2023 Richmond City Council Charter Review Commission Recommendations Report
City of Richmond · Richmond City County · meeting of Aug 2, 2023 · Other
Open the original document More from City of Richmond
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
2023 Richmond City Council Charter Review Commission
August 2, 2023
2023 Richmond City Charter Review Commission
900 East Broad Street, Suite 305
Richmond, Virginia 23219
1
August 2, 2023
To the Honorable Members of Richmond City Council and Mayor Stoney:
As per Ordinance 2021-347, as amended, the Richmond City Charter Review
Commission is pleased to submit its final report for your consideration. It has been an honor to
undertake this work on behalf of the residents of the City of Richmond. We have sought to the
best of our abilities to fulfill the ordinance’s request for a comprehensive review of the City
Charter, with special attention to the functioning of the current form of government.
Our final recommendations are grouped into four categories:
First, in Chapter Five, we specify recommended changes to the Charter document to
remove unneeded or outdated language, add clarity, and to bring the City Charter in greater
alignment with the Mayor-Council form of government and with prevailing state law and general
practice. We believe that these recommendations should be brought forward by the City for
action in the 2024 session of the Virginia General Assembly.
Second, we specify recommended adjustments to the Mayor-Council form of government
that are intended to improve its functioning and create a stronger partnership between the Mayor,
Chief Administrative Officer, and City Council in Chapter Six. While these recommendations
should be discussed and carefully considered by stakeholders, it is the Commission’s
recommendation that they also be brought forward as a package for action in the 2024 Virginia
General Assembly. Adoption in 2024 would allow for a revised Mayor-Council framework to
take effect at the start of the term of office beginning January 1, 2025.
Third, we recommend in Chapter Seven that City Council take steps to continue
exploration of a shift in the form of government to a Council-Manager system, to include an
elected full-time Mayor who presides over City Council. This report specifies what the
Commission believes would be the best version of this model for Richmond: a seven-member
Council including six districted representatives and a Mayor elected at-large via a ranked choice
voting (instant runoff) process. The Commission recognizes that many challenging legal and
organizational issues must be addressed to effect a change in the form of government, and also
strongly believes that any such change should be preceded by an advisory referendum so that the
voices of all City residents may be heard. For those reasons, while we believe the conversation
should continue, it should do so deliberately, with careful attention to detail, and with many
additional opportunities for engagement across the community so that residents may be fully
informed and have the opportunity to be heard. Chapter Seven of the report lays out the
reasoning for considering a shift in the form of government and details recommended next steps.
Fourth, we recommend that the City move forward with adopting staggered terms for
members of City Council, beginning in 2028. Chapter Eight briefly lays out the reasoning for
staggered terms as well as key questions to be resolved prior to their implementation.
We would like to thank Mayor Stoney, Chief Administrative Officer Lincoln Saunders,
and the members of Richmond City Council for their cooperation with and support for the work
of the Commission. We thank the Office of the City Attorney for its support of the Commission,
in particular Deputy City Attorney Tabrica Rentz and Assistant City Attorney Tori Cotman. We
thank Council Chief of Staff LaTesha Holmes and Council Public Information Manager Steven
Skinner for their extensive support of the Commission’s work. We especially thank Council
2
Policy Analyst Joyce Davis, who served as the Commission’s principal staff contact and played
an indispensable role in shepherding the Commission through each stage of our work.
We also acknowledge and thank Mr. Walter Erwin for providing a detailed legal analysis
of the Charter on behalf of the Commission, as well as Professor Andrew Block of the University
of Virginia School of Law State and Local Government Policy Clinic and law students Maya
Artis and Michael Pruitt for their detailed literature review on municipal forms of government
provided to the Commission.
Finally, we thank the many Richmond City residents who engaged the Commission’s
work by completing a survey, submitting written comment, or offering public comment at the
Commission’s meetings.
This report represents our best effort as a Commission and as a group of community
members who care deeply about the City. We thank you for reviewing it carefully, in hopes it
leads both to timely action as well as further public discussion concerning how best to realize the
practice of representative self-government in the City of Richmond.
Faithfully submitted,
Members of the Richmond City Charter Review Commission
Mr. Antoine Banks, Secretary
Ms. Rachael Deane, Esq., Vice-Chair
Mr. William Echelberger
Mr. Kyle Elliott, Esq.
Mr. John Girardi
Mr. Travis Gunn, Esq.
Mr. Steven Koski, Esq.
Ms. Daisy Weaver
Dr. Thad Williamson, Chair
3
Table of Contents
1. Executive Summary
2. History of Richmond City Charter
3. 2022 City Charter Review Commission Process
4. Demographic Changes in Richmond, 2000-2022
5. Recommendations, I: Document Optimization
6. Recommendations, II: Partnership Model of Mayor-Council Government
7. Recommendations, III: Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option
8. Recommendations, IV: Staggered Council Terms
9. Concluding Observations and Next Steps
Appendices:
A. List of Proposed Charter Changes and Action Steps
B. Resident Engagement Survey, Summary of Results
C. Demographic Change in Richmond and Electoral Implications, 2000-2022
D. Council Composition and Method of Election, Virginia Independent Cities
E. Form of Government and Council Composition, Mid-sized Southeastern Cities
F. Memorandum, University of Virginia School of Law State and Local Government Policy
Clinic
G. Memoranda on Richmond City Charter, Mr. Walter Erwin
H. Ordinance 2021-347 Establishing the Charter Review Commission
4
Chapter One. Executive Summary
Richmond’s municipal government belongs to the residents of the City, and it exists to protect,
serve and advance our shared interests. It is through city government that we work together both
to meet ongoing needs and to establish the City’s future direction and ultimately, what kind of
city we will become.
A bedrock principle of democratic government is that the tools and machinery of government
belong to the people. This principle has long been embedded in the Charter of the City of
Richmond, which provides both City Council and the citizens at-large the power to initiate
changes in the City Charter. This is significant because it is the City Charter that establishes the
precise mechanisms by which local government is organized.
From time to time in Richmond’s history, leaders and citizens have taken time to assess and
reassess the City Charter and consider possibilities for altering its structure in order to better
advance the public interest. In 2022, City Council established a Charter Review Commission to
undertake a comprehensive review of the Charter and provide recommendations for change.
This Commission has consisted of nine City residents selected by City Council who have served
on a volunteer basis. This is an advisory Commission. Decision-making power regarding
changes to the Charter rests with the Virginia General Assembly, who will take up deliberation
on proposed changes either on the recommendation of City Council or as a result of any voter
referendum that may result from this process.
The Commission’s aim is to consider how best to implement democratic self-government in the
City of Richmond under the City’s current conditions, taking account of both the city’s
experience with the current form of government and the numerous changes that have taken place
in Richmond from 2004 to the present.
The Commission undertakes this work noting that Richmond residents differ in their priorities
and expectations of city government. Some residents assess city government primarily from a
service delivery lens (whether the City provides good services at reasonable cost). Other
residents believe city government should focus primarily on tackling major ongoing concerns
such as public safety and public education. And still other residents believe city government
should act as a vehicle for expanding greater social, economic, and racial justice wherever
possible, so as to address the City’s historical and ongoing inequities. These various concerns
and priorities are not mutually exclusive, and many residents share each of these concerns to one
degree or another.
The Commission also undertakes this work recognizing that Richmond is a racially diverse city
that continues to be impacted by decisions and structures established in the era of segregation.
Protecting the voting and electoral power of racial and ethnic minorities must be a prime
consideration of any assessment of our City’s governance structure; so too must creating a
governance form that can protect and advance the interests of those same voters. The
Commission views Richmond as an ever-evolving experiment in multiracial democracy based on
the fundamental concept of people from diverse backgrounds learning to share power, to
deliberate and to work together, and in so doing to discover and then advance the public interest.
Lastly, the Commission undertakes this work cognizant that Richmond City government is a
complex organization meeting many different needs, that operates with a set of challenges (from
5
high poverty levels to aging infrastructure to a tax base limited by publicly owned land and the
City’s inability to grow) that are unique in central Virginia and among the most severe of any
municipality nationally. We acknowledge and honor the professionalism, commitment and
competency of the many City leaders and City employees who devote themselves to public
service every day, often with little recognition. It is our hope that the work of the Charter
Commission contributes to strengthening the City of Richmond as a place where talented
employees can do good work, feel valued, and build meaningful careers in public service, to the
benefit of City residents.
The Commission’s work is informed by past efforts to create a more inclusive, representative,
effective, and efficient local government. We respect the work of the many Richmond residents
and professionals within and adjacent to city government who have worked tirelessly in recent
decades to advance the City’s best interests as they understood them. But while we must study
and learn from the past, our primary aim in this process is to address a forward-looking question:
What should democratic self-government and the practice of multiracial democracy look like in
the City of Richmond in the decades to come?
This work is also undertaken with full awareness that many of the City’s challenges derive from
the legacy of policies and structural arrangements enacted at the regional and state level. From
affordable housing to regional transportation to public education funding to criminal justice
policies, the City of Richmond’s well-being is profoundly impacted by state policy as well as
decisions enacted by other local governments in the metropolitan area. In debates about the
Charter revisions enacted twenty years ago, many astute observers noted that Charter change was
no panacea for the City’s challenges.1
That observation holds true today. But Richmond’s challenged history and challenging state
context makes it all the more imperative that local government operate as efficiently and
effectively as possible, both as a provider of services and as a locus for democracy and self-
government.
We believe in the capacity of local government to have a positive impact on residents’ lives. We
believe there are many examples of Richmond City government and agencies doing exactly that,
now and in decades past. Our concern is to strengthen local government’s functioning, so that it
can positively impact even more lives and better address our current and future challenges.
The City Charter Review Commission was charged by Ordinance 2021-174 with undertaking a
comprehensive assessment of Richmond’s City Charter, including: “a. The resolution of
ambiguities and conflicts; b. The correction of clerical and grammatical errors; c. The removal of
outdated or otherwise inapplicable text; d. Any clarifications or changes to the definition and
delineation of the authority of the Council, the Mayor, and the Chief Administrative Officer; e.
Any other clarifications or changes pertaining to the City’s current form of government,
including, but by no means limited to, whether the Council should have staggered terms or how
to address any issues with the legal representation of the City; f. The enactment of amendments
1 Weeks before the 2003 advisory referendum, VCU Professor John V. Moeser, a supporter of the proposal, was
quoted as rhetorically asking “Is a mayor elected by the people enough? Enough to solve the most pressing problems
of this city?” and answering “Of course not.” Jeremy M. Lazarus, “It’s No Fix for City Ills,” Richmond Free Press,
October 9-11, 2003.
6
to general laws that would benefit the City; and g. Proposed text for the legislation needed to
effectuate the Commission’s recommendations.”
Subsequent sections of this report detail the modern history of Richmond’s City Charter (Chapter
Two), the process this Commission has undertaken (Chapter Three), demographic changes in the
City since the last major alteration to the Charter in 2004 (Chapter Four), the fourfold set of
recommendations and the reasoning behind them (Chapters Five, Six, Seven and Eight), and
recommended next steps (Chapter Nine). The remainder of this Executive Summary provides a
high-level overview of the four sets of recommendations offered by the Commission. We
encourage interested readers to review the entire document for more relevant detail and
explanation.
Recommendations, Part One: Updating the City Charter Document
Richmond’s current City Charter was adopted in 1948 by an act of the General Assembly,
following the report of the 1947 City Charter Commission and an advisory referendum held in
1947 supporting the proposal for the new Charter. This new Charter established the modern nine-
person City Council. Subsequent amendments have built on the fundamental 1948 framework.
Because the document is some 75 years old, it includes language, provisions, and details that are
no longer necessary or appropriate. (Indeed, the document is older than the current Virginia
Constitution.) In many cases, the Charter articulates specific powers that cities in Virginia are
granted under Virginia general law; in a few cases it articulates powers the City does not actually
have because the federal government or another entity has jurisdiction.
Moreover, in some instances the Charter has provisions that are inappropriate or even
contradictory to the Mayor-Council form of government.
As delineated in Chapter Five, the Commission makes forty-seven specific recommendations for
striking, amending, or adding language in the Charter, and provides rationales for each
recommendation. These recommendations are informed in large measure by a legal analysis of
the Charter performed on behalf of the Commission by municipal law expert Mr. Walter Erwin.
They also reflect the Commission’s consideration of numerous provisions cited by the
administration as unnecessary or as in tension with the Mayor-Council form of government.
The goal of these recommendation is to make the Charter more legible and less confusing to City
residents, and to reduce potential for confusion or dispute from instances in which the Charter
conflicts with general law.
With one partial exception, the Commission recommends that Council review these
recommendations and move forward with a request to adopt these changes to the Charter
in the General Assembly session beginning in January 2024.
With respect to the recommendation regarding Chapter 17 (Planning, Zoning, and Subdivisions),
the Commission recommends additional discussion among key stakeholders of the implications
of replacing current language (much of which originates from city ordinances adopted in the
1940s or earlier) with much simpler language mirroring approaches taken by other Virginia
cities. The Commission recognizes that those discussions may require additional time, and
therefore recommends that the Council move forward with preparing amendments to Chapter 17
for General Assembly approval either in January 2024 or in January 2025.
7
Recommendations, Part Two: Refining Mayor-Council Government
The second set of recommendations, totaling fourteen, include adjustments and alterations to the
current Mayor-Council form of government in order to improve its functioning. These
recommendations (delineated in Chapter Six) primarily concern the powers and responsibilities
of the Mayor, Council, Chief Administrative Officer, and City Attorney.
Taken as a group, these recommendations reconceive Richmond’s Mayor-Council form of
government as a Partnership Model between the Mayor and Council, with changes that are
intended to simultaneously enhance the ability of the Mayor to act as the city’s chief executive
officer and the ability of the Council to act as the City’s governing body.
Perhaps the most critical recommendations in this section concern the positions of Chief
Administrative Officer and City Attorney, each of which are crucial to the functioning of city
government. Whereas currently the Chief Administrative Officer is appointed and dismissed
solely by the Mayor (with Council consent to the appointment) and the City Attorney is
appointed and dismissed solely by City Council, we recommend that both Mayor and Council
have a substantial role in both the hiring and dismissal of both positions. We propose similar (not
identical) processes for the appointment and removal of each position.
The Commission also recommends significant changes in the budget process to advance the
goals of providing more avenues for Council to provide substantial front-end input in the
process, creating a more balanced amendment process, and providing the administration with
flexibility within defined limits to allocate additional resources to agencies in real time to meet
emergent needs without Council approval.
The Commission also proposes two adjustments to the powers and responsibilities of the Mayor:
First, to strengthen the ability of the Mayor to act as the City’s chief executive officer by
providing the Mayor the ability to appoint and remove department heads, or to delegate such
authority (in part or in whole) to the Chief Administrative Officer; and second, requiring the
Mayor to provide a monthly public update on the City’s progress (overall or in a specified policy
area) at a meeting of City Council, and to receive questions from each Council member. We
believe this requirement will both be an important avenue of communication and help City
residents better understand the ongoing work of city government.
Finally, the Commission recommends Charter changes to raise the compensation of the Mayor to
a level appropriate to the organizational role of chief executive officer, and also to in effect
double the compensation of Council members, in view of the importance of their work and to
make it feasible for more residents to consider service on the Council.
The Commission believes adoption of these proposals will strengthen the operation in practice of
the Mayor-Council form of government. Specifically, the adjustments to the Chief
Administrative Officer position and the budget process will provide Council greater scope to act
effectively as the City’s governing body and greater voice in the work of the administration. At
the same time, the adjustments expand the tools and flexibility available to the Mayor and the
administration to fulfill their responsibilities. Finally, the proposals establish a significant new
mechanism for ongoing public dialogue and discussion between the Mayor and Council.
The Commission believes that Council and the Administration should carefully review and
deliberate upon the package of proposals in Part Two. We also believe the City will benefit
8
from pushing forward this slate of Charter adjustments in January 2024 so that the
Partnership Model of Mayor-Council government can take effect on January 1, 2025.
Recommendations, Part Three: Considering Council-Manager Government
In Chapter Seven, the Commission examines an alternative path for Richmond local government:
maintaining a directly-elected Mayor position, while embedding it within a Council-Manager
form of government. This discussion is pursuant to the Ordinance’s charge that this Commission
make recommendations for Charter amendments to include “clarifications or changes pertaining
to the City’s current form of government.”
In this section, the Commission specifies what, based on presently available information, it
believes to be the best available model for a modern Council-Manager government in Richmond:
a seven-person Council to include six district representatives and a Mayor elected at-large, who
develop policies and then collectively hire a City Manager to implement them.
This discussion of shifting the form of government is not undertaken lightly. Chapter Seven of
the Report specifies several reasons why considering a shift in the form of government is a
reasonable endeavor with potential benefits for the City and the operation of local government
(and democracy) in Richmond.
The Commission, however, does not make a recommendation that the City change its form of
government for two primary reasons:
• Changing the form of government and associated electoral arrangements will require careful
legal review. That review may impact the details of any specific proposal in important ways.
In the absence of a fully specified proposal that has undergone thorough legal review it
would be irresponsible for the Commission to give a blanket endorsement to a shift to
Council-Manager government: details matter, and more work is needed to work out certain
details.
• We believe that the voters of the City of Richmond should have the opportunity to express
their views via an advisory referendum prior to any change in the form of government. While
cogent arguments can be made for or against Council-Manager government vis-à-vis Mayor-
Council government, at some level communities face a profound choice regarding whether it
is best to make a single individual (the Mayor) or a collective body (the Council) the lead
actor in local government. This is a choice the Commission believes should ultimately rest in
the hands of City residents, as expressed at the ballot box.
Instead, the Commission recommends that Council take deliberate steps to continue discussion
of a potential transition to a Council-Manager form of government, and delineates specific steps
that should be taken as part of that process. Specifically, if Council wishes to move forward, it
should appoint a new commission or committee to include a diverse set of residents as well as
professional expertise in municipal law, election law, demographics, and mapping to examine
the feasibility of bringing the Commission’s identified proposal (or a variant thereof) forward for
an advisory referendum as soon as 2024 (and no later than 2026) concerning a potential change
in the form of government, to take full effect by January 1, 2029.
The Commission recommends that Council act to create such a commission by December
15, 2023.
9
Recommendations, Part Four: Staggered Council Terms
Richmond is currently the only independent city in Virginia with four-year Council terms that
are not staggered.
The Commission believes the adoption of staggered Council terms would be beneficial,
regardless of the form of government practiced by the City. Staggered Council terms would
assure a measure of continuity and stability over time, while also giving City residents an
opportunity every two years to voice approval or dissatisfaction with the direction and
performance of city government.
Implementation of staggered Council terms in Richmond would require addressing several
specific questions, to assure procedural and substantive fairness across Council districts. The
resolution of those questions is beyond the proper scope of the Commission, but Chapter Eight
briefly lays out the relevant issues. The Commission recommends that Council develop a
process to address those issues as soon as feasible with a view to implementing staggered
terms in 2028.
Limitations of the Current Review
Finally, we wish to acknowledge several limitations of the Charter Review Commission’s work
and this final report.
First, this report is not, nor does it purport to be, a comprehensive assessment of the policy
accomplishments, setbacks, and ongoing challenges under the Mayor-Council form of
government implemented by the City in 2005. Such an assessment is outside the scope of this
Commission’s assigned work and in any case is best undertaken in the broader public arena. The
report does, however, note key issues related to the Charter and governance structure that have
arisen since that time, as per the Commission’s charge.
Second, the report is not, nor does it purport to be, a comprehensive assessment of the City’s
organizational development under the Mayor-Council form of government. Again, such an
assessment is outside the scope of this Commission’s assigned work, and would be best
undertaken by a different process. The City of Richmond has acknowledged organizational
challenges, many of which are not fundamentally related to the Charter or the form of
government. 2 The report and recommendations do, however, address some Charter provisions
that are clearly in tension with the Mayor-Council form of government and unhelpful to its
operation.
Third, the work of the Charter Review Commission did not engage the issues of School Board
governance or of cooperation among the School Board, City Council and Mayor. Consideration
of those issues was outside of the scope of the current Commission and in any case would be best
addressed through a process focused primarily on those issues, engaging the School Board as a
full partner. We note, however, that any change in the electoral process with respect to Council
2 For a helpful overview prepared in conjunction with key stakeholders in Richmond City government, see
Richmond City Auditor’s Office, “Fiscal and Efficiency Review: Final Report,” April 2022.
10
elections (including adoption of staggered terms or changing the number of Council districts)
should be preceded by engagement with the School Board, and would very likely require
adjustments to Charter provision 20.01 providing for the School Board and its method of
election.
Fourth, while the Commission undertook substantial public engagement in our process, we are
not satisfied that we have received fully representative engagement, as we note in our report.
More broadly, the Commission believes that much more civic education and outreach is needed
to inform all parts of the public regarding issues related to the City Charter. This will be
particularly crucial if Council wishes to move forward with further consideration of major
changes to the form of government. The report outlines some recommended steps in this regard.
Indeed, among our recommendations is that a decennial Charter review, led by City residents,
become a requirement of the Charter itself, beginning in 2030. As a rapidly changing city with a
somewhat novel form of government, it is appropriate that Richmond on a regular basis continue
to assess and re-assess the Charter document in light of ongoing experience and change, and
continue to consider promising new ideas.
This proposal would assure that such a review happens in a regular fashion, with timing set by
the Charter rather than by short-term political considerations. Perhaps some of the limitations of
the current process might be addressed in future reviews.
11
Chapter Two: A Short History of Richmond’s City Charter
Some 75 years ago, the current City Charter was established by a public process, beginning with
a City Charter Commission, chaired by future Supreme Court Justice Lewis F. Powell. The
Commission followed years of advocacy by “progressive” civic and business organizations for
reform, and a 1946 advisory referendum that both provided for a Charter Commission and
elected members to it.3 The resultant Commission forcefully argued that the City’s prior
governing structure (including a two-chamber legislative branch and an elected Mayor) was
unwieldy and poorly suited to the needs of modern cities.4 The result of that analysis was the
creation of the modern nine-member City Council, with two significant provisions: Council
members would be elected at large, and Council would collectively hire a city manager to
manage the day-to-day business of city government. The Charter also allowed for a ceremonial
Mayor to be chosen by the elected Council members from among themselves. These proposals
were endorsed by referendum in 1947 and enacted by the Virginia General Assembly in 1948.
Considerations of racial justice and fair representation of all groups played no role in the 1948
Charter. Indeed, the Charter was adopted in the context of ongoing racial segregation in the city,
state and region, and City leadership had been exclusively white for roughly half a century.
Nonetheless, according to scholars Rutledge Dennis and John Moeser, the Richmond Civic
Council, a prominent Black organization, endorsed the Charter change as an improvement over
the previous gerrymandered ward system; and 1948 saw the at-large election of the first Black
member of Richmond City Council in the 20th century, Oliver W. Hill, who served one term. In
the 1950s and early 1960s, even as Council remained exclusively white, Black voting rights
organizations such as the Richmond Crusade for Voters pushed for and to a substantial degree
attained significant electoral influence and by 1966 substantial Black representation on Council.5
Indeed, the establishment of the 1965 Voting Rights Act combined with demographic changes
raised the imminent prospect of majority Black control of Richmond local government. White
city leaders (whose previous efforts to forge a merger with Henrico County had been rejected by
county voters in a 1961 referendum) hastily struck a deal to annex part of Chesterfield County,
adding about 47,000 residents, overwhelmingly white, to the City on January 1, 1970, and
assuring the May 1970 municipal elections would be conducted with a majority-white city
electorate.6
3 Christopher Silver, Twentieth-Century Richmond: Planning, Politics, and Race. Knoxville: University of
Tennessee Press, 1984. p. 176.
4 Richmond Charter Commission, “Proposed Charter for the City of Richmond, For Submission to the Electorate,
November 4, 1947” filed in the office of the Clerk of the Hustings Court of the City of Richmond and in the office
of the City Clerk of the City of Richmond on May 2nd, 1947; and Richmond Charter Commission, “Report
Accompanying Proposed Charter for the City of Richmond,” September 1, 1947.
5 John Moeser and Rutledge Dennis, The Politics of Annexation: Oligarchic Power in a Southern City, Cambridge:
Schenkman Publishing Company, 1982; reissued open access edition, VCU Libraries, 2020; pp. 32 -33, 44-48, and
62-68. See also Silver, Twentieth-Century Richmond, pp. 176-181. In 1966, three Black candidates won election to
the Council (B.A. Cephas, Jr., Henry L. Marsh III, and Winfred Mundle). Cephas was first elected in 1964 as the
first Black Council member since Oliver W. Hill.
6 Moeser and Dennis, The Politics of Annexation. For a recent recital of these events, see Lelia Barghouty, “How the
Former Confederate Capital Slashed Black Voting Power, Overnight,” Washington Post, July 9, 2023.
12
Legal challenges to the annexation arguing that this maneuver was racially motivated led the
federal government to cancel the 1972 local elections and suspend local electoral activity, a
suspension that continued to 1977. The resolution of the dispute called for replacing the at-large
system of Council elections with single-member councilmanic districts, in order to assure Black
Richmond residents the opportunity to elect candidates of their choice in proportion to their share
of the city population. The result was the historic election in 1977 of Richmond’s first majority
Black City Council, and that Council’s selection of Richmond’s first Black Mayor, Henry L.
Marsh III.7
The reforms of 1977 represent the first set of major changes to the 1948 City Charter document.
The second major set of changes was enacted by the General Assembly in 2004, following a
citywide referendum in November 2003. In November 2003 voters overwhelmingly approved
proposals generated by a privately-organized commission led by former Richmond Mayor
Thomas Bliley (1970-1977) and former Virginia Governor L. Douglas Wilder (1990-1994), to
establish two major changes:
• Provide for a directly-elected Mayor, to be elected by winning five of the City’s nine
Council districts, a unique electoral system designed to protect Black voting power;
• Shift from a Council-Manager to a Mayor-Council form of government, in which the
Mayor would act as the “Chief Executive Officer” of the City, expressed primarily
through the right to hire and fire a Chief Administrative Officer with responsibility for
day-to-day operations of city government.
The advisory referendum had majority support in all nine Council districts, with support ranging
from 54.7% in the 6th District to 96.7% in the 1st District. The overall “yes” vote citywide was
80.2%.8
Following approval by the General Assembly and the federal government, the new system of
government took effect on January 1, 2005, with L. Douglas Wilder serving as first Mayor
elected under the new system. 9 This specific form of municipal government was and remains
unique within Virginia, although numerous cities nationally have similar structural arrangements.
Numerous conflicts and controversies related to the Charter and the respective powers of the
Mayor, Council and other bodies characterized the first full term of the system of government,
on matters ranging from the budget process to whether the Chief Administrative Officer had
7 Moeser and Dennis, The Politics of Annexation, pp. 141-175.
8 Virginia Department of Elections. While the measure had strong support in all nine districts, some 48. 8% of the
22,122 total “yes” votes in the 2003 referendum were cast in the 1 st and 4th Districts.
9 Nelson Wikstrom, “Richmond: Implementation of and Experience with Strong-Mayor Form of Government,” in
James H. Svara and Douglas J. Watson, eds., More Than Mayor or Manager: Campaigns to Change Form of
Government in America’s Largest Cities.” Georgetown University Press, 2010, pp. 81-102.
13
authority to dismiss the City Council staff to whether the Mayor should have direct authority
over schools to the validity of a lease agreement between City Council and the School Board.10
At stake in these initial conflicts (two of which resulted in lawsuits) were specific questions
about the correct interpretation of the Charter, but also broader questions about the role of both
Mayor and Council under the new form of government. The conflicts also surfaced ambiguities
in both the Charter language and their implications for practice. Indeed, some of the same issues
noted in this report were discussed as early as 2005 (including pay for the Mayor, whether
Council should have the right to initiate budget amendments, and the role of the City Attorney’s
office in the new form of government).11
Throughout the first term under the new form of government, Mayor Wilder regularly called for
revisions to the Charter with the aim of expanding the formal powers of the Mayor. (Some
alterations to the Charter were in fact made in 2005 and 2006, as detailed below.) The actual
powers afforded to the Mayor under the new system were indeed limited compared to many
other cities with a Mayor-Council form of government. The three primary powers provided
Richmond’s elected Mayor included the power to hire and fire a Chief Administrative Officer,
the power to introduce the budget, and a veto power for legislation (added in 2005). (Since the
veto can be overridden with six Council votes and only five votes are needed to pass an
ordinance, the veto power has rarely been highly salient in practice.)
