RecordWell Data

City Council Retreat Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Feb 4, 2022 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City of Lynchburg Visioning Work & City Council Retreat Retreat Agenda Friday, February 4, 2022 Academy Center of the Arts – 600 Main Street, Lynchburg MaryJane Tousignant-Dolan, Mayor Wynter C. Benda, City Manager John Martin, CEO - SIR Rachel Yost, Managing Partner - SIR I. Brunch, Welcome, and Introductions (10:00 – 10:10) II. Review Retreat Goals and Guardrails (10:10 – 10:20) III. City Visioning – What, Why, How (10:20 – 10:45) IV. Trends Shaping the Future of Cities + Traits of Effective City Councils (10:45 – 12:15) V. Lynchburg’s SWOT (12:15 – 1:15) VI. Value of Vision Navigating Trends and leveraging SWOT (1:15 – 1:30) VII. Lunch + City Council Exercise (1:30 – 2:15) 2 VIII. Workshop (2:15 – 3:30) IX. Key Take-Aways (3:30 – 3:55) X. Next Steps (3:55 – 4:00) XI. Closing Remarks (4:00) LynchburgCity Council 2022 Retreat February 4, 2022 Welcome & Introductions Retreat Agenda10:00 –10:15Welcome and Introductions10:15 –10:30Retreat Goals and Guidelines10:30 –11:156 Roles of Highly Effective City CouncilsCreating a Strategic Perspective11:15 -12:30ExternalConsiderations: Review and Discuss Trends Shaping the Future of Cities and LynchburgIdentify External Opportunities and Threats 12:30 –1:00Lunch Retreat Agenda 1:00 –2:00InternalConsiderations: –Internal City Government Strengths and Weaknesses2:00 –2:45Strategic Visioning: –Review Best Practices and Process –Starting the Process Today2:45-3:00 Break3:00 –3:55Using a Strategic Perspective to Prioritize and Make Short-term Decisions Group Exercise3:55 –4:00Next Steps4:00 Closing Remarks Retreat Agenda10:00 –10:15Welcome and Introductions10:15 –10:30Retreat Goals and Guidelines10:30 –11:156 Roles of Highly Effective City CouncilsCreating a Strategic Perspective11:15 -12:30ExternalConsiderations: Review and Discuss Trends Shaping the Future of Cities and LynchburgIdentify External Opportunities and Threats 12:30 –1:00Lunch What is your hope for the upcoming City Council retreat? “It is very easy for conversations to be hijacked, not in a malicious way but easy to go on tangents… we all want what’s best. How do we check our politics at the door?” “Just open and honest dialogue. Typically, what happens when you get a bunch of politicians who think differently it ends up with the fussing and feuding. When you talk about something specifically –just good open honest dialogue.” “That it’s not a sparring match” “That we will be united in our efforts anddo what is best for the complete city.” “Hoping we can use this retreat as a blueprint for the budget.”“Ultimate hope is you can come out of there with a vision and a plan to move forward. The underlying hope is that people are able to be respectful and transparent…the end result should be some sort of roadmap” What will define success for the retreat? “I want the city team to emerge from this feeling like they’ve got direction from Council and a good sense from Council (and hopefully the community) wants to pursue.” “I think that we all buy in to what we do that day. I think we have good vibrant discussion and at the end of the day everyone feels good and sees something they wanted to see happen and can leave with that.” Members express desire for unity and that they walk away with a way to move forward. “Unity(as much as we can).”“Some way to move forward.”“If we come away with or seeing some more tangible avenues for collaboration and realization.”“Something objective… and we can take it from there.” Members express desire for unity and that they walk away with a way to move forward. Retreat Goals•Objective: Learn about and inspire a strategic perspective to shape the future of Lynchburg. •Alignment: Arrive at a consensus perspective on the current state.•Engagement: Ensure all Council members’ voices are heard. •Action: Arrive at clear next steps to advance a strategic perspective. Retreat Guidelines •Focus this retreat on the big picture, not on any one immediate topic area or pressing issue.•Participate from a city-wide perspective –One Lynchburg.•Respect all points of view –only one person talks at a time.•Do not lean on the staff. •Trust the process.•For this retreat, focus on the future… The Future Generation Who Will Call Lynchburg Home Flow of Retreat Topics –How Today Will Work1. Review 6 Roles of Highly Effective City Councils(One Role is Strategy)2. Conduct a SWOT–Internal and External Forces (Trends)3. Based on this Situation Review –Create a Strategic PerspectiveValues, Vision, and Framework4. Look at Current Topics Through this Strategic Perspective5. Outline Next Steps Flow of Retreat Topics –How Today Will Work1. Review 6 Roles of Highly Effective City Councils(One Role is Strategy)2. Conduct a SWOT–Internal and External Forces (Trends)3. Based on this Situation Review –Create a Strategic PerspectiveValues, Vision, and Framework4. Look at Current Topics Through this Strategic Perspective5. Outline Next Steps Strategic Plan takes 6-12 months, this is a jumpstart on how to take Lynchburg to the next level. Retreat Agenda10:00 –10:15Welcome and Introductions10:15 –10:30Retreat Goals and Guidelines10:30 –11:156 Roles of Highly Effective City CouncilsCreating a Strategic Perspective11:15 -12:30ExternalConsiderations: Review and Discuss Trends Shaping the Future of Cities and LynchburgIdentify External Opportunities and Threats 12:30 –1:00Lunch What are the responsibilities of city council? •Review and approve the annual budget;•Establish long-and short-term objectives and priorities;•Oversee performance of the local public employees;•Oversee effectiveness of programs;•Establishtax rates;•Enter intolegal contracts;•Borrow funds;•Pass ordinances and resolutions;•Modify the city’s charter;•Regulate land use through zoning laws;•Regulate business activity through licensing and regulations;•Regulate public health and safety;•Exercise the power of eminent domain;•Communicate policies and programs to residents;•Respond to constituent needs and complaints; and•Represent the community to other levels of government. Bob O’NeillDavenport & CompanyFormer county executive, Fairfax County, Virginia, City Manager of HamptonExecutive director of the International City/County Management Association in Washington, D.C. Bob O’Neill’s “Six Roles” 6 Roles of Effective City Councils Setting The StrategicDirection Setting Policy Representing EveryoneEngaging The Community Being a Fiduciary Trustee ProvidingOversight Source: Bob O’Neil, SVP Public Finance, Davenport & Company SETTINGPOLICY1 Providing consistent and clear direction for decisions, actions, ethical conduct, and commitments. Creating Policies from Two Legitimate Perspectives “Community” Perspective vs.