RecordWell Data

City Council Work Session and Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Jan 12, 2021 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL PHYSICAL DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE Tuesday, January 12, 2021 8:00 a.m. Information Items: Recent/Pending Contract Awards: N/A - Presented by Lee Newland Priority Projects Update: Attached - Presented by Lee Newland General Business: 1. Advantage Court ROW Vacation: - Presented by Victoria Glasgow 2. Chiles Circle ROW Vacation: - Presented by Victoria Glasgow Roll Call: Pc: City Council Reid Wodicka, Interim City Manager Kent White, Interim Deputy City Manager/Director of Community Development John Hughes, Assistant City Manager Gaynelle Hart, Director of Public Works Next Meeting: February 9, 2021 Projects of Interest Phase Phase Completion Sch BudNotes Main Street Renewal Project Construction November 2021 Construction Underway Lakeside Drive Bridge Over Blackwater - Design-Build Design / Construction June 2023 Construction Underway CSO - Wastewater Treatment Plant Project Construction January 2021 On-Going Link Road Bridge Construction September 2021 Construction Underway One Way Pairs @ 501/221 Design December 2021 Reviewing 60% Plans - Discussing Scheduling a Public Meeting Downtown Watermain Replacement & Streetscape 2 Design May 2021 Design @ 90%. Design Being Completed Police Department Headquarters Pre-Design September 2020 Complete - Currently Reviewing Budget Estimates, Conceptual Designs & Other Design Options Fifth Street Phase 4 Design October 2021 Design Plans Underway Schedule - Green ● 0-5% Behind Budget - Green ● 0-10% Over Yellow ● 5-10% Behind Yellow ● 10-20% Over Red ● > 10% Behind Red ● > 20% Over V V VDOT Managed V V VDOT Managed Lynchburg Capital Projects Greater Than $1 Million (General Fund) January 12, 2021 LEGEND 1 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: January 12, 2021 – Physical Development Committee AGENDA ITEM #: CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Vacate Advantage Court KEY ELEMENTS: _ _Economic Development ___Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _ Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the right-of-way vacation of Advantage Court. SUMMARY: Ed Willman, on behalf of O Mayflower, LLC, is petitioning to vacate the Advantage Court right-of- way located off of Chiles Circle. The right-of-way vacation would facilitate the future development of the adjacent property for industrial use. The total area of the proposed vacation is approximately nine hundred seventy-nine thousandths (0.979) of an acre. The area to be vacated includes an unpaved gravel drive. The vacation would not impact vehicle or pedestrian access along Advantage Court or Chiles Circle. PRIOR ACTION(S): November 3, 2020: The Technical Review Committee (TRC) reviewed the petition. FISCAL IMPACT: Based on the zoning of the adjacent lots and property frontage, the value of the property is anticipated to be approximately $9,790. CONTACT(S): Victoria Glasgow, Neighborhood Planning Coordinator – 455-3900 Tom Martin, City Planner – 455-3900 ATTACHMENT(S): o Ordinance o Application o Plat o Title Work REVIEWED BY: klw UNCODIFIED ORDINANCE: AN ORDINANCE VACATING RIGHT-OF-WAY KNOWN AS ADVANTAGE COURT. WHEREAS, Ed Willman, on behalf of O Mayflower, LLC, is petitioning to vacate right-of-way known as Advantage Court; and WHEREAS, City Council finds that no public inconvenience will result from vacating the right of way; and WHEREAS, City Council determined that the City has no need for the portion of public right-of-way in question and the City’s continued ownership of such public right-of-way is not necessary or required to serve the best interest of the City; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Lynchburg, on its own motion, and in accordance with the provisions of Section 15.2-2006 of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, and Sections 35-71 through 35-77 of the City Code, 1981, as amended, the following described right of way be, and the same hereby is, discontinued and vacated, namely: BEGINNING AT THE POINT OF BEGINNING, A 1/2” REBAR SET AT THE INTERSECTION OF THE SOUTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF CHILES CIRCLE AND THE WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF ADVANTAGE COURT; THENCE S 53°43'43" E A DISTANCE OF 150.14' TO A STAKE FOUND; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 50.03', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 81.02', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 72.45', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF S 79°53'36" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 92°46'53",TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A COMPOUND CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 696.82', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 137.72', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 137.50', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF S 27°51'13" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 11°19'27",TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A COMPOUND CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 700.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 116.61', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 116.47', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF S 17°27'29" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 09°32'40",TO A POINT; THENCE S 12°41'10" W A DISTANCE OF 217.71' TO A POINT; THENCE S 12°41'10" W A DISTANCE OF 34.23' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 70.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 322.39', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 104.14', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 35°22'24" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 263°52'52",TO A POINT; THENCE S 82°34'46" E A DISTANCE OF 2.09' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 27.50', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 41.08', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 37.36', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 55°28'53" E, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 85°34'52",TO A POINT; THENCE N 12°41'10" E A DISTANCE OF 154.73' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 750.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 279.32', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 277.71', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 23°21'19" E, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 21°20'18",TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A REVERSE CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 50.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 76.57', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 69.30', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 09°50'45" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 87°44'25",TO A 1/2” REBAR SET; WHICH IS THE POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID PARCEL TO CONTAIN 0.979 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. Provided, however, that any easement to locate, relocate, repair, replace, maintain and perpetually operate all utilities currently located therein or needed by the City in the future is hereby reserved unto the City of Lynchburg and the construction of a permanent structure over any utility line without the prior written approval of the City is prohibited. BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED that the Clerk of Council is hereby authorized and directed to deliver a duly certified copy of this ordinance to the Clerk of the Circuit Court for the City of Lynchburg so that said certified copy of this ordinance may be recorded as deeds are recorded and indexed in the name of the City of Lynchburg, and the City Manager is hereby authorized to sign any documents that may be needed to complete the vacation of the right-of-way. Adopted: Certified: _____________________________ Clerk of Council SURVEYORS ENGINEERS SOIL EVALUATORS 434.610.43346200 FORT AVENUE | LYNCHBURG, VA 24502 www.accupointsurveying.com DBE# 723629 10/14/2020 Ms. Victoria Glasgow City Planning and Community Development 900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 Dear Ms. Glasgow and to whomever it may concern, Accupoint Surveying & Design undertook investigation of the title to an undeveloped and unimproved portion of Advantage Court, as It is the desire of our client, O’Mayflower, LLC to vacate the public interest in this land. A survey and dedication was filed and accepted in the clerk’s office of the circuit court of the City of Lynchburg entitled “Division of Property of CES Enterprises, Inc., by Hurt and Proffitt dated February 14, 2008” at Instrument number 080001820 and in Plat Cabinet 9, slide 159 and 160 [Exhibit A]. This survey establishes and clearly dedicates that portion of land within the right-of-way of Advantage Court as a street for public use. Please consider the following legislation. The General Assembly amended the 1888 Subdivision Act in 1928 to transfer in fee simple to the Commonwealth of Virginia that portion of land within the city limits set apart by subdivision plat for streets for public use. The current law under Virginia Code §15.2-2265 establishes that “the recordation of such [subdivision] plat shall operate to transfer, in fee simple, to the respective counties and municipalities in which the land lies such portion of the premises platted as is on such plat set apart for streets, alleys or other public use. ” In my opinion that the action of these case laws vest fee simple title to the land lying in the right-of-way of Advantage Court into the City of Lynchburg. Upon vacation of this right-of-way, Virginia Code § 15.2-2274 establishes reversion rights with respect to subdivision streets after sale of a lot to vest title to the abutting landowners to the centerline of the street, upholding the rule of common law. As O’Mayflower LLC owns all adjacent property to the right-of-way of Advantage Court, it is my opinion that title to that land lying within the right-of-way of Advantage Court would vest solely in O’Mayflower LLC upon vacation. Thank you for your consideration of this matter. Elizabeth M Davis Virginia Certified Title Examiner Accupoint Surveying & Design, LLC 1 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: January 12, 2021 – Physical Development Committee AGENDA ITEM #: CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Vacate a portion of Chiles Circle KEY ELEMENTS: _ _Economic Development ___Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _ Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the right-of-way vacation of a portion of Chiles Circle SUMMARY: Ed Willman, on behalf of O Mayflower, LLC, is petitioning to vacate a portion of Chiles Circle right-of-way, located off of Carroll Avenue and Chiles Circle. The right-of-way vacation would facilitate the future development of the adjacent property for industrial use. The total area of the proposed vacation is approximately two hundred eighty-seven thousandths (0.287) of an acre. The area to be vacated includes an unpaved gravel drive. The vacation would not impact vehicle or pedestrian access along Chiles Circle or Carroll Avenue. PRIOR ACTION(S): November 3, 2020: The Technical Review Committee (TRC) reviewed the petition. FISCAL IMPACT: Based on the zoning of the adjacent lots and property frontage, the value of the property is anticipated to be approximately $4,856. CONTACT(S): Victoria Glasgow, Neighborhood Planning Coordinator – 455-3900 Tom Martin, City Planner – 455-3900 ATTACHMENT(S): o Ordinance o Application o Plat o Title Work REVIEWED BY: klw UNCODIFIED ORDINANCE: AN ORDINANCE VACATING A PORTION OF RIGHT-OF-WAY KNOWN AS CHILES CIRCLE. WHEREAS, Ed Willman, on behalf of O Mayflower, LLC, is petitioning to vacate a portion of right-of-way known as Chiles Circle; and WHEREAS, City Council finds that no public inconvenience will result from vacating the right of way; and WHEREAS, City Council determined that the City has no need for the portion of public right-of-way in question and the City’s continued ownership of such public right-of-way is not necessary or required to serve the best interest of the City; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Lynchburg, on its own motion, and in accordance with the provisions of Section 15.2-2006 of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, and Sections 35-71 through 35-77 of the City Code, 1981, as amended, the following described right of way be, and the same hereby is, discontinued and vacated, namely: LEGAL DESCRIPTION PARCEL “A” COMMENCE AT A DRILL HOLE FOUND IN PAVEMENT AT THE INTERSECTION OF THE WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF CARROLL AVENUE AND THE SOUTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF CHILES CIRCLE, THENCE N 06°44'26" W AND PASSING A DRILL HOLE SET IN THE PAVEMENT AT 46.00’ A TOTAL DISTANCE OF 61.00' TO A POINT; THENCE S 83°54'01" W A DISTANCE OF 221.29' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 20.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 14.85', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 14.51', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 74°49'59" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 42°32'00" TO A POINT; THENCE N 53°33'59" W A DISTANCE OF 7.19' TO A POINT; POB “1”; THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF PARCEL “A”;THENCE S 36°26'01" W A DISTANCE OF 15.00' TO A POINT; THENCE N 53°33'59" W A DISTANCE OF 250.55' TO A POINT; THENCE N 36°26'01" E A DISTANCE OF 15.00' TO A POINT; THENCE S 53°33'59" E A DISTANCE OF 250.55' TO A POINT; WHICH IS THE POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID PARCEL “A” TO CONTAIN 0.0863 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. LEGAL DESCRIPTION PARCEL “B” COMMENCE AT A DRILL HOLE FOUND IN PAVEMENT AT THE INTERSECTION OF THE WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF CARROLL AVENUE AND THE SOUTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF CHILES CIRCLE, THENCE N 06°44'26" W AND PASSING A DRILL HOLE SET IN THE PAVEMENT AT 46.00’ A TOTAL DISTANCE OF 61.00' TO A POINT; THENCE S 83°54'01" W A DISTANCE OF 221.29' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 20.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 14.85', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 14.51', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 74°49'59" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 42°32'00" TO A POINT; THENCE N 53°33'59" W A DISTANCE OF 7.19' TO A POINT; POB “1”; THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF PARCEL “B”; THENCE N 53°33'59" W A DISTANCE OF 89.71' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 255.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 80.72', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 80.39', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF S 61°25'12" E, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 18°08'15",TO A POINT; THENCE S 06°05'59" E A DISTANCE OF 14.91' TO A POINT; WHICH IS THE POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID PARCEL “B” TO CONTAIN 0.0074 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. LEGAL DESCRIPTION PARCEL “C” COMMENCE AT A DRILL HOLE FOUND IN PAVEMENT AT THE INTERSECTION OF THE WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF CARROLL AVENUE AND THE SOUTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF CHILES CIRCLE, THENCE N 06°44'26" W AND PASSING A DRILL HOLE SET IN THE PAVEMENT AT 46.00’ A TOTAL DISTANCE OF 61.00' TO A POINT; THENCE S 83°54'01" W A DISTANCE OF 221.29' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 20.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 14.85', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 14.51', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 74°49'59" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 42°32'00" TO A POINT; THENCE N 53°33'59" W A DISTANCE OF 7.19' TO A POINT; POB “1”; THE POINT OF BEGINNING OF PARCEL “C”; THENCE N 06°05'59" W A DISTANCE OF 14.91' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 255.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 110.58', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 109.72', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF S 82°54'44" E, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 24°50'49",TO A POINT; THENCE S 83°54'01" W A DISTANCE OF 88.00' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 20.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 14.85', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 14.51', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 74°49'59" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 42°32'00",TO A POINT THENCE N 53°33'59" W A DISTANCE OF 7.19' TO A POINT; WHICH IS THE POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID PARCEL “C” TO CONTAIN 0.019 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. PARCEL “D” LEGAL DESCRIPTION BEGIN AT THE POINT OF BEGINNING, POB “2”; A DRILL HOLE SET AT THE INTERSECTION OF THE WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY OF CARROLL AVENUE AND THE CENTERLINE OF CHILES CIRCLE; THENCE S 83°54'01" W A DISTANCE OF 221.46' TO A 1/2” REBAR SET; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO TH RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 35.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 25.98', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 25.39', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 74°49'59" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 42°32'00",TO A 1/2” REBAR SET; THENCE N 53°33'59" W A DISTANCE OF 7.19' TO A POINT; THENCE N 36°26'01" E A DISTANCE OF 15.00' TO A POINT; THENCE S 53°33'59" E A DISTANCE OF 7.19' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 20.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 14.85', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 14.51', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF S 74°49'59" E, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 42°32'00", TO A POINT; THENCE N 83°54'01" E A DISTANCE OF 221.29' TO A POINT; THENCE S 06°44'26" E A DISTANCE OF 15.00' TO A DRILL HOLE SET; WHICH IS THE POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID PARCEL “D” TO CONTAIN 0.086 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. PARCEL “E” LEGAL DESCRIPTION BEGIN AT THE POINT OF BEGINNING, POB “2”; A DRILL HOLE SET AT THE INTERSECTION OF THE WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY OF CARROLL AVENUE AND THE CENTERLINE OF CHILES CIRCLE; THENCE S 06°44'26" E A DISTANCE OF 15.00' TO A POINT; THENCE S 83°54'01" W A DISTANCE OF 221.63' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 50.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 37.12', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 36.27', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 74°49'59" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 42°32'00",TO A POINT; THENCE N 53°33'59" W A DISTANCE OF 257.75' TO A POINT; THENCE N 36°26'01" E A DISTANCE OF 15.00' TO A POINT; THENCE S 53°33'59" E A DISTANCE OF 257.75' TO A 1/2” REBAR SET; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 35.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 25.98', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 25.39', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF S 74°49'59" E, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 42°32'00", TO A 1/2” REBAR SET; THENCE N 83°54'01" E A DISTANCE OF 221.46' TO A DRILL HOLE SET; WHICH IS THE POINT OF BEGINNING, SAID PARCEL “E” TO CONTAIN 0.176 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. PARCEL “F” LEGAL DESCRIPTION BEGIN AT THE POINT OF BEGINNING, POB “3”; A DRILL HOLE FOUND IN PAVEMENT AT THE INTERSECTION OF THE WESTERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF CARROLL AVENUE AND THE SOUTHERLY RIGHT-OF-WAY LINE OF CHILES CIRCLE, THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 25.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 39.27', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 35.36', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 51°44'23" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 89°59'47" TO A POINT; THENCE S 83°15'34" W A DISTANCE OF 182.84' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE RIGHT WITH A RADIUS OF 100.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 75.09', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 73.34', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF N 75°13'42" W, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 43°01'29" TO A POINT; THENCE N 53°41'45" W A DISTANCE OF 89.09' TO A POINT; THENCE N 53°43'43" W A DISTANCE OF 150.14' TO A 1/2” REBAR SET; THENCE N 36°26'01" E A DISTANCE OF 11.30' TO A 1/2” REBAR SET; THENCE S 53°33'59" E A DISTANCE OF 257.75' TO A POINT; THENCE WITH A CURVE TURNING TO THE LEFT WITH A RADIUS OF 50.00', WITH AN ARC LENGTH OF 37.12', WITH A CHORD LENGTH OF 36.27', WITH A CHORD BEARING OF S 74°49'59" E, WITH A DELTA ANGLE OF 42°32'00" TO A POINT; THENCE N 83°54'01" E A DISTANCE OF 221.63' TO A POINT;THENCE S 06°44'26" E A DISTANCE OF 31.00' TO A DRILL HOLE FOUND; WHICH IS THE POINT OF BEGINNING, HAVING AN AREA OF 0.111 ACRES, MORE OR LESS. Provided, however, that any easement to locate, relocate, repair, replace, maintain and perpetually operate all utilities currently located therein or needed by the City in the future is hereby reserved unto the City of Lynchburg and the construction of a permanent structure over any utility line without the prior written approval of the City is prohibited. BE IT FURTHER ORDAINED that the Clerk of Council is hereby authorized and directed to deliver a duly certified copy of this ordinance to the Clerk of the Circuit Court for the City of Lynchburg so that said certified copy of this ordinance may be recorded as deeds are recorded and indexed in the name of the City of Lynchburg, and the City Manager is hereby authorized to sign any documents that may be needed to complete the vacation of the right-of-way. Adopted: Certified: _____________________________ Clerk of Council     SURVEYORS            ENGINEERS            SOIL EVALUATORS  434.610.43346200 FORT AVENUE | LYNCHBURG, VA 24502                                                          www.accupointsurveying.com                                                 DBE# 723629              10/1/2020    Ms. Victoria Glasgow  City Planning and Community Development  900 Church Street  Lynchburg, VA 24504    Dear Ms. Glasgow and to whomever it may concern,     Accupoint Surveying & Design undertook investigation of the title to an undeveloped and unimproved portion of  Chiles Circle lying between Carroll Avenue and Advantage Court.  It is the desire of O’ Mayflower, LLC and R&B  Associates of Lynchburg, LLC to vacate the public interest in this portion of land, henceforward described as the  “subject property.”     The current public right‐of‐way of Chiles Circle, or the subject property, came into existence by three separate  dedications for public use as a street. I undertook research and consideration of the circumstances surrounding  each right‐of‐way dedication, as well as current case law and law at the time of dedication on an individual basis.     Please review the chronological summary of progressive dedication for public use as a street of the subject  property. The original subdivision plat entitled “Subdivision of E.N. Chiles Property by Adrian Overstreet, S. C. S.,”,  [Exhibit A] clearly establishes a 30’ road currently known as Chiles Circle for the public’s right to access the lots  within the E.N. Chiles Property subdivision as well as the state road on the face of the survey, currently known as  Carroll Avenue.     At the time of dedication in 1945, this portion of the subject property lay within the bounds of Campbell County.  As such, the first Subdivision Act of 1888 provides that the recording of a plat operates to create an easement for  public use, thus the fee interest in the lands lies with the subdivider, his heirs or assigns. However, upon vacation  of this right‐of‐way, Virginia Code §15.2‐2274 establish reversionary rights with respect to subdivision streets after  sale of a lot, vesting title to the abutting landowners to the centerline of the street, upholding the long standing  rule of common law.     Virginia Code § 15.2‐2272 establishes that in circumstances where lots have been sold in the subdivision, and the  vacation of the portion of a subdivision street right‐of‐way does not impede or alter the access for any other lot  owners, than the governing body may vacate the plat in writing, provided they obtain the signatures of the lot  owners immediately adjoining or contiguous to the vacated area, regardless of whether the plat was recorded  under the current statutory scheme.     It is clear from a thorough examination of the public land records the remaining lots within the original E.N. Chiles  Subdivision retain direct physical access to publicly maintained roads, and this vacation would not infringe upon  any other party’s rights of access.       SURVEYORS            ENGINEERS            SOIL EVALUATORS  434.610.43346200 FORT AVENUE | LYNCHBURG, VA 24502                                                          www.accupointsurveying.com                                                 DBE# 723629                It is my opinion that should the City of Lynchburg exercise the right to vacate the public’s interest in that portion of  the subject property lying within the original 30’ dedication of Chiles Circle, fee simple title shall vest in the  abutting landowners to the centerline of the street, under common law practice.     The subject property and adjacent parcels were annexed to the City of Lynchburg in 1958, and the following right‐ of‐way acquisitions which occurred after the annexation fall under separate legislation. The survey entitled “Plat  showing Division of Property of CEP Enterprises, Inc.,” by Hurt and Proffitt [Exhibit B] dedicates additional right‐of‐ way directly to the City of Lynchburg to widen the southerly border of Chiles Circle.     The deed and accompanying survey entitled “Plat Showing City of Lynchburg Right‐of‐Way Acquisition for Part of  Property of R & B Associates of Lynchburg, LLC, City of Lynchburg, Virginia,” [Exhibit C] dedicates additional right‐ of‐way to widen Chiles Circle’s northerly border.    There is little question that each of these conveyances vest title directly to the City of Lynchburg, one by express  platted dedication and the other by deed and survey. In each case, it is my opinion the vacation of the  aforementioned rights‐of‐way vest fee‐simple title to lands within to the abutting landowners.     As R&B Associates of Lynchburg, LLC owns all the adjacent parcels to the north of the subject property, and O  Mayflower LLC owns all the adjacent property to the south of the subject parcel, I believe upon vacation of the  public interest the title to the land withing the right‐of‐way of Chiles Circle shall pass in fee to each abutting owner,  to the centerline of the original street conveyance.    Thank you for your attention to this matter. Please let me know if there are any questions.    Elizabeth Davis   Virginia Certified Title Examiner   Accupoint Surveying & Design, LLC      REVISED January 12, 2021 1 GENERAL POLICY REGARDING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AT CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS Each speaker shall clearly state his or her name and locality of residence. The City Council agenda is divided into four sections. CONSENT AGENDA: This section includes routine items. All items may be approved by one vote. PUBLIC HEARINGS: This section includes all public hearings as required by law or as Council may direct. Procedure: • Staff will make a presentation. • For zoning petitions, the applicant or his or her representative shall have ten (10) minutes to make a presentation. • Comments will then be solicited from those in favor. • Comments will then be solicited from those in opposition. During the public hearing, there shall be a time limit of three (3) minutes for each individual speaker. If the speaker represents a group, there shall be a time limit of five (5) minutes. A speaker representing a group shall identify that group at the beginning of his or her remarks. A group may have only one spokesperson. After public comments have been received, for zoning petitions, the applicant or the representative of the applicant, at his or her discretion, may respond with a rebuttal. There shall be a five (5)- minute time limit for rebuttal. Upon the conclusion of public comments or the applicant’s rebuttal, the public hearing will be closed and the matter referred to Council for deliberation. PUBLIC COMMENT: Public comment shall be for the purpose of allowing members of the public to present any matter, which, in their opinion, deserves the attention of the Council. They shall not serve as a forum for debate with the Council. Individuals may speak up to three (3) minutes; or group spokesperson up to five (5) minutes. Once Council has heard a presentation from a citizen or organization on a particular subject, the citizen or organization may not make another presentation on the same subject within three (3) months of the first presentation, except by a majority vote of the members of Council present and voting. GENERAL BUSINESS: This section includes items of a general nature to be considered by Council. City Council may make exceptions to these rules at its discretion. Prior to a meeting, any questions which citizens may have regarding any item on the agenda may be addressed to City Council or the City Administration. The following numbers are provided for the convenience of the citizens: CITY COUNCIL 455-3995 MAYOR 455-3995 CITY MANAGER 455-3990 A reasonable charge may be made for copying and other activities related to responding to long and involved inquiries. CITIZENS OFTEN EXPRESS CONFLICTING AND DIVERSE POSITIONS REGARDING SPECIFIC ISSUES UNDER CONSIDERATION. TO ENCOURAGE CITIZEN PARTICIPATION AND TO AVOID INTIMIDATION TO PERSONS WHO MAY EXPRESS SOMETIMES UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, APPLAUSE, CHEERS, OR JEERS FROM THE AUDIENCE ARE NOT PERMITTED. WHEN APPEARING BEFORE CITY COUNCIL, CITIZENS MAY NOT ENGAGE IN BEHAVIOR THAT INTIMIDATES OR INSULTS OTHERS, ENGAGE IN DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOR, USE PROFANITY OR VULGAR LANGUAGE, PROMOTE PRIVATE BUSINESS VENTURES OR CAMPAIGN FOR PUBLIC OFFICE. * PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED AND/OR CONSIDERED BY CITY COUNCIL Physical Development Committee – 8:00 a.m. – Council Chamber A G E N D A City Council Meeting of January 12, 2021 Council Chamber | City Hall, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, VA 24504 4:00 P.M. WORK SESSION #1. Receive an update on the revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources. #2. Discuss the proposed amendments to the Telecommunications Ordinance. #3. Roll Call 7:30 P.M. City Council Agenda Items COUNCILMEMBER FARALDI WILL GIVE THE INVOCATION REVISED January 12, 2021 2 R E C O G N I T I O N ❖ Proclamation – Holocaust Education Month C O N S E N T A G E N D A #4. Consideration of adopting minutes from the December 8, 2020 Meeting P U B L I C H E A R I N G #5. Consideration of adopting a resolution requesting an exemption to the Utility Disconnection Moratorium. #R-21-___ #6. Consideration of adopting a resolution granting a Conditional Use Permit to Jefferson House, LLC to allow the construction of a five story, sixty-five unit apartment building for seniors. #R-21-___ #7. Consideration of adopting a resolution approving the goals for the Community Development Block Grant and HOME programs goals for FY 2022 Annual Action Plan. #R-21-___ #8. Consideration of adopting a resolution authorizing the City Manager to sell 97 Page Street. #R-21-___ #9. Consideration of adopting a resolution requesting the General Assembly to revise the City Charter to remove limits on City Council salaries. #R-21-___ P U B L I C C O M M E N T #10. Hear from a citizen regarding a concern (Gary Taylor). G E N E R A L B U S I N E S S #11. Consideration of re-adopting the Continuity of Governance Ordinance and associated Council procedures. #O-21-___ #12. Consideration of adopting a resolution supporting Virginia Housing Loan Funding for Miller’s Rest, Phase II. #R-21-___ #13. Consideration of a closed meeting to discuss appointments for vacancies to the following Boards and Commissions: Economic Development Authority, Horizon Behavioral Health, and City Employees Appeal Board pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 1 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: FY 2021 Monthly Revenue Update KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _ _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Receive an update on the revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources. SUMMARY: Several key Adopted FY 2021 revenue sources were reduced to reflect the anticipated economic impacts due to the COVID-19 pandemic; revenue collections are updated through December 31, 2020. PRIOR ACTION(S): Rebalancing the Proposed FY 2021 General Fund Budget Due to Economic Impact of COVID-19, City Council, April 28, 2020. FISCAL IMPACT: As noted. CONTACT(S): Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): FY 2021 Monthly Revenue Update REVIEWED BY: raw 009A City Council January 12, 2021 FY 2021 Adopted General Fund Monthly Revenue Update COVID-19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue Monthly Update 2 Note: Actual collections revised as of December 31, 2020. Local Sales and Use Tax Adopted FY 2021 Actual Collections FY 2021 Variance to Adopted Budget FY 2021 Local Sales and Use Tax $15,454,579 $7,439,316 ($8,015,263) July 1,119,330 1,503,837 384,507 August 1,025,719 1,396,989 371,270 September 1,252,153 1,531,422 279,269 October 1,251,875 1,498,945 247,070 (Sales and Use Tax for November due by January 15th) November *Not Final* 1,361,561 1,508,123 146,562 (Sales and Use Tax for December due by February 15th) December 1,585,420 0 (1,585,420) (Sales and Use Tax for January due by March 15th) January 1,160,079 0 (1,160,079) (Sales and Use Tax for February due by April 15th) February 1,196,836 0 (1,196,836) (Sales and Use Tax for March due by May 15th) March 1,432,681 0 (1,432,681) (Sales and Use Tax for April due by June 15th) April 1,331,840 0 (1,331,840) (Sales and Use Tax for May due by July 15th) May 1,447,319 0 (1,447,319) (Sales and Use Tax for June due by August 15th) June 1,289,766 0 (1,289,766) COVID-19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue Monthly Update (continued) 3 Note: Actual collections revised as of December 31, 2020. Meals Tax Adopted FY 2021 Actual Collections FY 2021 Variance to Adopted Budget FY 2021 Meals Tax $14,932,599 $5,866,341 ($9,066,258) July 970,231 1,090,332 120,101 August 1,081,853 1,186,360 104,507 September 1,161,186 1,203,439 42,253 October 1,357,034 1,283,797 (73,237) November 1,230,200 1,102,413 (127,787) (Meals Tax for December due by January 20th) December 1,286,319 0 (1,286,319) (Meals Tax for January due by February 20th) January 1,181,440 0 (1,181,440) (Meals Tax for February due by March 20th) February 1,237,691 0 (1,237,691) (Meals Tax for March due by April 20th) March 1,425,976 0 (1,425,976) (Meals Tax for April due by May 20th) April 1,352,984 0 (1,352,984) (Meals Tax for May due by June 20th) May 1,397,503 0 (1,397,503) (Meals Tax for June due by July 20th) June 1,250,182 0 (1,250,182) COVID-19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue Monthly Update (continued) 4 Note: Actual collections revised as of December 31, 2020. Lodging Tax Adopted FY 2021 Actual Collections FY 2021 Variance to Adopted Budget FY 2021 Lodging Tax $2,725,636 $1,012,025 ($1,713,611) July 147,156 155,637 8,481 August 177,753 213,511 35,758 September 208,246 257,411 49,165 October 314,431 226,390 (88,041) November 218,220 159,076 (59,144) (Lodging Tax for December due by January 20th) December 156,330 0 (156,330) (Lodging Tax for January due by February 20th) January 211,325 0 (211,325) (Lodging Tax for February due by March 20th) February 208,445 0 (208,445) (Lodging Tax for March due by April 20th) March 279,608 0 (279,608) (Lodging Tax for April due by May 20th) April 233,875 0 (233,875) (Lodging Tax for May due by June 20th) May 300,480 0 (300,480) (Lodging Tax for June due by July 20th) June 269,767 0 (269,767) COVID-19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue Monthly Update (continued) 5 Note: Actual collections revised as of December 31, 2020. Amusement Tax Adopted FY 2021 Actual Collections FY 2021 Variance to Adopted Budget FY 2021 Amusement Tax $795,190 $89,338 ($705,852) July 34,581 13,970 (20,611) August 28,321 19,248 (9,073) September 28,994 19,538 (9,456) October 73,504 18,752 (54,752) November 80,858 17,830 (63,028) (Amusement Tax for December due by January 20th) December 81,843 0 (81,843) (Amusement Tax for January due by February 20th) January 88,585 0 (88,585) (Amusement Tax for February due by March 20th) February 62,931 0 (62,931) (Amusement Tax for March due by April 20th) March 86,769 0 (86,769) (Amusement Tax for April due by May 20th) April 92,490 0 (92,490) (Amusement Tax for May due by June 20th) May 63,944 0 (63,944) (Amusement Tax for June due by July 20th) June 72,370 0 (72,370) Questions, Comments, Observations 6 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: January 12, 2021 AGENDA ITEM #: 2 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles Repeal Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.273.20 related to Telecommunication Towers and replace with Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance KEY ELEMENTS: _X _Economic Development __Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _ Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Conduct work session on Zoning Ordinance Amendments related to telecommunication facilities. SUMMARY: The City’s Zoning Ordinance sections related to Telecommunication Facilities were last updated in December 1997 with minor amendments in January 2020. Amendments to Virginia Code in 2017 - 2020 and federal law regarding telecommunications facilities requires the City to update the Ordinance in order to be compliant with the new regulations. PRIOR ACTION(S): November 11, 2020: Planning Commission work session on Zoning Ordinance Amendments. December 9, 2020: The Planning Division recommended approval of the Zoning Ordinance Amendments. The Planning Commission recommended approval (7-0) of the Zoning Ordinance Amendments. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A CONTACT(S): Tom Martin, City Planner – 455-3900 J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC – (703) 378-5770 ATTACHMENT(S): • City Council Presentation – January 12, 2021 • Telecommunications Fact Sheet • Planning Commission Minutes – December 9, 2020 • Planning Commission Packet – December 9, 2020 o Planning Commission Report o Zoning Ordinance Amendment – Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles (Proposed) o Zoning Ordinance Amendment – Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance (Proposed) o Power Point Presentation – December 9, 2020 o Planning Commission Memorandum – November 11, 2020 o Power Point Presentation – November 11, 2020 • Planning Commission Sign in Sheet – December 9, 2020 • Telecommunications Legal Notice • Existing Telecommunications Ordinance REVIEWED BY: raw 001A Telecommunications Ordinance J. Patrick Taves Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC Tom Martin, AICP , City Planner City Council Work Session January 12, 2021 Purpose and Outline Purpose: Discuss the proposed Telecommunications Ordinance Outline: 1. State and Federal mandates 2. Types of facilities – Small Cell, AREP, Standard Process Projects 3. Timelines for review 4. Where permitted - Height 5. Setbacks 2 Proposed regulations depend on the size of the facility. Three Types of Cell Facilities: • SMALL CELL FACILITIES: no more than 6 cu. ft. of volume for each antenna and no more than 28 cu. ft. of volume for all other wireless equipment • ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW ELIGIBLE PROJECTS (“AREPs”): not more than 50 ft. in height or co- location on any existing structure of a facility that is not a small cell facility • STANDARD PROCESS PROJECTS: any project that is not an AREP 3 Different Rules for Each Type of Facility. • Deadlines for Completeness of Applications---applications can be “deemed complete” • Fee Limitations • Deadlines for Decisions---applications can be “deemed approved” • Limited Grounds for Disapprovals • Different Rules for Different Facilities 4 Small Cell Facilities in the City’s Rights-of-Way and on City Property • Regulated by the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance (City Code Sections 35-28, 25-28.1, 35-28.2, 35-28.3, 35-28.4, 35-28.5, 35-28.6, and 35-28.7). • The New Telecommunications Ordinance provisions do not apply to these facilities. 5 Small Cell Facilities---Limited Reasons for Disapproval City can disapprove on existing structures for only four reasons: 1. Material potential interference with existing or future facilities designed and planned for a specific location or reserved for public safety communications 2. Safety of the public or other critical public service needs 3. Aesthetic impact, but only on publicly owned or publicly controlled property---but if the City owns the property or the structure, then the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance controls 4. Conflict with a historic distri ct ordinance, but only if that property is not eligible for a specified federal review process 6 Permitted Uses: • All Small Cell Facilities in all districts---CUPs cannot be required • All AREPs in all districts (50 feet or less in height)---CUPs cannot be required • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-1 District 100 feet or less • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts 150 feet or less • Any base station for a lawfully existing wireless facility or structure meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure meeting specified requirements 7 Conditional Use Permits Can Only Be Required For Standard Process Projects: • Standard Process Projects between 50 and 150 feet in height in the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1, and B-4 Districts • Standard Process Projects that exceed 100 feet in height in the B-1 District, but no greater than 150 feet • Standard Process Projects that exceed 150 feet in height in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts • Standard process project base stations meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure that increases the height of the facility, but any height increase is limited to no more than 15 feet • Any other standard process project 8 Standards for CUP’s – Standard Process Projects Only: • Substantial conformance with the Comprehensive Plan • No significant adverse impact on use and enjoyment of nearby properties • No significant negative impact on property values • No material potential interference with pre-existing facilities or for future planned facilities planned or designed for a specific location or any reserved for future public safety facilities* • No significant adverse impact on public safety or public service needs* • No available and existing wireless support structures nearby • Not in conflict with the City historic district ordinance* • Satisfies all other applicable requirements 9 Setbacks for Similar Structures: • Virginia law provides that the City cannot impose a setback or fall zone requirement that is larger than the setback or fall zone requirement “that is imposed on other types of similar structures of a similar size, including utility poles. • As a result, we propose establishing setbacks for wireless support structures that provide the same setbacks for wireless support structures as are applied to light poles, utility poles, and flag poles of a similar size. 10 Separate Amendment for Setbacks for Similar Structures: • No setback for flag poles, light poles or utility poles (“poles”) that are less than 35’ in height. • Poles greater than 35’ in height set back at a 1:1 in R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3. R-4, IN-1 or B-4 Districts. • Poles greater than 35’ in height in B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District and adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, IN-1 or B-4 District set back at 1:1 • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District between 35’ and 50’ must meet underlying district setback • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District greater than 50’ set back at least ½ the height of the pole. 11 Discussion: Discussion 12 TELECOMMUNICATIONS ORDINANCE FACT SHEET 1. Why is the City of Lynchburg proposing to amend the Telecommunications Ordinance? The Telecommunications Ordinance was last updated in December 1997 with minor revisions in January 2000. Amendments to the Virginia Code in 2017, 2018 & 2020 and Federal Law has resulted in the need for the City to revise the Ordinance to be consistent with State & Federal Law. 2. What does the City’s Comprehensive Plan state about Telecommunications Facilities? The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 recognizes that in order for the City to continue in its role as the economic engine for the region it must keep pace with changes in technology and telecommunications and that in order to attract businesses it must capitalize on comprehensive telecommunication services. (p.9, 83) 3. Who drafted the proposed Ordinance Revisions? City staff drafted the proposed revisions in conjunction with J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC, Fairfax, Virginia. Mr. Taves has 40+ years experience representing local governments in complex comprehensive plan, zoning and other land use issues. 4. Who has reviewed the proposed Ordinance Revisions? The draft ordinance was forwarded to over twenty-six representatives of the telecommunications industry in August 2020. Comments received were minor in nature and have been incorporated into the draft ordinance. The Planning Commission conducted a work session on the proposed ordinance revisions on November 11, 2020. The Planning Commission conducted a public hearing on the proposed ordinance revisions and recommend approval (7-0) on December 9, 2020. The City Council will conduct a work session on the proposed amendments on January 12, 2021 with an anticipated public hearing on February 9, 2021. 5. Why are setbacks proposed for flag poles, light poles, and utility poles? State and Federal law requires that telecommunication facilities be treated equally as similar structures. If setbacks are not established for flag poles, light poles and utility poles then the Zoning Ordinance can not require setbacks for telecommunication facilities. 6. How is the proposed Ordinance different from the existing ordinance? The proposed Ordinance classifies telecommunication facilities in one of three ways and sets review timeframes for each type as required by State and Federal Law: a. Small Cell Facilities – Permitted in all Zoning Districts (i) each antenna is or could fit within an imaginary enclosure of no more than six (6) cubic feet and (ii) all other wireless equipment associated with the facility has a cumulative volume of no more than twenty-eight (28) cubic feet. Small cell facilities proposed within City right-of-way or on City property are regulated by separate City Code and the proposed amendments would not apply to these facilities. Small Cell Facility b. Administrative Review-Eligible Project (AREP’s) – Permitted in all Zoning Districts (i) a new structure that is not more than fifty (50) feet above the ground level or not more than ten (10) feet above the tallest existing utility pole within five hundred (500) feet. (ii) not located in a local, state or federal historic district (iii) designed to support small cell facilities (iv) the colocation on any existing structure that is not a small cell facility c. Standard Process Project – Permitted or Conditional Use Permit (i) Any project that is not an administrative review eligible project. PERMITED USES BY DISTRICT & SETBACKS The permitted uses in each Zoning District are similar to the existing Ordinance in terms of height with the primary change being related to setbacks when telecommunication facilities are not located adjacent to a Residential District, Institutional 1 District or B-4, Urban Commercial District (Downtown). Current Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2-73.5 (a) 1 states: “All towers and any telecommunications facilities in any business and industrial zoning districts shall be set back on all sides a distance equal to the underlying building setback requirement in the applicable zoning district. All towers in residential zoning districts shall be set back on all sides a distance equal to the tower height. In addition, in order to preserve the aesthetics of residential areas and to maintain property values, whenever a tower is located in a residential district, the tower shall be located a distance at least equal to twice the height of the tower from any adjacent property lines. When a tower is located in a commercial district or industrial district, the tower shall be located a distance at least equal to twice the height of the tower from any residential district.” The proposed Ordinance would no longer require setbacks of twice the height of the tower or “fall zones” due to State & Federal Law that requires telecommunication facilities to be treated equally as similar structures. R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 & B-4 Districts Fifty (50) feet or less – Permitted by right Greater than fifty (50) feet, but no greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – Minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet – 0 B-1 District One hundred (100) feet or less – Permitted by Right Greater than one hundred (100) feet but no greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – structure less than fifty (50) feet – minimum setback of the B-1 District Setback – structure greater than fifty (50) feet – minimum of ½ the height of the structure Setback – structure adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 – minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet – 0 B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 & I-3 Districts One hundred fifty (150) feet or less – Permitted by Right Greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – structure less than fifty (50) feet – minimum setback of the District Setback – structure greater than fifty (50) feet – minimum of ½ the height of the structure Setback – structure adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 – minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet - 0 For more information contact Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner at (434) 455-3909 or tom.martin@lynchburgva.gov. 1 MINUTES OF THE DECEMBER 9, 2020 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING (MINUTES HAVE NOT BEEN APPROVED): Consideration of amending Section 35.2-61.2 of the City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Additional Height Regulations, by adding section (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles and Utility Poles. Consideration of proposed amendments to the City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance that seek to repeal Zoning Ordinance Chapters 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.20 of the City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance related to Telecommunication Towers. Simultaneous with the repeal of the foregoing chapters, the proposed amendments also propose consideration of the adoption of new Zoning Ordinance Chapters 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26 pertaining to Telecommunications Facilities. The proposed amendments shall be referred to herein as the “Telecommunications Facilities Ordinance.” Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, introduced Mr. J. Patrick Taves, of Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC. He has been working on this item with Mr. Tom Martin, City Planner. Mr. Taves addressed the Commission. There are four (4) items to discuss. These include setbacks for flag poles, light poles, and utility poles, the adoption of the new telecommunications ordinance, the repeal of the existing telecommunications ordinance, a nd the approval types for each zoning district. Rather than amending the existing ordinance piece by piece, it will be replaced entirely by the new one. The reason for proposing these changes in this manner is that it has been almost twenty (20) years sinc e the current ordinance was put in place. Over that time there have been many changes in State and Federal law relating to these provisions. To put it plainly, the current ordinance is woefully out of date. For example, the current law in Virginia talks ab out small cell facilities, administrative review eligible projects (AREPs), and standard process projects but those are terms that don’t exist in the current ordinance. The proposed ordinance incorporates those provisions and lays out the requirements in respect to those provisions. Requirements for timeliness of review depending on the type of facility are similar to the concept of a “shot clock”. If the City does not meet the deadlines laid out by State and Federal law, and in the proposed ordinance, the application may be deemed complete, even if it is not, or may be deemed approved, even if it should not be. The smallest types of facilities are the micro wireless facilities, and they are a subset of the small cell facilities. If they are twenty -four (24) inches in length, fifteen (15) inches in width, twelve (12) inches in height, or smaller, and have no exterior antenna greater than eleven (11) inches then no approval is required and there are no requirements that can apply. Small cell facilities have so me regulations applicable to them but not a lot. The administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) are subject to administrative review but not public hearings. The standard process projects are the largest facilities and may require a Conditional Use Pe rmit. The Virginia Code provisions on this subject are generally anti -local government. For example an application can be deemed complete even if it is not or can be deemed approved even if it shouldn’t be. There is limited discretion for the City for faci lities under fifty (50) feet in height. There are limitations on fees that the City can impose regardless of the City’s expenses. There are limited grounds for disapproval. If the City wants to disapprove a facility, it needs to provide a written statement as to why. Usually when acts are taken by local government bodies they do not have to explain their reasoning. In the case of disapproval, the City also has to release, in writing, a substantial record of evidence within thirty (30) days of the decision. Overall, there are a lot of “hoops to jump through” in order to disapprove one of these facilities. This ordinance does not apply to small cell facilities in the right -of-way or on City property because the City has franchise agreements with respect to tho se types of facilities. Small cell facilities can only be disapproved for four reasons. These reasons include material potential interference with existing or future facilities designed and planned for a specific location or reserved for public safety comm unication, safety of the public or other critical public service needs, aesthetic impact, but only on publicly owned or publicly controlled property, and conflict with a historic district ordinance. The provisions for disapproval of small cell facilities a re very narrow. Any other issues or complaints do not matter. The way the proposed ordinance has been structured is to first include the provisions required by State and Federal law. The 2 City has very little flexibility in regards to those. The provisions include the small cell facilities, the administrative review eligible projects (AREPs), and standard process projects. The facility is listed first and then all of the provisions that apply to that type of facility. There is some redundancy because a lot of the requirements are similar or the same for the administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) and the standard process projects. This layout makes it easier for the City, the residents, and any cell company who may be evaluating what requirements they need to meet, how quickly they need to respond, or what the flexibility is in regards to a type of facility. Small cell facilities are listed first, then administrative review eligible projects (AREPs), and finally standard process projects. Following tha t is permitted uses in each district and Conditional Use Permit requirements. This is where the City has more flexibility. The State and Federal requirements do not dictate what is allowed in each zoning district. This is only in regards to standard process projects though, which are over fifty (50) feet in height. A standard process project may require a Conditional Use Permit whereas small cell facilities and administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) cannot. The proposed ordinance is similar to the existing ordinance in terms of permitted uses and Conditional Use Permit requirements in each district. If a standard process project does not fall under a permitted use it may require a Conditional Use Permit. The districts fall into two (2) groupings. The first is the lower density districts which include the R -C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1, and B-4 districts. The B-1 district is separate and the standard process project facility is permitted in this district if it is less than one hundred (100) feet. The s econd grouping is the higher density districts which include the B -3, B-5, IN -2, I -1, I-2, and I -3 districts. This grouping is where there are allowances for larger facilities. Colocation, when a facility is added to an existing structure, is encouraged. T his allows for less general disruption and is more desirable than a standalone pole. If a Conditional Use Permit is required, standards can be applied. The most important standard is the one with respect to substantial conformance with the Comprehensive Pl an. That is where the City has a lot of flexibility and discretion. The Comprehensive Plan is drafted before there is an application or specific issue. It is where foresight comes into play. The proposed changes do not amend the Comprehensive Plan but agai n, one of the standards is substantial conformance with the Comprehensive Plan. Addressing whether or not there are sufficient standards and projection for the future in the Comprehensive Plan may be needed. The statute requires that the City not have a se tback or fall zone that exceeds the setback or fall zone established for similar structures. Flag poles, light poles, and utility poles are similar structures to wireless telecommunication facilities in height and appearance. There are no existing setback requirements for flag poles, light poles, or utility poles. The standards have to be established. It is proposed that structures that are thirty-five (35) feet in height or less have no setback requirements. The lower density districts require the height o f the structure, if greater than thirty -five (35) feet as the setback. If the property the facility or pole is on is next to a lower density district, the setback must be from the lower density district, wherever that may be. In the higher density district s for structures between thirty -five (35) and fifty (50) feet the minimum setback is the requirement and that is already built into the ordinance. If it is greater than fifty (50) feet, the setback is one half the height of the structure. The proposed setb acks will set standards for flag poles, light poles, utility poles, and telecommunication facilities. As a reminder there are four (4) items for the Commission’s consideration. The first is the adoption of the regulation of setbacks for the flag poles, lig ht poles, and utility poles. Once that is established, setbacks for telecommunication facilities can be established. The second would be the adoption of the new telecommunications ordinance. Once that is adopted, the existing ordinance can be repealed, which is the third item. The fourth item is the revisions of the approval types for the various districts. That will automatically happen though when and if the telecommunications ordinance is adopted. Chair Rogers asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in favor of the petition. When no one stepped forward he asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in opposition to the petition. When no one stepped forward again he closed the public hearing. Chair Rogers stated that the presentation was informative. The proposed changes seem necessary. 3 Mr. Taves noted that the proposed ordinance regarding the provisions dictated by State and Federal law are necessary but the following portion regarding the provisions for permitted and condi tional use offers more flexibility. Those provisions regarding permitted uses and Conditional Use Permit uses are modelled after the current City ordinance. Commissioner Marion stated that Mr. Taves seems well informed. She then asked if the proposed ordinance has been tested in other localities. Mr. Taves responded that for this particular ordinance, provisions regarding small cell facilities, administrative review eligible projects (AREPs), and standard process projects are in State code. He is comfortable with and recommends the adoption of this ordinance so the City can come into the 21st century with respect to wireless telecommunication facilities. Historically, there has been a tendency for local governments to abuse the zoning purview with respect to these types of facilities. People generally don’t like the idea of them but “by the same token” this is the 21st century and people expect the delivery of service. Again, he recommends strongly the adoption of this ordinance so the City can be in compliance with State code. He noted that he has dealt with telecommunication facilities for twenty -five (25) to thirty (30) years and has litigated many cases. During the review process, the proposed ordinance was sent to telecommunication companies, the users and beneficiaries of this ordinance, for feedback. Only very minor questions came back and there is no opposition at the present hearing. Commissioner Bowden stated that it is an evolving process. This is the beginning of that evolution and will establis h a framework to work with moving forward. What can be planned for at this point is covered. Mr. Taves shared agreement. There is little flexibility regarding what the State or Federal law dictates. The rest, regarding whether or not to permit something, whether or not to require a Conditional Use Permit, what the standard should be, is always an evolving process. That is why he recommends evaluating the Comprehensive Plan. At this point though, he feels that this is the best proposal. Commissioner Bowden noted that in the application of this ordinance the places that might provide the most pushback are going to be the “edges of Lynchburg”. There are already telecommunication facilities Downtown and they can be placed on existing buildin gs. The “edges” though may be more rural and may not have received that type of development yet. Those places are more likely to involve installation of towers and discuss aesthetics. Establishing standards now will allow for protection down the road. Mr. Taves shared agreement. Commissioner Bowden stated that the proposed setbacks make sense. That will probably be needed in relatively developed areas. He also noted that he can’t imagine anything else to do given the limited maneuverability to disapprove the facilities. Mr. Taves responded that the State and Federal law do not mandate which districts must allow standard process projects to be permitted or by Conditional Use Permit. Different localities have different zoning districts. They have already done that with respect to small cell facilities and administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) though since those cannot require a Conditional Use Permit and must be approved if they meet the application requirements for the type of facility in questio n. He then recommended that as time goes by, in two (2) or three (3) years, this should be reviewed to see how these provisions have worked. If necessary, the City can adopt new provisions. The proposed changes should be implemented and evaluated from there. Commissioner Perault added that the Comprehensive Plan should also be revisited once these provisions have “had time to settle”. There’s no rush to change the Comprehensive Plan now if changes 4 will be required in a few years. This should be implemente d now and reviewed in a few years in conjunction with necessary changes to the Comprehensive Plan. Commissioner Bowden shared agreement and noted that the Comprehensive Plan should be consistent with what the City wants to accomplish. Commissioner Marion recalled that in a previous meeting concerning a cell tower, discussion of the tower went on for a long time because numerous neighbors came to complain. She then asked if the proposed changes would limit that due to lack of ability of the City to disapprove. Mr. Taves responded that he would have to disagree. He worked on that project (Langhorne Road) for the City and drafted a denial motion for that. That project was a large monopole and a standard process project. It wasn’t an administrative review eligible project (AREP) or a small cell facility. It was a facility to which the City could lawfully apply Conditional Use Permit requirements. That is where the City has flexibility. The proposed ordinance does not increase the ability of the City to disa pprove small cell facilities or administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) though. The standards for Conditional Use Permits include having no significant adverse impact on use and enjoyment of nearby properties and no negative impact on property valu es. Those points were used in the denial of that project. If the Comprehensive Plan is amended, more tools can be added to evaluate such proposals in order to assure that such decisions are not made “in the heat of the moment.” Chair Rogers stated that he feels that the Commission still has tools and the ability to help lead planning the community. He noted that these proposed changes discuss facilities like the small cell facilities and the administrative review eligible projects (AREPs) that they prob ably haven’t seen much of yet but will see more of in the future. There are blank areas in the City that don’t yet have service. The increase in these types of facilities will be a good thing because they are limited in their impacts and appearance in comparison to standard process projects. These facilities are vital infrastructure especially as fewer people use landlines and the need for such facilities may be a matter of public safety at times. Discussion on how to proceed with a motion ensued. Mr. Taves suggested that the motion include the verbiage “as advertised” which would incorporate the comprehensive information included in the legal notice. He then referenced the following specifically from the legal notice: “In accordance with the adoption of t he proposed amendments, the “Approval Type” for “wireless telecommunications transmission” that is stated in each exhibit/chart for each applicable zoning district (for example, please see Exhibit IV -1 for the R -C District) shall be revised in order to state the “Approval Type” (“C” for “Conditional Use Permit” and/or “P” for “Permitted”) for each zoning district consistent with the terms of the proposed amendments.” Thus, if under the proposed amendments a wireless telecommunications facility may be allowed with a Conditional Use Permit (“C”) or may be Permitted (“P”), depending on the circumstances, then the “Approval Type” in the exhibit/chart for each district shall be stated as follows: “P/C”. If such facilities are only allowed by Conditional Use Permit, a “C” will be inserted in the applicable exhibit, and if such facilities are only Permitted, a “P” will be inserted in the applicable exhibit.” Commissioner Bowden made the following motion, seconded by Commissioner Johnson, and approved by the following vote: “Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City Council approval of amending the Zoning Ordinance by adopting Section 35.2 - 61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles and approval of repealing Sections, 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.20 related to Telecommunication Towers and replacing with Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance as 5 referenced in the attached legal notice that was advertised prior to the public hearing.” AYES: Bowden, Johnson, Light, Lowe, Marion, Perault, and Rogers 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 The Department of Community Development City Hall, Lynchburg, VA 24504 434-455-3900 To: Planning Commission From: Planning Division Date: December 9, 2020 Re: Zoning Ordinance Amendments: Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Pole s, Light Poles & Utility Poles Repeal Sections, 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.20 related to Telecommunication Towers and replace with Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance I. PETITIONER City of Lynchburg, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, Virginia 24504 Representative(s): J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC, Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner Property Owner: N/A II. LOCATION The Zoning Ordinance amendments would apply to any telecommunication facility in the R-C, R- 1, R-2, R-3, R-4, B-1, B-3, B-4, IN-1, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 Districts III. PURPOSE The purpose of the amendments is to bring the City’s Zoning Ordinance into compliance with State & Federal Law. IV. SUMMARY  The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 recognizes that in order for the City to continue in its role as the economic engine for the region it must keep pace with changes in technology and telecommunications and that in order to attract businesses it must capitalize on comprehensive telecommunication services. ( p.9, 83)  The City’s Telecommunications Ordinance was last updated in December 1997 with minor revisions in January 2000.  Amendments to the Virginia Code in 2017, 2018 & 2020 regarding telecommunication facilities established new terminology and rules.  Federal Law on telecommunication facilities is evolving.  The Telecommunication Ordinance would establish three type of facilities: Small Cell Facilities, Administrative Review-Eligible Projects (AREP’s) and Standard Process Projects  The Telecommunications Ordinance would establish review procedures for each type of telecommunication facility.  Setbacks for similar structures such as flag poles, light poles and utility poles must be established to be compliant with State & Federal Law.  Small Cell Facilities located in the City’s right-of-way or on City property regulated by separate City Code and proposed amendments do not apply to these facilities. Planning Commission: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – December 9, 2020 2 The Planning Division recommends approval of the Zoning Ordinance Amendments. V. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. Comprehensive Plan. The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 recognizes that in order for the City to continue in its role as the economic engine for the region it must keep pace with changes in technology and telecommunications and that in order to attract businesses it must capitalize on comprehensive telecommunication services. (p.9, 83) The purpose and intent of the proposed amendments is to facilitate the provision of telecommunication services, recognizing that telecommunication facilities are a necessary part of communication networks while protecting property from adverse impacts. 2. Zoning. The Telecommunications Ordinance was last updated in December 1997 with minor revisions in January 2000. 3. Proffers: N/A 4. Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA). N/A 5. Surrounding Area. N/A 6. Site Description. N/A 7. Proposed Use of Property. N/A 8. Traffic, Parking and Public Transit. N/A 9. Stormwater Management. N/A 10. Emergency Services: The Telecommunication Ordinance would require technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that proposed facilities would not interfere with pre-existing or future communication facilities for Public Safety Radio Services. 