City Council Work Session and Regular Meeting — Minutes
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Mar 29, 2022 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
March 29, 2022
1
// A special called meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 29th day of March,
2022, at 4:00 P.M. in the 2nd Floor Training Room, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The
following Members were present:
Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy,
Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7
Absent: 0
//In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #1, City Council continued the reconciliation of the FY 2023
Proposed Budget. City Manager Mr. Wynter C. Benda stated that Lynchburg City Schools (LCS) originally
asked for a 5% increase in their budget equating to $3.1 million dollars. Since then, LCS has revised their
request to an 8% increase equating to $5.1 million dollars. He stated that for LCS to increase their
teacher salary to the highest starting salary in close by municipalities, it would take approximately $6.7
million dollars.
Councilmember Faraldi noted that questions about LCS enrollment and graduation rates will be
answered in the reconciliation phase. In regards to total school age children in the City, he asked what
the ADM would be if LCS did not offer PreK. In regards to taxes, he stated that the real estate tax rebate
can still be done in conjunction with addressing compression and cost of living salary increase.
Councilmember Helgeson stated that they must rectify the real estate rate equalization from last
year.
Vice Mayor Wright stated that the tax value went up because City land is more valuable. He
asked what it would take to equalize the real estate tax rate. Chief Financial Officer Ms. Donna Witt stated
it would cost $4.8 million dollars. Mr. Benda stated that if Council would like to implement this rebate, he
can present different options.
Councilmember Helgeson asked if this is something that Council would like to move forward.
Mayor Dolan noted that the public has a right to know what may be cut from the budget in order to fund a
real estate tax rebate. Vice Mayor Wright clarified that he is not advocating for the proposal of cutting
from the budget but simply wants to have the information as to what could be cut if C ouncil decided to
move forward with this. Mayor Dolan stated her agreement.
March 29, 2022
2
Councilmember Helgeson stated that giving raises across all City employees has an impact on
the local economy. Mr. Benda responded that the 3% increases are to keep recruitment competitive and
are directed at municipal services. He noted that the 3% increase is working against the issue of
compression. Councilmember Helgeson asked what the total increase in compensation will be. Mr. Benda
replied he will get that information.
Councilmember Wilder stated that in regards to real estate taxes, the rate did not increase but the
value of property increased. He asked if the personal property tax rebate was being implemented. Mr.
Benda replied yes, it has been voted on. Councilmember Wilder asked what the total amount will be. Ms.
Witt replied it will be approximately $5.5 million that citizens will not pay and will reduce their assessments
and this amount will not be coming to the City. Councilmember Wilder stated that the needs of the City
outweighed the need to change the tax rate from last year.
Councilmember Nelson stated the tax assessments are going to be reflected in coming years. He
would like to rectify the overpayment by lowering the tax rate to equalize or refunding citizens. A
complication of doing this through a refund is that wealthy homes will be getting a substantial refund while
the average home will get a moderate refund. Councilmember Nelson noted that the impracticality and
the cost verses the reward to the taxpayer will not offset. He stated that inflation is going up as well as
cost of living and is a burden on taxpayers and he would like to mediate this. He also noted that the C ity
will also suffer from inflation.
Councilmember Tweedy referred to the chart in Council’s materials labeled “All Residential
Properties” noting the largest amount of single family detached homes would get an average rebate of
$103. The average car rebate would be approximately $115. Councilmember Tweedy asked if this would
be per car; Ms. Witt replied yes, that is correct. She stated that the potential savings of a citizen with
several cars could average out to more than the $103 average real estate rebate. The car tax relief would
give more relief to families based on the number of cars in the City. The greater real estate refund would
go to those with single family homes ranging from $850,000 – $1.7 million, which is approximately 40
homes in the City. These would get the larger average rebate of $770.96. Those who have more affluent
homes will get the greater rebate.
March 29, 2022
3
Vice Mayor Wright noted that if the majority of the tax rebate goes to wealthy people as opposed
to the working class, it matters. Presumably, the personal property tax relief would impact more people
than would the real estate tax rebate. Vice Mayor Wright replied that the question council should be
asking is how they can do the greatest good for the most amount of people. He also noted he would like
to discuss additional funds for education.
Mr. Benda replied that Lynchburg City Schools had asked for a 5% increase which is $3.1 million
and subsequently asked for an 8% increase which is $5.1 million. They also asked for an additional $1
million to meet the local match that will ensure the 5%. The number to get to the highest paid salary will
be approximately $6 million.
