RecordWell Data

Meeting of Collective Bargaining Task Force

City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of May 21, 2025 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Newport News

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

A GENDA OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS COLLECTIVE BARGAINING TASK FORCE May 21, 2025 City Council Conference Room, 10th Floor 2400 Washington Ave. 6:00 p.m. Roll Call: JoAnn Armstrong ( ), Randolph Dillard ( ), Dr. James Graves ( ), Curtis Hartsfield ( ), Matthew Jerasa ( ), Adrian Manning ( ), Jason Parker ( ), Christopher Puckett ( ), Denise Reynolds ( ). Alan Archer ( ), Gloria Washington ( ), Robert Pealo ( ), Virginia Lovell ( ), Roslyn Gervin ( ), Brian Sypolt ( ), Tiffany Mitchell ( ), Nate Loucks ( ). 1. C all to Order: 2. D isclosure Statements: 3. Ap proval of the Minutes of the Meeting of May 7, 2025: 4. O ld Business: a. B argaining Scope Discussion 5. N ew Business: 6. D ate for Next Meeting: The June 4th meeting will be canceled. The next regular Task Force m eeting will be Wednesday, June 18, 2025 at 6:00 p.m. in the City Council Conference Room, 10th Floor, 2400 Washington Ave. 7. A djournment: 1 1 MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS COLLECTIVE BARGAINING TASK FORCE May 7, 2025 James Room 700 Town Center Drive 6:00 p.m. Task Force Members: JoAnn Armstrong (X), Randolph Dillard (E), Dr. James Graves (X), Curtis Hartsfield (arrived at 6:09 pm), Matthew Jerasa (X), Adrian Manning (X), Jason Parker (X), Christopher Puckett (X), Denise Reynolds (arrived at 6:05 pm). City Staff: Alan Archer (E), Gloria Washington (X), Robert Pealo (X), Virginia Lovell (X), Brian Sypolt (X), Roslyn Gervin (X), Tiffany Mitchell (X), Nate Loucks (X). Others Present: Councilman Cleon Long Brian Washington, Department of Communications Citizens (7) 1. Call to Order: Mr. Manning called the Collective Bargaining Task Force meeting to order at 6: 01 p.m. on May 7, 2025. 2. Disclosure Statements: The following participants made disclosure statements, and disclosure letters are attached hereto and made part of the record: Dr. James Graves disclosed he is President of the Newport News Education Association and can participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest . Mr. Curtis Hartsfield disclosed he is employed by the City of Newport News in the Public Works Department and is a member of the Laborers International Union of North America and can participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest. Mr. Matthew Jerasa disclosed he is employed by the City of Newport News in the Police Department and is the President of the Newport News Chapter of the Virginia Police Benevolent Association and can participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest. Mr. Adrian Manning disclosed he is the President of the Newport News Firefighter’s Association, IAFF Local 794 and can participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest. Mr. Jason Parker disclosed he is a member of the Virginia American Federation of Labor and Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL -CIO) and a member of the International Brotherhood 2 2 of Electrical Workers Local Union 1340 and can participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest. Mr. Christopher Puckett disclosed he is a member of the United Steelworkers Local 8888 and can participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest. Ms. Denise Reynolds disclosed she is employed by the City of Newport News in the Commissioner of the Revenue’s office. 3. Approval of the Minutes of the Meeting of April 23, 2025: Upon motion by Mr. Manning, seconded by Mr. Puckett, the minutes of the April 23, 2025 meeting were unanimously approved. Vote on Roll Call (6-0): Ayes: Ms. Armstrong, Dr. Graves, Mr. Jerasa, Mr. Manning, Mr. Parker, Mr. Puckett, Nays: None Absent: Mr. Dillard, Mr. Hartsfield, Ms. Reynolds 4. Old Business: a. Bargaining Units Discussion: The Task Force continued its discussion on the proposed bargaining units. Mr. Manning reviewed the descriptions for each group, which included Fire, Police, Administration and Clerical, Labor and Trades, and Professional and Technical, inviting members to provide questions or suggested edits. Mr. Jerasa emphasized the importance of ensuring broad inclusion within the Police bargaining unit. He proposed that Captains be incorporated and recommended updating the description to state: “Excludes supervisory p ersonnel at the rank of Assistant Chief or above.” Councilman Long inquired about the roles of supervisors within the city, particularly within the Fire department and the position of Battalion Chiefs. The Task Force and staff explored the implications of supervisory responsibilities, such as performance evaluations and disciplinary recommendations, particularly within Police and Fire departments. Following these discussions, the Task Force reached a consensus: employees with significant disciplinary authority should be excluded from bargaining units, while leads and supervisors without such authority could remain included. Members also underscored the importance of ensuring fair representation for all eligible employees while mitigating potential conflicts in discipline and grievance procedures. The Task Force continued its discussion on the remaining bargaining units, concluding that all previously raised questions and concerns had been addressed. Members agreed that all employees would appropriately fall into a category based on their job descriptions. Following the discussion, a motion was made to amend the description of the Police bargaining unit to state: “Excludes supervisory personnel at the rank of Assistant Chief or above.” 