City Council Regular Meeting — Minutes
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Jul 1, 2020 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
AGENDA ITEM#: 10
July 1, 2020
1
// A special meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg, was held on the 1st day of July, 2020, at
10:00 A.M. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Robin Craig, Clerk of Council, presiding. The purpose of
the meeting was to elect City Council officers. The following members were present:
Present: Jeff S. Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, Treney Tweedy, MaryJane Dolan, Sterling Wilder,
Beau Wright, Chris Faraldi 7
Absent: 0
// The Clerk of Council declared nominations were in order for the Office of President of Council, who will
serve as ex-officio Mayor of the City of Lynchburg for a two-year term ending June 30, 2022.
Councilmember Nelson nominated Councilmember Tweedy.
Councilmember Helgeson nominated Councilmember Nelson.
Councilmember Tweedy nominated Councilmember Dolan.
Discussion over the merits of each nominee ensued. Councilmember Nelson commented on the many
successes and achievements of the City of Lynchburg over the years, but made note of our recent unique
and problematic challenges. He continued by citing the impending retirement of City Manager Bonnie
Svrcek and noted the lack of time to fully acclimate the next City Manager. He nominated Councilmember
Tweedy because she is an experienced Mayor who will be an asset to a new City Manager. He
commended her leadership during the public health emergency and recent civil un rest that befell the City,
and spoke of her acclaimed positive presence in the community.
Councilmember Helgeson spoke of the merits of his nomination, Councilmember Nelson. In its recent
past, City Council has lacked a certain unity, brought on by spirited debate and reactionary rejoinders
from its members. He cited Councilmember Nelson’s calm demeanor and bipartisanship as being strong
qualities that are well suited for the leadership role as Mayor.
Councilmember Tweedy discussed Councilmember Dolan’s experiences that qualify her as Mayor,
including: her longtime Lynchburg, Virginia, residency; her 40+ years of being an entrepreneur and a
business owner, which provide community investment; and planting herself firmly as a veteran leader
AGENDA ITEM#: 10
July 1, 2020
2
within the City. Councilmember Tweedy further discussed Councilmember Dolan’s time spent avidly
volunteering within the community, and spoke highly of her ability to listen to all citizens.
With there being no further nominations, City Council cast their votes by written ballot. Alicia L. Finney,
Administrative Associate, received the written ballots and read them aloud, as follows:
Councilmember Wright voted for Councilmember Dolan
Councilmember Nelson voted for Councilmember Tweedy
Councilmember Wilder voted for Councilmember Dolan
Councilmember Tweedy voted for Councilmember Dolan
Councilmember Faraldi voted for Councilmember Nelson
Councilmember Helgeson voted for Councilmember Nelson
Councilmember Dolan voted for Councilmember Dolan
Clerk of Council Craig announced that Council Member Dolan was elected President of City Council.
// Mayor Dolan, who began presiding over the meeting, declared nominations were in order for the Office
of Vice President of Council, who will serve as ex-officio Vice Mayor of the City of Lynchburg for a two-
year term ending June 30, 2020.
Councilmember Wilder nominated Councilmember Beau Wright
Councilmember Helgeson nominated Councilmember Nelson
Councilmember Wilder discussed Councilmember Wright’s assets for candidacy for Vice Mayor. As an at-
large member, Councilmember Wright has served on City Council for the past two years and often brings
a young perspective to issues. A native to the Lynchburg area, he is a supporter of the community and of
the education system. Councilmember Wright has prior experience in federal government and has an
extensive background in government finance. He is a proven leader and his service to the community is
admirable making him an asset to the municipality as Vice Mayor.
AGENDA ITEM#: 10
July 1, 2020
3
Councilmember Helgeson discussed the merits of Councilmember Nelson not ing that for the reasons he
thought him a strong candidate for Mayor, hold true of his nomination for Vice Mayor. He wanted to add
that a good balance between Mayor and Vice Mayor is prudent and Councilmember Nelson, in
conjunction with the new Mayor, would be able to contribute to that equilibrium.
With there being no further nominations, City Council cast their votes by written ballot. Alicia L. Finney,
Administrative Associate, received the written ballots and read them aloud, as follows:
Councilmember Wilder voted for Councilmember Wright
Councilmember Tweedy voted for Councilmember Wright
Mayor Dolan voted for Councilmember Wright
Councilmember Nelson voted for Councilmember Wright
Councilmember Wright voted for Councilmember Wright
Councilmember Helgeson voted for Councilmember Nelson
Councilmember Faraldi voted for Councilmember Nelson
Clerk of Council Craig announced that Councilmember Wright has been elected Vice President of City
Council.
// Council discussed Agenda Item #2, to amend, readopt, and reaffirm Council’s Rules of Procedu res. Mr.
Erwin, City Attorney, made a presentation to Council explaining that state law dictates that at its
Organizational Meeting, Council must adopt its regular meeting schedule for the upcoming calendar year.
