RecordWell Data

Board of Historic and Architectural Review Regular Meeting Agenda (PDF)

City of Chesapeake · Chesapeake City County · meeting of Oct 1, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Chesapeake

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

HISTORIC & ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD October 1, 2026 Board of Historic and Architectural Review October 1, 2026 Public Safety Operations Center 2130 S Military Hwy, Chesapeake, VA 23320 5:30 PM A. Call To Order B. Roll Call C. Approval of September 3 regular meeting minutes. D. Committee Reports E. Administrative Approvals F. Zoning Report G. Old and New Business a. Chesapeake Land Bank (CLBA) updates H. Consent Agenda Items I. Regular Agenda Items 1. 1312 Chesapeake Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-081) Replacement of existing front door, storm door, and transom window. 2. 1120 Jackson Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-094) Installation of a wheelchair lift on front porch. 3. 1016 Park Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-104) Replacement of existing double-hung wood windows with new vinyl windows. J. Public Input K. Legal Guidance L. Adjournment These applications and related documents are available for public review on the Planning Department’s website through the following link: https://www.cityofchesapeake.net/AgendaCenter/Board-of-Historic-Architectural- Review-4 The City of Chesapeake will provide reasonable accommodations and services necessary for sensory-impaired and disabled persons by contacting the Facilities Maintenance Administrator, Public Works at (757) 382-8951 at least three-working days in advance and language assistance to individuals with limited English proficiency to the extent possible by contacting the Planning Department at (757) 382-6176 at least 10 days in advance of this meeting. *While his is not a public hearing, the public and any one or several members of the Chesapeake City Council may choose to attend. 1 1 Meeting Minutes Historic and Architectural Review Board (HARB) September 3, 2026 Portlock Galleries at SoNo ROLL CALL HARB Members Present: Chair Frank Lilley, Vice Chair Scott Grinels, Ervin Young, Kaydee Moore. Dave Walski Staff: Anna Nagorniuk, Recording Secretary – Planning Department; Jessica Hadley, Assistant City Attorney – City Attorney’s Office; Carlos Rodriguez, Code Enforcement Officer – Developments and Permits; Anna Nagorniuk, Recording Secretary – Planning Department; Nat McCormick, Community Designer Manager – Planning Department Chair F. Lilley called the meeting to order at 5:34 p.m. MINUTES Approval of August 6 regular meeting minutes. Motion to approve the regular minutes as standing made by E. Young and seconded by K. Moore, with all members present voting for (5-0). COMMITTEE REPORTS None. ADMINISTRATIVE APPROVALS A. Nagorniuk reported eight (8) administrative approvals since the August 6 meeting. ZONING REPORT None. OLD AND NEW BUSINESS a.a. Chesapeake Land Bank (CLBA) updates N. McCormick reported on two (2) grant applications considered at the September Chesapeake Land Bank Authority meeting; one included a property outside of the Local Historic District but within the National Historic District. Both were approved. CONSENT AGENDA None. REGULAR AGENDA 1.1. 1136 Rodgers Street (PLN-CAPP-2026-083) Original Request Extend side concrete driveway. · Motion to approve the COA as presented made by S. Grinels and seconded by D. Walski, with all members present voting for (5-0). 2.2. 1020 Park Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-048) Original Request Replacement of existing wood and aluminum windows with vinyl windows with simulated divided lites. · Motion to approve the application as is made by K. Moore and seconded by S. Grinels, with all members present voting for (4-0). 2 2 3.3. 1203 Seaboard Avenue (PLN-CAPP-2026-079) Original Request Removal of awnings; replacement of existing wood and aluminum windows with vinyl windows;; removal of exterior metal plumbing pipes. · Discussion of the condition of the existing wooden windows, window styles and appropriate sizing, existing awnings, and the metal piping on exterior of the home. · Applicant proposed the following modifications to the application: keep/restore existing metal awnings; keep/restore existing front 1-over-1 wooden windows; replace other existing windows with vinyl 1-over-1 and slider windows; remove existing exterior metal piping. · Motion to approve the modifications by the applicant made by E. Young and seconded by F. Lilley, with all members present voting for (5-0). · Motion to accept the modifications and application made by F. Lilley and seconded by E. Young, with all members present voting for (5-0). PUBLIC INPUT None. LEGAL GUIDANCE None. ADJOURNMENT Motion to adjourn the meeting made by D. Walski and seconded by F. Lilley, with all members present voting yes (5-0). Meeting adjourned at 6:44 p.m. MEETING MINUTES APPROVED: _________________ _ 1312 