RecordWell Data

Presentation 2

Fairfax County · Fairfax County · Budget documents

Open the original document More from Fairfax County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

© PFM 1 Fairfax County Retirement System Governance and Investments Process Improvement Opportunities PFM Financial Advisors LLC Deep Blue Investment Advisors November 2026 November 24, 2026 © PFM 2 Introduction PFM and Deep Blue Investment Advisors (Deep Blue) were engaged by the County in late summer 2026 to evaluate the potential benefits and considerations of consolidating its retirement systems’ investment and administrative structure Over the course of the engagement, PFM and Deep Blue held interviews with each retirement fund’s Chief Investment Officer as well as investment analytics staff and retirement administration staff to better understand current processes PFM and Deep Blue gathered data on time spent on retirement functions, historical spending on data analytics, investment management and consultant fees, and performed targeted benchmarking analysis evaluating Fairfax County’s retirement plans’ investment fees and net returns PFM and Deep Blue concluded that consolidation of the three retirement funds’ investments would generate net savings from an investment fee efficiency perspective PFM and Deep Blue also concluded that the consolidation would bring process efficiencies from a more streamlined approach to analytics, administration, and reporting Using New York City’s pension systems as a case study, recommendations will focus on improving Fairfax County’s retirement funds’ net outcomes, not simply reducing fees © PFM 3 Key Finding: Investment Fees Above Peers Investment Management Fees as a % of Fair Value Retirement System FY2023 FY2024 FY2025 Fairfax County URS 0.8% 0.8% 0.8% Fairfax County ERS 1.1% 1.1% 1.1% Fairfax County PORS 1.2% 1.2% 1.3% Arlington County ERS 0.4% 0.4% 0.2% VRS 0.6% 0.5% 0.5% Maryland SRPS 0.6% 0.6% 0.6% Montgomery County ERS 0.4% 0.4% 0.3% Anne Arundel RPS 0.4% 0.4% 0.4% Baltimore City ERS 0.9% 1.1% 1.4% Baltimore City FPERS 0.5% 0.7% 1.0% District of Columbia PFRS 0.3% 0.3% 0.3% Median (Excl. Fairfax) 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 1 Investment fees run above peers Fairfax County pension systems pay 0.8% to 1.3% of fair value versus a 0.5% median for regional and national public plans 2 Custodial fees are in line FY2025 custodial fees were generally consistent with the industry average Source: Callan Institute 2025 Investment Management Fee Study, January 16, 2026 © PFM 4 Key Finding: Net Return Below Peers The Public Plan Database provides national pension plan data from FY2001 to FY2025 for over 250 major state and local government pension plans This sample, which includes Fairfax County’s three pension systems, covers 95 percent of public pension membership and assets nationwide Rolling net returns over the last five to ten years have generally been lower than the national average. The same trend is true among regional plans 3.0% 4.0% 5.0% 6.0% 7.0% 8.0% 9.0% 10.0% 11.0% 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 Fiscal Year 10-Year Rolling Net Return PORS ERS URS National Average Fairfax County investment return assumption (6.75% Since FY2022) Note: Median investment returns among national pension plans is 7.0% per National Association of State Retirement Administrators (NASRA) Public Fund Survey, FY2024 Source: Public Plan Database, accessed September 18, 2026; Rolling return based on annual intervals https://publicplansdata.org/public-plans-database/download-full-data-set/#nav-7 © PFM 5 Key Finding: Different Allocations Result in Different Returns Public Equity 44.8% Fixed income 15.5% Real Assets 15.8% Abs. Return 10.8% Private Mkts. 18.2% URS Source: FY25 Asset Risk Contribution, BNY Nexen; Annual Comprehensive Financial Statements -10.0% -5.0% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% FY2020 FY2021 FY2022 FY2023 FY2024 FY2025 One-Year Investment Return PORS ERS URS Fairfax County investment return assumption (6.75% Since FY2022) © PFM 6 Investment Recommendations  PFM partnered with Deep Blue to evaluate the investment strategies of the County’s three pension plans and identified ways to improve overall investment management and, ultimately, risk-adjusted net returns  Key recommendations include: Consolidation across the three retirement plans removes duplicate managers and improves negotiating leverage Consolidation creates savings A more consistent allocation across ERS, PORS and URS under one investment policy, with fund-specific variances One framework Shared data analytics, one CIO and investment team, and consolidated updates to the three Boards of Trustees Savings extend beyond fees Use low-cost passive strategies where appropriate to minimize fees Passive where it