Meeting of Collective Bargaining Task Force
City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of Apr 23, 2025 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Newport News
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
AGE
NDA OF THE MEETING OF
THE CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING TASK FORCE
Ap
ril 23, 2025
City Council Conference Room, 10th Floor
2400 Washington Ave.
6:00 p.m.
Roll Call: JoAnn Armstrong ( ), Randolph Dillard ( ), Dr. James Graves ( ), Curtis Hartsfield ( ),
Matthew Jerasa ( ), Adrian Manning ( ), Jason Parker ( ), Christopher Puckett ( ),
Denise Reynolds ( ).
Alan Archer ( ), Gloria Washington ( ), Robert Pealo ( ), Allison Dichoso ( ),
Virginia Lovell ( ), Brian Sypolt ( ), Tiffany Mitchell ( ), Nate Loucks ( ).
1. Ca
ll to Order:
2. Disc
losure Statements:
3. App
roval of the Minutes of the Meeting of April 9, 2025:
4. Old
Business:
a. Ba
rgaining Units Discussion
b. Ba
rgaining Scope Discussion
5. Ne
w Business:
6. Da
te for Next Meeting: The next regular Task Force meeting will be Wednesday, May 7, 2025 at
6:00 p.m. in the James Room, 1st Floor, 700 Town Center Drive.
7. Ad
journment:
1
1
MINUTES OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING TASK FORCE
April 9, 2025
James Room, 1st Floor
700 Town Center Drive
6:00 p.m.
Task Force Members: JoAnn Armstrong (X), Randolph Dillard (X), Dr. James Graves (arrived at 6:21pm),
Curtis Hartsfield (X), Matthew Jerasa (X), Adrian Manning (E),
Jason Parker (X), Christopher Puckett (virtual), Denise Reynolds (X).
City Staff: Alan Archer (E ), Gloria Washington (X), Robert Pealo (X ), Allison Dichoso (X) ,
Virginia Lovell (X), Brian Sypolt (E), Tiffany Mitchell (X), Nate Loucks (X).
Others Present: Emma Hundley, Assistant Director of Finance
Citizens (4)
1. Call to Order:
Ms. Reynolds called the Collective Bargaining Task Force meeting to order at 6:01 p.m. on April
9, 2025.
2. Electronic Participation:
Upon motion by Mr. Parker , seconded by Mr. Hartsfield , the motion to allow Mr. Puckett to join
the meeting virtually due to travel was unanimously approved.
Vote on Roll Call (7-0):
Ayes: Ms. Armstrong, Mr. Dillard, Mr. Hartsfield, Mr. Jerasa, Mr. Parker, Mr. Puckett,
Ms. Reynolds
Nays: None
Absent: Dr. Graves, Mr. Manning
3. Disclosure Statements:
The following participants made disclosure statements, and disclosure letters are attached hereto
and made part of the record:
Dr. James Graves disclosed he is President of the Newport News Education Association and can
participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest .
2
2
Mr. Curtis Hartsfield disclosed he is employed by the City of Newport News in the Public Works
Department and is a member of the Laborers International Union of North America and can
participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest.
M
r. Matthew Jerasa disclosed he is employed by the City of Newport News in the Police
Department and is the President of the Newport News Chapter of the Virginia Police Benevolent
Association and can participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest.
M
r. Jason Parker disclosed he is a member of the Virginia American Federation of Labor and
Congress of Industrial Organizations (AFL -CIO) and a member of the International Brotherhood
of Electrical Workers Local Union 1340 and can participate in these discussions fairly, objectively,
and in the public interest.
M
r. Christopher Puckett disclosed he is a member of the United Steelworkers Local 8888 and can
participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest.
M
r. Randolph Dillard disclosed he is the Director of the Laborers’ International Union of North
America and can participate in these discussions fairly, objectively, and in the public interest.
4. A
pproval of the Minutes of the Meeting of March 26, 2025:
U
pon motion by Mr. Parker , seconded by Ms. Armstrong , the minutes of the March 26, 20 25
m
eeting were unanimously approved.
V
ote on Roll Call (7-0):
A
yes: Ms. Armstrong, Mr. Dillard, Mr. Hartsfield, Mr. Jerasa, Mr. Parker, Mr. Puckett ,
Ms.
Reynolds
Nays: None
Absent: Dr. Graves, Mr. Manning
5. O
ld Business:
a. B
argaining Units Discussion:
M
s. Reynolds noted that, as requested, staff provided draft language regarding the classifications
of each unit approved from the last meeting: Fire, Police, Administrative & Clerical, Labor &
Trades, Professional & Technical. The Task Force continued its discussion regarding which city
employees would or would not qualify for inclusion in collective bargaining units, specifically
focusing on supervisory roles within each unit described above. The Task Force reviewed practices
from other jurisdictions, particularly in Police and Fire, and sought information from staff on the
impact of supervisory duties like timesheet approval, evaluations, and disciplinary
recommendations. The consensus from the Task Force was to exclude employees with significant
disciplinary authority from bargaining units, while allowing leads or other supervisors without
such authority to remain included. Members discussed ensuring fair representation for all eligible
employees while avoiding conflicts in discipline and grievance handling. After further discussion,
3
3
a motion was made to table further discussion on the bargaining units until all members of the
Task Force were present and to move onto the scope of items that can be bargained.
Upon motion by Mr. Parker , seconded by Mr. Jerasa , the Task Force tabled further discussion
around employee inclusion in bargaining units and moved onto discussion involving the scope of
the items that can be bargained.
Vote on Roll Call (8-0):
Ayes: Ms. Armstrong, Mr. Dillard, Dr. Graves, Mr. Hartsfield, Mr. Jerasa, Mr. Parker, Mr. Puckett,
Ms. Reynolds
Nays: None
Absent: Mr. Manning
6. New Business:
a. Collective Bargaining Scope Discussion:
The Task Force began discussion around the scope of collective bargaining, which could include
certain terms and conditions of employment, such as wages, benefits, scheduling, work hours, and
working conditions, among other things, if consistent with state and fed eral laws. Mr. Parker
noted that the Task Force should just begin the groundwork as not all members were present.
The Task Force began with a discussion of items which should or must be excluded. Members and
staff discussed grievance rights, mentioning some provisions for grievance procedures are
included in state code, with Police and Fire having specific regulation s. Ms. Lovell also reminded
the Task Force that provisions of the Virginia Retirement System (VRS) and funding appropriations
must be excluded under state law. The Task Force noted most ordinances contain language
specifying items controlled or preempted by Federal or State law are excluded.
Mr. Dillard noted that since the Task Force has decided on 5 bargaining units, the Task Force
should review collective bargaining ordinances from localities with 5 units (Alexandria, Richmond
and Arlington) to provide guidance in their discussion. Staff was asked if they foresee any
bargaining scopes that would present a challenge to the City. Staff noted grievances, schedules
and having multiple insurance plans could present administrative challenges to the City and staff.
Ms. Lovell mentioned that the Newport News Employees’ Retirement Fund could potentially
present a challenge to bargain as the Fund is already represented by a Board. Task Force members
shared their experiences with various potential provisions, including the desire for Weingarten
rights, input into scheduling and grievance procedures, and representation on retirement boards .
The Task Force asked staff if they could create and bring back to the next meeting a table
summarizing the scope of bargaining as defined in the ordinances of Alexandria, Arlington and
Richmond.
4
4
7. N
ext Meeting:
T
he next regular Collective Bargaining Task Force meeting will be at 6:00 p.m., Wednesday, April
23
, 2025 in the City Council Large Conference Room, 10th Floor, 2400 Washington Avenue.
8. A
djournment:
T
here being no further business to come before the Task Force, Ms. Reynolds adjourned the
m
eeting at 7:03 p.m.
A
true copy, attest:
____
____________________________
Virginia Lovell, Secretary
Collective Bargaining Task Force
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Collective Bargaining Task Force
Proposed Bargaining Groups
Fire and Emergency Medical Services Bargaining Unit
The Fire and EMS Bargaining Unit shall consist of all uniformed fire employees, including Fire marshals.
Excludes supervisory personnel at the rank of battalion chief or above.
Police Bargaining Unit
The Police Bargaining Unit shall consist of all sworn uniformed employees of the police department. Excludes
supervisory personnel at the rank of captain or above.
Labor and Trades Bargaining Unit
The Labor and Trades Bargaining Unit includes those eligible classes of employees associated with maintenance
and skilled crafts, i.e. job classes of workers performing duties that result directly in the comfort and convenience
of the general public, or contribute to the maintenance of capital assets, land and infrastructure of the city.
Administrative and Clerical Bargaining Unit
The Administrative and Clerical Bargaining Unit includes employee whose primary duty is in the performance of
office or non-manual work directly related to or in furtherance of the management or general business operations
and services of the city
Professional and Technical Bargaining Unit
The Professional and Technical Bargaining Unit includes employees whose work requires a combination of
basic scientific or technical knowledge and manual skill that can be obtained through specialized post-
secondary education or through equivalent on-the-job training (technical) and employees exempt from the FLSA
whose primary duty is the performance of work requiring knowledge of an advanced type in a field of science
or learning customarily acquired by a prolonged course of specialized intellectual instruction or requiring
invention, imagination, originality, or talent in a recognized field of artistic or creative endeavor (professional)
Excluded from ALL units:
• Constitutional Officers and their staff
• Management
• Supervisors
• Confidential employees
• Intermittent/Seasonal/Temporary/Intern
• Members of Boards and Commissions or any other appointee of any public body
• Volunteers
Language based on City of Alexandria, Virginia Ordinance No. 5336
14
Subject of Bargaining Arlington Richmond Alexandria
Wages and Other Monetary Compensation
Terms and Conditions of Employment means wages,
salaries and all forms of monetary compensation,
benefits, personnel policies and practices, and
working conditions. The term does not include
matters reserved to management's sole discretion in
subsection D (p 5)
Collective bargaining means to meet and negotiate in
good faith at reasonable times and places regarding
wages and benefits, as the term benefits is defined
herein, hours, and other terms and conditions of
employment, including procedures to resolve
employee grievances with the good faith intention of
reaching an agreement(p 3)
Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate
in good faith at reasonable times and places
regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is
defined herein), hours, and other terms and
conditions of employment, including procedures to
resolve employee grievances, but excluding
discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching
an agreement (p2)
Terms and Conditions of Employment
Terms and Conditions of Employment means wages,
salaries and all forms of monetary compensation,
benefits, personnel policies and practices, and
working conditions. The term does not include
matters reserved to management's sole discretion in
subsection D (p 5)
Collective bargaining means to meet and negotiate in
good faith at reasonable times and places regarding
wages and benefits, as the term benefits is defined
herein, hours, and other terms and conditions of
employment, including procedures to resolve
employee grievances with the good faith intention of
reaching an agreement(p 3)
Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate
in good faith at reasonable times and places
regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is
defined herein), hours, and other terms and
conditions of employment, including procedures to
resolve employee grievances, but excluding
discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching
an agreement (p2)
Hours and Scheduling of Work Not specified.