3 3 Upon motion by Mr. Jerasa, seconded by Mr. Parker, the motion to amend the description of the Police bargaining unit to state: “Excludes supervisory personnel at the rank of Assistant Chief or above” was unanimously approved. Vote on Roll Call (8-0): Ayes: Ms. Armstrong, Dr. Graves, Mr. Hartsfield, Mr. Jerasa, Mr. Manning, Mr. Parker, Mr. Puckett, Ms. Reynolds Nays: None Absent: Mr. Dillard b. Collective Bargaining Scope Discussion: The Task Force continued its discussion on the scope of collective bargaining, which could encompass various terms and conditions of employment, including wages, benefits, scheduling, work hours, and working conditions, provided they align with state and f ederal laws. Mr. Manning highlighted the table in the packet, which summarizes the scope of bargaining as defined in the ordinances of Alexandria, Arlington, and Richmond. These cities were chosen for comparison due to their similarity to the city. The Task Force reviewed the subjects of bargaining as presented to determine if any members had any questions or edits. Councilman Long inquired about the process for preparing and presenting the ordinance to the City Council. Mr. Manning explained that the Task Force would draft an ordinance outlining high- level recommendations on the scope of collective bargaining. This may include various employment terms and conditions, such as wages, benefits, scheduling, work hours, and working conditions, provided they align with state and federal laws. Additionally, the ordinance would offer recommendations on the number of collective bargaining units. He further noted that if the City Council approves collective bargaining, each bargaining unit representative would then present a more detailed proposal on the specific topics they wish to negotiate. The Tasked Force continued conversations around the City’s two retirement plans: Virginia Retirement System (VRS) and the Newport News Employees’ Retirement Fund (NNERF) . As previously noted provisions of the VRS must be excluded under state law. Conversations continued concerning NNERF as Mr. Manning noted including NNERF in a subject of bargaining could present challenges for negotiation since it is already represented by a Board. Several members felt certain aspects of NNERF could be included in the subject of bargaining. Mr. Parker asked if NNERF was not included, could the City add another pension plan or option for employees. Ms. Lovell noted that, under state la w, another pension plan could be added but informed the Task Force that either the Retirement Board or a nother board would have to be formed to oversee the plan as required under Virginia law. Several Task Force members emphasized that recommendations should remain practical and avoid placing items before the Council that would be difficult to approve. They also agreed that excessive details should be avoided, as many concerns can be effectively addressed through the bargaining process. Members then asked Councilman Long for guidance on what the Council would be 4 4 expecting from the Task Force. He advised that recommendations should be carefully considered in terms of feasibility, emphasizing that cost is always a key factor, as the Council must remain mindful of the City's budget. Councilman Long noted that including NNERF in the recommendations could be challenging, given that it is already one of the City's largest expenses. He cautioned that any additional provisions related to NNERF could significantly impact retirement costs. M s. Lovell added that the City cur rently has an unfunded liability of approximately $450 million related to NNERF. Following further discussion, a motion was made to exclude NNERF and VRS from the subjects of bargaining in the collective bargaining ordinance, while allowing ancillary retirement options to remain included. Upon motion by Mr. Manning, seconded by Ms. Reynolds, the motion to exclude NNERF and VRS from the subjects of bargaining in the collective bargaining ordinance, while allowing ancillary retirement options to remain included was unanimously approved. Vote on Roll Call (8-0): Ayes: Ms. Armstrong, Dr. Graves, Mr. Hartsfield, Mr. Jerasa, Mr. Manning, Mr. Parker, Mr. Puckett, Ms. Reynolds Nays: None Absent: Mr. Dillard Mr. Manning requested that all Task Force members conduct a further review of the subjects of bargaining, as well as the Reduction in Force (RIF) and Grievance Policy, before the next meeting. He expressed his intention to begin drafting definitions for the city as part of this process. 5. New Business: a. Staff Update: Ms. Lovell introduced Ms. Roslyn Gervin to the Task Force, noting that she is currently serving as the Acting Director of Human Resources. b. Excused Absences: Mr. Dillard asked to be excused from today’s meeting. 6. Next Meeting: The next regular Collective Bargaining Task Force meeting will be at 6 :00 p.m., Wednesday, May 21, 2025 in the City Council Conference Room, 10 th Floor, 2400 Washington Ave. 5 5 7. Adjournment: There being no further business to come before the Task Force, Mr. Manning adjourned the meeting at 7:22 p.m. A true copy, attest: ________________________________ Virginia Lovell, Secretary Collective Bargaining Task Force 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Collective Bargaining Task Force Proposed Bargaining Groups Fire and Emergency Medical Services Bargaining Unit The Fire and EMS Bargaining Unit shall consist of all uniformed fire employees, including Fire marshals. Excludes supervisory personnel at the rank of battalion chief or above. Police Bargaining Unit The Police Bargaining Unit shall consist of all sworn uniformed employees of the police department. Excludes supervisory personnel at the