City Council Regular Meeting — Minutes
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Dec 10, 2019 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
1
// A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 10th day of December 2019, at
4:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Treney Tweedy, President, presiding. The following members were
present:
Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Sterling A. Wilder, Beau
Wright, Treney Tweedy 7
Absent: 0
// In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #1, Mr. Norman Yoder and Ms. Julie Moore with Brown Edwards were in
attendance to give Council a presentation on the audit. Mr. Yoder commented that the financial summary shows a
clean report for the City of Lynchburg. He mentioned that the City’s assets have crossed a billion dollars and the
City’s liabilities total a little more than 600 million. He pointed out the statement of revenues and expenditures for
the governmental funds, especially the general fund. The fund balance in the general fund at the end of the year was
about $68 million, which is a strong fund balance relative to the total expenditures of $180 million.
Mr. Yoder also pointed out the budgeted versus actual results for the school operating fund. He pointed out a
return of funds of about $5 million. One of the reasons for that is an exceptionally good year at the schools in their
health insurance reserve.
Mr. Yoder directed them to a summary of the whole audit and is called the Schedule of Findings in Questio n
Costs. Number one is the unmodified opinion on the financial statements as a whole. Number two, there were no
significant deficiencies or material weaknesses identified in the controls at the City or the schools. They test various
areas of compliance both state and federal and there were no findings there. He remarked that the City was not
determined to be a low-risk auditee. The reason for this is that there was a material weakness found at the schools
because of a new payroll package. That situation has been rectified and there is an update provided in the audit
report. However, for two years after a material weakness, a locality cannot be considered a low -risk auditee. That
means that they have to test a larger percentage of the City’s overall federal expenditures.
Council was provided a letter with internal control comments for schools, some IT related ones. These are
suggestions and are not significant findings. He thinks that in the letter regarding the same to the City, there w as
only a couple of disclosure and economic interest statements that were not filed in a timely manner.
Mr. Yoder commented that this was a fairly clean audit and he was available to answer any questions.
Councilmember Perrow commended the budget and management staff on the clean audit and commended LCS
for cleaning up the material finding. He hopes the City is a low risk auditee in the future. Councilmember Perrow
said he has been made aware of an organization that had the same auditor for the past 15 years or so. However, they
found significant deficiencies in their books when they changed bookkeepers to the point that there may have been
criminal activity. Councilmember Perrow would like to know what Brown Edwards does to make sure that there are
fresh eyes looking and the tests are being done and they are not falling into complacency. Mr. Yoder acknowledged
that this topic has received a fair amount of attention over the last 20 to 30 years. There has been debate about
whether auditor rotation should be required. Most that have studied do not think an auditor needs to be rotated but
things need to be in place to make sure that complacency does not set in. Mr. Yoder said they have had many of
their municipal clients for years and they care a great deal about audit quality. Brown Edwards rotates partners on
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
2
engagements such as the City of Lynchburg. Other things are the tone of an organization and Brown Edwards’
expectations of its audit staff. He said they have brainstorming sessions for each job and ta lk about the risks and
what to look for and so forth. Councilmember Perrow noted that this organization thought everything was fine and
it shows how much we depend on an independent audit.
Mr. Yoder thanked staff for all their good work. The ten or 15 minutes he spends in front of Council represents
hundreds of hours of work on both sides.
// In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #2, Ms. Donna Witt addressed Council about its fund balance policy. At
Council’s request, Ms. Witt brought has brought them some language to consider in regards to growing its fund
balance incrementally to 15 percent. Ms. Witt explained that they did not want to set the goal of reaching 15 percent
as a specific goal within a specific period of time. If there is a downturn in the economy or competing priorities, she
did not want to see Council have to cut a service in order to put more money aside in a fund b alance. The language
is written to stress that our goal is a 15 percent unassigned fund balance but it is based on how our revenues are
growing and taking into account competing priorities.
Ms. Witt pointed out a change to the debt management policy. The total tax supported debt has been stricken.
The credit rating agency no longer looks at that item. Ms. Witt mentioned that these two items are the only changes
to the policies.
Councilmember Helgeson spoke on behalf of the Finance Committee. The co mmittee thought the policies
changes are good and appreciate what staff is doing and how it is suggesting they set aside more money in reserves.
The Finance Committee recommended approval of the policy changes and he made that motion on behalf of the
Finance Committee. Councilmember Helgeson noted that the five percent increase in the fund balance equates to
$10 million, which equates to 16 cents on a real estate tax rate. He hopes they propose to do this incrementally and
have it presented to them each budget year. Councilmember Wright feels this policy will put us on the right track
and he is excited to support it.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of Community Development – Zoning Ordinance, Agenda Item #3, Mr. Tom Martin summarized a
presentation on single-family development standards for Council. This is in response to a request made by City
Council a few months ago.
Mr. Martin explained that the Zoning Ordinance defines a detached dwelling as “a building containing only
dwelling units surrounded by yards or other open area on the same zoning lot.” A single -household dwelling is
defined as “a building containing not more than one (1) dwelling unit and occupied by not more than one (1)
household. These dwelling are allowed in many of the City’s zoning districts but for the purposes of today’s
discussion, they are being talking about in the R-1 and R-2 districts. R-C allows single-family homes but those
parcels have very distinct characteristics and there are really not many R -C parcels in the City.
Mr. Martin showed Council a map showing the R-C, R-1 and R-2 districts in the City. He explained that R-C,
Conservation, parcels have to have a minimum of 10 acres to be buildable. R-1, Low Density Residential have to
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
3
have a minimum lot size of 15,000 square feet and density is allowed at 2.9 units per acre. R -2, Low-Medium
Density Residential has to have a minimum lot size of 10,000 square feet and density is allowed at 4.35 units per
acre.
Councilmember Perrow noted there seems to be a disproportionate amount of R-C lots in the Tyreeanna area as
compared to other parts of the City. He wondered if that puts a hardship on that area in terms of development.
Mr. Martin said that could be looked at during the revising of the Tyreeanna Plan. He would need to look into the
reason why there is so much R-C land in that area and felt that Councilmember Perrow made a very good point.
Mr. Martin noted there are other issues associated with development in this area such as the availability of water and
sewer.
Mr. Martin noted another development standard, which is the necessity for improved, dedicated street that
extends across the entire frontage of new lots. The street width requirements are fifty feet of right -of-way with
twenty feet of pavement.
The subdivision ordinance also requires that subdivisions of five lots or more connect to public sanitary sewer
and public water where accessible. Accessibility is determined by the number of lots multiplied by 100 feet. For
example, a five-lot subdivision would be considered accessible if there is public water and sewer within 500 feet.
Subdivisions of five lots or less may be served by private well or septic if there are no new roads required and
public water and sewer is not available. Lots served by only one utility (water or sewer) have to be a minimum of
20,000 square feet. Lots served by neither utility (public water or sewer) have to be 25,000 square feet. Lots also
have to meet Health Department requirements. Councilmember Perrow thinks that is a perfectly reasonable
requirement from a public health perspective. Mr. Martin explained that subdivisions of six lots or more without
public water and sewer can be approved by City Council. Each lot must be an acre in size and have sufficient area
for drain fields. Easements have to be provided for future public water and sewer extension.
The subdivision ordinance also requires that new residential streets have curb and gutter per the City’s Manual
of Specifications. Sidewalks are required on one side of all new residential streets and both sides if vehicle trips
exceed 6,000 per day. Street trees are also required. In answer to a question from Councilmember Helgeson,
Mr. Martin commented that the Manual of Specifications is minimum engineering standards that are adopted by the
Engineering Division. They can change; however, the City receives maintenance dollars based on how we construct
our streets. A lot of the standards are VDOT standards and if we want the maintenance dollars, we have to build the
streets to a certain standard. Dr. Reid Wodicka clarified for Councilmember Helgeson that we get maintenance
dollars for all the roads and secondary streets and in order to receive those funds, all roads have to meet VDOT
standards. Dr. Wodicka explained that counties are different because the streets are typically maintained by VDOT.
Dr. Wodicka said he could not speak to that in any more detail. He acknowledged that our standards are above
VDOT’s minimum standards but they feel that leads to a better community. Mr. Martin said Council would need to
have that discussion with the Engineer Division if it would like to know about the actual standards and what may be
done to reduce costs.
Staff looked at data for the past five years and had a chart of single-family homes built in the City and
surrounding counties. The number of those built in R-1 and R-2 districts in the City has stayed fairly consistent over
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
4
the past five years. Mr. Martin pointed out that when they compare the City’s numbers to the surrounding counties,
Council needs to remember that the City is much smaller than the counties. The number of single-family homes
being built in the City is very proportional and we are capturing a good share. In answer to a question from
Councilmember Wright, Mr. Martin thought it was a fair assumption that the homes being built in the City are now
occupied. In answer to a question from Councilmember Perrow, some of the homes are a part of subdivisions. They
are not all single building permits.
Mr. Martin pointed out that the map also shows the amount of vacant land zoned R -1 and R-2 and indicated it is
about 3,051 acres. It captured parcels with a land value of six thousand dollars or less. The map does not include
large tracts of land that have only one house on them that could be subdivided.
Mr. Martin outlined some of the perceived barriers to development in the City. One is the land cost. The
average vacant residential land sale is $23,980 per acre. The infrastructure costs for the road frontage and utilities
total $511.25 per foot of road frontage. A developer is looking at $33,832 per 15,000 square foot lot with 100 feet
of road frontage. This does not take into account the costs for designing the road and infrastructure. Mr. Martin
said the cost for a foot of road in the counties is somewhere between $300 and $350. Councilmember Perrow feels
that the assessed value for homes is probably less than the investment cost. Mr. Martin said he understood
Councilmember Perrow’s point and they could talk to the assessor regarding this information. Councilmember
Perrow noted that developers have to sell a lot for the cost of the land and the amount it will or has cost them for
improvements and that is where it gets cost prohibitive. Some other perceived and some real barriers to single-
family development are the City’s topography, flood plains, landlocked parcels, water/sewer availability, stormwater
management, land availability and market conditions.
