_02112016-574
Loudoun County · Loudoun County · meeting of Feb 11, 2016 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Loudoun County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Administrative Operations
Committee
Minutes
February 11
, 201
6
The
February
meeting of the
Administrative Operations
Committee was held on Thur
sday
February 1
1
,
201
6
with Company
9
hosting
.
C
hairman
Quin
presided and called the meeting to
order
at
19
3
7
hours. The following were in attendance
:
Co. 1
Absent
Co. 2
Brad Quin
Co. 4
John Moring
Co. 5
John Malone
Co. 6
Jimmy Olevson/Don Graham
Co. 7
Excused
Co. 8
Eric Shank
Co. 9
J
ay
J Brown
Co. 10
Bob Akers
Co. 11
Andy Gode
Co.
12
Ryan Spencer
Co. 13
Jim Cromer
Co. 14
Aaron Kahn
Co. 15
Jen Ferguson
Co. 17
Absent
LCFR:
AC Matt Tobia
,
Christine Langley-Obaugh
Guests:
Gary Myers (Chaplain Committee Chairman)
Brian Be
e
be (DIT)
Minutes
Motion:
Motion
made to approve
the
January 21
, 201
6
minutes
with amendments
by
Aaron Kahn
and s
econded
by
J
immy Olevson
,
Company
6
.
Vote:
Approved
with a vote of
1
2
-0
-
0
-
3
.
Special Presentation on Cyber Security by Brian Bebee
Chair Quin asserted that systems may be vulnerable to issues associated with inappropriate
access. The connection with the County System may also breed similar challenges. Don stated
that it was his IT team, who are senior people in the industry that advised of liabilities and
responsibilities regarding the records kept at the Company level.
Thus, Brian Be
e
be, DIT Security
Manager in Loudoun County, was brought in to present on Cyber Security.
Brian Beebe focused on three components as the goal is to provide quality and timely
delivery of IT services in a
secure
manner:
(1)
Cybersecurity
in general
(2)
Cybersecurity
in the context of F&R Station IT practices
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
February 11,
201
6
Page
2
of
8
(3)
Cybersecurity
in the context of the impending F&R Volunteer program (i.e. secure access
to
email
, Orion, Summit7, and Alpine)
Should you have additional questions or need to reach Brian, his email address is
Brian.Beebe@loudoun.gov
and his work phone is (703) 771-5476.
Please note the cyber security presentation has been forwarded to all AOC members. Should
anyone desire a copy of the presentation, please contact Christine at
Christine.l.obaugh@loudoun.gov
.
Chaplain By-Laws, Procedural Manual and SWP:
Chair Quin stated that the Chaplain
’
s Committee planned to go to the EC this month provided
each of the sub-committees approve the by-laws, procedural manual and SWP.
Gary Myers submitted that the EMSOC unanimously approved the documents with one change
in the Chaplain
’
s procedural manual on page 10 under transporting others.
Gary mentioned that
“
sponsoring agency leadership
”
would take the place of
“
Chief
”
. Gary
also emphasized
that Law
Enforcement was consulted with regard to the procedural manual.
Discussion ensued reference
page 5: Demonstrate maturity and judgement
…
in that, how would one rate these types of
standards. Gary Myers stated that through their assessments as well as feedback sought and
received and on-going monitoring, they will determine if standards are met. Aaron Kahn stated
regarding general qualifications
(page 5)
,
the wording reads: must be ordained, licensed as
clergy or lay person acceptable to their Church. Aaron asserted that Loudoun County is diverse
and was concerned that membership may just be limited to Christians. Gary Myers answered
that as long as one is in good standing and of moral character and has a letter from their
organization, then they can be granted into the Chaplain
’
s Program. The
wording
:
“
You must
demonstrate you are in good standing with your religious organization
or must be licensed as a
religious leader in your denomination or a lay person who can provide a letter of good standing
from their
denomination
leader
”
would be acceptable according to the AOC. Jen Ferguson
asserted a recommended change to read:
“
must be ordained, licensed as clergy or religious
leader in your denomination, or a layperson acceptable to their religious organization to work as
a Chaplain in the community
”
.