11. Impact. The proposed Zoning Ordinance Amendments would establish regulations for telecommunication facilities in the City of Lynchburg. Small Cell Facilities – Permitted in all Zoning Districts (i) each antenna is or could fit in an imaginary enclosure of no more than six (6) cubic feet and (ii) all other wireless equipment associated with the facility has a cumulative volume of no more than twenty-eight (28) cubic feet. Administrative Review-Eligible Project (AREP’s) – Permitted in all Zoning Districts (i) a new structure that is not more than fifty (50) feet above the ground level or not more than ten (10) feet above the tallest existing utility pole within five hundred (500) feet. (ii) not located in a local, state or federal historic district (iii) designed to support small cell facilities (iv) the colocation on any existing structure that is not a small cell facility Planning Commission: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – December 9, 2020 3 Standard Process Project – Permitted or Conditional Use Permit (i) any project that is not an administrative review eligible project PERMITED USES BY DISTRICT & SETBACKS R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 & B-4 Districts Fifty (50) feet or less – Permitted by right Greater than fifty (50) feet, but no greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – Minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet - 0 B-1 District One hundred (100) feet or less – Permitted by Right Greater than one hundred (100) feet but no greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – structure less than fifty (50) feet – minimum setback of the B-1 District Setback – structure greater than fifty (50) feet – minimum of ½ the height of the structure Setback – structure adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 – minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet - 0 B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 & I-3 Districts One hundred fifty (150) feet or less – Permitted by Right Greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet – CUP Required Setback – structure less than fifty (50) feet – minimum setback of the District Setback – structure greater than fifty (50) feet – minimum of ½ the height of the structure Setback – structure adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1 or B-4 – minimum height of the structure Setback – Structure less than thirty-five (35) feet - 0 12. Technical Review Committee. N/A VI. PLANNING DIVISION RECOMMENDATION Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City Council approval of amending the Zoning Ordinance by adopting Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles and approval of repealing Sections, 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.20 related to Telecommunication Towers and replacing with Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance Planning Commission: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – December 9, 2020 4 This matter is respectfully offered for your consideration. William T. Martin, AICP City Planner pc: Dr. Reid Wodicka, Interim City Manager Mr. Kent L. White, Interim Deputy City Manager Mr. Walter C. Erwin, City Attorney Mr. J. Lee Newland, City Engineer Ms. Cynthia Kozerow, Lynchburg Police Department Battalion Chief Thomas Goode, Fire Marshal Mr. Doug Saunders, Building Official Mr. Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator Mr. J. Patrick Taves, Gr eehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC VII. ATTACHMENTS 1. Zoning Ordinance Amendment - Section 35.2-61.2 (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles & Utility Poles 2. Zoning Ordinance Amendment - Sections 35.2-73.1 through 35.2-73.26, Telecommunications Ordinance 3. Power Point Presentation – December 9, 2020 4. Planning Commission Memorandum – November 11, 2020 5. Power Point Presentation – November 11, 2020 35.2‐6 (a)   M   1. B o   a.   b.   c.     2. Ex   a.   b.   c.   61.2 Addition Measurement  uilding Heigh pposite the m The highest roof  The deck lin The mean h and ridge o xceptions to  Buildings w (35) feet or ground surf Large Corne the height o midpoint of Through Lo from the cr provided th extend bac (see followi nal Height Re of Height  ht. Building he middle of the  t point of roo ne of a mansa height level b of a gable, hip Measuremen with Large Set r more, buildi face along the er Lots. On co of the buildin f the building ots. For lots ex rown of eithe hat the maxim k from the rig ing illustratio egulations   eight is the ve front of the b f surface of a ard roof etween eave  or gambrel r nt of Building tbacks. Wher ng height sha e front of the orner lots exc g may be me g facing the ap xtending thro r street at the mum height th ght‐of‐way of n).    ertical distanc building to:  a flat s roof  g Height  e a building is all be measure e building.  ceeding twent asured from pplicable stre ough from str e midpoint of hat would be  f such street n ce measured s set back fro ed from the a ty thousand ( the crown of eet.  reet to street, f the building  permitted ba not less than from the cro om the street  average eleva (20,000) squa f either street , the height m facing the ap ased on the lo one hundred wn of the str     line thirty‐fiv ation of finish are feet in are t at the  may be measu pplicable stre ower street s  fifty (150) fe eet  ve  hed  ea,  ured  et,  hall  eet  d.   Properties  district abu at the horiz shall apply t property lin twenty (20) Abutting R‐1 tting propert zontal midpoi to any portio ne (see follow ) feet in heigh , R‐2 or R‐3 D ty zoned R‐1,  nt of the buil n of the build wing illustratio ht at the front Districts. For l R‐2 or R‐3, he ding wall faci ding located w on). In no cas t building line   lots in any R‐4 eight shall be ing each abut within one‐hu e shall a build e.  4, B‐3, B‐5, IN e measured fr tting resident undred‐feet (1 ding be requi N‐1, I‐ 1, I‐2 or rom natural g tial property a 100) feet of t red to be less   r I‐3  rade  and  he  s than    (b)  He   1.    Th ro oc an m ap lig pr   a.   b.   c. 2. 3. (c)  Tal ap ho pro the (se eight Excepti he height limi oof line: flag p ccupancy, chi nd television a echanical app ppurtenances ghting rods an rovided that:  Such a feat intended to with the ro The total ar fifteen (15) Such featur and related material as      Parapet w a on which th   No sign, na upon or att district heig ll Buildings in partment build ospital, may b ovided that t e street, lot o ee following i ons for Certa tations shall  poles, church  mneys, ventil antennas for  purtenances ( s, plumbing ve nd telecomm ure shall be e o serve, but in of.  rea covered b  percent of th res as water t d appurtenanc the main wa alls may exten hey rest.  me plate, dis tached to any ght limitation n the R‐4, B‐1 dings, public  e erected to  he portion of or required se llustration).  ain Structures not apply to t spires/steepl lators, skyligh the use of re (including, bu ents, exhaust unications co erected only t n no case mor by such featur he area of the tanks, cooling ces, shall be e lls of the buil nd not more t play or adver y chimney, tow s.  1, B‐3 and IN‐ or semi‐publi not more tha f such building etback line, on s  the following les, belfries, c hts, water tan sidents of dw ut not limited t vents, HVAC onnections) us to a height ne re than fiftee res shall not e e plane of roo g towers and b enclosed with ding on whic than five (5) f rtising device  wer, tank or o 1 Districts. In ic buildings su an one hundre g more than f ne (1) foot fo g features pro cupolas and d nks, bulkhead welling units in  to solar ener C equipment,  sually carried ecessary to ac n (15) feet ab exceed in hor of upon which bulkheads, bu hin walls cons h they are loc feet above th of any kind w other structu n the R‐4, B‐1, uch as a relig ed twenty‐fiv forty (40) fee r each one (1 ojecting above domes not use ds or similar fe n apartments rgy panels an electrical con d above the ro ccomplish the bove its lowes rizontal cross‐ h they are loc ut not solar e structed of th cated.  e limiting hei whatsoever sh re which exte , B‐3 and IN‐1 ious institutio ve (125) feet i et in height sh 1) foot of such   e the  ed for human eatures, radio s, and necessa d related  nnections,  oof level  e purpose it is st point of co ‐ sectional ar cated.  energy panels he same  ght of the bu hall be inscrib ends above th 1 districts,  on, school, lib in height;  hall set back f h additional h n  o  ary  s  ontact  ea  s  uilding  bed  he  brary,  from  height  (d)   Flag poles, Light Poles and Utility Poles   1. There shall be no setback requirement for any Flag Pole, Light Pole or Utility Pole that is   thirty‐five (35) feet or less in height.    2. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole greater than thirty‐five (35) in height in the R‐C, R‐ 1, R‐2, R‐3, R‐4, IN‐1 or  B‐4 District shall be required to set back a distance from all  property lines at least the height of the pole.    3. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole greater than thirty‐five (35) in height in the B‐1, B‐ 3, B‐5, IN‐2, I‐1, I‐2 or I‐3 District that is on a parcel adjacent to any parcel that is zoned  R‐ C, R‐1, R‐2, R‐3, R‐4, IN‐1 or B‐4 shall be set back a distance at least the height of the pole  from the R‐C, R‐1, R‐2, R‐3, R‐4, IN‐1 or B‐4 District.    4. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole in the B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐2, I‐1, I‐2 or I‐3 District that  is greater than thirty‐five (35) feet in height but less than fifty (50) feet in height shall be  required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the minimum applicable  setback for the district in which it is located.    5. Any Flag Pole, Light Pole, or Utility Pole in the B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐2, I‐1, I‐2 or I‐3 District that  is a height greater than fifty (50) feet shall be required to set back a distance from all  property lines at least one‐half the height of the pole.    6. Setback requirements for Flag Poles, Light Poles, and Utility Poles shall be measured from  the base of the pole to the property lines of the parcel on which the pole is located.    1 1 Updated to 2 October 30, 3 2020 4 ORDINANCE NO. ____-________ 5 6 7 AN ORDINANCE REPEALING CHAPTER 35.2-73, WHICH COMPRISES §§ 35.2-73.1 8 THROUGH 35.2-73.20, AND ADOPTING A NEW CHAPTER 35.2-73, WHICH 9 COMPRISES §§ 35.2-73.1 THROU GH 35.2-73.26, PERTAINING TO 10 TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES. 11 BE IT ORDAINED, by the City Council of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, that 12 Chapter 35.2-73 of the Code of the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, is hereby adopted as 13 follows: 14 § 35.2–73 TELECOMMUNICATIONS FACILITIES 15 § 35.2–73.1 Purpose and Intent. 16 The purpose and intent of this chapter is to create and implement regulations and requirements for 17 the placement, construction, modification, and removal of wireless support structures, wireless 18 facilities, and base stations in order to protect the health, safety, and welfare of the public, while at 19 the same time not unreasonably interfering with the development of a competitive wireless 20 telecommunications marketplace in the City. Specifically, the purposes of this chapter are: 21 (a) To facilitate the provision of wireless telecommunications services to the residents 22 and businesses of the City in an orderly fashion; 23 (b) To recognize and acknowledge that wireless telecommunications facilities, 24 including their support structures and related equipment, have become a necessary 25 part of today’s personal and commercial communications networks; 26 (c) To regulate the location of wireless suppor t structures, wireless facilities, and base 27 stations in the City; 28 (d) To protect residential, commercial, and industrial areas and land uses from any 29 significant potential adverse impact that may result from the establishment and 30 operation of wireless support structures, wireless facilities and base stations; 31 2 (e) To implement the provisions of the City’s Comprehensive Plan with respect to the 1 establishment of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations in 2 the City; 3 (f) To minimize, when possible, the adve rse visual impact of wireless support 4 structures, wireless facilities, and base stations through careful design, siting, 5 landscaping, and innovative camouflaging techniques to enhance the ability of such, 6 support structures, facilities, and base stations to be compatible with residential, 7 commercial, and industrial uses; 8 (g) To promote and encourage the co -location on and around wireless support 9 structures of multiple wireless facilities and base stations in order to reduce, when 10 possible, the need for additional such structures and facilities; 11 (h) To promote and encourage the locati on of wireless support structures, wireless 12 facilities, and base stations in commercial and industrial areas, rather than 13 residential areas; 14 (i) To ensure that wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations are 15 compatible with other land uses in the vicinity; 16 (j) To allow wireless support structures, wire less facilities, and base stations as a 17 matter of right, where appropriate, and with minimal administrative requirements 18 when the size, design, and location of such support structures, facilities, and base 19 stations does not result in any significant adverse impacts to other uses or any 20 significant adverse impact to the property values of nearby properties; 21 (k) To provide greater scrutiny of request s for wireless support structures, wireless 22 facilities, and base stations when their size, design, and location may result in 23 greater impacts on surrounding land uses and property values in order to assure that 24 adverse impacts of such structures, facilities, and base stations and any adverse 25 impact on the values of nearby properties are mitigated and minimized; 26 (l) To encourage the providers of wirele ss telecommunications services to utilize 27 smaller wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations in order to 28 reduce the overall impact of any single wireless support structure or facility on the 29 surrounding area; 30 (m) To reduce the need for larger and ta ller wireless support structures, wireless 31 facilities, and base stations through the encouragement of co-location on any new 32 structures as well as the installation, where feasible, of such facilities onto existing 33 structures; 34 3 (n) To avoid potential damage to the use a nd enjoyment of property caused by wireless 1 support structures, wireless facilities, and base stations by ensuring that such 2 structures, facilities, and stations are soundly, safely, and carefully designed; 3 constructed, modified, and maintained, and, when no longer structurally sound, 4 removed; and 5 (o) To require the removal of wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and base 6 stations that are no longer used to support wireless facilities and no longer retain 7 any other legitimate purposes. 8 § 35.2–73.2 Definitions. 9 As used in this Ordinance, unless the context requires a different meaning: 10 “Administrative review-eligible project” means a project that provides for: 11 1. The installation or construction of a new stru cture that is not more than 50 feet above 12 ground level, provided that the structure with attached wireless facilities is (i) not more than 10 13 feet above the tallest existing utility pole located within 500 feet of the new structure within the 14 same public right-of-way or within the existing line of utility poles; (ii) not located within the 15 boundaries of a local, state, or federal historic district; (iii) not located inside the jurisdictional 16 boundaries of a locality having expended a total amount equal to or greater than 35 percent of its 17 general fund operating revenue, as shown in the most recent comprehensive annual financial 18 report, on undergrounding projects since 1980; and (iv) designed to support small cell facilities; 19 or 20 2. The co-location on any existing structure of a wireless facility that is not a small cell 21 facility; 22 3. The term “administrative review-eligible project” shall include eligible facilities requests 23 as that term is defined by federal law in 47 Code of Federal Regulations 1.6100. 24 “Antenna” means communications equipment that transmits or receives electromagnetic radio 25 signals used in the provision of any type of wireless communications services. 26 “Base station” means a station that includes a structure that currently supports or houses an 27 antenna, transceiver, coaxial cables, power cables, or associated equipment at a specific site that 28 is authorized to communicate with mobile stations, generally consisting of radio transceivers, 29 antennas, coaxial cables, power supplies, and other associated electronics. 30 “City” means the City of Lynchburg, Virginia. 31 4 “Co-locate” means to install, mount, maintain, modify, operate, or replace a wireless facility on, 1 under, within, or adjacent to a base station, building, existing structure, utility pole, or wireless 2 support structure. “Co-location” has a corresponding meaning. 3 “Department” means the Virginia Department of Transportation. 4 “Existing structure” means any structure that is installed or approved for installation at the time 5 a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider provides notice to the City or the 6 Department of an agreement with the owner of the structure to co-locate equipment on that 7 structure. “Existing structure” includes any structure that is currently supporting, designed to 8 support, or capable of supporting the attachment of wireless facilities, including towers, 9 buildings, utility poles, light poles, flag poles, signs, and water towers. 10 “Micro-wireless facility” means a small cell facility that is not larger in dimension than 24 inches 11 in length, 15 inches in width, and 12 inches in height and that has an exterior antenna, if any, not 12 longer than 11 inches. 13 “New structure” means a wireless support structure that has not been installed or constructed, or 14 approved for installation or construction, at the time a wireless services provider or wireless 15 infrastructure provider applies to the City for any required zoning approval. 16 “New wireless support structure” has the same meaning as “new structure.” 17 “Project” means (i) the installation or construction by a wireless services provider or wireless 18 infrastructure provider of a new structure or (ii) the co-location on any existing structure of a 19 wireless facility that is not a small cell facility. “Project” does not include the installation of a 20 small cell facility by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider on an 21 existing structure to which the provisions of Code Virginia § 15.2-2316.4 apply. 22 “Small cell facility” means a wireless facility that meets both of the following qualifications: 23 (i) each antenna is located inside an enclosure of no more than six cubic feet in volume, or, in the 24 case of an antenna that has exposed elements, the antenna and all of its exposed elements could 25 fit within an imaginary enclosure of no more than six cubic feet; and 26 (ii) all other wireless equipment associated with the facility has a cumulative volume of 27 no more than 28 cubic feet, or such higher limit as is established by the Federal Communications 28 Commission. 29 The following types of associated equipment are not included in the calculation of 30 equipment volume: electric meter, concealment, telecommunications demarcation boxes, back-31 5 up power systems, grounding equipment, power transfer switches, cut-off switches, and vertical 1 cable runs for the connection of power and other services. 2 “Standard process project” means any project that is not an administrative review-eligible 3 project. 4 “Utility pole” means a structure owned, operated, or owned and operated by a public utility, local 5 government, or the Commonwealth that is designed specifically for and used to carry lines, 6 cables, or wires for communications, cable television, or electricity. 7 “Water tower” means a water storage tank, or a standpipe or an elevated tank situated on a 8 support structure, originally constructed for use as a reservoir or facility to store or deliver water. 9 “Wireless facility” means equipment at a fixed location that enables wireless communications 10 between user equipment and a communications network, including (i) equipment associated with 11 wireless services, such as private, broadcast, and public safety services, as well as unlicensed 12 wireless services and fixed wireless services, such as microwave backhaul, and (ii) radio 13 transceivers, antennas, coaxial, or fiber optic cable, regular and backup power supplies, and 14 comparable equipment, regardless of technological configuration. 15 “Wireless infrastructure provider” means any person that builds or installs transmission 16 equipment, wireless facilities, or wireless support structures, but that is not a wireless services 17 provider. 18 “Wireless services” means (i) “personal wireless services as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332(C)(7)(i); 19 “personal wireless service facilities” as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332(C)(7)(ii); including 20 commercial mobile services as defined in 47 U.S.C. § 332(d), provided to personal mobile 21 communications devices through wireless facilities, and (iii) any other fixed or mobile wireless 22 service, using licensed or unlicensed spectrum, provided using wireless facilities. 23 “Wireless services provider” means a provider of wireless services. 24 “Wireless support structure” means a freestanding structure, such as a monopole, tower, either 25 guyed or self-supporting, or suitable existing structure or alternative structure designed to 26 support or is capable of supporting wireless facilities. “Wireless support structure” does not 27 include any telephone or electrical utility pole or any tower used for the distribution or 28 transmission of electrical service. 29 § 35.2–73.3 Applicability. 30 The provisions of this chapter shall apply to all land within the jurisdictional boundaries of the 31 City of Lynchburg, provided, however, that the provisions of this chapter shall not apply to any 32 6 small cell facility within the City’s right-of-way or on any City-owned property. Small cell 1 facilities within the City’s right-of-way or on any City-owned property are regulated by §§ 35–2 28, 35–28.1, 35–28.2, 35–28.3, 35–28.4, 35–28.5, 35–28.6, and 35–28.7 of the City Code. 3 4 § 35.2–73.4 Small Cell Facilities. 5 A. Review of Applications for Small Cell Facilities. No conditional use permit or 6 its equivalent shall be required in the City for a small cell facility to be installed on an existing 7 structure if a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider has: (1) permission 8 from the owner to co-locate equipment on that structure; and (2) has notified the City that such 9 permission exists. A permit for the installation of a small cell facility shall be required before a 10 small cell facility may be installed on an existing structure. 11 B. Application Requirements for Small Cell Facilities. Applications filed by 12 a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider for administrative review of a 13 small cell facility on an existing structure shall include the following: 14 1. A valid electronic mail address for the applicant. 15 2. Written proof that the owner of the existing structure has given the applicant 16 consent to install the small cell facility as proposed. 17 3. The name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the 18 applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the parcel(s) of land on which the wireless 19 support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located, then the 20 applicant shall provide written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone 21 number, and the electronic mail address of the owner. 22 4. The valuation map number and address of the parcel of land on which the wireless 23 support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located. 24 5. A plan, drawn to scale, depicting the location and elevation of any small cell 25 facility that is the subject of the application, with engineering drawings showing the actual 26 size of the small cell facility and each component thereof, from which the City can 27 reasonably determine whether the proposed facility meets the definition of a small cell 28 facility. 29 6. Drawings showing where and how the small cell facility is proposed to be 30 attached to the existing structure. 31 7 7. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the proposed 1 facilities meet the standards set forth in this Ordinance, including, but not limited to, the 2 requirements set forth in § 35.2–73.13 (Interference With Public Safety Radio Services) 3 and will not materially interfere with other pre-existing communications facilities or with 4 future communications facilities that have already been designed and planned for a 5 specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety communications 6 facilities. 7 8. Evidence relating to any other factors the applicant believes are relevant to the 8 City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed small cell facility should be 9 approved. 10 9. Payment of an application processing fee of $100.00 each for up to five small cell 11 facilities on a permit application, and payment of a fee of $50 for each additional small cell 12 facility on that permit application. 13 C. Multiple Requests on a Single Application for Small Cell Facilities. Applications 14 filed by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider for a small cell facility to 15 be co-located on an existing structure may include multiple such permit requests on a single 16 application. 17 D. Notification of Incomplete Applic ation for Small Cell Facilities. If an 18 incomplete initial or resubmitted application is filed for a small cell facility to be installed on an 19 existing structure, then the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application 20 is incomplete and shall specify any missing information and documents in accordance with the 21 following: 22 1. for an initial application, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic 23 mail within ten (10) calendar days after receipt of a valid electronic mail address and the 24 application that the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any 25 missing information and documents; otherwise, the application shall be deemed 26 complete; and 27 2. for a resubmitted application for a sm all cell facility to be installed on an 28 existing structure, the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail within ten (10) 29 calendar days after the application is resubmitted whether the application is incomplete 30 and shall specify in that notification any missing information and documents; otherwise, 31 the application shall be deemed complete. 32 E. Deadline for Approval or Disapproval of Small Cell Facilities. The City shall 33 approve or disapprove any application filed by a wireless services provider or wireless 34 infrastructure provider proposing a small cell facility to be installed on an existing structure in 35 accordance with the following: 36 8 1. any such application shall be approv ed or disapproved in writing within 1 sixty (60) calendar days after receipt of the complete application; 2 2. if the applicant files an incomplete initial or resubmitted application and 3 the City notifies the applicant of its incompleteness in accordance with the applicable 4 timeframes set forth in subsection D above (Notification of Incomplete Application for 5 Small Cell Facilities), then the time within which the City must approve or disapprove 6 such an initial application shall be tolled for the period from the date of the submission of 7 the initial incomplete application to the date on which the applicant files a complete 8 application; 9 3. if the applicant files an incomp lete resubmitted application, the time 10 within which the City must approve or disapprove a resubmitted application shall also be 11 tolled for the period from the date of submission of the resubmitted incomplete 12 application to the date on which the applicant resubmits a complete application; 13 4. the initial sixty (60) calendar-day period for the City to approve or 14 disapprove an application for a small cell facility proposed to be installed on an existing 15 structure may be extended by the City in writing for a period not to exceed an additional 16 30 days; 17 5. any such application for a small cell f acility proposed to be installed on an 18 existing structure shall be deemed approved if the City fails to act within the timeframes 19 set forth in this section; 20 6. any disapproval of an application fo r a small cell facility on an existing 21 structures shall be in writing and accompanied by an explanation for the disapproval; and 22 7. approval of a permit for any such sm all cell facility application shall not 23 be unreasonably conditioned, withheld, or delayed. 24 F. Grounds for Disapproval of Small Cell Facilities. The City may disapprove an 25 application filed by a wireless services provider or wireless infrastructure provider proposing the 26 installation of a small cell facility on an existing structure for any of the following reasons: 27 1. Material potential interference with other pre-existing communications 28 facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and 29 planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety 30 communications facilities; 31 2. The safety of the public or ot her critical public service needs; 32 9 3. Only in the case of an installati on on or in publicly owned or publicly 1 controlled property, excluding privately owned structures where the applicant has an 2 agreement for attachment to the structure, aesthetic impact or the absence of all required 3 approvals from all departments, authorities, and agencies with jurisdiction over such 4 property; 5 4. Conflict with a City ordinance adopted pursuant to § 15.2-2306, or 6 pursuant to local charter on a historic property that is not eligible for the review process 7 established under 54 U.S.C § 306108. 8 G. Small Cell Facilities on New Structur es. Any application for the installation 9 of a small cell facility on a new structure shall require any approval that may be required by this 10 chapter for that new structure as either an administrative review-eligible project or a standard 11 process project. 12 § 35.2–73.5 Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. 13 A. Review of Administrative Review -Eligible Projects. Administrative 14 review-eligible projects shall not require that a conditional use permit or its equivalent be 15 obtained for the installation or construction of such a project; but administrative review shall be 16 required for the issuance of any zoning approval, or an acknowledgment that zoning approval is 17 not required, for such a project. 18 B. Application Requirements for Admi nistrative Review-Eligible Projects.19 Applications for wireless support structures, wi reless facilities, and/or base stations that 20 comprise administrative review-eligible projects shall require the following: 21 1. The name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the 22 applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the land on which the wireless support 23 structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located, then the 24 applicant shall provide written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone 25 number, and the electronic mail address of the owner. If the land on which the proposed 26 wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station is proposed to be located is, in 27 whole or in part, within the City’s right-of-way, then the applicant shall be required to 28 secure written consent from the City for the proposed wireless support structure, wireless 29 facility, or base station to be located within the City’s right-of-way prior to filing such 30 application and shall include such written consent as part of any such application. 31 2. An affirmative written statement signed by the applicant and the owner 32 that the applicant and the owner are aware of and agree to comply with the provisions of 33 this Zoning Ordinance set forth in § 35.2-73.24 (Abandonment) regarding removal and 34 dismantlement of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and 35 10 related equipment in the event such a structure, facility, base station, or related equipment 1 is no longer in use. 2 3. The valuation map number and address of the parcel of land on which the 3 wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located. 4 4. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the 5 proposed facilities meet the standards set forth in this Ordinance, including, but not 6 limited to, the requirements set forth in § 35.2–73.13 (Interference With Public Safety 7 Radio Services), and will not materially interfere with other pre-existing communications 8 facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and 9 planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety 10 communications facilities. 11 5. Written, technical evidence from an el ectrical engineer that the proposed 12 site of the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station does not pose a 13 risk of explosion, fire, or other danger due to its proximity to volatile, flammable, 14 explosive, or hazardous materials such as propane, gasoline, natural gas, or corrosive or 15 other dangerous chemicals. 16 6. A site plan, as required by § 35.2-14.2 (Site Plans) of this Ordinance. 17 7. A map showing the location and height of every utility pole within 500 18 feet of and within the same public right-of-way or within the existing line of utility poles 19 as the proposed wireless support structure or wireless facility. 20 8. In the case of an administrative review-eligible project proposing a new 21 structure, a detailed explanation of how the proposed new structure is designed to support 22 small cell facilities. 23 9. A copy of any approval granted by a federal agency, including any 24 conditions imposed by that agency, regarding the proposed wireless support structure, 25 wireless facility, and/or base station, provided, however, that this requirement shall not 26 apply to applications for small cell facilities. 27 10. Evidence relating to any other factors th e applicant believes are relevant to 28 the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed small cell facility should be 29 approved. 30 11. The applicable application fee fo r the proposed administrative review-31 eligible project. 32 11 12. Evidence that the applicant has gi ven written notice to all adjacent 1 landowners regarding the applicant’s intent to file the application at least 15 days before 2 the filing of any application to locate a new structure on the subject property. 3 C. Fee Limitations for Administrative Review-Eligible Projects. When an 4 application for an administrative review-eligible project is filed, the following provisions 5 shall apply to the fee that must be paid by the applicant: 6 1. The fee must be reasonable. 7 2. The fee charged by the City sha ll not include direct payment or 8 reimbursement of third-party fees charged on a contingency basis or a result-based 9 arrangement. 10 3. The City shall not charge market-b ased or value-based fees for the 11 processing of any such application. 12 4. Upon request, the City shall, within a reasonable amount of time after such 13 request, provide the applicant with the cost basis for any fee charged by the City for an 14 administrative review-eligible project. 15 D. Assessment of Fees for Administra tive Review-Eligible Projects. Each 16 application for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station that constitutes an 17 administrative review-eligible project shall be accompanied by payment of a $500 fee for the 18 processing of the application 19 E. Processing Applications for Admini strative Review-Eligible Projects. The 20 following provisions set forth the process that shall apply to any application for an administrative 21 review-eligible project: 22 1. Prior to accepting any application for an administrative review-eligible 23 project, the City shall first determine that the application includes the applicant’s 24 electronic mail address. In the event the application does not include the applicant’s 25 electronic mail address, the City shall not accept it for filing 26 2. If the application is in complete, but includes an electronic mail address for 27 the applicant, then within ten (10) business days after actual receipt of the application, the 28 City shall accept the application and notify the applicant by electronic mail that the 29 application is incomplete and shall specify any additional information, documents and 30 materials required to complete the application. 