Vice Mayor Wright replied that Lynchburg City Schools have outlined a number of different needs
and requested additional funds to accomplish 1) get state money that requires a local match 2) hire more
PreK teachers, counselors, and others. He stated that Council is prioritizing real needs in the proposed
budget. He noted that Lynchburg has not scaled its City services to meet the growth in the community. He
stated that this budget request is an investment in the future of the city and that the schools need funding
to meet their needs. He would like to see a comparison of what the City would need to cut to meet the
request of the schools. He stated his primary concern is that Lynchburg City Schools not lose the state
matched funds. Mr. Benda replied that the school has more employees than the City, to get to living wage
for schools there is a larger number by scale. Vice Mayor Wright replied that if Council entertained
equalizing the tax rate based on the 2019 assessment which is an ongoing cost to the City , they must
also talk about funding schools based on what they need and have requested.
Councilmember Wilder referred to the 2017 school budget and noted the difference in that budget
and the current budget is approximately $1.5 million. He stated that enrollment has declined but the need
for services has continued to increase. He would like possible options as to where the money can come
from to fund these things.
Councilmember Tweedy stated that she has spoken with individuals in the community and an
issue that has been raised is if the City can fund and prioritize certain things but not fund education. She
noted that if $1 million is what it takes to get the education match, she is open to that. She stated she
March 29, 2022
4
wants to invest and build in education. She stated she would like to see the options the City Manager will
propose.
Mr. Benda replied that the school construction piece will be outside of this budget process. He
noted he will have ways in which other municipalities have gotten to the $1.5 million an d will bring in
examples of school funding formulas.
Councilmember Faraldi stated that an increase for the fire department would be $9,000 per
individual. The response from previous questions is that every firefighter will receive increase based on
their certification level. He asked what an increase looks like for a 20- year employee as opposed to an
entry level employee. He would like a bit more information. Mr. Benda replied that to get to the highest
starting salary it will equate to be $9,000 for each person in department. Chief Financial Officer Witt
stated that it does not address compression. Councilmember Faraldi asked for a breakdown on specific
scenarios and detail on this increase carrying through the ranks. Chief Financial Officer Witt asked for
clarification if he means the average for a Captain, Battalion Chief, etc. Councilmember Faraldi noted he
is concerned about the 5, 10, 15-year employees. Mr. Benda replied that a piece of this is also
compression. He stated that they will get Council those models but it will not address what he is referring
to. Councilmember Faraldi stated that more information would be helpful.
Councilmember Faraldi stated that in reference to the Downtown Library data, the data is great
but some context on how to interpret the data would be helpful. He stated he is not opposed to closing the
downtown library, but if there is a need downtown for public space what does that look like. Mr. Benda
replied a physical location is important for people looking to apply and obtain jobs. There is also a
workforce development component to this library. He stated he will bring options on at Council’s meeting
on March 31, 2022. Councilmember Faraldi asked when they were planning to open the downtown
branch. Mr. Benda replied that they are holding off until conversations and budget season is done. He
noted he has heard quite a bit of support of the downtown branch.
Councilmember Wilder asked what the salary is for library personnel and asked if it was a part -
time position. Mr. Benda replied it is a full-time position with approximately $30,000 for salary and
approximately $50,000 with benefits. Councilmember Wilder asked if the City is utilizing other resources
with the library such as resources from the local colleges. He stated that the Liberty University School of
March 29, 2022
5
Law library may help support this to offset some of the costs. He also noted that utilizing college interns to
support the library may be feasible to offset those salaries.
Councilmember Tweedy asked if personal usage of the main library numbers were received
before the pandemic. She stated they received a report from the library that noted there was heavy
computer/internet usage. There were talks about upgrading computers in community centers. She stated
Council might need to invest in technology in other locations. She stated that the downtown library
computers were consistently full before the pandemic.
Vice Mayor Wright asked if there are any downsides to the River Ridge branch library. Mr. Benda
responded that a downside may be the closure of one library, provided that is the direction Council
decides. He stated there is a quality-of-life component to downtown library. Another downside could be if
the venture does not succeed. He stated there is a 5-year option with a leaseholder. Vice – Mayor Wright
asked if there is data of other localities undertaking this. Mr. Benda replied that information is forthcoming.
Vice Mayor Wright asked for clarification that this would be a 5-year lease with a 5-year option which
would mean the City is locked in for 5 years. Mr. Benda replied that this is correct.
