RecordWell Data

City Council Work Session and Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Nov 10, 2020 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL PHYSICAL DEVELOPMENT COMMITTEE Tuesday, November 10, 2020 8:00 a.m. Information Items: Recent/Pending Contract Awards: Project: Link Road Bridge Company: Burleigh Construction Company, Inc. Location: Concord, VA Award: $1,835,483.25 Engineer Est.: $3,210,160.00 Priority Projects Update: - Presented by Lee Newland General Business: 1. CIP Strategies: - Presented by Tom Martin Roll Call: Pc: City Council Reid Wodicka, Interim City Manager Kent White, Interim Deputy City Manager/Director of Community Development John Hughes, Assistant City Manager Gaynelle Hart, Director of Public Works Next Meeting: December 8, 2020 Projects of Interest Phase Phase Completion Sch BudNotes Memorial Ave. Storm Drainage/Reconstruction/Repave Construction August 2020 Mitigating Storm Drainage Concerns - Paving Complete Main Street Renewal Project Construction November 2021 Construction Underway Lakeside Drive Bridge Over Blackwater - Design-Build Design / Construction June 2023 Construction Underway CSO - Wastewater Treatment Plant Project Construction January 2021 On-Going Link Road Bridge Award January 2021 Awarding Contract - Working on Easements One Way Pairs @ 501/221 Design December 2021 Proceeding to 60% Plans Downtown Watermain Replacement & Streetscape 2 Design March 2021 Design @ 90%. Design Being Updated and Completed Police Department Headquarters Pre-Design September 2020 Nearing Completion - Currently Reviewing Budget Estimates, Value Engineering & Conceptual Designs Fifth Street Phase 4 Design October 2021 Design Plans Underway Schedule - Green ● 0-5% Behind Budget - Green ● 0-10% Over Yellow ● 5-10% Behind Yellow ● 10-20% Over Red ● > 10% Behind Red ● > 20% Over V V VDOT Managed V V VDOT Managed Lynchburg Capital Projects Greater Than $1 Million (General Fund) November 10, 2020 LEGEND LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: November 10, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) Prioritization Strategies KEY ELEMENTS: _X Economic Development X Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _X Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Hear presentation on CIP Prioritization Strategies SUMMARY: The CIP is a five year method of planning for the effective and efficient provision of public facilities, infrastructure improvements, major maintenance requirements and acquisition of property and equipment. These projects provide betterment to the community, have a life of not less than twenty (20) years and a total cost of $25,000. The CIP Prioritization Strategies are intended to be a technical tool that will be used by staff to aid in developing the CIP for a diverse set of projects within funding limitations. Ultimately, projects included in the CIP are decided by Council. PRIOR ACTION(S): N/A FISCAL IMPACT: N/A CONTACT(S): Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner – 455-3900 ATTACHMENT(S):  CIP Prioritization Strategies Draft  CIP Presentation REVIEWED BY: klw Capital Improvements Plan  Prioritization Strategies    A.  DEFINITION  The Capital Improvements Plan (CIP) is a five year method of planning for the effective and  efficient provision of public facilities, infrastructure improvements, major maintenance  requirements and acquisition of property and equipment.   A “capital project” is defined as an  acquisition that represents a public betterment to the community, has a life of not less than  twenty (20) years following its purchase, construction or other acquisition and has a total cost  exceeding twenty‐five thousand dollars ($25,000).      B. GOAL  The goal of the CIP is to establish a plan that outlines the projected public facility,  infrastructure, major maintenance, and acquisition of property and equipment for the City to  assist in the planning and budgeting process.  The investments in physical assets help the City  meet the priorities and goals of the community.    The City of Lynchburg cannot afford to do everything at once, and goals and resources are  constantly changing.  This document intends to outline strategies for project prioritization in  the CIP.  These “Prioritization Strategies” are intended to avoid the perception of “winners”  and “losers” and each project should be re‐evaluated each year to reaffirm or reprioritize the  Capital Improvements Plan.    C. PRIORITIZATION  The prioritization of eligible project is completed by city staff through the use of the CIP  Prioritization Strategies listed in this document.  Each project must first be classified as a CIP  Project according to the City’s definition of a CIP Project.  If a project is eligible, the project will  be ranked according to the Prioritization Strategies and placed into the yearly project  groupings for the next five years.      D.  PROJECT TYPES  After the overall CIP score is assigned to each project, the projects will be realigned based on  the project type.  These types include:  Buildings, Transportation, Public Transit, Economic  Development, Parks & Recreation, Water, Sewer, Stormwater and Miscellaneous.    E. FUNDING LIMITS  On an annual basis, funding for CIP projects will be limited based on the City’s fund balances  and bonding capabilities.  Projects identified in the CIP may be funded by different sources.    General Fund, Unassigned Fund Balance (Pay‐As‐You‐Go), General Obligation (GO) Bonds,  Grants, VDOT Revenue Sharing, Enterprise Funds or Private / Public Partnerships are a few of  the options for funding CIP Projects.  During the City’s annual budget process, the projects will  be analyzed for sources of funding, funding availability and impacts to long‐term debt service.     F. SCHEDULING OF PROJECTS  Project schedules will be developed based upon the available funding and project ranking.   The schedules will determine where each project fits in the 5‐year CIP and in order to aid in  budgeting and planning the City may seek to develop a longer term ten‐year CIP.  This will be  based on the priority of the project, funding availability and how it correlates with other  projects included in and out of the CIP.  The ability to fund projects that have significant  impacts on debt service will be scheduled, to the extent possible, in a manner that seeks to  limit dramatic year‐over‐year increases in debt service payments.  In these cases, smaller  projects may be scheduled sooner and larger projects may be deferred until such time as the  City has repayment capacity available.    The final CIP document will be produced based on the evaluation of the CIP project, funding  and schedule.  This will be developed for 5‐year duration.  The CIP and projects will be re‐ evaluated on an annual basis to align growth, needs and budgeting.  Ultimately, projects  included in the adopted CIP are decided by City Council.  These prioritization strategies are  intended to be a technical evaluation tool for aiding in the developing the CIP for a diverse set  of projects.        CIP PRIORITIZATION STRATEGIES    Strategies    1. Compliance with Plans or Studies.    Compliance with the Comprehensive Plan, Strategic Plan, Neighborhood Master Plan or other  Studies.  Plans and studies are invaluable in the City’s continuing efforts to meet goals,  objectives and the Vision of making the City of Lynchburg, a Great Place to Live, Work and  Play.  These plans have been prepared with Citizen Engagement, Stakeholders and  Consultants.   These plans have been adopted by the Planning Commission and City Council.    A. Is the proposed project contained in one or more City Plans?  B. Is the proposed project listed as a high priority, or has it become a high priority of Citizens,  staff, the Planning Commission or City Council due to an expressed need?  C. Has the project been fully developed and defined in enough detail so that specifics are  known?  D. Have adequate public discussion and citizen engagement occurred for broad community  support?  E. The project meets the goals and objectives of the Comprehensive  Plan.    Scoring Scale  1  2  3  4  5  The project is  not part of any  Plan or Study.      The project is  included in a Plan  or Study, but  may not be a  high priority or  appropriate  citizen  engagement has  not occurred.      The project is  included in a Plan  or Study, is a high  priority and has  had appropriate  citizen  engagement.      Downtown 2040 Master Plan Kick‐Off Session  2.  Regulatory Compliance    The project is to ensure compliance with regulatory mandates such as the Environmental  Protection Agency (EPA), Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ), Department of  Conservation and Recreation (DCR), the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) or other State  and Federal Laws.  This strategy also includes self‐imposed City Ordinances.    A. Does the project address a current regulatory mandate?  B. Will the project proactively address a foreseeable (within the next 5 years) regulatory  mandate?  C. Does the project have a lasting impact on promoting regulatory compliance over the long  term (more than 10 Years)?  Scoring Scale  1  2  3  4  5  The project does  not address a  regulatory  compliance  issue.      The project  provides a short‐ term fix for an  existing  regulatory  compliance issue  or for one  anticipated in  the near future.      The project  resolves a  pressing or long‐ term regulatory  compliance  issue.                            College Lake Dam     3.  Timing/Location  The timing and location is an important piece of a project.  If the project is in close proximity  to other CIP projects there may be an economy of scale.  If a project needs to be completed  before another project of high priority it may be rational to move the project ahead of other  CIP projects.    A. When is the project needed?  B. Do other projects require this one to be completed first?  C. Does this project require others to be completed first?  D. Can this project be done in conjunction with other projects?  E. Is it more economical to build multiple projects together, reducing the cost and timing of  construction?  F. Will the project reduce the overall number of disruptions to a neighborhood from year to  year?  G. Is this an existing facility near the end of its functional life?  H. Will deferring the project significantly increase the cost of the project?    Scoring Scale  1  2  3  4  5  The project does  not have a critical  timing/location  component.      The project has  either a timing  or location  factor that is  critical.      The project has  both a timing and  location that are  critical  components of  the project.         Downtown Lynchburg is open for business during renovations   4. Impact on Operational Budget    Some projects may affect the operational budget by increased maintenance costs, while others  may actually reduce maintenance costs by reducing the amount of repairs needed or operational  costs.  An example would be replacing a light with a more energy efficient LED may decrease  energy bills.    A. Will the project require additional personnel to operate?  B. Will the project require additional annual maintenance?  C. Will the project require additional equipment not included in the project budget?  D. Will the project reduce staff time and City resources currently devoted resulting in a positive  effect on the operational budget?  E. Will efficiency related to the project save money?  F. Will the project present a revenue generating opportunity?    Scoring Scale  1  2  3  4  5  The project will  require  additional  funding to  operate.      The project will  not affect the  operating budget  as it is revenue  neutral.      The project will  have a positive  effect on the  operating  budget.  It will  create savings in  time, materials  and/or  maintenance or  generate revenue  to offset costs.                          Snow Removal     5. Alternative Funding Sources    Some projects may be eligible for partial funding through Commu nity Development Block Grant,  other Grants, State or Federal funding.  Availability of alternative funding sources reduces the  fiscal impact on the City and may allow the project to be completed when it otherwise would not  be possible.    A. Is an alternative funding source available?  B. Would the City be able to complete the project in the next five years without the funding?  C. Will use of alternative funding result in a significant work load for staff managing the project?  D. Will use of alternative funding result in regulatory issues that may slow or make the project  infeasible?    Scoring Scale  1  2  3  4  5  There is no  alternative  funding source  available.      Alternative  funding sources  are available, but  will result in  significant  management and  will result in  additional  regulatory issues.      Alternative  funding sources  are available and  the City would  not be able to  complete the  project in the  next five years  without the  funding.          6. Economic Development  Some projects create positive economic impact by increasing pro perty values, job creation or  create an environment conducive to development by providing infrastructure, stabilizing or  revitalizing neighborhoods.  An example may be the extension of a public road to provide  access to land for development.    A. Will the project result in increased property values?  B. Will the project result in job creation?  C. Will the project result in job retention?  D. Will the project provide an amenity in an industrial park such as sidewalk, pocket park,  etc.?    1  2  3  4  5  There is no  increase to  property values  or potential for  job creation.      The project will  increase property  values / stabilize  / revitalize a  neighborhood.      The Project will  increase  property values  and result in job  creation.                   7. Improving Public Health & Safety  Some projects provide a direct benefit to public health and safety by reducing traffic  accidents, injuries, death, reducing health hazards related to poor water quality or sewer  issues or improve response times or service by Emergency Services?    A. Will the project reduce traffic accidents resulting in fewer injuries and/or deaths?   B. The project will result in correcting an existing structural deficiency and result in improved  safety.  C. Will the project provide for improved drinking water or sanitary sewer?  D. Will the project result in improved response times or service by Emergency Services?    1  2  3  4  5  There is no  direct impact to  Public Health or  Safety.      The project will  result in an  improvement to  overall public  health and  safety.      The Project will  result in reduced  accidents, deaths  or injuries.                            City of Lynchburg Fire Department    8. Connectivity and Accessibility in the Transportation Network  Transportation projects have the ability to improve citizens’ quality of life while providing  positive community impact in terms of improving safety, reducing traffic congestion, creating  opportunities for economic development and creating a multi‐modal transportation system.    A. Will the project reduce congestion in the City’s Transportation network  B. Will the project provide a citywide or regional benefit by improving a roadway designated  as collector or higher?  C. Will the project result in the improvement or replacement of functionally obsolete  transportation infrastructure?  (Functionally obsolete means that the infrastructure no  longer meets current standards in terms of safety or capacity.)  D. Does the project follow Better Streets Policy and provide opportunities for multi‐modal  transportation and accessibility.  E. Does the project improve connectivity between one mode of transportation to another  such as a new trail to a neighborhood?    1  2  3  4  5  There is no direct  impact to the  City’s  Transportation  Network.  The project will  provide an  improvement to  a roadway  designated as  collector or  higher.        The project will  result in the  improvement or  replacement of  functionally  obsolete  infrastructure.    The Project will  result in the  replacement of  functionally  obsolete  infrastructure  and provide  improvements  following the  Better Streets  Policy and  includes  opportunities for  multi‐modal  options and  accessibility.         Odd Fellows Road Interchange    9. Natural Systems  Lynchburg residents place a high value on preserving and enhancing the natural and  environmental resources.  The City desires to increase efforts to protect natural and  environmental resources while being fiscally responsible, providing for economic  development while not compromising the needs of future generations.    A.  Will the project result in a negative impact to the environment?  B.  Will the project be environmentally neutral?  C. Will the project provide a positive impact to the environment?    1  2  3  4  5  The project will  result in a  negative impact  to the  environment.      The project will  be neutral in the  impacts to the  environment.      The Project will  provide a  positive impact  to the  environment.       Hollins Mill Dam    10. Social Equity  Lynchburg recognizes that there are disparities in the level of service provided to areas  traditionally populated with minorities and individuals of low to moderate  income and that  these same areas were typically subject to redlining. Nationwide, these disparities sometimes  resulted in increased exposure to pollutants, higher heat indexes, increased stress and  associated health risks. The lack of street trees, sidewalks, and infrastructure is evident in  these areas. Utilities, including water, sewer, street lights, cable, and internet service may be  lacking or be of a lower quality as well. Public investment needs to address these inequalities  and add to the livability of these areas    A.  Will the project have a neutral impact on the livability of area?  B.  Will the project negatively impact the quality of life for the residents?    C.  Will the project have a positive impact on the area?  D.  Is the project located within a qualified Census Tract for reinvestment?      1  2  3  4  5  The project will  result in a  negative impact  to social equity.      The project will  be neutral in the  impacts to social  equity.      The Project will  provide a  positive impact  to social equity.        Helping Hands Mural      Capital Improvement Plan Prioritization Strategies November 10, 2020 Physical Development Committee (PDC) Project Team Team • Anna Bentson • Alex Fisher • Reid Lanham • Joann Martin • Tom Martin • Lee Newland • Greg Poff • Clay Simmons • Susannah Smith • Marjette Upshur • Michelle White • Kent White • Reid Wodicka 2 Definition CIP • Five year method of planning for provision of capital projects – City may wish to pursue a ten year CIP • Provides betterment to the community • At least a 20 Year life cycle • Cost exceeding $25,000 3 Goal Goal of CIP • Establish a plan for the budgeting process: – Public facilities – Infrastructure – Major maintenance – Acquisition of property – Equipment • Meets the priorities and goals of the community 4 Prioritization Prioritization • Must meet definition of a CIP Project • If eligible will be ranked and included in yearly project groupings. • Completed by city staff through use of strategies 5 Project Types Project Types • After overall score is assigned, projects aligned based on project type – Buildings – Transportation – Public Transit – Economic Development – Parks & Recreation – Water / Sewer / Stormwater – Miscellaneous 6 Funding Limits Funding Limits • Funding on an annual basis will be limited on fund balances and bonding capabilities: – General Fund – Pay-As-You-Go – Bonds – Grants – VDOT Revenue Sharing – Enterprise Funds – Public / Private Partnerships 7 Project Scheduling Project Scheduling • Project scheduling will be based upon available funding and project ranking and how they correlate to other projects. • Projects with significant impacts on debt service will be scheduled to the extent possible to limit dramatic increases in in year-to-year debt service. • Smaller projects may be scheduled sooner and larger projects deferred until repayment capacity is available. 8 Project Scheduling Project Scheduling • Prioritization strategies are intended to be technical evaluation tool for aiding in the developing a CIP with a diverse set of projects. • Projects will be re-evaluated on an annual basis to align growth and budgeting needs. • Ultimately, projects included in the adopted CIP are decided by Council. 9 CIP Flow Chart 10 CIP Prioritization Strategies • Compliance with Plans or Studies • Regulatory Compliance • Timing / Location • Impact on Operational Budget • Alternative Funding Sources • Economic Development • Improving Public Health & Safety • Connectivity and Accessibility in Transportation Network • Natural Systems • Social Equity 11 November 10, 2020 - REVISED 1 GENERAL POLICY REGARDING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AT CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS Each speaker shall clearly state his or her name and locality of residence. The City Council agenda is divided into four sections. CONSENT AGENDA: This section includes routine items. All items may be approved by one vote. PUBLIC HEARINGS: This section includes all public hearings as required by law or as Council may direct. Procedure:  Staff will make a presentation.  For zoning petitions, the applicant or his or her representative shall have ten (10) minutes to make a presentation.  Comments will then be solicited from those in favor.  Comments will then be solicited from those in opposition. During the public hearing, there shall be a time limit of three (3) minutes for each individual speaker. If the speaker represents a group, there shall be a time limit of five (5) minutes. A speaker representing a group shall identify that group at the beginning of his or her remarks. A group may have only one spokesperson. After public comments have been received, for zoning petitions, the applicant or the representative of the applicant, at his or her discretion, may respond with a rebuttal. There shall be a five (5)- minute time limit for rebuttal. Upon the conclusion of public comments or the applicant’s rebuttal, the public hearing will be closed and the matter referred to Council for deliberation. PUBLIC COMMENT: Public comment shall be for the purpose of allowing members of the public to present any matter, which, in their opinion, deserves the attention of the Council. They shall not serve as a forum for debate with the Council. Individuals may speak up to three (3) minutes; or group spokesperson up to five (5) minutes. Once Council has heard a presentation from a citizen or organization on a particular subject, the citizen or organization may not make another presentation on the same subject within three (3) months of the first presentation, except by a majority vote of the members of Council present and voting. GENERAL BUSINESS: This section includes items of a general nature to be considered by Council. City Council may make exceptions to these rules at its discretion. Prior to a meeting, any questions which citizens may have regarding any item on the agenda may be addressed to City Council or the City Administration. The following numbers are provided for the convenience of the citizens: CITY COUNCIL 455-3995 MAYOR 455-3995 CITY MANAGER 455-3990 A reasonable charge may be made for copying and other activities related to responding to long and involved inquiries. CITIZENS OFTEN EXPRESS CONFLICTING AND DIVERSE POSITIONS REGARDING SPECIFIC ISSUES UNDER CONSIDERATION. TO ENCOURAGE CITIZEN PARTICIPATION AND TO AVOID INTIMIDATION TO PERSONS WHO MAY EXPRESS SOMETIMES UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, APPLAUSE, CHEERS, OR JEERS FROM THE AUDIENCE ARE NOT PERMITTED. WHEN APPEARING BEFORE CITY COUNCIL, CITIZENS MAY NOT ENGAGE IN BEHAVIOR THAT INTIMIDATES OR INSULTS OTHERS, ENGAGE IN DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOR, USE PROFANITY OR VULGAR LANGUAGE, PROMOTE PRIVATE BUSINESS VENTURES OR CAMPAIGN FOR PUBLIC OFFICE. * PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED AND/OR CONSIDERED BY CITY COUNCIL Physical Development Committee – 8:00 a.m. – Council Chamber A G E N D A City Council Meeting of November 10, 2020 Council Chamber | City Hall, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, VA 24504 2:00 P.M. CLOSED SESSION #1. Consideration of a closed meeting to interview prospective recruitment firms relating to the appointment of a City Manager, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(29) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. 4:00 P.M. WORK SESSION #2. Receive an update on the revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources and a review of the FY 2021 Adopted General Fund Operating Budget. #3. Receive an update on utility disconnects moratorium. #4. Roll Call 7:30 P.M. City Council Agenda Items COUNCILMEMBER TWEEDY WILL GIVE THE INVOCATION November 10, 2020 - REVISED 2 R E C O G N I T I O N  Nurse Practitioner Week C O N S E N T A G E N D A #5. Consideration of adopting minutes from the October 27, 2020 Meeting *#6. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-20-083 amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget to appropriate $632,496 with resources of $632,496 from the FY 2020 Department of Justice, Office on Violence Against Women, Improving Criminal Justice Responses Grant Program, also known as Arrest Program, to enhance the criminal justice response to sexual assault, domestic violence, dating violence, stalking, and protective order process. *#7. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-20-084 amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $76,507 with resources from the 2020 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund equipment for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. *#8. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-20-085 amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $32,130 with resources from the 2020 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department, Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. *#9. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-20-086 amending the FY2021 City/Federal State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $122,990 with resources from the 2020 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) Grant through the Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) to purchase mobile vehicle barriers and a trailer for the Lynchburg Police Department. *#10. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-20-087 amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $59,138 with resources of $29,569 from the Bulletproof Vest Partnership 2020 Grant Program and $29,569 transferred from the FY2021 General Fund Police Department and Sheriff’s Office budgets to purchase 74 replacement ballistic vests for law enforcement officers. P U B L I C H E A R I N G #11. Consideration of adopting an ordinance approving amendments to Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2-45, Limited Business District (B-1), Section 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-48.4, B-5, District Development Standards, Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Regulations and Section 35.2-61.3, Setbacks related to residential uses permitted by right as part of mixed use developments. #O-20-___ #12. Consideration of adopting a resolution to amend the geographic boundaries and local incentives for Enterprise Zone #2 and #46. #R-20-___ November 10, 2020 - REVISED 3 G E N E R A L B U S I N E S S #13. Consideration of adopting a resolution approving the renaming of the existing public street located between Page Street and Caroline Street, currently named Hillcrest Avenue, as Caroline Street. #R-20-___ #14. Consideration of adopting the 2021 Legislative Agenda. #R-20-___ #15. Consideration of a closed meeting to discuss the disposition of certain real property identified as 97 Page Street, Lynchburg, Virginia, including, if any, improvements thereon; and to discuss the appointment of members to the Economic Development Authority, Historic Preservation Committee, Parking Authority, Social Services Advisory Board, City Employee Appeals Board, Horizon Board of Directors, and for discussion and consideration of prospective candidates for appointment as the Clerk of Council, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(3) and Section 2.2- 3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: November 10, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 2 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: FY 2021 Adopted General Fund Operating Budget Review and Monthly Revenue Update KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _ _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Receive an update on the revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources and a review of the FY 2021 Adopted General Fund Operating Budget. SUMMARY: Several key Adopted FY 2021 revenue sources were reduced to reflect the anticipated economic impacts due to the COVID-19 pandemic; revenue collections are updated through November 2, 2020. This report is updated to include a review of the FY 2021 Adopted General Fund Budget as well. PRIOR ACTION(S): Rebalancing the Proposed FY 2021 General Fund Budget Due to Economic Impact of COVID-19, City Council, April 28, 2020. FISCAL IMPACT: As noted. CONTACT(S): Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): FY 2021 Adopted General Fund Operating Budget Review and Monthly Revenue Update REVIEWED BY: raw 149A City Council November 10, 2020 FY 2021 Adopted General Fund Operating Budget Review and Monthly Revenue Update COVID-19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue Monthly Update 2 Note: Actual collections revised as of October 31, 2020. Local Sales and Use Tax Adopted FY 2021 Actual Collections FY 2021 Variance to Adopted Budget FY 2021 Local Sales and Use Tax $15,454,579 $4,429,461 ($11,025,118) July 1,119,330 1,503,837 384,507 August 1,025,719 1,396,989 371,270 (Sales and Use Tax for September due by November 15th) September *Not Final 1,252,153 1,528,635 276,482 (Sales and Use Tax for October due by December 15th) October 1,251,875 0 (1,251,875) (Sales and Use Tax for November due by January 15th) November 1,361,561 0 (1,361,561) (Sales and Use Tax for December due by February 15th) December 1,585,420 0 (1,585,420) (Sales and Use Tax for January due by March 15th) January 1,160,079 0 (1,160,079) (Sales and Use Tax for February due by April 15th) February 1,196,836 0 (1,196,836) (Sales and Use Tax for March due by May 15th) March 1,432,681 0 (1,432,681) (Sales and Use Tax for April due by June 15th) April 1,331,840 0 (1,331,840) (Sales and Use Tax for May due by July 15th) May 1,447,319 0 (1,447,319) (Sales and Use Tax for June due by August 15th) June 1,289,766 0 (1,289,766) COVID-19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue Monthly Update (continued) 3 Note: Actual collections revised as of October 31, 2020. Meals Tax Adopted FY 2021 Actual Collections FY 2021 Variance to Adopted Budget FY 2021 Meals Tax $14,932,599 $3,476,273 ($11,456,326) July 970,231 1,090,332 120,101 August 1,081,853 1,186,360 104,507 September 1,161,186 1,199,581 38,395 (Meals Tax for October due by November 20th) October 1,357,034 0 (1,357,034) (Meals Tax for November due by December 20th) November 1,230,200 0 (1,230,200) (Meals Tax for December due by January 20th) December 1,286,319 0 (1,286,319) (Meals Tax for January due by February 20th) January 1,181,440 0 (1,181,440) (Meals Tax for February due by March 20th) February 1,237,691 0 (1,237,691) (Meals Tax for March due by April 20th) March 1,425,976 0 (1,425,976) (Meals Tax for April due by May 20th) April 1,352,984 0 (1,352,984) (Meals Tax for May due by June 20th) May 1,397,503 0 (1,397,503) (Meals Tax for June due by July 20th) June 1,250,182 0 (1,250,182) COVID-19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue Monthly Update (continued) 4 Note: Actual collections revised as of October 31, 2020. Lodging Tax Adopted FY 2021 Actual Collections FY 2021 Variance to Adopted Budget FY 2021 Lodging Tax $2,725,636 $551,820 ($2,173,816) July 147,156 155,637 8,481 August 177,753 213,511 35,758 September 208,246 182,672 (25,574) (Lodging Tax for October due by November 20th) October 314,431 0 (314,431) (Lodging Tax for November due by December 20th) November 218,220 0 (218,220) (Lodging Tax for December due by January 20th) December 156,330 0 (156,330) (Lodging Tax for January due by February 20th) January 211,325 0 (211,325) (Lodging Tax for February due by March 20th) February 208,445 0 (208,445) (Lodging Tax for March due by April 20th) March 279,608 0 (279,608) (Lodging Tax for April due by May 20th) April 233,875 0 (233,875) (Lodging Tax for May due by June 20th) May 300,480 0 (300,480) (Lodging Tax for June due by July 20th) June 269,767 0 (269,767) COVID-19 FY 2021 Adopted Revenue Monthly Update (continued) 5 Note: Actual collections revised as of October 31, 2020. Amusement Tax Adopted FY 2021 Actual Collections FY 2021 Variance to Adopted Budget FY 2021 Amusement Tax $795,190 $52,756 ($742,434) July 34,581 13,970 (20,611) August 28,321 19,248 (9,073) September 28,994 19,538 (9,456) (Amusement Tax for October due by November 20th) October 73,504 0 (73,504) (Amusement Tax for November due by December 20th) November 80,858 0 (80,858) (Amusement Tax for December due by January 20th) December 81,843 0 (81,843) (Amusement Tax for January due by February 20th) January 88,585 0 (88,585) (Amusement Tax for February due by March 20th) February 62,931 0 (62,931) (Amusement Tax for March due by April 20th) March 86,769 0 (86,769) (Amusement Tax for April due by May 20th) April 92,490 0 (92,490) (Amusement Tax for May due by June 20th) May 63,944 0 (63,944) (Amusement Tax for June due by July 20th) June 72,370 0 (72,370) Reminder: What We Know • First and foremost we still have citizens to serve and a City to maintain – Direct/Indirect services • Historical trends do not apply • Future trends…we will know when we know – With every passing month we know more – Receipt of revenue collection data lags (i.e. March received in May) 6 Reminder: There’s Still Uncertainty • Anchor Institutions (i.e. Colleges/Universities, Hospital) doing things differently – Uncertainty regarding how many college students will return to campus • Future Business Models – Uncertainty regarding working remotely vs brick and mortar • Impacts of reductions by the State, particularly for annual police funding ($3.1m), Personal Property Tax Reduction Subsidy ($5.5m), Highway Maintenance ($9.0m), and Education funding • Impacts of changes in consumer behavior • Potential Council action to make changes to tax rates • Uncertainty of when a vaccine will be available and the economic impact should there be a reoccurrence 7 Reminder: Big Picture Revenue Assumptions • Phased reopening dependent on downward COVID-19 trends for fourteen days consistent with Governor Northam/ President Trump direction. • 1st Quarter – assumes Virginia moves from Phase One to Phase Three by the end of the quarter which includes most businesses open with relaxed social distancing • 2nd Quarter – Phase Three continues with social distancing and consumer behavior driven by individual health concerns; businesses open • 3rd - 4th Quarters – anticipating more “normal” consumer spending 8 Economic Impacts for COVID-19 FY 2021 Revised Revenue Projections 9 Actual FY 2019 Actual FY 2020 Adopted FY 2021 Revised FY 2021 Change Assumptions Real Property Allowance for Uncollectible Real Property Delinquent Real Property Taxes $57,645,519 $1,486,404 $60,650,828 $1,168,509 $62,771,448 ($3,138,572) 5% $700,000 $62,771,448 ($3,138,572) 5% $700,000 $0 $0 $0 Increased uncollectible to 5%. Assumes less delinquent collections. Personal Property - local portion Allowance for Uncollectible Personal Property Delinquent Personal Property Taxes $18,850,037 $1,518,716 $20,028,232 $1,547,279 $18,525,000 ($539,251) 3% $1,260,000 $19,500,000 ($585,000) 3% $1,260,000 $975,000 ($45,749) $0 Adopted Reduced growth of $875k and an additional $100k for a 5% reduction. Revised vehicle purchase up. No change in uncollectible percent. Assumes less delinquent collections. Motor Vehicle Licenses $1,601,711 $1,647,832 $1,605,000 $1,650,000 $45,000 Not due until June 5, 2021. Revised vehicle purchase up. Delinquent Motor Vehicle Licenses $198,716 $215,987 $190,000 $220,000 $30,000 Revised increased for trends. 