RecordWell Data

City Council Work Session and Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Feb 9, 2021 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

February 9, 2021 1 GENERAL POLICY REGARDING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AT CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS Each speaker shall clearly state his or her name and locality of residence. The City Council agenda is divided into four sections. CONSENT AGENDA: This section includes routine items. All items may be approved by one vote. PUBLIC HEARINGS: This section includes all public hearings as required by law or as Council may direct. Procedure: • Staff will make a presentation. • For zoning petitions, the applicant or his or her representative shall have ten (10) minutes to make a presentation. • Comments will then be solicited from those in favor. • Comments will then be solicited from those in opposition. During the public hearing, there shall be a time limit of three (3) minutes for each individual speaker. If the speaker represents a group, there shall be a time limit of five (5) minutes. A speaker representing a group shall identify that group at the beginning of his or her remarks. A group may have only one spokesperson. After public comments have been received, for zoning petitions, the applicant or the representative of the applicant, at his or her discretion, may respond with a rebuttal. There shall be a five (5)- minute time limit for rebuttal. Upon the conclusion of public comments or the applicant’s rebuttal, the public hearing will be closed and the matter referred to Council for deliberation. PUBLIC COMMENT: Public comment shall be for the purpose of allowing members of the public to present any matter, which, in their opinion, deserves the attention of the Council. They shall not serve as a forum for debate with the Council. Individuals may speak up to three (3) minutes; or group spokesperson up to five (5) minutes. Once Council has heard a presentation from a citizen or organization on a particular subject, the citizen or organization may not make another presentation on the same subject within three (3) months of the first presentation, except by a majority vote of the members of Council present and voting. GENERAL BUSINESS: This section includes items of a general nature to be considered by Council. City Council may make exceptions to these rules at its discretion. Prior to a meeting, any questions which citizens may have regarding any item on the agenda may be addressed to City Council or the City Administration. The following numbers are provided for the convenience of the citizens: CITY COUNCIL 455-3995 MAYOR 455-3995 CITY MANAGER 455-3990 A reasonable charge may be made for copying and other activities related to responding to long and involved inquiries. CITIZENS OFTEN EXPRESS CONFLICTING AND DIVERSE POSITIONS REGARDING SPECIFIC ISSUES UNDER CONSIDERATION. TO ENCOURAGE CITIZEN PARTICIPATION AND TO AVOID INTIMIDATION TO PERSONS WHO MAY EXPRESS SOMETIMES UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, APPLAUSE, CHEERS, OR JEERS FROM THE AUDIENCE ARE NOT PERMITTED. WHEN APPEARING BEFORE CITY COUNCIL, CITIZENS MAY NOT ENGAGE IN BEHAVIOR THAT INTIMIDATES OR INSULTS OTHERS, ENGAGE IN DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOR, USE PROFANITY OR VULGAR LANGUAGE, PROMOTE PRIVATE BUSINESS VENTURES OR CAMPAIGN FOR PUBLIC OFFICE. * PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED AND/OR CONSIDERED BY CITY COUNCIL Physical Development Committee – CANCELED A G E N D A City Council Meeting of February 9, 2021 Council Chamber | City Hall, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, VA 24504 4:00 P.M. WORK SESSION #1. Review the FY 2022 – FY 2026 Capital Improvement Plan for City Capital and City Schools projects. #2. Receive an update on the revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources. #3. Roll Call 7:30 P.M. City Council Agenda Items COUNCILMEMBER TWEEDY WILL GIVE THE INVOCATION February 9, 2021 2 C O N S E N T A G E N D A #4. Consideration of adopting minutes from the January 12, 2021 Meeting P U B L I C H E A R I N G #5. Consideration of adopting several ordinances dealing with telecommunications facilities and flag poles, light poles, and utility poles. #O-21-___ #O-21-___ #O-21-___ #6. Consideration of adopting an ordinance approving the right-of-way vacation of Advantage Court. #O-21-___ #7. Consideration of adopting an ordinance approving the right-of-way vacation of a portion of Chiles Circle. #O-21-___ P U B L I C C O M M E N T #8. Hear from a citizen regarding a concern (Bennie Castle). #9. Hear from a citizen regarding a concern (Andrew Glover). G E N E R A L B U S I N E S S #10. Consideration of introducing a resolution amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $24,794 with resources for a grant from the Library of Virginia to preserve several land books and marriage bonds at the Lynchburg Circuit Court Clerk’s Office. #R-21-___ #11. Consideration of introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $121,389 provided by the Department of Criminal Justice Services for the expansion of local probation and pretrial services to include Amherst County. #R-21-___ #12. Consideration of a closed meeting to discuss the appointment of a member to the Horizon Behavioral Health Board and to the Economic Development Authority, pursuant to Section 2.2- 3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia, as amended. LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: February 9, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 2 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: FY 2021 Revenue Update KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _ _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Receive an update on the revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources. SUMMARY: Several key Adopted FY 2021 revenue sources were reduced to reflect the anticipated economic impacts due to the COVID-19 pandemic; revenue collections are updated to include FY 2021 Second Quarter. PRIOR ACTION(S): Rebalancing the Proposed FY 2021 General Fund Budget Due to Economic Impact of COVID-19, City Council, April 28, 2020. FISCAL IMPACT: As noted. CONTACT(S): Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): FY 2021 Revenue Update REVIEWED BY: raw 018A City Council February 9, 2021 FY 2021 Adopted General Fund  Revenue Update COVID‐19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue  Monthly Update 2Note: Actual collections revised as of January 31, 2021. Local Sales and Use Tax Adopted  FY 2021 Actual  Collections FY 2021 Variance to  Adopted  Budget FY 2021 Local Sales and Use Tax $15,454,579  $9,333,014  ($6,121,565) July 1,119,330  1,503,837  384,507  August 1,025,719  1,396,989  371,270  September 1,252,153  1,531,422  279,269  October 1,251,875  1,498,945  247,070  November  1,361,561  1,516,545  154,984  (Sales and Use Tax for December due by February 15th)   December  *Not Final* 1,585,420  1,885,276  299,856  (Sales and Use Tax for January due by March 15th)  January 1,160 ,079  0  (1,160,079) (Sales and Use Tax for February due by April 15th)  February 1,1 96,836  0  (1,196,836) (Sales and Use Tax for March due by May 15th)  March 1,432,681  0   (1,432,681) (Sales and Use Tax for April due by June 15th)  April 1,331,840  0  (1,331,840) (Sales and Use Tax for May due by July 15th)  May 1,447,319  0  (1 ,447,319) (Sales and Use Tax for June due by August 15th)  June 1,289,766  0  (1,289,766) Local Sales and Use Tax 3 COVID‐19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue  Monthly Update (continued) 4Note: Actual collections revised as of January 31, 2021. Meals Tax Adopted  FY 2021 Actual  Collections FY 2021 Variance to  Adopted  Budget FY 2021 Meals Tax $14,932,599  $6,997,343  ($7,935,256) July 970,231  1,090,332  120,101  August 1,081,853  1,186,360  104,507  September 1,161,186  1,203,439  42,253  October 1,357,034  1,283,797  (73,237) November 1,230,200  1,109,005  (121,195) December 1,286,319  1,124,410  (161,909) (Meals Tax for January due by February 20th)  January 1,181,440  0  (1,181,440) (Meals Tax for February due by March 20th)  February 1,237,691  0   (1,237,691) (Meals Tax for March due by April 20th)  March 1,425,976  0  (1,42 5,976) (Meals Tax for April due by May 20th)  April 1,352,984  0  (1,352, 984) (Meals Tax for May due by June 20th)  May 1,397,503  0  (1,397,503 ) (Meals Tax for June due by July 20th)  June 1,250,182  0  (1,250,1 82) Meals Tax 5 COVID‐19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue  Monthly Update (continued) 6Note: Actual collections revised as of January 31, 2021. Lodging Tax Adopted  FY 2021 Actual  Collections FY 2021 Variance to  Adopted  Budget FY 2021 Lodging Tax $2,725,636  $1,126,258  ($1,599,378) July 147,156  155,637  8,481  August 177,753  213,511  35,758  September 208,246  257,411  49,165  October 314,431  226,390  (88,041) November 218,220  160,421  (57,799) December 156,330  112,888  (43,442) (Lodging Tax for January due b y February 20th)  January 211,325  0  (211,325) (Lodging Tax for February due by March 20th)  February 208,445  0   (208,445) (Lodging Tax for March due by April 20th)  March 279,608  0  (279, 608) (Lodging Tax for April due by May 20th)  April 233,875  0  (233,87 5) (Lodging Tax for May due by June 20th)  May 300,480  0  (300,480) (Lodging Tax for June due by July 20th)  June 269,767  0  (269,767 ) Lodging Tax 7 COVID‐19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue  Monthly Update (continued) 8Note: Actual collections revised as of January 31, 2021. Amusement Tax Adopted  FY 2021 Actual  Collections FY 2021 Variance to  Adopted  Budget FY 2021 Amusement Tax $795,190  $104,908  ($690,282) July 34,581  13,970  (20,611) August 28,321  19,248  (9,073) September 28,994  19,538  (9,456) October 73,504  18,752  (54,752) November 80,858  17,830  (63,028) December 81,843  15,570  (66,273) (Amusement Tax for January due by February 20th)  January 88,585   0  (88,585) (Amusement Tax for February due by March 20th)  February 62,931  0  (62,931) (Amusement Tax for March due by April 20th)  March 86,769  0  (86, 769) (Amusement Tax for April due by May 20th)  April 92,490  0  (92,49 0) (Amusement Tax for May due by June 20th)  May 63,944  0  (63,944) (Amusement Tax for June due by July 20th)  June 72,370  0  (72,370 ) Amusement Tax 9 Note:  The FY 2021 Revised Projection reduces uncollectible from 5.0% to 2.5%. Net Real Property 10 Net Personal Property Local Portion 11 Motor Vehicle License Fees 12 Use of Money and Property 13 Ambulance Fee 14 Building Inspections Permit Fee 15 All Other Permits and Fees 16 Consumer Utility Tax ‐ Electric  17 Consumer Utility Tax ‐ Gas  18 Expenditures Overall FY 2021 General Fund expenditures as of  12/31/2020 compared to FY 2020 for the same  period are down about $2 million.   – Reflects conservative department spending due to  COVID‐19 – CARES funding expenditures are included in the  City/Federal/State Aid Fund 19 Questions, Comments,  Observations 20 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: February 9, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 1 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: FY 2022 – FY 2026 Capital Improvement Plan Review for City Capital and City Schools Projects KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _ _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Review the submitted FY 2022 – FY 2026 Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) for City Capital and City Schools projects. SUMMARY: As part of the FY 2022 budget submissions, projects to be included in the FY 2022 – FY 2026 CIP for City Capital and City Schools have been received. Each year, staff reviews the submissions in conjunction with the City’s financial advisors, Davenport & Co., to determine the best funding strategy. Davenport staff are not able to attend this meeting but their analysis has been completed and will be presented. PRIOR ACTION(S): FISCAL IMPACT: As noted in report CONTACT(S): Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): Five Year Proposed Appropriations to be Financed by the City – City Capital and School Funds REVIEWED BY: raw Five Year Proposed Appropriations to be Financed by the City ‐ City Capital and School Fund Project Title Appropriations  Through  12/31/2020 Budget FY 2022 FY 2023 ‐ 2026  Planned Five‐Year  Estimated Net cost Estimated Cost  Beyond Program  Period Total Accumulated  Project Cost  Crossroads Lot ‐ Deck Addition  0 0 2,775,000 2,775,000 0 2,775,000  Downtown Parking Deck Facility  0 0 2,050,000 2,050,000 11,500,000 13,550,000  Major Building Repairs and Improvements/Multiple Projects  Continuing 3,009,400 9,171,500 12,180,900 Continuing Continuing  Parking Lot Repairs and Improvements/Multiple Projects  Continuing 251,000 800,000 1,051,000 Continuing Continuing  Police Department Headquarters  5,700,693 0 35,000,000 35,000,000 0 40,700,693  Public Library Renovation/Reimagination  1,092,710 0 3,500,000 3,500,000 0 4,592,710  Roof Replacement/Multiple Projects  Continuing 445,000 2,090,980 2,535,980 Continuing Continuing  Transfer Station for Refuse  0 0 550,000 550,000 4,000,000 4,550,000  Public Transit Improvements and Bus Replacements  10,144,772 5,510,103 13,041,323 18,551,426 3,466,172 32,162,370  5th Street Improvements, Phase IV  8,814,495 0 0 0 0 8,814,495  Bedford Avenue Bridge  0 3,000,000 2,000,000 5,000,000 0 5,000,000  Breezewood Drive Widening  0 6,000,000 0 6,000,000 0 6,000,000  Bridge Maintenance  Continuing 400,000 1,880,000 2,280,000 Continuing Continuing  Campbell Avenue Signal Improvements  0 0 2,500,000 2,500,000 0 2,500,000  Culvert Replacement Program  Continuing 65,000 1,330,000 1,395,000 Continuing Continuing  Florida Avenue Sidewalk  4,316,087 0 1,508,913 1,508,913 0 5,825,000  General Street Improvements  Continuing 850,000 3,500,000 4,350,000 Continuing Continuing  Hill Street/Moormans Road Improvements  400,000 0 4,500,000 4,500,000 0 4,900,000  Lakeside Drive Bridge over Blackwater Creek  28,500,000 0 0 0 0 28,500,000  Lakeside Drive Improvements  0 0 2,500,000 2,500,000 0 2,500,000  Liberty Mountain Drive Realignment  0 0 4,500,000 4,500,000 0 4,500,000  Link Road/Boonsboro Road Intersection Improvements  0 0 2,000,000 2,000,000 0 2,000,000  Lynchburg Expressway/Candlers Mountain Road Interchange  0 0 65,720,720 65,720,720 0 65,720,720  Lynchburg Expressway/Grace Street Interchange Improvements  0 0 125,000 125,000 1,000,000 1,125,000  Memorial Avenue Fuel Site  0 0 650,000 650,000 0 650,000  Public Works Infrastructure Improvements  Continuing 230,000 1,040,000 1,270,000 Continuing Continuing  Retaining Wall Replacement/Repair Program  Continuing 50,000 900,000 950,000 Continuing Continuing  Rivermont Avenue at Bedford Avenue Intersection Improvements  485,000 0 0 0 0 485,000  Rivermont Avenue Bridge Repair  0 7,500,000 0 7,500,000 0 7,500,000  Route 501/221 One‐Way Pairs  11,836,522 0 16,701,515 16,701,515 0 28,538,037  Storm Drainage System Repairs/Replacements  Continuing 135,000 700,000 835,000 Continuing Continuing  Street Overlay Program  Continuing 2,266,368 10,000,000 12,266,368 Continuing Continuing  Timberlake Road Bridge, East Bound Lanes  0 0 800,000 800,000 7,000,000 7,800,000  Timberlake Road Bridge, West Bound Lanes  0 0 7,800,000 7,800,000 0 7,800,000  Traffic Signal Repair and Replacement  Continuing 260,000 1,080,000 1,340,000 Continuing Continuing  Vassar Street at Langhorne Road Intersection Improvements  350,000 0 7,800,000 7,800,000 0 8,150,000  Wards Ferry Road at CVCC Campus Drive Roundabout  0 0 11,301,008 11,301,008 0 11,301,008  Wards Ferry Road/Atlanta Avenue Turn Lanes  0 0 1,700,000 1,700,000 0 1,700,000  Wards Ferry Road/Simons Run Pedestrian Accommodations  0 0 250,000 250,000 0 250,000 Project Title Appropriations  Through  12/31/2020 Budget FY 2022 FY 2023 ‐ 2026  Planned Five‐Year  Estimated Net cost Estimated Cost  Beyond Program  Period Total Accumulated  Project Cost  Downtown Development  Continuing 260,000 805,000 1,065,000 Continuing Continuing  Future Streetscape Improvements Downtown  0 0 10,050,000 10,050,000 0 10,050,000  Parking Station (On Street)  0 0 1,000,000 1,000,000 0 1,000,000  Street and Utility Extensions to Promote Economic Development  Continuing 250,000 1,000,000 1,250,000 Continuing Continuing  Streetscape Improvements Downtown, Phase II  5,258,052 600,000 2,051,459 2,651,459 0 7,909,511  Allen‐Morrison Site Assessment/Design  0 0 250,000 250,000 0 250,000  Athletic Field Maintenance  Continuing 250,000 1,000,000 1,250,000 Continuing Continuing  City Stadium Football Field Turf Replacement  0 0 1,650,000 1,650,000 0 1,650,000  College Park Upgrade  0 0 250,000 250,000 0 250,000  Creekside Trail Reconstruction/Flood‐Damage Repair  57,000 443,000 0 443,000 0 500,000  General Parks Maintenance  Continuing 100,000 400,000 500,000 Continuing Continuing  Lynchburg Community Market Renovations  0 82,500 4,605,000 4,687,500 0 4,687,500  Miller Park Pool Assessment/Replacement  0 0 5,990,000 5,990,000 0 5,990,000  New Dog Park  0 0 200,000 200,000 0 200,000  Parks Paving and Lighting/Reconstruction  Continuing 345,000 1,112,000 1,457,000 Continuing Continuing  Parks Tree Replacement Program  0 100,000 400,000 500,000 0 500,000  Riverside Park Pool‐Area Improvements  0 200,000 0 200,000 0 200,000  Sandbar Removal ‐ Hollins Mill Road Trail Crossing  0 165,000 0 165,000 0 165,000  Sustainable Infrastructure Program  Continuing 100,000 400,000 500,000 Continuing Continuing  College Lake Dam Removal  10,000,000 0 10,000,000 10,000,000 0 20,000,000  Computer Aided Dispatch Replacement  0 1,730,000 3,270,000 5,000,000 0 5,000,000  Radio Replacement   626,324 211,208 511,208 722,416 100,000 1,448,740  Lynchburg City Stadium Capital Maintenance Reserve  500,000 100,000 400,000 500,000 0 1,000,000  Snow, Street, and Bridge Reserve  Continuing 250,000 1,000,000 1,250,000 Continuing Continuing  Athletic Complexes  0 120,000 2,250,000 2,370,000 0 2,370,000  Linkhorne Elementary Renovation & Gym Addition  0 0 13,176,000 13,176,000 0 13,176,000  Mechanical/Electrical  0 590,080 2,500,000 3,090,080 0 3,090,080  New Transportation Building ‐ Schools  0 0 6,700,000 6,700,000 0 6,700,000  Paul Munro ES Renovation & Gym Addition  0 0 540,000 540,000 0 540,000  Paving and Fencing  0 0 650,000 650,000 0 650,000  Playground Equipment Replacement  0 0 200,000 200,000 0 200,000  Plumbing/Restroom Renovation  0 0 70,000 70,000 0 70,000  Roof Replacement/Repair  0 100,000 1,068,000 1,168,000 0 1,168,000  Sandusky Elementary School Replacement  0 0 37,000,000 37,000,000 0 37,000,000  Total Proposed FY 2022 ‐ 2026 CIP  $88,081,656 $35,968,659 $332,264,626 $368,233,285 $27,066,172 $435,6 54,865 1 January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 12th day of January, 2021, at 4:00 P.M. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, J. Randy Nelson, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 5 Absent: Jeff S. Helgeson, Treney Tweedy 2 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #1, Ms. Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, provided Council with a monthly update on revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources. These figures only looked at the month of November and were compared against November of 2019 revenue collections. Sales Tax continues to trend upward coming in at about 7% above the previous November. Ms. Witt attributes this to online sales and grocery sales continuing strong. Meals Tax is down 6% compared to the previous November. Ms. Witt attributed the numbers not being worse because the month of November was a very warm month so there was more outdoor seating available. Lodging Tax is down about 23% compared to last year, however, compared to the rest of the state Lodging Tax isn’t down as drastically as a lot of localities. Amusement Tax is still down 75%, but Regal Cinemas is hoping there will be enough movies released in the Spring that they will be able to open back up. Ms. Witt stated that at the first meeting in February the full 2nd Quarter will be presented. // In the matter of Community Development – Zoning, Agenda Item #2, Council conducted a work session on zoning ordinance amendments related to telecommunication facilities. Mr. Tom Martin, City Planner, and Mr. J. Patrick Taves with Greehan, Taves, & Pandak, PLLC presented Council with a summary of the item. The City’s Zoning Ordinance sections related to Telecommunication Facilities were last updated in December 1997 with minor amendments in January 2020. Amendments to Virginia Code in 2017 – 2020 and federal law regarding telecommunications facilities requires the City to update t he ordinance in order to be compliant with the new regulations. The City’s comprehensive plan states that in order for the City to continue its role as an economic engine for this region, the City has to keep pace with changes to technology and telecommunications. In January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 2 order for the City to support local businesses, it will have to capitalize on those changes. The fact that the telecommunications ordinance was last updated in the year 1997 really necessitated the need for the changes to the proposed draft, which has been drafted in conjunction with Mr. Taves. The draft ordinance was forwarded to over 26 firms in the telecommunications industry back in August of 2020 for their review and only received very minor comments. The Planning Commission conducted a work session in November of 2020, then a Public Hearing in December of 2020, and unanimously recommended approval of the draft telecommunication ordinance. The purpose of bringing the draft item to Council’s work session is to allow for a detailed review and discussion. The next step will be to hold a Public Hearing. Staff briefed Council on the different components of the draft ordinance which include State and Federal mandates, types of facilities (Small Cell, Administrative Review Eligible Products (AREPs), Standard Process Projects), timelines for review, height where permitted, and setbacks. Councilmember Faraldi asked if there is justification that flagpoles are in the same legal area as a telecommunication pole. Mr. Erwin stated that although it may seem farfetched to class these towers the same as flagpoles, it really is the best option when choosing a similar structure. Councilmember Faraldi requested clarification on whether the proposed ordinance would prohibit a company from installing a large flagpole as an attraction. Mr. Martin replied that the only new regulation in the ordinance regarding flagpoles is setbacks based on height. Mr. Erwin clarified that the ordinance does not impact the ability for businesses to put up flagpoles. Councilmember Nelson asked what the rationale was for abandoning the former twice the height fall zone criteria. He specifically wanted to know what the validation was for including it originally. Mr. Taves stated that many years ago localities looked at these facilities and thought they were precarious and prone to falling, however, that is just not the case. The technology has changed and is not as bulky as it once was and the towers themselves are incredibly substantial. The twice the height fall zone criteria was established out of an abundance of caution and there is no evidence to support the need to have the excessive distance from a property line. Councilmember Nelson also stated concerns over the phrase “deemed complete and deemed approved”. The statement carries with it some challenges for local January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 3 government in that if the process and procedures are not promptly and quickly scrutinized, applications that come in end up being deemed complete and deemed approved without any real diligence or scrutiny. On the other side of that is the concern with expanding internet access given the pandemic. The less obstacles there are to facilitating a widespread internet connection, the better everyone will be including the school division and families. Councilmember Nelson addressed a third concern, stating that Council has been advised not to base reasoning on certain aspects but to be focused on only the acceptable criteria and standards that are legitimate to deny an application. He asked specifically if there were any changes to the standards used to analyze or assess the acceptability or the non-acceptability of a project in this draft ordinance, or will Council be looking at this with the same scrutiny and the same precautions and only the setbacks and such have changed? Mr. Erwin stated that what has been done in the past is the City Attorney advises Council on the factors that can be considered and the factors that cannot be considered when Council is making a decision. The City Attorney’s Office would then draft a very detailed ordinance with the specifics. // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item #3, Councilmember Faraldi wanted to extend his appreciation to law enforcement given the recent National Law Enforcement Appreciation Day; he also stated that he is actively trying to spread awareness about trash pick-up and extended a thank you to the frontline workers who are working so hard to pick up the trash and do the best with the resources on hand; he would appreciate some update from the schools about how they are moving forward. Councilmember Wilder commended staff for working so long and hard for the trash pick-up. Councilmember Tweedy praised refuse staff for implementing trash pick-up and commended the school board and leadership for doing challenging work in a challenging time. Councilmember Nelson and Vice Mayor Wright had no items. Mayor Dolan spoke about the contest to help save the angel statue at the Old City Cemetery; she also asked citizens to take the pandemic seriously and to wear a mask, wash hands, and practice social distancing. // The meeting was recessed at 5:15 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff S. Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 Councilmember Faraldi gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan presented Ms. Alayah Henderson with a Proclamation declaring January as Holocaust Recognition Month. Ms. Henderson is a member of a teen task force working to combat antisemitism through educating the community. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda Item #4, copies of the minutes of the December 8, 2020 meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy, Council by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #5, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting Resolution #R-21-001 requesting an exemption to the Utility Disconnect Moratorium. Mr. Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources, presented Council with a summary of the item. In the beginning of March, 2020, the Department of Water Resources voluntarily suspended disconnection of water service for delinquent accounts as a direct response to the COVID-19 pandemic. During the 2020 Special Session I, the General Assembly approved Appropriations Act Amendments, Item 4-14, which included specific procedures and requirements for utility services related to the coronavirus declared state of emergency including: provisions related to customer assistance grants; utility disconnection moratorium requirements; customer repayment plans; and provisions for exemption to the disconnection moratorium. Municipal utilities may seek an exemption to the disconnection moratorium given that they: provide the accounts receivable arrearages exceeding one percent of the total annual operating revenues; make the accounting analysis showing the one percent exceedance available for public inspection; conduct a public hearing; and obtain verification from the governing body January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 that arrearages exceed one percent and affirming the intention to resume utility disconnections for non- payment. Upon verification, City staff recommends the resumption of utility disconnections beginning in February, 2021. In conjunction with the resumption of utility disconnections, repayment plans will also be offered to customers. Customers participating in repayment plans will not be cut-off as long as they remain current with their plan. Additionally, customers with arrearages may apply up until January 22, 2021 for funds from the COVID-19 Municipal Utility Relief Program to be applied to their outstanding water and sewer balances. Customers are encouraged to take advantage of both of these programs to help avoid disconnection for delinquent accounts. Mr. Mitchell reviewed the analysis showing that the accounts receivable arrearages exceed one percent (1.77% as of November 30, 2020) of Water and Sewer Funds’ annual operating revenues. There was no one to speak either in favor or opposition, either by phone, emails, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Wilder asked if these funds were different funds than that of the funds the nonprofits agencies are able to use. Mr. Mitchell explained that these are different funds specifically administered by the City and customers have to fill out an application and certify that they have been affected by COVID financially in order to be eligible for the funds. Councilmember Wilder asked how much funds were allotted to the City. Mr. Mitchell reiterated that the City has been allocated about $344,000 and to date the City has received applications for about $86,000. Councilmember Wilder asked how much funding the nonprofits had left. Mr. Kent White, Interim Deputy City Manager, stated that the agreement with the nonprofit organizations expired in December of 2020. Mayor Dolan clarified that she talked to Interfaith Outreach earlier in the day and confirmed that they do have funds still available from donors and not CARES funds, so that would be another resource for citizens. Vice Mayor Wright asked how tailored the repayment plans are to individual accounts. Mr. Mitchell stated that it was somewhat at the discretion of the billings and collections office. The plan is to offer a repayment plan for up to about twelve months, but if a customer has a low balance then that repayment plan might not be the full twelve months. January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 Councilmember Faraldi asked how staff plans to navigate the scenario if the funds are depleted but the City still has a balance in the arrearages. Mr. Mitchell said that under that scenario, staff would encourage customers to take advantage of the repayment program so that they can become current over a period of time. Another thing that we may do is adjust the cutoff threshold initially so that staff won’t be overburdened at one time. Councilmember Tweedy asked what the ratio was for residential and business. Mr. Mitchell explained that by far the majority is residential, and businesses are eligible for the funds as well, however, the legislation directs localities to prioritize residential first. If there are relief funds left over at the end, then that may be a possibility to apply to businesses, but there is no guarantee there will be relief left over; if there are, staff will be accepting applications from businesses. Councilmember Nelson stated that it has been made abundantly clear that citizens who are in debt for unpaid water bills are not taking advantage of money that is there to relie ve them of financial woe. In the course of dealing with this, he asked if staff has been able to identify any credible obstacle that the City could undertake to relieve what is preventing citizens from applying and receiving approval? Mr. Mitchell replied that he believes staff has made the process incredibly easy, especially with the latest addition of taking applications over the phone which resulted in an increase in applications. There were some applicants who did not indicate that they were experiencing hardship due to COVID-19. Those applications were rejected; however, Billings and Collections were following up with those customers. Mayor Dolan wanted to know what the deadline was to apply for the funds . Mr. Mitchell explained that the deadline has been extended until the end of the calendar year and any funds that remain at that time must be returned to the state by December 31 2021. Mr. Mitchell stated that staff will cease accepting applications a week prior to that date, but he anticipates the funds will be depleted before then. Councilmember Wilder made a motion to approve the resolution, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded, adopting Resolution #R - 21-001: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Community Development – Planning, Agenda Item #6, a public hearing was held for the consideration of adopting Resolution #R-21-002 granting a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) to Jefferson House, LLC to allow the construction of a five story, sixty-five unit apartment building for seniors. Mr. Tom Martin, City Planner, provided Council with a summary of the petition. Jefferson House LLC, is petitioning for a CUP at 1818 Langhorne Square to allow the construction of a sixty-five unit apartment complex in a B-3, Community Business District. The units would be deed restricted as affordable units for the elderly. If approved, a total of one hundred sixty-six units would exist with only sixty-seven parking spaces proposed for the two buildings. The Zoning Ordinance typically provides for one parking space per one residential unit but allows the City Planner to reduce the number of the spaces where mass transit is available and if the applicant provides credible information documenting that supports the reduction in parking. The petitioner has provided that there are currently forty-two parking spots serving the existing one hundred one residential units. Only twenty-five residents have cars and the other parking spaces are utilized by staff that comes in the morning and at night. The maximum usage of parking has averaged thirty-two spaces and most of the usage is by home health aides and the three staff members. Based upon the availability of mass transit, parking need demonstrated by the petitioner and the restriction to senior housing, staff believes parking will not be an issue. The Planning Commission also discussed how the project could potentially improve stormwater conveyance on the site. The Planning Commission conducted a Public Hearing on December 9, 2020, and recommended approval. Mr. Joe Eddy, President of JE Properties, the developer of this property, addressed Council. JE Properties works mostly with affordable housing and they came across this property a couple of years when it was in default with Virginia Housing. There were a lot of capital needs like a roof problem, leaks, and an infestation and used private capital in conjunction with the City’s real estate revitalization tax exemption program. This is a prime location for senior housing because it is near a hospital and the developer has already installed a sidewalk to help with access to the bus line. JE Properties is continuing to improve the property by adding additional units and will be done as a low-income tax credit project. They will apply to VHDA for the tax credits in March, with hopefully an approval in July and will begin the January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 8 project the following March. If they do not get the tax credits this year they will reapply for them the following year. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson noted that the developer stated that if they don’t receive the tax credits, they will delay the project until they do. Mr. Eddy replied that the funding is through the tax credit program and if they receive the funding, that is the subsidy to allow for lower rents. Councilmember Helgeson requested clarification from Mr. Martin in regards to the following scenario: if the developer does not receive the tax credits but Council approves a CUP for the property, could the property then be sold to somebody else that may not have similar intentions with the property? He specifically cited concerns regarding the lack of parking spaces. Mr. Martin stated that the CUP would be valid for 36-months, so the developer has quite a bit of time to see if they are going to get approvals. Councilmember Helgeson asked if Council were to approve the CUP and the developer doesn’t receive the funding, if the CUP would become void after the 36-months. Mr. Martin clarified that it would become void and they would have to apply again. Councilmember Helgeson asked what would happen if the developer sells the property? Mr. Martin explained that it would have to be the same type of development for the elderly and Council could add a phrase to the resolution indicating this, phrased as such, “the conditional use permit is being approved only for senior housing”. City Attorney Mr. Walter Erwin stated that they couldn’t put anything significantly different from the concept plan without coming back to Council and getting permission. Councilmember Helgeson said that the concept plan could be the same, but the tenants could be different. Councilmember Helgeson made the motion to approve the resolution with the revisions Mr. Martin suggested. Councilmember Wilder seconded the motion stating there is a need for additional hous ing for seniors. He also asked for clarification from Mr. Eddy regarding the renovations that are currently being done, even without the tax credit funding. Mr. Eddy clarified that yes, the renovations are still happening regardless of the expansion. January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 9 With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded, approving Resolution #R - 21-002: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Programs, Agenda Item #7, a public hearing was held to receive public comments regarding the goals for the development of the Fiscal Year 2022 Annual Action Plan and adopt Resolution #R-21-003 approving the goals. Ms. Melva Walker, Grants Manager, provided Council with a brief summary of the item. The U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) requires state and local governments, which receive federal community development funds, to prepare a Consolidated Plan. The Consolidated Plan for Lynchburg was approved in June 2020 and covers the period from July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2024. This plan outlines the City’s needs, goals, and objectives for community development (both housing and non-housing areas). HUD requires Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program entitlement communities to review these goals on an annual basis. City Council is seeking the input of citizens and other interested parties regarding the approved goals regarding the City’s housing and non-housing community development needs common to low- and moderate-income households and neighborhoods in Lynchburg. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone, email, or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. As Chair of the Community Development Advisory Committee, Vice Mayor Wright made the motion to approve the resolution stating that the goals are thoughtful and a result of a collaborative process with members of the community. Councilmember Wilder, who serves as the Vice Chair for the Community Development Advisory Committee seconded the motion stating that he appreciates all of the hard work from staff and is thankful to support the project and its many wraparound services. January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 10 Councilmember Helgeson stated he appreciated the work that goes into this type of plan by the Chairman, Vice Chairman, and the citizen volunteers. On the housing goals, it indicates the support of affordable housing in both the rental and the sales market. He stated that it seems a little vague as far as the word choice because rentals can be sold. He asked if the intention was to imply owner-occupied? Ms. Walker stated that the word “homeownership” was specified in the plan last year, but Council advised to change that to sales market to imply homeownership. Vice Mayor Wright clarified that Council directed staff on the wording change to represent owner-occupied as sales. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded, approving Resolution #R - 21-003: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the City Manager’s Office, Agenda Item #8, a public hearing was held to solicit feedback from the public on the potential sale of property at 97 Page Street. Interim City Manager Dr. Reid Wodicka provided Council with a brief summary of the item. The City received a request to sell the property which has been owned by the City since 1965. This is a vacant parcel that presently has no public use; that fact has been affirmed by the City’s Technical Review Committee. In addition to advertising this public hearing, the property was listed on multiple listing services since September 18, 2020. The City received one offer for purchase of this property for $10,000 with the intent of building a duplex or quadplex which is permitted by the City’s zoning ordinance. The City’s assessment on the property is for $5,000. The City has received no other offers. At the conclusion of the public hearing, staff are requesting Council adopt Resolution #R-21-004 authorizing the sale of this property. There was one citizen who spoke in favor through a statement previously provided to the Clerk of Council, which was read into the record. Mr. Tyler Brown who placed the offer on the property, displayed to Council his good intentions with the property, citing how this is intended to be a rental property that will bring funds back to the City through taxes, permits, etc., and will provide clean, affordable housing to the area. January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 11 There was no one else to speak in favor or opposition, either in-person, or through voicemails or emails, so the public hearting was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson made the motion to approve the resolution stating that he appreciates the fact that it was listed and that ample opportunity was given for other interested parties looking to purchase and appreciates the openness and transparency. He clarified that this resolution only authorizes the sale of the property and does not have any inferred approval of the items that the buyer mentioned. If there needs to be rezoning for example, adopting this resolution does not bind Council to that. He asked staff to look into any other properties like this that could be sold and returned back to the tax rolls. Councilmember Wilder seconded the motion. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded, approving Resolution #R - 21-004: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the City Charter, Agenda Item #9, a public hearing was held and Council considered adopting Resolution #R-21-005, requesting the General Assembly to revise the City Charter to remove limits on City Council salaries. Interim City Manager Dr. Reid Wodicka, provided Council with a brief summary of the item. The salaries that will be paid to the Mayor, Vice Mayor, and City Councilmembers is prescribed in Section 7 of the City Charter. While this provision has been in effect since 1976, Section 15.2-1414.6 of the State Code allows City Council to set salaries that are higher than the salaries set by the City Charter, and City Council has on several occasions voted to increase their rate of pay. As such, the pay rates found within the Charter ($2,400 for Councilmembers; $3,000 for the Vice Mayor; and $3,600 for the Mayor) are no longer accurate. During the legislative agenda setting process for the 2021 General Assembly Sessions, Council voted to request that the General Assembly revise the City Charter to remove those limits from the Charter and provide City Council the option to adopt its own salaries. Presently, Council has set their January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 12 salaries for the Mayor at $12,000, and Vice Mayor and Members of Council at $10,000. The purpose of the public hearing is to solicit feedback on the proposal of the charter amendment. If Council chooses to adopt the resolution it will be forwarded to the General Assembly tomorrow. There was no one to speak in favor, either in-person, or through voicemails or emails. There was one citizen who spoke in opposition through a statement previously provided to the Clerk of Council, which was read into the record. Ms. Starlette Early, resident of Ward I, urged Council to deny the recommendation of approving the resolution, indicating that City Council salaries should be set at a rate that would not place them better off than the citizens they represent, or at the expense of other needed programs for the residents. Ms. Early further urged Council to not allow the City’s charter to be opened and amended by the General Assembly just to provide this governing body an opportunity to set the level of their own salaries. With no other citizen input, the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Faraldi stated that the justification for this language as he interprets it would allow Council to be more flexible with setting their salaries as it is not clearly defined in the Charter. More importantly, the revision is needed due to legislation in last years’ legislative session that would mandate localities pay what is in their charter. He also stated that Delegate Walker has indicated that he is willing to carry this proposal to the General Assembly. City Attorney Mr. Walter Erwin clarified that what this proposal will do is make the City Charter consistent with State law. There is a provision in the State Code that spells out what members of governing bodies can do in regard to their salaries. The provision in the City Charter is old and inconsistent with the State Code and all this proposal does is ask that the City Code be made consistent with the State Code. Councilmember Tweedy made the motion to adopt the resolution. Vice Mayor Wright seconded the motion. Councilmember Nelson stated that the last time this issue came up, he voted with the sentiments that were expressed by the citizen in Ward I. However, as it was pointed out the last time this was January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 13 discussed, sitting on this Council is somewhat prohibited by citizens who do not have an abundance of resources because the job does not pay enough to pay the bills. In order to give some greater incentive to the average citizen to endear them to be on Council, an increase in compensation must happen. He continued by stating that he does not want to vote for an increase for his personal salary but because it does translate into benefits for all citizens to have the potential to serve on Council . Therefore, he will be supporting the motion. Vice Mayor Wright stated that if the State ends up making changes in the 2021 legislative session, Council could be restricted to what salary is listed in the City Charter. This proposal is just a matter of clearing up a technicality. Mr. Erwin clarified that this amendment would not let City Council raise its salary to whatever Council wishes. There are salary limits in the State Code, and City Council salaries will be confined to them. Mayor Dolan stated that she will be voting in favor since this motion is bringing the City Charter up to State Code and not a motion to increase Council salaries at this time. With no other discussion, the following vote was recorded approving Resolution #R -21-005: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #10, Mr. Gary Taylor, resident of Lynchburg, asked Council to consider restructuring the Bridges to Progress Steering Committee to be an Education subcommittee to address pre-K and K-12 issues in regards to the pandemic. // In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item #11, Council considered adopting Ordinance #O-21-006 to continue emergency procedures for the conduct of public business to ensure the continuity of City government and critical local services during the state of emergency and disaster caused by t he COVID- 19 pandemic. January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 14 Dr. Reid Wodicka, Interim City Manager, presented Council with a brief summary of the request. On March 24, 2020, City Council adopted a “Continuity of Government” ordinance and on April 28, 2020 adopted associated rules of procedure for City Council to follow in the event that City Council elected to hold electronic meetings. Though City Council has not chosen to conduct electronic meetings, the City’s Continuity of Government ordinance provides the authority to other City boards, c ommissions, and authorities to hold electronic meetings. Several of those bodies have chosen to conduct electronic meetings during the pandemic. The Continuity of Government ordinance was originally adopted for an initial term of six months, which expired on September 24, 2020. On September 22, 2020, City Council elected to extend this ordinance for an additional four months, ending January 22, 2021. Unfortunately, the COVID-19 pandemic remains a reality and if City Council wishes to extend the provisions o f this ordinance and associated procedures, it is necessary to adopt an additional extension . The continuance ordinance, as presented, would remain in effect until June 30, 2021, when City Council repeals the ordinance, or when the local Declaration of Local Emergency is ended, whichever occurs first. City Attorney Mr. Walter Erwin stated that this ordinance also authorizes emergency procurement for public bodies in the City that might need goods and services to deal with a pandemic. Vice Mayor Wright made the motion to approve the ordinance, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy. Councilmember Helgeson stated that he will not be supporting this ordinance because if Council should decide to not have meetings in which the public can attend, that should be discussed on an as- needed basis instead of declaring it for the next six months. Mayor Dolan said that she will be supporting this ordinance because Council meets in person but with great trepidation because certain members refuse to don the proper PPE. Councilmember Nelson stated that citizens having the ability to come in person to address their elected officials is their fundamental constitutional liberty. The power and impact of the in -person address is far more intense then if people are on a computer screen at a distant point. He strongly expressed that he does not want this Council, or any public body, to have the insulation from their public when the public has a right to bring their pleas to that body and be heard. He further commented that the language of the January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 15 ordinance is fine, however, there needs to be immense accommodations to address why the restriction is necessary and make certain that everyone is clear as to why the means to exercise that liberty should be constrained. He stated that he will be supporting this ordinance but reluctantly because there is no specific language stating the requirement for the accommodations being made for the body that is choosing to not have a public assembly. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he has strong reservations about adopting this ordinance, citing his stance against limiting Council’s engagement with the community. He further stated that members of boards and commissions are appointed by City Council and he does not believe they should limit their engagement with the community in an in-person fashion. He commented that if his voting in opposition expresses his disapproval of that then so be it. He reiterated that he has strong reservations to support this moving forward if boards and commissions are taking actions to limit their engagement with the constituency they are supposed to be representing. Councilmember Tweedy asked Mr. Erwin if this ordinance would give individual councilmembers the right to virtually join a meeting if they felt unsafe joining in-person; Mr. Erwin replied that yes, that is the case. Councilmember Wilder stated that he would be supporting the motion, but wants to make sure that the community is informed ahead of time. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he does support the idea of giving options and does support the idea of having virtual meetings, however, with that there are certain limitations in which the public can be involved. For example, the public is not offered the opportunity to join a virtual meeting or to join a conference call and are being limited to writing an email or leaving a voicemail. He stated that he respects the intention of this ordinance however, he has fundamental issues with the way some of the boards and commissions have operated with engaging the community. Mayor Dolan stated that this is not a mandate this is an option; during a pandemic, Council has a responsibility to safeguard the people that it appoints to its boards and commissions. January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 16 Councilmember Tweedy stated that it is Council’s responsibility to put forth those things that will provide protective measures for the people who serve at our bequest so when they do not have parameters that would keep them safe it is my responsibility to do those things necessary to help protect them. With no other discussion, the motion to adopt Ordinance #O-21-006 was approved with the following recorded vote: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 // In the matter of Community Development – Planning, Agenda Item #12, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-21-007 supporting Virginia Housing Loan Funding for Miller’s Rest, Phase II. Mr. Tom Martin, City Planner, provided Council with a brief summary of the request. Mr. Austin T. Pittman with Lawson Companies has submitted a letter requesting that City Council adopt a resolution that would allow the Lawson Companies to apply for tax credit funding from Virginia Housing (formerly Virginia Housing Development Authority). The project would consist of one hundred fifteen apartment units and be located at 6100 Old Mill Road. The property is zoned R-4, High Density Residential. The proposed apartments are a permitted use in this district. City Council adopted the Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice on June 23, 2020. The document lists “location and type of affordable housing” as a factor impeding housing choice. Providing more housing choices in more areas across the City could increase the accessibility and affordability of housing in Lynchburg. The project would be a “mixed-income” community housing families earning 20% to 80% of Area Median Income (AMI). Units can be rented within the range provided the project averages 60% of AMI. The project would have the potential to provide housing for families earning between $14,480 to $57,920. The 2018 Median Income for the City of Lynchburg was $43,374. Councilmember Helgeson stated that this resolution in essence is supporting one developer over another when, normally these things are competitive, and he does not think Council should be involved January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 17 with favoring one particular developer. He also mentioned that there was no site plan or details about the development to assess the project. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to deny the resolution. Mr. Martin explained that providing housing in this area, which is a workforce area, would benefit the City in its commercial, industrial, and economic development. There are numerous industries in that area that workforce housing may benefit. The resolution is saying that without tax credit fund ing, it is unlikely that anyone else is going to come in and build affordable housing in this area. Staff assured Council that this type of ask is fairly common. Mr. Erwin stated that this resolution will serve as a letter of support to include with the application, and having a letter of support from the locality greatly enhances the chances of getting the funding. Councilmember Faraldi asked if this project is possible without the tax credits. Mr. Pittman clarified that without the tax credit subsidy they would not be able to charge the affordable rent levels. He explained that Lawson Companies are tied to the affordable housing concept but if they don’t win tax credits this year they will be able to reapply the following year. He further explained that having this resolution to include with the packet will enhance their ability to procure tax credits from Virginia Housing. Councilmember Faraldi asked for clarification on the expiration of the credits, specifically, will the developer need to reapply every year in order to charge the affordable rent levels. Mr. Pitman responded that it is a one-time thing and the affordability will last for 30-years. With no second, the motion to deny the approval of the resolution failed. Vice Mayor Wright made the motion to approve the resolution, seconded by Councilmember Wilder. Vice Mayor Wright said that this resolution does not bind Council in any way, this merely shows support for this project. Councilmember Wilder said that the City needs affordable housing so he supports this. With no other discussion, the motion to adopt Resolution #R-21-007 was approved with the following recorded vote: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 18 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss appointments for vacancies to the following Boards and Commissions: Economic Development Authority and City Employees Appeal Board pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Faraldi made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg cer tifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Helgeson 1 January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 19 // On motion of Vice Mayor Wright, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Economic Development Authority: Ms. Patricia Mosby – unexpired term ending June 30, 2024 City Employees Appeal Board: No appointments were made at this time. Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Helgeson 1 // The meeting adjourned at 9:35 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: February 9, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles Repeal Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.20 related to Telecommunication Towers and replace with Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance, Amendments to Authorized Uses in the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, B-1, B-3, B-4, B-5, IN-1, IN-2, I-1, I-2 and I-3 Districts. KEY ELEMENTS: _X _Economic Development _X Excellent Government _X Natural and Built Environment _ Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION(s): Adopt the following three ordinances dealing with telecommunications facilities and flag poles, light poles, and utility poles: Ordinance #1: Adopt the proposed Zoning Ordinance amendment, as advertised, to add Section 35.2–61.2(d) with regard to flag poles, light poles, and utility poles to the City Code and to make that amendment effective upon adoption. Ordinance #2: Adopt an ordinance repealing Chapter 35.2–73 of the City Code, which comprises Sections 35.2–73.1 through 35.2–73.20 of the current Zoning Ordinance and pertains to Telecommunications Facilities, and simultaneously adopt the proposed Zoning Ordinance amendments, as advertised, to add a new Chapter 35.2–73 to the Zoning Ordinance, which comprises Sections 35.2–73.1 through 35.2–73.26, and to make those amendments effective upon adoption. Ordinance #3: Adopt the proposed Zoning Ordinance amendments, as advertised, to amend the exhibits in the Zoning Ordinance to reflect the “Approval Type” for wireless telecommunications transmission as “C” for Conditional Use Permit” and/or “P” for Permitted” in accordance with the new Chapter 35.2–73 Council just adopted, and to make those amendments effective upon adoption. SUMMARY: The City’s Zoning Ordinance sections related to Telecommunication Facilities were last updated in December 1997 with minor amendments in January 2020. Amendments to the Virginia Code in 2017 - 2020 and federal law regarding telecommunications facilities requires the City to update the Ordinance in order to be compliant with the new regulations. City Council received an overview of the proposed ordinance amendments on January 12, 2021. PRIOR ACTION(S): November 11, 2020: Planning Commission work session on the proposed Zoning Ordinance Amendments. December 9, 2020: The Planning Division recommended approval of the proposed Zoning Ordinance Amendments. The Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on the proposed Zoning Ordinance amendments and recommended approval (7-0) of the proposed Zoning Ordinance Amendments. January 12, 2021: City Council work session on the proposed Zoning Ordinance Amendments. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A CONTACT(S): Tom Martin, City Planner – 455-3900 J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC – (703) 378-5770 ATTACHMENT(S): • Ordinance #1 – Section 35.2-61.2(d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles • Ordinance #2 – Sections 35.2-73.1 – Section 35.2-73.20 Telecommunications Ordinance • Ordinance #3 – Authorized Uses in the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, B-1, B-3, B-4, B-5, IN-1, IN-2, I-1, I-2 & I-3 Districts • City Council Work Session Agenda Summary – January 12, 2021 • City Council Presentation – January 12, 2021 • Telecommunications Fact Sheet • Planning Commission Minutes – December 9, 2020 • Planning Commission Packet – December 9, 2020 o Planning Commission Report o Zoning Ordinance Amendment – Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles (Proposed) o Zoning Ordinance Amendment – Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance (Proposed) o Power Point Presentation – December 9, 2020 o Planning Commission Memorandum – November 11, 2020 o Power Point Presentation – November 11, 2020 • Planning Commission Sign in Sheet – December 9, 2020 • Telecommunications Legal Notice • Existing Telecommunications Ordinance REVIEWED BY: klw 011A ORDINANCE: AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT THE CODE OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, 1981 BY AMENDING ZONING ORDINANCE SECTION 35.2-61.2, ADDITIONAL HEIGHT REQUIREMENTS BY ADDING NEW SECTION 35.2-61.2 (D), FLAG POLES, LIGHT POLES AND UTILITY POLES. WHEREAS, City staff has proposed and recommends approval of an Ordinance amending Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2–61.2, Additional Height Requirements, to add new Section 35.2- 61.2(d), Flag Poles, Light Poles, and Utility Poles (“the proposed Ordinance”); and WHEREAS, on November 11, 2020, the Planning Commission of the City of Lynchburg held a work session on the proposed Ordinance; and WHEREAS, on December 9, 2020, the Planning Commission held a public hearing to consider and address the proposed Ordinance and to receive public comment on the proposed Ordinance; and WHEREAS, after its public hearing on the proposed amendments on December 9, 2020, the Planning Commission recommended that the City Council approve the proposed Ordinance; and WHEREAS, City Council conducted a work session on the proposed Ordinance on January 12, 2021; and WHEREAS, on February 9, 2021, City Council held a public hearing to consider and address the proposed Ordinance and to receive public comment on the proposed Ordinance; and WHEREAS, City Council finds that the proposed Ordinance should be adopted in order to promote the public necessity, convenience, welfare and good zoning practice. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: That Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Requirements of the Code of the City of Lynchburg, 1981 is hereby amended and reenacted by adding Section 35.2-61.2 (d), Flag Poles, Light Poles and Utility Poles as follows: (d) Flag poles, Light Poles and Utility Poles 1. There shall be no setback requirement for any Flag Pole, Light Pole or Utility Pole that is thirty-five (35) feet or less in height. 2. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole greater than thirty-five (35) in height in the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 District shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the height of the pole. 3. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole greater than thirty-five (35) in height in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District that is on a parcel adjacent to any parcel that is zoned R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 shall be set back a distance at least the height of the pole from the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 District. 4. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District that is greater than thirty-five (35) feet in height but less than fifty (50) feet in height shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the minimum applicable setback for the district in which it is located. 5. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District that is a height greater than fifty (50) feet shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least one-half the height of the pole. 6. Setback requirements for Flag Poles, Light Poles, and Utility Poles shall be measured from the base of the pole to the property lines of the parcel on which the pole is located. That this ordinance shall become effective upon its adoption. Adopted: Certified: ____________________________ Clerk of Council 1 ORDINANCE: AN ORDINANCE REPEALING CHAPTER 35.2 -73, WHICH COMPRISES §§ 35.2 -73.1 THROUGH 35.2-73.20, AND ADOPTING A NEW CHAPTER 35.2 -73, WHICH COMPRISES §§ 35.2-73.1 THROUGH 35.2-73.26, PERTAINING TO TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES. WHEREAS, City staff has proposed and recommends approval of an Ordinance that will create a new Chapter 35.2–73 of the current City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance, which comprises Sections 35.2–73.1 through 35.2–73.26 and pertains to Telecommunications Facilities (“the proposed Ordinance”); and WHEREAS, on November 11, 2020, the Planning Commission of the City of Lynchburg held a work session on the proposed Ordinance; and WHEREAS, on December 9, 2020, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on the proposed Ordinance to consider and address the proposed Ordinance and to receive public comment; and WHEREAS, after its public hearing on the proposed amendments on December 9, 2020, the Planning Commission recommended that the City Council approve the proposed Ordinance; and WHEREAS, City Council conducted a work session on the proposed Ordinance on January 12, 2021; and WHEREAS, on February 9, 2021, City Council held a public hearing to consider and address the proposed Ordinance and to receive public comment; and WHEREAS, City Council finds that the proposed Ordinance should be adopted in order to promote the public necessity, convenience, welfare and good zoning practice. NOW THEREFORE BE IT ORDAINED, by the City Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia that Chapter 35.2-73 of the current City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance, which comprises Sections 35.2.73.1 through 35.2-73.20, is hereby repealed. NOW THEREFORE, BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED, by the City Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, that Chapter 35.2-73 of the Code of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, is hereby adopted as follows: 2 § 35.2–73 TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES § 35.2–73.1 Purpose and Intent. The purpose and intent of this chapter is to create and implement regulations and requirements for the placement, construction, modification, and removal of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations in order to protect the health, safety, and welfare of the public, while at the same time not unreasonably interfering with the development of a competitive wireless telecommunications marketplace in the City. Specifically, the purposes of this chapter are: (a) To facilitate the provision of wireless telecommunications services to the residents and businesses of the City in an orderly fashion; (b) To recognize and acknowledge that wireless telecommunications facilities, including their support structures and related equipment, have become a necessary part of today’s personal and commercial communications networks; (c) To regulate the location of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations in the City; (d) To protect residential, commercial, and industrial areas and land uses from any significant potential adverse impact that may result from the establishment and operation of wireless support structures, wireless facilities and base stations; (e) To implement the provisions of the City’s Comprehensive Plan with respect to the establishment of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations in the City; (f) To minimize, when possible, the adverse visual impact of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations through careful design, siting, landscaping, and innovative camouflaging techniques to enhance the ability of such, support structures, facilities, and base stations to be compatible with residential, commercial, and industrial uses; (g) To promote and encourage the co-location on and around wireless support structures of multiple wireless facilities and base stations in order to reduce, when possible, the need for additional such structures and facilities; (h) To promote and encourage the location of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations in commercial and industrial areas, rather than residential areas; 3 (i) To ensure that wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations are compatible with other land uses in the vicinity; (j) To allow wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations as a matter of right, where appropriate, and with minimal administrative requirements when the size, design, and location of such support structures, facilities, and base stations does not result in any significant adverse impacts to other uses or any significant adverse impact to the property values of nearby properties; (k) To provide greater scrutiny of requests for wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations when their size, design, and location may result in greater impacts on surrounding land uses and property values in order to assure that adverse impacts of such structures, facilities, and base stations and any adverse impact on the values of nearby properties are mitigated and minimized; (l) To encourage the providers of wireless telecommunications services to utilize smaller wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations in order