan (CAP), adopted in 2023, guides the work of reducing our community’s greenhouse
gases. The proposed companion Climate Adaptation and Resilience Plan (CARP) will guide the work
Charlottesville does to prepare for the impacts. Additionally, the City’s Comprehensive Plan calls for
both a CAP and a CARP.
In 2022, as the first step in preparing for the impacts of climate change, the City conducted a Climate
Risk and Vulnerability Assessment. That study identified the specific climate-driven hazards and
vulnerabilities expected to impact the Charlottesville area. During the same timeframe, Albemarle
County’s Climate Program conducted a similar assessment for the County. Because the impacts of
climate change will affect our jurisdictions similarly, the decision was made to work collaboratively on
regional climate adaptation and resilience planning. City and County Climate Program staff reached out
to UVA Office for Sustainability staff and invited the University to join the collaborative planning work.
The resulting collaborative Resilient Together project was formally launched in September 2023.
From the outset, Resilient Together aimed to produce separate but complimentary Climate Adaptation
and Resilience Plans (CARPs) for each organization. Like the CAP, the CARP is intended to be
adopted as an amendment to the City’s Comprehensive Plan. Charlottesville’s draft plan is complete
and is currently being shared with the community for public review and comment via the Climate
Adaptation and Resilience Plan page on Connect Charlottesville. The comment period will close on
November 30.
Analysis
The attached presentation provides an overview of the development of the Climate Adaptation and
Resilience Plan, including history and background of the Resilient Together project, content and
examples from the plan, and its relationship to other City plans and projects.
The Resilience Plan features 16 broad strategies to be initiated over the next ten years that will
strengthen our community systems as the shocks and stressors of climate change intensify. The
strategy topics are variable, with some addressing multiple hazards and others addressing a single
hazard. Each strategy includes implementation projects that have been organized by the estimated
Page 4 of 143
timeframe to begin work on them. Lead departments, internal and external partners, level of staff effort,
and funding sources have also been identified for each project.
The projects identified in the CARP are intended to be primarily led by the City, and in some cases
partner organizations. However, durable resilience is not something a local government can do to or for
a community. The work of resilience building must be taken up collaboratively and at the individual,
household, neighborhood, and community level. In service to this idea, each strategy also includes a
“Community Action” section that shares information and resources to support community-led resilience
building. Many of the City-led implementation projects are designed to support community members in
household and community resilience-building.
The development of the CARP was informed by multiple rounds of engagement efforts to collect
community-member, partner organization, staff, and subject-matter expert input. The strategy topics
were chosen based on local context, lessons learned from peer communities, and community-member
input. The implementation projects associated with each strategy were identified and developed by
inter-organizational staff working groups and then refined by Charlottesville staff from across
departments.
Financial Impact
There is no budget impact associated with this report.
Recommendation
This is an informational report, no formal action is needed.
Recommended Motion (if Applicable)
N/A
Attachments
1. CARP_Council Preso_ Attachment A_111626
2. CARP_Council Preso_Attachment B_111626
Page 5 of 143
City of Charlottesville
Office of Sustainability
CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION
November 16, 2026
Attachment A – Draft Climate Adaptation and Resilience Plan
https://www.charlottesville.gov/DocumentCenter/View/16966/Draft-Charlottesville-
Climate-Adaptation-and-Resilience-Plan-
Page 6 of 143
Charlottesville’s
Climate
Adaptation and
Resilience Plan
Roadmap to a Strong, Safe, and
Healthy Future
Page 7 of 143
Agenda
• Project History & Background
• Plan Development
• About the Plan
• Questions & Next Steps
Page 8 of 143
History & Background
The why and how of resilience planning
Page 9 of 143
How We Got Here
2017
Joined Global Covenant of
Mayors for Climate and Energy
2019
Adoption of current emissions
reduction goals
2022
Charlottesville Risk &
Vulnerability Assessment
2023
Adoption of 1st Climate Action Plan
City of Charlottesville Strategic Plan Framework – Climate
Outcome Area
September: Resilient Together Project Kick-Off
2026
Completed Draft of
Charlottesville’s Climate
Adaptation & Resilience Plan
Page 10 of 143
CAP and CARP: Sibling Climate Plans
Mitigation
• Reducing
Greenhouse
Gases
• Addressing the
underlying
cause
• Climate Action
Plan (CAP)
Adaptation
• Strengthening
systems against
the impacts of
climate change
• Reacting to the
symptoms
• Climate
Adaptation and
Resilience Plan
(CARP)
Page 11 of 143
The Why: Local Impacts
Regional Hazards & Risks
• Extreme Heat
• Intense Rain and Flooding
• Drought
• Severe Storms
• Shifting Seasons
Pests & Disease
• Wildfire & Smoke
Page 12 of 143
The How: Resilient Together
Resilient Together is a joint planning
and community engagement process
to help our community prepare for the
more intense and frequent severe
weather events that we face.
Albemarle County, the City of
Charlottesville, and the University of
Virginia have partnered in this work.
The project has engaged staff, partner
institutions, community-based
organizations, and the public.
Project Vision: a strong, safe, and healthy future for all
Page 13 of 143
Plan Development
Getting from there to here
Page 14 of 143
Resilient Together: Project Outline
Prep
Prepare for
successful
process
Develop
partnership,
design process,
create materials
Late 2022 –
September
2023
Discover
Foster
shared
knowledge
of the
challenge
Gather, review,
and share
information with
staff, partners,
and community
October
2023 – May
2024
Define
Define
guiding
principles
& project
goals
Feedback from
staff, partners
June –
October
2024
Design
Design
strategies
for
adaptation
and
resilience
Input from staff,
partners, and
community
November
2024 –
March 2026
Decide
Create
adaptation
and
resilience
plans
Draft content,
seek community
and partner
feedback,
submit for
adoption
April 2026 -
Present
We are here!
Do
Implement
Pursue grants
Partner with
local orgs,
agencies,
community
Monitoring &
Evaluation
Future
Page 15 of 143
Engagement Tracks
• Led work to refine draft strategies and develop
implementation projects and roadmaps
• Supported all other engagement tracks
RT Project Team
• Participated in sector- and hazard-specific technical
working groups to develop implementation projects
and roadmaps
Staff & SMEs
• Planned and conducted engagement events around
community resilience building
• Reviewed draft plan and offered input/feedback
CBO Cohort
Members
• Participated in engagement events to provide place-
specific knowledge and inputCommunity
Page 16 of 143
Staff & SME Engagement
Office for Sustainability
Office of the Architect
Facilities Management
Emergency Management
Environmental Health and Safety
UVA Health
UVA Transportation
UVA Foundation
UVA
Office of Sustainability
Emergency Management
Neighborhood Development
Parks & Recreation
Utilities
Public Works
Human Services
Strategic Planning
Communications
Economic Development
Office of Human Rights
Charlottesville Area Transit
Charlottesville
Facilities & Environmental
Services
Communications & Public
Engagement
Office of Equity & Inclusion
AC Fire Rescue
Community Development
Human Services
Economic Development
Parks & Recreation
Albemarle
Emergency Communications
Center
Rivanna Water & Sewer Authority
Blue Ridge Health District
TJPDC
TJWSCD
Cultivate Charlottesville
Community Climate
Collaborative
IRC New Roots
Market Central
Partners
Over 125 cross-organizational & community meetings to develop,
refine, and finalize strategies and implementation projects.
(Not inclusive of project team meetings.)
Page 17 of 143
Relationship to Other City Plans & Projects
• Like the Climate Action Plan, Charlottesville’s Adaptation and Resilience Plan will be
proposed for adoption as an amendment to the City’s Comprehensive Plan.
• Final strategies support many of the goals and strategies of the Comprehensive Plan,
beyond those in Chapter 7 (Environment, Climate, and Food Equity).
• Charlottesville’s CARP includes a section that details its relationship to other City
planning documents, including:
• Comprehensive Plan
• Climate Action Plan
• Regional Hazard Mitigation Plan
• Flood Resilience Plan
• Forthcoming Urban Forest Management Plan
• Forthcoming Mobility Plan
• Ongoing Environmental Regulatory Review Projects
Page 18 of 143
About the Plan
What’s in Charlottesville’s CARP?
Page 19 of 143
What is Climate Resilience?
Climate Resilience means strengthening our community systems to better
withstand exposure to increasing climatic shocks and stressors.
Extreme
Heat
Severe
Storms
Intense
Rain &
Flooding
Drought
Shifting
Seasonal
Patterns
Wildfire &
Smoke
Page 20 of 143
What is Climate Resilience? (Continued)
Page 21 of 143
Strategy Topic Areas
Biodiversity Buildings Communication
& Information
Community
Training &
Partnerships
Economic
Resilience
Electric Energy
Infrastructure
Emergency
Response
Capacity
Food Systems
Resilience Hubs
State Support
for Local
Resilience
Stream
Corridors &
Floodplains
Transportation
Urban Heat Urban
Stormwater
Water Supply &
Conservation
Wildfire &
Smoke
Preparedness
Page 22 of 143
Strategies Topics – Hazard Alignment
Strategy Topic Area
Biodiversity X X X X
Buildings X X X X
Communications & Information X X X X X X
Community Training & Partnerships X X X X X X
Economic Resilience X X X X X X
Electric Energy Infrastructure X X X X
Emergency Response Capacity X X X X
Food Systems X X X X X X
Resilience Hubs X X X X X
State Support for Local Resilience X X X X X X
Stream Corridors & Floodplains X X
Transportation X X X
Urban Heat X
Urban Stormwater X X
Water Supply & Conservation X
Wildfire & Smoke Preparedness X
Page 23 of 143
Strategy & Project Development
Refine locally
relevant strategy
options from
NOAA Climate
Resilience Toolkit
Compare with
existing local
plans
What types of
strategies are
most appropriate
for our local
context and will
yield the desired
outcomes and
impacts?
What needs to
be done to
implement each
strategy? Who
will do it? When
is it feasible to
start? What
resources will we
need?
What does
success or
progress look
like? How will we
know?
RT Project Team Design Phase Engagement: Staff & local SMEs, Cohort, Community
Draft Strategies Strategy Options Implementation Steps Impacts
Page 24 of 143
Strategy Implementation Roadmaps
• Strategy
• Hazards Addressed
• Context & Background Information
• Prioritized Implementation Projects
• Lead Department or Organization
• Partners
• Staff Effort Estimation
• Funding Source
• Implementation Timeframe
• Corresponding Community Actions
• Success Indicators
Page 25 of 143
Sample Strategy: Urban Heat
Seven Associated Implementation Projects
• Complete a comprehensive review of all codes and
policies related to the urban forest
• Install green infrastructure and shade structures
• Formalize procedure for opening cooling centers
• Drinking fountains & water stations in public areas
• Update City’s tree guide to reflect future conditions
• Develop guideline for extreme heat outdoor safety
• Additional resources to support UFMP
Page 26 of 143
Sample Implementation Project
Description of project. Calls out
prioritization of neighborhoods with
greater exposure to urban heat.
Alignment with other plans/programs.
Staff and partners required for
implementation; level of staff
effort required
Project initiation timelinePotential sources of funding
Page 27 of 143
Community Actions
Page 28 of 143
Measuring Success
Page 29 of 143
Working Together to Build Regional Resilience
Strategy Priority Projects Timeframe
Communications &
Information
Provide user-friendly, locally-relevant information about how to prepare for
natural hazards and climate risks.
1 – 3 years
Launch a communications campaign using a diverse set of messaging tools to
ensure inclusive and broad reach.
1 – 3 years
Align emergency alert protocols across local agencies. 1 – 3 years
Invest in improvements to real-time data reporting. 1 – 3 years
Strengthen relationships with local media outlets. 3 – 5 years
Community Training &
Partnerships
Reconstitute a Community Emergency Response Team (CERT) 1 – 3 years
Emergency Response
Capacity
Ensure access to satellite communications, citizen band, and ham radio. 3 – 5 years
Transportation Build systems for communication and coordination across transit agencies. 1 – 3 years
Identify and improve vulnerable transportation infrastructure 3 – 5 years
Increase capacity to operate transit fleets and fleet vehicles in extreme weather 3 – 5 years
Enable resource sharing between organizations in extreme weather to maintain
infrastructure and access.
5 – 10 years
Urban Heat Create a protocol and procedure for opening cooling (and warming) centers. 1 – 3 years
Urban Stormwater Assess stormwater infrastructure adequacy to handle higher rainfall projections. 1 – 3 years
Page 30 of 143
Climate Resilience vs. Emergency Management
Acute
Event
During the Event
Response
RecoveryResilience
Prepar-
edness
After the Event
Before the Event
Page 31 of 143
Next Steps
Looking Ahead: Next Steps
• Public Comment Period – open thru November 30
• connect.charlottesville.gov/ResilientCharlottesville/
• Upcoming engagement opportunities:
• Tuesday, November 17; Drop-In Session @ City Space; 12 – 2 pm
• Wednesday, November 18; Virtual Drop-In Session (Zoom); 4 – 6 pm
• Friday, November 20; Climate Café @ Botanical Fare; 9:30 – 11:00 am
• Integrate Feedback as needed
• January 12 – Planning Commission Public Hearing
• February 15 – City Council Public Hearing
Page 32 of 143
Thank you!
Questions?
Emily Irvine, Climate Program Manager
City of Charlottesville, Office of Sustainability
irvinees@charlottesville.gov
Page 33 of 143
Policy Briefing Summary
City Council
Regarding: Draft Urban Forest Management Plan
Staff Contact(s): Kristel Riddervold, Director of the Office of Sustainability, Steven Gaines,
Urban Forester, Robert Mathes, Management Specialist II Landscape,
Victoria Kanellopoulos, City Planner, Dan Frisbee, Water Resources
Specialist
Presenter: Kristel Riddervold, Director of the Office of Sustainability, Steven
Gaines, Urban Forester, Robert Mathes, Management Specialist II
Landscape
Date of Proposed
Action:
November 16, 2026
Issue
The City of Charlottesville is working with Eocene Environmental Group to develop an updated Urban
Forest Management Plan (‘UFMP’). The draft plan has been completed and shared with the community
for public comment. This presentation will provide Council with a briefing on the draft UFMP and allow
Council to ask questions and provide feedback.
Background / Rule
The core goal of this project is to update the current UFMP to integrate climate action goals and
equitable implementation, specifically targeting increased and equitable urban canopy coverage and
greater stewardship capacity. This approach includes both public and private properties.
The City’s initial UFMP was completed in 2009 and is part of the Comprehensive Plan in the Plan
Appendix. In 2024, the City was awarded grant funding through the Inflation Reduction Act via the U.S.
Department of Agriculture Forest Service to conduct a set of data collection activities and update the
UFMP. In November of 2024, the project kicked off with consulting support from the firm Eocene
Environmental Group. Although the federal grant was terminated in April 2025, the City identified
internal funds to work with Eocene to modify the project scope and continue the UFMP update. Both
the Urban Forest Assessment (the data component of the project) which was completed in 2025 and
community engagement that occurred during spring/summer 2026, including a dedicated project page
on Connect Charlottesville, informed the draft UFMP. Key findings from the Urban Forest Assessment
and community engagement are included in the attached presentation.
The draft 2026 UFMP is a comprehensive update of the City’s 2009 UFMP and reflects current
approaches toward environmental stewardship, expanded climate and sustainability goals, and
commitments to equity and inclusion. It also aims to integrate a range of current plans relevant to urban
forest management, such as the Climate Action Plan, Comprehensive Plan and forthcoming Climate
Adaptation and Resilience Plan. The updated UFMP is intended to be adopted as an amendment to
the City’s Comprehensive Plan, replacing the original 2009 version. Charlottesville’s draft plan is
complete and is currently being shared with the community for public review and comment via
the Urban Forest Management Plan page on Connect Charlottesville. The comment period will close
on November 30.
Analysis
The attached presentation provides an overview of the development of the UFMP, including history and
background of the project, key takeaways from the 2025 Urban Forest Assessment and 2026
Page 34 of 143
community engagement efforts, the plan vision, goals and objectives, and next steps.
The draft UFMP establishes a citywide urban forest canopy goal of 47%, with an emphasis on forest
quality and equitable canopy distribution. The Plan also has neighborhood-specific canopy goals,
which used existing canopy cover, heat vulnerability, socioeconomic factors, and available planting
space to prioritize Plan implementation. The Plan features five goals, each with supporting objectives
and actions, to be initiated over the next ten years. These Plan recommendations address prioritization
of resources to reach lower canopy and high heat neighborhoods first, increasing street tree stocking,
management of public land and the public urban forest, collaborating with community members and
partner organizations to support stewardship of private trees, expanding outreach and education, and
building and growing overall program effectiveness.
The strategies and actions in the UFMP are largely intended to be led by the City. However, since most
of the city’s urban forest and tree canopy are located on private property, collaborating and
coordinating with community members and partner organizations will be essential for successful plan
implementation.
The development of the UFMP was informed by multiple rounds of stakeholder meetings and
engagement to collect input from community members, partner organizations, City staff, and subject
matter experts. The Plan recommendations, including policy and regulatory opportunities, were
developed based on relevant elements of the 2009UFMP, local context, the most recent Tree
Commission 2025 State of the Forest report (including their set of recommendations), the Urban Forest
Assessment, lessons learned from peer communities, and community member input.
Financial Impact
There is no budget impact associated with this report.
Recommendation
This is an informational report, no formal action is needed.
Recommended Motion (if Applicable)
N/A
Attachments
1. UFMP_Council Policy Brief_ Attachment A_111626
2. UFMP_Council Preso_Attachement B_11162026
Page 35 of 143
/i255
/i255
/1/2/3/4/i255/6/7/i255/1/8/9/10/11/6/3/3/12/13/14/2/11/11/12/i255
/15/7/7/2/16/12/i255/6/7/i255/17/18/13/3/9/2/19/9/20/2/11/2/3/4/i255/21/i255/22/12/23/9/10/3/24/12/19/3/i255/6/7/i255/25/9/10/26/13/i255/27/i255/28/12/16/10/12/9/3/2/6/19/i255/i255
/i255
/i255
/1/29/30/31/i255/1/15/32/33/1/29/34/i255/35/15 /28/36/i255/17/37/17/17/29/15/33/i255
/33/6/14/12/24/20/12/10/i255/38/39/40/i255/41/42/41/39/i255
/i255
/i255
/i255
/43/3/3/9/16/8/24/12/19/3/i255/43/i255/44/i255/22/10/9/7/3/i255/32/10/20/9/19/i255/45/6/10/12/13/3/i255/46/9/19/9/47/12/24/12/19/3/i255/25/11/9/19/i255
/i255
/48/49/49/50/51/52/53/53/54/54/54/55/56/48/57/58/59/60/49/49/61/51/62/63/59/59/61/55/64/60/62/53/65/60/56/66/67/61/68/49/69/61/68/49/61/58/53/70/63/61/54/53/71/72/71/73/72/53/74/58/75/57/68/76/77/60/58/61/51/49/76
/78/57/68/57/64/61/67/61/68/49/76/79/59/57/68/80/65/58/57/81/49/76/i255/i255
Page 36 of 143
Charlottesville
Urban Forest
Management Plan
2026
Page 37 of 143
Agenda
Agenda
1. Project Summary
2. Elements of the Plan
3. What do we have?
4. What do we want?
5. How do we get there?
6. What are we doing now?
7. Next Steps
Page 38 of 143
Project Scope & Goals
• In 2024, the City was awarded grant funding through the Inflation Reduction Act via the US
Department of Agriculture Forest Service to support this project.
• Scope: A comprehensive review and update of the City’s 2009 Urban Forest Management
Plan (UFMP), including robust urban forest assessment.
• Reflect current approaches toward environmental stewardship, expanded
sustainability goals, and commitments to equity and inclusion.
• Integrate a range of current materials relevant to urban forest management (e.g.,
Climate Action Plan, Comprehensive Plan).
• Goals: Update the current urban forest management plan to integrate climate action
goals, specifically targeting increased and equitable urban canopy coverage and greater
stewardship capacity. This approach includes both public and private properties.
• Project recognizes the need and opportunity to tackle a more relevant, adaptive, and
inclusive approach to the management of our urban forest.