In contrast, the Atlanta City Charter specifies some fifteen powers and responsibilities for its
elected mayor, including the ability to hire and fire a chief operating officer, prepare the budget,
and veto legislation, but also the ability to call special meetings of Council, to “Exercise
supervision over all the administration of all departments of the city and delegate all or part of
such supervision to the chief operating officer” and to “Prescribe, require, publish, and
implement standards of administrative, management, and operating practices and procedures to
be followed and adhered to by all offices, departments, boards, commissions, authorities, and
other agencies of the city subject to his or her supervision and jurisdiction or delegate all or part
of such responsibilities to the chief operating officer.”12
Ultimately, while some Richmonders had envisioned an extremely strong elected mayor with not
only broad powers with respect to city administration but also effective control or influence over
adjacent entities including schools, by the end of the first term public appetite for adding to the
Mayor’s powers had waned (along with public patience with continuing legal conflicts within
City Hall).
10 See Wikstrom, “Richmond: Implementation of and Experience with Strong-Mayor Form of Government,” pp. 93-
96 for discussion.
11 Jeremy Redmon, “Council Likely to Bump Up Wilder’s Salary,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, May 17, 2005;
Jeremy Redmon, “Wilder Says He Won’t Take the $25,000,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, May 22, 2005; David
Ress, “Changes Floated to Curb Mayor’s Powers,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, November 16, 2005; David Ress,
“’Growing Pains’ for City Council With a Mayor Who Knows a Lot About Power, Members Find ‘Sea Change’ in
Their Role,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, December 11, 2005.
12 City of Atlanta Charter (3-104), available at https://www.atlantaga.gov/home/showpublisheddocument/10018
14
In 2008, City Council, with the support of the Mayor, established a Charter Review Commission
to clarify ambiguities and reduce conflict within the Charter. Four members were selected by
Council, and four by the Mayor; those eight members selected a ninth member, Professor John
Douglass of the University of Richmond School of Law, to serve as chair.
That Commission discussed several issues addressed in the current report, in particular regarding
the City Attorney.13 Three of its recommendations were enacted by the General Assembly in
2010, including: clarifying that the Council could hire and fire its own staff and that the ability of
the Mayor to participate in personnel decisions be limited to the administrative departments;
adjustments to the Richmond Retirement System; and broadening the scope of the mayoral veto
to encompass any ordinance.14 The Commission’s proposal to have the Mayor appoint the City
Attorney with the consent of a majority of Council was not adopted.15
Since 2010, there have been four substantive Charter amendments: a new provision on school
modernization adopted in 2018 following an advisory referendum; establishment of an Inspector
General appointed by Council in 2018; amended provisions related to runoff elections for Mayor
adopted in 2019; and a district residency requirement for Council members adopted in 2020.
A complete list of amendments to the City Charter adopted from 2005 to 2020 is listed below:
Amendments Adopted in 2005
3.04, 4.03, 4.05. Substituted "president of council" for "vice mayor."
4.04. Specified position of deputy city clerk.
5.03. Replaced paragraph to allow Mayor to participate in hiring and removal of heads of city
departments.
5.05, 5.06. Allowed Mayor or designee to attend and participate in Council meetings and boards
and commissions (except School Board).
5B.01. Adjustments to retirement system to allow two mayoral appointments (of seven).
6.11. Establishment of mayoral line-item veto on budget ordinance.
6.14. Allow Mayor and Council to take any action regarding the school budget permitted by
section 22.1-94 of the Code of Virginia and general law.
7B.06. Substituted "chief administrative officer" for "city manager."
17.02. Provided for one mayoral appointment to the City Planning Commission.
13 Will Jones, “Changes to Richmond’s Charter Could Be Put Off,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, September 13, 2009.
14 2009 Richmond Charter Review Commission, Final Report.
15 Other recommendations of the 2009 Commission that did not become Charter amendments included giving the
Mayor a role in the appointment and dismissal of the City Auditor and the City Assessor; providing for time limits
on Interim Chief Administrative Officers and for the pre-designation of an Acting Chief Administrative Officer in
the case of a sudden vacancy; and stating that mayoral veto powers extended to sale or lease of real property.
Source: 2009 City Charter Review Commission Final Report and Richmond City Attorney’s Office .
15
Amendments Adopted in 2006
4.10. Deleted language related to passage of ordinances at special meetings.
4.16(b). Clerical edits.
4.17. Added language specifying the City Attorney and assistants may represent multiple city
officials or agencies in the same transaction, and allowing the Mayor to employ special counsel
when the City Attorney determines there is a conflict of interest prohibiting the rendering of
legal services to the Mayor and administration.
5.05 (a) Allow Mayor or designees to attend closed meetings of Council, unless the subject of the
meeting includes the office of the Mayor.
5.05 (d) Establish veto power on any ordinance "imposing such duties on him, the chief
administrative officer, or any department head appointed by the chief administrative officer,"
that can be over-ridden by six Council votes.
5.05.1 (e) Requires chief administrative officer to attend or be represented at all meetings of
Council provided the Council has given the Mayor 72 hours of advance notice concerning the
matters under discussion.
5.05.1 (f) Require chief administrative officer to perform duties assigned by ordinance (as well
as Charter).
6.02. Budget submission to take place no earlier than the second Monday in February.
6.03. Mayor's budget may make adjustments to the School Board budget to the extent permitted
by state law.
6.06 Clerical edits
6.07. Allows Council to require itemization below department level in the appropriation
ordinance.
6.10. Substitutes "mayor" for "manager."
6.11. Mayoral veto power not pertinent to budget resolutions (as opposed to ordinances).
6.12. Budget as adopted certified by city clerk only (not "city manager and city clerk.")
6.13. Deleted sentence from paragraph on utilities budget.
13.06, 13.08. Substituted "chief administrative officer" for "city manager."
13.07, 13.09. Substituted “mayor” for city manager.”
Amendments Adopted in 2010
4.02(f). New paragraph to give Council powers of appointment and removal of Council staff.
5.03. Mayor participation in hiring and removal limited to heads of administrative departments,
and chief administrative officer authority over personnel limited to administrative departments.
5.05(b). Removed gendered language referencing the Mayor.
16
5.05 (d). Mayoral veto power extends to all ordinances (not only those that impose duties on
Mayor and administration).
5B.01. New sentence providing for the appointment of an executive director of the retirement
system.
13.11. Amended language related to waiver of charges for developers who cause a "permanent
reduction in post-development stormwater flow and pollutant loading."
Amendments Adopted in 2018
4.16 Amended language on investigations to include the Inspector General.
4.18. Adjustments to further specify the authority and duties of City Auditor.
4.19. Establishment of separate office of the Inspector General appointed by Council.
6.15.3. New provision on school building modernization.
Amendment Adopted in 2019
3.01.1 and 3.04(c). Procedures for voter registration and absentee voting for any runoff election
following a general or special election for Mayor to be as provided by relevant provisions in the
Code of Virginia.
Amendment Adopted in 2020
3.01 (C) and 3.04 (A). Establishing requirement for members of Council to reside in the district
from which they were elected during their terms of office, and providing for removal of members
for noncompliance with requirement.16
16 See https://law.lis.virginia.gov/charters/richmond/ for a list of adopted amendments to the Charter, including
where available links to the enabling legislation.
17
Chapter Three: Richmond City Charter Review Commission Process
On March 14, 2022, Richmond City Council voted unanimously to approve Ordinance 2021-
347, co-patroned by Council President Newbille, Vice-President Robertson, and Councilwoman
Lambert, thereby establishing a City Charter Review Commission.
This Commission is an advisory study Commission. Its work is but one step in the overall
process of potentially changing the Charter. The following diagram illustrates the Commission’s
role within this larger process.
Following the selection of its members by City Council, the Commission met for the first time
on November 21, 2022. A total of twenty meetings of the full Commission were held, on the
following dates: November 21 and December 19, 2022; and January 19, February 8, March 14,
March 30, April 20, April 27, May 10, May 18, May 23, June 8, June 15, June 22, June 28, July
6, July 13, July 20, July 27, and August 1, 2023. All meetings were open to the public, and
approved minutes of each meeting have been submitted to the City Clerk. Four meetings were
designated as public hearings for the primary purpose of receiving public comment (May 23,
June 15, June 22 and June 28), and public comment was also invited for the July 6, July 13, July
City Council passes
ordinance to create
Charter Review
Commission (March
2022)
Commission gathers
and reviews research
(November 2022 - May
2023)
Public feedback on
initial reform options
(May 2023-July 2023)
Commission final report
to council
Council review of
recommendations
Council can decide to
take action or not take
action
Proposed changes
through council
resolution or
referendum
Proposed changes go to
General Assembly via
legislation for approval
Legislation enacted and
charter amended
18
20, and July 27 meetings, and accepted at other Commission meetings in which members of the
public expressed a desire to testify. Most Commission meetings were also accessible online.
The three subcommittees established by the Commission as described below also had numerous
meetings, which were also open to the public. In January, a landing page for the work of the
Commission was launched on the City Council website, and a dedicated email account
(rvacharterreview@gmail.com) was also established to receive public comment concerning the
Commission’s work.
In its initial meetings (November and December 2022), the Commission selected officers,
reviewed its charge as established by ordinance, reviewed the history of the Charter, and
established a work plan. A key feature of the work plan was to develop and present multiple
options for Charter reform for public feedback prior to the adoption of Commission
recommendations, consistent with the Ordinance’s requirement for soliciting public participation
as part of its work.
Beginning at its January meeting, the Commission conducted a shared public reading of the text
of the Charter, including discussion of key elements. In January and February, two members of
the commission (Mr. Kyle Elliott and Mr. Travis Gunn) conducted a series of interviews with
stakeholders regarding the Charter, including the Mayor, the Chief Administrative Officer
(CAO), current City Council members, the City Attorney, and past officials, and prepared a
summary of themes voiced in those interviews. The Commission also conducted an initial review
of Richmond’s form of government compared to other independent cities in Virginia as well as
cities outside Virginia. Finally, the Commission received for review a list of suggested Charter
changes provided by the City administration.
The Commission then moved to establish two subcommittees to develop options for reform, on
two separate tracks: a Governance Subcommittee charged with suggesting reforms within the
current Mayor-Council form of government and current electoral arrangements; and an Electoral
Subcommittee charged with developing for consideration an option for changing to a Council-
Manager system of government to include a directly elected Mayor.
The Commission subsequently established a Document Optimization subcommittee to look at
other issues related to the language of the Charter not covered by the other Subcommittees.
To assist in the work, the Commission was also supported by outside professional research. In
the spring, the University of Virginia School of Law State and Local Government Policy Clinic
prepared a literature review on the relative advantages of Mayor-Council compared to Council-
Manager forms of government. In May 2023, municipal law expert Mr. Walter Erwin, Esq.,
prepared a memorandum identifying Charter provisions that duplicate general law and hence
may be unnecessary, as well commenting on several other key aspects of the Richmond Charter.
In May 2023, the Commission launched a short public engagement survey with the support of
City Council staff. The survey was live between May 19 and June 21, and received 1148
responses. A summary of survey results is included within this report.
In advance of public hearings on May 23, June 15, June 22 and on June 28 the Commission
released summary versions of proposals under consideration as well as a FAQ addressing
questions about the Commission’s work and process. On June 12, a comprehensive list of
proposals under active consideration was shared with City Council and the administration with
19
an invitation for feedback, and also published to the Charter Review website along with
numerous supplementary documents.
On the basis of its consideration of all evidence presented to the Commission, public comment
and input, and the Commission’s deliberations, on July 6 the Commission agreed on a
framework for the final report and for its overarching recommendations. In subsequent meetings
of July 13, July 20, and July 27, the Commission conducted final review of each of its specific
recommendations as well as draft versions of this report. On August 1, the Commission voted to
approve this final report and empower the Chair and Vice-Chair to make any clerical or
grammatical edits needed in preparation for final submission of the report.
With the submission of this report on August 2, 2023, its work being completed, the Commission
is thereby dissolved.
20
Chapter Four: Demographic Change in Richmond, 2000-2022
The City of Richmond has changed in striking ways over the past twenty years. This information
is relevant to the work of the Commission insofar as Richmond is now a significantly different
city than at the time the last set of major changes to the Charter were enacted.
The purpose of this short section is to provide a high-level summary of key trends.
This section first outlines overall population trends in Richmond and the surrounding region
from 1970 to 2022; then it outlines trends in key demographic and socio-economic indicators in
the City over the period to 2000 to 2021; and finally, it outlines citywide trends in the voting-age
population between 2000 and 2020.
More detailed discussion of this data, including demographic changes within each Council
district since 2000, and their potential implications for the city’s electoral procedures, can be
found as Appendix C.
Table 4-1. Population Trends in Richmond and Surrounding Localities, 1970-2022
Population in thousands
1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2020 2022
City of Richmond 249.6 219.2 203.1 197.8 204.2 226.6 229.4
Chesterfield County 76.9 141.4 209.3 259.9 316.2 364.5 378.4
Hanover County 37.5 50.4 63.3 86.3 99.9 110.0 112.9
Henrico County 154.4 180.7 217.9 262.3 306.9 334.4 334.0
Source: United States Census; Decennial Census and Current Population Estimates. Note: The
City’s population, after remaining essentially flat between 2000 and 2004, began its upward
trajectory between 2005 and 2010. See U.S. Census City and Town Intercensal Data Sets, 2000-
2010.
21
Table 4-2. Selected Demographic and Socio-economic Trends in Richmond, 2000-2021
2000 2007-2011 2017-2021 2021
Black residents % 56.6% 50.1% 45.0% 42.8%
White (not Latino) residents % 37.8% 38.9% 41.4% 41.5%
Latino residents % 2.7% 5.9% 7.3% 7.8%
Asian residents % 1.2% 2.3% 2.1% 2.3%
Two or more races % 1.3% 2.6% 3.6% 4.9%
Other races % 0.4% 0.4% 0.5% 0.8%
Median household income $50,766 $47,326 $54,795 $51,770
Poverty rate 21.4% 26.3% 19.8% 21.1%
Child poverty rate 33.4% 40.5% 30.2% 33.7%
% Adults less than high school 24.8% 19.5% 12.3% 11.9%
% Adults with college degree 29.5% 32.9% 43.1% 43.7%
Median home value $137,891 $246,885 $263,000 $311,700
Sources: United States Census and American Community Survey (5-year estimates for 2007-
2011 and 2017-2021; one-year estimate for 2021); Social Explorer. All dollar values expressed
as inflation-adjusted 2021 dollars. Margin of error for one-year estimates is larger than for 5-
year estimates.
Table 4-3. Citywide Changes in Voting-Age Population by Race and Ethnicity, 2000-2020
Citywide Total
2000 2010 2020
Black 79,658 (51.5%) 77,186 (46.4%) 71,362 (38.0%)
White (not Latino) 66,608 (43.1%) 71,686 (43.1%) 85,498 (45.5%)
Latino 3,842 (2.5%) 9,518 (5.7%) 16,887 (9.0%)
Asian 2,175 (1.4%) 4,421 (2.7%) 5,830 (3.1%)
Two or More Races 1,688 (1.1%) 2,635 (1.6%) 7,003 (3.7%)
Other 641 (0.4%) 759 (0.5%) 1,366 (0.7%)
Source: United States Census, Decennial Redistricting Data.
22
Chapter Five: Recommendations, I: Document Optimization
The first set of recommendations consist primarily of removal of unnecessary or outdated
provisions of the Charter, updating language of some provisions, and clarifying some provisions
or making them more consistent with Richmond’s current form of government.
Most recommendations in this section are informed by a legal analysis performed on behalf of
the Commission by Walter Erwin, Esquire, a municipal law expert and former city attorney
based in Lynchburg, Virginia. The section provides brief explanations of the basis for each
change, in some cases, for the sake of precision, quoting verbatim or closely paraphrasing
language from Mr. Erwin’s memorandum. Mr. Erwin’s complete memorandum is attached as
an Appendix to this report.
A key principle underlying these recommendations is that a Charter shorn of unnecessary,
duplicative, or obsolete language will be easier for residents to understand and use, and also
reduce the incidence of confusion or conflict in cases where the Charter may conflict with
general law.17 Here it may be helpful to quote Mr. Erwin’s explanation directly:
Virginia's cities get their powers from two sources, their charters, in which the General
Assembly grants power s to a specific city and the general laws adopted by the General
Assembly which confer powers to all cities.
When Virginia's older cities, such as Richmond, were granted their charters, there were
few general laws granting powers to these cities. In the ab sence of general laws, city
charters attempted to cover every detail of a city's operations, defining the organization,
powers, functions and essential procedures of city government.
Over the years the General Assembly adopted an increasing number of gener al laws
granting powers to cities, and there may be provisions in an older city's charter that are
inconsistent with or duplicate the state's general laws. A city charter can also become
complicated as a result of piecemeal revisions. Differences between the provisions in a
charter and the Commonwealth's general laws can be confusing.18
With this background in mind, the Commission has prepared the following recommendations.
Each recommended change is labeled as follows: 5-1, 5-2, etc., for ease of reference.
Language to be added to the Charter is marked in bold and language to be deleted is struck
through.19
17 Walter Erwin Memorandum for the City Charter Review Commission, pp. 1-2. The primary memorandum and
two follow-up notes from Mr. Erwin are included as Appendix G of this report. All references in this report are to
the primary memorandum of June 8, 2023, unless otherwise noted.
18 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 1.
19 In drafting new or amended language for the Charter, the Commission has sought to follow current best practice
by avoiding use of the ambiguous word “shall,” instead using “will,” “must” or “may.” The Commission has not
23
Section 2.01. General grant of powers
5-1. Strike and Add
The city shall have and may exercise all powers which are now or may hereafter be
conferred upon or delegated to cities under the Constitution and laws of the
Commonwealth and all other powers pertinent to the conduct of a city government the
exercise of which is not expressly prohibited by the said Constitution and laws and which
in the opinion of the council are necessary or desirable to promote the general welfare of
the city and the safety, health, peace, good order, comfort, convenience and morals of its
inhabitants, as fully and completely as though such powers were specifically enumerated
in this charter, and no enumeration of particular powers in this charter shall be held to be
exclusive but shall be held to be in addition to this general grant of powers. (1948, c. 116)
Add
The powers set forth in sections 15.2-1100 through 15.2-1133 of the Code of Virginia
as in force on January 1, 2024, and as hereafter amended, are hereby conferred on
and vested in the city of Richmond, for the conduct of city government and to
promote the general welfare of the city and its residents. In addition thereto the City
of Richmond will have and may exercise all other powers which are now or may
hereafter be conferred upon or delegated to independent cities under the
Constitution or the laws of the Commonwealth, as fully and completely as though
such powers were specifically enumerated in this charter, and no enumerations of
particular powers in this charter will be held to be exclusive but will be held to be in
addition to this general grant of powers.
Purpose of Change: The new language accomplishes the same functional goal as the older
language with more modern and precise language.
Section 2.02. Financial powers
5-2. Strike
202. (b) To borrow money for the purposes and in the manner provided by Chapter 7B of
this charter.
Purpose of Change: This power is authorized under general law (Virginia Code 15.2-1105) and
Article VII of the Virginia Constitution.
5-3. Strike
however sought to edit out existing uses of the word “shall” in the Charter in passages not recommended for
amendment, except when needed to match recommended new language within specific provisions.
24
202. (c) To make appropriations, subject to the limitations imposed by this charter, for
the support of the city government, and any other purposes not prohibited by this charter
and the laws of the Commonwealth.
Purpose of Change: This power is authorized under Article VII of the Virginia Constitution.
5-4. Strike
202. (e) To accept or refuse gifts, donations, bequests or grants from any source for any
purpose related to the powers and duties of the city government.
Purpose of Change: These powers are authorized under general law (Virginia Code 15.2-1108).
5-5. Strike
202. (f) To provide, or aid in the support of, public libraries and public schools.
Purpose of Change: These powers are authorized under general law (Virginia Code 42.1-33
with respect to libraries, and Virginia Code 22.1-88 and Article VIII of the Virginia Constitution
with respect to schools.)
5-6. Strike
202. (g) To grant financial aid to military units organized in the city in accordance with
the laws of the Commonwealth, and to charitable or benevolent institutions and
corporations, including those established for scientific, literary or musical purposes or the
encouragement of agriculture and the mechanical arts, whose functions further the public
purposes of the city.
Purpose of Change: These powers are authorized under general law (Virginia Code 15.2-1112
with respect to military units and Virginia Code 15.2-953 with respect to charitable and nonprofit
organizations and associations.)
Section 2.04. Power to make regulations for the preservation of the
safety, health, peace, good order, comfort, convenience, morals and
welfare of the city and its inhabitants.
5-7. Strike
a) To provide for the prevention of vice, immorality, vagrancy and drunkenness;
prevention and quelling of riots, disturbances and disorderly assemblages; suppression of
houses of ill fame and gambling places; prevention of lewd and disorderly conduct or
exhibitions; and prevention of conduct in the streets dangerous to the public.
Purpose of Change: The constitutional power of the City to regulate “vice,” “immorality,” and
“drunkenness” is questionable. Virginia general law provides for the City’s power to regulate
disorderly conduct in public places (Virginia Code 18.2-415); regulate riots (Virginia Code 15.2-
925); and prohibit public intoxication (Virginia Code 18.2-388). Virginia general law also
provides for the City’s power to deal with drug-blighted properties (Virginia Code 15.2-907),
25
places of prostitution (Virginia Code 15.2-908.1) and illegal manufacture, sale, and distribution
of alcoholic beverages (Virginia Code 4.1-317).
5-8. Strike
(b) To regulate the construction, maintenance and repair of buildings and other structures
and the plumbing, electrical, heating, elevator, escalator, boiler, unfired pressure vessel,
and air conditioning installations therein, for the purpose of preventing fire and other
dangers to life and health.
Purpose of Change: The Uniform Statewide Building Code establishes the authority of local
government to regulate the construction, maintenance and repair of buildings and structures.
5-9. Strike
(d) To grant or authorize the issuance of permits under such terms and conditions as the
council may impose for the use of streets, alleys and other public places of the city by
railroads, street railways, buses, taxicabs and other vehicles for hire; prescribe the
location in, under or over, and grant permits for the use of, streets, alleys and other public
places for the maintenance and operation of tracks, poles, wires, cables, pipes, conduits,
bridges, subways, vaults, areas and cellars; require tracks, poles, wires, cables, pipes,
conduits and bridges to be altered, removed or relocated either permanently or
temporarily; charge and collect compensation for the privileges so granted; and prohibit
such use of the streets, alleys and other public places of the city, and no such use shall be
made of the streets, alleys, or other public places of the city without the consent of the
council.
Purpose of Change: Virginia general law provides for the City’s powers to regulate streets,
alleys and public places, to grant permits and charge fees for use (Virginia Code 15.2-1125), to
maintain and regulate its real property (Virginia Code: 15.2-1800[E]), and to “prohibit utilities
from using public streets and alleys without the City’s consent” (Virginia Code 15.2-2017).20
5-10. Strike
(e) To prevent any obstruction of or encroachment over, under or in any street, alley,
sidewalk or other public place; provide penalties for maintaining any such obstruction or
encroachment; remove the same and charge the cost thereof to the owner or owners,
occupant or occupants of the property so obstructing or encroaching, and collect the sum
charged in any manner provided by law for the collection of taxes; require the owner or
owners or the occupant or occupants of the property so obstructing or encroaching to
remove the same; pending such removal charge the owner or owners of the property so
obstructing or encroaching compensation for the use of such portion of the street, alley,
sidewalk or other public place obstructed or encroached upon the equivalent of what
would be the tax upon the land so occupied if it were owned by the owner or owners of
20 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 4.
26
the property so obstructing or encroaching, and, if such removal shall not be made within
the time ordered, impose penalties for each and every day that such obstruction or
encroachment is allowed to continue thereafter; authorize encroachments upon streets,
alleys, sidewalks or other public places, subject to such terms and conditions as the
council may prescribe, but such authorization shall not relieve the owner or owners,
occupant or occupants of the property encroaching, of any liability for negligence on
account of such encroachment; and recover possession of any street, alley, sidewalk or
other public place or any other property of the city by suit or action in ejectment.
Purpose of Change: Virginia general law authorizes the City “to deal with encroachments in
public rights of way” (Virginia Code 15.2-2009, 15.2-2010, and 15.2-2011). 21
5-11. Strike
(f) To prescribe the route and grade of any railroad laid in the city, regulate the operation
of locomotives and cars, and exclude such locomotives and cars from the city; provided,
no contract between the city and the corporation operating such locomotives or cars is
violated by such action.
Purpose of Change: Railroad operations are shielded from interference by local law or
regulations by federal law, including 49 U.S.C. 10501(b)(1) and the Interstate Commerce
Commission Termination Act of 1995. Any authority the City carries with respect to railroad
operations come from general regulatory powers such as the Uniform Statewide Building Code
and the Uniform Statewide Fire Code.
5-12. Strike
(g) To regulate the operation of motor vehicles and exercise control over traffic in the
streets of the city and provide penalties for the violation of such regulations; provided,
that ordinances or administrative regulations adopted by virtue of this subsection shall not
be inconsistent with the provisions of the Motor Vehicle Code of Virginia. All fines
imposed for the violation of such ordinances and regulations shall be paid into the city
treasury.
Purpose of Change: Virginia general law provides for the City’s authority to “manage the
operation of motor vehicles and exercise traffic control” (Virginia Code 13.46.2-1300 through
46.2-1314).22
5-13. Strike
(h) To regulate, in the interest of public health, the production, preparation, distribution,
sale and possession of milk, other beverages and foods for human consumption, and the
places in which they are produced, prepared, distributed, sold, served or stored; regulate
the construction, installation, maintenance and condition of all water and sewer pipes,
21 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 4.
22 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 4.
27
connections, toilets, water closets and plumbing fixtures of all kinds; regulate the
construction and use of septic tanks and dry closets, where sewers are not available, and
the sanitation of swimming pools and lakes; provide for the removal of night soil, and
charge and collect compensation for the removal thereof; compel the use of sewers, the
connection of abutting premises therewith, and the installation in such premises of
suitable sanitary facilities; regulate or prohibit connections to and use of sewers; provide
for the quarantine of any person afflicted with a contagious or infectious disease, and for
the removal of such person to a hospital or ward specially designated for contagious or
infectious diseases; inspect and prescribe reasonable rules and regulations, in the interest
of public health, with respect to private hospitals, sanatoria, convalescent homes, clinics
and other private institutions, homes and facilities for the care of the sick, of children, the
aged and the destitute; and make and enforce all regulations necessary to preserve and
promote public health and sanitation and protect the inhabitants of the city from
contagious, infectious or other diseases.
Purpose of Change: The powers in this section are either authorized by Virginia general law,
such as Virginia Code 15.2-1109 (regulation of milk and food products) and Virginia Code 15.2-
1110 (regulation of swimming pools and bodies of water); or are assigned by law to the Virginia
Department of Health (such as quarantine of persons with contagious disease) or are provided by
the Uniform Statewide Building Code (plumbing fixtures and toilets).
5-14. Strike
(i) To regulate cemeteries and burials therein, prescribe the records to be kept by
the owners of such cemeteries, and prohibit all burials except in a public
burying ground.
Purpose of Change: The City’s power to regulate cemeteries and burials is established by
Virginia Code 15.2-1111.
5-15. Strike
(j) To regulate or prohibit the exercise of any dangerous, offensive or unhealthful
business, trade or employment, and the transportation of any offensive or dangerous
substance.
Purpose of Change: These powers are provided by Virginia general law. The City’s powers to
regulate or prohibit dangerous, offensive or unhealthful business operations, and the
transportation of offensive or dangerous substances, are established by Virginia Code 15.2-1113.
5-16. Strike
(k) To regulate the light, ventilation, sanitation and use of occupancy of buildings
heretofore or hereafter constructed, altered, remodeled or improved, and the sanitation of
the premises surrounding the same.