Mr. Martin acknowledged Councilmember’s Perrow about development costs but would like to discuss with
them what the City has done and continues to do to try and address some of these perceived barriers. The City pays
for 100 percent of the cost of extending water and sewer to the subdivision boundary based upon economic
feasibility. For example, if 500 feet of water/sewer line is needed, at least five lots would need to be developed. If
5,000 feet of water/sewer line is needed, 50 lots would have to be developed. Past Councils have expressed their
concern with the perception that the City is not seeing enough single-family development and since 1989 things like
this have been put in the ordinance to try and offset some of the higher costs.
The City also cost shares curb, gutter and sidewalk at a 50/50 ratio. Councilmember Perrow thought they had
removed that and Mr. Martin said that was only for commercial development. The commercial development cost
sharing was never codified and a policy decision was made to discontinue doing it. The City also allows for the
development of flag lots with fifty feet of road frontage if it is the only feasible way to develop a parcel.
Mr. Martin highlighted several things that have been addressed in the Zoning Ordinance to encourage single -
family development. Lots existing as of July 11, 2011 may provide access on dedicated improved street extending a
minimum of 25 feet past the driveway entrance. Lots existing prior to September 12, 1989 may be accessed by a
perpetual unobstructed easement at least 30 feet in width. In February 2016, the Zoning Ordinance was amended to
allow a reduction in setbacks and lot sizes to encourage infill development (neighborhood norms).
Another new standard in the 2016 Zoning Ordinance is a Residential Cluster Subdivision. It allows up to a 50
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
5
percent reduction in the required lot size and setbacks to create residential cluster. It allows the density of the
underlying zoning district, undeveloped land is preserved in open space and it reduced infrastructure costs by shorter
water, sewer and road construction. Mr. Martin had an example to show them of a development dis cussed recently
with a developer. A typical subdivision layout would have only yielded 49 lots on a 31 acre tract. With the cluster
development concept, they can get 71 lots out of the 31 acres and retain 30 percent open space. The developer said
he would not be considering this development without the cluster development option because of development costs.
In answer to a question from Councilmember Helgeson, Mr. Martin said this differs from a Planned Unit
Development (PUD) because a PUD allows for different housing types. The cluster subdivision only allows for
detached housing and has the requirement for open space.
The City’s population was estimated to be around 80,000 in 2018. That is an increase of over 6,500 people
since 2010. Campbell County only increased by 131 people. Amherst declined by 688 people. Bedford County
increased by 4,000 people. The Comprehensive Plan recognizes that the City’s boundaries are unlikely to expand so
the City will need to provide opportunities for great densities in areas where they can be compatibly integrated with
existing neighborhoods.
Councilmember Wilder asked Mr. Martin if they have tried to address developers’ concerns that have been
expressed to staff. Mr. Martin said they always talk to developers about what the City can offer them. They have
been talking to developers about the residential clustering option and Mr. Martin believes it will encourage more
single-household development. Councilmember Wilder asked if there was a better way the City coul d make
developers aware of the various options the City has to offer. Mr. Martin suggested they might be able to promote
the residential clustering on the City’s website or possibly by working with Economic Development.
Councilmember Wilder said he is glad to hear the City has options available and tries to make concessions for
development. He would like staff to do whatever they can to help promote these options to the developers in the
community.
Mr. Martin explained that the residential clustering allows for a 50 percent reduction in lot size. Theoretically,
it allows a developer to do shorter street extensions and shorter water and sewer line extensions. In answer to a
question from Mayor Tweedy, Mr. Martin said this clustering applies to new subdivisions and not infill
development, unless the person had a very large lot.
Mayor Tweedy said she has heard from developers about things they felt would have made the price point better
for infill development and she asked Mr. Martin if they are doing anything to incentivize that type of development.
Mr. Martin said they attempted to do that with updates to the Zoning Ordinance and would love to listen to other
suggestions. Mayor Tweedy said the cost of hooking up to the City’s water and sewer was a cost that was
specifically mentioned. Dr. Wodicka indicated staff has not really talked about that issue but could certainly
consider it.
Councilmember Perrow noted that this Council has supported slowing down traffic by putting them on a “road
diet,” such as approving two-way traffic downtown, which effectively narrows the street and slows down traffic. He
thinks that a wide street does incentivize people to go faster. He thinks they might want to look at their standards
and see if we can get on a “road diet” in our residential subdivisions in order to slow traffic and make it more
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
6
conducive for pedestrians. Mr. Martin agreed that wider streets do promote speeding and the photo he had provided
them earlier of a newer versus an older street in Lynchburg speaks for itself.
Mayor Tweedy asked if our map shows areas that are prime for residential clustering. Mr. Martin said our
Future Land Use Map shows areas that the City would like to see developed as low-density development.
Sometimes developers ask staff to help them find tracts of land for a certain type of development (both commercial
and residential) and staff will do so. Councilmember Wilder suggested that Community Development work with
Economic Development and have an informational session to let them know what is available.
Councilmember Wright wondered if they are disincentivizing single-family development because they are
approving so many apartment complexes. Mr. Martin thinks that proportionately Lynchburg is capturing its fair
share of the single-family household dwellings proportionately to the counties. Council still has to talk about what
is the highest and best use of the property. Council may want to look at whether or not single -family detached
housing actually pays for itself, which is a difficult conversation to have. Ms. Svrcek said typically it does not.
Councilmember Helgeson said a townhome full of school aged children using services could not even remotely pay
for itself. Mr. Martin said he does not have the data in front of him but we are talking about assessed value of one
versus assessed value of another.
Councilmember Helgeson noted that the more that we put in densely populated areas, the less elbow room we
have. The more we make approvals for rezonings, it does not help us economically because you have a larger
supply with the same demand. If you have a smaller supply and the same demand, prices go up. Mr. Martin said the
City has 50 square miles and an increasing population and a limited availability of R -1 and R-2 land. We have said
it since at least the year 2000 that if the City wants to grow, it is going to have to become denser. Councilmember
Helgeson asked what is the importance in growing in population and Mr. Martin said “retail follows rooftop.”
Councilmember Helgeson pointed out people can come from other areas to shop here and they also shop online.
Mr. Martin said he is not sure what the right answer is and the topic of how the City is going to grow in the future is
a good discussion for us to have periodically. Mayor Tweedy noted that as we improve the quality of life here, we
are going to see people that want to benefit from those amenities. This is why she asked about encouraging infill
development because that may be where we get some traction.
// In the matter of City Code, City Council Compensation, Agenda Item #4, Ms. Svrcek explained that it has been
staff’s practice to bring them ever two years prior to a Council election an opportunity for them to review their
compensation to see if they want to change either their salaries or benefits and to receive budget guidance as we
prepare the FY 2021 proposed budget. State code states that no increase in salary shall take effect until July 1 after
the next regularly scheduled election of councilmembers. Code also states that any proposed increase in the salary
of members be adopted at least four months prior to the next election. For our population category of 75,000 to
174,999, the salary for the mayor shall not exceed $25,000 and $23,000 for councilmembers. The mayor’s and
councilmembers’ salaries are $12,000 and $10,000 respectively and have not changed since 2008. Currently,
Council is not eligible for any benefits.
Mayor Tweedy thinks that if you want a diverse group of people and more people interested, you have to pay
them more. A person is fine to serve if he or she is a professional with a flexible and schedule or has an employer
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
7
that is very flexible because he values the role of a public servant. There are others with great l eadership skills that
want to serve their community and they have to be able to help support their families. With a City like ours that is
growing, it takes a lot of time and she does not really think the public understands the amount of time that a
councilmember spends on the work. She supports a pay increase or benefits. You love public service but you have
to survive too.
Councilmember Wilder said it takes a lot of hours of a person’s time to do this job and you have to have a
flexible job that allows a person to do it. He commented how much time he spent this weekend reading the agenda
packet and the numerous emails he received about the Second Amendment. He noted that Charlottesville has about
half the population of Lynchburg and pays almost twice as much to its mayor and councilmembers. He would
suggest they change their salaries to Charlottesville ($20,000 and $18,000 ) or something close to it.
Vice Mayor Dolan noted that she is retired and has all kinds of time to do what she wants. She is sensitive to
those that do not have that kind of time; however, she would not be able to vote for a raise in good conscience
because we have City employees working two and three jobs to make ends meet. She would hate to have someone
sitting in this seat for the money. They are a public servant.
Councilmember Wilder thinks they are all committed to public service. He noted tha t he has to work this job
and other jobs just to make it.
Councilmember Perrow asked Ms. Svrcek when Council reduced its salaries because of budget. Ms. Svrcek
said they increased their salaries in FY 2009. Councilmember Perrow noted that he came on C ouncil in 2008. It
was not actually a change in the code. Council chose not to fully fund its salaries in the budget for a few years.
Their salaries were fully funded again around 2012 to 2013. Councilmember Perrow noted that there were some
changes made in the structure of Council’s meetings so they were not being held in the early afternoon.
Councilmember Perrow has never seen this as a job. He has seen it as a calling. He thinks it would be wrong to
consider this a job because maybe then he should have an office and be down here all the time. The mayor’s
position is different because he or she needs to be able to receive guests. He would not endorse changing their
salaries. He thinks you have to do this because you love the job and not because it is a supplemental source of
income.
