City Council Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of May 5, 2020 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Please bring:
Proposed FY 2021 Budget Document
CITY COUNCIL MEETING
MAY 5, 2020
4:00 – 6:00 P.M.
COUNCIL CHAMBER
CITY HALL
AGENDA
1. Continued Discussion regarding the FY 2021 Proposed Budget
Presentation and Discussion Regarding the Future Financial and Operating
Structure of Refuse Collection – Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager and Gaynelle
Hart, Director of Public Works
Continued discussion regarding Balancing the FY 2021 Operating Budget (aka
“The List”)
2. Update on City Actions regarding COVID-19
3. Roll Call
4. Consideration of a closed meeting for the discussion and consideration of prospective
candidates for the position of City Manager pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A.)(1) of the Code of
Virginia.
Decisions Regarding the
Future Financial and
Operating Structure of
Refuse Collection
City Council Work Session
May 5, 2020
Purpose and Outline
• Purpose: Discuss the future financial and
operating structure for refuse collection
• Outline:
– Council-approved changes to the refuse program
– Remaining decision points and alternatives
– Revised Timeline
2
Prior Council Decisions
• Transition to monthly billing structure (but
not necessarily the proposed new rate),
beginning January 1, 2021
• Bulk and Brush Schedule
• Continuation of multiple cart sizes
• Continuation of six recycling centers, no
curbside recycling at this time
• Remove exceptions to billing (SNAP, Tax
Relief, Tyreeanna/Pleasant Valley)
3
Remaining Council Decisions
• Refuse collection fee structure
• Addition of one Bulk and Brush Education and
Enforcement FTE
• Revisions to the Refuse Ordinance (tentatively
scheduled for May 12, 2020)
4
Refuse Collection Fee
• Original staff recommendation is $15.02 per month per trash
cart for all sizes
– This fee rate would be in effect for 18 months (January 1,
2021 – June 30, 2022)
– If a household desires/needs multiple cans, the fee
multiplies by the number of trash carts – the more you
throw away, the more you pay
• Present rate is $9.17 for the larger cart ($110/12 – 64 gallon
cart)
• At this rate, the service still requires a $1.67 million subsidy
from the General Fund
5
Additional Options and Revised Staff
Recommendation
• Given economic changes due to COVID19,
staff has developed additional options and a
revised staff recommendation for City
Council’s consideration
6
Options and Revised Staff
Recommendation
Option A Option B Option C
Option Title Original Staff
recommendation
Revised Staff
Recommendation
Status Quo – Annual
Decals
Fee $15.02/month on utility
bill
$9.17/month on
utility bill
$55 or $110/year
Timeframe Begin Jan 1, 2021, fee
good for 18 months
Beginning Oct 1,
2020, will require
additional fee
increase in FY 2022
Decals must be
purchased by
September 30, 2020;
would require
additional fee increase
in FY 2022
FY 2021
Financial
Impact
$0.00 Creates a $140,415
deficit
Creates a $262,644
deficit
Cons Increase in fee Does not allow for an
appropriate
inventory
No progress on
improving Refuse
situation 7
Options and Revised Staff
Recommendation
Option A Option B Option C
Option Title Original Staff
recommendation
Revised Staff
Recommendation
Status Quo – Annual
Decals
Fee $15.02/month on utility
bill
$9.17/month on
utility bill
$55 or $110/year
Timeframe Begin Jan 1, 2021, fee
good for 18 months
Beginning Oct 1,
2020, will require
additional fee
increase in FY 2022
Decals must be
purchased by
September 30, 2020;
would require
additional fee increase
in FY 2022
FY 2021
Financial
Impact
$0.00 Creates a $140,415
deficit
Creates a $262,644
deficit
Cons Increase in fee Does not allow for an
appropriate
inventory
No progress on
improving Refuse
situation 8
Looking Forward
• If Option B (revised staff recommendation) is
adopted in FY 2021 we will
– Begin monthly billing
– Complete the trash cart inventory
– Update accounts with the correct number of trash
carts per account
• In Fiscal Year 2022, we recommend:
– Beginning the slow process towards revenue self-
sufficiency
9
Bulk and Brush Education and
Enforcement Employee
• The present condition of brush and bulk
collections is not acceptable to Council and
