RecordWell Data

City Council Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Oct 22, 2019 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Page 1 of 2 FINANCE COMMITTEE AGENDA Tuesday, October 22, 2019 11:30 a.m. – Bidder’s Room GENERAL BUSINESS 11:30 a.m. 1. Approval of the Draft Finance Committee Meeting Notes from September 24, 2019. Contact: Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer 455-3968 11:35 a.m. 2. Report on the General Fund Reserve for Contingencies. Contact: Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer 455-3968 11:40 a.m. 3. Consider a request to adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 General Fund budget and appropriate $9,429 with resources from the State Compensation Board, Technology Trust Fund fees to support information technology needs in the Office of the Circuit Court. Contact: Eugene C. Wingfield, Circuit Court Clerk 455-2611 11:45 a.m. 4. Consider a request to adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund Budget and appropriate $65,000 for the Lynchburg Adult Drug Treatment Court award with resources from the Supreme Court of Virginia Drug Treatment Court Docket Grant. This grant is administered by the Supreme Court of Virginia. Contact: Eugene C. Wingfield, Circuit Court Clerk 455-2611 11:50 a.m. 5. Consider a request to adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $76,000 with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund water rescue equipment and training for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. Contact: Fire Chief Greg Wormser 455-6340 11:55 a.m. 6. Consider a request to adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $91,750 with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund equipment and training for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. Contact: Fire Chief Greg Wormser 455-6340 12:00 p.m. 7. Consider a request to adopt a resolution to amend the FY2020 City/Federal State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $24,517 with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) Grant through the Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department. Contact: Chief Ryan M. Zuidema 455-6171 Page 2 of 2 12:05 p.m. 8. Consider a request to adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $34,930 with resources from the 2019 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department, Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. Contact: Chief Ryan M. Zuidema 455-6171 12:10 p.m. 9. Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $42,612 with resources of $21,306 from the Bulletproof Vest Partnership 2019 Grant Program and $21,306 transferred from the FY 2020 General Fund Police Department ($18,506) and Sheriff’s Office ($2,800) budgets to purchase replacement bulletproof vests for law enforcement officers. Contact: Chief Ryan M. Zuidema 455-6171 12:15 p.m. 10. Review highlights of attached quarterly financial reports for the Greater Lynchburg Transit Company (GLTC) as well as the Regional Airport, Lynchburg Regional Juvenile Detention Center, Children’s Services Act, Water Operating, Sewer Operating, Stormwater Operating, and General Funds for the quarter ending June 30, 2019. Fund Preparer GLTC Brian Booth, General Manager of GLTC Regional Airport Fund Mark Courtney, Airport Manager Lynchburg Regional Juvenile Detention Center Tamara Rosser, Director of Human Services Children’s Services Act Fund (CSA) Tamara Rosser, Director of Human Services Water Operating Fund Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources Sewer Operating Fund Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources Stormwater Operating Fund Tim Mitchell, Director of Water Resources General Fund Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer 12:55 p.m. 11. Receive a report on the FY 2019 Write-Off of Uncollectible Accounts Receivable. Contact: Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer 455-3968 1:00 p.m. 12. Review collections received from five of the City’s largest revenue sources. Contact: Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer 455-3968 1:05 p.m. 13. Roll Call The next Finance Committee meeting is Tuesday, November 26, 2019, at 11:30 a.m. Page 1 of 2 FINANCE COMMITTEE NOTES-- DRAFT Tuesday, September 24, 2019 GENERAL BUSINESS Meeting commenced at 11:30 a.m. ATTENDEES Committee Members: Council Member Jeff S. Helgeson, Chair; Council Member Randy Nelson; Council Member Beau Wright; Mayor Treney Tweedy, Ex-Officio. Others: Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager; Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer ; Rhonda Allbeck, Assistant Director of Financial Services; Starlette Early, Budget Analyst 1. Approval of the Draft Finance Committee Meeting Notes from August 13, 2019. The meeting notes from August 13, 2019 were approved as submitted. 2. Report on the General Fund Reserve for Contingencies. Donna Witt noted there were no new items since the last report. The FY 2020 Reserve for Contingencies has a balance of $1.2 million, including $50,000 for Manager’s Discretionary Funding. 3. Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $55,335 with resources of $36,890 from the Department of Motor Vehicles Highway Safety Grant, an in-kind service and equipment match of $15,767, and $2,678 transferred from the FY 2020 General Fund Police Department budget to provide selective enforcement activities and attend related training. The Committee approved this item and is scheduled to be considered by full Council at their September 24, 2019 meeting. 4. Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $22,575 with resources of $15,050 from the Department of Motor Vehicles Highway Safety Grant, an in-kind service and equipment match of $6,374, and $1,151 transferred from the FY 2020 General Fund Police Department budget to provide funds for speed enforcement activities. The Committee approved this item and is scheduled to be considered by full Council at their September 24, 2019 meeting. 5. Consider a request to adopt a resolution authorizing the submittal of an application for the 2019 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) in the amount of $34,930 to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department, Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. The Committee approved this item and is scheduled to be considered by full Council at their September 24, 2019 meeting. AGENDA ITEM #: 1 Page 2 of 2 6. Approve the submittal of an application for the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) Grant through the Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) in the amount of $24,517 to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department. The Committee approved this item. 7. Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2019 Detention Home Fund budget to appropriate $17,995 for a welding simulator, and $5,000 for additional supplies for CPP (Community Placement Program) juveniles with resources from the Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice Community Placement Program. The Committee approved this item and is scheduled to be considered by full Council at their September 24, 2019 meeting. 8. Approve the submittal of a grant application to the Virginia Office of Emergency Medical Services – Rescue Squad Assistance Fund (RSAF) for $103,953 with resources of $83,162 from the RSAF grant, $20,791 from the FY 2020 General Fund Fire Department budget to purchase (3) LifePak 15 cardiac monitors for the Fire Department. The Committee approved this item. 9. Review collections received from five of the City’s largest revenue sources. Donna Witt reported on the status of revenue collections received for the month ending June 2019 for five revenues. She noted this report ends the Fiscal Year 2019 collections and, while the month of June did not meet budget expectations, the year ended above budget for all categories except Communications Sales & Use Tax. The monthly comparison report for FY 2020 has been revised to now report monthly Amusement Tax collections, and removed the Communications Sales & Use Tax. Overall, the month of July was slow, with Sales & Use Tax revenue trending down. 10. Roll Call There were no items for roll call. Meeting adjourned at 11:59 a.m. AGENDA ITEM NO.: 2 City Manager's Reserve for Discretionary Contingencies Funding BEGINNING BALANCE, JULY 1, 2019 $1,150,000 $50,000 Carryforward to FY 2020 Reserve for Contingencies - FY 2020 Adopted Budget 0 BALANCE $1,150,000 $50,000 APPROPRIATIONS (Second Reading) TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS $0 $0 REMAINING BALANCE $1,150,000 $50,000 ITEMS INTRODUCED TOTAL INTRODUCED ITEMS $0 $0 REMAINING BALANCE $1,150,000 $50,000 PENDING ITEMS TOTAL PENDING ITEMS $0 $0 PROJECTED BALANCE, JUNE 30, 2020 $1,150,000 $50,000 FY 2020 GENERAL FUND RESERVE FOR CONTINGENCIES October 2019 LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 3 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Technology Trust Fund (TTF) Fees for the Office of the Circuit Court Clerk KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 General Fund budget and appropriate $9,429 with resources from the State Compensation Board, Technology Trust Fund fees to support information technology needs in the Office of the Circuit Court. SUMMARY: As required by the Code of Virginia, Section 17.1-279 – Additional fee to be assessed by circuit court clerks for information technology, “the clerk of each circuit court shall assess a $5 fee, known as the “Technology Trust Fund Fee,” in each civil action, upon each instrument to be recorded in the deed books, and upon each judgment to be docketed in the judgment lien docket book. Such fee shall be deposited by the State Treasurer into a trust fund.” Annually, a portion of this fee is returned to the local Office of the Circuit Court Clerk based on its information technology needs. These funds cannot be used to take the place of current funding supplied by the locality. PRIOR ACTION(S): Finance Committee, October 22, 2019 FISCAL IMPACT: The Adopted FY 2020 General Fund Budget included $25,000 in Technology Trust Fund fees. The actual amount returned to the Office of the Circuit Court Clerk is $34,429, requiring an additional appropriation of $9,429. CONTACT(S): Eugene C. Wingfield, Circuit Court Clerk, 455-2611 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution REVIEWED BY: bms RESOLUTION: BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 General Fund budget is amended and $9,429 is appropriated with resources from the State Compensation Board, Technology Trust Fund fees to support information technology needs in the Office of the Circuit Court Clerk. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 4 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Appropriation of the Local Drug Court Grant KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X__Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community _X_Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund Budget and appropriate $65,000 for the Lynchburg Adult Drug Treatment Court award with resources from the Supreme Court of Virginia Drug Treatment Court Docket Grant. This grant is administered by the Supreme Court of Virginia. SUMMARY: Horizon Behavioral Health submitted a grant application in June of 2019 to the Supreme Court of Virginia with the objective of furthering the City's effort to administer a Local Drug Court program. The Award letter was received from the Supreme Court of Virginia in July, which indicated the Lynchburg Circuit Court was awarded $65,000. Funding is allocated over the remainder of FY 2020. These funds will be used to support the Drug Court Coordinator position in the Circuit Court. The match for the City is 50% (based on a formula, not directly 50% of request). This match will be used for supplies and other expenses associated with the Drug Court Coordinator position. This match was appropriated in the First Quarter Adjustments for FY 2020. PRIOR ACTION(S): Finance Committee, October 22, 2019 FISCAL IMPACT: Local match of $32,858 (formula driven calculation) was appropriated in First Quarter Adjustments for FY 2020 CONTACT(S): Eugene Wingfield, Lynchburg Circuit Court Clerk, 455-2620 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution Award Letter REVIEWED BY: bms RESOLUTION: BE IT RESOLVED THAT the FY 2020 City Federal State Aid budget is amended and $65,000 is appropriated for the Lynchburg Adult Drug Treatment Court award with resources from the Supreme Court of Virginia through the Supreme Court of Virginia Drug Treatment Court Docket Grant. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council S UPREME C OURT OF V IRGINIA O FFICE OF THE E XECUTIVE S ECRETARY 100 N ORTH N INTH S TREET R ICHMOND , V IRGINIA 23219-2334 (804) 786-6455 JUDICIAL INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY Michael J. Riggs, Sr., Director JUDICIAL PLANNING Cyril W. Miller, Jr., Director JUDICIAL SERVICES Paul F. DeLosh, Director LEGAL RESEARCH Steven L. Dalle Mura, Director LEGISLATIVE & PUBLIC RELATIONS Kristi S. Wright, Director MAGISTRATE SERVICES Jonathan E. Green, Director EXECUTIVE SECRETARY Karl R. Hade Assistant Executive Secretary & Legal Counsel Edward M. Macon COURT IMPROVEMENT PROGRAM Sandra L. Karison, Director EDUCATIONAL SERVICES CAROLINE E. KIRKPATRICK , DIRECTOR F ISCAL SERVICES JOHN B. RICKMAN , DIRECTOR HUMAN RESOURCES REN ÉE FLEMING MILLS , DIRECTOR July 16, 2019 Hon. R. Edwin Burnette, Jr., Judge Lynchburg Circuit Court P.O. Box 4 900 Court Street Lynchburg, VA 24505-0004 Supreme Court of Virginia Drug Treatment Court Docket Grant, Title: Lynchburg Adult Drug Treatment Court Dear Judge Burnette: I am pleased to advise you that your grant for the above-refer enced grant program has been approved for $65,000 in State funds for fiscal year 2020. Enclosed you will find a Statement of Grant Award and a Statement of Grant Award Special Conditions. To indicate your acceptance of the award and conditions, please sign the award acceptance and return it to Anna Powers, Drug Treatment Court Coordinator, at the Office of the Executive Secretary (OES). Please review the conditions carefully; as they require action on your part before we will disburse grant funds. Prior to the OES disbursing of funds, the Subrecipient must agree to comply with the following and the attached special conditions: a. Submit the quarterly grant reports by their due date to the Statewide Drug Treatment Court Coordinator. b. Maintain accurate & current data in the new web-based drug treatment court database beginning July 1, 2012. c. Submit a copy of any final federal grant report(s) and/or quarterly reports of any drug court Federal grant funds awarded. When we receive documentation showing that you have complied with the conditions, you will be eligible to request funds awarded under this grant. A REQUEST FOR FUNDS form is also included with this letter and should be used for this purp ose. You may request funds at the same time you submit the documentation of compliance with the g rant conditions or at any time thereafter. However, we cannot process your request until we h ave received and approved all required information. Lynchburg Adult Award Letter July 16, 2019 Page Two We appreciate your interest in this grant program and will be happy to assist you in any way we can to assure your project’s success. If you have any questions, please call Courtney Stewart at 804-356-1064. Yours very truly, Paul F. DeLosh PFD/atp Enclosures cc: Mr. Damien Cabezas, CEO, Horizon Behavioral Health Mr. Andre McDaniel, CFO, Horizon Behavioral Health Karl R. Hade, Executive Secretary Anna Powers, Drug Treatment Court Coordinator LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant: $76,000 for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment _X Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $76,000 with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund water rescue equipment and training for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. SUMMARY: The Fire Department seeks authorization to accept a non-matching grant for technical rescue equipment. The Virginia Department of Emergency Management administers this grant from the United States Department of Homeland Security (DHS) through the State Homeland Security Program (SHSP). The grant program provides funding to improve the nation’s readiness in preventing, protecting against, responding to, recovering from, and mitigating terrorist attacks, major disasters, and other emergencies. The grant reflects DHS’s focus on implementation of an all-of-nation, whole-community approach to building, sustaining, and delivering core capabilities essential to achieving a secure and resilient nation. The Fire Department was awarded $76,000 in pass-through funds from FEMA. These funds were made available to specifically target swift water rescue needs. There was no application process and the department was notified that we would be receiving this money on October 7, 2019 as a result of our commitment to deploy during water-related emergencies, such as hurricanes. The funds are specifically identified for use by the Technical Rescue Team for swift water rescue training, and equipment. This includes, but is not limited to, boats, boat motors, water rescue training, personal protective equipment, and other equipment capable of water rescue. This grant is 100% reimbursable; no local match is required. PRIOR ACTION(S): Finance Committee October 22, 2019 FISCAL IMPACT: None – No local match is required. Future funds may be needed for periodic maintenance of the equipment purchased. CONTACT(S): Fire Chief Greg Wormser, 455-6340 Battalion Chief Sean Regan, 546-1648 Fire Administrative Manager Annette Pettyjohn, 455-6368 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution REVIEWED BY: raw RESOLUTION BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget is amended and $76,000 is appropriated with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund equipment and training for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 6 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant: $91,750 for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $91,750 with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund equipment and training for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. SUMMARY: The Fire Department seeks authorization to accept a non-matching grant for technical rescue equipment. The Virginia Department of Emergency Management administers this grant from the United States Department of Homeland Security (DHS) through the State Homeland Security Program (SHSP). The grant program provides funding to improve the nation’s readiness in preventing, protecting against, responding to, recovering from, and mitigating terrorist attacks, major disasters and other emergencies. The grant reflects DHS’s focus on implementation of an all-of-nation, whole-community approach to building, sustaining, and delivering core capabilities essential to achieving a secure and resilient nation. The Fire Department was awarded $91,750 to be utilized by the Technical Rescue Team. The funds will be used for the purchase of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE), Urban Search & Rescue (USAR) bags, water rescue equipment, search camera, and specialized rescue equipment for heavy lifting for debris removal and large animal rescue. The majority of this equipment is replacing existing equipment that has exceeded its useful life, but there are a few items that are being added to enhance our rescue capabilities. This equipment can be used in a variety of ways such as stabilization of a structure that is in danger of collapse, stabilizing a vehicle after a crash, or clearing debris from a trench. This equipment is vital to the successful mitigation of a variety of incident types and ensures not only the prolonged safety of our citizens, but also the immediate safety of our responders. In addition, this grant includes training that will enhance that knowledge and skills of our Technical Rescue Team members when confronted with an animal rescue or wide area search in an urban or rural setting. This grant is 100% reimbursable; no local match is required. PRIOR ACTION(S): October 22, 2019: Finance Committee review May 28, 2019: Finance Committee – Grant Submittal Approval FISCAL IMPACT: None – No local match is required. Future funds may be needed for periodic maintenance of the equipment purchased. CONTACT(S): Fire Chief Greg Wormser, 455-6340 Battalion Chief Sean Regan, 546-1648 Fire Department Administrative Manager Annette Pettyjohn, 455-6368 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution REVIEWED BY: raw RESOLUTION: BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget is amended and $91,750 is appropriated with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund equipment and training for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 7 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: 2019 Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM)- State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) Grant KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution to amend the FY2020 City/Federal State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $24,517 with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) Grant through the Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department. SUMMARY: The Lynchburg Police Department has been awarded $24,517 through a competitive grant process with the Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) to purchase two Long Range Acoustic Devices that will be used in critical incidents that require communication between law enforcement and other persons in crises where traditional communication may not be effective. The equipment will also be used to communicate lifesaving information to citizens during natural disasters. The total equipment cost is $24,517 which is fully reimbursable by the grant; no local matching funds are required. PRIOR ACTION(S): Finance Committee September 24, 2019 (application approval) Finance Committee October 22, 2019 FISCAL IMPACT: None, no local match is required CONTACT(S): Chief Ryan M. Zuidema, 434-455-6171 Amy Lowe, Administrative Manager, Police Department, 455-6128 ATTACHMENT(S): None REVIEWED BY: bms RESOLUTION: BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget is amended and $24,517 is appropriated with resources of $24,517 from the Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) 2016 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 8 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: 2019 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $34,930 with resources from the 2019 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department, Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. SUMMARY: The City of Lynchburg is eligible to receive $34,930 in Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) funding. Funding will be utilized by the Lynchburg Police Department to purchase cameras for electronic surveillance, one digital camera for the Community Relations Coordinator position, and accessories for Tactical Unit firearms ($27,541). The Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office will utilize funds to upgrade their voice recording system ($3,762). The Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney will utilize funds to purchase two (2) computers ($3,627). Total equipment cost is $34,930 which is fully reimbursable by the grant. No local matching funds are required. PRIOR ACTION(S): Finance Committee, September 24, 2019 (application approval) Finance Committee, October 22, 2019 FISCAL IMPACT: None, no local match is required CONTACT(S): Chief Ryan M. Zuidema, 434-455-6171 Amy Lowe, Administrative Manager, Police Department, 455-6128 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution REVIEWED BY: bms RESOLUTION: BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget is amended and $34,930 is appropriated with resources from the 2019 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department, Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 9 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: 2019 Police Bulletproof Vest Partnership Grant Funding KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development ___Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment _X_Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $42,612 with resources of $21,306 from the Bulletproof Vest Partnership 2019 Grant Program and $21,306 transferred from the FY 2020 General Fund Police Department ($18,506) and Sheriff’s Office ($2,800) budgets to purchase replacement bulletproof vests for law enforcement officers. SUMMARY: Total vest replacement costs are $42,612. The grant requires a 50% local match; these funds are available in the FY 2020 General Fund Police and Sheriff’s Office operating budgets. PRIOR ACTION(S): Finance Committee, October 22, 2019 FISCAL IMPACT: The required local match is budgeted in the FY 2020 General Fund Police and Sheriff’s Office operating budgets; therefore, no additional funds are required. CONTACT(S): Chief Ryan Zuidema, 455-6045 Amy Lowe, Administrative Manager, Police Dept, 455-6128 ATTACHMENT(S): Resolution REVIEWED BY: bms RESOLUTION: BE IT RESOLVED that the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget is amended and $42,612 is appropriated with resources of $21,306 from the Bulletproof Vest Partnership 2019 Grant Program and $21,306 transferred from the FY 2020 General Fund Police Department ($18,506) and Sheriff’s Office ($2,800) budgets to purchase replacement bulletproof vests for law enforcement officers. Introduced: Adopted: Certified: _________________________________ Clerk of Council Finance Committee October 8th, 2019 City Council City of Lynchburg Lynchburg, Virginia RE: June 30th, 2019 (4th Quarter – FY 2019) Financial Report – Greater Lynchburg Transit Company The attached Greater Lynchburg Transit Company Quarterly Income Statement summarizes the financial activities for the fourth quarter of FY19 and YTD data for the fiscal year. REVENUE Total revenue for the fourth quarter is coming in approximately 3 % under budget. This is mainly from Passenger Revenue and Liberty University Revenue coming in less than budgeted. The Passenger Revenue is under budget approximately 5 % for the quarter. The Liberty University Revenue is under budget 15 % due to Liberty reducing the level of service to be provided from originally planned at the start of the spring semester, as well as conducting an adjustment for actual service provided at the end of the school year. Advertising is under budget 32 % and is due to a lower number of ad contracts during this period. Year to date, revenues are within 2 % of budget with the main factors being Passenger Revenue and Liberty Revenue under budget for the year. EXPENDITURES On the expense side, total expenses were under budget 4 % for the fourth quarter. Labor expenses have been under budget and overtime over budget due to vacant positions within operations and maintenance from staff turnover, netting a savings of approximately $ 57,000 during the fourth quarter between the two. All other expense line items were either just slightly over budget or under budget for the quarter. Year to date expenses to note are overtime expenses being significantly over budget approximately $ 256,000/203% for all departments combined due to understaffing from vacant positions and unexpected FMLA leave. Tires and tubes were over budget approximately $ 45,000/149%, due in part to an increase in tire expenses due to having to switch the style of tire used on the buses to one that could be retre aded for reuse. Casualty and Liability expenses were over budget approximately $ 63,000/121% due to not accurately accounting for insurance premiums rolling over from the previous fiscal year after the year end audit. SUMMARY At the end of the fourth quarter and year to date GLTC is reflecting a surplus of $ 137,689. Respectfully submitted, Brian Booth, General Manager AGENDA ITEM #: 10 QTR TO DATE FY2019 FY2019 FY2019 FY2019 % QTD QTD % YTD YTD of ACTUAL BUDGET VAR ACTUAL BUDGET Budget REVENUE FRT Passenger Revenue 139,586$ 147,070$ -5% 544,984$ 588,280$ 93% DRT Passenger Revenue 17,468 17,500 0% 65,155 70,000 93% Contracts (LU Access) 12,012 12,012 0% 60,060 60,060 100% Contracts (LC Access) 6,258 6,258 0% 25,032 25,032 100% Contracts (CVCC Access) 13,800 13,800 0% 55,200 55,200 100% Liberty University Revenue 265,700 313,490 -15% 1,435,415 1,567,450 92% Other Contract Revenue 77 1,925 -96% 13,119 7,700 170% Non-Operating Revenue 2,817 2,071 36% 29,358 8,285 354% Advertising Revenue 14,189 21,000 -32% 82,746 84,000 99% City Operating Assistance 432,196 432,196 0% 1,728,785 1,728,785 100% County Operating Assistance 18,695 18,695 0% 74,780 74,780 100% State Operating Assistance 506,760 502,781 1% 2,022,003 2,011,122 101% Federal Operating Assistance 488,382 486,348 0% 1,953,526 1,945,391 100% TOTAL REVENUE 1,917,940$ 1,975,146$ -3% 8,090,164$ 8,226,085$ 98% EXPENSES FIXED ROUTE Operator Labor 352,087$ 445,641$ -21% 1,500,670$ 1,782,565$ 84% Operator-Overtime 81,375 53,262 53% 406,327 213,049 191% Other Salaries & Wages 84,998 74,267 14% 305,564 297,067 103% Supervisors-Overtime 7,957 3,622 120% 24,812 14,487 171% Fringe Benefits 297,268 296,804 0% 1,113,224 1,187,215 94% TOTAL FIXED ROUTE 823,685$ 873,596$ -6% 3,350,596$ 3,494,383$ 96% DEMAND RESPONSE Operator Labor 64,492$ 80,465$ -20% 250,474$ 321,861$ 78% Operator-Overtime-PTS 1,120 2,001 -44% 9,933 