Page 39 of 143
Community Engagement
Page 40 of 143
Elements of the Urban Forest Management Plan
Elements of the Urban Forest Management Plan
• Introduction
• Urban Forest Assessment
• Program and Policy
• Vision, Goals, Objectives
• Action Framework
• Monitoring and Adaptive Management
• Appendices
Page 41 of 143
What do we have?
Page 42 of 143
Urban Forest
Assessment
Tree Canopy Analysis
• Spatial analysis and aerial photography to capture
insight about Charlottesville’s canopy.
Street Tree Study
• Inventory involving 200 randomly selected 200 street
segments.
• Trees were observed for species identification,
relative age, relative health, and structural defects.
Vegetation Assessment
• Stratified random sampling of public and private
properties
• Collected data on overstory and understory species
composition presence of invasive vegetation, and
relative age and health of the urban forest across the
City.
Components
Page 43 of 143
Urban Forest
Assessment
Tree Canopy Analysis
• 2025 canopy coverage is 46%; ~10% decline from 2006
• Neighborhood canopy cover varies widely; plantable space
also varies widely across neighborhoods
• Urban heat is directly linked to canopy cover
• Does not reflect health, diversity, or invasives
Street Tree Study
• Low number of street trees per centerline mile
• High rate of planting where possible
• Strong diversity
• Limited available space to plant large trees
Vegetation Assessment
• Invasive trees make up 6% of the urban forest
• Invasive plants detected in 82% of plots
• Private property trees contribute 83% of the canopy and
have more available space to plant medium and large trees
Key Takeaways
Page 44 of 143
Program
&
Policy
Context
• Status review of 2009 UFMP objectives
• Review of related City plans; identified
opportunities for alignment
• Regulatory framework for tree
conservation
• Program Benchmarking
• Staff and Community Partners Input
(SWOT Analysis)
• Community Survey
Page 45 of 143
What do we want?
Page 46 of 143
Every Charlottesville neighborhood has
a healthy, resilient tree canopy that
provides environmental, health, and
economic benefits to its neighbors and
visitors. The City, its partners, and the
community work together across public
and private land to protect, grow, and
sustain the urban forest in the face of a
changing climate.
Vision Statement –
Charlottesville’s
Urban Forest
Page 47 of 143
Urban Forest Canopy Goals
• 10-year goal: 47% with an emphasis on
avoiding loss and on forest quality
• 2050 goal: 50%
• Neighborhood specific goals based on
planting availability
Page 48 of 143
Goal 1:
Grow & Diversify Charlottesville’s
Trees and Forests
• Objective 1.1: Direct a majority of tree planting investments
to neighborhoods identified as highest priority through the
UFMP planting prioritization model, which accounts for
existing canopy cover, heat vulnerability, stormwater value,
socioeconomic factors, and available planting space.
• Objective 1.2: Increase street tree stocking citywide from
the current 66% toward the recommended 75-80%
minimum, concentrating new plantings in the largest open
sites within priority neighborhoods.
• Objective 1.3: Diversify species composition in new
plantings so that no single species, genus, or family
dominates the canopy, prioritizing climate-ready native
species chosen for heat, pest, and drought resilience.
Management
Plan Goals
Page 49 of 143
Goal 2:
Conserve & Manage the Public Urban Forest
• Objective 2.1: Lead by example on City-managed land,
meeting the same standards the City asks of private
development and actively restoring canopy and native forest.
• Objective 2.2: Pursue acquisition of forested or
environmentally significant private parcels to prevent canopy
loss on properties that could otherwise be subject to future
development, sale, or conversion.
• Objective 2.3: Manage City trees on a planned and proactive
basis, guided by consistent standards for inspection,
maintenance, removal, and planting.
• Objective 2.4: Control invasive species on City-owned lands
and rights-of-way, prioritizing areas where removal delivers the
greatest canopy and environmental benefits.
• Objective 2.5: Treat trees removed from City land as a
resource rather than waste.
Management
Plan Goals
Page 50 of 143
Goal 3:
Support Stewardship of Private Trees & Forests
• Objective 3.1: Increase participation in existing
programs and expand technical and
financial assistance for private property tree
planting, preservation, and care.
• Objective 3.2: Increase tree canopy on private
property through collaboration with nonprofit
partners and private property owners. Management
Plan Goals
Page 51 of 143
Goal 4:
Expand Communication, Outreach,
& Engagement
• Objective 4.1: Build understanding of urban forestry's
role among City decision-makers.
• Objective 4.2: Increase public awareness of urban forestry
programs and how to engage with them.
• Objective 4.3: Deliver place-based education and
engagement across Charlottesville’s neighborhoods.
• Objective 4.4: Work together with City staff, nonprofit
partners, and community groups like CCS to make outreach
more effective and avoid repeating efforts.
• Objective 4.5: Coordinate with the green industry in
Charlottesville to enhance cooperation among nurseries,
contractors, arborists, utility providers, and neighboring
jurisdictions, such as Albemarle County.
Management
Plan Goals
Page 52 of 143
Goal 5:
Build & Grow Program Effectiveness
• Objective 5.1: Align the staffing, data, and
funding resources required to implement and sustain the UFMP.
• Objective 5.2: Manage tree risk on City property and rights-of-way
through a documented approach to risk assessment, response,
and storm coordination.
• Objective 5.3: Establish a standing interdepartmental coordination
structure that brings Urban Forestry, Public Works,
Utilities, and Neighborhood Development Services into regular
dialogue on tree-related decisions to help prevent avoidable tree
loss.
• Objective 5.4: Build the training, knowledge, and skill base of
those who care for Charlottesville’s trees, from current City staff to
people entering the field, including students, veterans, and non-
traditional candidates.
• Objective 5.5: Identify and engage in state and local policy
opportunities
• Objective 5.6: Develop individual management plans for
neighborhoods, parks, and schools
Management
Plan Goals
Management
Plan Goals
Page 53 of 143
How do we get there?
Page 54 of 143
Action
Framework
• Planting Investment Priorities
• Implementation Phasing
• Policy and Regulatory
Recommendations
Page 55 of 143
Are we getting what we want?
Page 56 of 143
Monitoring & Adaptive Management
• Is the canopy growing where it is needed most?
• Are our streets more tree-lined?
• Is our tree population getting more varied and resilient?
• Is the City managing trees and risk on a schedule instead of reacting to
problems
• Are we growing and caring for canopy on City land?
• Is more forest being protected?
• Are neighbors planting and caring for trees on their own property?
• Are partners and the community taking part?
• Does the program have the people it needs?
• Is the City ready to use what the State allows?
Page 57 of 143
What are we doing now?
Page 58 of 143
• Updating and upgrading Comprehensive Tree List –
should improve likelihood of getting the right tree
in the right place.
• Updating Tree Preservation Guide (BMPs)
• Creating a user-friendly “pocket guide” for tree
preservation and development
• Opportunity to review and update, as needed, the
Tree and Landscaping Guide
• Increased monitoring and enforcement of tree
related zoning codes (regarding preservation and
tree installations) aiming for increased tree
survival.
Actions Underway
Page 59 of 143
2025 State of the Forest
2025 State
of the Forest
Tree Commission Recommendations
Preserving Downtown Mall Trees – Downtown Mall Tree
Management Plan
• Support both grant funding and annual city budgeting in order to finance
all phases of the Downtown Mall Tree Management Plan
The Charlottesville Invasive Plant Partnership: Invasive
Control on Private Properties
• Explore the provision of incentives and/or penalties to check the
rampant growth of tree-killing invasive vines on property property
• Consider an ordinance to address the overgrowth of invasive vines
analogous to the existing ordinance that prohibits the overgrowth of tall
weeds on private properties (Code of Ordinance, section 5-149)
Canopy Collective:Advocating Opportunistic and Innovative
Tree Planting on Public Land
• Consider proposals for alternative tree planting installations on
publicly-owned parcels in low-canopy neighborhoods and downtown
areas to pilot best practices and enhance the social and ecological
value of publicly-owned land
UFMP Goal 2
UFMP Goal 3
UFMP Goal 2
Page 60 of 143
Tree Commission Recommendations
Engagement with the City to Support Tree Preservation
Update City site plan guidance to facilitate preservation of mature trees.
• Engage a broad range of public and private stakeholders in steps to
preserve mature trees on public and private lands.
• Document successful efforts to preserve trees in concert with site
development.
Vulnerable Parcels
Emphasize and potentially expand key restrictions on site plan
development to ensure protection of critical slopes, urban forest, and
hydrological systems.
• Consider a zoning change to add a design overlay district for these
ecologically sensitive parcels.
• Evaluate parcels with critical slopes, urban forest connections, and/or
floodplains for potential City acquisition as both parkland/public space
and green infrastructure investments, in support of Comprehensive
Plan Goal 13.
UFMP
Goals 3 & 5
UFMP Goal 3
2025 State
of the Forest
Page 61 of 143
Next Steps
Note: Goal is for plan adoption as an amendment to the Comprehensive Plan
Page 62 of 143
Thank You
Page 63 of 143
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
OBSERVING
RESTORATIVE JUSTICE WEEK
November 15-21, 2026
WHEREAS Restorative Justice Week begins annually every third Sunday of
November, and aims to recognize the power and effect of justice based on the
restoration of human connection in lieu of retributive and punitive proceedings;
and
WHEREAS restorative justice is an internationally recognized approach for
responding to crime and incidents of harm that provides the opportunity for
dialogue between those who have experienced harm, the harm perpetrators, and
their community to address the harm and meet the needs of those involved; and
WHEREAS Central Virginia Community Justice, serving Charlottesville and
Albemarle, was established in 2022 to provide space for those involved in harm
to lead their own accountability and healing through restorative justice; and
WHEREAS Central Virginia Community Justice has supported over 200
individuals through the restorative justice process to address situations of harm
in our communities and our schools; and
WHEREAS Restorative Justice Week serves as an opportunity for residents to
reflect on how our community can find growth, healing, and accountability in
restorative approaches to conflict and harm;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIMED that the Charlottesville City
Council does hereby support and observe Restorative Justice Week,
November 15-21, 2026, to promote safety and well-being for all City residents
in their communities and schools by encouraging the learning and practicing of
restorative skills of human connection and healing as a means of attaining justice.
Signed and sealed the 16th day of November 2026.
___________________________
Juandiego Wade, Mayor
___________________________
Kyna Thomas, Clerk
Page 64 of 143
City Council Meeting Minutes – August 3, 2026
CHARLOTTESVILLE CITY COUNCIL MEETING MINUTES
August 3, 2026 at 4:00 PM
Council Chamber
The Charlottesville City Council met on Monday, August 3, 2026, Vice Mayor Natalie Oschrin presiding.
The meeting was called to order, and Clerk of Council Kyna Thomas called the roll, noting the following
councilors present: Vice Mayor Natalie Oschrin and Councilors Jen Fleisher and Lloyd Snook. Mayor
Juandiego Wade gave prior notice of his absence, and Councilor Payne arrived as the first report began.
On motion by Fleisher, seconded by Snook, Council by a 3-0 vote approved the meeting agenda
(Ayes: Fleisher, Oschrin, Snook; Noes: none; Absent: Payne, Wade).
REPORTS
1. REPORT: ANCHOR FY 26 Annual Report
Hunter Smith, Deputy Director of Human Services, presented the ANCHOR Annual Report for FY2026.
The ANCHOR (Assisting with Navigation, Crisis Help, and Outreach Resources) Co-Response Team is a
collaborative group of law enforcement officers, firefighters, medical professionals, and mental health
professionals who work together to respond to calls involving individuals experiencing behavioral health
crises. The team aims to de-escalate situations, assess needs, and connect people with appropriate services
instead of resorting to arrest when possible. Launched in July 2024, ANCHOR’s goals are to connect
community members to stabilizing provider/s for long support and prevention services and engage in
harm-reduction efforts. The Team, responding to calls for service that come into our community's 9-1-1
system, works to de-escalate and support residents who are in crisis to help provide support in the
moment and prevent alternative options for resolution.
Notable achievements in year two of the ANCHOR Co-Response Team operation included successfully
implementing a client record keeping system which allows team members to access up-to-date
information on client interactions. It also provides real-time data that can be shared community wide. The
team also attended the annual International Co-Responders Conference in Houston, Texas, to learn from
experts and peers in this emerging field. ANCHOR operates Monday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. to
6:00 p.m. The ANCHOR Team had 420 encounters and supported 241 unique clients, about 67% of
encounters which were live responses to 911 calls for service, and about 20% were related to follow-up
interactions post-incident.
Members of the ANCHOR team answered questions from City Council.
2. REPORT: Homeless Services Update
Assistant City Manager Samuel Roman provided an update of outreach activity over the past two weeks
to connect individuals at the Rivanna encampment with resources and to address logistical issues such as
cleanup of trash, and servicing of the dumpster, handwashing stations and portable restrooms. The City
continues to take the lead on emergency shelter operations while collaborating with community partners
and continuing the goal of opening 2000 Holiday Drive with a sustainable operating plan as close as
possible to September 1, 2026. The internal communications team solidified a communications and
engagement plan for businesses near Holiday Drive and City staff conducted business outreach visits
today. Several online resources were created and are being updated to keep the public informed.
Misty Graves, Director of Human Services, and Councilor Jen Fleisher, who serve on the engagement
team provided additional information to answer questions from Council. City Manager Samuel Sanders,
Page 65 of 143
City Council Meeting Minutes – August 3, 2026
Jr., explained how funding of $7 Million appropriated by the State of Virginia budget will be placed on an
upcoming City Council agenda for consideration of making a $3 Million contribution to the Salvation
Army Center of Hope capital campaign, and leaving $4 Million with the City for transitional housing and
workforce solutions for individuals who are unhoused.
CLOSED MEETING
On motion by Payne, seconded by Snook, Council voted 4-0 to meet in closed session as
authorized by the Virginia Freedom of Information Act, as follows:
1. Pursuant to Virginia Code Section 2.2-3711(A)(8) for consultation with legal counsel employed or
retained by a public body regarding specific legal matters requiring the provision of legal advice by
such counsel, specifically, interlocal agreements pertaining to natural gas and water infrastructure.
On motion by Payne, seconded by Fleisher, Council certified by the following vote: 4-0 (Ayes:
Fleisher, Oschrin, Payne, Snook; Noes: none; Absent: Wade), that to the best of each Council member’s
knowledge only public business matters lawfully exempted from the open meeting requirements of the
Virginia Freedom of Information Act and identified in the Motion convening the closed session were
heard, discussed or considered in the closed session.
BUSINESS SESSION
City Council began the business meeting by observing a moment of silence.
ANNOUNCEMENTS
Councilor Snook announced The Triangle of Hope project, of which three Charlottesville teenagers are
participating. On Saturday, August 8 the showing of "Jonathan Daniels: " at Trinity Episcopal Church He
provided background on each announcement.
Councilor Fleisher announced Loop de Ville on September 27, 2026.
Vice Mayor Oschrin announced the August 9 community walk in Fifeville, and the August 13 pop-up
workshop about a traffic-calming proposal in Fifeville.
COMMUNITY MATTERS
1. Donnas Chambers, Free Bridge, spoke in opposition to the proposed shelter at Holiday Drive, and
about the unhoused community living near Free Bridge, requesting help besides the proposed
shelter for unhoused neighbors.
2. James McKinley-Oakes, city resident, spoke in support of the restoration of the historical marker at
0 Park Street and Jefferson Street memorializing the auction block for enslaved people. He asked
that an item be placed on the August 17 City Council meeting agenda for a vote.
3. Andrew Gray, Albemarle County resident, spoke about the need to expand the housing supply to
help neighbors facing homelessness and improve public safety.
4. Jamie Knorr, Co-founder of Village School, spoke in support of restoring Court Square signage
memorializing the enslavement auction block, so that passersby can feel the full weight of history.
5. Isis Neumann, spoke about the City's role and approach to caring for people at the encampment
near the Rivanna River. She expressed that moving campers by September 1 would place people in
danger.
6. Heidi Dhivya Berthoud, city resident speaking for the Court Square Enslavement Memorial Group,
Page 66 of 143
City Council Meeting Minutes – August 3, 2026
spoke in support of the restoration of the enslavement auction block historical marker at 0 Park
Street and Jefferson Street.
7. Josh Epstein, city resident, spoke about the treatment of the unhoused community in
Charlottesville, particularly inhabitants of the Rivanna/Free Bridge encampment who do not want to
move into the emergency shelter on Holiday Drive. He suggested building housing.
8. Jennifer Grant, resident at the Free Bridge encampment, requested answers to questions and
concerns expressed by herself and others who are considering moving to the Holiday Drive shelter.
She requested that those working on the relocation effort listen to campers and provide answers.
9. Donna Tietjen, city resident, spoke about trauma in many people experiencing homelessness.
Regarding city outreach, she expressed the need for a trauma-informed response and relationship
building.
10. Mike Henrietta, city resident, spoke in support of the restoration of the historical marker in Court
Square memorializing the auction block for enslaved people. He stated that his group will cover the
cost.
11. Ann Cofflin, criminal law professor at UVA, spoke about the criminalization of people
experiencing homelessness. She stated that the city is not providing enough notice to people before
taking action to move them from the Rivanna encampment.
12. Genevieve Keller, city resident speaking for Preservation Piedmont, thanked Council for
supporting the 801 West Street IPP (Individually Protected Property) item on the Consent Agenda,
and she spoke about the gutting of Section 106 of National Historic Preservation Act of 1966,
specifically referring to the razing of Vinegar Hill, negatively impacting Black and Brown
neighbors. She stated that Section 106 is currently being rewritten without a consultative process.
13. Raimi Liebel, city resident, spoke about ineffective outreach efforts with the unhoused community
at Free Bridge. She stated that Holiday Drive will not be a viable option for people in need of
housing, by the September 1, 2026 deadline. She expressed a need for mental health resources.
14. Joshua Ballou, city resident, spoke about the encampment at the Rivanna Trail, the lack of security
provided by the installed cameras, and about unkept promises.
CONSENT AGENDA
Clerk Thomas read the following Consent Agenda items into the record, and on motion by Payne, seconded
by Snook, Council unanimously adopted the Consent Agenda (Ayes: Fleisher, Oschrin, Payne, Snook;
Noes: none; Absent: Wade).
3. MINUTES: May 4, 2026 regular meeting
4. RESOLUTION appropriating funds for the Virginia Department of Education Special Nutrition
Program Summer Food Service Program - $40,000 (2nd reading)
RESOLUTION
Appropriating up to $40,000.00 from the Virginia Department of Education Special Nutrition
Program to Provide Free Meals to Children at Select After-school Centers
WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville (“City”), through the Department of Parks & Recreation, has
received approval for reimbursement up to $40,000.00 from the Virginia Department of Education
Special Nutrition Program to provide free meals to children attending select drop-in after-school
centers; and
WHEREAS, the grant award period spans June 15, 2026, through October 31, 2026;
Page 67 of 143
City Council Meeting Minutes – August 3, 2026
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville (“City
Council”) that the sum of $40,000.00 received from the Virginia Department of Education Special
Nutrition Program is hereby appropriated in the following manner:
Revenues $40,000.00
Fund: 209 Internal Order: 1900678 G/L: 430120
Expenditures $40,000.00
Fund: 209 Internal Order: 1900678 G/L: 530670
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that this appropriation is conditioned upon the receipt of $40,000.00
from the Virginia Department of Education Special Nutrition Program.
5. ORDINANCE amending and reenacting Chapter 2, Article XV of the Code of the City of
Charlottesville, the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance (2nd reading)
AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT SECTION 2-437.2 OF THE CODE OF THE
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE TO PERMIT THE CITY MANAGER OR THEIR
DESIGNEE TO CONTRACT WITH THIRD PARTIES IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES
TO CONDUCT SPECIFIED TASKS ON BEHALF OF THE OFFICE OF HUMAN RIGHTS
AND TO MAKE OTHER MINOR CHANGES
6. RESOLUTION Allocating Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund Grant Program Funding for
Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority South First Street Phase Two in the
Amount of $425,000 (2nd reading)
RESOLUTION
Allocating Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund Grant Program Funding for Charlottesville
Redevelopment and Housing Authority South First Street Phase Two in the Amount of $425,000
WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, established the Charlottesville Affordable Housing
Fund (“CAHF”) Grant Program to provide financial support for community agency programs aiding in
affordable housing and homelessness relief.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia,
that the sum of $425,000 be allocated from previously appropriated funds in the CAHF under Fund
426 Project: CP-084 to the Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority for South First
Street Phase Two project.