projects a negative image for the City
– Lack of structure leads to excessive and
unpredictable set outs, primarily with bulk items
– Building a system that everyone can understand
will allow us to continue to provide service, while
cleaning up our community
• This position is critical to solving this issue
10
11
12
13
14
Bulk and Brush Education and
Enforcement Employee Role
• This employee’s role is the following:
– First, provide education to residents regarding
bulk and brush collection system rules
– Inspect properties throughout the City to ensure
compliance with the Solid Waste Ordinance
requirements
– When necessary, enforce the provisions of the
Solid Waste Ordinance to ensure compliance and
the cleanliness of the City
15
Bulk and Brush Education
and Enforcement Position
• Position cost $49,740 for salary, benefits, and
uniforms, etc. (Item 21 on “The List”)
• Addressing brush and bulk issue is both a logistical
and a regulatory challenge
– Public Works is establishing new collection procedures
that it will communicate, but not enforcing the rules will
lead us to the same condition we are in
– Doing one without the other will not work
• Absolutely critical to the improvement of our bulk
and brush collections
16
Bulk and Brush Education and
Enforcement Employee
• The Bulk and Brush Education and Enforcement
employee will be accountable for the improvement
of the bulk and brush conditions through:
– Documentation all citizen education contacts
– Tracking of violations and resolutions
• Program will be evaluated through
– Spot checks by department leadership
– Reduction in bulk and brush complaints
– Number of Complaints from Council members
17
Timeline
• May 5, 2020 – Council decision on refuse
collection structure and review recommended
changes to Solid Waste Ordinance
• May 2020 to September 2020 – Execute
Communications plan
• October 1, 2020 – New billing, rate, and brush
and bulk procedures go into effect
18
• Questions, comments, or concerns
19
Appendix A
20
Review of Prior Discussions
• Public Works Solid Waste Task Force Report - July 10,
2018 City Council Work Session
• Solid Waste System Evaluation - November 12, 2019
City Council Regular Meeting
– City Council asked staff to get additional feedback from the
community and return with recommendations.
• February 11, 2020 – Further Council discussion and
various decisions (reviewed later in this presentation)
• March 10, 2020 – Council decided to eliminate
exemption for Tyreeanna/Pleasant Valley refuse
collections fees 21
Appendix B
22
First Cities Benchmark
CITY
POPULATION
2019
BILLING METHOD
ANNUALIZED FEE
MONTHLY
EQUIVALENT*
CURBSIDE RECYCLING
by LOCALITY
Lynchburg
(current)
82,126 32 Gallon Bag and
32 & 64 Gallon Decals for Carts
$2.00/$55/$110 $2.00/$4.58/$9.17 No
Lynchburg
(proposed)
82,126 32 Gallon Bag and
32 & 64 Gallon Decals for Carts
$2.00/ $180.24 $2.00/$15.02 No
Danville 40,693 Monthly Fee Utility Bill $181-$200 $15.08 - $16.67 Yes
Hampton 134,313 Monthly Fee Utility Bill $300 $25.00 Yes
Newport News 178,626 Monthly Fee Utility Bill $293.28-$366.60 $24.44 - $30.55 Yes
Staunton 24,453 Monthly Fee Utility Bill $181-200 $15.08 - $16.67 Yes
Norfolk 244,076 Bi-monthly Fee Utility Bill $324.12 $27.01 Yes
Charlottesville 48,117 13 & 32 Gallon Tags $1.05/$2.10 and
$94.50/$283.50
$1.05 / $2.10 and
$7.88/$23.63
Yes
*for localities with other than monthly billing, the equivalent monthly rates have been shown
23
Other Localities Benchmark
CITY
POPULATION
2019
BILLING METHOD
ANNUALIZED FEE MONTHLY EQUIVALENT* CURBSIDE RECYCLING by
LOCALITY
Lynchburg
(current)
82,126 32 Gallon Bag and
32 & 64 Gallon Decals for
Carts
$2.00 per bag
/$55/$110
$2.00 per bag/$4.58/$9.17 No
Lynchburg
(proposed)
82,126 32 Gallon Bag and
32 & 64 Gallon Decals for
Carts
$2.00 per bag/
$180.24
$2.00 per bag/ $15.02 flat
fee
No
Roanoke 99,920 Real Estate Bill $96 Single
$192 Multi-Dwelling
$144 Business
$8.00 Single
$16.00 Multi-Dwelling
$12.00 Business
Yes
Blacksburg 44,678 Individual Solid Waste Bill $281.76 $23.48 Yes
Town of
Amherst
2,218 Water/Utility Bill $81 - $100 $6.75-$8.33 Yes
Town of
Bedford
6,585 Electric Bill $216.00 $18.00 No
Bedford
County
78,747 Not Applicable
Citizen can: take trash to
collection centers or contract
out.