rank of assistant chief or above. Labor and Trades Bargaining Unit The Labor and Trades Bargaining Unit includes those eligible classes of employees associated with maintenance and skilled crafts, i.e. job classes of workers performing duties that result directly in the comfort and convenience of the general public, or contribute to the maintenance of capital assets, land and infrastructure of the city. Administrative and Clerical Bargaining Unit The Administrative and Clerical Bargaining Unit includes employee whose primary duty is in the performance of office or non-manual work directly related to or in furtherance of the management or general business operations and services of the city Professional and Technical Bargaining Unit The Professional and Technical Bargaining Unit includes employees whose work requires a combination of basic scientific or technical knowledge and manual skill that can be obtained through specialized post- secondary education or through equivalent on-the-job training (technical) and employees exempt from the FLSA whose primary duty is the performance of work requiring knowledge of an advanced type in a field of science or learning customarily acquired by a prolonged course of specialized intellectual instruction or requiring invention, imagination, originality, or talent in a recognized field of artistic or creative endeavor (professional) Excluded from ALL units: • Constitutional Officers and their staff • Management • Supervisors • Confidential employees • Intermittent/Seasonal/Temporary/Intern • Members of Boards and Commissions or any other appointee of any public body • Volunteers Language based on City of Alexandria, Virginia Ordinance No. 5336 15 Subject of Bargaining Arlington Richmond Alexandria Wages and Other Monetary Compensation Terms and Conditions of Employment means wages, salaries and all forms of monetary compensation, benefits, personnel policies and practices, and working conditions. The term does not include matters reserved to management's sole discretion in subsection D (p 5) Collective bargaining means to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding wages and benefits, as the term benefits is defined herein, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances with the good faith intention of reaching an agreement(p 3) Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is defined herein), hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances, but excluding discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching an agreement (p2) Terms and Conditions of Employment Terms and Conditions of Employment means wages, salaries and all forms of monetary compensation, benefits, personnel policies and practices, and working conditions. The term does not include matters reserved to management's sole discretion in subsection D (p 5) Collective bargaining means to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding wages and benefits, as the term benefits is defined herein, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances with the good faith intention of reaching an agreement(p 3) Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is defined herein), hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances, but excluding discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching an agreement (p2) Hours and Scheduling of Work Not specified. Collective bargaining means to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding wages and benefits, as the term benefits is defined herein, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances with the good faith intention of reaching an agreement(p 3) Management right to (i) hire and classify all employees in accordance with applicable law; (ii) to promote, transfer, assign, and schedule all employees, except that the procedures related to such decisions shall be negotiable; (p8) Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is defined herein), hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances, but excluding discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching an agreement (p2) Working Conditions Terms and Conditions of Employment means wages, salaries and all forms of monetary compensation, benefits, personnel policies and practices, and working conditions. The term does not include matters reserved to management's sole discretion in subsection D (p 5) Not specified Not specified. 16 Subject of Bargaining Arlington Richmond Alexandria Layoffs / RIFs Management right except that the County Manager shall, upon request, negotiate procedures to implement such actions and arrangements for employees affected by such actions and such negotiations shall be governed by N(2)(c); (p 6) Management right except that the implementation procedures to be followed, notice, and alternatives to layoff shall be negotiable; (p 8) Management right to relieve employees from duties by layoff or other reduction-in-force due to lack of work, changed working conditions/requirements, budget limitations or for other reasons in the city's reasonable business judgment and not prohibited by law; (p 6) Personnel Policies and Practices Terms and Conditions of Employment means wages, salaries and all forms of monetary compensation, benefits, personnel policies and practices, and working conditions. The term does not include matters reserved to management's sole discretion in subsection D (p 5) Excluded: to establish and change standards of behavior or performance, job qualifications and job descriptions; to determine the goals, objectives, functions, structure and supervision of departments, divisions and offices of government; (p 6) Not specified Not specified. Procedures to Resolve Employee Grievances Management right