Jay J. Brown made a motion that the policy be endorsed with the
recommended change from EMSOC as well as what was added by the AOC. Aaron Kahn
seconded the motion. Motion passed with no one opposed.
Update of Key Issues
:
Executive Committee Update
:
Chief Tobia relayed that regarding the EMS Cost Recovery Financial Hardship Waiver SWP,
Danielle was asked to come forward with examples of alternate hardship policies as some EC
members had some concerns.
Chief Tobia stated that the Station Security and Equipment SWP passed unanimously. In
addition, the EC has formed an ad-hoc committee to address one of the strategic goals in the
current strategic plan on heavy rescue service delivery.
Lastly, Chief Tobia stated that a Dispatch
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
February 11,
201
6
Page
3
of
8
Algorithm Committee has been established. Several system members had been discussing for
some time a desire to see some revisions to the dispatch algorithm. (Chief Tobia announced that
new CAD will go live on or about May 24
th
).
Katie
Clarke is a temporary employee who has been hired by the County to fill Elizabeth
’
s
position doing HR centric issues for volunteers. The position will be reclassified, advertised and
filled. Lauren Hartman continues to do a tremendous job full time on volunteer recruitment and
retention.
Subcommittee Reports
:
Background Process Subcommittee Survey Monkey
:
Jamil Scott was not present thus no report was provided.
LOSAP/Benefits:
John Moring advised that there is no update as a meeting has not been held.
Discussion Topics
Fundraising Letter Boundary Language
:
Chair Quin reminded the AOC that a question was initially raised by Ed Carmichael concerning
second dues and whether or not the language in the letters was proper. Aaron Kahn stated that
the language in the letter is fine
and that
he would recommend no changes. Aaron reiterated
that
an
issue
can occur
when two companies cover the same area
, however, it is covered in sub
5 of the FRG, specifically that one
’
s fundraising material must clearly identify the companies, the
primary response company for fire service or EMS. The additional concern raised concerned
companies going into an area that is covered by a career owned and operated station. That
issue is also covered by sub 5:
“
If an area is served by a station that is both County
Owned and staffed exclusively with career personnel the solicitation will indicate that the area is
served by County resources and that the funds raised would be used by the next due company
to support volunteer operations
”
.
Aaron Kahn mentioned that as there are no changes, a vote was not required.
Update 3.6.1 Hearing Policy
:
The updated document with corrections and language changes was distributed among the AOC
members for review.
An issue
arose
regarding
what the SCS can actually hear
(as it is stated in
the ordinance) if a company appeals to the SCS about one
’
s possible membership.
Aaron relayed
that his hope is that no one will ask the SCS this question as no one sees a reason why a
company would come to the SCS and ask whether they are allowed to accept a member.
Aaron
mentioned that 1a was simplified and reduced from a paragraph to a sentence.
A question arose regarding the change from
“
serious misconduct
”
to
“
misconduct
”
. Chief Tobia
explained that if a member does something defined under misconduct, then the expectation is
that it is a system wide notification, meaning the EC and the System Chief.
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
February 11,
201
6
Page
4
of
8
One change on page 3,
“
If a member is reinstated system wide, he/she member
…”
should be
changed to
“
the member
”
.
Someone also inquired about whether a change was needed for
“
a
member may be reinstated by other volunteer companies
”
. Chief Tobia stated that phrase
should not change because if a member of Sterling Fire is suspended, but he is also a member at
Sterling Rescue, it would not be encouraged to bind the hands of Sterling Rescue and
automatically reinstate that member without having the benefit of first being notified and
second agreeing to it. Aaron stated once they lift the system wide suspension, it will then fall
under the Companies disciplinary policies.
Aaron moved that SWP 3.6.1 is approved, as amended. The motion was seconded and the
motion carried. It should be noted that no one opposed.