Councilmember Wright is not sure how he feels about this topic. Doing some math though and assuming a
councilmember puts in 15 hours, which is not unusual, that comes to $12.82 an hour. If a councilmember put in 20
hours a week, which is also not unusual, it comes to $9.61. There is a practical concern, which is wear and tear on
your vehicle and gas. Those expenses are defrayed somewhat by the compensation. He would also echo the
mayor’s comment about diversity. It is a privilege to serve here but he thinks it also requires privilege to serve here
in a lot of respects. If we want to make this body more accessible to more members of the community, he thinks
they could take steps to make it more equitable so that more folks can actually make this job a reality.
Councilmember Nelson agrees with what has been said about incentivizing a greater diversity of participation
of persons. He thinks he probably puts in around 25 hours a week, so we do not do it becaus e of the compensation.
He would not vote for any benefit that would come to him within his term.
Mayor Tweedy noted that the mayor spends a great deal of time being accessible to multiple areas, people and
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
8
groups. She would like to make everyone aware that these are part-time roles and it is always about the public
service.
Councilmember Wilder asked for clarification that they could approve a raise but would not necessarily have to
take it. Councilmember Helgeson noted the amount could be in the City Code but then not funded at a later date.
Ms. Svrcek said that is correct. Councilmember Wilder noted he is up for reelection in May and he is not sure
whether or not he is running. He is thinking about people in the future. He makes a motion to in crease each salary
level by $4,000. The mayor would receive $16,000 and a councilmember would receive $14,000. The motion was
seconded by Mayor Tweedy.
Councilmember Helgeson commented that the Clerk of Council sends them a lot of event invitations. Many of
them the mayor tries to attend. The mayor is also asked often to do proclamations. The mayor does not have to go
to all of them but people appreciate it. She showed up at the Finance Committee meeting this morning, which she is
not even a member of; she does the same for the Physical Development Committee. It is obviously not about the
money and is about the service. We want people to run and he has talked to many people that say they cannot run
because they cannot afford it. Having the amount in City Code does not mean that it will be funded.
Councilmember Perrow does not think he can support this motion because there are already constraints in the
upcoming budget. He is sure there is going to be pressure for a pay increase for many of our City employees.
Those will likely be small percentage raises so it is hard for him to justify a 40 percent pay increase for Council.
Councilmember Helgeson recognizes the percentage does not look good but it is a total of only $28,000 in the
budget, if it even gets funded. He thinks the issue is looking at the future and future councilmembers.
Mayor Tweedy noted that it takes a lot to be present to a City of 80,000 people. It is a reality that we are a
growing City and it takes more meetings and engagements if you are doing it well.
Councilmember Helgeson noted that this is supposed to be done four months before the election and the
election is in May. Ms. Svrcek noted their meeting in January 2020 would be too late because the election is May 5
and the meeting in January is the 14th. The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Helgeson, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 4
Noes: Dolan, Nelson, Perrow 3
// In the matter of Roll Call, Agenda Item #5, Councilmember Nelson had no items.
Councilmember Perrow commented the Christmas Parade being fun. He thought it was a really good event and
the more it happens in Midtown, the more he likes it. It is very accessible to a larger group of people.
Councilmember Helgeson echoed those comments. He thought it was great and it was easy for people to get to and
lots of food options available.
Councilmember Wright congratulated the Lynchburg Downtown Association and all their partner organizations
for the Christmas tree lighting down at the Craddock Terry Hotel. He also congratulated the City on the
groundbreaking for the Langhorne Road trestle project to extend the Blackwater Trail from the Ed Page entrance
over to Linkhorne Road. Also, he had a great experience recently when he went to the Diamond Hill Community
Center and got to meet the team and some of the folks that use the center. It looks great and he is really proud that
this institution exists in our City along with the other neighborhood centers.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
9
Councilmember Wilder congratulated Jane White on always doing an awesome job in our community in
recognizing the history of Lynchburg. This past weekend a marker was dedicated for Morris Alexander, a nationally
known caddy. His family came from all over the weekend and Councilmember Wilder thanked Oakwood Country
Club for hosting the event. He thanked all the men that participated in Moustaches for Kids. Over $185,000 was
raised in one month for children in our community. Councilmember Wilder won a Moore & Giles for his
fundraising efforts.
Vice Mayor Dolan had no items.
Councilmember Helgeson mentioned that this is the first year that Liberty University has been in the Football
Bowl championship series. It has qualified for the Cure Bowl, which is fabulous. Congratulations to them; this
should be great for Lynchburg as they move up in the division.
Councilmember Perrow noted that a press release just went out saying that Lynchburg ranks #55 in the country
for affordable homes. It is a Harvard study and the relevant data shows that 93.02 percent of Lynchburg homes
were affordable to the average household living there. Homes were considered to be affordable if the required
monthly payment was less than 31 percent of the median monthly household income.
Mayor Tweedy had the following announcements:
a. On Thursday, December 12th from 4:30 p.m. – 7:30 p.m., the public is cordially invited to attend an open
house for the development of the Dearington Neighborhood Plan. This kick-off event will take place at the
Dearington Elementary School for Innovation, 210 Smyth Street, in the school’s cafeteria. This is a collaborative
effort between the City of Lynchburg and the residents of Dearington to help pl an the neighborhood’s future.
Current and former neighborhood residents are encouraged to attend the open house and share information. In
addition, there will be an opportunity to visit information stations set up throughout the cafeteria with
representatives from various community organizations to discuss available resources. Complimentary pizza and
other refreshments will be provided, and adults in attendance can register to win gift cards to local establishments.
There will also be kids’ activities available during the open house.
b. The Blue Ridge and James River Chapters of the Daughters of the American Revolution, in cooperation
with the Old City Cemetery in Lynchburg, are proud to sponsor our 12th Anniversary Wreaths Across America
ceremony on Saturday, December 14, at 12:00 noon. This event is free and open to the public. Please arrive early as
parking within the cemetery is very limited and the cemetery gates close at 11:45 a.m.
c. In preparation of its 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan, 2020 Annual Action Plan and Analysis of Impediments
to Fair Housing Choice, the City of Lynchburg is seeking community input Ttwo public meetings are scheduled on
Tuesday, December 17 and Wednesday, December 18, 6:00 p.m. - 7:00 p.m. each evening. Both meetings will be
held at the Miller Center, 301 Grove Street, Room 205. This facility is handicapped accessible with free parking.
// On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Vice Mayor Dolan, Council by the following recorded vote
elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss appointments to the Building Code Appeals Board, Community
Development Advisory Committee, Horizon Behavioral Health Board, LYNCAG Board, Lynchburg Regional
Airport Commission, Planning Commission, Transit Company Board of Directors and Youth Ser vices Citizens
Board:
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
10
Ayes: Dolan, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6
Noes: Helgeson 1
// Agenda Item #6 - On nomination of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Perrow, Council by
the following recorded vote appointed Andrew Flint and Jody Miller to the Building Code Appeals Board for terms
ending September, 2023:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// On nomination of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Perrow, Council by the following
recorded vote reappointed Susan Murray, John Hughes, III, Valerie Harris and Councilmember Beau Wright and
appointed Leonard Briley, Mandze Dyke and Councilmember Wilder to serve on the Community Development
Advisory Committee for terms to expire December 31, 2020:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// On nomination of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Perrow, Council by the following
recorded vote reappointed Betty Brickhouse to serve on the Horizon Behavioral Health Board for a term to expire
December 31, 2022:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// On nomination of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Perrow, Council by the following
recorded vote reappointed Debra Allen and appointed Janice Crawford to serve on the Lynchburg Regional Airport
Commission for terms to expire December 31, 2022:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// On nomination of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Perrow, Council by the following
recorded vote reappointed Robert C. Light, Jr., and David Perault to serve on the Planning Commission for terms to
expire December 31, 2022:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// On nomination of Councilmember Helgeson, seconded by Councilmember Perrow, Council by the following
recorded vote appointed Tyeast Blanding, Amber Davis, Vice Mayor MaryJane Dolan, Tremayne Edwards and
Vivian Miller to serve on the Youth Services Citizens Board for terms to expire June 30, 2022:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// The meeting was re-opened to the public.
Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion:
WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an
affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
11
WHEREAS, Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed
meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of
each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by
Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such
public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or
considered by Council.
The motion was seconded by Councilmember Perrow, and Council by the following recorded vote adopted the
motion:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// The meeting was recessed at 6:30 p.m.
// City Council reconvened the meeting at 7:30 p.m. The following members were present:
Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Sterling Wilder,
Beau Wright, Treney Tweedy 7
Absent: 0
// Vice Mayor Dolan gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance led by Girl Scout Troop 9200.
Mayor Tweedy presented certificates to the following girls from the troop: Savannah Assent, Charlotte Assent,
Claudia Arp, Luci Ashare, Miriam Boyers, Alexis Day, Hailey Day, Aubrey Hopkins, Ellery McLemore, Caroline
Pollard, Brielle Ramirez, Claire Terry and Eva Wilson.
// In the matter of Recognitions, Chris Adams from the Lynchburg Fire Department was recognized as the
Governor’s EMS Provider of the Year. Fire Marshal Gregory Wormser was also present to help with the
presentation of the award. For more than thirty years, the Virginia Office of Emergency Medical Services has been
honoring Emergency Medical Service Providers and Agencies in the Commonwealth for their outstanding
contributions to the health and well-being of the citizens they serve. On November 9, 2019 Captain Chris Adams
became the recipient of the Governor’s Award for Outstanding Pre-hospital Provider in the Commonwealth of
Virginia. Chris was selected by his peers and State Officials for this award from nominations that were received
from eleven regions across the state. Fire Marshal Gregory Wormser was present to help with the recognition.
// In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Tweedy recognized the City’s IT Department for receiving the Digital Cities
Award. Every year, the City participates in the national Digital Cities Survey conducted by the Center for Digital
Government. This survey ranks cities across the country for how they utilize information technology to serve their
citizens and improve the efficiency and effectiveness of their local government operations. The City of Lynchburg
has received First Place in its population category (75,000 – 124,999). This is the 16th consecutive year the City of
Lynchburg has been in the national top 10 and the fourth time it has been ranked first in its population
category. The Mayor and City Manager also recognized Mike Goetz, the Director of IT, for his work and
announced that he will be retiring on February 1, 2020.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
12
// In the matter of Recognitions, Mayor Tweedy recognized two members of the Mayor’s Youth Council who are
attending the meeting tonight, John and Teddy Tharp.
