RecordWell Data

City Council Work Session and Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of May 12, 2020 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Physical Development Committee – canceled AGENDA City Council Meeting of May 12, 2020 4:00 P.M. – Work Session – Council Chamber #1. Consider revisions to the Solid Waste Ordinance #2. Continuation of balancing the FY2021 Operating Budget and addressing the Proposed Budget “List” #3. Update on City Actions regarding COVID-19 #4. Roll Call 7:30 P.M. City Council Agenda Items COUNCILMEMBER WRIGHT WILL GIVE THE INVOCATION GENERAL POLICY REGARDING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AT CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS Each speaker shall clearly state his or her name and locality of residence. The City Council agenda is divided into four sections. CONSENT AGENDA: This section includes routine items. All items may be approved by one vote. PUBLIC HEARINGS: This section includes all public hearings as required by law or as Council may direct. Procedure:  Staff will make a presentation.  For zoning petitions, the applicant or his or her representative shall have ten (10) minutes to make a presentation.  Comments will then be solicited from those in favor.  Comments will then be solicited from those in opposition. During the public hearing, there shall be a time limit of three (3) minutes for each individual speaker. If the speaker represents a group, there shall be a time limit of five (5) minutes. A speaker representing a group shall identify that group at the beginning of his or her remarks. A group may have only one spokesperson. After public comments have been received, for zoning petitions, the applicant or the representative of the applicant, at his or her discretion, may respond with a rebuttal. There shall be a five (5)- minute time limit for rebuttal. Upon the conclusion of public comments or the applicant’s rebuttal, the public hearing will be closed and the matter referred to Council for deliberation. PUBLIC COMMENT: Public comment shall be for the purpose of allowing members of the public to present any matter, which, in their opinion, deserves the attention of the Council. They shall not serve as a forum for debate with the Council. Individuals may speak up to three (3) minutes; or group spokesperson up to five (5) minutes. Once Council has heard a presentation from a citizen or organization on a particular subject, the citizen or organization may not make another presentation on the same subject within three (3) months of the first presentation, except by a majority vote of the members of Council present and voting. GENERAL BUSINESS: This section includes items of a general nature to be considered by Council. City Council may make exceptions to these rules at its discretion. Prior to a meeting, any questions which citizens may have regarding any item on the agenda may be addressed to City Council or the City Administration. The following numbers are provided for the convenience of the citizens: CITY COUNCIL 455-3995 MAYOR 455-3995 CITY MANAGER 455-3990 A reasonable charge may be made for copying and other activities related to responding to long and involved inquiries. CITIZENS OFTEN EXPRESS CONFLICTING AND DIVERSE POSITIONS REGARDING SPECIFIC ISSUES UNDER CONSIDERATION. TO ENCOURAGE CITIZEN PARTICIPATION AND TO AVOID INTIMIDATION TO PERSONS WHO MAY EXPRESS SOMETIMES UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, APPLAUSE, CHEERS, OR JEERS FROM THE AUDIENCE ARE NOT PERMITTED. WHEN APPEARING BEFORE CITY COUNCIL, CITIZENS MAY NOT ENGAGE IN BEHAVIOR THAT INTIMIDATES OR INSULTS OTHERS, ENGAGE IN DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOR, USE PROFANITY OR VULGAR LANGUAGE, PROMOTE PRIVATE BUSINESS VENTURES OR CAMPAIGN FOR PUBLIC OFFICE. * PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED AND/OR CONSIDERED BY CITY COUNCIL 2 Recognitions:  Proclamation – Recognize Lynchburg City Schools Graduating Seniors  Proclamation – Recognize Public Works Week  Proclamation - Recognize Police Week C O N S E N T A G E N D A #5. Consideration of approving the minutes of the April 14, 2020 meeting #6. Consideration of approving the minutes of the April 28, 2020 meeting #7. * Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-20-030 to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $112,531 with resources from the 2020 Coronavirus Emergency Supplemental Funding Program to purchase COVID-19 related Equipment, Decontamination Services, Supplies, Overtime & Fringe Benefits expenditures. P U B L I C H E A R I N G S #8. Public hearing regarding adopting a resolution approving the allocation of the Fiscal Year (FY) 2021, Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program funds and incorporating into the FY 2021 General Fund Operating Budget and Program Year (PY) 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan and FY 2021 Annual Action Plan (File: Community Development) #R-20-031 #9. Public hearing to receive comments regarding the proposed amendments to the Citizen Participation Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Investment Partnerships Act (HOME Program) and adopt a resolution approving the Plan. (File: Community Development) #R-20-032 #10. Public hearing regarding the consideration of adopting the Forest Brook Road Corridor Study as part of the City’s Comprehensive Plan 2013-2030. The purpose of the study is to provide the City of Lynchburg with a detailed planning level assessment of the options for future needs of Forest Brook Road that will enhance safety while accommodating future capacity of the roadway. The plan provides the following recommendations: trimming and maintenance of vegetation, upgrading guardrails, installation of curb & gutter and sidewalk, improve intersection radius at Forest Brook Road and Lakeside Drive, improve the horizontal curvature of the roadway, and ensure adequate sight distances. (File: City Council) #O-20-012 #11. Consideration of a closed meeting for the discussion and consideration of prospective candidates for the position of City Manager pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia. LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: May 12, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 1 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Solid Waste Ordinance Revisions KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X__Excellent Government __Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community _X__Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Approve recommended revisions to the solid waste ordinance. SUMMARY: Over the course of five City Council meetings, staff has presented recommendations for improvements to the City’s refuse collection system and City Council has approved a number of changes to our current system. As a result of those conversations, there are several changes to the City’s operations that must be reflected in a revised Chapter 21.2 - Solid Waste Collection and Disposal in the City Code. These changes will be reviewed by staff at the City Council meeting and reflect City Council’s prior decisions and add clarifying language to improve compliance with the ordinance provisions. The significant revisions include the following: - Clarifies how residents can receive extra trash carts (Section 21.2-11) - Refines bulk and brush collection rules and routes (Section 21.2-19 and 20) - Defines Commercial Business Eligibility for services, violation and services fess, and physical limits of service (Section 21.2-26) - Establishes the monthly trash collection fee per cart (Section 21.2-31) - Removes the annual decal language (primary in Section 21.2-31, but also throughout the ordinance) - Remove exceptions to billing (disadvantaged and tax relief) (Section 21.2-31) - Revisions to violations (Section 21.2-47) - Clarifies rules for landlord setouts (Section 21.2-52) - Clarifies types of vehicles allowed at the Concord Turnpike Convenience Center (Section 21.2-58) PRIOR ACTION(S): July 10, 2018: City Council Work Session, Public Works Solid Waste Task Force Report November 12, 2019: City Council Regular Meeting, Solid Waste System Evaluation Report February 11, 2020: City Council Regular Meeting, Further refuse discussion and various decisions March 10, 2020: City Council Regular Meeting, Tyreeanna/Pleasant Valley Trash Fee discussion May 5, 2020: City Council Work Session, Refuse Collection – monthly fee and education and enforcement decision FISCAL IMPACT: The Fiscal Year 2021 budget reflects reduction of City cost for the Refuse Division of $24,852 compared to the previous fiscal years as a result of moving to the monthly billing structure. Additionally, the new rules and structure associated with brush and bulk pickup will reduce operating costs for this service; that amount will be determined after implementation. CONTACT(S): Gaynelle Hart, Director Public Works – 455-4406 ATTACHMENT(S): Proposed Chapter 21.2 – Solid Waste Collection and Disposal REVIEWED BY: raw 1 AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT SECTIONS 21.2-1, 21.2-2, 21.2-3, 21.2-4, 21.2- 5, 21.2-6. 21.2-7, 21.2-8, 21.2-9, 21.2-11, 21.2-17, 21.2-18, 21.2-19, 21.2-20, 21.2-26, 21.2-27, 21.2-28, 21.2-29, 21.2-30, 21.2-31, 21.2-32, 21.2-36, 21.2-37, 21.2-38, 21.2-39, 21.2-40, 21.2- 47, 21.2-47.1, 21.2-48, 21.2-49, 21.2-50, 21.2-51, 21.2-52, 21.2-58, AND 21.2-59, OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, 1981, THE AMENDED SECTION RELATING TO SOLID WASTE COLLECTION AND DISPOSAL. BE IT ORDAINED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG: 1. That Sections 21.2-1, 21.2-2, 21.2-3, 21.2-4, 21.2-5, 21.2-6. 21.2-7, 21.2-8, 21.2-9, 21.2-11, 21.2-17, 21.2-18, 21.2-19, 21.2-20, 21.2-26, 21.2-27, 21.2-28, 21.2-29, 21.2-30, 21.2-31, 21.2- 32, 21.2-36, 21.2-37, 21.2-38, 21.2-39, 21.2-40, 21.2-47, 21.2-47.1, 21.2-48, 21.2-49, 21.2-50, 21.2-51, 21.2-52, 21.2-58, and 21.2-59, of the Code of the City of Lynchburg, 1981, be and the same are hereby amended and reenacted as follows: Chapter 21.2 - SOLID WASTE COLLECTION AND DISPOSAL ARTICLE I. - IN GENERAL Sec. 21.2-1. - Declaration of policy. It is hereby declared to be the policy of the City of Lynchburg to promote public safety, health, welfare, and to promote the recovery of useful resources by establishing rules and regulations relating to solid waste collection and disposal. The City operates a solid waste collection program that consists of regular refuse collection, special collections, and recycling collection centers. The City Manager or his or her designee is responsible for the proper management of this system. The City of Lynchburg is a member of the Region 2000 Services Authority (RSA) which operates a regional landfill for the disposal of solid waste from the cCity and other member localities. A transfer station for the convenience of city residents is located on Concord Turnpike at the site of the former cCity landfill. The rules and regulations contained herein are applicable to both facilities. Sec. 21.2-2. - Administration and enforcement of chapter. The cCity mManager or his or her designee shall be responsible for the administration and enforcement of this chapter, and shall have the authority to establish reasonable rules and regulations, consistent with the provisions of this chapter, which will carry out the purposes and intent. The City of Lynchburg Police Department shall assist in the enforcement of this policy in cooperation with the cCity mManager or his or her designee. 2 Sec. 21.2-3. - Definitions. Wherever used in this chapter, unless a different meaning clearly appears in the context, the following terms shall be given the following respective interpretations: Agricultural waste: All solid waste produced from farming operations, or related commercial preparation of farm products for marketing. Apartment: A building or portion thereof designed for or occupied by more than two families, and all living units of which are to be maintained under single ownership or management. This shall be interpreted to include all multi-family rental units. Ash: The fly ash or bottom ash residual waste material produced from incineration or burning of solid waste or from any fuel combustion. Bottom ash: Ash or slag remaining in a combustion unit after combustion. Boxes: Includes corrugated boxes, paperboard boxes, and cardboard boxes. Brush: Any yard or debris wastes tree trimmings no larger than three inches in diameter and eight feet in length which cannot be placed in containers in accordance with the regulations herein set forth. Brush does not include stumps, land clearing debris, wood pallets, landscape timbers, leaves, commercial or contractor cuttings or bags containing yard debris of any type. Bulk waste: Items of residential waste, such as furniture, tables, chairs, large cartons, white goods, or similar materials which cannot be placed in containers in accordance with the regulations herein set forth. Bulk waste does not include bags, tires, household hazardous waste, construction, and demolition, remodeling debris or items containing glass or glass-like materials. Bundles: A number of things bound together for collection (such as brush, broken-down boxes and waste). Brush and yard waste bundles shall meet the requirements of section 21.2-4 for collection. Boxes shall be broken down and tied together. No bundle shall exceed 50 pounds in weight. Collection: Removal or transportation of solid waste, ashes, recyclable material and yard waste, from its place of storage or collection point to its place of disposal. Commercial establishment: Any retail or wholesale, restaurant, religious, government or nonresidential establishment at which trash or garbage may be generated. Commercial waste: All solid waste generated by establishments engaged in business operations other than manufacturing or construction. This category includes, but is not limited to, solid waste resulting from the operation of stores, markets, office buildings, restaurants and shopping centers. Compost: A stabilized organic product produced by a controlled aerobic decomposition process in such a manner that the product can be handled, stored, and/or applied to the land without 3 adversely affecting public health or the environment. Composted sludge shall be as defined by the Virginia Sewerage Regulations. Condominium: An apartment house or complex in which the apartments or dwelling units are individually owned. Construction waste: Solid waste which is produced or generated during construction, remodeling, or repair of pavements, houses, commercial buildings and other structures. Construction wastes include, but not limited to, lumber, wire, sheetrock, broken brick, asphalt, shingles, glass, pipes, concrete, paving materials and metal and plastics if the metal or plastics are a part of the materials of construction or empty containers for such materials. Paints, coatings, solvents, asbestos, any liquid, compressed gases or semi-liquids and garbage are not construction wastes. Debris waste: Wastes resulting from land clearing operations. Debris wastes include, but are not limited to, stumps, wood, brush, leaves, soil, and road spoils. Demolition waste: Any solid waste which is produced by the destruction of structures and their foundations and includes the same materials as construction waste. Discard: To abandon, dispose of, burn, incinerate, accumulate, store or treat before or instead of being abandoned, disposed of, burned or incinerated. Discarded material: A material which is: (a) Abandoned by being: (1) Disposed of, (2) Burned or incinerated; or (3) Accumulated, stored or treated (but not used, reused, or reclaimed) before or in lieu of being abandoned by being disposed of, burned or incinerated, (b) Used, reused or reclaimed material as defined in this part, or (c) Considered as solid waste as defined in section 3.2 of the Virginia Solid Waste Management Regulations (VR 672-72-10). DEQ: The Virginia Department of Environmental Quality. Disposal: The act of discharging, depositing, injecting, dumping, spilling, leaking or placing of any solid waste into or on any land or water so that such solid waste or any constituent thereof may enter the environment or be emitted into the air or discharged into any waters. Disposal site: All land and structures, other appurtenances, and improvements thereon used for treating, storing, and disposing of solid waste. This term includes adjacent land within the property boundary used for the utility systems such as repair, storage, shipping or processing 4 areas, or other areas incident to the management of solid waste. All solid waste disposal sites must be approved and/or permitted by the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ). EPA: The United States Environmental Protection Agency. Fly ash: Ash particulate collected from air pollution attenuation devices on combustion units. Garbage: Readily putrescible discarded materials composed of animal, vegetable or other organic matter. Hazardous waste: A "hazardous waste" as described by the Virginia Hazardous Waste Regulations (VR 672-10-1). Household hazardous waste (HHW): The following are examples of what residents can bring on HHW collection days to the Region 2000 Services Authority (RSA) facility: acids/bases, aerosols, antifreeze, autostarter, brake fluids, batteries, cleaners/polishes, corrosives, drain openers, flammables, furniture stripper, herbicides, kerosene, lighter fluids, oven cleaners, oxidizers, oil based paints, pesticides, photo/pool chemicals, poisons, solvents/thinners, used motor oil, weed killers and wood preservatives. The RSA website maintains the current list of the types of waste that are accepted and not accepted. Household waste: Any waste material, including garbage, trash and refuse, derived from households. Households include single and multiple residences, hotels and motels, bunkhouses, ranger stations, crew quarters, campgrounds, picnic grounds and day-use recreation areas. Household wastes do not include sanitary waste in septic tanks (septage) which is regulated by state agencies other than DEQ's Division of Waste Management Programs. Industrial waste: Any solid waste generated by manufacturing or industrial process that is not a regulated hazardous waste. Such waste may include, but is not limited to, waste resulting from the following manufacturing processes: electric power generation; fertilizer/agriculture chemicals; food and related products/by-products; inorganic chemicals; iron and steel manufacturing; leather and leather products; nonferrous metals manufacturing/foundries; organic chemicals; plastics and resins manufacturing; pulp and paper industry; rubber and miscellaneous plastic products; stone, glass, clay, and concrete products; textile manufacturing; transportation equipment; and waste treatment. This term does not include mining waste or oil and gas waste. Inert waste: Solid waste which is physically, chemically and biologically stable from further degradation and considered to be non-reacting. Inert wastes include rubble, concrete, bricks, and blocks. Institutional waste: All solid waste emanating from institutions such as, but not limited to, hospitals, nursing homes, orphanages, and public or private schools. It can include infectious waste from health care facilities and research facilities that must be managed as an infectious waste. No medical waste is accepted at the RSA facility. 5 Landfill: A sanitary landfill, an industrial waste landfill or a construction/debris landfill. Landfill disposal area: The area within the property boundary or permitted for actual burial. Litter: Any waste as defined in 21.1-2 (Litter Control - Definitions) of this Code. Living units: One or more rooms in a residential building or in a mixed building which are arranged, designed, used or intended for use by one or more persons living together and maintaining a common household. Medical waste: Any solid waste identified by health care professionals in charge as capable of producing infectious disease in humans. Any solid waste is regulated medical waste if it is one of the following: (a) Discarded cultures, stocks, specimens, vaccines and associated items likely to have been contaminated by them are regulated medical wastes if they are likely to contain organisms likely to be pathogenic to healthy humans; (b) Waste consisting of human blood, human blood products and items contaminated by human blood are regulated human wastes; (c) All pathological wastes and all wastes that are human tissues, organs, body parts, or body fluids are regulated medical wastes; (d) Used sharps (needles, syringes, etc.) likely to be contaminated with organisms that are pathogenic to healthy humans and all sharps used in patient care are regulated medical waste; (e) Any residue or contaminated soil, water, or other debris resulting from the cleanup of a spill of any regulated medical waste is itself regulated medical waste; and (f) Any solid waste contaminated by or mixed with regulated medical waste is itself regulated medical waste. Trailer court Mobile or manufactured home parcel: Any lot, parcel or tract of land, together with open spaces, used, designed, maintained or held out to accommodate one or more mobile or manufactured homes,. or trailers, including all buildings, structures, tents, vehicles, accessories or appurtenances used or intended as equipment of such mobile or manufactured home. or trailer court. A mobile or manufactured home court provides for the permanent or long-term location of mobile or manufactured homes. The owner(s) of the mobile or manufactured home trailer court shall be responsible for ensuring that the residents of the trailer court mobile or manufactured home comply with the provisions of this chapter. Motor vehicle: Every device, which is self-propelled or designed for self-propulsion, in, upon, or by which any person or property is or may be transported or drawn upon the highway, except devices moved by human power or used exclusively upon stationary rails or tracks. Any structure designed, used, or maintained primarily to be loaded on or affixed to a motor vehicle to provide a mobile dwelling, sleeping place, office or commercial space, shall be considered a part of a motor vehicle. 6 Mover's trash: Solid waste generated due to person or persons moving-in to or moving-out of a residence. Multi-family unit: A building, or any appurtenances thereof, designed for occupancy or occupied by two or more families, and all living units of which are to be maintained under single ownership or management. This shall be interpreted to include all, but not limited to apartments, condominiums and duplexes with two or more rental units. The owner(s) of a multi-family unit shall be responsible for ensuring that the residents of a multi-family unit comply with the provisions of this chapter. Municipal solid waste: That waste which is normally composed of residential, commercial, and institutional solid waste. Medical waste is not accepted at the RSA facility. Occupant: Any person occupying or residing on any lot, premises or parcel of land in the city and having, at the time, apparent possession or control thereof. Owner: Any person who, alone or jointly or severally with others: (a) Shall have all or part of legal title to any lot, premises or parcel of land in the city, not, at the time, in the actual or apparent possession or control of another, or; (b) Shall have all or part of the beneficial ownership and a right to present use and enjoyment of the premises, and the term shall include a mortgagee in possession, or; (c) Shall have charge, care or control of any lot, premises or parcel of land in the city, as agent or representative of the owner, or as personal representative, trustee or guardian of the estate of the owner. Person: Any individual, corporation, partnership, association, a governmental body, a municipal corporation or any other legal entity. Putrescible waste: Solid waste which contains organic material capable of being decomposed by micro-organisms and cause odors. Recyclable material: Any material which retains useful properties that can be reclaimed after the production or consumption process. Recycling center: A facility designed for the collection, separation and/or recycling of recyclable materials. Refuse: All solid waste products having the character of solids rather than liquids and which are composed wholly or partially of materials such as garbage, trash, rubbish, litter, residues from clean-up of spills or contamination, or other discarded materials. Regulated medical waste: Solid wastes defined to be infectious by the Virginia Regulated Medical Waste Management Regulations (VR 672-40-01). Residential waste: Any household waste. 7 RSA facility: a landfill, transfer station, recycling center or other operation managed by the Region 2000 Services Authority for the purpose of collecting and disposing of solid waste. Rubbish: Combustible or slowly putrescible discarded materials which include but are not limited to trees, wood, leaves, trimmings from shrubs or trees, printed matter, plastic and paper products, grass, rags and other combustible or slowly putrescible materials not included under the term "garbage." Scavenging: The unauthorized or uncontrolled collection or removal of waste or recyclable materials from a solid waste management facility, waste that has been placed on the curbside for cCity collection or recycling center. Semitrailer: Every vehicle of the trailer type so designed and used in conjunction with a motor vehicle that some part of its own weight and that of its own load rests upon or is carried by another vehicle. Single-family residence: a residential building or structure containing only one dwelling unit, which is arranged, designed, used or intended for use by one family (as defined by the cCity's zoning ordinance). The owner(s) of a single-family residence that is being occupied as rental property shall be responsible for ensuring that the occupant(s) of such single-family residence comply with the provisions of this chapter. Site clearance materials: Any items such as boulders, rocks, tree trunks, stumps, or tree limbs. Solid waste: Any of those materials defined as 'solid waste' in Part III of the Virginia Solid Waste Management Regulations (VR 672-20-10). Solid waste management facility: A site used for planned treating, storing, or disposing of solid waste. A facility may consist of several treatment, storage, or disposal units. Special wastes: Solid wastes that are difficult to handle, require special precautions because of hazardous properties or the nature of the waste creates waste management problems in normal operations. Trash: Combustible and noncombustible discarded materials, and is used interchangeably with the term rubbish. Waste container: City approved trash cart or approved prepaid plastic trash bag. White goods: Any stoves, washers, hot water heaters and other large appliances. Yard waste: That fraction of municipal solid waste that consists of grass clippings, leaves, brush and tree prunings arising from general landscape maintenance. 8 Sec. 21.2-4. - Preparation of solid waste for curbside collection. (a) Generally. All solid waste designated for collection by the cCity is to be bagged and kept in a covered approved container. Paper must be placed in an approved waste container or kept securely bundled in order to prevent being blown or scattered about the street. (b) Ashes. Ashes shall be cool and dry before placing in an approved waste container. Ashes shall be kept separate from and not placed in containers with other solid waste. (c) Sharp objects. Solid waste with sharp edges or points, including but not limited to broken glass and fluorescent tubes, shall be placed in an approved waste container meeting criteria set in section 21.2-6, but not including a plastic bag as described in section 21.2-7. Needles should be placed in a plastic or glass food container with a lid securely fastened with tape. (d) Recyclable material. In an effort to reduce the flow of solid waste disposed of at the RSA facility and promote the recovery of useful resources, recyclable material should be taken to the proper recycling centers. Any recyclable material that is accepted pursuant to a cCity recycling program, whether publicly or privately administered, shall be separated from other solid waste for pickup in accordance with criteria to be established by the cCity mManager or his or her designee. Such items include, but are not limited to, aluminum and steel cans, newspaper, glass, mixed paper and some plastics. Such recyclable materials should be separated for recycling. (e) Yard waste. Yard waste collection by the cCity shall only be furnished to those residences regularly scheduled for the removal of solid waste by the cCity. All yard waste to be collected with normal residential waste shall be placed in approved containers or tied in bundles no larger than four feet in length, and 15 inches in diameter and weighing no more than 50 pounds. in weight. During special yard waste collection, all yard waste will be collected, provided no part is larger than three inches in diameter, and eight feet in length. Tree stumps and tree trunks will not be collected, nor will the waste resulting from topping or removal of a tree. Special yard waste collection is not offered to businesses. Any yard waste that is accepted pursuant to the city composting program shall be separated from other solid waste for pickup. (f) Paperboard boxes. Paperboard boxes should be taken to recycling centers for recycling and must beor broken down, bundled, and securely tied., and tagged with the appropriate refuse disposal tag. (g) Styrofoam packaging. Styrofoam packaging shall be placed in a securely tied plastic bag. and tagged with the appropriate refuse disposal tag. (h) Litter control bags. Litter control bags will be issued by the cCity to the neighborhood clean-up groups and individuals involved with adopt-a-street and adopt-a-spot clean- ups. The litter control bags shall be placed in the cCity right-of-way for collection after the individual(s) or group(s) have completed the clean-ups. 9 (i) Weight limitations. The total weight of a 32-gallon trash cart, including its contents, shall not exceed 100 pounds in weight. The total weight of a 64-gallon trash cart, including its contents, shall not exceed 200 pounds in weight. The total weight of any plastic bag, including its contents, shall not exceed fifty (50) pounds in weight. Sec. 21.2-5. - Containers required. Subject to the provisions of sections 21.2-6 through 21.2-10 of this chapter, it shall be the responsibility of all property owners to ensure waste containers comply with the specifications set forth by the cCity. It shall be unlawful for any person to place solid waste in containers other than those approved by the cCity. Sec. 21.2-6. - Approved waste containers— Generally. Approved waste containers for cCity collection shall be cCity-provided waste carts 32 gallons or 64 gallons in capacity or approved prepaid plastic trash bags as described in Sec. 21.2-7. No container shall be filled to the point of overflowing. Sec. 21.2-7. - Same— Approved prepaid plastic trash bags. Approved prepaid plastic trash bags as described herein shall constitute an approved waste container, and when plastic bags are used for the disposal of solid waste, the same shall conform to the following specifications: (a) Residents may purchase approved prepaid plastic trash bags for use inside an approved waste container or for occasional extra refuse that does not fit in trash container. Bags can be purchased at various vendor locations approved by the cCity and will display the City of Lynchburg seal. Fees for approved prepaid plastic trash bags will cover offset the all disposal costs for contents within bag. (b) Thirty-two-gallon bags shall not be filled to exceed 50 pounds in weight. (c) Approved prepaid plastic trash bags containing solid waste shall be securely tied when placed outside for collection to prevent refuse from falling out. (d) Approved prepaid plastic trash bags are for one time use only and will be collected and disposed of by cCity employees. 10 Sec. 21.2-8. - Maintenance of containers. Every waste container required by this article shall be maintained in as sanitary condition as possible in view of the use to which it is put, and shall be thoroughly cleansed as needed by washing, sanitizing or otherwise. All waste containers shall be kept in good condition, and solid waste shall not be placed in any container that is so constructed or is so defective that the contents leak or spill. Waste carts provided by the cCity are the property of the cCity and should remain at the address specified upon delivery. Waste carts may can be changed to a different size once per year for and may be subject to an administrative waste cart change fee established by the cCity Manager or his or her designee. Sec. 21.2-9. - Unacceptable containers. (a) Any container other than the aforementioned approved containers shall not be used for the storage and collection of solid waste for cCity collection; this includes, but is not limited to, cardboard boxes, and barrels. (b) Any uUnacceptable containers will be tagged with a warning of violation. Once tagged, these containers will be considered as solid waste that may be collected and disposed of by the cCity. Use of a waste container after it has been tagged with a warning of violation is prohibited and subject to penalties as described in this chapter. Sec. 21.2-10. - Sunken waste containers prohibited. It shall be unlawful for any person to install a new waste container, the bottom of which is sunken or depressed below the abutting grade level. Sec. 21.2-11. - Accumulation of solid waste. (a) Each residence, small commercial establishment or person having solid waste will be provided with at least one cCity- approved waste container adequate to contain the solid waste generated at said establishment which accumulates between periods of removal from the premises, and shall place and keep all solid waste therein until disposal. Eligible Rresidents and small commercial establishments requiring more than one trash cart may purchase from the city additional carts at cost may request an additional cart from the Department of Public Works and will be assessed an additional disposal fee per cart. These carts become the property of the resident. Solid waste may not accumulate outside of the cart(s) unless in approved plastic bags. Household waste that a resident is storing to bring to the RSA facility or for other disposal must be stored in closed containers in such a manner so as to not attract animals, emit offending odors, or be a safety or health risk, and such waste may not be stored for a period of more than one month. 