Collective bargaining means to meet and negotiate in
good faith at reasonable times and places regarding
wages and benefits, as the term benefits is defined
herein, hours, and other terms and conditions of
employment, including procedures to resolve
employee grievances with the good faith intention of
reaching an agreement(p 3)
Management right to (i) hire and classify all
employees in accordance with applicable law; (ii) to
promote, transfer, assign, and schedule all
employees, except that the procedures related to
such decisions shall be negotiable; (p8)
Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate
in good faith at reasonable times and places
regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is
defined herein), hours, and other terms and
conditions of employment, including procedures to
resolve employee grievances, but excluding
discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching
an agreement (p2)
Working Conditions
Terms and Conditions of Employment means wages,
salaries and all forms of monetary compensation,
benefits, personnel policies and practices, and
working conditions. The term does not include
matters reserved to management's sole discretion in
subsection D (p 5)
Not specified Not specified.
15
Subject of Bargaining Arlington Richmond Alexandria
Layoffs / RIFs
Management right except that the County Manager
shall, upon request, negotiate procedures to
implement such actions and arrangements for
employees affected by such actions and such
negotiations shall be governed by N(2)(c); (p 6)
Management right except that the implementation
procedures to be followed, notice, and alternatives
to layoff shall be negotiable; (p 8)
Management right to relieve employees from duties
by layoff or other reduction-in-force due to lack of
work, changed working conditions/requirements,
budget limitations or for other reasons in the city's
reasonable business judgment and not prohibited by
law; (p 6)
Personnel Policies and Practices
Terms and Conditions of Employment means wages,
salaries and all forms of monetary compensation,
benefits, personnel policies and practices, and
working conditions. The term does not include
matters reserved to management's sole discretion in
subsection D (p 5)
Excluded: to establish and change standards of
behavior or performance, job qualifications and job
descriptions; to determine the goals, objectives,
functions, structure and supervision of departments,
divisions and offices of government; (p 6)
Not specified Not specified.
Procedures to Resolve Employee Grievances
Management right to hire, promote and classify all
employees; and to, suspend, demote, discharge, or
take other disciplinary action against employees for
cause; and to establish criteria for all such actions
listed herein and make the ultimate decision as to
which employee(s) such actions will apply, except
that the venue for the final step in the County’s
grievance procedure available to challenge such
county decisions shall be negotiable, to the extent
consistent with Virginia law; (p 6)
Collective bargaining means to meet and negotiate in
good faith at reasonable times and places regarding
wages and benefits, as the term benefits is defined
herein, hours, and other terms and conditions of
employment, including procedures to resolve
employee grievances with the good faith intention of
reaching an agreement(p 3)
Management right to suspend, demote, discharge, or
take other disciplinary action against employees for
just cause in accordance with applicable law and
regulations, except that procedures to challenge
such decisions shall be negotiable to the extent
consistent with state law; (p 8)
Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate
in good faith at reasonable times and places
regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is
defined herein), hours, and other terms and
conditions of employment, including procedures to
resolve employee grievances, but excluding
discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching
an agreement (p2)
Procedures to Resolve Disciplinary Matters Not specified Not specified
Collective Bargaining means to meet and negotiate
in good faith at reasonable times and places
regarding wages and benefits (as the term benefits is
defined herein), hours, and other terms and
conditions of employment, including procedures to
resolve employee grievances, but excluding
discipline, with the good faith intention of reaching
an agreement (p2)
16
Subject of Bargaining Arlington Richmond Alexandria
Weingarten Rights
Rights of exclusive representative.
(6) To be represented at any formal discussion
between one or more representatives of the county
and one or more employees in the bargaining unit or
their representatives concerning (a) any matter that
is within the scope of collective bargaining as set
forth in the definition of collective bargaining (see
subsection B); or (b) any examination of bargaining
unit employees by a representative of the county in
connection with an investigation if the employee
reasonably believes that the examination involves
matters covered by any collective bargaining
agreement then in effect, or the employee
reasonably believes they may be disciplined based
on the subject of the examination, and the employee
requests representation. (p 13-14)
Right of exclusive representative
To be represented at any formal discussion between
one or more representatives of the City and one or
more employees in the bargaining unit or their
representatives concerning (i) any matter that is
within the scope of collective bargaining as set forth
in this divisions definition of collective bargaining, or
(ii) any examination of bargaining unit employees by
a representative of the City in connection with an
investigation if the employee reasonably believes
that the examination involves matters covered by any
collective bargaining agreement then in effect or any
matter that may reasonably lead to discipline of that
employee, and the employee requests
representation. The City shall inform the employee of
the employees right to union representation prior to
any such discussion or examination. (p20)
Right of exclusive representative
To be represented at any formal discussion between
one or more representatives of the city and one or
more employees in the bargaining unit or their
representatives concerning (1) any matter that is
within the scope of collective bargaining as set forth
in the definition of collective bargaining (see Section
2-5-68); or (2) any examination of bargaining unit
employees by a representative of the city in
connection with an investigation if the employee
reasonably believes that the examination involves
matters covered by any collective bargaining
agreement then in effect, and the employee requests
representation. (p12)
Leave (Paid/Unpaid, Vacation, Holidays)
Employee Contributions and Level of Insurance Coverage
Local Retirement Benefits (Non-VRS)
Benefits means, for the purpose of this Section,
leave (paid and unpaid, vacation, and holidays),
insurance (including contributions and levels of
coverage) and matters pertaining to the county-
provided retirement, pension or deferred
compensation/savings plan(s). (p 2)
Benefits means, for the purpose of this division, all
forms of non-wage compensation, leave (including
paid and unpaid, vacation, and holidays), insurance
(including contributions and levels of coverage),
general supplemental retirement plans, and police
and fire retirement plans presently made available
under City authority. (p3)
Except (d) The City shall not negotiate as to: (4) Any
decision to retain the Citys existing retirement plans
as set forth in Chapter 22 or to replace any or all of
such plans with the retirement plan of the Virginia
Retirement System. (p10)
Benefits means, for the purpose of this article, leave
(paid and unpaid, vacation, and holidays), insurance
(including contributions and levels of coverage),
general supplemental retirement plans, and police
and fire retirement plans presently made available
under city authority. (p2)
State and Federal Law
Collective bargaining shall not mean negotiation as
to matters controlled or preempted by any federal or
state constitutional provision, law, rule or regulation.
(p 2)
The City shall not negotiate as to: (1) Matters
controlled or preempted by any federal or state
constitutional provision, law, rule or regulation; (p9)
The city shall not negotiate as to matters controlled
or preempted by any federal or state constitutional
provision, law, rule or regulation. (p 2)
17
1
An ORDINANCE to amend Chapter 6 of the Code of the County of
Arlington, Virginia, Civil Service, by adding Section 6-30, Collective Bargaining,
as follows:
CHAPTER 6. – CIVIL SERVICE
§ 6- 30 Collective Bargaining
A. Statement of policy.
It is the public policy of the County of Arlington and the purpose of this Section
to promote orderly and constructive relationships between the county and its
employees subject, however, to the supreme right of the citizens of the county
that their government honor guarantees for their health, safety, welfare, and the
uninterrupted ope rations and functions of government. Because unresolved
disputes between the county and its employees are detrimental to the public and
to county employees, adequate means must be established for their speedy and
effective resolution. Within the limitation s required by the greater public interest,
and recognizing that amicable relationships are desired between the county and
its employees, the county board has determined that the overall polic ies set forth
here may best be accomplished by (1) granting to county employees the right to
organize and choose freely their representatives; (2) permitting the county to
negotiate and bargain in good faith with employee organizations representing
county employees and to e nter into written agreements evidencing the result of
such bargaining; and (3) establishing procedures to provide for the protection of
the rights of the county, county employees and the public at large.
The county board establishes this policy with the intent that county employees
enjoy the right to bargain collectively with in parameters that promote a
government that provides effective and efficient services that are responsive to
the community and focused on improving quality of life through the services of
staff who value and work to achieve and maintain a high performance work
environment characterized by commitment to integrity, inclusiveness, innovation,
efficiency and transparency.
18
2
B. - Definitions.
As used in this County Code Section, the following terms shall have the
meanings set forth below:
Arbitration means the procedure by which the county and an exclusive
bargaining representative submit their differences to a third party for decision
where permitted under Section N of this ordinance .
Benefits means, for the purpose of this Section, leave (paid and unpaid,
vacation, and holidays) , insurance (including contributions and levels of
coverage) and matters pertaining to the county-provided retirement, pension or
deferred compensation/savings plan(s) .
County means the County of Arlington acting through its county manager or
the county manager's designee.
Collective Bargaining means to perform the mutual obligation of the county,
by its representatives, and the exclusive bargaining representative of employees
in an appropriate bargaining unit to meet and negotiate in good faith a t reasonable
times and places , with the intent to reach an agreement regarding terms and
conditions of employment as defined herein, which agreement shall remain in
effect until superseded by a new agreement, subject to appropriation of fund s by
the county board. Collective bargaining shall not mean negotiation as to matters
controlled or preempted by any federal or state constitutional provision, law, rule
or regulation.
Collective bargaining agreement means the written legal contract between
the county and an exclusive bargaining agent representing the employees in a
bargaining unit authorized by this Section and resulting from collective bargaining
as defined in this subsection.
Confidential employee means any employee who works in:
(1) any office of a county board member;
(2) the Office of the County Manager;
(3) the Office of the County Attorney;
(4) the Department of Human Resources ;
(5) the Department of Management and Finance; or
19
3
(6) in a position, wherever assigned, with authorized access to confidential
information pertaining to county budgetary or fiscal data or confidential
personnel information pertaining to collective bargaining matters.
Employee means any employee of the county, except it does not include
anyone who is:
(1) a confidential employee , as defined in this subsection;
(2) a managerial employee , as defined in this subsection;
(3) a supervisor, as defined in this section ;
(4) temporary seasonal or grant funded employees as defined in applicable
county administrative regulations and temporary regular or temporary
occasional employed less than 500 hours in a calendar year ;
(5) an intern or volunteer;
(6) a member of a board or commission , or other appointee of any public body
as defined in state law, who is not otherwise an employee of the County ; or
(7) an employee of the courts or of any local constitutional officer as set forth
in Article VII, Section 4 of the Virginia Constitution, whether or not the
county provides perso nnel administrative services or supplements state or
other funding provided for the personnel of such officers.
Employee organization means an organization in which employees
participate, and that exists for the purpose , in whole or in part, of representing
employees in collective bargaining concerning labor disputes, wages, hours, and
other terms and conditions of employment .
Employee contract dispute means a difference of position as between the County
and an employee belonging to a bargain ing unit concerning administration,
interpretation or application of the collective bargaining agreement. It shall not
mean disciplinary actions such as dismissals, demotions or suspensions.
20
4
Exclusive bargaining representative and exclusive bargaining agent mean the
employee organization recognized by the County as the only organization to
bargain collectively for all employees in a bargaining unit (as defined in
subsection F).
Impasse means the failure of the county and an exclusive bargaining
representative to reach agreement in the course of collective bargaining
negotiations.
Labor-management dispute means a difference of position as between the
county and an exclusive bargaining agent ; action challenged as a prohibited
practice under subsection P; negotiability of subject matters ; and questions of
eligibility of disputes for resolution by mediation or arbitration. It shall not mean
disciplinary or other adverse personnel actions within the meaning of Virginia
Code Section 15.2 -1506, et seq., as implemented by the uniformly applicable
county grievance procedure, and state statutory procedures applicable to law
enforcement officers and fire and emergency medical services employees.
Managerial employee means any individual who:
(1) has responsibility for a unit or sub -unit of a division of an agency or
department;
(2) participates in the formulation of policy;
(3) is significantly engaged in executive or management functions ;
(4) is charged with the responsibility of directing the implementation of
management policies, procedures or practices; or
Mediation means an effort by a neutral, third -party factfinder chosen under the
terms of this Section to assist in resolving a n impasse or labor-management
dispute as provided in Section N.