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-081 1 Sta Report Version September 22, 2026 Proposal Replacement of existing storm door, modern front door, and wooden transom window. Address 1312 Chesapeake Avenue Year Built c. 19190000 (Contributing) Applicant Audra Swift After-the-Fact Yes" No # Owner Audra Swift Special Power of Attorney Yes " No # HARB Hearing Date October 1, 2026 Sta Planner Anna Nagorniuk Application Address 1312 Chesapeake Avenue Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-081 Sta Recommendation Approval 1312 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-081 2 Aerial Map 1312 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-081 3 Project Proposal Applicant is proposing the following replacements: 1.1. Replacement of existing storm door with full-view aluminum storm door; 2.2. Replacement of existing modern oval-lite door with new steel half-lite 2-panel door; 3.3. Replacement of existing wooden above-door transom with custom aluminum transom window. South Norfolk Design Guidelines Doors 2. Existing modern doors can be replaced with a di erent door style, provided it is compatible with the style of the building. a. Only replace historic doors that cannot be repaired; avoid wholesale replacement of all historic doors in a building. b. If replacement in-kind is not possible, the following criteria for historic door replacement apply: i. Replacement doors should match the historic doors as closely as possible in general composition, shape, size, profile, glass usage, pane division, muntin type, glazing, texture, and finish. ii. Replacement should be limited to the door itself to reduce the replacement of historic fabric and impacts to the building envelope. c. The size of the historic door opening should not be modified as a result of or to accommodate door replacement. (pg. 78) Screen and Storm Doors 1. Storm and screen door additions should minimize any obstruction of the door design and details. 2. Storm and screen doors should be compatible with the architectural style of the building. a. New screen and storm doors should be wood or prefinished metal, but should not have a metallic finish. (pg. 79) Windows 1. Only replace historic windows that cannot be salvaged; avoid wholesale replacement of historic windows. 2. If a historic window needs to be replaced, match the historic window in size, dimensions, configuration, and materials. (pg.75) General Analysis Doors The storm door replacement is an administrative-review item that was included due to the simultaneous door work. The proposed replacement storm door is a full-view door that is consistent with the Design Guidelines. The proposed replacement front door is also a historically appropriate style for the Vernacular Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1312 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-081 4 style of the home and would help return some of the character of the home, as opposed to the existing modern door. Clear glazing, as opposed to DLA glazing with gray tint, is preferred and encouraged. Transom Window The existing transom window glass is cracked, and the applicant wishes to replace the transom window as part of the custom door replacement/fitting, to match the vinyl trim-out of the doorway. While replacement of existing wood windows is discouraged by the Design Guidelines, sta believe it is reasonable to propose the transom window work as part of the door framing repairs and replacements to ensure the look is cohesive. Sta find the proposed door and above-door transom work to be consistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and therefore recommend approval. Staff Findings Additional Photos 1312 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-081 5 1312 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-081 6 1312 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-081 7 1312 Chesapeake Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-081 8 Adjacent residents were notified of the application and proposed scope of work in a letter sent on September 24, 2026. 1.1. eBUILD Application Supplemental Documents Public Notification City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: July 31, 2026 Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-081 Record Name: 1312 chesapeake ave Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: Replace front screen door and entry door as the frame work in severely damaged. Entry door sometimes doe not lock as well as the screen door. We need to replace the glass above the front door as it is cracked. The replacement screen and entry door will be light grey. Address: 1312 CHESAPEAKE AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone SWIFT ANTHONY L & AUDRA S Yes Parcel Information Parcel No: 1340000001800 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone Audra Sue Swift Applicant Address Audra Swift Individual Address Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description New screen and entry doors Zoning Sign Off No Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-081 Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Approval Date - Certificate Number - See supplemental submittal requirements - Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built 1914 Is this an After-the-Fact application? No $250 After the Fact fee, if required. UNCHECKED One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application UNCHECKED One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application UNCHECKED ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. UNCHECKED NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) UNCHECKED Front and side elevations UNCHECKED Samples UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. UNCHECKED ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan or city tax map UNCHECKED Elevations UNCHECKED Photographs of the existing structure and property. CHECKED Samples, photos, and brochures CHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. UNCHECKED ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. UNCHECKED Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-081 Photographs of the building/structure. UNCHECKED 2 quotes each are required for the following: UNCHECKED Photos numerically keyed UNCHECKED RELOCATIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. UNCHECKED Photographs of the premises to which the building or structure will be relocated. UNCHECKED Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. UNCHECKED DEMOLITIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. UNCHECKED Written report on condition of building or structure. UNCHECKED Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached UNCHECKED METAL ROOFS Explanation UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. UNCHECKED Picture UNCHECKED Specification Sheet UNCHECKED Roof color sample UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. UNCHECKED Quotes UNCHECKED Roof color sample (asphalt) UNCHECKED Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-081 1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-094 1 Sta Report Version September 22, 2026 Proposal Installation of wheelchair lift on the side of the front porch; paving/extension of existing gravel side drive. Address 1120 Jackson Avenue Year Built 1924 (Contributing) Applicant Ronnie Hadden After-the-Fact Yes" No # Owner Mary O’Learyc/o Debbie Sherwood Special Power of Attorney Yes # No 5 HARB Hearing Date October 1, 2026 Sta Planner Anna Nagorniuk Application Address 1120 Jackson Avenue Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-094 Sta Recommendation Approval 1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-094 2 Aerial Map 1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-094 3 Project Proposal Applicant is proposing to: 1.1. Install a wheelchair lift on the side of the front porch; 2.2. And pave/extend the existing gravel driveway. South Norfolk Design Guidelines Hardscaping (Driveways, Walkways, And Other Paving) 3. New parking areas and driveways should be placed at the side and rear of properties to limit visibility, and should be limited to single width (10’ wide) to maintain the character of the streetscape. Front yard parking is not appropriate within the Historic District. 4. Appropriate materials for new paving include ribbon paving, gravel or pebble paving, compacted oyster shells, and brick. Concrete is appropriate, but should be scored or exposed aggregate. Asphalt paving should be avoided unless there is historic precedent for the material on the individual site. (pg. 104) Decks and Patios 3.Ramps should be installed in the least intrusive location, such as at secondary elevations, where feasible to meet ADA requirements and accommodate access. If necessary, ramps can be installed at the front of a building to meet these needs. The following guidelines should be met to ensure these added features do not impact the character or integrity of the contributing building:… e. If the site is limited, consider the use of a handicap lift rather than a ramp, if feasible, as they require less space. (pg. 102) General Analysis Applicant is proposing to install a wheelchair lift on the side of the front porch by removing a portion of the porch railing and paving/extending the existing gravel drive to allow wheelchair access to the lift. The size and narrow frontage of the parcel is prohibitive to installing a ramp or installing a lift at an alternative location. The proposed rotating lift will be installed with the entrance facing the street. Some landscaping/trellis bu er may be installed to mitigate visual impact of the lift from neighboring properties. Sta find the proposed wheelchair lift and driveway extension to be consistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and therefore recommend approval. Staff Findings Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-094 4 Additional Photos 1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-094 5 1120 Jackson Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-094 6 "%*#$&-2 0&1)%&-21 3&0& -.2)4&% .' 