_05122016-569
Loudoun County · Loudoun County · meeting of May 12, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Loudoun County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Administrative Operations
Committee
Minutes
May 12
, 2016
The
Ma
y
meeting of the
Administrative Operations
Committee was held on Thur
sday
, March 10
,
201
6
in the DTCI Large Conference Room at 801 Sycolin Road
.
C
hairman
Quin
presided and
called the meeting to order
at
19
3
7
hours. The following were in attendance
:
Co. 1
Mark Arend
Co. 2
Brad Quin
Co. 4
John Moring
Co. 5
John Malone
Co. 6
Jimmy Olveson
Co. 7
Bernie Boteler
Co. 8
Eric Shank
Co. 9
J
ay
J Brown
Co. 10
Bob Akers
Co. 11
Andy Gode
Co.
12
Karen Deli
Co. 13
Jim Cromer
Co. 14
Sue Johnson
Co. 15
Jen Ferguson
Co. 17
Absent
LCFR:
AC Matt Tobia
,
Christine Langley-Obaugh
Minutes
Motion:
A m
otion
was
made
by
Bernie Boteler
to approve
the
April 14
,
201
6
minutes
.
The motion was
s
econded
by
Jimmy Olveson
,
Company
6
.
Vote:
Approved
with a vote of
1
3
-0
-
1
-
1
with Jen Ferguson abstaining
.
Update of Key Issues
:
Executive Committee Update
:
Chief Tobia reported that the Volunteer Physicals SWP was passed at the last EC meeting as the
AOC, EMSOC and FOC unanimously agreed to move the item forward. Chief Tobia explained a
subsequent motion on behalf of the FOC was proposed requesting that the system-wide Health,
Safety and Wellness Committee evaluate the feasibility of moving to a single standard. Chief
Tobia advised that questions and concerns arose about the inadvertent treating of single role
providers differently than dual role cross trained providers and further, if there is one standard
then what should that one standard be. Chief Tobia clarified that the Health, Safety and
Wellness Committee will research this issue. Chief Tobia shared that the second part of that
motion required that any recommendations being brought forward by the Health, Safety and
Wellness Committee return to the EC prior to any action being taken. Chief Tobia reiterated that
the only change is that effective July 1
st
, any individuals participating in the Volunteer Battalion
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
May 12, 2016
Page
2
of
8
Chief
’
s Program will be required to and successfully complete an annual NFPA 1582 physical.
Chief Tobia stated many are in compliance as they are part-time instructors and the NFPA 1582
is required for part-time instructors.
The EC, according to Chief Tobia, also retired a significant number of out of date and redundant
FRG
’
s, both operational and admin
i
strative. A system wide IB will follow
. Chief Tobia explained
that many FRG
’
s on the operations side may have stated to follow the NOVA Manuals. Chief
Tobia stated we do follow the NOVA Manuals and we are a signatory to the NOVA Compact,
thus several FRG
’
s were found to be redundant. This action was based upon recommendations
that came from the System-Wide Procedure Ad Hoc Committee. Chief Tobia
advised that the EC
voted unanimously to retire the FRG
’
s as recommended. Chief Tobia stated we will circulate the
information to include which FRG
’
s have been retired and which FRG
’
s were replaced by SWP
’
s.
Chief Tobia
mentioned that SWP
’
s have now been formatted uniformly and distributed.
Chief
Tobia stated that there are approximately 10 FRG
’
s that are under review with the SWP Ad-Hoc
Committee for merging of SOP and FRG into one document. Chief Tobia explained to the AOC
that once merged documents come to the EC, the intent is that the system stakeholders have
already been fully made aware of the work through their system representatives thus there is
not a need to distribute through the subcommittees. However, Chief Tobia stated that the EC
may have additional edits and ultimately, the System Chief becomes the final decision maker.