11 (b) It shall be unlawful for anyone to throw or to cause to accumulate onto the streets, sidewalks or private property any solid waste or any other substance that will render the street or premises unclean or unsightly or unsafe to any person or vehicle using the streets or liable to injuriously affect the health or safety of the community. ARTICLE II. - SOLID WASTE COLLECTION GENERALLY Sec. 21.2-16. - Transporting refuse in vehicles. No person shall transport any garbage, trash or any other waste or refuse substance upon the streets of the city in an open or uncovered vehicle, unless such solid waste is transported in a covered container within the vehicle. Sec. 21.2-17. - Substances not collected. Any substance prohibited from disposal in an RSA facility pursuant to section 21.2-59 (b) will not be collected for disposal by the cCity if identified by the cCity in the course of collection. Sec. 21.2-18. - Unauthorized removal. Once placed on the edge of the streets of the city at the curb, it shall be unlawful for any unauthorized person to remove solid waste from or otherwise interfere with waste containers or the contents thereof. Any persons other than designated cCity employees must obtain prior authorization from the property owner, cCity mManager or his or her his designee. Sec. 21.2-19. - Special collections— Generally. Special collections by the cCity shall only be furnished to eligible residential customers and neighborhood cleanup programs on a schedule established by the City Manager or his or her designee. Special collection services are not offered to businesses. In addition to regularly scheduled Sspecial collections, shall be scheduled by the residents, or neighborhood groups may schedule additional special collections in advance of placing the material out for collection. Special collections shall include but are not limited to bulk waste collection, and yard waste (brush and leaf) collection, and tires (up to four) and a one-time mover's trash collection of solid waste. No fee will be charged for the collection of designated waste during special collection. Bagged leaves, yard waste, and appropriately bundled brush will be subject to the disposal fee when put out with refuse at other times in accordance with the provisions of section 21.2-16 through 21.2-18. Prohibited items include Brush collection restrictions include tree trimmings sizes not exceeding three inches in diameter and eight feet in length, stumps, land clearing debris, wood pallets, landscape timber and contractor cuttings. As of July 1, 2012, segregated 12 loads of brush and bulk may be brought to the RSA facility at no charge. Residents will be allowed an unlimited number of trips for segregated brush and bulk material. Effective October 1, 2020, brush and bulk items will be collected on a schedule established by the City Manager or his or her designee that identifies one collection week each month. Brush and bulk items may be placed on the curb no earlier than 7:00 a.m. Saturday prior to the designated collection week. Items must be placed on the curb no later than 7:00 a.m. Monday of the designated collection week. Brush and bulk can only be set out at the property that it was generated. The City of Lynchburg websites maintains schedules and additional guidelines for brush, bulk, special waste and tires. Sec. 21.2-20. - Same— Bulk waste and white goods. The City will remove bulk wastes (large furniture items, chairs, tables, sofas etc.) and white goods (stoves, refrigerators, washers, etc.) which have been placed on the edge of the street at the curb once per month per address. Bulk waste piles can be no larger than 6 ft. in height and 8 ft. in length. White goods that would normally contain compressors with freon must have the compressor and relating tubing fully in tact unless said white good is accompanied by a certification from an appropriate person stating that all contained freon has been captured and recycled. Prohibited bulk items include, but are not limited to, construction materials, lawn mowers, automotive parts, kerosene heaters, fuel operated appliances, loose household trash, bags, boxes, and any gas-containing cylinders and items containing glass or glass-like materials. The City of Lynchburg website maintains the schedules and guidelines for bulk waste, white goods and tires. ARTICLE III. - SOLID WASTE COLLECTION— CITY COLLECTION Sec. 21.2-26. - Collection. (a) The cCity shall collect refuse from eligible residential and small detached commercial establishments abutting a public street and certain multi-family units. If solid waste is placed curbside on the day of cCity waste collection for that property, it is assumed that property desires cCity waste collection services. Owners or operators of multi-family units (to includeincluding, but not limited to apartments, condominiums, duplexes, and town homes) and mobile or manufactured homes) trailer courts with two or more rental units, and non-manufacturing businesses accept the fee-related responsibility for associated disposal charges and are responsible for displaying an official annual trash disposal decal or using approved City-issued trash carts and approved prepaid plastic trash bags for cCity curbside collection. Owners of all properties not eligible or desiring of cCity collection shall be responsible for the proper storage and disposal of all refuse; said refuse may not be placed curbside on the day the cCity is scheduled to provide collection services. Those properties not eligible for cCity collection include, but are not 13 limited to: properties of five or more living units, attached businesses, mixed-use developments, large restaurants, manufacturing businesses, and those commercial establishments and multi-family properties with four or less living units that put out require more than four containers per collection. (b) House trailers Mobile or manufactured homes shall be treated as single family units only if they front on a public street and reside upon individually platted lots. House trailers Mobile or manufactured homes which do not front on a public street and reside upon individually platted lots shall be treated as multi-family dwellings (c) If the waste containers put out by the occupants of a multi-family unit or trailer court mobile or manufactured home do not display Annual Decals, or if are not City approved trash carts or approved prepaid plastic trash bags are not used, a duly designated officer of the cCity will issue a violation notice(s) to the owner(s) or operator(s) of the multi- family unit or trailer court mobile or manufactured home. It shall be the responsibility of the owner(s) or operator(s) to take appropriate action to make sure the occupants of the multi-family unit or trailer court mobile or manufactured home place Annual Decals on their waste containers or use City approved trash carts and use approved prepaid plastic trash bags. If after giving reasonable notice(s) to the owner(s) or occupant(s) the waste containers of a multi-family unit or trailer court mobile or manufactured home are not City approved trash carts still do not display Annual Decals, or use approved prepaid plastic plastic trash bags, the cCity may discontinue refuse collection from such multi-family unit or trailer court mobile or manufactured home until such time as the owner or occupants are in compliance with the provisions of this chpater and the owner(s) or operator(s) satisfies the following:pay all applicable fees(s). (1) Pay all applicable service fee(s); or (2) Owner(s) or Operator(s) shall make arrangements with a commercial refuse collector for the collection and disposal of the solid waste generated by the multi- family unit or trailer court. mobile or manufactured home. (d) If waste containers put out by the occupants of a single-family residence that is being occupied as rental property do not display Annual Decals or if are not City approved trash carts or approved prepaid plastic trash bags are not used, a duly designated refuse collection enforcement officer of the cCity will issue violation notice(s) to the owner(s) or occupant(s) of the single-family residence. It shall be the responsibility of the owner(s) to take appropriate action to make sure the occupants of the single-family residence place Annual Decals on their waste containers use City approved trash carts or use approved prepaid plastic trash bags. If after giving reasonable notice(s) to the owner(s) or occupant(s) the waste containers still do not display Annual Decals, are not City approved trash carts or are not City approved trash carts and approved prepaid plastic trash bags are not used, the cCity may discontinue refuse collection from such single- family residence unit such time as and the owner(s)/occupant(s) are in compliance with 14 the provisions of this chapter and pay all applicable fee(s) resident satisfies the following: (2) Owner(s) or operator(s) shall make arrangements with a commercial refuse collector for the collection and disposal of the solid waste generated by such single-family residence. (e) If the waste containers put out by the occupants of a multi-family unit, trailer court mobile or manufactured home, or single-family residence being occupied as rental property do not display Annual Decals are not City approved trash carts or if City approved prepaid plastic trash bags are not used, in order to prevent the waste in the containers from being scattered upon public or private property, the cCity, at its option, may remove the waste and bill the owner of the multi-family unit, trailer court mobile or manufactured home or single family residence a service fee. In the event the owner of the multi-family unit, trailer court mobile or manufactured home or single-family residence fails to pay the service fee, the cCity may discontinue refuse collection from such multi-family unit, trailer court mobile or manufactured home or single-family residence and the owner(s), operator(s) or residents shall make arrangements with a commercial refuse collector for the collection and disposal of the solid waste generated by such multi-family unit, trailer court mobile or manufactured home, single-family residence. (f) When refuse from commercial establishments exceeds four containers per collection the operator of such business is required to remove and dispose of such excess at the expense of the operator. (g) When refuse from a multi-family property with four or less living units exceeds four containers per collection the owner or managing agent of such property is required to remove and dispose of such excess at their expense and is not eligible for cCity trash collection service. (h) Whenever a person places refuse or other waste material for collection by the cCity without complying with all the provisions of this article, in addition to or in lieu of prosecution of such person for a Class I misdemeanor violation, the cCity may also do one of the following: (1) The cCity may collect the refuse or material notwithstanding the fact that its placement or packaging does not comply with the provisions of this article. In such cases, the cCity shall after reasonable notice discontinue refuse collection service and assess a service/penalty fee(s) against the owner of the property in front of which such waste material was placed. Such service/penalty fee(s) shall be in accordance with the following to resume cCity collection services: (a) A service/penalty fee(s) as determined appropriate by the cCity mManager or his or her his designee. This service fee shall be billed to the owner or manager of the violating property. Fees authorized by this 15 section with which the owner of any such property shall have been assessed and which remains unpaid shall constitute a lien against such property (2) The cCity may choose not to collect the refuse or material after reasonable notice. In such case, the cCity shall affix a notice of violation to the rejected container(s), refuse or material explaining the reason for the rejection. A similar notice may be issued to the property owner of the property in front of which such uncollected refuse or material was placed. The latter notice may be verbal or written and shall be provided as soon as is feasible after the rejection. Where the cCity has not collected refuse or other material from curbside or elsewhere because such refuse or other materials was not placed or prepared in accordance with this article, the persons responsible for such placement shall remove that refuse or other material as soon as practical after the cCity has refused collection, and in any event, by the end of the designated collection day. Failure to meet the requirements in this chapter shall result in a minimum $250 service fee plus any additional costs incurred by the City. Sec. 21.2-27. - Entry on private property. Municipal vehicles and personnel will not enter private property for the purpose of removing solid waste unless a physical limitation service has been previously authorized by the owner/occupant and the Public Works Director or designee. All collections shall be made directly from the premises of the customer and any emptied receptacles or containers shall be returned directly to such premises. Sec. 21.2-28. - Placement for collection. (a) Bundles or approved waste containers containing solid waste which are to be collected by the cCity shall be placed at the edge of the street curb no earlier than 6:00 p.m. of the previous day and not later than 7:00 a.m. on the appropriate collection day. Approved waste containers shall be removed from the streets as soon as possible, but not later than 7:00 p.m. of that same day. (b) Containers for solid waste set out for collection and disposal by the cCity shall be placed so as not to hinder, block, retard or endanger those using the streets, alleys, sidewalks or walkways of the city and so as to be reasonably accessible to the employees of the cCity. (c) In any prosecution charging the failure to display an annual decal on a waste container or use an approved trash cart or prepaid plastic trash bag, proof that a waste container was placed in front of a residence in violation of this chapter with proof that the defendant was at the time of the violation the occupant of the residence shall constitute 16 in evidence a permissible inference that the occupant of the residence was the person who committed the violation. (d) In any prosecution charging the failure to display an annual decal on a waste container or use an approved trash cart or prepaid plastic trash bag, proof that an examination of the waste container in question revealed material that identifies the generator of the solid waste, shall constitute in evidence a permissible inference that the generator of the waste was the person who committed the violation. Sec. 21.2-29. - Collection frequency. (a) Curbside collection of solid waste will be provided by the cCity once each week. Solid waste collection in the Central Business District will be provided two times a week for those businesses not having exterior space for a commercial dumpster. A schedule of days for those collections performed by the cCity will be available at the waste pPublic wWorks Ddepartment, and information with reference thereto will be available to the public upon request. (b) Holidays shall include New Year's Day, Fourth of July, Thanksgiving Day and Christmas Day. One collection per week will be made regardless of holidays — collection dates will be advertised. Sec. 21.2-30. - Collection by other than cCity personnel. No person, other than designated cCity employees, may place solid waste in the cCity collection vehicles. Subject to the conditions and limitations of this chapter and other applicable regulations, the cCity or its agents, shall have the sole right to collect solid waste and refuse from single-family residences within the city limits unless otherwise approved by the cCity. Sec. 21.2-31. – Disposal fees billing, payment, and penalties (a) Disposal fees for City trash collection service will be billed monthly to the party responsible for each eligible water/utility account at a rate determined by City Council during the annual budget process. (b) Accounts will be billed for each City-approved trash cart at the service address and may be subject to penalty fee(s) for nonpayment. Should property become vacant, the disposal fee(s) may be transferred from the previous occupant to the owner. All eligible properties shall be rendered bills or statements for trash service. Such bills or statements shall be combined with sewer and water bills levied pursuant to Chapters 34 and 39 of the City of Lynchburg Code. For properties which do not receive a water or 17 sewer bill a separate bill for trash services will be issued. All payments received shall first be credited to disposal charges, then stormwater charges, then sewer charges, and finally to the water charges. (c b) Refuse collected pursuant to section 21.2-26 of this Code must be contained within (i) an approved prepaid plastic trash bag displaying the official cCity logo, or (ii) an approved City approved trash cart(s) container displaying a valid city decal. Approved prepaid plastic trash bags shall be available for purchase at those locations designated by the cCity mManager or his his or her designee. A list of the currently designated locations for the purchase of approved prepaid plastic trash bags and procedures for obtaining a trash cart will be available for review at the cCity cCollections dDivision, or pPublic wWorks dDepartment during regular business hours, and on the City’s website. Decals will be sold at the collections division windows of city hall during regular business hours and through the mail pursuant to a system approved by the city manager or his designee. (d) (b) Fees for Aapproved prepaid plastic trash bags shall cover offset the cost of the disposal and the cost of the bag and shall be determined by the cCity Mmanager or his his or her designee. (d) (c) Annual Decals Trash Collection Service for once per week pickup for reusable trash carts with a volume of up to 32 gallons shall cost $40.00 be billed a monthly disposal service fee each per trash cart. Annual Decals Trash Collection Service for once per week pickup for reusable trash carts with a volume of 64 gallons shall cost $80.00 each per trash cart. Such decals shall be valid for a 12-month period beginning October 1 through September 30 of each year. The cost for an annual decal will be prorated on a monthly basis by paying the following percentages of the annual decal: Period Percentage of Full Price September 1 — October 31 100% November 1 — November 30 92% December 1 — December 31 84% January 1 — January 31 76% February 1 — February 28 68% March 1 — March 31 60% April 1 — April 30 52% May 1 — May 31 44% June 1 — June 30 36% 18 July 1 — July 31 28% August 1 — August 31 20% Such decals are transferable from one address to another upon the approval of the city manager or his designee. All such decals shall prominently display the year of the decal and street address of the location of the trash container. (e) It shall be the responsibility of the owner to resume all monthly disposal fee(s) assessed for any dwelling(s) that becomes vacant. person purchasing a decal moves outside the city or goes out of business, the purchaser shall be entitled to receive a prorated refund on a monthly basis for that portion of the year the decal will not be used. A request for a refund must be made no later than 30 days after the end of the year for which the decal was issued. Before issuing a refund the director of finance may require satisfactory evidence that a decal for which the refund is sought has been destroyed. For purposes of proration, a period of more than one-half of a month shall be counted as a full month and a period of less than one-half of a month shall not be counted. (f) (d) Approved prepaid plastic trash bags with a volume up to 32 gallons include the costs of disposal of waste material. (e) In certain Downtown Central Business District (CBD) areas designated by the cCity mManager or hishis or her designee for twice per week pickup, Annual Decals for twice per week pickup for reusable trash carts with a volume of up to 32 gallons shall cost $80.00 each. In those same areas, Annual Decals for twice per week pickup for reusable trash carts with a volume of 64 gallons shall cost $160.00. Tthe monthly disposal fee(s) shall be double per water/utility account. The CBD refuse collection designation may vary from other definitions of the CBD used by the City for other purposes. Such decals shall be valid for a 12-month period beginning October 1 through September 30 of each year. The cost for an annual decal will be prorated on a monthly basis by paying the following percentages of the annual decal: Period Percentage of Full Price September 1 — October 31 100% November 1 — November 30 92% December 1 — December 31 84% January 1 — January 31 76% February 1 — February 28 68% 19 March 1 — March 31 60% April 1 — April 30 52% May 1 — May 31 44% June 1 — June 30 36% July 1 — July 31 28% August 1 — August 31 20% In the event the person purchasing a decal moves outside the city or goes out of business, the purchaser shall be entitled to receive a prorated refund on a monthly basis for that portion of the year the decal will not be used. A request for a refund must be made no later than 30 days after the end of the year for which the decal was issued. Before issuing a refund the director of finance may require satisfactory evidence that a decal for which the refund is sought has been destroyed. For purposes of proration, a period of more than one-half of a month shall be counted as a full month and a period of less than one-half of a month shall not be counted. Such decals are transferable from one address to another upon the approval of the city manager or his designee. All such decals shall prominently display the year of the decal and street address of the location of the trash container. (f)The owner or operator of any location designated to sell approved prepaid plastic trash bags shall be compensated for accounting and remitting the fee levied for the purchase of the approved prepaid plastic trash bags. Such compensation shall be a deduction of three percent of the amount of the fee from the sale of such approved prepaid plastic trash bags. The deduction shall be accounted for in the accounting report submitted to the cCity with the fees from the sale of the approved prepaid plastic trash bags provided that the amount due is not delinquent at the time of payment. The cCity mManager or his his or her designee shall establish criteria for the designation of locations and the accounting and payment procedures by the owners and operators of the designated locations. The fees collected from the sale of approved prepaid plastic trash bags are public funds and shall be held in trust for the cCity by the person collecting the same. It shall be a criminal offense for the person holding such fees to use them for any purpose whatsoever. (h) (g) Beginning October 1, 2012, the city manager or his designee shall have the authority to issue 64-gallon Annual Decals Trash Collection Service at no cost to disadvantaged citizens or families and to elderly or permanently and totally disabled citizens who qualify for the tax relief, who own and occupy an existing dwelling as of July 1, 2012, pursuant to section 36-175 of the City Code upon criteria to be developed by the city manager or his designee. Disadvantaged citizens or families and elderly or permanently and totally disabled citizens who live in multi-family dwellings and trailer 20 courts that do utilize the city's refuse collection services shall not be entitled to a free annual decal. (h)(g) Except as allowed in this chapter, no refunds in whole or in part shall be allowed for approved prepaid plastic trash bags which are unused, lost, destroyed or stolen. Except as allowed in this chapter, no refuse disposal fees shall be discounted, waived, refunded, or suspended. (ih) In the event any annual decal issued under this chapter shall be lost, stolen or destroyed, the person to whom the decal was issued may make application to the collections division or public works department and obtain a duplicate decal upon furnishing information of such fact, by affidavit or other evidence that is satisfactory to the director of finance/director of human services. Any person providing false or intentionally misleading information to the collections division/social services division City under this section shall may be found guilty of a class 3 4 misdemeanor, charged a penalty fee(s) as determined by the City Manager or his or her designee and/or have Solid Waste Services revoked. . and the collections division/social services division shall revoke any duplicate decal issued as a result of such false or intentionally misleading information. (i) The cCity mManager or his his or her designee shall have the authority to provide for refuse collection and disposal on a limited basis at no cost for cCity sponsored specific community clean-up or litter reduction efforts. The cCity mManager or his his or her designee shall use color-coded plastic bags or approved containers, or other special arrangements which are necessary or appropriate for the administration of such cleanup or litter reduction efforts. (j) The cCity mManager or his his or her designee shall have the authority to adjust or suspend fees due to natural disasters such as fires, floods and severe storms pursuant to criteria to be developed by the cCity mManager or his his or her designee. Sec. 21.2-32. - Administration, prohibition. (a) The cCity mManager or his his or her designee shall be responsible for overseeing and employing reasonable discretion in the design, implementation and administration of the variable fee-based disposal system. Any interpretation of sections 21.2-26 through 21.2-32 shall be the responsibility of the cCity mManager or his his or her designee. (b) The cCity mManager or his his or her designee shall have the authority to designate one or more persons to perform all or part of his his or her duties and exercise his his or her rights granted under this chapter. (c) It shall be unlawful for any person to steal, copy, or counterfeit an approved prepaid plastic trash bag or trash cart or to steal, copy, counterfeit, alter, or deface any official decal issued pursuant to section 21.2-31 of this chapter. 21 (d) The dDirector of pPublic wWorks, with the approval of the cCity mMCanager or his or her designee, shall have the authority to adopt an appeals process for customers who believe the provisions of this chapter have been applied in error. All appeals shall be in accordance with the process adopted by the dDirector of pPublic wWorks. A copy of the appeals process shall be kept in office of the dDirector of the department of pPublic wWorks and in the cCity mManager's office, and shall be available for review upon request. ARTICLE IV. - SOLID WASTE COLLECTION— COMMERCIAL COLLECTION Sec. 21.2-36. - Authority to make or revise regulations. The cCity mManager or his his or her designee shall have the authority to make or revise such regulations concerning commercial collection and disposal as deemed necessary; provided, that such regulations shall not be contrary to the provisions of this chapter. Sec. 21.2-37. - License required. No person shall engage in the business of collecting, transporting or disposal of solid waste without a business license for said business which is to be obtained from the appropriate cCity office. Sec. 21.2-38. - Compliance with code. The commercial collector shall conform to the applicable provisions of this Code and other ordinances of the cCity, as well as all other applicable regulations and policies. Sec. 21.2-39. - Placement for collection. (a) All solid waste collections made by commercial collectors shall be made directly from the premises of the owner, and any empty containers shall be returned directly to said premises. (b) No person shall place any commercial container on public property or in public right- of-way without written permission of the cCity mManager or his his or her designee, nor shall any person place such container on private property in such a way that collection of solid waste will obstruct or impede pedestrian or vehicular traffic or otherwise create a safety hazard for traffic. (c) It shall be the responsibility of the property owner to ensure all commercial containers and the immediate area around them shall be kept clean and sanitary at all times. Solid 22 waste shall be completely contained within such container, and all doors of the unit shall be kept closed. Containers shall conform to all state and federal regulations regarding storm water run-off. Sec. 21.2-40. - Container requirements. All solid waste containers to be collected by commercial collector shall conform to the specifications therefor established by this chapter. Sec. 21.2-41. - Vehicle regulations. (a) All vehicles used in the collection of solid waste shall be kept and maintained in a clean and sanitary condition, and shall be so constructed and maintained as to prevent spillage of the solid waste to be collected therein. (b) All vehicles transporting solid waste shall be watertight and completely enclosed. (c) All vehicles two tons gross in weight (G.P.W.) or more to be used to dispose of solid waste at the RSA facility shall be equipped with suitable hoisting or ejection equipment. (d) All vehicles to be used to dispose of solid waste at the RSA facility shall be rated with their volume capacity. (e) No vehicle used in the collection of solid waste shall be parked on a city street overnight. (f) No vehicle shall be parked in violation of the City Code relating to parking of trucks and commercial vehicles in a residential district. (g) All vehicles shall transport solid waste in such a manner as not to create a nuisance or adversely affect public health, nor create any unnecessary noise. (h) All vehicles used in the collection of solid waste shall meet all federal and state safety requirements for commercial vehicles. ARTICLE V. - MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS Sec. 21.2-46. - Dumping regulations. (a) It shall be unlawful for any person to dispose of solid waste upon the premises or in the container of another or in any public place or on any public road, street or highway, in any manner, except in approved waste containers provided for such purposes other than in a manner provided by this Code. 23 (b) When a violation of the provisions of this section has been observed by any person, or if the solid waste is dumped or disposed of in the highway, right-of-way, street, road, property adjacent to public way, or private property, and examination of the solid waste reveals material that identifies the generator of the solid waste, the generator shall be presumed to be the person dumping such solid waste; provided, however, that such presumption shall be rebuttable by competent evidence. Sec. 21.2-47. - Penalty for violation of this chapter. Except as provided in sections 21.2-26 and 21.2-51, violations of any provision of this chapter shall be punishable as follows: a class 4 misdemeanor punishable by a fine of $250 plus the cost incurred by the City in remedying non-compliance (a) For a first offense within one year, a class 3 misdemeanor. (b) For a second offense within one year, a class 2 misdemeanor. (c) For a third and all subsequent offenses within one year, a class 1 misdemeanor. (d) In addition to the penalties provided in this section, any person who unlawfully dumps trash, garbage or litter on public or private property may have his or her driving privileges suspended and may be ordered to perform community service as provided in Section 33.1-346 of the Code of Virginia. Sec. 21.2-47.1. - Payment of service fees. For failure to display an official annual decal on a waste container or for Ffailure to use an approved prepaid plastic trash bag(s), City-approved trash cart(s), or for failure to pay disposal fee(s), the person in violation shall may be assessed a penalty/service fee established by the cCity mManager or his or her designee. Sec. 21.2-48. - Solid waste generated outside the city. It shall be unlawful for any person or business to bring into the city any solid waste accumulated outside the city and deposit the same at a RSA facility or at any other place within the city, unless approved by the cCity mManager or his his or her designee. Sec. 21.2-49. - Placing or removing solid waste in or from public containers, or bins or containers for recyclable materials. 24 (a) It shall be unlawful for any person to dispose of any solid waste that is generated from ordinary conduct of a household, place of business, industrial establishment, or is prohibited from disposal at a RSA facility pursuant to section 21.2-59(b), in or around any public container(s)/dumpster(s) placed to prevent litter on public right-of-ways and City properties (b) It shall be unlawful for any person to deposit any unauthorized solid waste into or around recycling bins or containers which are part of a cCity recycling program, whether publicly or privately administered, except for such specific recyclable materials for which such bins or containers are designated. (c) It shall be unlawful for any person to remove any recyclable materials from a recycling bin or container that is part of a cCity recycling program, once the recyclable materials have been placed in or around the recycling bin or container. Sec. 21.2-50. - Repeated vViolations of this chapter. Any person who violates this chapter, two or more times during a one-year period may be prohibited from future use of any recycling and RSA facility by the cCity mManager or his his or her designee and may be charged service fee(s)/penalty as determined by the City Manager or his or her designee. Upon request, a hearing shall be held before a designated officer of the cCity on such prohibition. The hearing shall be an informal administrative proceeding other than a judicial-type of proceeding and the rules of evidence shall not apply. The decision of the designated officer shall be final and not subject to appeal. Sec. 21.2-51. - Illegal possession or usage of approved prepaid plastic trash bags. (a) It shall be unlawful for any person to possess, sell or use an approved prepaid plastic trash bag or annual decal that the person did not purchase at face value, receive from a person who purchased the approved prepaid plastic trash bag or annual decal at face value or receive from an authorized cCity agency. (b) It shall be unlawful for the owner or the operator of any business, other than a business that has been properly designated to sell approved prepaid plastic trash bags or Annual Decals as provided in section 21-2.31 of this chapter, to possess approved prepaid plastic trash bags or Annual Decals or to sell approved prepaid plastic trash bags or Annual Decals to any person. (c) It shall be unlawful for the owner or operator of any business that has been properly designated to sell approved prepaid plastic trash bags or Annual Decals as provided in section 21.2-31 of this chapter, to possess or to sell any approved prepaid plastic trash bag or annual decal that was not issued to the business by the cCity. 