Councilmember Helgeson responded that the north end of the City has had a library branch near
the plaza. He noted that River Ridge is a bit more of the center of the city. Geographically , the proposed
library makes sense. Mr. Benda replied the expectation would be that they would be pulling from other
counties and not just for city residents. It would provide more access for more people.
Councilmember Faraldi stated that CIP improvements have totaled approximately $6.7 million in
ARPA dollars. The need of extending sewer line is profound. He asked if there is a direction the City can
go in utilizing the $6.7 million. He stated he would like to see those projects aga in for sewer and
potentially those projects may be able to trade off from projects such as extending trails at Ivy Creek and
Riverfront Park improvements. Mr. Benda replied that Ivy Creek is taken care of by the state. If there is
interest in offsetting the expense of public safety headquarters, there will be information forthcoming at
the next meeting.
Councilmember Nelson stated that restrooms at Riverfront Park is a good improvement.
However, other funds for improvements to the park may be directed elsewhere. In a conversation with
Parks and Rec, they indicated that connection of Ivy Creek Park and Peaks View will solve a practical
March 29, 2022
6
problem for residents who want to use Peaks View but can’t get on roads if they do not have a car. This
trail may be a huge asset to quality of life for the citizens.
Councilmember Helgeson stated that the increase in Meals Tax can be attributed to inflation on
the cost of food. He stated that Council should consider lowering this tax, commenting that this may help
other restaurants invest in Lynchburg.
Councilmember Nelson stated that this is an artificially increased revenue source. The meals tax
is an optimal tax because it is optional. However, some individuals with more than one job do not have
much of an option than to eat out in getting to and from multiple jobs.
Councilmember Faraldi replied if the City eases tax, it may be an incentive for people to continue eating
out.
Vice Mayor Wright asked when was the last time the City raised meal tax. Chief Financial Officer
Witt stated it went up by a half of a percent in 2005, from 6% to 6.5%. Vice Mayor Wright stated that
Council should continuously revisit the tax rates but he has not been hearing concern on meals tax from
citizens.
//The meeting was recessed at 6:04pm.
// City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:00 p.m. in Council Chamber, City Hall, 900 Church Street.
The following members were present:
Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff S. Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy,
Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7
Absent: 0
// In the matter of the FY 2023 Water and Sewer Volume Rates, Sewer Only Rate and Stormwater Fee, a
public hearing was held to hear from the public; no vote was requested from City Council at this time.
Deputy City Manager Dr. Reid A. Wodicka provided Council with an overview of the proposed
rate and fee changes, which include the following: (1) Water volume rate increase from $2.68 to $2.77 (2)
Sewer volume rate increase from $6.14 to $7.22. (3) Monthly sewer only rate from $49.35 to $56.91 (4)
Stormwater single family unit (SFU) from $4.00 per month to $4.17 per month. Since 2012 when the rate
was established, there has not been a stormwater rate increase. The last water rate increase was July 1,
2017. There has been one sewer rate increase in the past 6 years. With these increases, the City will
March 29, 2022
7
increase capital expenditures throughout the funds, replacing approximately half the amount of water line
that should be replaced every year. It will also invest in frontline employee's salary increase. The
stormwater fund will cover multiple smaller projects within the city.
Councilmember Nelson asked Dr. Wodicka to explain what a consent order is. Deputy City
Manager responded that for many years Lynchburg was a combined sewer overflow city which meant
stormwater and sewers were combined. Waste was being pumped into the river. In 1994 the city came to
an agreement with the Commonwealth to rectify this problem. The city must set its rates so that it has
resources to make the repairs.
Mayor Dolan opened the public hearing for citizen input.
Mr. Downs Little stated that he is concerned about the 14 vacancies within the Department of
Water Resources. He explained that frontline employees are under paid and leaving for better paying
jobs. He is in favor of increasing the budget to fill these vacancies. He noted that other municipalities
have adopted tiered water rates which allows low-income households to access affordable water and has
higher rates for those who are greater consumers. He also noted that residential and commercial water
rates should be separate because industrial businesses have more hardscapes and chemicals to treat
and because of this, should pay more or treat their chemicals in house.
There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the
public hearing was closed.
Councilmember Helgeson asked if the average user increase of $6.14 is per household or per
person. Dr. Wodicka replied that this is the average per account.
// The meeting adjourned at 7:18 p.m.
____________________________
Clerk of Council
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.