_09112024-1121
City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of Sep 11, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Newport News
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
MINUTES
HILTON VILLAGE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD
W E D NE S DAY, September 11 , 2 02 4
Main Street Library
6 :3 0 P.M.
PRESENT: John Scruggs (Chair); William C. Black (Vice-Chair); Theresa Cansler;
Derek Lapiska; Matt Perez ; Dana Robbins
ABSENT: Anne Peterson
STAFF: Saul Gleiser D. , Staff
The meeting was called to order by Chair Scruggs at 6:3 5 PM
The meeting was held at the Main Street Library Meeting Room .
(A) Minutes August 14 , 2024 Meeting
The minutes were approved unanimously.
(B) Consideration of Appli cations for COA:
COAHV-2024-0007 – MILLER EOGHAN PATRICK, – 306 River Road
– Construction of one-story rear addition (Not visible from the public-
right-of-way)
Presentation: Ms. April Sulze explained the proposal for a 1-story rear
addition to accommodate a master bedroom for her father-in-law. This
addition would replace a previously approved but unbuilt 2-story
addition. The plans are in keeping with the comments made by the
Board at the August meeting when it was presented as a preliminary
review.
Dis cussion: Board members the addition is not visible from the public
right of way. Board members noted that the plans meet the guidelines.
They advised the applicant to make sure the slope of the roof meets the
manufacturers specifications.
Action : Ms. Cansler made a motion to approve as presented; the
motion was seconded by Mr. Lapiska and approved unanimously.
(C) Preliminary Design Reviews:
305 Piez Avenue - Ball Meriwether - Curb cut – driveway (Walk in)
Mr. Gleiser explained that a permit for work on the right of way had
been issued by the City in error. The inspector had issued a stop work
order when he noticed that no Certificate of Appropriateness had been
2
issued for the work .
Presentation: Ms. Ball and her contractor Megan Williams (Commercial
Concrete) discussed a curb - cut , apron and driveway needed for ADA
access to the property . Ms. Ball was unaware of COA requirements due
to misinformation during property purchase.
Discussion: The Board recognized the city's error in issuing a work
permit. They n oted that allowing a driveway could set an unwanted
precedent but acknowledged the special circumstances of the request.
The Board referred Ms. Ball and her contractor to appropriate pages in
the guidelines and asked that, if possible, they follow those guidelines
(12-feet wide and concrete should be buff color.) The actual driveway
should be treated as a landscape feature, using pavers for the ribbons.
Action: Ms. Ball must apply for a Certificate of Appropriateness,
including documentation that shows the need for the ADA
accommodation. The application must include the appropriate
drawings showing the proposed curb-cut, apron and driveway. Mr.
Perez moved to authorize staff to issue a temporary approval of the
curb cut and apron (for as long as Ms. Ball resides on the property) ,
recognizing the ADA compliance requirements to accommodate Ms.
Ball's needs; Ms. Robbins seconded. Approval was unanimous.
208 River Road – J. Scruggs – 8 ’X12 ’ Shed (Not visible from the
public-right-of-way)
Mr. Scruggs asked Mr. Black to chair the meeting while he presented
his proposal
Presentation: Mr. Scruggs presented plans for the installation of small
shed that does not require a permit . The shed will be in his back yard
and will not be visible from the public-right-of-way .
Discussion: The Board agreed no COA is needed and commended Mr.
Scruggs for his transparency.
Action: Ms. Robbins moved for approval; Mr. Black seconded. Motion
approved unanimously.
(D) Guidelines Discussion
Not addressed due to the late hour.
(E) Old Bus iness
No old business discussed.
(F) New Busines s
No New Business
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 7 :55 P.M.
Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.