RecordWell Data

Audit Committee Meeting Presentation

Fairfax County · Fairfax County · Notices

Open the original document More from Fairfax County

This document is no longer listed on Fairfax County's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

AUDIT COMMITTEE MEETING OFFICE OF FINANCIAL AND PROGRAM AUDIT FAIRFAXCOUNTY.GOV/BOARDAUDITOR +703-324-1501 AUDITOROFTHEBOARD@FAIRFAXCOUNTY.GOV Tuesday, October 6, 2026 Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Meeting Agenda 2 1. Opening Remarks – 3 minutes 2. Review: Minutes from July 7, 2026 Audit Committee Meeting – 2 minutes • Allowance for Vote by Audit Committee 3. Presentation: FY27 Evaluating the Restaurant Permitting Process Study – 60 minutes • Allowance for Vote by Audit Committee 4. Staffing Update – 5 minutes 5. New Business – Next Audit Committee Meeting • Tuesday, January 26, 2027 (3:00 pm) in Conference Room 11 6. Adjournment Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Evaluating the Restaurant Permitting Process Study: Overview 3 • OFPA issued three observations with recommendations which Management has agreed to implement. Objective: To evaluate the timeliness, efficiency, and overall experience of the permitting process for restaurants opening in Fairfax County Context: Fairfax County is home to more than 2,500 food establishments, and the County has issued an average of 280 new food establishment permits annually in recent years. Across Virginia, 9 out of 10 are small businesses. To perform this study • OFPA reviewed the restaurant permitting process through data analysis and sampling, review of applicant resources and fees, interviews with applicants and County staff, and comparisons with practices in other jurisdictions and established leading practices. Scope of review • Businesses receiving or pursuing food establishment permits between July 1, 2023, and August 3, 2026, including new establishments and ownership changes with building renovations or new construction. • Study did not include establishment types such as grocery stores, schools, and hospitals and generally excluded zoning and site plan approvals. OFPA issued three observations with recommendation which Management has agreed to implement. Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Restaurant Permitting Process, Systems and Resources 4 PLUS Portal: Centralized, online platform for submitting and tracking applications for zoning, building, permitting and other land development. Restaurants require multiple applications with multiple agencies. Applicant Resources and Expedited Support: The County offers guidance, assistance, and expedited review options, but resources are dispersed and do not provide a single, restaurant-specific guide or tool covering the full permitting process. Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Restaurant Permitting Data Analysis 5 Analysis of sample (non- statistical) of 34 food establishments Duration (in Calendar Days) to Open a Restaurant (in PLUS) Average duration by phase: • Construction/Inspection was the longest at 148 calendar days (47% of all phase time) • Plan Review at 98 calendar days (31% of all phase time) • Construction (to first inspection) at 50 calendar days • Application Submittal at 16 calendar days 14 of 34 restaurants had ALT-C (Commercial Building Addition/ Alteration) applications/records Duration (in Calendar Days) for Restaurants with ALT-C Records Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Restaurant Permitting Data Analysis 6 Restaurants require multiple applications (e.g., food establishment application, commercial addition/ alteration application, fire alarm application) and each has its own completeness review, plan review, and inspections. • The County returns applications/plans that are incomplete or do not meet requirements to applicants for correction and resubmission. • Plan reviews may involve multiple County agencies and disciplines, often reviewing concurrently. The County returns plans that do not meet code for correction and resubmission. • Failed inspections require corrections and reinspection so applicants may go through multiple inspection cycles before final approval and issuance of permits to operate. • Agency metrics focus on review times per review round / LDS and OFM generally met or exceeded their goals Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Restaurant Interviews & Economic Impact of Permitting Process 7 1. Lengthy and Unpredictable Timelines 2. Inconsistency Across Reviews and Inspections 3. Lack of Clear Guidance and Support for First-Time/Small Restaurant Owners 4. Communication Challenges, Customer Service, and PLUS 5. Fees and Costs Associated with Delays 6. Collaboration as a Goal 11 restaurant owners and restaurant groups that recently opened or were in the process of opening restaurants in Fairfax County Economic Impact