7. ORDINANCE: 801 West Street; Zoning Text Amendment (Pl-26-0043), Designation of
Individually Protected Property (2nd reading)
ORDINANCE AMENDING AND REENACTING CHAPTER 34 (DEVELOPMENT CODE)
OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA, TO DESIGNATE 801
WEST STREET (TMP 310042000) AS AN INDIVIDUALLY PROTECTED PROPERTY
8. ORDINANCE: 801 West Street: Zoning Map Amendment (Pl-26-0042), Designation of
Individually Protected Property (2nd reading)
ORDINANCE AMENDING AND REENACTING THE ZONING MAP INCORPORATED
WITHIN CHAPTER 34 OF THE CODE OF DEVELOPMENT OF THE CITY OF
Page 68 of 143
City Council Meeting Minutes – August 3, 2026
CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA, TO DESIGNATE 801 WEST STREET (TMP 310042000)
AS AN INDIVIDUALLY PROTECTED PROPERTY
9. RESOLUTION to Authorize $204,017 in additional funds for the Albemarle Charlottesville
Regional Jail (layover)
10. RESOLUTION to appropriate Albemarle County Human Services funding to the Department of
Human Services for the Community Attention Youth Internship Program for $63,000 (layover)
11. RESOLUTION to appropriate additional $45,330.18 from the Virginia Department of Housing and
Community Development, Housing Opportunities for Persons with AIDS/HIV grant 25-HOPWA-303
(layover)
12. RESOLUTION for Compromise of Claim: Water and Wastewater Leak Credit for $13,074.68 for
CRHA.
RESOLUTION
Approval of a Compromise of Claim in the Form of a Leak Credit of $13,074.68 for Water and
Wastewater Charges to the Utility Account of “CRHA”
WHEREAS, the Director of Finance, City Attorney, and City Manager concur that circumstances
associated with a leak at 801 Harris St. warrant a credit in the amount of $13,074.68 for water and
wastewater charges, in accordance with City Code Sec. 11-132(4), City Council has the authority to
grant such a compromise of claim;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia,
that the Director of Finance is hereby authorized to apply a credit of $13,074.68 to the utility account
of “CRHA”.
CITY MANAGER REPORT
Budget Director Krisy Hammill confirmed the City received the highest credit ratings possible from
Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s Investors Services. Moody’s has rated Charlottesville “Aaa” since 1973
and Standard & Poor’s has rated “AAA” since 1964. Ms. Hammill listed projects to be bonded by Series
2026 Bonds.
Deputy City Manager James Freas stated that the city continues to be in a drought watch status, and he
requested that residents conserve water where possible to prevent restrictions should it be necessary to
elevate to a drought warning.
City Manager Samuel Sanders, Jr., announced several community events, including back-to-school events
and the Soul of Cville Festival.
ACTION ITEMS
13. PUBLIC HEARING and RESOLUTION for Approving a Lease of City-Owned Property
located at 708 Page Street and a portion of City-Owned Property located at 210 8th Street NW
to City of Promise, Inc.
Brenda Kelley, Downtown Strategy Manager, asked for approval of a lease agreement for City of
Promise, for the use of City-owned property located at 708 Page Street and a portion of City-owned
property located at 210 8th Street NW.
Page 69 of 143
City Council Meeting Minutes – August 3, 2026
Vice Mayor Oschrin opened the public hearing, and with no speakers coming forward, the public hearing
was closed.
On motion by Fleisher, seconded by Snook, Council by a vote of 4-0 (Ayes: Fleisher, Oschrin,
Payne, Snook; Noes: none; Absent: Wade) approved the following resolution:
RESOLUTION
Authorizing the Execution of a New Lease Agreement for City-owned Property Located at 708 Page
Street and a Portion of Property Located at 210 8th Street NW to City of Promise, Inc. (“COP”)
WHEREAS, COP desires to lease a certain City-owned property for a term of one (1) year, and with
option for renewal of additional terms, and the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia (“City
Council”), has considered the terms of the proposed new Lease Agreement, and has conducted a
public hearing in accordance with the requirements of Virginia Code § 15.2-1800(B). NOW,
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by City Council, that the new Lease Agreement for the use of
City-owned property located at 708 Page Street and a portion of property located at 210 8th Street
NW, Charlottesville, Virginia, to COP, presented to City Council this same date for consideration, is
hereby APPROVED, and the City Manager is hereby authorized to execute the newly approved Lease
Agreement on behalf of City Council.
14. RESOLUTION Authorizing Agreement with Charlottesville-Albemarle Airport Authority for
Provision of Legal Services by City Attorney's Office
City Attorney John Maddux presented the request to approve an Agreement for Legal Services between
the City of Charlottesville and the Charlottesville-Albemarle Airport Authority. The City Attorney’s
Office has provided legal services to the Airport Authority for many years. Based on the records currently
available, however, that arrangement does not appear to have been formalized in a written agreement. In
addition, the compensation paid to the City for those services has not been updated in many years, if ever.
The proposed agreement formalizes the existing relationship and establishes the scope of services,
compensation, responsibilities of the parties, and procedures for addressing conflicts of interest, outside
counsel, amendments, and termination.
The agreement provides a clear and current framework for a longstanding relationship between the City
Attorney’s Office and the Airport Authority. It defines the legal services included within the arrangement
and updates the compensation paid to the City to better reflect the scope and value of those services.
Under the agreement, the City Attorney’s Office will provide general legal services concerning matters
such as governance, public meetings and records, contracts, procurement, leases, real estate, employment,
regulatory compliance, negotiations, claims, and routine operational matters. The agreement does not
require the City to assign a particular attorney or provide a dedicated attorney to the Authority. The City
Attorney will retain responsibility for assigning personnel and allocating office resources, and Authority
matters will not take priority over City matters.
Certain services are excluded from the annual fee, including litigation, bond counsel and public-finance
services, specialized federal aviation work, complex labor or employment matters, and other matters
requiring specialized outside expertise. The Authority will be responsible for retaining and paying outside
counsel when necessary. The agreement also addresses potential conflicts between the City and the
Authority.
The City Attorney’s Office will not represent the Authority in a matter adverse to the City and may
Page 70 of 143
City Council Meeting Minutes – August 3, 2026
decline, limit, or withdraw from representation when required by law or applicable professional
obligations. This arrangement allows the Authority to continue benefiting from the City Attorney’s
Office’s institutional knowledge while protecting the City’s ability to manage staffing, workload,
conflicts, and outside-counsel needs.
On motion by Payne, seconded by Fleisher, Council by a vote of 4-0 (Ayes: Fleisher, Oschrin,
Payne, Snook; Noes: none; Absent: Wade) approved the following resolution:
RESOLUTION
Approving an Agreement for Legal Services Between the City of Charlottesville and the
Charlottesville-Albemarle Airport
WHEREAS, Charlottesville City Attorney’s Office currently provides legal services to the
Charlottesville-Albemarle Airport Authority; and
WHEREAS, the City and the Authority desire to formalize that arrangement and establish the
scope of services to be provided, the compensation to be paid to the City, and the other terms
governing the representation; and
WHEREAS, City Council finds that continuation of this arrangement is in the best interests of the
City and the Authority;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia,
1. The Agreement for Legal Services between the City of Charlottesville and the
Charlottesville-Albemarle Airport Authority is hereby approved in substantially the form
presented to City Council.
2. The Mayor is authorized to execute the Agreement on behalf of the City, following
approval as to form by the City Attorney, with such minor or technical revisions as the City
Attorney determines are necessary and consistent with this Resolution.
3. The Agreement shall be effective as of July 1, 2026, as provided in the Agreement, and City
Council hereby ratifies the continuation of legal services provided to the Authority on and after
that date pending execution of the Agreement.
15. RESOLUTION to Authorize the Allocation of Up To $4 Million for Emergency Sheltering
Services and Direct to Housing Initiatives in Collaboration with the Department of Human
Services
Samuel Sanders, Jr., City Manager, presented a request for appropriation of funds from the Capital
Improvement Program (CIP) Contingency Fund to address one-time expenditures for homeless
intervention services to include emergency sheltering and direct-to-housing supports. He stated that
CASS (Central Arizona Shelter Services) has been identified as the entity to manage the low barrier
shelter based on their experience and expertise to tailor a program to Charlottesville's needs; however, no
contract has been issued.
Councilor Payne requested a future work session to review mental health resources, including Region Ten.
On motion by Fleisher, seconded by Payne, Council by a vote of 4-0 (Ayes: Fleisher, Oschrin,
Payne, Snook; Noes: none; Absent: Wade) approved the following Resolution, waiving the second
reading:
Page 71 of 143
City Council Meeting Minutes – August 3, 2026
RESOLUTION
To Appropriate $4,000,000 from the Capital Improvement Program Contingency Fund to be
used for Homeless Intervention Services to include Emergency Sheltering and Direct to
Housing Supports
WHEREAS per the City of Charlottesville’s financial policy, year-end surpluses from the City’s
General Fund are transferred to the CIP contingency Fund where they accumulate until appropriated
by the City Council for expenditure; and
WHEREAS the City Manager has made a recommendation and request to allocate a portion of the
contingency funds to address one-time expenditures that have not previously been appropriated; and
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia,
that the sum of $4,000,000 is hereby allocated from currently appropriated funds in the CIP
Contingency Fund to be used for homeless intervention services to include emergency sheltering and
direct to housing supports.:
Transfer from:
$4,000,000 Fund: 426 WBS Element: CP-080 GL Code: 599999
Transfer to:
$4,000,000 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01163 GL Code: 599999
COMMUNITY MATTERS (2)
• Lydia Brunk, county resident, asked about Council and staff motivations toward community members
who come before them to share their needs. She stated that unhoused people are asking to not be
displaced.
• Flores, county resident, spoke about helping people who live at the Free Bridge encampment, and
asked about the plan that will be in place for unhoused individuals should the shelter not be ready by the
September 1 deadline to move from the encampment. They asked for transparency, truthfulness, and
creating better relationships.
• Cooke Harvey, city resident, stated that a two-party political system prevents forward movement as a
united people.
• Lizzy M, city resident, requested that Council give housing, possibly tiny house villages, to people
instead of paying a company to run a shelter.
• Laura Sirgany, city resident, expressed concerns about the September 1 deadline for moving from the
Free Bridge/Rivanna encampment. She questioned how the information gathered from a community
needs assessment will be used.
ADJOURNMENT
On motion by Snook, seconded by Fleisher, Council by acclamation adjourned the meeting at 8:45 p.m.
BY Order of City Council BY Kyna Thomas, Clerk of Council
Page 72 of 143
Policy Briefing Summary
City Council
Regarding: Resolution to Appropriate funds from the Sentara Foundation to the
Department of Human Services for the Westhaven CARES Center -
$7,000 (2nd reading)
Staff Contact(s): Reginald Allen, Human Services Planner, Taylor Harvey-Ryan, Grants
Program Manager
Presenter: Reginald Allen, Human Services Planner
Date of Proposed
Action:
November 16, 2026
Issue
The City of Charlottesville’s Department of Human Services has been awarded a $7,000 Sentara
Cares grant to support the Westhaven Food Pantry that needs to be appropriated.
Background / Rule
The City of Charlottesville’s Department of Human Services has been awarded a $7,000 Sentara
Cares grant to support the Westhaven Food Pantry. Sentara Cares provides competitive grant
funding to eligible organizations for programs that advance community health and well-being.
The award aligns with Sentara’s food access funding priority, which promotes equitable access to
nutritious and culturally relevant food through food pantries, community partnerships, and
initiatives that reduce barriers to food access. Grant funds will support the Westhaven Food
Pantry in addressing food insecurity and improving food access for residents.
Analysis
Demand for services at the Westhaven CARES Center continues to grow. Based on anticipated
operating expenses and community needs, the Center identified a projected funding shortfall of
approximately $7,000. This shortfall was the primary basis for seeking Sentara Cares funding. The
$7,000 grant will help sustain pantry operations, maintain food inventory, and ensure consistent
food assistance for residents.
The Center’s monthly food pantry provides nutritious food and household essentials to at least 20
households, reaching an estimated 40 residents, including children. The Center also administers
the monthly First Wednesday Gift Card Program with assistance from the Emergency Food
Network, distributing approximately 30 gift cards valued at $50 each to households experiencing
financial hardship.
Over the past year, the Center has expanded its capacity through the acquisition of a deep freezer
and the creation of a walk-in pantry space. These improvements have increased food storage
capacity, expanded the variety of available foods, and improved distribution efficiency.
Page 73 of 143
The program supports priorities identified in the regional MAP to Health Community Health
Assessment by addressing food access and the social drivers of health. Grant funding will help
ensure the continued availability of these services and strengthen the Center’s role as a
community resource supporting families and improving quality of life in Westhaven and
surrounding neighborhoods.
Financial Impact
The $7,000 Sentara Cares grant will address the projected funding shortfall for the Westhaven
Food Pantry, support pantry operations, and maintain food inventory.
The funding will support community health by maintaining access to nutritious food for residents
experiencing food insecurity. Food and household assistance will also help reduce household
expenses, allowing residents to allocate limited financial resources toward housing, utilities,
transportation, medication, and other essential needs.
Recommendation
Staff recommends that City Council approve the appropriation of $7,000 in Sentara Cares grant
funds to support the Westhaven Food Pantry’s operations and continued provision of food
assistance to residents.
Recommended Motion (if Applicable)
Motion to approve the resolution to appropriate $7,000 in Sentara Cares grant funds to support
the Westhaven Food Pantry.
Attachments
1. West Haven Memo12
Page 74 of 143
RESOLUTION
TO APPROPRIATE $7000.00 IN GRANT FUNDING FROM SENTARA HEALTH FOR
WESTHAVEN’S FOOD PANTRY
WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville, through the Department of Human Services,
has received funding to support Westhaven’s food pantry from Sentara Health
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville
that the sum of $7000.00 is hereby appropriated in the following manner:
Revenue - $7000.00
$7000.00 Fund: 210 Order: 1900757 G/L Account: 451022
Expenditures - $7000.00
$7000.00 Fund: 210 Order: 1900757 G/L Account: 599999
Be it further resolved that this appropriation is subject to the receipt of $7000.00
from Sentara Health. All funds hereby appropriated shall be accounted for and expended
in accordance with the requirements of the Sentara Health Grant.
Page 75 of 143
Policy Briefing Summary
City Council
Regarding: Consideration of Amendments to the Code of the City of
Charlottesville, Chapter 19 - Personnel (1 of 2 readings)
Staff Contact(s): Joseph Gilkerson, Director of Human Resources, Shelia Weimer, Deputy
City Attorney
Presenter: Joseph Gilkerson, Director of Human Resources
Date of Proposed
Action:
November 16, 2026
Issue
The current language in Chapter 19 of the City Code lacks sufficient clarity regarding its intended application
and administration. The proposed amendments are designed to clarify administrative responsibilities,
strengthen reporting and accountability requirements, and establish a formal review process for determining
eligibility for retirement benefits. These revisions will improve consistency, transparency, and the effective
administration of retirement benefit provisions.
Background / Rule
Analysis
These amendments provide better clarity regarding Commission membership and create a structured
administrative review process that helps ensure procedural compliance while maintaining the
Retirement Commission's independence and final authority in retirement benefit eligibility matters.
Financial Impact
No Financial Impact
Recommendation
Recommended Motion (if Applicable)
Attachments
1. Memo to CM for Proposed Ch 19 Changes
2. ORD_Ch19
3. Chapter 19 Article III IV V revisions and redlines CLEAN
Page 76 of 143
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
To be a place where everyone thrives
TO: Sam Sanders, Charlottesville City Manager
FROM: Joseph Gilkerson, Director of Human Resources
DATE: 10/29/2026
SUBJECT: Summary of Proposed Amendments to Chapter 19
The proposed amendments to Chapter 19 are intended to clarify administrative responsibilities,
strengthen reporting requirements, and establish a formal review process for retirement benefit
eligibility determinations.
Key Changes
1. Retirement Commission Membership (Sec. 19-58)
The amendment clarifies that Commission members who serve by virtue of their City position, such
as the Human Resources Director, Finance Director, or Treasurer, will serve only while holding that
position. Their Commission membership automatically ends when they leave the position. The
amendment also affirms that the City Manager may appoint and replace their designee to the
Commission at their discretion.
2. Annual Reporting to City Council (Sec. 19-65)
The revised reporting requirements update the Commission's annual report to City Council by
focusing on actuarial and financial information, including:
• Biennial actuarial valuation results;
• Summary financial and investment performance data, including cash receipts, investment
income, and ending asset balances.
The amendment allows detailed investment and portfolio reports to be incorporated by reference,
while maintaining Council's access to supporting financial records through the City Treasurer upon
request.
Page 77 of 143
2
3. Administrative Oversight of Eligibility Determinations (Sec. 19-68)
The proposed section establishes a formal process for retirement benefit eligibility determinations
and administrative review. The amendment establishes defined timelines and clear definitions for
business days, reasonable review periods, and supporting documentation requirements.
Key changes include:
• The Retirement Commission retains sole authority to determine eligibility for retirement
benefits and will render a written initial determination within thirty (30) business days of its
review.
• Applicants receiving an adverse decision may request administrative oversight by the City
Manager within 10 business days;
• The City Manager's review is limited to determining whether the Commission acted in
accordance with the ordinance and applicable law, with a determination within thirty (30)
business days (or a reasonably agreed upon extension of time).
• The City Manager may not reweigh evidence, make factual determinations, or substitute
judgment regarding eligibility.
• If procedural or legal concerns exist, the City Manager may remand the matter to the
Commission for reconsideration.
• The Retirement Commission retains final authority over all eligibility determinations,
including decisions following remand.
4. Proposed Amendments to Article V – Definitions (Section 19-91)
The proposed amendments to Section 19-91 update and clarify several key retirement plan definitions
to improve consistency and administrative efficiency.
The revisions establish:
• Clear hierarchy for beneficiary payments when no beneficiary designation is on file;
• Update the definition of creditable compensation;
• Clarify the calculation of creditable service for part-time employees by prorating service for
benefit calculations while preserving full vesting credit;
The amendments also updates the definition of “employee” to expressly include regular part-time
employees working at least 20 hours per week, while continuing to exclude temporary, seasonal, and
short-term employees.
Page 78 of 143
3
5. Proposed Amendment to Participation in Defined Contribution Plans (Section 19-94)
The proposed amendment to Section 19-94 gives the City Manager discretion to determine the City's
annual contribution amount to the 401(a) plan.
6. Proposed Amendment to Service Retirement (Section 19-95(f))
The proposed amendment to Section 19-95(f) clarifies that pension benefits will begin only after the
eligible former employees submits written notice electing to commence benefits upon reaching
normal retirement eligibility.
7. Proposed Amendments to Long-Term Disability and Survivor Benefits Provisions (Section
19-102.1)
The revision to Section 19-102.1 provides that employees receiving long-term disability benefits will
continue to accrue creditable service for retirement eligibility and benefit calculation purposes,
provided they continue making any applicable member contributions (if any) based on their regular
rate of pay.
8. Proposed Amendments to Survivor Benefits Provisions (Section 19-105)
The amendment to Section 19-105 establishes a clear statutory order of beneficiary payment when a
deceased employee has not designated a beneficiary.
9. Proposed Amendments to Group Health Insurance Plan Eligibility and Cost Sharing
(Sections 19-136 and 19-137)
The proposed amendments to Sections 19-136 and 19-137 update and clarify eligibility and cost-
sharing provisions for the City's Group Health Insurance Plan.
Overall Impact
These amendments provide better clarity regarding Commission membership and create a structured
administrative review process that helps ensure procedural compliance while maintaining the
Retirement Commission's independence and final authority in retirement benefit eligibility matters.