fits Pursue strategies to minimize fees without sacrificing risk-adjusted net returns (e.g., investment manager RFP) Fee efficiency Use investment consultants strategically (e.g., consultants for specific asset classes) Consultant use Investment consolidation should ultimately improve net outcomes, not simply reduce fees © PFM 7 Process Recommendations PFM also identified five areas with opportunities for efficiencies: Disability tracker reporting A more uniform quarterly approach to disability tracker reporting among the three plans would save Retirement staff time, given the current time spent on compiling reports for the three boards Professional services Consolidation of investments would allow all three plans to use the same data and research services, instead of varying data analytics and licensing approaches by retirement plan (e.g., currently, the three plans use different operational due diligence vendors, data analytics services, and market research licenses) Investment analytics staff Currently, PORS and ERS use more of the County’s staff time for investment analysis while URS relies more on its investment consultant. Consolidation would use staff time more efficiently instead of the current bifurcated approach Investments manager contracts Currently, the three plans have 98 unique investment managers, but not all managers are shared among the three plans. Streamlining investment managers would help create efficiencies and potentially more favorable pricing Legal review Investment contracts are reviewed through the County Attorney’s office for URS and ERS, while PORS uses separately contracted attorneys, which results in a more cumbersome legal and FOIA response process than otherwise © PFM 8 A Spectrum of Alternatives Less integration More integration NO CONSOLIDATION Further coordination Plans stay separate • Share information and practices across the three plans • Align vendors, data, and meeting schedules where practical TIER 1 Streamline investment management Depends on consolidating investments • Share investment managers; more allocation consistency • Passive strategies where appropriate • Contracts based on assets across all three plans to maximize fee efficiencies • Consolidated data analytics; strategic use of consultants • 1 CIO over all three systems • One investment policy, with fund- specific variances TIER 2 Streamline Board meetings Keeps current board governance structure • Joint quarterly investment meetings across all three plans • Shorter individual board meetings focused on specific matters • Quarterly disability tracker reporting at individual board meetings TIER 3 Streamline Board governance Subject to state code changes • Consolidate legal teams and review process • Consolidate Board meetings and reporting, which also improves the availability of investment professional candidates to serve on the Board © PFM 9 Case Study: New York City Pension Systems • Each board meets and sets its own asset allocation, but allocations are similar and largely consistent among the five plans • Each has its own specialized independent consultants; some consultants serve several boards Five systems, similar investment allocations • A single Chief Investment Officer leads analytics and operations through the Bureau of Asset Management (BAM) • Asset class categories are common to all five systems, even where allocation weights differ • BAM prepares one reporting framework, populated separately for each system One investment office • Same master custodian (State Street), risk system (MSCI BarraOne), and attribution framework • One BAM manager monitoring report serves multiple boards; only allocation size varies • Single procurement and legal review, though each system's consultants evaluate proposals independently Shared platform Teachers’ Retirement System Employees’ Retirement System Police Pension Fund Fire Pension Fund Board of Education Retirement System © PFM 10 NYC vs. Fairfax County Pension Plan Governance and Investment NYC model Fairfax County today PEOPLE AND SERVICES Investment staff 1 CIO, deputy CIOs and senior leadership 3 CIOs plus shared analytics team Professional services Shared custodian, auditor, actuary, analytics Shared custodian, auditor, actuary GOVERNANCE Board authority 5 separate boards 3 separate boards Investment advisory BAM advises by delegation Not formalized; boards advise separately Joint meetings Six annual joint investment meetings in 2015; currently share common BAM materials Not established PORTFOLIO AND COST Portfolios Similar allocation across all 5 PORS and ERS similar, URS differs Return assumption 7.0% across all 5 plans 6.75% across all 3 plans Consultants 10 across 5 funds, 7 asset classes 1 consultant, URS only Investment managers Shared across all 5 plans Some shared, mainly PORS and ERS Fee negotiation