// Copies of the minutes of the November 7, 2019 Council Retreat, Agenda Item #7, having been previously
furnished Council, reading was dispensed with, and on motion of Vice Mayor Dolan, seconded by Councilmember
Wilder, by the following recorded vote, approved the minutes as presented.
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// Copies of the minutes of the November 12, 2019 meeting, Agenda Item #8, having been previously furnished
Council, reading was dispensed with, and on motion of Vice Mayor Dolan, seconded by Councilmember Wright, by
the following recorded vote, approved the minutes as presented.
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of Community Development - Conditional Use Permits, Agenda Item #9, a public hearing was
conducted regarding the petition of HumanKind for a Conditional Use Permit at 150 Linden Avenue to allow the
construction of recreational facilities including athletic fields, swimming pool, and parking areas in an R-1, Low-
Density Residential District. Mr. Tom Martin, the City Planner provided a summary of the request for Council.
Mr. Bob Dendy, the President of HumanKind was present to represent the petitioner. He feels they have addresse d
the concerns regarding access to the campus, the type of application (a CUP instead of institutional zoning) and the
retention of some requested accommodations.
Mr. Collin Byrne spoke in favor of the petition because athletic fields are very much in need in the City of
Lynchburg.
Mr. David Kerr came forward to speak. He is not necessarily opposed to the project but he has met with
someone from HumanKind and been promised things that have not happened and are not a part of the conditions of
their conditional use permit. He does acknowledge that many of his concerns were addressed at the Planning
Commission meeting. He would like to see HumanKind change its address after the n ew access road is constructed
so people do not have to come back Linden Avenue. Traffic, lights and noise are all concerns to him. He would
like to see a gate at the entrance on Linden Avenue. He does not understand why the CUP is being considered
without the access road.
Mr. John Bruce came forward to speak. He thinks the conditions have addressed many of the conce rns;
however, he is concerned about traffic on VES Road. He would like the City to study VES Road and how they what
traffic improvements might be helpful to slow down traffic. He would also like to see the construction of the access
road as a condition of the CUP.
Mr. Dendy came back for a rebuttal. The changing of the address to VES Road will happen. They are also
considering the possibility of putting a crash bar on Linden Avenue but would like to hear more feedback from
neighbors. The new road is not a CUP item but it is something to which HumanKind is committed doing before the
new elements are constructed. They have contacted a contractor and the construction of the new road should start in
the spring.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
13
There were no other persons who wished to speak and Mayor Tweedy closed the public hearing portion of the
petition. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion, which was seconded by Cou ncilmember Perrow to approve the
petition. Councilmember Helgeson appreciates the diligence and patience of HumanKind. He appreciates what they
will be doing for children and sports. He is concerned with the number of conditions on the CUP. He would li ke to
see some of them removed but he assumes HumanKind has agreed to all of them.
Councilmember Perrow thinks there has been a lot of work between all parties. There has been a lot of concern
from neighbors. A lot of those concerns will be alleviated with the conditions of the CUP. In answer to a question
from Councilmember Perrow, Mr. Martin said the construction of the access road is not directly tied to the CUP.
They could still build the athletic fields if the access road is not constructed but he has no reason to believe the
HumanKind would do that. Mr. Martin clarified that the conditions in the resolution were submitted by HumanKind
and not recommended by staff. Councilmember Perrow asked if the City has something in writing from
HumanKind that it will construct the road. Mr. Martin said he would have to go through the file but the plan for it
has been submitted.
Mr. Hank Creasy, an attorney and the chair of the board of HumanKind came forward. HumanKind is
committed to building the road but it is not part of the CUP because it is not a governmental process. They have
received a price from a contractor and fully expect this road to be constructed so the fields can be built. If the road
is not built, the fields will not be built. Councilmember Nelson commented that he assumes that is HumanKind built
the project as a CUP but did not build the new road to VES Road that it is unlikely that Westminster Canterbury
would let HumanKind use their easement as access leaving them with only Linden Av enue. Mr. Creasy said that as
part of the commitment with its neighbor, the easement area will be released and returned to Westminster
Canterbury. It is part of the agreement with Westminster Canterbury that the project will not be built unless the new
access road is built.
Mr. Walter Erwin explained that if the activity that is granted by the conditional use permit becomes a nuisance,
Council can revoke the conditional use permit. That has happened once before.
Councilmember Perrow asked the City Manager to look at VES Road in a future capital planning exercise, as
well as Williams Road because they could both stand a little bit of safety improvements.
Councilmember Wilder thanked HumanKind for its work in the community and for working with Westmi nster
Canterbury to address its concerns. He would HumanKind to address some of the other concerns expressed about
Linden Avenue.
Councilmember Nelson said there is no doubt that the athletic fields are needed and the good part is that it is
being funded by a private entity on land that is already tax exempt. It is impressive that the parties have complied
with all the recommendations that Council requested the last time they were before Council.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of Community Development – Conditional Use Permits, Agenda Item #10, a public hearing was
conducted regarding the Petition of Millside Development Center (Scott Zechini) to amend the previously approved
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
14
Conditional Use Permit for a Cluster Commercial Development at 1602, 1604, 1606, 1608, 1610, 1612, 1614 and
1620 Graves Mill Road to allow the construction of a twenty-two thousand three hundred (22,300) square foot
assisted living facility in a B-1, Limited Business District. Mr. Tom Martin provided a summary of the petition for
Council.
Mr. Michael Bryant with Hurt & Proffitt was present to represent the petitioner. The facility will serve a need
in the City of Lynchburg and is similar to a use that already exists in the Millside Development Center. He
explained it is a smaller use and the traffic will be reduced with this footprint as compared to what was approved
with the original CUP in 2005.
There were no other persons who wished to speak in favor or in opposition. Mayor Tweedy closed the public
hearing portion of the petition.
Councilmember Wilder made a motion, which was seconded by Councilmember Wright to approve the petition.
Councilmember Helgeson acknowledged the need in the community for this type of facility and thanked the
developer for building and investing in the City. Councilmember Wright said it was a great use of the property and
they are excited for it.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of Budget – Schools, Agenda Item #11, a Public hearing was conducted regarding amending the FY
2020 Budget to reflect the Return of Schools Fund Balance for ongoing activities not expended in FY 2019, and
appropriating supplemental funds for both the Capital and Operating Budgets for the twelve month period beginning
July 1 2019 and ending June 20, 2020. Ms. Svrcek said the Lynchburg City Schools requested the appropriation of
the entire $5,008,139 in FY 2019 operating fund balance for capital improvement program projects, the textbook
and health insurance reserves, technology upgrades, software and bus engine rebuilds. City staff recommends a
reduction of this request by $1,233,075 with $1.2 million allocated to a reserve for implementing recommendations
from the Task Force on the Future of PreK-12 Education and Beyond and $33,075 for expenses associated with the
work of the task force. Funding is needed for a demographic study to be performed by the Weldon Cooper Center
Demographics Research Group as well as other to be determined costs, which may include outside consultants. The
reduction proposed by staff comes from a deferral of elementary gym number four for $800,000 until the task force
completes its work and the request to increase the health insurance reserve by $433,075. The current balance in the
health insurance reserve is $2,066,925. This action is requested in accordance with an ag reement signed by the
Lynchburg City Council and the School Board dated December 14, 1993, which provides for the creation and
maintenance of the school’s operating fund balance for the purpose of underwriting any occasional shortfalls from
the various budgetary categories of direct state funding support, as well as other applications all based upon the
required expenditure approval of the School Board.
Dr. Crystal Edwards came forward to speak. She would like Council to seriously consider their fund ba lance
requests so they can do the best they can for our students and so they can create an environment that makes their
staff, families and students feel comfortable, welcome and supported.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
15
Coach Brian Farrell with E C Glass football came forward to ask for support for the E C Glass practice field.
They are constantly moving soccer nets off the field because everyone uses it. The practice field would allow them
to have a place to practice all the time rather than moving all over the City.
Coach Nicki Aarons with E C Glass field hockey also spoke in favor of the E C Glass practice field. She has to
find places off site for the girls to practice and transport the players and the equipment in her own vehicle. There is
also no athletic trainer on site for these practices.
Vondell Shavers came forward to speak in favor of the practice field. He is a graduate of E C Glass and was an
athlete as well. The practice field will allow more students to be able to participate in sports and give them a safe
place to practice.
Susan Morrison, the chair of the School Board came forward to ask for Council’s support. They put a great deal
of thought into these requests. They appreciate Council’s serious consideration for our kids.
Dr. James Coleman, also on the School Board, supported Ms. Morrison’s comments.
Megan Short, a student athlete at E C Glass came forward to ask for their support for the practice field. She told
Council how they have to go to the stadium to practice. It is a struggle to get everyon e there on time because not all
the students can drive and there is no bus service. There is also no athletic trainer on site.
The coach for the girls’ lacrosse team came forward to speak in favor of having the practice field. There is a
definite risk to having practices off site because there is not always a portable defibrillator available. The field
would allow the players to have continuous practice time. Sometimes a player cannot get back for a game because
they do not have a ride.
There were no other speakers for or against the petition and Mayor Tweedy closed the public hearing portion of
the petition.
Councilmember Wright made a motion to move the petition as recommended by the City Manager. The motion
was seconded by Councilmember Perrow. Councilmember Wright thinks it is a reasonable compromise between the
schools’ original request and what has now been worked out between the City Manager and the school
administration. He thinks it is productive and he is glad they are planning for and setting aside funds for what the
education task force may recommend.
