RecordWell Data

City Council Work Session and Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Jun 9, 2020 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 GENERAL POLICY REGARDING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AT CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS Each speaker shall clearly state his or her name and locality of residence. The City Council agenda is divided into four sections. CONSENT AGENDA: This section includes routine items. All items may be approved by one vote. PUBLIC HEARINGS: This section includes all public hearings as required by law or as Council may direct. Procedure: • Staff will make a presentation. • For zoning petitions, the applicant or his or her representative shall have ten (10) minutes to make a presentation. • Comments will then be solicited from those in favor. • Comments will then be solicited from those in opposition. During the public hearing, there shall be a time limit of three (3) minutes for each individual speaker. If the speaker represents a group, there shall be a time limit of five (5) minutes. A speaker representing a group shall identify that group at the beginning of his or her remarks. A group may have only one spokesperson. After public comments have been received, for zoning petitions, the applicant or the representative of the applicant, at his or her discretion, may respond with a rebuttal. There shall be a five (5)-minute time limit for rebuttal. Upon the conclusion of public comments or the applicant’s rebuttal, the public hearing will be closed and the matter referred to Council for deliberation. PUBLIC COMMENT: Public comment shall be for the purpose of allowing members of the public to present any matter, which, in their opinion, deserves the attention of the Council. They shall not serve as a forum for debate with the Council. Individuals may speak up to three (3) minutes; or group spokesperson up to five (5) minutes. Once Council has heard a presentation from a citizen or organization on a particular subject, the citizen or organization may not make another presentation on the same subject within three (3) months of the first presentation, except by a majority vote of the members of Council present and voting. GENERAL BUSINESS: This section includes items of a general nature to be considered by Council. City Council may make exceptions to these rules at its discretion. Prior to a meeting, any questions which citizens may have regarding any item on the agenda may be addressed to City Council or the City Administration. The following numbers are provided for the convenience of the citizens: CITY COUNCIL 455-3995 MAYOR 455-3995 CITY MANAGER 455-3990 A reasonable charge may be made for copying and other activities related to responding to long and involved inquiries. CITIZENS OFTEN EXPRESS CONFLICTING AND DIVERSE POSITIONS REGARDING SPECIFIC ISSUES UNDER CONSIDERATION. TO ENCOURAGE CITIZEN PARTICIPATION AND TO AVOID INTIMIDATION TO PERSONS WHO MAY EXPRESS SOMETIMES UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, APPLAUSE, CHEERS, OR JEERS FROM THE AUDIENCE ARE NOT PERMITTED. WHEN APPEARING BEFORE CITY COUNCIL, CITIZENS MAY NOT ENGAGE IN BEHAVIOR THAT INTIMIDATES OR INSULTS OTHERS, ENGAGE IN DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOR, USE PROFANITY OR VULGAR LANGUAGE, PROMOTE PRIVATE BUSINESS VENTURES OR CAMPAIGN FOR PUBLIC OFFICE. * PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED AND/OR CONSIDERED BY CITY COUNCIL Physical Development Committee - canceled A G E N D A City Council Meeting of June 9, 2020 4:00 P.M. – Work Session #1. Review and discussion of the draft Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (AI) #2. Receive an update on the status of brush and bulk collection during the COVID-19 pandemic #3. Update to the revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources #4. Roll Call 7:30 P.M. City Council Agenda Items COUNCILMEMBER PERROW GIVE THE INVOCATION C O N S E N T A G E N D A #5. Consideration of approving the minutes of the May 26, 2020 meeting 2 #6.* Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-20-033 approving the submission of Substantial Amendment #2 to the Fiscal Year (FY) 2020 (Program Year [PY] 2019) Annual Action Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program to the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD); and amend the FY 2020 Community Development Block Grant budget with resources of $420,487 from the Community Development Block Grant Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES ACT) (CDBG-CV) Program Funds #7.* Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-20-034 to amend the FY 2020 General Fund Ambulance Service Fees budget and appropriate $116,677 with resources from the 2020 Coronavirus Aid, ` Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES) Stimulus Act Provider Relief Fund to offset loss of revenue related to COVID-19 transports. #8.* Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-20-035 amending the FY 2020 Stormwater Operating Fund budget and appropriate up to $59,755 with resources from the North American Association for Environmental Educators (NAAEE) – National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) 21st Century Community Learning Center Watershed STEM Education Partnership Grant. P U B L I C H E A R I N G S #9. Petition of RNR of Virginia (Jonathan Rose) for a Conditional Use Permit in a B-3, Community Business District to operate a tire store in an existing building at 3139 Old Forest Road. (File: Community Development) #R-20-037 #10. Petition of Centra Health (Joe Archambeault) for a Conditional Use Permit in an R -C, Conservation District and R-4, High Density Residential District to allow fill within the 100 Year Floodplain to facilitate improvements to the Summit Lake Spillway at 1400 & 1700 Enterprise Drive. (File: Community Development) #R-20-038 #11. Consideration of adopting a resolution to authorize the City to contract a debt and issue General Obligation Public Improvement Bonds of the City (the “Bonds”) in the principal amount not to exceed $42,000,000 to finance the costs of the acquisition, construction, reconstruction, improvement, extension, enlargement, equipping, rehabilitation and repair of various public improvement projects of and for the City (including related design and architectural and engineering services and underwriting compensation and other costs of issuance of such Bonds), including, but not limited to acquisition of fleet vehicles, transportation projects, airport improvement projects, water system improvement projects, school improvement projects, sewer system improvement projects, construction, renovation and improvements to various City buildings, parks and recreation projects, economic development projects, and stormwater improvement projects (collectively, the “Projects”). The Resolution will also authorize the City to issue its general obligation public improvement bond anticipation notes of the City, if any, in an amount not to exceed $42,000,000 in order to provide short-term financing for the Projects in anticipation of the issuance of the Bonds and to reduce the annual debt service requirements of the City (File: Budget) #R-20-039 #R-20-040 #12. Consideration of adopting a resolution to authorize the City to contract a debt and issue sewer revenue bonds of the City in the principal amount not to exceed $1,500,000 to finance the costs of reconstruction of a permitted Combined Sewer Overflow (CSO) regulator structure within the City’s combined sewer system, a revenue producing undertaking of the City, such capital improvements constituting wastewater treatment facilities within the meaning of Title 62.1 224 of the Code of Virginia, 1950. (File: Budget) #R-20-041 #12a. Continuation of Public hearing to receive input from citizens regarding appointments (or reappointments) to vacancies that will exist June 30, 2020, in School Districts I, II, and III 3 P U B L I C C O M M E N T #13. Hear from a citizen (Hermina Hendricks) G E N E R A L B U S I N E S S #14. First Reading on the Adoption of the FY 2021 Budget Resolutions. A: Consideration of introducing a Resolution adopting the FY 2021 General Fund Operating Budget (excluding External Service Providers and Component Units expenditures) and appropriating $194,398,344 for this budget. #R-20-042 B: Consideration of introducing a Resolution adopting the FY 2021 Mandated and Contractual External Service Providers Budget and appropriating $8,192,056 for this budget. #R-20-043 C: Consideration of introducing a Resolution adopting the FY 2021 Discretionary External Service Providers Budget and appropriating $29,401 for this budget. #R-20-044 D: Consideration of introducing a Resolution adopting FY 2021 Operating Fund Budgets for other funds and appropriating the sums of each fund. #R-20-045 E: Consideration of adopting a Resolution amending the FY 2021 – 2025 Capital Improvement Program Budget. #R-20-046 F: Consideration of introducing a Resolution adopting the FY 2021 Capital Budget and appropriating $15,169,570 for the City Capital Projects Fund, $3,053.,086 for the Schools Capital Projects Fund, $1,400.000 for the Airport Capital Projects Fund, $3,560,000 for the Water Capital Projects Fund, $8,030,000 for the Sewer Capital Projects Fund, and $880,000 for the Stormwater Capital Projects Fund. #R-20-047 G: Consideration of introducing a Resolution appropriating $50,000 of the FY 202 1 Reserve for Contingencies funding for use by the City Manager for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2021. #R-20-048 H: Consideration of adopting a Resolution in accordance with Section 58.1-3524 of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended, to set the personal property tax relief rate for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2021 at 41.98%. #R-20-049 I: Consideration of adopting an ordinance to amend and reenact Sections 34-12.1 of the Code of the City of Lynchburg, 1981, as amended, the amended sections relating to sewer rates #O-20-013 #15. Discuss City Code Section 27-29, Relating to the Declaration of Curfews in Times of Emergency (File: City Council) #O-20-014 #16. Consideration of approving an ordinance confirming the City Manager’s Declaration of and Institution of a Curfew in the City of Lynchburg. (File: Budget) #O-20-015 #17. Consideration of selecting the date for the City Council Organizational Meeting (File: City Council) 4 #18. a. Consideration of a closed meeting to consider prospective candidates for the position of City Manager pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia and b. Consideration of a closed meeting to discuss appointments to the following boards, commissions or committees: City Employee Appeals Board, Economic Development Authority, Historic Preservation Commission, Martin Luther King/Lynchburg Community Council, Local Emergency Planning Committee, Metropolitan Planning Organization, Museum Advisory Board, Virginia First Cities Policy Committee and Youth Services Citizens Board LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: June 9, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 1 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Review and Discussion of the draft Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (AI) KEY ELEMENTS: _X_Economic Development ___Excellent Government _X_ Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _X_ Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Review and discussion of the draft Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (AI) SUMMARY: As a recipient of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Investment Partnerships Program funds, the City must certify to the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) that its housing programs are implemented in a non-discriminatory manner. The AI includes an analysis of public and private sector policies, programs and statutes which impact the development, financing, regulation and siting of housing in the City. The City has identified within the AI: (a) impediments to fair housing choice; and (b) recommended strategies that would eliminate the impediments to housing choice. The previous AI was prepared in January 2014. It is required by HUD that the City perform an AI typically once every five (5) years in conjunction with the Five-Year Consolidated Plan. A draft AI has been prepared for the City by the professional consulting team at Mullin & Lonergan Associates (M&L). M&L followed a comprehensive approach to complete the AI utilizing many different data sources, City documents, and specifically conducted interviews and focus group sessions with agencies and organizations that provide housing and housing related services to members of the protected classes. On December 17 and 18, 2019 M&L conducted several Stakeholder Workshops at The Miller Center with key community stakeholders to hear their thoughts and observations on fair housing in our community. These public meetings encompassed workshops on affordable housing, workforce development, housing for individuals and families in crisis, asset building in low-to-moderate income neighborhoods, and healthy housing and healthy neighborhoods as they related to not only the development of the AI but also the 2020-2024 Five- Year Consolidated Plan for the CDBG and HOME Program. At the work session on June 9th, M&L staff will provide a presentation summarizing the AI. A required public hearing will be held at the regular City Council meeting on June 23rd to provide the public one final opportunity to comment on the AI. At the conclusion of the public hearing, City Council will be asked to adopt a resolution endorsing the AI and approving the submittal of the final document, with any recommended changes from the public and/or City Council, to HUD. PRIOR ACTION(S): December 17 and 18, 2019 – Stakeholder Public Meetings FISCAL IMPACT: None CONTACT(S): Melva Walker, Grants Manager, 455-3916 Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager, 455-3987 Kevin Henry, Zoning Administrator, 455-3915 ATTACHMENT(S): Draft Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (AI) PowerPoint Presentation - Mullin & Lonergan Associates REVIEWED BY: bms 064R 2020 ANALYSIS OF IMPEDIMENTS TO FAIR HOUSING CHOICE Lynchburg, Virginia Draft for Public Display May 2020 1 Table of Contents Executive Summary .........................................................................................................................................8 Introduction ..................................................................................................................................................... 15 Background .................................................................................................................................................................. 15 Purpose of the Analysis of Impediments ............................................................................................................. 16 The Relationship between Fair Housing and Affordable Housing ............................................................... 17 The Federal Fair Housing Act .................................................................................................................................. 17 Recent Changes to HUD Program Regulations ................................................................................................. 17 Methodology used for the AI .................................................................................................................................. 18 Public Engagement .................................................................................................................................................... 18 Progress Achieved since 2015 AI .............................................................................................................. 20 Data Analysis .................................................................................................................................................. 53 Demographic Profile .................................................................................................................................................. 53 Population Trends.................................................................................................................................................. 53 Concentrations of Persons Ages 18 – 24 ......................................................................................................... 55 Race and Ethnicity.................................................................................................................................................. 60 Racial Segregation Patterns ................................................................................................................................ 65 Race/Ethnicity and Income .................................................................................................................................. 69 Racial and Ethnic Minority Concentration Areas of Poverty ...................................................................... 70 Educational Attainment and Income ................................................................................................................ 76 Disability and Income ........................................................................................................................................... 77 Family Status and Income.................................................................................................................................... 80 Ancestry and Income ............................................................................................................................................ 82 2 Protected Class Status and Unemployment ...................................................................................................84 Housing Market .......................................................................................................................................................... 85 Housing Inventory ................................................................................................................................................. 85 Types of Housing Units ........................................................................................................................................ 85 Vacancy Status ........................................................................................................................................................ 90 Protected Class Status and Homeownership ................................................................................................. 93 The Tendency of Protected Classes to Live in Larger Households .......................................................... 95 Cost of Housing ...................................................................................................................................................... 97 Cost-Burden .......................................................................................................................................................... 103 Communities of Opportunity ................................................................................................................................ 106 Prosperity Index .................................................................................................................................................... 107 Labor Market Engagement Index .................................................................................................................... 108 Job Access Index .................................................................................................................................................. 109 Transit Access Index ............................................................................................................................................. 110 Community Health Index .................................................................................................................................... 111 School Proficiency Index ..................................................................................................................................... 112 Public Sector Policy Analysis ..................................................................................................................... 113 City of Lynchburg 2013-2030 Comprehensive Plan ........................................................................................ 114 Zoning Risk Assessment .......................................................................................................................................... 117 Local Building Codes ............................................................................................................................................... 120 Anti-Displacement Plan and Relocation Plan ................................................................................................... 122 LRHA Tenant/ Applicant Demographics ............................................................................................................ 124 3 CDBG/HOME Investments ..................................................................................................................................... 126 Assisted Housing Location Patterns .................................................................................................................... 128 Location of Major Employers and Employment Opportunities ................................................................... 132 Public Transit .............................................................................................................................................................. 134 Language Access Plan ............................................................................................................................................ 136 Lending Discrimination ........................................................................................................................................... 137 Fair Housing Profile ..................................................................................................................................... 139 Fair Housing Laws .................................................................................................................................................... 139 Fair Housing Complaints ........................................................................................................................................ 139 Office of Fair Housing & Equal Opportunity ................................................................................................ 140 Virginia Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation ...................................................... 140 Summary of Impediments .........................................................................................................................142 Fair Housing Action Plan ........................................................................................................................... 144 4 Table of Figures Figure 1 Change in Population, 2000 – 2017 ........................................................................................................... 53 Figure 2 Change in Population since 1970 in Lynchburg and the State of Virginia ..................................... 53 Figure 3 Racial and Ethnic Composition, 2010 - 2017 ...........................................................................................64 Figure 4 Dissimilarity Index, Lynchburg 2017 .......................................................................................................... 67 Figure 5 Dissimilarity Index, Lynchburg 2010 .......................................................................................................... 67 Figure 6 Change in Dissimilarity Index, 2010-2017 ................................................................................................. 68 Figure 7 Median Income and Rates of Poverty by Race and Ethnicity, Lynchburg 2017 ............................ 69 Figure 8 Educational Attainment and Income (Age 25 or Older), Lynchburg 2017 ..................................... 76 Figure 9 Disability Type in Population Over Age 18, Lynchburg 2017 ............................................................. 78 Figure 10 Elderly Population (Age 65 or Older) Disability Type, Lynchburg 2017 ........................................ 78 Figure 11 Employment Status for Individuals by Disability Status, Lynchburg 2017 ...................................... 79 Figure 12 Median Income and Poverty Rates by Disability Status, Lynchburg 2017 .................................... 79 Figure 13 Household Type and Presence of Children, Lynchburg 2010 – 2017 ............................................ 81 Figure 14 Most Common Languages Spoken Among Individuals with Limited English Proficiency, Lynchburg 2015 ............................................................................................................................................................... 83 Figure 15 Civilian Labor Force, 2017 ...........................................................................................................................84 Figure 16 Total Housing Units, Lynchburg 2010 – 2017 ........................................................................................ 85 Figure 17 Trends in Housing units in Structures, Lynchburg 2017 ..................................................................... 89 Figure 18 Housing Units by Structures and Housing Type, Lynchburg 2017 .................................................. 89 Figure 19 Change in Vacancy Status, Lynchburg 2010 – 2017 ............................................................................ 90 Figure 20 Housing Tenure by Race and Ethnicity, Lynchburg 2017 ................................................................. 93 Figure 21 Large-Family Households (4 persons or more) by Race / Ethnicity, Lynchburg 2010 .............. 95 Figure 22 Housing Units by Number of Bedrooms and Tenure, Lynchburg 2017 ....................................... 96 Figure 23 Trends in Median Home Value, Rent, and Household Income, Lynchburg 2010-2017 ........... 97 Figure 24 Housing Costs in the City of Lynchburg and State of Virginia, ...................................................... 115 Figure 25 City of Lynchburg, VA Assessment of Fair Housing .......................................................................... 119 5 Figure 26 Tenant Demographics – Black and Hispanic Households .............................................................. 124 Figure 27 Tenant Demographics – Disability and Elderly Status ..................................................................... 125 Figure 28 Mortgage application outcomes by race/ethnicity, 2015-2017 ..................................................... 138 Figure 29 Rate of high cost loan originations by race/ethnicity, 2015-2017 ................................................. 138 Figure 30 High cost loan originations by income level by race, 2015-2017 ................................................. 138 Figure 31 DPOR Complaints by Basis of Alleged Discrimination, 2014-2019 ................................................ 140 Figure 32 DPOR Complaint Investigation Findings, 2014-2019 ......................................................................... 141 Figure 33 Contributing Factors Impeding Housing Choice in Lynchburg, VA ............................................ 143 6 Table of Maps Map 1 Population Change, 2010-2017 ...................................................................................................................... 55 Map 2 Concentration of persons ages 18 to 24 years-old, 2017 ....................................................................... 57 Map 3 Nonwhite and/or Hispanic Population ........................................................................................................ 61 Map 4 R/ECAPs ............................................................................................................................................................... 71 Map 5 Homeownership Rate, 2017 ............................................................................................................................ 87 Map 6 Percentage of housing units as multifamily rental units, 2017 .............................................................. 88 Map 7 Homeowner Vacancy Rates, 2017 ................................................................................................................. 91 Map 8 Rental Vacancy Rates, 2017............................................................................................................................. 92 Map 9 Black Homeownership Rate, 2017 .................................................................................................................94 Map 10 Median Household Income, 2017 ................................................................................................................ 98 Map 11 Median Home Value, 2017 ............................................................................................................................. 99 Map 12 Change in Median Home Value, 2017 ..................................................................................................... 100 Map 13 Median Gross Rent, 2017 .............................................................................................................................. 101 Map 14 Change in Median Gross Rent, 2010-2017 .............................................................................................. 102 Map 15 Cost-burdened Homeowners .................................................................................................................... 104 Map 16 Cost-burdened Renters ................................................................................................................................ 105 Map 17 Composite Opportunity Index.................................................................................................................... 106 Map 18 Prosperity Index .............................................................................................................................................. 107 Map 19 Labor Market Engagement Index .............................................................................................................. 108 Map 20 Job Access Index ........................................................................................................................................... 109 Map 21 Transit Access Index ....................................................................................................................................... 110 Map 22 Community Health Index ............................................................................................................................. 111 Map 23 School Proficiency Index .............................................................................................................................. 112 Map 24 CDBG and HOME Investments .................................................................................................................. 127 Map 25 Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority’s Public Housing Inventory, 2020 ............ 129 7 Map 26 Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Autho rity’s Section 8 Housing Choice Voucher Holders, 2018 .................................................................................................................................................................. 130 Map 27 City of Lynchburg LIHTC Properties, 2018 ............................................................................................... 131 Map 28 Job Access & Assisted Housing ................................................................................................................. 133 Map 29 Transit Access ................................................................................................................................................. 135 8 Executive Summary The City of Lynchburg has prepared an Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice to satisfy requirements of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974, as amended. This act requires that any community receiving Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and Home Investment Partnership Program (HOME) funds affirmatively further fair housing. Additionally, HUD entitlement communities must comply directly with HUD rules and regulations designed to uphold the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974, as amended. The responsibility of compliance with the federal Fair Housing Act extends to nonprofit organizations and other entities, including units of local government, which receive federal funds through the City. Entitlement communities that receive CDBG and HOME funds are required to:  Examine and attempt to alleviate housing discrimination within their jurisdiction  Promote fair housing choice for all persons  Provide opportunities for all persons to reside in any given housing development, regardless of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, or national origin  Promote housing that is accessible to and usable by persons with disabilities, and  Comply with the non-discrimination requirements of the Fair Housing Act. These requirements can be achieved through the preparation of an Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (AI). The AI is a review of a jurisdiction’s laws, regulations, and administrative policies, procedures, and practices affecting the location, availability, and accessibility of housing, as well as an assessment of conditions, both public and private, affecting fair housing choice. Entitlement communities have specific fair housing planning responsibilities. These include:  Conducting an Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice  Developing actions to overcome the effects of identified impediments to fair housing, and  Maintaining records to support the jurisdictions’ initiatives to affirmatively further fair housing. The following observations wer e noted throughout the AI. These issues are based on the primary research collected and analyzed and the numerous interviews and focus group sessions conducted for this report. They help to establish context for the impediments to fair housing choice. 9  Between 2000 and 2017 Lynchburg grew by 21.4%, adding 13,968 new residents. This is slightly faster than the State of Virginia, which grew by 18.2% during the same time period. Relative comparisons between Lynchburg and Virginia are provided to potentially h ighlight features unique to Lynchburg.  As a city that hosts several colleges and universities, college-aged students comprise a substantial portion of the city’s population . Approximately 22.2% of the city’s total population consists of undergraduate and graduate students and will likely have a strong impact on the City’s rental market.  However, population growth appears to be decentralized in Lynchburg in areas further away from downtown. These areas tend to have higher levels of opportunity for residents in terms of jobs, quality schools, and environmental health.  Racially and ethnically concentrated areas are concentrated around the downtown area. These areas have a population that consists of 50% or more minorities.  There exists a gap in income and weal th between White and minority households that is exacerbated by the concentration of minority neighborhoods that have lower levels of opportunity. This gap is especially prominent in between White and Black households.  