25 (d) Any person violating any of the provisions of this section shall be guilty of a class 1 4 misdemeanor. Each incident of possession, sale or use of an approved prepaid plastic trash bag(s) in violation of this section shall constitute a separate offense and shall be punishable as a class 1 4 misdemeanor. Sec. 21.2-52. - Removal of personal property from right-of-way. When personal property is removed from any leased or rented commercial or residential premises pursuant to an action of unlawful detainer or ejectment, or pursuant to any other action in which personal property is removed from the premises in order to restore such premises to the person entitled thereto, and the personal property is placed in the public right-of-way the tenant shall have the right to remove his his or her personal property from the public right-of- way during the 24-hour period after eviction. Upon the expiration of the 24-hour period after eviction, the landlord of the leased or rented commercial or residential premises shall remove, or dispose of, any such personal property remaining in the public right-of-way. If the landlord fails to remove the remaining personal property from the public right of way within a 48-hour period, the cCity shall remove the personal property and the costs or expenses incurred by the cCity in removing the personal property shall be chargeable to and paid by the landlord. The personal property must meet all requirements outlined in this ordinance. The charges authorized by this section which are charged to the landlord and which remain unpaid shall constitute a lien against the property from which the personal property was removed, ranking on a parity with liens for unpaid taxes and may be collected by the cCity in the same manner in which delinquent taxes are collected. ARTICLE VI. - SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL—REGION 2000 SERVICES AUTHORITY PROVISIONS Sec. 21.2-56. - Administration. The RSA board of directors is authorized to adopt appropriate rules and regulations and to establish policies to administer the operation of RSA facilities. Any rules or regulations adopted or policies established pursuant to this section shall be consistent with the provisions of this chapter. A violation of any rules or regulations adopted pursuant to this chapter shall constitute a violation of this chapter. Sec. 21.2-57. - Operating procedures. The RSA director may adopt rules and regulations and establish policies for the operating procedures of any RSA facility. Such facility shall be regulated by the RSA director in accordance with such operating procedures and with any rules and regulations adopted and policies established by the RSA board of directors for the administration of the operation of the facility. Any rules or regulations adopted or policies established pursuant to this section shall be 26 consistent with the provisions of this chapter. A violation of any rules or regulations adopted pursuant to this section shall constitute a violation of this chapter. Sec. 21.2-58. - Region 2000 Services Authority facility. (a) Solid waste which is generated within the city may be deposited at a RSA facility. Upon the request of a RSA facility attendant, any person delivering solid waste for disposal at a RSA facility shall provide verification to such employee that the solid waste proposed for disposal was generated in the city. (b) No scavenging or salvaging at a RSA facility shall be permitted except as may be contracted by the RSA. No person, except as specifically authorized by the RSA, shall dispose of any solid waste in a RSA facility, except during the hours of operation as established by the RSA and posted at the entrance to the facility. (c) City residents are allowed an unlimited number of free trips up to 500 pounds to the RSA facility per calendar month from the house in which they reside. Residents must show proof of their Lynchburg address to the RSA facility attendant each time they come to the RSA facility. If a resident's driver's license (or I.D. card) does not show their correct and current address, they must also bring a current utility bill showing their address of the origin of the load. If a resident has someone else bring in a load for them, they must give the hauler either a driver's license or a current utility bill from their address. In addition, the hauler must show their driver's license. If a resident's free trip goes over 500 pounds and/or if the resident makes other trips to the RSA facility during the calendar month after utilizing their free trip, the resident must pay by cash or check at the posted tipping fee. As of July 1, 2012 residents are allowed an unlimited number of free trips of segregated brush and bulk materials. These trips do not count towards a resident's free monthly trip to the RSA facility. Any mixed loads of brush, bulk and trash will count towards the resident's one free trip per month. The Concord Turnpike convenience center will not accept trailers or dump body vehicles. Pick-up trucks, passenger cars and SUVs are approved vehicles to dispose of brush & bulk. Tires are not included as part of a resident's free trip. There is a surcharge for disposal of tires. Tire disposal rates are posted at the RSA facility. Rental property is considered a business. Landlords, who do not have a charge account with the RSA facility, must pay by cash or check at the posted tipping fee rate when bringing a load from property they own but do not reside in. If a business, church (or other charitable organization) does not have a charge account with the RSA facility, they must also pay by cash or check at the posted tipping fee rate. Household hazardous waste collection is a service for Lynchburg residents only, businesses are excluded. Household hazardous waste collection days are announced yearly. City residents 27 must show a picture identification for proof of their Lynchburg address. Following are examples of what residents can bring to the RSA facility on the household hazardous waste collection day: acids/bases, aerosols, antifreeze, autostarter, brake fluids, batteries, cleaners/polishes, corrosives, drain openers, flammables, furniture stripper, herbicides, kerosene, lighter fluids, oven cleaners, oxidizers, oil based paints, pesticides, photo/pool chemicals, poisons, solvents/thinners, used motor oil, weed killers and wood preservatives. For more information, guidelines and restrictions are posted on the RSA website. Sec. 21.2-59. - Substance regulations. (a) Generally. No solid waste of any sort shall be removed from private premises and deposited for disposal within the city at any location other than those approved by the cCity mManager or his his or her designee provided that the materials approved for disposal are consistent with the federal and state regulations for the disposal of such solid waste and this chapter. (b) Prohibited solid waste. Solid waste prohibited from disposal in the RSA's facilities are as follows: (1) Free liquids. a. Bulk or non-containerized liquid waste unless the waste is leachate or gas condensate derived from the RSA facility itself and the facility is designed with a composite liner and leachate collection system as described in sections 5.1.B.9. and 5.5.B. of the Virginia Solid Waste Management Regulations (VR 672-20-10), or b. Containers holding liquid waste, unless: 1. The container is a small container similar in size and total quantity to that normally found in household waste; 2. The container is designed to hold liquids for use other than for storage; or (2) Regulated hazardous wastes. (3) Solid waste, residue or soil containing dioxins as regulated within the Virginia Solid Waste Management Regulations (VR 672-20-20), and as prohibited by rules or regulations adopted or policies established by the RSA. (4) Solid waste, residue or soil containing polychlorinated biphenylsbiphyenols (PCBs) as regulated within the Virginia Solid Waste Management Regulations (VR 672-20-10), and as prohibited by rules or regulations adopted or policies established by the RSA. 28 (5) Unstabilized sewage sludge or sludges and combustion residue (ash) as regulated within the Virginia Solid Waste Management Regulations (VR 672-20- 10), and as prohibited by rules or regulations adopted or policies established by the RSA. (6) Pesticide containers that have not been triple rinsed and crushed. (7) Drums and barrels that are not empty, properly cleaned and opened with both ends cut out. (8) Waste oil, with the exception being used motor oil accepted from Lynchburg residents on household hazardous waste collection days. (9) Contaminated soil as regulated within the Virginia Solid Waste Management Regulations (VR 672-20-10), and as prohibited by rules or regulations adopted or policies established by the RSA. (10) Asbestos containing material as prohibited by rules or regulations adopted or policies established by the RSA. (11) Regulated infectious wastes. (12) Large animal carcasses. (13) Any solid waste otherwise prohibited under this chapter or by rules or regulations adopted or policies established by the RSA. (c) Permitted solid waste. Solid waste not listed in subsection 21.2-59(b) may be accepted for disposal at a RSA facility. Such solid waste that generally will be accepted, subject to RSA facility operating procedures, for disposal in a RSA facility includes, but is not necessarily limited to, the following: (1) Garbage. (2) Household waste. (3) Inert waste. (4) Refuse. (5) Rubbish. (6) Debris and yard waste. (7) White goods. (8) Wood, debris and yard waste. Any wood, debris and yard waste delivered to a RSA facility for disposal shall be separated from other solid waste being delivered to the facility. 29 (d) Any person who delivers to a RSA facility any solid waste prohibited from disposal in the facility under subsection 21.2-59(b), shall promptly upon notification from the RSA remove such prohibited wastes from the facility. Failure to remove such prohibited waste constitutes a violation of this chapter. The RSA may choose to sample, test, store, transport and haul any such prohibited waste for appropriate disposal and charge the person delivering said waste for all incurred cCity and contractual costs. (e) Any person who delivers to a RSA facility any non-household waste, either entirely or in part, must participate in an inspection of that delivered waste upon request by authorized employees and according to solid waste management facility procedures. Sec. 21.2-60. - Region 2000 Services Authority (RSA) facility fees. (a) Fees for solid waste delivered to a RSA facility shall be periodically reviewed and determined by the RSA board of directors as specified and posted at the RSA facility. (b) Payments will be collected at the RSA facility. 2. That this ordinance shall become effective upon its adoption. Adopted: Certified: ________________________________ Clerk of Council May 12, 2020 Balancing the FY 2021 General Fund Budget $200,513,026 1 Updated Revenue Projection following April 1 st  review including COVID‐19 residual effects ($6,446,138) 2 Use of Reserve Committed/Assigned Fund Balance Projection for COVID‐19 residual effects $380,043 ($6,066,095) $194,446,931 $200,513,026 1 Expenditure Reduction Projection following April 1 st  review including COVID‐19 residual effects ($6,066,095) 2 Projected General Fund Fuel Savings ($95,000) ($6,161,095) $194,351,931 $95,000 Striked‐out ‐ Adjustments have been used to rebalance as noted above. The "LIST" ‐ Budget Adjustments for Council Discussion: Proposed Budget Budget Adjustmen ts to Discuss Council Decision 1 Non‐Departmental 2,015,952 3% General Wage Increase  (Helgeson)  Note:  Council to reconsider in January 2021 0 1 Non‐Departmental 946,481 Phase II Salary Study Implementation  (Helgeson)  Note:  Council to reconsider in January 2021 0 2 Council/Manager Offices 30,142 Increase in City Councilmember salaries from $10,000 to  $14,000 and from $12,000 to $16,000 for the Mayor based on  Council action on December 10, 2019 (salary + benefits)   (Nelson) 0 3 Non‐Departmental 50,000 Health Benefits Education and Advocacy  (Helgeson) 0 4 Economic Development and  Tourism 75,000 Reallocated funds for implementing the Downtown 2040 plan  due to no longer making payments to the Academy Center of  the Arts  (Perrow) Note:  Council to reconsider in January 2021 0 5 Parks and Recreation 37,148 During Staff Rebalancing ‐ reduced  to start 10/01/2020 Two (2) new part‐time positions starting 10/01/2020, a Senior  Recreation Specialist and a Recreation Aide, to reopen College  Hill Recreation Center ($34,91146,548  ‐ salary + benefits),  internet service ($7951,060), and supplies ($1,4421,923)   (Helgeson) 0 6 Non‐Departmental 50,000 During Staff Rebalancing ‐ reduced by $ 75,000 $50,000125,000 Safety and Security Task Force  (Helgeson) (50,000) 7 Council/Manager Offices $93,789 Chief Talent Development Office r full‐time position transferred  to the Council/Manager Offices from Human Resources (salary  + benefits)  (Helgeson) 0 8 Council/Manager Offices 68,074 Youth Futures Coordinator full‐t ime position transferred to the  Council/Manager Office from Human Services ‐ Juvenile  Services (salary + benefits)  (Helgeson) 0 9 Human Resources  0 NeoGov Onboarding software  (Wright) ‐ $12,000 10 Human Resources  0 NeoGov iLearn access for 200 part‐time employees  (Wright) ‐  $6,500 11 Registrar 0 Voting Booths ($600), Early Voting line management  supplies  ($120), off‐duty officer ($360)  (Wright) ‐ $1,080 Funded in FY 2020 with Manager's  Discrectionary funding Subtotal Staff Adjustments to Expenditures, Reserves, and Transfers:  Total Revised Expenditures, Reserves, and Transfers Preliminary Balance after Staff Adjustments Total Revised Revenues and Use of Fund Balance Proposed FY 2021 Expenditures, Reserves, and Transfers Staff Adjustments to Expenditures, Reserves, and Transfers:  Proposed FY 2021 Revenues and Use of Fund Balance Staff Adjustments to Revenues and Use of Fund Balance:  Subtotal Staff Adjustments to Revenues and Use of Fund Balance:  Page 1 of 3 May 12, 2020 The "LIST" ‐ Budget Adjustments for Council Discussion (continued) : Proposed Budget Budget Adjustmen ts to Discuss Council Decision 12 Registrar 0 Two laptops   (Perrow) ‐ $1,563 Funded in FY 2020 with Manager's  Discrectionary funding 13 Office of the Commonwealth's  Attorney 0 In‐House Investigator full‐time position (salary + benefits)   (Nelson) ‐ $48,228 14 Office of the Commonwealth's  Attorney 0 Legal Support Receptionist position change from part‐time to  full‐time (salary + benefits)  (Nelson) ‐ $15,881 15 Police 0 5 Sworn Officers and 3 Vehicles  (Wilder) ‐ $523,000                      The total cost includes salary/benefits ($285,805) and  uniforms/equipment ($38,935) for 5 officers.  It also includes  the cost of 3 fully outfitted police vehicles ($198,000). 16 Police 0 Recruitment Advertising  (Perrow) ‐ $4,800 17 Police 0 GrayKey software  (Perrow) ‐ $18,075 18 Police 0 Quantum Tape Library Back up  (Perrow) ‐ $11,685 19 Fire ‐ Option A 9 full‐time Firefighters Fund 07/01/2020 ‐ $489,623 (Academy > January 2021 Start) 9 full‐time Firefighters (salary + benefits)  (Wilder) ‐  ($529,623 ‐  $40,000 overtime annualized savings FY 2021) (FY 2022 Impact $449,623+ ($529,623‐$80,000) 19 Fire ‐  **NEW** Option B  9 full‐time Firefighters Fund 10/01/2020 ‐ $377,217 (Academy > March 2021 Start) 9 full‐time Firefighters (salary + benefits)  (Wilder) ‐  ($397,217 ‐ $20,000 overtime annualized savings FY 2021) (FY 2022 Impact $449,623+ ($529,623‐$80,000) 19 Fire ‐ Option C 9 full‐time Firefighters Fund 01/01/2021 ‐ $258,145 (Academy > June 2021 Start) 9 full‐time Firefighters (salary + benefits)  (Wilder) ‐  ($264,812 ‐ $6,667 overtime annualized savings FY 2021) (FY 2022 Impact $449,623+ ($529,623‐$80,000) 19 Fire ‐ Option D 6 full‐time Firefighters Fund 07/01/2020 ‐ $353,082 (Academy > January 2021 Start) 6 full‐time Firefighters (salary + benefits)  (Wilder) ‐ $353,082  (No overtime savings) (FY 2022 Impact $353,082+) 19 Fire ‐ Option E 6 full‐time Firefighters Fund 10/01/2020 ‐ $264,812  (Academy > March 2021 Start) 6 full‐time Firefighters (salary + benefits)  (Wilder) ‐ $264,812  (No overtime savings) (FY 2022 Impact $353,082+) 20 Option A Original Staff Recommendation Public Works ‐ Refuse REVENUE Refuse fee revenue  (Perrow) $15.02/month  on utility bill Begin January 1, 2021; fee good for 18 months FY 2021 Financial Impact $0 Cons ‐ increase in fee 20 Option B Revised Staff Recommendation Public Works ‐ Refuse REVENUE Refuse fee revenue  (Perrow) $10.00  $9.17 /month  on utility bill Begin October 1, 2020 ;  will require additional fee increase in FY 2022 FY 2021 Financial Impact creates a  $0   $140,415  deficit Cons ‐ Does not allow for an appropriate inventory 0 20 Option C Status Quo ‐ Annual Decals Public Works ‐ Refuse REVENUE Refuse fee revenue  (Perrow) $55 or $110/year Decals must be purchased by September 30, 2020;  would require additional fee increase in FY 2022 FY 2021 Financial Impact creates a $262,644 deficit Cons ‐ No progress on improving Refuse situation 262,644  0  Page 2 of 3 May 12, 2020 The "LIST" ‐ Budget Adjustments for Council Discussion (continued) : Proposed Budget Budget Adjustmen ts to Discuss Council Decision 21 Option 1 Public Works ‐ Refuse Brush/Bulk Enforcement full‐time position ($48,540) (salary +  benefits) and uniforms ($1,200)  (Perrow) 21 Option 2 Public Works ‐ Refuse Begin 10/01/2020 (FY 2021 savings of $12,435) Brush/Bulk Enforcement full‐time position ($36,405$48,540)  (salary + benefits) and uniforms ($9001,200)  (Perrow) (12,435) 22 Parks and Recreation 6,000 Increase in Miller Pool staff pay ( May 2021) to help attract and  retain staff (salary + benefits)  (Helgeson)  23 Parks and Recreation 4,600 Annual  maintenance contract for RecPro software for program  registration, fees, etc. (Helgeson) 24 Parks and Recreation 1,000 Increased chemical costs (May 2021)  for Miller Park Pool   (Helgeson) 25 Parks and Recreation 50,000 Furniture and kitchen equipment fo r Fairview and Yoder  Recreation Centers  (Helgeson)   Funded with Pay‐As‐You‐Go 26 Parks and Recreation 3,900 Rentals of portable toilets in the  park and trail system   (Helgeson) 27 Community Development 88,194 would need to  remove the  offsetting revenue  as well One (1) new full‐time Environmental Compliance Inspector  position in the Zoning and Natural Resources Division  ($61,594 salary + benefits).  Additional costs associated with  the new position a computer, software, phone, and training  ($3,600) and a vehicle ($23,000).  The cost is 100% funded  through the Stormwater Fund.  (Helgeson) 28 Community Development 7,000 Estimated costs of hiring a monito ring service to implement  the Short‐Term Rental Registration program  (Helgeson) 29 Economic Development and  Tourism 250,000 Transfer to the Economic Development Authority (EDA) of the  City of Lynchburg providing funds for implementation of  business development, expansion and retention.  Prior to FY  2021 these funds were budgeted in the Capital Improvement  Program but are better suited in the operating budget per  Finance staff.  (Perrow) 30 External Service Providers 12,167 Virginia Legal Aid Society   (Helgeson) 31 Non‐Departmental 0  Poverty Initiative  (Wright) 32 Schools Operating 39,828,498 School Funding reduced $2.2m from  Schools FY 2021 Request $42,028,498 Schools Request  $40,528,498 Manager's Proposed ($1.5m reduction ‐ down 3.6%) $39,828,498 Manager's Proposed Revised ($700k reduction due to  COVID‐19 for 10.9% share of the $6,446,138 City COVID‐19 revenue loss) 33 External Service Providers 40,685 Virginia Cooperative Extensi on Service $44,075 Submitted Request ‐ Manager's Proposed Budget kept  funding flat with Adopted FY 2020  $2,000 for Office Support Services (Wright) $1,390  for potential staff raises in 2020 (salary + benefits) $3,390 not proposed for funding in FY 2021 Proposed  34 Council/Manager Offices 72,852 Training and Conferences ($43,3 51)  (Helgeson)      Clerk of Council ($5,300)      City Council ($15,201)      City Manager/Deputy City Manager/Assistant City Manager ($ 22,850) Dues and Memberships ($29,501)      Clerk of Council ($675)      City Council ($22,901)      City Manager/Deputy City Manager/Assistant City Manager ($ 5,925) Total Balancing: ($62,435) $157,435Balance after Council Decisions 49,740  Page 3 of 3 April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 14th day of April, 2020, at 4:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Treney Tweedy, President, presiding. The following members were present: Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Sterling A. Wilder, Beau Wright, Treney Tweedy 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Ms. Bonnie Svrcek remarked that Council has been provided with answers to its questions from the April 7th meeting. Mayor Tweedy asked if she received the amount of overtime spent on the Fire Department. She mentioned that she might have sent the request by email. Ms. Svrcek said she would get that information to Council. Dr. Crystal Edwards, the Superintendent of Lynchburg City Schools (LCS) came forward to present its budget. She thanked her staff and everyone who has helped since things changed dramatically on March 13, 2020. She acknowledged she works with amazing people and you get the measure of people when a crisis happens. The entire staff stepped up and is continuing to provide for the students. She has provided them with the pre-COVID-19 budget, although it does have some adjustments in it. She said that things change daily and they will not have the final numbers until the governor’s budget goes to the General Assembly on April 22. At this point, she has made some guesstimates based on what she thinks might happen not what is factual. She has provided them with their state and federal revenues, as well as their request for flat funding from the City. She has provided them with their pre-COVID expenditures for FY2021 and the highlights from the General Assembly from March. She commented that she had received some questions from Councilmembers and has provided answers in her summary. It includes all the priorities, such as raises built into the governor’s budget and any local match for non SOQ funded positions. Councilmember Wright asked to what the loss of $645,000 in federal funds is attributed. Ms. Laconish from LCS explained that $600,000 of it is for non-center based tuition. Some of the students are not based on site with Laurel and are still in their base schools. With the old model, in order for them to go through as a special education student, they would be billed through Laurel. LCS would bill the cost of the instructor to Laurel and then Laurel would bill LCS. It was sort of a wash through. You will see a reduction in the revenue as well as a reduction in the expenditure because the state has completely revamped the special education model. Councilmember Wright asked if it is a “pass through” that is no longer on the books and she indicated yes. Dr. Edwards explained that the General Assembly put forth a 2 percent salary increase for SOQ funded positions. In order for LCS to accept any funds associated with it, they have to have the local match for the non - SOQ positions. The amount for the local match is included in the flat funding request. The budget proposed a new position for a counselor at R S Payne, but they will have to wait and see what happens with state funding. This applies to teachers and aides for two additional pre-K classes at Perrymont Elementary. These requests did not require any additional funding from the City. She mentioned that the budget includes a living wage increase to the minimum wage to $11.28 an hour. It did not include all the substitute positions though and the flat funding request would allow them to look at also increasing those to $11.28 an hour. April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 2 Dr. Edwards outlined some of the goals she would like to achieve with the flat funding request. One is to provide additional special education support at the alternative programs. They heard from staff and the community that there was a need to do that. Another goal is supporting field trips at all the schools. She mentioned some highlighted goals that they will go back and reevaluate once they receive their final revenue numbers. There are a lot of student centered goals in those highlighted. She outlined all the positions she hopes to be able to fill with the flat funding requests and state funds. With the flat funding request, they will also be able to make some salary adjustments and start a tuition reimbursement program. On hold is demographic and enrollment software. She mentioned that they also figured out a way to make the bus driver positions eight hour positions. It is very hard to hire enough bus drivers and they hope this will make the positions more attractive. She highlighted her answers to Councilmember Helgeson’s questions that are contained in her summary and covered the decreased expenses they are seeing from the school closure. Mayor Tweedy asked if she knew how schools will reopen in the fall, especially in light of how education is being delivered very differently currently. Dr. Edwards does not know when they will go back to brick and mortar learning but they are doing continuity of learning. They have online services and are also delivering paper copies to families that do not have internet. The teachers have been doing a lot of exciting learning tools and have been reaching out to families to make sure they are well served. All the teachers are working collaboratively within a grade instead of having separate elementary, middle and high schools. They know form the tracking that the IT department is doing that they have hits from all over the world accessing its curriculum. Councilmember Wilder thanked her and her staff for the great work they are doing, especially with feeding the children. Councilmember Perrow thanked her as well. He thought it was very well handled and thanked her the updates she has been sending. He thinks the way they have handled everything is a real “feather” in her whole team’s cap. He commended her on the reorganization of the teachers and schools. That is really adaptive thinking and makes a lot of sense. Councilmember Perrow asked her if they have a sense of how many students are connecting. She said she has a meeting with the Family Connect team on Friday and will have a better sense of how many are accessing the materials. They are trying to connect by phone or mail with any student who has not checked in. The anecdotal information she has been receiving from families and students has been very positive. Councilmember Perrow noted that he has been receiving feedback from teachers that it is more like work now. It is very challenging and they are not getting the reward of engaging with the students on a daily and personal basis. Dr. Edwards acknowledged the teachers are missing their students and the students are missing their teachers. The teachers have been trying to reach by Zoom and by phone. Councilmember Perrow asked how they will know where to place children when they are able to return and what classes to enroll them in. Dr. Edwards said they will assess their skill level and will make sure t hey have gap filler lessons. The first part of the year will be to assess them and see what they can do once you can do some face - to-face learning. The teachers are doing everything they can do to make sure the students are ready for the next level. April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 3 Councilmember Perrow asked if there is any talk about extending the school year next year because that could cause them to incur more costs. Dr. Edwards said everything is on the table right now as far as possibilities. Councilmember Helgeson thanked Dr. Edwards for providing him the information he requested. He noted there are 271 less children enrolled than 2019. He acknowledged this year’s budget is slightly down. He realizes she has not been in her position very long and has been working to clean things up. He noted that the state is funding a lot of the instructional positions. He said it looks like our local taxpayers are funding 100 extra instructional positions. She said that is correct. He said he has a problem with the support positions. 1 38 of those positions are funded by the state but there are 313 support positions. He thinks it is getting away from the goal of actually educating the students. He sees more positions that are bureaucratic or administrative positions but does realize it takes lots of things to keep the schools running. He asked her to help him understand the swing. Dr. Edwards said she is trying to find a division that is only SOQ funded. She has studied all the divisions because this is a Virginia thing and she was trying to understand the intent and philosophy? Is it possible for schools to run on SOQ with limited additional funding? She has not found one that fits that model. She sees the police out every day and understands they direct service they do. But there is a dispatcher to answer the phone who might not be a first responder. Schools has a similar situation. The school secretary might be the face you see when you go to school. They are not teaching a child but they provide a valuable service. The schoo l system is like a little mini city. She needs people to fix busses and process payroll and benefits. Councilmember Helgeson said he can appreciate the service but not the magnitude. The non -instructional positions are two and a half times the instructional positions. He noted that it is troubling to him. There are some schools that need an assistant principal but he does not think all of them need one. He noted that the composite index is 33 percent and local taxpayers are funding 41 percent of the school system. The difference would be about $8 million if we gave according to the composite index. The student population has gone down about 6.5 percent since 2010 and staffing has gone up 14 percent. The numbers for police and fire have stayed the s ame and the population they have to serve has gone up. Councilmember Helgeson noted that our revenues are declining from the pandemic and we need to figure out some administrative positions that can be cut. Dr. Edwards said she is seeing a decrease in 32 students for next year and they asked for flat funding. She noted that Councilmember Helgeson said there are a lot of people unemployed. Dr. Edwards said that has a way of manifesting with children and how they perform and what their needs are. Some o f the people that meet those children’s needs provide a service but are not a direct teacher in the classroom. They have people who help the children socially, emotionally and behaviorally. She would ask him to consider what the families and children are going to need from the system to recover from what is occurring right now. She does not know what the children will need but believes they need to be ready. She believes the City and the school system will need to repair and build up whatever could be breaking apart right now in their families. The child might have had internet until their parents lost their jobs or have had to start working from home and the computer is not available to the child until late at night. She mentioned the social workers, psychologists, school nurses and assistant teachers who are all considered support staff. There is a lot more that goes on than just what goes on in the classroom and all these positions have a April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 4 major impact on the children. She would not bring them a “fluff and stuff” budget. She is very transparent and is not trying to overstaff her departments but she will fight hard for the needs of kids. She does want them to suffer as a result of the pandemic and wants them to bounce back and even have more skills such as ingenuity and flexibility and be better than they were before this. Councilmember Helgeson noted they need to sharpen their pencils because of the governor’s orders to close nonessential things. He asked Dr. Edwards if she will be coming back to them with something after it is presented to the school board. Dr. Edwards said that is correct and why you see items that are highlighted. Dr. Edwards does not think the governor closes things that are nonessential. He has to make priorities and she is hearing that things will be suspended. He worked hard to put together a budget pre-COVID and it was very valuable. Value does not go down now because of the pandemic. It may be moved aside or delayed b ut the value of what was in that budget did not change because of COVID-19. Everything in the budget was essential for kids and is still essential. She does not want to call anything nonessential due to COVID-19. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the raises were gone and Dr. Edwards said they are suspended. Councilmember Helgeson said that would free up a lot of local match funds. Dr. Edwards said it could but mentioned that their revenues are also affected by sales tax. They have put in a spending freez e and are trying to do thoughtful planning for the unknown. Councilmember Helgeson noted that is why he brought up administrative positions as opposed to those on the front lines teaching. Hopefully, as those numbers come in, LCS will be able to adapt. Councilmember Nelson applauded Dr. Edwards, her staff and administration—everyone that is working to get the meals and lessons out. It has been a very creative and innovative approach to deal with something they have never seen before. He had seen an idea presented at a March 25, 2020 meeting where they might need to have a summer program to help students that were struggling and they would need a salary reserve for that program. He asked if that program has crystalized any in the last three weeks. She said it has not been crystalized yet. She asked for flexibility for a salary reserve with the stiff parameter that she would let the board know before doing anything. There will likely be more children enrolled in a summer program or they might need to of fer services on the weekends. She would need to pay her staff but it is not something she would ever do without going over it thoroughly with the school board. Councilmember Nelson noted that experts are saying we should not have large gathe rings until maybe next spring, which would apply to schools. He asked if the board or administration is conceptualizing how that would work if schools cannot open in the fall. He heard that public radio and television have offered to provide a median to provide education. That might drastically change the school budget or force it to adapt. It is of concern to him to begin planning for that because it may be a reality and not just a hypothetical. Dr. Edwards said she is always thinking about the “what if” and what the future might hold. She and the Mayor have talked about it in terms of an opportunity for innovation. She commented they might not be able to have a brick and mortar school if they can only have groups of ten in a classroom. They are collaborating with others to share best ideas. She is always thinking forward and staying present working with what we have now. April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 5 Councilmember Perrow noted that he and Councilmember Helgeson have seen the same thing year after year and they struggle with how they can affect it in some way. For every four instructional positions, there are more than three support positions. It is closer to ten instructional positions to eight support positions. That seems to be top heavy or not the right ratio of support to production. He would like to know if there is a consistent ratio among other school systems and how we compare to that ratio. Dr. Edwards said they all differ and you have to consider the demographics. Lynchburg has a very high poverty rate. All of our schools qualify for free and reduced lunches. She also did not want anyone to misunderstand that a support position is not j ust an assistant principal or secretary. Psychologists, social workers, behavioral coaches and nurses are all support positions. She does not want the community to think that support positions are people sitting behind a computer and not doing anything m eaningful for kids because that is definitely not the case. Councilmember Perrow thinks that talking about specific positions is out of their purview. He thinks the ratio should probably be less and he would not presume to deem any positions as less critical. He thinks bringing the ratio down a little bit would certainly help and Dr. Edwards indicated that point was duly noted. Councilmember Wright would like to see what the ratio is in other school systems just as it is helpful to know the per pupil cost. It is his understanding that Lynchburg does not stack up as well against other localities, especially against other cities our size in Virginia. Dr. Edwards said that is correct. Councilmember Wright asked if it is an imperfect proxy for community support. Dr. Edwards indicated it is and you cannot do that in isolation without looking at the communities. She tries not to compare our communities to other communities and say we are doing better because that seems disingenuous. She tries to focus on the needs of our community, particularly those created by the poverty impact. The poverty impact creates challenges and requires more support positions. She looks at all the positions every year and makes the best decisions because she wants to be a good s teward of the taxpayers’ money and do the best for the children. For example, they have had people retire and they have not filled the position because they were able to regroup and retool the duties and do without the position. Councilmember Wright asked for the projected increase is in full-time employees. Dr. Edwards said she does not have that information, especially since she may have to adjust some things. Councilmember Wright would note that the idea that the ratio of support to instructional positions is out of whack would only be accurate if we had accurate support positions to begin with. In other words, we have an evolving need and it might not be that the ratio is off but that the ratio needs tweaking because our students have different needs than they did ten or twenty years ago. Dr. Edwards said that is true and pointed out that sometimes the state mandates something like adding more guidance counselors. That is out of her control. She also reminded them that she is able to add some full time employees and is not asking for any more money from Council in order to do so. Councilmember Wright wished to echo the comments of others and thank her and her staff for the tremendous work they have been putting in over the past month to keep our kids safe and healthy and educated. He wondered if they might see an increase in students because parents might not be able to afford private schools. Dr. Edwards said the online registration for next year is just starting, so she has no indication of that just yet. April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 6 Mayor Tweedy commented that the world as we knew it has been reset from our economic system, our education system and our individual households. She thinks that a lot of people would be comfortable if we went back to kind of the norm. There were things we should have been trying to figure out years ago for the people that had the least or did not have access and all of that and now we are having to figure it out in order to just deliver the basic. This is a reset opportunity. They have been working on the issues that affect poverty for several years such as education, workforce, childcare, food, housing and shelters. We are now in the unknown for every single one of them. We do not know if we have enough child care for even our essential healthcare workers. She has learned that the business industry will find a way to reset itself. If you were working at a service industry and they can find a more efficient way to deliver their service, your services will no longer be needed. Children are in homes with adults that will have to reset as well. Mayor Tweedy would like them all to take a look at a reset on education and the question of poverty, which persons we include in our education and what the delivery looks like. We need to build a system that is more around the social, emotional, educational and financial aspects of what families and students need, which is a total reset from the traditional norm. This has now all been reset for them to do the right thing for people, in her opinion. It may not be a comfortable message for a lot of people. It may mean we become more efficient and things look a lot different. This is an opportunity for discovery and business internships. We could do school year round or create blended options year ro und. Let’s see how people can advance in opportunity and not just how we meet the basic needs of people. If we come with the same questions she has heard for 15 years, then we are missing an opportunity to reset as a City, an education system, a workforc e system and even in some cases, neighborhoods. She hopes someone tells the State that, which is why she is taking the opportunity now to say it. She thanked Dr. Edwards for her presentation. // In the matter of Budget, Dr. Reid Wodicka presented an overview of the FY2021 – 2025 Capital Improvement Program. Councilmember Helgeson asked if it has been reworked. Dr. Wodicka said he doubts there would be huge changes because pay-as-you-go is based on last year’s money and bond funding for the future and that sort of thing. Dr. Wodicka noted that these projects really help define and articulate what we want our City to look like. They greatly affect the quality of life in the City and make commerce happen, so they are very important. He also mentioned that the schools task force is continuing its work and there may be changes as a result of its recommendations, but they are not ready to say what those are just yet because they have not received its recommendations. We have approximately $346 million in the five year budget; $32 million of it is in FY2021. In the General Fund for FY2021, it is approximately $15.1 million. Dr. Wodicka began outlining each project. Councilmember Perrow asked if the $50,000 for the code foundation and foundation drains at the aviary is critical. Mr. Clay Simmons came up to answer the question and Councilmember Perrow asked if any of the projects could be deferred to a later time. Mr. Simmons said they found there were water penetration issues at the aviary when they rebuilt the floors last year. They are really trying to protect the building with this project. In terms of the floors and plumbing fixtures at Fire Station 1, those are really a quality of life question for the firemen. He is sure they will see them as very important. Dr. Wodicka said he April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 7 thinks it is important that they continue to make progress on fire station improvements. We do not want to allow the fire stations to continue to degrade. He also noted that when they were balancing the pay -as-you-go money, they probably dropped about a half a million dollars in necessary projects until next year. Councilmember Perrow said if it is pay-as-you-go money, then never mind. He is looking at debt service cost going forward primarily. Councilmember Nelson asked if staff wanted Council’s input as to what they feel is not essential knowing that staff will go through it and have their own opinion based on the department heads’ input. Dr. Wodicka said they are happy to receive the feedback and they will rework it some but he is not sure how much of it is going to change because how these projects are funded are not necessarily related to the economic issues we have today. Ms. Svrcek stated that certainly would apply to any new debt service, but we have existing debt service. Any comments Council has that could further inform them as they recreate this budget would be helpful. Councilmember Perrow clarified that the pay-as-you-go money is from FY2019 and is one-time money earmarked for capital projects. That makes sense to him to spend it because it is not costing us anything and according to policy, we cannot use it for recurring expenses. Dr. Wodicka said that is correct. With regard to Fifth Street Improvements Phase IV, Councilmember Perrow noted that we will have to borrow money for it. He asked Mr. Newland if the state revenue sharing money been allocated yet. Mr. Newland said part of the money has been allocated and they have applied for another round of revenue sharing tha t should come out this spring. They have heard preliminarily that it has been approved. Once they receive money for a project and transfer it to another project or decide not to use it on that project, they can no longer apply for revenue sharing for that project. Councilmember Perrow asked for clarification that this would be their “one bite of the apple” for this Fifth Street project and Mr. Newland said that is correct. Councilmember Perrow asked why culvert replacement is not paid for with the stormwater fu nd. Mr. Tim Mitchell explained that the stormwater fund includes the pipes and the inlets. The culverts stayed in the general fund because they are more like a bridge than a stormwater conveyance channel. Councilmember Perrow noted that the Florida Avenue sidewalk project started out at $10 million and now appears to be $2.5 million. Dr. Wodicka said it is $6.8 million in total. Mr. Newland said their meeting with the railroad was canceled due to the pandemic and they need to meet with the railroad to d iscuss the trestle. Councilmember Perrow asked for clarification that the $6.8 million is spent over five years and Dr. Wodicka said that is correct. Councilmember Nelson asked if it is still the plan to do the railroad trestle portion of the project fir st before the sidewalk. Mr. Newland said everything is on hold until they can meet with the railroad. They have to see what the railroad will allow them to do to open up the trestle enough to get the sidewalk under it. Mr. Newland clarified for Councilmember Nelson that it is still their intention to make the underpass safer during the first phase rather than a later phase. Councilmember Helgeson noted that there is $4.3 million sitting there appropriated for this project. Dr. Wodicka said that was done because revenue sharing money had to be appropriated. Dr. Wodicka explained that we have not borrowed that yet from the line of credit. If it as pay-as-you-go money, it would be sitting there. This is an appropriation. Councilmember Helgeson asked why there is $500,000 in line of credit money showing then for this year. Mr. Newland said they are spending money on preliminary engineering expenses. Councilmemer Perrow April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 8 asked why there would be an appropriation for this project in FY2021. Dr. Wodicka s aid it is because there are two phases to the project and you have to plan out for future years. Councilmember Perrow asked if previous appropriations are being shown as cash flow projections and Ms. Witt said that is correct. We are appropriating money in FY2023 and spending previously appropriated monies in FY2021 and 2022. He said that makes better sense. Councilmember Wright asked for clarification that the total project is expected to cost $6.8 million instead of the $10 million originally estimated. Mr. Newland said that is correct. Councilmember Wright asked if they should be using this amount when they having conversations with this public because this is still a hot topic. Dr. Wodicka and Mr. Newland both said to use this number in conversations. Councilmember Perrow noted that with good engineering and staff work, they were able to get the cost down to $6.8 million. He noted that is still extraordinarily expensive but less expensive that it was and he appreciates them saving the taxpayer dollars to the extent to which they were able. Dr. Wodicka clarified that $2.8 is local taxpayer money and the rest is revenue sharing money. Mayor Tweedy noted that staff had put the $9.9 million figure in the budget as a preliminary estimate until the engineering and pre-work had been done. She noted that staff had stated that last year during the budget discussion. She thanked staff for getting them to this point. Councilmember Wright noted that the term “a sidewalk to nowhere” is a phrase that is tossed around as a way to denigrate this project. He would like to know how many households will be served by this project and staff said they can get that information. Councilmember Helgeson noted that many cars park on the existing sidewalk on Florida Avenue. Dr. Wodicka pointed out that shows the importance of appropriate street design for the urban setting. Mayor Tweedy noted that Florida Avenue is a heavily traveled corridor on that side of the City, especially in order to get to and from downtown. Councilmember Wilder noted that a major business, KDC, is located and their trucks have to turn around there. There are also a lot of blind spots. Anything they can do to support making this corridor safer will be appreciated by Ward II. Councilmember Nelson commented that this topic is not up for re-debate or reconsideration. To argue the merits of this project one way or the other seems to b e not a good use of their time. Mayor Tweedy asked how the McConville Road and Wyndale Drive realignment project will play into the Forestbrook Road work. Mr. Newland said this project takes McConville Road where it comes out at Lakeside Drive and moves it back away from Forestbrook Road. Both of those intersections are close together and there is not enough room between them for it to operate efficiently. It will move the light rather than adding another light. With regard to the bridge on Timberlake Road, Councilmember Perrow said he feels like they have been forever making repairs to that bridge. Mr. Newland said there are two bridges at Logans Lane and Wards Ferry Road. He said it was hit one year and it was fixed but there were other issues that needed to be addressed. It has been in the fifth year for quite a few years. Councilmember Perrow asked how the Mayor how the traffic is moving through there now with the turn lane finished. She said traffic is moving wonderfully and traffic is not ba cking up onto the expressway. She said sometimes in recent weeks the traffic has been backing up in front of Heritage Elementary School. It is not often, so she thinks it might be related to work being done near the traffic light. April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 9 Mr. Newland said it the next phase will be deck and super structure work. Councilmember Perrow asked if there will be land closures and Mr. Newland said most likely. Construction will be in 2024. With regard to the rest of the projects, Council asked staff to outline the proj ects for this upcoming fiscal year and not all years. With regard to the stadium capital maintenance reserve fund, Councilmember Wright asked if the $25,000 they are to receive from their agreement with Bank of the James will go into this fund or into thei r operating budget. The City Manager said that after year one, it could be used toward the $100,000 they normally put into the reserve fund. The first year the cost sharing goes toward the fabrication and installation of a new sign. Councilmember Perrow asked Mr. Tim Mitchell if the state withholds grant funding for the stormwater projects, if those will be postponed. Mr. Mitchell said they are moving forward and there is still money in the governor’s stormwater grant; but if something changes, they will have to reevaluate. Mr. Mitchell said he does not see any jeopardy with state funding at this time. Ms. Svrcek said that concludes their presentation of the pre-COVID budget and they will now begin making adjustments. She sent them a preview of things they are considering to fund the budget due to loss of revenue sources. Many of them were already on the list. // Ms. Svrcek gave them an update on the City’s actions regarding COVID-19. They have been working with the Continuum of Care to address how we will deal with homeless individuals that may contract the virus and the plan will be finalized later this week. There was also a special edition of the City Source to cover what we are doing and encouraging people to fill out the census. We have an elder reassurance support hotline and is growing calls from our elderly citizens. Councilmember Perrow has had some conversations with business owners. One requested some relief on the fourth quarter installment of real estate taxes. That would create a cash flow problem for the City, so he would suggest a compromise and that Council consider delaying the penalty on the fourth installment until July 1. There would still be interest on a late payment. Small businesses really need some flexibility in cash flow, especially since there is a delay in the small business loans from the government. He asked other Councilmembers to keep their ears to the ground and see if this might be helpful and he would like City staff to figure out how m uch of a risk it would be to the City to defer the penalty on the fourth installment. Ms. Svrcek said this is something they would need Council approval for and they will bring it back to them. With response to what the state and federal governments are doing, Ms. Svrcek said the state is not deferring filing for state taxes. The federal government has extended the filing deadline to July 15 but not deferred interest. Councilmember Perrow said the PPP loan is not eligible to be used for tax payments. Councilmember Wright asked when the EDA plans to make some loans available for COVID support. The Deputy City Manager said he did not have an update but he knows they are working on it. Ms. Svrcek noted they are going to be getting approximately $400,000 in CDBG funds that have to be used specifically on COVID related expenses. // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Wright had no items. Councilmember Wilder had no items. Councilmember Nelson had no items. Councilmember Perrow thanked Mayor Tweedy a nd Councilmember Wilder April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 10 for discussing the Florida Avenue sidewalk project. He appreciates that they mentioned that the whole corridor is an important gateway, that it has a major business on it and needs improvement. He still would rather to see this as a road project and not just a sidewalk project. Councilmember Perrow also noted that Virginia First Cities has been asked to develop a position on the governor’s amendment 36 of the Executive Order moving the local election to November. The Virginia Munipal League does not support this amendment. He would like to make a motion to endorse a May 5th election. Mayor Tweedy said she had this as an item for the 7:30 agenda. Councilmember Perrow withdrew his motion, as Councilmembers would like a chance to read the information given them at the work session. Councilmember Helgeson had left the meeting prior to roll call. Vice Mayor Dolan had no items. Mayor Tweedy reminded everyone of the importance of responding to Census 2020. She also thanked the public for their cooperation with the recommendations regarding COVID-19. // The meeting was recessed at 6:27 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present: Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Sterling Wilder, Beau Wright, Treney Tweedy 7 Absent: 0 // Councilmember Nelson gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Councilmembers Nelson and Helgeson asked that the minutes of March 10, March 17 and March 24, 2020 meetings be postponed until the next meeting so they can make some corrections. // Mayor Tweedy asked if there was any objection to amending the agenda to include a discussion of their response to the request of Virginia First Cities to weigh in on the governor’s amendment to move the election to November. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Tweedy recognized the City Attorney, Walter Erwin, for forty yea rs of service to the City effective April 16, 2020. Mayor Tweedy noted that he has been valuable to the City but is highly regarded in the state. They are honored to have him here and that he chose Lynchburg to serve the forty years. Mr. Erwin thanked them and noted that his office has always received a tremendous amount of support and could not function without that support. Councilmember Nelson noted that when he tells people he is from Lynchburg in the legal community, they say they are lucky to have Walter Erwin. He graduated from law school with Walter forty-four years ago and said he was so glad he came to Lynchburg. // In the matter of Community Development, Conditional Use Permits, a public hearing was conducted regarding the petition of Virginia Episcopal School for a Conditional Use Permit in an R-1, Low Density Residential District and R-3, Medium Density Residential District for a Master Plan at 301 VES Road, 310 VES Road, 314 VES Road, 318 VES Road, 320 VES Road, 340 VES Road, 400 VES Road, 500 VES Road, 700 VES Road, 190 Old One Sixty Lane, 120 Oriskany Street, and 3805 Williams Road that includes the addition of new academic buildings, new faculty housing in the form of apartment buildings, duplexes and single household dwellings, stu dent housing, addition of lighted athletic fields, addition of bleachers at athletic fields and traffic calming to VES Road. The City Planner, Mr. Tom Martin, gave a summary of the petition. April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 11 The Clerk of Council, Robin Craig, had a statement from G. Thomas Battle, Headmaster, Virginia Episcopal School (VES): “In 2015 Virginia Episcopal School embarked on a collaborative effort to plan the future growth and development of its 100-year-old campus. Intended to offer a practical, yet visionary approach to the future, the master planning process was designed to hear the voices of VES’s many constituencies and blend them into priorities and design concepts. This collaborative approach included a year of listening, investigating, and brainstorming, and included much community input, meetings with students, faculty, and alumni, as well as a school-wide survey that reached parents and alumni around the world. To this end, VES would like to provide an opportunity for the City and public to weigh in on the Master Plan and the projects contained therein. This will help to provide the confidence and support to fundraise and develop programs necessary to achieve VES’s goals and vision for the next 20 years and beyond. In early 2020, VES met with the TRC, Planning Commission, and hosted a neighborhood gathering, pre-Covid- 19, in which the participants were able to review the Master Plan documents and ask questions and voice concerns. All meetings to date have been received with the enthusiasm and support that we also s hare for the campus and its future in this vibrant community. Any concerns voiced at these meetings, specifically field lighting and project phasing, have been addressed in the documents and are detailed herein. The 260, 9-12th grade students who attend VES are represented by 30% day students and 70% boarding students, while about 80% of staff and faculty live on campus. The Master Plan provides the opportunity to increase the number of boarding students to approximately 80% of the student body while maint aining a cap on total student enrollment at around 260. Additional housing for students, staff and faculty will decrease inbound traffic by locating living and working on the campus for more than 80% of the VES population. The Master Plan proposes traffic calming and pedestrian safety measures for portions of Williams and VES Roads including adding a planted median on VES Road and several clearly delineated pedestrian crossing areas. This is a planned improvement that would be developed with the City of Lynchburg. With the proposed changes to campus, the parking areas have been reconsidered to better serve housing and athletic fields. New additional spaces are designed to better accommodate on-campus staff, offer greater access to athletic facilities, and help to pull event traffic off of VES and Williams Roads and into planned parking areas. Athletic improvements include upgrades to all the athletic fields, including new bleachers, turf, lighting, and an enhanced trail system for team and recreational sports. Seating capacities for outdoor gatherings and sporting events are expected to remain the same since enrollment and faculty are projected to remain constant through the 20 -year projection of the Master Plan. Note that all athletic field lighting will comply with the International Dark-Sky Association requirements with zero trespass to any neighboring public or non-VES-owned properties. Phasing of the CAMPUS projects will be developed within a dynamic fundraising process as VES’s Development team builds campaigns for the future of the school. In the first initiative of the master plan a 15,000 sf new academic building is being planned along with some needed renovations to existing buildings, additional faculty housing, and improvements to athletic fields. Project phases beyond the next ten years will depend very much on fundraising and economic trends.” April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 12 There were no persons to speak either in favor or opposition to the petition. The Clerk reported that there were no phone calls or email regarding the petition. Mayor Tweedy closed the public hearing portion of the petition. Councilmember Perrow made a motion to approve the conditional use permit. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Helgeson. Councilmember Helgeson wished that the City could do as well with reducing noise and lighting from the City Stadium as VES is proposing to do with its athletic facilities. The proposal looks good and he thanked VES. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright, 7 Nos: 0 // In the matter of Community Development, Conditional Use Permits, a public hearing was conducted regarding the petition of TPB Enterprises for a Conditional Use Permit in a B-3C, Community Business (Conditional) District to allow the construction of a car wash at 7816 Timberlake Road. Mr. Tom Martin gave a summary of the petition. Mr. Norm Walton with Perkins & Orrison was present to represent the petitioner. He thanked Council and City staff for making it possible for them to speak, as he understands the pandemic has created some unusual challenges for meetings. He stated that water and sewer is available for the project. A large grocery store has been removed from the project. The intersection at Candlewood Court remains the same, so they feel very confident that traffic will be handled adequately. There is a triple lane going to the kiosk, which will keep queuing out from the private road and reduce impacts to the private road. There is one exit from the project as far away from Timberlake Road as possible. They have the landscaping on the concept plan per the ordinance. The underlying proffers for the development have not been revised, amended or removed by the conditional use permit request. Mr. Daniel Sowers of TPB Enterprises was present to represent the developer. This car wash was previously shown in a different location and they are proposing to relocate it to this spot in order to alleviate some traffic issues that arose. Based on a feasibility study by a national car wash chain and work done with Perkins & Orrison, they believe this is an effective location for the car wash and will mitigate any traffic concerns. They believe it will support the multi-family development proposed for the rear of the development, as well as other multi-family developments in the area. Mr. Timothy Santiago came forward to speak in favor of the petition. He used to live on Timberlake Road near Kroger and there was not a decent car wash nearby. He thinks this car wash will improve the lives of a lot of people that live in the area. He would like to see them approve something that will improve people’s lives, especially in a time where we need to focus on cleanliness. There was no one else present to speak either in favor or in opposition. Ms. Craig read one email into the record: “I am writing to oppose granting the subject conditional use permit. The proposed location has substantial traffic from the apartments and SSA. Adding this business to the already overwhelming traffic on Timberlake Road will reduce the safety of travelers and for local residents. Sincerely, William D. Conner, III, Moreview Drive, 24502.” Councilmember Helgeson asked why there is not a Future Land Use Map (FLUM) amendment before them because it is listed as High Density on the FLUM. Mr. Martin said that when it came before them previously for April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 13 rezoning in 2014, it was not changed. They are currently looking at the FLUM. There are certain areas of the City that need to be tweaked and updated and he thinks this is one of them. When this project was originally presented, it contained high density residential with a retail component and that may be one of the reasons they did not recommend it to be changed. Councilmember Helgeson noted it is not a big change moving the car wash from one lot to the other. Councilmember Helgeson noted that originally there was supposed to be a grocery store in this project and it would employ more people than a car wash and a different amount o f tax revenue. Mr. Martin noted that it was a different developer in 2014 and the property has been sold. The new owner, Mr. Thomas Bell, has taken a little different approach to what types of uses are going to go there. Mr. Martin said this project has changed, as they were originally proposed to be service industries that would support the residential uses in the rear. It is a philosophical switch, which was actually difficult for planning staff. Staff cannot dictate the market and the way the site is being developed, which is why staff ultimately ended up supporting the use. Councilmember Helgeson asked if there have been any violations from this site. Mr. Martin said there have been a few E & S violations, but the site is in compliance now. Councilmember Helgeson noted that there are other proposals coming their way from this developer, such as a lot of townhomes and apartments, which are the very thing to which the neighbors objected. He will not object to the car wash because it is not a big change. He hopes Council recognizes that often they get a project and they like it as presented but then it changes because there is a new owner and a new philosophy. He can tell them that the neighbors are not appreciative of it. Councilmember Perrow noted that there has been a history of challenges with making sure this developer meets City regulations, particularly regarding erosion and sediment control. He thinks there are some opportunities to partner with the developer going forward and improve the City overall. In order to do that, there has to be a solid basis of trust. The developer has to stick to their commitments and follow the regulations or the City is not going to be willing to go into any sort of agreement with someone they cannot trust to hold up their end of the agreement. He suggested they have a suggestion with their client and make sure he or they work really hard to establish trust with the City. He thinks that would make this next phase potentially go a lot smoother. He is excite d about some of the potentials they are bringing forward that helps us create more of a gateway into the area but we have to have that trust. Councilmember Perrow made a motion to approve the petition. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder and passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright, 7 Nos: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Council conducted a public hearing to consider introducing a resolution for the purpose of amending the FY2020 Budget and appropriating supplemental funds and rescinding appropriations for both the Capital and Operating Budgets for the twelve-month period beginning July 1, 2019 and ending June 30, 2020. Ms. Donna Witt gave them an overview of the request. She provided Council with proposed expenditure and revenue adjustments based on both the third quarter review and the recent COVID -19 projected impacts. She explained the research that went into the assumptions for projected revenues. They have been having weekly discussions facilitated by Virginia Tech with finance leaders state-wide to glean understanding of how localities are April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 14 handling the impacts of COVID-19. They have had discussions with the Commissioner of Revenue, Tourism Sales Team, which surveyed local businesses and canvassed regarding their dedicated revenues. Other information sources consulted were Virginia First Cities, Fiscal Analytics, Virginia Government Finance Officers Association, Government Finance Officers Association and Virginia Municipal League/Virginia Association of Counties. She explained that this is difficult because it is unprecedented and we do not have any history to fall back on and we are still waiting for our March revenue numbers. They searched every available avenue where they could get more information. Ms. Witt covered the changes they are projecting for real property, personal property, motor vehicles licenses, local sales and use tax, meals tax, lodging tax, amusement tax, business license tax and t he allowance for uncollectible business license tax. They also made adjustments to all other non -dedicated revenues such as bank stock tax, permits, fees and regulatory licenses, fines and forfeitures, revenue from use of money and property, charges for services and miscellaneous revenue. She went over the projections for our dedicated revenues such as charges for services, recreation revenue, parking revenue and miscellaneous revenue. In order to make the budget whole, they are proposing to use $500,000 from the Task Force on Future of PreK-12 Education and Beyond, $500,000 from the GLTC Reserve, $380,235 from the General Fund Reserve for Contingencies. They also made some expenditure reduction with reduced salary and benefit funds for part-time staff due to furloughs, reduced department operating funds for training, mileage and office supplies due to spending and travel freeze, reduced department fuel costs due to savings, use of managed vacancy funds, including the hiring freeze and reduced school operating local funding. She concluded by saying that staff is constantly monitoring the impacts to revenue as a result of COVID -19. Following receipt of meals, lodging and amusement taxes on May 20, staff will have a better idea of how these three consumer driven taxes are performing during the various directives from the governor. If there are significant changes, they will provide an update at the May 26th work session. Mr. Timothy Santiago came forward to speak. He said citizens rely on Council to provide a comprehensive budget. Changes to a budget and operating costs should not be taken lightly. We do not have all the facts right now. The times we are in are troubling. He would suggest they give it two weeks and see if we peak because we may be out of this sooner than we thought. He pointed out that our economy came back for quite a while after the 1918 Spanish influenza. We will come back because Lynchburg has always persevered. He thinks Lynchburg is unique in its ability to do so but through strong leadership. He thinks the budget should only be changed under extreme circumstances and he thinks we can continue it for the future. He thinks they should wait two weeks for m ore information to make sure they have made a good decision. There was a phone call from Phil Stump. He followed closely the discussion of the Lynchburg City Schools proposed budget and was very impressed by the virtual miracle performed by the superintendent. She was able to keep the spending at the same level as last year while addressing inflation and important emerging needs. She noted that the flat budgets are not sustainable in the long run. City Council will be tempted not to accept even this insufficient flat budget but will be tempted to make cuts that will be exceedingly harmful for the future of our schools. The pandemic will create fiscal challenges for the City and even more fiscal challenges for our schools. April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 15 He is a property owner and is willing to pay substantially higher property taxes to support schools. People that seek to be good stewards are to be supported and rewarded not punished with scarcity. When they are stewards of our children’s future, this is all the more necessary. What is at stake is indeed the future of our society. Mayor Tweedy closed the public hearing of the petition. Councilmember Helgeson thought that may people pay their real estate taxes through escrow so maybe the projected uncollectible amount is high. Ms. Witt said it is about 31 percent that pay it through escrow. Staff was surprised by that percentage, so they verified it twice. Councilmember Helgeson commented sometimes times like this help us separate the necessities from the niceties. He appreciates what the financial staff is doing. It is good and prudent and will hopefully carry over into next budget year. We are cutting approximately three percent from the general fund but there are people out there paying the bills that have lost all or almost all of their income. He made a motion for approval, which was seconded by Councilmember Perrow. Councilmember Perrow commented to Mr. Santiago that Council takes budget matters very, very seriously. He explained that state code requires them to have two readings to amend a budget. The second vote will be in two weeks and ensures that this is in fact what they want to do. If there is good news in two weeks, we can react to that change. He thought Mr. Santiago made some very good points. City staff has worked to figure out what they can do to slow spending down recognizing that revenues have fallen. He thinks what staff has done will allow C ity services to move on. The part-time employees furloughed were mainly those employed in gathering places such as the libraries and the recreation centers. He explained to Mr. Santiago that the cuts they are making are expenditures that are not being made that do not have a significant impact to current services. We have to balance this loss of revenue somehow. Councilmember Perrow asked Ms. Witt how staff made the projections so specific such as 79 percent and 41 percent rather than more general. Ms. Witt said part of it is historically what we have collected to date and basically it is just math. They took into account anything that could influence where they nee d to get to. She relied on staff members like Mitch Nuckles and Marjette Upshur and their wealth of knowledge. Councilmember Perrow noted it had to be a significant amount of effort and thanked her and the rest of staff involved. Councilmember Nelson noted they are hearing that hope is not a strategy. What they are doing is a very appropriate strategy to deal with novel and unpredictable challenges. He hopes it is not as dire as it is but these are good strategies. In answer to a question from Councilmember Wilder, she said it is about $5 million in a reduction in revenue and then using the committed and assigned fund balance and the reserve for contingencies. It is a net of about $3.5 million. Councilmember Wilder thanked staff for their efforts to try and deal with a moving target. Councilmember Wilder thanked staff for the hard work. He asked how much is left in the task force money and was told $700,000. He asked when the furloughs take effect and was told they have already taken place and those employees have been told that it is indefinite. Councilmember Wilder asked if the schools told them that they did not need the $1.5 million and Ms. Svrcek said it was a happy bit of coincidence. Vice Mayor Dolan thanked the staff for the extraordinary job. Mayor Tweedy echoed all the accolades. April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 16 The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright, 7 Nos: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Council considered introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2020 General Fund budget and appropriating $224,965 with resources from the General Fund Reserve for Contingencies to refund overpayment of Bank Franchise Tax for tax years 2012, 2013 and 2014 by BB&T for operations in the City of Lynchburg. Councilmember Perrow commented he is a stakeholder in BB&T and it is considered an amount enough to be a personal interest; however, he is a member of a much larger group and feels he is able to vote in an unbiased manner. Councilmember Nelson had the same disclosure to make but it does not rise to a statutory interest. He stated he can be objective and unbiased. Mr. Mitch Nuckles explained that banks pay an annual tax on their equity. BB&T filed 2012, 2013 and 2014 tax returns. They amended those returns, which were initially denied by the Department of Taxation. The Tax Commissioner overruled the denials in October 2019. BB&T has agreed not to seek any interest from localities if refunded by May 1, 2020. Councilmember Helgeson spoke on behalf of the Finance Committee and said that it was very benevolent of the bank not to request interest. He asked how much is left in the reserve for contingencies after this payment. Ms. Witt said it is approximately $255,000. It is obviously a bad time to be giving a refund like this, especially since it was through no fault of the City. He made a motion on behalf on the Finance Committee to approve the resolution. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright, 7 Nos: 0 // In the matter of City Council, Mr. Erwin provided them with a report regarding how other localities are conducting meetings during COVID-19, which is a variety of different ways. Each locality seems to be adopting procedures which are best for their situation. He provided them with a sample ordinance from Richmond that could be used as a starting for Lynchburg City Council. Councilmember Nelson noted this is probably a worthwhile tool to have in our tool belt of policies and procedures. His concern is that the opportunity for abuse may be high. He does not have a problem with having a way for a Councilmember to participate electronically if he or she needs to be away for a family medical reason. If it is not possible for a quorum to be physically present in Council Chamber, he would want an emergency to be declared that is higher than someone in the City. The meeting should also only deal with emergency type issues and not routine items that deal with ordinary operation of the City. It should be directly related to either resolving the emergency or something that has happened as a result of the emergency. The procedure should be very clear and precise and identify the emergency and why it is necessary for Council to act immediately. He would also like a super majority having to call for a virtual meeting. He feels they can make the effort to conduct their meetings since first responders and health care workers are facing the challenge every day. He wants to set the bar very high before we can conduct the people’s business in a way that is somewhat behind closed doors and not readily available to most people in their circumstances. Councilmember Wright would agree that there should be a really compelling public interest to hold a virtual meeting. He asked staff if they have the infrastructure to conduct a virtual meeting that still allows the public to be involved. There was discussion about how this could be facilitated but it would involve some staff being there to April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 17 operate the computer and audiovisual equipment. Councilmember Perrow asked why we would ask staff to be here and not be here ourselves. Councilmember Wilder thinks that with the way the world is changing, it is good to h ave a system in place if it does get worse or something else happens. Councilmember Helgeson thinks the bar needs to be very high. If it is so bad that we should not be asking staff to be here, then we should not be meeting. Our first responders are out there. The estimates of fatalities are coming in at three percent of the original estimates. He thinks they are coming out of the woods and he thinks we need to continue to have everything above board and out in the open as much as possible. Mayor Tweedy noted that she also thinks the bar should be high. The numbers were predicted but it is also because practices were put in place early enough that numbers were reduced. Vice Mayor Dolan agrees that it has to be an emergency situation and it needs to be further defined. Mayor Tweedy noted that we are elected officials but should not be in the category of first responders. They are not public safety responders and that is there job duty and career. We may very well be doing more damage by not adhering to the guidelines that are in place and we are not on the same level, in her opinion, as first responders. Councilmember Perrow likes the idea of a super majority for action. He wondered if they would have to call a meeting to declare the emergency. Councilmember Nelson said they would call a meeting in a virtual way if a state of emergency is declared. It happens in the process of opening the meeting. They have to articulate the reason and what is on the agenda. It would be limited to those things that are related to the emergency. He would be happy to meet with Walter Erwin to craft some language. Councilmember Perrow said that would be his recommendation. Councilmember Helgeson commented that he also likes the idea of a super majority needing to call for the virtual meeting. Councilmember Nelson would suggest they need a policy in order to deal with r outine items in a situation such as the building is not habitable. Dr. Wodicka said staff is working on a City Hall continuity of operations plan that was in the works before this pandemic. Councilmember Perrow asked if the continuity of government ordinance they approved previously would allow a councilmember to attend electronically if the rest of Council agrees. Mr. Erwin said that is correct and it was covered in the one they passed on March 24, 2020 and clarified that the member should be able to do anything they could do in person, including voting. // In the matter of City Council, Council had a discussion regarding the governor’s amendment 36 directing the local elections to be moved to November. Virginia First Cities is asking for each locality’ s input regarding this issue. Councilmember Perrow made a motion that Council directs him to vote on behalf of Lynchburg to reject this directive at the board meeting this week. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Helgeson. Councilmember Perrow explained the language cannot be changed. Either the General Assembly will accept it or not. Councilmember Helgeson seconded the motion because several of them are on the ballot. They have been preparing for it but the registrar is working very judiciously. The 2,000 ballots that have been submitted so far would be discarded and that is not good. He thinks it is terrible that the governor has both declared an emergency and the decided what needs to be changed. Normally an emergency requires a super major ity vote and hopefully that would still be the case. The suggestion that the local election be combined with the presidential election is also not acceptable to him because it would couple the election for the highest office in the nation with one of the lowest. April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 18 Councilmember Wright said he would normally agree but in this case the issue is a pandemic. There are people going into the registrar’s office to vote in person. Polls will still be open, since a mail only election has not approved. He has great concern about both voters and poll worker. The electoral board endorses the governor’s recommendation. Health and safety is paramount to him, so he would be opposed to them endorsing the recommendation to keep the local election in May. Councilmember Wilder echoed the concerns regarding the safety of the poll workers and voters. He has not heard of any protection measures being put in place for them. Councilmember Helgeson reminded them that the Fire Chief has offered protective equipment for the poll workers. He pointed out that people are shopping with social distancing measures and that could be done at the polls as well. Councilmember Wright commented that most of the poll workers are in the high risk category and we do not even know if they are willing to show up to work. Long lines were seen at the polls in Wisconsin and it created a public health fiasco. Councilmember Perrow noted that he has never seen a line at a May election. It is a very low turnout election. Councilmember Nelson said he likes the local elections to be held apart from the state and national elections so the issues do not become convoluted or obscured. Money has been spent on campaigns by the candidates and to drag it out six more months would be hard on them. Votes have been cast and they will be thrown away. Those voters would have to do it again. However, the voice of the local registrar rings high. If it cannot be carried out because the poll workers are not there, we are not going to have an election with integrit y in May. Vice Mayor Dolan thinks local elections get lost in a state or national election. She thinks they become more bipartisan and for that reason she would not like to see it moved. She would like to see mail in only campaign but she does not think they have the appetite for it. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Perrow, Tweedy 4 Nos: Nelson, Wilder, Wright 3 Mayor Tweedy noted that she thinks there are protective measures that can be p ut in place. Councilmember Perrow will communicate the vote to Virginia First Cities. // On motion of Councilmember Perrow, seconded by Vice Mayor Dolan, by the following recorded vote elected to hold a closed meeting to for the discussion and consideration of prospective candidates for the position of City Manager pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Nos: 0 // The meeting was re-opened to the public. Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and April 14, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 19 WHEREAS, Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Perrow, and Council by the following recorded vote adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was adjourned at 7:00 p.m. Clerk of Council April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 28th day of April, 2020, at 4:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Treney Tweedy, President, presiding. The following members were present: Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Sterling A. Wilder, Beau Wright, Treney Tweedy 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Council heard a presentation on budget revisions as a result of COVID-19. Ms. Svrcek said that first and foremost, we still have citizens to serve and a City to maintain with direct and indirect services. Historical trends do not apply and with regard to future trends, we know a little more with each passing month. Items that we do not know are what will happen with our anchor institutions. The colleges, universities and the hospital are doing things differently. We do not know how many college students will return to campus. There is uncertainty regarding whether people will continue to work remotely versus in a brick and mortar office. There is uncertainty regarding the impacts of reductions by the State, particularly for annual police funding ($3.1 million), Personal Property Tax Reduction Subsidy ($5.5 million), Highway Maintenance ($9 million) and Education funding. We do not know the impacts of changes in consumer behavior. There is the potential of Council to make changes to tax rates. There is the uncertainty of when a vaccine will be available and the economic impact should there be a reoccurrence of the virus. Councilmember Nelson asked if it was possible, if not too burdensome, to get some preliminary information from businesses even though it is not time for them to report their receipts. Dr. Reid Wodicka said they have been getting anecdotal information from businesses by using surveys and they were falling in line with their expectations. Ms. Witt covered the sources of information they used for forming their projections. Since the las t meeting, they have added information from the Virginia Employment Commission and the Virginia Restaurant and Lodging Association. Councilmember Perrow asked if the Lynchburg Business Alliance has been a source of information. Ms. Svrcek said they have been holding briefings called “Wednesdays at One.” He asked if there is a way we could use them to poll some of the businesses. Ms. Witt said she talks to Marjette Upshur on a weekly basis, as they are a long-term recovery team together. Both the Alliance and the EDA should be on this list. Councilmember Helgeson thinks you can tell what is going on by driving by the empty parking lots of the businesses and the colleges. He thinks we need to start lobbying to do something different as Lynchburg because we only five people in the hospital out of 82,000 residents. He thinks we need to do something different like was done yesterday when the governor tried to use his authority to unconstitutionally usurp something and was stopped by the court. He would like them to do something proactively but safely. Councilmember Perrow noted that he received an email sent to Virginia First Cities asking what steps can be taken to come out of this. The idea of regionalizing has been put forth because what is a problem for Fairfax or Arlington is not necessarily a problem for Bristol or Lynchburg. Councilmember Helgeson noted this is a medical crisis for hospitals. UVA has cut salaries and furloughing 20 percent of its personnel. If UVA is furloughing in a medical pand emic, something seems very askew to him. He thinks they need to look at some factual analysis and not just stoke fear. Councilmember Nelson thinks Councilmember Helgeson makes some points. We have to make decisions based on the mindset of our citizens and businesses. It has been pointed out that we need to rely on data and data is April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 2 scientific evidence. That is what we need and what has been promoted. We need to do testing. That confidence and information will facilitate people going back to restaurants and businesses knowing they can do so safely. Until we have that information is known and there is the ability to track contact, everyone is going to have the fear that will shut us all down. The formula has been laid out by scientists and medical peo ple who know and we should not rely on speculation. Just pushing a button and saying we are ready to go is not going to be the solution. Ms. Witt provided them with the unemployment data for Lynchburg. We are very similar to other cities in Virginia and are kind of in the middle of the pack. She also provided them with the Central Virginia Workforce Development Area top ten occupations with greatest number of initial unemployment claims. No surprise is that the food industry is the top one and administrative positions being second. There are just over 5,000 in Lynchburg in the initial unemployment numbers. They use 32,000 as the number for the Lynchburg workforce. Councilmember Helgeson noted that means that about15 percent of our workforce has been forcibly unemployed in the last few weeks. Ms. Witt had a slide showing the president’s guidelines for opening up America again. Before we can start Phase 1, we need a downward trajectory in cases for 14 days. They used this data for their assumptions for revenues. Ms. Witt noted that they are paying really close attention to what the governor is saying about whether regions can open up when they have reached Phase 1 but for now we have to go on what the president has outlined. For the big picture revenue assumptions, the first quarter assumes Virginia moves from Phase 1 to Phase 3 by the end of the quarter, which includes most businesses open with relaxed social distancing. Second quarter assumes Phase 3 continues with social distancing and consumer behavior driven by individual health concerns. Businesses are pretty much open. Third and fourth quarters are based on anticipating more “normal” consumer spending. Ms. Witt noted that grocery store and home improvement sales are up, as well as online sales. Restaurants with quick service or drive through are holding steady. Full service restaurants that changed to curbside pickup and/or delivery are down. She then went through the conservative, meaning worst case scenario, assumptions they have made for the economic impacts of COVID-19 on FY2021 revenue projections. Councilmember Wright asked how the projected decline in revenue correlates to the 2008 recession. M.s Witt said that was different. She cannot tell them the overall decline. Our consumption revenues were really impacted but it was different. He asked if it was worse and Ms. Witt and Ms. Svrcek said no. Councilmember Perrow note d it was more of a slow drain and we had to shrink the City budget. This is kind of a sudden shock and he is concerned about cash flow. Ms. Witt said she has two staff members continuously monitoring money coming in and going out to make sure what we are projecting is even feasible. We are good until the end of this fiscal year and we are also projecting out to the end of the calendar year. The May and June collections are so important though because they get us through the summer and fall and to our next due date in November. She covered the revenue projections for dedicated revenues and then the sources they propose to use to balance the FY2021 proposed budget: $2,015,952 from a loss in the 3 percent general wage increase; $946,481 from a delay in Phase II of the Korn-Ferry market adjustment; $1,142,346 from a one-time transfer from GLTC City Operating savings due to additional federal funds available through the CARES Act; $30,142 from eliminating City Council salary increases; $75,000 from reducing funding for implementing Safety and Security Task Force recommendations April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 3 leaving a budget of $50,000; $50,000 from eliminating health insurance consultant for employees; $700,000 from reducing the transfer to Lynchburg City Schools; $75,000 from Economic Development eliminating funding for 2040 Master Plan $60,000 from eliminating Public Works mini sweeper and $2,760 from reduced hours for part - time Volunteer Coordinator position at the library. Councilmember Wright asked what the alignment with Schools is regarding the proposed reduction of $700,000. Ms. Svrcek said they knew they needed to spread the impact quite frankly and they arrived at this number. Quite honestly, she has not had a conversation with the superintendent regarding it until today. Councilmember Wright would not be comfortable with it without consulting with Schools and would like it added to the “list.” Additional sources to balance the budget are $34,986 from eliminating a new part-time police accreditation position; $39,773 from eliminating a new part-time fire accreditation position; $12,383 from delaying the start of new Parks & Recreation positions for a neighborhood center until October 1, 2020; $61,315 from a delay in starting three new full-time Social Services positions (local savings) until January 1, 2021; $500,000 comes from eliminating the additional money for the Task Force on the Future of PreK-12 Education and Beyond reserve and the use of $700,000 of the Task Force on the Future of PreK-12 Education and Beyond reserve for a total of $6,446,138 in expenditure reductions and use of reserves. Councilmember Helgeson asked if there were any other studies or master plans that they could look at postponing. Staff could only think of a Parks & Recreation study that is in pay -as-you-go money. Councilmember Helgeson said it would to look through to see if they could find any “low hanging fruit.” Ms. Svrcek said they are looking at doing some of the implementation of the Economic Development 2040 Master Plan in -house. Mayor Tweedy asked if there is an economic recovery plan from the pandemic. Ms. Svrcek said there is a long -term recovery group that meets once a week and it is a work in progress. Ms. Witt explained that they will be monitoring revenues very closely. Following receipt of July 2020 meals, lodging and amusement taxes on September 21 and sales tax on October 5, staff will have a better idea of how consumer driven taxes are performing. Staff will provide an update at the October 13, 2020 Council work session. Expenditure adjustments will be proposed to Council on October 13 if the economy is not improving. She will also be giving a monthly report at Finance Committee. Ms. Svrcek indicated they would also update Council at the second meeting of each month. There are several things that they will know by October that will help them project revenues going forward such as FY2020 business license payments due May 20, FY2020 personal property tax payments due June 5, FY2020 real estate tax payments due May 15, July meals, lodging, amusement and sales tax payments, September meals, lodging and amusement tax payments and October 5 sales tax payments. We will have a better understanding of consumer behavior, college enrollment and return of students, rescheduled college gradua tions and the status of Lynchburg City Schools. If the economy is not improving by October, the hiring, spending, training and travel freeze will be extended. We might need to use the Fund Balance above 10% ($1,100,000). There could be a possible retur n of additional GLTC funds, if available ($500,000). We could reduce General Fund Pay-as-you-go Capital Improvement Program April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 4 projects. Staff furlough days may need to be taken. There could be other sources of expenditure reduction or revenues to be determined. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the furlough days would apply to public safety employees. Ms. Svrcek said that would be her recommendation. Councilmember Nelson noted that until testing and contact tracing is more robust, the consumer confidence to go out could be marginal. He asked Ms. Witt if there had been any discussion about testing in her meetings with other financial officers and she said that they had heard that hopefully by early summer the testing will be ramped up. He asked if any of the universities are implementing any requirements that students have to be tested or vaccinated before returning. She said she had read an article that all the major colleges are meeting to determine what that might look like in terms of students returning. They are all looking at different scenarios. It could be disastrous if the public perceives that the colleges are not doing that here in terms of wanting to go out to businesses. We should probably have a conversation with our college presidents regarding their plans. Councilmember Helgeson thinks the testing has gone up tremendously. He also pointed out that you can test one day negative and then get the virus the next day. He also hopes they do not go down the path of vilifying a select group of people. The paper said that a certain school was reckless and he went there and it was a ghost town. We are all in this together and we cannot be attacking a piece of our economy. We really do appreciate 15,000 students that come here and help fund our budget. He is sure they want to be healthy just like we all do. He thinks we all care about our safety and our health. Councilmember noted that the college students are certainly a viable part of our community. He just meant that he would like them to be here in a safe manner and he thinks the college presidents should be having conversations about how that will happen. He does not think anyone is trying to vilify anyone. It is a comfort and security level that he is seeking. Councilmember Wright stated that it is a fact that we do not have enough testing in Virginia. If we want people to feel comfortable opening their businesses and consumers to go out into the marketplace, they need the assurance that they can be readily tested. He wants the public watching to know that Lynchburg believes in science and evidence and data. It is not just about what feels good and we will look to the public health experts and epidemiologists for thoughtful, studied recommendations before we do anything with ou r most precious resource, which is our people. Mayor Tweedy thinks that because social distancing guidelines are so stringent and the conversation about reckless decisions was brought up early, the impact on our community has been minimized. That is a good thing because she knows people that are personally affected. She knows that life matter and we have the opportunity to preserve life and safety and have precaution in our leadership roles. She will do everything she needs to do to protect citizens and their lives. We can’t go to restaurants if we are six feet under. She does not have an expendable number of citizens that are expendable in our City no matter their length of residency. Ms. Witt will also give an update at the January 12, 2021 Council meeting if the economy is not improving. They would suggest extending the hiring freeze (managed vacancy savings), extend spending freeze, extend training and travel freeze, eliminate any remaining General Fund Pay-as-you-go Capital Improvement Program projects, consider additional staff furlough days, consider a reduction in force, including related service delivery impacts. There could other expenditures reductions and sources for revenue to be determined. April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 5 Councilmember Wilder commented that he is sorry that the three percent raises and Korn Ferry salary adjustments are being cut. He asked if there any way possible we can make adjustments to salaries or give a bonus if we see revenues are better later in the year. Ms. Witt said that would certainly be possible and it would be a Council decision. Ms. Svrcek would suggest they mention things they would like on a “list” to be considered in mid-year FY2021. He asked if schools have been consulted about the $2.2 million they are suggesting be taken from their budget. Ms. Witt said they talked about the initial $1.5 million but not the additional $700,000. Councilmember Wilder would like the entire $2.2 million added to the “list.” He would like to hear from the school superintendent as to the impact this will have on their budget. Councilmember Wilder asked about the increase in the trash fee. Ms. Svrcek said that will be on the agenda for next week’s work session. Councilmember Perrow would like to see the City’s portion of the school budget for the past several years so they can see the recent history. Ms. Svrcek said she will provide that to them. Councilmember Helgeson would like them to look at some reduction in force. UVA just announced today that they are cutting administrative salaries and positions by 20 percent. He would like them to look at the ones that are actually delivering services such as the firefighters, police, teacher and trash collectors but cut some of the administrative positions or salaries. In his tenure, he has never seen a zero base budget that looks at what we actually need. Things just seem to incrementally go up. He would suggest they keep “the boots on the ground” and possibly pay them more but cut some of the administration. There is some administration that is needed but there are probably things that we could do. They have listed these things as possibly being done in January 2021 but he would suggest they need to be done now. He does not want to impact the services to citizens but we could get rid of some of the middle stuff. Ms. Svrcek would say that for years City departments have been working at the margins from top to bottom. If there were fat in this budget, Council would have cut it by now. She does not believe they have a “fat” budget to say the least. Everyone is busy doing the work that Council has expected them to do. They may do some furlough days, if necessary, but they are hoping there does not have to be a reduction in force, quite frankly. Counci l needs to tell them if there are certain positions they want them to look at. The budget was zero based during the time of Kim Payne. Frankly, every year she has been the City Manager she has typically asked departments to submit a budget with less funding than the previous year. They have increased salaries to try to keep up with the market. It breaks her heart that they cannot go forward with the three percent increase and implementation of Phase 2 of the Korn Ferry study. We fought hard to do that study and to have Council support it. Frankly, she takes offense that he thinks that there is wasted taxpayer dollars in this budget. They do not believe there is and Council needs to tell them if they want to cut a particular service. Councilmember Helgeson thinks a lot of administrative things have grown over the years and he noted that not all department heads live in the City. Ms. Svrcek said more and more of them do as she has hired them. He suggested consolidated more divisions like they did with Economic Development, Tourism and Museums. He would like them to hone through it in light of what UVA did today. Ms. Svrcek said they are not a hospital and she does not think that is a fair comparison. April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 6 Mayor Tweedy noted that some companies have been able to have their CEOs take a 90 percent cut and still be able to pay their people. For more budget seasons now, she has seen “apples compared to oranges.” It would be constructive if people said cut services. You need supervisors and administrator s to run departments. The idea is grand as a PR point to say “let’s cut fat” or “let’s cut level of management.” It sounds good to some ears but it is not reality. We are looking at life, death and reality and how we are going to look on the other side of a pandemic and not just pandering to someone that wants to hear something that “tickles their ears.” These people that have been front line through the pandemic we are now saying cannot get a raise. We praise them but then tell them they are not worth the money we put aside. Councilmember Helgeson said he takes offense when she keeps saying he is pandering. He brought up something to the City Manager. She said he is comparing “apples to oranges” and he said absolutely not. She said she attacks just like she did with Liberty University. Speaking of pandering, he held up the newspaper where she had called Liberty University reckless and she did not even go over there. He is bringing up things that are important because our restaurants and businesses have done that. Mayor Tweedy acknowledged that she did call something reckless to someone who lied to her and the City Manager. He said he brought it up and if she does not like it to vote against it. She asked him to bring up something constructive and maybe they can agree with it. He would like her to be the leader and quit attacking a Councilmember. She asked him to quit being a weak Councilmember that she has to attack. Councilmember Perrow said she needed to move on and she said she did not need to move on if she thinks people are pandering and attacking the City staff and attacking the budget they have brought and the decisions they have made, she has the right to defend it. Councilmember Nelson thinks that the points made have been well articulated. He thinks the public and he understand both. In terms of the budget and the task before them, they need to move on. She would agree and they need to stick to the presentation. Councilmember Perrow suggested they talk about “the list.” There are several items on the list that would add dollars to the budget and he does not think it is appropriate to discuss them at this time. He would suggest they strike items nine through 19 and 31. Councilmember Helgeson seconded the motion. Councilmember Wright would like to remove items 11, 12 and 31 and made that as a friendly amendment. Councilmember s Perrow and Helgeson accepted that amendment. He said these were items that some of Council thought they could support but obviously the funding is not there. It hurts him to not support these at this time but he would like to see these items returned to the future “list.” Councilmember Wright said it is unfortunate not to be able to support some of these items and in any other budget cycle, these would be incredibly serious items for conversation. Councilmember Nelson wanted to have some discussion about item 19 because that deals with service to one of our most rapidly growing parts of the City. There would be a net savings to the fire department in the overtime they do not have to pay. Councilmembers Perrow and Helgeson accepted that amendment. Councilmember Nelson said three months ago all of these items would have been legitimate and viable topics for discussion but the economic landscape has changed so drastically. April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 7 Councilmember Helgeson is glad item 19 was pulled. When we are having tradeoffs like this, we really have to fixate and focus. It is not pandering. It is making sure our citizens are safe. If there is a way we could cut so we can add those desperately needed “boots on the ground,” that is what he would like to see them do. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright, Tweedy 7 Absent: 0 Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to accept stricken items 1 through 4, which are staff adjustments. Councilmember Wright asked what the $75,000 (item 4) includes and Dr. Wodicka thinks it is a number of place making initiatives, beautification and things like that, throughout downtown. Councilmembers Wright would like this item to be added to the future “list.” Council did not request items 2 or 3 be on the future “list.” The motion was seconded by Councilmember Helgeson and passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright, Tweedy 7 Noes: 0 Rather than discuss item 5, Councilmember Perrow suggested they talk about big ticket items to see if they are willing to make the decisions necessary to fund these items. Councilmember Wright suggested they start with item 19, the nine additional firefighters. Councilmember Helgeson noted they will have to do the same if they want to add back the $2.2 million for schools. Mayor Tweedy suggested they start at item 5 and go down the list. Council was in consensus to do it this way. Councilmember Perrow made a motion to keep the deduction of $37,148 from Parks & Recreation. Councilmember Helgeson seconded the motion. Ms. Svrcek said Council needs to understand it will delay the reopening of the College Hill center, which is currently delayed until October. Councilmember Nelson said we are not sure when groups can gather in large groups and for that reason he would support this motion and look at it in September. Councilmember Wilder is hesitant to remove it because it could be challenging to get it back. Mayor Tweedy felt this could be “double cutting” one of the most vulnerable populations, if cuts are also made to the schools budget. She would like to see what it would look like because it is her understanding that schools is partnering with the centers to help students reenter in the fall. Councilmember Nelson is an ardent supporter of the centers, but we are not even sure if the schools are goi ng to reopen in the fall. We will have a “litmus test” in the summer and early fall to see what staff and facilities are required or not required. Councilmember Helgeson noted they are new positions but Ms. Svrcek noted positions were moved from College Hill to Jefferson Park Center. Councilmember Wright wanted to know where the $380,043 came from with regard to the Use of Reserve Committed/Assigned Fund Balance. Ms. Witt said it the net of the money reduced from the Schools Task Force ($700,000) and the $319, 957 we put back from GLTC. Councilmember Perrow noted that Councilmember Nelson helped him become a supporter of the centers as well in recent years when he worked with the Boys & Girls Club. But if we are going to add things, we have to make some tough decisions. He noted that the reopening is already delayed until October, and we do not know if we will be able to have large groups together at that time or if schools are going to reopen in the fall. Mayor Tweedy asked if the internet would be cut as well. Ms. Svrcek reiterated that the center cannot open at all if it is not staffed. April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 8 Ms. Jenny Jones clarified that this center is a neighborhood internet hotspot. Councilmember Nelson noted they could leave $795 in the budget to cover the internet service. She also clarified for them that it is necessary to have two persons in the centers at all times for safety reasons. Councilmember Wright said he would not be in favor of removing funding for this center because the centers are so important to the fabric of neighborhoods. Vice Mayor Dolan wondered if this item could be put on the future “list” and they delay the reopening until maybe January. Ms. Svrcek said they could do that and bring it back as resources become available. Councilmember W ilder said he is not comfortable with taking money away from a center, particularly in the ward that he represents. The motion failed by the following vote: Ayes: Nelson, Perrow, Helgeson 4 Noes: Wilder, Wright, Tweedy, Dolan 3 The discussion moved to item 6, $50,000 for Safety and Security Task Force. A motion was made by Councilmember Helgeson and seconded by Councilmember Wright to strike this item. They were both satisfied with staff’s recommendation on this so the money can be used somewhere else. Mayor Tweedy asked what this will do to the efforts to make the buildings safer and more secure. Ms. Svrcek noted the first measures were supposed to add some additional safety measure to City Hall in particular. Councilmember Perrow commented it is not preferred to put this off but putting it off a year will not be the end of the world. It should certainly be implemented in future years. if she received the amount of overtime spent on the Fire Department. She mentioned that she might have sent the request by email. Ms. Svrcek said she would get that information to Council. Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 The discussion moved to item 7, $93,789 Chief Talent Development Officer full‐time position ($93,789) transferred to the Council/Manager Offices from Human Resources. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to accept this as a deduction to the budget. Councilmember Perrow seconded the motion and asked for clarification that there was an offsetting deduction in Human Resources. Ms. Svrcek said that was correct. The trans fer was made so they could work more closely with this trainer and she asked them to keep this already filled position. It is even more important for us to have this position when we are cutting trainings and conferences for employees. Mayor Tweedy thinks we need our employment related positions in this unprecedented time of unemployment and uncertainty. Mayor Tweedy clarified for Councilmember Perrow that this is a trainer position and not a recruitment position. He said since this was an even swap with another department’s budget, he would support the City Manager. Councilmember Helgeson said he would not speak against his own motion and was told it could be withdrawn. He declined to do so. Ayes: Helgeson 1 Noes: Dolan, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6 The discussion moved to item 8, C 68,074 Youth Futures Coordinator full‐time position transferred to the Council/Manager Office from Human Services ‐ Juvenile Services. Ms. Svrcek explained this position works with the Mayor’s Youth Council, the Youth Services Advisory Board and helps get youth prepared for the work force, which is really part of the poverty initiative. It is a filled position and has been filled for about a year. April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 9 Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to remove the position. There was no second to the motion and it failed due to a lack of a motion. The position stays in the budget. The discussion moved to item 19. Since the regular meeting was scheduled to start at 6:00 and we have guests present for that meeting, Ms. Svrcek suggested they pick up here at our next meeting on May 5, 2019. Ms. Svrcek noted they will figure out the net of the overtime saved by not having to pay current firefighters weighed against the cost of the nine additional firefighters before that meeting. // Roll call was postponed until after the regular meeting. // The meeting recessed at 6:05 p.m. // City Council reconvened the meeting at 6:15 p.m. The following members were present: Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Sterling Wilder, Beau Wright, Treney Tweedy 7 Absent: 0 // Councilmember Wilder gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Tweedy read a proclamation recognizing National Economic Development Week, National Travel and Tourism Week and National Small Business Week. Ms. Marjette Upshur gave some comments commending our businesses on their ingenuity and kindness during this difficult time. Her office remains focused on promoting and supporting the Lynchburg business community. They continue to invest in the local employers. They are hosting the Spring Co-Starters class virtually. They have started an “I am Lynchburg” campaign to highlight businesses and employees. All of us will be needed to serve on the front lines of recovery. We will get through this unprecedented time together. When the clouds lift, and they will, we will continue to work to make Lynchburg “the best small City in America.” // In the matter of Recognitions, several firefighters were recognized with Certificates of Valor. Communications and Public Engagement put together a video regarding extinguishing a fire and rescue of two children at James Crossing Apartments on April 13, 2020. Chief Greg Wormser had comments of accolade for his staff and thanked Council for its support. Councilmember Wilder also thanked them. He understands their importance to the community. It is important for us to be sensitive to each other. He had some suggestions to show them support such as cooking them a meal or sending them a gift basket. You could also show dual support for a restaurant by taking the first responders or healthcare workers a meal from a local restaurant. Mayor Tweedy said they see them and appreciate what they do for our community. Your courage and bravery takes special people with special hearts and training. Certificates of Valor were presented to Battalion Chief Ricky Bomar, Firefighter Toby Bouyea, Master Firefighter Wayne Casto, Firefighter Darryl DuBose, Firefighter Timothy Greenway, Battalion Chief David Jackson, Firefighter Tammy Kelly, Master Firefighter Patrick Madigan, Captain Matt Milner, Master Firefighter Holly Shackelford, Firefighter Christopher Wilmouth. // In the matter of Consent Agenda, Councilmember Perrow made a motion to approve it, which was seconded by Councilmember Helgeson. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 10 // In the matter of Budget, Consideration of introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $112,531 with resources from the 2020 Coronavirus Emergency Supplemental Funding Program to purchase COVID-19 related Equipment, Decontamination Services, Supplies, Overtime & Fringe Benefits expenditures. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion for approval. This item requires no local match, so it did not go to Finance Committee. Councilmember Nelson seconded the motion and it passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Council considered introducing an uncodified ordinance amending City Code to delay the assessment of the penalty that is normally assessed for the late payment of real estate taxes for the period of May 16, 2020, through June 30, 2020. For reference, she said $144,693 was assessed for penalties in FY2019. Councilmember Perrow moved the ordinance, which was seconded by Councilmember Helgeson. Councilmember Perrow understands that staff is not in support of this but also understands that staff has been very conservative in i ts view of how money has been managed this time. He commented that only $60,000 of that assessed penalty was collected before June 30, 2019. Ms. Witt clarified that we budget for penalties and interest. Councilmember Perrow clarified that it does not the due date or interest. He thinks it is a good will gesture and something they can do without jeopardizing an enormous amount of funds. Councilmember Nelson commented that they will have to come up with the $60,000 somehow for FY2020, if this is approved. He commented that you hear what the state and federal government are doing and this is one of the small nuances where we have some flexibility to do something as a City. Councilmember Perrow said he was speaking with a citizen, Norman Moon, who had made this suggestion. Councilmember Nelson noted that commercial property owners do not pay through escrow and this will likely affect them more than an individual taxpayer. Ms. Witt clarified for Councilmember Wright that the cash flow that would be affected would be cash flow for FY2020, as the assess penalty would be for FY2020 real estate payments. The penalty would have to be paid if it was not paid by July 1, 2020 and that would be cash flow for FY2021. Councilmember Wright wondered how this would affect the City if people took them up on this and delayed their payment. Ms. Witt clarified that banks will make the payments if the money is in escrow. Ms. Witt said she is concerned with the impact on cash flow. She believes the money will get collected eventually but people may choose to put it off longer than usual. She also clarified that interest would still be due. Councilmember Helgeson thinks it should be waived both for economic relief reasons and also because it will be difficult to figure but the bills. Ms. Witt said the system calculates everything for them. It gets billed in their next installment. Councilmember Wright is not sure he is comfortable with deciding on this tonight. He is wondering if they could do something like they are doing with the small business loans wherein the applicant has to certify that they need some COVID related relief. It does not have to be stringent but could hold them accou ntable on an honor system. Vice Mayor Dolan commented that Hampton is doing this but they have to apply by a certain date and show it is related to COVID. Councilmember Perrow said he was trying to limit the operational effort and not make April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 11 any more work for staff. Councilmember Wright asked if staff could bring it back next week with the commercial and residential properties broken out and an estimate of what deferring the interest as well would cost us. Ms. Witt said the longer you take to decide on this, the less people will know to take advantage of it, as the bills have already been mailed. Councilmember Nelson is in favor of no penalty because imposing a penalty right now on businesses and property owner while they are down is doing harm. He does not believe the City taxpayers should be financing anyone’s enterprise and we would making an interest free loan if we waive the interest. He is not in favor of that. Mayor Tweedy called for a motion that is on the floor. Councilmember Helgeson thin ks it is a small and they would not have to recalculate bills. Councilmember Nelson said he could not support that because it is based on principle and not the amount of money. Councilmember Wright said he could support this motion. He noted that he could not find the penalty and interest structure on the website without going into each property’s individual assessment information. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Consider adopting an ordinance establishing procedures for holding electronic meetings during the COVID-19 pandemic in order to ensure the continuity of City government. Mr. Erwin outlined the ordinance he and Councilmember Nelson worked on together that has been presented to Council for consideration. Councilmember Nelson noted the meeting can only be for matters directly related to the emergency or to resolve the emergency or to deal with issues that have a deadline that must be dealt with by Council before the next regularly scheduled meeting. The justification has to be explained and included in the minutes. Councilmember Wright moved the ordinance, which was seconded by Councilmember Nelson. Councilmember Wri ght said it was thoughtfully worded and raises the bar for meetings to be held electronically. Councilmember Perrow said it specifically ties it to the COVID-19 pandemic or it will have to be reinstated after six months. He is a little concerned with the term “exceptional condition.” We were supposed to get through this budget before May 15 according to their previous schedule. He reset his family vacation based on that and he wonders if that constitutes an “exceptional condition.” He wondered if he would be allowed to participate electronically. He would like to offer as a motion to strike the phrase “exceptional condition” as a friendly amendment. Councilmember Nelson said his main intent was not to make it convenient and the word was compelling enough that the majority of Council would have to find it as something legitimate. Councilmember Helgeson does not think it should be up to the rest of Council to decide that someone has met some arbitrary threshold. Councilmember Nelson thinks the Councilmember would let them know ahead of time and convince at least four of them that it was a legitimate reason that he or she needed to miss. Councilmember Perrrow’s reason would be good enough for him under the circumstances. Councilmember Helgeson would not want to have to disclose a medical condition that he wants to keep private. Councilmember Wright said they could strike the word but it would still be up to the other Councilmembers to decide. Councilmember Perrow hoped they could get the budget approved by March 12 and then he could miss the March 19 th meeting. Ms. Svrcek said there is no meeting April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 12 on the 19th due to the Council election. Councilmember Perrow said he would come back for the meeting on March 26th. Councilmember Wright agreed to remove the word “exceptional” as a friendly amendment and the motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Vice Mayor Dolan, by the following recorded vote elected to hold a closed meeting to for the discussion and consideration of prospective candidates for the position of City Manager pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1) of the Code of Virginia. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Nos: 0 // The meeting was re-opened to the public. Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Perrow, and Council by the following recorded vote adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was adjourned at 7:30 p.m. Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: April 28, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 11 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: 2020 Coronavirus Emergency Supplemental Funding Program (BJA/OJP) KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $112,531 with resources from the 2020 Coronavirus Emergency Supplemental Funding Program to purchase COVID-19 related Equipment, Decontamination Services, Supplies, Overtime & Fringe Benefits expenditures. SUMMARY: The Bureau of Justice Assistance and Office of Justice Programs have awarded the City $112,531 in 2020 Coronavirus Emergency Supplemental Funding for law enforcement. This emergency funding will be utilized by the Lynchburg Police Department & Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office to purchase COVID- 19 related Equipment ($46,872), Decontamination Services ($27,525), Supplies ($19,197), Overtime ($17,590) & Fringe Benefits ($1,347) expenditures. No local matching funds are required. PRIOR ACTION(S): None FISCAL IMPACT: None, no local match is required CONTACT(S): Chief Ryan M. Zuidema, 434-455-6171 Amy Lowe, Administrative Manager, Police Department, 455-6128 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution REVIEWED BY: bms RESOLUTION: #R-20-030 BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget is amended and $112,531 is appropriated with resources from the 2020 Coronavirus Emergency Supplemental Funding Program to purchase COVID-19 related Equipment, Decontamination Services, Supplies, Overtime & Fringe Benefits expenditures for the Lynchburg Police Department & Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council 051R 1 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: May 12, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Public Hearing Regarding the Fiscal Year (FY) 2021 Allocation of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program Funds KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government _X_ Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _X_ Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Hold a public hearing and adopt a resolution approving the allocation of the Fiscal Year (FY) 2021, Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program funds and incorporating into the FY 2021 General Fund Operating Budget and Program Year (PY) 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan and FY 2021 Annual Action Plan. SUMMARY: SUMMARY: The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) funds the CDBG and HOME Programs. The City has available the following funds to use for eligible CDBG and HOME activities during the Program Year 2020 (FY 2021). CDBG AVAILABLE FUNDING/SOURCE AMOUNT HUD Allocation $714,865.00 Reprogrammed Funds _____30.00 Total CDBG Funding Available $714,895.00 HOME AVAILABLE FUNDING AMOUNT HUD Allocation $424,288.00 Reprogrammed Funds 433,416.22 Recaptured Fund 10,576.00 Total HOME Funding Available $868,280.22 The public was notified of the public hearing through a public notice advertisement published in The News and Advance on April 27 and through various sources of social media. The Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) met on April 8, 2020 and reviewed the applications that were submitted. The following lists of projects have been recommended for funding by the CDAC. 2 CDBG PROJECTS RECOMMENDED FOR FUNDING BY CDAC: City Administration $80.000.00 Tinbridge Hill Neighborhood Pedestrian Improvements-Phase 2 $417,665.25 Biggers Park Improvements & Blackwater Creek Trail Connection $110,000.00 Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) Centralized Homeless Intake Coordinator $65,000.00 LRHA Affordable Housing Resource Center $16,289.75 Parks & Recreation and Blue Ridge Mountains Council Boys Scouts of America-Scoutreach $25,940.00 Total CDBG $714,895.00 HOME PROGRAM PROJECTS RECOMMENDED FOR FUNDING BY CDAC: City Administration $42,000.00 Rush Lifetime Homes- Florida Terrace Rental Housing (CHDO) $413,140.11 Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity Homeownership Program (Habitat for Humanity) $143,140.11 Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity Knott Street Development $270,000.00 Total HOME $868,280.22 All CDBG and HOME funds will be expended in accordance with primary objectives of these programs. The City estimates that over 70 percent of the CDBG FY 2021 funding will benefit low/moderate income persons which comply with HUD regulations. All applications submitted for funding consideration are available for review in the Grants Administration Office, Second Floor, City Hall. At the conclusion of the public hearing, City Council will review the recommendations of the CDAC and decide on the projects and allocations to be included in the 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan and FY 2021 Annual Action Plan and subsequently submitted to HUD for approval. PRIOR ACTION(S): April 8, 2020: Community Development Advisory Committee Meeting FISCAL IMPACT: FY 2020 Final Entitlements: CDBG Reduction-$18,647; HOME Program Increase-$31,424 CONTACT(S): Melva Walker, Grants Manager, 455-3916; Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager, 455-3987 ATTACHMENT(S): CDAC Meeting Notes – April 8, 2020 – Attachment A CDAC Funding Recommendations Worksheet – Attachment B Summary of CDBG and HOME Applications – Attachment C REVIEWED BY: bms RESOLUTION : #R-20-031 BE IT RESOLVED that the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program FY 2021 funding allocations are hereby approved for incorporation into the FY 2021 General Fund Operating Budget and PY 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan and FY 2021 Annual Action Plan Adopted: Certified: ______________________________________ Clerk of Council 053R ATTACHMENT A Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) Meeting April 8, 2020 City Hall, Council Chambers Virtual meeting by Webex 10:00 a.m. Meeting Notes *Note: CDAC members have reviewed and approved these notes Attendance included: CDAC Members: Council Member Beau Wright, Chair; Council Member, Sterling Wilder, Vice Chair; Ms. Mandze Dyke (Daniel’s Hill Representative); Mr. John H. Hughes, III (College Hill Representative); Ms. Susan E. Murray (Garland Hill Representative); Mr. Leonard “Rad” Briley (Diamond Hill-Historic District Representative) Note: Valerie Harris- (Tinbridge Hill Representative) was unable to join the meeting. All other members joined the meeting by Webex, phone, or viewed the live meeting and wrote in their responses in the chat. City Staff: Melva Walker (Grants Manager); Eve Mergenthaler (Planning Technician);Vanessa Closs, Financial Services); Jenny Jones (Parks & Recreation Director); Charlotte Lester (Neighborhood Center Coordinator, Parks & Recreation); Kent White, (Community Development Director) Note: Staff participated in the meeting via Webex or phone Guests/Applicants: April Shepherd, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA); Collison Corner (LRHA); Sarah Quarantotto (Central Virginia Continuum of Care-CVCoC); Donna Vincent (Habitat for Humanity); Greg Tyree (Habitat for Humanity); Jeff Smith (Rush Lifetime Homes); Kenneth Lyons (Blue Ridge Mountain Boy Scouts) Note: Applicants participated in the meeting via Webex or phone 2 Ms. Walker began the meeting at 10:11 a.m. She welcomed everyone to the video conference and thanked them for their patience as we navigated through a new process. She asked that everyone mute microphones until time for them to speak. Ms. Walker explained this meeting is a public meeting for the public to view. The public is not allowed to comment at this time, but will have opportunity at the City Council public hearing currently scheduled for April 28, 2020. With the pandemic situation this may change, but notices will be published with plenty of notice for the public to participate. Ms. Walker turned the meeting over to the Committee Chair, Council Member Beau Wright. Council Member Wright welcomed everyone attending the meeting. He thanked Ms. Walker and those participating and noted this was the first CDAC meeting ever held by Webex. He thanked Ms. Walker and the City team for making today’s meeting possible. He noted that all were dedicated to making sure to get the recommendations right that will be made to City Council. CDBG and HOME Program funds don’t just drive investment in the community, but they improve lives and he is excited about what the funds can do. Council Member Wright asked the CDAC members present to introduce themselves and the neighborhood they represent. (Valerie Harris of Tinbridge Hill was unable to be present at today’s meeting; Mr. John Hughes III has connectivity issues for the meeting, but viewed the live public viewing of the meeting and submitted his responses via chat.) Ms. Walker presented an overview of the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) for Program Year 2018 (7/1/2018-6/30/19) that was submitted to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). This Report provides HUD with the accomplishments and activities that were completed with the use of the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program funds. The Powerpoint summarizing the report was included in the packets provided to CDAC for the meeting. She did not go through the Powerpoint but advised members if they had questions to please let her know Ms. Walker reviewed the role of CDAC as it pertains to the Citizen Participation Plan for CDBG and HOME Programs. She stated that CDAC’s role is to:  Review CDBG and HOME applications received by City staff;  Make project recommendations to City Council;  City Council will conduct a public hearing, review the recommendations of CDAC, and give final approval for projects to be funded; and  Public Notices are published for all public meetings. Ms. Walker noted City Council’s direction for Fiscal Year (FY) 2021 application funding is as follows:  Maximize the use of CDBG funds for Capital Improvements Projects (CIP);  Partnership with the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) for projects such as: Vacant Housing Revitalization & Rehabilitation (formerly Spot Blight Program), Rental Rehabilitation, and other housing related projects; and 3  Focus resources on targeted neighborhood(s) through partnerships with City departments and/or LRHA. Ms. Walker explained the approved goals for the Five-Year 2020-2024Consolidated Plan. This plan is for Fiscal Years 2021-2025 and Program Years 2020-2024, and the Fiscal Year 2021 Annual Action Plan. She noted that HUD operates on a Program Year basis. She noted these goals were adopted by City Council on February 25, 2020. City Council accepted the recommendations by CDAC for goals and made a few changes which she will highlight. Goals for the next five year were approved by City Council. CDAC held a meeting on January 15, 2020 to review and develop goals.  The first goal is to support initiatives to increase permanent affordable housing in the rental markets. Increase the number of owner-occupied units. Emphasis to be placed on mixed income and inclusive communities. o Ms. Walker noted this goal was revised slightly by City Council and separated out in to rental and owner occupied units.  Support the preservation of affordable housing in both the rental and sales markets, including the rehabilitation of substandard housing.  Support the improvements to public facilities and infrastructure (that will support affordable housing projects). Non-Housing Goals All Non-Housing Goals stayed the same with City Council and no changes were made.  Support the efforts for the removal and redevelopment of dilapidated and condemned structures to eliminate neighborhood deterioration, blight and blighting influences.  Support efforts for the identification and remediation of rental housing in substandard conditions.  Support neighborhood partnerships that facilitate self-sufficiency and enable families and individuals to maintain their housing, remain in their neighborhoods, and age in place.  Support efforts that align with the goals of the City’s Blueprint for Opportunity to improve the economic base, job skills, and health of the community.  Promote public services activities which support the healthy development of the City’s at- risk youth, adults, and families.  Support efforts to develop, sustain, and coordinate a comprehensive, seamless system of services for homeless citizens in order to move the homeless population toward obtaining permanent housing.  Support efforts to remove barriers to escape poverty and strengthen low-income households and families. Ms. Walker made a note about the Section 108 Loan- Bluffwalk Section 108 Loan Proceeds. She stated that City Council held a Public hearing on June 25, 2019 and appropriated $1.25 million of the Bluffwalk Loan proceeds. HUD provided a loan in the amount of $3.2 million for the 4 Bluffwalk project in 2003 and these funds were repaid to HUD by the City. Some payments were made with entitlement monies over the years because the developer was unable to make the payments at the time they were due to HUD. City Council conducted a public hearing and allocated the $1.25 million to the design of the new police headquarters to be located at 1301-1305 Kemper Street, formerly the location of the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company (GLTC). Under the HOME Program, Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) has had to cancel the Homeowner Substantial Rehabilitation Program. Over the past year they have had difficulty securing qualified contractors to complete rehabilitations. Lyn-CAG returned over $400,000 for reallocation for Fiscal Year 2021. The HOME Program for Program Year (PY) 2020 will now have an additional $433,416.22 to be allocated. Under the HOME Program- Community Housing Development Organization (CHDO) Project- A Substantial Amendment (FY 2019) was submitted for the James River Housing Project by Rush Homes, which has been cancelled. Rush Homes plans to move forward with the Florida Terrace Rental Housing Project with reallocated funds from PY 2018- $95,000 and PY 2019- $75,000. Rush Homes has submitted an application for funding this year for this project. Jeff Smith, Executive Director, will give details on this later. This project will be located at 2117 Florida Avenue and is a 48 apartment unit project for low-income housing for persons with and without disabilities and permanent supportive housing for people exiting homelessness who have disabilities. City Council approved the Substantial Amendments on February 25, 2020. Ms. Walker explained to CDAC that they will notice an adjustment to the Financial Worksheet they were provided. CDBG Program Administration was reduced to $80,000 and HOME Program Administration was increased to $42,000. This adjustment was made to better accommodate all that projects that were submitted under each program. Ms. Walker turned the meeting over to the CDAC Chair, Council Member Beau Wright. Council Member Wright explained that he will read out the application request in order and ask the agency representatives to present their application at that time. Once all applicants have presented, CDAC will discuss. Council Member Wright started with CDBG applicants. Kent White, Director of Community Development, came forward to present the application for the Tinbridge Hill Neighborhood Pedestrian Improvements Project. Mr. White stated that in 2013 CDAC appropriated funding in the Tinbridge Hill Neighborhood. City Council approved the Tinbridge Hill Plan in March 2014 and is now the sixth anniversary of the plan. The neighborhood worked hard to leverage public and private resources and CDBG funds were included. This provided for sidewalk connectivity, crosswalks, work with Parks and Recreation on a trail connection, and has renovated the Yoder Neighborhood Center just to name a few of the projects. 