Purpose of Change: The Uniform Statewide Building Code establishes the authority of local
government to regulate the construction, maintenance and repair of buildings and structures.
28
5-17. Strike
(l) To regulate the emission of smoke or the construction, installation, operation and
maintenance of fuel burning equipment, internal combustion engines or any other
equipment or source of air pollution.
Purpose of Change: Virginia Code 15.2-1116 authorizes the City to regulate smoke and fuel-
burning equipment; “Chapter 13 of Title 10.1 of the Virginia Code gives the Virginia Pollution
Control Board authority to control and regulate air pollution statewide.”23
5-18. Strike
(m) To compel the removal of weeds from private and public property and snow from
sidewalks; the covering or removal of offensive, unwholesome, unsanitary or unhealthy
substances allowed to accumulate in or on any place or premises; the filling in to the
street level of the portion of any lot adjacent to a street where the difference in level
between the lot and the street constitutes a danger to life and limb; the raising or draining
of grounds subject to be covered by stagnant water; the razing or repair of all unsafe,
dangerous or unsanitary public or private buildings, walls or structures which constitute a
menace to the health and safety of the occupants thereof or the public; and to compel the
abatement or removal of any and all other nuisances whatsoever including the removal of
inoperative or unlicensed motor vehicles or parts thereof from public or private property.
If after such reasonable notice as the council may prescribe by ordinance the owner or
owners, occupant or occupants of the property or premises affected by the provisions of
this subsection shall fail to abate or obviate the condition or nuisance, the city may do so
and charge and collect the cost thereof from the owner or owners, occupant or occupants
of the property affected in any manner provided by law for the collection of taxes.
Purpose of Change: Virginia general law via Virginia Code 15.2-900, 15.2-906, and 15.2-1115
“give a city broad authority to address nuisances.”24
5-19. Strike
(n) To regulate or prohibit the manufacture, storage, transportation, possession and use of
explosive or inflammable substances and the use and exhibition of fireworks and
discharge of firearms.
Purpose of Change: The Uniform Statewide Fire Code regulates the use of explosive or
inflammable substances and the use of firework; additionally, Virginia Code 15.2-1113 gives the
City authority to regulate explosive and flammable substances and the discharge of fireworks.
Virginia Code 15.2-915 provides and defines the limits of the City’s authority to regulate
firearms.
23 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 5.
24 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 5.
29
5-20. Strike
(o) To regulate or prohibit the making of fires in the streets, alleys and other public places
in the city and to regulate the making of fires on private property.
Purpose of Change: “15.2-1800(E) of the Virginia Code authorizes the City to maintain, and
regulate the use of its real property and the Virginia Uniform Statewide Fire Code regulates the
making of fires.”25
5-21. Strike
(p) To regulate or prohibit the running at large and the keeping of animals and fowl and
provide for the impounding and confiscation of any such animal or fowl found at large or
kept in violation of such regulations.
Purpose of Change: “15.2-1108 of the Virginia Code authorizes a city to regulate the running at
large and the keeping of animals and fowl.”26
5-22. Strike
(q) To prevent cruelty to and abuse of animals.
Purpose of Change: This power is provided to the city by Virginia general law: “The Virginia
Comprehensive Animal Care Act gives a city the authority to deal with animal cruelty and
abuse.”27
5-23. Strike
(r) To regulate the sale of goods, wares or merchandise at auction; regulate the conduct of
and prescribe the number of pawnshops and dealers in secondhand goods, wares and
merchandise; regulate or prohibit the peddling or hawking of any article for sale on the
streets of the city; prevent fraud or deceit in the sale of goods, wares and merchandise;
require the weighing, measuring, gauging and inspection of goods, wares and
merchandise offered for sale; require weights and measures to be sealed and subject to
inspection; and provide for the appointment of a sealer and one or more weightmasters
who shall perform such duties and functions as may be prescribed by ordinance. (1948, c.
116; 1968, c. 644; 1972, c. 336; 1975, c. 112)
Purpose of Change: These various powers are provided to cities or assigned to statewide
jurisdiction by Virginia general law. “For example: 15.2-1114 of the Virginia Code authorizes a
city to regulate, auctions, pawnshops, secondhand dealers, peddling, fraud, and deceit in sales,
25 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 5.
26 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 5.
27 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 6.
30
and weights and measures; 54.1-4001 and 54.1-4003 impose regulations on pawnshops; 15.2-913
authorizes localities to adopt ordinances that regulate door to door solicitation; 59.1-201
authorizes a locality to deal with consumer protection complaint; the Virginia Department of
Agriculture and Consumer Services has a Weights and Measures Bureau to oversee weights and
measurements throughout the state; etc.” 28
2.05. Miscellaneous Powers
5-24. Strike
(b) To establish, maintain and operate, within and without the city, public hospitals,
sanatoria, convalescent homes, clinics and other public institutions, homes and facilities
for the care of the sick, of children, the aged and the destitute.
Purpose of Change: These powers are provided by general law under Virginia Code 15.2-1119.
5-25. Strike
(c) To provide care for the poor and have all the powers and duties conferred and
imposed on cities by the laws of the Commonwealth relating to public assistance.
Purpose of Change: The ability of a city to provide assistance to the poor is authorized and
defined by Article 2 of Title 63.2 of the Virginia Code.
5-26. Strike
(d) To establish, own, maintain and operate, within and without the city, cemeteries for
the interment of the dead, fix the price at which graves and lots therein shall be sold,
make contracts for their perpetual care and establish the rates to be charged for the
digging of graves, construction of vaults and other services.
Purpose of Change: Power to establish and operate cemeteries is provided by Virginia Code
15.2-1121.
5-27. Strike
(g) To establish and collect such fees, including a charge for expenses incurred in
auditing reports, accounts, and any records of organizations operating bingo games and
raffles under the permissive provisions of § 18.2-335 of the Code of Virginia and
admitting to record the annual report of such organization, as may be determined by the
council to be reasonable for the rendering of special services.
28 Walter Erwin Memorandum, pp. 5-6.
31
Purpose of Change: “As a result of amendments to the Virginia code, bingo games and raffles
are no longer regulated by local governments, but are regulated by the Virginia Charitable
Gaming Commission.”29
2.06. Enforcement of Regulations
5-28. Strike 2.06 in its entirety:
§ 2.06. Enforcement of regulations.
When by the provisions of this charter or the Constitution and general laws of the
Commonwealth the city is authorized to pass ordinances on any subject, the council may
provide suitable penalties for the violation of any such ordinances, including ordinances
effective outside the city as provided in this charter. No such penalty shall exceed the
maximum fine permitted under state law for violation of a Class 1 misdemeanor or
confinement for twelve months or both. Upon conviction for violation of any ordinance,
the court trying the case may require bond of the person so convicted with proper security
in the penalty of not more than $2,000, conditioned to keep the peace and be of good
behavior and especially for the period of not more than one year not to violate the
ordinance for the breach of which he/she has been convicted. From any fine or
confinement imposed, an appeal shall lie as in cases of misdemeanor. Whenever any fine
or penalty shall be imposed but not paid, the court trying the case may, unless an appeal
be forthwith taken, issue a writ of fieri facias for the collection of the amount due,
returnable within sixty days from its issuance. The city is hereby expressly authorized
and empowered to institute and maintain a suit or suits to restrain by injunction the
violation of any ordinance legally adopted by it, notwithstanding such ordinance may
provide penalties for its violation.
Purpose of Change: “The provisions of 2.06 dealing with the establishment of penalties for
violations of ordinances, requiring bonds of persons convicted of ordinances, appeals of
convictions, and seeking injunctions are covered in 15.2-1429, 15.2-1430, 15.2-1431, and 15.2-
1432 of the Virginia Code.” 30
3.04.1. Removal of council member or mayor and forfeiture of office
5-29. Amended language
C. The mayor or any member of council who shall be convicted by a final judgment of
any court from which no appeal has been taken or which has been affirmed by a court of
last resort on a charge involving moral turpitude, or of any felony, or any misdemeanor
29 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 6.
30 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 6.
32
involving possession of marijuana or any controlled substances, shall forfeit his/her
office.
Purpose of change: Consistent with the statewide decriminalization of marijuana, remove
misdemeanor possession of marijuana or other controlled substances as a cause for removal from
office of the Mayor and Council, as well as strike archaic, ambiguous, and unneeded language
regarding “moral turpitude.”
4.06 Rules (of Council)
5-30. Amend:
The council shall have power, subject to the provisions of this charter, to adopt its own
rules of procedure. Such rules shall provide for the time and place of holding regular
meetings of the council which shall be not less frequently than once in each month;
however, the council shall not be required to hold a regular meeting in the month of
August. They shall also provide for the calling of special meetings by the mayor or any
three members of the council, and shall prescribe the method of giving notice thereof,
provided that the notice of each special meeting shall contain a statement of the specific
item or items of business to be transacted and no other business shall be transacted at
such meeting except by the unanimous consent of all the members of the
council. Council must follow Robert’s Rules or another generally accepted order of
parliamentary procedure agreed to by the council; such procedure may be set aside
temporarily in specific instances by unanimous consent of council.
Purpose of Change: Assure Council consistently follows recognizable procedures and rules of
order in its meetings.
4.07. Voting (by Council)
5-31. Amended Language
No ordinance, resolution, motion or vote shall be adopted by the council except at a
meeting open to the public and, except motions to adjourn, to fix the time and place of
adjournment, and other motions of a purely procedural nature, unless it shall have
received the affirmative votes of at least five members. All voting except on procedural
motions shall be by roll call or by electronic devices and the ayes and noes shall be
recorded in the journal.
Purpose of change: Provide Council the option to change to electronic voting in its meetings.
4.09. Ordinances; form
5-32. Amended language
Every ordinance except the annual appropriation ordinances and an ordinance codifying
ordinances shall be confined to a single subject which shall be clearly expressed in its
33
title. All introduced ordinances will be made available by electronic means, with one
or more printed copies provided to the city clerk for public inspection. All
ordinances shall be introduced in typewritten or printed form or a combination of both.
All ordinances which repeal or amend existing ordinances shall set forth in full the
section or subsection to be repealed or amended and, if it is to be amended, shall indicate
matter to be omitted by enclosing the same in brackets, striking through the matter to be
omitted, or by both such brackets and striking through and indicating new matter by
underscoring. When printed or published prior to enactment the same indications of
omitted and new matter shall be used except that strikeout type may be substituted for
brackets and italics for underscoring. The enacting clause of all ordinances shall be: "The
City of Richmond hereby ordains." Unless another date is specified therein and except as
otherwise provided in this charter an ordinance shall take effect on the tenth day
following its passage.
Purpose of Change: Assure introduced ordinances are available electronically while reducing
the need for multiple hard-copy print outs of documents, a requirement that is costly, time-
consuming, and paper-consuming; while assuring at least one print copy is available on record at
all times (as good practice and in event of network or system failure).
4.14. Appointments and removals generally
5-33. Added Section
4.14.1. Composition of boards and commissions established by ordinance
The council by ordinance will establish the composition, duties, and other relevant
provisions of each board and commission reporting to the council, except for boards
and commissions whose composition is established by the charter.
Purpose of Change: To codify existing practice.
4.15. Removal of members of boards and commissions; forfeiture of
office or employment for certain convictions
5-34. Strike and Add
B. Any officer, appointee of the council or employee of the city who shall be convicted
by a final judgment of any court from which no appeal has been taken or which has been
affirmed by a court of last resort on a charge involving moral turpitude or any felony or
any misdemeanor involving possession of marijuana or any controlled substances shall
forfeit his/her office or employment.
The council, in consultation with the chief administrative officer, must establish by
ordinance, consistent with general law, provisions for the sanction or removal of
officers, appointees and employees of the city for cause.
34
Purpose of Change: Provided the Council establish an ordinance for this purpose, the specific
language regarding removal from office or employment need not be in the Charter. Sanction and
removal of employees should be a function of the city’s personnel policies and adopted
ordinances, not the Charter. In contrast, it is appropriate that the Charter have language of this
kind with respect to the Mayor and Council (as in 3.04.1).
4.16. Powers of investigation
5-35. Amend
(a) The council, or any committee of members of the council when authorized by the
council, shall have power to make such investigations relating to the municipal affairs of
the city as it may deem necessary, and shall have power to investigate any or all
departments, boards, commissions, offices and agencies of the city government and any
officer or employee of the city, concerning the performance of their duties and functions
and use of property of the city. The council will have all investigative powers provided
by general law in addition to those stated in the charter.
Purpose of Change: Clarify the Council has all investigatory powers available to governing
bodies in Virginia, in addition to those enumerated in the Charter.
5A.03. Personnel rules and regulations
5-36. Amend
The council, upon receiving any recommendations submitted to it by the mayor chief
administrative officer, and subject to such conditions as may be set out elsewhere in
the charter, shall establish a personnel system for the city administrative officials and
employees. Such system shall be based on merit and professional ability and shall not
discriminate on the basis of race, including traits historically associated with race,
including hair texture, hair type, and protective hairstyles such as braids, locks, and
twists; color; religion; sex; age; pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical
conditions, including lactation; sexual orientation; gender identity; national origin;
citizenship status; disability; genetic information; marital status; veteran status;
military status; political affiliation; or membership in any other protected group.
race, national origin, religion, sex, age, disabilities, political affiliation, sexual
orientation, gender identity, military status, childbirth and pregnancy status, or
marital status. The personnel system shall consist of rules and regulations which provide
for the general administration of personnel matters to include a director of human
resources who must support the council and the chief administrative officer in
fulfilling their respective duties under the charter and perform other duties as
assigned by ordinance to the director of human resources; a classification plan for
employees; a uniform pay plan; and a procedure for resolving grievances of employees
as provided by general law for either local government or state government employees;
and a uniform severance plan for the compensation of employees who are separated
from city service for reasons other than cause.
35
Purpose of Change: This amendment has two purposes: 1) update Charter language on
protected classes to be current with Virginia general law, federal law, and current City personnel
policies. 2) clarify that the chief administrative officer recommends the personnel system, that
the personnel system is to continue a uniform severance plan, and that there is to be a director of
human resources. This amendment is identical to 5-43-D below, and is listed in both places to
stress the importance of moving forward with amending the list of protected classes.
5B. Retirement system
5-37. Amend
From and after July 1, 1978, the Board of Trustees of the Richmond Retirement System
shall consist of seven members for terms of three years. Any vacancy shall be filled for
the unexpired portion of the term. The mayor shall appoint two members; the council
shall appoint five members, at least two of whom shall be members of the classified
service employees or retirees who are participants in the retirement system.
Purpose of Change: To give both unclassified and classified employees and retirees the
opportunity to serve on the Board of Trustees.
6.15.3. School buildings and infrastructure modernization
5-38. Strike 6.15.3 in its entirety
(a) Not later than January 1, 2019, the mayor shall formally present to the city council a
fully funded plan to modernize the city's K-12 educational infrastructure consistent with
national standards or inform city council such a plan is not feasible. In fulfilling the
duties herein, the mayor shall consult with the school board and city council, consider
cost savings available in state or federal law, and further provide an opportunity for
public participation.
(b) Such fully funded plan required in subsection (a) shall not be based on the passage of
new or increased taxes for that purpose.
(c) Nothing herein shall alter powers previously given to the school board.
(d) Once the mayor has complied with subsection (a), the city council shall have 90 days
to take such action as it deems appropriate. (2018, c. 664)
Purpose of Change: Relevant provisions have expired.
13.06. Each utility a separate enterprise
5-39. Strike
36
The water, wastewater, stormwater, gas and electric utilities shall each be conducted as a
separate enterprise, provided that nothing herein shall prevent the transfer of employees
from one utility to another or the division of the time of any officer or employee between
two or more of such utilities. To facilitate accurate analysis of the financial results of the
operation of each utility:
(a) The customer service division shall, as directed by ordinance, bill for and collect on
behalf of each utility not only the charges due from domestic, commercial and industrial
users of its services but similar charges against the city and each department, board,
commission, office and agency thereof, including the school board and each other utility.
The rates to be charged for street lighting and for electric current furnished to the city and
its departments, boards, commissions, offices and agencies, as well as any political
subdivision, shall be fixed by the director of public utilities to generate such revenue as
shall enable the utility to make a reasonable return on investment and meet retirement
schedules and other debt service requirements in accordance with the provisions of any
bond ordinance pursuant to which bonds have been issued to finance capital
improvements of such utility and to comply with the terms and conditions of any
documents securing any such bonds.
(b) Separate budgets shall be prepared for each utility annually at the time and in the
manner prescribed in Chapter 6 of this charter, which shall include estimates of revenue
and expense for the ensuing fiscal year. After the budget of a utility has been adopted,
should it appear that substantial sales of the unit product of the utility can be made in
excess of the sales of the unit product contemplated by the budget which were not
reasonably foreseen at the time the estimates of revenue and expense were made,
additional expenditures may be authorized by the chief administrative officer from the
funds of the utility in an amount not exceeding the estimated cost of producing or
purchasing additional units of the product of the utility to be sold upon the justification of
such expenditure by and recommendation of the director of public utilities. The chief
administrative officer shall report to the council as soon as practicable any such
additional expenditures authorized by him/her and shall also report any such additional
expenditures to the director of finance, who shall adjust the appropriation accounts
accordingly. The expenditure of any other funds of any utility shall be authorized only
when an additional appropriation thereof is made in accordance with § 6.16 of this
charter. The budget estimates of each department of the city shall include items for gas,
water, wastewater, stormwater, and electric current to be used by them. An item for street
lighting shall be included in the general fund budget and shall be disbursed by the
director of finance on the basis of bills rendered by the customer service division.
(c) The accounting system of each utility shall conform to generally accepted principles
of public utility accounting and shall be kept on an accrual basis. Expenditures shall be
authorized and made in accordance with appropriations made by the council and in
accordance with the provisions of Chapters 6, 8 and 13 of this charter. The records of
revenues of each utility shall be kept so that the services rendered to each class of
37
customer according to the rate schedules adopted by the council for each utility can be
obtained. After the close of each fiscal year there shall be submitted to the chief
administrative officer and the council a report as to the operation of each utility
containing at least the following financial statements: (1) a comparative balance sheet
showing the financial condition of the utility as of the beginning and close of the fiscal
year and an analysis of the surplus account showing the factors of change in the account
as reflected by the comparative balance sheet; and (2) a comparative profit and loss
statement of the last two fiscal years; and a comparative detailed analysis of operating
expense for the last two fiscal years according to functional grouping. The expense of
operating each utility shall include: (1) taxes, if any, lawfully accruing during the fiscal
year; and (2) except for the stormwater utility, taxes not actually accruing but which
would have accrued had the utility not been municipally owned, and such taxes shall be
paid annually into the general fund. For the purposes of this chapter, all indebtedness of
the city incurred on account of each utility shall be considered as the indebtedness of
such utility. (1948, c. 116; 1954, c. 64; 1982, c. 658; 1988, c. 269; 1993, c. 613; 1994,
c. 215; 1998, c. 711; 2006, cc. 650, 712)
Purpose of Change: The City administration recommended removal of both sections 6.13
(utilities budgets) and 13.06. There was not consensus among the Commission regarding 6.13,
out of concern for assuring transparency with respect to utilities budgets, hence no
recommendation is made with respect to that section. The Commission agreed that most of 13.06
can be struck and its provisions provided for by ordinance as needed, but recommends retaining
language that the utilities are to be separate enterprises.
20.10. Courtrooms for courts of record and office space for constitutional officers
5-40. Strike
It shall be the duty of the city to provide suitable courtrooms for the courts of record of
the city and suitable offices for the city treasurer and attorney for the Commonwealth.
Purpose of Change: “15.2-1638 of the Virginia Code requires a locality to provide courthouses
and facilities to accommodate the various courts and officials and 15.2-1600 to 15.2-1637
require localities to provide facilities and benefits for constitutional officers.”31
20.11. Posting of bonds by city unnecessary
5-41. Strike
31 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 13.
38
Whenever the general law requires the posting of a bond, with or without surety, as a
condition precedent to the exercise of any right, the city, without giving such bond, may
exercise such right, provided all other conditions precedent are complied with, and no
officer shall fail or refuse to act because the city has not filed or executed the bond that
might otherwise be required, and the city shall be bound to the same extent that it would
have been bound had the bond been given. This exemption from the requirement of
posting a bond shall also apply in cases involving a city employee to whom liability
coverage has been granted by the city.
Purpose of Change: “15.2-1126 of the Virginia Code provides that a municipal corporation
does not have to post a bond as a condition precedent to the exercise of its rights.”32
32 Walter Erwin Memorandum, pp. 13-14.
39
Special Section, I. Adjustments to Provisions Concerning Creation of Departments,
Personnel
Items 5-42 and 5-43 are both multi-part adjustments intended to make Charter provisions
regarding the creation or alteration of agencies and the establishment of the personnel system
more consistent with the Mayor-Council form of government, while retaining for Council a role
in a) creating or altering agencies that are not established by Charter and do not report to the
Chief Administrative Officer b) having the option to develop its own job classifications for
employees reporting to the Council (or to use the classifications developed by the Chief
Administrative Officer) and c) establishing pay ranges for heads of administrative departments.
5-42 concerns the creation of departments and 5-43 concerns the personnel system.
The recommended amendments clearly establish that departments reporting to the Chief
Administrative Officer are only to be created, altered, or abolished at the initiative of Mayor,
while retaining Council’s role in approving such initiatives; and that the Chief Administrative
Officer is to develop the job classification system for employees in agencies reporting to the
CAO, while retaining Council’s role in approving the salary ranges for agency heads.
The Commission views the recommendations of 5-42 and 5-43 as consistent with the
Partnership Model of Mayor-Council government detailed in Chapter Six.
5-42-A. Amended Language
4.02. Powers (of Council)
(b) To create, alter, combine or abolish departments, bureaus, divisions, boards,
commissions, offices and agencies other than 1) those specifically established by this
charter and 2) those reporting to the chief administrative officer; and to approve
changes to bureaus, departments divisions, boards, commissions, office, and
agencies reporting to the chief administrative officer upon the recommendation of
the mayor.
Purpose of Changes: Under the Mayor-Council form of government, Council should not be
able to alter the structure of agencies that report to the CAO except on the initiative of the
Mayor. It should have the power to approve or reject changes proposed by the Mayor.
Also, the word “combine” is added to allow the removal of section 5A.01 (see 5-42-C
below).
5-42-B. Amended Language
(c) To create, alter or abolish and to assign and reassign to departments, all bureaus,
divisions, offices and agencies, assign and reassign employees to departments,
bureaus, divisions, offices or agencies other than those that are 1) specifically assigned
by this charter; or 2) report to the chief administrative officer.
Purpose of Change: Under the Mayor-Council form of government, Council should not be
able to assign or reassign employees within agencies that report to the CAO. This change to
4.02(c) also removes language duplicating 4.02(b).
40
5-42-C. Amend 5A.01.
5A.01. Creation of departments.
The mayor may propose to establish, alter, combine, or abolish administrative
departments, bureaus, divisions or offices that report to the chief administrative
officer, subject to the approval of council; and the council may establish, alter,
combine, or abolish departments, bureaus, divisions or offices that report to the
council. The city council may establish administrative departments, bureaus, divisions, or
offices, or may alter, combine or abolish existing administrative departments, bureaus,
divisions or offices; however, Neither the council, the mayor, nor the chief administrative
officer shall have the power to alter the purpose of, combine, transfer or abolish any
department created by this charter. (1998, c. 711; 2004, cc. 877, 898)
Purpose of change: State clearly powers to create departments under the Mayor-Council
form of government.
5-43-A. Amend 4.02(d)
4.02. Powers (of Council)
(d) To provide for the titles, qualifications, powers, duties and compensation of all
officers and employees that report to council of the city, subject to certain
conditions: in the case of members of the classified service to the provisions of §
5A.03 of this charter.
1) These titles, qualifications, powers, duties and the compensation plan may
mirror those established by the chief administrative officer for department
heads and executive level employees in whole or in part.
2) No changes to the compensation plan shall be made unless funds are
currently available to fully cover the increased cost of such change, including
employee benefits for both the remainder of the current fiscal year, and the
full annualized cost going forward without the need for an increased
appropriation.
3) If funds are currently unavailable to fully cover the increased cost of such
change, including employee benefits, council shall work with the chief
administrative officer to propose changes to the compensation plan for such
employees, subject to approval of a budget amendment, or amendments to
provided funds therefor.
41
5-43-B. Add paragraph (e) to 4.0233
e. Council in consultation with the chief administrative officer must establish the
compensation of department heads and executive level employees and who report to
the chief administrative officer, by means of establishing:
1) A salary range or ranges for executive level employees;
2) Rules for establishing the maximum salary for newly appointed executives;
3) Rules for movement of such employees through the established ranges;
4) A methodology to be used in calculating the amounts that may be included
in any severance package offered to executive level employees, and any
conditions or restrictions thereon.
5-43-C. Add provision (g)
5.05.1. General duties; chief administrative officer.
g. The chief administrative officer must establish, promulgate and maintain the
titles, qualifications, powers, duties and compensation plan for general and public
safety employees of those departments that report to the chief administrative officer,
subject to certain conditions:
(1) No changes to the compensation plan may be made unless funds are
currently available to fully cover the increased cost of such change, including
employee benefits for both the remainder of the current fiscal year, and the
full annualized cost going forward without the need for an increased
appropriation.
(2) If funds are currently unavailable to fully cover the increased cost of such
change, including employee benefits, the chief administrative officer may
propose changes to the cash compensation plan for such employees subject to
approval of a budget amendment, or amendments to provided funds therefor.
(3) The chief administrative officer will notify council of any significant
revisions.
33 Adoption of this amendment will require re-lettering of current Charter provisions 4.02 (e) and 4.02 (f) to 4.02
(f) and 4.02 (g), respectively.
42
5-43-D. Amend34
5A.03. Personnel rules and regulations
The council, upon receiving any recommendations submitted to it by the mayor chief
administrative officer, and subject to such conditions as may be set out elsewhere in
the charter, shall establish a personnel system for the city administrative officials and
employees. Such system shall be based on merit and professional ability and shall not
discriminate on the basis of race, including traits historically associated with race,
including hair texture, hair type, and protective hairstyles such as braids, locks, and
twists; color; religion; sex; age; pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical
conditions, including lactation; sexual orientation; gender identity; national origin;
citizenship status; disability; genetic information; marital status; veteran status;
military status; political affiliation; or membership in any other protected group.
race, national origin, religion, sex, age, disabilities, political affiliation, sexual
orientation, gender identity, military status, childbirth and pregnancy status, or
marital status. The personnel system shall consist of rules and regulations which provide
for the general administration of personnel matters to include a director of human
resources who must support the council and the chief administrative officer in
fulfilling their respective duties under the charter and perform other duties as
assigned by ordinance to the director of human resources; a classification plan for
employees; a uniform pay plan; and a procedure for resolving grievances of employees
as provided by general law for either local government or state government employees;
and a uniform severance plan for the compensation of employees who are separated
from city service for reasons other than cause.
34 5-43-D, which both expands the list of protected categories and expands the required components of the personnel
plan, duplicates amendment 5-36 above. It is listed here so readers can see the provision in the context of the four
inter-related adjustments to the Charter’s language on personnel; in that context, its primary function is requiring
that a uniform severance plan be part of the personnel system recommended by the c hief administrative officer, and
that there be a director of human resources.
43
Special Section, II. Notes Chapter 17 (Planning, Zoning and Subdivision Control) and
Chapter 18, (Acquisition of Property for Public Purposes).
Both Chapters 17 and 18 of the Charter present special challenges.
Chapter 18 specifies rules regarding eminent domain proceedings “inconsistent with the
provision in Title 25.1 of the Virginia Code and Chapter 19 of Title 15.2 of the Virginia Code.”35
However, 18.03 provides the city with a special “quick take” power which it would be in the
City’s interests to retain, yet could potentially be removed by General Assembly. Hence it may
not be advisable to seek to alter the provisions of Chapter 18 without an assessment of the
likelihood of that taking place. 36 Nonetheless, below we present language recommended by Mr.
Walter Erwin that would effectively bring the Charter into compliance with general law while
preserving the city’s “quick take” power. See recommendations 5-45 and 5-46 below.