10 Actual FY 2019 Actual FY 2020 Adopted FY 2021 Revised FY 2021 Change Assumptions Local Sales and Use Tax $15,978,346 $16,553,430 $15,454,579 $16,500,000 $1,045,421 Adopted Projects Q1 (Jul- Sep) down 15% ($612,193), Q2 (Oct-Dec) down 3% ($133,228), or 5% annualized loss. Revised increased for trends. Meals Tax $15,111,870 $13,708,339 $14,932,599 $13,200,000 ($1,732,599) Adopted Projects Q1 (Jul- Sep) down 15% ($567,401), or 4% annualized loss. Revised to continue reductions in current trends. Lodging Tax $2,847,497 $2,346,355 $2,725,636 $2,135,623 ($590,013) Adopted Projects Q1 (Jul- Sep) down 38% ($324,364), or 11% annualized loss. Revised to continue reductions in current trends. Economic Impacts for COVID-19 FY 2021 Revised Revenue Projections (continued) Economic Impacts for COVID-19 FY 2021 Revised Revenue Projections (continued) Actual FY 2019 Actual FY 2020 Adopted FY 2021 Revised FY 2021 Change Assumptions Amusement Tax $820,805 $624,430 $795,190 $205,201 ($589,989) Adopted Projects Q1 (Jul- Sep) down 53% ($104,810), or 12% annualized loss. Revised to continue reductions in current trends. Communications Sales and Use Tax $2,877,715 $2,812,099 $2,500,000 $2,200,000 ($300,000) Revised based on monthly receipts. Consumer Utility Tax - Electric $3,852,130 $3,591,341 $3,800,000 $3,500,000 ($300,000) Revised based on monthly receipts. ($1,462,929) COVID-19 Revised FY 2021 Projected Additional Revenue Loss 11 FY 2021 Expenditure Directives • Extend hiring frost • Extend spending frost on all non-personnel related expenditures • Exercise mindful spending 12 February 9th Council Meeting • Expenditure adjustments will be proposed to Council on February 9th if the economy is not improving. • FY 2020 Personal Property Tax Payments (due December 5th) • FY 2020 Real Estate Tax Payments (due January 15th) • December Meals, Lodging, Amusement, and Sales Tax Payments – January 21st - Meals, lodging, and amusement tax payments – February 5th - Sales tax payments • Consumer behavior trends • Impact of College students on campus 13 February 9th Council Meeting The “LIST” - Items to Reconsider • If revenue trends allow: – Explore Addition of a Medic Unit ($264,812) (FY 2022 Impact $353,082+) (No overtime savings) (Academy > March 2021 Start) 6 full-time Firefighters (salary + benefits) – Explore Phase 2 of the Salary Study ($946,481) – 3% General Wage Increase ($2,015,952) – Funds for implementing the Downtown 2040 plan due to no longer making payments to the Academy Center of the Arts ($75,000) – Poverty Initiative 14 Questions, Comments, Observations 15 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: November 10, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 3 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Update on Utility Disconnect Moratorium KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _ _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Receive an update on utility disconnect moratorium and the status of current past due accounts. SUMMARY: Recently the General Assembly passed legislation related to a State Mandated Utility Disconnection Moratorium and Coronavirus Relief Funds; this legislation is included in the amended State budget and is currently on the Governor’s desk for his signature. These amendments enact a “universal” prohibition on service disconnections for past due accounts, require the establishment of repayment plans within 60 days on enactment, prohibits the charging of late fees, interest, or penalties. The act does allow for exemptions to the moratorium provided that arrearages exceed 1% of the utilities annual operating revenues, however, specific processes must be followed to qualify. Additionally, the act includes significant reporting requirements due on December 31st for the period of March 16, 2020 through December 15, 2020. Additional reports will also be required and are dependent upon how long the moratorium is in effect. There are provisions to allow for the use of $100 million in CARES funds but timing, availability, and administration of such funds will be challenging since this act also applies to electric and gas utilities and the funds have to be spent by the end of the calendar year. A summary of the requirements is attached. Below is the October utility delinquent account information. B Cycle (October 13th) Accounts with a Past Due balance of $35.01 or greater 311 Accounts Past Due Charges $87,385.11 Accounts with a Past Due balance of $100.00 or greater 176 Accounts Past Due Charges $79,938.20 A Cycle (October 27th) Accounts with a Past Due balance of $35.01 or greater 875 Accounts Past Due Charges $196,489.66 Accounts with a Past Due balance of $100.00 or greater 548 Accounts Past Due Charges $175,429.64 Pledges from August 11th through October 30th B Cycle A Cycle TOTAL Pledged by Accounts Pledge Amount Residential 294 811 1,105 Interfaith 48 $12,574.91 Non-Residential 17 64 81 Fairview Church 1 $140.00 TOTAL 311 875 1,186 Salvation Army* 5 $461.49 Hyland Heights Baptist Church 1 $37.11 Thomas Road Baptist Church 3 $402.81 St. Thomas Moore* 2 $198.36 Miriam’s House 2 $271.93 TOTAL TO DATE 62 $14,086.61 *NOTE: One account received assistance from Interfaith and St. Thomas Moore. PRIOR ACTION(S): n/a FISCAL IMPACT: As noted. CONTACT(S): Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources, 455-4252 Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): Summary of Disconnection Moratorium REVIEWED BY: raw 150A SUMMARY OF UTILITY DISCONNECTION MORATORIUM LEGISLATION Moratorium in effect until:  Applicable to water, wastewater, gas, and electric utilities.  Moratorium effective upon Governor’s signature.  Governor determines economic and public health conditions have improved enough to lift moratorium.  Or 60 days after State of Emergency ends (whichever is sooner).  Also, this is a biennial budget bill so it could be in effect until June 30, 2022. Notification  Within 60 days must notify all customers at least 30 days in arrears of the COVID Relief Repayment plan. Needs to include: eligibility, billing information, applicable financial resources, and contact information where customers can file a complaint or repayment plan related disputes. Repayment Plan  Shall not require: any new deposits, down payments, fees, late fees, interest charges, or penalties. Cannot accrue fees, interest, penalties, or prepayment penalties.  Plan shall amortize the repayment of debt over a minimum of 6 months up to 24 months.  Utility shall work with each customer to develop a plan that the customer determines is sustainable and affordable.  Utility shall not apply eligibility criteria such as payment history but can require the customer attest that they have experienced financial hardship as a result of COVID.  Utility must report that the customer is current.  Customer can seek debt relief from any available source and can renegotiate terms of repayment plan.  Utilities shall use available funding from CARES to provide subsidy payments on behalf of customers over 30 days in arrears with priority to customers over 60 days and to the extent possible cover 100% of arrearage. Exemption to Moratorium  Utilities can apply if arrearages exceed 1% of total annual operating revenue.  Must provide written analysis that demonstrates exceedance to governing body.  Documents must be made available for public inspection including work papers that verify exceedance.  Governing Body verifies exceedance, provides public notice, takes public comment in public meeting, and votes to approve. Reporting  Require to make report to Commission on Local Government including: o Number and value of accounts 30 days in arrears. o Number and value of accounts 60 days in arrears. o Number, total value, and average debt of accounts participating in repayment plan. o Number of accounts removed from repayment plan categorized by reason. o The amount and average debt still remaining for accounts removed from repayment plan. o Carrying costs of debt for accounts in repayment plan and associated administrative costs. o Number, total value and average debt offset by CARES. o Cumulative level of customer arrearages. o Report period March 16th through December 16th due December 31st. Cares Funds  $100 million available to all gas, electric, water, and sewer utilities in the state.  SCC develops application process.  Utilities shall create COVID -19 Utility Assistance Fund.  Record direct assistance payments.  Reflect direct assistance payment on customer’s bill.  Planning and Budget shall distribute funds to SCC within 30 days of this Act.  DHCD to verify utility eligibility. October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 27th day of October, 2020, at 3:15 P.M. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, MaryJane Dolan, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff S. Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Agenda Item #1, Council considered a closed meeting for the discussion of the terms and scope of a contract with a recruitment company for the hiring of a City Manager because discussion in an open session would adversely affect the bargaining position or negotiating strategy of the City and for discussion and consideration of prospective candidates for appointment as the Clerk of Council, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(29) and Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia. Councilmember Helgeson made the motion, seconded by Councilmember Wilder to enter into a closed session. There was no further discussion; Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was re-opened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 2 NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion conven ing the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Wright, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was recessed at 5:50 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: MaryJane Dolan, Beau Wright, Jeff S. Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Consent Agenda Item #2, copies of the minutes of the October 13, 2020 meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Registrar’s Office, Consent Agenda Item #3, Resolution #R-20-079 amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $63,882 with resources of $63,882 from the Center for Tech and Civic Life Grant (CTCL) to purchase voting equipment and supplies in addition to temporary staffing to meet the needs of new General Assembly Election laws and manage early voting October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 3 procedures for Lynchburg Citizens, and on motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, Council by the following recorded vote adopted Resolution #R-20-079: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Water Resources, Consent Agenda Item #4, Resolution #R-20-080 approving the water and sewer availability fees in the amount of $7,576 for water and $11,966 for sewer for the Bausch Health Expansion, and on motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, Council by the following recorded vote adopted Resolution #R-20-080: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Sheriff’s Office, Agenda Item # 5, this Council report was withdrawn prior to the meeting. // In the matter of the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney, Agenda Item #6, Council received the first reading of Resolution #R-20-083, amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget to appropriate $632,496 with resources of $632,496 from the FY 2020 Department of Justice, Office on Violence Against Women, Improving Criminal Justice Responses Grant Program, also known as Arrest Program, to enhance the criminal justice response to sexual assault, domestic violence, dating violence, stalking, and protective order process. Commonwealth’s Attorney Ms. Bethany Harrison provided Council with a brief summary of the request. The Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office was awarded $632,496 in FY 2020 for the Improving Criminal Justice Responses Program for the period of 10/1/2020 to 9/30/2024. The Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney is requesting approval to appropriate $632,496 towards the following criminal justice responses and victim services: hire an hourly (30 hours per week) In-House Investigator; hire a part-time (32 hours per week) Domestic/Dating Violence Prosecutor; hire a consultant to lead and further develop the Lynchburg Domestic Abuse Response Team (DART); in partnership with the YWCA October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 4 Domestic Violence Prevention Center and Sexual Assault Response Program, hire and house a part-time Protective Order advocate within the Lynchburg Juvenile and Domestic Relations District Court to assist victims in navigating the protective order process and to obtain needed resources and supports; training for new and seasoned staff members; and, computers and equipment for newly hired staff. Ms. Harrison continued by stating that this is a four year grant and the Commonwealth’s Attorney’s Office would have to wait a year before applying again. This item went to the October 27, 2020 Finance Committee meeting. Mayor Dolan deferred to the Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson. He stated there are staggering numbers in the increase of domestic violence cases. This grant will help facilitate in helping those that are witnesses, and those that are assaulted, with prevention of domestic violence, and the prosecution of such acts. He affirmed that the Finance Committee is thankful staff received this grant. There is no local match required. He brought the Finance Committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was needed, and Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Fire Department, Agenda Item #7, Council received the first reading of Resolution #R-20-084, amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $76,507 with resources from the 2020 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund equipment for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. Fire Chief Greg Wormser provided Council with a brief summary of the request. The Fire Department is seeking authorization to appropriate funds for a non-matching grant for technical rescue equipment. The Virginia Department of Emergency Management administers this grant from the United States Department of Homeland Security (DHS) through the State Homeland Security Program (SHSP). The grant program provides funding to improve the nation’s readiness in preventing, protecting against, responding to, recovering from, and mitigating terrorist attacks, major disasters and other emergencies. The grant reflects DHS’s focus on implementation of an all-of-nation, whole-community approach to October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 5 building, sustaining, and delivering core capabilities essential to achieving a secur e and resilient nation. The funds will be used for the purchase of confined space rescue equipment, confined space monitoring equipment, rope rescue equipment and USAR PPE that includes helmets and class III harnesses. The majority of this equipment is replacing existing equipment that has exceeded its useful life, but there are a few items that are being added to enhance rescue capabilities. He stated that this grant is 100% reimbursable and no local match is required. This item went to the October 27, 2020 Finance Committee meeting. Mayor Dolan deferred to the Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson. He stated that this equipment will help to protect our firefighters. He affirmed that the Finance Committee is thankful staff received this grant. He brought the Finance Committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was needed, and Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #8, Council received the first reading of Resolution #R-20-085 amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $32,130 with resources from the 2020 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department, Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. Police Chief Ryan Zuidema provided Council with a brief summary of the request. This is a recurring grant that is split between the Police Department, the Sheriff’s Office, and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. The City of Lynchburg was awarded $32,130 in Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) funding. The Lynchburg Police Department will use this funding to purchase 70 protective suits and 70 sets of protective gloves ($25,540). This equipment is essential for safety of both officers and citizens during events of civil unrest. Currently, the department has 85 sets of protective gear. Purchasing these additional suits and gloves will move the Lynchburg Police Department closer to the goal of equipping all 176 sworn staff. The Lynchburg Sheriff’s Offi ce will use funds to October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 6 purchase two laptops to assist with training ($3,435). The Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney will use funds to purchase two laptops ($3,155). The total equipment cost is $32,130, which is fully reimbursable by the grant. No local matching funds are required. The grant application requires the approval of the governing body prior to submission of the grant request. This item went to the October 27, 2020 Finance Committee meeting. Mayor Dolan deferred to the Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson. He offered the opinion of what’s interesting about this grant is that three law enforcement offices worked together in a concerted effort to receive this grant. He affirmed that the Finance Committee is thankful staff received this grant. There is no local match required. He brought the Finance Committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was needed, and Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #9, Council received a first reading of Resolution #R-20-086 amending the FY2021 City/Federal State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $122,990 with resources from the 2020 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) Grant through the Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) to purchase mobile vehicle barriers and a trailer for the Lynchburg Police Department. Police Chief Ryan Zuidema provided Council with a brief summary of the request. The Police Department was awarded $122,990 through a competitive grant process with the Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) to purchase mobile vehicle barriers and a trailer to transport them. This equipment will protect residents, visitors , and officers by preventing intentional motor vehicle assaults during planned permit gatherings, special events, demonstrations, dignitary visits and other assemblies. The total equipment cost is $122,990 which is fully reimbursable by the grant; no local matching funds are required. This item went to the October 27, 2020 Finance Committee meeting. Mayor Dolan deferred to the Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson. He stated that this equipment will ensure the safety of October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 7 our officers and our citizens. He affirmed that the Finance Committee is thankful staff received this grant. There is no local match required. He brought the Finance Committee’s recommendation for approva l forward as a motion. No second was needed, and Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of the Police Department, Agenda Item #10, Council received a first reading of Resolution #R-20-087, amending the FY 2021 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $59,138 with resources of $29,569 from the Bulletproof Vest Partnership 2020 Grant Program and $29,569 transferred from the FY2021 General Fund Police Department ($24,769) and Sheriff’s Office ($4,800) budgets to purchase 74 replacement ballistic vests for law enforcement officers. Police Chief Ryan Zuidema provided Council with a brief summary of the request . This is an annual request for the Bulletproof Vest Partnership through the Office of Justice Programs. For the 2020 Police Bulletproof Vest Partnership the City was awarded the funding, covering the cost of replacement ballistic vests for both the Police Department and the Sheriff’s Office. The vests provide protection to officers in the line of duty and the life of the vest is five years from the manufacturer date. The total replacement cost for seventy-four vests is $59,138. The grant requires a 50% local match; these funds are available in the FY 2021 General Fund Police and Sheriff’s Office operating budgets. This item went to the October 27, 2020 Finance Committee meeting. Mayor Dolan deferred to the Chair of that committee, Councilmember Helgeson. He stated that this is great defensive equipment that is needed to keep our officers safe. He also commended Chief Zuidema and his staff for recognizing that these would be ongoing expenses and obtaining grant funding to help alleviate those costs. He brought the Finance Committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion. No second was needed, and Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 8 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Engineering, Agenda Item #11, Council considered approving Ordinance #O-20-025 for the vacation of a sewer easement on 8004 Timberlake Road. City Engineer Mr. Lee Newland provided Council with a brief summary of the request. In 1988 the City acquired an easement to construct and operate a sewer line across the property located at 8004 Timberlake Road. However, the current owner of 8004 Timberlake Road, the Westwood Corporation, has plans to develop the property and the location of the City’s sewer easement limits the development of the property as the owner desires. TPB Enterprises is developing the adjacent property and has installed other sewer lines from Dreaming Creek and is not tying into this line. In order for the Westwood Corporation to develop 8004 Timberlake Road it has requested that the City vacate the City’s 1988 sewer easement. Staff have reviewed the request and recommends the City’s 1988 sewer easement be vacated. This matter has been vetted through, and has full support of, the Technical Review Committee. The vacation of the sewer easement will not have a negative impact on the City and will allow the Westwood Corporation to proceed with its development of the property. This item went to the October 13, 2020 Physical Development Committee and Acting Chair Councilmember Sterling Wilder made the motion to approve this ordinance. No second was needed, and Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Community Development – Rezoning, Agenda Item #12, Council considered the approval of the rezoning petition from R-4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional) to R-4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional) to amend a proffer that would increase the total number of apartments by ten (10) units. Ms. Rachel Frischeisen, Planner II, provided Council with a brief summary stating that TPB Enterprises, LLC (Tom Bell) is petitioning to rezone approximately seventeen and n ine tenths (17.9) acres located at 127 Brunswick Drive from R-4C, High Density Residential District (Conditional) to R-4C, High October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 9 Density Residential District (Conditional) to amend a previously approved proffer. The proffer included substantial compliance with a concept plan that showed a maximum of two hundred and seventy (270) units. The revised proffer/concept plan would amend the maximum to two hundred and eighty (280) units. The additional ten (10) units were incorporated into the original traffic study and concept plan. The change should have minimal effect on the area. All other proffers will remain unchanged. On October 13, 2020, City Council postponed action on the item and requested summaries of the previous rezoning of the property and environmental violations on the site. Since April of 2020, when former Councilmember Turner Perrow first gave this developer a stern warning, this particular site had eight environmental violations. Councilmember Helgeson stated that he is glad Council decided to table this item so that staff could bring the environmental violations pertaining to this site and the overall lack of the developer to address the issues, to Council for their consideration. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to deny the request, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi. Councilmember Nelson noted that he must abstain from voting on this item because he represents a client, who although not directly involved with this project, does stand to benefit financially from the success of the project. Councilmember Wilder asked if the amount of violations cited by the Department of Environmental Quality was normal. Zoning Administrator Mr. Kevin Henry said that this was a large site and the amount of violations is not uncommon, but what are not typical of these findings are the lack of correction and the lack of maintenance associated with these violations. Mayor Dolan commented that this development has changed in character over the years. She further explained that she read several sets of minutes over the years that this development changed hands. She mentioned a comment that stuck with her during her research; in March of 2020 , during a planning commission meeting, a commissioner asked City Planner Mr. Tom Martin how to prevent developers from transitioning from their original plans. His response was that Council needs to stop amending proffers. For this reason, Mayor Dolan will support the denial of amending this proffer. October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 10 There was no further discussion; Council, by the following recorded vote, approved t he motion for denial: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: 0 Abstain: Nelson 1 // In the matter of the City Manager’s Office, Agenda Item #13, Council reviewed and provided feedback to the 2021 Draft Legislative Agenda in preparation for the Virginia General Assembly Session. Interim City Manager Dr. Reid Wodicka provided a summary of staff recommendations:  Updated language regarding recommendation for the improvement of commercial air service development.  Removal of language requesting changes to the Virginia’s Region 2000 Airport Authority Act since it was not successful in the last year.  Updates to the Economic Development section to more accurately reflect the present economic development environment.  Addition of language in support of continued state tourism funding.  Addition of language requesting the repeal of the requirements for Economic Development Authority members to file financial disclosure forms.  Added language to request that the General Assembly revise the Lynchburg Parking Authority’s terms from five years to three years and allow members to serve three terms instead of two.  Updated language regarding the impact of changes in legislation that could eliminate Machinery and Tools and/or Business License taxes.  Updated and reorganized section on Drinking Water, Water Quality, and the Environment to better reflect the current present regulatory environment.  Updated language to the binding arbitration section opposing any language th at would amend the City’s choice as to their participation in collective bargaining or binding arbitration. Additionally, opposing the repeal of Virginia’s right to work law. October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 11  Addition of language opposing any preclearance of changes to voting laws or prac tices, such as changing the City’s wards and polling places.  Addition of language opposing the removal of qualified immunity for local law enforcement officers.  Update to the short-term rental language to reflect the current state of short term rentals in Virginia localities. Vice Mayor Wright will be attending a Virginia First Cities meeting as Lynchburg’s representative and offered to bring any proposals or recommendations that are in-line with Lynchburg’s interest back to staff for incorporation. Councilmember Helgeson cautioned that this approach seems too broad and asked Council to consider a more focused approach; a strategy used years ago of picking a few specific topics agreed upon by the vast majority of Council and really pushing for those. Councilmember Faraldi asked for clarification on the updated language to the binding arbitration section opposing any language that would amend the City’s choice as to their participation in collective bargaining or binding arbitration, and opposing the repeal of Virginia’s right to work law. City Attorney Mr. Walter Erwin stated that the legislation that was adopted by the General Assembly this year dealing with collective bargaining was a compromise. The House wanted to require localities to recognize unions and engage in collective bargaining. The Senate wanted to make it optional, and the Senate version passed. Currently, a locality is not required to engage in collective bargaining or to recognize union s. The language is asking the General Assembly to not change the existing legislation and require that it should remain a local option and that it should not be mandatory. So the initiative behind the agenda would be to support the Senate version and not the House version. Councilmember Faraldi confirmed his support of keeping this on the agenda. Councilmember Faraldi also asked staff for the addition of a statement regarding unfunded mandates. He emphasized the importance of protecting the fact that if the State will be mandating that the City of October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 12 Lynchburg has to establish certain policy initiatives, then the State has a responsibility to find a solution for assisting localities in achieving that. Vice Mayor Wright asked for clarification regarding the City’s process for drawing wards. Mr. Erwin explained that this is addressed after receiving the results of the 2020 census. The population in each ward has to be in certain percentage of one another, so once the census figures are received, this data will be input into software programs that determine the various options that are possible for drawing the boundaries. Staff will then present those options to City Council and Council adopts the changes that they believe are the most appropriate. In the past, those changes would need to be approved by the U.S. Department of Justice, but that is no longer a requirement. Councilmember Nelson stated that for strategic reasons, he would like to keep everything that our staff, our administrators, and our community feel is important to be on the list so that when it gets to the proper place in Richmond where it will be discussed, they will know we have a position on it even though it might not be a priority to us in relation to other things. Councilmember Tweedy asked for the addition of language supporting early childhood education, particularly how to incentivize expanding daycare options in the workforce. Dr. Wodicka explained that these revisions will be addressed and the final agenda brought back at the November 10th Council meeting. // In the matter of Schools, Agenda Item #14, Resolution #R-20-082 received a second reading, laid over from a previous meeting, amending the FY 2021 General Fund budget and appropriate $3,431,645 with resources from unexpended FY 2020 Schools Operating Fund for transfer to the FY 2021 Schools Operating Fund and to the Schools Capital Fund to fund needs as approved by the School Board. Interim City Manager Dr. Reid Wodicka explained that according to Council’s Rules of Procedure, since this item did not receive a unanimous vote for approval, the second reading comes back to Council under General Business. October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 13 Councilmember Wilder made the motion to approve the resolution stating he sees the value in the school system and is in favor or appropriating the funds they need; Councilmember Tweedy seconded the motion. Councilmember Helgeson remarked to the staggering number of daily average of absenteeism among students and worries the achievement gap is expanding. Even though this item comes before Council as the second reading, he explained that he feels it prudent to discuss different strategies and allow for more conversation on how the schools spend their funds. Vice Mayor Wright said that the items that the return to fund balance would go to buy are not necessarily correlated to the potentially short-term fluctuation in school attendance. These resources would be used to fund maintenance-type products and do not support the rise and fall of attendance during the pandemic. He confirmed his support of this resolution. Councilmember Faraldi asked if Councilmember Wilder would allow for a friendly amendment to his motion so that Council could consider this in two votes. He emphasized his support of awarding bonuses for the frontline workers, i.e. the nutritionists and the bus drivers. However, he commented that there are aspects of this proposal that he would like to delay in order to have a more robust discussion. He attributed this to the schools receiving CARES Act funds plus additional funding from the State and he would like to see a plan for how the schools propose to use all of those funds. Councilmember Wilder replied that he does not feel it is Council’s position to micromanage how the school board and school administration spend their funds. He entrusts the school system to see how best to utilize their funds based on their needs, and as such, will be leaving his motion as-is. Councilmember Faraldi made a substitute motion to engage on this issue in two separate votes. Councilmember Nelson seconded the substitute motion. Councilmember Faraldi further affirmed his support of the bonuses for the workers, but emphasized his desire of learning how the schools intend to spend all of the funds they received from federal and state aid. He maintained that grasping this bigger picture will help maintain financial prudence. October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 14 Councilmember Nelson stated that the schools have received a substantial amount of federal funding that has an impending expiration date. He is in favor of giving the school division as much incentive to spend all of those funds. He clarified that he is not saying to not appropriate the fund balance to the schools, but rather hold the funds in reserve until other aid is expended. From a comprehensive point of view, it is prudent and not an unreasonable approach to set aside those funds and make certain that the money with an expiration date is spent before the money that has been generated by the fund balance. Vice Mayor Wright stated that these are in two different buckets of funds; a fund balance that can be spent on the list of smaller capital projects, and funding that can only be spent on items specifically attributable to the pandemic. He further asked Councilmembers Wilder and Tweedy to consider splitting the vote so that Council can clear up certain aspects of this resolution. Councilmember Wilder stated that the resolution is in reference to the fund balance and as such, will be voting against the substitute motion. Councilmember Tweedy echoed that this item is in relation to the fund balance and further reiterated that the CARES Act funds need to be spent within certain parameters. The school system is aware of those guidelines and Council should entrust them to stay within those rules. She also stated, for further consideration at a later date, that Council should consider improving the infrastructure of internet and Wi-Fi accessibility in households of residents of the City of Lynchburg. She stated that this issue is not just on the shoulders of the schools, this is a citywide issue and one that Council needs to support. There was no other discussion, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Helgeson, Nelson, Faraldi 5 Noes: Tweedy, Wilder 2 Vice Mayor Wright made the motion to approve the line item listed for the bonuses, seconded by Councilmember Nelson. Councilmember Helgeson stated that he would have liked to see this motion further divided so that the bonuses could be awarded only to the frontline workers within the school October 27, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 15 system. He believes that this is a huge priority and a motion he would have voted in favor for; however, in the interest of time he would not be requesting to further divide this vote, but he would be supporting the motion. Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Faraldi 6 Noes: Helgeson 1 Councilmember Wilder made the motion to appropriate the remaining funds to be allocated for the items on the list, seconded by Vice Mayor Wright. Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5 Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2 // The meeting is adjourned at 9:10 p.m. LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: November 10, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 11 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Proposed Amendments to mixed use development in B-1, B-3 & B-5 Zoning Districts KEY ELEMENTS: _X Economic Development X Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _X Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Approve amendments to Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2-45, Limited Business District (B-1), Section 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-48.4, B-5, District Development Standards, Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Regulations and Section 35.2-61.3, Setbacks related to residential uses permitted by right as part of mixed use developments. SUMMARY: City Council directed staff to prepare Zoning Ordinance amendments related to residential uses permitted by right as part of mixed use developments in business districts on September 22, 2020. City staff has prepared draft amendments based upon discussion with City Council on September 22, 2020 and with representatives from the Richland Hills Neighborhood Association. At the October 28, 2020 meeting, the Planning Commission requested that ground floor residential be defined. The proposed amendments would:  Clarify that multi-tenant commercial developments or mixed-use developments are limited to fifty thousand (50,000) sf per lot.  Define ground floor residential as the floor of a building most nearly on a level with the ground and facing the public street.  Prohibit ground floor residential in the B-1, B-3 & B-5 Districts.  For lots in the B-1 District, limit buildings to two (2) stories when adjacent to an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District.  Require commercial space to comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of building gross floor area when part of a mixed-use development in the B-1, B-3 & B-5 District.  For lots in the B-1 District, require a fence at least six (6) feet in height to be established when adjacent to an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District.  For lots in the B-1 District, require height to be measured from the natural grade at the horizontal midpoint of the building when adjacent to a residential district.  For lots in the B-1 District, require a fifty (50) foot setback when adjacent to an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District. PRIOR ACTION(S): January 14, 2014: The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 was adopted by City Council. February 23, 2016: The City’s Zoning Ordinance was adopted by City Council. September 22, 2020: City Council initiated amendments to the Zoning Ordinance. October 28, 2020: The Planning Division recommended approval of the Zoning Ordinance amendments. The Planning Commission recommended approval (6-0, with one member absent, Perault) of the Zoning Ordinance amendments. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A CONTACT(S): Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner – 455-3900 ATTACHMENT(S):  Ordinance  Planning Commission Minutes – October 28, 2020  Planning Commission Presentation Slides – October 28, 2020  Planning Commission Report – October 28, 2020 o Draft Ordinance – October 28, 2020  City Council Agenda Summary – September 22, 2020 o Presentation Slides o Memo o Logan’s Landing II Preliminary Site Plan (excerpt)  Planning Commission Sign-in Sheet – October 28, 2020 REVIEWED BY: klw 145A ORDINANCE: AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT THE CODE OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, 1981 BY AMENDING ZONING ORDINANCE SECTION 35.2-45, LIMITED BUSINESS DISTRICT (B-1), SECTION 35.2-46.4, B-3 DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, SECTION 35.2-48.4, B-5 DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, SECTION 35.2-61.2, ADDITIONAL HEIGHT REGULATIONS AND SECTION 35.2-61.3, SETBACKS RELATED TO RESIDENTIAL USES PERMITTED BY RIGHT AS PART OF A MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT. WHEREAS, the City Council directed City staff to prepare Zoning Ordinance Amendments related to residential uses allowed by right in the B-1, B-3 and B-5 Districts on September 22, 2020. WHEREAS, the City Council held a public hearing to consider and address the proposed Zoning Ordinance Amendments and to receive public comment on November 10, 2020. WHEREAS, the City Council finds that these amendments should be adopted in order to promote the public necessity, convenience, welfare and good zoning practice. BE IT ORDANINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: That Section 35.2-45, Limited Business District (B-1), Section 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-48.4, B-5 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Regulations and Section 35.1-61.3, Setbacks related to residential uses permitted by right as part of a mixed use development of the Code of the City of Lynchburg, 1981, be the same is hereby amended and reenacted as follows: 35.2‐45 Limited Business Districts (B‐1) 35.2‐45.2 Authorized Uses (a) The uses authorized by IV‐12 may be established in accordance with the procedures in Article II, the district standards in this article, the site development standards established in Article II and specific use standards established in Article VI, as well as other applicable rules and regulations. (b) Uses may also be limited by overlay standards established in Article V of this Zoning Ordinance. (c) See Article III for the rules of interpreting authorized uses and Appendix A for a complete listing of land uses allowed in every zoning district. (d) Uses designated “P” are permitted by right and uses designated “C” require issuance of a conditional use permit. Exhibit IV‐12: Authorized Uses in B‐1 District Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type single‐household detached 1111S Typical single‐household dwelling P modular home 1114S A prefabricated home without axles or frames (see definitions) P Two‐household (duplex) 1121S A building located on one (1) zoning lot containing not more than two (2) dwelling units C single‐household attached (townhouse) 1140S Each unit on a separate lot; fire wall may protrude from roof or roofs may be staggered C Multi‐household structures 1200S Includes triplexes, four‐plexes, and other multi‐ household dwellings C Mixed‐use residential structures (see district regulations for limitations) 1201S Typically commercial uses on lower floors and residential uses on upper floors P Housing Services 1200 Housing and custodial services for those who cannot care for themselves. Includes nursing and retirement homes, congregate living, assisted and continuing care living, but excludes rehab uses in LBCS #6520) P Bed & Breakfast and Tourist Homes 1310 Guest rooms in a private home or accessory building to a private home P boarding house 1321 Non‐transient lodging that may include meals and is owner occupied P rooming house 1322 Transient or non‐transient lodging that may include meals P dormitory, sorority or fraternity house 1323 Allowed only as accessory uses to and owned by a college or university C Short Term Rental 1350 Provision of lodging for fewer than thirty (30) consecutive days. (See Section 35.2‐71.16) P Bicycles 2113b New or used bicycle sales, rental and repair P Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type camera and photographic supplies; clothing, jewelry, luggage, shoes, clocks, sewing; sporting goods, toy and hobby, and musical instruments; mixed media, school and office supplies 2132‐ 2135 Primarily retail cameras and photographic supplies or retail with repair and film developing; clothing (including shoe repair and tailoring, sporting goods, toys, musical instruments, kitchen goods, books, magazines, music, videos, stationary, greeting cards, seasonal decorations, office and school supplies. P florist, art supplies, tobacco products 2141‐ 2143 Florists, art supplies and art dealers, frame shops, tobacco products P art galleries 2142b Excludes art supply sales and retail framing services P antique shop 2145 Antique shops, (excludes flea markets, thrift stores and pawn shops) P grocery store, supermarket, or bakery, convenience store, specialty food stores 2151‐ 2154 Included are grocery stores, convenience stores, meat, seafood and produce markets, coffee, confections, variety goods and general stores, and delicatessens. Excludes stores with fuel pumps (see 2116 for fuel sales). P beer, wine, and liquor store 2155 P Health and personal care 2160 Retail prescription or nonprescription drugs; retail cosmetics, perfumes, toiletries; prescription or nonprescription eyeglasses; prescription or nonprescription health and convalescent aids; medical devices, retail food supplement products such as vitamins, nutrition supplements, and body enhancing supplements. P Bank, credit union, or savings institution 2210 Central banking functions P credit card and other financing 2221 Credit card, sales financing, unsecured consumer lending, real estate credit, mortgages, international trade financing P Investment banking, securities, and brokerages; insurance; fund, trust, or other financial establishment 2230‐ 2250 Securities underwriting, brokering, exchange services, managing portfolios; Insurance underwriting, selling insurance; manage assets on behalf of shareholders or beneficiaries P Real estate services 2310 Sell or lease real estate such as buildings, manufactured home sites and vacant lots; includes real estate appraisers and realtor offices P professional offices 2411‐ 2014 Title abstract, lawyers, notaries, accountants, bookkeeping, payroll services, architects, engineers, surveyors, graphic design, interior design and industrial design P consulting services (management, environmental technical) 2415 Advise and assist businesses on management, scientific, and technological issues P scientific research and development services 2416 Conduct research or analyze in the physical, engineering, cognitive, or life sciences in offices. P Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type other professional offices 2419, 6810, 6820 Includes advertising and media services intellectual property rights, franchising, labor, political or business organizations, and uses with similar impacts P office administrative services 2421 Office administration such as billing, record keeping, personnel, organizational planning P facilities support services 2422 Provide operating staff for support services within a client's facilities, including janitorial, security, laundry services, etc. P employment agency 2423a Provide employee placement, temporary help P copy center, private mail center, other business support services 2424 Provide document preparation, telephone answering, telemarketing, court reporting, steno typing, FAX, internet access, small signs and banners P collection agency 2425 Collect payments, compile credit information, repossess tangible assets P Travel arrangement and reservation services 2430 Promote or sell travel, includes convention and visitors' bureaus P Restaurants, cafeterias, snack bars & catering 2510‐ 2530 &2560 Provide food and drinks to patrons – see district specific use regulations for limitations. Includes banquet, assembly and reception halls. See district standards. P Personal care 2610 Hair, nail, and skin care and related personal care, barbers, beauty shops, dieting and weight loss, tanning, hair removal, hair weaving, ear piercing and similar services P laundromat and dry cleaning 2621 & 2622 Includes Laundromats, dry cleaners, diaper services as well as other commercial laundry services P Photofinishing 2630 Primarily engaged in developing film or making slides, etc. P Parking lot and parking garage 2640 See district standards P licensed massage therapist 2651 P pet cemetery 2723 C national post office 4181 P retail courier and package delivery 4182 Retail courier, package drop‐off and mail services P wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see section 35.2-73 for telecommunications towers P telephone and other wired telecommunications 4234 Operate telephone networks – excludes switching stations P Telecommunications switching stations/exchanges 4239 Telecommunications switching stations and exchanges with no on‐site employees C library or archive 4242 Provide library or archive services P data processing and management, hosting and related services 4244 Web hosting, computer data storage, optical scanning, computer input preparation, microfilm imaging P Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type Public Utilities Services, Major 4315, 4329, 4339, 4349 Includes transmission lines for water, wastewater, stormwater, electricity, natural gas or telecommunications services regulated by the State Corporation Commission of a regional nature and normally entail the construction of new buildings or structures such as electrical switching facilities and stations or substations, electric, gas, and other utility transmission lines of a regional nature which are not otherwise reviewed and approved by the Virginia State Corporation Commission. All overhead transmission lines are included in this definition. C Public Utilities Service Minor 4315, 4329, 4339, 4349 Includes distribution or collection lines and appurtenances for water, wastewater, stormwater, electricity, natural gas or telecommunications services regulated by the State Corporation Commission that are necessary to support development within the immediate vicinity and involve only minor structures. Included in this use type are small facilities such as transformers, relay and booster devices, and well, water and sewer pump stations, and wireless communication antennas attached to existing buildings or structures. P electric substations 4316 C Water treatment plants and utility facilities 4331 – 4333, Water treatment plants, pumping stations and lift stations C Theater, dance or music establishment 5110 & 5160 Companies, groups, or theaters that produce theatrical presentations, dance, dinner theaters, and live musical entertainment; includes facilities for independent artists and performers P Promoter of sports, performing arts, similar events and management services 5140 ‐ 5150 Organize, promote, and manage performances and events; agents representing artists, athletes and entertainers P Museums and Other Special Purpose Recreational Institutions 5200 Public and private museums, historical sites, and similar establishments P Country Club 5340 & 6830 Operate private country clubs, with tennis courts and golf courses along with dining facilities and other recreational facilities; includes civic, social and fraternal organizations without dwellings P fitness and recreational sports center 5371 Aerobic dance or exercise center, gymnasium, physical fitness center, health and athletic club, indoor handball, racquetball, volleyball, tennis, or swimming facilities conducted inside a building P outdoor recreation 5372, 5373 & 5374 Includes for profit golf courses, archery ranges, outdoor volleyball, tennis, or swimming facilities, recreational courts, recreational day camp and horseback riding C Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type Natural and other Recreational Parks 5500 All parks without special economic functions, other than limited concessions P Nursery or preschool 6110 P Grade school 6120 Comprises all public, private, and specialty schools between the preschool and university level; includes adult education services not addressed elsewhere. See district use standards P College or university 6130 See district use standards P Public Safety 6400 Government‐owned establishments providing fire and rescue, police, and emergency response services P Clinic 6511 & 6567 Include physician offices, dentists, chiropractors, optometrists, licensed massage therapists, and veterans affairs services P outpatient care clinic 6512 Provide outpatient family planning services and outpatient care P group home small 6522 Fewer than five (5) aged or infirm individuals or fewer than nine (9) individuals with mental, intellectual or developmental disabilities P group home large 6523 Five or more aged or infirm individuals, or nine (9) or more individuals with mental, intellectual or developmental disabilities P Hospital 6530 C child and adult day care 6562 Provide day care for children and adults Home 6562a Day care for fewer than six (6) individuals in a residence P Small 6562b Day care for six (6) to twelve (12) individuals in a residence P Large 6562c Provide care for more than 12 individuals P Religious Institutions 6600 Churches, temples, synagogues, mosques, convents and monasteries P Funeral home and services 6710 Includes funeral homes combined with crematories P free‐standing cemetery 6722 P Columbarium 6724 C Vegetable farming or growing 9120 Includes private fields and community gardens with production limited to retail sales P Commercial orchards 9130 Includes fruit and nut trees with production limited to retail sales P Animal Production 9300 Keep, graze, breed or feed animals (see district standards) P tent revival meetings/transient amusements 9921 Includes temporary carnivals and circuses sponsored by non‐profit organizations (see section35.2‐72.23) P cluster commercial development 9955 See section 35.2‐85 C 35.2‐45.3 B‐1 District Use Standards The following standards supplement the standards for specific uses established in Error! Reference source not found.: (a) No lot, building or structure shall be used and no building or structure shall be erected that is intended or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any industrial or manufacturing purposes. (b) Drive‐through and drive‐in uses are not allowed in this district except under the following conditions: 1. Drive through and drive‐in uses shall not be associated with businesses providing food or beverage services; 2. Drive‐through services shall be located in the rear of the building and shall take access from an urban collector or local street; and 3. Drive‐through services shall be designed so that not more than one (1) two‐way access or two (2) one‐way access points serving such uses shall be located on a single block. (c) Outdoor operations, storage, or display are prohibited except as authorized for temporary outdoor display or outdoor dining. (d) The scale of businesses shall be compatible with adjacent neighborhoods and shall not exceed the floor areas established in Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in document.‐1. Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in document.‐1: Maximum Floor Areas for the B‐1 District Maximum Gross Floor Area (sq.ft.) Per Lot Development Multi‐tenant commercial developments or Mixed Use Developments 50,000 Single office development 20,000 Single retail or service business 5,000 Restaurant 4,000 (e) Except authorized single household dwellings and other residential uses permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited. except when part of a mixed‐use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or local street. For purposes of this section ground floor residential shall be the floor of a building most nearly on a level with the ground and facing the public street. (f) Schools for general education with maximum enrollments of twenty‐five (25) or fewer students shall only be allowed subject to the setbacks for other uses allowed in the district. Schools with maximum enrollments in excess of twenty‐five (25) students shall be subject to approval of a conditional use permit and setback requirements for schools established in section Error! Reference source not found. (Schools, Colleges and Vocational Schools). (g) Not more than three (3) unrelated individuals may occupy a dwelling unit in the B‐1 district unless otherwise approved by a conditional use permit. (h) Accessory uses and structures shall comply with the provisions of section Error! Reference source not found.. 35.2‐45.4 B‐1 District Development Standards Dimensional standards for the B‐1 district are summarized in Exhibit . Section cross‐references identify the location of additional dimensional standards and rules for their application. The standards in this section apply in addition to the site development standards of Article VI and site development standards applicable to specific uses established in Article VII. (a) Setbacks. Setbacks are subject to compliance with in section Error! Reference source not found. (Error! Reference source not found.) and applicable landscaping requirements. (b) Lot Area Regulations. In addition to the minimum lot size of 6,000 square feet, a total minimum area of 1,000 square feet is required for each dwelling unit, or unit in a boardinghouse, lodging house, nursing home, tourist home or hotel unit. (c) Parking. Required on‐site parking shall be provided behind the front building line in accordance with section Error! Reference source not found. except where an existing building with parking in front of the building line is being reused and locating required parking in rear or side yards is not practical due to extreme topography or access limitations. (d) Dumpsters. Dumpsters on lots abutting residential zoning districts shall be screened pursuant to section Error! Reference source not found. (Utility Screening) and set back at least twenty‐five (25) feet from any residential property line (e) Landscaping Where a building is located within five (5) feet of the right‐of‐way, required street trees and foundation plantings may be planted in City right‐of‐way with permission of the City. (f) Development Patterns. The B‐1 district development standards may be modified through the approval of a cluster commercial development. (g) Lots abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts. Multi‐story buildings on lots that abut lots in an R‐1, R‐3 or R‐3 Districts shall not exceed 2 stories within 100 feet of the property line of said abutting lots. See section #5.2‐61.2 for additional height requirements and section 35.2‐61.3 for additional setback requirements for lots abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 districts. (h) Mixed Use Developments permitted by right. 1. Commercial space shall comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of the building gross floor area. 2. When a mixed use development in a B‐1 District is adjacent to an R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 District, a fence that is not less than six (6) feet in height shall be established with the required buffer as required by Section 35.2‐63.10 (d). 10 Exhibit Summary of B‐1 Development Standards Design Element Standards Section Cross‐Reference Maximum height 40’ Error! Reference source not found. Minimum front setback from right‐of‐way (dimension A) 0’ 0 Minimum side setback, interior (dimension B) 0’ 0 Minimum side setback, exterior (dimension C) 0’ 0 Minimum rear setback (dimension D) 25’ 0 Minimum lot width at front property line (dimension E) and front setback line (dimension F) 50’ Error! Reference source not found. Minimum lot depth (dimension F) 100’ Error! Reference source not found. Minimum lot area (square feet) 6,000 with 1,000 sq.ft. of lot area per dwelling unit or boarding unit Error! Reference source not found. Letters in drawing to the left correspond with dimensions cited in the design element column 11 35.2‐46.3 B‐3 District Use Standards The following standards supplement the standards for specific uses established in Article VII: (a) Schools and colleges of all types (including vocational schools) shall not exceed a maximum enrollment of one hundred (100) students except as authorized by conditional use permit. (b) Radio and television studios and stations shall not have towers, shall produce no exterior electromagnetic effect and shall be soundproofed from adjoining properties. (c) Large‐scale retail establishments shall comply with section 35.2‐84 (Retail Establishments, Large Scale) unless otherwise approved through the conditional use permit process. (d) Dance floors may be allowed as accessory uses to restaurants. (e) Arenas and auditoriums approved through the conditional use permit process shall be limited to a maximum capacity of two thousand five hundred (2,500) persons. (f) Veterinarian hospitals authorized through the conditional use permit process shall not have outdoor kennels. (g) Except authorized single household dwellings and other residential uses permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited. except when part of a mixed‐use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or local street. For purposes of this section ground floor residential shall be the floor of a building most nearly on a level with the ground and facing the public street. (h) Outdoor storage is prohibited. (i) Accessory uses and structures shall comply with the provisions of section 35.2‐71 12 35.2‐48.3 B‐5 District Use Standards The following standards supplement the standards for specific uses established in Article VII: (a) No operations shall create conditions of smoke, fumes, noise, odor, light or dust detrimental to health, safety or the general welfare of the community. (b) Billboards shall be subject to the regulations of section 35.2‐64.16 (Billboards). (c) Second‐hand stores may include auction sales provided such activity is conducted wholly within an enclosed building. (d) Storage warehouses and yards shall not include the storage of combustibles prohibited by the fire code, sand yards, gravel yards, coal yards, railroad yards and automobile wrecking yards. (e) Schools and colleges of all types that exceed a maximum enrollment of one hundred (100) students are prohibited unless otherwise approved through issuance of a conditional use permit. (f) Except residential uses specifically permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited. except when part of a mixed‐use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or local street. For purposes of this section ground floor residential shall be the floor of a building most nearly on a level with the ground and facing the public street. (g) Large‐scale retail establishments shall comply with the provisions of section 35.2‐84 (Retail Establishments, Large Scale) unless otherwise approved through issuance of a conditional use permit. (h) Outdoor storage, which is permitted as an accessory to a principal use, shall be screened in accordance with section 35.2‐63.9 (Utility Screening). 13 35.2‐46.4 B‐3 District Development Standards Dimensional standards for the B‐3 district are summarized in Error! Reference source not found.. Section cross‐references identify the location of additional dimensional standards and rules for their application. The standards in this section apply in addition to the site development standards of Article VI and site development standards applicable to specific uses established in Article VII. (a) Setbacks. Setbacks are subject to compliance with in section Error! Reference source not found. (Error! Reference source not found.) and applicable landscaping requirements. (b) Lots Abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts. See section Error! Reference source not found. for additional height requirements and section 0 for additional setback requirements for lots abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 districts. (c) Area Regulations. A minimum of one thousand (1,000) square feet of lot area is required for each dwelling unit or unit in a boardinghouse, lodging house, convalescent and nursing home, tourist home or hotel. (d) Parking. Parking areas shall be set back at least twenty (20) feet from front or exterior side property lines or set behind the front building line on all street frontages. (e) Development Patterns. The B‐3 district development standards may be modified through the approval of a cluster commercial development or traditional neighborhood development. (f) Mixed Use Developments permitted by right. 1. Commercial space shall comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of the building gross floor area. 14 35.2‐48.4 B‐5 District Development Standards Dimensional standards for the B‐5 district are summarized in Exhibit IV 20. Section cross‐references identify the location of additional dimensional standards and rules for their application. The standards in this section apply in addition to the site development standards of Article VI and site development standards applicable to specific uses established in Article VII. (a) Height regulations. Subject to the provisions of sections 35.2‐61.2 (Height) and 35.2‐61.3 (Setbacks), buildings may be erected to any height, provided that the height of that portion of the building in excess of two (2) times the width of the street on which it abuts shall be governed by the following regulations: 1. For each foot such building or portion thereof is set back from any street, lot or minimum setback line, such building or portion thereof may be erected ten (10) feet in height, provided that no street shall for this purpose be considered to be less than forty (40) feet nor more than sixty (60) feet in width. 2. If a building abuts on two (2) or more streets, that street which permits the greater height shall be used as the basis of measurement. (b) Lots Abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts. See section 35.2‐61.2 (Height) for additional height requirements and section 35.2‐61.3 (Setbacks) for additional setback requirements for lots abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 districts. (c) Area regulations. Each dwelling, boardinghouse, lodging house, convalescent and nursing home, tourist home and hotel, together with their accessory buildings, shall be located on a lot having an area of not less than one thousand (1,000) square feet for each household unit, except that the minimum area for any such lot shall be six thousand (6,000) square feet, and the minimum width fifty (50) feet. (d) Development Patterns. The B‐5 district development standards may be modified through the approval of a cluster commercial development or traditional neighborhood development. (e) Mixed Use Developments permitted by right. 1. Commercial space shall comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of the building gross floor area. 15 35.2‐61 Building Envelope, Lot Area and Density Standards 35.2‐61.1 Rules for Building Envelope Standards (Height, Setbacks and Building Coverage) (a) The building envelope standards are listed for each zoning district in Article IV and are summarized in Appendix B. This section describes the general rules for applying height, setback and building coverage standards. (b) Building envelope standards, other than those established in the applicable zoning district and this article may apply when: 1. Greater setbacks or lesser heights are required pursuant to the zoning district standards in Article IV or the standards in this article; 2. An overlay district imposes different standards pursuant to Article V; 3. The City Council approves alternative building envelope standards pursuant to a conditional use permit issued in accordance with section 35.2‐11 (Applications Requiring Public Hearings Before City Council); or 4. Board of Zoning Appeals modifies building envelope standards by granting a variance pursuant to section 35.2‐12 (Variances and Appeals to the Board of Zoning Appeals). 35.2‐61.2 Additional Height Regulations (a) Measurement of Height 1. Building Height. Building height is the vertical distance measured from the crown of the street opposite the middle of the front of the building to: 16 The highest point of roof surface of a flat roof The deck line of a mansard roof The mean height level between eaves and ridge of a gable, hip or gambrel roof 2. Exceptions to Measurement of Building Height a. Buildings with Large Setbacks. Where a building is set back from the street line thirty‐five (35) feet or more, building height shall be measured from the average elevation of finished ground surface along the front of the building. b. Large Corner Lots. On corner lots exceeding twenty thousand (20,000) square feet in area, the height of the building may be measured from the crown of either street at the midpoint of the building facing the applicable street. c. Through Lots. For lots extending through from street to street, the height may be measured from the crown of either street at the midpoint of the building facing the applicable street, provided that the maximum height that would be 17 permitted based on the lower street shall extend back from the right‐of‐way of such street not less than one hundred fifty (150) feet (see following illustration). d. Properties Abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts. For lots in any R‐4, B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐1, I‐1, I‐ 2 or I‐3 district abutting property zoned R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3, height shall be measured from natural grade at the horizontal midpoint of the building wall facing each abutting residential property and shall apply to any portion of the building located within one‐ hundred‐feet (100) feet of the property line (see following illustration). In no case shall a building be required to be less than twenty (20) feet in height at the front building line. (b) Height Exceptions for Certain Structures 1. The height limitations shall not apply to the following features projecting above the roof line: flag poles, church spires/steeples, belfries, cupolas and domes not used for human occupancy, chimneys, ventilators, skylights, water tanks, bulkheads or 18 similar features, radio and television antennas for the use of residents of dwelling units in apartments, and necessary mechanical appurtenances (including, but not limited to solar energy panels and related appurtenances, plumbing vents, exhaust vents, HVAC equipment, electrical connections, lightning rods and telecommunications connections) usually carried above the roof level provided that: a. Such a feature shall be erected only to a height necessary to accomplish the purpose it is intended to serve, but in no case more than fifteen (15) feet above its lowest point of contact with the roof. b. The total area covered by such features shall not exceed in horizontal cross‐ sectional area fifteen (15) percent of the area of the plane of roof upon which they are located. c. Such features as water tanks, cooling towers and bulkheads, but not solar energy panels and related appurtenances, shall be enclosed within walls constructed of the same material as the main walls of the building on which they are located. 