5 The February 2020 meeting of the Friends of Tinbridge Hill, prioritized pedestrian safety and connectivity in the neighborhood as their goal. This application supports the construction of additional sidewalks, trail widening and additional enhancements in conjunction with the Tinbridge Hill waterline replacement project. The waterline replacement project is slated to begin in Fall 2020. Unfortunately, there is not enough funds available in this cycle. Funds would be focused on the areas of 4th, Monroe, and Polk Streets. The goals of this project are consistent with HUD’s goals. Any reduction in CDBG funds would limit the project, but it would still be possible. The scope and prioritization of the improvements would change some. Jenny Jones, Director of Parks and Recreation presented the application request for $150,000 for the Biggers Park project located at 501 Fifth Street. This request includes five projects: Outdoor fitness area, park benches, way-finding signage on Fifth Street, handicapped access from Clay Street, and connection to the Blackwater Creek Trail. The outdoor fitness equipment request is a new request, but the other four are a part of the Fifth Street Master Plan. Ken Lyons, Director of Development of Blue Ridge Mountains Council Boy Scouts of America, presented the application for Scoutreach. The Soutreach program partnered with Lynchburg Parks and Recreation a few years ago with a program in Cub Scouting with outreach. The program came about in areas in the community with a difficult time recruiting and retaining adult leadership. Scouting’s answer to this was to hire a program leader to conduct meetings, in the afternoons and after school. With the funds requested, they would be able to hire a hire a part-time program leader at Neighborhood Centers in coordination with Parks and Recreation to conduct the Scouting program. Charlotte Lester, Neighborhood Centers Manager, emphasized that Parks and Recreation has a long history with partnering with scouting for many years, but due to a loss in funding, the program stalled. This funding would rekindle a valuable program and expands the world beyond the neighborhood. She appreciates the support CDAC has given the centers over the last few years. Council Member Wright asked Sarah Quarantotto and April Shepherd with Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) to come forward to present the applications on Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) and Affordable Housing Resource Center (AHRC) programs. Ms. Shepherd explained that CHIA and AHRC are the two programs applications submitted for the two positions that are housed at the Housing Authority and she oversees the funds for these programs. She introduced Sarah Quarantotto, Executive Director of Miriam’s House, which is lead agency for the Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC), who spoke for CHIA and Collison Corner, who is the Housing Navigator for the AHRC. Ms. Quarantotto stated that about five years ago, HUD required all CoCs have a single point of entry to streamline services to homeless individuals. At that time, the community came together to offer CHIA. CHIA acts as a hotline, allows for walk-ins at the Housing Authority, and can serve homeless persons transparently and determine their level of service need. The position has been able to divert households from homelessness and from households becoming homeless. 6 Mr. Corner introduced himself and stated he served in the role as the Housing Navigator for the AHRC. The Resource Center is open to the public and located at the Housing Authority. It is a centralized access point and provides support services for persons needing housing and housing resources. This year the AHRC will finalize several goals. One goal is for landlords and apartment complexes to post their vacancies. They want to streamline access to LRHA programs. They are working to reduce barriers to LRHA services, help landlords and participants understand the process. They will install tablets in the lobby for people to have a self-service place to find housing and resources. The Resource Center will begin hosting housing education meetings for landlord and tenants and will have a computer lab set up for the public to come in and look for housing in the City. In 2019, 826 people by phone, in person or through email have been helped to find housing in Lynchburg. For 2020, 220 people so far have been assisted and they look to surpass last year’s numbers. Council Member Wright asked for confirmation from Ms. Walker that the Public Service allocation cap is at $107,229.75 and we have received more requests for funding in this category. Ms. Walker confirmed this is correct. She explained the public service category cap is at 15% , which is the $107,229.75 and the current funding requests for public service are at $157,940.00. Council Member Wright invited HOME Program applicants to present, starting with Jeff Smith of Rush Homes. Mr. Smith stated he is the Executive Director for Rush Homes. The Florida Terrace project would provide 48 units on Florida Avenue near the Food Lion Shopping Center. This would serve twenty- four (24) persons with disabilities. Of that twelve (12) will serve persons exiting homelessness or disabled. Some of the units will serve low-income individuals that do not have disabilities. All of the tenants will be at 60% of LMI (low-moderate income) and most at 30%. The project will consist of three buildings. One building will consist of the office, a community room and maintenance area with the other two buildings being apartment units of twenty-four (24) units each). Mr. Smith explained that Rush Homes initially went into partnership with LRHA and reviewed ten (10) sites in the City for the James River Housing project. They chose this site near the shopping center because it was close to shopping, proximity to Campbell Avenue, and the bus stop is forty (40) feet away. Those features make it viable. James Crossing is being renovated and is half a mile down the road. This project will help the whole community. The agreement with the Housing Authority will provide some project management and about fifteen (15) vouchers. Most of the vouchers will support Permanent Supportive Housing (PSH) tenants. Mr. Smith stated that Rush asked that $170,000 be reprogrammed from the James River Housing project to Florida Terrace. In part because of the needs established from the housing study sponsored by the Housing Collaborative. It made sense to focus on this project. They currently have applications in for tax credits to support the project and will know more the end of the first week in May. This HOME funding will be a 25% match for any State HOME funding. The match will go from $800,000 to $1.3 million. They have been working on this for some time and anticipate that construction costs 7 will rise. They are concerned about the Virginia Housing Trust fund dollars. Any dollars provided by the HOME funds will be critical. Donna Vincent and Greg Tyree with Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity presented their applications. Mr. Tyree presented the application request for $125,000 for the Homeownership program that provides for down payment assistance. This funding would provide for the building of five homes with an estimated $25,000 per home for down payment assistance. Down payment assistance is necessary because they sale the homes at an appraised value with a 0% interest mortgage. The payments are based on the affordability of the families they serve. Families usually fall between 40% and 70% AMI. The assistance cushions the different between what they are selling the house for and what they can afford in the equity. This makes the family able to afford the payment. In order for a family to receive down payment assistance, they must meet three criteria. They must meet the need for housing, have the ability to pay a modest mortgage and a willingness to partner with Habitat. Partnering with Habitat includes sweat equity hours on their homes and homes of others. Mr. Tyree explained they have been doing this for about 32 years and have constructed 306 homes. Ms. Vincent presented the application for the Knott Street Development at a request of $250,000. This project is to develop a street allowing access to eleven homes. Right now, it is just a street that ends that is accessed off of Radcliff Avenue off of Fort Avenue. She explained it is a beautiful area, in a neighborhood that would enable them to have same size of the homes as built by Habitat. The $250,000 would be used to assist with the construction of the street in accordance with City code regulations. Council Member Wright asked that before discussion began on the projects if there were any presenters he missed, otherwise the committee would proceed with discussing the recommendations. Ms. Walker let CDAC know it was time for them to discuss their recommendation for funding of the projects. She will manipulate the worksheet displayed as they discuss and let them know remaining totals as they proceed. She noted one caveat for the HOME Program. There is over $433,000 to be reprogrammed due to the cancellation of the Homeowner Rehabilitation Program at Lyn-CAG. There is a total of $868,280 to allocate for HOME funds. The applications total $792,000. There is an additional $76,280.22 to put back in to the projects. The $42,000 in Administration is the maximum 10% allowed than can be taken and is concrete. Ms. Walker turned the meeting over to Council Member Wright and CDAC. Council Member Wright started with the CDBG funds and invited thoughts from the committee on the Tinbridge Hill Neighborhood Pedestrian Improvements-Phase 2 application. Council Member Wilder asked for a point of clarification with this being his first time on CDAC, that they are looking at eight projects? Ms. Walker confirmed. Council Member Wilder inquired as to how the 8 projects are separated. Ms. Walker noted the committee can work on CDBG or HOME first or can review the public service piece, before working on the other projects. Council Member Wright began with the CDBG, non-public service applications. He explained the $80,000 is set as the administrative piece and asked for thoughts and input on the Tinbridge Hill funding request. Council Member Wilder stated he had attended the Tinbridge Hill meeting in February and he wanted to thank Kent White and his staff for their support. The neighbors had a part in the discussion and he was glad to see they had solicited input from the neighbors. Ms. Murray stated she is a resident of Garland Hill. She lives one block from the trail head on Madison Street, which is included in the Biggers Park application . It takes her about six minutes on bike to get to the Tinbridge Hill trail head. She inquired if funding could be allocated to finish the Tinbridge Hill trail head because that would be a nicer area. She would like to see more funds go toward the Tinbridge Hill project and less to Biggers Park. Ms. Jones, Parks and Recreation, expressed this did make sense. The application submitted for Biggers Park was trying to accommodate what was requested and asked for in the Fifth Street Master Plan and completing those projects. It is located fairly close by and they could widen the trail and there are some other projects that are planned. The trail head was a little unsteady when the trail was first built. They did not own the property needed and the trail head was not in the optimal place. Fast forward two years and now they have that property and it could be a much nicer trail (Hollins Street/Tinbridge).The City does not own the property off Madison and would need an easement for this, and would take some doing to make it ADA acceptable. She is not opposed to moving the money to make the Hollins Street/Tinbridge Hill trail head nicer. Council Member Wright inquired if the committee recommends, is this permissible? Ms. Walker explained that as it was in the Biggers Park application it could be moved from Biggers Park to the Tinbridge Hill project . Ms. Jones noted that there are five projects in the application, but only one of them is the trail connection ($40,000). Council Member Wilder expressed he would like to keep the other projects in the application. Ms. Walker explained this could be done. Only a shortage of $22,000 and could rearrange the budget for other items. Ms. Murray noted the access to the trail head on Madison is difficult. She votes not to fund the 5th objective in the Biggers Park application. 9 Council Member Wright explained to the committee and applicants this would take the request from $150,000 to $110, 000. This would make up the full deficit moving the funds to Tinbridge Hill if needed, or some additional to Biggers Park. Ms. Jones attended the Tinbridge Hill meeting in February and noted the neighbors did want additional sidewalks and wanted more done to the trail head but positive they do want additional sidewalks. Council Member Wright asked Ms. Walker if those changes were made, what it would look like on the spreadsheet: take Biggers Park project to $110,000; assume $400,000 for the Tinbridge Hill project; showing the funds as Ms. Jones and Ms. Murray have suggested. This leave $17,665.25 to add to Tinbridge Hill. Ms. Jones stated she would be in support of this adjustment in the projects. Ms. Murray, Mr. Briley, Ms. Dyke, and Council Member Wilder were all in support of this. Mr. Hughes had connectivity issues, but was viewing the meeting and putting in comments in the chat. He supported this adjustment with the funds. Council Member Wright noted that Mr. White had sent in a message, with some difficulty connecting. Mr. White was then able to join the meeting. He stated that the Tinbridge Hill application is in partnership with Parks and Recreation and the extra funds can definitely be used. He can confirm that the trail head be raised as a priority if consistent with the neighborhood wishes. There was a consensus on the allocations for Tinbridge Hill ($417,665.25) and Biggers Park ($110,000). Ms. Walker summarized that there was a consensus among a majority of members present to allocate $417,665.25 to Tinbridge Hill and $110,000 to Biggers Park with incorporating access to the trail on Hollins Street and eliminate connection on Blackwater Creek on Madison Street. The committee then focused on the Public Service applications with an available allocation of $107,229.75. Council Member Wright invited comments on the public service projects and noted $50,710.25 to be cut. He started with the question if everyone was in favor of the $65,000 being allocated to the Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) program. Council Member Wilder expressed he was in support of this and feels it is a very important program. Ms. Dyke stated after she reviewed the application, she is 100% in support of this program. Ms. Murray said it is a hard choice to cut things, but she would agree with this. 10 For clarification, Mr. Briley inquired if the recommendation is to give $65,000 to fully fund CHIA and then to reduce from the other two public service projects. This was confirmed. Ms. Murray asked if some funds could be taken off CHIA and Affordable Housing Resource Center (AHRC) and that all are very valuable program. Ms. Shepherd, from LRHA, stated the CHIA program is mandated by HUD. They do have some funds in the AHRC program from previous years. But, if there were a cut, she would suggest it come from the AHRC program. She recommends fully funding CHIA and cutting from AHRC. Ms. Walker noted there is some funding in the AHRC from prior years. As of December 31, 2019, there is $24,684 in Program Year 2018 funds; $5,345 left in Program Year 2019; and the remaining $12,000 in Program Year 2017 has been expended since December. There is approximately $70,000 left that can be used with whatever is allocated in Program Year 2020 for FY 2021. Council Member Wright asked Ms. Shepherd if funding were reduced for AHRC, would they be able to use the prior year’s funding. Ms. Shepherd agreed. Ms. Walker confirmed with CDAC to put $65,000 on CHIA, fully fund the Scouting program at $25,940 and to put the remaining balance in AHRC at $16,289.75. Ms. Murray concurred. She felt like removing funds from the AHRC would be okay because they have sufficient funds from prior years to help cover the program. Mr. Briley, Council Member Wilder, Ms. Dyke and Council Member Wright agreed. Mr. Hughes supported this recommendation. Council Member Wright then led the committee to discuss the applications for the HOME Program and that there are additional funds to allocate, He inquired of the group if they were comfortable funding Rush and the two applications for Habitat in full. Council Member Wilder, Mr. Briley, Ms. Murray, and Ms. Dyke all agreed; Mr. Hughes wrote in his response in agreement. Council Member Wright explained there is an additional $76,280.22 to be allocated. Ms. Murray questioned about the Rehabilitation program. Ms. Walker explained they did not submit an application for this year. That program has been cancelled because Lyn-CAG have been unable to secure contractors. It cannot be funded because there was no application request submitted for it. Mr. Smith, Rush Homes, stated that he and Donna Vincent, Habitat, were amiable to splitting the additional funds 50-50. 11 Council Member Wright questioned that if the funds were split, should the portion to Habitat go toward the Knott Street Development or to the Homeownership program. Ms. Vincent expressed that if the funds were split, the Knott Street Development could use the additional funds. There are a number of trees that need to be cleared and street lamps to install that were not included in the proposal. Anything additional would help cover these additional costs. Council Member Wright asked CDAC their thoughts, that both Rush Homes and Habitat are comfortable splitting the funds 50-50. This means an additional $38,140.11 would go to Rush and $38,140.11 to Knott Street. Council Member Wilder agreed. Mr. Briley asked Ms. Vincent how much additional funds will Knott Street need that has not been requested. Ms. Vincent explained the street lamps would be an additional $9,000 and she does not have an exact price for the tree clearing. The developer suggested that about $8,500.. Mr. Briley asked if half of the amount adequately covers what Habitat would need at this point. Ms. Vincent expressed that she believed it would. She said that the $125,000 request for the Homeownership programs is a guess and they can always use money there. Mr. Briley inquired that if the $38,000 was put in Knott Street and not all used there, could it be shifted to the other program. Ms. Walker explained that money cannot be switched from one program to another if any left over. Habitat would have to come to City Council at that point to get approval for it. But, CDAC can make that kind of determination today to split the funds. Ms. Vincent said that of the little over $38,000 that would be allocated to Habitat, she would suggest $20,000 of it go to Knott Street, and the remaining $18,000 go toward Homeownership. Council Member Wright asked if CDAC had any objections to this recommendation. All members were in agreement (Mr. Hughes submitted his agreement by written response through the chat). Ms. Walker displayed this allocation on the worksheet. Council Member Wright noted of the additional $76,280.22 remaining to allocate, half would be allocated to Rush on top of the $375,000; half to Habitat with $20,000 of that going to Knott Street on top of the $250,000 allocated; and $18,140.11 going to the Homeownership program on top of the $125,000 allocated. These recommendations balance the HOME Program funds side- Florida Terrace to $413,140.11; Habitat’s Homeownership Program to $143,140.11; Habitat’s Knott Street Development to $270,000; and Program Administration to $42,000 for a total of $868,280.22. Ms. Walker reminded CDAC of the tentative schedule for the remaining meetings: 12 -City Council Public Hearing (CDAC Recommendations) & City Council Allocations- Tentative Date*-April 28th @ 7:30 p.m. -CDAC Public Meeting (Five Year Consolidated Plan, Annual Action Plan, Analysis of Impediments (AI) to Fair Housing, and revisions to the Citizen Participation Plan) – Tentative Date*- May 6th @ 7:00 p.m. (Council Chambers or video conferencing). -City Council Public Hearing on Consolidated Plan, Annual Action Plan, and AI-Tentative Date*- May 26th @ 7:30 p.m. CDAC will receive additional information about remaining meetings. She thanked them for their participation and Council Member Wright and Council Member Wilder for their patience during the preparations for this meeting. Council Member Wright asked if there were any other items before the meeting was adjourned. Ms. Murray did mention Biggers Park and meetings of the Garland Hill neighborhood. Several neighbors are upset about the benches near the Hands Up Lodge and people congregating in that area (near Madison/Harrison). Ms. Jones stated she can pass this on to Gaynelle Hart with Public Works and to Kent White, Community Development Director, as well. Mr. White noted they will take a look at this matter. Council Member Wright thanked CDAC for sharing their insights, the dedicated staff members, partner organizations, and citizens for watching. The meeting was adjourned. ATTACHMENT B ATTACHMENT B 714,895.00$ 63,643.20$ CDBG - Non-Public Service HOME Amount to Award FY 2021 607,665.25$ Amount Available City Council City Council 868,280.22$ Prior Year Amount CDAC Amount Prior Year Amount CDAC Amount FY2020 Requested Recommendation Awarded FY2020 Requested Recommendation Awarded NAME Award FY 2021 FY 2021 FY 2021 NAME Award FY 2021 FY 2021 FY 2021 City Administration 24,000.00$ 42,000.00$ 42,000.00$ City Administration 98,000.00$ 80,000.00$ 80,000.00$ Rush Lifetime Homes - Florida Terrace Rental Housing CHDO 70,000.00 375,000.00 413,140.11 City Administration - Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing 25,000.00$ -$ Habitat for Humanity - Homeownership 60,000.00 125,000.00 143,140.11 Dearington Neighborhood Plan 23,000.00 - Lyn-CAG Homeownership Substantial Rehab 200,000.00 Dearington Neighborhood Improvements 100,000.00 - Habitat for Humanity - Knott Street Development - 250,000.00 270,000.00 Fairview Heights Neighborhood Center Rehabilitation 240,000.00 - Yoder Neighborhood Center Rehabilitation 200,000.00 - Tinbridge Hill Neighborhood Pedestrian Improvements-Phase 2 400,000.00 417,665.25 Biggers Park Improvements & Blackwater Creek Trail Connection 150,000.00 110,000.00 Totals 686,000.00$ 630,000.00$ 607,665.25$ -$ Total HOME 354,000.00$ 792,000.00$ 868,280.22$ -$ Remaining Amount to Award (22,334.75)$ -$ 607,665.25$ Remaining Amount to Award 76,280.22$ -$ 868,280.22$ FY 2020 FY 2021 Difference % CDBG - Public Service 15% Allocation CDBG Amount to Award FY 2021 $ 107,229.75 Entitlement $733,512.00 $714,865.00 ($18,647.00) -2.5% City Council Reprogrammed Funds 113,301.89 30.00 (113,271.89) -100.0% Prior Year Amount CDAC Amount Program Income 2,100.00 0.00 (2,100.00) -100.0% FY2020 Requested Recommendation Awarded TOTAL $848,913.89 $714,895.00 ($134,018.89) -15.8% NAME Award FY 2021 FY 2021 FY 2021 Administration CAP $147,182.60 142,973.00 ($4,209.60) -2.9% LRHA / CVCoC -Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access $ 65,000.00 $ 65,000.00 $ 65,000.00 LRHA - Affordable Housing Resource Center 45,341.80 67,000.00 16,289.75 Parks & Rec and Blue Ridge Mountains Council Boy Scouts of Public Service CAP $110,341.80 107,229.75 ($3,112.05) -2.8% America - Scoutreach - 25,940.00 25,940.00 HOME Entitlement $392,864.00 $424,288.00 $31,424.00 8.0% Totals 110,341.80$ 157,940.00$ 107,229.75$ -$ Reprogrammed 0.00 433,416.22 433,416.22 0.0% Available 107,229.75 107,229.75$ 107,229.75$ Recaptured Funds 0.00 10,576.00 10,576.00 0.0% Balance (50,710.25)$ -$ 107,229.75$ TOTAL $392,864.00 $868,280.22 $475,416.22 121.0% Total CDBG $ 796,341.80 $ 787,940.00 $ 714,895.00 $ - Administration CAP $39,286.40 $42,428.80 $3,142.40 8.0% CHDO Required $58,929.60 $63,643.20 $4,713.60 8.0% CVCoC - Central Virginia Continuum of Care Lyn-CAG - Lynchburg Community Action Group LRHA - Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority Habitat for Humanity- Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity CDBG and HOME Allocations Worksheet 2020-2021 Total CDBG Available Fiscal Year (FY) 2021 CHDO Requirement ATTACHMENT C 1 Summary of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program Funding Requests Fiscal Year (FY) 2021 received from the U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Following is a brief summary of each of the applications received for consideration of CDBG and HOME Program funding. Entire applications are available and can be reviewed in the Grants Administration Office. The Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) notes for the recommendations are included in Attachment A. Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) Applicants City Administration (Grants Administration) FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $80,000 $80,000 Funding is requested to fully fund the personnel, operating and HUD-required training costs associated with managing the CDBG Program. Tinbridge Hill Neighborhood Pedestrian Improvements-Phase 2 (City-Department of Community Development) FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $400,000 $417,665.25 Consistent with the Growing Tinbridge Hill Neighborhood Plan there were identified pedestrian safety and connectivity as goals for the neighborhood. At their February 2020 meeting, the Friends of Tinbridge Hill (FOTH) identified new sidewalk connections and trail improvements as priorities that would further this goal. The project application supported the construction of sidewalks, trail widening and/or trailhead enhancements in conjunction with the upcoming Tinbridge Hill waterline replacement project. The waterline replacement project is slated to begin in fall 2020. Phase I pedestrian improvements have previously been constructed on Jackson Street, Hollins Street, Garland Street and McIvor Street. Remaining sidewalk priorities include sections of Monroe Street, 2nd Street, Garland Street, Polk Street, 4th Street and Floyd Street. The proposed funding request would not address all of these needs; however, prioritization will be given to sidewalk segments within and adjacent to the waterline replacement project located at Fourth, Monroe, Polk, etc. to better leverage engineering design and construction mobilization costs. However, costs to address drainage, topography and available right-of-way may require that project funds shift to address other sidewalk or trail needs in the neighborhood. The final scope would be refined with the FOTH and Tinbridge Hill Neighborhood Council. ATTACHMENT C 2 Biggers Park Improvements and Blackwater Creek Trail Connection (City-Department of Parks and Recreation) FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $150,000 $110,000 Biggers Park located in the Garland Hill Neighborhood, is situated at 501 5th Street, This neighborhood pocket park's stone wall and steps along 5th Street are the only remnants of the former Biggers School built in 1881. In 1967 the school was demolished and Biggers Neighborhood Park was built soon after on the same site. Some improvements to Biggers Park such as stabilization of the stone wall along Clay Street were recently completed. A new basketball court resurfacing is scheduled for May 2020. The project application included a request for funds to make the following improvements: 1. Outdoor Fitness Center; 2. Park benches located near the basketball courts; 3. Wayfinding sign on 5th Street; 4. Handicapped accessible entrance off Clay Street; and 5. Connection to Blackwater Creek Trail on Madison Street While some improvements have been made to the Park, the Park is in need of more upgrades. Current plans include installation of an outdoor fitness center, as well as completion of the recommendations regarding park and recreation improvements called for in the 5th Street Corridor Master Plan, amenities such as a passive seating area, wayfinding sign on 5th Street, and a handicapped-accessible entrance from Clay Street. Objective 3E of the Master Plan calls for a connection to the Blackwater Creek Trail from Madison Street. Centralized Homeless intake Coordinator - Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) and Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $65,000 $65,000 The Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC), in partnership with Lynchburg Redevelopment & Housing Authority (LRHA), applied for funding to continue supporting the position of the Homeless Intake Coordinator. HUD’s Continuum of Care program regulations require a coordinated intake process in order for a community to be eligible for federal grants to assist with homeless response programs. HUD’s vision of the coordinated entry process is coordination and management of a crisis response system’s resources that allows users to make consistent decisions from available information to efficiently and effectively connect people to interventions that will rapidly end their homelessness. This vision emphasizes that the process is not just assessment, but also about facilitating entry into the crisis response system and exit into housing. ATTACHMENT C 3 Affordable Housing Resource Center – Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $67,000 $16,289.75 Lynchburg Redevelopment & Housing Authority (LRHA) applied for funding to continue supporting the Affordable Housing Resource Center (AHRC) which has been created and is managed by LRHA. The ARHC is led by a full–time Housing Navigator and provides a centralized access point to all affordable housing resources and supportive services available in the City. This project is a collaboration of LRHA, City of Lynchburg, Lynchburg Regional Housing Collaborative and the Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC). Included in the plans for the coming project year are to finalize several goals set for the ARHC. These goals include: development of a website that will allow private landlords, local rental agencies, and apartment complexes to post their vacancies as they happen; streamlining access to LRHA housing programs to reduce barriers to LRHA services making it easier for landlords and participants to understand the process; installing kiosk/tablets in the lobby at LRHA as well as other key locations to provide an electronic option for accessing housing and other resources; continue to gather and maintain a database of resources available in the City; and hosting housing education meetings. The Resource Center is setting up a computer lab that the public may access during normal business hours to assist in their search for housing and resources. Applying for housing, finding other resources and educational opportunities related to housing issues will also be available. The Resource Center will be the premier housing resource for the City. Scoutreach (Boy Scouts of America) – Partnership with Parks and Recreation Department FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $25,940 $25,940 Boy Scouts of America plans to offer Scoutreach to youth in Lynchburg’s central city neighborhoods, by partnering with the Lynchburg Parks and Recreation Department throughout the school year, and utilizing the neighborhood centers as meeting locations. The targeted neighborhoods have many unique assets, including neighborhood centers, where programs and services are designed to meet the interests and needs of neighborhood residents. A core program, common to all neighborhood centers, is the popular after-school program for youth. The Scoutreach program pairs well with the after-school program, and provides an opportunity for school-age youth to broaden their experiences inside and beyond the neighborhood setting. Situating the Scoutreach program within neighborhood centers helps to support our families, for many of whom, transportation is a barrier. Scoutreach is the Boy Scout of America’s commitment to making sure that all young people have an opportunity to join Scouting, regardless of their circumstances, neighborhood, or ethnic background. Scoutreach meets the developmental needs of youth in urban settings. Scouting, by emphasizing ethics and moral values, addresses many of the social concerns of parents and youth in our country. Scouting prepares urban and rural youth to be leaders, to accept responsibility, and to care about principles and causes beyond their own self- interest. Our ATTACHMENT C 4 biggest asset in urban and rural neighborhoods is a well-defined program based on values, learning by doing, fun, and positive role models. The CDBG funds will be used for membership registration, staff costs for program coordinator, handbooks, travel, and program supplies. ATTACHMENT C 5 HOME Program Applicants City Administration FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $42,000 $42,000 Funding is requested to fund the personnel, operating and training costs associated with managing the HOME Program. Florida Terrace Rental Housing Development – Rush Lifetime Homes, Inc. (Rush Homes) Certified Community Housing Development Organization (CHDO) FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $375,000 $413,140.11 NOTE: The City is required to commit 15 percent of its HOME Program entitlement funds to a CHDO. Rush Homes is the only CHDO application submitted for FY 2021. This application is a continuation of the FY 2019 and FY 2020 HOME Program allocations of $165,000 to Rush Homes for the development of this project. Florida Terrace is a forty-eight (48) apartment development, which includes 32 one-bedroom apartments and 16 two-bedroom apartments featuring Universal Design, EarthCraft energy efficiency, and Energy Star features with at least eight (8) apartments featuring Section 504 accessibility. Two building will comprise the apartment portion of the development, each with 24 apartments, two floors, and an elevator. A third building will contain a community room, rental/property management office space, and a maintenance area. Building exteriors will feature substantial brick and cement board exteriors to provide an aesthetically appealing structure. At least 50% of tenant families will have disabilities; among the 50% Florida Terrace will set aside at least eight units for tenant families requiring Permanent Supportive Housing (PSH) and five units for tenants with developmental disabilities. Rush Homes will contract with a local Permanent Supportive Housing service provider for appropriate case management services for tenants requiring PSH. Homeownership Program - Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $125,000 $143,140.11 Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) develops homeownership opportunities for low-income families that would not qualify or be able to afford homeownership through conventional bank mortgages. GLHFH builds good quality, moderately appointed homes and sells them to qualified applicants. The target population for the program is families whose income falls in the range of 40% to 70% of HUD’s Area Median Income (AMI), adjusted for size of family. To qualify, families must demonstrate need (residing in poor, unsafe, unhealthy, and/or unaffordable housing); they must have the ability to pay a no -interest mortgage (must have a steady income and low debt to income ratio); and must be willing to partner with GLHFH (provide sweat equity, participate in train ing, and prepare for the responsibilities of homeownership). ATTACHMENT C 6 GLHFH solicits funding, materials, and volunteer labor from the community and is thereby allowing the organization the ability to maintain low construction costs. GLHFH is therefore able to se ll the home to the qualified family with a no -interest mortgage loan. Families have to provide 200 (single applicant) to 300 (multiple applicants) hours of labor, referred to as “sweat equity,” to the project. The mortgagees must attend GLHFH’s course designed to prepare them for homeownership. The series of classes provide education about financial literacy, budgeting, home maintenance, taxes and insurance, predatory lending, and loss mitigation options, and include the required training facilitated by a HUD Certified Housing Counselor. Currently this is provided by Denise Crews through a Memorandum of Understanding with LYNCAG. GLHFH will use HOME funds to pay for down -payment assistance which will reduce the principal balance so that the family can afford the monthly mortgage payments. GLHFH defines “payment affordability” as not more than 30% of monthly income, though we strive for 25% when possible as to make our homes affordable for families in the lower tiers of HUD AMI income. Knott Street Development - Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) FY 2021 Request CDAC Recommendation $250,000 $270,000 The Knott Street Development project serves to create eleven buildable lots upon which GLHFH can construct modestly appointed homes and sell to low-income families who qualify for its homeownership program. Currently, GLHFH is struggling to acquire buildable properties in Lynchburg. Its property inventory has been consumed by steady home construction. The Site Selections Committee of the board of directors has been challenged by the lack of availability in its search for properties to acquire. Two realtors diligently monitor the real estate agents property listings (known as MLS) and one board member has brought several large parcels to the group for consideration; the costs are prohibitive unless GLHFH has a special capital campaign. Without affordable buildable properties, GLHFH cannot proceed with construction, even though the house construction funding may already be in hand. The home that is currently under construction was delayed due to the time it took to negotiate the purchase of a suitable vacant residential property. Currently there are three more families in the queue for homeownership; one of them has a lot assigned for their home. The others await some good news that desirable properties will be acquired and available when Habitat is ready to start their house. GLHFH owns four tax parcels on Knott Street but does not have the capital to fund their development into 11 separate lots. HOME funding for the road and infrastructure improvements will enable GLHFH to put its acquired house-specific sponsorship funds toward the construction costs of eleven homes. City staff has acknowledged that these lots can be developed by-right. In other words, with HOME funding availability, GLHFH can quickly proceed to engage a contractor to build the street and improvements. 