Subcommittee Reports
:
Audits:
President Quin spoke about the on-going
risk management audit process. Chairman Quin
advised the AOC that five companies were in the current process which included the following
companies: 10, 11, 12, 14 and 17.
Chairman Quin reported that he and Chief Tobia met with Janet
Romanchyk
in the Controller
’
s
Office as well as John Sandy to review next steps in follow-up and the report from them
indicated things were on track and moving smoothly. Chair Quin advised that the reason for the
meeting was to follow-up regarding the request made to the AOC by the Board and the Finance
Government Services Operations Committee to the risk management assessments that were
completed last year. Final reports were previously distributed which included recommended
processes in accounting. The BOS would like to see how companies address dealing with
categories rated red or yellow whereby weak or non-existent practices need some attention.
President Quin informed the group that the sub-committee will draft some recommendations
for consideration to help improve and engage the process going forward. Chair Quin explained
that the desire is to report back to the BOS how companies have improved processes
.
Chief Tobia explained that
Supervisor
Buona
made a motion that there should be follow-up.
Chief Tobia also shared that there is a guidebook, a set of policies and procedures, developed in
cooperation with the companies by Cherry Beka
e
rt. Chief Tobia explained that if a company
wants to draft a policy and if you want to ensure it meets the standards, we would engage with
Cherry Beka
e
rt and
they can
review the model policy
.
Chief Tobia clarified that is County
Administration
’
s desire that the AOC continue to administrate this process. Chair Quin added
that there are several companies that have good and stable practices. Chair Quin shared that
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
May 12, 2016
Page
3
of
8
there is an understanding between large companies that have complex practices and financials
and smaller companies with more straightforward policies.
Chairman Quin summarized by stating that we would like to be able to give a response to Mr.
Buona in the fall. Chief Tobia clarified as soon as policy is written, it should be operationalized as
soon as possible. Chief Tobia stated that individual companies can already be embarked on
evaluating the reports, identifying areas for improvement and engaging in steps to reflect that
improvement. Chief Tobia explained that if a company would like Cherry Bekaert, the auditing
firm, to review something, please contact him and he will make the contact.
Budget Sub-committee
:
Dave Short
provided a brief summary of the underlying principles
guiding the process for distribution the County allocation each year via the algorithm: to
determine the delta (funding gap) after company
’
s income and expenses are considered before
the allocation of County assistance. Each company
’
s percentage of that gap is the percentage of
the subsequent allocation.
Dave
shared
that this year a decision was made to take a three year
rolling average
of those expense to
dampen
the impact of
single year pe
aks and
valleys
in
company expenses
.
Dave
reviewed the other key areas of discussion in the budget Subcommittee: EMS billing
revenue; capital reserves (apparatus costs and service life); and safety center expenses (rents)
;
and the AOC approved $250,000
‘
minimum
’
allocation
.
While it is anticipated that changes to the life cycle (shorter) and replacement costs (higher) of
apparatus to match current County standards as originally implemented in the algorithm will be
nominal, EMS billing revenue has the
potential to
dramatically impact the process given the
anticipated high levels of income that will flow to several companies.
Final decisions on how to
accommodate such an influx of income are the subject of continuing discussion.
With respect to safety center rent expenses impacting
just five companies, concern has been
expressed over the level of some of the expenses companies are passing on to through the
algorithm. For the first time the budget subcommittee has secured income and expense data
for each safety center to secure a better understanding of those cost drivers. A
recommendation to change or modify policy on how those coasts are reported to the algorithm
for the final cut is being discussed and does not impact the first cut allocations.
Jimmy Olveson expressed concern
regarding
significantly higher numbers being reported by
some companies. It is Jimmy
’
s opinion that there are issues with
the numbers provided by the
safety centers to their companies and its impact on t
he algorithm. Dave Short stated that the
group will strive for transparency and defensibility of reporting.
Chair Quin stated that the budget sub-committee has recognized this as an issue. Chair Quin
emphasized it has been discussed and
is why,
for the first time, information
regarding such
expenses is being collected from the safety centers themselves.