Professional employee means an employee whose primary duty is the
performance of work requiring knowledge of an advanced type in a field of science
or learning customarily acquired by a prolonged course of specialized intellectual
instruction; or requiring invention, imagination, originality or talent in a
recognized field of artistic or creative endeavor.
21
5
Supervisor means any individual who customarily and regularly devotes
work time to supervision and has authority to hire, transfer, suspend, layoff ,
recall, promote, demote, discharge, assign, evaluate, reward or discipline other
employees, or adjust grievances, or effectively to recommend any such action s.
With respect to the Fire Department, "supervisor" includes all personnel at the
rank of battalion chief or above. With respect to the Police Department,
"supervisor" includes all personnel with the rank of captain or above.
Strike means, in concerted action with others, an employee's refusal to report
to duty or willful absence from their position, or stoppage of work, for the
purpose of inducin g, influencing, or coercing a change in the conditions,
compensation, rights, privileges or obligations of public employment.
Technical employee means an individual whose work requires a combination
of basic scientific or technical knowledge or manual skill that can be obtained
through specialized post -secondary school education or through equivalent on -
the-job training.
Terms and Conditions of Employment means wages, salaries and all forms of
monetary compensation, benefits, personnel policies and practices, and working
conditions. The term does not include matters reserved to management's sole
discretion in subsection D.
C. - Employee Rights.
1. Employees shall have the right to organize, form, join, assist, and pay dues
or contributions to employee organizations, to bargain collectively through an
exclusive bargaining representative of their own choosing, and to engage in
other concerted activiti es for the purpose of collective bargaining or other
mutual aid and protection insofar as such activity is not inconsistent with this
Section or prohibited by any other applicable law. Employees shall also have
the right to refrain from any or all such activities.
2. A collective bargain ing agreement provision that violates the rights of
employees set forth in this section shall be void . A collective bargaining
agreement provision that establishes a time period for the exercise of an
employee right set forth in this subsection shall not violate this section.
3. The county and each employee organization will refrain from any
intimidation, coercion, or harassment o f employees who choose to exercise
their rights under this subsection.
22
6
D. - County's Rights and Authority.
The county shall at all times retain exclusive rights regarding the
following non-negotiable matters/subjects :
a) to hire, promote and classify all employees ; and to, suspend, demote,
discharge, or take other disciplinary action against employees for cause;
and to establish criteria for all such actions listed herein and make the ultimate
decision as to which employee(s) such actions wil l apply, except that the
venue for the final step in the County’s grievance procedure available to
challenge such county decisions shall be negotiable, to the extent consistent
with Virginia law;
(b) to lay off employees or effect a reduction -in-force or to transfer, assign or
retain employees , except that the County Manager shall, upon request,
negotiate procedures to implement such actions and arrangements for
employees affected by such actions and such negotiations shall be governed
by N(2)(c);
(c) to establish and change standards of behavior or performance, job
qualifications and job description s;
(d) to determine the goals, objectives, functions, structure and supervision of
departments, divisions and offices of government;
(e) to do all things reasonable and necessary to carry out the mission of the
county in emergencies declared in accordance with applicable federal, state or
local laws, regulations and policies; and
(f) to establish the county budget and appropriate funds in the county board's
discretion in accordance with applicable law.
E. – Official Work Time
1. Where no exclusive bargaining agent has been reco gnized as the
representative of the employees involved, s olicitation of support,
23
7
membership, or dues, or engaging in any other employee organization
activities is not permitted when the employee (s) involved is on duty unless
authorized in a collective bargaining agreement provided, however, that this
section shall not be applied in a m anner that discriminates against casual non -
disruptive conversation in the workplace.
2. Any employee representing an exclusive bargaining agent in the
negotiation of an agreement under this Section shall be authorized official
time for such purposes, including attendance at an impasse resolution
proceeding, during the time the employee otherw ise would be in a duty
status, but only to the extent reasonable and consistent with county
operations and service demands . Exclusive bargaining agents retain the
exclusive right to determine who shall represent them at any negotiation and
the County’s det ermination of its operations and service demands under this
section shall not infringe on that right.
F. - Bargaining units.
The county shall recognize only the following bargaining units for the purposes of
collective bargaining:
1. Police: The police employees ' bargaining unit shall consist of all sworn
uniformed employees of the police department, except those excluded by
definition under subsection B;
2. Fire and Emergency Medical Services: The fire and emergency medical
services employees' bargaining unit shall consist of the uniformed fire
employees, including fire marshals, except those excluded by definition
under subsection B;
3. Service, Labor & Trades (SL&T): Those eligible classes of full -time
employees associated with service/maintenance and skilled crafts, i.e., job
classes of workers performing duties that result directly in the comfort,
convenience and well -being of the general public, or contribute to the
maintenance of capital assets, land and infrastructure of the county ;
4. Office and Technical employees (O&T): Those eligible cla sses of workers
other than employees included in the Service, Labor and Trades units or the
Professional employees unit.
24
8
5. Professional employees: employees meeting the definition of Professional
employee in the County Code section.
G. – Labor Relations Administrator
1. A labor relations administrator (LRA or the administrator) shall be
appointed by the county manager within 90 days of the effective date of this
ordinance in the manner set forth in subsection 3, below, to effectively
administer this Section as it governs exclusive bargaining representative
selection, bargaining unit membership, certification and decertification
procedures, negotiation impasses, labor-management disputes, prohibited
practices, and choice of mediator/arbitrator as needs arise under this Section or
any collective bargaining agreement.
2. The administrator must be experienced as a neutral in the field of labor
relations, and must not be a person who, because of vocation, employment, or
affiliation, can be categorized as a representative of the interest of the county or
any employee organization, including an exclusive bargaining agent for a
bargaining unit permitted under this Section.
3. The county manager shall appoint the labor relations administrator who shall
be selected from a list of no more than 3 (three) nominees jointly developed by
a committee made up of the exclusive bargaining agents of the bargaining units
permitted by this Section and an equal number of designees of the county
manager. The administrator so appointed shall serve a 4-year term.
If, as of the time LRA services are first required, no exclusive bargaining
agent(s) have yet been recognized by the county under this Section, a labor
relations administrator meeting the qualifications described in this subsection
shall be appointed for a 4-year term by the county manager following
consultation with employee organizations from whom the county manager has
received notice of interest in representing county employees.
4. The administrator's services shall be subject to termination by the county
manager or the exclusive bargaining agents of the bargaining units permitted by
this Section, if any.
25
9
5. If the administrator dies, resigns, becomes disabled, or otherwise becomes
unable or ineligible to continue to serve within six (6) months of the date of
appointment, the county manager must appoint a new administrator from the
list from which that administrator was selected to serve the remainder of the
previous administrator’s term. Otherwise, the administrator vacancy shall be
filled as provided in subsection 3.
6. An administrator appointed under this subsection may be reappointed in
accordance with the provisions of subsection 3.
7. The terms of payment for the services of the administrator shall be set as
specified by contract with the county.
8. The administrator shall:
(a) hold and conduct elections for certification or decertification pursuant
to the provisions of this Section and issue the certification or
decertification or cause these actions to occur.
(b) request from the county or an employee organization, and the county
or such organization shall provide, any relevant assistance, service, and
data that will enable the administrator to properly carry out duties under
this subsection.
(c) hold hearings and make inquiries, administer oaths and affirmations,
examine witnesses and documents, take testimony and receive evidence,
and compel by issuance of subpoenas the attendance of witnesses and the
production of relevant documents, to the extent permitted by applicable
law, in proceedings within the responsibility of the administrator under
this subsection.
(d) investigate and attempt to resolve or settle, as provided in subsection
N - Mediation and Arbitration, charges of either the county or an
employee organization engaging in prohibited practices as defined in this
Section. However, if the county and a certified representative have
negotiated a labor-management dispute resolution procedure, the
administrator must defer to that procedure to resolve any dispute that
properly may be submitted to the procedure, absent a showing that the
26
10
deferral results in the application of principles contrary to this
Section. The administrator must defer to state procedures in any matter
governed by the Law-Enforcement Officers’ or Firefighters and
Emergency Medical Technicians' Bill of Rights set forth in the Virginia
Code.
(e) determine unresolved issues of employee inclusion in or exclusion
from the bargaining units permitted under this Section except as limited
by definition as set forth in subsection B.
(f) obtain any necessary support services and make necessary
expenditures in the performance of duties, subject to appropriation.
(g) determine any issue regarding the negotiability of any collective
bargaining proposal as a subject of bargaining permitted under this
article.
(h) Exercise any other powers and perform any other duties and functions
specified in this article of an administrative nature.
H. - Recognition of exclusive bargaining agent.
(1) A bargaining agent shall be the exclusive representative of all
employees in an appropriate bargaining unit described in subsection F if
the employee organization is selected by a majority of the employees
voting in an appropriate bargaining unit in an election conducted pursuant
to subsection I, and rules and procedures adopted by the LRA, following a
request for recognition. A ny cost of such election shall be shared equally
by the parties involved.
(2) "Administratively acceptable evidence" to support a petition for
recognition or certification by election or for decertification may consist of
a combination of membership card s or a membership roster, evidence of
dues payment, or other evidence of bargaining unit employees' desire to be
represented by an employee organization for collective bargaining
purposes. An authorization that satisfies the Uniform Electronic
Transactions Act (Virginia Code § 59.1 -479 et seq.) including shall be
valid for employees' authorization for purposes of a petition filed by a labor
organization for exclusive representation. The determination by the LRA of
27
11
the sufficiency of a showing of support for a representation election shall
not be subject to challenge by any person or employee organization or by
the county.
I. - Request for election.
(1) An employee organization may request an election be held by
submitting a petition for an election to the LRA who shall notify the county
manager in accordance with procedures set and published by the LRA,
including but not limited to provisions for public notice of a petition and
election. The petition must represent a showing of interest by at least thirty
(30) percent of the employees in a bargaining unit described in subsection
F, based upon administratively acceptable evidence .
(2) Any additional interested employee organization must submit a petition
of intervention to the LRA, which must be accompanied by a showing of
interest by thirty (30) percent of the employees in the
appropriate bargaining unit, based upon administratively ac ceptable
evidence, within ten (10) days of notice of the petition.
(3) An election under this subsection shall be held within forty -five (45)
calendar days after written notice to all parties and the public of the
determination by the LRA of a valid petition for election in accordance
with guidelines established by the LRA. If an employee organization
receives a majority of the valid ballots cast by the employees in a permitted
bargaining unit, it shall be recognized by the county as the
exclusive bargaining agent, unless and until the LRA certifies a different
organization or otherwise decertifies the agent in accordance with
provisions of this Section. However, the county or the employee
organization may file exceptions with the LRA in accordance with its rules ,
and the county need not recognize the employee organization pending the
resolution of any process to review those exceptions. In an election in
which none of the choices on the ballot receives a majority, a runoff
election shall be conducted in which the ballot shall provide for a selection
between the two choices or parties receiving the highest and second highest
number of ballots cast in the election.
(4) Nothing in this Section shall require or permit an election in
any bargaining unit within twelve (12) months after a previous election has
been held in such bargaining unit.
28
12
(5) No party shall have an advantage over the other in gaining access to
employees during organizational or representation campaign activity.
J. - Decertification.
(1) Recognition of an employee organization as the exclusive bargaining agent
for a bargaining unit permitted by this Section shall continue only so long as
such organization satisfies the criteria of this Section.