“Professional/Technical” Perspective REPRESENTING EVERYONE2 Representing the perspectives and sentiments of all constituents and stakeholdersfairly. ENGAGINGTHE COMMUNITY3 Helping stakeholders better understand and actively participatein advancing key issues and important initiatives. BEING A FIDUCIARY4 Fulfilling all ethical obligations to the public. Putting the public's interest before your owndirect or indirect personal interests. Our Declaration of Independence advanced the concept of “delegated authority” "We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. —That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed." One way to define FiduciarySource: Markkula Center for Applied Ethics, Santa Clara University The Duty of CareThe duty care requires that the public official competently and faithfully execute the duties of the office. Under duty of care fall such obligations as the duty to manage assets competently and be good stewards of the public treasury, to use due diligence in the selection and supervision of staff, to follow the rules and to uphold the constitution and laws of the jurisdiction. Examples of breach of this duty include failure to attend meetings, failure to investigate, failure to engage in the deliberative process, and failure to vote.The Duty of LoyaltyPublic fiduciaries have an absolute obligation to put the public’s interest before their owndirect or indirect personal interests.The public fiduciary breaches this obligation when he or she benefits at the public expense. Prohibited benefits can be financial, career related,orpersonal such as benefits to family members or close associates. Duty of ImpartialityPublic officials have a duty to represent all of their constituents fairly. This means that the public fiduciary cannot favor those of his or her own party over other constituents or let the fact that someone voted against him or her impact the ability to act fairly. They must overcome any inherent bias that they possess.Duty of AccountabilityEnsure the public’s ability to monitor the behavior of public fiduciaries.From the duty of accountability flow the duty of transparency and the concepts of disclosure, open meetings, and accessibility of public records. PROVIDINGOVERSIGHT5 Ensuring Oversight –Calling for KPIs and Performance Dashboards SETTING THESTRATEGIC DIRECTION 6 Ensure the city has a vision, clearaction framework, and movement towards that future. INTERNAL EXTERNAL What Are The Factors That Drive Towards Our Desired Future State? Desired Future StateCreating a Strategic Framework Current State An Example: TechWho is watching for and thinking about technological advancements? … Like the impact of autonomous vehicles? Connected and automated vehicles (CAVs)will impactallcommunities. It’s Sooner Than You Think –Next 20 Years 2022Level 4 vehicles are here today! Early 2040sAutonomous vehicles have a Transformative societal impact. This includes city design and redevelopment. Source: Synopsys.comLevels of Driving Automation 2035Tipping Point:Level 5 vehicles are here. There are a number of vehicles in service to make a difference Many city councils fall short on setting strategic directionfor 2 reasons: 1. The “Good Enough is Good Enough” Syndrome Change requires a case for change –a compelling reason to change. It’s hard for people to appreciate the concept of “opportunity cost.”In a dynamic world, perpetuating the status quo creates the conditions for decline.Individuals and organizations miss out on opportunities to meaningfully address systemic challenges and take advantage of opportunities that can change the trajectory of their city. Urgent Not Urgent ImportantNot Important 2. Agenda Setting You need to operate here to meaningfully practice the 6throle –setting the strategic direction of your city Most city councils operate here. 6 Roles of Effectives City Councils Setting The StrategicDirection Setting Policy Representing EveryoneEngaging The Community Being a Fiduciary Trustee ProvidingOversight Source: Bob O’Neil, SVP Public Finance, Davenport & Company TRUST Without public trust, government doesn’t work.Period! Ways to build trust in government ROLESACTIONPolicy Make consistent and clear policies and follow them.RepresentationGive everyone a way to follow, participate, and provide suggestions. Make it easy.Community EngagementHyper-engage people through surveys, workshops, meetings, and volunteer initiatives. Build a growing list of “followers.”FiduciaryPublish a code of ethics. Be open and easily accessible (Facebook Live).Oversight (noun)Create and promote performance dashboards.StrategyHave your strategic plan (goals and actions) on your home page. Retreat Agenda10:00 –10:15Welcome and Introductions10:15 –10:30Retreat Goals and Guidelines10:30 –11:156 Roles of Highly Effective City CouncilsCreating a Strategic Perspective11:15 -12:30ExternalConsiderations: Review and Discuss Trends Shaping the Future of Cities and LynchburgIdentify External Opportunities and Threats 12:30 –1:00Lunch Creating a Strategic Perspective •Setting strategic goals•Identifyingand assessing internal strengths and weaknesses•Assessing external opportunities and threats•Identifying values residents want for their community (2030)•Setting a vision•Establishing a framework•Monitoring and reporting progress Today:6 hours50K feetTypical Process:6 to 12 months5K voicesSMART GoalsAction Plan Retreat Agenda10:00 –10:15Welcome and Introductions10:15 –10:30Retreat Goals and Guidelines10:30 –11:156 Roles of Highly Effective City CouncilsCreating a Strategic Perspective11:15 -12:30ExternalConsiderations: Review and Discuss Trends Shaping the Future of Cities and LynchburgIdentify External Opportunities and Threats 12:30 –1:00Lunch External -Opportunities •There is an opportunity to tell Lynchburg’s story and bring clarity around the story•To become a city that can and is focused on access to technologyto ultimately prepare the future workforce•Increase partnerships with higher educational institutions •Increase tourism•Expand programs with the community college and focus on workforce development External -Threats •Lynchburg’s lack of identity•Liberty may be seen as the only brandfor Lynchburg (outside of the region) •Some feel there may be a lack of unity throughout the city•Raising taxes pushing people out of the city •Poverty–not everyone has access to opportunity •Preparing the future workforce•Lack of trained workforce Let’s look at some additional external opportunities and threats… SIR’s trends work We help organizations plan today how to win tomorrow. Understanding TODAYPRIMARY RESEARCH+ Understanding TOMORROWTRENDS RESEARCH Strategy. Insights. Results. Rule #1:It’s not about an exact prediction. It’s about a general direction TODAY TOMORROWRule #2:It’s about connecting the DOTS The DOTS are forcesthat shape change WILDCARDS TECH SHIFTSSOCIETAL & CULTURALTRENDSDEMOGRAPHICFACTORSTODAY TOMORROW WILDCARDS TECH SHIFTSSOCIETAL & CULTURALTRENDSDEMOGRAPHICFACTORSTODAY TOMORROW GENERATIONAL LENS Rule #3: Challenge Your Assumptions “It’s time to look the other way and focus on flexibility. You are notwhatyou know orwhatyou think…You arehowyou know andhowyou think.” Rule #4:Package and share your work; it’s a journey, not a one-time exercise TOMORROW MAPSM Consumers will choose and support green businesses. Sustainable business practices indicate com-munit y focus. Be g reenor be gone. IMPACT SUSTAINABILITY STICKS Find ways to demonstrate and differentiate your com-mit mentto being green. Whatever you do, don’t “greenwash.” IMPLICATIONPOPULATION EXPANDS AGE SHIFTS COMMUNITY EVOLVES DIVERSITY RULES HOUSEHOLDS CHANGE MILLENNIALS DOMINATE FRUGALITY PREVAILS EVERYONE CONNECTS PURPOSE REIGNS They will reshape the work-place and the marketplace. Those who shift to meet their needs will succeed. React slowly and y ou won’t see 2030. IMPACT It is no longer enough to have a mission or vision . N ow you need a stated purpose, which ex plains y our “why ” in meaningful terms for Millennials. IMPACT Digital social connections will r ule, and an anonymous review er’s post delivers the same impact as a TV news report. This trust shift is permanent. IMPACT Bu yin g on “d eal,” sh op p in g via eBay and cra igslist, shar-ingbikes, rides, bedrooms will tr ansfor m m any sector s of the economy for years to come. IMPACT Each state will have pockets of growth and vast expanses of declining populations. Most opport unit ies w ill