In Lynchburg, 14.2% of the population over the age of 18 years old had at least one disability. Of individuals with a disability, 33.5% were living in poverty compared to 21.7% without a disability. Additionally, most individuals with a disability do not participate in the labor force (64.9%) , reducing their ability to afford housing.  Family households comprise 58.3% of all households in Lynchburg in 2017. This is lower than that of the State of Virginia, in which family households consist of 66.9% of all households. This is likely a result of the high student population in Lynchburg.  The majority of Lynchburg’s housing stock in 2017 was single-family housing units which comprised 65.6% of all housing units, but only 49.7% of these units were owner-occupied. Multi- family housing can be a more affordable housing option that provides members of the protected classes access to other parts of the City that are otherwise unaffordable. 10  Lynchburg has a slightly higher vacancy rate than the State with the highest rental vacancy rates is concentrated around the University of Lynchburg and Liberty University. Vacancy is determined if no one is living in a specific unit at the time of the interview, indicating that the student population may play a contributing factor to this.  While home values in Lynchburg decreased by 3.8% after adjusting for inflation, gross rent increased by 11.5% during the same time period.  In Lynchburg, 35.5% of all households are cost -burdened, and renters (49.4%) are more disproportionately cost-burdened than homeowners (19.8%). Areas with a high proportion of cost-burdened homeowners also tend to have cost-burdened renters as well. These areas are centered around the University of Lynchburg  The highest opportunity areas in Lynchburg are concentrated in the western parts of the City and the lowest opportunity areas are found around the HUD -defined R/ECAP and the modified R/ECAPs west of Downtown Lynchburg.  Under HUD’s definition of racially/ethnically concentrated areas of poverty, only one census tract meets this definition: Census Tract 7. HUD defines concentrations of racial and ethnic minorities as a census tract with a non-White population of 50% or more. A concentrated area of poverty is defined as a census tract with 40% or more individuals living at or below the poverty line.  There is one less census tract that no longer meets both HUD’s R/ECAP definition and the modified R/ECAP definition: Census Tract 19. The poverty rate in this census tract decreased from 37.5% in 2013 to 28.8% in 2017, indicating that opportunities for residents in this area have improved since the previous AI.  Two census tracts meet the definition for modified R/ECAP: Census Tracts 6 and 11. While these areas do not meet the 40% poverty threshold defined by HUD these census tract s show disproportionate poverty rates compared to Lynchburg as a whole and may require attention for improving opportunity. The modified R/ECAPS are located adjacent to the HUD R/ECAP. A summary of the impediments to fair housing choice that emerged from t he data analysis, public engagement initiatives, and policy review were identified. They are the results of primary and secondary 11 research that define the underlying conditions, trends, and context for fair housing planning in Lynchburg. The impediments were assigned three priority levels based on the amount and strength of the supporting evidence that initially identified the factor:  High – factors that limit or deny fair housing choice or access to opportunity, as well as other factors that are urgent or establish a foundation for future actions  Medium – moderately urgent or building on prior actions  Low – limited impact on fair housing issue Figure 1 Contributing Factors Impeding Housing Choice in Lynchburg, VA Factor Priority Responsible Parties Discussion Access to community assets and opportunities High City Community assets such as public transit and jobs can improve access to opportunities, especially for lower income households and persons with disabilities. While the City has good coverage regarding public transit in R/ECAPs, these areas have poor access to the City's employment centers and higher performing schools. Expanding the public transit system to higher opportunity areas could increase opportunities for low- and moderate-income residents. Location and type of affordable housing High City, LRHA, Private Sector Providing more housing choices in more areas across the City could increase the accessibility and affordability of housing in Lynchburg. While households in Lynchburg are almost evenly split between renters and homeowners, most of the housing stock consists of single-family homes at 65.6% of all housing stock. Multifamily housing is typically more affordable than single-family housing in the same area as a result of increased housing supply and efficient land use. However, multifamily housing options are limited in both the highest opportunity areas and lowest opportunity areas. Additionally, areas with a high concentration of multifamily units are in close proximity to the universities, creating high competition for housing. While the City has shown to be investing funds, such as CDBG and HOME, in higher opportunity areas, the lack of public transit access and landlords to accept HCVs are barriers in locating affordable housing options in higher opportunity areas. 12 Factor Priority Responsible Parties Discussion Discriminatory behavior toward members of the protected class Low Private Sector Lending discrimination exists within the City of Lynchburg. Because this lending primarily occurs in the private sector, the City has little direct control. However, the City could continue to provide education and outreach to lenders and borrowers regarding fair housing and lending discrimination, in addition to the organizations advocating for fair housing. Black and Hispanic households are more likely to have their mortgage application denied than White households. Black households were also more likely to receive high-cost loans compared to other races/ethnicities. High cost loans have higher interest rates, making housing less affordable and contributes to both segregation and cost burden. Households receiving high cost loans will seek more affordable housing in lower quality housing stock and be more cost-burdened due to high interest rates. 13 The Fair Housing Action Plan included below contains recommendations based on the identified factors impeding, or restricting, fair housing choice for Lynchburg residents: Impediment Action Measurable Benchmarks Timeframe Barriers to housing choices for members of the protected class The City should specify procedures, training, and monitoring process for implementing the Language Access Plan (LAP) to streamline services and better accommodate persons with limited English proficiency (LEP). This is especially important for when the LEP Spanish- speaking population reaches the safe harbor threshold. Percent of current and number of new staff members trained in accordance with LAP procedures 2020-2024 Location and type of affordable housing LRHA should expand Section 8 HCV Program to higher opportunity areas. Number of landlords recruited to participate in Section 8 program, especially in higher opportunity areas Ongoing The City and other local organizations should address the diverse housing needs for the City's various subpopulation, including students, low- and moderate-income households, persons with disabilities, and elderly persons. Continue investing in housing in a wide geographic area throughout the City. Number of accessible units created/rehabilitated. Ongoing The City should collaborate with local universities to ensure students are not competing with low- and moderate-income households for housing. Number on-campus housing units created. Ongoing 14 Impediment Action Measurable Benchmarks Timeframe Location of community assets The City should collaborate with GLTC to improve access to GLTC routes in higher opportunity areas and employment centers in the City and for individuals working unconventional hours. Number of transit stops added Ongoing The City and local service providers should centralize public services in locations with good transit access and high concentration of members of protected classes Increase in number of service users Ongoing Discriminatory behavior toward members of the protected class The City should continue supporting fair housing services, such as housing counseling from Lyn- CAG and legal counseling from VLAS, to reduce rates of eviction, mortgage application denials, high-cost lending, and other discriminatory practices. Number of program participants Ongoing 15 Introduction Background Equal and unimpeded access to residential housing is a fundamental civil right that enables members of protected classes, as defined in the federal Fair Housing Act, to pursue personal, educational, employment, or other goals. Because housing choice is so critical to personal development, fair housing is a goal that government, public officials, and private citizens must embrace if social equity is to become a reality. The federal Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination in housing based on a person’s race, color, religion, gender, disability, familial status, or national origin. In addition, the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Devel opment (HUD) issued a Final Rule on February 3, 2012 that prohibits entitlement communities, public housing authorities, and other recipients of federal housing resources from discriminating on the basis of actual or perceived sexual orientation, gender identity, or marital status. Persons who are protected from discrimination by fair housing laws are referred to as members of the protected classes. HUD awards funds from the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), HOME Investment Partnership, Housing Opportunities for Persons with AIDS (HOPWA), and Emergency Solutions Grant (ESG) programs directly to eligible municipalities of a certain size. As a grantee of HUD funding, the City of Lynchburg has specific fair housing planning responsibilities including:  Conducting an Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice  Developing actions to overcome the effects of identified impediments to fair housing, and  Maintaining records to support initiatives to affirmatively further fair housing HUD interprets these three certifying elements to include:  Analyzing housing discrimination in a jurisdiction and working toward its elimination  Promoting fair housing choice for all people  Providing racially and ethnically inclusive patterns of housing occupancy  Promoting housing that is physically accessible to and usable by all people, particularly individuals with disabilities 16  Fostering compliance with the nondiscrimination provisions of the Fair Housing Act Purpose of the Analysis of Impediments The Housing and Community D evelopment Act of 1974 requires that any community receiving HUD funds affirmatively further fair housing. Communities receiving HUD entitlement funds are required to:  Examine and attempt to alleviate housing discrimination within their jurisdiction  Promote fair housing choice for all persons  Provide opportunities for all persons to reside in any given housing development, regardless of race, color, religion, gender, disability, familial status, or national origin  Promote housing that is accessible to and usable by persons with disabilities, and  Comply with the non-discrimination requirements of the Fair Housing Act. These requirements can be achieved through the preparation of an Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (AI). An AI is a review of a j urisdiction’s laws, regulations, and administrative policies, procedures, and practices affecting the location, availability, and accessibility of housing. It is also an assessment of conditions, both public and private, affecting fair housing choice. This AI will:  Evaluate population, household, income, and housing characteristics by protected classes  Evaluate public and private sector policies that impact fair housing choice  Identify blatant or de facto impediments to fair housing choice where any may ex ist, and  Recommend specific strategies to overcome the effects of any identified impediments. An impediment to fair housing choice is defined as any action, omission, or decision that restricts or has the effect of restricting the availability of housing choices of members of the protected classes. This AI serves as the basis for fair housing planning; provides essential information to policy makers, administrative staff, housing providers, lenders, and fair housing advocates; and assists in building public support for fair housing efforts. The City is expected to review and approve the AI and use it for direction, leadership, and resources for future fair housing planning. The AI will serve as a point-in-time baseline against which future progress in implem enting fair housing initiatives will be evaluated and recorded. 17 The Relationship between Fair Housing and Affordable Housing To the extent that members of the protected classes tend to have lower incomes, then access to fair housing is related to affordabl e housing. In many areas across the U.S., a primary impediment to fair housing is a relative absence of affordable housing. Often, the public policies implemented in towns and cities can contribute to the lack of affordable housing in these communities, th ereby disproportionately affecting housing choice for members of the protected classes. The Federal Fair Housing Act The Federal Fair Housing Act covers most housing. In some circumstances, the Act exempts owner - occupied buildings with no more than four un its, single family housing sold or rented without the use of a broker, and housing operated by organizations and private clubs that limit occupancy to members. In the sale and rental of housing, no one may take any of the following actions based on race, c olor, religion, gender, disability, familial status, or national origin:  Refuse to rent or sell housing  Refuse to negotiate for housing  Make housing unavailable  Deny a dwelling  Set different terms, conditions, or privileges for the sale or rental of a dwelling  Provide different housing services or facilities  Falsely deny that housing is available for inspection, sale, or rental  Persuade owners to sell or rent at a loss (“blockbusting”)  Deny anyone access to or membership in a facility or service (such as a multiple listing service) related to the sale or rental of housing Recent Changes to HUD Program Regulations On March 5, 2012, HUD implemented policies to ensure that its core programs are open to all eligible individuals and families regardless of sexual orientation, gender identity, or marital status. In response to evidence suggesting that lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender individuals and families were being arbitrarily excluded from housing opportunities in the private sector, HUD’s aim was to ens ure that its 18 own programs do not allow for discrimination against any eligible person or household, and that HUD’s own programs serve as models for equal housing opportunity. This change to HUD program regulations does not amend the Fair Housing Act to pro hibit all discrimination in the private market on the basis of sexual orientation, gender identity, or marital status. However, it prohibits discrimination of those types by any housing provider who receives HUD funding, including public housing agencies, those who are insured by the Federal Housing Administration (including lenders), and those who participate in federal entitlement grant programs through HUD. Methodology used for the AI A comprehensive approach was used to complete the Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice for the City of Lynchburg. The following sources were utilized:  The most recently available demographic data regarding population, household, housing, income, and employment at the census tract and municipal level  Public policies affecting the siting and development of housing  Administrative policies concerning housing and community development  Financial lending institution data from the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (HMDA) database  Agencies that provide housing and housing related services to members of the protected classes  Fair housing complaints filed with HUD  Interviews and workshop sessions conducted with agencies and organizations that provide housing and housing related services to members of the protected classes Public Engagement An extensive Outreach Plan was carried out jointly for the City’s Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice, the 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan and the 2020 Annual Action Plan . Across all outreach initiatives, the most frequently cited needs include the following:  Affordable housing o Adequate funding at federal and state levels to develop more affordable housing and provide more rental assistance o Adequate supply of affordable housing to meet the demand in urban and rural areas o Support for affordable housing from local, regional and state officials o Affordable housing accessible to people with disabilities  Fair housing 19 o Support from local officials for all types of affordable housing, including emergency housing and permanent housing o Education for landlords o Education for tenants on rights and responsibilities o Education for the public o Fair housing enforcement  Community development o Affordable transportation, including public transit with frequent service and service for second and third shift workers o Workforce development o Other supportive services to keep individuals and families housed —substance abuse treatment, case management, childcare 20 Progress Achieved since 2015 AI Lynchburg’s last Analysis of Impediments was completed in 2015. The 2015 document identified a total of 14 impediments to fair housing choice. Each impediment and associated recommendations from the 2015 AI are listed below, along with a summary of the progress the City has made. Progress on goals was provided by the City and based on the City’s annual Consolidated Annual Performance Evaluation Reports (CAPER). Impediment (City) Status The City’s subsidized housing units and affordable HOME housing activities are located primarily in older neighborhoods near the Central Business District that are more likely to be impacted areas (i.e. Black concentrated areas of poverty and low-moderate-income areas). Action Step 1: The City should seek to strike a balance between revitalizing RCAPs and LMI areas and creating new affordable housing opportunities in other City neighborhoods. Specifically, the City should update its HOME policies and procedures to incentivize the creation of affordable housing opportunities in higher opportunity neighborhoods. COMPLETE & CONTINUING PY2015: $350,000 of the $686,040 (51%) of CDBG funds were allocated to the City’s Downtown infrastructure project located in Census Tract 5 in which approximately 65% of the residents are LMI persons. All HOME Program funds ($305,985) were allocated for affordable housing projects within the targeted Census Tracts and city-wide based on eligibility criteria. PY2016: $413,867 of the $662,772 (63%) of CDBG funds were allocated to the City’s Downtown infrastructure project and rehabilitation of a public housing complex, located in Census Tracts 5 and 7 in which approximately 83% and 69%, respectively, of the residents are LMI persons. All HOME Program funds ($317,893) were allocated for affordable housing projects within the targeted Census Tracts and city-wide based on eligibility criteria. PY2017: $201,948 of the $300,951 (68%) of HOME Program funds were allocated to the following projects: Vacant Housing Revitalization and Rehabilitation; First- time Homebuyer, and Homeownership development. All projects have provided or will continue to provide affordable housing opportunities in the targeted Census Tracts and city-wide based on eligibility criteria. Lynchburg Regional Housing Collaborative engaged Enterprise Community Partners to conduct a housing stability and economic security study through a 21 Community Impact Grant from VHDA to determine the actual state of housing in Lynchburg. PY2018: $450,412 of the $474,412 (95%) of HOME Program funds were allocated to the following projects: Homeowner rehabilitation; First-time Homebuyer, and Homeownership development. All projects have provided or will continue to provide affordable housing opportunities in the targeted Census Tracts and city- wide based on eligibility criteria. There was $283,548 HOME funds expended for these affordable housing projects. There were four minority-owned business contracts issued for the homeowner rehabilitation projects. Lynchburg Regional Housing Collaborative completed and distributed to the public through the Lynchburg City Council a study “Opportunity Profile: Housing Stability in Lynchburg, VA” through a Community Impact Grant from VHDA. The study stated that there is a need for additional affordable housing units and the relation of these housing needs to LMI persons/households. As a result, City Council is focused on addressing affordable housing and is beginning to discuss with the LRHA what an affordable housing policy would be and resources and options to create and further encourage the development of affordable housing in Lynchburg. The City has also engaged in a variety of initiatives designed to improve the quality of the housing stock while still ensuring attainability and affordably, such as the Real Estate Rehabilitation Program and the Rental Inspection Program. Additionally, the City partnered with a variety of public, private, and non-profit organizations that are dedicated to improving housing opportunities for people who live in Lynchburg. Members of the protected classes tend to experience higher rates of unemployment and have lower incomes, thereby encountering greater difficulty in securing affordable housing in Lynchburg. Action Step 1: Continue to use HOME dollars to fund homebuyer assistance programs. PY2015: $75,000 was provided to Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) to provide homebuyer assistance to eligible persons to write down their mortgage so that the housing units assisted would be 22 COMPLETED & CONTINUING affordable. GLHFH provided down payment assistance to five families. PY2016: GLHFH provided down payment assistance to four families and Lyn-CAG provided down payment assistance to two families. PY2017: $143,890 was provided to Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) and Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG). GLHFH provided down payment assistance to three families and Lyn-CAG provided down payment assistance to three families. PY2018: $208,890 provided to Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) and Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) to provide homebuyer assistance. GLHFH provided down payment assistance to three persons and Lyn-CAG provided down payment assistance to three persons. Of these six persons, household incomes consisted of: one within 50-60% of the Area Median Income (AMI); three within 30-50% of the AMI; and two within 60-80% of the AMI. The racial breakdown included all Black households. Action Step 2: Fund homebuyer counseling for lower income households, particularly minority households. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: The agencies listed below conducted the following classes: Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity: Orientation Classes (2-hour acclimation class) - August 24 and 27, 2015 (80 persons) May 10, 2016 (8 people) June 21, 2016 (40 persons) For the following seven sessions, there were 10 participants with 7 graduates (8 Blacks, 2 NH Whites) Personal Finance – September 28, 2015 Spanish-Speaking Orientation Class in October 2016 (15 persons) Credit and Credit Reporting – October 5, 2015 Developing a Savings and Spending Plan - October 19, 2015 Virginia Fair Housing and Fringe Banking - October 26, 2015 Insurance and Warranties - November 2, 2015 Loan Closing - November 9, 2015 Life as a Homeowner - November 16, 2015 23 Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) staff conducted 12 homebuyer education classes with 11 participants: 9 Blacks (82%) and 2 Whites (18%). There were an additional 112 participants who attended pre- purchase classes that met monthly over the last year to receive homebuying counseling. PY2016: The agencies listed below conducted the following classes: Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity Introduction and Class Creed -September 12, 2016 & April 3, 2017 Personal Finance - September 19, 2016 & April 10, 2017Credit and Credit Reporting - September 26, 2016 & April 24, 2017 Developing a Savings and Spending Plan - October 3, 2016 & May 8, 2017 Virginia Fair Housing and Fringe banking - October 17, 2016 & May 15, 2017 Insurance and Warranties - October 24, 2016 & May 22, 2017 Loan Closing - November 7, 2016 & May 28, 2017 Life as a Homeowner - November 14, 2016 & June 12, 2017 There were 10 participants in these classes, all Black. PY2017: The agencies listed below conducted the following classes: Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity Homebuyers’ Club Fall 2017 – November 12, 2017 through December 4, 2017 (12 hours) Homebuyers’ Club Spring 2018 – May 17, 2018 through June 25, 2018 (12 hours) There were eight participants, all Black. Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG)’s Housing Counseling Services Department assisted individuals with their housing and rental counseling; foreclosure prevention; first-time homebuyer; and fair housing. There were 203 clients served throughout the program year. These clients included 143 Blacks and 60 Whites. Income levels included: <30% of the Area Median Income (AMI)-134; 30-40% of AMI-35; 50-79%- 20; and 80-100% of AMI-14. 24 PY2018: Agencies listed below conducted the following classes and the recipients of the HOME Program funds for homebuyer purchases were provided with home buyer counseling: GLHFH conducted one Homebuyer Class with five Black participants. GLHFH conducted two Warranties, Maintenance, and Closing Counseling Classes with two Black participants. GLHFL conducted an Application Orientation Class with 50 participants including 43 Blacks, two Hispanics and five Whites. Lyn-CAG’s First Time Home Buyers Club had 15 individuals completed the 12-month program. All graduated, six pre-qualified to purchase homes and three purchased homes in Lynchburg. Two are currently looking at real estate purchase options and one purchased in the surrounding county. The three first- time homebuyers were Black and within the 60-80% of the Area Median Income (AMI). Two of the individuals who have prequalified are White and within less than 50% of the AMI and one individual is Black and within 50-80% of the AMI. In addition, Lyn-CAG’s Housing Counseling Services Department assisted individuals with their housing needs; foreclosure prevention; first-time homebuyer; and fair housing. There were 147 clients served throughout the program year. These clients included 89 Black and 57 White and one Asian. The Income levels included: <30% of the Area Median Income (AMI) - 65 persons; 30-40% of AMI - 40 persons; 50-79%-36 persons; and 80-100% of AMI six persons. The City’s supply of decent and affordable housing remains inadequate, and there is a growing mismatch between incomes and housing costs. Action Step 1: Continue the City’s Rental Inspection Program, which is focused in 11 older LMI neighborhoods to improve and preserve the existing affordable housing stock. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: During this program year within the Rental Inspection Program there were 423 cases (homeowner, rental and neighborhood services) brought up to Code compliance. PY2016: There were 413 cases (homeowner and neighborhood services) brought up to code. There were 110 one-year and 847 four-year Certificate of 25 Compliance (COC) waivers issued for rental housing inspections that were conducted and the properties were in compliance with the Virginia Maintenance Code. PY2017: Residential rental properties are located in six rental inspection districts and are inspected periodically to determine if they are being maintained with the City’s minimum building code standards. There were 492 existing residential rental inspections completed and 408 rental inspections completed on new apartment units. PY2018: Residential rental properties are located in six rental inspection districts (Census Tracts 4, 5, 6, 7, 11, and 19) and are inspected periodically to determine if they are being maintained with the City’s minimum building code standards. 1,500 rental inspections completed. Action Step 2: Continue to use HOME dollars to fund homebuyer assistance programs. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: $75,000 provided to Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) to provide homebuyer assistance. Lyn-CAG assisted one homebuyer and included the required homebuyer counseling for the purchase of the housing unit. GLHFH provided down payment assistance to five families. PY2016: GLHFH provided down payment assistance to four families and Lyn-CAG provided down payment assistance to two families. PY2017: $143,890 was provided to Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) and Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) to provide homebuyer assistance. GLHFH provided down payment assistance to three families and Lyn-CAG provided down payment assistance to three families. PY2018: $208,890 was provided to Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) and Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) to provide homebuyer assistance. GLHFH provided down payment assistance to three persons and Lyn-CAG provided down payment assistance to three persons. Of these six persons, the household incomes consisted of: one within 50-60% of the Area Median Income (AMI); three 26 within 30-50% of the AMI; and two within 60-80% of the AMI, all Black households. 27 Although there was an insufficient number of housing discrimination complaints filed in the City to identify significant trends, it was possible to identify a pattern of discriminatory behavior on the basis of disability and race. Action Step 1: Contract with an experienced HUD-certified fair housing organization to perform paired testing for race and disability in rental housing. Utilize the results to file housing discrimination complaints; publicize results to deter future discriminatory behavior. PY2015-PY2017: As of this date, the City has not begun this process. City staff is aware of the requirements and will pursue contacting an agency to conduct this testing. PY2018: City staff requested Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG), a HUD-certified fair housing organization, to provide a cost estimate and timeline for completion of this parity testing. Action Step 2: Contract with an experienced HUD-certified fair housing organization to provide education and outreach on fair housing laws, rights and responsibilities. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: The City provided one percent of its CDBG allocation ($6,800) in Program Year 2014 to Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) to provide education and outreach on fair housing laws, rights, and responsibilities. The following fair housing workshops were conducted by Lyn-CAG staff: May 26, 2016 – Conducted two Workshops: Fair Housing – There were 30 in attendance Lyn-CAG staff provided educational materials regarding fair housing rights/laws Hoarding Workshop: There were 20 persons in attendance and materials provided regarding hoarding and the rights of a hoarder. PY2016: The following fair housing and housing counseling workshops were conducted by Lyn-CAG staff: April 18, 2017 - Fair Housing Certification and Hoarding Workshop – Lead by Mahalia “Mally” Dryden-Mason, Fair Housing Training Specialist, Virginia Department of Professional and Occupational Regulations – 65 participants May 6, 2017 – Women’s Empowerment – Jubilee Family Development Center (Homeownership and Budgeting Session) January 26, 2017 – Community Resource Fair – Point in Time (PIT) Count for Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) – Approximately 50 persons attended the event. PY2017: The following fair housing and housing counseling workshops were conducted by Lyn-CAG: 28 April 24, 2018 – In recognition of “April is Fair Housing Month” – Lyn-CAG staff scheduled a “Tenants’ Rights and Responsibilities” Workshop at the Lynchburg Public Library. Advertisements were placed on five billboards throughout the City of Lynchburg regarding “Fair Housing Month” and citizens’ rights to Fair Housing. PY2018: The following fair housing and housing counseling workshops were conducted by Lyn-CAG: Staff conducted weekly seminars at local rental properties on tenants’ rights and responsibilities. These seminars were conducted at four rental property complexes located in the City. Staff conducted a Landlord Tenant Workshop held at Lyn-CAG in which 15 landlords/tenants attended. In recognition of “April is Fair Housing Month”, Lyn-CAG staff scheduled a “Communicating Fair Housing” Workshop at the Miller Center. Ms. Mahalia Dryden- Mason, Fair Housing Training Specialist, from the Virginia Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation, was the guest speaker. There were 25 individuals in attendance. Lyn-CAG staff partnered with Virginia Legal Aid and conducted a workshop on the new housing related laws being implemented on July 1, 2019. There were 20 people in attendance at this workshop. Lyn-CAG staff had a booth promoting Fair Housing and Rental Counseling at the City’s Day in the Park in June 2019. All five staff members who are housing counselors were recertified in Fair Housing and provide this service to all citizens of Lynchburg. In addition, the City and Lyn-CAG partnered and a Fair Housing Flyer was developed and provided to the City of Lynchburg Utilities Department to be inserted into the April 2019 water utility bills. There were 24,000 Flyers provided and inserted into the water bills. There is a need for improved fair housing services across Lynchburg. Action Step 1: Delegate the City’s Housing Collaborative as the centralized fair housing organization for Lynchburg. PY2015-2016: As recommended in the AI, the Housing Collaborative is the centralized fair housing organization for the City. This Collaborative consist of: City staff 29 COMPLETED & CONTINUING (Grants Manager and Zoning Administrator); Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA); Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG); Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH); Rush Homes; Lynchburg Covenant Fellowship (LCF); and Continuum of Care (CoC) Lead and Co-Leader. During this program year, the Collaborative has met and discussed proposed housing projects related to new construction, redevelopment, and rehabilitation, and the CoC activities for the homeless (permanent supportive housing programs, emergency shelters, and transitional housing). These meetings included conversations to ensure that all affordable housing projects were offered to all persons and that no discriminatory action would be taken against any applicant. See below for the specific planned project to create a “one- stop” shop for all persons seeking housing assistance whether permanent or temporary. PY2017-2018: The Collaborative met and discussed proposed housing projects related to new construction, redevelopment, and rehabilitation, and the CVCoC activities for the homeless (permanent supportive housing programs and emergency shelters). These meetings included conversations to ensure that all affordable housing projects were offered to all persons and that no discriminatory action would be taken against any applicant. Action Step 2: The Housing Collaborative should partner with LRHA to pool fair housing resources, run fair housing training and educational meetings, and improve fair housing compliance citywide. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: There was a project to establish a Housing Resource Center at LRHA. The concept of an Affordable Housing Resource Center is a solution that would bring all housing related resources under one roof to provide citizens of Lynchburg a “one stop shop” for accessing resources to address and solve their housing questions and needs. The Lynchburg Housing Collaborative and Central Virginia Continuum of Care would be partners in this endeavor. LRHA is in the process of developing a job description to staff the Housing Resource Center. PY2016: A Fair Housing Seminar was conducted on April 29, 2017 at the Lynchburg Public Library. There were 13 persons who attended along with staff from the City of 30 Lynchburg, Lynchburg Community Action Group and Virginia Legal Aid. Mr. Jeremy White an attorney with Virginia Legal Aid provided a PowerPoint presentation regarding fair housing rights and responsibilities. Mr. White concluded with providing resources for information regarding the Virginia laws and regulations for Fair Housing. Ms. Denise Crews from Lynchburg Community Action Group provided a presentation on Tenants Rights and Responsibilities. Ms. Crews provided pamphlets and handouts regarding Fair Housing and tenants’ rights and responsibilities. City staff has Fair Housing links on its web page to the HUD Fair Housing Office, Virginia Fair Housing Office, Lyn-CAG Housing Counseling Services, and Virginia Legal Aid Office for housing resources. Go to: www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration PY2017: LRHA hired a Housing Navigator staff person for the Housing Resource Center. The Housing Navigator has met with some of the people and organizations concerned about housing in Lynchburg to discuss challenges of housing quality standards. A recent meeting included representatives from Virginia Legal Aid, Lynchburg Community Action Group, Miriam's House, Central Virginia Continuum of Care and the City of Lynchburg’s Community Development Department. Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG placed advertisements on five billboards throughout the City of Lynchburg regarding “Fair Housing Month” and citizens’ rights to Fair Housing. The Housing Counseling Services Department assisted individuals with housing and rental counseling; foreclosure prevention; first-time homebuyer; and fair housing. There were 206 clients served throughout the program year. City staff has Fair Housing links on its web page to the HUD Fair Housing Office, Virginia Fair Housing Office, Lyn-CAG Housing Counseling Services, and Virginia Legal Aid Office for housing resources. Go to: www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration PY2018: AHRC staff continued to provide housing and supportive services referrals to the respective agencies 31 that could assist the citizens. The LRHA Housing Navigator assists citizens in navigating the vast sea of affordable housing challenges and opportunities in the City. Information, fair housing education and training programs are offered to provide a number of learning tools to assist citizens to be successful obtaining and maintaining stable housing. These programs include: Renter counseling; Homebuyer Counseling; Landlord/Tenant Law training; Energy-Saving Education; Avoiding Eviction guidance; Home Maintenance tips, etc. The Center works with citizens to understand their need, whether immediate or future, and assist them in determining what program/resource best meets their need. The Center is an “information hub” in which all housing providers can report the status of their existing program information and openings. The Center tracks data related to citizens assisted the needs, the income level and the results. The Center plans to provide a computer resource for access to on-line training opportunities, housing location, and a variety of other resources that would assist citizens in obtaining and retaining stable housing. LRHA, the Housing Collaborative and the CVCoC have established a “Housing First” model program within the City of Lynchburg to provide permanent, affordable housing as quickly as possible to persons facing homelessness or assist them in solving challenges they face in their housing status. Diversion programs can prevent eviction and foreclosure when citizens have a central resource that will guide them through the hardships they are facing. The Housing Navigator provided the public, and local organizations, with information regarding housing, local resources for housing, how to apply for numerous services and programs. The AHRC is a "one-stop" shop for housing resources. The AHRC will debut a new web-based software program that will simplify the affordable housing world. LRHA has partnered with UpTop to bring the Authority up to current technology in searching, applying, managing and reporting on 32 available housing in the Lynchburg area. Staff has assisted approximately 415 persons through visits to the AHRC, telephone calls and email. City staff has Fair Housing links on its web page to the HUD Fair Housing Office, Virginia Fair Housing Office, Lyn-CAG Housing Counseling Services, and Virginia Legal Aid Office for housing resources. Go to: www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration 33 Action Step 3: The City should allocate at least 1% of its annual CDBG entitlement grant exclusively to fair housing activities, such as education, outreach, training, and enforcement. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: The City provided one percent of its CDBG allocation ($6,800) in Program Year 2014 to Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) to provide education and outreach on fair housing laws, rights, and responsibilities. This project continued in Program Year 2015. In Program Year 2016 there has been $10,000 allocated to Lyn-CAG to provide fair housing events and housing counseling to prospective homebuyers. PY2016: The City allocated $10,000 of CDBG funds to Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) to provide housing counseling, education and outreach on fair housing laws, rights, and responsibilities. During Program Year 2016 the following fair housing and housing counseling workshops were conducted by Lyn- CAG staff. April 18, 2017 - Fair Housing Certification and Hoarding Workshop – Lead by Mahalia “Mally” Dryden-Mason, Fair Housing Training Specialist, Virginia Department of Professional and Occupational Regulations – 65 participants May 6, 2017 – Women’s Empowerment – Jubilee Family Development Center (Homeownership and Budgeting Session) January 26, 2017 – Community Resource Fair – Point in Time (PIT) Count for Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) – Approximately 50 persons attended the event. PY2017: Five billboards throughout the City regarding “Fair Housing Month” and citizens’ rights to Fair Housing. The Housing Counseling Services Department assisted individuals with housing and rental counseling; foreclosure prevention; first-time homebuyer; and fair housing. There were 206 clients served throughout the program year. PY2018: Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) continued to provide housing counseling, education and outreach on fair housing laws, rights, and responsibilities. The following fair housing and housing counseling workshops were conducted by Lyn-CAG and City staff: 34 Staff conducted weekly seminars at local rental properties on tenants’ rights and responsibilities. These seminars were conducted at four rental property complexes located in the City. Staff conducted a Landlord Tenant Workshop held at Lyn-CAG in which 15 landlords/tenants attended this workshop. In recognition of “April is Fair Housing Month” – Lyn- CAG staff scheduled a “Communicating Fair Housing” Workshop at the Miller Center. This session was well attended and Ms. Mahalia Dryden-Mason, Fair Housing Training Specialist, from the Virginia Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation, was the guest speaker. There were 25 individuals in attendance. On April 27, 2019 Mayor Treney Tweedy had “Storytime with the Mayor” at the Lynchburg Public Library. Children of all ages and families attended this event. Lyn-CAG staff partnered with Virginia Legal Aid and conducted a workshop on the new laws being implemented on July 1, 2019. There were 20 people in attendance at this workshop. Lyn-CAG staff had a booth promoting Fair Housing and Rental Counseling at the city’s Day in the Park in June 2019. All five staff members who are housing counselors were recertified in Fair Housing and provide this service to all citizens of Lynchburg. In addition, the City and Lyn-CAG partnered and a Fair Housing Flyer was developed and provided to the City of Lynchburg Utilities Department to be inserted into the April 2019 water utility bills. There were 24,000 Flyers provided and inserted into the water bills. The Grants Manager placed two advertisements in The News and Advance during April 2019 noting the designation of “April is Fair Housing Month”. The National Fair Housing Alliance developed a social media campaign to assist communities in promoting the 50th Anniversary of the Fair Housing Act, housing discrimination, and general fair housing information. City staff used this campaign information and developed a social media campaign for Lynchburg on 35 fair housing. The postings on the City’s website, Facebook, and Twitter occurred on December 3, 5, 12, 17, 19, and 26, 2018. 36 Action Step 4: The City should formally designate a current employee as the Fair Housing Officer within the Community Development Department to ensure that the HUD entitlement programs are implemented in a non-discriminatory manner. This designee should serve as staff to the Housing Collaborative to advise the Collaborative on fair housing issues. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: The Grants Manager was appointed to serve as the Fair Housing Officer. During Program Year 2015 the Grants Manager did not receive any fair housing complaints. Through the Fair Housing project funded with CDBG funds, workshops were conducted and information was distributed (i.e. posters, brochures, flyers, etc.) to inform the citizens of the opportunities for everyone to have the right to live where they so choose and that no one should be denied “fair housing choice.” The Grants Manager placed two advertisements in The News and Advance during April 2016 noting the designation of “April is Fair Housing Month”. In addition, posters were posted at various agencies and locations throughout the City. Posters were placed at the following locations: Lyn-CAG, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) (Public Housing Agency), Rush Homes (Serves persons with disabilities), City Hall. PY2016: The Grants Manager did not receive any fair housing complaints. Through the Fair Housing project funded with CDBG funds, workshops were conducted and information was distributed (i.e. posters, brochures, flyers, etc.) to inform the citizens of the opportunities for everyone to have the right to live where they so choose and that no one should be denied “fair housing choice.” The Grants Manager placed two advertisements in The News and Advance during April 2017 noting the designation of “April is Fair Housing Month”. In addition, posters were posted at various agencies and locations throughout the City. Posters were placed at the following locations: Lyn-CAG, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) (Public Housing Agency), Rush Homes (Serves persons with disabilities), City Hall. PY2017: The Grants Manager did not receive any fair housing complaints. Through the Fair Housing project funded with CDBG funds, workshops were conducted and information was distributed (i.e. posters, brochures, flyers, etc.) to inform the citizens of the opportunities for everyone to have the right to live where they so choose and that no one should be denied “fair housing choice.” 37 The Grants Manager placed two advertisements in The News and Advance during April 2018 noting the designation of “April is Fair Housing Month”. In addition, posters were posted at various agencies and locations throughout the City. Posters were placed at the following locations: Lyn-CAG, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) (Public Housing Agency), Rush Homes (serves persons with disabilities), and City Hall. PY2018: The Grants Manager did not receive any fair housing complaints. Action Step 5: The City should revise its Affirmative Marketing Plan to clarify how developments will be monitored, evaluate tenant data, and require fair housing training where needed. COMPLETED PY2015: Each subrecipient that receives HOME Program funds and is completing a development or redevelopment project with 5 or more units does have an Affirmative Marketing Plan. City staff is in the process of updating the Affirmative Marketing Plan for the HOME Program to include the referenced items. PY2016: City staff has updated its Affirmative Fair Housing Marketing Plan for the HOME Program to include the referenced items. Action Step 6: The City should revise its Section 3 policy to list specific ways in which policy will be advertised to eligible residents and businesses. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: City staff reviewed this Policy for an update. PY2016: City staff updated its Section 3 Policy stating the specific requirements for advertisements to eligible residents and businesses. PY2018: The Section 3 Report for Program Year 2018 was submitted through the HUD Section 3 - Performance Evaluation and Registry System (SPEARS) data system. Action Step 7: The Housing Collaborative and the City should promote fair housing education to the general public, especially to renters, in addition to developers and landlords. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: City staff has Fair Housing links on its web page to the HUD Fair Housing Office, Virginia Fair Housing Office, Lyn-CAG Housing Counseling Services, and Virginia Legal Aid Office for housing resources. Go to: www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration PY2016: During this program year a Fair Housing Seminar was conducted on April 29, 2017 at the Lynchburg Public Library. There were 13 persons who attended along with staff from the City of Lynchburg, Lynchburg Community Action Group and Virginia Legal Aid. Mr. Jeremy White an attorney with Virginia Legal Aid provided a PowerPoint presentation regarding fair 38 housing rights and responsibilities. Mr. White concluded with providing resources for information regarding the Virginia laws and regulations for Fair Housing. Ms. Denise Crews from Lynchburg Community Action Group provided a presentation on Tenants Rights and Responsibilities. Ms. Crews provided pamphlets and handouts regarding Fair Housing and tenants’ rights and responsibilities. City staff has Fair Housing links on its web page to the HUD Fair Housing Office, Virginia Fair Housing Office, Lyn-CAG Housing Counseling Services, and Virginia Legal Aid Office for housing resources. Go to: www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration PY2017: The Grants Manager placed two advertisements in The News and Advance during April 2018 noting the designation of “April is Fair Housing Month”. Posters were posted at various agencies and locations throughout the City: Lyn-CAG, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) (Public Housing Agency), Rush Homes (serves persons with disabilities), City Hall. Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG placed advertisements on five billboards throughout the City of Lynchburg regarding “Fair Housing Month” and citizens’ rights to Fair Housing. The Housing Counseling Services Department assisted individuals with their housing and rental counseling; foreclosure prevention; first-time homebuyer; and fair housing. There were 206 clients served throughout the program year. City staff has Fair Housing links on its web page to the HUD Fair Housing Office, Virginia Fair Housing Office, Lyn-CAG Housing Counseling Services, and Virginia Legal Aid Office for housing resources. Go to: www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration PY2018: The Grants Manager placed two advertisements in The News and Advance during April 2019 noting the designation of “April is Fair Housing Month”. As a participant of the Housing Collaborative, the Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) Housing Counseling Services Department assisted individuals with their housing and rental counseling; 39 foreclosure prevention; first-time homebuyer; and fair housing. There were 147 persons served during this program year. These clients included 89 Blacks and 57 Whites and one Asian. The Income levels included: <30% of the Area Median Income (AMI) - 65 persons; 30-40% of AMI - 40 persons; 50-79%-36 persons; and 80-100% of AMI six persons. As a participant of the Housing Collaborative and as recipient of the CDBG and HOME entitlement funds, City staff has Fair Housing links on its web page to the HUD Fair Housing Office, Virginia Fair Housing Office, Lyn-CAG Housing Counseling Services, and Virginia Legal Aid Office for housing resources. Go to: www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration In addition, the National Fair Housing Alliance developed a social media campaign to assist communities in promoting the 50th Anniversary of the Fair Housing Act, housing discrimination, and general fair housing information. City staff used this campaign information and developed a social media campaign for Lynchburg on fair housing. The postings on the City’s website, Facebook, and Twitter occurred on December 3, 5, 12, 17, 19, and 26, 2018. Members of the protected classes are under-represented on City boards and commissions that address housing issues. Action Step 1: Annually, the City should schedule a recruitment period for new board and commission applicants with an emphasis on recruiting members of the protected classes. PY2015: The City Clerk placed public notices for boards and commission applicants on a regular basis on the City’s web page and the Newsletter “City Source”. During Program Year 2015 the public notices were placed in August 2015, April 2016, and May 2016. PY2016: The City Clerk placed public notices for boards and commission applicants on a regular basis on the City’s web page and the Newsletter “City Source”. During Program Year 2016 the public notices were placed in August 2016, September 2016, November 2016, and May 2017. PY2017: The City Clerk places public notices for boards and commission applicants on a regular basis on the City’s web page (Board and Commissions) and the Newsletter “City Source”. The public notices were placed in September 2017, May 2018, and June 2018 40 PY2018: The City’s recruitment process for boards and commissions was conducted on a continuous basis and is advertised through the local newspaper, City website, and local media. The City Clerk placed public notices for boards and commission applicants on a regular basis on the City’s web page (Board and Commissions) and in the Newsletter “City Source”. The “City Source” is published in the local newspaper The News and Advance each time it is placed on the City’s website and distributed to the public. Public notices were placed in August 2018, October 2018, and June 2019. The City Source was published in The News and Advance on August 14, 2018; October 16, 2018; and June 18, 2019. In addition, the City’s website provides a link specifically describing the various Board and Commissions that the public may serve as a volunteer. Press releases are also disseminated to recruit Boards and Commissions applicants. The dates of these releases were October 3, 2018; November 12, 2018; and August 1, 2018. These press releases are posted on the City’s website (under “News Items”) until the deadline for applications ended. Through the Bridges to Progress initiative citizens are provided with information on the Boards and Commissions and encouraged to participate. The Bridges to Progress group engages the public; enhance support for ongoing programs and flushes out definitive community concerns. Citizens of all ages, creeds, ethnicities, and incomes (many of whom may have not been at the same table otherwise) were now a part of a long-term collective effort to reduce poverty in Lynchburg. This event began the process of developing action items focused on eliminating barriers for our low- income citizens. It was also a catalyst for the civic engagement of faith-based organizations, non-profits, individuals, businesses, schools, and others to rally around the cause of community uplift to get involved not only on a community level but with the local government through the various City boards and commissions. There is an inadequate supply of affordable and accessible housing for persons with disabilities. 41 Action Step 1: The Housing Collaborative should incorporate a disability element into its fair housing training. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015-2016: No accomplishments. PY2017: Lynchburg Regional Housing Collaborative engaged Enterprise Community Partners to conduct a housing stability and economic security study through a Community Impact Grant from VHDA to determine the actual state of housing in Lynchburg. PY2018: The Collaborative continued its efforts through meetings and discussed proposed housing projects related to new construction, redevelopment, and rehabilitation, and the CVCoC activities for the homeless (permanent supportive housing programs and emergency shelters). These meetings included conversations to ensure that all affordable housing projects were offered to all persons and that no discriminatory action would be taken against any applicant. Action Step 2: The City should continue using HOME funds to support housing and supportive services for persons with disabilities. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: The City allocated $150,000 of HOME Program funds to Rush Homes for the development of a 28-unit Old Forest Village Apartment project. Rush Homes provides housing and supportive services to persons with disabilities. PY2016: The City allocated $150,000 of HOME Program funds to Rush Homes for the development of a 28-unit Old Forest Village Apartment project. Project development was completed in Program Year 2016 and construction will begin in Program year 2017. PY2017: Construction began on Rush Homes, a 28-unit Old Forest Village Apartment project providing housing and supportive services to persons with disabilities. HOME funds in the amount of $150,000 was provided for the project. PY2018: Rush Homes was completed in January 2019 and all housing units are occupied by persons with disabilities. The City’s zoning ordinance could be improved from a fair housing perspective. Action Step 1: The City should amend its zoning ordinance to remove restrictions on group living facilities for persons with disabilities. PY2015: The Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance was adopted in February 2016. The new zoning ordinance promotes higher density development, more flexibility in the development of smaller urban lots and reduced setbacks in higher density residential zoning districts. 42 COMPLETED The ordinance also allows for more opportunities for mixed-use development, helping promote transit- oriented development in lower income neighborhoods. Finally, one major principle carried on throughout the ordinance is greater connectivity amongst neighborhoods, especially through the requirement of sidewalks in all high-density residential zoning and commercial districts. Public transit is limited to the City’s most densely developed areas and is unavailable to second and third shift workers, and those working on weekends and holidays. Action Step 1: The City should continue collaborating with Greater Lynchburg Transit Company (GLTC) as it updates its Comprehensive Plan to promote the expansion of public transit service in non-impacted, high growth areas of the City. PY2015-2017: City staff continues to collaborate with Greater Lynchburg Transit Company (GLTC) in the updates related to the Comprehensive Plan. PY2018: GLTC conducted a study which gathered feedback on the needs of riders. Out of this survey, proposed route changes were recommended which took effect in December 2018. These changes worked to extend weekend service to 10:15 pm, create more direct service (reducing travel times), and create more frequent service. The Bridges to Progress initiative which is focused on trying to reduce poverty within Lynchburg has a transportation focus group. This group meets regularly and is exploring alternatives to fill the gaps for transportation needs not met by GLTC. Ride Solutions is a program that promotes alternative transportation and housed at the Central Virginia Planning District Commission. This program provides ride-matching for carpool options and has recently released new software called Agile Mile which will facilitate ride matching options. Action Step 2: As part of its zoning ordinance update in 2014, the City should identify opportunities around existing areas of public transit for the development of medium-density and higher-density affordable multi-family residential uses. COMPLETED PY2015: The Lynchburg zoning ordinance was adopted in February 2016. The ordinance also allows for more opportunities for mixed-use development, helping promote transit-oriented development in lower income neighborhoods. 43 Impediment (LRHA) Status Housing Choice Voucher Units are concentrated in RCAPs and LMI areas near the Central Business District. Action Step 1: LRHA should continue to actively recruit landlords in lower poverty/high opportunity neighborhoods to participate in the Housing Choice Voucher (HCV) Program. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: LRHA continued to hold quarterly Landlord meetings to educate and recruit new landlords to participate in the HCV program. LRHA staff is working with the City Inspections Division to obtain a listing of landlords that are not current HCV landlords, so that they can be invited to the Landlord meetings. PY2016: LRHA continued to hold quarterly Landlord meetings to educate and recruit new landlords to participate in the HCV program. LRHA staff continues to partner with the City Inspections Division to obtain a listing of landlords that are not current HCV landlords, so that they can be invited to the Landlord meetings. The Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) has prepared and provides to the CVCoC a listing of available landlords to serve the homeless and persons within the CVCoC diversion program. PY2017: LHRA continued to hold quarterly Landlord meetings to educate and recruit new landlords to participate in the HCV program. LRHA staff continues to partner with the City Inspections Division to obtain a listing of landlords that are not current HCV landlords, so that they can be invited to the Landlord meetings. The Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) has prepared and provides to the CVCoC a listing of available landlords to serve the homeless and persons within the CVCoC diversion program. LRHA hired a Housing Navigator to staff the Housing Resource Center. One of the goals is to contact landlord to develop a robust pool of potential rental housing options. As a part of that process the Housing Navigator will work to address concerns from landlords and potential landlords about renting to people with 44 subsidies. This will provide an opportunity to get concrete data on why some providers are reluctant to rent to this population and address actual concern and overcome issues that are more anecdotal than fact. PY2018: LRHA continued to hold quarterly Landlord meetings to educate and recruit new landlords to participate in the HCV program. LRHA staff continues to partner with the City Inspections Division to obtain a listing of landlords that are not current HCV landlords, so that they can be invited to the Landlord meetings. The Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) has prepared and provides to the CVCoC a listing of available landlords to serve the homeless and persons within the CVCoC diversion program. In addition, LRHA hired a Housing Navigator to staff the Housing Resource Center. One of the goals is to contact landlords to develop a robust pool of potential rental housing options. As a part of that process the Housing Navigator will work to address concerns from landlords and potential landlords about renting to people with subsidies. This will provide an opportunity to get concrete data on why some providers are reluctant to rent to this population and address actual concern and overcome issues that are more anecdotal than fact. Due to limited resources and hilly topography throughout Lynchburg, handicapped accessible units are limited within LRHA’s public housing inventory. Action Step 1: LRHA should continue to use all available resources to retrofit public housing units to meet its minimum requirements, at the least, for handicapped accessible units and in compliance with Section 504/UFAS requirements. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: LRHA completed renovations of two housing units to bring them into Section 504/UFAS compliance. The total is now six public housing units that are compliant. LRHA plans to contract for the seventh unit by September 2016. The Dearington Community Room was rehabilitated and is now Section 504/UFAS compliant. The two community rooms within 45 LRHA’s public housing complexes are now Section 504 compliant. PY2016: LRHA completed renovations of one housing unit to bring it into Section 504/UFAS compliance. The total is now seven public housing units that are compliant. LRHA plans to contract for the eighth unit by January 2018. PY2017: LRHA completed renovations of one housing unit to bring it into Section 504/UFAS compliance. PY2018: LRHA completed renovations of one public housing unit to bring it into Section 504/UFAS compliance. LRHA continues to review and access the public housing units to meet the Section 504 requirements. LRHA could improve its Admissions and Continued Occupancy Policy from a fair housing perspective. Action Step 1: LRHA should amend its Admissions and Continued Occupancy Policy (ACOP) to allow applicants to refuse a unit at least once before they are removed from the waiting list. COMPLETED LRHA amended the ACOP in October 2013. The policy was updated as follows: The LRHA has adopted a “two-to-three offer plan” for offering units to applicants. Under this plan, the LRHA will determine how many locations within its jurisdiction have available units of suitable size and type in the appropriate type of project. The number of unit offers will be based on the distribution of vacancies. If a suitable unit is available in: Three (3) or more locations: The applicant will be offered a unit in the location with the highest number of vacancies. If the offer is rejected, the applicant will be offered a suitable unit in the location with the second highest number of vacancies. If that unit is rejected, a final offer will be made in the location with the third highest number of vacancies. The offers will be made in sequence and the applicant must refuse an offer before another is made. Two (2) locations: The applicant will be offered a suitable unit in the location with the higher number of vacancies. If the offer is rejected, a final offer will be made at the other location. 