RecordWell Data

Police Civilian Oversight Board — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Police Civilian Oversight Board · meeting of Nov 12, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CHARLOTTESVILLE POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD MEETING MINUTES Date: October 8, 2026 Scheduled Time: 6:30 p.m., Regular Session Location: CitySpace, 100 5th St NE, Charlottesville, VA 22902; virtual participation was available Board Members Attending: Dr. Jeffrey Fracher, Dr. Kyle Dobson (remote), George Dillard Jr., Albe LaFave, Nathalie Reaves, Ruairi Vaughan Board Members Not Attending: Caron LeNoir-Kelly, Andrew Frye Staff Present: James Walker, Director, Office of Police Civilian Oversight Guests: None Call to Order: • Chair Dr. Fracher called the meeting to order at 6:45pm. He reviewed the rules for public participation and public comments and the procedure for submitting questions in writing. • Mr. Walker conducted roll call. Six Board members were present, constituting a quorum. Agenda & Minutes Approval: • A motion to approve the October 8, 2026 agenda as presented was made by Mr. LaFave and seconded by Mr. Vaughn. The Chair called for a vote. The motion was approved unanimously by members present. • A motion to approve the September 10, 2026 meeting minutes as written was made by Mr. Vaughn and seconded by Mr. LaFave. The Chair called for a vote. The motion was approved unanimously by members present. Announcements: Board Retreat • Mr. Walker reported that he has reserved the Hillsdale Conference Center for the Board retreat on Sunday, November 8. The retreat will take place from 1:30 to 5:00 or 5:30, followed by dinner. Dr. Fracher identified Lauren Shepard as the facilitator and encouraged members to attend. Board Calendar and Upcoming Events • Mr. Walker asked members to review the Board calendar for fall outreach opportunities, including CPD activities at the Boys and Girls Club at 3:30pm on Wednesdays as well as Thursday community walks. In addition, Mr. Walker and PCOB members are visiting The Haven on the last Monday of each month at 9:00 a.m. The next CPD command staff meeting (CompStat) is scheduled for October 21 at 9:15 a.m. Board Member Check-Ins • Dr. Fracher asked board members if they have anything to report, comments, questions, or recommendations. • Mrs. Reaves reported getting feedback from one of the parents she works with about both good and bad experiences with CPD. • Mr. Vaughn attended a meeting with police and hospitality-industry representatives concerning the temporary shelter. He reported that people seemed impressed with the way that police were handling interactions with residents, but representatives also noted that regular check-ins from police seemed to have fallen off in recent weeks. • Mr. LaFave indicated he went on a ride along and had a very positive experience. He wanted to write a letter commending the officer's conduct. Mr. Walker recommended sending any personal appreciation to the Chief of Police and copying Mr. Walker. • Dr. Fracher, Mr. Walker and Dr. Dobson described an initial visit to The Haven in which 11 surveys were collected. The Haven invited them back for monthly visits. The goal is to develop relationships and listen to community concerns. Mr. Walker agreed to seek City Attorney guidance on whether participation by multiple Board members at Board- organized outreach raises public-meeting requirements. • Dr. Dobson reported outreach with local businesses around the Downtown Mall, and interest in continuing conversations and distributing surveys with the help of his students. • Mr. Vaughan and members discussed police interactions involving the temporary housing shelter and the possibility of doing outreach there. A possible future meeting with shelter leadership was mentioned; no formal action was taken. • Mr. Dillard reported listening to community members at neighborhood association meetings. Said he would relay forthcoming meeting invitations to Mr. Walker so more members could participate. Public Comment (First Period): • No public comment was received. Making Connections - Listening to the Community's Voice: Outreach coordination and messaging • Mr. Walker presented a survey action plan and asked members to identify community organizations they would contact, report these selections to the Office, and coordinate efforts to avoid duplication. Dr. Dobson and Mr. Vaughan had identified groups for outreach; Mr. Dillard is the key contact for the NAACP. • Members discussed the importance of direct, sustained engagement, particularly through neighborhood meetings, local businesses, The Haven and groups not yet reached. The Chair and Vice Chair expected to follow up with members regarding outreach commitments. • Mr. Walker reviewed a Board messaging guide with suggested talking points on the Board’s purpose, why it seeks community input, anonymous surveys and how comments may inform its communication with City leadership. Members were reminded not to guess when answering questions about PCOB authority and to refer uncertain questions to Office