RecordWell Data

Meeting of the Collective Bargaining Task Force

City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of Feb 26, 2025 · Agendas

Open the original document More from City of Newport News

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

AGENDA OF THE MEETING OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS COLLECTIVE BARGAINING TASK FORCE Febr uary 26, 2025 James Room 700 Town Center Drive 5:30 p.m. Roll Call: Erica Callicutt ( ), Randolph Dillard ( ), Dr. James Graves ( ), Curtis Hartsfield ( ), Matthew Jerasa ( ), Adrian Manning ( ), Jason Parker ( ), Christopher Puckett ( ), Denise Reynolds ( ). Alan Archer ( ), Gloria Washington ( ), Robert Pealo ( ), Allison Dichoso ( ), Virginia Lovell ( ), Brian Sypolt ( ) 1. Call t o Order: 2. Wel come and Introductions: 3. Task Fo rce Policies and Procedures: a. Res olution No. 13751-24 b. FOIA & COIA c. Busin ess at Meetings 4. Elec tions of Chair and Vice Chair: 5. Old B usiness: 6. New Business: a. Colle ctive Bargaining Overview (PFM) b. Nex t Meeting Topics and Schedule 7. Dat e for Next Meeting: 8. Adj ournment: 1 13751-24 PASSED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF NEWPORT NEWS ON JULY 2, 2024 Mabel Washington Jenkins, MMC Phillip Jones City Clerk Mayor A true copy, teste: City Clerk 2 FOIA & COIA A Brief Overview 3 Virginia Freedom of Information Act “FOIA” 2.2-3700 et seq of Code of Virginia 4 • FOIA ensures the people of the Commonwealth the right to access public records in the custody of a public body, its officers and employees, and ensures free entry to meetings of public bodies. • The general rule is that all public records are open to public inspection and copying, and all meetings of public bodies are open to the public. FOIA 5 • Public records include “all writings and records that consist of letters, words or numbers, or their equivalent, set down by handwriting, typewriting, printing, photostatting, photography, magnetic impulse, optical or magneto-optical form, mechanical or electronic recording or other form of data compilation, however stored, regardless of physical form or characteristics, prepared or owned by, or in the possession of a public body or its officers, employees or agents in the transaction of public business.” • Examples include contracts, emails, electronic files, and text messages. Essentially, any document or recording used in the transaction of public business and possessed by a public body, its officers, employees, or agents. FOIA – Public Records 6 • Records created by this Task Force are subject to FOIA. This includes documents generated by the Task Force, email communications between members concerning Task Force business, meeting agendas, and minutes and other records of the meetings of the Task Force • Any Virginia citizen who is not in jail or prison, or any member of the press, can make a FOIA request. FOIA – Public Records 5 7 • FOIA requests are not required to be in writing, and the requestor is not required to cite FOIA or refer to it as a FOIA request. Any request for documents or records can constitute a FOIA request. The request must identify the records requested with reasonable specificity. • Upon receipt of a request, we have five working days to respond. FOIA – Requests for Documents 6 8 • FOIA response must indicate that the government is: • Providing the records requested; • Providing redacted versions of the records and citing the applicable exemption(s) in writing; • Withholding the records, citing the applicable exemption(s) in writing (must disclose subject matter and quantity of records withheld); • Notifying in writing of the need for an additional seven days to respond; or • Requesting a deposit (if cost to respond will exceed $200) FOIA – Requests for Documents 7 9 • There are many categories of documents that are exempt from mandatory disclosure (such as certain law enforcement records, public safety records, personnel records, and health and social services records) • Unless another law prohibits the release of a document, FOIA exemptions are discretionary, not mandatory. • Exemptions must be narrowly construed. FOIA Exemptions 8 10 • All meetings of public bodies are required to be open (unless a closed meeting exemption applies) • What is a meeting? Formal meetings and work sessions, but also any meeting of three or more members of the body, sitting physically or through electronic communications means, where public business is discussed. As a result, we must discourage any “informal meetings” of task force members to discuss task force business, including any electronic chat or email “meetings”. • Every public body shall give notice of the date, time, and location of all meetings at least three working days prior to the meeting by: • Posting notice on its official public government website, if any; • Placing notice in a prominent public location at which notices are regularly posted; and • Placing such notice at the office of the clerk of the public body. FOIA – Open Meeting Requirements 9 11 • At least one copy of the proposed agenda and all agenda packets and materials furnished to members of a public body for a meeting shall be made available for public inspection at the time they are furnished to the public body. • Any person can photograph, film, records, or