46 The offers will be made in sequence and the applicant must refuse the first offer before a second offer is made. One (1) location: The applicant will be offered a suitable unit in that location. If the offer is rejected, the applicant will be offered the next suitable unit that becomes available, whether it is at the same location as the first offer or at another location. The second unit offer will be the final offer, unless there is good cause for refusing the offer. If more than one unit of the appropriate type and size is available, the first unit to be offered will be the first unit that is ready for occupancy. Applicants may refuse to accept a unit offer for “good cause.” Good cause includes situations in which an applicant is willing to move but is unable to do so at the time of the unit offer, or the applicant demonstrates that acceptance of the offer would cause undue hardship not related to considerations of the applicant’s race, color, national origin, etc. [PH Occ GB, p. 104]. Examples of good cause for refusal of a unit offer include, but are not limited to, the following: The family demonstrates to the LRHA’s satisfaction that accepting the unit offer will require an adult household member to quit a job, drop out of an educational institution or job training program, or take a child out of day care or an educational program for children with disabilities. The family demonstrates to the LRHA’s satisfaction that accepting the offer will place a family member’s life, health, or safety in jeopardy. The family should offer specific and compelling documentation such as restraining orders, other court orders, risk assessments related to witness protection from a law enforcement agency, or documentation of domestic violence, dating violence, or stalking in 47 accordance with section 16-VII.D of this ACOP. Reasons offered must be specific to the family. Refusals due to location alone do not qualify for this good cause exemption. A health professional verifies temporary hospitalization or recovery from illness of the principal household member, other household members (as listed on final application) or live-in aide necessary to the care of the principal household member. The unit is inappropriate for the applicant’s disabilities, or the family does not need the accessible features in the unit offered and does not want to be subject to a 30-day notice to move. The unit has lead-based paint and the family includes children under the age of six. In the case of a unit refusal for good cause the applicant will not be removed from the waiting list as described later in this section. The applicant will remain at the top of the waiting list until the family receives an offer for which they do not have good cause to refuse. LRHA will require documentation of good cause for unit refusals. When an applicant rejects the final unit offer without good cause, the LRHA will remove the applicant’s name from the waiting list and send notice to the family of such removal. The notice will inform the family of their right to request an informal hearing and the process for doing so (see Chapter 14). The applicant may reapply for assistance if the waiting list is open. If the waiting list is not open, the applicant must wait to reapply until the LRHA opens the waiting list. Impediment (Private Sector) Status Mortgage loan denials and high-cost lending disproportionately affect minority applicants in Lynchburg similar to national trends. PY2015: $75,000 provided to Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity to provide homebuyer 48 Action Step 1: Fund homebuyer counseling for lower income households, particularly minority households. COMPLETED & CONTINUING assistance to eligible persons to write down their mortgage so that the housing units assisted would be affordable. During this program year Lyn-CAG assisted one homebuyer and included the required homebuyer counseling for the purchase of the housing unit. Habitat for Humanity provided down payment assistance to five families. During the year prior to purchase the qualified applicant is required to participate in home buyer counseling and financial planning classes for the planned purchase. While HOME Program funds were not directly provided for homebuyer counseling, the agencies listed below conducted the following classes: Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity: Orientation Classes (2-hour acclimation class) - August 24 and 27, 2015 (80 persons) May 10, 2016 (8 people) June 21, 2016 (40 persons) For the following seven sessions, there were 10 participants with 7 graduates (8 Blacks, 2 NH Whites) Personal Finance – September 28, 2015 Spanish-Speaking Orientation Class in October 2016 (15 persons) Credit and Credit Reporting – October 5, 2015 Developing a Savings and Spending Plan - October 19, 2015 Virginia Fair Housing and Fringe Banking - October 26, 2015 Insurance and Warranties - November 2, 2015 Loan Closing - November 9, 2015 Life as a Homeowner - November 16, 2015 Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) Lyn-CAG staff conducted 12 homebuyer education classes with 11 participants: 9 Blacks (82%), 2 Whites (18%). There were an additional 112 participants who attended pre-purchase 49 classes that met monthly over the last year to receive homebuying counseling. PY2016: the City provided HOME Program funds in the amount of $75,000 to Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity to provide homebuyer assistance to eligible persons to write down their mortgage so that the housing units assisted would be affordable. During this program year, Habitat for Humanity provided down payment assistance to four families. During the year prior to purchase the qualified applicant is required to participate in home buyer counseling and financial planning classes for the planned purchase. In Program Year 2014 Lyn-CAG received $60,000 in HOME Program funds for homebuyer assistance. During this program year Lyn-CAG assisted two (2) homebuyers and included the required homebuyer counseling for the purchase of the housing unit. In addition, while HOME Program funds were not directly provided to Habitat for Humanity for home buyer counseling, the agency did conduct the following classes: Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity 1. Introduction and Class Creed - September 12, 2016 & April 3, 2017 2. Personal Finance - September 19, 2016 & April 10, 2017 3. Credit and Credit Reporting - September 26, 2016 & April 24, 2017 4. Developing a Savings and Spending Plan - October 3, 2016 & May 8, 2017 5. Virginia Fair Housing and Fringe banking - October 17, 2016 & May 15, 2017 6. Insurance and Warranties - October 24, 2016 & May 22, 2017 7. Loan Closing - November 7, 2016 & May 28, 2017 8. Life as a Homeowner - November 14, 2016 & June 12, 2017 50 There were 10 participants in these classes. All 10 participants were Black. PY2017: The City provided HOME Program funds in the amount of $96,163 to Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity to provide homebuyer assistance to eligible persons to write down their mortgage so that the housing units assisted would be affordable. Habitat for Humanity provided down payment assistance to three families. During the year prior to purchase the qualified applicant is required to participate in homebuyer counseling and financial planning classes for the planned purchase. In addition, while HOME Program funds were not directly provided to Habitat for Humanity for home buyer counseling, the agency did conduct the following classes: Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity Homebuyers’ Club Fall 2017 – November 12, 2017 through December 4, 2017 (12 hours) Homebuyers’ Club Spring 2018 – May 17, 2018 through June 25, 2018 (12 hours) There were eight participants in these classes, all Black. PY2018: The following classes and the recipients of the HOME Program funds for homebuyer purchases were provided with home buyer counseling. Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) GLHFH conducted one Homebuyer Class with five Black participants. GLHFH conducted two Warranties, Maintenance, and Closing Counseling Classes with two Black participants. GLHFL conducted an Application Orientation Class and there were 50 participants who attended the class: 43 Blacks, two Hispanics, and five Whites. 51 Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG There were 15 individuals who completed the 12-month program: 15 graduated from the First- time Home Buyers Club and six pre-qualified to purchase a home. Three of the six purchased homes in Lynchburg. Two are currently looking at real estate purchase options and one purchased in the surrounding county. The three first-time homebuyers were Black and within the 60-80% of the Area Median Income (AMI). Two of the individuals who pre-qualified were White and within less than 50% of the AMI and one individual is Black and within 50-80% of the AMI. In addition, Lyn-CAG’s Housing Counseling Services Department assisted individuals with their housing and rental counseling; foreclosure prevention; first-time homebuyer; and fair housing. There were 147 clients served throughout the program year. These clients included 89 Blacks and 57 Whites and one Asian. The income levels included: <30% of the Area Median Income (AMI) - 65 persons; 30- 40% of AMI - 40 persons; 50-79%-36 persons; and 80-100% of AMI six persons. The advertising policies of the News and Advance could be improved from a fair housing perspective. Action Step 1: The City should inform the editors of the News and Advance that it is responsible for displaying the publisher’s policy in all sections of the paper, which list rental and sales housing. COMPLETED & CONTINUING PY2015: City staff contacted The News and Advance on July 17, 2014 regarding the publication of the publisher’s policy for all real estate advertisements. Since that time The News and Advance has been publishing the advertisement below daily. During Program Year 2015 The News and Advance continued to publish this advertisement. In addition, the News and Advance publishes in the Real Estate Home This Week publication, on a weekly basis, the following advertisement regarding Equal Housing Opportunity. PY2016: City staff contacted The News and Advance on August 21, 2017 regarding the publication of the publisher’s policy for all real 52 estate advertisements. City staff received a response that the public notice would continue to be published. PY2018: The News and Advance continued to publish its policy for all real estate advertisements. 53 Data Analysis This section of the AI analyzes the demographic and housing characteristics of the City of Lynchburg, focusing on members of the protected classes. The federal Fair Housing Act protects the following characteristics: race, color, religion, sex, national origin, familial status and disability status. Virginia’s Fair Housing Law also adds elderliness and disability status as protected classes. Elderliness is defined as an individual who has attained their 55th birthday. Demographic Profile Population Trends Between 2000 and 2017 Lynchburg grew by 21.4% , adding 13,968 new residents . This is slightly higher than Virginia’s population growth rate of 18.2% during the same time period. The Lynchburg metropolitan statistical area (MSA) increased by 13.3% (228,616 to 265,405) between 2000 and 201 7, and includes Amherst County, Appomattox County, Bedford County, Campbell County, the Town of Bedford, and the City of Lynchburg. Figure 2 Change in Population, 2000 – 2017 2000 2010 2017 % Change 2000-2017 Virginia 7,078,515 7,841,754 8,365,952 18.2% Lynchburg 65,269 73,726 79,237 21.4% Source: American Community Survey, 2013 – 2017: B01003 Figure 3 Change in Population since 1970 in Lynchburg and the State of Virginia 54 Population growth appears to be decentralized in Lynchburg in areas further away from downtown. Growth was especially high along the Lynchburg Expressway near the cloverleaf interchanges. These areas are i n close proximity to commercial areas. Downtown Lynchburg itself also experienced high rates of growth; this is likely due to its already small population relative to the rest of the City. 55 Map 1 Population Change, 2010-20171 Concentrations of Persons Ages 18 – 24 As a city that hosts several colleges and universities, college-aged students comprise a substantial portion of the city’s population. According to the 2013-2017 ACS, a total of 17,557 undergraduate and graduate students resided in Lynchburg, comprising approximately 22.2% of the city’s total population. This high concentration of students is especially important as it relates to the rental market. There may be increased competition for rental housing between students and low - and moderate -income 1 HUD defines racially and ethnically concentrated areas of poverty as a census tract with a non -White population of 50% or more and with 40% or more individuals living at or below the poverty line. It is important to look at disparities between groups in relation to disproportionate poverty and access to community assets to assess fair housing needs. However, there were other census tracts that fell just short of the 40% poverty threshold. A modified definition to loosen the threshold to be ten percentage points above the City’s poverty rate of 22.3%, added two additional census meeting the requirements for the modified R/ECAP. 56 households, with the caveat that students are better able to meet rent payments with access to loans and generally stronger support systems which could include financial support from family members. Figure 3 Lynchburg Age Breakdown Age Category Number Percentage Under 18 15,330 19.3% 18 - 24 19,952 25.2% 15 - 44 39,613 50.0% 65 years and older 11,016 13.9% Total 79,237 Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 – 2017: S0101 57 Map 2 Concentration of persons ages 18 to 24 years-old, 2017 58 59 Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey 60 Race and Ethnicity As defined by HUD, a racially and ethnically concentrated area is defined by a census tract where the non-White population is at least 50% of the population. Minorities include Black, Asian, and Hispanic populations, representing 28.5%, 2.8%, and 3.7% of the population, respectively. In Lynchburg, three census tracts meet this criterion, as illustrated in the map below. These census tracts are concentrated near downtown Lynchburg and includes the following neighborhoods:  Tate Springs  Dearington  Miller Park  Garland Hill  College Hill  Diamond Hill  Fairview Heights  Winston Ridge  Tyreanna 61 Map 3 Nonwhite and/or Hispanic Population 62 63 Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey 64 Figure 4 Racial and Ethnic Composition, 2010 - 2017 Lynchburg, VA 2010 2017 Percentage Change Since 2010 Race/Ethnicity Total Percent Total Percent White 48,674 64.4% 51,573 65.1% 6.0% Non-White 26,894 35.6% 27,664 34.9% 2.9% Black 22,140 29.3% 22,555 28.5% 1.9% American Indian 107 0.1% 175 0.2% 63.6% Asian/Pacific Islander 1,905 2.5% 2,224 2.8% 16.7% Some Other Race 950 1.3% 658 0.8% -30.7% Two or More Races 1,662 2.2% 2,052 2.6% 23.5% Hispanic* 2,300 3.0% 2,901 3.7% 26.1% Total 75,568 79,237 4.9% Virginia 2010 2017 Percentage Change Since 2010 Race/Ethnicity: Total Percent Total Percent White 5,486,852 2,514,172 1,551,399 5,486,852 68.6% 5,720,209 68.4% 4.3% Non-White 2,514,172 2,514,172 31.4% 2,645,743 31.6% 5.2% Black 1,551,399 1,551,399 19.4% 1,605,447 19.2% 3.5% American Indian 24,941 0.3% 22,499 0.3% -9.8% Asian/Pacific Islander 445,870 5.6% 525,588 6.3% 17.9% Some Other Race 254,278 3.2% 200,265 2.4% -21.2% Two or More Races 233,400 2.9% 291,944 3.5% 25.1% Hispanic* 631,825 7.9% 749,458 9.0% 18.6% Total 8,001,024 8,365,952 4.6% *Hispanic ethnicity is counted independently of race Source: 2010 Census QT-P3; 2013 - 2017 ACS (B02001 & B02005 & B03003) 65 Racial Segregation Patterns Residential segregation is a measure of the degree of separation of racial or ethnic groups living in a neighborhood or community. Latent factors, such as attitudes, or overt factors, such as real estate practices, can limit the range of housing opportunities for minorities. A lack of racial or ethnic integration in a community creates other problems, such as reinforcing prejudicial attitudes and behaviors, narrowing opportunities for interaction, and reducing the degree to which community life is considered harmonious. Areas of extreme minority isolation often experience poverty and social problems at rates that are disproportionately high. Racial segregation has been linked to diminished employment prospects, poor educational attainment, increased infant and adult mortality rates and increased homicide rates. The distribution of racial or ethnic groups across a geographic area can be analyzed using an index of dissimilarity. This method allows for comparisons between s ubpopulations, indicating how much one group is spatially separated from another within a community. The index of dissimilarity is rated on a scale from 0 to 100, in which a score of 0 corresponds to perfect integration and a score of 100 represents total segregation.2 The index is typically interpreted as the percentage of the minority population (in this instance, the Black population) that would have to move in order for a community or neighborhood to achieve full integration. Segregation in Lynchburg across most minority groups is moderate but the magnitude of segregation is increasing among Hispanic and Asian populations. Values ranging between 40 and 50 are considered moderate levels of segregation . American Indian and Other populations show high lev els of segregation, but this is likely a result of their relatively small population size. Since 2010, segregation has increased, especially among the Hispanic population. Similar to trends between 2000 and 2010, the high magnitude of increasing segregation is a result of relatively high population growth of Asian and 2 The index of dissimilarity is a commonly used demographic tool for measuring inequality. For a given geographic area, the index is equal to 1/2 Σ ABS [(b/B)-(a/A)], where b is the subgroup population of a census tract, B is the total subgroup population in a city, a is the majority population of a census tract, and A is the total majority population in the city. ABS refers to the absolute value of the calculation that follows. 66 Hispanic populations. On the same note, segregation among the Black population only marginally increased by 1.2 points; population growth of the Black population also marginally increased by 1.9% 67 Figure 5 Dissimilarity Index, Lynchburg 2017 Dissimilarity Index Subpopulation Total Share of Total Population Black / White 47.9 22,449 28.3% American Indian** / White 69.3 175 0.2% Asian / White 42.8 2,202 2.8% Other** / White 85.9 122 0.2% Two or More Races / White 40.8 1,735 2.2% Hispanic * / Non-Hispanic 43.8 2,901 3.7% Total 79,237 *Hispanic ethnicity is counted independently of race ** The DI score for American Indian /Alaska Native and Other is not statistically reliable due to small sample size Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey: 2013 - 2017 B03002 Figure 6 Dissimilarity Index, Lynchburg 2010 Dissimilarity Index Subpopulation Total Share of Total Population Black / White 46.5 21,984 27.7% American Indian** / White 34.7 200 200 0.3% Asian / White 35.9 1,879 2.4% Other** / White 36.1 184 0.2% Two or More Races / White 30.7 1,447 1.8% Hispanic * / Non-Hispanic 17.8 2,300 2.9% Total 75,568 *Hispanic ethnicity is counted independently of race ** The DI score for American Indian /Alaska Native and Other is not statistically reliable due to small sample size Source: Census Bureau, Decennial Census Count: 2010, SF1 P5 68 Figure 7 Change in Dissimilarity Index, 2010-2017 Race / Ethnicity 2010 2017 Dissimilarity Index Percentage Change Population Dissimilarity Index Population Dissimilarity Index Black 21,984 46.5 22,449 47.9 + 3.0% Asian / Pacific Islander 1,879 35.9 2,202 42.8 + 19.2% Hispanic/Non-Hispanic 2,300 17.8 2,901 43.8 + 146.0% 69 Race/Ethnicity and Income Household income is one of the most significant determining factors impacting where one lives. It is one of the factors considered in determining eligibility for a home mortgage or rental lease. Median Household Income (MHI) in Ly nchburg in 2018 was $43,374. The city’s median income is significantly lower than Virginia’s median household income of $71,564. The discrepancy is partially attributed to the relatively high proportion of college -students who reside within Lynchburg , making up 25.5% of the city’s population. There exists a gap in income and wealth between White and minority households that is exacerbated by the concentration of minorities in particular neighborhoods that often have far less opportunity for minority children to access the tools associated with social mobility . Understanding where these concentrations exist is the first step to alleviating the disparity. Compared to the State, Lynchburg has a slightly larger minority population, with its Black population almost ten percentage points higher than that of the State. Minority households had lower household incomes than White households, especially Black households. Black and White households had the largest income gap, with median household incomes of $27,366 and $52,421, respectively. Along the same lines, the Black and Asian households also showed greater levels of poverty than White households. Hispanic households, however, showed relatively low poverty rates when compared to the City. When looking at household incomes across income brackets, Black and Asian households were more concentrated in the bottom two income brackets while White and Hispanic households had more even distribution. Figure 8 Median Income and Rates of Poverty by Race and Ethnicity, Lynchburg 2017 Median Household Income Poverty Rate Virginia $ 68,766 11.2% Lynchburg $ 41,971 22.3% White $ 52,421 17.3% Black/African American $ 27,366 31.9% 70 Asian $ 39,187 37.3% Hispanic/Latino $ 42,024 18.2% Source: 2013 – 2017 ACS (B1703; B19013) Racial and Ethnic Minority Concentration Areas of Poverty Under HUD’s definition of racially/ethnically concentrated areas of poverty, only one census tract meets this definition: Census Tract 7. HUD defines concentrations of racial and ethnic minorities was as a census tract with a non -White population of 50% or more. A con centrated area of poverty is defined as a census tract with 40% or more individuals living at or below the poverty line. I t is important to look at disparities between groups in relation to disproportionate poverty and access to community assets to assess fair housing needs. However, there were other census tracts that fell just short of the 40% poverty threshold. By modifying the threshold to be ten percentage points above the City’s poverty rate of 22.3%, two additional census meet the definition for the modified R/ECAP: Census Tracts 6 and 11. The HUD R/ECAP and the modified R/ECAPS are located west of Downtown Lynchburg and include the following neighborhoods:  Tate Springs  Dearington  Miller Park  Garland Hill  College Hill  Diamond Hill Compared to the previous AI, there is one less census tract that no longer meets both HUD’s R/ECAP definition and the modified R/ECAP definition: Census Tract 19. The poverty rate in this census tract decreased from 37.5% in 2013 to 28.8% in 2017. 71 Map 4 R/ECAPs 72 73 Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey 74 In the previous map, Census Tract 7 is identified as a racially concentrated area of poverty and Census Tracts 6 and 11 are identified as modified racially concentrated areas of poverty based on recent Census data. These areas of Lynchburg are the same areas identified in a historical map created in 1937 by the federal Home Owners’ Loan Corporation in designating the quality level of neighborhoods where local lending institutions were directed to approve or deny mortgages to homebuyers. Highest quality neighborhoods, which were predominantly or exclusively White neighborhoods, were categorized as “A – First Grade” as shown on the following map. The area encompassed by Census Tract 7 today is found in the center of the HOLC map (still colored yellow coincidentally) and was designed as “C – Third Grade” indicating neighborhoods that were declining; the lowest grade of D indicated “hazardous areas” and encompasses parts of Census Tracts 6 and 11 as well . These designations were used by lenders, appraisers and insurance agents to determine the terms of mortgage and insurance products to be made available to residents. Buying a home in a D – Fourth Grade neighborhood would mean higher interest rates, for example, along with a higher downpayment, up to 50% in many cases. These terms effectively shut out minority families from becoming homeowners and acquiring wealth. It also sealed the fate of many lower income minority neighborhoods through disinvestment and neglect. As stated in a 2019 Bridges to Progress report, Redlining in Lynchburg, “The real estate redlining of the 1930s offers a lens through which we might make a connection between the racism of the past and the poverty of the present.” 75 76 Educational Attainment and Income Persons with a high school diploma earn, on average, $23,907 per year compared to persons with a Bachelor’s degree earning $38,121, on average. In Lynchburg there exists a strong correlation between lower educational levels and lower income/increased poverty. Persons with lower education tend to experience higher levels of unemployment and lower wages. Figure 9 Educational Attainment and Income (Age 25 or Older), Lynchburg 2017 Educational Attainment Median Income Percentage Poverty Rate Less than High School Graduate $ 24,107 12.0% 33.9% High School Graduate $ 23,907 24.8% 16.6% Some College or Associate’s Degree $ 27,849 29.6% 13.9% Bachelor's Degree $ 38,121 20.1% 6.9%* Graduate or Professional Degree $ 47,931 13.5% Population (Age 25 or Older with earnings) $ 30,587 100% - * ACS provides poverty rate for bachelor and graduate/professional degree holders together source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 - 2017: S1501 77 Disability and Income The Census Bureau reports disability status for non -institutionalized disabled persons age 5 and over. As defined by the Census Bureau, a disability is a long-lasting physical, mental, or emotional condition that can make it difficult for a person to do activities such as walking, climbing stairs, dressing, bathing, learning, or remembering. This condition can also impede a person from being able to go outside the home alone or to work at a job or business. The Fair Housing Act prohibits discrimination b ased on physical, mental, or emotional handicap, provided “reasonable accommodation” can be made. Reasonable accommodation may include changes to address the needs of disabled persons, including adaptive structural (e.g., constructing an entrance ramp) or administrative changes (e.g., permitting the use of a service animal). In Lynchburg, 14.2% of the population over the age of 18 years old had at least one disability. Of individuals with a disability, 33.5% were living in poverty compared to 21.7% withou t a disability. Additionally, most individuals with a disability do not participate in the labor force (64.9%), reducing their ability to afford housing. Finally, the elderly are more likely to have a disability than the general population, especially as it relates to hearing, ambulatory, self-care, and independent living difficulties. While this outcome is expected, age is a protected class under the Virginia Human Rights Act and may play a role when furthering fair housing in Lynchburg as it relates to reasonable accommodation and aging-in-place. 78 Figure 10 Disability Type in Population Over Age 18, Lynchburg 2017 Population Type Total Percent Individuals Over Age 18 Years Old 62,541 - With a Disability 8,874 14.2% Hearing Difficulty 1,903 3.0% Vision Difficulty 1,976 3.2% Cognitive Difficulty 3,433 5.5% Ambulatory Difficulty 2,525 7.9% Self-Care Difficulty 887 2.9% Independent Living Difficulty 2,364 6.6% Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 – 20117: S1810 Figure 11 Elderly Population (Age 65 or Older) Disability Type, Lynchburg 2017 Population Type Total Percent Elderly (Age 65 or Older) 10,317 - With a Disability 3,525 34.2% Hearing Difficulty 1,336 12.9% Vision Difficulty 712 6.9% Cognitive Difficulty 928 9.0% Ambulatory Difficulty 2,427 23.5% Self-Care Difficulty 939 9.1% Independent Living Difficulty 1,747 16.9% Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 – 20117: S1810 79 Figure 12 Employment Status for Individuals by Disability Status, Lynchburg 2017 Employment Status With a disability Without a disability Subtotal Percent Subtotal Percent Employed 1,819 28.7% 32,569 70.0% Unemployed 404 6.4% 2,210 4.7% Not in Labor Force 4,118 64.9% 11,767 25.3% Total 6,341 46,546 Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 - 2017: B18120 Figure 13 Median Income and Poverty Rates by Disability Status, Lynchburg 2017 Population Median Annual Income Poverty Rate Total Population $ 18,282 23.0% with a disability $ 12,279 33.5% without a disability $ 18,677 21.7% Source: ACS 2013-2017 B23024 80 Family Status and Income The Census Bureau divides households into family and non-family households. Family households are married couples with or without children, single-parent families, and other families comprised of related persons. Non -family households are either single persons living alone, or two or more non -related persons living together. Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968 protects against sex discrimination in housing. Protection for families with children was added in the 1988 amendments to Title VIII. Except in limited circumstances involving elderly housing and owner-occupied buildings of one to four units, it is unlawful to refuse to rent or sell to families with children. Family households comprise of 58.3% of all households in Lynchburg in 2017. This is lower than that of the State of Virginia, in which family households consist of 66.9% of all households. This is likely a result of the high student population in Lynchburg. The household type composition in Lynchburg has remained stable. In 2017, 37.5% of female -headed households with children were living in poverty compared to 16.3% among all family households. Female-headed households with children often experience difficulty in obtaining housing as a result of lower incomes and higher expenses. 81 Figure 14 Household Type and Presence of Children, Lynchburg 2010 – 2017 Household Type 2010 2017 Total Percent Total Percent Family Households 16,368 57.5% 16,422 58.3% Married Couples 10,598 37.2% 10,392 36.9% with children 3,862 13.6% 3,860 13.7% without children 6,736 23.7% 6,532 23.2% Female-headed Household 4,637 16.3% 4,759 16.9% with children 2,626 9.2% 2,831 10.1% without children 2,011 7.1% 1,928 6.8% Male-headed Households 1,133 4.0% 1,271 4.5% with children 485 1.7% 589 2.1% without children 648 2.3% 682 2.4% Nonfamily Households* 12,108 42.5% 11,728 41.7% Total Households 28,476 - 28,150 - *Nonfamily households include individuals living alone and unrelated persons, including students Source: Census 2010 SF1-P19; 2013 - 2017 American Community Survey B11003, B11001 82 Ancestry and Income In Lynchburg, 7.1% of the population is foreign-born. It is illegal to refuse the right to housing based on place of birth or ancestry. Additionally, children living in homes where at least one parent is foreign - born were more likely to be living in poverty. While important to consider when furthering fair housing, Lynchburg does not have a large number of families with children with at least one foreign-born parent. Data from the American Community Survey was not available as a result. Persons with limited English proficiency (LEP) are defined as persons who have a limited ability to read, write, speak or understand English. HUD uses the prevalence of persons with LEP to identify the potential for impediments to fair housing choice due to their inability to comprehend English. Persons with LEP may encounter obstacles to fair housing by virtue of language and cultural barriers within their new environment. To assist these individuals, it is important that a community recognizes their presence and the potential for discrimination, whether intentional or inadve rtent, and establishes policies to eliminate barriers. It is also incumbent upon HUD entitlement communities to determine the need for language assistance and comply with Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. HUD has adopted a “safe harbor” threshold for the translation of written materials to make public services accessible to persons with limited English proficiency (LEP), as outlined in Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The safe harbor threshold is defined has having 1,000 or more LEP indiv iduals of a certain language or more than 5% of the population being LEP. Failure to provide written translations under these services under these circumstances may place the City at-risk of noncompliance. 83 Figure 15 Most Common Languages Spoken Among Individuals with LEP, Lynchburg 2015 Language Total Speakers Total Limited- English Proficiency Speakers Percent of Total Population with LEP (Age 5+) 1 Spanish or Spanish Creole 1,832 687 0.93% 2 Korean 351 206 0.28% 3 Chinese 286 165 0.22% 4 Gujarati 308 113 0.15% 5 Vietnamese 192 71 0.10% 6 Other Asian Languages 263 46 0.06% 7 Italian 154 31 0.04% 8 German 152 27 0.04% 9 Tagalog 85 24 0.03% 10 French (incl. Patois & Cajun) 228 21 0.03% 11 African Languages 512 17 0.02% 12 Thai 33 18 0.02% 13 Urdu 13 13 0.02% 14 Japanese 51 15 0.02% 15 Portuguese or Portuguese Creole 59 10 0.01% Total Population 73,529 Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2010 – 2015: B16001 84 Protected Class Status and Unemployment At 7.4%, Lynchburg’s unemployment rate was higher than that of the State in 2017. Female members of the labor force showed similar unemployment rates compared to their male counterparts, 5.0% unemployment versus 5.1%, respectively. Howeve r, the Black population is more likely to be unemployed than Whites; Blacks had an unemployment rate of 9.0% while Whites had a rate of 5.1%. Asians and Hispanics had similar or lower rates at 4.2% and 5.4%, respectively. Higher unemployment rates and lower incomes among minorities will make it more difficult for these populations to obtain housing, especially outside of traditionally low-income neighborhoods where minorities already live. Figure 16 Civilian Labor Force (CLF), 2017 Lynchburg, VA Virginia Total % Total % Total CLF 65,731 6,708,391 Employed 60,867 92.6% 6,339,429 94.5% Unemployed 4,864 7.4% 368,962 5.5% Male CLF 22,249 2,519,027 Employed 20,914 94.0% 2,390,557 94.9% Unemployed 1,335 6.0% 128,470 5.1% Female CLF 24,436 2,559,750 Employed 22,725 93.0% 2,431,763 95.0% Unemployed 1,711 7.0% 127,988 5.0% White CLF 43,124 4,342,655 Employed 40,795 94.6% 4,147,236 95.5% Unemployed 2,329 5.4% 195,419 4.5% Black CLF 17,259 1,269,048 Employed 15,222 88.2% 1,154,834 91.0% Unemployed 2,037 11.8% 114,214 9.0% Asian CLF 1,748 420,320 Employed 1,626 93.0% 402,667 95.8% Unemployed 122 7.0% 17,653 4.2% Hispanic CLF 2,217 529,633 Employed 2,062 93.0% 501,033 94.6% Unemployed 155 7.0% 28,600 5.4% Source: American Community Survey, 2013 – 2017 85 Housing Market Housing Inventory According to 2013-2017 ACS data, Lynchburg’s housing inventory consisted of 32,309 dwelling units in 2017. The housing stock grew by only 317 housing units, representing a 1.0% increase since 2010. However, it should be noted that 543 new multi -family units were created between 2014 and 2017 according to records from the City of Lynchburg’s Community Development Department. Discrepancies between the 2017 ACS and local data are likely due to the Census Bureau estimating housing units through sampling, resulting in a degree of uncertainty in the data compared to actual counts. Figure 17 Total Housing Units, Lynchburg 2010 – 2017 Location Total Housing Units (2010) Total Housing Units (2017) Percentage Change Lynchburg 31,992 32,309 1.0% Source: Census Bureau, Decennial Census, 2010: H1; American Community Survey, 2013 - 2017: B25001 Types of Housing Units The majority of Lynchburg’s housing stock in 2017 was single-family housing units which comprised 65.6% of all housing units. Conversely, multi-family units comprised 33.81% of the total housing stock in Lynchburg. Multi-family housing can be a more affordable housing option that provides members of the protected classes access to other parts of the City that are otherwise unaffordable. The City’s 28,513 occupied units were 49.7% owner-occupied and 50.3% renter-occupied. Single-family housing made up almost all owner-occupied housing units, at 96.6%. Multifamily housing composed 64.6% of all renter -occupied units and 35.0% single -family housing. Building more multi -family affordable housing outside of these areas will provide greater housing choice for residents in need of opportunities, such as better schools, jobs, or safe neighborhoods that lie outside of the traditional affordable housing locations. Areas with the highest percentages of multifamily rental units are concentrated around Liberty University and the University of Lynchburg. The City’s largest employer, 86 Centra Health, is also in an area with a high concentration of multifamily units. Areas further away from these institutions have higher concentrations of single family housing. 