_04142016-571
Loudoun County · Loudoun County · meeting of Apr 14, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Loudoun County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Administrative Operations
Committee
Minutes
April 14
, 2016
The
April
meeting of the
Administrative Operations
Committee was held on Thur
sday
,
April 14
,
201
6
in the DTCI Large Conference Room at 801 Sycolin Road
.
C
hairman
Quin
presided and
called the meeting to order
at
19
3
0
hours. The following were in attendance
:
Co. 1
Absent
Co. 2
Brad Quin
Co. 4
John Moring
, Ted Spara
Co. 5
John Malone
Co. 6
Jimmy
Olveson
Co. 7
Bernie Boteler
Co. 8
Eric Shank
Co. 9
J
ay
J Brown
Co. 10
Bob Akers
Co. 11
Andy Gode
Co.
12
Karen Deli
Co. 13
Absent
Co. 14
Aaron Kahn
, Amanda Palmieri
Co. 15
Jen Ferguson
Co. 17
Absent
LCFR:
AC Matt Tobia
,
Christine Langley-Obaugh
Minutes
Motion:
A m
otion
was
made
to approve
the
March 10
,
201
6
minutes
with one
correction on page 2
. The motion was
s
econded
by
Bernie Boteler
,
Company
7
.
Vote:
The motion was a
pproved
with a vote of
12-0-0-3
.
Update of Key Issues
:
Executive Committee Update
:
Chief Tobia shared that the Executive Committee passed SWP 201.1,
Suspensions
and Dismissal
s
of Volunteers
(which used to be FRG 3.6.1)
. Chief Tobia thanked
Aaron Kahn and Jen Ferguson
for their hard work.
Chief Tobia shared that the SWP will reflect which FRG it is replacing. Chief Tobia stated
additional items will be forthcoming by the SWP AD-Hoc Committee.
Subcommittee Reports
:
Budget Sub-committee
:
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
April 14
,
201
6
Page
2
of
9
Chief Short
participated via conference call and
thanked everyone on the sub-committee for all
of their hard work. Chief Short reviewed the AOC proposals offered by the
Budget
sub-
committee which were also included in the AOC packet as a handout.
Recommendation #1
:
Conversation ensued about
a three year average for consideration for
planning purposes using FY13, FY14 and FY 15 actuals
for the
‘
first cut
’
on the annual data
collection
. Chief Short explained the draft number would be provided at the June, 2016 AOC
meeting. Chief Short stated that the final allocation will be calculated using FY14, FY15, and
FY16 actuals with the final number being provided at the August, 2016 AOC meeting.
Chairman Quin reiterated one of the advantages of this proposal would be that the budget
sub-committee would not need to field requests for estimates
of final FY 16 income and
expenses for the
‘
first cut
’
which proved to be problematic for some companies
. President
Quin reminded the AOC members that a table of
allowable
income and expenses had been
created over the past four to five years. A three year average may result in a better number
than how previous estimates were garnered. President Quin clarified that funding would be
based on the actual data
. Chief Tobia explained that if
in a given single year
funding is cut by
their local jurisdiction,
for example, the negative impact of that large cut would be
minimized because the
analysis
is based on
a three year average versus a single year
.
Recommendation #2
:
Conversation took place regarding Capital Assets
(apparatus)
.
The
proposal
includes
increasing the replacement costs for several apparatus, decreasing the
service life expectancy for some apparatus,
no longer funding for reserve apparatus
,
removal of the
fast/slow company discriminator. The net impact of this proposed change is
on actual reserve figures for each company is expected to be minimal.
Recommendation #3:
Discussion occurred surrounding Safety Center payments and a
request for breakdowns of what it is included in monthly rent. (Hamilton, Purcellville and
Sterling have been part of the discussion.)
The subcommittee is continuing this discussion
and will meet again on
April 24
to finalize a process for evaluating safety center expenses
and how they impact
‘
rent
’
figures reported by companies occupying safety center managed
facilities.
Recommendation #4:
Discussion
ensued
of the
Capital Assets (Buildings)
reserve figure
currently in the algorithm and its derivation
.
Chief Short suggested the possibility of
exploring this area using a cost per square footage estimate. Companies are being requested
to supply an estimated measurement of living space to include parking lots, living space and
roof size.