Since Council’s schedule of meetings is set forth in Council’s Rules of Procedure, Council readopts its
rules and procedures to reaffirm its meetings for the upcoming year. The other item for consideration is
the possibility of amending its rules and procedures that require a twelve-hour notice be given in order to
call a special meeting. This topic was originally discussed at the June 18, 2020 Special Meeting. State
law and the Freedom of Information Act allows Council to call special meetings as Council deems
necessary, and there is no requirement in state code or in the Freedom of Information Act that any
specific notice has to be given in a special meeting other than a notice as reasonable under the
circumstances. During the past few months, Council felt the need to call several special meetings in order
to deal with pressing issues that require Council to get together and for those special meetings it wasn’t
AGENDA ITEM#: 10
July 1, 2020
4
always possible to give twelve hours of advance written notice in order to call the meeting. Council’s rules
and procedures stated purpose is to allow Council to conduct its business in an efficient and orderly
manner and is not intended to make it more difficult for the governing body to carry out its duties. The
rules and procedures citing a twelve-hour notice was first added to the City Code in the year 1931, at
which time there were no other means but written notice. The Freedom of Information Act, which
regulates special meetings, was not in existence at that time. The issue of not giving proper notice of a
special meeting continues to come up on a number of occasions, so it has been offered for Council’s
consideration that Council’s rules and procedures be amended to state that while an effort will be made to
give a twelve-hour advance notice of a special meeting, twelve hours of advance notice is not required
and that the notice that will be given will be one that is reasonable given the circumstances. Mr. Erwin
stated that this language is aligned with the Freedom of Information Act for giving notice of a special
meeting of a governing body.
Councilmember Helgeson stated that since Council’s rules and procedures were adopted over a decade
ago that he can appreciate wanting to update them to be consistent with present day. However, all three
special meetings that were called into order recently could have been done so with a minimum of a
twelve-hour notice. He continued, stating that changing these rules and procedures raises a lot of
questions; Council is a deliberative body and not one that governs with an iron fist. Each Councilmember
is an elected representative of the citizens and decisions should not be made hurriedly without giving the
constituents proper time to weigh in. He compared the June 1, 2020 Special Meeting when the curfew
was first discussed, versus the June 3, 2020 Special Meeting when the same issue was discussed but
proper notice was given. Councilmember Helgeson cited that Council Chamber was filled with concerned
citizens; the same people that Council represents. Having these particular rules and procedures in place
regarding the bare minimum of a twelve-hour notice allows for Council to hear from its constituents and
actually think through all of the potential negative ramifications of any decisions being made.
Councilmember Helgeson continued stating ample time is prudent for Council to consider the issues and
learn of the thoughts of the citizens Council represents. For example, Juneteenth has been on the
calendar for many years and had Council talked about making Juneteenth an official Holiday during any
AGENDA ITEM#: 10
July 1, 2020
5
regularly scheduled meeting where all positions could have thoughtfully been considered, he would have
voted in favor. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to keep these rules and procedures as is.
Councilmember Faraldi seconded the motion citing the importance of City Council’s first action in the new
fiscal year, be one that helps keep constituents informed. He continued by stating that he would also be in
favor of amending the language to include electronic means of a notice, such as tex t messages or an
email message. He also stated that he would be in favor of a shorter timeframe than twelve hours, but
since the motion on the floor is to keep the rules and procedures as it currently states, he will second and
support the motion.
Councilmember Wilder made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Tweedy, to adopt the
amended rules and procedures as they are written. Councilmember Wilder said that these meetings were
called to save our City due to the public health crisis and the civil unrest. Both events were emergencies
that were currently happening and required a response from City Council. The Chief of Police and the
City Manager advised City Council during the special meetings on how to best protect the citizens during
both emergencies and Council should feel comfortable taking their direction. Councilmember Tweedy
echoed his sentiments, citing public safety and safeguarding business investment as Council’s priorities.
Councilmember Nelson prefaced his statements by saying his comments are not directed to the specific
meetings that were just called, rather are broader and deal with specific issues such as due process and
equal protection of law. The problem that was presented to Council when the special meetings were
called was that there was a specifically described period of time that Council had to deal with before they
could call a special meeting. On advice of the City Attorney, Council was directed that there was
opportunity to wave the rules and procedures. However, in order to wave the rules and procedure, there
needed to be a lawful meeting at which there is a quorum to wave those rules and procedures.
Councilmember Nelson continued, stating that if there needed to be a twelve-hour notice, then he
questioned whether the meeting held to wave the twelve-hour notice was even valid meeting. Council
then resolved that concern the following meeting held on June 3, 2020 by giving proper notice; however,
there could be some other situation in the future that Council will need to conduct a special meeting.
AGENDA ITEM#: 10
July 1, 2020
6
Councilmember Nelson would like Council to have some finding before any other emergency special
meeting occurs. Councilmember Nelson made the friendly amendment to the substitute motion on the
floor to include the following guidelines: in order to hold a special meeting, a majority of the members of
City Council who are physically present at the special meeting must agree that uncommon or unexpected
conditions justify holding a special meeting without at least twelve hours advance notice. Vice Mayor
Wright supports Councilmember Nelson’s friendly amendment.
The first item of business is to vote whether Councilmember Wilder’s substitute motion with
Councilmember Nelson’s friendly amendment becomes the main motion.
Councilmember Helgeson respectfully disagrees with Councilmember Wilder’s sentiments stating
especially during an emergency, Council needs to take time to think through its actions and cautioned
against being reactionary. With no further discussion, the following recorded vote was conducted, and the
motion passed:
Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5
Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2
// The substitute motion became the main motion and it became appropriate to vote on the rules and
procedures as it has been discussed. According to state law, Council must readopt their rules and
procedures at its organizational meeting to set forth the calendar for the next year. Mr. Erwin offered to
work on the new language of the rules and procedures and insert it into the resolution. The motion
passed by the following recorded vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Wright, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder 5
Noes: Helgeson, Faraldi 2
// In the matter of Parking, Agenda Item #3, Mr. Dave Malewitz, Director of Parking Management, briefly
discussed Council’s options for a parking permit. Council has the option to include a rearview mirror
hanging tag, a window decal, or provide Parking Management with their make/model/license plate
AGENDA ITEM#: 10
July 1, 2020
7
number for Parking Enforcement to have programmed into their systems. Councilmembers decided that
they would prefer the latter option.
// The meeting was adjourned at 10:55 a.m.
____________________________
Interim Clerk of Council
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.