8,002 124% Other Salaries & Wages 19,542 16,275 20% 61,823 65,098 95% Fringe Benefits 47,267 50,968 -7% 160,328 203,870 79% TOTAL DEMAND RESPONSE 132,421$ 149,708$ -12% 482,558$ 598,831$ 81% MAINTENANCE Other Salaries & Wages 151,625$ 166,576$ -9% 591,760$ 666,302$ 89% Inspection&Maint,Srvc-Overtime 14,521 7,272 100% 90,821 29,087 312% Fringe Benefits 93,335 89,736 4% 339,624 358,945 95% Fuel & Lubricants 167,887 175,280 -4% 660,543 701,121 94% Tires & Tubes 14,932 23,063 -35% 137,647 92,250 149% Other Materials & Supplies 132,866 122,624 8% 519,320 490,496 106% TOTAL MAINTENANCE 575,166$ 584,550$ -2% 2,339,715$ 2,338,201$ 100% ADMINISTRATION Other Salaries & Wages 107,219$ 93,061$ 15% 393,422$ 372,243$ 106% Fringe Benefits 59,260 48,036 23% 195,750 192,144 102% Services 118,431 112,213 6% 475,002 448,850 106% Utilities 38,879 45,165 -14% 171,744 180,661 95% Casualty & Liability Expenses 76,712 75,056 2% 363,460 300,223 121% Information Technology 30,744 40,691 -24% 133,847 162,764 82% Other Materials & Supplies 7,010 8,324 -16% 35,468 33,296 107% Miscellaneous 1,423 26,122 -95% 10,914 104,489 10% TOTAL ADMINISTRATION 439,678$ 448,668$ -2% 1,779,607$ 1,794,670$ 99% TOTAL EXPENSES 1,970,950$ 2,056,521$ -4% 7,952,476$ 8,226,085$ 97% NET INCOME/(LOSS) (53,010)$ (81,376)$ 137,689$ -$ CENTRAL VIRGINIA TRANSIT MANAGEMENT CO INC. QUARTERLY INCOME STATEMENT AS OF JUNE 30, 2019 LYNCHBURG REGIONAL AIRPORT OPERATING FUND FINANCIAL SUMMARY June 30, 2019 FY 2019 $ Variance FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2018 * FY 2019 FY 2019 FY 2019 * FY 2019 FY 2019 Actual vs. Amended Actual % of * Amended Actual % of * Amended Actual Amended Budget (thru 6/30/18) Budget * Budget (thru 6/30/19) Budget * Budget (thru 6/30/19) Budget * * BEGINNING NET ASSETS 250,000$ 36,977,478$ * 250,000$ 36,037,844$ (1) * 250,000$ 36,037,844$ (1) Less: Invested in Capital Assets, net of related debt (36,717,501) * (36,959,451) * (36,959,451) Less: GASB75 Prior Period Adjustment-Life & Health Insurance (907,483) (2) * * BEGINNING UNRESTRICTED NET ASSETS 250,000$ (647,506)$ * 250,000$ (921,607)$ * 250,000$ (921,607)$ -$ * * USE OF ENCUMBRANCES CARRIEDFORWARD 21,155$ 103,481$ 103,481$ TRANSFER OF RESERVES - NEW CORPORATE HANGER (500,000)$ (500,000)$ * * USE OF RESERVES - DEBT SERVICE 32,597$ * * * * REVENUES * * Airfield 98,000 101,875 104% * 110,000 119,818 109% * 110,000 119,818 9,818 Terminal 1,495,827 1,517,824 101% * 1,544,333 1,618,024 105% * 1,544,333 1,618,024 73,691 General Aviation 518,557 558,047 108% * 567,857 627,599 111% * 567,857 627,599 59,742 Other Leased Property 261,900 272,001 104% * 382,400 390,005 102% * 382,400 390,005 7,605 State Airport Aid 260,000 212,824 82% * 200,000 147,635 74% * 200,000 147,635 (52,365) Federal Security Aid 95,000 87,260 92% * 85,000 87,320 103% * 85,000 87,320 2,320 General Fund Subsidy 0 0 0% * 0 0 0% * 0 0 0 Interest & Other 94,096 115,545 123% * 80,832 68,342 85% * 80,832 68,342 (12,490)* * TOTAL REVENUES 2,823,380$ 2,865,377$ * 2,970,422$ 3,058,743$ * 2,970,422$ 3,058,744$ 88,322$ * * EXPENSES * * Airfield Operations 319,111 313,470 98% * 309,254 300,934 97% * 309,254 300,934 8,320 Terminal Operations 567,103 579,317 102% * 572,091 590,757 103% * 572,091 590,757 (18,666) General Aviation 142,431 138,355 97% * 137,524 130,929 95% * 137,524 130,929 6,595 Administration 727,174 757,028 104% * 799,767 804,717 101% * 799,767 804,717 (4,950) Safety (ARFF & LEO) 423,125 446,267 105% * 424,939 446,659 105% * 424,939 446,659 (21,720) Snow Removal 34,930 30,478 87% * 22,930 19,933 87% * 22,930 19,933 2,997 Debt Service 117,244 126,595 108% * 139,568 137,661 99% * 139,568 137,661 1,907 Small Projects & Equipment (State-Supported) 329,528 216,976 66% * 338,658 316,677 94% * 338,658 316,677 21,981 Transfers to Other Airport Funds 0 0 0% * 5,000 0 0% * 5,000 0 5,000 Other Airport Expenses 60,422 30,992 51% * 127,974 83,374 65% * 127,974 83,374 44,600* * TOTAL EXPENSES 2,721,068$ 2,639,478$ * 2,877,704$ 2,831,642$ * 2,877,704$ 2,831,641$ 46,063$ * * ENDING UNRESTRICTED NET ASSETS (93,936)$ (921,607)$ * 446,199$ (694,505)$ * 446,199$ (694,505)$ (3) FOOTNOTES: 1) Beginning Net Assets agrees with the Comprehensive Annual Financial Report (CAFR) with the following adjustment: 38,153,588$ (2,115,744)$ Total Revenues 3,058,744$ 36,037,844$ Total Expenses 2,831,641$ FY2019 Surplus 227,102$ (tentative final) 2) Beginning Net Assets was restated in FY2018 by ($907,483) for a Prior Period Adjustment upon implementation of GASB75 accrual for Life & Health Insurance liability 3) FY 2019 Ending Unrestricted Net Assets is comprised of the following: 115,176$ ($132,958.35 - $17,782.14 year-end decrease) 31,927$ (encumbrances carried forward to FY2020) (987,821)$ (net liability as of the end of FY2019) (1,111,472)$ (net liability as of the end of FY2019) 1,257,685$ (694,505)$ FY2019 Financial SummaryTotal Net Assets per CAFR 6/30/18 Less: Net Assets in Capital & PFC Funds Undesignated Retained Earnings Total Beginning Net Assets Des. for Maintenance (Rental Car Facility) Reserve for Encumbrances at Year-end GASB68 Pension-related Accrual GASB75 Other OPEB Obligations 10/17/2019 October 22, 2019 Finance Committee City Council City of Lynchburg Lynchburg, Virginia RE: June 30, 2019 Quarterly Financial Report - Lynchburg Regional Juvenile Detention Center Lynchburg Regional Juvenile Detention Center The attached Lynchburg Regional Juvenile Detention Center (Detention Center) financial report summarizes the financial activities through June 30, 2019. The financial spreadsheet provides comparative year-to-date data for FY 2018. REVENUES Charges for Services Revenue in this category for the fourth quarter of FY 2019 is $1,028,249 or 99.2% of the budget. The revenue projection is consistent with the estimated FY 19 population for the Detention Center. Department of Juvenile Justice Block Grant This revenue category represents allocations from the Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice (DJJ) for operational expenses of the Detention Center. Revenue received from the DJJ through the fourth quarter of FY 2019 totals $1,007,758 or 94.7% of the budget. Community Placement Program This revenue category represents allocations from the Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice (DJJ) for operational expenses of the Community Placement Program (CPP). The CPP is a partnership between DJJ and local det ention facilities to provide secure, highly structured, disciplined residential services for juvenile offenders committed to the Department of Juvenile Justice. The goal is to place residents in the CPP closest to their home in order to increase community connections and family visitation. The CPP focuses on skill development and competency in the areas of education, job readiness, life , and social skills to ensure a seamless transition back into the community. Revenues received from the DJJ through the f ourth quarter of FY 2019 are $866,684 or 103.8% of the budget. Additional revenues were received from DJJ to fund educational initiatives such as a welding simulator program and approved college courses for residents. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 2 United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) This revenue category consists of reimbursements for meals served to juveniles at the Detention Center. Year-to-date revenues from USDA for FY 2019 are $49,828 or 110.7% of the budget. EXPENDITURES Overall expenditures for FY 2019 were $ 2,970,795 and are within budget. The costs are allocated between the Community Placement Program and the contracting localities. The Detention Center incurred additional expenses this year to replace the hot water heater and install a new fire alarm system. Juvenile Population The average number of juveniles being served per day through the fourth quarter of FY 2019 is 22.42 as compared to 25.25 in FY 2018, reflecting a continuing downward trend in the overall juvenile detention population. The percentage of Lynchburg City’s juveniles through the fourth quarter is 42% of the total juvenile population. SUMMARY The Lynchburg Regional Detention Center is recognized as an outstanding facility by the juvenile judicial system for providing educational services, mental health services, physical health services, and partnerships with local area businesses. Turning Point Academy was recently approved by Lynchburg City School Officials as the name of the Detention Center’s in-house school. Respectfully submitted, Tamara Rosser Director, Department of Juvenile Services c: Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager Donna Witt, Director, Financial Services Robin Mamola, Accounting Supervisor, Human Services Sherry McIntyre, Accountant, Juvenile Services FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2019 FY 2019 FY 2019 FY 2019 FY 2019 FY 2019 Amended Actual % of Amended Actual % of Amended Actual Actual to Budget 4th QTR YTD Budget Budget 4th QTR YTD Budget Budget 4th QTR YTD Amended Beginning Funds at July 1 100,012 140,604 Revenues: Charges for Services 1,034,880 1,108,243 107.1% 1,036,571 1,028,249 99.2% 1,036,571 1,028,249 8,322.00 Intergovernmental- Department of Juvenile Justice Block Grant 1,063,886 1,026,594 96.5% 1,063,886 1,007,758 94.7% 1,063,886 1,007,758 56,128.00 Intergovernmental- USDA 45,000 47,901 106.4% 45,000 49,828 110.7% 45,000 49,828 (4,828.00) Community Placement Program (CPP) 771,317 771,316 100.0% 834,985 866,684 103.8% 834,985 866,684 (31,699.00) Miscellaneous and State Ward Per Diem 1,650 94 5.7% 1,650 0 0.0% 1,650 0 1,650.00 Budget Designations/Purchase Orders 100,000 0 0.0% 100,000 0 0.0% 100,000 0 - Total Revenues 3,016,733 2,954,147 97.9% 3,082,092 2,952,519 95.8% 3,082,092 2,952,519 29,573.00 Expenditures: Salaries 1,526,963 1,526,963 100.0% 1,620,477 1,609,531 99.3% 1,620,477 1,609,531 10,946.12 Employee Benefits 601,526 598,805 99.5% 616,951 611,976 99.2% 616,951 611,976 4,975.19 Contractual Services 58,007 58,442 100.7% 41,594 57,487 138.2% 41,594 57,487 (15,892.53) Fleet Services 14,014 13,687 97.7% 15,657 13,076 83.5% 15,657 13,076 2,580.95 Supplies and Materials 155,391 162,692 104.7% 138,670 115,570 83.3% 138,670 115,570 23,099.88 Utilities 80,750 80,636 99.9% 80,750 75,565 93.6% 80,750 75,565 5,184.93 Training and Conferences 4,550 5,488 120.6% 4,550 1,979 43.5% 4,550 1,979 2,570.65 Telephone Services 4,200 2,653 63.2% 4,200 2,752 65.5% 4,200 2,752 1,448.22 Postage and Mailing 850 265 31.1% 850 231 27.1% 850 231 619.24 Indirect Costs 259,063 259,063 100.0% 233,048 233,048 100.0% 233,048 233,048 - Self Insurance 16,937 16,937 100.0% 16,422 16,422 100.0% 16,422 16,422 - Dues and Memberships 500 702 140.3% 500 1,013 202.5% 500 1,013 (512.71) Rentals and Leases 2,409 2,393 99.4% 3,209 2,247 70.0% 3,209 2,247 961.82 Health and Dental Benefits for Retirees 52,704 46,848 88.9% 58,560 46,848 80.0% 58,560 46,848 11,712.00 Unemployment Compensation 1,000 0 0.0% 1,000 0 0.0% 1,000 0 1,000.00 Professional Services 6,910 4,121 59.6% 6,910 4,652 67.3% 6,910 4,652 2,258.00 Special Use Equipment 0 0 0.0% 60,377 95,203 0.0% 60,377 95,203 (34,826.55) Serial Bond Interest 4,654 4,654 100.0% 3,302 3,302 100.0% 3,302 3,302 (0.18) Serial Bond Principal 81,305 81,305 0.0% 30,065 30,065 100.0% 30,065 30,065 - USDA Grant 45,000 47,901 106.4% 45,000 49,828 110.7% 45,000 49,828 (4,828.00) Budget Designations/Purchase Orders 100,000 0 0.0% 100,000 0 0.0% 100,000 0 - Total Expenditures 3,016,733 2,913,555 96.6% 3,082,092 2,970,795 96.4% 3,082,092 2,970,795 11,297.03 TOTAL RESTRICTED FUND BALANCE Maint./Equipment 140,604 122,328 Lynchburg Regional Juvenile Detention Center Special Revenue Fund Financial Summary Fourth Quarter: As of June 30, 2019 October 22, 2019 Finance Committee City Council City of Lynchburg Lynchburg, Virginia Re: Children’s Services Act (CSA) Fund Financial Report for the period ending June 30, 2019. The attached CSA Fund Financial Summary summarizes the financial activity for this Fund through June 30, 2019. Under the State guidelines, CSA prior year obligations are paid through September 30th of each year. However, the annual budget is prepared on a fiscal year (July-June). Because of the State guidelines, expenditures for this fund are unique due to the overlap of grants each fiscal year. REVENUES • Public Assistance – Welfare and Administration The Public Assistance revenue source is the reimbursement received from the State for local expenses incurred under CSA for providing services to troubled youth and their families. The current rate of reimbursement for comm unity-based services is 86.32%, residential services is 65.8%, and for all other services, 72.64%. Funds to assist in administering the grant, ($38,287) for FY 2019 are provided by the State . Reimbursements for expenditures incurred through the fourth quarter of 2019 are $4,125,708. • CSA Contribution – General Fund and Schools These revenue sources are comprised of the required local match for all State funds received for the Children Services Act. For the fourth quarter of FY 2019, local matching funds for programs in the amount of $1,980,464 for the General Fund and $196,541 for the Schools have been received. • Miscellaneous Revenue Miscellaneous revenues in the amount of $31,874 were collected through the fourth quarter of FY 2019. These revenues are mainly comprised of recoupments from children’s social security payments for expenditures incurred on their behalf, and registered billings for CSA parental co-payments. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 2 EXPENSES • Administrative expenses CSA Administrative funds are used for salaries, supplies, and materials. Budgeted funds for FY 2019 are $66,670. Actual YTD administrative expenditures through the fourth quarter of FY 2019 are $56,863 or 85.3% of the budget. • Mandated – Foster Care Foster care expenses include funds for residential facilities, day care, maintenance payments to foster parents, enhanced maintenance payments to foster parents and foster care prevention. Year -to-date foster care expenditures through the fourth quarter of F Y 2019 totaled $2,251,813 or 75.2% of the budget. Expenditures in this category can rise with an increase in the number of children placed in foster care. • Mandated – Special Education Special Education expenses include services for Special Education students from the Lynchburg City Schools. Expenditures through the fourth quarter of FY 2019 total $3,006,695 or 135.5% of the budget. Expenditures for this budget line will rise due to increased enrollments at private day placements such as Rivermont School , Bridges and New Vistas School, in addition to students attending for longer periods of time. • Non-Mandated Services Non-mandated expenditures are for services such as counseling, mentoring, crisis intervention, and foster care prevention services. Non-mandated expenditures through the fourth quarter of FY 2019 are $222,499 or 62.4% of the budget . Non-mandated services are provided almost exclusively to youth involved in the c ourt system. Decreases in this budget line are attributed to the Court Services Unit accessing alternate funding for court-involved youth. • Community Based Services This category includes services to children while they are living at home, in the home of an extended family, in a regular foster family home, or in an independent living arrangement. Community services may include assessment, crisis stabilization, therapy, or intervention services provided in the child’s home. Community Based Services through the fourth quarter of FY 2019 are $538,295 or 123.3% of the budget. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 3 SUMMARY The Children’s Services Act Fund creates a collaborative system of services and funding that is child - centered, family-focused, and community-based when addressing the strengths and needs of at-risk youths and their families in the City of Lynchburg. While the number of children currently in foster care fluctuates during the year , more children are now classified as mandated and can access CSA funds due to the severity of their needs. Other factors such an increased number of children receiving more intensive services f or longer periods of time, increased vendor rates, parental agreements, and an increase in special educational services impact this budget. The Community Policy and Management Team, in collaboration with the professional community, continues to work hard and is diligent and deliberate in efforts to reduce costs associated with CSA. We continue to work with the professional community to provide the most cost effective service to children and their families. Respectfully submitted, Tamara T. Rosser Director of Human Services c: Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager Donna Witt, Director of Financial Services Rhonda Allbeck, Assistant Director of Financial Services Robin Mamola, Financial Professional IV Kathy Collins, Financial Professional III FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2019 FY 2019 FY 2019 Amended Actual 4 QTR % of Amended Actual 4 QTR % of Budget YTD Budget Budget YTD Budget Beginning Fund Balance 0 5,037 335,312 Revenues: Public Assistance - Welfare and Administration 3,774,017 3,961,874 105.0% 3,836,994 4,125,708 107.5% Transfer from Lynchburg City Schools 196,541 196,541 100.0% 196,541 196,541 100.0% Transfer from General Fund 1,980,464 1,980,464 100.0% 2,001,194 1,980,464 99.0% Miscellaneous/Budget Designations 48,000 48,149 100.3% 44,330 31,874 71.9% Total Revenues 5,999,022 6,187,028 103.1% 6,079,059 6,334,587 104.2% Expenses: Administrative Expenses 65,475 57,959 88.5% 66,670 56,863 85.3% Mandated - Foster Care 2,996,823 2,641,117 88.1% 2,995,628 2,251,813 75.2% Mandated - Special Education 2,143,500 2,536,140 118.3% 2,218,500 3,006,695 135.5% Non-Mandated Services 356,636 210,645 59.1% 356,636 222,499 62.4% Community Based 436,588 410,892 94.1% 436,588 538,295 123.3% Miscellaneous/Budget Designations 5,037 0 0.0% Total Expenditures 5,999,022 5,856,753 97.6% 6,079,059 6,076,165 100.0% ENDING FUND BALANCE 0 335,312 0 593,734 Children's Services Act Special Revenue Fund Financial Summary June 30, 2019 October 22, 2019 Finance Committee City Council City of Lynchburg Lynchburg, Virginia Re: June 30, 2019 Quarterly Financial Report – Water Operating Fund The attached Water Operating Fund Financial Summary summarizes the financial activity for this f und through June 30, 2019. This quarterly report provides comparative financial information for the same period of the prior fiscal year . Variances between the FY 2019 Budget and the D epartment’s year end actuals are described below. REVENUES Following the completion of the fourth quarter, overall revenues for FY 2019 were $924,959 (6.2%) more than budget. Explanations follow: • Charges for Services: Revenue in this category was $143,619 (1.1%) over budget mostly due to the combination of higher than anticipated revenues from the following: 1) Inside City – Water Sales of $54,306 2) Availability Fees of $54,670 3) Account Charges of $21,141. • Water Contracts: This revenue account reflects the billing activity to counties of Amherst, Bedford, and Campbell, and the industries of WestRock and Frito- Lay. Revenue in this category was $286,299 (14.5%) higher than budget. WestRock, who is the City’s largest water consumer, has steadily increased water use since FY 2016. WestRock’s water use in FY 2019 increased 44% compared to FY 2016 thus exceeding the FY 2019 budget by $143,697. Counties of Bedford and Campbell billed unit (hundred cubic feet) rates were higher than antici pated resulting in $82,413 i ncrease in revenues. Frito -Lay incurred higher than estimated consumption resulting in additional revenue of $36,809. • Interest and Other: Interest and Other was $495,041 (171.9%) more than budget mostly due to higher returns on cash investments. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 2 EXPENSES Overall expenses for FY 20 19 were $722,359 (4.3%) less than budget. A breakdown and explanations of this variance follow: • Departmental Operation and Maintenance: This category includes the Water Treatment Plant, Meter Operations, Water Line Maintenance and Administration. Expenses in this category are expected to be $401,517 (4.0%) less than the FY 20 19 budget (Water Treatment - $235,895 savings, Meter Operations - $58,193 savings, Water Line Maintenance - $19,932 savings, Administration - $87,497 savings). This variance is broken down as follows:  Personnel Services  Fringe Benefits $102,578 (77,307)  Chemicals  Utilities  Contractual Services  Supplies and Materials  All Other 67,088 91,491 93,998 83,330 40,339 Total $401,517 The Personnel Services savings variance is related to deferred implementation of wage rate adjustments using recommendations from Korn Ferry’s compensation study . Higher than expected health insurance claims resulted in the Fringe Benefit’s budget over run. Contractual Services savings are mostly attributable the foll owing: 1) $32,910 for Maintenance and R epair Services of plant machinery 2) $27,945 for Maintenance on G rounds. 3) $21,498 for Emergency Line Protection Services needed when City line protection crews are not available. Additional savings were incurred by Chemicals and Utilities due to wet weather conditions . Pedlar Reservoir was used as the first water source at 95% during FY 2019 as opposed to using the James River. • Non-Departmental Operation and Maintenance: Non-Departmental Operation and M aintenance expenses were $176,160 (52.7%) under budget primarily due to Allowance for Doubtful Accounts and Other Pension Employment Benefit ( OPEB) expenses for retirees were less than expected. • Capital Outlay Purchases in this category are reported to be $96,000 under budget. All purchase activity in this category meet the criteria of capitalization under generally accepted accounting principles rather than reported as an expense. Purchase activity included $85,750 of various field equipment items and one vehicle. • Transfers to Capital Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 3 Transfers to Capital were at budget. • Debt Service: Expenditures in debt service were under budget by $48,682 (1.2%) mostly due to deferred startups of several capital projects that have funding from the available credit line. SUMMARY The fourth quarter report reflects a stable FY 2019 financial position for this fund. Under the Council financial policies, two important financial ratios, debt coverage and fund balance are above policy targets. The debt coverage r atio fo r end of the fis cal year was 1.61 which is above Council’s financial policy minimum target of 1.20. The fund balance ratio at the end of the fiscal year was 73% compared to target range of 25% - 40%. Respectfully submitted, Timothy A. Mitchell, P.E. Director of Water Resources cc: Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager Donna Witt, Director of Financial Services WATER OPERATING FUND FINANCIAL SUMMARY Quarter Ending June 30, 2019 FY 2019 FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2019 FY 2019 FY 2019 $ Variance Adopted Actual % of Adopted Actual % of Adopted Budget Budget Q4 YTD Budget Budget Q4 YTD Budget vs. Actual REVENUES: Charges for Services $12,728,131 $13,083,729 103% $12,718,935 $12,862,554 101% $143,619 Water Contracts 1,892,470 2,266,915 120% 1,971,330 2,257,629 115% 286,299 Interest and Other 278,737 562,209 202% 287,993 783,034 272% 495,041 $14,899,338 $15,912,853 $14,978,258 $15,903,217 $924,959 EXPENSES Departmental O&M $9,867,239 $9,424,508 96% $9,976,654 $9,575,137 96% $401,517 Non-Departmental O&M 325,584 193,017 59% 334,477 158,317 47% 176,160 Capital Outlay/Purchases 66,500 - 0% 96,000 - 0% 96,000 Transfers to Capital 1,500,000 1,500,000 100% 2,400,000 2,400,000 100% 0 Debt Service 4,157,150 4,318,959 104% 3,914,943 3,866,261 99% 48,682 $15,916,473 $15,436,484 $16,722,074 $15,999,715 $722,359 Adjustment for Expenses from Capital Projects ($199,991) ($31,727) KEY RATIOS: Unrestricted cash target range as a % of operating expenses & debt service: 25% - 40% Unrestricted cash as a % of operating expenses & debt service: 73% Financial Policy targeted debt coverage ratio minimum: 1.20 Ending debt coverage ratio: 1.61 (a) Note (a) Calculation of debt coverage includes $92,704 of estimated capitalizable costs for internal labor charges applicable to time spent on capital project activities. October 22, 2019 Finance Committee City Council City of Lynchburg Lynchburg, Virginia Re: June 30, 2019 Quarterly Financial Report – Sewer Operating Fund The attached Sew er Operating Fund Financial Summary summarizes the financial activity for this fund through June 30, 2019. This quarterly report provides comparative financial information for the same period of the prior fiscal year . Variances between the FY 20 19 Budget and the D epartment’s year end actuals are described below. REVENUES Following the completion of the fourth quarter, overall revenues for FY 2019 were $2,259,240 (10%) more than budget. Explanations follow: • Charges for Services: Revenue in this category was $1,607,827 (8.7%) over budget mostly due to the following: 1) Higher than anticipated Septic H auler Charges of $1,402,958 primarily from to a customer bringing leachate from Mapl ewood Landfill in Amelia County 2) Increased Sewer Sales -Inside City of $252,842 3) Availability Fees excee ding budget of $106,163 4) Less than expect ed Industrial Surcharges of $152,643 mostly due to two industrial customers and one institutional customer. • Sewer Contracts: Revenue in this category reflects billing activity in counties of Amherst, Bedford, and Campbell and industries of WestRock and Frito- Lay. Revenue in this category was 273,511 (7%) over budget. This is primarily due to more than anticipated revenues from WestRock and Frito-Lay. • Interest and Other: Revenue is this category was $377,902 (353.4%) more than budget primarily due to higher returns on cash investments of $326,021. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 2 EXPENSES Overall expenses for FY 2019 were $856,506 (3.3%) less than budget. A breakdown and e xplanations of this variance follow: • Departmental Operation and Maintenance: This category includes the Wastew ater Treatment Plant and Sewer Line Maintenance. E xpenses in this category were $174,892 (1.5%) less than budget (Waste water Treatment Plant - $5,788 over budget and Sewer Line Maintenance - $180,680 under budget). This variance is broken down as follows:  Personnel Services  Fringe Benefits $283,141 (5,494)  Contractual Services  Utilities (122,207) 36,348  All Other (16,896) Total $174,892 The savings i n Personnel Services i s related to unfilled positions during FY 2019 and deferred implementation of wage rate adjustments using recommendations from Korn Ferry’s compensation study. Contractual Services are higher than anticipated due the following: 1) $71,894 related to l onger than planned use of Temporary Personnel to work at new truck haul waste station. Once complete the new truck haul waste station will be fully automated and will not require any employee or temporary personnel to manage gate or process any truckload delivery manifests for waste. 2) $52,937 higher than anticipated costs for Sewer Maintenance and Repair Services due to increased sewer line breaks and debris cleanup and removal around several sewer lines crossing creeks within the City. This work is a result of accumulation of several stor ms since August, 2018. 3) Wastew ater Treatment Plant building repairs were higher than previous years thus exceeding budget by $65,530. 4) $23,483 savings in Engineering and Legal Services. • Non-Departmental Operation and Maintenance: Non-Departmental Operation and Maintenance expenses were $93,228 (25%) under budget primarily due to Allowance for Doubtful Accounts and Other Pension Employment Benefits ( OPEB) expenses for retirees were less than expected. • Capital Outlay: Purchases in this category are r eported to be $464,535 under budget. All purchase activity in this category meet the criteria of capitalization under generally accepted accounting principles rather than reported as an expense. Purchase activity included $346,303 of equipment. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 3 • Transfers to Capital: Transfers to Capital were at budget. • Debt Service: Expenditures in debt service were $123,851 (1.4%) below budget mostly due to deferred startups of several projects that have funding from available credit line. SUMMARY This fourth quarter report reflects a stable FY 201 9 financial position for this fund. Under the Council adopted financial policies, the two important financial ratios, debt coverage and fund balanc e was within or exceed policy targets. The debt coverage ratio for the end of the fiscal year was 1.45 compared to a target range of 1.20 to 1.50. The fund balance ratio at the end of the fiscal year was 44% compared to a target range 25% - 40%. Respectfully submitted, Timothy A. Mitchell, P.E. Director of Water Resources cc: Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager Donna Witt, Director of Financial Services SEWER OPERATING FUND FINANCIAL SUMMARY Quarter Ending June 30, 2019 FY 2019 FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2019 FY 2019 FY 2019 $ Variance Adopted Actual % of Adopted Actual % of Adopted Budget Budget Q4 YTD Budget Budget Q4 YTD Budget vs. Actual REVENUES: Charges for Services $18,494,475 $19,384,577 105% $18,451,183 $20,059,010 109% $1,607,827 Sewer Contracts 3,791,116 3,825,007 101% 3,893,603 4,167,114 107% 273,511 Interest and Other 132,328 375,580 284% 106,920 484,822 453% 377,902 $22,417,919 $23,585,164 $22,451,706 $24,710,946 $2,259,240 EXPENSES: Departmental O&M $11,151,647 $10,576,265 95% $11,431,281 11,256,389 98% $174,892 Non-Departmental O&M 353,874 188,739 53% 373,580 280,352 75% 93,228 Capital Outlay/Purchases 612,500 - 0% 464,535 - 0% 464,535 Transfers to Capital 1,100,000 1,100,000 100% 4,500,000 4,500,000 100% - Debt service 9,301,933 9,281,726 100% 9,196,406 9,072,555 99% 123,851 $22,519,954 $21,146,730 $25,965,802 $25,109,296 $856,506 Adjustment for Expenses from Capital Projects ($194,700) ($90,801) KEY RATIOS: Unrestricted cash target range as a % of operating expenses & debt service: 25% - 40% Unrestricted cash as a % of operating expenses & debt service: 44% Financial Policy targeted debt coverage ratio minimum: 1.20 Ending debt coverage ratio: 1.45 (a) Note (a) Calculation of debt coverage includes $103,546 of estimated capitalizable costs for internal labor charges applicable to time spent on capital project activities. October 22, 2019 Finance Committee City Council City of Lynchburg Lynchburg, Virginia Re: June 30, 2019 Quarterly Financial Report – Stormwater Operating Fund The attached Stormwater Operating Fund Financial Summary summarizes the financial act ivity for this fund through June 30, 2019. This quarterly report provides comparative financial information for the same period of the prior fiscal year. Variances between the FY 2019 Budget and the Department’s actuals are described below. REVENUES Following the completion of the fourth quarter, the overall revenues for FY 2019 were $72,740 (2.1%) more than budget. Explanations follow: • Charges for Services: Revenue in this category reflects billing activity for all known impervious areas, Virginia Stormwater Management Program (VSMP) permits and delinquent charges on past due accounts. Charges for services exceeded budget by $21,146 (.7%) primarily due to higher than anticipated billings for impervious areas. • Interest and Other: Interest was $51,594 (515.9%) higher than budget due to higher returns on cash investments than anticipated. • Transfers from Other Funds: Transfers from General Fund were at budget. EXPENSES Overall expenses for FY 2019 were $319,930 (8.6%) less than budget. A breakdown and explanations of this variance follow: Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 2 • Departmental Operation and Maintenance: Departmental Operation and Maintenance expenses were 185,761 (6.5%) less than budget . Explanations of this variance follow:  Personnel Services  Fringe Benefits  Contractual Services $53,976 14,522 (25,973)  Internal Service Charges  Public Works Stormwater Services  Other 15,231 86,012 41,993 Total $185,761 The savings in Personnel Services were attributable to unfilled positions during FY 2019 and deferred implementation of wage rate adjustments using recommendations from Korn Ferry’ s compensation study. Contractual Services were higher than budget primarily due to unanticipated detention pond repairs due to August 2 nd 2018 flood event and e ngineering services that were budgeted in FY 2018 for sediment control study for four inland ponds was deferred to FY 2019. Savings in Public Works Stormwater Services was primarily due to implementing a new program for leaf collection and fewer interruptions caused by snow. Non-Departmental Operation and Maintenance: Non-Departmental Operation and Maintenance Expen ses were $31,444 (60.9%) less than budget. $39,893 in savings was primarily related to Allowance for Doubtful Accounts and Other Pension Employment Benefits ( OPEB) expenses for retirees. These savings were offset by E ngineering Services expenses of $8,900 used to restore Greenwood Pond’s damaged embankment due to August 2 nd 2018 flood event. Restoration of the embankment was completed September, 2019. Costs associated for the restoration are expected to be partially reimbursed by Virginia Department of Emergency Management. The percentage or dollar amount of reimbursement is undetermined at this time. • Capital Outlay: Purchases in Capital Outlay are reported to be $54,535 under budget. All purchase activity in this category meet the criteria of capitalization under generally accepted accounting principles rather than reported as an expens e. Purchase activity included $42,060 various field equipment items and one vehicle. Transfers to Capital: Transfers to Capital were at budget. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 3 • Debt Service: Expenditures in Debt Service were $48,190 (54.4%) less than budget. This was primarily due to deferred closing (to 1st quarter of FY 2020) of a Virginia Resource Authority loan for $991,948 to be used with Stormwater Local Assistance Fund (SLAF) Grant to fully fund the Rock Castle Creek Tributary Stream Restoration Project . This project will help meet compliance requirements under our current Municipal Storm Sewer System (MS4) permit. SUMMARY The fourth quarter report reflects a stable FY 2019 financial position for this fund. Under the Council financial policies, two important financial ratios, debt coverage and fund balance are above policy targets. The debt coverage ratio for end of the fiscal year w as 12.19 which was above Council’s financial policy minimum target of 1.20. The fund balance ratio at the end of the fiscal year was 34% compared to target range of 15%- 20%. Respectfully submitted, Timothy A. Mitchell, P.E. Director of Water Resources cc: Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager Donna Witt, Director of Financial Services STORMWATER OPERATING FUND FINANCIAL SUMMARY Quarter Ending June 30, 2019 FY 2019 FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2018 FY 2019 FY 2019 FY 2019 $ Variance Adopted Actual % of Adopted Actual % of Adopted Budget Budget Q4YTD Budget Budget Q4YTD Budget vs. Actual REVENUES: Charges for Services $3,199,120 $3,211,372 100% $3,205,800 $3,226,946 101% $21,146 Interest and Other 2,000 32,812 1641% 10,000 61,594 616% 51,594 Transfers from Other Funds 275,000 283,593 103% 275,000 275,000 100% 0 $3,476,120 $3,527,777 $3,490,800 $3,563,540 $72,740 EXPENSES: Departmental O&M $2,778,006 $2,723,287 98% $2,840,836 $2,655,075 93% $185,761 Non-Departmental O&M 51,168 (8,551) -17% 51,656 20,212 39% 31,444 Capital Outlay/Purchases 0 0 54,535 0 54,535 Transfers to Capital 850,000 850,000 100% 337,500 337,500 100% 0 Transfers to General Fund 0 0 337,500 337,500 100% 0 Transfers to City/Fed/State Aid Fund 0 4,215 0 0 0 Debt Service 0 4,672 88,628 40,438 48,190 $3,679,174 $3,573,623 $3,710,655 $3,390,725 $319,930 Adjustment for Expenses from Capital Projects ($16,171) ($91,548) ` KEY RATIOS: Unrestricted cash target range as a % of operating expenses & debt service 15% - 20% Projected unrestricted cash as a % of operating expenses at year end 34% Financial Policy targeted debt coverage ratio minimum: 1.20 Ending debt coverage ratio: 12.19 (a) Note (a) Calculation of debt coverage includes $33,883 of estimated capitalizable costs for internal labor charges applicable to time spent on capital project activities. October 22, 2019 Finance Committee City Council City of Lynchburg Lynchburg, Virginia Re: June 30, 2019 Quarterly Report - General Fund Attached is the Financial Summary for the General Fund (Fund) for the period ending June 30 , 201 9. This quarterly report provides comparative information for the same period of the prior fiscal year and represents FY 2019 financial postings. This report is preliminary pending completion of the annual audit.  UNASSIGNED FUND BALANCE The General Fund e nded FY 201 9 with an Unassigned Fund balance of $ 29.4 million compared to a projected balance of $ 18.5 million. The City’s Fund Balance Policy for General Fund requ ires maintaining an Unassigned Fund Balance equal to a targeted goal of 10% of General Fund revenues . The City ended with a projected Fund Balance ratio of 15.4%. According to the Fund Balance policy, Fund Balance in excess of 10% will be dedicated to one-time expenditures in the next year.  RESTRICTED, COMMITTED, AND ASSIGNED FUND BALANCE The General Fund ended FY 201 9 with Restricted, Committed, and Assigned Fund balances of $14,093,629, $12,959,640 and $8,967,108, respectively.  REVENUES Revenues were $4.3 million (2.3%) more than the amended budget. City staff continually monitors the major revenue categories, revising estimates as needed. NON-DEDICATED REVENUES  Real Property Tax: Real Estate Tax revenue for FY 2019 was 0.6% or $ 318,623 more than the amended budget per the actual Tax Levy posted in October, net of allowances and Tax Relief credits. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 2  Personal Property Tax: Personal Property Tax revenue for FY 2019 was 5.0% or $905,037 more than the amended budget. In 1998, the Virginia General Assembly enacted t he Personal Property Tax Relief Act (PPTRA) to reimburse citizens for a portion of the local personal property tax . In the 2004 Virginia General Assembly, the State capped the amount reimbursed to localities at $950 million for FY 201 9. This action eliminates the 70% reimbursement. Lynchburg’s share is $5,543,584. During FY 2019 the City received the total reimbursement of $5,543,584.  Consumer Utility Taxes: Consumer Utility Tax revenue for FY 2019 was 2.0% or $76,167 more than the amended budget.  Communications Sales and Use Tax: Communications Sales and Use Tax revenue for FY 201 9 was 5.5% or $ 167,600 less than the amended budget.  Local Sales Tax: Local Sales Tax revenue for FY 2019 was 4.1% or $626,999 more than the amended budget.  Business License Tax: Business License Tax revenue for FY 2019 was 8.6% or $718,533 more than the amended budget. The City continues to use a conservative approach when estimating revenue.  Meals Tax: Meals Tax revenue for FY 2019 was 1.2% or $179,070 more than the amended budget.  Delinquent Taxes, Penalties and Interest: Delinquent Taxes, Penalties and Interest revenue for FY 2019 was 8.0% or $326,843 greater than the amended budget. This excess is a reflection of the continued efforts of the collect ions department in utilizing all available methods for collecting debt.  Other Local Taxes: Other Local Tax revenue for FY 2019 was 10.2% or $267,433 greater than the amended budget. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 3  Motor Vehicle License Tax: Motor Vehicle License Tax revenue for FY 201 9 was equal to the amended budget with $1,601,711 collected.  Bank Stock Tax: Bank Stock Tax revenue for FY 2019 was 15.6% or $128,307 greater than the amended budget. This tax is based on the percentage of deposits within the City of Lynchburg compared to the whole state of Virginia.  Lodging Tax: Lodging Tax revenue for FY 2019 was 5.5% or $147,497 more than the amended budget.  Permits, Fees, and Licenses: Permits, Fees , and Licenses revenue for FY 201 9 was 7.0% or $72,193 more than the amended budget. The majority of revenue in this category comes from permits and fees associated with new construction and/or renovations , re-zoning, false alarm fees, vacant building registration, and concealed weapons fees.  Fines and Forfeitures: Fines and forfeitures revenue for FY 201 9 was 1.2% or $4,490 less than the amended budget due to Parking Fines.  Interest on Investments: Interest on I nvestments revenue for FY 201 9 was 212.7% or $1,461,235 greater than the amen ded budget due to conservative budgeting and investment performance better than expected.  Charges for Services Charges for Services revenue for FY 2019 was 2.5% or $273,303 less than the amended budget, due primarily to the timing of receipts for LPD off-duty revenue, as well as Group Home charges.  Miscellaneous Revenue Miscellaneous Revenue for FY 2019 was 18.0% or $161,819 less than the amended budget, primarily due to the Region 2000 Services Authority not approving the allocation of excess revenue. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 4 DEDICATED REVENUES Intergovernmental Revenues consisting of Constitutional Officers, Health and Human Services, and State/Federal subsidies total ed $37,433,967 and were 0.7% or $ 247,038 less than FY 201 9 budget projection. EXPENDITURES  Operating Expenditures: Total operating expenditures for FY 20 19 were 94.5% of amended budget, compared to 96.5% for FY 2018. The actual operating expenditures for FY 201 9 were 5.5% or $9,238,183 less than the amended budget, which is attributable to departments closely monitoring their spending.  Debt Service Debt service expenditures are consistent with the budget. The payment schedule is based on a preset schedule and is not evenly disbursed over twelve months.  Transfers Transfers of $ 530,038 to other funds for FY 201 9 were consistent with the amended budget. Transfers of $6,778,968 to capital funds for FY 2019 were consistent with the budget. Finance Committee October 22, 2019 Page 5 SUMMARY This report represents twelve months of fiscal activity. The revenues and expenditures were adjusted in the 3rd Quarter process accordingly . The financial position of the General Fund remains stable. Staff recognizes that the gap between revenues and expenditures needs constant monitoring, and will continue to advise City Council of major developments through continued quarterly reports. Respectfully submitted, Donna S. Witt Chief Financial Officer cc: Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager Rhonda Allbeck, Assistant Director of Financial Services Fiscal Year Fiscal Calendar 2019 Fiscal Quarter of Year All Fiscal Month of Year All Fund 1001 General Fund Account Type Revenue Process Status Posted Revenues Adopted Budget Budget Amendment Amended Budget Actual Amount 6/30/19 Remaining Budget w/o Encumbrances Percentage of Amended Budget Actual Amount 6/30/18 100 Taxes 02110.0100 - Current Real Property Tax 57,124,670 - 57,124,670 57,645,519 (520,849) 100.9% 56,841,340 02110.0105 - Tax Relief For Elderly (650,000) - (650,000) (613,926) (36,074) 94.5% (637,012) 02110.0110 - Tax Relief-Rehabilitation Real Property (725,000) - (725,000) (963,300) 238,300 132.9% (699,836) 02110.0200 - Delinquent Real Property Tax 1,525,000 - 1,525,000 1,486,404 38,596 97.5% 1,440,939 02110.0900 - Real Estate Tax- Economic Development Incentive - - - (13,644) 13,644 0.0% (17,981) 02120.0100 - Current PSC Tax 2,475,000 - 2,475,000 2,596,128 (121,128) 104.9% 2,522,219 02130.0101 - Current Personal Property Tax PCI 17,945,000 - 17,945,000 18,850,037 (905,037) 105.0% 18,206,205 02130.0201 - Delinquent Personal Property Tax PCI 1,175,000 - 1,175,000 1,518,716 (343,716) 129.3% 1,358,387 02130.0205 - Recovery-C/O Personal Property Tax - - - 255 (255) 0.0% 72,964 02130.0900 - Personal Property Tax- Economic Development Incentive - (3,412) (3,412) (21,753) 18,341 637.6% (2,150) 02170.0100 - Penalty-PSC Tax - - - 7,328 (7,328) 0.0% 10,466 02170.0105 - Penalty-Delinquent Tax 650,000 - 650,000 666,958 (16,958) 102.6% 674,599 02170.0200 - Interest-PSC Tax - - - 72 (72) 0.0% 1,169 02170.0205 - Interest-Delinquent Tax 400,000 - 400,000 369,812 30,188 92.5% 426,858 02510.0000 - Local Sales And Use Tax 15,351,347 - 15,351,347 15,978,346 (626,999) 104.1% 15,297,496 02510.0900 - Local Sales & Use Tax- Economic Development Incentive - (26,803) (26,803) (64,617) 37,814 241.1% (14,755) 02515.0100 - Consumer Utility Tax-Electric 3,775,650 - 3,775,650 3,851,817 (76,167) 102.0% 3,890,588 02515.0105 - Consumer Utility Tax-Gas 575,000 - 575,000 647,354 (72,354) 112.6% 652,095 02515.0120 - Right of Way Fees 200,000 - 200,000 174,426 25,574 87.2% 226,288 02515.0900 - Pen & Int - Consumer Utility Tax, None - - - 313 (313) 0.0% - 02517.0000 - Communication Sales & Use Tax 3,045,315 - 3,045,315 2,877,715 167,600 94.5% 3,101,975 02520.0000 - Business License Tax 8,349,271 - 8,349,271 9,067,804 (718,533) 108.6% 8,745,469 02520.0010 - Consumption Tax-Electric 315,000 - 315,000 320,779 (5,779) 101.8% 323,676 02520.0015 - Consumption Tax-Gas 30,000 - 30,000 30,819 (819) 102.7% 31,988 02520.0030 - Pen & Int-Business License 90,000 - 90,000 96,072 (6,072) 106.7% 107,328 02520.0900 - Business License Tax- Economic Development Incentive - (7,346) (7,346) (21,139) 13,793 287.8% (5,845) 02530.0001 - Motor Vehicle Licenses PCI 1,575,000 - 1,575,000 1,601,711 (26,711) 101.7% 1,559,167 02530.0201 - Delinquent Motor Vehicle License 190,000 - 190,000 198,716 (8,716) 104.6% 206,740 02535.0000 - Bank Stock Tax 825,000 - 825,000 953,307 (128,307) 115.6% 829,988 02540.0100 - Recordation Tax-City 485,000 - 485,000 673,456 (188,456) 138.9% 600,639 02540.0200 - Probate Tax 15,000 - 15,000 21,027 (6,027) 140.2% 29,207 02545.0000 - Tobacco Tax 850,000 - 850,000 846,122 3,878 99.5% 870,084 02550.0000 - Amusement Tax 725,000 - 725,000 820,805 (95,805) 113.2% 847,388 02550.0005 - Pen & Int - Amusement Tax - - - 2,524 (2,524) 0.0% 1,558 02555.0000 - Lodging Tax 2,700,000 - 2,700,000 2,847,497 (147,497) 105.5% 2,627,328 02555.0005 - Pen & Int - Lodging Tax - - - 3,228 (3,228) 0.0% 3,379 02555.0900 - Lodging Tax- Economic Development Incentive - (84,331) (84,331) (199,455) 115,124 236.5% (44,087) 02560.0000 - Meals Tax 14,932,800 - 14,932,800 15,111,870 (179,070) 101.2% 14,719,911 02560.0005 - Pen & Int - Meals Tax 65,000 - 65,000 71,699 (6,699) 110.3% 49,793 02560.0900 - Meals Tax- Economic Development Incentive - (160,678) (160,678) (218,517) 57,839 136.0% (20,399) 100 Taxes Total 134,014,053 (282,570) 133,731,483 137,222,286 (3,490,803) 102.6% 134,835,168 110 Permits, Fees, & Licenses 03005.0000 - Animal Licenses 8,000 - 8,000 8,599 (599) 107.5% 8,849 03010.0100 - Bicycle Licenses, None - - - - - 0.0% - 03010.0200 - Permit Parking Fees 210,000 - 210,000 227,519 (17,519) 108.3% 201,805 03010.0400 - Land Disturbing Fees 18,000 - 18,000 14,587 3,413 81.0% 19,035 03010.0600 - Transfer Fees 1,600 - 1,600 2,062 (462) 128.9% 2,212 03010.0700 - Zoning Appeal Fees-Inspc 1,000 - 1,000 999 1 99.9% 375 03010.0702 - Zoning Certification Letter - - - 3,600 (3,600) 0.0% 600 03010.0705 - Legal Notice Advertising 16,000 - 16,000 5,489 10,511 34.3% 11,533 03010.0710 - Site Plan Reviews 15,000 - 15,000 14,125 875 94.2% 14,267 03010.0715 - Conditional Use Permits 4,000 - 4,000 4,620 (620) 115.5% 2,680 03010.0720 - Re-zoning Fees 6,000 - 6,000 18,853 (12,853) 314.2% 8,162 03010.0800 - Subdivision Plat Review 5,000 - 5,000 7,680 (2,680) 153.6% 5,475 03010.0900 - Building Insp Permit Fee 500,600 - 500,600 497,998 2,603 99.5% 527,973 03010.0901 - Elevator Inspect Admin Fee 21,000 - 21,000 18,197 2,803 86.7% 19,068 03010.0902 - Elevator Inspect Admin Fee Pen & Int - - - 411 (411) 0.0% 278 03010.0920 - Sign Inspect Permit Fee 5,900 - 5,900 6,050 (150) 102.5% 5,525 03010.0925 - Demolition Fees 6,000 - 6,000 10,550 (4,550) 175.8% 10,200 03010.0927 - Building Plan Review 40,000 - 40,000 44,375 (4,375) 110.9% 47,869 03010.0928 - Vacant Building Registration Fee 18,000 - 18,000 29,896 (11,896) 166.1% 12,518 03010.0929 - Pen & Int-Vacant Building Registration Fee - - - 1,561 (1,561) 0.0% 562 03010.0930 - Certificate of Occupancy for Existing Building - - - 3,900 (3,900) 0.0% 600 03010.0931 - Temporary Certificate of Occupancy, None - - - 3,450 (3,450) 0.0% - 03010.0932 - Working Without a Building Permit - - - 200 (200) 0.0% 200 03010.1000 - False Alarm Service Assessment 105,000 - 105,000 124,409 (19,409) 118.5% 139,788 03010.1100 - Concealed Weapon Permit 30,000 - 30,000 28,329 1,671 94.4% 31,920 03010.2005 - Taxicab Application Fees 5,000 - 5,000 3,020 1,980 60.4% 4,000 03010.2010 - Precious Metal Premits 1,600 - 1,600 1,000 600 62.5% 1,400 03010.2011 - Rental Reinspect/FollowUp - - - 1,350 (1,350) 0.0% 2,050 03010.2012 - Rental Intial Inspection - - - 5,700 (5,700) 0.0% 2,050 03010.2013 - Annual/Periodic Inspect Fee 15,000 - 15,000 8,700 6,300 58.0% 11,700 03010.2014 - Rental Intial Inspect-No Show - - - 1,200 (1,200) 0.0% 1,100 03010.2015 - Rental Inspect- Pre Court - - - - - 0.0% 850 03010.2016 - Rental Inspect-Annual No Show - - - 800 (800) 0.0% 1,000 03010.2020 - Mobile Vendor License Fee - - - 90 (90) 0.0% 400 03010.2028 - Dumpster Permit Fee , None - - - 50 (50) 0.0% - 03010.2050 - Misc Permit Fee & License 2,000 - 2,000 7,527 (5,527) 376.4% 5,241 110 Permits, Fees, & Licenses Total 1,034,700 - 1,034,700 1,106,893 (72,193) 107.0% 1,101,285 120 Fines & Forfeitures 03510.0100 - Court Fines And Forfeitures, None 240,000 - 240,000 258,205 (18,205) 107.6% 302,600 Revenues Adopted Budget Budget Amendment Amended Budget Actual Amount 6/30/19 Remaining Budget w/o Encumbrances Percentage of Amended Budget Actual Amount 6/30/18 03510.0105 - Criminal Court Fees 2,500 - 2,500 3,517 (1,017) 140.7% 3,324 03510.0200 - Parking Fines 125,000 - 125,000 101,288 23,712 81.0% 100,981 120 Fines & Forfeitures Total 367,500 - 367,500 363,010 4,490 98.8% 406,905 130 Use of Money & Property 04010.0100 - Interest on Investment 125,000 - 125,000 675,049 (550,049) 540.0% 308,785 04010.0101 - Interest-City Capital 60,000 - 60,000 294,688 (234,688) 491.1% 142,605 04010.0123 - Interest-Health Ins Resrv 15,000 - 15,000 17,918 (2,918) 119.5% 2,172 04010.0124 - Interest-OPEB 5,000 - 5,000 24,215 (19,215) 484.3% 28,753 04010.0129 - Interest Income- US Bank Escrow (Crossover Refunding) - - - 188,232 (188,232) 0.0% 65,287 04010.0156 - Interst-MktValueGain/Loss - - - 174,141 (174,141) 0.0% 35,529 04010.0157 - Interest-SNAP Income 70,000 - 70,000 132,596 (62,596) 189.4% 191,913 04020.0105 - Gen Govt Property Rental 75,000 - 75,000 82,558 (7,558) 110.1% 82,380 04020.0115 - Public Safety Prop Rent 36,250 - 36,250 36,250 - 100.0% 36,250 04020.0125 - Human Services Prop Rent 100,000 - 100,000 100,000 0 100.0% 100,000 04020.0135 - Dwntwn Parking Deck Lease 90,000 - 90,000 85,034 4,967 94.5% 76,276 04020.0200 - Culture & Rec. Prop Rent 15,070 - 15,070 15,070 - 100.0% 15,070 04020.0201 - Prop Rental-Stadium 3,200 - 3,200 216,657 (213,457) 6770.5% 215,957 04020.0202 - Prop Rental-Market/Park. 92,000 - 92,000 105,313 (13,313) 114.5% 90,891 04020.0205 - Market Rent- Pen & Int 560 - 560 594 (34) 106.1% 722 130 Use of Money & Property Total 687,080 - 687,080 2,148,315 (1,461,235) 312.7% 1,392,590 140 Charges for Services 04010.0129 - Interest Income- US Bank Escrow (Crossover Refunding) - - - - - 0.0% - 04510.0900 - Collection & Tax Lien Fees 25,000 - 25,000 49,287 (24,287) 197.1% 35,226 04510.0901 - DMV Admin Fee 250,000 - 250,000 278,607 (28,607) 111.4% 264,995 04510.0902 - DMV Select Agency 35,000 - 35,000 50,504 (15,504) 144.3% 39,694 04510.0911 - Sale of GIS Maps & Data 150 - 150 180 (30) 120.0% 106 04510.0915 - Processng Fee - Payroll deduction 5,000 - 5,000 4,950 50 99.0% 5,500 04510.0916 - Indirect Cost&Svc DetHome 233,048 - 233,048 233,048 - 100.0% 259,063 04510.0918 - Indirect Cost&Srvc Water 1,123,362 - 1,123,362 1,123,362 - 100.0% 1,045,633 04510.0919 - Indirect Cost&Srvc Sewer 281,299 - 281,299 276,087 5,212 98.1% 247,246 04510.0920 - Indirect Cost&Srvc WWTP 627,653 - 627,653 632,865 (5,212) 100.8% 608,114 04510.0921 - Indirect Cost&Srvc Airprt 162,596 - 162,596 161,131 1,465 99.1% 155,501 04510.0922 - Indirect Cost&Svc Strmwtr 182,783 - 182,783 182,783 - 100.0% 235,717 04510.0924 - Indirect Cost & Svc- Community Corrections - - - 5,022 (5,022) 0.0% 4,968 04515.0101 - Document Reprod Costs 8,000 - 8,000 6,366 1,634 79.6% 7,685 04515.0200 - Court Rm Sheriff Fee $10, None 80,000 - 80,000 59,519 20,481 74.4% 65,110 04515.0300 - Fees For Court Officers 7,244 - 7,244 7,244 (0) 100.0% 7,244 04515.0301 - Legal Service Charges 40,000 - 40,000 40,000 - 100.0% 40,000 04515.0302 - Non Consecutive Jail Fee - - - - - 0.0% 63 04515.0303 - Probation Supervisor Fee 13,789 - 13,789 15,259 (1,470) 110.7% 14,102 04515.0400 - Commonwealth Atty.Fees 7,000 - 7,000 9,147 (2,147) 130.7% 7,459 04515.0401 - CA Coll Fees- Gen Dist Ct 55,000 - 55,000 (26,557) 81,557 -48.3% 23,249 04515.0402 - CA Coll Fees- J&D Court 10,050 - 10,050 9,789 261 97.4% 9,356 04515.0403 - CA Coll Fees- Circuit Crt 62,600 - 62,600 77,565 (14,965) 123.9% 72,038 04520.0300 - Fire Prevention Fees 3,300 - 3,300 4,065 (765) 123.2% 3,050 04520.0301 - Ambulance Service Fees 2,665,000 - 2,665,000 2,813,828 (148,828) 105.6% 2,480,387 04520.0304 - Delinq Ambulance>120 Days 115,000 - 115,000 242,654 (127,654) 211.0% 229,115 04520.0901 - PIER Contract Payments 32,500 - 32,500 26,500 6,000 81.5% 32,500 04520.0902 - Criminal Records Check - - - - - 0.0% - 04520.0903 - Police-Schools Resource Officer (SRO) Prog 148,750 - 148,750 142,494 6,256 95.8% 97,435 04520.0904 - Local Reimb-COL Confined Space 50,000 - 50,000 50,000 - 100.0% 50,000 04520.0905 - Police Report Sales 14,000 - 14,000 14,610 (610) 104.4% 14,579 04520.0906 - Range Use Fee 15,200 - 15,200 14,400 800 94.7% 16,000 04520.0908 - $250 DUI Fees - - - 8,035 (8,035) 0.0% 12,518 04520.0909 - LPD Off Duty 1,268,000 - 1,268,000 1,058,893 209,107 83.5% 1,101,043 04525.0106 - Downtown Parking Fees 40,000 - 40,000 42,534 (2,534) 106.3% 38,009 04525.0107 - PW Admin Stormwater Charges 131,855 - 131,855 89,325 42,530 67.7% 119,245 04525.0108 - PW Eng Stormwater Charges 17,927 - 17,927 6,843 11,084 38.2% 10,533 04525.0109 - PW Streets Stormwater Charges 161,131 - 161,131 130,200 30,931 80.8% 147,974 04525.0206 - Residential Disposal-Decals 820,000 - 820,000 874,558 (54,558) 106.7% 838,344 04525.0218 - Trash Bag Srvc-Waste Zero 185,000 - 185,000 180,092 4,908 97.3% 176,781 04525.0300 - Bldg Maint Charge-Other 10,142 - 10,142 10,142 - 100.0% 10,142 04530.0401 - CSA Service Providers 45,000 - 45,000 37,882 7,118 84.2% 34,390 04530.0403 - Local Reimb-Opportunity - - - - - 0.0% - 04530.0404 - Local Reimb-Sparc House - - - - - 0.0% - 04530.0409 - Human Services Court Order Fees - - - 2,583 (2,583) 0.0% 4,751 04530.0410 - Lynchburg Youth Group Home Charges 801,496 31,928 833,424 573,120 260,304 68.8% 743,297 04530.0412 - Horizon Contribution for Outstationed Benefit Workers, None - 17,500 17,500 17,500 - 100.0% - 04535.0100 - Swimming Pool Fees 25,000 - 25,000 25,021 (21) 100.1% 32,414 04535.0150 - Recreation Program Fees 461,500 - 461,500 434,735 26,765 94.2% 411,038 04535.0200 - Point of Honor Admission Fees 11,000 - 11,000 9,430 1,570 85.7% 12,644 04535.0300 - Library Fines & Fees 56,000 - 56,000 54,152 1,848 96.7% 54,706 04535.0301 - Law Library Fees 30,000 - 30,000 36,375 (6,375) 121.2% 34,734 04535.0303 - Lost/Damaged Library Prop 5,000 - 5,000 5,771 (771) 115.4% 5,987 04535.0304 - Delinq Library Fines & Fees - - - 1,889 (1,889) 0.0% 2,413 04535.0305 - Delinq Library Lost/Damaged - - - 3,642 (3,642) 0.0% 4,637 04535.0306 - Delinq Library Pen & Int - - - 1,115 (1,115) 0.0% 1,385 04540.0103 - Charges For Demolition - - - - - 0.0% 5,449 04540.0105 - Comm Develop Stormwater Charges 495,590 - 495,590 495,590 - 100.0% 495,590 04599.0002 - Secure Vacant Stru Reimb - - - 3,363 (3,363) 0.0% 2,223 04599.0004 - Weed Ordinance Program 28,000 - 28,000 14,590 13,410 52.1% 31,888 140 Charges for Services Total 10,845,965 49,428 10,895,393 10,622,090 273,303 97.5% 10,403,269 150 Miscellaneous Revenue 05030.0105 - Suspense Revenue/Exp Ref - - - - - 0.0% - 05050.0105 - Pmt In Lieu Tax-WestCntbr 52,900 - 52,900 52,901 (1) 100.0% 52,901 05050.0110 - Pymt In Lieu of Tax-LRHA 25,000 - 25,000 35,847 (10,847) 143.4% - 05050.0230 - Friends of Lynchburg Library 7,250 2,217 9,467 9,467 - 100.0% 7,250 05050.0232 - Digg's Trust Rec-Pt Honor 36,900 - 36,900 27,750 9,150 75.2% 39,850 05050.0251 - Contributions-Adopt-A-Bed - - - 2,005 (2,005) 0.0% 2,647 Revenues Adopted Budget Budget Amendment Amended Budget Actual Amount 6/30/19 Remaining Budget w/o Encumbrances Percentage of Amended Budget Actual Amount 6/30/18 05050.0278 - Donations for Rotary Centennial Skate Park, None - - - 12,844 (12,844) 0.0% - 05050.0290 - Gifts And Misc. 2,000 - 2,000 3,319 (1,319) 165.9% 2,991 05050.0400 - Sale-Salvage/Surplus Prop - - - 5,332 (5,332) 0.0% 1,232 05050.0415 - Proceeds frm PropRoom.com - - - 839 (839) 0.0% 605 05050.0500 - Sale-Real Property - - - 90,000 (90,000) 0.0% 307,000 05050.0801 - Miscellaneous Subrogation - - - - - 0.0% - 05050.2001 - Cash Overage And Shortage - - - (1,856) 1,856 0.0% (4,768) 05050.2011 - Reimb.POH Carriage House 26,300 - 26,300 20,813 5,488 79.1% 27,750 05050.2013 - Photo Reprod And Royalty 200 - 200 70 130 35.0% 168 05050.2016 - Dedicated Misc Rev HumSvc - - - - - 0.0% (4,819) 05050.2022 - Trash Cart Sales 3,000 - 3,000 4,011 (1,011) 133.7% 4,210 05050.2025 - Credit Card Rebate 100,000 - 100,000 115,682 (15,682) 115.7% 112,953 05050.2028 - WardsCrossingWestSvcFee 135,923 - 135,923 135,923 - 100.0% 135,923 05050.2033 - PointOfHonr-GiftShopSales 1,000 - 1,000 - 1,000 0.0% - 05050.2034 - P&R Spec Event Sponsorship, None 12,000 - 12,000 11,310 690 94.2% 10,092 05050.2037 - RSA Profit Sharing 300,000 - 300,000 - 300,000 0.0% 369,465 05050.2046 - Visitor Ctr Merchandise 23,700 - 23,700 5,454 18,246 23.0% 19,294 05050.2049 - Trash Bag&Decal Violation 5,000 - 5,000 400 4,600 8.0% 2,331 05050.2052 - Parking Lease Agreement 100,000 - 100,000 113,841 (13,841) 113.8% 110,617 05050.2055 - Hillcats - Donation Youth Athletic Programs 10,000 - 10,000 - 10,000 0.0% 10,000 05050.2056 - Commission on City Vending Machine Sales - 389 389 3,762 (3,373) 967.0% 3,863 05050.2090 - Miscellaneous Revenue 57,000 - 57,000 89,247 (32,247) 156.6% 132,301 150 Miscellaneous Revenue Total 898,173 2,606 900,779 738,960 161,819 82.0% 1,343,856 300 State Non-Categorical Aid 06100.0300 - Rolling Stock Taxes 90,000 - 90,000 90,734 (734) 100.8% 90,544 06100.0400 - Mobile Home Titling Taxes 1,000 - 1,000 3,326 (2,326) 332.6% 4,298 06100.0600 - Deeds Of Conveyance 125,000 - 125,000 188,816 (63,816) 151.1% 162,310 06100.0800 - Recordation Taxes-State 150,000 - 150,000 202,516 (52,516) 135.0% 204,314 06100.0900 - Auto Rental Tax-DMV 280,000 - 280,000 386,029 (106,029) 137.9% 325,766 06100.1108 - Personal Prop Tax Relief 5,543,584 - 5,543,584 5,543,584 0 100.0% 5,543,584 300 State Non-Categorical Aid Total 6,189,584 - 6,189,584 6,415,005 (225,421) 103.6% 6,330,816 310 State Shared Exp (Cat.) 06510.0200 - Commissioner of Revenue 179,935 - 179,935 179,737 198 99.9% 179,450 06510.0300 - Treasurer 102,000 - 102,000 104,639 (2,639) 102.6% 102,118 06510.1000 - Registrar/Electoral Board 47,000 - 47,000 47,586 (586) 101.2% 46,739 06515.0100 - Clerk of Cir Crt-Fringes 562,000 - 562,000 570,876 (8,876) 101.6% 577,061 06515.0200 - Sheriff 1,130,080 - 1,130,080 1,088,364 41,716 96.3% 1,151,150 06515.0400 - Commonwealth Attorney 1,013,636 - 1,013,636 1,045,048 (31,412) 103.1% 1,043,288 310 State Shared Exp (Cat.) Total 3,034,651 - 3,034,651 3,036,250 (1,599) 100.1% 3,099,806 320 State Categorical Aid 06820.0200 - Juvenile Correct-Block Gt 247,716 - 247,716 247,716 - 100.0% 247,716 06820.0201 - Wireless E911 371,373 - 371,373 381,670 (10,297) 102.8% 301,120 06820.0203 - HB 599 Law Enforc.Asst 3,137,083 - 3,137,083 3,137,084 (1) 100.0% 3,025,152 06825.0100 - Street And Highway Maint. 