2. Parapet walls may extend not more than five (5) feet above the limiting height of the building on which they rest. 3. No sign, name plate, display or advertising device of any kind whatsoever shall be inscribed upon or attached to any chimney, tower, tank or other structure which extends above the district height limitations. (c) Tall Buildings in the R‐4, B‐1, B‐3 and IN‐1 Districts. In the R‐4, B‐1, B‐3 and IN‐1 districts, apartment buildings, public or semi‐public buildings such as a religious institution, school, library, hospital, may be erected to not more than one hundred twenty‐five (125) feet in height; provided that the portion of such building more than forty (40) feet in height shall set back from the street, lot or required setback line, one (1) foot for each one (1) foot of such additional height (see following illustration). 19 35.2‐61.3 Setbacks (a) Measuring Setbacks. Setbacks shall be measured as the shortest distance between the applicable property line (front, side or rear) and the nearest portion of the building, except as specifically provided in this section. For purposes of this measurement, the property line shall be considered a vertical plane and all distances shall be measured horizontally from that plane. (b) Setbacks, Buffers and Open Spaces Unique to Lot. No required setback, buffer or open space for any building or lot shall be considered to provide a required setback, buffer or open space for a building on any other lot. (c) Corner Lots. On a corner lot, the required side setback abutting a street (exterior side setback) shall be at least equal to a required front setback for other lots fronting on the side street. The Zoning Administrator shall determine the front, side and rear yards based on the predominant orientation of lots on the block on which the property is located. (d) Interior Lots with Double Frontage. Interior lots having frontages on two (2) streets shall have a front setback on each street, except where all lots or existing dwellings are designed to face the same street. (e) Authorized Encroachments. The following structures may encroach upon minimum setback areas as provided herein: 1. Terraces. A paved terrace shall not be subject to minimum setback or maximum lot coverage requirements; provided that such terrace is without roof, awnings, screens, walls, parapets or other forms of enclosure and is not more than three (3) feet above grade. Such terrace, however, may have a guard railing, wall or fence not over four (4) feet high with less than fifty (50) percent opacity, and shall not be closer than five (5) feet from any lot line. 2. Porches. Unenclosed porches or decks may project not more than ten (10) feet beyond the front, exterior side and rear walls of a building into the minimum front, exterior side or rear setback for the district. Any two (2) story or enclosed porch, or one having a roof, shall be considered a part of the building in the determination of the required setback and amount of building coverage. 3. Projecting Horizontal Architectural Features. Architectural features, such as windowsills, belt courses, chimneys, cornices, eaves or bay windows, may project not more than three (3) feet into any required setback, but not closer than five (5) feet to any lot line. The sum of any bay or bow window projections on any wall shall not exceed one‐fourth (1/4th) of the length of said wall. 4. Fire Escapes. Open fire escapes may extend into any required setback not more than five (5) feet; provided, however, that such fire escapes shall not be closer than five (5) feet at any point to any lot line. 20 5. Fences and Walls a. The setback requirements of this Zoning Ordinance shall not be deemed to prohibit any otherwise lawful fence or wall if: i) Each fence and/or wall does not exceed four (4) feet in height in a front yard. ii) Each fence and/or wall shall not exceed eight (8) feet in height in side and rear yards in residential districts of ten (10) feet in height in other districts. iii) Fences and/or walls in required exterior side setbacks shall not exceed four (4) feet in height. iv) Fences and walls do not conflict the standards for visibility at intersections established in section Error! Reference source not found. (Visibility at Intersections) in any district. v) On a corner lot, no fence and/or wall shall exceed four (4) feet in height in the required exterior side or rear setback abutting a street when a front yard is required for any lot on the side street in any district. (f) Setback Reductions for Neighborhood Norms. The following provisions are applicable to new development, additions or redevelopment in the R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 districts: 1. Subject to the provisions of paragraphs 3 and 4 of this section, the minimum front and side setbacks shall be reduced to match the lesser of: a. The average setbacks on the block face on which the proposed building fronts and the block face opposite the front of the proposed building; b. The average setback of the buildings located on either side of the proposed development; c. The mode of setbacks on the block face of the proposed development and the block face opposite the front of the proposed development; 21 2. The minimum rear setback shall be reduced by twenty‐five (25) percent when a legally created lot is less than the minimum lot area for the applicable district. 3. When determining the average setbacks, the City shall determine the mean of all principal structure setbacks. For any structure set back further than the minimum required setback for the applicable zoning district shall be deemed to be set back to that minimum. The mode shall be the most frequently occurring setback on the applicable lot’s block face and the block face across the street. 4. Regardless of the neighborhood norm, side and rear setbacks shall comply with minimum fire code requirements. 5. When the neighborhood norm provisions are not applicable, the Zoning Administrator may authorize a minor exception, not to exceed one (1) foot from the required dimension, for a building setback for one and two‐household dwellings to preserve existing vegetation or where other purposes of this Zoning Ordinance are achieved. (g) Future Street Widening. On any street where a street widening plan designating future right‐of‐way lines has been officially adopted by the City or Commonwealth of Virginia, the setbacks required by this Zoning Ordinance shall be measured from such lines rather than the existing street lines; and where no setback is otherwise required, a setback at the future right‐of‐way line is required. 22 (h) Setbacks from Limited Access Highways. On any limited access highway (including ramps), there shall be provided a setback line of fifty (50) feet from the right‐of‐way line for billboards. (i) B‐1 District Abutting and R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 District. Where a B‐1 lot abuts a R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 lot, the minimum front setbacks along block faces shall be the lesser of the neighborhood norm as provided in paragraph (f) of this section or twenty (20) feet. (j) R‐4, B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐1 or IN‐2 Districts Adjacent to R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts 1. In all instances where a lot in a R‐4, B‐1 B‐3, B‐5, IN‐1 or IN‐2 district abuts a lot in a R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 district: a. A buffer shall be established between the districts in compliance with section Error! Reference source not found.. b. A fifty (50) foot setback shall be provided. 2. Where lot in a B‐3, B‐5, IN‐1 or IN‐2 district is on the same block as a residential district, the front and exterior side setback requirements of the residential district shall apply to the applicable business or institutional district. 3. The buffer and setback requirements of paragraphs (j)1. and (j)2. of this section do not apply when the property within the R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 district is owned or leased by an institutional use. (k) Industrial Districts Adjacent to Residential Districts 1. In all instances where a lot in an industrial district (I‐1, I‐2 or I‐3) abuts a lot in a residential district (R‐1, R‐2, R‐3 or R‐4): a. A buffer shall be established between the districts in compliance with section Error! Reference source not found.. b. There shall be required a one‐hundred (100) foot minimum building setback on the lot in the industrial district. 2. Where a lot in an industrial district is on the same block as a residential district, the front and exterior side setback requirements of the residential district shall apply to the applicable industrial district. (l) Private recreational facilities. Private recreational facilities such as swimming pools, tennis courts and basketball courts permitted as accessory uses located on residentially zoned land, shall not be located in any front yard and shall have the following setbacks: 1. If accessory to a single‐household use or duplex, the edge of the facility shall be located not less than five (5) feet from any lot line. 23 2. If accessory to a residential use other than a single‐household residence or duplex, the edge of the facility shall be located not less than twenty (20) feet from any lot line. 3. Any private recreational facility with above ground lighting shall comply with minimum setback requirements for the principal structure in the applicable location. 4. In the event that a lighted facility is located less than fifty (50) feet from any lot line, it shall be screened pursuant to section Error! Reference source not found. (Error! Reference source not found.). (m) Dedicated Street as Portion of Required Buffer. When a dedicated street separates two (2) districts requiring additional setbacks, one fourth (1/4th) of the width of the dedicated right‐of‐way may be deducted from the required setback. That this ordinance shall become effective upon its adoption. Adopted: November 10, 2020 Certified: ____________________________ Interim Clerk of Council 1 MINUTES OF THE OCTOBER 28, 2020 PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING (MINUTES HAVE NOT BEEN APPROVED): Consideration of amending Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2-45, Limited Business District (B- 1) to clarify that “Mixed Use Developments” may not exceed 50,000 square feet of gross floor area per lot, prohibit ground floor residential uses except when authorized or by conditional use permit, require multi-story buildings to not exceed 2 stories when within 100 feet of the property line of an abutting R-1, R-2 or R-3 District, require commercial space to comprise at least 50% of the building gross floor area of a mixed use development permitted by right and to require a mixed use development to establish a fence not less than 6 feet in height when adjacent to an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District. Consideration of amending Zoning Ordinance Sections 35.2-46.4 B-3 District Development Standards and 35.2-48.4 B-5 District Development Standards to require commercial space to comprise at least 50% of the building gross floor area in a mixed use development permitted by right and to prohibit ground floor residential uses except when authorized or by conditional use permit. Consideration of amending Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2-61.2 (d) to add the Limited Business District (B-1) to the standard of how building height is measured when abutting an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District. Consideration of amending Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2-61.3 (j) to provide for a 50 foot setback in a Limited Business District (B-1) when abutting R-1, R-2 or R-3 Districts. Mr. Tom Martin, City Planner, provided the following summary to the Commission. The Zoning Ordinance amendments were initiated by City Council. City Council directed staff to review not only the B- 1, limited business district but the other business districts as well. The proposed amendments were drafted with consultation by the Richland Hills Neighborhood Association and there are two (2) representatives in attendance. The Comprehensive Plan recognizes the need to make efficient use of the City’s limited land resources and recommends policies that provide for accessory dwellings, density bonuses, and mixed use development. This was done in an effo rt to provide for the City’s growing population without having to increase densities in underlying residential districts. Mixing uses in business districts allows people to live and possibly work in the same place. The Comprehensive Plan notes that the City could be a city of one hundred thousand (100,000) people within the next ten (10) years. There is a proposed development called Logan’s Landing II at 7051 Timberlake Road and is 7.6 acres. It is primarily zoned B-1, limited business district but there is a small strip of B -3, community business district fronting Timberlake Road. It is proposed to have one hundred twenty -three (123) apartment units, seventeen (17) commercial units, and will be one hundred eighty -nine thousand three hundred thirty-two (189,332) square feet in four (4) buildings. There will also be two hundred fifty -nine (259) parking spaces, a pool, and a pool house. The proposal is a very large development in a B -1 district. The purpose of a B -1 district is to provide for office, retail, re staurant, and service uses that are compatible with nearby residential areas. They should be in scale with adjacent neighborhood development, have pedestrian-oriented designs, generate a moderate level of traffic, and provide a transition from retail districts and heavily traveled thoroughfares to residential areas. When the Ordinance was being drafted in 2016 what was in mind for the B -1 district were something similar to the blocks at 2472 to 2496 Rivermont Avenue. Those are thirty -seven thousand three hu ndred ninety-four (37,394) square feet on about one and nineteen hundredths (1.19) acres. It is smaller scale development and serves as a good transition between Rivermont Avenue and residential areas to the rear. That is a stark contrast to what is being proposed on Timberlake. Right now there are several types of residential uses permitted in the B-1 district. Single -household developments are permitted by right, duplexes, townhomes, and apartments are allowed by Conditional Use Permits, and mixed use residential structures, which typically have commercial uses on lower floors with residential uses on upper floors are permitted by right. There are 2 also standards that go along with the district and multi- tenet commercial development is limited to fifty thousand (50,000) square feet. This is one of the biggest flaws in the Ordinance because it does not say multi-tenet and mixed use developments. That is one of the things that the proposed amendments are trying to clarify. The development standards include the following: maximum height forty (40) feet, a front setback of zero (0) feet, a rear setback of twenty -five (25) feet, a minimum lot width of fifty (50) feet, and a minimum lot depth of one hundred (100) feet. There were a lot of concerns expressed by the neighborhood. One concern was allowing commercially zoned land to be developed largely as high density residential apartment complexes without review or approval by the Planning Commission or City Council. Staff agrees that the intent was not to allow high density residential uses in the B -1 district. Other concerns were the impact the development would have on Timberlake Road, the ratio of commercial to residential uses, and the ability of the mixed use development to exceed the fifty thousand (50,000) square foot gross floor area. Staff has provided some responses to City Council and the neighborhood. Again, staff agrees that it was not the intent to allow high density apartments without review by the Planning Commission or City Council but staff does believe it is the intent to allow limited residential uses as part of a mixed -use development. A traffic analysis is being reviewed by the City Engineer. Staff considered amending the Ordinance to require fifty (50) foot setbacks, amending the standards to cla rify no single development can exceed fifty thousand (50,000) square feet gross floor area, and considered maximum lot sizes or requirements for internal private or local streets. The amendments that are proposed were presented to the neighborhood who are in agreement with the majority of them. The changes to the B -1 district clarifies that multi- tenet commercial developments or mixed use developments are limited to fifty thousand (50,000) square feet per lot, prohibits ground floor residential, and require s a fifty/fifty (50/50) ratio of commercial to residential for mixed use developments. Other changes to the B -1 district require buildings in excess of two (2) stories to have a one hundred (100) foot setback when adjacent to R -1, R-2, or R -3 districts and require a fence when adjacent to R-1, R-2, or R-3 districts in addition to the normal vegetative buffer. Changes to the B -3 and B-5 districts propose to require the same fifty/fifty (50/50) ratio of commercial to residential for mixed use developments. Ad ditional height requirements and a minimum setback of fifty (50) feet when adjacent to R -1, R -2, or R -3 districts are also proposed for B -1 districts and are consistent with the current requirements for R-4, B-3, B-5, IN-1, I-1, I-2, and I-3 districts. Additional neighborhood concerns include that a Conditional Use Permit should be required for mixed use developments. Staff understands the concern but does not support that stance. In order to have an efficient use of the land, mixed use needs to be provided for and needs to be allowed by right in a limited capacity. Another neighborhood concern is how the property could be further subdivided. The City cannot prevent individuals from subdividing their property. To do so would establish over seven (7) acres fo r a B -1 lot size, this doesn’t make logical sense. For comparison, an R -1 parcel is fifteen thousand (15,000) square feet and a Conservation district requires a ten (10) acre parcel. Chair Rogers asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in favor of the petition. Mr. Jason Snyder, a Richland Hills resident and the president of the Richland Hills Neighborhood Association addressed the Commission. He is in support of the proposed Zoning Ordinance amendments. The association sent a letter to City Council in August expressing concerns with the Logan’s Landing II development. It is a seven (7) acre property in a B -1 district and due to lack of clarity and some gaps in the Zoning Ordinance the developer has been able to propose four (4) three (3) story apartment buildings that contain one hundred twenty -three (123) apartment units and seventeen (17) commercial units. That development would turn land intended for low traffic, small scale development into a high density residential apartment complex. The buildings will also be just twenty (20) feet from the property line. There are also traffic concerns. A B-1 district is intended to have moderate amounts of traffic but the proposed development would be more than that. This is a highly trav eled area already between the two (2) busy intersections of Wards Ferry Road and Leesville Road, where the Richland Hills neighborhood is located. This development would drop traffic directly onto Timberlake Road in this area and in the middle of a school zone where children walk back and forth. The resulting traffic would be in addition to the Logan’s Landing I development, which is already more than one hundred fifty (150) apartment units. 3 During the day, traffic often backs up coming off the expressway a lready. The development as proposed runs completely counter to the spirit of a B -1 and will not be reviewed by Planning Commission or City Council as long as it meets the Zoning Ordinance. As a neighborhood, they have been in communication with Mr. Martin and are grateful the City has taken the time to address their concerns. The proposed amendments will limit the scale of mixed use developments, increase setbacks from neighborhoods, and set a fifty/fifty (50/50) ratio. These are significant improvements an d the Association supports them. They will insure that future developments live up to the spirit of the code. The Neighborhood Association would also like to see the requirement for a Conditional Use Permit when a developer wants to add residential to their upper floors. This would allow Planning Commission and City Council the opportunity to review the petition and determine if it is appropriate for the property. This is most important in a B -1 district and less so in a B -3 or B-5 district since they are intended to have more traffic. The B -1 district, by definition, is usually by a neighborhood, small scale, and serves as a transition to the neighborhood and should not be subdivided to serve a different purpose without the review of the Planning Commission and the City Council. At a minimum, the neighborhood would like the proposed Zoning Ordinance amendments to be approved. Chair Rogers asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in opposition. When no one stepped forward, he closed the public hearing. Commissioner Johnson asked for clarification that the City Council requested changes be made to the Ordinance. Mr. Martin responded that was correct. After the Richland Hills Neighborhood Association expressed concerns, City Council requested tha t he give a presentation on the B -1 district. The presentation took place on September 22. After the presentation, Council requested the concerns be addressed, the other business districts be examined, and amendments to the Ordinance be drafted. The propos ed amendments are the result of that. Commissioner Johnson asked for clarification that the proposed amendments need to be approved by Council. Mr. Martin responded that was correct. Commissioner Johnson asked how to prevent the Ordinance from being changed every time there is a proposed development that the City does not like. Mr. Martin responded that in this instance there were some items in the B-1 district that needed to be clarified. The Logan’s Landing II plan as submitted showed ground floor residential use but did not front on an urban or collector street, which is not permitted. At the time, the developer wanted to appeal the decision to the Board of Zoning Appeals so the p lan has not moved forward yet. City Council felt there was enough need for clarification to move forward with amendments to the Ordinance. The City should not arbitrarily change its Ordinances as a result of proposed development, there should be a real rea son for doing so and in this instance Council determined there was. Commissioner Bowden asked if the approval of the proposed amendments to the Ordinance will have bearing on the proposed development. Mr. Martin responded that it could. Chair Rogers stated that sometimes these sorts of things become litigated but there is a need for these amendments. 4 Mr. Martin stated that when the Ordinance was developed the intent was for small scale development. The proposed development is one hundred eighty-nine thousand (189,000) square feet and is not in line with the original intent. Commissioner Bowden noted that the proposed amendments would enforce the original intent of the Ordinance. These are all relatively new Ordinances and there are going to be holes t hat need to be addressed. Planning Commission likely would not approve the proposed development if it came before them and showed one hundred eighty -nine (189,000) square feet because that is outside the bounds of the intent. Changing the Ordinance now tho ugh will have immediate ramifications for the developer as well as moving forward. Mr. Martin responded that there are a couple of different routes this could go. The developer could change the plans, someone could appeal the fifty thousand (50,000) squar e foot restriction, or Council could approve the amendments to the Ordinance. The first to occur is what will be followed. Again, it was not the intent of the B -1 district to allow a very large apartment complex with a small section of commercial use. When the Ordinance was first drafted it was known that it would need to be amended time to time. The Logan’s Landing II development is the first mixed use development that has come through by right since then and has shown some issues with the Ordinance. These proposed amendments are trying to address those issues. Commissioner Bowden stated that the Ordinance needs to be changed. What happens after that is out of the Planning Commission’s hands. The task now is to address the proposed amendments. Mr. Martin agreed that regardless of any single development the Commission should focus on the overall intent of the district and whether or not the Ordinance needs to be changed. Commissioner Bowden stated that the proposed development brought the discussion forwar d. Chair Rogers asked what the difference between Wyndhurst and Cornerstone and B-1 districts are. Mr. Martin responded that they are Traditional Neighborhood Developments (TND) and they required a detailed set of design guidelines, a master plan, traff ic studies, and approval of a Conditional Use Permit by Planning Commission and Council. They are larger developments and should require more scrutiny. The B-1 district was intended for smaller scale developments, with some residential component on the upper floors not to create large sprawling suburban style models. Chair Rogers noted that these areas can be denser than TNDs, which are small areas with a lot of apartments in them. He is concerned about mixed use developments where the goal is to be mostly apartments rather than true mixed use. Developers will continue to take advantage of that. There wasn’t this type of apartment growth ten (10) years ago. Mr. Martin responded that the fifty/fifty (50/50) ratio is important to maintain the underlyin g commercial use, if it is by -right, rather than allowing a majority to be high density residential. If a developer wants to deviate from the fifty/fifty (50/50) ratio they can petition for a Conditional Use Permit. Examples of mixed use development includes Cornerstone, Wyndhurst, and Downtown Lynchburg. Commissioner Johnson asked if there is any other proposed development happening currently in a B - 1 district that the proposed amendments might effect. Mr. Martin responded that there is not. Chair Roger s noted that the Graves Mill Road development has offices on the lower floors and residential uses on the upper floors. 5 Mr. Kevin Henry responded that the development is in an R -4 district which has allowances of up to five (5) percent as commercial use. There is an office on one of the ground levels. Mr. Martin reiterated that it is only five (5) percent commercial and is in an R-4 district. Commissioner Marion asked what the definition of ground floor is and if there is none it should probably be defined. Mr. Martin responded that ground floor would be the ground level floor that fronts the street. Chair Rogers stated that the fifty/fifty (50/50) ratio seems that it is intended to focus the development on business. He then asked why mixed use does not require a conditional use. Mr. Martin responded it is designed to focus on business on the bottom floors. The whole drive at the time of drafting the Ordinance was to make it easier for developers to develop. They would not have to go through a three (3) month lengthy process to get something approved. The City’s Comprehensive Plan policies and goals are promoting walkability and living, working, and playing in the same place. Ordinances should be in place that allows that by right. The Comprehensive P lan encourages mixed use but Conditional Use Permits are a discouragement. It is likely that if a developer had to go through the process to request a Conditional Use Permit they would choose to do standalone residential rather than mixed use. Commissioner Bowden asked if the setbacks limit the development. The footprint as the building goes up will get smaller. Mr. Martin responded that if the footprint is smaller but taller, anything more than two (2) stories would have to setback further from the property line. Two (2) stories would have to have a fifty (50) foot setback in the proposed amendments. The fifty thousand (50,000) square feet can be developed as they want but the taller it is, the further it needs to be from the property line. Commissioner Johnson asked if this change was started because of the neighbors’ concerns. Mr. Martin responded that when the proposed Logan’s Landing II plan came forward staff didn’t think it was a great idea. It was City Council however that initiated the changes to the Ordinance after hearing the citizens’ concerns. Commissioner Johnson noted that this is a result of enough people coming together to voice their concern. Mr. Martin agreed and noted that staff makes recommendations to Planning Commission who make recommendations to City Council who is the ultimate authority and decision makers. Chair Rogers stated that every B-1 parcel is currently “open game” for apartment development if they meet loose standards that were designed with good intentions but not to create residential density. It makes sense to pursue something that rights that. That may create problems in the long run because Planning Commission is not involved in the proposed development at all but the amendments to the Ordinance still need to be addressed. Mr. Martin responded that development is not a bad thing and developers are not bad people but the City needs to make sure it has the Ordinances in place to ensure the quality of development that it desires. That is why these amendments are prop osed. The Planning Commission should focus its discussion on City wide rather than one development. 6 Chair Rogers noted that there is probably a lot of B-1 land. Commissioner Johnson asked if the developer can come back on the City because of the possibl e Ordinance amendments. Mr. Martin responded that anything is a possibility but that is for the City Attorney and City Council to handle. Commissioner Bowden stated that the Commission tries to do the best they can with the information and experience that they have. There needs to be room for both the developer and the citizens. This is a good opportunity to introduce density where possible but not at the rate that is proposed in Logan’s Landing II and in the Ordinance as it stands. He would vote to accept the amendments as proposed. Chair Rogers stated that he is hesitant about making a change that is retroactive to something that is in process. That is his only hold up. Commissioner Bowden responded that Planning Commission can’t control that. That response will not come from the Commission but will come from the City Attorney. The Commission’s task is to see that what is in place for Ordinances is creating the type of growth that they want for Lynchburg. It is important to focus on the vision and mission. Commissioner Lowe shared agreement and stated that the Planning Commission is here to look at specific set of words and to vote on the Ordinance wording. It would have been nice to have these words when the Ordinance was drafted but they did not envi sion something of this nature happening. The Commission’s job is to fix the wording and let the elected officials make decisions regarding grandfathering. If the amendments are not passed, this will happen again on other B -1 parcels and result in B-1 apartment complexes across the City. What staff has done is wonderful and Planning Commission should vote and let City Council make the final decision. The Commission serves as advisors to Council. Chair Rogers stated that addresses his question about retroact ivity. That will not be the Commission’s fight. The way that things are worded saves a lot of effort for developers. Commissioner Bowden made the following motion, seconded by Commissioner Lowe, and approved by the following vote: “Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City Council approval of the Section 35.2-45, Limited Business District (B-1), Section 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-48.4, B-5, District Development Standards, Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Regulations and Section 35.2-61.3, Setbacks related to residential uses permitted by right as part of mixed use developments.” AYES: Bowden, Johnson, Light Lowe, Marion, and Rogers 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Perault 1 Zoning Ordinance Amendments Tom Martin, AICP City Planner Department of Community Development Planning Commission October 28, 2020 Purpose Zoning Ordinance Amendments initiated by Council – September 22, 2020 • Concerns expressed by Richland Hills Neighborhood Association with mixed use developments in the B-1, Limited Business District • City Council directed staff to look at other business districts • Amendments drafted with consultation by Richland Hills Neighborhood Association 2 Zoning Ordinance Amendments Zoning Ordinance Sections: • 35.2-45, Limited Business District • 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards • 35.2-48.4, B-5, General Business District Development Standards • 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Regulations • 35.2-61.3, Setbacks 3 Comprehensive Plan Comprehensive Plan • Recognizes the need to make efficient use of limited land resources. • Recommends policies that provide for accessory dwellings, density bonuses and mixed use development. • Effort to provide for City’s growing population without having to increase densities in residential districts. 4 Proposed Logan’s Landing II Proposed Logan’s Landing II • 7051 Timberlake Road – 7.6 acres • Zoned B-1, Limited Business District and B-3, Community Business District • 123 Apartments, 17 Commercial Units • 189,332 sf. In 4 Buildings • 259 Parking Spaces • Pool & Pool House 5 B-1 District Purpose B-1 District Purpose • Provide for office, retail, restaurant and service uses compatible with nearby residential areas. • Be in scale with adjacent neighborhood development. • Have pedestrian-oriented designs. • Generate a moderate level of traffic. • Provide a transition from retail districts and heavily traveled thoroughfares to residential areas. 6 B-1 District Purpose 7 2472-2496 Rivermont Avenue - 37,394 sf on 1.19 ac Residential Uses in the B-1 District Residential Uses in the B-1 District • Single-Household Detached – Permitted by Right • Two-Household (Duplex) – Conditional Use Permit • Single-Household Attached (Townhomes) – Conditional Use Permit • Multi-Household Structures (Apartments) – Conditional Use Permit • Mixed-use Residential Structures (Typically Commercial uses on lower floors with residential uses on upper floors – Permitted by Right 8 B-1 District Standards B-1 District Standards • Limitations on drive-through location. • Prohibited outdoor operations such as storage or display. • Scale of business that is compatible with adjacent neighborhoods. – Multi-Tenant Commercial Developments – 50,000 sf. – Single-Office Development – 20,000 sf. – Single Retail or Service Business – 5,000 sf. – Restaurant – 4,000 sf. • Except authorized single-household dwellings and other residential uses permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited except when part of a mixed-use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or local street. 