87 Map 5 Homeownership Rate, 2017 Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey 88 Map 6 Percentage of housing units as multifamily rental units, 2017 89 Figure 18 Trends in Housing units in Structures, Lynchburg 2017 Type of Housing Total Percent of Total Housing Single Family Housing 18,457 65.6% Multi-Family Housing 9,528 33.8% 2 - 4 Units 2,981 10.6% 5 - 9 Units 2,079 7.4% 10 - 19 Units 2,078 7.4% 20 or More Units 2,390 8.5% Mobile Homes 165 0.6% Total Housing Units 28,150 Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 - 2017, B25032 Figure 19 Housing Units by Structures and Housing Type, Lynchburg 2017 Type of Housing Total Percent of Total Housing Owner-Occupied Housing 13,978 49.7% Single-Family Units 13,501 48.0% Multi-Family Units 376 1.3% Renter-Occupied Housing 14,172 50.3% Single-Family Units 4,956 17.6% Multi-Family Units 9,152 32.5% total housing units 28,150 Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 - 2017, B25032 90 Vacancy Status Lynchburg has a slightly higher vacancy rate than the State at 12.9% compared to 10.4%. Rental vacancy rates in Lynchburg (5.4%) are higher than homeowner vacancy rates (3.1%) Relative to the State, rental vacancies in Lynchburg are lower (5.8% for all of Virginia) while homeowner vacancies are higher (1.6% for all of Virginia). Vacancy rates data come from the American Community Survey, which defines vacancy rate as the ratio of vacant available units to total units. The lower rental vacancy rate is expected due to Lynchburg’s large student population. Given that Lynchburg has a relatively even split between owners and renters, the relatively high homeowner vacancy rates may indicate a ne ed for more multifamily housing units, or the quality of homes for-sale are lacking. The highest rental vacancy rates are concentrated around the University of Lynchburg and Liberty University. While dormitories are excluded from the Census’ housing unit count, vacancy is determined if no one is living in a specific unit at the time of the interview. This includes vacant units that are currently for rent or those have been rented but the new renters have not yet moved in. As a result, student populations may inflate vacancy rates when taking into consideration off-campus housing. Figure 20 Change in Vacancy Status, Lynchburg 2010 – 2017 Vacancy Status 2017 % Vacant Total Vacant Housing Units 4,159 12.9% Vacant for Rent 846 2.6% Vacant Rented Units 606 1.9% Vacant for Sale 456 1.4% Vacant Sold (not occupied) 58 0.1% Vacant (seasonal, recreational or occasional use) 568 1.8% Vacant (other) 1,625 5.0% Total Housing Units 32,309 1.0% Source: Census Bureau, Decennial Census, 2010: QT-H1; American Community Survey, 2013 -2017: B25004 91 Map 7 Homeowner Vacancy Rates, 2017 Source: 2013-2017 ACS 92 Map 8 Rental Vacancy Rates, 2017 Source: 2013-2017 ACS 93 Protected Class Status and Homeownership The value in homeownership lies in the accumulation of wealth as the owner’s share of equity increases with the property’s value. Paying a monthly mortgage instead of rent is an investment in an asset that is likely to appreciate. Minority households tended to have lower rates of homeownership. Historically, minorities tend to have lower homeownership rates than Whites due in large part to housing discrimination and redlining . As previously noted, Lynchburg’s median incomes for minority households are lower than those of White households. This is one among several factors that contributed to the lower rates of homeowner ship among minority households across Lynchburg. In 2017, White households had a homeownership rate of 58.6%. This was significantly higher than minority homeownership rates. Black households had the second highest homeownership rate at 33.1%, followed by Asians at 27.8%, and Hispanics at 20.5%. Black homeownership was highest in the Fort Hill neighborhood and the western outskirts of Lynchburg. Figure 21 Housing Tenure by Race and Ethnicity, Lynchburg 2017 Race Ethnicity Total Households Homeowners Homeownership Rate White 18,698 10,959 58.6% Black / African American 8,299 2,750 33.1% Asian 561 156 27.8% Hispanic / Latino 561 115 20.5% Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2013 - 2017, B25003, B25003A, B25003B, B25003D, B25003I 94 Map 9 Black Homeownership Rate, 2017 Source: 2013.-2017 American Community Survey 95 The Tendency of Protected Classes to Live in Larger Households Larger households may be at risk for housing discrimination on the basis of race and the presence of children (familial status). A larger household, whether or not children are present, can raise fair housing concerns. If there are policies or programs that restrict the number of persons that can live together in a single housing unit, and members of the protected classes need more b edrooms to accommodate their larger household, there is a fair housing concern because the restriction on the size of the unit will have a negative impact on members of the protected classes. Minority households were more likely than White households to live in households with four or more people. In 2011, 25.5% of White households had four or more persons. By comparison, Black, Asian, and Hispanic households had higher rates of larger households. Figure 22 Large-Family Households (4 persons or more) by Race / Ethnicity, Lynchburg 2010 Race / Ethnicity Total Percent White 2,666 25.5% Black 1,766 34.4% Asian 155 44.7% Hispanic 160 44.7% All Households 4,760 29.1% Source: Census Bureau, Census 2010, SF-1 P28, P28A, P28B, P28D, P28H In order to house larger families, a sufficient supply of larger dwelling units consisting of three or more bedrooms is necessary. Since minority households are more likely to have larger families and be renters, there needs to be a sufficient supply of larger rental units to meet the needs of their families. While 56.0% of housing units in Lynchburg have at least three bedrooms, rental units only made up 29.7% of these larger bedroom units. This could potentially constrain the housing choice for lower income families that cannot afford to purchase a home. 96 Figure 23 Housing Units by Number of Bedrooms and Tenure, Lynchburg 2017 Number of bedrooms Renter-Occupied Owner-Occupied Total Percent Total Percent 0 - 1 bedrooms 2,641 18.6% 133 1.0% 2 bedrooms 6,843 48.3% 2,766 19.8% 3 bedrooms 3,822 27.0% 6,186 44.3% 4 bedrooms or more 866 6.1% 4,893 35.0% Total 14,172 100% 13,978 100% Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2013 - 2017: B25042 97 Cost of Housing While home values decreased by 3.8% after adjusting for inflation, gross rent increased by 11.5% during the same time period after adjusting for inflation. The inflation adjusted median income slightly increase in Lynchburg by 1.1% between 2010 and 2017. Increasing housing costs are not a direct form of housing discrimination. However, a lack of affo rdable housing does constrain housing choice. Residents may be limited to a smaller selection of neighborhoods or communities because of a lack of affordable housing in those areas. Lower income residents will have severely limited housing options if rent continues to outpace income growth at this rate. Conversely, decreasing home values may allow for low-income households to transition to homeownership. Figure 24 Trends in Median Home Value, Rent, and Household Income, Lynchburg 2010-2017 2010 (adj. to 2017 dollars) 2017 Percent Change Median Home Value $159,888 $153,800 -3.8% Median Gross Rent $749 $835 11.5% Median Household Income $41,531 $41,971 1.1% Source: Census Bureau, American Community Survey, 2006 – 2010: B19013; B25064; B25077 American Community Survey, 2013 - 2017: B19013; B25064; B25077 98 Map 10 Median Household Income, 2017 Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey 99 Map 11 Median Home Value, 2017 Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey 100 Map 12 Change in Median Home Value, 2017 Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey 101 Map 13 Median Gross Rent, 2017 Source: American Community Survey, 2013-2017 102 Map 14 Change in Median Gross Rent, 2010-2017 Source: American Community Survey, 2013-2017 103 Cost-Burden In Lynchburg, 35.5% of all households are cost -burdened, and renters (49.4%) are more disproportionately cost-burdened than homeowners (19.8%). Cost burdened households are defined by HUD as households spending more than 30% of their annual income on housing costs. Severely cost burdened households spend more than 50% of their income. Independent from median income, cost burden serves as an indicator of a homeowner’s ability to afford property mainte nance and improvements. Additionally, according to 2011 -2015 CHAS data, elderly households are nearly disproportionately cost-burdened (44.9%). Areas with a high proportion of cost-burdened homeowners also tend to have cost-burdened renters as well. These areas are centered around the University of Lynchburg, which itself is located in a census tract that is not cost-burdened. The HUD-defined R/ECAP is also part of these highly cost -burdened areas. However, the modified R/ECAPs do not have nearly have as high of rates of cost-burden. According to the 2019 Bridges to Progress report, Redlin ing in Lync hburg, housing insecu rity is associated with evictions, a higher cost of living, hypermobility (move from one home to another frequently), mental health problems, physical health problems, crime, poor educational outcomes, increased chances of employment layoffs and detachment from the labor force. 104 Map 15 Cost-burdened Homeowners Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey 105 Map 16 Cost-burdened Renters Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey 106 | P a g e Communities of Opportunity An Opportunity Index was developed to classify and visualize areas of opport unity for Lynchburg residents. The Opportunity Index identifies areas in which new developments may be more financially feasible in the long-term due to proximity to factors that allow residents to have successful access to employment, quality education, and a healthy environment. The data is linearly normalized to values between 0 and 1, after which census tracts are classified into quintiles ranging from Very Low Opportunity to Very High Opportunity. The Composite Opportunity Index averages six indices th at measure different areas of opportunity: prosperity, labor market engagement, job access, transit access, community health, and school proficiency. Overall, the highest opportunity areas are found in the western portions of Lynchburg away from Downtown a nd the Fort Hill neighborhood south of the University of Lynchburg. Further detail into each component index is included below. Map 17 Composite Opportunity Index 107 | P a g e Prosperity Index This index is a c ombination of poverty rate and the percentage of households with children receiving public assistance. Public assistance includes Supplemental Security Income (SSI), cash public assistance income, or Food Stamps/SNAP. Poverty has lasting effects that can impact a wide range of factors, including public education primarily funded by the local community, job opportunities, and the ability to afford quality housing. Prosperity scores were highest on the western side of Lynchburg while lowest near Downtown. Map 18 Prosperity Index 108 | P a g e Labor Market Engagement Index The Labor Force Engagement Index is a measure of the relative intensity of labor market engagement and human capital. As defined by HUD, the index is a combination of unemployment rates, labor force participation rates, and percent of the population with at least a bachelor’s degree within a census tract. Employment opportunities are necessary for individuals to afford stable housing. Labor force participation represents the amount of labor resources available for the production for goods and services. The percent of the population with at least a bachelor’s degree is used to estimate the availability of skilled labor. The three variables were averaged to produce the Labor Market Engagement Index. Areas outside of Liberty University and the University of Lynchburg along with Downtown Lynchburg had the highest scores. Lowest scores are in the modified R/ECAPs and the site of the universities themselves, likely a result of high student populations. Map 19 Labor Market Engagement Index 109 | P a g e Job Access Index Job Access was calculated based on the “as the crow flies” distance or straight -line distance from the center of a census tract from population and job centers. Areas with many jobs were positively weighted and areas with a high labor supply were inversely weighted due to increased competition. The highest scores were found near the universities and along the Lynchburg Expressway. Areas with low job access had low densities or met the definition of an R/ECAP. Map 20 Job Access Index 110 | P a g e Transit Access Index Transit Access represents the ease with which people can access public transportation. The Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) under the US Department of Transpo rtation, most people are willing to walk for five to ten minutes to a transit stop. FHWA uses these walking times as a proxy for distance, estimating accessible transit stops being ¼ to ½ mile away from a pedestrian’s starting point, typically their place of residence. To calculate accessibility, ¼ mile and ½ buffers were placed around each transit stop to find the percentage of a census tract that is within walking distance to a transit stop. This percentage was averaged to produce the Transit Access Index . Transit stop data was supplied by the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company. The areas just outside of Downtown Lynchburg had the best transit access score, which includes all R/ECAPs. Areas in the northwest and southeast had the poorest access, with one area being the location of Liberty University. Map 21 Transit Access Index 111 | P a g e Community Health Index The Community Health Index is a function of the percentage of residents in a census tract without health insurance and low food access as ranked by the USDA. Low food access is defined by the USDSA as where at least one-third of a census tract’s population is more than a half-mile from the nearest grocery store. Health hazards have an adverse effect on children’s growth and development and can limit one’s ability to work. Low-income and minority individuals are also found to be disproportionately affected by health hazards, perpetuating the lack of opportunity for vulnerable populations. Areas with the lowest community health scores are largely residential and include the modified R/ECAPs. Map 22 Community Health Index 112 | P a g e School Proficiency Index The School Proficiency Index uses school-level data on the performance of 4th grade students on state exams to describe which neighborhoods have high-performing elementary schools nearby and which are near lower performing elementary schools. Values are percentile ranked and range from 0 to 100. The higher the school proficiency index score, the higher the school system proficiency. The school proficiency index is a function of the percent of 4th grade students proficient in reading and math on state test scores for up to three sc hools within 1.5 miles of the block -group. Scores are assigned to a census tract by taking the average of the block groups. Quality education is critical for the growth and development of children and enhancing their future opportunities. The most proficie nt schools are found in the western and eastern extremities of Lynchburg. The least proficient schools are found along the southern border of Lynchburg and just north of Lakeside Drive. Map 23 School Proficiency Index 113 | P a g e Public Sector Policy Analysis The analysis of impediments is a review of impediments to fair housing choice in the public and private sector. Impediments to fair housing choice are any actions, omissions, or decisions taken because of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status or national origin that restrict housing choices or the availability of housing choices, or any actions, omissions or decisions that have the effect of restricting housing choices or the availability of housing choices on the basis of race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status or national origin. Policies, practices or procedures that appear neutral on their face but which operate to deny or adversely affect the provision of housing to persons of a particular race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status or national origin may constitute such impediments. In Virginia, the additional protected class of elderliness (55 and older) is also included along with the seven from the Fair Housing Act. An important element o f the AI includes an examination of public policy in terms of its impact on housing choice. This section evaluates public policies in order to determine opportunities for affirmatively furthering fair housing. 114 | P a g e City of Lynchburg 2013-2030 Comprehensive Plan This section will review local planning initiatives outlined in Lynchburg’s 2013-2030 Comprehensive Plan as it relates to affordable housing, desegregation, elimination of poverty, and fair housing policies. Overall, the Comprehensive Plan advocates for expanding housing choices and improving conditions for LMI and special needs residents through renovation, rehabilitation, and multimodal transition, but falls short in terms of de-segregating racially and ethnically concentrated areas of poverty (R/ECAPs). The Comprehensive Plan was adopted on September 27, 2013 and has a chapter dedicated to neighborhoods and housing. Housing goals identified in the plan include:  Providing diverse housing choices  Increasing the number of owner-occupied units  Rehabilitating substandard housing with an emphasis requiring an investment of funds and/or labor on the part of the owner commensurate with the owner’s resources  Supporting initiatives to increase permanent affordable rental and housing ownership opportunities  Supporting programs that assist individuals in retaining their homes in challenging economic times Lynchburg identifies three types of neighborhoods in the City, each with unique housing needs: traditional neighborhoods, suburban neighborhoods, and mixed -use nei ghborhoods. Traditional neighborhoods provide convenient access to goods and services due to their proximity to downtown and smaller units of naturally affordable housing. The plan identifies a need to provide flexible zoning and policies along with active code enforcement to keep properties maintained and updated while preserving neighborhood character. Mixed-use neighborhoods see similar development patterns and needs as traditional neighborhoods. Suburban neighborhoods are identified as areas predominantly consisting of low -density, single family homes further away from the downtown core. The City emphasizes improving access and infrastructure, such as sidewalks and bikeways and implementing small-scale neighborhood retail and services at key intersections in suburban areas. 115 | P a g e Age and affordability of housing are areas of major concern for the City’s overall housing stock, especial for lower income residents. Lynchburg homes are generally older than that of the State of Virginia, with a median year built of 1969 for Lynchburg versus 1981 in Virginia, according the 2013 -2017 ACS. The primary method of improving housing conditions if the City’s aging housing stock will be through renovations and rehabilitation. Funding will be conducted through loans , tax abatements, and/or tax credits. A program to encouraging renovation, reviewing loan programs, and working with builders and financial institutions to develop guides on renovation and rehabilitation are being explored. While housing costs are generally lower compared to the State, the plan makes apparent the disproportionate rates of cost-burden on lower income households. The needs of Lynchburg’s lower income households are primarily addressed through the City’s Consolidated Plan and CDBG funds. Figure 25 Housing Costs in the City of Lynchburg and State of Virginia, Virginia Lynchburg Median Home Value $ 255,800 $ 153,800 Median Gross Rent $ 1,166 $ 835 Median Contract Rent $ 981 $ 665 Source: 2013-2017 American Community Survey The City also determined its large student population creates housing concerns in terms of competition with LMI households for affordable units and the ability to maintain upkeep of these properties. Collaboration with schools and landlords along with rental housing registration and inspection is planned to expand citywide. LMI households interested in homeownership will be addressed by coordinating with lenders and housing providers to implement programs that reduce barriers to homeownership. In terms of furthering fair housing policies, the plan emphasizes the role and proximity of public transit and social services for special needs populations. This population includes aging residents, individuals with physical and mental disabilities, and lower income residents. The primary avenue for improving special needs housing through promoting rehabilitation of housing units using a mix of funding possibilities. The City found that having access to goods and services needed on a regular basis (food, parks, schools, etc.) plays a large role in all their residents’ quality of life. 116 | P a g e Finally, the plan has a dedicated chapter on transportation, outlining initiatives to implement the Better Streets Policy and Multimodal System Design Guidelines. These initiatives serve as guiding principles for planning for all modes of transportation to support the delivery and access of goods and services. The Better Streets Policy prioritizes the needs of pedestrians, bicyclists, transit, street trees, stormwater, utilities, and livability to improve citizens’ quality of life. Similarly, Multimodal System Guidelines were created by the Virginia Department of Rail and Public Transportation (DRPT) to accommodate for all modes of transportation and be adapted to local needs. Adoption of t hese guidelines also improves implementation by creating consistency between local planning efforts and the Virginia Department of Transportation. There is no clear mention, however, of de-segregating areas of concentrated poverty and/or minorities. Almost one-third of the city is Black, and R/ECAPs in Lynchburg were defined and identified in the Data Analysis section of the AI. The City should make more apparent the parallels between de-concentration of LMI minorities and the goals and initiatives identified in the plan for improving access and opportunity for residents. More transparent connections to anti-poverty strategies, such as Bridge to Progress, and its links to housing could also be made, such as those included in the Consolidated Plan. 117 | P a g e Zoning Risk Assessment The City of Lynchburg adopted its current zoning ordinance on February 23, 2016 and it was evaluated based on the following criteria on how the ordinance:  Defines “family” inclusively, without a cap on the number of unrelated persons and with a focus on functioning as a single housekeeping unit  Defines “group home” for persons with disabilities or similarly named land use compared to single family dwellings  Allows up to 6 unrelated people with disabilities to reside in a group home without requiring a special use/conditional use permit or public hearing  Regulates the siting of group homes as single family dwelling units without an additional regulatory provision  Has a “Reasonable Accommodation” provision or allows for persons with disabilities to request reasonable accommodation/modification to regulatory provisions  Permits multi-family housing of more than 4 units per structure in one or more residential zoning districts by-right  Does not distinguish between “affordable housing/multi-family housing” (i.e. financed with public funds) and “multi-family housing” (i.e. financed with private funds)  Does not restrict residential uses such as emergency housing/homeless shelters, transitional housing, or permanent supportive housing facilities exclusively to non-residential zoning districts  Permits manufactured and modular housing on single lots like single family dwelling units  Provides residential zoning districts with minimum lot sizes of ¼ acre or less  Does not include exterior design/aesthetic standards for all single-family dwelling units regardless of size, location, or zoning district Overall, the zoning ordinance of the City of Lynchburg is at a low risk relative to discriminatory provisions for housing members of protected classes. Although the definition of “family” is limited to no more than three unrelated persons living together as a household, the number is expanded to four to eight for residents of group homes. Small group homes, defined as fewer than four aged or infirmed individuals or fewer than eight individuals with mental, intellectual or developmental disabilities, are permitted by right in all residential districts. Additionally, no conditions more restrictive than those imposed on residences occupied by persons rel ated by blood, marriage, or adoption can be imposed on group homes. This is consistent with fair housing law. While larger group homes need a conditional use permit in all residential districts, group homes do not typically exceed six people. 118 | P a g e The following table summarizes the zoning risk assessment for Lynchburg. A score of 12 places the ordinance at low risk relative to discriminatory provisions for housing members of protected classes. A score of 13-14 places a zoning ordinance at moderate risk, while any higher score indicates a potentially high risk. Lynchburg’s score of 12 equates to a low risk factor. 119 | P a g e Figure 26 City of Lynchburg, VA Assessment of Fair Housing Scoring: 1 – low risk for discrimination 2 – high risk for discrimination Zoning Ordinance Regulatory Provision Score 1. Ordinance defines “family” inclusively, without cap on number of unrelated persons, with focus on functioning as a single housekeeping unit Ex: Two or more persons who live in the same dwelling unit and function as a single housekeeping unit Yes (1) No (2) 2 2. Ordinance defines “group home” or similarly named land use as “a single family dwelling unit” Yes (1) No (2) 2 3. Ordinance allows up to 6 unrelated people with disabilities to reside in a group home without requiring a special use / conditional use permit or public hearing Yes (1) No (2) 1 4. Ordinance regulates group homes as single family dwelling units without any a dditional regulatory provisions Yes (1) No (2) 1 5. Ordinance has a Reasonable Accommodation provision or allows for persons with disabilities to request reasonable accommodation / modification to regulatory provisions Yes (1) No (2) 1 6. Ordinance permits multi-family housing of more than 4 units/structure in one or more residential zoning districts by-right Yes (1) No (2) 1 7. Ordinance does not distinguish between “affordable housing / multi-family housing” (i.e., financed with public funds) and “multi-family housing” (i.e., financed without any public funds) Yes (1) No (2) 1 8. Ordinance does not restrict residential uses such as emergency housing/homeless shelters, transitional housing or permanent supportive housing facilities exclusively to non-residential zoning districts Yes (1) No (2) 1 9. Ordinance permits manufactured and modular housing on single lots like single family dwelling units Yes (1) No (2) 1 10. Ordinance provides residential zoning districts with minimum lot sizes of ¼ acre or less Yes (1) No (2) 1 TOTAL SCORE 12 11-12: Ordinance is at LOW risk relative to discriminatory provisions for housing and members of the protected classes. 13-14: Ordinance is at MODERATE risk relative to discriminatory provisions for housing and members of the protected classes. 15 and higher: Ordinance is at HIGH risk relative to discriminatory provisions for housing and members of the protected classes. 120 | P a g e Local Building Codes Accessible design and construction requirements are necessary to make public and common use spaces and facilities accessible to everyone . This gives people with disabilities greater freedom of choice to choose where they live. The Fair Housing Act requires all “covered multifamily dwellings” to be accessible to and usable by people with disabilities. Here, covered multifamily dwellings are defined as buildings containing four or more units, either with all ground floor units or at least one elevator. The following seven accessibility standards are required by the Fair Housing Act for these dwelling units: 1. An accessible building entrance on an accessible route. 2. Accessible common and public use areas 3. Usable doors (usable by a person in a wheelchair) 4. Accessible route into and through the dwelling unit 5. Light switches, electrical outlets, thermostats, and other environmental controls in accessible locations 6. Reinforced walls in bathrooms for later installation of grab bars 7. Usable kitchens and bathrooms Additionally, it is unlawful to refuse to make reasonable accommodati ons that allow for a person with a disability equal opportunity and use and enjoy their home. Building design and construction standards in Lynchburg more than adequately implements accessible measures for people with disabilities by utilizing state buildi ng codes. The City incorporates three parts of the Virginia Uniform Statewide Building Code (USBC) for their construction, rehabilitation and maintenance regulations. These regulations were last updated in 2018. Two sections, t he Virginia Construction Code and the Virginia Existing Building Code , each dedicate a chapter to accessibility , meeting the accessibility requirements outlined by the Fair Housing Act along with providing additional protections. The Virginia Construction Cod e (VCC) deems a structure as being constructed in accordance with universal design features for accessibility, dwellings must comply with Section 1005 of ICC (International Code Council) A117.1 Accessible and Usable Buildings and Facilities. All seven requ irements of the Fair 121 | P a g e Housing Act’s accessibility standards are covered under this code. The Virginia Construction Code also requires that at least one bedroom , one bathroom regardless of size, food preparation areas, and thermostats must be available on the entrance level of a dwelling. All bathrooms must include a shower or bathtub with reinforcement for future installation of grab bars. For existing structures, the Virginia Existing Building Code abides by 2015 International Existing Building Code (IEBC) standards. Existing buildings or structures that undergo a complete change of occupancy or use must implement all accessibility features mentioned in the Fair Housing Act. Existing buildings observing only a partial change in occupancy are not required to implement these features. Alterations must comply with the requirements of the VCC to the maximum extent technically feasible. Toilet rooms that cannot be feasibly modified to be accessible allows for the construction of new toilet rooms on the same floor and areas as the existing toilet rooms along with appropriate signage. Accessible dwelling units in historic buildings are not required to comply with VCC standards; however, the public spaces of historic buildings must provide accessible arrival points and entrances. 122 | P a g e Anti-Displacement Plan and Relocation Plan Anti-displacement and Relocation Plans serve to advance the interests of lower-income individuals and households at risk of displacement due to neighborhood changes in various sectors, such as housing, businesses, and infrastructure. The replacement plan is compliant with HUD regulation 24 CFR § 42 and 24 CFR § 570 outlining plans and strategies for addressing displacement. The City requires that all occupied and vacant LMI dwelling units expect ed to undergo demolition, rehabilitation, and conversion activities assisted with funds provided through CDBG or HOME programs will be replaced within three years. A replacement plan submitted to HUD will include in writing:  A description of the proposed activity  A map providing the location and number units described by number of bedrooms that will be demolished or converted and the replacement units that will be provided  A time schedule for commencement and completion of the demolition or conversion  The source of funding and a time schedule for provision of replacement units  The basis for concluding that each replacement unit will remain a LMI dwelling unit for ten years from the date of initial occupancy. The City will utilize the following displacement strategy to minimize or prevent displacement , keep residents in their present neighborhoods, or otherwise mitigate adverse effects of displacement:  Plan, organize, and stage the rehabilitation of assisted housing to allow tenants to remain during and after rehabilitation to provide the most convenient, safe, and economically sound rehabilitation effort possible  Assist in the identification of temporary relocation facilities to house families whose displacement will be of short duration so that they can move back to their neighborhood after completion of rehabilitation or new construction  Evaluate housing codes and rehabilitation standards in reinvestment areas to prevent the placing of undue financial burdens on long-established homeowners or tenants of multifamily buildings 123 | P a g e  Counsel and advise homeowners and renters to understand the range of assistance that may be available to meet and protect their housing rights and interests.  In cooperation with neighborhood organizations, continuously review neighborhood development trends, identify displacement problems, and identify individuals facing displacement who need assistance.  Provide lower-income housing in the neighborhood through HUD housing programs; purchase units as-is; rehabilitate vacant units; or construct housing units.  Give priority in assisted housing units in the neighborhood to area residents facing displacement.  Target Section 8 existing programs and certificates to households being displaced, and recruit area landlords to participate in the program.  Provide counseling and referral services to assist persons displaced in finding alternate housing in the neighborhood.  Work with area landlords and real estate brokers to locate vacancies or households facing displacement.  Use public funds, such as CDBG and/or HOME, to pay moving costs and provide relocation payments, or, to the extent permissible by local or state law, require private developers to provide compensation to persons displaced by development activities.  Give persons displaced priority in obtaining subsidized housing.  Provide counseling and referral services to assist persons displaced to locate elsewhere in the community. In carrying out this strategy, Lynchburg ensures all displaced residents are provided housing that is decent, safe, and sanitary, adequate in size, functionally equivalent to their previous residence, and in an area not subject to adverse environmental conditions. 124 | P a g e LRHA Tenant/ Applicant Demographics Historically, assisted housing had been highly segregated and concentrated in areas of poverty through ineffective management, redlining, and other discriminatory practices. However, public housing authorities, such as LRHA, are attempting to take appropriate actions to overcome the effects of these impediments. Members of the protected class are disproportionately represented in public housing, particularly Black households. Conversely, Hispanic households are underrepresented. However, it should be noted that Lynchburg’s Hispanic population is small, consisting of only 3% of the total population. Figure 27 Tenant Demographics – Black and Hispanic Households Source: Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority The elderly and persons with disabilities show relatively high representation in Section 8 housing but underrepresentation in public housing. Persons with disabilities represent 38.0% of Section 8 HCV holders but are only 11.2% of public housing tenants. Similarly, 35.7% of Section 8 HCV holders are elderly compared to 13.9% of all Lynchburg residents and 6.7% of public housing tenants. As defined in LRHA’s Admissions and Continued Occupancy Policy (last updated in 2018), local preferences include victims of domestic viole nce, homeless individuals and their families, veterans, working families, the elderly, and the disabled. Victims of domestic violence, homeless persons, and veterans have a higher level of preference than the elderly and persons with disabilities. 