RecordWell Data

Planning Commission — Agenda Packet

Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Planning Commission · meeting of Mar 19, 2024 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Chesterfield County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CHESTERFIELD COUNTY PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING AGENDA TUESDAY, MARCH 19, 2024 Public Meeting Room 10001 Iron Bridge Road, Chesterfield VA 23832 NOTE: Attachments are generally available the Wednesday prior to the Planning Commission meeting. Any subsequent changes to this agenda prior to the date of the meeting, and more detailed information regarding items on the agenda can be found at www.chesterfield.gov/plan, or by calling the Planning Department at 804-748-1050 during regular business hours, 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m Monday through Friday. Comments or recommendations regarding items on the agenda can be submitted to planning@chesterfield.gov. Providing a FIRST CHOICE community through excellence in public service 12 p.m. Planning Commission Work Session - Public Meeting Room 1. Requests to Postpone Action, Emergency Additions, Changes in the Order of Presentation 2. Item for Discussion A. Update of Zoning Ordinance Modernization (ZOMod) Project (20PJ0107) - Review of Zoning Districts 3. Review Day's Agenda (Items to be considered at the 6 p.m. session) 4. Approval of the Planning Commission Minutes for: • February 20, 2024 Minutes 5. Planning Commission Work Program Update 6. Recess 5 p.m. Dinner - Executive Meeting Room 6 p.m. Public Hearing - Public Meeting Room 7. Call to Order 8. Invocation 9. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America 10. Requests to Postpone Action, Emergency Additions, or Change in the Order of Presentation 11. Review Meeting Procedures 12. Citizen Comment Period on Unscheduled Matters Involving the Services, Policies and Affairs of the County Government regarding Planning or Land Use Matters Page 1 of 87 Chesterfield County Planning Commission Meeting March 19, 2024 At this time, the Commission will hear citizen comments on unscheduled matters involving the services, policies and affairs of the county government regarding planning or land use matters. Such comments may not address any matter of business that was a subject on the Commission’s work session earlier today or is a subject on the Commission’s agenda this evening. The length of this item is limited to a maximum of fifteen (15) minutes total. Should additional time be necessary, an additional citizen input item is scheduled at the end of the agenda. 13. Public Hearing, Consideration of the Following Proposals in this Order: Requests for withdrawals/deferrals; cases where the applicant accepts the recommendation and there is no public opposition; cases where the applicant does not accept the recommendation and/or there is public opposition; and zoning ordinance amendments. A. 23SN0053: In Midlothian Magisterial District, Unity Church of Bon Air Sign is a request for conditional use to permit a changeable copy sign plus conditional use planned development to permit exceptions to ordinance requirements and amendment of zoning district map in a Residential (R-15) District on 4.53 acres known as 923 and 925 Buford Road. Density will be controlled by zoning conditions or ordinance standards. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax IDs 757-710-7093 and 758-710-0393. B. 23SN0056: In Bermuda Magisterial District, Kingsland Acres Buffer and Setback Reduction is a request for conditional use planned development to permit exceptions to ordinance requirements and amendment of zoning district map in a Residential (R-7) District on 2.02 acres known as 3530 Kingsland Road. Density will be controlled by zoning conditions or ordinance standards. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 787-673-3401. C. 23SN0121 (Deferred from 02/20/2024): In Matoaca Magisterial District, Studio M Training is a request for conditional use to permit a fitness training studio incidental to a dwelling and amendment of zoning district map in an Agricultural (A) District on 1.8 acres known as 17600 Elko Road. Density will be controlled by zoning conditions or ordinance standards. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Low Density Residential use (Maximum of 1 dwelling per acre). Tax ID 787-626-2199. 14. Citizen Comment Period on Unscheduled Matters Involving the Services, Policies and Affairs of the County Government regarding Planning or Land Use Matters At this time, the Commission will hear citizen comments on unscheduled matters involving the services, policies and affairs of the county government regarding planning or land use matters. Such comments may not address any matter of business that was a subject on the Commission’s work session earlier today or is a subject on the Commission’s agenda this evening. The length of this item is limited to a maximum of fifteen (15) minutes total. Page 2 of 87 Chesterfield County Planning Commission Meeting March 19, 2024 15. Other Business 16. Adjournment Page 3 of 87 CLOVER HILL DALE BERMUDA MATOACA MIDLOTHIAN COALB ORO ROAD TAYLOR ROAD DUVAL ROAD M OSELEY ROA D PE AR OR C HARD ROAD GENITO RD S ECON D BRAN CH ROA DW I NTE R POCK ROAD BEAVER BRIDGE RD BUNDLE RD BEACH RD RIVER RD I RON BRIDG E R O A D HICKO RY RO AD GRAVES RD M ATO ACA RD RIVER RD RIVER RD NASH RD B RADL E Y BRIDGE ROAD BERMUDA HUNDRED RO A D RUFF IN MILL R DBRA N DERS BRIDG EROAD HARROW G ATE ROA D W HUNDRED ROAD CATTAIL RD WOODPECKER RD BEACH RD S I-295 QUALL A ROAD BAILEY BRI DGE ROAD COU RTHOUSE ROAD GENITO RD B EULAH ROAD KINGS L AND RO AD C OGBILL ROAD BELM ONT ROAD NEW BY S BR IDG E ROAD Route 1 BELLWOOD RD REYMET RD WILLIS RD RT 288 HULL STREET RD HULL STREET RD TUR N ER ROA D OTTERDALE ROAD C O A LFIELD ROA D POWHITE PARKWAY O LD HUND RED ROAD EL KHA RDTRO AD CO URTH OUSE ROAD MIDL OTHIAN TURNPIKE ROBI OUS ROAD DINWIDDIE CO. RICHMOND POWHATANCO. HENRICO CO. AMELIACO. JESSUP RD BUFORD RD HUG UENOT ROAD RT 288 NASH RD HOPEWELL COLONIAL HEIGHTS HENRICO CO. Route 1 23SN0121 23SN0056 23SN0053 March 19, 2024 CPC Agenda Overview Legend Bermuda Clover Hill Dale Matoaca Midlothian Page 4 of 87 Providing a FIRST CHOICE community through excellence in public service Planning Commission Minutes Chesterfield, VA 23832 February 20, 2024 PRESENT: Mr. Gib Sloan Ms. Elizabeth Hardin Dr. LeQuan Hylton Mr. Tommy Owens Mr. Frank Petroski Mr. Andrew Gillies, Secretary to the Commission, Director, Planning Department ALSO PRESENT: Mr. Steve Donohoe, Assistant Director, Planning Department Mr. Steve Haasch, Assistant Director, Planning Department Mr. Rob Robinson, Senior Deputy County Attorney, County Attorney’s Office Mr. Andrew Fulwider, Senior Assistant County Attorney, County Attorney’s Office Ms. Kathi Eshleman, Clerk to the Planning Commission, Planning Department Ms. Sharon Mason, Clerk to the Board of Zoning Appeals, Planning Department Mr. Thomas Jenkins, Zoning Administrator, Planning Department Mr. Joe Feest, Planning Manager, Planning Department Ms. Rachel Chieppa, Planning Manager, Planning Department Ms. Amanda Adams, Zoning Administrative Coordinator, Planning Department Mr. Harold Ellis, Planning Administrator, Planning Department Ms. Summer Hobson, Principal Planner, Planning Department Mr. Richard Saunders, Principal Planner, Planning Department Mr. Drew Noxon, Principal Planner, Planning Department Ms. Joanne Wieworka, Principal Planner, Planning Department Page 5 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 2 | Pa ge Mr. Martin Stith, Production Operations Coordinator, Communications & Media Department Mr. Michael Bowman, Enterprise Systems Information Systems Technology Department Mr. Matt Rembold, Assistant Director, Utilities Department ASSEMBLY AND WORK SESSION 3:00 P.M. PLANNING COMMISSION WORK SESSION. 1. REQUESTS TO POSTPONE ACTION, EM ERGENCY ADDITIONS, AND CHANGES IN T HE ORDER OF PRESENTATION. There were no requests or changes in the order of presentation. 2. REVIEW DAY’S AGENDA. Mr. Steve Don ohoe stated for the 6: 00 p.m. a genda to day we h ave ten (10) cases: one (1) withdrawal case; three (3) deferral cases, two (2) consent cases, and four (4) discussion cases. 3. APPROVAL OF PLANNING COMMISSION MINUTES. • January 16, 2024 CPC Regular Minutes On motion of Mr. Sloan, seconded by Mr. Owens, the Commission resolved to approve the Planning Commission minutes for January 16, 2024. Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye 4. ITEMS FOR DISCUSSION. A. Update of Zoning Ordinance Modernization (ZOMod) Project (20PJ0107) Mr. Gillies introduced the day’s discussion on the ZOMod project and began by s aying that staff is excited to bring back the ZOMod project for review. He welcomed Mr. Mark White who is the lead consultant from White and Smith and is pa rticipating virtually today . Mr. Gillies explained that ZOMod was put on a n official pause last July after the review of Draft 1 was completed. Since that time , we have had public comments coming in and staff has been working to make changes by going through all the chapters of Draft 1 and reorganizing and improving the document. Staff has responded to every comment that was submitted and has tried to incorporate many of the comments in potential changes. We have also tried to simplify and org anize the document, resulting in Draft 2 . Mr. Gillies said that t oday a general overview of Draft 2 will be given. We will start next month diving into the first chapter. Page 6 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 3 | Pa ge Mr. Gillies reminded the C ommission why we st arted this project in the first place . The old Zoning Ordinance from the 1980s was outdated and unable to keep up with all of the many changes that have taken place since then . Starting with a clean s late or can vas and working with a new Ordinance seemed to be the right approach. We desire it to be more readable and to contain better graphics, to clarify the terminology, and to modernize the zoning distri cts. In addition to modernizing the districts we saw the need t o modernize the terminology. In all the chapters, we are trying to create better transparency and flexibility. Mr. Gillies continued by gi ving a brief history of the ZOMod project. In 2019 , the B oard of Supervisors appropriated the funds for a new Zoning Ordinance and gave permission to begin the RFP process. The project was delayed to 2021 because of the Pandemic. In the interim, listening sessions were h eld with various groups. In 2021, we b egan working on the ZOMod document and in spring of 2023 we reviewed the f irst draft with the Co mmission. In fall of 2023 we began creating Draft 2, which brings us to where we are today. Mr. Gillies turned the podium over to Thomas Jenkins. Mr. Jenkins began by highlighting a few major features of the new Or dinance. The new Zoning Ordnance better a ligns with the Comprehensive Plan. Each zoning district has a range of options which enables flexibility. The use matrix has been vastly improved and streamlined from over 450 uses, many of which are redundant and outdated , to approximately 210 uses. The new Ordinance is much more logically org anized and user friendly. Finally, the CUPD process has been rep laced with a Proffer Adjustment Process. Mr. Jenkins sha red a brief overview of the fourteen (14) proposed zoning districts, beginning with Agricultura l which is similar to t oday’s Agricultural district. There are s even (7) Residential districts which were outlined. Mr. Jenkins briefly mentioned the Neighborhood Business and Corridor Commercial districts and an entirely new option of a Mixed-Use district. There are three (3) districts for employment uses. District flexibility was described for each of the various districts. Mr. Jenkins then showed some of the major changes between Draft 1 an d Draft 2, which are creation of a Rural Community district, adjusted amenity space requirements, expansion of the P roffer Adjustment Process, an added utilities requirement to zoning district tables, modernized employment uses, and further refineme nt of development standards. Each of these were described. Ms. Rachel Chieppa came to the podium. She stated she would explain the testing phase. As we move forward , we want to ensure that we do case testing. She showed examples of the current zoning ma p and the proposed new zoning map. When we get to the community meeting phase, we will have a tool available to the public which will allow citizens to compare the zoning. Ms. Ch ieppa continued by describing an ambitious work s ession schedule planned for the next five (5) months. Every article in Draft 2 will be covered. Th e work sessions will begin at 10 a.m. and extend to 5 p.m. Additional meetings can be added if needed. In March w e will begin with the zoning districts which ar e the DNA of the Zoning Ordinance. In April uses and use restrictions will be covered. In May we will cover development standards, and in June we will review the submittal request sections. In July, we will review non-conformities. The timeline for adoptio n of the new Z oning Ordinance is ambitious as well. We will release it to Page 7 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 4 | Pa ge the public on March 1 and leave the public comment line op en until July. ZOMOd advisory committee meetings will be taking pla ce during the same time that the Commission wi ll be reviewing the new Ordinance. The community outreach phase will take place in Oc tober or November. After the community meeting pha se, we will re-group again and get ready for the final draft which will com e to the Co mmission in the Public Hearing phase. Postcards to the entire County will be mailed and everyone will