_06122024-1114
City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of Jun 12, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Newport News
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
MINUTES
HILTON VILLAGE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD
W E D NE S DAY, June 12 , 2 02 4
Main Street Library Meeting Room
6 :3 0 P.M.
PRESENT: Theresa Cansler; Matt Perez ; Dana Robbins ; John Scruggs (Chair) ;
William C. Black (Vi ce-Chair) ; Derek Lapiska
ABSENT: Anne Peterson
STAFF: Saul Gleiser D. , Staff
The meeting was called to order by Chai rman Scruggs at 6:30 PM
The meeting was held at the Main Street Library Meeting Room .
(A) Minutes May 8 , 2024 Meeting
The minutes were approved unanimously.
(B) Consideration of Applications for COA:
Mr. Gleiser introduced COA Application COAHV-2024-0003, presented
by Mr. Fuller regarding the installation of a full concrete driveway at
201 Piez Avenue.
It was noted that the work was completed without securing a
Certificate of Appropriateness (COA) and an Engineering Permit, as
required.
Mr. Fuller acknowledged his awareness of the property's location
within the historic district and expressed that he was misled by his
contractor who assured him he had secured all necessary permits.
Board members discussed the limitations within the Village regarding
driveway installations, particularly in properties like Mr. Fuller's
where side installation is not feasible due to space constraints.
The Board explained that approving a concrete driveway in front of the
house would not align with the Village guidelines and would negatively
impact its character.
Mr. Fuller inquired about potential modifications to the driveway
design that could comply with guidelines, but it was c larified that such
modifications were not feasible given the property's constraints.
After deliberation, the Board informed Mr. Fuller that their only action
could be to deny the application due to non-compliance with
guidelines and regulations.
2
Mr. Black made a motion to deny COA Application COAHV-2024-0003
due to non-compliance with the guidelines . Ms. Cansler seconded the
motion. The decision to deny the application was unanimous 5-0
Mr. Fuller was advised that the driveway must be removed within a
month of him receiving the letter of denial .
(C) Preliminary Design Reviews:
There were no request for a review. However, Mr. Brian C h alsma with
the Roofing Company was present and wanted to encourage the Board
to not change the guidelines as they pertain to the slate roofs. He
explained that there was no good alternative to replace the original
slate as most if not all synthetic products did not age well or provided
the texture or color vari ations of natural slate. He said there was an
abundance of Vermont Slate to replace any slate that needed to be
replaced. He mentioned that he would like to have the next meeting of
the ” Slate School ” in Newport News and showcase Hilton Village as one
of the few districts that has kept their slate roofs.
(D) Guidelines
Mr . Gleiser gave a summary of what was agreed on at the last meeting.
The Board then proceeded with discussion on other issues that should
be clarify in the guidelines.
Issues to be revised included:
Need for clarification on how to address the switch between a 4-foot
front yard fence when it meets a 6-foot privacy fence on the same plain
in a given property .
Remove page s 40 -41 “ Landscape, Yard Elements and Outdoor
Structures ” Given that the Board does not have purview over items not
visible from the public-right-of-way th ese items are not necessary.
There was discussion about solar panels and lighting it is clear that
solar panels on the slate roofs would be detrimental to the character of
the historic district. The only time the panels would be appropriate
would be if they are not visible from the public - right -of-way so no
guidelines for that item would be necessary.
The Board will continue the discussion at the next meeting.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 7 :50
P.M.
Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.