Private Collection
Est. $240 -$264
Private Collection
Est. $20.00 to $22.00
No
*for localities with other than monthly billing, the equivalent monthly rates have been shown
24
May 5, 2020
Balancing the FY 2021 General Fund Budget
$200,513,026
1 Updated Revenue Projection following April 1 st review including COVID‐19 residual effects ($6,446,138)
2 Use of Reserve Committed/Assigned Fund Balance Projection for COVID‐19 residual effects $380,043
($6,066,095)
$194,446,931
$200,513,026
1 Expenditure Reduction Projection following April 1 st review including COVID‐19 residual effects ($6,066,095)
($6,066,095)
$194,446,931
$0
Striked‐out ‐ Adjustments have been used to rebalance as noted above.
The "LIST" ‐ Budget Adjustments for Council Discussion:
Proposed Budget Budget Adjustmen ts to Discuss Council Decision
1 Non‐Departmental 2,962,433 3% General Wage Increase and Phase II Salary Study
Implementation (Helgeson)
Future List
2 Council/Manager Offices 30,142 Increase in City Councilmember salaries from $10,000 to
$14,000 and from $12,000 to $16,000 for the Mayor based on
Council action on December 10, 2019 (salary + benefits)
(Nelson)
3 Non‐Departmental 50,000 Health Benefits Education and Advocacy (Helgeson)
4 Economic Development and
Tourism
75,000 Reallocated funds for implementing the Downtown 2040 plan
due to no longer making payments to the Academy Center of
the Arts (Perrow)
Future List
5 Parks and Recreation 37,148 During Staff Rebalancing ‐ reduced to start 10/01/2020
Two (2) new part‐time positions starting 10/01/2020, a Senior
Recreation Specialist and a Recreation Aide, to reopen College
Hill Recreation Center ($34,91146,548
‐ salary + benefits),
internet service ($7951,060), and supplies ($1,4421,923)
(Helgeson)
0
6 Non‐Departmental 50,000 During Staff Rebalancing ‐ reduced by $ 75,000
$50,000125,000 Safety and Security Task Force (Helgeson)
(50,000)
7 Council/Manager Offices $93,789 Chief Talent Development Office r full‐time position
transferred to the Council/Manager Offices from Human
Resources (salary + benefits) (Helgeson)
0
8 Council/Manager Offices 68,074 Youth Futures Coordinator full‐t ime position transferred to
the Council/Manager Office from Human Services ‐ Juvenile
Services (salary + benefits) (Helgeson)
0
9 Human Resources 0 NeoGov Onboarding software (Wright) ‐ $12,000
10 Human Resources 0 NeoGov iLearn access for 200 part‐time employees (Wright) ‐
$6,500
11 Registrar 0 Voting Booths ($600), Early Voting line management supplies
($120), off‐duty officer ($360) (Wright) ‐ $1,080
Funded in FY 2020
with Manager's
Discrectionary funding
12 Registrar 0 Two laptops (Perrow) ‐ $1,563 Funded in FY 2020
with Manager's
Discrectionary funding
Proposed FY 2021 Revenues and Use of Fund Balance
Staff Adjustments to Revenues and Use of Fund Balance:
Subtotal Staff Adjustments to Revenues and Use of Fund Balance:
Total Revised Revenues and Use of Fund Balance
Proposed FY 2021 Expenditures, Reserves, and Transfers
Staff Adjustments to Expenditures, Reserves, and Transfers:
Subtotal Staff Adjustments to Expenditures, Reserves, and Transfers:
Total Revised Expenditures, Reserves, and Transfers
Preliminary Balance after Staff Adjustments
Page 1 of 3
May 5, 2020
The "LIST" ‐ Budget Adjustments for Council Discussion (continued) :
Proposed Budget Budget Adjustmen ts to Discuss Council Decision
13 Office of the Commonwealth's
Attorney
0 In‐House Investigator full‐time position (salary + benefits)
(Nelson) ‐ $48,228
14 Office of the Commonwealth's
Attorney
0 Legal Support Receptionist position change from part‐time to
full‐time (salary + benefits) (Nelson) ‐ $15,881
15 Police 0 5 Sworn Officers and 3 Vehicles (Wilder) ‐ $523,000
The total cost includes salary/benefits ($285,805) and
uniforms/equipment ($38,935) for 5 officers. It also includes
the cost of 3 fully outfitted police vehicles ($198,000).