Chapter 17 also presents a unique challenge that likely will require more discussion among
stakeholders. Walter Erwin’s memorandum includes nineteen paragraphs discussing the
discrepancies between the Charter provisions and state law and prevailing practice. The
memorandum also notes that “17.01 of the City Charter which authorizes City Council to adopt a
master plan for the City seems to be inconsistent with the provisions of 17.06 which give the
planning commission the authority to adopt the master plan and provides that City Council
approves the plan that was adopted by the planning commission.”37
Many of these discrepancies reflect the fact that the Charter is an older document and that state
law with respect to planning has changed considerably since 1948. It is also worth noting that
advocacy documents and summaries related to the 1948 Charter in advance of its adoption stated
that the Charter did not make substantive changes in existing planning processes; in short, some
of the provisions in Chapter 17 may reflect practice that far predate 1948. Indeed, the Richmond
Charter Commission proceeded by importing various pre-existing ordinances related to planning
into the Charter adopted in 1948. Put another way, in 2023 Richmond’s planning practices are
governed by ordinances adopted in the 1940s or before.38
35 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 13.
36 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 13.
37 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 10.
38 In 1947, the Richmond Chamber of Commerce published a Digest of the Proposed Charter for the City of
Richmond. The document summarizes the provisions of and advocates for the new charter. The document contains
this description regarding “Planning and Zoning Regulations” (p.15): “The structure and operation of the planning
commission and the board of zoning appeals are substantially unchanged. Control is tightened over subdivision
within the metropolitan area. Restrictions are set up against spot zoning. Planning and zoning regulations, now in the
form of separate ordinances, are incorporated as a basic part of the proposed Charter.” See also Report of the
Richmond Charter Commission (p. 91), which notes: “Chapter 17 of the new charter contains provisions for
planning, zoning and subdivision control. These provisions are new in the charter, although in basic structure most
of the zoning and planning provisions are presently contained in city ordinances now in effect. In view of the
44
Mr. Erwin recommends that Chapter 17 of the Charter be replaced with much simpler, more
modern language, while taking care to retain any special provisions of the current Charter that it
may be in the City’s interests to retain.
The commission concurs with this approach. We additionally have received numerous comments
from the public calling for term limits on both the Planning Commission and the Board of
Zoning Appeals.
Hence recommendation 5-44 below outlines draft language for a new Chapter 17, modeled on
the Virginia Beach Charter, but with special provisions for the composition of the Planning
Commission (to reflect the Mayor-Council form of government) and the specifications of term
limits.
We further recommend that the Director of Planning and Development Review, City Attorney,
and City Council, with input of stakeholders, confer to identify any special provisions of the
current language that ought to be retained in the rewritten Chapter 17. Such detailed work is
beyond the scope of expertise of this Commission. We further recognize that this work may
require additional time and that it may be more feasible to bring forward new Charter language
for Chapter 17 to the General Assembly in 2025 rather than 2024; but if it is possible to bring
forward the new language in the 2024 session, it would be beneficial and help assure the changes
are in place prior to the start of the next Mayoral and Council term.
Chapter 17. Planning, Zoning and Subdivision Control
5-44. Strike and Amend
Note: This language is partial and reflects only general clauses that should be in the new
chapter. As stated above, the Director of Planning and Development Review, the City Attorney,
and other stakeholders should carefully deliberate concerning other clauses that should be
added to the revised chapter.
Strike all of existing Chapter 17 and replace with this language.
17.01. Planning commission.
There will be a city planning commission which will consist of nine members. One
member must be a member of the council appointed by the council for a term
coincident with his/her term in the council; one member must be a member of the
board of zoning appeals appointed by the board of zoning appeals for a term
coincident with his/her term on such board; one member must be the chief
administrative officer or an officer or employee of the city designated from time to
time by the chief administrative officer; six citizen members must be qualified
voters of the city who hold no office of profit under the city government, appointed
for terms of three years, one of whom must be appointed by the mayor, and five of
importance of the subject, which is fundamental to the sound future growth and welfare of the ci ty, the Commission
felt that it was desirable to incorporate the planning, zoning and subdivision control provisions in the charter itself.”
45
whom must be appointed by the council. Vacancies must be filled by the authority
making the appointment, for the unexpired portion of the term. Members of the city
planning commission, other than the member of council appointed to the
commission and the chief administrative officer, or such officer or employee of the
city as the chief administrative officer may designate to serve on the commission,
will be entitled to receive such compensation as may be fixed from time to time by
ordinance adopted by the council. Apart from the member of council and the chief
administrative officer or their designated employee, no member may serve more
than two terms consecutively.
Note: This language does not alter the current composition of the Planning Commission, except
for the establishment of term limits.
17.02. Functions of planning commission.
The planning commission will be responsible for making recommendations to the
council on all phases of city planning, including a master plan, zoning and
subdivision control. It will have the powers and duties provided by general law and
such other powers and duties as may be assigned by the council.
17.03. Board of zoning appeals.
There will be a board of zoning appeals which will consist of five members
appointed for three-year terms by the circuit court of the city or the judges thereof
in vacation. No member may serve more than two terms consecutively.
17.04. Powers of the board of zoning appeals.
The board of zoning appeals will have all powers granted to boards of zoning
appeals by general law.
17.05. Appeals from actions of the board of zoning appeals.
Appeals from any action of the board of zoning appeals may be taken to the circuit
court of the city in the manner prescribed by general law.
Plus: any additional specific clauses or powers from the current Charter that may be deemed
advisable by Council to retain, on the recommendation of the Director of Planning and
Development Review, City Attorney, and other stakeholders. (See above).
Note: one substantive effect of the new language proposed here worth emphasizing is that the
City Council would, unlike current practice, have full authority over the master plan, with the
46
planning commission defined as an advisory body. This arrangement is the norm in other
localities in Virginia.39
18.02. Eminent domain
5-45. Strike and Amend
The city is hereby authorized to acquire by condemnation proceedings lands, buildings,
structures and personal property or any interest, right, easement or estate therein, of any
person or corporation, whenever in the opinion of the council a public necessity exists
therefor, which shall be expressed in the resolution or ordinance directing such
acquisition, whether or not any corporation owning the same be authorized to exercise the
power of eminent domain or whether or not such lands, buildings, structures or personal
property or interest, right, easement or estate has already been devoted to a public use,
and whenever the city cannot agree on terms of purchase or settlement with the owners of
the subject of such acquisition because of incapacity of such owner, or because of the
inability to agree on the compensation to be paid or other terms of settlement or purchase,
or because the owner or some one of the owners is a nonresident of the Commonwealth
and cannot with reasonable diligence be found in the Commonwealth or is unknown.
In the exercise of its eminent domain authority, the city has all the applicable
powers and will follow all the applicable procedures and requirements set forth in
Title 25.1, 15.2-1901 through 15.2-1907. l. and S 1-219.1 of the Code of Virginia,
which eminent domain powers are hereby conferred on and vested in the city. In
addition thereto, the city has and may exercise all other eminent domain powers
which are now or may hereafter be conferred upon or delegated to cities under the
Constitution or laws of the Commonwealth, as fully and completely as though such
powers were specifically enumerated in this charter and no enumerations of powers
in this charter will be held to be exclusive but will be held to be in addition to this
general grant of powers.
Such proceedings may be instituted in the Circuit Court of the City of Richmond,
Divisions I or II, if the subject to be acquired is located within the city, or, if it is not
located within the city, in the circuit court of the county in which it is located. If the
subject is situated partly within the city and partly within any county the circuit court of
such county shall have concurrent jurisdiction in such condemnation proceedings with
the circuit court of the city. The judge or the court exercising such concurrent jurisdiction
shall appoint five disinterested freeholders any or all of whom reside either in the county
39 Walter Erwin Memorandum, p. 10.
47
or city, any three of whom may act as commissioners, as provided by law. (1948, c. 116;
1975, c. 112)
18.03. Alternative procedures in condemnation
5-46. Strike and Amend
The city may, in exercising the right of eminent domain conferred by the preceding
section, make use of the procedure prescribed by the general law as modified by said
section or may elect to proceed as hereinafter provided. In the latter event the resolution
or ordinance directing acquisition of any property, as set forth in the preceding section,
shall provide therein in a lump sum the total funds necessary to compensate the owner or
owners thereof for such property to be acquired or damaged. Upon the adoption of such
resolution or ordinance the city may file a petition in the clerk's office of a court
enumerated in the preceding section, having jurisdiction of the subject, which shall be
signed by the city manager or the city attorney and set forth the interest or estate or estate
to be taken in the property and the uses and purposes for which the property or the
interest or estate therein is wanted, or when property is not to be taken but is likely to be
damaged, the necessity for the work or improvement which will cause or is likely to
cause such damage. There shall also be filed with the petition a plat of a survey of the
property with a profile, if pertinent to the question of damage to remaining property of
the owner or owners, showing cuts and fills, trestles and bridges, if any, and a description
of the property which, or an interest or estate in which, is sought to be taken or likely to
be damaged and a memorandum showing names and residences of the owners and
tenants of the property, if known, and showing also the quantity of property which, or an
interest or estate in which, is sought to be taken or which will be or is likely to be
damaged. There shall be filed also with said petition a notice directed to the owners and
tenants of the property, if known, copies of which shall be served on such owners and
tenants of the freehold of such property, if known. If the owner or tenant of the freehold
be unknown or a nonresident of the Commonwealth or cannot with reasonable diligence
be found in the Commonwealth, or if the residence of the owner or tenant be unknown,
he may be proceeded against by order of publication which order, however, need not be
published more than once a week for two successive weeks and shall be posted at a main
entrance to the courthouse. The publication shall in all other respects conform to §§ 8.01-
316, 8.01-317 and 8.01-319 of the requirements of the Code of Virginia, as amended.
Upon the filing of said petition and the deposit of the funds provided by the council for
the purpose in a bank to the credit of the court in such proceedings and the filing of a
certificate of deposit therefor the interest or estate of the owner of such property shall
terminate and the title to such property or the interest or estate to be taken in such
property shall be vested absolutely in the city and such owner shall have such interest or
estate in the funds so deposited as he had in the property taken or damaged and all liens
by deed of trust, judgment or otherwise upon said property or estate shall be transferred
to such funds and the city shall have the right to enter upon and take possession of such
property for its uses and purposes and to construct its works or improvements. The clerk
48
of the court in which such proceeding is instituted shall make and certify a copy of the
petition, exhibits filed therewith, and orders, and deliver or transmit the same to the clerk
of the court in which deeds are admitted to record, who shall record the same in his deed
book and index them in the name of the person or persons who had the property' before
and in the name of the city for which he shall receive the same fees prescribed for
recording a deed, which shall be paid by the city. From the funds so paid into court or to
the clerk thereof, the court shall, at the request of the owner, pay any indebtedness of the
owner which is a lien upon such property and is evidenced by a deed of trust or other
instrument duly recorded; provided, that not in excess of ninety per centum of the money
paid into court or to the clerk may be so used, and provided further, that if the award of
the court in condemnation proceedings be less than the amount so paid, the city may
recover the excess from any person to whom the same has been paid. The balance of such
money shall be held by the court for disposition in accordance with the order of the court
in the condemnation proceedings.
If the city and the owner of property so taken or damaged agree upon compensation
therefor, upon filing such agreement in writing in the clerk's office of such court the court
or judge thereof in vacation shall make such distribution of such funds as to it may seem
right, having due regard to the interest of all persons therein whether such interest be
vested, contingent or otherwise, and to enable the court or judge to make a proper
distribution of such money it may in its discretion direct inquiries to be taken by a special
commissioner in order to ascertain what persons are entitled to such funds and in what
proportions and may direct what notice shall be given of the making of such inquiries by
such special commissioner.
If the city and the owner cannot agree upon the compensation for the property
taken or damaged, if any, proceedings will continue in accordance with general law.
If the city and the owner cannot agree upon the compensation for the property taken or
damaged, if any, upon the filing of a memorandum in the clerk's office of said court to
that effect, signed by either the city or the owner, the court shall appoint commissioners
provided for in §§ 25.1-220 and 25.1-226 through 25.1-230 of the Code of Virginia or as
provided for in § 18.02, and all proceedings thereafter shall be had as provided in Chapter
2 (§ 25.1-200 et seq.) of Title 25.1 of the Code of Virginia insofar as they are then
applicable and are not inconsistent with the provisions of this and the preceding section,
and the court shall order the deposit in bank to the credit of the court of such additional
funds as appear to be necessary to cover the award of the commissioners or shall order
the return to the city of such funds deposited that are not necessary to compensate such
owners for property taken or damaged. The commissioners so appointed shall not
consider improvements placed upon the property by the city subsequent to its taking nor
the value thereof nor the enhancement of the value of said property by said improvements
in making their award. (1948, c. 116; 1968, c. 644; 1998, c. 711; 2004, cc. 877, 898)
49
Purpose of Change: Bring the City’s processes with respect to Eminent Domain in congruence
with state law while preserving the City’s existing powers in this area. 40
40 This language reflects the recommendation of Mr. Walter Erwin on this matter, in a memorandum sent to the
Commission on July 19, 2023.
50
Special Section, III: Recommendation on Gender-Inclusive Language
In section 4.17 (City Attorney), the Commission provisionally recommends replacing Charter
language utilizing masculine pronouns (“he” and “his”) with “he/she” and “his/her” in
accordance with common practice, including elsewhere in the Charter (see recommendation 6-2).
This is a step forward insofar as it removes from the Charter the archaic assumption that holders
of key offices and positions in the City are men.
However, it is the Commission’s overarching recommendation that all gendered language (“he”
or “he/she”) in the Charter be replaced with gender-inclusive terminology (i.e.
“they/them/their.”) This recommendation is consistent with current best practice, and also
recognizes the diversity of gender identities present in our city and our society.
Existing Charter provisions with gendered language include 2.06, 3.06.1, 4.04, 4.15a, 4.17,
5.01.1, 5.07, 6.03, 6.07, 6.13, 6.14, 6.19, 8.03, 17.02, 18.03, 18.05, and possibly others. The
Commission recommends that “he/she” be replaced with “they” or “them”; or alternatively be
reworded such as not to require the use of pronouns, in each of those instances. This can be
accomplished by the City Attorney’s office in preparation of Council’s resolution requesting
amendments to the Charter.
5-47. Replace gendered language with inclusive gender-neutral language throughout the
Charter document, including in 2.06, 3.06.1, 4.04, 4.15a, 4.17, 5.01.1, 5.07, 6.03, 6.07, 6.13,
6.14, 6.19, 8.03, 17.02, 18.03, 18.05, and elsewhere as needed.
Final Notes for Chapter Five
We close this chapter with two important notes.
First, with respect to those Charter provisions that are recommended for deletion because they
duplicate general law, it is not the Commission’s intention that these deletions impact the
practice of City agencies. We strongly recommend that the administration share these
recommended changes with heads of administrative departments, as well as their associated staff
attorneys in the City Attorney’s office, to confirm that the removal of these paragraphs have no
implications for practice: that is, that the removal of the paragraphs would not affect the ability
of agencies to perform work authorized under current Charter language.
Second, should most or all of the recommendations of this chapter ultimately be implemented by
the General Assembly, we strongly recommend that the City Attorney’s office work closely with
agency directors, deputy directors, and others who may be habituated to looking to the language
of the Charter to understand the scope of their authority, to direct them instead to the relevant
sections of Virginia general law. Agency directors and leadership teams should know where to
find relevant legal provisions concerning their agencies’ work; the preparation of documents,
presentations, or training sessions to help relevant City personnel understand the implications of
these proposed Charter changes may prove a critical step in making sure they are implemented
smoothly.
51
Chapter Six: Recommendations, II: Partnership Model of Mayor-Council
Government
In this chapter, we lay out recommendations for adjustments to the powers and responsibilities of
the Mayor, Chief Administrative Officer, City Council, and City Attorney, within the basic
structure of the existing Mayor-Council form of government, consisting of a citywide, elected
Mayor alongside a nine-member City Council representing nine districts.
The Mayor-Council form of government, while unique to Richmond within the Commonwealth
of Virginia, is a widely practiced form of government. Richmond’s structure, including a
professional chief administrative officer serving under the elected mayor, matches best practice
recommended by the National Civic League for Mayor-Council governments.41 Its specific
structure tracks closely with recommendations made by VCU Professor Nelson Wikstrom, a
respected authority on local government, during the debates over Charter change in 2003.42
Yet, implementation of this model in practice has not been smooth or straightforward (as also
acknowledged by Dr. Wikstrom in a subsequent analysis).43 The ongoing challenge is translating
a reasonable basic framework into effective practice in the specific context of Richmond.
The goal of these recommendations is to cast and codify a Partnership Model for Richmond’s
Mayor-Council form of government that encourages and incentivizes collaboration between the
key actors in the Richmond’s governance system (Mayor, Council, CAO, City Attorney) while
establishing mutual respect for the distinctive roles, responsibilities, and powers of those same
actors. We have sought to identify a pathway that might allow the Mayor to more effectively act
as the City’s chief executive officer (as stated by the Charter) while at the same time
strengthening Council’s role as the City’s governing body (as stated by Virginia Code).
The Partnership Model framework can be seen in contrast to the notion of “Super-Strong
Mayor” governance, in which the elected Mayor has effective control or influence over all key
institutions within the city and the Council has a secondary role. As noted in the historical
section on the Charter, some key actors in the adoption of Richmond’s Mayor-Council system
had this view of the new system: hence the various proposals to give the Mayor the right to hire
and fire the Schools Superintendent, the dispute in 2005 over which version of the FY 2006
budget was the official legal document, the conflict concerning whether the CAO had
hiring/firing authority over City Council staff, and the conflict concerning the legality of City
Council’s lease with the School Board to retain office space in City Hall.
The sum result of those conflicts was to clearly establish the limits on the elected Mayor’s
powers, within the bounds of the Charter and Virginia general law. But challenges remain:
41 National Civic League, Model City Charter , 9th edition; see also the University of Virginia School of Law Clinic
on Local and State Policy literature review for this Commission, Appendix F.
42 Nelson Wikstrom, “Multiple Alternatives Are Available to Richmond,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, June 16, 2003.
43 Nelson Wikstrom, “Richmond: Implementation of and Experience with Strong-Mayor Form of Government,” in
James H. Svara and Douglas J. Watson, eds., More Than Mayor or Manager: Campaigns to Change Form of
Government in America’s Largest Cities.” Georgetown University Press, 2010, pp. 81-102.
52
• First, the fact that the actual powers of the Mayor do not match the perception or
expectation that Richmond has a “Strong Mayor” creates ongoing frustration (as well as
unrealistic expectations for the office);
• Second, the perception and reality that City Council does not have sufficient tools to act
effectively either as the governing body or as effective representatives of their
constituents’ concerns;
• Third, the fact that the specific roles of the Mayor and Council, and the specific rules for
their engagement with one another, remain under-defined; this lack of clarity can hamper
effective cooperation and also incentivize more adversarial behavior.
The Commission offers these proposals as friends of the City of Richmond, motivated by this
concern: we want as City residents to see the key actors in City Hall having robust debates about
how best to advance the public interest and the common good, and at the same time working
together effectively and cooperatively to implement agreed-upon actions. This means developing
spaces for public deliberation and “fair fights” among the actors—especially when competing
views are in play—and it also means fostering a culture of communication and collaboration to
facilitate constructive action.44
The specific proposals delineated below speak to the following understanding of the appropriate
roles of the key actors in a Mayor-Council form of government, conceived on the Partnership
Model.45
• Mayor: to act as the City’s chief executive officer with ultimate responsibility for the
operations of city government, expressed through the right to nominate a Chief
Administrative Officer and right to appoint agency directors (or delegate such authority
to the Chief Administrative Officer); to propose legislation and policy, through the
annual budget and through other legislative initiatives; to represent and advocate for the
City of Richmond in broader public and political arenas; and to provide a broad vision for
the direction of the city and formal and informal leadership in support of that vision
among all stakeholders and residents.
• City Council: to act as the City’s governing body through the introduction and
consideration of legislation, through the consideration of legislation introduced by the
Mayor, and through approval of the annual budget; to exercise voice and oversight
responsibilities in the operations of city government through participation in the selection
of the Chief Administrative Officer and the City Attorney, through oversight of auditing
and investigations, through receipt of financial reporting, through its powers of inquiry,
44 Harvard political theorist Danielle Allen describes capacity for “fair fighting” as a critical civic virtue and core
component of democratic citizenship. “Fair fighting” as defined by Allen involves civic actors whose ends and
means are “shaped by a commitment to the existence of the community and shared political institutions through
which they act. Fair fighters seek to best their opponents within the scope of agreed-upon rules by mobilizing
noncommitted groups to their side. . . ‘Fair fighting’ is characterized by recognition of the dignity and rights of
ones’ rivals…and by norms of forbearance and tolerance…” Danielle Allen, Justice by Means of Democracy.
Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2023, p. 224.
45 To be clear, this description of roles is not an account of the current roles, but the roles as they are conceived
under the proposed Partnership Model.
53
and through its committee structure; and to represent the concerns and interests of district
constituents.
• Chief Administrative Officer: to assume direct responsibility for the details of
government operations on behalf of the Mayor, working in collaboration with City
Council; to give direction to the work of city agencies and assess the performance of
agencies and directors; to work with or on behalf of the Mayor to hire or dismiss agency
heads; to implement continuous improvement processes and governmental best practices
(broadly conceived) throughout the organization; to represent the City as assigned by the
Mayor in dialogue and negotiations with other entities, governmental and
nongovernmental; and to report to the Mayor, City Council, and the public on the
performance of city agencies on a regular basis as determined by ordinance, resolution or
agreed-upon practice.
The thirteen core recommendations contained in this chapter speak to this conception of Mayor-
Council government as a partnership. While these ideas are significant, they retain the basic
structure of the current form of government. We also note that there are likely additional ideas
and practices in support of the Partnership Model that might be developed and implemented via
ordinance, resolution or agreement among the key actors. Consideration of all such possibilities
is beyond the scope of this Commission, which is to focus on proposed changes to the Charter.
We further stress that nothing in these recommendations should be construed as an assessment of
or commentary on the performance of any current or past City official, elected or appointed. It is
our observation and belief that City officials working within this form of government as a rule
act and have acted to the best of their abilities to advance the public interest as they variously
understood it, within the framework of the existing Charter. The Commission’s intent is to
recommend processes to improve the functionality of this form of government and allow the City
to better meet the needs of all residents.
These proposals are grouped into six categories: Mayoral Executive Power; the City Attorney’s
Office; Hiring and Dismissal of the Chief Administrative Officer; Budget Process;
Compensation; and Public Deliberation and Communication. We also offer an additional
governance-strengthening recommendation not requiring Charter change, as well as a proposal to
institutionalize regular Charter review, in a short section at the end of this chapter.
A. Strengthening ability of Mayor to act as hands-on executive
The City Charter states that the Mayor is the “chief executive officer of the city” with
responsibility for the “proper administration of city government.” (5.01)46 But the Charter
provides few tools to the Mayor for exercising this responsibility. Instead, responsibility for day-
to-day administration of city government rests with the Chief Administrative Officer, who has
sole ability to hire and fire directors or to give directives to employees.
46 The Commission understands this sentence to be fundamental to the Mayor-Council form of government.
Proposals 6-1 through 6-13 in this chapter all operate within the logic of the Mayor-Council form. For discussion of
possible Council-Manager forms of government, with an elected Mayor who is not the chief executive of the city,
see Chapter Seven.
54
Proposal:
6-1. Explicitly state that the Mayor will have the power to appoint or dismiss department
heads, or to delegate such authority to the Chief Administrative Officer. (Sections 5.02
and 5.03 would be modified).
This proposal allows but does not require the Mayor to take more hands-on responsibility for the
operations of City government, while continuing to respect the professional prerogatives of
agency directors and top administrators. Currently the only tool the Mayor has to exercise this
responsibility is to hire and dismiss the CAO. The CAO in practice may have considerable
autonomy in the administration of government, since replacing a CAO is not a costless action for
the Mayor.
This reality sits in tension with the intent of the Mayor-Council system, to empower an elected
Mayor to give direction to the work of city government.47 (The Council-Manager form of
government, by contrast, explicitly prioritizes the professional expertise of the city manager over
that of elected officials with respect to the day-to-day management of government operations.)
Adopting this provision would also give Mayors multiple pathways to lead. A greater explicit
say in personnel could allow a more hands-on Mayor to more easily assemble a leadership team
in the agencies committed to their vision of the city. Conversely, a Mayor may opt instead to
empower the CAO to take responsibility for personnel decisions; but this provision would also
allow such a Mayor to directly intervene on occasion when warranted. The provision also would
make clear that ultimate responsibility for the functioning of the administration lies with the
Mayor.
Textbook theories of the Mayor-Council model envision a CAO who is to a considerable degree
politically insulated from the Mayor.48 Experience suggests this may not be a reasonable
expectation in a city the size of Richmond.49 Issues or problems within the agencies are often
perceived as reflecting directly upon the Mayor’s leadership. Hence, a provision of this kind that
allows the Mayor’s actual powers to better match public perception of those powers may be
appropriate to Richmond’s circumstances.
Further, it is worth noting that this shift is relatively modest. The Charter already confers on the
Mayor the right to “participate” in personnel decisions related to agency heads, a right that is
47 It also, at times, can lead to uncertainty within the organization about who is ultimately in charge.
48 On this point, see the memorandum prepared for the Commission by the University of Virginia School of Law
State and Local Government Policy Clinic, attached to this report as Appendix F.
49 Specifically, in a relatively small city, the Mayor is often expected by the public to be on top of everything that
happens within the administration, an expectation stoked by the frequent descriptions (especially when the system
was adopted) of Richmond as having a “Strong Mayor.” Problems and issues in the agencies are generally attached
by residents and media outlets to the Mayor’s name, providing the Mayor a strong incentive to exert influence on the
Chief Administrative Officer and the agencies. More generally, there is tension if not contradiction between the
conception of the Chief Administrative Officer as the primary vehicle by which the Mayor exerts authority as the
chief executive officer of the city, and the notion that the Chief Administrative Officer is to be politically insulated
from the Mayor. If the Chief Administrative Officer were thus insulated from the Mayor, it’s hard to see in what
sense the Mayor would in fact be the City’s chief executive officer.
55
regularly exercised. Clearly stating that the Mayor has the right to make hiring/firing decisions at
the agency head level would make clear where ultimate authority and responsibility lies, even if
the Mayor elects to delegate this authority some, most, or all of the time to the CAO.50
Finally, adoption of this provision should be accompanied by corollary language establishing the
right of the Mayor to give directives to agency heads, provided the Chief Administrative Officer
is given written notification at the same time. In almost all instances, we expect that as currently,
directives to the agency heads will come from the Chief Administrative Officer or the Mayor and
the Chief Administrative Officer together; but the Commission believes the Mayor should also
have the ability to give directives if they are also to have the right to hire or remove agency
heads.51
5.02. Power of appointment and removal.
6-1 (a). Amend
Except for heads of administrative departments which may be directly hired or
removed at the directive of the mayor in accordance with the provisions of 5.03, the
chief administrative officer shall appoint for an indefinite term qualified officers and
employees to head all the administrative departments of the city, and shall appoint,
dismiss and discipline, in accordance with the city's personnel regulations, all officers
and employees in such departments, except as otherwise specifically provided by law or
this charter. Department heads who are appointed by the chief administrative officer shall
serve at the pleasure of the chief administrative officer.
The chief administrative officer shall designate some other officer or employee to
perform the duties of any office or position of the administrative service under his/her
control which is vacant or which lacks administration due to the absence or disability of
the incumbent. (1948, c. 116; 1998, c. 711; 2004, cc. 877, 898)
5.03. Involvement of mayor and council in appointment and removals.
6-1 (b). Amend, including creation of sub-sections (a-e)
(a) The mayor may elect to participate in, and take responsibility for, in part or in
full, the hiring and removal of heads of administrative departments, or may
50 An intricate question is whether mayoral appointment power should also extend to the rank of Deputy Chief
Administrative Officers, who may or may not also be agency heads. (Currently only the Deputy Chief
Administrative Officer for Human Services is an agency head.) The Commission intends that the mayoral
appointment power be construed narrowly to include agency heads only, but notes that the Mayors, wo rking in
conjunction with the CAO, have broad flexibility to organize and re-organize leadership structures as they see fit.