otherwise reproduce any portion of an open meeting. • Minutes shall be taken at all open meetings. FOIA – Open Meeting Requirements 1 0 12 State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act (COIA) 2.2-3100 et seq. of Code of Virginia 13 1 2 • COIA is designed to ensure that citizens maintain the highest trust in their public officers and to provide guidance for state and local government officers and employees. • COIA defines and prohibits inappropriate conflicts and addresses and requires disclosure of other conflicts and economic interests. • Applies to employees and officers of governmental agencies, including advisory agencies such as this task force. COIA 14 1 3 • COIA regulations generally fall into three categories: • Generally prohibited and unlawful conduct • Prohibited conduct relating to contracts • Prohibited conduct relating to transactions COIA – In general 15 1 4 • Soliciting or accepting money or things of value for performance of official duties (except compensation paid by agency) • Offering or accepting money or anything of value for or in consideration of employment, appointment, or promotion of any person within a governmental or advisory agency. • Offering or accepting money or anything of value for or in consideration of the use of the public position to obtain a contract for any person or business with the governmental agency. • Using confidential information acquired because of public position for private economic benefit. • Accepting any money, loan, gift, favor, etc. that reasonably tends to influence you in the performance of your official duties. COIA – Generally prohibited & unlawful conduct 16 1 5 • Accepting any business or professional opportunity when you know there is a reasonable likelihood it is being afforded to influence you in the performance of your official duties. • Accepting any honoraria for a speech or appearance in which you provide expertise or opinions related to the performance of your official duties. • Accepting a gift from a person who has interest that may be substantially affected by the performance of your official duties, when the circumstances and timing of the gift would cause a reasonable person to question your impartiality. • Accepting gifts so frequently as to raise an appearance of use of public office for private gain. • Use of public position to retaliate or threaten to retaliate against any person for expressing views on a matter of public concern or exercising any right protected by law. COIA – Generally prohibited & unlawful conduct 17 1 6 • Generally, the analysis of a potential conflict hinges on whether the public official has a personal interest in a contract or transaction. • Definitions are long and detailed, but generally: • A “personal interest” is a financial benefit or liability accruing to you or a member of your immediate family, by reason of (i) ownership in a business (more than 3% of total equity), (ii) annual income in excess of $5,000 from ownership in real or personal property or a business, (iii) salary or other compensation paid or provided by a business or governmental agency that exceeds $5,000 annually, (iv) ownership of real or personal property if interest exceeds $5,000 in value, (v) personal liability incurred or assumed on behalf of a business, if liability exceeds three percent of the asset value of the business, or (vi) an option for ownership of a business or real or personal property if it will consist of clause (i) or (iv) COIA – Personal Interest in a Contract or Transaction 18 1 7 • A “personal interest in a contract” means a personal interest that an officer or employee has in a contract with a governmental agency, whether due to his being a party to the contract or due to a personal interest in a business that is a party to the contract. • A “personal interest in a transaction” means a personal interest of an officer or employee in any matter considered by his agency. Such personal interest exists when an officer or employee or a member of his immediate family has a personal interest in property or a business or governmental agency, or represents or provides services to any individual or business and such property, business or represented or served individual or business (i) is the subject of the transaction or (ii) may realize a reasonably foreseeable direct or indirect benefit or detriment as a result of the action of the agency considering the transaction. • Notwithstanding the above, such personal interest in a transaction shall not be deemed to exist where (a) an elected member of a local governing body serves without remuneration as a member of the board of trustees of a not-for- profit entity and such elected member or member of his immediate family has no personal interest related to the not-for-profit entity or (b) an officer, employee, or elected member of a local governing body is appointed by such local governing body to serve on a governmental agency, or an officer, employee, or elected member of a separate local governmental agency formed by a local governing body is appointed to serve on a governmental agency, and the personal interest in the transaction of the governmental agency is the result of the salary, other compensation, fringe benefits, or benefits provided by the local governing body