1 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: May 12, 2020 AGENDA ITEM #: 9 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Public Hearing and Adoption of the Amended Citizen Participation Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government _X_ Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _X_ Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Conduct a public hearing to receive comments regarding the proposed amendments to the Citizen Participation Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Investment Partnerships Act (HOME Program) and adopt a resolution approving the Plan. SUMMARY: The U. S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) requires each entitlement city that receives CDBG and HOME Program funds to have a Citizen Participation Plan. The purpose of the Citizen Participation Plan is to provide policies and procedures for citizen participation with respect to activities funded under the CDBG and HOME Program from HUD. With the recent COVID-19 emergency, HUD has provided the availability of waivers of certain regulatory requirements associated with the CDBG and HOME Program to prevent the spread of COVID-19 and to facilitate assistance to eligible communities and households economically impacted by COVID-19. One waiver is related to the 30-day public comment period for substantial amendments to approved Annual Action Plans. HUD has provided a waiver that reduces the 30-day minimum for the required public comment period for Consolidated Plans, Annual Action Plan, and Substantial Amendments to no fewer than 5 days. The second waiver is related to citizen participation where public places may be closed to the public or in-person participation may not be feasible or large gatherings may be considered a public health risk, the City may select to conduct public hearings and meetings virtually via conference call or live web-streaming with the ability to ask questions and provide comment in real time where public comment is required to be heard. In order for the City to implement these waivers now for the COVID-19 emergency and the receipt of the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act) funds allocated to the City from HUD; and for future local, state or federally declared disaster or emergency the current Citizen Participation Plan must be updated. The current Citizen Participation Plan was updated by City Council on March 8, 2011. City staff recommends that revisions to the Plan be made so that it will better align the contents of the Plan with HUD requirements for emergencies and to expand the public outreach within the Consolidated Plan process. The following are the alternatives that are included in the update of the Plan and may be instituted by the City:  The length of the public comment and display period for the Consolidated Plan or Annual Action Plan and Substantial Amendments will be consistent with HUD’s requirements.  Draft documents for public comment and review will be made available on the City’s website at https://www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration. Copies of the draft documents will be mailed or e- mailed upon request, if possible.  Public meetings may be held as virtual meetings using local cable access television or other online platforms for public viewing with the option for real-time questions to be presented.  The City may opt to hold one public hearing during the Consolidated Plan/Annual Plan process and its second required public hearing during the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) process for the same program year.  The City may opt to cancel the Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) public meeting or hold a conference call if a public meeting is not feasible. 2 The following list of agencies and individuals will be expanded to include and consult with during the Consolidated Plan preparation process:  The City will identify and involve broadband internet service providers and organizations engaged in narrowing the digital divide.  The City will identify and involve agencies whose primary responsibilities include the management of flood prone areas, public land or water resources.  The City will involve emergency management agencies. A public notice was placed in The News and Advance on Tuesday, April 28 and through social media. For reference, the attached draft Plan has the recommended changes highlighted. PRIOR ACTION(S): None FISCAL IMPACT: None CONTACT(S): Melva Walker, Grants Manager, 455-3916; Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager, 455-3987 ATTACHMENT(S): Proposed Citizen Participation Plan REVIEWED BY: bms RESOLUTION: #R-20-032 BE IT RESOLVED that the Lynchburg City Council hereby adopts the Citizen Participation Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program dated April 2, 2020. Adopted: Certified: ______________________________________ Clerk of Council 054R CCCiiitttyyy ooofff LLLyyynnnccchhhbbbuuurrrggg,,, VVViiirrrgggiiinnniiiaaa Citizen Participation Plan for the Community Development Block Grant and HOME Programs Prepared by the Grants Administration Office 900 Church Street Lynchburg, Virginia 24504 (434) 455-3900 The proposed amendments to the City’s Citizen Participation Plan are underlined and highlighted in yellow. April 2020 Page 1 April 2, 2020 Table of Contents Page Number INTRODUCTION 2 CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE 2 CITIZEN PARTICIPATION PLAN Encouragement and Methods of Citizen Participation 3 RESPONSIBILITIES AND OBLIGATIONS Assignments 4 Notification Process 4 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE (CDAC) Membership and Composition 6 Terms 6 Officers 6 Meetings 6 Quorum 6 Rules of Procedure 7 Citywide Citizen Participation Program 7 IN THE EVENT OF AN EMERGENCY 7 REQUIRED SUBMISSIONS Annual Action Plan 7 Consolidated Plan 9 Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 11 AMENDMENT PROCESS 12 ACCESS TO RECORDS 13 TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE 13 COMPLAINT PROCESS 13 APPENDIX A – Definitions 14 APPENDIX B – Description of CDBG and HOME Programs 15 APPENDIX C - Map of CDBG target areas 19 Page 2 April 2, 2020 CITIZEN PARTICIPATION PLAN City of Lynchburg, Virginia INTRODUCTION This Citizen Participation Plan was prepared in accordance with Section 104(a) of the Housing and Community Development Act of 1974, as amended. The 24 CFR 91.105 federal regulations outline the “citizen participation” requirements. This document has been developed in order for the City of Lynchburg, Virginia to be in compliance with the requirements of the regulations. The Plan sets forth the City’s policies and procedures by which it encourages local citizens to participate and comment on the federally funded Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program. The provisions concerning citizen involvement in implementing and assessing the CDBG and HOME Program apply to all activities that are ongoing, as well as to all future activities. This Plan shall remain in effect until all activities are completed, or until this Plan is superseded by a new Plan. In accordance with the City of Lynchburg’s mission of responsive, effective local government and vision principles that include engaging the community, the City will follow the Citizen Participation Plan detailed in this document. This Plan will help the City to determine and prioritize the needs of neighborhoods and communities, administer programs intended to address those needs, and involve the public in the Consolidated Plan, Annual Action Plan and Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) process. CERTIFICATION OF COMPLIANCE As a part of the City’s submission of its Five-Year Consolidated Plan, and any amendments thereto, the City will submit certification to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) that the City is following an approved Citizen Participation Plan, which: 1. Provides for and encourages citizen participation with particular emphasis on participation by persons of low and moderate income who are residents of slum and blighted areas and of areas in which funds are proposed to be used; 2. Provides for participation by residents in low and moderate income neighborhoods or targeted revitalization areas as defined by the City; 3. Provides for and encourages citizen participation of residents of public and assisted housing developments, as well as providing information to the housing agency about Consolidated Plan activities related to its development; 4. Provides for and encourages citizen participation of persons with disabilities as well as provides a copy of the Citizen Participation Plan in a format accessible to persons with disabilities, upon request; 5. Provides for and encourages citizen participation of all of the City of Lynchburg citizens, including minorities and non-English speaking persons, and identifies how the needs of non-English speaking residents will be met in the case of public hearings where a significant number of non-English speaking residents can be reasonably expected to participate; Page 3 April 2, 2020 6. Provides citizens with reasonable and timely notification and access to local meetings, information, and records relating to the City’s proposed and actual use of federal CDBG and HOME funds; 7. Provides for technical assistance to groups/organizations representative of persons of low and moderate income that request such assistance in developing proposals, with the level and type of assistance to be determined by the City; 8. Provides for public hearings to obtain citizen views, and to respond to proposals and questions at all stages of the community development program process, including at least the development of needs, the review of proposed activities, and the review of the programs annual performance. The hearings shall be held after adequate notice, at times and locations convenient to potential or actual beneficiaries, and with accommodations for the disabled; and 9. Provides for timely written response to written complaints and grievances where applicable. CITIZEN PARTICIPATION PLAN The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development requires the City of Lynchburg to have and follow a Citizen Participation Plan as a condition of receiving federal funds. This Plan contains the City’s policies and procedures for involving the community in: § the development of the Annual Action Plan and the Five-Year Consolidated Plan; § the review of the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report; and § the use of Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME program funds. Included in this Citizen Participation Plan are policies and procedures for amending these documents and local programs. The Citizen Participation Plan will apply to the Section 108 loan program and other HUD programs that would require citizen participation. (See Appendix A for a definition of the Annual Action Plan, Consolidated Plan and CAPER and Appendix B for a description of the CDBG and HOME Program). This Plan was prepared by the Grants Administration Office, which is the lead entity for the administration of the CDBG and HOME Program for the City of Lynchburg. Encouragement and Methods of Citizen Participation Participation by residents in low and moderate income neighborhoods, as well as minorities, non-English speaking persons, and persons with mobile, visual and hearing disabilities is encouraged throughout the development of the Consolidated Plan, Annual Action Plan, the CAPER, and any amendments to these Plans. Residents of public and housing developments are also encouraged to participate. Citizens are encouraged to participate in the process via public input through the Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC), and City Council. The City and HUD recognize community input as an important component in identifying high priority needs in the community and ensuring that CDBG and HOME funds are used for activities that address those issues and concerns. These groups include public and private entities, both non-profit and for-profit, particularly those whose purpose relates to housing, homelessness, neighborhoods, community development and economic development; Page 4 April 2, 2020 Prior to the annual review of the Five Year Consolidated Plan Goals, City staff will conduct an informal conversation with citizens to hear comments and determine if the Goals continue to be meaningful and effective. In addition, to expand and broaden citizen participation, the City will also post public notices on the City’s web site (www.lynchburgva.gov/grants), at community centers and other neighborhood anchors (i.e. schools, neighborhood health centers, and public housing agencies/complexes). City staff will coordinate these efforts through the City’s Communications and Marketing Department. RESPONSIBILITIES AND OBLIGATIONS This section of the Citizen Participation Plan provides guidance to the various stakeholders in the activities required to develop and implement the Consolidated Plan, Annual Action Plan and the CAPER. These guidelines are provided to be inclusive and protect the fairness and integrity of the Community Development Block Grant and HOME Programs. They are not intended, in any way, to exclude or limit access to the process. Assignments The City of Lynchburg Citizen Participation Plan describes the roles of the City Council, Community Development Advisory Committee, City staff and others involved in developing and evaluating progress toward implementation of the Consolidated Plan and Annual Action Plan. The Lynchburg City Council serves as the body of elected community-wide representatives responsible for addressing policy issues related to the Consolidated Plan and Annual Action Plan. The City Council gives direction to City staff as to how to proceed in assessing Lynchburg’s housing and community development needs and a strategy to address the needs identified. It must approve the Consolidated Plan and the Annual Action Plan prior to submission to HUD. The City Council must also comment and approve revisions to the Citizen Participation Plan and amendments to the Consolidated Plan. City Council will appoint a Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC). The CDAC will make recommendations to City Council for funding activities and programs in the Annual Action Plan for the CDBG and HOME Program and generally to act in an advisory capacity to City Council with reference to the programs and related project activities. (A detailed description of the CDAC is provided on Page 6 of this document). City staff will facilitate the process by assisting City Council and the CDAC in meeting the City’s obligations and responsibilities as an entitlement City for the CDBG and HOME Program. This will include preparing and submitting the required reports and documents to HUD and providing other support as required. Notification Process It is the policy of the City of Lynchburg to give citizens timely notice of local meetings and reasonable and timely access to local meetings, information, performance reports, and records relating to the City’s proposed and actual use of CDBG and HOME Program funds. Page 5 April 2, 2020 All meetings will be published as a legal advertisement in the local paper at least 15 days in advance of the public hearing date. Those meetings requiring more than 15 days notice in advance, will meet the required advance notice timeline. The published information will include: § Description of the activity; § What entity is conducting the meeting; § Amount of source of funds; § Where and how information may be obtained; § The date, time and location of the public meetings(s); § Timeframe for the public to submit public comments; § How and in what format comments will be accepted; and § Contact person for additional information. Public notices related to proposed funding allocations for the Annual Action Plan will include: a statement of program objectives; amount of grant funds and program income anticipated; range of activities that may be undertaken; estimated amount of grant funds and program income proposed to be used for activities that will benefit low and moderate income persons; any proposed activities likely to result in displacement; and the City’s plan for minimizing displacement. Documents that require a Public Comment period will be available for review at the following locations: § Grants Administration Division, Second Floor, City Hall, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, Virginia 24504; § Lynchburg Public Library, 2311 Memorial Avenue, Lynchburg, Virginia and other branches of the Library that may be in operation; and § Grants Administration website at www.lynchburgva.gov/grants. The City wants to ensure that all people are able to participate in public meetings. Therefore, the City will make reasonable efforts to provide translators, upon request, to help non-English speaking persons at public hearings, working sessions and public meetings. Likewise, the City will make reasonable efforts to provide special accommodations for persons with disabilities so they can participate. The City will schedule meetings in locations that are accessible and at times that are convenient for the community. Persons needing special accommodations or translators should make their requests one week before the meeting so that the City can assure that the special needs are met. These requests should be made to the Grants Administration Office at (434) 455-3916. Page 6 April 2, 2020 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ADVISORY COMMITTEE (CDAC) Membership and Composition: The CDAC shall consist of seven (7) members. The composition of the Committee shall be as follows: 1. a. Members: Five (5) members shall be residents of predominately low and moderate income neighborhoods, and/or other slum and blighted areas of the City. No more than one representative from a single neighborhood shall be allowed to serve at a time. These persons may or may not be current members of neighborhood organizations. Two (2) members shall be current members of the Lynchburg City Council. b. Terms: All members will be appointed annually by City Council for a period of one year. No person may serve for more than four consecutive years. 2. Objectives: CDAC will review CDBG and HOME Program applications and will make recommendations to City Council regarding proposed Annual Action Plan projects. 3. Officers: The officers of the CDAC shall consist of a Chair and Vice-Chair. The Chair and Vice-Chair shall be members of City Council and selected annually by City Council. Chair: The Chair shall preside at all meetings of the Committee. Except as otherwise authorized by resolution of the Committee, the Chair shall sign all official documents and other instruments to be executed by the Committee. Vice-Chair: In the absence or incapacity of the Chair, the Vice-Chair shall preside at all meetings of the Committee, and may perform such other duties as may be required by the Chair. Recording Secretary: The Recording Secretary shall keep the records of the Committee, act as Secretary to all meetings of the Committee, record all votes and shall keep a record of the proceedings of the Committee. The Grants Manager, or his/her designee, shall act as Recording Secretary. The Recording Secretary shall not be a member, and will have no voting power; however, he or she may participate in discussions, and provide such information as requested by the Committee. 4. Meetings: a. Regular Meetings. The regular meetings of the Committee will be to review the CDBG and HOME Program applications and to make funding recommendations to City Council. These meetings will be open to the public. The agenda for any regular or other public Advisory Committee meeting will be provided to all Committee members in writing five (5) days before the meeting. Meeting dates and times shall be determined by consent of Committee members. b. Special Meetings. The Chairman may, when it is deemed necessary and expedient, and shall, by written request to the members of the Committee, call a special meeting of the Committee for the purpose of transacting any business designated in the call. No business shall be considered other than as designated in the call. 5. Quorum: At all meetings of the Committee, a majority of the total membership shall constitute a quorum for the purpose of transacting business. Page 7 April 2, 2020 6. Rules of Procedure: The Committee will operate under “Roberts Rules of Order”, as revised. The Community Development Director and Grants Administration staff will provide technical assistance and support to the CDAC. This support includes notice of meetings, provision of meeting space, minutes, interpretation of HUD policies and requirements, and program status reports. Community Development staff may also prepare letters, reports, responses and other documents for the Committee, as requested, and shall attend all CDAC meetings and hearings. 7. Citywide Citizen Participation Program: A Citywide Citizen Participation Program, designed to encourage a broader range of membership on the City's boards and commissions, was initially approved by City Council in July, 1978. Persons' names received through the Citywide Citizen Participation Program who are interested in serving on the Community Development Advisory Committee will be submitted to City Council for consideration for annual appointments and as vacancies occur. IN THE EVENT OF AN EMERGENCY In the event of a local, state or federally declared disaster or emergency where public places may be closed to the public or in-person participation may not be feasible or large gatherings may be considered a public health risk, the City may opt to conduct public hearings and meetings virtually via conference call or live web-streaming with the ability to ask questions and provide comment in real time where public comment is required to be heard. Accommodations will be made for persons with disabilities and non-English speaking persons upon request. Documents for public review will be shared via the City’s website. This provision shall apply to all documents covered by this Plan. In the event of an emergency, the following alternatives may be instituted by the City: 1. The length of the public comment and display period for the Consolidated Plan or Annual Action Plan and Substantial Amendments will be consistent with HUD’s requirements. 2. Draft documents for public comment and review will be made available on the City’s website at https://www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration. Copies of the draft documents will be mailed or e-mailed upon request, if possible. 3. Public meetings may be held as virtual meetings using local cable access television or other online platforms for public viewing with the option for real-time questions to be presented. 4. The City may opt to hold one public hearing during the Consolidated Plan/Annual Plan process and its second required public hearing during the CAPER process for the same program year. 5. The City may opt to cancel the Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) public meeting or hold a conference call if a public meeting is not feasible. REQUIRED SUBMISSIONS Although both the Five-Year Consolidated Plan and the Annual Action Plan seek community involvement on many levels, the involvement levels differ for the two plans. Efforts to involve local citizens, non-profit entities and other interested stakeholders, is more intensive during the Five-Year Consolidated Plan preparation process, than in the Annual Action Plan process. The purpose of the Five-Year Plan is to identify needs and develop a multi-year strategy to address those needs. The primary purpose of the Annual Action Plan is to identify specific activities to be funded or actions to be taken Page 8 April 2, 2020 during a particular fiscal year to address needs that were identified in the Five-Year Consolidated Plan. Therefore, the citizen involvement process for each plan is described separately below. Annual Action Plan At the beginning of the Annual Action Plan process City Council will conduct a public hearing to receive citizen input regarding the Citywide community development and housing needs and the review of the approved Consolidated Plan goals. A notice of this meeting will be published in the local newspaper at least 15 days prior to the meeting. In addition, at the beginning of the Annual Action Plan process, City staff will prepare an Application for Funding that describes the City’s funding application processes. The Application for Funding will include the objectives and eligible uses of the CDBG and HOME Program funds and the amount of funds expected to be received by the City, including program income. This document will also provide a tentative time schedule that the City is expected to follow in the preparation of the Plan. Local Community Involvement: The City will make every effort to involve the community, especially low and moderate income persons and those who live in areas eligible for CDBG and/or HOME Program funds, in the annual planning and funding process. (See Appendix C for a map of eligible areas). For the community as a whole, the City will publish a public notice in the local newspaper that the City is starting the Annual Action Plan process and the acceptance of funding application requests. This notice will include information regarding the application process. The City’s Grants Administration Office website (www.lynchburgva.gov/grants) will also contain information about the City’s application process, application, and the time schedule. Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) meeting: The CDAC will be responsible for reviewing and making recommendations on the funding applications described in the Annual Action Plan. The CDAC will conduct at least one meeting at the onset of the planning process for the Annual Action Plan. The CDAC will conduct a meeting to review Annual Action Plan funding requests for the CDBG and HOME Program. A notice of this meeting will be published in the local newspaper at least 15 days prior to the meeting. If needed, the CDAC will conduct a second meeting to review applications, prior to making recommendations to the City Council. At the discretion of the CDAC, entities with eligible applications, including the City, may be invited to present their projects at the CDAC meeting and to answer questions. The CDAC may also at its discretion, seek information and clarity from City staff. At the conclusion of the CDAC process, City staff will prepare a Council report with CDAC’s funding recommendations for City Council consideration and adoption. The CDAC recommendations will be included in the final adopted Annual Action Plan for information. City Council Public Hearings: The CDAC funding recommendations for the CDBG and HOME Program activities for the Annual Action Plan will be submitted to City Council. City Council will hold at least one public hearing on the Annual Action Plan to obtain citizen input on housing and community development needs and proposed Annual Action Plan activities; and allow CDBG and HOME Program applicants to present their funding requests. This public hearing will be advertised in the local newspaper at least 15 days prior to the hearing. Thirty-Day (30-day) Public Review Period: City staff will prepare a draft Annual Action Plan which will include the projects and programs recommended for funding with CDBG and HOME funds. City staff will then publish a 30-day legal notice in the local newspaper that the draft Annual Action Plan is available for public review and written comment. Any written comments must be submitted to the Grants Administration Office prior to the end of the 30-day review period. During the review period, the draft Page 9 April 2, 2020 Annual Action Plan will be available for review at the Grants Administration Office, the Lynchburg Public Library, and the City of Lynchburg website (www.lynchburgva.gov/grants). City Council Adoption: At the conclusion of the 30-day public review period, City Council will conduct a public hearing for the adoption of the Annual Action Plan. This public hearing will be advertised in the local newspaper at least 15 days prior to the hearing. After adoption, the City will attach to the Annual Action Plan, a summary of any written or oral comments received during the public review period and the public hearings. If the City does not incorporate a recommendation received from the public, the City will attach the reasons why that recommendation was not included when the Annual Action Plan is sent to HUD. City staff will send the Annual Action Plan to HUD for review and approval. HUD Review Period: The HUD approval process takes 45 calendar days. If the Plan has included all of the required sections and has gone through the required public comment and review, HUD approval is considered routine. The City may incur costs at the beginning of the program year which starts on July 1st, but may not draw down any funds until HUD has completed its 45 day review period and a grant agreement has been fully executed with HUD. Consolidated Plan As stated earlier, the City is required to prepare a multi-year Consolidated Plan. Consolidated Plans are usually prepared for a three to five year period. The City of Lynchburg has traditionally prepared a Five-Year Consolidated Plan. The purpose of the Consolidated Plan is to identify the needs of lower income persons, establish funding priorities and develop a multi-year strategy to address those needs. The Annual Action Plan must be consistent with the Consolidated Plan. Local Community Involvement: The City will make every effort to involve the community, particularly low to moderate income persons and those living in areas eligible for CDBG funds, during the preparation of the Consolidated Plan. Community involvement will be at the planning and the funding processes and will be within the reasonable limits of staff time and cost considerations. This involvement will include people and groups that participate in the preparation of the Annual Action Plan. In addition to those traditionally included in the preparation of the Annual Action Plan, the City will seek input from other groups that might not be eligible for funding, particularly housing industry representatives, such as lenders and real estate professionals. In that the Consolidated Plan is concerned with identifying Citywide needs and trends, the City will seek information, data and input from these groups to assist the City decision makers in identifying and prioritizing needs and developing strategies in addressing those needs. The City will use the following procedure in developing the list of agencies and individuals that the City will consult with during the Consolidated Plan preparation process: § The City will identify all agencies and individuals that have applied for HUD funds from the City since the previous Consolidated Plan was prepared. § The City will identify and involve nonprofit and governmental agencies that might have useful

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.