(2) If a petition for decertification of a r ecognized exclusive bargaining agent
is presented to the LRA showing, based upon administratively acceptably
evidence, that at least thirty (30) percent of the employees in
the bargaining unit no longer want the employee organization to be
their bargaining agent, then the LRA shall hold an election in the manner
prescribed in sub section I.
(3) A petition for decertification of a recognized exclusive collective
bargaining agent in an appropriate unit may be filed in a thirty -day (30) period
between the one hundred eightieth (180th) and one hundred fiftieth (150th) day
prior to expiration of any existing collective bargain ing agreement for
that bargaining unit or any time after that collective bargain ing agreement has
expired.
(4) For a period of one (1) year following recognition or certification of an
exclusive bargaining agent, no decertification petitions may be filed .
(5) An employee organization no longer shall be recognized as the exclusive
bargaining agent of the employees in the bargaining unit if a majority of the
employees in the appropriate bargaining unit vote in the decertification
election to no longer be represented by the employee organization.
Decertification shall be effective upon the LRA's certification of the results of
such election.
K. – Rights Accompanying Exclusive Representation.
Any employee organization recognized as the bargaining agent for
employees in an appropriate bargaining unit shall have the following
rights:
29
13
(1) To speak on behalf of all members of the unit and represent the
interests of all members of the bargaining unit without discrimination
and without regard to employee organization membership; and
(2) To meet at reasonable times and places to engage in good
faith collective bargaining on matters that, under this Section, may be
the subject of collective bargaining, in an effort to reach an agreement,
subject to the approval of the county manager or his/her designee with
responsibility for the employees in the bargaining unit.
(3) To meet with bargaining unit employees on the premises of the
county in non-secure areas during times when the employees are on
break or in a non-duty status. Any other employee organization that has
submitted a petition and established a valid question concerning
representation of the bargaining unit shall also be permitted to meet with
bargaining unit employees with the same limitations. This subsection
shall not restrict an exclusive bargaining agent and the county from
negotiating for greater access to employees by the exclusive bargaining
agent as provision of a collective bargaining agreement.
(4) To meet with newly hired employees, without charge to the pay or
leave time of any of the employees for a maximum of 30 minutes , within
30 calendar days from the date of hire during new employee orientations,
or if the employer does not conduct new employee orientations, at
individual or group meetings.
(5) To be the only labor organization eligible to receive from the county
amounts deducted from the pay of employees as authorized by written
assignment of the employees, for the payment of regular and periodic
dues to the exclusive bargaining agent, unless two exclusive bargaining
agents of county employees agree that they can both receive deductions
from the same employee. Any such authorization may be revoked in
accordance with the terms of the authorization which shall provide a
period of irrevocability of not more than one year. An authorization that
satisfies the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (Virginia Code § 59.1-
479 et seq.) shall be valid for employees' authorizations for payroll
deductions.
(6) To be represented at any formal discussion between one or more
representatives of the county and one or more employees in the
bargaining unit or their representatives concerning (a) any matter that is
within the scope of collective bargaining as set forth in the definition of
30
14
collective bargaining (see subsection B); or (b) any examination of
bargaining unit employees by a representative of the county in
connection with an investigation if the employee reasonably believes that
the examination involves matters covered by any collective bargaining
agreement then in effect, or the employee reasonably believes they may
be disciplined based on the subject of the examination, and the employee
requests representation.
(7) Notwithstanding any other provision in this Section, an individual
employee may present a personal complaint or question at any time to the
county without the intervention of an employee organization, provided
that any such organization that is recognized by the county as the
exclusive bargaining agent for the bargaining unit in which the employee
is a member is afforded an effective opportunity to be present and to
offer its view at any meetings held to adjust the matter and that any
adjustment made shall not be inconsistent with the terms of any
applicable collective bargaining agreement. Such employee or employees
who utilize this avenue of presenting personal complaints to the county
shall not do so under the name, or by representation, of an employee
organization.
L. – Good Faith Bargaining.
(1) A written request for bargaining must be submitted by the exclusive
bargaining agent to the county manager no later than March 1, and
negotiations must begin by April 1 and conclude by October 1 of any year
where an agreement is sought to be effective at the beginning of the next fiscal
year, in order to accommodate the county budget process. Failure of the
parties to reach agreement by October 1, shall constitute impasse and trigger
impasse resolution proce dures under this Section.
(2) Nothing in this Section requires either party to make any concessions or
agree to the other party's proposals.
(3) Good faith bargaining shall not include submission of or a response to a
proposal that either violates the rights of employees as set forth in this Section,
or impairs, restricts, or delegates the authority of the county as set forth in
subsection D provided, however, that the County Manager shall, upon request,
negotiate regarding proposals addressing the impact of county decisions that
substantially impact the general working conditions of two or more employees
made pursuant to authorities in subsecti on D and the procedures the county
shall follow as it implements such decisions, and such negotiations shall be
31
15
governed by N(2)(c). During the term of unexpired collective bargaining
agreement, the County shall have the right to implement a proposed chan ge
upon agreement with the exclusive representative or at impasse.
(4) The county manager shall designate or appoint the county's
representative(s) in collective bargaining negotiations in the county manager’s
sole discretion. The exclusive representative shall designate its
representatives at its sole discretion.
M. - Approval of tentative agreement.
(1) When an exclusive bargaining agent and the county manager’s bargaining
representative reach a tentative agreement, they shall reduce it to writing and
execute it signifying the approval of the bargaining agent and the
county manager. No agreement shall be effective or enforceable , however,
until:
(a) a fiscal impact study of the tentative agreement is prepared by the county’s
Department of Management and Finance ;
(b) the fiscal impact study of the tentative agreement is submitted to the
county board, and a public hearing held no later than the November Board
Meeting on the fiscal impact of the tentative agreement; and
(c) the county board specifies by resolution the December Board Meeting its
good faith commitment to appropriate funding necessary for the county to meet
obligations under the tentative agreement as set forth in the fiscal impact study
provided for in this subsection, with the understanding that any such resolution
remains subject to actual appropriation. If the board does not resolve to fund
any provision(s) of the tentative agreement requiring appropriation, the county
manager or the exclusive bargaining agent may re -open negotiations on those
provisions which shall be scheduled as p romptly as possible with the good
faith objective to negotiate provisions that may be acceptable to the board for
its consideration within the county’s budget approval schedule. Upon
presentation to the board of any tentative agreement re -negotiated under this
subsection, the board shall consider and specify by resolution as soon as
practicable its good faith commitment to appropriate funding necessary for the
county to meet obligations under the tentative agreement, with the
32
16
understanding that any such resolution remains subject to actual appropriation;
and
(d) the tentative agreement is approved b y:
(i) the county manager or county manager's designee with supervisory
responsibility for the employees in the bargaining unit as evidenced by
signature, which may be an electronic signature made in accordance with
applicable state law; and
(ii) the exclusive bargaining agent by ratification in accordance with the
bargaining agent's governing procedures and evidenced by the signature of
an authorized agent which may be an electronic signature made in
accordance with applicable state law .
(2) A written agreement shall be contrary to public policy and therefore shall
not bind the parties or be enforceable by either party to the extent that it is not
the result of good faith bargaining as defined in this Section.
N. – Mediation, Arbitration, Grievance Procedures.
(1) Mediation.
(a) Labor-Management Disputes : The county and an exclusive bargaining
agent shall first attempt to resolve labor -management disputes informally by
discussion between the parties' designees. In the event that the county and
the bargaining agent are unable to informally resolve a labor-management
dispute, either party or the parties jointly may submit the dispute to the LRA
for mediation pursuant to procedures instituted by the LRA.
(b) Impasse: If after a reasonable period of negotiation over the terms of an
agreement there is a d ispute over specific issues between the county and the
bargaining agent, an impasse may be called by either party and resolution may
be sought by submission of those issues for mediation by the LRA or a
mediator selected through procedures established by the LRA . The parties
shall jointly request mediation within five (5) days of such a declared impasse.
Whether impasse is declared as set forth here or triggered by operation of
subsection L due to f ailure to reach agreement by October 1 as provided
therein, the LRA or other mediator shall set reasonable deadlines for all steps
of the mediation process. Negotiations on other matters may continue
throughout impasse procedures.
33
17
(c) The mediation process is advisory only, and the LRA or other mediator
shall have no authority to bind either party .
(d) The mediation process and any comments, statements or suggestions from
the LRA or other mediator or the parties and any documents evidencing the
same made or created during the mediation process shall not be disclosed
except as required by law or by agreement of the parties .
(e) The parties shall share the costs of mediation equally .
(2) Arbitration:
(a) If the county and exclusive bargaining agent are unable to reach
agreement in mediation to resolve (i) any impasse regarding wages,
salaries and any forms of monetary compensation, benefits, working
conditions affecting physical health and safety and related equipment,
administrative procedures/processes for lay -offs or reductions -in-force,
and administrative procedures/processes for promotion , or (ii) any labor-
management dispute by any deadline set forth in procedures provided in
this Section or adopted by the LRA, such impasse as described in this
subsection N(2)(a) or labor-management dispute shall be submitted to
final and binding arbitration pursuant to procedures adopted by the LRA
which shall, at a minimum, require the parties' joint selection of an
arbitrator. The parties shall share the costs of arbitration equally.
(b) Each collective bargaining agreement shall contain an employee
contract dispute resolution procedure, culminating in final and binding
arbitration. This negotiated contract dispute resolution procedure shall be
the exclusive procedure available to an employee of a bargaining unit
covered by that agreement unless the employee contract dispute is also a
grievable matter under Va. Code 15.2 -1507(excluding disciplinary actions
such as dismissals, demotions or suspensions ), in which case the
employee may elect to file an employee contract dispute under the
procedures in the collective bargaining agreement, or file a grievance
under the procedures guaranteed by Va Code 15.2 -1507 and any other
applicable state laws. The employ ee contract dispute procedure and
grievance procedure shall be mutually exclusive, and an employee’s initial
election to file an employee contract dispute or grievance shall be binding
and irrevocable at the time of filing.
34
18
(c) Non-binding arbitration, in accordance with procedures established by
the LRA, shall be available for resolution of impasses regarding any
matters not set forth in subsection N(2) (a) above. In the event that the
County does not implement the recommendations or resolutions resulting
from non-binding arbitration, the County Manager shall, at the next
meeting of the County Board, explain why he has not accepted the
recommendation
In making any decision under the impasse procedure authorized by this
subsection N(2)(a), the arbitrator shall give weight to the following
factors:
a. The lawful authority of the County;
b. Stipulations of the parties;
c. The interests and welfare of the public;
d. The financial ability of the e mployer to meet the costs of any items
to be included in the agreement;
e. Comparison of wages, hours, and terms and conditions of
employment of the employees involved in the arbitration
proceedings with the wages, hours, and terms and conditions of
employment of other persons performing similar services in the
public and private sectors, if applicable;
f. The average consumer prices for goods and services, commonly
known as the cost of living;
g. The overall compensation presently received by the employees
involved in the arbitration;
h. Changes in any of the foregoing circumstances during the pendency
of the arbitration proceedings; and
i. Such other factors that are normally or traditionally taken into
consideration in the determination of wages, hours, and terms and
conditions of employment through voluntary collective bargaining,
mediation, arbitration, or otherwise between the parties, in the
public sector.