or the separate governmental agency to the officer, employee, elected member, or member of his immediate family. COIA – Personal Interests 19 1 8 • No officer or employee of any governmental agency of local government shall have a personal interest in a contract with the agency of which he is an officer or employee, other than his own contract of employment (with certain limited exceptions). • Cannot have a personal interest in a contract with any other governmental agency that is a component of the government of the city unless it is awarded as a result of sealed bidding or competitive negotiation (or administrative head of agency finds that competitive bidding or negotiation is contrary to best interest of public). COIA – Prohibited Conduct Relating to Contracts 20 1 9 • Any officer or employee of a local government or advisory agency who has a personal interest in a transaction shall disqualify himself from participating in the transaction if: • The transaction has application solely to property or a business (or parent- subsidiary/affiliated relationship thereof) or governmental agency in which he has a personal interest; OR • He is unable to participate pursuant to one of the following exceptions: COIA – Prohibited Conduct Relating to a Personal Interest in a Transaction 21 2 0 • An officer or employee of any local government or advisory agency who has a personal interest in a transaction may participate in the transaction if: • He is a member of a business, profession, occupation, or group of three or more persons which are affected by the transaction, and he complies with the declaration requirements of COIA to declare the personal interest; • When a party to the transaction is a client of his firm, if he does not personally represent or provide services to such client and complies with the declaration requirements; or • When the transaction affects the public generally, even though his personal interest, as a member of the public, may be affected. COIA – Prohibited Conduct Relating to a Personal Interest in a Transaction 22 2 1 • Some of you are affiliated with employee or union groups who may be affected by the work of this task force and any resulting city council action. • While it does not appear that any of those affiliations rise to the level of a personal interest that would limit your participation in this task force, we will prepare declarations for you to sign to disclose those interests and ask you to verbally disclose the same at each meeting. COIA – Prohibited Conduct Relating to a Personal Interest in a Transaction 23 Business at Meetings Collective Bargaining Task Force 24 • The Chair will have the power and duty to preside at meetings and correspond with City Council on behalf of the Task Force. • The Vice Chair will exercise the duties of the Chair in their absence. • The Department of Finance will prepare and distribute agendas in coordination with the Chair, record minutes and votes, and provide other administrative support for the Task Force. Finance can also assist with information gathering from City staff. • The Director of Human Resources will provide information on Human Resources matters as requested by the Task Force. • The City Attorney will advise the Task Force on legal matters. Roles 25 • Task Force meetings will be guided by Robert’s Rules. • A quorum of five members is required to conduct business. • Order of Business / Standing Agenda will generally be: • Call to Order • Review of Minutes • Old Business • New Business • Adjournment • Agenda packets will be distributed by Finance in advance of each meeting. • Please notify Chair and Finance of planned absences. • If members wish to participate remotely or hold virtual meetings (via Zoom, Teams, etc), the Task Force must adopt an electronic meeting policy. Meetings 26 Sec. 2-11.1. Attendance of members of city boards, authorities, commissions and committees; procedure governing unexcused absences. (a) As used in this section the words and phrases identified below shall have the following meaning: (1) Appointed body shall mean the city's boards, authorities, commissions and committees, whose members are appointed by the Newport News City Council. The phrase "appointed body" shall not mean regional boards, or authorities, such as, but not limited to, the Peninsula Airport Commission. (2) Consistent absence shall mean unexcused absences by a member of an appointed body from three (3) consecutive regularly scheduled meetings of that appointed body during any city fiscal year. (3) Irregular attendance shall mean unexcused absences by a member of an appointed body from three (3) regularly scheduled meetings of that appointed body during any city fiscal year. (4) Member shall mean a person appointed by the Newport News City Council to serve as a voting member of an appointed body. (5) Unexcused absence shall mean an absence, by a member of an appointed body from a regularly scheduled meeting of that appointed body, for which the member of that appointed body failed to notify the chairman or other designated officer thereof of an impending absence prior to the date of the public body's regularly scheduled meeting. (b) The city council finds that attendance of members of appointed bodies are an important and necessary component of service on same