Chair Quin emphasized the issue
will be resolved and it will affect the final analysis in the end. Chair Quin clarified by stating that
the budget sub-committee will make a recommendation and bring it forward to the AOC for
approval
after its May and June meetings
.
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
May 12, 2016
Page
4
of
8
Dave Short
stated missing data from approximately 6 companies is still needed.
Dave Short
also discussed the $250,000 minimum.
Dave stated
that
applying the AOC approved
policy to this year
’
s first cut,
three companies fell below the $250,000 and they were only below
by a little amount.
Dave explained that these companies
’
first cut allocation were adjusted
upward to
$250,000
reducing all other companies
’
allocations accordingly and actually resulting
in an elimination of the funding gap for one
.
A
spreadsheet
of the proposed first cut allocations
was handed out for AOC members to review.
Dave Short clarified that the numbers are for FY17. Dave explained that by examining the post
adjustment category which is your predicted funding from the County for FY17. Adjustments to
the draft will occur based upon all the variables that have been discussed.
Chair Quin stated that company 3 is included in the calculation and it may not be appropriate to
put them in. Chief Tobia stated that the remaining amount of money left in escrow right now is
sufficient to cover the expenses going forward for probably another year or two while they are
in the process of dissolving.
Chief Tobia stated they can be removed from the FY17 calculation.
Chief Tobia stated that the County is currently paying for the expenses of the building. Chief
Tobia stated that company 3 should not be included in the algorithm at all going forward.
To summarize
Dave
pointed out that
the
total expense needs of the volunteer system before
any consideration of EMS billing revenue is included is $
6.836 million to
make each company
100% whole. The County is
budgeting $
6.315 million, so there is a
total system funding gap of
just under
$500,000
.
If, for example, someone is over funded, the intent or purpose of the
motion was not to give them extra money, it was to ensure everyone had a minimum level in
which to operate. Dave stated that this potential loophole will be examined by the budget sub-
committee and a possible amendment may be necessary.
Chief Tobia stated that if it is the intent of the AOC that the EMS
r
evenue is counted dollar for
dollar as income against expenses, then every dollar that you will make in EMS
r
evenue is a
dollar that comes off of the money that you are getting from the County algorithm. Chief Tobia
stated that it means three quarters of the way through the fiscal year, the volunteer companies
have realized over a million dollars in revenue. If the current funding gap is $439,000 or even if it
is $521,000 what we are looking at is functionally ending the year
with a $500,000 delta of
positive money not necessarily available for re-distribution because everyone will have 100% of
their allowed expenses to have been counted. Chief Tobia stated that the budget sub-
committee will need to have a discussion based on what that means.
Chief Tobia stated that the
System Chief is concerned because while he acknowledges the concern of the AOC at the
conception of the algorithm, that EMS revenue should be counted, the functional effect is more
than certainly the Board
’
s intent which has all along articulated that the intent of the EMS
revenue money was a system add. Chief Tobia emphasized that he is not articulating a position.
Chief Tobia stated that the legislative history of EMS billing revenue seems to reflect the intent
that this money could be used to improve the services delivered. Chief Tobia said, for example,
it would allow company 14 to buy power lift cots for all of its ambulances which you could not
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
May 12, 2016
Page
5
of
8
otherwise do in a normal funding year. Chief Tobia wants all to be cognizant of the functional
fact.
Jay J. Brown shared that part of the testimony that went into the hearings that was from the
companies saying that they were not able to purchase everything that they wanted to that
’
s
why their budget would not reflect what they truly needed. Jay J. stated much like where we are
right now that we are putting off remodeling something because we have other needs.
Chief Tobia stated we want to continue to be good stewards of the taxpayer dollars and ensure
needs are addressed. Chief Tobia submitted that one of the things this could lead to potentially
is an opportunity for some of that money to go towards a prioritized list of system-wide needs
to help the volunteer companies
(ex. fuel, PPE
’
s, insurance)
.