be around the “activity centers,” which will be many. IMPACT Healthcare will keep boom-ing, but how we provide care and services for this big part of our population will create problems and opport-unities for all. IMPACT All or ganizations, public and private, need to reflect the diversity of their com-munit y. This is an expecta-tionguaranteed to increase. IMPACT The key decision-maker is harder to identify, with such different household types. Organizations must connect with all households, espec-iallythose headed by women. IMPACT Ideas on “trust” will shift from institutions to the crowd—based on reviews available online. Price mat t ers and w ill grow in importance. IMPLICATION Monit or t he prevailing sent-imentonline and actively engage. Strengthen loyalty programs and recruit your ow n onlineadvocates. IMPLICATION Engage them now, at work and in the market. Make sure you understand their collaborative mindset and what it m eans for y our organization. IMPLICATION Craft a compelling and be-lievablepurpose statement for your organization. The best are crowdsourcedfrom within, not dictated from the top. IMPLICATION Bot h in t ern ally in h ow you operate from your board down and externally in how you communicate, reflect more diversity now. IMPLICATION Learn what this permanent shift means for your cate-gory. The wave of older adults is important, but the ultimate change is the ratio of old-to-young. IMPLICATION Make sure your oper at ions are located in these centers, if you’re trying to attract young, creative, skilled wor ker s. Focus sales efforts there, too. IMPLICATION The new model is that there isn’t a model household definition any more. Look for older Boomer women to establish new modelsby 2030. IMPLICATION DEMOGRAPHIC SOCIETAL/CULTURAL To successfully navigate to 2030 and beyond, you’ll need to understand the key trends shaping the future for your organization and industry. This Tomorrow Map identifies important demographic and societal/cultural trends, how they impact your category, and some ideas about what you can do now to ensure success tomorrow.More people means mor e opportunity. But growth will be uneven across states, counties, and regions. Scale your operation to match the population. IMPACT Growing population doesn’t guarantee success in the market place. You’ll have to identify where growth can be leveraged and focus accordingly. IMPLICATIONUSA population expected to grow from 321 million today to 358 million by 2030. Virginia’s population will grow 15%, reaching 9.6 million by 2030. Cities and urban areas are growing as small towns and rural areas shrink. Future growth will concentrate in “activity centers,”which appeal to Millennials. Bet w een n ow an d 2 0 3 0 , t h e 6 5 + population will explode and reach 72 million –1 in 5 Americans will be over 65. At the same time, the ratio of old-to-young w ill shift forever, changing almost everything. Ar ound 2040 the com bined minor-itypopulations will becom e the majorit y, as A merica ’s m elt ing pot reaches a paradigm shift. Already, minorit y birt hs exceed majorit y births. The future is coming in a rainbow of colors. Traditional families are the minority. More adult s (51%) are unmarrie d. Now 27% live alone. Today 41% of births are to unmarried women. The composition of America’s house-holds will continue ev olv ing for years to come. OPPORTUNITY?Across each customized map, we will identify opportunities fo r yo ur industry or organizat io n. © 2015 SIR Research, Inc. All rights reserved.Tomorrow Map is a registered trademark of SIR Research. To get a customized Tomorrow Map for your organization, contact map@tomorrowmap.com OPPORTUNITY?Across each customized map, we will identify opportunities fo r yo ur industry or organizat io n. OPPORTUNITY?Across each customized map, we will identify opportunities fo r yo ur industry or organizat io n. OPPORTUNITY?Across each customized map, we will identify opportunities fo r yo ur industry or organizat io n. OPPORTUNITY?Across each customized map, we will identify opportunities fo r yo ur industry or organizat io n. OPPORTUNITY?Across each customized map, we will identify opportunities fo r yo ur industry or organizat io n. Eight out of 10 people now thinks or acts “green.” This sustainability mindset now brings more scrut iny and pressure on organizations to embrace sustainable practices. The Great Recession has brought a new normal—spending less, saving more, reducing personal footprints. Con-sumptionpatterns will change, bartering will bloom, and the sharing economy will boom . The largest demo in US history, their view of w hat’s important, w hat’s fair, and who is responsible differ from the mindset s of prior generat ions. It is they who will shape culture going forward. Social media has birthed a new collaborative consumption ecosystem, embraced by all ages. The collective makes decisions and recomme nda-tions, not the expert or authority. Power rests in the hands of everyone. With answers to any question in the device you’re holding, the role for organizations is changing. In our wide open society, where everything about anything is a click away, there’s a growing need to know “why” an organization exists. Let’s Build a Quick Tomorrow Map for Lynchburg KEY TRENDS10 What questions should Lynchburg be asking related to this trend? STRATEGIC QUESTION GROWINGPOPULATION1 U.S POPULATION 359Million 2030 332Million Source: U. S. Census Reports Today 190019101920193019401950196019701980199020002010010%20%30%40%50%60%70%80% Transcendent Trend:Over a 100 years of moving from rural to suburban / urban locationsPercent U.S. citizens living in urban –suburban locations Percent U.S. citizens living in rural locations Source: U.S. Census Virginia Population Growth 80%of Virginia’s future population growth will occur in the “Golden Crescent” Source: U.S. Census projections, Weldon Cooper Center for Public Service, Demographics & Workforce Group, www.coopercenter.org/demographics, University of Virginia. City of Lynchburg in the next 10 years 10% growth… 8K people 75,568 2020 2010 Source: US Census and Cooper Center 2019 2030 81,445 89,753 City of Lynchburg in the next 20 years ~19% growth… 15K people 75,568 2020 2010 81,445 96,652 2040 89,753 2030 Source: US Census and Cooper Center 2019 Is Lynchburg thinking about its long-term growth? STRATEGIC QUESTION GROWING DIVERSITYAND NEED FOR INCLUSION 2 America is changing By 2045 the Minority will become the Majority 2045 WhiteNon-white City of Lynchburg’s Growing Diversity 57%51%43%% of total pop. THE FUTURE OF AMERICA ISN’T ABOUT BEINGBLACK, BROWN OR WHITE… IT’S ABOUT BEING A PLURALIST SOCIETY There are IDENTITIESLIBERAL CONSERVATIVE HAVE NOTS WELL OFFS WHITE BLACK HISPANIC LATINOASIAN NATIVE OLDER YOUNGER GAY STRAIGHTBISEXUALMEN WOMENTRANS TEA PARTY BLM CHRISTIAN MUSLIM JEWISH ATHEIST THERE ARE TOO MANY CATEGORIES TO BLENDBINARY Choices are now MULTIPLE Choice•Men/Women now is gender fluidity•Old/Young now is 4 or more generations•People now self-identify their race(s)•Sexual orientation is fluid for someMutual respect, and equity has been rocky for nearly every religious, racial, and ethnic group that has become part of the American fabric along the way. The same is true for groups identified by specific experiences and characteristics, such as gender, sexual orientation,and In many respects, though, the disconnect in identity and experience between White Americans and those of non-majority backgrounds is deeply intertwined in our most difficult challenges, such as poverty, disenfranchisement, isolation, inequity, and violence, and it isn’t fully possible