to reduce the overall impact of any single wireless support structure or facility on the surrounding area; (m) To reduce the need for larger and taller wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations through the encouragement of co-location on any new structures as well as the installation, where feasible, of such facilities onto existing structures; (n) To avoid potential damage to the use and enjoyment of property caused by wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations by ensuring that such structures, facilities, and stations are soundly, safely, and carefully designed; constructed, modified, and maintained, and, when no longer structurally sound, removed; and (o) To require the removal of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations that are no longer used to support wireless facilities and no longer retain any other legitimate purposes. § 35.2–73.2 Definitions. As used in this Ordinance, unless the context requires a different meaning: “Administrative review-eligible project” means a project that provides for: 1. The installation or construction of a new structure that is not more than 50 feet above ground level, provided that the structure with attached wireless facilities is (i) not more than 10 feet above the tallest existing utility pole located within 500 feet of the new structure within the same public right-of-way or within the existing line of utility poles; (ii) not located within the boundaries of a local, state, or federal historic district; (iii) not located inside the jurisdictional boundaries of a locality having expended a total amount equal to or greater than 35 percent of its general fund operating revenue, as shown in the most recent 4 comprehensive annual financial report, on undergrounding projects since 1980; and (iv) designed to support small cell facilities; or 2. The co-location on any existing structure of a wireless facility that is not a small cell facility; 3. The term “administrative review-eligible project” shall include eligible facilities requests as that term is defined by federal law in 47 Code of Federal Regulations 1.6100. “Antenna” means communications equipment that transmits or receives electromagnetic radio signals used in the provision of any type of wireless communications services. “Base station” means a station that includes a structure that currently supports or houses an antenna, transceiver, coaxial cables, power cables, or associated equipment at a specific site that is authorized to communicate with mobile stations, generally consisting of radio transceivers, antennas, coaxial cables, power supplies, and other associated electronics. “City” means the City of Lynchburg, Virginia. “Co-locate” means to install, mount, maintain, modify, operate, or replace a wireless facility on, under, within, or adjacent to a base station, building, existing structure, utility pole, or wireless support structure. “Co-location” has a corresponding meaning. “Department” means the Virginia Department of Transportation. “Existing structure” means any structure that is installed or approved for installation at the time a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider provides notice to the City or the Department of an agreement with the owner of the structure to co-locate equipment on that structure. “Existing structure” includes any structure that is currently supporting, designed to support, or capable of supporting the attachment of wireless facilities, including towers, buildings, utility poles, light poles, flag poles, signs, and water towers. “Micro-wireless facility” means a small cell facility that is not larger in dimension than 24 inches in length, 15 inches in width, and 12 inches in height and that has an exterior antenna, if any, not longer than 11 inches. “New structure” means a wireless support structure that has not been installed or constructed, or approved for installation or construction, at the time a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider applies to the City for any required zoning approval. “New wireless support structure” has the same meaning as “new structure.” “Project” means (i) the installation or construction by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider of a new structure or (ii) the co-location on any existing structure of a 5 wireless facility that is not a small cell facility. “Project” does not include the installation of a small cell facility by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider on an existing structure to which the provisions of Code Virginia § 15.2-2316.4 apply. “Small cell facility” means a wireless facility that meets both of the following qualifications: (i) each antenna is located inside an enclosure of no more than six cubic feet in volume, or, in the case of an antenna that has exposed elements, the antenna and all of its exposed elements could fit within an imaginary enclosure of no more than six cubic feet; and (ii) all other wireless equipment associated with the facility has a cumulative volume of no more than 28 cubic feet, or such higher limit as is established by the Federal Communications Commission. The following types of associated equipment are not included in the calculation of equipment volume: electric meter, concealment, telecommunications demarcation boxes, back-up power systems, grounding equipment, power transfer switches, cut-off switches, and vertical cable runs for the connection of power and other services. “Standard process project” means any project that is not an administrative review-eligible project. “Utility pole” means a structure owned, operated, or owned and operated by a public utility, local government, or the Commonwealth that is designed specifically for and used to carry lines, cables, or wires for communications, cable television, or electricity. “Water tower” means a water storage tank, or a standpipe or an elevated tank situated on a support structure, originally constructed for use as a reservoir or facility to store or deliver water. “Wireless facility” means equipment at a fixed location that enables wireless communications between user equipment and a communications network, including (i) equipment associated with wireless services, such as private, broadcast, and public safety services, as well as unlicensed wireless services and fixed wireless services, such as microwave backhaul, and (ii) radio transceivers, antennas, coaxial, or fiber optic cable, regular and backup power supplies, and comparable equipment, regardless of technological configuration. “Wireless infrastructure provider” means any person that builds or installs transmission equipment, wireless facilities, or wireless support structures, but that is not a wireless services provider. “Wireless services” means (i) “personal wireless services as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332(C)(7)(i); “personal wireless service facilities” as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332(C)(7)(ii); including commercial mobile services as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332(d), provided to personal mobile communications devices through wireless facilities, and (iii) any other fixed or mobile wireless service, using licensed or unlicensed spectrum, provided using wireless facilities. 6 “Wireless services provider” means a provider of wireless services. “Wireless support structure” means a freestanding structure, such as a monopole, tower, either guyed or self-supporting, or suitable existing structure or alternative structure designed to support or is capable of supporting wireless facilities. “Wireless support structure” does not include any telephone or electrical utility pole or any tower used for the distribution or transmission of electrical service. § 35.2–73.3 Applicability. The provisions of this chapter shall apply to all land within the jurisdictional boundaries of the City of Lynchburg, provided, however, that the provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any small cell facility within the City’s right-of-way or on any City-owned property. Small cell facilities within the City’s right-of-way or on any City-owned property are regulated by §§ 35–28, 35–28.1, 35–28.2, 35–28.3, 35–28.4, 35–28.5, 35–28.6, and 35–28.7 of the City Code. § 35.2–73.4 Small Cell Facilities. A. Review of Applications for Small Cell Facilities. No conditional use permit or its equivalent shall be required in the City for a small cell facility to be installed on an existing structure if a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider has: (1) permission from the owner to co-locate equipment on that structure; and (2) has notified the City that such permission exists. A permit for the installation of a small cell facility shall be required before a small cell facility may be installed on an existing structure. B. Application Requirements for Small Cell Facilities. Applications filed by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider for administrative review of a small cell facility on an existing structure shall include the following: 1. A valid electronic mail address for the applicant. 2. Written proof that the owner of the existing structure has given the applicant consent to install the small cell facility as proposed. 3. The name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the parcel(s) of land on which the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located, then the applicant shall provide written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone number, and the electronic mail address of the owner. 4. The valuation map number and address of the parcel of land on which the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located. 7 5. A plan, drawn to scale, depicting the location and elevation of any small cell facility that is the subject of the application, with engineering drawings showing the actual size of the small cell facility and each component thereof, from which the City can reasonably determine whether the proposed facility meets the definition of a small cell facility. 6. Drawings showing where and how the small cell facility is proposed to be attached to the existing structure. 7. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the proposed facilities meet the standards set forth in this Ordinance, including, but not limited to, the requirements set forth in § 35.2–73.13 (Interference With Public Safety Radio Services) and will not materially interfere with other pre-existing communications facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety communications facilities. 8. Evidence relating to any other factors the applicant believes are relevant to the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed small cell facility should be approved. 9. Payment of an application processing fee of $100.00 each for up to five small cell facilities on a permit application, and payment of a fee of $50 for each additional small cell facility on that permit application. C. Multiple Requests on a Single Application for Small Cell Facilities. Applications filed by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider for a small cell facility to be co- located on an existing structure may include multiple such permit requests on a single application. D. Notification of Incomplete Application for Small Cell Facilities. If an incomplete initial or resubmitted application is filed for a small cell facility to be installed on an existing structure, then the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any missing information and documents in accordance with the following: 1. for an initial application, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail within ten (10) calendar days after receipt of a valid electronic mail address and the application that the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing information and documents; otherwise, the application shall be deemed complete; and 2. for a resubmitted application for a small cell facility to be installed on an existing structure, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail within ten (10) calendar days after the application is resubmitted whether the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing information and documents; otherwise, the application shall be deemed complete. 8 E. Deadline for Approval or Disapproval of Small Cell Facilities. The City shall approve or disapprove any application filed by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider proposing a small cell facility to be installed on an existing structure in accordance with the following: 1. any such application shall be approved or disapproved in writing within sixty (60) calendar days after receipt of the complete application; 2. if the applicant files an incomplete initial or resubmitted application and the City notifies the applicant of its incompleteness in accordance with the applicable timeframes set forth in subsection D above (Notification of Incomplete Application for Small Cell Facilities), then the time within which the City must approve or disapprove such an initial application shall be tolled for the period from the date of the submission of the initial incomplete application to the date on which the applicant files a complete application; 3. if the applicant files an incomplete resubmitted application, the time within which the City must approve or disapprove a resubmitted application shall also be tolled for the period from the date of submission of the resubmitted incomplete; 4. application to the date on which the applicant resubmits a complete application; 5. the initial sixty (60) calendar-day period for the City to approve or disapprove an application for a small cell facility proposed to be installed on an existing structure may be extended by the City in writing for a period not to exceed an additional 30 days; 6. any such application for a small cell facility proposed to be installed on an existing structure shall be deemed approved if the City fails to act within the timeframes set forth in this section; 7. any disapproval of an application for a small cell facility on an existing structure shall be in writing and accompanied by an explanation for the disapproval; and approval of a permit for any such small cell facility application shall not be unreasonably conditioned, withheld, or delayed. F. Grounds for Disapproval of Small Cell Facilities. The City may disapprove an application filed by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider proposing the installation of a small cell facility on an existing structure for any of the following reasons: 1. Material potential interference with other pre-existing communications facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety communications facilities; 2. The safety of the public or other critical public service needs; 9 3. Only in the case of an installation on or in publicly owned or publicly controlled property, excluding privately owned structures where the applicant has an agreement for attachment to the structure, aesthetic impact or the absence of all required approvals from all departments, authorities, and agencies with jurisdiction over such property; 4. Conflict with a City ordinance adopted pursuant to § 15.2-2306, or pursuant to local charter on a historic property that is not eligible for the review process established under 54 U.S.C § 306108. G. Small Cell Facilities on New Structures. Any application for the installation of a small cell facility on a new structure shall require any approval that may be required by this chapter for that new structure as either an administrative review-eligible project or a standard process project. § 35.2–73.5 Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. A. Review of Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. Administrative review-eligible projects shall not require that a conditional use permit or its equivalent be obtained for the installation or construction of such a project; but administrative review shall be required for the issuance of any zoning approval, or an acknowledgment that zoning approval is not required, for such a project. B. Application Requirements for Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. Applications for wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and/or base stations that comprise administrative review-eligible projects shall require the following: 1. The name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the land on which the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located, then the applicant shall provide written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone number, and the electronic mail address of the owner. If the land on which the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station is proposed to be located is, in whole or in part, within the City’s right-of-way, then the applicant shall be required to secure written consent from the City for the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station to be located within the City’s right- of-way prior to filing such application and shall include such written consent as part of any such application. 2. An affirmative written statement signed by the applicant and the owner that the applicant and the owner are aware of and agree to comply with the provisions of this Zoning Ordinance set forth in § 35.2-73.24 (Abandonment) regarding removal and dismantlement of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related equipment in the event such a structure, facility, base station, or related equipment is no longer in use. 10 3. The valuation map number and address of the parcel of land on which the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located. 4. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the proposed facilities meet the standards set forth in this Ordinance, including, but not limited to, the requirements set forth in § 35.2–73.13 (Interference With Public Safety Radio Services), and will not materially interfere with other pre-existing communications facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety communications facilities. 5. Written, technical evidence from an electrical engineer that the proposed site of the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station does not pose a risk of explosion, fire, or other danger due to its proximity to volatile, flammable, explosive, or hazardous materials such as propane, gasoline, natural gas, or corrosive or other dangerous chemicals. 6. A site plan, as required by § 35.2-14.2 (Site Plans) of this Ordinance. 7. A map showing the location and height of every utility pole within 500 feet of and within the same public right-of-way or within the existing line of utility poles as the proposed wireless support structure or wireless facility. 8. In the case of an administrative review-eligible project proposing a new structure, a detailed explanation of how the proposed new structure is designed to support small cell facilities. 9. A copy of any approval granted by a federal agency, including any conditions imposed by that agency, regarding the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station, provided, however, that this requirement shall not apply to applications for small cell facilities. 10. Evidence relating to any other factors the applicant believes are relevant to the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed small cell facility should be approved. 11. The applicable application fee for the proposed administrative review-eligible project. 12. Evidence that the applicant has given written notice to all adjacent landowners regarding the applicant’s intent to file the application at least 15 days before the filing of any application to locate a new structure on the subject property. C. Fee Limitations for Administrative Review -Eligible Projects. When an application for an administrative review-eligible project is filed, the following provisions shall apply to the fee that must be paid by the applicant: 11 1. The fee must be reasonable. 2. The fee charged by the City shall not include direct payment or reimbursement of third-party fees charged on a contingency basis or a result-based arrangement. 3. The City shall not charge market-based or value-based fees for the processing of any such application. 4. Upon request, the City shall, within a reasonable amount of time after such request, provide the applicant with the cost basis for any fee charged by the City for an administrative review-eligible project. D. Assessment o f Fees for Administrative Review -Eligible Projects. Each application for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station that constitutes an administrative review-eligible project shall be accompanied by payment of a $500 fee for the proce ssing of the application E. Processing Applications for Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. The following provisions set forth the process that shall apply to any application for an administrative review-eligible project: 1. Prior to accepting any application for an administrative review-eligible project, the City shall first determine that the application includes the applicant’s electronic mail address. In the event the application does not include the applicant’s electronic mail address, the City shall not accept it for filing 2. If the application is incomplete, but includes an electronic mail address for the applicant, then within ten (10) business days after actual receipt of the application, the City shall accept the application and notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any additional information, documents and materials required to complete the application. 3. If the application is incomplete and does not include an electronic mail address for the applicant when it was filed, the City shall use reasonable means to contact the applicant and request the applicant’s electronic mail address. Within ten (10) days after actual receipt of the applicant’s electronic mail address, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any additional information, documents and materials required to complete the application. 4. If an incomplete initial or resubmitted application is filed for an administrative review- eligible project, then the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any missing information and documents and materials in accordance with the following: (a) for an initial application, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail within ten (10) business days after the application is submitted whether the 12 application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing information, documents and materials; otherwise, the application will be deemed complete; and (b)for a resubmitted application, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail within ten (10) days after the application is resubmitted whether the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing information, documents and materials; otherwise, the application will be deemed complete. 5. If the City fails to timely provide the applicant with notice that the initial application or a resubmitted application is incomplete in accordance with the foregoing provisions, as applicable, the application shall be deemed complete. 6. Except as provided for in subsection 7 below, the City shall approve or disapprove a complete application in accordance with the following: (a) For a new structure, within 150 days after receipt of the completed application minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the date any notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City; (b) For the modification of an existing wireless support structure or base station that involves the co-location of new transmission equipment, the removal of transmission equipment, or the replacement of transmission equipment, but does not substantially change, as that term is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or base station, within 60 days after receipt of the application provided, however, that this period shall be tolled during any time after which the applicant has been informed that the application is not complete and is provided with the grounds for its incompleteness by the City, and when the applicant files all requested information and items necessary to make the application complete; (c) For the co-location on an existing support structure of any wireless facility that is not a small cell facility and substantially changes, as that term is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or any related base station, within the lesser of 90 days after receipt by the City of the completed application, minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the date any notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City; and (d) For any wireless facility that is not a small cell facility on a new structure, within the lesser of 150 days after receipt of a completed application, minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the date any notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City . 7. Any period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above within which the City must approve or disapprove an application may be extended by written agreement of the applicant and the City. 13 8. A complete application for an administrative review-eligible project shall be deemed approved if the City fails to approve or disapprove such application within the applicable period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above or within any agreed extension thereof pursuant to subsection 7 above. 9. If the City disapproves an application for an administrative review-eligible project: (a) the City shall provide the applicant with a written statement listing all of the reasons for the disapproval; and (b) if the City is aware of any modifications to the project as described in the application that if made would permit the City to approve the proposed project, the City shall identify them in the written statement provided under subsection 9(a) above. The City’s subsequent disapproval of an application for a project that incorporates the modifications identified in such a written statement may be used by the applicant as evidence that the City’s subsequent disapproval was arbitrary or capricious in any appeal of the City’s subsequent disapproval. 10. If an application for an administrative review-eligible project is disapproved, the City’s disapproval shall: (a) not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services; and (b) be supported by substantial record evidence contained in a written record publicly released within 30 days following the disapproval. F. Limitations on Disapprovals of Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. Whenever the City receives, considers, and processes a complete application for an administrative review- eligible project, it shall not disapprove any such application on the basis of: (a) the applicant’s business decision with respect to its designed service, customer demand, or quality of service to or from a particular site; (b) the applicant’s specific need for the project, including the applicant’s desire to provide additional wireless coverage or capacity; or (c) he wireless facility technology selected by the applicant for use at the project. G. Disapproval Considerations for Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. Nothing in this Ordinance shall be construed to prohibit the City from disapproving an application for an administrative review-eligible project: 14 1. On the basis of the fact that the proposed height of any wireless support structure, wireless facility, or wireless support structure with attached wireless facilities exceeds 50 feet above ground level, provided that the City follows a local ordinance or regulation that does not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services , and other providers of functionally equivalent services; or 2. That proposes to locate a new structure, or to co-locate a wireless facility in an area where all cable and public utility facilities are required to be placed underground by a date certain or encouraged to be undergrounded as part of a transportation improvement project or rezoning proceeding as set forth in objectives contained in a comprehensive plan, if: (a) The undergrounding requirement or comprehensive plan objective existed at least three months prior to the submission of the application; (b) The City allows the co-location of wireless facilities on existing utility poles, government-owned structures with the government’s consent, existing wireless support structures, or a building within that area; (c) The City allows the replacement of existing utility poles and wireless support structures with poles or support structures of the same size or similar within that area; and (d) The disapproval of the application does not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services. H. Disapproval Limitation If Administrative Review-Eligible Project Does not Substantially Change Physical Dimensions. The City may not deny, and shall approve, within sixty (60) days, any administrative review-eligible project which requests any modification of an existing base station or wireless support structure that does not substantially change, as that term is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or base station and that involves the co-location of new transmission equipment, the removal of transmission equipment, or the replacement of transmission equipment. I. Disapproval Allowed If Written Notice Not Provided to Adjacent Property Owners. The City may disapprove an application for an administrative review-eligible project if the applicant has not given written notice to all adjacent property owners at least 15 days before the applicant applies to locate a new structure on the subject property. § 35.2–73.6 Standard Process Projects. A. Review of Standard Process Projects. Standard process projects may require the approval of a conditional use permit and/or a site plan.for the installation or construction of such a 15 project, and City staff review may also be required for the issuance of any zoning permit, or an acknowledgment that zoning approval is not required, for a standard process project. B. Application Requirements for Standard Process Projects. Applications for wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and/or base stations that constitute standard process projects shall include the following: 1. The name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the land on which the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located, then the applicant shall provide written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone number, and the electronic mail address of the owner. If the land on which the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station is proposed to be located is, in whole or in part, within the City’s right-of-way, then the applicant shall be required to secure written consent from the City for the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station to be located within the City’s right-of-way prior to filing such application and shall include such written consent as part of any such application. 2. An affirmative written statement signed by the applicant and the owner that the applicant and the owner are aware of and agree to comply with the provisions of this Zoning Ordinance set forth in § 35.2-73.24 (Abandonment) regarding removal and dismantlement of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related equipment in the event such a structure, facility, base station, or related equipment is no longer in use. 3. The valuation map number and address of the parcel of land on which the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located. 4. The names, addresses, and telephone numbers of the owners of and a map showing the location and height of all wireless support structures or potential wireless support structures taller than fifty (50) feet that are within a one (1) mile radius of the proposed new site for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station, including City-owned property. 5. Written documentation that the applicant has made diligent, but unsuccessful, efforts to secure the permission to co-locate the applicant’s proposed wireless facility on an existing or proposed wireless support structure owned by others, including the City, within a one-mile radius of the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station. 6. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, or project cannot be installed or co- located on another existing or proposed wireless support structure within a one (1) mile radius of the proposed site for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station and must be located at the proposed site in order to meet the coverage requirements for applicant’s wireless telecommunications system. 16 7. Written, technical evidence from a structural engineer that the proposed wireless support structure can support the wireless facilities and base stations of other carriers for the purposes of co-location. 8. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the proposed facilities meet the standards set forth in this Ordinance, including, but not limited to, the requirements set forth in § 35.2–73.13 (Interference With Public Safety Radio Services), and will not materially interfere with other pre-existing communications facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety communications facilities. 9. Written, technical evidence from an electrical engineer that the proposed site of the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station does not pose a risk of explosion, fire, or other danger due to its proximity to volatile, flammable, explosive, or hazardous materials such as propane, gasoline, natural gas, or corrosive or other dangerous chemicals . 10. A map of the City and the first half-mile of all bordering communities showing the design of the applicant’s entire existing or proposed telecommunications network. Such map shall, at a minimum, indicate the general location of all proposed or existing sites of the applicant’s wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related equipment, the dimensions of the sites, specifications relating to the facilities, and signal area coverage. 11. Color photo simulations showing the proposed site of the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, or project with a photo-realistic representation of the proposed structure and facility as they would appear viewed from at least four (4) substantially different vantage points on the eight (8) closest residential properties or adjacent roadways. 12. Any initial application fee required by § 35.2–73.6(D) (Fees for Standard Process Projects). 13. A site plan, including a depiction of the lot lines, setbacks, existing structures and other improvements on the property, the location of adjacent and nearby structures, the proposed location of the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, and base station that are the subject of the application, separation distances, proposed height of any new structure, screening and landscaping, existing and proposed, access, parking, security, zoning district(s) for the subject property and all adjacent properties, and any floodplain on the subject property. 14. A copy of any approval granted by a federal agency, including any conditions imposed by that agency, regarding the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station. 