9 B-1 Development Standards B-1 Development Standards • Visibility at Intersections • Lot area regulations – 6,000 sf. minimum plus 1,000 sf. per dwelling unit • Parking provided behind the front building line • Dumpster screening • Landscaping • Height – 40 Feet Maximum • Front Setback – 0 Foot • Side Setback – 0 Foot • Rear Setback – 25 Feet • Lot Width – 50 Feet Minimum • Lot Depth – 100 Feet Minimum 10 Richland Hills Neighborhood Concerns Neighborhood Concerns 1. Allowing commercially zoned land to be developed largely as high-density residential (apartment complexes) without review or approval by the Planning Commission or City Council. 2. The impact the proposed development would have on Timberlake Road traffic. 3. The intention of the developer to purchase the property at 1514 Brookville Lane to include as part of the proposed development. 4. Setbacks for B-1, Limited Business District uses adjacent R-1, Low Density Residential Districts. 5. Ratio of commercial space to residential units. 6. Mixed use developments ability to exceed the maximum 50,000 square foot maximum gross floor area. 11 Staff Response Staff Response • Intent not to allow high density apartments without review by Planning Commission or Council. Should allow for “limited” residential uses as part of a mixed-use development. • A traffic analysis is being reviewed by the City Engineer. • The property at 1514 Brookville Lane is not part of the submitted site plan and would require a FLUM Amendment and Rezoning. • Amend Section 35.2-16 (j) to require a 50’ setback when B-1 Districts are adjacent to Low Density Residential Districts. 12 Staff Response Staff Response • Ground floor residential uses must take access from collector or local street. Developer expressed intent to appeal Zoning Administrator decision. (No official decision and no appeal filed • Amend B-1 Standards or further explanation of when ground floor residential uses are permitted. • Amend B-1 Standards to clarify no single development can exceed 50,000 sf. Maximum gross floor area. • Consider maximum lot sizes or requirements for internal private or local streets. 13 Zoning Ordinance Amendments Section 35.2-45, Limited Business District • Clarifies that multi-tenant commercial developments or mixed use developments are limited to 50,000 sf per lot. • Prohibits ground floor residential. • Requires 50/50 ratio of commercial to residential for mixed use developments • Buildings in excess of two stories require 100’ setback when adjacent to R-1, R-2 or R-3 Districts • Requires a fence when adjacent to R-1, R-2 or R-3 Districts 14 Zoning Ordinance Amendments Section 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards • Requires 50/50 ratio of commercial to residential for mixed use developments 15 Zoning Ordinance Amendments Section 35.2-48.4, B-5 District Development Standards • Requires 50/50 ratio of commercial to residential for mixed use developments 16 Zoning Ordinance Amendments Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Requriements • Requires building height in a B-1 District to be measured from the natural grade at the horizontal midpoint of the building when adjacent to residential district. (Consistent with R-4, B-3, B-5, IN- 1, I-1, I-2 & I-3 District) 17 Zoning Ordinance Amendments Section 35.2-61.3, Setbacks • Requires a 50’ setback in the B-1, Limited Business District when adjacent to an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District. (Consistent with R-4, B-3, B-5, IN-1, I-1, I-2 or I-3 Districts) 18 Zoning Ordinance Amendments Additional Neighborhood Concerns • CUP for Mixed Use Developments • Ability of properties to be further subdivided 19 Discussion Discussion 20 The Department of Community Development City Hall, Lynchburg, VA 24504 434-455-3900 To: Planning Commission From: Planning Division Date: October 28, 2020 Re: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – Section 35.2-45, Limited Business District (B-1), Section 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-48.4, B-5, District Development Standards, Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Regulations and Section 35.2-61.3, Setbacks related to residential uses permitted by right as part of mixed use developments. I. PETITIONER City of Lynchburg, 900 Church St reet, Lynchburg, Virginia 24504 Property Owners: N/A II. LOCATION The Zoning Ordinance amendments would affect mixed use developments permitted by right in the B-1, Limited Business District, B-3, Community Business District and B-5, General Business District. III. PURPOSE The purposes of the Zoning Ordinance amendments are to:  Clarify that multi-tenant commercial developments or mixed-use developments are limited to fifty thousand (50,000) sf per lot.  Prohibit ground floor residential in the B-1, B-3 & B-5 Districts.  For lots in the B-1 District, limit buildings to two (2) stories when adjacent to an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District.  Require commercial space to comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of building gross floor area when part of a mixed-use development in the B-1, B-3 & B-5 District.  For lots in the B-1 District, require a fence at least six (6) feet in height to be established when adjacent to an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District.  For lots in the B-1 District, require height to be measured from the natural grade at the horizontal midpoint of the building when adjacent to a residential district.  For lots in the B-1 District, require a fifty (50) foot setback when adjacent to an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District. IV. SUMMARY  The Zoning Ordinance amendments were initiated by City Council on September 22, 2020.  The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030, recognizes the need to make efficient use of limited land resources, recommends policies that provide for accessory dwellings, density bonuses and mixed use development in an effort to provide for the City’s growing population without having to increase densities in residential districts.  The Zoning Ordinance amendments would ensure that business districts are used primarily for commercial purposes while allowing an appropriate mix of residential uses while protecting adjacent residential neighborhoods. Planning Commission: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – October 28, 2020 2 The Planning Division recommends approval of the Zoning Ordinance amendments. V. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. Comprehensive Plan. The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030, recognizes the need to make efficient use of limited land resources, recommends policies that provide for accessory dwellings, density bonuses and mixed use development in an effort to provide for the City’s growing population without having to increase densities in residential districts.   2. Zoning. The Zoning Ordinance was adopted by City Council on February 23, 2016. 3. Proffers: N/A 4. Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA). N/A 5. Surrounding Area. There have been several items requiring City Council approval in the immediate area:  On January 14, 2014, City Council adopted the Comprehensive Plan 2013-2020.  On February 23, 2016, City Council adopted the current Zoning Ordinance.  On September 22, 2020, City Council initiated amendments to the Zoning Ordinance. 6. Site Description. N/A 7. Proposed Use of Property. N/A 8. Traffic, Parking and Public Transit. N/A 9. Stormwater Management. N/A 10. Emergency Services: N/A 11. Impact. As a result of concerns expressed by the Richland Hills Neighborhood related to a proposed development at 7051 Timberlake Road, City Council requested staff provide an overview of the B-1, Limited Business District standards. This overview was presented to City Council on September 22, 2020. As a result of the presentation and neighborhood concerns, City Council initiated changes to the Zoning Ordinance related to mixed uses allowed by right in the B-1, Limited Business District, B-3, Community Business District and B-5, General Business District. Policies adopted in the Comprehensive Plan recognizes the need to make efficient use of the City’s limited land resources. These policies were adopted to in an effort to provide for the City’s growing population without having to increase densities in the residential districts. The City also recognizes the need to preserve commercial land for commercial purposes as demonstrated by the requirement for a conditional use permit for standalone residential uses in business districts. The proposed Zoning Ordinance amendments will provide a more appropriate commercial / residential mix while clarifying standards that were adopted in 2016. 12. Technical Review Committee. N/A VI. PLANNING DIVISION RECOMMENDATION Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City Council approval of the Section 35.2-45, Limited Planning Commission: Zoning Ordinance Amendments – October 28, 2020 3 Business District (B-1), Section 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-48.4, B-5, District Development Standards, Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Regulations and Section 35.2-61.3, Setbacks related to residential uses permitted by right as part of mixed use developments. This matter is respectfully offered for your consideration. William T. Martin, AICP City Planner pc: Dr. Reid Wodicka, Interim City Manager Mr. Kent L. White, Interim Deputy City Manager Mr. Walter C. Erwin, City Attorney Mr. J. Lee Newland, City Engineer Ms. Cynthia Kozerow, Lynchburg Police Department Battalion Chief Thomas Goode, Fire Marshal Mr. Doug Saunders, Building Official Mr. Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator VII. ATTACHMENTS 1. Ordinance 2. City Council Agenda Summary – September 22, 2020              DRAFT ORDINANCE: Planning Commission – October 28, 2020 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT THE CODE OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, 1981 BY AMENDING ZONING ORDINANCE SECTION 35.2-45, LIMITED BUSINESS DISTRICT (B-1), SECTION 35.2-46.4, B-3 DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, SECTION 35.2-48.4, B-5 DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, SECTION 35.2-61.2, ADDITIONAL HEIGHT REGULATIONS AND SECTION 35.2-61.3, SETBACKS RELATED TO RESIDENTIAL USES PERMITTED BY RIGHT AS PART OF A MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT. WHEREAS, the City Council directed City staff to prepare Zoning Ordinance Amendments related to residential uses allowed by right in the B-1, B-3 and B-5 Districts on September 22, 2020. WHEREAS, the City Council held a public hearing to consider and address the proposed Zoning Ordinance Amendments and to receive public comment on November 10, 2020. WHEREAS, the City Council finds that these amendments should be adopted in order to promote the public necessity, convenience, welfare and good zoning practice. BE IT ORDANINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: That Section 35.2-45, Limited Business District (B-1), Section 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-48.4, B-5 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Regulations and Section 35.1-61.3, Setbacks related to residential uses permitted by right as part of a mixed use development of the Code of the City of Lynchburg, 1981, be the same is hereby amended and reenacted as follows:              35.2‐45 Limited Business Districts (B‐1)  35.2‐45.2  Authorized Uses  (a) The uses authorized by IV‐12 may be established in accordance with the procedures in Article II, the  district standards in this article, the site development standards established in Article II and specific  use standards established in Article VI, as well as other applicable rules and regulations.   (b) Uses may also be limited by overlay standards established in Article V of this Zoning Ordinance.   (c) See Article III for the rules of interpreting authorized uses and Appendix A for a complete listing of  land uses allowed in every zoning district.  (d) Uses designated “P” are permitted by right and uses designated “C” require issuance of a conditional  use permit.  Exhibit IV‐12:  Authorized Uses in B‐1 District  Land Use  LBCS #  Description  Approval  Type  single‐household detached  1111S Typical single‐household dwelling P modular home  1114S A prefabricated home without axles or frames (see  definitions) P  Two‐household (duplex)  1121S A building located on one (1) zoning lot containing not  more than two (2) dwelling units C  single‐household attached  (townhouse)  1140S Each unit on a separate lot; fire wall may protrude from  roof or roofs may be staggered  C  Multi‐household structures  1200S Includes triplexes, four‐plexes, and other multi‐ household dwellings  C  Mixed‐use residential  structures (see district  regulations for limitations)  1201S Typically commercial uses on lower floors and  residential uses on upper floors  P  Housing Services  1200 Housing and custodial services for those who cannot  care for themselves. Includes nursing and retirement  homes, congregate living, assisted and continuing  care living, but excludes rehab uses in LBCS #6520)   P  Bed & Breakfast and Tourist  Homes  1310 Guest rooms in a private home or accessory building  to a private home  P  boarding house  1321 Non‐transient lodging that may include meals and is  owner occupied  P  rooming house  1322 Transient or non‐transient lodging that may include  meals   P  dormitory, sorority or  fraternity house  1323 Allowed only as accessory uses to and owned by a  college or university  C  Short Term Rental  1350 Provision of lodging for fewer than thirty (30)  consecutive days.  (See Section 35.2‐71.16)  P  Bicycles  2113b New or used bicycle sales, rental and repair  P              Land Use  LBCS #  Description  Approval  Type  camera and photographic  supplies; clothing, jewelry,  luggage, shoes, clocks,  sewing; sporting goods, toy  and hobby, and musical  instruments; mixed media,  school and office supplies  2132‐ 2135  Primarily retail cameras and photographic supplies or  retail with repair and film developing; clothing  (including shoe repair and tailoring, sporting goods,  toys, musical instruments, kitchen goods, books,  magazines, music, videos, stationary, greeting cards,  seasonal decorations, office and school supplies.  P  florist, art supplies, tobacco  products  2141‐ 2143  Florists, art supplies and art dealers, frame shops,  tobacco products  P  art galleries  2142b Excludes art supply sales and retail framing services P antique shop  2145 Antique shops, (excludes flea markets, thrift stores  and pawn shops)  P  grocery store, supermarket,  or bakery, convenience store,  specialty food stores  2151‐ 2154  Included are grocery stores, convenience stores,  meat, seafood and produce markets, coffee,  confections, variety goods and general stores, and  delicatessens. Excludes stores with fuel pumps (see  2116 for fuel sales).  P  beer, wine, and liquor store  2155 P Health and personal care  2160 Retail prescription or nonprescription drugs; retail  cosmetics, perfumes, toiletries; prescription or  nonprescription eyeglasses; prescription or  nonprescription health and convalescent aids;  medical devices, retail food supplement products  such as vitamins, nutrition supplements, and body  enhancing supplements.  P  Bank, credit union, or savings  institution  2210 Central banking functions P  credit card and other financing  2221 Credit card, sales financing, unsecured consumer  lending, real estate credit, mortgages, international  trade financing  P  Investment banking,  securities, and brokerages;  insurance; fund, trust, or  other financial establishment  2230‐ 2250  Securities underwriting, brokering, exchange  services, managing portfolios; Insurance  underwriting, selling insurance; manage assets on  behalf of shareholders or beneficiaries  P  Real estate services 2310 Sell or lease real estate such as buildings,  manufactured home sites and vacant lots; includes  real estate appraisers and realtor offices  P  professional offices  2411‐ 2014  Title abstract, lawyers, notaries, accountants,  bookkeeping, payroll services, architects, engineers,  surveyors, graphic design, interior design and  industrial design  P  consulting services  (management, environmental  technical)  2415 Advise and assist businesses on management,  scientific, and technological issues  P  scientific research and  development services  2416 Conduct research or analyze in the physical,  engineering, cognitive, or life sciences in offices.  P               Land Use  LBCS #  Description  Approval  Type  other professional offices  2419,  6810,  6820  Includes advertising and media services intellectual  property rights, franchising, labor, political or  business organizations, and uses with similar impacts  P  office administrative services  2421 Office administration such as billing, record keeping,  personnel, organizational planning  P  facilities support services  2422 Provide operating staff for support services within a  client's facilities, including janitorial, security, laundry  services, etc.  P  employment agency  2423a Provide employee placement, temporary help  P copy center, private mail  center, other business support  services  2424 Provide document preparation, telephone  answering, telemarketing, court reporting, steno  typing, FAX, internet access, small signs and banners  P  collection agency  2425 Collect payments, compile credit information,  repossess tangible assets  P  Travel arrangement and  reservation services  2430 Promote or sell travel, includes convention and  visitors' bureaus  P  Restaurants, cafeterias, snack  bars & catering  2510‐ 2530  &2560  Provide food and drinks to patrons – see district  specific use regulations for limitations. Includes  banquet, assembly and reception halls. See district  standards.  P  Personal care    2610 Hair, nail, and skin care and related personal care,  barbers, beauty shops, dieting and weight loss,  tanning, hair removal, hair weaving, ear piercing and  similar services  P  laundromat and dry cleaning   2621 &  2622  Includes Laundromats, dry cleaners, diaper services  as well as other commercial laundry services  P  Photofinishing  2630 Primarily engaged in developing film or making  slides, etc.  P  Parking lot and parking garage  2640 See district standards P licensed massage therapist  2651 P pet cemetery  2723 C national post office  4181 P retail courier and package  delivery  4182 Retail courier, package drop‐off and mail services  P  wireless telecommunications  transmission  4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see section 35.2-73 for telecommunications towers  P  telephone and other wired  telecommunications  4234 Operate telephone networks – excludes switching  stations   P  Telecommunications switching  stations/exchanges  4239 Telecommunications switching stations and  exchanges with no on‐site employees  C  library or archive  4242 Provide library or archive services P data processing and  management, hosting and  related services  4244 Web hosting, computer data storage, optical  scanning, computer input preparation, microfilm  imaging   P               Land Use  LBCS #  Description  Approval  Type  Public Utilities Services, Major  4315,  4329,  4339,  4349  Includes transmission lines for water, wastewater,  stormwater, electricity, natural gas or  telecommunications services regulated by the State  Corporation Commission of a regional nature and  normally entail the construction of new buildings or  structures such as electrical switching facilities and  stations or substations, electric, gas, and other utility  transmission lines of a regional nature which are not  otherwise reviewed and approved by the Virginia  State Corporation Commission. All overhead  transmission lines are included in this definition.  C  Public Utilities Service Minor  4315,  4329,  4339,  4349  Includes distribution or collection lines and  appurtenances for water, wastewater, stormwater,  electricity, natural gas or telecommunications  services regulated by the State Corporation  Commission that are necessary to support  development within the immediate vicinity and  involve only minor structures. Included in this use  type are small facilities such as transformers, relay  and booster devices, and well, water and sewer  pump stations, and wireless communication  antennas attached to existing buildings or structures.  P  electric substations  4316 C Water treatment plants and  utility facilities  4331 – 4333,  Water treatment plants, pumping stations and lift  stations  C  Theater, dance or music  establishment  5110 &  5160  Companies, groups, or theaters that produce  theatrical presentations, dance, dinner theaters, and  live musical entertainment; includes facilities for  independent artists and performers  P  Promoter of sports, performing  arts, similar events and  management services  5140 ‐ 5150  Organize, promote, and manage performances and  events; agents representing artists, athletes and  entertainers  P  Museums and Other Special  Purpose Recreational Institutions  5200 Public and private museums, historical sites, and  similar establishments  P  Country Club  5340 &  6830  Operate private country clubs, with tennis courts and  golf courses along with dining facilities and other  recreational facilities; includes civic, social and  fraternal organizations without dwellings  P  fitness and recreational sports  center   5371 Aerobic dance or exercise center, gymnasium,  physical fitness center, health and athletic club,  indoor handball, racquetball, volleyball, tennis, or  swimming facilities conducted inside a building  P  outdoor recreation  5372,  5373 &  5374  Includes for profit golf courses, archery ranges,  outdoor volleyball, tennis, or swimming facilities,  recreational courts, recreational day camp and  horseback riding  C               Land Use  LBCS #  Description  Approval  Type  Natural and other  Recreational Parks  5500 All parks without special economic functions, other  than limited concessions   P  Nursery or preschool  6110 P Grade school  6120 Comprises all public, private, and specialty schools  between the preschool and university level; includes  adult education services not addressed elsewhere.  See district use standards  P  College or university  6130 See district use standards P Public Safety  6400 Government‐owned establishments providing fire  and rescue, police, and emergency response services  P  Clinic  6511 &  6567  Include physician offices, dentists, chiropractors,  optometrists, licensed massage therapists, and  veterans affairs services  P  outpatient care clinic  6512 Provide outpatient family planning services and  outpatient care  P  group home small  6522 Fewer than five (5) aged or infirm individuals or  fewer than nine (9) individuals with mental,  intellectual or developmental disabilities  P  group home large  6523 Five or more aged or infirm individuals, or nine (9) or  more individuals with mental, intellectual or  developmental disabilities  P  Hospital  6530 C child and adult day care  6562 Provide day care for children and adults   Home  6562a Day care for fewer than six (6) individuals in a  residence  P  Small  6562b Day care for six (6) to twelve (12) individuals in a  residence  P  Large  6562c Provide care for more than 12 individuals  P Religious Institutions  6600 Churches, temples, synagogues, mosques, convents  and monasteries  P  Funeral home and services  6710  Includes funeral homes combined with crematories P free‐standing cemetery  6722 P Columbarium  6724 C Vegetable farming or growing   9120 Includes private fields and community gardens with  production limited to retail sales  P  Commercial orchards   9130 Includes fruit and nut trees with production limited  to retail sales  P  Animal Production  9300 Keep, graze, breed or feed animals (see district  standards)  P  tent revival meetings/transient  amusements  9921 Includes temporary carnivals and circuses sponsored  by non‐profit organizations (see section35.2‐72.23)  P  cluster commercial  development  9955 See section 35.2‐85 C               35.2‐45.3  B‐1 District Use Standards  The following standards supplement the standards for specific uses established in Error! Reference  source not found.:  (a) No lot, building or structure shall be used and no building or structure shall be erected that is  intended or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any industrial or manufacturing  purposes.    (b) Drive‐through and drive‐in uses are not allowed in this district except under the following  conditions:    1. Drive through and drive‐in uses shall not be associated with businesses providing food or  beverage services;    2. Drive‐through services shall be located in the rear of the building and shall take access from  an urban collector or local street; and    3. Drive‐through services shall be designed so that not more than one (1) two‐way access or  two (2) one‐way access points serving such uses shall be located on a single block.     (c) Outdoor operations, storage, or display are prohibited except as authorized for temporary  outdoor display or outdoor dining.    (d) The scale of businesses shall be compatible with adjacent neighborhoods and shall not exceed  the floor areas established in Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in document.‐1.     Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in document.‐1: Maximum Floor Areas for the B‐1 District  Development  Maximum Gross Floor  Area (sq.ft.) Per Lot  Multi‐tenant commercial developments or  Mixed Use Developments  50,000  Single office development 20,000  Single retail or service business  5,000 Restaurant  4,000   (e) Except authorized single household dwellings and other residential uses permitted by conditional  use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited. except when part of a mixed‐use  building where the residential  access is taken from an urban collector or local street.               (f) Schools for general education with maximum enrollments of twenty‐five (25) or fewer students  shall only be allowed subject to the setbacks for other uses allowed in the district. Schools with  maximum enrollments in excess of twenty‐five (25) students shall be subject to approval of a  conditional use permit and setback requirements for schools established in section Error!  Reference source not found. (Schools, Colleges and Vocational Schools).     (g) Not more than three (3) unrelated individuals may occupy a dwelling unit in the B‐1 district  unless otherwise approved by a conditional use permit.     (h) Accessory uses and structures shall comply with the provisions of section Error! Reference source  not found..    35.2‐45.4   B‐1 District Development Standards   Dimensional standards for the B‐1 district are summarized in Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in  document.‐2. Section cross‐references identify the location of additional dimensional standards and  rules for their application.  The standards in this section apply in addition to the site development  standards of Article VI and site development standards applicable to specific uses established in Article  VII.  (a) Setbacks. Setbacks are subject to compliance with in section Error! Reference source not found.  (Error! Reference source not found.) and applicable landscaping requirements.    (b) Lot Area Regulations. In addition to the minimum lot size of 6,000 square feet, a total minimum  area of 1,000 square feet is required for each dwelling unit, or unit in a boardinghouse, lodging  house, nursing home, tourist home or hotel unit.     (c) Parking. Required on‐site parking shall be provided behind the front building line in accordance  with section Error! Reference source not found. except where an existing building with parking  in front of the building line is being reused and locating required parking in rear or side yards is  not practical due to extreme topography or access limitations.    (d) Dumpsters. Dumpsters on lots abutting residential zoning districts shall be screened pursuant to  section Error! Reference source not found. (Utility Screening) and set back at least twenty‐five  (25) feet from any residential property line  (e) Landscaping Where a building is located within five (5) feet of the right‐of‐way, required street  trees and foundation plantings may be planted in City right‐of‐way with permission of the City.   (f) Development Patterns. The B‐1 district development standards may be modified through the  approval of a cluster commercial development.  (g) Lots abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts.  Multi‐story buildings on lots that abut lots in an  R‐1, R‐3 or R‐3 Districts shall not exceed 2 stories within 100 feet of the property line  9    of said abutting lots.  See section #5.2‐61.2 for additional height requirements and  section 35.2‐61.3 for additional setback requirements for lots abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3  districts.    (h) Mixed Use Developments permitted by right.    1. Commercial space shall comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of the building gross  floor area.  2. When a mixed use development in a B‐1 District is adjacent to an R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3  District, a fence that is not less than six (6) feet in height shall be established with  the required buffer as required by Section 35.2‐63.10 (d).      Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in document.‐2: Summary of B‐1 Development  Standards    10    Design Element  Standards Section Cross‐Reference Maximum height   40’   Error! Reference source  not found.  Minimum front setback from right‐of‐way (dimension A) 0’ 0  Minimum side setback, interior (dimension B) 0’ 0  Minimum side setback, exterior (dimension C) 0’ 0  Minimum rear setback (dimension D)  25’ 0  Minimum lot width at front property line (dimension E) and  front setback line (dimension F)  50’  Error! Reference source  not found.  Minimum lot depth (dimension F)  100’  Error! Reference source  not found.  Minimum lot area (square feet)  6,000 with 1,000  sq.ft. of lot area  per dwelling unit  or boarding unit   Error! Reference source  not found.  Letters in drawing to the left correspond  with dimensions cited in the design element  column     11    35.2‐46.3  B‐3 District Use Standards  The following standards supplement the standards for specific uses established in Article VII:  (a) Schools and colleges of all types (including vocational schools) shall not exceed a maximum  enrollment of one hundred (100) students except as authorized by conditional use permit.    (b) Radio and television studios and stations shall not have towers, shall produce no exterior  electromagnetic effect and shall be soundproofed from adjoining properties.    (c) Large‐scale retail establishments shall comply with section 35.2‐84 (Retail Establishments,  Large Scale) unless otherwise approved through the conditional use permit process.    (d) Dance floors may be allowed as accessory uses to restaurants.    (e) Arenas and auditoriums approved through the conditional use permit process shall be  limited to a maximum capacity of two thousand five hundred (2,500) persons.    (f) Veterinarian hospitals authorized through the conditional use permit process shall not have  outdoor kennels.    (g) Except authorized single household dwellings and other residential uses permitted by  conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited. except when part  of a mixed‐use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or  local street.     (h) Outdoor storage is prohibited.    (i) Accessory uses and structures shall comply with the provisions of section 35.2‐71       12    35.2‐48.3  B‐5 District Use Standards  The following standards supplement the standards for specific uses established in Article VII:  (a) No operations shall create conditions of smoke, fumes, noise, odor, light or dust detrimental to  health, safety or the general welfare of the community.    (b) Billboards shall be subject to the regulations of section 35.2‐64.16 (Billboards).     (c) Second‐hand stores may include auction sales provided such activity is conducted wholly within  an enclosed building.    (d) Storage warehouses and yards shall not include the storage of combustibles prohibited by the  fire code, sand yards, gravel yards, coal yards, railroad yards and automobile wrecking yards.    (e) Schools and colleges of all types that exceed a maximum enrollment of one hundred (100)  students are prohibited unless otherwise approved through issuance of a conditional use  permit.     (f) Except residential uses specifically permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential  uses shall be prohibited. except when part of a mixed‐use building where the residential  access is taken from an urban collector or local street.     (g) Large‐scale retail establishments shall comply with the provisions of section 35.2‐84 (Retail  Establishments, Large Scale) unless otherwise approved through issuance of a conditional use  permit.    (h) Outdoor storage, which is permitted as an accessory to a principal use, shall be screened in  accordance with section 35.2‐63.9 (Utility Screening).    13    35.2‐46.4  B‐3 District De velopment Standards   Dimensional standards for the B‐3 district are summarized in Error! Reference source not found..  Section cross‐references identify the location of additional dimensional standards and rules for their  application.  The standards in this section apply in addition to the site development standards of Article  VI and site development standards applicable to specific uses established in Article VII.  (a) Setbacks. Setbacks are subject to compliance with in section Error! Reference source not found.  (Error! Reference source not found.) and applicable landscaping requirements.  (b) Lots Abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts. See section Error! Reference source not found. for  additional height requirements and section 0 for additional setback requirements for lots  abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 districts.   (c) Area Regulations. A minimum of one thousand (1,000) square feet of lot area is required for  each dwelling unit or unit in a boardinghouse, lodging house, convalescent and nursing home,  tourist home or hotel.  (d) Parking. Parking areas shall be set back at least twenty (20) feet from front or exterior side  property lines or set behind the front building line on all street frontages.  (e) Development Patterns. The B‐3 district development standards may be modified through the  approval of a cluster commercial development or traditional neighborhood development.  (f) Mixed Use Developments permitted by right.  1. Commercial space shall comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of the building gross floor  area.  14    35.2‐48.4  B‐5 District Development Standards   Dimensional standards for the B‐5 district are summarized in Exhibit IV 20. Section cross‐references  identify the location of additional dimensional standards and rules for their application.  The standards  in this section apply in addition to the site development standards of Article VI and site development  standards applicable to specific uses established in Article VII.  (a) Height regulations. Subject to the provisions of sections 35.2‐61.2 (Height) and 35.2‐61.3  (Setbacks), buildings may be erected to any height, provided that the height of that portion  of the building in excess of two (2) times the width of the street on which it abuts shall be  governed by the following regulations:     1. For each foot such building or portion thereof is set back from any street, lot or  minimum setback line, such building or portion thereof may be erected ten (10) feet in  height, provided that no street shall for this purpose be considered to be less than forty  (40) feet nor more than sixty (60) feet in width.     2. If a building abuts on two (2) or more streets, that street which permits the greater  height shall be used as the basis of measurement.       (b) Lots Abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts. See section 35.2‐61.2 (Height) for additional height  requirements and section 35.2‐61.3 (Setbacks) for additional setback requirements for lots  abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 districts.     (c) Area regulations. Each dwelling, boardinghouse, lodging house, convalescent and nursing  home, tourist home and hotel, together with their accessory buildings, shall be located on a  lot having an area of not less than one thousand (1,000) square feet for each household  unit, except that the minimum area for any such lot shall be six thousand (6,000) square  feet, and the minimum width fifty (50) feet.    (d) Development Patterns. The B‐5 district development standards may be modified through  the approval of a cluster commercial development or traditional neighborhood  development.    (e) Mixed Use Developments permitted by right.    1. Commercial space shall comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of the building gross floor  area.        15      35.2‐61  Building Envelope, Lot  Area and Density Standards   35.2‐61.1  Rules for Building En velope Standards (Height, Setbacks and Building Coverage)  (a) The building envelope standards are listed for each zoning district in Article IV and are  summarized in Appendix B. This section describes the general rules for applying height,  setback and building coverage standards.     (b) Building envelope standards, other than those established in the applicable zoning  district and this article may apply when:    1. Greater setbacks or lesser heights are required pursuant to the zoning district  standards in Article IV or the standards in this article;    2. An overlay district imposes different standards pursuant to Article V;    3. The City Council approves alternative building envelope standards pursuant to a  conditional use permit issued in accordance with section 35.2‐11 (Applications  Requiring Public Hearings Before City Council); or    4. Board of Zoning Appeals modifies building envelope standards by granting a  variance pursuant to section 35.2‐12 (Variances and Appeals to the Board of Zoning  Appeals).     35.2‐61.2  Additional Height Regulations  (a) Measurement of Height    1. Building Height. Building height is the vertical distance measured from the crown of  the street opposite the middle of the front of the building to:   16    The highest point of roof  surface of a flat roof    The deck line of a mansard  roof      The mean height level  between eaves and ridge  of a gable, hip or  gambrel roof    2. Exceptions to Measurement of Building Height   a. Buildings with Large Setbacks. Where a building is set back from the street line  thirty‐five (35) feet or more, building height shall be measured from the average  elevation of finished ground surface along the front of the building.      b. Large Corner Lots. On corner lots exceeding twenty thousand (20,000) square  feet in area, the height of the building may be measured from the crown of  either street at the midpoint of the building facing the applicable street.     c. Through Lots. For lots extending through from street to street, the height may be  measured from the crown of either street at the midpoint of the building facing  the applicable street, provided that the maximum height that would be  17    permitted based on the lower street shall extend back from the right‐of‐way of  such street not less than one hundred fifty (150) feet (see following illustration).                  d. Properties Abutting R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts. For lots in any R‐4, B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐1, I‐1, I‐ 2 or I‐3 district abutting property zoned R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3, height shall be measured from  natural grade at the horizontal midpoint of the building wall facing each abutting  residential property and shall apply to any portion of the building located within one‐ hundred‐feet (100) feet of the property line (see following illustration). In no case shall a  building be required to be less than twenty (20) feet in height at the front building line.                   (b)  Height Exceptions for Certain Structures  1.  The height limitations shall not apply to the following feat ures projecting above the  roof line: flag poles, church spires/steeples, belfries, cupolas and domes not used  for human occupancy, chimneys, ventilators, skylights, water tanks, bulkheads or  18    similar features, radio and television antennas for the use of residents of dwelling  units in apartments, and necessary mechanical appurtenances (including, but not  limited to solar energy panels and related appurtenances, plumbing vents, exhaust  vents, HVAC equipment, electrical connections, lightning rods and  telecommunications connections) usually carried above the roof level provided  that:  a.  Such a feature shall be erected only to a height necessary to accomplish the  purpose it is intended to serve, but in no case more than fifteen (15) feet above  its lowest point of contact with the roof.   b.  The total area covered by such features shall not exceed in horizontal cross‐ sectional area fifteen (15) percent of the area of the plane of roof upon which  they are located.    c.  Such features as water tanks, cooling towers and bulkheads, but not solar energy  panels and related appurtenances, shall be enclosed within walls constructed of  the same material as the main walls of the building on which they are located.  2.  Parapet walls may extend not  more than five (5) feet above the limiting height of the  building on which they rest.   3.  No sign, name plate, display  or advertising device of any kind whatsoever shall be  inscribed upon or attached to any chimney, tower, tank or other structure which  extends above the district height limitations.  (c)  Tall Buildings in the R‐4, B‐1, B‐3 and IN‐1 Districts. In the R‐4, B‐1, B‐3 and IN‐1  districts, apartment buildings, public or semi‐public buildings such as a religious  institution, school, library, hospital, may be erected to not more than one hundred  twenty‐five (125) feet in height; provided that the portion of such building more  than forty (40) feet in height shall set back from the street, lot or required setback  line, one (1) foot for each one (1) foot of such additional height (see following  illustration).     19    35.2‐61.3 Setbacks  (a) Measuring Setbacks. Setbacks shall be measured as the shortest distance between the  applicable property line (front, side or rear) and the nearest portion of the building,  except as specifically provided in this section. For purposes of this measurement, the  property line shall be considered a vertical plane and all distances shall be measured  horizontally from that plane.   (b) Setbacks, Buffers and Open Spaces Unique to Lot. No required setback, buffer or open  space for any building or lot shall be considered to provide a required setback, buffer or  open space for a building on any other lot.   (c) Corner Lots. On a corner lot, the required side setback abutting a street (exterior side  setback) shall be at least equal to a required front setback for other lots fronting on the  side street. The Zoning Administrator shall determine the front, side and rear yards  based on the predominant orientation of lots on the block on which the property is  located.   (d) Interior Lots with Double Frontage. Interior lots having frontages on two (2) streets  shall have a front setback on each street, except where all lots or existing dwellings are  designed to face the same street.   (e) Authorized Encroachments. The following structures may encroach upon minimum  setback areas as provided herein:  1. Terraces. A paved terrace shall not be subject to minimum setback or maximum lot  coverage requirements; provided that such terrace is without roof, awnings,  screens, walls, parapets or other forms of enclosure and is not more than three (3)  feet above grade. Such terrace, however, may have a guard railing, wall or fence not  over four (4) feet high with less than fifty (50) percent opacity, and shall not be  closer than five (5) feet from any lot line.   2. Porches. Unenclosed porches or decks may project not more than ten (10) feet  beyond the front, exterior side and rear walls of a building into the minimum front,  exterior side or rear setback for the district. Any two (2) story or enclosed porch, or  one having a roof, shall be considered a part of the building in the determination of  the required setback and amount of building coverage.   3. Projecting Horizontal Architectural Features. Architectural features, such as  windowsills, belt courses, chimneys, cornices, eaves or bay windows, may project  not more than three (3) feet into any required setback, but not closer than five (5)  feet to any lot line. The sum of any bay or bow window projections on any wall shall  not exceed one‐fourth (1/4th) of the length of said wall.  4. Fire Escapes. Open fire escapes may extend into any required setback not more  than five (5) feet; provided, however, that such fire escapes shall not be closer than  five (5) feet at any point to any lot line.  20    5. Fences and Walls  a. The setback requirements of this Zoning Ordinance shall not be deemed to  prohibit any otherwise lawful fence or wall if:  i) Each fence and/or wall does not exceed four (4) feet in height in a front  yard.  ii) Each fence and/or wall shall not exceed eight (8) feet in height in side and  rear yards in residential districts of ten (10) feet in height in other districts.  iii) Fences and/or walls in required exterior side setbacks shall not exceed four  (4) feet in height.   iv) Fences and walls do not conflict the standards for visibility at intersections  established in section Error! Reference source not found. (Visibility at  Intersections) in any district.  v) On a corner lot, no fence and/or wall shall exceed four (4) feet in height in  the required exterior side or rear setback abutting a street when a front  yard is required for any lot on the side street in any district.   (f) Setback Reductions for Neighborhood Norms. The following provisions are applicable  to new development, additions or redevelopment in the R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 districts:   1. Subject to the provisions of paragraphs 3 and 4 of this section, the minimum front  and side setbacks shall be reduced to match the lesser of:  a. The average setbacks on the block face on which the proposed building fronts  and the block face opposite the front of the proposed building;    b. The average setback of the buildings located on either side of the proposed  development;  c. The mode of setbacks on the block face of the proposed development and the  block face opposite the front of the proposed development;   21      2. The minimum rear setback shall be reduced by twenty‐five (25) percent when a  legally created lot is less than the minimum lot area for the applicable district.  3. When determining the average setbacks, the City shall determine the mean of all  principal structure setbacks. For any structure set back further than the minimum  required setback for the applicable zoning district shall be deemed to be set back to  that minimum. The mode shall be the most frequently occurring setback on the  applicable lot’s block face and the block face across the street.   4. Regardless of the neighborhood norm, side and rear setbacks sha ll comply with  minimum fire code requirements.  5. When the neighborhood norm provisions are not applicable, the Zoning  Administrator may authorize a minor exception, not to exceed on e (1) foot from the  required dimension, for a building setback for one and two‐hous ehold dwellings to  preserve existing vegetation or where other purposes of this Zoning Ordinance are  achieved.   (g) Future Street Widening. On any street where a street widening plan designating future   right‐of‐way lines has been officially adopted by the City or Commonwealth of Virginia,  the setbacks required by this Zoning Ordinance shall be measured from such lines rather  than the existing street lines; and where no setback is otherwise required, a setback at  the future right‐of‐way line is required.   22    (h) Setbacks from Limited Access Highways. On any limited access highway (including  ramps), there shall be provided a setback line of fifty (50) feet from the right‐of‐way line  for billboards.   (i) B‐1 District Abutting and R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 District. Where a B‐1 lot abuts a R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3  lot, the minimum front setbacks along block faces shall be the lesser of the  neighborhood norm as provided in paragraph (f) of this section or twenty (20) feet.   (j) R‐4, B‐1, B‐3, B‐5, IN‐1 or IN‐2 Districts Adjacent to R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 Districts  1. In all instances where a lot in a R‐4, B‐1 B‐3, B‐5, IN‐1 or IN‐2 district abuts a lot in a  R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 district:  a. A buffer shall be established between the districts in compliance with section  Error! Reference source not found..  b. A fifty (50) foot setback shall be provided.   2. Where lot in a B‐3, B‐5, IN‐1 or IN‐2 district is on the same block as a residential  district, the front and exterior side setback requirements of the residential district  shall apply to the applicable business or institutional district.   3. The buffer and setback requirements of paragraphs (j)1. and (j)2. of this section do  not apply when the property within the R‐1, R‐2 or R‐3 district is owned or leased by  an institutional use.    (k) Industrial Districts Adjacent to Residential Districts  1. In all instances where a lot in an industrial district (I‐1, I‐2 or I‐3) abuts a lot in a  residential district (R‐1, R‐2, R‐3 or R‐4):  a. A buffer shall be established between the districts in compliance with section  Error! Reference source not found..  b. There shall be required a one‐hundred (100) foot minimum building setback on  the lot in the industrial district.   2. Where a lot in an industrial district is on the same block as a residential district, the  front and exterior side setback requirements of the residential district shall apply to  the applicable industrial district.   (l) Private recreational facilities. Private recreational facilities such as swimming pools,  tennis courts and basketball courts permitted as accessory uses located on residentially  zoned land, shall not be located in any front yard and shall have the following setbacks:  1. If accessory to a single‐household use or duplex, the edge of the facility shall be  located not less than five (5) feet from any lot line.  23    2. If accessory to a residential use other than a single‐household residence or duplex,  the edge of the facility shall be located not less than twenty (20) feet from any lot  line.  3. Any private recreational facility with above ground lighting shall comply with  minimum setback requirements for the principal structure in the applicable location.   4. In the event that a lighted facility is located less than fifty (50) feet from any lot line,  it shall be screened pursuant to section Error! Reference source not found. (Error!  Reference source not found.).  (m) Dedicated Street as Portion of Required Buffer. When a dedicated street separates two  (2) districts requiring additional setbacks, one fourth (1/4th) of the width of the  dedicated right‐of‐way may be deducted from the required setback.       That this ordinance shall become effective upon its adoption.    Adopted:  Certified:  __________________________________________________     C l e r k   o f   C o u n c i l         LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: September 22, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Proposed Amendments to mixed use development in the B-1, Limited Business Zoning District KEY ELEMENTS: _X Economic Development X Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _X Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Review the current requirements of the B-1, Limited Business Zoning District and initiate changes related to mixed-use developments. SUMMARY: The City of Lynchburg’s current Zoning Ordinance was adopted by City Council on February 23, 2016. When the B-1, Limited Business District Standards were drafted, the purpose was to provide for office, retail, restaurant and service uses that are compatible and in scale with nearby residential areas, have pedestrian-oriented designs and do not involve the constant traffic flows characteristic of community-scaled retail activities. The B-1 Zoning District also allows for a variety of residential uses. Single-household detached and mixed-use (typically commercial uses on lower floors with residential uses on upper floors) structures are permitted by right; two-household (duplexes), single-household attached (townhouses) and multi-household structures (apartments) are allowed with approval of a conditional use permit by City Council. In an August 25, 2020 email to City Council, the Richland Hills Neighborhood Association expressed their concerns with a proposed mixed use development at 7051 Timberlake Road. Planning staff met with representatives from the neighborhood association on September 9, 2020. Although staff maintains the intent of the ordinance is to allow limited residential uses as part of a mixed-use development, the consensus is that the development as proposed does not meet the intent of the B-1, Limited Business District. In lieu of eliminating the provision for “by right” mixed-use residential uses, staff recommends that City Council initiate changes to the B-1, Limited Business District that would (i) increase setbacks from lower density residential zoning districts, (ii) add a graphic and/or further explanation to the ordinance of when ground floor residential units are permitted as part of a mixed-use development, (iii) clarify that no development can exceed the fifty thousand (50,000) square foot maximum gross floor area and (iv) consider adding a maximum lot size or a requirement for a series of private or local streets to serve larger B-1 areas. If initiated by City Council, staff would also review applicability of the standards to other business zoning districts prior to scheduling public hearings with Planning Commission and City Council to amend the ordinance. PRIOR ACTION(S): January 14, 2014: Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 adopted by City Council February 23, 2016: Zoning Ordinance adopted by City Council FISCAL IMPACT: N/A CONTACT(S): Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner – 455-3900 K e n t W h i t e , C o m m u n i t y D e v e l o p m e n t D i r e c t o r – 455-3900 ATTACHMENT(S): Presentation Slides; Memo; Logan’s Landing II Preliminary Site Plan (excerpt) REVIEWED BY: raw B-1, Limited Business District Tom Martin, AICP City Planner Department of Community Development City Council Work Session September 22, 2020 Purpose and Outline Purpose: Discuss staff recommendations to amend the B-1, Limited Business District Outline: 1. Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 2. Proposed Logan’s Landing II Development 3. B-1 District Purpose 4. B-1 District Residential Uses 5. B-1 District Standards 6. B-1 District Development Standards 7. Richland Hill Neighborhood Concerns 8. Staff Analysis and Recommendations 2 Comprehensive Plan Comprehensive Plan • Recognizes the need to make efficient use of limited land resources. • Recommends policies that provide for accessory dwellings, density bonuses and mixed use development. • Effort to provide for City’s growing population without having to increase densities in residential districts. 3 Proposed Logan’s Landing II Proposed Logan’s Landing II • 7051 Timberlake Road – 7.6 acres • Zoned B-1, Limited Business District and B-3, Community Business District • 123 Apartments, 17 Commercial Units • 189,332 sf. In 4 Buildings • 259 Parking Spaces • Pool & Pool House 4 B-1 District Purpose B-1 District Purpose • Provide for office, retail, restaurant and service uses compatible with nearby residential areas. • Be in scale with adjacent neighborhood development. • Have pedestrian-oriented designs. • Generate a moderate level of traffic. • Provide a transition from retail districts and heavily traveled thoroughfares to residential areas. 5 B-1 District Purpose 6 2472-2496 Rivermont Avenue Residential Uses in the B-1 District Residential Uses in the B-1 District • Single-Household Detached – Permitted by Right • Two-Household (Duplex) – Conditional Use Permit • Single-Household Attached (Townhouses) – Conditional Use Permit • Multi-Household Structures (Apartments) – Conditional Use Permit • Mixed-use Residential Structures (Typically Commercial uses on lower floors with residential uses on upper floors – Permitted by Right 7 B-1 District Standards B-1 District Standards • Limitations on drive-through location. • Prohibited outdoor operations such as storage or display. • Scale of business that is compatible with adjacent neighborhoods. – Multi-Tenant Commercial Developments – 50,000 sf. – Single-Office Development – 20,000 sf. – Single Retail or Service Business – 5,000 sf. – Restaurant – 4,000 sf. • Except authorized single-household dwellings and other residential uses permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited except when part of a mixed-use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or local street. 8 B-1 Development Standards B-1 Development Standards • Visibility at Intersections • Lot area regulations – 6,000 sf. minimum plus 1,000 sf. per dwelling unit • Parking provided behind the front building line • Dumpster screening • Landscaping • Height – 40 Feet Maximum • Front Setback – 0 Foot • Side Setback – 0 Foot • Rear Setback – 25 Feet • Lot Width – 50 Feet Minimum • Lot Depth – 100 Feet Minimum 9 Richland Hills Neighborhood Concerns Neighborhood Concerns 1. Allowing commercially zoned land to be developed largely as high-density residential (apartment complexes) without review or approval by the Planning Commission or City Council. 2. The impact the proposed development would have on Timberlake Road traffic. 3. The intention of the developer to purchase the property at 1514 Brookville Lane to include as part of the proposed development. 4. Setbacks for B-1, Limited Business District uses adjacent R-1, Low Density Residential Districts. 5. Ratio of commercial space to residential units. 6. Mixed use developments ability to exceed the maximum 50,000 square foot maximum gross floor area. 10 Staff Response Analysis and Recommendations • Intent is not to allow high density apartments without review by Planning Commission or Council. Should allow for “limited” residential uses as part of a mixed-use development. • A traffic analysis is being reviewed by the City Engineer. • The property at 1514 Brookville Lane is not part of the submitted site plan and would require a FLUM Amendment and Rezoning. • Amend Section 35.2-16 (j) to require a 50’ setback when B-1 Districts are adjacent to Low Density Residential Districts. 11 Staff Response Analysis and Recommendations • Ground floor residential uses must take access from collector or local street. Developer expressed intent to appeal Zoning Administrator decision. (No official decision and no appeal filed) • Amend B-1 standards or clarify explanation of when ground floor residential uses are permitted. • Amend B-1 Standards to clarify no single development can exceed 50,000 square feet of maximum gross floor area. • Consider maximum lot sizes or requirements for internal private or local streets. 12 13 Recommended Action Next Steps • Draft amendments to the B-1 Limited Business District – increase setbacks if adjacent to lower density residential zoning districts; – add a graphic and/or further explanation to the ordinance of when ground floor residential units are permitted as part of a mixed-use development; – clarify that no development can exceed the fifty thousand (50,000) square maximum gross floor area; and – provide for a maximum lot size and/or a requirement for a series of private or local streets to serve larger B-1 areas. • Review applicability of the standards to other business districts. • Schedule public hearings to amend the Zoning Ordinance with Planning Commission and City Council. Discussion Questions? 14     To: City Council From: Tom Martin, AICP, City Planner CC: Reid Wodicka, Interim City M anager; John Hughes, IV, Assistant City Manager; Walter Erwin, City Attorney; Kent White, Director Community Development; Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator Date: September 17, 2020 Re: B-1, Limited Business Zoning District The City of Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance was adopted by City Council on February 23, 2016. The updated ordinance was the result of a process that began in 2012 and included fifteen community listening sessions, interviews with staff, elected officials, appointed bodies and work sessions with Planning Commission and City Council. The adopted Zoning Ordinance replaced an ordinance that had not been comprehensively revised since 1978. It was intended to create a document that streamlined City processes to enhance the City’s built environment and implement many of the goals of the Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030. The Comprehensive Plan 2012-2030 recognizes the need to make efficient use of the City’s limited land resources and establishes policies that provide for accessory dwellings, density bonuses (for provision of community benefits e.g., open space or water quality enhancements) and mixed use development in commercial categories that previously excluded residences. These policies were adopted in the plan and implemented in the subsequent rewrite of the Zoning Ordinance in an effort to provide for the City’s growing population, without having to increase densities in the residential districts. As a result of concerns expressed by the Richland Hills Neighborhood related to a proposed development at 7051 Timberlake Road, City Council requested that staff provide an overview of the B-1, Limited Business District standards at an upcoming work session. The development proposes the construction of four “mixed use” buildings containing one hundred twenty-three (123) apartment units and seventeen (17) commercial units. Each building would contain a floor plate of fifteen thousand seven hundred seventy-seven (15,777) square feet and contain three (3) stories. Each building would contain approximately forty-seven thousand three hundred thirty- three (47,333) square feet. Total square footage of all four buildings would be approximately one hundred eighty-nine thousand, three hundred, thirty-two (189,332) square feet. The submitted site plan also indicates the construction of two hundred fifty-nine (259) parking spaces, a pool and pool house. The total disturbed area would be seven and six tenths (7.6) acres. Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2-45.1 states the purpose of the B-1, Limited Business District:  Provide for office, retail, restaurant and service uses compatible with nearby residential areas.  Be in scale with adjacent neighborhood development.  Have pedestrian-oriented designs.  Generate a moderate level of traffic.  Provide a transition from retail districts and heavily traveled thoroughfares to residential areas. When the B-1, Limited Business District Standards were drafted, they were intended to create development patterns similar to what exists at 2472–2496 Rivermont Avenue. This block is zoned B-1, Limited Business District and contains thirty-seven thousand, three hundred ninety- four (37,394) square feet of commercial space on one and nineteen hundredths (1.19) acres. This area is bordered by residential neighborhoods and would meet all of the intended purposes as stated for the B-1, Limited Business District. 2472-2496 Rivermont Avenue The B-1, Limited Business District allows a variety of residential uses:  Single-Household Detached – Permitted by Right  Two-Household (Duplex) – Conditional Use Permit  Single-Household Attached (Townhouses) – Conditional Use Permit  Multi-Household Structures (Apartments) – Conditional Use Permit  Mixed-use Residential Structures (Typically Commercial uses on lower floors with residential uses on upper floors) – Permitted by Right Mixed use residential structures permitted by right in the B-1, Limited Business District are subject to “District Standards”. District Standards include the following:  Limitations on drive-through location.  Prohibited outdoor operations such as storage or display.  Scale of business that is compatible with adjacent neighborhoods. o Multi-Tenant Commercial Developments – 50,000 sf. o Single-Office Development – 20,000 sf. o Single Retail or Service Business – 5,000 sf. o Restaurant – 4,000 sf.  Except authorized single-household dwellings and other residential uses permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited except when part of a mixed-use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or local street. The B-1, Limited Business District also includes the following “Development Standards”:  Visibility at Intersections  Lot area regulations – 6,000 sf. minimum plus 1,000 sf. per dwelling unit  Parking provided behind the front building line  Dumpster screening  Landscaping  Height – 40 Feet Maximum  Front Setback – 0 Foot  Side Setback – 0 Foot  Rear Setback – 25 Feet  Lot Width – 50 Feet Minimum  Lot Depth – 100 Feet Minimum In an August 25, 2020 e-mail to City Council, the Richland Hills Neighborhood Association expressed the following concerns with the proposed development at 7051 Timberlake Road: 1. Allowing commercially zoned land to be developed largely as high-density residential (apartment complexes) without review or approval by the Planning Commission or City Council. 2. The impact the proposed development would have on Timberlake Road traffic. 3. The intention of the developer to purchase the property at 1514 Brookville Lane to include as part of the proposed development. 4. Setbacks for B-1, Limited Business District uses adjacent R-1, Low Density Residential Districts. 5. Ratio of commercial space to residential units. 6. The provision for mixed use developments to exceed the maximum 50,000 square foot maximum gross floor area. Planning staff agrees that the development as proposed does not meet the intent of the B-1, Limited Business District. The following are offered as responses to the concerns expressed by the Richland Hills Neighborhood Association and possible solutions that Council may wish to consider: 1. The intent of the B-1, Limited Business District was not to allow high-density residential (apartment complexes) without review by the Planning Commission or City Council. The B-1, Limited Business District expressly requires standalone, duplex, townhouse and apartment units to obtain a Conditional Use Permit from Planning Commission and City Council. Staff does believe it was the intent to allow “limited” residential uses as part of a mixed-use development. 2. The proposed development exceeded the thresholds for which a traffic study is required. The City Engineer has requested and reviewed a traffic-analysis for the proposed development. The City Engineer has requested corrections to the traffic-analysis, which have not yet been submitted. Primary access to the proposed development would be from Logan’s Lane. An access with turn-lane into the development is proposed from Timberlake Road. This access would be “right-in” and “right-out” of the development due to an existing median in Timberlake Road. Greater Lynchburg Transit Company (GLTC) Route 7 would serve the proposed development with a stop located at Middleview Street within approximately seven hundred (700) feet. A sidewalk would be required along the entire property frontage of Timberlake Road. 3. The property located at 1514 Brookville Lane is currently zoned R-1, Low Density Residential District and recommended for Low Density Residential uses on the Future Land Use Map (FLUM). If the developer was to propose using this property for anything other than low density residential uses it would need to have a FLUM Amendment and be rezoned. Planning staff informed the developer and the Richland Neighborhood Association that they would not support a FLUM Amendment or rezoning of this property. However, final decision on any proposed FLUM Amendment or zoning change would, of course, rest with City Council. 4. Setbacks for B-1, Limited Business Districts adjacent to R-1, Low Density Residential Districts. As written the underlying B-1, Limited Business District rear yard setback of twenty-five (25) feet is required. Zoning Ordinance Section 35.2-61.3, Setbacks establishes standards for adjacent districts. Section 35.2-61.3 (j) establishes the setback as fifty (50) feet when an R-4, B-3, B-5, IN-1 or IN-2 District is adjacent to R-1, R-2 or R-3 Districts. City staff recommends City Council consider adding B-1, Limited Business District to this section of the Zoning Ordinance. 5. Ratio of commercial space to residential units. City staff has informed the developer that the first floor of all buildings must be commercial space and that ground floor residential units are prohibited unless access to the residential units is taken from an urban collector or local street. The developer has indicated that he intends to appeal this decision of the Zoning Administrator; however, no official interpretation or appeal has been requested. The site plan will not be approved as submitted unless all ground floor space is commercial. City staff recommends City Council consider adding a graphic and/or further explanation of when ground floor residential units are permitted as part of a mixed-use development. 6. Mixed-use ability to exceed the maximum fifty thousand (50,000) square foot maximum gross floor area in the B-1, Limited Business District. The Zoning Administrator has opined that the fifty thousand square foot maximum gross floor area does not apply to mixed-use developments in the B-1, Limited Business District because it is not listed in Exhibit IV-13: Maximum Floor Area for the B-1 District. This is the largest “flaw” with the existing Ordinance. City staff recommends City Council consider adding clarification that no development can exceed the fifty thousand (50,000) square maximum gross floor area in the B-1, Limited Business District. City Council may also want to consider adding a maximum lot size for the B-1, Limited Business District or adding a requirement for a series of private or local streets to serve larger B-1 areas. -XODP??'$7$?3URMHFWV???(QJLQHHULQJ?&$'?