to address these issues without also addressing this reality. National Association of School Psychologists WE ARE LESS MELTING POT AND MORE BENTO BOX Residents of socially connected communities are more likely to thrive.Research suggests that individuals who feel a sense of security, belonging, and trust in their community have better health. People who don’t feel connected are less inclined to act in healthy ways or work with others to promote well-being for all. Connections at Places of Worship Connectionsat Work Work is no longer TIED TO PLACE(Distributed Workforce) Source: Future Workplace 91%of young people (20-38) expect to stay in a job for less than three years. Source: Future Workplace 15-20JOBS ACROSS THEIR WORKING LIFE Telework Works 47%of company executives will allow employees to work from home after the pandemic. Source: Gartner Survey Joining and participating in one group cuts in half your odds of dying next year.Every ten minutes of commuting reduces all forms of social capital by 10%Watching commercial entertainment TV is the only leisure activity where doing more of it is associated with lower social capital.Declining Social Capital Trends over the last 25 years:•Attending Club Meetings: 58% drop•Family dinners: 43% drop•Having friends over: 35% drop Successful citiesof the future will be places where EVERYONEof every race, economic class, gender, and mindset BELONGS and THRIVES Be a “BIG TENT” Organization Can Lynchburg be THEbig tent city where people feel they belong and connect? STRATEGIC QUESITON INCREASINGPOVERTY3 The “Wealth Gap” 7.5X 1989 62+year olds40 and under Source: Federal Reserve Bank The “Wealth Gap” 7.5X 1989 Today 62+year olds40 and under Source: Federal Reserve Bank 15X 40 and under 62+year olds Source: Stanford University Fading American DreamPercent of children earning more than their parents, by year of birth Pre-COVID-19: Life Has Gotten Harder for Millions of Americans 40%Live paycheck to paycheck struggling to meet basic needs –buying food, covering rent. 40%Can't cover a$400emergency expense. City of Lynchburg in the next20 years3K more people in poverty* 75,568 2020 2010 81,445 Source: US Census 96,652 2040 89,753 2030 X 20%17,950X 20%16,289 X 20%19,330 *There are many nuances to poverty numbers. For example, students in college townsimpact poverty numbers: https://news.virginia.edu/content/uva-study-college-students-skew-small-town-poverty-rates Is Lynchburg a placewhere everyone thrives? STRATEGIC QUESTION The City of Charlotte put this core focus into the city’s vision statement GROWINGAGE WAVE4 The Population Age Pyramid Source: U.S. Census Bureau Source: U.S. Census Bureau 1960 vs. 2030 Source: U.S. Census Bureau FEWER MORE Empire State Building102 Stories FEMALES2030 BOOMERS (ages 66-84) MALES 4% 2% 0% 2% 4% 85+80-8475-7970-7465-6960-6455-5050-5445-4940-4435-3930-3425-2920-2415-1910-145-90-4 GEN X (49-65) MILLENNIALS (35-50) GEN Z (18-34) GEN NEXT (0-17) AGE COMPOSITION OF TOMORROW’S CITIES Source: Census Bureau Projections 20% of population is 65+ THE OLDER ADULT BOOMDOESN’T END WITH BOOMERS: NO END IN SIGHT OF MORE OLDER ADULTS: You’ve heard the stat: Thanks to Boomers, every day 10,000 people turn 65.Few seem to know it doesn’t end 12/31/29 when the last Boomer reaches age 65. Source: US Census Projections. THE NUMBER 65+ IS PROJECTED TO INCREASE EVERY YEAR THROUGH 2060YEAR POP 65+202157,842,422 202565,226,333 203073,137,570 203577,997,363 204080,826,591 204582,834,627 205085,674,674 205589,615,168 206094,675,928 HOW WILL THE AGE WAVE AFFECT CITIES? FOR MANY CITIES, GROWTH ISN’T MORE BABIES BEING BORN … GROWTH ISN’T ABOUT MORE PEOPLE COMING IT’S ABOUT MORE RESIDENTS GROWING OLDER 38%OF RVA’s PROJECTED POPULATION CHANGE IS 65+ AGES20202030Change0-19 313,350355,456 +42,10620-64 740,590 813,417 +72,82765+195,544 269,939 +74,395TOTAL1,249,4841,438,812 +189,328 Source: SIR analysis of current RVA MSA Census data from Cooper Center on Demographics, UVA +15%+38%+10%+13% City of Virginia Beach: 72%OF PROJECTED POPULATION CHANGE IS 65+ AGES20172030ChangeUnder 18100,136 104,950 +4,814 18-64 289,668296,125+6,457 65+61,63191,504+29,873 TOTAL451,435 492,579 +41,144 Source: SIR analysis of current RVA MSA Census data from Cooper Center on Demographics, UVA 72% 2022 City of Lynchburg2022 But wait, what is this? 123 Themedian age in Lynchburg is 29,the US median age is 37.4. FACT ONLY 11%OF LYNCHBURG’S PROJECTED POPULATION CHANGE IS 65+2020–2030AGES20202030Change0-19 21K 24K +3K20-64 47K 52K +5K65+13K 14K +1KTOTAL81K 90K +9K Source: Virginia Employment Commission LMI -https://www.virginiaworks.com/_docs/Local-Area-Profiles/5104000680.pdf 0%OF LYNCHBURG’S PROJECTED POPULATION CHANGE IS 65+2030–2040AGES202020302040Change0-1921K24K26K+5K20-6447K52K57K+10K65+13K14K13K-TOTAL81K 90K97K+15K Source: Virginia Employment Commission LMI -https://www.virginiaworks.com/_docs/Local-Area-Profiles/5104000680.pdf CityMedian AgeProvo, Utah23.3Gainesville, Fla.24.9Athens, Ga.25.9Tallahassee, Fla.26.1Columbia, Mo.26.8Killeen, Texas27.1Denton, Texas27.1Ann Arbor, Mich.27.8Laredo, Texas27.9Tempe, Ariz.28.1 Lynchburg almost makes the top 10 U.S. market for the youngest towns in America. LynchburgUSA 128 Can Lynchburg furtherembrace the “town and gown” partnership to advance a vibrant, youthful market position? STRATEGIC QUESTION INCREASINGREMOTE WORK5 Telework Works “We firmly believe that in-person, being together, having a sense of community is super important when you have to solve hard problems and create something new so we don’t see that changing. But we do think we need to create more flexibility and more hybrid models,”Google, CEO, Sundar Pichaie 30% TODAY Source: SIR 50% 203010%1990s Pre-COVIDThe distributed workforce is growing 30% TODAY Source: SIR Post-COVIDThe distributed workforce is here50% SIR Prediction -2025 10%1990s www.tulsaremote.com St. Clair County, MichiganDubbed theCome Home Award, this reverse-scholarship will pay students who have completed a degree in a STEAM-related program (science, technology, engineering, arts or math). Those promising to live and work in the county could receive up to $15,000 to make the move. City of Hamilton, Ohio Harmony, Minnesota Vermont Pays $10K 145 West Va. Remote Work Program Offers$12,000Cash, Free Outdoor Recreation and More Is Lynchburg wired for success in retaining and attracting remote workers? STRATEGIC QUESTION RISING IMPORTANCE OFPLACE 6 Walkable Community Trends Source: National Association of Realtors National Community and Transportation Preference Survey (2004, 2011, 2015) 70% 30% 61% 37%45% 48% Community ACommunity B200420112015 Community A: Houses with large yards, and you have to drive to the places you need to goCommunity B: Houses with small yards, and it is easy to walk to the places you need to go 2015 is the first year a preference for walkable communities overtook a preference for conventionalcommunities. Such a big shift in about 10 years is remarkable. Top desires for “ideal” neighborhood I would love to live within 15 minutes commute of my work and/or my school. Having access to stores, restaurants, and services close to my home (within about 15 minutes) Q40. How much do you agree with each of the following statements, when thinking about your ideal neighborhood? Please use a scale of 1 to 5, where “1” means “completely disagree” and “5” means “completely agree.”Future Moversn = 300 81% 64% Percent saying “4” or “5” Source: SIR national Mover Study Activity Centers Richmond region has 14 activity centers … “15-minute communities” How many activity centers… 15-minute activity centers make up Lynchburg? What do