17 15. Evidence relating to any other factors the applicant believes are relevant to the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed standard process project should be approved. 16. Written documentation regarding whether and how the location of the proposed wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in relation to existing structures, trees, and other visual buffers, minimizes, to the greatest extent reasonably practicable under the circumstances, any significant negative adverse impact. 17. Witten documentation regarding whether and how the location of the wireless support structure and/or wireless facility will not have a significant detrimental impact on the property values of adjacent and nearby properties. 18. Written documentation regarding any other factors the applicant believes are relevant to the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed standard process project should be approved. 19. Evidence that the applicant has given written notice to all adjacent landowners regarding the applicant’s intent to file the application at least 15 days before the filing of any application to locate a new structure on the subject property C. Fee Limitations for Standard Process Projects. When an application for a standard process project is filed, the following provisions shall apply to the fee that must be paid by the applicant: 1. The fee must be reasonable. 2. The fee charged by the City shall not include direct payment or reimbursement of third- party fees charged on a contingency basis or a result-based arrangement. 3. The fee charged by the City shall not exceed the actual direct costs to process the application, including permits and inspection. 4. The City shall not charge market-based or value-based fees for the processing of any such application. 5. Upon request, the City shall, within a reasonable amount of time after such request, provide the applicant with the cost basis for any fee charged by the City for a standard process project. D. Fees for Standard Process Projects. Each application for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station that constitutes a standard process project shall be accompanied by payment of the following fees for the processing of the application: 18 1. For an application for a standard process project that requires the approval of a conditional use permit and a site plan, the initial fee shall be $900. 2. For an application for a standard process project that requires the approval of a site plan, but not a conditional use permit, the initial fee shall be $500. 3. The City reserves the right to employ an outside consultant to assist in the review of any application for a standard process project. In the event the City employs an outside consultant to review an application for a standard process project, the applicant shall reimburse the City for the reasonable expenses related to such review as an additional application fee, provided, however, that the fee limitations set forth in § 35.2–73.6(C) (Fee Limitations for Standard Process Projects) shall apply to the calculation of any such additional fee. 4. For any standard process project that requires the approval of a conditional use permit, the applicant shall be responsible for the payment of any costs for any legal notices that may be required for the conditional use permit. E. Processing Applications for Standard Process Projects. The following provisions set forth the process that shall apply to any application for a standard process project: 1. Prior to accepting any application for a wireless support structure, a wireless facility, or a base station, that constitutes a standard process project, the City shall first determine that the application includes the applicant’s electronic mail address. In the event the application does not include the applicant’s electronic mail address, the City shall not accept it for filing 2. If the application is incomplete, but includes an electronic mail address for the applicant, then within ten (10) business days after actual receipt of the application, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail if the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any additional information, documents, and materials required to complete the application. 3. If the application is incomplete and does not include a valid electronic mail address for the applicant when it was filed, the City shall use reasonable means to contact the applicant and request the applicant’s valid electronic mail address. Within ten (10) days after actual receipt of a valid electronic mail address for the applicant, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any additional information, documents, and materials required to complete the application. 4. If an incomplete initial or resubmitted application is filed for a standard process project, then the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any missing information, documents, and materials in accordance with the following: 19 (a) for an initial application, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail within ten (10) business days after the application is submitted whether the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing information, documents, and materials; otherwise, the application will be deemed complete; and (b) for a resubmitted application, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail within ten (10) days after the application is resubmitted whether the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing information, documents and materials; otherwise, the application will be deemed complete. 5. If the City fails to timely provide the applicant with notice that the initial application or a resubmitted application is incomplete in accordance with the foregoing provisions, as applicable, the application shall be deemed complete. 6. Except as provided for in subsection 7 below, the City shall approve or disapprove a complete application for a standard process project in accordance with the following: 7. Any period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above within which the City must approve or disapprove an application may be extended by written agreement of the applicant and the City. 8. A complete application for a standard process project shall be deemed approved if the City fails to approve or disapprove such application within the applicable period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above or any agreed extension thereof pursuant to subsection 7 above. 9. If the City disapproves an application for a standard process project: (a) the City shall provide the applicant with a written statement listing all of the reasons for the disapproval; and (b) if the City is aware of any modifications to the project as described in the application that if made would permit the City to approve the proposed project, the City shall identify them in the written statement provided under subsection 6(a) above. The City’s subsequent disapproval of an application for a project that incorporates the modifications identified in such a written statement may be used by the applicant as evidence that the City’s subsequent disapproval was arbitrary or capricious in any appeal of the City’s subsequent disapproval. 10. If an application for a standard process project is disapproved, the City’s disapproval shall: (a) not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services; and. 20 (b) be supported by substantial record evidence contained in a written record publicly released within 30 days following the disapproval. F. Limitations on Disapprovals of Standard Process Projects. Whenever the City receives, considers, and processes a complete application for a standard process project, it shall not disapprove any such application on the basis of: (a) the applicant’s business decision with respect to its designed service, customer demand, or quality of service to or from a particular site; (b) the applicant’s specific need for the project, including the applicant’s desire to provide additional wireless coverage or capacity; or (c) the wireless facility technology selected by the applicant for use at the project. G. Disapproval Considerations for Standard Process Projects. Nothing in this Ordinance shall be construed to prohibit the City from disapproving an application for a standard process project: 1. On the basis of the fact that the proposed height of any wireless support structure, wireless facility, or wireless support structure with attached wireless facilities exceeds 50 feet above ground level, provided that the City follows a local ordinance or regulation that does not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services , and other providers of functionally equivalent services; or 2. That proposes to locate a new structure, or to co-locate a wireless facility in an area where all cable and public utility facilities are required to be placed underground by a date certain or encouraged to be undergrounded as part of a transportation improvement project or rezoning proceeding as set forth in objectives contained in a comprehensive plan, if: (a) The undergrounding requirement or comprehensive plan objective existed at least three months prior to the submission of the application; (b) The City allows the co-location of wireless facilities on existing utility poles, government-owned structures with the government’s consent, existing wireless support structures, or a building within that area; (c) The City allows the replacement of existing utility poles and wireless support structures with poles or support structures of the same size or similar within that area; and (d) The disapproval of the application does not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, 21 providers of telecommunications services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services. H. Disapproval Limitation If Standard Process Project Does not Substantially Change Physical Dimensions. The City may not deny, and shall approve, within sixty (60) days, any standard process project which requests any modification of an existing base station or wireless support structure that does not substantially change, as that term is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or base station and that involves the co- location of new transmission equipment, the removal of transmission equipment, or the replacement of transmission equipment. I. Disapproval Allowed If Written Notice Not Provided to Adjacent Property Owners. The City may disapprove an application for a standard process project if the applicant has not given written notice to all adjacent property owners at least 15 days before the applicant applies to locate a new structure on the subject property. § 35.2–73.7 Permitted Uses. A. The following uses shall be permitted by right as follows: 1. Small cell facilities in all zoning districts. 2. Administrative review-eligible projects in all zoning districts. 3. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility that does not exceed one hundred (100) feet in height in the B–1 District. 4. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility that does not exceed one hundred and fifty (150) feet in height in the B–3, B–5, IN–2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts. 5. Any base station associated with a lawfully existing wireless support structure and/or wireless facility, provided, however, that: (a) the base station shall be located inside the wireless support structure; or (b) the base station shall be located on the ground within 50 feet of the base of the wireless support structure; or (c) the base station is not visible at ground level from off-site; and (d) the size of the base station shall not exceed seventy-two (72) cubic feet in size and/or six (6) feet in height; and 22 (e) all applicable setbacks shall be complied with. 6. The co-location of a wireless facility on a lawfully existing wireless support structure in any zoning district, provided, however, that: (a) the height of any such wireless support structure, wireless facility, or wireless support structure with wireless facility attached, shall not increase as a result of the co-location; and (b) all applicable setbacks must be complied with. B. Existing wireless support structures and wireless facilities shall be exempt from the maximum height restrictions of the districts in which they are located to the extent such structures and facilities lawfully existed on the date of adoption of this Ordinance. § 35.2-73.8 Conditional Use Permit Required. A. The following uses require the approval of a conditional use permit by the City Council: 1. In the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 Districts, any standard process project that is between fifty (50) and one hundred and fifty (150) feet in height, provided, however, that no new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in such districts shall exceed 150 feet in height; 2. In the B–1 District, any standard process project in which a new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility exceeds one hundred (100) feet in height; provided, however, that the maximum height for any wireless facility and/or wireless support structure in the B–1 District shall be 150 feet; 3. In the B–3, B–5, IN–2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts, any standard process project in which a new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility exceeds one hundred fifty (150) feet in height; 4. Any base station that is a standard process project and exceeds seventy-two cubic feet above ground and/or six feet in height; 5. Any base station associated with a lawfully existing wireless support structure and/or wireless facility that is a standard process project, is not located inside the wireless support structure, is visible at ground level from off-site, and/or is not located within 50 feet of the base of the wireless support structure; 6. The co-location of a wireless facility on a lawfully existing wireless support structure in any zoning district that, after the proposed co-location, would result in an increase in height of the wireless support structure and/or wireless facility, provided, however, that 23 no such structure and/or facility shall be allowed to increase more than fifteen (15) feet in height as a result of the approval of such a conditional use permit; and 7. Any other project that constitutes a standard process project. B. Whenever a conditional use permit is required for a proposed wireless structure or wireless facility, any application for such a conditional use permit shall be made to the City Planner in the manner provided in Article 2 of this Zoning Ordinance. In districts for which a conditional use permit is required, the City Council shall make its decision to approve or deny such permit in writing and in a manner consistent with applicable state and federal law. C. Any wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station that is not permitted by right or upon the approval of a conditional use permit under this Ordinance shall be considered to be in violation of this Ordinance. D. No new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility for which a conditional use permit is approved shall exceed a maximum height of one hundred fifty (150) feet in the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 Districts. 35.2-73.9 Setbacks. A. There shall be no setback requirement for any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility that is thirty-five (35) feet or less in height. B. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility greater than thirty-five (35) feet in height in the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 Districts shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the height of such structure and/or facility. C. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility greater than thirty-five (35) feet in height in the B–1, B–3, B–5, IN–2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts that is on a parcel adjacent to any parcel that is zoned R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 shall be set back a distance at least the height of such structure and/or facility from the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 District. D. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in the B–1, B–3, B–5, IN–2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts that is greater than thirty-five (35) feet in height but less than fifty (50) feet in height shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the minimum applicable setback for the district in which it is located. E. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in the B–1, B–3, B–5, IN–2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts that is a height greater than fifty (50) feet shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least one-half the height of such structure and/or facility. 24 F. Setback requirements for wireless support structures and/or wireless facilities shall be measured from the base of the structure and/or facility to the property lines of the parcel on which the structure and/or facility is located. §35.2-73.10 Standards for Conditional Use Permits for Standard Process Projects. In order to approve a conditional use permit for a standard process project, the City Council must find that the application for such project satisfies all of the following standards: 1. The proposed use is in substantial conformance with the provisions of the City’s Comprehensive Plan. 2. The proposed use will not result in any significant adverse impact on the use and enjoyment of nearby properties. 3. The proposed use will not have any significant negative impact on the value of nearby properties. 4. The proposed use will not cause any material potential interference with other pre-existing communications facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been planned or designed for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety communications facilities. 5. The proposed use will not result in any significant adverse impact on public safety or other critical public service needs. 6. The proposed use must be compatible with the character of the area in which it is proposed to be located. 7. There are no existing wireless support structures within a reasonable distance from the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station that are available to be used for co-location at reasonable terms and conditions without imposing technical limitations on the applicant. 8. The proposed use shall not conflict with any City ordinance adopted pursuant to Code of Virginia § 15.2-2306, or pursuant to local charter on a historic property that is not eligible for the review process established under 54 U.S.C. § 306108. 9. The proposed use satisfies all other applicable requirements set forth in this chapter with respect to the location, size, design, and construction of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations. §35.2-73.11 Use of City-Owned Property for Wireless Facilities. 25 The City may authorize the use of City property for wireless facilities in appropriately zoned districts in accordance with the procedures of the City charter and code. The City shall have no obligation whatsoever to allow the use of City property for such purposes and any such approval by the City shall be subject to the discretion of the City Council. §35.2–73.12 Co-Location Availability. An application for a standard process project may be disapproved by the City on the basis of the availability of the existence of one or more wireless support structures within a reasonable distance that could be used for co-location at reasonable terms and conditions without imposing technical limitations on the applicant. § 35.2–73.13 Interference With Public Safety Radio Services. In order to ensure that the City’s public safety radio services will be free from harmful or destructive interference, all applicants requesting a permit to establish or install a wireless support structure or wireless facility shall: A. Demonstrate compliance with good engineering practices; B. Not cause material potential interference to the City’s existing public safety radio services or to future communications facilities that have already been designed and planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety communications facilities; and C. Comply with all FCC regulations regarding susceptibility to radio frequency interference, frequency coordination requirements, general technical standards for power, antenna bandwidth limitations, frequency stability, transmitter measurements, operating requirements, and any and all other federal statutory and regulatory requirements relating to radio frequency interference (RFI), provided, however, that this subparagraph (C) shall not apply to applications for small cell facilities. § 35.2-73.14 Structural Requirements. All wireless support structures and wireless facilities must be designed and certified by a structural engineer licensed in the Commonwealth of Virginia to be structurally sound and, at a minimum, in conformance with the Virginia Uniform Statewide Building Code and any other applicable standards set forth in this chapter. § 35.2-73.15 Method of Determining Height of A Wireless Support Structure. Measurement of the height of a wireless support structure for the purpose of determining compliance with all requirements of this chapter shall include the wireless support structure itself and any wireless facilities associated with the wireless support structure, and any other support 26 features installed thereon which extend over the top of the structure itself. Structure height shall be measured from grade. § 35.2-73.16 Illumination. Wireless support structures whose principal use is the facilitation of wireless telecommunications shall not be artificially lighted except as may be required by the FAA. § 35.2–73.17 Exterior Finish. Wireless support structures and wireless facilities not requiring painting or marking by the FAA shall be painted a neutral color. A galvanized finish is considered a neutral color. § 35.2–73.18 Landscaping. All landscaping on parcels containing wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and/or base stations shall be designed to screen the structure, facilities, base station, and related equipment to a height of at least six (6) feet from grade. This requirement may be waived at the discretion of the planning division if the base of the structure, facilities, base station, and related equipment to be screened is not located in and is not visible from any commercial or residential district or from any public street. All required landscaping shall be continually maintained in a healthy and attractive manner. § 35.2-73.19 Security. All wireless support structures and wireless facilities shall be reasonably posted and secured to prevent against trespass. § 35.2–73.20 Access. All parcels upon which wireless support structures are located must provide access during normal business hours to at least one (1) paved vehicular parking space on site. § 35.2–73.21 Maintenance. A. The owners and operators of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related equipment shall at all times employ ordinary and reasonable care in maintaining such structures, facilities, base stations, and equipment and shall install and maintain in use nothing less than commonly accepted methods and devices for the prevention of failures and accidents which are likely to cause damage, injuries, or nuisances to the public, 27 provided, however, that no zoning approval of the City shall be required for routine maintenance of any existing wireless support structure or wireless facility. B. The owners and operators of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations shall at all times employ ordinary and reasonable care and shall install and maintain such wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and equipment in substantial compliance with the requirements of the national electric safety code and all federal, state, and local regulations and in such manner that will not interfere with the use and enjoyment of other property. C. All wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related equipment shall at all times be kept and maintained in good condition, order, and repair so that the same shall not menace or endanger the life or property of any person. D. All wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related equipment shall be maintained in compliance with any applicable radio frequency emission standards of the FCC. E. In the event the use of any wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment is discontinued by the owner or operator thereof, or in the event the owner or operator thereof files notice with the FCC or any other federal agency of its interest in ceasing to operate any wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment, said owner or operator shall, within thirty (30) days, provide written notice to the City of its intent to discontinue such use and the date when such use shall be discontinued. If the facility in question, or any part thereof, is located within the City’s right- of-way, then the owner or operator shall submit the foregoing written notice to the Department of Public Works. If the facility in question, or any part thereof, is located outside the City’s right-of-way, then the owner or operator shall submit the foregoing written notice to the Department of Community Development. § 35.2–73.22 Stealth. The City encourages, but does not require, the installation of small cell facilities and administrative review-eligible projects that employ stealth designs and blend into the environments in which they are proposed to be located. All standard process projects proposing wireless support structures and wireless facilities shall be of stealth design. For purposes of this section, the term “stealth design” refers to a wireless support structure and wireless facility that is designed in such a way as to effectively blend into the environment in which that structure is proposed to be located. Examples of stealth designs include, but are not limited to, a wireless support structure in a wooded area that is designed to look like a tree, a wireless facility that is encased in a flagpole, a wireless support structure on a church property that is designed to look like a bell tower or church steeple, and a wireless support structure in an agricultural area that is designed to look like a farm silo. § 35.2-73.23 Existing Wireless Support Structures. 28 A. An existing wireless support structure may be modified or demolished and rebuilt to accommodate the co-location of additional wireless facilities and base stations as follows: 1. Application for a permit for any wireless facility or base station, other than a small cell facility, located, in whole or in part, within the City’s right-of-way shall be made to the Department of Public Works. 2. Application for a permit for any wireless facility or base station located, in whole or in part, outside the City’s right-of-way shall be made to the Department of Community Development. 3. The total height of the new or modified wireless support structure and any wireless facilities installed thereon shall not exceed the height of the existing wireless support structure or the maximum height allowed for wireless support structures permitted by right in the applicable zoning district under this ordinance whichever is greater. B. The City may not deny and shall approve any request to modify the physical dimensions of an existing wireless tower or base station if that request does not substantially increase the physical dimensions of such tower or base station and involves: (1) co-location of new transmission equipment; (2) removal of transmission equipment; or (3) replacement of transmission equipment. § 35.2–73.24 Abandonment. If the City receives notice pursuant to § 35.2-73.21(E), or if any wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, and/or related equipment shall cease to be used for a period of one hundred eighty (180) consecutive days, then for wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations and/or related equipment inside the City’s right-of-way, the Department of Public Works shall notify the owner and/or operator of such structure, facility, base station, and related equipment, with a copy to the applicant therefor, that the site will be subject to a determination by the Department of Public Works that such site has been abandoned. In the event such structure, facility, base station, and related equipment is located outside the City’s right-of-way, then the foregoing notification and determination shall be made by the Department of Community Development. The owner, operator, and/or applicant shall have thirty (30) days from receipt of said notice to show, by a preponderance of the evidence, that the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and/or related equipment has been in use or under repair during the period. If the owner, operator, and/or applicant fails to show that the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and/or related equipment has been in use or under repair during the period, the Department of Public Works, or Department of Community Development, whichever applies, shall issue a final determination of abandonment for the site. Upon issuance of the City’s final determination, the owner, operator, and/or applicant shall, within seventy-five (75) days, dismantle and remove the support structure, wireless facility, 29 base station, and related equipment. If the owner, operator, and/or applicant fails to remove the abandoned support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment within seventy-five (75) days after the City’s final determination of abandonment, the City and/or its agents may, at its option, enter upon the property and dismantle, remove, and lawfully dispose of the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment that has been determined by the City to have been abandoned. The City may place a lien on the property of the owner from which the abandoned support structure, wireless facility, base station, or related equipment was removed in the amount of the City’s expenses in dismantling, removing, and lawfully disposing of such support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment. The City also may recover from the owner, operator, and/or applicant the costs of dismantling, removing, and lawfully disposing of the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment from the owner. For purposes of this section, removal includes all physical improvements associated with the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment, including foundation and tower grounding. § 35.2–73.25 Miscellaneous Provisions. A. Voluntary Conditions Allowed. Nothing in this Ordinance shall prohibit an applicant from voluntarily submitting, and the City from accepting, any conditions that otherwise address potential visual or aesthetic effects resulting from the placement of any new structure or wireless facility, including small cell facility. B. Micro-Wireless Facilities Exemption. Nothing in this Ordinance shall be construed to require any permitting requirements and fees imposed by the City for the installation, placement, maintenance, or replacement of micro-wireless facilities that are suspended on cables or lines that are strung between existing utility poles in compliance with national safety codes, because the installation, placement, maintenance, or replacement of such facilities are exempt from any City-imposed permitting requirements and fees. C. Limitations on Review of Administrative Review-Eligible Projects and Standard Process Projects. Whenever the City receives, considers, and processes an application for an administrative review-eligible project or a standard process project, it shall not: 1. Discriminate or create a preference on the basis of the ownership by the City, of any property, structure, base station, or wireless support structure when promulgating rules or procedures for siting wireless facilities or for evaluating applications; 2. Impose any unreasonable requirements or obligations regarding the presentation or appearance of a project, including unreasonable requirements relating to (i) the kinds of materials used or (ii) the arranging, screening, or landscaping of wireless facilities or wireless structures; 3. Impose any requirement that an applicant purchase, subscribe to, use, or employ facilities, networks, or services owned, provided, or operated by the City, in whole or in part, by the City or by any other entity in which the City has a competitive, economic, financial, governance, or other interest; 30 4. Condition or require the approval of an application solely on the basis of the applicant’s agreement to allow any wireless facilities provided or operated, in whole or in part, by the City, or by any other entity, to be placed at or co-located with the applicant’s project; 5. Impose a setback or fall zone requirement for a project that is larger than a setback or fall zone area that is imposed on other types of similar structures of a similar size, including utility poles; 6. Limit the duration of the approval of an application, except the City may require that construction of the approved project shall commence within two years after final approval and be diligently pursued to completion; and 7. Require an applicant to perform services unrelated to the project described in the application, including restoration work on any surface not disturbed by the applicant’s project. D. Nothing in this chapter shall prohibit the City from disapproving an application submitted under a standard process project on the basis of availability of existing wireless support structures within a reasonable distance that could be used for co-location at reasonable terms and conditions without imposing technical limitations on the applicant. E. No zoning approval shall be required for (i) routine maintenance or (ii) the replacement of wireless facilities or wireless support structures within a six-foot perimeter with wireless facilities or wireless support structures that are substantially similar or smaller; provided, however, that the City may require a permit to work within the right-of-way for the activities described in clause (i) or (ii), if applicable. F. Nothing in this chapter shall prohibit the City from limiting the number of new structures or the number of wireless facilities that can be installed in a specific location. G. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to require an applicant to provide proprietary, confidential, or other business information to justify the need for a project, including propagation maps and telecommunications traffic studies, or information reviewed by a federal agency as part of the approval process for the same structure and wireless facility H. All information submitted with an application that is a trade secret or proprietary shall be clearly marked as such when submitted to the City. The City shall not disclose publicly, or to any third party, any such proprietary information unless compelled to do so by federal, state, or local law. § 35.2–73.26 Reservation of Rights. The City reserves the right to impose any other reasonable conditions it determines are necessary for the proper placement, construction, or modification of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, or base stations and/or to impose any other reasonable conditions on the 31 issuance of a conditional use permit for the placement or construction of, or modification to, a wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station, provided, however, that the imposition of any such conditions must be in conformance with federal and state law and the provisions of this chapter. This ordinance shall become effective upon adoption. Adopted: Certified: ____________________________ Clerk of Council 1 ORDINANCE: AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT THE CODE OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, 1981 BY AMENDING ZONING ORDINANCE EXHIBIT IV-1: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-C DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-3: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-1 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-5: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-2 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-7: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-3 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-9: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-4 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-12: AUTHORIZED USES IN B-1 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-15: AUTHORIZED USES IN B-3 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-17: AUTHORIZED USES IN B-4 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-19: AUTHORIZED USES IN B-5 DISTRICT,EXHIBIT IV-21: AUTHORIZED USES IN IN-1 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-23: AUTHORIZED USES IN IN-2 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-24, AUTHORIZED USES IN I-1 DISTRICT, EXHIBIT IV-26: AUTHORIZED USES IN I-2 DISTRICT AND EXHIBIT IV-28: AUTHORIZED USES IN I-3 DISTRICT. WHEREAS, City staff has proposed and recommends approval of an Ordinance that will amend certain exhibits in the current City Zoning Ordinance (Exhibit IV-1: Authorized Uses in R-C District, Exhibit IV-3: Authorized Uses in R-1 District, Exhibit IV-5: Authorized Uses in R-2 District, Exhibit IV-7: Authorized Uses in R-3 District, Exhibit IV-9: Authorized Uses in R-4 District, Exhibit IV-12: Authorized Uses in B-1 DISTRICT, Exhibit IV-15: Authorized Uses in B-3 District, Exhibit IV-17: Authorized Uses in B-4 District, Exhibit IV-19: Authorized Uses in B-5 District, Exhibit IV-21: Authorized Uses in IN-1 District, Exhibit IV-23: Authorized Uses in IN-2 District, Exhibit IV-24, Authorized Uses in I-1 District, Exhibit IV-26: Authorized Uses in I-2 District and Exhibit IV-28: Authorized Uses in I-3 District approval type for wireless telecommunications transmission) to reflect the “Approval Type” for wireless telecommunications transmission as “C” for “Conditional Use Permit” and/or “P” for “Permitted” depending on the requirements of Sections 35.2–73.1 through 35.2–73.26 of the City Zoning Ordinance related to Telecommunications Facilities (“the proposed Ordinance”); and WHEREAS, on November 11, 2020, the Planning Commission of the City of Lynchburg held a work session on the proposed Ordinance; and WHEREAS, on December 9, 2020, the Planning Commission held a public hearing on the proposed Ordinance to consider and address the proposed Ordinance and to receive public comment; and WHEREAS, after its public hearing on the proposed Ordinance on December 9, 2020, the Planning Commission recommended that the City Council approve the proposed Ordinance; and WHEREAS, City Council conducted a work session on the proposed Ordinance on January 12, 2021; and WHEREAS, on February 9, 2021, City Council held a public hearing to consider and address the proposed Ordinance and to receive public comment on the proposed Ordinance; and WHEREAS, City Council finds that the proposed Ordinance should be adopted in order to promote the public necessity, convenience, welfare and good zoning practice. 2 NOW THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: That Exhibit IV-1: Authorized Uses in R-C District, Exhibit IV-3: Authorized Uses in R-1 District, Exhibit IV-5: Authorized Uses in R-2 District, Exhibit IV-7: Authorized Uses in R-3 District, Exhibit IV-9: Authorized Uses in R-4 District, Exhibit IV-12: Authorized Uses in B-1 DISTRICT, Exhibit IV-15: Authorized Uses in B-3 District, Exhibit IV-17: Authorized Uses in B-4 District, Exhibit IV-19: Authorized Uses in B-5 District, Exhibit IV-21: Authorized Uses in IN-1 District, Exhibit IV-23: Authorized Uses in IN-2 District, Exhibit IV-24, Authorized Uses in I-1 District, Exhibit IV-26: Authorized Uses in I-2 District and Exhibit IV-28: Authorized Uses in I-3 District approval type for wireless telecommunications transmission is amended as follows: EXHIBIT IV-1: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-C DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-3: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-1 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-5: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-2 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P 3 EXHIBIT IV-7: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-3 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-9: AUTHORIZED USES IN R-4 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-12: AUTHORIZED USES IN B-1 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P 4 EXHIBIT IV-15: AUTHORIZED USES IN B-3 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-17: AUTHORIZED USES IN B-4 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-19: AUTHORIZED USES IN B-5 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-21: AUTHORIZED USES IN IN-1 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication ordinance C / P 5 EXHBIT IV-23: AUTHORIZED USES IN IN-2 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-24, AUTHORIZED USES IN I-1 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-26: AUTHROIZED USES IN I-2 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for telecommunication towers ordinance C / P EXHIBIT IV-28: AUTHROIZED USES IN I-3 DISTRICT Land Use LBCS# Description Approval Type Wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see Section 35.2-73 for C / P 6 telecommunication towers ordinance That this ordinance shall become effective upon its adoption. Adopted: Certified: ____________________________ Clerk of Council MEETING DATE: January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: ITEM TITLE: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles Repeal Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.273.20 related to Telecommunication Towers and replace with Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance KEY ELEMENTS: _X _Economic Development _X_Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _ Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: (Confidential) RECOMMENDATION: Conduct work session on Zoning Ordinance Amendments related to telecommunication facilities. SUMMARY: The City’s Zoning Ordinance sections related to Telecommunication Facilities were last updated in December 1997 with minor amendments in January 2020. Amendments to Virginia Code in 2017 - 2020 and federal law regarding telecommunications facilities requires the City to update the Ordinance in order to be compliant with the new regulations. PRIOR ACTION(S): November 11, 2020: Planning Commission work session on Zoning Ordinance Amendments. December 9, 2020: The Planning Division recommended approval of the Zoning Ordinance Amendments. The Planning Commission recommended approval (7-0) of the Zoning Ordinance Amendments. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A CONTACT(S): Tom Martin, City Planner – 455-3900 J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC – (703) 378-5770 ATTACHMENT(S): • City Council Presentation – January 12, 2021 • Telecommunications Fact Sheet • Planning Commission Minutes – December 9, 2020 • Planning Commission Packet – December 9, 2020 o Planning Commission Report o Zoning Ordinance Amendment – Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles (Proposed) o Zoning Ordinance Amendment – Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance (Proposed) o Power Point Presentation – December 9, 2020 o Planning Commission Memorandum – November 11, 2020 o Power Point Presentation – November 11, 2020 • Planning Commission Sign in Sheet – December 9, 2020 • Telecommunications Legal Notice • Existing Telecommunications Ordinance Telecommunications Ordinance J. Patrick Taves Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner City Council Work Session January 12, 2021 Purpose and Outline Purpose: Discuss the proposed Telecommunications Ordinance Outline: 1. State and Federal mandates 2. Types of facilities – Small Cell, AREP, Standard Process Projects 3. Timelines for review 4. Where permitted - Height 5. Setbacks 2 Proposed regulations depend on the size of the facility. Three Types of Cell Facilities: • SMALL CELL FACILITIES: no more than 6 cu. ft. of volume for each antenna and no more than 28 cu. ft. of volume for all other wireless equipment • ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW ELIGIBLE PROJECTS (“AREPs”): not more than 50 ft. in height or co- location on any existing structure of a facility that is not a small cell facility • STANDARD PROCESS PROJECTS: any project that is not an AREP 3 Different Rules for Each Type of Facility. • Deadlines for Completeness of Applications---applications can be “deemed complete” • Fee Limitations • Deadlines for Decisions---applications can be “deemed approved” • Limited Grounds for Disapprovals • Different Rules for Different Facilities 4 Small Cell Facilities in the City’s Rights-of-Way and on City Property • Regulated by the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance (City Code Sections 35-28, 25-28.1, 35-28.2, 35-28.3, 35-28.4, 35-28.5, 35-28.6, and 35-28.7). • The New Telecommunications Ordinance provisions do not apply to these facilities. 5 Small Cell Facilities---Limited Reasons for Disapproval City can disapprove on existing structures for only four reasons: 1. Material potential interference with existing or future facilities designed and planned for a specific location or reserved for public safety communications 2. Safety of the public or other critical public service needs 3. Aesthetic impact, but only on publicly owned or publicly controlled property---but if the City owns the property or the structure, then the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance controls 4. Conflict with a historic district ordinance, but only if that property is not eligible for a specified federal review process 6 Permitted Uses: • All Small Cell Facilities in all districts---CUPs cannot be required • All AREPs in all districts (50 feet or less in height)---CUPs cannot be required • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-1 District 100 feet or less • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts 150 feet or less • Any base station for a lawfully existing wireless facility or structure meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure meeting specified requirements 7 Conditional Use Permits Can Only Be Required For Standard Process Projects: • Standard Process Projects between 50 and 150 feet in height in the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1, and B-4 Districts • Standard Process Projects that exceed 100 feet in height in the B-1 District, but no greater than 150 feet • Standard Process Projects that exceed 150 feet in height in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts • Standard process project base stations meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure that increases the height of the facility, but any height increase is limited to no more than 15 feet • Any other standard process project 8 Standards for CUP’s – Standard Process Projects Only: • Substantial conformance with the Comprehensive Plan • No significant adverse impact on use and enjoyment of nearby properties • No significant negative impact on property values • No material potential interference with pre-existing facilities or for future planned facilities planned or designed for a specific location or any reserved for future public safety facilities* • No significant adverse impact on public safety or public service needs* • No available and existing wireless support structures nearby • Not in conflict with the City historic district ordinance* • Satisfies all other applicable requirements 9 Setbacks for Similar Structures: • Virginia law provides that the City cannot impose a setback or fall zone requirement that is larger than the setback or fall zone requirement “that is imposed on other types of similar structures of a similar size, including utility poles. • As a result, we propose establishing setbacks for wireless support structures that provide the same setbacks for wireless support structures as are applied to light poles, utility poles, and flag poles of a similar size. 10 Separate Amendment for Setbacks for Similar Structures: • No setback for flag poles, light poles or utility poles (“poles”) that are less than 35’ in height. • Poles greater than 35’ in height set back at a 1:1 in R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3. R-4, IN-1 or B-4 Districts. • Poles greater than 35’ in height in B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District and adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, IN-1 or B-4 District set back at 1:1 • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District between 35’ and 50’ must meet underlying district setback • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District greater than 50’ set back at least ½ the height of the pole. 11 Discussion: Discussion 12 TELECOMMUNICATIONS ORDINANCE FACT SHEET 1. Why is the City of Lynchburg proposing to amend the Telecommunications Ordinance? The Telecommunications Ordinance was last updated in December 1997 with minor revisions in January 2000. Amendments to the Virginia Code in 2017, 2018 & 2020 and Federal Law has resulted in the need for the City to revise the Ordinance to be consistent with State & Federal Law. 2. What does the City’s Comprehensive Plan state about Telecommunications Facilities? The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013‐2030 recognizes that in order for the City to continue in its role as the economic engine for the region it must keep pace with changes in technology and telecommunications and that in order to attract businesses it must capitalize on comprehensive telecommunication services. (p.9, 83) 3. Who drafted the proposed Ordinance Revisions? City staff drafted the proposed revisions in conjunction with J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC, Fairfax, Virginia. Mr. Taves has 40+ years experience representing local governments in complex comprehensive plan, zoning and other land use issues. 4. Who has reviewed the proposed Ordinance Revisions? The draft ordinance was forwarded to over twenty‐six representatives of the telecommunications industry in August 2020. Comments received were minor in nature and have been incorporated into the draft ordinance. The Planning Commission conducted a work session on the proposed ordinance revisions on November 11, 2020. The Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on the proposed ordinance revisions and recommend approval (7‐0) on December 9, 2020. The City Council will conduct a work session on the proposed amendments on January 12, 2021 with an anticipated public hearing on February 9, 2021. 5. Why are setbacks proposed for flag poles, light poles, and utility poles? State and Federal law requires that telecommunication facilities be treated equally as similar structures. If setbacks are not established for flag poles, light poles and utility poles then the Zoning Ordinance can not require setbacks for telecommunication facilities. 6. How is the proposed Ordinance different from the existing ordinance? The proposed Ordinance classifies telecommunication facilities in one of three ways and sets review timeframes for each type as required by State and Federal Law: a. Small Cell Facilities – Permitted in all Zoning Districts (i) each antenna is or could fit within an imaginary enclosure of no more than six (6) cubic feet and (ii) all other wireless equipment associated with the facility has a cumulative volume of no more than twenty‐eight (28) cubic feet. Small cell facilities proposed within City right‐of‐way or on City property are regulated by separate City Code and the proposed amendments would not apply to these facilities. Small Cell Facility b. Administrative Review‐Eligible Project (AREP’s) – Permitted in all Zoning Districts (i) a new structure that is not more than fifty (50) feet above the ground level or not more than ten (10) feet above the tallest existing utility pole within five hundred (500) feet. (ii) not located in a local, state or federal historic district (iii) designed to support small cell facilities (iv) the colocation on any existing structure that is not a small cell facility c. Standard Process Project – Permitted or Conditional Use Permit (i) Any project that is not an administrative review eligible project. PERMITED USES BY DISTRICT & SETBACKS The permitted uses in each Zoning District are similar to the existing Ordinance in terms of height with the primary change being related to setbacks when telecommunication facilities are not located adjacent to a Residential District, Institutional 1 District or B‐4, Urban Commercial District (Downtown). Current Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2‐73.5 (a) 1 states: “All towers and any telecommunications facilities in any business and industrial zoning districts shall be set back on all sides a distance equal to the underlying building setback requirement in the applicable zoning district. All towers in residential zoning districts shall be set back on all sides a distance equal to the tower height. In addition, in order to preserve the aesthetics of residential areas and to maintain property values, whenever a tower is located in a residential district, the tower shall be located a distance at least equal to twice the height of the tower from any adjacent property lines. When a tower is located in a commercial district or industrial district, the tower shall be located a distance at least equal to twice the height of the tower from any residential district.” The proposed Ordinance would no longer require setbacks of twice the height of the tower or “fall zones” due to State & Federal Law that requires telecommunication facilities to be treated equally as similar structures. R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 & B-4 Districts Fifty (50) feet or less – Permitted by right Greater than fifty (50) feet, but no greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – Minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet – 0 B-1 District One hundred (100) feet or less – Permitted by Right Greater than one hundred (100) feet but no greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – structure less than fifty (50) feet – minimum setback of the B-1 District Setback – structure greater than fifty (50) feet – minimum of ½ the height of the structure Setback – structure adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 – minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet – 0 B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 & I-3 Districts One hundred fifty (150) feet or less – Permitted by Right Greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – structure less than fifty (50) feet – minimum setback of the District Setback – structure greater than fifty (50) feet – minimum of ½ the height of the structure Setback – structure adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 – minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet - 0 For more information contact Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner at (434) 455‐3909 or tom.martin@lynchburgva.gov. 1 MINUTES OF THE DECEMBER 9, 2020 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING (MINUTES HAVE NOT BEEN APPROVED): Consideration of amending Section 35.2-61.2 of the City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Additional Height Regulations, by adding section (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles and Utility Poles. Consideration of proposed amendments to the City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance that seek to repeal Zoning Ordinance Chapters 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.20 of the City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance related to Telecommunication Towers. Simultaneous with the repeal of the foregoing chapters, the proposed amendments also propose consideration of the adoption of new Zoning Ordinance Chapters 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26 pertaining to Telecommunications Facilities. The proposed amendments shall be referred to herein as the “Telecommunications Facilities Ordinance.” Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, introduced Mr. J. Patrick Taves, of Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC. He has been working on this item with Mr. Tom Martin, City Planner. Mr. Taves addressed the Commission. There are four (4) items to discuss. These include setbacks for flag poles, light poles, and utility poles, the adoption of the new telecommunications ordinance, the repeal of the existing telecommunications ordinance, and the approval types for each zoning dist rict. Rather than amending the existing ordinance piece by piece, it will be replaced entirely by the new one. The reason for proposing these changes in this manner is that it has been almost twenty (20) years since the current ordinance was put in place. Over that time there have been many changes in State and Federal law relating to these provisions. To put it plainly, the current ordinance is woefully out of date. For example, the current law in Virginia talks about small cell facilities, administrative review eligible projects (AREPs), and standard process projects but those are terms that don’t exist in the current ordinance. The proposed ordinance incorporates those provisions and lays out the requirements in respect to those provisions. Requirements f or timeliness of review depending on the type of facility are similar to the concept of a “shot clock”. If the City does not meet the deadlines laid out by State and Federal law, and in the proposed ordinance, the application may be deemed complete, even i f it is not, or may be deemed approved, even if it should not be. The smallest types of facilities are the micro wireless facilities, and they are a subset of the small cell facilities. If they are twenty -four (24) inches in length, fifteen (15) inches in width, twelve (12) inches in height, or smaller, and have no exterior antenna greater than eleven (11) inches then no approval is required and there are no requirements that can apply. Small cell facilities have some regulations applicable to them but not a lot. The administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) are subject to administrative review but not public hearings. The standard process projects are the largest facilities and may require a Conditional Use Permit. The Virginia Code provisions on this subject are generally anti -local government. For example an application can be deemed complete even if it is not or can be deemed approved even if it shouldn’t be. There is limited discretion for the City for facilities under fifty (50) feet in height. Th ere are limitations on fees that the City can impose regardless of the City’s expenses. There are limited grounds for disapproval. If the City wants to disapprove a facility, it needs to provide a written statement as to why. Usually when acts are taken by local government bodies they do not have to explain their reasoning. In the case of disapproval, the City also has to release, in writing, a substantial record of evidence within thirty (30) days of the decision. Overall, there are a lot of “hoops to jump through” in order to disapprove one of these facilities. This ordinance does not apply to small cell facilities in the right -of-way or on City property because the City has franchise agreements with respect to those types of facilities. Small cell facilit ies can only be disapproved for four reasons. These reasons include material potential interference with existing or future facilities designed and planned for a specific location or reserved for public safety communication, safety of the public or other critical public service needs, aesthetic impact, but only on publicly owned or publicly controlled property, and conflict with a historic district ordinance. The provisions for disapproval of small cell facilities are very narrow. Any other issues or compla ints do not matter. The way the proposed ordinance has been structured is to first include the provisions required by State and Federal law. The 2 City has very little flexibility in regards to those. The provisions inclu de the small cell facilities, the administrative review eligible projects (AREPs), and standard process projects. The facility is listed first and then all of the provisions that apply to that type of facility. There is some redundancy because a lot of the requirements are similar or the same for the administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) and the standard process projects. This layout makes it easier for the City, the residents, and any cell company who may be evaluating what requirements they need to meet, how quickly they need to respond, or what the flexibility is in regards to a type of facility. Small cell facilities are listed first, then administrative review eligible projects (AREPs), and finally standard process projects. Following that is permitted uses in each district and Conditional Use Permit requirements. This is where the City has more flexibility. The State and Federal requirements do not dictate what is allowed in each zoning district. This is only in regards to standard process projects though, which are over fifty (50) feet in height. A standard process project may require a Conditional Use Permit whereas small cell facilities and administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) cannot. The proposed ordinance is similar to the exist ing ordinance in terms of permitted uses and Conditional Use Permit requirements in each district. If a standard process project does not fall under a permitted use it may require a Conditional Use Permit. The districts fall into two (2) groupings. The fir st is the lower density districts which include the R -C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1, and B-4 districts. The B-1 district is separate and the standard process project facility is permitted in this district if it is less than one hundred (100) feet. The second grouping is the higher density districts which include the B -3, B -5, IN -2, I-1, I-2, and I -3 districts. This grouping is where there are allowances for larger facilities. Colocation, when a facility is added to an existing structure, is encouraged. This a llows for less general disruption and is more desirable than a standalone pole. If a Conditional Use Permit is required, standards can be applied. The most important standard is the one with respect to substantial conformance with the Comprehensive Plan. That is where the City has a lot of flexibility and discretion. The Comprehensive Plan is drafted before there is an application or specific issue. It is where foresight comes into play. The proposed changes do not amend the Comprehensive Plan but again, o ne of the standards is substantial conformance with the Comprehensive Plan. Addressing whether or not there are sufficient standards and projection for the future in the Comprehensive Plan may be needed. The statute requires that the City not have a setbac k or fall zone that exceeds the setback or fall zone established for similar structures. Flag poles, light poles, and utility poles are similar structures to wireless telecommunication facilities in height and appearance. There are no existing setback requ irements for flag poles, light poles, or utility poles. The standards have to be established. It is proposed that structures that are thirty-five (35) feet in height or less have no setback requirements. The lower density districts require the height of t he structure, if greater than thirty -five (35) feet as the setback. If the property the facility or pole is on is next to a lower density district, the setback must be from the lower density district, wherever that may be. In the higher density districts for structures between thirty-five (35) and fifty (50) feet the minimum setback is the requirement and that is already built into the ordinance. If it is greater than fifty (50) feet, the setback is one half the height of the structure. The proposed setbac ks will set standards for flag poles, light poles, utility poles, and telecommunication facilities. As a reminder there are four (4) items for the Commission’s consideration. The first is the adoption of the regulation of setbacks for the flag poles, light poles, and utility poles. Once that is established, setbacks for telecommunication facilities can be established. The second would be the adoption of the new telecommunications ordinance. Once that is adopted, the existing ordinance can be repealed, which is the third item. The fourth item is the revisions of the approval types for the various districts. That will automatically happen though when and if the telecommunications ordinance is adopted. Chair Rogers asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in favor of the petition. When no one stepped forward he asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in opposition to the petition. When no one stepped forward again he closed the public hearing. Chair Rogers stated that the presentation was informative. The proposed changes seem necessary. 3 Mr. Taves noted that the proposed ordinance regarding the provisions dictated by State and Federal law are necessary but the following portion regarding the provisions for permitted and conditional use offers more flexibility. Those provisions regarding permitted uses and Conditional Use Permit uses are modelled after the current City ordinance. Commissioner Marion stated that Mr. Taves seems well informed. She then asked if the proposed ordinance has been tested in other localities. Mr. Taves responded that for this particular ordinance, provisions regarding small cell facilities, administrative review eligible projects (AREPs), and standard process projects are in State code. He is comfortable with and recommends the adoption of this ordinance so the City can come into the 21st century with respect to wireless telecommunication facilities. Historically, there has been a tendency for local governments to abuse the zoning purview with res pect to these types of facilities. People generally don’t like the idea of them but “by the same token” this is the 21st century and people expect the delivery of service. Again, he recommends strongly the adoption of this ordinance so the City can be in compliance with State code. He noted that he has dealt with telecommunication facilities for twenty-five (25) to thirty (30) years and has litigated many cases. During the review process, the proposed ordinance was sent to telecommunication companies, the users and beneficiaries of this ordinance, for feedback. Only very minor questions came back and there is no opposition at the present hearing. Commissioner Bowden stated that it is an evolving process. This is the beginning of that evolution and will est ablish a framework to work with moving forward. What can be planned for at this point is covered. Mr. Taves shared agreement. There is little flexibility regarding what the State or Federal law dictates. The rest, regarding whether or not to permit someth ing, whether or not to require a Conditional Use Permit, what the standard should be, is always an evolving process. That is why he recommends evaluating the Comprehensive Plan. At this point though, he feels that this is the best proposal. Commissioner Bowden noted that in the application of this ordinance the places that might provide the most pushback are going to be the “edges of Lynchburg”. There are already telecommunication facilities Downtown and they can be placed on existing buildings. The “edges ” though may be more rural and may not have received that type of development yet. Those places are more likely to involve installation of towers and discuss aesthetics. Establishing standards now will allow for protection down the road. Mr. Taves shared agreement. Commissioner Bowden stated that the proposed setbacks make sense. That will probably be needed in relatively developed areas. He also noted that he can’t imagine anything else to do given the limited maneuverability to disapprove the facilities. Mr. Taves responded that the State and Federal law do not mandate which districts must allow standard process projects to be permitted or by Conditional Use Permit. Different localities have different zoning districts. They have already done t hat with respect to small cell facilities and administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) though since those cannot require a Conditional Use Permit and must be approved if they meet the application requirements for the type of facility in question. He then recommended that as time goes by, in two (2) or three (3) years, this should be reviewed to see how these provisions have worked. If necessary, the City can adopt new provisions. The proposed changes should be implemented and evaluated from there. Commissioner Perault added that the Comprehensive Plan should also be revisited once these provisions have “had time to settle”. There’s no rush to change the Comprehensive Plan now if changes 4 will be required in a few years. This should be implemented now and reviewed in a few years in conjunction with necessary changes to the Comprehensive Plan. Commissioner Bowden shared agreement and noted that the Comprehensive Plan should be consistent with what the City wants to accomplish. Commissioner Marion recalled that in a previous meeting concerning a cell tower, discussion of the tower went on for a long time because numerous neighbors came to complain. She then asked if the proposed changes would limit that due to lack of ability of the City to disapprove. Mr. Taves responded that he would have to disagree. He worked on that project (Langhorne Road) for the City and drafted a denial motion for that. That project was a large monopole and a standard process project. It wasn’t an administrative re view eligible project (AREP) or a small cell facility. It was a facility to which the City could lawfully apply Conditional Use Permit requirements. That is where the City has flexibility. The proposed ordinance does not increase the ability of the City to disapprove small cell facilities or administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) though. The standards for Conditional Use Permits include having no significant adverse impact on use and enjoyment of nearby properties and no negative impact on property values. Those points were used in the denial of that project. If the Comprehensive Plan is amended, more tools can be added to evaluate such proposals in order to assure that such decisions are not made “in the heat of the moment.” Chair Rogers stated that he feels that the Commission still has tools and the ability to help lead planning the community. He noted that these proposed changes discuss facilities like the small cell facilities and the administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) that they probably haven’t seen much of yet but will see more of in the future. There are blank areas in the City that don’t yet have service. The increase in these types of facilities will be a good thing because they are limited in their impacts and appearance in comparison to standard process projects. These facilities are vital infrastructure especially as fewer people use landlines and the need for such facilities may be a matter of public safety at times. Discussion on how to proceed with a motion ensued. Mr. Taves suggested that the motion include the verbiage “as advertised” which would incorporate the comprehensive information included in the legal notice. He then referenced the following specifically from the legal notice: “In accordance with the adoption of the proposed amendments, the “Approval Type” for “wireless telecommunications transmission” that is stated in each exhibit/chart for each applicable zoning district (for example, please see Exhibit IV -1 for the R -C District) shall be revised in order to state the “Approval Type” (“C” for “Conditional Use Permit” and/or “P” for “Permitted”) for each zoning district consistent with the terms of the proposed amendments.” Thus, if under the proposed amendments a wireless telecommunications facility may be allowed with a Conditional Use Permit (“C”) or may be Permitted (“P”), depending on the circumstances, then the “Approval Type” in the exhibit/chart for each district shall be stated as follows: “P/C”. If such facilities are only allowed by Conditional Use Permit, a “C” will be inserted in the applicable exhibit, and if such facilities are only Permitted, a “P” will be inserted in the applicable exhibit.” Commissioner Bowden made the following motion, seconded by Commissioner Johnson, and approved by the following vote: “Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City Council approval of amending the Zoning Ordinance by adopting Section 35.2 - 61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles and approval of repealing Sec tions, 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.20 related to Telecommunication Towers and replacing with Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance as 5 referenced in the attached legal notice that was advertised prior to the public hearing.” AYES: Bowden, Johnson, Light, Lowe, Marion, Perault, and Rogers 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 The Department of Community Development City Hall, Lynchburg, VA 24504 434-455-3900 To: Planning Commission From: Planning Division Date: December 9, 2020 Re: Zoning Ordinance Amendments: Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles Repeal Sections, 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.20 related to Telecommunication Towers and replace with Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance I. PETITIONER City of Lynchburg, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, Virginia 24504 Representative(s): J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC, Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner Property Owner: N/A II. LOCATION The Zoning Ordinance amendments would apply to any telecommunication facility in the R-C, R- 1, R-2, R-3, R-4, B-1, B-3, B-4, IN-1, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 Districts III. PURPOSE The purpose of the amendments is to bring the City’s Zoning Ordinance into compliance with State & Federal Law. IV. SUMMARY • The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 recognizes that in order for the City to continue in its role as the economic engine for the region it must keep pace with changes in technology and telecommunications and that in order to attract businesses it must capitalize on comprehensive telecommunication services. (p.9, 83) • The City’s Telecommunications Ordinance was last updated in December 1997 with minor revisions in January 2000. • Amendments to the Virginia Code in 2017, 2018 & 2020 regarding telecommunication facilities established new terminology and rules. • Federal Law on telecommunication facilities is evolving. • The Telecommunication Ordinance would establish three type of facilities: Small Cell Facilities, Administrative Review-Eligible Projects (AREP’s) and Standard Process Projects • The Telecommunications Ordinance would establish review procedures for each type of telecommunication facility. • Setbacks for similar structures such as flag poles, light poles and utility poles must be established to be compliant with State & Federal Law. • Small Cell Facilities located in the City’s right-of-way or on City property regulated by separate City Code and proposed amendments do not apply to these facilities. Planning Commission: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – December 9, 2020 2 The Planning Division recommends approval of the Zoning Ordinance Amendments. V. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. Comprehensive Plan. The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 recognizes that in order for the City to continue in its role as the economic engine for the region it must keep pace with changes in technology and telecommunications and that in order to attract businesses it must capitalize on comprehensive telecommunication services. (p.9, 83) The purpose and intent of the proposed amendments is to facilitate the provision of telecommunication services, recognizing that telecommunication facilities are a necessary part of communication networks while protecting property from adverse impacts. 2. Zoning. The Telecommunications Ordinance was last updated in December 1997 with minor revisions in January 2000. 3. Proffers: N/A 4. Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA). N/A 5. Surrounding Area. N/A 6. Site Description. N/A 7. Proposed Use of Property. N/A 8. Traffic, Parking and Public Transit. N/A 9. Stormwater Management. N/A 10. Emergency Services: The Telecommunication Ordinance would require technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that proposed facilities would not interfere with pre-existing or future communication facilities for Public Safety Radio Services. 11. Impact. The proposed Zoning Ordinance Amendments would establish regulations for telecommunication facilities in the City of Lynchburg. Small Cell Facilities – Permitted in all Zoning Districts (i) each antenna is or could fit in an imaginary enclosure of no more than six (6) cubic feet and (ii) all other wireless equipment associated with the facility has a cumulative volume of no more than twenty-eight (28) cubic feet. Administrative Review-Eligible Project (AREP’s) – Permitted in all Zoning Districts (i) a new structure that is not more than fifty (50) feet above the ground level or not more than ten (10) feet above the tallest existing utility pole within five hundred (500) feet. (ii) not located in a local, state or federal historic district (iii) designed to support small cell facilities (iv) the colocation on any existing structure that is not a small cell facility Planning Commission: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – December 9, 2020 3 Standard Process Project – Permitted or Conditional Use Permit (i) any project that is not an administrative review eligible project PERMITED USES BY DISTRICT & SETBACKS R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 & B-4 Districts Fifty (50) feet or less – Permitted by right Greater than fifty (50) feet, but no greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – Minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet - 0 B-1 District One hundred (100) feet or less – Permitted by Right Greater than one hundred (100) feet but no greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – structure less than fifty (50) feet – minimum setback of the B-1 District Setback – structure greater than fifty (50) feet – minimum of ½ the height of the structure Setback – structure adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 – minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet - 0 B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 & I-3 Districts One hundred fifty (150) feet or less – Permitted by Right Greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – structure less than fifty (50) feet – minimum setback of the District Setback – structure greater than fifty (50) feet – minimum of ½ the height of the structure Setback – structure adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 – minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet - 0 12. Technical Review Committee. N/A VI. PLANNING DIVISION RECOMMENDATION Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City Council approval of amending the Zoning Ordinance by adopting Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles and approval of repealing Sections, 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.20 related to Telecommunication Towers and replacing with Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance Planning Commission: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – December 9, 2020 4 This matter is respectfully offered for your consideration. William T. Martin, AICP City Planner pc: Dr. Reid Wodicka, Interim City Manager Mr. Kent L. White, Interim Deputy City Manager Mr. Walter C. Erwin, City Attorney Mr. J. Lee Newland, City Engineer Ms. Cynthia Kozerow, Lynchburg Police Department Battalion Chief Thomas Goode, Fire Marshal Mr. Doug Saunders, Building Official Mr. Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator Mr. J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC VII. ATTACHMENTS 1. Zoning Ordinance Amendment - Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles 2. Zoning Ordinance Amendment - Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance 3. Power Point Presentation – December 9, 2020 4. Planning Commission Memorandum – November 11, 2020 5. Power Point Presentation – November 11, 2020 35.2‐61.2 Additional Height Regulations (a) Measurement of Height 1. Building Height. Building height is the vertical distance measured from the crown of the street opposite the middle of the front of the building to: a. The highest point of roof surface of a flat roof b. The deck line of a mansard roof c. The mean eight level between eaves and ridge of a gable, hip or gambrel roof 2. Exceptions to Measurement of Building Height a. Buildings with Large Setbacks. Where a building is set back from the street line thirty‐five (35) feet or more, building height shall be measured from the average elevation of finished ground surface along the front of the building. b. Large Corner Lots. On corner lots exceeding twenty thousand (20,000) square feet in area, the height of the building may be measured from the crown of either street at the midpoint of the building facing the applicable street. c. Through Lots. For lots extending through from street to street, the height may be measured from the crown of either street at the midpoint of the building facing the applicable street, provided that the maximum height that would be permitted based on the lower street shall extend back from the right‐of‐way of such street not less than one hundred fifty (150) feet (see following illustration). d. Properties Abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts. For lots in any R‐4, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐1, I‐ 1, I‐2 or I‐3 district abutting property zoned R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3, height shall be measured from natural grade at the horizontal midpoint of the building wall facing each abutting residential property and shall apply to any portion of the building located within one‐hundred‐feet (100) feet of the property line (see following illustration). In no case shall a building be required to be less than twenty (20) feet in height at the front building line. (b) Height Exceptions for Certain Structures 1. The height limitations shall not apply to the following features projecting above the roof line: flag poles, church spires/steeples, belfries, cupolas and domes not used for human occupancy, chimneys, ventilators, skylights, water tanks, bulkheads or similar features, radio and television antennas for the use of residents of dwelling units in apartments, and necessary mechanical appurtenances (including, but not limited to solar energy panels and related appurtenances, plumbing vents, exhaust vents, HVAC equipment, electrical connections, lighting rods and telecommunications connections) usually carried above the roof level provided that: a. Such a feature shall be erected only to a height necessary to accomplish the purpose it is intended to serve, but in no case more than fifteen (15) feet above its lowest point of contact with the roof. b. The total area covered by such features shall not exceed in horizontal cross‐ sectional area fifteen (15) percent of the area of the plane of roof upon which they are located. c. Such features as water tanks, cooling towers and bulkheads, but not solar energy panels and related appurtenances, shall be enclosed within walls constructed of the same material as the main walls of the building on which they are located. 2. Parapet walls may extend not more than five (5) feet above the limiting height of the building on which t ey rest. 3. No sign, name plate, display or advertising device of any kind whatsoever shall be inscribed upon or attached to any chimney, tower, tank or other structure which extends above the district height limitations. (c) Tall Buildings in the R‐4, B‐1, B‐3 and IN‐1 Districts. In the R‐4, B‐1, B‐3 and IN‐1 districts, apartment buildings, public or semi‐public buildings such as a religious institution, school, library, hospital, may be erected to not more than one hundred twenty‐five (125) feet in height; provided that the portion of such building more than forty (40) feet in height shall set back from the street, lot or required setback line, one (1) foot for each one (1) foot of such additional height (s e following illustration). (d) Flag poles, Light Poles and Utility Poles 1. There shall be no setback requirement for any Flag Pole, Light Pole or Utility Pole that is thirty‐five (35) feet or less in height. 2. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole greater than thirty‐five (35) in height in the R‐C, R‐ 1, R‐2, R‐3, R‐4, IN‐1 or B‐4 District shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the height of the pole. 3. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole greater than thirty‐five (35) in height in the B‐1, B‐ 3, B‐5, IN‐2, I‐1, I‐2 or I‐3 District that is on a parcel adjacent to any parcel that is zoned R‐ C, R‐1, R‐2, R‐3, R‐4, IN‐1 or B‐4 shall be set back a distance at least the height of the pole from the R‐C, R‐1, R‐2, R‐3, R‐4, IN‐1 or B‐4 District. 4. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole in the B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐2, I‐1, I‐2 or I‐3 District that is greater than thirty‐five (35) feet in height but less than fifty (50) feet in height shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the minimum applicable setback for the district in which it is located. 5. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole in the B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐2, I‐1, I‐2 or I‐3 District that is a height greater than fifty (50) feet shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least one‐half the height of the pole. 6. Setback requirements for Flag Poles, Light Poles, and Utility Poles shall be measured from the base of the pole to the property lines of the parcel on which the pole is located. 1 1 2 3 4 5 ORDINANCE NO. - 6 7 Updated to October 30, 2020 8 AN ORDINANCE REPEALING CHAPTER 35.2-73, WHICH COMPRISES §§ 35.2-73.1 9 THROUGH 35.2-73.20, AND ADOPTING A NEW CHAPTER 35.2-73, WHICH 10 COMPRISES §§ 35.2-73.1 THROUGH 35.2-73.26, PERTAINING TO 11 TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES. 12 BE IT ORDAINED, by the City Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, that 13 Chapter 35.2-73 of the Code of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, is hereby adopted as 14 follows: 15 § 35.2–73 TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES 16 § 35.2–73.1 Purpose and Intent. 17 The purpose and intent of this chapter is to create and implement regulations and requirements for 18 the placement, construction, modification, and removal of wireless support structures, wireless 19 facilities, and base stations in order to protect the health, safety, and welfare of the public, while at 20 the same time not unreasonably interfering with the development of a competitive wireless 21 telecommunications marketplace in the City. Specifically, the purposes of this chapter are: 22 (a) To facilitate the provision of wireless telecommunications services to the residents 23 and businesses of the City in an orderly fashion; 24 (b) To recognize and acknowledge that wireless telecommunications facilities, 25 including their support structures and related equipment, have become a necessary 26 part of today’s personal and commercial communications networks; 27 (c) To regulate the location of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base 28 stations in the City; 29 (d) To protect residential, commercial, and industrial areas and land uses from any 30 significant potential adverse impact that may result from the establishment and 31 operation of wireless support structures, wireless facilities and base stations; 2 1 (e) To implement the provisions of the City’s Comprehensive Plan with respect to the 2 establishment of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations in 3 the City; 4 (f) To minimize, when possible, the adverse visual impact of wireless support 5 structures, wireless facilities, and base stations through careful design, siting, 6 landscaping, and innovative camouflaging techniques to enhance the ability of such, 7 support structures, facilities, and base stations to be compatible with residential, 8 commercial, and industrial uses; 9 (g) To promote and encourage the co-location on and around wireless support 10 structures of multiple wireless facilities and base stations in order to reduce, when 11 possible, the need for additional such structures and facilities; 12 (h) To promote and encourage the location of wireless support structures, wireless 13 facilities, and base stations in commercial and industrial areas, rather than 14 residential areas; 15 (i) To ensure that wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations are 16 compatible with other land uses in the vicinity; 17 (j) To allow wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations as a 18 matter of right, where appropriate, and with minimal administrative requirements 19 when the size, design, and location of such support structures, facilities, and base 20 stations does not result in any significant adverse impacts to other uses or any 21 significant adverse impact to the property values of nearby properties; 22 (k) To provide greater scrutiny of requests for wireless support structures, wireless 23 facilities, and base stations when their size, design, and location may result in 24 greater impacts on surrounding land uses and property values in order to assure that 25 adverse impacts of such structures, facilities, and base stations and any adverse 26 impact on the values of nearby properties are mitigated and minimized; 27 (l) To encourage the providers of wireless telecommunications services to utilize 28 smaller wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations in order to 29 reduce the overall impact of any single wireless support structure or facility on the 30 surrounding area; 31 (m) To reduce the need for larger and taller wireless support structures, wireless 32 facilities, and base stations through the encouragement of co-location on any new 33 structures as well as the installation, where feasible, of such facilities onto existing 34 structures; 3 1 (n) To avoid potential damage to the use and enjoyment of property caused by wireless 2 support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations by ensuring that such 3 structures, facilities, and stations are soundly, safely, and carefully designed; 4 constructed, modified, and maintained, and, when no longer structurally sound, 5 removed; and 6 (o) To require the removal of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base 7 stations that are no longer used to support wireless facilities and no longer retain 8 any other legitimate purposes. 9 § 35.2–73.2 Definitions. 10 As used in this Ordinance, unless the context requires a different meaning: 11 “Administrative review-eligible project” means a project that provides for: 12 1. The installation or construction of a new structure that is not more than 50 feet above 13 ground level, provided that the structure with attached wireless facilities is (i) not more than 10 14 feet above the tallest existing utility pole located within 500 feet of the new structure within the 15 same public right-of-way or within the existing line of utility poles; (ii) not located within the 16 boundaries of a local, state, or federal historic district; (iii) not located inside the jurisdictional 17 boundaries of a locality having expended a total amount equal to or greater than 35 percent of its 18 general fund operating revenue, as shown in the most recent comprehensive annual financial 19 report, on undergrounding projects since 1980; and (iv) designed to support small cell facilities; 20 or 21 2. The co-location on any existing structure of a wireless facility that is not a small cell 22 facility; 23 3. The term “administrative review-eligible project” shall include eligible facilities requests 24 as that term is defined by federal law in 47 Code of Federal Regulations 1.6100. 25 “Antenna” means communications equipment that transmits or receives electromagnetic radio 26 signals used in the provision of any type of wireless communications services. 27 “Base station” means a station that includes a structure that currently supports or houses an 28 antenna, transceiver, coaxial cables, power cables, or associated equipment at a specific site that 29 is authorized to communicate with mobile stations, generally consisting of radio transceivers, 30 antennas, coaxial cables, power supplies, and other associated electronics. 31 “City” means the City of Lynchburg, Virginia. 4 1 “Co-locate” means to install, mount, maintain, modify, operate, or replace a wireless facility on, 2 under, within, or adjacent to a base station, building, existing structure, utility pole, or wireless 3 support structure. “Co-location” has a corresponding meaning. 4 “Department” means the Virginia Department of Transportation. 5 “Existing structure” means any structure that is installed or approved for installation at the time 6 a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider provides notice to the City or the 7 Department of an agreement with the owner of the structure to co-locate equipment on that 8 structure. “Existing structure” includes any structure that is currently supporting, designed to 9 support, or capable of supporting the attachment of wireless facilities, including towers, 10 buildings, utility poles, light poles, flag poles, signs, and water towers. 11 “Micro-wireless facility” means a small cell facility that is not larger in dimension than 24 inches 12 in length, 15 inches in width, and 12 inches in height and that has an exterior antenna, if any, not 13 longer than 11 inches. 14 “New structure” means a wireless support structure that has not been installed or constructed, or 15 approved for installation or construction, at the time a wireless services provider or wireless 16 infrastructure provider applies to the City for any required zoning approval. 17 “New wireless support structure” has the same meaning as “new structure.” 18 “Project” means (i) the installation or construction by a wireless services provider or wireless 19 infrastructure provider of a new structure or (ii) the co-location on any existing structure of a 20 wireless facility that is not a small cell facility. “Project” does not include the installation of a 21 small cell facility by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider on an 22 existing structure to which the provisions of Code Virginia § 15.2-2316.4 apply. 23 “Small cell facility” means a wireless facility that meets both of the following qualifications: 24 (i) each antenna is located inside an enclosure of no more than six cubic feet in volume, or, in the 25 case of an antenna that has exposed elements, the antenna and all of its exposed elements could 26 fit within an imaginary enclosure of no more than six cubic feet; and 27 (ii) all other wireless equipment associated with the facility has a cumulative volume of 28 no more than 28 cubic feet, or such higher limit as is established by the Federal Communications 29 Commission. 30 The following types of associated equipment are not included in the calculation of 31 equipment volume: electric meter, concealment, telecommunications demarcation boxes, back- 5 1 up power systems, grounding equipment, power transfer switches, cut-off switches, and vertical 2 cable runs for the connection of power and other services. 3 “Standard process project” means any project that is not an administrative review-eligible 4 project. 5 “Utility pole” means a structure owned, operated, or owned and operated by a public utility, local 6 government, or the Commonwealth that is designed specifically for and used to carry lines, 7 cables, or wires for communications, cable television, or electricity. 8 “Water tower” means a water storage tank, or a standpipe or an elevated tank situated on a 9 support structure, originally constructed for use as a reservoir or facility to store or deliver water. 10 “Wireless facility” means equipment at a fixed location that enables wireless communications 11 between user equipment and a communications network, including (i) equipment associated with 12 wireless services, such as private, broadcast, and public safety services, as well as unlicensed 13 wireless services and fixed wireless services, such as microwave backhaul, and (ii) radio 14 transceivers, antennas, coaxial, or fiber optic cable, regular and backup power supplies, and 15 comparable equipment, regardless of technological configuration. 16 “Wireless infrastructure provider” means any person that builds or installs transmission 17 equipment, wireless facilities, or wireless support structures, but that is not a wireless services 18 provider. 19 “Wireless services” means (i) “personal wireless services as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332(C)(7)(i); 20 “personal wireless service facilities” as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332(C)(7)(ii); including 21 commercial mobile services as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332(d), provided to personal mobile 22 communications devices through wireless facilities, and (iii) any other fixed or mobile wireless 23 service, using licensed or unlicensed spectrum, provided using wireless facilities. 24 “Wireless services provider” means a provider of wireless services. 25 “Wireless support structure” means a freestanding structure, such as a monopole, tower, either 26 guyed or self-supporting, or suitable existing structure or alternative structure designed to 27 support or is capable of supporting wireless facilities. “Wireless support structure” does not 28 include any telephone or electrical utility pole or any tower used for the distribution or 29 transmission of electrical service. 30 § 35.2–73.3 Applicability. 31 The provisions of this chapter shall apply to all land within the jurisdictional boundaries of the 32 City of Lynchburg, provided, however, that the provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any 6 1 small cell facility within the City’s right-of-way or on any City-owned property. Small cell 2 facilities within the City’s right-of-way or on any City-owned property are regulated by §§ 35– 3 28, 35–28.1, 35–28.2, 35–28.3, 35–28.4, 35–28.5, 35–28.6, and 35–28.7 of the City Code. 4 5 § 35.2–73.4 Small Cell Facilities. 6 A. Review of Applications for Small Cell Facilities. No conditional use permit or 7 its equivalent shall be required in the City for a small cell facility to be installed on an existing 8 structure if a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider has: (1) permission 9 from the owner to co-locate equipment on that structure; and (2) has notified the City that such 10 permission exists. A permit for the installation of a small cell facility shall be required before a 11 small cell facility may be installed on an existing structure. 12 B. Application Requirements for Small Cell Facilities. Applications filed by 13 a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider for administrative review of a 14 small cell facility on an existing structure shall include the following: 15 1. A valid electronic mail address for the applicant. 16 2. Written proof that the owner of the existing structure has given the applicant 17 consent to install the small cell facility as proposed. 18 3. The name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the 19 applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the parcel(s) of land on which the wireless 20 support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located, then the 21 applicant shall provide written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone 22 number, and the electronic mail address of the owner. 23 4. The valuation map number and address of the parcel of land on which the wireless 24 support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located. 25 5. A plan, drawn to scale, depicting the location and elevation of any small cell 26 facility that is the subject of the application, with engineering drawings showing the actual 27 size of the small cell facility and each component thereof, from which the City can 28 reasonably determine whether the proposed facility meets the definition of a small cell 29 facility. 30 6. Drawings showing where and how the small cell facility is proposed to be 31 attached to the existing structure. 7 1 7. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the proposed 2 facilities meet the standards set forth in this Ordinance, including, but not limited to, the 3 requirements set forth in § 35.2–73.13 (Interference With Public Safety Radio Services) 4 and will not materially interfere with other pre-existing communications facilities or with 5 future communications facilities that have already been designed and planned for a 6 specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety communications 7 facilities. 8 8. Evidence relating to any other factors the applicant believes are relevant to the 9 City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed small cell facility should be 10 approved. 11 9. Payment of an application processing fee of $100.00 each for up to five small cell 12 facilities on a permit application, and payment of a fee of $50 for each additional small cell 13 facility on that permit application. 14 C. Multiple Requests on a Single Application for Small Cell Facilities. Applications 15 filed by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider for a small cell facility to 16 be co-located on an existing structure may include multiple such permit requests on a single 17 application. 18 D. Notification of Incomplete Application for Small Cell Facilities. If an 19 incomplete initial or resubmitted application is filed for a small cell facility to be installed on an 20 existing structure, then the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application 21 is incomplete and shall specify any missing information and documents in accordance with the 22 following: 23 1. for an initial application, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic 24 mail within ten (10) calendar days after receipt of a valid electronic mail address and the 25 application that the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any 26 missing information and documents; otherwise, the application shall be deemed 27 complete; and 28 2. for a resubmitted application for a small cell facility to be installed on an 29 existing structure, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail within ten (10) 30 calendar days after the application is resubmitted whether the application is incomplete 31 and shall specify in that notification any missing information and documents; otherwise, 32 the application shall be deemed complete. 33 E. Deadline for Approval or Disapproval of Small Cell Facilities. The City shall 34 approve or disapprove any application filed by a wireless services provider or wireless 35 infrastructure provider proposing a small cell facility to be installed on an existing structure in 36 accordance with the following: 8 1 1. any such application shall be approved or disapproved in writing within 2 sixty (60) calendar days after receipt of the complete application; 3 2. if the applicant files an incomplete initial or resubmitted application and 4 the City notifies the applicant of its incompleteness in accordance with the applicable 5 timeframes set forth in subsection D above (Notification of Incomplete Application for 6 Small Cell Facilities), then the time within which the City must approve or disapprove 7 such an initial application shall be tolled for the period from the date of the submission of 8 the initial incomplete application to the date on which the applicant files a complete 9 application; 10 3. if the applicant files an incomplete resubmitted application, the time 11 within which the City must approve or disapprove a resubmitted application shall also be 12 tolled for the period from the date of submission of the resubmitted incomplete 13 application to the date on which the applicant resubmits a complete application; 14 4. the initial sixty (60) calendar-day period for the City to approve or 15 disapprove an application for a small cell facility proposed to be installed on an existing 16 structure may be extended by the City in writing for a period not to exceed an additional 17 30 days; 18 5. any such application for a small cell facility proposed to be installed on an 19 existing structure shall be deemed approved if the City fails to act within the timeframes 20 set forth in this section; 21 6. any disapproval of an application for a small cell facility on an existing 22 structures shall be in writing and accompanied by an explanation for the disapproval; and 23 7. approval of a permit for any such small cell facility application shall not 24 be unreasonably conditioned, withheld, or delayed. 