Aggregated across all 5 plans Not formally aggregated across the 3 plans © PFM 11 NYC Pension Plan Dashboard Source: https://comptroller.nyc.gov/services/financial-matters/pension/asset-under-management/ The analytical infrastructure supporting the Boards’ decisions is built once and applied across all five systems Greater fee efficiencies from shared managers across systems Each board reviews and votes on its own investment and allocation decisions © PFM 12 NYC Pension Plans Investment Allocation Allocation weights vary by plan, but the asset class structure is largely consistent across the five plans. Board of Education (BERS) FIRE ERS POLICE Teachers (TRS) © PFM 13 Appendix A: Case Studies © PFM 14 Case Study: New York City Pension Systems  New York City has five pension systems: Employees' Retirement System (NYCERS), Teachers' Retirement System (TRS), Board of Education Retirement System (BERS), Police Pension Fund (POLICE), and Fire Pension Fund (FIRE)  In 2015, Funston Advisory Services (FAS) conducted a comprehensive management and operations study of the Bureau of Asset Management (BAM) — the Comptroller's internal investment advisory function serving all five NYC pension systems — delivering its final report in December 2015, which was publicly released in January 2016  At the time, BAM was an approximately 100-person unit overseeing roughly $163 billion in assets, with a single Chief Investment Officer responsible for serving five independent boards, each with its own investment program, asset allocation, and governance requirements  In parallel with the study, the Comptroller and the five boards established a Common Investment Meeting (CIM) in December 2015, consolidating 54 separate monthly board investment meetings into six joint meetings of all trustees per year • At joint CIM sessions, trustees from all five systems would meet in public session to review overall performance and the direction of common investments as recommended by BAM • Following the public session, trustees would hear presentations in executive session from investment managers, then meet as individual boards to vote on hiring and retention of managers and conduct other business • Each board retained full independent fiduciary and voting authority — the CIM was a coordination and efficiency mechanism, not a governance consolidation Source: The Trustees Of The New York City Pension Funds Announce The Formation Of A Common Investment Meeting, December 3, 2015 © PFM 15 NYC Pension Plan Investment Consultants Currently, there are 10 unique investment consultants shared across the five systems and seven asset classes. Asset Class TRS NYCERS POLICE FIRE BERS Public Equity Goldman Sachs Callan Associates (CALLAN) Wilshire Associates New England Pension Consultants (NEPC) Segal Marco Advisors Public Fixed Income Goldman Sachs Callan Associates (CALLAN) Wilshire Associates New England Pension Consultants (NEPC) Segal Marco Advisors Private Equity Hamilton Lane StepStone Group Aksia LLC StepStone Group Meketa Investment Group Real Estate StepStone Group StepStone Group The Townsend Group The Townsend Group Meketa Investment Group Infrastructure StepStone Group StepStone Group StepStone Group StepStone Group Meketa Investment Group Hedge Funds N/A N/A Aksia LLC Aksia LLC N/A Alternative Credit Goldman Sachs Callan Associates (CALLAN) Wilshire Associates New England Pension Consultants (NEPC) Meketa Investment Group Source: New York City Comptroller Pension / Investment Management Frequently Asked Questions © PFM 16 NYC Pension Systems Manager Search Process (2026 RFP) Investment manager procurement is performed on a consolidated basis across the five retirement systems. Source: New York City Notice of Search for Equity Index Investment Management Products and Services (PIN 015-268-328-00 QQ), June 5, 2026, https://comptroller.nyc.gov/wp-content/uploads/documents/Equity-Index-Notice-of-Search-6-5-26-FINAL.pdf Investment manager RFP search process is performed on a consolidated basis across all systems Each Board has independent authority over asset holdings, purchases, and investment allocation Fees are negotiated on an aggregated basis across all five systems Each Board uses its own investment consultants to evaluate proposals independently © PFM 17 Case Study: Arlington County Source: FY2025 ACERS Annual Retirement Summary Arlington County Code (§§ 46-39, 46-41) 1946 Separate plans Ordinances create one plan for police and fire, one for general employees 1953 ACERS unifies all groups Earlier plans repealed; a single retirement system replaces them 2004 Admin duties move Code amendments shift disability medical administration to the County Manager Today One fund, one policy Single fund and one investment policy statement for all participants How Arlington County Employee Retirement