and that failure of a member of an appointed body to attend scheduled meetings of his or her appointed body affects the ability of that appointed body to conduct its public business. Attendance data shall be compiled by the chairman or other designated officer of the appointed body and reported by him or her to the city clerk on a monthly basis. Such data shall be a factor utilized by city council when it considers an individual for removal, appointment or reappointment to an appointed body. A member of an appointed body who is unable to attend a meeting of that body shall notify the chairman or other designated officer thereof of that impending absence prior to the date of the appointed body's meeting. (c) Irregular attendance. During the city's fiscal year, if any member's attendance at regularly scheduled meetings of that appointed body shall be deemed to be irregular attendance, such occurrences shall give rise to the presumption that such member has voluntarily resigned from that appointed body. Prior to a determination that the member has voluntarily resigned from that appointed body, the following shall occur: (1) During that fiscal year of the city, once any member incurs two (2) unexcused absences from regularly scheduled meetings of his or her appointed body the chairman or other designated officer thereof shall cause a letter to be written to the member who has incurred two (2) unexcused absences, requesting that the member advise the chairman or other designated officer of the member's intent with reference to future attendance at meetings of the appointed body. (2) If the member provides a written statement to the chairman or other designated officer of the appointed body indicating a desire to continue to serve on said appointed body, the chairman or other designated officer shall report same to the city clerk who shall write to said member who experienced two (2) unexcused absences, and remind that member that a third such unexcused absence will be deemed to be a voluntary resignation. (3) If the member does not communicate with the chairman or other designated officer of the appointed body prior to the next regularly scheduled meeting of the appointed body, the chairman or other designated officer thereof shall so notify the city clerk. The city clerk shall thereafter notify the city council of the attendance issue; provided that the city clerk shall send a copy of that correspondence 27 to said member. The city council shall take such action with reference to the attendance issue as the city council in its sole discretion deems appropriate. (d) Consistent absence. During the city's fiscal year, if any member's attendance at regularly scheduled meetings of that appointed body shall be deemed to be a consistent absence, such occurrences shall give rise to the presumption that such member has voluntarily resigned from that appointed body. Prior to a determination that the member has voluntarily resigned from that appointed body, the following shall occur: (1) The chairman or other designated officer of the appointed body shall cause a letter to be written to such member who has incurred two (2) consecutive unexcused absences from two (2) regularly scheduled meetings requesting that the person advise the chairman or other designated officer of the member's intent with reference to future attendance at meetings. (2) If the member provides a written statement of the member's intent to cease attending and to officially resign as a member of that appointed body, the chairman or other designated officer shall so notify the city clerk and provide the city clerk with a copy of that written statement. The city clerk shall thereafter request in writing that the city council appoint a new member to the affected appointed body; provided that the city clerk shall send a copy of that correspondence to said member. (3) If the member provides a written statement to the chairman or other designated officer of the appointed body indicating a desire to continue to serve on said appointed body, the chairman or other designated officer shall report same to the city clerk who shall write to said member who incurred two (2) unexcused absences, and remind that member that a third unexcused absence will be deemed to be a voluntary resignation. (4) If the member does not communicate with the chairman or other designated officer of the appointed body prior to the next regularly scheduled meeting of the appointed body the chairman or other designated officer thereof shall notify the clerk of such occurrence. The city clerk shall thereafter notify the city council in writing of the attendance issue; provided that the city clerk shall send a copy of that correspondence to said member. The city council shall take such action with reference to the attendance issue as the council in its sole discretion deems appropriate. (Ord. No. 6297-06; Ord. No. 8038-24, § 1) 28 © PFM 1 Collective Bargaining Overview PFM Group Consulting LLC PFM Financial Advisors LLC 215.567.6100 pfm.com February 26, 2025 29 © PFM Agenda  Background on Collective Bargaining  Commonwealth of Virginia Experience To Date • Bargaining Unit Composition • Scope of Bargaining 30 © PFM 3 Background on Collective Bargaining 31 © PFM Three Models of Bargaining Bargaining Not Required • States law prohibits collective bargaining Meet and Confer • Employees have right to organize • Employers obligated to “meet and confer” with union – if no agreement, public employer may impose terms of an agreement Interest Arbitration • Third-party neutral arbitrator determines a final resolution • Employer generally must implement terms awarded by arbitrator (under some statutes, including Virginia’s, terms may be subject to funding or related constraints) 32 © PFM Code of Virginia § 40.1-57.2. Collective bargaining  In 2020, the Virginia General Assembly adopted legislation amending § 40.1-57.2. of the Code of Virginia  Code of Virginia § 40.1-57.2 allows local jurisdictions to create and pass collective bargaining ordinances, but it does not mandate that localities do so  Code of Virginia § 40.1-57.2 presents two options to Virginia localities: • Pass an ordinance authorizing collective bargaining • Maintain the status quo without bargaining  If employees organize into a collective bargaining unit, the locality has 120 days to vote on whether to adopt a collective bargaining ordinance • A locality can still vote to decline the authorization of collective bargaining if employees organ ize, as long as the vote is held within 120 days 33 © PFM Code of Virginia § 40.1-57.2 Employees Covered and Employees Excluded  Most, but not all, employees of Virginia counties, cities, towns, and school boards may collectively bargain under § 40.1-57.2 – as long as they are represented by a certified union and the jurisdiction authorizes bargaining Constitutional Offices Prohibited from Collective Bargaining • Clerk of Court • Com monwealth’s Attorney • Commissioner of Revenue • S heriff • Treasurer Public Employees Who May Collectively Bargain • Civilians • Police • F ire and rescue • School Board employees (e.g., teac hers) under jurisdiction of the B oard 34 © PFM Code of Virginia § 40.1-57.2 Local Collective Bargaining Ordinance Features  Policy Statement and definitions  Determination of Bargaining Units within authorized parameters  Employee/Union and Management Rights • Under the Code, no local bargaining ordinance can include provisions that restrict a jurisdiction’s authority to est ablish the budget or appropriate funds • Also under the Code, striking is prohibited and leads to immediate termination and inability to be employe d by a ny Commonwealth jurisdiction for 12 months • Other prohibited practices maybe specified  Labor Relations Administrator • § 40.1-57.2 does not create a statewide labor relations board to administer statutes covering collectiv e b argaining and adjudicate unfair labor practice charges • If a jurisdiction authorizes collective bargaining, it will need to set up this function internally and develo p p roc edures for certifying and decertifying exclusive bargaining representatives  Scope of Bargaining – authorized and excluded subjects of bargaining  Procedures for Impasse Resolution • Mediation, Fact-Finding, Interest Arbitration • Standards and procedures (e.g., time limits, approval of tentative agreements) 35 © PFM Newport News Collective Bargaining Task Force Charged by Resolution Number 13751-24 to develop recommendations to City Council in two specific areas if bargaining were to be authorized for the City: 1. Number of collective bargaining units 2. Scope of collective bargaining “..c ould include certain items and terms of condition of employment such as wages, benefits, scheduling, work hours, and working conditions, among other things, if consistent with state and federal law” 36 © PFM 9 Commonwealth of Virginia Experience To Date 37 © PFM Jurisdictions with Adopted Ordinances / Bargaining Unit Number  Since the Virginia General Assembly adopted legislation amending § 40.1-57.2. of the Code of Virginia, eight Virginia jurisdictions (excluding school divisions) have adopted a collective bargaining ordinance  Bargaining unit number and structure is summarized below. Seven jurisdictions now have ratified public safety collective bargaining agreements, while status with civilian units varies1 Ordinance Adoption Police Fire General Government Labor and Trades Administrative and Technical Professional Transit Total # of Units City of Alexandria 5/1/2021   -    - 5 City of Richmond 7/25/2022   -    - 5 City of Charlottesville 10/3/2022   -     6 Arlington County 7/17/2021   - 1 2  - 5 Fairfax County 10/19/2021    - - - - 3 Loudoun County 12/7/2021 -    - - - 3 Prince William County 11/22/2022   3 - - - - 3 City of Portsmouth2 11/14/2023 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A City of Norfolk Rejected 11/28/2023 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A City of Virginia Beach Rejected 4/30/2024 N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A N/A 1 Note that all jurisdictions exclude civilian managerial, supervisory, and confidential civilian employees from representation, but definitions for managerial and supervisory vary (see appendix). 2 The City of Portsmouth adopted a collective bargaining ordinance that authorized collective bargaining, but the City has not yet adopted a subsequent ordinance that establishes the scope, conditions, and terms of collective bargaining. 