O. - Strikes and other job actions.
(1) Pursuant to Virginia Code § 40.1-55, any employee of the county or of any
agency or authority of the county who, in concert with two or more other such
employees, strikes or willfully refuses to perform the duties of their
35
19
employment shall be deemed by that action to have terminated their
employment and shall be ineligible for employment in any position or cap acity
during the next 12 months by the county, the Commonwealth of Virginia or
any county, county, town or political subdivision of the Commonwealth or any
department of any such public entities. The county agrees that no lockout
shall take place.
(2) Any employee organization determined to have violated this subsection
shall cease to be accorded recognition under this Section, shall cease to
receive any dues or fees collected by paycheck withholding and shall not be
accorded recognition or receive any dues or fees collected by paycheck
withholding for a period of one (1) year.
P. – Prohibited Practices
Neither the county nor any exclusive bargaining agent shall refuse to
negotiate in good faith with respect to matters within the scope of collective
bargaining as defined in subsection B.
(1) The county and its agents shall not:
(a) Interfere with, restrain or coerce employees in the exercise of rights
granted by this Section;
(b) Dominate or interfere in the administration of any employee
organization;
(c) Encourage or discourage membership in any employee organization,
committee, or association including by discrimination in hiring, tenure, or
other terms and conditions of employment;
(d) Discharge or discriminate against any employee because the
employee has filed an affidavit, petition, or complaint or given any
information or testimony under this subsection or because the employee
has formed, joined, or chosen to be represented by any exclusive
bargaining agent;
(e) Deny the rights accompanying certification as the exclusive
bargaining agent as conferred by this Section;
(f) Refuse to bargain collectively with the recognized exclusive
bargaining agent as provided in this Section;
(g) Refuse to participate in good faith in any agreed-upon impasse
resolution procedures or those set forth in this Section; or
36
20
(h) Refuse to reduce a collective bargaining agreement to writing and
sign such agreement provided all conditions for an enforceable
agreement, as set forth in this Section and under other applicable law,
have been met.
(2) No employee organization or its agents shall:
(a) Interfere with, restrain, or coerce any employee with respect to rights
granted in this Section or with respect to selecting an exclusive
representative;
(b) Fail to represent an employee who is in a bargaining unit exclusively
represented by the employee organization fairly regarding negotiation
and administration of collective bargaining agreements and without
discrimination, provided such failure is willful or deliberate;
(c) Refuse to bargain collectively with the county as provided in this
Section; or
(d) Refuse to participate in good faith in or violate any agreed-upon
impasse resolution procedures or those set forth in this Section.
(3) Prohibited practice charge procedures.
(a) Proceedings against a party alleging a violation of this
subsection shall be commenced by filing a charge with the LRA
within 90 days of the alleged violation, or acquiring knowledge
thereof, and causing a copy of the charge to be served upon the
accused party in the manner of an original notice as provided in
subsection R. The accused party shall have 10 days within which
to file a written answer to the charge. The LRA may conduct a
preliminary investigation of the alleged violation, and if the LRA
determines that the charge has no legal or factual basis, they may
dismiss the charge. If the charge is not dismissed, the LRA shall
promptly thereafter set a time and place for a hearing. The parties
shall be permitted to be represented by counsel or other
designated representative, summon witnesses, and request the
LRA to subpoena witnesses and the production of records on the
requester's behalf. Compliance with the technical rules of
pleading and evidence shall not be required.
(b) The LRA may designate a hearing officer to conduct any
hearing. The hearing officer shall have such powers as may be
37
21
exercised by the LRA for conducting the hearing and shall follow
procedures adopted by the LRA for conducting the hearing. The
decision of the hearing officer may be appealed to the LRA and
the LRA may hear the case de novo or upon the record as
submitted before the hearing officer.
(c) The LRA, at their discretion, shall provide for an official
written transcript to report the proceedings, the costs of which
shall be borne equally by the parties.
(d) The LRA shall file its findings of fact and conclusions. If the
LRA finds that the party accused has violated any provision of
this subsection, the LRA may issue an order directing the party to
cease and desist engaging in the violation and may order such
other reasonable affirmative relief as is necessary to remedy the
violation. Under the provisions for court review of arbitration
awards set forth in the Uniform Arbitration Act (Virginia Code
§§8.01-581.01 et seq.), the LRA may petition the circuit court for
enforcement of an order made under this subsection.
(e) Any party aggrieved by any decision or order of the LRA may
within 21 days from the date such decision or order is filed,
appeal to the circuit court to obtain judicial review pursuant to
the provisions for judicial review set forth in the Uniform
Arbitration Act, Virginia Code §§8.01-581.01, et seq. A party
may seek enforcement an LRA or arbitrator’s decision or order in
accordance with the procedures of the Uniform Arbitration Act.
Q. - Time limits.
Any time limits in this Section may be extended by written agreement of the
county, the employee organization and any other appropriate parties.
R. – Notices.
Any notice required under the provisions of this Section shall be in writing,
but service of any such notice shall be sufficient if mailed by certified mail, return
receipt requested, addressed to the last-known address of the parties, unless
otherwise provided in this Section or by the rules of the LRA, which rules shall
provide for the electronic service of documents. Refusal of certified mail by any
38
22
party shall be considered service. Prescribed time periods shall commence from the
date of the receipt of the notice.
39
AYES: 8 NOES: 0 ABSTAIN:
ADOPTED: JUL 25 2022 REJECTED: STRICKEN:
INTRODUCED: July 18, 2022
AN ORDINANCE No. 2022-221
To amend ch. 2, art. VI of the City Code by adding therein a new div. 6, consisting of §§ 2 -
1301.1—2-1301.20, concerning collective bargaining, for the purpose of providing for collective
bargaining with certain City employees.
Patrons – All Members of Council and Mayor Stoney
Approved as to form and legality
by the City Attorney
PUBLIC HEARING: JUL 25 2022 AT 6 P.M.
THE CITY OF RICHMOND HEREBY ORDAINS:
§ 1. That Chapter 2, Article VI of the Code of the City of Richmond (2020) be and is
hereby amended by adding therein a new Division 6, consisting of sections numbered 2 -1301.1
through 2-1301.20, as follows:
DIVISION 6
COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
Sec. 2-1301.1. Statement of policy.
It is the public policy of the City of Richmond and the purpose of this division to promote
orderly and constructive relationships between the City and its employees subject, however, to
40
2
the supreme right of the citizens of the City that their government p rovides for their health,
safety, welfare, and the uninterrupted operations and functions of government. Because
unresolved disputes between the City and its employees are detrimental to the public and to City
employees, adequate means must be established for their speedy and effective resolution. Within
the limitations required by the greater public interest, and recognizing that amicable relationships
are required between the City and its employees, the City Council has determined that the overall
policies set forth here may best be accomplished by (1) granting to City employees the right to
organize and choose freely their collective bargaining representatives; (2) permitting the City to
negotiate and bargain in good faith with employee organizations repr esenting City employees
and to enter into written agreements evidencing the result of such bargaining; and (3)
establishing procedures to provide for the protection of the rights of the City, City employees
and the public at large.
The Council establishe s this policy with the intent that City employees enjoy the right to
bargain collectively within parameters that promote a government that provides ethical, effective
and efficient services that are responsive to the community and focused on improving qua lity of
life through the services of well -qualified staff who value and work to actively promote policies
(1) to achieve and maintain diversity, equity and inclusion in City government, and (2) to advance
all things reasonably necessary to achieve organiza tional excellence, while at all times elevating
principles of cooperation, ethics, honesty, initiative, and learning.
Sec. 2-1301.2. Definitions.
As used in this division, the following terms shall have the meanings ascribed to them in
this section:
41
3
Administrative employee means an employee whose primary duty is the performance of
office or non -manual work directly related to or in furtherance of the management or general
business operations and services of the City.
Arbitration means the pro cedure by which the City and an exclusive bargaining
representative when involved in a labor -management dispute, as defined in this section, submit
their differences to a third party for a final and binding decision subject to the provisions of this
division.
Benefits means, for the purpose of this division, all forms of non -wage compensation,
leave (including paid and unpaid, vacation, and holidays), insurance (including contributions
and levels of coverage), general supplemental retirement plans, and pol ice and fire retirement
plans presently made available under City authority.
City means the City of Richmond acting through the Chief Administrative Officer or the
Chief Administrative Officer’s designee.
Collective bargaining means to perform the mutual obligation of the City, by its
representatives, and the exclusive bargaining representative of employees in an appropriate
bargaining unit to meet and negotiate in good faith at reasonable times and places regarding
wages and benefits, as the term benefits is defined herein, hours, and other terms and conditions
of employment, including procedures to resolve employee grievances with the good faith
intention of reaching an agreement of no shorter duration than three years and remaining in effect
until superseded by a new agreement.
Collective bargaining agreement means the written legal contract between the City and
an exclusive bargaining agent representing the employees in a bargaining unit authorized by this
division and resulting from collective bargaining as defined in this section.
42
4
Confidential employee means any employee who works:
(1) Directly for a member of the City Council;
(2) For the Mayor;
(3) In the Office of the City Assessor, the Office of the City Attorney, the
Office of the City Auditor, t he Office of the City Clerk, the Office of the Council Chief
of Staff, or the Office of the Inspector General ;
(4) In the Department of Human Resources or any other department in which
the employee directly assists and acts in a confidential capacity to persons who formulate,
determine, and effectuate management policies in the field of labor relations ; or
(5) In the Department of Budget and Strategic Planning ;
Employee means any employee of the City, except it does not include anyone who is:
(1) An employee of the courts or of any officer elected pursuant to article VII,
section 4 of the Constitution of Virginia;
(2) A confidential employee, as defined in this section;
(3) A managerial employee, as defined in this secti on;
(4) A supervisor, as defined in this section;
(5) A temporary or seasonal employee, as defined in this section;
(6) An intern or volunteer;
(7) A member of a board or commission, or other appointee of any public
body as defined by Virginia law who is not otherwise an employee of the City ; or
(8) An attorney whose responsibilities include providing legal advice to the
City or performing legal research for the City as a client.
43
5
Employee organization means an organization in which employees participate, and that
exists for the purpose, in whole or in part, of representing employees in collective bargaining
concerning labor disputes, wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment.
Exclusive bargaining representative , exclusive bargaining agent , and bargaining agent
mean the employee organization recognized by the City as the only organization to bargain
collectively for all employees in a bargaining unit.
Impasse means the failure of the City and an exclusive bargaining representative to agree
upon the terms of a first or successor collective bargaining agreement in the course of collective
bargaining negotiations.
Labor-management dispute means an action challenged as a prohibited practice u nder
this division; a dispute as to the negotiability of subject matters; and question of eligibility of
disputes for resolution by mediation or impasse arbitration. It shall not mean disciplinary or other
adverse personnel actions within the meaning of Co de of Virginia, § 15.2 -1507(A)(1), as
implemented by any personnel rules adopted pursuant to section 2 -1265 or a grievance filed
pursuant to a negotiated grievance procedure.
Lockout means any action taken by the City intended to interrupt or prevent the continuity
of work properly and usually performed by employees for the purpose of coercing or intimidating
employees in the exercise of their rights conferred by this division, or influencing their exclusive
bargaining agents’ positions in collective barg aining contract negotiations.
Managerial employee means any individual who:
(1) Has responsibility for a unit or sub -unit of a division of an agency or
department;
(2) Participates in the formulation of policy;
44
6
(3) Is significantly engaged in executive or management functions;
(4) Is charged with the responsibility of directing the implementation of
management policies, procedures or practices; or
(5) Is involved in administration of collective bargaining agreements or
human resources or personnel decisions , including, but not limited to, staffing,
reductions-in-force or layoffs, reorganizations, hiring, discipline, evaluations, pay,
assignments, transfers, promotions or demotions.