System (ACERS) operates today Single fund for all participants, with no assets segregated by employee class One investment allocation strategy and one investment policy statement Benefits still vary by hire date and employment type Investment management stays with the Board of Trustees Virginia Code § 51.1-820, which authorizes police pension plans in county-manager governments, explicitly excludes Arlington County © PFM 18 Appendix B: Investment Recommendations © PFM 19 Use Low-Cost Passive Strategies Where Appropriate  Active strategies should be part of Fairfax County’s investment strategy, even if those strategies result in higher fees in exchange for potential diversification and return benefits  At the same time, the County should also pursue low-cost passive strategies where it makes sense (e.g., domestic large cap exposure) to minimize fees  According to Callan’s 2025 study, the average percentage of each fund’s total assets invested in passive (index) strategies among public funds was 25% to 36%  Based on the FY2025 ACFR, less than 25% of Fairfax pension plans were allocated to passive strategies1 1 Based on manager schedules disclosed in the FY2025 ACFR, passive strategies are defined to include ETFs, Parametric overlays, Core Risk Parity mandates, passive indexes (e.g., BNY Fallen Angels), Active Risk Parity mandates (which are systematic and rules- based), and strategies where the manager also offers index-based products and the specific mandate style is not explicitly disclosed (e.g., Cohen & Steers real estate securities, DWS Real Assets, BNY Mellon U.S. Large Cap, and PIMCO TIPS). Source: Callan Institute 2025 Cost of Doing Business Study © PFM 20 Active vs Passive Spectrum In 2024, 31% of the assets under management among the 55 public funds surveyed (with average assets of $9.5B) were allocated to passive strategies. Source Data: Callan Institute 2025 Cost of Doing Business Study The study uses a sample size of 180 asset pools with more than $772 billion in assets, including public defined benefit (DB) plans, corporate DB plans, nonprofits, and insurance pools in 2024. © PFM 21 Create More Consistent Investment Allocation  Currently, ERS/PORS and URS have materially different investment allocation strategies  As a best practice, the three plans should have a more consistent allocation  Similar to NYC, Fairfax County can maintain three different Boards of Trustees that make investment allocation decisions, but the allocations should be similar • NYC police and fire pension plans have some hedge fund exposure while the other three NYC pension plans do not, but the investment allocations are largely consistent and similar (see NYC case study) Public Equity 44.8% Fixed income 15.5% Real Assets 15.8% Abs. Return 10.8% Private Mkts. 18.2% URS Source: FY25 Asset Risk Contribution, BNY Nexen © PFM 22 Use Investment Consultants Strategically  Currently, URS uses a generalist investment consultant while PORS and ERS use in-house staff and do not utilize an investment consultant  Once investments are consolidated, the County should use investment consultants strategically • Use investment consultants to support investment manager selection: • The Government Finance Officers Association (GFOA) recommends using a competitive selection process to minimize investment fees and using investment consultants / review committee for evaluation1 • Fairfax County currently does not require a competitive bidding process for investment managers. As the County’s pension assets grow in size, it should eventually move toward using RFP processes for select investment managers and make use of the consultant's knowledge of the marketplace to minimize fees for contracted services, consistent with GFOA best practices and New York City’s current practice2 • In the interim, the County should use investment consultants’ knowledge base to interview and select managers and negotiate fees accordingly • Use investment consultants with subject matter expertise • There are benefits in using investment consultants specialized in certain asset classes, similar to New York City’s current practice. This can result in a more strategic use of consultant’s subject matter expertise to supplement the County’s internal investment teams’ general knowledge  Both recommendations are geared toward a consolidated pension plan with larger assets under management 1 GFOA, Investment Fee Guidelines for External Management of Defined Benefit Plans; GFOA, Selecting Third-Party Investment Professionals for Pension Fund Assets 2 New York City Notice of Search for Equity Index Investment Management Products and Services (PIN 015-268-328-00 QQ), June 5, 2026 © PFM 23 Adopt a Single Investment Policy  Each of the three pension plans is currently working on formalizing / updating investment policies  Instead of