With the exception of the DCAO for Human Services (which is established by ordinance), the current DCAO
structure is a convention, not a requirement of City Code or the Charter.
51 The specific provisions to enact this idea have been drafted such that all official personnel actions continue to go
through the Chief Administrative Officer, while providing a mechanism by which the Mayor may formally order the
Chief Administrative Officer to take such an action (as well as the opportunity to block a proposed action by the
Chief Administrative Officer).
56
delegate such responsibility in part or in full to the chief administrative
officer.
(b) No individual who has not formally applied for a position as head of an
administrative department, and has not been certified by the director of
human resources as meeting all the minimum requirements stated in the
public posting for the position, is eligible for appointment to such position, in
any circumstance.
(c) When the mayor has elected to take full responsibility for the hiring or
removal of the head of an administrative department, the mayor is to provide
a written directive to the chief administrative officer on the course of action,
to be executed by the chief administrative officer.
(d) When the mayor has elected to delegate such authority to the chief
administrative officer, the chief administrative officer must notify the mayor
in writing one business day in advance of taking any action regarding the
hiring or removal of the head of an administrative department, unless the
mayor approves immediate action.
(e) The mayor and members of council may (i) communicate publicly or privately
their approval or disapproval of the performance of any particular city employee,
(ii) recommend persons to the chief administrative officer for consideration for
hiring or promotion, or (iii) request of the chief administrative officer that he
remove or take other disciplinary action against any particular city employee, as
they may see fit. Ultimate responsibility for hiring, removal and other personnel
decisions relating to administrative personnel, and for the directing of
administrative personnel, shall reside in the chief administrative officer, except as
noted above or unless expressly provided otherwise in this charter.
(f) Except for the purpose of inquiry, the mayor, council and its members shall may
deal with the administrative services solely through the chief administrative
officer, and neither the mayor, council nor any member thereof shall may give
orders either publicly or privately to any subordinate of the chief administrative
officer. Except for the purpose of inquiry, the mayor may deal with the
administrative services solely through the chief administrative officer and the
heads of administrative departments. The mayor may give orders to the
heads of administrative departments in writing, with written notification of
the chief administrative officer of the order taking place at the same time.
The mayor may not give orders either publicly or privately to any
subordinate of the heads of administrative departments.
B. Altering the structure of the City Attorney’s office
57
Under current interpretation of the Charter (see Chapter 4.17), the City Attorney represents the
City of Richmond as an entity, and regards the Mayor, Chief Administrative Officer and City
Council as its “constituents.” This should be stated explicitly in the Charter. This positionality
in effect gives the City Attorney a policy role in the event of conflicting perspectives between the
Mayor and the City Council. The fact that the City Attorney is appointed by the Council, but
does the majority of its work in service of the administration, also potentially gives rise to
conflict.
The Commission identified two primary strategies for resolving the structural conflict. The first
is to allow the administration and Council each to hire separate attorneys to handle their
respective work. Baltimore, Maryland is an example of a Mayor-Council city with this approach,
in which the Mayor appoints a City Solicitor to head a Law Department that handles the business
of the city administration while City Council appoints a General Counsel that acts as legal
advisor to the Council.52
The second is to have a single City Attorney who represents both Mayor and Council, but
provide both Mayor and Council a role in hiring and firing the position. Atlanta, Georgia is an
example of a Mayor-Council city with this approach.53
After considerable deliberation, the Commission believes the second model would work better in
Richmond’s case: by reducing or mitigating conflict, by avoiding confusion generated from
having multiple attorney offices in the same organization, and by avoiding additional new costs.
The Commission’s recommendation closely resembles the 2009 Charter Review Commission’s
recommendation that the Mayor appoint the City Attorney with the consent of Council and that
both Mayor and Council have a role in the dismissal of the City Attorney. The recommendation
also parallels the Commission’s recommendations for the Chief Administrative Officer position
(see next section).
In making this recommendation, the Commission acknowledges two possible issues that may
arise under the proposed structure. First, there may be legitimate disagreement on the legal
powers of the City’s constituents (Mayor, Council, CAO) under the Charter and general law, and
instances where the Council believes the City Attorney’s opinions are both incorrect and harmful
to the institutional standing of Council. Second, because most of the work performed by the City
Attorney’s office is on behalf of the administration, and because the Mayor would have a lead
role in the hiring of the City Attorney, it is possible over time a perception may arise that the
City Attorney is simply the “Mayor’s Attorney” and not the attorney representing the City as a
whole.
To mitigate those potential issues, we also recommend an additional provision intended to
protect the interests of Council: to permit, by super-majority vote, the Council to obtain outside
counsel to challenge opinions of the City Attorney that specifically pertain to the powers of
Council under the Charter and general law. This provision would provide a mechanism for
52 See Charter of Baltimore City, Article III (15) and Article VII (22-25).
53 See Charter of City of Atlanta, Section 3-303.
58
Council to challenge opinions specifically related to the powers of Council (not City business
more generally) without resorting to taking employment action on the City Attorney.54
Proposals:
6-2. State explicitly in the Charter that the City Attorney represents the City of Richmond as
its client, and various stakeholders as its constituents.
6-3. Alter the hiring and dismissal process of the City Attorney, such that the Mayor and
Council have shared powers with respect to both the hiring and dismissal of the CAO.
6-4. Allow City Council by super-majority vote to hire outside counsel on questions
specifically concerning the powers of the Council under the Charter or general law.
4.17. City attorney
6-2, 6.3(a). Amend
The city attorney will represent the interests of the city of Richmond and shall be the
chief legal advisor of the council, the mayor, the chief administrative officer and all
departments, boards, commissions and agencies of the city in all matters affecting the
interests of the city. The city of Richmond is the city attorney’s client, and each of
the parties named above are constituents of the city. The city attorney shall perform
particular duties and functions as assigned by the council. The city attorney shall be
appointed by the mayor with the agreement and consent of council, according to the
process specified in 4.17a, the council and shall serve at its pleasure, and shall devote
full time and attention to the representation of the city and the protection of its legal
interests. The city attorney is subject to removal according to the process specified in
4.17b. The city attorney shall have the power to appoint and remove assistants or any
other employees as shall be authorized by the council and to authorize any assistant or
special counsel to perform any of the duties imposed upon him in this charter or under
general law. The city attorney may represent personally or through one of his/her
assistants any number of city officials, departments, commissions, boards, or agencies
that are parties to the same transaction or that are parties in the same civil or
administrative proceeding and may represent multiple interests within the same
department, commission, board, or agency. In matters where the city attorney determines
that he/she is unable to render legal services to the mayor, chief administrative officer, or
city departments or agencies under the supervision of the chief administrative officer due
to a conflict of interests, the mayor, after receiving notice of such conflict, may employ
special counsel to render such legal services as may be necessary for such matter.
6-3 (b). Added subsection
54 It is not the intention of the Commission that adoption of proposals altering the hiring and dismissal procedures of
crucial positions in city government (including the City Attorney and Chief Administrative Officer) should affect the
employment of persons currently serving in such positions who have been properly appointed under the provisions
of the current Charter. See proposed new section 20.15.1 below (recommendation 6 -14) to address this point.
59
4.17a. Appointment of city attorney
In the event of a vacancy in the city attorney, the mayor will nominate a practicing
attorney in the city attorney’s office to serve as interim city attorney, with the
consent of council. The interim city attorney is subject to the removal process
described in 4.17b of this charter. The interim city attorney is eligible to be
nominated and serve in the permanent role.
To make a permanent appointment, the mayor must form a search committee to
include the city council president or another council member designated by the
president, and must cause the position to be advertised nationally for at least one
month according to industry norms as verified by the director of human resources
and publicly documented. Within six months of the position becoming vacant, the
mayor must nominate a candidate for the position, to be confirmed by the
affirmative consent of six members of council.
In the event the mayor’s nomination is rejected, the mayor must make another
nomination within six months. The interim city attorney may remain in the interim
position until the permanent position is filled.
6-3 (c). Added subsection
4.17b. Removal of city attorney
The city attorney may be removed upon the recommendation of the mayor by five
affirmative votes of council, or without the recommendation of the mayor by seven
affirmative votes of council.
6-4. Added subsection
4.17c. Council’s right to outside legal counsel
Upon seven affirmative votes, council may retain legal counsel, other than the city
attorney, to give an opinion on any matter specifically concerning the powers of
council. Council may act under this section upon seven affirmative votes based on
retained counsel’s opinion notwithstanding any opinion by the city attorney.
If the mayor, chief administrative officer, city attorney, or any other agent of the city
acts or fails to act and either thereby prevents council from acting based on retained
counsel’s opinion or thereby fails to execute or administer council’s action based on
retained counsel’s opinion, there is an actual controversy. If city council acts based
on retained counsel’s opinion, but the city attorney has given an opinion that
challenges council’s ability to take such action, there is an actual controversy.
When there is an actual controversy as specified in this section, council and the mayor
each have their own right to bring a civil action seeking declaratory, injunctive, or
other equitable r elief. The Circuit Court for the City of Richmond has exclusive
jurisdiction over a civil action filed under this section, subject to appellate review as
60
provided by law. Upon seven affirmative votes, city council may retain legal counsel,
other than the city attorney, to represent council throughout the civil action filed
under this section and all appeals thereto.
Nothing in this section requires any legal counsel to act in a manner inconsistent with
the Virginia Rules of Professional Conduct. Nothing in this section creates a cause of
action or right of action by implication. Nothing in this section prevents council or
the mayor from taking any other action or seeking any other relief permitted by law.
Council cannot retain legal counsel for purposes not specified in this section unless
permitted elsewhere in this charter or by law.
Costs associated with implementation of this section will be borne by the city as
specified by ordinance.
C. Adjusting the Hiring and Removal Process for the Chief Administrative
Officer
Background: Commission conversations with stakeholders established a widespread concern that
the Mayor-Council system is structured to be excessively adversarial. Some stakeholders also
expressed concern that because the CAO is hired and may be fired by the Mayor, City Council
members have little leverage over the actions of the administration, including implementation of
policies adopted or endorsed by Council. To gain sufficient leverage on problems or concerns to
produce action, Council members may have to turn to the media or to outside groups to publicize
concerns that might be more easily addressed through more frequent communication and
cooperation.
The proposals below offer one strategy for redressing this issue, by redefining the ways in which
the Chief Administrative Officer (and Interim Chief Administrative Officer) is hired and can be
removed. The intent of this redefinition is to reflect the reality that the Chief Administrative
Officer and City Council routinely work together, and that this work goes better when there is
recognition of a shared interest in the City’s success. City Council members depend on the CAO
to report on progress and to solve problems; the responsiveness and overall relationship between
the administration and Council significantly impacts Council members’ ability to be effective
representatives of their constituents as well as effective members of the governing body.
These proposals give City Council an explicit but subordinate role in the hiring of the Chief
Administrative Officer, and under some circumstances a role in the removal of the Chief
Administrative Officer. With one exception, final decision-making power remains with the
Mayor. This final power is in fact decisive to the maintenance of the Mayor-Council form of
government.
Taken together, it is the intention of these proposals to incentivize a stronger partnership between
the administration and City Council. The Mayor remains the lead actor and the chief executive
61
officer of the City, but the role of City Council as the governing body and a key partner in the
day-to-day work of city government is more explicitly recognized. 55
Proposal:
6-5. Hiring of the Chief Administrative Officer
In the event of a vacancy in the CAO role, the pre-designated Acting CAO will immediately
assume the powers of the CAO. (The concept of a pre-designated Acting CAO was discussed
by the 2009 Charter Review Commission report.)56
Within ten days of a vacancy, and for a maximum length of six months, the Mayor must
designate as the Interim Chief Administrative Officer a qualified individual who currently
serves or previously has served on a permanent appointment as a member of the City of
Richmond’s senior executive group as currently defined by City Code Sec. 22-317(k), or a
qualified individual who has served as a permanent CAO, City Manager, or County Manager
in another locality in the United States. (The senior executive group consists of the CAO,
DCAOs, and agency heads, including those reporting to the CAO and to City Council, as
well as the Chiefs of Staff of the Mayor’s Office, City Council, and the Office of the Chief
Administrative Officer, and several other specified positions.)
The Mayor shall present the qualifications of the nominee to City Council in an open
meeting, and members of City Council shall have the opportunity to ask questions and
receive answers from the nominee prior to a confirmation vote. The Mayor’s selection for
Interim CAO must be confirmed by Council on a majority vote. In the event the Mayor’s
selection for Interim CAO is not confirmed, the Mayor must bring forward an alternative
Interim CAO candidate meeting the above qualifications within five working days. The
Interim CAO shall be eligible to be nominated as permanent CAO.
To fill the position of permanent Chief Administrative Officer, the Mayor must form and
lead a Search Committee, to include the City Council President or another member of City
Council designated by the President. The committee shall cause the position to be advertised
in appropriate national outlets according to industry standards as verified by the Director of
Human Resources and publicly documented. The position shall be publicly advertised for a
minimum of one month.
No later than six months after the confirmation of the interim CAO, the Search Committee
shall provide the names and credentials of at least two candidates to City Council in closed
session. (The requirements of eligibility for appointment as Interim CAO do not apply to the
permanent position.) The closed session may include in-person or remote interviews with the
candidates, but this is not required. City Council members shall have the opportunity to
convey feedback on candidates to the Search Committee.
55 See National Civic League, Model City Charter¸ 9th edition, pp. 71-74 for discussion of the Chief Administrative
Officer position in Mayor-Council governments. That report stresses the benefits of Council participation in
selection of the CAO, stating “Shared power provisions may serve to knit the separate branches more closely
together. The CAO, although ultimately accountable to the mayor, serves both sets of officials and can promote
closer interaction between them.” (p. 73.)
56 2009 City Charter Review Commission Report.
62
Within five days of this closed session meeting of City Council, the Mayor must designate a
candidate as the preferred nominee for permanent CAO, or refer additional candidates to
Council for feedback (repeating the step noted above). Once a nomination has been made,
the Mayor shall present the qualifications of the nominee to City Council in an open meeting,
and members of City Council shall have the opportunity to ask questions and receive answers
from the nominee prior to a confirmation vote. The Mayor’s selection for permanent Chief
Administrative Officer must be confirmed by City Council with a minimum of six positive
votes required for confirmation.
In the event the Mayor’s nomination is rejected, the Mayor may elect to bring forward any
other applicant as an alternative nominee, or may elect to restart the search process. In the
event the search process is restarted, the Interim CAO shall be eligible to serve in the role a
further six months. No single individual may serve as the Interim CAO for more than twelve
months consecutively or more than twelve months in a single mayoral term.
Finally, the Mayor and Council must pre-select an Acting CAO, who will be an
administrative head reporting to the CAO, who will assume the powers of CAO on an
emergency basis for up to 10 days in the event of a sudden vacancy in the position of CAO.
The Acting CAO shall be eligible to be nominated and serve as Interim and/or permanent
CAO.
Note: The intent is to a) provide City Council a strengthened role in the selection of the CAO and
b) set limits on who may be appointed Interim CAO and how long an individual may serve in that
capacity c) provide for an Acting CAO who is pre-designated to assume the authority of the CAO
in the event of a sudden, unexpected vacancy, to assure continuity of government operations. The
Acting CAO role, which is envisioned as temporary and short-term, is distinct from the Interim
CAO, who may hold the position for up to six months or in some cases one year.
Proposal:
6-6. Removal of Chief Administrative Officer
The Mayor may request the resignation of the Chief Administrative Officer at any time. In
the event the Chief Administrative Officer refuses to resign, the following procedures for
involuntary separation will be followed:
Upon election or re-election to the office of Mayor, in the first six months of the new term
the Mayor may terminate the employment of the sitting Chief Administrative Officer
without giving cause and without consulting City Council.
In the first six months of a Chief Administrative Officer’s tenure, the Mayor may
terminate the employment of the sitting Chief Administrative Officer without giving cause
and without consulting City Council.
After a Chief Administrative Officer has served six months, the Mayor may initiate the
termination of the Chief Administrative Officer by notifying the City Council President of
intent to do so. The City Council President may call a emergency Council meeting to
consider the matter in closed session, or may within two business days notify the Mayor in
writing that no meeting will be called. If no meeting is called, the Mayor may proceed
with the action to terminate employment of the CAO. If the meeting is called, the Mayor
63
must attend the meeting and participate in the closed session. City Council members will
have the right to provide feedback and to ask questions of the Mayor concerning the
proposed termination, which the Mayor may agree or decline to answer. Upon completion
of the closed session, the Mayor may opt to move forward with termination.
Note: This language creates a requirement in some circumstances for the Mayor to consult with
City Council prior to an involuntary separation with the CAO. It does not constrain the authority
of the Mayor to terminate the CAO’s contract.
Council-initiated
City Council has the right once per calendar year to consider a motion of no-confidence
in the performance of the Chief Administrative Officer. Such a motion will require a total
of five sponsors to move to consideration by full Council. Once such a resolution is
introduced and read at a City Council meeting, the vote must take place at a subsequent
meeting within ten working days. A motion of no-confidence requires seven affirmative
votes to pass. The effect of such a vote will be to remove the Chief Administrative
Officer from the position, taking effect on the last business day of the week in which the
motion is adopted. If a motion of no-confidence fails, such a motion cannot be refiled
until the next calendar year.
Note: This proposal provides an avenue by which a strong super-majority of Council members
could act to remove the Chief Administrative Officer, without involvement of the Mayor. The
Commission believes that invocation of this power would be exceedingly rare, as most
imaginable circumstances where 7 of 9 Council members publicly endorsed removal would
already have led to mayoral termination or to a resignation of the CAO. The proposed clause
should be understood as placing an outer boundary to protect the interests of the city and its
residents in the case of gross incompetence or negligence attributed to the CAO which the Mayor
declines to address or correct. An example of a Mayor-Council city that provides an analogous
power to its City Council is Columbus, Georgia.
5.01. Chief Administrative Officer
6-5 (a). Amend
In accordance with the provisions of 5.01.1, the mayor shall appoint a chief
administrative officer, subject to the advice and consent of a two-thirds majority of the
members of city council, who shall be chosen solely on the basis of his/her executive and
administrative qualifications, with special reference to his/her actual experience in or
knowledge of accepted practice with respect to the duties of his/her office. At the time of
his/her appointment, the chief administrative officer need not be a resident of the city or
the Commonwealth but he/she shall reside within the city during his/her tenure in office.
The chief administrative officer shall serve at the pleasure of the mayor. The mayor shall
set the salary of the chief administrative officer subject to the approval of a majority of
the members of city council. (2004, cc. 877, 898)
5.01.1. Pre-designation of acting chief administrative officer
6-5 (b). Amend
64
The mayor shall, with the advice and consent of a majority of the members of council,
designate the head of a department, bureau or other officer appointed by the chief
administrative officer, to assume immediately the powers of the chief administrative
officer in case of the absence, incapacity, death or resignation of the chief administrative
officer, until his/her return to duty or the appointment of an interim or permanent chief
administrative officer. The acting chief administrative officer will assume the
powers of chief administrative officer once the mayor has provided (by print or
electronic means) written, simultaneous notice to all members of council, the city
attorney, and the chief of police.
At all times, there must be a designated individual nominated by the mayor and
consented by council to serve in this emergency capacity. An acting chief
administrative officer shall serve at the pleasure of the mayor. The acting chief
administrative officer is eligible for nomination and appointment as interim and/or
permanent chief administrative officer.
6-5 (c). Add section
5.01.2. Selection of interim chief administrative officer
(a) Within ten days of a vacancy in the permanent role, the mayor must designate as
the interim chief administrative officer qualified individual who currently serves or
previously has served on a permanent appointment as a member of the city’s senior
executive group as defined by city code, or a qualified individual who has served as
a permanent chief administrative officer, city manager, or county manager in
another locality in the United States. The interim chief administrative officer may
serve in the role for up to six months, with one permitted extension in the
circumstances specified in 5.01.3(d).
(b) The mayor will present the qualifications of the nominee to council in an open
meeting, and members of council will have the opportunity to ask questions and
receive answers from the nominee prior to a confirmation vote. The mayor’s
selection for interim chief administrative officer must be confirmed by council on a
majority vote. In the event the mayor’s selection for interim chief administrative
officer is not confirmed, the mayor must bring forward an alternative interim chief
administrative officer candidate meeting the above qualifications within five
working days. The interim chief administrative officer serves at the pleasure of the
mayor, and is eligible to be nominated as permanent chief administrative officer.
(c) If the previously designated acting chief administrative officer is named interim
chief administrative officer, a new designated acting chief administrative officer
must be named and approved at the same time.
6-5 (d). Add section
5.01.3. Selection of chief administrative officer
65
(a) To fill the position of permanent chief administrative officer, the mayor must
form and lead a search committee, to include the council president or another
member of council designated by the president. The committee will cause the
position to be advertised in appropriate national outlets according to industry
standards as verified by the director of human resources and publicly documented.
The position must be publicly advertised for a minimum of one month.
(b) No later than six months after the confirmation of the interim chief
administrative officer, the search committee will provide the names and credentials
of at least two candidates to council in closed session. (The requirements of
eligibility for the interim position described in 5.01.2 do not apply to the permanent
position.) The closed session may include in-person or remote interviews with the
candidates. Council members will have the opportunity to convey feedback on
candidates to the search committee.
(c) Within five days of this closed session, the mayor will designate a candidate as
the preferred nominee for permanent chief administrative officer, or refer
additional candidates to council for feedback. Once a nomination has been made,
the mayor will present the qualifications of the nominee to council in an open
meeting, and members of council will have the opportunity in open session to ask
questions and receive answers from the nominee prior to a confirmation vote. The
mayor’s nomination for permanent chief administrative officer must be confirmed
by council with a minimum of six positive votes required for confirmation.
(d) In the event the mayor’s nomination is rejected, the mayor may elect to bring
forward any other applicant as an alternative nominee, or may elect to restart the
search process. In the event the search process is restarted, the interim chief
administrative officer will be eligible to serve in the role a further six months. No
single individual may serve as the interim chief administrative officer for more than
twelve months consecutively or more than twelve months in a single mayoral term
of office.
6-6. Add Chapter
5.01.4. Removal of the chief administrative officer
(a) The mayor may request the resignation of the chief administrative officer at any
time. In the event the chief administrative officer declines to resign, the following
procedures for involuntary separation will be followed:
(b) Upon election or re-election to the office of mayor, in the first six months of the
new term the mayor may terminate the employment of the sitting chief
administrative officer without giving cause and without consulting council.
(c) In the first six months of a chief administrative officer’s tenure, the mayor may
terminate the employment of the sitting chief administrative officer without giving
cause and without consulting council.
66
(d) After a chief administrative officer has served six months and after the first six
months of a mayoral term, the mayor may initiate the termination of the chief
administrative officer by notifying the council president of intent to do so. The
council president may call an emergency meeting to consider the matter in closed
session, or may within two business days notify the mayor in writing that no meeting
will be called. If no meeting is called, the mayor may proceed with the action to
terminate employment of the chief administrative officer. If the meeting is called,
the mayor will attend the meeting and participate in the closed session. Council
members will have the right to provide feedback and to ask questions of the mayor
concerning the proposed termination, which the mayor may agree or decline to
answer. Upon completion of the closed session, the mayor may elect to move
forward with termination.
(e) Council has the right once per calendar year to consider a motion of removal of
the chief administrative officer. Such a motion will require a total of five co-
sponsors to move to consideration by the full council. Once such a resolution is
introduced and read at a council meeting, the vote must take place at a subsequent
meeting within ten working days. A motion of removal requires seven affirmative
votes to pass. The effect of such a vote will be to remove the chief administrative
officer from the position, taking effect on the last business day of the week in which
the motion is adopted. If a motion of removal fails, such a motion may not be refiled
until the next calendar year.
6-5 (e). Strike (moved to 5.01.1., with amendments).
5.07. Acting chief administrative officer.
The mayor shall, with the advice and consent of a majority of the members of council,
designate the head of a department, bureau or other officer appointed by the chief
administrative officer, to act as chief administrative officer in case of the absence,
incapacity, death or resignation of the chief administrative officer, until his/her return to
duty or the appointment of his/her successor. An acting chief administrative officer shall
serve at the pleasure of the mayor.
D. Budget Process
The Commission has heard considerable concern about the budget process, specifically the fact
that only the Mayor can introduce a budget amendment during the fiscal year. Conversely, the
Commission has also heard the desire to provide the administration more flexibility to move
funds in response to changing conditions. The Commission is also aware that the practice of
including multiple changes to the adopted budget in a single ordinance that is subject to an up or
down vote restricts City Council’s ability to exercise its role as the governing body. These
proposed steps seek to address those issues.
Proposals:
67
6-7. The Chief Administrative Officer is to develop the annual budget under the direction of
the Mayor. City Council shall have the formal opportunity to provide input on budget
priorities to the Mayor at a pre-budget public meeting to take place between December 1
and January 15 each year. City Council shall have access to the budget requests
submitted by each agency to the Mayor and the Office of Budget and Strategic Planning
seven days prior to this meeting.
6-8. Any ordinance to amend the budget after adoption must address a single narrowly
defined purpose. If, in the opinion of a majority of City Council, an ordinance addresses
more than one purpose, it may be:
I. Voted on as introduced, or
II. Severed into its component parts each of which may be voted on separately, or
III. Acted upon in the same manner as the original budget ordinance as though it is
before City Council for the first time.
6-9. City Council shall have the power to initiate amendments to the adopted budget twice
during the fiscal year: at a meeting in October and at a meeting in April. The net fiscal
effects of proposed amendments must be neutral. Six affirmative votes are needed to
adopt the proposed amendments. Budget amendments shall not be combined with non-
budget legislative items.
6-10. The Mayor and City Council in the annual budget process may designate a sum of
money no greater than 1% of the annual general fund budget as a General Operational
fund that can be assigned by the CAO to any city agency (not non-departmental entities)
during the fiscal year without further Council action, with the exception that no more
than 50% of this fund may be re-assigned to any single agency within a fiscal year
without Council action. The CAO and Budget Office must provide a monthly update to
Council on use of this fund as part of its routine reporting.
Note: The purpose of item 6-7 is to allow Council to see the full scope of need expressed by the
City agencies as well as to provide up-front public input to the Mayor prior to the development
of the annual budget. The purpose of item 6-8 is to allow City Council to address ordinances that
propose to amend the adopted budget, when such ordinances address multiple purposes. The
proposed language is based on Article V. Section 6 (b) (iii) of the Constitution of Virginia. The
purpose of item 6-9 is to give City Council limited opportunity to initiate a budget amendment in
response to changed circumstances or in the event funds designated for a purpose are not being
utilized as intended. The purpose of item 6-10 is to allow the administration to supplement
department budgets in response to shifting circumstances at its discretion, to a modest degree,
without requiring a prior Council amendment.
6.03. Preparation (of budget)
6-7. Amend (a) and add sections (b) and (c). Section (b) is new language and section (c) is
existing language.
(a) It shall be the duty of the head of each department, the judges of the municipal
courts, each board or commission, including the school board, and each other
office or agency supported in whole or in part by the city, including the attorney
68
for the Commonwealth, to provide, at such time as the mayor may prescribe,
estimates of revenue and expenditure for that department, court, board,
commission, office or agency for the ensuing fiscal year. For all entities except
the school board, such estimates must be supplied no later than January 1.
Such estimates shall be submitted in a form as determined by the mayor, and it
shall be the duty of the head of each such department, judge, board, commission,
office or agency to supply all of the information which the mayor may require to
be submitted thereon.
(b) Prior to the preparation of the proposed budget, and no later than January
15 each fiscal year, there must be a special meeting of council to discuss the
ensuing fiscal year budget and communicate priorities. The mayor must
provide copies of the estimates of revenue and expenditure provided by each
of the agencies, boards, and commissions as noted in 6.03.a, except that of the
school board, seven days in advance of this meeting. The mayor must attend
and participate in this meeting.