Councilmember Perrow thought Councilmember Wright summarized it very well. Councilmember Perrow
thought the field was busy when he graduated in 1992 and they probably only had half the number of athletic teams.
He is happy to support this and wishes all the athletic teams the best of success.
Councilmember Nelson appreciates all the effort and thought that went into this and thinks the City Manager’s
compromise/proposal is appropriate. The task force is going to come forth with some significant recommendations
which are not going to be inexpensive and we need to be putting funds aside for those operational and capital
expenses. It is not up to Council to tell the schools how to spend the funds allocated to them, but he does think that
the plea for an additional practice field is appropriate.
Councilmember Helgeson is thinking about last year when we funded about $100 million to the schools to
educate about 8,000 kids. He voted against it because he said there is extra money in here. He appreciates schools
saving this $5 million but he is not sure it is judicious and prudent with our taxpayers’ resources to turn around and
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
16
spend it right away. Normally money that is not being used goes to a capital fund and not an operating fund and he
is looking at a recommendation for $1 million to go to the school’s operating fund. Ms. Donna Witt explained that
there are several items that are not at the level to be capitalized and are funded thro ugh the school’s operating fund.
They are one-time expenses such as rugs and blinds but do not rise to the level to be capitalized.
Councilmember Helgeson likes saving the $1.2 million for the task force recommendations but would like to
see it bumped up. The athletic field could be built but then more money could be saved for the recommendations of
the task force. He thinks the need for the athletic field is very evident but he does not understand the rush to spend
the rest of it.
Councilmember Nelson noted his wife is a principal of one of the Lynchburg elementary schools. He does not
think that this type of funding would impact her school or any of the schools to any degree. To the extent that there
may be the appearance of a conflict, he discloses that he can be unbiased and without prejudice in voting and
discussing this. He has been advised by both the Commonwealth and City attorneys that there is no legal conflict of
interest.
Councilmember Wilder asked the City Manager if she and the school administration negotiated this
compromise together. Ms. Svrcek said it is the City’s recommendation but she did have a conversation with the
school superintendent. She cannot speak to whether or not they are in agreement but they did have a conversati on.
Dr. Edwards indicated they are willing to compromise. Councilmember Wilder thinks the list of items is all things
that will make our school system better. You want to keep your budget to a certain size but when you have some
extra funds, there are always things that have been put on the back burner that you need. He was on the School
Board for nine years and knows that there were always things they had to postpone because they did not have the
funds at that time. He does not think this list is “fluff.” It is all things that are needed for the kids to better their
education and make the schools even better.
Councilmember Helgeson noted that the auditor said that the health insurance reserve for schools can be
decreased because of its claims experience. Ms. Witt explained that the approximately $400,000 requested by
schools for the health insurance reserve is being earmarked for the recommendations of the school task force.
Vice Mayor Dolan thanked staff for their work on this. She thinks all these projects are really needed. She
thinks it is a great compromise.
Mayor Tweedy said she appreciates all the advocates of the schools here today. The task force is doing some
good work and we are looking for great outcomes. She thinks we need to supp ort that financially.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6
Noes: Helgeson 1
// In the matter of Budget – Bonds, Agenda Item #12, a public hearing was conducted regarding the proposed
adoption of a resolution to authorize the City to contract a debt and issue General Obligation Public Improvement
Bonds of the City (the “Bonds”) in the principal amount not to exceed $32,000,000 to finance the costs of the
acquisition, construction, reconstruction, improvement, extension, enlargement, equipping, rehabilitation and repair
of various public improvement projects of and for the City) including related design and architectural and
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
17
engineering services and underwriting compensation and other costs of issuance of such Bonds), including, but not
limited to, the Lakeside Drive bridge project, acquisition of fleet vehicles, transportation projects, school
improvement projects, sewer improvement projects, water improvement pro jects, construction, renovation and
improvements to various City buildings, parks and recreation projects, economic development projects, and
stormwater improvement projects (collectively, the “Projects”). The Resolution will also authorize the City to is sue
its general obligation public improvement bond anticipation notes of the City, if any, in an amount not to exceed
$32,000,000 in order to provide short-term financing for the Projects in anticipation of the issuance of the Bonds
and to reduce the annual debt service requirements of the City.
Ms. Witt reminded them the Davenport & Company gave Council a report last month to explain the plan and to
permanently finance the current line of credit and also to borrow not to exceed $32 million for the design and
construction of Lakeside Drive Bridge at College Lake Dam. The resolution that Council is asked to consider gives
latitude to fund other projects should the bridge project come in under budget or be delayed. The maximum interest
rate that we could move forward with this bond issuance is 5 percent. Because the permanent financing of the line
of credit was included in the original resolution to establish the line of credit, Council is not required to do a separate
resolution for it.
There were no speakers either in favor or in opposition to the petition. Mayor Tweedy closed the public hearing
portion of the petition.
Councilmember Perrow made a motion, which was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to approve the first
resolution. Councilmember Perrow asked Ms. Witt what our target rate is for the interest rate. She said we are
hoping to be at about 2.25 percent. Councilmember Perrow commented we are taking what amounts to credit card
debt and now make that loan permanent. This is a very prudent measure to be taking. Councilmember Wilder
thought Councilmember Perrow explained it perfectly.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
Ms. Witt explained the second resolution is to appropriate the actual cost of issuance to do this bond issue.
Councilmember Perrow made a motion, which was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to approve the second
resolution. In answer to a question from Councilmember Helgeson, Ms. Witt said this is to pay for bond counsel,
the bond rating agencies, our financial advisor fee, official statement preparation and any other miscellaneous
expenditures with this issuance. It is estimated high just in case.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of City Code, Agenda Item #13, a public hearing was conducted regarding the Consideration of
adding a new section 36-178 to the Code of the City of Lynchburg, 1981, relating to the establishment of a
Commercial Property Assessed Clean Energy (C-PACE) Financing Program. Pursuant to the C-PACE Act, any
Virginia locality may enact an ordinance authorizing a C-PACE program to provide C-PACE loans for the initial
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
18
acquisition and installation of eligible clean energy, resiliency, and/or stormwater management improvements with
willing owners of qualifying properties, which may include renovations to existing improvements or new
construction.
Ms. Anna Bentson from Economic Development gave a summary of the proposed ordinance to Council. It is
enabled by Virginia statute and established by local governments that allow property owners to fi nance energy
efficiency, water conservation and renewable energy projects. Property owners receive long -term 100 percent
financing from qualified capital providers and repay that loan through a special voluntary real estate assessment.
Eligible activities include renovations to existing improvements or new construction. City staff has also provided a
recommended standard financing agreement. Economic Development believes this is another tool in the tool kit to
encourage rehabilitation and renovation of older buildings in the City and sustainable development practices.
Locally, they have seen interest from developers.
Simon Burgess from Winston-Salem, North Carolina came forward to speak. His development company,
Mayfair Street Partners, is looking to invest in Lynchburg. They support the C-PACE program and think it would
be a great fiscal benefit for Lynchburg. He thinks it would incentivize and motivate other developers and investors
to enter the Lynchburg market.
There were no other speakers either in favor or in opposition to the petition. Mayor Tweedy closed the public
hearing portion of the petition.
Councilmember Wright moved for approval of the ordinance. The motion was seconded by Councilmember
Perrow. Councilmember Wright thinks this will be a valuable addition to our economic development toolbox and it
will hopefully incentivize folks to make more investments in our community, especially since the City has no
liability in this question. Councilmember Perrow thinks this is an excellent opportunity for economic development
and growth of our tax base without raising our tax rate. He asked Mr. Erwin if this language is derived directly from
state code. Mr. Erwin said it is based on the language but is a little more detailed than what is in the state code. It is
modeled after some organizations and other localities in order to meet Lynchburg’s needs. Councilmember Perrow
thinks this is a great starting point and there is always the ability to tweak it later.
Councilmember Helgeson asked if there has been negative downside in places where this has been tried.
Mr. Jeff Bandy said the energy efficiency aspect is superior with the lien status just below real estate taxes. The
construction person would get a better rate on financing for it. The yield on these projects is not very good unless
they use these types of things along with tax credits. Mr. Bandy said there is quite a bit of risk with renovation
projects and this helps to mitigate that risk somewhat. In answer to a question f rom Councilmember Helgeson,
Mr. Bandy said there is no risk to our City or our taxpayers.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #14, Curt Diemer addressed Council and presented it with a
petition with 1,500 signature that requests it support making Lynchburg a Second Amendment Sanctuary City.
They would like Council to uphold the Constitution and the constitution of the State of Virginia and protect Second
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
19
Amendment rights being threatened by the governor. He feels that a person’s safety is mainly their responsibility
and cannot be passed on to public safety individuals, no matter how good they are. He does not want citizens to be
turned into Class C felons or have self-protection possibly grandfathered for him and then taken away from his kids
and grandkids because he cannot pass his gun on to them. He would like them to pass a Sec ond Amendment
sanctuary resolution and keep Lynchburg what it is, a relatively safe place to live. Trust the citizens to partner with
the public safety professionals. He would like them to let Richmond that we will never give up the tools that we
need to protect our families. This is not a Republican or Democratic issue. It is a “life or death” issue. He would
like them to make this a sanctuary city like 47 other cities and counties in Virginia have done.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #15, Roger Fons addressed Council about why he feels the right to
bear arms is so high on the list. Detroit made concealed weapons legal and reduced the death rate by 22 percent. He
said Council has allowed criminals to post lower bonds so they are back to what they were. He had a demonstration
to make for them with dowel rods. Together they could not be broken but when several of them are taken away, one
by one, they are able to be broken. The dowel rods together represent the Constitution.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #16, Isaiah Knight addressed Council on behalf of Virginia
Families Political Action Committee. He expressed that our civil liberties need to be protected against all attacks.