to hire, promote and classify all employees; and to, suspend, demote, discharge, or take other disciplinary action against employees for cause; and to establish criteria for all such actions listed herein and make the ultimate decision as to which employee(s) such actions will apply, except that the venue for the final step in the County’s grievance procedure available to challenge such county decisions shall be negotiable, to the extent consistent with Virginia law; (p 6) Collective bargaining means to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding wages and benefits, as the term benefits is defined herein, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances with the good faith intention of reaching an agreement(p 3) Management right to suspend, demote, discharge, or take other disciplinary action against employees for just cause in accordance with applicable law and regulations, except that procedures to challenge such decisions shall be negotiable to the extent consistent with state law; (p 8) Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is defined herein), hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances, but excluding discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching an agreement (p2) Procedures to Resolve Disciplinary Matters Not specified Not specified Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is defined herein), hours, and other terms and conditions of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances, but excluding discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching an agreement (p2) 17 Subject of Bargaining Arlington Richmond Alexandria Weingarten Rights Rights of exclusive representative. (6) To be represented at any formal discussion between one or more representatives of the county and one or more employees in the bargaining unit or their representatives concerning (a) any matter that is within the scope of collective bargaining as set forth in the definition of collective bargaining (see subsection B); or (b) any examination of bargaining unit employees by a representative of the county in connection with an investigation if the employee reasonably believes that the examination involves matters covered by any collective bargaining agreement then in effect, or the employee reasonably believes they may be disciplined based on the subject of the examination, and the employee requests representation. (p 13-14) Right of exclusive representative To be represented at any formal discussion between one or more representatives of the City and one or more employees in the bargaining unit or their representatives concerning (i) any matter that is within the scope of collective bargaining as set forth in this divisions definition of collective bargaining, or (ii) any examination of bargaining unit employees by a representative of the City in connection with an investigation if the employee reasonably believes that the examination involves matters covered by any collective bargaining agreement then in effect or any matter that may reasonably lead to discipline of that employee, and the employee requests representation. The City shall inform the employee of the employees right to union representation prior to any such discussion or examination. (p20) Right of exclusive representative To be represented at any formal discussion between one or more representatives of the city and one or more employees in the bargaining unit or their representatives concerning (1) any matter that is within the scope of collective bargaining as set forth in the definition of collective bargaining (see Section 2-5-68); or (2) any examination of bargaining unit employees by a representative of the city in connection with an investigation if the employee reasonably believes that the examination involves matters covered by any collective bargaining agreement then in effect, and the employee requests representation. (p12) Leave (Paid/Unpaid, Vacation, Holidays) Employee Contributions and Level of Insurance Coverage Local Retirement Benefits (Non-VRS) Benefits means, for the purpose of this Section, leave (paid and unpaid, vacation, and holidays), insurance (including contributions and levels of coverage) and matters pertaining to the county- provided retirement, pension or deferred compensation/savings plan(s). (p 2) Benefits means, for the purpose of this division, all forms of non-wage compensation, leave (including paid and unpaid, vacation, and holidays), insurance (including contributions and levels of coverage), general supplemental retirement plans, and police and fire retirement plans presently made available under City authority. (p3) Except (d) The City shall not negotiate as to: (4) Any decision to retain the Citys existing retirement plans as set forth in Chapter 22 or to replace any or all of such plans with the retirement plan of the Virginia Retirement System. (p10) Benefits means, for the purpose of this article, leave (paid and unpaid, vacation, and holidays), insurance (including contributions and levels of coverage), general supplemental retirement plans, and police and fire retirement plans presently made available under city authority. (p2) State and Federal Law Collective bargaining shall not mean negotiation as to matters controlled or preempted by any federal or state constitutional provision, law, rule or regulation. (p 2) The City shall not negotiate as to: (1) Matters controlled or preempted by any federal or state constitutional provision, law, rule or regulation; (p9) The city shall not negotiate as to matters controlled or preempted by any federal or state constitutional provision, law, rule or regulation. (p 2) 18

Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.