_05022024-1119
City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of May 2, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Newport News
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MEETING MINUTES
North End Huntington Heights
Architectural Review Board
Thursday May 2, 2024
10th Floor Conference Room of City Hall
6:00 P.M.
In attendance:
ARB members: Chair Mary Kayaselcuk, Vice-Chair Drew Velkey, Roy Stubbs, Mark
Bunn, Linda Bordeaux
Residents: Jessica Byars Hyman & Justin Byars – owners of 322 56th Street
Dawn Stahmer – 327 56th Street
Amber Houston, 328 56th Street
I. Call to Order
A. Approval of Minutes of April 4, 2024 meeting
Suggested motion: I hereby recommend approval of the minutes of April 4,
2024 as submitted.
Motion by: BUNN Second: STUBBS Vote: 5 in favor 0 against APPROVED
II. New Business (Action Items)
A. COANE-2024-0003 322 56th Street
Applicants & Owner: Jessica Byars Hyman and Justin Byars
Ms. Poissant presented the application materials and invited the applicant /
owners to provide additional information about their request. Ms. Byars
indicated that they had inherited the home from their parents, who had always
tried to take good care of the property. Her father had repaired the roof many
times. At this point, the underlying wood support structure has deteriorated
and there are numerous leaks into the house. She obtained a quote of over
$10,000 to repair the entire roof with slate, which is prohibitively expensive.
Because of the leaking and mold issues, the roof was replaced with the
submitted example of roofing material previous to this board hearing.
The board expressed discontent with approving applications “retroactively”
i.e., where the work has already been completed. There was considerable
discussion about the perceived lack of information about the historic district
and issues with people performing renovations that may not have been
properly reviewed by the board. Board members and staff provided
background regarding the historic district creation and explained that all
affected property owners had been notified prior to city council approving the
historic district overlay ordinance and associated regulations and guidelines in
2000. The Facebook pages called “North End Huntington Height Preservation
Association” and “North End Huntington Heights Historic District” have not
been monitored or posted on since 2022 and the other residents in attendance
indicated that they thought the district was somehow disbanded. However,
Ms. Poissant indicated that there have been several posts on City of Newport
News social media platforms highlighting the district and calling for new
board members. A neighborhood group run by a local resident has also
regularly publicized information about the district’s regulations and cases over
the past few years.
It was suggested by both residents and board members that information
materials be sent out to all owners and residents as well as local realtors to
convey the requirements of historic district. It was recommended that residents
contact their City Council representatives to request specific items to bring
more attention to the district, such as signs and markers, meetings,
informational post cards, public forums, etc.
Motion: I hereby recommend approval of the issuance of a Certificate of
Appropriateness for COANE-2024-0004 for the removal of slate tile shingles and
installation of architectural fiberglass composite shingles (as completed).
Motion by: VELKEY Second: BUNN Vote: 5 in favor 0 against APPROVED
III. Other Business
IV. Adjournment
Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.