be notified of the Public Hearings. Ms. Chieppa said staff was available to answer the Commission’s questions. Mr. Sloan said that he appreciates the hard work of staff. He asked as we move through these more intens ive meetings, will the presentations be recorded in Civic Clerk? Can we h ave appointments sent out right away for these extended sessions? Mr. Gillies said that March will be a good test of what the timeline needs to be. He said we tentatively thought 10 a.m. would be a good start time. Dr. Hylton said he encourages us to make sure all Commissioners can be here in person. He thinks starting at 10 a.m. is a pretty long day and suggests maybe a briefing session by phone or Teams be held first to be better prepared. He suggested that 12 noon is a better start time. Mr. Owens said that going a month of two longer with shorter sessions would allow more time to digest the information. Ms. Hardin stated she appreciates her fellow Commissioners’ comments and she is fully able and willing to do any necessary homework at home. A 10 a .m. start time will not be sustainable for her with her employment. A half-day is much more doable than a full day. She wants to be present and fully engaged in all sessions. Mr. Petroski asked Ms. Hardin if noon would work. Ms. Hardin responded that starting at noon would be a huge improvement. Mr. Owens reminded staff to make sure that the advertised start time is handled correctly. Mr. Petroski stated that the Commissioner consensus is to begin at noon, rather than 10 a.m. He said he a grees with the idea of a pre-check in, but at the same ti me wants to make sure that does not take anything away from the public meeting. Mr. Sloan stated that his observation is that we have regular work session business which needs to go on, so essentially only 12-3 p.m. will be dedicated to ZOMod . He would rather adjust all of the time frames now rather than later because time will go quickly when they get on a topic of conversation and they may not be able to cover what they need to. He requested that we get the extended work sessions on all of their calendar s today and we can pull back later if necessary. Ms. Hardin asked if there is any legal or procedural reason that would prohibit the body from going back into a work session in the evening after the pu blic hearing if the re is a short agenda. She said tha t might also help to promote better public engagement by holding the discussions in the evening rather than the da ytime. Mr. Robinson confirmed there was no legal reason why that could not be done. Page 8 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 5 | Pa ge Mr. Owens suggested extending the ZOMod work sessions through October and having them be shorter sessions. People aren’t engaged after that time because of the holidays. There was discussion about public engagement. Mr. Petroski stated that through October, we will have noon work session start t imes. He asked Ms. Chieppa to share the plan for how the public will be alerted regarding opportunities to join us and become engaged in submitting public comments. Ms. Chieppa responded that the County web site, social media, and all avenues we have used before will be utilized. Mr. Petroski stated he wants to make sure the Commu nity is as aware as possible of the opportunities. B. Discussion of Planning Commission Work Program Mr. Steve Haasc h presented an overview of the Plann ing Commission work program. He stated that for var ious Code Ame ndments, other than ZOMod which is the major project, the Code Amendment Relative to P ublic Notices goes to the Board of Supervisors tomorrow. Mr. Haasch also said that the Subdivision Ordinance is being updated in tandem with ZOMod. Mr. Haas ch continued by reviewing the Comprehensive Plan pro jects. We are cur rently working on approaches for the Housing Diversity Strategy. The Eastern 60 Corridor Plan is underway. An update of Chapter 10 in the Comprehensive Plan to make sure the land use s are appropriate with the new Zoning Ordinance is also underway. The County Transportation Department is working on the Chapter 14 Bikeways and Trails Plan Update with a consultant, and we are participating in that. The Western 360 Corridor Plan in the Ma toaca district will hopefully begin this year. Mr. Haasch closed by saying that a s discussed last month, we are working with Dr. Hylton to identify a Plan along Route 10 to bring quality development forward and how to best move forward with that Plan. Mr. Sloan asked what else we need to specifically do w ith the Comp rehensive Plan. Mr. Haasch responded that from a legal standpoint, the Comprehensive Plan is in good shape. Every time we add a n area plan, it is an update to the Comprehensive Plan. For the various chapters, if there are major shifts in the C ounty budget process, adjustments may need to be made. In other business. Mr. Gillies introduced Sharon Mason, the new Clerk to the BZA and back-up to the Clerk to the P lanning Commission. Ms. Mason brings 15 ye ars of experience and is a Chesterfield County native. 5. RECESS. The Commission went into recess at 4:25 p.m. agreeing to reconvene at 5 p.m. for dinner and 6 p.m. for the Public Meeting and Hearing. Page 9 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 6 | Pa ge 6:00 P.M. PUBLIC MEETING AND HEARING. 6. CALL TO ORDER. Mr. Petroski called the session to order at 6 p.m. He welcomed the audience and read the following statement: Good evening and w elcome to the evening se ssion of the February 20th, 2024 Planning Commission mee ting. We are pleased to now have a QR Cod e av ailable. Anyone who is interested may scan the QR Code that has been provided and download the agenda and all of the staff reports for tonight’s meeting. 7. INVOCATION. The invocation was presented by Mr. Sloan. 8. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE TO THE FLAG OF THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA. Mr. Sloan led the Pledge of Allegiance to the flag. 9. REQUESTS TO POSTPONE ACTION, EMERGENCY ADD ITIONS OR CHANGES I N THE ORDER OF PRESENTATION. There were no additions or changes in the order of presentation. 10. REVIEW MEETING PROCEDURES. Mr. Andy Gillies reviewed the meeting procedures. 11. CITIZEN COMMENT PERIOD ON UNSCHEDULED MATTERS INVOLVING THE SERVICES, POLICIES AND AF FAIRS OF THE COUNTY GOV ERNMENT REGARDIN G P LANNING OR LAND USE ISSUES. There were no comments on unscheduled matters received through the portal. No one came forward to speak. 12. PUBLIC HEARINGS, CONSIDERATION OF THE FOLLOWING PROPOSALS IN THIS ORDER: Requests for withdrawals/deferrals; cases where the applicant accepts the recommendation and there is no public opposition; and cases where the applicant does not accept the recommendation and/or there is public opposition. Mr. Petroski reviewed all the avenues of public comment which had been made available to the public and stated that copies of any and all comments had been given to the Commissioners. He also stated where public comments may be viewed on the County website. Page 10 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 7 | Pa ge (A) WITHDRAWAL ITEM. 23SN0048 (Defe rred from 01/16/2 024): In Midlothian Magisteri al District, Mall Drive Apartments Amendment is a request to amend zoning approval of Case 21SN0592 relative to ordinance requirements and development standards and amendment of zoning district map in a Multifamily Residential (R-MF) District on 22.19 acres fronting 500 feet along the west line of Mall Drive, 750 feet south of Robious Road. Density will be controlled by zoning conditions or ordi nance standards. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is app ropriate for Regional Mixed Use. Tax ID 741-713-7004-00002. Mr. Steve Donohoe stated that the case has been withdrawn by the applicant and no further action by the Commission is necessary. (B) DEFERRAL ITEMS. THE DEFERRAL CASES BELOW WERE VOTED ON USING THE BLOCK VOTE SYSTEM. 23SN0023 (Deferred from 01/16/2024) : In Matoaca Magisterial Distr ict, Moseley Communications Tower is a request for conditional use to perm it a communications tower facility with fu ll array antennas and amendment of zoning dis trict map in an Agricultur al (A) District on 0.70 acre known as 18411 Duval Road. Density will be controlled by zoning conditions or ordinanc e standards. The Comprehensi ve Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Suburban Residential I use (Maximum of 2 dwellings per acre). Ta x ID 700- 676- Part of 1841. Mr. Steve Donoh oe presented the case and stated the District Planning Commissioner wishes to defer the case to the regularly scheduled April 2024 Planning Commission Public Hearing. Mr . Donohoe also stated that there is no public opposition to the request f or deferral at this time. There was opportunity for questions by the Commissioners for Mr. Donohoe. There were no questions. Mr. Petroski opened the Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski asked if there was anyone p resent who wi shed to speak in favor of, or in opposition to, the request for deferral. No one came forward to speak in favor of, or in opposition to, the request for deferral. There being no one to speak, Mr. Petroski closed the Public Hearing. On motion of Mr. Owens, seconded by Dr. Hylton, the Commission resolved to defer Case 23SN0023 at the request of the District Commissioner to the regularly scheduled April 2024 Planning Commission Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Page 11 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 8 | Pa ge Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye 23SN0043 (Deferred from 01/16/2024): In Bermuda Magisterial District, Bensley Agrihood is a request t o rezone from Residential (R -7) to Residential (R -12) plus conditional use plus conditional use planned developme nt to permit exceptions to ordinance requirements and amendment of zo ning district map on 7.04 acr es known as 2600 Swineford Road. Density will be controlled by zoning conditions or ordinance standards. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appro priate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 789-682-9065. Mr. Steve Donohoe presented the case and s tated the District Planning Commissioner wishes to defer t he case to the regularly scheduled April 2024 Planning Commission Public Hearing. Mr . Donohoe also stated that the re is no public opposition to the request f or deferral at this time. There was opportunity for questions by the Commissioners for Mr. Donohoe. There were no questions. Mr. Sloan exte nds his a ppreciation to th e applicants and stated they continue to work together to make the case the best possible case. Mr. Will Shewmake came forward to represent the applicant and stated they consented to the deferral. Mr. Petroski opened the Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski asked if there was anyone p resent who wishe d to speak in favor of, or in opposition to, the request for deferral. Mr. Greg Allen came forward to speak in support of the request for deferral. He said the case has many benefits not often seen. There being no one else to speak, Mr. Petroski closed the Public Hearing. On motion of Mr. Owens, seconded by Dr. Hylton, the Commission resolved to defer Case 23SN0043 at the request of the District Commissioner to the regularly scheduled April 2024 Planning Commission Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye 23SN0121: In Ma toaca Magisterial District, Studio M Training is a request for conditional use to permit a fitness training studi o incidental to a dwelling and amendmen t of zoning district map in an Agricultural (A) District on 1.8 acres known as 17600 Elko Roa d. Density will be controlled by zoning condit ions or ordinance standards. The Comprehensive Plan Page 12 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 9 | Pa ge suggests the property is appropriate for Low Density Residential use (Maximum of 1 dwelling per acre). Tax ID 787-626-2199. Mr. Steve Donoh oe presented the case and s tated the District Planning Commissioner wishes to defer the case to the regularly scheduled March 2024 Planning Commission Public Hearing. Mr . Donohoe also stated that the re is no public opposition to the request for deferral at this time. There was opportunity for questions by the Commissioners for Mr. Donohoe. There were no questions. Mr. Petroski opened the Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski asked if there was anyone p resent who w ished to speak in favor of, or in opposition to, the request for deferral. No one came forward to speak in favor of, or in opposition to, the request for deferral. There being no one to speak, Mr. Petroski closed the Public Hearing. On motion of Mr. Owens, seconded by Dr. Hylton, the Commission resolved to defer Case 23SN0121 at the re quest of the District Commissioner to the regul arly scheduled March 2024 Planning Commission Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye (C) CONSENT ITEMS. THE CONSENT CASES BELOW WERE VOTED ON USING THE BLOCK VOTE SYSTEM. 