Millennials want in a place? “…used SIR’s research to attract and retain more young professionals —and the strategy worked.” When you think about a city as a place you’d really want to live, how important are each of the following to you? RALEIGHNCWASH.DCCHARLOTTENCAUSTINTX ATLANTAGADenverCOIs safe 89%87%86%91%81%90%Has a variety of employment options 90%82%83%85%82%87%Quality andaffordability of housing options 92%83%87%87%83%83%Offersoutdoor recreation options71%60%71%77%71%76%Offers a great food scene76%75%78%85%77%75%Embraces creativity59%55%58%69%59%64%Embraces innovation70%58%61%69%60%64%Is near the mountains28%24%40%17%30%64%Has access to water59%54%64%65%54%63%Is bike-able/walkable46%50%41%43%44%61%Has easy public transportation42%66%40%47%46%60%Embraces small business/start-ups/entrepreneurship54%48%60%61%54%57%Higher education options76%60%60%73%62%57%Is diverse60%63%55%69%55%55%Urban living environment47%59%51%60%46%53%Offers an active music scene51%36%46%53%49%49%Offers an active arts scene42%38%44%43%42%46%Has rich history42%47%39%41%42%42% Safety, variety of employment, quality and affordability of housing top the list Q20.When you think about a city as a place you’d really want to live, how important are each of the following to you? BASICS Raleigh, NCn = 198Washington, DCn = 199Charlotte, NCn = 200Austin, TX n = 194Atlanta, GAn = 204Denver, COn = 195 RALEIGHNCWASH.DCCHARLOTTENCAUSTINTX ATLANTAGADenverCOIs safe 89%87%86%91%81%90%Has a variety of employment options 90%82%83%85%82%87%Quality andaffordability of housing options 92%83%87%87%83%83%Offersoutdoor recreation options71%60%71%77%71%76%Offers a great food scene76%75%78%85%77%75%Embraces creativity59%55%58%69%59%64%Embraces innovation70%58%61%69%60%64%Is near the mountains28%24%40%17%30%64%Has access to water59%54%64%65%54%63%Is bike-able/walkable46%50%41%43%44%61%Has easy public transportation42%66%40%47%46%60%Embraces small business/start-ups/entrepreneurship54%48%60%61%54%57%Higher education options76%60%60%73%62%57%Is diverse60%63%55%69%55%55%Urban living environment47%59%51%60%46%53%Offers an active music scene51%36%46%53%49%49%Offers an active arts scene42%38%44%43%42%46%Has rich history42%47%39%41%42%42% Placemaking Attributes Raleigh, NCn = 198Washington, DCn = 199Charlotte, NCn = 200Austin, TX n = 194Atlanta, GAn = 204Denver, COn = 195 Q20.When you think about a city as a place you’d really want to live, how important are each of the following to you? PLACEMAKING Is Lynchburg advancing a collection (portfolio) of 15-minute livable communities –all types of neighborhoods and living options? Is Lynchburg effectively packaging its place story for young people? STRATEGIC QUESTION SHIFTINGWORKFORCE NEEDS7 COMPUTING POWER HAS BEEN DOUBLING EVERY 1-2 YEARS Moore’s Law –50 Years Running 2020 –Quantum Computing Tech Singularity 2018 -Hyper-specialized CPUs Terminators? It’s now starting to improve EXPONENTIALLY BIG DATATHE CLOUD ARTICFICAL INTELLIGENCE MANUALMINIMUM WAGE JOBS A big job shift is coming COGNITIVE ROUTINE MANUALMINIMUM WAGE JOBS A big job shift is coming “Manage the exception”Innovators …Creative COGNITIVE ROUTINE Telephone operatorsWord processors & typistsTravel AgentsBookkeepers Vanishing Jobs Source: Oxford University 1/3of all jobs eliminated within next 20 years Future of Work Bain & Company“By 2030, automation may eliminate20% to 25% of current jobs, hitting middle-to low-income workers the hardest.This could trigger economic disruption far greater than we have experienced over the past 60 years.” McKinsey & Company"30% of 'work activities' could be automatedby 2030-up to 375 million workers worldwide could be affected by emerging technologies.” Oxford University"47% of U.S. workers have ahigh probability of seeing their jobs automated over the next 20 years.” Organization for Econ. Cooperation and Development“46% of jobs at risk. Using task-related data from 32 OECD countries, OECD estimates that 14% of jobs are highly automatable and another 32% of jobs have a significant risk of automation.” Pew Research’s Expert Survey Findings:“Half (48%) of 1,896 experts interviewed on emerging technologies envision a future in which robots and digital agents will displaced significant numbers of both blue-and white-collar workers, enough to cause social breakdown.” replacedbyrobot.info New Public Education Partnership ModelsFord FoundationNashville AcademiesP-Tech Schools Ford Foundation Schools Nashville Academies ptech.com 177 Is Lynchburg re-thinking and hyper-coordinating its workforce ecosystem? STRATEGIC QUESTION INCREASING COLLABORATION8 Winning cities of the future realize they are not isolated islands competing against nearby cities. Today, more than 70% of our nation’s population, obsand GDP are located in 12 megaregions Megaregions Defined“Megaregions are becoming the new competitive units in the global economy, characterized by the increasing movement of goods, people and capital among their metropolitan regions.”Jonathan Barnett Cascadia Innovation Corridor Successful Megaregion Design is all about Intentionality Example:Cascadia MegaregionPortland –Seattle –Vancouver Cascadia MegaregionPortland –Seattle –VancouverThe Department of Transportation for Washington State just released a newreportidentifying the next joint steps for the governments of British Columbia, Washington, and Oregonto take in order to realizeultra-high-speed rail, linking Vancouver, Seattle, and Portland.The $900K report was funded equally between all three jurisdictions and Microsoft. The Texas Triangle Dallas-Fort Worth(DFW), Houston, San Antonio, and Austin Florida High-Tech Corridor I-69 Innovation Corridor PA’s I-99 Innovation Corridor NC Innovation Corridor FOUR COUNTIESCOMBINED POP.186,929NORTH OF THE RALEIGH/DURHAM RESEARCH TRIANGLE(MSA POP: 1.3MM) TRIANGLE NORTH 194 RVA-757 Connects Balt.-Richmond Innovation Corridor RVA and 757 are addingstrength to strength UNIFIEDBUSINESS COMMUNITY INNOVATION ECOSYSTEM RICHMONDMARINE TERMINAL STATECAPITALLOGISTICSCENTERDEEP BENCH OF PROFESSIONALSERVICES FORTUNE500 COMPANIES DIGITALPORTJEFFERSONLAB NASAMILITARY VIRGINIAPORTTOURISM SHIP-BUILDING AND SHIPREPAIR PRIMARY REGIONALASSETS RICHMOND REGION HAMPTON ROADSHIGHER EDUCATIONHIGHEREDUCATION Pathway Improve the economic success and quality of life for everyone in the RVA and 757 regions. Mission Identify, support and advance major opportunities, initiatives and projects that will meaningfully benefit bothcommunities for generations to come. Priority Focus Areas 3 1.Accelerate the I-64 Innovation Corridor status as a global internet hub2.Support the completion of the Virginia Capital Trail 3.Remove barriers to increase passenger rail service4.Advocate for I-64 widening (29-mile gap from RVA to Williamsburg)5.Increase R&D collaboration6.Support directors’ and members’ initiatives7.Advance the megaregion’s brand –I-64 Innovation Corridor www.RVA757Connects.com Is the City of Lynchburg thinking and acting beyond its borders? STRATEGIC QUESTION DECREASING TRUST 9 Trust in government Source: Pew The wisdom of MANYis better than the thoughts of FEW The COLLECTIVE SELF Dominates SIR’s Trust Model: Grow Followers OLD TRUST MODELInstitutions, Organizations, Experts, Authorities, Regulators TRUST NEW TRUST MODEL TRUSTFamily, Friends, Peers, Colleagues and Fellow Users Where trust is headed TOMORROW Tala:New company that mines a person’s online network to prove they are trustworthy –a blockchain-like ID system. Traity: A Spanish insurance company that assesses risk by scoring people’s online reputations.Tala sells service to banks and landlords. TODAY, PEOPLE ARE HYPER-CONNECTEDTo each other, and anyone on the planet with a device Social media has changed the communications model OLD MODELNEW MODELCompany in controlConsumer in control, both figuratively and literallyInterrupt consumers when you want to speak to themEngage consumers 24/7React to issues and remain privateInteract on issues and be transparentSeeconsumers as passive targetsSee customers as activebrand advocates and co-creators The basic organization communication model has changed WORD OF MOUTH BUZZ is one of the oldest and most effective forms of marketing.The biggest opportunity for cities IS TO GENERATEBUZZ ON A MAJOR SCALE. The key is to intentionally EMPOWER ADVOCATES —give them shared experiences and information. Disney Corporation •Sophisticated social media strategy being deployed. •Extensive communications training for every Disney employee.