_04302026-1149
City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of Apr 30, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Newport News
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
MINUTES OF MEETING OF BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE
CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS EMPLOYEES’ RETIREMENT FUND
April 30, 2026
EDA Board Room, 3rd Floor,
City Center
9:00 a.m.
Roll Call: Tom Brooks (X), William Donaldson (X), Alison Funaicock (X), Derry Haywood (X),
Lars Lassen (X), Jennifer Loftin (X), Jonthan Matthews (X), Christopher Perry (X),
James Young (X).
Lynn Spratley (X), Sanu Dieng-Cooper (E), Bill Keeler ( X), Sheila White (X), Brian
Sypolt (X), Mary Ellen Compton (X).
Others Present: Sabrina Joy-Hogg, Retirees (2)
1. Call to Order
Mr. Young called the Retirement Board meeting to order at 9:00 a.m. on April 30, 2026.
2. Minutes of the Meeting of March 26, 2026:
Approved Upon motion duly made by Mr. Donaldson, seconded by Mr. Lassen, the minutes of the March 26,
2026, meeting were unanimously approved.
3. Committee on Investments:
a. Funds Review – March 31, 2026 Financials.
The Committee did not meet, however, Mr. Lassen reported that the Fund lost approximately 4.8%
net of fees in March. Estimated assets as of March 31st were:
Pension $ 1,171,697,727 YTD 5.3% (74.8% Funded Status)
Post Retirement 63,384,658 YTD 7.4%
$ 1,235,082,385
LODA $ 4,401,682 YTD 7.3%
4. Committee on Administration:
a. The Committee did not meet.
Docusign Envelope ID: 7392547C-F558-81BF-803D-CE229B214050
2
5. Benefits and Welfare Committee:
a. DROP Study Update
Mr. Haywood reported that t he Committee met on April 13, 2026 to continue discussion of the
DROP Study and provided the following update. He noted that the Committee continued its
review of Cheiron’s Deferred Retirement Option Plan (DROP) study for the public safety group
focusing on the potential cost impacts to both the Fund and the public safety members. Mr.
Heywood summarized the more important aspects of the study for the Board and indicated the
DROP lets eligible public safety employees accumulate their monthly pension benefit in a DROP
account for up to 5 years while continuing to work and entering DROP freezes the retirement
benefit at the level in effect when the employee enters, with COLAs still applied. He noted that
implementing DROP increases the Fund’s actuarial liability by about $9.8M and raises the
employer ADC slightly under a 20 -year amortization, or more significantly un der a 10 -year
amortization. Mr. Haywood believes assumptions used are conservative which include 100%
participation, entry at earliest eligibility, and full 5-year DROP stay and that OPEB liabilities also
increase (about $4.75M) because more retirees are expected to continue medical/dental coverage
after receiving DROP lump sums.
Mr. Haywood explained to the Board that the DROP may not be beneficial to the Fund because of
increased pension liabilities and the Fund immediately absorbs nearly $10M in additional actuarial
liability, with higher ADCs required to amortize the change. He noted that cash-flow risks occur
if many DROP participants retire and withdraw lump sums at the same time, and that the Fund
could face significant negative cash flow, especially during market downturns. Mr. Haywood
reported on the shifting investment risk to the Fund as DROP accounts earn 0% while the Fund
bears the investment volatility. He concluded the poor market performance creates losses the Fund
must absorb.
Mr. Haywood also shared that the DROP study may not be beneficial to employees because of the
frozen benefit calculation which means that an employee’s pension benefit is locked in at the time
they enter DROP and i f th e employee would have potentially earned promotions, raises, or
additional service credit, that growth is lost. He noted that there is no interest on DROP balances
and accumulated DROP funds earn 0% which means that inflation erodes real value over the 5-year
period. Mr. Haywood reported that there is a p otential for reduced DROP benefits if
cost-neutrality is pursued and the analysis shows DROP benefits might need to be cut to around
60% of the full accrued benefit to avoid increasing plan costs.fiscall
Mr. Haywood reported that the Committee also discussed and agreed that any potential DROP
offering should be evaluated in a way that considers fairness and consistency across all Fund
members. Mr. Young noted that the costs incurred for all the studies around the DROP are
approximately $14,800.
Mr. Haywood noted that the Committee agreed to table further discussion of the DROP study and
not pursue any action at this time, concluding that moving forward would not be fiscally prudent.
Docusign Envelope ID: 7392547C-F558-81BF-803D-CE229B214050
3
6. Disability Review Committee:
a. Applicant Case #047257
Mr. Young informed the Board that the Committee met on April 27th to review Applicant Case
#047257. He reported that the Committee reviewed Dr. Lee’s medical report and also heard from
the applicant, who attended the meeting and provided additional information to the Committee.
Based on the information received from Dr. Lee and the applicant, Mr. Young noted that the
Committee recommended 65% non -occupational partial disability. He went on to say that
although pursuant to City Code Sec. 31-58(d), the initial disability percentage shall be increased by
two percent (2%) for each full year of credited service, not to exceed the lesser of two (2) times the
initial rating or eighty percent (80%) resulting that the total disability percentage recommended by
the Committee was forty percent ( 80%) and that t he applicant has been informed of the
recommendation.
Mr. Young indicated that the Board would not need to go into closed session unless the Board
would like additional information or if the applicant was attending today’s meeting and would
like to address the Board.
Approved Upon motion duly made and seconded, the Disability Committee unanimously agreed to
recommend 65% non-occupational partial disability rating. Pursuant to City Code Sec. 31-
58(d), the initial disability percentage shall be increased by two percent (2%) for each full
year of credited service, not to exceed the lesser of two (2) times the initial rating or eighty
percent (80%). The resulting total disability percentage recommended by the Committee
for case #047257 is, therefore, eighty percent (80%).
7. Old Business:
a. There was no old business for discussion.
8. New Business:
a. There was no new business for discussion.
9. Citizen Comments on Matters Germane to the Business of the Retirement Board
a. There were no citizen comments during the meeting of April 30, 2026.
10. Next Meeting:
The next regular Retirement Board meeting will be at 9:00 a.m., Thursday, May 28, 2026 in the EDA
Board Room, 3rd floor, City Center.
Docusign Envelope ID: 7392547C-F558-81BF-803D-CE229B214050
4
11. Adjournment:
There being no further business to come before the Board, Mr. Young adjourned the meeting at
9:10 a.m.
A true copy, attest:
__________________________________
Sheila White, Secretary
Board of Trustees
Docusign Envelope ID: 7392547C-F558-81BF-803D-CE229B214050
Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.