Summary of Plan Provisions
:
John
M
oring
reminded the AOC that a survey was conducted on the LOSAP program and there
were a number of outcomes. One specific outcome was that there was not a great deal of
information available to the volunteers regarding the LOSAP program. Additionally, only three
sentences appear about the program on the
Answer the Call
website. Thus, a recommendation
was that a one or two page document be developed for the volunteers. Penflex representatives
attended the last meeting and as they administer the LOSAP program, they volunteered
to
prepare the document. An integral part of the program description was about how to become
vested as well as beneficiary information. John recommended that the document attached be
disseminated for comments. Jay J. Brown stated he believed the document went before the R&R
committee last night.
Chair Quin advised the AOC if anyone has comments or suggestions to please provide them to
John and he can take them to the LOSAP Committee. At this time, John will advise Karen that
the watermark can be removed so the document can be disseminated.
For additional information, one can call 1-800-742-1409 or
www.penflexinc.com
Chaplain By-Laws, Procedural Manual and SWP:
See above.
Action Item
/New Business:
Request by Aaron Kahn
Aaron stated the he will be making a motion dealing with the budget, which will be to institute a
$250,000 floor that will apply to those companies that still operate on a volunteer basis at least
seven days a week for twelve hours a day. The reason is because of his company
’
s own
experience through the algorithm. Aaron asserted that the solution does not just assist his
company, it assists other smaller companies with low levels of expenses, particularly company
17, and company 12 which squeaked by with $3,000 more than the $250,000 minimum.
Aaron mentioned that there is an understanding that if
a company
’
s
costs are lower, then
the
company will
get less
money
than companies who have higher costs. According to Aaron, the
problem was that they reported $337,000 in costs and received $150,000 this year. Aaron
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
February 11,
201
6
Page
5
of
8
advised that when the rest of the budget items are added in, that brings the entire annual
budget down to $225,000 which is unsustainable. Aaron stated that they cannot run a twenty
four a day seven day a week operation on $225,000. Aaron emphasized that is over $100,000
less than what they spent last year. Aaron relayed that because the budget has been cut, they
are actually putting off maintenance and cutting other items. Aaron reported they are looking at
pulling a huge amount out of their reserves. Aaron submitted that if they continued receiving
$150,000 in the future, then, they would be filing for bankruptcy in approximately three years.
Aaron emphasized that their reserves are not that big to take that much of a hit on a multi-year
basis. Since the budget has been cut, Aaron stated that they are spending less
,
which means
t
hey will show more savings going into the next budget cycle.
Aaron
’
s point of view is that t
his
formula
(
everyone entered into this in good faith and his company voted for it as well
)
rewards
spending
and harms those who save.
Aaron reiterated that e
xpenses were cut by approximately
25% by putting everything through a bid process.
Aaron emphasized that t
he $337,000 they
reported is not an anomaly
.
Aaron advised that the number will not be larger unless they
purchase a new ambulance or a new chase. In Aaron
’
s
opinion
, a 3-5 year average would only
help in the
short term because in the long term their numbers will still be exceedingly low
compared to many other companies.
Aaron stated that a
floor is not unlike what is used in the ATL funding algorithm. It ensures that
if you save money or have low expenses, you won
’
t be cut below a level which is
sustainable to
keep your company operating.
Aaron asserted that t
o institute this floor does not harm any
company.
Aaron surmised that i
f the floor was instituted last year,
then
it would have cost
$110,000.
Aaron submitted that
Middleburg, a company that doesn
’
t even exist, is receiving
$170,000 this year.
Aaron stated
that one
could look at the money it would take to institute this
f
loor as the money from Middleburg. Aaron stated that we
would
not
be
taking money
from
a
nyone else to create this floor.
Aaron stated he agreed that this may not be the perfect result. This would, however, give
Aaron
’
s Company the certainty it needs that they are not going to be harmed again.