8,133,555 426,261 8,559,816 8,559,817 (1) 100.0% 8,069,555 06830.0412 - Health Department 70,000 - 70,000 34,320 35,680 49.0% 53,378 06830.0413 - SS State Adm Sub 0901 2,310,216 123,103 2,433,319 1,729,982 703,337 71.1% 1,716,392 06830.0414 - SS State Prog Sub 0902 5,644,405 - 5,644,405 4,437,354 1,207,051 78.6% 4,569,806 06830.0428 - Finance-Social Srvc-State - - - - - 0.0% - 06835.0101 - SNAP Benefit Prog Grant, None - - - 10 (10) 0.0% - 06835.0102 - SNAP Program Reimb 15,000 - 15,000 11,951 3,049 79.7% 12,742 06835.0103 - SNAP Prog-Double Dollar - - - 250 (250) 0.0% 1,000 06835.0104 - VDH- We Got the Beet Campaign - 13,332 13,332 13,332 - 100.0% 45,583 06835.0300 - Finan Asst-Public Library 156,353 1,211 157,564 157,564 - 100.0% 155,687 320 State Categorical Aid Total 20,085,701 563,907 20,649,608 18,711,049 1,938,559 90.6% 18,198,131 330 State Aid in Suspense 05030.0100 - Suspense Rev-Va EDI Pmts - - - - - 0.0% - 330 State Aid in Suspense Total - - - - - 0.0% - 510 Federal Direct Cat. Aid 07540.1001 - IRS Int Subsidy 8/09 BABs 81,328 - 81,328 81,502 (174) 100.2% 81,197 07540.1002 - IRS Int Subs 8/09 BABsSCH 192,969 - 192,969 193,382 (413) 100.2% 192,659 510 Federal Direct Cat. Aid Total 274,297 - 274,297 274,884 (587) 100.2% 273,856 520 Fed Cat Aid- Pass Thru 07825.0300 - B&G Chrgs Commerce St Bld 55,000 - 55,000 48,119 6,881 87.5% 51,415 07830.0420 - Fed Pass Thru:Cost AIIDMG 450,000 - 450,000 572,494 (122,494) 127.2% 539,749 07830.0421 - SS Fed Adm Sub 0901 3,709,562 89,266 3,798,828 4,698,673 (899,845) 123.7% 4,649,713 07830.0422 - SS Fed Prog Sub 0902 3,051,946 - 3,051,946 3,519,632 (467,686) 115.3% 3,633,298 07830.0428 - Finance-Social Srvc-Fed - - - - - 0.0% - 07830.0430 - USDA Funding - Group Home, None 15,000 - 15,000 16,739 (1,739) 111.6% - 07875.0003 - Human Service Lease 147,091 - 147,091 129,786 17,305 88.2% 129,786 07875.0021 - FINI Double-Dollars - 15,000 15,000 11,337 3,663 75.6% 10,535 520 Fed Cat Aid- Pass Thru Total 7,428,599 104,266 7,532,865 8,996,780 (1,463,915) 119.4% 9,014,497 700 Proceed From Indebtedness 08510.0001 - Proceeds From Bond Sale - - - - - 0.0% - 08510.0005 - Refunding Bond Proceeds - - - - - 0.0% 5,095,489 08510.0006 - Refunding Bond Proc Prem - - - - - 0.0% 561,020 08510.0007 - Refundng Bnd Proceeds Sch - - - - - 0.0% 10,126,066 08510.0008 - Refndng Bds Proc Prem Sch - - - - - 0.0% 1,139,743 08550.0000 - Proceeds - Line of Credit - - - - - 0.0% 103,342 700 Proceed From Indebtedness Total - - - - - 0.0% 17,025,659 710 Operating Transfers In 09201.0037 - TrfFrmCFSA-Operating Trfr - - - - - 0.0% 2,397 09225.0015 - Transfer from Tech Fund to General Fund, None - 50,000 50,000 50,000 - 100.0% - 09301.0003 - TrfFrmCtyCp-Capital Proj - 306,314 306,314 306,314 - 100.0% 250,000 09425.0001 - Trfr From Stormwater Oper, None - 337,500 337,500 337,500 - 100.0% - 710 Operating Transfers In Total - 693,814 693,814 693,814 - 100.0% 252,397 Grand Total 184,860,303 1,131,451 185,991,754 190,329,334 (4,337,581) 102.3% 203,678,234 Fiscal Year Fiscal Calendar 2019 Fiscal Quarter of Year All Fund 1001 General Fund Account Type Expenses Process Status Posted Expenditures Adopted Budget Budget Amendment Amended Budget Actual Amount 6/30/19 Remaining Budget w/ Encumbrances Percentage Used w/ Encumbrances Actual Amount 6/30/18 2022 Communications/Marketing 0021 Public Information 491,651 (1,808) 489,843 472,398 17,445 96.4% 555,326 0022 Customer Service Center 128,775 584 129,359 138,413 (9,054) 107.0% 129,741 0029 Local Government Channel 169,412 6,439 175,851 170,142 5,709 96.8% 160,283 2022 Communications/Marketing Total 789,838 5,215 795,053 780,954 14,099 98.2% 845,350 2023 Council / Manager 0028 Council / Manager 1,046,832 16,310 1,063,142 1,040,237 22,905 97.8% 1,068,191 0033 Parking Division 532,774 67,532 600,306 546,500 53,807 91.0% 507,103 2023 Council / Manager Total 1,579,606 83,842 1,663,448 1,586,736 76,712 95.4% 1,575,293 2027 Tourism 0044 Tourism 1,036,338 (1,036,338) - - - 0.0% 889,849 0045 Visitors Center 136,393 (136,393) - - - 0.0% 110,196 2027 Tourism Total 1,172,731 (1,172,731) - - - 0.0% 1,000,045 2030 City Attorney 0050 City Attorney 803,121 18,097 821,218 802,996 18,222 97.8% 738,700 0051 Risk Management 588,357 - 588,357 588,357 - 100.0% 601,049 2030 City Attorney Total 1,391,478 18,097 1,409,575 1,391,353 18,222 98.7% 1,339,749 2035 State Treasurer 0060 State Treasurer 169,985 8,538 178,523 178,290 233 99.9% 170,234 2035 State Treasurer Total 169,985 8,538 178,523 178,290 233 99.9% 170,234 2040 Commissioner Of Revenue 0070 Com Rev-State/Loc Budget 730,338 29,111 759,449 705,091 54,358 92.8% 728,032 2040 Commissioner Of Revenue Total 730,338 29,111 759,449 705,091 54,358 92.8% 728,032 2045 City Assessor 0080 City Assessor 731,167 34,888 766,055 751,843 14,212 98.1% 723,346 2045 City Assessor Total 731,167 34,888 766,055 751,843 14,212 98.1% 723,346 2050 Finance 0090 Office of Management & Budget 603,434 24,026 627,460 637,762 (10,302) 101.6% 608,755 0093 Billings And Collections 1,288,204 33,243 1,321,447 1,306,220 15,228 98.8% 1,202,126 0094 Procurement 311,971 15,396 327,367 315,840 11,527 96.5% 309,560 0095 Accounting 961,587 20,541 982,128 969,792 12,336 98.7% 944,172 0097 Human Services-Finance - - - - - 0.0% - 2050 Finance Total 3,165,196 93,206 3,258,402 3,229,613 28,788 99.1% 3,064,613 2055 Human Resources 0110 Human Resources 800,718 144,394 945,112 921,423 23,689 97.5% 916,581 0111 Occupational Health Svs 130,000 6,500 136,500 202,750 (66,250) 148.5% 213,724 0112 Health Management Program - - - - - 0.0% - 2055 Human Resources Total 930,718 150,894 1,081,612 1,124,172 (42,561) 103.9% 1,130,305 2057 Information Technology 0115 Application Services 1,325,785 31,872 1,357,657 1,300,185 57,472 95.8% 1,286,894 0116 Network Services 1,713,476 36,940 1,750,416 1,638,142 112,274 93.6% 1,693,888 0117 I T Administration 456,933 5,184 462,117 417,521 44,596 90.3% 358,960 0125 GIS 324,902 4,931 329,833 311,434 18,399 94.4% 301,435 2057 Information Technology Total 3,821,096 78,926 3,900,022 3,667,282 232,740 94.0% 3,641,178 2065 Registrar 0150 Registrar 183,546 11,450 194,996 191,038 3,958 98.0% 191,651 0151 Electoral Board 103,061 20,900 123,961 93,358 30,603 75.3% 115,747 2065 Registrar Total 286,607 32,350 318,957 284,396 34,561 89.2% 307,398 2090 Education 0200 Lcl Sch Oper Contribution 42,028,498 1,086,573 43,115,071 38,373,801 4,741,270 89.0% 38,824,341 2090 Education Total 42,028,498 1,086,573 43,115,071 38,373,801 4,741,270 89.0% 38,824,341 2105 Circuit Court-Judge 0300 Circuit Court-Judge 159,917 2,933 162,850 152,227 10,623 93.5% 138,473 2105 Circuit Court-Judge Total 159,917 2,933 162,850 152,227 10,623 93.5% 138,473 2110 General District Court 0310 General District Court 58,173 (174) 57,999 31,859 26,140 54.9% 31,373 2110 General District Court Total 58,173 (174) 57,999 31,859 26,140 54.9% 31,373 2115 Juvenile & Dr Dist Court 0320 Juvenile & Dr Dist Court 15,024 - 15,024 18,008 (2,984) 119.9% 12,747 2115 Juvenile & Dr Dist Court Total 15,024 - 15,024 18,008 (2,984) 119.9% 12,747 2120 24th Court Service Unit 0330 24th Court Service Unit 1,550 380 1,930 1,716 214 88.9% 1,169 Expenditures Adopted Budget Budget Amendment Amended Budget Actual Amount 6/30/19 Remaining Budget w/ Encumbrances Percentage Used w/ Encumbrances Actual Amount 6/30/18 2120 24th Court Service Unit Total 1,550 380 1,930 1,716 214 88.9% 1,169 2125 Commonwealth's Attorney 0340 Commonwealth Attorney 1,608,104 32,724 1,640,828 1,653,773 (12,945) 100.8% 1,645,599 0343 Com Aty Fines & Fees Coll 62,075 1,916 63,991 62,149 1,842 97.1% 62,881 2125 Commonwealth's Attorney Total 1,670,179 34,640 1,704,819 1,715,922 (11,103) 100.7% 1,708,480 2130 Magistrate's Office 0350 Magistrate's Office 3,977 435 4,412 3,446 966 78.1% 3,162 2130 Magistrate's Office Total 3,977 435 4,412 3,446 966 78.1% 3,162 2135 Circuit Court-Clerk 0360 Circuit Court-Clerk 877,504 84,491 961,995 923,567 38,428 96.0% 889,194 2135 Circuit Court-Clerk Total 877,504 84,491 961,995 923,567 38,428 96.0% 889,194 2200 City Sheriff 0400 City Sheriff And Jail 2,091,581 103,312 2,194,893 2,201,374 (6,481) 100.3% 2,195,382 2200 City Sheriff Total 2,091,581 103,312 2,194,893 2,201,374 (6,481) 100.3% 2,195,382 2240 Police 0420 Police Operations 16,709,468 544,137 17,253,605 17,070,444 183,160 98.9% 16,556,943 0421 Animal Warden 331,998 9,780 341,778 336,300 5,478 98.4% 276,370 0429 Range Operations 15,000 1,451 16,451 13,677 2,774 83.1% 17,823 0430 Police Off Duty Employmnt 1,146,894 273 1,147,167 1,049,879 97,288 91.5% 1,085,839 2240 Police Total 18,203,360 555,641 18,759,001 18,470,301 288,700 98.5% 17,936,975 2245 Emergency Services 0422 Emergency Communications 2,691,621 105,052 2,796,673 2,659,359 137,314 95.1% 2,641,979 2245 Emergency Services Total 2,691,621 105,052 2,796,673 2,659,359 137,314 95.1% 2,641,979 2270 Fire 0444 Fire Operations And Ems 15,947,300 282,175 16,229,475 15,968,142 261,333 98.4% 15,885,248 0446 TRT- PIER Program 82,500 2,438 84,938 67,322 17,616 79.3% 70,911 2270 Fire Total 16,029,800 284,613 16,314,413 16,035,464 278,949 98.3% 15,956,159 2400 Public Works 0600 Public Works Administrat. 943,804 8,355 952,159 968,782 (16,624) 101.7% 961,318 0605 Engineering 3,874,391 120,329 3,994,720 3,839,919 154,801 96.1% 3,867,611 0632 Street Maintenance,II 3,282,439 (245,652) 3,036,787 2,766,500 270,287 91.1% 2,459,379 0635 Snow Removal 287,207 378,353 665,560 675,384 (9,824) 101.5% 281,025 0640 Refuse Collection 3,032,291 200,233 3,232,524 3,267,881 (35,357) 101.1% 2,922,619 0645 Parks/Grounds Maintenance 2,901,625 192,315 3,093,940 3,330,437 (236,497) 107.6% 3,028,762 0649 Baseball Stadium Maint 112,023 460 112,483 127,380 (14,897) 113.2% 122,254 0650 Building Maintenance 3,809,449 86,147 3,895,596 3,692,960 202,636 94.8% 3,847,860 0660 Human Services Maint. 245,510 1,094 246,604 237,160 9,444 96.2% 242,870 2400 Public Works Total 18,488,739 741,633 19,230,372 18,906,403 323,969 98.3% 17,733,696 2555 Health 0800 Health Operations 830,977 - 830,977 747,685 83,292 90.0% 743,015 2555 Health Total 830,977 - 830,977 747,685 83,292 90.0% 743,015 2561 Juvenile Services 0904 Juvenile Service Admin. 306,069 3,604 309,673 199,937 109,736 64.6% 203,964 0905 Juvenile Detention Home 400,000 - 400,000 621,813 (221,813) 155.5% 487,044 0906 Lynchburg Youth Group Home 1,216,950 62,317 1,279,267 1,213,675 65,592 94.9% 1,192,357 0915 Csa Service Providers 2,038,296 2,340 2,040,636 2,037,395 3,241 99.8% 2,089,575 0929 Lynchburg Outreach Prog 190,966 4,707 195,673 199,076 (3,403) 101.7% 195,825 2561 Juvenile Services Total 4,152,281 72,968 4,225,249 4,271,896 (46,647) 101.1% 4,168,764 2562 Social Services 0901 Social Services Admin. 8,166,049 541,380 8,707,429 8,620,412 87,017 99.0% 8,050,376 0902 Public Assistance 8,869,737 20,250 8,889,987 7,473,176 1,416,812 84.1% 8,430,329 2562 Social Services Total 17,035,786 561,630 17,597,416 16,093,587 1,503,829 91.5% 16,480,704 2563 Recreation Services 0116 Network Services 76,393 1,264 77,657 75,545 2,112 97.3% 48,406 1002 Parks/Rec/Market 401,073 29,880 430,953 416,419 14,534 96.6% 438,122 1010 Recreation, General Admin 559,498 21,442 580,940 567,117 13,823 97.6% 578,017 1011 Recreation Services 139,580 3,604 143,184 144,025 (841) 100.6% 123,354 1013 Recreation, Athletic 146,192 4,681 150,873 155,628 (4,755) 103.2% 144,086 1015 Recreation, Park Services 700,951 29,772 730,723 766,945 (36,222) 105.0% 704,334 1022 Recreation, Aquatics 93,313 - 93,313 82,971 10,342 88.9% 85,755 1023 Recreation, Naturalist 179,271 8,799 188,070 165,263 22,807 87.9% 165,522 1024 Special Events-Cty Sponsr 50,000 - 50,000 49,721 279 99.4% 55,681 1027 Recreation Programs 539,604 15,000 554,604 471,271 83,333 85.0% 498,953 1028 City-wide Centers 275,604 8,516 284,120 278,733 5,387 98.1% 264,629 1029 Neighborhood Centers 636,806 13,644 650,450 585,983 64,467 90.1% 559,137 2563 Recreation Services Total 3,798,285 136,602 3,934,887 3,759,620 175,267 95.5% 3,665,996 2610 Libraries And Museums 1100 Public Library 1,426,397 86,800 1,513,197 1,480,893 32,304 97.9% 1,443,070 Expenditures Adopted Budget Budget Amendment Amended Budget Actual Amount 6/30/19 Remaining Budget w/ Encumbrances Percentage Used w/ Encumbrances Actual Amount 6/30/18 1120 Law Library 8,200 - 8,200 8,435 (235) 102.9% 9,250 2610 Libraries And Museums Total 1,434,597 86,800 1,521,397 1,489,328 32,070 97.9% 1,452,319 2611 Museum System 1150 Museum 469,134 17,941 487,075 449,536 37,539 92.3% 398,796 2611 Museum System Total 469,134 17,941 487,075 449,536 37,539 92.3% 398,796 2715 Community Development 1200 Director-Comm Plan/Dev 312,567 8,858 321,425 286,838 34,587 89.2% 321,476 1201 Planning 335,376 10,727 346,103 343,661 2,442 99.3% 326,584 1202 Inspections 902,420 32,382 934,802 895,507 39,295 95.8% 836,996 1205 Zoning 249,023 11,580 260,603 278,954 (18,351) 107.0% 254,839 2715 Community Development Total 1,799,386 63,547 1,862,933 1,804,960 57,973 96.9% 1,739,894 2720 Office Of Economic Devel 1300 Economic Development 461,599 1,188,658 1,650,257 1,546,044 104,212 93.7% 445,427 2720 Office Of Economic Devel Total 461,599 1,188,658 1,650,257 1,546,044 104,212 93.7% 445,427 5000 Nondept Employee Benefits 1430 Non-allocated Emp Benefit 3,388,834 9,461 3,398,295 2,909,946 488,349 85.6% 3,463,611 5000 Nondept Employee Benefits Total 3,388,834 9,461 3,398,295 2,909,946 488,349 85.6% 3,463,611 5050 Non-Departmental 1506 Water Oper Fund Payments 815,335 - 815,335 815,335 - 100.0% 871,831 1508 Stormwater Fee-City Bldgs 87,900 - 87,900 95,408 (7,508) 108.5% 87,276 1509 Stormwater Fee-School Bld 70,200 - 70,200 75,688 (5,488) 107.8% 69,696 1512 College Lake Dam Repairs - 856,481 856,481 989,429 (132,948) 115.5% - 1529 Landfill Closure Costs - - - 16,710 (16,710) 0.0% 13,077 1566 Managed Vacancy Program - - - - - 0.0% - 1567 Years of Service Awards 16,089 - 16,089 14,400 1,689 89.5% 11,862 1568 Retirement Recognition 2,311 3,012 5,323 4,871 452 91.5% 4,600 1569 Take Your Kids to Work Dy 600 - 600 206 394 34.4% 693 1570 Emp Appreciation Luncheon 3,000 953 3,953 3,215 738 81.3% 2,910 1573 Payment-Fleet Capital Chg 2,787,005 - 2,787,005 2,436,685 350,320 87.4% 2,339,409 1574 Health Management Program 15,000 - 15,000 29,622 (14,622) 197.5% 216,715 1575 Employee Committee Funds 8,000 6,559 14,559 4,860 9,699 33.4% 4,491 1576 Line of Duty Act 250,000 - 250,000 267,213 (17,213) 106.9% 225,614 1578 Poverty Intiative 50,000 91,108 141,108 20,107 121,001 14.2% 7,563 1579 Recruitment 15,000 - 15,000 1,829 13,171 12.2% 100 1580 International Festival - - - (2,174) 2,174 0.0% (1,188) 1581 Workplace Safety & Wellness 50,000 - 50,000 51,454 (1,454) 102.9% - 1637 City Cemetery Master Plan 132,438 - 132,438 132,438 - 100.0% 132,438 5050 Non-Departmental Total 4,302,878 958,113 5,260,991 4,957,294 303,696 94.2% 3,987,087 5060 Support Local/State Organ 1702 V.P.I. Extension Service 39,890 - 39,890 38,138 1,752 95.6% 37,727 1705 Lynchburg Humane Society 351,697 - 351,697 351,697 - 100.0% 351,697 1707 Cent Va Area Agc On Aging 15,000 - 15,000 15,000 - 100.0% 15,000 1708 Horizon Behavioral Health 555,900 - 555,900 555,900 - 100.0% 457,323 1709 Cvcc Board & Related Oper 1,942 - 1,942 1,942 - 100.0% 1,922 1711 Cent Va Planning Dist Com 45,731 - 45,731 45,730 1 100.0% 45,238 1715 Greater Lynch. Transit Co 1,728,785 - 1,728,785 1,591,096 137,689 92.0% 1,451,063 1721 Blue Ridge Regional Jail 5,255,314 - 5,255,314 5,325,906 (70,592) 101.3% 5,055,837 1724 Legal Aid Society 11,699 - 11,699 11,699 - 100.0% 11,699 1739 Contrib- Amazement Square 200 - 200 - 200 0.0% - 1743 Central Va Reg Radio Brd 720,173 - 720,173 720,173 (0) 100.0% 720,393 1747 The Virginian 168,250 - 168,250 - 168,250 0.0% - 1748 Elizabeth's Early Learn Center 15,000 - 15,000 11,066 3,934 73.8% - 5060 Support Local/State Organ Total 8,909,581 - 8,909,581 8,668,348 241,233 97.3% 8,147,900 7450 Debt Service 5985 Refunded Debt Payments - - - - - 0.0% 2,160,352 5990 Principal Bonds/BANS/LOC 10,653,977 (4,193) 10,649,784 10,649,783 1 100.0% 10,416,914 5994 Interest Bonds/BANS/LOC 7,388,184 4,193 7,392,377 7,316,952 75,425 99.0% 7,378,458 5996 Debt Issuance Costs - - - - - 0.0% 346,067 5997 Debt - Misc. Charges 6,910 - 6,910 4,691 2,219 67.9% 1,706 7450 Debt Service Total 18,049,071 - 18,049,071 17,971,427 77,644 99.6% 20,303,498 7570 Other Financing Uses 9710 Operating Transfers Out 6,125,251 1,776,305 7,901,556 7,901,556 - 100.0% 5,623,614 7570 Other Financing Uses Total 6,125,251 1,776,305 7,901,556 7,901,556 - 100.0% 5,623,614 Grand Total 187,846,343 7,233,888 195,080,231 185,764,404 9,315,828 95.2% 183,219,299 TO: City Council Bonnie Svrcek, City Manager Reid Wodicka, Deputy City Manager Robin Craig, Clerk of Council FROM: Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer DATE: October 22, 2019 RE: FY 2019 Write-Off of Uncollectible Accounts Receivable In June 2005, an Accounts Receivable Policy was established to write-off uncollectible accounts. In accordance with the policy, the Chief Financial Officer is authorized to write-off accounts on an annual basis, providing this information to Finance Committee and City Council. Using the criteria set-forth in the Accounts Receivable Policy, a breakdown of write-offs for FY 2019 is as follows: If you have any questions, please let me know. Thank you. Account Statute of Limitations Write-off Year and Billing Amount Write-Off Amount Billing Amount % Written-Off Real Estate 20 1998 19,982.09 25,424,234.48 0.08% Amusement Tax 5 2013 0.03 644,263.82 0.00% Business License 5 2013 62,386.96 7,850,754.15 0.79% Library Fines 5 2013 5,429.68 48,429.65 11.21% Lodging Tax 5 2013 0.00 1,901,626.64 0.00% Meals Tax 5 2013 52,488.27 12,206,343.82 0.43% Personal Property 5 2013 144,170.26 17,668,163.59 0.82% Public Service Corporation 5 2013 1.00 2,349,747.33 0.00% Ambulance 3 2015 677,331.59 5,288,936.30 12.81% Miscellaneous Invoices 3 2015 27,356.81 2,844,872.83 0.96% Non Sufficient Funds 3 2015 858.92 61,142.09 1.40% Utility Billing System 3 2015 26,441.51 37,463,462.00 0.07% Total Write-Off 1,016,447.12$ 113,751,976.70$ 0.89% AGENDA ITEM #: 11 FINANCE COMMITTEE Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 12 CONSENT: REGULAR: X WORK SESSION: CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Revenue Update KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X__Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _ _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Review the collections received from five of the City’s revenue sources. SUMMARY: Five of the City’s major revenue sources are taxes collected on a monthly basis: Local Sales and Use Tax, Consumer Utility Tax – Electric, Meals Tax, Lodging Tax, and Amusement Tax. Since the last Finance Committee meeting, revenue information through August 2019 has been posted for these five revenue streams. PRIOR ACTION(S): This information is provided monthly to the Finance Committee. FISCAL IMPACT: None CONTACT(S): Donna Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): Comparison of Collections Budget to Actual FY 2019 – FY 2020 REVIEWED BY: Comparison of Collections Budget to Actual FY 2019 - FY 2020 Actual FY 2017 Actual FY 2018 Actual FY 2019 Adopted FY 2020 Actual FY 2020 Actual FY 2020 to Adopted FY 2020 Actual FY 2020 to Actual FY 2019 SALES & USE TAX ADOPTED FY 2020 BUDGET - $15,673,983 JULY $1,152,527 $1,134,520 $1,361,089 $1,335,342 $1,302,652 ($32,690) ($58,437) AUGUST 1,267,330 1,248,275 1,287,868 1,263,506 1,398,983 135,477 111,115 TOTAL $2,419,857 $2,382,795 $2,648,957 $2,598,848 $2,701,635 $102,787 $52,678 CONSUMER UTILITY TAX - ELECTRIC ADOPTED FY 2020 BUDGET - $3,800,000 JULY $328,501 $335,326 $343,448 $338,828 $323,666 ($15,162) ($19,782) AUGUST 355,434 327,959 332,393 327,921 335,376 7,455 2,983 TOTAL $683,935 $663,285 $675,841 $666,749 $659,042 ($7,707) ($16,799) Actual Collected FY 2017 2 Actual Collected FY 2018 2 Actual Collected FY 2019 2 Adopted FY 2020 Actual Assessed FY 2020 Actual Assessed FY 2020 to Adopted FY 2020 Actual Collected FY 2020 2 Actual Collected FY 2020 to Adopted FY 2020 Actual Collected FY 2020 to Assessed FY 2020 MEALS TAX ADOPTED FY 2020 BUDGET - $15,500,000 JULY 1 $1,088,474 $1,109,545 $1,157,381 $1,203,713 $1,192,588 ($11,125) $1,167,412 ($36,301) ($25,176) AUGUST 1,098,748 1,140,836 1,208,215 1,280,948 1,338,608 57,660 1,327,301 46,353 (11,307) TOTAL $2,187,222 $2,250,381 $2,365,596 $2,484,661 $2,531,196 $46,535 $2,494,713 $10,052 ($36,483) LODGING TAX ADOPTED FY 2020 BUDGET - $2,950,000 JULY 1 $207,361 $248,422 $291,530 $301,067 $238,068 ($62,999) $235,865 ($65,202) ($2,203) AUGUST 167,929 224,761 266,637 274,331 356,692 82,361 359,491 85,160 2,799 TOTAL $375,290 $473,183 $558,167 $575,398 $594,760 $19,362 $595,356 $19,958 $596 AMUSEMENT TAX ADOPTED FY 2020 BUDGET - $850,000 JULY 1 $72,413 $66,786 $72,761 $75,349 $92,901 $17,552 $90,398 $15,049 ($2,503) AUGUST 50,145 53,857 51,694 53,533 54,599 1,066 56,722 3,189 2,123 TOTAL $122,558 $120,643 $124,455 $128,882 $147,500 $18,618 $147,120 $18,238 ($380) 1 Due to year end accounting activities, a portion of revenues associated with May and June were posted in June and July. 2 "Actual Collected" includes all revenue received per month regardless of whether the payment is current or delinquent. Prepared for Finance Committee 1 Finance Committee – 11:30 a.m. A G E N D A City Council Meeting of October 22, 2019 4:00 P.M. – Work Session City Council Agenda Items #1. Receive a Report on the Downtown Loading Zone Pilot Program #2. Hear a presentation by Davenport & Company, LLC, regarding Finance Plan for Capital Improvement Plan. #3. Hear a presentation by Davenport & Company, LLC, regarding Fund Balance #4. Roll Call 7:30 P.M. City Council Agenda Items COUNCILMEMBER WRIGHT WILL GIVE THE INVOCATION GENERAL POLICY REGARDING PUBLIC PARTICIPATION AT CITY COUNCIL MEETINGS Each speaker shall clearly state his or her name and locality of residence. The City Council agenda is divided into four sections. CONSENT AGENDA: This section includes routine items. All items may be approved by one vote. PUBLIC HEARINGS: This section includes all public hearings as required by law or as Council may direct. Procedure: • Staff will make a presentation. • For zoning petitions, the applicant or his or her representative shall have ten (10) minutes to make a presentation. • Comments will then be solicited from those in favor. • Comments will then be solicited from those in opposition. During the public hearing, there shall be a time limit of three (3) minutes for each individual speaker. If the speaker represents a group, there shall be a time limit of five (5) minutes. A speaker representing a group shall identify that group at the beginning of his or her remarks. A group may have only one spokesperson. After public comments have been received, for zoning petitions, the applicant or the representative of the applicant, at his or her discretion, may respond with a rebuttal. There shall be a five (5)-minute time limit for rebuttal. Upon the conclusion of public comments or the applicant’s rebuttal, the public hearing will be closed and the matter referred to Council for deliberation. PUBLIC COMMENT: Public comment shall be for the purpose of allowing members of the public to present any matter, which, in their opinion, deserves the attention of the Council. They shall not serve as a forum for debate with the Council. Individuals may speak up to three (3) minutes; or group spokesperson up to five (5) minutes. Once Council has heard a presentation from a citizen or organization on a particular subject, the citizen or organization may not make another presentation on the same subject within three (3) months of the first presentation, except by a majority vote of the members of Council present and voting. GENERAL BUSINESS: This section includes items of a general nature to be considered by Council. City Council may make exceptions to these rules at its discretion. Prior to a meeting, any questions which citizens may have regarding any item on the agenda may be addressed to City Council or the City Administration. The following numbers are provided for the convenience of the citizens: CITY COUNCIL 455-3995 MAYOR 455-3995 CITY MANAGER 455-3990 A reasonable charge may be made for copying and other activities related to responding to long and involved inquiries. CITIZENS OFTEN EXPRESS CONFLICTING AND DIVERSE POSITIONS REGARDING SPECIFIC ISSUES UNDER CONSIDERATION. TO ENCOURAGE CITIZEN PARTICIPATION AND TO AVOID INTIMIDATION TO PERSONS WHO MAY EXPRESS SOMETIMES UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, APPLAUSE, CHEERS, OR JEERS FROM THE AUDIENCE ARE NOT PERMITTED. WHEN APPEARING BEFORE CITY COUNCIL, CITIZENS MAY NOT ENGAGE IN BEHAVIOR THAT INTIMIDATES OR INSULTS OTHERS, ENGAGE IN DISRUPTIVE BEHAVIOR, USE PROFANITY OR VULGAR LANGUAGE, PROMOTE PRIVATE BUSINESS VENTURES OR CAMPAIGN FOR PUBLIC OFFICE. * PREVIOUSLY DISCUSSED AND/OR CONSIDERED BY CITY COUNCIL 2 R E C O G N I T I O N S  Recognize The Water Dog for receiving The Ordinary Award in the category of Restaurant of the Year from the Virginia Restaurant, Lodging & Travel Association  Recognize the Exchange Club and Present a Proclamation for the 60th Annual Pancake Jamboree  Recognize the Office of Economic Development & Tourism for the Excellence in Economic Development Gold Award from the International Economic Development Council for the 2018 “Year in Review” Annual Report ____________________________________________________________________________________ C O N S E N T A G E N D A #5. Consideration of approving the minutes of the October 8, 2019 Council meeting #6.* Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-19-070 for the purpose of amending the Fiscal Year 2020 Budget to reflect the carry forward of appropriations for ongoing activities not expended in FY 2019, and appropriating supplemental funds and rescinding appropriations for both the Capital and Operating Budgets for the twelve month period beginning July 1, 2019 and ending June 30, 2020 #7.* Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-19-080 to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $49,210 with resources from the Commonwealth of Virginia, Department of Criminal Justice Services to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department. ____________________________________________________________________________________ P U B L I C H E A R I N G S #8. Public hearing to receive comments on the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) and the Federal Highway Administration (FHWA) Environmental Assessment (EA) for the US 501 (Lynchburg Expressway) and US 221 (Lakeside Drive) Intersection Improvements Project. (File: Engineering) G E N E R A L B U S I N E S S #9. Consideration of approving a resolution for a name change from the Central Virginia Metropolitan Planning Organization (CVMPO) to the Central Virginia Transportation Planning Organization (CVTPO). (File: CVMPO) #R-19-083 #10. Consideration of introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund Budget and appropriate $65,000 for the Lynchburg Adult Drug Treatment Court award with resources from the Supreme Court of Virginia Drug Treatment Court Docket Grant. This grant is administered by the Supreme Court of Virginia. (File: Budget) #R-19-084 #11. Consideration of introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2020 General Fund budget and appropriate $9,429 with resources from the State Compensation Board, Technology Trust Fund fees to support information technology needs in the Office of the Circuit Court. (File: Budget) #R-19-085 #12. Consideration of introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $34,930 with resources from the 2019 Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department, Lynchburg Sheriff’s Office and the Office of the Commonwealth’s Attorney. (File: Budget) #R-19-086 3 #13. Consideration of introducing a resolution to amend the FY2020 City/Federal State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $24,517 with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) Grant through the Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department. (File: Budget) #R-19-087 #14. Consideration of adopting a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $42,612 with resources of $21,306 from the Bulletproof Vest Partnership 2019 Grant Program and $21,306 transferred from the FY 2020 General Fund Police Department ($18,506) and Sheriff’s Office ($2,800) budgets to purchase replacement bulletproof vests for law enforcement officers. (File: Budget) #R-19-088 #15. Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $91,750 with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund equipment and training for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. (File: Budget) #R-19-089 #16. Adopt a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriate $76,000 with resources from the 2019 State Homeland Security Program (SHSP) grant from U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to fund water rescue equipment and training for the Fire Department Technical Rescue Team. (File: Budget) #R-19-090 #17. Consideration of adopting the Final 2020 Legislative Agenda (File: City Council) #R-19-082 #18. Consideration of a closed meeting to discuss appointments to the Parking Authority and Transit Board of Directors LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 1 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: X INFORMATION: (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Downtown Loading Zone Pilot Program Report and Recommendation to Make the Loading Zone Management Program Permanent KEY ELEMENTS: __Economic Development _X_Excellent Government _X_Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community _ _Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Receive this presentation as a follow-up to previous discussions, City Council action, and a pilot program addressing Loading Zones in the Central Business District. City staff recommends that the adopted ordinance language approved during the May 14, 2019 City Council meeting for loading zone management in the Central Business District remain in effect. SUMMARY: On May 14, 2019, City Council adopted ordinance amendments in City Code Sections 25-1, 25- 249, 25-250, 25-265, and 25-270 relating to Central Business District parking. These amendments updated the manner of use of loading zones, made it illegal for vehicles to park in the traffic lane on one-way streets, and increased the fine amounts for violations related to these matters. At the request of City Council, between June 3, 2019 and September 16, 2019, City staff initiated a downtown loading zone pilot program to study the effects of the newly designated and timed loading zones on vehicular traffic. The project study area included the 800, 900, 1000, 1100, and 1200 blocks of Main Street, 100 block of 13th Street, and the 900 block of Commerce Street. Upon completion of the pilot program, City staff noted several positive changes in the manner and use of loading zones. Delivery companies and businesses were communicative with City staff throughout the pilot program and adjustments were made to ensure challenges were addressed successfully. The result was that deliveries were still capable of being made to the businesses even with alterations to parking spaces and designated loading zones. Furthermore, by changing loading zone signage and increasing the size of the loading zones, drivers are able to better identify loading zone parking and those with large delivery vehicles are able to access loading zone parking easier. As a result, delivery vehicles are not causing a traffic hazard when parking in a lane of traffic for deliveries, allowing for safer vehicular and pedestrian travel to occur without obstructions in the roadway. City staff is continuing to monitor loading zone activity and noting modifications that may need to be made in other areas of the Central Business District to accommodate delivery vehicles using the lessons learned from this pilot program. PRIOR ACTION(S): November 13, 2018: City Council adopted the Downtown 2040 Master Plan February 26, 2019: Physical Development Committee reviewed recommended revisions March 12, 2019: Physical Development Committee reviewed recommended revisions April 9, 2019: Physical Development Committee recommended approved of ordinance amendments April 23, 2019: City Council received recommendations May 14, 2019: City Council approved ordinance amendments related to the manner and use of designated loading zones in the Central Business District. FISCAL IMPACT: Cost for new loading zone sign production and installation was $1,200. Cost for communication outreach was $245. CONTACT(S): Gaynelle Hart, Director of Public Works, 455-4406 David Malewitz, Parking Manager, 455-4240 ATTACHMENT(S): • October 22, 2019 Downtown Loading Zone Pilot Program Report Presentation Slides • May 14, 2019 Loading Zone Ordinance Amendments for the Central Business District Agenda Summary and Enacted Resolution • Loading Zone Communication Flyer & Pilot Program Area Map REVIEWED BY: raw 136R Downtown Loading Zone Pilot Program Update City Council Work Session October 22, 2019 Purpose and Outline • Purpose: Provide City Council with an update on the results of the Downtown Loading Zone Pilot Program • Outline: – Brief overview of the program and definition of success – Overview of Success and Challenges – Review of public outreach efforts – Overall assessment of pilot program – Recommendations and Next Steps 2 Loading Zone Pilot Area 3 Definition of Success • Ensure the effective designation, use and enforcement of loading zones for deliveries to occur outside of travel lanes. • Create safer and more effective traffic flow. • Improve public safety. • Respond to concerns from businesses and delivery companies. 4 Successes • Deliveries still occurred and businesses received product. • Created parking spaces for large delivery trucks. • Delivery trucks used loading zones appropriately and made deliveries efficiently. • Delivery trucks parking in traffic lanes dramatically reduced. 5 Successes • Flyers helped educate drivers on loading zones. • Businesses and delivery companies were communicative on issues as they arose. • Very few issues outside of the 900 block of Main Street. • Deliveries occurred during downtown Midtown Parking Deck construction project. • Clear line of sight in traffic lanes due to no semi-trucks obstructing view. 6 Public Outreach Initial Flyer Before Start of Pilot 7 Public Outreach Flyers Distributed During Pilot 8 Public Outreach Citation Notices 9 Public Outreach Business Involvement: Communication to Customers 10 Adjustments During Pilot 1000 Block Main Street • Expanded the all day 30 minute loading zone. – Requested by business and delivery companies. • Primarily large truck deliveries to businesses • (-2) 1 hour parking spaces 11 Adjustments During Pilot 1200 Block Main Street • Relocated Loading Zone – Mid-block to corner of Main & 13th Streets • Businesses requested • Old zone difficult for large truck access • (+1) 1 hour parking space – Sign Change • OLD: 30 Minutes 7AM – 11AM then 1 hour after 11am • NEW: All Day 30 minutes 8 AM – 5 PM 12 Adjustments During Pilot 13th Street • Removed Loading Zone – No delivery vehicle utilization – Reinstalled 2 hour parking (+3) 2 hour parking spaces 13 Examples of Success 14 Examples of Success 15 Challenges • Some delivery trucks still parked in lane of traffic if loading zone unavailable. • 7 AM – 11 AM signs confusing to the public. – Signs have a lot of text, leading public to not read all of the signs thoroughly. • Majority of delivery trucks arrived after 10 AM. • 900 block required the most attention to prevent illegal parking in the loading zone. 16 Examples of Challenges 17 Examples of Challenges 18 Survey Results • Approximately 40 surveys emailed to Main Street businesses, delivery companies • Two surveys were conducted – one midway through the pilot and one at the end • Only 9 respondents for the 1st/8 respondents for the second • Overall 50/50 pro and con 19 Overall Assessment • Program is working. • Deliveries occurring in designated loading zones. • Traffic and pedestrian travel is safer. • All Day loading zones work better than morning 7 AM – 11 AM. – Signs easier for public to read quickly. • Businesses and delivery companies aware of loading zone issues. 20 Overall Assessment • City staff responded to issues and made necessary adjustments. • Delivery drivers appreciated new, larger loading zones. • Enforcement helped educate public on the rules and use of loading zones. 21 Recommendation City staff recommends that the ordinance amendments instituted for the loading zone pilot program remain as written in order to continue to maintain a safer and more efficient flow of vehicular traffic. 22 Next Steps • City staff will continue to work with businesses owners and delivery companies outside of the pilot area to create effective loading zones throughout downtown. • Prepare a communication plan regarding the use of loading zones for businesses and the public. • Install consistent loading zone signage for easy identification. 23 Closing Questions? 24 Where a loading and unloading zone has been set apart by the city manager or his designee in accordance with applicable provisions of this chapter, the following regulations shall apply with respect to the use of such areas so as not to unduly interfere with the use of public streets: (a) No person shall stop, stand or park a vehicle for any purpose or length of time, other than for the expeditious unloading and delivery or pickup and loading of materials, in any place marked as a curb loading zone during hours when the provisions applicable to such zones are in effect.more than thirty (30) minutes for the purposes of actively unloading and loading of materials or passengers in any place marked as a loading zone during when the provisions applicable to such zones are in effect as stated on appropriate signage. (b) The driver of a passenger vehicle may stop temporarily in a space marked as a curb loading zone for the purpose of, and -.1,hile actually engaged in, loading or unloading passengers or bundles. If a person requires parking accommodations for the purposes of unloading and delivery or pickup and loading materials that will exceed the thirty {30} minute time length, then such person shall obtain a Temporary Parking Permit for the Central Business District as described in Section 25-270 of the City Code. Sec. 25-270. - Construction parking permitsTemporary Parking Permits in the Central Business District. Construction parking permits are issued by the inspections division of the community development department. Permits will be issued to vehicle owners i.1.iho are actively engaged in the construction project (plumbing/electrical contractors, etc.). Construction parking permits shall only be issued for vehicles that are used to transport equipment, tools and supplies used by the owner at the work site. Temporary parking permits are issued by the City Manager's designee for the use of on-street or off-street parking spaces for persons who are engaged in activities that require short-term parking accommodations within a reasonable proximity to a worksite, business, event or residence for special need occasions. 2. That this ordinance shall become effective upon its adoJjion. Adopted: Certifie�----" -� -- --\ ----­ ClerkofCoundl May 14, 2019 BACKGROUND Lynchburg City Council instructed staff to conduct a pilot period regarding loading zones in the Central Business District (CBD) and to make recommendations that would help ensure the effective designation, use and enforcement of timed and permanent loading zones for the deliveries outside of travel lanes. The purpose of the changes to the loading zone management practices in the CBD is to ensure a safer and more efficient flow of vehicular traffic. The pilot will assist staff in determining the best locations and time limits for the loading zones and to address any concerns that businesses may have regarding them. ORDINANCE CHANGES  Fine for a loading zone violation will increase from $30 to $50. The purpose of the increase is to encourage drivers to respect the time limits and to use the area for loading or unloading only.  Fine for parking illegally in the travel lane of traffic will result in a $100 fine. The purpose of the fine is to dissuade drivers from parking in the travel lane and to promote a safe environment for vehicular travel. DOWNTOWN LOADING ZONE PILOT BEGINS JUNE 3, 2019  When it is necessary to provide parking accommodations for longer deliveries or to facilitate special requests for all day parking related to construction, moving or other special needs from businesses, a right-of-way permit may be obtained through the Public Works Engineering Division or a temporary parking permit may be issued by the Parking Management Office. Fees may apply.  Delivery companies using the all day Commerce Street loading zone may make deliveries using the E-level Midtown Deck Elevator. IMPLEMENTATION  Information regarding the changes to loading zones is being sent to all downtown stakeholders, companies that deliver goods and services to the CBD, the general public, etc.  A survey will be sent to CBD businesses and delivery companies in July 2019 and again in September 2019 to gather feedback regarding the loading zone changes.  A final report regarding the loading zone ordinance changes will be made to City Council at its September 2019 meeting.  Enforcement of the new ordinances will begin on June 3rd. INFORMATION Citizens First - (434) 856-CITY (2489) Parking Management - (434) 455-4045 Public Works Department - (434) 455-3950 Media Inquiries - Communications and Marketing Department (434) 455-3800 www.lynchburgva.gov/ loadingzones see map on reverse side COURT ST 10TH ST 13TH ST JEFFERSON ST 11TH ST 11TH ST 13TH ST JEFFERSON ST COURT ST COMMERCE ST 9TH ST 9TH ST 12TH ST 12TH ST CHURCH ST MAIN ST 1208 901 5E 918 1017 901 109 12171225 1209 320 314 1215 10101020 10001004 206 210 1107 1111 1124 1101 110311071113300 1200 11201124 1021 1125 216 309 1219 1100 325 1215 1222 109 1300 1315 1300 1306 1310 12001220 1213 820 1011 1001 900 921 1 915 911 927 925 919 310 313 863 1000 901 1110 1010 1023 1008 1101 10241030 1016 1000 1001 1100 1016 1019 10091011 1001 1201 916920 102211001104 1023 1130 1310 1306 1315 1301 13121316 1310 1308 1307 12101216 1026 1117 306 1201 120112051211 212 1225 1220 1110 107 212 1115 1112 11001104 1103 1025 1022 211A 910 1000 921 926 1009 901907 923 828910 900904 846 825 821 918 900 1020 901 922 58 821 27 56 1016 1031 1008 1105 1100 1117 1109 924 900 108 50 57 210 64 208 99 829 205 209 110 203 901 S1901 107 901 214901 4I 901 3C 901 1217 211 61 51 914 921 2 921 3 1114 1151 1001 139 1215 1 1019 309 1214 50 1200 300 310 51 1 51 7 51 12 51 18 51 23 1007 1300 109 LOADING ZONE CHANGES TO DOWNTOWN LYNCHBURG 30 min loading zone 7AM - 11AM 30 min loading zone 8AM - 5PM DISCLAIMER: THIS MAP IS NEITHER A LEGALLY RECORDED MAP NOR A SURVEY AND IS NOT INTENDED TO BE USED AS SUCH. THE INFORMATION DISPLAYED IS A COMPILATION OF RECORDS, INFORMATION, AND DATA OBTAINED FROM VARIOUS SOURCES. THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ITS ACCURACY OR HOW CURRENT IT MAY BE. LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 2 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Finance Plan for Capital Improvement Plan KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Hear a presentation by Davenport & Company, LLC representatives. SUMMARY: Davenport & Company LLC (Davenport), as the City’s Financial Advisor, has been monitoring the credit markets for interest rate trends and has been working with City staff to develop a recommended Plan of Finance for the City’s ongoing capital improvement program needs. PRIOR ACTION(S): May 14, 2019 Adoption of the FY 2020 – 2024 Capital Improvement Program FISCAL IMPACT: Potential Interest Savings (to be determined) CONTACT(S): Donna S. Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): Finance Plan for Capital Improvement Program Plan PowerPoint REVIEWED BY: bms 137R Member NYSE|FINRA|SIPC October 22, 2019 City of Lynchburg, Virginia Capital Needs Plan of Finance  Davenport & Company LLC (“Davenport”), in our capacity as Financial Advisor to the City of Lynchburg (the “City”), has been monitoring the credit markets for interest rate trends and has been working with City staff to develop a recommended Plan of Finance for the City’s ongoing capital needs.  The City’s Capital Improvement Plan contemplates approximately $125.8 Million of General Fund and School related bond financing from Fiscal Years 2020-2025. Additionally, the City is considering funding the $26 Million Lakeside Drive Bridge at College Lake project in Fiscal Year 2020. The timing/rationale and recommended approach for obtaining this financing is described in detail in this presentation.  Working with City staff, Davenport and the City instituted a “Just-In-Time” funding approach for its capital needs. This contemplates a 2-Year renewing Line of Credit. The rationale for this approach is as follows: 1. Allows the City to borrow for funds exactly when they are needed which minimizes interest costs; 2. Reduces the pressure on Key Debt Ratios (i.e. Debt Service vs. Expenditures and Debt vs. Full Value); and, 3. Less budgetary (i.e. cash flow) pressure on the General Fund. October 22, 2019 Background 1Capital Needs Plan of Finance October 22, 2019 Capital Needs Plan of Finance 2 Interest Rate Trends 20 year AAA interest rates as compiled by Municipal Market Data (MMD) are shown in the charts above. Long term interest rates are near historic lows. Source: Thomson Reuters MMD Publication. 1.50% 1.70% 1.90% 2.10% 2.30% 2.50% 2.70% 2.90% 3.10% 3.30% 3.50% Nov-16 Dec-16 Jan-17 Feb-17 Mar-17 Apr-17 May-17 Jun-17 Jul-17 Aug-17 Sep-17 Oct-17 Nov-17 Dec-17 Jan-18 Feb-18 Mar-18 Apr-18 May-18 Jun-18 Jul-18 Aug-18 Sep-18 Oct-18 Nov-18 Dec-18 Jan-19 Feb-19 Mar-19 Apr-19 May-19 Jun-19 Jul-19 Aug-19 Sep-19 Oct-19 20 Year AAA MMD (Since November 2016) 1.50% 2.00% 2.50% 3.00% 3.50% 4.00% 4.50% 5.00% 5.50% 6.00% 6.50% 20 Year AAA MMD (Since 2000)  In June 2018, the City entered into a roughly 2 Year Line of Credit with Bank of America. This initial Line of Credit will expire in June 2020. Given the success of this funding strategy, Davenport recommends that the City plan to enter into a new Line of Credit in Spring 2020 for future General Fund and School capital needs in anticipation of July 2020 (i.e. the 2021 Fiscal Year). – Note: Current draws on the 2018 Line of Credit total approximately $2 Million.  In addition to its General Fund and School capital needs, the City is also seeking/recommending it secure financing for the Lakeside Drive Bridge at College Lake project at this time. This is anticipated to cost approximately $26 million.  The rationale for the above is as follows: Interest rates are at/near historic lows. Taking into account the relative certainty of the costs as well as the current interest rate environment, Davenport recommends that the City permanently finance the Lakeside Drive Bridge at College Lake project immediately concurrently with a take out of its Line of Credit and certain other identified 2020 capital needs. – Note: Initially, Davenport had estimated a 4.50% interest rate for the City’s New Money borrowings. Based upon current market conditions, the City could expect results closer to 2.50%. October 22, 2019 Proposed Plan of Finance/Rationale 3Capital Needs Plan of Finance  In summary, Davenport recommends that the City’s Plan of Finance consider a 2019 Borrowing to include amounts for the following purposes totaling approximately $44 Million: 1. $18 Million to permanently finance the current balance on the 2018 Line of Credit and fund the remaining amount of Fiscal Year 2020 General Fund/Schools CIP Projects; and, 2. $26 Million to permanently finance the Lakeside Drive Bridge at College Lake project.  Detailed cost estimates for the projects financed as part of both the 2019 Financing as well as the future Lines of Credit are provided in the table on the following page.  In this presentation, Davenport will outline the impact of both the 2019 Financing as well as the City’s other expected financings over the next five years on the City’s Key Debt Ratios and cash flows. October 22, 2019 Summary of 2019 Financing 4Capital Needs Plan of Finance Fiscal Year 2020 Fiscal Year 2021 Fiscal Year 2022 Fiscal Year 2023 Fiscal Year 2024 Fiscal Year 2025+(2) General & Schools CIP Projects (3) $18,000,000(1) $18,177,826 $19,829,130 $19,481,087 $30,108,478 $20,250,000 Lakeside Drive Bridge $26,000,000 (10,000,000) (13,000,000) (3,000,000) $0 $0 Total $44,000,000 $8,177,826 $6,829,130 $16,481,087 $30,108,478 $20,250,000 Line of Credit Financing $8,177,826 $6,829,130 $16,481,087 $30,108,478 $20,250,000 Perm. Financing $44,000,000 $31,488,043 Permanent Financing to Occur in Fiscal Year 2026 October 22, 2019 Capital Needs Plan of Finance 5 Timing of Financings Note: (1) Includes $15.6 million of 2020 CIP Projects plus $2.4 million currently drawn under the 2018 Line of Credit. (2) For purposes of this analysis, Davenport assumed that the remaining $20 million would be drawn in Fiscal Year 2025. (3) Does not include Water & Sewer related financing needs. The City may require an additional permanent financing for utility draws on the 2018 Line of Credit. October 22, 2019 Capital Needs Plan of Finance 6 Summary of Key Assumptions Lakeside Drive Bridge at College Lake and 2018 Line of Credit Take Out 2021 Line of Credit Take Out (2023 Permanent Financing) 2024 Line of Credit Take Out (2026 Permanent Financing) Borrowing Amount $44,000,000 $31,488,043 $50,358,478 Term 22 Years 20 Years 20 Years Planning Rate Used 2.50% 4.50% 4.50% Interest Only 4 Years 4 Years 1 Year Structured Principal Years 5-7 N/A Years 2-3 Level Debt Service Remaining 15 Years Remaining 16 Years Remaining 17 Years  Davenport’s analysis presented herein incorporates the following Key Assumptions: October 22, 2019 Capital Needs Plan of Finance 7 Recommended Approach (Year by Year Debt Service) FY Principal Interest Total Debt Service Principal Interest Total Debt Service Principal Interest Total Debt Service 2020 $10,928,056 $6,884,518 $17,812,574 $0 $0 $0 $10,928,056 $6,884,518 $17,812,574 2021 11,219,004 6,462,824 17,681,828 0 1,306,754 1,306,754 11,219,004 7,769,578 18,988,582 2022 11,285,959 6,011,146 17,297,105 0 1,401,685 1,401,685 11,285,959 7,412,831 18,698,789 2023 12,083,807 5,524,068 17,607,875 0 1,693,062 1,693,062 12,083,807 7,217,130 19,300,937 2024 11,104,577 5,011,034 16,115,611 0 3,043,356 3,043,356 11,104,577 8,054,390 19,158,967 2025 10,851,552 4,521,333 15,372,885 370,000 3,548,587 3,918,587 11,221,552 8,069,920 19,291,472 2026 10,982,590 4,032,013 15,014,603 380,000 3,792,337 4,172,337 11,362,590 7,824,350 19,186,940 2027 9,191,359 3,546,596 12,737,955 1,570,000 4,988,669 6,558,669 10,761,359 8,535,265 19,296,623 2028 7,663,547 3,190,006 10,853,553 4,295,000 4,705,113 9,000,113 11,958,547 7,895,118 19,853,666 2029 7,618,007 2,891,978 10,509,985 4,800,000 4,547,975 9,347,975 12,418,007 7,439,953 19,857,960 2030 6,865,937 2,612,027 9,477,964 5,965,000 4,354,463 10,319,463 12,830,937 6,966,489 19,797,426 2031 5,848,842 2,345,591 8,194,433 6,195,000 4,130,813 10,325,813 12,043,842 6,476,404 18,520,246 2032 5,869,985 2,100,165 7,970,150 6,420,000 3,898,175 10,318,175 12,289,985 5,998,340 18,288,325 2033 5,685,255 1,865,313 7,550,568 6,670,000 3,656,150 10,326,150 12,355,255 5,521,463 17,876,718 2034 5,565,948 1,638,453 7,204,401 6,915,000 3,404,338 10,319,338 12,480,948 5,042,791 17,523,739 2035 4,734,897 1,418,497 6,153,393 7,180,000 3,142,400 10,322,400 11,914,897 4,560,897 16,475,793 2036 4,753,060 1,228,909 5,981,969 7,450,000 2,869,825 10,319,825 12,203,060 4,098,734 16,301,794 2037 3,773,615 1,038,763 4,812,378 7,730,000 2,586,275 10,316,275 11,503,615 3,625,038 15,128,653 2038 3,765,149 878,027 4,643,176 8,030,000 2,291,125 10,321,125 11,795,149 3,169,152 14,964,301 2039 3,755,177 717,561 4,472,738 8,340,000 1,983,800 10,323,800 12,095,177 2,701,361 14,796,538 2040 3,747,736 557,350 4,305,086 8,655,000 1,663,963 10,318,963 12,402,736 2,221,313 14,624,049 2041 2,655,000 424,200 3,079,200 8,990,000 1,331,050 10,321,050 11,645,000 1,755,250 13,400,250 2042 2,650,000 318,000 2,968,000 9,340,000 984,375 10,324,375 11,990,000 1,302,375 13,292,375 2043 2,650,000 212,000 2,862,000 6,285,000 666,113 6,951,113 8,935,000 878,113 9,813,113 2044 2,650,000 106,000 2,756,000 3,715,000 441,113 4,156,113 6,365,000 547,113 6,912,113 2045 0 0 0 3,885,000 270,113 4,155,113 3,885,000 270,113 4,155,113 2046 0 0 0 4,060,000 91,350 4,151,350 4,060,000 91,350 4,151,350 Total $167,899,059 $65,536,371 $233,435,430 $127,240,000 $66,792,975 $194,032,975 $295,139,059 $132,329,346 $427,468,405 Existing Tax Supported Debt Aggregate New Money Borrowings (2019 - 2026) Total Existing and Potential Debt Year Existing Debt Service Projected New Money Debt Service Total Estimated Debt Service Total Revenues Available* Additional Revenues Needed 2020 $17,812,574 $0 $17,812,574 18,111,342 2021 17,681,828 1,306,754 18,988,582 18,631,342 357,240 2022 17,297,105 1,401,685 18,698,789 18,988,582 2023 17,607,875 1,693,062 19,300,937 18,988,582 312,355 2024 16,115,611 3,043,356 19,158,967 19,300,937 2025 15,372,885 3,918,587 19,291,472 19,300,937 2026 15,014,603 4,172,337 19,186,940 19,300,937 2027 12,737,955 6,558,669 19,296,623 19,300,937 2028 10,853,553 9,000,113 19,853,666 19,300,937 552,729 2029 10,509,985 9,347,975 19,857,960 19,853,666 4,294 2030 9,477,964 10,319,463 19,797,426 19,857,960 2031 8,194,433 10,325,813 18,520,246 19,857,960 2032 7,970,150 10,318,175 18,288,325 19,857,960 2033 7,550,568 10,326,150 17,876,718 19,857,960 2034 7,204,401 10,319,338 17,523,739 19,857,960 2035 6,153,393 10,322,400 16,475,793 19,857,960 2036 5,981,969 10,319,825 16,301,794 19,857,960 2037 4,812,378 10,316,275 15,128,653 19,857,960 2038 4,643,176 10,321,125 14,964,301 19,857,960 2039 4,472,738 10,323,800 14,796,538 19,857,960 2040 4,305,086 10,318,963 14,624,049 19,857,960 2041 3,079,200 10,321,050 13,400,250 19,857,960 2042 2,968,000 10,324,375 13,292,375 19,857,960 2043 2,862,000 6,951,113 9,813,113 19,857,960 2044 2,756,000 4,156,113 6,912,113 19,857,960 2045 0 4,155,113 4,155,113 19,857,960 2046 0 4,151,350 4,151,350 19,857,960 Total $233,435,430 $194,032,975 $427,468,405 $0 $5 $10 $15 $20 $25 Million s Existing & Projected Tax-Supported Debt Service Existing Debt Service Projected New Money Debt Service Total Revenues Available* October 22, 2019 Capital Needs Plan of Finance 8 Estimated Case Cash Flow Impact *Initial Total Revenues available is estimated based on 2020 Budget. Incorporates Interest earnings from the Lakeside Drive Bridge at College Lake Borrowing. Under the old strategy of pursuing upfront permanent financing for all projects, the City would need to come up with several additional millions of dollars for its debt service budget. Under the Line of Credit approach, the City is estimated to need approximately $1.2 million. October 22, 2019 Capital Needs Plan of Finance 9 Effect on Debt as a Percentage of Assessed Value The City’s Debt Service to Assessed Valuation is currently projected to remain well below the City’s policy of 4.50%. Note: Assessed Values are assumed to grow 2.0% annually beginning in Fiscal Year 2020. *Note: Projected Debt includes all future borrowings contemplated in the Plan of Finance including the future Lines of Credit and associated take outs. 0.00% 0.50% 1.00% 1.50% 2.00% 2.50% 3.00% 3.50% 4.00% 4.50% 5.00% 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 Existing Debt Projected Debt* City Policy October 22, 2019 Capital Needs Plan of Finance 10 Effect on Debt Service as a Percentage of Expenditures The City’s Debt Service to Expenditures Ratio is projected to be below the City’s Policy of 10%. Note: Expenditures are assumed to grow 2.0% annually beginning in Fiscal Year 2020. *Note: Projected Debt includes all future borrowings contemplated in the Plan of Finance including the future Lines of Credit and associated take outs. 0.00% 2.00% 4.00% 6.00% 8.00% 10.00% 12.00% 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027 2028 2029 Existing Debt Projected Debt* City Policy October 22, 2019 Capital Needs Plan of Finance 11 Timetable Date Action October 22, 2019 City Council Meeting: Davenport presents Plan of Finance to City Council and recommended funding approach. Balance of October – November  Develop financing documents and Credit Package.  