31 12 3. If the application is incomplete and does not include an electronic mail 1 address for the applicant when it was filed, the City shall use reasonable means to contact 2 the applicant and request the applicant’s electronic mail address. Within ten (10) days 3 after actual receipt of the applicant’s electronic mail address, the City shall notify the 4 applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any 5 additional information, documents and materials required to complete the application. 6 4. If an incomplete initial or resubmitted application is filed for an 7 administrative review-eligible project, then the City shall notify the applicant by 8 electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall specify any missing 9 information and documents and materials in accordance with the following: 10 (a) for an initial application, the City shall notify the applicant by 11 electronic mail within ten (10) business days after the application is submitted 12 whether the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any 13 missing information, documents and materials; otherwise, the application will be 14 deemed complete; and 15 (b) for a resubmitted application, th e City shall notify the applicant by 16 electronic mail within ten (10) days after the application is resubmitted whether 17 the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing 18 information, documents and materials; otherwise, the application will be deemed 19 complete. 20 5. If the City fails to timely provide th e applicant with notice that the initial 21 application or a resubmitted application is incomplete in accordance with the foregoing 22 provisions, as applicable, the application shall be deemed complete. 23 6. Except as provided for in subsection 7 below, the City shall approve or 24 disapprove a complete application in accordance with the following: 25 (a) For a new structure, within 150 days after receipt of the completed 26 application minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the 27 date any notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City; 28 (b) For the modification of an ex isting wireless support structure or 29 base station that involves the co-location of new transmission equipment, the removal of 30 transmission equipment, or the replacement of transmission equipment, but does not 31 substantially change, as that term is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of 32 such support structure or base station, within 60 days after receipt of the application 33 provided, however, that this period shall be tolled during any time after which the 34 applicant has been informed that the application is not complete and is provided with the 35 13 grounds for its incompleteness by the City, and when the applicant files all requested 1 information and items necessary to make the application complete; 2 (c) For the co-location on an existi ng support structure of any wireless 3 facility that is not a small cell facility and substantially changes, as that term is defined by 4 federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or any related base station, 5 within the lesser of 90 days after receipt by the City of the completed application, minus 6 any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the date any notice of 7 incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City; and 8 (d) For any wireless facility that is not a small cell facility on a new 9 structure, within the lesser of 150 days after receipt of a completed application, minus 10 any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the date any notice of 11 incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City . 12 7. Any period specified in subsection 6(a) , 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above within 13 which the City must approve or disapprove an application may be extended by written 14 agreement of the applicant and the City. 15 8. A complete application for an admini strative review-eligible project shall 16 be deemed approved if the City fails to approve or disapprove such application within the 17 applicable period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above or within any 18 agreed extension thereof pursuant to subsection 7 above. 19 9. If the City disapproves an applicatio n for an administrative review-eligible 20 project: 21 (a) the City shall provide the applic ant with a written statement listing 22 all of the reasons for the disapproval; and 23 (b) if the City is aware of any modi fications to the project as described 24 in the application that if made would permit the City to approve the proposed 25 project, the City shall identify them in the written statement provided under 26 subsection 9(a) above. The City’s subsequent disapproval of an application for a 27 project that incorporates the modifications identified in such a written statement 28 may be used by the applicant as evidence that the City’s subsequent disapproval 29 was arbitrary or capricious in any appeal of the City’s subsequent disapproval. 30 10. If an application for an admini strative review-eligible project is 31 disapproved, the City’s disapproval shall: 32 14 (a) not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other 1 wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications 2 services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services; and 3 (b) be supported by substantial r ecord evidence contained in a written 4 record publicly released within 30 days following the disapproval. 5 F. Limitations on Disapprovals of Ad ministrative Review-Eligible Projects.6 Whenever the City receives, considers, a nd processes a complete application for an 7 administrative review-eligible project, it shall not disapprove any such application on the basis 8 of: 9 (a) the applicant’s business decisi on with respect to its designed 10 service, customer demand, or quality of service to or from a particular site; 11 (b) the applicant’s specific need for the project, including the 12 applicant’s desire to provide additional wireless coverage or capacity; or 13 (c) the wireless facility technology selected by the applicant for use at 14 the project. 15 G. Disapproval Considerations for Ad ministrative Review-Eligible Projects.16 Nothing in this Ordinance shall be constr ued to prohibit the City from disapproving an 17 application for an administrative review-eligible project: 18 1. On the basis of the fact that th e proposed height of any wireless support 19 structure, wireless facility, or wireless support structure with attached wireless facilities exceeds 20 50 feet above ground level, provided that the City follows a local ordinance or regulation that 21 does not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, 22 wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services , and other providers 23 of functionally equivalent services; or 24 2. That proposes to locate a new structure, or to co-locate a wireless facility 25 in an area where all cable and public utility facilities are required to be placed 26 underground by a date certain or encouraged to be undergrounded as part of a 27 transportation improvement project or rezoning proceeding as set forth in objectives 28 contained in a comprehensive plan, if: 29 (a) The undergrounding requirement or comprehensive plan objective 30 existed at least three months prior to the submission of the application; 31 15 (b) The City allows the co-locati on of wireless facilities on existing 1 utility poles, government-owned structures with the government’s consent, 2 existing wireless support structures, or a building within that area; 3 (c) The City allows the replacement of existing utility poles and 4 wireless support structures with poles or support structures of the same size or 5 similar within that area; and 6 (d) The disapproval of the application does not unreasonably 7 discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless 8 infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services, and other 9 providers of functionally equivalent services, and other providers of functionally 10 equivalent services. 11 H. Disapproval Limitation If Administra tive Review-Eligible Project Does not 12 Substantially Change Physical Dimensions. The City may not deny, and shall approve, within 13 sixty (60) days, any administrative review-eligible project which requests any modification of an 14 existing base station or wireless support structure that does not substantially change, as that term 15 is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or base station and 16 that involves the co-location of new transmission equipment, the removal of transmission 17 equipment, or the replacement of transmission equipment. 18 I. Disapproval Allowed If Written Notice Not Provided to Adjacent Property 19 Owners. The City may disapprove an application for an administrative review-eligible project if 20 the applicant has not given written notice to all adjacent property owners at least 15 days before 21 the applicant applies to locate a new structure on the subject property. 22 § 35.2–73.6 Standard Process Projects. 23 A. Review of Standard Process Proj ects. Standard process projects may 24 require the approval of a conditional use permit and/or a site plan.for the installation or 25 construction of such a project, and City staff review may also be required for the issuance of any 26 zoning permit, or an acknowledgment that zoning approval is not required, for a standard process 27 project. 28 B. Application Requirements for Standa rd Process Projects. Applications for 29 wireless support structures, wireless facilities, and/or base stations that constitute standard 30 process projects shall include the following: 31 1. The name, address, telephone number, and electronic mail address of the 32 applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the land on which the wireless support 33 structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located, then the 34 applicant shall provide written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone 35 16 number, and the electronic mail address of the owner. If the land on which the proposed 1 wireless support structure, wireless facility, or base station is proposed to be located is, in 2 whole or in part, within the City’s right-of-way, then the applicant shall be required to 3 secure written consent from the City for the proposed wireless support structure, wireless 4 facility, or base station to be located within the City’s right-of-way prior to filing such 5 application and shall include such written consent as part of any such application. 6 2. An affirmative written statement signed by the applicant and the owner 7 that the applicant and the owner are aware of and agree to comply with the provisions of 8 this Zoning Ordinance set forth in § 35.2-73.24 (Abandonment) regarding removal and 9 dismantlement of all wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and 10 related equipment in the event such a structure, facility, base station, or related equipment 11 is no longer in use. 12 3. The valuation map number and address of the parcel of land on which the 13 wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station is proposed to be located. 14 4. The names, addresses, and telephone numbers of the owners of and a map 15 showing the location and height of all wireless support structures or potential wireless 16 support structures taller than fifty (50) feet that are within a one (1) mile radius of the 17 proposed new site for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station, 18 including City-owned property. 19 5. Written documentation that the applicant has made diligent, but 20 unsuccessful, efforts to secure the permission to co-locate the applicant’s proposed 21 wireless facility on an existing or proposed wireless support structure owned by others, 22 including the City, within a one-mile radius of the proposed wireless support structure, 23 wireless facility, and/or base station. 24 6. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the 25 proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, or project cannot be 26 installed or co-located on another existing or proposed wireless support structure within a 27 one (1) mile radius of the proposed site for a wireless support structure, wireless facility, 28 or base station and must be located at the proposed site in order to meet the coverage 29 requirements for applicant’s wireless telecommunications system. 30 7. Written, technical evidence from a st ructural engineer that the proposed 31 wireless support structure can support the wireless facilities and base stations of other 32 carriers for the purposes of co-location. 33 8. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the 34 proposed facilities meet the standards set forth in this Ordinance, including, but not 35 limited to, the requirements set forth in § 35.2–73.13 (Interference With Public Safety 36 17 Radio Services), and will not materially interfere with other pre-existing communications 1 facilities or with future communications facilities that have already been designed and 2 planned for a specific location or that have been reserved for future public safety 3 communications facilities. 4 9. Written, technical evidence from an el ectrical engineer that the proposed 5 site of the wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base station does not pose a 6 risk of explosion, fire, or other danger due to its proximity to volatile, flammable, 7 explosive, or hazardous materials such as propane, gasoline, natural gas, or corrosive or 8 other dangerous chemicals. 9 10. A map of the City and the first half-mile of all bordering communities 10 showing the design of the applicant’s entire existing or proposed telecommunications 11 network. Such map shall, at a minimum, indicate the general location of all proposed or 12 existing sites of the applicant’s wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base 13 stations, and related equipment, the dimensions of the sites, specifications relating to the 14 facilities, and signal area coverage. 15 11. Color photo simulations showing th e proposed site of the proposed 16 wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, or project with a photo-realistic 17 representation of the proposed structure and facility as they would appear viewed from at 18 least four (4) substantially different vantage points on the eight (8) closest residential 19 properties or adjacent roadways.. 20 12. Any initial application fee requi red by § 35.2–73.6(D) (Fees for Standard 21 Process Projects). 22 13. A site plan, including a depiction of the lot lines, setbacks, existing 23 structures and other improvements on the property, the location of adjacent and nearby 24 structures, the proposed location of the proposed wireless support structure, wireless 25 facility, and base station that are the subject of the application, separation distances, 26 proposed height of any new structure, screening and landscaping, existing and proposed, 27 access, parking, security, zoning district(s) for the subject property and all adjacent 28 properties, and any floodplain on the subject property. 29 14. A copy of any approval granted by a federal agency, including any 30 conditions imposed by that agency, regarding the proposed wireless support structure, 31 wireless facility, and/or base station. 32 15. Evidence relating to any other factors th e applicant believes are relevant to 33 the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed standard process project 34 should be approved. 35 18 16. Written documentation regarding whet her and how the location of the 1 proposed wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in relation to existing 2 structures, trees, and other visual buffers, minimizes, to the greatest extent reasonably 3 practicable under the circumstances, any significant negative adverse impact. 4 17. Witten documentation regarding whether and how the location of the 5 wireless support structure and/or wireless facility will not have a significant detrimental 6 impact on the property values of adjacent and nearby properties. 7 18. Written documentation regarding any ot her factors the applicant believes 8 are relevant to the City’s consideration of whether the applicant’s proposed standard 9 process project should be approved. 10 19. Evidence that the applicant has gi ven written notice to all adjacent 11 landowners regarding the applicant’s intent to file the application at least 15 days before 12 the filing of any application to locate a new structure on the subject property 13 C. Fee Limitations for Standard Proce ss Projects. When an application for a 14 standard process project is filed, the following provisions shall apply to the fee that must 15 be paid by the applicant: 16 1. The fee must be reasonable. 17 2. The fee charged by the City sha ll not include direct payment or 18 reimbursement of third-party fees charged on a contingency basis or a result-based 19 arrangement. 20 3. The fee charged by the City shall not exceed the actual direct costs to 21 process the application, including permits and inspection. 22 4. The City shall not charge market-b ased or value-based fees for the 23 processing of any such application. 24 5. Upon request, the City shall, within a reasonable amount of time after such 25 request, provide the applicant with the cost basis for any fee charged by the City for a 26 standard process project. 27 D. Fees for Standard Process Projects. Each application for a wireless support 28 structure, wireless facility, or base station that constitutes a standard process project shall be 29 accompanied by payment of the following fees for the processing of the application: 30 19 1. For an application for a standard pro cess project that requires the approval 1 of a conditional use permit and a site plan, the initial fee shall be $900. 2 2. For an application for a standard pro cess project that requires the approval 3 of a site plan, but not a conditional use permit, the initial fee shall be $500. 4 3. The City reserves the right to employ an outside consultant to assist in the 5 review of any application for a standard process project. In the event the City employs an 6 outside consultant to review an application for a standard process project, the applicant 7 shall reimburse the City for the reasonable expenses related to such review as an 8 additional application fee, provided, however, that the fee limitations set forth in § 35.2–9 73.6(C) (Fee Limitations for Standard Process Projects) shall apply to the calculation of 10 any such additional fee. 11 4. For any standard process project that requires the approval of a conditional 12 use permit, the applicant shall be responsible for the payment of any costs for any legal 13 notices that may be required for the conditional use permit. 14 E. Processing Applications for Sta ndard Process Projects. The following 15 provisions set forth the process that shall apply to any application for a standard process project: 16 1. Prior to accepting any application for a wireless support structure, a 17 wireless facility, or a base station, that constitutes a standard process project, the City 18 shall first determine that the application includes the applicant’s electronic mail address. 19 In the event the application does not include the applicant’s electronic mail address, the 20 City shall not accept it for filing 21 2. If the application is in complete, but includes an electronic mail address for 22 the applicant, then within ten (10) business days after actual receipt of the application, the 23 City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail if the application is incomplete and shall 24 specify in that notification any additional information, documents, and materials required 25 to complete the application. 26 3. If the application is incomplete and does not include a valid electronic 27 mail address for the applicant when it was filed, the City shall use reasonable means to 28 contact the applicant and request the applicant’s valid electronic mail address. Within ten 29 (10) days after actual receipt of a valid electronic mail address for the applicant, the City 30 shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the application is incomplete and shall 31 specify any additional information, documents, and materials required to complete the 32 application. 33 4. If an incomplete initial or resubmitte d application is filed for a standard 34 process project, then the City shall notify the applicant by electronic mail that the 35 20 application is incomplete and shall specify any missing information, documents, and 1 materials in accordance with the following: 2 (a) for an initial application, the City shall notify the applicant by 3 electronic mail within ten (10) business days after the application is submitted 4 whether the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any 5 missing information, documents, and materials; otherwise, the application will be 6 deemed complete; and 7 (b) for a resubmitted application, th e City shall notify the applicant by 8 electronic mail within ten (10) days after the application is resubmitted whether 9 the application is incomplete and shall specify in that notification any missing 10 information, documents and materials; otherwise, the application will be deemed 11 complete. 12 5. If the City fails to timely provide th e applicant with notice that the initial 13 application or a resubmitted application is incomplete in accordance with the foregoing 14 provisions, as applicable, the application shall be deemed complete. 15 6. Except as provided for in subsection 7 below, the City shall approve or 16 disapprove a complete application for a standard process project in accordance with the 17 following: 18 (a) For a new structure, within th e lesser of 150 days after receipt of 19 the completed application minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the 20 application to the date any notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the 21 City ; 22 (b) For the modification of an ex isting wireless support structure or 23 base station that involves the co-location of new transmission equipment, the removal of 24 transmission equipment, or the replacement of transmission equipment, but does not 25 substantially change, as that term is defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of 26 such support structure or base station, within 60 days after receipt of the application 27 provided, however, that this period shall be tolled during any time after which the 28 applicant has been informed that the application is not complete and is provided with the 29 grounds for its incompleteness by the City, and when the applicant files all requested 30 information and items necessary to make the application complete; 31 (c) For the co-location on an existi ng wireless support structure of any 32 wireless facility that is not a small cell facility and substantially changes, as that term is 33 defined by federal law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or any related 34 base station, within the lesser of 90 days after receipt by the City of the completed 35 21 application minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the 1 date any notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City; and 2 (d) For any standard process project that is not a small cell facility on 3 a new structure, within the lesser of 150 days after receipt of a completed application 4 minus any days that expired from the date of filing of the application to the date any 5 notice of incompleteness was given to the applicant by the City . 6 7. Any period specified in subsection 6(a) , 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above within 7 which the City must approve or disapprove an application may be extended by written 8 agreement of the applicant and the City. 9 8. A complete application for a standa rd process project shall be deemed 10 approved if the City fails to approve or disapprove such application within the applicable 11 period specified in subsection 6(a), 6(b), 6(c), or 6(d) above or any agreed extension 12 thereof pursuant to subsection 7 above. 13 9. If the City disapproves an applica tion for a standard process project: 14 (a) the City shall provide the applic ant with a written statement listing 15 all of the reasons for the disapproval; and 16 (b) if the City is aware of any modi fications to the project as described 17 in the application that if made would permit the City to approve the proposed 18 project, the City shall identify them in the written statement provided under 19 subsection 6(a) above. The City’s subsequent disapproval of an application for a 20 project that incorporates the modifications identified in such a written statement 21 may be used by the applicant as evidence that the City’s subsequent disapproval 22 was arbitrary or capricious in any appeal of the City’s subsequent disapproval. 23 10. If an application for a standard pr ocess project is disapproved, the City’s 24 disapproval shall: 25 (a) not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other 26 wireless services providers, wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications 27 services, and other providers of functionally equivalent services; and. 28 (b) be supported by substantial r ecord evidence contained in a written 29 record publicly released within 30 days following the disapproval. 30 22 F. Limitations on Disapprovals of Standa rd Process Projects. Whenever the City 1 receives, considers, and processes a complete application for a standard process project, it shall 2 not disapprove any such application on the basis of: 3 (a) the applicant’s business deci sion with respect to its designed 4 service, customer demand, or quality of service to or from a particular site; 5 (b) the applicant’s specific need for the project, including the 6 applicant’s desire to provide additional wireless coverage or capacity; or 7 (c) the wireless facility technology selected by the applicant for use at 8 the project. 9 G. Disapproval Considerations for Standa rd Process Projects. Nothing in this 10 Ordinance shall be construed to prohibit the City from disapproving an application for a standard 11 process project: 12 1. On the basis of the fact that th e proposed height of any wireless support 13 structure, wireless facility, or wireless support structure with attached wireless facilities exceeds 14 50 feet above ground level, provided that the City follows a local ordinance or regulation that 15 does not unreasonably discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, 16 wireless infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services , and other providers 17 of functionally equivalent services; or 18 2. That proposes to locate a new structure, or to co-locate a wireless facility 19 in an area where all cable and public utility facilities are required to be placed 20 underground by a date certain or encouraged to be undergrounded as part of a 21 transportation improvement project or rezoning proceeding as set forth in objectives 22 contained in a comprehensive plan, if: 23 (a) The undergrounding requirement or comprehensive plan objective 24 existed at least three months prior to the submission of the application; 25 (b) The City allows the co-locati on of wireless facilities on existing 26 utility poles, government-owned structures with the government’s consent, 27 existing wireless support structures, or a building within that area; 28 (c) The City allows the replacement of existing utility poles and 29 wireless support structures with poles or support structures of the same size or 30 similar within that area; and 31 23 (d) The disapproval of the application does not unreasonably 1 discriminate between the applicant and other wireless services providers, wireless 2 infrastructure providers, providers of telecommunications services, and other 3 providers of functionally equivalent services, and other providers of functionally 4 equivalent services. 5 H. Disapproval Limitation If Standard Pr ocess Project Does not Substantially 6 Change Physical Dimensions. The City may not deny, and shall approve, within sixty (60) days, 7 any standard process project which requests any modification of an existing base station or 8 wireless support structure that does not substantially change, as that term is defined by federal 9 law, the physical dimensions of such support structure or base station and that involves the co-10 location of new transmission equipment, the removal of transmission equipment, or the 11 replacement of transmission equipment. 12 I. Disapproval Allowed If Written Notice Not Provided to Adjacent Property 13 Owners. The City may disapprove an application for a standard process project if the applicant 14 has not given written notice to all adjacent property owners at least 15 days before the applicant 15 applies to locate a new structure on the subject property. 16 § 35.2–73.7 Permitted Uses. 17 A. The following uses shall be permitted by right as follows: 18 1. Small cell facilities in all zoning districts. 19 2. Administrative review-eligible pr ojects in all zoning districts. 20 3. Any wireless support structure and/ or wireless facility that does not 21 exceed one hundred (100) feet in height in the B–1 District. 22 4. Any wireless support structure and/ or wireless facility that does not 23 exceed one hundred and fifty (150) feet in height in the B–3, B–5, IN–2, 24 I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts. 25 5. Any base station associated with a lawfully existing wireless support 26 structure and/or wireless facility, provided, however, that: 27 (a) the base station shall be lo cated inside the wireless support 28 structure; or 29 (b) the base station shall be located on the ground within 50 feet of the 30 base of the wireless support structure; or 31 24 (c) the base station is not visible at ground level from off-site; and 1 (d) the size of the base station sha ll not exceed seventy-two (72) cubic 2 feet in size and/or six (6) feet in height; and 3 (e) all applicable setbacks shall be complied with. 4 6. The co-location of a wireless faci lity on a lawfully existing wireless 5 support structure in any zoning district, provided, however, that: 6 (a) the height of any such wireless support structure, wireless facility, 7 or wireless support structure with wireless facility attached, shall not increase as a result 8 of the co-location; and 9 (b) all applicable setbacks must be complied with. 10 B. Existing wireless support structures and wi reless facilities shall be exempt from 11 the maximum height restrictions of the districts in which they are located to the extent such 12 structures and facilities lawfully existed on the date of adoption of this Ordinance. 13 § 35.2-73.8 Conditional Use Permit Required. 14 A. The following uses require the approval of a conditional use permit by the City 15 Council: 16 1. In the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 Districts, any standard 17 process project that is between fifty (50) and one hundred and fifty (150) feet in height, 18 provided, however, that no new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in such 19 districts shall exceed 150 feet in height; 20 2. In the B–1 District, any standard pr ocess project in which a new wireless 21 support structure and/or wireless facility exceeds one hundred (100) feet in height; 22 provided, however, that the maximum height for any wireless facility and/or wireless 23 support structure in the B–1 District shall be 150 feet; 24 3. In the B–3, B–5, IN–2, I–1, I–2, or I –3 Districts, any standard process 25 project in which a new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility exceeds one 26 hundred fifty (150) feet in height; 27 4. Any base station that is a standard process project and exceeds seventy-28 two cubic feet above ground and/or six feet in height; 29 25 5. Any base station associated with a lawfully existing wireless support 1 structure and/or wireless facility that is a standard process project, is not located inside 2 the wireless support structure, is visible at ground level from off-site, and/or is not 3 located within 50 feet of the base of the wireless support structure; 4 6. The co-location of a wireless faci lity on a lawfully existing wireless 5 support structure in any zoning district that, after the proposed co-location, would result 6 in an increase in height of the wireless support structure and/or wireless facility, 7 provided, however, that no such structure and/or facility shall be allowed to increase 8 more than fifteen (15) feet in height as a result of the approval of such a conditional use 9 permit; and 10 7. Any other project that constitu tes a standard process project. 11 B. Whenever a conditional use permit is requi red for a proposed wireless structure or 12 wireless facility, any application for such a conditional use permit shall be made to the City 13 Planner in the manner provided in Article 2 of this Zoning Ordinance. In districts for which a 14 conditional use permit is required, the City Council shall make its decision to approve or deny 15 such permit in writing and in a manner consistent with applicable state and federal law. 16 C. Any wireless support structure, wirele ss facility, or base station that is not 17 permitted by right or upon the approval of a conditional use permit under this Ordinance shall be 18 considered to be in violation of this Ordinance. 19 D. No new wireless support structure and/or wireless facility for which a conditional 20 use permit is approved shall exceed a maximum height of one hundred fifty (150) feet in 21 the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 Districts. 22 35.2-73.9 Setbacks. 23 A. There shall be no setback requirement for any wireless support structure and/or 24 wireless facility that is thirty-five (35) feet or less in height. 25 B. Any wireless support structur e and/or wireless facility greater than thirty-five (35) 26 feet in height in the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 Districts shall be required to set 27 back a distance from all property lines at least the height of such structure and/or facility. 28 C. Any wireless support structur e and/or wireless facility greater than thirty-five (35) 29 feet in height in the B–1, B–3, B–5, IN–2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts that is on a parcel adjacent to 30 any parcel that is zoned R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–4 shall be set back a distance at 31 least the height of such structure and/or facility from the R–C, R–1, R–2, R–3, R–4, IN–1, or B–32 4 District. 33 26 D. Any wireless support stru cture and/or wireless facility in the B–1, B–3, B–5, IN–1 2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts that is greater than thirty-five (35) feet in height but less than fifty 2 (50) feet in height shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the 3 minimum applicable setback for the district in which it is located. 4 E. Any wireless support structure and/or wireless facility in the B–1, B–3, B–5, IN–5 2, I–1, I–2, or I–3 Districts that is a height greater than fifty (50) feet shall be required to set 6 back a distance from all property lines at least one-half the height of such structure and/or 7 facility. 8 F. Setback requirements for wireless suppor t structures and/or wireless facilities 9 shall be measured from the base of the structure and/or facility to the property lines of the parcel 10 on which the structure and/or facility is located. 11 §35.2-73.10 Standards for Conditional Use Permits for Standard Process Projects. 12 In order to approve a conditional use permit for a standard process project, the City 13 Council must find that the application for such project satisfies all of the following standards: 14 1. The proposed use is in substantial conformance with the provisions of the 15 City’s Comprehensive Plan. 16 2. The proposed use will not result in any significant adverse impact on the 17 use and enjoyment of nearby properties. 