Mediation means an effort by a neutral, third-party chosen under the terms of this division
to assist confidentially in resolving an impasse, as defined in this section, arising in the course
of collective bargaining between the City and the exclusive bargaining agent of a bargaining
unit, or the first step prior to arbitration of a labor-management dispute other than a prohibited
practice claim or charge.
Professional employee means an employee exempt from the Fair Labor Standards Act
pursuant to the Fair Labor Standards Act definition of a professional employee .
Seasonal employee means an employee who is hired into a position for which the
customary annual employment is three months or less and for which the period of employment
begins each calendar year in approximately the same part of the year, such as summer or winter,
for reasons related to work demands that arise during those parts of the year.
Supervisor means any individual who customarily and regularly devotes a majority of
work time to supervision of two or more employees and has authority to hire, transfer, suspend,
layoff, recall, promote, demote, discharge, assign, evaluate, reward or discipline other
employees, or adjust grievances, or effectively to recommend any such actions. With respect to
the Department of Fire and Emergency Services, “supervisor” includes all pers onnel at the rank
45
7
of battalion chief or above. With respect to the Department of Police, “supervisor” includes all
personnel at the rank of captain or above.
Strike means any strike or willful refusal to perform the duties of an employee’s
employment that would be deemed to terminate that employee’s employment pursuant to Code
of Virginia, § 40.1 -55.
Technical employee means an individual whose work requires a combination of basic
scientific or technical knowledge and manual skill that can be obtained through specialized
postsecondary school education or through equivalent on-the-job training.
Temporary employee means an individual who is employed by the City for not more than
150 consecutive days.
Sec. 2-1301.3. Employee rights.
(a) Employees shall have the right to organize, form, join, assist, and pay dues or
contributions to employee organizations, to bargain collectively through an exclusive bargaining
representative of their own choosing, and to engage in other concerted activities for the purpose
of collective bargaining or other mutual aid and protection insofar as such activity is not
inconsistent with this division or prohibited by any other applicable law. Employees shall also
have the right to refrain from any or all such activities.
(b) A collective bargain ing agreement provision that violates the rights of employees
set forth in this section shall be void. A collective bargain ing agreement provision that
establishes a time period for the exercise of an employee right set forth in thi s section shall not
violate this section. The City and each employee organization will refrain from any intimidation,
coercion, or harassment of employees who choose to exercise their rights under this division.
Sec. 2-1301.4. City’s rights and authority.
46
8
(a) This division shall not be deemed in any way to limit or diminish the authority of
the City to manage and direct the operations and activities of the City to the fullest extent
authorized and permitted by law. Thus, unless the City elects to bargain r egarding the following
matters, the City retains exclusive rights:
(1) To determine the type and scope of work to be performed by City employees
and the manner in which services are to be provided;
(2) To direct the work of employees;
(3) To (i) hire and classify all employees in accordance with applicable law; (ii)
to promote, transfer, assign, and schedule all employees, except that the procedures related
to such decisions shall be negotiable; and (iii) to suspend, demote, discharge, or take other
disciplinary action against employees for just cause in accordance with applicable law and
regulations, except that procedures to challenge such decisions shall be negotiable to the
extent consistent with state law;
(4) To relieve employees from duties by layoff or other reduction-in-force due
to lack of work, budget limitations, changed working conditions or requirements or for
other reasons in the City’s reasonable business judgment and not prohibited by law, except
that the implementation procedures to be follo wed, notice, and alternatives to layoff shall
be negotiable;
(5) To contract for, expand, reduce, sell, transfer, convey, or eliminate
particular operations or services of general government, as well as any department, office,
or part thereof; except that the alternatives to contracting and impact on employees shall
be negotiable; and
47
9
(6) To establish and change standards of behavior or performance, job
qualifications, and job descriptions, except that the impact of any changes on employees
and performance evaluation procedures will be negotiable.
(b) The City retains the right to take whatever actions may be necessary to carry out
the City’s mission during emergencies. If a collective bargaining agreement includes procedures
for how the City and its employees will respond to a specific type of emergency situation, then the
terms of such agreement shall govern the response to that specific emergency. Otherwise, the City
shall meet with the exclusive bargaining representative at the earliest practical time f ollowing
actions taken in response to an emergency to discuss the effects of such emergency actions on
bargaining unit employees as they pertain to matters within the scope of bargaining under this
division and to bargain in good faith over any supplemental collective bargaining agreements that
are proposed to address the effects of such emergency actions.
(c) In accordance with Code of Virginia, § 40.1-57.2 and other applicable law, nothing
in this division, any provision of this division, or the terms of any collective bargaining agreement
shall impair or restrict the authority of the City Council to establish its budget and appropriate
funds in its discretion. Any collective bargaining agreement reached under this division shall be
subject to the appropr iation of funds by the City Council.
(d) The City shall not negotiate as to :
(1) Matters controlled or preempted by any federal or state constitutional
provision, law, rule or regulation ;
(2) Any provision relating to the composition, duties, or powers of any
civilian review board applicable to police officers;
48
10
(3) Any previously rendered decision of any civilian review board applicable
to police officers or of the Personnel Board; or
(4) Any decision to retain the City’s existing retirement plan s as set forth in
Chapter 22 or to replace any or all of such plans with the retirement plan of the Virginia
Retirement System .
Sec. 2-1301.5. Employee activity on official work time; use of City communication
systems.
(a) Employees shall have the right t o hold informal conversations and interactions
with one another to discuss workplace and employee organization issues while on duty, provided
that such conversations do not interfere with the employee’s job duties.
(b) In the absence of a collective bargaining agreement or a provision in such an
agreement governing employee labor relations activity on official time, any employee
representing an employee organization that has been recognized as an exclusive bargaining agent
in the negotiation of an agreement under this division shall be authorized official time in amounts
reasonable for such purposes, including attendance at impasse resolution proceedings.
(c) Employees are not prohibited from, and shall not be penalized or retaliated against
for, using City electronic mail, telephone, facsimile transmission, bulletin board, or other
communication systems owned by the City to discuss employee organization business or
activities or employee organizing activities; however, the City remains the o wner of such
communication systems, and no employee shall have any expectation of privacy in the use of
such a communication system.
Sec. 2-1301.6. Bargaining units.
The City shall recognize only the following bargaining units for the purposes of collective
bargaining:
49
11
(1) Police. The police employees’ bargaining unit shall consist of all sworn employees
of the Department of Police.
(2) Fire and Emergency Services. The fire and emergency services employees’
bargaining unit shall consist of (i) the unifo rmed employees, including fire marshals , of the
Department of Fire and Emergency Services and (ii) the employees of the Department of
Emergency Communications.
(3) Labor and Trades. The labor and trades employees’ bargaining unit shall consist of
eligible classes of employees associated with maintenance and skilled crafts, i.e., job classes of
workers performing duties that result directly in the comfort and convenience of the general public,
or contribute to the maintenance of capital assets, land and infrastructure of the City.
(4) Professional. The professional employees’ bargaining unit shall consist of
nonsupervisory and non-managerial employees within the definition of “professional employee”
as set forth in section 2-1301.2.
(5) Administrative and Technical. The administrative and technical employees’
bargaining unit shall consist of non -supervisory and non -managerial employees who are
administrative employees or technical employees or who perform office support work and who are
not confidential employees.
Sec. 2-1301.7. Labor relations administrator.
(a) A labor relations administrator, referred to in this division as the “administrator,”
shall be selected and appointed in the manner set forth in subsection (c) of this section to effectively
administer this division as it governs exclusive bargaining representative selection, certification
and decertification procedures, labor -management disputes, and the methods for the selection of
50
12
mediators or arbitrators when needed under this division or u nder any collective bargaining
agreement.
(b) The administrator must be experienced as a neutral in the field of labor relations,
and must not be a person who, because of vocation, employment, or affiliation, can be categorized
as a representative of the interest of the City or any employee organization, including an exclusive
bargaining agent for a bargaining unit permitted under this division.
(c) The selection of the administrator will be conducted through competitive
negotiation for nonprofessional services as provided in Chapter 21 of this Code. Proposals will be
evaluated by a panel that will consist of an equal number of City representatives and either (i)
representatives of those employee organizations that have notified the Chief Administrative
Officer of their interest in representing bargaining units permitted by this division, if no bargaining
agents have been recognized at the time the selection process begins or (ii) representatives of the
bargaining agent for the bargaining unit permitted by t his division. The panel shall evaluate and
rank all proposals and recommend up to the three highest -ranked offerors for presentation to the
City Council for approval. The City Council shall approve one of the offerors presented to the
City Council as the administrator.
(d) The administrator shall be contracted for a four -year term, provided that the
administrator’s services shall be subject to termination by mutual agreement of the Chief
Administrative Officer and a majority of the exclusive bargaining ag ents of the bargaining units
permitted by this division, and with approval by the City Council by resolution.
(e) If the administrator dies, resigns, becomes disabled, or otherwise becomes unable
or ineligible to continue to serve within six months of init ial appointment, the administrator
vacancy shall be filled as provided in subsection (c).
51
13
(f) An administrator appointed under this section may be reappointed as provided in
subsection (c).
(g) The terms of payment for the services of the administrator shall be paid as specified
by contract with the City entered into pursuant to Chapter 21 of this Code.
(h) The administrator shall:
(1) Hold and conduct elections for certification or decertification pursuant to
the provisions of this division and issue the certification or decertification, or cause these
actions to occur.
(2) Request from the City or an employee organization, and the City or such
organization shall provide, any relevant assistance, service, and data that will enable the
administrator to properly carry out duties under this division.
(3) Hold hearings and make inquiries, administer oaths and affirmations,
examine witnesses and documents, take testimony and receive evidence, and compel by
issuance of subpoenas the attendance of witnesses an d the production of relevant
documents in proceedings within the responsibility of the administrator under this division.
(4) Investigate and attempt to resolve or settle, pursuant to this division, charges
of either the City or an employee organization engaging in prohibited practices as defined
in this division. However, if the City and a certified representative have negotiated a labor-
management dispute resolution procedure, the administrator must defer to that procedure
to resolve any dispute that pro perly may be submitted to the procedure, absent a showing
that the deferral results in the application of principles contrary to this division. The
administrator must defer to the procedures in Code of Virginia, §§ 9.1 -300—9.1-304 and
9.1-500—9.1-507, and any other procedure required by the Code of Virginia.
52
14
(5) Determine unresolved issues of employee inclusion in or exclusion from the
bargaining units permitted under this division.
(6) Obtain any necessary support services and make necessary expenditures in
the performance of duties, subject to appropriation.
(7) Determine any issue regarding the negotiability of any collective bargaining
proposal.
(8) Exercise any other powers and perform any other duties and functions
specified in this division of an administrative nature.
(9) Issue rules and regulations to carry out the duties of the administrator set
forth in this division, provided that the administrator shall provide the rules and regulations
for comment by the City, labor organizations, and other in terested parties before
implementing the rules and regulations.