23SN0065: In Bermuda Magis terial District, Old Stage Rd Rezoning is a request to rezone from Light Industrial (I-1) to General Industrial (I-2) and amendment of zoning district map on 5.35 acres known as 13119 Old Stage Road. Densi ty will be controlled by zoning conditions or ordinance standa rds. The Comprehe nsive Plan suggests the property is appropria te for Corporate Office/Research & Development/Light Industrial use. Tax ID 803-652-7826. Mr. Steve Donohoe presented the case. He reported that staff h ad received n o public opposition to this case an d that staff had received agreement to the conditions f rom the applicant. There was opportunity for questions by the Commissioners for Mr. Donohoe. There were no questions. Mr. Petroski opened the Public Hearing. Page 13 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 10 | Pa ge There were no public comments reported. Mr. Petroski asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak i n favor of, or in opposition to, the request. No one came forward to speak in favor of, or in opposition to, the request. There being no one to speak, Mr. Petroski closed the Public Hearing. On motion of Mr. Sloan, seconded by Mr. Owens, the Commission resolved to reco mmend approval of Case 23SN0065 subject to the Proffered Conditions. PROFFERED CONDITIONS The Applicant in this case, pursuant to Section 15.2 -2298 of the Code of Virginia (1950 as amended) and the Zoning Ordinance of Chesterfield County, for it self and its successors or assigns, proffer that the property know n a s Chesterfield County Tax Identi fication Number 803-652-7826-00000 (the “Property”) under con sideration will be used according to the following proffers if, and only if, the request submi tted here with is granted with only those conditions agreed to by t he Applicant. In the event this re quest is denied or approved with conditions not agreed to by the Applicant, the proffers shall immediately be null and void and of no further force or effect. 1. Master Plan. The Concept Plan, attached hereto as EXHIBIT A, shall be considered the Master Plan. Development of the Property shall be in substantial con formance with the Master Plan, except as otherwise approved by the Planning Department. (P) 2. Public Utilities. Public water and wastewater shall serve the Pr operty. At time of initial development of the Property, the Property owner shall extend public water service to the Property by extending the end of the existing public line on property at 1901 Ware Bottom Spring Road, across the Old Stage Road right-of-way onto the Property. The line shall be constructed past the paved improvements on the Property , or as otherwise requested by the Utilities Department, outside the ultimate right -of-way of Old Stage Road, with an additional public water line easement prov ided to the southern boundary li ne of the Property. (U) 3. Road Improvement. a. Road Improve ments. Prior to the issuance of certificate of occupancy, the owner/developer shall be respon sible for widening/improving the east side of Old Stage Road to an eleven (11) foot wide travel la ne, measured from the centerline of the existing pavement, with an additional four (4) foot paved shoulder and overlaying to the centerline of the road with o ne and a half (1.5) inch of surface asphalt, with any modifications a pproved by the Transportation Department, for the entire property frontage. The developer sh all dedicate, free and unrestricted, to and for the benefit of Chesterfield County any additio nal right -of-way (or easements) required for these improvements. (T) Page 14 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 11 | Pa ge 4. Architectural Design. Buildings constructed on the Property shall substantially conform to the conceptual elevations attached hereto as EXHIBIT B, except as otherwise approved by the Planning Department. A chain link fence, measuring a minimum of eight (8) feet in height, shall be installed within the required setbacks; said fence shall fea ture one of the following to reduce visibility through the fence: slats constructed of durable material and painted a neutral color, windscreen, or similar mate rial. Materials used for any fe ncing constructed on the Property shall not include untreated wood or barbed wire. (P) 5. Tree-Save Area. Except as may be necessary for the construction of the entrance to the Property and any required road improvements, t he area measuring fifty feet (5 0’) in width from the western boundary of the Property toward the interior of the Property for the length of the Property’s frontage along Old Stage Road shall be prese rved as a “Tree - Save Area.” Within the Tree-Save Area, no trees measuring more than four inches (4”) in caliper (as measured six inches (6”) above grade ) shall be removed unless such removal is necessary to protect the health, safety, or welfare of persons, property, or the overall health of the species within the Tree-Save Area. (P) 6. Permitted Uses. Only the following uses shall be permitted on the P roperty: All by -right uses permitted in the I-1 (Light Industrial District) as well as outdoor storage. (P) Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye 23SN0104: In Dale Magisterial District, Aldous Second Dwelling is a request for conditional use to permit a second dwelling and amendment of zoning district map in a Residential (R-7) District on 1.61 a cres known as 9930 Bresli n Drive. De nsity will be controlled by zoning conditions or ordinance s tandards. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 752-681-1027 Mr. Steve Donohoe presented the case. He re ported t hat staff had received no public opposition to this case and that sta ff had received agr eement to the cond itions from the applicant. There was opportunity for questions by the Commissioners for Mr. Donohoe. There were no questions. Mr. Petroski opened the Public Hearing. There were no public comments reported. Mr. Petros ki asked i f th ere was anyone present who wished to speak in favor of, or in opposition to, the request. No one came forward to speak in favor of, or in opposition to, the request. There being no one to speak, Mr. Petroski closed the Public Hearing. Page 15 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 12 | Pa ge On motion of Mr. Sloan, seconded by Mr. Owens, the Commission resolved to recommend approval of Case 23SN0104 subject to the Conditions. CONDITIONS 1. Occupancy. Occupancy of the second dwelling unit shall be limited to: the occupan ts of the principal dwelling unit, individuals related to them by blood, marriage, adoption, or guardianship, foster children, personal guests, and household employees. (P) 2. Deed Restriction. For the purpose of providing record notice, prior to the issu ance of a certificate of occupancy for the second dwelling unit, a deed restriction shall be recorded setting forth the limitation in Condition 1. The deed book and page nu mber of such restriction and a copy of the restriction as recorded shall be submitte d to the Planning Department. (P) 3. Water Connection . Should the prope rty be legally subdivided in th e future, the owner shall establish separate water connec tions to eac h dwelling unit, subject to the review and approval of the Utilities Department. The owner shall be responsible for all costs to establish the new water connection, including payment of water connection fees in effect at the time service is initiated. (U) Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye (D) DISCUSSION ITEMS. 23SN0083: In Bermuda Magisterial District, J.D. Shelton’s Backhoe Service is a request to rezone from Agricultural (A) to General Industrial (I-2), conditional use planned d evelopment to perm it exceptions to ordinance r equirements, and an exception to Sect ion 18-60 of the Utility Ordinance f or connection to the public was tewater system and amendment of zoning district map on 3.5 acres located in the southwest corner of Old Bermuda Hundred Road and Ramblewood Drive. Densi ty will be controlled by zoning condi tions or ordinance standards. The Co mprehensive Plan suggests the p roperty is appropriate for Suburban Reside ntial II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 806-650-4415 Mr. Joe Feest gave a brief presentation on the case. He stated that this case involves two (2) requests. Request one ( 1) is a request to re zone from Ag ricultural to Genera l Industrial. Request two (2) is for an exception to Section 18-60 of the Utilities Ordinance for connection to the public wastewater system. Mr. Feest explained that a contractor’s office and storage yard uses are planned for the prope rty. Exceptions are being requested which Mr. Feest outlined. He closed by sa ying that s taff recommends approval of Request 1. Utilities staff recommends denial of Request 2. There was op portunity for questions by the Commissioners for Mr. Feest. There were no questions. Page 16 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 13 | Pa ge Mr. Jim Daniels came forward to represent the case. He stated that t he sewer line is over a mile and a half away with no easement to access it. They ask for approval of both requests. Mr. Petroski opened the Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski asked Commissioner Sloan for a summary of submitted comments. Mr. Sloan reported receiving no comments. Mr. Petroski asked if th ere was anyone present who wished to sp eak in fa vor of, or in opposition to, the request. No one came forward to speak in favor or, or in opposition to, the request. There being no one to speak, Mr. Petroski closed the Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski turned the case over to Commissioner Sloan for discussion. Mr. Sloan asked the Commission for a recommendation of support of both requests in this case. On motion of Mr. Sloan, seconded by Mr. Owens, the Commission resolved to re commend approval of requests one (1) and two (2) of Case 23SN0083, subject to the Conditions. CONDITIONS Conditions for Request I: 1. Master Plan. Development of the Property for a contractor's office and storage yard use shall generally conform to the Conceptual Plan (Exhibit A), titled “J.D. Shelto n Backhoe Service Conceptual Plan”, last revised January 22, 2 024, with respect to the general layout of buildings, parking, fen ce or wall, outside storage, acc ess, and setbacks. The layout on the Conceptual Plan is conceptual in nature and may vary based on the final site plan depending on final engineering and envi ronmental studies or as otherwise approved by the Planning Commiss ion at the time of plans review. All other permitted uses for the Property shall conform to Ordinance requirements and shall not be subject to Exhibit A. (P) 2. Uses. Uses shall be limited to those uses permitted by-right or with restrictions in the Light Industrial (I-1) District. In addition, the following General Industrial (I-2) use is also permitted with the following restrictions: a. Contractor's office and storage yard (outside storage). i. One (1) modular office building o r one (1) temporary shed structure shall be permitted for this use only. The exterior of the building or structure shall be maintained to be free of dete rioration such as peeling, graffiti, or a faded appearance. An y repainting of the exte rior shall be don e in a neutral color as approved by the Planning Department. No exterior signage shall be placed on the building or structure. ii. Development of this use shall conform to the Conceptual Plan. (P) Page 17 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 14 | Pa ge 3. Height Restri ction for Outside Storag e. Any outside st orage of materials shall not exceed ten (10) feet in height. (P) 4. Surface Treatment for Drives and Parking Areas . Gravel treatment for drive aisles an d parking areas shall be permitted for a contractor's office and storage yard use only. The use of gravel for parking areas shall comply with the Ordinance requ irements for gravel treatment. Measures shall be taken to control air -borne dust generated by gr avel parking and drives. The entrance/exit to the Property sha ll be paved for a minimu m depth of twenty (20) feet. (P) 5. Setbacks along Major Arterials & Lawi ng Drive . The required setback for buildings, parking, and outside storage areas shall be develo ped under one (1) of the following design scenarios based on the use. a. Contractor's Office & Storag e Yard (Option 1). A mini mum of forty (40) feet from any major arterial road and Lawing Drive. Existing trees and vegetation shall be preserved in the re quired se tbacks along Ramblewood Road, Old Bermuda Hundred Roa d, and Lawing Drive. Whe re supplementatio n is required in these setbacks, the Ordinance requiremen t for Perimeter Landscaping standards shall apply. In addition, an opaque wall or fence that is a minimum of ten (10) feet tall shall be constructed in the ge neral location shown on Exhibit A to scre en the use from each right-of-way. The exact design of th is wall or fence shall be approved at time of plan review. These exceptions shall apply to the c ontractor's office and storage yard use only. b. Permitted I-1 Uses or Contractor's Office & Storage Yard (Option 2). A minimu m of sixty (60) feet from any ma jor arterial road and Lawing Drive. Existing trees and vegetation shall be preserved in the requ ired setbacks along Ramblewood Road, Old Bermuda Hundred Road, and Lawing Drive. Where supplementation is required in these setbacks, the Ordinance requirement for Perimeter Landscaping standards shall apply. These exceptions shall apply to any permitted u se or the contractor's office and storage yard use. c. Design Scenarios. Only one (1 ) design scenario shall be used for the Pr operty. Exceptions shall not be mixed between the two (2) design scenarios. (P) 6. Screening & Setbacks from the Future Old Ber muda Hundred Road and Ramblewood Drive Intersection Improvemen ts. For the contractor's office and stora ge yard use, no structures, storage yard, or parking area s shall be permitted in the area shown as "Preserved Vegetation Area (No Structures)" on the Con ceptual P lan. Existing vegetation shall be retained within this area. This area shall be depicted on the approved site plan to preserve either a forty (40) foot setback with an opaque wall or fence that is a minimum of ten (10) feet tall (Option 1) or a si xty (60) foot setback with no requirement for a fence or wall (Option 2) from the future intersection improvements for Old Bermuda Hundred