•Employees share the Disney story. Formal program teaching people how to share “The Best of Nashville” Identify Individual ApostlesCommunity members who post, share, and retweet positive messages Organize and Support These Apostles Effective shared stories have two parts:1.Unified Imagery2.Unified Message Effective shared stories have two parts:1.Unified Imagery2.Unified Message Brand Architecture StrategyMost communities present themselves as a HOUSE OF BRANDS Brand Architecture StrategyIt’s best to communicate as a BRANDED HOUSE Columbus, Ohio’s United Logomark Columbus City Government City Municipal Initiatives: (example is for technology) City Dept. Logos: Columbus Chamber Columbus Tourism Columbus Regional Economic Development BrandColumbus.com Columbus Relators From this… RECREATION, PARKS & OPEN SPACE FINANCE GENERAL SERVICES the city of N RFOLK the city of N RFOLK the city of N RFOLK To this… Effective shared stories have two parts:1.Unified Imagery2.Unified Message NORFOLK’S STORY An example of how to help shape a shared narrative: It’s a collaborative effort We are creating an amazing community where people desire to live, work, and play. PURPOSE: Whether you are a resident, worker, or visitor, Norfolk is an amazing place where you feel welcomed, connected, and fulfilled. Here you quickly become part of a dynamic and authentic urban waterfront community. BRAND PROMISE: Vibrant, Inclusive, Diverse, Creative, Innovative, Transform- ative , Urban, Hip, Nautical, Laidback, Fun, and Welcoming. PERSONALITY: WHAT MAKES NORFOLK UNIQUE? What three words describe Norfolk when compared to other cities? Diversity, History and Water. This Wordle TM chart shows the words mentioned most often by residents, workers, and visitors in a recent survey. The larger the word, the more times it was mentioned. Each word in this statement is significant: ⚓   NORFOLK – The entire city, not just downtown ⚓   VIBRANT AND HISTORIC PORT CITY – An active port for over 400 years ⚓   AMAZING PLACE – Norfolk has surprises around every corner ⚓   CULTURALLY DIVERSE CITIZENS – Living, working, playing together ⚓   MILITARY AND BUSINESSES – With a shared passion to move Norfolk forward ⚓   CREATING – Makers and doers actively investing in building something great ⚓   DYNAMIC – Ever-evolving, growing as a community and city ⚓   AUTHENTIC – Neighborhoods, port culture, architecture, parks ⚓   URBAN WATERFRONT – A natural asset that sets Norfolk apart from other cities ⚓   COMMUNITY – Making Norfolk a welcoming and accepting place for all ⚓   IN AMERICA – An aspiration to become a most preferred city and destination Norfolk’s Story: Our Brand Message Architecture This document is Norfolk’s story. It was designed by and for all the organizations that are responsible for pro- moting Norfolk’s overall brand or any of Norfolk’s premier assets and attractions. This brand message architecture serves two very important purposes. First, the message blueprint will inform, empower, and inspire every organization to advance a more seamless story on why people should live, work, and play in Norfolk. Second, this template will help inform the development of Norfolk’s future placemaking and product development initiatives, providing guidance on what aligns with and reinforces Norfolk’s unique and compelling story. This document was created by the Norfolk Collaboratory, a crowdsourcing process that included the leaders, staff, and boards of dozens of Norfolk’s leading organizations, the City Council, and over one thousand engaged stake- holders, people who live, work, and play in Norfolk. The Southeastern Institute of Research provided research and strategy development support. THE NORFOLK COLLABORATORY A NOTE ON TAGLINES: “Life. Celebrated Daily.” is Norfolk’s current tagline. For this initiative, let’s take a step back from using a tagline and see what emerges from Norfolk’s creative culture, which has already developed community- inspired expressions like “NFK” and “We’re not Norfolking around.” Let’s also take this opportunity to refresh and update Norfolk’s mermaid, embracing different looks and uses. Norfolk is an amazing place, a vibrant and historic port city where culturally diverse citizens, the military, and businesses are creating the most dynamic and authentic urban waterfront community in America. POSITIONING STATEMENT: Photo Credit: Mario Barkley Photography, mbarkleyphotography.com New website for Festevents New logo for Jazz Festival Norfolk Organizations Started Talking About The Waterfront: Even Norfolk’s neighborhoods: Norfolk, Va.“The most dynamic urban waterfront community in America”language now shows up everywhere. 242 Does Lynchburg have a shared narrative? Are all lead organizations united around shared iconology and messaging? STRATEGIC QUESTION This is a good start . . . RISING IMPORTANCE OFPURPOSE 10 TREND DESCRIPTIONTAKE CARECOVID-19 is a health crisis. We are seeing, hearing, and watching this healthcare story unfold all around us 24-7. Social isolation, lack of exercise, and financial uncertainty are creating higher levels of mental and physical stress in all of us. In addition, the crisis has helped to increase awareness of the health disparities affecting minority populations. VALUE ALLThe COVID-19 virus affects everyone —young, old, rich, poor, black, white. In addition, society has a newfound appreciation forfrontline essential workers, as well as what they are being paid. The events and protests related to the social justice BLM movement have advanced our understanding beyond economic inequities and health disparities. There is no longer a neutral zone. Anti-racism attitudes and practices will increase. There will be an increasing appreciation of and support for equity and social justice policies and initiatives. GO TEAMThe COVID-19 crisis has reinforced the spirit and power of teamwork —“we are all in this together.” Corporate advertising continues to mirror this through “stronger together” messaging. This social sentiment is reinforcing the expectation that companies must do more than make a profit, they must contribute to community stakeholders, too. Greater investments will be made in new supportive pathways to help ensure everyone thrives. HYPER-CONNECTPeople are driven by a deep-seated personal need to belong. This includes belonging to a family, peer group, team, organization,and community. Social isolation, economic and health-related uncertainty and vulnerability, and civil unrest are fueling this primary need for personal connections. Similarly, the uncertainty of a post-COVID world is driving the need for more corporate emotional connections through formal and informal employee support. PURPOSEMillennials and Gen Zs have been advancing the importance of social and