He pointed out that law enforcement officers carry weapons with more than 10 rounds. He feels he should be
allowed the same opportunity to protect his family and eliminate a threat. If not, how is this equal protection under
the law? The red flag laws are another form of tyranny proposed that would allow someone to remove property by
force ex parte without the ability to defend yourself, which violates several of our constitutional rights. Every
surrounding county has pledged to uphold its oath of office by doing all in their power to protec t its citizens
constitutional rights. Lynchburg is a desert island in a sea of liberty right now. He asked them to protect their
citizens and their constitutional rights or they will all remember on Election Day.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #17, Nathan Cantu addressed Council. The idea of Lynchburg
being torn apart by gun violence scares him. He wants himself and his family to feel safe and not live in fear. We
all want the same things, which is why we have laws. We all know there are evil individuals from which we need to
protect ourselves but we disagree on how we stop them. He and others in this room have decided to seek out the
same tools and training that law enforcement uses every day. The new laws being proposed will remove the access
of private citizens to the best tools possible to defend our communities against evil people. The laws are
unconstitutional and vague and will criminalize otherwise law abiding citizens. Healthy communities are built on
trust and these laws demonstrate a lack of trust in its citizens by the General Assembly. He urges Council to send
and signal its disapproval of its legislative agenda with a resolution that states that, if passed, that these gun laws
will not be enforced in the City of Lynchburg.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #18, Ryan Thomas addressed Council. He commented that when
Senate Bill 16 passes, hundreds of thousands of otherwise peaceful and law abiding citizens will be rendered felons
with the stroke of a pen. It will mean punishment in the extreme for something that harms no one and for something
that has been practiced in this state for centuries. If Senate Bill 16 was really predicated on promoting public safety,
it would have targeted handguns, which are used in the overwhelming majority of homicides. He challenges Moms
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
20
Demand Action to either openly admit that they want to forcibly deprive them of legally acquired property, which is
explicitly protected by the federal and state constitutions or speak out a gainst Senate Bill 16 with them. He employs
City Council to do the right thing and make Lynchburg a Second Amendment Sanctuary City. These laws would be
an illegitimate dictate and we are morally obligated to treat it as such.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #19, citizen asked to be removed from the agenda.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #20, Craig Storrs, Jr., addressed Council. He commented that
Democrats are learning that their victories have consequences across Virginia. They have galvanized gun owners in
a way not seen before. Mr. Storrs was part of making Liberty University a gun friendly university. It was predicted
that Liberty would turn into the Wild West and that has been proven cataclysmically wrong. Co uncil’s power comes
from the people in this City and he wants to believe that they understand that the people have the right to defend
themselves as they see fit, not as the government sees fit. The same people that say that being a Second Amendment
Sanctuary City is not worth the paper it is written on are the same people that argue for localities to become
sanctuary cities for illegal immigration. If a locality can refuse cooperation with ICE, it can certainly refuse to
enforce unconstitutional gun laws.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #21, Jamie Cash addressed Council. He feels that people blame
the gun when a mass shooting happens but it is a person to blame. There is one officer per 500 Lynchburg residents.
This is not about hunting. It is about protection. He gives gun classes and the most given reason for people taking
his class is to protect themselves and their families. He listed several cities with the strictest gun laws but also the
highest crime rates. He reiterated that the proposed laws are against the U.S. Constitution as well as the constitution
of Virginia.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #22, Damien Miller addressed Council. The main point he made
is that it takes time for the police to arrive and it is an unfair expectation that they can get there within seconds. The
average is seven to ten minutes. It is his responsibility and his alone to protect his own life and his wellbeing and
those of his loved ones. The laws being filed in Richmond seek to limit the ability of guns to be used in the role of
force equalizers. Mr. Miller asks them to consider if it is fair to expect people to be able to defend themselves in
violent situations with the guns to which they are being limited. He would ask the m not to let the lawmakers in
Richmond to strip the defenseless of the only tool they have at their disposal to stand against evil men and to stand
with neighboring counties and make Lynchburg a Second Amendment Sanctuary City.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #23, Mike Sharrett addressed Council. Councilmember Nelson
asked the speakers to state their jurisdiction. Mr. Sharrett said he is from Ward II. The bills will restrict rights and
also set dangerous precedent for lack of due process during enforcement because of the red flag component. There
will be inevitable economic repercussions that may be long lasting, including the credit rating and appetite for future
bond offerings, if Lynchburg does not declare itself a Second Amendment Sanctuary City. Tourism, retail and
dining revenues in Lynchburg may suffer because some people do not travel to cities that have adverse gun laws.
Portable businesses will relocate to counties that have become sanctuaries. Imagine the outflow of home sale s to
surrounding counties when the option to protect your constitutional rights is simply the zip code where you buy a
home. Our country does not forget its history particularly when it comes to violating the Bill of Rights. He would
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
21
also ask them to think about police recruitment, which is already difficult. It will become more difficult when they
have to disarm law abiding citizens. The citizens of Lynchburg are more aware when each of you are up for
reelection whether you stand for our right to defend ourselves. It has never been something he considered until now.
Council has a responsibility to protect its citizens from unconstitutional federal and state laws being enforced.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #24, citizen asked to be r emoved from the agenda.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #25, citizen asked to be removed from the agenda.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #26, Karch Frankenfield addressed Council. He used to live in
Lynchburg and now lives really close to the line in Campbell County. The decision we have to make is the place for
guns in our modern society. The horror we have seen with mass shootings is a terrible basis for sound decisions.
Data is pretty strongly the best thing that we have and he provided some statistics to demonstrate that there are far
more people that attribute a gun to their being live as those that were murdered by one. He provided statistics to
show that more people would attribute a gun being used in self-defense as those attacked by one. He had many
statistics to show that guns are good in the hands of the majority of citizens. We should not restrict gun rights for
fear of a violent offender and Lynchburg should become a Second Amendment Sanctuary City.
// In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #27, Katie Webb Cyphert addressed Council. She is a Lynchburg
resident and a gun owner. On one side we have people horrified by guns and on the other side we have people that
declare every gun legislation to be unconstitutional confiscation. The fact is that most of us are in the middle. The
middle supports background checks. A person who is a danger to himself, herself or others could have their guns
stored by the police and when he or she is stabilized, he or she deserves due process to get their guns back. Children
should be taught gun safety and awareness. Senate Bill 16 goes too far and restricts our hunting and marksmen
communities but so does this. Localities are pledging to refuse enforcement measures that hearken back to our
terrible history of massive resistance. We will not solve these issues tonight and people are asking our legislators to
thread the needle carefully. The path forward will take discussions and considering impacts of proposed legi slation.
We get that through civil dialogue with legislators in Richmond. City Council has been careful with its legislative
agenda in the past requesting changes to code that have specific local fiscal impact and she asks that this body retain
that moderate stance.
// In the matter of the Legislative Agenda, Agenda Item #28, Council considered a resolution amending City
Council’s 2020 General Assembly Legislative Agenda to include language regarding the right of citizens to keep
and bear arms. Councilmember Helgeson noted that the discussion today is great and everyone on Council
obviously wants less criminal activity and less violence against citizens. We can unify and recognize that we are all
pulling the oars in the same direction for a safer community. The role of government is to enforce against evil and
not against good and our framers really put that through. It is nice that it has been protected for so long.
Councilmember Helgeson spent some time talking about the analogy of sheep (who are the good people) and wolves
(who are the bad people) and sheepdogs who protect. Sometimes the sheep look at the wolves and sheepdogs being
equally evil because they both carry guns. Councilmember Helgeson gave credit for this illustration to retired
Lieutenant Colonel Dave Grossman.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
22
Councilmember Helgeson thinks it is important for Lynchburg to look at these bills because they are telling the
sheepdogs to go do the opposite and not protect the sheep but go after and arrest the sheep. Someone that proposes
that type of legislation—to him, that is truly evil. This legislation will take 180 good officers and make them have a
choice and he thinks it is a terrible choice. He thinks we can clarify and classify which laws to enforce and back our
police officers. Some of these people have never committed a crime and now they are going to be classified as a
felon with the stroke of a pen. Council has an opportunity today to tell our legislators that we back our police
officers. One of our elected legislators has already said he supports it. Two of our State Senators say they support
it. Other delegates in the area say that they support it. It is not a tough ask to add this to our legislative agenda. We
can take it a step forward but he will yield for now. There is a lot more they can do in Lynchburg because he would
like to see less victims. This is not just about the Constitution. It actually affects us and affects our men in blue.
Let’s back our sheepdogs and let them do what they are trained to do and uphold their oath that they are sworn to
uphold.
Councilmember Perrow thanked Councilmember Helgeson for his well-spoken remarks. He thanked everyone
in attendance for the way they have conducted themselves. This is a civil discourse and could have been a rowdy
affair. It makes him proud to be a resident citizen of Lynchburg. Councilmember Perrow said we have an
opportunity and need to send a message to the Governor, Lieutenant Governor and Attorney General. He thinks
they should have taken a look at this when they first looked at their legislative agenda. Maybe we should go further
with amendments to this legislative agenda to protect right-to-work, which affects our financing and our budgetary
process.
Councilmember Perrow would like to make a motion for Option A: Public Safety: Oppose any additional
legislation infringing on the right of its citizens to keep and bear arms. New legislation is ill advised due to the
pending court cases that may have a significant impact on any proposed legislation. The motion was seconded by
Councilmember Helgeson. Councilmember Perrow asked if he could read a statement on behalf of Congressman
Ben Cline. He kept the statement germane to the subject and read a statement from him that is in support of a
citizen’s right to bear arms. Councilmember Perrow very much appreciates the opportunity to take a firm stance
supporting the citizens of Lynchburg. Our voice provides a powerful influence in Richmond. It is important to send
a message that encroachment on our constitutional rights is unacceptable. Our founding fathers thought that the
right to keep and bear arms was so important that they made it the Second Amendment. Councilmember Perrow
disagrees that guns kill people. People kill people. Freedom of religion is protected by the First Amendment but
some religious sects support terrorism. We support the First Amendment but do not argue that some religious sects
should be suppressed because it is one of the fundamental principles upon which our country was fou nded.