(c) The mayor shall hold such hearings as he/she may deem advisable and shall
review the estimates and other data pertinent to the preparation of the budgets and
make such revisions in such estimates as he/she may deem proper, subject to the
laws of the Commonwealth relating to obligatory expenditures for any purpose,
except that in the case of the school board, he/she may recommend a revision only
as permitted by § 22.1-94 of the Code of Virginia or any other provision of general
law not in conflict with this charter. (1948, c.116; 1989, c. 349; 1998, c. 711;
2004, cc. 877, 898; 2006, cc. 650, 712)
6.16. Amendments after adoption.
6-8. Added subsection (f).
No ordinance to amend the revenues; or the operating, or capital budget may
address more than one narrowly defined purpose. If such an ordinance proposes to
amend more than one narrowly defined purpose, then:
(1) Council may determine, in accordance with its own procedures, whether
to act on the proposed amendments en bloc or individually, or any
combination thereof. Whether treated en bloc or individually, each
amendment to the budget ordinance is adopted by not less than six
affirmative votes.
(2) If the amending ordinance does not contain specific and severable
amendments as determined by the majority vote of the members present,
then the adopted revenue, operating, or capital budget ordinance wll be
before City Council, in the form originally adopted and may be acted
69
upon as though for the first time subject to the provisions of § 6.10, and §
6.11 of this Charter, with the exception of the deadline. Under these
circumstances, amendments to the budget ordinance are adopted by not
less than five affirmative votes.
6-9. Added subsection (g).
(g) Twice during the fiscal year, at any council meeting in October and at any
council meeting in April, the council may by ordinance adopted by not less than six
affirmative votes transfer part of or all of the unencumbered appropriation balance
from one department or major organizational unit to the appropriation for other
departments or major organizational units. The chief administrative officer and
budget office must provide council with current unencumbered appropriation
balances as requested for this purpose within five working days of the request. This
transfer may not be combined with any other legislative item.
6.04. Scope of the budget.
6-10. Added section 6.04.1
6.04.1. General operational fund line item
The adopted budget may designate a sum of money no greater than 1% of the
annual general fund budget as a general operational fund that may be assigned by
the chief administrative officer to any city agency (not non-departmental entities)
during the fiscal year without council approval, with the exception that no more
than one-half of this fund may be re-assigned to any single agency within a fiscal
year without approval of six members of council. The chief administrative officer
and budget office must provide a monthly update to council on use of this fund
during the fiscal year.
E. Increasing Compensation for Elected Officials
Mayoral Compensation
The Charter describes the Mayor as the “chief executive officer” for the City. Yet the Mayor’s
compensation is actually less than that of the Chief Administrative Officer, and that of the
majority of Deputy Chief Administrative Officers and Directors that the Mayor is to lead and
direct.
Obviously, comparison to CEO roles of comparative size and complexity in the private sector is
inappropriate. But we believe a significant pay increase to assure that the Mayor is better
compensated both makes sense from an organizational perspective and would potentially
increase the pool of talented individuals with executive-level experience willing to seek the
office.
The Charter currently states that the salary of the Mayor is set by City Council.
70
Proposal:
6-11. Alter the Charter to stipulate that the salary of a new Mayor upon beginning a term of
office shall be set by Council shall be equivalent to or greater than the salary of the five
highest-paid city executive officials (excluding constitutional officers) in the last full
fiscal year of the previous mayoral term. This salary shall remain flat for the entire
tenure of a mayor’s term of office (including, if re-elected, a second term) except by
positive vote of seven members of City Council.
Context: In 2021, the average salary for the five highest-paid city executives was reported to be
approximately $200,000, while the salary for the Mayor was $125,000, plus benefits. If the
Mayoral salary had risen since 2005 at the same rate as inflation, the current salary would be
approximately $196,000, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics inflation calculator.
Increasing Compensation for City Council
The current low pay for service on City Council inhibits the ability of Council collectively to act
as the City’s governing body and to hold the city administration meaningfully accountable, in
two ways: the current pay scale impacts the pool of eligible residents willing to run for office and
serve, and it inhibits the time available for Council service for members to devote to the role as
opposed to earning additional money in other paid employment.
Proposal
6-12. It is proposed the Charter set Council pay as equivalent to the median household income
for the City of Richmond (currently approximately $55,000).
Note: The Commission has been advised that cities may in their charters (if approved by the
General Assembly) adopt compensation standards for Council members distinct from those set
by Virginia general law. See https://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/15.2-1414.5/ providing
exceptions for cities that specify compensation standards in their charters.
5.01. Mayor.
6-11. Amend
The mayor shall be the chief executive officer of the city and shall be responsible for the
proper administration of city government. The mayor shall be recognized as the head of
government for all ceremonial purposes, military law and the service of civil process. The
office of mayor shall be a full-time position with salary and expenses set by the
council. Following the election of a new mayor and prior to the start of a mayor’s
term of office, council must by ordinance set the salary of the mayor to be
equivalent or greater to the average salary of the five highest-paid city officials
reporting to the mayor or chief administrative officer in the fiscal year in which the
mayor is elected. The salary of the mayor must remain flat during the mayor’s
entire tenure of office (whether one or two terms) unless increased by the
affirmative vote of seven members of council.
4.01. Composition; compensation; appointment of members to office of profit.
6-12. Strike and add
71
The council shall consist of nine members elected as provided in Chapter 3. After a
general election in which council members are elected and prior to the new term of
office, council shall adopt an ordinance establishing compensation for newly elected
or re-elected members effective January 1 of the new term of office. Compensation
of members of council shall be fixed in accordance with and within the limits prescribed
in general laws of the Commonwealth for pay and expenses of councils and mayors of
cities of the Commonwealth match the median household income for city residents as
reported by the American Community Survey of the U.S. Census Bureau for the
most recent available five-year period at the time the council compensation
ordinance is adopted, and will remain flat for the entire term of office. The council
president may receive additional compensation equivalent to up to ten percent of the
compensation level for all council members, as approved by council. The members
of the council, subject to the approval of the council, may also be allowed their
reasonable actual expenses incurred in representing the city. No member of the council
shall during the term of which he was elected and one year thereafter be appointed to any
office of profit under the government of the city.
Note: To implement these provisions, best practice would be for Council to account for
anticipated salary increases in adopting the budget for an upcoming fiscal year that includes a
general election. Alternatively, a mid-year budget amendment adopted prior to the swearing in
of elected officials on January 1 could also satisfy these provisions. In either case, Council is to
adopt an ordinance setting the specific salaries for Mayor and Council in the new terms effective
January 1. In the event the City adopts staggered Council terms as recommended by this report
(see 8-1), this provision should be further amended to state that Council salaries for all members
are re-adjusted each four years at the start of each mayoral term. In the event of a runoff in the
election for Mayor, this language allows an ordinance setting the salary for the Mayor to be
introduced but not adopted until the mayoral election is resolved.
F. Public Deliberation and Communication
A striking feature of the current governance structure is that the Mayor and City Council are
rarely seen engaging in citywide forums in public deliberation about policy matters or the
general functioning of government. It may be worth considering a requirement that the Mayor
appear at Council meetings on a monthly basis to give a short update on the overall functioning
of the City and to answer questions from Council, or a similar mechanism to establish regular,
publicly viewed communication and deliberation amongst the city’s elected leaders.
Proposal:
6-13. The Mayor will be required to attend one regular meeting of City Council per month
(August excluded) to provide a short update either on the city’s progress overall or on a
designated topic, and to answer questions from Council members pertinent to the
Mayor’s presentation. All Council members shall have the opportunity to ask (or decline
to ask) a question (with a follow-up). After all Council members have had the
72
opportunity to ask a question and a follow-up, the Council President shall bring this part
of the agenda to a close unless the Mayor agrees to respond to additional questions.
5.05. General duties; mayor.
6-13. Add section (b)
(b) Attend one regular meeting of council per month (excepting any month in
which no regular meeting is held) to provide an update either on the city’s
progress overall or on a designated topic published as part of the meeting
agenda, and to respond to questions from council members pertinent to the
mayor’s presentation. All council members will have the opportunity to ask
(or decline to ask) a question (with a follow-up). After all council members
have had the opportunity to ask a question and a follow-up, the council
president will bring this part of the agenda to a close.
Additional Notes for Chapter Six
Additional Note, 1: Governance reform as a package
The proposals in this chapter are to a considerable degree independent of one another and could
be adopted piecemeal, accepting some and rejecting others. The Commission, however,
encourages stakeholders to consider these ideas as a package and their cumulative impact on the
functioning of the Mayor-Council form of government.
Additional Note, 2: Continual process improvement
As noted above, many other possible steps short of Charter change might be taken in support of
the Partnership Model of Mayor-Council government. We recommend the Mayor and Council
consider jointly establishing an internal governance committee, to include the Mayor’s Office,
Chief Administrative Officer, City Council President or designee, Council Chief of Staff, and
additional officials, employees, or community members as might be helpful to the endeavor, to
work over the remainder of 2023 and 2024 on developing and codifying processes for productive
communication and engagement between the administration and Council, building on existing
practices. The aim would be both to identify opportunities for improvement and to the degree
possible codify best practice in advance of the new mayoral and Council terms to begin in 2025.
Additional Note, 3: Regular Charter Review
Richmond is a rapidly changing city, and continues to accumulate experience with its current
form of government. While this Commission has made its best effort, we recognize that our
recommendations likely do not cover all suboptimalities in the Charter; further, to the degree
some or all of this report’s recommendations are implemented, their impact on practice should be
assessed after a reasonable length of time.
A healthy city regularly reviews its governing arrangements to identify opportunities for
improvement and to adapt to changes and challenges. Institutionalizing Charter review as a
regular function of city government would provide a mechanism for doing so, in a way that is not
tied to the political conflicts or issues of a particular moment. Linking regular Charter review to
73
the decennial census and subsequent redistricting processes would be one way to achieve that
goal. Baltimore, Maryland is an example of a city that within its charter creates a requirement of
a decennial charter review commission.57
To this effect, we recommend this language:
20. Miscellaneous Provisions
6-14. Add new sections, 20.15 and 20.15.1.
20.15. Decennial charter review
No later than July 1, 2030, and each ten years thereafter, council must establish by
ordinance a charter review commission for the purpose of reviewing the provisions
of this charter and making any such recommendations for changes as are deemed
advisable. The ordinance establishing the commission must specify the charge,
composition, deliverables, and timeline of the commission’s work. The council will
endeavor to appoint to each commission one or more residents from each of the
council districts, subject to additional qualifications or provisions council may
establish by ordinance. The commission will expire upon the submission to council
of its final report, or after two years have passed since its establishment.
20.15.1. Charter changes not to impact employment status of officials
Neither changes in the hiring or dismissal processes nor changes in the duties and
responsibilities of specific officials resulting from periodic adjustments to the
charter are to affect the employment of persons serving in those roles at the time the
charter changes take effect, unless the effect of the charter change is to abolish said
position. Changes in the responsibilities of positions and in the processes related to
hiring and dismissal of positions are effective from the date the charter changes go
into effect.
57 See Charter of Baltimore City, Article XI.
74
Chapter Seven. Recommendations, III: Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option
The Council ordinance establishing this Commission charged it with considering and making
recommendations to the Charter, to include “clarifications or changes to the definition and
delineation of the authority of the Council, the Mayor, and the Chief Administrative Officer” as
well as “clarifications or changes to Richmond’s current form of government.”
Richmond’s adoption of a Mayor-Council form of government is nearly twenty years old.
Richmond remains the only city in Virginia to employ this form of government, although several
other Southern cities of similar size to Richmond also employ Mayor-Council government.
It is critically important to understand that the 2004 Charter changes made two major changes
simultaneously:
• First, it established a directly elected Mayor, to assure that city government would be led
by someone elected on the basis of a citywide agenda.
• Second, it transferred day-to-day authority over city government from a City Manager
appointed by the Council to a Chief Administrative Officer selected by the Mayor,
thereby creating distinct legislative and executive branches of city government.
Although these changes took place at the same time, they are logically distinct, with distinct
rationales behind each component. The primary rationale for moving from an indirectly elected
to an elected Mayor was to assure that at least one full-time elected official in City government
(outside the constitutional officers) would have a citywide view, having been elected by voters
citywide. An elected Mayor could lead with the good of the whole city in mind, and would have
the potential to unify a diverse city.58
Several rationales for moving the City administration under the elected Mayor were offered in
the public discussions leading to the Charter change:
• That the City administration, being beholden to nine “mini-mayors,” was pulled in too
many directions or too beholden to parochial district concerns to forge a strategic vision;
• That the City Manager in effect ran the City, especially at times when Council was
perceived as divided or less effective, meaning that many important decisions were made
by someone voters did not elect;
• That the City administration was not performing effectively under the Council-Manager
system from an efficiency or service delivery point of view;
• That even if the City administration was doing the best it could, the problems facing the
City were so severe that it needed the strongest, most consolidated leadership possible to
get real traction on them; and more generally, that the status quo in Richmond was simply
unacceptable, and something new needed to be done.59
58 See Melvin Law, “Direct Election of the Mayor Qill Give Voters More Voice,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, April
11, 2003; Thomas Shields, “Richmond Needs a Face for the City,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, October 6, 2003.
59 See, among many other commentaries, L. Douglas Wilder, “Richmonders Have Tolerated Mediocrity Long
Enough,” Richmond Times-Dispatch, June 2, 2002.
75
The present Commission has proceeded from the premise that Richmond should keep a directly
elected Mayor, for two primary reasons: first, that the City benefits from having a full-time
elected official elected on a citywide vision and agenda, and second, that electing the Mayor
directly has become an important way that City residents can exercise influence over City Hall,
and an important civic exercise.
Consistent with its charge, however, the Commission has lent significant consideration to
altering the roles and responsibilities of the elected Mayor. A critical question is how to assure
that the elected Mayor, at the least, has the power of initiative; that is, the capacity to set a policy
agenda and initiate steps to realize it consistent with the commitments made to voters in the
electoral process. In the Mayor-Council system, the Mayor clearly has this power (as well as the
power to supervise policy implementation and day-to-day city operations).
But this is not the only way the power of initiative can be secured. In many cities with an elected
mayor, the mayor sits on and presides over city council, which sets citywide policy, establishes
budgets, and collectively hires and dismisses a city manager to run the day-to-day operations of
the city. A full-time Mayor elected on a citywide agenda who presides over the business of City
Council would be well-positioned to set the policy agenda of the Council and therefore the City.
There are several reasons why the Commission believed it was important consider this
alternative model--not going back to the pre-2004 system, but potentially going forward with a
Council-Manager system to include a directly-elected Mayor:
• The City of Richmond has changed significantly over the past twenty years; most
obviously a thirty-five year period of population decline dating to the Chesterfield
annexation of 1970 has reversed itself, with the City gaining over 32,000 new residents
since 2004. Insofar as Richmond’s adoption of the Mayor-Council model was motivated
by a sense of crisis about the City’s long-term viability, it may be worth revisiting
whether the model remains appropriate to Richmond’s changed circumstances.
• Conversely, it is also worth asking whether the Mayor-Council form of government has
produced the changes residents hoped for when they voted to adopt it, or perhaps solved
some issues while creating new ones.
• Even if one judges that adopting the system was a rational decision at the time it was
made, and also judges that the system has performed fairly well in advancing the City’s
interests and meeting residents’ needs, it is possible that an alternative system that
retained the strengths of the existing system while removing its weaknesses might
perform even better going forward.
• Given that this Commission is the first systemic effort by a body of Richmond
government to assess the Charter as a whole in the past twenty years, the Commission
believes it would have been irresponsible not to at least raise the question of whether
Richmond should continue indefinitely with the Mayor-Council form of government or
consider an alternative. In democracies, both individuals and communities can change
their minds, and while it’s important to take note of and give due respect to the historical
reasons policy and institutional decisions were made, present-day and future
76
Richmonders should not be bound by decisions and arrangements made twenty years ago,
if better arrangements for the future can be identified.
The Commission’s examination of Council-Manager forms of government included several
steps:
• Review of forms of government and electoral arrangements in independent cities across
Virginia, in comparably sized cities across the Southeast U.S., and in a selection of larger
cities in the Southeast U.S.
• Consideration of professional materials related to local forms of government produced by
national organizations such as the National Civic League, particularly its Model City
Charter, 9th edition.
• Consideration of the findings of a literature review conducted on behalf of the
Commission by the University of Virginia School of Law’s State and Local Government
Policy Clinic on the advantages of Mayor-Council vs. Council-Manager forms of
government.
• Research and deliberation undertaken by the Electoral Subcommittee of the Commission,
which considered numerous possible models of Council-Manager government in
Richmond before identifying a preferred version of this form of government, as described
below.
The following discussion includes general considerations concerning why a Council-Manager
form of government might be a better option for Richmond than the existing Mayor-Council
system, as well as several Richmond-specific considerations. It then summarizes the specific
reasoning for the Commission’s preferred option (a seven-person Council consisting of six
districted members, led by a Mayor elected at-large via ranked choice voting procedures), which
this report will term the Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option (EMCM).
We begin by noting an important caveat and limitation to the Commission’s work in this area. It
is not possible for Richmond to shift to a Council-Manager form of government, to include a
directly elected Mayor, without adopting new electoral arrangements. Any such changes in turn
will face scrutiny and review under state and federal law to assure the new arrangement protects
the voting rights of minority groups. This Commission is not equipped, nor has it attempted to
undertake, the detailed development of a specific proposal (including proposed maps of new
district lines) in a form that is prepared for legal review of this kind. 60
To be clear: the Commission is not aware of any reason at this time why a shift to the Elected
Mayor Council-Manager Option, as specified below, is not a legally available option. But formal
legal work and scrutiny must be undertaken in a separate process designed specifically for that
60 For a review of relevant procedures in Virginia pursuant to the Voting Rights Act of Virginia adopted in 2 020, see
Senator Jennifer L. McClellan, “The Voting Rights Act of Virginia: Overcoming a History of Voter
Discrimination,” 26 Richmond Public Interest Law Review 111 (2023), especially pp. 149-153.
77
purpose, and it is possible that this scrutiny would either identify a reason the option cannot be
adopted or uncover good reasons for preferring an alternative model.61
In the absence of a well-specified model that has already undergone thorough legal review and
expert vetting, it would be irresponsible for the Commission to simply recommend a blanket
change. The precise structure a Council-Manager form of government takes is critically
important, and may impact its desirability vis-à-vis continuing with the Mayor-Council form of
government. People may reasonably prefer one kind of Council-Manager model to Mayor-
Council, but prefer Mayor-Council government to a different model of Council-Manager
government.
This is one of the key reasons why the Commission is not recommending a change in
Richmond’s form of government, but rather continued serious exploration of such a change, as
outlined at the conclusion of this section.
General Considerations Regarding Form of Government
Both review of relevant literature and the Commission’s own deliberations and evaluation of
available data suggest several general reasons why Council-Manager form of government may
be desirable for Richmond’s future.
61 Mr. Walter Erwin has delineated the steps that Richmond would need to take to effect a change in its voting
system in his memorandum for the Commission, quoted here at length. See Appendix G for the full memorandum.
“A city can seek to change its election system when the demographic characteristics of the locality have changed.
For example, a new census may show that the city's minority population has decreased throughout all or a portion
of a city, which would justify changes in the election process.
Federal and state election laws would allow Richmond to change its current nine district election system. However,
any changes to the current election system could be challenged on the grounds that the changes violate the
provisions of the Civil Rights Act. In order to change the current election system, the City will have the burden of
demonstrating that: (1) the changes to the current election system are not motivated by a racially discriminatory
purpose, and (2) the new election system will not have a retrogressive effect, that is, the City's minority voters will
not be "worse off' under the new election plan.
In the 2013 in the case of Shelby County v. Holder, 570 U.S. 529 (2013), the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the
preclearance requirements of the Voting Rights Act. Consequently, any changes to Richmond's election system will
no longer have to be approved by the U.S. Justice Department or the Federal District Court for the District of
Columbia.
However, in 2021 the Virginia General Assembly amended the Virginia Code to require that any locality that has a
voting-age population containing two or more racial or ethnic groups, each constituting at least 20 percent of the
voting-age population must obtain preclearance approval from the Virginia Attorney General before making changes
to its election districts. Any changes to Richmond's current election system will have to be approved by the Attorney
General….
If the City decides to pursue changes to the current election system, it should work with an election law attorney
and a statistician to create an appropriate record to demonstrate that the new election system will not have a
retrogressive effect and that the new election system will not dilute the voting strength the City minority population
enjoys under the current election system.”
78
1. Reducing Conflict and Making the Work of Government More Straightforward
The first reason is this: the familiar checks-and-balances model of multi-branch government
familiar from the state and federal government and from civic textbooks is not necessarily the
best model for local government.
Local governments typically deal with a common set of issues on which citizens want and expect
effective action: education and youth programs, housing, public safety, infrastructure provision,
and service provision (i.e. utilities, sanitation). Economic opportunity, workforce development,
and wealth building more generally are also major concerns in cities (like Richmond) which have
elevated poverty rates compared to their neighbors.
Generally speaking, there is broad agreement among City residents on what they want city
government to provide. The survey conducted for the Commission found a high level of
agreement across districts on the priorities of affordable housing, housing more generally,
education, and public safety, and many respondents also mentioned issues related to poverty and
economic opportunity. (In contrast, at the state and federal level, there is often deep
disagreement on the purposes and priorities of government; the checks-and-balances model is
intended to make it hard to move too quickly in one direction or another. At the local level, that
same framework can inhibit timely action on urgent, widely acknowledged problems.)
Under a Council-Manager form of government, the process for developing and implementing
policies to address these needs has three major steps:
1. Council deliberates on a proposed course of action of policy direction to address some
particular problem or problems. Council may seek input from the professional staff on
courses of action or other relevant information, but remains the policy-making body.
2. Via ordinance or resolution, the Council directs the City Manager and subordinate staff to
take some particular course of action.
3. After a reasonable amount of time, the Council evaluates both the effectiveness of the
professional staff in implementing the course of action and the impact of the course of
action in addressing the problem or problems.
In the Mayor-Council form of government, matters are often more complicated.
1. Following internal deliberation with the professional administrative staff, the Mayor
proposes a course of action. The proposal becomes the official position of the
administration.
2. The Council may ask questions about the course of action, but is unlikely to receive
information from the professional staff that may cast doubt on the proposed course of
action.
3. Council deliberates on the proposal using the information at its disposal and votes either
in favor or against the proposal. In some cases, it might be possible to negotiate
alterations to the proposal with the Mayor as a condition of its acceptance.
4. Via ordinance and resolution, the Council directs the administration to take the action.
79
5. After a reasonable amount of time, the Council may request information about
implementation of the action and/or its success. The information it receives in response to
this request often will be filtered or channeled through the Mayor’s Office and/or the
CAO.
Further, the very format of the Mayor-Council form of government may heighten conflict and
politicization of issues. In a conversation or deliberation among equals, persons with different
perspectives on a proposed course of action may often through the exchange of views either find
ways to improve the course of action by taking account of nuances or perspectives lacking from
the original proposal, or finding avenues for acceptable compromises that allow productive
action to proceed.
In the Mayor-Council form of government, a proposal once publicly announced becomes a test
of the Mayor’s strength (or from the standpoint of an adversarial Council member, the Mayor’s
weakness). The conversation can then quickly become about “the fight,” rather than about the
issue itself. The strategic deployment or withholding of information in order to win those
“fights” can soon become a norm, corroding trust between the Council and the Administration
over time.
Council often finds itself in a no-win situation. If it is largely supportive of the Mayor’s
initiatives, it is charged with failing to hold the administration accountable and operating a
rubber stamp factory. If it is critical or skeptical of the Mayor’s initiatives, it is charged with
being obstructionist.
In short, a Mayor-Council system adds a layer of complexity to the policymaking process that
can invite conflict and mean more energy in City Hall is spent on political drama compared to
the work of policy development, implementation and evaluation. Arguably residents would be
better served and the City could make faster progress on its core problems with a simpler, less
conflict-prone policy process.
2. Administrative Stability
A second consideration is the challenge of maintaining long-term administrative stability under
the Mayor-Council form of government, especially in comparison to neighboring Chesterfield
and Henrico Counties who have well-established legacies of long-term stability in key
administrative positions. The current County Administrator of Chesterfield County and County
Manager of Henrico Counties have served in their current roles for seven years and ten years,
respectively. Their predecessors served for nine years and twenty-one years, respectively. To
date, the longest-serving Chief Administrative Officer in Richmond since the adoption of the
Mayor-Council form of government served just over five years.
Structural reasons make it challenging to have long-term stable administrative leadership under
the Mayor-Council form of government. Appointment of a Chief Administrative Officer is one
of two primary powers Mayors are given under the Charter to direct the work of city
government, and it should not be surprising that Mayors on occasion elect to use it. Conversely,
80
top administrators near the end of a mayoral term may begin to seek other positions, recognizing
that they may lose their positions when a new Mayor is elected.
It is difficult to make sustained progress on either policy or organizational challenges when the
political cycle creates the possibility if not probability of administrative resets every four or eight
years. A more stable administrative environment in turn might make it easier for Richmond to
retain outstanding public servants at all levels of the organization.
3. Cost of Government
A third general consideration is the issue of cost. In the Mayor-Council form of government,
there is need for a Mayor’s Office and an Office of the Chief Administrative Officer; but also for
a substantial City Council staff to include policy and budget analysts. Council requires such
analysts in the Mayor-Council system of government because otherwise they would lack
resources to independently examine the administration’s proposals; the staff reporting to the
Chief Administrative Officer and the Mayor have a vested interest in supporting the
administration’s position on any given issue.
In a Council-Manager form of government, there is need for an office of the City Manager and
for a smaller Council staff focused primarily on the legislative process and constituent relations.
In a well-functioning Council-Manager system the Council should be able to trust the
information received from the agency-based professional staff, as the staff reports to the City
Manager who reports directly to Council; and to the extent the system is not well-functioning in
that manner, Council has the power to install a new City Manager.
Cost of government is also relevant in instances when the Mayor directs the administrative staff
to spend substantial time and resources on policy initiatives or projects that need Council
approval, only for Council in the end to reject the proposal. In a well-functioning Council-
Manager system, Council has greater capacity to ask more front-end questions of proposed
projects, and can authorize additional expenditure of resources on a step-by-step basis during the
project development process.
4. Transparency
Finally, Council-Manager systems tend to produce a greater degree of transparency (when well-
functioning). As noted, under Mayor-Council systems of government information provided by
agency employees to Council is often vetted through the Chief Administrative Officer or the
Mayor’s Office. There are good reasons from the administration’s point of view for this practice:
to assure consistency of messaging, to prevent agency heads from trying to reach separate “side
deals” with Council members, and to make sure the administration’s priorities are emphasized.
This practice can come at the cost of transparency and create a culture in which volunteering or
sharing unflattering information or data that might be in tension with stated positions is strongly
discouraged. This dynamic in turn can encourage frustrated Council members to adopt a more
adversarial position, exacerbating the likelihood of conflict.
81
None of these dynamics are specific to Richmond or the personalities involved in Richmond’s
governance in recent decades. The National Civic League’s Model City Charter anticipates much
of the above in its summary statement about the challenges with Mayor-Council government:
The council in the council-manager form is a true governing body, not just a legislative
body that checks the mayor. The council sets policy, of course, but it also sets goals and
priorities, reviews and revises policy proposals, and oversees the performance of the
manager and staff. The council chooses the city manager—the appointed chief executive
officer—who is the best qualified applicant from across the country to achieve the vision
the council has established for the city, and monitors the manager’s performance. The
council conducts real oversight through review of extensive information provided by the
city manager.
…. Council decisions are built on the comprehensive and objective information and
advice from the city manager that is provided to all of the council members and to the
public. This kind of communication contributes to the inherent transparency of the
council-manager form…
In the mayor-council form the council’s role may be limited to reacting to the mayor’s
proposals based on information provided by the mayor. The oversight role can be
constrained by limits on the performance data that the mayor will permit departments to
provide to the council. A council member could be the beneficiary of a reward from the
mayor for supporting his/her proposals, but council members could be punished for
taking an independent stand. As is true of separation-of-powers structures at the state
and national level, conflict between the mayor and council is likely and can produce
divisions within the council based on differing levels of allegiance to the mayor.