38 © PFM Bargaining Unit Composition - Considerations  Community of interest  Existing organizational structures  Complexity of bargaining and contract administration  Supervisory and managerial relationships 39 © PFM Scope of Bargaining: Authorized Subjects  The following table summarizes subjects explicitly noted in the collective bargaining ordinances Alexandria Richmond Charlottesville Arlington Fairfax Loudoun Prince William Wages        Other monetary compensation        Terms and conditions of employment  Hours and scheduling of work     Working conditions       Personnel policies and practices   Procedures to resolve employee grievances      Procedures to resolve disciplinary matters   Benefits / Non-wage compensation    Leave (paid and unpaid leave, vacation, holidays)     Employee contributions to insurance     Employee level of insurance coverage   Limited*  Retirement benefits (non VRS only)     General supplemental retirement plans (non VRS)   Deferred compensation plans (non VRS)  VRS Benefits        Funding and Appropriations        Other Management Rights (see appendix)        * Charlottesville’s collective bargaining ordinance limits authorized subjects to health and dental insurance pr emiums, deductibles, and co-payments for active employees and covered dependents. 40 © PFM Scope of Bargaining - Considerations  Employee Relations  Internal Consistency and Equity  Administrative Efficiency and Cost-Effectiveness 41 © PFM 14 Thank You! Questions? 42 © PFM 15 Appendix 43 © PFM Bargaining Status Ordinance Adoption Police Fire Transit Labor and Trades Administrative and Technical Professional General Government City of Alexandria 5/1/2021 7/1/203- 6/30/2026 7/1/203- 6/30/2026 N/A 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 Pending Pending N/A City of Richmond 7/25/2022 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 N/A Pending 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 Pending N/A City of Charlottesville 10/3/2022 7/1/2024- 6/30/2026 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 7/1/2025- 6/30/2029 Pending Pending N/A Arlington County 7/17/2021 7/1/2023- 6/30/2026 7/1/2023- 6/30/2026 N/A 7/1/2024- 6/30/20271 Pending2 Pending N/A Fairfax County 10/19/2021 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 N/A N/A N/A N/A Pending Loudoun County 12/7/2021 N/A 7/1/2024- 6/30/2027 N/A Pending N/A N/A Pending Prince William County 11/22/2022 7/1/2024- 6/30/2028 7/1/2024- 6/30/2028 N/A N/A N/A N/A Pending3 City of Portsmouth 11/14/2023 Pending Pending Pending Pending Pending Pending Pending  Of the eight Virginia jurisdictions (excluding school divisions) that have adopted a collective bargaining ordinance, seven have ratified public safety collective bargaining agreements, while status with civilian units varies  The City of Portsmouth adopted a collective bargaining ordinance in November 2023 that authorized collective bargaining, but the City has not yet adopted a subsequent ordinance that establishes the scope, conditions, and terms of collective bargaining 44 © PFM Police Bargaining Unit Comparison Bargaining Unit Definition Ranks / Positions Included Ranks / Positions Excluded Alexandria Sworn uniformed employees of the police department excluding the rank of Captain or above Police Officer, Police Sergeant, Police Lieutenant Police Captain Richmond Sworn employees of the Police Department excluding the rank of Captain or above Police Officer, Police Sergeant, Police Lieutenant Police Captain Charlottesville Sworn uniformed employees of the Police Department excluding the rank of Sergeant and above Police Officer, Corporal, Detective Police Sergeant, Police Lieutenant, Police Captain Assistant Chief of Police Arlington Sworn uniformed employees of the police department excluding the rank of Captain or above Police Officer, Police Corporal, Police Sergeant, Police Lieutenant Police Captain Fairfax Sworn uniformed employees of the police department, including uniformed officers of the Animal Protection Police, excluding the rank of First Lieutenant and above Animal Protection Police Officer, Master Animal Protection Police Officer, Police Officer, Master Police Officer, Animal Protection Police Sergeant, Animal Protection Police 2nd Lieutenant, Police Sergeant (Police 2nd Lieutenant) Police First Lieutenant, Police Captain, Police Major, Deputy Chief of Police Loudoun N/A - Law enforcement primarily a function of the Sherriff’s Office N/A N/A Prince William Uniformed, sworn law enforcement officers excluding those eligible for the fire and rescue Bargaining Unit, civilian employees, and public safety communication employees Police Officer, Master Police Officer, Police Sergeant, Police First Sergeant, Police Lieutenant, Police Captain, Police Major, Police Deputy Chief Police Chief (+ Public safety communication employees) 45 © PFM Fire Bargaining Unit Comparison Bargaining Unit Definition Ranks / Positions Included Ranks / Positions Excluded Alexandria Uniformed fire employees, including Fire Marshals excluding rank of Battalion Chief or above Sworn Firefighters (including Fire Marshals) Battalion Chief and above Richmond Uniformed employees, including Fire Marshals, of the Department of Fire and Emergency Services and the employees of the Department of Emergency Communications excluding the rank of Battalion Chief and above Sworn Firefighters (including Fire Marshals) + public