Schedule interaction with Fitch, Moody’s and Standard & Poor’s. December 10 City Council Meeting: Public Hearing held on the 2019 Bonds and City Council Considers adopting Bond Resolution. Week of December 16(1) City interacts with Credit Rating Agencies in anticipation of Bond Sale. On or about January 8 Post Preliminary Official Statement. On or about January 15 Sale/Pricing of Series 2019 Bonds. On or about January 29 Close on Series 2019 Bonds. (1) Subject to change/confirmation with all parties. Richmond — Headquarters One James Center 901 East Cary Street, Suite 1100, Richmond, Virginia 23219 Telephone: (804) 780-2000 Toll-Free: (800) 846-6666 E-Mail: info@investdavenport.com October 22, 2019 Courtney E. Rogers Senior Vice President (804) 697-2902 crogers@investdavenport.com David Rose Manager of Public Finance Senior Vice President (804) 697-2905 drose@investdavenport.com Alex Hock Associate Vice President (804) 915-2748 ahock@investdavenport.com Capital Needs Plan of Finance 12 Doug Gebhardt Vice President 804-698-2651 dgebhardt@investdavenport.com October 22, 2019 Capital Needs Plan of Finance 13 Disclaimer The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) has clarified that a broker, dealer or municipal securities dealer engaging in municipal adv isory activities outside the scope of underwriting a particular issuance of municipal securities should be subject to municipal advisor registration. Davenport & Company LLC (“Davenport”) has registered as a municipal advisor with the SEC. As a registered municipal advisor Davenpor t may provide advice to a municipal entity or obligated person. An obligate d person is an entity other than a municipal entity, such as a not for profit corporation, that has comme nced an application or negotiation with an entity to issue municipal secur ities on its behalf and for which it will provide support. If and when an issuer engages Davenport to provide financial advisory or consultant services with respect to the issuan ce of municipal securities, Davenport is obligated to evidence such a financial advisory relationship with a written agreement. When acting as a registered municipal advisor Davenport is a fiduciary requ ired by federal law to act in the best interest of a municipal entity without regard to its own financial or other interests. Davenport is not a fiduciary when it acts as a registered in vestment advisor, when advising an obligated person, or when acting as an u nderwriter, though it is required to deal fairly with such persons, This material was prepared by public finance, or other non-research person nel of Davenport. This material was not produced by a research analyst, alt hough it may refer to a Davenport research analyst or research report. Unl ess otherwise indicated, these views (if any) are the author’s and may differ from those of the Dave nport fixed income or research department or others in the firm. Davenport may perform or seek to perform financial advisory services for the issuers of the securities and instruments mentioned herein. This material has been prepared for information purposes only and is not a so licitation of any offer to buy or sell any security/instrument or to partic ipate in any trading strategy. Any such offer would be made only after a prospective participant had comple ted its own independent investigation of the securities, instruments or t ransactions and received all information it required to make its own investment decision, including, wh ere applicable, a review of any offering circular or memorandum describin g such security or instrument. That information would contain material information not contained herein and to which prospective participants are referred. This material is base d on public information as of the specified date, and may be stale thereafter. We have no obligation to tell yo u when information herein may change. We make no representation or warrant yw i t hr e s p e c tt ot h e completeness of this material. Davenport has no obligation to continue to p ublish information on the securities/instruments mentioned herein. Rec ipients are required to comply with any legal or contractual restrictions on their purchase, holding, sale, exercise of rights or performance of obligations under any securities/instruments transaction. The securities/instruments discussed in this material may not be suitable f or all investors or issuers. Recipients should seek independent financi al advice prior to making any investment decision based on this material. This material does not provide individually tailored investment ad vice or offer tax, regulatory, accou nting or legal advice. Prior to entering into any proposed transaction, recipients should determine, in c onsultation with their own investmen t, legal, tax, regulatory and accoun ting advisors, the economic risks and merits, as well as the legal, tax, regulatory and accounting characteristics and consequences, o f the transaction. You should consider this mate rial as only a single factor in making an investment decision. The value of and income from investments and the cost of borrowing may vary bec ause of changes in interest rates, for eign exchange rates, default rates , prepayment rates, securities/instruments prices, market indexes, operational or financia l conditions or companies or other factors. There may be time limitations o n the exercise of options or other rights in securities/instruments transactions. Past performance is not n ecessarily a guide to future performance and estimates of future performa nce are based on assumptions that may not be realized. Actual events may differ from those assumed and changes to any assumptions may have a material impact on any projections or estimates. Other events not taken into account may occur and may significantly affect the projections or estimates. Certain assumptions may have been made for modeling purpo ses or to simplify the presentation and/or calculation of any projections or estimates, and Dave nport does not represent that any such assumptions will reflect actual fut ure events. Accordingly, there can be no assurance that estimated returns or projections will be realized o r that actual returns or performance results will not materially differ fr om those estimated herein. This material may not be sold or redistributed without the prior written consent of Davenport. Version 01/13/2014 AH/DJG/CR/DR LYNCHBURG CITY COUNCIL Agenda Item Summary MEETING DATE: October 22, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 3 CONSENT: REGULAR: WORK SESSION: X CLOSED SESSION: ACTION: INFORMATION: X (Confidential) ITEM TITLE: Fund Balance Policy Presentation KEY ELEMENTS: ___Economic Development _X_Excellent Government ___Natural and Built Environment ___Safe Community ___Vibrant Community RECOMMENDATION: Hear a presentation by Davenport & Company, LLC representatives regarding the City’s Fund Balance Policy and consider changes at a later date. SUMMARY: During the FY 2020 budget discussions, City Council requested information regarding the City’s Fund Balance Policy. Davenport & Company LLC (Davenport), as the City’s Financial Advisor, works with the rating agency analysts to make recommendations concerning the City’s Financial Policies. PRIOR ACTION(S): March 27, 2018 Reaffirmed Fund Balance Policy FISCAL IMPACT: Potential increase in Unassigned Fund Balance CONTACT(S): Donna S. Witt, Chief Financial Officer, 455-3968 ATTACHMENT(S): Fund Balance Policy Presentation REVIEWED BY: bms 138R October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 1 October 8, 2019 City Council Work Session: Members Present: Mayor Treney Tweedy, Vice Mayor Mary Jane Dolan, Councilmember Beau Wright. Councilmember Sterling Wilder, Councilmember Jeff Helgeson, Councilmember Turner Perrow, Councilmember Randy Nelson, Deputy City Manager Reid Wodicka, Assistant City Manager John Hughes, Airport Commissioner Massie Ware, Airport Commissioner Debra Allen, Airport Commissioner Robert Day, Airport Commissioner Bert Dodson, Airport Director Mark Courtney, Airport Commissioner Jones Stanley, and members of the public. The meeting began at 4:00 p.m. Agenda Item #1: Joint Meeting of City Council and the Lynchburg Regional Airport Commission to Discuss the Formation of an Independent Airport Authority Mayor Tweedy explained that the purpose of the joint meeting is to discuss the formation of an independent Airport Authority. Ms. Svrcek noted that the Airport Commission has done a lot of research over the past several months. The airport consultant they hired, Steve Baldwin Associates, is present to make a presentation. Mr. Courtney indicated that Steve specializes in organizational management services for airports and is considered a national expert on airport governance and performance benchmarking. Mr. Baldwin explained that he has been involved with airport management for 38 years. What his firm does best is helping airport boards and their leadership work on policy matters, governance models, performance benchmarking, efficiency and effectiveness. They have been working with airport management and the airport commission for about six months to assess the feasibility and the benefit of moving the airport governance model from a voluntary commission to a fully autonomous Airport Authority. He said that normally they come in and start from scratch with a very educational process but in this case, City and airport staff had already done a lot of excellent work. Mr. Baldwin said this seems somewhat mundane to the average person but it is important because of the enormous economic impact the airport provides to the regional economy. The Lynchburg Airport generates $180 million a year in regional economic impact. It is important that the airport is run to its maximum efficiency and to the benefit of the larger regional area that it serves. It supports 1,700 plus jobs, $61 million in wages and $3.2 million in tax revenue from the airport jobs. The airport has a history of being a subsidy operation, not completely uncommon for an airport of its size. That was broken away from in 2016 and the airport has a trajectory of being profitable from that point. The City has paid about $8 million in subsidy to keep the airport operating but in return has received $180 million in economic impact to the community. The airport has been successful in getting $56 million in capital improvement grant money from the state and federal governments. Mr. Baldwin said there is probably not a better time in the airport’s history to be looking at the governance model. Sometimes it is not feasible to become an airport authority because the airport is running so well with its current model. Mr. Baldwin commented that this has been a conflict that has been in discussion here for almost twenty years. There have been downturns in the service at the airport. The airport is down to American Airlines feeding into Charlotte airport and his firm thinks that is October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 2 a little bit risky and they need to strive hard to get a second carrier. His firm believes an authority model will help them reach that goal. There is also enabling legislation that was created in 2010 that allows communities to opt into an authority governance model relatively easily. Outside of Virginia there have been other airports that have seen merit to move to an authority and they range in size and geography. They found that the model set up in Lynchburg is a legacy model. It is not unusual; there are many airports in the country that still have this model but it is being identified in the industry as a dated model. No airport is moving to this model; every airport is moving away from this model. The airport authority model started by Mr. Courtney is a very valid proposal because it provides the single business focus that the airport needs to keeps its momentum going and to protect its future. It will allow it to make decisions in a business format that will other airlines and other businesses to do business with it. An authority is more streamlined and more businesslike and it is shielded from politics. The consultant believes the airport has land opportunities and opportunities for bringing in maintenance operations. There are opportunities to bring in more fixed-based operators as well. That diversification in air service is really important and can be better handled through an authority model. Setting up an authority properly so that it is wholly self-funded and self-sustaining will help to protect the revenue stream. The airport pays a fair amount of money for City services that it does not really use and that are just a function of the City governance model. It will save the airport approximately $100,000 a year and that money can be invested into air service development to attract another carrier. Mr. Baldwin said the current decision making processes are kind of strung out and back loop into each other. That process needs to be streamlined. The way the system is structured is that a decision has to go to the commission, then to City Council and then back to the commission. Councilmember Helgeson said he thought that could be solved by not requiring a decision to go back to the commission. Mr. Baldwin said they can discuss the alternatives at the end of the presentation. Mr. Baldwin had a slide showing the 18 City departments that are involved in a decision and there is no one in the structure that is the champion of the airport within the City. It is a busy system and there are priorities that are being pulled in every single direction. When you have an airport authority, the singular focus of the authority is the airport. It can make decisions for the airport at its table and try to advance the airport forward. He had a slide showing the present flow of decisions that is a bit convoluted. An authority flow is a bit more streamlined and safeguards can effectively be built in so that the City does not lose control of the airport. The members of the authority will be appointed by City Council or if there is a second sponsor of the authority, a partnership of the sponsor and the City. What Mr. Baldwin and his associates hear from the business community is that is how they want it. There will be a very structured role and mission statement in the governing documents and Council will help define the singular purpose of the airport authority. The airport needs to have partners with the airport management as its board members in order to promote the airport. Mr. Baldwin explained that the authority would not have the burdens of some of the things the airport is paying for such as IT services and pension funding and the authority would have the flexibility to enter October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 3 into inter-municipal agreements and continue those services if it is beneficial for the airport. While the airport has been generating some surpluses, they are fairly narrow surpluses. Mr. Baldwin mentioned that an airport authority can help them build on some of their strengths that not all airports of its size have, such as the business jets and general aviation aircraft on its ramps and a great flight school operation. There had been some discussion about a joint county/city air park in the past and that should be pursued more vigorously. The time is now to diversify the risk the airport has with only having one carrier currently. An authority can also develop rates and charges that are aligned with industry norms. In summary, it is the findings of the consultant firm that overall, transitioning to an airport authority governance model would help serve to increase management efficiency, create a singularly focused business mindset at the airport and form a more nimble operating environment leading to enhanced revenue and business opportunities. Ms. Svrcek said staff is looking for feedback from Council to move forward with an authority or not. Mayor Tweedy opened it up for discussion. Is there a difference between an authority and an authority/commission (referring to other Virginia localities on one of the slides)? (Perrow) The ones labeled authority/commission may have the name of a commission but are enabled under the authority statute and act and perform as an authority. (Baldwin) If we were to proceed with this, we could call it a commission? (Perrow) I could research that and find that answer for you. (Baldwin) If the authority is not paying for the real costs, approximately $200,000, would that be a transfer of funds? (Perrow) It would be a transfer from the airport to the general fund. (Svrcek) It is a fixed cost? (Perrow) It depends on the amount of service that is delivered and based on employee costs and overhead. (Svrcek) The overhead is going to be there regardless of this department. (Helgeson) If it becomes an authority, it can choose to contract with the City or go outside for those services. (Svrcek) If they do not, there is a fixed cost that will need to be picked up by the rest of the departments. (Perrow) That is correct. (Svrcek) Have they found that moving to an authority has come with an increased bargaining power when they are talking with airlines? (Wright) The most recent examples are Syracuse, Grand Rapids and Asheville. Their performance has increased significantly in the past two to three years after creating an authority. They did go to an authority during a time where we have had economic expansion too, out of fairness. (Baldwin) It enables through greater efficiency, nimbleness and streamlining to allow airport management to prioritize their air service development. (Courtney) If revenue decreases and it is operating at a deficit, who is the responsible party? (Wright) It would be the sponsors. (Baldwin) The feeling is that since it has been generating $3.2 billion over 20 years to the region, your sponsors should be more than just the City. (Baldwin) What has the reaction been from the surrounding counties? (Wright) The commission has not reached out to the counties because the process has to go through Council first. There are members from Amherst, Bedford and Campbell October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 4 County on the commission currently but Campbell County is the one that will most likely to be involved as 900 acres of the airport is in the county. (Dodson) If the counties enter into the authority, would they be responsible for any deficit along with the City? (Wilder) If there are additional sponsors, it is my understanding that they would take some share of the deficit based on the governing document. (Svrcek) They put a lot of the surplus into a reserve fund so if there is a short-term deficit, they would be able to fund it probably for several years. (Courtney) When they retired the debt from the new terminal, that is when the surpluses happened. (Dodson) The maintenance is paid for through an operating fund and not from the surplus or reserve fund. (Courtney) There is a fee paid by the consumer that goes toward capital improvements that are paid back to airports in grants. (Baldwin) There are multiple safety valves that can be defined and principals will have to decide what is best for this airport and the consultant firm will help them with their expertise in terms of the financial process. (Baldwin) Would there be additional expenses to the City if it went to an authority? (Wilder) The authority can decide to contract with the City for IT services or they can go outside the City, for example. (Svrcek) The rate the authority would pay for pension funding would be reduced by ten percent. (Courtney) There are 16 to 18 City employees at the airport and they would convert to authority employees. (Svrcek) The property is in Campbell County, but the City owns it. (Svrcek) How would that be handled if it goes to an authority? (Wilder) The industry uses a couple of different methods for that but it would be either a non-revenue lease or a fee simple transfer could be done. (Baldwin) Has anyone reverted back after becoming an authority? (Wilder) Only one example he can think of and it had some extraordinary circumstances. (Baldwin) In most cases, when they switched over, they found it to be beneficial? (Wilder) Yes. (Baldwin) It was a good overview of the distinctions between the two models. In general, he understands that the authority increases efficiencies and business opportunities, would potentially allow increased fees and rates, which could be directed toward airport improvement and the attraction of additional services, reduces the oversight and bureaucratic scrutiny and procedures that lengthen the approval time for any decision, which stifles nimble decision making, which is something commercial airlines would like to see. (Nelson) Most businesses do like to see that. (Baldwin) It would also promote the development possibly of a lucrative air park. (Nelson) I think that should be a priority goal of the authority. (Baldwin) It is also shielded by politics and Mr. Baldwin went over some of the differences in the cost of employees. The primary argument is that the authority is the most popular model used now, other airports do it so Lynchburg should do it because the legacy model is dated? (Nelson) He cannot say it is the most popular model but can say it is being moved toward by more airports than any other model. There are a lot of small airports that are City run but they have no commercial service. (Baldwin) Has American Airlines expressed any specific objection to Lynchburg’s current operating model? (Nelson) No. (Baldwin) That is reassuring. (Nelson) Would having an airport authority prevented Delta from leaving Lynchburg? (Nelson) We also had United Airlines here before 9/11. There was a $4 million subsidy per year from the City to keep the service and Delta said we were part of the Roanoke market and we did not need commercial service. Being or not being an authority had nothing to do with it. (Dodson) Delta merged with Northwest in 2008. They decided to rationalize and consolidate their route maps. (Courtney) October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 5 Is there any specific example of how the City’s current model prevented or impaired the implementation of an FAA or airline request? (Nelson) It pertains more to air service development and priorities. We are not able to prioritize air service development because of the inefficiencies of having to go through a large bureaucracy. We need to be able to operate like and be as nimble as a small business and we are far from a small business. We need to be able to react and compete with the surrounding airports that are airport authorities. You pay a price for having it take so long to be able to get through the process. (Courtney) We have not been presented with that problem before. (Nelson) We have been able to manage that to ensure that but it takes a lot of extra work. (Courtney) Could the City grant and convey the actual operational portion of the airport property and retain the undeveloped land without conveying it to the authority? (Nelson) No. You could put conditions in the document around which decisions are made over on one part of the operation versus another part of the operation. (Baldwin) There is about 100 acres of City-owned property that has been designated by the FAA to be able to be released and has been such for about 20 years. The FAA would require that the airport be compensated at fair market value from the City’s general fund. (Courtney) That is a little bit complicated because we do not want to release the land for your air park. We want to reserve the revenue generated from that land to help grow your air service. (Baldwin) I understand that and that is the area where the lucrative future revenues may be derived but there are other interests in the City that may not want to give away a valuable asset. The report implies that responsible and close public oversight, careful budget analysis, close scrutiny of the permitting process, public transparency with open public discussions to protect citizen’s interests and taxpayer’s pocketbooks are inconsistent with the effective and efficient operation of the airport under the current model. (Nelson) l do not think an authority gets rid of transparency or public accountability. It allows for streamlining and efficiency. It allows City Council to make appointments of business savvy people to a board that can make business decisions and you entrust them to make the right decisions. (Baldwin) The current airport director is savvy, capable and skilled. He has done an admirable job and was selected by Council. We can only select them when a term is up and then they are like an oligarchy and do what they want based on their own personal and professional insights without any checks or balances. (Nelson) An authority has to meet all State statutes. It is restricted by what is permitted of a public body. (Courtney) If you are happy with the current operation, then the current is model is perfect. If your goal is to grow, then the City model is not the best choice. (Day) I do not think there is anyone in this room that does not want the airport to grow but we are at a crossroad. Once we make a decision, I do not think there is any going back. Is there any guarantee that if we have an authority that there will be another commercial carrier? (Nelson) If that were the case, every airport would convert to an authority. (Baldwin) Lynchburg has been very prudent, efficient and frugal and for that last three plus years profitable because of the capable people they have chosen. Hopefully those chosen for the authority would make the same decisions. (Nelson) The continuity of the membership of the board is very important. A Council is cyclical. An airport authority tends to stay in place and they get steeped in the aviation business and its partners, which is why they make good decisions. (Baldwin) There is nothing that says that Council cannot appoint a Councilmember to the authority. (Courtney) That is important because democratic October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 6 republics tend to survive difficult times. Oligarchies do not. It is critically important that Council can pull things in if bad things are happening. (Nelson) There is no guarantee that going to an authority will get the airport another carrier but the report shows you the likelihood of getting one drastically increases. We have the same amount of seats going out of the airport as when Delta was here so we have rebounded. (Dodson) I could be enthusiastic about supporting an authority because Lynchburg historically has always had a regional perspective. An authority would be consistent with our practices, policies and heritage. I want to make sure the details are ironed out and ensure that the taxpayers have accountability when we give away an asset like our airport. (Nelson) The articles of incorporation for an authority are written by you and the authority has to abide by them. (Day) The report swayed him even more to going against an authority because there really is not a compelling reason. We only hearing that it could be better but there is no guarantee. He does not see how it is beneficial simply the name changes. Our taxpayers have paid $8 million funding the airport. You are asking Council to give away the assets and give away the oversight. He would be open to selling the assets to an entity that thinks it can do the job better. He was at the dedication of the new tower that was slated for demolition and with that tower we are very fortunate because the general aviation side is booming. It was because one of our partners has an aviation school and it has been booming. The commission has made some recommendations to Council to which he thinks Council has almost unanimously said no. If we had given up that authority to a different body, he thinks those would have been bad decisions. He thinks it is a false assumption/dichotomy that we either want growth or we stay with this model. He thinks they could tweak what they are doing now and do it better. It is a very tough stretch for him to give up the assets the taxpayers have entrusted to them and the oversight. We went to an authority on solid waste a few years ago and we are going to be talking about it tonight because we are at a standoff. There are unintended consequences and that is what is going to happen. (Helgeson) What are some of the unintended consequences that localities have run into? (Wright) Honestly most people move to this model because they are trying to get out of unintended consequences. They run into roadblocks with regard to a significant capital improvement program, how the airport is run or how to separate it from the political environment. He thinks it is an unfair characterization to say that you would just be giving the airport to somebody else. Council can redact the power of the authority at any time. The airport is a business and is no comparison to a solid waste authority. He cannot say that he has really experienced the downside of this. (Baldwin) Items are brought to the Finance Committee by the airport director and happen quickly. I do not understand how the authority is different if the decision is going to one group of seven versus a different group of seven. (Helgeson) From an airport management standpoint, the airport director and his pretty limited management team have to manage two boards. It is redundant and most businesses that are looking to improve and grow are looking to trim redundancy. (Baldwin) What he reads is mostly theoretical. It would be nice if there some certainties and there were no other problems. He is fearful of October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 7 acquiescing authority by a governing body that is elected to represent the people. He thinks they can streamline the process. (Helgeson) There was a really good airport study done a few years that sits on the shelf. He thinks there is an illusion that the $8 million that the City subsidized can be returned to the City. He asked Mr. Erwin to explain. (Dodson) FAA regulations would not allow future airport revenues to be paid back to the City. All airport revenues have to be used for airport purposes. The City could do what Roanoke did and have a buy in. If any other locality wanted to participate in the authority, it could make a contribution to the City. (Erwin) Council has many responsibilities and issues. The primary and only focus of the authority will be the airport. He was on Council and found out a lot more when he got on the airport commission. We can prosper so much more with an authority than our present setup. (Dodson) What are local businesses saying about this issue? (Tweedy) The president of Freedom Aviation has been attending the meetings and has not expressed an official opinion. He could have expressed opposition if he chose. (Courtney) The Business Alliance strongly supports it. (Feraldi) I spoke with the president of Freedom Aviation and he is very concerned. (Helgeson) Janice Crawford from Framatome is strongly in support of this. (Dolan) The devil is in the details. (Helgeson) I agree and I can point to other authorities that have worked well. We will be responsible for drafting the language. (Tweedy) For some time, I have been in favor of moving to an authority. When it