16 Police 0 Recruitment Advertising (Perrow) ‐ $4,800
17 Police 0 GrayKey software (Perrow) ‐ $18,075
18 Police 0 Quantum Tape Library Back up (Perrow) ‐ $11,685
19 Fire ‐ Option 1
9 full‐time Firefighters
9 full‐time Firefighters (salary + benefits) (Wilder) ‐ $529,623
19 Fire ‐ Option 2
9 full‐time Firefighters
Begin 01/01/2021
9 full‐time Firefighters (salary + benefits) (Wilder) ‐
$264,812 (FY 2022 Impact $529,623+)
19 Fire ‐ Option 3
6 full‐time Firefighters
6 full‐time Firefighters (salary + benefits) (Wilder) ‐ $353,082
19 Fire ‐ Option 4
6 full‐time Firefighters
Begin 10/01/2020
6 full‐time Firefighters (salary + benefits) (Wilder) ‐
$264,812 (FY 2022 Impact $353,082+)
20 Option A
Original Staff Recommendation
Public Works ‐ Refuse REVENUE
Refuse fee revenue (Perrow)
$15.02/month on utility bill
Begin January 1, 2021; fee good for 18 months
FY 2021 Financial Impact $0
Cons ‐ increase in fee
20 Option B
Revised Staff Recommendation
Public Works ‐ Refuse REVENUE
Refuse fee revenue (Perrow)
$9.17/month on utility bill
Begin October 1, 2020;
will require additional fee increase in FY 2022
FY 2021 Financial Impact creates a $140,415 deficit
Cons ‐ Does not allow
for an appropriate inventory
20 Option C
Status Quo ‐ Annual Decals
Public Works ‐ Refuse REVENUE
Refuse fee revenue (Perrow)
$55 or $110/year
Decals must be purchased by September 30, 2020;
would require additional fee increase in FY 2022
FY 2021 Financial Impact creates a $262,644 deficit
Cons ‐ No
progress on improving Refuse situation
21 Option 1
Public Works ‐ Refuse
Brush/Bulk Enforcement full‐time position ($48,540) (salary +
benefits) and uniforms ($1,200) (Perrow)
21 Option 2
Public Works ‐ Refuse
Begin 10/01/2020 (FY 2021 savings of $12,435)
Brush/Bulk Enforcement full‐time position ($36,405$48,540)
(salary + benefits) and uniforms ($9001,200) (Perrow)
22 Parks and Recreation 6,000 Increase in Miller Pool staff pay ( May 2021) to help attract
and retain staff (salary + benefits) (Helgeson)
23 Parks and Recreation 4,600 Annual maintenance contract for RecPro software for
program registration, fees, etc. (Helgeson)
24 Parks and Recreation 1,000 Increased chemical costs (May 2021) for Miller Park Pool
(Helgeson)
25 Parks and Recreation 50,000 Furniture and kitchen equipment fo r Fairview and Yoder
Recreation Centers (Helgeson)
Funded with Pay‐As‐You‐Go
49,740
262,644
0
Page 2 of 3
May 5, 2020
The "LIST" ‐ Budget Adjustments for Council Discussion (continued) :
Proposed Budget Budget Adjustmen ts to Discuss Council Decision
26 Parks and Recreation 3,900 Rentals of portable toilets in the park and trail system
(Helgeson)
27 Community Development 88,194
would need to
remove the
offsetting revenue
as well
One (1) new full‐time Environmental Compliance Inspector
position in the Zoning and Natural Resources Division
($61,594 salary + benefits). Additional costs associated with
the new position a computer, software, phone, and training
($3,600) and a vehicle ($23,000). The cost is 100% funded
through the Stormwater Fund. (Helgeson)
28 Community Development 7,000 Estimated costs of hiring a monito ring service to implement
the Short‐Term Rental Registration program (Helgeson)
29 Economic Development and
Tourism
250,000 Transfer to the Economic Development Authority (EDA) of the
City of Lynchburg providing funds for implementation of
business development, expansion and retention. Prior to FY
2021 these funds were budgeted in the Capital Improvement
Program but are better suited in the operating budget per
Finance staff. (Perrow)
30 External Service Providers 12,167 Virginia Legal Aid Society (Helgeson)
31 Non‐Departmental 0 Poverty Initiative (Wright)
32 Schools Operating 39,828,498 School Funding reduced $2.2m from Schools FY 2021 Request
$42,028,498 Schools Request
$40,528,498 Manager's Proposed
$39,828,498 Manager's Proposed Revised
Total Balancing: ($50,000)
$50,000Balance after Council Decisions
Page 3 of 3
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.