_04042024-1118
City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of Apr 4, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Newport News
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MEETING MINUTES
North End Huntington Heights
Architectural Review Board
Thursday, April 4, 2024
10th Floor Conference Room of City Hall
6:00 P.M.
In attendance
ARB: Mary Kayaselcuk, Mark Bunn, Roy Stubbs, Akshar Patel, and Steve Kostoff
Applicant / owner: Jorge Garza, 341 55th Street
Staff: Senior Planner Carolyn Poissant
I. Call to Order
A. Approval of Minutes of February 1, 2024 meeting
I hereby recommend approval of the minutes of February 1, 2024 as
submitted.
Motion by: Bunn Second: Patel Vote: 5 in favor 0 against APPROVED
II. New Business (Action Items)
A. COANE-2024-0002 341 55th Street
Applicants & Owner: Jorge Garza
Ms. Poissant presented the application and asked the applicant to explain his
reasons for the chimney removal. Mr. Garza indicated that when he secured the
loan for the house, he was unaware of the historic district regulations. His loan
did not include enough money to repair the two chimneys. He had a lot of
difficulty with the contractor he originally hired and after several delays,
decided to hire a new contractor to complete the home repairs, including the
exterior repairs that were previously approved by the board in 2022. Both
chimneys were leaning and becoming a safety concern so he decided to take
them down.
There was quite a bit of discussion as the board did not want to set the
precedent that brick chimneys could be removed easily. They are an iconic
feature in the historic district and although expensive to maintain, are
important to the historic architectural integrity of the district.
Ms. Poissant explained that if denied, the applicant could appeal to City
Council, and if denied by City Council, he could also file an appeal with the
Circuit Court. She indicated that she felt there would likely be fairly strong
sympathy for the applicant on the part of City Council due to the fact that he
had taken a home in serious disrepair and completed several costly
improvements and is living in the home, not renting it out.
Board members shared their experiences with chimney and other masonry
restoration and acknowledged that it can be very expensive. It was also noted,
however, that property owners can learn from board’s expertise, which is why
the process of review is so important.
The applicant was asked whether the building department had made any type
of safety assessment, which they had not, according to Mr. Garza. Ms. Poissant
indicated that Codes Compliance has specific criteria for citing homes due to
disrepair or other health and safety issues.
There was additional discussion by the board about the need for an “awareness
campaign” targeting realtors and prospective home buyers to educate them
about the district guidelines and ARB review. It was suggested that a postcard
or letter be sent to all local realtors and property owners in the district. It was
also suggested that markers or signage be placed at the boundaries of the
district to bring attention to the historic district and the guidelines.
Board members again expressed reluctance to approve due to the possible
precedent being set.
I hereby recommend approval of the issuance of a Certificate of
Appropriateness for COANE-2024-0002 for the (previously completed) removal
of 2 brick chimneys due to extenuating circumstances.
Motion by: Patel Second: Kostoff Vote: 3 in favor, 1 against, 1 abstained
APPROVED
III. Other Business - none
IV. Adjournment
Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.