Further discussion occurred regarding having all companies provide this data.
Aaron Kahn
raised the question of counting the expense data twice. Chief Tobia stated that potentially
one may count the data twice, however, it would be dependent upon whether the safety
center includes replacement costs of key systems. Chief Tobia clarified by stating that if the
rent is only intended to cover the mortgage, then the answer would be
“
no
”
. If, however,
alternately, the safety center
’
s monthly charge to the company does include a factor for
capital replacement of key systems, then
“
yes
”
,
potentially
,
it would. Chief Tobia explained
that at this point, it is unknown regarding what is included in safety center payments.
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
April 14
,
201
6
Page
3
of
9
Discussion also took place regarding if two companies share a safety center, would they split
the square footage to report 50/50. The answer to this questions was
“
yes
”
. Chief Tobia
suggested that Presidents should communicate with one another. The numbers have been
requested as soon as possible.
Chair Quin stated that the number that is presently in the algorithm
was the budget
committee
’
s best estimate of a placeholder fi
gure. It was
adjusted, only slightly, within the
first three years.
A
ccording to President Quin, there was not a good measure
for this
expense in the past and the subcommittee will evaluate the suggestions noted above in an a
effort to find a better way to estimate the costs
driving the estimate
.
Recommendation #5:
The proposal includes considering EMS billing income as an income
source for FY16.
The next Budget Sub-Committee meeting will be held on April 24, 2016 at Station 6.
(Rescheduled from April 23, 2016).
Discussion Topics
Social Media Draft SWP
and
Use of Personal Electronic Devices Draft SWP
Chairman Quin stated that
the AOC is not under obligation to make decision
s
regarding th
ese
SWP
’
s
tonight as
they
will not return to the EC until May.
Chief Tobia stated that the Social Media Draft SWP and the Use of Personal Electronic Devices
were both developed at the direction of Chief Brower. Chief Tobia advised that
,
currently, a
County policy does not exist. Further, Chief Tobia stated that a number of companies have
created their own social media as well as use of personal electronic devices policies. Tobia
shared that these two policies were developed out of research conducted by Matt Schultz as
part of his Bachelor
’
s program and capstone project. Chief Tobia relayed that Matt spent two
years looking at issues relating to the use of social media and personal electronic devices and
their
impact on fire and emergency services.
Chief Tobia stated without question, we are all at risk. Chief Tobia explained that we are all
instrumentalities of the County. We are all equally responsible in sharing in the protection of our
collective reputations. There are numerous examples whereby individuals sought to destroy the
reputation of their organization on social media. Chief Tobia asserted that many members in the
system are millennials and they have lived according to electronic devices. Chief Tobia stated
that it was perfectly natural for them to think they can use their personal electronic devices to
capture protected health information and then reference back to it when they are completing
their patient care report. Chief Tobia explained that problem is that they are taking HIPAA
sensitive information and they are carrying it with them wherever their phone goes. In addition,
Chief Tobia stated that oftentimes, organizations do not have policies and procedures or
expectations about the manner in which those individuals control, delete and protect that
information. Beyond reputation issues, Chief Tobia submitted there are very real financial
implications when lawsuits are brought with regard to HIPAA violations.
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
April 14
,
201
6
Page
4
of
9
Chief Tobia shared feedback he received regarding a recommendation that will be incorporated
to include business appropriate uses for personal electronic devices (ex. Epocrates or Mapping).
According to Chief Tobia, over the past year, there have been several instances in which system
members have conducted themselves in a way that is out of concert with the expectations of
the system. Chief Tobia stated that the reality is that system members are actually very good
about policing the conduct that they find to be completely out of the expected code of conduct.
Chief Tobia explained that the intent is not to prevent any company from creating a policy
that
is more restrictive.
As a system, however, a common set of expectations needs to be
established. Chief Tobia stated that oftentimes, there are individuals who conduct themselves in
a way that is completely blind to them in terms of what is and what is not acceptable from a
protected health information standpoint. Likewise, these policies do not seek to restrict
anyone
’
s ability
to highlight the very good work of their companies (ex. training, fundraising,
community outreach activities).