comes to making decisions, Council is not the most informed people to make these decisions. They are complex decisions; we do not understand all the parameters and we tend to take more of a political look at it probably than a pure business approach. We have reversed some of the decisions of the commission and he is not prepared to get into those details but we were just scratching the surface of the information that was there. I think the risk of going to an authority is minor. Council should appoint the members and the statutory authority that we have is key. I think it gives a lot of control to the City but allows the day-to-day and leasing and policy decisions to be handled by the group of people that we have selected. At this table, we have experts in the field focusing on the airport. I do not know anything about airport operations and do not understand that level of detail. I believe in a decentralization of authority as much as possible. If the authority does not implement what Council would like, they could be replaced. He likes the idea of having only one decision making group to do negotiations and thinks it is a key point. When he talks to businesses, the number one concern he hears is the inability to access other airline markets. We used to have more access and now we have nothing but Charlotte. Our businesses need alternatives. We may have the same number of seats leaving the airport as we did in 2007-2008 but we certainly do not have the same number of choices. (Perrow) Councilmember Perrow made a motion to approve Resolution A but would like to change the language that references the statutory authority and not reference the specific statute and have it say “the enabling legislation from the Commonwealth.” Councilmember Nelson said he would second it with a slight change. The third line suggests that in approving this, we are absolutely agreeing to move to an authority. How the articles are drafted is going to determine the type of authority we have and what sort of oversight Council and the taxpayers will have and that is what he would like to see. He would October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 8 suggest “take the necessary steps to compile and present a plan by which it could be formed.” Councilmember Perrow modified his motion and it was seconded by Councilmember Nelson. We are assuming that just because there is a model thrown out that it is actually going to work. He is fearful with what he has seen with our current airport group. He is looking at the growth we have had at the airport. He thinks that making these assumptions that the authority will help with growth is a stretch. He has been on Council for 14 years and the airport has only come to them maybe three or four times in that time. If this resolution passes, he hopes there will be a bonafide plan presented to Council and stakeholders will be appointed to the authority. He hopes they will look out for our FBO who is really trying to do a good job. He hopes it is not an adversarial relationship. He hopes they look at lots of different variables and will be able to see lots of unintended consequences. If the consultant does not know of any unintended consequences, I think there are going to be a lot of them. (Helgeson) The City has done very well and this report is not saying that it has not done so. We need to remember that there has been a return on investment. It has been a regional impact and we have all benefited. That would be the goal of whomever Council or the sponsors appoint and they should be the people they think are most qualified to do what is in the best interest of the community. Mr. Baldwin has talked about how Lynchburg is a commercial non-hub airport. We are doing well but there other similar airports that are not and there is consolidation going. We have being doing well and maybe we can continue that but environments change and how are we most ready. That is why she supports an authority. (Allen) We are working with a mix of airports that are having successes and ones that are not. The trend in the industry with consolidations and mergers is that these airports of your size under a million passengers a year are feeling the pinch because there are such competing services. They are going to airline headquarters and making their pitches. Mr. Courtney has said he needs additional resources to make those pitches. We have to be able to convince the airlines that the best choice for its asset and return on investment is Lynchburg. Ms. Svrcek read the resolution before Mayor Tweedy called for the vote. “BE IT RESOLVED That the Lynchburg City Council hereby approves the Lynchburg Regional Airport Commission’s recommendation to form an independent airport authority as the governing body of Lynchburg Regional Airport and directs the City Administration to take the necessary steps to compile and present a plan to City Council to form such an authority as authorized by the enabling legislation.” Vice Mayor Dolan asked if “enabling legislation” covers them if they have no sponsors. Ms. Svrcek said they will be talking about the legislative agenda later today and it has been suggested to add something to that to amend the enabling legislation, if there is not another sponsor. A voice vote was taken and the motion passed by the following vote: AYES: Dolan, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6 NOES: Helgeson 1 October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 9 Agenda Item #2: Review information on the impact of Emergency Custody Orders (ECOs) and Temporary Detention Orders (TDOs) on the Police Department. Ms. Svrcek remarked that this is the last item that emerged from Council’s discussions and deliberations on the FY2020 operating budget. This is a huge impact to the police and sheriff’s departments. She has incorporated some language into the draft legislative agenda regarding this item. Chief Ryan Zuidema explained that ECOs are a civil process that allows officers to involuntarily take custody of someone exhibiting concerning mental health behavior who is a risk to himself or others and who is unwilling to volunteer or incapable of volunteering to seek treatment. It can last up to eight hours with an option for a four-hour extension. An officer has to be with that patient for the entire duration of that eight or twelve hour period of time. Is there an ability to say that we cannot get them today due to an emergency somewhere else? (Helgeson) Unfortunately, no, because that could incur liability to the officer. If an officer said they were too busy and the person harms himself or someone else, that would incur liability to the officer. (Zuidema) The medical staff will then make a decision on whether the person can be released or if there needs to be a TDO. A TDO is a civil process that allows the patient to be involuntarily held for additional mental health treatment up to 72 hours. It requires officers to transport a mental health anywhere in the state for treatment based upon available beds and it requires two officers per patient. Often off-duty officers have to be called in and paid overtime to transport TDOs because there are not the resources to use on- duty officers. This amounts to an unfunded state mandate. Numbers were presented to show the cost of ECOs and TDOs to the departments. It approaches two to almost full-time officers and those costs do not reflect vehicle, fuel or benefits costs. (Zuidema) Is there a better operational model such as partnering with our mental health partners? (Tweedy) There is an officer sitting in the emergency room 24 hours a day due to a grant that Horizon received. As long as that officer is not already sitting with a patient, an officer could turn over custody of an ECO to the emergency room officer. We will continue to explore options. Horizon is a real good partner. (Zuidema) I think it would be prudent for the legislature to look at going back to some compromise so that private security could be deputized to handle these issues. (Nelson) When staffing is available at Centra, the security officers that have been designated as special conservators of the peace will temporarily take custody of the patients, at least for the 24-hour window that they have to transport the patient. A lot of times, they do not have the staff at the hospital to do that though. The state has a pilot program that is allowing private security companies to transport TDO patients. The whole mental health system needs an overhaul though and that has to happen at the state legislature level. We will be getting the pilot program in early 2020 but the company cannot transport people that are combative or juvenile. It usually translates to being able to handle about 40 percent of the transports. (Zuidema) To help in the short term, we need more local beds and we need to be able to be reimbursed for some of the costs of ECOs and TDOs. It is allowed by state legislature but is not funded. (Zuidema) Is there a way for insurance, Medicare or Medicaid to pay for the cost of the officer? Or could the transport officers be lower paid officers such as deputy sheriffs? (Helgeson) We are open to any and all options. October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 10 To clarify, our deputy sheriffs are sworn law enforcement officers and have all the arrest powers and they help us whenever they can. The surrounding counties do provide officers for the emergency room officer (grant funded) that I mentioned earlier. (Zuidema) Could there be a different level of police officer that is dedicated to the ECOs and TDOs? (Wilder) They have discussed hiring a part time or reserve police officer to do these but anyone he puts in a uniform has to have all the training. We could look at our retirees but he does not have the resources in his current budget and would need additional funding for personnel and vehicles. (Zuidema) Do the counties have to bear the cost of their ECOs and TDOs? (Wilder) We are required to deal with anyone that is more than 50 miles from their residence. (Zuidema) I would like to hear more about the numbers and explore some of the cost saving suggestions made today during our upcoming budget discussions. (Tweedy) We need to push for state funding and it will be in our legislative agenda. (Dolan and Perrow) Agenda Item #3: Roll Call Councilmembers Wright, Perrow and Helgeson had no items. Councilmember Nelson noted he and Vice Mayor Dolan attended the Farm to School event at Perrymont Elementary School today. The program emphasizes the need to use local farms’ produce and products to feed our school children. The Secretary and Assistant Secretary of Agriculture and Forestry attended, as well as distinguished representatives from the Dairy Association and the Department of Education. It is good for the local economy and more nutritious for the children. It also helps with conservation because it comes in relatively unpackaged. Councilmember Wilder had the honor of attending the Day at the Point this past Saturday. He wanted to commend our museum system and Mr. Delaney for doing a wonderful family friendly event with over 3,000 attendees. Vice Mayor Dolan had no items. Mayor Tweedy mentioned that the Farm to Table event was a very creative event. She had the following announcements: a. The Red Kettle Campaign starts on Friday, November 29 and runs through Christmas Eve. Bell ringing runs in two-hour increments starting at 10 a.m. through 8 p.m. It is not staffed on Sundays. If you are interested in volunteering for a shift, please contact the Salvation Army. b. The Annual Fallen Firefighters Memorial Service will be Sunday, October 13th at 2:00 p.m. at Miller Park. c. The Central Virginia Planning District Commission meeting will be held October 17th at 5:00 p.m. at the Business Alliance Center. October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 11 The meeting was adjourned at 6:32 p.m. // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 8th day of October, 2019 at 7:30 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Treney Tweedy, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Sterling A. Wilder, Beau Wright, Treney Tweedy 7 // The following members were present: Present: Mary Jane Dolan, Jeff Helgeson, J. Randy Nelson, E. J. Turner Perrow, Sterling Wilder, Beau Wright, Treney Tweedy 7 Absent: 0 // Councilmember Nelson gave the Invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // Copies of the minutes of the September 24, 2019 meeting and retreat, Agenda Items 4 and 4a, having been previously furnished Council, reading was dispensed with, and on motion of Councilmem ber Perrow, seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, by the following recorded vote, approved the minutes as presented. Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #5, Resolution #R-19-074, laid over from the September 24, 2019 meeting, was again presented and read, on motion of Councilmember Perrow and seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, the FY 2019 Detention Home Fund budget was amended and $17,995 was appropriated for a welding simulator, and $5,000 for additional supplies for CPP (Community Placement Program) juveniles with resources from the Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice Community Placement Program. // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #6, Resolution #R-19-076, laid over from the September 24, 2019 meeting, was again presented and read, on motion of Councilmember Perrow and seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget was amended and $55,335 was appropriated with resources of $36,890 from the Department of Motor Vehicles Highway Safety Grant, an in-kind service and equipment match of $15,767 and $2,678 transferred from the FY 2020 General Fund Police Department budget to provide selective enforcement activities and attend related training. // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #7, Resolution #R-19-077, laid over from the September 24, 2019 meeting, was again presented and read, on motion of Councilmember Perrow and seconded by Councilmember Helgeson, the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget was amended and $22,575 was appropriated with resources of $15,050 from the Department of Motor Vehicles Highway Safety Grant, an in-kind service and equipment match of $6,374 and $1,151 transferred from the FY 2020 General Fund Police Department budget to provide funds for speed enforcement. // In the matter of Community Development – Street Vacations, Agenda Item #8, a public hearing was held regarding the petition of Victoria's Inventory, LLC, to vacate an undeveloped portion of the Bridge Street right -of- way located off of Blackford Street. The total area of the proposed vacation is approximately one hundred sixteen thousandths (0.116) of an acre. Ms. Victoria Glasgow gave a summary of the report to Council. Mr. Ed Willman of Accupoint Surveying was present to answer any questions on behalf of the petition. T here was no one who wished to speak either in favor or in opposition to the petition and Mayor Tweedy closed the public hearing portion of the October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 12 petition. Councilmember Nelson indicated that he has represented the petitioner in this matter and will be abstaining from the discussion and vote. Councilmember Perrow on behalf of the Physical Development Committee (PDC) commented that this street vacation and the one that will follow really support the renovation of the old Virginian apartments. They are dead end streets and have no value for the City but have great value to the project. He made a motion on behalf of the PDC to approve this street vacation. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6 Noes: 0 Abstentions: Nelson 1 // In the matter of Community Development – Street Vacations, Agenda Item #9, a public hearing was held regarding the petition of Victoria’s Inventory, LLC, to vacate an undeveloped portion of the Blackford Street right- of-way located off of D Street. The total area of the proposed vacation is approximately eighteen thousandths (0.018) of an acre. Ms. Victoria Glasgow gave a summary of the report to Council. Mr. Ed Willman of Acc upoint Surveying was present to answer any questions on behalf of the petition. There was no one who wished to speak either in favor or in opposition to the petition and Mayor Tweedy closed the public hearing portion of the petition. Councilmember Nelson indicated that he has represented the petitioner in this matter and will be abstaining from the discussion and vote. Councilmember Perrow, for the reasons stated previously, made a motion on behalf of PDC to approve this street vacation. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6 Noes: 0 Abstentions: Nelson 1 // In the matter of Community Development – Zoning Amendments, Agenda Item #10, a public hearing was held regarding the petition of regarding the petition of Richard Oldham to amend the Future Land Use Map from Institutional to Neighborhood Commercial and to rezone approximately three and eighty -nine hundredths (3.89) acres at 221 Wiggington Road from R-2, Low-Medium Density Residential District to B-1C, Limited Business District (Conditional) to allow the construction of a dentist office and associated parking. Mr. Tom Martin summarized the report for Council. Mr. Richard Oldham was present to answer any questions. Scott Beasley of Hurt & Proffitt was present to represent the petitioner. There was no one who wished to speak in favor or against the petition and Mayor Tweedy closed the public hearing portion of the petition. Counc ilmember Helgeson noted there this property is abutted by business uses and makes a nice transition from residential to business. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to approve the Future Land Use Map from Institutional to Neighborhood Commercial. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Wright and passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Wright made a motion to approve the rezoning from R-2 to B-1C. Councilmember Helgeson noted that Mr. Martin had mentioned that a revised concept plan was submitted since the Planning Commission meeting showing that the building addition may be detached and that the Planning Division was fine with that October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 13 change as it did not change the square footage of the layout. Councilmember Helgeson asked if that change is implicit in the motion and Councilmember Wright indicated yes. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Perrow and passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #11, Report on the City’s Health Insurance Plan effective January 1, 2020, Ms. Svrcek commented that this item would normally be a work session item. It is an information item only and needs no action tonight. Mr. Lowe gave a presentation that provided an overview on trends in medical costs, budg et versus actual, cost sharing model, monthly rates and what is recommended going forward. Following a cost sharing model implemented in 2016, it is recommended that the employee contribution be raised an additional five percent. In addition, they are researching the utilization of a third-party auditor to review a sample of claims for accuracy of coding and billing of medical services delivered, as well as hiring a health insurance ombudsman to serve as a resource for employees regarding complex medical bills and insurance. The Employee Wellness Committee will continue to be engaged in matters that will target the wellness of the employees and the cost savings. Goals going forward are to provide cost effective, high quality health plan, which assists t he City with recruitment and retention efforts, smooth future increases, build a margin for adverse experiences, fund at Anthem projection plus 2.5 percent until an 8 to 10 percent reserve is established. There are no plan changes proposed but we are planning to bid out insurance for the 2021 plan year to remain competitive. Councilmember Helgeson asked for further explanation as to how they arrived at an eight to ten percent reserve as that would not be enough to fund the 2018 shortfall. Mr. Lowe said 2018 was much higher than anything we had ever experienced and it has stabilized since then. They feel that with the increase to employees and some residual that we will be in the black at the end of the next plan year. Mr. Matt Smith, the health care consultant, indicated that there were a couple of years where there was no increase at all. The employee and employer rates are projected to increase in the future at a trend rate so that we do not get significantly behind the curve. In addition, 2018 was highly unusual and he would not expect that to happen again. Councilmember Helgeson said that in previous years we had a reserve that was twice as high as what we are shooting for and normally in times with inflation we have a bigger reserve. Mr. Sm ith said the ten percent is based on actuarial numbers and is what you should be able to expect over time for the maximum variance expected. A higher reserve would mean that they have to increase employee and employer costs at more like eight or nine percent per year as opposed to five percent. Councilmember Helgeson asked how we had $3 million in reserve that we were able to use to cover the shortfall. Ms. Svrcek said that was built over time due to reduced claims and then had an epically bad year. Councilmember Helgeson asked if the goal is to reach a ten percent reserve and no more. Mr. Smith said that is the short-term goal and it is a moving target. It will be reevaluated based on the situation. Mr. Smith thinks it will take two to three years to reach the eight to ten percent reserve. Mr. Smith said he cannot promise that a year like 2018 will never happen again but can say it was a highly unusual variance for a group this size. They could buy aggregate reinsurance that would pay the difference of claims over ten percent, for example. October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 14 It would be a relatively minor cost for a group the size of the City of Lynchburg. He would not normally recommend for a group this size though because they are not likely to have another year with claims like 20 18. Councilmember Perrow said he could not reconcile slides three and four. It shows that from 2017 to 2020 our average increase is below our trend increase. That tells him we are not doing anything to match our trends in employee contributions. Our employee contributions are not indexed to the trend because if they were then by the average percentage, we should have been okay. Mr. Smith said they should have been but they have not increased the employer or employee contributions. Councilmember Perrow believes that is a failing and we should be doing a whole lot better. He thinks we need to set up a new class; protect our existing employees but charge new employees more because paying 95% of health insurance premiums is not sustainable. He is not sur e who else even does that. Ms. Svrcek said they will provide some additional information and do some comparisons with peers and bring back some research. Mr. Smith said they are trying to implement a plan that increases employer and employee contributions by at least five percent. Councilmember Perrow said it is a too little too late. Mayor Tweedy noted that we will have to look at how much the cost of health insurance plays into recruitment and retention as well. Ms. Svrcek indicated that there is no question that having a plan that is comparable to other localities is a recruitment and retention tool. Mayor Tweedy thinks they need to balance it out since health care is so important and we do not want to lose our competitiveness over other employers. Ms. Svrcek noted that average salary increases for employees do not even come close to the health insurance increases. Councilmember Helgeson thinks that paying 68 percent for employees with families is very rich. Many employers pay for the employee but very little with regard to their dependents. Councilmember Helgeson thinks they need to look at the whole compensation package and not just isolate and cherry pick. Mr. Smith said he would agree with Councilmember Helgeson that paying 68 percent fo r an employee’s family members is pretty rich. Councilmember Wright would like to see how Lynchburg compares to other localities but thinks that it is very important that we offer a benefits package that is competitive in the low employment economy in whi ch we are competing for talent. If we want high talent, we have to offer competitive wages and certainly competitive benefits. He is happy to dive into this deeper but would caution them against adjusting the benefit structure anytime soon. Councilmember Helgeson asked for clarification that Ms. Svrcek is looking into auditing the 2018 claims to make sure the high claim costs were not due to billing or coding errors. Ms. Svrcek said Mr. Smith is helping them in finding an auditor. // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #12, Council considered introducing a resolution to amend the FY 2020 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $49,210 with resources from the Commonwealth of Virginia, Department of Criminal Justice Services to purchase law enforcement equipment for the Lynchburg Police Department. Chief Zuidema noted that he was contacted by DCJS on September 27, 2019 to inquire if they could use this money and there is no local match required. DCJS noted that the police department’s budget team stays on top of its grant monies. October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 15 There was not time for the item to go to the Finance Committee. Councilmember Helgeson made a motion to approve the item because of its urgency, the fact that there is no local match required and the department’s need for the equipment. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Perrow and passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of City Council, Consideration of the Draft 2020 Legislative Agenda, Agenda Item #13, Ms. Svrcek summarized some of the highlights of the agenda, which include updated language regarding the potential impact of changes in legislation that could eliminate the machinery and tools tax and/or business licenses taxes, a significantly enhanced section on economic development which clarifies the importance of funding from the Commonwealth for business attraction, retention and expansion, updated language relating recent amendments regarding proffers, new language regarding support for an overhaul of the mental health system and particularly support for temporary detention order transports and support for additional local beds for local mental health patience to avoid out-of-town transports. There is new language regarding support for various transportation initiatives and a significant update to the section formerly labeled water quality and environment and now labeled drinking water, water quality and environment. There have been two suggestions for additions made for Council’s consideration, one regarding the language that exists that authorized the creation of an airport authority. Ms. Svrcek is proposing they add language that states that we ask the General Assembly to amend Region 2000’s Airport Authority Act to allow the City of Lynchburg by itself or with the governing bodies of one or more counties by resolution declare there is a need to establish an authority. It was also suggested by Councilmember Perrow that we add language that came out of the draft Virginia First Cities legislative agenda to state that we support increasing funding by $4 million in the brownfields restoration and remediation fund and have a specific state budget language that would allow grant application for public housing remediation and infrastructure work associated with public housing on former landfill sites. Ms. Svrcek added $1 million as potential funding for public housing perhaps at Dearington. Councilmember Perrow thinks we need to make sure that the language says “on or adjacent to.” He asked staff to get more information from Richmond regarding their project and if they could carry the same language as Richmond. Mayor Tweedy wondered if this was an opportunity to add language regarding weeds. Mr. Erwin said they already have a weed ordinance but we get complaints about people’s shrubs or bushes. Mayor Tweedy thinks they have many properties in the City that have this problem. Councilmember Wilder thought it was worth looking into; he did not know that we did not have the ability to regulate shrubs until recently. He would be interested in thoughts from other localities. He knows there are a lot of issues around people’s property rights and he would like to hear about the concerns. Councilmember Helgeson noted that weeds can be regulated because they can harbor vermin and snakes. If someone is not trimming their boxwoods, he is not sure that can be handled in a similar fashion. He does not think so because that is more of an aesthetic issue. He understands shrubs could cause a sight problem for vehicles at a corner or something but that is different. October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 16 Mr. Erwin said that the General Assembly as a general rule does not allow us to regulate aesthetics. If a person is not harming anyone, the General Assembly has not really given jurisdictions the ability to regulate something that people just do not like to look at. Mayor Tweedy thinks this issue is important to people that are making an investment in their properties and she does not take it lightly. Vice Mayor Dolan said she would be concerned with overregulation in this area. What might be ugly to someone might not be ugly to another person. Councilmember Wright does not have any comment on this particular item but thinks they w ant to keep their list relatively concise and prioritize our “asks”. Councilmember Perrow thinks it is personal taste and preference and we should not get in the way of that. Mayor Tweedy wished the record to reflect that she inquired about it and there was discussion. Ms. Svrcek noted this item will come back to them at their October 22nd meeting for final approval. Councilmember Helgeson would like them to focus on the Emergency Custody Orders because they can be granted a lot easier. Councilmember Perrow suggested to Ms. Svrcek that they bring up the ECO/TDO issue with the Virginia First Cities as well. She said she will share this draft with Virginia First Cities. // In the matter of Zoning Amendments – Zoning Amendments, Agenda Item #14, Mr. Kent White reviewed where they are with the amendments to date. He clarified for Council that it would like to put more restrictive language into the ordinance in the future, it would not apply to existing short-term rentals (STRs) because they would be considered a legal nonconforming use. It would be allowed to continue even if the property owner changed indefinitely unless the use is stopped for two years. There was a question about whether this ordinance would apply to accessory uses. Mr. White clarified that in R-1 or R-2 districts, owner occupancy would be required. In R-C, R-3 and R-4 zoning, owner occupancy is not required for an accessory unit. The number of units allowed be dictated by the underlying zoning district standards. Staff researched options to exempt STR hosts from registering or paying lodging tax if only hosting a limited number of times. Unfortunately the current technology only identifies the location and current owner -operator information. It is staff’s intent to determine if operators intend to operate their STR annually. If an exemption is set, the default would be for staff to assume non-registered units are operating with an exemption; proving otherwise would be difficult. The Airbnb collection agreement does not provide for exemptions. This would create inequity among hosts that list on different platforms. There were questions regarding why staff feels we need a registry process. Mr. White reminded them that state code gives a locality the ability to discontinue a STR due to problems only if there is a registry process. In addition, it will provide contact information on the owner that will help staff. The three -code violations within a three-year period would provide due process without requiring staff to take individual violations to court. Also, staff costs are estimated to go up from $51,000 to $63,000 is there is no registry. Councilmember Helgeson noted that staff now estimates it will collect $150,000, which is a 78% increase over what it estimated just a few months ago. The increase would cover 440 units from not having to pay an annual fee. Mr. Nuckles confirmed that this is an annual estimate. Councilmember Helgeson noted that if they chose to change the fee in the future, grandfathering does not apply to increased fees. October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 17 Mr. White clarified that the registry will give them the information about where the STRs are located. A fee does not have to be charged. Mayor Tweedy noted that they had discussed the $150 fee to help defray some of the staff cost. Councilmember Nelson asked staff how much trouble it would cause staff if they said that an owner -occupied STR does not have to register. He is trying to get to something like what we have for yard sales and not burden the owner who is doing STR infrequently. Councilmember Perrow suggested an owner could register but pay no fee. Mr. White thinks staff could do that as long as they are not involving them in figuring the number of nights and that sort of thing. Mr. Nuckles said he just needs the information whether or not there is a fee. Councilmember Wright suggested two people, a boyfriend and girlfriend, for example, could have two residences and rent one of them out quite a bit. He is not sure it addresses the frequency challenge. Councilmember Perrow noted that normally it is a person that rents out a room in their home and it takes renting the room several times before they can recoup the cost of the registration fee. He heard that from people and it sounded like a reasonable concern to him. Councilmember Wright wondered if they should take away the fee altogether because they could be introducing a fair amount of inequity into the system. Councilmember Helgeson thinks that is why just collecting lodging tax is the equitable thing because that is based on how much the unit is rented. Councilmember Wilder wondered how many more times we are going to talk about this and Councilmember Nelson thinks they need to talk about as many times as they need to in order to get it right. We want to build neighborhoods with integrated citizens. That is a valuable purpose and why we designate residential zoning. We have to balance the competing issues of citizens who want to be able to do whatever they want to with their property with citizens who want peace and tranquility in their neighborhoods and not have a lot of transiency occurring around them. He thinks they should err with balance in the latter direction. He would like to see restrictions that restrict the investment and not the mere occasional occupancy. Councilmember Nelson cautioned them against having any ambiguity in the fee language because a court will interpret that ambiguity and give the least restrictive interpretation. He proposes the following language to make it clear that the owner and property is not forever exempt from paying the registration fee. “An additional fee of one hundred and fifty dollars ($150) shall be paid when either (1) the identity of the owner(s) of the previously registered dwelling unit(s) changes, or (2) an additional address is shown on the registration form filed for a previously registered owner. A change in the “identity of the owners” is deemed to occur if there is any modification in either the quantity of unrelated owners or the nature of the owner(s).” Councilmember Helgeson thinks they are already getting enough money from the lodging tax that we can remove the registration fee. This additional language is adding to the difficultness of the ordinance. He would support just a registry and no fee because the fee could be added later because it is not a vested right. Mayor Tweedy wanted to state for the record that she has changed her mind and it is abo ut the money. Councilmember Nelson made a motion to add the language above to the ordinance. Councilmember Perrow seconded the motion and said he supports it because it provides clarity. Councilmember Wright asked what the justification would be for requiring an additional $150 fee if a person added a property. Councilmember Nelson said he does not want to provide incentives to having Airbnb “lords” who October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 18 continually expand their inventory of properties without some consequences because residential neighb orhoods should be for those that are invested in the community and not a commercial commodity. Councilmember Helgeson thinks this seems like trying to make something punitive when the STR property owner is vested in improving his property and the neighborhood and bringing additional lodging and real estate taxes to the City. The short-term renter is not invested and that is who should be paying the money. He also pointed out that there are a lot of properties being rented long term and they do not have to pay a fee. There are a lot of things in this ordinance that do not seem equitable to him. Councilmember Nelson noted that the number of nights is set in state statute. The long -term renter is more likely to become invested in the neighborhood and contribute to it than someone that stays a weekend. That distinction in the quality of the occupancy is what is important to him. Councilmember Helgeson asked him if he thinks the $150 is fair. Mayor Tweedy said yes and Councilmember Nelson said he thinks i t is fair because it compensates the City for the costs associated, which all other taxpayers would have to bear otherwise. He does not think we should waive the lodging tax for what is essentially a mini hotel but charge our other hotels the same tax. The tax is equitable. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 6 Noes: Helgeson 1 Councilmember Helgeson asked staff if a long-term rental has violations if their right to rent their property is revoked. Mr. White said no but reiterated that staff had been asked to restrict the violations to only those related to the use such as noise, trash and occupancy, things like that. The provision to revoke a STR use is allowed b y state code if there is a registry. Councilmember Helgeson asked if this is allowable when we do not do it for a long -term rental. Mr. White reiterated that is allowed under state code if they adopt some type of language regarding violations in the STR ordinance. Councilmember Helgeson does not think this is equitable because the same is not done for long-term rentals or for a business that has a noisy tenant. We do not revoke their ability to earn income. Mayor Tweedy reminded them that she has asked staff to bring forward long-term rentals and our policies regarding them for a future discussion. Councilmember Perrow asked if this is a legal proceeding. Mr. White said the Zoning Administrator will write a notice of violation. It is appealable to the Board of Zoning Appeals just like any other decision of the Zoning Administrator. You would be allowed three of them in a three-year period and then the Zoning Administrator would send the owner a letter that their STR use has been revoked. Mr. Erwin explained that the decision of the Zoniing Administrator can be appealed to the BZA and then to the Circuit Court. Councilmember Perrow questioned the language of revoking approval because we do not approve STR properties. It is a by right use. Mr. Martin said it was included because it was in the state code. That is where the language came from. It was originally suggested as three violations in a one-year period and Planning Commission suggested it should be within a three-year period. The General Assembly gave localities the ability to cease the permitted use if they became problems. Councilmember Perrow thinks it gets back to protection of the neighborhoods and is a valid point. If you have October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 19 a repeat offender that is a “bad actor,” he would like the City to be able to issue notices of violations with some teeth and he would like the “bad actor” to have the ability to appeal. Mr. Erwin said if a person registers his property, he receives approval from staff to operate a STR. If you violate that right, then they will be given notice that he or she has lost the approval under the Zoning Ordinance. Councilmember Perrow suggested some language might need to be added. Mr. Martin said they are looking at only one part of the ordinance. If they do meet the requirements in the stated section of the Zoning Ordinance, then they are not permitted. It is already under each zoning district. Councilmember Perrow said he is getting hung up on the word approval because we are not “approving” anything. Councilmember Helgeson thinks three times in a three year period is heavy because one violation per year is not really a “bad actor.” Mr. Martin suggested that is more in line with three violations within a one-year period because that demonstrates a consistent problem. Councilmember Nelson suggested they change the word “approval” to “permitted,” which keeps it consistent with it being a permitted use in the first paragraph. Councilmember Nelson also addressed Councilmember Helgeson’s point about long-term rentals and indicated that the General Assembly does not give them the right to revoke a long-term rental use. Mr. Erwin said that is exactly right. Councilmember Perrow said he could go down to three violations in a one-year period. Because if you are a “bad actor,” there are going to be multiple complaints. Councilmember Nelson noted it would not be hard to get to three complaints in a three-year period. Councilmember Perrow made that as a motion and it was seconded by Councilmember Nelson. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Perrow made a motion to adopt the language from “approved” to “no longer permitted.” The motion was seconded by Councilmember Nelson and passed by the following vote: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Wright asked Mr. White to explain the consequence of what happens if they adopt an ordinance that does not require owner occupancy. Mr. White said those STRs now operating would become nonconforming uses. It has staying power as long as it continues its use indefinitely. It only loses its nonconformity if the use discontinues for a period of two years. It has been talked about in terms of grandfathering, which is different because it goes away if the property were sold. It is a right that would go with the owner and not the property. Mr. White noted that they still have nonconforming uses from when the Zoning Ordinance was revised in 1978. Councilmember Wright asked for clarification that a person would have to be operating at the time that Council makes a change (they could not hurry up and start a use within a two-year period) and Mr. White said that is correct. Mr. Erwin said you would have to be a legal conforming use to become a legal nonconforming use. Mr. Erwin also clarified that if a nonconforming use is destroyed by other than natural causes, it would also cease. If it is destroyed by a natural disaster, then it can be rebuilt. Mr. Erwin also clarified that “grandfathering” is a use that the local governing body decides to give the owner. October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 20 Councilmember Nelson asked if they need to comprehensively approve the entire ordinance. Mr. Erwin said they would need to make a motion to approve the ordinance as amended tonight. Mr. Erwin explained that they have not discussed every provision in the ordinance so everyone is assuming that those provi sions are okay. Councilmember Nelson thought that several weeks ago they went through each provision and came to a consensus on all of them except the ones they have been discussing at this meeting and a previous work session. Councilmember Nelson made a motion to approve the ordinance as amended. Mayor Tweedy asked Councilmember Wright if he was asking about owner occupancy for a reason. He said he wanted to clarify that point and confesses to being troubled by that particular provision and would welcome further discussion on it. Councilmember Perrow seconded Councilmember Nelson’s motion. Councilmember Nelson said to address Councilmember Wright’s comment, they are requiring an owner to register but not requiring owner occupancy. We can tag that to discuss later if the need arises and then the issue of grandfathering and nonconformity would be discussed. Councilmember Perrow seconded the motion because he thinks it is a reasonable compromise. He has seen the gamut of opinions and does not think there is a definitive right way or wrong way to do this. We have worked hard and gone through the issues. It is not perfect but is a pretty good stab. Let’s talk about the good things. Currently, STRs are not allowed in the City. It allows STRs and sets up a way for the City to collect lodging tax revenue, which makes it fair for hotels. It creates a registry so we can understand in the long term what the impact is to our neighborhoods. If there is an issue, we actually have the teeth to remove the STR. It provides some protection but allows owners to use their property as they see fit. He thinks it is a good balance. They can revisit it and tweak it if they need to and the nonconforming use assumes that a house would be sold as a business and not a residence. It could be the case but he does not think it will be the majority of cases. He thinks this ordinance equally addresses the positives and negatives of STRs. Vice Mayor Dolan thinks they hashed through the owner occupancy with kind of a pai ntbrush. She is still not convinced that the integrity of our neighborhoods will not be totally compromised. There is nothing preventing an investor from buying up a block of homes and turning that neighborhood into a mini hotel area. She will not suppo rt this ordinance as it is written. Councilmember Wright said the biggest challenge has been the owner occupancy in R -1 and R-2. This is not an issue that governments are finding it easy to deal with. It is a really challenging set of circumstances. He voted to remove owner occupancy because he believes our regulatory touch should be as light as possible to ensure maximum compliance protect private enterprise, especially given how many people rely on STRs for part of all of their income. He also voted to remove it because of issues regarding grandfather and the amount of investment that STR owners have put into neighborhoods, the need for more non-traditional lodging options in the community. If we find that issues arise, Council should update the regulations with solutions that are targeted and tailored specifically to address the issues that arise and not a “one size fits all” approach on the front end that might stifle business. It does concern him that not requiring owner occupancy in the single -family neighborhoods that we are shifting the goalposts significantly. Times change and technology adapts and new markets open up and that is what they have been wrestling with and trying to reconcile. Even though he will be voting for this ordinance, he w ould October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 21 like to note that he does find the lack of owner occupancy requirement in single-family neighborhoods to be concerning. Councilmember Wilder appreciates the conversation and noted it is a sensitive subject. He will be supporting this because it is a starting point. We can continue to listen to our citizens and make any adjustments needed in the future. Councilmember Helgeson appreciates all the discussion and recognizes the positives in the ordinance. He does not like the negatives like the registration fee and thinks we should have recognized the benefits to our neighborhoods. We value people that own their homes and some of them rent them out long term. Does the reality match the rhetoric? He has looked at it in his neighborhood and kind of wishes he had some Airbnbs as opposed to long-term rentals. We have some excellent hosts and the short-term renters spend money in our businesses and restaurants. We have hosts attracting people to come here through various platforms and he thinks we shoul d have a lighter touch on that. He thinks they are all to be commended for the time they spent on the ordinance. He would like to protect neighborhoods and some of the people he represents on Leesville Road bought into a single -family neighborhood and Council recently recommended approval of a rezoning that will allow 87 townhomes, many of which will be rentals. He questions whether we really protect all neighborhoods. Mayor Tweedy will support this and acknowledges that she gets a little conflicted. She wants to maintain the integrity of neighborhoods. We are in a different area and a different economy. She does not want to inhibit people from a business opportunity. She would like a report to come back to them at some point. She will leave it to staff to figure out the right time period. Councilmember Helgeson had the privilege of meeting with a lot of Airbnb hosts. They educated him and he appreciates their desire to be good hosts in the neighborhoods. He appreciated hearing from our citizens that had some concerns and complaints and he is glad they listened and wrestled with the decision. The motion passed by the following vote: Ayes: Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 5 Noes: Dolan, Helgeson 2 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Wrightn, by the following recorded vote elected to hold a closed meeting for consultation with legal counsel and briefings by staff members regarding a legal matter requiring the provision of legal advice, specifically legal matters relating to the Region 2000 Services Authority Member Use Agreement for the disposal of solid waste, pursuant to Section 2.2- 3711(A.)(7) of the Code of Virginia Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wright 6 Noes: Wilder 1 // The meeting was re-opened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 22 WHEREAS, Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The Motion was seconded by Councilmember Wilder, and Council by the following recorded vote adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Councilmember Perrow, by the following recorded vote elected to hold a closed meeting for discussion of and consideration of the City Manager’s and the City Attorney’s performance evaluations, pursuant to Section 2.2-3711(A)(1) of the Code of Virginia. Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was re-opened to the public. // Councilmember Helgeson made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2-3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The Motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Dolan, and Council by the following recorded vote adopted the motion: Ayes: Dolan, Helgeson, Nelson, Perrow, Tweedy, Wilder, Wright 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was adjourned at 9:45 p.m. Clerk of Council October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 23 e time, they are also providing a short left turn lane into the development so that a car can get off into a turn lane and not restrict the flow down towards J Crew. This should help with the seasonal traffic issue that was brought up by Mr. Forest. The developer Gary Schmincke came forward to speak, in favor of the petition. He explained the first phase of the development will be a fitness center with an indoor turf area. There will also be a multi-use venue space for trade shows and concerts as well as basketball/volleyball courts. They will be able to host travel teams and there is a lot of use locally for this type of facility. Marjette Upshur and Lisa Meriwether seem very excited about this project as it adds another component for athletic events in the City. There is always a need for practice facilities for local sports. The commercial areas and apartments will be built in a second phase. They love the mixed use environment and feel everything complements each other. Mr. Rick Reed with Coldwell Banker was present to speak in favor of the petition. He said he has been working with Buzzy Coleman on this property since the 1980s. He knows there is concern about rezoning industrial land to commercial but with the development of Enterprise Drive and Wyndhurst the whole complexion of the area has changed dramatically. The value of this property has priced itself beyond industrial to probably four times what your typical industrial site sells for in the City. This property has been on and off the market for eight years and he has only had one industrial prospect but once price was discussed, they were not interested. Everyone that has looked at and been interested has been for commercial uses. He goes up and down Enterprise Drive all day long and October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 24 has experienced maybe a 15 to 20 minute delay during a shift change. The turning lane should help that situation a lot and the developer has voluntarily agreed to install it. There was no else that wished to speak in favor or in opposition to the petition. Mayor Tweedy closed the public hearing portion of the petition. Councilmember Perrow asked Mr. Martin if this widening will help the situation on Dillard Drive during shift changes at J Crew. Mr. Martin said it is adding extra storage capacity at the light which would allow more throug h movement. The traffic just backs up right now in one lane. Councilmember Perrow had wanted that restated since they are not able to discuss public comments items during the public comment period. Councilmember Perrow asked Ms. Upshur to address a question. He does not believe in rezoning industrial property because we are landlocked and have limited industrial space. Councilmember Perrow asked Ms. Upshur why she is supportive of this project and to try to convince him why he should support it. He likes the idea but is very concerned about industrial space. Ms. Upshur noted that the land has been for sale for a very long time. She has marketed the land on the state’s website and the City’s website. She has only had one interested party and that was a church. The cost of the property is prohibitive for an industrial use and the neighborhood has changed drastically with the development of Wyndhurst. She is always concerned about the industrial neighbors and how they feel and a member of Wexco that backs up to this property came to the Planning Commission meeting. He had questions but seemed to have no issues with this site plan. Councilmember Perrow asked her if she thinks this development will detract from any of the industries in the area and she indicated she did not think it would. The fitness center and apartments might benefit the employees that work in the industrial areas. From a tourism standpoint, the gym and the way they are proposing to attract travel teams would mean tax revenue for the City. Councilmember Perrow noted he hears there are not enough basketball courts in the area and indoor soccer could be played as well. Ms. Upshur said they have just completed a sports tourism strategic plan to try and determine how they leverage the unbelievable assets of Liberty University but they cannot always access those facilities. She noted that Virginia Beach has built a business off of attracting youth sports. The same people developing this project own the Kinetix Gym in Fort Hill. It is so full and this fitness center would be a complement to the area. Councilmember Perrow asked her if there is still marketable industrial property that can be preserved. Ms. Upshur said the EDA has two sites and the extension of John Capron Road will probably open up two or three additional sites. There are more sites on Odd Fellows Road. For some industrial prospects, a 15 acre site will not even be enough. They just finished a site characterization plan for the state for any sites over 25 acres. There is also another site of some good size behind Home Depot. Councilmember Perrow if she thinks it will be a detriment to the City if they let this go to commercial. She stated, in her opinion, no. Councilmember Perrow made a motion to change the FLUM from Employment 2 to Mixed Use. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Nelson. Councilmember Wilder said he supports the project. He was concerned with traffic but he thinks the road improvements will ease that issue. He likes the mixed use and he understands the need for more gym space. He knows that there is always a need for places of a size that can facilitate AAU October 8, 2019 AGENDA ITEM #: 5 25 tournaments. This should bring in more tax revenue to the City. Since this site has been for sale for several years and the project is supported by Economic Development, he will support it as well. Councilmember Nelson noted that Councilmember Perrow covered many of his concerns and points very well. It is hard to find a facility that will has all the amenities that this facility would purportedly have. There is tremendous stress on the school gymnasiums for sports uses. To the extent that it will take some of that stress off the school facilities, this would be a tremendous boon. He likes that the residential use is in the back and it backs up to the Forestdale subdivision and Graves Drive and he feels it makes a good transition from residential to commercial. The elements of the development being able to serve employees of the industrial uses is a plus. This should be complementary to other uses up and down Enterprise Drive. He agrees that they need to preserve their industrial sites and is normally hesitant to downzone industrial to commercial but there are good reasons to do adopt this proposal and he thinks it will be successful. Councilmember Helgeson noted that they have been talking about the gym but there will be 116 more apartments here. When Wyndhurst was built people felt they built they built way too many apartments and townhomes there and not bigger grocery stores or more anchor type institutions such as banks and pharmacies. He does not mind going from industrial to commercial because it still provides employment but there are always apartments thrown in with mixed use. He asked Mr. Schmincke to address that topic. Mr. Schmincke said they felt it was a good mix. The president of Wexco had liked the idea that some of his employees might live in them and be able to walk to work. A representative of Azdel came to their office and echoed the same thi ng. They feel it works in that environment. They have done studies and people see it as a benefit to have residential uses mixed with the other uses they are proposing.

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.