Aaron
suggested that i
f the budget sub-committee comes up with something better that makes
more sense,
then the AOC
should
vote on that. This
proposal, according to Aaron,
allows 12, 14,
and 17 to go back to their Boards and Officers and say that they are at least going to have a
minimum level of funding necessary to sustain operations.
MOTION: Aaron Kahn moved that the AOC institute a floor on the County funding Algorithm
of $250,000. Said floor will only apply to those Companies still operational on a seven day a
week twelve hour a day basis or more and it will not apply to any Company whose expenses
fall below $250,000. The motion was seconded.
Discussion
ensued. The request for the Budget Sub-Committee to run two proposals surfaced.
President Quin asked the AOC to recall that there are approximately twenty categories of
expense and approximately fourteen categories of income and not all of them are part of the
algorithm. Certain categories were selected by the budget sub-committee because they were
thought to be and what was theoretically perceived as the drivers for your expenses. It so
happened, according to Chair Quin, that when the balls fell into those slots, their numbers were
significantly lower than other people in those same slots so when the algorithm handle got
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
February 11,
201
6
Page
6
of
8
turned, those were the results. Chairman Quin reminded the AOC that the
algorith
m
’
s purpose
is to calculate the respective costs of operation of each company with data supplied by each to
determine each company
’
s percentage of the total cost of all volunteer operations. That
percentage is then applied to the county contrition at the same percentage. Since the county
contribution is less than the total cost of company operations a
‘
funding gap
’
exists overall
and
for each company.
That gap will continue unless operating expenses drop and company income
increases, or if the County increases its contribution to cover all operating costs.
Chairman Quin stated that he has no issue with the Budget Sub-Committee reviewing this
particular proposal or any subsequent response that the budget sub-committee thinks that is
appropriate that accommodates the concern that Aaron has. Chair Quin would prefer, and he
has spoken with Dave Short (Chair of the Budget Sub-Committee) to advise him that this issue
may come before the AOC for consideration of a vote, that the budget sub-committee have an
opportunity to examine probable solutions. It should be noted Dave Short concurs per Chairman
Quin. Chair Quin advised that the plan for the Budget Sub-committee was to engage
this month
and next month and return to the AOC with a recommendation in March or April as to if any
changes would occur. Data will begin to be collected from the companies in May
,
so in early
June everyone has awareness regarding what the numbers will look like.
A final cut with the
final data comes before the AOC in August. According to Chairman Quin, those numbers were
approved by the AOC and the EC with no objection from Company 14
in June or later in
August
or at any time
.
In two of the previous three years adjustments were made, some dramatic, to
the outcomes initially produced by the algorithm and before final adoption to address similar
issues raised by individual companies.
Chair
man
Quin would implore
the members of the AOC
to consider having the Budget Sub-Committee review this material
and
propose
r
ecommendations
before mandating an arbitrary floor be established of $250,000
.
Aaron Kahn stated that Company 14 did not protest last year because they did not think anyone
would be interested in revisiting the issue at the same time a vote was being called and
companies were anticipating payments. Aaron stated, thus the reason for bringing it up this
fiscal year. In addition, Aaron Kahn relayed that the issue was also brought forward in
November. Aaron emphasized that this is not the first time the issue has been brought to the
attention of the AOC, with the exception of those that are new to the committee. Aaron stated
he did make attempts to reach out to people to advise of the situation.
Aaron stated that he believed that there was enough information to institute the minimum
while the Budget-Sub-Committee does their work. Aaron relayed that his Company recorded
$337,000 in expenses. Aaron emphasized that $250,000, if it were come to pass, still would not
make his company whole. Aaron
’
s opinion is that the algorithm makes no one company whole.
Aaron reiterated that $250,000 leaves his company with approximately $87,000 with town
contribution which is $45,000 a year and fundraising. Aaron stated grants are an insignificant for
their company
’
s income, only amounting to approximately $10,000 or less.
Chairman Quin
reminded the group that the intent of the distribution was not and cannot be to make
companies whole with respect to their operating expenses over income if overall expenses
exceed that which the County makes available in funding (see above).