writing and formalizing three individual policies, PFM and Deep Blue recommend developing a single investment policy that governs the three plans, with fund-specific variances as needed • Adopt investment fee policy:1 GFOA’s best practice recommends adopting an investment management fee policy that will allow funds to negotiate competitive fees, with guidelines that address the roles and responsibilities of internal and external participants involved in the investment management fee negotiations; example responsibilities include using peer comparisons as part of the negotiations and including a “most favored nation” clause in the agreement • Uniform policy across the three plans: Instead of developing three separate policies, the County should develop a single policy with potential fund-specific variances that accommodate the various needs and constraints. This recommendation ties back to the prior recommendation that the County’s three pension plans should have more consistent investment allocations. Similar to NYC, Fairfax County can maintain three different Boards of Trustees that make investment allocation decisions, but the allocations should be broadly consistent and documented as such in the policy • Incorporate GFOA best practices in investment policies:2 As the County moves toward formalizing policies, it should incorporate GFOA best practices into the policy statements. Elements such as cost management and fee transparency (e.g., transaction cost, investment management fees, custodial fees, performance-based fees, and other investment-related expenses) and investment management guidelines (e.g., manager watch list / termination process) should be added 1 GFOA, Investment Fee Guidelines for External Management of Defined Benefit Plans; GFOA, Selecting Third-Party Investment Professionals for Pension Fund Assets 2 GFOA, Investment Policies for Defined Benefit Plans; Asset Allocation for Defined Benefit Plans © PFM 24 Savings from an Improved Net Return Perspective In summary, investment consolidation should improve net outcomes, not simply reduce fees. Centralized procurement and aggregated fee negotiation may reduce costs where there is overlap Common reporting and attribution would improve accountability for net investment results Each plan should retain an allocation consistent with its liabilities, liquidity needs, risk tolerance, and fiduciary objectives Higher-cost strategies should be retained only where expected net value added, diversification, or downside protection justifies their cost and complexity Implementation should prioritize opportunities supported by mandate-level analysis rather than uniform assumptions across total assets Centralize procurement, reporting, monitoring, and fee negotiations where beneficial © PFM 25 Appendix C: Alternatives and Savings Estimates © PFM 26 A Spectrum of Alternatives Less integration More integration NO CONSOLIDATION Further coordination Plans stay separate • Share information and practices across the three plans • Align vendors, data and meeting schedules where practical TIER 1 Streamline investment management Depends on consolidating investments • Share investment managers; more allocation consistency • Passive strategies where appropriate • Contracts based on assets across all three plans to maximize fee efficiencies • Consolidated data analytics; strategic use of consultants • 1 CIO over all three systems • One investment policy, with fund- specific variances TIER 2 Streamline Board meetings Keeps current board governance structure • Joint quarterly investment meetings across all three plans • Shorter individual board meetings focused on specific matters • Quarterly disability tracker reporting at individual board meetings TIER 3 Streamline Board governance Subject to state code changes • Consolidate legal teams and review process • Consolidate Board meetings and reporting, which also improves the availability of investment professional candidates to serve on the Board © PFM 27 Investment Fee Savings Sensitivity ERS URS PORS Total FY2025 Midpoint Fair Value $5,176,148,842 $2,270,107,806 $1,897,899,763 $9,344,156,411 FY2025 Disclosed Management Fees $54,542,863 $17,223,889 $25,337,048 $97,103,800 Disclosed Fee as a % of Midpoint Fair Value 1.05% 0.76% 1.34% 1.04% Disclosed Investment Fee Scenario – Fee Reduction by % for Illustration Only Estimated Savings -0.03% $1,552,845 $681,032 $569,370 $2,803,247 -0.05% $2,588,074 $1,135,054 $948,950 $4,672,078 -0.10% $5,176,149 $2,270,108 $1,897,900 $9,344,157 -0.15% $7,764,223 $3,405,162 $2,846,850 $14,016,235 -0.20% $10,352,298 $4,540,216 $3,795,800 $18,688,314 Note: This illustration does not include any savings from performance fees, which would vary from year to year. Disclosed fee percentages are calculated on the midpoint between each System’s FY2025 