Road and Ramblewood Drive. (P) 7. Dedication. Prior to final site plan approval or within sixty (60) days of a writt en request by the Transportation Department, whichever occurs first, the following rights -of-way shall be dedicated, free and un restricted, to and for the benef it of Chest erfield County, Page 18 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 15 | Pa ge measured from the centerline of that part of the road immediately adj acent to the Property: a. Forty-five (45) feet on the south side of Old Bermuda Hundred Road; b. Forty-five (45) feet on the west side of Ramblewood Drive; and c. Thirty (30) feet on the east side of Lawing Drive. (T) 8. Access. There shall be no direct vehicular access from the property to Old Bermuda Hundred Road . There shall be no direct vehicular acce ss from the property to Ramblewood Drive, unless otherwise approved by the Transportation Department. (T) 9. Road Improvements. In conjunction with init ial development or prior to issuance of any certificate of occ upancy on the property, whichever occurs first, the owner/develope r shall be responsible for reloc ating the e xisting ditch along Old Bermuda Hundred Road and Ramblewood Drive to provide for an adequate shoulder along both roads. (T) 10. Utility Connection - Public Water. The Property shall connect to the County's public water system. (U) 11. Pre/Post Discharge Rate. The post development 2/10/100 -year peak discharge rates cannot exceed the prede velopment 2/10/100-year peak discharge rates, respectively. (EE) Conditions for Request II: 12. Wastewater Exception. The exce ption to the use of the public w astewater system shall only apply to the 3.5 -acre parcel shown on Exhibit A and shall be limited to the contractor's office and storage yard use. Any developm ent of the Property for any other use will be required to conform to the Code provision at that ti me for conne ction to the public wastewater system. (U) 13. Future Wastewater Connection. If in the future the public wastewater system is extended to within 200 feet of the Property, the property ow ner shall extend a public line to the Property and connec t any buildi ng generating domestic wastewater to the public wastewater system. (U) 14. Wastewater Easeme nts. In conjunction with site plan approval, dedicati on of public wastewater easements across the Property to facilitat e future the extension of future public wast ewater service to adjacent properties, if requested by the Utilities Department. (U) Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye 23SN0091: In Dale Magisterial Dis trict, Cogbill Road New Centralia Water Tank is a request to amend zoning approval (Case 21SN0687) to allow a water tank and co nditional Page 19 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 16 | Pa ge use to permit communications equipmen t collocated on the water to wer (co mmunications tower) an d conditional use planned development to permit e xceptions to ordinance requirements and amendment of zoning district map on 1.8 acres known as 4001 Cog bill Road. Density will be controlled by zoning conditions or o rdinance sta ndards. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property i s appropriate for Suburban Residential II use (2 to 4 dwellings per acre). Tax ID 782-685-0557. Ms. Summer Hob son gave a prese ntation on the case . The request is to amend zoning approval to permit a 146 feet tall water tank. Ms. H obson stated she would be going over the zoning and Comprehensive Plan details for the subject property. The subject property and all surrounding properties are c urrently z oned agricultural. The property is undeveloped and located at the same site as the Park and Ride lot in the case being amended . Ms. Hobson stated that t he previous approval was for a commuter Park and Ride lot to provide ride - sharing opp ortunities and help with traffic congestion. The pri or case had proposals for a District Trans portation office for Chesterfield County Public School s, and for school bus parking and storage for County vehicles. The options were shown and the Park and Ride lot is complete. A fifty ( 50) foot bu ffer was req uired a djacent to Meadowbrook Manor. C onditions of t he previous case were explained. The back half of the Park and Ride was developed for school bus storage. 20 -25 buses will be stored for daily use during the schoo l year . During the summer up to 90 buses will be stored on the lot. A conceptual layout was shown. Ms. Hobson continued by describing the proposed water tank . The wate r tank will be 146 feet tall and painted white, gray, or another neutral color. The tank will be similar to the tank visible on Willis Road. This request amends the buffer conditio n by requiring landscaping and a six ( 6) foot tall fence. Images of the tank were shown which were provided by the Utilities department. Ms. Hobson c oncluded by s aying that s taff recommends approval of the request. The proposed water tank in the Centr alia Pressure Zone will improve the County ’s capacity to provide water services and meet anticipated increases in water demands in the future. It conforms to the Public Facilities Plan and the location of the tower will have minimal impacts on area properties. There was op portunity for questions by the Commissioners for Ms. Hobson or staff. There were no questions. Mr. Matt Rembol d from the Utilities Departm ent came forward to represent the case. He stated he was going to explain the need f or a tank, what the County looks for in a site, and discuss some of the community engagement. Mr. Rembold explained th at the current Centralia water tank was constructed in 1957 and is a small tank at the end of its useful life . The need has out grown the tank and the tank requires extensive maintenance. A new tank would better meet the needs of the County. Mr. Rembold said there are three (3) sources of water in Chesterfield County, one of which is the City of Richmond, and explained the need for increased flow from the Hopkins Road point of entry. A new tank closer to the source allows more water to be s afely withdrawn, and the additional capacity will add reliability and will accommodate growth in Chesterfield County. Page 20 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 17 | Pa ge Mr. Rembold described the proposed tank w hich will be a composite style tank with a reinforced concrete pedestal. It will be painted a neutral color and potential branding is included. The tank site will be protected by security fencing and lan dscaping. The tank will not be l it and allows for an allowance to co-locate cell carriers. Mr. Rembold said that t he adjacent communities did come out for the community meeting, and concerns were heard about the bus sto rage more than the water tank. Staff reviewed the concerns. They offered to provide enhanced landscaping. Should this case be approved, construction traffic wil l access from Cogbill Road using the existing Park and Ride e ntrance. Regarding the schedule, should approval be received, it will take 12 m onths to design, and another 15 -18 months to actually construct the tank. Once the tank is placed into service, they are quiet and no odor is present. They require infrequent visits from staff. Mr. Rembold stat ed that wh en considering a site, they looked for a 2 -acre si te and an appropriate pressure elevation. A higher elevation can provide for a shorter ta nk, minimizing the height impact and associated costs. They try to avoid environmental features and wetlands. They fe el this is the best option for a tank in this area . A 2 -acre site is needed because they need to be able to operate large pieces of equipment for cons truction in addition to having access to the tank. In closing, Mr. Rembold said that t he need for a new C entralia tank was identified in 2016 and they went through an internal site selection process . They brough t forth a s ite last year on Hopkins Road and there were concerns about the close proximity to a residential area. In response to Dr. Hylto n’s request, they did another site search and found the County Park and Ride and bus storage site which seemed like it would be able to be co-used for the water tank. A new application was brought forth in September and two (2) community meetings were held. Mr. Rembol d sho wed the previous sites which had bee n considered. An evaluation matrix was shown which shows this site scored very high in comparison with other sites. Mr. Petroski opened the Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski asked Commissioner Hylton for a summary of submitted comments. Dr. Hylton reported he has no comments to report. Mr. Petroski asked if there was anyone present who wi shed to sp eak in fa vor of, or in opposition to, the request. Mr. Larry Akers came forward to speak regarding the request. He understands the need tor the water tank but the bus parking is a big concern. Diesel mo tors run for 30-40 minutes. He doesn’t think a buffer is going to do anything to help the noise. They are concerned about the noise and the looks of so man y bu ses, a s well as the safe ty of the Park and Ride. He reported concerns about property values. Mr. Owens asked for clarification that this case has nothing to do with the bus parking case and would not change anything about it. Mr. Gillies confirmed. There being no one else to speak, Mr. Petroski closed the Public Hearing. Page 21 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 18 | Pa ge Mr. Rembold came forward to speak in rebuttal. Utilities staff has heard these concerns from citizens, but the tank itself will reduce the number of bus parking spaces and they have done what they can to reduce the impact. Mr. Petroski turned the case over to Commissioner Hylton for discussion. Dr. Hylton wanted to t hank the C ounty staff for their response to his pressing them f or the best location for the water tank. The pros and cons were weighed a nd this location is definitely the best location. The issues heard were about the pr evious case where s chools will park their buses, but nothing about this case will change t hat. The County wants to be a good neighbor and goes through the same process as a private applicant would. On motion of Dr. Hylton, seconded by Ms. Hardin, the Commission resolved to recommend approval of Case 23SN0091 subject to the Conditions. CONDITIONS Condition 1 of Case 21SN0687 is deleted in its entirety and is replaced with: 1. Uses. This conditional use shall permit the following uses on the Property: a park a nd ride parking lot, government building uses, and a wate r storage tank with communications antennas collocated on the tank. Condition 8 of Case 21SN0687 is deleted in its entirety and is replaced with: 2. Buffer. A fifty (50) foot buffer shall be provide d along the eastern property line, adjacent to Meadowbrook Manor subdivision. a. Landscaping shall be planted in the buffer as conceptually shown on the Conceptual Landscape plan titled “Landscaping Plan” and attached hereto as Exhibit D. b. A six (6) feet high black chain-link fence shall be installed approxima tely following the eastern property line of 4003 Cogbill Road according to Exhibit D. c. The landscaping and chain-link fence shall be installed prior to the completion of the proposed water storage tank. The following conditions are here by imposed with approval of this case: 3. Master Plan. The Master Plan for the Property shall consist of the following: a. The site shall be developed in conformance with the conceptual site plan t itled “Conceptual Site Plan” and attached hereto as Exhibit A. b. The pro posed water tank shall be developed in conformance with the conceptual elevations, titled “Conceptual Tank Elevation” and attached hereto as Exhibit B. (P) 4. Screening. a. The eight (8) foot fence, which shall surround the water tank on all sides, and vehicle double gate along the front of the site, and noted on Exhibit A, shall be opaque. b. Additional la ndscaping for enhanced screening shall be planted outside of the perimeter o f the fence to be coordinated with the Planning Department during Site Plan review. 5. Stormwater. The maximum post -development drainage discharge rate for the 100 -year storm shall be based on the maximum capacity of the existing downstream facilities an d shall not incre ase any recorded and/ or established 100 - year backwater and/ or Page 22 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 19 | Pa ge floodplain. On -site detention of the post -development discharge rate for the 100 -year storm to bel ow the pre -development discharge rate may be provided to satisfy this requirement. 6. Communication Tower and Equipment . The communications tower us e shall only be permitted if it is incorporated into the structure of the water storage tank. Eq uipment and cables shall be mounted to minimize their visual impact, and antennas shal l be mounted on the top of the tank. 7. Water Tank Design and Height and setbacks. a. The water storage tank shall be white, grey, or other neutral color, acceptable to the Planning Department. b. Signage on the tank will be blue, gray, black, or other c olor acceptable to the Planning Department. The total sign area shall be n o greater than six hundred (600) square feet. c. The communications equipment (antennas, mountin g hardware, cables, etc.) mounted on the outside of the water tank structure shall be the same or simil ar color as the tank. d. Except for security lighting over the access doors at the base of the tank, the tank and communications equipment shall not be lighted. e. The water tank and associated structures (including communication tower a nd equipment) shall not exceed 146 feet. f. The side yard setback on the western side property line (adjacent to Tax ID 781-685-6979) shall be a minimum of fifty (50) fe et. Landscaping shall be planted in the proposed landscape buffer shown on Exhibit A. Landscaping will be planted as approved by the Planning Department. All other conditions of Case 21SN0687 remain in effect with this approval. Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye 23SN0097 (Deferred from 01/16/2024): In Matoaca Magisterial D istrict, Dabney Special Events B usiness is a request for conditional use to permit a special events busi ness (outdoor pool renta l) inciden tal to a dwelling and amendment of zonin g distri ct map in an Agricultural (A) District on 17.09 acres known as 6101 an d 6111 (access only) Woodpecker Road. Density will be controlled by zoning conditions or ordinance stand ards. The Comprehensive Plan sugge sts the p roperty is appropriate for Resi dential Agricultural use. Tax IDs 780-625-9023 and 7340 (access only). Mr. Joe Feest gave a presentation on the case. The request is for conditional use to permit a special events b usiness in an agricultural district. This application i nvolves two (2) parcels. Mr. Feest explained that the two (2) parcels total 17.09 acres and have a shared driveway. This case only involves the parcel on the southern side. The applicant is on the south side of Woodpecker Road and the property is zoned agricultural. An aerial and land use map was shown. Page 23 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 20 | Pa ge The applicant is seeking approval to permit daily rental of a pool and patio a rea. The special events rental service is advertised online on a website called Swimply . The applicant seeks to hold events for daily use from June 1 through September 15 for not exceeding 30 guests. Approximately 20 parking spaces are provided and guests have access to the pool and patio as well as a bathroom. Mr. Feest concluded by saying that s taff recommends denial and believes there are no conditions that would adequality mitigate the negative impacts of this use. The use would generate noise and traffic which would adversely impact the adjacent properties. The lots are only about 250 feet wide. There is not enough area to separate the use from the adjoin ing property. Mr. Feest stated t hat staff recommends denial of the request because t he use is not compatible with existing area residential us es and diminish es the use and enjoyment of adjacent properties. Should the request be approved, conditions would be imposed which were reviewed. There was opportunity for questions by the Commissioners for Mr. Feest. The applica nt came forward to represent the case. She stated she owns the subj ect property. Mr. Petroski opened the Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski asked Commissioner Owens for a summary of submitted comments. Mr. Owens reported that h e received negative comments from a djacent homeowners for noise, parking, and times they have had to call and have noise reduced. Photos were sent to support the concerns. Mr. Pet roski asked if th ere was anyone present who wi shed to sp eak in fa vor of, or i n opposition to, the request. Mr. John Bleatter came forward to speak in opposition to the request. They live right ne xt door to the applicants. They have had to listen to the no ise for the past year. The neig hbors on the other side have said they hear it inside their house. They bought their home as a quiet retirement location and said they had a realtor come out who said their property value would be adversely affected. Ms. Renae Eldred came for ward to speak in opposition to the request. She said this is a business, and the Swimply website had 33 comments on last year’s activity so it is frequently used. She asked the C ommission to i magine if you have to live next door to some one who had pool parties all day long every day . She urges t he Co mmission to not support t he request. It is a business. There being no one else to speak, Mr. Petroski closed the Public Hearing. The applicant declined the opportunity to speak in rebuttal. Mr. Petroski turned the case over to Commissioner Owens for discussion. Page 24 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 21 | Pa ge Mr. Owens sai d it is a special events business. Typically, an agricultural district can be allowed four special events per year, but in this case close proximity to the neighbors is an issue. This is too intensive of a use for this area. On motion of Mr. Owens, seconded by Mr. Slo an, the Commission resolved to re commend denial of Case 23SN0097. Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye 23SN0107: In Bermuda M agisterial District, Bermuda Orchar d Lane Comm unications Tower Amendme nt is a request to amend zoning approva l (Case 11SN0100) relative to communication tower height and design and amendm ent of zoning district map in Agricultural (A) and General Business ( C-5) Districts on 1.1 acres frontin g 20 feet o n the south line of East Hundred Road, 740 feet east of Rivers Bend Boulevard. Density will be controlled by zoning con ditions or ordinance s tandards. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Community Business uses. Tax ID 816-651-Parts of 0395 and 5749; and 816-652-Part of 0411. Mr. Joe Feest gave a presentation on the case. The request is a proposal to amend approval for a 149 foot cell tower which currently exists on the s ite. The applicant desires to ex tend the height of the cell tower by fifty (50) feet to be able to install sector arr ays for the exterior. Mr. Feest said that t he subject property is zoned Agricultural and General Business and has direct vehicular access to Route 10. The proposed height change requires amendment of prior zoning approval. The applicant states that the proposal will provide the infrastructure needed for Verizon Wireless to expand and improve their service t o residents in the area. The applicant has indic ated that the tower as proposed would minimize capacity i ssues for cellular service in the area and would be designed to accommodate additional carriers. The proposed Network Solutions tower was granted zoning approval in October 2023 and is 1200 feet from this request site. Mr. Feest said as of tonight, we do not have a site plan submitted for th e approved tower. Staff notes that both applicants cited the same need to accommodate equipment for Verizon Wireless. This applicant’s request would allow for two (2) towers within close proximity to each other that would provide comparable service. Mr. Feest closed by saying that staff finds the applicant’s proposal d oes no t s upport the County’s goal of minimizing towers an d therefore recommends denial of the req uest. The proposed change in height will also increase the visibility of the tower. There was op portunity for questions by the Commissioners for Mr. Feest. There w ere no questions. Mr. Ed Donoh ue came forward to represent the case. He th anked Mr. Feest for the presentation but stated tha t he thinks we have th is backwards. The opportunity for co - location is the opportunity to modify and improve the tower which is existing since 2011. The height was limited. Network Solutions was only approved back in October with sector arrays. Page 25 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 22 | Pa ge Additional height and sec tor arrays are what is being asked for , and this tower is already in place. Mr. Donohue stated that in our Comprehensive Plan we encourage co -location on existing infrastructure, which their tower is. We ap pear to have gone to the full sector array technology which is what w as approved in October. They ask that we consider the same modification request f rom them. They consi der themselves to be the poster child for co - location. Mr. Petroski opened the Public Hearing. Mr. Petroski asked Commissioner Sloan for a summary of subm itted comments. Mr. Sloan stated he had no comments to report. Mr. Pet roski asked if th ere was anyone present who wi shed to sp eak in fa vor of, or in opposition to, the request. Mr. Wi ll Shewmake came f orward to s peak in opposition of the r equest. He represents Network Solutions Towers. His client is closely working with Verizon and are actively moving forward. Ms. Renae Eldred came forward to speak in opposition of the request. She said no one likes to look at cell towers but everyone wants good service. This tower has been here since 2011 and has never come forward unt il now to make any improvemen ts. The one that w as recently approved should be the only one. We don’t need another. There being no one else to speak, Mr. Petroski closed the Public Hearing. The applicant came forward to spea k in rebuttal. There has been no site plan for the approved tower submitted. The ir tower that has been there i s asking to b e allowed to co - locate. Mr. Petroski turned the case over to Commissioner Sloan for discussion. Mr. Sloan asked the Commissioners to support a recommendation of denial. On motion of Mr. Sloan, seconded by Dr. Hylton, the Commission resolved to re commend denial of Case 23SN0107. Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye Page 26 of 87 2-20-24 DRAFT Minutes/KE 23 | Pa ge 13. CITIZEN COM MENT PERIOD ON UNSCHEDULED MATTERS INVOLVING THE SE RVICES, POLICIES AND AF FAIRS OF T HE CO UNTY GOVERNMENT REGARDING PLANNING O R LAND USE ISSUES. There were no citizen comments on unscheduled matters. 14. OTHER BUSINESS. There was no other business. 15. ADJOURNMENT. There being no further b usiness to come b efore th e Commission, on motion of Mr. Owens , seconded by Dr. Hylton, the meeting adjourned at 7:30 p.m. to 12:00 p.m. on Tuesday, March 19, 2024. Mr. Petroski aye Mr. Sloan aye Ms. Hardin aye Dr. Hylton aye Mr. Owens aye ______________________________________ Chairman/Date ______________________________________ Secretary/Date Page 27 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 1 of 11 23SN0053 – Unity Church of Bon Air Sign Magisterial District – Midlothian Applicant – Rusty Rothrock (804-334-3307) CPC Public Hearing – March 19, 2024 Time Remaining 100 Days Case Manager Haley Gist (804-748-1071) Request Conditional Use & Conditional Use Planned Development A freestanding sign with a changeable copy component is proposed for Unity Church of Bon Air. Staff Recommendation Approval The Property 923 and 925 Buford Road Site Size 4.53 Acres Comprehensive Plan – Land Use Designation Suburban Residential II Plan Area County Wide Plan Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Area Map of Request & Land Use Plan Map Request for a conditional use to permit a changeable copy sign within a Residential (R-15) District, plus conditional use planned development for exceptions to ordinance standards for a freestanding sign. A changeable copy component incorporated into the freestandi ng identification sign for the Unity Church of Bon Air is planned. Exceptions relative to the sign’s area and height are also requested. Summary of Proposal Page 28 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 2 of 11 STAFF - APPROVAL Staff recommends approval of this request. The proposed sign will improve identification for Unity Church of Bon Air and foster community communication. The requested sign area and height exception is compatible to the permitted sign area and height for churches where the sign is located on the premises. As conditioned, the proposed sign will have minimal impacts on area development. NOTES FOR THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND BOARD OF SUPERVISORS 1. Conditions may be imposed. 2. Conditions have been identified in this report. 3. Conceptual sign elevations have been provided. Recommendations Page 29 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 3 of 11 Summary of Proposal .............................................................................................................................................................. 1 Recommendations .................................................................................................................................................................. 2 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 6 Supplemental Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................ 7 Community Enhancement .................................................................................................................................................. 7 Environmental Engineering ................................................................................................................................................. 7 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................... 7 Police ................................................................................................................................................................................... 7 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................... 7 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................... 7 Utilities – Water and Wastewater ...................................................................................................................................... 7 Community Engagement & Public Hearings ........................................................................................................................... 8 Conditions ............................................................................................................................................................................... 9 Conceptual Plan – Exhibit A .................................................................................................................................................. 