Human Rights Commission Regular Meeting — Minutes
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Human Rights Commission · meeting of Feb 20, 2025 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Human Rights Commission
Meeting Minutes
Regular Meeting
February 20, 2025
City Space, 100 5th Street NE, Charlottesville, VA 22902
6:30 pm
1. WELCOME
a. CALL TO ORDER
i. Chair, Heather Roberson Gaston, called the meeting to order at 6:38 pm
b. ROLL CALL
i. Present
1. Heather Roberson Gaston
2. Jason Melendez
3. Mary Bauer
4. Ernest Chambers
5. Wolfgang Keppley
6. Kathryn Laughon
7. Dawn Lawson (attending virtually from her residence in Charlottesville,
Va due to a personal matter pursuant to City Policy No. 100-02 and Va.
Code § 2.2-3708.3.B.)
8. Suzanne Lynn
9. Elizabeth Stark
ii. Absent
1. None
c. MISSION (recited by all): Act as a strong advocate to justice and equal opportunity
by providing citywide leadership and guidance in the area of civil rights.
2. MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
a. PUBLIC COMMENT
i. None
b. COMMISSION RESPONSE TO MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
i. None
3. MINUTES
a. Review of minutes from 01-16-2025
i. Vote
1. In favor: 9
2. Opposed: 0
3. Abstained: 0
ii. Motion to approve minutes passes
b. Review of minutes from 02-06-2025
i. Staff member proposes edit to indicate that Elizabeth Stark participated
in this meeting virtually due to temporary or permanent disability or other
medical condition that prevented the member's physical attendance,
pursuant to City Policy No. 100-02 and Va. Code § 2.2-3708.3.B.
ii. Vote
1. In favor: 7
2. Opposed: 0
3. Abstained: 2
iii. Motion to approve minutes with above amendment passes
4. BUSINESS MATTER
a. CHAIR UPDATE
i. Chair shares that she, Jason, and Ernest attended the most recent
Fifeville Neighborhood Association meeting on the proposed low-barrier
shelter on Cherry Avenue
1. Commissioners present at the meeting affirmed that no Commission
business was discussed at the Fifeville Neighborhood Association
meeting
b. OHR STAFF REPORT
i. Director shares that Mariane Doyle and L.D. Perry have been appointed
to the HRC
ii. Director shares that staff are working on OHR/HRC Annual Report, and
it will be ready for commissioners to review soon
5. WORK SESSION
a. Snow removal plan updates
i. Working on scheduling a meeting to discuss this with Deputy City
Manager James Freas
ii. The City plans to develop new plan and implement changes to the snow
removal practices by Fall 2025
1. Commissioner asks if the City received the Livable Cville letter
and if any reflections were shared
a. Director shares that staff did receive the letter, and that
no additional reflections were shared
2. Commissioner observes that the most recent snow was cleared
more quickly than previous snow
3. Another commissioner adds that the City appeared to enforce
the snow removal policy more effectively following this snow
than they have in the past
4. Commissioner shares observation that Monticello Avenue and
6th Street sidewalks continue to be covered in snow
iii. Commissioner shares concern about snow on paths and bus stops that
children riding the bus use to get to school
iv. Commissioner(s) will meet with James Freas next week
b. Annual Planning Meeting discussion
i. Director shares that staff and HRC Leadership are meeting with Maya
Pace next week, a potential facilitator for group dynamics work at the
Annual Planning Meeting
ii. Commissioner suggests beginning work plan drafting earlier in the day
at the Annual Planning Meeting
iii. Commissioners discuss public poll and ways to further encourage
community members to respond
c. Commissioners discuss March HRC Work Session and response to the
University of Virginia (UVA) Health System decision to pause providing gender-
affirming care for minors
i. Commissioner shares that some community members are uncertain that
a town hall would be a helpful addition to organizing efforts that are
already taking place
ii. Another commissioner suggests that the HRC may have a role through
an individual complaint process
1. Director states that the OHR does not have jurisdiction over
UVA
iii. Commissioner states that there may not be a large number of private
providers within City limits providing gender-affirming care to minors,
making the scope of the HRC’s potential impact through individual
complaints limited
iv. Commissioner states that HRC’s role may be to think about how to
positively impact the protection of human rights
v. Commissioner Mary Bauer shares that the ACLU is involved in litigation
of UVA Health, and while she supports the HRC’s advocacy on this
topic, due to her employment with the ACLU, she could not participate
directly in an HRC listening session on this issue
vi. Commissioners discuss the scope and goal of this proposed meeting
1. Commissioners would like to ask individual people if they would
be willing to speak on this issue prior to scheduling a meeting to
do so
2. Commissioner states that the HRC has a role to loudly call out
human rights violations as they occur
3. Commissioners discuss the public poll as an alternative to
inviting people to attend a public meeting to share their
perspectives
4. Commissioner suggests that the HRC could provide a space for
individuals affected by UVA Health’s decision regarding gender-
affirming care to share their stories
a. Another commissioner expresses support for this idea
b. Another commissioner suggests sharing anonymous
stories with City Council to say this is what is happening
in our city
c. Commissioner asks how this impacts OHR staff
workload
i. Director suggests setting up a way to receive
these stories that does not require extensive
staff time given other obligations, such as
emails, polls, or transcribed voice messages
1. Commissioner suggests that this could
be used for other topics and issue
areas in the future
5. Commissioner states that HRC needs to think through
confidentiality and privacy concerns for any initiative that asks
individuals to participate or share stories
6. Commissioner states that stories could be used to make
legislative recommendations more powerful
a. Commissioner agrees with this, and affirms need to
protect confidentiality
b. Director shares that IT may be able to offer an
encrypted tool
vii. Commissioner asks where complaints that are outside of Charlottesville
can be referred
1. Director provides an overview of agencies that receive different
types of complaints
viii. Commissioner proposes opening a new public poll asking how
responding individuals and their families have been impacted by recent
federal Executive Orders and if responding individuals have a
recommendation for the HRC to consider in how to protect human rights
locally
1. Commissioner suggests adding that people can provide contact
information if they would like to be contacted and a question
about whether the respondent would be interested in attending
a listening session hosted by the HRC
2. Another commissioner suggests not including the title of the
Executive Order
3. Another commissioner suggests broadening scope to include
additional Executive Orders not related to medical services
4. Another commissioner suggests adding additional community
resources with permission from those organizations
ix. Director shares that if March Work Session is held at Carver, it will start
at 6pm
d. Commissioners discuss proposed Draft Resolution
i. Commissioner suggests removing the full titles of the Executive Order
and Attorney General’s Memo
1. Another commissioner supports this amendment
2. Another commissioner asks if the resolution could be sent this
evening or early tomorrow morning
a. Director and Chair will work on finalizing the Resolution
this evening
3. Vote
a. In favor: 8
b. Opposed: 0
c. Abstained: 1
4. Motion to amend and approve the Draft Resolution passes
e. Commissioners decide not to hold Work Session on March 6, 2025
6. MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
a. PUBLIC COMMENT
i. None
b. COMMISSION RESPONSE TO MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
i. None
7. COMMISSIONER UPDATES
a. Commissioner shares that $1.5 million remains in proposed State budget to be
used for a shelter in Charlottesville
b. Commissioner reminds everyone of the Regional Housing Summit hosted by the
Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission on March 13th
8. NEXT STEPS
a. Wolfgang
i. Meet with James Freas
b. Todd
i. Ask IT about privacy protection options for poll respondents
c. Todd and Heather
i. Resolution follow-up
9. ADJOURN
a. Meeting adjourned at 8:06pm
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.