beginning and ending balances. Investment fee savings would vary depending on asset-class mix, manager consolidation, contract terms, and negotiation outcomes. © PFM 28 Tier 2 Initiatives: Streamline Board Meetings  Tier 2 initiatives focus on streamlining administrative processes related to monthly Board meetings  Even without combining the governance structure, there may be opportunities to gain efficiencies • Currently, board meetings vary in length and can be as long as three hours depending on the agenda and related discussions • If investments are consolidated, Fairfax County could explore organizing monthly or quarterly joint investment meetings while limiting each individual board meeting to investment allocation matters (which would vary by board) as well as other board-specific matters • This approach follows the example of New York City’s consolidation initiative in 2015 when monthly Board meetings were streamlined, with the formation of six annual joint investment meetings • The goal of streamlining board meetings is to reduce staff time in attending board meetings and preparing investment- related materials • There may also be an opportunity for more uniform and less frequent (i.e., quarterly) disability tracker reporting • Currently, staff provides monthly disability case statuses to each Board; each report is separately generated by Retirement’s Deputy Director utilizing the Disability Tracker (an in-house shared Excel file independently and continuously updated by Membership and Retiree Services staff). Disability case metrics are verified by each department’s management team and compared against each Board’s agenda items prior to final submission • Quarterly uniform reporting1 would allow staff to easily export and provide the same format and report to the Board Source: The Trustees Of The New York City Pension Funds Announce The Formation Of A Common Investment Meeting 1 Staff noted that the PORS Board of Trustees recently adopted this format. © PFM 29 Tier 1 and 2 Initiatives – Savings Illustration Tier Function Opportunities for Efficiencies Savings Opportunities Savings Illustration 1 Reduce CIOs 1 CIO plus 1 Deputy CIO Reduce 1 CIO $320k (Personnel cost of 1 CIO) 1 Streamline investment managers Reduce number of procurement and related administrative processes Reduced staff time $125k - $250k (~5-10% of Investment staff time) 1 Consolidated reporting Same financial reporting Reduced staff time $5k - $10k (~5-10% of Accounting staff time) 1 Streamlined professional fees / software / subscription Same research / data analytics platforms Reduced professional fees $200k - $400k (~5-10% of total fees) 2 Investment updates to Boards Monthly individual board meetings → Quarterly joint investment meetings Reduced staff time $125k (~5% of Investment staff time) 2 Disability tracker Monthly customized reporting → Quarterly uniform reporting Reduced staff time $15k - $30k (~5-10% of Board Support staff time) Total Administrative Savings (for Illustration) $790k - $1.1M Total Investment Management Savings (5 to 10 bps for Illustration) $4.7M - $9.3M © PFM 30 Tier 3 Initiatives: Consolidate Board Governance Function Current Process Opportunities for Efficiencies Legal review Investment contracts are reviewed through the County Attorney’s office for URS and ERS, while PORS uses separately contracted attorneys Because some funds use the same investment managers, the review process would be more efficient and less costly if all three funds used the same legal team FOIA requests While the County charges the hourly rate of the lowest compensated Agency employee (not including benefits) for document retrieval, the charge does not fully recover the cost of retrieving investment contracts based on FOIA requests. In addition to the administrative process of retrieving documents, the Retirement Administration Agency requires each plan’s legal team to determine contents to be redacted before responding to the FOIA request Staff describe the current process for responding to FOIA requests as extremely burdensome due to the separate legal teams and the need to seal/redact records based on legal input. The inefficiencies described is one example of how the separate legal structure of the plans has a cascading effect on process and administration  If the County is able to eventually combine the governance structure of the three boards, it could gain efficiencies by reducing the number of Board meetings from the current 33 each year to 11 Improves the availability of investment professional candidates to serve on the Board Associated savings related to board orientation, education, and site visits Current separation of legal structure and FOIA response process may also be streamlined

Source: Fairfax County website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.