&29(5GZJ (1*,1((5,1*‡6859(<,1*‡/$1''(9(/230(17‡(19,5210(17$/ *(27(&+1,&$/‡&216758&7,217(67,1* ,163(&7,21‡&8/785$/5(6285&(6 352)),77+857 5(9,(: 6(7 7+,66+((7,6,17(1'('72%(5(352'8&('$7;5(352'8&7,212)7+,66+((7$7$',))(5(176,=(7+$1,17(1'('6+$//92,'7+(6&$/(6+2:1217+(6+((7 /$1*+251(52$'/<1&+%85*9$ +$1'3&20  75& '$7( ( 6 '$7( 2+( 2+7 2+&79 29(5+($'(/(&75,& 29(5+($'7(/(3+21( 29(5+($'&$%/(79 8*7 66 8*)2 8** : 8*( 8*&79 8*7(/(3+21(/,1( 8*6$16(:(5/,1( 8*),%(5237,&/,1( 8**$6/,1( 8*:$7(5/,1( 8*(/(&75,&/,1( 8*&$%/(7(/(9,6,21 7(/(3+21(3('(67$/ 6$1,7$5<0$1+2/( ('*(2)3$9(0(17 ' 672500$1+2/( ('*(2):22'6 6,*1 *$69$/9( &5((. ('*(2)*5$9(/ /,*+732/( ),5(+<'5$17  *9+ ' 6 < (/(&75,&32/( *8<:,5( :$7(50(7(5 7(/(3+21(32/( &/($1287 :$7(59$/9(:9 : &2 *$60(7(5* 7(/(3+21(0$5.(5 *$60$5.(5 7(/(3+21(0$1+2/(7 (/(&75,&3('(67$/ )(1&(;; &21&5(7(  352326(',1'(;&217285  352326('&217285 /,0,762)&/($5,1**5$',1* 672506(:(5 67250,1/(7 &21&5(7( 0$5. 7(/ *$6 0$5. 7+((1*,1((5$1'256859(<257$.(6125(63216,%,/,7<)257+( /2&$7,2125$&&85$&<2)7+(87,/,7,(6$66+2:1+(5(2125$1< 87,/,7,(6:,7+,17+(352-(&77+$70$<127%(6+2:1+(5(217+( &2175$&7256+$//%(5(63216,%/()25&217$&7,1*7+(87,/,7< &203$1,(6726((,)$1<87,/,7,(6(;,67:,7+,17+($5($2)7+( 352-(&7%()25($1<&216758&7,21%(*,16$1<&267,1&855('%< '$0$*,1*$1<87,/,7<:,7+,17+(352-(&76+$//%($77+((;3(16( 2)7+(&2175$&725 :25.,1*+285635,257267$57,1*7+(:25.7+(&2175$&725 6+$//&$//0,6687,/,7<$73+21(180%(5$1'$'9,6(7+( 1$785($1'/2&$7,212)7+(:25. 7,0%(5/$.(5' 5,&+/$1''5 %522.9,//(/1 *5$9(60,//5' /<1&+%85* (;35(66:$< )257$9( :$5'6)(55<5' %8,/',1* %8,/',1* %8,/',1* %8,/',1*   75&&RPPHQWV : ; ; ; ; ; ; ; 66) 66) :9 :9 &2 67%/2&.%8,/',1* :%607 67%5,&.+286( :%607 6+(' 6+(' 6+(' 6+(' 0(7$/ &$53257 &21&:$7(5 9$8/7 25,&.(5 ; ; ; :22' )(1&( ::)(1&( &/)(1&( /$ (/(&678% 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 266,1*1$/ (/(&3(' :22''(&. 66 %(1&+0$5. &+,6(/('648$5(6(721723%$&.2)&21&5(7(&85%(/(9  '5$,1723 1/(7  ,1/(7   ; ; ; ; 3,' 6&+(:(/7,0%(5/$.( '%3$*( 3,' %($&21&5(',781,21,1&25325$7(' '%3$*(3&6/,'( /2*$16/$1',1*,,//& 3,'$&5(6 $&5( %=21,1*%=21,1*   -XODP??'$7$?3URMHFWV???(QJLQHHULQJ?&$'?6,7(GZJ (1*,1((5,1*‡6859(<,1*‡/$1''(9(/230(17‡(19,5210(17$/ *(27(&+1,&$/‡&216758&7,217(67,1* ,163(&7,21‡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‡6859(<,1*‡/$1''(9(/230(17‡(19,5210(17$/ *(27(&+1,&$/‡&216758&7,217(67,1* ,163(&7,21‡&8/785$/5(6285&(6 352)),77+857 5(9,(: 6(7 7+,66+((7,6,17(1'('72%(5(352'8&('$7;5(352'8&7,212)7+,66+((7$7$',))(5(176,=(7+$1,17(1'('6+$//92,'7+(6&$/(6+2:1217+(6+((7 /$1*+251(52$'/<1&+%85*9$ +$1'3&20  :9 :9 :9 &2 ' : :9 ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; ; 66) 66) 23 :9 :9 &2 67%/2&.%8,/',1* :%607 67%5,&.+286( :%607 6+(' 6+(' 6+(' 6+(' 0(7$/ &$53257 &21&:$7(5 9$8/7 25,&.(5 ; ; ; :22' )(1&( ::)(1&( &/)(1&( /$ (/(&678% 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 266,1*$/ (/(&3(' :22''(&. 66 39& 39& 39& 39& %(1&+0$5.  &+,6(/('648$5(6(721723%$&.2)&21&5(7(&85%(/(9  '5$,1723 /(7  ,1/(7   ; ; ; ; %=21,1*%=21,1* -XODP??'$7$?3URMHFWV???(QJLQHHULQJ?&$'?6,7(GZJ (1*,1((5,1*‡6859(<,1*‡/$1''(9(/230(17‡(19,5210(17$/ *(27(&+1,&$/‡&216758&7,217(67,1* ,163(&7,21‡&8/785$/5(6285&(6 352)),77+857 5(9,(: 6(7 7+,66+((7,6,17(1'('72%(5(352'8&('$7;5(352'8&7,212)7+,66+((7$7$',))(5(176,=(7+$1,17(1'('6+$//92,'7+(6&$/(6+2:1217+(6+((7 /$1*+251(52$'/<1&+%85*9$ +$1'3&20  9,5*,1,$81,)250&2',1*6<67(0)25(526,21 $1'6(',0(17&21752/35$&7,&(6 &+$577$.(1)5207+(9,5*,1,$(526,21$1'6(',0(17 &21752/+$1'%22. -8/< 6) 23 76 36 08 0 % 6,/7)(1&(  287/(73527(&7,21  7(0325$5<6((',1*  3(50$1(176((',1*  08/&+,1*  62,/67$%,/,=$7,21%/$1.(76 0$77,1*  6% 7(0325$5<6(',0(17%$6,1  ',9(56,21',.(  '' 65 685)$&(528*+(1,1*  66) :,5(5(,1)25&(' 6,/7)(1&(  7(0325$5<&216758&7,21(175$1&(  &( ,1/(73527(&7,21  ,3 287/(73527(&7,217$%/(  23 6$) 7(0325$5<6$)(7<)(1&(  -XODP??'$7$?3URMHFWV???(QJLQHHULQJ?&$'?87,/,7<3/$1GZJ (1*,1((5,1*‡6859(<,1*‡/$1''(9(/230(17‡(19,5210(17$/ *(27(&+1,&$/‡&216758&7,217(67,1* ,163(&7,21‡&8/785$/5(6285&(6 352)),77+857 5(9,(: 6(7 7+,66+((7,6,17(1'('72%(5(352'8&('$7;5(352'8&7,212)7+,66+((7$7$',))(5(176,=(7+$1,17(1'('6+$//92,'7+(6&$/(6+2:1217+(6+((7 /$1*+251(52$'/<1&+%85*9$ +$1'3&20  -XODP??'$7$?3URMHFWV???(QJLQHHULQJ?&$'?''GZJ (1*,1((5,1*‡6859(<,1*‡/$1''(9(/230(17‡(19,5210(17$/ *(27(&+1,&$/‡&216758&7,217(67,1* ,163(&7,21‡&8/785$/5(6285&(6 352)),77+857 5(9,(: 6(7 7+,66+((7,6,17(1'('72%(5(352'8&('$7;5(352'8&7,212)7+,66+((7$7$',))(5(176,=(7+$1,17(1'('6+$//92,'7+(6&$/(6+2:1217+(6+((7 /$1*+251(52$'/<1&+%85*9$ +$1'3&20  &2 ; ; ; ' &5(3(0<57/( /$ (/(&678% 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 2+( 66 %(1&+0$5. &+,6(/('648$5(6(721723%$&.2)&21&5(7(&85%(/(9  323/$5 ; ; ; ;   66 66 66 66 66 6 66 6 66 6 6 : :9 :9 :9 66 &2 &2 &2 &2 &2 &2 66 &2 &2 6 6 &2 &2 ' : : : : : : < : : : : : : : : :9 6 &2 :9 :9 & 5 2+( +( 2+( 2+( 2+(   -XODP??'$7$?3URMHFWV???(QJLQHHULQJ?&$'?/$1'6&$3(GZJ (1*,1((5,1*‡6859(<,1*‡/$1''(9(/230(17‡(19,5210(17$/ *(27(&+1,&$/‡&216758&7,217(67,1* ,163(&7,21‡&8/785$/5(6285&(6 352)),77+857 5(9,(: 6(7 7+,66+((7,6,17(1'('72%(5(352'8&('$7;5(352'8&7,212)7+,66+((7$7$',))(5(176,=(7+$1,17(1'('6+$//92,'7+(6&$/(6+2:1217+(6+((7 /$1*+251(52$'/<1&+%85*9$ +$1'3&20 7+5((7,0(6 %$//',$0(7(5   6+58%3/$17,1*'(7$,/ &/&/ 7+5((7,0(6 %$//',$0(7(5 9$5,(6 75((3/$17,1*'(7$,/ ORDINANCE: #O-20-026 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT THE CODE OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, 1981 BY AMENDING ZONING ORDINANCE SECTION 35.2-45, LIMITED BUSINESS DISTRICT (B-1), SECTION 35.2-46.4, B-3 DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, SECTION 35.2-48.4, B-5 DISTRICT DEVELOPMENT STANDARDS, SECTION 35.2-61.2, ADDITIONAL HEIGHT REGULATIONS AND SECTION 35.2-61.3, SETBACKS RELATED TO RESIDENTIAL USES PERMITTED BY RIGHT AS PART OF A MIXED USE DEVELOPMENT. WHEREAS, the City Council directed City staff to prepare Zoning Ordinance Amendments related to residential uses allowed by right in the B-1, B-3 and B-5 Districts on September 22, 2020. WHEREAS, the City Council held a public hearing to consider and address the proposed Zoning Ordinance Amendments and to receive public comment on November 10, 2020. WHEREAS, the City Council finds that these amendments should be adopted in order to promote the public necessity, convenience, welfare and good zoning practice. BE IT ORDANINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: That Section 35.2-45, Limited Business District (B-1), Section 35.2-46.4, B-3 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-48.4, B-5 District Development Standards, Section 35.2-61.2, Additional Height Regulations and Section 35.1-61.3, Setbacks related to residential uses permitted by right as part of a mixed use development of the Code of the City of Lynchburg, 1981, be the same is hereby amended and reenacted as follows: 35.2-45 Limited Business Districts (B-1) 35.2-45.2 Authorized Uses (a) The uses authorized by IV-12 may be established in accordance with the procedures in Article II, the district standards in this article, the site development standards established in Article II and specific use standards established in Article VI, as well as other applicable rules and regulations. (b) Uses may also be limited by overlay standards established in Article V of this Zoning Ordinance. (c) See Article III for the rules of interpreting authorized uses and Appendix A for a complete listing of land uses allowed in every zoning district. (d) Uses designated “P” are permitted by right and uses designated “C” require issuance of a conditional use permit. Exhibit IV-12: Authorized Uses in B-1 District Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type single-household detached 1111S Typical single-household dwelling P modular home 1114S A prefabricated home without axles or frames (see definitions) P Two-household (duplex) 1121S A building located on one (1) zoning lot containing not more than two (2) dwelling units C single-household attached (townhouse) 1140S Each unit on a separate lot; fire wall may protrude from roof or roofs may be staggered C Multi-household structures 1200S Includes triplexes, four-plexes, and other multi- household dwellings C Mixed-use residential structures (see district regulations for limitations) 1201S Typically commercial uses on lower floors and residential uses on upper floors P C Housing Services 1200 Housing and custodial services for those who cannot care for themselves. Includes nursing and retirement homes, congregate living, assisted and continuing care living, but excludes rehab uses in LBCS #6520) P Bed & Breakfast and Tourist Homes 1310 Guest rooms in a private home or accessory building to a private home P boarding house 1321 Non-transient lodging that may include meals and is owner occupied P rooming house 1322 Transient or non-transient lodging that may include meals P dormitory, sorority or fraternity house 1323 Allowed only as accessory uses to and owned by a college or university C Short Term Rental 1350 Provision of lodging for fewer than thirty (30) consecutive days. (See Section 35.2-71.16) P Bicycles 2113b New or used bicycle sales, rental and repair P Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type camera and photographic supplies; clothing, jewelry, luggage, shoes, clocks, sewing; sporting goods, toy and hobby, and musical instruments; mixed media, school and office supplies 2132- 2135 Primarily retail cameras and photographic supplies or retail with repair and film developing; clothing (including shoe repair and tailoring, sporting goods, toys, musical instruments, kitchen goods, books, magazines, music, videos, stationary, greeting cards, seasonal decorations, office and school supplies. P florist, art supplies, tobacco products 2141- 2143 Florists, art supplies and art dealers, frame shops, tobacco products P art galleries 2142b Excludes art supply sales and retail framing services P antique shop 2145 Antique shops, (excludes flea markets, thrift stores and pawn shops) P grocery store, supermarket, or bakery, convenience store, specialty food stores 2151- 2154 Included are grocery stores, convenience stores, meat, seafood and produce markets, coffee, confections, variety goods and general stores, and delicatessens. Excludes stores with fuel pumps (see 2116 for fuel sales). P beer, wine, and liquor store 2155 P Health and personal care 2160 Retail prescription or nonprescription drugs; retail cosmetics, perfumes, toiletries; prescription or nonprescription eyeglasses; prescription or nonprescription health and convalescent aids; medical devices, retail food supplement products such as vitamins, nutrition supplements, and body enhancing supplements. P Bank, credit union, or savings institution 2210 Central banking functions P credit card and other financing 2221 Credit card, sales financing, unsecured consumer lending, real estate credit, mortgages, international trade financing P Investment banking, securities, and brokerages; insurance; fund, trust, or other financial establishment 2230- 2250 Securities underwriting, brokering, exchange services, managing portfolios; Insurance underwriting, selling insurance; manage assets on behalf of shareholders or beneficiaries P Real estate services 2310 Sell or lease real estate such as buildings, manufactured home sites and vacant lots; includes real estate appraisers and realtor offices P professional offices 2411- 2014 Title abstract, lawyers, notaries, accountants, bookkeeping, payroll services, architects, engineers, surveyors, graphic design, interior design and industrial design P consulting services (management, environmental technical) 2415 Advise and assist businesses on management, scientific, and technological issues P scientific research and development services 2416 Conduct research or analyze in the physical, engineering, cognitive, or life sciences in offices. P Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type other professional offices 2419, 6810, 6820 Includes advertising and media services intellectual property rights, franchising, labor, political or business organizations, and uses with similar impacts P office administrative services 2421 Office administration such as billing, record keeping, personnel, organizational planning P facilities support services 2422 Provide operating staff for support services within a client's facilities, including janitorial, security, laundry services, etc. P employment agency 2423a Provide employee placement, temporary help P copy center, private mail center, other business support services 2424 Provide document preparation, telephone answering, telemarketing, court reporting, steno typing, FAX, internet access, small signs and banners P collection agency 2425 Collect payments, compile credit information, repossess tangible assets P Travel arrangement and reservation services 2430 Promote or sell travel, includes convention and visitors' bureaus P Restaurants, cafeterias, snack bars & catering 2510- 2530 &2560 Provide food and drinks to patrons – see district specific use regulations for limitations. Includes banquet, assembly and reception halls. See district standards. P Personal care 2610 Hair, nail, and skin care and related personal care, barbers, beauty shops, dieting and weight loss, tanning, hair removal, hair weaving, ear piercing and similar services P laundromat and dry cleaning 2621 & 2622 Includes Laundromats, dry cleaners, diaper services as well as other commercial laundry services P Photofinishing 2630 Primarily engaged in developing film or making slides, etc. P Parking lot and parking garage 2640 See district standards P licensed massage therapist 2651 P pet cemetery 2723 C national post office 4181 P retail courier and package delivery 4182 Retail courier, package drop-off and mail services P wireless telecommunications transmission 4233 Operate, maintain or provide access to facilities for the transmission of voice, data, text, sound or video, see section 35.2-73 for telecommunications towers P telephone and other wired telecommunications 4234 Operate telephone networks – excludes switching stations P Telecommunications switching stations/exchanges 4239 Telecommunications switching stations and exchanges with no on-site employees C library or archive 4242 Provide library or archive services P data processing and management, hosting and related services 4244 Web hosting, computer data storage, optical scanning, computer input preparation, microfilm imaging P Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type Public Utilities Services, Major 4315, 4329, 4339, 4349 Includes transmission lines for water, wastewater, stormwater, electricity, natural gas or telecommunications services regulated by the State Corporation Commission of a regional nature and normally entail the construction of new buildings or structures such as electrical switching facilities and stations or substations, electric, gas, and other utility transmission lines of a regional nature which are not otherwise reviewed and approved by the Virginia State Corporation Commission. All overhead transmission lines are included in this definition. C Public Utilities Service Minor 4315, 4329, 4339, 4349 Includes distribution or collection lines and appurtenances for water, wastewater, stormwater, electricity, natural gas or telecommunications services regulated by the State Corporation Commission that are necessary to support development within the immediate vicinity and involve only minor structures. Included in this use type are small facilities such as transformers, relay and booster devices, and well, water and sewer pump stations, and wireless communication antennas attached to existing buildings or structures. P electric substations 4316 C Water treatment plants and utility facilities 4331 – 4333, Water treatment plants, pumping stations and lift stations C Theater, dance or music establishment 5110 & 5160 Companies, groups, or theaters that produce theatrical presentations, dance, dinner theaters, and live musical entertainment; includes facilities for independent artists and performers P Promoter of sports, performing arts, similar events and management services 5140 - 5150 Organize, promote, and manage performances and events; agents representing artists, athletes and entertainers P Museums and Other Special Purpose Recreational Institutions 5200 Public and private museums, historical sites, and similar establishments P Country Club 5340 & 6830 Operate private country clubs, with tennis courts and golf courses along with dining facilities and other recreational facilities; includes civic, social and fraternal organizations without dwellings P fitness and recreational sports center 5371 Aerobic dance or exercise center, gymnasium, physical fitness center, health and athletic club, indoor handball, racquetball, volleyball, tennis, or swimming facilities conducted inside a building P outdoor recreation 5372, 5373 & 5374 Includes for profit golf courses, archery ranges, outdoor volleyball, tennis, or swimming facilities, recreational courts, recreational day camp and horseback riding C Land Use LBCS # Description Approval Type Natural and other Recreational Parks 5500 All parks without special economic functions, other than limited concessions P Nursery or preschool 6110 P Grade school 6120 Comprises all public, private, and specialty schools between the preschool and university level; includes adult education services not addressed elsewhere. See district use standards P College or university 6130 See district use standards P Public Safety 6400 Government-owned establishments providing fire and rescue, police, and emergency response services P Clinic 6511 & 6567 Include physician offices, dentists, chiropractors, optometrists, licensed massage therapists, and veterans affairs services P outpatient care clinic 6512 Provide outpatient family planning services and outpatient care P group home small 6522 Fewer than five (5) aged or infirm individuals or fewer than nine (9) individuals with mental, intellectual or developmental disabilities P group home large 6523 Five or more aged or infirm individuals, or nine (9) or more individuals with mental, intellectual or developmental disabilities P Hospital 6530 C child and adult day care 6562 Provide day care for children and adults Home 6562a Day care for fewer than six (6) individuals in a residence P Small 6562b Day care for six (6) to twelve (12) individuals in a residence P Large 6562c Provide care for more than 12 individuals P Religious Institutions 6600 Churches, temples, synagogues, mosques, convents and monasteries P Funeral home and services 6710 Includes funeral homes combined with crematories P free-standing cemetery 6722 P Columbarium 6724 C Vegetable farming or growing 9120 Includes private fields and community gardens with production limited to retail sales P Commercial orchards 9130 Includes fruit and nut trees with production limited to retail sales P Animal Production 9300 Keep, graze, breed or feed animals (see district standards) P tent revival meetings/transient amusements 9921 Includes temporary carnivals and circuses sponsored by non-profit organizations (see section35.2-72.23) P cluster commercial development 9955 See section 35.2-85 C 35.2-45.3 B-1 District Use Standards The following standards supplement the standards for specific uses established in Error! Reference source not found.: (a) No lot, building or structure shall be used and no building or structure shall be erected that is intended or designed to be used, in whole or in part, for any industrial or manufacturing purposes. (b) Drive-through and drive-in uses are not allowed in this district except under the following conditions: 1. Drive through and drive-in uses shall not be associated with businesses providing food or beverage services; 2. Drive-through services shall be located in the rear of the building and shall take access from an urban collector or local street; and 3. Drive-through services shall be designed so that not more than one (1) two-way access or two (2) one-way access points serving such uses shall be located on a single block. (c) Outdoor operations, storage, or display are prohibited except as authorized for temporary outdoor display or outdoor dining. (d) The scale of businesses shall be compatible with adjacent neighborhoods and shall not exceed the floor areas established in Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in document.-1. Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in document.-1: Maximum Floor Areas for the B-1 District Development Maximum Gross Floor Area (sq.ft.) Per Lot Multi-tenant commercial developments or Mixed Use Developments 50,000 Single office development 20,000 Single retail or service business 5,000 Restaurant 4,000 (e) Except authorized single household dwellings and other residential uses permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited. except when part of a mixed-use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or local street. (f) Schools for general education with maximum enrollments of twenty-five (25) or fewer students shall only be allowed subject to the setbacks for other uses allowed in the district. Schools with maximum enrollments in excess of twenty-five (25) students shall be subject to approval of a conditional use permit and setback requirements for schools established in section Error! Reference source not found. (Schools, Colleges and Vocational Schools). (g) Not more than three (3) unrelated individuals may occupy a dwelling unit in the B-1 district unless otherwise approved by a conditional use permit. (h) Accessory uses and structures shall comply with the provisions of section Error! Reference source not found.. 35.2-45.4 B-1 District Development Standards Dimensional standards for the B-1 district are summarized in Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in document.-2. Section cross-references identify the location of additional dimensional standards and rules for their application. The standards in this section apply in addition to the site development standards of Article VI and site development standards applicable to specific uses established in Article VII. (a) Setbacks. Setbacks are subject to compliance with in section Error! Reference source not found. (Error! Reference source not found.) and applicable landscaping requirements. (b) Lot Area Regulations. In addition to the minimum lot size of 6,000 square feet, a total minimum area of 1,000 square feet is required for each dwelling unit, or unit in a boardinghouse, lodging house, nursing home, tourist home or hotel unit. (c) Parking. Required on-site parking shall be provided behind the front building line in accordance with section Error! Reference source not found. except where an existing building with parking in front of the building line is being reused and locating required parking in rear or side yards is not practical due to extreme topography or access limitations. (d) Dumpsters. Dumpsters on lots abutting residential zoning districts shall be screened pursuant to section Error! Reference source not found. (Utility Screening) and set back at least twenty-five (25) feet from any residential property line (e) Landscaping Where a building is located within five (5) feet of the right-of-way, required street trees and foundation plantings may be planted in City right-of-way with permission of the City. (f) Development Patterns. The B-1 district development standards may be modified through the approval of a cluster commercial development. (g) Lots abutting R-1, R-2 or R-3 Districts. Multi-story buildings on lots that abut lots in an R-1, R-3 or R-3 Districts shall not exceed 2 stories within 100 feet of the property line 9 of said abutting lots. See Section 35.2-61.2 for additional height requirements and Section 35.2-61.3 for additional setback requirements for lots abutting R-1, R-2 or R-3 districts. (h) Mixed Use Developments permitted by conditional use permit. 1. Commercial space shall comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of the building gross floor area. 2. When a mixed use development in a B-1 District is adjacent to an R-1, R-2 or R-3 District, a fence that is not less than six (6) feet in height shall be established with the required buffer as required by Section 35.2-63.10 (d). Exhibit Error! No text of specified style in document.-2: Summary of B-1 Development Standards 10 Design Element Standards Section Cross-Reference Maximum height 40’ Error! Reference source not found. Minimum front setback from right-of-way (dimension A) 0’ 0 Minimum side setback, interior (dimension B) 0’ 0 Minimum side setback, exterior (dimension C) 0’ 0 Minimum rear setback (dimension D) 25’ 0 Minimum lot width at front property line (dimension E) and front setback line (dimension F) 50’ Error! Reference source not found. Minimum lot depth (dimension F) 100’ Error! Reference source not found. Minimum lot area (square feet) 6,000 with 1,000 sq.ft. of lot area per dwelling unit or boarding unit Error! Reference source not found. Letters in drawing to the left correspond with dimensions cited in the design element column 11 35.2-46.3 B-3 District Use Standards The following standards supplement the standards for specific uses established in Article VII: (a) Schools and colleges of all types (including vocational schools) shall not exceed a maximum enrollment of one hundred (100) students except as authorized by conditional use permit. (b) Radio and television studios and stations shall not have towers, shall produce no exterior electromagnetic effect and shall be soundproofed from adjoining properties. (c) Large-scale retail establishments shall comply with section 35.2-84 (Retail Establishments, Large Scale) unless otherwise approved through the conditional use permit process. (d) Dance floors may be allowed as accessory uses to restaurants. (e) Arenas and auditoriums approved through the conditional use permit process shall be limited to a maximum capacity of two thousand five hundred (2,500) persons. (f) Veterinarian hospitals authorized through the conditional use permit process shall not have outdoor kennels. (g) Except authorized single household dwellings and other residential uses permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited. except when part of a mixed-use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or local street. (h) Outdoor storage is prohibited. (i) Accessory uses and structures shall comply with the provisions of section 35.2-71 12 35.2-48.3 B-5 District Use Standards The following standards supplement the standards for specific uses established in Article VII: (a) No operations shall create conditions of smoke, fumes, noise, odor, light or dust detrimental to health, safety or the general welfare of the community. (b) Billboards shall be subject to the regulations of section 35.2-64.16 (Billboards). (c) Second-hand stores may include auction sales provided such activity is conducted wholly within an enclosed building. (d) Storage warehouses and yards shall not include the storage of combustibles prohibited by the fire code, sand yards, gravel yards, coal yards, railroad yards and automobile wrecking yards. (e) Schools and colleges of all types that exceed a maximum enrollment of one hundred (100) students are prohibited unless otherwise approved through issuance of a conditional use permit. (f) Except residential uses specifically permitted by conditional use permit, ground floor residential uses shall be prohibited. except when part of a mixed-use building where the residential access is taken from an urban collector or local street. (g) Large-scale retail establishments shall comply with the provisions of section 35.2-84 (Retail Establishments, Large Scale) unless otherwise approved through issuance of a conditional use permit. (h) Outdoor storage, which is permitted as an accessory to a principal use, shall be screened in accordance with section 35.2-63.9 (Utility Screening). 13 35.2-46.4 B-3 District Development Standards Dimensional standards for the B-3 district are summarized in Error! Reference source not found.. Section cross-references identify the location of additional dimensional standards and rules for their application. The standards in this section apply in addition to the site development standards of Article VI and site development standards applicable to specific uses established in Article VII. (a) Setbacks. Setbacks are subject to compliance with in section Error! Reference source not found. (Error! Reference source not found.) and applicable landscaping requirements. (b) Lots Abutting R-1, R-2 or R-3 Districts. See section Error! Reference source not found. for additional height requirements and section 0 for additional setback requirements for lots abutting R-1, R-2 or R-3 districts. (c) Area Regulations. A minimum of one thousand (1,000) square feet of lot area is required for each dwelling unit or unit in a boardinghouse, lodging house, convalescent and nursing home, tourist home or hotel. (d) Parking. Parking areas shall be set back at least twenty (20) feet from front or exterior side property lines or set behind the front building line on all street frontages. (e) Development Patterns. The B-3 district development standards may be modified through the approval of a cluster commercial development or traditional neighborhood development. (f) Mixed Use Developments permitted by right. 1. Commercial space shall comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of the building gross floor area. 14 35.2-48.4 B-5 District Development Standards Dimensional standards for the B-5 district are summarized in Exhibit IV 20. Section cross-references identify the location of additional dimensional standards and rules for their application. The standards in this section apply in addition to the site development standards of Article VI and site development standards applicable to specific uses established in Article VII. (a) Height regulations. Subject to the provisions of sections 35.2-61.2 (Height) and 35.2-61.3 (Setbacks), buildings may be erected to any height, provided that the height of that portion of the building in excess of two (2) times the width of the street on which it abuts shall be governed by the following regulations: 1. For each foot such building or portion thereof is set back from any street, lot or minimum setback line, such building or portion thereof may be erected ten (10) feet in height, provided that no street shall for this purpose be considered to be less than forty (40) feet nor more than sixty (60) feet in width. 2. If a building abuts on two (2) or more streets, that street which permits the greater height shall be used as the basis of measurement. (b) Lots Abutting R-1, R-2 or R-3 Districts. See section 35.2-61.2 (Height) for additional height requirements and section 35.2-61.3 (Setbacks) for additional setback requirements for lots abutting R-1, R-2 or R-3 districts. (c) Area regulations. Each dwelling, boardinghouse, lodging house, convalescent and nursing home, tourist home and hotel, together with their accessory buildings, shall be located on a lot having an area of not less than one thousand (1,000) square feet for each household unit, except that the minimum area for any such lot shall be six thousand (6,000) square feet, and the minimum width fifty (50) feet. (d) Development Patterns. The B-5 district development standards may be modified through the approval of a cluster commercial development or traditional neighborhood development. (e) Mixed Use Developments permitted by right. 1. Commercial space shall comprise at least fifty percent (50%) of the building gross floor area. 15 35.2-61 Building Envelope, Lot Area and Density Standards 35.2-61.1 Rules for Building Envelope Standards (Height, Setbacks and Building Coverage) (a) The building envelope standards are listed for each zoning district in Article IV and are summarized in Appendix B. This section describes the general rules for applying height, setback and building coverage standards. (b) Building envelope standards, other than those established in the applicable zoning district and this article may apply when: 1. Greater setbacks or lesser heights are required pursuant to the zoning district standards in Article IV or the standards in this article; 2. An overlay district imposes different standards pursuant to Article V; 3. The City Council approves alternative building envelope standards pursuant to a conditional use permit issued in accordance with section 35.2-11 (Applications Requiring Public Hearings Before City Council); or 4. Board of Zoning Appeals modifies building envelope standards by granting a variance pursuant to section 35.2-12 (Variances and Appeals to the Board of Zoning Appeals). 35.2-61.2 Additional Height Regulations (a) Measurement of Height 1. Building Height. Building height is the vertical distance measured from the crown of the street opposite the middle of the front of the building to: 16 The highest point of roof surface of a flat roof The deck line of a mansard roof The mean height level between eaves and ridge of a gable, hip or gambrel roof 2. Exceptions to Measurement of Building Height a. Buildings with Large Setbacks. Where a building is set back from the street line thirty-five (35) feet or more, building height shall be measured from the average elevation of finished ground surface along the front of the building. b. Large Corner Lots. On corner lots exceeding twenty thousand (20,000) square feet in area, the height of the building may be measured from the crown of either street at the midpoint of the building facing the applicable street. c. Through Lots. For lots extending through from street to street, the height may be measured from the crown of either street at the midpoint of the building facing the applicable street, provided that the maximum height that would be 17 permitted based on the lower street shall extend back from the right-of-way of such street not less than one hundred fifty (150) feet (see following illustration). d. Properties Abutting R-1, R-2 or R-3 Districts. For lots in any R-4, B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-1, I-1, I- 2 or I-3 district abutting property zoned R-1, R-2 or R-3, height shall be measured from natural grade at the horizontal midpoint of the building wall facing each abutting residential property and shall apply to any portion of the building located within one- hundred-feet (100) feet of the property line (see following illustration). In no case shall a building be required to be less than twenty (20) feet in height at the front building line. (b) Height Exceptions for Certain Structures 1. The height limitations shall not apply to the following features projecting above the roof line: flag poles, church spires/steeples, belfries, cupolas and domes not used for human occupancy, chimneys, ventilators, skylights, water tanks, bulkheads or 18 similar features, radio and television antennas for the use of residents of dwelling units in apartments, and necessary mechanical appurtenances (including, but not limited to solar energy panels and related appurtenances, plumbing vents, exhaust vents, HVAC equipment, electrical connections, lightning rods and telecommunications connections) usually carried above the roof level provided that: a. Such a feature shall be erected only to a height necessary to accomplish the purpose it is intended to serve, but in no case more than fifteen (15) feet above its lowest point of contact with the roof. b. The total area covered by such features shall not exceed in horizontal cross- sectional area fifteen (15) percent of the area of the plane of roof upon which they are located. c. Such features as water tanks, cooling towers and bulkheads, but not solar energy panels and related appurtenances, shall be enclosed within walls constructed of the same material as the main walls of the building on which they are located. 