72.1% 86.9% 29.3% 1.1% 0.6% 3.0% 0.0% 20.0% 40.0% 60.0% 80.0% 100.0% Section 8 HCVs Public Housing City of Lynchburg % Black % Hispanic 125 | P a g e Figure 28 Tenant Demographics – Disability and Elderly Status Source: Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority 38.0% 11.2% 14.2% 35.7% 6.7% 13.9% 0.0% 5.0% 10.0% 15.0% 20.0% 25.0% 30.0% 35.0% 40.0% Section 8 HCVs Public Housing City of Lynchburg % Disability % Elderly 126 | P a g e CDBG/HOME Investments The Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Program provides annual grants on a formula basis to states, cities, and counties to develop viable urban communities by providing decent housing and a suitable living environment, and by expanding economic opportunities, principally for low - and moderate-income persons. Similarly, the HOME Investment Partnerships Program (HOME) provides formula grants to States and localities that communities use - often in partnership with local nonprofit groups - to fund a wide range of activities including building, buying, and/or rehabilitating affordable housing for rent or homeownership or providing direct rental assistance to low-income people. HOME is the largest federal block grant to state and local governments designed exclusively to create affordable housing opportunities for low-income households. During PY 2015-2019, 92 housing units received some form of housing assistance using CDBG or HOME funds. Rental rehabilitation was the most common form of investment, consisting of 69 units or 75% of all assisted housing units using CDBG or HOME funds. The remaining investments include eleven homeowner rehabilitations and twelve homeownership assistances. Less than half (45) of all assisted units are in R/ECAPs, indicating an effort to deconcentrate poverty in Lynchburg. 127 | P a g e Map 24 CDBG and HOME Investments Source: City of Lynchburg 128 | P a g e Assisted Housing Location Patterns Housing programs serving very -low- and low -income households have historically exacerbated problems of concentrated poverty. However, modern agencies are attempting to administer programs and housing to provide better opportunities for their clients. While most of Lynchburg’s assisted housing is located in lower opportunity areas, these areas have better access to public transit that serve important roles for assisted housing tenants and facilitate the use of vital goods and services. The Lynchburg Red evelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) provides affordable housing through public housing and Section 8 Housing Choice Vouchers (HCVs). As of 2019, LRHA owns and operates 328 units of public housing at four locations within the City. Only one public housing property, the 100- unit Dearington Apartments, is located in an R/ECAP. Other public housing developments are located in census tracts with overall moderate (Brookside and Birchwood Apartments) or high levels (Langview Apartments) of opportunity relative to the rest of the City. These areas can be characterized as having moderate levels of prosperity, moderate health outcomes, and good access to public transit while have poor access to job opportunities and quality schools. According to PolicyMap, Lynchbu rg has 1,318 Section 8 HCV holders and showed similar distribution patterns as public housing. Most HCV holders resided in or around the R/ECAPs while no HCV holders could be found in any of the highest opportunity areas in the western and northern parts of the City. Properties receiving Low Income Housing Tax Credits numbered at 26 properties, with a total of 1,621 housing units. Housing units set aside for low-income Lynchburg residents made up 89.9% of housing units, or 1,458 units. Of these units, 23.9% or 349 low -income units are located in either the HUD - defined R/ECAP or the modified R/ECAPs. Compared to Section 8 housing, LIHTC recipients have a more diverse geographic distribution and can be found in more high opportunity areas such as Census Tract 1, which includes the neighborhoods of Boonsboro, Peakland, and Riverside. However, there are still no LIHTC units located in the highest opportunity areas. 129 | P a g e Map 25 Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority’s Public Housing Inventory, 2020 Source: Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority 130 | P a g e Map 26 Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority’s Section 8 Housing Choice Voucher Holders, 2018 Source: Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority 131 | P a g e Map 27 City of Lynchburg LIHTC Properties, 2018 Source: PolicyMap; HUD 132 | P a g e Location of Major Employers and Employment Opportunities The United States Office of Management and Budget delineates metropolitan statistical areas as a core area containing a substantial population of at least one urbanized area of 50,000 or more inhabitants and having high levels of economic and social integration. As a result, commuting and employment opportunities are best observed at the regiona l level. The City of Lynchburg serves as the core of the Lynchburg Metropolitan Statistical Area, which also includes the neighboring counties of Amherst, Appomattox, Bedford, and Campbell. Accessibility to jobs from a given residential neighborhood is a function of a block group’s distance to all job locations and labor supply (competition). Block groups close to job opportunities and with less competition tend to receive higher scores. Job opportunities are defined here as the number of jobs within a bloc k group and labor supply the number of workers within in a block group. Distance is measured as the most direct path between the centers of block groups. Areas with the highest levels of job access are located along the Lynchburg Expressway, especially in areas close to Liberty University and the University of Lynchburg. R/ECAPs have the lowest levels of job access. Additionally, very few assisted housing units are located in these areas, potentially impeding employment opportunities for low- and moderate-income households. It is important to note that job quality is not measured; this index only captures the quantity of jobs and workers. Job quality is a complex and multifaceted concept that can include a variety of factors weighted differently by individual preferences, including pay and benefits, job security, health and safety, work - life balance, and more. The high concentration of universities in the area may show a demand and need for highly skilled workers not typically found in low - and moderate-income households. Additionally, the areas with high job access have large commercial areas. While these jobs are accessible, they may not provide adequate career progression to lift low- and moderate-income families out of poverty. 133 | P a g e Map 28 Job Access & Assisted Housing Source: LEHD; Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority; HUD 134 | P a g e Public Transit Public transit provides additional mobility options for individuals with limited choices due to financial and/or physical barriers or lifestyle choices. Half fares are offered for individuals 65 years of age or older, Medicare Card holders, or persons with disabilities. Persons with disabilities must provide a letter from a physician stating they have a permanent disability. For individuals without a personal vehicle, proximity to transit stops is important to accessing services and amenities. According to the Pedestrian Safety Guide for Transit Agencies by the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) under the US Department of Transportation, most people are willing to walk for five to ten minutes to a transit stop. FHWA uses these walking times as a proxy for distance, estimating accessible transit stops being ¼ to ½ mile away from a pedestrian’s starting point, typically their place of residence. The following map displays two buffers with ¼ mile and ½ mile radii to determine transit accessibility. Transit stop data was provided by the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company (GLTC) for fixed bus routes. R/ECAPs are also shown to ensure that areas where poverty and race intersect have adequate access to vital public services such as transit. All R/ECAPs are located within walkable distance to public transit stops. The areas with the poorest transit access can be found in the northwestern and eastern portions of the City. Additionally, all assisted housing properties are within accessible walking distance to transit stops in Lynchburg. Further consideration should be made based on available pedestrian infrastructure (e.g. sidewalks, crosswalks, curb extensions, etc.) and pedestrian characteristics such as age, physical disabilities, and English proficiency. Higher opportunity areas within walking distance to public transit stops are located in the southwestern portion of the City, specifically Census Tract 18 along Graves Mill Road. Landlord participation in these areas should be considered to deconcentrate poverty and improve opportunities for voucher holders. 135 | P a g e Map 29 Transit Access Source: Greater Lynchburg Transit Company 136 | P a g e Language Access Plan To improve public safety, health, convenience, comfort, and general welfare of all residents, a language access plan is necessary for individuals who are non-English speaking or have limited English proficiency (LEP) to access available services. While Lynchburg does not meet the safe harbor threshold requirement for a Language Access Plan, the City has 896 Spanish-speakers with LEP. The safe harbor threshold is met when a language group with LEP exceeds the lesser of 5% of the population or 1,000 persons. The City has a brief Language Assistance Plan in place in case an LEP group meets the threshold. The purpose of the plan is to ensure “meaningful access to housing and community development program information and services” for the City’s LEP population. Interpretation and translation services are offered free of charge. Contact information for further clarification on offered services is also provided. While a language access plan is cu rrently not required for the City, there is room for improvement to provide more specific guidelines when providing language assistance. This includes written guidelines for staff training on policies and procedures for providing language assistance, provi sion of notices of language assistance services, and the monitoring and updating the language access plan. 137 | P a g e Lending Discrimination In addition to the public sector policies that influence fair housing choice, there are private sector policies that can influence the development, financing, and advertising of real estate. In this section of the AI, mortgage lending practices and high-cost lending are analyzed. There is evidence of lending discrimination in the private market. Any lender that meets an asse t threshold and makes a minimum number of mortgages is required to report mortgage data according to the Home Mortgage Disclosure Act of 1975. The following three tables were generated using mortgage data for 2015 -2017 for the City of Lynchburg. Figure 28 indicates that Black and Hispanic applicants faced higher denial rates and lower origination rates (approvals) than White applicants; denial rates for Blacks and Whites were 38.1% and 16.7%, respectively. Hispanic applicants also have a slightly higher denial rate of 26.4% compared to White applicants. Figure 29 shows that there are differences by race and ethnicity for originations of high cost loans. As of 2014, a high cost loan was defined as a loan with an interest rate more than 6.5 percentage points higher than the average prime rate. The overall rate of high cost loan originations was low in Lynchburg; only 4.3% of originated loans were high cost loans. Black applicants were slightly more likely to have a high cost loan at 7.0%. Figure 30 compares the rates of high cost loan origination by whether the applicant’s income was above or below the HUD area median family income (HAMFI) of the area in which the purchased home is located. Among all high cost loans, 37.0% of recipients had incomes above HAMFI; White and Race Unknown recipients had a higher rate at 40.2% and 83.3%, respectively. However, high cost loans make up only 4.3% of all originated mortgage applications in Lynchburg. 138 | P a g e Figure 29 Mortgage application outcomes by race/ethnicity, 2015-2017 White Black Asian Other Race Unknown Hispanic Total # % # % # % # % # % # % # % Approved 3,095 83.3% 532 61.9% 74 79.6% 20 69.0% 475 73.0% 81 73.6% 4,196 78.5% Denied 619 16.7% 327 38.1% 19 20.4% 9 31.0% 176 27.0% 29 26.4% 1,150 21.5% Total 3,714 69.5% 859 16.1% 93 1.7% 29 0.5% 651 12.2% 110 2.1% 5,346 100.0% Source: HMDA Figure 30 Rate of high cost loan originations by race/ethnicity, 2015-2017 White Black Asian Other Race Unknown Hispanic Total # % # % # % # % # % # % # % Not high cost 3095 83.3% 532 61.9% 74 79.6% 20 69.0% 475 73.0% 81 73.6% 4,196 95.7% High cost 112 3.0% 60 7.0% 4 4.3% 1 3.4% 12 1.8% 3 2.7% 189 4.3% Total 3,207 73.1% 592 13.5% 78 1.8% 21 0.5% 487 11.1% 84 1.9% 4,385 82.0% Source: HMDA Figure 31 High cost loan originations by income level by race, 2015-2017 White Black Asian Other Race Unknown Hispanic Total # % # % # % # % # % # % # % High Cost Loans Originated 112 59.3% 60 31.7% 4 2.1% 1 0.5% 12 6.3% 3 1.6% 189 100.0% Applicant Income Above AMI 45 40.2% 14 23.3% 1 25.0% 0 0.0% 10 83.3% 0 0.0% 70 37.0% Applicant Income Below AMI 67 59.8% 46 76.7% 3 75.0% 1 100.0% 2 16.7% 3 100.0% 119 63.0% Source: HMDA 139 | P a g e Fair Housing Profile Fair Housing Laws The Fair Housing Act defines seven protect classes: race, color, religion, national origin, sex, disability, and familial status. Virginia’s Fair Housing Law also adds elderliness as protected classes. Elderliness is defined as an individual who has attained their 55th birthday. As a result, Lynchburg residents have more protections under the State’s fair housing law. The Virginia Fair Housing Office explicitly mentions groups not protected under state or federal fair housing law. Examples given include students, smokers, income status, sexual orientation, and marital status. Should the City of Lynchburg determine a need for additional classes to be protected, a local fair housing ordinance can be passed. Fair Housing Complaints Lynchburg residents can receive fair housing services from a variety of agencies such as: the Virginia Fair Housing Office, Virginia Legal Aid Society, and Lynchburg Community Action Group. These groups provide education and outreach, sponsor community events, process fair housing complaints, and in some cases investigate complaints through testing, and /or work to promote a mutual understandin g of diversity among residents. A lack of filed complaints does not necessarily indicate a lack of housing discrimination. Some persons may not file complaints because they are not aware of how to go about filing a complaint or where to go to file a compl aint. In a tight rental market, tenants may want to avoid confrontations with prospective landlords. Discriminatory practices can be subtle and may not be detected by someone who does not have the benefit of comparing his treatment with that of another hom e seeker. Other times, persons may be aware that they are being discriminated against, but they may not be aware that the discrimination is against the law and that there are legal remedies to address the discrimination. Finally, households may be more int erested in achieving their priority of finding decent housing and may prefer to avoid going through the process of filing a complaint and following through with it. 140 | P a g e Therefore, education, information, and referral regarding fair housing issues remain critic al to equip persons with the ability to reduce impediments. Office of Fair Housing & Equal Opportunity The Office of Fair Housing & Equal Opportunity (FHEO) at HUD receives complaints from persons regarding alleged violations of the federal Fair Housing Ac t. Fair housing complaints originating in Lynchburg were requested for this AI but have not been received yet. Virginia Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation The Fair Housing Office at the State of Virginia’s Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation (DPOR) receives complaints from persons regarding alleged violations of Virginia’s Fair Housing Law. DPOR estimates receiving an average of 180 complaints each year for the State of Virginia. Fair housing complaints originating in Lynchburg between the beginning of 2014 to the end of 2019 were requested on January 22, 2020 and received January 30, 2020. During this period, fifteen (15) cases were processed and closed. Please note that many cas es have multiple bases for alleged discrimination or split rulings; the sum of all bases will be larger than the number of processed cases. Figure 32 DPOR Complaints by Basis of Alleged Discrimination, 2014-2019 Basis of Discrimination Count Percent Total 15 100.0% Sex 4 26.7% Disability 10 66.7% Physical 9 60.0% Mental 1 6.7% Race 3 20.0% Age 1 6.7% Source: Fair Housing Office, Virginia Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation Of the fifteen cases, most cases were filed based on discrimination against persons with disabilities (66.7%) with nine out of ten of these cases relating to physical disability. Discrimination on the basis of sex was the second most frequent complaint followed by race and then age. 141 | P a g e However, only one case resulted in conciliation, which was filed based on race and disability status. The remaining cases were closed due to no jurisdiction, no violation or reasonable cause found, or the case was closed administratively, which includes withdrawn complaints and uncooperative complainants. Figure 33 DPOR Complaint Investigation Findings, 2014-2019 Findings Count Percent Total 15 100.0% Closed administrative 5 33.3% No jurisdiction 4 26.7% No reasonable cause found 2 13.3% Complaint withdrawn 1 6.7% Conciliation 1 6.7% No violation 1 6.7% Uncooperative complainant 1 6.7% Source: Fair Housing Office, Virginia Department of Professional and Occupational Regulation 142 | P a g e Summary of Impediments This section describes the impediments to fair housing choice that emerged from the data analysis, public engagement initiatives, and policy review discussed throughout the AI. They are the results of primary and secondary research that define the underlyi ng conditions, trends, and context for fair housing planning in Lynchburg. The impediments were assigned three priority levels based on the amount and strength of the supporting evidence that initially identified the factor:  High – factors that limit or deny fair housing choice or access to opportunity, as well as other factors that are urgent or establish a foundation for future actions  Medium – moderately urgent or building on prior actions  Low – limited impact on fair housing issue 143 | P a g e Figure 34 Contributing Factors Impeding Housing Choice in Lynchburg, VA Factor Priority Responsible Parties Discussion Access to community assets and opportunities High City Community assets such as public transit and jobs can improve access to opportunities, especially for lower income households and persons with disabilities. While the City has good coverage regarding public transit in R/ECAPs, these areas have poor access to the City's employment centers and higher performing schools. Expanding the public transit system to higher opportunity areas could increase opportunities for low- and moderate-income residents. Location and type of affordable housing High City, LRHA, Private Sector Providing more housing choices in more areas across the City could increase the accessibility and affordability of housing in Lynchburg. While households in Lynchburg are almost evenly split between renters and homeowners, most of the housing stock consists of single-family homes at 65.6% of all housing stock. Multifamily housing is typically more affordable than single-family housing in the same area as a result of increased housing supply and efficient land use. However, multifamily housing options are limited in both the highest opportunity areas and lowest opportunity areas. Additionally, areas with a high concentration of multifamily units are in close proximity to the universities, creating high competition for housing. While the City has shown to be investing funds, such as CDBG and HOME, in higher opportunity areas, the lack of public transit access and landlords to accept HCVs are barriers in locating affordable housing options in higher opportunity areas. Discriminatory behavior toward members of the protected class Low Private Sector Lending discrimination exists within the City of Lynchburg. Because this lending primarily occurs in the private sector, the City has little direct control. However, the City could continue to provide education and outreach to lenders and borrowers regarding fair housing and lending discrimination, in addition to the organizations advocating for fair housing. Black and Hispanic households are more likely to have their mortgage application denied than White households. Black households were also more likely to receive high-cost loans compared to other races/ethnicities. High cost loans have higher interest rates, making housing less affordable and contributes to both segregation and cost burden. Households receiving high cost loans will seek more affordable housing in lower quality housing stock and be more cost-burdened due to high interest rates. 144 | P a g e Fair Housing Action Plan The following chart includes recommendations based on the identified factors impeding fair housing choice: Impediment Action Measurable Benchmarks Timeframe Barriers to housing choices for members of the protected class The City should specify procedures, training, and monitoring process for implementing the Language Access Plan (LAP) to streamline services and better accommodate persons with limited English proficiency (LEP). This is especially important for when the LEP Spanish-speaking population reaches the safe harbor threshold. Percent of current and number of new staff members trained in accordance with LAP procedures 2020-2024 Location and type of affordable housing LRHA should expand Section 8 HCV Program to higher opportunity areas. Number of landlords recruited to participate in Section 8 program, especially in higher opportunity areas Ongoing The City and other local organizations should address the diverse housing needs for the City's various subpopulation, including students, low- and moderate-income households, persons with disabilities, and elderly persons. Continue investing in housing in a wide geographic area throughout the City. Number of accessible units created/rehabilitated. Ongoing The City should collaborate with local universities to ensure students are not competing with low- and moderate-income households for housing. Number on-campus housing units created. Ongoing 145 | P a g e Impediment Action Measurable Benchmarks Timeframe Location of community assets The City should collaborate with GLTC to improve access to GLTC routes in higher opportunity areas and employment centers in the City and for individuals working unconventional hours. Number of transit stops added Ongoing The City and local service providers should centralize public services in locations with good transit access and high concentration of members of protected classes Increase in number of service users Ongoing Discriminatory behavior toward members of the protected class The City should continue supporting fair housing services, such as housing counseling from Lyn-CAG and legal counseling from VLAS, to reduce rates of eviction, mortgage application denials, high-cost lending, and other discriminatory practices. Number of program participants Ongoing CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION PRESENTATION JUNE 9, 2020 MULLIN & LONERGAN ASSOCIATES CITY OF LYNCHBURG ANALYSIS OF IMPEDIMENTS TO FAIR HOUSING CHOICE BACKGROUND Fair Housing is the right to choose housing free from unlawful discrimination • Federal, state, and local laws protect people from discrimination in housing transactions such as rentals, sales, mortgage lending, and insurance Protected Class: Group of people with a common characteristic who are legally protected from discrimination on the basis of that characteristic • Federal: race, color, religion, national origin, sex,disability, familial status • Virginia: elderliness (55+) FAIR HOUSING PROTECTED CLASSES Race Color Religion Disability Sex Familial Status National Origin Age (55+) in VA BACKGROUND An Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice is: § an analysis of fair housing data § an assessment of fair housing issues § identification of impediments to fair housing choice § development of an action plan to overcome impediments As recipients of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME funds, the City is legally obligated to Affirmatively Further Fair Housing: • It must work to stop housing discrimination, and • It must work to de-segregate and integrate racially concentrated areas of poverty. Completing the AI is required to meet this obligation. FAIR HOUSING OBLIGATION AI PROCESS Community Outreach in December Drafted the AI Document Public Comment Period Public Hearing • Met with staff and community stakeholders • Facilitated two public meetings • Reviewed goals in previous AI, assessed progress • Analyzed demographic, economic, housing market trends • Reviewed public and private policies impacting housing choice • Identified barriers to housing choice • Developed action plan to overcome barriers May 19 through June 23 To be held on June 23 at 7 pm Submission to HUD June 30, 2020 SUMMARY OF FINDINGS MEDIAN HOUSEHOLD INCOME (MHI) $68,766 $41,971 $52,421 $27,366 $39,187 $42,024 $0 $10,000 $20,000 $30,000 $40,000 $50,000 $60,000 $70,000 $80,000 Virginia Lynchburg White Black/African American Asian Hispanic/Latino Median Household Income• MHI for Black/African American households is only 52% of Whites’ • Asian households fared slightly better at 75% of Whites’ • MHI for Hispanic households is 80% of Whites’ • MHIs for White households and Hispanic households exceeded the City’s overall MHI R/ECAPS • Racially or Ethnically Concentrated Areas of Poverty: • A census tract with a non-White population of 50% or more, AND • A census tract with 40% or more poverty. • CT 7 • Two census tracts fell just short of the 40% poverty threshold: census tracts 6 and 11 • Tate Springs, Dearington, Miller Park, Garland Hill, College Hill, Diamond Hill FAIR HOUSING ACTION PLAN IMPEDIMENT #1 Barriers to housing choices for members of the protected classes The City should specify procedures, training, and monitoring process for implementing the Language Access Plan (LAP) to streamline services and better accommodate persons with limited English proficiency (LEP). This is especially important for when the LEP Spanish-speaking population reaches the safe harbor threshold. IMPEDIMENT #2 Location and type of affordable housing LRHA should expand Section 8 HCV Program to higher opportunity areas. The City and other local organizations should address the diverse housing needs for the City's various subpopulation, including students, low- and moderate-income households, persons with disabilities, and elderly persons. The City should collaborate with local universities to ensure students are not competing with low- and moderate-income IMPEDIMENT #3 Location of community assets The City should collaborate with GLTC to improve access to GLTC routes in higher opportunity areas and employment centers in the City and for individuals working unconventional hours. The City and local service providers should centralize public services in locations with good transit access and high concentration of members of protected classes IMPEDIMENT #4 Discriminatory behavior toward members of the protected class The City should continue supporting fair housing services, such as housing counseling from Lyn- CAG and legal counseling from VLAS, to reduce rates of eviction, mortgage application denials, high-cost lending, and other discriminatory practices. NEXT STEPS • Public Hearing on June 23 at 7 pm • Council to consider AI along with Consolidated Plan and Annual Action Plan on June 23 • AI will be submitted to HUD no later than June 30 • Implementation of AI occurs through the Annual Action Plan and is reported in the Consolidated Annual Performance & Evaluation Report (CAPER) COMMENTS TO: Phone: 434.455.3916 Email: melva.walker@lynchburgva.gov Website: www.lynchburgva.gov Melva Walker Grants Manager LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: June 9, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 2 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Brush and Bulk Collection during COVID-19 KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X__Excellent Government __Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community _X__Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Receive an update on the status of brush and bulk collection during the COVID-19 pandemic SUMMARY: On March, 2020, the Governor of Virginia closed schools and non-essential businesses on March due to the COVID-19 pandemic. As a result of the closures more citizens are staying at home for a variety of reasons: to provide childcare, due to layoffs, or working from home. After the closure, City staff experienced an increase in weekly residential collection overflow and an increase in brush and bulk piles. The increase in residential trash, brush and bulk collection is consistent with the experience of other cities around the Commonwealth. City staff took steps to respond to the increase in weekly refuse and brush & bulk piles, and to plan for the virus resulted in quarantining refuse staff including: • Cross training Public Works staff in refuse collection duties • Temporarily reassigning Public Works staff to refuse duties, in particular brush and bulk • Changing work schedules to provide social distancing resulting in reduced overtime • Using large dump trucks to assist with collection Even after engaging in these steps, Public Works staff has not been able to keep up with the volume of brush and bulk being set at the curb. At times brush and bulk collection response time is exceeding 6 weeks. The increased efforts listed above were offset by reduction of overtime, a hiring freeze and other factors related to costs saving measure. Staff recommends some alternative additional resources that may be eligible for the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act) funding (this will be addressed by City Council at its next meeting). • Purchase 2 additional knuckle boom trucks - $340,000 • Contract with 3 chipper crews to chip brush - $90,000 • Contract with small haulers to temporarily increase capacity – (cost depends on the number of haulers) PRIOR ACTION(S): City Council has engaged in numerous discussions in the last two years related to brush and bulk collection. However, there have been no prior actions specifically related to COVID-19 brush and bulk collection challenges. FISCAL IMPACT: The fiscal impact of this item depends on the actions taken, but will be offset by CARES funding. Additionally, if the City utilizes CARES funds to purchase knuckle boom trucks, there would be no need for the FY 2021 planned purchase, resulting in savings of $220,000 from the Fleet Fund. CONTACT(S): Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager – 455-3990 Gaynelle Hart, Director Public Works – 455-4406 Joann Martin, Director of Communications and Public Engagement – 455-3800 ATTACHMENT(S): Powerpoint REVIEWED BY: raw 065R Brush & Bulk Collection During COVID 19City Council Work Session June 9, 2020 Purpose and Outline•Purpose: Provide an overview of the COVID-19-related challenges associated with bulk and brush pickup•Outline:•Video discussing collection service challenges•Steps taken to remediate increased brush and bulk set outs•Further available options•Communication efforts regarding current brush and bulk status2 Video•City staff will show a video outlining some of the challenges associated with bulk and brush collection during COVID-19 3 Steps Taken for Increased Bulk and Brush Set Outs•Temporary Full-Time Reassignment of Public Works Employees:•All Public Works CDL holders have been trained on the operation of trash trucks and knuckle boom trucks•Temporarily reassigned a Buildings employee (talented equipment operator) to collect brush and bulk•Other Public Works employees work in Refuse Division as needed to cover for illness/vacation4 Employees receive training on refuse equipment for temporary reassignments Steps Taken for Increased Bulk and Brush Set Outs•Schedule Changes to Reallocate Resources•Streets & Grounds Divisions schedule changes to provide social distancing using two shifts using only “straight time” (not overtime):•Sunday-Tuesday – 12 hour days; 4 hours on Wednesday •Thursday – Saturday – 12 hour days; 4 hours on Wednesday•Streets employees re-assigned to bulk and brush collection are also paired with large dump trucks: •12 hours Saturday; 12 hours Sunday5 Challenges•It is clear that there is more bulk and brush being set out, but we are not able to pick up much more. •Recorded collected tonnage remains steady for a number of reasons:•Eliminated all overtime for brush and bulk collection (budget savings)•Hiring freeze (budget savings)•During pre- COVID- 19 times, brush and bulk collection required overtime (6 days per week, 10 to 14 hours per day) to keep response times reasonable •Brush tonnage not currently recorded due to non- functioning scale at Concord Turnpike brush storage site•Trash has significantly increased in City Parks, which has created an additional burden6 Challenges•Normal operational demands have continued•Four knuckle boom trucks assigned to refuse with a fifth truck assigned to Buildings and Grounds (B&G) available on weekends•Trucks are sometime out of service due to preventative maintenance, repairs and warranty work•Conflicts with emergency tree response•Benefits of additional resources negated by these challenges7 Proposed Additional Resources 8 •Purchase two additional knuckle boom trucks with CARES funding ($340,000)•Contract with Asplundh for 2-3 chipper crews to chip brush –($2,500/per week/crew for 12 weeks= $90,000)•Contract with small hauling businesses to provide additional collection capacity until we are caught up (costs depend on the number of people we contract with) Communication Efforts•Increased communications to citizens–Video–Targeted Social Media – Facebook/Next Door/Instagram–Website–Radio–The City Source–Citizens First–City App9 Communication Efforts 10 VIDEOSOCIAL MEDIACITY SOURCEPRINTED MATERIALS BULK AND BRUSH COLLECTION LYNCHBURG VA APP Questions11 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: June 9, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 3 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Revenue Update KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X__Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _ _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Receive an update on the revenue collections received in several key City revenue sources. SUMMARY: Several key Adopted FY 2020 revenue sources were revised to reflect the anticipated economic impacts due to the COVID-19 pandemic. At the May 26, 2020 City Council meeting, staff informed Council future monthly updates will be provided at the meeting on the second Tuesday of the month to better coincide with timing of City and State due dates. This report includes revenue collections through June 2, 2020. The revenues in the attached PowerPoint will be updated on Tuesday, June 9th prior to staff’s presentation. PRIOR ACTION(S): Rebalancing the Adopted FY 2020 General Fund Budget Due to Economic Impact of COVID-19, City Council, April 14, 2020. FISCAL IMPACT: As noted. CONTACT(S): Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): COVID-19 FY 2020 Revised Revenue General Fund Operating Budget Monthly Update REVIEWED BY: bms 066R City Council June 9, 2020 COVID‐19 FY 2020 Revised Revenue General Fund Operating Budget Monthly Update COVID‐19 FY 2020 Revised Revenue  Monthly Update 2 Note: Actual collections revised as of June 2, 2020. Revised  FY 2020 Actual  Collections FY 2020 Remaining to  Collect  FY 2020 Net Real Property $60,338,212  $60,319,052  ($19,160) Real Property  $62,125,204  Allowance for Uncollectible Real Property  ($1,786,992) % Allowance for Uncollectible Real Property  3.0% Net