Page 79 of 143
#O-26-________
ORDINANCE AMENDING PARTS OF CHAPTER 19 ARTICLES III, IV, AND V OF
THE CHARLOTTESVILLE CITY CODE RELATING TO HUMAN RESOURCES
WHEREAS parts of Chapter 19 Articles III, IV and VA of the Code of the City of
Charlottesville have not been revised for a sign; and
WHEREAS the current section 19-58 relates to ex officio members of the Retirement
Commission. The amendment clarifies that Commission members who serve by virtue of their
City position, such as the Human Resources Director, Finance Director, or Treasurer, will serve
only while holding that position. Their Commission membership automatically ends when they
leave the position. The amendment also affirms that the City Manager may appoint and replace
their designee to the Commission at their discretion; and
WHEREAS the current section 19-65 relates to the annual report to City Council regarding the
retirement accounts. The revised reporting requirements update the Commission's annual report
to City Council by focusing on actuarial and financial information, including:
• Biennial actuarial valuation results;
• Summary financial and investment performance data, including cash receipts, investment
income, and ending asset balances.
The amendment allows detailed investment and portfolio reports to be incorporated by reference,
while maintaining Council's access to supporting financial records through the City Treasurer
upon request.
WHEREAS the current section 19-68 does not include a process for administrative review of
benefit eligibility determinations. The proposed section establishes a formal process for
retirement benefit eligibility determinations and administrative review. The amendment
establishes defined timelines and clear definitions for business days, reasonable review periods,
and supporting documentation requirements.
Key changes include:
• The Retirement Commission retains sole authority to determine eligibility for retirement
benefits and will render a written initial determination within thirty (30) business days of
its review.
• Applicants receiving an adverse decision may request administrative oversight by the
City Manager within 10 business days;
• The City Manager's review is limited to determining whether the Commission acted in
accordance with the ordinance and applicable law, with a determination within thirty (30)
business days (or a reasonably agreed upon extension of time).
• The City Manager may not reweigh evidence, make factual determinations, or substitute
judgment regarding eligibility.
Page 80 of 143
• If procedural or legal concerns exist, the City Manager may remand the matter to the
Commission for reconsideration.
• The Retirement Commission retains final authority over all eligibility determinations,
including decisions following remand.
WHEREAS the current section 19-91 relates to plan definitions. The proposed amendments to
Section 19-91 update and clarify several key retirement plan definitions to improve consistency
and administrative efficiency.
The revisions establish:
• Clear hierarchy for beneficiary payments when no beneficiary designation is on file;
• Update the definition of creditable compensation;
• Clarify the calculation of creditable service for part-time employees by prorating service
for benefit calculations while preserving full vesting credit;
The amendments also updates the definition of “employee” to expressly include regular part-time
employees working at least 20 hours per week, while continuing to exclude temporary, seasonal,
and short-term employees.
WHEREAS the current section 19-94 relates to annual contributions to the 401(a) plan. The
proposed amendment to Section 19-94 gives the City Manager discretion to determine the City's
annual contribution amount to the 401(a) plan.
WHEREAS the current section 19-95(f) relates to pension benefits and written notice regarding
retirement. The proposed amendment to Section 19-95(f) clarifies that pension benefits will
begin only after the eligible former employees submits written notice electing to commence
benefits upon reaching normal retirement eligibility.
WHEREAS the current section 19-102.1 relates to long-term disability benefits. The revision to
Section 19-102.1 provides that employees receiving long-term disability benefits will continue to
accrue creditable service for retirement eligibility and benefit calculation purposes, provided they
continue making any applicable member contributions (if any) based on their regular rate of pay.
WHEREAS the current section 19-105 relates to beneficiary payment. The amendment to
Section 19-105 establishes a clear statutory order of beneficiary payment when a deceased
employee has not designated a beneficiary.
WHEREAS the current sections 19-136 and 19-137 relate to health insurance plans. The
proposed amendments to Sections 19-136 and 19-137 update and clarify eligibility and cost-
sharing provisions for the City's Group Health Insurance Plan.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council for the City of Charlottesville,
Virginia, that parts of Chapter 19 Articles III, IV and V of the Code of the City of Charlottesville
are hereby repealed and replaced as follows in the attached amendments.
Page 81 of 143
Page 1 of 15
ARTICLE III. RETIREMENT PLAN COMMISSION
Sec. 19-58. Terms of ex officio members who serve due to their respective position within the
City structure.
The terms of the ex officio members of the commission who serve due to their respective
position(s) within the City structure (including, but not limited to, the Human Resources
Director, the Finance Director, the Treasurer, or others) shall be concurrent with their service in
such position(s) or office(s) and shall cease when they leave such office(s) or position(s).
However, the term of the City Manager’s designee on the commission shall be within the
complete discretion of the City Manager.
(Code 1976, § 20-12; Ord. No. O-24-044, 4-1-24; Ord. No. _______)
Sec. 19-65. Annual report to council.
The commission shall, through the city treasurer, not later than November 30 of each year, make an annual
report to city council on the condition of the supplemental retirement or pension plan and the defined
contribution plan as of the preceding June 30. Each such report shall include the results of an actuarial valuation of
the assets and liabilities of the retirement plans, made not less frequently than biennially, and a statement of the
amounts to be contributed by the city pursuant to section 19-92. The report shall also state the cash receipts of
the retirement fund for the previous year in detail, an itemized list of securities bought or sold with the price paid
or received and a detailed list of all assets of the fund. The report may also contain any recommendations the
commission desires to make concerning changes in this Code with respect to the retirement fund or the retirement
plans.
The commission shall, through the city treasurer, not later than November 30 of each year,
submit to city council an annual report on the condition of the supplemental retirement or
pension plan and the defined contribution plan as of the preceding June 30.
Each report shall include:
1. The results of an actuarial valuation of the assets and liabilities of the retirement plans,
conducted not less frequently than biennially;
2. A statement of the amounts to be contributed by the city pursuant to section 19-92; and
3. A summary of the financial condition and investment performance of the retirement fund
for the preceding fiscal year, including total cash receipts, investment income, and ending
asset balances.
The report shall incorporate by reference any annual investment or portfolio reports prepared
by or on behalf of the commission. Detailed information regarding cash receipts, investment
Page 82 of 143
Page 2 of 15
transactions, and fund assets shall be maintained by the city treasurer and made available to city
council upon request.
The report may also contain any recommendations the commission desires to make concerning
changes in this Code with respect to the retirement fund or the retirement plans.
(Code 1976, § 20-17; Ord. No. O-24-044, 4-1-24; Ord. No. _______________)
Secs. 19-68. Administrative oversight of eligibility determinations.
(a) Initial determinations. The commission shall have sole authority to determine eligibility
for benefits under the retirement plans governed by this chapter. The commission shall
consider the request for benefits at a regular or special called meeting of the retirement
commission within a reasonable time after receipt of the full application, along with all
supporting information, for benefits submitted by the applicant. The commission may
request any additional supporting information it may need to fully consider the
application and can set the matter over to a future meeting in the event more
information is required to reach a determination of eligibility for benefits.
The commission shall render a written initial determination of eligibility within thirty
(30) business days of its review of the application and supporting information at its
regular or special called meeting, or the date the matter was set over in the event
additional information is requested of the applicant. The written initial determination
shall state the results of the review of the application and state the ability of the
applicant to request administrative review by the City Manager in the event the
eligibility is denied. The written determination can be emailed or mailed to the
applicant. The initial determination of eligibility rendered by the commission shall be
considered a final determination.
In the event the commission renders an adverse eligibility determination, the affected
employee or affected individual(s) may request administrative oversight of the process
by the City Manager as stated below. Any request for administrative oversight shall be
submitted in writing within ten (10) business days of the receipt of the initial
determination and the request shall include all information the person wishes the City
Manager to consider pertaining to the limited purpose of determining whether the
decision was made in accordance with this chapter and applicable law.
(b) Administrative oversight by the City Manager. Following a final determination by the
commission, the City Manager may, within thirty (30) business days (which may be
extended for good cause shown) of the receipt of the final determination made by the
commission, upon request of the affected employee or affected individual(s), or upon
Page 83 of 143
Page 3 of 15
the City Manager’s own initiative, review the commission’s decision for the limited
purpose of determining whether the decision was made in accordance with this chapter
and applicable law. The City Manager must render a decision regarding administrative
oversight, either denying the request (making the decision of the commission final and
unappealable) or remanding the matter for further consideration by the commission,
within forty-five (45) business days (which may be extended for good cause shown)
following the final determination by the commission.
The City Manager’s review shall not include reconsideration of factual determinations or
substitution of judgment regarding eligibility. If the City Manager determines that the
commission’s determination was not made in accordance with this chapter or applicable
law, the City Manager may remand the matter to the commission with written guidance
identifying the issue to be addressed.
The commission must reconsider the remanded application within a reasonable time
from the date of the receipt by the commission of the written determination by the City
Manager, as defined below. The commission shall render its final eligibility
determination after the remand in writing to the applicant within thirty (30) business
days of its review.
(c) Final eligibility authority. The commission shall retain final authority to determine
eligibility for benefits under the retirement plans. Any decision issued by the
commission, whether it is the initial determination or following remand, shall constitute
the final administrative determination of the City and shall not be further appealable
beyond the processes described above. However, all judicial remedies that may be
available at law to the applicant are not affected by this authority.
(d) Definition of business day. For purposes of this section, “business day” means any day
upon which the City offices are open for business, excluding weekends, holidays, and
day upon which the offices are closed due to emergency or weather conditions.
(e) Definition of reasonable time. For purposes of this section, “reasonable time” means no
more than sixty (60) business days from the receipt of the application or receipt of the
remanded written determination by the City Manager, and all relevant supporting
information.
(f) Definition of supporting information. For purposes of this section, “supporting
information”" means all relevant and material medical, financial or any other
information the commission may need to consider an application.
Secs. 19-69—19-90. Reserved.
Page 84 of 143
Page 4 of 15
ARTICLE IV. SUPPLEMENTAL RETIREMENT OR PENSION PLAN1
Sec. 19-91. Definitions.
As used in this article, the following words and phrases shall have the meanings ascribed to
them by this section, unless a different meaning is plainly required by the text:
Accumulated contributions means the sum of all amounts deducted from the
compensation of a member and credited to their individual account in the member's
contribution account, all amounts the member may contribute to purchase creditable service
and all interest credited to the member's contribution account pursuant to section 19-92(g).
Actuarial equivalent means a benefit of equal value when computed upon the basis of
such actuarial tables as are adopted by the commission. The actuarial equivalents and all
actuarial calculations shall be determined on the basis of interest at an assumed rate of seven
and one-half (7.5) percent.
Appointing authority means the city council in the case of city council appointees; the
commissioner of revenue, the city treasurer, the city sheriff, the clerk of the circuit court and
the commonwealth's attorney in the case of their employees; and the city manager in the case
of all other members of the plan, except for such elected constitutional officers.
Average final compensation means the average annual creditable compensation of a
member during the three (3) consecutive years of creditable service in which such
compensation was at its greatest amount. However, for any person who becomes a member
after June 30, 2012, average final compensation means the average annual creditable
compensation of a member during the five (5) consecutive years of creditable service in which
such compensation was at its greatest amount.
Beneficiary means any person entitled to receive benefits under this article. A beneficiary
for purposes of a payment made in the event of death (other than a contingent beneficiary
under an annuity option form or the survivor allowance payable pursuant to section 19-105(b)
or (c)) shall be that person named by the member in a beneficiary designation form filed with
the city. If no designation is filed, the beneficiary shall be the members' spouse or, if none, the
member's estate. In the event no beneficiary has been named by a member, the following shall
be the order of the person(s) entitled to benefits: (1) to the member’s living spouse; if none,
then (2) to the member’s living natural and/or living adopted child or children in equal shares; if
none, then (3) to the member’s living parents in equal shares; and if none, then (4) to the
personal representative of the member’s estate.
Commission means the retirement plan commission provided for in article III of this
chapter.
Creditable compensation means the full compensation payable annually to an employee
working the full normal working time for their position exclusive of overtime. The creditable
compensation of an employee paid on an hourly basis shall be computed at their regular hourly
1State law reference(s)—Virginia Supplemental Retirement Act, Code of Virginia, § 51-111.951.1-800 et seq.
Page 85 of 143
Page 5 of 15
rate multiplied by the regular number of working hours per week multiplied by fifty-two (52). In
cases where compensation includes maintenance and other perquisites, the city manager shall
fix the value of the part of the compensation not paid in money. Notwithstanding the
foregoing, creditable compensation taken into account for purposes of determining benefits
under the plan shall be limited by the compensation limit prescribed by the Internal Revenue
Code, in particular pursuant to Section 401(a)(17) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as
amended. For purposes hereof, the compensation limit, for years beginning on or after January
1, 1986 but before December 31, 1992, is two hundred thousand dollars ($200,000.00) as
adjusted by the cost of living adjustment factor prescribed by the Secretary of the Treasury or
their delegate under Section 415(d) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, the
"adjustment factor"; and for years beginning on or after January 1, 1993, is one hundred fifty
thousand dollars ($150,000.00) (as adjusted by the adjustment factor in ten thousand dollars
($10,000.00) increments on the basis of a base period of the calendar quarter beginning
October 1, 1993). For purposes of applying the limitation applicable to each year, the limit for a
plan year shall be the limitation in effect for the calendar year in which the plan year begins
determined without increases in the limitation for subsequent years.
Creditable service means, for any member who is in service at any time after July 1, 1982,
their total service as an employee, whether or not continuous, exclusive of any separate period
of service of less than nine (9) months in duration, but inclusive of official leave for military
service, to the extent required by federal or state law. Creditable service shall be counted in
terms of calendar years, with completed months of creditable service in excess of complete
years being counted as a fractional part of a year.
For any period during which a member works less than full-time, as defined as 40 hours or
more per week, creditable service shall be pro-rated based upon the ratio of the member’s
actual hours scheduled to work to the standard full-time hours for the position and salary will
be increased, if necessary, to the full-time salary for purposes of the calculation. Pro-ration
under this paragraph shall not affect creditable service for vesting purposes.
For any employee eligible to retire pursuant to the provisions of section 19-95(a), (e), (g) or
section 19-100 of this chapter, creditable service shall include, for purposes of computing the
retirement allowance, one-half (½) of the employee's accumulated and unused sick leave as of
the date of retirement, up to a maximum of two thousand (2,000) hours.
Employee means any person who is employed by the city, and in service on or after July 1,
1987, in a regular, continuous position that requires forty (40) hours or more of work per week,
who has not been hired on a short-term, temporary, or seasonal basis; and any person who is
employed by the city in a regular, continuous position that requires at least twenty (20) hours
of work per week, but less than forty (40) hours per week, who has not been hired on a short-
term, temporary, or seasonal basis. on a full-time, year-round basis, whether paid by the hour,
week, month or otherwise. Such term shall not include any person, judicial, professional or
otherwise, employed either on a part-time basis or on a seasonal basis; nor shall it The term
Page 86 of 143
Page 6 of 15
employee shall not include any official elected by the people or any person employed in the
office of such official; except, that it shall include the commissioner of revenue, the city
treasurer, the city sheriff, the clerk of the circuit court, the commonwealth's attorney, and any
regional agencies or other entities which the City has entered into an agreement to cover said
employees under the City’s plans, and their full-timeregular employees as there are
agreements with the city to treat such persons as if they are employees of the city. Such term
shall not include the employees of any office, department or agency which participates in the
Virginia Supplemental Retirement System, regardless of whether such office, department or
agency is funded wholly or partly by the city; provided, that any clerk or employee of the
district court employed in such capacity on June 30, 1973, who elected not to participate in the
Virginia Supplemental Retirement System shall continue to be considered an employee, for
purposes of this article only, and be eligible for benefits hereunder to the full extent of their
salary. Such term shall include the employees of any multi-jurisdictional agency in which the
city is a participating jurisdiction, when such employees are not covered under the Virginia
Supplemental Retirement System, or in any other retirement plan, and when the city has
contractually agreed to include such employees in the retirement plan provided by this article.
Notwithstanding the foregoing definition, "employee" also includes any person who meets the
foregoing definition, except that they:
(1) Works less than full-time but at least half-time;
(2) Works less than year-round but at least thirty-six (36) weeks per year; and
(3) Is in service on or after July 1, 1987.
In case of dispute, the commission shall determine who is an employee within the meaning
of this article.
Member means any employee or former employee who is currently, or shall in the future,
be recognized as having membership in the plan.
Member contribution account means the account established under the plan to hold the
member's contributions and earnings thereon required and credited pursuant to section 19-92.
Normal retirement date means the first day of the month coinciding with or next following:
(1) For a member who is a police officer, firefighter, sheriff or sheriff's deputy, the
sixtieth birthday of the member, and
(2) For a member who is not a police officer, firefighter, sheriff or sheriff's deputy, the
sixty-fifth birthday of the member.
Person who becomes a member after June 30, 2012 means a person who is not a member
of a plan described in section 19-94(a) or (c) who is hired or rehired after June 30, 2012 as an
employee as defined herein. In the case of an employee who is rehired after such date and
whose credited service attributable to employment prior to July 1, 2012 is reinstated or is
otherwise not disregarded, shall not be treated as a person who becomes a member after June
30, 2012 if such employee elects to be a member of a plan described in section 19-94(a) or (c)
at the time of their rehire. Any benefit accumulated under the plan based on employment prior
to July 1, 2012 shall remain frozen as though their employment after June 30, 2012 had not
Page 87 of 143
Page 7 of 15
occurred. If such employee does not elect to be a member of a plan described in section 19-
94(a) or (c) at the time of their rehire, their benefit under the plan shall be determined based
on the provisions applicable to a person who becomes a member after June 30, 2012, except
that no employee contribution shall be required or collected with respect to service performed
prior to July 1, 2012. If such employee elected to be a member of a plan described in section
19-94(a) or (c), later received a disability retirement under article VI of this chapter, and then
recovers and is rehired by the city, they will not be eligible to elect to be a member of a plan
described in section 19-94(a) or (c) and their benefit under the plan shall be determined based
on the provisions applicable to a person who becomes a member after June 30, 2012 and is
rehired after June 30, 2017, subject to the applicable offset provided under section 19-156, and
except that no employee contribution shall be required or collected with respect to service
performed prior to their rehire.
Plan means "The Supplemental Retirement or Pension Plan of the City of Charlottesville,"
as set forth in this article.
Retirement allowance means the retirement payments to which a member is entitled, as
provided in this article.
Service means service as an employee for which compensation is paid.
(Code 1976, § 20-19; 12-21-92; 10-16-00(1); 5-5-03(2); 1-3-12; 9-7-21(1), § 2; Ord. No. O-24-
091, 7-15-24; Ord. No. O-25-027, 3-17-25; Ord. No. _________)
Cross reference(s)—Definitions and rules of construction generally, § 1-2.
Sec. 19-94. Participation in defined contribution and deferred compensation plans.
(a) The city manager may approve the withdrawal from membership in the plan of any
employee who is exempt from the personnel appeals system as set forth in section 19-
36(b) and may execute an agreement for such employee to participate in an optional
defined contribution plan approved by the Internal Revenue Service as a qualified plan
within the meaning of Section 401(a) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended.
Such agreement may provide that the city shall contribute to such plan an annual amount
no greater than the total amount which the city would contribute to the city plan on behalf
of such employee for such year pursuant to section 19-92(b). The contribution shall not
include any contribution made to fund the city's post-employment benefits trust in
accordance with section 19-141.determined by the city manager. Any employee who
enters into such an agreement shall be deemed to have terminated all membership in the
supplemental retirement or pension plan of the city and to have waived any rights
whatsoever to any benefits thereunder. Upon execution of any such agreement, the
retirement plan commission is authorized to make the payments called for therein, but in
no event shall the payment for any period exceed the amount contributed by the city to
the city plan for such employee for such period. A copy of such plan shall be kept on file in
Page 88 of 143
Page 8 of 15
the city's personnel Human Resources department, and it may be amended from time to
time. Any employee who is a public safety employee (as defined in section 19-150), whose
active membership under the plan was terminated under such an agreement, and who
later receives a disability retirement under article VI of this chapter shall again be an active
member of the plan as provided in section 19-151 and section 19-156, subject in all events
to the applicable offset referenced therein.
(b) The city council may likewise approve participation by the city manager in a supplemental
defined contribution plan approved by the Internal Revenue Service as a qualified plan
within the meaning of Section 401(a) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended,
in which case the city's annual contribution thereto shall likewise equal the amount which
would have been contributed to the city plan, unless the council shall determine a greater
or lesser amount. A copy of such plan shall be kept on file in the city's personnel Human
Resources department, and it may be amended from time to time.