18 3. The proposed use will not have any significant negative impact on the 19 value of nearby properties. 20 4. The proposed use will not cause any material potential interference with 21 other pre-existing communications facilities or with future communications facilities that 22 have already been planned or designed for a specific location or that have been reserved 23 for future public safety communications facilities. 24 5. The proposed use will not result in any significant adverse impact on 25 public safety or other critical public service needs. 26 6. The proposed use must be compatible with the character of the area in 27 which it is proposed to be located. 28 7. There are no existing wireless suppo rt structures within a reasonable 29 distance from the proposed wireless support structure, wireless facility, and/or base 30 27 station that are available to be used for co-location at reasonable terms and conditions 1 without imposing technical limitations on the applicant. 2 8. The proposed use shall not conflict with any City ordinance adopted 3 pursuant to Code of Virginia § 15.2-2306, or pursuant to local charter on a historic 4 property that is not eligible for the review process established under 54 U.S.C. § 306108. 5 9. The proposed use satisfies all other applicable requirements set forth in 6 this chapter with respect to the location, size, design, and construction of wireless support 7 structures, wireless facilities, and base stations. 8 §35.2-73.11 Use of City-Owned Property for Wireless Facilities. 9 The City may authorize the use of City prope rty for wireless facilities in appropriately 10 zoned districts in accordance with the procedures of the City charter and code. The City shall 11 have no obligation whatsoever to allow the use of City property for such purposes and any such 12 approval by the City shall be subject to the discretion of the City Council. 13 §35.2–73.12 Co-Location Availability. 14 An application for a standard process project may be disapproved by the City on 15 the basis of the availability of the existence of one or more wireless support structures within a 16 reasonable distance that could be used for co-location at reasonable terms and conditions without 17 imposing technical limitations on the applicant. 18 § 35.2–73.13 Interference With Public Safety Radio Services. 19 In order to ensure that the City’s public safety radio services will be free from 20 harmful or destructive interference, all applicants requesting a permit to establish or install a 21 wireless support structure or wireless facility shall: 22 A. Demonstrate compliance with good engineering practices; 23 B. Not cause material potential interference to the City’s existing 24 public safety radio services or to future communications facilities 25 that have already been designed and planned for a specific location 26 or that have been reserved for future public safety communications 27 facilities; and 28 C. Comply with all FCC regulations regarding susceptibility to radio 29 frequency interference, frequency coordination requirements, 30 general technical standards for power, antenna bandwidth 31 28 limitations, frequency stability, transmitter measurements, 1 operating requirements, and any and all other federal statutory and 2 regulatory requirements relating to radio frequency interference 3 (RFI), provided, however, that this subparagraph (C) shall not 4 apply to applications for small cell facilities. 5 § 35.2-73.14 Structural Requirements. 6 All wireless support structures and wireless facilities must be designed and certified by a 7 structural engineer licensed in the Commonwealth of Virginia to be structurally sound 8 and, at a minimum, in conformance with the Virginia Uniform Statewide Building Code 9 and any other applicable standards set forth in this chapter. 10 § 35.2-73.15 Method of Determining Height of A Wireless Support Structure. 11 Measurement of the height of a wireless s upport structure for the purpose of determining 12 compliance with all requirements of this chapter shall include the wireless support structure itself 13 and any wireless facilities associated with the wireless support structure, and any other support 14 features installed thereon which extend over the top of the structure itself. Structure height shall 15 be measured from grade. 16 § 35.2-73.16 Illumination. 17 Wireless support structures whose princi pal use is the facilitation of wireless 18 telecommunications shall not be artificially lighted except as may be required by the FAA. 19 § 35.2–73.17 Exterior Finish. 20 Wireless support structures and wireless facilities not requiring painting or marking by 21 the FAA shall be painted a neutral color. A galvanized finish is considered a neutral color. 22 § 35.2–73.18 Landscaping. 23 All landscaping on parcels containing wireless support structures, wireless facilities, 24 and/or base stations shall be designed to screen the structure, facilities, base station, and related 25 equipment to a height of at least six (6) feet from grade. This requirement may be waived at the 26 discretion of the planning division if the base of the structure, facilities, base station, and related 27 equipment to be screened is not located in and is not visible from any commercial or residential 28 district or from any public street. All required landscaping shall be continually maintained in a 29 healthy and attractive manner. 30 31 29 § 35.2-73.19 Security. 1 All wireless support structures and wireless facilities shall be reasonably posted and 2 secured to prevent against trespass. 3 § 35.2–73.20 Access. 4 All parcels upon which wireless support structures are located must provide access during 5 normal business hours to at least one (1) paved vehicular parking space on site. 6 § 35.2–73.21 Maintenance. 7 A. The owners and operators of all wire less support structures, wireless facilities, 8 base stations, and related equipment shall at all times employ ordinary and reasonable care in 9 maintaining such structures, facilities, base stations, and equipment and shall install and maintain 10 in use nothing less than commonly accepted methods and devices for the prevention of failures 11 and accidents which are likely to cause damage, injuries, or nuisances to the public, provided, 12 however, that no zoning approval of the City shall be required for routine maintenance of any 13 existing wireless support structure or wireless facility. 14 B. The owners and operators of all wire less support structures, wireless facilities, 15 and base stations shall at all times employ ordinary and reasonable care and shall install and 16 maintain such wireless support structures, wireless facilities, base stations, and equipment in 17 substantial compliance with the requirements of the national electric safety code and all federal, 18 state, and local regulations and in such manner that will not interfere with the use and enjoyment 19 of other property. 20 C. All wireless support struct ures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related 21 equipment shall at all times be kept and maintained in good condition, order, and repair so that 22 the same shall not menace or endanger the life or property of any person. 23 D. All wireless support struct ures, wireless facilities, base stations, and related 24 equipment shall be maintained in compliance with any applicable radio frequency emission 25 standards of the FCC. 26 E. In the event the use of any wireless support structure, wireless facility, base 27 station, and related equipment is discontinued by the owner or operator thereof, or in the event 28 the owner or operator thereof files notice with the FCC or any other federal agency of its interest 29 in ceasing to operate any wireless support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related 30 equipment, said owner or operator shall, within thirty (30) days, provide written notice to the 31 City of its intent to discontinue such use and the date when such use shall be discontinued. If the 32 facility in question, or any part thereof, is located within the City’s right-of-way, then the owner 33 30 or operator shall submit the foregoing written notice to the Department of Public Works. If the 1 facility in question, or any part thereof, is located outside the City’s right-of-way, then the owner 2 or operator shall submit the foregoing written notice to the Department of Community 3 Development. 4 § 35.2–73.22 Stealth. 5 The City encourages, but doe s not require, the installation of small cell facilities and 6 administrative review-eligible projects that employ stealth designs and blend into the 7 environments in which they are proposed to be located. All standard process projects proposing 8 wireless support structures and wireless facilities shall be of stealth design. For purposes of this 9 section, the term “stealth design” refers to a wireless support structure and wireless facility that is 10 designed in such a way as to effectively blend into the environment in which that structure is 11 proposed to be located. Examples of stealth designs include, but are not limited to, a wireless 12 support structure in a wooded area that is designed to look like a tree, a wireless facility that is 13 encased in a flagpole, a wireless support structure on a church property that is designed to look 14 like a bell tower or church steeple, and a wireless support structure in an agricultural area that is 15 designed to look like a farm silo. 16 § 35.2-73.23 Existing Wireless Support Structures. 17 A. An existing wireless support structur e may be modified or demolished and rebuilt 18 to accommodate the co-location of additional wireless facilities and base stations as follows: 19 1. Application for a permit for any wirele ss facility or base station, other than 20 a small cell facility, located, in whole or in part, within the City’s right-of-way shall be made to 21 the Department of Public Works. 22 2. Application for a permit for any wirele ss facility or base station located, in 23 whole or in part, outside the City’s right-of-way shall be made to the Department of Community 24 Development. 25 3. The total height of the new or modi fied wireless support structure and any 26 wireless facilities installed thereon shall not exceed the height of the existing wireless 27 support structure or the maximum height allowed for wireless support structures 28 permitted by right in the applicable zoning district under this ordinance whichever is 29 greater. 30 B. The City may not deny and shall approve any request to modify the physical 31 dimensions of an existing wireless tower or base station if that request does not substantially 32 increase the physical dimensions of such tower or base station and involves: 33 31 (1) co-location of new transmission equipment; 1 (2) removal of transmission equipment; or 2 (3) replacement of transmission equipment. 3 § 35.2–73.24 Abandonment. 4 If the City receives notice pursuant to § 35.2-73.21(E), or if any wireless support structure, 5 wireless facility, base station, and/or related equipment shall cease to be used for a period of 6 one hundred eighty (180) consecutive days, then for wireless support structures, wireless 7 facilities, base stations and/or related equipment inside the City’s right-of-way, the 8 Department of Public Works shall notify the owner and/or operator of such structure, 9 facility, base station, and related equipment, with a copy to the applicant therefor, that the 10 site will be subject to a determination by the Department of Public Works that such site has 11 been abandoned. In the event such structure, facility, base station, and related equipment is 12 located outside the City’s right-of-way, then the foregoing notification and determination 13 shall be made by the Department of Community Development. The owner, operator, and/or 14 applicant shall have thirty (30) days from receipt of said notice to show, by a preponderance 15 of the evidence, that the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and/or related 16 equipment has been in use or under repair during the period. If the owner, operator, and/or 17 applicant fails to show that the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and/or 18 related equipment has been in use or under repair during the period, the Department of 19 Public Works, or Department of Community Development, whichever applies, ashall issue a 20 final determination of abandonment for the site. Upon issuance of the City’s final 21 determination, the owner, operator, and/or applicant shall, within seventy-five (75) days, 22 dismantle and remove the support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related 23 equipment. If the owner, operator, and/or applicant fails to remove the abandoned support 24 structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment within seventy-five (75) days 25 after the City’s final determination of abandonment, the City and/or its agents may, at its 26 option, enter upon the property and dismantle, remove, and lawfully dispose of the support 27 structure, wireless facility, base station, and related equipment that has been determined by 28 the City to have been abandoned. The City may place a lien on the property of the owner 29 from which the abandoned support structure, wireless facility, base station, or related 30 equipment was removed in the amount of the City’s expenses in dismantling, removing, and 31 lawfully disposing of such support structure, wireless facility, base station, and related 32 equipment. The City also may recover from the owner, operator, and/or applicant the costs 33 of dismantling, removing, and lawfully disposing of the support structure, wireless facility, 34 base station, and related equipment from the owner. For purposes of this section, removal 35 includes all physical improvements associated with the support structure, wireless facility, 36 base station, and related equipment, including foundation and tower grounding. 37 § 35.2–73.25 Miscellaneous Provisions. 38 32 A. Voluntary Conditions Allowed. Nothing in this Ordinance shall prohibit an 1 applicant from voluntarily submitting, and the City from accepting, any 2 conditions that otherwise address potential visual or aesthetic effects resulting 3 from the placement of any new structure or wireless facility, including small cell 4 facility. 5 B. Micro-Wireless Facilities Exemption. Nothing in this Ordinance shall be 6 construed to require any permitting requirements and fees imposed by the City for 7 the installation, placement, maintenance, or replacement of micro-wireless 8 facilities that are suspended on cables or lines that are strung between existing 9 utility poles in compliance with national safety codes, because the installation, 10 placement, maintenance, or replacement of such facilities are exempt from any 11 City-imposed permitting requirements and fees. 12 C. Limitations on Review of Administrativ e Review-Eligible Projects and Standard 13 Process Projects. Whenever the City receives, considers, and processes an 14 application for an administrative review-eligible project or a standard process 15 project, it shall not: 16 1. Discriminate or create a preference on the basis of the ownership by the 17 City, of any property, structure, base station, or wireless support structure 18 when promulgating rules or procedures for siting wireless facilities or for 19 evaluating applications; 20 2. Impose any unreasonable requirement s or obligations regarding the 21 presentation or appearance of a project, including unreasonable 22 requirements relating to (i) the kinds of materials used or (ii) the 23 arranging, screening, or landscaping of wireless facilities or wireless 24 structures; 25 3. Impose any requirement that an appli cant purchase, subscribe to, use, or 26 employ facilities, networks, or services owned, provided, or operated by 27 the City, in whole or in part, by the City or by any other entity in which 28 the City has a competitive, economic, financial, governance, or other 29 interest; 30 4. Condition or require the approval of an application solely on the basis of 31 the applicant’s agreement to allow any wireless facilities provided or 32 operated, in whole or in part, by the City, or by any other entity, to be 33 placed at or co-located with the applicant’s project; 34 33 5. Impose a setback or fall zone requiremen t for a project that is larger than a 1 setback or fall zone area that is imposed on other types of similar 2 structures of a similar size, including utility poles; 3 6. Limit the duration of the approval of an application, except the City may 4 require that construction of the approved project shall commence within 5 two years after final approval and be diligently pursued to completion; and 6 7. Require an applicant to perform servi ces unrelated to the project described 7 in the application, including restoration work on any surface not disturbed 8 by the applicant’s project. 9 D. Nothing in this chapter shall prohibit the City from disapproving an application 10 submitted under a standard process project on the basis of availability of existing 11 wireless support structures within a reasonable distance that could be used for co-12 location at reasonable terms and conditions without imposing technical limitations 13 on the applicant. 14 E. No zoning approval shall be required for (i) routine maintenance or (ii) the 15 replacement of wireless facilities or wireless support structures within a six-foot 16 perimeter with wireless facilities or wireless support structures that are 17 substantially similar or smaller; provided, however, that the City may require a 18 permit to work within the right-of-way for the activities described in clause (i) or 19 (ii), if applicable. 20 F. Nothing in this chapter shall prohibit the City from limiting the number of new 21 structures or the number of wireless facilities that can be installed in a specific 22 location. 23 G. Nothing in this chapter shall be cons trued to require an applicant to provide 24 proprietary, confidential, or other business information to justify the need for a 25 project, including propagation maps and telecommunications traffic studies, or 26 information reviewed by a federal agency as part of the approval process for the 27 same structure and wireless facility 28 H. All information submitted with an applica tion that is a trade secret or proprietary 29 shall be clearly marked as such when submitted to the City. The City shall not 30 disclose publicly, or to any third party, any such proprietary information unless 31 compelled to do so by federal, state, or local law. 32 § 35.2–73.26 Reservation of Rights. 33 34 The City reserves the right to impose any other reasonable conditions it determines are necessary 1 for the proper placement, construction, or modification of wireless support structures, wireless 2 facilities, or base stations and/or to impose any other reasonable conditions on the issuance of a 3 conditional use permit for the placement or construction of, or modification to, a wireless support 4 structure, wireless facility, or base station, provided, however, that the imposition of any such 5 conditions must be in conformance with federal and state law and the provisions of this chapter. 6 This ordinance shall become effective upon adoption. 7 8 PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING: xxxx xx, 2020 9 CITY COUNCIL PUBLIC HEARING: _________________ 10 11 ENACTED: ______________________ 12 13 ATTEST: 14 15 ______________________________ 16 City Clerk 17 18 19 Telecommunications Ordinance J. Patrick Taves Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC Tom Martin, AICP City Planner Planning Commission Public Hearing December 9, 2020 Purpose and Outline Purpose: Discuss the proposed Telecommunications Ordinance Outline: 1. State and Federal mandates 2. Types of facilities – Small Cell, AREP, Standard Process Projects 3. Timelines for review 4. Where permitted - Height 5. Setbacks 2 Proposed regulations depend on the size of the facility. Three Types of Cell Facilities: • SMALL CELL FACILITIES: no more than 6 cu. ft. of volume for each antenna and no more than 28 cu. ft. of volume for all other wireless equipment • ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW ELIGIBLE PROJECTS (“AREPs”): not more than 50 ft. in height or co- location on any existing structure of a facility that is not a small cell facility • STANDARD PROCESS PROJECTS: any project that is not an AREP 3 Different Rules for Each Type of Facility. • Deadlines for Completeness of Applications---applications can be “deemed complete” • Fee Limitations • Deadlines for Decisions---applications can be “deemed approved” • Limited Grounds for Disapprovals • Different Rules for Different Facilities 4 Small Cell Facilities in the City’s Rights-of-Way and on City Property • Regulated by the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance (City Code Sections 35-28, 25-28.1, 35-28.2, 35-28.3, 35-28.4, 35-28.5, 35-28.6, and 35-28.7). • The New Telecommunications Ordinance provisions do not apply to these facilities. 5 Small Cell Facilities---Limited Reasons for Disapproval City can disapprove on existing structures for only four reasons: 1. Material potential interference with existing or future facilities designed and planned for a specific location or reserved for public safety communications 2. Safety of the public or other critical public service needs 3. Aesthetic impact, but only on publicly owned or publicly controlled property---but if the City owns the property or the structure, then the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance controls 4. Conflict with a historic distri ct ordinance, but only if that property is not eligible for a specified federal review process 6 Permitted Uses: • All Small Cell Facilities in all districts---CUPs cannot be required • All AREPs in all districts (50 feet or less in height)---CUPs cannot be required • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-1 District 100 feet or less • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts 150 feet or less • Any base station for a lawfully existing wireless facility or structure meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure meeting specified requirements 7 Conditional Use Permits Can Only Be Required For Standard Process Projects: • Standard Process Projects between 50 and 150 feet in height in the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1, and B-4 Districts • Standard Process Projects that exceed 100 feet in height in the B-1 District, but no greater than 150 feet • Standard Process Projects that exceed 150 feet in height in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts • Standard process project base stations meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure that increases the height of the facility, but any height increase is limited to no more than 15 feet • Any other standard process project 8 Standards for CUP’s – Standard Process Projects Only: • Substantial conformance with the Comprehensive Plan • No significant adverse impact on use and enjoyment of nearby properties • No significant negative impact on property values • No material potential interference with pre-existing facilities or for future planned facilities planned or designed for a specific location or any reserved for future public safety facilities* • No significant adverse impact on public safety or public service needs* • No available and existing wireless support structures nearby • Not in conflict with the City historic district ordinance* • Satisfies all other applicable requirements 9 Setbacks for Similar Structures: • Virginia law provides that the City cannot impose a setback or fall zone requirement that is larger than the setback or fall zone requirement “that is imposed on other types of similar structures of a similar size, including utility poles. • As a result, we propose establishing setbacks for wireless support structures that provide the same setbacks for wireless support structures as are applied to light poles, utility poles, and flag poles of a similar size. 10 Separate Amendment for Setbacks for Similar Structures: • No setback for flag poles, light poles or utility poles (“poles”) that are less than 35’ in height. • Poles greater than 35’ in height set back at a 1:1 in R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3. R-4, IN-1 or B-4 Districts. • Poles greater than 35’ in height in B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District and adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, IN-1 or B-4 District set back at 1:1 • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District between 35’ and 50’ must meet underlying district setback • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District greater than 50’ set back at least ½ the height of the pole. 11 Discussion: Discussion 12 To: Planning Commission From: Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner CC: Reid Woodicka, Interim City Manager, Ke nt White, Interim Deputy City Manager, Walter Erwin, City Attorney, Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator Date: November 11, 2020 Re: Telecommunications Ordinance Revisions – Work Session The City’s Telecommunications Ordinance was last updated December 1997 with minor amendments in January 2000. The current ordinance is no longer compliant with State or Federal Laws. The proposed Telecommunications Ordinance was drafted with the assistance of J. Patrick Taves, Greehan, Taves & Pandek, PLLC. Mr. Taves will be in attendance at the November 11, 2020 Planning Commission work session to discuss the proposed amendments to the Telecommunications Ordinance. If you have questions, please contact me at (434) 455-3909 or tom.martin@lynchburgva.gov. Attachments:  Telecommunications Ordinance Slides  Draft Telecommunications Ordinance  Draft Revisions to Section 35.2-61.2 Telecommunications Ordinance J. Patrick Taves Greehan, Taves & Pandak, PLLC Tom Martin, AICP City Planner Planning Commission Work Session November 11, 2020 Purpose and Outline Purpose: Discuss required updates to the Telecommunications Ordinance Outline: 1. Reasons for updates 2. Types of facilities – Small Cell, AREP, Standard Process Projects 3. Timelines for review 4. Where permitted - Height 5. Setbacks 2 Why does the City need a new Telecommunications Ordinance? • Last overhaul of the City’s Telecommunications Ordinance was in December 1997 with minor amendments in January 2000 • Amendments to the Virginia Code in 2017, 2018, and 2020 regarding telecom facilities---new terminology and rules. • Federal law on telecom facilities is evolving. 3 What are some of the changes that are needed? Three Types of Cell Facilities: • Small cell facilities • Administrative review-eligible projects (“AREPs”) • Standard process projects 4 Other Changes • Deadlines for Completeness of Applications • Fee Limitations • Deadlines for Decisions • Different Rules for Different Facilities 5 Small Cell Facilities**: • “. . . A wireless facility that meets both of the following qualifications: (i) each antenna is located inside an enclosure of no more than six cubic feet in volume, or, in the case of an antenna that has exposed elements, the antenna and all its exposed elements could fit within an imaginary enclosure of no more than six cubic feet and (ii) all other wireless equipment associated with the facility that has a cumulative volume of no more than 28 cubic feet, or such higher limit as is established by the Federal Communications Commission. 6 Small Cell Facilities May be Larger Than You Think: Associated equipment does not include: • electric meter • concealment • telecommunications demarcation boxes • back-up power systems • grounding equipment • power transfer switches • cut-off switches • vertical cable runs for the connection of power and other services So it could really be more than 28 cubic feet! 7 ** Really Small Facilities are Exempt: Micro-wireless facility: “means a small cell facility that is not larger in dimension than 24 inches in length, 15 inches in width, and 12 inches in height and that has an exterior antenna, if any, not longer than 11 inches.” Va. Code Section 15.2-2316.4(C) provides that micro-wireless facilities are exempt from locality-imposed permitting requirements and fees if “suspended on cables or lines that are strung between existing utility poles” in compliance with national safety codes. 8 Small Cell Facilities in the City’s Rights-of-Way and on City Property • Regulated by the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance (City Code Sections 35-28, 25-28.1, 35-28.2, 35-28.3, 35-28.4, 35-28.5, 35-28.6, and 35-28.7. • The New Telecommunications Ordinance provisions do not apply to these facilities. 9 Small Cell Facility Requirements, Part 1: • CUPs cannot be required • Application can be deemed complete if City acts late • Fee limitations • City has 60 days to approve or disapprove • City can unilaterally extend by 30 days in writing • Any disapproval must be in writing and state the reasons • Application deemed approved if City acts late 10 Small Cell Facility Requirements, Part 2: City can disapprove on existing structures for only four reasons: 1. Material potential interference with existing or future facilities designed and planned for a specific location or reserved for public safety communications 2. Safety of the public or other critical public service needs 3. Aesthetic impact, but only on publicly owned or publicly controlled property---but if the City owns the structure, then the City’s Small Cell Facility Ordinance controls 4. Conflict with a historic distri ct ordinance, but only if that property is not eligible for a specified federal review process 11 Administrative Review-Eligible Projects (“AREPs): “a project that provides for: 1. The installation or construction of a new structure that is not more than 50 feet above the ground level, provided that the structure with attached wireless facilities is (i) not more than 10 feet above the tallest existing utility pole located within 500 feet of the new structure within the same public right-of-way or within the existing line of utility poles; (ii) not located inside the jurisdictional boundaries of a local, state, or federal historic district; . . . (iv) designed to support small cell facilities; or 2. The co-location on any existing structure of a wireless facility that is not a small cell facility.” 12 AREPs, Part 1: • CUPs cannot be required • Application can be deemed complete if City acts late (10 days) • Fee limits: -shall not exceed $500 -must be reasonable -no market-based or value-based fees -no direct payment or reimbursement of 3rd party fees • City can extend by 30 days in writing with applicant’s agreement • Any disapproval must be in writing and state the reasons 13 AREPs, Part 2: • 150 days to act on an application for a new structure • 60 days to act on an application for a modification, a co-location, removal or replacement of equipment if application does not substantially change the physical dimensions of the structure • 90 days to act on the co-location on an existing structure of any wireless facility that is not a small cell facility and substantially changes the physical dimensions • 150 days to act on any wireless facility that is not a small cell facility on a new structure • Applications are deemed approved if the City does not act timely 14 AREPs, Part 3: • Disapproval of AREPs not allowed on the basis of: -applicant’s decision re: its designed service, customer demand, or quality of service -applicant’s specific need for the project -the wireless technology involved • If an AREP is disapproved, the City must: -provide a written statement stating all reasons -state in writing any modifications that would permit the City to approve the project -not unreasonably discriminate between providers -publicly release within 30 days substantial record evidence in writing that supports the action 15 AREPs, Part 4: • If the AREP requests: a. the modification of an existing wireless support structure; or b. co-location of new transmission equipment; or c. removal or replacement of transmission equipment; and • that request does not substantially change the physical dimensions, then the City may not deny it and shall approve it within 60 days • What does “SUBSTANTIAL CHANGE” mean? - For a new antenna array outside the R-O-W, the FCC says it is not a “substantial change” if there is no more than 20 feet of separation from the top of the nearest existing antenna to the bottom of the proposed new antenna 16 AREPs, Part 5: • Disapprovals---Disapproval of AREPs are allowed: -if the proposed height exceeds 50 feet and the City follows a local ordinance that does not unreasonably discriminate between providers • Aesthetics---Nothing prohibits an applicant from voluntarily submitting, and the City from accepting, any conditions that address potential visual or aesthetic effects resulting from the placement of a new structure or facility • 2020 Bone to Localities---The City can disapprove an AREP if the applicant has failed to give written notice to all adjacent property owners within at least 15 days before filing the application (this provision also applies to Standard Process Projects) 17 Standard Process Projects: • “. . . Any project that is not an administrative review-eligible project.” 