25 F. Grounds for Disapproval of Small Cell Facilities. The City may disapprove an 26 application filed by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider proposing the 27 installation of a small cell facility on an existing structure for any of the following reasons: 28 1. Material potential interference with other pre-existing communications 29 facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and 30 planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety 31 communications facilities; 32 2. The safety of the public or other critical public service needs; 9 1 3. Only in the case of an installation on or in publicly owned or publicly 2 controlled property, excluding privately owned structures where the applicant has an 3 agreement for attachment to the structure, aesthetic impact or the absence of all required 4 approvals from all departments, authorities, and agencies with jurisdiction over such 5 property; 6 4. Conflict with a City ordinance adopted pursuant to § 15.2-2306, or 7 pursuant to local charter on a historic property that is not eligible for the review process 8 established under 54 U.S.C § 306108. 9 G. Small Cell Facilities on New Structures. Any application for the installation 10 of a small cell facility on a new structure shall require any approval that may be required by this 11 chapter for that new structure as either an administrative review-eligible project or a standard 12 process project. 13 § 35.2–73.5 Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. 14 A. Review of Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. Administrative 15 review-eligible projects shall not require that a conditional use permit or its equivalent be 16 obtained for the installation or construction of such a project; but administrative review shall be 17 required for the issuance of any zoning approval, or an acknowledgment that zoning approval is 18 not required, for such a project. 19 B. Application Requirements for Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. 20 Applications for wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and/or base stations that 21 comprise administrative review-eligible projects shall require the following: 22 1. The name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the 23 applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the land on which the wireless support 24 structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located, then the 25 applicant shall provide written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone 26 number, and the electronic mail address of the owner. If the land on which the proposed 27 wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station is proposed to be located is, in 28 whole or in part, within the City’s right-of-way, then the applicant shall be required to 29 secure written consent from the City for the proposed wireless support structure, wireless 30 facility, or base station to be located within the City’s right-of-way prior to filing such 31 application and shall include such written consent as part of any such application. 32 2. An affirmative written statement signed by the applicant and the owner 33 that the applicant and the owner are aware of and agree to comply with the provisions of 34 this Zoning Ordinance set forth in § 35.2-73.24 (Abandonment) regarding removal and 35 dismantlement of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and 10 1 related equipment in the event such a structure, facility, base station, or related equipment 2 is no longer in use. 3 3. The valuation map number and address of the parcel of land on which the 4 wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located. 5 4. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the 6 proposed facilities meet the standards set forth in this Ordinance, including, but not 7 limited to, the requirements set forth in § 35.2–73.13 (Interference With Public Safety 8 Radio Services), and will not materially interfere with other pre-existing communications 9 facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and 10 planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety 11 communications facilities. 12 5. Written, technical evidence from an electrical engineer that the proposed 13 site of the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station does not pose a 14 risk of explosion, fire, or other danger due to its proximity to volatile, flammable, 15 explosive, or hazardous materials such as propane, gasoline, natural gas, or corrosive or 16 other dangerous chemicals. 17 6. A site plan, as required by § 35.2-14.2 (Site Plans) of this Ordinance. 18 7. A map showing the location and height of every utility pole within 500 19 feet of and within the same public right-of-way or within the existing line of utility poles 20 as the proposed wireless support structure or wireless facility. 21 8. In the case of an administrative review-eligible project proposing a new 22 structure, a detailed explanation of how the proposed new structure is designed to support 23 small cell facilities. 24 9. A copy of any approval granted by a federal agency, including any 25 conditions imposed by that agency, regarding the proposed wireless support structure, 26 wireless facility, and/or base station, provided, however, that this requirement shall not 27 apply to applications for small cell facilities. 28 10. Evidence relating to any other factors the applicant believes are relevant to 29 the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed small cell facility should be 30 approved. 31 11. The applicable application fee for the proposed administrative review- 32 eligible project. 11 1 12. Evidence that the applicant has given written notice to all adjacent 2 landowners regarding the applicant’s intent to file the application at least 15 days before 3 the filing of any application to locate a new structure on the subject property. 4 C. Fee Limitations for Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. When an 5 application for an administrative review-eligible project is filed, the following provisions 6 shall apply to the fee that must be paid by the applicant: 7 1. The fee must be reasonable. 8 2. The fee charged by the City shall not include direct payment or 9 reimbursement of third-party fees charged on a contingency basis or a result-based 10 arrangement. 11 3. The City shall not charge market-based or value-based fees for the 12 processing of any such application. 13 4. Upon request, the City shall, within a reasonable amount of time after such 14 request, provide the applicant with the cost basis for any fee charged by the City for an 15 administrative review-eligible project. 16 D. Assessment of Fees for Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. Each 17 application for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station that constitutes an 18 administrative review-eligible project shall be accompanied by payment of a $500 fee for the 19 processing of the application 20 E. Processing Applications for Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. The 21 following provisions set forth the process that shall apply to any application for an administrative 22 review-eligible project: 23 1. Prior to accepting any application for an administrative review-eligible 24 project, the City shall first determine that the application includes the applicant’s 25 electronic mail address. In the event the application does not include the applicant’s 26 electronic mail address, the City shall not accept it for filing 27 2. If the application is incomplete, but includes an electronic mail address for 28 the applicant, then within ten (10) business days after actual receipt of the application, the 29 City shall accept the application and notify the applicant by electronic mail that the 30 application is incomplete and shall specify any additional information, documents and 31 materials required to complete the application. 12 1 3. If the application is incomplete and does not include an electronic mail 2 address for the applicant when it was filed, the City shall use reasonable means to contact 3 the applicant and request the applicant’s electronic mail address. Within ten (10) days 4 after actual receipt of the applicant’s electronic mail address, the City shall notify the 5 applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any 6 additional information, documents and materials required to complete the application. 7 4. If an incomplete initial or resubmitted application is filed for an 8 administrative review-eligible project, then the City shall notify the applicant by 9 electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any missing 10 information and documents and materials in accordance with the following: 11 (a) for an initial application, the City shall notify the applicant by 12 electronic mail within ten (10) business days after the application is submitted 13 whether the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any 14 missing information, documents and materials; otherwise, the application will be 15 deemed complete; and 16 (b) for a resubmitted application, the City shall notify the applicant by 17 electronic mail within ten (10) days after the application is resubmitted whether 18 the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing 19 information, documents and materials; otherwise, the application will be deemed 20 complete. 21 5. If the City fails to timely provide the applicant with notice that the initial 22 application or a resubmitted application is incomplete in accordance with the foregoing 23 provisions, as applicable, the application shall be deemed complete. 24 6. Except as provided for in subsection 7 below, the City shall approve or 25 disapprove a complete application in accordance with the following: 26 (a) For a new structure, within 150 days after receipt of the completed 27 application minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the 28 date any notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City; 29 (b) For the modification of an existing wireless support structure or 30 base station that involves the co-location of new transmission equipment, the removal of 31 transmission equipment, or the replacement of transmission equipment, but does not 32 substantially change, as that term is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of 33 such support structure or base station, within 60 days after receipt of the application 34 provided, however, that this period shall be tolled during any time after which the 35 applicant has been informed that the application is not complete and is provided with the 13 1 grounds for its incompleteness by the City, and when the applicant files all requested 2 information and items necessary to make the application complete; 3 (c) For the co-location on an existing support structure of any wireless 4 facility that is not a small cell facility and substantially changes, as that term is defined by 5 federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or any related base station, 6 within the lesser of 90 days after receipt by the City of the completed application, minus 7 any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the date any notice of 8 incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City; and 9 (d) For any wireless facility that is not a small cell facility on a new 10 structure, within the lesser of 150 days after receipt of a completed application, minus 11 any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the date any notice of 12 incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City . 13 7. Any period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above within 14 which the City must approve or disapprove an application may be extended by written 15 agreement of the applicant and the City. 16 8. A complete application for an administrative review-eligible project shall 17 be deemed approved if the City fails to approve or disapprove such application within the 18 applicable period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above or within any 19 agreed extension thereof pursuant to subsection 7 above. 20 9. If the City disapproves an application for an administrative review-eligible 21 project: 22 (a) the City shall provide the applicant with a written statement listing 23 all of the reasons for the disapproval; and 24 (b) if the City is aware of any modifications to the project as described 25 in the application that if made would permit the City to approve the proposed 26 project, the City shall identify them in the written statement provided under 27 subsection 9(a) above. The City’s subsequent disapproval of an application for a 28 project that incorporates the modifications identified in such a written statement 29 may be used by the applicant as evidence that the City’s subsequent disapproval 30 was arbitrary or capricious in any appeal of the City’s subsequent disapproval. 31 10. If an application for an administrative review-eligible project is 32 disapproved, the City’s disapproval shall: 14 1 (a) not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other 2 wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications 3 services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services; and 4 (b) be supported by substantial record evidence contained in a written 5 record publicly released within 30 days following the disapproval. 6 F. Limitations on Disapprovals of Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. 7 Whenever the City receives, considers, and processes a complete application for an 8 administrative review-eligible project, it shall not disapprove any such application on the basis 9 of: 10 (a) the applicant’s business decision with respect to its designed 11 service, customer demand, or quality of service to or from a particular site; 12 (b) the applicant’s specific need for the project, including the 13 applicant’s desire to provide additional wireless coverage or capacity; or 14 (c) the wireless facility technology selected by the applicant for use at 15 the project. 16 G. Disapproval Considerations for Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. 17 Nothing in this Ordinance shall be construed to prohibit the City from disapproving an 18 application for an administrative review-eligible project: 19 1. On the basis of the fact that the proposed height of any wireless support 20 structure, wireless facility, or wireless support structure with attached wireless facilities exceeds 21 50 feet above ground level, provided that the City follows a local ordinance or regulation that 22 does not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, 23 wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services , and other providers 24 of functionally equivalent services; or 25 2. That proposes to locate a new structure, or to co-locate a wireless facility 26 in an area where all cable and public utility facilities are required to be placed 27 underground by a date certain or encouraged to be undergrounded as part of a 28 transportation improvement project or rezoning proceeding as set forth in objectives 29 contained in a comprehensive plan, if: 30 (a) The undergrounding requirement or comprehensive plan objective 31 existed at least three months prior to the submission of the application; 15 1 (b) The City allows the co-location of wireless facilities on existing 2 utility poles, government-owned structures with the government’s consent, 3 existing wireless support structures, or a building within that area; 4 (c) The City allows the replacement of existing utility poles and 5 wireless support structures with poles or support structures of the same size or 6 similar within that area; and 7 (d) The disapproval of the application does not unreasonably 8 discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless 9 infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services, and other 10 providers of functionally equivalent services, and other providers of functionally 11 equivalent services. 12 H. Disapproval Limitation If Administrative Review-Eligible Project Does not 13 Substantially Change Physical Dimensions. The City may not deny, and shall approve, within 14 sixty (60) days, any administrative review-eligible project which requests any modification of an 15 existing base station or wireless support structure that does not substantially change, as that term 16 is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or base station and 17 that involves the co-location of new transmission equipment, the removal of transmission 18 equipment, or the replacement of transmission equipment. 19 I. Disapproval Allowed If Written Notice Not Provided to Adjacent Property 20 Owners. The City may disapprove an application for an administrative review-eligible project if 21 the applicant has not given written notice to all adjacent property owners at least 15 days before 22 the applicant applies to locate a new structure on the subject property. 23 § 35.2–73.6 Standard Process Projects. 24 A. Review of Standard Process Projects. Standard process projects may 25 require the approval of a conditional use permit and/or a site plan.for the installation or 26 construction of such a project, and City staff review may also be required for the issuance of any 27 zoning permit, or an acknowledgment that zoning approval is not required, for a standard process 28 project. 29 B. Application Requirements for Standard Process Projects. Applications for 30 wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and/or base stations that constitute standard 31 process projects shall include the following: 32 1. The name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the 33 applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the land on which the wireless support 34 structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located, then the 35 applicant shall provide written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone 16 1 number, and the electronic mail address of the owner. If the land on which the proposed 2 wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station is proposed to be located is, in 3 whole or in part, within the City’s right-of-way, then the applicant shall be required to 4 secure written consent from the City for the proposed wireless support structure, wireless 5 facility, or base station to be located within the City’s right-of-way prior to filing such 6 application and shall include such written consent as part of any such application. 7 2. An affirmative written statement signed by the applicant and the owner 8 that the applicant and the owner are aware of and agree to comply with the provisions of 9 this Zoning Ordinance set forth in § 35.2-73.24 (Abandonment) regarding removal and 10 dismantlement of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and 11 related equipment in the event such a structure, facility, base station, or related equipment 12 is no longer in use. 13 3. The valuation map number and address of the parcel of land on which the 14 wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located. 15 4. The names, addresses, and telephone numbers of the owners of and a map 16 showing the location and height of all wireless support structures or potential wireless 17 support structures taller than fifty (50) feet that are within a one (1) mile radius of the 18 proposed new site for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station, 19 including City-owned property. 20 5. Written documentation that the applicant has made diligent, but 21 unsuccessful, efforts to secure the permission to co-locate the applicant’s proposed 22 wireless facility on an existing or proposed wireless support structure owned by others, 23 including the City, within a one-mile radius of the proposed wireless support structure, 24 wireless facility, and/or base station. 25 6. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the 26 proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, or project cannot be 27 installed or co-located on another existing or proposed wireless support structure within a 28 one (1) mile radius of the proposed site for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, 29 or base station and must be located at the proposed site in order to meet the coverage 30 requirements for applicant’s wireless telecommunications system. 31 7. Written, technical evidence from a structural engineer that the proposed 32 wireless support structure can support the wireless facilities and base stations of other 33 carriers for the purposes of co-location. 34 8. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the 35 proposed facilities meet the standards set forth in this Ordinance, including, but not 36 limited to, the requirements set forth in § 35.2–73.13 (Interference With Public Safety 17 1 Radio Services), and will not materially interfere with other pre-existing communications 2 facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and 3 planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety 4 communications facilities. 5 9. Written, technical evidence from an electrical engineer that the proposed 6 site of the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station does not pose a 7 risk of explosion, fire, or other danger due to its proximity to volatile, flammable, 8 explosive, or hazardous materials such as propane, gasoline, natural gas, or corrosive or 9 other dangerous chemicals. 10 10. A map of the City and the first half-mile of all bordering communities 11 showing the design of the applicant’s entire existing or proposed telecommunications 12 network. Such map shall, at a minimum, indicate the general location of all proposed or 13 existing sites of the applicant’s wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base 14 stations, and related equipment, the dimensions of the sites, specifications relating to the 15 facilities, and signal area coverage. 16 11. Color photo simulations showing the proposed site of the proposed 17 wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, or project with a photo-realistic 18 representation of the proposed structure and facility as they would appear viewed from at 19 least four (4) substantially different vantage points on the eight (8) closest residential 20 properties or adjacent roadways.. 21 12. Any initial application fee required by § 35.2–73.6(D) (Fees for Standard 22 Process Projects). 23 13. A site plan, including a depiction of the lot lines, setbacks, existing 24 structures and other improvements on the property, the location of adjacent and nearby 25 structures, the proposed location of the proposed wireless support structure, wireless 26 facility, and base station that are the subject of the application, separation distances, 27 proposed height of any new structure, screening and landscaping, existing and proposed, 28 access, parking, security, zoning district(s) for the subject property and all adjacent 29 properties, and any floodplain on the subject property. 30 14. A copy of any approval granted by a federal agency, including any 31 conditions imposed by that agency, regarding the proposed wireless support structure, 32 wireless facility, and/or base station. 33 15. Evidence relating to any other factors the applicant believes are relevant to 34 the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed standard process project 35 should be approved. 18 1 16. Written documentation regarding whether and how the location of the 2 proposed wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in relation to existing 3 structures, trees, and other visual buffers, minimizes, to the greatest extent reasonably 4 practicable under the circumstances, any significant negative adverse impact. 5 17. Witten documentation regarding whether and how the location of the 6 wireless support structure and/or wireless facility will not have a significant detrimental 7 impact on the property values of adjacent and nearby properties. 8 18. Written documentation regarding any other factors the applicant believes 9 are relevant to the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed standard 10 process project should be approved. 11 19. Evidence that the applicant has given written notice to all adjacent 12 landowners regarding the applicant’s intent to file the application at least 15 days before 13 the filing of any application to locate a new structure on the subject property 14 C. Fee Limitations for Standard Process Projects. When an application for a 15 standard process project is filed, the following provisions shall apply to the fee that must 16 be paid by the applicant: 17 1. The fee must be reasonable. 18 2. The fee charged by the City shall not include direct payment or 19 reimbursement of third-party fees charged on a contingency basis or a result-based 20 arrangement. 21 3. The fee charged by the City shall not exceed the actual direct costs to 22 process the application, including permits and inspection. 23 4. The City shall not charge market-based or value-based fees for the 24 processing of any such application. 25 5. Upon request, the City shall, within a reasonable amount of time after such 26 request, provide the applicant with the cost basis for any fee charged by the City for a 27 standard process project. 28 D. Fees for Standard Process Projects. Each application for a wireless support 29 structure, wireless facility, or base station that constitutes a standard process project shall be 30 accompanied by payment of the following fees for the processing of the application: 19 1 1. For an application for a standard process project that requires the approval 2 of a conditional use permit and a site plan, the initial fee shall be $900. 3 2. For an application for a standard process project that requires the approval 4 of a site plan, but not a conditional use permit, the initial fee shall be $500. 5 3. The City reserves the right to employ an outside consultant to assist in the 6 review of any application for a standard process project. In the event the City employs an 7 outside consultant to review an application for a standard process project, the applicant 8 shall reimburse the City for the reasonable expenses related to such review as an 9 additional application fee, provided, however, that the fee limitations set forth in § 35.2– 10 73.6(C) (Fee Limitations for Standard Process Projects) shall apply to the calculation of 11 any such additional fee. 12 4. For any standard process project that requires the approval of a conditional 13 use permit, the applicant shall be responsible for the payment of any costs for any legal 14 notices that may be required for the conditional use permit. 15 E. Processing Applications for Standard Process Projects. The following 16 provisions set forth the process that shall apply to any application for a standard process project: 17 1. Prior to accepting any application for a wireless support structure, a 18 wireless facility, or a base station, that constitutes a standard process project, the City 19 shall first determine that the application includes the applicant’s electronic mail address. 20 In the event the application does not include the applicant’s electronic mail address, the 21 City shall not accept it for filing 22 2. If the application is incomplete, but includes an electronic mail address for 23 the applicant, then within ten (10) business days after actual receipt of the application, the 24 City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail if the application is incomplete and shall 25 specify in that notification any additional information, documents, and materials required 26 to complete the application. 27 3. If the application is incomplete and does not include a valid electronic 28 mail address for the applicant when it was filed, the City shall use reasonable means to 29 contact the applicant and request the applicant’s valid electronic mail address. Within ten 30 (10) days after actual receipt of a valid electronic mail address for the applicant, the City 31 shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall 32 specify any additional information, documents, and materials required to complete the 33 application. 34 4. If an incomplete initial or resubmitted application is filed for a standard 35 process project, then the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the 20 1 application is incomplete and shall specify any missing information, documents, and 2 materials in accordance with the following: 3 (a) for an initial application, the City shall notify the applicant by 4 electronic mail within ten (10) business days after the application is submitted 5 whether the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any 6 missing information, documents, and materials; otherwise, the application will be 7 deemed complete; and 8 (b) for a resubmitted application, the City shall notify the applicant by 9 electronic mail within ten (10) days after the application is resubmitted whether 10 the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing 11 information, documents and materials; otherwise, the application will be deemed 12 complete. 13 5. If the City fails to timely provide the applicant with notice that the initial 14 application or a resubmitted application is incomplete in accordance with the foregoing 15 provisions, as applicable, the application shall be deemed complete. 16 6. Except as provided for in subsection 7 below, the City shall approve or 17 disapprove a complete application for a standard process project in accordance with the 18 following: 19 (a) For a new structure, within the lesser of 150 days after receipt of 20 the completed application minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the 21 application to the date any notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the 22 City ; 23 (b) For the modification of an existing wireless support structure or 24 base station that involves the co-location of new transmission equipment, the removal of 25 transmission equipment, or the replacement of transmission equipment, but does not 26 substantially change, as that term is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of 27 such support structure or base station, within 60 days after receipt of the application 28 provided, however, that this period shall be tolled during any time after which the 29 applicant has been informed that the application is not complete and is provided with the 30 grounds for its incompleteness by the City, and when the applicant files all requested 31 information and items necessary to make the application complete; 32 (c) For the co-location on an existing wireless support structure of any 33 wireless facility that is not a small cell facility and substantially changes, as that term is 34 defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or any related 35 base station, within the lesser of 90 days after receipt by the City of the completed 21 1 application minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the 2 date any notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City; and 3 (d) For any standard process project that is not a small cell facility on 4 a new structure, within the lesser of 150 days after receipt of a completed application 5 minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the date any 6 notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City . 7 7. Any period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above within 8 which the City must approve or disapprove an application may be extended by written 9 agreement of the applicant and the City. 10 8. A complete application for a standard process project shall be deemed 11 approved if the City fails to approve or disapprove such application within the applicable 12 period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above or any agreed extension 13 thereof pursuant to subsection 7 above. 14 9. If the City disapproves an application for a standard process project: 15 (a) the City shall provide the applicant with a written statement listing 16 all of the reasons for the disapproval; and 17 (b) if the City is aware of any modifications to the project as described 18 in the application that if made would permit the City to approve the proposed 19 project, the City shall identify them in the written statement provided under 20 subsection 6(a) above. The City’s subsequent disapproval of an application for a 21 project that incorporates the modifications identified in such a written statement 22 may be used by the applicant as evidence that the City’s subsequent disapproval 23 was arbitrary or capricious in any appeal of the City’s subsequent disapproval. 24 10. If an application for a standard process project is disapproved, the City’s 25 disapproval shall: 26 (a) not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other 27 wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications 28 services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services; and. 29 (b) be supported by substantial record evidence contained in a written 30 record publicly released within 30 days following the disapproval. 22 1 F. Limitations on Disapprovals of Standard Process Projects. Whenever the City 2 receives, considers, and processes a complete application for a standard process project, it shall 3 not disapprove any such application on the basis of: 4 (a) the applicant’s business decision with respect to its designed 5 service, customer demand, or quality of service to or from a particular site; 6 (b) the applicant’s specific need for the project, including the 7 applicant’s desire to provide additional wireless coverage or capacity; or 8 9 the project. (c) the wireless facility technology selected by the applicant for use at 10 G. Disapproval Considerations for Standard Process Projects. Nothing in this 11 Ordinance shall be construed to prohibit the City from disapproving an application for a standard 12 process project: 13 1. On the basis of the fact that the proposed height of any wireless support 14 structure, wireless facility, or wireless support structure with attached wireless facilities exceeds 15 50 feet above ground level, provided that the City follows a local ordinance or regulation that 16 does not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, 17 wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services , and other providers 18 of functionally equivalent services; or 19 2. That proposes to locate a new structure, or to co-locate a wireless facility 20 in an area where all cable and public utility facilities are required to be placed 21 underground by a date certain or encouraged to be undergrounded as part of a 22 transportation improvement project or rezoning proceeding as set forth in objectives 23 contained in a comprehensive plan, if: 24 (a) The undergrounding requirement or comprehensive plan objective 25 existed at least three months prior to the submission of the application; 26 (b) The City allows the co-location of wireless facilities on existing 27 utility poles, government-owned structures with the government’s consent, 28 existing wireless support structures, or a building within that area; 29 (c) The City allows the replacement of existing utility poles and 30 wireless support structures with poles or support structures of the same size or 31 similar within that area; and 23 1 (d) The disapproval of the application does not unreasonably 2 discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless 3 infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services, and other 4 providers of functionally equivalent services, and other providers of functionally 5 equivalent services. 6 H. Disapproval Limitation If Standard Process Project Does not Substantially 7 Change Physical Dimensions. The City may not deny, and shall approve, within sixty (60) days, 8 any standard process project which requests any modification of an existing base station or 9 wireless support structure that does not substantially change, as that term is defined by federal 10 law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or base station and that involves the co- 11 location of new transmission equipment, the removal of transmission equipment, or the 12 replacement of transmission equipment. 