(c) Effective July 1, 2001, the city manager may approve the withdrawal from membership in
the plan of any employee and may execute an agreement for such employee to participate
in an optional defined contribution plan approved by the Internal Revenue Service as a
qualified plan within the meaning of Section 401(a) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986,
as amended. Such agreement may provide that the city shall contribute to such plan an
annual amount determined by the retirement commission with the approval of the city
manager on behalf of such employee for such year. Any employee who enters into such an
agreement shall be deemed to have terminated all active membership in the supplemental
retirement or pension plan of the city and to have waived any rights whatsoever to accrue
additional benefits thereunder. Upon execution of any such agreement, the retirement
plan commission is authorized to make the payments called for therein. A copy of such
plan shall be kept on file in the city's personnel department, and it may be amended from
time to time. Any employee who is a public safety employee (as defined in section 19-150),
whose active membership under the plan was terminated under such an agreement, and
who later receives a disability retirement under article VI of this chapter shall again be an
active member of the plan as provided in section 19-151 and section 19-156, subject in all
events to the applicable offset referenced therein.
(d) Effective November 1, 1987, all regular city employees as defined above, including city
council members, who work at least twenty (20) hours per week shall be eligible to
participate in a deferred compensation plan, whether or not they participate in the
supplemental retirement or pension plan of the city or the defined contribution plans
described in subsections (a) through (c) of this section. Such new plan shall enable
employees to defer part of their compensation if they choose to do so to provide for their
retirement. Participation in this new plan shall have no effect on eligibility for participation
in the supplemental retirement or pension plan of the city or the defined contribution
plans described in subsections (a) through (c) of this section. A copy of such plan shall be
kept on file in the city's human resources department, and it may be amended from time
to time.
(Code 1976, § 20-21.1; 10-16-00(1); 6-5-17(1); Ord. No. O-25-027, 3-17-25; Ord. No. _____________)
Page 89 of 143
Page 9 of 15
Sec. 19-95. Service retirement—Mandatory retirement dates.
(a) Any member who is in service at their normal retirement date may retire then or at any
time thereafter, provided they have completed five (5) or more years of creditable service,
upon written notification to the commission made by the member or by their appointing
authority setting forth at what date the retirement is to become effective. Such effective
date shall be after the member's last day of service and shall not be more than ninety (90)
days prior to the filing of such notification.
(b) No member who is a police officer, fire fighter or sheriff's deputy shall be permitted to
continue in service after their normal retirement date, unless the member's appointing
authority, upon a determination that organizational needs so require, grants the member
an exemption from such mandatory retirement requirements. Any such member who
continues in service under such an exemption from the appointing authority, may be
retired by that authority at any time thereafter. Such retirement shall be initiated by the
appointing authority by notification to the commission setting forth at what date the
retirement is to become effective. Such effective date shall be after the member's last day
of service and shall not be more than ninety (90) days prior to the filing of such
notification.
(c) The commissioner of revenue, city treasurer, city sheriff, clerk of the circuit court and
commonwealth's attorney may continue in service so long as they hold office.
(d) The appointing authority of any member not listed in subsection (b) or (c) of this section,
subsequent to the member's normal retirement date, upon a determination that age is a
bona fide occupational qualification reasonably necessary to the normal operation of the
city, and that such member has reached the age limit, or upon a determination that such
member is incapable of performing their duties in a safe and efficient manner, may require
the service retirement of such member upon written notification to the commission
setting forth at what date the retirement is to become effective. Such effective date shall
be after the member's last day of service and shall not be more than ninety (90) days prior
to the filing of such notification. Notwithstanding the foregoing, if such member lacks five
(5) years of creditable service, such member shall be discharged and shall be ineligible for
a retirement allowance.
(e) Any member who is in service and who has completed five (5) or more years of creditable
service may retire at any time after the fifty-fifth (55th) birthday of the member or, in the
case of a person who becomes a member after June 30, 2012 other than a police officer,
firefighter, sheriff or sheriff's deputy, after the sixtieth (60th) birthday of the member, or
at any time thereafter, upon written notification to the commission, made by the member,
setting forth at what date the retirement to become effective. Such effective date shall be
after the member's last day of service and shall not be more than ninety (90) days prior to
the filing of such notification.
Page 90 of 143
Page 10 of 15
(f) Any member who terminates service after completing five (5) or more years of creditable
service may retire under the provisions of either subsection (a) or subsection (ce) of this
section; provided, that the requirement as to such member being in service shall not apply.
Further, in the event any terminated member gives written notice of intention to receive
pension payments at any time after normal retirement age, said payments shall only be
applicable going forward from the date of such written notification; pension payments will
not be made retroactively to the terminated members’ normal retirement date.
(g) Any member who is in service and who has completed thirty (30) or more years of
creditable service may retire at age fifty (50), or, in the case of a person who becomes a
member after June 30, 2012, at age sixty (60), or at any time thereafter, upon written
notification to the commission, made by the member, setting forth at what date the
retirement is to be effective, without suffering the penalty imposed by section 19-96(d).
Such effective date shall be after the member's last day of service and shall not be more
than ninety (90) days prior to the filing of such notification.
(h) Any member who is a police officer, firefighter, sheriff or sheriff's deputy, and has
completed twenty-five (25) or more years in service may retire at age fifty (50), or at any
time thereafter until the mandatory retirement date is reached, without suffering the
penalty imposed by section 19-96(e).
(i) Notwithstanding the forgoing, on or after January 1, 1989, the retirement allowance of a
member who has terminated employment shall begin no later April 1 of the calendar year
following the later of (i) the calendar year in which the member attains seventy and one-
half (70½) years of age, or (ii) the calendar year in which the member terminates
employment.
(j) Upon attaining normal retirement age and completion of the required years of service,
each employee's interest shall be fully vested.
(Code 1976, § 20-22; 8-15-94; 3-6-95; 6-5-00(1); 10-16-00(1); 5-5-03(2); 1-3-12; 6-5-17(1); 9-7-
21(1), § 2)
Editor's note(s)—It should be noted that § 2 of Ord. No. 89-7-5, adopted April 3, 1989, provided
that the ordinance become effective July 1, 1990. Section 1 of the ordinance amended and
reordained § 20-22, in effect reciting paragraphs (a) through (d) as they existed prior to
amendment and adding paragraph (e) as set forth above. (Ord. No. __________)
Sec. 19-102.1. Long term disability benefits.
(a) Effective January 1, 2003 the city may provide for long term disability insurance coverage
for employees, as defined in section 19-91. Eligibility for the receipt of long term disability
insurance benefits, and the terms and conditions of such benefits, shall be established by
contract between the city and a third party insurer.
(b) No employee shall be eligible for an award of retirement benefits for total and permanent
disability pursuant to section 19-101 or partial disability benefits pursuant to section 19-
Page 91 of 143
Page 11 of 15
102 for any period of time during which the employee is receiving, or is qualified to
receive, long term disability insurance benefits pursuant to this section.
(c) Any employee who is receiving, or is qualified to receive, long term disability insurance
benefits pursuant to this section shall continue to accrue creditable service for purposes of
determining eligibility for retirement and, if applicable, the amount of any retirement
benefit, provided that the employee makes the applicable member contribution(s), if any,
for the time period the employee is receiving such long term disability payments, based
upon the employee’s regular rate of pay. Accrual of creditable service pursuant to this
section shall terminate on the employee's normal retirement date.
(12-16-02; Ord. No. -________)
Sec. 19-105. Survivor's allowance.
(a) Should a member hired after June 30, 2012 die in service before completing at least five
(5) years of creditable service, the member's beneficiary shall receive a refund of the
balance in the member's contribution account. In the event no beneficiary has been
named by a member, the refund of the balance of the member’s contribution account
shall be dispersed in the following manner: (1) to the member’s living spouse; if none, then
(2) to the member’s living natural and/or living adopted child or children in equal shares; if
none, then (3) to the member’s living parents in equal shares; and if none, then (4) to the
personal representative of the member’s estate.
(b) Should a member die in service at any time before retirement and after either becoming
eligible for early service retirement under section 19-95(e), or completing at least thirty
(30) years of creditable service, the member's surviving spouse if any, shall receive a
retirement allowance payable monthly for the life of such spouse. Such allowance shall be
in the same amount and shall commence at the same date as the retirement allowance
that would have been payable to the member, computed in accordance with section 19-
96, subsections (a) and (b), whichever is applicable, had the member survived and retired
on the first day of the month coinciding with or next following the date on which their
death occurred after having elected an allowance paid under the full joint and last survivor
option provided for in section 19-104(b), with their surviving spouse designated as
contingent beneficiary. In the case of a member who had not become eligible for early
service retirement at their date of death, it shall be assumed that the requirements of
section 19-95(e) were such that they would have been eligible for early service retirement
and that the retirement allowance payable in such event would be reduced by one-half
(0.5) percent for each complete month in the period between the member's date of death
and a date five (5) years prior to their normal retirement date.
(c) Should a member die in service at any time after July 1, 2000 and after completing five (5)
years of creditable service and before either becoming eligible for early service retirement
under section 19-95(e), or completing at least thirty (30) years of creditable service, the
member's surviving spouse, if any, shall receive a retirement allowance payable monthly
Page 92 of 143
Page 12 of 15
for the life of such spouse. Such allowance shall commence at the same date as the
retirement allowance that would have been payable to the member, computed in
accordance with section 19-96, subsection (b), had the member survived and retired on
the first day of the month coinciding with or next following the date on which the
member's death occurred after having elected an allowance paid under the one-half (½)
joint and survivor option provided for in section 19-104(b), with the surviving spouse
designated as contingent beneficiary.
(d) Any allowance payable to the member's surviving spouse under this section shall be
reduced by the amount of any payments made to such member's surviving spouse as
required by the Virginia Workers' Compensation Act, and the excess of such allowance
over such required payments, if any, shall be paid to the member's surviving spouse. When
the time for payment of compensation under such act shall have elapsed, the member's
surviving spouse shall thereafter receive the full amount of the allowance, as provided by
subsections (ba) and (cb) of this section, monthly during such spouse's lifetime.
(e) For any member hired after June 30, 2012, whose surviving spouse receiving an allowance
payable under the provisions set forth above dies, any excess balance in the member's
contribution account as of the date of the member's death, over the total survivor
allowance paid to the member or surviving spouse shall be paid to the spouse's estate.
(Code 1976, § 20-32; 6-2-97; 6-5-00(1); 1-3-12; 9-7-21(1), § 2; Ord. No. ______________)
ARTICLE V. GROUP HEALTH INSURANCE PLAN2
Sec. 19-136. Eligibility.
City employees who work in a regular, continuous position that requires forty (40) hours or
more of work per week, who has not been hired on a short-term, temporary, or seasonal basis;
and any person who is employed by the city in a regular, continuous position that requires at
least twenty (20) hours of work per week, but less than forty (40) hours per week, who has not
been hired on a short-term, temporary, or seasonal basis, at least twenty (20) hours per week,
other than temporary or seasonal employees, are eligible to participate in the city's group
insurance plan for health care coverage.
City Council members are eligible for the following benefits: health insurance, dental
insurance, vision insurance, and may participate in the Deferred Compensation 457 plan
provided for city employees.
(Code 1976, § 20-39(a); 10-16-00(1); Ord. No. ________)
Sec. 19-137. Employee cost.
Full-time Employees in a regular, continuous position, as defined above in Section 19-136
are considered eligible employees are eligible to receive basic health care coverage at city
2State law reference(s)—Authority to provide health insurance programs, Code of Virginia, § 15.1-7.315.2-1517.
Page 93 of 143
Created: 2026-05-05 11:30:45 [EST]
(Supp. No. 63)
Page 13 of 15
expense, but the city reserves the right to offer extra coverage at employee expense. Further,
the cost-sharing percentages payable by eligible employees for coverage will be determined by
the City.
(1) Eligible employees who work thirty (30) to thirty-nine (39) hours per week are eligible
to receive basic health care coverage if they pay twenty-five (25) percent of the cost;
the city will pay the remainder.
(2) Eligible employees who work twenty (20) to twenty-nine (29) hours per week are
eligible to receive basic health care coverage if they pay fifty (50) percent of the cost;
the city will pay the remainder.
(Code 1976, § 20-39(b); 10-16-00(1); Ord. No. __________)
Sec. 19-139. Termination of coverage; termination of service; retirement.
(a) Effective January 1, 1985, city contributions to the expense of any employee's health care
coverage shall cease as of the last day of the month during which any such employee
leaves city service without retiring either for service or disability, even if such employee
may be a vested member of the city's supplemental retirement or pension plan and
eligible to retire under such plan in the future. However, coverage may continue during
the period that coverage is required to be available on a continuation basis pursuant to the
Public Health Services Act, if the former employee or other qualified beneficiary pays 100%
of the cost plus a 2% administrative fee, if charged by the city.
(b) All employees eligible for city health care coverage on December 2, 2002, who continue to
work for the city until they retire for service or disability, shall remain eligible in retirement
for city health care coverage (which shall only include health insurance and dental
insurance but no other benefits) on the same terms and conditions as active employees
who are eligible for coverage, but the city reserves the right to amend the plan from time
to time as it deems appropriate.
(c) Any city employee who (i) retires for service or disability on or before December 2, 2002
and (ii) who, immediately prior to their effective date of retirement, was eligible for city
health care coverage, shall remain eligible in retirement for city health care coverage on
the same terms and conditions as active employees who are eligible for coverage.
(d) Employees who begin city employment on or after December 3, 2002 but on or before
June 30, 2012, shall be eligible to continue in the city's health care plan following
retirement for service or disability upon payment of a portion of the cost of such
membership. Each year the city will determine the amount of its contribution to the
premium costs of health care coverage for individual employees. For employees who retire
with five (5) years of service and elect to continue in the city's health care plan after
retirement, the city will pay 20% of the annual contribution amount. For employees who
retire with more than five (5) years of service, the city will pay an additional 4% of the
Page 94 of 143
Page 14 of 15
annual contribution amount for each additional full year of service completed as of the
effective date of retirement up to a maximum of 100% of the annual contribution amount.
The retiree will be required to pay the remaining percentage of the city's annual
contribution and the additional premium or cost, if any, of the health care plan selected as a
condition of membership in the plan.
(e) Employees who begin city employment after June 30, 2012 shall be eligible to continue in
the city's health care plan following retirement for service or disability until such employee
becomes eligible to elect Medicare, upon payment of a portion of the cost of such
membership. Each year the city will determine the amount of its contribution to the
premium costs of health care coverage for individual employees. For employees who retire
with ten (10) years of service and elect to continue in the city's health care plan after
retirement, the city will pay 40% of the annual contribution amount. For employees who
retire with more than ten (10) years of service, the city will pay an additional 4% of the
annual contribution amount for each additional full year of service completed as of the
effective date of retirement up to a maximum of 100% of the annual contribution amount.
The retiree will be required to pay the remaining percentage of the city's annual
contribution and the additional premium or cost, if any, of the health care plan selected as a
condition of membership in the plan.
(f) Notwithstanding the foregoing, employees who elect pursuant to subsection 19-94(c) of
Article IV of this chapter to participate in the optional defined contribution plan adopted
pursuant to that subsection, shall be eligible to enroll, at the retiree's expense, in the
health care coverage offered through the city following retirement under such plan.
(g) (1) An employee enrolled in the health care plan who retires for service or disability prior to
July 1, 2013, may elect to enroll a family member in the plan at the retiree's sole expense,
provided such election is made prior to the date of retirement. For employees retired on
or before July 1, 2010, such election shall be made on or before July 1, 2010.
(2) Effective July 1, 2013, an employee enrolled in the health care plan who retires for
service or disability may elect to continue the enrollment of a family member in the
plan at the retiree's sole expense, provided (i) such election to continue enrollment of
the family member is made prior to the date of retirement; and (ii) the family
member has been enrolled in the health care plan for no less than thirty-six (36)
consecutive months immediately prior to the employee's retirement date.
(3) Any spouse or other family member who is enrolled in the city's health care plan at
the time of the retiree's death may continue as a member of the plan upon payment
of the applicable premium.
(h) Notwithstanding the foregoing, enrollment of a retiree's family members is subject to
certain restrictions that may vary from time to time, and the city reserves the right to
amend its health care coverage plan from time to time as the city in its discretion deems
appropriate.
Page 95 of 143
Page 15 of 15
(Code 1976, § 20-40; 6-2-97; 3-2-98; 10-16-00(1); 12-2-02(2); 3-1-10(2); 1-3-12; Ord. No.
___________)
Page 96 of 143
City Manager’s Report
Offices of the City Manager
Elected & Appointed Officials
11-16-2026
Page 97 of 143
City Manager – Sam Sanders (he/him)
• November 5:
o Joined Krisy Hammill, Director of the Office of Budget and Grants
Management for a financial briefing by PFM, the City’s financial advisor. The
presentation provided an overview of the City's financial health and identified
areas where competing priorities continue to create challenges. The City
Council will have a retreat on January 15 and the financial health of the
organization will be the primary focus of the event.
• November 6:
o Over 100 City employees gathered at the Contemplative Sciences building at
UVA to work with The Spill Teem on the continued rollout of organizational
excellence. This is the City’s internal culture-setting effort to support the
realization of Council’s Vision: to be a place where everyone thrives.
• November 9:
o Joined Jean Runyon, President of Piedmont Virginia Community College
(PVCC), and Jeff Richardson, Albemarle County Executive, for a quarterly
check-in. We each shared updates on key priorities. PVCC is very much
committed to engaging in training and preparation activities to help residents
find opportunities to work at AstraZeneca. There is a concerted effort
underway by the Virginia Community College System to develop opportunities
in the regions where multiple pharmaceutical companies are building new
facilities.
• November 10:
o Joined Assistant City Manager Roman for a meeting with Nathan Smith and
Richard Southee, leadership of Central Arizona Shelter Services (CASS). The
meeting was to check in on the operations of the low barrier shelter at 2000
Holiday Drive. Great work continues in service to the unhoused population,
and we will continue providing a solid foundation on which our most
vulnerable can begin to reclaim control of their lives.
o Joined Abi Matthew Wade, Economic Mobility Officer, to celebrate the work of
community members who engaged in the co-development of economic
mobility and opportunity priorities. Abi is developing a plan to help lift
individuals and families from poverty to thriving in our community. The
community participants worked over several weeks in crafting the
components of this work. I delivered congratulatory remarks with my deepest
thanks to those who dedicated their time to support others.
o Spoke to the Rotary Club of Charlottesville at their monthly meeting. I
provided a snapshot on current events in the City and planning for what’s to
come.
Page 98 of 143
City Manager’s Office – Assistant City Manager India Adams-Jacobs
• Bennett’s Village Treehouse at Pen Park has received the Virginia Recreation
and Park Society’s Best New Facility Award in the Playgrounds category. The
award recognizes the facility as an inclusive space where residents of all ages
and abilities can play, connect, and feel welcome. It also reflects the Parks &
Recreation team's dedication and Bennett’s Village's collaboration with the
families, advocates, donors, and community partners who made the project
possible.
• Public Works has completed the crosswalk at Angus Road and Route 29,
improving pedestrian safety in that area.
• Led by the Director of Utilities, the Utilities Department has issued a gas survey
to more than 120 regional stakeholders to assess the effectiveness of its
community utilities education. Stakeholder input will inform efforts to maintain
and improve service delivery.
• The Director of Information Technology and the Emergency Management
Coordinator jointly attended a tabletop cybersecurity training course to
strengthen organizational resilience. In addition, the Director of Information
Technology attended the SAP Public Sector Summit and technology
modernization from a local government perspective.
Communications & Public Engagement (CAPE) - Director Afton Schneider
(she/her)
• Organizational Excellence Initiative:
o CAPE provided communications and multimedia support for the November 6
Organizational Excellence Retreat, capturing content to support the Citywide
rollout of the initiative. The team is developing three videos to introduce the
four organizational value pillars to employees, demonstrate their impact on
community service, and support future employee onboarding.
• Climate Adaptation and Resilience Plan:
o CAPE supported the Office of Sustainability in promoting community
engagement opportunities for the City's Climate Adaptation and Resilience
Plan. The team created a dedicated Connect Charlottesville page to provide
information and collect community feedback on the plan's 16 proposed
strategies. CAPE also promoted opportunities for public input through the
City's On the Spot video series and digital communications.