If, for example, Chief Tobia explained, you have a company photographer who goes to the scene
of a call and stands where the public is standing and where the public has access, then there is
no restriction on that individual
’
s ability to take photographs. However, if the photographer
arrives on the scene, identifies himself as a member of the system and gets access to the scene
that the members of the public do not have access to, then the intent would be that the policy
would be applicable. Photographs can be forensically evaluated for metadata to evaluate where
the call was and identify the location, time and date of the incident that could subsequently be
used to identify the patient that was involved in the incident.
Tragically, Tobia stated that
families have learned of the death of their loved ones through social media because emergency
responders have posted the photograph of the scene.
Chief Tobia explained that we can control
that we do not become the source of that information.
Chief Tobia stated that feedback has already been received and any suggestions are welcome.
The policies will not be operationalized without training. Guidance regarding the intent of the
policies will be provided.
It should be noted that there is a mechanism by which, for example, you want to take pictures
at the scene of a motor vehicle collision to provide mechanism of injury information. Chief Tobia
stated that the recommendation in this case would be that the companies provide a department
issued/company issued digital camera and that the digital camera is an official device for which
official purposes are used only. The device could then be used to transmit the information to the
physicians at the hospital and then those photographs can then be destroyed/deleted. Chief
Tobia clarified that there is an archival process as well. Chief Tobia explained that if a
photograph is taken with a personal device then that device can become
“
FOIAable
”
. Further,
anything that occurred during that emergency incident for which you used that personal device
could be
“
FOIAable
”
.
Discussion ensued regarding the contradiction between the two policies. The question was
posed, Does there need to be two separate policies or can these two be combined? Aaron Kahn
also noted that Company 14 finds the policies far too restrictive and show a lack of recognition
in regard to how the volunteer companies operate.
Aaron Kahn stated that if we are truly a
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
April 14
,
201
6
Page
5
of
9
combination system, then it would have been helpful to have volunteer input when this policy
was first being drafted as opposed to seeing the drafts as completed drafts. Aaron stated there
may be a lot less work in the long term if there was some understanding
of how the volunteer
companies that are part of LC-CFRS view these issues.
Aaron Kahn stated that the way LC-CFRS is defined, it includes all memb
er organizations so in
theory
, C
ompany 14 is not authorized to utilize social media for even non-emergency capacities.
Any other social media accounts are considered personal use
,
according to Aaron
. Aaron stated
14 has twitter, F
acebook,
and a
blog and Aaron disagrees with those being personal use. Aaron
clarified by stating they are not LCFR use, but they are certainly not personal. Chief Tobia
brought Aaron
’
s attention to section 12 in the social media policy which
talks about s
ystem
affiliated entities who operate their own social media platforms
.
Chief Tobia stated inherent in
that statement is the ability to have the social media platforms in the first place. Aaron stated
there was a contradiction
between section 12 and
sections 2 and 3. Chief Tobia validated
Aaron
’
s point.
Aaron states that he finds the social media policy to be more troublesome
because many of the companies, if not all, utilize social media. Aaron stated that having LCFR
regulate the use and personal use of social media makes him uncomfortable. Chief Tobia shared
that there needed to be a starting point. Chief Tobia stated that Matt Shultz has been in the
system for over 18 years and as a Volunteer Chief and as a Volunteer Rescue Squad Member
speaks to the fact that he wasn
’
t speaking blindly about the impact this policy would have on
system organizations.
Discussion also took place regarding on duty verses off duty, the enforcement of the policy,
patient care
,
HIPAA Violations
and free speech
.
Chairman Quin believes there will be a good deal of angst, in his company, regarding how this
will play out amongst the members. Chairman Quin recommended that AOC members share the
policies with their Boards and membership.
Chief Tobia reiterated to all to send written comments prior to the May AOC meeting so that
there is an opportunity to respond and provide feedback. Aaron Kahn suggested that it may be
helpful to consider adding additional definitions, such as to define
“
actual harm or disruption
”
.
Questions also arose regarding whether or not the County plans on regulating volunteers like
they are employees.
Chief Tobia shared that volunteers are already regulated, to some extent,
as employees by virtue of being an instrumentality of the County as well as through Workers
Compensation.
Chairman Quin asked for written comments to be submitted a week before the next AOC
meeting.
Awards and Recognition Draft SWP
Chairman Quin stated that this SWP will not return to the EC until May, 2016.