18 Standard Process Projects, Part 1: • CUPs can be required • Fee limits: -must be reasonable -cannot exceed City’s actual direct costs -no market-based or value-based fees -no direct payment or 3rd party fees • Application deemed complete if City acts late • Can be disapproved on the basis of availability of an existing wireless support structure within a reasonable distance • Any disapproval must be in writing and state the reasons 19 Standard Process Projects, Part 2: THESE ARE THE SAME AS THE REQUIREMENTS FOR AREPS: • 150 days to act on an application for a new structure • 60 days to act on an application for a modification, a co-location, removal or replacement of equipment if application does not substantially change the physical dimensions of the structure • 90 days to act on the co-location on an existing structure of any wireless facility that is not a small cell facility and substantially changes the physical dimensions • applications are deemed approved if the City does not act timely • the Applicant can agree to extend deadline, but City cannot extend unilaterally 20 Standard Process Projects, Part 3: SAME REQUIREMENTS AS FOR AREPS: • Disapproval of Standard Process Projects not allowed on the basis of: -applicant’s decision re: its designed service, customer demand, or quality of service -applicant’s specific need for the project -the wireless technology involved • If a Standard Process Project is disapproved, the City must: -provide a written statement stating all reasons -state in writing any modifications that would permit the City to approve the project -not unreasonably discriminate between providers -publicly release within 30 days substantial record evidence in writing that supports the action 21 Standard Process Projects, Part 4: SAME REQUIREMENTS AS FOR AREPS: • If the Standard Process Project requests: a. the modification of an existing wireless support structure; or b. co-location of new transmission equipment; or c. removal or replacement of transmission equipment; and • that request does not substantially change the physical dimensions, then the City may not deny it and shall approve it within 60 days 22 Standard Process Projects, Part 5: • “SUBSTANTIAL CHANGE” here means the same as for AREPs: -For a new antenna array outside the R-O-W, the FCC says it is not a “substantial change” if there is no more than 20 feet of separation from the top of the nearest existing antenna to the bottom of the proposed new antenna • APPLICANTS AUTOMATICALLY GET AT LEAST 20 EXTRA FEET OF HEIGHT • Disapprovals---Disapproval of AREPs are allowed: -if the proposed height exceeds 50 feet and the City follows a local ordinance that does not unreasonably discriminate between providers • 2020 Bone to Localities also applies 23 Permitted Uses: • All Small Cell Facilities in all districts • All AREPs in all districts (50 feet or less in height) • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-1 District 100 feet or less • Any wireless facility or structure in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts 150 feet or less • Any base station for a lawfully existing wireless facility or structure meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure meeting specified requirements 24 Conditional Use Permits Required: • Standard Process Projects between 50 and 150 feet in height in the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1, and B-4 Districts • Standard Process Projects that exceed 100 feet in height in the B-1 District, but no greater than 150 feet • Standard Process Projects that exceed 150 feet in height in the B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts • Standard process project base stations meeting specified requirements • Any co-location on an existing structure that increases the height of the facility, but any height increase is limited to no more than 15 feet • Any other standard process project 25 Setbacks: • In the R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1, and B-4 Districts: minimum setback is the height of the structure • In the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts: if parcel adjacent to any parcel zoned R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, R-4, IN-1, or B-4, the minimum setback is the height of the structure • In the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts: if structure is 50 feet or less in height, the setback is the minimum setback for the applicable district • In the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2, and I-3 Districts: if structure is 50 feet or more in height, the minimum setback is ½ the height of the structure 26 Standards for CUP’s – Standard Process Projects Only: • Substantial conformance with the Comprehensive Plan • No significant adverse impact on use and enjoyment of nearby properties • No significant negative impact on property values • No material potential interference with pre-existing facilities or for future planned facilities planned or designed for a specific location or any reserved for future public safety facilities • No significant adverse impact on public safety or public service needs • No available and existing wireless support structures nearby • Not in conflict with the City historic district ordinance • Satisfies all other applicable requirements 27 Setbacks for Similar Structures: • Virginia law provides that the City cannot impose a setback or fall zone requirement that is larger than the setback or fall zone requirement “that is imposed on other types of similar structures of a similar size, including utility poles. • As a result, we propose establishing setbacks for wireless support structures that provide the same setbacks for wireless support structures as are applied to light poles, utility poles, and flag poles of a similar size. 28 Setbacks for Similar Structures: • No setback for flag poles, light poles or utility poles (“poles”) that are less than 35’ in height. • Poles greater than 35’ in height set back at a 1:1 in R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3. R-4, IN-1 or B-4 Districts. • Poles greater than 35’ in height in B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District and adjacent to R-C, R-1, R-2, R-3, IN-1 or B-4 District set back at 1:1 • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District between 35’ and 50’ must meet underlying district setback • Poles in the B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-2, I-1, I-2 or I-3 District greater than 50’ set back at least ½ the height of the pole. • Measured from base of pole to the property line 29 Discussion: Discussion 30   Legal Notice Page 1    The Lynchburg Planning Commission will hold a public hearing for citizen comment on December 9,  2020, at 4:00 p.m., in the Council Chamber, first floor, City Hall, 900 Church Street, on the following  matters:  Petition of Jefferson House LLC for a conditional use permit at 1818 Langhorne Square to allow the  construction of sixty‐five senior housing units in a B‐3, Community Business District.  City Council is tentatively scheduled to hear this petition on January 12, 2021, at 7:30 p.m., in City  Council Chamber, first floor, City Hall, 900 Church Street.  Consideration of amending Section 35.2‐61.2 of the City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Additional  Height Regulations, by adding section (d) Flag Poles, Light Poles and Utility Poles.  The proposed  amendment would:  (1) establish that there shall be no  setback requirement for any flag pole, light pole or utility pole that is  thirty‐five (35) feet or less in height;  (2)  provide that any flag pole, light pole or utility pole greater than thirty‐five (35) feet in height and  located in the R‐C, Conservation District, R‐1, Low Density Residential District, R‐2, Low‐Medium Density  Residential District, R‐3, Medium Density Residential District, R‐4, High Density Residential District, IN‐1,  Institutional 1 District or B‐4, Urban Commercial District shall be required to set back a distance from all  property lines at least the height of the pole;  (3)  provide that any flag pole, light pole or utility pole greater than thirty‐five (35) feet in height and  located in the B‐1, Limited Business District, B‐3, Community Business District, B‐5, General Business  District, IN‐2, Institutional 2 District, I‐1, Restricted Industrial District, I‐2, Light Industrial District or I‐3,  Heavy Industrial District, that is adjacent to any parcel that is zoned R‐C, R‐1, R‐2, R‐3,  R‐4, IN‐1, or B‐4  shall be required to set back a distance at least the height of the pole from any land zoned R‐C, R‐1, R‐2,  R‐3, R‐4, IN‐1, or B‐4;  (4)  provide that any flag pole, light pole or utility pole located in the B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐2, I‐1, I‐2, or I‐3  District that is greater than thirty‐five (35) feet in height but less than fifty (50) feet in height shall be  required to set back a distance from all property lines at least the minimum applicable setback for the  district in which it is located;  (5)  provide that any flag pole, light pole or utility pole in the B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐2, I‐1, I‐2, or I‐3, that is  greater than fifty (50) feet in  height shall be required to set back a distance from all property lines at  least one‐half (1/2) the height of the pole; and  (6)  provide that setbacks for flag poles, light poles and utility poles shall be measured from the base of  the pole to the property lines of the parcel on which the pole is located.  Consideration of proposed amendments to the City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance that seek to  repeal  Zoning Ordinance Chapters 35.2‐73.1 through 35.2‐73.20 of the City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance  related to Telecommunication Towers.  Simultaneous with the repeal of the foregoing chapters, the    Legal Notice Page 2    proposed amendments also propose consideration of the adoption of new Zoning Ordinance Chapters  35.2‐73.1 through 35.2‐73.26 pertaining to Telecommunications Facilities.  The proposed amendments  shall be referred to herein as the “Telecommunications Facilities Ordinance.”  The purpose and intent of the proposed amendments  is to facilitate the provision of telecommunication  services, recognize that telecommunication facilities are a necessary part of communication networks,  regulate the location of telecommunication facilities,  protect property from significant adverse impact,  implement the provisions of the City’s Comprehensive Plan while being in compliance with State &  Federal Law, minimize, where possible, adverse visual impact of telecommunications facilities, promote  co‐location of such facilities, promote and encourage the location of telecommunications facilities in  commercial and industrial areas, ensure that telecommunications facilities are compatible with other  land uses in the vicinity, allow telecommunications facilities as a matter of right, where appropriate,  provide greater scrutiny of requests for telecommunications facilities when their size, design, and  location may result in greater impacts on surrounding uses, encourage the utilization of smaller  telecommunications facilities in order to reduce their impact on the surrounding area, reduce the need  for larger and taller telecommunications facilities through the co‐location of such facilities on new  structures and, where feasible, on existing structures, avoid potential damage to the use and enjoyment  of property by ensuring that telecommunication facilities are soundly, safely, and carefully designed,  constructed, and maintained and, where no longer structurally sound, removed, and require the  removal of telecommunications facilities when they are no longer used to support telecommunications  facilities and no longer retain any other legitimate purposes.  The provisions of the proposed Telecommunications Facilities Ordinance shall be applicable to all land  within the boundaries of the City of Lynchburg, however, the proposed Ordinance amendments shall  not apply to any “small cell facility” within the City’s right‐of‐way or on any City‐owned property which  are regulated by separate provisions in the City Code.  The proposed Telecommunications Facilities Ordinance will classify facilities into three categories and  provide application submission, processing, timing, and fee requirements for:   Small Cell Facilities,  Administrative Review‐Eligible Projects and Standard Process Projects.  A Small Cell Facility is proposed to be defined in the same way a “small cell facility” is defined in Virginia  Code § 15.2‐2316.3.  A small cell facility is one that satisfies both of the following qualifications:  each  antenna is located inside an enclosure of no more than six cubic feet of volume or, if the antenna has  exposed elements, the antenna and all exposed elements could fit within an imaginary enclosure of no  more than six cubic feet; and all other wireless equipment has a cumulative volume of no more than 28  cubic feet, or such higher limit as may be established by the Federal Communications Commission.   Small cell facilities are proposed to be permitted by right in all Zoning Districts.  Administrative Review–Eligible Projects are proposed to be defined in the same way “administrative  review‐eligible projects” are defined in Virginia Code § 15.2‐2316.3, which provides, that such projects  include 1.  The installation or construction of a new structure that is not more than 50 feet above  ground level, provided that the structure with attached wireless facilities is (i) not more than 10 feet    Legal Notice Page 3    above the tallest existing utility pole located within 500 feet of the new structure within the same public  right‐of‐way or within the existing line of utility poles; (ii) not located within the boundaries of a local,  state, or federal historic district; (iii) not located inside the jurisdictional boundaries of a locality having  expended a total amount equal to or greater than 35 percent of its general fund operating revenue, as  shown in the most recent comprehensive annual financial report, on undergrounding projects since  1980; and (iv) designed to support small cell facilities; or 2.  The co‐location on any existing structure of  a wireless facility that is not a small cell facility.  The proposed amendments also provide that the term “administrative review‐eligible project” shall also  include eligible facilities requests as that term is defined by federal law in 47 Code of Federal  Regulations 1.6100.  Administrative Review‐Eligible Projects are proposed to be permitted by right in all Zoning Districts.  Standard Process Projects are proposed to be defined in the same way “standard process projects” are  defined in Virginia Code § 15.2‐2316.3, which states that such projects include any project that is not an  administrative review‐eligible project.  A Standard Process Project which proposes a wireless facility or structure in the B‐1, Limited Business  District, that is one hundred feet or less, or a wireless facility or structure in the B‐3, Community  Business District, B‐5, General Business District, IN‐2, Institutional 2 District, I‐1, Restricted Industrial  District, I‐2, Light Industrial District or I‐3, Heavy Industrial District, that is one hundred fifty (150) feet or  less is proposed to be a use permitted by right in those districts.  A Standard Process Project which proposes a wireless facility or structure between fifty (50) feet and  one hundred fifty feet in height in the R‐C, Conservation District, R‐1, Low Density Residential District, R‐ 2, Low‐Medium Density Residential District, R‐3, Medium Density Residential District , R‐4, High Density  Residential District, IN‐1, Institutional 1 District or B‐4, Urban Commercial District, or a wireless facility  or structure exceeding one hundred feet but no greater than one hundred fifty (150) feet in the B‐1,  Limited Business District, or a Standard Process Project that exceeds one hundred fifty (150) feet in the  B‐3, Community Business District, B‐5, General Business District, IN‐2, Institutional 2 District, I‐1,  Restricted Industrial District, I‐2, Light Industrial District or I‐3, Heavy Industrial District is proposed to  require approval of a conditional use permit by the City Council.  In accordance with the adoption of the proposed amendments, the “Approval Type” for “wireless  telecommunications transmission” that is stated in each exhibit/chart for each applicable zoning district  (for example, please see Exhibit IV‐1 for the R‐C District) shall be revised in order to state the “Approval  Type” (“C” for “Conditional Use Permit” and/or “P” for “Permitted”) for each zoning district consistent  with the terms of the proposed amendments.”  Thus, if under the proposed amendments a wireless  telecommunications facility may be allowed with a Conditional Use Permit (“C”) or may be Permitted  (“P”), depending on the circumstances, then the “Approval Type” in the exhibit/chart for each district  shall be stated as follows: “P/C”.  If such facilities are only allowed by Conditional Use Permit, a “C” will  be inserted in the applicable exhibit, and if such facilities are only Permitted, a “P” will be inserted in the  applicable exhibit.    Legal Notice Page 4    Setbacks for wireless facilities and structures are proposed as follows:  Wireless facilities and structures that are less than thirty‐five (35) feet in height would require no  setback in all Zoning Districts.  Wireless facilities and structures greater than thirty‐five (35) feet in height and located in the R‐C,  Conservation District, R‐1, Low Density Residential District, R‐2, Low‐Medium Density Residential  District, R‐3, Medium Density Residential District, R‐4, High Density Residential District, IN‐1,  Institutional 1 District, or the B‐4, Urban Commercial District, are proposed to be required to set back at  least one (1) foot for each one (1) foot in height from all property lines.  Wireless facilities and structures between thirty‐five (35) feet and fifty (50) feet in height and located in  the B‐1, Limited Business District, B‐3, Community Business District, B‐5, General Business District, IN‐2,  Institutional 2 District, I‐1, Restricted Industrial District, I‐2, Light Industrial District or I‐3, Heavy  Industrial District are proposed to be required to meet the underlying district setback.  Wireless facilities and structures greater than fifty (50) feet in height and located in the B‐1, Limited  Business District, B‐3, Community Business District, B‐5, General Business District, IN‐2, Institutional 2  District, I‐1, Restricted Industrial District, I‐2, Light Industrial District or I‐3, Heavy Industrial District, are  proposed to be required to set back one‐half (1/2) the height of the tower from all property lines.  Setbacks are proposed to be measured from the base of the structure to the property line.  The proposed amendments also include requirements and terms applicable to the use of City‐owned  property for wireless facilities, interference with public safety radio services, structural requirements for  telecommunications facilities, the method of determining the height of a wireless support structure,  illumination of telecommunications facilities, the exterior finish of telecommunications facilities, the  landscaping on parcels containing telecommunications facilities, security of telecommunications  facilities, access to parcels containing  telecommunications facilities, maintenance of   telecommunications facilities, the City’s preference for telecommunications facilities with a stealth  design, the modification, demolition, and rebuilding of telecommunications facilities, abandonment of  telecommunications facilities and removal requirements applicable thereto, the allowance of voluntary  conditions, the exemption of micro‐wireless facilities from the proposed amendments, and a reservation  of rights of the City with respect to telecommunications facilities.  The proposed amendments are tentatively scheduled to go to a City Council work session on January 12,  2021 and to a City Council public hearing on February 9, 2021 at 7:30 p.m., in City Council Chamber, first  floor, City Hall, 900 Church Street.   A copy of all draft ordinances, Future Land Use Map amendments, rezoning, conditional use permit  petitions or any other matter advertised by this legal notice may be viewed in the Department of  Community Development, Planning Division, second floor, City Hall, 900 Church Street between the  hours of 8:30 a.m. to 5:00 p.m. or on the internet at www.lynchburgva.gov.  At the conclusion of the    Legal Notice Page 5    public hearing, the Planning Commission/Council will consider adopting each item advertised by this  legal notice. For additional information, contact the Planning Division at 455‐3900.  City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 287 6. If at any time evidence is provided that the lot or parcel is being used other than in compliance with these regulations, the property owner may be cited for violation of this zoning ordinance. 7. Copies of the business license and all applicable permits shall be kept in the food truck, trailer or cart at all times. Section 72 Updates: Ord. No. O-17-013, 2-14-17 Telecommunications Towers 35.2-73 35.2-73.1 Findings (a) The City has the authority to regulate the placement, construction, and modification of towers, antennas support structures, and telecommunications facilities. (b) The federal communications act of 1934 as amended by the telecommunications act of 1996 ("the act") grants the federal communications commission ("FCC") exclusive jurisdiction over: 1. The regulation of the environmental effects of radio frequency emissions from telecommunications facilities. 2. The regulation of radio signal interference among users of the radio frequency spectrum. (c) The City's regulation of towers and telecommunications facilities cannot have the effect of prohibiting any person from providing wireless telecommunications services in violation of the act. 35.2-73.2 Purposes. The general purpose of this article is to regulate the placement, construction, and modification of towers and telecommunications facilities in order to protect the health, safety, and welfare of the public, while at the same time not unreasonably interfering with the development of the competitive wireless telecommunications marketplace in Lynchburg. Specifically, the purposes of this article are: (a) To facilitate the provision of wireless telecommunications services to the residents and businesses of the City in an orderly fashion; (b) To regulate the location of towers and telecommunications facilities in the City; (c) To protect residential areas and land uses from potential adverse impact of towers and telecommunications facilities; City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 288 (d) To minimize adverse visual impact of towers and telecommunications facilities through careful design, siting, landscaping, and innovative camouflaging techniques; (e) To promote and encourage shared use/collocation of towers and antenna support structures as a primary option rather than construction of additional single-use towers; (f) To avoid potential damage to property caused by towers and telecommunications facilities by ensuring that such structures are soundly and carefully designed, constructed, modified, maintained, and removed when no longer used or determined to be structurally unsound; (g) To ensure that towers and telecommunications facilities are compatible with surrounding land uses; (h) To promote the location of towers in industrial and business, rather than residential areas. 35.2-73.3 Development and approval of towers. (a) A tower and associated telecommunications facilities shall be a permitted use of land in business and industrial districts (B-1 through B3, B-5, and I-1 through I-3). A conditional use permit from the City Council shall be required for applicants seeking to locate towers, regardless of height, and related telecommunications facilities, in business districts zoned as B-4 and B-6 and in conservation and residential districts designated R- C through R-5. No structure, regardless of design or material, shall be permitted in any residential district as a telecommunications facility, except small equipment cabinets located on the tower or on the ground immediately adjacent to a telecommunications facility, provided they do not exceed seventy-two cubic feet above ground, and six feet in height. If another company collocates its antenna on the same tower, each company is permitted to have a small equipment cabinet of this size. Any proposal exceeding these parameters shall be subject to review by the City Council as part of a conditional use permit application. Application shall be made to the City Planner in the manner provided in Article II of this Zoning Ordinance. In districts for which a conditional use permit is required, the City Council shall make its decision to grant or deny such permit in writing and in a manner consistent with applicable state and federal law. (b) Existing towers are exempt from the maximum height restrictions of the districts where located. New towers shall not exceed a maximum height of fifty (50) feet in any residential district, one hundred (100) feet in a B-1 district, or one hundred fifty (150) feet in any other commercial or industrial district, unless the City Council approves a conditional use permit authorizing a maximum height in excess of these limits (c) The City may authorize the use of City property in appropriately zoned districts in accordance with the procedures of the City charter and code. The City shall have no obligation whatsoever to use City property for such purposes. City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 289 (d) No new tower shall be built, constructed, or erected in the City unless such tower, including the ground area for associated telecommunications facilities, is capable of supporting another person's operating telecommunications facilities comparable in weight, size, and surface area to the applicant's telecommunications facilities. For purposes of this section, the "applicant's facilities" shall mean those installed within six months of completion of tower construction. These provisions are encouraged for, but need not apply to, towers no greater than 50 feet in height. (e) An application to develop a tower shall include: 1. The name, address, and telephone number of the applicant. If the applicant is not the owner of the parcel of land upon which the tower is situated, the written consent of the owner, and the name, address, telephone number of the owner, shall be evidenced in the application. The application shall also contain an affirmative statement indicating that both the owner and applicant are aware of and agree to comply with the provisions in section 35.2-73.19 of this Zoning Ordinance regarding abandonment. 2. The legal description, valuation map number, and address of the parcel of land upon which the tower is situated. 3. The names, addresses, and telephone numbers of all tower owners with towers or usable antenna support structures within a one (1) mile radius of the proposed new tower site, including City-owned property. 4. Written documentation that the applicant made diligent, but unsuccessful, efforts for permission to install or collocate the applicant's telecommunications facilities on City-owned towers or usable antenna support structures located within a one (1) mile radius of the proposed tower site. 5. Written documentation that the applicant made diligent, but unsuccessful, efforts to install or collocate the applicant's telecommunications facilities on existing or proposed towers, and their ground area, or usable support structures owned by other persons located within a one (1) mile radius of the proposed tower site. 6. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the proposed tower or telecommunications facilities cannot be installed or collocated on another person's tower or usable antenna support structure located within a one (1) mile radius of the proposed tower site and must be located at the proposed site in order to meet the coverage requirements of the applicant's wireless communications system. 7. Written, technical evidence from a structural engineer that the proposed structure meets the standards set forth in this code, including but not limited to the requirements set forth in sections Article I35.2-73.3(d) and 35.2-73.6. City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 290 8. Written, technical evidence from a radio frequency engineer that the proposed facilities meet the standards set forth in this code, including, but not limited to, the requirements set forth in section 35.2-73.4. 9. Written, technical evidence from an electrical engineer that the proposed site of the tower or telecommunications facilities does not pose a risk of explosion, fire, or other danger due to its proximity to volatile, flammable, explosive, or hazardous materials such as LP gas, propane, gasoline, natural gas, or corrosive or other dangerous chemicals. 10. A map of the City and the first half-mile of all bordering communities showing the design of the applicant's entire existing or proposed wireless telecommunications network. Such map shall, at minimum, indicate the general location of all proposed or existing tower and antenna sites, their dimensions, specifications, and signal area coverage. 11. Color photo simulations showing the proposed site of the tower with a photo- realistic representation of the proposed tower as it would appear viewed from the closest residential property or properties and from adjacent roadways. 12. An application fee that represents the site plan fee and conditional use fee otherwise required. The City reserves the right to employ an outside consultant to review any application. The applicant shall reimburse the City for the reasonable expenses related to such review as an additional application fee. 13. A site plan, including a description of the lot lines, setbacks, location of adjacent structures, proposed location of the tower, separation distances, proposed tower height, landscaping, screening, access, parking, and security. 14. An acknowledgment that the applicant currently complies and will continue to comply with all FCC standards, including reporting requirements regarding radio frequency emissions. 15. When seeking approval of a telecommunication tower or facility, the applicant shall furnish written documentation that: a. The proposed communication tower is reasonably necessary to serve an adjacent residential area or areas; b. Any variance (or conditional use permit) sought is the minimum necessary to address the need for the variance (or conditional use permit), subsequent to exploring all reasonable siting alternatives; c. The location of the communication tower in relation to the existing structures, trees and other visual buffers shall minimize, to the greatest extent reasonably practicable under the circumstances, any impact on affected residentially zoned property; City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 291 d. The location of the communication tower will not have a significant detrimental impact on adjacent property values; and e. Any other factors that the applicant deems to be relevant to the City's consideration of a tower or facility siting. f. All information submitted with an application that is trade secret information or is for other reasons proprietary shall be clearly marked as such when submitted with an application. The City shall not disclose publicly, or to any third party, proprietary information unless compelled to do so by federal, state, or local law. 35.2-73.4 Interference with Public Safety Radio Services In order to ensure that the City's public safety radio services will be free from harmful or destructive interference, all applicants requesting a permit to site a tower or telecommunications facilities must: (a) Demonstrate compliance with good engineering practices; (b) Provide the City a copy of all intermodulation studies submitted to the FCC; (c) Not induce harmful or destructive interference to the City's public safety radio services; (d) Comply with FCC regulations regarding susceptibility to radio frequency interference, frequency coordination requirements, general technical standards for power, antenna, bandwidth limitations, frequency stability, transmitter measurements, operating requirements, and any and all other federal statutory and regulatory requirements relating to radio frequency interference (RFI); and (e) In the case of co-location of telecommunications facilities either in the same location or on the same tower as the City's, comply with FCC emissions requirements and not radiate any RFI or any electromagnetic interference (EMI) that may interfere with the City's public safety radio services. 35.2-73.5 Setbacks and Fall Zones (a) Setbacks 1. All towers and any telecommunications facilities in any business and industrial zoning districts shall be set back on all sides a distance equal to the underlying building setback requirement in the applicable zoning district. All towers in residential zoning districts shall be set back on all sides a distance equal to the tower height. In addition, in order to preserve the aesthetics of residential areas and to maintain property values, whenever a tower is located in a residential district, the tower shall be located a distance at least equal to twice the height of the tower from any adjacent property lines. When a tower is located in a commercial district City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 292 or industrial district, the tower shall be located a distance at least equal to twice the height of the tower from any residential district. 2. Setback requirements for towers shall be measured from the base of the tower to the property line of the parcel on which it is located. (b) Fall Zones 1. Every tower shall be designed to fall within the boundaries of the parcel on which the tower is located. The applicant shall submit written certification and supporting documentation from a structural engineer that a tower proposed for a residential area will fall within the specified fall zone. In the case of towers located in commercial or industrial areas that are specified and certified by a structural engineer to be collapsible or incapable of failure, the Zoning Administrator may reduce the fall zone accordingly. 2. In those instances, in which there is a conflict between the required setback and the required fall zone, the greater distance shall apply. 35.2-73.6 Structural Requirements All towers must be designed and certified by a structural engineer to be structurally sound and, at minimum, in conformance with the statewide uniform building code, and any other standards outlined in this article. 35.2-73.7 Separation or Buffer Requirements (a) Towers shall be separated from all residentially zoned lands and all residences (irrespective of zoning classification) by a minimum distance equal to one hundred percent (100%) of the height of the proposed tower. (b) Tower separation distances for the purpose of compliance with this article shall be measured from the base of a tower to the closest point of a designated area. The minimum tower separation distance shall be calculated and applied irrespective of City and county jurisdictional boundaries. 35.2-73.8 Method of Determining Tower Height Measurement of tower height for the purpose of determining compliance with all requirements of this article shall include the tower structure itself, the base pad, and any other telecommunications facilities attached thereto which extend over the top of the tower structure itself. Tower height shall be measured from grade. 35.2-73.9 Illumination Towers shall not be artificially lighted except as required by the federal aviation administration ("FAA"). Upon commencement of construction of a tower, in cases where there are residential City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 293 uses located within a distance equal to the height of the tower from the tower, and when required by federal law, dual mode lighting shall be requested from the FAA. 35.2-73.10 Exterior Finish Towers not requiring FAA painting or marking shall be painted a neutral color (galvanized finish is considered a neutral color). 35.2-73.11 Landscaping All landscaping on parcels containing towers, antenna support structures, or telecommunications facilities shall be designed to screen the tower, antenna support structure, and telecommunications facilities to a height of at least six (6) feet from grade. This requirement may be waived at the discretion of the inspections division if the base of the tower and facilities to be screened are not located in and not visible from any business or residential districts or visible from public streets. All landscaping must be continually maintained in a healthy and attractive manner. 35.2-73.12 Security All towers must be reasonably posted and secured to protect against trespass. 35.2-73.13 Access All parcels upon which towers are located must provide access during normal business hours to at least one (1) paved vehicular parking space(s) on site. 35.2-73.14 Certifications and Inspections (a) All towers shall be certified by an engineer to be structurally sound and in conformance with the requirements of the City building code and all other construction standards set forth by the City code and federal and state law. For new monopole towers, such certification shall be submitted with an application pursuant to section 35.2-73.3(e) and every five (5) years thereafter; for existing monopole towers, such certification shall be submitted within sixty (60) days of the effective date of this article and then every five (5) years thereafter; for new lattice or guyed towers, such certification shall be submitted with an application pursuant to section 35.2-73.3(e) and every two (2) years thereafter; and for existing lattice or guyed towers, such certification shall be submitted within sixty (60) days of the effective date of this article and then every two (2) years thereafter. The tower owner may be required by the City to submit more frequent certifications should there be reason to believe that the structural and electrical integrity of the tower is jeopardized. (b) The City and its agents shall have authority to enter onto the property upon which a tower is located, between the inspections and certifications required above, to inspect the tower for the purpose of determining whether it complies with the statewide City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 294 building code and all other construction standards provided by the City code and federal and state law. (c) (The City reserves the right to conduct such reasonable and necessary inspections, upon reasonable notice to the tower owner. All expenses by the City related to such inspections shall be borne by the tower owner if any unresolved defects exist. (d) The tower or telecommunication facilities owner shall certify to the City on an annual basis that it is in compliance with all of the requirements of this article, including the requirements set forth in Sec. 35.2-73.15. 