Chair Quin stated that last year and the previous three years, first cut data was requested by
June 1
st
. Chair Quin stated that they reported to the EC in July the first cut data. Chair Quin
shared that final numbers were then gathered so that those numbers could be provided to the
EC in late September. Chair Quin reiterated that we will need to work within that rough time
frame to have final decisions made prior to September.
For clarification, any discussions that the budget sub-committee will have will only impact the
true-up.
Chief Tobia shared that the intent is, in order for the checks to go out in the first week of July,
they need to have that 30 day window
in order to process them. Chief Tobia stated if the AOC
votes tonight, it would guarantee that the money would be available for July 1 because the EC
could vote on it at the end of this month which gives the County amble time.
Chair Quin stated if the numbers are approved with Company 3 in it and then the adjustment is
made without 3, you will notice a slight increase. Chair Quin stated there is no damage done to
approving the document as written with a provision that Dave update the numbers relative to
the discussion. Jay J. Brown suggested a special meeting after the budget sub-committee
meeting if everyone wanted to view the numbers. Chair Quin stated that if we examine the
numbers tonight and are sufficiently comfortable as a beginning process and know that there
will be a slight change in the positive, we will have that settled so we can give the information to
the County so companies can be funded. Chair Quin then stated we would begin today through
the end of July to resolve the remaining questions and do the true-up.
Chief Tobia
would recommend that the AOC accept this and follow it up with a revised
document excluding company 3 and do a straw poll by email to affirm the revised document.
Chief Tobia shared he did not feel it was appropriate for Company 3 to be in the algorithm.
Jay J. Brown offered a friendly amendment that we approve this with Company 3
’
s funding be
added back in. Motion seconded.
Motion passed with no one opposed.
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
May 12, 2016
Page
6
of
8
Dave Short asked that safety center numbers and fleet information be communicated. Dave
advised that he no longer needs square footage information.
Chief Tobia asked all to report anything on the document t that is not accurate.
Chief Tobia stated the whole basis for this entire thing is predicated on the integrity and the
openness and transparency of this group. Chief Tobia further stated that the AOC has done a
colossal job in gaining the trust and respect of the BOS in managing this money.
Chair Quin added that the budget sub-committee meetings have all been highly productive,
highly collaborative and very directed to make sure we honor that particular perspective.
Discussion Topics
Social Media Draft SWP and Use of Personal Electronic Devices SWP
Chief Tobia shared that the first drafts of these policies spurred discussion. Chief Tobia stated
that he was impressed regarding the feedback and communication received from several
companies. Chief Tobia will continue to revise the draft accordingly. A revised document will
return soon and ample opportunity for input to be provided will occur. Earl Hall has offered to
assist with the policies and Matt Schultz, the primary author, continues his involvement, as well.
Chief Tobia shared that an incident occurred just the other day whereby a system member took
a screen shot of a CAD call and posted it on his
Facebook
page. Chief Tobia stated he received an
unsolicited phone call and the matter was dealt with swiftly and efficiently. Chief Tobia
emphasized that there is a need to provide system members some boundaries and guidance.
Chief Tobia stated we are sensitive and mindful to the terrible dangers that exist.
Chief Tobia summarized by stating the need to provide comments as soon as possible.
Chair Quin applauded Chief Tobia
’
s willingness to add Earl to the group as it is important to have
a voice from the volunteer side of the house.
Awards and Recognition SWP
Chair Quin explained that the SWP in the packet includes one minor change with the renaming
of an award in honor of Leo Kelly.
Chief Tobia stated that this is a living product and the EMSOC did endorse it earlier this week.
Chair Quin shared a question posed by Rick Etter regarding Length of Service Awards. The
Recruitment and Retention Committee is considering doing away with Length of Services awards
due to differences in how members are tracked. Chair Quin stated that the R & R Committee is
giving consideration to replacing it with a rewards program
employing another method to
determine edibility
.