safety communications employees Battalion Chief and above + Emergency Communications Supervisor / Manager Charlottesville All sworn uniformed employees of the Fire Department excluding the rank of Battalion Chief and above Sworn Firefighters Battalion Chief and above Arlington Uniformed fire employees, including fire marshals excluding rank of Battalion Chief or above Sworn Firefighters (including Fire Marshals) Battalion Chief and above + Fire Protection Engineer I to II, Fire Medical Director, Fire Inspector, Fire Inspector Supervisor Fairfax Uniformed fire employees, including Fire Marshals and emergency communications employees, excluding all positions above the rank of Deputy Chief in fire department and those at the P-25 level and above in Public Safety Communications Sworn Firefighters (including Fire Marshals) + public safety communications employees Battalion Chief and above + Public Safety Communication Operations Supervisor / Manager Loudoun Uniformed fire employees, including uniformed and civilian Fire Marshal employees and public safety communications employees excluding rank of Battalion Chief or above Sworn Firefighters (including Fire Marshals) + public safety communications employees (Note: Unit also includes civilian Fire Inspector and Fire Plan Reviewer according to most recent CBA) Battalion Chief, and above + (Note: Unit excludes System Chief, Deputy Fire Marshal, Fire Inspection Supervisor, Emergency Communications Center (ECC) Director, and Dispatch Supervisor according to the most recent CBA) Prince William Uniformed, sworn fire and rescue employees excluding those eligible for the police Bargaining Unit, civilian employees, and public safety communication employees Sworn Firefighters Battalion Chief and above (+ Public safety communication employees) 46 © PFM Labor and Trades  Non-supervisory and non-managerial employees associated with labor and trades generally include job classifications that: 1. Involve duties that directly support public comfort a nd co nvenience; or 2. Contribute to maintaining capital assets, land, and infrastructure  Most jurisdictions have a Labor and Trades unit dedicated to employees associated with maintenance and skilled crafts • In Arlington, these employees are included in the Servi ce, Labor, and Trades unit • In Fairfax County and Prince William County, these empl oyees are included in a broader general employee bargaining unit  Examples of employees with maintenance and skilled crafts include Maintenance Worker, Service Technician, Mechanic, and Custodian Bargaining Unit City of Alexandria Labor and Trades City of Richmond Labor and Trades City of Charlottesville Labor and Trades Arlington County Service, Labor & Trades Fairfax County General Government Loudoun County Labor and Trades Prince William County General Service Employees Bargaining Unit Representing Employees Associated with Maintenance and Skilled Crafts 47 © PFM Administrative and Technical Employees  Administrative and office employees are generally defined as non- supervisory, non-managerial employees whose main responsibilities involve: 1. Office or non-manual work directly related to the management or general business operations and services 2. Office support work, excluding confidential employees Exampl es of administrative and office employees include Administrative Assistant and Office Clerk  Technical employees are generally defined as non-supervisory and non- managerial employees whose work requires: 1. A combination of basic scientific or technical knowledge and manual skil l that can be obtained through specialized postsecondary school education or equivalent on-the-job training Examples of technical employees include Code Enforcement Officer, Permit Technician, Family Service Specialist, Food Service Technician  In Richmond, Charlottesville, Alexandria, and Arlington County, administrative and office employees are grouped with technical employees as one bargaining unit  In Fairfax County, Loudoun County, and Prince William County, administrative and technical employees are grouped within a broader general government bargaining unit Bargaining Units Representing Administrative and Technical Employees Bargaining Unit City of Alexandria Administrative and Technical City of Richmond Administrative and Technical City of Charlottesville Administrative and Technical Arlington County Office and Technical Fairfax County General Government Loudoun County General Government Prince William County General Service Employees 48 © PFM Professional Employees  Professional employees are generally defined as non-supervisory, non-managerial and exempt from the Fair Labor Standards Act  Some ordinances also define professional employees as those who: 1. Have the primary duty of performance of work 2. Require knowledge of an advanced type in a field of science or learning customarily acquired by a prolonged course of specialized intellectual instruction 3. Consistently exercise discretion and judgment in its perform ance 4. Require invention, imagination, originality, or talent in a recogni zed field of artistic or creative endeavor  In Richmond, Charlottesville, Alexandria, and Arlington County, professional employees have their own bargaining unit  In Fairfax, Loudoun, and Prince William Counties, professional