_07102024-1116
City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of Jul 10, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Newport News
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
MINUTES
HILTON VILLAGE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD
W E D NE S DAY, J uly 1 0 , 2 02 4
Main Street Library Meeting Room
6 :3 0 P.M.
PRESENT: William C. Black (Vice-Chair) ; Theresa Cansler; Derek Lapiska ; Matt
Perez ; Dana Robbins ; John Scruggs (Chair)
ABSENT:
STAFF: Saul Gleiser D. , Staff
The meeting was called to order by Chairman Scruggs at 6:30 PM
The meeting was held at the Main Street Library Meeting Room .
(A) Minutes June 12 , 2024 Meeting
The minutes were approved unanimously.
(B) Consideration of Applications for COA:
There ere no applications for certificate of appropriateness
(C) Preliminary Design Reviews:
1020 3-05 Warwick Boulevard; Robert R ego – Replace slate roof
(zoning violation)
Mr. Rego was represented by Delis a Reyes who explained that she
helps manage the pr operties as Mr. Rego is stationed overseas. Ms.
Reyes addressed concerns raised by the Board regarding the
unauthorized removal of slate roofing. The properties had been cited
because the slate was removed without obtaining a Certificate of
Appropriateness, and the planned replacement with asphalt shingles
was deemed inappropriate.
Reyes inquired about using synthetic slate, but the Board advised
against it, citing concerns about its durability and appearance. They
presented samples of synthetic slate that had warped even without
weather exposure. The Board e mphasized the importance of
preserving the original slate and recommended repair over
replacement.
2
Ms. Reyes assured the Board that they intended to install new natural
slate. The Board instructed that the violation must be remedied within
30 days, with at least the contracting of the work and acquisition of the
slate completed by then. They approved the use of any natural slate
that closely matches the original color.
(D) Guidelines
Based on the discussion on the violation at 10203-05 Warwick
Boulevard the Board wanted to take a second look at what was being
recommended for slate in the guidelines .
Slate Recommendation: The Board agreed with the recommendation
to use natural slate for any necessary . They decided not to specify a
particular color, allowing for flexibility in the choice of slate that best
matches the existing roof or meets aesthetic preferences.
Repair vs. Replacement: The Board emphasized a preference for
repairing the existing roof rather than opting for a complete
replacement. This approach aligns with both cost-effectiveness and
preservation of the original materials where possible.
In summary, the Board is satisfied with the guideline for slate roofs
support ing using natural slate for replacements with an emphasis on
repairing rather than replacing the entire roof.
The Board will continue the discussion on the guidelines at the next
meeting.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 7 :40
P.M.
Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.