2(& #//,)$#2).- #-% /0./.1&% 1$./& .' 3.0+ )- # ,&22&0 1&-2 .- September 24, 2026. 1.1. Special Power of Attorney 2.2. eBUILD Application Supplemental Documents Public Notification City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: August 25, 2026 Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-094 Record Name: 1120 Jackson Ave- Wheelchair Lift Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: Installation of wheelchair lift adjacent to the front porch; pave and extend driveway to be 11 feet long, alongside the home. Address: 1120 JACKSON AVE, CHESAPEAKE, VA 23324 Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone OLEARY MARY MYes Parcel Information Parcel No: 1270000005080 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone Ronnie Hadden Applicant Address Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description Installation of wheelchair lift adjacent to the front porch; pave and extend driveway to be 11 feet long, alongside the home. Zoning Sign Off No Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Approval Date - Certificate Number - Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-094 See supplemental submittal requirements - Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built 1924 Is this an After-the-Fact application? No $250 After the Fact fee, if required. - One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application - One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application - ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. - NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. - Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) - Front and side elevations - Samples - Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. - Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. - ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. - Surveyed site plan or city tax map - Elevations - Photographs of the existing structure and property. - Samples, photos, and brochures - Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. - Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. - ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. - Written description of work to be performed - Photographs of the building/structure. - 2 quotes each are required for the following: - Photos numerically keyed - Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-094 RELOCATIONS Completed application form - Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. - Photographs of the premises to which the building or structure will be relocated. - Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. - DEMOLITIONS Completed application form - Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. - Written report on condition of building or structure. - Written description of work to be performed - SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached - METAL ROOFS Explanation - Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. - Picture - Specification Sheet - Roof color sample - Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. - Quotes - Roof color sample (asphalt) - Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-094 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 1 Sta Report Version September 23, 2026 Proposal Replacement of existing 1-over-1 wood windows with new 1-over-1 vinyl windows. Address 1016 Park Avenue Year Built c.1900 (Contributing) Applicant Anthony Enlow After-the-Fact %*7 @ $4 " Owner Anthony Enlow Special Power of Attorney %*7 @ $4 " HARB Hearing Date October 1, 2026 Sta Planner Anna Nagorniuk Application Address 1016 Park Avenue Application Number PLN-CAPP-2026-104 Sta Recommendation Denial 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 2 Aerial Map 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 3 Project Proposal Applicant is proposing to replace all existing wooden 1-over-1 windows with new vinyl double-hung 1-over- 1 windows with forest green trim coil. South Norfolk Design Guidelines Windows 1. Only replace historic windows that cannot be salvaged; avoid wholesale replacement of historic windows. => #+ & -.7846.( :.3)4: 3**)7 84 '* 6*51&(*)? 2&8(- 8-* -.7846.( :.3)4: .3 7.;*? ).2*37.437? (43<,96&8.43? and materials. This should include utilizing replacement windows that have 3D muntins with internal spacer bars between the glass to achieve a simulated divided light (SDL). a. Provide detailed photographic documentation of deterioration of each window proposed for replacement to the HARB. b. Provide dimensioned drawings of the existing historic windows and the proposed replacement windows to illustrate they match. (pg. 75) General Analysis Currently, most of the windows on the property appear to have metal (aluminum) storm windows installed, protecting the existing wood windows. The documentation provided shows some damage to some of the frames and seals of a portion of the existing windows on the property; however, the photos provided do not provide su icient documentation of the condition of all windows on the property nor do they