• Election Communications:
o CAPE coordinated with the Office of the Voter Registrar and City leadership
to support public information efforts surrounding the November 3 election.
The team also participated in the Election Day command post, providing
Page 99 of 143
communications support, monitoring potential issues, and helping ensure
coordinated messaging and timely responses throughout the day.
• Charlottesville’s Grand Illumination: A Holiday Celebration:
o CAPE is looking forward to supporting Parks & Recreation with this year’s
Grand Illumination, happening Saturday, December 5 from 9 AM-6 PM.
o This year, Charlottesville’s Grand Illumination is expanding into a day-long
celebration across Downtown Charlottesville. Enjoy live performances, family-
friendly activities, interactive experiences, holiday-themed fun, and cozy
gathering spaces as the Downtown Mall comes alive with festive spirit.
o Interested in being part of the holiday magic? Consider volunteering! Email
Special Events Coordinator Ellen Joy at joye@charlottesville.gov for more
information.
• Charlottesville Community Media Center:
o CAPE worked closely with the ADA Team to support accessibility initiatives
and help ensure City communications, public meetings, and engagement
opportunities remain inclusive and accessible to all residents. This included
supporting awareness of accessibility resources such as the assisted listening
system available in Council Chambers.
o The latest episode of Inside Charlottesville is now live! Stream online
alongside previous episodes at https://www.charlottesville.gov/1773/Inside-
Charlottesville.
• Assistant Director Ose Akinlotan attended the National Association of ADA
Coordinators Conference, participating in the Web Accessibility and Professional
Certification tracks to prepare for upcoming federal accessibility requirements and
strengthen the City's digital accessibility efforts.
Commissioner of the Revenue – Todd Divers (he/him)
• The Commissioner of the Revenue’s Office is responding to customer inquiries
regarding the December 7 tax payment deadline.
• The Office is also finalizing rental relief audits to facilitate grant disbursements in
December and preparing systems for the annual transition to the 2027 tax year.
Office of Economic Development (OED) – Director Chris Engel (he/him)
• NextGen Skilled Trades Day:
o On Saturday, October 17, Piedmont Virginia Community College welcomed
an estimated 250 attendees and more than 30 exhibitors for the second
annual NextGen Skilled Trades Day! The event, initiated in 2025 by the City’s
OED, brought together students, families, employers, educators, and
community members for a day filled with hands-on activities, interactive
demonstrations, and opportunities to explore rewarding careers in the skilled
trades.
Page 100 of 143
o From construction and automotive technology to electrical, HVAC,
manufacturing, and more, attendees experienced firsthand the skills,
equipment, and technology that power these essential industries. They also
connected directly with employers and training providers to learn about career
pathways, certifications, apprenticeships, and educational opportunities.
o The feedback speaks to the value of these experiences. One exhibitor
shared, "Intentional conversations - the folks that turned out were really
interested in learning and what opportunities are available!" Another
commented, "We made some great connections with prospective
students/applicants and school representatives."
o A parent shared, "My child had a great time at the event," while a school
representative enthusiastically expressed, "The students had a great time.
We all learned a lot today!"
o According to the 2026 State of America's Skilled Trades report, approximately
24% of skilled trades workers nationwide are age 55 or older, while only 11%
are under age 25. With an aging workforce and growing demand for skilled
professionals, introducing the next generation to these career opportunities is
more important than ever.
o Thank you to everyone who helped make NextGen Skilled Trades Day 2026
a memorable and meaningful experience. We look forward to building on this
momentum in 2027!
Budget & Grants Management – Director Krisy Hammill (she/her)
• The application window for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and
HOME is currently open, and applications will be accepted through midnight on
Friday, December 4. Mandatory pre-application workshops are underway and
anyone interested in attending or asking questions can learn more at
https://www.charlottesville.gov/678/CDBG-HOME-Programs.
Office of Sustainability (OS) – Director Kristel Riddervold (she/her)
• The draft Climate Adaptation and Resilience Plan (CARP) is available for public
review and comment at the following Connect Charlottesville page:
https://connect.charlottesville.gov/ResilientCharlottesville/.
• The draft Urban Forest Management Plan (UFMP) is available for public review and
comment at the following Connect Charlottesville page:
https://connect.charlottesville.gov/urbanforest-managementplan/
• The community is invited to attend any of the following Drop-In Sessions for both
plans to meet with project team members, talk about the plans, and share any
comments and questions. Here is the Community Drop-In Schedule:
o November 12 from 2:30-4:00 PM (Carver Recreation Center)
o November 17 from 12:00-2:00 PM (CitySpace)
Page 101 of 143
o November 18 from 4:00-6:00 PM (via Zoom)
o November 20 from 9:30-11:00 AM (Botanical Fare)
• There has been robust uptake of the landscaping electrification rebates since their
launch in early October. Thus far, there have been 18 rebates processed, covering
25 landscaping tools. The most popular rebate item has been electric leaf blowers,
with 14 purchased to date.
• The LED lighting upgrade project at five Charlottesville City Schools (CCS) facilities
that includes lighting replacements and occupancy sensor/dimmer control upgrades
began in September and is still underway. Tall Oaks Elementary was largely
completed in October. CATEC and Sunrise Elementary started in October with
completion in November. Trailblazer Elementary will start in November and Summit
Elementary will start in December with full project completion expected in January
2027.
• Charlottesville’s first Tree Week, led by ReLeaf C’ville, hosted a total of 20
community events. These events took the form of guided tree walks, a sustainability-
themed trivia night, invasive vine removal efforts, tree ring printmaking, a community
art installation, a keynote speaker presentation, and plenty more. Thank you to
everyone who participated in celebrating our community’s urban canopy!
• The Office of Sustainability (OS) helped host “Bees, Trees, and EVs”, a partner
event of C’ville Tree Week that brought out community members of all ages for a
game of trivia. Community organizations including the Botanical Garden of the
Piedmont, ReLeaf, Piedmont Master Gardeners, the Local Energy Alliance Program,
and CHS Green BACON hosted craft and activity tables and contributed ideas for
trivia questions.
• The Charlottesville Invasive Plant Partnership (CHIPP), a project co-led by the Office
of Sustainability and Parks & Recreation, hosted the kick-off event for Charlottesville
Tree Week at the Lab School. The event brought out 33 volunteers and resulted in
177 trees being liberated by invasive vines.
• The Office of Sustainability and the CHIPP jointly tabled at the Botanical Garden of
the Piedmont’s Fall Festival and encouraged attendees to view and comment on the
UFMP and the CARP while they are both open for public comment.
• The Imagine a Day without Water Art Contest submittal deadline has passed and
now you can help select the Fan Favorite winner! The art contest challenged youth
to show how a small water drop makes a big difference through artistic creation. Fan
Favorite voting is open now through December 2. All art contest winners will be
announced on December 9. To vote for your favorite art entry, visit:
https://2026art.cmpgn.page/20VRzp.
• Jill Greiner, Water Efficiency Program Coordinator, successfully graduated in
October from the 10-month American Water Works Association’s Transformative
Water Leadership Academy, strengthening her leadership skills and advancing the
City’s capacity to address water conservation efforts.
Page 102 of 143
Public Works – Director Steven Hicks (he/him)
• Public Engagement:
o Fifeville Traffic Calming, Thursday, November 12, 6:30–8:30 PM, Tonsler
Park:
Public Works met with the Fifeville Neighborhood Association and
residents to discuss ways to slow traffic, reduce cut-through traffic, and
improve pedestrian safety. Options included all-way stops, speed
cushions, possible one-way streets, and longer-term sidewalk and
intersection improvements. Community feedback will help shape the
recommendations. Public Works plans to include proposed
improvements in its FY28 budget request.
o Stribling Avenue Sidewalk, Tuesday, November 17, 6:30–8:30 PM, Fry’s
Spring Beach Club:
Public Works will meet with residents to discuss the proposed sidewalk
along Stribling Avenue from Jefferson Park Avenue to Huntley Avenue.
The project would provide a continuous sidewalk along this stretch,
with raised crosswalks and flashing beacons to improve pedestrian
safety.
o Dairy Road Bridge Replacement, Wednesday, November 18, 5:30–7:30 PM,
Charlottesville Early Learning Center, formerly Walker Upper Elementary
School, 1564 Dairy Road:
Public Works will update residents on the replacement of the Dairy
Road bridge over the Route 250 Bypass and explain what to expect
during construction, including the detour. The bridge is tentatively
scheduled to close January 4, 2027.
• Barracks–Emmet Streetscape:
o VDOT approved the award of the Barracks–Emmet Streetscape project to
M&F Concrete. The project will improve the intersection of Barracks Road
and Emmet Street and has a construction budget of $6.9 million. The
preconstruction meeting is tentatively scheduled for November 30, and
construction could begin as early as December 14. Public Works is working
with the contractor to finalize the construction schedule and sequence of
work.
• Leaf Collection:
o Public Works began curbside leaf collection on October 26 and is nearly
finished with the first of three scheduled passes through each neighborhood.
Residents should place loose, unbagged leaves at the curb and keep
sidewalks, bike lanes, and travel lanes clear. Saturday drop-off is available at
1505 Avon Street Extended. Residents can sign up for collection reminders
by texting their street address to 434-771-0251.
Page 103 of 143
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
To be a place where everyone thrives
To: City Council
From: Sam Sanders, City Manager
Krisy Hammill, Director, Budget and Grants Management
Date: November 16, 2026
Topic: FY 2027 Q1 Financial Review
A review of the City’s Q1 financial performance for FY 2027 has completed and some highlights
have been compiled and noted within this memorandum.
General Fund
Expenditures
As of September 30, 2026, the City had spent $70,978,834, or 25.0% of the total General Fund
budget. Salary and benefit expenses accounted for $18 million, while other expenses totaled
$53 million.
Total General Fund spending on other expenses is slightly lower in FY 2027, at 27.2%,
compared with 30.6% in FY26. Many City operations are seasonal, and large General Fund
interfund transfers—such as transfers for debt service, the Capital Improvement Program (CIP),
and Charlottesville Area Transit (CAT)—are posted as lump sums later in the fiscal year. In
addition, first-quarter recruiting and procurement activities for the new fiscal year are only
beginning. Together, these factors create an irregular expenditure pattern that is difficult to
project. We will continue to monitor expenditures, but current indicators suggest that expenses
are tracking in line with the budget.
Revenues
As of September 30, 2026, 11.27% or $31,612,388 of the total General Fund Budget has been
collected. Real Estate and Personal Property tax payments for the second half of 2026 are due
on December 5th and represent two of the City’s largest revenue sources. Current revised
projections indicate that total revenues are tracking slightly over budget, by $2,448,808 or
0.93%.
The chart below indicates revenue projections which have been revised for FY 2027 based on
performance. Real Estate and Personal Property projections have been increased to reflect
supplement billings for projects that have been partially completed, and stronger than
Page 104 of 143
ii
anticipated vehicle supplements. Public Service Tax reflects a slight increase based on
completed assessments. Meals and sales tax collections continue to perform stronger than
expected. Interest earnings are continuing to perform strong with rates staying higher for longer
than originally anticipated. Refunds from a Prior Year are higher than expected with Jaunt
returning $225,252 in excess funds from FY 2026. Several state revenues have been adjusted
to reflect the final decisions of the General Assembly. State highway assistance reflects a
statewide reduction of 4% passed on to all localities. State police assistance reflects a revised
projection that remains flat with the FY 2026 funding amount. The proposed state budget
included amendments to increase the amount of police assistance for FY 2027, but the final
budget kept allocations flat.
Capital (CIP) Fund
The City’s current capital budget totals $233.9M with $185M in unspent budget carrying over
from prior years and $48.6M being added in FY 2027. As of the end of Q1, 13.29% or $31.1M
was spent or encumbered for various projects.
FY 2027 FY 2027
Local Taxes Budget Revised* Change
Real Estate Tax 122,152,333 $ 122,615,065 $ 462,732 $
Personal Property Tax 15,100,000 15,400,000 300,000
Public Service Tax 2,048,263 2,163,056 114,793
Utility Taxes 5,020,000 5,371,400 351,400
Virginia Communications Sales and Use Tax 2,000,000 1,950,000 (50,000)
Sales & Use Tax 16,033,000 16,100,000 67,000
Transient Room Tax 9,785,000 10,300,000 515,000
Meals Tax 19,584,000 19,714,286 130,286
Vehicle Daily Rental 135,000 125,000 (10,000)
Revenue from State Agencies
State Highway Assistance 5,926,840 $ 5,810,627 $ (116,213)
Reimbursement/Constitutional Offices 2,457,327 2,485,704 28,377
State Aid for Police Protection 2,734,767 2,681,144 (53,623)
Miscellaneous Revenues
Interest Income 2,700,000 $ 3,300,000 $ 600,000
Refund of Prior Year Expenses 150,000 $ 225,252 $ 75,252
Designated Revenues
Meals Tax Designated for the Debt Service Fund 3,000,000 $ 3,033,804 $ 33,804 $
2,448,808$
*Projected as of October 18, 2026
Surplus/Deficit as a % of Total Adopted Budget 0.93%
Total Revenue Budget Surplus
FY 2027 Revenue Revised Projections
Page 105 of 143
iii
Individual project budget details can be reviewed using the Budget Explorer Tool described
below.
Budget Explorer Tool
Expenditure details can be viewed using the Budget Explorer Tool which can be found on the
City’s Budget webpage at www.charlottesville.gov/budget. These quarterly tabs are
automatically updated at the end of each quarter and are available for public viewing. The 1st
quarter visualization contains financial information through September 30, 2026. The tool gives
you the ability to review the results of other City funds in addition to the General Fund as well as
the ability to drill-down to the individual department expenditure detail. The information
presented in the visualization comes directly from SAP, the City’s financial system, and
represents dollars that have been received and/or paid out as of the chosen date.
Page 106 of 143
Policy Briefing Summary
City Council
Regarding: Public Hearing and Ordinance regarding Petition to Vacate a Portion of
the Swift Lane Right-of-Way adjacent to 1210 Smith Street (Tax Map
and Parcel 490139100)
Staff Contact(s): Deborah D Willard, Paralegal
Presenter: Steven Hicks, Director of Public Works
Date of Proposed
Action:
November 16, 2026
Issue
Stewart Lawrence ("Mr. Lawrence"), a City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City"), resident, has requested
that a 42x46 foot portion of Swift Lane in the City be vacated and closed.
Background / Rule
The requested portion of Swift Lane is an unimproved right-of-way ("ROW") adjacent to Mr. Lawrence's
residence at 1210 Smith Street, being forty-two (42) feet in width and beginning at its intersection with
Smith Street and extending south-west forty-six (46) feet, adjacent to TMP#49013900 and
490139100. If approved, Mr. Lawrence plans on planting trees for shade, extending garden space,
and installing outdoor patio space.
Analysis
Property owners along Swift Lane have been duly notified of the proposed partial street closing and a
Public Hearing Notice has been published pursuant to Virginia Code § 15.2-1813. The subject
property currently is not a through street and Mr. Lawrence will only be taking a portion of the platted
street. Easements must be granted for any existing utilities, and access must be maintained to 1037
Smith Street, located behind 1210 Smith Street. The addition of the subject property to the existing
1210 Smith Street property could open the possibility of development of the property, with additional
units and should be considered when establishing the purchase price.
Revocation of ownership does remove property that the City could use at some point in the future for
utility needs, stormwater facilities, or other unknown public infrastructure. The City could retain the
ability in the future via easement or some other form of covenant to be worked out during the
negotiations.
Financial Impact
The subject property has monetary value that should be established through negotiation. Upon
transfer of ownership, yearly tax revenue could be collected.
Recommendation
Following conducting the Public Hearing legally required by Virginia Code § 15.2-1800(B) to dispose of
publicly-owned property, City Staff recommends that City Council direct the City Attorney to enter
negotiations with Mr. Lawrence over the value of the subject property.
Recommended Motion (if Applicable)
"I make a Motion to direct the City Attorney to enter negotiations with Mr. Lawrence over the value of
the subject property to be potentially disposed of by the City. If the City Attorney and Mr. Lawrence
Page 107 of 143
can reach a agreeable amount to be paid to the City for the disposal of the subject property, the City
Attorney is further directed to place this matter on a future City Council Agenda for potential
vacation/closure of the subject property and sale of the same to Mr. Lawrence."
Attachments
1. ORDINANCE - Partial Closure of Swift Ln. 2026 (1).docxjvhedits (1)
2. PETITION TO VACATE A STREET OR ALLEY_Lawrence Dec 2025_
3. Lawrence_Response_to_Engineering_Memo_Swift_Lane_FINAL
4. SWIFT LANE VACATION Exhibit
Page 108 of 143
#O-__-___
ORDINANCE CLOSING, VACATING, AND DISCONTINUING A PORTION OF THE
UNIMPROVED ROAD KNOWN AS SWIFT LANE
IN THE CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA
WHEREAS, Stewart Lawrence and Victoria Jones (“Applicants”) have petitioned the City of
Charlottesville, Virginia (“City”), to close a 42 x 46 foot portion of Swift Lane (“Subject Street”);
and;
WHEREAS, the portion of Swift Lane that is the subject of this Petition was created circa 1964,
as depicted on a Plat recorded in the City’s land records at Deed Book 266 Page 32-A; and
WHEREAS, notice has been given to the public pursuant to Virginia Code §§ 15.2-2204, 15.2-
2272, and 15.2-2006, and a legally advertised Public Hearing by City Council was held and
conducted on November 16, 2026; and
WHEREAS, after due consideration of the Application, this City Council finds and determines
that Applicants’ request should be granted; now, therefore,
BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, that a 42 x 46 foot
portion of the Subject Street is hereby closed, vacated, and abandoned, and the said area of the
Subject Street, being more particularly described as follows: unimproved right-of-way portion of
Swift Lane adjacent to Applicants’ residence at 1210 Smith Street, being 42 feet in width and
beginning at its intersection with Smith Street and extending southwest 46 feet, adjacent to TMP#s
490139000 and 490139100, as shown on the map attached hereto as Exhibit “A;” and
BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED this Ordinance shall take effect upon enactment. The City
Attorney and City Manager, or their designees, are authorized to take all actions necessary to carry
out the actions authorized by this Ordinance, and, on or after the effective date, to record an attested
copy of this Ordinance within the Street Closing Book in the land records of the Charlottesville
Circuit Court.
Date Introduced: ___________, 2026
Date Adopted: ___________, 2026
Certified: _________________________
Clerk of Council
Page 109 of 143
PETITION TO VACATE A STREET OR ALLEY
Please Return To: Department of Neighborhood Development Services
PO Box 911, City Hall, Charlottesville, Virginia 22902
Telephone (434) 970-3182 Fax (434) 970-3359
FEE: A filing fee of $100.00 made payable to the City of Charlottesville.
A. PETITIONER INFORMATION
Petitioner(S) Name(S):
Stewart Reese Lawrence
Petitioner Malling Address(es):
1210 Smith Street, Char lottesville, Virginia 22901
Do/Does Petitloner(s) currently own property adjacent to the area requested to be closed? Yes
If no, please el(lllain
Petitioner Phone Number(s):
Wooc 804-335-4062
Home:
804-335-4062
Fax
Fax. ________ _
Email
Slawrence1003 @gmail.com
B. ADDRESSES OF PROPERTY OWNERS ADJACENT TO THE STREET/ALLEY (use back of page if necessary)
Property Owner Name Mailing Address City Tax Map and Parcel#
Donald E Shifflett 1037 Swift Lane 490139000
Stewart R Lawrence & Victoria R Jones 1210 Smith Street 490139100
't~ot 1.1000
C. PETITIONER'S REQUEST
1. That the said Petitioner(s) apply for the vacation, closing or discontinuance of a certain st reet or alley,
situated in the City of Charlottesville, Virginia, as described below (Provide name, right-of-way width and length of
That pt&llo?l t9f'SOOffiOt~&o~?fflj·4~ ffMT~rPW16ffffftWf B~ning at its intersection
with Smith Street and extending south west for approximately 46 feet, shown on attached
Plat and Charlottesville G IS Viewer, adjaceot to parcels, 490139000 aod 490139100.