13 I. Disapproval Allowed If Written Notice Not Provided to Adjacent Property 14 Owners. The City may disapprove an application for a standard process project if the applicant 15 has not given written notice to all adjacent property owners at least 15 days before the applicant 16 applies to locate a new structure on the subject property. 17 § 35.2–73.7 Permitted Uses. 18 A. The following uses shall be permitted by right as follows: 19 1. Small cell facilities in all zoning districts. 20 2. Administrative review-eligible projects in all zoning districts. 21 3. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility that does not 22 exceed one hundred (100) feet in height in the B–1 District. 23 4. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility that does not 24 exceed one hundred and fifty (150) feet in height in the B–3, B–5, IN–2, 25 I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts. 26 5. Any base station associated with a lawfully existing wireless support 27 structure and/or wireless facility, provided, however, that: 28 (a) the base station shall be located inside the wireless support 29 structure; or 30 (b) the base station shall be located on the ground within 50 feet of the 31 base of the wireless support structure; or 24 1 (c) the base station is not visible at ground level from off-site; and 2 (d) the size of the base station shall not exceed seventy-two (72) cubic 3 feet in size and/or six (6) feet in height; and 4 (e) all applicable setbacks shall be complied with. 5 6. The co-location of a wireless facility on a lawfully existing wireless 6 support structure in any zoning district, provided, however, that: 7 (a) the height of any such wireless support structure, wireless facility, 8 or wireless support structure with wireless facility attached, shall not increase as a result 9 of the co-location; and 10 (b) all applicable setbacks must be complied with. 11 B. Existing wireless support structures and wireless facilities shall be exempt from 12 the maximum height restrictions of the districts in which they are located to the extent such 13 structures and facilities lawfully existed on the date of adoption of this Ordinance. 14 § 35.2-73.8 Conditional Use Permit Required. 15 A. The following uses require the approval of a conditional use permit by the City 16 Council: 17 1. In the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 Districts, any standard 18 process project that is between fifty (50) and one hundred and fifty (150) feet in height, 19 provided, however, that no new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in such 20 districts shall exceed 150 feet in height; 21 2. In the B–1 District, any standard process project in which a new wireless 22 support structure and/or wireless facility exceeds one hundred (100) feet in height; 23 provided, however, that the maximum height for any wireless facility and/or wireless 24 support structure in the B–1 District shall be 150 feet; 25 3. In the B–3, B–5, IN–2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts, any standard process 26 project in which a new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility exceeds one 27 hundred fifty (150) feet in height; 28 4. Any base station that is a standard process project and exceeds seventy- 29 two cubic feet above ground and/or six feet in height; 25 1 5. Any base station associated with a lawfully existing wireless support 2 structure and/or wireless facility that is a standard process project, is not located inside 3 the wireless support structure, is visible at ground level from off-site, and/or is not 4 located within 50 feet of the base of the wireless support structure; 5 6. The co-location of a wireless facility on a lawfully existing wireless 6 support structure in any zoning district that, after the proposed co-location, would result 7 in an increase in height of the wireless support structure and/or wireless facility, 8 provided, however, that no such structure and/or facility shall be allowed to increase 9 more than fifteen (15) feet in height as a result of the approval of such a conditional use 10 permit; and 11 7. Any other project that constitutes a standard process project. 12 B. Whenever a conditional use permit is required for a proposed wireless structure or 13 wireless facility, any application for such a conditional use permit shall be made to the City 14 Planner in the manner provided in Article 2 of this Zoning Ordinance. In districts for which a 15 conditional use permit is required, the City Council shall make its decision to approve or deny 16 such permit in writing and in a manner consistent with applicable state and federal law. 17 C. Any wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station that is not 18 permitted by right or upon the approval of a conditional use permit under this Ordinance shall be 19 considered to be in violation of this Ordinance. 20 D. No new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility for which a conditional 21 use permit is approved shall exceed a maximum height of one hundred fifty (150) feet in 22 the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 Districts. 23 35.2-73.9 Setbacks. 24 A. There shall be no setback requirement for any wireless support structure and/or 25 wireless facility that is thirty-five (35) feet or less in height. 26 B. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility greater than thirty-five (35) 27 feet in height in the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 Districts shall be required to set 28 back a distance from all property lines at least the height of such structure and/or facility. 29 C. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility greater than thirty-five (35) 30 feet in height in the B–1, B–3, B–5, IN–2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts that is on a parcel adjacent to 31 any parcel that is zoned R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 shall be set back a distance at 32 least the height of such structure and/or facility from the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B– 33 4 District. 26 1 D. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in the B–1, B–3, B–5, IN– 2 2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts that is greater than thirty-five (35) feet in height but less than fifty 3 (50) feet in height shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the 4 minimum applicable setback for the district in which it is located. 5 E. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in the B–1, B–3, B–5, IN– 6 2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts that is a height greater than fifty (50) feet shall be required to set 7 back a distance from all property lines at least one-half the height of such structure and/or 8 facility. 9 F. Setback requirements for wireless support structures and/or wireless facilities 10 shall be measured from the base of the structure and/or facility to the property lines of the parcel 11 on which the structure and/or facility is located. 12 §35.2-73.10 Standards for Conditional Use Permits for Standard Process Projects. 13 In order to approve a conditional use permit for a standard process project, the City 14 Council must find that the application for such project satisfies all of the following standards: 15 1. The proposed use is in substantial conformance with the provisions of the 16 City’s Comprehensive Plan. 17 2. The proposed use will not result in any significant adverse impact on the 18 use and enjoyment of nearby properties. 19 3. The proposed use will not have any significant negative impact on the 20 value of nearby properties. 21 4. The proposed use will not cause any material potential interference with 22 other pre-existing communications facilities or with future communications facilities that 23 have already been planned or designed for a specific location or that have been reserved 24 for future public safety communications facilities. 25 5. The proposed use will not result in any significant adverse impact on 26 public safety or other critical public service needs. 27 6. The proposed use must be compatible with the character of the area in 28 which it is proposed to be located. 29 7. There are no existing wireless support structures within a reasonable 30 distance from the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base 27 1 station that are available to be used for co-location at reasonable terms and conditions 2 without imposing technical limitations on the applicant. 3 8. The proposed use shall not conflict with any City ordinance adopted 4 pursuant to Code of Virginia § 15.2-2306, or pursuant to local charter on a historic 5 property that is not eligible for the review process established under 54 U.S.C. § 306108. 6 9. The proposed use satisfies all other applicable requirements set forth in 7 this chapter with respect to the location, size, design, and construction of wireless support 8 structures, wireless facilities, and base stations. 9 §35.2-73.11 Use of City-Owned Property for Wireless Facilities. 10 The City may authorize the use of City property for wireless facilities in appropriately 11 zoned districts in accordance with the procedures of the City charter and code. The City shall 12 have no obligation whatsoever to allow the use of City property for such purposes and any such 13 approval by the City shall be subject to the discretion of the City Council. 14 §35.2–73.12 Co-Location Availability. 15 An application for a standard process project may be disapproved by the City on 16 the basis of the availability of the existence of one or more wireless support structures within a 17 reasonable distance that could be used for co-location at reasonable terms and conditions without 18 imposing technical limitations on the applicant. 19 § 35.2–73.13 Interference With Public Safety Radio Services. 20 In order to ensure that the City’s public safety radio services will be free from 21 harmful or destructive interference, all applicants requesting a permit to establish or install a 22 wireless support structure or wireless facility shall: 23 A. Demonstrate compliance with good engineering practices; 24 B. Not cause material potential interference to the City’s existing 25 public safety radio services or to future communications facilities 26 that have already been designed and planned for a specific location 27 or that have been reserved for future public safety communications 28 facilities; and 29 C. Comply with all FCC regulations regarding susceptibility to radio 30 frequency interference, frequency coordination requirements, 31 general technical standards for power, antenna bandwidth 28 1 limitations, frequency stability, transmitter measurements, 2 operating requirements, and any and all other federal statutory and 3 regulatory requirements relating to radio frequency interference 4 (RFI), provided, however, that this subparagraph (C) shall not 5 apply to applications for small cell facilities. 6 § 35.2-73.14 Structural Requirements. 7 All wireless support structures and wireless facilities must be designed and certified by a 8 structural engineer licensed in the Commonwealth of Virginia to be structurally sound 9 and, at a minimum, in conformance with the Virginia Uniform Statewide Building Code 10 and any other applicable standards set forth in this chapter. 11 § 35.2-73.15 Method of Determining Height of A Wireless Support Structure. 12 Measurement of the height of a wireless support structure for the purpose of determining 13 compliance with all requirements of this chapter shall include the wireless support structure itself 14 and any wireless facilities associated with the wireless support structure, and any other support 15 features installed thereon which extend over the top of the structure itself. Structure height shall 16 be measured from grade. 17 § 35.2-73.16 Illumination. 18 Wireless support structures whose principal use is the facilitation of wireless 19 telecommunications shall not be artificially lighted except as may be required by the FAA. 20 § 35.2–73.17 Exterior Finish. 21 Wireless support structures and wireless facilities not requiring painting or marking by 22 the FAA shall be painted a neutral color. A galvanized finish is considered a neutral color. 23 § 35.2–73.18 Landscaping. 24 All landscaping on parcels containing wireless support structures, wireless facilities, 25 and/or base stations shall be designed to screen the structure, facilities, base station, and related 26 equipment to a height of at least six (6) feet from grade. This requirement may be waived at the 27 discretion of the planning division if the base of the structure, facilities, base station, and related 28 equipment to be screened is not located in and is not visible from any commercial or residential 29 district or from any public street. All required landscaping shall be continually maintained in a 30 healthy and attractive manner. 31 29 1 § 35.2-73.19 Security. 2 All wireless support structures and wireless facilities shall be reasonably posted and 3 secured to prevent against trespass. 4 § 35.2–73.20 Access. 5 All parcels upon which wireless support structures are located must provide access during 6 normal business hours to at least one (1) paved vehicular parking space on site. 7 § 35.2–73.21 Maintenance. 8 A. The owners and operators of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, 9 base stations, and related equipment shall at all times employ ordinary and reasonable care in 10 maintaining such structures, facilities, base stations, and equipment and shall install and maintain 11 in use nothing less than commonly accepted methods and devices for the prevention of failures 12 and accidents which are likely to cause damage, injuries, or nuisances to the public, provided, 13 however, that no zoning approval of the City shall be required for routine maintenance of any 14 existing wireless support structure or wireless facility. 15 B. The owners and operators of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, 16 and base stations shall at all times employ ordinary and reasonable care and shall install and 17 maintain such wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and equipment in 18 substantial compliance with the requirements of the national electric safety code and all federal, 19 state, and local regulations and in such manner that will not interfere with the use and enjoyment 20 of other property. 21 C. All wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related 22 equipment shall at all times be kept and maintained in good condition, order, and repair so that 23 the same shall not menace or endanger the life or property of any person. 24 D. All wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related 25 equipment shall be maintained in compliance with any applicable radio frequency emission 26 standards of the FCC. 27 E. In the event the use of any wireless support structure, wireless facility, base 28 station, and related equipment is discontinued by the owner or operator thereof, or in the event 29 the owner or operator thereof files notice with the FCC or any other federal agency of its interest 30 in ceasing to operate any wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related 31 equipment, said owner or operator shall, within thirty (30) days, provide written notice to the 32 City of its intent to discontinue such use and the date when such use shall be discontinued. If the 33 facility in question, or any part thereof, is located within the City’s right-of-way, then the owner 30 1 or operator shall submit the foregoing written notice to the Department of Public Works. If the 2 facility in question, or any part thereof, is located outside the City’s right-of-way, then the owner 3 or operator shall submit the foregoing written notice to the Department of Community 4 Development. 5 § 35.2–73.22 Stealth. 6 The City encourages, but does not require, the installation of small cell facilities and 7 administrative review-eligible projects that employ stealth designs and blend into the 8 environments in which they are proposed to be located. All standard process projects proposing 9 wireless support structures and wireless facilities shall be of stealth design. For purposes of this 10 section, the term “stealth design” refers to a wireless support structure and wireless facility that is 11 designed in such a way as to effectively blend into the environment in which that structure is 12 proposed to be located. Examples of stealth designs include, but are not limited to, a wireless 13 support structure in a wooded area that is designed to look like a tree, a wireless facility that is 14 encased in a flagpole, a wireless support structure on a church property that is designed to look 15 like a bell tower or church steeple, and a wireless support structure in an agricultural area that is 16 designed to look like a farm silo. 17 § 35.2-73.23 Existing Wireless Support Structures. 18 A. An existing wireless support structure may be modified or demolished and rebuilt 19 to accommodate the co-location of additional wireless facilities and base stations as follows: 20 1. Application for a permit for any wireless facility or base station, other than 21 a small cell facility, located, in whole or in part, within the City’s right-of-way shall be made to 22 the Department of Public Works. 23 2. Application for a permit for any wireless facility or base station located, in 24 whole or in part, outside the City’s right-of-way shall be made to the Department of Community 25 Development. 26 3. The total height of the new or modified wireless support structure and any 27 wireless facilities installed thereon shall not exceed the height of the existing wireless 28 support structure or the maximum height allowed for wireless support structures 29 permitted by right in the applicable zoning district under this ordinance whichever is 30 greater. 31 B. The City may not deny and shall approve any request to modify the physical 32 dimensions of an existing wireless tower or base station if that request does not substantially 33 increase the physical dimensions of such tower or base station and involves: 31 1 (1) co-location of new transmission equipment; 2 (2) removal of transmission equipment; or 3 (3) replacement of transmission equipment. 4 § 35.2–73.24 Abandonment. 5 If the City receives notice pursuant to § 35.2-73.21(E), or if any wireless support structure, 6 wireless facility, base station, and/or related equipment shall cease to be used for a period of 7 one hundred eighty (180) consecutive days, then for wireless support structures, wireless 8 facilities, base stations and/or related equipment inside the City’s right-of-way, the 9 Department of Public Works shall notify the owner and/or operator of such structure, 10 facility, base station, and related equipment, with a copy to the applicant therefor, that the 11 site will be subject to a determination by the Department of Public Works that such site has 12 been abandoned. In the event such structure, facility, base station, and related equipment is 13 located outside the City’s right-of-way, then the foregoing notification and determination 14 shall be made by the Department of Community Development. The owner, operator, and/or 15 applicant shall have thirty (30) days from receipt of said notice to show, by a preponderance 16 of the evidence, that the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and/or related 17 equipment has been in use or under repair during the period. If the owner, operator, and/or 18 applicant fails to show that the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and/or 19 related equipment has been in use or under repair during the period, the Department of 20 Public Works, or Department of Community Development, whichever applies, ashall issue a 21 final determination of abandonment for the site. Upon issuance of the City’s final 22 determination, the owner, operator, and/or applicant shall, within seventy-five (75) days, 23 dismantle and remove the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related 24 equipment. If the owner, operator, and/or applicant fails to remove the abandoned support 25 structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment within seventy-five (75) days 26 after the City’s final determination of abandonment, the City and/or its agents may, at its 27 option, enter upon the property and dismantle, remove, and lawfully dispose of the support 28 structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment that has been determined by 29 the City to have been abandoned. The City may place a lien on the property of the owner 30 from which the abandoned support structure, wireless facility, base station, or related 31 equipment was removed in the amount of the City’s expenses in dismantling, removing, and 32 lawfully disposing of such support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related 33 equipment. The City also may recover from the owner, operator, and/or applicant the costs 34 of dismantling, removing, and lawfully disposing of the support structure, wireless facility, 35 base station, and related equipment from the owner. For purposes of this section, removal 36 includes all physical improvements associated with the support structure, wireless facility, 37 base station, and related equipment, including foundation and tower grounding. 38 § 35.2–73.25 Miscellaneous Provisions. 32 1 A. Voluntary Conditions Allowed. Nothing in this Ordinance shall prohibit an 2 applicant from voluntarily submitting, and the City from accepting, any 3 conditions that otherwise address potential visual or aesthetic effects resulting 4 from the placement of any new structure or wireless facility, including small cell 5 facility. 6 B. Micro-Wireless Facilities Exemption. Nothing in this Ordinance shall be 7 construed to require any permitting requirements and fees imposed by the City for 8 the installation, placement, maintenance, or replacement of micro-wireless 9 facilities that are suspended on cables or lines that are strung between existing 10 utility poles in compliance with national safety codes, because the installation, 11 placement, maintenance, or replacement of such facilities are exempt from any 12 City-imposed permitting requirements and fees. 13 C. Limitations on Review of Administrative Review-Eligible Projects and Standard 14 Process Projects. Whenever the City receives, considers, and processes an 15 application for an administrative review-eligible project or a standard process 16 project, it shall not: 17 1. Discriminate or create a preference on the basis of the ownership by the 18 City, of any property, structure, base station, or wireless support structure 19 when promulgating rules or procedures for siting wireless facilities or for 20 evaluating applications; 21 2. Impose any unreasonable requirements or obligations regarding the 22 presentation or appearance of a project, including unreasonable 23 requirements relating to (i) the kinds of materials used or (ii) the 24 arranging, screening, or landscaping of wireless facilities or wireless 25 structures; 26 3. Impose any requirement that an applicant purchase, subscribe to, use, or 27 employ facilities, networks, or services owned, provided, or operated by 28 the City, in whole or in part, by the City or by any other entity in which 29 the City has a competitive, economic, financial, governance, or other 30 interest; 31 4. Condition or require the approval of an application solely on the basis of 32 the applicant’s agreement to allow any wireless facilities provided or 33 operated, in whole or in part, by the City, or by any other entity, to be 34 placed at or co-located with the applicant’s project; 33 1 5. Impose a setback or fall zone requirement for a project that is larger than a 2 setback or fall zone area that is imposed on other types of similar 3 structures of a similar size, including utility poles; 4 6. Limit the duration of the approval of an application, except the City may 5 require that construction of the approved project shall commence within 6 two years after final approval and be diligently pursued to completion; and 7 7. Require an applicant to perform services unrelated to the project described 8 in the application, including restoration work on any surface not disturbed 9 by the applicant’s project. 10 D. Nothing in this chapter shall prohibit the City from disapproving an application 11 submitted under a standard process project on the basis of availability of existing 12 wireless support structures within a reasonable distance that could be used for co- 13 location at reasonable terms and conditions without imposing technical limitations 14 on the applicant. 15 E. No zoning approval shall be required for (i) routine maintenance or (ii) the 16 replacement of wireless facilities or wireless support structures within a six-foot 17 perimeter with wireless facilities or wireless support structures that are 18 substantially similar or smaller; provided, however, that the City may require a 19 permit to work within the right-of-way for the activities described in clause (i) or 20 (ii), if applicable. 21 F. Nothing in this chapter shall prohibit the City from limiting the number of new 22 structures or the number of wireless facilities that can be installed in a specific 23 location. 24 G. Nothing in this chapter shall be construed to require an applicant to provide 25 proprietary, confidential, or other business information to justify the need for a 26 project, including propagation maps and telecommunications traffic studies, or 27 information reviewed by a federal agency as part of the approval process for the 28 same structure and wireless facility 29 H. All information submitted with an application that is a trade secret or proprietary 30 shall be clearly marked as such when submitted to the City. The City shall not 31 disclose publicly, or to any third party, any such proprietary information unless 32 compelled to do so by federal, state, or local law. 33 § 35.2–73.26 Reservation of Rights. 34 1 The City reserves the right to impose any other reasonable conditions it determines are necessary 2 for the proper placement, construction, or modification of wireless support structures, wireless 3 facilities, or base stations and/or to impose any other reasonable conditions on the issuance of a 4 conditional use permit for the placement or construction of, or modification to, a wireless support 5 structure, wireless facility, or base station, provided, however, that the imposition of any such 6 conditions must be in conformance with federal and state law and the provisions of this chapter. 7 This ordinance shall become effective upon adoption. 8 9 PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING: xxxx xx, 2020 10 CITY COUNCIL PUBLIC HEARING: 11 12 ENACTED: 13 14 ATTEST: 15 16 17 City Clerk 18 19 Telecommunications Ordinance J. Patrick Taves Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC Tom Martin, AICP City Planner Planning Commission Public Hearing December 9, 2020 Purpose and Outline Purpose: Discuss the proposed Telecommunications Ordinance Outline: 1. State and Federal mandates 2. Types of facilities – Small Cell, AREP, Standard Process Projects 3. Timelines for review 4. Where permitted - Height 5. Setbacks 2 Proposed regulations depend on the size of the facility. Three Types of Cell Facilities: • SMALL CELL FACILITIES: no more than 6 cu. ft. of volume for each antenna and no more than 28 cu. ft. of volume for all other wireless equipment • ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW ELIGIBLE PROJECTS (“AREPs”): not more than 50 ft. in height or co- location on any existing structure of a facility that is not a small cell facility • STANDARD PROCESS PROJECTS: any project that is not an AREP 3 Different Rules for Each Type of Facility. • Deadlines for Completeness of Applications---applications can be “deemed complete” • Fee Limitations • Deadlines for Decisions---applications can be “deemed approved” • Limited Grounds for Disapprovals • Different Rules for Different Facilities 4 Small Cell Facilities in the City’s Rights-of-Way and on City Property • Regulated by the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance (City Code Sections 35-28, 25-28.1, 35-28.2, 35-28.3, 35-28.4, 35-28.5, 35-28.6, and 35-28.7). • The New Telecommunications Ordinance provisions do not apply to these facilities. 5 Small Cell Facilities---Limited Reasons for Disapproval City can disapprove on existing structures for only four reasons: 1. Material potential interference with existing or future facilities designed and planned for a specific location or reserved for public safety communications 2. Safety of the public or other critical public service needs 3. Aesthetic impact, but only on publicly owned or publicly controlled property---but if the City owns the property or the structure, then the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance controls 4. Conflict with a historic district ordinance, but only if that property is not eligible for a specified federal review process 6 Permitted Uses: • All Small Cell Facilities in all districts---CUPs cannot be required • All AREPs in all districts (50 feet or less in height)---CUPs cannot be required • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-1 District 100 feet or less • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts 150 feet or less • Any base station for a lawfully existing wireless facility or structure meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure meeting specified requirements 7 Conditional Use Permits Can Only Be Required For Standard Process Projects: • Standard Process Projects between 50 and 150 feet in height in the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1, and B-4 Districts • Standard Process Projects that exceed 100 feet in height in the B-1 District, but no greater than 150 feet • Standard Process Projects that exceed 150 feet in height in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts • Standard process project base stations meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure that increases the height of the facility, but any height increase is limited to no more than 15 feet • Any other standard process project 8 Standards for CUP’s – Standard Process Projects Only: • Substantial conformance with the Comprehensive Plan • No significant adverse impact on use and enjoyment of nearby properties • No significant negative impact on property values • No material potential interference with pre-existing facilities or for future planned facilities planned or designed for a specific location or any reserved for future public safety facilities* • No significant adverse impact on public safety or public service needs* • No available and existing wireless support structures nearby • Not in conflict with the City historic district ordinance* • Satisfies all other applicable requirements 9 Setbacks for Similar Structures: • Virginia law provides that the City cannot impose a setback or fall zone requirement that is larger than the setback or fall zone requirement “that is imposed on other types of similar structures of a similar size, including utility poles. • As a result, we propose establishing setbacks for wireless support structures that provide the same setbacks for wireless support structures as are applied to light poles, utility poles, and flag poles of a similar size. 10 Separate Amendment for Setbacks for Similar Structures: • No setback for flag poles, light poles or utility poles (“poles”) that are less than 35’ in height. • Poles greater than 35’ in height set back at a 1:1 in R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3. R-4, IN-1 or B-4 Districts. • Poles greater than 35’ in height in B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District and adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, IN-1 or B-4 District set back at 1:1 • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District between 35’ and 50’ must meet underlying district setback • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District greater than 50’ set back at least ½ the height of the pole. 11 Discussion: Discussion 12 To: Planning Commission From: Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner CC: Reid Woodicka, Interim City Manager, Kent White, Interim Deputy City Manager, Walter Erwin, City Attorney, Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator Date: November 11, 2020 Re: Telecommunications Ordinance Revisions – Work Session The City’s Telecommunications Ordinance was last updated December 1997 with minor amendments in January 2000. The current ordinance is no longer compliant with State or Federal Laws. The proposed Telecommunications Ordinance was drafted with the assistance of J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandek, PLLC. Mr. Taves will be in attendance at the November 11, 2020 Planning Commission work session to discuss the proposed amendments to the Telecommunications Ordinance. If you have questions, please contact me at (434) 455-3909 or tom.martin@lynchburgva.gov. Attachments: • Telecommunications Ordinance Slides • Draft Telecommunications Ordinance • Draft Revisions to Section 35.2-61.2 Telecommunications Ordinance J. Patrick Taves Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC Tom Martin, AICP City Planner Planning Commission Work Session November 11, 2020 Purpose and Outline Purpose: Discuss required updates to the Telecommunications Ordinance Outline: 1. Reasons for updates 2. Types of facilities – Small Cell, AREP, Standard Process Projects 3. Timelines for review 4. Where permitted - Height 5. Setbacks 2 Why does the City need a new Telecommunications Ordinance? • Last overhaul of the City’s Telecommunications Ordinance was in December 1997 with minor amendments in January 2000 • Amendments to the Virginia Code in 2017, 2018, and 2020 regarding telecom facilities---new terminology and rules. • Federal law on telecom facilities is evolving. 3 What are some of the changes that are needed? Three Types of Cell Facilities: • Small cell facilities • Administrative review-eligible projects (“AREPs”) • Standard process projects 4 Other Changes • Deadlines for Completeness of Applications • Fee Limitations • Deadlines for Decisions • Different Rules for Different Facilities 5 Small Cell Facilities**: • “. . . A wireless facility that meets both of the following qualifications: (i) each antenna is located inside an enclosure of no more than six cubic feet in volume, or, in the case of an antenna that has exposed elements, the antenna and all its exposed elements could fit within an imaginary enclosure of no more than six cubic feet and (ii) all other wireless equipment associated with the facility that has a cumulative volume of no more than 28 cubic feet, or such higher limit as is established by the Federal Communications Commission. 6 Small Cell Facilities May be Larger Than You Think: Associated equipment does not include: • electric meter • concealment • telecommunications demarcation boxes • back-up power systems • grounding equipment • power transfer switches • cut-off switches • vertical cable runs for the connection of power and other services So it could really be more than 28 cubic feet! 7 ** Really Sm

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.