staff. • Available outreach resources include online surveys, QR-code cards, paper survey cards, larger signs and Office-provided materials for outreach tables. The Office planned to order approximately 1,000 small paper survey cards. Members were encouraged to request materials for smaller community events where dialogue could be more substantive. • Mr. Walker described plans to fill an Operations and Engagement Specialist position to support Office operations and community-outreach coordination. The position had not yet been filled at the time of the meeting. Complaint handling and case-review pathway • In response to Board questions, Mr. Walker explained that complaints submitted to the Office are documented and, when appropriate, referred to CPD Internal Affairs for investigation. Once the Department finalizes the investigative process, all cases will return to the Board for review and possible findings or recommendations. • Mr. Walker reported three August submissions to the Office; one resolved through direct communication and two formal complaints referred to Internal Affairs and still pending. He distinguished inquiries and requests for information from formal complaints. He also indicated that approximately 50 earlier complaints had been received under a prior framework with a more limited Board role. • The Office had begun to receive digital access to Internal Affairs case materials through Axon, including body-worn camera footage; several cases were nearing closure. Mr. Walker stated that written operating procedures for intake and monitoring remained to be developed. Survey results and limitations • Mr. Walker reported a total of 41 survey responses, 21 more than at the prior meeting. The updated visualization indicated an eight-point decline in average trust compared with the prior set of responses. Approximately 46% of respondents rated trust above 70, and average perceived values alignment was 3.8 out of 7 for police compared with 4.9 out of 7 for the community. • Staff displayed respondent distributions, demographic comparisons and selected written comments describing both positive and critical experiences of policing. Members discussed the usefulness of viewing differences across groups and the need to increase responses from communities currently underrepresented in outreach. • Members and staff expressly cautioned that the small, nonrepresentative sample could not support reliable conclusions about the broader Charlottesville population. Budget Season - Recommendations for Fiscal Year 2028: Office of Police Civilian Oversight • Mr. Walker introduced the fiscal year 2028 budget planning cycle, which begins well before the July 1, 2027 fiscal-year start. He explained that the Office has two budgeted full-time positions but has operated with one vacant position, and that the operating budget is separate from salaries and benefits. • The Office operating budget was described as approximately $125,000 in fiscal year 2026 and $104,600 in fiscal year 2027. Mr. Walker described anticipated needs for legal review, training, printed outreach materials and food or refreshments supporting community engagement. Members were invited to submit their budget perspectives before the Office presentation to City management. Charlottesville Police Department • Mr. Walker reviewed CPD budget and expenditure trends for fiscal years 2022 through 2026, including salaries and benefits, personnel vacancies, overtime, vehicles, equipment, special events and technology costs. Budget underuse related to previously unfilled sworn positions and rising technology spending were discussed. • The materials were presented as background rather than a proposed Board recommendation. • Mr. Walker anticipated CPD would present its fiscal year 2028 request internally around late November or early December, after which the Board could review the proposal and consider recommendations. Discussion suggested a practical window through approximately February for Board input. No budget recommendation or vote was made at this meeting. • Members also briefly discussed the Board’s ability to propose state legislative changes, including possible changes to rules governing closed-session consideration of confidential case materials. No motion was made on this topic. Case Review Initiation - Setting a Schedule: • Mr. Walker reiterated that digital access to case files had been established and that multiple Internal Affairs cases were approaching closure. Review would begin after cases were finalized by CPD and reviewed by the Chief. • Mr. Walker circulated a list of CPD General Orders relevant to expected case reviews and asked members to prioritize policies and share initial reactions. Topics discussed included officer courtesy, truthfulness, stops, detention and foot patrols. He noted that foot-patrol expectations appeared in general mission and objectives policy sections rather than a separate detailed policy. • Members could take the priority list home and request complete General Orders from the Office. Staff emphasized that case review would provide an opportunity for the