of Permitting Timelines • Extended permitting timelines can prolong the period when restaurants incur costs (rent, operating/staff, financing) without generating revenue. • Permitting delays can also defer County tax revenue when restaurant openings are postponed. For example, a restaurant with $30,000 in weekly taxable sales would generate approximately $1,200 per week in County meals tax revenue, meaning a one-month delay could defer about $4,800 per restaurant, not including revenue from the local option tax. Restaurants Interviews Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Existing Efforts to Improve the Permitting Process / Leading Practices 8 Existing Efforts To Improve the Process • Economic Competitiveness Strategic Roadmap: Multiple planned initiatives could benefit restaurant applicants, including clearer project dashboards, dedicated assistance for qualifying small businesses and tenant projects, tiered plan-review pathways based on project complexity, PLUS workflow automation and AI-enabled plan review tools, multidisciplinary pre-submission meetings, expanded parallel reviews, and guidance on common submission errors to help reduce corrections, resubmissions, and delays. • Plan Review Quality Control Program: LDS reviews selected plan-review comments for clarity, consistency, code references, actionability, and duplication. • Customer Feedback: LDS has offered customer service surveys since 2018, but technical accessibility issues have contributed to a significant decline in responses; interviewed restaurant owners were generally unaware of the feedback option but interested in providing feedback. Leading Practices Across the jurisdictions reviewed, the strongest approaches do not necessarily eliminate regulatory requirements or require a complete redesign of the permitting system. Instead, they focus on making existing processes simpler to navigate, better coordinated, and more responsive to the complexity of individual projects. Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Observation 1: Fragmented, Outdated Guidance and Limited Support Dedicated to Restaurants 9 • Outdated and fragmented restaurant permitting guidance, limited dedicated support to restaurants • Permitting information and support resources are difficult to find • Small and first-time businesses may face greater barriers • Applicants lack an end-to-end view of permitting timelines • Customer feedback mechanisms (surveys) are not functioning effectively 1. Update and maintain the County’s comprehensive restaurant permitting guide, align it with current PLUS workflows, include expected timelines and available resources, and proactively provide or link the guide to applicants early in the process. 2. Review and improve permit-related County website pages for clarity and comprehensiveness, create audience-specific permitting resources where appropriate, and consistently link users to the updated restaurant guide and available support programs. 3. Consider providing a single point of contact, such as a case manager or concierge, for first-time and small-business restaurant owners. 4. Improve permitting dashboards across agencies and consider end-to-end metrics that better communicate total expected processing timelines. 5. Update the customer service survey and outreach, with particular attention to small and first-time businesses, and establish a process for addressing recurring issues identified through feedback. 6. Evaluate the feasibility of using AI, automation, and other system tools to accelerate initial plan reviews and assist applicants, particularly small businesses that may lack specialized technical resources. Observation Recommendation Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Observation 1: Fragmented, Outdated Guidance and Limited Support Dedicated to Restaurants - Continued 10 Management Response Management agrees to update the Restaurant Guide and consolidate restaurant permitting information. LDS will form a multi-agency workgroup in November 2026 to inventory existing resources by March 2027 and develop a plan to update information by June 2027. LDS also plans to coordinate permit review dashboards with the Office of the Fire Marshal and develop a plan for incorporating Health Department metrics by June 2027. Customer surveys are scheduled to resume by August 2027 following PLUS’s anticipated cloud migration, and agencies will continue exploring AI-assisted plan review options, with implementation dependent on market availability. Accountable Individuals • The LDS PACA Division Director in LDS (currently Brandy Mueller) • The LDS Operations Division Director in LDS (currently Helman Castro) Implementation Dates 1. Multi-agency workgroup- by November 2026 2. Inventory of information - completed by March 2027 3. Plan - completed by June 2027 4. LDS and OFM dashboard platform work - completed by June 2027 • Develop a similar plan of action for Health Department - completed by June 2027 5. PLUS migration - December 2026 • New surveys will launch - August 2027 6. AI plan review - implementation dependent on market availability, etc. - Ongoing Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Observation 2: Cross Agency Workflow Challenges in Food Establishment Plan Reviews 11 Observation Recommendation • Health Department involvement can occur too late in the plan review process: Food establishment projects are sometimes not correctly identified during LDS intake and routing, resulting in Health not being added as a required reviewer until later in the process, potentially after the building permit has been issued. • LDS should strengthen intake and routing procedures to consistently identify food establishment projects and involve Health at the appropriate stage, including considering improved PLUS prompts or mandatory fields, staff refresher training, a verification step, and AI or other tools to help flag food establishment projects earlier. Management Response Management acknowledges this can occasionally occur and will train Building Division staff to better identify restaurant applications by December 2026. The workgroup will be tasked with identifying potential PLUS automation or process changes to prevent these errors by March 2027. Accountable Individual • LDS PACA Division Director (currently Brandy Mueller) Implementation Dates 1. Training - by December 2026 2. PLUS or process changes to remedy the issue - by March 2027 Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Observation 3: Restaurants Report Inconsistent, Conflicting and Lengthy Permitting Processes 12 Observation Recommendation • Restaurant interviews revealed concerns regarding timeliness and consistency of permitting reviews and inspections, with accumulating delays. • County staff provided reasonable explanations as to why permitting timelines can be lengthy or get delayed. • These differing perspectives indicate that some delays may reflect shared responsibility and an expectations gap between the County and applicants. OFPA was not able to independently confirm the prevalence of these issues through our analysis; however, the consistency of feedback from restaurant owners suggests challenges that the County has not fully addressed. • Restaurants expressed concerns that some decisions may reflect individual reviewer or inspector preferences rather than the consistent application of established codes; LDS does not maintain standard operating procedures governing reviews and inspections. • Challenges with inspection logistics and routing exist, which may contribute to extended timelines. 1. Establish a cross-agency workgroup involving LDS, Health, and the Office of the Fire Marshal to analyze applicant feedback, staff insights, and PLUS data, identify root causes, and implement improvements within the County’s control. 2. Strengthen consistency among reviewers and inspectors by clarifying expectations, improving alignment in applying code requirements, and establishing internal mechanisms or escalation processes to resolve conflicting interpretations before they affect applicants. 3. Explore opportunities to optimize inspection scheduling and routing tools available in PLUS to improve efficiency and reduce avoidable delays. 4. Coordinate permitting improvements, where possible, with initiatives under the Economic Competitiveness Strategy Roadmap to avoid duplication and support broader County goals for business experience and economic growth. Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Observation 3: Restaurants Report Inconsistent, Conflicting and Lengthy Permitting Processes - Continued 13 Management Response Management acknowledges the concerns raised and will task a multiagency workgroup to review customer feedback, identify root causes, and recommend corrective measures. LDS will complete a commercial inspection manual by September 2027 and identify a path to resolve inspection routing issues by April 2027, following PLUS’s cloud migration. Accountable Individuals • Workgroup – LDS PACA Division Director (currently Brandy Mueller) • Inspection Manual – LDS Building Official (currently Jay Riat) • Routing Solution – LDS Operations Division Director (currently Helman Castro) Implementation Dates 1. Multi-agency workgroup - by November 2026 2. Review of Customer service surveys - to begin after August 2027 3. Inspection manual - September 2027 4. Routing Tools options identified - April 2027 Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting OFPA Update 14 Staffing Update Office of Financial and Program Audit Audit Committee Meeting Audit Committee: Next Meeting 15 Tuesday, January 26, 2027 at 3:00 pm Conference Room 11

Source: Fairfax County website. First collected Oct 5, 2026.