He submits that the Second Amendment should be treated the same way and not be infringed upon. He would
submit that all our articles and its amendments be treated with the same respect. If there is a need to modify the
Constitution, Article 5 instructs us how to do so. He stands by the way it was written and by the oath he took as an
elected official to uphold it. He hopes Council will join them in supporting the motion they put forward and the
citizens of Lynchburg.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
23
Councilmember Nelson thanked everyone for being there and speaking very clearly and understandably. The
Second Amendment Sanctuary movement implies that Lynchburg should not comply with state laws that it deems to
restrict the Second Amendment liberties. As a subdivision of the Commonwealth of Virginia, Lynchburg must
comply with all of Virginia’s laws. Councilmembers took an oath to obey the Constitution and all of Virginia’s
laws. Lynchburg could express its concerns by becoming a Second Amendment Sanctuary City but it cannot
lawfully be enforced. Council’s rules and procedures also demand that we not express opinions on theoretical issues
or those beyond our jurisdictional authority. He sees no reason for them to now deviate from those protocols. If
Richmond enacts laws offensive to us, we can resort to a very sound judicial system to redress our grievances.
He affirmed that the Second Amendment is as significant as any other constitutional right. Nevertheless,
rational limitations have been repeatedly authorized upon all constitutional rights for more than two centuries. The
standard of review by the Supreme Court applies a strict scrutiny test to the targeted law. It has to promote a
compelling governmental purpose, has to be crafted in its narrowest fashion and has to adopt the least restrictive
means to accomplish the compelling governmental purpose. Councilmember Nelson is reasonably confident that the
primary purpose of every firearm is either to kill, main or destroy someone or something. He is equally confident
that firearms have increasingly been designed and produced to inflict death and destruction in volumes and at rates
that are far greater than those familiar to the 18th Century authors of our Constitution and Bill of Rights. Reducing
or preventing harm to innocent people is a compelling governmental purpose. There is debate on how to do this and
preserve the Second Amendment, but weapons should certainly be kept out of the hands of the mentally ill and those
expressing a clear intent to harm others.
Previous attempts such as the Second Amendment Sanctuary City resolution have been attempted and have
been shown to be unlawful. There was the practice of massive resistance in the 1950s and 1960s in Virginia
requiring localities to racially integrate their public schools. The judiciary is the third branch of government by
which legal disputes are to be resolved. This is not a conflict to be resolved by Councils or Boards of Supervisors.
The U.S. Supreme Court is considering whether to adjudicate a former New York City ordinance that required a
license to possess a firearm. They had to keep the gun in their home unless they were transporting it to a firing
range by the most direct and uninterrupted route. If the Supreme Court renders a decision on the merit s of that case,
the legal standards for testing the constitutional validity of a law affecting the Second Amendment may change what
is being considered by the passage of some of the Virginia Assembly bills such as Senate Bill 16. The Supreme
Court’s decision next summary may invalidate whatever the General Assembly does. Lynchburg could possibly be
caught in a bind if the court decision and the legislature do not coincide.
He would like the motion to be amended as follows: “The City of Lynchburg oppos es any legislation directly
impacting the Second Amendment of the Constitution until the U.S. Supreme Court resolves issues presented in the
New York City Second Amendment case now pending before it.” Councilmember Perrow accepted the amendment
because he thought it accomplishes the intent of his motion. It clarifies and puts a finer point on the original motion.
Councilmember Wright thanked everyone for their attendance tonight and their powerful testimony. He thinks
this is an important and people have strong feelings about it for very good reason. We need to be having this
conversation about firearms and our rights as a community with each and with their state and national legislators.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
24
He is not going to comment on the bills in state legislature because he feels this is a state and national issue. It is a
constitutional issue and Council has no legal authority to affect it. If a resolution is passed, it would carry no legal
weight and case law bears that out. We have to enforce the state laws. That is their job and their oath. We can
disagree and that is why we have elections so we can vote out the people that put those laws in place. That is also
why we have a judicial system so the courts can bear out whether or not that law is constitution al. City Council
traditionally stays out of partisan political debates and he thinks that is a wise policy. It is not their job to get
involved in national and state level debates. Their job is to fix potholes, work on public schools and think about
what our community’s needs are and try to address them. The only thing we would do by passing a resolution is to
say what our community thinks and feels and the community is divided on this question. Passing a resolution would
be divisive for this community and why do that if we cannot actually control this issue. He strongly encourages
folks to reach out to their state and congressional representatives to let them know how they feel so they can enact
laws that respond to their will. Councilmember Wright will be doing that himself.
Councilmember Wilder thanked everyone for their comments. He thinks it is so important to honor the Second
Amendment. He will be deferring to our state legislators. He has not read any of the bills that have been proposed
and talk to our legislators about them. He thanked everyone and said their voice has been heard.
Vice Mayor Dolan thanked everyone and said she appreciated the respectful participation. She thought all her
colleagues had very powerful statements to make that going forward will be very helpful. She strongly feels that
this is a matter for the constitutional scholars and for the state and national legislative bodies. Without a clear
mandate from the majority of our constituents, she finds it problematic to add this piece to our legislative agenda.
The statement gives the appearance that we are representing the voice of the majority and as you can see here this
evening the majority did not show up for reasons that she is not sure of. New gun laws will have to pass
constitutional muster and the rule of law will prevail. From a practical standpoint, this is a meaningless gesture
without a compelling reason that only serves to be divisive.
Councilmember Helgeson said he can appreciate the concepts and the punting. The founders of this document
made it not legalese. They made it the people’s document that we can read it and understand it. We are a compound
republic. We are a branch of the government and do not just punt because we have local legislative aut hority of our
budget. We can tell our City Manager and our police department not to enforce unconstitutional laws. We have to
stand in this gap because this affects us locally. Apparently we need to hear from more citizens and he has asked the
City Manager to schedule a public hearing for January 14, 2020 to decide whether the City should become a Second
Amendment Sanctuary City. It does not need to be a motion. Two City Councilmembers can request a public
hearing. Councilmember Perrow said he would be supportive in listening to the public voice.
Councilmember Perrow went back to the motion on the table. He appreciates Councilmember Wright’s point
about trying to stay out of larger affairs but there has been a real up swale in this and we have a peti tion with several
hundred signatures. He is responding to the citizens demanding that Council take this up by proposing this motion.
He is confident that he is representing the principles of Ward IV by bringing this forward.
Councilmember Nelson wanted to respond to Councilmember Wright’s comment that we have no legal weight.
We have no legal weight in enacting legislation in Richmond but we certainly have legal weight with regard to what
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
25
happens in Lynchburg. But what happens in Richmond can affect what happens in Lynchburg. The facts of the
case in New York are very similar to what might be the facts of the Virginia statute if those proposed bills end up
being enacted. The Supreme Court is going to decide on the ownership of a magazine of a certai n quantity and the
Supreme Court is going to give the entire country its standard as to how those types of laws are going to be looked
at. Lynchburg could be shackled by having to spend the money to file a lawsuit to have the state l aw declared
unconstitutional. He does not want our budget money to be used to attack a statute that is unconstitutional when it
could have been written properly by waiting for the Supreme Court’s order to be known. He knows that legislators
try to find a common ground. Rather than issue a blanket prohibition or completely ban something, they license or
permit it and look at why the right of ownership should be allowed to some people but denied to others. He thinks
the state legislature would be wise to hold off until the Supreme Court case has been decided. He would like to see
the citizens of Lynchburg talking to the legislators in Richmond in January because that is a direct communication to
the folks that are going to have the authority to make a decision not us. He would like it on our legislative agenda so
we can move it along to the appropriate venues.
Mayor Tweedy asked Ms. Svrcek to explain our rules about the public hearing process. The rules of procedure
state that unless required by law, no item will be scheduled for a public hearing unless by unanimous consent or the
vote of a majority of the council. Mr. Erwin concurred that what she read is correct.
Mayor Tweedy said she will not be supporting the motion. She appreciates the passion and opinions on all
sides but believes this is a matter for our legislators to decide. To take this on the lo cal level is premature to her and
not giving our legislators the opportunity to do their job at the state level. She is not willing to commit this body or
a future Council to stand against our state legislative body before giving them the opportunity to d o their due
diligence. She believes that no action is the best action right now for our City. She has heard from many people on
all sides even if they were not all equally represented here tonight. She is not a fearful person and does not believe
there is false evidence appearing real to her. She called for a vote on the motion and Councilmember Helgeson
asked if they could then bring a motion regarding a public hearing. She said another motion could certainly be
brought forward at that time. The motion regarding the legislative agenda failed by the following vote:
Ayes: Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow 3
Noes: Dolan, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 4
Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to have a public hearing about making Lynchburg a S econd
Amendment Sanctuary so we can hear from the citizens that were not here today. Councilmember Perrow seconded
the motion. Councilmember Perrow thought they would have to have the meeting at the E C Glass Auditorium.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow 4
Noes: Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 3
// In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #29, Council considered introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2020
General Fund budget and appropriate $32,585 with resources from the General Fund Reserve for Contingencies to
provide funding to the Electoral Board/Registrar’s Office for estimated costs associated with the March 3, 2019
Democratic Presidential and City Council Primary. A third quarter budget request may occur due to a possible U.S.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
26
Senate or U.S. House of Representative Primary in June. Councilmember Helgeson said it came to the Finance
Committee and the committee made recommendation for approval and he brings it forward as a motion.