Board to assess policy application and recommend changes. Public Comment (Second Period): • Joshua Barr, City Chief Prosperity Officer, urged members to select organizations from the outreach list, use their existing relationships to distribute the brief survey and collect community input. He emphasized that a larger network of community participation would strengthen the Board’s ability to make recommendations to City leaders. Adjournment: • A motion to adjourn was made by Dr. Fracher and seconded by Mr. LaFave. The motion was approved unanimously by members present. • Meeting adjourned at 8:20pm. Police Civilian Oversight Board Retreat | November 8, 2026 Summary of Discussion Themes | Outreach • Monitor • Audit • Review OVERVIEW The retreat discussions centered on strengthening public trust through transparent, meaningful civilian oversight and sustained engagement with Charlottesville residents. Outreach should elevate diverse community experiences and communicate the Board’s work, while monitoring should deepen understanding of police practices and departmental culture. Audits can use objective data to identify disparities and inform practical, proactive improvements, and reviews can bring a fair civilian perspective to accountability. Across all four functions, participants emphasized collaboration, measurable outcomes, and following identified concerns with feasible action. OUTREACH Build two-way relationships with Charlottesville’s diverse communities so residents understand the PCOB and feel comfortable sharing experiences and ideas. • Focus: Communicate Board work with evidence, listen to underrepresented voices, and understand lived experiences, gaps and opportunities in public safety. • Application: Offer varied ways to participate, such as community events or an open house; pursue collaboration and shared ownership of public safety. • Success measures: Greater public awareness, consistent engagement across community groups, residents approaching the Board directly, and increased transparency and trust. MONITOR Build an informed, ongoing understanding of CPD activities, personnel and culture, while fostering working relationships that support constructive change. • Focus: Define “quality policing” and effective monitoring; keep the process understandable, accessible and free from biased language. • Application: Strengthen Board self-education and relationships with CPD leadership and line officers; establish regular monitoring opportunities and sign-ups. • Questions: How can the Board distinguish individual conduct from broader departmental culture, communicate concerns, and use observations to shape audits and review criteria? AUDIT Use objective examination of policing practices and data to strengthen transparency, identify potential misconduct or disparities, and inform feasible prevention and policy changes. • Focus: Consider traffic-stop audits, racial-disparity information, and data concerning youth and people experiencing homelessness; confirm which topics communities want examined. • Application: Translate findings into proactive, agency-wide improvements rather than simply identifying problems; share results publicly. • Questions: How often should the Board review data, what actions can follow findings, and how will changes in community trust and officer perceptions be measured? REVIEW Bring an open-minded, detailed civilian perspective to police accountability, helping residents feel heard and understand that change is possible. • Focus: Use multiple reviewers and perspectives to consider complaints carefully and illuminate how accountability works for both community and police. • Application: Help CPD understand community perceptions and help residents understand police practices and review processes. • Questions: How should disagreements about outcomes be addressed, and what follow -up options exist when Board recommendations are not acted upon? To: Police Civilian Oversight Board From: Sam Heath, Commonwealth Justice Coalition RE: Cville Reimagined Public Safety Initiative Date: November 12, 2026 The Commonwealth Justice Coalition is still riding high on the momentum from the Justice Is Community Summit, which brought together more than 200 people over two days last month. (Restorative Justice Day and Reentry Day + One Stop Shop; public official engagement). Now, we want to build on that momentum by taking a comprehensive look at public safety in Charlottesville and engaging the community in defining what it takes to create true community safety. Inspired by the John Jay Institute’s Reimagine Public Safety Pledge, we’ve developed our own: Cville Reimagined Public Safety Initiative. Our vision is for city leadership to sign the initiative and work alongside the community to lead its implementation. The folks at the John Jay Institute and Cities United are supportive of these efforts and ready to contribute their time and expertise. We also have a growing group of city, organizational, and state-level stakeholders interested in moving this forward. Here’s where the PCOB comes in. Would you reply to this email to