warrant the replacement of the existing windows. The documentation provided along with communication with the applicant indicates that the frames/seals of the existing windows could be repaired. Wholesale replacement of existing windows with vinyl should be avoided if the existing wooden windows can be restored. Sta find the proposed work to be inconsistent with the South Norfolk Design Guidelines and therefore recommend denial. Staff Findings Project Proposal Staff Analysis 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 4 Additional Photos 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 5 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 6 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 7 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 8 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 9 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 1010 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 1111 1016 Park Avenue – PLN-CAPP-2026-104 1212 ")/&(*38 6*7.)*387 :*6* 348.<*) 4+ 8-* &551.(&8.43 &3) 564547*) 7(45* 4+ :460 .3 & 1*88*6 7*38 43 September 24, 2026. 1.1. eBUILD Application Supplemental Documents Public Notification City of Chesapeake Department of Planning Record Summary for Certificate of Appropriateness Record Detail Information Record Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Record Status: Pending Board Review File Date: September 8, 2026 Record Number: PLN-CAPP-2026-104 Record Name: 1016 Park Ave Expiration Date: Description: Parent Record Number: Replace Windows Address: 1016 Park Ave AVE Owner Information Primary Owner Name Owner Address Owner Phone Anthony EnlowYes Parcel Information Parcel No: 1330000005520 Contact Information Organization NameName Contact Type Phone Anthony A Enlow Applicant Address Application Specific Information NATURE OF THE APPLICATION Description Replace 21 wood double hung windows with energy efficient double hung vinyl windows. Zoning Sign Off No Economic Hardship No PLANNING STAFF TO COMPLETE Application After-the-Fact - After-the-Fact Fee Paid - Approved Administratively - Approving Planner - Approval Date - Certificate Number - See supplemental submittal requirements - Page 1 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-104 Board Approved Certificate Number - I, _______________, hereby grant permission for City Staff & members of the Historic Architectural Review Board to enter my site to view exterior areas related to theis Certificate of Appropriateness Application. - Structure Designation - GENERAL INFORMATION Year Structure Built 1914 Is this an After-the-Fact application? No $250 After the Fact fee, if required. UNCHECKED One original delivered to the Planning Department OR a copy attached to the on-line application UNCHECKED One disk containing all photos OR photos attached to on-line application UNCHECKED ? Completed and notarized power of attorney form if the applicant is not the property owner. UNCHECKED NEW CONSTRUCTION Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan (including proposed buildings, structure(s), parking, etc.) UNCHECKED Front and side elevations UNCHECKED Samples UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Photographs of the property and adjoining or opposite properties. UNCHECKED ADDITIONS TO EXIST. STRUCTURES Completed application form. UNCHECKED Surveyed site plan or city tax map UNCHECKED Elevations UNCHECKED Photographs of the existing structure and property. UNCHECKED Samples, photos, and brochures UNCHECKED Arrangement of proposed exterior lighting. UNCHECKED Proposed signs with appropriate detail as to character and location. UNCHECKED ALTERATIONS OR REPAIRS Completed application form. UNCHECKED Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED Photographs of the building/structure. CHECKED 2 quotes each are required for the following: UNCHECKED Photos numerically keyed UNCHECKED RELOCATIONS Page 2 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-104 Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be relocated and adjacent properties. UNCHECKED Photographs of the premises to which the building or structure will be relocated. UNCHECKED Written description of reasons for the relocation and the proposed use of the vacated property. UNCHECKED DEMOLITIONS Completed application form UNCHECKED Photographs of the building or structure to be demolished to illustrate its state of disrepair. UNCHECKED Written report on condition of building or structure. UNCHECKED Written description of work to be performed UNCHECKED SPECIAL POWER OF ATTORNEY Special Power of Attorney attached UNCHECKED METAL ROOFS Explanation UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with metal roof. UNCHECKED Picture UNCHECKED Specification Sheet UNCHECKED Roof color sample UNCHECKED Info required to replace metal roof with architectural shingles. UNCHECKED Quotes UNCHECKED Roof color sample (asphalt) UNCHECKED Page 3 of 3 PLN-CAPP-2026-104

Source: City of Chesapeake website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.