(i) If, no fewer than 120 days after the adoption of the ordinance that initially
establishes this division, a petition is filed requesting certification of an exclusive bargaining
representative, a party seeks to file an prohibited practice claim, or any other labor-management
dispute arises and there is no administrator serving at the time, then the parties sh all submit the
certification petition or dispute to a mutually agreed upon interim neutral. The parties shall jointly
select an interim neutral from another Virginia locality available under section 21 -40 or, if they
are unable to agree on such an available interim neutral, they shall request a list of seven arbitrators
from the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service or American Arbitration Association. Each
party in turn shall strike a name from the list until only one name remains. The interim neutral
shall serve as the administrator under this division until an administrator is selected pursuant to
subsection (c).
53
15
Sec. 2-1301.8. Recognition of exclusive bargaining agent.
(a) A bargaining agent shall be the exclusive representative of all employees in an
appropriate bargaining unit described in section 2 -1301.6 if the employee organization is
selected by a majority of the employees voting in the bargaining unit in an election conducted
pursuant to this division and rules and procedures adopted by the administrator.
(b) In the event that more than one employee organization files a request for
recognition or for election within ten calendar days after a first request for recognition or for
election has been filed, an election to select an exclusive barg aining agent shall be held under
the rules and procedures adopted by the administrator. If an employee organization receives a
majority of the votes cast by the employees voting in an appropriate bargaining unit, it shall be
recognized by the City as the exclusive bargaining agent, provided, however, that the Chief
Administrative Officer or an employee organization may file exceptions to the election with the
administrator alleging that there has been misconduct which has affected the outcome of the
election, and the City need not recognize the employee organization pending the resolution of
any process to review those exceptions. Any cost of such election shall be shared equally by the
parties involved.
(c) “Administratively acceptable evidence” to support a petition for certification
within the meaning of Code of Virginia, § 40.1 -57.2(C) for certification or decertification under
this division may consist of a combination of membership cards or a membership roster,
evidence of dues payment, or other eviden ce of bargaining unit employees’ desire to be
represented by an employee organization for collective bargaining purposes. An authorization
that satisfies the Uniform Electronic Transactions Act (Code of Virginia, §§ 59.1 -479—59.1-
497), including, without limitation, electronic authorizations and voice authorizations, shall be
54
16
valid for employees’ authorization for representation for purposes of a petition filed by a labor
organization for exclusive representation. The determination by the administrator of the
sufficiency of a showing of majority support or for a representation election shall not be subject
to challenge by any person or employee organization or by the City.
Sec. 2-1301.9. Request for election.
(a) An employee organization may request an elec tion be held by submitting a
petition for an election to the administrator who shall notify the Mayor pursuant to its rules and
procedures. The petition must represent a showing of interest by at least 30 percent of the
employees in a bargaining unit permi tted by this division.
(b) Any additional interested employee organization must submit a petition of
intervention to the administrator, which must be accompanied by a showing of interest by 30
percent of the employees in the appropriate bargaining unit wit hin ten days of notice that a valid
petition for an election has been filed.
(c) A mail-ballot election under this division shall be held within 45 days after written
notice to all parties of the determination by the administrator of a valid petition for election in
accordance with guidelines established by the administrator. If an employee organiza tion
receives a majority of the valid ballots cast by the employees in a permitted bargaining unit, it
shall be recognized by the City as the exclusive bargaining agent, unless and until the
administrator certifies a different organization or otherwise dec ertifies the bargaining agent in
accordance with rules set forth in this section. In an election in which none of the choices on
the ballot receives a majority, a runoff election shall be conducted in which the ballot shall
provide for a selection between the two choices or parties receiving the highest and second
highest number of ballots cast in the election. However, the City or the employee organization
55
17
may file exceptions with the administrator in accordance with its rules, and the City will not
recognize the employee organization pending the resolution of any process to review those
exceptions.
(d) Nothing in this division shall require or permit an election in any bargaining unit
within 12 months after a previous election has resulted in the recogni tion of an exclusive
bargaining representative or a determination that the employees choose no representation in such
bargaining unit.
(e) No party shall have an advantage over the other in gaining access to employees
during organizational or representation campaign activity.
Sec. 2-1301.10. Decertification.
(a) If a petition for decertification of a recognized exclusive bargaining agent is
presented to the administrator showing that at least 50 percent of the employees in the bargaining
unit no longer want the employee organization to be their bargaining agent, then the
administrator shall hold an election pursuant to section 2 -1301.9.
(b) A petition for decertification of a recognized exclusive collective bargaining
agent in an appropriate unit may be file d in a 30 -day period between the one hundred eightieth
and one hundred fiftieth day prior to expiration of any existing collective bargaining agreement
for that bargaining unit or any time after that collective bargaining agreement has expired.
(c) For a p eriod of one year following recognition or certification of an exclusive
bargaining agent, no decertification petitions may be filed.
(d) The employee organization no longer shall be recognized as the exclusive
bargaining agent of the employees in the barg aining unit if a majority of the employees in the
appropriate bargaining unit vote in the decertification election to no longer be represented by the
56
18
employee organization and a final outcome of that election has been certified by the
administrator.
Sec. 2-1301.11. Rights of employee organizations and rights accompanying exclusive
representation.
(a) Employee organizations, whether or not certified as bargaining agents, shall have
the right , subject to section 2 -1293(d) and other applicable laws , to meet with bargaining unit
employees on City premises to which access is not restricted for security reasons during times
when employees are on break or off duty, including the right to conduct worksite meetings during
meal periods and other breaks and outside of the employees’ working hours .
(b) Any employee organization recognized as the bargaining agent for employees in
an appropriate bargaining unit shall have the following rights:
(1) To speak on behalf of all employees in the unit and shall be responsible for
representing the interests of all employees in the bargaining unit without discrimination
and without regard to employee organization membership;
(2) To meet at reasonable times and places to engage in good faith coll ective
bargaining on matters that, under this division, may be the subject of collective
bargaining, in an effort to reach an agreement, subject to the tentative approval of the
Chief Administrative Officer.
(3) To meet with bargaining unit employees on the premises of the City in non-
secure areas during times when the employees are on break or in a non -duty status. Any
other employee organization that has submitted a petition and established a valid question
concerning representation of the bargaining unit shall also be permitted to meet with
bargaining unit employees with the same limitations. This subsection shall not restrict an
57
19
exclusive bargaining agent and the City from negotiating for greater access to employees
by the exclusive bargaining agent as a provision of a collective bargaining agreement.
(4) To meet with newly hired employees, without charge to the pay or leave
time of any of the employees for a minimum of 30 minutes and a maximum of 60 minutes,
within 30 calendar days from the date of hire, immediately following new employee
orientations conducted by the City and in the same City location or, if the City fails to
conduct new employee orientation, during other group or individual meetings of new hires
on City premises. The union orientation shall be considered a part of any required new
City employee orientation , in the sequence described above . The City shall provide the
bargaining agent with ten days’ notice of the time and place of new employee orientations,
a list of expected participant s, and the opportunity to provide materials for distribution.
This subdivision shall not limit the parties from bargaining to further define this right.
(5) To be the only labor organization eligible to receive from the City amounts
deducted from the pay of employees as authorized by written assignment of the employees,
for the payment of regular and periodic dues to the exclusive bargaining agent, unless two
exclusive bargaining agents of City employees agree that they can both receive deductions
from the same employee. Any such authorization may be revoked in accordance with the
terms of the authorization. An authorization that satisfies the Uniform Electronic
Transactions Act (Code of Virginia, §§ 59.1 -479—59.1-497), including, without
limitation, electronic authorizations and voice authorizations, shall be valid for employees’
authorizations for payroll deductions and authorization for representation for purposes of
a petition filed by an employee organization for exclusive representation.
58
20
(6) To be repre sented at any formal discussion between one or more
representatives of the City and one or more employees in the bargaining unit or their
representatives concerning (i) any matter that is within the scope of collective bargaining
as set forth in this division’s definition of collective bargaining, or (ii) any examination of
bargaining unit employees by a representative of the City in connection with an
investigation if the employee reasonably believes that the examination involves matters
covered by any col lective bargaining agreement then in effect or any matter that may
reasonably lead to discipline of that employee, and the employee requests representation.
The City shall inform the employee of the employee’s right to union representation prior
to any such discussion or examination.
(c) Notwithstanding any other provision in this section, an individual employee may
present a personal complaint, concern or question at any time to the City without the intervention
of an employee organization, provided that any such organization that is recognized by the City as
the exclusive bargaining agent for the bargaining unit in which the employee is a member is
afforded an effective opportunity to be present and to offer its view at any meetings held to adjust
the matter and that any adjustment made shall not be inconsistent with the terms of any applicable
collective bargaining agreement. Such employee or employees who utilize this avenue of
presenting personal complaints, concerns or questions to the City shall not d o so under the name,
or by representation, of an employee organization.
Sec. 2-1301.12. Good faith bargaining.
(a) The bargaining agent must submit a written request to the Chief Administrative
Officer for any collective bargaining intended to result in a collective bargaining agreement to
become effective for a given fiscal year in time for collective bargaining to begin on or before July
59
21
1 of the preceding fiscal year and conclude, including any impasse resolution procedures, by
December 1 of the preceding fiscal year to ensure adequate time for inclusion in the Mayor’s
proposed budget for the given fiscal year.
(b) Nothing in this division requires either party to make any concessions or agree to
the other party’s proposals.
(c) Good faith bargaining shall not include submission of or a response to a proposal
that (i) violates the rights of employees as set forth in s ection 2-1301.3 or (ii) impairs, restricts,
or delegates any authority of the City that this division has explicitly reserved solely to the City.
(d) The Mayor shall designate or appoint the City’s representative(s) in collective
bargaining negotiations in the Mayor’s sole discretion.
(e) If an employee organization serves as the exclusive bargaining representative of
more than one bargaining unit, it shall consolidate its bargaining with the City and negotiate a
common master agreement on all matters not u nique to particular bargaining unit.
(f) The Chief Administrative Officer shall meet and confer with police and fire
supervisors ineligible to bargain collectively regarding matters within the scope of collective
bargaining as specified in this division wi th the specific intent to address salary compression, as
commonly defined or understood, resulting from collective bargaining with eligible police and
fire uniformed employees.
Sec. 2-1301.13. Collective bargaining agreement.
(a) No collective bargaining agreement shall be effective or enforceable until the City
Council has adopted an ordinance to approve the text of the collective bargaining agreement after
reviewing the fiscal impact statement required by this section and holding the requisite public
hearing.
60
22
(b) When the parties reach a tentative agreement, they shall reduce it to writing, and
the Chief Administrative Officer and the duly authorized representative of the bargaining agent
shall sign the tentative agreement to indicate their approvals. The bargaining agent’s signature
certifies that the bargaining unit has approved or ratified the tentative agreement in accordance
with the procedures or governing rules of the bargaining agent.
(c) No later than 60 days after the parties have signed the tentative agreement, the Chief
Administrative Officer shall (i) prepare a fiscal impact statement for the tentative agreement and
(ii) submit the tentative agreement with the fiscal impact statement for approval by the City
Council via ordinance in accordance with the City Council’s standard procedures and schedules.
(d) Should the City Council reject the tentative agreement, it may cause the Council
Chief of Staff to provide a detailed statement of the reasons for rejection to inform any further
negotiations. Any such negotiations shall be scheduled as promptly as possible with the good faith
objective to negotiate provisions that may be acceptable to the City Council for its consideration
as part of the City’s annual budget process.
(e) A collective bargaining agreement reached by the parties shall be contrary to public
policy and shall not bind the parties or be enforceable by either party to the extent that it is not the
result of good faith bargaining in accordance with section 2-1301.12.
Sec. 2-1301.14. Labor-management dispute and impasse resolution.