Chief Tobia pointed out that this SWP does not
affect any individual company
’
s policies and
procedures with regard to presenting awards at their annual banquets or within their own
companies. Chief Tobia stated eventually, an intent will be to hold a medal day or a day of
recognition. Chief Tobia shared that there will be an on-line nominating system whereby the
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
April 14
,
201
6
Page
6
of
9
entire process can be done electronically.
In addition, there will be opportunities that will be
open to both career and volunteer personnel.
Chief Tobia stated that, in addition, there will be
opportunities for people to receive certificates as opposed to ribbons as acknowledgment of an
accomplishment or action. Chief Tobia asserted that the intent for the committee members of
the Ad-Hoc Committee will become the members of the review committee.
According to Chief Tobia, t
he Chamber of Commerce Valor Awards are already in place and
nothing changes in regard to that banquet
, however, by including it in the SWP, we are
recognizing that it has been established
. Chief Tobia shared that we just recognized 59 members
of our system
at the annual Valor Awards Banquet.
Chief Tobia clarified that this SWP is meant to be more comprehensive, system wide and also
capture in one place what has thus far what has been pockets of award programs. Eventually,
per Chief Tobia, the Deener-Carr Awards may become the Deener-Carr County wide system
awards program in which additional awards from the SWP will also be given out. Chief Tobia
stated that the hope is that the end result may be just one awards ceremony
.
Chief Tobia asked all to share their comments directly with Chief Johnson. Chairman Quin
reminded AOC members to share the SWP with their Boards and membership.
Action Item
/New Business:
NFPA 1582 Physicals
Chairman Quin motioned that the AOC approve the Volunteer Physicals SWP as written in
attachment 5A of the AOC packet. The motion was seconded by Andy Gode. No further
discussion ensued. The motion carried.
AOC
Meeting Date, Time and Location
Chairman Quin stated 11 out of 16 voted for a central location for AOC meetings. Chair Quin
shared that 9 voted for a meeting time of 1900
while 4 voted for a 1930 start time. Chairman
Quin advised that the second Thursday of the month received 10 votes. JJ Brown made a motion
that the AOC hold meetings at 7pm on the second Thursday of each month at 801 Sycolin Road.
The motion was seconded by
Andy
.
Discussion ensued regarding calling in to the meeting and/or sending representatives. Chief
Tobia offered that the motion was centered on time, date and location whereby the other issue
that has arisen points to the by-laws of the AOC which defines attendance at meetings.
Additional discussion also occurred regarding the start time of the meetings. A friendly
amendment to the motion followed
to include a start time of 1930. This was seconded by Andy.
The motion carried and AOC meetings will be held at 1930 the second Thursday of each month
at 801 Sycolin Road.
Chair Quin clarified that we will leave the issue of people calling in wide open. Chief Tobia
recommended that the AOC by-laws stand as written and that further, physical attendance of
the meeting should occur and one can send a proxy if needed upon written notification. Aaron
Kahn reiterated that having a conference call was not an issue, however, voting and having a
quorum might be the issue. Aaron Kahn requested that Chief Tobia inquire at the County
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
April 14
,
201
6
Page
7
of
9
Attorney
’
s Office. Chief Tobia stated that until a determination is received by the County
Attorney
’
s Office, that the AOC operate according to their by-laws.
Information Sharing Across Volunteer Councils and Committees
Andy Gode
inquired about electronic LED signs at stations. Please provide vendor information as
he is examining costs.
Philomont Horse show will occur on 4/23/16.
Bernie advised of road changes along route 50.
Chairman Quin congratulated Jen Ferguson on her Valor recognition.
Arcola hosted a Town Hall for Chair Randall and it was very successful. JJ Brown stated the
community was supportive.
Company 4 hosted Congresswoman Comstock and Town and County leadership were present. It
was a good exchange of information.
Purcellville will be hosting Personal Public Safety Day on the 15
th
of May.
Purcellville has formally started the process to be a training center for AHA. Aaron Kahn stated it
will take a few months to get through their entire review process, but it is their intent to open it
to all companies. Aaron stated they will be charging only face value of what the AHA charges
them for the electronic cards.