ethical causes they think are important, putting pressure on companies, organizations, institutions, and brands to have a positive impact on the greater community. COVID-19 is accelerating this trend. Through COVID, more and more people are searching for meaning in their lives –their purpose. Purpose is bigger than whoyou are, what you do, how you do it. It’s your “WHY.” COVID-ACCELERATED TRENDS 245 Bigger than who you are, what you do, how you do it. It’s your “WHY.” PURPOSE GENERATIONAL VALUES: ARCHTYPE: MILLENNIALS crave purposeConfidence plusCivic dutyAchievementHyper connectedMulti-tasking FearlessCo-dependentPurposefulAmbitious MAKE ALIVING BOOMERS/GEN X: MAKE ADIFFERENCE MILLENNIALS:Work Goals “I want my employer to contribute to social or ethical causes that I think are important” Boomers Gen Xers Millennials Somewhat AgreeAgreeAgree Strongly 38%34%34% 20%22%25% 6% 14%19% 64% 70%78% TOTAL AGREE Majority want to work where “purpose” is shared Source: GenerationsMatter National Study For Cities: Purpose is VisionMissionValues VISION Where is Lynchburg headed? Why should someone stay here after college? What will they be part of? What kind of city can they help build? STRATEGIC QUESTION Retreat Agenda10:00 –10:15Welcome and Introductions10:15 –10:30Retreat Goals and Guidelines10:30 –11:156 Roles of Highly Effective City CouncilsCreating a Strategic Perspective11:15 -12:30ExternalConsiderations: Review and Discuss Trends Shaping the Future of Cities and LynchburgIdentify External Opportunities and Threats 12:30 –1:00Lunch Retreat Agenda 1:00 –2:00InternalConsiderations: –Internal City Government Strengths and Weaknesses2:00 –2:45Strategic Visioning: –Review Best Practices and Process –Starting the Process Today2:45-3:00 Break3:00 –3:55Using a Strategic Perspective to Prioritize and Make Short-term Decisions Group Exercise3:55 –4:00Next Steps4:00 Closing Remarks Internal -Strengths •City leadership•New City Manager•New people in senior positions across the city•Full of great people •Resilient •The complete package –diversity and central cultural and economic hub for the region Internal -Weaknesses•Lack of compensation for city employees (which leads to turnover and making it hard to recruit and retain talent)•High tax rates•There’s no major interstate •Poverty and homelessness•Declining infrastructure 258 259 “You know, when I moved here, I thought there were 2 maybe 3 communities. What I’ve come to learn, that we have like 12 or 15 different communities that are relatively insular.”“There is a great energy to collaborate and need to continue that.” Status of Collaboration Discussion on the status of collaboration •Colleges and universities: Most feel it has gotten stronger especially in convening leadership. Some feel there could be even stronger partnerships. •Business community: Most say this is good and many pointed to the great work Economic Development is doing in building and maintaining relationships with local businesses.•Religious community: There is a sense that the relationship between the city and religious groups could improve. It is not bad, but rather presents opportunities. The challenging is that there are so many groups. Fragmentation and silos make it hard to coordinate and keep everyone informed. •Neighborhood leaders/associations: This category is also fragmented, perhaps especially along racial divides. There is a feeling from some that leaders work well together, but there is a lack of partnership on bigger initiatives.•The surrounding counties: Felt to be cordial and when needed, everyone works well together. Retreat Agenda 1:00 –2:00InternalConsiderations: –Internal City Government Strengths and Weaknesses2:00 –2:45Strategic Visioning: –Review Best Practices and Process –Starting the Process Today2:45-3:00 Break3:00 –3:55Using a Strategic Perspective to Prioritize and Make Short-term Decisions Group Exercise3:55 –4:00Next Steps4:00 Closing Remarks What’s the vision for Lynchburg’s future? STRATEGIC QUESTION 8THINGS TO KNOW ABOUT STRATEGICVISIONING 1. Defining What a Vision Is and Understanding the Benefits of Having One Vision & Mission Relationship•Apple’s Vision: We are here to make the best products on earth, and to leave the world better than we found it.”•Apple’s Mission: Bring the best user experience to our customers through innovative hardware, software, and services. Vision Examples •Disney:To make people happy•IKEA:To create a better everyday life for the many people•Microsoft:Empower every person and every organization on the planet to achieve more•Avon:To be the company that best understands and satisfies the product, service and self-fulfillment needs of women—globally•Apple: We are here to make the best products on earth, and to leave the world better than we found it.” Community Visioning Benefits 1.Educates the community on challenges and opportunities and key trends shaping the future.2.Inventories current programs and initiatives.3.Identifies shared values –values the community wants to become.4.Articulates a shared story –who we are today.5.Articulates a long-term vision and identifies leading priorities that are shared by all –where we want to be. 6.Builds awareness, creates alignment, and accelerates the great work –programs and initiatives –that are already underway.7.Creates a framework to help everyone understand how all these efforts are working to build a great community for all.8.Inspires community-wide collaboration to achieve shared vision and priorities.9.Makes the case for even greater funding and resource allocation on the things that are most important.10.Fuels a positive “can do” spirit -driving regional momentum. 2. Including the Lead Organizations in Visioning Process Typical parties involved Municipal GovernmentPlanning District CommissionCommunity Foundation and other Nonprofits Chamber of Commerce and other leading orgs 3. Packaging the Process Very predictable and understandable names are used•Envision Region•Fast Forward Region •RegionVision 2040•Imagine Region•Region2040 •Region’sFuture•RegionTomorrow•RegionAhead•Forward Region Most cities brand the overall visioning initiative 4. Engaging the Community(City Council Role #3) . . . . . . . . The level of stakeholder engagement varies Number of Residents Included Number of EngagementChannels Surveys –scientific and convenience, events, neighborhood meetings, pop-up events, social media, mass media process, etc. Survey only -convenience sample . . . . . . . . Most Visioning Initiatives 8,0001,000Most Visioning Initiatives The most inclusive visioning initiatives use intercept surveys to include underrepresented voices Charlotte Example: 20 low-income neighborhoods. The gold standard –Vision PDX (Portland, Oregon)•Extensive 2-year public engagement process. •Goal: Develop a shared vision for the next 20 years and beyond.•Over 17,000 Portlanders weighed in with opinions and comments.•Largest public engagement process for Portland region to date and one of the largest ever in North America. 