10 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 11 Table of Contents Page 30 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 4 of 11 Zoning History 21SN01617: Approved (8/2021) Request for a conditional use to permit the Unity Church of Bon Air to operate a private school, incidental to an existing church in a Residential (R-15) District. Conditions of approval were as follows: 1. Use. The private school shall only be permitted in conjunction with the church use. (P) 2. Expansion of the Use. There shall be no exterior additions or alterations to the existing structures to accommodate this use. (P) 3. Enrollment. School enrollment shall be limited to thirty (30) children. (P) 4. Hours of Operation. Hours and days of operation shall be limited to Monday through Friday from 8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. (P) Comprehensive Plan – Land Use Plan Designation The Comprehensive Plan designates the Property for Suburban Residential II, which suggests the Property is appropriate for residential development at a maximum density of 2.0 to 4.0 dwellings per acre. Proposal Currently the church has a freestanding sign containing the Church’s name, phone number and a web address. A changeable copy sign is proposed to be incorporated into a new freestanding sign identifying Unity Church of Bon Air and will also incorporate a changeable copy message, which will be presented by changing the message at the discretion of the church. The sign will comply with Ordinance requirements for a freestanding sign relative to setbacks and landscaping. An exception is requested for the sign area and height (Conditions 3 and 4). The applicant’s initial request was for a computer controlled variable message electronic (EMC) sign. After hearing opposition from the community regarding EMC signs in this area, relative to visual impacts of an EMC sign and neighborhood preservation, the applicant changed their sign type from an EMC sign to a changeable copy sign. Signs along collector roads are not permitted to have changeable copy. Since this sign is proposed along a collector road, conditional use is necessary. Figure 1: Original sign on the left and proposed replacement sign with changeable copy on the right. Planning Page 31 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 5 of 11 Ordinance Exceptions The Ordinance permits signs with a maximum sign area of sixteen (16) square feet and height of eight (8) feet on the property. The applicant’s proposed freestanding sign requires an exception to the sign area and height because the proposed sign area is 31.2 square feet, and the proposed height is 8.4 feet as shown in Figure 1 above and on the conceptual plan in Exhibit A. Findings While the proposed freestanding sign will contain a changeable copy component and will be located along a collector road, the sign will better identify Unity Church of Bon Air and facilitate community communication to vehicular traffic passing the site. The design of the proposed sign provides architectural compatibility to Unity Church of Bon Air, creating a uniform appearance. As conditioned, the modified development standards of this request will be no less beneficial to adjoining property owners and provide integrated development. Page 32 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 6 of 11 Current Zoning Map Page 33 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 7 of 11 No comment on this request. No comment on this request. Service Area The Buford Fire Station, Company Number 9 Additional Information This request will have minimal impacts on Fire & Emergency Medical Services. Division Beat District Swift Creek 10 Midlothian Additional Information This request is anticipated to have minimal impacts on Police. This request will have no impact on the transportation network. The Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) has reviewed zoning Case 23SN0053 to request a conditional use for a changeable copy sign and conditional use planned development for exceptions to ordinance requirements for sign area and height. The location of the proposed sign appears to be outside of the rights-of-way (ROW). Although outside of ROW, please ensure the sign is installed outside of the clear zone (at least seventeen (17) feet from the edge of the travel way), and please ensure the proposed sign follows VDOT outdoor advertising regulations currently found in the Code of Virginia Title 33.2 Chapter 12 and all other applicable outdoor advertising laws and mandates. 1. The proposed changeable copy sign will not encroach into an adjacent public water line easement or impact the public water system. 2. The U�li�es Department supports this request. Supplemental Analysis Community Enhancement Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Police Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Page 34 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 8 of 11 Community Meetings A virtual community meeting was held on July 12, 2023 , for the original request of a computer controlled variable message electronic (EMC) sign. Nine (9) members of the public attended this meeting. In lieu of a second community meeting , the District Commissioner instructed the applicant to send a letter to each adjacent property owner and attendees of the first community meeting . The letter referenced the revision to the application to remove the EMC portion of the a pplication and replace it with a changeable copy instead. All recipients were instructed to respond with their respective views. The applicant received two (2) letters in response supporting the changeable copy sign. 7/12/2023 – Discussion Topics: 1. Appropriateness of EMC signage for this area. 2. Visual impacts of an EMC sign. 3. Preservation of neighborhood character. Community Engagement & Public Hearings Page 35 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 9 of 11 1. Sign Design and Location. The sign shall be designed generally as shown on Exhibit A. (P) 2. Changeable Copy Component. The changeable copy component of the freestanding sign shall be permitted as shown on Exhibit A. (P) 3. Sign Area. The freestanding sign shall not exceed a sign area of 31.2 square feet. (P) 4. Sign Height. The freestanding sign shall not exceed a height of 8.4 feet. (P) Conditions Page 36 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 10 of 11 Conceptual Plan – Exhibit A Page 37 of 87 Unity Church of Bon Air Sign 23SN0053 Page 11 of 11 Applicant • Applicant’s Contact: Rusty Rothrock (804-334-3307) rustyr3@gmail.com District Planning Commissioner • Frank Petroski (804-768-7558) petroskif@chesterfield.gov Staff • Planning Department Case Manager: Haley Gist (804-748-1071) gistha@chesterfield.gov • Budget & Management: David Oakley (804-706-2586) oakleyd@chesterfield.gov • Community Enhancement: Ted Barclay (804-748-1802) barclayt@chesterfield.gov • Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov • Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Anthony Batten (804-717-6167) battena@chesterfield.gov • Libraries: Jennifer Stevens (804-751-4998) stevensj@chesterfield.gov • Parks & Recreation: Stuart Connock (804-751-4484) connocks@chesterfield.gov • Police: Jim Eicher (804-318-8693) eicherj@chesterfield.gov • Schools: David Oakley (804-706-2586) oakleyd@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation: Dustin Dunnagan (804-674-2384) dustin.dunnagan@vdot.virginia.gov • Utilities: Randy Phelps (804-796-7126) phelpsc@chesterfield.gov Case Contacts Page 38 of 87 Conditional use to permit a changeable copy sign plus  conditional use planned development to permit exceptions to  ordinance requirements in a Residential (R‐15) District. Rusty Rothrock (Unity Church of Bon Air) 23SN0053 – Midlothian Case 23SN0053, in the Midlothian Magisterial District, is a request for a conditional use to  permit a changeable copy sign plus conditional use planned development for exceptions to  development standards for a freestanding sign. A freestanding sign with a changeable copy  component is proposed for Unity Church of Bon Air .  1 Page 39 of 87 23SN0053 –O v e r v i e w 1. Permit  a freestanding sign  with a changeable copy  component 2. Permit  freestanding sign to  exceed sign area and height 3. Staff  recommends approval  Overview slide.  2 Page 40 of 87 23SN0053 –Z o n i n g Map The subject properties, which are zoned Residential (R‐15) and total 4.53 acres, are shown  outlined in red. All properties surrounding the subject properties are also zoned Residential  (R‐15).  Conditional use to permit a changeable copy sign at Unity Church of Bon Air is requested.  Conditional use planned development is also requested to permit exceptions to ordinance  standards relative to sign area and height.  Staff recommends approval of this request.  3 Page 41 of 87 23SN0053 –A e r i a l & Land Use Plan Map The aerial map on the left shows the subject properties outlined in white.  The Land Use Plan map on the right shows the subject properties outlined in white and  that they are designated as Suburban Residential II.  4 Page 42 of 87 23SN0053 –P r o p o s e d Sign Design This slide shows the proposed design for the freestanding sign. Approval of conditional use  is necessary because this sign is being proposed along a collector road where changeable  copy signs are specifically prohibited by the ordinance.  The applicant’s proposed freestanding sign requires an exception to the sign area, as well  as the sign height. The ordinance limits this sign to a sign area of sixteen (16) square feet  and height of eight (8) feet. The proposed sign area is 31.2 square feet and 8.4 feet in  height. Therefore, conditional use planned development to permit exceptions is necessary.  5 Page 43 of 87 23SN0053 – Recommendation 1. Staff Recommendation  – Approval  While the proposed freestanding sign will contain a changeable copy component and will  be located along a collector road, the sign will better identify Unity Church of Bon Air and  facilitate community communication to vehicular traffic passing the site.  The design of the proposed sign provides architectural compatibility to Unity Church of Bon  Air, creating a uniform appearance.  As conditioned, the modified development standards of this request will be no less  beneficial to adjoining property owners and provide integrated development. Staff  recommends approval of this request.   6 Page 44 of 87 23SN0053 –Z o n i n g Map End of presentation.  7 Page 45 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 1 of 12  23SN0056 – Kingsland Acres Buffer                          Setback Reduction   Magisterial District – Bermuda  Applicant – Elizabeth Floyd (804‐892‐5680)   CPC Public Hearing – March 19, 2024    Time Remaining  100 Days    Case Manager  Harold Ellis  (804‐768‐7592)    Request  Conditional Use Planned Development  A reduction in required buffer width and planting  requirements, and setbacks is requested.      Staff Recommendation  Approval  The Property  3530 Kingsland Road  Site Size  2.02 Acres  Comprehensive Plan –  Land Use Designation  Suburban Residential II  Plan Area   County Wide Plan  Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS      Figure 2: Area Map of Request & Land Use Plan Map      Subdivision of the property into three (3) single‐family residential lots is planned.  Exceptions are requested as at time  of subdivision the required buffer width and planting requirements and setback for proposed Lot 1 of the subject  property will not be met. Accordingly, the applicant is requesting conditional use planned development approval for  buffer and setback requirements.     Summary of Proposal  Page 46 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 2 of 12  STAFF ‐ APPROVAL  Staff recommends approval.   No adverse impacts are anticipated for adjacent or nearby properties as a result of this  request.     NOTES FOR THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND BOARD OF SUPERVISORS  1. Conditions may be imposed, or the property owner may proffer conditions.  2. Proffered conditions, Textual Statement, and a conceptual plan have been submitted by the applicant.   3. Staff recommends acceptance of the proffered conditions offered by the applicant.       Recommendations  Page 47 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 3 of 12    Summary of Proposal .............................................................................................................................................................. 1  Recommendations .................................................................................................................................................................. 2  Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 3  Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 4  Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 6  Supplemental Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................ 7  Community Enhancement .................................................................................................................................................. 7  Environmental Engineering ................................................................................................................................................. 7  Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................... 7  Police ................................................................................................................................................................................... 7  Transportation ‐ County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................... 7  Transportation ‐ Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................... 7  Utilities – Water and Wastewater ...................................................................................................................................... 