2. Parapet walls may extend not more than five (5) feet above the limiting height of the building on which they rest. 3. No sign, name plate, display or advertising device of any kind whatsoever shall be inscribed upon or attached to any chimney, tower, tank or other structure which extends above the district height limitations. (c) Tall Buildings in the R-4, B-1, B-3 and IN-1 Districts. In the R-4, B-1, B-3 and IN-1 districts, apartment buildings, public or semi-public buildings such as a religious institution, school, library, hospital, may be erected to not more than one hundred twenty-five (125) feet in height; provided that the portion of such building more than forty (40) feet in height shall set back from the street, lot or required setback line, one (1) foot for each one (1) foot of such additional height (see following illustration). 19 35.2-61.3 Setbacks (a) Measuring Setbacks. Setbacks shall be measured as the shortest distance between the applicable property line (front, side or rear) and the nearest portion of the building, except as specifically provided in this section. For purposes of this measurement, the property line shall be considered a vertical plane and all distances shall be measured horizontally from that plane. (b) Setbacks, Buffers and Open Spaces Unique to Lot. No required setback, buffer or open space for any building or lot shall be considered to provide a required setback, buffer or open space for a building on any other lot. (c) Corner Lots. On a corner lot, the required side setback abutting a street (exterior side setback) shall be at least equal to a required front setback for other lots fronting on the side street. The Zoning Administrator shall determine the front, side and rear yards based on the predominant orientation of lots on the block on which the property is located. (d) Interior Lots with Double Frontage. Interior lots having frontages on two (2) streets shall have a front setback on each street, except where all lots or existing dwellings are designed to face the same street. (e) Authorized Encroachments. The following structures may encroach upon minimum setback areas as provided herein: 1. Terraces. A paved terrace shall not be subject to minimum setback or maximum lot coverage requirements; provided that such terrace is without roof, awnings, screens, walls, parapets or other forms of enclosure and is not more than three (3) feet above grade. Such terrace, however, may have a guard railing, wall or fence not over four (4) feet high with less than fifty (50) percent opacity, and shall not be closer than five (5) feet from any lot line. 2. Porches. Unenclosed porches or decks may project not more than ten (10) feet beyond the front, exterior side and rear walls of a building into the minimum front, exterior side or rear setback for the district. Any two (2) story or enclosed porch, or one having a roof, shall be considered a part of the building in the determination of the required setback and amount of building coverage. 3. Projecting Horizontal Architectural Features. Architectural features, such as windowsills, belt courses, chimneys, cornices, eaves or bay windows, may project not more than three (3) feet into any required setback, but not closer than five (5) feet to any lot line. The sum of any bay or bow window projections on any wall shall not exceed one-fourth (1/4th) of the length of said wall. 4. Fire Escapes. Open fire escapes may extend into any required setback not more than five (5) feet; provided, however, that such fire escapes shall not be closer than five (5) feet at any point to any lot line. 20 5. Fences and Walls a. The setback requirements of this Zoning Ordinance shall not be deemed to prohibit any otherwise lawful fence or wall if: i) Each fence and/or wall does not exceed four (4) feet in height in a front yard. ii) Each fence and/or wall shall not exceed eight (8) feet in height in side and rear yards in residential districts of ten (10) feet in height in other districts. iii) Fences and/or walls in required exterior side setbacks shall not exceed four (4) feet in height. iv) Fences and walls do not conflict the standards for visibility at intersections established in section Error! Reference source not found. (Visibility at Intersections) in any district. v) On a corner lot, no fence and/or wall shall exceed four (4) feet in height in the required exterior side or rear setback abutting a street when a front yard is required for any lot on the side street in any district. (f) Setback Reductions for Neighborhood Norms. The following provisions are applicable to new development, additions or redevelopment in the R-1, R-2 or R-3 districts: 1. Subject to the provisions of paragraphs 3 and 4 of this section, the minimum front and side setbacks shall be reduced to match the lesser of: a. The average setbacks on the block face on which the proposed building fronts and the block face opposite the front of the proposed building; b. The average setback of the buildings located on either side of the proposed development; c. The mode of setbacks on the block face of the proposed development and the block face opposite the front of the proposed development; 21 2. The minimum rear setback shall be reduced by twenty-five (25) percent when a legally created lot is less than the minimum lot area for the applicable district. 3. When determining the average setbacks, the City shall determine the mean of all principal structure setbacks. For any structure set back further than the minimum required setback for the applicable zoning district shall be deemed to be set back to that minimum. The mode shall be the most frequently occurring setback on the applicable lot’s block face and the block face across the street. 4. Regardless of the neighborhood norm, side and rear setbacks shall comply with minimum fire code requirements. 5. When the neighborhood norm provisions are not applicable, the Zoning Administrator may authorize a minor exception, not to exceed one (1) foot from the required dimension, for a building setback for one and two-household dwellings to preserve existing vegetation or where other purposes of this Zoning Ordinance are achieved. (g) Future Street Widening. On any street where a street widening plan designating future right-of-way lines has been officially adopted by the City or Commonwealth of Virginia, the setbacks required by this Zoning Ordinance shall be measured from such lines rather than the existing street lines; and where no setback is otherwise required, a setback at the future right-of-way line is required. 22 (h) Setbacks from Limited Access Highways. On any limited access highway (including ramps), there shall be provided a setback line of fifty (50) feet from the right-of-way line for billboards. (i) B-1 District Abutting and R-1, R-2 or R-3 District. Where a B-1 lot abuts a R-1, R-2 or R-3 lot, the minimum front setbacks along block faces shall be the lesser of the neighborhood norm as provided in paragraph (f) of this section or twenty (20) feet. (j) R-4, B-1, B-3, B-5, IN-1 or IN-2 Districts Adjacent to R-1, R-2 or R-3 Districts 1. In all instances where a lot in a R-4, B-1 B-3, B-5, IN-1 or IN-2 district abuts a lot in a R-1, R-2 or R-3 district: a. A buffer shall be established between the districts in compliance with section Error! Reference source not found.. b. A fifty (50) foot setback shall be provided. 2. Where lot in a B-3, B-5, IN-1 or IN-2 district is on the same block as a residential district, the front and exterior side setback requirements of the residential district shall apply to the applicable business or institutional district. 3. The buffer and setback requirements of paragraphs (j)1. and (j)2. of this section do not apply when the property within the R-1, R-2 or R-3 district is owned or leased by an institutional use. (k) Industrial Districts Adjacent to Residential Districts 1. In all instances where a lot in an industrial district (I-1, I-2 or I-3) abuts a lot in a residential district (R-1, R-2, R-3 or R-4): a. A buffer shall be established between the districts in compliance with section Error! Reference source not found.. b. There shall be required a one-hundred (100) foot minimum building setback on the lot in the industrial district. 2. Where a lot in an industrial district is on the same block as a residential district, the front and exterior side setback requirements of the residential district shall apply to the applicable industrial district. (l) Private recreational facilities. Private recreational facilities such as swimming pools, tennis courts and basketball courts permitted as accessory uses located on residentially zoned land, shall not be located in any front yard and shall have the following setbacks: 1. If accessory to a single-household use or duplex, the edge of the facility shall be located not less than five (5) feet from any lot line. 23 2. If accessory to a residential use other than a single-household residence or duplex, the edge of the facility shall be located not less than twenty (20) feet from any lot line. 3. Any private recreational facility with above ground lighting shall comply with minimum setback requirements for the principal structure in the applicable location. 4. In the event that a lighted facility is located less than fifty (50) feet from any lot line, it shall be screened pursuant to section Error! Reference source not found. (Error! Reference source not found.). (m) Dedicated Street as Portion of Required Buffer. When a dedicated street separates two (2) districts requiring additional setbacks, one fourth (1/4th) of the width of the dedicated right-of-way may be deducted from the required setback. That this ordinance shall become effective upon its adoption. Adopted: Certified: Interim Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: November 10, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 12 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Enterprise Zone Boundary Adjustment KEY ELEMENTS: _X_Economic Development ___Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Approve amendments to Virginia Enterprise Zones #2 and #46 to encompass the areas delineated on the maps entitled “Enterprise Zone Amendment, Zone # 2” and “Enterprise Zone Amendment, Zone #46.” SUMMARY: Enterprise Zones are geographically specific areas established by the Commonwealth of Virginia to provide incentives for businesses to locate or expand, stimulating economic development within the designated areas. Lynchburg has two Enterprise Zones designated by the Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD) as # 2 and #46. Commercial and industrial businesses located in one of the City’s Enterprise Zones may be eligible to apply for two grant programs offered by Virginia DHCD – a real property improvement grant and a job creation grant. In 2019, twelve businesses located in the City of Lynchburg’s two Enterprise Zones received $1,175,524 in cash grants for real property improvements and for job creation from the Virginia Department of Housing and Community Development. Zone boundaries are eligible for amendment upon approval of City Council and DHCD. Under the state’s regulations, the zone size is limited to 7% of the locality’s total land area. Currently, Zone #2 is 6.94% and Zone #46 is 6.87%. In order to add additional acreage, the Office of Economic Development & Tourism works closely with the Department of Information Technology’s Geographic Information Systems Division to find residential or government-owned property where the zone designation provides no benefit. The parcels identified for proposed deletion – 3525 John Capron Road (LCS Transportation Facility) and 331 Chapel Lane (vacant land with access limitations) – are both publicly owned. In order to accomplish this amendment, City Council is required to conduct a public hearing regarding the proposed amendments. Enterprise Zone designation has no impact on land use regulation. PRIOR ACTION(S): Boundaries of zones #2 and #46 were amended in FY2015. Zone #46 was re-designated in 2016. FISCAL IMPACT: The zones may positively impact tax receipts as business growth and expansion is incentivized in newly designated areas. Grant funds flow from the Commonwealth of Virginia to the recipient business. The Director of Economic Development & Tourism is the Local Zone Administrator but no local outlay is required. CONTACT(S): Marjette Upshur, 434-455-4492 ATTACHMENT(S): Map showing existing zone #2, proposed deletion, and proposed expansion; Map showing existing zone #46, proposed deletion, and proposed expansion. REVIEWED BY: klw 148A RESOLUTION: BE IT RESOLVED That the Lynchburg City Council endorses the removal of areas “2-S2” from the City of Lynchburg, Virginia Enterprise Zone #2 and the addition of areas “2-A15“through “2-A21” to the City of Lynchburg Virginia Enterprise Zone #2 as shown on the map entitled Enterprise Zone Amendment Zone #2. BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the Lynchburg City Council endorses the removal of area “46- S1” from the City of Lynchburg, Virginia Enterprise Zone #46 and the addition of areas “46-A1” through “46-A14” to the City of Lynchburg, Virginia Enterprise Zone #46 as shown on the map entitled “Enterprise Zone Amendment, Zone 46. Adopted: November 10, 2020 Certified: ____________________________ Interim Clerk of Council COMMERCE ST FLORIDA AVE LINKRD MARTINST CANDLERS M OUNTAIN RD GRACE ST BEDFORDAVE PARK AVE WADSWORTH ST LANGHORNE LN SANDUSKY DR CARROLL AVE COURT ST CABELLST HUDSON ST STADIUM RD OLDFORESTRD CAMPBELL AVE LANGHORNE RD MURRELLRD THOMASRD ELDON ST HOLLINS M ILLRD PAWNEE DR UNIVERSITYBLVD TATE SPRINGS RD GREENWOODDR LONG M EADO W S DR MAYFLOWER DR LINKHORNEDR CRANEHILL DR REUSENSRD POPLAR ST PERRYMONTAVE IGLOEDR ALLEGHANYAVE EUCLID AVE W ARDS FERRYRD AUTUMN DR D ST OAKRIDGEBLVD 14TH ST 15TH ST FEDERAL ST MOORMANS RD HILL ST ROBINSRDOAKLEYAVE SHEFFIELD DR MADISON ST EDGEWOOD AVE CLAY ST SUSSEX ST WYTHE RD VES RD WINS TONRIDGE RD CONCORD TPKE WINCHESTER ST FORTAVE MAIN ST LANGHORNE RD LAKESIDE DR CAMPBELL AVE FORTAVE M EM ORIALAVE RIVERMONT AVE 12TH ST KEMPER ST CHURCH ST W ARDS RD W ARDS RD 5TH ST BOONSBORO RD ODDFELLOWSRD LYNCHBURG EXPY RICHMOND HWY 460 HWY Zone 46Zone 46 Zone 2Zone 2 DISCLAIMER: THIS MAP IS NEITHER A LEGALLY RECORDED MAP NOR A SURVEY AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED AS SUCH. THE INFORMATION DISPLAYED IS A COMPILATION OF RECORDS, INFORMATION, AND DATA OBTAINED FROM VARIOUS SOURCES. THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ITS ACCURACY OR HOW CURRENT IT MAY OVERVIEW MAP FFIRSTIRST L LYNCHBURGYNCHBURG I INDUSTRIALNDUSTRIAL P PARKARK µ Proposed Enterprise Zone #2 Acreage 2211.16 23.34 ac. 2212.70 ac. 10.71 ac. ENTERPRISE ZONE AMENDMENT ZONE #2 - MAP 1 CURRENT BOUNDARY PROPOSED SUBTRACTIONS PROPOSED ADDITIONS CORPORATE LIMIT 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 Miles Proposed Addition: A15 Proposed Addition: A16 Proposed Addition: A17 Proposed Addition: A19 Proposed Addition: A18 Proposed Addition: A20 Proposed Addition: A21 Proposed Subtraction: S2 FFIFTHIFTH S STT R REVITALIZATIONEVITALIZATION A AREAREA AARTS ANDRTS AND C CULTURALULTURAL D DISTRICTISTRICT CCENTRALENTRAL B BUSINESSUSINESS D DISTRICTISTRICT Main Map City of Lynchburg: 10/21/2020 LINKRD CANDLERS M OUNTAIN RD BEDFORDAVE LANGHORNE LN SANDUSKY DR CARROLLAVE GRAVES MILL RD STADIUM RD LANGHORNE RD MURRELLRD THOMASRD HOLLINSM ILLRD PAWNEE DR GREENWOODDR MOREVIEW DR LONGM EADOW S DR CRANEHILL DR REUSENS RD GREENVIEWDR W ARDSFERRY RD PERRYMONTAVE LEESVILLERD IGLOEDR ALLEGHANYAVE EUCLID AVE ALTA LN AUTUMN DR OLD GRAVES M ILL RD MOORMANSRD HILL ST BUCKINGHA M DR MELINDA DR OAKLEYAVE SHEFFIELD DR WIGGINGTONRD EDGEWOOD AVE VES RD SUSSEX ST MCCONVILLE RD ENTERPRISEDR FOREST BROOKRD INDIANHILLRD WYNDALE DR BURNTBRIDGERD MAYFLOW ER DR FORTAVE OLD FORESTRD 12TH ST LAKESIDE DR RIVERMONT AVE FORT AVE MEMORIALAVE PFC DESMOND T DOSS M EM ORIAL EXPY BOONSBORO RD 5TH ST TIMBERLAKERD W ARDS RD PARK AVE LYNCHBURGEXPY 460 HWY LAKESIDE DR Zone 46Zone 46 Zone 2Zone 2 DISCLAIMER: THIS MAP IS NEITHER A LEGALLY RECORDED MAP NOR A SURVEY AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED AS SUCH. THE INFORMATION DISPLAYED IS A COMPILATION OF RECORDS, INFORMATION, AND DATA OBTAINED FROM VARIOUS SOURCES. THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ITS ACCURACY OR HOW CURRENT IT MAY OVERVIEW MAP FFIRSTIRST L LYNCHBURGYNCHBURG I INDUSTRIALNDUSTRIAL P PARKARK µ 0 0.25 0.5 0.75 1 Miles Proposed Addition: A8 Proposed Addition: A11 Proposed Addition: A1 Proposed Subtraction: S1 Main Map City of Lynchburg: 10/21/2020 Proposed Addition: A2 Proposed Addition: A3 Proposed Addition: A4 Proposed Addition: A5 Proposed Addition: A6Proposed Addition: A7 Proposed Addition: A9 Proposed Addition: A10 Proposed Addition: A12 Proposed Addition: A14 Proposed Addition: A13 MMILLILL R RIDGEIDGE I INDUSTRIALNDUSTRIAL P PARKARK IIVYVY C CREEKREEK IINNOVATIONNNOVATION P PARKARK TTOMAHAWKOMAHAWK I INDUSTRIALNDUSTRIAL P PARKARK LLYNCHBURGYNCHBURG C CENTER FORENTER FOR TTECHNOLOGYECHNOLOGY Proposed Enterprise Zone #46 Acreage 2205.11 57.10 ac. 2176.39 ac. 28.38 CURRENT BOUNDARY PROPOSED SUBTRACTIONS PROPOSED ADDITIONS CORPORATE LIMIT ENTERPRISE ZONE AMENDMENT ZONE #46 - MAP 1 1 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: November 10, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 13 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Rename a portion of Hillcrest Drive KEY ELEMENTS: _ _Economic Development ___Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _ X Safe Community __Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the renaming of a portion of Hillcrest Avenue to be renamed Caroline Street. SUMMARY: The City of Lynchburg is petitioning to rename a portion of public right-of-way named Hillcrest Avenue as Caroline Street for E911 purposes. The name change will alter the address of one (1) private undeveloped property and one (1) city-owned undeveloped property. Presently, the street name changes from Caroline Street to Hillcrest Avenue in the middle of the street. Once approved, the street will instead change names at the intersection of Hillcrest Avenue and Page Street. PRIOR ACTION(S): October 13, 2020: The Physical Development Committee (PDC) reviewed this item and recommended approval. September 9, 2020: Planning Commission reviewed the item and had no concerns. August 18, 2020: The Technical Review Committee (TRC) reviewed the petition. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A CONTACT(S): Victoria Glasgow, Neighborhood Planning Coordinator – 455-3900 Tom Martin, City Planner – 455-3900 ATTACHMENT(S): o Resolution o October 13, 2020 PDC packet o Physical Development Committee Agenda Summary – October 13, 2020 o Proposed Resolution o Planning Commission Report – September 9, 2020 o Planning Commission Minutes – September 9, 2020 o Map o Application REVIEWED BY: klw 146A RESOLUTION: A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE RENAMING OF THE EXISTING PUBLIC STREET LOCATED BETWEEN PAGE STREET AND CAROLINE STREET, CURRENTLY NAMED HILLCREST AVENUE, AS CAROLINE STREET. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG that the name of an existing public street located between Page Street and Caroline Street, currently named Hillcrest Avenue, be and the same is hereby changed as follows:  The portion of Hillcrest Avenue located between Page Street and Caroline Street is changed to Caroline Street. The name of the public street is hereby changed as depicted on the attached map, dated July 29, 2020. Adopted: November 10, 2020 Certified: _____________________________ Interim Clerk of Council 1 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 13, 2020 Physical Development Committee AGENDA ITEM #: CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Rename a portion of Hillcrest Drive KEY ELEMENTS: _ _Economic Development ___Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _ X Safe Community __Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the renaming of a portion of Hillcrest Avenue to be renamed Caroline Street. SUMMARY: The City of Lynchburg is petitioning to rename a portion of public right-of-way named Hillcrest Avenue as Caroline Street for E911 purposes. The name change will alter the address of one (1) private undeveloped property and one (1) city-owned undeveloped property. Presently, the street name changes from Caroline Street to Hillcrest Avenue in the middle of the street. Once approved, the street will instead change names at the intersection of Hillcrest Avenue and Page Street. PRIOR ACTION(S): September 9, 2020: Planning Commission reviewed the item and had no concerns. August 18, 2020: The Technical Review Committee (TRC) reviewed the petition. FISCAL IMPACT: N/A CONTACT(S): Victoria Glasgow, Neighborhood Planning Coordinator – 455-3900 Kent White, Community Development Director – 455-3900 ATTACHMENT(S): o October 13, 2020 PDC packet o Resolution o Planning Commission Minutes – September 9, 2020 o Map o Application REVIEWED BY: RESOLUTION: A RESOLUTION APPROVING THE RENAMING OF THE EXISTING PUBLIC STREET LOCATED BETWEEN PAGE STREET AND CAROLINE STREET, CURRENTLY NAMED HILLCREST AVENUE, AS CAROLINE STREET. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG that the name of an existing public street located between Page Street and Caroline Street, currently named Hillcrest Avenue, be and the same is hereby changed as follows: • The portion of Hillcrest Avenue located between Page Street and Caroline Street is changed to Caroline Street. The name of the public street is hereby changed as depicted on the attached map, dated July 29, 2020. Adopted: November 10, 2020 Certified: _____________________________ Clerk of Council The Department of Community Development City Hall, Lynchburg, VA 24504 434-455-3900 To: Planning Commission From: Planning Division Date: September 9, 2020 Re: Renaming of a portion of what is currently Hillcrest Avenue to Caroline Street I. PETITIONER City of Lynchburg Property Owner: Public Right-of-Way (City of Lynchburg) II. PURPOSE The purpose of the renaming is for E911 purposes and to create continuity with the street name, which currently changes midway. Renaming the proposed section will allow for future subdivisions and new parcels to be properly addressed without duplicate or confusing assignments. Technical Review Committee. The Technical Review Committee (TRC) reviewed the petition on August 18, 2020. Comments have or will be addressed prior to final subdivision approval. III. ATTACHMENTS 1. Street Renaming Application 2. Diagram showing section of street to be renamed 5 b) Consideration of renaming a portion of a street from Hillcrest Avenue to Caroline Street. Ms. Victoria Glasgow, Neighborhood Planning Coordinator, provided the following summary to the Commission. This is a proposition to rena me a portion of Hillcrest Avenue to Caroline Street. There is going to be development in the area and for E911 purposes and continuity the entire street will be named Caroline Street. Again, this is before the Commission for comment. Chair Rogers noted that the section to be renamed was originally built to connect the two sections. Commissioner Bowden stated that this makes perfect sense to him and he wishes it was more common in Lynchburg. Commissioner Perault stated that this brings to mind the urban legend that the streets were named after old cow trails. The Commissioners offered no further comment or concerns. c) Consideration of naming the streets in the Fleetwood Drive Subdivision. Ms. Victoria Glasgow, Neighborhood Planning Coordinator, provi ded the following summary to the Commission. This is a consideration to name the streets in the Fleetwood Drive subdivision. Again, this is protocol and for addressing purposes and is before the Commission for comment. Chair Rogers stated that he had no issue with the street names. The Commissioners offered no further comment or concerns. d) Consideration of naming a new street Stables Lane in the Randolph Stables Subdivision. Ms. Victoria Glasgow, Neighborhood Planning Coordinator, provided the follow ing summary to the Commission. This is a consideration to name a new street Stables Lane and is before the Commission for comment. Chair Rogers stated that he likes the street name. The Commissioners offered no further comment or concerns. 5. Upcoming Meetings: The next regular meeting will be Wednesday, September 23, 2020. 6. Adjournment: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 4:28 p.m. ATTEST:_____________________________________ATTEST:__________________________ ________ City Planner Chair Rogers Service Layer Credits: City of Lynchburg - GIS Local Historic District State National Historic Disctrict Streets Addresses Legal Lot Lines Vacated Right of Way Ingress Egress Prescriptive Private Road Stream Restoration Other Parcels Owner Undetermined Survey Gap Assessed By County µ DISCLAIMER: THIS MAP IS NEITHER A LEGALLY RECORDED MAP NOR A SURVEY AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED AS SUCH. THE INFORMATION DISPLAYED IS A COMPILATION OF RECORDS, INFORMATION, AND DATA OBTAINED FROM VARIOUS SOURCES. THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ITS ACCURACY OR HOW CURRENT IT MAY BE. PRINTED ON July 29, 2020 0 50 100 ft 1 inch = 50 feet 1:600 Portion to be renamed Caroline Street APPLICATION FOR THE RENAMING OF _________________________Hillcrest Avenue_________________________  (Current street name) LOCATED BETWEEN ___________________Caroline Street and Page Street___________________  The undersigned applicant, Bonnie Svrcek, pursuant to the provisions of Section 24.1-6 of the City Code, 1959, as amended, respectfully makes application to the City of Lynchburg for the naming of Caroline Street, formerly known as Hillcrest Avenue. The applicant further requests the Lynchburg Planning Commission to review and provide comment to the City Council on the proposed street naming request in Lynchburg, Virginia on September 9th, 4:00 p.m., or as soon thereafter as the matter may be heard. Given under my hand this 30 th day of July, 2020. Bonnie Svrcek Applicant signature  900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 Address  434-455-3990 Telephone number  LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: November 10, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 14 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: 2021 General Assembly Legislative Agenda KEY ELEMENTS: _X_Economic Development _X_Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community _X_Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Review and Adopt the Fiscal Year 2021 Legislative Agenda SUMMARY: On October 27, 2020, City Council reviewed recommended revisions to the City’s Legislative Agenda for the upcoming General Assembly session. City Council requested the following revisions to the proposed language: - Add a statement opposing unfunded mandates from state government - Add a statement requesting that the General Assembly revise the City Charter to eliminate the salary cap for Lynchburg City Council members. - Add a statement advocating for General Assembly action to improve early childhood education Additionally, the Vice Mayor recommends the following additions to the City’s legislative agenda based on the Virginia First Cities Legislative Agenda: - Add language supporting additional options for the City to address blighted properties - Add language supporting a comprehensive governmental effort to improve broadband access and affordability - Add language supporting revising the Aid to Localities with Police Departments funding formula to more adequately address the challenges faced by urban police departments - Add language supporting measures to assist local government to reduce their carbon footprint and promote energy efficiency These revisions are in addition to the following revisions that were generated by City staff: - Updated language regarding recommendations for the improvement of commercial air service development - Removal of language requesting changes to the Virginia’s Region 2000 Airport Authority Act, since it was not successful in the last year - Updates to the Economic Development section to more accurately reflect the present economic development environment - Addition of language in support of continued state tourism funding - Addition of language requesting the repeal of the requirements for Economic Development Authority members to file financial disclosure forms - Added language to request that the General Assembly revise the Lynchburg Parking Authority’s terms from five years to three years - Updated language regarding the impact of changes in legislation that could eliminate Machinery and Tools and/or Business License taxes - Updated and reorganized section on Drinking Water, Water Quality, and the Environment to better reflect the current present regulatory environment - Updated language to the binding arbitration section opposing any language that would amend the City’s choice as to their participation in collective bargaining or binding arbitration. Additionally, oppose repeal of Virginia’s right to work law - Addition of language opposing any preclearance of changes to voting laws or practices, such as changing the City’s wards and polling places - Addition of language opposing the removal of qualified immunity for local law enforcement officers - Updates to the short-term rental language to reflect the current state of short term rentals in Virginia localities PRIOR ACTION(S): n/a FISCAL IMPACT: To be determined CONTACT(S): Reid A. Wodicka, Interim City Manager, 455-3990 Walter Erwin, City Attorney, 455-3973 ATTACHMENT(S): Draft 2021 Legislative Agenda (with and without annotations); Resolution REVIEWED BY: raw 147A RESOLUTION: BE IT RESOLVED that the Lynchburg City Council adopts its 2021 Legislative Agenda and directs the Clerk of Council to forward it to the City’s General Assembly delegation for information and action, as appropriate Adopted: November 10, 2020 Certified: _________________________________ Interim Clerk of Council CITY OF LYNCHBURG 20201 LEGISLATIVE AGENDA Adopted October 22, 2019 The City of Lynchburg 20201 Legislative Agenda is meant to highlight those issues of particular importance to the City. The Lynchburg City Council asks that legislators keep the following principles in mind as they evaluate and vote on legislation and the budget. PRINCIPLES • Local governments are instruments of the state, created in large measure to deliver state responsible services in a more efficient and effective manner. This state/local partnership requires an equitable allocation of costs between the two levels of government and across the various jurisdictions of the Commonwealth. • The state must continue to meet constitutional and statutory responsibilities to adequately fund the state share of state/local services, especially in education, human services, and public safety. Any shortfall in state revenues should not be shifted to local governments. • When the state experiences or anticipates a budget surplus, due to either increased revenues or reduced expenditures, it should relieve localities of funding responsibilities that have been shifted to them for state mandated/locally delivered serves. • Rather than shifting responsibilities for programs that the state is unwilling to fund down to the localities, the state should consider eliminating those programs. • The state should explore ways to increase the efficiency and effectiveness of the delivery of state services at the local level including the regionalization of service delivery (e.g. Social Services) and the elimination of inefficient structures such as the Compensation Board. • The General Assembly should defeat proposed legislation that would erode local taxing authority, cap or reduce local revenue sources or that would impose unfunded mandates on localities. • The General Assembly should support legislation that provides greater authority to localities in implementing sustainability initiatives especially with regard to land use and transportation planning. • The General Assembly should preserve local zoning and land use authority, allowing flexibility to meet the needs of individual communities. • The General Assembly should defeat all efforts to impose unfunded mandates on localities. Unfunded mandates from state government are an abdication of state responsibility and limit localities’ ability to perform their own core responsibilities. Comment [RW1]: Date will change Formatted: Font color: Auto, Character scale: 100% Formatted: Normal, No bullets or numbering Formatted: Left, Indent: Left: 0.87", Hanging: 0.23", Right: 0", Line spacing: single, No bullets or numbering, Tab stops: Not at 0.34" 20201 LEGISLATIVE PRIORITIES Airport: The impact of the Coronavirus pandemic on Virginia’s commercial service airports has been unprecedented in the history of the aviation industry. As a result, the City supports: • Increased funding for the “Governor’s New Airline Service Incentive Fund” as passed by the General Assembly during its 2019 session (SB 990). This legislation created a special non-reverting fund to be used at the discretion of the Governor for grants to airlines serving commercial service airports in Virginia. The fund is intended to provide or assist in the marketing, advertising and promotional activities by airlines in connection with the launch of new airline service, and to provide incentives to airli nes as part of such new service. • Increasing commercial service airport entitlement funding under the Commonwealth Aviation Program (CAF). This initiative, adopted by the Virginia Airport Board (VAB) September 17, 2020, is designed to assist airports in moving forward capital projects during this time that would otherwise be cancelled or deferred, as well as allow those airports to use entitlement funds for operating expenses. • Funding a new marketing program, adopted by the VAB September 17, 2020, aimed at maximizing the state-wide potential to create jobs in travel and tourism. This would be accomplished by working together with the various Commonwealth agencies and public/private-sector partners to support grants to communities to promote available airline service and build consumer confidence in air transportation. Amend the Virginia’s Region 2000 Airport Authority Act (“Act”) to allow the City of Lynchburg by itself or with the governing bodies of one or more counties of Amherst, Appomattox, Bedford and Campbell by resolution declare there is a need for an airport authority to be created for the purpose of establishing or operating an airport for such participating political subdivision(s). In addition support other changes to the Act as necessary t o support the creation of the Airport Authority. Blighted Properties: The General Assembly should amend the Code of Virginia to allow cities to transfer blighted properties directly to a land bank created by the City or an existing nonprofit in lieu of sale at public auction for unpaid real estate taxes. This ability is provided to several Virginia cities and should be applied to all cities. Additionally, the General Assembly should adjust the qualifying criteria for localities that are authorized to treat blighted properties and derelict structures as a separate property class for local taxation of real property so that all l Virginia cities have the ability to do so. Broadband: The General Assembly should create a concerted governmental effort to ensure broadband coverage that is both available and afford able to the most in need. Particularly in low income neighborhoods, a lack of broadband coverage and affordability has far -reaching implications for K-12 education and lifelong learning. Children's Services Act (CSA): CSA funding continues to be a serious concern. Actions taken by the General Assembly have increased mandated services and shifted costs to the localities. The General Assembly should refrain from adding additional mandated services and should fund its full share of the CSA program. Comprehensive Poverty Reduction: Support continued funding of the Community Wealth Building state matching fund which partners with local programs that target intract

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.