Aaron
’
s relayed that only certain forms of income are acceptable into the algorithm. He further
stated that they accept everything except for capital expenditures as expenses. Further, Aaron
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
February 11,
201
6
Page
7
of
8
stated that an examination is not done to reveal whether expenses were necessary or prudently
incurred.
President Quin stated that Aaron was technically correct, however, he asked the AOC members
to recall that everyone was asked to supply the information publically when the process was
established. Further, the spreadsheet is shared amongst all Companies.
Chair Quin stated the
reasoning behind that was to ensure transparency as well as to be able to examine any
differences
or anomalies that would indicate a problem with the process.
Further, Chairman
Quin noted that adding back excluded income categories would have the effect of reducing even
more the allocation for each company
.
Discussion arose regarding how the $250,000 floor was determined. Aaron answered by stating
that the $250,000 is two thirds of their company
’
s expenses. Chair Quin reminded the AOC that
previously there was a floor in the old algorithm and unfortunately, the floor did not work.
President Quin asked that the AOC conclude the matter and asked for Aaron to repeat
the motion.
Aaron so moved to institute into the County Funding Algorithm a $250,000 floor which is
applicable only to those companies operating volunteer on at least a seven day a week
twelve hour a day basis and who
’
s expenses exceed $250,000.
The question was posed: All expenses across the board? Aaron stated except for
c
apital
e
xpenses that don
’
t count now. Aaron further stated either way, those would just add to it, so
we can go with that as well.
Vote:
1: Absent
2: Nay
4: Yea
5: Nay
6: Nay
7: Absent
8: Nay
9: Nay
10: Absent
11: Yea
12: Yea
13: Yea
14: Yea
15: Yea
Chairman Quin announced w
ith 6
“
Yea
’
s
”
,
the motion passes
.
Information Sharing Across Volunteer Councils and Committees
Administrative Operations Committee
Minutes
February 11,
201
6
Page
8
of
8
Recruitment and Retention Committee
-
None
DFREM
-
Chief Tobia stated he came from Finance Government Services and Economic
Development meeting where a conversation with Mr. Hemstreet occurred. Chief Tobia stated
that Mr. Hemstreet has included in his proposed budget for the upcoming year at the base with
no change in the tax rate and no change in the County
’
s contribution to county funding for
volunteer companies. Chief Tobia explained that this means that even if the BOS voted no tax
increase whatsoever, the number we are working with currently is the number we will be
working with in the coming fiscal year. As budget deliberations, recognize that no increase in the
County tax rate will not adversely affect any of the programs that are currently in place including
the three million dollar CIP funding for apparatus program as well as the annual County
algorithm.
Chief Tobia stated that Middleburg will not be eligible for County algorithm in the coming fiscal
year. Regarding Middleburg, Chief Tobia stated that there will continue to be expenses
associated with the operation of that station that were not budgeted, so the costs associated
with that will continue to be drawn from their current fiscal year funding allotment. That money
will remain in escrow until such time that the Company concludes its dissolution and/or turns
the building over to the County in which case they end up with no expenses whatsoever. At that
time, the escrowed amount of money will come back into the algorithm and be made available
as a one-time redistribution in whatever fiscal year it then appears.
Everyone is aware that there is a lawsuit pending against the Company and the County. There
was a plea on that subject in January and a jury trial will occur in June.
Announcements-
Chair Quin announced that
Chief Tobia will meet with the next five companies involved in the
audit process
after tonight
’
s meeting
which
will
include 10, 11,
12,
14
and 17.
A
djournmen
t
There being
no further business to discuss,
t
he meeting was adjourned at
2
216
hours
.
The n
ext
Administrative Operations
Committee meeting will be held on
T
hurs
day,
March 10
,
201
6
at 1930
hours
at
611, Sterling Volunteer Fire
.
Respectfully submitted:
Christine Langley-Obaugh, M.Ed., CVA
Executive Liaison
Source: Loudoun County website. First collected Oct 5, 2026.