8  Community Engagement ........................................................................................................................................................ 9  Conditions ............................................................................................................................................................................. 10  Proposed Subdivision Plan – Exhibit A .................................................................................................................................. 11  Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 12         Table of Contents  Page 48 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 4 of 12  Comprehensive Plan – Land Use Plan Designation  The Comprehensive Plan designates the Property for Suburban Residential II, which suggests the Property is appropriate  for residential development at a maximum density of 2.0 to 4.0 dwellings per acre.    Proposal  The applicant is proposing subdivision of the 2.02 acre property to permit three (3) single family lots known as  “Kingsland Acres, SecƟon 6”. Upon subdivision of the property, forty‐five (45) feet of right‐of‐way will be required to be  dedicated for all three (3) proposed lots.  Additionally, a fifty (50) foot buffer will be required along Kingsland Road, from  which, a thirty (30) foot front setback is required for primary dwellings. The applicant is requesting an exception to  eliminate the buffer requirement for Lot 1 only to preserve the existing single family home located on the property.  Additionally, a setback exception is requested to permit the existing home on Lot 1 to be a minimum twelve (12) feet  from the ultimate right‐of‐way (ROW). All buffer and setback requirements for proposed Lots 2 and 3 will be met where  new single family homes are planned.  All other zoning ordinance requirements for the subject property will be met.   The conditions in this report address the exceptions to buffering and setback requirements for lot 1 as proposed. Figure  3 illustrates the planned three (3) lot subdivision.                                                                 Figure 2: Excerpt from proposed subdivision plat      Planning  Ultimate ROW Dedication  (Addt’l 45’ from centerline)  Required Vegetative Buffer (50’)  Required Building Setback (30’)  Existing Property Line  Page 49 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 5 of 12  The blue line on the exhibit above illustrates the limits of the right of way (ROW) dedication required at time of plat.   The orange line represents the buffer required after the dedication. Finally, the purple line represents a thirty (30) feet  front yard setback from the buffer. At time of subdivision proposed lots two (2) and three (3) will be required to meet  the buffer after dedication, and the future homes will be required to meet the setback from the buffer.  However, the  existing home on Lot 1 requires an exception to the required front yard setback and elimination of the buffer.    Staff is supportive of the requested buffer elimination and reduction in required setback for proposed Lot 1 to a  minimum of twelve (12) feet.  As stated, the two additional lots will meet all Ordinance requirements for buffer and  setbacks.     Figure 3, below, is an image showing the existing home on Lot 1.                                                      Figure 3: Image showing existing home on Lot 1    Ordinance Exceptions  The applicant proposes the following exceptions to Ordinance requirements for Lot 1 only of the proposed subdivision:     Buffer  o A fifty (50) foot buffer along Kingsland Road required per ordinance, conditions of approval allow the  buffer to be eliminated on proposed Lot 1 only.   Setbacks:  o A thirty (30) foot front yard setback is required per ordinance.  Conditions of approval allow the existing  home on proposed Lot 1 to have a twelve (12) feet setback in order to preserve the existing home.    Staff is supportive of these exceptions for the proposed subdivision in order to preserve the existing home on the  property. The exceptions in this request are solely for the purpose of promoting an integrated  plan that is no less  beneficial to the occupants of the development and other area properties than what would be obtained with the  requirements of the Zoning Ordinance.           Page 50 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 6 of 12        Current Zoning Map  Page 51 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 7 of 12      No comment on this request.    No comment on this request.      Service Area  The Centralia Fire Station, Company Number 17  Additional Information  This request will have minimal impacts on Fire & Emergency Medical Services.      Division  Beat   District  Falling Creek  51  Bermuda  Additional Information  This request is anticipated to have minimal impacts on Police.    This request will have no impact on the transportation network.       The Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) has reviewed zoning Case 23SN0056 to request a Conditional Use  Planned Development for exceptions to the zoning ordinance for the dwelling to remain on Lot 1 within the proposed  subdivision.  The existing house as shown on the submitted plat (Case 23FP0005) will encroach into the buffer and not  meet the minimum setback. Relief to the buffer planting requirement (Landscape C) is also requested. This request  appears to only be looking for exceptions to minimum setback and buffer planting requirements; there looks to be no  impact on VDOT maintained rights‐of‐way (ROW) and VDOT offers no comment at this time.  VDOT recommends Lots 2  and 3 share an entrance location to minimize access point locations along Kingsland Road.                  Supplemental Analysis  Community Enhancement  Environmental Engineering  Fire & Emergency Medical Services  Police  Transportation ‐ County Department of Transportation  Transportation ‐ Virginia Department of Transportation  Page 52 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 8 of 12  1. The request property is located within a mandatory public water and wastewater connecƟon area for new  residenƟal development.  2. The proposed three lot subdivision, “Kingsland Acres, SecƟon 6” , will be recorded with a requirement for  connecƟon to the public water and wastewater systems.   3. The exisƟng residenƟal structure, which will remain on Lot 1, is connected to the public water and wastewater  systems.  The proposed buffer reducƟon necessary for that structure to remain will not impact the public water  and wastewater systems.  4. The UƟliƟes Department supports this request.          Utilities – Water and Wastewater  Page 53 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 9 of 12    Community Meetings   2/8/2024 – A virtual community meeting was scheduled.  No members of the public signed up to attend and  subsequently the meeting was cancelled.        Community Engagement   Page 54 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 10 of 12      1. Buffer:  There shall be no buffer requirement for proposed Lot 1 as shown on Exhibit A. (P)    2. Setbacks:  The required front yard setback for the existing home on Lot 1 shall be reduced to twelve (12) feet as  shown on Exhibit A. Should the dwelling be removed or demolished, all new construction shall meet current  ordinance requirements. (P)                                                                                  Conditions   Page 55 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 11 of 12        Proposed Subdivision Plan – Exhibit A  Page 56 of 87 Kingsland Acres Buffer Setback Reduction   23SN0056       Page 12 of 12    Applicant   Applicant’s Contact:  Elizabeth Floyd (804‐892‐5680)  request@va‐surveys.com  District Planning Commissioner  Gib Sloan (804‐892‐5633)  sloang@chesterfield.gov  Staff  Planning Department Case Manager: Harold Ellis (804‐768‐7592) ellish@chesterfield.gov     Community Enhancement: Ted Barclay (804‐748‐1802) barclayt@chesterfield.gov     Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804‐748‐1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov    Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Anthony Batten (804‐717‐6167) battena@chesterfield.gov     Parks & Recreation: Stuart Connock (804‐751‐4484) connocks@chesterfield.gov     Police: Jim Eicher (804‐318‐8693) eicherj@chesterfield.gov     Transportation ‐ County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804‐751‐4461)  adamsst@chesterfield.gov     Transportation ‐ Virginia Department of Transportation: Dustin Dunnagan (804‐674‐2384)  dustin.dunnagan@vdot.virginia.gov     Utilities: Randy Phelps (804‐796‐7126) phelpsc@chesterfield.gov    Case Contacts  Page 57 of 87 Conditional use planned development to permit exceptions to  ordinance requirements in an Residential (R‐7) District on  2.02 acres . Kingsland Acres Buffer and Setback Reduction  23SN0056 – Bermuda 23SN0056, in the Bermuda District, is a request for conditional use planned development  to permit exceptions to ordinance requirements in an R‐7 District on 2.02 acres. 1 Page 58 of 87 23SN0056 –O v e r v i e w 1. Three  lot subdivision  proposed necessitating CUPD  for Buffer and Setback  requirements • 50’ buffer + plantings • 30’ front setback (45’ ROW dedication) 2. Exception only  for Lot 1 3. No  adverse impacts 4. Staff  recommends approval The applicant is proposing to subdivide one lot into three.  In order to do so, the applicant  is requesting a conditional use planned development for buffering and setback  requirements.  For lot 1, which has an existing house, the applicant is requesting  elimination of the required buffer and a setback exception in order to maintain the existing  home after the required platting ROW dedication.  Additionally, the applicant is requesting  that existing trees on Lot 1 count towards the buffer landscaping requirements.  Lots two  and three of the subdivision will meet all ordinance requirements.  No adverse impacts are  anticipated based on the request and staff recommends approval. 2 Page 59 of 87 23SN0056 –Z o n i n g Map The subject property, outlined in red above, is located along the north side of Kingsland  Road, east of Firethrone Lane.  The zoning of the property and all surrounding properties is  residential (R‐7). 3 Page 60 of 87 23SN0056 –A e r i a l & Land Use Plan Map The subject property is outlined in white above.  As illustrated on the aerial map, the  property is currently developed with one residential home, and the land use map shows  the land use designation for the property is Suburban Residential‐II. 4 Page 61 of 87 23SN0056 –E x c e r p t from Concept Plan The applicant is proposing subdivision of the 2.02 acre property to permit three (3)  single family lots known as “Kingsland Acres, Section 6” . Upon subdivision of the  property, forty‐five (45) feet of right‐of‐way will be required to be dedicated for all  three (3) proposed lots.  Additionally, a fifty (50) foot buffer will be required along  Kingsland Road, from which, a thirty (30) foot front setback is required for primary  dwellings. The applicant is requesting an exception to eliminate the buffer  requirement for Lot 1 only to preserve the existing single family home located on  the property. Additionally, a setback exception is requested to permit the existing  home on Lot 1 to be a minimum twelve (12) feet from the ultimate right‐of‐way  (ROW).  All buffer and setback requirements for proposed Lots 2 and 3 will be met  where new single family homes are planned.  All other zoning ordinance  requirements for the subject property will be met.   5 Page 62 of 87 23SN0056 – Recommendation Approval Staff recommends approval.  No adverse impacts are anticipated. 6 Page 63 of 87 23SN0056 –Z o n i n g Map 7 Page 64 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 1 of 14 23SN0121 – Studio M Training Magisterial District – Matoaca Applicant – Caitlen Manning (804-691-4776) CPC Public Hearing – March 19, 2024 Time Remaining 100 Days Case Manager Richard Saunders (804-796-7192) Request Conditional Use Conditional use to permit a business (fitness training) incidental to a dwelling in an Agricultural (A) District. Staff Recommendation Approval The Property 17600 Elko Road Site Size 1.8 Acres Comprehensive Plan – Land Use Designation Low Density Residential Plan Area County Wide Plan Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Area Map of Request & Land Use Plan Map A private and group fitness training business consisting of indoor exercise activities is currently operating within the 2,920 square foot detached accessory structure. A previous zoning case (18SN0841) authorized the business through a conditional use but has since expired. Conditions of the original approval restricted the number of clients, employees and vehicles on the property at any one time. The applicant is requesting to amend the conditions of the original case to allow for expansion of the business. Summary of Proposal Page 65 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 2 of 14 STAFF - APPROVAL Staff recommends approval. All adjacent property owners signed a letter expressing support for the case. Conditions minimize impacts on surrounding residential properties. NOTES FOR THE PLANNING COMMISSION AND BOARD OF SUPERVISORS 1. Conditions may be imposed. 2. Conditions and a proposed layout plan have been identified in this report. Recommendation Page 66 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 3 of 14 Summary of Proposal .............................................................................................................................................................. 