(a) Impasses.
(1) In the event that the City and the bargaining agent are unable to reach a
collective bargaining agreement within 120 days after their first meeting or September 1,
whichever is earlier, an im passe may be called by either party and resolution may be
sought by submission of any unresolved issues for mediation by the administrator or a
61
23
mediator selected through procedures established by the administrator. The parties shall
jointly request mediat ion within five days of a declared impasse. The administrator or
other mediator shall set reasonable deadlines for all steps of the mediation process.
Negotiations on all matters shall continue throughout impasse procedures.
(2) The mediation process is advisory only, and the administrator or other
mediator shall have no authority to bind either party.
(3) The mediation process and any comments, statements or suggestions from
the administrator or other mediator or the parties and any documents evidencing the same
made or created during the mediation process shall not be disclosed except as required
by law.
(4) The parties shall share the costs of mediation equally.
(5) At the request of either party, and not later than September 15, impasses
not resolved t hrough negotiation or mediation shall be submitted to non -binding fact -
finding. The parties shall jointly select a fact -finder or, if they are unable to agree on a
fact-finder, they shall request a list of seven arbitrators from the Federal Mediation and
Conciliation Service or American Arbitration Association. Each party in turn shall strike
a name from the list until only one name remains. Negotiations shall continue throughout
the impasse procedures.
(6) In making any decision under the impasse proced ure authorized by this
division, the fact -finder shall give weight to the following factors:
a. The lawful authority of the City;
b. Stipulations of the parties;
c. The interests and welfare of the public;
62
24
d. The financial ability of the employer to meet the costs of any items
to be included in the agreement;
e. Comparison of wages, hours, and terms and conditions of
employment of the employees involved in the arbitration proceedings with the
wages, hours, and terms and conditions of employment of oth er persons
performing similar services in the public and private sectors, if applicable;
f. The average consumer prices for goods and services, commonly
known as the cost of living;
g. The overall compensation presently received by the employees
involved in the arbitration;
h. Changes in any of the foregoing circumstances during the
pendency of the arbitration proceedings; and
i. Such other factors that are normally or traditionally taken into
consideration in the determination of wages, hours, and terms an d conditions of
employment through voluntary collective bargaining, mediation, arbitration, or
otherwise between the parties, in public service or in private employment.
(7) The fact-finder’s decisions shall be provided to the Chief Administrative
Officer and the bargaining agent not later than October 15 and, to the extent permitted
by law, shall not be made public for a period of 14 days. During this 14 -day period, the
parties shall meet and attempt to negotiate an agreement based on the fact -finder’s
recommendations. By mutual agreement, the 14 -day period may be extended.
(8) At the conclusion of the 14 -day period (or longer period agreed to by the
parties) period, the Chief Administrative Officer shall submit the last written bargaining
63
25
position of the City and of the bargaining agent on each issue that remains in dispute with
a copy of all of the fact -finder’s recommendations to the City Council.
(9) At its next meeting, the City Council shall provide 30 minutes to each of
the parties at impasse for the purposes of explaining and justifying its last offer and
thereafter render a decision on the matters subject to continuing impasse. The City
Council’s decision shall be final and not subject to further review.
(10) The expenses of the fact -finder shall be borne equally by the parties.
(b) Labor-management disputes.
(1) The City and a bargaining agent shall discuss the feasibility of resolution of
labor-management disputes informally by discussion between the parties’ designees before
resort to formal medi ation or arbitration. Failure to actually engage in such informal
resolution prior to submitting a labor-management dispute or prohibited practice claim for
mediation or arbitration shall not be a ground for dismissal of a claim under this division.
In the event that the City and the bargaining agent are unable to informally resolve a labor-
management dispute if and when engaged, either party or the parties jointly may submit
the dispute to the administrator for mediation or arbitration, if applicable, pu rsuant to
procedures instituted by the administrator.
(2) If the City and the bargaining agent are unable to reach agreement resolving
any labor-management dispute submitted to mediation as provided for in this division by
any deadline set forth in procedu res provided in this division or adopted by the
administrator, the labor -management dispute shall be submitted to final and binding
arbitration pursuant to procedures adopted by the administrator which shall, at a minimum,
64
26
require the parties’ joint select ion of an arbitrator. The parties shall share the costs of
arbitration equally.
Sec. 2-1301.15. Strikes and lockouts.
Pursuant to Code of Virginia, § 40.1 -55, any employee who, in concert with two or more
other such employees, strikes or willfully refuses to perform the duties of their employment shall
be deemed by that action to have terminated their employment and shall be ineligible for
employment in any position or capacity during the next 12 months by the City. The City shall
not engage in a lockout of employees from the workplace.
Sec. 2-1301.16. Prohibited practices.
(a) Neither the City nor any exclusive bargaining agent shall refuse to negotiate in
good faith with respect to matters within the scope of collective bargaining as def ined in this
division.
(b) The City and its agents shall not:
(1) Interfere with, restrain or coerce employees in the exercise of rights granted
by this division;
(2) Dominate or interfere in the administration of any employee organization;
(3) Encourage or discourage membership in any employee organization,
committee, or association including by discrimination in hiring, tenure, or other terms and
conditions of employment;
(4) Discharge or discriminate against any employee because the employee has
filed an affidavit, petition, or complaint or given any information or testimony under this
division or because the employee has formed, joined, or chosen to be represented by any
exclusive bargaining agent;
65
27
(5) Deny the rights accompanying certification as the e xclusive bargaining
agent as conferred by this division;
(6) Refuse to participate in good faith in any agreed -upon impasse resolution
procedures or those set forth in this division;
(7) Deter or discourage , or knowingly aid any other entity in deterring o r
discouraging, employees or applicants for City employment from becoming or remaining
members of an employee organization, authorizing representation by an employee
organization, authorizing dues or fee deductions to an employee organization, or exercising
any right of an employee under this division; or
(8) Refuse to reduce a collective bargaining agreement to writing and sign such
agreement provided all conditions for an enforceable agreement, as set forth in this
division, have been met.
(c) No employee organization or its agents shall:
(1) Interfere with, restrain, or coerce any employee with respect to rights
granted in this division or with respect to selecting an exclusive representative;
(2) Willfully fail to represent an employee who is in a bargai ning unit
exclusively represented by the employee organization fairly regarding matters within the
scope of collective bargaining, and without discrimination.;
(3) Refuse to bargain collectively with the City as provided in this division; or
(4) Refuse to participate in good faith in or violate any agreed -upon impasse
resolution procedures or those set forth in this division.
Sec. 2-1301.17. Prohibited practice charge procedures.
66
28
(a) Proceedings against a party alleging a violation of section 2 -1301.16 shall be
commenced by filing a charge with the administrator within 180 days of the alleged violation, or
acquiring knowledge thereof, and causing a copy of the charge to be served upon the accused party
in accordance with section 2-1301.19. The accused party shall have ten days within which to file
a written answer to the charge. The administrator may conduct a preliminary investigation of the
alleged violation, and if the administrator determines that the charge has no legal or factual basis,
they may dismiss the charge. If the charge is not dismissed, the administrator shall promptly
thereafter set a time and place for a hearing. The parties shall be permitted to be represented by
counsel or other designated representative, summon witnesses, and re quest the administrator to
subpoena witnesses and the production of records on the requester’s behalf. Compliance with the
technical rules of pleading and evidence shall not be required.
(b) The administrator may designate a hearing officer to conduct any hearing. The
hearing officer shall have such powers as may be exercised by the administrator for conducting
the hearing and shall follow procedures adopted by the administrator for conducting the hearing.
The decision of the hearing officer may be appealed to the administrator and the administrator may
hear the case de novo or upon the record as submitted before the hearing officer.
(c) The administrator shall provide for an official written transcript to report the
proceedings, the costs of which shall be borne equally by the parties.
(d) The administrator shall file its findings of fact and conclusions. If the administrator
finds that the party accused has violated any provision of this section, the administrator may issue
an order directing the party to cease and desist engaging in the violation and may order such other
reasonable affirmative relief as is necessary to remedy the violation. Under the provisions for court
review of arbitration awards set forth in the Uniform Arbitration Act, Code of Virginia , §§ 8.01-
67
29
581.01—8.01-581.016, the administrator or either party may petition the circuit court within 21
days from the date of the decision for enforcement of an order made under this section.
(e) Any party aggrieved by any decision or order of the admini strator may within 21
days from the date of such decision or order is filed, appeal to the circuit court to obtain judicial
review pursuant to the provisions for judicial review set forth in the Uniform Arbitration Act, Code
of Virginia, §§ 8.01-581.01—8.01-581.016.
Sec. 2-1301.18. Time limits.
Any time limits in this division may be extended by written agreement of the Chief
Administrative Officer, the employee organization, and any other appropriate parties.
Sec. 2-1301.19. Notices.
Any notice required under this division shall be in writing, but service of any such notice
shall be sufficient if mailed by certified mail, return receipt requested, addressed to the last-known
address of the party to be served, unless otherwise provided in this div ision or by the rules of the
administrator, which rules shall provide for the electronic service of documents. Refusal of
certified mail by any party shall be considered service. Prescribed time periods shall commence
from the date of the receipt of the notice.
Sec. 2-1301.20. Review of division.
The Mayor shall conduct a review of this division and its effectiveness for the purposes set
forth in section 2-1301.1 and submit a report of the Mayor’s findings and recommendations to the
City Council within one year after the division has been in effect for two years.
§ 2. This ordinance shall be in force and effect upon adoption.
68
69
70
ORDINANCE NO. 5336
An ORDINANCE to amend Title 2 of the Code of the City of Alexandria, Virginia, General
Government, Chapter 5, Officers and Employees, by adding Article E, Collective Bargaining,
Sections 2-5-67 through 2-5-80.
THE CITY COUNCIL OF ALEXANDRIA HEREBY ORDAINS:
Section I. That Title 2, Chapter 5, Article E of the Code of the City of Alexandria, Virginia, 1981,
as amended, be, and the same hereby is, added as follows:
CHAPTER
5 - OFFICERS AND EMPLOYEES
***
ARTICLE E - COLLECTIVE BARGAINING
Sec. 2-5-67 - Statement of Policy.
It is the public policy of the City of Alexandria and the purpose of this article to promote orderly
and constructive relationships between the city and its employees subject, however, to the
supreme right of the citizens of the city that their government honor guarantees for their health,
safety, welfare, and the uninterrupted operations and functions of government. Because
unresolved disputes between the city and its employees are detrimental to the public and to city
employees, adequate means must be established for their speedy and effective resolution. Within
the limitations required by the greater public interest, and recognizing that amicable relationships
are required between the city and its employees, the city council has determined that the overall
policies set forth here may best be accomplished by ( 1) granting to city employees the right to
organize and choose freely their representatives; (2) permitting the city to negotiate
and bargain in good faith with employee organizations representing city employees and to enter
into written agreements evidencing the result of such bargaining; and (3) establishing procedures
to provide for the protection of the rights of the city, city employees and the public at large.
The council establishes this policy with the intent that city employees enjoy the right to bargain
collectively within parameters that promote a government that provides ethical, effective and
efficient
services that are responsive to the community and focused on improving quality of life
through the services of well-qualified staff who value and work to actively promote policies (1) to
achieve
and maintain diversity, equity and inclusion in city government, and (2) to advance all
things reasonably necessary to achieve organizational excellence, while at all times elevating
principles of cooperation, ethics, honesty, initiative, and learning. .
Sec. 2-5-68 - Definitions.
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.