Disagreement between a majority of the council but fewer than the number needed to
override a mayoral veto and the mayor can produce an impasse. In the council-manager
form, the council is designed to be the governing body.62
Richmond-specific considerations
In addition to those general considerations about form of government, there are several
Richmond-specific considerations that inform the Electoral Subcommittee’s EMCM Option.
1. Positive benefits of the elected Mayor
There are significant potential benefits to having an elected Mayor in a city like Richmond.
While it is instructive to study and learn from the examples of Chesterfield County and Henrico
County, Richmond City is not Chesterfield County or Henrico County. It is a city with deep
challenges and structural inequities. Maintaining the policy status quo in Richmond means
62 National Civic League, Model City Charter, 9th Edition (2021), p. 6.
82
maintaining unjust outcomes in several important areas, from life expectancy to educational
outcomes.
Effective political leadership in Richmond’s context means leadership for change, in recognition
that at any given moment in time many residents are in crisis, and that the City faces more
challenging and severe obstacles than its suburban neighbors. The City does not simply need a
manager who can put the functioning of City government on auto-pilot using tried and true
scripts.
Mayors can supply the needed leadership in two ways: first, by representing the interests of
socially and economically marginalized persons who vote, but may be less likely to lobby City
Hall as frequently as more affluent residents; and second, by developing and building support for
change agendas.
Richmond’s experience with Mayor-Council government provides examples of leadership taking
this form.63 In a Council-Manager form of government that includes an elected Mayor, it would
be desirable to assure the elected Mayor has enough clout and authority to lead on policy, even
though that leadership would take a different form.
2. Collaborative Mayors vs. “Super-Strong Mayors”
As noted in Chapter Five, at the onset of the Mayor-Council form of government in Richmond
some actors believed the city needed a “Super-Strong Mayor” to get a handle on its various long-
standing issues. Under Council-Manager government, the Mayor would lead primarily by
building consensus on Council around policy initiatives, then working with Council colleagues
to hold the administration responsible for effective execution.
The Mayor-Council form of government tends to import a script derived from higher levels of
government to the local level: a Mayor is elected, advocates for the part of the community that
supported their candidacy, and tries to overcome any opposition from one or more Council
members (who in turn may see themselves as representing voters who did not support the
Mayor). Especially when the elected Mayor lacks a strong electoral mandate, each contested
issue tends to become a test of power.
Under a Council-Manager form of government, the Mayor will be judged primarily by their
ability to build consensus with Council colleagues. Not all colleagues will agree with all or most
of a Mayor’s policy agenda, and there will always be political tension and conflict. But
compared to the Mayor-Council form of government, it will be harder for a Council member to
forge a political persona simply based on regularly challenging the Mayor’s initiatives; the
public will judge Council, and all its members, on its ability to deliberate and act effectively
63 New policy tools and initiatives focused specifically on the needs of low-income residents that have emerged
under the Mayor-Council form of government in Richmond include (among others) the Affordable Housing Trust
Fund, the Office of Community Wealth Building, the City of Richmond Ambassadors, and the Richmond Equity
Agenda, as well as numerous community organizations and partnerships supported by City funding. Assessment of
the impact of these initiatives is beyond the scope of this report.
83
together. Likewise, the Mayor will have strong reasons to develop and maintain strong
relationships at all times with all Council members, regardless of policy disagreements.
3. Freeing Mayors from the Burden of Administration
Finally, it should be pointed out that a Mayor who provides leadership in the policy arena and in
presiding over Council under a Council-Manager system would also be free from the burden of
being directly responsible for administrative affairs. This is potentially helpful in two ways:
allowing the elected Mayor to focus on their areas of greatest strength (policy development,
communication, coalition building); and giving the Mayor greater independence to ask tough
questions and call to account administrative problems and issues (since they would no longer
reflect back on their own leadership).
Envisioning a Council-Manager Government for Richmond, led by an Elected Mayor
None of these considerations are decisive, taken alone or together, but they do give sufficient
motivation to ask this question: “If Richmond wanted to go to a Council-Manager form of
government while retaining an elected Mayor, what would that look like?”
The Electoral Subcommittee considered that question and developed the following model. The
Commission as a whole believes this is the most desirable model of Council-Manager
government based on presently available information, pending more formal legal review.
The Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option has these key features:
• A seven-person City Council, to consist of six district representatives and one elected
Mayor, which acts as the city’s governing and policymaking body;
• A City Manager appointed and dismissed by Council collectively, who has day-to-day
responsibility for the administration of government;
• A Mayor elected on a citywide basis via Ranked Choice Voting, who is a full voting
member of Council and presides over Council meetings.
The following account lays out the reasoning for this model with respect to four key issues: role
of and method of election of the Mayor, role of the City Manager, role of the City Attorney,
composition and role of the Council.
Detailed Description of the Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option
I. Mayor.
A. Role.
The Mayor will serve as a member of City Council.
The Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option retains the role of elected Mayor established in
2005. Retaining an elected Mayor will keep in place a decisionmaker in City government who
brings a City-wide perspective, and having the Mayor is a member of City Council ensures that
this City-wide perspective is represented in the policy-making body. Moreover, including the
84
Mayor as part of City Council would eliminate the current structural conflict between City
Council and Mayor cited by stakeholders as a major impediment to good governance. By
bringing the Mayor into the legislative fold of City Council, that existing structural conflict is
removed.
B. Authority.
In the Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option, the Mayor is given significant powers and
duties while serving on City Council, as set forth below.
It is recommended that the Mayor not only have a vote as a member of City Council, but also
have significant authority in leading City Council. Taking the opposite approach, by making the
Mayor a non-voting member of City Council, would render the role largely ineffective.
Moreover, imbuing the Mayor with significant authority within City Council gives the Mayor
the ability to effectuate their unifying, City-wide platform—a primary goal Richmond sought to
achieve in moving to the Mayor-Council structure.
“While the mayor of a council-manager city is not an executive as in the mayor-council form, he
or she is uniquely positioned to be the political and policy leader of the city.”64 The EMCM
Option recommends that the Mayor’s powers and duties include the following, as set forth in
Model City Charter § 2.03(a):
• The Mayor must attend and preside at meetings of City Council.
• The Mayor will represent the City in intergovernmental relationships.
• The Mayor has the power to appoint, with the advice and consent of City Council, the
members of community advisory boards and commissions.
• The Mayor must present an annual State of the City address.
• The Mayor has the power to appoint the members and officers of City Council
committees.
• The Mayor has the power to assign subject to the consent of City Council agenda items
to committees.
• The Mayor may perform other duties specified by City Council.
• The Mayor will be the head of City government for all ceremonial purposes and by the
Governor for purposes of military law.
• Like other Council members, the Mayor will be able to introduce and advocate for
policy legislation.
64 Model City Charter, p. 16.
85
These powers and duties create real and “enormous leadership opportunities.”65 The National
Civic League’s explanation of this point is helpful, as it dovetails with the City’s longstanding
desire for a Mayor to bring a City-wide perspective to the policymaking decisions in City
governance:
First, the mayor may coordinate the activities of other officials by providing
liaison between the city manager and the council, fostering a sense of cohesion
among council members, and educating the public about the needs and prospects
of the city. Second, the mayor may facilitate policy guidance through setting
goals for the council and advocating the adoption of policies that address the
city’s problems. Third, the mayor is an ambassador who promotes the city and
represents it in dealing with other governments as well as the public.66
These powers provide the Mayor sufficient authority and influence to bring a Citywide vision to
bear on City Council. (While not reprinted here, the Model City Charter provides commentary
explaining how the above authority empowers the Mayor in practical terms.) Moreover, while
“the mayor should not encroach on the executive responsibilities of the manager” because “the
mayor is preeminently a legislator, a member, and leader of the council; the mayor is not an
executive,” the recommended structure allows the Mayor to have a close, working relationship
with the City Manager to ensure that an appropriate vision for the City is executed. 67
C. Status; Compensation.
The EMCM Option recommends that the Mayor be a full-time position with pay
commensurate with their importance within City government.
In a City-Council structure, the Mayor is “the presiding officer of [City Council] and ceremonial
head of the [C]ity,” and therefore is “the most conspicuous official of the [C]ity.”68 The mayor
“is the public face of the community who presides at meetings, assigns agenda items to
committees, facilitates communication and understanding between elected and appointed
officials, and assists the governing body in setting goals and advocating policy decisions.”69
Given that the Mayor is the leader of City government within the Council-Manager structure, in
both form and substance, the role cannot be performed on a part-time basis. Additionally,
appropriate compensation is necessary to ensure that the position attracts sufficiently qualified
candidates for office. The Commission recommends that compensation for the Mayor within
the Elected Mayor Council-Manager structure should be no less than current compensation for
the position under the Mayor-Council form of government, or two times greater than the
compensation of other members of Council (whichever number is higher).
65 Model City Charter, p. 16.
66 Model City Charter, p. 16.
67 Model City Charter, p. 17.
68 Model City Charter, p. 16.
69 “Key Roles in Council-Manager Government,” International City/County Management Association (2017).
86
D. Election.
The EMCM Option envisions that the Mayor be elected every four years, in an at-large,
City-wide election that uses instant run-off voting.
Given the significant authority the Mayor retains as head of City Council and the City itself, a
democratic election is appropriate rather than appointment from, and conducted by, existing
members of City Council.
Shifting from nine to six Council districts obviously means that the current five-of-nine district
method for electing the Mayor could no longer be applied. In its place, the EMCM Option
entails adoption of Ranked Choice Voting, which provides an avenue for all voters in all districts
to influence the outcome of the race even if their preferred candidate is not elected.
Indeed, as detailed in Appendix C, significant demographic changes in Richmond over the past
twenty years call into question the future efficacy of the five-of-nine district model in protecting
minority interests and voting power; Ranked Choice Voting may be a superior method for
protecting those interests given Richmond’s current demographics.
Generally stated, instant runoff voting in Virginia encompasses: (1) voters rank candidates in
order of preference, (2) if no candidate gets 50% of the vote in the initial tabulation of first-
preference votes, the candidate who received the least amount of votes is “eliminated” from the
race, and the voters who voted for that eliminated candidate as their first preference have their
votes transferred to their second preference, and (3) that elimination process continues until a
candidate receives more than 50% of the vote, thus winning the election. Instant runoff voting
requires a competent Registrar’s office and a robust public education campaign. The
Commission has confidence in both.
Ranked Choice Voting procedures also address two major challenges in the current system: it
would assure the elected Mayor can claim majority support, and therefore be in better position to
lead and unify the city; and it would eliminate the possibility of a costly run-off election.
E. Deputy Mayor.
It is recommended that City Council elect from its members a Deputy Mayor.
The Deputy Mayor will act as Mayor during the absence of disability of the Mayor and, if a
vacancy occurs, will become Mayor for the remainder of the unexpired term. This scope of
power and method of selection is what the Model City Charter § 2.03(b) recommends, and it
creates an important role in City government with an efficient means of selection relative to the
position.
II. City Manager.
A. Appointment; Retention.
The EMCM Option recommends that the City Manager be selected, appointed, and
retained at the pleasure and direction of City Council.
87
It is recommended that City Council, by majority vote of City Council’s total members, appoint
a City Manager for an indefinite term and fix the City Manager’s compensation. The City
Council should be able to remove a City Manager, who refuses to resign, by a majority vote of
City Council’s total members only after adequate and written notice of the reasons for
suspension and opportunity to be heard.
A City Manager is key to a Council-Manager plan. The EMCM Option embraces the
qualifications of requiring a majority vote of the entire City Council, and for specifying an
indefinite term.
Moreover, City Council should have ultimate authority in the retention of the City Manager.
That said, the Charter should specify that the City Manager have opportunity to consider and
respond to any reasons for termination to “assur[e] that any unjust charges will come to light
and be answered.”70
B. Qualifications.
The EMCM Option recommends that City Council impose qualification standards for the
City Manager, with an industry-approved baseline imposed by the Charter.
The EMCM Option recommends that the Charter direct City Council to appoint the City
Manager based solely on education and experience in the accepted competencies and practices
of local government management, with attention to how the City Manager expresses support for
and enacts social equity. Moreover, the Charter should direct City Council to enact an ordinance
that sets the minimum qualifications for any City Manager. The Charter should also specify that
any such ordinance must set qualifications that meet a minimum standard, to assure residents
that the City Manager will be adequately qualified.
The minimum qualification standard set forth in the Charter need not be a specific set of
qualifications, but might instead reference the model qualifications in the most recent edition of
the Model City Charter published by the National Civic League. This allows for the minimum
standards for a City Manager’s qualifications to evolve over time, without needing to amend the
Charter, as experts in the field might reach consensus about whether those minimum standards
should change. The current version of these model qualifications reads:
A master’s degree with a concentration in public administration, public affairs or
public policy and two years’ experience in an appointed managerial or
administrative position in a local government or a bachelor’s degree and 5 years
of such experience.71
C. Authority.
In the EMCM Option, the City Manager is the chief executive officer.
70 Model City Charter, p. 28.
71 Model City Charter, p. 27.
88
The City Manager should be responsible to City Council for managing all City affairs placed in
the City Manager’s charge by or under the Charter. The City Manager, in overseeing the daily
administration of City government, should have powers and duties explicitly set forth in the
Charter. Those powers and duties should include, as set forth in Model City Charter § 3.04:
• The City Manager can appoint, suspend, and remove all city employees and appointive
administrative officers provided for by or under the Charter, except as otherwise
provided by law, the Charter or personnel rules adopted pursuant to the Charter.
• The City Manager must direct and supervise the admi nistration of all departments,
offices, and agencies of the City, except as otherwise provided by the Charter or by
law.
• The City Manager must attend all City Council meetings. The City Manager has the
right to take part in discussion but may not vote.
• The City Manager must see that all laws, provisions of the Charter, and acts of City
Council, subject to enforcement by the City Manager or by officers subject to the City
Manager’s direction and supervision, are faithfully executed.
• The City Manager must prepare and submit the annual budget and capital program to
City Council, and implement the final budget approved by City Council to achieve the
goals of the City.
• The City Manager must submit to City Council, and make available and accessible to
the public, a complete report on the finances and administrative activities of the City
as of the end of each fiscal year, and provide information needed by City Council for
its annual evaluation of performance.
• The City Manager must make available and accessibl e such other reports relating to
operations as City Council may require.
• The City Manager must keep City Council fully advised as to the financial condition
and future needs of the City.
• The City Manager must make recommendations to City Council concerning the affairs
of the City and facilitate the work of City Council in developing policy.
• The City Manager must provide staff support services for the Mayor and City Council
Members.
• The City Manager must assist City Council to develop long term goals for the City and
strategies to implement these goals.
• The City Manager must encourage and provide staff support for partnerships with
community organizations and for regional and intergovernmental cooperation and
equitable programming.
89
• The City Manager must promote partnerships among City Council, staff, and
community members in developing public policy and building a sense of community.
• The City Manager must perform such other duties as are specified in the Charter or
may be required by City Council.72
III. City Attorney.
A. General.
In the EMCM Option, the City Attorney is the chief legal counsel for the entire City and all
its constituents (officers, employees, departments, boards, etc.).
In the EMCM Option, the City Attorney is the chief legal officer for the City, including all the
City’s “constituents,” including City Council, the Mayor, the City Manager, and all City
departments, boards, commissions, and agencies.
This recommendation does not substantively change the current City Charter. Under the current
City structure, the City Attorney is viewed as having to play favorites between City Council and
the Mayor, and having too much power over the Mayor and city administration without those
stakeholders’ involvement in the selection and retention of City Attorney. However, by bringing
the Mayor into City Council, the City Attorney no longer has a “conflict” (whether real or
perceived) in representing equal yet independent stakeholders who may take opposing views on
issues.
B. Appointment; Retention.
The EMCM Option recommends that the City Attorney be selected, appointed, and
retained at the pleasure and direction of City Council.
This recommendation does not change the current City Charter. The City Manager should have
no role in the selection, appointment, or retention process of the City Attorney. City Council, as
the policy-making body of the City, should have sole authority over both the City Manager and
the City Attorney. This allows the City Manager and City Attorney to have a degree of
independence of one another, which for purposes of the City Attorney makes clear that the City
Attorney is ultimately responsive to City Council. The City Attorney therefore has the
independence to provide legal counsel to city administration, through the City Manager, while
also ensuring that this counsel ultimate reflects City Council’s priorities.
IV. City Council.
A. Authority.
In the EMCM Option, the City Council retains all powers vested in the City.
72 Model City Charter, pp. 28-29.
90
This recommendation does not change the current City Charter, but alongside the other
recommended changes, City Council will be the focal point for City policy.
B. Size.
The EMCM Option envisions that City Council districts be reduced from nine to six, with a
total of seven City Council votes when considering the at-large Mayor.
The Committee extensively discussed the appropriate size and composition of City Council.
Stakeholders expressed frustration with the at-times unwieldy nature of nine members of
Council. Others expressed skepticism at the ability of a City Manager to be able to adequately
manage expectations from nine different members. When considering comparable Virginia
localities, Richmond has one of the larger elected bodies. (Virginia Code requires that the
governing bodies of localities have between 3 and 11 members.)
Adding a Mayor to the existing nine-member City Council would result in Council having 10
votes (9 Council Members each representing a district, plus 1 Mayor). A Council with an even
number of voting members is not advisable.
To reach an odd number of votes on City Council, the Subcommittee considered three options:
(1) adding electoral districts; (2) removing the Mayor’s vote; and (3) removing electoral
districts. Each of these options, however, has some negative value. First, the Subcommittee sees
no benefit in adding another electoral district so that City Council has eleven votes. There is no
indication that City Council has too few seats, and adding more votes would only exacerbate the
perceived challenges with the current size. Second, to strip the Mayor of a vote on City Council
(to keep the total votes at 9) would be to improperly render the office ineffective for the City’s
goals in having a Mayor. Third, reducing the number of electoral districts would present fewer
political opportunities and may create more expensive campaigns.
After considering these points and related concerns, the EMCM Option developed by the
Subcommittee entails reducing the size of City Council to achieve an odd number of votes on
City Council. Reducing the number of Council districts, and therefore the number of Council
Members, would address the concerns of a too-large City Council voiced by stakeholders.
Moreover, fewer electoral districts may create competitive races for each seat of City Council.
(Historically, 7 of 36 of Council regular election races since the adoption of the four-year in
Council term in 2008 have been noncompetitive, defined as only one candidate appearing on the
ballot.)73 Competitive elections are critical to a well-functioning democracy.
To that end, the EMCM Option reduces the number of districts to six, for several reasons.
Numerous cities in Virginia (and neighboring states) of similar size to Richmond have seven-
person Councils including an elected Mayor.74 Reducing the number of districts will enlarge
each district, and therefore each district-based member of City Council will have a broader
“home base” perspective as their respective districts grow. Fewer members of City Council
73 See https://historical.elections.virginia.gov/ for historical results of Council races since 2008.
74 Norfolk (235,000 persons) has a 7-member Council plus an elected Mayor who presides over Council. Newport
News (185,000 persons) has a 7-member Council including an elected Mayor. Alexandria (155,000 persons) has a 7 -
member Council including an elected Mayor. Durham, NC (286,000) has a 7 -person Council including an elected
Mayor. Mobile, AL (185,000) and Shreveport, LA (184,000) are Mayor -Council cities with 7-person Councils.
91
means less cost, more streamlined government, and less potential for personalities to complicate
City governance. Moreover, the 2011 Mayor’s Redistricting Advisory Committee noted that
several benefits can result from “starting over from scratch in drawing the City’s electoral
map,” which would be required when reducing the number of districts. The new districts could
be drawn to have “both poverty rates close to the city average and substantial internal
diversity.” Moreover, districts could be redrawn in a way “encourage the political
incorporation of the Hispanic community,” which could equally apply to other discrete
communities of interest. 75
All these reasons support the recommendation of reducing the number of electoral districts (and
district-elected Members of City Council) to six. The Commission in response to the initial
presentation of this proposal heard several comments from residents expressing concern about
the reduction in the number of districts. The Commission agrees that with larger districts it will
be more challenging for Council members to maintain close contact with neighborhood leaders,
but believe this could be mitigated by higher Council pay and bolstering Council staff capacity.
The Commission disagrees with claims that a smaller Council to include an elected Mayor
would “reduce” representation, for three reasons. First, while there would be fewer Council
members, each individual Council member would have more influence as one of seven rather
than one of nine voting members. Second, each resident would in fact have two representatives
on Council: their district representative, and the citywide elected Mayor. Third, whereas Council
members have minimal direct leverage on the day-to-day operations of the City administration
under the current system, in the Council-Manager system each member would have significant
opportunity to hold the City Manager and staff accountable for performance and service
delivery.
Finally, it should be reiterated that a smaller Council would give greater scope for the elected
Mayor to lead and build coalitions on policy matters within a Council-Manager form of
government, consistent with the decision Richmond voters made in 2005 to establish the elected
Mayor. An elected Mayor who does not have the practical capacity to run on, be elected, and
enact a citywide agenda, because they are just one vote on a fairly large Council, adds little
value, and creates the significant possibility that Council business will be driven excessively by
district-level interests. Under Council-Manager government, the elected Mayor is no longer the
chief executive officer; but as leader of a seven-person Council, would have significant
opportunity to build consensus on Council around a policy agenda responsive to the needs of
voters and all city residents.
C. Terms.
The EMCM Option recommends four-year, staggered terms for district-wide elections.
The EMCM Option recommends that staggering of terms should be implemented, such that the
Mayor and three district representatives are elected at one time, and the other three
representatives are elected two years later. Guidelines should be set either to allow an incumbent
Council member to run for Mayor and for Council re-election simultaneously, or to require an
incumbent Council member to resign their seat to run for Mayor, so that all Council members
75 Mayor’s Advisory Committee on Redistricting, 2011.
92
are on equal footing with respect to ability to run for Mayor. (See Chapter Eight for further
discussion.)
6.03. D. Status; Compensation.
The EMCM Option recommends that non-mayoral members of City Council be a part-
time position with pay commensurate with their importance within City government.
The Commission believes that Virginia’s tradition of the citizen-legislator is appropriately
maintained for the district-wide elected members of City Council. It recognizes, however, that
the current salaries of these members of City Council should be increased to reflect the realities
of modern costs of living. The EMCM Option recommends that salaries of the non-Mayor
members of City Council match the median household income for the City (currently
approximately $55,000).
Next Steps in Considering Council-Manager form of Government
The identification of an Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option that has a strong prospect of
combining the strengths of Council-Manager government with scope for effective Mayoral
leadership in support of a citywide vision is a significant and helpful step. The Electoral
Subcommittee and the Commission as a whole have invested careful thought into developing and
refining the concept presented above. Appendix C provides further detailed analysis of one key
component of the proposal, adoption of a ranked choice voting method of electing the Mayor, in
light of the demographic changes in the city over the past twenty years.
Nonetheless, numerous additional steps need to take place before this concept becomes an
actionable option for Richmond city government. These include:
• Extensive public education and outreach to engage more city residents in this discussion,
so that residents can both have the opportunity to weigh in and the opportunity to become
fully informed well in advance of a potential referendum;
• Extensive review of the proposal from the standpoint of state and federal voting rights
law, to include detailed assessment of Richmond’s current demographics as well as the
provisional drawing of sample maps for a six-district City Council, to maximize
confidence that the finalized proposal would meet all relevant legal standards;
• Development of specific enabling Charter language (drawing where possible from the
current report) with attention to other Charter changes that should be enacted at the same
time;
• Development of specific language/questions for a potential referendum;
• Development of a provisional voter education plan to assure all City residents are aware
of the electoral changes, including the potential change to Ranked Choice Voting, and to
assure all residents are fully prepared and can take full advantage of the new system, to
be enacted in the event an advisory referendum passes;
• Development of a provisional organizational transition plan, to work through the
organizational issues, to include any needed ordinances or Charter adjustments, to
transition to a Council-Manager form of government while maintaining continuity of all
93
operations and services, and to establish new legislative procedures as may be necessary
for the smooth implementation of the new system, to be enacted in the event an advisory
referendum passes;
• Development of a provisional process and timeline for the drawing of new Council
district lines in accordance with state and federal law, to be enacted in the event an
advisory referendum passes;
• Engagement with Richmond School Board concerning the implications of the proposal
for the composition and method of election of the School Board and/or needed
amendments to Charter section 20.01 if the number of Council districts changes.
This is a significant scope of work that will require dedicated resources and attention to
complete with thoroughness and care. Consequently, this Commission recommends that the
City Council act by December 15, 2023 to create an ad hoc Electoral Transition Commission
to undertake the work delineated above.76
The envisioned Electoral Transition Commission should have the following composition,
charge, and timeline.
Composition
• To consist of no fewer than nine and no more than fifteen city residents, to include one
from each voting district; to include at least one representative of an organization
historically concerned with protecting the voting rights of Black city residents; to include
at least one representative of an organization engaged in advocacy on behalf of Latino
city residents; and to include (if available to serve) at least one and no more than three
members of the 2022 City Charter Review Commission. The composition of the
commission should reflect the city’s diversity and the equitable representation of
communities of interest.
• The Commission will be supported by the City Attorney and staff, City Council staff, and
professional and legal expertise in the areas of voting rights law, demographics and
statistical analysis, and mapping,
Charge
• To develop actionable language for a future advisory referendum on transitioning the
form of government to a Council-Manager system, to include an elected Mayor who sits
on Council.
• To undertake each of the additional specific steps noted just above, with support from
professional staff and expertise, and to document carefully all actions taken with respect
to electoral proposals.
• The Commission will take as its starting point the EMCM Option for Council-Manager
government specified by the City Charter Review Commission, but may make any
76 Under the City Charter (3.06.1), an advisory referendum regarding a charter change can either be called for by
City Council, or can be placed on the ballot via a petition campaign of registered voters in the City.
94
adjustments to the proposal as it sees fit, or as it is advised to make by professional and
legal experts. Any changes and the reason for the modifications will be fully documented.
• To provide for significant public participation, to include one more or public hearings
prior to finalization of the Committee recommendations. Council should allocate
sufficient resources to assure inclusive and representative participation citywide.
Timeline and Process
• The final recommendation from the Commission for language for an advisory
referendum is to be adopted by a majority vote of all voting members. If no specific
recommendation gains majority support from the Electoral Transition Commission, this
result must be conveyed to Council.
• Council should in the ordinance establishing the Commission establish a timeline for the
Electoral Transition Commission’s work, with the possibility of an extension. The City
Charter Review Commission believes it is possible to complete the scope of work
described above in time for holding an advisory referendum in 2024. There may be good
reasons for taking additional time; however, the Charter Review Commission believes
that to enact a change in the form of government to begin with the term commencing
January 1, 2029, such an advisory referendum should take place at the very latest in the
2026 general election with a view to General Assembly approving the new provisions in
2027. This timeline is necessary to allow for an orderly and effective organizational
transition as well as to educate the public on the forthcoming changes.
• The ordinance should obligate Council, whether the current Council or the Council
elected in 2024, to consider and vote yes or no on moving forward with the Advisory
Referendum based on the Electoral Transition Commission’s recommendation within
sixty days of receipt of the recommendation. The ordinance should further specify that
while Council may provide input to the Electoral Transition Commission’s work process,
once the report is received it must vote on the Commission’s recommendation in the form
and substance in which they are presented, without substantive amendment.77
77 This is an important provision insofar as the Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option presented in this report
envisions a reduction in the number of Council seats from nine to six. It is obviously challenging for a sitting
Council to reduce the number of its own seats. Requiring the Council to vote on the recommendations as they are
received would pre-empt Council from amending the recommendations to preserve the existing Council size,
without at least taking an on-the-record vote to reject the Commission’s recommendations. If the Commission
recommendation were rejected, the Council would of course retain the power to place an alternative Charter change
proposal on the ballot.
95
Chapter Eight. Recommendations, IV: Adoption of Staggered Council Terms
Finally, the Commission recommends staggered Council terms (8-1) to increase stability in the
governing body. While staggered terms are a feature of the proposal described in Chapter Seven,
they could also be adopted within the existing Mayor-Council structure.
Regardless of form of government, staggered terms are helpful by assuring continuity of
processes and protocols and assuring that most or all sources of valuable institutional knowledge
are not lost simultaneously following any single election. Mid-term elections of several Council
seats would also assure residents have the opportunity to provide meaningful feedback on the
direction and performance of city government every two years.