express your support for the effort and interest in a gathering to plan its implementation? For now, this simply demonstrates growing community support as we work toward the initiative's eventual signing. It’s not a commitment to sign the initiative itself. You can simply reply with: I support the efforts of the Cville Reimagined Public Safety Initiative and am interested in a gathering in 2027 to plan its implementation. Read the Cville Reimagined Public Safety Initiative here. Thanks for considering it, and please reach out with any questions. I’d love to have you involved! Cville Reimagined Public Safety Initiative Charlottesville believes that public safety requires the entire community and must serve the entire community. We hold that safety is more than the absence of violence—it is the presence of well-being. We seek to move from awareness to action by addressing the root causes of violence, supporting prevention, and strengthening the people and organizations already working to make our community safer. As a city, we commit to: ● Examine how Charlottesville currently approaches public safety and identify opportunities to make our approach more effective, equitable, and responsive to community needs; ● Invest in preventing, interrupting, and recovering from violence , including approaches that address the root causes that contribute to violence; ● Partner with community organizations and residents to build on their experience and expertise of what works; ● Meaningfully engage the Charlottesville community , particularly people and communities most affected by violence and the systems intended to address it; ● Develop a citywide public safety roadmap that establishes shared priorities, strategies, and measurable goals; ● Report back to the community on what we learn , what we will do, and how we will measure progress; and ● Turn the roadmap into action , continually evaluating and improving our approach to public safety. Together, we can reimagine public safety as something we build with one another—not simply something we provide to one another. ________________________ ______________________ Charlottesville City Manager Charlottesville City Mayor Build Political Will to Change Create a City-Wide Work Group or Local Leadership Team Engage Leaders in Areas Most Impacted by Violence Build Partnerships and Relationships Raise Awareness Connect City Leaders to National Network Develop an Integrated Response Strategy Develop Balanced Approach Based on PIER (Prevention, Intervention, Enforcement, Re-Entry) Tactics Develop Multi-Layered SMART Goals: Education, Employment/ Workforce Readiness, Community Engagement, Family Support, and Criminal and Juvenile Justice Create Multi-Year Evaluation Plan and Data Plan Identify and Move Policy Agenda (Organizational, Local, State) Continuously Engage Philanthropy Develop Communication Plan Align and Identify Evidence-Based Activities CREA TE SUST AINABILITY PLAN Secure Sustainable Funding Streams Identify and Secure Goal Owners and Activity Leads Identify and Match Sustainable Resources Implement Multi-Year Evaluation Plan and Data Plan Communicate Successes and Activities Develop Community- Wide Integrated Governance Structure Implement Community Feedback Mechanisms Annually Review and Update Multi-Year Plan of Action Enhance and Grow Organizational Capacity CONSTRUCT A MUL TI-YEAR PLAN OF ACTION PREPARE TO PLAN ACTION PLANNING IMPLEMENT A MUL TI-YEAR PLAN OF ACTION DEVELOP CONTINUOUS IMPROVEMENT & EVALUA TION Roadmap to Safe, Healthy, Hopeful Communities CITY ASSESSING PEER NETWORK BUILDING ACTION PLANNING PROCESS NA TIONAL MOVEMENT BUILDING ONGOING SUPPORT Monthly Report CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE Office of Police Civilian Oversight OCTOBER 2026 ACCOUNTABILITYTRUST TRANSPARENCY Photo: City of Charlottesville, publicly posted on Facebook From the Director This monthly report covers the work of the Police Civilian Oversight Board (PCOB) and the Office that supports it. The PCOB is a City board of community members who monitor, audit, and review the activity, conduct, and poli- cies of the Charlottesville Police Department. The Board reviews how complaints are investigated and makes public recommendations to the Chief of Police, who must respond; it does not run the Police Department or investigate complaints itself. TO FILE A COMPLAINT OR REACH US PHONE (434) 970-3794 EMAIL pcob@charlottesville.gov VISIT 106 5th St NE · 8:30 AM–4:30 PM MAIL Attn: PCOB, PO Box 911, Charlottesville, VA 22902 MEETINGS Second Thursday of each month, 6:30 PM, CitySpace, 100 5th Street NE NEXT MEETINGThursday, December 10, 2026 IN THIS ISSUE 01Month in Review p. 2 02CPD Annual Awards Banquet p. 2 03October Survey Data p. 3 04Operations & Engagement Specialist p. 4 05October Coverage p. 4 Tell us about your experience with policing in Charlottesville. SCAN TO TAKE OUR 3-MINUTE SURVEY What you tell us helps set Board priorities. Office of Police Civilian Oversight · City of Charlottesville · (434) 970-3794 October 2026 MONTHLY REPORT · OCTOBER 2026 Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board