1 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 7 Supplemental Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................ 8 Community Enhancement .................................................................................................................................................. 8 Environmental Engineering ................................................................................................................................................. 8 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................... 8 Police ................................................................................................................................................................................... 8 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................... 9 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................... 9 Utilities – Water and Wastewater ...................................................................................................................................... 9 Community Engagement & Public Hearings ......................................................................................................................... 10 Conditions ............................................................................................................................................................................. 11 Site Layout – Exhibit A ........................................................................................................................................................... 12 Case 18SN0841 Approved Conditions .................................................................................................................................. 13 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 14 Table of Contents Page 67 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 4 of 14 Zoning History 18SN0841: Approved (10/2018) Conditional use to permit a business (fitness training) incidental to a dwelling in an Agricultural (A) District. Conditions of approval included: 1. Use is not transferable with ownership. 2. Limitation on use 3. Time limitation of 5 years 4. Limitation on hours of operation 5. No expansion of use 6. Employees limited to applicant and family members living in the home. 7. No more than six (6) clients on the premises at one time 8. No signs identifying the use. 9. No more than eight (8) vehicles, other than applicant’s vehicles, on the premises at one time Comprehensive Plan – Land Use Plan Designation The Comprehensive Plan designates the Property for Low Density Residential, which suggests the Property is appropriate for residential development at a maximum density of 1.0 dwellings per acre. Proposal A group fitness training business has been operating on the subject property since 2018. A conditional use (18SN0841) for the business was approved in October 2018 and expired in October 2023. The applicant utilizes a detached accessory structure, approximately 2,920 square feet in area, as a gym and training area. The applicant indicates that no outdoor exercises take place on the premises. The Planning Commission recommended approval and the Board of Supervisors approved Case 18SN0841 with conditions imposed to help mitigate impacts on the surrounding neighborhood. The original case limited group instruction to no more than six (6) clients at any one time and limited employees to only the applicant and any family member employees living in the home and was approved for a time period of five (5) years. With this application for renewal the applicant requests to remove the limitation on the number of clients on the premises at any one time , to increase the number of employees who do not reside in the home to two (2) employees, and to modify the hours of operation . As proposed, no more than one employee would be permitted to work on the premises at any one time. Staff recommends approval of the request. As shown in Figure 4, the fitness studio is located further from the street than the main house and does not detract from the residential character of the area. Ample parking is provided to accommodate the increase in class size as shown in Exhibit A . Figure 3 is an aerial image of the subject property, showing its relationship to other residential properties in the area, and Figure 4 is an image of the fitness studio on the subject property as viewed from Elko Road. Planning Page 68 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 5 of 14 Figure 3: Aerial of current residential development in the area (Subject Parcel in Blue) Figure 4: View of studio and parking from Elko Road Page 69 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 6 of 14 Figure 5, below, highlights the approved conditions of Case No. 18SN0841 and the applicant’s proposed conditions to accommodate the existing operations of the business. Staff recommends approval of the request, as support has been expressed by adjacent property owners and ample parking is provided to accommodate the increase in class size. Should this request be approved, staff recommends the conditions shown in Figure 5 and in the conditions included in this report. Figure 5: Requested Conditions Requirements Approved Conditions of 18SN0841 Applicant’s Request and Recommended Conditions for 23SN0121 Ownership Limited to the applicant only No change Use Fitness training limited to only indoors within the 2,920 square foot detached accessory building No change Time Limitation 5 Years Remove time limitation Hours of Operation Monday-Thursday, 6:00 a.m. – 11:30 a.m., and 3:00 p.m. – 6:30 p.m.; Friday 8:00 a.m. – 11:30 a.m.; no weekend operation Monday-Thursday, 6:00 a.m. – 11:30 a.m., and 3:00 p.m. – 6:30 p.m.; Friday 6:00 a.m. – 9:30 a.m.; Saturday 8:30 a.m. – 9:30 a.m.; no Sunday operation Expansion of Use Alteration and/or expansion prohibited No change Employees No employees other than family member employees who reside in the home Up to two (2) employees who do not reside in the home. No more than one (1) employee shall be on site at any one time. Group Instruction No more than six (6) clients on the premises at any one time All activities for the business shall be conducted indoors. Signs No signs permitted to identify the use No change Parking No more than eight (8) vehicles, other than the applicant’s vehicles, shall be parked on the premises at one time. No more than fifteen (15) vehicles, including the applicant’s vehicles, shall be parked on the premises at one time. Page 70 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 7 of 14 Current Zoning Map Page 71 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 8 of 14 No comment on this request. No comment on this request. Service Area The Matoaca Station, Company Number 8 Additional Information This request will have minimal impacts on Fire & Emergency Medical Services. Division Beat District Appomattox 78 Matoaca Additional Information This request is anticipated to have minimal impacts on Police. Supplemental Analysis Community Enhancement Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Police Page 72 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 9 of 14 This request will have a minimal impact on the transportation network. The Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) has reviewed zoning Case 23SN0121 and recommends evaluating the commercial entrance based on the proposed increase in capacity. If the use generates fifty (50) or more vehicles per day, then it is recommended that the entrance be improved to meet moderate commercial entrance standards (per Appendix F of the VDOT Road Design Manual). 1. The exis�ng residence on the request property is served by a private well and sep�c system, as public water and wastewater service is not available in that area. 2. The U�li�es Department supports this request. Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Page 73 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 10 of 14 Community Meetings Signed letters of support for the proposal were received from each of the adjacent property owners in lieu of a community meeting. Planning Commission 2/20/2024: ACTION - DEFERRED TO MARCH 19, 2024 ON THE COMMISSION’S OWN MOTION WITH THE APPLICANT’S CONSENT. Community Engagement & Public Hearings Page 74 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 11 of 14 1. Non-Transferable Ownership. This Conditional Use approval shall be granted to and for Caitlin Manning, exclusively, and shall not be transferable or run with the land. (P) 2. Use Limitation. This Conditional Use approval shall be for the operation of a business (fitness training) with group instruction, incidental to a dwelling. The use shall be limited to only indoor activities and equipment within the 2,920 square foot detached accessory building, as depicted on the site layout in Exhibit A. (P) 3. Hours of Operation. Hours of operation shall be limited to the following: a. Monday – Thursday, 6:00 a.m. – 11:30 a.m., and 3:00 p.m. – 6:30 p.m. b. Friday, 6:00 a.m. – 9:30 a.m. c. Saturday, 8:30 a.m. – 9:30 a.m. d. There shall be no operation of the use on Sunday. (P) 4. Expansion of Use. No new building construction shall be permitted to accommodate this use, unless as otherwise required by code to accommodate handicapped accessibility. (P) 5. Employees. Employees working on the premises shall be limited to the applicant, any family member employees living in the home, and up to two (2) employees who do not reside in the home. No more than one (1) employee shall be working on site at any one time. (P) 6. Group Instruction. All activities for the business shall be conducted indoors. (P) 7. Signage. No signs shall be permitted to identify this use. (P) 8. Parking. No more than fifteen (15) vehicles, including the applicant’s vehicles, shall be parked on the premises at any one time. Parking for these vehicles shall be restricted to the area designated in Exhibit A. (P) Conditions Page 75 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 12 of 14 Site Layout – Exhibit A Page 76 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 13 of 14 Case 18SN0841 Approved Conditions Page 77 of 87 Studio M Training 23SN0121 Page 14 of 14 Applicant • Applicant’s Contact: Caitlen Manning (804-691-4776) caitlen.manning@gmail.com District Planning Commissioner • Tommy Owens (804-869-2214) owenstommy@chesterfield.gov Staff • Planning Department Case Manager: Richard Saunders (804-796-7192) saundersri@chesterfield.gov • Budget & Management: David Oakley (804-706-2586) oakleyd@chesterfield.gov • Community Enhancement: Carl Schlaudt (804-318-8674) schlaudtc@chesterfield.gov • Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov • Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Anthony Batten (804-717-6167) battena@chesterfield.gov • Libraries: Jennifer Stevens (804-751-4998) stevensj@chesterfield.gov • Parks & Recreation: Stuart Connock (804-751-4484) connocks@chesterfield.gov • Police: Jim Eicher (804-318-8693) eicherj@chesterfield.gov • Schools: David Oakley (804-706-2586) oakleyd@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov • Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation: Dustin Dunnagan (804-674-2907) dustin.dunnagan@vdot.virginia.gov • Utilities: Randy Phelps (804-796-7126) phelpsc@chesterfield.gov Case Contacts Page 78 of 87 Conditional use to permit a business (fitness training)  incidental to a dwelling in an Agricultural (A) District on 1.8  acres.  Studio M Training 23SN0121 –M a t o a c a Case 23SN0121, in the Matoaca District, is a request by the applicant for  conditional use to permit a business (fitness training) incidental to a dwelling  in an Agricultural (A) District. 1 Page 79 of 87 23SN0121 –O v e r v i e w 1. Continuation  and  expansion of fitness  training business 2. Proposed  increase in  clients, instructors and  hours 3. Staff  recommends  approval Overview slide.  Applicant proposes to expand a fitness training business  incidental to a dwelling.  Staff recommends approval of the request. 2 Page 80 of 87 19SN0626 –Z o n i n g Map The Property contains two parcels that combine for 3.3 acres and is current  zoned Agricultural (A).  Properties to the north, east and south are also zoned  A.  Properties to the west are zoned Residential (R‐7). 3 Page 81 of 87 23SN0121 –A e r i a l & Land Use Plan Map The Property is outlined in white above.  The Property is occupied by a single‐ family residence with a 2,920 SF detached garage where the business  currently operates.  The land use plan designates the area for Low Density  Residential. 4 Page 82 of 87 23SN0121 – Conditions The table highlights the approved conditions of Case No. 18SN0841 and the applicant’s proposed  conditions to accommodate the existing operations of the business. 5 Page 83 of 87 23SN0121 –S i t e Layout The layout in the current slide shows the applicant’s property.  The applicant  utilizes the 2,920 SF garage for the fitness training studio.  There are a total of  15 paved parking spaces on the property that are currently being used by the  applicant, clients, and employees. 6 Page 84 of 87 23SN0121 – Recommendation(s) Staff‐ Approval Staff recommends approval of the request. All adjacent property owners  signed a letter expressing support for the case.  Conditions minimize impacts  on surrounding residential properties. The fitness studio is located  further from the street than the main house and does not  detract from the residential character of the area.  Ample  parking is provided to accommodate the increase in class  size. 7 Page 85 of 87 19SN0626 –Z o n i n g Map End of Presentation 8 Page 86 of 87 23SN0121 –P h o t o s of Property Extra Slide‐ Photos of Property 9 Page 87 of 87

Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.