Adoption of staggered Council terms will require addressing several issues:
1. Like any change in the City’s electoral process, adoption of staggered Council terms
must be shown to comply with relevant state and federal law. If Council wishes to
consider moving forward, it should notify the City Attorney as soon as possible and
request a legal analysis to identify any potential issues with this shift and to create a
documentary record concerning why the City is considering this electoral change.
2. The Council must decide whether four or five Council seats are to be elected at the
same time as the Mayor (with the remainder elected two years later).
3. The Council must decide which districts are to be elected at the same time as the
Mayor and which elected two years later.
4. The Council must decide whether to adopt provisions that do not advantage or
disadvantage Council members who may wish to run for Mayor on the basis of which
district they represent.
5. The Council must decide on a timeline for implementation of staggered terms.
6. Under Virginia general law, School Board members are to be elected at the same time
as Council representatives, unless a specific exception has been created in the Code of
Virginia. Charter provision 20.01 also provides that School Board elections are to
happen in Richmond at the same time as Council elections. Hence, Council’s
adoption of staggered terms will necessitate that School Board adopt staggered terms
(and the same timing for districts) at the same time, unless the Charter is amended
and/or an exception is created in the Code of Virginia. Consequently, it is advisable
that Council inform and engage the School Board if it wishes to move forward with
staggered Council terms.
With respect to issue #2 above, the Commission believes it probably is beneficial to elect a
majority of the Council at the same time Mayors are elected. With respect to issue #3, the
Commission believes the Council should come to an agreement by consensus or create an
agreed-upon, fair process for deciding the specific timing of each district’s election.
With respect to issue #4, the concern is that with staggered terms, representatives of some
Council districts (those whose district elections do not take place at the same time as the Mayor)
would be able to run for Mayor without giving up their Council seat, and some would not. This
discrepancy seems unfair and unwise, and if not addressed may become a significant issue over
time. There are three possible approaches to remedy that concern:
96
a. Create language in the Charter that allows an incumbent to run for re-election as a
Council member and for Mayor at the same time. (If a Council member exercised this
provision and won the office of Mayor, a special election would need to be called to fill
the Council seat.)
b. Create language in the Charter that requires a Council member to resign their seat in
order to run for Mayor, effective no later than July 1 of the year of the mayoral election.
(This would then require Council to appoint a resident or call a special election to fill the
seat for the remainder of the term, depending on the length of time remaining in the
term.) Chesapeake, VA is an example of a city taking this approach, which is common in
Virginia cities with both directly elected mayors and staggered council terms.
c. Shift all Council elections on to a different timeline than the Mayoral election. For
instance, the Mayoral election would take place on an even year, and the Council
elections on odd years. (Such an approach would impact voter turnout, and it would be
unusual for the legislative and executive branches to have terms of office that were not
synced to one another.)
The Commission believes Council should deliberate on the best approach to this issue before
implementing staggered terms. Option b) specified above perhaps entails fewer potential
complications than the other approaches, but in this case the most important consideration is that
Council reach consensus on approach that is widely agreed as fair.
The question of creating a timeline for implementation (issue #6) is also ultimately a matter for
Council deliberation. The Commission believes there should be lengthy lead time provided
before making this change so that it is fully transparent both to voters and to potential candidates
the length of terms that will be at stake in each election. At this point in the cycle, it would be
reasonable to plan on implementation of staggered terms beginning in 2028.
However, it would be beneficial to seek charter change in 2024 on this issue, to take effect in
2028, so that Council members elected in 2024 will start their terms in January 2025 with this
matter a settled issue.
For that reason, the Commission recommends that Council act by October 1 to create a
special committee to address the issues noted above and make recommendations for
addressing them by no later than November 1, 2023, so that staggered terms may be included
in Council’s legislative package for January 2024 along with the other Charter changes
recommended by this Commission.
97
Chapter Nine. Next Steps and Concluding Observations
The Charter Review Commission was charged by Richmond City Council with undertaking a
comprehensive assessment of the City Charter, with particular attention to questions pertaining
to the form of government.
This report fulfills that charge in three ways:
• By identifying over forty recommended deletions, amendments, or additions to the
Charter to remove unnecessary or outdated language, make the Charter more consistent
with the existing Mayor-Council form of government, make the Charter more consistent
with state general law and practice, and to address specific concerns noted by the
Commission or brought to its attention. (See Chapter Five.)
• By identifying a coherent package of alterations to the existing Mayor-Council form of
government intended to better clarify and specify the roles and responsibilities of each
actor, according to a Partnership Model. (See Chapter Six.) The Commission believes
those recommendations could significantly improve the practical function of the Mayor-
Council model and address some of the persistent frustrations addressed by stakeholders
on all sides. So long as Richmond retains this system of government, residents should
want both Mayors and Councils to be successful; success almost all of the time consists
in finding the right balance between constructive collaboration and healthy dialogue and
deliberation about disputed questions.
• By identifying an alternative pathway forward for Richmond city government that
combines the advantages of Council-Manager government with the continued need for
strong citywide leadership from an elected Mayor. While the Commission does not make
a recommendation for or against adoption of a Council-Manager system led by an elected
Mayor, it believes Council should give serious consideration to this pathway. The
Commission has outlined specific steps that would need to be taken if Council wishes to
move forward with the idea. (See Chapter Seven.)
It is the Commission’s hope that this report, taken as a whole, can both contribute to short-term
improvements in the Charter and in institutional practice, and also stimulate broader civic
conversation about the future of the city.
In this final section, we provide a brief timeline by which Council may take (or refuse to take)
action on the Commission’s recommendations.
• August: Submission of Charter Review Report to Council
• September-October: Council and Administration review of recommendations from
Chapters Five and Chapter Six, with particular focus on discussion among stakeholders
regarding the ideas in Chapter Six for adjusting the Mayor-Council form of government;
development of legislation for changing the Charter during the 2024 session of General
Assembly. Council should also establish an ad hoc committee to resolve questions
pertaining to the implementation of staggered Council terms beginning in 2028 if it
wishes to bring that recommendation forward. (See Chapter Eight.)
98
• November-December: Discussion of ideas regarding Council-Manager form of
government inclusive of an elected Mayor, and decision by December 15 regarding
whether to move forward with establishment of an Electoral Transition Commission.
• January 2024 and continuing: Introduction of Charter changes (from Chapters Five and
Chapters Six) to Virginia General Assembly.
• January-July 2024 (or later): Work of the Electoral Transition Commission, if
established, according to timelines to be established by ordinance.
We urge City Council and the Administration to focus its initial attention on serious
consideration of the reform ideas contained in Chapter Six, along with the document
improvements of Chapter Five. Unless or until Richmond changes its form of government, all
residents and stakeholders have a clear interest in seeking to improve the workings of the
existing Mayor-Council government. The Charter Review process and its timing gives the City a
chance to adopt significant reforms, some of which have been called for nearly since the system
was implemented twenty years ago, so that the next Mayor and next Council has a refreshed set
of rules in place at the start of their terms on January 1, 2025. To take advantage of that
opportunity, Council and the Administration should prioritize serious and frank discussion about
the ideas presented here, motivated by this question: will these changes help the Mayor be more
successful as chief executive officer, help the Council be more successful as the governing body,
and help city government as a whole function better?
The Commission believes it is appropriate for the Council-Manager discussion to take place on a
longer time scale, for reasons already articulated in Chapter Seven. But we also believe it is in
the City’s best interests to have this discussion, whatever its outcome. It is a large statement to
say that Richmond should continue as the only city in Virginia with a Mayor-Council form of
government indefinitely into the future. It is also a large statement to say that Richmond should
change its form of government again two decades after the most recent alteration, and that the
costs of doing so would be outweighed by its benefits.
Both the Mayor-Council and the Council-Manager systems offer plausible theories of local
democratic government, and predictable strengths and weaknesses, many of which have been
noted at various points in this report. To choose between the two involves both a philosophical
judgement concerning how much authority to invest in an individual position as opposed to a
collective body, as well as a practical judgment about which system is likely to be most effective
in meeting the needs of the people, in a particular place at a particular time.
Those complex judgments, the Commission submits, are best made by the people. But it is
important that from time to time they have the right to make those judgments, informed by but
not bound by the past, in hopes of creating a better shared future for the residents of this City.
99
Appendix A. List of Recommendations
See full report for explanation of each item.
Document Improvements
5-1. Replace Section 2.01 (General grant of powers) with updated language
Striking specific financial powers established by general law
5-2. Strike 2.02(b)
5-3. Strike 2.02 (c)
5-4. Strike 2.02 (e)
5-5. Strike 2.02 (f)
5-6. Strike 2.02 (g)
Striking specific powers to preserve the general welfare established by general law or not under the jurisdiction
of local government
5-7. Strike 2.04 (a)
5-8. Strike 2.04 (b)
5-9. Strike 2.04 (d)
5-10. Strike 2.04 (e)
5-11. Strike 2.04 (f)
5-12. Strike 2.04 (g)
5-13. Strike 2.04 (h)
5-14. Strike 2.04 (i)
5-15. Strike 2.04 (j)
5-16. Strike 2.04 (k)
5-17. Strike 2.04 (l)
5-18. Strike 2.04 (m)
5-19. Strike 2.04 (n)
5-20. Strike 2.04 (o)
5-21. Strike 2.04 (p)
5-22. Strike 2.04 (q)
5-23. Strike 2.04 (r)
Striking miscellaneous powers established by general law
5-24. Strike 2.05(b)
5-25. Strike 2.05 (c)
100
5-26. Strike 2.05 (d)
5-27. Strike 2.05 (g)
Strike section on regulations: powers named are established by general law
5-28. Strike 2.06
5-29. Amend 3.04.1 (c) to remove misdemeanor drug offenses and “moral turpitude” as cause for removal of Mayor
or Council member.
5-30. Amend 4.06 to require Council to follow parliamentary procedure.
5-31. Amend 4.07 to allow Council to cast votes in meetings electronically.
5-32. Amend 4.09 to allow introduced ordinances to be distributed electronically.
5-33. Add section 4.14.1 to stipulate that Council establishes composition of boards and commissions by ordinance.
5-34. Amend 4.15(b) to require Council to establish by ordinance policies with respect to the sanction or removal of
officers, appointees, or employees for cause.
5-35. Amend 4.16 (a) to clarify Council has all investigatory powers provide under general law.
5-36. Amend 5A.03 to update and expand the list of protected categories in personnel matters . (Amendment
identical to 5-43(d) below.)
5-37. Amend 5.B to broaden employees and retirees eligible to serve on the Retirement System board .
5-38. Strike 6.15.3 as provisions have expired.
5-39. Strike most of 13.06 concerning utilities as separate enterprises to remove unnecessary detail.
5-40. Strike 20.10 regarding courtroom provision as duplicative of general law.
5-41. Strike 20.11 regarding posting of bonds as duplicative of general law.
5-42 (a,b,c). Amend 4.02(b) and 4.02 (c) regarding creation of departments and reassignment of employees to make
consistent with Mayor-Council government; amend 5A.01 to make consistent with Mayor-Council government.
5-43 (a,b,c,d). Amend 4.02(d) to establish Council’s authority to create titles, qualifications, duties, powers for
officers and employees reporting to Council; add new provision 4.02(e) to provide Council power to establish pay
ranges for heads of administrative departments; add provision 5.05.1(g) to give Chief Administrative Officer
authority to establish titles, qualifications, duties and powers of officers and employees reporting to the CAO;
amend provision; amend provision 5A.03 to require development of a uniform severance plan as part of the
personnel system and that there be a director of human resources.
5-44. Replace existing Chapter 17 regarding Planning with new, simpler language establishing the Planning
Commission and Board of Zoning Appeals.
(Note: Council, the director of Planning and Development Review, the City Attorney, and other stakeholders should
confer regarding the content of a revised Chapter 17.)
5-45. Amend 18.02 regarding eminent domain processes to conform with general law and practice while retaining
the City’s powers.
5-46. Amend 18.03 regarding alternative procedures in condemnation to conform with general law and practice
while retaining the City’s powers.
5-47. Replace gendered language with gender-inclusive language throughout the Charter.
101
Partnership Model of Mayor-Council Government
6-1. Amend 5.02 to give Mayor power to directly appoint or remove administrative department heads, or to delegate
such authority to chief administrative officer, and Amend 5.03 to give Mayor power to give orders to heads of
administrative departments with written notification of the chief administrative officer.
6-2. Amend 4.17 to state explicitly the City Attorney represents the City of Richmond and that the various officers,
agencies and bodies that compose the city are its constituents.
6-3. Add subsections 4.17a and 4.17b to provide for Mayoral appointment of the City Attorney with Cou ncil
participation and approval by six votes, and to give both Mayor and Council a role in dismissal of the City Attorney .
6-4. Add subsection 4.17c to establish Council’s right to retain outside counsel on matters concerning the powers of
the Council.
6-5. Amend 5.01 and add subsections 5.01.1, 5.01.2, 5.01.3 to establish procedures for automatic appointing of a
pre-designated Acting Chief Administrative Officer in emergency circumstances; to provide for the Mayoral
appointment with Council consent of a interim Chief Administrative Officer; and to specify procedures for the
Mayoral appointment of a permanent Chief Administrative Officer, with substantive Council participation
throughout the process and confirmation of the Mayor’s nominee by six Council vote s.
6-6. Amend 5.01 and add subsections 5.01.4 to specify procedures for the removal of the Chief Administrative
Officer, including the duty of the Mayor to provide City Council advance notice in some circumstances, and
establishing the right of Council by super-majority vote (seven votes) to remove the Chief Administrative Officer.
6-7. Amend 6.03 and add paragraph 6.03(b) to provide for Council input into the development of the Mayor’s
budget proposal, informed by access to agency-level budget requests.
6-8. Add paragraph 6.16 (f) to require budget amendments to have a single purpose, or to allow Council to severe
them and treat them as separate amendments.
6-9. Add paragraph 6.16 (g) to permit Council twice a year (October, April) to introduce budget amend ments.
6-10. Add section 6.04.1 to permit establishment of a general operational fund capped at 1% of the general fund
budget that can be assigned by the Chief Administrative Officer to any agency during the year without requiring a
budget amendment.
6-11. Amend 5.01 to require Council to set the Mayor’s salary to meet or exceed the salary level of top
administrative officers during the year the Mayor is elected.
6-12. Amend 4.01 to set Council compensation to be equivalent to the median household income fo r City residents.
6-13. Add paragraph 5.05(b) to require the Mayor to attend one Council meeting per month to provide an update on
the City’s progress or on some issue, to receive and respond to questions pertaining to the update from all Council
members.
6.14. Add new section 20.15 to establish a process for decennial review of the Charter via a resident-led commission
appointed by Council to begin in 2030, and to state that alterations to responsibilities or hiring and dismissal
processes of any position resulting from changes to the Charter will not affect the employment of persons already
serving in those roles (unless the position is abolished).
Elected Mayor Council-Manager Option
7-1. The Commission recommends that Council create an Electoral Transition Committee to undertake a
comprehensive review of the legal, governance and organizational issues involved in shifting to a Council-Manager
form of government to include a directly elected Mayor, and to charge it with preparing language for a specific
proposal for transitioning the form of government, to be placed on an advisory referendum, as soon as the 2024
102
general election and no later than the 2026 general election. Once Council has received the report and
recommendation, it can elect whether or not to move forward with a referendum o n this proposal.
Staggered Council Terms
8-1. The Commission recommends adoption of staggered four-year Council terms, and recommends that Council
take steps to address (or create a process for addressing) several specific questions about how staggered terms would
work in practice, with a goal of implementing staggered Council terms no later than the 2028 general election.
103
Appendix B: Summary Results of Resident Engagement Survey
The Commission’s Resident Engagement Survey was open from May 19 to June 21. The survey
was made available via the RVA.Gov website, via the portal for the City Charter Review
Commission, and was shared in press releases, social media posts, and in numerous district
newsletters sent by Councilpersons. Paper copies of the survey were also made available in city
library branches.78
This survey is not a representative sample of Richmond residents, and should not be interpreted
or reported as such.
The intent of the survey was to gauge resident satisfaction with various dimensions of Richmond
city government. There was a specific interest in gauging residents’ perceptions of the impact of
Richmond’s change of government form in 2004 on the effectiveness of city government,
although the views of all residents (regardless of length of residence in the city) were of valued
interest. The results, while not representative, clearly indicated to Commission members that
many residents would like to see City government performing significantly better.
The survey did not ask for specific feedback on potential Charter changes under consideration by
the Commission, as these had not been formulated at the time the survey was designed. The
survey did allow for open-ended comments on matters relevant to the City Charter, and some
respondents took the opportunity to comment on the proposals under consideration. (Other
residents emailed the Charter Review Commission directly.)
The survey has serious limitations that must be kept in mind. First, it is not a random sample;
respondents were self-selected. Second, it is not a representative sample, as responses
disproportionately came from the 1st, 2nd, 3rd, 4th, and 5th districts, and responses were
disproportionately white, disproportionately older, and with disproportionately high levels of
educational attainment, relative to the city’s overall population.
These limitations must be kept in mind in considering the following results. The City Charter
Review Commission strongly recommends that, should City Council wish to consider
exploration of a potential change in government in the foreseeable future, that the Council make
a significant investment in additional engagement, to include:
• Mailings to all city residents
• Multiple meetings in all nine districts
• Print and electronic versions of materials related to potential Charter changes
• Translation of all material into Spanish
• Professionally conducted phone surveys constructed to produce a representative sample
This survey can be understood as information on how a self-selected group of Richmond
residents with sufficient motivation to spend several minutes answering questions about
Richmond local government feel about aspects of local government.
Because this not a representative sample, the Commission is not reporting sample-wide totals in
hopes of preventing the results from being reported or used in a misleading way. Instead, the
78 The Commission thanks Mr. Lazaro Perez, a consultant for Richmond City Council, with assistance in preparing
the survey data for analysis by the Commission.
104
results are reported along three axes: first, comparing the responses of current or former City
employees to those of persons who have never worked for the City; second, comparing responses
across Council districts, sorted into three groupings by geography (Districts 1 and 4; Districts 2,
3, and 5; and Districts 6,7,8 and 9); and third, comparing responses by race/ethnicity (white,
Black, and other races/ethnicities).79
That said, the survey demographics mandate that caution must be used in interpreting these
results. For example, City residents with relatively low educational attainment are seriously
under-represented in this this sample: whereas persons with a high school diploma or lower as
their highest level of education complete constitute 32.6% of the City’s adult population (2017-
2021 American Community Survey), they are just 2.8% of this sample.
The Commission strongly recommends that the Council invest in additional engagement
strategies to reach a more representative sample of residents. It is possible that a more
representative sample would replicate or even strengthen these results, but it still should be done
in the interest of having the most accurate assessment possible and in being sure all residents’
voices are heard.
Survey Demographics
Total Respondents: 1148
City Residents: 96% of sample
Ever Employed by City of Richmond: 11% of sample
District:
“I Don’t Know” 131
1st District 189
2nd District 172
3rd District 108
4th District 163
5th District 137
6th District 34
7th District 58
8th District 37
9th District 24
Length of Residence
Less Than 1 Year 27
1-5 Years 193
6-10 Years 166
11-20 Years 215
21-30 Years 157
More than 30 Years 295
79 The Commission also examined survey results at the individual district level. Sample sizes are too small in certain
districts to merit reporting out results by individual district, a problem alleviated in reporting by groups of districts.
105
Highest Educational Level
Graduate Degree 517
Some Graduate School 87
Undergraduate Degree 363
Some College 73
High School/GED 28
Less Than High School 4
Age
18-24 26
25-34 170
35-44 202
45-54 178
55-64 193
65 and up 322
Race/Ethnicity
White 767
No Response 140
Black 92
Multiracial 28
Hispanic 22
Asian 12
Other 18
List of Survey Questions
1. What locality do you live in?
2. Are you a resident of the City of Richmond?
3. What's your zip code?
4. What district of the city do you live in?
5. How many years (in total) have you lived in the City of Richmond?
6. What is your race or ethnicity?
7. What is your age?
8. What is the highest level of education you have completed?
9. [Which category] best describes your employment status?
10. [Which field of employment] best describes your fields/sector?
11. Have you ever been employed by Richmond City Government?
106
12. If yes, how many years have you been employed in the City of Richmond?
13. What do you believe are the three most important issues or problems facing the City of
Richmond?
14. Assess the following statements about current Richmond City Government
(Strongly Agree, Agree, Neither Agree nor Disagree, Disagree, Strongly Disagree)
• Provides effective services to residents
• Helps promote economic opportunity
• Mitigates poverty for city residents
• Effectively supports public education
• Effectively promotes public safety
• Achieves desirable levels of transparency and accountability
• Is responsive to residents
15. Based on your opinion or experience, compared to the Council-Manager system, the Mayor-
Council system:
(Strongly Agree, Neither Agree nor Disagree, Disagree, Strongly Disagree, Don't Know)
• Has led to better service delivery
• Gives residents more of a voice in City government by allowing them to vote directly for
a Mayor
• Has improved the budget establishment process
• Has improved the policy making process
• Has made it easier for the City to tackle big goals
• Assisted Richmond Public Schools with achieving stronger educational outcomes
• Reduced incidence of unethical behavior in City government
• Given a greater voice in the regional, state, and national arenas
• Has improved the City of Richmond as an organization
• Helped develop a shared vision for the City that all residents can connect with
• Has allowed the City of Richmond to move forward and achieve progress to become a
better City
• Has made it more cost effective and efficient (i.e. less expensive to deliver services)
16. Please share any other comments or recommendations you may have concerning the City
Charter, the City's current form of governance, or other potential forms of governance for the
City. Please focus your remarks on the form of governance, not specific complaints or criticisms
of specific individuals.
107
Top Three Citywide Issues, by District
1st District (n=189): Housing, Education, Affordable Housing
2nd District (n=172): Education, Schools, Affordable Housing
3rd District (n=108): Affordable Housing, Crime, Housing
4th District (n=163): Crime, Affordable Housing, High Taxes, Housing
5th District (n=137): Affordable Housing, Poverty, Education
6th District (n=34): Affordable Housing, Gun Violence, 9 other issues (3 related to housing)
7th District (n=58): Affordable Housing, Schools, 13 other issues (2 related to housing)
8th District (n=37): Affordable Housing, Crime, 9 other issues (including housing)
9th District (n=24): 7 issues
City Government Employees (n=131): Affordable Housing, Housing, Poverty
Open-ended Comments
The open-ended comments offered by survey respondents expressed a wide range of views and
concerns. While the Commission has not undertaken a detailed quantitative analysis of those
comments, they generally reflected both the concerns noted above and the general assessment of
city government and city governance reported in the summary results below.
Comparison to Other Data
The results reported in Tables B-1, B-2, and B-3 should be seen in the context of the inherent
limitations of the data noted above. However, these results broadly align with the 2021 National
Community Survey, a representative survey which found that 26% of Richmond residents had a
“good” (22%) or excellent (4%) level of confidence in local government, 41% had a “fair” level
of confidence, and 33% had a “poor level of confidence.”
108
B-1. Summary Survey Results by Employee Status
Currently City Government Effectively Acts to
Never City employee Current/Former City employee
Promote Economic Opportunity 21% agree, 39% disagree 34% agree, 30% disagree
Mitigate Poverty for City Residents 8% agree, 60% disagree 18% agree, 48% disagree
Support Public Education 16% agree, 63% disagree 34% agree, 40% disagree
Promotes Public Safety 19% agree, 55% disagree 38% agree, 37% disagree
Achieves Transparency/Accountability 7% agree, 73% disagree 15% agree, 69% disagree
Responsive to Residents 15% agree, 58% disagree 28% agree, 52% disagree
Compared to the previous Council-Manager system, the Mayor-Council system has produced…
Better Service Delivery 10% agree, 47% disagree 8% agree, 46% disagree
More Resident Voice 33% agree, 38% disagree 42% agree, 35% disagree
Improved Policy Making 12% agree, 50% disagree 10% agree, 51% disagree
Easier to Tackle Big Goals 12% agree, 51% disagree 16% agree, 50% disagree
Stronger Educational Outcomes 5% agree, 57% disagree 14% agree, 45% disagree
Reduced Unethical Behavior 8% agree, 47% disagree 8% agree, 47% disagree
Given City a Greater Voice 21% agree, 30% disagree 28% agree, 25% disagree
Improved City as Organization 13% agree, 45% disagree 12% agree, 44% disagree
Developed a Shared Vision 12% agree, 50% disagree 13% agree, 49% disagree
Allow Richmond to Make Progress 15% agree, 46% disagree 17% agree, 48% disagree
More Cost Effective Government 5% agree, 54% disagree 6% agree, 50% disagree
Note: n=945 for “never City employee”; n=131 for “current or former City employee.”
“Agree” is the total of respondents answering “agree” or “strongly agree” with each item; “Disagree” is
the total of respondents answering “disagree” or “strongly disagree” with each item. Other available
responses included “Neither Agree Nor Disagree” and (for the comparative questions) “Don’t Know.”
109
Table B-2. Summary Results by Council District
Districts 1 and 4 Districts 2,3,5 Districts 6,7,8,9
(West End and Southwest) (North Central, Northside, (Gateway, East End,
Central) South Central, Southside)
Currently City Government Effectively Acts to
Promote Economic Opportunity 21% A/ 34% D 21% A/ 39% D 29% A/ 41% D
Mitigate Poverty 7% A/ 58% D 9% A/ 58% D 11% A/ 63% D
Supports Public Education 16% A/ 64% D 18% A/ 60% D 20% A/ 59% D
Promotes Public Safety 18% A/ 55% D 22% A/ 51% D 27% A/ 50% D
Achieves Transparency/Acct 6% A/ 75% D 10% A/ 72% D 7% A/ 73% D
Responsive to Residents 14% A/ 64% D 19% A/ 52% D 18% A/ 54% D
Compared to the previous Council-Manager system, the Mayor-Council system has produced
Better Service Delivery 7% A/ 51% D 10% A/ 50% D 12% A/ 44% D
More Resident Voice 33% A/ 39% D 29% A/ 43% D 43% A/ 33% D
Improved Policy Making 7% A/ 53% D 14% A/ 53% D 15% A/ 50% D
Easier to Tackle Big Goals 9% A/ 53% D 13% A/ 53% D 19% A/ 47% D
Stronger Educational Outcomes 4% A/ 59% D 6% A/ 58% D 10% A/ 52% D
Reduced Unethical Behavior 6% A/ 49% D 8% A/ 49% D 11% A/ 47% D
Greater Voice for City 17% A/ 33% D 16% A/ 31% D 28% A/ 25% D
Improved City as Organization 8% A/ 49% D 13% A/ 47% D 20% A/ 40% D
Developed a Shared Vision 10% A/ 57% D 13% A/ 50% D 15% A/ 45% D
Allowed City to Move Forward 10% A/ 52% D 15% A/ 47% D 22% A/ 37% D
More Cost Effective Gov’t 4% A/ 57% D 5% A/ 54% D 9% A/ 53% D
Note: n=352 for Districts 1 and 4; n=417 for Districts 2, 3, and 5; n=152 for Districts 6,7 , 8 and 9
“A” is the total of respondents answering “agree” or “strongly agree” with each item; “D” is the total of respondents
answering “disagree” or “strongly disagree” with each item. Other available responses included “Neither Agree
Nor Disagree” and (for the comparative questions) “Don’t Know.”
110
Table B-3. Summary Results by Race/Ethnicity
White Black Other
Currently City Government Effectively Acts to
Promote Economic Opportunity 24% A/ 36% D 24% A/ 41% D 23% A/34% D
Mitigate Poverty for City Residents 9% A/ 60% D 13% A/ 60% D 8% A/ 59% D
Support Public Education 17% A/ 61% D 28% A/51% D 23% A/59% D
Promotes Public Safety 20% A/ 53% D 37% A/40% D 18% A/56% D
Achieves Transparency/ Accountability 7% A/73% D 13% A/ 70% D 10% A/ 71% D
Responsive to Residents 16% A/55% D 21% A/ 5
Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.
Source: City of Richmond website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.