Prior to the motion being voted on, Vice Mayor Dolan announced that she had voted incorrectly on the motion
to hold a public hearing on the Second Amendment Sanctuary City. Mr. Erwin said it would be proper to go ahead
and vote on the motion on the table regarding the budget item and then return to Vice Mayor Dolan. The motion
passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of a reconsideration of the vote taken on the public hearing, Vice Mayor Dolan indicated that she had
made a mistake in her vote. Mr. Erwin said Council’s rules of procedure are for their convenience. If a member
makes a mistake in their vote, he has never known City Council to try to hold someone to a vote. He thinks it would
be appropriate for a motion to be made to retake the vote. Councilmember Helgeson said he cannot tolerate or abide
changing the vote after everyone has left thinking they are having a public hearing. If a mistake was made, what is
the harm in having a public hearing? Vice Mayor Dolan thought he was painting a picture that was not quite
accurate. As soon as she realized she made a mistake, she went to the Clerk o f Council to see what she should do
but everyone was leaving.
Councilmember Wright moved the motion as a matter of courtesy that it sounds like we have traditionally
afforded to other councilmembers. Councilmember Wilder seconded the motion. Councilme mber Perrow
understands making a mistake but we were at capacity and the public saw the vote. He thinks it is a bad idea and if
we take a revote, he hopes they choose to go forward with the public hearing because he feels there is a commitment
out there. Mr. Erwin explained that this is a motion to essentially wipe out the previous vote and take up the issue
again. Councilmember Nelson agreed everyone was here in mass. If the public was unaware that the decision had
been reversed that would be one thing but there will be more than a month before the meeting was set. He has faith
in our media to communicate that it was a mistake and nothing clandestine or deceptive. The fact that the public
was here should not influence them. They were not participating in our discussion. It is somewhat of a moot point
as to their involvement. It is unfortunate but he would support a revote. The motion to reconsider passed by the
following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Nelson, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 5
Noes: Helgeson, Perrow 2
Councilmember Perrow made a motion to have a public hearing to address the Second Amendment City at our
earliest convenience. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Helgeson. Councilmember Perrow would like
those that did not vote for it the first time to be considerate of the group that was here and the citizens of Lynchburg
and go ahead and have a public hearing. Councilmember Helgeson thought they had a good dialogue. He heard
from people that do not want the City to be a Second Amendment Sanctuary City so he would like to hear from
them. It never hurts to hear from our citizens and he hopes Vice Mayor Dolan will vote to have a public hearing
even though she made a mistake the first time. Vice Mayor Dolan said she did not support a public hearing because
those against did not show up tonight for obvious reasons because they were afraid they were going to be harassed.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
27
There were a number of citizens that dropped off the agenda because they heard what happened in o ther areas. She
thinks they will hear from the same people at a public hearing and hear the same stuff we heard tonight.
Councilmember Helgeson is not sure how she can make assumptions about certain people acting like they are
violent. There was zero level of violence tonight. They were respectful. It is all safe and secure and it’s what we
do. We hear from people. He would love to hear from them and they will be gladly escorted in by people that want
to protect them.
Councilmember Wilder thinks that if they have another public hearing, they will not get anything different but
he is uncomfortable with people leaving here thinking we were going to have a public hearing and now we are going
to change it. Right now our nation is so divided and has so many issues, it is challenging. He feels like they need to
have a public hearing and let persons voice their concerns. He would prefer to wait until the General Assembly
presents something but it is important for our citizens to have a platform. He doe s not want to give people the
wrong impression of what we did because they might not understand what happened.
Councilmember Wright would like to reassert that everyone here is of good intent and we are not trying to
diminish anyone or their voice or perspective or cast anyone as a bad person. This is one of those issues where
people can disagree and disagreement is okay. He thinks that is important to say because we might be moving into
territory that might be demonizing of certain folks or their opinions. We should keep things civil and recognize that
as rational friends, we can disagree.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Wilder 4
Noes: Dolan, Tweedy, Wright 3
// In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #30, Council considered introducing a resolution approving the issuance of
up to $28,000,000 in taxexempt revenue bonds for the rehabilitation of the James Crossing Apartments located at
808 Greenfield Drive through the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA). Mr. Richard L.
Hurlbert, Jr., Bond Counsel and Mr. Herschel Keller, Attorney, LRHA were present to address Council. Mr. Keller
commented that Atlantic Housing Foundation has asked LRHA to issue these low-income housing finance bonds to
renovate the James Crossing Apartments. Council has approved these types of bond issues previously for other
projects. Mr. Hurlbert clarified that the action is for Council to adopt a resolution to approve LRHA to issue up to
$28 million in multifamily revenue bonds. LRHA has been very thorough in its process. LRHA will serve as a
conduit bond issuer. The bonds do not represent a debt of LRHA except in the context of the repayment source
being the revenues generated by the operation of the project. They are not a general obligation of LRHA or the City.
There is no pledge over the faith and credit or taxing power of the City involved this particular issue. The resolution
also includes approval of a standalone agreement between the City, LRHA and the owner of the property to ensure
that there would always be a dialogue and this agreement establishes the guidelines for that dialogue.
Councilmember Perrow, who is also the Chair of the Housing Authority, commented t hat the Housing
Authority had an opportunity to review this and he thinks the key takeaway is the agreement. He thinks the
agreement is a key component because they have seen these types of projects fall into disrepair over time. This
agreement open channels of communication and will help facilitate the way this redeveloped center is managed.
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
28
The City is being an active partner because this is a troubled neighborhood and this is an opportunity for the City to
engage. Councilmember Perrow is very pleased with what the developer has brought to the table and the discussion
really made him feel comfortable with the services and plans for the redevelopment. It gives him a lot of hope for
James Crossing in the future. He thanked the developer for their propo sed investment in the property.
Councilmember Perrow made a motion to move the resolution forward, which was seconded by Councilmember
Wright. Mayor Tweedy recognized Mr. French and thanked him for sitting through this evening’s agenda.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of City Code, Agenda Item #31, Council considered adopting an ordinance to regulate the use of
shared mobility devices such as electric power-assisted scooters, skateboards, bicycles, etc. within the City.
Mr. Erwin reminded them the state legislation is giving localities the ability to regulate these devices but the
ordinance needs to be on the books by the end of this year. He has revised the ordinance to reflect Council’s
requests from the November 12, 2019 meeting.
Councilmember Wright is satisfied with the changes made to the ordinance and they address his concerns. He
made a motion to adopt the ordinance. Vice Mayor Dolan seconded the motion. Councilmember Helgeson
appreciates Mr. Erwin adding some items but he thought it was supposed to be as miniscule as possible.
Councilmember Wright thought that some of these items were areas of concern by other co uncilmembers because
they are safety issues. Councilmember Helgeson is concerned with having some of these items being offenses, such
as wearing earbuds and riding on the sidewalk. Mr. Erwin said this was added at the request of some of the
councilmembers and he thinks it is a public safety issue. He came across a report that 47 cities have reported over
1,500 accidents. He does not think there is anything inappropriate about saying that we want our police officers to
make sure that people do not do things like text or operate these devices while under the influence. He clarified that
they would be misdemeanor offences with no jail time and just a fine of up to $500 at the discretion of the court.
Councilmember Helgeson thinks there are many laws on the books that are not enforced. He thought they were
going to tread lightly because there are a lot of benefits of these devices.
Councilmember Perrow said he would be supporting this because it is important to get something on the books.
It may not be perfect but we can certainly change it and tweak it once we have some situations that actually arise.
He thinks the safety measures are a way for the police officers to charge someone with improper use in case there is
an accident.
The motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6
Noes: Helgeson 1
// In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #32, Council considered introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2020
City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $215,474 with resources from the Commonwealth of Virginia
Department of Social Services (VDSS) through the Employment Advancement for Temp orary Assistance for Needy
Families (TANF) Participants Community Wealth Building (CWB) Gra nt. Mr. John Hughes said the idea for
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
29
expansion of poverty reduction strategy includes but is not limited to the Higher Lynchburg Initiative Partnership
with the Lynchburg Office of Economic Development and Tourism, as well as other job readiness training and
internships with local stakeholders and direct intervention with eligible City of Lynchburg residents.
On behalf of the Finance Committee, Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to approve the resolution. The
motion passed by the following vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// In the matter of City Council, Agenda Item #33, Council considered approving a support resolution for Holiday
Lake 4-H Educational Center to the Commonwealth of Virginia for funding capital improvement projects.
Ms. Svrcek explained that Mr. Preston Wilson, President/CEO of Holiday Lake 4-H Education Center is requesting
support of the attached resolution as part of its application to the Virginia General Assembly for $332,000 in
essential capital safety improvements. Holiday Lake 4-H Educational Center serves nineteen (19) Virginia localities
and many have supported this resolution.
Councilmember Perrow said this is a very good local, convenient spot for all Lynchburg families to visit and he
sees no reason not to support it. It supports recreation in our area. Councilmember Perrow made a motion to
approve the resolution, which was seconded by Councilmember Wilder and passed by the fol lowing vote:
Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7
Noes: 0
// Ms. Svrcek asked for direction on where Council would like to hold the public hearing on January 14, 2020.
Mayor Tweedy would like to hold the meeting for purposes of being able to televise it. Councilmember Perrow said
he would defer operationally to staff. He does not think it is a policy issue. Ms. Svrcek said she would consult with
the police department. Councilmember Helgeson said it would be his preference to hold it somewhere other than a
public school because they are “gun free” zones. There are probably places like the Academy or Liberty University
that have ample room and are not “gun free” zones. Mayor Tweedy reiterated that she would like to have it here
because it is a non-partisan, local body public building and because of the ability to televise it live for the viewing
audience.
// The meeting was adjourned at 11:05 p.m.
Clerk of Council
December 10, 2019
AGENDA ITEM #: 3
30
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.