Aaron Kahn stated Purcellville has also started the process to begin their own exchange
program
. Aaron stated that they ha
ve
been heavily involved in the
VAVRS
firefighter exchange
program for years. Aaron stated that they only received $75 from VAVRS to cover expenses for
firefighters from Germany for eight days. In addition and according to Aaron, they do not
provide anything to Germany for hosting our members. Aaron stated that they have begun talks
through the Marshall Foundation regarding establishing their own program. Aaron stated that
the intent would be to open it up to any of the volunteer organizations who wish to participate
assuming costs are shared.
Aaron stated that
he hopes the County is working toward allowing BLS providers to use NARCAN.
He stated
an incident occurred last week whereby NARCAN
was given to a member of the crew
by a deputy. The member handed the NARCAN back to the deputy and informed him he had to
use it. It should be noted that the deputy was surprised that the member could not give
NARCAN and the NARCAN did end up saving the patient
’
s life.
Recruitment and Retention Committee
-
Nothing to report.
DFREM
-
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
April 14
,
201
6
Page
8
of
9
CIP Apparatus and Facility Requests
Chief Tobia reminded all that capital apparatus and facility requests are due June 1
st
. If you have
a piece of apparatus that is scheduled for replacement and you want to take advantage of the
59/41 funding algorithm, please submit by June 1
st
. If one should desire a copy of the policy,
please let Chief Tobia know. Please ensure your letter covers the components of the policy in
terms of what information is being requested. These requests are for FY18.
Budget
Chief Tobia shared that the County passed a budget
at $1.145, a one cent increase over last year.
They fully funded the 6.3 million dollars for the County Funding Algorithm. In addition, they fully
funded the 3 million dollar CIP which is now being funded through local tax dollars as opposed
to bond funding which makes monies available July 1. Chief Tobia stated there were three
enhancements that were passed, one being a full time medical director which will be an RFP
process. Chief Tobia shared that Dr. Morgan has done a tremendous job and has given us far
more than part time hours for many years. Chief Tobia shared that we expect that several
medical groups will bid that project and then assign one individual to be the medical director.
The theory is that if Dr. Morgan
’
s medical group of physicians would bid it, then Dr. Morgan
would be the medical director. Chief Tobia also informed the group that a QA/QI person will be
obtained. Currently, according to Chief Tobia, we are
“
QA
-
ing
”
about 5% of our total EMS calls.
Ideally, we should be
“
QA
-
ing
”
100% of the calls. Chief Tobia stated the third enhancement was
an HR admin position.
Chief Tobia explained that there was no enhancement put forward for
staffing of Kirkpatrick Farms due to the fact that it is expected that the station will not
operationalize until February of 2018. As a result, it was thought that positions could be hired
after July 1
st
of FY 18 to be able to get those folks through recruit training, out in the field and
ready to provide service when the station opens. Chief Tobia relayed that Station 27 will be
going out for bid for a construction company at the end of this month.
CAD
Chief Tobia stated that CAD was originally supposed to go love on May 24
th
, however, it has
been delayed. Chief Tobia it may be delayed until the end of summer. Chief Tobia explained that
the issue is that Motorola has identified an issue with GPS locating of vehicles when they are
inside of stations. The solution will cost some money and the County is prepared to pick up the
cost. The solution will involve placing a GPS antenna on every piece of equipment. Chief Tobia
shared that the antenna will allow for automatic vehicle locating and appropriate mapping. It
also relates to the connectivity of mobile CAD.
Announcements-
Lovettsville will hold their 50
th
anniversary celebration this year in November.
Arcola
’
s 60
th
anniversary celebration will occur in January.
Middleburg Celebration
Chief Tobia shared that there will be a celebration of service at Middleburg Volunteer Fire
Company on May 7
th
. The intent is to hold a formal passing of the torch ceremony. There will be
a memorialization of the 80 years of service to the community.
The dissolution has not been
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
April 14
,
201
6
Page
9
of
9
finalized. Chief Tobia asked that each company send a representative to help them celebrate
their lifetime of service.
A
djournmen
t
There being
no further business to discuss,
t
he meeting was adjourned at
2
1
49
hours
.
The n
ext
Administrative Operations
Committee meeting will be held on
T
hurs
day,
May
12
,
201
6
at 1930
hours
at
801 Sycolin Road, DTCI Large
Conference Room
.
Respectfully submitted:
Christine Langley-Obaugh, M.Ed., CVA
Executive Liaison
Source: Loudoun County website. First collected Oct 5, 2026.