Chair Quin shared Rick
’
s concern as he wants to make sure this does not
violate the SWP. Chair Quin stated that he did not find any reference to the Length of Service
Program within the SWP. Chair Quin stated he will share with Rick that it does not impact the
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
May 12, 2016
Page
7
of
8
policy and further, that they own that process and they should pursue appropriate avenues to
recognize members.
Chair Tobia advised the AOC that the change in the Chamber of Commerce Awards this year was
the walking heart awards. Chief Tobia stated that there has been a tremendous level of
discussion within the selection committee bout whether or not individuals should be recognized
when they save a life and someone walks out of the hospital. Chief Tobia shared that the
nationwide survival rate for out of hospital cardiac arrests is 5%. Chief Tobia stated that it
reflects the very best in exemplary teamwork.
Discussion ensued regarding Honor Guards. Chair Quin stated he would entertain a motion from
the floor to accept the document as written with a qualification to Chief Johnson regarding
Honor Guards.
The motion was made and seconded. The motion passed with no one opposed
and no abs
t
entions.
Action Item
/New Business:
Budget Sub-committee changes to the FY17 Allocation Process
: See above
Social Media SWP
: No action needed; will be heard at the EC in June
Use of Personal Electronic Devices
SWP
:
No action needed; will be heard at the EC in J
u
ne
Awards and Recognition SWP
: See above
Information Sharing Across Volunteer Councils and Committees
Recruitment and Retention Committee
-
Nothing noted
DFREM
-
C
hief Tobia recognized Francis
R
ath
in the County. One of the career members in the
department has a son with special needs and has been dealing with significant health issues
since he was 7 weeks old. Chief Tobia stated Francis bought a cooling vest for this young man
which has allowed the young man to escape from being trapped in his own home for the first
time in his life. He will be upset, most likely, according to Chief Tobia that something was said
because he certainly did not want any fanfare. Chief Tobia stated that the company that creates
the cooling vest has posted the
story on their
F
acebook
page and it is being widely shared. Chief
Tobia shared that he also sent the story to the EC.
EMSOC-
Jay J. Brown shared that there have been issues with biohazard pick-ups.
Announcements-
Please forward the oper
at
ions messa
g
es from Chief Johnson.
Open Houses are coming up.
Child Safety Seat Inspections on May 31
st
.
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
May 12, 2016
Page
8
of
8
Races will take place on Saturday according to Andy Gode.
Fundraising Boundary Files
: Chief Tobia stated the lists have now gone to sequel server and it doesn
’
t
translate quickly. Chief Tobia shared that Kate is working diligently to work through the issues. Chief
Tobia suggested that folks use their calendar year 2015 lists.
Child Safety Checks in Arcola is sponsored by Ashburn Rotary. Extra car seats will be available.
Grand Opening of station 6 will be held on Sunday, May 15
th
.
Open House at Round Hill is May 28
th
.
Chair Quin attended the ceremony at Company 3, a well done ceremony and highly respectful of the
long tradition of the company.
Chair Quin stated his company will be holding an event on May 28
th
. The group will participate in
Memorial Day ceremonies. They raise money for Veteran activities.
Chair Quin advised that he has been asked to speak at the Town Memorial Day Ceremony occurring on
5/30, thus any friendly faces are welcome.
Consideration may wish to be given to sponsoring an Honor Flight in the future.
A
djournmen
t
There being
no further business to discuss,
t
he meeting was adjourned at
2
1
43
hours
.
The n
ext
Administrative Operations
Committee meeting will be held on
T
hurs
day,
June 9
,
201
6
at 1930
hours
at
801 Sycolin Road, DTCI Large
Conference Room
.
Respectfully submitted:
Christine Langley-Obaugh, M.Ed., CVA
Executive Liaison
Source: Loudoun County website. First collected Oct 5, 2026.