2. Attach all information and documentation requir ed by the City's current policy.
3. Attach a copy of the City real estate/GIS map showing the portion of the street or alley to be vacated with the
square footage dearly indicated.
4. Applicant must review the attached dosing policy prior to submission of th,s form and atta ch a narrative which
addresses the objectives outlined in that policy to include specific informat ion as to why an alley dosing Is being
requested.
Page 110 of 143
Signature of Pet1tioner(s)
If a score on the Rubric allows an application to proceed for cons1derat1on, valid applications will be forwarded to a jomt
Planning Commission and City Council Pubhc Hearing and then to City Council for two readings,
Endorsed by:
a
Victoria R. Jones
- ~
A"'- ro11. ,.✓. c--otc
Page 111 of 143
Stewart R Lawrence
1210 Smith Street
CharlottesviUe, VA 22901
Slawrencel 003@gmail.com
804-335-4062
Charlottesville City Council and Planning Staff
605 E Main St,
Charlottesville, VA 22902
Re: Request to Close and Convey Unimproved Right of Way
Dear Council Members and City Staff,
3 October 2025
My wife and I are writing to respectfully request consideration for the closure and conveyance of
an unimproved right of way adjacent to our home on Smith Street.
When we purchased our home, I was serving overseas on military deployment. In the months
prior, I had saved most of my combat pay with the dream that my wife and I would one day have
a home of our own. When I returned to Charlottesville in the summer of 2024, I struggled to
adjust to civilian life after living through many difficult experiences. I found comfort and
protection in the home we had purchased, and over time, I discovered that working on home
projects helped me heal and reconnect with the world around me- from repairing our deck and
planting a garden to using large, flat rocks donated by a kind neighbor to line our flower bed.
These efforts not only strengthened my sense of peace but also helped me feel more rooted in our
neighborhood and community.
By obtaining the parcel in question, my wife and I hope to continue building upon this progress .
Our vision is to plant trees that will provide shade, extend our garden space, and eventually
create an outdoor patio where friends, family, and neighbors can gather. We believe these
improvements will enhance the beauty and livability of the property, and in tum contribute
positively to the surrounding community.
We sincerely thank you for your time, consideration, and support as we pursue this request.
Respectfully ,
Stewart R. Lawrence
Victoria R. Jones
Page 112 of 143
ll
fi
I
I
I
Book 266 Paga 32-A
l'Jot Showing
Lot n
Conet ~ l Jna or th• lte a idue
of Lot• 2)8 and 2!>9
LOCUST GIIOV£ £XTl:NS10H
Ch arlo~ t ••vill• , Vi r g i n ia
,. ... .... .J.!.LL!-
110
I
L
'
N 41 1• I It • I'.
f I , 0
Ill/I j"'
• .. 8178 "'I • ...
15 I • .
I ~
LOT jB ... . "'
I~
.., ..
• • ... ;
.. " .. • _.,D·.,,~,d
I
r. SW/FY ~ANE l '
I 60
' UHI MP~O Y[ O
' '
.ID/I I J OI
0 ...,
._:
(I)
0
a::
x ....
..,:
(I)
:z: ....
0" p.
\,
WILLIAM S, ROUOAOUSH, JR,
Cf.A1Yll0 t.,0 1 IUllV( YOA
uu11 umo 1U,l I YIU IN A
0.AU : NOY,. ' 1114 ICAt.l ' ~
"" ... ..1.llLL
Page 113 of 143
I'
I
I
"•' 0
LO" •l• tlnc of the lte et due
•' L•\• !\I and 2)f
lOCH~T CkO\[ UTL'~JO~
,. ... .... .L!.t,..!.!..
,,.
;
...... ' ...
.,, .. ,
....
I 41• II •w
SWIF'r 1,ANE:
5 0
" .
; ,. . . ;
-
0 ..,
... .,,
0
Q:
:i? ...
..:
Cl)
:z:
...
:E
Cl)
'tllLUAM S II0UOUUSH, JII
CPffC.t~•,.t ••---• •-
'··-·
I
_J
Page 114 of 143
Page 115 of 143
End of other neighbor’s
property line (Cole); Not
adjacent to parcel in
question.
Adjacent property line
(Schifflett)
Page 116 of 143
1
Stewart Lawrence & Victoria Jones 1210 Smith Street, Charlottesville, VA 22901 Slawrence1003@gmail.com | 804-335-4062 May 12, 2026 Charlottesville City Council 605 East Main Street, Charlottesville, VA 22902 Re: Petitioner Response to Engineering Memorandum on Swift Lane Right-of-Way Closure Dear Council Members and City Staff: We submit this memorandum in response to the April 10, 2026 memorandum from City Engineer Brennen Duncan regarding our petition to vacate a portion of the unimproved Swift Lane right-of-way adjacent to our home at 1210 Smith Street. We are grateful for the Engineering Department's careful analysis, and we agree with most of it. We write to address the points where we respectfully disagree and to propose a path forward. 1. Summary of Position This vacation aligns with the City's interests in three concrete ways. It enables a service-disabled veteran-and-spouse household to invest in the appearance and livability of a Locust Grove block by planting trees, extending a vegetable garden, and creating an outdoor patio space for friends, family, and neighbors to gather. It transfers the maintenance burden of an unused right-of-way from the City to a private owner. And it does so in a way that preserves all current and reasonably foreseeable public uses: the requested parcel is a grassy non-through area bounded by Smith Street, our residence, and the hedge along the Shifflett property line, while the remainder of the Swift Lane right-of-way (the corridor that currently provides access to the adjacent Shifflett property and any future alley-style use the City may identify) remains entirely unaffected by this petition. For background: We purchased our home at 1210 Smith Street two years ago following an extremely challenging counter-terror deployment to central and western Africa. One of the ways I found peace and healing during my difficult transition out of the military was gardening and home improvement projects, as they helped me feel a sense of positive impact and connection to the new community we found ourselves in. At the same time, we became friends with our neighbors on the small dead-end of Smith Street, eventually hosting gatherings in the open grass area next to our home. These experiences led me to seek the closure and conveyance of the grassy, unimproved piece of land that is directly connected to our front yard. In doing so, we hope to provide beauty and care to the land while improving for future benefit of friends, family, neighbors and the Locust Grove community. On the procedural posture: the application satisfies the rubric Council adopted in 2019. The cumulative weighted score of 1.5 falls below the 1.75 threshold for forward movement,1 and on that objective measure the application qualifies for Council consideration. The 2019 Alley Closure Procedures expressly leave the question of purchase price to Council's discretion under Part Three, Section 1(c)(vi),2 and the considerations relevant to that discretion are addressed below. We acknowledge the City's interest in receiving fair value for any conveyance and propose to pay the encumbered value of the parcel rather than seek a no-cost vacation. 2. The 2019 Procedures Leave the Purchase Question to Council's Discretion The 2019 Procedures govern this application, and we have followed them. Part Three, Section 1(c)(vi) of the Procedures asks Council a discrete question: "If the street or alley is currently owned by the City, does City Council desire staff to negotiate a purchase price with the Applicant and other adjoining property owners?"3 By the Procedures' own terms, this is a discretionary question, and Council may answer it either way. Virginia law recognizes two distinct frameworks for street vacations. When a locality holds a right-of-way as a public easement created by subdivision plat, Va. Code Sections 15.2-2272 and 15.2-2274 provide for automatic reversion to abutting lot owners at no cost, subject to existing utility easements.4 Where, as here, the locality holds title in fee, Va. Code Section 15.2-2008 governs and contemplates that Council may set the terms of any
Page 117 of 143
2
conveyance, including price.5 We acknowledge that Section 15.2-2008 is the governing statute for this petition and that Council is not required to convey at no consideration. We ask only that Council exercise its discretion under (vi) informed by the policy rationale that animates the paper-street default: this parcel cannot be put to any productive third-party use, it is bounded by features that prevent independent development, the petition is not associated with any business expansion or replatting, and the abutting petitioners are the only economically rational buyers. Section 1(c)(v) of the Procedures further illuminates the analysis: that provision contemplates conditioning vacations on commencement of business expansion or development,6 with the implication that vacations tied to development merit different treatment than those that are not. This petition is not associated with any business expansion, development, or replatting. The Procedures’ structure recognizes that not all vacations present identical fiscal considerations, and the encumbered-value framework we propose in Section 6 honors both the City's fiscal stewardship obligations under Section 15.2-2008 and the practical reality that this parcel has no realistic buyer other than the abutting owners. 3. The Eight Rubric Criteria Support Closure We accept the Engineer's scoring on all eight rubric items. The cumulative weighted score of 1.5 falls below the 1.75 threshold,7 and the application qualifies for Council consideration. We add three points of context. • Future ADU access is preserved. The petition does not touch the portion of Swift Lane that actually provides access to the rear of the block. The requested parcel is the grassy triangle at the Smith Street intersection, which is geometrically isolated from any potential alley function. As the Engineer’s memorandum confirms, “20’ access for a future alley connection”8 is preserved, and the corridor currently used as access by the Shifflett property remains entirely intact. • Driveway concerns are addressable. We have no plans for a new driveway off Smith Street and would accept a covenant prohibiting any new curb cut as a condition of the vacation. • Utility maintenance is protected. We are prepared to grant any easements the City or adjacent owners reasonably require for maintenance of existing utilities, and we ask only that the form and scope of any such easements be defined before the conveyance is finalized. 4. The Engineer's Concern About Future Public Use The Engineer's recommendation rests primarily on preserving the parcel for potential future City uses, citing examples including gas regulators, water control valves, stormwater facilities, vehicle and bike parking, EV charging, and bus stops. We understand and respect the Engineer's institutional obligation to preserve long-term flexibility for the City, and the rubric criteria appropriately ask Council to weigh that flexibility against the costs of retention. We engage that question directly. The Locust Grove block where Swift Lane terminates is a low-traffic interior residential pocket of single-family homes built between the 1930s and the 2000s. The nearest transit stop, school, and commercial node are each several blocks away; in fact, the city removed a transit stop located one block away--at the corner of Smith Street and St. Clair Avenue--within the last 18 months. The specific infrastructure types listed by the Engineer are typically sited where they connect to active corridors or concentrated demand, neither of which is present at this dead-end stub. Bus stops require active road frontage, which Swift Lane does not have. EV charging and public vehicle or bike parking are generally sited along commercial frontage or at destination nodes, not at residential dead ends. For linear utilities such as gas regulators and water valves, the easements we have offered to grant are sufficient, and the parcel’s small size, sub-minimum lot dimensions, and constrained geometry make it ill-suited for facility-scale infrastructure such as stormwater detention basins in any event. The petition leaves the entire remaining Swift Lane right-of-way intact and available for any future use the City may identify; we are requesting only the grassy non-through area at the Smith Street intersection.
Page 118 of 143
3
5. Responsible Stewardship and the City's Housing Goals The Engineer expresses concern that vacating the parcel without consideration would amount to a donation of land that could later be developed for considerable personal gain. We share the underlying concern about responsible stewardship of public assets, and we address it directly: we are not asking the City to donate the parcel to us. We are prepared to pay the encumbered value the parcel commands, as analyzed in Section 6 below, in addition to bearing the costs of plat preparation, recording, and any necessary easement work. Paying fair encumbered value addresses the stewardship concern without requiring restrictions on the parcel's future use that would conflict with the City's broader housing objectives. We recognize that under Charlottesville's new Development Code, the City has set ambitious goals for expanding its housing supply, and that R-A parcels permit up to three dwelling units per lot by right and up to six with applicable bonuses,9 regardless of lot size. The 2,036 square foot Swift Lane parcel cannot independently support any housing unit, and its conveyance to us therefore does not subtract from the City's housing capacity. Equally important, addressing the stewardship concern through a fair purchase price (rather than through a use-restricting covenant) preserves the full Code-allowed density on our combined parcel for future owners. This approach is consistent with Council's stated commitment to expanding housing supply and avoids creating a precedent in which conveyances of City property are conditioned on permanent reductions in housing potential. We would also accept, as part of a final ordinance, a recorded covenant prohibiting subdivision of the conveyed parcel from 1210 Smith Street so that the parcel cannot later be split off and sold separately. That structural restriction addresses the speculative-sale variant of the gain concern without restricting any housing use of the combined parcel. The conveyance also partially resolves a longstanding gap in the title record. Our sewer service line crosses directly through the requested parcel before connecting to the City main (exhibits attached). A private easement recorded in 1997 authorizes the line’s run across the adjacent Shifflett parcel (Tax Map Parcel 49-139, Deed Book 708, Page 27), but the legal status of the City’s interest in the segment of the line that passes through the Swift Lane right-of-way has never been formally documented, notwithstanding the line’s continuous in-service use since at least 2004. Conveying the requested parcel to us brings the segment of the line within that parcel under our own property, simplifying the title picture for the segment most likely to be implicated in any future use of the area we propose to acquire. A short segment of the line will remain within the unimproved portion of Swift Lane that we are not requesting; we are prepared to grant any easement the City reasonably requires for that remaining segment as part of the final ordinance. 6. Valuation of the Encumbered Parcel Section 6 of the City's 2020 Policy for the Sale of City-Owned Property presumes full fair market value,10 but fair market value depends on the actual character of the property being conveyed. The City Assessor's 2025 land-only valuation of 1210 Smith Street is $131,600 on 0.144 acres,11 implying a per-square-foot rate of approximately $21. Applied to the 2,036 square foot Swift Lane parcel without adjustment, that rate would suggest a hypothetical unencumbered value of roughly $42,700. That figure, however, assumes a buyer who can put the parcel to productive standalone use. No such buyer exists, and four features of this specific parcel materially reduce that figure when actual marketability is considered. • The parcel cannot be sold to any third party for productive standalone use, and the abutting petitioners are the only economically rational buyers. The parcel is bounded on three sides by features that prevent independent productive use: Mr. Shifflett’s gravel driveway, a >2 feet tall curb that limits direct access to Smith Street, and our existing residence. At approximately 2,036 square feet it falls well below the 6,000 square foot R-A district minimum lot size,12 meaning it cannot be developed as an independent lot. It is too small, too constrained, and too geometrically isolated to be marketed to any buyer other than the adjoining property owners. Parcels of this character (sub-minimum in size, saleable only to abutters) are recognized in appraisal practice as “uneconomic remnants” and are valued at a substantial discount to their per-square-foot assessment rate. This is the dispositive marketability fact, and
Page 119 of 143
4
it is truly independent of the encumbrances discussed below; the remaining factors reinforce this conclusion. • An existing sewer line crosses the parcel. Our active sewer service line runs from 1210 Smith Street directly across the parcel to connect to the City sewer at the edge of Mr. Shifflett’s gravel drive. The line’s run across the adjacent Shifflett parcel is authorized by a private easement recorded in 1997 (Deed Book 708, Page 27), establishing the line’s legal permanence as an instrument running with the land.13 The line is not a defect for us; it serves our home as it has served previous owners since 2004. But for any other prospective buyer, the line is a material encumbrance that would require resolving the legal status of the in-service connection, obtaining or reconveying easement rights, and potentially paying to relocate the line at typical Virginia residential costs ranging from approximately $1,000 to $20,000.14 The City does not need to absorb that cost through a reduced price; rather, the encumbrance simply confirms that no third-party buyer would pay full unencumbered value for a parcel that comes with an in-service line serving someone else’s home. • The parcel sits directly across from an electrical substation. Proximity to electrical infrastructure is a recognized depressant on residential land values in the appraisal literature, with peer-reviewed studies finding statistically significant discounts for properties in close proximity to substations and high-voltage lines, generally in the range of approximately two to nine percent and dissipating with distance.15 • The terrain is uneven and slopes across the parcel. The parcel slopes meaningfully across its narrow dimension. Any productive use requires grading and site preparation that, for a parcel this size, would consume a portion of the parcel’s hypothetical value before any improvement could be placed on it. The site photographs included in the attached exhibits reflect the existing topographic condition, where the position of the photographer is approximately three to four feet below Smith Street. Putting these factors together yields a transparent walk-down from the hypothetical unencumbered figure to a defensible conveyance range: • Starting point: Approximately $42,700 (2,036 SF at the $21/SF rate implied by the 1210 Smith Street assessment), assuming an unencumbered, independently marketable parcel. • Adjustment for non-marketability to any third party (sub-minimum lot size, geometric isolation, sewer line encumbrance): A 60 to 70 percent reduction. The uneconomic-remnant framework discussed above supports substantial discounts for parcels that cannot be developed independently and have no market beyond the abutting owner. Applied here, this brings the figure to approximately $12,800 to $17,100. • Adjustment for substation proximity: An additional 3 to 5 percent reduction at the midpoint of the appraisal literature, bringing the figure to approximately $12,100 to $16,500. • Adjustment for terrain and site preparation: An additional reduction of 10-15% to reflect grading and site preparation costs of $1,500 to $2,500 that would be required before any productive use, modestly applied given the parcel’s small size. Together, these adjustments support a defensible conveyance range of approximately $10,000 to $15,000. This range honors the stewardship presumption of the 2020 Policy and Va. Code Section 15.2-2008 by establishing meaningful consideration tied to a transparent walk-down, while reflecting the parcel’s actual marketability. We would welcome the opportunity to engage with the City Assessor or an independent appraiser to refine this range, and we are prepared to bear the reasonable costs of plat preparation, recording, and any necessary easement work in addition to the conveyance price.
Page 120 of 143
5
7. Requested Action
We respectfully request that Council approve the petition for vacation of the requested portion of Swift Lane on
the following terms:
• Conveyance of the vacated parcel to the petitioners at a price reflecting the parcel's encumbered character,
as analyzed in Section 6, with the petitioners participating in the valuation process alongside the City
Assessor or an independent appraiser;
• Reservation of any utility easements reasonably required for maintenance of existing utilities;
• A recorded covenant prohibiting subdivision of the conveyed parcel from 1210 Smith Street, ensuring the
parcel cannot be split off and sold separately for development; and
• Petitioners to bear the reasonable costs of plat preparation, recording, and any necessary easement work.
If Council approves the petition, the practical result within two years will be visible from Swift Lane and Smith
Street: trees and a vegetable garden where the barren stub now stands, a maintained patio area for neighborhood
gatherings, and clean title separating the abutting owners’ properties from a City right-of-way that has served no
public function for decades. The net cost to the City is zero; the City receives meaningful consideration and is
relieved of maintenance responsibility for an unused stub. The benefit to the block, and to a veteran-and-spouse
household investing in their community, is substantial.
We are grateful for the time the Engineering Department has spent on this matter and for Council's careful
consideration. We have asked that the public hearing be scheduled in September or October to accommodate
professional commitments out of state through the summer, and we appreciate the City's flexibility on timing.