Office of Police Civilian Oversight · City of Charlottesville · (434) 970-3794 Page 2 OVERVIEW Month in Review October focused on getting the Board ready for a larger oversight role. The Office completed an in-depth review of the Charlottesville Police Department’s budget from FY2022 through FY2027, identifying areas of interest for Board oversight and preparing a presentation for the Board. Work on the ordinance transition continued with a training activity that explains how the Office and the Board share responsibility for monitoring, auditing, review and community outreach. The Office also drafted a proposed conflict-of-interest policy covering disclosure, recusal and impartiality for Board members. On police technology, the Office researched CPD’s drone operations, including Drone as First Responder programs, and City Council’s au- thority to regulate police equipment and programs. In the community, Board Chair Dr. Jeffrey Fracher recognized Lieutenant Greg Wade and Sergeant Eric Thomas at the CPD banquet for months of relationship-building that helped encampment residents move into shelter. The Office also explored hosting community survey tables in public spaces such as the Downtown Mall and City parks. ACTIVITY HIGHLIGHT CPD Annual Awards Banquet Photo: Charlottesville Police Department, publicly posted on Facebook October 2, 2026 The Charlottesville Police Department held its Annual Awards Banquet on Friday, October 2, bringing together department members, their families, city management, members of the PCOB, and City Council. The evening honored officers and staff for life- saving actions and formal commendations, recognized personnel who earned recent promotions, and thanked recent retirees for their years of dedicated service to the City of Charlottesville. MONTHLY REPORT · OCTOBER 2026 Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board Office of Police Civilian Oversight · City of Charlottesville · (434) 970-3794 Page 3 COMMUNITY SURVEY · OCTOBER 2026 October drew 41 survey responses, more than July through September combined AVERAGE TRUST 63/100 56 for July to September RATED TRUST 70+ 61% 25 of 41; 44% for July to September PAPER SURVEYS 13 The Haven, Downtown Mall, Riverview Park VALUES GAP +0.8 closer to community than police, on a 1–7 scale RESPONSES BY MONTH 14 5 15 41 Jul Aug Sep Oct AVERAGE TRUST BY MONTH (0–100) 69 43 48 63 Jul Aug Sep Oct WHAT WE HEARD IN OCTOBER Trust was higher online (66) than on paper (57); the 8 surveyed at The Haven averaged 46. New themes: a call for more traffic enforce- ment, thanks from an unhoused respondent, and a student who now feels safer with the school’s SRO. Concerns included a stop without cause and little follow-up after a hit-and-run. Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Small monthly samples may reflect who was reached, not a change in views. Community Survey responses dated October 1 to 31, 2026 (n = 41). Full results: Community Survey Results, November 2026. MONTHLY REPORT · OCTOBER 2026 Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board Office of Police Civilian Oversight · City of Charlottesville · (434) 970-3794 Page 4 ACTIVITY HIGHLIGHT Operations & Engagement Specialist Jen Lucas Operations & Engagement Specialist October 26, 2026 Jen Lucas joined the Office of Police Civilian Oversight on October 26 as its Operations & Engagement Specialist. A Charlottesville resident for more than 34 years, Jen holds a Master of Public Health and brings experi- ence in operations, administration, and out- reach. Reporting to the Director, she serves as a primary point of contact between the community and the Board. The role manages complaint intake, logging, and routing; coor- dinates outreach events, listening sessions, and public education; supports Board meet- ings, including public notice and minutes; maintains the PCOB webpage; and analyzes oversight data for the Office’s reports. Jen is excited to contribute to the work of the Office and the Board. IN THE MEDIA October Coverage Two in-depth stories examined the Board’s oversight authority and its move to review- ing police investigations. Local TV coverage of police technology and data analytics also mentioned the Board. CVILLE RIGHT NOWOct 29, 2026 Charlottesvilleʼs Police Civilian Oversight Board set to review first cases Mike Barber’s feature on the revised ordinance, the Monitor, Audit, and Review model, and first case reviews expected in December. Features Chair Jeffrey Fracher, Director James Walker, Chief Michael Kochis, and activist Tanesha Hudson, and notes criticism that the Board lacks independent investigative and disci- plinary power. Read the story at cvillerightnow.com VPM NEWSOct 26, 2026 Charlottesville eyes post-Flock surveillance needs Report on CPD’s technology and surveillance plans with substantial oversight coverage: Director Walker’s Oct. 20 remarks, the revised ordinance, the status of the case-review man- ual, and the Board’s August letter supporting better police data systems. Read the story at vpm.org

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.