5. Shaping the Vision(City Council Role #6) CityVision Statement Community’s Value #3 Community values inform the vision statement development Community’s Value #2Community’s Value #1 EnvironmentInclusionHealth Charlotte City CouncilLooking forward, what are the top three desired community values you would like associated with Charlotte? TOP values residents would like associated with Charlotte in 2030 Q10. Looking forward, what are the top three desired community values associated with Charlotte? Gray shaded boxes indicate respondent-generated values Residents Input Into City of Charlotte’s Values:•Safe•Family-oriented•Diverse•Economic opportunitiesfor everyone•Affordable•Clean•Welcoming and friendly•Inclusive 31%17%17%17%12%10%9%8%7%6%6%5%4%3%3%3%3%3%3%2%23%0% 20 %40 %60 %80 %10 0% Sa feFamily-orientedDiverseEconomic opportunities for everyoneAffordableCleanWel comi ng/Fri endlyInclusiveEasy to get aroundGrowingEducation-focusedEnvironmentally-friendlyCommunity-orientedGood police-community relationsCollaborativeContemporaryInnovativeMultigenerationalCaringUnitedOther 16%10%9%9%9%9%7%7%5%5%4%3%2%1%1%0% 20 %40 %60 %80 %10 0% Queen CityFriendlyFinance CityA Neighborhood for EveryoneGreen SpaceLand of OpportunityMost-Desirable CitySports CityEducational VillageMost-Compassionate CityMost-Popular CityMost "Get It Done" CityVisual and Performing Arts CommunityOutdoor CityOther When respondents are asked to choose their TOP unique feature from the same list, queen and friendly are ranked first and second respectively, and many are tied for third place 281Q5. Which of the following is your top choice for a unique, defining feature or characteristic that Charlotte could be known forin 2030? This research –with 7K voices (resident input) created this vision . . . Our Values City of Charlotte’s Vision Community Builders The city of Charlotte’s long-term vision –By 2030: Charlotte is America’s Queen City, opening her arms to a diverseand inclusive communityof residents, businesses, and visitors alike; a safe, family-oriented city where peoplework together to help everyone thrive. SAFEFAMILYFRIENDLY & WELCOMINGDIVERSE & INCLUSIVEEQUITABLE 6. Advancing the Vision(City Council Role #6) Charlotte’s vision statement is being used to seamlessly advance the city’s strategic direction (6throle of city council). City Council painted a picture of the vision. This painting was in the news and now hangs in the lobby of city hall. The vision is featured in the budget documents FY2020 Budget Document Vision statement is included in plans: The FY2020 Community Engagement on Housing FY2020 Comprehensive Plan –Public Input Started with the Vision statement “The City of Charlotte is a $2.6 billion organization with more than 8,000 employees. Leveraging corporate America’s best practices, such as advancing a clear vision, is imperative. Our vision helps focus our resources and ensures we’re aligned in building the type of community we aspire to be –a place where people work together to help everyone thrive.”Ed DriggsCouncilman, City of Charlotte 7. Making the Final Product a Strategic Plan The Vision Drives The Development of a Strategic Plan Community VisionBased on the defining values, howdo we envision our physical, economic, and social fabric —10-to 20-yearsin the future. CommunityValuesWhat are the ideal set of defining values –what do we want for our community in say 2030? CommunityPrioritiesWhat should we prioritize to achieve our vision? Where areresourcesneeded most? 2.1. 3. The Vision Helps You Move from the Current State to the Future State As identified in the SWOT As identified in the SWOT Inspired by the vision As identified in the Situation Review The Final Output is Packaged as a Stand-alone Strategy Report Fort Lauderdale Example The Report Shows How Everything Supports the Vision “The Vision 2035 is the roadmap to guide our everyday work. The employees of the City of Fort Lauderdale are committed to integrating and connecting the Vision to our City’s strategic planning, budgeting, and day-to-day service delivery.” Lee R. FeldmanICMA Former City Manager, City of Fort Lauderdale 296 8. Ensuring the Overall Effort Advances the City’s / Region’s Strategic Framework and Inspires Supportive Ambassadors Vision for Hampton Roads Over 757 Business Leaders in Hampton Roads are Now Ambassadors Your Vision:Today & Tomorrow smallwelcoming Today Equity and fair combined as “equitable.” Humming and vibrant combined as “vibrant.” Tomorrow Retreat Agenda 1:00 –2:00InternalConsiderations: –Internal City Government Strengths and Weaknesses2:00 –2:45Strategic Visioning: –Review Best Practices and Process –Starting the Process Today2:45-3:00 Break3:00 –3:55Using a Strategic Perspective to Prioritize and Make Short-term Decisions Group Exercise3:55 –4:00Next Steps4:00 Closing Remarks Retreat Agenda 1:00 –2:00InternalConsiderations: –Internal City Government Strengths and Weaknesses2:00 –2:45Strategic Visioning: –Review Best Practices and Process –Starting the Process Today2:45-3:00 Break3:00 –3:55Using a Strategic Perspective to Prioritize and Make Short-term Decisions Group Exercise3:55 –4:00Next Steps4:00 Closing Remarks GROUP EXERCISE:Using a strategic perspective to prioritize and make short-term decisions •Infrastructure (X4)•New Police HQ (X4)•Schools(X3)•City Compensation(X2)•Affordable housing•Poverty reduction•Climate resiliency•Violence intervention•Neighborhood investment Every city is going to receive funding from the federal and/or state government. What are some of your priorities for these resources? Using a strategic perspectivein a priority setting •Compensation (especially police and fire) (x3)•Schools (both improving schools and also COVID) (x3)•Taxes (x2)•Infrastructure•Branding•Transparency•Economic development and how we spread wealth with innovative programs•How we develop our neighborhoods•Unity•Reduce poverty•Reduce crime•Environmental strategies•Better job of connecting businesses with education [talent pipeline] Using a strategic perspectiveon sorting through specific initiatives What focus areas and/or topics would you like to ensure we cover during the retreat? Combined 2 Lists as Categories • Taxes• City Compensation (especially police and fire)• Infrastructure• How we develop our neighborhoods• Neighborhood investment • New Police• Reduce crime• Violence intervention• Better job of connecting businesses with education [talent pipeline)• Schools (both improving schools and also COVID) (x3)• Affordable housing• Poverty reduction• Equitable Economic development -spread wealth with innovative programs• Climate resiliency• Environmental strategies• Branding• Transparency• Unity TaxesCompensationInfrastructureSafetyEducationUpward MobilityEnvironmentBrandingPartnerships 3 tables… Pick 2 topics*… Answer these2 questions on each topic…Share with the group What should Lynchburg (all stakeholders) do to strategically address this topic area in a way that reinforces our story as a great place for young people and young families?How should City Council provide strategic leadership in this topic area (think 6 roles)? *If you finish early, pick a 3rdtopic Exercise 1.What should Lynchburg (all stakeholders) do to strategically address this topic area in a way that reinforces our story as a great place for young people and young families?2.How should City Council provide leadership in this topic area (think 6 roles)? *If you finish early, pick a 3rdtopic •Taxes•Compensation•Infrastructure•Safety•Education•Upward Mobility•Environment•Branding•Partnerships Pick Two Topics 20 Minutes -Table Discussion -Your 2 Topic Areas (10 min. each)*35 Minutes -Share With the Group •Setting policy•Representing everyone•Engaging the community•Providing oversite •Being a fiduciary•Setting strategic direction•Building trust Each table has 10 minutes for report out. Retreat Agenda 1:00 –2:00InternalConsiderations: –Internal City Government Strengths and Weaknesses2:00 –2:45Strategic Visioning: –Review Best Practices and Process –Starting the Process Today2:45-3:00 Break3:00 –3:55Using a Strategic Perspective to Prioritize and Make Short-term Decisions Group Exercise3:55 –4:00Next Steps4:00 Closing Remarks

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.