Personal Property ‐ local portion $18,051,339  $16,139,661  ($ 1,911,678) Personal Property ‐ local portion  $18,625,000  Allowance for Personal Property ‐ local portion  ($573,661) % Allowance for Uncollectible Personal Property ‐ local portion 3.1% Net Business License Tax $7,988,490  $8,431,585  $443,095  Business License Ta x $8,876,651  Allowance for Uncollectible Business License  ($888,161) % Allowance for Uncollectible Business License  10.0% Motor Vehicle Licenses $1,259,385  $985,106  ($274,279) COVID‐19 FY 2020 Revised Revenue  Monthly Update (continued) 3 Note: Actual collections revised as of June 2, 2020. Revised  FY 2020 Actual  Collections FY 2020 Remaining to  Collect  FY 2020 Local Sales and Use Tax $15,567,411  $12,473,745  ($3,093,666) March 1,386,161  1,295,372  (90,789) April 966,446  0  (966,446) May 1,050,243  0  (1,050,243) Meals Tax $13,253,905  $11,811,485  ($1,442,420) March 1,140,782  935,569  (205,213) April 541,194  802,509  261,315  May 559,001  156  (558,845) Lodging Tax $2,107,532  $2,123,077  $15,545  March 120,725  170,886  50,161  April 11,361  60,603  49,242  May 16,061  0  (16,061) Amusement Tax $626,614  $617,679  ($8,935) March 40,975  32,690  (8,285) April 0  1,332  1,332  May 0  0  0  Questions, Comments,  Observations 4 May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 26th day of May, 2020 at 4:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Treney Tweedy, President, presiding. The following members were present: Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Beau Wright 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Ms. Donna Witt presented Council with an overview of the Coronavirus Aid, Recovery and Economic Recovery (CARES) Act stimulus funds for the City. The City is receiving $7.18 million in funds and will receive them around the middle of June. It is one-time funding and cannot be used to replace revenue. It must also be spent by December 31, 2020 and the expenses must be directly related to COVID-19. They are trying to prioritize them into three priorities: public health and safety, continuity of operations and small business assistance. They also propose to give $2 million to Schools for one-time purposes. The Finance department will be scrutinizing all expenses very carefully. Councilmember Perrow noted this is a crutch, a temporary fix. We have to be diligent about not committing any of these funds for recurring expenses. Councilmember Perrow would imagine that the auditors will look at all of this very carefully. Ms. Witt said Brown & Edwards is already requesting information. Ms. Witt said if they are not spent according to the guidelines, the State can say you have to give them back. Any unspent funds may have to be given back as well. Councilmember Nelson asked if there will be a rigid protocol to review requests before the funds are expended, and Ms. Witt indicated yes. Ms. Svrcek noted that the school superintendent did a great job of connecting the i tems on the schools list to the eligibility criteria. Staff will be looking at the list very carefully to make sure that everything is eligible. Ms. Witt said they have been given guidelines but do not have to get the expenses preapproved by the state or federal government. The general guidelines are very specific but she meets with other financial officers every week so they can make sure they get it right. Councilmember Wilder thanked the City staff and the school staff for pulling all of this together for them today in such an expedit ious manner. Councilmember Helgeson agreed that there needs to be a very good, judicious process to review items before the money is spent, so there is no clawback. A clawback makes it even worse for your next year’s budget. It would be better not to spend the money than spend it inappropriately and have to pay it back. Councilmember Perrow asked if this would be a pot of money for consideration outside of their regular budget balancing and Ms. Witt indicated yes. Ms. Witt clarified that the approximately $2.5 million that the schools received in a separate CARES Act allocation can be used to replace revenue. Ms. Witt also outlined all the amounts that the City has received and how it can be spent and pointed out there is a summary of all amounts received included in the agenda summary. Councilmember Perrow noted that we need to be very mindful that the money is spent in ways that will improve the City in its totality in the future and not find ourselves relying on this time and time again. It is really up to staff to figure out the best way to invest these dollars in the future of the City and thanked staff for doing so. // In the matter of Budget, Ms. Witt gave them an overview of the City’s March numbers and some of the April numbers. She said she should present at the first meeting of the month instead of the second meeting of the month May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 2 because she will have more numbers at that time. She is cautiously optimistic that they read their “crystal ball” well enough that the revenue projections they made are going to come in very close to the e stimates. She will report to them again on June 9. Councilmember Perrow noted that she and her staff really dug into the numbers and gave their best guesstimate with not a lot of information and with a lot of speculation. They gave it their best shot and it looks like it was a pretty good one. He thanked Ms. Witt and her staff for a great job. Councilmember Nelson noted that the due dates for several large money items is still yet to come, so there is the potential for some very good news between now and June 9. There is good news in some of the smaller categories where they have returns at this time. She said that is a fair statement. Councilmember Nelson thinks the credit for that goes to the ingenuity and creativity of the local businesses. They saw the challenge and quickl y adapted so they could stay in business and serve the public. He thanked the Downtown Lynchburg Association and Economic Development for making that possible and keeping the spirit of commerce in Lynchburg positive. // In the matter of Budget, Council continued its discussion of schools and balancing the budget. Ms. Svrcek noted there were a couple of changes since the May 12 meeting. There is now a shortfall of $38,207 and that issue needs to be resolved. She does not want to suggest this but thinks this shortfall will have to come from the money set aside for the additional firefighters of $193,936. Councilmember Helgeson does not think they should do that because some of the items on the list did not have a unanimous vote, but the $193,936 decision was a unanimous vote and this is really important. Councilmember Wilder noted they have to review the budget in October and January but setting aside this money has shown that they are committed to funding it. He thinks they can make a better assessment in October when numbers are more solid. He made a motion to accept Ms. Svrcek’s recommendation and it was seconded by Mayor Tweedy. Councilmember Nelson commented that we know this amount of money will not do anything to promote what we want to do for the fire department. He is very hesitant to take any of that money if it sends the signal to our first responders that they get cut from the top first, even though at this point it is purely theoretical. He could support this motion if we revisit the item in June. Councilmember Wright accepted that suggestion as a friendly amendment. Ms. Svrcek clarified for Council that this decision would not preclude them from balancing the budget tonight. Councilmember Helgeson said he will not be supporting this motion because we should not gi ve our first responders what is left over. It should be a concerted effort to say we care about public safety and it sends a bad message. He thinks they should be sending a message that we will treat them first and not last. Councilmember Perrow does not understand the point of balancing a budget if we are just going to discuss a significant chunk of it later. If we do not support what the manager has recommended, we are going to have to find a bunch of money. It seems this item will just be revisited again during this budget balancing process. He thinks they should resolve the schools item first and then come back to this item. Councilmember Wilder does not think it diminishes their support for the firefighters because they have shown that they are committed. The police department made some requests and they did not get them. We allocated a portion and he does not think it is a fair statement to say they are not showing the fire department they support it. Lots of items got cut from this budget such as items Parks & Recreation and the employees’ raises. May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 3 Councilmember Wright thinks all of our City colleagues are important. He asked Ms. Witt if she thinks her projection would be that much different in June and she said she did not think so and noted that she has nothing to go on for the fall. Mayor Tweedy asked if they had been sent any numbers for other expenditures such as eliminating the tellers, leaf collection and the Templeton Center. Ms. Witt noted that the teller windows are closed and they are still getting a lot of calls to make payments in cash. The tellers are front line customer service and they are important to the public. They also process a lot of the mail payments and payments from City departments. They also have to reconcile all the online payments and check them for errors. She listed many other functions they perform. The cost savings would be approximately $57,784. She noted that Water Resources pays 58 percent of the tellers’ salaries. Eliminating the Templeton Center would save $106,224, and the majority of that is staff costs. Ms. Tweedy noted they are already lessening the services at two community centers by delaying their reopening. Councilmember Nelson noted the Templeton Center does a multitude of services to the community that have a value to the community much higher than the staff cost. He thinks it is an asset we would be imprudently closing. Mayor Tweedy recognizes the programs are valuable and a lot of citizens benefit from them , but sometimes we have to spread the pain. She is not recommending it but she wanted to see the numbers. Ms. Gaynelle Hart discussed the elimination of leaf collection. They are reimbursed by VDOT for some of it and some of it comes from the stormwater fund. Thirty percent of it is from the general fund. If they reduced staff, it would reduce street maintenance, snow removal and all the other services we provide. Mr. Tim Mitchell ga ve her information that it would potentially increase the cost at the wastewater treatment due to the leaves going into the inlets. It is a savings of $73,000 and they feel it is insignificant to the service. Councilmember Perrow thought that it was an interesting point that each visit to the Templeton C enter has a cost of $6.11 per person per visit. He is not passing judgment one way or the other. He just thought it was an interesting data point. Mayor Tweedy wondered what that cost would be per child per visit because that comparison would tell you something. Mayor Tweedy noted that she was not trying to pit demographics aga inst each other, but adults do have options and opportunities to find activities but not children. Councilmember Helgeson noted there are options for children like the Jubilee Center and an after-school program at the James Crossing Apartments, as well as lots of churches. There are lots of programs for children that are not run by the government. Councilmember Perrow applauded her for bringing those items up and he thinks it warrants discussion and consideration. He brought up managed vacancies and asked the City Manager if it has been a while since they have used anything from managed vacancies for balancing the budget in years. Ms. Witt said they left it alone in case things are worse than what we anticipated and we need to use it. Councilmember Perrow said there should be an aggregate number that you can count on as reoccurring revenue. It has operational value and that is kind of the way it has been and how it works out. He thinks it is a real tool if we need it and we need to understand what the aggregate number is and not an immediate number. Ms. Svrcek said he raises a good point and it would be very easy to use managed vacancies to balance the budget and not use the firefighter money at all. Councilmember Wilder amended his motion to balance the budget with managed vacancy money in the amount of $38,207. Councilmember Nelson accepted the friendly amendment May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 4 and it was seconded by Mayor Tweedy. Councilmember Perrow said he would be voting against it because he still thinks it is premature to balance the budget at this point without talking about schools. Councilmember Helgeson asked Ms. Svrcek if this is a good policy or not, as it has not been used for several years. Ms. Svrcek said they have not used it for years because they have let it fall to fund balance to pay for those one-time capital needs in the future. We used $1.5 million in the current fiscal year to help close our $5 million dollar projected revenue gap. They have not budgeted anything for managed vacancies in FY2021. This is a simple solution in terms of $38,207 out of a $194 million budget, but she would caution Council to not use managed vacancies for anything else. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6 Noes: Perrow 1 // Ms. Svrcek directed them to Item #32 on the list (schools funding). The revised operating budget is $39,828,498. Schools requested $42 million and then revised its request to $41 million. Then the City Manager proposed $40,000,528. She proposed taking an additional $700,000 to help with the lost revenues from COVID-19, which brings us to where we are today. Councilmember Wright asked Ms. Witt if she plans to bring back the proposed allocation for the CARES act funds at a later date. She said it will be brought back June 23. He asked if it would include the 28 percent recommended for schools, which is $2,000,007. She said that is correct. Councilmember Wright wanted to clarify for the viewing audience that is still a $1.2 million delta between what schools originally re quested and what the City Manager is proposing. He noted that we are dealing with an unknown fund balance on both the City side and the schools side. There is a big concern with fourth quarter 2020 sales tax and lottery revenue for schools and first quarter 2021 is really an unknown. We also do not know what the City’s deficit is going to be at this point. We know that the City can afford $39.8 million and we know that schools has received approximately $2.5 million in CARES money that it can use at its discretion within federal guidelines. We have also heard that the City is willing to part with $2 million of its CARES money. He would like to make a proposal but wished to note that everyone is feeling the pain. No one is immune. It is heartbreaking that City staff will not be receiving the wage increase or salary adjustments. It is also heartbreaking for the schools staff that waited a decade to get on a salary step scale. A lot of us do not take it lightly what they have been holding out for and what it means to them. Council does not do anything hastily, but it is a hole that has to be plugged for now and circumstances might change. He offers this up with the idea of the shared sacrifice of schools staff, as well as City staff. He would propose that Council approve the $39.8 million and $2 million in the City’s stimulus money. He would further propose that whatever the fund balance is (the latest estimate is $1.3 million) to be set aside and appropriated at a later date. He would also hope Council will agree by consensus to revisit schools funding in October. It is his understanding that the school superintendent and the school board are amenable to this proposal. He made that in the form of a motion to affirm the City Manager’s amount of $39, 828,498 and setting aside the fund balance to be appropriated once we know the final figure. Councilmember Perrow seconded the motion and noted that will be done next fiscal year but the intent is there to revisit this in October or earlier. It seems the logical May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 5 approach that Council should take and it supports the diligent work of staff but keeps the door open so the City can make changes as necessary. Councilmember Nelson thinks it is refreshing and commented it is the identical motion he made two weeks, which was voted down. The rationale was that we did not want to deny schools any more than the $39.8 million when we might have more and the desire was to postpone it. The net result of his motion and this motion are essentially the same, so he would ask why it was prudent to delay. Councilmember Wright thought there was an undue rush at the last meeting. There were too many variables and, granted there are still many, but the additional two weeks gave them more time to consult, talk and understand what is in front of them. He is glad they had the two weeks but agrees the net is the same; however, the additional $2 million in CARES fund are a different twist. In answer to a question from Councilmember Nelson, Councilmember Wright said he is not including the caveat part about raises contained in his memo as part of his motion given that they cannot stipulate how schools spends its money. He thinks it is fair that neither schools staff nor City staff receive a raise until everyone receives a raise. Councilmember Nelson said he had watched a school board meeting and heard that half of the staff would receive a raise this year and the rest would receive a raise the following year. Dr. Crystal Edwards said that is based on the steps on the salary pay schedules. He heard a discussion that all the teachers were not scheduled to get an increase the way the pay tables were set up. There was no finality on that discussion that half of the teachers were absolutely getting a raise next year. She said the $41 million request had already removed the step increases , hoping they might be able to revisit it if revenues came in higher than they are projecting. To clarify it for Councilmember Nelson, step increases are not in Option B. She clarified there is no salary increases or step increases. Councilmember Nelson said there is no question in his mind that the teachers deserve a raise. She said that based on the $39.8 million from the City, the raises are not there; however, if they receive more revenue than they are projecting, they will revisit the step increases. Councilmember Helgeson said when a person calls something reckless and almost diabolical one week and then it is fine—he recognizes people have different learning curves and sometimes it takes a little longer to get there. Sometimes you haven’t done that and didn’t have the experience of the budgets. He is glad they are now coming back full circle. He thinks they need to be empathetic to people that aren’t getting any pay and pushing for raises at this time isn’t the best thing for us to say. We have to balance between the payers and the services. He hopes the superintendent and the school board will be looking at consolidation with the declining enrollments and looking at how the City is paying for a lot of administrative positions. He knows they are trying and doing their best. He appreciates that. It was his understanding that the state was giving an extra $2.5 million, which should take a little pressure off our local taxpayers. He thinks that the CARES money can be helpful, but we have to be very careful that we don’t take this one-time money and get hooked on it. Sometimes not having that money can be better than having it because you figure out what you can do without and kind of regroup while making sure our children are getting the best learning environment possible. He also said they need to be sure one-time fund balance money isn’t just utilized for operations. May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 6 Mayor Tweedy said she was somewhat in agreement with Councilmember Nelson’s motion at the last meeting. The City Manager had just received the information regarding the stimulus money that morning. She wanted to learn more of what the funds could be used for and is appreciative that the school superintendent came back with more detailed clarification of how it could be used. Councilmember Wright said here was no urgency last time to push the decision through and it was not going to make a practical difference in the production of this budget. He told Councilmember Helgeson that his remarks did not go unnoticed and he is dismayed. Councilmember Helgeson noted that Councilmember Wright had said that something worthy of debate was deemed reckless. That is not a good way to do things and that was his point. He is sorry Councilmember Wright took it that way and he should not have expunged Councilmember Wright’s budget process. Vice Mayor Dolan was glad to have the extra time and to get the extra information from Dr. Edwards and the City Manager. She thanked the superintendent for her hard work and hopes they can get some decorum and stop insulting each other. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Nelson made a motion that it is Council’s intention to allocate whatever fund balance is generated by the schools to fill whatever gap it has and then address any other priorities. It was seconded by Councilmember Wright. Councilmember Helgeson said he will not be supporting this motion because it is supposed to be one-time money and they should not be put into an operating budget. He does not think that is a good pattern or their normal procedure. Councilmember Perrow agreed with those statements; however, he sees this as an extraordinary circumstance. It is not a good principle or sound finance, but this is an extraordinary time. It is the intent that it is a “one-off” and not a recurring thing. This motion is a nicety and is not a binding motion, but it certainly does show the intent of Council. He would caution Council to craft the resolution carefully and in conjunction with the auditors because it could be stated that one-time funds had to suddenly be appropriated for operating expenses because of the pandemic. Would that pass the litmus test to use the one-time funds to pay for a couple of roofs? If you get the language correct with the help of the accountants, maybe it could introduce some fungibility into those dollars. Councilmember Wilder said it is important to give schools some flexibility with the fund balance because we do not know what will happen when the children are able to resume school in the fall. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6 Noes: Helgeson 1 Councilmember Nelson mentioned several people who have retired from the school system: Wyllys VanDerwerker, Director, Special Education; Dixie Sears, Supervisor of Curriculum and Instruction in five different areas; Marie Gee, the Director of Personnel and Dr. Ben Copeland, Deputy Superintendent. Counci lmember Helgeson recognized Councilmember Nelson’s wife, Karen Nelson, the Principal of Perrymont Elementary School, May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 7 who is also retiring soon. // Dr. Reid Wodicka gave Council an update on the City’s actions regarding COVID -19. ESF5 will be using funds from CDBG to prepare COVID-19 care kits for citizens. There is also going to be an opportunity to hold a community testing event in partnership with the health department. ESF14 is continuing to develop some best practices for some of the businesses that are reopening. This group will be preparing recommendations for the CARES Act allocation and managing those requests. He mentioned we are seeing new unemployment claims , but we are certainly headed in the right direction. Mayor Tweedy mentioned to the public that staff is looking into the issue of excessive trash on the streets. // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Nelson had no items. Councilmember Wilder wanted to thank school staff and City staff for working together. He is thankful for their leadership and how th ey are putting their all into everything they are doing. Councilmember Wright wished to acknowledge the Registrar’s office and its team for conducting a safe election and offered congratulations to his colleagues on their reelections. He is looking forwar d to welcoming Councilmember-Elect Faraldi in July. Councilmember Perrow congratulated his colleagues and Councilmember-Elect Faraldi and wished them his best over the next four years. Councilmember Helgeson mentioned all the trash that is piling up on the streets. He commended the Public Works staff on working efficiently, even working on Sundays, and picking up a record amount of trash. He would like to see the second scale fixed at the convenience center and possibly a waiver of the 500-pound limit at the convenience center. He also suggested maybe they use a short-term contractor to pick up some of the trash. He was at an event yesterday at Monument Terrace and noticed it could use some pressure washing and other cleanup. He also noted that City Hall needs to be open for public meetings. The doors should not be locked during public meetings. Vice Mayor Dolan thanked the school leadership. She believes public education is the backbone of our community, if not our democracy. She thanked City staff for getting them through this budget. Mayor Tweedy congratulated the reelected Councilmembers and Councilmember Elect Faraldi. She asked for a discussion regarding selecting a date for the organizational meeting and it was decided to postpone this discussion until June 9. She also thanked the public for their compliance with the COVID-19 directives to help protect each other and ourselves during the Phase 1 reopening. // The meeting was recessed at 5:50 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Treney Tweedy, Sterling A. Wilder, Beau Wright 7 Absent: 0 // Vice Mayor Dolan gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, the Mayor recognized Trish Roth of Communications & Public Engagement and Krista Boothby of the Office of Economic Development and Tourism for receiving First Place from the National Association of Government Communicators for the Office of Economic Development’s Annual Report. May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 8 // In the matter of Recognitions, the Mayor recognized the Spring 2020 CO.STARTERS graduates: Amy Corbett; Jennifer Demmin; Keesha Simon; Randy Sass; Seth McGuire; Talia Conner and Taunya Bryant. // In the matter of Recognitions, the Mayor recognized the week of May 17–23 as Emergency Medical Services Week. // In the matter of Recognitions, the Mayor recognized the Mayor’s Youth Council graduating seniors: Jackson Brestel; Gracie Patterson; Landis Thompson; Annie Townsend and Virginia Townsend. // The City Attorney, Mr. Walter Erwin introduced Mr. Matthew Freedman, who is joining the City Attorney’s office as the Deputy City Attorney. // Copies of the revised minutes of the March 10, 2020, having been previously furnished Council, and previously approved, reading was dispensed with, and on motion of Councilmember Perrow, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // Copies of the minutes of the May 5, 2020, having been previously furnished Council, reading was dispensed with, and on motion of Councilmember Perrow, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // Copies of the minutes of the May 12, 2020, having been previously furnished Council, reading was dispensed with, and on motion of Councilmember Perrow, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, by the following recorded vote approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Community Development, Council conducted a public hearing to adopt a resolution approving the submission of Substantial Amendment #2 to the Fiscal Year (FY) 2020 (Program Year [PY] 2019) Annual Action Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program to the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD); and amend the FY 2020 Community Development Block Grant budget with resources of $420,487 from the Community Development Block Grant Coronavi rus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES ACT) (CDBG-CV) Program Funds. Ms. Melva Walker summarized the request for Council. Ms. Charlotte Lester of Parks and Recreation spoke in favor of the request. Ms. Denise Crews of LYNCAG spoke in favor of the request. Ms. Shawne Farmer of Interfaith Outreach spoke in favor of the request. There were no others present in Council Chamber to speak in favor or in opposition to the petition. The Clerk of Council played a phone call from Sarah Quarantotto of Miriam’s House speaking in favor of the request. There was no one else to speak in favor or in opposition of the petition, and the public hearing was closed. The Community Development Action Group (CDAC) did not have a formal meeting but was g iven the opportunity to comment. Councilmember Wright noted that there was consensus among the committee members that these are worthy and valuable projects. Most of it is going to go toward utility and rent assistance, which is May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 9 desperately needed. He is very pleased to recommend all the projects for approval by Council. Councilmember Wilder said he was glad to hear that the programs are working together, so there is no duplication of efforts. He made that in the form of a motion and it was seconded by Councilmember Perrow. Councilmember Helgeson thinks a lot of the programs mentioned are great. He thinks the $39,990 for a communications and awareness campaign of coronavirus could be used for needs such as rent and utility payments. He does not think there is anyone who is not aware of COVID-19. He would like to see the $39,990 go to the nonprofits that are actually working and not for marketing, especially since people are not working and the nonprofits are seeing fewer donations. He would recommend we amend this and take the $39,990 and give it to the four groups that are actually doing “boots on the ground” work. Ms. Joann Martin came forward and said the title might be a little misleading. This is not a campaign to tell people about the coronavirus but rather to make them aware of the resources that are available. They know that oftentimes low to moderate income people do not know what resources are out there and might not have the same access to resources that some of us might have. They will be working with these four agencies and the United Way. Some ideas are water bill inserts, door hangers and billboards in target areas. Councilmember Wilder thinks it is very important for our community to be aware of things. He thinks COVID - 19 has really affected the African American community, but he would like all people to know what resources are available. He gets calls every day from the business community. Vice Mayor Dolan works with many nonprofits and hears quite often that people do not know what resources are available to them. She thinks this is a fantastic idea. Councilmember Perrow would like them to partner with other departments to make sure they are getting information out for those departments as well. Ms. Martin said of course they could do that and they work with all the departments, even the court system. They are very open to collaborating because that is how they will be successful. Councilmember Helgeson noted the marketing campaign will generate calls but then there is no money available because it was spent on the campaign. The CDBG area is a large area and then there will be no resources to assist them. Ms. Martin said this is a public education campaign to also let people know where to get medical or legal help, for example. Mayor Tweedy said this is an unprecedented time where people who thought they would never help now need help and they do not know where to find it. It is more of an awareness campaign. Ms. Martin said it will also connect people who are willing to give money with organizations that need it. Councilme mber Helgeson asked Councilmember Wright if he could separate this item from the motion to approve the entirety of the requests. He agreed to do so. Mayor Tweedy and Vice Mayor Dolan disclosed she is on the board of LYNCAG but they can both be impartial in their vote. The motion to approve the requests, except for the $39,990 for the communications campaign, passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 The motion to approve the $39,990 for the COVID-19 communications awareness campaign passed by the following vote: May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 10 Ayes: Dolan, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6 Noes: Helgeson 1 // In the matter of Schools, a public hearing was held regarding to receive input from citizens regarding appointments (or reappointments) to vacancies that will exist June 30, 20 20, in School Board Districts 1, 2 and 3. Mayor Tweedy read into the record the names of the current School Board members whose terms will expire on June 30, 2020: Dr. Robert Brennan, School District 1 (Willing to serve again); Dr. Kimberly Sinha, School District 2 (Willing to serve again); Dr. James Coleman, School District 3 (Willing to serve again). Mayor Tweedy then read into the record the name of volunteers who have applied to-date to serve on the School Board: District 1 District 2 District 3 Dr. Kathie Carwile Ms. Consuela M. Mosley Ms. Cheryl Giggetts Mr. Brian Farrow Dr. Tony Ryals Mr. Andrew Glover Mrs. Tracey Langseth Ms. Christina M. Wilson Dr. Richard Heinlein The following candidates spoke before City Council to communicate their interest and present their credentials and qualifications to serve on the School Board: Dr. Robert Brennan (current Board Member in District 1); Dr. Kimberly Sinha (current Board Member in District 2) and Dr. James Coleman (current Board Member in District 3). Dr. Kathie Carwile was not present due to a family emergency and was not able to submit a statement. Mr. Brian A. Farrow was not present and the Clerk of Council read a statement on his behalf. Mrs. Tracey Langseth was not present and the Clerk of Council read a statement on his behalf. Ms. Consuela M. Mosley was not present and the Clerk of Council read a statement on her behalf. Dr. Tony Ryals was not present and the Clerk of Council read a statement on his behalf. Ms. Christina M. Wilson was present and communicated her interest and presented her credentials and qualifications. Ms. Cheryl Giggetts was not present and the Clerk of Council read a statement on her behalf. Mr. Andrew Glover and Dr. Richard Heinlein were present and communicated their interest and presented their credentials and qualifications. There was no one else present who wished to speak to this item. Councilmember Wright made a motion to close the public hearing and move this discussion to closed session. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Nelson who felt they have a broad slate of candidates and does not see the need to keep it open. Councilmember Perrow said there are good candidates but traditionally they have left it open just because this interaction raises awareness. He would recommend they keep it open for one more meeting. He made that as a substitute motion and it was seconded by Councilmember Helgeso n. Councilmember Helgeson did not think it hurts to keep it open since this is the first time it has been discussed. Councilmember Wright noted that the applicants tonight do not need to come back to the next meeting. Vice Mayor Dolan was concerned if that gives them enough time to conduct interviews. Councilmember Perrow said they could begin scheduling interviews while keeping the public hearing open. The motion to accept the substitute motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wright 6 Noes: Wilder 1 May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 11 The motion to keep the public hearing open until June 9 passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Public Comment, Joshua Pratt addressed Council. He owns BRT Transportation and they are the only charter bus service in the City and provide school field trips for LCS. He would like Council to consider a property tax relief due to the circumstances that we are all going through with the pandemic. If we are really in this together, he would ask Council to consider cutting the personal property tax in half of behalf of the small businesses and citizens of Lynchburg. // In the matter of Budget, Council considered introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2020 General Fund Ambulance Service Fees budget and appropriate $116,677 with resources from the 2020 Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES) Stimulus Act Provider Relief Fund to offset loss of revenue related to COVID-19 transports. Councilmember Nelson, the Vice Chair of and on behalf of the Finance Committee, made a motion to approve the resolution. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Council considered introducing a resolution amending the FY 2020 Stormwater Operating Fund budget and appropriate up to $59,755 with resources from the North American Association for Environmental Educators (NAAEE) – National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) 21st Century Community Learning Center Watershed STEM Education Partnership Grant. Councilmember Helgeson, the Chair of and on behalf of the Finance Committee, made a motion to approve the resolution. The motion passed b y the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Council considered introducing a resolution amending the FY 2020 Water Fund Operating Budget to increase revenues by $57,561 with resources from the Liquid Aluminum Sulfate Class Action Settlement. Councilmember Helgeson, the Chair of and on behalf of the Finance Committee, made a motion to approve the resolution. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // On motion of Vice Mayor Dolan, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, by the following recorded vote, elected to hold a closed meeting to consider appointments and scheduling for Lynchburg City School Board interviews and for the discussion and consideration of prospective candidates for the position of City Manager pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was re-opened to the public. May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #5: 12 Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Perrow, and Council by the following recorded vote adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was adjourned at 9:00 p.m. Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: May 26, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 8 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Public Hearing Regarding Substantial Amendment #2 for the CDBG program and the receipt of the Community Development Block Grant Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES ACT) (CDBG-CV) Program Funds KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government _X_ Natural and Built Environment _X Safe Community _X _Vibrant Community RE COMMENDATION: Hold a public hearing and adopt a resolution approving the submission of Substantial Amendment #2 to the Fiscal Year (FY) 2020 (Program Year [PY] 2019) Annual Action Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program to the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD); and amend the FY 2020 Community Development Block Grant budget with resources of $420,487 from the Community Development Block Grant Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES ACT) (CDBG-CV) Program Funds. S UMMARY: The City has received notification from HUD for a special allocation of Community Development Block Grant funds to be used to prevent, prepare for, and respond to the coronavirus (COVID-19). This allocation was authorized by the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act), which was signed by President Trump on March 27, 2020, to respond to the growing effects of this historic public health crisis. HUD allocated $2 billion based on the fiscal year 2020 CDBG formula for entitlement cities. Lynchburg’s allocation is $420,487. For receipt of these funds, in accordance with HUD regulations; the City is required to submit a "Substantial Amendment" to its FY 2020 (PY 2019) CDBG Annual Action Plan. This Amendment is to include projects that will prevent, prepare for, and respond to the Coronavirus (COVID-19). Utilizing the CDBG application process and the guidelines from HUD for eligible projects/activities, City staff solicited and accepted applications for the CDBG-CV funds. Attached is a summary of the applications received from local nonprofits and City departments. These projects/activities are eligible according to the HUD guidelines and will benefit the citizens of Lynchburg that have been or will be affected by COVID-19. In ac cordance with the CDBG Citizen Participation Plan’s “In the Event of an Emergency” section, the public comment period was reduced to five (5) days as approved by HUD and the Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) did not conduct a public meeting regarding the submitted projects. However, the applications were provided to CDAC with the opportunity to comment on the proposed projects. The CDAC comments provided to City staff supported the funding of the proposed projects. The following lists of projects are recommended for funding by City staff: For reference for Items #6-8 CDBG-CV PROJECTS PROPOSED FOR FUNDING: City Administration $22,745 Summer Lunch and Play Program (City-Parks and Recreation Department) $20,000 Community First-Rent & Utilities Assistance (Miriam’s House) $75,000 Emergency Housing and Utility Assistance (Lynchburg Community Action Group) $170,000 Safe at Home Emergency Assistance (Interfaith Outreach) $40,000 COVID-19 Care Kits (City-Department of Emergency Services) $52,752 COVID-19 Awareness Communications Campaign (City-Communications and Marketing) $39,990 Total CDBG-CV $420,487 The public was notified of the public hearing through a public notice advertisement published in The News and Advance on May 20 and through various sources of social media. To date no public comments have been received regarding the Substantial Amendment and the proposed projects. PRIOR ACTION(S): None FISCAL IMPACT: The FY 2020 Community Development Block Grant fund will be increased by $420,487 CONTACT(S): Melva Walker, Grants Manager, 455-3916; Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager, 455-3987 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution Attachment A – Summary of CDBG-CV Applications Attachment B – CDBG-CV Worksheet REVIEWED BY: raw RESOLUTION: #R-20-033 BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 (PY 2019) Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Annual Action Plan Substantial Amendment #2 incorporating the proposed CDBG-CV projects is hereby approved for submittal to the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD); and BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that the FY 2020 Community Development Block Grant budget is amended and $420,487 is appropriated with resources from the Community Development Block Grant Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES ACT) (CDBG-CV). Introduced: Adopted: Certified: ____________________________ Clerk of Council 059R ATTACHMENT A 1 Summary of Fiscal Year (FY) 2020 Community Development Block Grant Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (Cares Act) (CDBG-CV) Program funds from the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Following is a brief summary of each of the applications received for consideration of the CARES Act CDBG-CV Program funding. Entire applications are available and can be reviewed in the Grants Administration Office. City Administration (Grants Administration) - $22,745 Funding is requested to fund personnel and operating costs associated with managing and monitoring the CDBG-CV projects. Summer Lunch & Play Program (City-Department of Parks and Recreation) - $20,000 The Summer Lunch & Play Program supports families by providing nutritious meals and recreational activities for youth, from the neighborhood center grounds, during the summer recess. The free program is offered in partnership with non-profit organizations and Lynchburg City Schools, the sponsor of the USDA Summer Food Service Program. Due to the coronavirus, the Summer Lunch & Play Program model has necessarily been modified – with the guidance of federal and state public health authorities – in an effort to keep citizens safe through physical distancing, restrictions on gathering, and enhanced cleaning. Throughout the weeks of summer recess, the Summer Lunch & Play Program at Neighborhood Centers will be continue to follow the Governor of Virginia’s Forward Virginia Blueprint, which identifies progressive response phases: I, II, and III. In response to the coronavirus the Parks and Recreation Department proposes to administer the Summer Lunch & Play Program in a new way this year. The “Lunch” component began early, on March 30, and will remain carry-out, rather than congregant, through the end of July. The Department proposes to add the “Play” component, as a carry-out component, for six weeks in June/July. This “recreation -to-go” model, keeps kids healthy and active during the lazy days of summer, by providing them with unitized play things, to support at-home recreational activity, until such time as we may safely gather at the centers again. While the City of Lynchburg General Fund provides for the operations and maintenance of these facilities and adjoining parks, funds available for recreational supplies are limited under normal circumstances, even more so during the coronavirus pandemic. The free Summer Lunch and Play Program address social equity as well as health and wellness for low- to moderate-income families and children during this public health emergency. Community First-Rent & Utilities Assistance (Miriam’s House) - $75,000 Miriam’s House is applying for $75,000 in order to provide short term rental assistance to households who become homeless as a result of COVID-19. These funds will be administered through their organization’s Community First program which already provides rental assistance and supportive services to homeless families with children and youth-headed households. The ATTACHMENT A 2 project infrastructure including trained staff, a robust landlord network and financial controls are all in place to quickly provide this crucial assistance to households made vulnerable as a result of COVID-19. This specific funding will be segmented from existing Community First funding in order to ONLY provide rental assistance for households who become homeless due to COVID- 19. It is anticipated that much like the recession in 2008 that the current economic recession due to COVID-19 will result in an increase in households experiencing homelessness. This new project will allow homeless households who lost their housing due to the economic impact of COVID-19, to get back on their feet by linking them with affordable rental housing and providing supportive services. Current households enrolled in Community First were connected to rental housing in less than 30 days of when their homeless episode began which ensures continuity of employment, health care services, educational services and other stabilizing supports. Emergency Housing and Utility Program (Lynchburg Community Action Group- Lyn-CAG)-$170,000 During the Covid-19 Pandemic several individuals have lost employment. Lynchburg Community Action Group, Inc. (Lyn-CAG) proposes to offer three (3) months of services to individuals and families who are behind in rent/mortgage and/or utilities. Individuals will need to show proof they lost their job due to the pandemic and be HUD income eligible. Staff will review the information and if eligible clients can receive up to three (3) months of expenses in the identified area. Lyn-CAG is the only HUD certified Housing Counseling agency in the region. The services that are offered give clients the tools necessary to become sustainable. Through the rental program, classes are offered in money management and counseling is provided on how to pay debt. This service also addresses the fair housing laws so that clients can become better educated on their rights and responsibilities as a tenant. Clients are taught about saving for such a crisis by having three (3) months of income saved. Lyn-CAG is one of the organizations in the area who offers emergency utility assistance. They have partnered for over 20 years with American Electric Power’s (AEP) Neighbor to Neighbor program to aid clients who are facing a termination notice. When funding was available, Lyn- CAG has provided an Emergency Assistance and Crisis Intervention Program which provided clients with financial assistance through a voucher system for rental assistance, utility assistance (electric, gas, wood and water) as well as a food pantry. The Foreclosure Prevention Counseling program is one that helps a homeowner in the region stabilize during crisis while creating an action plan to either save their home or transition. This service provides the client with tools necessary to make a sound judgment while working with servicers to ensure that remaining in the home or transitioning out of the home is the best option. Clients who receive assistance through the CDBG-CV funds will be strongly encouraged to enroll in one of these to programs. This will help to ensure that the client will be better situated in the event another crisis arises. ATTACHMENT A 3 Safe at Home Emergency Assistance (Interfaith Outreach) - $40,000 The local unemployment rate in Lynchburg skyrocketed with the mandatory COVID-19 related closing of some businesses, organizations, schools, and childcare. With safety in mind, evictions and utility terminations was halted beginning in mid-March to present with people amassing large bills for both. Many homeowners got extensions on having to pay their mortgages which are now delinquent. Interfaith Outreach’s Safe at Home Emergency Assistance will provide assistance to households with verified financial needs due to COVID-19 in the form of delinquent mortgage assistance payments, delinquent rent assistance payments, and delinquent utility payments made directly to the vendors. Loss of shelter, power, and water would pose an immediate threat to the health and welfare of the Lynchburg community. Households receiving this assistance must have a need as a result of COVID-19 and are low and moderate income persons whose household incomes are at or below 80% of the Area Median Income (AMI) as adjusted for family size and as determined by HUD for Lynchburg. COVID-19 Care Kits (City-Department of Emergency Services)-$52,752 The Center for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) guidelines recommends that everyone should wear a cloth face cover when they have to go out in public. Also, if soap and water are not readily available it is recommended to use hand sanitizer that contains at least 60% alcohol. The Pandemic has proven to be a major setback for many of those already struggling to improve their lives particularly households with young children within the urban core of the City. The youth in the City schools could benefit from a COVID-19 kit that would include masks, hand sanitizers, and educational materials to help reduce the spread of the COVID-19 virus. This project would meet an urgent need that poses a serious and immediate threat to the health or welfare of the community and other financial resources. This project would provide COVID-19 preparedness kits to at least 2,400 City school students who participate in the Summer Food Service Program. The Summer Food Service Program is available at the neighborhood centers where at least 50% of the children are eligible for free meals from the schools. The kits would include hand sanitizer, masks, and preparedness information in multiple languages. COVID-19 Awareness Communications Campaign (City-Department of Communications and Marketing)-$39,990 Accurate, easily obtainable, relevant information is critical even in good times. During a pandemic it can be the difference between life and death. Experts have recommended that people avoid large crowds, stockpile shelf-stable foods in case they end up quarantined, stay home from work and contact a doctor if they are ill. There’s a confluence of issues that indicate individuals who are on the lower end of the income scale, or are unemployed and underinsured, but there’s a key problem with that advice: A lot of low-income people can’t afford to follow it. Low-income jobs - line-cooks, nurse’s aides, grocery store clerks - mostly can’t be done remotely, and the majority of low-income jobs don’t offer paid sick days. It is also difficult for people on the lower to moderate end of the socio-economic spectrum to obtain useful information on how and where to obtain the resources they need including food, financial assistance, healthcare and other vital information. The purpose of this project is to insure easy ATTACHMENT A 4 access to important information to all sectors of the City’s population but with a focus on those individuals and families in the lower to moderate social-economic spectrum. In order to reach the intended audience, a variety of public information tools will be employed. The information will address prevention (staying closer to home when possible, wearing masks and possible resources, washing hands) financials resources, food resources, etc. The funds will be used to purchase air time on local television and radio stations, printed materials to insert in water bills, billboard rentals in strategic locations, door hangars and flyers left in neighborhoods with large low to moderate income residents, radio advertising, paid advertisements on the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company buses, printed advertisement pieces placed in neighborhood markets/gas stations, etc. ATTACHMENT B Total CDBG CV Available 420,487.00$ City Council Amount Amount Requested Awarded NAME FY 2020 FY 2020 City Administration 22,745.00$ Summer Lunch & Play Program (City-Parks & Recreation Dept.) 20,000.00 Community First-Rent & Utilities Assist. (Miriam's House) 75,000.00 Emergency Housing and Utility Program (Lyn-CAG) 170,000.00 Safe at Home Emergency Assistance (Interfaith Outreach) 40,000.00 COVID-19 Care Kits (City-Dept,. Of Emergency Services) 52,752.00 COVID-19 Awareness Communications Campaign (City-Communications and Marketing) 39,990.00 Totals 420,487.00$ -$ Remaining Amount to Award -$ 420,487.00$ CDBG CARES ACT CORONAVIRUS (CV) ENTITLEMENT FUNDS FISCAL YEAR (FY) 2020 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: May 26, 2020 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: AGENDA ITEM #: 11 CLOSED SESSION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES) Provider Relief Fund Stimulus Payment: $116,677 for the Fire Department KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 General Fund Ambulance Service Fees budget and appropriate $116,677 with resources from the 2020 Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES) Stimulus Act Provider Relief Fund to offset loss of revenue related to COVID-19 transports. SUMMARY: The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services has awarded the City a stimulus payment through the CARES Act Provider Relief Fund in the amount of $116,677 to support healthcare-related expenses attributable to COVID-19. The CARES Act prohibits the Fire Department from direct billing patients with COVID-19 symptoms, which results in a loss of revenue. However, these funds are authorized to be used to offset loss of revenue related to COVID-19 transports. This lost revenue does not include payments that have been or will be made by insurance companies or other third party entities where direct billing may be applicable. This allocation is a stimulus requiring no reimbursement. PRIOR ACTION(S): May 26, 2020: Finance Committee will review this request FISCAL IMPACT: None – No local match is required. CONTACT(S): Fire Chief Greg Wormser, 455- 6340 Fire Administrative Manager Annette Pettyjohn, 455-6368 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution REVIEWED BY: raw RESOLUTION: #R-20-034 BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 General Fund Ambulance Service Fees budget is amended and $116,677 is appropriated with resources from the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES) Stimulus Act Provider Relief Fund to be used to offset loss of revenue related to COVID-19 transports. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council 061R LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: May 26, 2020 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: AGENDA ITEM #: 12 CLOSED SESSION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: North American Association for Environmental Educators (NAAEE) – National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association (NOAA) Watershed STEM Education Partnership Grant KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution amending the FY 2020 Stormwater Operating Fund budget and appropriate up to $59,755 with resources from the North American Association for Environmental Educators (NAAEE) – National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) 21st Century Community Learning Center Watershed STEM Education Partnership Grant. SUMMARY: The Department of Water Resources (DWR) has been awarded the NAAEE and NOAA 21 st Century Community Learning Center Watershed STEM Education Partnership Grant totaling $59,755 to be distributed over two years. This grant was a national, competitive award with an application process which included creating partnerships with 21st Century Community Learning Centers (21st CCLCs) in the Lynchburg City Schools (LCS). Funds from this grant will provide the opportunity for DWR to partner with two 21st CCLCs within LCS to implement service learning and watershed focused enrichment activities. The grant will allow students to safely visit parts of their City they otherwise might not experience, learn about the value of water, and strengthen their personal experiences and positive impact in the watershed and the world. The program is tentatively scheduled to run from Fall 2020 to Spring 2022. Programming will occur at Linkhorne Elementary School and Heritage Elementary School. Through this partnership pilot program, students will have the opportunity to: - Tour the City’s water treatment plant, visit the James River, and collect data from streams on or near their school’s property. Students will use new stream monitoring technology and testing kits, which will be purchased with funds from this grant. - Partake in service learning by identifying a water related problem in their community and will propose and implement an action plan to address the identified problem. Additionally, the grant will allow DWR to engage students’ parents in water-related topics during parent engagement sessions. Finally, the grant provides funds for professional development opportunities for partnering 21st CCLC’s educators to attend the Virginia Association of Environmental Education’s Annual Conference and participation in professional development workshops led by Department of Water Resources educators. PRIOR ACTION(S): May 26, 2020 : Finance Committee will review this request FISCAL IMPACT: There is no financial impact other than staff time and the use of City vehicles and existing equipment. CONTACT(S): Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources, 455-4252 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution REVIEWED BY: raw RESOLUTION: #R-20-034 BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 Stormwater Fund Operating budget is amended and $59,755 is appropriated with resources from the North American Association for Environmental Educators (NAAEE) – National Oceanic and Atmospheric Association (NOAA) 21st Century Community Learning Center Watershed STEM Education Partnership Grant to implement service learning and watershed focused activities in partnership with Lynchburg City Schools. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: June 9, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 9 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Conditional Use Permit – Automotive Tire Store – 3139 Old Forest Road KEY ELEMENTS: _X Economic Development __Excellent Government _ X_Natural and Built Environment _ Safe Community _ X _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Approval of the Conditional Use Permit to allow the use of the existing building as an automotive tire store. SUMMARY: RNR of Virginia (Jonathan Rose) is petitioning for a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) at 3139 Old Forest Road to allow the use of an existing building as an Automotive Tire Store in a B-3, Community Business District. Automotive Tire Stores are a permitted use in the B-3, Community Business District upon approval of a CUP by City Council. One (1) existing vehicular entrance on Confederate Avenue is proposed to be closed and landscaping on the site would be improved. PRIOR ACTION(S): May 13, 2020: The Planning Division recommended approval of the Conditional Use Permit. The Planning Commission recommended approval of the CUP. (7-0) FISCAL IMPACT: Increased real estate value to be determined upon construction completion. CONTACT(S): Tom Martin, City Planner – 455-3900 Kent White, Community Development Director – 455-3900 ATTACHMENT(S): • Resolution • Planning Commission Minutes – May 13, 2020 • Planning Commission Packet – May 13, 2020 o Planning Commission Report o Zoning Map with Adjoining Owners o Future Land Use Map o Watershed Map o Planimetric and Topographic Map o Concept Plan o Narrative o Property Photograph o Speaker Sign in Sheet REVIEWED BY: raw RESOLUTION: #R-20-037 A RESOLUTION GRANTING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO RNR OF VIRGINIA IN THE B-3, COMMUNITY BUSINESS DISTRICT AT 3139 OLD FOREST ROAD TO ALLOW THE USE OF AN EXISTING BUILDING AS AN AUTOMOTIVE TIRE STORE. BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG that the petition of RNR of Virginia for a Conditional Use Permit at 3139 Old Forest Road to allow the use of an existing building as an Automotive Tire Store in the B-3, Community Business District is hereby approved subject to the following conditions: 1. The site shall be developed in substantial compliance with the conceptual site plan. 2. Landscaping shall be added to the site so as to be in closer conformance with the City’s Landscaping Ordinance. Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council 068R 1 MINUTES OF THE MAY 13 , 20 20 PLANNING C OMMISSION MEETING (MINUTES HAVE NOT BEEN APPROVED): Petition of RNR of Virginia (Jonathan Rose) for a Conditional Use Permit in a B-3, Community Business District to operate a tire store in an existing building at 3139 Old Forest Road. Mr. Tom Martin, City Planner, provided the following summary to the Commission. This property is currently zoned B -3, Community Business District, and was most recently used as a carpet store. Tire stores are permitted in B -3 distric ts upon approval of a Conditional Use Permit by City Council. This proposed use and the zoning along the corridor are not really in keeping with the proposed neighborhood commercial uses but City Council has recently approved other auto oriented uses in th e area. One existing entrance to the property would be closed, which would improve access management to the property as well as help along Old Forest Road. The petitioner will be working with staff to bring the site as close as possible in compliance with the City’s landscaping ordinance. Staff recommends approval of the Conditional Use Permit. Chair Rogers asked who was here to speak on behalf of the petition. Mr. Will Sigler, of Cardinal Survey & Design, addressed the Commission. This is an adaptive re use of an existing building so that it doesn’t sit there and go to waste. There are no proposed improvements to the building, other than signage and façade. Contact has been made with adjacent neighbors but there has been no response. Commissioner Bowden asked for clarification on the change being made to the access point. Mr. Sigler responded that the entrance will be turned into landscaping. Chair Rogers asked if there was anyone present who wished to speak in favor of the petition. Mr. Gary Case, of Gary W. Case & Co., Inc., addressed the Commission. Additional landscaping will be added along Old Forest Road and, as stated in the report from staff, there will be no negative impact on the adjoining neighborhood. Chair Rogers asked if th ere was anyone present who wished to speak in opposition of the petition, when no one came forward he closed the public hearing. Commissioner Marion noted that she had no questions or objections. This use fits in as well as the carpet store did with the other businesses along Old Forest Road. Commissioner Lowe stated that he has no objections to this either. There are auto part stores across the street as well as garages and oil change places so a tire store will fit in. It is also better than having an empty building. Chair Rogers asked for clarification on what will specifically be sold. Mr. Jonathan Rose, of RNR of Virginia, addressed the Commission. His company is a franchise that sells passenger tires, light truck tires, wheels, and does light automotive aftermarket work if people want to lift up their truck or achieve that “off-road” look. It is a simple and clean business. Chair Rogers responded that it doesn’t seem like there’s a lot of competition for something like that. Mr. Rose responded that there is plenty of competition but the company is Norfolk -based and has wanted to expand in Lynchburg for a long time. 2 Chair Rogers stated that this will be a nice use for a property that has been sitting empty. It is a unique building and not every business would be able to utilize it. Commissioner Johnson shared agreement. Commissioner Bowden stated that this will take away some traffic issues. Commissioner Bowden made the following motion, seconded by Commissioner Lowe, and passed by the following vote: “Based on the preceding Findings of Fact, the Planning Commission recommends to City Council approval of the petition of RNR of Virginia for a Conditional Use Permit at 3139 Old Forest Road to allow the operation of an automotive tire store in a B-3, Community Business District subject to the following conditions: 1. The site will be developed in substantial compliance with the conceptual site plan. 2. Landscaping shall be added to the site so as to be in closer conformance with the City’s Landscaping Ordinance.” AYES: Bowden, Johnson, Light, Lowe, Marion, Perault, and Rogers 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 The Department of Community Development City Hall, Lynchburg, VA 24504 434-455-3900 To: Planning Commission From: Planning Division Date: May 13, 2020 Re: Conditional Use Permit (CUP) – 3139 Old Forest Road – Automotive Tire Store I. PETITIONER RNR of Virginia (Jonathan Rose), 160-A Wellman Street, Norfolk, Virginia 23502 Representative: Mr. Willard Sigler, Cardinal Civil Resources, 306 Enterprise Drive, Suite C, Forest, Virginia 24551 Property Owner: Clagar Partners, 155 Deer Haven Drive, Lynchburg, Virginia 24501 II. LOCATION The subject Property is a tract of approximately one (1) acre located at 3139 Old Forest Road. III. PURPOSE The purpose of the petition is to allow the use of an existing building as an automotive tire store. IV. SUMMARY  The City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030 recommends a “Neighborhood Commercial” use for the area.  Automotive Tire Stores are permitted in the B-3, Community Business District upon approval of a Conditional Use Permit (CUP) by City Council. The Planning Division recommends approval of the CUP petition. V. FINDINGS OF FACT 1. Comprehensive Plan. The Future Land Use Map (FLUM) recommends a Neighborhood Commercial use for the area. These areas are intended to consist primarily of office, retail, personal service, and restaurant uses that are scaled and designed to be compatible with and serve their immediate neighborhood. Patrons can walk, bike or take a short drive to reach them. They are comprised of individual businesses, clusters of businesses, or small shopping centers. Neighborhood shopping centers meet the day-to-day needs of a limited residential trade area of 2,500 to 10,000 people and average about 50,000 square feet of space. A small grocery store or drug store is often the anchor for a neighborhood shopping center. Office uses should be relatively small-scale with building floor areas not exceeding 20,000 square feet and heights not exceeding four stories. Residential uses may be established on the upper floors of commercial structures or as transitional structures between residential and commercial buildings. ( p.75) The proposed use does not fit well within the proposed Neighborhood Commercial land use. However, the property was most recently used as a carpet store and the proposal would reuse an existing building. Another “auto oriented” use was recently approved by Council (Valvoline) at 3033 Old Forest Road. The Future Land Use Map in this area should be examined Planning Commission: CUP – 3139 Old Forest Road –May 13, 2019 2 for revisions, given the existing B-3, Community Business District Zoning in the area and historical development patterns. 2. Zoning. The subject property was annexed into the City in 1976 from Campbell County. The existing B-3, Community Business District zoning was established on May 22, 1979 as part of a study of the Old Forest Road area. 3. Board of Zoning Appeals (BZA). The Zoning Administrator has determined that no variances are needed for the development of the property as proposed. 4. Surrounding Area. There have been several items requiring City Council approval in the immediate area:  On May 22, 1979, City Council approved the Old Forest Road Study which rezoned several parcels along the Old Forest Road Corridor.  On November 10, 1981, City Council approved the petition of Lynchburg Investment Company to rezone the property located at 2820 Linkhorne Drive from R-3 to B-3C to allow the construction of a shopping center.  On March 8, 1983, City Council approved the petition of Hammer Gay to amend previously approved proffers for the property located at 2820 Linkhorne Drive.  On November 12, 1985, City Council approved the petition of Lynchburg Investment Company to rezone the property located at Linkhorne Drive and Fulton Street from B-3 to B-5C to allow the operation of a television studio with a transmitting tower.  On January 14, 1992, City Council approved the conditional use permit petition of Monro Muffler, Inc. to allow the construction of a facility for minor auto repairs at 3201 Old Forest Road.  On February 14, 1996, City Council approved the petition of Ivy Lake Properties, Inc. to rezone the property at 3112-3132 Link Road, from R-3 to R-4 to allow the construction of apartments.  On April 9, 1996, City Council approve

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.