Respectfully submitted,
Stewart Lawrence
Victoria Jones
1210 Smith Street, Charlottesville, VA 22901
~
Page 121 of 143
6
Endnotes 1 Resolution Approving Updated Procedures for the Alteration of Streets, Alleys, Public Rights-of-Way and Public Easements (Charlottesville City Council, Sept. 16, 2019); see also City of Charlottesville Memorandum from Brennen Duncan, P.E., to Steven Hicks, Subject: Swift Lane RW Closure (Apr. 10, 2026), at 2 (calculating cumulative weighted score of 1.5). 2 City Council Procedures for Consideration of Applications Seeking Alteration or Vacation of Public Easements, or of Certain Public or Private Streets/Alleys, or Public Rights of Way, Part Three, Section 1(c)(vi) (Charlottesville, revised Sept. 16, 2019). 3 Id. 4 Va. Code Ann. § 15.2-2274 ("The recordation of the instrument as provided under subdivision 1 of § 15.2-2272 or of the ordinance as provided under subdivision 2 of § 15.2-2272 shall operate to destroy the force and effect of the recording of the plat or part thereof so vacated, and to vest fee simple title to the centerline of any streets, alleys or easements for public passage so vacated in the owners of abutting lots free and clear of any rights of the public or other owners of lots shown on the plat, but subject to the rights of the owners of any public utility installations which have been previously erected therein."); Va. Code Ann. § 15.2-2272. 5 Va. Code Ann. § 15.2-2008 (authorizing localities to convey, lease, or otherwise dispose of real property held in fee on such terms and conditions as the governing body may prescribe). For a discussion distinguishing the automatic reversion framework of § 15.2-2272 from the conditional conveyance framework of § 15.2-2008, see Examining Title to Streets - Part II, Virginia Land Title Association Examiner (Sept. 15, 2022). 6 City Council Procedures, supra note 2, Part Three, Section 1(c)(v). 7 Resolution Approving 2019 Procedures, supra note 1; see also City of Charlottesville Memorandum from Brennen Duncan, supra note 1, at 2 (calculating cumulative weighted score of 1.5). 8 City of Charlottesville Memorandum from Brennen Duncan, supra note 1, at 1. 9 Charlottesville Development Code § 2.2.2.A.2 (R-A density: maximum three dwellings per lot base; four with existing structure preservation bonus; six with affordable dwelling unit bonus). 10 Policy for the Sale of City-Owned Property, Section 6 (Charlottesville, adopted Jan. 3, 2005, revised Sept. 8, 2020). 11 City of Charlottesville, 2025 Real Estate Tax Assessment for 1210 Smith Street, Tax Map and Parcel 490139100 (Lot B, Locust Grove Extension; 0.144 acres; land assessment $131,600; improvements $258,000; total $389,600). 12 Charlottesville Development Code § 2.2.2.A.1 (effective Feb. 19, 2024) (R-A district minimum lot area of 6,000 SF). 13 See City of Charlottesville GIS Viewer, Swift Lane Utilities Map (depicting active sewer service line from 1210 Smith Street crossing the requested parcel and connecting at the edge of 1037 Swift Lane). The map is attached as an exhibit. For the recorded private easement authorizing the line’s run across Tax Map Parcel 49-139, see Easement Agreement between Donald E. Shifflett (Grantor) and E. Grant Cosner (Grantee), dated Nov. 26, 1997, recorded Dec. 5, 1997, Charlottesville Circuit Court Deed Book 708, Page 27 (also an exhibit). 14 For typical Virginia residential sewer line replacement costs, see Caffi Services, How Much Does It Cost to Replace a Sewer Line? (Feb. 26, 2026), https://www.caffiservices.com/blog/how-much-to-replace-sewer-line/ (reporting Virginia average of approximately $3,500 with a range of $1,000 to $20,000 depending on length, depth, and access conditions); Angi, How Much Does Sewer Line Replacement Cost? [2026 Data] (Mar. 17, 2026), https://www.angi.com/articles/how-much-does-sewer-line-replacement-or-repair-cost.htm. 15 See Ted Tatos, Mark Glick & Troy A. Lunt, Property Value Impacts from Transmission Lines, Subtransmission Lines, and Substations, 84 Appraisal J. 205 (Summer 2016) (finding statistically significant value decreases for single-family homes within 50 meters of substations and certain transmission lines, with effects diminishing with distance); Thomas O. Jackson & Jennifer Pitts, The Effects of Electric Transmission Lines on Property Values: A Literature Review, 18 J. Real Est. Literature 239 (2010) (reviewing the literature and reporting that observed effects, where present, generally range from approximately two to nine percent and tend to dissipate with distance and time); Lita Furby et al., Electric Power Transmission Lines, Property Values, and Compensation, 27 J. Envtl. Mgmt. 69 (1988).
Page 122 of 143
0 15 30 60 Feet
G
12-10
Swift Lane, Charlottesville, VA
'= l!li)
:E
'= .....,
~
l!li)
Page 123 of 143
Page 124 of 143
70
0 7
( I
•
I .
r
•
•
•
0 RAPH IC SCALE
----
• . . ,,,.., . . .
SOOK 708PA6 27
~ •• "'· tar
PLAT SHOWING EASEMENT
,oR PRIVATE SANITARY SEWER LINE
ACROSS PARCEL 159 TAX MAP 48
LOCUST GROVE EXTENSION
CHAIILOJ fllYIU.!. VlttJNIA
-
.,
I
I
L::7
tM.4 B9. w
~
....
~,
.-¥
Fi
Sl~E
~ l
-· I
LDT A
tll flalU
•
D vid o l1n
Lie. No. l
•
.___, --
ROUDABUSH. GALE & ASSOC .. INC.
LlJ
w
~ V)
X
.... -2
V)
'
ICAL 1 ___ _
DAff : ocr 3Qm1
A P'Tofeetlonef C0tpo,edon
C!RTlftlO LANO IU"VE.YOfl lNOINl 111
a..ton..1i. , v.,_.,.
, I ' • • ,1 • • • I • ' • Ii • • t t
• - . - ---• •
-- .. ,. ··---.. . •
. - -
I •
I
I
• •
• • ,
I
•
I
I
I
•
•
Page 125 of 143
SWIFT LANE VACATION
Page 126 of 143
Policy Briefing Summary
City Council
Regarding: Ordinance Amending and Re-Ordaining Chapter 14 (Licenses), Section
14-24 (Tax Incentives for Technology Businesses) to Extend Eligibility
Period for Five (5) Years to December 31, 2031 (2nd reading)
Staff Contact(s): Chris Engel, Director of Economic Development, Todd Divers,
Commissioner of the Revenue, Matt Johnson, Assistant Director of
Economic Development
Presenter: Chris Engel, Director of Economic Development
Date of Proposed
Action:
November 16, 2026
Issue
The Charlottesville Technology Zone Program ("Program") allows qualifying businesses a reduction in
their Business Professional and Occupational License ("BPOL") tax. The reduction is based on the
amount of annual gross receipts and is set to a sliding scale. The Program's purpose is to help
advance early-stage technology businesses through their initial years and scale their growth, while
creating local job opportunities.
Background / Rule
The City of Charlottesville, Virginia ("City"), was the first city in Virginia to offer the incentive and has
done so since first enabled in 2001. City Council previously reauthorized the Program's Ordinance in
2006, 2011, 2016, and 2021. The current Ordinance expires December 31, 2026, unless reauthorized.
Analysis
From 2022 through 2026, a total of 154 applications have received benefits from the Program. This
Agenda item aligns with City Council’s vision for Economic Prosperity by promoting small business
growth and diversification in the City.
Financial Impact
This Program impacts the City's General Fund. Over the past five (5) years, the credits issued under
this Program have resulted in an average annual reduction of $109,124 in BPOL revenue. BPOL
revenue for FY 2021 through FY 2025 ranged from $7.6 - $10.7 million annually.
Recommendation
City Staff recommends City Council adopt the attached, amended Ordinance reauthorizing the
Program for another five (5) years as presented.
Recommended Motion (if Applicable)
"I Move to adopt the attached, amended Ordinance reauthorizing the Charlottesville Technology Zone
Program for another five (5) years."
Attachments
1. techzonecitycodeamendmentsordinance
2. Tech Zone Credits and Employment Charts
Page 127 of 143
#O-26-___
AN ORDINANCE AMENDING AND RE-ORDAINING CHAPTER 14 (LICENSES),
SECTION 14-24 (TAX INCENTIVES FOR TECHNOLOGY BUSINESSES) TO EXTEND
ELIGIBILITY PERIOD FOR FIVE YEARS TO DECEMBER 31, 2031
BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia that Section
14-24 of Chapter 14 of the Charlottesville City Code, 1990, as amended, is hereby amended and
reordained, as follows:
Sec. 14-24. - Tax incentives for technology businesses.
(a) A "qualified technology business" is a business which meets each of the following criteria:
(1) The business must constitute a "technology business," as that term is defined within
chapter 2, article XIV of this Code;
(2) The business must not be operating under a certificate of public convenience issued
by the Virginia State Corporation Commission;
(3) The business must not be engaged in the provision of a "utility service" as that term
is defined within section 30-221 of this Code;
(4) The business must certify that it expects to be engaged in a technology business
throughout the tax year for which a reduction is sought (or, for new technology
businesses which had not commenced doing business as of January 1 of the tax year
for which application is made, for the balance of the tax year); and
(5) The business must have submitted an application for qualification to the
commissioner of revenue, on or before March 1 st of the tax year for which a
reduction of taxes is sought under this section. A separate application shall be
required for each tax year. A business seeking to obtain a reduction of taxes under
this section shall have the burden of demonstrating, to the satisfaction of the
commissioner, that it meets the definition of a technology business and that
it meets all applicable criteria for a reduction.
(b) The following incentives, in the form of reduction of taxes owed, shall be available
to qualified technology businesses:
(1) For a qualified technology business whose gross receipts from a technology
business subject to licensure are one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000.00) or
less, any license fee which would otherwise be required by this chapter shall be
reduced by one hundred percent (100%) for no more than seven (7) tax years.
(2) A qualified technology business whose gross receipts from a technology business
subject to licensure are more than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000.00) shall
Page 128 of 143
receive a fifty percent (50%) reduction of any taxes owed pursuant to this
chapter for no more than seven (7) tax years.
(c) Where a qualified technology business' license tax is determined pursuant to subsection
14-13(c) of this chapter, the commissioner shall determine the appropriate reduction based
on the actual tax owed by the business for a tax year, as may be corrected by the
commissioner.
(d) Except as otherwise specifically provided, nothing set forth within this section shall affect
a technology business' status or classification for tax purposes, its obligation to report
gross receipts and to file tax returns, or to pay any license issuance fees or local taxes under
this chapter. Nothing contained in this section shall relieve any technology business from
its obligation to comply with the requirements of section 14-11, or any other section, of
this chapter.
(e) The tax incentives provided by this section shall be available to qualified technology
businesses through the tax year ending on December 31, 2031. A qualified technology
business shall receive the applicable tax reduction for no more than seven (7) tax years.
Approved by Council
__________ ____, 2026
__________________
Kyna Thomas, MMC
Clerk of Council
Aye No
Fleisher ___ ___
Oschrin ___ ___
Payne ___ ___
Snook ___ ___
Wade ___ ___
Page 129 of 143
Page 130 of 143
Policy Briefing Summary
City Council
Regarding: Resolution to Appropriate $67,667 from the City's low-barrier shelter
operations fund to SupportWorks Housing for Vista 29 (2nd reading)
Staff Contact(s): Steven King, Assistant to the City Manager
Presenter: Allison Bogdanovic
Date of Proposed
Action:
November 16, 2026
Issue
Support Works Housing is seeking $67,667 in connection with Vista 29's first year of supportive
services for tenants.
Background / Rule
Vista 29 will deliver 80 deeply affordable, supportive living spaces in a transit-accessible location. By
combining secure housing with robust on-site services, SupportWorks aims to help formerly homeless
residents transition into stable, long-term housing.
Analysis
SupportWorks Housing is requesting a one-time contribution of $67,667 from the City of Charlottesville
to support first-year onsite supportive services at Vista 29, the region’s newest permanent supportive
housing community.
The total cost to launch first-year services is $200,000, with SupportWorks seeking an equal three-way
partnership among the City, Albemarle County, and the Charlottesville Area Community Foundation.
The requested funding would support two new full-time roles: a Senior Case Manager/Clinical Lead
and a Housing Specialist/Case Manager, as well as administrative support and benefits/payroll costs.
These positions are intended to provide clinical oversight, crisis intervention, housing stabilization,
landlord engagement, and resident support services essential to long-term housing retention.
SupportWorks views this as a bridge-year request. The organization indicates it will apply for Virginia
Housing Trust Fund supportive services funding once Vista 29 is operational, with anticipated state
award notifications in spring 2027.
Financial Impact
Funds previously appropriated in the City's General Fund for low barrier shelter operations will be used
to fund this request.
Recommendation
Staff recommends approval of the resolution.
Recommended Motion (if Applicable)
Attachments
1. Vista 29 Presentation October 2026 packet
2. FY27 SupportWorks Resolution
Page 131 of 143
Page 132 of 143
Vista 29
80 supportive homes
Thank you to our Partners
Charlottesville $936,722
Albemarle $3,477,970
CACF $500,000
TJPDC $500,000
Foundations $962,947
HUD CPF/CDI $500,000
Virginia DHCD $6,400,000
VH Perm Loan $1,646,500
Equity $12,861,598
$27,785,737
Opening December 2026
Page 133 of 143
Outdoor gathering space
Thank you to our
development and
service partners
Page 134 of 143
Model Apartment
Page 135 of 143
Our Residents
Meet Mrs. Powell & her case manager Monica
Page 136 of 143
Our Homeless Service Programs in Charlottesville
Six dedicated outreach & support services specialists
Page 137 of 143
RESOLUTION
Resolution to Reallocate $67,667 Originally Appropriated for Low Barrier Shelter
Operations to Support Works Housing Vista29 project as One-Time Investment
WHEREAS the City Council of the City of Charlottesville, VA adopted an ordinance on April
14, 2026 (“the Budget Ordinance”), setting a budget in the amount of $500,000 to be used in FY
2027 for Low Barrier Shelter Operations; and
WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville is committed to supporting transitional and permanent
housing solutions for individuals and families emerging from homelessness; and
WHEREAS, Vista 29 is intended to provide 80 deeply affordable units with 66 units reserved to
serve as transitional housing for formerly homeless individuals, providing a stable residential
environment as they work toward long-term housing stability; and
WHEREAS, Support Works Housing has identified a need for additional staffing capacity in
order to adequately support tenants residing at Vista 29 and to ensure the success of the
transitional housing program; and
WHEREAS, the City recognizes that supportive services are essential to helping formerly
homeless individuals maintain housing, improve health and well-being, and progress toward
self‑sufficiency;
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, that $67,667
of the $500,000 previously appropriated as part of the FY 2027 Budget Ordinance to be used for
low barrier shelter operations is hereby approved to use for a one-time investment in the Vista29
project.
Expenditure:
$67,667 Fund: 105 Cost Center: 9773006000 GL Code: 540100
Page 138 of 143
Policy Briefing Summary
City Council
Regarding: Ordinance Amending City Code Sections 2-8, 2-37 AND 2-455
Concerning Board and Commission Membership
Staff Contact(s): John Maddux, City Attorney
Presenter: John Maddux, City Attorney
Date of Proposed
Action:
November 16, 2026
Issue
Whether to amend City Code Sections 2-8, 2-37, and 2-455 to provide for holdover service, allow an
additional term for CRHA and PCOB members, and expand eligibility for one CRHA resident seat.
Background / Rule
City Code generally limits board and commission members to two complete terms, or four complete
terms for boards with two-year terms. PCOB also has an eight-year consecutive-service limit. CRHA’s
membership requirements reserve at least two seats for public-housing residents. Federal regulations
generally require at least one eligible resident commissioner on a housing authority board.
Analysis
The ordinance makes three changes:
1. Members would continue serving after their terms expire until their successors are selected and
qualified, subject to controlling law and governing agreements. This provides continuity without
beginning a new term.
2. CRHA commissioners other than Council members could serve three complete three-year
terms. PCOB members could serve five complete two-year terms, subject to a ten-year
consecutive-service limit. Prior service would continue to count.
3. One required CRHA resident seat could be filled by a recipient of CRHA-administered Section 8
assistance, including tenant-based or project-based vouchers. At least one seat would remain
reserved for a public-housing resident who meets federal eligibility requirements.
These changes allow Council to retain experienced members and broaden resident representation as
CRHA redevelops its properties. Reappointment would remain within Council’s discretion.
Financial Impact
No direct financial impact is anticipated.
Recommendation
Adopt the proposed ordinance.
Recommended Motion (if Applicable)
I move to adopt the ordinance as presented amending City Code Sections 2-8, 2-37, and 2-455
concerning board and commission membership.
Attachments
Page 139 of 143
1. Boards and Commissions Terms Ordinance - V1
Page 140 of 143
1
ORDINANCE AMENDING CITY CODE SECTIONS 2-8, 2-37 AND 2-455
CONCERNING BOARD AND COMMISSION MEMBERSHIP
WHEREAS, City Council wishes to provide for continued service on boards and commissions
until successors are selected; and
WHEREAS, City Council wishes to allow an additional term for members of the Charlottesville
Redevelopment and Housing Authority and the Police Civilian Oversight Board, and allow one of
the Authority’s required resident seats to be filled by a recipient of Section 8 assistance
administered by the Authority;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville:
1. That section 2-8 of the Charlottesville City Code is hereby amended to read as
follows:
Sec. 2-8. Limitation on terms of members of boards and commissions;
holdover service.
(a) Unless otherwise provided, no person shall be appointed by the city
council to any board or commission for more than two (2) complete
terms. For boards and commissions with two-year terms, no person shall
be appointed by the city council for more than four (4) complete terms,
unless otherwise provided.
(b) Appointments by the city council to any board or commission to fill
vacancies shall be for the unexpired portion of the term only.
(c) Persons initially appointed for less than a full term may thereafter serve
the maximum number of complete terms permitted for that board or
commission.
(d) Except as otherwise required by law or a governing agreement,
members of boards, commissions, authorities and committees selected
by city council or another city official or body shall continue to serve
after their terms expire until their successors are selected and qualified.
Holdover service is permitted notwithstanding any term or service limit
in this Code and does not begin a new term or alter established term
dates. This subsection does not affect removal, resignation or required
qualifications.
Page 141 of 143
2
2. That subsection (b) and (d) of section 2-37 of the Charlottesville City Code are hereby amended
to read as follows:
(b) Effective July 31, 1999 there shall be seven (7) commissioners of the
Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority appointed by city council.
The board of commissioners shall include:
(1) At least one (1) member of city council;
(2) At least two (2) current residents of public housing administered by the
authority, except that no more than one (1) of these seats may instead be
filled by a person receiving housing assistance under Section 8 of the United
States Housing Act of 1937, as amended, administered by the authority.
The remaining members of the board of commissioners shall be appointed
by city council from the public at-large.
(d) Any member of city council appointed to the board of commissioners shall
serve a one (1) year term and shall be eligible for reappointment for so long as
such person is a member of city council. All other commissioners shall be
appointed for three (3) year terms and may serve no more than three (3)
complete terms.
3. That subsection (d) of section 2-455 of the Charlottesville City Code, as amended by Ordinance
O-26-137, is hereby amended to read as follows:
(d) Terms. Members shall be appointed for two (2) year terms and may serve no
more than five (5) complete terms, subject to a limit of ten (10) consecutive years.
No person shall be appointed or reappointed to a term that, if completed, would
exceed that limit. Service in an unexpired term shall not count toward that limit.
Service in a term under this article as it existed before September 21, 2026, shall be
credited as the number of years in that term. Members serving on September 21,
2026, shall complete their then-current terms; the composition requirements and
term length adopted on that date apply to appointments and reappointments made
on or after that date. Except as otherwise provided in this subsection, section 2-8
applies.
4. This ordinance takes effect upon adoption. The amended resident-seat requirements apply to
appointments and reappointments made thereafter. Prior service continues to count toward
applicable limits.
Page 142 of 143
Policy Briefing Summary
City Council
Regarding: Vinegar Hill Group Presentation
Staff Contact(s): Mayor Juandiego Wade
Presenter: Vinegar Hill Group
Date of Proposed
Action:
November 16, 2026
Issue
An update on the Vinegar Hill Legacy Memorial Council’s work to honor the neighborhood and its
history, presented on the fifteenth anniversary of the City’s formal apology for its role in Vinegar Hill’s
destruction.
Background / Rule
Vinegar Hill was a center of African American community life in Charlottesville. Its destruction through
Urban Renewal displaced residents, businesses, and a church that had been built over generations.
On Nov. 7, 2011, City Council formally apologized for the City government’s role in the destruction of
the neighborhood and acknowledged that those impacted had not been included in the decision-
making process.
Every month since April, 2025 — for the last 18 months — the Vinegar Hill Legacy Memorial Council
has met to develop community priorities for preserving and sharing the history of the Vinegar Hill
neighborhood. With research and logistical support from the Jefferson School African American
Heritage Center’s Center for Local Knowledge, the group is advancing a set of proposals for future
interpretation that are crafted and guided by former Vinegar Hill residents, their families, and members
of Charlottesville’s Black community.
The presentation will share the group’s work to date and its developing vision for memorialization and
ongoing future recognition.
Analysis
n/a
Financial Impact
No appropriation is requested as part of this informational briefing. Any future request for City funding
will be presented separately.
Recommendation
Receive the presentation and discuss next steps for continued collaboration with the Vinegar Hill
Legacy Memorial Council.
Recommended Motion (if Applicable)
n/a
Attachments
None
Page 143 of 143
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.