employees are grouped within a broader general government bargaining unit  Examples of professional employees include Appraiser, Buyer, Management Analyst, and Program Coordinator Bargaining Units Representing Professional Employees Definition Bargaining Unit City of Alexandria Exempt employees + Criteria 2 or 4 Professional City of Richmond Exempt employees Professional City of Charlottesville Exempt employees + Criteria 1, 2, 3, or 4 Professional Arlington County Exempt employees + Criteria 2 or 4 Professional Fairfax County N/A General Government Loudoun County N/A General Government Prince William County N/A General Service Employees 49 © PFM Definition of Supervisors  Supervisors are excluded from the civilian bargaining unit(s), but the definitions of supervisors vary  Ordinances generally define supervisors as individuals who: 1. Supervise two or more employees 2. Have the authority to hire, transfer , s uspe nd, lay off, promote, demote, discharge, assign, evaluate, reward, discipline, or adjust grievances, or r ecommend such actions  While the definition of supervisors generally fall into these two categories, some ordinances require an individual to meet both criteria to be defined as a supervisor, while some ordinances only require one criterion to be met Supervisor Definition City of Alexandria Criteria 1 and 2 City of Richmond Criteria 1 and 2 City of Charlottesville Criteria 1 or 2 Arlington County Criteria 1 and 2 Fairfax County Criteria 1 and 2 Loudoun County Criteria 2 only, provided that the exercise of such authority is not merely routine or clerical but requires independent judgment Prince William County Criteria 2 only, provided that the exercise of such authority is not merely routine or clerical but requires independent judgment 50 © PFM Definition of Managerial Employees  Managerial employees are excluded from the civilian bargaining unit(s), but the definitions of managerial employees vary  Ordinances generally define managerial employees as individuals responsible for: 1. Overseeing a unit or sub-unit 2. Participating in policy formulation 3. Engaging in executive functions 4. Directing management practices 5. Handling personnel decisions such as staff ing, hiring, discipline, and evaluations 6. Involved directly in the determination of labor relations or personnel policy Managerial Employee Definition City of Alexandria Criteria 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 City of Richmond Criteria 1, 2, 3, 4, or 5 City of Charlottesville Criteria 2 or 6 Arlington County Criteria 1, 2, 3, or 4 Fairfax County Criteria 3 or 6 Loudoun County Criteria 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, or 6 Prince William County Criteria 1, 2, 4, or 5 51 © PFM Authorized Subjects of Collective Bargaining  Wages and other monetary compensation are included as authorized subjects of collective bargaining  Terms and conditions of employment are also authorized subjects of bargaining, but hours and scheduling of work are not always explicitly noted as authorized subjects  Some ordinances note broadly that personnel policies and practices are subjects of bargaining, while others specifically note that only procedures to resolve employee grievances are subjects of bargaining • Alexandria excludes procedures to resolve employee grievances related to disciplinary matters from bargai ning, while Loudoun includes procedures for disciplinary matters as an authorized subject of bargaining  Health and miscellaneous benefits are typically authorized subjects, though definitions vary • Prince William County’s ordinance does not explicitly list benefit elements • Fairfax County defines benefits as all forms of non-wage compensation • Charlottesville defines benefits as all forms of non-wage compensation but explicitly excludes insurance b enefit options and plan providers as subjects of bargaining (only employee contributions, premiums, deductibles, and copays are authorized subjects of bargaining)  All jurisdictions list benefits provided or administered by the Commonwealth of Virginia through the Virginia Retirement System (VRS) as prohibited subjects of bargaining  All jurisdictions note that agreements are subject to appropriation of funds 52 © PFM Reserved Management Rights Alexandria Richmond Charlottesville Arlington Fairfax Loudoun Prince William Determine the type and scope of work        Determine the number of employees     Direct the work of employees; determine the goals, objectives, functions, structure and supervision of departments, divisions and offices        Make personnel decisions (e.g., hire, promote, demote, transfer, classify, take disciplinary actions etc.)        Layoffs / reduction-in-force        Contract for, expand, reduce, sell, transfer, convey, or eliminate operations or services        Establish and change standards of behavior or performance, job qualifications, and job descriptions        Establish, maintain, modify, and eliminate workplace health and safety rules        Do all things reasonable and necessary to carry out the mission in emergencies        Establish the budget and appropriate funds         The following table summarizes management rights explicitly noted in the collective bargaining ordinances 53

Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.