35.2-73.15 Maintenance (a) Tower owners shall at all times employ ordinary and reasonable care and shall install and maintain in use nothing less than commonly accepted methods and devices for preventing failures and accidents which are likely to cause damage, injuries, or nuisances to the public. (b) Tower owners shall install and maintain towers, telecommunications facilities, wires, cables, fixtures, and other equipment in substantial compliance with the requirements of the national electric safety code and all FCC, state, and local regulations, and in such manner that will not interfere with the use of other property. (c) All towers, telecommunications facilities, and antenna support structures shall at all times be kept and maintained in good condition, order, and repair so that the same shall not menace or endanger the life or property of any person. (d) All telecommunication facilities shall maintain compliance with current radio frequency emission standards of the FCC. (e) In the event the use of a tower is discontinued by the tower owner, or in the event a tower owner files notice to the FCC of its interest to cease operating the tower owner shall provide written notice to the City of its intent to discontinue use and the date when the use shall be discontinued. 35.2-73.16 Stealth All towers and telecommunications facilities in business and residential districts shall be of stealth design. 35.2-73.17 Telecommunications Facilities on Antenna Support Structures (a) Any telecommunications facilities which are not attached to a tower may be permitted as an accessory use to any antenna support structure at least thirty (30) feet tall, regardless of the zoning restrictions applicable to the zoning district where the structure is located. Telecommunications facilities are prohibited on all other structures. City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 295 (b) The owner of such structure or telecommunication facilities shall, by written certification, graphic representation, and detailed plans to the technical review committee verify that: 1. The antenna support structure and telecommunications facilities comply with the statewide building code; 2. Any telecommunications facilities and their appurtenances, located upon the roof of an antenna support structure, are set back a distance at least equal to the height of the telecommunications facilities. However, this setback requirement shall not apply to telecommunications facilities and their appurtenances, located above the roof of an antenna support structure, if such facilities are appropriately screened from view through the use of screening techniques that are compatible with the surrounding built environment and approved by the City. Setback requirements shall not apply to stealth antennas which are mounted to the exterior of antenna support structures below the roof, but which do not protrude more than twenty- four (24) inches from the side of such an antenna support structure; and 3. All applicable standards of this article are being met. 35.2-73.18 Existing Towers (a) An existing tower may be modified or demolished and rebuilt to accommodate collocation of additional telecommunications facilities as follows: 1. Application for a permit shall be made to the division of inspections which shall have the authority to issue a permit without further approval by the City Council. 2. The total height of the modified tower and telecommunications facilities attached thereto shall not exceed the lesser of the height of the existing tower or the maximum height for towers allowed under this article. 3. A tower which is being rebuilt to accommodate the collocation of additional telecommunications facilities may be relocated on the same parcel subject to the setback requirements of this article. However, if it is impossible for the tower to be rebuilt in compliance with the setback requirements of this article, such set back requirements shall require approval of a variance from the Board of Zoning Appeals to allow the tower to be rebuilt in its exact previous location. 35.2-73.19 Abandonment (a) If the City receives notice pursuant to section 35.2-73.15, or if any tower shall cease to be used for a period of three hundred sixty-five (365) consecutive days, the division of inspection shall notify the owner, with a copy to the applicant, that the site will be subject to a determination by the division of inspection that such site has been abandoned. The owner shall have thirty (30) days from receipt of said notice to show by a preponderance of the evidence that the tower has been in use or under repair during City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance Article VII: Specific Land Use Standards Adopted February 23, 2016 Page 296 the period. If the owner fails to show that the tower has been in use or under repair during the period, the division of inspection shall issue a final determination of abandonment for the site. Upon issuance of the final determination of abandonment, the owner shall, within seventy-five (75) days, dismantle and remove the tower. If an owner fails to remove an abandoned tower within seventy-five (75) days of the final determination of abandonment, the City may dismantle and remove the tower and recover the costs of the same from the owner or by accessing the bond set forth below. For the purposes of this section, removal includes all physical improvements associated with towers, including foundation and tower grounding. (b) To secure the obligation set forth above, the owner shall post a bond or provide a letter of credit in an amount to be determined by the City's risk manager based on the anticipated cost of removal of the tower. 35.2-73.20 Reservation of Rights The City reserves the right to impose any other reasonable conditions it determines are necessary for the proper placement, construction, or modification of towers or facilities, and/or to impose any other reasonable conditions on the issuance of a conditional use permit for placement, construction, or modification of a tower or facilities. REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 8th day of December, 2020, at 4:00 P.M. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff S. Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Agenda Item #1, Ms. Kristen Nolan and Ms. Sarah Quarantotto, the Director of Housing Services and the Executive Director of Miriam’s House, respectively, presented the Central Virginia’s Continuum of Care’s (CVCoC) Strategic Plan to End Homelessness. Miriam’s House serves as a lead agency for the Continuum of Care. It is in this capacity that Miriam’s House is a liaison between local homeless response efforts, and local, state, and federal government entities. The CVCoC’s mission statement outlined in the strategic plan is to ensure that homelessness is rare, brief, and non-recurring. Its vision is for all individuals and families experiencing homelessness in the City of Lynchburg and surrounding counties to have a permanent, safe, decent, and affordable place to call home by the year 2024. The CVCoC is funded through federal, state, and local grants totaling $964,720. The way the mission is carried out is through the homeless response system, comprised of shelters, prevention programs, rapid re-housing, and supportive housing that all come together to work cohesively to make sure that there are no gaps in service, that everyone receives the help that they need, and that everyone receives the appropriate level of intervention. Councilmember Tweedy commented on the fact that seniors are posing a serious increase in homelessness since they are unable to grow their income. Ms. Quarantotto said that nationally those numbers are rising, however an analysis was recently conducted on the local level and there were no alarming findings yet. She agreed that as housing costs increase and seniors’ retirement income does not, it is a looming crisis. Mayor Dolan noted that in the survey over half of the responses indicated that the individuals did not have a job and she wanted to know how workforce is being addressed. Ms. Nolen stated that the REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 2 CVCoC has increased its partnership with Virginia Career Works, and are attempting to better communicate with frontline staff (caseworkers) on those resources. Councilmember Faraldi asked how the pandemic is affecting the workforce aspect. Ms. Nolen responded that one of the big issues they’re facing is obtaining proper identification. Getting an appointment at the DMV is really hard due to the pandemic, and having proper identification to fill out an I- 9 Form is the first step to applying for a job. It has also been a challenge to find jobs that are available along the bus line. Although there are less people who have become homeless, the CVCoC has had to help people with rent assistance for a much longer time period than normal because getting a job or keeping a job has been really difficult during the COVID-19 pandemic. // In the matter of Finance, Agenda Item #2, Council received a report on the FY 2020 Comprehensive Annual Financial Report from the City’s external auditing firm. Mr. Chris Banta with Brown Edwards, LLC was in attendance and presented the results of the audit. He stated that when doing an audit, it is important to understand how the organization serves the citizenry and how it pays its vendors. Those are called internal controls and understanding that is the backbone of the process. Also, understanding how the organization adapted to the pandemic in regards to remote work and serving the citizens is also important because that could have enhanced risks from an auditor’s standpoint. The City and School finance did adapt well to the remote processing and had no enhanced risks. Mr. Banta presented the highlights of the CAFR. An audit opinion gives an opinion on the financial statements. An unmodified opinion, or clean opinion, states that the auditor believes the financial statements are materially correct. That’s the highest level of assurance an auditor can give to a set of audited financials, and the City received an unmodified opinion. The next report was a General Fund Budget to Actual Statement. The City’s general fund underspent the expenditures for the year so it is in compliance with the legally adopted budget. Mr. Banta explained that there is a footnote within the statement referencing the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic and that is to simply let the user know, as they’re digesting this document, they need to keep in mind that REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 3 there was a global pandemic going on and that had wide-ranging implications on operations and financials for local governments. The next phase of the audit was to craft the Yellow Book opinion which takes a deeper dive in assessing the internal controls and processes. If there are any significant deficiencies or material weaknesses, not just in problems found but in problems based on the design of the operations, it would have to be reported in the CAFR. There were no significant deficiencies or material weaknesses to report. The next opinion is called a Passenger Facility Charge Audit Report. Since the City operates a commercial airport, it charges what is called a Passenger Facility Charge, an additional fee with a purchase of an airline ticket. There are certain compliance requirements that auditors have to test as a result of charging these fees. This looks at how those fees are being used and reports on any significant findings; there were no significant finding for the City. Last is the Federal Single Audit Report. The City expended about 40 million dollars of federal awards this year in coronavirus relief funding. Mr. Banta stated that staff is anticipating this will be subject to audit. The Office of Management and Budget issues the compliance supplements that guides staff and tells them exactly what to look at; however, that guidance has not been released yet. Therefore, this portion of the audit is on hold but will be submitted by its deadline of March 31 st. The state deadline for issuing the CAFR is December 15th. Mr. Banta stated that the CAFR will be issued with just the Passenger Facility Charge, the report on the financials, and the yellow book government report. Then an update will be issued with the federal award report at a later time. // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #3, Ms. Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, presented Council with an update on the revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources. Ms. Witt explained that these numbers are through October which means that we are starting to look at the 2nd Quarter. The 1st Quarter came in stronger than what staff anticipated, however staff thought the economy would be more back to normal by the 2nd Quarter, but unfortunately, that is not the case overall. Fortunately, Sales Tax is about $233,000 above budget. This continues to come in very strong; the revenues are up about 6.7% compared to last year’s numbers and up just about 4% compared to last REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 4 month. This is based primarily on online sales, grocery sales, and home improvement sales. Ms. Witt anticipates these numbers will remain strong. Unfortunately, Meals Tax, for the first time, is below what was anticipated in the budget. Restaurants are just not as open, or back to normal, as staff thought they would be. Ms. Witt anticipates that these collections will not rebound and a decline will be continual probably through the rest of the 2nd Quarter, and possibly in to the 3rd Quarter. Lodging Tax, poses the same situation as Meals Tax. Staff is seeing about an $88,000 difference from what was collected to what we anticipated in the budget. Ms. Witt explained that she again expects a decline through at least the rest of the 2nd Quarter. The Amusement Tax sector is really still very much closed; very little is open for people to participate with in order for the City to collect Amusement Tax. Ms. Witt anticipates that the mere $18,000 - $19,000 being collected is going to continue for at least the 2nd Quarter and possibly in to the 3rd and 4th Quarter. // In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #4, Council received an update on the Utility Disconnect Moratorium and considered adopting Resolution #R-20-092 related to the COVID-19 Municipal Utility Relief Program and associated CARES funding. Mr. Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources presented Council with a summary of the recommendation. On November 19, 2020, as a result of recent State Budget Amendments, the City received a memorandum from the Virginia Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD) regarding the COVID-19 Municipal Utility Relief Program (Relief Program). The memorandum explained the process for municipal utilities to apply for CARES funds for the Relief Program. The applications were due on November 30, 2020 and only included utility and locality identification and the total arrearages for 60 and 30 days which were $397,121 and $619,181, respectively, at the time of the application. The funds will be distributed to all water, sewer, gas, and electric utilities that applied for the funding on a pro- rata basis and are considered pass-through funds since they will be applied directly to qualifying customer accounts. $344,014.82 was awarded to the City. REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 5 The General Assembly 2020 Special Session Budget Bill HB5005 Item 4-14 requires that notification be sent to all customers by January 17, 2020 with arrearages over 30 days with information about the disconnect moratorium and repayment plan options. The City can qualify for an exemption from the Utility Disconnect Moratorium to resume utility cut-offs of delinquent accounts, but certain criteria must be first met. These include, arrearages must exceed 1% of the total annual operating revenue; documents must be available to the public; and City Council must conduct a public hearing and affirm the 1% exceedance and the intent to resume cut-offs. Mr. Mitchell outlined the staff recommendations to Council which included adopting a resolution waiving Councils normal fiscal policies and accepting the COVID-19 Relief Funds. Councilmember Helgeson asked for clarification about the statement, wanting to know exactly what fiscal responsibilities are being waived. Ms. Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, clarified that Council’s normal financial procedures require appropriations of funds to have two readings; however that is a City code not a State code. This means that Council has the ability to waive the need for a second reading and appropriate these funds with one reading. There is a very short window to work with citizens to get information out about these funds to pay their bill. If Council waited to have a second reading at the next Council meeting in January 12, 2021, the window to receive these funds would be missed. Mr. Mitchell continued with the following staff recommendations: within the next two weeks notify customers with arrearages of the repayment plan and relief fund availability and requir ements; conduct a Public Hearing on January 12, 2021 for consideration approving the 1% Exemption from the moratorium and resumption of utility disconnections on a date to be established; if it is determined that utility disconnections will resume, immediately notify customers again with arrearages of the available resources, assistance, and repayment plan options and when cut-offs will resume. Vice Mayor Wright made a motion to approve Resolution #R-20-092, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 6 // In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item #5, Councilmember Faraldi had no items. Councilmember Wilder thanked the community for all of the work they are doing during this crisis. Councilmember Tweedy asked that all citizens be diligent and adhere to guidelines that will make us all safe. Councilmembers Nelson and Helgeson had not items. Vice Mayor Wright recently went to an unveiling of a marker at the Juvenile Court for Lucy Harrison Baber who is a Lynchburg native and longtime resident who advocated for Juvenile Justice Reform in Virginia and helped establish the juvenile justice system that we have here in Lynchburg. Mayor Dolan had the following roll call items: • Mustaches for Kids (M4K) Lynchburg just completed our annual fundraiser and raised $318,713 in 30 days for local children’s charities. Since the inception of this organization in 2014, this brings the total amount raised for local non-profits to over $1,000,000. • “Since the onslaught of the COVID-19 pandemic, I have seen this community come together in so many different ways to support one another - whether it was following safety guidelines and wearing masks, supporting local businesses, checking on elderly neighbors or donating to those who were in need. I have been so proud to witness just how great this community continues to be and how, in times of adversity, we come together and grow stronger! This evening, I would like to take just a moment to recognize a special group of people. I don’t think anyone has seen their lives change quite as much as the lives of our healthcare workers. On a daily basis, these individuals have been on the frontline risking their lives and working long, exhausting hours to take care of our friends and loved ones struck down with COVID-19. On behalf of this community, I want to thank not only the doctors and nurses, but every technician and CNA, every aide and housekeeper, every senior care and doctor’s office worker -thank you for what you are doing! We want you to know we appreciate your sacrifice, dedication and service. What you are doing is so very important, and we owe you a great debt of gratitude. If my fellow Council Members would be so kind, I’d like us to stand and give our healthcare REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 7 workers a standing ovation of thanks. God bless you!” Vice Mayor Wright asked the City Attorney what the potential for citation was due to having more people in the room than the current allowable 25 people under State law. City Attorney Mr. Walter Erwin clarified that there is an exemption in the Governor’s executive order for government operations. He continued by stating that if there are more people in the room than is allowed, the City runs the risk of the Health Department sending a notice saying we are in violation. However the governor’s order is vague, as in is a meeting of a governing body a government operation. Vice Mayor Wright asked that his fellow Councilmembers concede to keeping the number of individuals in Council Chamber for the 7:30 p.m. meeting to 25 people. Councilmember Helgeson stated that Council meetings are open public meetings which are required under the Virginia Freedom of Information Act. He further commented that Council does not get to arbitrarily decide which citizens get to attend the meeting and who does not and he would not be agreeing. Vice Mayor Wright made a formal motion to restrict Council Chamber to 25 persons with overflow seating in a different location within City Hall. Councilmember Tweedy seconded the motion stating she has concerns and errs on the side of safety and compliance. Councilmember Faraldi asked Vice Mayor Wright who he envisioned would enforce these orders. He specifically wanted to know if local law enforcement would be asked to enforce the attendee restrictions. Vice Mayor Wright retorted that the logistics could be worked out, but the idea of limiting the number of people allowed in one space is to keep people safe and comply with the State law. Councilmember Faraldi stated that he could walk in to any restaurant, and if there were 35 – 40 people in the restaurant, remaining socially distanced, that business would be considered complying with state mandates. He commented that the proposal to limit Council Chamber to 25 people when it could hold, by his count, around 40 people and allow for social distancing, seemed inconsistent with this executive order. Further, he stated that adding any agenda item, especially an item that would greatly impact the community, within seven days of the Council meeting violates Council’s Rules of Procedure. Lastly, he stated that he cannot in good conscious infringe on the rights of the constituency that he represents to REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 8 view and engage with their government in-person. He also noted the importance for citizens who are at- risk, to stay at home, but for these reasons, he will not be supporting the motion. Councilmember Nelson stated that he appreciates both sides of the argument, however, on the agenda for the 7:30 p.m. meeting are two public hearings, one for a zoning issue and the other an appeal. The citizens have a right to come and petition at the public hearings. That is a government operation. He stated that Council should not skirt the right of citizens to a fundamental constitutional liberty on the basis of whether we would fall under the exemption under the governor’s mandate. Mayor Dolan stated that she would agree to limit the number of people in Council Chamber to 25 people with an overflow room for viewing if there were more time to notify the public of this stance. For that reason she will not support the motion. With no further discussion, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Wright, Tweedy 2 Noes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Wilder, Faraldi 5 Interim City Manager Dr. Reid Wodicka had an item for Council’s consideration. In the recently adopted Legislative Agenda, there is a request to the General Assembly to remove certain provisions from the City’s Charter, specifically related to City Council’s pay. In order to request that, Council either needs to hold a public hearing on the subject, or conduct a referendum on the subject to reopen the Charter. Dr. Wodicka recommends holding a public hearing, but needs Council’s permission to advertise and schedule a public hearing for the first January meeting. Council reached a consensus, giving staff the ability to do so. // The meeting was recessed at 5:42 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff S. Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 9 Absent: 0 Councilmember Wilder gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Dolan made the following acknowledgements: • She congratulated the graduates of the CO.STARTERS Fall 2020 program: Andrea Plunkett, Kenneth Payne, Thomas Morris, Kathryn Lewis, Heather Knopp, Vanessa Kaszubowski, Diana Ferrell, Skyler Donaldson, Molly Corbet. • The International Economic Development Council awarded the City of Lynchburg an Excellence in Economic Development Silver Award for the 2019 Annual Report, produced by the Office of the Economic Development & Tourism. • The Office of Economic Development & Tourism received the VIRGO award for Destination Event of the Year for the 2019 State Games of America. • Ms. Marjette Upshur, Director of Economic Development & Tourism , provided Council with a copy of the Economic Development 2020 Annual Report and played a short video of the highlights of the report. // In the matter of Consent Agenda Item #6, copies of the minutes of the November 10, 2020 meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, Council by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Fire Department, Consent Agenda #7, Resolution #R-20-093 amending the FY 2021 General Fund Personnel budget and appropriating $193,936 with resources from the Fire Medic Unit Reserve to fund six Advanced Life Support Firefighters for the Fire Department , received a second reading. On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, Council by the following recorded vote approved the motion to adopt Resolution #R-20-093: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 10 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Community Development – Rezoning, Agenda Item #8, a public hearing was held to discuss adopting Ordinance #O-20-027 approving the rezoning petition of Meanwhile Back on the Farm to rezone approximately three and sixty-one hundredths (3.61) acres at 2627 Old Forest Road, 2624 & 2700 Confederate Avenue. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, provided Council with a brief summary of the request. Meanwhile Back on the Farm is a business petitioning to rezone approximately three and sixty-one hundredths (3.61) acres at 2627 Old Forest Road, 2624 and 2700 Confederate Avenue from B -3C, Community Business District (Conditional) to B-3C, Community Business District (Conditional) to amend a previously approved concept plan. The approved concept plan was proffered during a rezoning in 2014 and showed a restaurant use in the existing manor house and a three-thousand (3,000) square foot event space. The proposed concept plan shows a retail use in the manor house and a four-thousand (4,000) square foot event space. In summary, the concept plan is very similar to the rezoning from 2014. The use should not have a significant impact on the surrounding neighborhood given the nature of the activities that this business will be conducting. Additionally, the sites designation as a local historic district which provides another layer of protection for this neighborhood since the HPC will need to review the changes and ensure that the nature of the character is maintained. The approval of the petition will also allow for the reuse of a historic site. The Planning Commission held a public hearing on November 11, 2020 and recommended approval of the petition. Mr. Bobby Harris, co-owner of Meanwhile Back on the Farm was in attendance and made a presentation. He stated that they would like to expand the business at the Locus Thicket, utilizing the manor house for retail, bag making, and event space for workshops. The historic nature and beauty of Locus Thicket is a key factor that drew them to the property. It is a perfect match for their business and is their intention to preserve, improve, and be good stewards of the property. Mr. Vance Driskill, the owner of 2610 and 2613 Confederate Avenue, the property neighboring the development, was in attendance to speak in opposition of the petition. Although he is excited to have REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 11 this business as a neighbor, he is concerned about the headlights from vehicles that would beam directly into his home. He has no concern of daytime operations; it is at dusk that concerns him. Mr. Driskill has talked to the business owner addressing his concerns and they have ensured him that they would take care of the issues. Mr. Driskill’s also has a concern with what is outlined in the proffers doesn’t give the City enough bite to make the owner adhere to these promises should there be a need. Mr. Harris rebutted, stating that he would take care of the light issue. This is addressed in the concept plan. There was no one else to speak either in favor or opposition, either in-person, or with emails or voicemails from citizens, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Helgeson thanked both Mr. Driskill and Mr. Harris for being good neighbors and made the motion to approve the ordinance. He asked staff what action has to be taken in order to ensure the proper shielding is erected. Ms. Frischeisen stated that the zoning ordinance requires that when commercial property that backs-up to a single family residence, as in this instance, there would be a 20 foot evergreen buffer required, staggered in-between any building or parking lot and a residence. Councilmember Faraldi seconded the motion stating that as the representative for Ward IV, he is glad something is being done to the property since it has been sitting for a while. Councilmember Wilder asked staff if there were any additional traffic concerns. They did not have to do a traffic study based on the projections the developer provided not meeting the City’s threshold for requiring a traffic study. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded approving Ordinance #O- 20-027: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 12 // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #9, a public hearing was held to consider adopting Resolution #R-20-094 to either uphold or reverse the decision of Historic Preservation Commission to deny a Certificate of Appropriateness at 2144 Rivermont Avenue. Mr. Chris McSwain, Chair of the Historic Preservation Commission provided Council with a brief request of the summary. Mr. Martin Donovan is appealing the decision of the HPC that denied his COA request to erect a black aluminum fence at 2144 Rivermont Avenue. The HPC reviewed the petition on September 21, 2020 and found that there was insufficient information to make a determination. The Commission postponed the item and requested that the petitioner “provide the Commission a visual of what the 6’ fence looks like, show where the fence is located in relation to the house, property lines, and street. The petitioner did not provide the materials by the October 19th, 2020 meeting. The Commission was unable to decide based upon what was originally provided and denied the petition due to lack of information. The City’s Zoning Ordinance, Section 35.2-13.11, Appeals to City Council, states: “On any such appeal, the final decision of the HPC … shall be stayed pending the outcome of the appeal to City Council, except that the filing of such appeal shall not stay the decision of the HPC if such dec ision denies the right to raze or demolish a historic landmark, building or structure. The City Council shall conduct a full and impartial public hearing on the matter and apply the same criteria as the HPC before rendering any decision. The City Council may affirm, reverse or modify the decision of the HPC, in whole or in part. The decision of City Council, subject to the provisions of Section 35.2-13.12, shall be final. If approved, a certificate of appropriateness, signed by the Clerk of the City Council, shall be issued to the applicant.” Mr. Donovan was in attendance and provided Council with background information on his project. There was a dilapidated fence on his lot previously which he removed with the intent of replacing it with a newer fence. Due to traveling for work, he was unable to attend the HPC meetings, leading the commissioners to deny his request. Mr. Donovan asked Council to consider reversing the decision of the HPC so that he may erect his fence which will protect his dogs from traffic, as well as, the neighborhood children from the pool in his backyard. REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 13 Councilmember Helgeson made the motion to reverse the decision of the Historic Preservation Commission stating that this is aligns with historic preservation in his opinion. Councilmember Faraldi seconded the motion. Councilmember Wilder asked Mr. McSwain if Mr. Donovan has properly addressed the HPC’s concerns. Mr. McSwain said he could not speak for the whole commission, but explained that he feels they never received proper clarification as to where the fence would lie. Councilmember Wilder said that he would be supporting the motion because Mr. Donovan did a very good job with the revitalization of the property already and he feels comfortable with what he will do with this next step. Councilmember Nelson asked Mr. McSwain if there was something about this that would violate some of the protocols or qualifications set forth by the HPC that the commission would normally requi re. Mr. McSwain stated that in his opinion, he does not see any issues with the details provided today, but asked Ms. Victoria Glasgow, Planner I, if she could clarify the guidelines in regards to the height of the fence. Ms. Glasgow stated that they will have to adhere to the zoning ordinance requirements, which she did not have on hand. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded approving Resolution #R - 20-094: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #10, Mr. Andrew Glover presented to Council a proposal on community engagement. Currently stated in City Council’s Rules of Procedures, any Lynchburg citizen is allowed to address Council at its regularly scheduled meeting by contacting the Clerk of Council by noon the Wednesday before the Council meeting. Mr. Glover requested that City Council amend their rules of procedure postponing the deadline for citizens to register for Public Comment in response to agenda items, and have it moved 24 hours before the Council meeting. This would allow citizens to review the items on the agenda and decide what they would like to speak about. REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 14 // In the matter of Lynchburg Redevelopment Housing Authority (LRHA), Agenda Item #11, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-20-095 re-authorizing the issuance by the LRHA tax-exempt revenue bonds for the acquisition and rehabilitation of James Crossing Apartments. Mr. Walter Erwin, City Attorney, provided a brief summary of the request on behalf of Mr. Richard L. Hurlbert, Jr., Bond Counsel, and Mr. Herschel Keller, Attorney of LRHA, who were both unable to be in attendance. On December 10, 2019, City Council authorized the issuance of tax exempt revenue bonds by the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority for the acquisition and rehabilitation of the James Crossing Apartments, located at 808 Greenfield Drive; there have been no changes to the project. Due to the impacts of COVID-19, this issuance has not been completed and must be re-authorized by City Council. The Housing Authority conducted the requisite public hearing on November 19, 2020 and recommended approval. Although the bonds will be issued through the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority and the City has no obligations to pay these bonds, however; regulations require that Lynchburg City Council adopt a resolution supporting the transaction. Councilmember Helgeson asked Mr. Erwin to clarify that Mr. Hurlbert and Mr. Keller weren’t getting cold feet since they were not in attendance. Mr. Erwin assured Council that they are very eager for the project to continue, but other obligations kept them away from tonight’s Council meeting. Councilmember Tweedy stated that she sits on the LRHA board and they are still in favor of the project. LRHA met with the owners prior to the approval and they were very cooperative and responsive to the housing authority with development of programs and understanding of what the expectations for this property are. Councilmember Wilder stated that he is encouraged by the development and some of the plans they have. He commented on the need to continue revitalizing that community and give them support and services. Councilmember Nelson stated that City Council approved this a year ago and the circumstances have not gotten any better; in fact the needs may be greater. REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 15 Councilmember Helgeson made the motion, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, to approve the resolution. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded approving Resolution #R-20-095: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Planning, Agenda Item #12, Council considered approving a resolut ion abandoning a portion of Top Ridge Drive from the City’s Street System. Mr. Lee Newland, City Engineer, presented Council with a brief summary of the request. The Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) has requested that the City of Lynchburg formally abandon a section of Top Ridge Drive (Frontage Road FR- 794) from the city’s street system. This section of roadway was removed to accommodate the construction of the Odd Fellows Interchange on and off ramps. This is simply an administrative “clean-up” item for VDOT since this section of roadway no longer exists. If City Council approves the abandonment of this street section, the Commonwealth Transportation Board will take action on this item at a future meeting. Councilmember Helgeson asked for clarification on how much of the roadway would be abandoned. Mr. Newland stated that it was just for the interchange that no longer exists and not for the entire length of Top Ridge. Vice Mayor Wright made the motion to approve the resolution, seconded by Councilmember Wilder. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorde d approving Resolution #R- 20-096: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of City Manager’s Office, Agenda Item #13, Council considered adopting Resolution #R- 20-097 adding Juneteenth and Veterans Day as permanent City holidays. Dr. Reid Wodicka, Interim City Manager, presented Council with a brief summary of the request. The City’s personnel policies identify a REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 16 number of holidays for which City offices are closed. In reviewing the City’s holidays compared with many of our surrounding counties as well as the Commonwealth of Virginia, the City provides considerably fewer paid holidays. For example, the state recognizes 15.5 holidays, while the City recognizes just 10. Last year, members of City Council suggested adding Juneteenth to the list of holidays. City Council did so, but just for calendar year 2020. Given the importance of this holiday to everyone in our community, this holiday should be added to the permanent list. Additionally, Veterans Day has not traditionally been recognized by the City and, given the number of employees who are veterans, plus the impo rtant role that veterans play in our community, staff recommends adding this holiday as well. With the addition of holidays, there was a concern about overtime costs. If these two holidays are added, staff will increase the amount of time that employees carryover from year-to-year from 80 hours to 96 hours. This will decrease the amount of payouts from the City and can be done administratively and does not require Council action. Councilmember Wilder stated that he is in support of adding both holidays to the City’s register and made the motion to approve the resolution. Vice Mayor Wright seconded the motion and briefly read an email sent from a citizen on why he supports observing Juneteenth. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded approving Resolution #R-20-097: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Appointments, Agenda Item #14, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-20-098 appointing Ms. Alicia L. Finney, Interim Clerk of Council, as the new Clerk of Council for the City of Lynchburg, Virginia, effective December 9, 2020. Vice Mayor Wright made the motion to approve the resolution, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi. With no other discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded approving Resolution #R- 20-098: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 17 Noes: 0 // On motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss the disposition of certain real property identified as 97 Page Street, Lynchburg, Virginia, including, if any, improvements thereon; and to discuss the appointment of members to the Economic Development Authority, Historic Preservation Committee, Parking Authority, Social Services Advisory Board, Transit Board, Community Development Advisory Committee, Towing Advisory Committee, Planning Commission, Airport Commission, an d Horizon Board of Directors, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(3) and Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. State law requires City Council to disclose the name of the person who is being considered for appointment to Horizon’s Board of Directors. City Council will consider appointing Mr. Chris Faraldi as the Council representative to this board. With no discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was re-opened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 18 meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // On motion of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Nelson, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Economic Development Authority: no appointments were made at this time. Historic Preservation Committee: Ms. Tracey Langseth – unexpired term ending June 30, 2022 Parking Authority: Mr. Charles Warner – unexpired term ending October 31, 2023 Social Services Advisory Board: Ms. Denise Dempsey – term ending September 30, 2024; Mr. Jeffrey Krantz – term ending September 30, 2024 Transit Company Board of Directors: Dr. Les Reed – unexpired term ending October 31, 2022 Lynchburg Regional Airport Commission: Mr. Jones Stanley – term ending December 31, 2023; Mr. John (Dennis) Marcinik – term ending December 31, 2023 Planning Commission: Ms. Nancy Marion – term ending December 31, 2023 Towing Advisory Board: Mr. Timothy Clements – term ending December 31, 2023; Mr. Charles Cramer – term ending December 31, 2023; Mr. James Hall – term ending December 31, 2023 Community Development Advisory Committee: Mr. Leonard “Rad” Briley – term ending December 31, 2021; Ms. Mandze Dyke – term ending December 31, 2021; Ms. Valerie Harris – term ending December 31, 2021; Mr. John Hughes, III – term ending December 31, 2021; Ms. Susan Murray – term ending REVISED December 8, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 19 December 31, 2021; Mr. Sterling Wilder – term ending December 31, 2021; Mr. Beau Wright – term ending December 31, 2021 Horizon Board of Directors: Councilmember Chris Faraldi – term ending December 31, 2023. Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was adjourned at 9:15 p.m. ____________________________ Interim Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: January 12, 2021 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: AGENDA ITEM #: 5 CLOSED SESSION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Utility Disconnection Moratorium Exemption KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _ _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Review the attached analysis showing that the accounts receivable arrearages exceed one percent of Water and Sewer Funds’ annual operating revenues, conduct a Public Hearing regarding exemption to the Utility Disconnection Moratorium due to arrearages exceeding one percent of annual operating revenues, and adopt the attached resolution verifying that the arrearages exceed one percent of the annual operating revenues and the intent to resume disconnection of water service for non-payment. SUMMARY: Due to COVID-19, beginning in March, 2020, the Department of Water Resources voluntarily suspended disconnection of water service for delinquent accounts. During the 2020 Special Session I, the General Assembly approved Appropriations Act Amendments, Item 4-14, which included specific procedures and requirements for utility services related to the corona-virus declared state of emergency including: provisions related to customer assistance grants; utility disconnection moratorium requirements; customer repayment plans; and provisions for exemption to the disconnection moratorium. Municipal utilities may seek an exemption to the disconnection moratorium provided that they provide the accounts receivable arrearages exceeding one percent of the total annual operating revenues, make the accounting analysis showing the one percent exceedance available for public inspection, conduct a public hearing, and obtain verification from the governing body that arrearages exceed one percent and affirming the intention to resume utility disconnections for non-payment. Upon verification, City staff recommends the resumption of utility disconnections beginning in February, 2021. In conjunction with the resumption of utility disconnections, repayment plans will also be offered to customers. Customers participating in repayment plans will not be cut-off as long as they remain current with their plan. Additionally, customers with arrearages may apply up until January 22, 2021 for funds from the COVID-19 Municipal Utility Relief Program to be applied to their outstanding water and sewer balances. Customers are encouraged to take advantage of both of these programs to help avoid disconnection for delinquent accounts. PRIOR ACTION(S): December 8, 2020, Adoption of the COVID-19 Municipal Utility Relief Program Resolution FISCAL IMPACT: As noted in the attached analysis. CONTACT(S): Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources, 455-4252 Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution Accounting Records Analysis - showing one-percent exceedance REVIEWED BY: raw 006A RESOLUTION: A RESOLUTION VERIFYING AND APPROVING UTILITY ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE ARREARAGES ARE IN EXCESS OF ONE PERCENT OF ANNUAL OPERATING REVENUES WHEREAS, during the 2020 Special Session I (Appropriation Act Amendments, Item 4 -14) the Virginia General Assembly approved specific procedures and requirements for utility service applicable in the coronavirus -related declared state of emergency, including provisions related to customer assistance grants, utility shutoffs for nonpayment, and customer utility debt repayment plans; and WHEREAS, the City of Lynchburg is well -positioned to implement these new procedures and requirements because City of Lynchburg has always worked to assist customers in a fiscally responsible manner to pay utility; and WHEREAS, the City of Lynchburg’s Department of Water Resources revenue sources are from charges for services provided, which are generally based on rates necessary to recover the full cost of operations without reserve for forgiveness of payment due for such services; and WHEREAS, the City of Lynchburg’s Department of Water Resources employs industry-standard collection process for unpaid bills including disconnection of water service in appropriate cases, which historically has proven effective in minimizing losses; and WHEREAS, the City of Lynchburg’s Department of Water Resources self -imposed a moratorium on disconnection of water service for unpaid bills in response to the coronavirus pandemic; and WHEREAS, during the disconnection moratorium period to date, cust omers generally have not availed themselves financial assistance opportunities and instead have accumulated increasing debt; and WHEREAS, a significant number of accounts have increasing overdue balances such that customers may find their repayment respon sibility difficult to manage without undertaking an effort now to begin paying down balances over time through a reasonable repayment plan; and WHEREAS, the City of Lynchburg’s Department of Water Resources determined and documented in a written analysis from accounting records that account receivable arrearages exceed one percent of annual operating revenues and also provided such analysis to Lynchburg City Council as the Utility’s governing body; WHEREAS, the City of Lynchburg’s Department of Water Resources contemporaneously made the associated working papers verifying such facts available for public inspection; now therefore be it NOW THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED BY the Lynchburg City Council that it has re viewed the calculations of account receivable arrearages and verifies that the arrearages exceed one percent of annual operating revenues and; be it BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the City of Lynchburg’s Department of Water Resources resume normal collection procedures including disconnection of water service where necessary to achieve customer response, while also continuing normal procedures to avoid disconnecting water service for customers that request and implement repayment plans to bring accounts current over time. Adopted: Certified: ____________________________ Clerk of Council Accounting Records Analysis ARREARAGE CALCULATION FOR WATER AND SEWER RECEIVABLES AS OF 11/30/2020 0-30 31-60 61-90 91-120 Over 120 Totals Total Water Accounts Receivable 764,581.71 83,551.66 45,436.18 29,076.37 121,730.24 1,044,376.16 Total Sewer Accounts Receivable 1,535,826.70 174,081.25 59,600.30 40,861.97 173,066.60 1,983,436.82 2,300,408.41 257,632.91 105,036.48 69,938.34 294,796.84 3,027,812.98 Total Arrearage (Over 30 Days) 257,632.91 105,036.48 69,938.34 294,796.84 727,404.57 FY20 Revenues Water 16,305,505.52 Sewer 24,748,364.44 Total FY20 Revenues 41,053,869.96 Arrearage Ratio to FY20 Revenues 1.77% 1 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: January 12, 2021 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: AGENDA ITEM #: 6 CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Conditional Use Permit (CUP) – Jefferson House LLC – 1818 Langhorne Square KEY ELEMENTS: _X _Economic Development ___Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _ Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the CUP petition to allow the construction of a five (5) story, sixty-five unit apartment building for seniors. SUMMARY: Jefferson House LLC, is petitioning for a CUP at 1818 Langhorne Square to allow the construction of a sixty-five (65) unit apartment complex in a B-3, Community Business District. The units would be deed restricted as affordable units for the elderly. If approved, a total of one hundred sixty-six (166) units would exist with only sixty-seven (67) parking spaces proposed for the two (2) buildings. The Zoning Ordinance typically provides for one (1) parking space per one (1) residential unit but allows the City Planner to reduce the number of the spaces where mass transit is available and if the applicant provides credible information documenting that the use will require fewer spaces. The petitioner has provided that there are currently forty-two (42) parking spots serving the existing one hundred one (101) residential units. Only twenty-five (25) residents have cars and the other parking spaces are utilized by staff that comes in the morning and at night. The maximum usage of parking has averaged thirty- two (32) spaces and most of the usage is by home health aides and the three (3) staff members. Based upon the availability of mass transit, parking need demonstrated by the petitioner and the restriction to senior housing, staff believes parking will not be an issue. The Planning Commission also discussed how the project could potentially improve stormwater conveyance on the site. PRIOR ACTION(S): December 9, 2020: The Planning Division recommended approval of the CUP petition. The Planning Commission recommended approval (7-0) of the CUP petition. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A CONTACT(S): Tom Martin, City Planner – 455-3900 ATTACHMENT(S):  Resolution  Planning Commission Minutes – December 9, 2020  Planning Commission Packet – December 9, 2020 o Planning Commission Report o Zoning Map with Adjoining Owners o Future Land Use Map o Watershed Map o Planimetric and Topographic Map o Concept Plan o Narrative o Parking Narrative o Property Photograph o Speaker Signup Sheet REVIEWED BY: klw 003A RESOLUTION A RESOLUTION GRANTING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO JEFFERSON HOUSE LLC AT 1818 LANGHORNE SQUARE TO ALLOW THE CONSTRUCTION OF A SIXTY-FIVE (65) UNIT APARTMENT BUILDING TO BE USED AS SENIOR HOUSING IN A B-3, COMMUNITY BUSINESS DISTRICT. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, that the petition of Jefferson House LLC to allow the construction of a sixty-five (65) unit apartment building to be used as senior housing is hereby approved subject to the following condition: 1. The site shall be developed in substantial compliance with the concept plan “Conditional Use Permit for Jefferson House” dated November 2, 2020 and revised. Adopted: Certified: ____________________________ Clerk of Council 1 MINUTES OF THE DECEMBER 9, 2020 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING (MINUTES HAVE NOT BEEN APPROVED): Petition of Jefferson House LLC for a conditional use permit at 1818 Langhorne Square to allow the construction of sixty-five (65) senior housing units in a B-3, Community Business District. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, provided the following summary to the Commission. The area is approximately one and forty -nine hundredths (1.49) acres located at 1818 Langhorne Square. If the Conditional Use Permit (CUP) is approved it will be subdivided fr om the larger two and thirty -three hundredths (2.33) acre parcel. The purpose of the Conditional Use Permit is to allow the construction of a five (5) story, ten thousand eight hundred and eighty -three (10,833) squ are foot building containing sixty-five (65) Senior Affordable Units. The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013 -2030 and Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends a “Mixed Use” for the area. Multi -household structures are permitted in the B - 3, Community Business Dist rict upon approval of a Conditional Use Permit by City Council. The existing building contains one hundred and one (101) senior units. Again, if the Conditional Use Permit is approved the existing parcel will be subdivided and a five (5) story, sixty-five (65) unit apartment building will be constructed on site. The proposed units will be deed restricted to seniors that are rent burdened. The existing facility would also be improved. The approval of the Conditional Use Permit to allow the construction of af fordable senior housing units should have little impact on the area and is consistent with both the City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013 -2030 and the Midtown Area Master Plan. The primary concern with the proposed development is that of parking. A total of one h undred sixty-six (166) units would exist with only sixty-seven (67) parking spaces proposed for the two (2) buildings. This is less than half of the normally required one (1) parking space per one (1) residential unit required by the Zoning Ordinance. Howe ver, based upon the availability of mass transit, parking need demonstrated by the petitioner and the restriction of senior housing, parking should not become an issue. The location of the senior housing within walking distance to medical offices and retai l uses should fit well into the area. The Technical Review Committee (TRC) reviewed the petition on November 17, 2020. Comments were minor in nature. Planning staff recommends approval of the petition with the condition outlined in the report. Chair Rogers asked who was present to speak on behalf of the petition. Mr. Joe Eddy, President of JE Properties, addressed the Commission. JE Properties is a Boston based company with a few other affiliates. The company works mostly with affordable hou sing. They came across this property a couple of years ago and it was a mess. Before they bought it, it was in default with Virginia Housing (VHDA). There were a lot of capital needs like a roof problem, leaks, and an infestation. They bought it and have b een fixing it up. Part of the acquisition plan is to build additional units to improve the economics of the project. It will be done as a low income tax credit project. They will apply to VHDA for the tax credits in March but the tax credits are not guaranteed. If they do get the tax credits, they will be approved in July and begin the project the following March. If they do not get the tax credits they will reapply for them the next year. This is an awesome location for senior housing. It is near a hospital. They put in a sidewalk and are right in front of a bus stop. They plan to install a bench or something similar there for the residents. Only about twenty -five (25) of the residents have cars. Another twenty-five (25) or so use the bus daily. They feel t hat this is a great project that fits well with the City’s plans. Chair Rogers asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in favor of the petition. When no one stepped forward he asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in oppositi on of the petition. When no one stepped forward he closed the public hearing. Commissioner Johnson asked for clarification concerning the parking situation. 2 Mr. Eddy responded that there are currently forty -two (42) parking spots and one hundred one (10 1) units. Only twenty-five (25) residents have cars. The other parking spaces are utilized by staff that comes in the morning and at night. The max usage of parking has been about thirty -two (32) spaces and most of the usage is by home health aides and the three (3) staff members. Commissioner Marion asked if the proposed pedestrian connectors are at grade. Mr. Eddy responded that they are. Commissioner Perault stated that there is a steep drop off from the parking lot and that the footprint goes out pretty far into the ravine. An underground detention storage area is also shown. He asked how far out it actually goes into the ravine area. Mr. Patrick Proffitt, of Hurt & Proffitt, responded that the grades and how to handle stormwater were reviewed when preparing this project. It gets close to the ravine of the natural channel, but does not actually get into it. The building is back off of it somewhat but the parking area extends a little bit further. That will be stopped vertically with retaining walls . Construction will not get into the water course. It already has a piping system dumping into it and it goes a little bit further into a natural channel that is off of the property. Chair Rogers noted that the gradient helps with the underground detention. It fits within that with the retaining wall. Mr. Proffitt responded that they will bring that up to the bottom of that detention structure and include that as part of the fill. It works out nicely with the fill and the wall. There is a second m odular system proposed for the left-hand side of the property as well. For the stormwater quality, the owner has been advised to purchase credits. Chair Rogers stated that will be an improvement. Mr. Proffitt shared agreement. Commissioner Perault stated that the footprint is not much larger than what is there now and there is nothing in place. It could be better off after the fact. Mr. Proffitt responded that is a good point. There is a lot of impervious there now. Commissioner Perault stated that this petition is good fit for the area, serves a need, and is not a radical petition. It is not a rezoning, just a Conditional Use Permit. Commissioner Bowden stated that this type of housing was needed a few years ago. This petition also utilizes a building that is in rough shape and fixes it up. He is in support of this petition. Chair Rogers stated that this is a great project that addresses the community’s needs. He is also in support of this petition. Commissioner Bowden made the following motion, seconded by Commissioner Marion, and approved by the following vote: “Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City Council approval of the petition of Jefferson House LLC for a Conditional Use Permit at 1818 Langhorne Square subject to the following condition: 3 1. The property shall be developed in substantial compliance with the concept plan “Conditional Use Permit for Jefferson House” dated “Revised November 24, 2020” AYES: Bowden, Johnson, Light, Lowe, Marion, Perault, and Rogers 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 The Department of Community Development City Hall, Lynchburg, VA 24504 434-455-3900 To: Planning Commission From: Planning Division Date: December 9, 2020 Re: Conditional Use Permit (CUP) – Jefferson House LLC – 1818 Langhorne Square I. PETITIONER Jefferson House LLC, 150 Mount Vernon Street, Suite 500, Dorchester, MA 02125 Representative: Patrick Proffitt, PE, Hurt & Proffitt, Inc., 2524 Langhorne Road, Lynchburg, VA 24501 Property Owner: Jefferson House LLC, 150 Mount Vernon Street, Suite 500, Dorchester, MA 02125 II. LOCATION The area is approximately one and forty-nine hundredths (1.49) acres located at 1818 Langhorne Square. If the CUP is approved it would be subdivided form the larger two and thirty-three hundredths (2.33) acre parcel. III. PURPOSE The purpose of the CUP is to allow the construction of a five (5) story, ten thousand eight hundred and eighty-three (10,833) square foot building containing sixty-five (65) Senior Affordable Units. IV. SUMMARY  The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030, Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends a “Mixed Use” for the area.  The proposed sixty-five (65) units would be deed restricted as affordable units for the elderly.  The petitioner is requesting a reduction in the amount of required off-street parking due to the availability of mass transit in the area. This reduction is allowed by Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2-62.4(e).  Multi-household structures are permitted in the B-3, Community Business District upon approval of a Conditional Use Permit by City Council. The Planning Division recommends approval of the Conditional Use Permit. V. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. Comprehensive Plan. The Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends a Mixed Use for the area. These areas do not fit into any single use category as they are planned for a mix of uses carefully designed so as to mitigate any potential land use conflicts. The mixed-use areas generally consist of large undeveloped or greenfield areas that are intended to be developed for a balanced mix of residential, neighborhood commercial, civic uses, parks and open spaces. The mix of uses in these areas is intended to be determined at the time of development review and Planning Commission: CUP – Jefferson House LLC, 1818 Langhorne Sq. – December 9, 2020 2 approval. The adopted area plans should be consulted for a more fine-grained discussion of the mix of uses planned for the Midtown/Plaza area and the Tyreeanna mixed use area. (p. 76) The property is designated as being part of a “Village Center” in the Midtown Area Master Plan adopted by City Council on October 11, 2005: These important village centers should contain a variety of uses in a compact area, easily accessible by surrounding residential neighborhoods. Each center should continue to evolve as centerpieces of Midtown life. (p. 4.3) The property is also directly adjacent to the “M edical Arts District” as designated by the Midtown Area Master Plan. The Medical Arts District will mark the location of medical services located in Midtown to serve greater Lynchburg. The district is designed to attract all services related to the medical field, in hopes of creating a compact cluster of medical facilities. Maintaining functional links is important to encourage and allow for a pedestrian environment and campus type atmosphere for the district. As a great economic engine for the City, the centerpiece of the Medical Arts District is Lynchburg General Hospital. The district should operate as a unique center by providing a mix of uses to serve this prosperous medical community. (p. 4.6) 2. Zoning. The subject property was annexed into the City in 1926. The existing B-3, Community Business District was established in 1978. 3. Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA). The Zoning Administrator has determined that no variances are needed for the development of the property as proposed. 4. Surrounding Area. There have been several items requiring City Council approval in the immediate area:  On August 12, 1980, City Council approved the request of Gary Case to rezone 2104 Langhorne Road from B-1, Limited Business District to B-3C, Community Business District (Conditional) to allow the development of a restaurant.  On April 13, 1982, City Council approved the request of Alexander Partnership to rezone 2104 Langhorne Road from B-3, Community Business District (Conditional) to B-3C, Community Business District (Conditional) to amend previously approved proffers.  On May 11, 1982, City Council approved the rezoning petition of Alexander Partnership to rezone 2104 Langhorne Road from B-3C, Community Business District (Conditional) to B-1, Limited Business District to allow the construction of a medical office building.  On June 14, 1983, City Council approved the CUP petition of Holy Cross School at 2125 Langhorne Road to allow a classroom addition.  On November 13, 1984, City Council approved the CUP petition of Hold Cross School at 2125 Langhorne Road to allow the construction of an amphitheater and tennis courts.  On August 13, 1985, City Council approved the CUP petition of Lynchburg General Hospital at 1901 Tate Springs Road to allow the construction of a building expansion, helistop and childcare center playground.  On November 10, 1987, City Council approved the CUP petition of Hold Cross School at 2125 Langhorne Road to allow the use of an existing building as a religious retreat. Planning Commission: CUP – Jefferson House LLC, 1818 Langhorne Sq. – December 9, 2020 3  On June 14, 1988, City Council approved the rezoning petition of David Marks and Jane Blickenstaff to rezone 2091-2099 Langhorne Road from R-4, High Density Residential District to B-1C, Limited Business District (Conditional) to allow legal, medical and office space.  On September 12, 1989, City Council approved the rezoning petition of Howard Terry to rezone 2092 Langhorne Road and 46 Clifton Street from R-3, Medium Density Residential District to B-1C, Limited Business District (Conditional) to allow the construction of a two (2) story office building.  On April 14, 1992, City Council approved the CUP petition of Centra Health Inc. at 1901 Tate Springs Road to allow the expansion of the Hospital.  On February 9, 1993, City Council approved the CUP petition of Hold Cross School at 2125 Langhorne Road to allow the installation of a modular classroom.  On October 12, 1993, City Council approved the rezoning petition of Giles, Cox and Associates to rezone 2102 Langhorne Road from R-4, High Density Residential District to B-1C, Limited Business District (Conditional) to allow the construction of office buildings.  On November 11, 1993, City Council approved the CUP petition of Charles Grant at 2130 Langhorne Road to allow the addition of two (2) garage bays to an existing service station.  On June 11, 1996, City Council approved the rezoning petition of Beach Medical to rezone 2092 Langhorne Road from B-1C, Limited Business District (Conditional) to B- 3C, Community Business District (Conditional) to allow an office with equipment sales, service and rental.  On June 10, 1997, City Council approved the rezoning petition of Rehabilitation Associates of Central Virginia to rezone 44 Clifton Street from B-1C, Limited Business District (Conditional) to B-1C, Limited Business District (Conditional) to amend previously approved proffers.  On December 14, 1999, City Council approved the rezoning petition of Avante at Lynchburg to rezone 2081 Langhorne Road from R-4, High Density Residential District to B-1C, Limited Business District (Conditional) to allow commercial access and future expansion of a nursing home.  On June 12, 2001, City Council approved the CUP petition of Central Health, Inc. at 1901 Tate Springs Road to allow the construction of a Cath Lab Addition.  On November 12, 2002, City Council approved the CUP petition of Hold Cross School at 2125 Langhorne Road to allow the construction of building additions and parking.  On June 8, 2004, City Council approved the CUP petition of Centra Health, Inc. at 1901 Tate Springs Road to allow the construction of a bed tower addition.  On October 11, 2005, City Council adopted the Midtown Area Master Plan.  On January 12, 2010, City Council approved the CUP petition of Hold Cross School at 2125 Langhorne Road to allow a consolidated sign plan. 5. Site Description. The property currently contains a six (6) story brick building constructed in 1973. City Assessor records indicate it contains seventy-three thousand two hundred and twelve (73,212) square feet. The existing building contains one hundred and one (101) Senior Planning Commission: CUP – Jefferson House LLC, 1818 Langhorne Sq. – December 9, 2020 4 units. On May 26, 1981, the Board of Zoning Appeals, BZA approved a variance allowing the construction of up to one hundred seventy-four (174) apartment units. Only one hundred and one (101) of those units were constructed and the City’s Zoning Administrator has determined that the variance would no longer allow the construction of additional units, necessitating the need for the CUP. 6. Proposed Use of Property. If the CUP is approved the existing parcel would be subdivided and a five (5) story, sixty-five (65) unit apartment building would be constructed on site. The proposed units would be deed restricted to seniors that are rent burdened. The existing facility would also be improved. 7. Traffic, Parking and Public Transit. The petitioner has requested a reduction to the off- street parking requirements based upon mass-transit being available to the property and demonstrated parking need. The proposed concept plan indicates a total of sixty-seven (67) parking spaces that would be shared between the two properties. The property is served by Greater Lynchburg Transit Company (GLTC) Route 1A with a stop in front of 1818 Langhorne Square. As required for a mass transit parking reduction, the submitted concept plan indicates sidewalks connecting both buildings to the bus stop and the addition of a bench at the stop. 8. Stormwater Management. The petitioner has indicated that stormwater management is proposed to be addressed by the use of underground detention and the purchase of off-site nutrient credits. 9. Emergency Services: The City Fire Marshal and Police Department had no concerns regarding the CUP petition. 10. Impact. The approval of the CUP to allow the construction of rent based housing for seniors should have little impact on the area and is in keeping with the City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013- 2030 and the more detailed Midtown Area Master Plan . The primary concern with the proposed development is that of parking. A total of one hundred sixty-six (166) units would exist with only sixty-seven (67) parking spaces proposed. This is less than half of the normally required one (1) parking space per one (1) residential unit required by the Zoning Ordinance . Based upon the availability of mass transit, parking need demonstrated by the petitioner and the restriction of senior housing, parking should not become an issue. The location of the senior housing within walking distance to medical offices and retail uses should fit well into the area. 11. Technical Review Committee. The Technical Review Committee (TRC) reviewed the petition on November 17, 2020. Comments have or will be addressed prior to final site plan approval. VI. PLANNING DIVISION RECOMMENDATION Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City Council approval of the petition of Jefferson House LLC for a Conditional Use Permit at 18 18 Langhorne Square subject to the following condition: 1. The property shall be developed in substantial compliance with the concept plan “Conditional Use Pe rmit for Jefferson House” dated “Revised November 24, 2020” This matter is respectfully offered for your consideration. Planning Commission: CUP – Jefferson House LLC, 1818 Langhorne Sq. – December 9, 2020 5 William T. Martin, AICP City Planner pc: Dr. Reid Wodicka, Interim City Manager Mr. Kent L. White, Interim Deputy City Manager Mr. Walter C. Erwin, City Attorney Mr. J. Lee Newland, City Engineer Ms. Cynthia Kozerow, Lynchburg Police Department Battalion Chief Thomas Goode, Fire Marshal Mr. Doug Saunders, Building Official Mr. Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator Mr. Joseph Eddy, Petitioner Mr. Patrick Proffitt, Representative VII. ATTACHMENTS 1. Zoning Map with Adjoining Property Owners 2. Future Land Use Map

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.